diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_0/index_tensor([728, 728])_group_0_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_0/index_tensor([728, 728])_group_0_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..010b034c042e78e262717fc5a94d04accb29e17d --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_0/index_tensor([728, 728])_group_0_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "In a soft-focus close-up shot, we shoot from a low angle, the camera panning extremely slowly to the right, following the subject's movements. A massive yellow excavator dominates the frame, its weathered metal body mottled with dirt and scratches from work. In the warm afternoon sun, the fine dust particles lingering in the air shimmer golden against the backlight. The excavator's massive mechanical arm rises steadily and calmly, its massive bucket, laden with moist, dark-brown earth, moving precisely into position amid the deep, powerful hum of its hydraulic system. As the bucket tilts gently at a precisely controlled angle, the earth, mixed with rocks, cascades down like a heavy waterfall, merging into the massive mound gradually taking shape in the background. The entire picture is shrouded in a warm golden halo. The main colors are the yellow of the excavator and the brown of the soil. The light and shadow outline a rich texture on the rough surface, creating a unique beauty that combines industrial power with natural tranquility. The atmosphere is focused and powerful.", + "seed": 22358, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_0/index_728_seed_22358_dp_0_rank_0_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.05422743754461408, + "vlm_logprob": -0.05422743754461408, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.975, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.05422743754461408, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a soft-focus close-up taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera panning extremely slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive yellow excavator with a weathered, dirt-covered metal body visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the excavator's mechanical arm rise steadily while its bucket tilts to cascade moist, dark-brown earth mixed with rocks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm afternoon sunlight with visible golden dust particles shimmering in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02014334872364998 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.145143508911133 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02014334872364998, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02014334872364998, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11950404196977615, + 0.03260129317641258, + 0.09305587410926819, + 0.14856965839862823, + 0.0671411082148552, + 0.1200648844242096, + 0.05724569782614708, + 0.11319812387228012, + 0.1979467272758484, + 0.050672657787799835 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02014334872364998 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a soft-focus close-up taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera panning extremely slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive yellow excavator with a weathered, dirt-covered metal body visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the excavator's mechanical arm rise steadily while its bucket tilts to cascade moist, dark-brown earth mixed with rocks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm afternoon sunlight with visible golden dust particles shimmering in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22555172443389893 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.600551724433899 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.22555172443389893, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.22555172443389893, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05932455137372017, + 0.012762416154146194, + 0.03741773962974548, + 0.0898943766951561, + 0.06804367899894714, + 0.16764673590660095, + 0.021713633090257645, + 0.08127857744693756, + 0.399824321269989, + 0.06209400296211243 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.22555172443389893 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a soft-focus close-up taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera panning extremely slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive yellow excavator with a weathered, dirt-covered metal body visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the excavator's mechanical arm rise steadily while its bucket tilts to cascade moist, dark-brown earth mixed with rocks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm afternoon sunlight with visible golden dust particles shimmering in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006739622913300991 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006739616394043 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006739622913300991, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006739622913300991, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0328652560710907, + 0.04157714918255806, + 0.025539280846714973, + 0.07424645125865936, + 0.021641258150339127, + 0.5219821929931641, + 0.027066726237535477, + 0.025705931708216667, + 0.15897229313850403, + 0.07040337473154068 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 8, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006739622913300991 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a soft-focus close-up taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera panning extremely slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive yellow excavator with a weathered, dirt-covered metal body visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the excavator's mechanical arm rise steadily while its bucket tilts to cascade moist, dark-brown earth mixed with rocks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm afternoon sunlight with visible golden dust particles shimmering in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011079339310526848 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.51107931137085 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011079339310526848, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011079339310526848, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07324770838022232, + 0.05234818160533905, + 0.047918010503053665, + 0.09574492275714874, + 0.045952342450618744, + 0.30458399653434753, + 0.0461035892367363, + 0.10654475539922714, + 0.11399843543767929, + 0.11355806887149811 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011079339310526848 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a soft-focus close-up taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera panning extremely slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive yellow excavator with a weathered, dirt-covered metal body visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the excavator's mechanical arm rise steadily while its bucket tilts to cascade moist, dark-brown earth mixed with rocks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm afternoon sunlight with visible golden dust particles shimmering in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00762315234169364 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882623195648193 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00762315234169364, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00762315234169364, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05861372500658035, + 0.034307658672332764, + 0.019908150658011436, + 0.07702066004276276, + 0.039845313876867294, + 0.46035394072532654, + 0.03871656209230423, + 0.08404891937971115, + 0.1389884650707245, + 0.048196595162153244 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00762315234169364 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a soft-focus close-up shot, we shoot from a low angle, the camera panning extremely slowly to the right, following the subject's movements. A massive yellow excavator dominates the frame, its weathered metal body mottled with dirt and scratches from work. In the warm afternoon sun, the fine dust particles lingering in the air shimmer golden against the backlight. The excavator's massive mechanical arm rises steadily and calmly, its massive bucket, laden with moist, dark-brown earth, moving precisely into position amid the deep, powerful hum of its hydraulic system. As the bucket tilts gently at a precisely controlled angle, the earth, mixed with rocks, cascades down like a heavy waterfall, merging into the massive mound gradually taking shape in the background. The entire picture is shrouded in a warm golden halo. The main colors are the yellow of the excavator and the brown of the soil. The light and shadow outline a rich texture on the rough surface, creating a unique beauty that combines industrial power with natural tranquility. The atmosphere is focused and powerful.", + "seed": 22359, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_0/index_728_seed_22359_dp_0_rank_0_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.11450123749673366, + "vlm_logprob": -0.11450123749673366, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.125, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.11450123749673366, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a soft-focus close-up taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera panning extremely slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive yellow excavator with a weathered, dirt-covered metal body visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the excavator's mechanical arm rise steadily while its bucket tilts to cascade moist, dark-brown earth mixed with rocks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm afternoon sunlight with visible golden dust particles shimmering in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.025171754881739616 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.9001717567443848 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.025171754881739616, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.025171754881739616, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10641403496265411, + 0.05606815963983536, + 0.35489752888679504, + 0.0786430761218071, + 0.11560807377099991, + 0.033041249960660934, + 0.06643550097942352, + 0.1449166089296341, + 0.014762789942324162, + 0.029212981462478638 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 7, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.025171754881739616 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a soft-focus close-up taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera panning extremely slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive yellow excavator with a weathered, dirt-covered metal body visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the excavator's mechanical arm rise steadily while its bucket tilts to cascade moist, dark-brown earth mixed with rocks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm afternoon sunlight with visible golden dust particles shimmering in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.47426626086235046 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9742662906646729 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.47426626086235046, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.47426626086235046, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08869211375713348, + 0.07100974023342133, + 0.11214200407266617, + 0.0446975938975811, + 0.05745663866400719, + 0.12361703813076019, + 0.0921185091137886, + 0.2825663089752197, + 0.1045977920293808, + 0.023102331906557083 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 5, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.47426626086235046 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a soft-focus close-up taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera panning extremely slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive yellow excavator with a weathered, dirt-covered metal body visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the excavator's mechanical arm rise steadily while its bucket tilts to cascade moist, dark-brown earth mixed with rocks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm afternoon sunlight with visible golden dust particles shimmering in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016079863533377647 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141079902648926 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016079863533377647, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016079863533377647, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15977692604064941, + 0.06789910793304443, + 0.26593300700187683, + 0.0960833802819252, + 0.0817645713686943, + 0.03724350035190582, + 0.08688396215438843, + 0.1031862124800682, + 0.03424377739429474, + 0.0669856071472168 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016079863533377647 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a soft-focus close-up taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera panning extremely slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive yellow excavator with a weathered, dirt-covered metal body visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the excavator's mechanical arm rise steadily while its bucket tilts to cascade moist, dark-brown earth mixed with rocks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm afternoon sunlight with visible golden dust particles shimmering in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03370559215545654 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408705711364746 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03370559215545654, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03370559215545654, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10697479546070099, + 0.05925755202770233, + 0.16743610799312592, + 0.1628236472606659, + 0.05610192194581032, + 0.09275174140930176, + 0.07562314718961716, + 0.14728912711143494, + 0.05564562603831291, + 0.0760962963104248 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03370559215545654 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a soft-focus close-up taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera panning extremely slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive yellow excavator with a weathered, dirt-covered metal body visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the excavator's mechanical arm rise steadily while its bucket tilts to cascade moist, dark-brown earth mixed with rocks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm afternoon sunlight with visible golden dust particles shimmering in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023282716050744057 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773282766342163 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023282716050744057, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023282716050744057, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3210999667644501, + 0.16594436764717102, + 0.11928098648786545, + 0.07773734629154205, + 0.0735134705901146, + 0.02812204509973526, + 0.07437998056411743, + 0.03681591525673866, + 0.02632988803088665, + 0.07677602767944336 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023282716050744057 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a soft-focus close-up shot, we shoot from a low angle, the camera panning extremely slowly to the right, following the subject's movements. A massive yellow excavator dominates the frame, its weathered metal body mottled with dirt and scratches from work. In the warm afternoon sun, the fine dust particles lingering in the air shimmer golden against the backlight. The excavator's massive mechanical arm rises steadily and calmly, its massive bucket, laden with moist, dark-brown earth, moving precisely into position amid the deep, powerful hum of its hydraulic system. As the bucket tilts gently at a precisely controlled angle, the earth, mixed with rocks, cascades down like a heavy waterfall, merging into the massive mound gradually taking shape in the background. The entire picture is shrouded in a warm golden halo. The main colors are the yellow of the excavator and the brown of the soil. The light and shadow outline a rich texture on the rough surface, creating a unique beauty that combines industrial power with natural tranquility. The atmosphere is focused and powerful.", + "seed": 22360, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_0/index_728_seed_22360_dp_1_rank_2_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.07497081579640508, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07497081579640508, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.475, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07497081579640508, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a soft-focus close-up taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera panning extremely slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive yellow excavator with a weathered, dirt-covered metal body visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the excavator's mechanical arm rise steadily while its bucket tilts to cascade moist, dark-brown earth mixed with rocks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm afternoon sunlight with visible golden dust particles shimmering in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014564272947609425 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.764564037322998 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014564272947609425, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014564272947609425, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1122366264462471, + 0.07739566266536713, + 0.07288514822721481, + 0.09140448272228241, + 0.09539283066987991, + 0.13307954370975494, + 0.133755624294281, + 0.05046077072620392, + 0.12039826810359955, + 0.11299100518226624 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014564272947609425 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a soft-focus close-up taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera panning extremely slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive yellow excavator with a weathered, dirt-covered metal body visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the excavator's mechanical arm rise steadily while its bucket tilts to cascade moist, dark-brown earth mixed with rocks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm afternoon sunlight with visible golden dust particles shimmering in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3486069440841675 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2236069440841675 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3486069440841675, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3486069440841675, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0811133161187172, + 0.12657423317432404, + 0.05118761584162712, + 0.08045460283756256, + 0.1417354792356491, + 0.06253819912672043, + 0.17761625349521637, + 0.14891579747200012, + 0.0787581279873848, + 0.05110642686486244 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3486069440841675 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a soft-focus close-up taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera panning extremely slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive yellow excavator with a weathered, dirt-covered metal body visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the excavator's mechanical arm rise steadily while its bucket tilts to cascade moist, dark-brown earth mixed with rocks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm afternoon sunlight with visible golden dust particles shimmering in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0028191369492560625 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877819061279297 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0028191369492560625, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0028191369492560625, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.131583571434021, + 0.06858605146408081, + 0.05989701673388481, + 0.21537458896636963, + 0.16105251014232635, + 0.038330987095832825, + 0.13054607808589935, + 0.07594229280948639, + 0.050448279827833176, + 0.06823860108852386 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0028191369492560625 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a soft-focus close-up taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera panning extremely slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive yellow excavator with a weathered, dirt-covered metal body visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the excavator's mechanical arm rise steadily while its bucket tilts to cascade moist, dark-brown earth mixed with rocks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm afternoon sunlight with visible golden dust particles shimmering in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005252727307379246 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255252838134766 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005252727307379246, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005252727307379246, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.056370723992586136, + 0.0275675468146801, + 0.020041905343532562, + 0.11948710680007935, + 0.08832394331693649, + 0.03668980672955513, + 0.15155094861984253, + 0.17746949195861816, + 0.11568453907966614, + 0.2068140208721161 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005252727307379246 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a soft-focus close-up taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera panning extremely slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive yellow excavator with a weathered, dirt-covered metal body visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the excavator's mechanical arm rise steadily while its bucket tilts to cascade moist, dark-brown earth mixed with rocks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm afternoon sunlight with visible golden dust particles shimmering in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036109976936131716 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628611087799072 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036109976936131716, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036109976936131716, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17838510870933533, + 0.03536354750394821, + 0.06197993457317352, + 0.15886922180652618, + 0.2152397781610489, + 0.033826012164354324, + 0.14857375621795654, + 0.05385473370552063, + 0.04715438187122345, + 0.06675350666046143 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036109976936131716 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a soft-focus close-up shot, we shoot from a low angle, the camera panning extremely slowly to the right, following the subject's movements. A massive yellow excavator dominates the frame, its weathered metal body mottled with dirt and scratches from work. In the warm afternoon sun, the fine dust particles lingering in the air shimmer golden against the backlight. The excavator's massive mechanical arm rises steadily and calmly, its massive bucket, laden with moist, dark-brown earth, moving precisely into position amid the deep, powerful hum of its hydraulic system. As the bucket tilts gently at a precisely controlled angle, the earth, mixed with rocks, cascades down like a heavy waterfall, merging into the massive mound gradually taking shape in the background. The entire picture is shrouded in a warm golden halo. The main colors are the yellow of the excavator and the brown of the soil. The light and shadow outline a rich texture on the rough surface, creating a unique beauty that combines industrial power with natural tranquility. The atmosphere is focused and powerful.", + "seed": 22361, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_0/index_728_seed_22361_dp_1_rank_2_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.10421109376475216, + "vlm_logprob": -0.10421109376475216, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.85, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.10421109376475216, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a soft-focus close-up taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera panning extremely slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive yellow excavator with a weathered, dirt-covered metal body visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the excavator's mechanical arm rise steadily while its bucket tilts to cascade moist, dark-brown earth mixed with rocks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm afternoon sunlight with visible golden dust particles shimmering in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.021996689960360527 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.14699649810791 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.021996689960360527, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.021996689960360527, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21704156696796417, + 0.05825868621468544, + 0.041923198848962784, + 0.2819528877735138, + 0.07643260061740875, + 0.058405615389347076, + 0.05306457728147507, + 0.11481692641973495, + 0.045179903507232666, + 0.052924007177352905 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.021996689960360527 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a soft-focus close-up taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera panning extremely slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive yellow excavator with a weathered, dirt-covered metal body visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the excavator's mechanical arm rise steadily while its bucket tilts to cascade moist, dark-brown earth mixed with rocks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm afternoon sunlight with visible golden dust particles shimmering in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.47425270080566406 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9742527008056641 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.47425270080566406, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.47425270080566406, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09365270286798477, + 0.18219560384750366, + 0.049700140953063965, + 0.05559536814689636, + 0.021384766325354576, + 0.04359852895140648, + 0.3131960928440094, + 0.08654436469078064, + 0.09309564530849457, + 0.06103670597076416 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.47425270080566406 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a soft-focus close-up taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera panning extremely slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive yellow excavator with a weathered, dirt-covered metal body visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the excavator's mechanical arm rise steadily while its bucket tilts to cascade moist, dark-brown earth mixed with rocks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm afternoon sunlight with visible golden dust particles shimmering in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007631197106093168 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882631301879883 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007631197106093168, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007631197106093168, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.26437443494796753, + 0.1313224583864212, + 0.060490526258945465, + 0.10306496173143387, + 0.045730963349342346, + 0.03476327285170555, + 0.19991622865200043, + 0.03586464747786522, + 0.033686161041259766, + 0.0907863974571228 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007631197106093168 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a soft-focus close-up taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera panning extremely slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive yellow excavator with a weathered, dirt-covered metal body visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the excavator's mechanical arm rise steadily while its bucket tilts to cascade moist, dark-brown earth mixed with rocks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm afternoon sunlight with visible golden dust particles shimmering in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012541357427835464 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.3875412940979 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012541357427835464, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012541357427835464, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12341676652431488, + 0.1668325662612915, + 0.01752164401113987, + 0.025340400636196136, + 0.047296248376369476, + 0.038627512753009796, + 0.47055748105049133, + 0.04435919597744942, + 0.02188008464872837, + 0.04416802525520325 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012541357427835464 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a soft-focus close-up taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera panning extremely slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive yellow excavator with a weathered, dirt-covered metal body visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the excavator's mechanical arm rise steadily while its bucket tilts to cascade moist, dark-brown earth mixed with rocks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm afternoon sunlight with visible golden dust particles shimmering in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004633523523807526 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.37963342666626 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004633523523807526, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004633523523807526, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.28247854113578796, + 0.1164759173989296, + 0.04480850696563721, + 0.1728821098804474, + 0.057180535048246384, + 0.03640035539865494, + 0.125836580991745, + 0.027779964730143547, + 0.07438191026449203, + 0.06177563965320587 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004633523523807526 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_1/index_tensor([2225, 2225])_group_1_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_1/index_tensor([2225, 2225])_group_1_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..2e92648be4dc3c6d5aa2e3faf8178a9186003682 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_1/index_tensor([2225, 2225])_group_1_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "slow, graceful 360-degree drone orbit begins, circling a lone, ancient olive tree with a steady, reverent motion. The camera begins at a slightly lower angle, emphasizing the tree's grandeur. The initial view focuses on the massive, gnarled trunk, its bark an intricate tapestry of deep cracks and twisted muscle structures in weathered grays and earthy browns. As the camera slides counterclockwise, the warm, golden light of the Mediterranean afternoon captures the intricate textures, revealing patches of moss in the cracks. The orbit gradually widens, revealing the tree's full form. Its dense, sinuous branches reach toward the sky like arthritic fingers, adorned with dense clusters of tiny, silvery-green leaves that shimmer and dance in the gentle, warm breeze. Light filters through the leaves, casting speckled, shifting patterns on the sun-drenched terracotta ground below. In the background, the camera's circular path reveals a landscape of rolling, sun-drenched hills, with the deep blue Aegean Sea shimmering in the hazy distance. The atmosphere is one of profound peace and timeless tranquility, a cinematic portrayal of nature's endurance and quiet majesty.", + "seed": 25760, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_1/index_2225_seed_25760_dp_2_rank_4_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.01910199134144932, + "vlm_logprob": -0.01910199134144932, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.8, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.01910199134144932, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a lone, ancient olive tree with a massive, gnarled trunk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, graceful 360-degree orbit around the tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the tree's branches dense and sinuous with silvery-green leaves that shimmer in the breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a landscape of rolling hills with the deep blue Aegean Sea in the distance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at a slightly lower angle and slide counterclockwise during the orbit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0018942285096272826 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.751893997192383 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0018942285096272826, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0018942285096272826, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16505290567874908, + 0.16086937487125397, + 0.1629798263311386, + 0.07905974239110947, + 0.0426977165043354, + 0.10216231644153595, + 0.08518413454294205, + 0.05942168086767197, + 0.04563981667160988, + 0.09693253040313721 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0018942285096272826 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a lone, ancient olive tree with a massive, gnarled trunk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, graceful 360-degree orbit around the tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the tree's branches dense and sinuous with silvery-green leaves that shimmer in the breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a landscape of rolling hills with the deep blue Aegean Sea in the distance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at a slightly lower angle and slide counterclockwise during the orbit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02979404106736183 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5297939777374268 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02979404106736183, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02979404106736183, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07340410351753235, + 0.13074180483818054, + 0.0935467779636383, + 0.1339889019727707, + 0.07941944897174835, + 0.12491560727357864, + 0.09398827701807022, + 0.12269560247659683, + 0.07971734553575516, + 0.0675821527838707 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02979404106736183 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a lone, ancient olive tree with a massive, gnarled trunk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, graceful 360-degree orbit around the tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the tree's branches dense and sinuous with silvery-green leaves that shimmer in the breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a landscape of rolling hills with the deep blue Aegean Sea in the distance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at a slightly lower angle and slide counterclockwise during the orbit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003624063218012452 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628623962402344 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003624063218012452, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003624063218012452, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19265203177928925, + 0.1999518871307373, + 0.1259632110595703, + 0.10080059617757797, + 0.03793446719646454, + 0.07825310528278351, + 0.08230841904878616, + 0.07112914323806763, + 0.03750406205654144, + 0.07350310683250427 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003624063218012452 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a lone, ancient olive tree with a massive, gnarled trunk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, graceful 360-degree orbit around the tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the tree's branches dense and sinuous with silvery-green leaves that shimmer in the breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a landscape of rolling hills with the deep blue Aegean Sea in the distance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at a slightly lower angle and slide counterclockwise during the orbit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005249644163995981 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255249500274658 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005249644163995981, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005249644163995981, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06835690885782242, + 0.1309395730495453, + 0.03554117679595947, + 0.040034063160419464, + 0.05022157356142998, + 0.08373097330331802, + 0.16450092196464539, + 0.07608979940414429, + 0.26502346992492676, + 0.08556151390075684 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005249644163995981 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a lone, ancient olive tree with a massive, gnarled trunk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, graceful 360-degree orbit around the tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the tree's branches dense and sinuous with silvery-green leaves that shimmer in the breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a landscape of rolling hills with the deep blue Aegean Sea in the distance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at a slightly lower angle and slide counterclockwise during the orbit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.054947979748249054 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929948091506958 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.054947979748249054, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.054947979748249054, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1400464028120041, + 0.09689165651798248, + 0.09619127959012985, + 0.15770898759365082, + 0.053948257118463516, + 0.07097931206226349, + 0.13387730717658997, + 0.09020205587148666, + 0.0721331387758255, + 0.0880216583609581 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.054947979748249054 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow, graceful 360-degree drone orbit begins, circling a lone, ancient olive tree with a steady, reverent motion. The camera begins at a slightly lower angle, emphasizing the tree's grandeur. The initial view focuses on the massive, gnarled trunk, its bark an intricate tapestry of deep cracks and twisted muscle structures in weathered grays and earthy browns. As the camera slides counterclockwise, the warm, golden light of the Mediterranean afternoon captures the intricate textures, revealing patches of moss in the cracks. The orbit gradually widens, revealing the tree's full form. Its dense, sinuous branches reach toward the sky like arthritic fingers, adorned with dense clusters of tiny, silvery-green leaves that shimmer and dance in the gentle, warm breeze. Light filters through the leaves, casting speckled, shifting patterns on the sun-drenched terracotta ground below. In the background, the camera's circular path reveals a landscape of rolling, sun-drenched hills, with the deep blue Aegean Sea shimmering in the hazy distance. The atmosphere is one of profound peace and timeless tranquility, a cinematic portrayal of nature's endurance and quiet majesty.", + "seed": 25761, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_1/index_2225_seed_25761_dp_2_rank_4_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.023579570930451155, + "vlm_logprob": -0.023579570930451155, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.475, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.023579570930451155, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a lone, ancient olive tree with a massive, gnarled trunk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, graceful 360-degree orbit around the tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the tree's branches dense and sinuous with silvery-green leaves that shimmer in the breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a landscape of rolling hills with the deep blue Aegean Sea in the distance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at a slightly lower angle and slide counterclockwise during the orbit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0029812674038112164 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002981185913086 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0029812674038112164, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0029812674038112164, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14891116321086884, + 0.1750563085079193, + 0.03318525478243828, + 0.0741322711110115, + 0.07163750380277634, + 0.07034516334533691, + 0.17435020208358765, + 0.06430850923061371, + 0.08225052058696747, + 0.10582313686609268 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0029812674038112164 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a lone, ancient olive tree with a massive, gnarled trunk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, graceful 360-degree orbit around the tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the tree's branches dense and sinuous with silvery-green leaves that shimmer in the breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a landscape of rolling hills with the deep blue Aegean Sea in the distance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at a slightly lower angle and slide counterclockwise during the orbit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.033699944615364075 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4086999893188477 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.033699944615364075, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.033699944615364075, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1416311115026474, + 0.040969595313072205, + 0.13937900960445404, + 0.13527777791023254, + 0.04468045383691788, + 0.04556332901120186, + 0.17594240605831146, + 0.14475663006305695, + 0.06186047941446304, + 0.06993917375802994 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.033699944615364075 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a lone, ancient olive tree with a massive, gnarled trunk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, graceful 360-degree orbit around the tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the tree's branches dense and sinuous with silvery-green leaves that shimmer in the breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a landscape of rolling hills with the deep blue Aegean Sea in the distance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at a slightly lower angle and slide counterclockwise during the orbit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005260554142296314 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255260467529297 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005260554142296314, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005260554142296314, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09698967635631561, + 0.02997518889605999, + 0.057777103036642075, + 0.21800053119659424, + 0.0453348383307457, + 0.048971205949783325, + 0.29301872849464417, + 0.05493588000535965, + 0.09588374942541122, + 0.05911305546760559 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005260554142296314 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a lone, ancient olive tree with a massive, gnarled trunk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, graceful 360-degree orbit around the tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the tree's branches dense and sinuous with silvery-green leaves that shimmer in the breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a landscape of rolling hills with the deep blue Aegean Sea in the distance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at a slightly lower angle and slide counterclockwise during the orbit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0059472741559147835 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130947113037109 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0059472741559147835, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0059472741559147835, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25399237871170044, + 0.08420803397893906, + 0.06793151050806046, + 0.1603338122367859, + 0.058606088161468506, + 0.05771016702055931, + 0.14922474324703217, + 0.0617867074906826, + 0.04087529331445694, + 0.06533125042915344 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0059472741559147835 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a lone, ancient olive tree with a massive, gnarled trunk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, graceful 360-degree orbit around the tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the tree's branches dense and sinuous with silvery-green leaves that shimmer in the breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a landscape of rolling hills with the deep blue Aegean Sea in the distance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at a slightly lower angle and slide counterclockwise during the orbit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07000881433486938 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950087547302246 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07000881433486938, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07000881433486938, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.27838560938835144, + 0.04546050727367401, + 0.04835672676563263, + 0.1354638636112213, + 0.07179750502109528, + 0.05819714069366455, + 0.05820520222187042, + 0.07522328197956085, + 0.13501565158367157, + 0.09389454126358032 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07000881433486938 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow, graceful 360-degree drone orbit begins, circling a lone, ancient olive tree with a steady, reverent motion. The camera begins at a slightly lower angle, emphasizing the tree's grandeur. The initial view focuses on the massive, gnarled trunk, its bark an intricate tapestry of deep cracks and twisted muscle structures in weathered grays and earthy browns. As the camera slides counterclockwise, the warm, golden light of the Mediterranean afternoon captures the intricate textures, revealing patches of moss in the cracks. The orbit gradually widens, revealing the tree's full form. Its dense, sinuous branches reach toward the sky like arthritic fingers, adorned with dense clusters of tiny, silvery-green leaves that shimmer and dance in the gentle, warm breeze. Light filters through the leaves, casting speckled, shifting patterns on the sun-drenched terracotta ground below. In the background, the camera's circular path reveals a landscape of rolling, sun-drenched hills, with the deep blue Aegean Sea shimmering in the hazy distance. The atmosphere is one of profound peace and timeless tranquility, a cinematic portrayal of nature's endurance and quiet majesty.", + "seed": 25762, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_1/index_2225_seed_25762_dp_3_rank_6_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.024586903443560005, + "vlm_logprob": -0.024586903443560005, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.45, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.024586903443560005, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a lone, ancient olive tree with a massive, gnarled trunk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, graceful 360-degree orbit around the tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the tree's branches dense and sinuous with silvery-green leaves that shimmer in the breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a landscape of rolling hills with the deep blue Aegean Sea in the distance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at a slightly lower angle and slide counterclockwise during the orbit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002096837153658271 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.752096652984619 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002096837153658271, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002096837153658271, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10448866337537766, + 0.043918266892433167, + 0.033133987337350845, + 0.08851799368858337, + 0.15251438319683075, + 0.0628150925040245, + 0.04469290375709534, + 0.0632370337843895, + 0.2258579432964325, + 0.18082375824451447 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002096837153658271 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a lone, ancient olive tree with a massive, gnarled trunk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, graceful 360-degree orbit around the tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the tree's branches dense and sinuous with silvery-green leaves that shimmer in the breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a landscape of rolling hills with the deep blue Aegean Sea in the distance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at a slightly lower angle and slide counterclockwise during the orbit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03809397295117378 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2880940437316895 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03809397295117378, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03809397295117378, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12091472744941711, + 0.0704730972647667, + 0.037940092384815216, + 0.023504087701439857, + 0.0321526862680912, + 0.135196253657341, + 0.0317995548248291, + 0.025373857468366623, + 0.4627700448036194, + 0.05987559258937836 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03809397295117378 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a lone, ancient olive tree with a massive, gnarled trunk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, graceful 360-degree orbit around the tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the tree's branches dense and sinuous with silvery-green leaves that shimmer in the breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a landscape of rolling hills with the deep blue Aegean Sea in the distance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at a slightly lower angle and slide counterclockwise during the orbit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004645270295441151 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379645347595215 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004645270295441151, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004645270295441151, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0626767948269844, + 0.017811650410294533, + 0.041730575263500214, + 0.07130452990531921, + 0.29868489503860474, + 0.18555848300457, + 0.022628039121627808, + 0.17046323418617249, + 0.04979824647307396, + 0.0793435201048851 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004645270295441151 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a lone, ancient olive tree with a massive, gnarled trunk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, graceful 360-degree orbit around the tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the tree's branches dense and sinuous with silvery-green leaves that shimmer in the breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a landscape of rolling hills with the deep blue Aegean Sea in the distance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at a slightly lower angle and slide counterclockwise during the orbit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016061915084719658 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141061782836914 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016061915084719658, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016061915084719658, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17128801345825195, + 0.0584040991961956, + 0.10374181717634201, + 0.09989970177412033, + 0.027419624850153923, + 0.09527280926704407, + 0.014047018252313137, + 0.13984955847263336, + 0.21061886847019196, + 0.07945851981639862 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016061915084719658 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a lone, ancient olive tree with a massive, gnarled trunk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, graceful 360-degree orbit around the tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the tree's branches dense and sinuous with silvery-green leaves that shimmer in the breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a landscape of rolling hills with the deep blue Aegean Sea in the distance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at a slightly lower angle and slide counterclockwise during the orbit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06203652173280716 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120365142822266 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06203652173280716, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06203652173280716, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11144047230482101, + 0.05999773368239403, + 0.03595304116606712, + 0.10926838964223862, + 0.12661126255989075, + 0.13170380890369415, + 0.0750185027718544, + 0.11075393855571747, + 0.15401864051818848, + 0.08523419499397278 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06203652173280716 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow, graceful 360-degree drone orbit begins, circling a lone, ancient olive tree with a steady, reverent motion. The camera begins at a slightly lower angle, emphasizing the tree's grandeur. The initial view focuses on the massive, gnarled trunk, its bark an intricate tapestry of deep cracks and twisted muscle structures in weathered grays and earthy browns. As the camera slides counterclockwise, the warm, golden light of the Mediterranean afternoon captures the intricate textures, revealing patches of moss in the cracks. The orbit gradually widens, revealing the tree's full form. Its dense, sinuous branches reach toward the sky like arthritic fingers, adorned with dense clusters of tiny, silvery-green leaves that shimmer and dance in the gentle, warm breeze. Light filters through the leaves, casting speckled, shifting patterns on the sun-drenched terracotta ground below. In the background, the camera's circular path reveals a landscape of rolling, sun-drenched hills, with the deep blue Aegean Sea shimmering in the hazy distance. The atmosphere is one of profound peace and timeless tranquility, a cinematic portrayal of nature's endurance and quiet majesty.", + "seed": 25763, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_1/index_2225_seed_25763_dp_3_rank_6_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.027070599887520076, + "vlm_logprob": -0.027070599887520076, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.075, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.027070599887520076, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a lone, ancient olive tree with a massive, gnarled trunk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, graceful 360-degree orbit around the tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the tree's branches dense and sinuous with silvery-green leaves that shimmer in the breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a landscape of rolling hills with the deep blue Aegean Sea in the distance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at a slightly lower angle and slide counterclockwise during the orbit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005272530950605869 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.380272388458252 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005272530950605869, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005272530950605869, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1820070594549179, + 0.08503035455942154, + 0.039930183440446854, + 0.11548184603452682, + 0.10930673778057098, + 0.08123356848955154, + 0.05315200984477997, + 0.09174774587154388, + 0.15803028643131256, + 0.08408021181821823 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005272530950605869 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a lone, ancient olive tree with a massive, gnarled trunk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, graceful 360-degree orbit around the tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the tree's branches dense and sinuous with silvery-green leaves that shimmer in the breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a landscape of rolling hills with the deep blue Aegean Sea in the distance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at a slightly lower angle and slide counterclockwise during the orbit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.054947979748249054 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929948091506958 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.054947979748249054, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.054947979748249054, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1414501965045929, + 0.10801158100366592, + 0.08810354024171829, + 0.1320674866437912, + 0.08970619738101959, + 0.1289549320936203, + 0.11561775952577591, + 0.04118454083800316, + 0.0791592001914978, + 0.07574452459812164 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.054947979748249054 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a lone, ancient olive tree with a massive, gnarled trunk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, graceful 360-degree orbit around the tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the tree's branches dense and sinuous with silvery-green leaves that shimmer in the breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a landscape of rolling hills with the deep blue Aegean Sea in the distance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at a slightly lower angle and slide counterclockwise during the orbit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007640779484063387 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882640838623047 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007640779484063387, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007640779484063387, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13832014799118042, + 0.13644132018089294, + 0.08033037930727005, + 0.09809209406375885, + 0.16559216380119324, + 0.05864378437399864, + 0.08226573467254639, + 0.036833204329013824, + 0.11875668168067932, + 0.08472444862127304 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007640779484063387 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a lone, ancient olive tree with a massive, gnarled trunk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, graceful 360-degree orbit around the tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the tree's branches dense and sinuous with silvery-green leaves that shimmer in the breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a landscape of rolling hills with the deep blue Aegean Sea in the distance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at a slightly lower angle and slide counterclockwise during the orbit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012538767419755459 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387538909912109 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012538767419755459, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012538767419755459, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2878061830997467, + 0.02234134078025818, + 0.02588428184390068, + 0.041661012917757034, + 0.034209296107292175, + 0.15785935521125793, + 0.15160152316093445, + 0.05345677584409714, + 0.13438785076141357, + 0.09079236537218094 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012538767419755459 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a lone, ancient olive tree with a massive, gnarled trunk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, graceful 360-degree orbit around the tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the tree's branches dense and sinuous with silvery-green leaves that shimmer in the breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a landscape of rolling hills with the deep blue Aegean Sea in the distance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at a slightly lower angle and slide counterclockwise during the orbit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.054952941834926605 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.92995285987854 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.054952941834926605, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.054952941834926605, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2774389088153839, + 0.06861812621355057, + 0.06691344082355499, + 0.1077481359243393, + 0.08749701827764511, + 0.09383983910083771, + 0.10894489288330078, + 0.03747294843196869, + 0.0919160544872284, + 0.05961059033870697 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.054952941834926605 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_10/index_tensor([4238, 4238])_group_10_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_10/index_tensor([4238, 4238])_group_10_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..93cf3f6c6311ccdacb260e84390ba881be9998a4 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_10/index_tensor([4238, 4238])_group_10_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "low-angle, wide shot, the camera slowly pans right, tracking a lone figure walking down a broad, rain-soaked street in front of the magnificent Arc de Triomphe. The figure is a sharp, resolute man, dressed in a long, dark trench coat, its damp surface reflecting chaotic light like polished obsidian. He walks with a confident, unhurried demeanor, his hands tucked deep into his pockets, his heavy boots deliberately splashing in shallow puddles. In the background, the monumental Arc de Triomphe looms, its classical form reimagined in a gritty, Grand Theft Auto art style; its stone surfaces are dark, weathered, and streaked with rain, while its intricate carvings are rendered into sharp, dramatic relief by harsh artificial light. The entire scene is saturated in the glow of a rain-soaked sky, with vibrant pinks, electric blues, and vivid greens casting long, distorted reflections across the smooth, inky black asphalt. A steady downpour catches the light, creating a shimmering, dynamic veil across the frame, creating a cool, moody and intense cinematic atmosphere that blends historical grandeur with a menacing, digitally rendered, and distinctly modern urban noir aesthetic.", + "seed": 23423, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_10/index_4238_seed_23423_dp_20_rank_40_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.41474574711173773, + "vlm_logprob": -0.41474574711173773, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.2, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.41474574711173773, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a low-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera slowly panning right while tracking a lone man walking down a rain-soaked street?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the Arc de Triomphe visible in the background with a gritty, Grand Theft Auto art style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a long, dark trench coat with a damp surface reflecting chaotic light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene saturated with vibrant pinks, electric blues, and vivid greens casting reflections on the asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5048791170120239 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.004879117012024 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5048791170120239, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5048791170120239, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17194509506225586, + 0.11025389283895493, + 0.07364340126514435, + 0.09034569561481476, + 0.07277040928602219, + 0.07605968415737152, + 0.03023647516965866, + 0.1641700267791748, + 0.1355299949645996, + 0.07504528015851974 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5048791170120239 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a low-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera slowly panning right while tracking a lone man walking down a rain-soaked street?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the Arc de Triomphe visible in the background with a gritty, Grand Theft Auto art style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a long, dark trench coat with a damp surface reflecting chaotic light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene saturated with vibrant pinks, electric blues, and vivid greens casting reflections on the asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5020735263824463 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.25207358598709106 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.5020735263824463, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -1.5020735263824463, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13315144181251526, + 0.1065741777420044, + 0.16820324957370758, + 0.08866684883832932, + 0.04823688045144081, + 0.07368376851081848, + 0.01844235323369503, + 0.1750083565711975, + 0.10453464835882187, + 0.08349835872650146 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.5020735263824463 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a low-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera slowly panning right while tracking a lone man walking down a rain-soaked street?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the Arc de Triomphe visible in the background with a gritty, Grand Theft Auto art style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a long, dark trench coat with a damp surface reflecting chaotic light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene saturated with vibrant pinks, electric blues, and vivid greens casting reflections on the asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01256337109953165 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387563228607178 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01256337109953165, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01256337109953165, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23134151101112366, + 0.10414372384548187, + 0.07428911328315735, + 0.07338462024927139, + 0.05426150932908058, + 0.03164568543434143, + 0.02263084426522255, + 0.10526473075151443, + 0.24421222507953644, + 0.0588260181248188 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01256337109953165 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a low-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera slowly panning right while tracking a lone man walking down a rain-soaked street?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the Arc de Triomphe visible in the background with a gritty, Grand Theft Auto art style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a long, dark trench coat with a damp surface reflecting chaotic light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene saturated with vibrant pinks, electric blues, and vivid greens casting reflections on the asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016094880178570747 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.14109468460083 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016094880178570747, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016094880178570747, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3136044442653656, + 0.0749790146946907, + 0.08818954974412918, + 0.076046884059906, + 0.027290740981698036, + 0.034330353140830994, + 0.02096894569694996, + 0.2260439693927765, + 0.09447221457958221, + 0.04407385364174843 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016094880178570747 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a low-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera slowly panning right while tracking a lone man walking down a rain-soaked street?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the Arc de Triomphe visible in the background with a gritty, Grand Theft Auto art style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a long, dark trench coat with a damp surface reflecting chaotic light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene saturated with vibrant pinks, electric blues, and vivid greens casting reflections on the asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03811784088611603 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881178855895996 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03811784088611603, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03811784088611603, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.6188470721244812, + 0.10213097184896469, + 0.03231153264641762, + 0.022907104343175888, + 0.025561729446053505, + 0.006893232464790344, + 0.013698174618184566, + 0.05066051706671715, + 0.1051829606294632, + 0.021806683391332626 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03811784088611603 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, wide shot, the camera slowly pans right, tracking a lone figure walking down a broad, rain-soaked street in front of the magnificent Arc de Triomphe. The figure is a sharp, resolute man, dressed in a long, dark trench coat, its damp surface reflecting chaotic light like polished obsidian. He walks with a confident, unhurried demeanor, his hands tucked deep into his pockets, his heavy boots deliberately splashing in shallow puddles. In the background, the monumental Arc de Triomphe looms, its classical form reimagined in a gritty, Grand Theft Auto art style; its stone surfaces are dark, weathered, and streaked with rain, while its intricate carvings are rendered into sharp, dramatic relief by harsh artificial light. The entire scene is saturated in the glow of a rain-soaked sky, with vibrant pinks, electric blues, and vivid greens casting long, distorted reflections across the smooth, inky black asphalt. A steady downpour catches the light, creating a shimmering, dynamic veil across the frame, creating a cool, moody and intense cinematic atmosphere that blends historical grandeur with a menacing, digitally rendered, and distinctly modern urban noir aesthetic.", + "seed": 23424, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_10/index_4238_seed_23424_dp_20_rank_40_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.20508446572348477, + "vlm_logprob": -0.20508446572348477, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.725, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.20508446572348477, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a low-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera slowly panning right while tracking a lone man walking down a rain-soaked street?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the Arc de Triomphe visible in the background with a gritty, Grand Theft Auto art style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a long, dark trench coat with a damp surface reflecting chaotic light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene saturated with vibrant pinks, electric blues, and vivid greens casting reflections on the asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3404221534729004 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3404221534729004 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3404221534729004, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3404221534729004, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09420695155858994, + 0.08529745787382126, + 0.23840275406837463, + 0.15993250906467438, + 0.1372889131307602, + 0.1465214192867279, + 0.019823815673589706, + 0.042397141456604004, + 0.05073685571551323, + 0.02539217658340931 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3404221534729004 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a low-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera slowly panning right while tracking a lone man walking down a rain-soaked street?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the Arc de Triomphe visible in the background with a gritty, Grand Theft Auto art style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a long, dark trench coat with a damp surface reflecting chaotic light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene saturated with vibrant pinks, electric blues, and vivid greens casting reflections on the asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6328105330467224 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7578105330467224 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.6328105330467224, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.6328105330467224, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06536080688238144, + 0.04384809732437134, + 0.2404506802558899, + 0.2471110075712204, + 0.12114418298006058, + 0.09587649255990982, + 0.030382299795746803, + 0.05070488154888153, + 0.03034629300236702, + 0.07477527111768723 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.6328105330467224 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a low-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera slowly panning right while tracking a lone man walking down a rain-soaked street?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the Arc de Triomphe visible in the background with a gritty, Grand Theft Auto art style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a long, dark trench coat with a damp surface reflecting chaotic light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene saturated with vibrant pinks, electric blues, and vivid greens casting reflections on the asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007639951538294554 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.8826398849487305 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007639951538294554, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007639951538294554, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.046381283551454544, + 0.015231615863740444, + 0.3898063600063324, + 0.17578299343585968, + 0.03634512424468994, + 0.15760639309883118, + 0.008070295676589012, + 0.012384777888655663, + 0.011768566444516182, + 0.14662256836891174 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007639951538294554 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a low-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera slowly panning right while tracking a lone man walking down a rain-soaked street?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the Arc de Triomphe visible in the background with a gritty, Grand Theft Auto art style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a long, dark trench coat with a damp surface reflecting chaotic light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene saturated with vibrant pinks, electric blues, and vivid greens casting reflections on the asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026356181129813194 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513562202453613 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026356181129813194, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026356181129813194, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04666423425078392, + 0.07448127120733261, + 0.26523357629776, + 0.32556819915771484, + 0.10840564221143723, + 0.07221255451440811, + 0.016758641228079796, + 0.03827262669801712, + 0.020942138507962227, + 0.03146114572882652 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026356181129813194 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a low-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera slowly panning right while tracking a lone man walking down a rain-soaked street?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the Arc de Triomphe visible in the background with a gritty, Grand Theft Auto art style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a long, dark trench coat with a damp surface reflecting chaotic light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene saturated with vibrant pinks, electric blues, and vivid greens casting reflections on the asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018193509429693222 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.01819372177124 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018193509429693222, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018193509429693222, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.024007100611925125, + 0.03575679287314415, + 0.17959097027778625, + 0.08958213031291962, + 0.22509600222110748, + 0.051544126123189926, + 0.02481473609805107, + 0.048610880970954895, + 0.036241475492715836, + 0.28475576639175415 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018193509429693222 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, wide shot, the camera slowly pans right, tracking a lone figure walking down a broad, rain-soaked street in front of the magnificent Arc de Triomphe. The figure is a sharp, resolute man, dressed in a long, dark trench coat, its damp surface reflecting chaotic light like polished obsidian. He walks with a confident, unhurried demeanor, his hands tucked deep into his pockets, his heavy boots deliberately splashing in shallow puddles. In the background, the monumental Arc de Triomphe looms, its classical form reimagined in a gritty, Grand Theft Auto art style; its stone surfaces are dark, weathered, and streaked with rain, while its intricate carvings are rendered into sharp, dramatic relief by harsh artificial light. The entire scene is saturated in the glow of a rain-soaked sky, with vibrant pinks, electric blues, and vivid greens casting long, distorted reflections across the smooth, inky black asphalt. A steady downpour catches the light, creating a shimmering, dynamic veil across the frame, creating a cool, moody and intense cinematic atmosphere that blends historical grandeur with a menacing, digitally rendered, and distinctly modern urban noir aesthetic.", + "seed": 23425, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_10/index_4238_seed_23425_dp_21_rank_42_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.29724543578922746, + "vlm_logprob": -0.29724543578922746, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.224999988079071, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.29724543578922746, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a low-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera slowly panning right while tracking a lone man walking down a rain-soaked street?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the Arc de Triomphe visible in the background with a gritty, Grand Theft Auto art style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a long, dark trench coat with a damp surface reflecting chaotic light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene saturated with vibrant pinks, electric blues, and vivid greens casting reflections on the asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4161072373390198 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.166107177734375 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.4161072373390198, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.7499999403953552, + "token_credit_reward": -0.4161072373390198, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2141047865152359, + 0.10784152150154114, + 0.15525011718273163, + 0.10511394590139389, + 0.08696480840444565, + 0.053896255791187286, + 0.06317368894815445, + 0.07466621696949005, + 0.09498203545808792, + 0.04400668293237686 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.4161072373390198 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a low-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera slowly panning right while tracking a lone man walking down a rain-soaked street?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the Arc de Triomphe visible in the background with a gritty, Grand Theft Auto art style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a long, dark trench coat with a damp surface reflecting chaotic light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene saturated with vibrant pinks, electric blues, and vivid greens casting reflections on the asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9742538928985596 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.47425389289855957 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.9742538928985596, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.9742538928985596, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12847033143043518, + 0.16804543137550354, + 0.051049020141363144, + 0.17701154947280884, + 0.06888294219970703, + 0.0943298488855362, + 0.04634040221571922, + 0.1210217997431755, + 0.12071522325277328, + 0.024133482947945595 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.9742538928985596 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a low-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera slowly panning right while tracking a lone man walking down a rain-soaked street?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the Arc de Triomphe visible in the background with a gritty, Grand Theft Auto art style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a long, dark trench coat with a damp surface reflecting chaotic light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene saturated with vibrant pinks, electric blues, and vivid greens casting reflections on the asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011091364547610283 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511091232299805 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011091364547610283, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011091364547610283, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09313183277845383, + 0.0806567370891571, + 0.0787569060921669, + 0.09943974763154984, + 0.19118930399417877, + 0.22032879292964935, + 0.031167590990662575, + 0.08159104734659195, + 0.09414218366146088, + 0.02959584817290306 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011091364547610283 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a low-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera slowly panning right while tracking a lone man walking down a rain-soaked street?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the Arc de Triomphe visible in the background with a gritty, Grand Theft Auto art style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a long, dark trench coat with a damp surface reflecting chaotic light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene saturated with vibrant pinks, electric blues, and vivid greens casting reflections on the asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05496467649936676 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929964780807495 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05496467649936676, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05496467649936676, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08938098698854446, + 0.09864619374275208, + 0.10919293016195297, + 0.13655708730220795, + 0.0361044742166996, + 0.0455971360206604, + 0.025736169889569283, + 0.07828959077596664, + 0.07002007961273193, + 0.31047534942626953 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05496467649936676 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a low-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera slowly panning right while tracking a lone man walking down a rain-soaked street?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the Arc de Triomphe visible in the background with a gritty, Grand Theft Auto art style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a long, dark trench coat with a damp surface reflecting chaotic light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene saturated with vibrant pinks, electric blues, and vivid greens casting reflections on the asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02981000766158104 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298099517822266 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02981000766158104, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02981000766158104, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2642165422439575, + 0.051323339343070984, + 0.07096721231937408, + 0.07116648554801941, + 0.05378476530313492, + 0.30371758341789246, + 0.04429323598742485, + 0.04361807182431221, + 0.04097335785627365, + 0.05593942478299141 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02981000766158104 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, wide shot, the camera slowly pans right, tracking a lone figure walking down a broad, rain-soaked street in front of the magnificent Arc de Triomphe. The figure is a sharp, resolute man, dressed in a long, dark trench coat, its damp surface reflecting chaotic light like polished obsidian. He walks with a confident, unhurried demeanor, his hands tucked deep into his pockets, his heavy boots deliberately splashing in shallow puddles. In the background, the monumental Arc de Triomphe looms, its classical form reimagined in a gritty, Grand Theft Auto art style; its stone surfaces are dark, weathered, and streaked with rain, while its intricate carvings are rendered into sharp, dramatic relief by harsh artificial light. The entire scene is saturated in the glow of a rain-soaked sky, with vibrant pinks, electric blues, and vivid greens casting long, distorted reflections across the smooth, inky black asphalt. A steady downpour catches the light, creating a shimmering, dynamic veil across the frame, creating a cool, moody and intense cinematic atmosphere that blends historical grandeur with a menacing, digitally rendered, and distinctly modern urban noir aesthetic.", + "seed": 23426, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_10/index_4238_seed_23426_dp_21_rank_42_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.15526630338281394, + "vlm_logprob": -0.15526630338281394, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.45, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.15526630338281394, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a low-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera slowly panning right while tracking a lone man walking down a rain-soaked street?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the Arc de Triomphe visible in the background with a gritty, Grand Theft Auto art style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a long, dark trench coat with a damp surface reflecting chaotic light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene saturated with vibrant pinks, electric blues, and vivid greens casting reflections on the asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.23500417172908783 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.735004186630249 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.23500417172908783, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.23500417172908783, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1589299440383911, + 0.08858910948038101, + 0.11060657352209091, + 0.11303139477968216, + 0.10697561502456665, + 0.11927558481693268, + 0.11613648384809494, + 0.06362207233905792, + 0.06598728895187378, + 0.05684588849544525 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.23500417172908783 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a low-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera slowly panning right while tracking a lone man walking down a rain-soaked street?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the Arc de Triomphe visible in the background with a gritty, Grand Theft Auto art style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a long, dark trench coat with a damp surface reflecting chaotic light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene saturated with vibrant pinks, electric blues, and vivid greens casting reflections on the asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5233752727508545 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8983752727508545 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5233752727508545, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5233752727508545, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1960320621728897, + 0.12129060178995132, + 0.05952078476548195, + 0.044615548104047775, + 0.05616772174835205, + 0.03354885056614876, + 0.13581471145153046, + 0.12295658886432648, + 0.07017833739519119, + 0.15987475216388702 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5233752727508545 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a low-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera slowly panning right while tracking a lone man walking down a rain-soaked street?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the Arc de Triomphe visible in the background with a gritty, Grand Theft Auto art style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a long, dark trench coat with a damp surface reflecting chaotic light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene saturated with vibrant pinks, electric blues, and vivid greens casting reflections on the asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005260909907519817 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255260944366455 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005260909907519817, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005260909907519817, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11213197559118271, + 0.19125235080718994, + 0.14738371968269348, + 0.16530558466911316, + 0.1681019812822342, + 0.0379038043320179, + 0.047240886837244034, + 0.045167166739702225, + 0.03889118507504463, + 0.04662134125828743 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005260909907519817 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a low-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera slowly panning right while tracking a lone man walking down a rain-soaked street?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the Arc de Triomphe visible in the background with a gritty, Grand Theft Auto art style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a long, dark trench coat with a damp surface reflecting chaotic light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene saturated with vibrant pinks, electric blues, and vivid greens casting reflections on the asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006740570068359375 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006740570068359 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006740570068359375, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006740570068359375, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22930659353733063, + 0.0856020376086235, + 0.05766470730304718, + 0.09671781957149506, + 0.05112598091363907, + 0.12474581599235535, + 0.10123825073242188, + 0.1356981098651886, + 0.07234585285186768, + 0.04555481672286987 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006740570068359375 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a low-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera slowly panning right while tracking a lone man walking down a rain-soaked street?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the Arc de Triomphe visible in the background with a gritty, Grand Theft Auto art style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a long, dark trench coat with a damp surface reflecting chaotic light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene saturated with vibrant pinks, electric blues, and vivid greens casting reflections on the asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005950592458248138 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130950450897217 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005950592458248138, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005950592458248138, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08252150565385818, + 0.07159329205751419, + 0.13114601373672485, + 0.1330980509519577, + 0.15940052270889282, + 0.09622713923454285, + 0.07094131410121918, + 0.08438904583454132, + 0.06442965567111969, + 0.10625344514846802 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005950592458248138 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_11/index_tensor([4971, 4971])_group_11_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_11/index_tensor([4971, 4971])_group_11_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..11bd6d5b5ea7b844b2d73ffc064c8d26eb25de76 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_11/index_tensor([4971, 4971])_group_11_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "stunning first-person close-up, the camera held perfectly still, immersing the viewer completely in the operator's field of vision. At the bottom of the frame, a pair of bony hands with meticulously manicured nails appeared steadily in view. In the right hand, a scalpel, gleaming with a dazzling metallic gleam, was gripped. Its sharp blade carefully and slowly sliced into the black plastic casing of an old-fashioned car CD player. The surface of the machine was covered in a crisscross of scratches, deep and shallow, and the marks of age. With steady, slow pressure from the wrist, the blade silently sliced through the casing, leaving a precise and deep incision. As the casing peeled away, piece by piece, revealing not the expected cold metal circuit boards and cables, but clumps and clumps of vibrant, moist, gray-white nerve tissue. Like countless tangled worms, they pulsed and wriggled in a slow, rhythmic rhythm. Fine veins of blood spread across the surface, and some nerve endings even twitched slightly at the contact of air. The entire picture adopts the artistic style of Junji Ito, presenting an extreme black and white high contrast. The only top light cuts the picture sharply, creating dazzling highlights on the metal surface of the scalpel and the slippery nerve tissue, while in the grooves of the scratches and the folds of the tissue, there is an impenetrable pure darkness. This extreme detail is combined with the biological grotesqueness to create a strong and disturbing atmosphere that is a mixture of surgical calmness and unspeakable physiological fear.", + "seed": 26686, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_11/index_4971_seed_26686_dp_22_rank_44_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.17005720566958188, + "vlm_logprob": -0.17005720566958188, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.9, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.17005720566958188, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective with the camera held perfectly still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are bony hands with meticulously manicured nails visible at the bottom of the frame holding a scalpel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scalpel slicing slowly into a black plastic casing of an old-fashioned car CD player covered in scratches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the casing reveal vibrant, moist, gray-white nerve tissue that pulses and wriggles instead of metal circuit boards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the image rendered in an extreme black and white high contrast style resembling the artistic style of Junji Ito?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7121109962463379 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7121109962463379 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.7121109962463379, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.7121109962463379, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19229619204998016, + 0.0514189675450325, + 0.023357246071100235, + 0.044835805892944336, + 0.02423323132097721, + 0.05103854089975357, + 0.03942272812128067, + 0.36510905623435974, + 0.1155148446559906, + 0.0927734300494194 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.7121109962463379 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective with the camera held perfectly still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are bony hands with meticulously manicured nails visible at the bottom of the frame holding a scalpel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scalpel slicing slowly into a black plastic casing of an old-fashioned car CD player covered in scratches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the casing reveal vibrant, moist, gray-white nerve tissue that pulses and wriggles instead of metal circuit boards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the image rendered in an extreme black and white high contrast style resembling the artistic style of Junji Ito?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07905332744121552 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5790534019470215 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07905332744121552, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07905332744121552, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25252240896224976, + 0.06299827247858047, + 0.04689332842826843, + 0.10670231282711029, + 0.04815346375107765, + 0.07939793169498444, + 0.022833749651908875, + 0.1386294811964035, + 0.10671074688434601, + 0.13515831530094147 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07905332744121552 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective with the camera held perfectly still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are bony hands with meticulously manicured nails visible at the bottom of the frame holding a scalpel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scalpel slicing slowly into a black plastic casing of an old-fashioned car CD player covered in scratches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the casing reveal vibrant, moist, gray-white nerve tissue that pulses and wriggles instead of metal circuit boards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the image rendered in an extreme black and white high contrast style resembling the artistic style of Junji Ito?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018215984106063843 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018216133117676 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018215984106063843, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018215984106063843, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24781709909439087, + 0.08832352608442307, + 0.08428087830543518, + 0.10570721328258514, + 0.03729410842061043, + 0.03333568200469017, + 0.040411271154880524, + 0.12641645967960358, + 0.14367073774337769, + 0.09274303913116455 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018215984106063843 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective with the camera held perfectly still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are bony hands with meticulously manicured nails visible at the bottom of the frame holding a scalpel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scalpel slicing slowly into a black plastic casing of an old-fashioned car CD player covered in scratches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the casing reveal vibrant, moist, gray-white nerve tissue that pulses and wriggles instead of metal circuit boards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the image rendered in an extreme black and white high contrast style resembling the artistic style of Junji Ito?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011088653467595577 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511088848114014 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011088653467595577, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011088653467595577, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20544877648353577, + 0.07672823220491409, + 0.1495443433523178, + 0.1960158795118332, + 0.03415246680378914, + 0.022593727335333824, + 0.024060672149062157, + 0.05054377764463425, + 0.13089430332183838, + 0.1100178137421608 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011088653467595577 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective with the camera held perfectly still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are bony hands with meticulously manicured nails visible at the bottom of the frame holding a scalpel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scalpel slicing slowly into a black plastic casing of an old-fashioned car CD player covered in scratches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the casing reveal vibrant, moist, gray-white nerve tissue that pulses and wriggles instead of metal circuit boards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the image rendered in an extreme black and white high contrast style resembling the artistic style of Junji Ito?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029817067086696625 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298171043395996 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029817067086696625, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029817067086696625, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2507927417755127, + 0.1911386102437973, + 0.06919677555561066, + 0.09626331180334091, + 0.019696354866027832, + 0.028332702815532684, + 0.02204105630517006, + 0.0790448859333992, + 0.10889628529548645, + 0.13459722697734833 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029817067086696625 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "stunning first-person close-up, the camera held perfectly still, immersing the viewer completely in the operator's field of vision. At the bottom of the frame, a pair of bony hands with meticulously manicured nails appeared steadily in view. In the right hand, a scalpel, gleaming with a dazzling metallic gleam, was gripped. Its sharp blade carefully and slowly sliced into the black plastic casing of an old-fashioned car CD player. The surface of the machine was covered in a crisscross of scratches, deep and shallow, and the marks of age. With steady, slow pressure from the wrist, the blade silently sliced through the casing, leaving a precise and deep incision. As the casing peeled away, piece by piece, revealing not the expected cold metal circuit boards and cables, but clumps and clumps of vibrant, moist, gray-white nerve tissue. Like countless tangled worms, they pulsed and wriggled in a slow, rhythmic rhythm. Fine veins of blood spread across the surface, and some nerve endings even twitched slightly at the contact of air. The entire picture adopts the artistic style of Junji Ito, presenting an extreme black and white high contrast. The only top light cuts the picture sharply, creating dazzling highlights on the metal surface of the scalpel and the slippery nerve tissue, while in the grooves of the scratches and the folds of the tissue, there is an impenetrable pure darkness. This extreme detail is combined with the biological grotesqueness to create a strong and disturbing atmosphere that is a mixture of surgical calmness and unspeakable physiological fear.", + "seed": 26687, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_11/index_4971_seed_26687_dp_22_rank_44_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.3056273074820638, + "vlm_logprob": -0.3056273074820638, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.475, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.3056273074820638, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective with the camera held perfectly still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are bony hands with meticulously manicured nails visible at the bottom of the frame holding a scalpel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scalpel slicing slowly into a black plastic casing of an old-fashioned car CD player covered in scratches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the casing reveal vibrant, moist, gray-white nerve tissue that pulses and wriggles instead of metal circuit boards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the image rendered in an extreme black and white high contrast style resembling the artistic style of Junji Ito?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3207372426986694 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.32073724269866943 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.3207372426986694, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -1.3207372426986694, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2247595191001892, + 0.043641749769449234, + 0.14842116832733154, + 0.059442371129989624, + 0.12361083179712296, + 0.07159879058599472, + 0.08669761568307877, + 0.07658214122056961, + 0.05055809020996094, + 0.1146877110004425 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.3207372426986694 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective with the camera held perfectly still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are bony hands with meticulously manicured nails visible at the bottom of the frame holding a scalpel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scalpel slicing slowly into a black plastic casing of an old-fashioned car CD player covered in scratches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the casing reveal vibrant, moist, gray-white nerve tissue that pulses and wriggles instead of metal circuit boards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the image rendered in an extreme black and white high contrast style resembling the artistic style of Junji Ito?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07904429733753204 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5790443420410156 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07904429733753204, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07904429733753204, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.27889469265937805, + 0.17980371415615082, + 0.06564828008413315, + 0.03142591565847397, + 0.08970662206411362, + 0.039168715476989746, + 0.12134739011526108, + 0.09153017401695251, + 0.050105296075344086, + 0.05236908048391342 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07904429733753204 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective with the camera held perfectly still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are bony hands with meticulously manicured nails visible at the bottom of the frame holding a scalpel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scalpel slicing slowly into a black plastic casing of an old-fashioned car CD player covered in scratches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the casing reveal vibrant, moist, gray-white nerve tissue that pulses and wriggles instead of metal circuit boards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the image rendered in an extreme black and white high contrast style resembling the artistic style of Junji Ito?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018207555636763573 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018207550048828 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018207555636763573, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018207555636763573, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.30591917037963867, + 0.09957617521286011, + 0.07092329859733582, + 0.034993983805179596, + 0.07161841541528702, + 0.06434507668018341, + 0.09612951427698135, + 0.09651532769203186, + 0.05492398515343666, + 0.10505503416061401 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018207555636763573 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective with the camera held perfectly still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are bony hands with meticulously manicured nails visible at the bottom of the frame holding a scalpel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scalpel slicing slowly into a black plastic casing of an old-fashioned car CD player covered in scratches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the casing reveal vibrant, moist, gray-white nerve tissue that pulses and wriggles instead of metal circuit boards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the image rendered in an extreme black and white high contrast style resembling the artistic style of Junji Ito?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009797225706279278 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634797096252441 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009797225706279278, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009797225706279278, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15539073944091797, + 0.07869528979063034, + 0.09331067651510239, + 0.03816036880016327, + 0.03305356949567795, + 0.024494174867868423, + 0.14334586262702942, + 0.19507454335689545, + 0.13349127769470215, + 0.104983389377594 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009797225706279278 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective with the camera held perfectly still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are bony hands with meticulously manicured nails visible at the bottom of the frame holding a scalpel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scalpel slicing slowly into a black plastic casing of an old-fashioned car CD player covered in scratches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the casing reveal vibrant, moist, gray-white nerve tissue that pulses and wriggles instead of metal circuit boards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the image rendered in an extreme black and white high contrast style resembling the artistic style of Junji Ito?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10035021603107452 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3503501415252686 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10035021603107452, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10035021603107452, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09188424050807953, + 0.05145811289548874, + 0.03057793900370598, + 0.019222524017095566, + 0.012490643188357353, + 0.018287599086761475, + 0.20934107899665833, + 0.4679131507873535, + 0.02748389169573784, + 0.07134080678224564 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10035021603107452 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "stunning first-person close-up, the camera held perfectly still, immersing the viewer completely in the operator's field of vision. At the bottom of the frame, a pair of bony hands with meticulously manicured nails appeared steadily in view. In the right hand, a scalpel, gleaming with a dazzling metallic gleam, was gripped. Its sharp blade carefully and slowly sliced into the black plastic casing of an old-fashioned car CD player. The surface of the machine was covered in a crisscross of scratches, deep and shallow, and the marks of age. With steady, slow pressure from the wrist, the blade silently sliced through the casing, leaving a precise and deep incision. As the casing peeled away, piece by piece, revealing not the expected cold metal circuit boards and cables, but clumps and clumps of vibrant, moist, gray-white nerve tissue. Like countless tangled worms, they pulsed and wriggled in a slow, rhythmic rhythm. Fine veins of blood spread across the surface, and some nerve endings even twitched slightly at the contact of air. The entire picture adopts the artistic style of Junji Ito, presenting an extreme black and white high contrast. The only top light cuts the picture sharply, creating dazzling highlights on the metal surface of the scalpel and the slippery nerve tissue, while in the grooves of the scratches and the folds of the tissue, there is an impenetrable pure darkness. This extreme detail is combined with the biological grotesqueness to create a strong and disturbing atmosphere that is a mixture of surgical calmness and unspeakable physiological fear.", + "seed": 26688, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_11/index_4971_seed_26688_dp_23_rank_46_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.3363409166224301, + "vlm_logprob": -0.3363409166224301, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.55, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.3363409166224301, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective with the camera held perfectly still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are bony hands with meticulously manicured nails visible at the bottom of the frame holding a scalpel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scalpel slicing slowly into a black plastic casing of an old-fashioned car CD player covered in scratches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the casing reveal vibrant, moist, gray-white nerve tissue that pulses and wriggles instead of metal circuit boards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the image rendered in an extreme black and white high contrast style resembling the artistic style of Junji Ito?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5067206621170044 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2567206621170044 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.5067206621170044, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -1.5067206621170044, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.02575697749853134, + 0.013642515987157822, + 0.008185227401554585, + 0.015162229537963867, + 0.8548135757446289, + 0.010585852898657322, + 0.04227681830525398, + 0.0041244844906032085, + 0.01141720823943615, + 0.014035111293196678 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.5067206621170044 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective with the camera held perfectly still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are bony hands with meticulously manicured nails visible at the bottom of the frame holding a scalpel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scalpel slicing slowly into a black plastic casing of an old-fashioned car CD player covered in scratches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the casing reveal vibrant, moist, gray-white nerve tissue that pulses and wriggles instead of metal circuit boards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the image rendered in an extreme black and white high contrast style resembling the artistic style of Junji Ito?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0790700763463974 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5790700912475586 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0790700763463974, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0790700763463974, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.061993811279535294, + 0.0163243617862463, + 0.0060799336060881615, + 0.022533204406499863, + 0.7848572134971619, + 0.005131107289344072, + 0.02130492590367794, + 0.009109980426728725, + 0.027651023119688034, + 0.0450144037604332 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0790700763463974 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective with the camera held perfectly still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are bony hands with meticulously manicured nails visible at the bottom of the frame holding a scalpel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scalpel slicing slowly into a black plastic casing of an old-fashioned car CD player covered in scratches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the casing reveal vibrant, moist, gray-white nerve tissue that pulses and wriggles instead of metal circuit boards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the image rendered in an extreme black and white high contrast style resembling the artistic style of Junji Ito?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01821024715900421 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018210411071777 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01821024715900421, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01821024715900421, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12445845454931259, + 0.037458837032318115, + 0.029539527371525764, + 0.06602499634027481, + 0.4279956519603729, + 0.0436253659427166, + 0.09466738998889923, + 0.036183275282382965, + 0.10291937738656998, + 0.037127092480659485 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01821024715900421 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective with the camera held perfectly still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are bony hands with meticulously manicured nails visible at the bottom of the frame holding a scalpel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scalpel slicing slowly into a black plastic casing of an old-fashioned car CD player covered in scratches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the casing reveal vibrant, moist, gray-white nerve tissue that pulses and wriggles instead of metal circuit boards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the image rendered in an extreme black and white high contrast style resembling the artistic style of Junji Ito?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007640542928129435 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882640361785889 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007640542928129435, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007640542928129435, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.02026013471186161, + 0.007705045863986015, + 0.0066734482534229755, + 0.012662246823310852, + 0.8215174078941345, + 0.005863606464117765, + 0.015093393623828888, + 0.015534174628555775, + 0.049150511622428894, + 0.04554007202386856 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007640542928129435 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective with the camera held perfectly still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are bony hands with meticulously manicured nails visible at the bottom of the frame holding a scalpel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scalpel slicing slowly into a black plastic casing of an old-fashioned car CD player covered in scratches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the casing reveal vibrant, moist, gray-white nerve tissue that pulses and wriggles instead of metal circuit boards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the image rendered in an extreme black and white high contrast style resembling the artistic style of Junji Ito?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07006305456161499 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950631141662598 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07006305456161499, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07006305456161499, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.01622396521270275, + 0.006776513531804085, + 0.0030270167626440525, + 0.005054670851677656, + 0.8596312403678894, + 0.007862911559641361, + 0.010793954133987427, + 0.03140097111463547, + 0.007000939454883337, + 0.05222782492637634 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07006305456161499 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "stunning first-person close-up, the camera held perfectly still, immersing the viewer completely in the operator's field of vision. At the bottom of the frame, a pair of bony hands with meticulously manicured nails appeared steadily in view. In the right hand, a scalpel, gleaming with a dazzling metallic gleam, was gripped. Its sharp blade carefully and slowly sliced into the black plastic casing of an old-fashioned car CD player. The surface of the machine was covered in a crisscross of scratches, deep and shallow, and the marks of age. With steady, slow pressure from the wrist, the blade silently sliced through the casing, leaving a precise and deep incision. As the casing peeled away, piece by piece, revealing not the expected cold metal circuit boards and cables, but clumps and clumps of vibrant, moist, gray-white nerve tissue. Like countless tangled worms, they pulsed and wriggled in a slow, rhythmic rhythm. Fine veins of blood spread across the surface, and some nerve endings even twitched slightly at the contact of air. The entire picture adopts the artistic style of Junji Ito, presenting an extreme black and white high contrast. The only top light cuts the picture sharply, creating dazzling highlights on the metal surface of the scalpel and the slippery nerve tissue, while in the grooves of the scratches and the folds of the tissue, there is an impenetrable pure darkness. This extreme detail is combined with the biological grotesqueness to create a strong and disturbing atmosphere that is a mixture of surgical calmness and unspeakable physiological fear.", + "seed": 26689, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_11/index_4971_seed_26689_dp_23_rank_46_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.24003105144947767, + "vlm_logprob": -0.24003105144947767, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.424999988079071, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.24003105144947767, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective with the camera held perfectly still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are bony hands with meticulously manicured nails visible at the bottom of the frame holding a scalpel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scalpel slicing slowly into a black plastic casing of an old-fashioned car CD player covered in scratches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the casing reveal vibrant, moist, gray-white nerve tissue that pulses and wriggles instead of metal circuit boards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the image rendered in an extreme black and white high contrast style resembling the artistic style of Junji Ito?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.144378423690796 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3943783640861511 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.144378423690796, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.7500000596046448, + "token_credit_reward": -1.144378423690796, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12957382202148438, + 0.06012169271707535, + 0.0902114138007164, + 0.10676045715808868, + 0.09825946390628815, + 0.05374320596456528, + 0.16774718463420868, + 0.15619869530200958, + 0.055560819804668427, + 0.08182323724031448 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.144378423690796 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective with the camera held perfectly still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are bony hands with meticulously manicured nails visible at the bottom of the frame holding a scalpel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scalpel slicing slowly into a black plastic casing of an old-fashioned car CD player covered in scratches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the casing reveal vibrant, moist, gray-white nerve tissue that pulses and wriggles instead of metal circuit boards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the image rendered in an extreme black and white high contrast style resembling the artistic style of Junji Ito?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026382653042674065 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513826847076416 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026382653042674065, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026382653042674065, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16338728368282318, + 0.08663704246282578, + 0.09399677067995071, + 0.11392852663993835, + 0.13055121898651123, + 0.03623716160655022, + 0.06895332038402557, + 0.04485232010483742, + 0.05437440425157547, + 0.20708192884922028 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026382653042674065 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective with the camera held perfectly still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are bony hands with meticulously manicured nails visible at the bottom of the frame holding a scalpel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scalpel slicing slowly into a black plastic casing of an old-fashioned car CD player covered in scratches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the casing reveal vibrant, moist, gray-white nerve tissue that pulses and wriggles instead of metal circuit boards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the image rendered in an extreme black and white high contrast style resembling the artistic style of Junji Ito?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014209521003067493 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264209747314453 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014209521003067493, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014209521003067493, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.302979052066803, + 0.04321277514100075, + 0.04127753525972366, + 0.033948738127946854, + 0.08233936876058578, + 0.07669556140899658, + 0.2092522531747818, + 0.08618449419736862, + 0.05135563388466835, + 0.07275456935167313 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014209521003067493 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective with the camera held perfectly still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are bony hands with meticulously manicured nails visible at the bottom of the frame holding a scalpel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scalpel slicing slowly into a black plastic casing of an old-fashioned car CD player covered in scratches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the casing reveal vibrant, moist, gray-white nerve tissue that pulses and wriggles instead of metal circuit boards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the image rendered in an extreme black and white high contrast style resembling the artistic style of Junji Ito?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004100368358194828 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504100322723389 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004100368358194828, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004100368358194828, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1000933051109314, + 0.043493907898664474, + 0.061278752982616425, + 0.06309966742992401, + 0.12769626080989838, + 0.06419039517641068, + 0.22750215232372284, + 0.09203356504440308, + 0.07387164235115051, + 0.14674033224582672 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004100368358194828 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective with the camera held perfectly still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are bony hands with meticulously manicured nails visible at the bottom of the frame holding a scalpel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scalpel slicing slowly into a black plastic casing of an old-fashioned car CD player covered in scratches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the casing reveal vibrant, moist, gray-white nerve tissue that pulses and wriggles instead of metal circuit boards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the image rendered in an extreme black and white high contrast style resembling the artistic style of Junji Ito?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011084291152656078 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511084079742432 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011084291152656078, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011084291152656078, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08483767509460449, + 0.09197820723056793, + 0.05827762186527252, + 0.03744754195213318, + 0.07708278298377991, + 0.26801571249961853, + 0.20065563917160034, + 0.038326188921928406, + 0.037443608045578, + 0.10593506693840027 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011084291152656078 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_12/index_tensor([5367, 5367])_group_12_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_12/index_tensor([5367, 5367])_group_12_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..5378f17510eb01fccd49fa0766fa981597ac8ad0 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_12/index_tensor([5367, 5367])_group_12_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "The high-contrast macro shot begins, the camera tracking uncomfortably slowly from left to right, maintaining a tight profile. The subject is a dead black ant, its black exoskeleton rendered with exquisite clarity. Its jaws make a final, desperate grip on the vibrant green edge of a waxy leaf, its stiff legs curled tightly around its dark, segmented body. As the camera continues its deliberate crawl, it passes over the ant's thorax and peaks at its head, from which a sinister fungal stalk erupts vertically. The eerie, pale orange plant is fibrous and strangely textured, its surface covered in a layer of glistening, globular morning dew that catches the sharp, directed light like tiny jewels. The intense, high-contrast lighting casts deep, dramatic shadows, sculpting every gruesome detail of the stem's texture and the ant's lifeless form, creating an eerie atmosphere that is both clinically beautiful and deeply unsettling against the backdrop, which dissolves into a soft, out-of-focus blur of dark green and earthy brown.", + "seed": 7434, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_12/index_5367_seed_7434_dp_24_rank_48_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.056011170893907544, + "vlm_logprob": -0.056011170893907544, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.625, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.056011170893907544, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a dead black ant with a visible black exoskeleton?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the ant gripping the edge of a vibrant green waxy leaf with its jaws and legs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a sinister pale orange fungal stalk erupt vertically from the ant's head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the fungal stalk covered in glistening globular dew that catches sharp directed light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera track slowly from left to right, passing over the ant's thorax and peaking at its head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.18053603172302246 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8055360317230225 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.18053603172302246, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.18053603172302246, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.37818416953086853, + 0.04509245231747627, + 0.03183304890990257, + 0.046806227415800095, + 0.05986882001161575, + 0.058228567242622375, + 0.07590706646442413, + 0.06663376092910767, + 0.06118408218026161, + 0.17626184225082397 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.18053603172302246 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a dead black ant with a visible black exoskeleton?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the ant gripping the edge of a vibrant green waxy leaf with its jaws and legs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a sinister pale orange fungal stalk erupt vertically from the ant's head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the fungal stalk covered in glistening globular dew that catches sharp directed light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera track slowly from left to right, passing over the ant's thorax and peaking at its head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011094076558947563 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511094093322754 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011094076558947563, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011094076558947563, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.36376652121543884, + 0.0464596301317215, + 0.12581957876682281, + 0.04741085693240166, + 0.13599248230457306, + 0.020864026620984077, + 0.041140709072351456, + 0.05565829575061798, + 0.055832117795944214, + 0.10705579817295074 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011094076558947563 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a dead black ant with a visible black exoskeleton?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the ant gripping the edge of a vibrant green waxy leaf with its jaws and legs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a sinister pale orange fungal stalk erupt vertically from the ant's head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the fungal stalk covered in glistening globular dew that catches sharp directed light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera track slowly from left to right, passing over the ant's thorax and peaking at its head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00978530291467905 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634785175323486 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00978530291467905, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00978530291467905, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14498496055603027, + 0.053910281509160995, + 0.03927241638302803, + 0.03120039403438568, + 0.0731944739818573, + 0.04713154211640358, + 0.04741514101624489, + 0.09089136123657227, + 0.054013948887586594, + 0.4179854393005371 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00978530291467905 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a dead black ant with a visible black exoskeleton?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the ant gripping the edge of a vibrant green waxy leaf with its jaws and legs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a sinister pale orange fungal stalk erupt vertically from the ant's head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the fungal stalk covered in glistening globular dew that catches sharp directed light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera track slowly from left to right, passing over the ant's thorax and peaking at its head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008636740036308765 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758636951446533 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008636740036308765, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008636740036308765, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13010235130786896, + 0.08190308511257172, + 0.07177916914224625, + 0.04858847334980965, + 0.1211547777056694, + 0.04265341907739639, + 0.043394654989242554, + 0.05222981050610542, + 0.11607713997364044, + 0.2921172082424164 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008636740036308765 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a dead black ant with a visible black exoskeleton?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the ant gripping the edge of a vibrant green waxy leaf with its jaws and legs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a sinister pale orange fungal stalk erupt vertically from the ant's head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the fungal stalk covered in glistening globular dew that catches sharp directed light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera track slowly from left to right, passing over the ant's thorax and peaking at its head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0700037032365799 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950037479400635 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0700037032365799, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0700037032365799, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06969654560089111, + 0.033928822726011276, + 0.04263651371002197, + 0.08360087871551514, + 0.09949014335870743, + 0.04416146129369736, + 0.032634831964969635, + 0.03557005897164345, + 0.028693249449133873, + 0.5295875072479248 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0700037032365799 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "The high-contrast macro shot begins, the camera tracking uncomfortably slowly from left to right, maintaining a tight profile. The subject is a dead black ant, its black exoskeleton rendered with exquisite clarity. Its jaws make a final, desperate grip on the vibrant green edge of a waxy leaf, its stiff legs curled tightly around its dark, segmented body. As the camera continues its deliberate crawl, it passes over the ant's thorax and peaks at its head, from which a sinister fungal stalk erupts vertically. The eerie, pale orange plant is fibrous and strangely textured, its surface covered in a layer of glistening, globular morning dew that catches the sharp, directed light like tiny jewels. The intense, high-contrast lighting casts deep, dramatic shadows, sculpting every gruesome detail of the stem's texture and the ant's lifeless form, creating an eerie atmosphere that is both clinically beautiful and deeply unsettling against the backdrop, which dissolves into a soft, out-of-focus blur of dark green and earthy brown.", + "seed": 7435, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_12/index_5367_seed_7435_dp_24_rank_48_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.06039447672665119, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06039447672665119, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.949999952316284, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06039447672665119, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a dead black ant with a visible black exoskeleton?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the ant gripping the edge of a vibrant green waxy leaf with its jaws and legs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a sinister pale orange fungal stalk erupt vertically from the ant's head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the fungal stalk covered in glistening globular dew that catches sharp directed light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera track slowly from left to right, passing over the ant's thorax and peaking at its head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1016298457980156 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3516297340393066 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1016298457980156, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1016298457980156, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11352028697729111, + 0.14037474989891052, + 0.16322439908981323, + 0.06349194794893265, + 0.04601325839757919, + 0.10078119486570358, + 0.08795180171728134, + 0.09948883950710297, + 0.14577873051166534, + 0.039374854415655136 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1016298457980156 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a dead black ant with a visible black exoskeleton?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the ant gripping the edge of a vibrant green waxy leaf with its jaws and legs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a sinister pale orange fungal stalk erupt vertically from the ant's head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the fungal stalk covered in glistening globular dew that catches sharp directed light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera track slowly from left to right, passing over the ant's thorax and peaking at its head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.055016353726387024 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.930016279220581 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.055016353726387024, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.055016353726387024, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09545198827981949, + 0.0566331185400486, + 0.054525893181562424, + 0.029846232384443283, + 0.017938219010829926, + 0.14236915111541748, + 0.28344157338142395, + 0.06437136232852936, + 0.16326622664928436, + 0.09215610474348068 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.055016353726387024 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a dead black ant with a visible black exoskeleton?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the ant gripping the edge of a vibrant green waxy leaf with its jaws and legs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a sinister pale orange fungal stalk erupt vertically from the ant's head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the fungal stalk covered in glistening globular dew that catches sharp directed light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera track slowly from left to right, passing over the ant's thorax and peaking at its head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018194327130913734 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018194198608398 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018194327130913734, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018194327130913734, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09362509846687317, + 0.0809478834271431, + 0.1619243323802948, + 0.09522829949855804, + 0.0679728090763092, + 0.0997764840722084, + 0.0994601845741272, + 0.08727400749921799, + 0.12576918303966522, + 0.08802172541618347 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018194327130913734 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a dead black ant with a visible black exoskeleton?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the ant gripping the edge of a vibrant green waxy leaf with its jaws and legs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a sinister pale orange fungal stalk erupt vertically from the ant's head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the fungal stalk covered in glistening globular dew that catches sharp directed light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera track slowly from left to right, passing over the ant's thorax and peaking at its head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03810613602399826 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881062030792236 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03810613602399826, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03810613602399826, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21358376741409302, + 0.08974551409482956, + 0.11737348884344101, + 0.09466616064310074, + 0.06988553702831268, + 0.08745591342449188, + 0.08796296268701553, + 0.059270136058330536, + 0.12476933747529984, + 0.05528721958398819 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03810613602399826 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a dead black ant with a visible black exoskeleton?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the ant gripping the edge of a vibrant green waxy leaf with its jaws and legs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a sinister pale orange fungal stalk erupt vertically from the ant's head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the fungal stalk covered in glistening globular dew that catches sharp directed light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera track slowly from left to right, passing over the ant's thorax and peaking at its head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08902572095394135 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4640257358551025 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08902572095394135, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08902572095394135, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2027885913848877, + 0.07225453108549118, + 0.11930964887142181, + 0.06438455730676651, + 0.04493439570069313, + 0.10056360810995102, + 0.14149260520935059, + 0.07060901075601578, + 0.11898676306009293, + 0.06467628479003906 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08902572095394135 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "The high-contrast macro shot begins, the camera tracking uncomfortably slowly from left to right, maintaining a tight profile. The subject is a dead black ant, its black exoskeleton rendered with exquisite clarity. Its jaws make a final, desperate grip on the vibrant green edge of a waxy leaf, its stiff legs curled tightly around its dark, segmented body. As the camera continues its deliberate crawl, it passes over the ant's thorax and peaks at its head, from which a sinister fungal stalk erupts vertically. The eerie, pale orange plant is fibrous and strangely textured, its surface covered in a layer of glistening, globular morning dew that catches the sharp, directed light like tiny jewels. The intense, high-contrast lighting casts deep, dramatic shadows, sculpting every gruesome detail of the stem's texture and the ant's lifeless form, creating an eerie atmosphere that is both clinically beautiful and deeply unsettling against the backdrop, which dissolves into a soft, out-of-focus blur of dark green and earthy brown.", + "seed": 7436, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_12/index_5367_seed_7436_dp_25_rank_50_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.13907787445932626, + "vlm_logprob": -0.13907787445932626, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.25, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.13907787445932626, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a dead black ant with a visible black exoskeleton?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the ant gripping the edge of a vibrant green waxy leaf with its jaws and legs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a sinister pale orange fungal stalk erupt vertically from the ant's head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the fungal stalk covered in glistening globular dew that catches sharp directed light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera track slowly from left to right, passing over the ant's thorax and peaking at its head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5769741535186768 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8269741535186768 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5769741535186768, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5769741535186768, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09741783887147903, + 0.09442856162786484, + 0.09082625061273575, + 0.19802840054035187, + 0.061110012233257294, + 0.12951050698757172, + 0.0863356739282608, + 0.10428217053413391, + 0.07333788275718689, + 0.06472273170948029 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5769741535186768 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a dead black ant with a visible black exoskeleton?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the ant gripping the edge of a vibrant green waxy leaf with its jaws and legs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a sinister pale orange fungal stalk erupt vertically from the ant's head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the fungal stalk covered in glistening globular dew that catches sharp directed light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera track slowly from left to right, passing over the ant's thorax and peaking at its head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0206155888736248 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895615577697754 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0206155888736248, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0206155888736248, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11179393529891968, + 0.147682324051857, + 0.10539580881595612, + 0.15810894966125488, + 0.04927613586187363, + 0.13567638397216797, + 0.08399713039398193, + 0.10696082562208176, + 0.04769893363118172, + 0.05340956524014473 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0206155888736248 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a dead black ant with a visible black exoskeleton?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the ant gripping the edge of a vibrant green waxy leaf with its jaws and legs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a sinister pale orange fungal stalk erupt vertically from the ant's head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the fungal stalk covered in glistening globular dew that catches sharp directed light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera track slowly from left to right, passing over the ant's thorax and peaking at its head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004639100283384323 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379639148712158 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004639100283384323, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004639100283384323, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12716035544872284, + 0.15054620802402496, + 0.07988866418600082, + 0.09443962574005127, + 0.05819975212216377, + 0.07596585154533386, + 0.043302930891513824, + 0.12017610669136047, + 0.08216289430856705, + 0.1681576669216156 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004639100283384323 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a dead black ant with a visible black exoskeleton?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the ant gripping the edge of a vibrant green waxy leaf with its jaws and legs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a sinister pale orange fungal stalk erupt vertically from the ant's head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the fungal stalk covered in glistening globular dew that catches sharp directed light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera track slowly from left to right, passing over the ant's thorax and peaking at its head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014193889684975147 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264194011688232 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014193889684975147, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014193889684975147, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10272157192230225, + 0.09675700217485428, + 0.07572472840547562, + 0.09935448318719864, + 0.08440641313791275, + 0.07823275774717331, + 0.04948269575834274, + 0.20300251245498657, + 0.10227552801370621, + 0.10804234445095062 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014193889684975147 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a dead black ant with a visible black exoskeleton?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the ant gripping the edge of a vibrant green waxy leaf with its jaws and legs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a sinister pale orange fungal stalk erupt vertically from the ant's head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the fungal stalk covered in glistening globular dew that catches sharp directed light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera track slowly from left to right, passing over the ant's thorax and peaking at its head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0789666399359703 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5789666175842285 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0789666399359703, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0789666399359703, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.27017152309417725, + 0.15741696953773499, + 0.07634976506233215, + 0.05802732706069946, + 0.08021026104688644, + 0.05385547876358032, + 0.10912059992551804, + 0.07997970283031464, + 0.06313570588827133, + 0.05173268914222717 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0789666399359703 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "The high-contrast macro shot begins, the camera tracking uncomfortably slowly from left to right, maintaining a tight profile. The subject is a dead black ant, its black exoskeleton rendered with exquisite clarity. Its jaws make a final, desperate grip on the vibrant green edge of a waxy leaf, its stiff legs curled tightly around its dark, segmented body. As the camera continues its deliberate crawl, it passes over the ant's thorax and peaks at its head, from which a sinister fungal stalk erupts vertically. The eerie, pale orange plant is fibrous and strangely textured, its surface covered in a layer of glistening, globular morning dew that catches the sharp, directed light like tiny jewels. The intense, high-contrast lighting casts deep, dramatic shadows, sculpting every gruesome detail of the stem's texture and the ant's lifeless form, creating an eerie atmosphere that is both clinically beautiful and deeply unsettling against the backdrop, which dissolves into a soft, out-of-focus blur of dark green and earthy brown.", + "seed": 7437, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_12/index_5367_seed_7437_dp_25_rank_50_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.038445886597037314, + "vlm_logprob": -0.038445886597037314, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.85, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.038445886597037314, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a dead black ant with a visible black exoskeleton?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the ant gripping the edge of a vibrant green waxy leaf with its jaws and legs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a sinister pale orange fungal stalk erupt vertically from the ant's head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the fungal stalk covered in glistening globular dew that catches sharp directed light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera track slowly from left to right, passing over the ant's thorax and peaking at its head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11477401852607727 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.239773988723755 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11477401852607727, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11477401852607727, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03147529438138008, + 0.01523964200168848, + 0.031198253855109215, + 0.027994351461529732, + 0.007858481258153915, + 0.01710580475628376, + 0.5274661183357239, + 0.02066134847700596, + 0.30320584774017334, + 0.01779485121369362 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11477401852607727 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a dead black ant with a visible black exoskeleton?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the ant gripping the edge of a vibrant green waxy leaf with its jaws and legs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a sinister pale orange fungal stalk erupt vertically from the ant's head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the fungal stalk covered in glistening globular dew that catches sharp directed light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera track slowly from left to right, passing over the ant's thorax and peaking at its head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014225269667804241 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264225482940674 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014225269667804241, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014225269667804241, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.02936473675072193, + 0.012677476741373539, + 0.04874928668141365, + 0.012549263425171375, + 0.008153736591339111, + 0.012021963484585285, + 0.2758673429489136, + 0.03603605180978775, + 0.5332308411598206, + 0.03134924918413162 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014225269667804241 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a dead black ant with a visible black exoskeleton?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the ant gripping the edge of a vibrant green waxy leaf with its jaws and legs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a sinister pale orange fungal stalk erupt vertically from the ant's head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the fungal stalk covered in glistening globular dew that catches sharp directed light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera track slowly from left to right, passing over the ant's thorax and peaking at its head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005952014587819576 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130951881408691 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005952014587819576, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005952014587819576, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03695498779416084, + 0.018450306728482246, + 0.018156060948967934, + 0.03141164034605026, + 0.017703291028738022, + 0.024420643225312233, + 0.37734004855155945, + 0.07842491567134857, + 0.2962454855442047, + 0.10089264810085297 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005952014587819576 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a dead black ant with a visible black exoskeleton?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the ant gripping the edge of a vibrant green waxy leaf with its jaws and legs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a sinister pale orange fungal stalk erupt vertically from the ant's head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the fungal stalk covered in glistening globular dew that catches sharp directed light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera track slowly from left to right, passing over the ant's thorax and peaking at its head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008639931678771973 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758639812469482 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008639931678771973, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008639931678771973, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.008424883708357811, + 0.008551942184567451, + 0.003162998938933015, + 0.0057186949998140335, + 0.0035182852298021317, + 0.005526306573301554, + 0.9109371900558472, + 0.015408184379339218, + 0.010997788980603218, + 0.02775374799966812 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008639931678771973 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a dead black ant with a visible black exoskeleton?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the ant gripping the edge of a vibrant green waxy leaf with its jaws and legs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a sinister pale orange fungal stalk erupt vertically from the ant's head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the fungal stalk covered in glistening globular dew that catches sharp directed light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera track slowly from left to right, passing over the ant's thorax and peaking at its head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.048638198524713516 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048638105392456 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.048638198524713516, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.048638198524713516, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.010609540157020092, + 0.006297551095485687, + 0.007662096526473761, + 0.017317188903689384, + 0.010738641023635864, + 0.011222117580473423, + 0.7251102924346924, + 0.01874951273202896, + 0.1689426302909851, + 0.0233504269272089 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.048638198524713516 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_13/index_tensor([2917, 2917])_group_13_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_13/index_tensor([2917, 2917])_group_13_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..8d3ed8d618ba7e0b5b2283efab8172210de7fe32 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_13/index_tensor([2917, 2917])_group_13_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "The camera executes dynamic rotating shots, spiraling 360-degree barrel rolls, perfectly reflecting the exhilarating and carefree aerial acrobatics of a magnificent avian creature soaring through the cosmos. Its body is composed not of flesh but of shimmering, sun-filled crystal feathers; each feather is a perfectly faceted, translucent prism, capturing and refracting ambient light, spreading a kaleidoscope of color across its body while emitting a soft, inner golden glow. As it joyfully swoops and dives into a vast, vibrant cloud of swirling fuchsia, deep purple, and glowing cyan gas, it playfully chases its tail—a trailing ribbon of ethereal energy woven from sapphire blue and molten gold light particles, leaving a luminous wake. With effortless grace, it treats the floating crystal asteroids like toys, quickly nudging the smaller ones with its beak to send them tumbling away, and weaving in a tight, joyful circle around the larger metallic structure. The entire scene is a dreamlike symphony of light, with the clouds providing a soft, multi-hued glow that is amplified by the countless prismatic points of light shimmering in the creature’s own luminescent tail and crystalline feathers, creating an atmosphere of pure, unadulterated cosmic joy and infinite freedom.", + "seed": 14635, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_13/index_2917_seed_14635_dp_26_rank_52_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.1346575476229191, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1346575476229191, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.15, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1346575476229191, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an avian creature with shimmering, faceted crystal feathers instead of flesh?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the creature emit a soft inner golden glow and refract light into a kaleidoscope of colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the creature chasing a trailing ribbon of ethereal energy composed of sapphire blue and molten gold light particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the creature interact with floating crystal asteroids by nudging smaller ones with its beak and circling a larger metallic structure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute dynamic rotating shots including 360-degree barrel rolls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05539786443114281 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9303977489471436 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05539786443114281, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05539786443114281, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2569945454597473, + 0.05283980444073677, + 0.0546112060546875, + 0.0747690498828888, + 0.07465318590402603, + 0.05173270031809807, + 0.1691007912158966, + 0.14450128376483917, + 0.031625352799892426, + 0.08917209506034851 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05539786443114281 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an avian creature with shimmering, faceted crystal feathers instead of flesh?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the creature emit a soft inner golden glow and refract light into a kaleidoscope of colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the creature chasing a trailing ribbon of ethereal energy composed of sapphire blue and molten gold light particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the creature interact with floating crystal asteroids by nudging smaller ones with its beak and circling a larger metallic structure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute dynamic rotating shots including 360-degree barrel rolls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04308246821165085 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680824756622314 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04308246821165085, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04308246821165085, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22063925862312317, + 0.09667067974805832, + 0.07744201272726059, + 0.16715815663337708, + 0.08922560513019562, + 0.0400509312748909, + 0.04928202927112579, + 0.14477521181106567, + 0.05066046863794327, + 0.06409559398889542 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04308246821165085 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an avian creature with shimmering, faceted crystal feathers instead of flesh?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the creature emit a soft inner golden glow and refract light into a kaleidoscope of colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the creature chasing a trailing ribbon of ethereal energy composed of sapphire blue and molten gold light particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the creature interact with floating crystal asteroids by nudging smaller ones with its beak and circling a larger metallic structure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute dynamic rotating shots including 360-degree barrel rolls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.25211581587791443 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5021158456802368 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.25211581587791443, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.25211581587791443, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1387784332036972, + 0.096830815076828, + 0.16007111966609955, + 0.1585588902235031, + 0.1338498294353485, + 0.0489620640873909, + 0.08724594116210938, + 0.1057429239153862, + 0.042151112109422684, + 0.027808859944343567 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.25211581587791443 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an avian creature with shimmering, faceted crystal feathers instead of flesh?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the creature emit a soft inner golden glow and refract light into a kaleidoscope of colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the creature chasing a trailing ribbon of ethereal energy composed of sapphire blue and molten gold light particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the creature interact with floating crystal asteroids by nudging smaller ones with its beak and circling a larger metallic structure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute dynamic rotating shots including 360-degree barrel rolls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1799132525920868 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8049132823944092 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1799132525920868, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1799132525920868, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11667410284280777, + 0.08674851804971695, + 0.17161086201667786, + 0.0902881771326065, + 0.08555039018392563, + 0.04920734092593193, + 0.13033761084079742, + 0.17653603851795197, + 0.037223540246486664, + 0.055823419243097305 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 2, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1799132525920868 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an avian creature with shimmering, faceted crystal feathers instead of flesh?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the creature emit a soft inner golden glow and refract light into a kaleidoscope of colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the creature chasing a trailing ribbon of ethereal energy composed of sapphire blue and molten gold light particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the creature interact with floating crystal asteroids by nudging smaller ones with its beak and circling a larger metallic structure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute dynamic rotating shots including 360-degree barrel rolls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14277833700180054 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0177783966064453 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14277833700180054, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14277833700180054, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24395033717155457, + 0.09799809753894806, + 0.12099873274564743, + 0.059838369488716125, + 0.11113647371530533, + 0.04970960691571236, + 0.13090850412845612, + 0.06933796405792236, + 0.05300895869731903, + 0.06311295926570892 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14277833700180054 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "The camera executes dynamic rotating shots, spiraling 360-degree barrel rolls, perfectly reflecting the exhilarating and carefree aerial acrobatics of a magnificent avian creature soaring through the cosmos. Its body is composed not of flesh but of shimmering, sun-filled crystal feathers; each feather is a perfectly faceted, translucent prism, capturing and refracting ambient light, spreading a kaleidoscope of color across its body while emitting a soft, inner golden glow. As it joyfully swoops and dives into a vast, vibrant cloud of swirling fuchsia, deep purple, and glowing cyan gas, it playfully chases its tail—a trailing ribbon of ethereal energy woven from sapphire blue and molten gold light particles, leaving a luminous wake. With effortless grace, it treats the floating crystal asteroids like toys, quickly nudging the smaller ones with its beak to send them tumbling away, and weaving in a tight, joyful circle around the larger metallic structure. The entire scene is a dreamlike symphony of light, with the clouds providing a soft, multi-hued glow that is amplified by the countless prismatic points of light shimmering in the creature’s own luminescent tail and crystalline feathers, creating an atmosphere of pure, unadulterated cosmic joy and infinite freedom.", + "seed": 14636, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_13/index_2917_seed_14636_dp_26_rank_52_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.06417709421366453, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06417709421366453, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.05, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06417709421366453, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an avian creature with shimmering, faceted crystal feathers instead of flesh?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the creature emit a soft inner golden glow and refract light into a kaleidoscope of colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the creature chasing a trailing ribbon of ethereal energy composed of sapphire blue and molten gold light particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the creature interact with floating crystal asteroids by nudging smaller ones with its beak and circling a larger metallic structure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute dynamic rotating shots including 360-degree barrel rolls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03413057327270508 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.409130573272705 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03413057327270508, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03413057327270508, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10671931505203247, + 0.06312943249940872, + 0.08589638769626617, + 0.16736821830272675, + 0.08072606474161148, + 0.06094255670905113, + 0.06487583369016647, + 0.08680060505867004, + 0.20928122103214264, + 0.07426033914089203 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03413057327270508 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an avian creature with shimmering, faceted crystal feathers instead of flesh?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the creature emit a soft inner golden glow and refract light into a kaleidoscope of colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the creature chasing a trailing ribbon of ethereal energy composed of sapphire blue and molten gold light particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the creature interact with floating crystal asteroids by nudging smaller ones with its beak and circling a larger metallic structure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute dynamic rotating shots including 360-degree barrel rolls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008653285913169384 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758653163909912 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008653285913169384, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008653285913169384, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.132559671998024, + 0.09173400700092316, + 0.1666284203529358, + 0.06248176842927933, + 0.04639805480837822, + 0.04717428982257843, + 0.06179895997047424, + 0.0851883813738823, + 0.20351780951023102, + 0.10251861810684204 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008653285913169384 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an avian creature with shimmering, faceted crystal feathers instead of flesh?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the creature emit a soft inner golden glow and refract light into a kaleidoscope of colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the creature chasing a trailing ribbon of ethereal energy composed of sapphire blue and molten gold light particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the creature interact with floating crystal asteroids by nudging smaller ones with its beak and circling a larger metallic structure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute dynamic rotating shots including 360-degree barrel rolls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08904415369033813 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4640440940856934 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08904415369033813, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08904415369033813, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06240072846412659, + 0.08301045000553131, + 0.07102026790380478, + 0.02855164371430874, + 0.047498468309640884, + 0.028971243649721146, + 0.035540200769901276, + 0.03191834315657616, + 0.5597286820411682, + 0.05136001110076904 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08904415369033813 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an avian creature with shimmering, faceted crystal feathers instead of flesh?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the creature emit a soft inner golden glow and refract light into a kaleidoscope of colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the creature chasing a trailing ribbon of ethereal energy composed of sapphire blue and molten gold light particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the creature interact with floating crystal asteroids by nudging smaller ones with its beak and circling a larger metallic structure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute dynamic rotating shots including 360-degree barrel rolls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06205097213387489 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120510578155518 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06205097213387489, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06205097213387489, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09485675394535065, + 0.049250561743974686, + 0.23932258784770966, + 0.07729817926883698, + 0.06643062829971313, + 0.07746998965740204, + 0.05189969018101692, + 0.06634826958179474, + 0.18610580265522003, + 0.09101755172014236 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06205097213387489 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an avian creature with shimmering, faceted crystal feathers instead of flesh?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the creature emit a soft inner golden glow and refract light into a kaleidoscope of colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the creature chasing a trailing ribbon of ethereal energy composed of sapphire blue and molten gold light particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the creature interact with floating crystal asteroids by nudging smaller ones with its beak and circling a larger metallic structure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute dynamic rotating shots including 360-degree barrel rolls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12700648605823517 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1270065307617188 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12700648605823517, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12700648605823517, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11771203577518463, + 0.04697973281145096, + 0.1959284245967865, + 0.13413122296333313, + 0.05745748430490494, + 0.11590415984392166, + 0.04540785402059555, + 0.11536676436662674, + 0.09842565655708313, + 0.07268670201301575 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12700648605823517 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "The camera executes dynamic rotating shots, spiraling 360-degree barrel rolls, perfectly reflecting the exhilarating and carefree aerial acrobatics of a magnificent avian creature soaring through the cosmos. Its body is composed not of flesh but of shimmering, sun-filled crystal feathers; each feather is a perfectly faceted, translucent prism, capturing and refracting ambient light, spreading a kaleidoscope of color across its body while emitting a soft, inner golden glow. As it joyfully swoops and dives into a vast, vibrant cloud of swirling fuchsia, deep purple, and glowing cyan gas, it playfully chases its tail—a trailing ribbon of ethereal energy woven from sapphire blue and molten gold light particles, leaving a luminous wake. With effortless grace, it treats the floating crystal asteroids like toys, quickly nudging the smaller ones with its beak to send them tumbling away, and weaving in a tight, joyful circle around the larger metallic structure. The entire scene is a dreamlike symphony of light, with the clouds providing a soft, multi-hued glow that is amplified by the countless prismatic points of light shimmering in the creature’s own luminescent tail and crystalline feathers, creating an atmosphere of pure, unadulterated cosmic joy and infinite freedom.", + "seed": 14637, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_13/index_2917_seed_14637_dp_27_rank_54_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.049730385467410085, + "vlm_logprob": -0.049730385467410085, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.25, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.049730385467410085, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an avian creature with shimmering, faceted crystal feathers instead of flesh?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the creature emit a soft inner golden glow and refract light into a kaleidoscope of colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the creature chasing a trailing ribbon of ethereal energy composed of sapphire blue and molten gold light particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the creature interact with floating crystal asteroids by nudging smaller ones with its beak and circling a larger metallic structure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute dynamic rotating shots including 360-degree barrel rolls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01856803148984909 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.01856803894043 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01856803148984909, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01856803148984909, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20090427994728088, + 0.04127700999379158, + 0.13988594710826874, + 0.05270060896873474, + 0.09032085537910461, + 0.1547790765762329, + 0.044716302305459976, + 0.08771929889917374, + 0.10947016626596451, + 0.07822650671005249 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01856803148984909 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an avian creature with shimmering, faceted crystal feathers instead of flesh?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the creature emit a soft inner golden glow and refract light into a kaleidoscope of colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the creature chasing a trailing ribbon of ethereal energy composed of sapphire blue and molten gold light particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the creature interact with floating crystal asteroids by nudging smaller ones with its beak and circling a larger metallic structure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute dynamic rotating shots including 360-degree barrel rolls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011083347722887993 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511083126068115 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011083347722887993, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011083347722887993, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2211773693561554, + 0.055049505084753036, + 0.0661151260137558, + 0.05403326824307442, + 0.12833073735237122, + 0.11333877593278885, + 0.16286709904670715, + 0.07731355726718903, + 0.05763158202171326, + 0.06414299458265305 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011083347722887993 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an avian creature with shimmering, faceted crystal feathers instead of flesh?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the creature emit a soft inner golden glow and refract light into a kaleidoscope of colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the creature chasing a trailing ribbon of ethereal energy composed of sapphire blue and molten gold light particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the creature interact with floating crystal asteroids by nudging smaller ones with its beak and circling a larger metallic structure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute dynamic rotating shots including 360-degree barrel rolls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07898569852113724 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5789856910705566 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07898569852113724, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07898569852113724, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1633736491203308, + 0.04573209211230278, + 0.08330459147691727, + 0.04405704513192177, + 0.06737467646598816, + 0.03532934561371803, + 0.15625129640102386, + 0.17989349365234375, + 0.04248005524277687, + 0.18220371007919312 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07898569852113724 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an avian creature with shimmering, faceted crystal feathers instead of flesh?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the creature emit a soft inner golden glow and refract light into a kaleidoscope of colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the creature chasing a trailing ribbon of ethereal energy composed of sapphire blue and molten gold light particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the creature interact with floating crystal asteroids by nudging smaller ones with its beak and circling a larger metallic structure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute dynamic rotating shots including 360-degree barrel rolls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07001948356628418 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695019483566284 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07001948356628418, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07001948356628418, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1354445517063141, + 0.04038364067673683, + 0.05609003081917763, + 0.05194232985377312, + 0.2663324177265167, + 0.0705045685172081, + 0.11016600579023361, + 0.04689579829573631, + 0.07882960885763168, + 0.14341101050376892 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07001948356628418 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an avian creature with shimmering, faceted crystal feathers instead of flesh?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the creature emit a soft inner golden glow and refract light into a kaleidoscope of colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the creature chasing a trailing ribbon of ethereal energy composed of sapphire blue and molten gold light particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the creature interact with floating crystal asteroids by nudging smaller ones with its beak and circling a larger metallic structure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute dynamic rotating shots including 360-degree barrel rolls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06999536603689194 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.694995403289795 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06999536603689194, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06999536603689194, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10677403956651688, + 0.058941442519426346, + 0.055205173790454865, + 0.06711767613887787, + 0.09219351410865784, + 0.11179250478744507, + 0.16474324464797974, + 0.15879510343074799, + 0.04489036649465561, + 0.1395469456911087 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06999536603689194 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "The camera executes dynamic rotating shots, spiraling 360-degree barrel rolls, perfectly reflecting the exhilarating and carefree aerial acrobatics of a magnificent avian creature soaring through the cosmos. Its body is composed not of flesh but of shimmering, sun-filled crystal feathers; each feather is a perfectly faceted, translucent prism, capturing and refracting ambient light, spreading a kaleidoscope of color across its body while emitting a soft, inner golden glow. As it joyfully swoops and dives into a vast, vibrant cloud of swirling fuchsia, deep purple, and glowing cyan gas, it playfully chases its tail—a trailing ribbon of ethereal energy woven from sapphire blue and molten gold light particles, leaving a luminous wake. With effortless grace, it treats the floating crystal asteroids like toys, quickly nudging the smaller ones with its beak to send them tumbling away, and weaving in a tight, joyful circle around the larger metallic structure. The entire scene is a dreamlike symphony of light, with the clouds providing a soft, multi-hued glow that is amplified by the countless prismatic points of light shimmering in the creature’s own luminescent tail and crystalline feathers, creating an atmosphere of pure, unadulterated cosmic joy and infinite freedom.", + "seed": 14638, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_13/index_2917_seed_14638_dp_27_rank_54_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.09561106376349926, + "vlm_logprob": -0.09561106376349926, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.625, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.09561106376349926, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an avian creature with shimmering, faceted crystal feathers instead of flesh?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the creature emit a soft inner golden glow and refract light into a kaleidoscope of colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the creature chasing a trailing ribbon of ethereal energy composed of sapphire blue and molten gold light particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the creature interact with floating crystal asteroids by nudging smaller ones with its beak and circling a larger metallic structure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute dynamic rotating shots including 360-degree barrel rolls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04903781786561012 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0490379333496094 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04903781786561012, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04903781786561012, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05677475780248642, + 0.13562920689582825, + 0.08197293430566788, + 0.025319119915366173, + 0.05558951571583748, + 0.08146627247333527, + 0.046516481786966324, + 0.06613031774759293, + 0.3505201041698456, + 0.10008130222558975 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04903781786561012 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an avian creature with shimmering, faceted crystal feathers instead of flesh?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the creature emit a soft inner golden glow and refract light into a kaleidoscope of colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the creature chasing a trailing ribbon of ethereal energy composed of sapphire blue and molten gold light particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the creature interact with floating crystal asteroids by nudging smaller ones with its beak and circling a larger metallic structure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute dynamic rotating shots including 360-degree barrel rolls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02059854008257389 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955986499786377 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02059854008257389, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02059854008257389, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08925656974315643, + 0.1670628786087036, + 0.07596619427204132, + 0.051288802176713943, + 0.04663023725152016, + 0.04397048056125641, + 0.04339345544576645, + 0.04558398574590683, + 0.28427961468696594, + 0.1525678187608719 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02059854008257389 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an avian creature with shimmering, faceted crystal feathers instead of flesh?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the creature emit a soft inner golden glow and refract light into a kaleidoscope of colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the creature chasing a trailing ribbon of ethereal energy composed of sapphire blue and molten gold light particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the creature interact with floating crystal asteroids by nudging smaller ones with its beak and circling a larger metallic structure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute dynamic rotating shots including 360-degree barrel rolls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17990608513355255 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8049061298370361 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17990608513355255, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17990608513355255, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09085448086261749, + 0.08668513596057892, + 0.03475698083639145, + 0.04577208310365677, + 0.07208701223134995, + 0.024746473878622055, + 0.056025728583335876, + 0.06520097702741623, + 0.3633691668510437, + 0.1605018973350525 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17990608513355255 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an avian creature with shimmering, faceted crystal feathers instead of flesh?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the creature emit a soft inner golden glow and refract light into a kaleidoscope of colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the creature chasing a trailing ribbon of ethereal energy composed of sapphire blue and molten gold light particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the creature interact with floating crystal asteroids by nudging smaller ones with its beak and circling a larger metallic structure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute dynamic rotating shots including 360-degree barrel rolls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04865727573633194 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048657178878784 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04865727573633194, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04865727573633194, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06271077692508698, + 0.12243691831827164, + 0.04086184501647949, + 0.03296254947781563, + 0.09974478930234909, + 0.06624635308980942, + 0.11872158199548721, + 0.09568116813898087, + 0.2589769661426544, + 0.10165707021951675 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04865727573633194 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an avian creature with shimmering, faceted crystal feathers instead of flesh?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the creature emit a soft inner golden glow and refract light into a kaleidoscope of colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the creature chasing a trailing ribbon of ethereal energy composed of sapphire blue and molten gold light particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the creature interact with floating crystal asteroids by nudging smaller ones with its beak and circling a larger metallic structure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute dynamic rotating shots including 360-degree barrel rolls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1798555999994278 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8048555850982666 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1798555999994278, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1798555999994278, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05728623643517494, + 0.13987617194652557, + 0.04921944439411163, + 0.07057222723960876, + 0.10213705897331238, + 0.07620946317911148, + 0.07141043245792389, + 0.1670188009738922, + 0.1128913089632988, + 0.15337885916233063 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1798555999994278 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_14/index_tensor([7439, 7439])_group_14_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_14/index_tensor([7439, 7439])_group_14_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..ec4dceb2f72e8dcd2b2579ccb8e9f49f0c2a7df2 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_14/index_tensor([7439, 7439])_group_14_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "medium close-up shot, shot from a level angle, slowly pans forward, focusing on an elderly man with a face deeply wrinkled and furrowed. He wears a thick, dark brown wool cardigan over an off-white cotton shirt with a slightly yellowed collar. His wispy silver hair gleams softly in the warm light. He sits in an old wooden armchair, a rough stone fireplace behind him. The crackling, orange-red flames in the hearth provide the scene's sole source of light. The flickering flames cast soft, dynamic shadows across his deep wrinkles, accentuating the depths of his dark brown eyes, which shimmer with wisdom and opacity. He leans forward slightly, one hand, covered in age spots, moving slowly and expressively in the air. His lips move slightly as he speaks, leisurely unwinding a forgotten story to an audience whose outlines are blurred and out of focus. The entire picture is shrouded in warm amber light, with the main colors being dark brown and warm orange, creating an intimate atmosphere of extreme tranquility, nostalgia, and wisdom, as if time has frozen at this moment for an ancient story.", + "seed": 2579, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_14/index_7439_seed_2579_dp_28_rank_56_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.06818184005096554, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06818184005096554, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.65, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06818184005096554, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up of an elderly man with deeply wrinkled and furrowed skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a thick dark brown wool cardigan over an off-white cotton shirt with a slightly yellowed collar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man sitting in an old wooden armchair with a rough stone fireplace behind him?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature crackling orange-red flames in a hearth that serve as the sole light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan forward while the man leans forward and moves one hand expressively in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004766411613672972 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.879766464233398 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004766411613672972, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004766411613672972, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18224897980690002, + 0.33551454544067383, + 0.09433155506849289, + 0.049671441316604614, + 0.0487319752573967, + 0.05000988766551018, + 0.06281200796365738, + 0.040263354778289795, + 0.022680766880512238, + 0.11373543739318848 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004766411613672972 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up of an elderly man with deeply wrinkled and furrowed skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a thick dark brown wool cardigan over an off-white cotton shirt with a slightly yellowed collar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man sitting in an old wooden armchair with a rough stone fireplace behind him?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature crackling orange-red flames in a hearth that serve as the sole light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan forward while the man leans forward and moves one hand expressively in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029846686869859695 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529846668243408 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029846686869859695, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029846686869859695, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25302591919898987, + 0.3093855679035187, + 0.06698517501354218, + 0.04921060428023338, + 0.08452009409666061, + 0.046495068818330765, + 0.06171829253435135, + 0.04838981479406357, + 0.024306101724505424, + 0.05596340820193291 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029846686869859695 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up of an elderly man with deeply wrinkled and furrowed skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a thick dark brown wool cardigan over an off-white cotton shirt with a slightly yellowed collar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man sitting in an old wooden armchair with a rough stone fireplace behind him?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature crackling orange-red flames in a hearth that serve as the sole light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan forward while the man leans forward and moves one hand expressively in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04313088208436966 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168130874633789 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04313088208436966, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04313088208436966, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17883086204528809, + 0.1029222160577774, + 0.08004190027713776, + 0.04934396967291832, + 0.08524057269096375, + 0.05130905658006668, + 0.2966236174106598, + 0.065902940928936, + 0.029240088537335396, + 0.06054479628801346 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04313088208436966 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up of an elderly man with deeply wrinkled and furrowed skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a thick dark brown wool cardigan over an off-white cotton shirt with a slightly yellowed collar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man sitting in an old wooden armchair with a rough stone fireplace behind him?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature crackling orange-red flames in a hearth that serve as the sole light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan forward while the man leans forward and moves one hand expressively in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011077924631536007 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511077880859375 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011077924631536007, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011077924631536007, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23378796875476837, + 0.17934446036815643, + 0.10704968124628067, + 0.03621372580528259, + 0.07899999618530273, + 0.0451502725481987, + 0.11988730728626251, + 0.04505838081240654, + 0.045307330787181854, + 0.1092008724808693 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011077924631536007 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up of an elderly man with deeply wrinkled and furrowed skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a thick dark brown wool cardigan over an off-white cotton shirt with a slightly yellowed collar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man sitting in an old wooden armchair with a rough stone fireplace behind him?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature crackling orange-red flames in a hearth that serve as the sole light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan forward while the man leans forward and moves one hand expressively in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2520872950553894 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5020873546600342 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2520872950553894, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2520872950553894, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.29706230759620667, + 0.13278859853744507, + 0.08180814236402512, + 0.054623041301965714, + 0.0828811377286911, + 0.05476246774196625, + 0.0775664672255516, + 0.08858973532915115, + 0.07713481038808823, + 0.052783332765102386 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2520872950553894 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "medium close-up shot, shot from a level angle, slowly pans forward, focusing on an elderly man with a face deeply wrinkled and furrowed. He wears a thick, dark brown wool cardigan over an off-white cotton shirt with a slightly yellowed collar. His wispy silver hair gleams softly in the warm light. He sits in an old wooden armchair, a rough stone fireplace behind him. The crackling, orange-red flames in the hearth provide the scene's sole source of light. The flickering flames cast soft, dynamic shadows across his deep wrinkles, accentuating the depths of his dark brown eyes, which shimmer with wisdom and opacity. He leans forward slightly, one hand, covered in age spots, moving slowly and expressively in the air. His lips move slightly as he speaks, leisurely unwinding a forgotten story to an audience whose outlines are blurred and out of focus. The entire picture is shrouded in warm amber light, with the main colors being dark brown and warm orange, creating an intimate atmosphere of extreme tranquility, nostalgia, and wisdom, as if time has frozen at this moment for an ancient story.", + "seed": 2580, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_14/index_7439_seed_2580_dp_28_rank_56_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.0428048781119287, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0428048781119287, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.2, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0428048781119287, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up of an elderly man with deeply wrinkled and furrowed skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a thick dark brown wool cardigan over an off-white cotton shirt with a slightly yellowed collar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man sitting in an old wooden armchair with a rough stone fireplace behind him?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature crackling orange-red flames in a hearth that serve as the sole light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan forward while the man leans forward and moves one hand expressively in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004531946964561939 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.6295318603515625 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004531946964561939, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004531946964561939, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14389006793498993, + 0.09140770882368088, + 0.08477427810430527, + 0.07302384078502655, + 0.07696735858917236, + 0.039698515087366104, + 0.1107957735657692, + 0.08589546382427216, + 0.1550195813179016, + 0.13852743804454803 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004531946964561939 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up of an elderly man with deeply wrinkled and furrowed skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a thick dark brown wool cardigan over an off-white cotton shirt with a slightly yellowed collar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man sitting in an old wooden armchair with a rough stone fireplace behind him?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature crackling orange-red flames in a hearth that serve as the sole light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan forward while the man leans forward and moves one hand expressively in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018212705850601196 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018212795257568 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018212705850601196, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018212705850601196, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06751611083745956, + 0.048490118235349655, + 0.04883923754096031, + 0.06727363169193268, + 0.06137017160654068, + 0.05523507669568062, + 0.04273352771997452, + 0.09883499145507812, + 0.39461132884025574, + 0.11509570479393005 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018212705850601196 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up of an elderly man with deeply wrinkled and furrowed skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a thick dark brown wool cardigan over an off-white cotton shirt with a slightly yellowed collar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man sitting in an old wooden armchair with a rough stone fireplace behind him?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature crackling orange-red flames in a hearth that serve as the sole light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan forward while the man leans forward and moves one hand expressively in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023298904299736023 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773298978805542 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023298904299736023, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023298904299736023, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12683667242527008, + 0.09004999697208405, + 0.1657506376504898, + 0.0568334199488163, + 0.06802208721637726, + 0.09651954472064972, + 0.02873414196074009, + 0.05796660855412483, + 0.10643766820430756, + 0.20284928381443024 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023298904299736023 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up of an elderly man with deeply wrinkled and furrowed skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a thick dark brown wool cardigan over an off-white cotton shirt with a slightly yellowed collar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man sitting in an old wooden armchair with a rough stone fireplace behind him?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature crackling orange-red flames in a hearth that serve as the sole light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan forward while the man leans forward and moves one hand expressively in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007631315384060144 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882631301879883 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007631315384060144, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007631315384060144, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14351274073123932, + 0.09291791170835495, + 0.15794609487056732, + 0.09680698812007904, + 0.06588542461395264, + 0.1503923088312149, + 0.030651547014713287, + 0.04615195468068123, + 0.10770472884178162, + 0.1080302745103836 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007631315384060144 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up of an elderly man with deeply wrinkled and furrowed skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a thick dark brown wool cardigan over an off-white cotton shirt with a slightly yellowed collar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man sitting in an old wooden armchair with a rough stone fireplace behind him?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature crackling orange-red flames in a hearth that serve as the sole light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan forward while the man leans forward and moves one hand expressively in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1603495180606842 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9103494882583618 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1603495180606842, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1603495180606842, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05764802172780037, + 0.050556495785713196, + 0.040520552545785904, + 0.03311183303594589, + 0.03503020107746124, + 0.07005153596401215, + 0.07481062412261963, + 0.06921549886465073, + 0.08725332468748093, + 0.48180192708969116 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1603495180606842 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "medium close-up shot, shot from a level angle, slowly pans forward, focusing on an elderly man with a face deeply wrinkled and furrowed. He wears a thick, dark brown wool cardigan over an off-white cotton shirt with a slightly yellowed collar. His wispy silver hair gleams softly in the warm light. He sits in an old wooden armchair, a rough stone fireplace behind him. The crackling, orange-red flames in the hearth provide the scene's sole source of light. The flickering flames cast soft, dynamic shadows across his deep wrinkles, accentuating the depths of his dark brown eyes, which shimmer with wisdom and opacity. He leans forward slightly, one hand, covered in age spots, moving slowly and expressively in the air. His lips move slightly as he speaks, leisurely unwinding a forgotten story to an audience whose outlines are blurred and out of focus. The entire picture is shrouded in warm amber light, with the main colors being dark brown and warm orange, creating an intimate atmosphere of extreme tranquility, nostalgia, and wisdom, as if time has frozen at this moment for an ancient story.", + "seed": 2581, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_14/index_7439_seed_2581_dp_29_rank_58_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.09376133712939919, + "vlm_logprob": -0.09376133712939919, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.625, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.09376133712939919, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up of an elderly man with deeply wrinkled and furrowed skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a thick dark brown wool cardigan over an off-white cotton shirt with a slightly yellowed collar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man sitting in an old wooden armchair with a rough stone fireplace behind him?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature crackling orange-red flames in a hearth that serve as the sole light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan forward while the man leans forward and moves one hand expressively in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00343186198733747 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.378431797027588 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00343186198733747, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00343186198733747, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2621351480484009, + 0.15332072973251343, + 0.079794742166996, + 0.03824087232351303, + 0.053448036313056946, + 0.06234828010201454, + 0.12244413793087006, + 0.054779812693595886, + 0.07829176634550095, + 0.09519648551940918 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00343186198733747 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up of an elderly man with deeply wrinkled and furrowed skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a thick dark brown wool cardigan over an off-white cotton shirt with a slightly yellowed collar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man sitting in an old wooden armchair with a rough stone fireplace behind him?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature crackling orange-red flames in a hearth that serve as the sole light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan forward while the man leans forward and moves one hand expressively in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026384858414530754 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513848304748535 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026384858414530754, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026384858414530754, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2874533534049988, + 0.18038728833198547, + 0.061338871717453, + 0.0499260276556015, + 0.039370059967041016, + 0.025188490748405457, + 0.18680329620838165, + 0.056313082575798035, + 0.04847363755106926, + 0.06474584341049194 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026384858414530754 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up of an elderly man with deeply wrinkled and furrowed skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a thick dark brown wool cardigan over an off-white cotton shirt with a slightly yellowed collar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man sitting in an old wooden armchair with a rough stone fireplace behind him?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature crackling orange-red flames in a hearth that serve as the sole light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan forward while the man leans forward and moves one hand expressively in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01821223832666874 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.01821231842041 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01821223832666874, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01821223832666874, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2931469678878784, + 0.23437629640102386, + 0.12470393627882004, + 0.050722118467092514, + 0.04672297462821007, + 0.03041197918355465, + 0.10995443165302277, + 0.03553466498851776, + 0.03002762794494629, + 0.04439900070428848 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01821223832666874 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up of an elderly man with deeply wrinkled and furrowed skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a thick dark brown wool cardigan over an off-white cotton shirt with a slightly yellowed collar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man sitting in an old wooden armchair with a rough stone fireplace behind him?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature crackling orange-red flames in a hearth that serve as the sole light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan forward while the man leans forward and moves one hand expressively in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03371112421154976 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4087111949920654 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03371112421154976, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03371112421154976, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25454002618789673, + 0.14535506069660187, + 0.05462720990180969, + 0.01804354228079319, + 0.0329660102725029, + 0.03333818167448044, + 0.10653521120548248, + 0.18824611604213715, + 0.07382677495479584, + 0.09252182394266129 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03371112421154976 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up of an elderly man with deeply wrinkled and furrowed skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a thick dark brown wool cardigan over an off-white cotton shirt with a slightly yellowed collar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man sitting in an old wooden armchair with a rough stone fireplace behind him?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature crackling orange-red flames in a hearth that serve as the sole light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan forward while the man leans forward and moves one hand expressively in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3870666027069092 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1370666027069092 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3870666027069092, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3870666027069092, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1203131303191185, + 0.22381892800331116, + 0.07152613997459412, + 0.05209020525217056, + 0.045461032539606094, + 0.043866951018571854, + 0.2803400754928589, + 0.039057083427906036, + 0.07398168742656708, + 0.0495447963476181 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3870666027069092 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "medium close-up shot, shot from a level angle, slowly pans forward, focusing on an elderly man with a face deeply wrinkled and furrowed. He wears a thick, dark brown wool cardigan over an off-white cotton shirt with a slightly yellowed collar. His wispy silver hair gleams softly in the warm light. He sits in an old wooden armchair, a rough stone fireplace behind him. The crackling, orange-red flames in the hearth provide the scene's sole source of light. The flickering flames cast soft, dynamic shadows across his deep wrinkles, accentuating the depths of his dark brown eyes, which shimmer with wisdom and opacity. He leans forward slightly, one hand, covered in age spots, moving slowly and expressively in the air. His lips move slightly as he speaks, leisurely unwinding a forgotten story to an audience whose outlines are blurred and out of focus. The entire picture is shrouded in warm amber light, with the main colors being dark brown and warm orange, creating an intimate atmosphere of extreme tranquility, nostalgia, and wisdom, as if time has frozen at this moment for an ancient story.", + "seed": 2582, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_14/index_7439_seed_2582_dp_29_rank_58_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.04610933111980557, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04610933111980557, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.85, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04610933111980557, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up of an elderly man with deeply wrinkled and furrowed skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a thick dark brown wool cardigan over an off-white cotton shirt with a slightly yellowed collar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man sitting in an old wooden armchair with a rough stone fireplace behind him?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature crackling orange-red flames in a hearth that serve as the sole light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan forward while the man leans forward and moves one hand expressively in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005686535034328699 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.0056867599487305 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005686535034328699, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005686535034328699, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18702396750450134, + 0.0899200439453125, + 0.0698007345199585, + 0.0499134324491024, + 0.049733538180589676, + 0.07895538955926895, + 0.10317704826593399, + 0.1042359247803688, + 0.11653861403465271, + 0.15070131421089172 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005686535034328699 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up of an elderly man with deeply wrinkled and furrowed skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a thick dark brown wool cardigan over an off-white cotton shirt with a slightly yellowed collar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man sitting in an old wooden armchair with a rough stone fireplace behind him?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature crackling orange-red flames in a hearth that serve as the sole light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan forward while the man leans forward and moves one hand expressively in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020610801875591278 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895610809326172 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020610801875591278, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020610801875591278, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17536070942878723, + 0.0811743289232254, + 0.07365189492702484, + 0.035345569252967834, + 0.04452069476246834, + 0.03977274149656296, + 0.05020277574658394, + 0.2908029556274414, + 0.03683970123529434, + 0.1723286360502243 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020610801875591278 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up of an elderly man with deeply wrinkled and furrowed skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a thick dark brown wool cardigan over an off-white cotton shirt with a slightly yellowed collar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man sitting in an old wooden armchair with a rough stone fireplace behind him?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature crackling orange-red flames in a hearth that serve as the sole light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan forward while the man leans forward and moves one hand expressively in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02330426312983036 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7733042240142822 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02330426312983036, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02330426312983036, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.271725058555603, + 0.15057875216007233, + 0.03810427710413933, + 0.03707239404320717, + 0.21059563755989075, + 0.07609306275844574, + 0.04699420556426048, + 0.07461536675691605, + 0.0480017326772213, + 0.046219442039728165 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02330426312983036 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up of an elderly man with deeply wrinkled and furrowed skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a thick dark brown wool cardigan over an off-white cotton shirt with a slightly yellowed collar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man sitting in an old wooden armchair with a rough stone fireplace behind him?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature crackling orange-red flames in a hearth that serve as the sole light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan forward while the man leans forward and moves one hand expressively in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020589547231793404 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895589590072632 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020589547231793404, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020589547231793404, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.29946061968803406, + 0.17766110599040985, + 0.1232505738735199, + 0.0404120609164238, + 0.0944039449095726, + 0.031101925298571587, + 0.03927699476480484, + 0.048374876379966736, + 0.04484257474541664, + 0.10121532529592514 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020589547231793404 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up of an elderly man with deeply wrinkled and furrowed skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a thick dark brown wool cardigan over an off-white cotton shirt with a slightly yellowed collar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man sitting in an old wooden armchair with a rough stone fireplace behind him?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature crackling orange-red flames in a hearth that serve as the sole light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan forward while the man leans forward and moves one hand expressively in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16035550832748413 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.910355567932129 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16035550832748413, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16035550832748413, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10998634248971939, + 0.03753640130162239, + 0.03435918688774109, + 0.047392651438713074, + 0.038118116557598114, + 0.0939222052693367, + 0.05716565623879433, + 0.10788141936063766, + 0.13560689985752106, + 0.3380310535430908 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16035550832748413 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_15/index_tensor([1478, 1478])_group_15_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_15/index_tensor([1478, 1478])_group_15_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..5fb16c8de80791eec0ec7491c3a08f0c211d14df --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_15/index_tensor([1478, 1478])_group_15_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "dynamic, low-angle shot moves swiftly, following a sleek, multi-car light rail train as it teeters on elevated tracks, rendered in a vibrant, animated style. At night, the train negotiates a perilous, sharp turn above a busy, futuristic city street. The entire scene is bathed in a predominantly cool blue, creating a moody, nocturnal atmosphere. The train's polished silver metal surface acts like a distorting mirror, capturing and distorting the chaotic light emanating from the metropolis below. On the street, the light from car headlights and taillights blurs into streaks of white and red, while massive skyscrapers are adorned with vibrant neon signs in vibrant pink, electric yellow, and deep purple. These brilliant, varied colors cast long, shimmering reflections that slide and twist across the train's swaying body, emphasizing its precarious motion. The train itself tilts at an extreme angle, its individual cars jostling against each other as it strains against the curve, creating a palpable sense of high-speed tension and exhilarating danger.", + "seed": 28853, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_15/index_1478_seed_28853_dp_30_rank_60_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.06299731453182175, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06299731453182175, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.6, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06299731453182175, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, multi-car light rail train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the train traveling on elevated tracks above a busy, futuristic city street?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at night with a predominantly cool blue color palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the train tilt at an extreme angle while navigating a sharp turn?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot dynamic and moving swiftly to follow the train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018017785623669624 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.143017768859863 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018017785623669624, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018017785623669624, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15704084932804108, + 0.04239380359649658, + 0.10000656545162201, + 0.028450915589928627, + 0.25735288858413696, + 0.027385814115405083, + 0.11175743490457535, + 0.10268975794315338, + 0.05052848905324936, + 0.12239351868629456 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018017785623669624 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, multi-car light rail train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the train traveling on elevated tracks above a busy, futuristic city street?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at night with a predominantly cool blue color palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the train tilt at an extreme angle while navigating a sharp turn?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot dynamic and moving swiftly to follow the train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012558426707983017 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387558460235596 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012558426707983017, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012558426707983017, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0654173269867897, + 0.08198533952236176, + 0.0716671347618103, + 0.08118876814842224, + 0.2756344676017761, + 0.044647712260484695, + 0.0654301568865776, + 0.13957278430461884, + 0.029795726761221886, + 0.1446605771780014 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012558426707983017 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, multi-car light rail train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the train traveling on elevated tracks above a busy, futuristic city street?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at night with a predominantly cool blue color palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the train tilt at an extreme angle while navigating a sharp turn?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot dynamic and moving swiftly to follow the train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0006370898918248713 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.375637054443359 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0006370898918248713, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0006370898918248713, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08059495687484741, + 0.04864055663347244, + 0.04681731387972832, + 0.039486076682806015, + 0.3319266736507416, + 0.06607520580291748, + 0.1561266928911209, + 0.129579558968544, + 0.03181689232587814, + 0.0689360722899437 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0006370898918248713 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, multi-car light rail train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the train traveling on elevated tracks above a busy, futuristic city street?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at night with a predominantly cool blue color palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the train tilt at an extreme angle while navigating a sharp turn?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot dynamic and moving swiftly to follow the train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2812834680080414 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4062834978103638 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2812834680080414, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2812834680080414, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06747004389762878, + 0.17025551199913025, + 0.05831814929842949, + 0.037745051085948944, + 0.06261595338582993, + 0.03338281810283661, + 0.2698056697845459, + 0.09127099066972733, + 0.03072010725736618, + 0.1784157007932663 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2812834680080414 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, multi-car light rail train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the train traveling on elevated tracks above a busy, futuristic city street?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at night with a predominantly cool blue color palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the train tilt at an extreme angle while navigating a sharp turn?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot dynamic and moving swiftly to follow the train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0024898024275898933 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.0024895668029785 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0024898024275898933, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0024898024275898933, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07977798581123352, + 0.09908629208803177, + 0.07410376518964767, + 0.06780856847763062, + 0.2653634548187256, + 0.058401115238666534, + 0.12015843391418457, + 0.04473241791129112, + 0.08586794883012772, + 0.1046999841928482 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0024898024275898933 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dynamic, low-angle shot moves swiftly, following a sleek, multi-car light rail train as it teeters on elevated tracks, rendered in a vibrant, animated style. At night, the train negotiates a perilous, sharp turn above a busy, futuristic city street. The entire scene is bathed in a predominantly cool blue, creating a moody, nocturnal atmosphere. The train's polished silver metal surface acts like a distorting mirror, capturing and distorting the chaotic light emanating from the metropolis below. On the street, the light from car headlights and taillights blurs into streaks of white and red, while massive skyscrapers are adorned with vibrant neon signs in vibrant pink, electric yellow, and deep purple. These brilliant, varied colors cast long, shimmering reflections that slide and twist across the train's swaying body, emphasizing its precarious motion. The train itself tilts at an extreme angle, its individual cars jostling against each other as it strains against the curve, creating a palpable sense of high-speed tension and exhilarating danger.", + "seed": 28854, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_15/index_1478_seed_28854_dp_30_rank_60_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.12516048880061134, + "vlm_logprob": -0.12516048880061134, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.0, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.12516048880061134, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, multi-car light rail train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the train traveling on elevated tracks above a busy, futuristic city street?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at night with a predominantly cool blue color palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the train tilt at an extreme angle while navigating a sharp turn?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot dynamic and moving swiftly to follow the train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4800242781639099 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9800242781639099 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.4800242781639099, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.4800242781639099, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4187840223312378, + 0.023825164884328842, + 0.04018665850162506, + 0.011929478496313095, + 0.019468480721116066, + 0.019541285932064056, + 0.09779229015111923, + 0.027506250888109207, + 0.08292333036661148, + 0.2580430507659912 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.4800242781639099 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, multi-car light rail train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the train traveling on elevated tracks above a busy, futuristic city street?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at night with a predominantly cool blue color palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the train tilt at an extreme angle while navigating a sharp turn?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot dynamic and moving swiftly to follow the train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05502019077539444 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9300200939178467 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05502019077539444, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05502019077539444, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4435047507286072, + 0.052139729261398315, + 0.07569390535354614, + 0.05099242553114891, + 0.03696337714791298, + 0.033383872359991074, + 0.0860440582036972, + 0.03364204615354538, + 0.051209867000579834, + 0.1364259272813797 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05502019077539444 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, multi-car light rail train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the train traveling on elevated tracks above a busy, futuristic city street?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at night with a predominantly cool blue color palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the train tilt at an extreme angle while navigating a sharp turn?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot dynamic and moving swiftly to follow the train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0005623904871754348 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.5005621910095215 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0005623904871754348, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0005623904871754348, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3780812919139862, + 0.03376680985093117, + 0.07385282218456268, + 0.11376272141933441, + 0.08085358887910843, + 0.060137636959552765, + 0.06359215080738068, + 0.04387947544455528, + 0.05252402275800705, + 0.0995495393872261 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0005623904871754348 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, multi-car light rail train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the train traveling on elevated tracks above a busy, futuristic city street?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at night with a predominantly cool blue color palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the train tilt at an extreme angle while navigating a sharp turn?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot dynamic and moving swiftly to follow the train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08901503682136536 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.464015007019043 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08901503682136536, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08901503682136536, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18208691477775574, + 0.06524942815303802, + 0.15230511128902435, + 0.04309556633234024, + 0.1502426415681839, + 0.11468823254108429, + 0.1533392369747162, + 0.03929021954536438, + 0.05522175133228302, + 0.044480856508016586 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08901503682136536 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, multi-car light rail train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the train traveling on elevated tracks above a busy, futuristic city street?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at night with a predominantly cool blue color palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the train tilt at an extreme angle while navigating a sharp turn?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot dynamic and moving swiftly to follow the train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0011805477552115917 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.751180648803711 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0011805477552115917, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0011805477552115917, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.29762670397758484, + 0.08050847798585892, + 0.19205550849437714, + 0.036236319690942764, + 0.03936827927827835, + 0.06677760183811188, + 0.11823944002389908, + 0.03812474384903908, + 0.0837884321808815, + 0.04727449640631676 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0011805477552115917 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dynamic, low-angle shot moves swiftly, following a sleek, multi-car light rail train as it teeters on elevated tracks, rendered in a vibrant, animated style. At night, the train negotiates a perilous, sharp turn above a busy, futuristic city street. The entire scene is bathed in a predominantly cool blue, creating a moody, nocturnal atmosphere. The train's polished silver metal surface acts like a distorting mirror, capturing and distorting the chaotic light emanating from the metropolis below. On the street, the light from car headlights and taillights blurs into streaks of white and red, while massive skyscrapers are adorned with vibrant neon signs in vibrant pink, electric yellow, and deep purple. These brilliant, varied colors cast long, shimmering reflections that slide and twist across the train's swaying body, emphasizing its precarious motion. The train itself tilts at an extreme angle, its individual cars jostling against each other as it strains against the curve, creating a palpable sense of high-speed tension and exhilarating danger.", + "seed": 28855, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_15/index_1478_seed_28855_dp_31_rank_62_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.07904241303913295, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07904241303913295, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.324999988079071, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07904241303913295, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, multi-car light rail train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the train traveling on elevated tracks above a busy, futuristic city street?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at night with a predominantly cool blue color palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the train tilt at an extreme angle while navigating a sharp turn?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot dynamic and moving swiftly to follow the train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3166273236274719 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3166272640228271 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3166273236274719, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.9999999403953552, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3166273236274719, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07332706451416016, + 0.07992258667945862, + 0.2048398107290268, + 0.16610164940357208, + 0.11019968241453171, + 0.10972193628549576, + 0.0587843656539917, + 0.0769382193684578, + 0.06196117773652077, + 0.05820350721478462 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3166273236274719 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, multi-car light rail train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the train traveling on elevated tracks above a busy, futuristic city street?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at night with a predominantly cool blue color palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the train tilt at an extreme angle while navigating a sharp turn?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot dynamic and moving swiftly to follow the train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014226092025637627 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264225959777832 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014226092025637627, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014226092025637627, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17354239523410797, + 0.2685530483722687, + 0.13990575075149536, + 0.0373198427259922, + 0.058146826922893524, + 0.04033128172159195, + 0.03824672847986221, + 0.0603063628077507, + 0.10685551166534424, + 0.07679224759340286 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014226092025637627 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, multi-car light rail train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the train traveling on elevated tracks above a busy, futuristic city street?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at night with a predominantly cool blue color palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the train tilt at an extreme angle while navigating a sharp turn?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot dynamic and moving swiftly to follow the train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0008137490367516875 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.125813961029053 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0008137490367516875, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0008137490367516875, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2084832340478897, + 0.12557382881641388, + 0.08350694179534912, + 0.08739271759986877, + 0.09203530848026276, + 0.09505652636289597, + 0.05897936224937439, + 0.06853704154491425, + 0.12108995020389557, + 0.059345100075006485 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0008137490367516875 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, multi-car light rail train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the train traveling on elevated tracks above a busy, futuristic city street?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at night with a predominantly cool blue color palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the train tilt at an extreme angle while navigating a sharp turn?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot dynamic and moving swiftly to follow the train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.062031254172325134 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120312690734863 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.062031254172325134, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.062031254172325134, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10518298298120499, + 0.0945049449801445, + 0.10717882961034775, + 0.09680041670799255, + 0.20922718942165375, + 0.10863833874464035, + 0.02698386274278164, + 0.06395260989665985, + 0.11435293406248093, + 0.07317785173654556 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.062031254172325134 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, multi-car light rail train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the train traveling on elevated tracks above a busy, futuristic city street?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at night with a predominantly cool blue color palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the train tilt at an extreme angle while navigating a sharp turn?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot dynamic and moving swiftly to follow the train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0015136463334783912 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.501513481140137 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0015136463334783912, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0015136463334783912, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14005590975284576, + 0.14236396551132202, + 0.07904121279716492, + 0.08953498303890228, + 0.11579029262065887, + 0.08214595168828964, + 0.10209761559963226, + 0.04786848649382591, + 0.12142989039421082, + 0.0796717032790184 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0015136463334783912 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dynamic, low-angle shot moves swiftly, following a sleek, multi-car light rail train as it teeters on elevated tracks, rendered in a vibrant, animated style. At night, the train negotiates a perilous, sharp turn above a busy, futuristic city street. The entire scene is bathed in a predominantly cool blue, creating a moody, nocturnal atmosphere. The train's polished silver metal surface acts like a distorting mirror, capturing and distorting the chaotic light emanating from the metropolis below. On the street, the light from car headlights and taillights blurs into streaks of white and red, while massive skyscrapers are adorned with vibrant neon signs in vibrant pink, electric yellow, and deep purple. These brilliant, varied colors cast long, shimmering reflections that slide and twist across the train's swaying body, emphasizing its precarious motion. The train itself tilts at an extreme angle, its individual cars jostling against each other as it strains against the curve, creating a palpable sense of high-speed tension and exhilarating danger.", + "seed": 28856, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_15/index_1478_seed_28856_dp_31_rank_62_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.030575706472154705, + "vlm_logprob": -0.030575706472154705, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.625, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.030575706472154705, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, multi-car light rail train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the train traveling on elevated tracks above a busy, futuristic city street?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at night with a predominantly cool blue color palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the train tilt at an extreme angle while navigating a sharp turn?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot dynamic and moving swiftly to follow the train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.09176263958215714 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4667625427246094 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.09176263958215714, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.09176263958215714, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06163841113448143, + 0.09026502072811127, + 0.0691167563199997, + 0.04757513105869293, + 0.08460496366024017, + 0.05958809703588486, + 0.10386794060468674, + 0.2997649908065796, + 0.08053780347108841, + 0.10304094105958939 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.09176263958215714 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, multi-car light rail train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the train traveling on elevated tracks above a busy, futuristic city street?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at night with a predominantly cool blue color palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the train tilt at an extreme angle while navigating a sharp turn?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot dynamic and moving swiftly to follow the train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020601458847522736 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895601511001587 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020601458847522736, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020601458847522736, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07153081893920898, + 0.10225333273410797, + 0.18363995850086212, + 0.048182275146245956, + 0.04988831654191017, + 0.050669025629758835, + 0.08191470801830292, + 0.13981656730175018, + 0.1643378585577011, + 0.10776712000370026 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020601458847522736 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, multi-car light rail train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the train traveling on elevated tracks above a busy, futuristic city street?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at night with a predominantly cool blue color palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the train tilt at an extreme angle while navigating a sharp turn?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot dynamic and moving swiftly to follow the train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0007176207727752626 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.250717639923096 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0007176207727752626, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0007176207727752626, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06645508110523224, + 0.1005433052778244, + 0.05965478718280792, + 0.021374279633164406, + 0.031203333288431168, + 0.0672607496380806, + 0.03240128606557846, + 0.3936242461204529, + 0.1391860395669937, + 0.08829687535762787 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0007176207727752626 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, multi-car light rail train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the train traveling on elevated tracks above a busy, futuristic city street?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at night with a predominantly cool blue color palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the train tilt at an extreme angle while navigating a sharp turn?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot dynamic and moving swiftly to follow the train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03808547928929329 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288085460662842 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03808547928929329, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03808547928929329, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08066338300704956, + 0.10923999547958374, + 0.26583582162857056, + 0.05744751915335655, + 0.07179979979991913, + 0.14226798713207245, + 0.04907219484448433, + 0.0693599134683609, + 0.08539624512195587, + 0.06891714036464691 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03808547928929329 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, multi-car light rail train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the train traveling on elevated tracks above a busy, futuristic city street?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at night with a predominantly cool blue color palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the train tilt at an extreme angle while navigating a sharp turn?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot dynamic and moving swiftly to follow the train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0017113338690251112 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.376711368560791 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0017113338690251112, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0017113338690251112, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19536638259887695, + 0.07307180017232895, + 0.16430003941059113, + 0.023175373673439026, + 0.14253820478916168, + 0.0979144349694252, + 0.041689641773700714, + 0.18367420136928558, + 0.045261871069669724, + 0.03300803154706955 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0017113338690251112 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_2/index_tensor([3336, 3336])_group_2_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_2/index_tensor([3336, 3336])_group_2_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..2e9ccf440d54cfe665ba09389910b82fd0ed8be0 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_2/index_tensor([3336, 3336])_group_2_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "static, medium shot, held at eye level, presents the scene in a striking pop art style, defined by highly saturated colors and bold, thick black outlines. At its center lies a high-speed blender, its base a gleaming chrome surface, and a pitcher, a thick, transparent container, resting on a bright canary-yellow countertop. Inside the pitcher, a vibrant, unnatural pink liquid boils violently, stirring constantly into a chaotic vortex. Large, graphic bubbles, depicted as perfect circles with sharp white highlights, expand rapidly across the bubbling surface before bursting with exaggerated energy. From the blender's lid, stylized steam rises not as soft steam but in a distinctive pattern of bold black lines and Ben Day dots against a solid cobalt blue background. The entire composition is illuminated by bright, flat lighting, casting hard-edged, minimal shadows, creating an atmosphere of high contrast, energy, and graphic dynamism that feels both chaotic and meticulously designed.", + "seed": 17787, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_2/index_3336_seed_17787_dp_4_rank_8_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.010598562320228665, + "vlm_logprob": -0.010598562320228665, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 5.325, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.010598562320228665, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene presented in a pop art style with bold, thick black outlines and highly saturated colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a high-speed blender with a gleaming chrome base visible on a bright canary-yellow countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a thick, transparent pitcher containing a vibrant, unnatural pink liquid that boils violently into a chaotic vortex visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are large, graphic bubbles depicted as perfect circles with sharp white highlights expanding and bursting on the liquid surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a solid cobalt blue color with stylized steam rising in bold black lines and Ben Day dots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.000596107158344239 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.875596046447754 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.000596107158344239, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.000596107158344239, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19064661860466003, + 0.06556665152311325, + 0.07985891401767731, + 0.11277727037668228, + 0.16856293380260468, + 0.06004123017191887, + 0.05377279967069626, + 0.13910998404026031, + 0.06047537922859192, + 0.0691881850361824 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.000596107158344239 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene presented in a pop art style with bold, thick black outlines and highly saturated colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a high-speed blender with a gleaming chrome base visible on a bright canary-yellow countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a thick, transparent pitcher containing a vibrant, unnatural pink liquid that boils violently into a chaotic vortex visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are large, graphic bubbles depicted as perfect circles with sharp white highlights expanding and bursting on the liquid surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a solid cobalt blue color with stylized steam rising in bold black lines and Ben Day dots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03371458128094673 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408714532852173 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03371458128094673, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03371458128094673, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07442452013492584, + 0.09768600761890411, + 0.07842420786619186, + 0.1545373648405075, + 0.21798667311668396, + 0.05691827833652496, + 0.03534351661801338, + 0.1961507350206375, + 0.01885303296148777, + 0.06967562437057495 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 7, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03371458128094673 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene presented in a pop art style with bold, thick black outlines and highly saturated colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a high-speed blender with a gleaming chrome base visible on a bright canary-yellow countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a thick, transparent pitcher containing a vibrant, unnatural pink liquid that boils violently into a chaotic vortex visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are large, graphic bubbles depicted as perfect circles with sharp white highlights expanding and bursting on the liquid surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a solid cobalt blue color with stylized steam rising in bold black lines and Ben Day dots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004097875207662582 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504097938537598 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004097875207662582, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004097875207662582, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1895851045846939, + 0.07943575829267502, + 0.07068300247192383, + 0.10813060402870178, + 0.31676965951919556, + 0.06919822096824646, + 0.040073245763778687, + 0.052061405032873154, + 0.017200089991092682, + 0.0568629689514637 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004097875207662582 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene presented in a pop art style with bold, thick black outlines and highly saturated colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a high-speed blender with a gleaming chrome base visible on a bright canary-yellow countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a thick, transparent pitcher containing a vibrant, unnatural pink liquid that boils violently into a chaotic vortex visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are large, graphic bubbles depicted as perfect circles with sharp white highlights expanding and bursting on the liquid surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a solid cobalt blue color with stylized steam rising in bold black lines and Ben Day dots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008638040162622929 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.75863790512085 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008638040162622929, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008638040162622929, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12802551686763763, + 0.1900309920310974, + 0.13745459914207458, + 0.03894071653485298, + 0.14308489859104156, + 0.15455424785614014, + 0.04223264381289482, + 0.10085129737854004, + 0.027384303510189056, + 0.037440765649080276 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008638040162622929 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene presented in a pop art style with bold, thick black outlines and highly saturated colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a high-speed blender with a gleaming chrome base visible on a bright canary-yellow countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a thick, transparent pitcher containing a vibrant, unnatural pink liquid that boils violently into a chaotic vortex visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are large, graphic bubbles depicted as perfect circles with sharp white highlights expanding and bursting on the liquid surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a solid cobalt blue color with stylized steam rising in bold black lines and Ben Day dots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005946207791566849 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130946159362793 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005946207791566849, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005946207791566849, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20852030813694, + 0.1342058926820755, + 0.12694646418094635, + 0.0931515097618103, + 0.13624747097492218, + 0.13364164531230927, + 0.035248298197984695, + 0.07048695534467697, + 0.01731080189347267, + 0.04424060508608818 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005946207791566849 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, medium shot, held at eye level, presents the scene in a striking pop art style, defined by highly saturated colors and bold, thick black outlines. At its center lies a high-speed blender, its base a gleaming chrome surface, and a pitcher, a thick, transparent container, resting on a bright canary-yellow countertop. Inside the pitcher, a vibrant, unnatural pink liquid boils violently, stirring constantly into a chaotic vortex. Large, graphic bubbles, depicted as perfect circles with sharp white highlights, expand rapidly across the bubbling surface before bursting with exaggerated energy. From the blender's lid, stylized steam rises not as soft steam but in a distinctive pattern of bold black lines and Ben Day dots against a solid cobalt blue background. The entire composition is illuminated by bright, flat lighting, casting hard-edged, minimal shadows, creating an atmosphere of high contrast, energy, and graphic dynamism that feels both chaotic and meticulously designed.", + "seed": 17788, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_2/index_3336_seed_17788_dp_4_rank_8_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.014309808181133121, + "vlm_logprob": -0.014309808181133121, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.975, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.014309808181133121, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene presented in a pop art style with bold, thick black outlines and highly saturated colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a high-speed blender with a gleaming chrome base visible on a bright canary-yellow countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a thick, transparent pitcher containing a vibrant, unnatural pink liquid that boils violently into a chaotic vortex visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are large, graphic bubbles depicted as perfect circles with sharp white highlights expanding and bursting on the liquid surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a solid cobalt blue color with stylized steam rising in bold black lines and Ben Day dots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0006426891195587814 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -8.125642776489258 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0006426891195587814, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 8.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0006426891195587814, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11826593428850174, + 0.06750479340553284, + 0.052872419357299805, + 0.05718989297747612, + 0.10767968744039536, + 0.08583884686231613, + 0.030661817640066147, + 0.014156369492411613, + 0.39911168813705444, + 0.06671851873397827 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0006426891195587814 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene presented in a pop art style with bold, thick black outlines and highly saturated colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a high-speed blender with a gleaming chrome base visible on a bright canary-yellow countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a thick, transparent pitcher containing a vibrant, unnatural pink liquid that boils violently into a chaotic vortex visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are large, graphic bubbles depicted as perfect circles with sharp white highlights expanding and bursting on the liquid surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a solid cobalt blue color with stylized steam rising in bold black lines and Ben Day dots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02981729805469513 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298173427581787 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02981729805469513, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02981729805469513, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10079363733530045, + 0.06742570549249649, + 0.072731152176857, + 0.118047796189785, + 0.34459778666496277, + 0.01714617945253849, + 0.04966306686401367, + 0.03911042958498001, + 0.09072964638471603, + 0.09975451976060867 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02981729805469513 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene presented in a pop art style with bold, thick black outlines and highly saturated colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a high-speed blender with a gleaming chrome base visible on a bright canary-yellow countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a thick, transparent pitcher containing a vibrant, unnatural pink liquid that boils violently into a chaotic vortex visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are large, graphic bubbles depicted as perfect circles with sharp white highlights expanding and bursting on the liquid surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a solid cobalt blue color with stylized steam rising in bold black lines and Ben Day dots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006736780982464552 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006736755371094 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006736780982464552, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006736780982464552, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13070344924926758, + 0.03086133301258087, + 0.14430546760559082, + 0.09545225650072098, + 0.2655342221260071, + 0.045677900314331055, + 0.09147948771715164, + 0.03284551575779915, + 0.04687270522117615, + 0.11626766622066498 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006736780982464552 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene presented in a pop art style with bold, thick black outlines and highly saturated colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a high-speed blender with a gleaming chrome base visible on a bright canary-yellow countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a thick, transparent pitcher containing a vibrant, unnatural pink liquid that boils violently into a chaotic vortex visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are large, graphic bubbles depicted as perfect circles with sharp white highlights expanding and bursting on the liquid surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a solid cobalt blue color with stylized steam rising in bold black lines and Ben Day dots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023282483220100403 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773282527923584 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023282483220100403, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023282483220100403, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2064167857170105, + 0.037122249603271484, + 0.08937028050422668, + 0.09823685139417648, + 0.1166653260588646, + 0.09650739282369614, + 0.056003637611866, + 0.03294908255338669, + 0.19564476609230042, + 0.07108365744352341 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023282483220100403 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene presented in a pop art style with bold, thick black outlines and highly saturated colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a high-speed blender with a gleaming chrome base visible on a bright canary-yellow countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a thick, transparent pitcher containing a vibrant, unnatural pink liquid that boils violently into a chaotic vortex visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are large, graphic bubbles depicted as perfect circles with sharp white highlights expanding and bursting on the liquid surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a solid cobalt blue color with stylized steam rising in bold black lines and Ben Day dots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01106978952884674 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.5110697746276855 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01106978952884674, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01106978952884674, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2040291279554367, + 0.05061306431889534, + 0.08912765979766846, + 0.049897000193595886, + 0.1348596215248108, + 0.030954821035265923, + 0.018231704831123352, + 0.011007330380380154, + 0.36951467394828796, + 0.041765015572309494 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01106978952884674 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, medium shot, held at eye level, presents the scene in a striking pop art style, defined by highly saturated colors and bold, thick black outlines. At its center lies a high-speed blender, its base a gleaming chrome surface, and a pitcher, a thick, transparent container, resting on a bright canary-yellow countertop. Inside the pitcher, a vibrant, unnatural pink liquid boils violently, stirring constantly into a chaotic vortex. Large, graphic bubbles, depicted as perfect circles with sharp white highlights, expand rapidly across the bubbling surface before bursting with exaggerated energy. From the blender's lid, stylized steam rises not as soft steam but in a distinctive pattern of bold black lines and Ben Day dots against a solid cobalt blue background. The entire composition is illuminated by bright, flat lighting, casting hard-edged, minimal shadows, creating an atmosphere of high contrast, energy, and graphic dynamism that feels both chaotic and meticulously designed.", + "seed": 17789, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_2/index_3336_seed_17789_dp_5_rank_10_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.03547643348574638, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03547643348574638, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 5.1, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03547643348574638, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene presented in a pop art style with bold, thick black outlines and highly saturated colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a high-speed blender with a gleaming chrome base visible on a bright canary-yellow countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a thick, transparent pitcher containing a vibrant, unnatural pink liquid that boils violently into a chaotic vortex visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are large, graphic bubbles depicted as perfect circles with sharp white highlights expanding and bursting on the liquid surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a solid cobalt blue color with stylized steam rising in bold black lines and Ben Day dots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0006193388253450394 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.875619411468506 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0006193388253450394, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0006193388253450394, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.7474972009658813, + 0.012084715068340302, + 0.01468554139137268, + 0.012501628138124943, + 0.015077518299221992, + 0.051401134580373764, + 0.08779997378587723, + 0.04668239504098892, + 0.006786004640161991, + 0.005483850371092558 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0006193388253450394 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene presented in a pop art style with bold, thick black outlines and highly saturated colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a high-speed blender with a gleaming chrome base visible on a bright canary-yellow countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a thick, transparent pitcher containing a vibrant, unnatural pink liquid that boils violently into a chaotic vortex visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are large, graphic bubbles depicted as perfect circles with sharp white highlights expanding and bursting on the liquid surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a solid cobalt blue color with stylized steam rising in bold black lines and Ben Day dots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16037754714488983 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9103775024414062 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16037754714488983, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16037754714488983, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.8593018054962158, + 0.017961889505386353, + 0.03164627030491829, + 0.010033832862973213, + 0.017582381144165993, + 0.015030508860945702, + 0.01725834049284458, + 0.012559802271425724, + 0.008466452360153198, + 0.010158720426261425 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16037754714488983 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene presented in a pop art style with bold, thick black outlines and highly saturated colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a high-speed blender with a gleaming chrome base visible on a bright canary-yellow countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a thick, transparent pitcher containing a vibrant, unnatural pink liquid that boils violently into a chaotic vortex visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are large, graphic bubbles depicted as perfect circles with sharp white highlights expanding and bursting on the liquid surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a solid cobalt blue color with stylized steam rising in bold black lines and Ben Day dots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0059472741559147835 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130947113037109 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0059472741559147835, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0059472741559147835, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.7080173492431641, + 0.05236594006419182, + 0.01819399558007717, + 0.029099931940436363, + 0.016543172299861908, + 0.027810119092464447, + 0.054480474442243576, + 0.047649726271629333, + 0.021532703191041946, + 0.02430662512779236 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0059472741559147835 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene presented in a pop art style with bold, thick black outlines and highly saturated colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a high-speed blender with a gleaming chrome base visible on a bright canary-yellow countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a thick, transparent pitcher containing a vibrant, unnatural pink liquid that boils violently into a chaotic vortex visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are large, graphic bubbles depicted as perfect circles with sharp white highlights expanding and bursting on the liquid surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a solid cobalt blue color with stylized steam rising in bold black lines and Ben Day dots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007623744197189808 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882623672485352 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007623744197189808, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007623744197189808, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.8508672714233398, + 0.01418155338615179, + 0.010589317418634892, + 0.01241221185773611, + 0.018288861960172653, + 0.018223728984594345, + 0.026377307251095772, + 0.029021747410297394, + 0.003320008749142289, + 0.016717946156859398 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007623744197189808 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene presented in a pop art style with bold, thick black outlines and highly saturated colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a high-speed blender with a gleaming chrome base visible on a bright canary-yellow countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a thick, transparent pitcher containing a vibrant, unnatural pink liquid that boils violently into a chaotic vortex visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are large, graphic bubbles depicted as perfect circles with sharp white highlights expanding and bursting on the liquid surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a solid cobalt blue color with stylized steam rising in bold black lines and Ben Day dots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002814263105392456 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877814292907715 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002814263105392456, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002814263105392456, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.8794896602630615, + 0.007017305586487055, + 0.01115045603364706, + 0.00631959643214941, + 0.010173225775361061, + 0.021434038877487183, + 0.036451999098062515, + 0.022583764046430588, + 0.0029332744888961315, + 0.0024467292241752148 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002814263105392456 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, medium shot, held at eye level, presents the scene in a striking pop art style, defined by highly saturated colors and bold, thick black outlines. At its center lies a high-speed blender, its base a gleaming chrome surface, and a pitcher, a thick, transparent container, resting on a bright canary-yellow countertop. Inside the pitcher, a vibrant, unnatural pink liquid boils violently, stirring constantly into a chaotic vortex. Large, graphic bubbles, depicted as perfect circles with sharp white highlights, expand rapidly across the bubbling surface before bursting with exaggerated energy. From the blender's lid, stylized steam rises not as soft steam but in a distinctive pattern of bold black lines and Ben Day dots against a solid cobalt blue background. The entire composition is illuminated by bright, flat lighting, casting hard-edged, minimal shadows, creating an atmosphere of high contrast, energy, and graphic dynamism that feels both chaotic and meticulously designed.", + "seed": 17790, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_2/index_3336_seed_17790_dp_5_rank_10_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.014120249741245062, + "vlm_logprob": -0.014120249741245062, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.875, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.014120249741245062, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene presented in a pop art style with bold, thick black outlines and highly saturated colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a high-speed blender with a gleaming chrome base visible on a bright canary-yellow countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a thick, transparent pitcher containing a vibrant, unnatural pink liquid that boils violently into a chaotic vortex visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are large, graphic bubbles depicted as perfect circles with sharp white highlights expanding and bursting on the liquid surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a solid cobalt blue color with stylized steam rising in bold black lines and Ben Day dots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0007010624394752085 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.500700950622559 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0007010624394752085, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0007010624394752085, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4397839307785034, + 0.030778037384152412, + 0.0342533215880394, + 0.033609017729759216, + 0.34095779061317444, + 0.024245386943221092, + 0.01592366211116314, + 0.02455585077404976, + 0.030777715146541595, + 0.02511531673371792 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0007010624394752085 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene presented in a pop art style with bold, thick black outlines and highly saturated colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a high-speed blender with a gleaming chrome base visible on a bright canary-yellow countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a thick, transparent pitcher containing a vibrant, unnatural pink liquid that boils violently into a chaotic vortex visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are large, graphic bubbles depicted as perfect circles with sharp white highlights expanding and bursting on the liquid surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a solid cobalt blue color with stylized steam rising in bold black lines and Ben Day dots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.033710431307554245 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408710479736328 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.033710431307554245, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.033710431307554245, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16537456214427948, + 0.01782432571053505, + 0.014523050747811794, + 0.008345807902514935, + 0.6849196553230286, + 0.016417087987065315, + 0.006663997657597065, + 0.00936874933540821, + 0.008321920409798622, + 0.06824089586734772 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.033710431307554245 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene presented in a pop art style with bold, thick black outlines and highly saturated colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a high-speed blender with a gleaming chrome base visible on a bright canary-yellow countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a thick, transparent pitcher containing a vibrant, unnatural pink liquid that boils violently into a chaotic vortex visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are large, graphic bubbles depicted as perfect circles with sharp white highlights expanding and bursting on the liquid surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a solid cobalt blue color with stylized steam rising in bold black lines and Ben Day dots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016061563044786453 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141061782836914 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016061563044786453, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016061563044786453, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07039221376180649, + 0.016797350719571114, + 0.009300777688622475, + 0.009803039021790028, + 0.8355987071990967, + 0.01143049355596304, + 0.0027942426968365908, + 0.006207759492099285, + 0.01217561960220337, + 0.02549988217651844 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016061563044786453 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene presented in a pop art style with bold, thick black outlines and highly saturated colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a high-speed blender with a gleaming chrome base visible on a bright canary-yellow countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a thick, transparent pitcher containing a vibrant, unnatural pink liquid that boils violently into a chaotic vortex visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are large, graphic bubbles depicted as perfect circles with sharp white highlights expanding and bursting on the liquid surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a solid cobalt blue color with stylized steam rising in bold black lines and Ben Day dots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014186250045895576 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264186382293701 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014186250045895576, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014186250045895576, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03625355288386345, + 0.010599523782730103, + 0.009054101072251797, + 0.005101961549371481, + 0.902413547039032, + 0.00709904357790947, + 0.003411948448047042, + 0.004733686801046133, + 0.010332146659493446, + 0.011000549420714378 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014186250045895576 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene presented in a pop art style with bold, thick black outlines and highly saturated colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a high-speed blender with a gleaming chrome base visible on a bright canary-yellow countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a thick, transparent pitcher containing a vibrant, unnatural pink liquid that boils violently into a chaotic vortex visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are large, graphic bubbles depicted as perfect circles with sharp white highlights expanding and bursting on the liquid surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a solid cobalt blue color with stylized steam rising in bold black lines and Ben Day dots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0059419418685138226 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130941867828369 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0059419418685138226, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0059419418685138226, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15218810737133026, + 0.015982188284397125, + 0.028530441224575043, + 0.011122013442218304, + 0.744486391544342, + 0.011415226384997368, + 0.004432793706655502, + 0.009701685979962349, + 0.013678410090506077, + 0.008462801575660706 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0059419418685138226 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_3/index_tensor([4598, 4598])_group_3_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_3/index_tensor([4598, 4598])_group_3_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..baa3c3da9651fa2d64b24f82e3b9c4b7fa9a955a --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_3/index_tensor([4598, 4598])_group_3_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "static, high-angle close-up meticulously depicts a pile of clay-composite poker chips, precariously balanced, resting on the smooth, dark, highly polished surface of a wooden table. The chips, with their matte texture and slightly worn edges, are arranged in a vibrant pattern of red, white, and blue. A warm, overhead light casts a striking, focused glow, creating sharp, mirror-like highlights on the chips' rounded edges and bright reflections on the mirror-like tabletop, while the background dissolves into a soft, blurred darkness. The scene is tense and quiet. Suddenly, a subtle vibration travels through the surface, and the pile collapses instantly; the chips begin sliding outward in a chaotic cascade. They move rapidly at first, their colors blurring as they glide across the polished wood. Then, a steady rubbing and deliberate slowing of their movement causes them to sway and twirl, finally coming to rest in a scattered, overlapping pile—a moment frozen in chaos on the dark, gleaming surface.", + "seed": 26270, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_3/index_4598_seed_26270_dp_6_rank_12_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.051640638057142495, + "vlm_logprob": -0.051640638057142495, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.425, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.051640638057142495, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a static, high-angle close-up of a pile of poker chips on a dark, polished wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the poker chips matte with slightly worn edges and arranged in a red, white, and blue pattern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does warm overhead lighting create sharp, mirror-like highlights on the chips and bright reflections on the tabletop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the pile collapse instantly due to a subtle vibration, causing the chips to slide outward in a chaotic cascade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the chips transition from rapid sliding to a steady rubbing motion, swaying and twirling before coming to rest in a scattered pile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06318560242652893 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.813185691833496 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06318560242652893, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06318560242652893, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17717638611793518, + 0.061277665197849274, + 0.12685605883598328, + 0.08930180966854095, + 0.14548549056053162, + 0.11485160887241364, + 0.02557549998164177, + 0.027400044724345207, + 0.11276785284280777, + 0.11930767446756363 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06318560242652893 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a static, high-angle close-up of a pile of poker chips on a dark, polished wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the poker chips matte with slightly worn edges and arranged in a red, white, and blue pattern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does warm overhead lighting create sharp, mirror-like highlights on the chips and bright reflections on the tabletop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the pile collapse instantly due to a subtle vibration, causing the chips to slide outward in a chaotic cascade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the chips transition from rapid sliding to a steady rubbing motion, swaying and twirling before coming to rest in a scattered pile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12707629799842834 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1270763874053955 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12707629799842834, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12707629799842834, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14693306386470795, + 0.11780159920454025, + 0.12667346000671387, + 0.048390693962574005, + 0.1563308835029602, + 0.037606511265039444, + 0.026690663769841194, + 0.031028946861624718, + 0.13734564185142517, + 0.1711985319852829 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12707629799842834 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a static, high-angle close-up of a pile of poker chips on a dark, polished wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the poker chips matte with slightly worn edges and arranged in a red, white, and blue pattern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does warm overhead lighting create sharp, mirror-like highlights on the chips and bright reflections on the tabletop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the pile collapse instantly due to a subtle vibration, causing the chips to slide outward in a chaotic cascade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the chips transition from rapid sliding to a steady rubbing motion, swaying and twirling before coming to rest in a scattered pile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006747674662619829 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006747722625732 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006747674662619829, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006747674662619829, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1785500943660736, + 0.05458313226699829, + 0.07101631909608841, + 0.0546308271586895, + 0.3284851014614105, + 0.04313215613365173, + 0.02044236660003662, + 0.0395110659301281, + 0.08469470590353012, + 0.12495429068803787 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006747674662619829 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a static, high-angle close-up of a pile of poker chips on a dark, polished wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the poker chips matte with slightly worn edges and arranged in a red, white, and blue pattern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does warm overhead lighting create sharp, mirror-like highlights on the chips and bright reflections on the tabletop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the pile collapse instantly due to a subtle vibration, causing the chips to slide outward in a chaotic cascade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the chips transition from rapid sliding to a steady rubbing motion, swaying and twirling before coming to rest in a scattered pile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04865284636616707 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486528873443604 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04865284636616707, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04865284636616707, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12547017633914948, + 0.06627649068832397, + 0.2790820598602295, + 0.12339387089014053, + 0.1567765325307846, + 0.039405081421136856, + 0.023545613512396812, + 0.026085997000336647, + 0.08538351953029633, + 0.07458070665597916 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04865284636616707 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a static, high-angle close-up of a pile of poker chips on a dark, polished wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the poker chips matte with slightly worn edges and arranged in a red, white, and blue pattern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does warm overhead lighting create sharp, mirror-like highlights on the chips and bright reflections on the tabletop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the pile collapse instantly due to a subtle vibration, causing the chips to slide outward in a chaotic cascade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the chips transition from rapid sliding to a steady rubbing motion, swaying and twirling before coming to rest in a scattered pile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012540768831968307 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387540817260742 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012540768831968307, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012540768831968307, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09627358615398407, + 0.053436052054166794, + 0.11506309360265732, + 0.07239459455013275, + 0.2633417844772339, + 0.053584400564432144, + 0.02524760365486145, + 0.04317837208509445, + 0.12921039760112762, + 0.1482701599597931 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012540768831968307 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, high-angle close-up meticulously depicts a pile of clay-composite poker chips, precariously balanced, resting on the smooth, dark, highly polished surface of a wooden table. The chips, with their matte texture and slightly worn edges, are arranged in a vibrant pattern of red, white, and blue. A warm, overhead light casts a striking, focused glow, creating sharp, mirror-like highlights on the chips' rounded edges and bright reflections on the mirror-like tabletop, while the background dissolves into a soft, blurred darkness. The scene is tense and quiet. Suddenly, a subtle vibration travels through the surface, and the pile collapses instantly; the chips begin sliding outward in a chaotic cascade. They move rapidly at first, their colors blurring as they glide across the polished wood. Then, a steady rubbing and deliberate slowing of their movement causes them to sway and twirl, finally coming to rest in a scattered, overlapping pile—a moment frozen in chaos on the dark, gleaming surface.", + "seed": 26271, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_3/index_4598_seed_26271_dp_6_rank_12_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.10802585361525416, + "vlm_logprob": -0.10802585361525416, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.95, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.10802585361525416, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a static, high-angle close-up of a pile of poker chips on a dark, polished wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the poker chips matte with slightly worn edges and arranged in a red, white, and blue pattern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does warm overhead lighting create sharp, mirror-like highlights on the chips and bright reflections on the tabletop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the pile collapse instantly due to a subtle vibration, causing the chips to slide outward in a chaotic cascade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the chips transition from rapid sliding to a steady rubbing motion, swaying and twirling before coming to rest in a scattered pile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.25307774543762207 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.503077745437622 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.25307774543762207, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.25307774543762207, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4708504378795624, + 0.033833589404821396, + 0.08096837997436523, + 0.046646807342767715, + 0.124949149787426, + 0.16922897100448608, + 0.020510995760560036, + 0.028334438800811768, + 0.016393931582570076, + 0.008283308707177639 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.25307774543762207 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a static, high-angle close-up of a pile of poker chips on a dark, polished wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the poker chips matte with slightly worn edges and arranged in a red, white, and blue pattern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does warm overhead lighting create sharp, mirror-like highlights on the chips and bright reflections on the tabletop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the pile collapse instantly due to a subtle vibration, causing the chips to slide outward in a chaotic cascade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the chips transition from rapid sliding to a steady rubbing motion, swaying and twirling before coming to rest in a scattered pile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20162734389305115 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7016273736953735 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20162734389305115, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20162734389305115, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.8186096549034119, + 0.03690481558442116, + 0.024362115189433098, + 0.02104986272752285, + 0.021142983809113503, + 0.02915366366505623, + 0.008689054287970066, + 0.01892835460603237, + 0.010450578294694424, + 0.010708914138376713 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20162734389305115 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a static, high-angle close-up of a pile of poker chips on a dark, polished wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the poker chips matte with slightly worn edges and arranged in a red, white, and blue pattern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does warm overhead lighting create sharp, mirror-like highlights on the chips and bright reflections on the tabletop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the pile collapse instantly due to a subtle vibration, causing the chips to slide outward in a chaotic cascade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the chips transition from rapid sliding to a steady rubbing motion, swaying and twirling before coming to rest in a scattered pile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004107966553419828 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.50410795211792 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004107966553419828, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004107966553419828, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3418344557285309, + 0.05577405169606209, + 0.19009870290756226, + 0.042122043669223785, + 0.09222329407930374, + 0.03710436820983887, + 0.066631019115448, + 0.07666287571191788, + 0.03129430487751961, + 0.0662548765540123 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004107966553419828 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a static, high-angle close-up of a pile of poker chips on a dark, polished wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the poker chips matte with slightly worn edges and arranged in a red, white, and blue pattern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does warm overhead lighting create sharp, mirror-like highlights on the chips and bright reflections on the tabletop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the pile collapse instantly due to a subtle vibration, causing the chips to slide outward in a chaotic cascade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the chips transition from rapid sliding to a steady rubbing motion, swaying and twirling before coming to rest in a scattered pile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05496467649936676 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929964780807495 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05496467649936676, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05496467649936676, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.6643927097320557, + 0.04365529865026474, + 0.06993246078491211, + 0.031003151088953018, + 0.08144631236791611, + 0.04262074455618858, + 0.011008097790181637, + 0.030807338654994965, + 0.010340247303247452, + 0.014793670736253262 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05496467649936676 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a static, high-angle close-up of a pile of poker chips on a dark, polished wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the poker chips matte with slightly worn edges and arranged in a red, white, and blue pattern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does warm overhead lighting create sharp, mirror-like highlights on the chips and bright reflections on the tabletop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the pile collapse instantly due to a subtle vibration, causing the chips to slide outward in a chaotic cascade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the chips transition from rapid sliding to a steady rubbing motion, swaying and twirling before coming to rest in a scattered pile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026351535692811012 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513514518737793 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026351535692811012, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026351535692811012, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.42847123742103577, + 0.039060674607753754, + 0.0705961361527443, + 0.027977129444479942, + 0.10092678666114807, + 0.10216635465621948, + 0.0746920257806778, + 0.06023363769054413, + 0.020383335649967194, + 0.07549265027046204 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026351535692811012 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, high-angle close-up meticulously depicts a pile of clay-composite poker chips, precariously balanced, resting on the smooth, dark, highly polished surface of a wooden table. The chips, with their matte texture and slightly worn edges, are arranged in a vibrant pattern of red, white, and blue. A warm, overhead light casts a striking, focused glow, creating sharp, mirror-like highlights on the chips' rounded edges and bright reflections on the mirror-like tabletop, while the background dissolves into a soft, blurred darkness. The scene is tense and quiet. Suddenly, a subtle vibration travels through the surface, and the pile collapses instantly; the chips begin sliding outward in a chaotic cascade. They move rapidly at first, their colors blurring as they glide across the polished wood. Then, a steady rubbing and deliberate slowing of their movement causes them to sway and twirl, finally coming to rest in a scattered, overlapping pile—a moment frozen in chaos on the dark, gleaming surface.", + "seed": 26272, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_3/index_4598_seed_26272_dp_7_rank_14_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.10247970339842141, + "vlm_logprob": -0.10247970339842141, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.275, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.10247970339842141, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a static, high-angle close-up of a pile of poker chips on a dark, polished wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the poker chips matte with slightly worn edges and arranged in a red, white, and blue pattern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does warm overhead lighting create sharp, mirror-like highlights on the chips and bright reflections on the tabletop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the pile collapse instantly due to a subtle vibration, causing the chips to slide outward in a chaotic cascade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the chips transition from rapid sliding to a steady rubbing motion, swaying and twirling before coming to rest in a scattered pile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03259284794330597 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5325927734375 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03259284794330597, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03259284794330597, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03891739994287491, + 0.10910595953464508, + 0.20475374162197113, + 0.04943861812353134, + 0.04055902361869812, + 0.04924642667174339, + 0.07665589451789856, + 0.06735114008188248, + 0.13746370375156403, + 0.22650818526744843 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 2, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03259284794330597 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a static, high-angle close-up of a pile of poker chips on a dark, polished wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the poker chips matte with slightly worn edges and arranged in a red, white, and blue pattern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does warm overhead lighting create sharp, mirror-like highlights on the chips and bright reflections on the tabletop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the pile collapse instantly due to a subtle vibration, causing the chips to slide outward in a chaotic cascade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the chips transition from rapid sliding to a steady rubbing motion, swaying and twirling before coming to rest in a scattered pile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2813698351383209 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4063698053359985 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2813698351383209, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2813698351383209, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11422239243984222, + 0.03824010118842125, + 0.1786917746067047, + 0.043275147676467896, + 0.028272461146116257, + 0.15335607528686523, + 0.09453126043081284, + 0.04005257785320282, + 0.08437887579202652, + 0.22497935593128204 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2813698351383209 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a static, high-angle close-up of a pile of poker chips on a dark, polished wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the poker chips matte with slightly worn edges and arranged in a red, white, and blue pattern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does warm overhead lighting create sharp, mirror-like highlights on the chips and bright reflections on the tabletop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the pile collapse instantly due to a subtle vibration, causing the chips to slide outward in a chaotic cascade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the chips transition from rapid sliding to a steady rubbing motion, swaying and twirling before coming to rest in a scattered pile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002498364308848977 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002498149871826 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002498364308848977, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002498364308848977, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07117385417222977, + 0.07242671400308609, + 0.17696955800056458, + 0.0723692998290062, + 0.11908914148807526, + 0.1973692923784256, + 0.0395054966211319, + 0.05089779943227768, + 0.08378607034683228, + 0.11641277372837067 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002498364308848977 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a static, high-angle close-up of a pile of poker chips on a dark, polished wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the poker chips matte with slightly worn edges and arranged in a red, white, and blue pattern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does warm overhead lighting create sharp, mirror-like highlights on the chips and bright reflections on the tabletop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the pile collapse instantly due to a subtle vibration, causing the chips to slide outward in a chaotic cascade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the chips transition from rapid sliding to a steady rubbing motion, swaying and twirling before coming to rest in a scattered pile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17986276745796204 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8048627376556396 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17986276745796204, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17986276745796204, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08051428943872452, + 0.11560353636741638, + 0.13369981944561005, + 0.07697457820177078, + 0.07223161309957504, + 0.06380303204059601, + 0.08935929834842682, + 0.128550186753273, + 0.16726893186569214, + 0.07199480384588242 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 2, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17986276745796204 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a static, high-angle close-up of a pile of poker chips on a dark, polished wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the poker chips matte with slightly worn edges and arranged in a red, white, and blue pattern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does warm overhead lighting create sharp, mirror-like highlights on the chips and bright reflections on the tabletop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the pile collapse instantly due to a subtle vibration, causing the chips to slide outward in a chaotic cascade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the chips transition from rapid sliding to a steady rubbing motion, swaying and twirling before coming to rest in a scattered pile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01607470214366913 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.1410746574401855 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01607470214366913, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01607470214366913, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07718992233276367, + 0.06468141078948975, + 0.15313968062400818, + 0.029380900785326958, + 0.02621506340801716, + 0.15171867609024048, + 0.10882525891065598, + 0.04456305876374245, + 0.15516960620880127, + 0.1891164779663086 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01607470214366913 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, high-angle close-up meticulously depicts a pile of clay-composite poker chips, precariously balanced, resting on the smooth, dark, highly polished surface of a wooden table. The chips, with their matte texture and slightly worn edges, are arranged in a vibrant pattern of red, white, and blue. A warm, overhead light casts a striking, focused glow, creating sharp, mirror-like highlights on the chips' rounded edges and bright reflections on the mirror-like tabletop, while the background dissolves into a soft, blurred darkness. The scene is tense and quiet. Suddenly, a subtle vibration travels through the surface, and the pile collapses instantly; the chips begin sliding outward in a chaotic cascade. They move rapidly at first, their colors blurring as they glide across the polished wood. Then, a steady rubbing and deliberate slowing of their movement causes them to sway and twirl, finally coming to rest in a scattered, overlapping pile—a moment frozen in chaos on the dark, gleaming surface.", + "seed": 26273, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_3/index_4598_seed_26273_dp_7_rank_14_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.07230843249708414, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07230843249708414, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.525, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07230843249708414, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a static, high-angle close-up of a pile of poker chips on a dark, polished wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the poker chips matte with slightly worn edges and arranged in a red, white, and blue pattern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does warm overhead lighting create sharp, mirror-like highlights on the chips and bright reflections on the tabletop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the pile collapse instantly due to a subtle vibration, causing the chips to slide outward in a chaotic cascade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the chips transition from rapid sliding to a steady rubbing motion, swaying and twirling before coming to rest in a scattered pile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014765740372240543 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264765739440918 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014765740372240543, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014765740372240543, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04895943030714989, + 0.03130396828055382, + 0.019879011437296867, + 0.05947335064411163, + 0.08129633218050003, + 0.09416325390338898, + 0.15995199978351593, + 0.09706251323223114, + 0.0804581567645073, + 0.3274519741535187 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014765740372240543 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a static, high-angle close-up of a pile of poker chips on a dark, polished wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the poker chips matte with slightly worn edges and arranged in a red, white, and blue pattern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does warm overhead lighting create sharp, mirror-like highlights on the chips and bright reflections on the tabletop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the pile collapse instantly due to a subtle vibration, causing the chips to slide outward in a chaotic cascade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the chips transition from rapid sliding to a steady rubbing motion, swaying and twirling before coming to rest in a scattered pile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.25211888551712036 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5021188259124756 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.25211888551712036, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.25211888551712036, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07415793091058731, + 0.040146611630916595, + 0.03516280651092529, + 0.07399610430002213, + 0.2965298593044281, + 0.05359233543276787, + 0.2321142703294754, + 0.055693820118904114, + 0.022696703672409058, + 0.11590957641601562 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.25211888551712036 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a static, high-angle close-up of a pile of poker chips on a dark, polished wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the poker chips matte with slightly worn edges and arranged in a red, white, and blue pattern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does warm overhead lighting create sharp, mirror-like highlights on the chips and bright reflections on the tabletop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the pile collapse instantly due to a subtle vibration, causing the chips to slide outward in a chaotic cascade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the chips transition from rapid sliding to a steady rubbing motion, swaying and twirling before coming to rest in a scattered pile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002828052267432213 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877828121185303 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002828052267432213, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002828052267432213, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09601492434740067, + 0.02826281078159809, + 0.021570170298218727, + 0.04812280088663101, + 0.06036316603422165, + 0.08239101618528366, + 0.5185893177986145, + 0.04076780751347542, + 0.049934931099414825, + 0.05398304760456085 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002828052267432213 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a static, high-angle close-up of a pile of poker chips on a dark, polished wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the poker chips matte with slightly worn edges and arranged in a red, white, and blue pattern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does warm overhead lighting create sharp, mirror-like highlights on the chips and bright reflections on the tabletop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the pile collapse instantly due to a subtle vibration, causing the chips to slide outward in a chaotic cascade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the chips transition from rapid sliding to a steady rubbing motion, swaying and twirling before coming to rest in a scattered pile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06203405559062958 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120341300964355 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06203405559062958, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06203405559062958, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04146412014961243, + 0.012801723554730415, + 0.013598384335637093, + 0.04383192956447601, + 0.6472557783126831, + 0.07035789638757706, + 0.04623554274439812, + 0.060510896146297455, + 0.008851394057273865, + 0.05509230121970177 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06203405559062958 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a static, high-angle close-up of a pile of poker chips on a dark, polished wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the poker chips matte with slightly worn edges and arranged in a red, white, and blue pattern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does warm overhead lighting create sharp, mirror-like highlights on the chips and bright reflections on the tabletop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the pile collapse instantly due to a subtle vibration, causing the chips to slide outward in a chaotic cascade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the chips transition from rapid sliding to a steady rubbing motion, swaying and twirling before coming to rest in a scattered pile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02979542873799801 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5297954082489014 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02979542873799801, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02979542873799801, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06378597766160965, + 0.02303759939968586, + 0.024985481053590775, + 0.07058244198560715, + 0.08954358100891113, + 0.11283168941736221, + 0.054350391030311584, + 0.0701724961400032, + 0.12326240539550781, + 0.36744794249534607 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02979542873799801 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_4/index_tensor([6969, 6969])_group_4_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_4/index_tensor([6969, 6969])_group_4_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..4d5dd729ce80d021596a6fca2f12fbaf66212aee --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_4/index_tensor([6969, 6969])_group_4_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "In dramatic graphic novel style, a static, slightly low-angled medium shot immerses the viewer in a dense forest of distinctive square-stemmed bamboo during a fierce thunderstorm. The scene is defined by extreme black and white contrast, with intermittent bursts of lightning as the primary light source. Each bright white flash momentarily illuminates the bamboo stalks, revealing their sharply defined geometric edges and a deep, saturated emerald green, smoothed and reflective by the rain, before the woods return to near-total darkness. These flashes cast stark, high-contrast, inky black shadows, sharply delineating the angular shapes of the stems against the muddy, puddled ground. Thick, slanting rain pummels the woods relentlessly, whipping the long, spear-shaped leaves into a chaotic frenzy, trembling and flapping violently in the downpour. The overall image conveys a tense and powerful atmosphere, capturing a raw, elemental moment of conflict, contrasting with the stylized, high-impact aesthetic of the dark comic book panels.", + "seed": 8819, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_4/index_6969_seed_8819_dp_8_rank_16_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.05901923393830657, + "vlm_logprob": -0.05901923393830657, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.35, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.05901923393830657, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a dramatic graphic novel or dark comic book aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the bamboo stalks depicted with distinctive square stems and sharp geometric edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by intermittent bursts of lightning acting as the primary light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the bamboo stalks appear deep emerald green, smoothed and reflective due to rain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the long, spear-shaped leaves shown whipping chaotically in thick, slanting rain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04979154095053673 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0497915744781494 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04979154095053673, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04979154095053673, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.31744229793548584, + 0.057061050087213516, + 0.04601873457431793, + 0.03869915008544922, + 0.09252579510211945, + 0.252838134765625, + 0.09858876466751099, + 0.013540390878915787, + 0.022526685148477554, + 0.060758981853723526 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04979154095053673 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a dramatic graphic novel or dark comic book aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the bamboo stalks depicted with distinctive square stems and sharp geometric edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by intermittent bursts of lightning acting as the primary light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the bamboo stalks appear deep emerald green, smoothed and reflective due to rain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the long, spear-shaped leaves shown whipping chaotically in thick, slanting rain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11292755603790283 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2379274368286133 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11292755603790283, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11292755603790283, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2590288817882538, + 0.07987810671329498, + 0.08845259249210358, + 0.05895574763417244, + 0.06405947357416153, + 0.17775803804397583, + 0.05205830559134483, + 0.03858558461070061, + 0.08183760941028595, + 0.09938564151525497 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11292755603790283 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a dramatic graphic novel or dark comic book aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the bamboo stalks depicted with distinctive square stems and sharp geometric edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by intermittent bursts of lightning acting as the primary light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the bamboo stalks appear deep emerald green, smoothed and reflective due to rain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the long, spear-shaped leaves shown whipping chaotically in thick, slanting rain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1129331961274147 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2379331588745117 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1129331961274147, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1129331961274147, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15830177068710327, + 0.07280290871858597, + 0.06266942620277405, + 0.024463914334774017, + 0.09887014329433441, + 0.4746548533439636, + 0.04101969301700592, + 0.0178777277469635, + 0.01677774265408516, + 0.03256184235215187 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1129331961274147 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a dramatic graphic novel or dark comic book aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the bamboo stalks depicted with distinctive square stems and sharp geometric edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by intermittent bursts of lightning acting as the primary light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the bamboo stalks appear deep emerald green, smoothed and reflective due to rain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the long, spear-shaped leaves shown whipping chaotically in thick, slanting rain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014195299707353115 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264195442199707 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014195299707353115, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014195299707353115, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1570299118757248, + 0.09806138277053833, + 0.08525091409683228, + 0.06978467106819153, + 0.07091427594423294, + 0.28038156032562256, + 0.09452634304761887, + 0.03575441986322403, + 0.04174718260765076, + 0.06654936075210571 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014195299707353115 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a dramatic graphic novel or dark comic book aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the bamboo stalks depicted with distinctive square stems and sharp geometric edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by intermittent bursts of lightning acting as the primary light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the bamboo stalks appear deep emerald green, smoothed and reflective due to rain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the long, spear-shaped leaves shown whipping chaotically in thick, slanting rain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005248576868325472 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255248546600342 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005248576868325472, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005248576868325472, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17242811620235443, + 0.1395285576581955, + 0.29064440727233887, + 0.04299987107515335, + 0.02402494288980961, + 0.1444188505411148, + 0.02663356438279152, + 0.06311493366956711, + 0.057809021323919296, + 0.03839769586920738 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005248576868325472 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In dramatic graphic novel style, a static, slightly low-angled medium shot immerses the viewer in a dense forest of distinctive square-stemmed bamboo during a fierce thunderstorm. The scene is defined by extreme black and white contrast, with intermittent bursts of lightning as the primary light source. Each bright white flash momentarily illuminates the bamboo stalks, revealing their sharply defined geometric edges and a deep, saturated emerald green, smoothed and reflective by the rain, before the woods return to near-total darkness. These flashes cast stark, high-contrast, inky black shadows, sharply delineating the angular shapes of the stems against the muddy, puddled ground. Thick, slanting rain pummels the woods relentlessly, whipping the long, spear-shaped leaves into a chaotic frenzy, trembling and flapping violently in the downpour. The overall image conveys a tense and powerful atmosphere, capturing a raw, elemental moment of conflict, contrasting with the stylized, high-impact aesthetic of the dark comic book panels.", + "seed": 8820, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_4/index_6969_seed_8820_dp_8_rank_16_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.05315862274728715, + "vlm_logprob": -0.05315862274728715, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.4, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.05315862274728715, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a dramatic graphic novel or dark comic book aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the bamboo stalks depicted with distinctive square stems and sharp geometric edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by intermittent bursts of lightning acting as the primary light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the bamboo stalks appear deep emerald green, smoothed and reflective due to rain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the long, spear-shaped leaves shown whipping chaotically in thick, slanting rain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07984443008899689 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5798444747924805 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07984443008899689, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07984443008899689, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2745651304721832, + 0.051025617867708206, + 0.06304016709327698, + 0.13740567862987518, + 0.0676727220416069, + 0.08878930658102036, + 0.15245555341243744, + 0.09928444772958755, + 0.021091695874929428, + 0.04466957598924637 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07984443008899689 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a dramatic graphic novel or dark comic book aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the bamboo stalks depicted with distinctive square stems and sharp geometric edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by intermittent bursts of lightning acting as the primary light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the bamboo stalks appear deep emerald green, smoothed and reflective due to rain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the long, spear-shaped leaves shown whipping chaotically in thick, slanting rain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11292222887277603 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.237922191619873 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11292222887277603, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11292222887277603, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3305251896381378, + 0.07466355711221695, + 0.08825134485960007, + 0.06375527381896973, + 0.07614606618881226, + 0.10327260941267014, + 0.11556580662727356, + 0.05269469693303108, + 0.025435959920287132, + 0.06968951225280762 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11292222887277603 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a dramatic graphic novel or dark comic book aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the bamboo stalks depicted with distinctive square stems and sharp geometric edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by intermittent bursts of lightning acting as the primary light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the bamboo stalks appear deep emerald green, smoothed and reflective due to rain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the long, spear-shaped leaves shown whipping chaotically in thick, slanting rain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04306991025805473 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168069839477539 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04306991025805473, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04306991025805473, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16706611216068268, + 0.04690328985452652, + 0.046687498688697815, + 0.25823506712913513, + 0.04809930548071861, + 0.0866798609495163, + 0.2315206676721573, + 0.059386637061834335, + 0.02894306741654873, + 0.026478491723537445 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04306991025805473 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a dramatic graphic novel or dark comic book aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the bamboo stalks depicted with distinctive square stems and sharp geometric edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by intermittent bursts of lightning acting as the primary light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the bamboo stalks appear deep emerald green, smoothed and reflective due to rain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the long, spear-shaped leaves shown whipping chaotically in thick, slanting rain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026343408972024918 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.65134334564209 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026343408972024918, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026343408972024918, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.6611499190330505, + 0.041032932698726654, + 0.05232198163866997, + 0.05202362686395645, + 0.019079923629760742, + 0.06075596064329147, + 0.05957090109586716, + 0.028781317174434662, + 0.008888453245162964, + 0.016394995152950287 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026343408972024918 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a dramatic graphic novel or dark comic book aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the bamboo stalks depicted with distinctive square stems and sharp geometric edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by intermittent bursts of lightning acting as the primary light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the bamboo stalks appear deep emerald green, smoothed and reflective due to rain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the long, spear-shaped leaves shown whipping chaotically in thick, slanting rain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036131355445832014 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628612995147705 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036131355445832014, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036131355445832014, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.49402496218681335, + 0.02989276312291622, + 0.036750685423612595, + 0.02764023095369339, + 0.027993613854050636, + 0.14397893846035004, + 0.15220312774181366, + 0.04543997719883919, + 0.0262971892952919, + 0.01577850617468357 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036131355445832014 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In dramatic graphic novel style, a static, slightly low-angled medium shot immerses the viewer in a dense forest of distinctive square-stemmed bamboo during a fierce thunderstorm. The scene is defined by extreme black and white contrast, with intermittent bursts of lightning as the primary light source. Each bright white flash momentarily illuminates the bamboo stalks, revealing their sharply defined geometric edges and a deep, saturated emerald green, smoothed and reflective by the rain, before the woods return to near-total darkness. These flashes cast stark, high-contrast, inky black shadows, sharply delineating the angular shapes of the stems against the muddy, puddled ground. Thick, slanting rain pummels the woods relentlessly, whipping the long, spear-shaped leaves into a chaotic frenzy, trembling and flapping violently in the downpour. The overall image conveys a tense and powerful atmosphere, capturing a raw, elemental moment of conflict, contrasting with the stylized, high-impact aesthetic of the dark comic book panels.", + "seed": 8821, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_4/index_6969_seed_8821_dp_9_rank_18_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.03293809602037072, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03293809602037072, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.65, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03293809602037072, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a dramatic graphic novel or dark comic book aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the bamboo stalks depicted with distinctive square stems and sharp geometric edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by intermittent bursts of lightning acting as the primary light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the bamboo stalks appear deep emerald green, smoothed and reflective due to rain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the long, spear-shaped leaves shown whipping chaotically in thick, slanting rain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016873136162757874 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141873359680176 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016873136162757874, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016873136162757874, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1964273899793625, + 0.10568758100271225, + 0.032691627740859985, + 0.056753963232040405, + 0.04755067080259323, + 0.1908404678106308, + 0.04351545125246048, + 0.043772317469120026, + 0.1078992411494255, + 0.17486131191253662 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016873136162757874 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a dramatic graphic novel or dark comic book aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the bamboo stalks depicted with distinctive square stems and sharp geometric edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by intermittent bursts of lightning acting as the primary light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the bamboo stalks appear deep emerald green, smoothed and reflective due to rain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the long, spear-shaped leaves shown whipping chaotically in thick, slanting rain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05496162921190262 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929961681365967 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05496162921190262, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05496162921190262, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07453790307044983, + 0.09889635443687439, + 0.0603080578148365, + 0.10172668844461441, + 0.02791994996368885, + 0.0519862025976181, + 0.060521937906742096, + 0.03645918518304825, + 0.19136667251586914, + 0.29627707600593567 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05496162921190262 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a dramatic graphic novel or dark comic book aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the bamboo stalks depicted with distinctive square stems and sharp geometric edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by intermittent bursts of lightning acting as the primary light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the bamboo stalks appear deep emerald green, smoothed and reflective due to rain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the long, spear-shaped leaves shown whipping chaotically in thick, slanting rain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04306568205356598 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680657863616943 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04306568205356598, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04306568205356598, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15531010925769806, + 0.07612195611000061, + 0.11163392663002014, + 0.09960504621267319, + 0.0697958916425705, + 0.12951889634132385, + 0.04102195426821709, + 0.050083357840776443, + 0.08624600619077682, + 0.18066288530826569 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04306568205356598 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a dramatic graphic novel or dark comic book aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the bamboo stalks depicted with distinctive square stems and sharp geometric edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by intermittent bursts of lightning acting as the primary light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the bamboo stalks appear deep emerald green, smoothed and reflective due to rain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the long, spear-shaped leaves shown whipping chaotically in thick, slanting rain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04305609315633774 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168056011199951 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04305609315633774, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04305609315633774, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13749322295188904, + 0.10072173178195953, + 0.05418835207819939, + 0.1863453984260559, + 0.07775715738534927, + 0.1058996245265007, + 0.05299290269613266, + 0.06080789119005203, + 0.08162625879049301, + 0.14216752350330353 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04305609315633774 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a dramatic graphic novel or dark comic book aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the bamboo stalks depicted with distinctive square stems and sharp geometric edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by intermittent bursts of lightning acting as the primary light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the bamboo stalks appear deep emerald green, smoothed and reflective due to rain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the long, spear-shaped leaves shown whipping chaotically in thick, slanting rain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0067339395172894 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.0067338943481445 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0067339395172894, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0067339395172894, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1799926459789276, + 0.08989448845386505, + 0.06862011551856995, + 0.06114380061626434, + 0.08441749215126038, + 0.058912862092256546, + 0.10557551681995392, + 0.12553031742572784, + 0.1293054223060608, + 0.09660734981298447 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0067339395172894 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In dramatic graphic novel style, a static, slightly low-angled medium shot immerses the viewer in a dense forest of distinctive square-stemmed bamboo during a fierce thunderstorm. The scene is defined by extreme black and white contrast, with intermittent bursts of lightning as the primary light source. Each bright white flash momentarily illuminates the bamboo stalks, revealing their sharply defined geometric edges and a deep, saturated emerald green, smoothed and reflective by the rain, before the woods return to near-total darkness. These flashes cast stark, high-contrast, inky black shadows, sharply delineating the angular shapes of the stems against the muddy, puddled ground. Thick, slanting rain pummels the woods relentlessly, whipping the long, spear-shaped leaves into a chaotic frenzy, trembling and flapping violently in the downpour. The overall image conveys a tense and powerful atmosphere, capturing a raw, elemental moment of conflict, contrasting with the stylized, high-impact aesthetic of the dark comic book panels.", + "seed": 8822, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_4/index_6969_seed_8822_dp_9_rank_18_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.17970718462020158, + "vlm_logprob": -0.17970718462020158, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.2749999880790712, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.17970718462020158, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a dramatic graphic novel or dark comic book aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the bamboo stalks depicted with distinctive square stems and sharp geometric edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by intermittent bursts of lightning acting as the primary light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the bamboo stalks appear deep emerald green, smoothed and reflective due to rain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the long, spear-shaped leaves shown whipping chaotically in thick, slanting rain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4300072193145752 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.0550072193145752 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.4300072193145752, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.4300072193145752, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.33496910333633423, + 0.09805293381214142, + 0.11198429018259048, + 0.023932045325636864, + 0.028522223234176636, + 0.10509316623210907, + 0.07671493291854858, + 0.08705534785985947, + 0.014525062404572964, + 0.11915083974599838 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.4300072193145752 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a dramatic graphic novel or dark comic book aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the bamboo stalks depicted with distinctive square stems and sharp geometric edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by intermittent bursts of lightning acting as the primary light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the bamboo stalks appear deep emerald green, smoothed and reflective due to rain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the long, spear-shaped leaves shown whipping chaotically in thick, slanting rain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0890556052327156 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4640555381774902 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0890556052327156, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0890556052327156, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.514551043510437, + 0.058205559849739075, + 0.05744236707687378, + 0.042541660368442535, + 0.03925777226686478, + 0.06869726628065109, + 0.09323310852050781, + 0.05659652128815651, + 0.015223607420921326, + 0.05425107851624489 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0890556052327156 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a dramatic graphic novel or dark comic book aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the bamboo stalks depicted with distinctive square stems and sharp geometric edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by intermittent bursts of lightning acting as the primary light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the bamboo stalks appear deep emerald green, smoothed and reflective due to rain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the long, spear-shaped leaves shown whipping chaotically in thick, slanting rain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3134503960609436 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3134503364562988 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3134503960609436, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.9999999403953552, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3134503960609436, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4290328025817871, + 0.056350093334913254, + 0.05997561663389206, + 0.020235173404216766, + 0.05085757002234459, + 0.1397000253200531, + 0.0752217024564743, + 0.03940509259700775, + 0.022520408034324646, + 0.10670154541730881 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3134503960609436 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a dramatic graphic novel or dark comic book aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the bamboo stalks depicted with distinctive square stems and sharp geometric edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by intermittent bursts of lightning acting as the primary light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the bamboo stalks appear deep emerald green, smoothed and reflective due to rain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the long, spear-shaped leaves shown whipping chaotically in thick, slanting rain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.054948315024375916 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929948329925537 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.054948315024375916, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.054948315024375916, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3522792458534241, + 0.08869007974863052, + 0.08478543907403946, + 0.013822073116898537, + 0.04951324313879013, + 0.14257895946502686, + 0.060341332107782364, + 0.037873774766922, + 0.02927549183368683, + 0.14084041118621826 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.054948315024375916 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a dramatic graphic novel or dark comic book aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the bamboo stalks depicted with distinctive square stems and sharp geometric edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by intermittent bursts of lightning acting as the primary light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the bamboo stalks appear deep emerald green, smoothed and reflective due to rain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the long, spear-shaped leaves shown whipping chaotically in thick, slanting rain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011074387468397617 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511074542999268 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011074387468397617, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011074387468397617, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.31586501002311707, + 0.09155355393886566, + 0.056915003806352615, + 0.012796452268958092, + 0.043265748769044876, + 0.0706627145409584, + 0.026028037071228027, + 0.05864058434963226, + 0.030390944331884384, + 0.29388198256492615 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011074387468397617 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_5/index_tensor([5673, 5673])_group_5_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_5/index_tensor([5673, 5673])_group_5_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..22fef077db1bba73683e098100cbb52de0412603 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_5/index_tensor([5673, 5673])_group_5_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "An epic wide-angle aerial shot, the camera slowly and gracefully orbits an ancient stone tower suspended in the twilight sky. A mythical dragon, its vast, sinuous form, circling the tower in majestic presence. Each scale, seemingly carved from sapphires and emeralds, emanates a steady, luminous bioluminescence from within, pulsing through the deep, scaly hues like breathing with every flex of its muscles. Its head, majestic and regal, bears translucent crystal horns, and gazes forth from golden eyes ablaze with ancient wisdom. The tower itself is constructed of weathered, dark gray stone, its surface covered in intricate carvings and mottled with moss. Its Gothic spire reaches up to a sky tinged with deep indigo and violet. The dragon wasn't flying at a swift speed, but rather gliding through the air with a near-weightless, leisurely grace. Its massive, membranous wings flapped only occasionally and slowly, each time silently stirring the surrounding mist. Its luminous form cast ever-shifting, shimmering reflections on the rough stone face of the ancient pagoda. The entire scene, serene and profound, exuded an awe-inspiring atmosphere of magical power and grandeur.", + "seed": 30568, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_5/index_5673_seed_30568_dp_10_rank_20_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.12231832332909107, + "vlm_logprob": -0.12231832332909107, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.625, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.12231832332909107, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a wide-angle aerial view that orbits an ancient stone tower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a mythical dragon visible with scales appearing to be made of sapphires and emeralds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the dragon glide slowly and leisurely with membranous wings that flap only occasionally?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the stone tower constructed of weathered dark gray stone with intricate carvings and moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky tinged with deep indigo and violet colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2828628122806549 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4078627824783325 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2828628122806549, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2828628122806549, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2708679139614105, + 0.06490433216094971, + 0.052672822028398514, + 0.0546000637114048, + 0.22108153998851776, + 0.019815810024738312, + 0.026331011205911636, + 0.11189131438732147, + 0.07717879861593246, + 0.10065636038780212 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2828628122806549 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a wide-angle aerial view that orbits an ancient stone tower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a mythical dragon visible with scales appearing to be made of sapphires and emeralds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the dragon glide slowly and leisurely with membranous wings that flap only occasionally?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the stone tower constructed of weathered dark gray stone with intricate carvings and moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky tinged with deep indigo and violet colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.033714234828948975 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4087142944335938 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.033714234828948975, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.033714234828948975, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.26393628120422363, + 0.06870006024837494, + 0.17035053670406342, + 0.06557431817054749, + 0.20834925770759583, + 0.026871539652347565, + 0.024347884580492973, + 0.06010166183114052, + 0.07269477099180222, + 0.03907371312379837 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.033714234828948975 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a wide-angle aerial view that orbits an ancient stone tower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a mythical dragon visible with scales appearing to be made of sapphires and emeralds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the dragon glide slowly and leisurely with membranous wings that flap only occasionally?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the stone tower constructed of weathered dark gray stone with intricate carvings and moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky tinged with deep indigo and violet colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12702348828315735 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.127023458480835 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12702348828315735, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12702348828315735, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1469763070344925, + 0.13876478374004364, + 0.1210155338048935, + 0.2860109508037567, + 0.05888857692480087, + 0.026313992217183113, + 0.041884299367666245, + 0.03304499387741089, + 0.0997748002409935, + 0.04732583090662956 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12702348828315735 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a wide-angle aerial view that orbits an ancient stone tower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a mythical dragon visible with scales appearing to be made of sapphires and emeralds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the dragon glide slowly and leisurely with membranous wings that flap only occasionally?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the stone tower constructed of weathered dark gray stone with intricate carvings and moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky tinged with deep indigo and violet colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1603669822216034 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9103670120239258 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1603669822216034, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1603669822216034, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.34249621629714966, + 0.03619126230478287, + 0.04130745679140091, + 0.06939440965652466, + 0.15742623805999756, + 0.03450493514537811, + 0.02213733270764351, + 0.0698380246758461, + 0.11141175776720047, + 0.11529237776994705 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1603669822216034 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a wide-angle aerial view that orbits an ancient stone tower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a mythical dragon visible with scales appearing to be made of sapphires and emeralds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the dragon glide slowly and leisurely with membranous wings that flap only occasionally?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the stone tower constructed of weathered dark gray stone with intricate carvings and moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky tinged with deep indigo and violet colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007624099031090736 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.88262414932251 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007624099031090736, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007624099031090736, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1796565055847168, + 0.050110988318920135, + 0.02394045516848564, + 0.07999871671199799, + 0.08424580097198486, + 0.0831974521279335, + 0.14726261794567108, + 0.09273412078619003, + 0.06835980713367462, + 0.19049353897571564 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007624099031090736 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An epic wide-angle aerial shot, the camera slowly and gracefully orbits an ancient stone tower suspended in the twilight sky. A mythical dragon, its vast, sinuous form, circling the tower in majestic presence. Each scale, seemingly carved from sapphires and emeralds, emanates a steady, luminous bioluminescence from within, pulsing through the deep, scaly hues like breathing with every flex of its muscles. Its head, majestic and regal, bears translucent crystal horns, and gazes forth from golden eyes ablaze with ancient wisdom. The tower itself is constructed of weathered, dark gray stone, its surface covered in intricate carvings and mottled with moss. Its Gothic spire reaches up to a sky tinged with deep indigo and violet. The dragon wasn't flying at a swift speed, but rather gliding through the air with a near-weightless, leisurely grace. Its massive, membranous wings flapped only occasionally and slowly, each time silently stirring the surrounding mist. Its luminous form cast ever-shifting, shimmering reflections on the rough stone face of the ancient pagoda. The entire scene, serene and profound, exuded an awe-inspiring atmosphere of magical power and grandeur.", + "seed": 30569, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_5/index_5673_seed_30569_dp_10_rank_20_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.6859788082540035, + "vlm_logprob": -0.6859788082540035, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.075, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.6859788082540035, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a wide-angle aerial view that orbits an ancient stone tower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a mythical dragon visible with scales appearing to be made of sapphires and emeralds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the dragon glide slowly and leisurely with membranous wings that flap only occasionally?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the stone tower constructed of weathered dark gray stone with intricate carvings and moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky tinged with deep indigo and violet colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812252998352051 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06225306913256645 + ], + "logprob_reward": -2.812252998352051, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -2.812252998352051, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0526864267885685, + 0.01442747749388218, + 0.01946371980011463, + 0.010163385421037674, + 0.021434012800455093, + 0.011922485195100307, + 0.8268105983734131, + 0.006710261572152376, + 0.024789562448859215, + 0.011592129245400429 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -2.812252998352051 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a wide-angle aerial view that orbits an ancient stone tower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a mythical dragon visible with scales appearing to be made of sapphires and emeralds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the dragon glide slowly and leisurely with membranous wings that flap only occasionally?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the stone tower constructed of weathered dark gray stone with intricate carvings and moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky tinged with deep indigo and violet colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0621454156935215 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812145471572876 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0621454156935215, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0621454156935215, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07964983582496643, + 0.010527652688324451, + 0.025639168918132782, + 0.009048188105225563, + 0.02740531601011753, + 0.015388540923595428, + 0.7741028666496277, + 0.007355362642556429, + 0.0357760414481163, + 0.015107069164514542 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0621454156935215 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a wide-angle aerial view that orbits an ancient stone tower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a mythical dragon visible with scales appearing to be made of sapphires and emeralds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the dragon glide slowly and leisurely with membranous wings that flap only occasionally?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the stone tower constructed of weathered dark gray stone with intricate carvings and moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky tinged with deep indigo and violet colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.31349727511405945 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3134973049163818 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.31349727511405945, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.31349727511405945, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22226566076278687, + 0.07990404218435287, + 0.07156552374362946, + 0.11195721477270126, + 0.03813154250383377, + 0.017769841477274895, + 0.3385816216468811, + 0.011544211767613888, + 0.038589030504226685, + 0.06969132274389267 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.31349727511405945 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a wide-angle aerial view that orbits an ancient stone tower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a mythical dragon visible with scales appearing to be made of sapphires and emeralds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the dragon glide slowly and leisurely with membranous wings that flap only occasionally?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the stone tower constructed of weathered dark gray stone with intricate carvings and moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky tinged with deep indigo and violet colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17994950711727142 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8049495220184326 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17994950711727142, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17994950711727142, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0290615763515234, + 0.028311651200056076, + 0.01234844233840704, + 0.015514751896262169, + 0.018782760947942734, + 0.01226152665913105, + 0.8224291205406189, + 0.008266421966254711, + 0.03309715539216995, + 0.01992669142782688 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17994950711727142 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a wide-angle aerial view that orbits an ancient stone tower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a mythical dragon visible with scales appearing to be made of sapphires and emeralds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the dragon glide slowly and leisurely with membranous wings that flap only occasionally?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the stone tower constructed of weathered dark gray stone with intricate carvings and moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky tinged with deep indigo and violet colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06204884499311447 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.81204891204834 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06204884499311447, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06204884499311447, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.589059054851532, + 0.01165600586682558, + 0.010898197069764137, + 0.006420472636818886, + 0.020558997988700867, + 0.007330886088311672, + 0.31516033411026, + 0.0036476049572229385, + 0.027454841881990433, + 0.007813544943928719 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06204884499311447 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An epic wide-angle aerial shot, the camera slowly and gracefully orbits an ancient stone tower suspended in the twilight sky. A mythical dragon, its vast, sinuous form, circling the tower in majestic presence. Each scale, seemingly carved from sapphires and emeralds, emanates a steady, luminous bioluminescence from within, pulsing through the deep, scaly hues like breathing with every flex of its muscles. Its head, majestic and regal, bears translucent crystal horns, and gazes forth from golden eyes ablaze with ancient wisdom. The tower itself is constructed of weathered, dark gray stone, its surface covered in intricate carvings and mottled with moss. Its Gothic spire reaches up to a sky tinged with deep indigo and violet. The dragon wasn't flying at a swift speed, but rather gliding through the air with a near-weightless, leisurely grace. Its massive, membranous wings flapped only occasionally and slowly, each time silently stirring the surrounding mist. Its luminous form cast ever-shifting, shimmering reflections on the rough stone face of the ancient pagoda. The entire scene, serene and profound, exuded an awe-inspiring atmosphere of magical power and grandeur.", + "seed": 30570, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_5/index_5673_seed_30570_dp_11_rank_22_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.10162054272368551, + "vlm_logprob": -0.10162054272368551, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.95, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.10162054272368551, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a wide-angle aerial view that orbits an ancient stone tower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a mythical dragon visible with scales appearing to be made of sapphires and emeralds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the dragon glide slowly and leisurely with membranous wings that flap only occasionally?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the stone tower constructed of weathered dark gray stone with intricate carvings and moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky tinged with deep indigo and violet colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.31401747465133667 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3140175342559814 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.31401747465133667, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.31401747465133667, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18326589465141296, + 0.06662245839834213, + 0.0459974929690361, + 0.09006119519472122, + 0.1590586155653, + 0.026638559997081757, + 0.2240995317697525, + 0.08433999866247177, + 0.05394700914621353, + 0.06596922129392624 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.31401747465133667 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a wide-angle aerial view that orbits an ancient stone tower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a mythical dragon visible with scales appearing to be made of sapphires and emeralds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the dragon glide slowly and leisurely with membranous wings that flap only occasionally?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the stone tower constructed of weathered dark gray stone with intricate carvings and moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky tinged with deep indigo and violet colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029807809740304947 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298078060150146 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029807809740304947, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029807809740304947, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.054745499044656754, + 0.03977957367897034, + 0.06552427262067795, + 0.08620593696832657, + 0.09391232579946518, + 0.029990551993250847, + 0.48006123304367065, + 0.04024564474821091, + 0.07134700566530228, + 0.03818802908062935 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029807809740304947 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a wide-angle aerial view that orbits an ancient stone tower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a mythical dragon visible with scales appearing to be made of sapphires and emeralds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the dragon glide slowly and leisurely with membranous wings that flap only occasionally?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the stone tower constructed of weathered dark gray stone with intricate carvings and moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky tinged with deep indigo and violet colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06999891996383667 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6949989795684814 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06999891996383667, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06999891996383667, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03517858311533928, + 0.03549904003739357, + 0.05704059824347496, + 0.1722123622894287, + 0.21217775344848633, + 0.08256921917200089, + 0.09742265939712524, + 0.07269792258739471, + 0.1558900773525238, + 0.07931176573038101 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06999891996383667 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a wide-angle aerial view that orbits an ancient stone tower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a mythical dragon visible with scales appearing to be made of sapphires and emeralds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the dragon glide slowly and leisurely with membranous wings that flap only occasionally?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the stone tower constructed of weathered dark gray stone with intricate carvings and moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky tinged with deep indigo and violet colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08903313428163528 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4640331268310547 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08903313428163528, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08903313428163528, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21374039351940155, + 0.0928260013461113, + 0.1712217479944229, + 0.03103153221309185, + 0.1340337097644806, + 0.04269466549158096, + 0.20859748125076294, + 0.049779802560806274, + 0.025637052953243256, + 0.030437566339969635 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08903313428163528 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a wide-angle aerial view that orbits an ancient stone tower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a mythical dragon visible with scales appearing to be made of sapphires and emeralds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the dragon glide slowly and leisurely with membranous wings that flap only occasionally?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the stone tower constructed of weathered dark gray stone with intricate carvings and moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky tinged with deep indigo and violet colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005245374981313944 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255245208740234 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005245374981313944, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005245374981313944, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07885219156742096, + 0.09567607939243317, + 0.12064927816390991, + 0.06049759313464165, + 0.36420148611068726, + 0.021302981302142143, + 0.153312548995018, + 0.04739455133676529, + 0.035732828080654144, + 0.022380406036973 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005245374981313944 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An epic wide-angle aerial shot, the camera slowly and gracefully orbits an ancient stone tower suspended in the twilight sky. A mythical dragon, its vast, sinuous form, circling the tower in majestic presence. Each scale, seemingly carved from sapphires and emeralds, emanates a steady, luminous bioluminescence from within, pulsing through the deep, scaly hues like breathing with every flex of its muscles. Its head, majestic and regal, bears translucent crystal horns, and gazes forth from golden eyes ablaze with ancient wisdom. The tower itself is constructed of weathered, dark gray stone, its surface covered in intricate carvings and mottled with moss. Its Gothic spire reaches up to a sky tinged with deep indigo and violet. The dragon wasn't flying at a swift speed, but rather gliding through the air with a near-weightless, leisurely grace. Its massive, membranous wings flapped only occasionally and slowly, each time silently stirring the surrounding mist. Its luminous form cast ever-shifting, shimmering reflections on the rough stone face of the ancient pagoda. The entire scene, serene and profound, exuded an awe-inspiring atmosphere of magical power and grandeur.", + "seed": 30571, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_5/index_5673_seed_30571_dp_11_rank_22_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.09060795493423938, + "vlm_logprob": -0.09060795493423938, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.775, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.09060795493423938, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a wide-angle aerial view that orbits an ancient stone tower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a mythical dragon visible with scales appearing to be made of sapphires and emeralds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the dragon glide slowly and leisurely with membranous wings that flap only occasionally?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the stone tower constructed of weathered dark gray stone with intricate carvings and moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky tinged with deep indigo and violet colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.25369396805763245 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.50369393825531 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.25369396805763245, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.25369396805763245, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.241408571600914, + 0.17656077444553375, + 0.09084508568048477, + 0.10996938496828079, + 0.12038511782884598, + 0.04859108105301857, + 0.08215542882680893, + 0.032089684158563614, + 0.02330654300749302, + 0.0746883675456047 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.25369396805763245 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a wide-angle aerial view that orbits an ancient stone tower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a mythical dragon visible with scales appearing to be made of sapphires and emeralds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the dragon glide slowly and leisurely with membranous wings that flap only occasionally?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the stone tower constructed of weathered dark gray stone with intricate carvings and moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky tinged with deep indigo and violet colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029819034039974213 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298190116882324 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029819034039974213, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029819034039974213, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.32860684394836426, + 0.12431976944208145, + 0.05994488298892975, + 0.0869741290807724, + 0.033466190099716187, + 0.04458361119031906, + 0.06345535814762115, + 0.0794992744922638, + 0.10745809972286224, + 0.0716918483376503 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029819034039974213 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a wide-angle aerial view that orbits an ancient stone tower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a mythical dragon visible with scales appearing to be made of sapphires and emeralds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the dragon glide slowly and leisurely with membranous wings that flap only occasionally?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the stone tower constructed of weathered dark gray stone with intricate carvings and moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky tinged with deep indigo and violet colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10029953718185425 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.350299596786499 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10029953718185425, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10029953718185425, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1126837357878685, + 0.07726192474365234, + 0.13128457963466644, + 0.12275717407464981, + 0.12097325176000595, + 0.06341109424829483, + 0.15055789053440094, + 0.06377541273832321, + 0.06296391785144806, + 0.0943310558795929 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10029953718185425 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a wide-angle aerial view that orbits an ancient stone tower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a mythical dragon visible with scales appearing to be made of sapphires and emeralds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the dragon glide slowly and leisurely with membranous wings that flap only occasionally?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the stone tower constructed of weathered dark gray stone with intricate carvings and moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky tinged with deep indigo and violet colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04865613952279091 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486562252044678 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04865613952279091, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04865613952279091, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3150750398635864, + 0.2521694600582123, + 0.05874379724264145, + 0.049691420048475266, + 0.09865802526473999, + 0.025112994015216827, + 0.0340760238468647, + 0.064968042075634, + 0.055825214833021164, + 0.045679982751607895 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04865613952279091 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a wide-angle aerial view that orbits an ancient stone tower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a mythical dragon visible with scales appearing to be made of sapphires and emeralds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the dragon glide slowly and leisurely with membranous wings that flap only occasionally?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the stone tower constructed of weathered dark gray stone with intricate carvings and moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky tinged with deep indigo and violet colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020571095868945122 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895570993423462 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020571095868945122, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020571095868945122, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1887458711862564, + 0.1172749400138855, + 0.04990974813699722, + 0.07969341427087784, + 0.07228431105613708, + 0.07444585859775543, + 0.07504662126302719, + 0.08161642402410507, + 0.0433853343129158, + 0.21759751439094543 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020571095868945122 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_6/index_tensor([804, 804])_group_6_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_6/index_tensor([804, 804])_group_6_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..12d3b7b223d86cf12f0fc28ea977e6b7731210bc --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_6/index_tensor([804, 804])_group_6_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "An unwavering, static wide-angle shot captures a dramatic scene rendered entirely in the iconic Ukiyo-e woodcut style. The mountainous landscape, its rolling forms defined by simple, elegant lines and a flattened perspective, is completely covered in thick, stylized kudzu foliage. Each leaf is a unique heart-shaped form, with a bold black outline and flat planes of soft green and earthy brown, creating a richly textured graphic tapestry across the mountain. From the edge of the frame, a stylized flame advances relentlessly; the flames are not real, but depicted as vibrant, flat orange and yellow shapes, each lick and curl defined by a thick, inky black outline, devouring the foliage with artistic ferocity. As the fire spreads, billowing black smoke rises into the pale ochre sky, revealing solid, swirling gray and black forms with identical outlines, resembling the dynamic, stylized waves of a classic print. The camera's unwavering gaze transforms the destructive events into a living, moving photograph, the fire's relentless advance and the rising plumes of smoke creating a mesmerizing and powerful atmosphere of controlled, beautiful disaster.", + "seed": 22852, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_6/index_804_seed_22852_dp_12_rank_24_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.025427120504900813, + "vlm_logprob": -0.025427120504900813, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.65, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.025427120504900813, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in the Ukiyo-e woodcut style with bold black outlines and flat planes of color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a mountainous landscape covered in thick, stylized heart-shaped kudzu foliage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a stylized flame advancing from the edge of the frame, depicted as vibrant flat orange and yellow shapes with black outlines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is billowing black smoke rising into a pale ochre sky, resembling stylized waves with solid gray and black forms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static and wide-angle throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0034920922480523586 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.7534918785095215 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0034920922480523586, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0034920922480523586, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4052676856517792, + 0.05046045035123825, + 0.035773877054452896, + 0.06798167526721954, + 0.1390264630317688, + 0.13297918438911438, + 0.014108632691204548, + 0.029900891706347466, + 0.10976175218820572, + 0.01473940722644329 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0034920922480523586 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in the Ukiyo-e woodcut style with bold black outlines and flat planes of color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a mountainous landscape covered in thick, stylized heart-shaped kudzu foliage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a stylized flame advancing from the edge of the frame, depicted as vibrant flat orange and yellow shapes with black outlines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is billowing black smoke rising into a pale ochre sky, resembling stylized waves with solid gray and black forms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static and wide-angle throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0022027057129889727 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.12720251083374 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0022027057129889727, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0022027057129889727, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13380785286426544, + 0.04834672436118126, + 0.10342441499233246, + 0.07427170127630234, + 0.09288233518600464, + 0.23743121325969696, + 0.07681584358215332, + 0.07330205291509628, + 0.12057773023843765, + 0.039140086621046066 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0022027057129889727 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in the Ukiyo-e woodcut style with bold black outlines and flat planes of color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a mountainous landscape covered in thick, stylized heart-shaped kudzu foliage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a stylized flame advancing from the edge of the frame, depicted as vibrant flat orange and yellow shapes with black outlines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is billowing black smoke rising into a pale ochre sky, resembling stylized waves with solid gray and black forms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static and wide-angle throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008637331426143646 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758637428283691 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008637331426143646, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008637331426143646, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22864790260791779, + 0.03661457821726799, + 0.027658438310027122, + 0.3585839867591858, + 0.11391597986221313, + 0.04134752228856087, + 0.01746000163257122, + 0.06153111904859543, + 0.09432005882263184, + 0.019920479506254196 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008637331426143646 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in the Ukiyo-e woodcut style with bold black outlines and flat planes of color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a mountainous landscape covered in thick, stylized heart-shaped kudzu foliage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a stylized flame advancing from the edge of the frame, depicted as vibrant flat orange and yellow shapes with black outlines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is billowing black smoke rising into a pale ochre sky, resembling stylized waves with solid gray and black forms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static and wide-angle throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012532292865216732 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.3875322341918945 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012532292865216732, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012532292865216732, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4236791729927063, + 0.03273814544081688, + 0.045607853680849075, + 0.09370822459459305, + 0.08630060404539108, + 0.029579829424619675, + 0.013862618245184422, + 0.03514385223388672, + 0.22199229896068573, + 0.01738741248846054 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012532292865216732 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in the Ukiyo-e woodcut style with bold black outlines and flat planes of color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a mountainous landscape covered in thick, stylized heart-shaped kudzu foliage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a stylized flame advancing from the edge of the frame, depicted as vibrant flat orange and yellow shapes with black outlines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is billowing black smoke rising into a pale ochre sky, resembling stylized waves with solid gray and black forms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static and wide-angle throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10027118027210236 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.350271224975586 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10027118027210236, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10027118027210236, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19826170802116394, + 0.27353253960609436, + 0.03648358955979347, + 0.06569673866033554, + 0.06819947808980942, + 0.21941380202770233, + 0.017298080027103424, + 0.06896436214447021, + 0.03483840078115463, + 0.017311347648501396 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10027118027210236 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An unwavering, static wide-angle shot captures a dramatic scene rendered entirely in the iconic Ukiyo-e woodcut style. The mountainous landscape, its rolling forms defined by simple, elegant lines and a flattened perspective, is completely covered in thick, stylized kudzu foliage. Each leaf is a unique heart-shaped form, with a bold black outline and flat planes of soft green and earthy brown, creating a richly textured graphic tapestry across the mountain. From the edge of the frame, a stylized flame advances relentlessly; the flames are not real, but depicted as vibrant, flat orange and yellow shapes, each lick and curl defined by a thick, inky black outline, devouring the foliage with artistic ferocity. As the fire spreads, billowing black smoke rises into the pale ochre sky, revealing solid, swirling gray and black forms with identical outlines, resembling the dynamic, stylized waves of a classic print. The camera's unwavering gaze transforms the destructive events into a living, moving photograph, the fire's relentless advance and the rising plumes of smoke creating a mesmerizing and powerful atmosphere of controlled, beautiful disaster.", + "seed": 22853, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_6/index_804_seed_22853_dp_12_rank_24_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.015331917582079769, + "vlm_logprob": -0.015331917582079769, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.725, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.015331917582079769, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in the Ukiyo-e woodcut style with bold black outlines and flat planes of color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a mountainous landscape covered in thick, stylized heart-shaped kudzu foliage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a stylized flame advancing from the edge of the frame, depicted as vibrant flat orange and yellow shapes with black outlines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is billowing black smoke rising into a pale ochre sky, resembling stylized waves with solid gray and black forms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static and wide-angle throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0031572754960507154 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.878157138824463 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0031572754960507154, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0031572754960507154, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05514349043369293, + 0.03147256001830101, + 0.024801097810268402, + 0.5819101333618164, + 0.05478744953870773, + 0.01816798374056816, + 0.06788477301597595, + 0.008159270510077477, + 0.04479009658098221, + 0.11288309842348099 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0031572754960507154 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in the Ukiyo-e woodcut style with bold black outlines and flat planes of color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a mountainous landscape covered in thick, stylized heart-shaped kudzu foliage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a stylized flame advancing from the edge of the frame, depicted as vibrant flat orange and yellow shapes with black outlines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is billowing black smoke rising into a pale ochre sky, resembling stylized waves with solid gray and black forms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static and wide-angle throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002496223896741867 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002496242523193 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002496223896741867, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002496223896741867, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08258134871721268, + 0.06685519963502884, + 0.06025606766343117, + 0.3025679886341095, + 0.028782019391655922, + 0.01638639159500599, + 0.135433629155159, + 0.03548584505915642, + 0.02547583356499672, + 0.24617570638656616 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002496223896741867 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in the Ukiyo-e woodcut style with bold black outlines and flat planes of color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a mountainous landscape covered in thick, stylized heart-shaped kudzu foliage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a stylized flame advancing from the edge of the frame, depicted as vibrant flat orange and yellow shapes with black outlines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is billowing black smoke rising into a pale ochre sky, resembling stylized waves with solid gray and black forms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static and wide-angle throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018190933391451836 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018190860748291 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018190933391451836, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018190933391451836, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05555565655231476, + 0.08632151037454605, + 0.025111230090260506, + 0.4078701436519623, + 0.06706409156322479, + 0.01682593859732151, + 0.14879612624645233, + 0.05824655666947365, + 0.06284691393375397, + 0.07136183977127075 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018190933391451836 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in the Ukiyo-e woodcut style with bold black outlines and flat planes of color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a mountainous landscape covered in thick, stylized heart-shaped kudzu foliage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a stylized flame advancing from the edge of the frame, depicted as vibrant flat orange and yellow shapes with black outlines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is billowing black smoke rising into a pale ochre sky, resembling stylized waves with solid gray and black forms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static and wide-angle throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009775505401194096 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634775638580322 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009775505401194096, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009775505401194096, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0833219513297081, + 0.0801352709531784, + 0.05980286747217178, + 0.19878442585468292, + 0.046038564294576645, + 0.04089229553937912, + 0.3558141589164734, + 0.05505523830652237, + 0.059179965406656265, + 0.020975261926651 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009775505401194096 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in the Ukiyo-e woodcut style with bold black outlines and flat planes of color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a mountainous landscape covered in thick, stylized heart-shaped kudzu foliage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a stylized flame advancing from the edge of the frame, depicted as vibrant flat orange and yellow shapes with black outlines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is billowing black smoke rising into a pale ochre sky, resembling stylized waves with solid gray and black forms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static and wide-angle throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04303964972496033 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168039560317993 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04303964972496033, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04303964972496033, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1420363038778305, + 0.16712673008441925, + 0.028696071356534958, + 0.17299196124076843, + 0.13548018038272858, + 0.0262907724827528, + 0.09710178524255753, + 0.041199345141649246, + 0.1022220253944397, + 0.08685479313135147 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04303964972496033 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An unwavering, static wide-angle shot captures a dramatic scene rendered entirely in the iconic Ukiyo-e woodcut style. The mountainous landscape, its rolling forms defined by simple, elegant lines and a flattened perspective, is completely covered in thick, stylized kudzu foliage. Each leaf is a unique heart-shaped form, with a bold black outline and flat planes of soft green and earthy brown, creating a richly textured graphic tapestry across the mountain. From the edge of the frame, a stylized flame advances relentlessly; the flames are not real, but depicted as vibrant, flat orange and yellow shapes, each lick and curl defined by a thick, inky black outline, devouring the foliage with artistic ferocity. As the fire spreads, billowing black smoke rises into the pale ochre sky, revealing solid, swirling gray and black forms with identical outlines, resembling the dynamic, stylized waves of a classic print. The camera's unwavering gaze transforms the destructive events into a living, moving photograph, the fire's relentless advance and the rising plumes of smoke creating a mesmerizing and powerful atmosphere of controlled, beautiful disaster.", + "seed": 22854, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_6/index_804_seed_22854_dp_13_rank_26_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.016304109198972582, + "vlm_logprob": -0.016304109198972582, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.825, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.016304109198972582, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in the Ukiyo-e woodcut style with bold black outlines and flat planes of color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a mountainous landscape covered in thick, stylized heart-shaped kudzu foliage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a stylized flame advancing from the edge of the frame, depicted as vibrant flat orange and yellow shapes with black outlines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is billowing black smoke rising into a pale ochre sky, resembling stylized waves with solid gray and black forms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static and wide-angle throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004279028624296188 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504279136657715 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004279028624296188, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004279028624296188, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21226516366004944, + 0.1110285148024559, + 0.09048621356487274, + 0.04091305285692215, + 0.05572183057665825, + 0.052486974745988846, + 0.06387300044298172, + 0.04215312749147415, + 0.2577577531337738, + 0.07331433892250061 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004279028624296188 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in the Ukiyo-e woodcut style with bold black outlines and flat planes of color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a mountainous landscape covered in thick, stylized heart-shaped kudzu foliage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a stylized flame advancing from the edge of the frame, depicted as vibrant flat orange and yellow shapes with black outlines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is billowing black smoke rising into a pale ochre sky, resembling stylized waves with solid gray and black forms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static and wide-angle throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0024966993369162083 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002496719360352 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0024966993369162083, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0024966993369162083, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0985247865319252, + 0.1843748390674591, + 0.08319045603275299, + 0.10546945780515671, + 0.07023965567350388, + 0.05001005902886391, + 0.1266818344593048, + 0.09768080711364746, + 0.12489858269691467, + 0.058929428458213806 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0024966993369162083 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in the Ukiyo-e woodcut style with bold black outlines and flat planes of color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a mountainous landscape covered in thick, stylized heart-shaped kudzu foliage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a stylized flame advancing from the edge of the frame, depicted as vibrant flat orange and yellow shapes with black outlines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is billowing black smoke rising into a pale ochre sky, resembling stylized waves with solid gray and black forms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static and wide-angle throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0028204445261508226 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.8778204917907715 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0028204445261508226, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0028204445261508226, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10314087569713593, + 0.19150801002979279, + 0.14613044261932373, + 0.03994685038924217, + 0.0327734611928463, + 0.03181426227092743, + 0.04620779678225517, + 0.09767613559961319, + 0.15678542852401733, + 0.15401677787303925 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0028204445261508226 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in the Ukiyo-e woodcut style with bold black outlines and flat planes of color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a mountainous landscape covered in thick, stylized heart-shaped kudzu foliage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a stylized flame advancing from the edge of the frame, depicted as vibrant flat orange and yellow shapes with black outlines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is billowing black smoke rising into a pale ochre sky, resembling stylized waves with solid gray and black forms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static and wide-angle throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02328469604253769 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773284673690796 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02328469604253769, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02328469604253769, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1470823436975479, + 0.07112623006105423, + 0.2101648449897766, + 0.06457821279764175, + 0.07893925905227661, + 0.05579126626253128, + 0.03472818434238434, + 0.1451079100370407, + 0.10434507578611374, + 0.08813677728176117 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02328469604253769 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in the Ukiyo-e woodcut style with bold black outlines and flat planes of color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a mountainous landscape covered in thick, stylized heart-shaped kudzu foliage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a stylized flame advancing from the edge of the frame, depicted as vibrant flat orange and yellow shapes with black outlines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is billowing black smoke rising into a pale ochre sky, resembling stylized waves with solid gray and black forms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static and wide-angle throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.048639677464962006 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486397743225098 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.048639677464962006, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.048639677464962006, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18151475489139557, + 0.07394623756408691, + 0.243082195520401, + 0.061282429844141006, + 0.03158067911863327, + 0.08814084529876709, + 0.04020528867840767, + 0.07701544463634491, + 0.15577779710292816, + 0.04745430871844292 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.048639677464962006 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An unwavering, static wide-angle shot captures a dramatic scene rendered entirely in the iconic Ukiyo-e woodcut style. The mountainous landscape, its rolling forms defined by simple, elegant lines and a flattened perspective, is completely covered in thick, stylized kudzu foliage. Each leaf is a unique heart-shaped form, with a bold black outline and flat planes of soft green and earthy brown, creating a richly textured graphic tapestry across the mountain. From the edge of the frame, a stylized flame advances relentlessly; the flames are not real, but depicted as vibrant, flat orange and yellow shapes, each lick and curl defined by a thick, inky black outline, devouring the foliage with artistic ferocity. As the fire spreads, billowing black smoke rises into the pale ochre sky, revealing solid, swirling gray and black forms with identical outlines, resembling the dynamic, stylized waves of a classic print. The camera's unwavering gaze transforms the destructive events into a living, moving photograph, the fire's relentless advance and the rising plumes of smoke creating a mesmerizing and powerful atmosphere of controlled, beautiful disaster.", + "seed": 22855, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_6/index_804_seed_22855_dp_13_rank_26_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.03344450772274286, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03344450772274286, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.75, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03344450772274286, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in the Ukiyo-e woodcut style with bold black outlines and flat planes of color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a mountainous landscape covered in thick, stylized heart-shaped kudzu foliage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a stylized flame advancing from the edge of the frame, depicted as vibrant flat orange and yellow shapes with black outlines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is billowing black smoke rising into a pale ochre sky, resembling stylized waves with solid gray and black forms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static and wide-angle throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01442433800548315 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.2644243240356445 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01442433800548315, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01442433800548315, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.055659208446741104, + 0.05740765109658241, + 0.03687300905585289, + 0.044466614723205566, + 0.2208891063928604, + 0.23658835887908936, + 0.22495494782924652, + 0.028027281165122986, + 0.05258939787745476, + 0.04254443943500519 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01442433800548315 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in the Ukiyo-e woodcut style with bold black outlines and flat planes of color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a mountainous landscape covered in thick, stylized heart-shaped kudzu foliage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a stylized flame advancing from the edge of the frame, depicted as vibrant flat orange and yellow shapes with black outlines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is billowing black smoke rising into a pale ochre sky, resembling stylized waves with solid gray and black forms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static and wide-angle throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0019464610377326608 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.251946449279785 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0019464610377326608, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0019464610377326608, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07407402247190475, + 0.05784233286976814, + 0.026168175041675568, + 0.020399264991283417, + 0.24789439141750336, + 0.20946502685546875, + 0.2527046501636505, + 0.02877196855843067, + 0.05336184427142143, + 0.029318347573280334 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0019464610377326608 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in the Ukiyo-e woodcut style with bold black outlines and flat planes of color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a mountainous landscape covered in thick, stylized heart-shaped kudzu foliage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a stylized flame advancing from the edge of the frame, depicted as vibrant flat orange and yellow shapes with black outlines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is billowing black smoke rising into a pale ochre sky, resembling stylized waves with solid gray and black forms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static and wide-angle throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0005626287311315536 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.50056266784668 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0005626287311315536, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0005626287311315536, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10079769790172577, + 0.07215333729982376, + 0.041257619857788086, + 0.06082877889275551, + 0.2817997932434082, + 0.10137978196144104, + 0.17993633449077606, + 0.048105426132678986, + 0.07570822536945343, + 0.03803302347660065 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0005626287311315536 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in the Ukiyo-e woodcut style with bold black outlines and flat planes of color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a mountainous landscape covered in thick, stylized heart-shaped kudzu foliage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a stylized flame advancing from the edge of the frame, depicted as vibrant flat orange and yellow shapes with black outlines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is billowing black smoke rising into a pale ochre sky, resembling stylized waves with solid gray and black forms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static and wide-angle throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023282833397388458 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773282766342163 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023282833397388458, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023282833397388458, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06382087618112564, + 0.10501176118850708, + 0.07470951229333878, + 0.10908552259206772, + 0.22160480916500092, + 0.22917762398719788, + 0.08687460422515869, + 0.031686414033174515, + 0.035447556525468826, + 0.04258134588599205 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023282833397388458 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in the Ukiyo-e woodcut style with bold black outlines and flat planes of color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a mountainous landscape covered in thick, stylized heart-shaped kudzu foliage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a stylized flame advancing from the edge of the frame, depicted as vibrant flat orange and yellow shapes with black outlines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is billowing black smoke rising into a pale ochre sky, resembling stylized waves with solid gray and black forms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static and wide-angle throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12700627744197845 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1270062923431396 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12700627744197845, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12700627744197845, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.050195224583148956, + 0.046618714928627014, + 0.05103147402405739, + 0.05951652303338051, + 0.26539531350135803, + 0.20903617143630981, + 0.2904056906700134, + 0.009015112183988094, + 0.00888023804873228, + 0.009905478917062283 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12700627744197845 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_7/index_tensor([8397, 8397])_group_7_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_7/index_tensor([8397, 8397])_group_7_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..d55cb0acc3d5d3eb7558f0ea6f74f914bb94ac33 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_7/index_tensor([8397, 8397])_group_7_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "slightly low-angle, full-body tracking shot smoothly follows a female ice skater, maintaining the perfect center of the frame as she glides across a vast, pristine ice rink. Her dark brown hair is pulled back into a sleek, tight bun, her cheeks flushed from the cold, an expression of intense, elegant concentration. She wears a stunning deep blue figure skating costume made of stretch velvet, the bodice embroidered with silver thread and shimmering sequins, capturing the light with every movement. Beneath, her muscular legs, clad in flesh-colored tights, culminate in pristine white leather skates, their smooth steel blades silently slicing through the ice. The camera moves parallel to her as she powerfully pushes off with one leg, the other extending behind her in a long, graceful glide, her arms extended for perfect balance. The setting is a vast, dark indoor arena, with powerful, cool-toned stadium spotlights shining down from above, isolating her in a pool of bright light. This high-contrast lighting casts a long, sharp, dramatic shadow extending directly onto the mirrored ice behind her, dynamically lengthening and contracting with her fluid movements, creating a powerful atmosphere of solitary focus, athleticism, and breathtaking artistry.", + "seed": 23661, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_7/index_8397_seed_23661_dp_14_rank_28_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.029146843310445546, + "vlm_logprob": -0.029146843310445546, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.125, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.029146843310445546, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle full-body tracking shot of a female ice skater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the skater wearing a deep blue velvet costume with silver embroidery and sequins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the skater have dark brown hair in a tight bun and flushed cheeks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast dark indoor arena with cool-toned spotlights creating high contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera track parallel to the skater while she glides with one leg pushing off and the other extended?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.013268977403640747 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.763268947601318 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.013268977403640747, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.013268977403640747, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13965006172657013, + 0.05617375671863556, + 0.03312359377741814, + 0.14301197230815887, + 0.07630263268947601, + 0.052865609526634216, + 0.02622494287788868, + 0.05326271802186966, + 0.031241530552506447, + 0.3881431818008423 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.013268977403640747 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle full-body tracking shot of a female ice skater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the skater wearing a deep blue velvet costume with silver embroidery and sequins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the skater have dark brown hair in a tight bun and flushed cheeks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast dark indoor arena with cool-toned spotlights creating high contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera track parallel to the skater while she glides with one leg pushing off and the other extended?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08908602595329285 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4640860557556152 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08908602595329285, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08908602595329285, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1807733178138733, + 0.07073954492807388, + 0.03199613839387894, + 0.17197100818157196, + 0.24336813390254974, + 0.0360361747443676, + 0.027895838022232056, + 0.08137647807598114, + 0.04303162544965744, + 0.11281169205904007 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08908602595329285 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle full-body tracking shot of a female ice skater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the skater wearing a deep blue velvet costume with silver embroidery and sequins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the skater have dark brown hair in a tight bun and flushed cheeks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast dark indoor arena with cool-toned spotlights creating high contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera track parallel to the skater while she glides with one leg pushing off and the other extended?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029806189239025116 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529806137084961 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029806189239025116, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029806189239025116, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.198040172457695, + 0.07477084547281265, + 0.03960274159908295, + 0.03352372720837593, + 0.12352104485034943, + 0.0737510547041893, + 0.06054617464542389, + 0.08204322308301926, + 0.02217857725918293, + 0.29202237725257874 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029806189239025116 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle full-body tracking shot of a female ice skater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the skater wearing a deep blue velvet costume with silver embroidery and sequins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the skater have dark brown hair in a tight bun and flushed cheeks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast dark indoor arena with cool-toned spotlights creating high contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera track parallel to the skater while she glides with one leg pushing off and the other extended?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007628949359059334 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882628917694092 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007628949359059334, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007628949359059334, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22820085287094116, + 0.03905002772808075, + 0.07239170372486115, + 0.07014576345682144, + 0.05855772644281387, + 0.022264737635850906, + 0.020228169858455658, + 0.19977325201034546, + 0.04503660276532173, + 0.24435116350650787 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007628949359059334 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle full-body tracking shot of a female ice skater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the skater wearing a deep blue velvet costume with silver embroidery and sequins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the skater have dark brown hair in a tight bun and flushed cheeks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast dark indoor arena with cool-toned spotlights creating high contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera track parallel to the skater while she glides with one leg pushing off and the other extended?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005944074597209692 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.13094425201416 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005944074597209692, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005944074597209692, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.29645612835884094, + 0.034474972635507584, + 0.04050866886973381, + 0.06807348877191544, + 0.05242513492703438, + 0.09298782795667648, + 0.16651369631290436, + 0.09374769032001495, + 0.013853766024112701, + 0.14095854759216309 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005944074597209692 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slightly low-angle, full-body tracking shot smoothly follows a female ice skater, maintaining the perfect center of the frame as she glides across a vast, pristine ice rink. Her dark brown hair is pulled back into a sleek, tight bun, her cheeks flushed from the cold, an expression of intense, elegant concentration. She wears a stunning deep blue figure skating costume made of stretch velvet, the bodice embroidered with silver thread and shimmering sequins, capturing the light with every movement. Beneath, her muscular legs, clad in flesh-colored tights, culminate in pristine white leather skates, their smooth steel blades silently slicing through the ice. The camera moves parallel to her as she powerfully pushes off with one leg, the other extending behind her in a long, graceful glide, her arms extended for perfect balance. The setting is a vast, dark indoor arena, with powerful, cool-toned stadium spotlights shining down from above, isolating her in a pool of bright light. This high-contrast lighting casts a long, sharp, dramatic shadow extending directly onto the mirrored ice behind her, dynamically lengthening and contracting with her fluid movements, creating a powerful atmosphere of solitary focus, athleticism, and breathtaking artistry.", + "seed": 23662, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_7/index_8397_seed_23662_dp_14_rank_28_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.04426678540185094, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04426678540185094, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.625, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04426678540185094, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle full-body tracking shot of a female ice skater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the skater wearing a deep blue velvet costume with silver embroidery and sequins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the skater have dark brown hair in a tight bun and flushed cheeks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast dark indoor arena with cool-toned spotlights creating high contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera track parallel to the skater while she glides with one leg pushing off and the other extended?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.025197908282279968 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.900197982788086 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.025197908282279968, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.025197908282279968, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18290503323078156, + 0.09794989228248596, + 0.03214104846119881, + 0.11991625279188156, + 0.23997193574905396, + 0.08388709276914597, + 0.056567031890153885, + 0.05884531885385513, + 0.02991015650331974, + 0.09790627658367157 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.025197908282279968 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle full-body tracking shot of a female ice skater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the skater wearing a deep blue velvet costume with silver embroidery and sequins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the skater have dark brown hair in a tight bun and flushed cheeks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast dark indoor arena with cool-toned spotlights creating high contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera track parallel to the skater while she glides with one leg pushing off and the other extended?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12719649076461792 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1271965503692627 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12719649076461792, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12719649076461792, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10585545748472214, + 0.1213570311665535, + 0.14523687958717346, + 0.05950440838932991, + 0.30693453550338745, + 0.050594691187143326, + 0.015175252221524715, + 0.04271472245454788, + 0.09558121860027313, + 0.057045795023441315 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12719649076461792 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle full-body tracking shot of a female ice skater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the skater wearing a deep blue velvet costume with silver embroidery and sequins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the skater have dark brown hair in a tight bun and flushed cheeks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast dark indoor arena with cool-toned spotlights creating high contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera track parallel to the skater while she glides with one leg pushing off and the other extended?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.043097883462905884 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168097972869873 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.043097883462905884, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.043097883462905884, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1552782952785492, + 0.16739773750305176, + 0.06139620393514633, + 0.0623970627784729, + 0.2978944182395935, + 0.02800770290195942, + 0.044319551438093185, + 0.053031742572784424, + 0.056020308285951614, + 0.07425692677497864 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.043097883462905884 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle full-body tracking shot of a female ice skater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the skater wearing a deep blue velvet costume with silver embroidery and sequins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the skater have dark brown hair in a tight bun and flushed cheeks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast dark indoor arena with cool-toned spotlights creating high contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera track parallel to the skater while she glides with one leg pushing off and the other extended?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02059200033545494 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895591974258423 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02059200033545494, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02059200033545494, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10425252467393875, + 0.33095860481262207, + 0.024021591991186142, + 0.04178997501730919, + 0.14035211503505707, + 0.1823550909757614, + 0.009422177448868752, + 0.03029496595263481, + 0.02588602714240551, + 0.11066696792840958 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02059200033545494 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle full-body tracking shot of a female ice skater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the skater wearing a deep blue velvet costume with silver embroidery and sequins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the skater have dark brown hair in a tight bun and flushed cheeks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast dark indoor arena with cool-toned spotlights creating high contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera track parallel to the skater while she glides with one leg pushing off and the other extended?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005249644163995981 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255249500274658 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005249644163995981, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005249644163995981, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09873691201210022, + 0.13782426714897156, + 0.10025139898061752, + 0.05422908440232277, + 0.06257357448339462, + 0.07574721425771713, + 0.05140818655490875, + 0.03908031806349754, + 0.11918094009160995, + 0.26096808910369873 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005249644163995981 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slightly low-angle, full-body tracking shot smoothly follows a female ice skater, maintaining the perfect center of the frame as she glides across a vast, pristine ice rink. Her dark brown hair is pulled back into a sleek, tight bun, her cheeks flushed from the cold, an expression of intense, elegant concentration. She wears a stunning deep blue figure skating costume made of stretch velvet, the bodice embroidered with silver thread and shimmering sequins, capturing the light with every movement. Beneath, her muscular legs, clad in flesh-colored tights, culminate in pristine white leather skates, their smooth steel blades silently slicing through the ice. The camera moves parallel to her as she powerfully pushes off with one leg, the other extending behind her in a long, graceful glide, her arms extended for perfect balance. The setting is a vast, dark indoor arena, with powerful, cool-toned stadium spotlights shining down from above, isolating her in a pool of bright light. This high-contrast lighting casts a long, sharp, dramatic shadow extending directly onto the mirrored ice behind her, dynamically lengthening and contracting with her fluid movements, creating a powerful atmosphere of solitary focus, athleticism, and breathtaking artistry.", + "seed": 23663, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_7/index_8397_seed_23663_dp_15_rank_30_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.04268255988135934, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04268255988135934, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.625, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04268255988135934, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle full-body tracking shot of a female ice skater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the skater wearing a deep blue velvet costume with silver embroidery and sequins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the skater have dark brown hair in a tight bun and flushed cheeks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast dark indoor arena with cool-toned spotlights creating high contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera track parallel to the skater while she glides with one leg pushing off and the other extended?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0166331697255373 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.391633033752441 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0166331697255373, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0166331697255373, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23188352584838867, + 0.23915648460388184, + 0.046227987855672836, + 0.12875477969646454, + 0.15126216411590576, + 0.041011322289705276, + 0.032998256385326385, + 0.050414204597473145, + 0.024496449157595634, + 0.05379483848810196 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0166331697255373 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle full-body tracking shot of a female ice skater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the skater wearing a deep blue velvet costume with silver embroidery and sequins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the skater have dark brown hair in a tight bun and flushed cheeks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast dark indoor arena with cool-toned spotlights creating high contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera track parallel to the skater while she glides with one leg pushing off and the other extended?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10038041323423386 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3503804206848145 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10038041323423386, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10038041323423386, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5756677389144897, + 0.06711293011903763, + 0.02065015211701393, + 0.0292031392455101, + 0.15326327085494995, + 0.041230037808418274, + 0.030485177412629128, + 0.026859115809202194, + 0.011417652480304241, + 0.04411070793867111 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10038041323423386 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle full-body tracking shot of a female ice skater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the skater wearing a deep blue velvet costume with silver embroidery and sequins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the skater have dark brown hair in a tight bun and flushed cheeks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast dark indoor arena with cool-toned spotlights creating high contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera track parallel to the skater while she glides with one leg pushing off and the other extended?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04308703541755676 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680870056152344 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04308703541755676, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04308703541755676, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4721401631832123, + 0.1633860021829605, + 0.03185232728719711, + 0.017288586124777794, + 0.06707865744829178, + 0.052805036306381226, + 0.014776092953979969, + 0.022413469851017, + 0.021405337378382683, + 0.13685424625873566 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04308703541755676 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle full-body tracking shot of a female ice skater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the skater wearing a deep blue velvet costume with silver embroidery and sequins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the skater have dark brown hair in a tight bun and flushed cheeks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast dark indoor arena with cool-toned spotlights creating high contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera track parallel to the skater while she glides with one leg pushing off and the other extended?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04867521673440933 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048675298690796 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04867521673440933, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04867521673440933, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5061354637145996, + 0.23276571929454803, + 0.029662638902664185, + 0.03978150337934494, + 0.05150073394179344, + 0.032467324286699295, + 0.017639242112636566, + 0.056962285190820694, + 0.019132841378450394, + 0.013952228240668774 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04867521673440933 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle full-body tracking shot of a female ice skater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the skater wearing a deep blue velvet costume with silver embroidery and sequins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the skater have dark brown hair in a tight bun and flushed cheeks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast dark indoor arena with cool-toned spotlights creating high contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera track parallel to the skater while she glides with one leg pushing off and the other extended?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0046369642950594425 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379636764526367 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0046369642950594425, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0046369642950594425, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13784225285053253, + 0.21659965813159943, + 0.0931469053030014, + 0.10371863096952438, + 0.09255263209342957, + 0.13540495932102203, + 0.07144925743341446, + 0.07242725789546967, + 0.04131413996219635, + 0.035544268786907196 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0046369642950594425 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slightly low-angle, full-body tracking shot smoothly follows a female ice skater, maintaining the perfect center of the frame as she glides across a vast, pristine ice rink. Her dark brown hair is pulled back into a sleek, tight bun, her cheeks flushed from the cold, an expression of intense, elegant concentration. She wears a stunning deep blue figure skating costume made of stretch velvet, the bodice embroidered with silver thread and shimmering sequins, capturing the light with every movement. Beneath, her muscular legs, clad in flesh-colored tights, culminate in pristine white leather skates, their smooth steel blades silently slicing through the ice. The camera moves parallel to her as she powerfully pushes off with one leg, the other extending behind her in a long, graceful glide, her arms extended for perfect balance. The setting is a vast, dark indoor arena, with powerful, cool-toned stadium spotlights shining down from above, isolating her in a pool of bright light. This high-contrast lighting casts a long, sharp, dramatic shadow extending directly onto the mirrored ice behind her, dynamically lengthening and contracting with her fluid movements, creating a powerful atmosphere of solitary focus, athleticism, and breathtaking artistry.", + "seed": 23664, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_7/index_8397_seed_23664_dp_15_rank_30_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.031189424078911544, + "vlm_logprob": -0.031189424078911544, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.975, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.031189424078911544, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle full-body tracking shot of a female ice skater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the skater wearing a deep blue velvet costume with silver embroidery and sequins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the skater have dark brown hair in a tight bun and flushed cheeks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast dark indoor arena with cool-toned spotlights creating high contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera track parallel to the skater while she glides with one leg pushing off and the other extended?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01650935225188732 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.641509532928467 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01650935225188732, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01650935225188732, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14339224994182587, + 0.11669043451547623, + 0.06268187612295151, + 0.22490161657333374, + 0.05765188857913017, + 0.09286883473396301, + 0.04648412764072418, + 0.14147590100765228, + 0.05004914104938507, + 0.06380388140678406 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01650935225188732 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle full-body tracking shot of a female ice skater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the skater wearing a deep blue velvet costume with silver embroidery and sequins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the skater have dark brown hair in a tight bun and flushed cheeks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast dark indoor arena with cool-toned spotlights creating high contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera track parallel to the skater while she glides with one leg pushing off and the other extended?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07904837280511856 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5790483951568604 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07904837280511856, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07904837280511856, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08798979222774506, + 0.08939878642559052, + 0.10305880755186081, + 0.2020440399646759, + 0.10740941762924194, + 0.05984947457909584, + 0.06289536505937576, + 0.14752697944641113, + 0.09530860185623169, + 0.04451869800686836 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 7, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07904837280511856 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle full-body tracking shot of a female ice skater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the skater wearing a deep blue velvet costume with silver embroidery and sequins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the skater have dark brown hair in a tight bun and flushed cheeks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast dark indoor arena with cool-toned spotlights creating high contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera track parallel to the skater while she glides with one leg pushing off and the other extended?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.038104645907878876 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.28810453414917 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.038104645907878876, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.038104645907878876, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23424935340881348, + 0.11320134997367859, + 0.08963984251022339, + 0.0905987098813057, + 0.0644293799996376, + 0.09094435721635818, + 0.04882408678531647, + 0.09805750846862793, + 0.10398513823747635, + 0.0660703182220459 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.038104645907878876 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle full-body tracking shot of a female ice skater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the skater wearing a deep blue velvet costume with silver embroidery and sequins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the skater have dark brown hair in a tight bun and flushed cheeks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast dark indoor arena with cool-toned spotlights creating high contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera track parallel to the skater while she glides with one leg pushing off and the other extended?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01819257251918316 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018192768096924 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01819257251918316, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01819257251918316, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07084234803915024, + 0.13785475492477417, + 0.10492599010467529, + 0.06548609584569931, + 0.4064846932888031, + 0.028328733518719673, + 0.027465684339404106, + 0.09228593856096268, + 0.05018683895468712, + 0.016138887032866478 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01819257251918316 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle full-body tracking shot of a female ice skater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the skater wearing a deep blue velvet costume with silver embroidery and sequins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the skater have dark brown hair in a tight bun and flushed cheeks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast dark indoor arena with cool-toned spotlights creating high contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera track parallel to the skater while she glides with one leg pushing off and the other extended?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004092176910489798 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504092216491699 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004092176910489798, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004092176910489798, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05614980310201645, + 0.06717466562986374, + 0.12205001711845398, + 0.29598644375801086, + 0.08778668195009232, + 0.08931957185268402, + 0.09569573402404785, + 0.09110210835933685, + 0.0562288835644722, + 0.03850604593753815 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004092176910489798 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_8/index_tensor([2326, 2326])_group_8_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_8/index_tensor([2326, 2326])_group_8_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..6bc7badecb9185aa7fa1f26bb0a3d31758a53ee7 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_8/index_tensor([2326, 2326])_group_8_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "low-angle, ultra-wide shot, the camera moving slowly and steadily backward, captures a lone figure walking along a straight, dusty path. The figure's features are obscured by the deep hood of a rough, earth-colored cloak, and he moves with a steady, deliberate pace. Each footstep stirs up a lingering puff of pale, fine dust from the cracked earth. Seen from above, a vast geometric grid of towering steel power lines dominates the frame; their intricate, repetitive pattern of towers and sagging cables stretches from the foreground to a vanishing point on the distant horizon, dwarfing the lone traveler. In the evening, harsh golden sunlight casts long shadows across the barren landscape, highlighting the textures of the parched earth and the weathered, rusted metal towers. The color palette is a gentle symphony of ochre, brown, and a hazy, faded blue sky, creating an overwhelming atmosphere of desolation, quiet determination, and an endless journey.", + "seed": 13459, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_8/index_2326_seed_13459_dp_16_rank_32_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.09954477516002953, + "vlm_logprob": -0.09954477516002953, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.05, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.09954477516002953, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving slowly and steadily backward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a lone figure walking along a straight, dusty path visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing a rough, earth-colored cloak with a deep hood obscuring their features?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a vast geometric grid of towering steel power lines visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.13770608603954315 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6377060413360596 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.13770608603954315, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.13770608603954315, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3377896845340729, + 0.11013725399971008, + 0.026427924633026123, + 0.13783620297908783, + 0.13043297827243805, + 0.07808258384466171, + 0.049973975867033005, + 0.06899604946374893, + 0.042520586401224136, + 0.017802774906158447 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.13770608603954315 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving slowly and steadily backward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a lone figure walking along a straight, dusty path visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing a rough, earth-colored cloak with a deep hood obscuring their features?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a vast geometric grid of towering steel power lines visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3486463129520416 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2236462831497192 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3486463129520416, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3486463129520416, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07121928781270981, + 0.06394579261541367, + 0.0822855681180954, + 0.21046510338783264, + 0.24228763580322266, + 0.06270008534193039, + 0.04174108803272247, + 0.08646294474601746, + 0.02776550129055977, + 0.11112698912620544 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3486463129520416 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving slowly and steadily backward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a lone figure walking along a straight, dusty path visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing a rough, earth-colored cloak with a deep hood obscuring their features?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a vast geometric grid of towering steel power lines visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0024953915271908045 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002495288848877 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0024953915271908045, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0024953915271908045, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.128904327750206, + 0.07439721375703812, + 0.0750042274594307, + 0.20670948922634125, + 0.16288267076015472, + 0.037106167525053024, + 0.06065192446112633, + 0.16726712882518768, + 0.05700463801622391, + 0.030072208493947983 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 7, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0024953915271908045 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving slowly and steadily backward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a lone figure walking along a straight, dusty path visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing a rough, earth-colored cloak with a deep hood obscuring their features?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a vast geometric grid of towering steel power lines visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003627745434641838 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628627777099609 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003627745434641838, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003627745434641838, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.30958473682403564, + 0.0395481213927269, + 0.04915144667029381, + 0.06711370497941971, + 0.39319413900375366, + 0.020963532850146294, + 0.05069196596741676, + 0.023214029148221016, + 0.02594250813126564, + 0.020595815032720566 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003627745434641838 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving slowly and steadily backward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a lone figure walking along a straight, dusty path visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing a rough, earth-colored cloak with a deep hood obscuring their features?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a vast geometric grid of towering steel power lines visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005248339846730232 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255248546600342 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005248339846730232, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005248339846730232, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10777627676725388, + 0.10948344320058823, + 0.04229453206062317, + 0.03392671048641205, + 0.3827148675918579, + 0.08410089462995529, + 0.0607835128903389, + 0.09802695363759995, + 0.053041115403175354, + 0.027851756662130356 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005248339846730232 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, ultra-wide shot, the camera moving slowly and steadily backward, captures a lone figure walking along a straight, dusty path. The figure's features are obscured by the deep hood of a rough, earth-colored cloak, and he moves with a steady, deliberate pace. Each footstep stirs up a lingering puff of pale, fine dust from the cracked earth. Seen from above, a vast geometric grid of towering steel power lines dominates the frame; their intricate, repetitive pattern of towers and sagging cables stretches from the foreground to a vanishing point on the distant horizon, dwarfing the lone traveler. In the evening, harsh golden sunlight casts long shadows across the barren landscape, highlighting the textures of the parched earth and the weathered, rusted metal towers. The color palette is a gentle symphony of ochre, brown, and a hazy, faded blue sky, creating an overwhelming atmosphere of desolation, quiet determination, and an endless journey.", + "seed": 13460, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_8/index_2326_seed_13460_dp_16_rank_32_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.0952430188888684, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0952430188888684, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.3, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0952430188888684, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving slowly and steadily backward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a lone figure walking along a straight, dusty path visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing a rough, earth-colored cloak with a deep hood obscuring their features?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a vast geometric grid of towering steel power lines visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11981812119483948 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6198182106018066 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11981812119483948, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11981812119483948, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14287467300891876, + 0.3530420660972595, + 0.028033817186951637, + 0.058826763182878494, + 0.09480704367160797, + 0.06405528634786606, + 0.0480736680328846, + 0.03206244856119156, + 0.10830371081829071, + 0.06992055475711823 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11981812119483948 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving slowly and steadily backward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a lone figure walking along a straight, dusty path visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing a rough, earth-colored cloak with a deep hood obscuring their features?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a vast geometric grid of towering steel power lines visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.34864580631256104 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.223645806312561 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.34864580631256104, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.34864580631256104, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1486438810825348, + 0.24865509569644928, + 0.0453510507941246, + 0.036588482558727264, + 0.055246751755476, + 0.11267190426588058, + 0.06222114711999893, + 0.026630129665136337, + 0.08960084617137909, + 0.17439065873622894 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.34864580631256104 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving slowly and steadily backward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a lone figure walking along a straight, dusty path visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing a rough, earth-colored cloak with a deep hood obscuring their features?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a vast geometric grid of towering steel power lines visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0017162130679935217 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.376716136932373 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0017162130679935217, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0017162130679935217, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16639924049377441, + 0.22114679217338562, + 0.132854163646698, + 0.03863835334777832, + 0.06763859838247299, + 0.1142612174153328, + 0.030553726479411125, + 0.03604699671268463, + 0.0666130930185318, + 0.12584781646728516 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0017162130679935217 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving slowly and steadily backward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a lone figure walking along a straight, dusty path visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing a rough, earth-colored cloak with a deep hood obscuring their features?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a vast geometric grid of towering steel power lines visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0019449143437668681 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.2519450187683105 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0019449143437668681, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0019449143437668681, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.253084272146225, + 0.27312928438186646, + 0.11072251945734024, + 0.08691059798002243, + 0.06025540083646774, + 0.06466289609670639, + 0.03572727367281914, + 0.027647079899907112, + 0.053133830428123474, + 0.034726813435554504 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0019449143437668681 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving slowly and steadily backward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a lone figure walking along a straight, dusty path visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing a rough, earth-colored cloak with a deep hood obscuring their features?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a vast geometric grid of towering steel power lines visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004090039525181055 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504089832305908 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004090039525181055, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004090039525181055, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19696852564811707, + 0.3333398699760437, + 0.061749063432216644, + 0.03859765827655792, + 0.11168378591537476, + 0.05413707718253136, + 0.04422253370285034, + 0.057180535048246384, + 0.04822695255279541, + 0.05389399453997612 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004090039525181055 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, ultra-wide shot, the camera moving slowly and steadily backward, captures a lone figure walking along a straight, dusty path. The figure's features are obscured by the deep hood of a rough, earth-colored cloak, and he moves with a steady, deliberate pace. Each footstep stirs up a lingering puff of pale, fine dust from the cracked earth. Seen from above, a vast geometric grid of towering steel power lines dominates the frame; their intricate, repetitive pattern of towers and sagging cables stretches from the foreground to a vanishing point on the distant horizon, dwarfing the lone traveler. In the evening, harsh golden sunlight casts long shadows across the barren landscape, highlighting the textures of the parched earth and the weathered, rusted metal towers. The color palette is a gentle symphony of ochre, brown, and a hazy, faded blue sky, creating an overwhelming atmosphere of desolation, quiet determination, and an endless journey.", + "seed": 13461, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_8/index_2326_seed_13461_dp_17_rank_34_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.07378115823958069, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07378115823958069, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.55, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07378115823958069, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving slowly and steadily backward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a lone figure walking along a straight, dusty path visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing a rough, earth-colored cloak with a deep hood obscuring their features?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a vast geometric grid of towering steel power lines visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.18317368626594543 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.433173656463623 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.18317368626594543, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.18317368626594543, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3303404748439789, + 0.061120275408029556, + 0.05173167213797569, + 0.07012822479009628, + 0.07207947969436646, + 0.06277459114789963, + 0.057520441710948944, + 0.0575275719165802, + 0.17814216017723083, + 0.05863509699702263 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.18317368626594543 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving slowly and steadily backward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a lone figure walking along a straight, dusty path visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing a rough, earth-colored cloak with a deep hood obscuring their features?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a vast geometric grid of towering steel power lines visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17988507449626923 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8048850297927856 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17988507449626923, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17988507449626923, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08421576768159866, + 0.05390840023756027, + 0.04712535813450813, + 0.1695668250322342, + 0.046243760734796524, + 0.05623794347047806, + 0.2746643126010895, + 0.06719940155744553, + 0.11238986998796463, + 0.08844839036464691 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 3, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17988507449626923 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving slowly and steadily backward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a lone figure walking along a straight, dusty path visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing a rough, earth-colored cloak with a deep hood obscuring their features?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a vast geometric grid of towering steel power lines visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0015151937259361148 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.5015153884887695 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0015151937259361148, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0015151937259361148, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11428125202655792, + 0.1534310281276703, + 0.20307563245296478, + 0.13592521846294403, + 0.03507049381732941, + 0.06556946039199829, + 0.09258773922920227, + 0.036431021988391876, + 0.0981210246682167, + 0.06550709903240204 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0015151937259361148 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving slowly and steadily backward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a lone figure walking along a straight, dusty path visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing a rough, earth-colored cloak with a deep hood obscuring their features?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a vast geometric grid of towering steel power lines visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0015170981641858816 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.501517295837402 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0015170981641858816, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0015170981641858816, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2097565084695816, + 0.2738558351993561, + 0.09096179902553558, + 0.12544143199920654, + 0.03040871024131775, + 0.04334775358438492, + 0.11356192082166672, + 0.02495802380144596, + 0.027378613129258156, + 0.060329388827085495 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0015170981641858816 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving slowly and steadily backward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a lone figure walking along a straight, dusty path visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing a rough, earth-colored cloak with a deep hood obscuring their features?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a vast geometric grid of towering steel power lines visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0028147385455667973 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877814769744873 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0028147385455667973, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0028147385455667973, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10622397065162659, + 0.13151854276657104, + 0.12818513810634613, + 0.08872917294502258, + 0.05906597897410393, + 0.05148759111762047, + 0.24880385398864746, + 0.06479887664318085, + 0.030147312209010124, + 0.09103958308696747 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0028147385455667973 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, ultra-wide shot, the camera moving slowly and steadily backward, captures a lone figure walking along a straight, dusty path. The figure's features are obscured by the deep hood of a rough, earth-colored cloak, and he moves with a steady, deliberate pace. Each footstep stirs up a lingering puff of pale, fine dust from the cracked earth. Seen from above, a vast geometric grid of towering steel power lines dominates the frame; their intricate, repetitive pattern of towers and sagging cables stretches from the foreground to a vanishing point on the distant horizon, dwarfing the lone traveler. In the evening, harsh golden sunlight casts long shadows across the barren landscape, highlighting the textures of the parched earth and the weathered, rusted metal towers. The color palette is a gentle symphony of ochre, brown, and a hazy, faded blue sky, creating an overwhelming atmosphere of desolation, quiet determination, and an endless journey.", + "seed": 13462, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_8/index_2326_seed_13462_dp_17_rank_34_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.15396304028108715, + "vlm_logprob": -0.15396304028108715, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.85, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.15396304028108715, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving slowly and steadily backward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a lone figure walking along a straight, dusty path visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing a rough, earth-colored cloak with a deep hood obscuring their features?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a vast geometric grid of towering steel power lines visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12247869372367859 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.997478723526001 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12247869372367859, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12247869372367859, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3897513449192047, + 0.0362345352768898, + 0.08061789721250534, + 0.043638575822114944, + 0.07309981435537338, + 0.12253470718860626, + 0.049273692071437836, + 0.040721263736486435, + 0.11818678677082062, + 0.04594135284423828 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12247869372367859 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving slowly and steadily backward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a lone figure walking along a straight, dusty path visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing a rough, earth-colored cloak with a deep hood obscuring their features?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a vast geometric grid of towering steel power lines visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6328482031822205 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7578482031822205 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.6328482031822205, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.6328482031822205, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0905086025595665, + 0.015317774377763271, + 0.057695064693689346, + 0.031483378261327744, + 0.1400720328092575, + 0.043276745826005936, + 0.04878342151641846, + 0.15069344639778137, + 0.3904823362827301, + 0.03168727457523346 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.6328482031822205 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving slowly and steadily backward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a lone figure walking along a straight, dusty path visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing a rough, earth-colored cloak with a deep hood obscuring their features?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a vast geometric grid of towering steel power lines visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006742109544575214 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006742000579834 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006742109544575214, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006742109544575214, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3199021518230438, + 0.03708414360880852, + 0.10438061505556107, + 0.052728306502103806, + 0.03970795124769211, + 0.11494208872318268, + 0.03062782809138298, + 0.06532909721136093, + 0.17485898733139038, + 0.06043882668018341 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006742109544575214 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving slowly and steadily backward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a lone figure walking along a straight, dusty path visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing a rough, earth-colored cloak with a deep hood obscuring their features?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a vast geometric grid of towering steel power lines visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005260316655039787 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255260467529297 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005260316655039787, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005260316655039787, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4344501495361328, + 0.0429568774998188, + 0.12756717205047607, + 0.035913582891225815, + 0.021170558407902718, + 0.0693364143371582, + 0.04510337859392166, + 0.04866992309689522, + 0.16136719286441803, + 0.013464757241308689 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005260316655039787 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving slowly and steadily backward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a lone figure walking along a straight, dusty path visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing a rough, earth-colored cloak with a deep hood obscuring their features?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a vast geometric grid of towering steel power lines visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002485878299921751 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002485752105713 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002485878299921751, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002485878299921751, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.27562451362609863, + 0.05339684337377548, + 0.04959649592638016, + 0.029549945145845413, + 0.12516558170318604, + 0.048962630331516266, + 0.044958923012018204, + 0.07940107583999634, + 0.22878341376781464, + 0.06456051021814346 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002485878299921751 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_9/index_tensor([1979, 1979])_group_9_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_9/index_tensor([1979, 1979])_group_9_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..54bf6035322944a7260e96c7f731b930aba7c116 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_9/index_tensor([1979, 1979])_group_9_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "wide, long shot, the camera panning slowly to the right along the broad crest of an ancient city wall from a slightly bird's-eye view, captures a group of children chasing and playing freely. The wall, constructed of massive, mottled gray bricks, is weathered and covered with moss over time. The surface is wide and flat, wide enough for them to run freely. The setting sun casts a warm, golden-orange glow over the world, the sky gradating from fiery orange to soft violet. A boy, wearing a faded blue short-sleeved shirt and beige shorts, leads the group, laughing excitedly as he glances back. Following closely behind is a girl with twin pigtails in a simple white dress, her hands reaching out, intently trying to catch him. Their faces, rosy in the warm glow of the setting sun, are filled with pure joy. Most striking is the dramatic, elongated, deep shadows cast behind them as they run. These shadows leap and dance across the ancient stone pavement, almost as vibrant as the people themselves. In the distance, the dark blue rooftops of the ancient city loom in the twilight, creating a tranquil and poetic scene, imbued with nostalgia and the carefree spirit of childhood.", + "seed": 24068, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_9/index_1979_seed_24068_dp_18_rank_36_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.22404766040854157, + "vlm_logprob": -0.22404766040854157, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.65, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.22404766040854157, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a wide, long shot with a bird's-eye view panning slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on an ancient city wall made of massive, mottled gray bricks covered with moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are a boy in a faded blue short-sleeved shirt and beige shorts and a girl with twin pigtails in a white dress visible chasing each other?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by a setting sun casting a warm, golden-orange glow with dramatic, elongated deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are dark blue rooftops of an ancient city visible in the distance against a sky gradating from fiery orange to soft violet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6965873837471008 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6965873837471008 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.6965873837471008, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.6965873837471008, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2042059451341629, + 0.11858182400465012, + 0.03906011953949928, + 0.25615188479423523, + 0.027226734906435013, + 0.04205453768372536, + 0.055159129202365875, + 0.03693075478076935, + 0.11750944703817368, + 0.10311952978372574 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.6965873837471008 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a wide, long shot with a bird's-eye view panning slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on an ancient city wall made of massive, mottled gray bricks covered with moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are a boy in a faded blue short-sleeved shirt and beige shorts and a girl with twin pigtails in a white dress visible chasing each other?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by a setting sun casting a warm, golden-orange glow with dramatic, elongated deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are dark blue rooftops of an ancient city visible in the distance against a sky gradating from fiery orange to soft violet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.34866228699684143 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.223662257194519 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.34866228699684143, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.34866228699684143, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18447503447532654, + 0.12817153334617615, + 0.07525543868541718, + 0.13186760246753693, + 0.019553255289793015, + 0.03251876309514046, + 0.03066672757267952, + 0.11330459266901016, + 0.2026914358139038, + 0.08149567246437073 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.34866228699684143 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a wide, long shot with a bird's-eye view panning slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on an ancient city wall made of massive, mottled gray bricks covered with moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are a boy in a faded blue short-sleeved shirt and beige shorts and a girl with twin pigtails in a white dress visible chasing each other?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by a setting sun casting a warm, golden-orange glow with dramatic, elongated deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are dark blue rooftops of an ancient city visible in the distance against a sky gradating from fiery orange to soft violet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.033708587288856506 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4087085723876953 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.033708587288856506, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.033708587288856506, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06264820694923401, + 0.05248366296291351, + 0.027367867529392242, + 0.20391738414764404, + 0.05890027433633804, + 0.09997215867042542, + 0.022128818556666374, + 0.09774670004844666, + 0.24575215578079224, + 0.1290828436613083 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.033708587288856506 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a wide, long shot with a bird's-eye view panning slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on an ancient city wall made of massive, mottled gray bricks covered with moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are a boy in a faded blue short-sleeved shirt and beige shorts and a girl with twin pigtails in a white dress visible chasing each other?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by a setting sun casting a warm, golden-orange glow with dramatic, elongated deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are dark blue rooftops of an ancient city visible in the distance against a sky gradating from fiery orange to soft violet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003193875541910529 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.7531938552856445 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003193875541910529, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003193875541910529, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13995561003684998, + 0.04944993928074837, + 0.1652076691389084, + 0.11313819885253906, + 0.016042061150074005, + 0.04770604893565178, + 0.027482805773615837, + 0.07879234850406647, + 0.24614503979682922, + 0.11608026921749115 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003193875541910529 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a wide, long shot with a bird's-eye view panning slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on an ancient city wall made of massive, mottled gray bricks covered with moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are a boy in a faded blue short-sleeved shirt and beige shorts and a girl with twin pigtails in a white dress visible chasing each other?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by a setting sun casting a warm, golden-orange glow with dramatic, elongated deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are dark blue rooftops of an ancient city visible in the distance against a sky gradating from fiery orange to soft violet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.038086168467998505 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288086175918579 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.038086168467998505, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.038086168467998505, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1993616223335266, + 0.039478495717048645, + 0.04717380180954933, + 0.12801799178123474, + 0.02187425270676613, + 0.10389616340398788, + 0.027841519564390182, + 0.11048678308725357, + 0.2043391466140747, + 0.11753012239933014 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.038086168467998505 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "wide, long shot, the camera panning slowly to the right along the broad crest of an ancient city wall from a slightly bird's-eye view, captures a group of children chasing and playing freely. The wall, constructed of massive, mottled gray bricks, is weathered and covered with moss over time. The surface is wide and flat, wide enough for them to run freely. The setting sun casts a warm, golden-orange glow over the world, the sky gradating from fiery orange to soft violet. A boy, wearing a faded blue short-sleeved shirt and beige shorts, leads the group, laughing excitedly as he glances back. Following closely behind is a girl with twin pigtails in a simple white dress, her hands reaching out, intently trying to catch him. Their faces, rosy in the warm glow of the setting sun, are filled with pure joy. Most striking is the dramatic, elongated, deep shadows cast behind them as they run. These shadows leap and dance across the ancient stone pavement, almost as vibrant as the people themselves. In the distance, the dark blue rooftops of the ancient city loom in the twilight, creating a tranquil and poetic scene, imbued with nostalgia and the carefree spirit of childhood.", + "seed": 24069, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_9/index_1979_seed_24069_dp_18_rank_36_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.16448012692853808, + "vlm_logprob": -0.16448012692853808, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.85, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.16448012692853808, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a wide, long shot with a bird's-eye view panning slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on an ancient city wall made of massive, mottled gray bricks covered with moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are a boy in a faded blue short-sleeved shirt and beige shorts and a girl with twin pigtails in a white dress visible chasing each other?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by a setting sun casting a warm, golden-orange glow with dramatic, elongated deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are dark blue rooftops of an ancient city visible in the distance against a sky gradating from fiery orange to soft violet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4765434265136719 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9765434265136719 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.4765434265136719, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.4765434265136719, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2563253343105316, + 0.0861736536026001, + 0.10747430473566055, + 0.10395944863557816, + 0.08116865158081055, + 0.05851711332798004, + 0.03479424864053726, + 0.09891851991415024, + 0.12714318931102753, + 0.04552553966641426 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.4765434265136719 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a wide, long shot with a bird's-eye view panning slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on an ancient city wall made of massive, mottled gray bricks covered with moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are a boy in a faded blue short-sleeved shirt and beige shorts and a girl with twin pigtails in a white dress visible chasing each other?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by a setting sun casting a warm, golden-orange glow with dramatic, elongated deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are dark blue rooftops of an ancient city visible in the distance against a sky gradating from fiery orange to soft violet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2520981431007385 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5020980834960938 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2520981431007385, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2520981431007385, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11146420985460281, + 0.0561753511428833, + 0.07739469408988953, + 0.29426324367523193, + 0.08009007573127747, + 0.20048072934150696, + 0.02132672443985939, + 0.025562867522239685, + 0.11031760275363922, + 0.022924473509192467 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2520981431007385 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a wide, long shot with a bird's-eye view panning slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on an ancient city wall made of massive, mottled gray bricks covered with moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are a boy in a faded blue short-sleeved shirt and beige shorts and a girl with twin pigtails in a white dress visible chasing each other?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by a setting sun casting a warm, golden-orange glow with dramatic, elongated deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are dark blue rooftops of an ancient city visible in the distance against a sky gradating from fiery orange to soft violet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02979913167655468 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529799222946167 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02979913167655468, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02979913167655468, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08618935197591782, + 0.036294471472501755, + 0.06853137165307999, + 0.26207205653190613, + 0.12003721296787262, + 0.12287258356809616, + 0.06005661562085152, + 0.04237959161400795, + 0.11677625775337219, + 0.08479052037000656 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02979913167655468 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a wide, long shot with a bird's-eye view panning slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on an ancient city wall made of massive, mottled gray bricks covered with moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are a boy in a faded blue short-sleeved shirt and beige shorts and a girl with twin pigtails in a white dress visible chasing each other?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by a setting sun casting a warm, golden-orange glow with dramatic, elongated deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are dark blue rooftops of an ancient city visible in the distance against a sky gradating from fiery orange to soft violet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0019393223337829113 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.251939296722412 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0019393223337829113, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0019393223337829113, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14491552114486694, + 0.11702027916908264, + 0.07953574508428574, + 0.18432863056659698, + 0.11025923490524292, + 0.1522105485200882, + 0.0333714559674263, + 0.037594024091959, + 0.10627992451190948, + 0.03448466211557388 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0019393223337829113 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a wide, long shot with a bird's-eye view panning slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on an ancient city wall made of massive, mottled gray bricks covered with moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are a boy in a faded blue short-sleeved shirt and beige shorts and a girl with twin pigtails in a white dress visible chasing each other?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by a setting sun casting a warm, golden-orange glow with dramatic, elongated deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are dark blue rooftops of an ancient city visible in the distance against a sky gradating from fiery orange to soft violet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06202061101794243 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120205402374268 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06202061101794243, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06202061101794243, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13724195957183838, + 0.32251718640327454, + 0.09800112247467041, + 0.028966469690203667, + 0.06940346956253052, + 0.15208467841148376, + 0.021912287920713425, + 0.036553606390953064, + 0.07765199989080429, + 0.055667225271463394 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06202061101794243 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "wide, long shot, the camera panning slowly to the right along the broad crest of an ancient city wall from a slightly bird's-eye view, captures a group of children chasing and playing freely. The wall, constructed of massive, mottled gray bricks, is weathered and covered with moss over time. The surface is wide and flat, wide enough for them to run freely. The setting sun casts a warm, golden-orange glow over the world, the sky gradating from fiery orange to soft violet. A boy, wearing a faded blue short-sleeved shirt and beige shorts, leads the group, laughing excitedly as he glances back. Following closely behind is a girl with twin pigtails in a simple white dress, her hands reaching out, intently trying to catch him. Their faces, rosy in the warm glow of the setting sun, are filled with pure joy. Most striking is the dramatic, elongated, deep shadows cast behind them as they run. These shadows leap and dance across the ancient stone pavement, almost as vibrant as the people themselves. In the distance, the dark blue rooftops of the ancient city loom in the twilight, creating a tranquil and poetic scene, imbued with nostalgia and the carefree spirit of childhood.", + "seed": 24070, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_9/index_1979_seed_24070_dp_19_rank_38_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.16133443936705588, + "vlm_logprob": -0.16133443936705588, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.8, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.16133443936705588, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a wide, long shot with a bird's-eye view panning slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on an ancient city wall made of massive, mottled gray bricks covered with moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are a boy in a faded blue short-sleeved shirt and beige shorts and a girl with twin pigtails in a white dress visible chasing each other?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by a setting sun casting a warm, golden-orange glow with dramatic, elongated deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are dark blue rooftops of an ancient city visible in the distance against a sky gradating from fiery orange to soft violet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5255103707313538 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9005103707313538 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5255103707313538, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5255103707313538, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23494753241539001, + 0.07685831189155579, + 0.10718858987092972, + 0.0708521157503128, + 0.09885255992412567, + 0.12192586809396744, + 0.06441831588745117, + 0.05177679657936096, + 0.06595280021429062, + 0.10722712427377701 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5255103707313538 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a wide, long shot with a bird's-eye view panning slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on an ancient city wall made of massive, mottled gray bricks covered with moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are a boy in a faded blue short-sleeved shirt and beige shorts and a girl with twin pigtails in a white dress visible chasing each other?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by a setting sun casting a warm, golden-orange glow with dramatic, elongated deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are dark blue rooftops of an ancient city visible in the distance against a sky gradating from fiery orange to soft violet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22559234499931335 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6005923748016357 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.22559234499931335, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.22559234499931335, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3996845781803131, + 0.06558027863502502, + 0.22520330548286438, + 0.07067961245775223, + 0.03193431347608566, + 0.05535752326250076, + 0.025786245241761208, + 0.018332676962018013, + 0.04569302126765251, + 0.061748430132865906 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.22559234499931335 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a wide, long shot with a bird's-eye view panning slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on an ancient city wall made of massive, mottled gray bricks covered with moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are a boy in a faded blue short-sleeved shirt and beige shorts and a girl with twin pigtails in a white dress visible chasing each other?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by a setting sun casting a warm, golden-orange glow with dramatic, elongated deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are dark blue rooftops of an ancient city visible in the distance against a sky gradating from fiery orange to soft violet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020589197054505348 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955891132354736 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020589197054505348, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020589197054505348, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16115331649780273, + 0.07838605344295502, + 0.09381423890590668, + 0.051904454827308655, + 0.12789537012577057, + 0.06099075824022293, + 0.1091664507985115, + 0.1342209428548813, + 0.07928469032049179, + 0.10318374633789062 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020589197054505348 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a wide, long shot with a bird's-eye view panning slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on an ancient city wall made of massive, mottled gray bricks covered with moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are a boy in a faded blue short-sleeved shirt and beige shorts and a girl with twin pigtails in a white dress visible chasing each other?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by a setting sun casting a warm, golden-orange glow with dramatic, elongated deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are dark blue rooftops of an ancient city visible in the distance against a sky gradating from fiery orange to soft violet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008644422516226768 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.7586445808410645 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008644422516226768, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008644422516226768, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3184289336204529, + 0.09953806549310684, + 0.07665041834115982, + 0.06344156712293625, + 0.06540802866220474, + 0.24833109974861145, + 0.027344195172190666, + 0.022164348512887955, + 0.029852239415049553, + 0.04884108528494835 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008644422516226768 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a wide, long shot with a bird's-eye view panning slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on an ancient city wall made of massive, mottled gray bricks covered with moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are a boy in a faded blue short-sleeved shirt and beige shorts and a girl with twin pigtails in a white dress visible chasing each other?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by a setting sun casting a warm, golden-orange glow with dramatic, elongated deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are dark blue rooftops of an ancient city visible in the distance against a sky gradating from fiery orange to soft violet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026335861533880234 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513359546661377 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026335861533880234, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026335861533880234, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4640335440635681, + 0.14450737833976746, + 0.06538907438516617, + 0.05937180668115616, + 0.040053725242614746, + 0.07028686255216599, + 0.032639868557453156, + 0.022627871483564377, + 0.047270599752664566, + 0.053819213062524796 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026335861533880234 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "wide, long shot, the camera panning slowly to the right along the broad crest of an ancient city wall from a slightly bird's-eye view, captures a group of children chasing and playing freely. The wall, constructed of massive, mottled gray bricks, is weathered and covered with moss over time. The surface is wide and flat, wide enough for them to run freely. The setting sun casts a warm, golden-orange glow over the world, the sky gradating from fiery orange to soft violet. A boy, wearing a faded blue short-sleeved shirt and beige shorts, leads the group, laughing excitedly as he glances back. Following closely behind is a girl with twin pigtails in a simple white dress, her hands reaching out, intently trying to catch him. Their faces, rosy in the warm glow of the setting sun, are filled with pure joy. Most striking is the dramatic, elongated, deep shadows cast behind them as they run. These shadows leap and dance across the ancient stone pavement, almost as vibrant as the people themselves. In the distance, the dark blue rooftops of the ancient city loom in the twilight, creating a tranquil and poetic scene, imbued with nostalgia and the carefree spirit of childhood.", + "seed": 24071, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000012/group_9/index_1979_seed_24071_dp_19_rank_38_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.24755875077098607, + "vlm_logprob": -0.24755875077098607, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.375, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.24755875077098607, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a wide, long shot with a bird's-eye view panning slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on an ancient city wall made of massive, mottled gray bricks covered with moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are a boy in a faded blue short-sleeved shirt and beige shorts and a girl with twin pigtails in a white dress visible chasing each other?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by a setting sun casting a warm, golden-orange glow with dramatic, elongated deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are dark blue rooftops of an ancient city visible in the distance against a sky gradating from fiery orange to soft violet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.35228607058525085 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2272861003875732 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.35228607058525085, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.35228607058525085, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21620604395866394, + 0.16192062199115753, + 0.08012565970420837, + 0.22820056974887848, + 0.09282879531383514, + 0.041734714061021805, + 0.024692054837942123, + 0.08860322088003159, + 0.038363438099622726, + 0.027324948459863663 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.35228607058525085 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a wide, long shot with a bird's-eye view panning slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on an ancient city wall made of massive, mottled gray bricks covered with moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are a boy in a faded blue short-sleeved shirt and beige shorts and a girl with twin pigtails in a white dress visible chasing each other?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by a setting sun casting a warm, golden-orange glow with dramatic, elongated deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are dark blue rooftops of an ancient city visible in the distance against a sky gradating from fiery orange to soft violet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7577869296073914 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6327869296073914 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.7577869296073914, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.7577869296073914, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15136271715164185, + 0.09749428927898407, + 0.08383523672819138, + 0.21814754605293274, + 0.2549970746040344, + 0.022898774594068527, + 0.0434953011572361, + 0.032628484070301056, + 0.02681833878159523, + 0.06832218915224075 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.7577869296073914 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a wide, long shot with a bird's-eye view panning slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on an ancient city wall made of massive, mottled gray bricks covered with moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are a boy in a faded blue short-sleeved shirt and beige shorts and a girl with twin pigtails in a white dress visible chasing each other?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by a setting sun casting a warm, golden-orange glow with dramatic, elongated deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are dark blue rooftops of an ancient city visible in the distance against a sky gradating from fiery orange to soft violet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06206587329506874 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812065839767456 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06206587329506874, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06206587329506874, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12111537903547287, + 0.05500786378979683, + 0.03958554565906525, + 0.2932125926017761, + 0.08246677368879318, + 0.13387686014175415, + 0.046262484043836594, + 0.06786784529685974, + 0.029057778418064117, + 0.13154691457748413 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06206587329506874 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a wide, long shot with a bird's-eye view panning slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on an ancient city wall made of massive, mottled gray bricks covered with moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are a boy in a faded blue short-sleeved shirt and beige shorts and a girl with twin pigtails in a white dress visible chasing each other?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by a setting sun casting a warm, golden-orange glow with dramatic, elongated deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are dark blue rooftops of an ancient city visible in the distance against a sky gradating from fiery orange to soft violet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036202622577548027 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628620147705078 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036202622577548027, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036202622577548027, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15225665271282196, + 0.06801652908325195, + 0.04531385377049446, + 0.27480438351631165, + 0.1675013303756714, + 0.051050614565610886, + 0.017980188131332397, + 0.07981996238231659, + 0.04882991313934326, + 0.09442659467458725 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036202622577548027 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a wide, long shot with a bird's-eye view panning slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on an ancient city wall made of massive, mottled gray bricks covered with moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are a boy in a faded blue short-sleeved shirt and beige shorts and a girl with twin pigtails in a white dress visible chasing each other?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by a setting sun casting a warm, golden-orange glow with dramatic, elongated deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are dark blue rooftops of an ancient city visible in the distance against a sky gradating from fiery orange to soft violet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.062034618109464645 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120346069335938 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.062034618109464645, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.062034618109464645, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.31967511773109436, + 0.08215569704771042, + 0.07035677134990692, + 0.14427466690540314, + 0.1256541907787323, + 0.03575892746448517, + 0.022967541590332985, + 0.07225842773914337, + 0.02754010260105133, + 0.09935858100652695 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.062034618109464645 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_0/index_tensor([8800, 8800])_group_0_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_0/index_tensor([8800, 8800])_group_0_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..1436ee56d58a5c2b89e110d3427cd02342db807b --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_0/index_tensor([8800, 8800])_group_0_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "dynamic low-angle shot captures the pinnacle of athleticism, the camera smoothly tracking a male gymnast executing a powerful lunge. Starting with an explosive push of his hands on the leather-covered pommel horse, his lean, muscular body soars into the air. He wears a tight, sleeveless royal blue and white leotard and crisp white trousers, his short, dark hair damp with sweat. Under the bright, even glare of the overhead stage lights, shadows are minimal, and his body forms a perfectly straight line. Then, gracefully and decisively, he twists through the air, legs firmly together, toes pointed, completing a full rotation with astonishing precision. His face is a mask of intense concentration, jaw set, eyes fixed on his landing. The soft-focus blur of the vast arena and the audience in the distance in the background isolates the gymnast from the deep blue of the thick landing mat below, creating an intense and awe-inspiring atmosphere that celebrates a moment of perfect form and controlled strength.", + "seed": 13689, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_0/index_8800_seed_13689_dp_0_rank_0_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.2071257894858718, + "vlm_logprob": -0.2071257894858718, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.375, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.2071257894858718, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a low angle looking up at the gymnast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly track the male gymnast as he executes a powerful lunge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the gymnast wearing a tight, sleeveless royal blue and white leotard with crisp white trousers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the gymnast perform a full rotation in the air with legs firmly together and toes pointed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a soft-focus blur of a vast arena and audience while the gymnast is isolated against a deep blue landing mat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5942955613136292 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8442955613136292 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5942955613136292, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5942955613136292, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10293196886777878, + 0.040449053049087524, + 0.42346930503845215, + 0.07033481448888779, + 0.09026512503623962, + 0.0651911273598671, + 0.06060951203107834, + 0.05164942890405655, + 0.030153213068842888, + 0.0649464875459671 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5942955613136292 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a low angle looking up at the gymnast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly track the male gymnast as he executes a powerful lunge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the gymnast wearing a tight, sleeveless royal blue and white leotard with crisp white trousers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the gymnast perform a full rotation in the air with legs firmly together and toes pointed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a soft-focus blur of a vast arena and audience while the gymnast is isolated against a deep blue landing mat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.048705194145441055 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0487051010131836 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.048705194145441055, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.048705194145441055, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10673036426305771, + 0.025422697886824608, + 0.6627178192138672, + 0.04488781467080116, + 0.027886347845196724, + 0.031098801642656326, + 0.03693348914384842, + 0.017884692177176476, + 0.015175464563071728, + 0.03126247972249985 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.048705194145441055 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a low angle looking up at the gymnast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly track the male gymnast as he executes a powerful lunge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the gymnast wearing a tight, sleeveless royal blue and white leotard with crisp white trousers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the gymnast perform a full rotation in the air with legs firmly together and toes pointed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a soft-focus blur of a vast arena and audience while the gymnast is isolated against a deep blue landing mat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029799016192555428 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529798984527588 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029799016192555428, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029799016192555428, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05212675407528877, + 0.012707561254501343, + 0.8097009062767029, + 0.015071078203618526, + 0.0316135473549366, + 0.009576219134032726, + 0.011045072227716446, + 0.026571713387966156, + 0.008787297643721104, + 0.022799894213676453 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029799016192555428 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a low angle looking up at the gymnast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly track the male gymnast as he executes a powerful lunge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the gymnast wearing a tight, sleeveless royal blue and white leotard with crisp white trousers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the gymnast perform a full rotation in the air with legs firmly together and toes pointed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a soft-focus blur of a vast arena and audience while the gymnast is isolated against a deep blue landing mat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3486352860927582 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2236353158950806 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3486352860927582, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3486352860927582, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10244296491146088, + 0.061592865735292435, + 0.7134047746658325, + 0.021050304174423218, + 0.035976629704236984, + 0.008412343449890614, + 0.028006920590996742, + 0.008318097330629826, + 0.0062029059045016766, + 0.014592256397008896 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3486352860927582 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a low angle looking up at the gymnast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly track the male gymnast as he executes a powerful lunge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the gymnast wearing a tight, sleeveless royal blue and white leotard with crisp white trousers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the gymnast perform a full rotation in the air with legs firmly together and toes pointed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a soft-focus blur of a vast arena and audience while the gymnast is isolated against a deep blue landing mat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014193889684975147 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264194011688232 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014193889684975147, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014193889684975147, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05897039920091629, + 0.04431147500872612, + 0.3938823938369751, + 0.023261431604623795, + 0.07409707456827164, + 0.062408946454524994, + 0.16217558085918427, + 0.03231782466173172, + 0.01245194859802723, + 0.136122927069664 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014193889684975147 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dynamic low-angle shot captures the pinnacle of athleticism, the camera smoothly tracking a male gymnast executing a powerful lunge. Starting with an explosive push of his hands on the leather-covered pommel horse, his lean, muscular body soars into the air. He wears a tight, sleeveless royal blue and white leotard and crisp white trousers, his short, dark hair damp with sweat. Under the bright, even glare of the overhead stage lights, shadows are minimal, and his body forms a perfectly straight line. Then, gracefully and decisively, he twists through the air, legs firmly together, toes pointed, completing a full rotation with astonishing precision. His face is a mask of intense concentration, jaw set, eyes fixed on his landing. The soft-focus blur of the vast arena and the audience in the distance in the background isolates the gymnast from the deep blue of the thick landing mat below, creating an intense and awe-inspiring atmosphere that celebrates a moment of perfect form and controlled strength.", + "seed": 13690, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_0/index_8800_seed_13690_dp_0_rank_0_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.1344506463035941, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1344506463035941, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.95, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1344506463035941, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a low angle looking up at the gymnast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly track the male gymnast as he executes a powerful lunge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the gymnast wearing a tight, sleeveless royal blue and white leotard with crisp white trousers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the gymnast perform a full rotation in the air with legs firmly together and toes pointed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a soft-focus blur of a vast arena and audience while the gymnast is isolated against a deep blue landing mat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4542715549468994 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.0792715549468994 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.4542715549468994, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.4542715549468994, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0919300988316536, + 0.12152847647666931, + 0.1335275024175644, + 0.08001714944839478, + 0.1507423222064972, + 0.05595383048057556, + 0.08525069802999496, + 0.15012352168560028, + 0.0311944130808115, + 0.0997319445014 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 7, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.4542715549468994 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a low angle looking up at the gymnast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly track the male gymnast as he executes a powerful lunge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the gymnast wearing a tight, sleeveless royal blue and white leotard with crisp white trousers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the gymnast perform a full rotation in the air with legs firmly together and toes pointed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a soft-focus blur of a vast arena and audience while the gymnast is isolated against a deep blue landing mat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0550270713865757 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9300270080566406 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0550270713865757, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0550270713865757, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0707218125462532, + 0.07107695937156677, + 0.36001095175743103, + 0.07202325761318207, + 0.1455056220293045, + 0.03067159838974476, + 0.0932464748620987, + 0.054217975586652756, + 0.02579985372722149, + 0.07672549039125443 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0550270713865757 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a low angle looking up at the gymnast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly track the male gymnast as he executes a powerful lunge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the gymnast wearing a tight, sleeveless royal blue and white leotard with crisp white trousers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the gymnast perform a full rotation in the air with legs firmly together and toes pointed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a soft-focus blur of a vast arena and audience while the gymnast is isolated against a deep blue landing mat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014201411046087742 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264201641082764 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014201411046087742, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014201411046087742, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04462173581123352, + 0.039023131132125854, + 0.10350103676319122, + 0.05029010400176048, + 0.6142820715904236, + 0.025196993723511696, + 0.026241933926939964, + 0.054824016988277435, + 0.027099618688225746, + 0.01491936668753624 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 2, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014201411046087742 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a low angle looking up at the gymnast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly track the male gymnast as he executes a powerful lunge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the gymnast wearing a tight, sleeveless royal blue and white leotard with crisp white trousers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the gymnast perform a full rotation in the air with legs firmly together and toes pointed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a soft-focus blur of a vast arena and audience while the gymnast is isolated against a deep blue landing mat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1428060382604599 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.017806053161621 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1428060382604599, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1428060382604599, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06163064390420914, + 0.07102976739406586, + 0.4054051637649536, + 0.11443852633237839, + 0.1367456465959549, + 0.015181032009422779, + 0.034468360245227814, + 0.030420644208788872, + 0.01999092288315296, + 0.11068934947252274 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1428060382604599 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a low angle looking up at the gymnast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly track the male gymnast as he executes a powerful lunge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the gymnast wearing a tight, sleeveless royal blue and white leotard with crisp white trousers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the gymnast perform a full rotation in the air with legs firmly together and toes pointed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a soft-focus blur of a vast arena and audience while the gymnast is isolated against a deep blue landing mat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005947155877947807 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130947113037109 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005947155877947807, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005947155877947807, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09589898586273193, + 0.11414910852909088, + 0.09861245006322861, + 0.05427097529172897, + 0.21686816215515137, + 0.07500796020030975, + 0.03952115401625633, + 0.08997900038957596, + 0.08723105490207672, + 0.12846113741397858 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005947155877947807 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dynamic low-angle shot captures the pinnacle of athleticism, the camera smoothly tracking a male gymnast executing a powerful lunge. Starting with an explosive push of his hands on the leather-covered pommel horse, his lean, muscular body soars into the air. He wears a tight, sleeveless royal blue and white leotard and crisp white trousers, his short, dark hair damp with sweat. Under the bright, even glare of the overhead stage lights, shadows are minimal, and his body forms a perfectly straight line. Then, gracefully and decisively, he twists through the air, legs firmly together, toes pointed, completing a full rotation with astonishing precision. His face is a mask of intense concentration, jaw set, eyes fixed on his landing. The soft-focus blur of the vast arena and the audience in the distance in the background isolates the gymnast from the deep blue of the thick landing mat below, creating an intense and awe-inspiring atmosphere that celebrates a moment of perfect form and controlled strength.", + "seed": 13691, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_0/index_8800_seed_13691_dp_1_rank_2_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.18466534484177827, + "vlm_logprob": -0.18466534484177827, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.5, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.18466534484177827, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a low angle looking up at the gymnast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly track the male gymnast as he executes a powerful lunge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the gymnast wearing a tight, sleeveless royal blue and white leotard with crisp white trousers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the gymnast perform a full rotation in the air with legs firmly together and toes pointed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a soft-focus blur of a vast arena and audience while the gymnast is isolated against a deep blue landing mat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.34072327613830566 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3407232761383057 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.34072327613830566, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.34072327613830566, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.226507768034935, + 0.10689055174589157, + 0.06918618828058243, + 0.09986088424921036, + 0.057669222354888916, + 0.11037637293338776, + 0.2003501057624817, + 0.039547644555568695, + 0.0349583774805069, + 0.054652854800224304 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.34072327613830566 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a low angle looking up at the gymnast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly track the male gymnast as he executes a powerful lunge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the gymnast wearing a tight, sleeveless royal blue and white leotard with crisp white trousers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the gymnast perform a full rotation in the air with legs firmly together and toes pointed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a soft-focus blur of a vast arena and audience while the gymnast is isolated against a deep blue landing mat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0790371373295784 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5790371894836426 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0790371373295784, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0790371373295784, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20847105979919434, + 0.1560853272676468, + 0.07808740437030792, + 0.09997555613517761, + 0.05356784909963608, + 0.09491956979036331, + 0.1813216507434845, + 0.033565953373909, + 0.04563889652490616, + 0.048366740345954895 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0790371373295784 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a low angle looking up at the gymnast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly track the male gymnast as he executes a powerful lunge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the gymnast wearing a tight, sleeveless royal blue and white leotard with crisp white trousers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the gymnast perform a full rotation in the air with legs firmly together and toes pointed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a soft-focus blur of a vast arena and audience while the gymnast is isolated against a deep blue landing mat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018195616081357002 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018195629119873 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018195616081357002, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018195616081357002, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15497305989265442, + 0.12567490339279175, + 0.03162870556116104, + 0.021247271448373795, + 0.08558008074760437, + 0.08138561993837357, + 0.35839635133743286, + 0.03602096065878868, + 0.039021316915750504, + 0.0660717710852623 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018195616081357002 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a low angle looking up at the gymnast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly track the male gymnast as he executes a powerful lunge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the gymnast wearing a tight, sleeveless royal blue and white leotard with crisp white trousers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the gymnast perform a full rotation in the air with legs firmly together and toes pointed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a soft-focus blur of a vast arena and audience while the gymnast is isolated against a deep blue landing mat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4742940664291382 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9742940664291382 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.4742940664291382, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.4742940664291382, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14517587423324585, + 0.11578361690044403, + 0.08432567119598389, + 0.27891626954078674, + 0.034587785601615906, + 0.07274436950683594, + 0.19238287210464478, + 0.02353767305612564, + 0.028261160477995872, + 0.02428467385470867 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.4742940664291382 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a low angle looking up at the gymnast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly track the male gymnast as he executes a powerful lunge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the gymnast wearing a tight, sleeveless royal blue and white leotard with crisp white trousers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the gymnast perform a full rotation in the air with legs firmly together and toes pointed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a soft-focus blur of a vast arena and audience while the gymnast is isolated against a deep blue landing mat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011076628230512142 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.5110764503479 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011076628230512142, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011076628230512142, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24505722522735596, + 0.04749186709523201, + 0.03247774392366409, + 0.12018471211194992, + 0.14092379808425903, + 0.062239959836006165, + 0.07246465981006622, + 0.19676755368709564, + 0.05968107655644417, + 0.022711437195539474 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011076628230512142 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dynamic low-angle shot captures the pinnacle of athleticism, the camera smoothly tracking a male gymnast executing a powerful lunge. Starting with an explosive push of his hands on the leather-covered pommel horse, his lean, muscular body soars into the air. He wears a tight, sleeveless royal blue and white leotard and crisp white trousers, his short, dark hair damp with sweat. Under the bright, even glare of the overhead stage lights, shadows are minimal, and his body forms a perfectly straight line. Then, gracefully and decisively, he twists through the air, legs firmly together, toes pointed, completing a full rotation with astonishing precision. His face is a mask of intense concentration, jaw set, eyes fixed on his landing. The soft-focus blur of the vast arena and the audience in the distance in the background isolates the gymnast from the deep blue of the thick landing mat below, creating an intense and awe-inspiring atmosphere that celebrates a moment of perfect form and controlled strength.", + "seed": 13692, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_0/index_8800_seed_13692_dp_1_rank_2_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.14233432281762362, + "vlm_logprob": -0.14233432281762362, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.65, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.14233432281762362, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a low angle looking up at the gymnast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly track the male gymnast as he executes a powerful lunge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the gymnast wearing a tight, sleeveless royal blue and white leotard with crisp white trousers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the gymnast perform a full rotation in the air with legs firmly together and toes pointed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a soft-focus blur of a vast arena and audience while the gymnast is isolated against a deep blue landing mat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.35249409079551697 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3524941205978394 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.35249409079551697, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.35249409079551697, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12183332443237305, + 0.10018288344144821, + 0.08163914829492569, + 0.20244625210762024, + 0.10704275220632553, + 0.0837869867682457, + 0.06024680659174919, + 0.0638672336935997, + 0.10425778478384018, + 0.07469677925109863 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.35249409079551697 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a low angle looking up at the gymnast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly track the male gymnast as he executes a powerful lunge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the gymnast wearing a tight, sleeveless royal blue and white leotard with crisp white trousers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the gymnast perform a full rotation in the air with legs firmly together and toes pointed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a soft-focus blur of a vast arena and audience while the gymnast is isolated against a deep blue landing mat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.160453200340271 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.910453200340271 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.160453200340271, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.160453200340271, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09739577770233154, + 0.084224633872509, + 0.18756155669689178, + 0.10284359008073807, + 0.11626539379358292, + 0.03750920295715332, + 0.042630866169929504, + 0.07112613320350647, + 0.05260545760393143, + 0.20783743262290955 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.160453200340271 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a low angle looking up at the gymnast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly track the male gymnast as he executes a powerful lunge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the gymnast wearing a tight, sleeveless royal blue and white leotard with crisp white trousers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the gymnast perform a full rotation in the air with legs firmly together and toes pointed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a soft-focus blur of a vast arena and audience while the gymnast is isolated against a deep blue landing mat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03371158614754677 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4087116718292236 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03371158614754677, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03371158614754677, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10910619795322418, + 0.11765511333942413, + 0.08386480063199997, + 0.3190823197364807, + 0.0655951276421547, + 0.0626058429479599, + 0.0862293466925621, + 0.03537530079483986, + 0.048337314277887344, + 0.07214862108230591 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03371158614754677 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a low angle looking up at the gymnast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly track the male gymnast as he executes a powerful lunge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the gymnast wearing a tight, sleeveless royal blue and white leotard with crisp white trousers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the gymnast perform a full rotation in the air with legs firmly together and toes pointed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a soft-focus blur of a vast arena and audience while the gymnast is isolated against a deep blue landing mat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1603754162788391 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9103753566741943 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1603754162788391, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1603754162788391, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06486884504556656, + 0.07533261179924011, + 0.0914408341050148, + 0.12933027744293213, + 0.3822920322418213, + 0.05149092525243759, + 0.04556175693869591, + 0.03700360283255577, + 0.06105512008070946, + 0.061624061316251755 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1603754162788391 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a low angle looking up at the gymnast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly track the male gymnast as he executes a powerful lunge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the gymnast wearing a tight, sleeveless royal blue and white leotard with crisp white trousers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the gymnast perform a full rotation in the air with legs firmly together and toes pointed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a soft-focus blur of a vast arena and audience while the gymnast is isolated against a deep blue landing mat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004637320525944233 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379637241363525 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004637320525944233, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004637320525944233, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09673124551773071, + 0.09959312528371811, + 0.07312320172786713, + 0.03520679473876953, + 0.07039115577936172, + 0.08774244040250778, + 0.3026667833328247, + 0.05091080069541931, + 0.08570457249879837, + 0.09792985022068024 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004637320525944233 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_1/index_tensor([2695, 2695])_group_1_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_1/index_tensor([2695, 2695])_group_1_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..b7dc4764dd77e6ce84331fda998e4de690054966 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_1/index_tensor([2695, 2695])_group_1_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "wide-angle shot, shot from a slightly upward angle and panning slowly to the right, captures a solitary dancer, lost in the ecstasy of a twirl in the center of a grand yet empty Baroque ballroom. Her long, dark brown curls are elegantly tied into a loose bun, a few strands of hair freed from their restraints as she spins, gently brushing against her serene face, eyes closed and a hint of a smile playing on her lips. She wears a deep, royal blue, sleeveless silk gown, the tight bodice emphasizing her slender waist. The massive, multi-tiered skirt, lifted high by centrifugal force as she steadily and effortlessly spun, pivoting on the toe of her left foot, unfolds like a fully blossoming blue flower, almost parallel to the ground, its pleats drawing graceful, undulating curves in the air. A massive crystal chandelier atop the soaring dome casts a warm, radiant golden light, illuminating the mirror-like polished marble floor, which reflects the dancers' twirling figures and the blurred motion of their skirts, as well as the intricate gold reliefs on the walls. Light filters through the swirling skirts, casting ever-shifting, interwoven patterns of light and shadow on the floor. The entire scene, bathed in warm hues, creates an atmosphere of profound tranquility, dreamy elegance, and a touch of solitary elegance.", + "seed": 29085, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_1/index_2695_seed_29085_dp_2_rank_4_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.02007809402421117, + "vlm_logprob": -0.02007809402421117, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.65, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.02007809402421117, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a grand, empty Baroque ballroom with gold reliefs on the walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a female dancer wearing a deep royal blue sleeveless silk gown with a tight bodice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the dancer's skirt a massive multi-tiered blue skirt that is lifted high and unfolds parallel to the ground while she spins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the dancer spinning on the toe of her left foot with her eyes closed and a hint of a smile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera use a wide-angle shot from a slightly upward angle that pans slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00217106519266963 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.252171039581299 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00217106519266963, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00217106519266963, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03054904192686081, + 0.02260749228298664, + 0.01430812943726778, + 0.10550181567668915, + 0.006702969316393137, + 0.024721169844269753, + 0.028654873371124268, + 0.010536029003560543, + 0.03073245845735073, + 0.7256860136985779 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 3, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00217106519266963 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a grand, empty Baroque ballroom with gold reliefs on the walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a female dancer wearing a deep royal blue sleeveless silk gown with a tight bodice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the dancer's skirt a massive multi-tiered blue skirt that is lifted high and unfolds parallel to the ground while she spins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the dancer spinning on the toe of her left foot with her eyes closed and a hint of a smile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera use a wide-angle shot from a slightly upward angle that pans slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005950829479843378 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130950927734375 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005950829479843378, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005950829479843378, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08738532662391663, + 0.030987273901700974, + 0.032267920672893524, + 0.08823109418153763, + 0.042380884289741516, + 0.038129668682813644, + 0.038803424686193466, + 0.031777091324329376, + 0.029253991320729256, + 0.5807833075523376 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005950829479843378 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a grand, empty Baroque ballroom with gold reliefs on the walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a female dancer wearing a deep royal blue sleeveless silk gown with a tight bodice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the dancer's skirt a massive multi-tiered blue skirt that is lifted high and unfolds parallel to the ground while she spins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the dancer spinning on the toe of her left foot with her eyes closed and a hint of a smile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera use a wide-angle shot from a slightly upward angle that pans slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036168177612125874 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628616809844971 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036168177612125874, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036168177612125874, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.024258114397525787, + 0.0298685971647501, + 0.023249967023730278, + 0.07683341205120087, + 0.02522953972220421, + 0.05157927796244621, + 0.033252425491809845, + 0.01891602762043476, + 0.02471221052110195, + 0.6921004056930542 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036168177612125874 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a grand, empty Baroque ballroom with gold reliefs on the walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a female dancer wearing a deep royal blue sleeveless silk gown with a tight bodice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the dancer's skirt a massive multi-tiered blue skirt that is lifted high and unfolds parallel to the ground while she spins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the dancer spinning on the toe of her left foot with her eyes closed and a hint of a smile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera use a wide-angle shot from a slightly upward angle that pans slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.054967835545539856 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299678802490234 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.054967835545539856, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.054967835545539856, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04472975805401802, + 0.047661736607551575, + 0.044311363250017166, + 0.038115210831165314, + 0.021822551265358925, + 0.016872959211468697, + 0.01815991848707199, + 0.024113964289426804, + 0.02401396445930004, + 0.7201985716819763 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.054967835545539856 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a grand, empty Baroque ballroom with gold reliefs on the walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a female dancer wearing a deep royal blue sleeveless silk gown with a tight bodice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the dancer's skirt a massive multi-tiered blue skirt that is lifted high and unfolds parallel to the ground while she spins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the dancer spinning on the toe of her left foot with her eyes closed and a hint of a smile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera use a wide-angle shot from a slightly upward angle that pans slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03368392214179039 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408684015274048 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03368392214179039, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03368392214179039, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09123438596725464, + 0.058380305767059326, + 0.07423244416713715, + 0.11311013251543045, + 0.05676468089222908, + 0.11649914085865021, + 0.05439553037285805, + 0.0318157933652401, + 0.040063679218292236, + 0.3635038435459137 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03368392214179039 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "wide-angle shot, shot from a slightly upward angle and panning slowly to the right, captures a solitary dancer, lost in the ecstasy of a twirl in the center of a grand yet empty Baroque ballroom. Her long, dark brown curls are elegantly tied into a loose bun, a few strands of hair freed from their restraints as she spins, gently brushing against her serene face, eyes closed and a hint of a smile playing on her lips. She wears a deep, royal blue, sleeveless silk gown, the tight bodice emphasizing her slender waist. The massive, multi-tiered skirt, lifted high by centrifugal force as she steadily and effortlessly spun, pivoting on the toe of her left foot, unfolds like a fully blossoming blue flower, almost parallel to the ground, its pleats drawing graceful, undulating curves in the air. A massive crystal chandelier atop the soaring dome casts a warm, radiant golden light, illuminating the mirror-like polished marble floor, which reflects the dancers' twirling figures and the blurred motion of their skirts, as well as the intricate gold reliefs on the walls. Light filters through the swirling skirts, casting ever-shifting, interwoven patterns of light and shadow on the floor. The entire scene, bathed in warm hues, creates an atmosphere of profound tranquility, dreamy elegance, and a touch of solitary elegance.", + "seed": 29086, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_1/index_2695_seed_29086_dp_2_rank_4_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.029340671887621284, + "vlm_logprob": -0.029340671887621284, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.3, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.029340671887621284, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a grand, empty Baroque ballroom with gold reliefs on the walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a female dancer wearing a deep royal blue sleeveless silk gown with a tight bodice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the dancer's skirt a massive multi-tiered blue skirt that is lifted high and unfolds parallel to the ground while she spins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the dancer spinning on the toe of her left foot with her eyes closed and a hint of a smile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera use a wide-angle shot from a slightly upward angle that pans slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004299325868487358 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504299163818359 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004299325868487358, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004299325868487358, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07076943665742874, + 0.045527517795562744, + 0.027566581964492798, + 0.1988760530948639, + 0.035867903381586075, + 0.048154037445783615, + 0.0370757095515728, + 0.2511904835700989, + 0.0639650970697403, + 0.22100716829299927 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004299325868487358 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a grand, empty Baroque ballroom with gold reliefs on the walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a female dancer wearing a deep royal blue sleeveless silk gown with a tight bodice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the dancer's skirt a massive multi-tiered blue skirt that is lifted high and unfolds parallel to the ground while she spins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the dancer spinning on the toe of her left foot with her eyes closed and a hint of a smile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera use a wide-angle shot from a slightly upward angle that pans slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006740333512425423 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006740570068359 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006740333512425423, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006740333512425423, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08744469285011292, + 0.08594723045825958, + 0.050024617463350296, + 0.04667554050683975, + 0.1139269471168518, + 0.14166750013828278, + 0.036292754113674164, + 0.07836979627609253, + 0.3003517687320709, + 0.059299178421497345 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006740333512425423 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a grand, empty Baroque ballroom with gold reliefs on the walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a female dancer wearing a deep royal blue sleeveless silk gown with a tight bodice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the dancer's skirt a massive multi-tiered blue skirt that is lifted high and unfolds parallel to the ground while she spins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the dancer spinning on the toe of her left foot with her eyes closed and a hint of a smile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera use a wide-angle shot from a slightly upward angle that pans slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036157488357275724 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628615856170654 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036157488357275724, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036157488357275724, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06428616493940353, + 0.05831249803304672, + 0.048754893243312836, + 0.2269527167081833, + 0.148421049118042, + 0.08866392076015472, + 0.01974768564105034, + 0.041088834404945374, + 0.13039982318878174, + 0.17337234318256378 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036157488357275724 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a grand, empty Baroque ballroom with gold reliefs on the walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a female dancer wearing a deep royal blue sleeveless silk gown with a tight bodice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the dancer's skirt a massive multi-tiered blue skirt that is lifted high and unfolds parallel to the ground while she spins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the dancer spinning on the toe of her left foot with her eyes closed and a hint of a smile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera use a wide-angle shot from a slightly upward angle that pans slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07003159821033478 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950316429138184 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07003159821033478, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07003159821033478, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07689658552408218, + 0.06806527078151703, + 0.06771839410066605, + 0.12768608331680298, + 0.09180419892072678, + 0.06698701530694962, + 0.09462179243564606, + 0.14029806852340698, + 0.18118998408317566, + 0.08473258465528488 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07003159821033478 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a grand, empty Baroque ballroom with gold reliefs on the walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a female dancer wearing a deep royal blue sleeveless silk gown with a tight bodice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the dancer's skirt a massive multi-tiered blue skirt that is lifted high and unfolds parallel to the ground while she spins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the dancer spinning on the toe of her left foot with her eyes closed and a hint of a smile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera use a wide-angle shot from a slightly upward angle that pans slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06201635301113129 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812016248703003 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06201635301113129, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06201635301113129, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.054351288825273514, + 0.10320740938186646, + 0.07936979830265045, + 0.23686547577381134, + 0.10902419686317444, + 0.12187782675027847, + 0.039013367146253586, + 0.05754932388663292, + 0.06959573179483414, + 0.1291455775499344 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06201635301113129 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "wide-angle shot, shot from a slightly upward angle and panning slowly to the right, captures a solitary dancer, lost in the ecstasy of a twirl in the center of a grand yet empty Baroque ballroom. Her long, dark brown curls are elegantly tied into a loose bun, a few strands of hair freed from their restraints as she spins, gently brushing against her serene face, eyes closed and a hint of a smile playing on her lips. She wears a deep, royal blue, sleeveless silk gown, the tight bodice emphasizing her slender waist. The massive, multi-tiered skirt, lifted high by centrifugal force as she steadily and effortlessly spun, pivoting on the toe of her left foot, unfolds like a fully blossoming blue flower, almost parallel to the ground, its pleats drawing graceful, undulating curves in the air. A massive crystal chandelier atop the soaring dome casts a warm, radiant golden light, illuminating the mirror-like polished marble floor, which reflects the dancers' twirling figures and the blurred motion of their skirts, as well as the intricate gold reliefs on the walls. Light filters through the swirling skirts, casting ever-shifting, interwoven patterns of light and shadow on the floor. The entire scene, bathed in warm hues, creates an atmosphere of profound tranquility, dreamy elegance, and a touch of solitary elegance.", + "seed": 29087, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_1/index_2695_seed_29087_dp_3_rank_6_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.020852612098678946, + "vlm_logprob": -0.020852612098678946, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.475, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.020852612098678946, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a grand, empty Baroque ballroom with gold reliefs on the walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a female dancer wearing a deep royal blue sleeveless silk gown with a tight bodice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the dancer's skirt a massive multi-tiered blue skirt that is lifted high and unfolds parallel to the ground while she spins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the dancer spinning on the toe of her left foot with her eyes closed and a hint of a smile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera use a wide-angle shot from a slightly upward angle that pans slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002720704535022378 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002720832824707 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002720704535022378, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002720704535022378, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1412595510482788, + 0.06766331195831299, + 0.18403373658657074, + 0.05186647176742554, + 0.06448505073785782, + 0.07985315471887589, + 0.14869153499603271, + 0.09146874397993088, + 0.09203368425369263, + 0.0786447674036026 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002720704535022378 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a grand, empty Baroque ballroom with gold reliefs on the walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a female dancer wearing a deep royal blue sleeveless silk gown with a tight bodice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the dancer's skirt a massive multi-tiered blue skirt that is lifted high and unfolds parallel to the ground while she spins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the dancer spinning on the toe of her left foot with her eyes closed and a hint of a smile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera use a wide-angle shot from a slightly upward angle that pans slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00763498293235898 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882635116577148 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00763498293235898, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00763498293235898, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14973221719264984, + 0.11052265018224716, + 0.09643171727657318, + 0.08160131424665451, + 0.0461316853761673, + 0.06394290179014206, + 0.1605108380317688, + 0.14274419844150543, + 0.07692377269268036, + 0.07145877182483673 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00763498293235898 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a grand, empty Baroque ballroom with gold reliefs on the walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a female dancer wearing a deep royal blue sleeveless silk gown with a tight bodice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the dancer's skirt a massive multi-tiered blue skirt that is lifted high and unfolds parallel to the ground while she spins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the dancer spinning on the toe of her left foot with her eyes closed and a hint of a smile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera use a wide-angle shot from a slightly upward angle that pans slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005254032090306282 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.25525426864624 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005254032090306282, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005254032090306282, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1441017985343933, + 0.06723935902118683, + 0.09666969627141953, + 0.04447014257311821, + 0.07690127193927765, + 0.06308932602405548, + 0.0901627168059349, + 0.19589343667030334, + 0.10488744080066681, + 0.11658487468957901 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005254032090306282 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a grand, empty Baroque ballroom with gold reliefs on the walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a female dancer wearing a deep royal blue sleeveless silk gown with a tight bodice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the dancer's skirt a massive multi-tiered blue skirt that is lifted high and unfolds parallel to the ground while she spins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the dancer spinning on the toe of her left foot with her eyes closed and a hint of a smile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera use a wide-angle shot from a slightly upward angle that pans slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05496930330991745 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929969310760498 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05496930330991745, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05496930330991745, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14348872005939484, + 0.07068236172199249, + 0.08014310896396637, + 0.061783090233802795, + 0.04532138630747795, + 0.08459053188562393, + 0.12008043378591537, + 0.12569595873355865, + 0.07256663590669632, + 0.19564774632453918 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05496930330991745 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a grand, empty Baroque ballroom with gold reliefs on the walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a female dancer wearing a deep royal blue sleeveless silk gown with a tight bodice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the dancer's skirt a massive multi-tiered blue skirt that is lifted high and unfolds parallel to the ground while she spins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the dancer spinning on the toe of her left foot with her eyes closed and a hint of a smile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera use a wide-angle shot from a slightly upward angle that pans slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03368403762578964 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408684015274048 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03368403762578964, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03368403762578964, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17373593151569366, + 0.08588153123855591, + 0.20310838520526886, + 0.08414085954427719, + 0.061264459043741226, + 0.06201880797743797, + 0.07363540679216385, + 0.0537576749920845, + 0.0953061431646347, + 0.10715082287788391 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03368403762578964 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "wide-angle shot, shot from a slightly upward angle and panning slowly to the right, captures a solitary dancer, lost in the ecstasy of a twirl in the center of a grand yet empty Baroque ballroom. Her long, dark brown curls are elegantly tied into a loose bun, a few strands of hair freed from their restraints as she spins, gently brushing against her serene face, eyes closed and a hint of a smile playing on her lips. She wears a deep, royal blue, sleeveless silk gown, the tight bodice emphasizing her slender waist. The massive, multi-tiered skirt, lifted high by centrifugal force as she steadily and effortlessly spun, pivoting on the toe of her left foot, unfolds like a fully blossoming blue flower, almost parallel to the ground, its pleats drawing graceful, undulating curves in the air. A massive crystal chandelier atop the soaring dome casts a warm, radiant golden light, illuminating the mirror-like polished marble floor, which reflects the dancers' twirling figures and the blurred motion of their skirts, as well as the intricate gold reliefs on the walls. Light filters through the swirling skirts, casting ever-shifting, interwoven patterns of light and shadow on the floor. The entire scene, bathed in warm hues, creates an atmosphere of profound tranquility, dreamy elegance, and a touch of solitary elegance.", + "seed": 29088, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_1/index_2695_seed_29088_dp_3_rank_6_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.02520246906206012, + "vlm_logprob": -0.02520246906206012, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.35, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.02520246906206012, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a grand, empty Baroque ballroom with gold reliefs on the walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a female dancer wearing a deep royal blue sleeveless silk gown with a tight bodice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the dancer's skirt a massive multi-tiered blue skirt that is lifted high and unfolds parallel to the ground while she spins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the dancer spinning on the toe of her left foot with her eyes closed and a hint of a smile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera use a wide-angle shot from a slightly upward angle that pans slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0038484097458422184 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628848552703857 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0038484097458422184, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0038484097458422184, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17590002715587616, + 0.0625089779496193, + 0.08934902399778366, + 0.07709301263093948, + 0.0384780690073967, + 0.1160304918885231, + 0.24232785403728485, + 0.1029728353023529, + 0.035627491772174835, + 0.05971219018101692 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0038484097458422184 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a grand, empty Baroque ballroom with gold reliefs on the walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a female dancer wearing a deep royal blue sleeveless silk gown with a tight bodice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the dancer's skirt a massive multi-tiered blue skirt that is lifted high and unfolds parallel to the ground while she spins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the dancer spinning on the toe of her left foot with her eyes closed and a hint of a smile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera use a wide-angle shot from a slightly upward angle that pans slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008643949404358864 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758644104003906 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008643949404358864, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008643949404358864, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16938897967338562, + 0.05811847001314163, + 0.09825091809034348, + 0.07681891322135925, + 0.025692909955978394, + 0.15601976215839386, + 0.14209763705730438, + 0.03894493728876114, + 0.14189347624778748, + 0.09277400374412537 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008643949404358864 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a grand, empty Baroque ballroom with gold reliefs on the walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a female dancer wearing a deep royal blue sleeveless silk gown with a tight bodice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the dancer's skirt a massive multi-tiered blue skirt that is lifted high and unfolds parallel to the ground while she spins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the dancer spinning on the toe of her left foot with her eyes closed and a hint of a smile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera use a wide-angle shot from a slightly upward angle that pans slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003616699017584324 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628616809844971 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003616699017584324, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003616699017584324, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12671470642089844, + 0.03065897710621357, + 0.03813052922487259, + 0.059702929109334946, + 0.026988070458173752, + 0.11036206781864166, + 0.3137989640235901, + 0.23484095931053162, + 0.023176155984401703, + 0.035626690834760666 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003616699017584324 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a grand, empty Baroque ballroom with gold reliefs on the walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a female dancer wearing a deep royal blue sleeveless silk gown with a tight bodice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the dancer's skirt a massive multi-tiered blue skirt that is lifted high and unfolds parallel to the ground while she spins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the dancer spinning on the toe of her left foot with her eyes closed and a hint of a smile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera use a wide-angle shot from a slightly upward angle that pans slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05497020483016968 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299702644348145 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05497020483016968, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05497020483016968, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08660722523927689, + 0.052351538091897964, + 0.20545043051242828, + 0.15230979025363922, + 0.02685181051492691, + 0.10782201588153839, + 0.16490915417671204, + 0.1166878342628479, + 0.058761198073625565, + 0.02824893407523632 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 6, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05497020483016968 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a grand, empty Baroque ballroom with gold reliefs on the walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a female dancer wearing a deep royal blue sleeveless silk gown with a tight bodice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the dancer's skirt a massive multi-tiered blue skirt that is lifted high and unfolds parallel to the ground while she spins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the dancer spinning on the toe of her left foot with her eyes closed and a hint of a smile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera use a wide-angle shot from a slightly upward angle that pans slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.054933082312345505 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299330711364746 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.054933082312345505, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.054933082312345505, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0916265994310379, + 0.022691242396831512, + 0.08372105658054352, + 0.10389009863138199, + 0.021006258204579353, + 0.08736289292573929, + 0.32873618602752686, + 0.22266581654548645, + 0.0227564238011837, + 0.01554337702691555 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.054933082312345505 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_10/index_tensor([6936, 6936])_group_10_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_10/index_tensor([6936, 6936])_group_10_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..31c2e054765f4c84edfe764704691d7b9121e837 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_10/index_tensor([6936, 6936])_group_10_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "slowly advancing, empty shot captures a corner of a bare room. A warm, slanting beam of sunset light filters through an unrecognized window, casting a precise shadow across the dusty wooden floor, illuminating a pair of aluminum medical crutches resting quietly against a mottled corner. Their gray rubber grips and armpit pads appear worn, and the gleaming, cold metal brackets bear slight scratches, silently telling a forgotten story. As the camera moves forward ever more slowly, an incredible process unfolds: the cold metal surface of the crutches begins to petrify inch by inch, its original luster gradually fading, replaced by a rough, grayish-white texture. Microscopic cracks creep from the contact points like a spiderweb, strikingly clear in the warm, golden light. Finally, when the camera lingers in close-up, the pair of crutches has completely transformed into a silent sculpture, covered with deep and poignant cracks, as if solidifying a heavy memory in an eternal form. The whole picture, with its sharp contrast of warm light and cold texture, creates a sad atmosphere of forgetfulness, silence and the solidification of time.", + "seed": 24576, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_10/index_6936_seed_24576_dp_20_rank_40_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.21827886865939944, + "vlm_logprob": -0.21827886865939944, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.099999988079071, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.21827886865939944, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene an empty corner of a bare room with a dusty wooden floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a warm, slanting beam of sunset light visible filtering through a window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of aluminum medical crutches with gray rubber grips and armpit pads visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the crutch metal surface gradually transform from gleaming cold metal to a rough, grayish-white petrified texture with cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move forward slowly and end in a close-up shot of the transformed crutches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.0552394390106201 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.43023937940597534 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.0552394390106201, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.6250000596046448, + "token_credit_reward": -1.0552394390106201, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.40094587206840515, + 0.0890854001045227, + 0.08117744326591492, + 0.04541323706507683, + 0.07506897300481796, + 0.04523318633437157, + 0.10121946781873703, + 0.06601852178573608, + 0.02872399240732193, + 0.06711380183696747 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.0552394390106201 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene an empty corner of a bare room with a dusty wooden floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a warm, slanting beam of sunset light visible filtering through a window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of aluminum medical crutches with gray rubber grips and armpit pads visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the crutch metal surface gradually transform from gleaming cold metal to a rough, grayish-white petrified texture with cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move forward slowly and end in a close-up shot of the transformed crutches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026369184255599976 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651369094848633 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026369184255599976, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026369184255599976, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.48827821016311646, + 0.045379579067230225, + 0.0340854711830616, + 0.08312216401100159, + 0.07777310907840729, + 0.034997954964637756, + 0.05112411081790924, + 0.04742846637964249, + 0.04742036387324333, + 0.09039052575826645 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026369184255599976 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene an empty corner of a bare room with a dusty wooden floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a warm, slanting beam of sunset light visible filtering through a window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of aluminum medical crutches with gray rubber grips and armpit pads visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the crutch metal surface gradually transform from gleaming cold metal to a rough, grayish-white petrified texture with cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move forward slowly and end in a close-up shot of the transformed crutches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0017184742027893662 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.376718521118164 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0017184742027893662, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0017184742027893662, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.164857417345047, + 0.09140409529209137, + 0.04624437168240547, + 0.16590546071529388, + 0.0558764822781086, + 0.06476449966430664, + 0.0867084488272667, + 0.05676276981830597, + 0.13671691715717316, + 0.13075950741767883 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0017184742027893662 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene an empty corner of a bare room with a dusty wooden floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a warm, slanting beam of sunset light visible filtering through a window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of aluminum medical crutches with gray rubber grips and armpit pads visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the crutch metal surface gradually transform from gleaming cold metal to a rough, grayish-white petrified texture with cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move forward slowly and end in a close-up shot of the transformed crutches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0028217521030455828 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877821922302246 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0028217521030455828, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0028217521030455828, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13005444407463074, + 0.04678191617131233, + 0.1265333741903305, + 0.10894250869750977, + 0.043529659509658813, + 0.053487952798604965, + 0.04007398337125778, + 0.08748944103717804, + 0.16126683354377747, + 0.201839879155159 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0028217521030455828 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene an empty corner of a bare room with a dusty wooden floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a warm, slanting beam of sunset light visible filtering through a window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of aluminum medical crutches with gray rubber grips and armpit pads visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the crutch metal surface gradually transform from gleaming cold metal to a rough, grayish-white petrified texture with cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move forward slowly and end in a close-up shot of the transformed crutches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005245493724942207 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255245685577393 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005245493724942207, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005245493724942207, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08355510234832764, + 0.04280617833137512, + 0.06147763505578041, + 0.10748255997896194, + 0.38923710584640503, + 0.07972172647714615, + 0.031174488365650177, + 0.059464070945978165, + 0.09855806082487106, + 0.04652313143014908 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005245493724942207 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slowly advancing, empty shot captures a corner of a bare room. A warm, slanting beam of sunset light filters through an unrecognized window, casting a precise shadow across the dusty wooden floor, illuminating a pair of aluminum medical crutches resting quietly against a mottled corner. Their gray rubber grips and armpit pads appear worn, and the gleaming, cold metal brackets bear slight scratches, silently telling a forgotten story. As the camera moves forward ever more slowly, an incredible process unfolds: the cold metal surface of the crutches begins to petrify inch by inch, its original luster gradually fading, replaced by a rough, grayish-white texture. Microscopic cracks creep from the contact points like a spiderweb, strikingly clear in the warm, golden light. Finally, when the camera lingers in close-up, the pair of crutches has completely transformed into a silent sculpture, covered with deep and poignant cracks, as if solidifying a heavy memory in an eternal form. The whole picture, with its sharp contrast of warm light and cold texture, creates a sad atmosphere of forgetfulness, silence and the solidification of time.", + "seed": 24577, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_10/index_6936_seed_24577_dp_20_rank_40_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.08471881044097244, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08471881044097244, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.7, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08471881044097244, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene an empty corner of a bare room with a dusty wooden floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a warm, slanting beam of sunset light visible filtering through a window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of aluminum medical crutches with gray rubber grips and armpit pads visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the crutch metal surface gradually transform from gleaming cold metal to a rough, grayish-white petrified texture with cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move forward slowly and end in a close-up shot of the transformed crutches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.35225656628608704 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2272565364837646 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.35225656628608704, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.35225656628608704, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2654111087322235, + 0.10354555398225784, + 0.05033199116587639, + 0.19367094337940216, + 0.05800022557377815, + 0.05639398843050003, + 0.042019072920084, + 0.05951567739248276, + 0.059143636375665665, + 0.11196780204772949 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.35225656628608704 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene an empty corner of a bare room with a dusty wooden floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a warm, slanting beam of sunset light visible filtering through a window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of aluminum medical crutches with gray rubber grips and armpit pads visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the crutch metal surface gradually transform from gleaming cold metal to a rough, grayish-white petrified texture with cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move forward slowly and end in a close-up shot of the transformed crutches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03814331442117691 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881433963775635 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03814331442117691, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03814331442117691, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.45220571756362915, + 0.06622036546468735, + 0.059482332319021225, + 0.05496649444103241, + 0.10200274735689163, + 0.050772979855537415, + 0.015794234350323677, + 0.015211954712867737, + 0.04586256667971611, + 0.13748057186603546 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03814331442117691 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene an empty corner of a bare room with a dusty wooden floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a warm, slanting beam of sunset light visible filtering through a window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of aluminum medical crutches with gray rubber grips and armpit pads visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the crutch metal surface gradually transform from gleaming cold metal to a rough, grayish-white petrified texture with cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move forward slowly and end in a close-up shot of the transformed crutches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020592117682099342 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895592212677002 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020592117682099342, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020592117682099342, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10008414089679718, + 0.08210784196853638, + 0.022515445947647095, + 0.050278034061193466, + 0.054829977452754974, + 0.08865582197904587, + 0.04261913523077965, + 0.03732728585600853, + 0.08863379061222076, + 0.4329484701156616 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020592117682099342 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene an empty corner of a bare room with a dusty wooden floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a warm, slanting beam of sunset light visible filtering through a window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of aluminum medical crutches with gray rubber grips and armpit pads visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the crutch metal surface gradually transform from gleaming cold metal to a rough, grayish-white petrified texture with cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move forward slowly and end in a close-up shot of the transformed crutches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009786602109670639 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634786605834961 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009786602109670639, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009786602109670639, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.054531726986169815, + 0.03320759907364845, + 0.02190009132027626, + 0.028103016316890717, + 0.0190094206482172, + 0.04440530017018318, + 0.02955837920308113, + 0.03473943844437599, + 0.17098693549633026, + 0.563558042049408 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009786602109670639 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene an empty corner of a bare room with a dusty wooden floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a warm, slanting beam of sunset light visible filtering through a window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of aluminum medical crutches with gray rubber grips and armpit pads visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the crutch metal surface gradually transform from gleaming cold metal to a rough, grayish-white petrified texture with cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move forward slowly and end in a close-up shot of the transformed crutches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002815451705828309 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877815246582031 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002815451705828309, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002815451705828309, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09903280436992645, + 0.06792129576206207, + 0.058387745171785355, + 0.02706030197441578, + 0.041245125234127045, + 0.09758155047893524, + 0.04037744551897049, + 0.06232958287000656, + 0.11599815636873245, + 0.3900660574436188 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002815451705828309 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slowly advancing, empty shot captures a corner of a bare room. A warm, slanting beam of sunset light filters through an unrecognized window, casting a precise shadow across the dusty wooden floor, illuminating a pair of aluminum medical crutches resting quietly against a mottled corner. Their gray rubber grips and armpit pads appear worn, and the gleaming, cold metal brackets bear slight scratches, silently telling a forgotten story. As the camera moves forward ever more slowly, an incredible process unfolds: the cold metal surface of the crutches begins to petrify inch by inch, its original luster gradually fading, replaced by a rough, grayish-white texture. Microscopic cracks creep from the contact points like a spiderweb, strikingly clear in the warm, golden light. Finally, when the camera lingers in close-up, the pair of crutches has completely transformed into a silent sculpture, covered with deep and poignant cracks, as if solidifying a heavy memory in an eternal form. The whole picture, with its sharp contrast of warm light and cold texture, creates a sad atmosphere of forgetfulness, silence and the solidification of time.", + "seed": 24578, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_10/index_6936_seed_24578_dp_21_rank_42_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.22859004235360772, + "vlm_logprob": -0.22859004235360772, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.95, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.22859004235360772, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene an empty corner of a bare room with a dusty wooden floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a warm, slanting beam of sunset light visible filtering through a window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of aluminum medical crutches with gray rubber grips and armpit pads visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the crutch metal surface gradually transform from gleaming cold metal to a rough, grayish-white petrified texture with cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move forward slowly and end in a close-up shot of the transformed crutches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.0546550750732422 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4296551048755646 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.0546550750732422, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.625, + "token_credit_reward": -1.0546550750732422, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.6310871839523315, + 0.04375574737787247, + 0.05588928982615471, + 0.03726785257458687, + 0.017867548391222954, + 0.13456180691719055, + 0.009331905283033848, + 0.019863944500684738, + 0.01739821769297123, + 0.03297651559114456 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.0546550750732422 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene an empty corner of a bare room with a dusty wooden floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a warm, slanting beam of sunset light visible filtering through a window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of aluminum medical crutches with gray rubber grips and armpit pads visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the crutch metal surface gradually transform from gleaming cold metal to a rough, grayish-white petrified texture with cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move forward slowly and end in a close-up shot of the transformed crutches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07904033362865448 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.579040288925171 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07904033362865448, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07904033362865448, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.6153462529182434, + 0.06526537984609604, + 0.02208160236477852, + 0.04225733131170273, + 0.009587778709828854, + 0.10429905354976654, + 0.018640698865056038, + 0.029807142913341522, + 0.04580803960561752, + 0.04690677672624588 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07904033362865448 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene an empty corner of a bare room with a dusty wooden floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a warm, slanting beam of sunset light visible filtering through a window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of aluminum medical crutches with gray rubber grips and armpit pads visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the crutch metal surface gradually transform from gleaming cold metal to a rough, grayish-white petrified texture with cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move forward slowly and end in a close-up shot of the transformed crutches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0028267446905374527 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877826690673828 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0028267446905374527, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0028267446905374527, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5106711387634277, + 0.12229830771684647, + 0.0845806822180748, + 0.07282543927431107, + 0.019317759200930595, + 0.02239152602851391, + 0.020151447504758835, + 0.019926248118281364, + 0.03232954442501068, + 0.09550787508487701 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0028267446905374527 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene an empty corner of a bare room with a dusty wooden floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a warm, slanting beam of sunset light visible filtering through a window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of aluminum medical crutches with gray rubber grips and armpit pads visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the crutch metal surface gradually transform from gleaming cold metal to a rough, grayish-white petrified texture with cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move forward slowly and end in a close-up shot of the transformed crutches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0011807858245447278 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.751180648803711 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0011807858245447278, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0011807858245447278, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3731426000595093, + 0.04895709082484245, + 0.04447103291749954, + 0.03581681102514267, + 0.02932801842689514, + 0.028104472905397415, + 0.022441783919930458, + 0.050846926867961884, + 0.12115885317325592, + 0.2457324117422104 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0011807858245447278 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene an empty corner of a bare room with a dusty wooden floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a warm, slanting beam of sunset light visible filtering through a window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of aluminum medical crutches with gray rubber grips and armpit pads visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the crutch metal surface gradually transform from gleaming cold metal to a rough, grayish-white petrified texture with cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move forward slowly and end in a close-up shot of the transformed crutches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005247272551059723 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255247116088867 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005247272551059723, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005247272551059723, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.40809470415115356, + 0.038579389452934265, + 0.04073652997612953, + 0.05710415169596672, + 0.01302905660122633, + 0.031005702912807465, + 0.029178358614444733, + 0.2655391991138458, + 0.06960819661617279, + 0.0471247136592865 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005247272551059723 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slowly advancing, empty shot captures a corner of a bare room. A warm, slanting beam of sunset light filters through an unrecognized window, casting a precise shadow across the dusty wooden floor, illuminating a pair of aluminum medical crutches resting quietly against a mottled corner. Their gray rubber grips and armpit pads appear worn, and the gleaming, cold metal brackets bear slight scratches, silently telling a forgotten story. As the camera moves forward ever more slowly, an incredible process unfolds: the cold metal surface of the crutches begins to petrify inch by inch, its original luster gradually fading, replaced by a rough, grayish-white texture. Microscopic cracks creep from the contact points like a spiderweb, strikingly clear in the warm, golden light. Finally, when the camera lingers in close-up, the pair of crutches has completely transformed into a silent sculpture, covered with deep and poignant cracks, as if solidifying a heavy memory in an eternal form. The whole picture, with its sharp contrast of warm light and cold texture, creates a sad atmosphere of forgetfulness, silence and the solidification of time.", + "seed": 24579, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_10/index_6936_seed_24579_dp_21_rank_42_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.010030477773398161, + "vlm_logprob": -0.010030477773398161, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 5.4, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.010030477773398161, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene an empty corner of a bare room with a dusty wooden floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a warm, slanting beam of sunset light visible filtering through a window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of aluminum medical crutches with gray rubber grips and armpit pads visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the crutch metal surface gradually transform from gleaming cold metal to a rough, grayish-white petrified texture with cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move forward slowly and end in a close-up shot of the transformed crutches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.019687717780470848 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.019687652587891 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.019687717780470848, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.019687717780470848, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17397184669971466, + 0.10881710797548294, + 0.1285121887922287, + 0.08522156625986099, + 0.04566925764083862, + 0.09795428067445755, + 0.07836128771305084, + 0.08379993587732315, + 0.05526554957032204, + 0.14242686331272125 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.019687717780470848 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene an empty corner of a bare room with a dusty wooden floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a warm, slanting beam of sunset light visible filtering through a window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of aluminum medical crutches with gray rubber grips and armpit pads visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the crutch metal surface gradually transform from gleaming cold metal to a rough, grayish-white petrified texture with cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move forward slowly and end in a close-up shot of the transformed crutches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023311249911785126 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773311138153076 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023311249911785126, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023311249911785126, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.37272700667381287, + 0.11186446994543076, + 0.08564908057451248, + 0.03861392289400101, + 0.05582696571946144, + 0.06499940901994705, + 0.11681430786848068, + 0.04567904770374298, + 0.044058289378881454, + 0.0637674480676651 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023311249911785126 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene an empty corner of a bare room with a dusty wooden floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a warm, slanting beam of sunset light visible filtering through a window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of aluminum medical crutches with gray rubber grips and armpit pads visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the crutch metal surface gradually transform from gleaming cold metal to a rough, grayish-white petrified texture with cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move forward slowly and end in a close-up shot of the transformed crutches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0011863820254802704 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.751186370849609 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0011863820254802704, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0011863820254802704, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09895157814025879, + 0.17216569185256958, + 0.1759243607521057, + 0.08918537944555283, + 0.10450688749551773, + 0.11543690413236618, + 0.0867762491106987, + 0.06233323737978935, + 0.03450239077210426, + 0.060217294842004776 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0011863820254802704 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene an empty corner of a bare room with a dusty wooden floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a warm, slanting beam of sunset light visible filtering through a window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of aluminum medical crutches with gray rubber grips and armpit pads visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the crutch metal surface gradually transform from gleaming cold metal to a rough, grayish-white petrified texture with cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move forward slowly and end in a close-up shot of the transformed crutches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0007201223634183407 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.250720024108887 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0007201223634183407, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0007201223634183407, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08419177681207657, + 0.1856549233198166, + 0.04980120807886124, + 0.06643835455179214, + 0.0544702485203743, + 0.0476723350584507, + 0.14686311781406403, + 0.11071406304836273, + 0.08572105318307877, + 0.1684730052947998 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0007201223634183407 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene an empty corner of a bare room with a dusty wooden floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a warm, slanting beam of sunset light visible filtering through a window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of aluminum medical crutches with gray rubber grips and armpit pads visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the crutch metal surface gradually transform from gleaming cold metal to a rough, grayish-white petrified texture with cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move forward slowly and end in a close-up shot of the transformed crutches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00524691678583622 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255247116088867 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00524691678583622, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00524691678583622, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0813397690653801, + 0.0983169749379158, + 0.257578045129776, + 0.09060802310705185, + 0.04089270159602165, + 0.08218804001808167, + 0.11703591793775558, + 0.11542795598506927, + 0.055730052292346954, + 0.0608825609087944 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00524691678583622 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_11/index_tensor([9452, 9452])_group_11_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_11/index_tensor([9452, 9452])_group_11_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..7fe49b69f6b25a645c0494a6fc03849f33478752 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_11/index_tensor([9452, 9452])_group_11_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "static shot, shot from a horizontal angle, yet accompanied by constant, high-frequency micro-vibrations due to the train's breathtaking speed, expertly and directly captures the interior of a high-speed maglev train. The interior showcases a minimalist, futuristic design, with ergonomically designed, streamlined seats constructed of a light gray, high-tech composite material, neatly arranged. Bright sunlight streams through the large picture windows, blending with the soft, even cool white light emitted by LED strips embedded in the ceiling, illuminating the nearly invisible dust particles in the air. The rural landscape outside the windows is reduced to a blur of rapidly passing dynamic streaks, with only swift flashes of green and brown. The immense power of the train generates a deep resonance throughout the train, transforming into a barely perceptible vibration that reflects fine, flowing light off the metal handrails and window glass, creating a unique atmosphere of cutting-edge technology, extreme speed, and cool efficiency.", + "seed": 7773, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_11/index_9452_seed_7773_dp_22_rank_44_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.07466742023825645, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07466742023825645, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.1, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07466742023825645, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene the interior of a high-speed maglev train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the seats light gray, streamlined, and made of a high-tech composite material?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting a mix of bright sunlight from large windows and cool white LED strips on the ceiling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the view outside the windows a blur of rapidly passing green and brown streaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static with constant, high-frequency micro-vibrations visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.09631127119064331 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.471311330795288 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.09631127119064331, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.09631127119064331, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2907690703868866, + 0.033045798540115356, + 0.25470930337905884, + 0.10151638090610504, + 0.05742696672677994, + 0.04205804318189621, + 0.08637919276952744, + 0.03983508050441742, + 0.02529788576066494, + 0.06896223872900009 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.09631127119064331 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene the interior of a high-speed maglev train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the seats light gray, streamlined, and made of a high-tech composite material?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting a mix of bright sunlight from large windows and cool white LED strips on the ceiling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the view outside the windows a blur of rapidly passing green and brown streaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static with constant, high-frequency micro-vibrations visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04871518537402153 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048715114593506 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04871518537402153, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04871518537402153, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18603940308094025, + 0.14569643139839172, + 0.11204198002815247, + 0.060448456555604935, + 0.09587161988019943, + 0.037535056471824646, + 0.022997858002781868, + 0.050334565341472626, + 0.11623762547969818, + 0.1727970689535141 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04871518537402153 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene the interior of a high-speed maglev train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the seats light gray, streamlined, and made of a high-tech composite material?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting a mix of bright sunlight from large windows and cool white LED strips on the ceiling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the view outside the windows a blur of rapidly passing green and brown streaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static with constant, high-frequency micro-vibrations visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012551127932965755 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387551307678223 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012551127932965755, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012551127932965755, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.26793310046195984, + 0.020581968128681183, + 0.06483891606330872, + 0.06263219565153122, + 0.016150876879692078, + 0.02919934131205082, + 0.47283288836479187, + 0.016532130539417267, + 0.029427381232380867, + 0.019871244207024574 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012551127932965755 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene the interior of a high-speed maglev train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the seats light gray, streamlined, and made of a high-tech composite material?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting a mix of bright sunlight from large windows and cool white LED strips on the ceiling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the view outside the windows a blur of rapidly passing green and brown streaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static with constant, high-frequency micro-vibrations visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014192597009241581 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264192581176758 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014192597009241581, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014192597009241581, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5117003917694092, + 0.02002493478357792, + 0.10588341951370239, + 0.14782926440238953, + 0.042381033301353455, + 0.010190503671765327, + 0.0936867818236351, + 0.02736886776983738, + 0.02176576480269432, + 0.019169045612215996 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014192597009241581 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene the interior of a high-speed maglev train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the seats light gray, streamlined, and made of a high-tech composite material?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting a mix of bright sunlight from large windows and cool white LED strips on the ceiling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the view outside the windows a blur of rapidly passing green and brown streaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static with constant, high-frequency micro-vibrations visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2015669196844101 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7015669345855713 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2015669196844101, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2015669196844101, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11976533383131027, + 0.04082677885890007, + 0.056014593690633774, + 0.06104016676545143, + 0.024748101830482483, + 0.010485065169632435, + 0.026841668412089348, + 0.6262970566749573, + 0.013806908391416073, + 0.020174210891127586 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2015669196844101 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static shot, shot from a horizontal angle, yet accompanied by constant, high-frequency micro-vibrations due to the train's breathtaking speed, expertly and directly captures the interior of a high-speed maglev train. The interior showcases a minimalist, futuristic design, with ergonomically designed, streamlined seats constructed of a light gray, high-tech composite material, neatly arranged. Bright sunlight streams through the large picture windows, blending with the soft, even cool white light emitted by LED strips embedded in the ceiling, illuminating the nearly invisible dust particles in the air. The rural landscape outside the windows is reduced to a blur of rapidly passing dynamic streaks, with only swift flashes of green and brown. The immense power of the train generates a deep resonance throughout the train, transforming into a barely perceptible vibration that reflects fine, flowing light off the metal handrails and window glass, creating a unique atmosphere of cutting-edge technology, extreme speed, and cool efficiency.", + "seed": 7774, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_11/index_9452_seed_7774_dp_22_rank_44_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.20825253296643495, + "vlm_logprob": -0.20825253296643495, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.025, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.20825253296643495, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene the interior of a high-speed maglev train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the seats light gray, streamlined, and made of a high-tech composite material?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting a mix of bright sunlight from large windows and cool white LED strips on the ceiling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the view outside the windows a blur of rapidly passing green and brown streaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static with constant, high-frequency micro-vibrations visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4797072112560272 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9797072410583496 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.4797072112560272, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.4797072112560272, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2799842059612274, + 0.179759681224823, + 0.04859718680381775, + 0.042904287576675415, + 0.10352551937103271, + 0.06774025410413742, + 0.12461633235216141, + 0.038565605878829956, + 0.06681001931428909, + 0.047496870160102844 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.4797072112560272 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene the interior of a high-speed maglev train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the seats light gray, streamlined, and made of a high-tech composite material?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting a mix of bright sunlight from large windows and cool white LED strips on the ceiling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the view outside the windows a blur of rapidly passing green and brown streaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static with constant, high-frequency micro-vibrations visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.18006013333797455 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8050601482391357 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.18006013333797455, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.18006013333797455, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3787352740764618, + 0.09125891327857971, + 0.02750544063746929, + 0.04573575407266617, + 0.11800380051136017, + 0.04912957549095154, + 0.13701756298542023, + 0.03455813229084015, + 0.08287274092435837, + 0.0351828895509243 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.18006013333797455 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene the interior of a high-speed maglev train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the seats light gray, streamlined, and made of a high-tech composite material?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting a mix of bright sunlight from large windows and cool white LED strips on the ceiling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the view outside the windows a blur of rapidly passing green and brown streaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static with constant, high-frequency micro-vibrations visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08906007558107376 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.464060068130493 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08906007558107376, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08906007558107376, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3286939859390259, + 0.16660122573375702, + 0.05802776291966438, + 0.0583970844745636, + 0.061431463807821274, + 0.03643909469246864, + 0.07617736607789993, + 0.09183657169342041, + 0.04421228915452957, + 0.07818309217691422 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08906007558107376 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene the interior of a high-speed maglev train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the seats light gray, streamlined, and made of a high-tech composite material?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting a mix of bright sunlight from large windows and cool white LED strips on the ceiling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the view outside the windows a blur of rapidly passing green and brown streaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static with constant, high-frequency micro-vibrations visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011083112098276615 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511083126068115 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011083112098276615, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011083112098276615, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11580394208431244, + 0.06833358854055405, + 0.03422907367348671, + 0.028252381831407547, + 0.05866861715912819, + 0.0399145744740963, + 0.256483256816864, + 0.14097380638122559, + 0.20141980051994324, + 0.05592099204659462 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011083112098276615 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene the interior of a high-speed maglev train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the seats light gray, streamlined, and made of a high-tech composite material?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting a mix of bright sunlight from large windows and cool white LED strips on the ceiling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the view outside the windows a blur of rapidly passing green and brown streaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static with constant, high-frequency micro-vibrations visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.28135213255882263 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.406352162361145 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.28135213255882263, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.28135213255882263, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0918000116944313, + 0.060765668749809265, + 0.056119248270988464, + 0.12588907778263092, + 0.47129061818122864, + 0.04446849599480629, + 0.04044521972537041, + 0.01936360076069832, + 0.05622129514813423, + 0.033636730164289474 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.28135213255882263 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static shot, shot from a horizontal angle, yet accompanied by constant, high-frequency micro-vibrations due to the train's breathtaking speed, expertly and directly captures the interior of a high-speed maglev train. The interior showcases a minimalist, futuristic design, with ergonomically designed, streamlined seats constructed of a light gray, high-tech composite material, neatly arranged. Bright sunlight streams through the large picture windows, blending with the soft, even cool white light emitted by LED strips embedded in the ceiling, illuminating the nearly invisible dust particles in the air. The rural landscape outside the windows is reduced to a blur of rapidly passing dynamic streaks, with only swift flashes of green and brown. The immense power of the train generates a deep resonance throughout the train, transforming into a barely perceptible vibration that reflects fine, flowing light off the metal handrails and window glass, creating a unique atmosphere of cutting-edge technology, extreme speed, and cool efficiency.", + "seed": 7775, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_11/index_9452_seed_7775_dp_23_rank_46_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.2379787465557456, + "vlm_logprob": -0.2379787465557456, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.075, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.2379787465557456, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene the interior of a high-speed maglev train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the seats light gray, streamlined, and made of a high-tech composite material?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting a mix of bright sunlight from large windows and cool white LED strips on the ceiling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the view outside the windows a blur of rapidly passing green and brown streaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static with constant, high-frequency micro-vibrations visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.393633097410202 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1436331272125244 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.393633097410202, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.393633097410202, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3036133944988251, + 0.02977333404123783, + 0.03412944823503494, + 0.4025300145149231, + 0.025431495159864426, + 0.13490156829357147, + 0.012932103127241135, + 0.011634779162704945, + 0.027614636346697807, + 0.01743920147418976 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.393633097410202 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene the interior of a high-speed maglev train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the seats light gray, streamlined, and made of a high-tech composite material?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting a mix of bright sunlight from large windows and cool white LED strips on the ceiling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the view outside the windows a blur of rapidly passing green and brown streaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static with constant, high-frequency micro-vibrations visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11303456127643585 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.23803448677063 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11303456127643585, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11303456127643585, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10553930699825287, + 0.11052647978067398, + 0.09556496143341064, + 0.258167028427124, + 0.09287221729755402, + 0.07661544531583786, + 0.07140538841485977, + 0.030318118631839752, + 0.10147521644830704, + 0.05751582980155945 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11303456127643585 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene the interior of a high-speed maglev train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the seats light gray, streamlined, and made of a high-tech composite material?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting a mix of bright sunlight from large windows and cool white LED strips on the ceiling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the view outside the windows a blur of rapidly passing green and brown streaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static with constant, high-frequency micro-vibrations visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10034170001745224 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.350341796875 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10034170001745224, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10034170001745224, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4947693943977356, + 0.03436959534883499, + 0.030790263786911964, + 0.1801019310951233, + 0.035604365170001984, + 0.14889927208423615, + 0.02125685103237629, + 0.013845935463905334, + 0.0233240257948637, + 0.017038388177752495 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10034170001745224 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene the interior of a high-speed maglev train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the seats light gray, streamlined, and made of a high-tech composite material?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting a mix of bright sunlight from large windows and cool white LED strips on the ceiling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the view outside the windows a blur of rapidly passing green and brown streaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static with constant, high-frequency micro-vibrations visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0067402152344584465 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006740093231201 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0067402152344584465, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0067402152344584465, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.054046787321567535, + 0.014025483280420303, + 0.06203601881861687, + 0.6491119861602783, + 0.047547921538352966, + 0.1324089914560318, + 0.009060950949788094, + 0.005087089724838734, + 0.013683806173503399, + 0.012990990653634071 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 5, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0067402152344584465 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene the interior of a high-speed maglev train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the seats light gray, streamlined, and made of a high-tech composite material?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting a mix of bright sunlight from large windows and cool white LED strips on the ceiling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the view outside the windows a blur of rapidly passing green and brown streaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static with constant, high-frequency micro-vibrations visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5761441588401794 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8261441588401794 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5761441588401794, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5761441588401794, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.195316344499588, + 0.024115676060318947, + 0.02204875461757183, + 0.39505037665367126, + 0.017505981028079987, + 0.23862798511981964, + 0.0169246643781662, + 0.016964716836810112, + 0.023786045610904694, + 0.049659423530101776 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5761441588401794 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static shot, shot from a horizontal angle, yet accompanied by constant, high-frequency micro-vibrations due to the train's breathtaking speed, expertly and directly captures the interior of a high-speed maglev train. The interior showcases a minimalist, futuristic design, with ergonomically designed, streamlined seats constructed of a light gray, high-tech composite material, neatly arranged. Bright sunlight streams through the large picture windows, blending with the soft, even cool white light emitted by LED strips embedded in the ceiling, illuminating the nearly invisible dust particles in the air. The rural landscape outside the windows is reduced to a blur of rapidly passing dynamic streaks, with only swift flashes of green and brown. The immense power of the train generates a deep resonance throughout the train, transforming into a barely perceptible vibration that reflects fine, flowing light off the metal handrails and window glass, creating a unique atmosphere of cutting-edge technology, extreme speed, and cool efficiency.", + "seed": 7776, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_11/index_9452_seed_7776_dp_23_rank_46_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.15532810445874928, + "vlm_logprob": -0.15532810445874928, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.425, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.15532810445874928, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene the interior of a high-speed maglev train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the seats light gray, streamlined, and made of a high-tech composite material?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting a mix of bright sunlight from large windows and cool white LED strips on the ceiling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the view outside the windows a blur of rapidly passing green and brown streaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static with constant, high-frequency micro-vibrations visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3212299048900604 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3212299346923828 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3212299048900604, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3212299048900604, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24979181587696075, + 0.05261022225022316, + 0.11087845265865326, + 0.29375389218330383, + 0.02918444387614727, + 0.015205778181552887, + 0.09419789165258408, + 0.0409756563603878, + 0.055908624082803726, + 0.0574931763112545 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3212299048900604 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene the interior of a high-speed maglev train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the seats light gray, streamlined, and made of a high-tech composite material?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting a mix of bright sunlight from large windows and cool white LED strips on the ceiling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the view outside the windows a blur of rapidly passing green and brown streaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static with constant, high-frequency micro-vibrations visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08910554647445679 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4641056060791016 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08910554647445679, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08910554647445679, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3465069532394409, + 0.14092089235782623, + 0.06976252049207687, + 0.09919964522123337, + 0.03852178156375885, + 0.026403648778796196, + 0.11119331419467926, + 0.04104599356651306, + 0.060394786298274994, + 0.06605041772127151 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08910554647445679 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene the interior of a high-speed maglev train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the seats light gray, streamlined, and made of a high-tech composite material?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting a mix of bright sunlight from large windows and cool white LED strips on the ceiling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the view outside the windows a blur of rapidly passing green and brown streaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static with constant, high-frequency micro-vibrations visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00979274045675993 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634792804718018 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00979274045675993, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00979274045675993, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2916109263896942, + 0.07573579996824265, + 0.14915946125984192, + 0.21078716218471527, + 0.03147197887301445, + 0.015431155450642109, + 0.04970918968319893, + 0.03401502966880798, + 0.07931430637836456, + 0.06276502460241318 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00979274045675993 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene the interior of a high-speed maglev train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the seats light gray, streamlined, and made of a high-tech composite material?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting a mix of bright sunlight from large windows and cool white LED strips on the ceiling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the view outside the windows a blur of rapidly passing green and brown streaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static with constant, high-frequency micro-vibrations visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04305609315633774 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168056011199951 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04305609315633774, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04305609315633774, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13773344457149506, + 0.042846713215112686, + 0.10409540683031082, + 0.513891339302063, + 0.03974892571568489, + 0.023156799376010895, + 0.07028048485517502, + 0.02120865136384964, + 0.03049526922404766, + 0.016543015837669373 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04305609315633774 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene the interior of a high-speed maglev train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the seats light gray, streamlined, and made of a high-tech composite material?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting a mix of bright sunlight from large windows and cool white LED strips on the ceiling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the view outside the windows a blur of rapidly passing green and brown streaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static with constant, high-frequency micro-vibrations visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3134562373161316 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3134562969207764 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3134562373161316, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3134562373161316, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14980196952819824, + 0.1681188941001892, + 0.051880404353141785, + 0.16167151927947998, + 0.08215176314115524, + 0.053168244659900665, + 0.08203783631324768, + 0.07850632816553116, + 0.14142796397209167, + 0.031235074624419212 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3134562373161316 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_12/index_tensor([1156, 1156])_group_12_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_12/index_tensor([1156, 1156])_group_12_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..995210f0c2f17aa5fb4b45b2e8e90322d2edd81b --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_12/index_tensor([1156, 1156])_group_12_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "dramatic and intense cinematic low-angle wide shot maintains a static-like view of a vast, sinister Gothic mansion, its form almost completely engulfed by the deep black of a stormy night. A fierce thunderstorm is in full swing, and thick rain pelts the building, obscuring the view. Suddenly, a massive flash of brilliant white lightning streaks across the turbulent, roiling purple-black sky, momentarily and violently illuminating the entire scene. In this fleeting, high-contrast flash, the mansion is revealed in stark detail: towering, needle-like spires reach toward the sky, weathered stone walls gleam damply, and eerie gargoyles seem to scream silently in the gusts of wind. Dark, tall lancet windows, like hollow eyes, reflect the searing flash before the scene returns to near-total darkness, leaving only a haunting, ominous silhouette against briefly ignited clouds. The intense atmosphere is filled with foreboding and the raw power of nature.", + "seed": 6671, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_12/index_1156_seed_6671_dp_24_rank_48_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.11448414970654994, + "vlm_logprob": -0.11448414970654994, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.45, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.11448414970654994, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle looking up at the mansion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a wide shot showing the vastness of the mansion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the mansion engulfed by a stormy night with thick rain pelting the building?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a massive flash of brilliant white lightning streak across a purple-black sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are towering needle-like spires and weathered stone walls visible during the lightning flash?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.045934900641441345 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4209349155426025 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.045934900641441345, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.045934900641441345, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09902841597795486, + 0.03767295554280281, + 0.022906210273504257, + 0.2547810971736908, + 0.07005339115858078, + 0.03146972507238388, + 0.3721795678138733, + 0.020473811775445938, + 0.00919745210558176, + 0.08223742991685867 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.045934900641441345 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle looking up at the mansion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a wide shot showing the vastness of the mansion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the mansion engulfed by a stormy night with thick rain pelting the building?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a massive flash of brilliant white lightning streak across a purple-black sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are towering needle-like spires and weathered stone walls visible during the lightning flash?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12702779471874237 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.127027750015259 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12702779471874237, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12702779471874237, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06396924704313278, + 0.07026665657758713, + 0.03645483776926994, + 0.39416933059692383, + 0.05678195506334305, + 0.05356805399060249, + 0.12293921411037445, + 0.03561913222074509, + 0.012834902852773666, + 0.15339672565460205 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12702779471874237 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle looking up at the mansion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a wide shot showing the vastness of the mansion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the mansion engulfed by a stormy night with thick rain pelting the building?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a massive flash of brilliant white lightning streak across a purple-black sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are towering needle-like spires and weathered stone walls visible during the lightning flash?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.387037068605423 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1370370388031006 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.387037068605423, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.387037068605423, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11626848578453064, + 0.16602197289466858, + 0.07999099791049957, + 0.11605586856603622, + 0.033535294234752655, + 0.03890696540474892, + 0.09950104355812073, + 0.06780871748924255, + 0.03331870585680008, + 0.24859194457530975 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.387037068605423 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle looking up at the mansion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a wide shot showing the vastness of the mansion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the mansion engulfed by a stormy night with thick rain pelting the building?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a massive flash of brilliant white lightning streak across a purple-black sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are towering needle-like spires and weathered stone walls visible during the lightning flash?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0013427060330286622 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.6263427734375 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0013427060330286622, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0013427060330286622, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06764212995767593, + 0.0586635060608387, + 0.043959975242614746, + 0.1558687686920166, + 0.06653047353029251, + 0.05042193830013275, + 0.03924340382218361, + 0.05106094852089882, + 0.01632082462310791, + 0.45028799772262573 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0013427060330286622 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle looking up at the mansion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a wide shot showing the vastness of the mansion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the mansion engulfed by a stormy night with thick rain pelting the building?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a massive flash of brilliant white lightning streak across a purple-black sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are towering needle-like spires and weathered stone walls visible during the lightning flash?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01107827853411436 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511078357696533 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01107827853411436, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01107827853411436, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.054050326347351074, + 0.048670072108507156, + 0.029786402359604836, + 0.64680415391922, + 0.04162963852286339, + 0.028627833351492882, + 0.09373738616704941, + 0.031067630276083946, + 0.009176243096590042, + 0.01645030826330185 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01107827853411436 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dramatic and intense cinematic low-angle wide shot maintains a static-like view of a vast, sinister Gothic mansion, its form almost completely engulfed by the deep black of a stormy night. A fierce thunderstorm is in full swing, and thick rain pelts the building, obscuring the view. Suddenly, a massive flash of brilliant white lightning streaks across the turbulent, roiling purple-black sky, momentarily and violently illuminating the entire scene. In this fleeting, high-contrast flash, the mansion is revealed in stark detail: towering, needle-like spires reach toward the sky, weathered stone walls gleam damply, and eerie gargoyles seem to scream silently in the gusts of wind. Dark, tall lancet windows, like hollow eyes, reflect the searing flash before the scene returns to near-total darkness, leaving only a haunting, ominous silhouette against briefly ignited clouds. The intense atmosphere is filled with foreboding and the raw power of nature.", + "seed": 6672, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_12/index_1156_seed_6672_dp_24_rank_48_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.38247838327661154, + "vlm_logprob": -0.38247838327661154, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.424999976158142, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.38247838327661154, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle looking up at the mansion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a wide shot showing the vastness of the mansion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the mansion engulfed by a stormy night with thick rain pelting the building?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a massive flash of brilliant white lightning streak across a purple-black sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are towering needle-like spires and weathered stone walls visible during the lightning flash?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.13322743773460388 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1332273483276367 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.13322743773460388, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.9999998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -0.13322743773460388, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07196144759654999, + 0.10660538822412491, + 0.028654705733060837, + 0.01631428860127926, + 0.01457883045077324, + 0.16531182825565338, + 0.24687369167804718, + 0.028651215136051178, + 0.30753621459007263, + 0.013512387871742249 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.13322743773460388 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle looking up at the mansion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a wide shot showing the vastness of the mansion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the mansion engulfed by a stormy night with thick rain pelting the building?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a massive flash of brilliant white lightning streak across a purple-black sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are towering needle-like spires and weathered stone walls visible during the lightning flash?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16032332181930542 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9103233814239502 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16032332181930542, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16032332181930542, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2254616916179657, + 0.3118784725666046, + 0.07384180277585983, + 0.05855272337794304, + 0.055716805160045624, + 0.08702937513589859, + 0.04035038501024246, + 0.03998178243637085, + 0.0671892911195755, + 0.039997659623622894 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16032332181930542 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle looking up at the mansion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a wide shot showing the vastness of the mansion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the mansion engulfed by a stormy night with thick rain pelting the building?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a massive flash of brilliant white lightning streak across a purple-black sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are towering needle-like spires and weathered stone walls visible during the lightning flash?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6005277633666992 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22552774846553802 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.6005277633666992, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -1.6005277633666992, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1612192988395691, + 0.3654301166534424, + 0.05221789330244064, + 0.025178896263241768, + 0.04394672438502312, + 0.0457504503428936, + 0.14716431498527527, + 0.08399780094623566, + 0.04815146327018738, + 0.026942996308207512 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.6005277633666992 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle looking up at the mansion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a wide shot showing the vastness of the mansion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the mansion engulfed by a stormy night with thick rain pelting the building?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a massive flash of brilliant white lightning streak across a purple-black sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are towering needle-like spires and weathered stone walls visible during the lightning flash?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004109866451472044 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504109859466553 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004109866451472044, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004109866451472044, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21565330028533936, + 0.35919511318206787, + 0.0369478203356266, + 0.033507321029901505, + 0.04288413003087044, + 0.13937632739543915, + 0.0809876024723053, + 0.04063943028450012, + 0.02767033502459526, + 0.023138562217354774 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004109866451472044 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle looking up at the mansion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a wide shot showing the vastness of the mansion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the mansion engulfed by a stormy night with thick rain pelting the building?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a massive flash of brilliant white lightning streak across a purple-black sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are towering needle-like spires and weathered stone walls visible during the lightning flash?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014203527010977268 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.2642035484313965 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014203527010977268, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014203527010977268, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18581070005893707, + 0.25167518854141235, + 0.04327519237995148, + 0.049199946224689484, + 0.06211717054247856, + 0.12006352096796036, + 0.1882297545671463, + 0.04350675269961357, + 0.026309989392757416, + 0.02981179766356945 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014203527010977268 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dramatic and intense cinematic low-angle wide shot maintains a static-like view of a vast, sinister Gothic mansion, its form almost completely engulfed by the deep black of a stormy night. A fierce thunderstorm is in full swing, and thick rain pelts the building, obscuring the view. Suddenly, a massive flash of brilliant white lightning streaks across the turbulent, roiling purple-black sky, momentarily and violently illuminating the entire scene. In this fleeting, high-contrast flash, the mansion is revealed in stark detail: towering, needle-like spires reach toward the sky, weathered stone walls gleam damply, and eerie gargoyles seem to scream silently in the gusts of wind. Dark, tall lancet windows, like hollow eyes, reflect the searing flash before the scene returns to near-total darkness, leaving only a haunting, ominous silhouette against briefly ignited clouds. The intense atmosphere is filled with foreboding and the raw power of nature.", + "seed": 6673, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_12/index_1156_seed_6673_dp_25_rank_50_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.1330439941957593, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1330439941957593, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.475, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1330439941957593, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle looking up at the mansion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a wide shot showing the vastness of the mansion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the mansion engulfed by a stormy night with thick rain pelting the building?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a massive flash of brilliant white lightning streak across a purple-black sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are towering needle-like spires and weathered stone walls visible during the lightning flash?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.060717515647411346 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1857175827026367 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.060717515647411346, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.060717515647411346, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.132337287068367, + 0.03635990992188454, + 0.07449973374605179, + 0.09262828528881073, + 0.09922104328870773, + 0.021258415654301643, + 0.024852318689227104, + 0.39680078625679016, + 0.06582633405923843, + 0.056215886026620865 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.060717515647411346 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle looking up at the mansion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a wide shot showing the vastness of the mansion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the mansion engulfed by a stormy night with thick rain pelting the building?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a massive flash of brilliant white lightning streak across a purple-black sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are towering needle-like spires and weathered stone walls visible during the lightning flash?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07002637535333633 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695026397705078 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07002637535333633, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07002637535333633, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14082975685596466, + 0.05592137575149536, + 0.2091033160686493, + 0.0990593284368515, + 0.01715271547436714, + 0.01813330501317978, + 0.10001512616872787, + 0.2076878696680069, + 0.09540563076734543, + 0.05669158324599266 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07002637535333633 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle looking up at the mansion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a wide shot showing the vastness of the mansion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the mansion engulfed by a stormy night with thick rain pelting the building?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a massive flash of brilliant white lightning streak across a purple-black sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are towering needle-like spires and weathered stone walls visible during the lightning flash?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5233423709869385 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8983423709869385 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5233423709869385, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5233423709869385, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1422998011112213, + 0.0399724617600441, + 0.05898648127913475, + 0.2817777097225189, + 0.08687782287597656, + 0.023503098636865616, + 0.028651680797338486, + 0.2206142246723175, + 0.050207775086164474, + 0.06710898131132126 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5233423709869385 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle looking up at the mansion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a wide shot showing the vastness of the mansion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the mansion engulfed by a stormy night with thick rain pelting the building?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a massive flash of brilliant white lightning streak across a purple-black sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are towering needle-like spires and weathered stone walls visible during the lightning flash?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0013466347008943558 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.626346588134766 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0013466347008943558, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0013466347008943558, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09143257886171341, + 0.037409234791994095, + 0.06137222424149513, + 0.2660154402256012, + 0.062426965683698654, + 0.019520040601491928, + 0.05804159492254257, + 0.27536147832870483, + 0.06509938091039658, + 0.06332109123468399 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0013466347008943558 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle looking up at the mansion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a wide shot showing the vastness of the mansion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the mansion engulfed by a stormy night with thick rain pelting the building?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a massive flash of brilliant white lightning streak across a purple-black sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are towering needle-like spires and weathered stone walls visible during the lightning flash?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009787074290215969 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634787082672119 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009787074290215969, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009787074290215969, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05377496778964996, + 0.0202641561627388, + 0.02541823871433735, + 0.09125549346208572, + 0.055272724479436874, + 0.015659166499972343, + 0.013981726951897144, + 0.6339831948280334, + 0.043009862303733826, + 0.04738052934408188 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009787074290215969 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dramatic and intense cinematic low-angle wide shot maintains a static-like view of a vast, sinister Gothic mansion, its form almost completely engulfed by the deep black of a stormy night. A fierce thunderstorm is in full swing, and thick rain pelts the building, obscuring the view. Suddenly, a massive flash of brilliant white lightning streaks across the turbulent, roiling purple-black sky, momentarily and violently illuminating the entire scene. In this fleeting, high-contrast flash, the mansion is revealed in stark detail: towering, needle-like spires reach toward the sky, weathered stone walls gleam damply, and eerie gargoyles seem to scream silently in the gusts of wind. Dark, tall lancet windows, like hollow eyes, reflect the searing flash before the scene returns to near-total darkness, leaving only a haunting, ominous silhouette against briefly ignited clouds. The intense atmosphere is filled with foreboding and the raw power of nature.", + "seed": 6674, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_12/index_1156_seed_6674_dp_25_rank_50_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.30103429248556496, + "vlm_logprob": -0.30103429248556496, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.875, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.30103429248556496, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle looking up at the mansion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a wide shot showing the vastness of the mansion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the mansion engulfed by a stormy night with thick rain pelting the building?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a massive flash of brilliant white lightning streak across a purple-black sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are towering needle-like spires and weathered stone walls visible during the lightning flash?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.038237061351537704 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4132370948791504 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.038237061351537704, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.038237061351537704, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19192810356616974, + 0.055233728140592575, + 0.20864512026309967, + 0.15213872492313385, + 0.15372814238071442, + 0.0590316504240036, + 0.07616633921861649, + 0.03895401209592819, + 0.032980576157569885, + 0.031193699687719345 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.038237061351537704 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle looking up at the mansion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a wide shot showing the vastness of the mansion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the mansion engulfed by a stormy night with thick rain pelting the building?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a massive flash of brilliant white lightning streak across a purple-black sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are towering needle-like spires and weathered stone walls visible during the lightning flash?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2255316525697708 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6005316972732544 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2255316525697708, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2255316525697708, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14073888957500458, + 0.08335334062576294, + 0.26918572187423706, + 0.049274545162916183, + 0.16944321990013123, + 0.09809619188308716, + 0.06309249252080917, + 0.03667387738823891, + 0.042003750801086426, + 0.04813800007104874 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2255316525697708 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle looking up at the mansion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a wide shot showing the vastness of the mansion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the mansion engulfed by a stormy night with thick rain pelting the building?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a massive flash of brilliant white lightning streak across a purple-black sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are towering needle-like spires and weathered stone walls visible during the lightning flash?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2235957384109497 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3485957682132721 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.2235957384109497, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -1.2235957384109497, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07547224313020706, + 0.06726018339395523, + 0.5922666788101196, + 0.07844216376543045, + 0.0401545949280262, + 0.09789835661649704, + 0.020874353125691414, + 0.007446437142789364, + 0.010692927055060863, + 0.009492081589996815 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.2235957384109497 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle looking up at the mansion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a wide shot showing the vastness of the mansion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the mansion engulfed by a stormy night with thick rain pelting the building?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a massive flash of brilliant white lightning streak across a purple-black sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are towering needle-like spires and weathered stone walls visible during the lightning flash?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0017260904423892498 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.376726150512695 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0017260904423892498, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0017260904423892498, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.046188026666641235, + 0.023711958900094032, + 0.36336490511894226, + 0.12233734875917435, + 0.3218955099582672, + 0.06298841536045074, + 0.02135288715362549, + 0.013134593144059181, + 0.015682315453886986, + 0.009344050660729408 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0017260904423892498 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle looking up at the mansion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a wide shot showing the vastness of the mansion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the mansion engulfed by a stormy night with thick rain pelting the building?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a massive flash of brilliant white lightning streak across a purple-black sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are towering needle-like spires and weathered stone walls visible during the lightning flash?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01608091965317726 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141080856323242 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01608091965317726, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01608091965317726, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11153122037649155, + 0.04454750567674637, + 0.3800564110279083, + 0.11513017117977142, + 0.11300663650035858, + 0.08014453947544098, + 0.06714211404323578, + 0.04221603646874428, + 0.027307741343975067, + 0.01891760155558586 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01608091965317726 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_13/index_tensor([1580, 1580])_group_13_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_13/index_tensor([1580, 1580])_group_13_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..6eafdede40ea635dbb92ad86e4a12248d680a589 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_13/index_tensor([1580, 1580])_group_13_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "In a Ghibli-inspired art style, a high-speed slow-motion, low-angle, medium-length shot slowly zooms in on a majestic, ancient walnut tree, the centerpiece of a sun-dappled clearing. The tree's trunk is remarkably thick, richly painted with hand-painted textures, covered in deeply fissured gray-brown bark dotted with soft green moss. Its dense, gnarled branches spread outward like ancient arms, their vibrant green husks laden with clusters of walnuts. As the camera pans, the branches begin to vibrate gently and rhythmically, a slow yet powerful pulse derived not from the wind but from a magical, unseen energy. In exquisite slow motion, each lush leaf trembles and shimmers, capturing the warm, filtered sunlight, while the walnut itself begins to vibrate with a quiet intensity. A soft, inner golden light emanates from within, pulsating in sync with the tree's movement, revealing a quiet, powerful vitality within the scene and creating a serene, breathtakingly magical atmosphere.", + "seed": 6546, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_13/index_1580_seed_6546_dp_26_rank_52_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.02958854380995035, + "vlm_logprob": -0.02958854380995035, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.925, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.02958854380995035, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a Ghibli-inspired art style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an ancient walnut tree with thick, gray-brown bark covered in green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the branches laden with clusters of walnuts and vibrant green husks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tree and its leaves vibrate gently with a soft inner golden light pulsating from within?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle medium-length shot that slowly zooms in on the tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08242950588464737 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5824294090270996 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08242950588464737, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08242950588464737, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17022524774074554, + 0.12447701394557953, + 0.06305345892906189, + 0.04917915165424347, + 0.2894437909126282, + 0.10396265983581543, + 0.0603877454996109, + 0.08133841305971146, + 0.02593187801539898, + 0.03200063481926918 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08242950588464737 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a Ghibli-inspired art style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an ancient walnut tree with thick, gray-brown bark covered in green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the branches laden with clusters of walnuts and vibrant green husks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tree and its leaves vibrate gently with a soft inner golden light pulsating from within?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle medium-length shot that slowly zooms in on the tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01255360059440136 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387553691864014 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01255360059440136, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01255360059440136, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21190176904201508, + 0.09656424075365067, + 0.07336048036813736, + 0.07658013701438904, + 0.10608907788991928, + 0.14329351484775543, + 0.07540673017501831, + 0.1410057544708252, + 0.040749531239271164, + 0.035048745572566986 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01255360059440136 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a Ghibli-inspired art style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an ancient walnut tree with thick, gray-brown bark covered in green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the branches laden with clusters of walnuts and vibrant green husks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tree and its leaves vibrate gently with a soft inner golden light pulsating from within?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle medium-length shot that slowly zooms in on the tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006741991266608238 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006742000579834 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006741991266608238, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006741991266608238, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16785991191864014, + 0.11949551105499268, + 0.05561487749218941, + 0.07035090774297714, + 0.049330275505781174, + 0.11196040362119675, + 0.1742939054965973, + 0.06924024969339371, + 0.09970492124557495, + 0.08214909583330154 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006741991266608238 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a Ghibli-inspired art style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an ancient walnut tree with thick, gray-brown bark covered in green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the branches laden with clusters of walnuts and vibrant green husks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tree and its leaves vibrate gently with a soft inner golden light pulsating from within?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle medium-length shot that slowly zooms in on the tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01253888476639986 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387538909912109 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01253888476639986, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01253888476639986, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12272574752569199, + 0.10576067119836807, + 0.07707928866147995, + 0.09923193603754044, + 0.12429460883140564, + 0.06372952461242676, + 0.03865435719490051, + 0.05581401661038399, + 0.03819847106933594, + 0.2745113670825958 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01253888476639986 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a Ghibli-inspired art style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an ancient walnut tree with thick, gray-brown bark covered in green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the branches laden with clusters of walnuts and vibrant green husks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tree and its leaves vibrate gently with a soft inner golden light pulsating from within?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle medium-length shot that slowly zooms in on the tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03367873653769493 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4086787700653076 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03367873653769493, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03367873653769493, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15963004529476166, + 0.07417664676904678, + 0.0444985069334507, + 0.14923949539661407, + 0.195624440908432, + 0.12767162919044495, + 0.07239532470703125, + 0.07861492037773132, + 0.03290901705622673, + 0.06523995101451874 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03367873653769493 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a Ghibli-inspired art style, a high-speed slow-motion, low-angle, medium-length shot slowly zooms in on a majestic, ancient walnut tree, the centerpiece of a sun-dappled clearing. The tree's trunk is remarkably thick, richly painted with hand-painted textures, covered in deeply fissured gray-brown bark dotted with soft green moss. Its dense, gnarled branches spread outward like ancient arms, their vibrant green husks laden with clusters of walnuts. As the camera pans, the branches begin to vibrate gently and rhythmically, a slow yet powerful pulse derived not from the wind but from a magical, unseen energy. In exquisite slow motion, each lush leaf trembles and shimmers, capturing the warm, filtered sunlight, while the walnut itself begins to vibrate with a quiet intensity. A soft, inner golden light emanates from within, pulsating in sync with the tree's movement, revealing a quiet, powerful vitality within the scene and creating a serene, breathtakingly magical atmosphere.", + "seed": 6547, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_13/index_1580_seed_6547_dp_26_rank_52_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.008697023778222502, + "vlm_logprob": -0.008697023778222502, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 5.175, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.008697023778222502, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a Ghibli-inspired art style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an ancient walnut tree with thick, gray-brown bark covered in green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the branches laden with clusters of walnuts and vibrant green husks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tree and its leaves vibrate gently with a soft inner golden light pulsating from within?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle medium-length shot that slowly zooms in on the tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020112155005335808 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.020112037658691 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020112155005335808, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020112155005335808, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19703887403011322, + 0.03476556017994881, + 0.05577519163489342, + 0.060429587960243225, + 0.0771569162607193, + 0.10786694288253784, + 0.07012777030467987, + 0.10733824223279953, + 0.2173486202955246, + 0.07215223461389542 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020112155005335808 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a Ghibli-inspired art style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an ancient walnut tree with thick, gray-brown bark covered in green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the branches laden with clusters of walnuts and vibrant green husks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tree and its leaves vibrate gently with a soft inner golden light pulsating from within?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle medium-length shot that slowly zooms in on the tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00674353027716279 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006743431091309 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00674353027716279, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00674353027716279, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1436995267868042, + 0.07944196462631226, + 0.10504906624555588, + 0.14037111401557922, + 0.06115094944834709, + 0.03369377553462982, + 0.11476325243711472, + 0.11500836908817291, + 0.08448144048452377, + 0.12234047800302505 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00674353027716279 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a Ghibli-inspired art style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an ancient walnut tree with thick, gray-brown bark covered in green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the branches laden with clusters of walnuts and vibrant green husks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tree and its leaves vibrate gently with a soft inner golden light pulsating from within?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle medium-length shot that slowly zooms in on the tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0009205871028825641 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.00092077255249 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0009205871028825641, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0009205871028825641, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14082691073417664, + 0.19111941754817963, + 0.17598368227481842, + 0.0626874566078186, + 0.037923041731119156, + 0.045814286917448044, + 0.06899682432413101, + 0.12060340493917465, + 0.10322093963623047, + 0.05282406136393547 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0009205871028825641 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a Ghibli-inspired art style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an ancient walnut tree with thick, gray-brown bark covered in green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the branches laden with clusters of walnuts and vibrant green husks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tree and its leaves vibrate gently with a soft inner golden light pulsating from within?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle medium-length shot that slowly zooms in on the tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011076509952545166 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.5110764503479 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011076509952545166, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011076509952545166, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1518414467573166, + 0.05516474321484566, + 0.08747826516628265, + 0.04549415409564972, + 0.1525537222623825, + 0.059292521327733994, + 0.07592274248600006, + 0.08146964758634567, + 0.14750277996063232, + 0.1432799994945526 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011076509952545166 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a Ghibli-inspired art style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an ancient walnut tree with thick, gray-brown bark covered in green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the branches laden with clusters of walnuts and vibrant green husks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tree and its leaves vibrate gently with a soft inner golden light pulsating from within?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle medium-length shot that slowly zooms in on the tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004632336553186178 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379632472991943 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004632336553186178, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004632336553186178, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1903340071439743, + 0.03771048039197922, + 0.09224987775087357, + 0.030474483966827393, + 0.07195122539997101, + 0.03577644005417824, + 0.10534167289733887, + 0.1566166877746582, + 0.20968061685562134, + 0.06986446678638458 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004632336553186178 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a Ghibli-inspired art style, a high-speed slow-motion, low-angle, medium-length shot slowly zooms in on a majestic, ancient walnut tree, the centerpiece of a sun-dappled clearing. The tree's trunk is remarkably thick, richly painted with hand-painted textures, covered in deeply fissured gray-brown bark dotted with soft green moss. Its dense, gnarled branches spread outward like ancient arms, their vibrant green husks laden with clusters of walnuts. As the camera pans, the branches begin to vibrate gently and rhythmically, a slow yet powerful pulse derived not from the wind but from a magical, unseen energy. In exquisite slow motion, each lush leaf trembles and shimmers, capturing the warm, filtered sunlight, while the walnut itself begins to vibrate with a quiet intensity. A soft, inner golden light emanates from within, pulsating in sync with the tree's movement, revealing a quiet, powerful vitality within the scene and creating a serene, breathtakingly magical atmosphere.", + "seed": 6548, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_13/index_1580_seed_6548_dp_27_rank_54_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.006175530841574073, + "vlm_logprob": -0.006175530841574073, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 5.275, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.006175530841574073, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a Ghibli-inspired art style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an ancient walnut tree with thick, gray-brown bark covered in green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the branches laden with clusters of walnuts and vibrant green husks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tree and its leaves vibrate gently with a soft inner golden light pulsating from within?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle medium-length shot that slowly zooms in on the tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.010811444371938705 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.8858113288879395 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.010811444371938705, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.010811444371938705, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5602086782455444, + 0.052298981696367264, + 0.04184197634458542, + 0.022907176986336708, + 0.04764939099550247, + 0.03812003880739212, + 0.059019021689891815, + 0.06793186068534851, + 0.054724495857954025, + 0.055298447608947754 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.010811444371938705 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a Ghibli-inspired art style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an ancient walnut tree with thick, gray-brown bark covered in green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the branches laden with clusters of walnuts and vibrant green husks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tree and its leaves vibrate gently with a soft inner golden light pulsating from within?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle medium-length shot that slowly zooms in on the tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006746135652065277 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006746292114258 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006746135652065277, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006746135652065277, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.28566765785217285, + 0.1765320897102356, + 0.05642973259091377, + 0.02320697531104088, + 0.042230039834976196, + 0.0760829821228981, + 0.07106773555278778, + 0.1261359602212906, + 0.04733479395508766, + 0.09531203657388687 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006746135652065277 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a Ghibli-inspired art style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an ancient walnut tree with thick, gray-brown bark covered in green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the branches laden with clusters of walnuts and vibrant green husks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tree and its leaves vibrate gently with a soft inner golden light pulsating from within?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle medium-length shot that slowly zooms in on the tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002493250882253051 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002493381500244 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002493250882253051, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002493250882253051, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0838318020105362, + 0.3525131642818451, + 0.07899139821529388, + 0.03381482884287834, + 0.06083407625555992, + 0.049580369144678116, + 0.06609418243169785, + 0.0997631847858429, + 0.0921056717634201, + 0.0824713259935379 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002493250882253051 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a Ghibli-inspired art style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an ancient walnut tree with thick, gray-brown bark covered in green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the branches laden with clusters of walnuts and vibrant green husks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tree and its leaves vibrate gently with a soft inner golden light pulsating from within?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle medium-length shot that slowly zooms in on the tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006735833827406168 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006735801696777 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006735833827406168, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006735833827406168, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3596797585487366, + 0.047161493450403214, + 0.027565810829401016, + 0.024290746077895164, + 0.02058228850364685, + 0.03788701072335243, + 0.03403693065047264, + 0.08138208836317062, + 0.0484805703163147, + 0.31893324851989746 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006735833827406168 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a Ghibli-inspired art style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an ancient walnut tree with thick, gray-brown bark covered in green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the branches laden with clusters of walnuts and vibrant green husks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tree and its leaves vibrate gently with a soft inner golden light pulsating from within?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle medium-length shot that slowly zooms in on the tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004090989474207163 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504090785980225 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004090989474207163, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004090989474207163, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5293130874633789, + 0.057626135647296906, + 0.04627591371536255, + 0.02297322265803814, + 0.03501829504966736, + 0.04836350679397583, + 0.04991789162158966, + 0.047221988439559937, + 0.0906233936548233, + 0.07266651093959808 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004090989474207163 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a Ghibli-inspired art style, a high-speed slow-motion, low-angle, medium-length shot slowly zooms in on a majestic, ancient walnut tree, the centerpiece of a sun-dappled clearing. The tree's trunk is remarkably thick, richly painted with hand-painted textures, covered in deeply fissured gray-brown bark dotted with soft green moss. Its dense, gnarled branches spread outward like ancient arms, their vibrant green husks laden with clusters of walnuts. As the camera pans, the branches begin to vibrate gently and rhythmically, a slow yet powerful pulse derived not from the wind but from a magical, unseen energy. In exquisite slow motion, each lush leaf trembles and shimmers, capturing the warm, filtered sunlight, while the walnut itself begins to vibrate with a quiet intensity. A soft, inner golden light emanates from within, pulsating in sync with the tree's movement, revealing a quiet, powerful vitality within the scene and creating a serene, breathtakingly magical atmosphere.", + "seed": 6549, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_13/index_1580_seed_6549_dp_27_rank_54_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.033234324958175424, + "vlm_logprob": -0.033234324958175424, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.125, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.033234324958175424, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a Ghibli-inspired art style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an ancient walnut tree with thick, gray-brown bark covered in green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the branches laden with clusters of walnuts and vibrant green husks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tree and its leaves vibrate gently with a soft inner golden light pulsating from within?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle medium-length shot that slowly zooms in on the tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1159294918179512 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.24092960357666 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1159294918179512, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1159294918179512, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3117198944091797, + 0.2340945452451706, + 0.1194596141576767, + 0.06396738439798355, + 0.05142716318368912, + 0.02837056666612625, + 0.07951704412698746, + 0.0380992516875267, + 0.01854097470641136, + 0.05480353534221649 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1159294918179512 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a Ghibli-inspired art style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an ancient walnut tree with thick, gray-brown bark covered in green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the branches laden with clusters of walnuts and vibrant green husks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tree and its leaves vibrate gently with a soft inner golden light pulsating from within?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle medium-length shot that slowly zooms in on the tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011095372959971428 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.5110955238342285 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011095372959971428, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011095372959971428, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3823612332344055, + 0.1630340814590454, + 0.06525546312332153, + 0.06243734061717987, + 0.08169322460889816, + 0.022871961817145348, + 0.06514538079500198, + 0.041271910071372986, + 0.034811437129974365, + 0.08111792057752609 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011095372959971428 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a Ghibli-inspired art style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an ancient walnut tree with thick, gray-brown bark covered in green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the branches laden with clusters of walnuts and vibrant green husks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tree and its leaves vibrate gently with a soft inner golden light pulsating from within?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle medium-length shot that slowly zooms in on the tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0024963426403701305 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002496242523193 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0024963426403701305, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0024963426403701305, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3184458911418915, + 0.11108476668596268, + 0.08081049472093582, + 0.07422163337469101, + 0.08713064342737198, + 0.05676674842834473, + 0.11360397189855576, + 0.07464203983545303, + 0.017742402851581573, + 0.06555134803056717 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0024963426403701305 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a Ghibli-inspired art style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an ancient walnut tree with thick, gray-brown bark covered in green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the branches laden with clusters of walnuts and vibrant green husks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tree and its leaves vibrate gently with a soft inner golden light pulsating from within?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle medium-length shot that slowly zooms in on the tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02058732882142067 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.89558744430542 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02058732882142067, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02058732882142067, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2018650621175766, + 0.09677291661500931, + 0.1318747103214264, + 0.04327751696109772, + 0.03962714970111847, + 0.07348974794149399, + 0.11844340711832047, + 0.22272434830665588, + 0.019299836829304695, + 0.0526253916323185 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02058732882142067 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a Ghibli-inspired art style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an ancient walnut tree with thick, gray-brown bark covered in green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the branches laden with clusters of walnuts and vibrant green husks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tree and its leaves vibrate gently with a soft inner golden light pulsating from within?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle medium-length shot that slowly zooms in on the tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016063088551163673 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141063213348389 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016063088551163673, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016063088551163673, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21869498491287231, + 0.14908774197101593, + 0.07839225977659225, + 0.0981333777308464, + 0.12238667905330658, + 0.13589978218078613, + 0.12326058745384216, + 0.020152835175395012, + 0.011376558803021908, + 0.042615197598934174 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016063088551163673 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_14/index_tensor([1474, 1474])_group_14_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_14/index_tensor([1474, 1474])_group_14_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..82512db433a7620235e8991e513da08a7ac69313 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_14/index_tensor([1474, 1474])_group_14_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "The film begins with an extreme close-up shot from ground level, revealing an ultra-high-definition, photorealistic CGI image focused on a patch of moist, dark brown soil rich in organic matter. Soft morning light slants down, making tiny water droplets cling to the variously sized soil particles shimmer with a shimmering brilliance. Suddenly, the ground arches slightly, a tiny crack appears. A fresh, emerald green sprout, its curved stem thrusting upward with unstoppable vitality, pushes away the soil particles above it, sending clumps of moist earth tumbling to the side. As the translucent sprout fully emerges from the earth, its stem gradually straightens, and the two cotyledons curled at the top begin to carefully and nearly symmetrically unfold to the sides, revealing the fresher green and distinct veins within. Throughout this process, the camera rises in a smooth and steady rhythm from a close-up perspective, maintaining focus on the growing sprout, ultimately settling at a perspective parallel to the unfolding leaves. The whole process appears sacred and poetic under the warm light, creating a tranquil atmosphere of rebirth, resilience and hope.", + "seed": 2400, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_14/index_1474_seed_2400_dp_28_rank_56_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.03989180689677596, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03989180689677596, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.975000023841858, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03989180689677596, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot an extreme close-up from ground level showing moist, dark brown soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does a fresh emerald green sprout with a curved stem emerge from the soil and push away earth particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the two cotyledons at the top of the sprout unfold symmetrically to reveal distinct veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rise smoothly from a close-up perspective to a view parallel to the unfolding leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft morning light causing water droplets on the soil to shimmer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006777158007025719 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.256777286529541 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006777158007025719, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006777158007025719, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1861603707075119, + 0.12085920572280884, + 0.07110459357500076, + 0.08057320863008499, + 0.05813313275575638, + 0.07028336822986603, + 0.15694090723991394, + 0.05057154595851898, + 0.052540943026542664, + 0.15283262729644775 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006777158007025719 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot an extreme close-up from ground level showing moist, dark brown soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does a fresh emerald green sprout with a curved stem emerge from the soil and push away earth particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the two cotyledons at the top of the sprout unfold symmetrically to reveal distinct veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rise smoothly from a close-up perspective to a view parallel to the unfolding leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft morning light causing water droplets on the soil to shimmer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005977728869765997 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130977630615234 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005977728869765997, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005977728869765997, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10732868313789368, + 0.19892284274101257, + 0.06843198835849762, + 0.04723319783806801, + 0.029667627066373825, + 0.040651701390743256, + 0.09964415431022644, + 0.08176320791244507, + 0.050660647451877594, + 0.27569594979286194 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005977728869765997 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot an extreme close-up from ground level showing moist, dark brown soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does a fresh emerald green sprout with a curved stem emerge from the soil and push away earth particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the two cotyledons at the top of the sprout unfold symmetrically to reveal distinct veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rise smoothly from a close-up perspective to a view parallel to the unfolding leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft morning light causing water droplets on the soil to shimmer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02059456892311573 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895594596862793 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02059456892311573, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02059456892311573, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1033572405576706, + 0.09055370837450027, + 0.050699181854724884, + 0.04541558399796486, + 0.10791023820638657, + 0.05552917346358299, + 0.059725113213062286, + 0.03478265181183815, + 0.048448916524648666, + 0.40357816219329834 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02059456892311573 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot an extreme close-up from ground level showing moist, dark brown soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does a fresh emerald green sprout with a curved stem emerge from the soil and push away earth particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the two cotyledons at the top of the sprout unfold symmetrically to reveal distinct veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rise smoothly from a close-up perspective to a view parallel to the unfolding leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft morning light causing water droplets on the soil to shimmer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02329506166279316 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732951641082764 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02329506166279316, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02329506166279316, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06902842968702316, + 0.07799902558326721, + 0.025891076773405075, + 0.06295225024223328, + 0.044833067804574966, + 0.06435924023389816, + 0.05669471621513367, + 0.06968877464532852, + 0.04626993462443352, + 0.48228347301483154 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02329506166279316 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot an extreme close-up from ground level showing moist, dark brown soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does a fresh emerald green sprout with a curved stem emerge from the soil and push away earth particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the two cotyledons at the top of the sprout unfold symmetrically to reveal distinct veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rise smoothly from a close-up perspective to a view parallel to the unfolding leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft morning light causing water droplets on the soil to shimmer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1428145170211792 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0178146362304688 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1428145170211792, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.8750001192092896, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1428145170211792, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18672771751880646, + 0.0661487877368927, + 0.040920644998550415, + 0.09695354849100113, + 0.025106072425842285, + 0.07024422287940979, + 0.03172831982374191, + 0.18468692898750305, + 0.0606408566236496, + 0.23684285581111908 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1428145170211792 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "The film begins with an extreme close-up shot from ground level, revealing an ultra-high-definition, photorealistic CGI image focused on a patch of moist, dark brown soil rich in organic matter. Soft morning light slants down, making tiny water droplets cling to the variously sized soil particles shimmer with a shimmering brilliance. Suddenly, the ground arches slightly, a tiny crack appears. A fresh, emerald green sprout, its curved stem thrusting upward with unstoppable vitality, pushes away the soil particles above it, sending clumps of moist earth tumbling to the side. As the translucent sprout fully emerges from the earth, its stem gradually straightens, and the two cotyledons curled at the top begin to carefully and nearly symmetrically unfold to the sides, revealing the fresher green and distinct veins within. Throughout this process, the camera rises in a smooth and steady rhythm from a close-up perspective, maintaining focus on the growing sprout, ultimately settling at a perspective parallel to the unfolding leaves. The whole process appears sacred and poetic under the warm light, creating a tranquil atmosphere of rebirth, resilience and hope.", + "seed": 2401, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_14/index_1474_seed_2401_dp_28_rank_56_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.019022907549515366, + "vlm_logprob": -0.019022907549515366, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.8, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.019022907549515366, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot an extreme close-up from ground level showing moist, dark brown soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does a fresh emerald green sprout with a curved stem emerge from the soil and push away earth particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the two cotyledons at the top of the sprout unfold symmetrically to reveal distinct veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rise smoothly from a close-up perspective to a view parallel to the unfolding leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft morning light causing water droplets on the soil to shimmer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0028567002154886723 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.502856731414795 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0028567002154886723, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0028567002154886723, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3496954143047333, + 0.0771079957485199, + 0.0852293148636818, + 0.0698365867137909, + 0.04632140323519707, + 0.0944608673453331, + 0.02730562537908554, + 0.05969328433275223, + 0.07942464202642441, + 0.11092495918273926 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0028567002154886723 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot an extreme close-up from ground level showing moist, dark brown soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does a fresh emerald green sprout with a curved stem emerge from the soil and push away earth particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the two cotyledons at the top of the sprout unfold symmetrically to reveal distinct veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rise smoothly from a close-up perspective to a view parallel to the unfolding leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft morning light causing water droplets on the soil to shimmer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0022130541037768126 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127213001251221 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0022130541037768126, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0022130541037768126, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11887121200561523, + 0.10561283677816391, + 0.06163596734404564, + 0.04536649212241173, + 0.029158776625990868, + 0.12273121625185013, + 0.08450938761234283, + 0.1331554502248764, + 0.23011693358421326, + 0.06884171813726425 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0022130541037768126 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot an extreme close-up from ground level showing moist, dark brown soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does a fresh emerald green sprout with a curved stem emerge from the soil and push away earth particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the two cotyledons at the top of the sprout unfold symmetrically to reveal distinct veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rise smoothly from a close-up perspective to a view parallel to the unfolding leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft morning light causing water droplets on the soil to shimmer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009790970012545586 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634790897369385 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009790970012545586, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009790970012545586, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09069033712148666, + 0.04639212414622307, + 0.03943205624818802, + 0.04067366570234299, + 0.04655971750617027, + 0.05845843628048897, + 0.1559361070394516, + 0.09982526302337646, + 0.23499593138694763, + 0.18703635036945343 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009790970012545586 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot an extreme close-up from ground level showing moist, dark brown soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does a fresh emerald green sprout with a curved stem emerge from the soil and push away earth particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the two cotyledons at the top of the sprout unfold symmetrically to reveal distinct veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rise smoothly from a close-up perspective to a view parallel to the unfolding leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft morning light causing water droplets on the soil to shimmer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018191635608673096 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018191814422607 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018191635608673096, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018191635608673096, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14417782425880432, + 0.05436502397060394, + 0.07158733159303665, + 0.057027675211429596, + 0.1041783019900322, + 0.09007718414068222, + 0.0410640724003315, + 0.08464562147855759, + 0.13301751017570496, + 0.21985936164855957 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018191635608673096 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot an extreme close-up from ground level showing moist, dark brown soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does a fresh emerald green sprout with a curved stem emerge from the soil and push away earth particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the two cotyledons at the top of the sprout unfold symmetrically to reveal distinct veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rise smoothly from a close-up perspective to a view parallel to the unfolding leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft morning light causing water droplets on the soil to shimmer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06206217780709267 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120622634887695 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06206217780709267, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06206217780709267, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3396165668964386, + 0.05916375294327736, + 0.10058760643005371, + 0.03791378065943718, + 0.08449441939592361, + 0.12620124220848083, + 0.04632382467389107, + 0.05231558531522751, + 0.03875362128019333, + 0.11462964117527008 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06206217780709267 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "The film begins with an extreme close-up shot from ground level, revealing an ultra-high-definition, photorealistic CGI image focused on a patch of moist, dark brown soil rich in organic matter. Soft morning light slants down, making tiny water droplets cling to the variously sized soil particles shimmer with a shimmering brilliance. Suddenly, the ground arches slightly, a tiny crack appears. A fresh, emerald green sprout, its curved stem thrusting upward with unstoppable vitality, pushes away the soil particles above it, sending clumps of moist earth tumbling to the side. As the translucent sprout fully emerges from the earth, its stem gradually straightens, and the two cotyledons curled at the top begin to carefully and nearly symmetrically unfold to the sides, revealing the fresher green and distinct veins within. Throughout this process, the camera rises in a smooth and steady rhythm from a close-up perspective, maintaining focus on the growing sprout, ultimately settling at a perspective parallel to the unfolding leaves. The whole process appears sacred and poetic under the warm light, creating a tranquil atmosphere of rebirth, resilience and hope.", + "seed": 2402, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_14/index_1474_seed_2402_dp_29_rank_58_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.031213920190930368, + "vlm_logprob": -0.031213920190930368, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.2, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.031213920190930368, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot an extreme close-up from ground level showing moist, dark brown soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does a fresh emerald green sprout with a curved stem emerge from the soil and push away earth particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the two cotyledons at the top of the sprout unfold symmetrically to reveal distinct veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rise smoothly from a close-up perspective to a view parallel to the unfolding leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft morning light causing water droplets on the soil to shimmer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004746242426335812 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504746437072754 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004746242426335812, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004746242426335812, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20375527441501617, + 0.046110305935144424, + 0.03603874519467354, + 0.019041743129491806, + 0.40867263078689575, + 0.026715194806456566, + 0.04672619327902794, + 0.11498777568340302, + 0.02956911362707615, + 0.06838300824165344 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004746242426335812 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot an extreme close-up from ground level showing moist, dark brown soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does a fresh emerald green sprout with a curved stem emerge from the soil and push away earth particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the two cotyledons at the top of the sprout unfold symmetrically to reveal distinct veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rise smoothly from a close-up perspective to a view parallel to the unfolding leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft morning light causing water droplets on the soil to shimmer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005976899527013302 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130976676940918 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005976899527013302, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005976899527013302, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22047610580921173, + 0.05601030960679054, + 0.05105476453900337, + 0.05822170525789261, + 0.3810618817806244, + 0.023127807304263115, + 0.07300498336553574, + 0.03908262401819229, + 0.021583316847682, + 0.07637646794319153 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005976899527013302 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot an extreme close-up from ground level showing moist, dark brown soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does a fresh emerald green sprout with a curved stem emerge from the soil and push away earth particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the two cotyledons at the top of the sprout unfold symmetrically to reveal distinct veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rise smoothly from a close-up perspective to a view parallel to the unfolding leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft morning light causing water droplets on the soil to shimmer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014206700026988983 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264206886291504 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014206700026988983, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014206700026988983, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13575191795825958, + 0.07298696786165237, + 0.08737991750240326, + 0.06391503661870956, + 0.20601791143417358, + 0.02972756326198578, + 0.06660875678062439, + 0.11870107054710388, + 0.03857798129320145, + 0.18033283948898315 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014206700026988983 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot an extreme close-up from ground level showing moist, dark brown soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does a fresh emerald green sprout with a curved stem emerge from the soil and push away earth particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the two cotyledons at the top of the sprout unfold symmetrically to reveal distinct veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rise smoothly from a close-up perspective to a view parallel to the unfolding leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft morning light causing water droplets on the soil to shimmer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018193040043115616 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018193244934082 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018193040043115616, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018193040043115616, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08130793273448944, + 0.06306584924459457, + 0.08456029742956161, + 0.07172220200300217, + 0.17844809591770172, + 0.03050568327307701, + 0.044783663004636765, + 0.2332422137260437, + 0.0878254771232605, + 0.12453852593898773 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018193040043115616 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot an extreme close-up from ground level showing moist, dark brown soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does a fresh emerald green sprout with a curved stem emerge from the soil and push away earth particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the two cotyledons at the top of the sprout unfold symmetrically to reveal distinct veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rise smoothly from a close-up perspective to a view parallel to the unfolding leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft morning light causing water droplets on the soil to shimmer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11294671893119812 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2379467487335205 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11294671893119812, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11294671893119812, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09533163905143738, + 0.08023431152105331, + 0.050698135048151016, + 0.025944257155060768, + 0.4571349024772644, + 0.032344382256269455, + 0.03751794248819351, + 0.07569235563278198, + 0.04870186373591423, + 0.0964001938700676 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11294671893119812 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "The film begins with an extreme close-up shot from ground level, revealing an ultra-high-definition, photorealistic CGI image focused on a patch of moist, dark brown soil rich in organic matter. Soft morning light slants down, making tiny water droplets cling to the variously sized soil particles shimmer with a shimmering brilliance. Suddenly, the ground arches slightly, a tiny crack appears. A fresh, emerald green sprout, its curved stem thrusting upward with unstoppable vitality, pushes away the soil particles above it, sending clumps of moist earth tumbling to the side. As the translucent sprout fully emerges from the earth, its stem gradually straightens, and the two cotyledons curled at the top begin to carefully and nearly symmetrically unfold to the sides, revealing the fresher green and distinct veins within. Throughout this process, the camera rises in a smooth and steady rhythm from a close-up perspective, maintaining focus on the growing sprout, ultimately settling at a perspective parallel to the unfolding leaves. The whole process appears sacred and poetic under the warm light, creating a tranquil atmosphere of rebirth, resilience and hope.", + "seed": 2403, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_14/index_1474_seed_2403_dp_29_rank_58_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.02687192540615797, + "vlm_logprob": -0.02687192540615797, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.525, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.02687192540615797, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot an extreme close-up from ground level showing moist, dark brown soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does a fresh emerald green sprout with a curved stem emerge from the soil and push away earth particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the two cotyledons at the top of the sprout unfold symmetrically to reveal distinct veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rise smoothly from a close-up perspective to a view parallel to the unfolding leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft morning light causing water droplets on the soil to shimmer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004668408073484898 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.629668235778809 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004668408073484898, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004668408073484898, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23274053633213043, + 0.0734667107462883, + 0.028408581390976906, + 0.08172903209924698, + 0.054126620292663574, + 0.10229574143886566, + 0.03003884106874466, + 0.04402434825897217, + 0.013605168089270592, + 0.3395644724369049 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004668408073484898 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot an extreme close-up from ground level showing moist, dark brown soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does a fresh emerald green sprout with a curved stem emerge from the soil and push away earth particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the two cotyledons at the top of the sprout unfold symmetrically to reveal distinct veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rise smoothly from a close-up perspective to a view parallel to the unfolding leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft morning light causing water droplets on the soil to shimmer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0022116266191005707 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127211570739746 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0022116266191005707, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0022116266191005707, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4430769979953766, + 0.04440544918179512, + 0.04832686856389046, + 0.06698323786258698, + 0.03324877470731735, + 0.10669703781604767, + 0.0269953440874815, + 0.053573548793792725, + 0.024726100265979767, + 0.15196669101715088 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0022116266191005707 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot an extreme close-up from ground level showing moist, dark brown soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does a fresh emerald green sprout with a curved stem emerge from the soil and push away earth particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the two cotyledons at the top of the sprout unfold symmetrically to reveal distinct veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rise smoothly from a close-up perspective to a view parallel to the unfolding leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft morning light causing water droplets on the soil to shimmer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016082562506198883 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141082763671875 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016082562506198883, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016082562506198883, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14620910584926605, + 0.02706817351281643, + 0.01726033166050911, + 0.20768854022026062, + 0.08662889897823334, + 0.07730592787265778, + 0.05900825560092926, + 0.04797874018549919, + 0.031410906463861465, + 0.29944106936454773 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016082562506198883 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot an extreme close-up from ground level showing moist, dark brown soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does a fresh emerald green sprout with a curved stem emerge from the soil and push away earth particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the two cotyledons at the top of the sprout unfold symmetrically to reveal distinct veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rise smoothly from a close-up perspective to a view parallel to the unfolding leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft morning light causing water droplets on the soil to shimmer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011080989614129066 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511081218719482 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011080989614129066, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011080989614129066, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.33501189947128296, + 0.02116849273443222, + 0.01592263951897621, + 0.03411063924431801, + 0.04181894287467003, + 0.16255900263786316, + 0.10146153718233109, + 0.08042623847723007, + 0.017657648772001266, + 0.189862921833992 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011080989614129066 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot an extreme close-up from ground level showing moist, dark brown soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does a fresh emerald green sprout with a curved stem emerge from the soil and push away earth particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the two cotyledons at the top of the sprout unfold symmetrically to reveal distinct veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rise smoothly from a close-up perspective to a view parallel to the unfolding leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft morning light causing water droplets on the soil to shimmer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10031604021787643 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.350316047668457 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10031604021787643, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10031604021787643, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.28511330485343933, + 0.017808545380830765, + 0.008377142250537872, + 0.017467956990003586, + 0.05592130497097969, + 0.10837574303150177, + 0.01871492527425289, + 0.03502148017287254, + 0.006376389879733324, + 0.4468231797218323 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10031604021787643 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_15/index_tensor([1268, 1268])_group_15_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_15/index_tensor([1268, 1268])_group_15_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..818df91894e00f46b3933c7322b6a585562e001a --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_15/index_tensor([1268, 1268])_group_15_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "medium close-up shot from the side, the camera steady, captures the concentration of an elderly craftsman in Steve McCurry's signature documentary style. A rich beam of afternoon sunlight filters through a dusty window, casting a sharp beam of light precisely upon the man and his work. The old craftsman's face, deeply wrinkled, his eyes narrowed, his expression solemn and serene. Dressed in a faded dark blue cotton work shirt, he bends over his workbench. His left hand, calloused yet remarkably steady, supports an unfinished boxwood Buddha statue. His right hand grips a traditional carving knife, its handle glistening with sweat. Carefully yet decisively, he advances, his precise pressure gracefully peeling a thin, curled shaving from the statue's smooth, curved surface. In the process, countless tiny particles of sawdust are stirred up, dancing in the golden light, shimmering like golden dust imbued with life. The entire picture is filled with warm earth tones and strong contrasts of light and shadow, creating an almost sacred atmosphere of tranquility and concentration, and profoundly conveying the beauty of the inheritance of handicrafts.", + "seed": 19664, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_15/index_1268_seed_19664_dp_30_rank_60_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.07716773971915245, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07716773971915245, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.575, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07716773971915245, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera steady throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the craftsman wearing a faded dark blue cotton work shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a rich beam of afternoon sunlight filtering through a dusty window to illuminate the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are tiny particles of sawdust visible dancing in the light while the craftsman carves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0270546767860651 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.152054786682129 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0270546767860651, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0270546767860651, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11777140200138092, + 0.09580634534358978, + 0.06475824862718582, + 0.16292709112167358, + 0.14448413252830505, + 0.05179973319172859, + 0.09271613508462906, + 0.07731810212135315, + 0.14831089973449707, + 0.044107913970947266 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0270546767860651 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera steady throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the craftsman wearing a faded dark blue cotton work shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a rich beam of afternoon sunlight filtering through a dusty window to illuminate the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are tiny particles of sawdust visible dancing in the light while the craftsman carves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3134743571281433 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.313474416732788 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3134743571281433, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3134743571281433, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15612410008907318, + 0.07519001513719559, + 0.2583446204662323, + 0.16918741166591644, + 0.09978651255369186, + 0.10714974254369736, + 0.033154383301734924, + 0.038845259696245193, + 0.0447663888335228, + 0.01745155267417431 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3134743571281433 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera steady throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the craftsman wearing a faded dark blue cotton work shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a rich beam of afternoon sunlight filtering through a dusty window to illuminate the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are tiny particles of sawdust visible dancing in the light while the craftsman carves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02059258334338665 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.89559268951416 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02059258334338665, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02059258334338665, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15017004311084747, + 0.12180737406015396, + 0.06660714000463486, + 0.06610307842493057, + 0.16914331912994385, + 0.09543514996767044, + 0.0892663523554802, + 0.07349085062742233, + 0.08796597272157669, + 0.08001073449850082 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02059258334338665 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera steady throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the craftsman wearing a faded dark blue cotton work shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a rich beam of afternoon sunlight filtering through a dusty window to illuminate the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are tiny particles of sawdust visible dancing in the light while the craftsman carves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01607927680015564 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141079425811768 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01607927680015564, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01607927680015564, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06929861754179001, + 0.07403029501438141, + 0.11938849836587906, + 0.2149410843849182, + 0.1219334602355957, + 0.0798126757144928, + 0.14990095794200897, + 0.08806406706571579, + 0.05895683169364929, + 0.02367355301976204 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01607927680015564 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera steady throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the craftsman wearing a faded dark blue cotton work shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a rich beam of afternoon sunlight filtering through a dusty window to illuminate the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are tiny particles of sawdust visible dancing in the light while the craftsman carves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008637804538011551 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.75863790512085 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008637804538011551, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008637804538011551, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13818365335464478, + 0.061935629695653915, + 0.13727237284183502, + 0.2505323588848114, + 0.09697502106428146, + 0.07963778078556061, + 0.08510054647922516, + 0.04068172723054886, + 0.06756782531738281, + 0.04211302474141121 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008637804538011551 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "medium close-up shot from the side, the camera steady, captures the concentration of an elderly craftsman in Steve McCurry's signature documentary style. A rich beam of afternoon sunlight filters through a dusty window, casting a sharp beam of light precisely upon the man and his work. The old craftsman's face, deeply wrinkled, his eyes narrowed, his expression solemn and serene. Dressed in a faded dark blue cotton work shirt, he bends over his workbench. His left hand, calloused yet remarkably steady, supports an unfinished boxwood Buddha statue. His right hand grips a traditional carving knife, its handle glistening with sweat. Carefully yet decisively, he advances, his precise pressure gracefully peeling a thin, curled shaving from the statue's smooth, curved surface. In the process, countless tiny particles of sawdust are stirred up, dancing in the golden light, shimmering like golden dust imbued with life. The entire picture is filled with warm earth tones and strong contrasts of light and shadow, creating an almost sacred atmosphere of tranquility and concentration, and profoundly conveying the beauty of the inheritance of handicrafts.", + "seed": 19665, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_15/index_1268_seed_19665_dp_30_rank_60_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.0770737909246236, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0770737909246236, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.824999952316284, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0770737909246236, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera steady throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the craftsman wearing a faded dark blue cotton work shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a rich beam of afternoon sunlight filtering through a dusty window to illuminate the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are tiny particles of sawdust visible dancing in the light while the craftsman carves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02675713784992695 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.77675724029541 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02675713784992695, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02675713784992695, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13512419164180756, + 0.4496454894542694, + 0.08439729362726212, + 0.03543294593691826, + 0.17652587592601776, + 0.02983040362596512, + 0.019967325031757355, + 0.01580394059419632, + 0.015220249071717262, + 0.038052305579185486 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02675713784992695 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera steady throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the craftsman wearing a faded dark blue cotton work shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a rich beam of afternoon sunlight filtering through a dusty window to illuminate the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are tiny particles of sawdust visible dancing in the light while the craftsman carves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3134803771972656 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3134803771972656 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3134803771972656, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3134803771972656, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06732471287250519, + 0.7343112230300903, + 0.12663975358009338, + 0.01611756719648838, + 0.010609475895762444, + 0.008473774418234825, + 0.006070586387068033, + 0.011907276697456837, + 0.0063606020994484425, + 0.012185066938400269 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3134803771972656 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera steady throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the craftsman wearing a faded dark blue cotton work shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a rich beam of afternoon sunlight filtering through a dusty window to illuminate the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are tiny particles of sawdust visible dancing in the light while the craftsman carves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0233310479670763 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7733311653137207 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0233310479670763, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0233310479670763, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07575633376836777, + 0.38052478432655334, + 0.0790649801492691, + 0.078434519469738, + 0.13400262594223022, + 0.03500434756278992, + 0.0383363738656044, + 0.03536473959684372, + 0.04310494288802147, + 0.10040638595819473 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0233310479670763 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera steady throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the craftsman wearing a faded dark blue cotton work shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a rich beam of afternoon sunlight filtering through a dusty window to illuminate the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are tiny particles of sawdust visible dancing in the light while the craftsman carves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036178866866976023 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628617763519287 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036178866866976023, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036178866866976023, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.33409491181373596, + 0.22904066741466522, + 0.09093953669071198, + 0.03223825991153717, + 0.04556693881750107, + 0.05647057294845581, + 0.06460795551538467, + 0.0677972063422203, + 0.036786239594221115, + 0.042457759380340576 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036178866866976023 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera steady throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the craftsman wearing a faded dark blue cotton work shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a rich beam of afternoon sunlight filtering through a dusty window to illuminate the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are tiny particles of sawdust visible dancing in the light while the craftsman carves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018182504922151566 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018182277679443 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018182504922151566, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018182504922151566, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18420732021331787, + 0.14784802496433258, + 0.3626968562602997, + 0.044955912977457047, + 0.11316099762916565, + 0.016649505123496056, + 0.028138991445302963, + 0.04101720079779625, + 0.034880127757787704, + 0.02644505724310875 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018182504922151566 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "medium close-up shot from the side, the camera steady, captures the concentration of an elderly craftsman in Steve McCurry's signature documentary style. A rich beam of afternoon sunlight filters through a dusty window, casting a sharp beam of light precisely upon the man and his work. The old craftsman's face, deeply wrinkled, his eyes narrowed, his expression solemn and serene. Dressed in a faded dark blue cotton work shirt, he bends over his workbench. His left hand, calloused yet remarkably steady, supports an unfinished boxwood Buddha statue. His right hand grips a traditional carving knife, its handle glistening with sweat. Carefully yet decisively, he advances, his precise pressure gracefully peeling a thin, curled shaving from the statue's smooth, curved surface. In the process, countless tiny particles of sawdust are stirred up, dancing in the golden light, shimmering like golden dust imbued with life. The entire picture is filled with warm earth tones and strong contrasts of light and shadow, creating an almost sacred atmosphere of tranquility and concentration, and profoundly conveying the beauty of the inheritance of handicrafts.", + "seed": 19666, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_15/index_1268_seed_19666_dp_31_rank_62_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.08062985949218274, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08062985949218274, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.925, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08062985949218274, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera steady throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the craftsman wearing a faded dark blue cotton work shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a rich beam of afternoon sunlight filtering through a dusty window to illuminate the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are tiny particles of sawdust visible dancing in the light while the craftsman carves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05156271159648895 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.426562786102295 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05156271159648895, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05156271159648895, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3159477114677429, + 0.07984758168458939, + 0.07664015889167786, + 0.06490197777748108, + 0.08896449208259583, + 0.05861788988113403, + 0.06359638273715973, + 0.067898228764534, + 0.11379969865083694, + 0.06978590786457062 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05156271159648895 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera steady throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the craftsman wearing a faded dark blue cotton work shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a rich beam of afternoon sunlight filtering through a dusty window to illuminate the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are tiny particles of sawdust visible dancing in the light while the craftsman carves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12708333134651184 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1270833015441895 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12708333134651184, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12708333134651184, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2637372314929962, + 0.09473715722560883, + 0.044683635234832764, + 0.08530187606811523, + 0.08265678584575653, + 0.06317570805549622, + 0.08975997567176819, + 0.1592256873846054, + 0.07123344391584396, + 0.04548846185207367 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12708333134651184 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera steady throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the craftsman wearing a faded dark blue cotton work shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a rich beam of afternoon sunlight filtering through a dusty window to illuminate the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are tiny particles of sawdust visible dancing in the light while the craftsman carves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018202640116214752 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018202781677246 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018202640116214752, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018202640116214752, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.28416410088539124, + 0.2239808440208435, + 0.07683668285608292, + 0.045794207602739334, + 0.07181387394666672, + 0.05192887410521507, + 0.03572647273540497, + 0.09599510580301285, + 0.03716666251420975, + 0.07659318298101425 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018202640116214752 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera steady throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the craftsman wearing a faded dark blue cotton work shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a rich beam of afternoon sunlight filtering through a dusty window to illuminate the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are tiny particles of sawdust visible dancing in the light while the craftsman carves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1799486130475998 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8049485683441162 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1799486130475998, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1799486130475998, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20913706719875336, + 0.10161750018596649, + 0.0403960645198822, + 0.03203369677066803, + 0.05777003988623619, + 0.07887674868106842, + 0.052280113101005554, + 0.14855530858039856, + 0.12149450182914734, + 0.15783897042274475 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1799486130475998 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera steady throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the craftsman wearing a faded dark blue cotton work shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a rich beam of afternoon sunlight filtering through a dusty window to illuminate the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are tiny particles of sawdust visible dancing in the light while the craftsman carves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02635200135409832 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513519287109375 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02635200135409832, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02635200135409832, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2711109519004822, + 0.14425696432590485, + 0.049277178943157196, + 0.1325240582227707, + 0.04435059428215027, + 0.025083603337407112, + 0.052772387862205505, + 0.15034261345863342, + 0.09232917428016663, + 0.03795257955789566 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02635200135409832 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "medium close-up shot from the side, the camera steady, captures the concentration of an elderly craftsman in Steve McCurry's signature documentary style. A rich beam of afternoon sunlight filters through a dusty window, casting a sharp beam of light precisely upon the man and his work. The old craftsman's face, deeply wrinkled, his eyes narrowed, his expression solemn and serene. Dressed in a faded dark blue cotton work shirt, he bends over his workbench. His left hand, calloused yet remarkably steady, supports an unfinished boxwood Buddha statue. His right hand grips a traditional carving knife, its handle glistening with sweat. Carefully yet decisively, he advances, his precise pressure gracefully peeling a thin, curled shaving from the statue's smooth, curved surface. In the process, countless tiny particles of sawdust are stirred up, dancing in the golden light, shimmering like golden dust imbued with life. The entire picture is filled with warm earth tones and strong contrasts of light and shadow, creating an almost sacred atmosphere of tranquility and concentration, and profoundly conveying the beauty of the inheritance of handicrafts.", + "seed": 19667, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_15/index_1268_seed_19667_dp_31_rank_62_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.08967067170888185, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08967067170888185, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.925, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08967067170888185, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera steady throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the craftsman wearing a faded dark blue cotton work shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a rich beam of afternoon sunlight filtering through a dusty window to illuminate the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are tiny particles of sawdust visible dancing in the light while the craftsman carves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06251033395528793 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0625102519989014 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06251033395528793, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06251033395528793, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.278739333152771, + 0.11058399826288223, + 0.05758759751915932, + 0.05890711769461632, + 0.1428893506526947, + 0.057400014251470566, + 0.023971974849700928, + 0.08478941023349762, + 0.08640231937170029, + 0.09872891008853912 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06251033395528793 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera steady throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the craftsman wearing a faded dark blue cotton work shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a rich beam of afternoon sunlight filtering through a dusty window to illuminate the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are tiny particles of sawdust visible dancing in the light while the craftsman carves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22560852766036987 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6006085872650146 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.22560852766036987, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.22560852766036987, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10482407361268997, + 0.051824528723955154, + 0.03186057507991791, + 0.035904254764318466, + 0.10638336092233658, + 0.12768597900867462, + 0.07579725980758667, + 0.14540879428386688, + 0.20619188249111176, + 0.11411923915147781 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.22560852766036987 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera steady throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the craftsman wearing a faded dark blue cotton work shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a rich beam of afternoon sunlight filtering through a dusty window to illuminate the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are tiny particles of sawdust visible dancing in the light while the craftsman carves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012546890415251255 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387547016143799 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012546890415251255, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012546890415251255, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14491410553455353, + 0.0913577675819397, + 0.046583373099565506, + 0.03435671702027321, + 0.14856861531734467, + 0.08144334703683853, + 0.03170245140790939, + 0.25970426201820374, + 0.10759139806032181, + 0.053778015077114105 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012546890415251255 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera steady throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the craftsman wearing a faded dark blue cotton work shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a rich beam of afternoon sunlight filtering through a dusty window to illuminate the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are tiny particles of sawdust visible dancing in the light while the craftsman carves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1271040141582489 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1271040439605713 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1271040141582489, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1271040141582489, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3091118335723877, + 0.12007677555084229, + 0.0450335368514061, + 0.02681070752441883, + 0.07399700582027435, + 0.11843178421258926, + 0.027247607707977295, + 0.1355791985988617, + 0.0553099550306797, + 0.08840160816907883 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1271040141582489 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera steady throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the craftsman wearing a faded dark blue cotton work shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a rich beam of afternoon sunlight filtering through a dusty window to illuminate the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are tiny particles of sawdust visible dancing in the light while the craftsman carves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020583592355251312 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955836296081543 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020583592355251312, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020583592355251312, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.29537373781204224, + 0.0971275344491005, + 0.05393135920166969, + 0.027047106996178627, + 0.15837500989437103, + 0.08951963484287262, + 0.04117738828063011, + 0.08496366441249847, + 0.06620455533266068, + 0.08628010004758835 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020583592355251312 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_2/index_tensor([9880, 9880])_group_2_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_2/index_tensor([9880, 9880])_group_2_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..8d97f22fd8d7d3b654151d2c7a42058e24176c98 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_2/index_tensor([9880, 9880])_group_2_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "stunning low-angle close-up, almost completely immersed in the scalding hot pot, the camera trembles subtly with the bubbling liquid. Within this deep, viscous, roiling sea of crimson oil, countless dried red chilies, dark Sichuan peppercorns, and a variety of star anise and bay leaves, saturated with grease and glistening with oil, are swept up by a turbulent vortex. They tumble, collide, and tumble fiercely within the seething red oil, like a vast army engaged in an epic melee. A powerful wave of heat erupts from the pot's bottom, hurling peppers and spices into the air. In slow-motion detail, captured by high-speed photography, they streak across the camera, accompanied by splattering, flaming droplets of oil, before slamming back into the crimson purgatory. The entire picture is illuminated by a hellish fire that originates from the bottom of the pot and shines from the inside out, forming an extremely high contrast of light and shadow, locking the main color in a saturated and almost supernatural red. This is not just food, but also a visual feast full of Tsui Hark's martial arts fantasy style, full of wild and unrestrained energy and spectacular aesthetics of destruction, creating a grand and dangerous atmosphere.", + "seed": 6168, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_2/index_9880_seed_6168_dp_4_rank_8_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.06462331842631101, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06462331842631101, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.05, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06462331842631101, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle in a close-up view of a pot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are dried red chilies, dark Sichuan peppercorns, star anise, and bay leaves visible in the oil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the ingredients tumble, collide, and swirl in a turbulent vortex within the roiling oil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a high-contrast light source originating from the bottom of the pot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the dominant color of the scene a saturated, supernatural red?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.019249066710472107 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.144248962402344 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.019249066710472107, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.019249066710472107, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0984729677438736, + 0.5375007390975952, + 0.04069673642516136, + 0.04647329822182655, + 0.0437471903860569, + 0.07890329509973526, + 0.014182684943079948, + 0.032323744148015976, + 0.04541255161166191, + 0.062286727130413055 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.019249066710472107 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle in a close-up view of a pot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are dried red chilies, dark Sichuan peppercorns, star anise, and bay leaves visible in the oil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the ingredients tumble, collide, and swirl in a turbulent vortex within the roiling oil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a high-contrast light source originating from the bottom of the pot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the dominant color of the scene a saturated, supernatural red?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04307881370186806 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168078899383545 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04307881370186806, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04307881370186806, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.02940283715724945, + 0.7781522274017334, + 0.019054627045989037, + 0.05948460102081299, + 0.016026152297854424, + 0.02438775636255741, + 0.008765086531639099, + 0.025229688733816147, + 0.013094160705804825, + 0.026402810588479042 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04307881370186806 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle in a close-up view of a pot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are dried red chilies, dark Sichuan peppercorns, star anise, and bay leaves visible in the oil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the ingredients tumble, collide, and swirl in a turbulent vortex within the roiling oil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a high-contrast light source originating from the bottom of the pot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the dominant color of the scene a saturated, supernatural red?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007631788495928049 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882631778717041 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007631788495928049, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007631788495928049, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07965686172246933, + 0.4419282078742981, + 0.03242168575525284, + 0.07088513672351837, + 0.07149910926818848, + 0.03990643098950386, + 0.06173943728208542, + 0.13305574655532837, + 0.03001856803894043, + 0.038888849318027496 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007631788495928049 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle in a close-up view of a pot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are dried red chilies, dark Sichuan peppercorns, star anise, and bay leaves visible in the oil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the ingredients tumble, collide, and swirl in a turbulent vortex within the roiling oil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a high-contrast light source originating from the bottom of the pot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the dominant color of the scene a saturated, supernatural red?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2521146237850189 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5021146535873413 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2521146237850189, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2521146237850189, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1523401290178299, + 0.377103328704834, + 0.050712645053863525, + 0.057089999318122864, + 0.026531126350164413, + 0.1026729866862297, + 0.05851299688220024, + 0.1012762114405632, + 0.03178572654724121, + 0.04197483882308006 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2521146237850189 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle in a close-up view of a pot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are dried red chilies, dark Sichuan peppercorns, star anise, and bay leaves visible in the oil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the ingredients tumble, collide, and swirl in a turbulent vortex within the roiling oil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a high-contrast light source originating from the bottom of the pot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the dominant color of the scene a saturated, supernatural red?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0010422994382679462 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.876042366027832 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0010422994382679462, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0010422994382679462, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1333775520324707, + 0.4823719263076782, + 0.026813775300979614, + 0.04105069860816002, + 0.026036633178591728, + 0.11025736480951309, + 0.05826369673013687, + 0.07066867500543594, + 0.012369339354336262, + 0.038790326565504074 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0010422994382679462 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "stunning low-angle close-up, almost completely immersed in the scalding hot pot, the camera trembles subtly with the bubbling liquid. Within this deep, viscous, roiling sea of crimson oil, countless dried red chilies, dark Sichuan peppercorns, and a variety of star anise and bay leaves, saturated with grease and glistening with oil, are swept up by a turbulent vortex. They tumble, collide, and tumble fiercely within the seething red oil, like a vast army engaged in an epic melee. A powerful wave of heat erupts from the pot's bottom, hurling peppers and spices into the air. In slow-motion detail, captured by high-speed photography, they streak across the camera, accompanied by splattering, flaming droplets of oil, before slamming back into the crimson purgatory. The entire picture is illuminated by a hellish fire that originates from the bottom of the pot and shines from the inside out, forming an extremely high contrast of light and shadow, locking the main color in a saturated and almost supernatural red. This is not just food, but also a visual feast full of Tsui Hark's martial arts fantasy style, full of wild and unrestrained energy and spectacular aesthetics of destruction, creating a grand and dangerous atmosphere.", + "seed": 6169, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_2/index_9880_seed_6169_dp_4_rank_8_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.043956993403844534, + "vlm_logprob": -0.043956993403844534, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.075, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.043956993403844534, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle in a close-up view of a pot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are dried red chilies, dark Sichuan peppercorns, star anise, and bay leaves visible in the oil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the ingredients tumble, collide, and swirl in a turbulent vortex within the roiling oil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a high-contrast light source originating from the bottom of the pot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the dominant color of the scene a saturated, supernatural red?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02582542411983013 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.9008255004882812 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02582542411983013, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02582542411983013, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1263788640499115, + 0.0727728083729744, + 0.19720594584941864, + 0.09875523298978806, + 0.19650736451148987, + 0.04914233088493347, + 0.09999439120292664, + 0.07334292680025101, + 0.021280910819768906, + 0.06461919099092484 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02582542411983013 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle in a close-up view of a pot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are dried red chilies, dark Sichuan peppercorns, star anise, and bay leaves visible in the oil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the ingredients tumble, collide, and swirl in a turbulent vortex within the roiling oil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a high-contrast light source originating from the bottom of the pot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the dominant color of the scene a saturated, supernatural red?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.054993223398923874 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929993152618408 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.054993223398923874, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.054993223398923874, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07567686587572098, + 0.14378277957439423, + 0.1715710163116455, + 0.09373423457145691, + 0.15617820620536804, + 0.15634451806545258, + 0.043233055621385574, + 0.04702484980225563, + 0.019786149263381958, + 0.09266828745603561 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.054993223398923874 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle in a close-up view of a pot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are dried red chilies, dark Sichuan peppercorns, star anise, and bay leaves visible in the oil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the ingredients tumble, collide, and swirl in a turbulent vortex within the roiling oil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a high-contrast light source originating from the bottom of the pot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the dominant color of the scene a saturated, supernatural red?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01107910368591547 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.51107931137085 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01107910368591547, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01107910368591547, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1323055922985077, + 0.06374479085206985, + 0.21285682916641235, + 0.0711011290550232, + 0.1244085356593132, + 0.1175541877746582, + 0.058298029005527496, + 0.11873584240674973, + 0.030332257971167564, + 0.07066277414560318 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01107910368591547 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle in a close-up view of a pot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are dried red chilies, dark Sichuan peppercorns, star anise, and bay leaves visible in the oil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the ingredients tumble, collide, and swirl in a turbulent vortex within the roiling oil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a high-contrast light source originating from the bottom of the pot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the dominant color of the scene a saturated, supernatural red?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1270734667778015 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1270735263824463 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1270734667778015, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1270734667778015, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06419320404529572, + 0.10562846064567566, + 0.4257829487323761, + 0.1105593591928482, + 0.018878426402807236, + 0.015817837789654732, + 0.0480894036591053, + 0.016025429591536522, + 0.013201592490077019, + 0.18182334303855896 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1270734667778015 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle in a close-up view of a pot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are dried red chilies, dark Sichuan peppercorns, star anise, and bay leaves visible in the oil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the ingredients tumble, collide, and swirl in a turbulent vortex within the roiling oil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a high-contrast light source originating from the bottom of the pot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the dominant color of the scene a saturated, supernatural red?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0008137490367516875 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.125813961029053 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0008137490367516875, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0008137490367516875, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13504938781261444, + 0.06455862522125244, + 0.1909165382385254, + 0.1744489073753357, + 0.06145201995968819, + 0.058797385543584824, + 0.16820840537548065, + 0.06270615011453629, + 0.035711586475372314, + 0.048150986433029175 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0008137490367516875 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "stunning low-angle close-up, almost completely immersed in the scalding hot pot, the camera trembles subtly with the bubbling liquid. Within this deep, viscous, roiling sea of crimson oil, countless dried red chilies, dark Sichuan peppercorns, and a variety of star anise and bay leaves, saturated with grease and glistening with oil, are swept up by a turbulent vortex. They tumble, collide, and tumble fiercely within the seething red oil, like a vast army engaged in an epic melee. A powerful wave of heat erupts from the pot's bottom, hurling peppers and spices into the air. In slow-motion detail, captured by high-speed photography, they streak across the camera, accompanied by splattering, flaming droplets of oil, before slamming back into the crimson purgatory. The entire picture is illuminated by a hellish fire that originates from the bottom of the pot and shines from the inside out, forming an extremely high contrast of light and shadow, locking the main color in a saturated and almost supernatural red. This is not just food, but also a visual feast full of Tsui Hark's martial arts fantasy style, full of wild and unrestrained energy and spectacular aesthetics of destruction, creating a grand and dangerous atmosphere.", + "seed": 6170, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_2/index_9880_seed_6170_dp_5_rank_10_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.057671906985342504, + "vlm_logprob": -0.057671906985342504, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.075, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.057671906985342504, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle in a close-up view of a pot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are dried red chilies, dark Sichuan peppercorns, star anise, and bay leaves visible in the oil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the ingredients tumble, collide, and swirl in a turbulent vortex within the roiling oil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a high-contrast light source originating from the bottom of the pot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the dominant color of the scene a saturated, supernatural red?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.019254213199019432 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.144254207611084 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.019254213199019432, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.019254213199019432, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1846933513879776, + 0.48431944847106934, + 0.05196021869778633, + 0.042320989072322845, + 0.03382928669452667, + 0.11124549061059952, + 0.022398389875888824, + 0.0222784373909235, + 0.021995680406689644, + 0.024958748370409012 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.019254213199019432 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle in a close-up view of a pot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are dried red chilies, dark Sichuan peppercorns, star anise, and bay leaves visible in the oil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the ingredients tumble, collide, and swirl in a turbulent vortex within the roiling oil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a high-contrast light source originating from the bottom of the pot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the dominant color of the scene a saturated, supernatural red?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03371504321694374 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408715009689331 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03371504321694374, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03371504321694374, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3910271227359772, + 0.2026015967130661, + 0.058748096227645874, + 0.057658612728118896, + 0.032919250428676605, + 0.15280364453792572, + 0.017906496301293373, + 0.05995414778590202, + 0.012973597273230553, + 0.013407492078840733 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03371504321694374 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle in a close-up view of a pot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are dried red chilies, dark Sichuan peppercorns, star anise, and bay leaves visible in the oil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the ingredients tumble, collide, and swirl in a turbulent vortex within the roiling oil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a high-contrast light source originating from the bottom of the pot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the dominant color of the scene a saturated, supernatural red?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008640168234705925 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758640289306641 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008640168234705925, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008640168234705925, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.49252596497535706, + 0.10703126341104507, + 0.0473342165350914, + 0.03889447823166847, + 0.05239776894450188, + 0.15654471516609192, + 0.02840285561978817, + 0.03176083043217659, + 0.020155474543571472, + 0.024952396750450134 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008640168234705925 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle in a close-up view of a pot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are dried red chilies, dark Sichuan peppercorns, star anise, and bay leaves visible in the oil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the ingredients tumble, collide, and swirl in a turbulent vortex within the roiling oil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a high-contrast light source originating from the bottom of the pot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the dominant color of the scene a saturated, supernatural red?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22557075321674347 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.600570797920227 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.22557075321674347, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.22557075321674347, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.49524399638175964, + 0.1457410752773285, + 0.03772323578596115, + 0.07308246940374374, + 0.05317998677492142, + 0.07526929676532745, + 0.02029482275247574, + 0.03517347201704979, + 0.018315134570002556, + 0.045976441353559494 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.22557075321674347 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle in a close-up view of a pot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are dried red chilies, dark Sichuan peppercorns, star anise, and bay leaves visible in the oil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the ingredients tumble, collide, and swirl in a turbulent vortex within the roiling oil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a high-contrast light source originating from the bottom of the pot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the dominant color of the scene a saturated, supernatural red?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0011793570592999458 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.751179218292236 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0011793570592999458, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0011793570592999458, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3456540107727051, + 0.20845447480678558, + 0.057212911546230316, + 0.0410633310675621, + 0.07119651138782501, + 0.17917834222316742, + 0.012246663682162762, + 0.031139997765421867, + 0.016022324562072754, + 0.03783143311738968 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0011793570592999458 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "stunning low-angle close-up, almost completely immersed in the scalding hot pot, the camera trembles subtly with the bubbling liquid. Within this deep, viscous, roiling sea of crimson oil, countless dried red chilies, dark Sichuan peppercorns, and a variety of star anise and bay leaves, saturated with grease and glistening with oil, are swept up by a turbulent vortex. They tumble, collide, and tumble fiercely within the seething red oil, like a vast army engaged in an epic melee. A powerful wave of heat erupts from the pot's bottom, hurling peppers and spices into the air. In slow-motion detail, captured by high-speed photography, they streak across the camera, accompanied by splattering, flaming droplets of oil, before slamming back into the crimson purgatory. The entire picture is illuminated by a hellish fire that originates from the bottom of the pot and shines from the inside out, forming an extremely high contrast of light and shadow, locking the main color in a saturated and almost supernatural red. This is not just food, but also a visual feast full of Tsui Hark's martial arts fantasy style, full of wild and unrestrained energy and spectacular aesthetics of destruction, creating a grand and dangerous atmosphere.", + "seed": 6171, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_2/index_9880_seed_6171_dp_5_rank_10_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.037377677368931474, + "vlm_logprob": -0.037377677368931474, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.574999976158142, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.037377677368931474, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle in a close-up view of a pot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are dried red chilies, dark Sichuan peppercorns, star anise, and bay leaves visible in the oil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the ingredients tumble, collide, and swirl in a turbulent vortex within the roiling oil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a high-contrast light source originating from the bottom of the pot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the dominant color of the scene a saturated, supernatural red?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.015022126957774162 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.390022277832031 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.015022126957774162, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.015022126957774162, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05487116053700447, + 0.03959287330508232, + 0.10847221314907074, + 0.025815360248088837, + 0.0406358577311039, + 0.06358013302087784, + 0.5277978777885437, + 0.02911323681473732, + 0.07125123590230942, + 0.03887007385492325 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 2, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.015022126957774162 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle in a close-up view of a pot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are dried red chilies, dark Sichuan peppercorns, star anise, and bay leaves visible in the oil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the ingredients tumble, collide, and swirl in a turbulent vortex within the roiling oil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a high-contrast light source originating from the bottom of the pot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the dominant color of the scene a saturated, supernatural red?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023305892944335938 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773305892944336 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023305892944335938, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023305892944335938, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04315486177802086, + 0.042431462556123734, + 0.030464734882116318, + 0.06655427068471909, + 0.026454998180270195, + 0.03386162966489792, + 0.3911004662513733, + 0.03422458469867706, + 0.2917051315307617, + 0.04004796966910362 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023305892944335938 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle in a close-up view of a pot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are dried red chilies, dark Sichuan peppercorns, star anise, and bay leaves visible in the oil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the ingredients tumble, collide, and swirl in a turbulent vortex within the roiling oil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a high-contrast light source originating from the bottom of the pot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the dominant color of the scene a saturated, supernatural red?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005255098920315504 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255255222320557 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005255098920315504, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005255098920315504, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03763171657919884, + 0.05657977610826492, + 0.05776558071374893, + 0.028040476143360138, + 0.01828596740961075, + 0.03392321988940239, + 0.5258172154426575, + 0.031000757589936256, + 0.19306612014770508, + 0.017889242619276047 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005255098920315504 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle in a close-up view of a pot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are dried red chilies, dark Sichuan peppercorns, star anise, and bay leaves visible in the oil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the ingredients tumble, collide, and swirl in a turbulent vortex within the roiling oil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a high-contrast light source originating from the bottom of the pot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the dominant color of the scene a saturated, supernatural red?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14280924201011658 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0178091526031494 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14280924201011658, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.8749998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14280924201011658, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08848574012517929, + 0.07746795564889908, + 0.22557112574577332, + 0.12117261439561844, + 0.11821777373552322, + 0.06331344693899155, + 0.17406083643436432, + 0.02647210843861103, + 0.08962777256965637, + 0.015610624104738235 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 6, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14280924201011658 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle in a close-up view of a pot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are dried red chilies, dark Sichuan peppercorns, star anise, and bay leaves visible in the oil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the ingredients tumble, collide, and swirl in a turbulent vortex within the roiling oil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a high-contrast light source originating from the bottom of the pot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the dominant color of the scene a saturated, supernatural red?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0004960260121151805 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.625495910644531 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0004960260121151805, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0004960260121151805, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07812882214784622, + 0.08783585578203201, + 0.16847161948680878, + 0.06740377098321915, + 0.05112917721271515, + 0.05674807354807854, + 0.16280874609947205, + 0.029946302995085716, + 0.2547128200531006, + 0.04281476512551308 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 2, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0004960260121151805 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_3/index_tensor([8394, 8394])_group_3_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_3/index_tensor([8394, 8394])_group_3_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..4e41b4bbda20539136242485c2057a50c0b172c3 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_3/index_tensor([8394, 8394])_group_3_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "slow, low-angle shot panning rightward, captured in Steve McCurry's signature documentary style, captures a scene on a wet city sidewalk late at night. In the frame, a highly saturated neon light casts a shadow from the entrance of an unseen bar. Deep reds and electric blues intertwine, creating psychedelic patches of light across the damp asphalt. At the center of the image is a ginger tabby cat, one ear slightly chipped, its fur slightly matted but warm in the multicolored light. Huddled in the shadows near the bar entrance, its body forming an elegant arc, it raises one front paw with focused and deliberate concentration, meticulously and methodically licking the dust from its paw pad with its pink tongue. The camera moves in incredibly slow steps, following the rhythm of its licking, capturing in close-up the way water droplets from its tongue touch its paw and the soft golden edges of its body outlined by the neon light. The entire scene is shrouded in a quiet and profound atmosphere. The strong color contrast forms a sharp contrast with the subject's quiet posture, creating a poetic moment full of dignity and loneliness found in a corner of a bustling city.", + "seed": 13001, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_3/index_8394_seed_13001_dp_6_rank_12_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.36071121573913845, + "vlm_logprob": -0.36071121573913845, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.8, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.36071121573913845, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a wet city sidewalk late at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a ginger tabby cat with one slightly chipped ear visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cat raising one front paw to lick dust from its paw pad with a pink tongue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow pan rightward while capturing close-up details of water droplets and neon light edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the colors highly saturated with deep reds and electric blues creating psychedelic patches of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5037974119186401 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.25379738211631775 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.5037974119186401, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -1.5037974119186401, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19950005412101746, + 0.06874438375234604, + 0.07787926495075226, + 0.17681552469730377, + 0.06693510711193085, + 0.01707814261317253, + 0.06774986535310745, + 0.1257200539112091, + 0.14985644817352295, + 0.049721140414476395 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.5037974119186401 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a wet city sidewalk late at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a ginger tabby cat with one slightly chipped ear visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cat raising one front paw to lick dust from its paw pad with a pink tongue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow pan rightward while capturing close-up details of water droplets and neon light edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the colors highly saturated with deep reds and electric blues creating psychedelic patches of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016100158914923668 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.14109992980957 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016100158914923668, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016100158914923668, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20859293639659882, + 0.08832772076129913, + 0.08346181362867355, + 0.20847664773464203, + 0.07852830737829208, + 0.02255033701658249, + 0.0807441771030426, + 0.1121613085269928, + 0.06865265965461731, + 0.04850413277745247 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016100158914923668 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a wet city sidewalk late at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a ginger tabby cat with one slightly chipped ear visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cat raising one front paw to lick dust from its paw pad with a pink tongue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow pan rightward while capturing close-up details of water droplets and neon light edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the colors highly saturated with deep reds and electric blues creating psychedelic patches of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02982400916516781 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298240184783936 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02982400916516781, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02982400916516781, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14460133016109467, + 0.06972973793745041, + 0.20532555878162384, + 0.21071070432662964, + 0.030995046719908714, + 0.030167479068040848, + 0.0612698495388031, + 0.08756627887487411, + 0.08983368426561356, + 0.06980036944150925 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02982400916516781 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a wet city sidewalk late at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a ginger tabby cat with one slightly chipped ear visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cat raising one front paw to lick dust from its paw pad with a pink tongue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow pan rightward while capturing close-up details of water droplets and neon light edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the colors highly saturated with deep reds and electric blues creating psychedelic patches of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.25211602449417114 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5021159648895264 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.25211602449417114, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.25211602449417114, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.050088509917259216, + 0.05374394729733467, + 0.1191742792725563, + 0.0854102075099945, + 0.3365415632724762, + 0.02880825102329254, + 0.024653634056448936, + 0.19137944281101227, + 0.08648587763309479, + 0.023714210838079453 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 7, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.25211602449417114 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a wet city sidewalk late at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a ginger tabby cat with one slightly chipped ear visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cat raising one front paw to lick dust from its paw pad with a pink tongue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow pan rightward while capturing close-up details of water droplets and neon light edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the colors highly saturated with deep reds and electric blues creating psychedelic patches of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0017184742027893662 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.376718521118164 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0017184742027893662, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0017184742027893662, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19340968132019043, + 0.043096717447042465, + 0.07205266505479813, + 0.18957242369651794, + 0.12970204651355743, + 0.12469666451215744, + 0.09270396083593369, + 0.05604874715209007, + 0.062370285391807556, + 0.036346837878227234 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0017184742027893662 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow, low-angle shot panning rightward, captured in Steve McCurry's signature documentary style, captures a scene on a wet city sidewalk late at night. In the frame, a highly saturated neon light casts a shadow from the entrance of an unseen bar. Deep reds and electric blues intertwine, creating psychedelic patches of light across the damp asphalt. At the center of the image is a ginger tabby cat, one ear slightly chipped, its fur slightly matted but warm in the multicolored light. Huddled in the shadows near the bar entrance, its body forming an elegant arc, it raises one front paw with focused and deliberate concentration, meticulously and methodically licking the dust from its paw pad with its pink tongue. The camera moves in incredibly slow steps, following the rhythm of its licking, capturing in close-up the way water droplets from its tongue touch its paw and the soft golden edges of its body outlined by the neon light. The entire scene is shrouded in a quiet and profound atmosphere. The strong color contrast forms a sharp contrast with the subject's quiet posture, creating a poetic moment full of dignity and loneliness found in a corner of a bustling city.", + "seed": 13002, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_3/index_8394_seed_13002_dp_6_rank_12_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.21983362772734835, + "vlm_logprob": -0.21983362772734835, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.3, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.21983362772734835, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a wet city sidewalk late at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a ginger tabby cat with one slightly chipped ear visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cat raising one front paw to lick dust from its paw pad with a pink tongue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow pan rightward while capturing close-up details of water droplets and neon light edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the colors highly saturated with deep reds and electric blues creating psychedelic patches of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8993138670921326 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5243138670921326 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.8993138670921326, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.8993138670921326, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2155931442975998, + 0.16337628662586212, + 0.07122170925140381, + 0.04479299485683441, + 0.2290981113910675, + 0.12458551675081253, + 0.04939950630068779, + 0.0343908816576004, + 0.04769308492541313, + 0.019848791882395744 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.8993138670921326 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a wet city sidewalk late at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a ginger tabby cat with one slightly chipped ear visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cat raising one front paw to lick dust from its paw pad with a pink tongue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow pan rightward while capturing close-up details of water droplets and neon light edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the colors highly saturated with deep reds and electric blues creating psychedelic patches of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018202288076281548 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018202304840088 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018202288076281548, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018202288076281548, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1645122617483139, + 0.3281301259994507, + 0.08598103374242783, + 0.0817427933216095, + 0.0858888253569603, + 0.07207894325256348, + 0.03143776208162308, + 0.028317896649241447, + 0.0948207899928093, + 0.027089610695838928 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018202288076281548 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a wet city sidewalk late at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a ginger tabby cat with one slightly chipped ear visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cat raising one front paw to lick dust from its paw pad with a pink tongue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow pan rightward while capturing close-up details of water droplets and neon light edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the colors highly saturated with deep reds and electric blues creating psychedelic patches of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020584875717759132 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.89558482170105 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020584875717759132, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020584875717759132, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17672914266586304, + 0.0635688453912735, + 0.1928277611732483, + 0.13413943350315094, + 0.0857982411980629, + 0.10206480324268341, + 0.11992166191339493, + 0.016844818368554115, + 0.0891168862581253, + 0.018988395109772682 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020584875717759132 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a wet city sidewalk late at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a ginger tabby cat with one slightly chipped ear visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cat raising one front paw to lick dust from its paw pad with a pink tongue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow pan rightward while capturing close-up details of water droplets and neon light edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the colors highly saturated with deep reds and electric blues creating psychedelic patches of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16034770011901855 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9103477001190186 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16034770011901855, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16034770011901855, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10846710205078125, + 0.10221484303474426, + 0.0640799030661583, + 0.05915161222219467, + 0.10685866326093674, + 0.11352122575044632, + 0.19249190390110016, + 0.06586010754108429, + 0.11355981975793839, + 0.07379480451345444 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16034770011901855 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a wet city sidewalk late at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a ginger tabby cat with one slightly chipped ear visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cat raising one front paw to lick dust from its paw pad with a pink tongue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow pan rightward while capturing close-up details of water droplets and neon light edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the colors highly saturated with deep reds and electric blues creating psychedelic patches of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0007194076315499842 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.2507195472717285 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0007194076315499842, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0007194076315499842, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21089765429496765, + 0.15930762887001038, + 0.06351134181022644, + 0.11318738013505936, + 0.16998547315597534, + 0.08523515611886978, + 0.06390102952718735, + 0.048162832856178284, + 0.04873592406511307, + 0.03707560524344444 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0007194076315499842 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow, low-angle shot panning rightward, captured in Steve McCurry's signature documentary style, captures a scene on a wet city sidewalk late at night. In the frame, a highly saturated neon light casts a shadow from the entrance of an unseen bar. Deep reds and electric blues intertwine, creating psychedelic patches of light across the damp asphalt. At the center of the image is a ginger tabby cat, one ear slightly chipped, its fur slightly matted but warm in the multicolored light. Huddled in the shadows near the bar entrance, its body forming an elegant arc, it raises one front paw with focused and deliberate concentration, meticulously and methodically licking the dust from its paw pad with its pink tongue. The camera moves in incredibly slow steps, following the rhythm of its licking, capturing in close-up the way water droplets from its tongue touch its paw and the soft golden edges of its body outlined by the neon light. The entire scene is shrouded in a quiet and profound atmosphere. The strong color contrast forms a sharp contrast with the subject's quiet posture, creating a poetic moment full of dignity and loneliness found in a corner of a bustling city.", + "seed": 13003, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_3/index_8394_seed_13003_dp_7_rank_14_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.41056694433791563, + "vlm_logprob": -0.41056694433791563, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.9, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.41056694433791563, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a wet city sidewalk late at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a ginger tabby cat with one slightly chipped ear visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cat raising one front paw to lick dust from its paw pad with a pink tongue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow pan rightward while capturing close-up details of water droplets and neon light edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the colors highly saturated with deep reds and electric blues creating psychedelic patches of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9108573198318481 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16085733473300934 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.9108573198318481, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -1.9108573198318481, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0739276334643364, + 0.06635043770074844, + 0.15806140005588531, + 0.06360755115747452, + 0.194575697183609, + 0.058960046619176865, + 0.13201270997524261, + 0.034980032593011856, + 0.17943450808525085, + 0.03809007257223129 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.9108573198318481 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a wet city sidewalk late at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a ginger tabby cat with one slightly chipped ear visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cat raising one front paw to lick dust from its paw pad with a pink tongue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow pan rightward while capturing close-up details of water droplets and neon light edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the colors highly saturated with deep reds and electric blues creating psychedelic patches of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05499999225139618 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.930000066757202 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05499999225139618, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05499999225139618, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1342528760433197, + 0.06320059299468994, + 0.042025502771139145, + 0.03814263641834259, + 0.275071918964386, + 0.1399047076702118, + 0.07909350097179413, + 0.0407208614051342, + 0.1416151225566864, + 0.04597225785255432 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05499999225139618 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a wet city sidewalk late at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a ginger tabby cat with one slightly chipped ear visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cat raising one front paw to lick dust from its paw pad with a pink tongue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow pan rightward while capturing close-up details of water droplets and neon light edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the colors highly saturated with deep reds and electric blues creating psychedelic patches of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04308087006211281 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680808067321777 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04308087006211281, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04308087006211281, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1375124156475067, + 0.07831097394227982, + 0.07426314055919647, + 0.07269888371229172, + 0.28490132093429565, + 0.12144754827022552, + 0.09750289469957352, + 0.0505371056497097, + 0.06449995934963226, + 0.018325764685869217 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04308087006211281 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a wet city sidewalk late at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a ginger tabby cat with one slightly chipped ear visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cat raising one front paw to lick dust from its paw pad with a pink tongue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow pan rightward while capturing close-up details of water droplets and neon light edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the colors highly saturated with deep reds and electric blues creating psychedelic patches of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04308052733540535 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680805683135986 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04308052733540535, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04308052733540535, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0854005515575409, + 0.04090186953544617, + 0.10259830951690674, + 0.1371307373046875, + 0.15299081802368164, + 0.10096489638090134, + 0.10052735358476639, + 0.03805987909436226, + 0.22149235010147095, + 0.01993323117494583 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04308052733540535 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a wet city sidewalk late at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a ginger tabby cat with one slightly chipped ear visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cat raising one front paw to lick dust from its paw pad with a pink tongue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow pan rightward while capturing close-up details of water droplets and neon light edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the colors highly saturated with deep reds and electric blues creating psychedelic patches of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.000816012208815664 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.1258158683776855 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.000816012208815664, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.000816012208815664, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07150843739509583, + 0.049328677356243134, + 0.13733547925949097, + 0.15591999888420105, + 0.2089807540178299, + 0.06918080151081085, + 0.06661897897720337, + 0.0509154386818409, + 0.1613345742225647, + 0.028876839205622673 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 8, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.000816012208815664 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow, low-angle shot panning rightward, captured in Steve McCurry's signature documentary style, captures a scene on a wet city sidewalk late at night. In the frame, a highly saturated neon light casts a shadow from the entrance of an unseen bar. Deep reds and electric blues intertwine, creating psychedelic patches of light across the damp asphalt. At the center of the image is a ginger tabby cat, one ear slightly chipped, its fur slightly matted but warm in the multicolored light. Huddled in the shadows near the bar entrance, its body forming an elegant arc, it raises one front paw with focused and deliberate concentration, meticulously and methodically licking the dust from its paw pad with its pink tongue. The camera moves in incredibly slow steps, following the rhythm of its licking, capturing in close-up the way water droplets from its tongue touch its paw and the soft golden edges of its body outlined by the neon light. The entire scene is shrouded in a quiet and profound atmosphere. The strong color contrast forms a sharp contrast with the subject's quiet posture, creating a poetic moment full of dignity and loneliness found in a corner of a bustling city.", + "seed": 13004, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_3/index_8394_seed_13004_dp_7_rank_14_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.06231558509171009, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06231558509171009, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.55, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06231558509171009, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a wet city sidewalk late at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a ginger tabby cat with one slightly chipped ear visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cat raising one front paw to lick dust from its paw pad with a pink tongue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow pan rightward while capturing close-up details of water droplets and neon light edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the colors highly saturated with deep reds and electric blues creating psychedelic patches of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05947012081742287 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9344701766967773 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05947012081742287, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05947012081742287, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2920224070549011, + 0.15465743839740753, + 0.055032193660736084, + 0.0753292441368103, + 0.0599496029317379, + 0.0383719876408577, + 0.03197817504405975, + 0.15949854254722595, + 0.07938935607671738, + 0.05377114191651344 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05947012081742287 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a wet city sidewalk late at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a ginger tabby cat with one slightly chipped ear visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cat raising one front paw to lick dust from its paw pad with a pink tongue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow pan rightward while capturing close-up details of water droplets and neon light edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the colors highly saturated with deep reds and electric blues creating psychedelic patches of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11295470595359802 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.237954616546631 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11295470595359802, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11295470595359802, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07529815286397934, + 0.07980667799711227, + 0.026571301743388176, + 0.06832018494606018, + 0.05458185449242592, + 0.12207100540399551, + 0.22381581366062164, + 0.0914410799741745, + 0.1786249279975891, + 0.07946901023387909 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11295470595359802 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a wet city sidewalk late at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a ginger tabby cat with one slightly chipped ear visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cat raising one front paw to lick dust from its paw pad with a pink tongue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow pan rightward while capturing close-up details of water droplets and neon light edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the colors highly saturated with deep reds and electric blues creating psychedelic patches of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03812174126505852 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881217002868652 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03812174126505852, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03812174126505852, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09438503533601761, + 0.10448021441698074, + 0.12348497658967972, + 0.06839995086193085, + 0.07225596159696579, + 0.13905499875545502, + 0.14368149638175964, + 0.07322701066732407, + 0.12424997240304947, + 0.05678039789199829 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03812174126505852 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a wet city sidewalk late at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a ginger tabby cat with one slightly chipped ear visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cat raising one front paw to lick dust from its paw pad with a pink tongue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow pan rightward while capturing close-up details of water droplets and neon light edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the colors highly saturated with deep reds and electric blues creating psychedelic patches of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10031183063983917 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.350311756134033 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10031183063983917, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10031183063983917, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04229961335659027, + 0.11640628427267075, + 0.02935643680393696, + 0.08689587563276291, + 0.09691637009382248, + 0.186802476644516, + 0.08722639828920364, + 0.12204175442457199, + 0.11428387463092804, + 0.11777094751596451 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10031183063983917 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a wet city sidewalk late at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a ginger tabby cat with one slightly chipped ear visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cat raising one front paw to lick dust from its paw pad with a pink tongue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow pan rightward while capturing close-up details of water droplets and neon light edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the colors highly saturated with deep reds and electric blues creating psychedelic patches of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0007195267826318741 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.2507195472717285 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0007195267826318741, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0007195267826318741, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14389577507972717, + 0.050422314554452896, + 0.10619708895683289, + 0.06064940616488457, + 0.04062839224934578, + 0.047259025275707245, + 0.08722075819969177, + 0.1872565597295761, + 0.22694645822048187, + 0.04952424764633179 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0007195267826318741 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_4/index_tensor([5716, 5716])_group_4_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_4/index_tensor([5716, 5716])_group_4_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..636a5e63394a02f54323e6e23dca4caef4c3e5fa --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_4/index_tensor([5716, 5716])_group_4_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "low, wide-angle shot, shot from above, slowly pans upward through a lush bamboo forest shrouded in morning mist. Soft, diffused light penetrates the mist and dense bamboo foliage, casting visible beams of light in the air. The camera finally settles on a woman in a traditional Chinese costume, dressed in an elegant aquamarine silk robe. Her long, cascading black hair is held together only partially by a simple jade hairpin. Her face is clear and beautiful, her eyes focused and ethereal. With a light touch of the ground, her entire body rises as if weightless. The camera instantly switches to a fast, dynamic tracking shot, following her graceful figure as she nimbly weaves between the towering bamboo branches. Her wide sleeves flutter like butterfly wings as she moves swiftly, her skirt carving graceful arcs through the mist. A series of rapidly alternating close-ups follows: the tip of her shoe, delicately embroidered with cloud patterns, lightly steps on a dewy bamboo leaf, which trembles only slightly before returning to its composure; a strand of hair brushes across her focused and serene profile, revealing her perfectly defined jawline; her slender fingers form an elegant sword-like gesture in the air, steadily and calmly directing her body. The entire sequence is seamless, the camera language sharp and precise, capturing every moment of her ethereal, ethereal beauty. Amidst the cool tones of light and the lingering mist, an ethereal atmosphere is created, imbued with both martial arts power and poetic imagery.", + "seed": 17757, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_4/index_5716_seed_17757_dp_8_rank_16_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.046515779476612805, + "vlm_logprob": -0.046515779476612805, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.775, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.046515779476612805, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a lush bamboo forest shrouded in morning mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a woman wearing an elegant aquamarine silk robe with long black hair held by a simple jade hairpin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman rise weightlessly from the ground and then weave nimbly between the bamboo branches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video include a sequence of rapidly alternating close-ups showing her shoe stepping on a dewy leaf, her hair brushing her face, and her fingers forming a sword-like gesture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low wide-angle shot panning upward, then switch to a fast dynamic tracking shot, and finally execute rapidly alternating close-ups?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16192765533924103 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9119277000427246 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16192765533924103, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16192765533924103, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13300785422325134, + 0.030528489500284195, + 0.10301261395215988, + 0.03400249034166336, + 0.14051112532615662, + 0.044749658554792404, + 0.050540290772914886, + 0.05056636035442352, + 0.1584239900112152, + 0.2546570301055908 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16192765533924103 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a lush bamboo forest shrouded in morning mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a woman wearing an elegant aquamarine silk robe with long black hair held by a simple jade hairpin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman rise weightlessly from the ground and then weave nimbly between the bamboo branches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video include a sequence of rapidly alternating close-ups showing her shoe stepping on a dewy leaf, her hair brushing her face, and her fingers forming a sword-like gesture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low wide-angle shot panning upward, then switch to a fast dynamic tracking shot, and finally execute rapidly alternating close-ups?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006746016908437014 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.0067458152771 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006746016908437014, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006746016908437014, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11867177486419678, + 0.03607333078980446, + 0.0549771711230278, + 0.06516280770301819, + 0.29105937480926514, + 0.0680219978094101, + 0.0537540502846241, + 0.0811949223279953, + 0.07650192826986313, + 0.15458272397518158 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006746016908437014 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a lush bamboo forest shrouded in morning mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a woman wearing an elegant aquamarine silk robe with long black hair held by a simple jade hairpin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman rise weightlessly from the ground and then weave nimbly between the bamboo branches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video include a sequence of rapidly alternating close-ups showing her shoe stepping on a dewy leaf, her hair brushing her face, and her fingers forming a sword-like gesture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low wide-angle shot panning upward, then switch to a fast dynamic tracking shot, and finally execute rapidly alternating close-ups?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03809259459376335 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288092613220215 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03809259459376335, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03809259459376335, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0717698335647583, + 0.06273312121629715, + 0.04706483334302902, + 0.08673280477523804, + 0.15599270164966583, + 0.20023620128631592, + 0.05649241432547569, + 0.08194331079721451, + 0.08864951133728027, + 0.14838531613349915 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03809259459376335 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a lush bamboo forest shrouded in morning mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a woman wearing an elegant aquamarine silk robe with long black hair held by a simple jade hairpin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman rise weightlessly from the ground and then weave nimbly between the bamboo branches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video include a sequence of rapidly alternating close-ups showing her shoe stepping on a dewy leaf, her hair brushing her face, and her fingers forming a sword-like gesture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low wide-angle shot panning upward, then switch to a fast dynamic tracking shot, and finally execute rapidly alternating close-ups?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007629540748894215 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.88262939453125 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007629540748894215, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007629540748894215, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1779935508966446, + 0.08006836473941803, + 0.086247019469738, + 0.04777815565466881, + 0.24585764110088348, + 0.10813788324594498, + 0.04830643907189369, + 0.05874115228652954, + 0.060272216796875, + 0.08659759163856506 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007629540748894215 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a lush bamboo forest shrouded in morning mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a woman wearing an elegant aquamarine silk robe with long black hair held by a simple jade hairpin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman rise weightlessly from the ground and then weave nimbly between the bamboo branches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video include a sequence of rapidly alternating close-ups showing her shoe stepping on a dewy leaf, her hair brushing her face, and her fingers forming a sword-like gesture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low wide-angle shot panning upward, then switch to a fast dynamic tracking shot, and finally execute rapidly alternating close-ups?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018183089792728424 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.01818323135376 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018183089792728424, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018183089792728424, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08846249431371689, + 0.02369230054318905, + 0.07233919948339462, + 0.0575542226433754, + 0.37017613649368286, + 0.16847141087055206, + 0.046740442514419556, + 0.04256592318415642, + 0.043844133615493774, + 0.08615374565124512 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018183089792728424 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low, wide-angle shot, shot from above, slowly pans upward through a lush bamboo forest shrouded in morning mist. Soft, diffused light penetrates the mist and dense bamboo foliage, casting visible beams of light in the air. The camera finally settles on a woman in a traditional Chinese costume, dressed in an elegant aquamarine silk robe. Her long, cascading black hair is held together only partially by a simple jade hairpin. Her face is clear and beautiful, her eyes focused and ethereal. With a light touch of the ground, her entire body rises as if weightless. The camera instantly switches to a fast, dynamic tracking shot, following her graceful figure as she nimbly weaves between the towering bamboo branches. Her wide sleeves flutter like butterfly wings as she moves swiftly, her skirt carving graceful arcs through the mist. A series of rapidly alternating close-ups follows: the tip of her shoe, delicately embroidered with cloud patterns, lightly steps on a dewy bamboo leaf, which trembles only slightly before returning to its composure; a strand of hair brushes across her focused and serene profile, revealing her perfectly defined jawline; her slender fingers form an elegant sword-like gesture in the air, steadily and calmly directing her body. The entire sequence is seamless, the camera language sharp and precise, capturing every moment of her ethereal, ethereal beauty. Amidst the cool tones of light and the lingering mist, an ethereal atmosphere is created, imbued with both martial arts power and poetic imagery.", + "seed": 17758, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_4/index_5716_seed_17758_dp_8_rank_16_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.029841463454067706, + "vlm_logprob": -0.029841463454067706, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.7, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.029841463454067706, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a lush bamboo forest shrouded in morning mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a woman wearing an elegant aquamarine silk robe with long black hair held by a simple jade hairpin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman rise weightlessly from the ground and then weave nimbly between the bamboo branches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video include a sequence of rapidly alternating close-ups showing her shoe stepping on a dewy leaf, her hair brushing her face, and her fingers forming a sword-like gesture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low wide-angle shot panning upward, then switch to a fast dynamic tracking shot, and finally execute rapidly alternating close-ups?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07062572240829468 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6956257820129395 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07062572240829468, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07062572240829468, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.30756741762161255, + 0.15674881637096405, + 0.07320327311754227, + 0.14985467493534088, + 0.061795394867658615, + 0.03279411047697067, + 0.0569457970559597, + 0.052606429904699326, + 0.018747035413980484, + 0.08973710238933563 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07062572240829468 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a lush bamboo forest shrouded in morning mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a woman wearing an elegant aquamarine silk robe with long black hair held by a simple jade hairpin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman rise weightlessly from the ground and then weave nimbly between the bamboo branches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video include a sequence of rapidly alternating close-ups showing her shoe stepping on a dewy leaf, her hair brushing her face, and her fingers forming a sword-like gesture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low wide-angle shot panning upward, then switch to a fast dynamic tracking shot, and finally execute rapidly alternating close-ups?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011084762401878834 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.51108455657959 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011084762401878834, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011084762401878834, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12163674831390381, + 0.1092660203576088, + 0.08561770617961884, + 0.06560243666172028, + 0.13835249841213226, + 0.052808914333581924, + 0.0901792049407959, + 0.07061894983053207, + 0.09136025607585907, + 0.17455723881721497 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011084762401878834 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a lush bamboo forest shrouded in morning mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a woman wearing an elegant aquamarine silk robe with long black hair held by a simple jade hairpin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman rise weightlessly from the ground and then weave nimbly between the bamboo branches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video include a sequence of rapidly alternating close-ups showing her shoe stepping on a dewy leaf, her hair brushing her face, and her fingers forming a sword-like gesture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low wide-angle shot panning upward, then switch to a fast dynamic tracking shot, and finally execute rapidly alternating close-ups?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026339925825595856 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513400077819824 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026339925825595856, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026339925825595856, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14284905791282654, + 0.13968004286289215, + 0.08824750036001205, + 0.08472060412168503, + 0.035431839525699615, + 0.05961756780743599, + 0.07334122061729431, + 0.0673128142952919, + 0.0808119848370552, + 0.22798731923103333 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026339925825595856 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a lush bamboo forest shrouded in morning mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a woman wearing an elegant aquamarine silk robe with long black hair held by a simple jade hairpin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman rise weightlessly from the ground and then weave nimbly between the bamboo branches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video include a sequence of rapidly alternating close-ups showing her shoe stepping on a dewy leaf, her hair brushing her face, and her fingers forming a sword-like gesture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low wide-angle shot panning upward, then switch to a fast dynamic tracking shot, and finally execute rapidly alternating close-ups?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020581956952810287 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955819606781006 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020581956952810287, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020581956952810287, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0967026948928833, + 0.1688065081834793, + 0.07821232080459595, + 0.14827018976211548, + 0.05181172862648964, + 0.10794670134782791, + 0.045047689229249954, + 0.03523404523730278, + 0.08482366800308228, + 0.1831444650888443 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020581956952810287 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a lush bamboo forest shrouded in morning mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a woman wearing an elegant aquamarine silk robe with long black hair held by a simple jade hairpin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman rise weightlessly from the ground and then weave nimbly between the bamboo branches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video include a sequence of rapidly alternating close-ups showing her shoe stepping on a dewy leaf, her hair brushing her face, and her fingers forming a sword-like gesture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low wide-angle shot panning upward, then switch to a fast dynamic tracking shot, and finally execute rapidly alternating close-ups?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02057494968175888 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955750465393066 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02057494968175888, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02057494968175888, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20329490303993225, + 0.09659358114004135, + 0.0807652547955513, + 0.1644720733165741, + 0.09329153597354889, + 0.05006701126694679, + 0.0851898342370987, + 0.041009921580553055, + 0.06483816355466843, + 0.12047769874334335 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02057494968175888 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low, wide-angle shot, shot from above, slowly pans upward through a lush bamboo forest shrouded in morning mist. Soft, diffused light penetrates the mist and dense bamboo foliage, casting visible beams of light in the air. The camera finally settles on a woman in a traditional Chinese costume, dressed in an elegant aquamarine silk robe. Her long, cascading black hair is held together only partially by a simple jade hairpin. Her face is clear and beautiful, her eyes focused and ethereal. With a light touch of the ground, her entire body rises as if weightless. The camera instantly switches to a fast, dynamic tracking shot, following her graceful figure as she nimbly weaves between the towering bamboo branches. Her wide sleeves flutter like butterfly wings as she moves swiftly, her skirt carving graceful arcs through the mist. A series of rapidly alternating close-ups follows: the tip of her shoe, delicately embroidered with cloud patterns, lightly steps on a dewy bamboo leaf, which trembles only slightly before returning to its composure; a strand of hair brushes across her focused and serene profile, revealing her perfectly defined jawline; her slender fingers form an elegant sword-like gesture in the air, steadily and calmly directing her body. The entire sequence is seamless, the camera language sharp and precise, capturing every moment of her ethereal, ethereal beauty. Amidst the cool tones of light and the lingering mist, an ethereal atmosphere is created, imbued with both martial arts power and poetic imagery.", + "seed": 17759, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_4/index_5716_seed_17759_dp_9_rank_18_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.05945565830916166, + "vlm_logprob": -0.05945565830916166, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.325, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.05945565830916166, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a lush bamboo forest shrouded in morning mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a woman wearing an elegant aquamarine silk robe with long black hair held by a simple jade hairpin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman rise weightlessly from the ground and then weave nimbly between the bamboo branches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video include a sequence of rapidly alternating close-ups showing her shoe stepping on a dewy leaf, her hair brushing her face, and her fingers forming a sword-like gesture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low wide-angle shot panning upward, then switch to a fast dynamic tracking shot, and finally execute rapidly alternating close-ups?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16091600060462952 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9109159708023071 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16091600060462952, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16091600060462952, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4299376308917999, + 0.014750726521015167, + 0.02407732792198658, + 0.020303450524806976, + 0.02071690373122692, + 0.27801331877708435, + 0.01847362332046032, + 0.031793516129255295, + 0.09790307283401489, + 0.06403046101331711 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16091600060462952 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a lush bamboo forest shrouded in morning mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a woman wearing an elegant aquamarine silk robe with long black hair held by a simple jade hairpin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman rise weightlessly from the ground and then weave nimbly between the bamboo branches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video include a sequence of rapidly alternating close-ups showing her shoe stepping on a dewy leaf, her hair brushing her face, and her fingers forming a sword-like gesture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low wide-angle shot panning upward, then switch to a fast dynamic tracking shot, and finally execute rapidly alternating close-ups?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012548773549497128 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387548923492432 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012548773549497128, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012548773549497128, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12942355871200562, + 0.016156645491719246, + 0.04537733271718025, + 0.02416563406586647, + 0.2439221888780594, + 0.25458770990371704, + 0.05159064009785652, + 0.023385807871818542, + 0.19876649975776672, + 0.012624002993106842 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012548773549497128 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a lush bamboo forest shrouded in morning mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a woman wearing an elegant aquamarine silk robe with long black hair held by a simple jade hairpin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman rise weightlessly from the ground and then weave nimbly between the bamboo branches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video include a sequence of rapidly alternating close-ups showing her shoe stepping on a dewy leaf, her hair brushing her face, and her fingers forming a sword-like gesture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low wide-angle shot panning upward, then switch to a fast dynamic tracking shot, and finally execute rapidly alternating close-ups?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08903498947620392 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4640350341796875 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08903498947620392, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08903498947620392, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.30529963970184326, + 0.016492139548063278, + 0.10668235272169113, + 0.04153842851519585, + 0.04810433089733124, + 0.27377527952194214, + 0.042512569576501846, + 0.027309255674481392, + 0.12370897829532623, + 0.014577009715139866 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08903498947620392 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a lush bamboo forest shrouded in morning mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a woman wearing an elegant aquamarine silk robe with long black hair held by a simple jade hairpin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman rise weightlessly from the ground and then weave nimbly between the bamboo branches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video include a sequence of rapidly alternating close-ups showing her shoe stepping on a dewy leaf, her hair brushing her face, and her fingers forming a sword-like gesture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low wide-angle shot panning upward, then switch to a fast dynamic tracking shot, and finally execute rapidly alternating close-ups?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020585225895047188 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895585298538208 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020585225895047188, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020585225895047188, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3117707669734955, + 0.04092299938201904, + 0.1726730316877365, + 0.03639376536011696, + 0.1270405501127243, + 0.1215045228600502, + 0.025471432134509087, + 0.014446659944951534, + 0.11779065430164337, + 0.03198566660284996 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020585225895047188 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a lush bamboo forest shrouded in morning mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a woman wearing an elegant aquamarine silk robe with long black hair held by a simple jade hairpin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman rise weightlessly from the ground and then weave nimbly between the bamboo branches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video include a sequence of rapidly alternating close-ups showing her shoe stepping on a dewy leaf, her hair brushing her face, and her fingers forming a sword-like gesture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low wide-angle shot panning upward, then switch to a fast dynamic tracking shot, and finally execute rapidly alternating close-ups?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014193302020430565 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264193534851074 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014193302020430565, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014193302020430565, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13624291121959686, + 0.07444170862436295, + 0.1836034059524536, + 0.07568801939487457, + 0.09707927703857422, + 0.2162778228521347, + 0.05798213928937912, + 0.02414628490805626, + 0.11005952209234238, + 0.024478884413838387 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014193302020430565 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low, wide-angle shot, shot from above, slowly pans upward through a lush bamboo forest shrouded in morning mist. Soft, diffused light penetrates the mist and dense bamboo foliage, casting visible beams of light in the air. The camera finally settles on a woman in a traditional Chinese costume, dressed in an elegant aquamarine silk robe. Her long, cascading black hair is held together only partially by a simple jade hairpin. Her face is clear and beautiful, her eyes focused and ethereal. With a light touch of the ground, her entire body rises as if weightless. The camera instantly switches to a fast, dynamic tracking shot, following her graceful figure as she nimbly weaves between the towering bamboo branches. Her wide sleeves flutter like butterfly wings as she moves swiftly, her skirt carving graceful arcs through the mist. A series of rapidly alternating close-ups follows: the tip of her shoe, delicately embroidered with cloud patterns, lightly steps on a dewy bamboo leaf, which trembles only slightly before returning to its composure; a strand of hair brushes across her focused and serene profile, revealing her perfectly defined jawline; her slender fingers form an elegant sword-like gesture in the air, steadily and calmly directing her body. The entire sequence is seamless, the camera language sharp and precise, capturing every moment of her ethereal, ethereal beauty. Amidst the cool tones of light and the lingering mist, an ethereal atmosphere is created, imbued with both martial arts power and poetic imagery.", + "seed": 17760, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_4/index_5716_seed_17760_dp_9_rank_18_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.025586372520774604, + "vlm_logprob": -0.025586372520774604, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.925, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.025586372520774604, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a lush bamboo forest shrouded in morning mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a woman wearing an elegant aquamarine silk robe with long black hair held by a simple jade hairpin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman rise weightlessly from the ground and then weave nimbly between the bamboo branches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video include a sequence of rapidly alternating close-ups showing her shoe stepping on a dewy leaf, her hair brushing her face, and her fingers forming a sword-like gesture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low wide-angle shot panning upward, then switch to a fast dynamic tracking shot, and finally execute rapidly alternating close-ups?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0554879754781723 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.930487871170044 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0554879754781723, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0554879754781723, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4882476031780243, + 0.05515484884381294, + 0.04519796371459961, + 0.10975668579339981, + 0.037344787269830704, + 0.10858209431171417, + 0.05297540873289108, + 0.015458553098142147, + 0.03930613398551941, + 0.047975968569517136 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0554879754781723 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a lush bamboo forest shrouded in morning mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a woman wearing an elegant aquamarine silk robe with long black hair held by a simple jade hairpin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman rise weightlessly from the ground and then weave nimbly between the bamboo branches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video include a sequence of rapidly alternating close-ups showing her shoe stepping on a dewy leaf, her hair brushing her face, and her fingers forming a sword-like gesture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low wide-angle shot panning upward, then switch to a fast dynamic tracking shot, and finally execute rapidly alternating close-ups?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007634391542524099 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882634162902832 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007634391542524099, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007634391542524099, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17587551474571228, + 0.14124040305614471, + 0.06990931183099747, + 0.035597916692495346, + 0.0691947340965271, + 0.23897534608840942, + 0.07434123009443283, + 0.052430324256420135, + 0.06399642676115036, + 0.07843869179487228 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007634391542524099 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a lush bamboo forest shrouded in morning mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a woman wearing an elegant aquamarine silk robe with long black hair held by a simple jade hairpin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman rise weightlessly from the ground and then weave nimbly between the bamboo branches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video include a sequence of rapidly alternating close-ups showing her shoe stepping on a dewy leaf, her hair brushing her face, and her fingers forming a sword-like gesture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low wide-angle shot panning upward, then switch to a fast dynamic tracking shot, and finally execute rapidly alternating close-ups?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03808777406811714 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288087844848633 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03808777406811714, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03808777406811714, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20512090623378754, + 0.0871136486530304, + 0.07607217133045197, + 0.10518376529216766, + 0.12925992906093597, + 0.09858887642621994, + 0.04988744482398033, + 0.03848855569958687, + 0.08666091412305832, + 0.123623788356781 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03808777406811714 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a lush bamboo forest shrouded in morning mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a woman wearing an elegant aquamarine silk robe with long black hair held by a simple jade hairpin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman rise weightlessly from the ground and then weave nimbly between the bamboo branches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video include a sequence of rapidly alternating close-ups showing her shoe stepping on a dewy leaf, her hair brushing her face, and her fingers forming a sword-like gesture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low wide-angle shot panning upward, then switch to a fast dynamic tracking shot, and finally execute rapidly alternating close-ups?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012535235844552517 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387535095214844 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012535235844552517, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012535235844552517, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18123576045036316, + 0.22097939252853394, + 0.05253199487924576, + 0.11377318948507309, + 0.08195365220308304, + 0.0710410624742508, + 0.0686163678765297, + 0.06191045790910721, + 0.0750555545091629, + 0.07290259748697281 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012535235844552517 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a lush bamboo forest shrouded in morning mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a woman wearing an elegant aquamarine silk robe with long black hair held by a simple jade hairpin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman rise weightlessly from the ground and then weave nimbly between the bamboo branches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video include a sequence of rapidly alternating close-ups showing her shoe stepping on a dewy leaf, her hair brushing her face, and her fingers forming a sword-like gesture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low wide-angle shot panning upward, then switch to a fast dynamic tracking shot, and finally execute rapidly alternating close-ups?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014186485670506954 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264186382293701 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014186485670506954, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014186485670506954, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2994421422481537, + 0.15088337659835815, + 0.057844504714012146, + 0.1577335149049759, + 0.05165790766477585, + 0.05815986543893814, + 0.05366497486829758, + 0.06102254241704941, + 0.06282573193311691, + 0.046765442937612534 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014186485670506954 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_5/index_tensor([8683, 8683])_group_5_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_5/index_tensor([8683, 8683])_group_5_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..37e9cd72c386745a006265a1e55639568e416d69 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_5/index_tensor([8683, 8683])_group_5_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "dynamic, high-speed tracking shot, as if shot from an accompanying aircraft, captures the flight of a vibrant, candy-apple-red biplane, its smooth surface reflecting brilliant sunlight. The camera maintains an eye-level perspective in the single, open cockpit, revealing the faint outline of the pilot. The aircraft's propellers spin at such a rapid rate that the nose becomes a mesmerizingly transparent blur. Against the expansive backdrop of a flawless, deep blue sky, the biplane playfully executes daring maneuvers, weaving between and through enormous, fluffy, white cumulus clouds that appear as soft as cotton. It executes a swift and graceful barrel roll, its wings swiveling 360 degrees with thrilling precision, before sharply pulling up in a perfect, gravity-defying loop. The entire scene is bathed in crisp, high-key sunlight, creating brilliant highlights on the aircraft's fuselage and enlivening the saturated primary colors of red, white, and blue, perfectly capturing the festive atmosphere of pure, unadulterated joy in flight.", + "seed": 5587, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_5/index_8683_seed_5587_dp_10_rank_20_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.1925983926281333, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1925983926281333, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.15, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1925983926281333, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a biplane painted in a vibrant candy-apple-red color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned inside the single open cockpit at an eye-level perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pilot visible as a faint outline in the cockpit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the biplane execute a barrel roll followed by a sharp pull-up into a loop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a deep blue sky with enormous fluffy white cumulus clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.25264450907707214 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5026445388793945 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.25264450907707214, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.25264450907707214, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06207676976919174, + 0.03230275958776474, + 0.035261742770671844, + 0.03129638358950615, + 0.21401874721050262, + 0.04827115684747696, + 0.058200396597385406, + 0.06534143537282944, + 0.13513033092021942, + 0.318100243806839 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.25264450907707214 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a biplane painted in a vibrant candy-apple-red color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned inside the single open cockpit at an eye-level perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pilot visible as a faint outline in the cockpit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the biplane execute a barrel roll followed by a sharp pull-up into a loop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a deep blue sky with enormous fluffy white cumulus clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10035334527492523 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.350353240966797 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10035334527492523, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10035334527492523, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0690232515335083, + 0.07015478610992432, + 0.04509219154715538, + 0.1646917462348938, + 0.06797526776790619, + 0.09198754280805588, + 0.05839087814092636, + 0.10152561962604523, + 0.1528615802526474, + 0.17829713225364685 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 3, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10035334527492523 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a biplane painted in a vibrant candy-apple-red color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned inside the single open cockpit at an eye-level perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pilot visible as a faint outline in the cockpit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the biplane execute a barrel roll followed by a sharp pull-up into a loop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a deep blue sky with enormous fluffy white cumulus clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.47427642345428467 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9742764234542847 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.47427642345428467, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.47427642345428467, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06284696608781815, + 0.052700016647577286, + 0.031261831521987915, + 0.038465168327093124, + 0.45473653078079224, + 0.04370599612593651, + 0.02720337174832821, + 0.052457232028245926, + 0.13073842227458954, + 0.10588441044092178 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.47427642345428467 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a biplane painted in a vibrant candy-apple-red color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned inside the single open cockpit at an eye-level perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pilot visible as a faint outline in the cockpit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the biplane execute a barrel roll followed by a sharp pull-up into a loop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a deep blue sky with enormous fluffy white cumulus clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12708070874214172 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1270806789398193 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12708070874214172, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12708070874214172, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0906624123454094, + 0.0508984737098217, + 0.04306361451745033, + 0.05324716493487358, + 0.1840648055076599, + 0.04406141862273216, + 0.045810308307409286, + 0.15381678938865662, + 0.19636428356170654, + 0.13801071047782898 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 4, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12708070874214172 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a biplane painted in a vibrant candy-apple-red color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned inside the single open cockpit at an eye-level perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pilot visible as a faint outline in the cockpit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the biplane execute a barrel roll followed by a sharp pull-up into a loop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a deep blue sky with enormous fluffy white cumulus clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008636976592242718 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758636951446533 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008636976592242718, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008636976592242718, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11854105442762375, + 0.05290118604898453, + 0.06532783806324005, + 0.15992438793182373, + 0.1486455202102661, + 0.07782956957817078, + 0.07203375548124313, + 0.13228465616703033, + 0.044874075800180435, + 0.12763798236846924 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008636976592242718 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dynamic, high-speed tracking shot, as if shot from an accompanying aircraft, captures the flight of a vibrant, candy-apple-red biplane, its smooth surface reflecting brilliant sunlight. The camera maintains an eye-level perspective in the single, open cockpit, revealing the faint outline of the pilot. The aircraft's propellers spin at such a rapid rate that the nose becomes a mesmerizingly transparent blur. Against the expansive backdrop of a flawless, deep blue sky, the biplane playfully executes daring maneuvers, weaving between and through enormous, fluffy, white cumulus clouds that appear as soft as cotton. It executes a swift and graceful barrel roll, its wings swiveling 360 degrees with thrilling precision, before sharply pulling up in a perfect, gravity-defying loop. The entire scene is bathed in crisp, high-key sunlight, creating brilliant highlights on the aircraft's fuselage and enlivening the saturated primary colors of red, white, and blue, perfectly capturing the festive atmosphere of pure, unadulterated joy in flight.", + "seed": 5588, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_5/index_8683_seed_5588_dp_10_rank_20_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.11437342334538698, + "vlm_logprob": -0.11437342334538698, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.724999952316284, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.11437342334538698, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a biplane painted in a vibrant candy-apple-red color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned inside the single open cockpit at an eye-level perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pilot visible as a faint outline in the cockpit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the biplane execute a barrel roll followed by a sharp pull-up into a loop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a deep blue sky with enormous fluffy white cumulus clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12781153619289398 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1278114318847656 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12781153619289398, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.9999998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12781153619289398, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10502823442220688, + 0.10804509371519089, + 0.4779648780822754, + 0.04289069399237633, + 0.03323974087834358, + 0.015328533947467804, + 0.06882006675004959, + 0.07704776525497437, + 0.027073899284005165, + 0.044561080634593964 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12781153619289398 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a biplane painted in a vibrant candy-apple-red color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned inside the single open cockpit at an eye-level perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pilot visible as a faint outline in the cockpit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the biplane execute a barrel roll followed by a sharp pull-up into a loop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a deep blue sky with enormous fluffy white cumulus clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1129656732082367 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2379655838012695 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1129656732082367, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1129656732082367, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12177538871765137, + 0.12345977127552032, + 0.2380513846874237, + 0.13124479353427887, + 0.1307721734046936, + 0.021819090470671654, + 0.04420797899365425, + 0.0637805312871933, + 0.0383434034883976, + 0.08654550462961197 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1129656732082367 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a biplane painted in a vibrant candy-apple-red color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned inside the single open cockpit at an eye-level perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pilot visible as a faint outline in the cockpit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the biplane execute a barrel roll followed by a sharp pull-up into a loop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a deep blue sky with enormous fluffy white cumulus clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20155854523181915 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7015585899353027 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20155854523181915, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20155854523181915, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1384878009557724, + 0.04352027550339699, + 0.5484040975570679, + 0.029332878068089485, + 0.0161100085824728, + 0.01932569593191147, + 0.06836262345314026, + 0.041615404188632965, + 0.061838019639253616, + 0.03300315886735916 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20155854523181915 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a biplane painted in a vibrant candy-apple-red color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned inside the single open cockpit at an eye-level perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pilot visible as a faint outline in the cockpit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the biplane execute a barrel roll followed by a sharp pull-up into a loop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a deep blue sky with enormous fluffy white cumulus clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12704595923423767 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1270458698272705 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12704595923423767, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.9999998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12704595923423767, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25366780161857605, + 0.037908051162958145, + 0.30297648906707764, + 0.05188370868563652, + 0.06500864773988724, + 0.015151741914451122, + 0.05198578163981438, + 0.05263350158929825, + 0.14264509081840515, + 0.026139168068766594 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12704595923423767 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a biplane painted in a vibrant candy-apple-red color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned inside the single open cockpit at an eye-level perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pilot visible as a faint outline in the cockpit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the biplane execute a barrel roll followed by a sharp pull-up into a loop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a deep blue sky with enormous fluffy white cumulus clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00248540285974741 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002485275268555 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00248540285974741, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00248540285974741, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11444166302680969, + 0.02358248084783554, + 0.6577473878860474, + 0.05663898214697838, + 0.03197917714715004, + 0.02215244062244892, + 0.01810651458799839, + 0.024467933923006058, + 0.024633513763546944, + 0.026249872520565987 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00248540285974741 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dynamic, high-speed tracking shot, as if shot from an accompanying aircraft, captures the flight of a vibrant, candy-apple-red biplane, its smooth surface reflecting brilliant sunlight. The camera maintains an eye-level perspective in the single, open cockpit, revealing the faint outline of the pilot. The aircraft's propellers spin at such a rapid rate that the nose becomes a mesmerizingly transparent blur. Against the expansive backdrop of a flawless, deep blue sky, the biplane playfully executes daring maneuvers, weaving between and through enormous, fluffy, white cumulus clouds that appear as soft as cotton. It executes a swift and graceful barrel roll, its wings swiveling 360 degrees with thrilling precision, before sharply pulling up in a perfect, gravity-defying loop. The entire scene is bathed in crisp, high-key sunlight, creating brilliant highlights on the aircraft's fuselage and enlivening the saturated primary colors of red, white, and blue, perfectly capturing the festive atmosphere of pure, unadulterated joy in flight.", + "seed": 5589, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_5/index_8683_seed_5589_dp_11_rank_22_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.19993241364136338, + "vlm_logprob": -0.19993241364136338, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.124999988079071, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.19993241364136338, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a biplane painted in a vibrant candy-apple-red color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned inside the single open cockpit at an eye-level perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pilot visible as a faint outline in the cockpit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the biplane execute a barrel roll followed by a sharp pull-up into a loop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a deep blue sky with enormous fluffy white cumulus clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22648023068904877 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.60148024559021 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.22648023068904877, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.22648023068904877, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12921275198459625, + 0.025335319340229034, + 0.029490426182746887, + 0.02850412391126156, + 0.019870387390255928, + 0.3188743591308594, + 0.11204728484153748, + 0.066276915371418, + 0.1871025264263153, + 0.08328594267368317 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.22648023068904877 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a biplane painted in a vibrant candy-apple-red color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned inside the single open cockpit at an eye-level perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pilot visible as a faint outline in the cockpit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the biplane execute a barrel roll followed by a sharp pull-up into a loop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a deep blue sky with enormous fluffy white cumulus clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1799260973930359 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8049261569976807 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1799260973930359, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1799260973930359, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1347293257713318, + 0.024776747450232506, + 0.01682255044579506, + 0.031117407605051994, + 0.013309130445122719, + 0.03704219311475754, + 0.22412072122097015, + 0.04567651078104973, + 0.38521820306777954, + 0.08718722313642502 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1799260973930359 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a biplane painted in a vibrant candy-apple-red color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned inside the single open cockpit at an eye-level perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pilot visible as a faint outline in the cockpit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the biplane execute a barrel roll followed by a sharp pull-up into a loop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a deep blue sky with enormous fluffy white cumulus clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.387043297290802 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1370432376861572 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.387043297290802, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.7499999403953552, + "token_credit_reward": -0.387043297290802, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.047713205218315125, + 0.018245313316583633, + 0.013741112314164639, + 0.01199444942176342, + 0.011889408342540264, + 0.12823665142059326, + 0.048962220549583435, + 0.10939562320709229, + 0.5810345411300659, + 0.028787491843104362 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.387043297290802 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a biplane painted in a vibrant candy-apple-red color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned inside the single open cockpit at an eye-level perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pilot visible as a faint outline in the cockpit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the biplane execute a barrel roll followed by a sharp pull-up into a loop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a deep blue sky with enormous fluffy white cumulus clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20157666504383087 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7015767097473145 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20157666504383087, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20157666504383087, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.024680934846401215, + 0.007008457090705633, + 0.005560537334531546, + 0.015056713484227657, + 0.008866350166499615, + 0.14717334508895874, + 0.33112284541130066, + 0.09698008000850677, + 0.3289853036403656, + 0.03456547111272812 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20157666504383087 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a biplane painted in a vibrant candy-apple-red color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned inside the single open cockpit at an eye-level perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pilot visible as a faint outline in the cockpit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the biplane execute a barrel roll followed by a sharp pull-up into a loop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a deep blue sky with enormous fluffy white cumulus clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004635777790099382 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379635810852051 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004635777790099382, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004635777790099382, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05021698400378227, + 0.015983575955033302, + 0.04362565651535988, + 0.0180585365742445, + 0.010009123012423515, + 0.23174190521240234, + 0.27486452460289, + 0.041928693652153015, + 0.2911234200000763, + 0.02244763821363449 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004635777790099382 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dynamic, high-speed tracking shot, as if shot from an accompanying aircraft, captures the flight of a vibrant, candy-apple-red biplane, its smooth surface reflecting brilliant sunlight. The camera maintains an eye-level perspective in the single, open cockpit, revealing the faint outline of the pilot. The aircraft's propellers spin at such a rapid rate that the nose becomes a mesmerizingly transparent blur. Against the expansive backdrop of a flawless, deep blue sky, the biplane playfully executes daring maneuvers, weaving between and through enormous, fluffy, white cumulus clouds that appear as soft as cotton. It executes a swift and graceful barrel roll, its wings swiveling 360 degrees with thrilling precision, before sharply pulling up in a perfect, gravity-defying loop. The entire scene is bathed in crisp, high-key sunlight, creating brilliant highlights on the aircraft's fuselage and enlivening the saturated primary colors of red, white, and blue, perfectly capturing the festive atmosphere of pure, unadulterated joy in flight.", + "seed": 5590, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_5/index_8683_seed_5590_dp_11_rank_22_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.13582579549402, + "vlm_logprob": -0.13582579549402, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.575, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.13582579549402, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a biplane painted in a vibrant candy-apple-red color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned inside the single open cockpit at an eye-level perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pilot visible as a faint outline in the cockpit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the biplane execute a barrel roll followed by a sharp pull-up into a loop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a deep blue sky with enormous fluffy white cumulus clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10078121721744537 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.350781202316284 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10078121721744537, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10078121721744537, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1177004799246788, + 0.14099495112895966, + 0.07496349513530731, + 0.03288179263472557, + 0.057612355798482895, + 0.11451942473649979, + 0.1111082136631012, + 0.021703945472836494, + 0.14659453928470612, + 0.1819208264350891 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10078121721744537 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a biplane painted in a vibrant candy-apple-red color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned inside the single open cockpit at an eye-level perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pilot visible as a faint outline in the cockpit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the biplane execute a barrel roll followed by a sharp pull-up into a loop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a deep blue sky with enormous fluffy white cumulus clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2814003527164459 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4064003229141235 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2814003527164459, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2814003527164459, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12189403921365738, + 0.2971479594707489, + 0.10045843571424484, + 0.03693903610110283, + 0.03667648136615753, + 0.095467209815979, + 0.04959734529256821, + 0.036688026040792465, + 0.08023558557033539, + 0.14489583671092987 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2814003527164459 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a biplane painted in a vibrant candy-apple-red color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned inside the single open cockpit at an eye-level perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pilot visible as a faint outline in the cockpit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the biplane execute a barrel roll followed by a sharp pull-up into a loop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a deep blue sky with enormous fluffy white cumulus clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2521000802516937 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5021001100540161 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2521000802516937, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2521000802516937, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1483251005411148, + 0.1409073919057846, + 0.07125617563724518, + 0.03862423822283745, + 0.04491189867258072, + 0.16455069184303284, + 0.09124863892793655, + 0.03147249296307564, + 0.10575089603662491, + 0.16295243799686432 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2521000802516937 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a biplane painted in a vibrant candy-apple-red color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned inside the single open cockpit at an eye-level perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pilot visible as a faint outline in the cockpit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the biplane execute a barrel roll followed by a sharp pull-up into a loop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a deep blue sky with enormous fluffy white cumulus clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03811267763376236 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881126403808594 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03811267763376236, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03811267763376236, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07449602335691452, + 0.11757127195596695, + 0.0977589562535286, + 0.08878256380558014, + 0.038237035274505615, + 0.058039210736751556, + 0.07368236780166626, + 0.06859441101551056, + 0.14327265322208405, + 0.23956546187400818 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03811267763376236 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a biplane painted in a vibrant candy-apple-red color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned inside the single open cockpit at an eye-level perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pilot visible as a faint outline in the cockpit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the biplane execute a barrel roll followed by a sharp pull-up into a loop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a deep blue sky with enormous fluffy white cumulus clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006734649650752544 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006734848022461 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006734649650752544, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006734649650752544, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0875651016831398, + 0.09760621190071106, + 0.1446247547864914, + 0.030805567279458046, + 0.011661291122436523, + 0.14361143112182617, + 0.04627534747123718, + 0.1287878304719925, + 0.07069484889507294, + 0.23836766183376312 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006734649650752544 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_6/index_tensor([7019, 7019])_group_6_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_6/index_tensor([7019, 7019])_group_6_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..def689529d61639c00be9cc8feaab55e1d3422f1 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_6/index_tensor([7019, 7019])_group_6_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "low-angle, wide-angle tracking shot follows a column of heavily armored cavalry on the march, capturing their epic journey across the vast wasteland. The group, comprised of approximately ten knights, is clad in weathered steel plate armor. Their closed helmets, with only narrow eye slits, obscure their features, revealing only a steely resolve. The metal of their armor, stained with battle scratches and a touch of rust, reflects a dazzling, sharp white light in the glaring afternoon sun. Their towering warhorses, similarly clad in metal armor, march with steady, powerful strides. Each hooves' tread on the cracked yellow earth and scattered gravel stirs up powerful plumes of yellow dust. This dust, illuminated by the sun, forms a golden mist that shrouds the cavalry, blurring the distant horizon and imbuing the scene with a profound sense of historical weight and vicissitudes. The leading knight occasionally raises his gauntleted hand and points into the distance, as if to determine the direction. The entire team maintains a compact and vigilant formation, steadily exploring forward. The main colors of the picture are ochre and the pale sky, punctuated by the silver-grey of the armor and the occasional crimson of the edge of the battle robe, creating a solemn, tenacious, and epic atmosphere of exploration.", + "seed": 1458, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_6/index_7019_seed_1458_dp_12_rank_24_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.27830060916021465, + "vlm_logprob": -0.27830060916021465, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.125, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.27830060916021465, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene featuring a column of approximately ten knights in weathered steel plate armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the knights' helmets closed with only narrow eye slits visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the knights riding warhorses clad in metal armor across cracked yellow earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a wide-angle tracking shot following the cavalry's forward movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5242023468017578 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.0242023468017578 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5242023468017578, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5242023468017578, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13956308364868164, + 0.05491821467876434, + 0.5940094590187073, + 0.030932392925024033, + 0.04549768939614296, + 0.008138311095535755, + 0.07703069597482681, + 0.024484941735863686, + 0.012933106161653996, + 0.012492095120251179 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5242023468017578 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene featuring a column of approximately ten knights in weathered steel plate armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the knights' helmets closed with only narrow eye slits visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the knights riding warhorses clad in metal armor across cracked yellow earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a wide-angle tracking shot following the cavalry's forward movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.693354606628418 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.693354606628418 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.693354606628418, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.693354606628418, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23094548285007477, + 0.08342080563306808, + 0.18742398917675018, + 0.08148843795061111, + 0.122495137155056, + 0.035912662744522095, + 0.12012714147567749, + 0.039526745676994324, + 0.06954052299261093, + 0.02911907248198986 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.693354606628418 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene featuring a column of approximately ten knights in weathered steel plate armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the knights' helmets closed with only narrow eye slits visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the knights riding warhorses clad in metal armor across cracked yellow earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a wide-angle tracking shot following the cavalry's forward movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11305096000432968 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.238050937652588 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11305096000432968, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11305096000432968, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2863862216472626, + 0.08422254025936127, + 0.09036959707736969, + 0.07648561149835587, + 0.12083754688501358, + 0.08495186269283295, + 0.1057237833738327, + 0.042706042528152466, + 0.07868790626525879, + 0.029628936201334 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11305096000432968 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene featuring a column of approximately ten knights in weathered steel plate armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the knights' helmets closed with only narrow eye slits visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the knights riding warhorses clad in metal armor across cracked yellow earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a wide-angle tracking shot following the cavalry's forward movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005949525628238916 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.1309494972229 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005949525628238916, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005949525628238916, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18098007142543793, + 0.03907505422830582, + 0.5219634175300598, + 0.04558708146214485, + 0.0453493595123291, + 0.04235391691327095, + 0.04005475714802742, + 0.01731470599770546, + 0.04011125862598419, + 0.027210406959056854 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005949525628238916 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene featuring a column of approximately ten knights in weathered steel plate armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the knights' helmets closed with only narrow eye slits visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the knights riding warhorses clad in metal armor across cracked yellow earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a wide-angle tracking shot following the cavalry's forward movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.054945606738328934 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929945707321167 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.054945606738328934, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.054945606738328934, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12262735515832901, + 0.036438874900341034, + 0.5966609716415405, + 0.03687271848320961, + 0.12349485605955124, + 0.020297328010201454, + 0.016958728432655334, + 0.017671944573521614, + 0.017632942646741867, + 0.011344301514327526 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.054945606738328934 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, wide-angle tracking shot follows a column of heavily armored cavalry on the march, capturing their epic journey across the vast wasteland. The group, comprised of approximately ten knights, is clad in weathered steel plate armor. Their closed helmets, with only narrow eye slits, obscure their features, revealing only a steely resolve. The metal of their armor, stained with battle scratches and a touch of rust, reflects a dazzling, sharp white light in the glaring afternoon sun. Their towering warhorses, similarly clad in metal armor, march with steady, powerful strides. Each hooves' tread on the cracked yellow earth and scattered gravel stirs up powerful plumes of yellow dust. This dust, illuminated by the sun, forms a golden mist that shrouds the cavalry, blurring the distant horizon and imbuing the scene with a profound sense of historical weight and vicissitudes. The leading knight occasionally raises his gauntleted hand and points into the distance, as if to determine the direction. The entire team maintains a compact and vigilant formation, steadily exploring forward. The main colors of the picture are ochre and the pale sky, punctuated by the silver-grey of the armor and the occasional crimson of the edge of the battle robe, creating a solemn, tenacious, and epic atmosphere of exploration.", + "seed": 1459, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_6/index_7019_seed_1459_dp_12_rank_24_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.2892548210918903, + "vlm_logprob": -0.2892548210918903, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.949999988079071, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.2892548210918903, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene featuring a column of approximately ten knights in weathered steel plate armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the knights' helmets closed with only narrow eye slits visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the knights riding warhorses clad in metal armor across cracked yellow earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a wide-angle tracking shot following the cavalry's forward movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5191352963447571 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.0191352367401123 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5191352963447571, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.4999999403953552, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5191352963447571, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21175089478492737, + 0.1384841799736023, + 0.11572703719139099, + 0.07096823304891586, + 0.060325540602207184, + 0.10199722647666931, + 0.03564543277025223, + 0.06561493873596191, + 0.14895571768283844, + 0.0505308173596859 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5191352963447571 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene featuring a column of approximately ten knights in weathered steel plate armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the knights' helmets closed with only narrow eye slits visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the knights riding warhorses clad in metal armor across cracked yellow earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a wide-angle tracking shot following the cavalry's forward movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7577999830245972 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6327999830245972 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.7577999830245972, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.7577999830245972, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19474732875823975, + 0.17368504405021667, + 0.09033603221178055, + 0.07476609200239182, + 0.037913642823696136, + 0.14425812661647797, + 0.04351311922073364, + 0.13551349937915802, + 0.026873039081692696, + 0.07839410752058029 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.7577999830245972 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene featuring a column of approximately ten knights in weathered steel plate armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the knights' helmets closed with only narrow eye slits visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the knights riding warhorses clad in metal armor across cracked yellow earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a wide-angle tracking shot following the cavalry's forward movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11305319517850876 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2380530834198 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11305319517850876, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11305319517850876, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2428896129131317, + 0.1928212195634842, + 0.08506752550601959, + 0.07327134162187576, + 0.03893372789025307, + 0.07949180901050568, + 0.021901605650782585, + 0.1375661939382553, + 0.04435272887349129, + 0.08370423316955566 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11305319517850876 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene featuring a column of approximately ten knights in weathered steel plate armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the knights' helmets closed with only narrow eye slits visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the knights riding warhorses clad in metal armor across cracked yellow earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a wide-angle tracking shot following the cavalry's forward movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01819268986582756 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018192768096924 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01819268986582756, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01819268986582756, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21146933734416962, + 0.17744098603725433, + 0.11647234112024307, + 0.08707501739263535, + 0.04400559514760971, + 0.12677942216396332, + 0.020208533853292465, + 0.11874371767044067, + 0.06027961149811745, + 0.037525393068790436 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01819268986582756 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene featuring a column of approximately ten knights in weathered steel plate armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the knights' helmets closed with only narrow eye slits visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the knights riding warhorses clad in metal armor across cracked yellow earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a wide-angle tracking shot following the cavalry's forward movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03809294104576111 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288092851638794 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03809294104576111, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03809294104576111, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16130073368549347, + 0.18629804253578186, + 0.08375972509384155, + 0.09274222701787949, + 0.02529103122651577, + 0.05120590329170227, + 0.029053570702672005, + 0.13973453640937805, + 0.19520273804664612, + 0.03541150316596031 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03809294104576111 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, wide-angle tracking shot follows a column of heavily armored cavalry on the march, capturing their epic journey across the vast wasteland. The group, comprised of approximately ten knights, is clad in weathered steel plate armor. Their closed helmets, with only narrow eye slits, obscure their features, revealing only a steely resolve. The metal of their armor, stained with battle scratches and a touch of rust, reflects a dazzling, sharp white light in the glaring afternoon sun. Their towering warhorses, similarly clad in metal armor, march with steady, powerful strides. Each hooves' tread on the cracked yellow earth and scattered gravel stirs up powerful plumes of yellow dust. This dust, illuminated by the sun, forms a golden mist that shrouds the cavalry, blurring the distant horizon and imbuing the scene with a profound sense of historical weight and vicissitudes. The leading knight occasionally raises his gauntleted hand and points into the distance, as if to determine the direction. The entire team maintains a compact and vigilant formation, steadily exploring forward. The main colors of the picture are ochre and the pale sky, punctuated by the silver-grey of the armor and the occasional crimson of the edge of the battle robe, creating a solemn, tenacious, and epic atmosphere of exploration.", + "seed": 1460, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_6/index_7019_seed_1460_dp_13_rank_26_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.26956569217145443, + "vlm_logprob": -0.26956569217145443, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.125, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.26956569217145443, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene featuring a column of approximately ten knights in weathered steel plate armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the knights' helmets closed with only narrow eye slits visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the knights riding warhorses clad in metal armor across cracked yellow earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a wide-angle tracking shot following the cavalry's forward movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.46919262409210205 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.094192624092102 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.46919262409210205, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.46919262409210205, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.30293816328048706, + 0.037517424672842026, + 0.18407690525054932, + 0.04887022823095322, + 0.13423581421375275, + 0.04798160120844841, + 0.04316587373614311, + 0.10646295547485352, + 0.05581432953476906, + 0.038936715573072433 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.46919262409210205 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene featuring a column of approximately ten knights in weathered steel plate armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the knights' helmets closed with only narrow eye slits visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the knights riding warhorses clad in metal armor across cracked yellow earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a wide-angle tracking shot following the cavalry's forward movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6933540105819702 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6933540105819702 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.6933540105819702, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.6933540105819702, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18475750088691711, + 0.06163206323981285, + 0.3342073857784271, + 0.028227947652339935, + 0.04634125158190727, + 0.03374028578400612, + 0.0866565927863121, + 0.10605952143669128, + 0.08715052157640457, + 0.031226931139826775 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.6933540105819702 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene featuring a column of approximately ten knights in weathered steel plate armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the knights' helmets closed with only narrow eye slits visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the knights riding warhorses clad in metal armor across cracked yellow earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a wide-angle tracking shot following the cavalry's forward movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14294761419296265 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0179476737976074 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14294761419296265, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14294761419296265, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17116834223270416, + 0.1092044860124588, + 0.22374887764453888, + 0.09409735351800919, + 0.023581966757774353, + 0.042546048760414124, + 0.11605256795883179, + 0.08369836211204529, + 0.09894219785928726, + 0.036959774792194366 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14294761419296265 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene featuring a column of approximately ten knights in weathered steel plate armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the knights' helmets closed with only narrow eye slits visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the knights riding warhorses clad in metal armor across cracked yellow earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a wide-angle tracking shot following the cavalry's forward movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008639222010970116 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758639335632324 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008639222010970116, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008639222010970116, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1713605523109436, + 0.08697532117366791, + 0.19542139768600464, + 0.0870923399925232, + 0.10382229089736938, + 0.07814756780862808, + 0.07635219395160675, + 0.06243954971432686, + 0.09947077929973602, + 0.038917962461709976 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008639222010970116 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene featuring a column of approximately ten knights in weathered steel plate armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the knights' helmets closed with only narrow eye slits visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the knights riding warhorses clad in metal armor across cracked yellow earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a wide-angle tracking shot following the cavalry's forward movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03369498997926712 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4086949825286865 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03369498997926712, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03369498997926712, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.26045724749565125, + 0.04683977738022804, + 0.17784981429576874, + 0.19159343838691711, + 0.049169108271598816, + 0.017493413761258125, + 0.03267640620470047, + 0.1697387397289276, + 0.023930436000227928, + 0.030251650139689445 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03369498997926712 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, wide-angle tracking shot follows a column of heavily armored cavalry on the march, capturing their epic journey across the vast wasteland. The group, comprised of approximately ten knights, is clad in weathered steel plate armor. Their closed helmets, with only narrow eye slits, obscure their features, revealing only a steely resolve. The metal of their armor, stained with battle scratches and a touch of rust, reflects a dazzling, sharp white light in the glaring afternoon sun. Their towering warhorses, similarly clad in metal armor, march with steady, powerful strides. Each hooves' tread on the cracked yellow earth and scattered gravel stirs up powerful plumes of yellow dust. This dust, illuminated by the sun, forms a golden mist that shrouds the cavalry, blurring the distant horizon and imbuing the scene with a profound sense of historical weight and vicissitudes. The leading knight occasionally raises his gauntleted hand and points into the distance, as if to determine the direction. The entire team maintains a compact and vigilant formation, steadily exploring forward. The main colors of the picture are ochre and the pale sky, punctuated by the silver-grey of the armor and the occasional crimson of the edge of the battle robe, creating a solemn, tenacious, and epic atmosphere of exploration.", + "seed": 1461, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_6/index_7019_seed_1461_dp_13_rank_26_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.2146626112051308, + "vlm_logprob": -0.2146626112051308, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.525, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.2146626112051308, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene featuring a column of approximately ten knights in weathered steel plate armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the knights' helmets closed with only narrow eye slits visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the knights riding warhorses clad in metal armor across cracked yellow earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a wide-angle tracking shot following the cavalry's forward movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.39674487709999084 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2717448472976685 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.39674487709999084, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.39674487709999084, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.35539937019348145, + 0.1302221566438675, + 0.12195252627134323, + 0.039926331490278244, + 0.0906170904636383, + 0.023426532745361328, + 0.058436136692762375, + 0.04369302839040756, + 0.0996457114815712, + 0.036681171506643295 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.39674487709999084 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene featuring a column of approximately ten knights in weathered steel plate armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the knights' helmets closed with only narrow eye slits visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the knights riding warhorses clad in metal armor across cracked yellow earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a wide-angle tracking shot following the cavalry's forward movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5761322379112244 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8261322379112244 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5761322379112244, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5761322379112244, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06831308454275131, + 0.0431763119995594, + 0.05254033952951431, + 0.030364694073796272, + 0.023533763363957405, + 0.024358635768294334, + 0.024222200736403465, + 0.09078002721071243, + 0.6152756810188293, + 0.02743525244295597 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5761322379112244 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene featuring a column of approximately ten knights in weathered steel plate armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the knights' helmets closed with only narrow eye slits visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the knights riding warhorses clad in metal armor across cracked yellow earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a wide-angle tracking shot following the cavalry's forward movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06210721656680107 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8121073246002197 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06210721656680107, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06210721656680107, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07226069271564484, + 0.036072902381420135, + 0.03657917305827141, + 0.02945535071194172, + 0.015727447345852852, + 0.015218664892017841, + 0.02089858613908291, + 0.053157780319452286, + 0.6888338923454285, + 0.03179549798369408 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06210721656680107 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene featuring a column of approximately ten knights in weathered steel plate armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the knights' helmets closed with only narrow eye slits visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the knights riding warhorses clad in metal armor across cracked yellow earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a wide-angle tracking shot following the cavalry's forward movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0046369642950594425 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379636764526367 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0046369642950594425, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0046369642950594425, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1762988567352295, + 0.06298341602087021, + 0.07277289032936096, + 0.029681449756026268, + 0.020077239722013474, + 0.04133646562695503, + 0.02761813811957836, + 0.06900075823068619, + 0.4668191075325012, + 0.033411670476198196 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0046369642950594425 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene featuring a column of approximately ten knights in weathered steel plate armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the knights' helmets closed with only narrow eye slits visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the knights riding warhorses clad in metal armor across cracked yellow earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a wide-angle tracking shot following the cavalry's forward movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.033691760152578354 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408691644668579 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.033691760152578354, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.033691760152578354, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1069168671965599, + 0.0931241363286972, + 0.054081499576568604, + 0.022931229323148727, + 0.04946765676140785, + 0.018720196560025215, + 0.0414767824113369, + 0.09255453944206238, + 0.4389539659023285, + 0.08177309483289719 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.033691760152578354 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_7/index_tensor([2825, 2825])_group_7_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_7/index_tensor([2825, 2825])_group_7_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..9d9775bdc81d5c80fe50a9cf656c0aea26266b6f --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_7/index_tensor([2825, 2825])_group_7_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "surreal, static, extreme macro close-up, tightly framed from a slightly low angle, captures the raw moment of the confrontation with breathtaking clarity. A small, sleek black scorpion dominates the frame, its jet-black, carapace-like exoskeleton gleaming with a menacing sheen. Its body tenses, its pincers slightly open, poised, its distinctive, segmented tail arched high over its back in a characteristically menacing pose. At its tip, a sharp, yellow stinger gleams, poised to strike with deadly precision. Its target is a larger beetle larva, helplessly wriggling directly beneath it. The larva's soft, milky-white, C-shaped body, with its fleshy, translucent sections, twitches in slow, desperate waves. This dramatic encounter unfolds on a piece of rotting, damp wood, where the intricate texture of the dark veins and shredded fibers is clearly rendered. A soft, diffuse light, as if filtering through a forest canopy, meticulously captures the tiny, almost invisible hairs on the scorpion's legs and highlights the larva's damp, glistening surface, creating a scene of intense, suspended tension. The overall atmosphere is clean and calm, a raw and focused look at the predator-prey dynamic frozen in the moments before its violent end.", + "seed": 30778, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_7/index_2825_seed_30778_dp_14_rank_28_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.014833289803937078, + "vlm_logprob": -0.014833289803937078, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.6, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.014833289803937078, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro close-up of a small, sleek black scorpion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scorpion's body tensed with pincers slightly open and its segmented tail arched high over its back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a larger beetle larva visible directly beneath the scorpion, wriggling in a soft, milky-white C-shaped body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a piece of rotting, damp wood with clearly rendered dark veins and shredded fibers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera framed from a slightly low angle in a static position?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.039000801742076874 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2890007495880127 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.039000801742076874, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.039000801742076874, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24276190996170044, + 0.05559263378381729, + 0.25059691071510315, + 0.07066794484853745, + 0.0380808562040329, + 0.09547771513462067, + 0.03416808694601059, + 0.18182727694511414, + 0.018585357815027237, + 0.012241365388035774 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.039000801742076874 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro close-up of a small, sleek black scorpion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scorpion's body tensed with pincers slightly open and its segmented tail arched high over its back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a larger beetle larva visible directly beneath the scorpion, wriggling in a soft, milky-white C-shaped body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a piece of rotting, damp wood with clearly rendered dark veins and shredded fibers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera framed from a slightly low angle in a static position?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01108936034142971 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511089324951172 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01108936034142971, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01108936034142971, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2137712687253952, + 0.1580769270658493, + 0.10211680084466934, + 0.04094395041465759, + 0.19694523513317108, + 0.032356616109609604, + 0.13746249675750732, + 0.06056523695588112, + 0.03862844035029411, + 0.01913309283554554 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01108936034142971 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro close-up of a small, sleek black scorpion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scorpion's body tensed with pincers slightly open and its segmented tail arched high over its back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a larger beetle larva visible directly beneath the scorpion, wriggling in a soft, milky-white C-shaped body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a piece of rotting, damp wood with clearly rendered dark veins and shredded fibers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera framed from a slightly low angle in a static position?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011071204207837582 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.51107120513916 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011071204207837582, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011071204207837582, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07051476091146469, + 0.060830965638160706, + 0.017017845064401627, + 0.045440271496772766, + 0.6073717474937439, + 0.009996382519602776, + 0.09148432314395905, + 0.011707962490618229, + 0.026795024052262306, + 0.05884066969156265 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011071204207837582 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro close-up of a small, sleek black scorpion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scorpion's body tensed with pincers slightly open and its segmented tail arched high over its back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a larger beetle larva visible directly beneath the scorpion, wriggling in a soft, milky-white C-shaped body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a piece of rotting, damp wood with clearly rendered dark veins and shredded fibers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera framed from a slightly low angle in a static position?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0019370617810636759 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.251936912536621 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0019370617810636759, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0019370617810636759, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21475231647491455, + 0.13012227416038513, + 0.1823081374168396, + 0.04500135779380798, + 0.06314750015735626, + 0.012911837548017502, + 0.23984295129776, + 0.054990410804748535, + 0.03480239585042, + 0.022120777517557144 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0019370617810636759 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro close-up of a small, sleek black scorpion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scorpion's body tensed with pincers slightly open and its segmented tail arched high over its back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a larger beetle larva visible directly beneath the scorpion, wriggling in a soft, milky-white C-shaped body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a piece of rotting, damp wood with clearly rendered dark veins and shredded fibers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera framed from a slightly low angle in a static position?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011068020947277546 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511067867279053 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011068020947277546, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011068020947277546, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09744666516780853, + 0.23035866022109985, + 0.09635309129953384, + 0.0282876156270504, + 0.046080153435468674, + 0.08074764162302017, + 0.15519559383392334, + 0.10287047177553177, + 0.07007767260074615, + 0.09258244186639786 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011068020947277546 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "surreal, static, extreme macro close-up, tightly framed from a slightly low angle, captures the raw moment of the confrontation with breathtaking clarity. A small, sleek black scorpion dominates the frame, its jet-black, carapace-like exoskeleton gleaming with a menacing sheen. Its body tenses, its pincers slightly open, poised, its distinctive, segmented tail arched high over its back in a characteristically menacing pose. At its tip, a sharp, yellow stinger gleams, poised to strike with deadly precision. Its target is a larger beetle larva, helplessly wriggling directly beneath it. The larva's soft, milky-white, C-shaped body, with its fleshy, translucent sections, twitches in slow, desperate waves. This dramatic encounter unfolds on a piece of rotting, damp wood, where the intricate texture of the dark veins and shredded fibers is clearly rendered. A soft, diffuse light, as if filtering through a forest canopy, meticulously captures the tiny, almost invisible hairs on the scorpion's legs and highlights the larva's damp, glistening surface, creating a scene of intense, suspended tension. The overall atmosphere is clean and calm, a raw and focused look at the predator-prey dynamic frozen in the moments before its violent end.", + "seed": 30779, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_7/index_2825_seed_30779_dp_14_rank_28_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.010843281075358391, + "vlm_logprob": -0.010843281075358391, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.775, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.010843281075358391, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro close-up of a small, sleek black scorpion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scorpion's body tensed with pincers slightly open and its segmented tail arched high over its back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a larger beetle larva visible directly beneath the scorpion, wriggling in a soft, milky-white C-shaped body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a piece of rotting, damp wood with clearly rendered dark veins and shredded fibers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera framed from a slightly low angle in a static position?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016406161710619926 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141406059265137 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016406161710619926, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016406161710619926, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.41769030690193176, + 0.13695058226585388, + 0.11362505704164505, + 0.07630251348018646, + 0.0988035649061203, + 0.02942805364727974, + 0.01845041662454605, + 0.05019770935177803, + 0.03308626636862755, + 0.025465531274676323 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016406161710619926 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro close-up of a small, sleek black scorpion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scorpion's body tensed with pincers slightly open and its segmented tail arched high over its back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a larger beetle larva visible directly beneath the scorpion, wriggling in a soft, milky-white C-shaped body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a piece of rotting, damp wood with clearly rendered dark veins and shredded fibers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera framed from a slightly low angle in a static position?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0097922682762146 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634792327880859 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0097922682762146, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0097922682762146, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.29951024055480957, + 0.11124978214502335, + 0.1243286281824112, + 0.05575195699930191, + 0.12049029022455215, + 0.020765438675880432, + 0.07767672091722488, + 0.09405684471130371, + 0.07032819092273712, + 0.025841914117336273 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0097922682762146 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro close-up of a small, sleek black scorpion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scorpion's body tensed with pincers slightly open and its segmented tail arched high over its back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a larger beetle larva visible directly beneath the scorpion, wriggling in a soft, milky-white C-shaped body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a piece of rotting, damp wood with clearly rendered dark veins and shredded fibers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera framed from a slightly low angle in a static position?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004635659046471119 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379635810852051 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004635659046471119, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004635659046471119, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19652554392814636, + 0.2551974654197693, + 0.15447776019573212, + 0.06480160355567932, + 0.14378739893436432, + 0.043896015733480453, + 0.023050697520375252, + 0.048680663108825684, + 0.036176297813653946, + 0.03340652957558632 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004635659046471119 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro close-up of a small, sleek black scorpion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scorpion's body tensed with pincers slightly open and its segmented tail arched high over its back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a larger beetle larva visible directly beneath the scorpion, wriggling in a soft, milky-white C-shaped body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a piece of rotting, damp wood with clearly rendered dark veins and shredded fibers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera framed from a slightly low angle in a static position?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0028139064088463783 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877813816070557 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0028139064088463783, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0028139064088463783, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2004663497209549, + 0.10342823714017868, + 0.13078369200229645, + 0.11257471144199371, + 0.06188878417015076, + 0.013450675643980503, + 0.022408144548535347, + 0.11911479383707047, + 0.2080877125263214, + 0.027796907350420952 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0028139064088463783 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro close-up of a small, sleek black scorpion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scorpion's body tensed with pincers slightly open and its segmented tail arched high over its back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a larger beetle larva visible directly beneath the scorpion, wriggling in a soft, milky-white C-shaped body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a piece of rotting, damp wood with clearly rendered dark veins and shredded fibers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera framed from a slightly low angle in a static position?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02056840993463993 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895568370819092 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02056840993463993, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02056840993463993, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04409553110599518, + 0.18766887485980988, + 0.07810621708631516, + 0.0793149322271347, + 0.29887914657592773, + 0.02564123086631298, + 0.07867086678743362, + 0.0802992507815361, + 0.09669897705316544, + 0.03062499314546585 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02056840993463993 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "surreal, static, extreme macro close-up, tightly framed from a slightly low angle, captures the raw moment of the confrontation with breathtaking clarity. A small, sleek black scorpion dominates the frame, its jet-black, carapace-like exoskeleton gleaming with a menacing sheen. Its body tenses, its pincers slightly open, poised, its distinctive, segmented tail arched high over its back in a characteristically menacing pose. At its tip, a sharp, yellow stinger gleams, poised to strike with deadly precision. Its target is a larger beetle larva, helplessly wriggling directly beneath it. The larva's soft, milky-white, C-shaped body, with its fleshy, translucent sections, twitches in slow, desperate waves. This dramatic encounter unfolds on a piece of rotting, damp wood, where the intricate texture of the dark veins and shredded fibers is clearly rendered. A soft, diffuse light, as if filtering through a forest canopy, meticulously captures the tiny, almost invisible hairs on the scorpion's legs and highlights the larva's damp, glistening surface, creating a scene of intense, suspended tension. The overall atmosphere is clean and calm, a raw and focused look at the predator-prey dynamic frozen in the moments before its violent end.", + "seed": 30780, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_7/index_2825_seed_30780_dp_15_rank_30_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.03309125071391463, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03309125071391463, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.175, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03309125071391463, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro close-up of a small, sleek black scorpion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scorpion's body tensed with pincers slightly open and its segmented tail arched high over its back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a larger beetle larva visible directly beneath the scorpion, wriggling in a soft, milky-white C-shaped body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a piece of rotting, damp wood with clearly rendered dark veins and shredded fibers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera framed from a slightly low angle in a static position?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11352962255477905 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.238529682159424 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11352962255477905, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11352962255477905, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4550028145313263, + 0.08035336434841156, + 0.04285804182291031, + 0.032719966024160385, + 0.044709350913763046, + 0.07700547575950623, + 0.11066435277462006, + 0.026554783806204796, + 0.050088249146938324, + 0.08004366606473923 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11352962255477905 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro close-up of a small, sleek black scorpion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scorpion's body tensed with pincers slightly open and its segmented tail arched high over its back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a larger beetle larva visible directly beneath the scorpion, wriggling in a soft, milky-white C-shaped body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a piece of rotting, damp wood with clearly rendered dark veins and shredded fibers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera framed from a slightly low angle in a static position?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03372564539313316 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4087257385253906 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03372564539313316, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03372564539313316, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.32956594228744507, + 0.13092473149299622, + 0.05576774850487709, + 0.0666026771068573, + 0.03740919753909111, + 0.03505498543381691, + 0.19106681644916534, + 0.06412283331155777, + 0.06544619798660278, + 0.024038808420300484 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03372564539313316 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro close-up of a small, sleek black scorpion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scorpion's body tensed with pincers slightly open and its segmented tail arched high over its back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a larger beetle larva visible directly beneath the scorpion, wriggling in a soft, milky-white C-shaped body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a piece of rotting, damp wood with clearly rendered dark veins and shredded fibers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera framed from a slightly low angle in a static position?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005943719297647476 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130943775177002 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005943719297647476, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005943719297647476, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2879946231842041, + 0.1413222700357437, + 0.08677933365106583, + 0.04454081133008003, + 0.06245879456400871, + 0.038017403334379196, + 0.19984164834022522, + 0.03343987092375755, + 0.03301726654171944, + 0.07258797436952591 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005943719297647476 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro close-up of a small, sleek black scorpion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scorpion's body tensed with pincers slightly open and its segmented tail arched high over its back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a larger beetle larva visible directly beneath the scorpion, wriggling in a soft, milky-white C-shaped body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a piece of rotting, damp wood with clearly rendered dark veins and shredded fibers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera framed from a slightly low angle in a static position?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004633167292922735 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379632949829102 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004633167292922735, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004633167292922735, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2493370622396469, + 0.09324241429567337, + 0.025950593873858452, + 0.09917002171278, + 0.09105387330055237, + 0.04666931927204132, + 0.23803314566612244, + 0.03424946963787079, + 0.05092298611998558, + 0.07137108594179153 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004633167292922735 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro close-up of a small, sleek black scorpion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scorpion's body tensed with pincers slightly open and its segmented tail arched high over its back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a larger beetle larva visible directly beneath the scorpion, wriggling in a soft, milky-white C-shaped body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a piece of rotting, damp wood with clearly rendered dark veins and shredded fibers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera framed from a slightly low angle in a static position?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007624099031090736 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.88262414932251 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007624099031090736, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007624099031090736, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2120022475719452, + 0.09470797330141068, + 0.06094808503985405, + 0.08545541018247604, + 0.052531562745571136, + 0.05440489575266838, + 0.18393464386463165, + 0.08207070827484131, + 0.07031257450580597, + 0.10363193601369858 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007624099031090736 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "surreal, static, extreme macro close-up, tightly framed from a slightly low angle, captures the raw moment of the confrontation with breathtaking clarity. A small, sleek black scorpion dominates the frame, its jet-black, carapace-like exoskeleton gleaming with a menacing sheen. Its body tenses, its pincers slightly open, poised, its distinctive, segmented tail arched high over its back in a characteristically menacing pose. At its tip, a sharp, yellow stinger gleams, poised to strike with deadly precision. Its target is a larger beetle larva, helplessly wriggling directly beneath it. The larva's soft, milky-white, C-shaped body, with its fleshy, translucent sections, twitches in slow, desperate waves. This dramatic encounter unfolds on a piece of rotting, damp wood, where the intricate texture of the dark veins and shredded fibers is clearly rendered. A soft, diffuse light, as if filtering through a forest canopy, meticulously captures the tiny, almost invisible hairs on the scorpion's legs and highlights the larva's damp, glistening surface, creating a scene of intense, suspended tension. The overall atmosphere is clean and calm, a raw and focused look at the predator-prey dynamic frozen in the moments before its violent end.", + "seed": 30781, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_7/index_2825_seed_30781_dp_15_rank_30_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.009386648377403616, + "vlm_logprob": -0.009386648377403616, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.875, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.009386648377403616, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro close-up of a small, sleek black scorpion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scorpion's body tensed with pincers slightly open and its segmented tail arched high over its back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a larger beetle larva visible directly beneath the scorpion, wriggling in a soft, milky-white C-shaped body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a piece of rotting, damp wood with clearly rendered dark veins and shredded fibers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera framed from a slightly low angle in a static position?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007000443059951067 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.00700044631958 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007000443059951067, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007000443059951067, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08078444749116898, + 0.048126526176929474, + 0.10373576730489731, + 0.10864965617656708, + 0.0661047026515007, + 0.046301569789648056, + 0.4307641386985779, + 0.022956950590014458, + 0.04168155416846275, + 0.050894733518362045 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007000443059951067 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro close-up of a small, sleek black scorpion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scorpion's body tensed with pincers slightly open and its segmented tail arched high over its back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a larger beetle larva visible directly beneath the scorpion, wriggling in a soft, milky-white C-shaped body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a piece of rotting, damp wood with clearly rendered dark veins and shredded fibers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera framed from a slightly low angle in a static position?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009786602109670639 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634786605834961 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009786602109670639, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009786602109670639, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08563505858182907, + 0.04030589014291763, + 0.03962210193276405, + 0.032394926995038986, + 0.0711965262889862, + 0.02914024330675602, + 0.4546385407447815, + 0.1296151578426361, + 0.07358130812644958, + 0.04387017711997032 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009786602109670639 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro close-up of a small, sleek black scorpion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scorpion's body tensed with pincers slightly open and its segmented tail arched high over its back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a larger beetle larva visible directly beneath the scorpion, wriggling in a soft, milky-white C-shaped body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a piece of rotting, damp wood with clearly rendered dark veins and shredded fibers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera framed from a slightly low angle in a static position?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00977869238704443 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.6347784996032715 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00977869238704443, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00977869238704443, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1478240191936493, + 0.06986238062381744, + 0.09244786202907562, + 0.030201690271496773, + 0.07561905682086945, + 0.05788329616189003, + 0.29570022225379944, + 0.04819255694746971, + 0.12839223444461823, + 0.05387672036886215 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00977869238704443 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro close-up of a small, sleek black scorpion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scorpion's body tensed with pincers slightly open and its segmented tail arched high over its back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a larger beetle larva visible directly beneath the scorpion, wriggling in a soft, milky-white C-shaped body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a piece of rotting, damp wood with clearly rendered dark veins and shredded fibers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera framed from a slightly low angle in a static position?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0021934278775006533 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127193450927734 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0021934278775006533, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0021934278775006533, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13934504985809326, + 0.039608485996723175, + 0.23929698765277863, + 0.04949714615941048, + 0.065098337829113, + 0.06227225065231323, + 0.20137280225753784, + 0.08859328925609589, + 0.08081623911857605, + 0.03409942239522934 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0021934278775006533 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro close-up of a small, sleek black scorpion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scorpion's body tensed with pincers slightly open and its segmented tail arched high over its back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a larger beetle larva visible directly beneath the scorpion, wriggling in a soft, milky-white C-shaped body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a piece of rotting, damp wood with clearly rendered dark veins and shredded fibers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera framed from a slightly low angle in a static position?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018174076452851295 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018174171447754 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018174076452851295, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018174076452851295, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03226377069950104, + 0.04267885535955429, + 0.07340146601200104, + 0.022089825943112373, + 0.17255152761936188, + 0.05403219908475876, + 0.3840788006782532, + 0.08580410480499268, + 0.11399584263563156, + 0.019103551283478737 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 4, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018174076452851295 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_8/index_tensor([3933, 3933])_group_8_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_8/index_tensor([3933, 3933])_group_8_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..b7c6f7a2009d796c2928f25e77f1605c443615fa --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_8/index_tensor([3933, 3933])_group_8_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "At night, a dramatic low-angle shot pans slowly sideways across an abandoned outdoor basketball court, focusing on a lone athlete in the center of the frame. The athlete is a highly focused figure, with short, sweat-soaked hair and dressed in a simple, dark, sleeveless sweatshirt and matching shorts that cling slightly to their muscular frame. They maintain a low, dribbling stance, dribbling the ball rhythmically with steady, powerful hands. Every impact of the orange ball on the worn, painted concrete is deliberate and controlled. The towering, bright stadium floodlights pierce the inky night sky, casting an intense, high-contrast glow that sculpts the athletes' forms and captures the sheen of sweat on their skin. This intense, direct light casts distinctly elongated and crisp shadows of the players and the bouncing ball, a dark twin that stretches far across the empty court. The surrounding stands are engulfed in a vast, silent darkness, amplifying the profound sense of solitude and creating a stark, focused atmosphere of pure, meditative devotion.", + "seed": 7574, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_8/index_3933_seed_7574_dp_16_rank_32_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.03326348420232535, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03326348420232535, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.8, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03326348420232535, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at night on an abandoned outdoor basketball court?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a slow sideways pan from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete wearing a dark sleeveless sweatshirt and matching shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete dribbling an orange ball with steady, powerful hands?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do bright stadium floodlights cast intense, elongated shadows across the court?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04083603248000145 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2908360958099365 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04083603248000145, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04083603248000145, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16213905811309814, + 0.05887787416577339, + 0.15143121778964996, + 0.0534837581217289, + 0.032194025814533234, + 0.05451948195695877, + 0.06409768760204315, + 0.0811881572008133, + 0.28723376989364624, + 0.054835014045238495 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04083603248000145 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at night on an abandoned outdoor basketball court?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a slow sideways pan from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete wearing a dark sleeveless sweatshirt and matching shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete dribbling an orange ball with steady, powerful hands?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do bright stadium floodlights cast intense, elongated shadows across the court?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07897292077541351 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.578972816467285 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07897292077541351, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07897292077541351, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13338761031627655, + 0.09385862946510315, + 0.1939716339111328, + 0.11204618960618973, + 0.09459496289491653, + 0.059719398617744446, + 0.0633658766746521, + 0.06614049524068832, + 0.0970553532242775, + 0.08585990965366364 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07897292077541351 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at night on an abandoned outdoor basketball court?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a slow sideways pan from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete wearing a dark sleeveless sweatshirt and matching shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete dribbling an orange ball with steady, powerful hands?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do bright stadium floodlights cast intense, elongated shadows across the court?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026347704231739044 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513476371765137 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026347704231739044, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026347704231739044, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2022850066423416, + 0.12547752261161804, + 0.14058761298656464, + 0.05760179087519646, + 0.08409599214792252, + 0.08441279083490372, + 0.10763709992170334, + 0.021925311535596848, + 0.11756356805562973, + 0.05841328576207161 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026347704231739044 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at night on an abandoned outdoor basketball court?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a slow sideways pan from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete wearing a dark sleeveless sweatshirt and matching shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete dribbling an orange ball with steady, powerful hands?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do bright stadium floodlights cast intense, elongated shadows across the court?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016069892793893814 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.1410698890686035 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016069892793893814, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016069892793893814, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1594291776418686, + 0.08774644136428833, + 0.10220909863710403, + 0.17560191452503204, + 0.06418122351169586, + 0.09201222658157349, + 0.072562575340271, + 0.05708829313516617, + 0.11831226944923401, + 0.07085681706666946 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016069892793893814 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at night on an abandoned outdoor basketball court?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a slow sideways pan from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete wearing a dark sleeveless sweatshirt and matching shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete dribbling an orange ball with steady, powerful hands?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do bright stadium floodlights cast intense, elongated shadows across the court?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004090870730578899 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504090785980225 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004090870730578899, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004090870730578899, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16708411276340485, + 0.044674042612314224, + 0.11437856405973434, + 0.05659370869398117, + 0.11458364874124527, + 0.046837396919727325, + 0.05715782940387726, + 0.05338550731539726, + 0.1298336386680603, + 0.2154715359210968 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004090870730578899 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "At night, a dramatic low-angle shot pans slowly sideways across an abandoned outdoor basketball court, focusing on a lone athlete in the center of the frame. The athlete is a highly focused figure, with short, sweat-soaked hair and dressed in a simple, dark, sleeveless sweatshirt and matching shorts that cling slightly to their muscular frame. They maintain a low, dribbling stance, dribbling the ball rhythmically with steady, powerful hands. Every impact of the orange ball on the worn, painted concrete is deliberate and controlled. The towering, bright stadium floodlights pierce the inky night sky, casting an intense, high-contrast glow that sculpts the athletes' forms and captures the sheen of sweat on their skin. This intense, direct light casts distinctly elongated and crisp shadows of the players and the bouncing ball, a dark twin that stretches far across the empty court. The surrounding stands are engulfed in a vast, silent darkness, amplifying the profound sense of solitude and creating a stark, focused atmosphere of pure, meditative devotion.", + "seed": 7575, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_8/index_3933_seed_7575_dp_16_rank_32_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.03880036789923906, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03880036789923906, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.5, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03880036789923906, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at night on an abandoned outdoor basketball court?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a slow sideways pan from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete wearing a dark sleeveless sweatshirt and matching shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete dribbling an orange ball with steady, powerful hands?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do bright stadium floodlights cast intense, elongated shadows across the court?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05010543763637543 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.050105333328247 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05010543763637543, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05010543763637543, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1633184850215912, + 0.23297953605651855, + 0.08265649527311325, + 0.15135475993156433, + 0.06850437074899673, + 0.025641320273280144, + 0.04032967984676361, + 0.03895355015993118, + 0.10622060298919678, + 0.09004122018814087 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05010543763637543 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at night on an abandoned outdoor basketball court?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a slow sideways pan from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete wearing a dark sleeveless sweatshirt and matching shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete dribbling an orange ball with steady, powerful hands?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do bright stadium floodlights cast intense, elongated shadows across the court?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07897578179836273 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5789756774902344 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07897578179836273, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07897578179836273, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1715182363986969, + 0.1870042234659195, + 0.03966016694903374, + 0.09572704881429672, + 0.14148776233196259, + 0.07018666714429855, + 0.09706399589776993, + 0.07394680380821228, + 0.07076302915811539, + 0.05264199152588844 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07897578179836273 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at night on an abandoned outdoor basketball court?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a slow sideways pan from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete wearing a dark sleeveless sweatshirt and matching shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete dribbling an orange ball with steady, powerful hands?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do bright stadium floodlights cast intense, elongated shadows across the court?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.038096725940704346 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2880966663360596 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.038096725940704346, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.038096725940704346, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13382014632225037, + 0.1913081407546997, + 0.05450375750660896, + 0.12972897291183472, + 0.08137467503547668, + 0.08127329498529434, + 0.06708822399377823, + 0.10612049698829651, + 0.055990979075431824, + 0.09879136085510254 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.038096725940704346 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at night on an abandoned outdoor basketball court?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a slow sideways pan from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete wearing a dark sleeveless sweatshirt and matching shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete dribbling an orange ball with steady, powerful hands?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do bright stadium floodlights cast intense, elongated shadows across the court?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018190698698163033 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018190860748291 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018190698698163033, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018190698698163033, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1689143031835556, + 0.15838861465454102, + 0.06302928924560547, + 0.09109713137149811, + 0.07416310161352158, + 0.06881687790155411, + 0.0491233728826046, + 0.12836900353431702, + 0.12056609243154526, + 0.07753225415945053 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018190698698163033 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at night on an abandoned outdoor basketball court?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a slow sideways pan from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete wearing a dark sleeveless sweatshirt and matching shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete dribbling an orange ball with steady, powerful hands?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do bright stadium floodlights cast intense, elongated shadows across the court?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008633195422589779 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758633136749268 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008633195422589779, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008633195422589779, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11694920063018799, + 0.04890123009681702, + 0.047251325100660324, + 0.1799243986606598, + 0.34524866938591003, + 0.0709887146949768, + 0.04479055106639862, + 0.037598367780447006, + 0.06763149052858353, + 0.04071604460477829 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008633195422589779 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "At night, a dramatic low-angle shot pans slowly sideways across an abandoned outdoor basketball court, focusing on a lone athlete in the center of the frame. The athlete is a highly focused figure, with short, sweat-soaked hair and dressed in a simple, dark, sleeveless sweatshirt and matching shorts that cling slightly to their muscular frame. They maintain a low, dribbling stance, dribbling the ball rhythmically with steady, powerful hands. Every impact of the orange ball on the worn, painted concrete is deliberate and controlled. The towering, bright stadium floodlights pierce the inky night sky, casting an intense, high-contrast glow that sculpts the athletes' forms and captures the sheen of sweat on their skin. This intense, direct light casts distinctly elongated and crisp shadows of the players and the bouncing ball, a dark twin that stretches far across the empty court. The surrounding stands are engulfed in a vast, silent darkness, amplifying the profound sense of solitude and creating a stark, focused atmosphere of pure, meditative devotion.", + "seed": 7576, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_8/index_3933_seed_7576_dp_17_rank_34_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.08608911484479904, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08608911484479904, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.674999976158142, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08608911484479904, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at night on an abandoned outdoor basketball court?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a slow sideways pan from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete wearing a dark sleeveless sweatshirt and matching shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete dribbling an orange ball with steady, powerful hands?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do bright stadium floodlights cast intense, elongated shadows across the court?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.15160712599754333 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.026607036590576 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.15160712599754333, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.8749998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -0.15160712599754333, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12845991551876068, + 0.025726983323693275, + 0.0841478556394577, + 0.4263513684272766, + 0.05748241767287254, + 0.11227409541606903, + 0.06460528075695038, + 0.030538486316800117, + 0.014517358504235744, + 0.05589619651436806 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.15160712599754333 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at night on an abandoned outdoor basketball court?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a slow sideways pan from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete wearing a dark sleeveless sweatshirt and matching shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete dribbling an orange ball with steady, powerful hands?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do bright stadium floodlights cast intense, elongated shadows across the court?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16035906970500946 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9103590250015259 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16035906970500946, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16035906970500946, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.208941251039505, + 0.12467030435800552, + 0.08359673619270325, + 0.21682631969451904, + 0.07803734391927719, + 0.05667799711227417, + 0.06569870561361313, + 0.05632232874631882, + 0.07607603073120117, + 0.03315297141671181 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16035906970500946 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at night on an abandoned outdoor basketball court?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a slow sideways pan from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete wearing a dark sleeveless sweatshirt and matching shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete dribbling an orange ball with steady, powerful hands?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do bright stadium floodlights cast intense, elongated shadows across the court?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.033708129078149796 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408708095550537 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.033708129078149796, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.033708129078149796, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20333217084407806, + 0.14397189021110535, + 0.07980482280254364, + 0.08006972074508667, + 0.05666371062397957, + 0.07617233693599701, + 0.05534655600786209, + 0.07787022739648819, + 0.05085510388016701, + 0.1759134978055954 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.033708129078149796 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at night on an abandoned outdoor basketball court?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a slow sideways pan from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete wearing a dark sleeveless sweatshirt and matching shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete dribbling an orange ball with steady, powerful hands?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do bright stadium floodlights cast intense, elongated shadows across the court?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05497697740793228 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299769401550293 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05497697740793228, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05497697740793228, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.369059294462204, + 0.06759953498840332, + 0.06516358256340027, + 0.04909983277320862, + 0.03307824581861496, + 0.11390571296215057, + 0.13835281133651733, + 0.047880250960588455, + 0.014491373673081398, + 0.10136940330266953 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05497697740793228 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at night on an abandoned outdoor basketball court?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a slow sideways pan from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete wearing a dark sleeveless sweatshirt and matching shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete dribbling an orange ball with steady, powerful hands?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do bright stadium floodlights cast intense, elongated shadows across the court?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029794272035360336 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529794216156006 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029794272035360336, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029794272035360336, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2991631329059601, + 0.0273368451744318, + 0.05004987493157387, + 0.10179541260004044, + 0.052106648683547974, + 0.1444980353116989, + 0.031129198148846626, + 0.049086377024650574, + 0.034571729600429535, + 0.2102627009153366 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029794272035360336 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "At night, a dramatic low-angle shot pans slowly sideways across an abandoned outdoor basketball court, focusing on a lone athlete in the center of the frame. The athlete is a highly focused figure, with short, sweat-soaked hair and dressed in a simple, dark, sleeveless sweatshirt and matching shorts that cling slightly to their muscular frame. They maintain a low, dribbling stance, dribbling the ball rhythmically with steady, powerful hands. Every impact of the orange ball on the worn, painted concrete is deliberate and controlled. The towering, bright stadium floodlights pierce the inky night sky, casting an intense, high-contrast glow that sculpts the athletes' forms and captures the sheen of sweat on their skin. This intense, direct light casts distinctly elongated and crisp shadows of the players and the bouncing ball, a dark twin that stretches far across the empty court. The surrounding stands are engulfed in a vast, silent darkness, amplifying the profound sense of solitude and creating a stark, focused atmosphere of pure, meditative devotion.", + "seed": 7577, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_8/index_3933_seed_7577_dp_17_rank_34_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.04079890735447407, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04079890735447407, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.674999952316284, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04079890735447407, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at night on an abandoned outdoor basketball court?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a slow sideways pan from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete wearing a dark sleeveless sweatshirt and matching shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete dribbling an orange ball with steady, powerful hands?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do bright stadium floodlights cast intense, elongated shadows across the court?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.025188609957695007 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.775188684463501 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.025188609957695007, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.025188609957695007, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3376738429069519, + 0.041868340224027634, + 0.09745515882968903, + 0.03151600807905197, + 0.04137290269136429, + 0.24494503438472748, + 0.05002094432711601, + 0.02215312235057354, + 0.057957831770181656, + 0.07503684610128403 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.025188609957695007 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at night on an abandoned outdoor basketball court?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a slow sideways pan from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete wearing a dark sleeveless sweatshirt and matching shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete dribbling an orange ball with steady, powerful hands?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do bright stadium floodlights cast intense, elongated shadows across the court?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11291967332363129 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.237919569015503 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11291967332363129, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11291967332363129, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17410346865653992, + 0.13428814709186554, + 0.07493113726377487, + 0.0515008345246315, + 0.18085353076457977, + 0.09517233818769455, + 0.11301502585411072, + 0.1199263483285904, + 0.01936630718410015, + 0.036842815577983856 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11291967332363129 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at night on an abandoned outdoor basketball court?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a slow sideways pan from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete wearing a dark sleeveless sweatshirt and matching shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete dribbling an orange ball with steady, powerful hands?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do bright stadium floodlights cast intense, elongated shadows across the court?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.043061573058366776 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680614948272705 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.043061573058366776, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.043061573058366776, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2033732533454895, + 0.05710870027542114, + 0.07557591795921326, + 0.04097378998994827, + 0.26408424973487854, + 0.1359531283378601, + 0.07043788582086563, + 0.05006542429327965, + 0.0363171212375164, + 0.0661105364561081 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.043061573058366776 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at night on an abandoned outdoor basketball court?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a slow sideways pan from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete wearing a dark sleeveless sweatshirt and matching shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete dribbling an orange ball with steady, powerful hands?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do bright stadium floodlights cast intense, elongated shadows across the court?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0181919876486063 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018191814422607 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0181919876486063, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0181919876486063, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.29808947443962097, + 0.061393968760967255, + 0.0638149157166481, + 0.048036035150289536, + 0.1260698437690735, + 0.17115464806556702, + 0.04670058935880661, + 0.0401281975209713, + 0.03888790309429169, + 0.10572446882724762 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0181919876486063 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at night on an abandoned outdoor basketball court?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a slow sideways pan from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete wearing a dark sleeveless sweatshirt and matching shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete dribbling an orange ball with steady, powerful hands?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do bright stadium floodlights cast intense, elongated shadows across the court?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004632692784070969 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379632472991943 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004632692784070969, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004632692784070969, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15976037085056305, + 0.2133813053369522, + 0.07072877883911133, + 0.03791143372654915, + 0.07594531029462814, + 0.1264939308166504, + 0.08372189849615097, + 0.06811357289552689, + 0.09709395468235016, + 0.06684938073158264 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004632692784070969 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_9/index_tensor([6940, 6940])_group_9_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_9/index_tensor([6940, 6940])_group_9_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..b3dc3eb78f2d7fbb28dda4d8fb6a74b36d4ed2f8 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_9/index_tensor([6940, 6940])_group_9_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "static, low-angle, wide-angle shot captures a dramatic confrontation across the vast, dusty expanse of the Australian outback. Two male red kangaroos engage in a ritual boxing match, their powerful bodies rendered in stark, dark silhouettes. They rear up on their massive hind legs, balancing on their thick, muscular tails against the arid, red-brown earth. The setting sun, low below the horizon, ignites the sky into a breathtaking canvas of fiery red, deep scarlet, and faded violet. This intense backlighting perfectly delineates their forms, capturing the edges of their fur with a subtle, luminous rim light. As they struggle and strike each other—jabbing with their front paws and delivering powerful, deliberate kicks—wisps of fine red dust are kicked up from the dry ground, swirling around their feet and catching the surrounding light, creating a glowing, ethereal mist. The entire scene is imbued with a primal, breathtaking atmosphere, contrasting the raw, untamed energy of the battle with the serene, majestic beauty of the sunset.", + "seed": 3146, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_9/index_6940_seed_3146_dp_18_rank_36_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.04106981577351689, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04106981577351689, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.725, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04106981577351689, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two male red kangaroos visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the kangaroos rearing up on their hind legs and balancing on their tails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the kangaroos engaged in a boxing match involving jabs with front paws and kicks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment the Australian outback with red-brown earth and wisps of red dust swirling around the kangaroos' feet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky colored with fiery red, deep scarlet, and faded violet due to a low setting sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07171660661697388 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.696716547012329 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07171660661697388, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07171660661697388, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13117048144340515, + 0.08514129370450974, + 0.03758923336863518, + 0.03211667016148567, + 0.23947957158088684, + 0.1377412974834442, + 0.03230944275856018, + 0.22138041257858276, + 0.06361111253499985, + 0.019460415467619896 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 7, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07171660661697388 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two male red kangaroos visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the kangaroos rearing up on their hind legs and balancing on their tails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the kangaroos engaged in a boxing match involving jabs with front paws and kicks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment the Australian outback with red-brown earth and wisps of red dust swirling around the kangaroos' feet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky colored with fiery red, deep scarlet, and faded violet due to a low setting sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026357805356383324 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651357889175415 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026357805356383324, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026357805356383324, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10848832130432129, + 0.15318886935710907, + 0.06807442009449005, + 0.0645178034901619, + 0.15557914972305298, + 0.1748070865869522, + 0.10094333440065384, + 0.10774128884077072, + 0.038172975182533264, + 0.02848677523434162 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026357805356383324 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two male red kangaroos visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the kangaroos rearing up on their hind legs and balancing on their tails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the kangaroos engaged in a boxing match involving jabs with front paws and kicks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment the Australian outback with red-brown earth and wisps of red dust swirling around the kangaroos' feet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky colored with fiery red, deep scarlet, and faded violet due to a low setting sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026346080005168915 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.65134596824646 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026346080005168915, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026346080005168915, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09971007704734802, + 0.09005764126777649, + 0.11350955069065094, + 0.05561836436390877, + 0.2550284266471863, + 0.15335504710674286, + 0.04439951106905937, + 0.1162109449505806, + 0.04384959489107132, + 0.028260892257094383 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026346080005168915 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two male red kangaroos visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the kangaroos rearing up on their hind legs and balancing on their tails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the kangaroos engaged in a boxing match involving jabs with front paws and kicks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment the Australian outback with red-brown earth and wisps of red dust swirling around the kangaroos' feet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky colored with fiery red, deep scarlet, and faded violet due to a low setting sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07899164408445358 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.578991651535034 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07899164408445358, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07899164408445358, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2682037949562073, + 0.15216226875782013, + 0.03725001588463783, + 0.05124736949801445, + 0.22408238053321838, + 0.10830351710319519, + 0.01819440722465515, + 0.049786195158958435, + 0.0559026300907135, + 0.03486743941903114 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07899164408445358 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two male red kangaroos visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the kangaroos rearing up on their hind legs and balancing on their tails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the kangaroos engaged in a boxing match involving jabs with front paws and kicks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment the Australian outback with red-brown earth and wisps of red dust swirling around the kangaroos' feet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky colored with fiery red, deep scarlet, and faded violet due to a low setting sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0019369428046047688 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.251936912536621 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0019369428046047688, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0019369428046047688, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19503825902938843, + 0.05809194594621658, + 0.028089627623558044, + 0.031735822558403015, + 0.26373228430747986, + 0.12941427528858185, + 0.0516737699508667, + 0.10618793964385986, + 0.10041534155607224, + 0.03562074899673462 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0019369428046047688 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, low-angle, wide-angle shot captures a dramatic confrontation across the vast, dusty expanse of the Australian outback. Two male red kangaroos engage in a ritual boxing match, their powerful bodies rendered in stark, dark silhouettes. They rear up on their massive hind legs, balancing on their thick, muscular tails against the arid, red-brown earth. The setting sun, low below the horizon, ignites the sky into a breathtaking canvas of fiery red, deep scarlet, and faded violet. This intense backlighting perfectly delineates their forms, capturing the edges of their fur with a subtle, luminous rim light. As they struggle and strike each other—jabbing with their front paws and delivering powerful, deliberate kicks—wisps of fine red dust are kicked up from the dry ground, swirling around their feet and catching the surrounding light, creating a glowing, ethereal mist. The entire scene is imbued with a primal, breathtaking atmosphere, contrasting the raw, untamed energy of the battle with the serene, majestic beauty of the sunset.", + "seed": 3147, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_9/index_6940_seed_3147_dp_18_rank_36_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.0320074948715046, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0320074948715046, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.125, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0320074948715046, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two male red kangaroos visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the kangaroos rearing up on their hind legs and balancing on their tails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the kangaroos engaged in a boxing match involving jabs with front paws and kicks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment the Australian outback with red-brown earth and wisps of red dust swirling around the kangaroos' feet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky colored with fiery red, deep scarlet, and faded violet due to a low setting sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.055752284824848175 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9307522773742676 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.055752284824848175, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.055752284824848175, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23346100747585297, + 0.2094118446111679, + 0.0722210481762886, + 0.060594506561756134, + 0.1176312118768692, + 0.09449896961450577, + 0.03637884184718132, + 0.03490334004163742, + 0.03188356012105942, + 0.10901567339897156 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.055752284824848175 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two male red kangaroos visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the kangaroos rearing up on their hind legs and balancing on their tails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the kangaroos engaged in a boxing match involving jabs with front paws and kicks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment the Australian outback with red-brown earth and wisps of red dust swirling around the kangaroos' feet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky colored with fiery red, deep scarlet, and faded violet due to a low setting sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023290403187274933 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732903957366943 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023290403187274933, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023290403187274933, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1722373068332672, + 0.20270785689353943, + 0.1964271068572998, + 0.053184665739536285, + 0.06791814416646957, + 0.06888509541749954, + 0.05471022054553032, + 0.07002586126327515, + 0.05784555524587631, + 0.056058187037706375 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023290403187274933 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two male red kangaroos visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the kangaroos rearing up on their hind legs and balancing on their tails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the kangaroos engaged in a boxing match involving jabs with front paws and kicks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment the Australian outback with red-brown earth and wisps of red dust swirling around the kangaroos' feet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky colored with fiery red, deep scarlet, and faded violet due to a low setting sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009787309914827347 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634787082672119 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009787309914827347, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009787309914827347, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18417978286743164, + 0.136457160115242, + 0.12486819177865982, + 0.035068437457084656, + 0.07692612707614899, + 0.1809675544500351, + 0.04760655388236046, + 0.035373423248529434, + 0.0616140179336071, + 0.11693872511386871 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009787309914827347 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two male red kangaroos visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the kangaroos rearing up on their hind legs and balancing on their tails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the kangaroos engaged in a boxing match involving jabs with front paws and kicks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment the Australian outback with red-brown earth and wisps of red dust swirling around the kangaroos' feet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky colored with fiery red, deep scarlet, and faded violet due to a low setting sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07002859562635422 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.69502854347229 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07002859562635422, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07002859562635422, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17213024199008942, + 0.30637863278388977, + 0.27796533703804016, + 0.02754873037338257, + 0.027252066880464554, + 0.04718225821852684, + 0.027479758486151695, + 0.02359633892774582, + 0.023843897506594658, + 0.06662262976169586 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07002859562635422 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two male red kangaroos visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the kangaroos rearing up on their hind legs and balancing on their tails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the kangaroos engaged in a boxing match involving jabs with front paws and kicks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment the Australian outback with red-brown earth and wisps of red dust swirling around the kangaroos' feet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky colored with fiery red, deep scarlet, and faded violet due to a low setting sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0011788808042183518 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.751178741455078 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0011788808042183518, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0011788808042183518, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21640215814113617, + 0.08192265033721924, + 0.1682688295841217, + 0.058063022792339325, + 0.06744384765625, + 0.07933071255683899, + 0.030983086675405502, + 0.027899039909243584, + 0.12739375233650208, + 0.14229288697242737 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0011788808042183518 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, low-angle, wide-angle shot captures a dramatic confrontation across the vast, dusty expanse of the Australian outback. Two male red kangaroos engage in a ritual boxing match, their powerful bodies rendered in stark, dark silhouettes. They rear up on their massive hind legs, balancing on their thick, muscular tails against the arid, red-brown earth. The setting sun, low below the horizon, ignites the sky into a breathtaking canvas of fiery red, deep scarlet, and faded violet. This intense backlighting perfectly delineates their forms, capturing the edges of their fur with a subtle, luminous rim light. As they struggle and strike each other—jabbing with their front paws and delivering powerful, deliberate kicks—wisps of fine red dust are kicked up from the dry ground, swirling around their feet and catching the surrounding light, creating a glowing, ethereal mist. The entire scene is imbued with a primal, breathtaking atmosphere, contrasting the raw, untamed energy of the battle with the serene, majestic beauty of the sunset.", + "seed": 3148, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_9/index_6940_seed_3148_dp_19_rank_38_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.02441218162421137, + "vlm_logprob": -0.02441218162421137, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.1, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.02441218162421137, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two male red kangaroos visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the kangaroos rearing up on their hind legs and balancing on their tails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the kangaroos engaged in a boxing match involving jabs with front paws and kicks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment the Australian outback with red-brown earth and wisps of red dust swirling around the kangaroos' feet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky colored with fiery red, deep scarlet, and faded violet due to a low setting sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04362788423895836 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168627977371216 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04362788423895836, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04362788423895836, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19494444131851196, + 0.1538795679807663, + 0.0646570473909378, + 0.05553867667913437, + 0.13667342066764832, + 0.06658783555030823, + 0.06105564534664154, + 0.04733114317059517, + 0.11592996120452881, + 0.10340218991041183 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04362788423895836 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two male red kangaroos visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the kangaroos rearing up on their hind legs and balancing on their tails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the kangaroos engaged in a boxing match involving jabs with front paws and kicks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment the Australian outback with red-brown earth and wisps of red dust swirling around the kangaroos' feet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky colored with fiery red, deep scarlet, and faded violet due to a low setting sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029800519347190857 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298004150390625 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029800519347190857, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029800519347190857, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12813793122768402, + 0.12479455769062042, + 0.12099681794643402, + 0.17164602875709534, + 0.0739632174372673, + 0.04264858737587929, + 0.058501649647951126, + 0.09288933128118515, + 0.07617730647325516, + 0.11024455726146698 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029800519347190857 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two male red kangaroos visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the kangaroos rearing up on their hind legs and balancing on their tails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the kangaroos engaged in a boxing match involving jabs with front paws and kicks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment the Australian outback with red-brown earth and wisps of red dust swirling around the kangaroos' feet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky colored with fiery red, deep scarlet, and faded violet due to a low setting sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020582307130098343 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955821990966797 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020582307130098343, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020582307130098343, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1436794400215149, + 0.14754408597946167, + 0.06792077422142029, + 0.0816376581788063, + 0.08387976884841919, + 0.03894297778606415, + 0.03268112614750862, + 0.12119635194540024, + 0.13177362084388733, + 0.15074415504932404 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020582307130098343 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two male red kangaroos visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the kangaroos rearing up on their hind legs and balancing on their tails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the kangaroos engaged in a boxing match involving jabs with front paws and kicks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment the Australian outback with red-brown earth and wisps of red dust swirling around the kangaroos' feet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky colored with fiery red, deep scarlet, and faded violet due to a low setting sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02633957751095295 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651339530944824 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02633957751095295, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02633957751095295, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18875370919704437, + 0.1872415840625763, + 0.04134524613618851, + 0.03308645263314247, + 0.057864464819431305, + 0.0658702626824379, + 0.03959374874830246, + 0.031603120267391205, + 0.06807311624288559, + 0.286568284034729 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02633957751095295 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two male red kangaroos visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the kangaroos rearing up on their hind legs and balancing on their tails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the kangaroos engaged in a boxing match involving jabs with front paws and kicks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment the Australian outback with red-brown earth and wisps of red dust swirling around the kangaroos' feet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky colored with fiery red, deep scarlet, and faded violet due to a low setting sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0017106198938563466 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.376710414886475 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0017106198938563466, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0017106198938563466, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2748677432537079, + 0.15974611043930054, + 0.053863197565078735, + 0.07062894850969315, + 0.05936645343899727, + 0.06090827286243439, + 0.062406670302152634, + 0.09685160964727402, + 0.09346035122871399, + 0.0679006427526474 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0017106198938563466 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, low-angle, wide-angle shot captures a dramatic confrontation across the vast, dusty expanse of the Australian outback. Two male red kangaroos engage in a ritual boxing match, their powerful bodies rendered in stark, dark silhouettes. They rear up on their massive hind legs, balancing on their thick, muscular tails against the arid, red-brown earth. The setting sun, low below the horizon, ignites the sky into a breathtaking canvas of fiery red, deep scarlet, and faded violet. This intense backlighting perfectly delineates their forms, capturing the edges of their fur with a subtle, luminous rim light. As they struggle and strike each other—jabbing with their front paws and delivering powerful, deliberate kicks—wisps of fine red dust are kicked up from the dry ground, swirling around their feet and catching the surrounding light, creating a glowing, ethereal mist. The entire scene is imbued with a primal, breathtaking atmosphere, contrasting the raw, untamed energy of the battle with the serene, majestic beauty of the sunset.", + "seed": 3149, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000018/group_9/index_6940_seed_3149_dp_19_rank_38_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.07773285617586226, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07773285617586226, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.425, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07773285617586226, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two male red kangaroos visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the kangaroos rearing up on their hind legs and balancing on their tails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the kangaroos engaged in a boxing match involving jabs with front paws and kicks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment the Australian outback with red-brown earth and wisps of red dust swirling around the kangaroos' feet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky colored with fiery red, deep scarlet, and faded violet due to a low setting sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10193585604429245 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.351935863494873 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10193585604429245, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10193585604429245, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2969805598258972, + 0.06315366923809052, + 0.0708429291844368, + 0.06750872731208801, + 0.04694963991641998, + 0.03896471858024597, + 0.05868895351886749, + 0.056884534657001495, + 0.048126112669706345, + 0.2519001364707947 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10193585604429245 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two male red kangaroos visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the kangaroos rearing up on their hind legs and balancing on their tails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the kangaroos engaged in a boxing match involving jabs with front paws and kicks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment the Australian outback with red-brown earth and wisps of red dust swirling around the kangaroos' feet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky colored with fiery red, deep scarlet, and faded violet due to a low setting sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02981220744550228 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298120975494385 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02981220744550228, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02981220744550228, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23840448260307312, + 0.09953505545854568, + 0.08874653279781342, + 0.05567003786563873, + 0.04153498634696007, + 0.03361910209059715, + 0.02951696142554283, + 0.06909719854593277, + 0.05393501743674278, + 0.28994062542915344 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02981220744550228 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two male red kangaroos visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the kangaroos rearing up on their hind legs and balancing on their tails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the kangaroos engaged in a boxing match involving jabs with front paws and kicks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment the Australian outback with red-brown earth and wisps of red dust swirling around the kangaroos' feet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky colored with fiery red, deep scarlet, and faded violet due to a low setting sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02980387583374977 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529803991317749 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02980387583374977, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02980387583374977, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.32402893900871277, + 0.09478165209293365, + 0.05476142093539238, + 0.12478525191545486, + 0.03866272419691086, + 0.02078913524746895, + 0.03188740834593773, + 0.031009409576654434, + 0.04683097451925278, + 0.2324630469083786 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02980387583374977 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two male red kangaroos visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the kangaroos rearing up on their hind legs and balancing on their tails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the kangaroos engaged in a boxing match involving jabs with front paws and kicks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment the Australian outback with red-brown earth and wisps of red dust swirling around the kangaroos' feet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky colored with fiery red, deep scarlet, and faded violet due to a low setting sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2256002426147461 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.600600242614746 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2256002426147461, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2256002426147461, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24811674654483795, + 0.07073886692523956, + 0.08881071209907532, + 0.08707848191261292, + 0.08536287397146225, + 0.026559101417660713, + 0.02996925264596939, + 0.06888406723737717, + 0.07620176672935486, + 0.21827811002731323 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2256002426147461 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two male red kangaroos visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the kangaroos rearing up on their hind legs and balancing on their tails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the kangaroos engaged in a boxing match involving jabs with front paws and kicks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment the Australian outback with red-brown earth and wisps of red dust swirling around the kangaroos' feet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky colored with fiery red, deep scarlet, and faded violet due to a low setting sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0015120989410206676 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.501512050628662 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0015120989410206676, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0015120989410206676, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3344605565071106, + 0.11126241087913513, + 0.06688502430915833, + 0.0730588361620903, + 0.050534993410110474, + 0.029052894562482834, + 0.04960322752594948, + 0.06197619065642357, + 0.05922871083021164, + 0.16393716633319855 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0015120989410206676 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_0/index_tensor([5415, 5415])_group_0_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_0/index_tensor([5415, 5415])_group_0_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..f42527a7e63b7e98b7ee2ddc3113fa1ce9a1da30 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_0/index_tensor([5415, 5415])_group_0_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "In the vibrant style of Disney Pixar animation, a static, slightly low-angled, full-body shot captures a captivating and determined Indian cobra. Its upper body is supported by protective coils on the ground, its signature thorn-patterned hood fully open, revealing bold black markings that contrast starkly against its smooth, golden-brown animated scales, which have a soft, plasticine-like sheen. Its large, expressive dark brown eyes, wide with genuine concern, gaze forward, guarding a small clutch of glossy, off-white eggs nestled in a depression on the mossy jungle floor. It sways with a deliberate, rhythmic movement, a classic defensive dance humorously undercut by an oversized, comedic sweatdrop that meticulously rolls down its temples, catching a glint of light as it follows a path along its smooth scales. The scene is set in a colorful jungle clearing, bathed in sunlight, with warm golden shafts piercing a dense canopy of oversized, waxy green leaves. The backdrop is a soft-focus tapestry of lush foliage and vibrant tropical flowers in shades of fuchsia and sunny yellow, creating a warm, lovely atmosphere filled with easy tension and parental devotion.", + "seed": 11619, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_0/index_5415_seed_11619_dp_0_rank_0_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.07445965153165161, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07445965153165161, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.6, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07445965153165161, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an Indian cobra with a thorn-patterned hood fully open?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the cobra's body color smooth and golden-brown with a soft, plasticine-like sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cobra swaying with a deliberate, rhythmic movement while guarding a clutch of glossy, off-white eggs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there an oversized, comedic sweatdrop rolling down the cobra's temples along its scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a colorful jungle clearing with warm golden sunlight shafts and a background of fuchsia and sunny yellow flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0793437510728836 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.579343795776367 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0793437510728836, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0793437510728836, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18791384994983673, + 0.1414305716753006, + 0.30241692066192627, + 0.15000399947166443, + 0.030771004036068916, + 0.01665537618100643, + 0.02449742890894413, + 0.0663103386759758, + 0.05563035607337952, + 0.02437014691531658 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0793437510728836 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an Indian cobra with a thorn-patterned hood fully open?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the cobra's body color smooth and golden-brown with a soft, plasticine-like sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cobra swaying with a deliberate, rhythmic movement while guarding a clutch of glossy, off-white eggs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there an oversized, comedic sweatdrop rolling down the cobra's temples along its scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a colorful jungle clearing with warm golden sunlight shafts and a background of fuchsia and sunny yellow flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012551363557577133 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387551307678223 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012551363557577133, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012551363557577133, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3915869891643524, + 0.10364466905593872, + 0.06415686011314392, + 0.061972033232450485, + 0.22110354900360107, + 0.023791488260030746, + 0.051412273198366165, + 0.018305789679288864, + 0.019132215529680252, + 0.04489412531256676 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012551363557577133 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an Indian cobra with a thorn-patterned hood fully open?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the cobra's body color smooth and golden-brown with a soft, plasticine-like sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cobra swaying with a deliberate, rhythmic movement while guarding a clutch of glossy, off-white eggs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there an oversized, comedic sweatdrop rolling down the cobra's temples along its scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a colorful jungle clearing with warm golden sunlight shafts and a background of fuchsia and sunny yellow flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.25210627913475037 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5021063089370728 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.25210627913475037, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.25210627913475037, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03764322027564049, + 0.04331324249505997, + 0.3933473229408264, + 0.04036705195903778, + 0.07065633684396744, + 0.04806635156273842, + 0.03907134756445885, + 0.22691066563129425, + 0.04294426366686821, + 0.057680241763591766 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 7, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.25210627913475037 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an Indian cobra with a thorn-patterned hood fully open?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the cobra's body color smooth and golden-brown with a soft, plasticine-like sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cobra swaying with a deliberate, rhythmic movement while guarding a clutch of glossy, off-white eggs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there an oversized, comedic sweatdrop rolling down the cobra's temples along its scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a colorful jungle clearing with warm golden sunlight shafts and a background of fuchsia and sunny yellow flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026358850300312042 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513588428497314 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026358850300312042, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026358850300312042, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12815672159194946, + 0.08174153417348862, + 0.3748091161251068, + 0.11110030859708786, + 0.16250137984752655, + 0.01538437232375145, + 0.017663178965449333, + 0.009786211885511875, + 0.035409729927778244, + 0.06344743818044662 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026358850300312042 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an Indian cobra with a thorn-patterned hood fully open?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the cobra's body color smooth and golden-brown with a soft, plasticine-like sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cobra swaying with a deliberate, rhythmic movement while guarding a clutch of glossy, off-white eggs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there an oversized, comedic sweatdrop rolling down the cobra's temples along its scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a colorful jungle clearing with warm golden sunlight shafts and a background of fuchsia and sunny yellow flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.001938013592734933 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.2519378662109375 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.001938013592734933, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.001938013592734933, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2543242275714874, + 0.12144719064235687, + 0.1809467375278473, + 0.04352610930800438, + 0.04110502079129219, + 0.03579377755522728, + 0.04536605253815651, + 0.03933708742260933, + 0.08204832673072815, + 0.15610548853874207 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.001938013592734933 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In the vibrant style of Disney Pixar animation, a static, slightly low-angled, full-body shot captures a captivating and determined Indian cobra. Its upper body is supported by protective coils on the ground, its signature thorn-patterned hood fully open, revealing bold black markings that contrast starkly against its smooth, golden-brown animated scales, which have a soft, plasticine-like sheen. Its large, expressive dark brown eyes, wide with genuine concern, gaze forward, guarding a small clutch of glossy, off-white eggs nestled in a depression on the mossy jungle floor. It sways with a deliberate, rhythmic movement, a classic defensive dance humorously undercut by an oversized, comedic sweatdrop that meticulously rolls down its temples, catching a glint of light as it follows a path along its smooth scales. The scene is set in a colorful jungle clearing, bathed in sunlight, with warm golden shafts piercing a dense canopy of oversized, waxy green leaves. The backdrop is a soft-focus tapestry of lush foliage and vibrant tropical flowers in shades of fuchsia and sunny yellow, creating a warm, lovely atmosphere filled with easy tension and parental devotion.", + "seed": 11620, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_0/index_5415_seed_11620_dp_0_rank_0_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.0980740150436759, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0980740150436759, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.175, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0980740150436759, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an Indian cobra with a thorn-patterned hood fully open?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the cobra's body color smooth and golden-brown with a soft, plasticine-like sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cobra swaying with a deliberate, rhythmic movement while guarding a clutch of glossy, off-white eggs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there an oversized, comedic sweatdrop rolling down the cobra's temples along its scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a colorful jungle clearing with warm golden sunlight shafts and a background of fuchsia and sunny yellow flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2817284166812897 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4067283868789673 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2817284166812897, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2817284166812897, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05975492671132088, + 0.2231340855360031, + 0.10130801796913147, + 0.039898619055747986, + 0.030925793573260307, + 0.07232311367988586, + 0.08061659336090088, + 0.04825185611844063, + 0.22684764862060547, + 0.11693933606147766 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2817284166812897 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an Indian cobra with a thorn-patterned hood fully open?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the cobra's body color smooth and golden-brown with a soft, plasticine-like sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cobra swaying with a deliberate, rhythmic movement while guarding a clutch of glossy, off-white eggs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there an oversized, comedic sweatdrop rolling down the cobra's temples along its scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a colorful jungle clearing with warm golden sunlight shafts and a background of fuchsia and sunny yellow flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012544417753815651 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387544631958008 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012544417753815651, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012544417753815651, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07444309443235397, + 0.09019558876752853, + 0.08766312897205353, + 0.018001049757003784, + 0.03561687469482422, + 0.059361230581998825, + 0.37787875533103943, + 0.06927745044231415, + 0.16409876942634583, + 0.023464078083634377 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012544417753815651 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an Indian cobra with a thorn-patterned hood fully open?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the cobra's body color smooth and golden-brown with a soft, plasticine-like sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cobra swaying with a deliberate, rhythmic movement while guarding a clutch of glossy, off-white eggs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there an oversized, comedic sweatdrop rolling down the cobra's temples along its scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a colorful jungle clearing with warm golden sunlight shafts and a background of fuchsia and sunny yellow flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1603475958108902 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.910347580909729 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1603475958108902, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1603475958108902, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07557687163352966, + 0.1260693371295929, + 0.0611434169113636, + 0.07267434149980545, + 0.045850932598114014, + 0.10712483525276184, + 0.41160789132118225, + 0.05805416777729988, + 0.02543448470532894, + 0.016463736072182655 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1603475958108902 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an Indian cobra with a thorn-patterned hood fully open?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the cobra's body color smooth and golden-brown with a soft, plasticine-like sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cobra swaying with a deliberate, rhythmic movement while guarding a clutch of glossy, off-white eggs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there an oversized, comedic sweatdrop rolling down the cobra's temples along its scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a colorful jungle clearing with warm golden sunlight shafts and a background of fuchsia and sunny yellow flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029807347804307938 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298073291778564 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029807347804307938, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029807347804307938, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1368812620639801, + 0.10314159840345383, + 0.07042311877012253, + 0.033046089112758636, + 0.07052672654390335, + 0.10493742674589157, + 0.28247007727622986, + 0.045398034155368805, + 0.08145194500684738, + 0.07172376662492752 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029807347804307938 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an Indian cobra with a thorn-patterned hood fully open?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the cobra's body color smooth and golden-brown with a soft, plasticine-like sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cobra swaying with a deliberate, rhythmic movement while guarding a clutch of glossy, off-white eggs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there an oversized, comedic sweatdrop rolling down the cobra's temples along its scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a colorful jungle clearing with warm golden sunlight shafts and a background of fuchsia and sunny yellow flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005942297168076038 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130942344665527 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005942297168076038, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005942297168076038, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08089537918567657, + 0.07218413800001144, + 0.18563514947891235, + 0.1469811052083969, + 0.07209724932909012, + 0.08519481867551804, + 0.17228947579860687, + 0.08526570349931717, + 0.07235732674598694, + 0.027099646627902985 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 6, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005942297168076038 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In the vibrant style of Disney Pixar animation, a static, slightly low-angled, full-body shot captures a captivating and determined Indian cobra. Its upper body is supported by protective coils on the ground, its signature thorn-patterned hood fully open, revealing bold black markings that contrast starkly against its smooth, golden-brown animated scales, which have a soft, plasticine-like sheen. Its large, expressive dark brown eyes, wide with genuine concern, gaze forward, guarding a small clutch of glossy, off-white eggs nestled in a depression on the mossy jungle floor. It sways with a deliberate, rhythmic movement, a classic defensive dance humorously undercut by an oversized, comedic sweatdrop that meticulously rolls down its temples, catching a glint of light as it follows a path along its smooth scales. The scene is set in a colorful jungle clearing, bathed in sunlight, with warm golden shafts piercing a dense canopy of oversized, waxy green leaves. The backdrop is a soft-focus tapestry of lush foliage and vibrant tropical flowers in shades of fuchsia and sunny yellow, creating a warm, lovely atmosphere filled with easy tension and parental devotion.", + "seed": 11621, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_0/index_5415_seed_11621_dp_1_rank_2_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.07128449929878115, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07128449929878115, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.7, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07128449929878115, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an Indian cobra with a thorn-patterned hood fully open?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the cobra's body color smooth and golden-brown with a soft, plasticine-like sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cobra swaying with a deliberate, rhythmic movement while guarding a clutch of glossy, off-white eggs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there an oversized, comedic sweatdrop rolling down the cobra's temples along its scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a colorful jungle clearing with warm golden sunlight shafts and a background of fuchsia and sunny yellow flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.25241929292678833 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5024192333221436 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.25241929292678833, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.25241929292678833, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16328968107700348, + 0.0536041222512722, + 0.06016002967953682, + 0.09926559031009674, + 0.052847299724817276, + 0.03526631370186806, + 0.09431298077106476, + 0.15725107491016388, + 0.0864243358373642, + 0.1975785791873932 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.25241929292678833 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an Indian cobra with a thorn-patterned hood fully open?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the cobra's body color smooth and golden-brown with a soft, plasticine-like sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cobra swaying with a deliberate, rhythmic movement while guarding a clutch of glossy, off-white eggs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there an oversized, comedic sweatdrop rolling down the cobra's temples along its scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a colorful jungle clearing with warm golden sunlight shafts and a background of fuchsia and sunny yellow flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006743293721228838 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006743431091309 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006743293721228838, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006743293721228838, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14256498217582703, + 0.08199310302734375, + 0.049656204879283905, + 0.08258000016212463, + 0.1822051703929901, + 0.037655044347047806, + 0.15064749121665955, + 0.09593041241168976, + 0.08997368067502975, + 0.08679389953613281 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006743293721228838 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an Indian cobra with a thorn-patterned hood fully open?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the cobra's body color smooth and golden-brown with a soft, plasticine-like sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cobra swaying with a deliberate, rhythmic movement while guarding a clutch of glossy, off-white eggs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there an oversized, comedic sweatdrop rolling down the cobra's temples along its scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a colorful jungle clearing with warm golden sunlight shafts and a background of fuchsia and sunny yellow flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07897104322910309 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5789711475372314 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07897104322910309, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07897104322910309, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13783633708953857, + 0.10565660148859024, + 0.052186984568834305, + 0.18559709191322327, + 0.12130742520093918, + 0.05726849287748337, + 0.05886765569448471, + 0.11075037717819214, + 0.0746241882443428, + 0.09590481221675873 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07897104322910309 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an Indian cobra with a thorn-patterned hood fully open?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the cobra's body color smooth and golden-brown with a soft, plasticine-like sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cobra swaying with a deliberate, rhythmic movement while guarding a clutch of glossy, off-white eggs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there an oversized, comedic sweatdrop rolling down the cobra's temples along its scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a colorful jungle clearing with warm golden sunlight shafts and a background of fuchsia and sunny yellow flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014198708347976208 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.2641987800598145 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014198708347976208, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014198708347976208, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17324091494083405, + 0.07382944226264954, + 0.06547823548316956, + 0.12804560363292694, + 0.06333992630243301, + 0.08816810697317123, + 0.0815052017569542, + 0.14299824833869934, + 0.11930783838033676, + 0.06408646702766418 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014198708347976208 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an Indian cobra with a thorn-patterned hood fully open?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the cobra's body color smooth and golden-brown with a soft, plasticine-like sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cobra swaying with a deliberate, rhythmic movement while guarding a clutch of glossy, off-white eggs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there an oversized, comedic sweatdrop rolling down the cobra's temples along its scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a colorful jungle clearing with warm golden sunlight shafts and a background of fuchsia and sunny yellow flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0040901582688093185 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504090309143066 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0040901582688093185, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0040901582688093185, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1502290666103363, + 0.07107378542423248, + 0.13331151008605957, + 0.0612998828291893, + 0.05207008495926857, + 0.23376740515232086, + 0.14989642798900604, + 0.040511615574359894, + 0.05128884315490723, + 0.05655130743980408 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0040901582688093185 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In the vibrant style of Disney Pixar animation, a static, slightly low-angled, full-body shot captures a captivating and determined Indian cobra. Its upper body is supported by protective coils on the ground, its signature thorn-patterned hood fully open, revealing bold black markings that contrast starkly against its smooth, golden-brown animated scales, which have a soft, plasticine-like sheen. Its large, expressive dark brown eyes, wide with genuine concern, gaze forward, guarding a small clutch of glossy, off-white eggs nestled in a depression on the mossy jungle floor. It sways with a deliberate, rhythmic movement, a classic defensive dance humorously undercut by an oversized, comedic sweatdrop that meticulously rolls down its temples, catching a glint of light as it follows a path along its smooth scales. The scene is set in a colorful jungle clearing, bathed in sunlight, with warm golden shafts piercing a dense canopy of oversized, waxy green leaves. The backdrop is a soft-focus tapestry of lush foliage and vibrant tropical flowers in shades of fuchsia and sunny yellow, creating a warm, lovely atmosphere filled with easy tension and parental devotion.", + "seed": 11622, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_0/index_5415_seed_11622_dp_1_rank_2_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.03342181565240025, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03342181565240025, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.925, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03342181565240025, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an Indian cobra with a thorn-patterned hood fully open?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the cobra's body color smooth and golden-brown with a soft, plasticine-like sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cobra swaying with a deliberate, rhythmic movement while guarding a clutch of glossy, off-white eggs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there an oversized, comedic sweatdrop rolling down the cobra's temples along its scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a colorful jungle clearing with warm golden sunlight shafts and a background of fuchsia and sunny yellow flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10074543207883835 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.350745439529419 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10074543207883835, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10074543207883835, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.031126050278544426, + 0.010833331383764744, + 0.010262974537909031, + 0.047401200979948044, + 0.09676388651132584, + 0.49998971819877625, + 0.18380895256996155, + 0.02693047933280468, + 0.0660342127084732, + 0.026849206537008286 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10074543207883835 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an Indian cobra with a thorn-patterned hood fully open?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the cobra's body color smooth and golden-brown with a soft, plasticine-like sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cobra swaying with a deliberate, rhythmic movement while guarding a clutch of glossy, off-white eggs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there an oversized, comedic sweatdrop rolling down the cobra's temples along its scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a colorful jungle clearing with warm golden sunlight shafts and a background of fuchsia and sunny yellow flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008640168234705925 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758640289306641 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008640168234705925, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008640168234705925, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07769933342933655, + 0.025290900841355324, + 0.020065193995833397, + 0.10608403384685516, + 0.18166567385196686, + 0.06771887093782425, + 0.054251015186309814, + 0.30922049283981323, + 0.08667530864477158, + 0.07132922112941742 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008640168234705925 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an Indian cobra with a thorn-patterned hood fully open?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the cobra's body color smooth and golden-brown with a soft, plasticine-like sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cobra swaying with a deliberate, rhythmic movement while guarding a clutch of glossy, off-white eggs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there an oversized, comedic sweatdrop rolling down the cobra's temples along its scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a colorful jungle clearing with warm golden sunlight shafts and a background of fuchsia and sunny yellow flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0298001728951931 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298001766204834 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0298001728951931, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0298001728951931, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06066783890128136, + 0.0423356257379055, + 0.049679819494485855, + 0.17796404659748077, + 0.19234168529510498, + 0.03588110953569412, + 0.16657081246376038, + 0.13133125007152557, + 0.09427525103092194, + 0.048952534794807434 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0298001728951931 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an Indian cobra with a thorn-patterned hood fully open?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the cobra's body color smooth and golden-brown with a soft, plasticine-like sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cobra swaying with a deliberate, rhythmic movement while guarding a clutch of glossy, off-white eggs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there an oversized, comedic sweatdrop rolling down the cobra's temples along its scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a colorful jungle clearing with warm golden sunlight shafts and a background of fuchsia and sunny yellow flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023291917517781258 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773291826248169 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023291917517781258, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023291917517781258, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11208038777112961, + 0.02829635515809059, + 0.03394083306193352, + 0.09171094000339508, + 0.1289043426513672, + 0.18575060367584229, + 0.06279721111059189, + 0.16271549463272095, + 0.14003832638263702, + 0.053765494376420975 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023291917517781258 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an Indian cobra with a thorn-patterned hood fully open?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the cobra's body color smooth and golden-brown with a soft, plasticine-like sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cobra swaying with a deliberate, rhythmic movement while guarding a clutch of glossy, off-white eggs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there an oversized, comedic sweatdrop rolling down the cobra's temples along its scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a colorful jungle clearing with warm golden sunlight shafts and a background of fuchsia and sunny yellow flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004631387535482645 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379631519317627 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004631387535482645, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004631387535482645, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14184851944446564, + 0.0317758172750473, + 0.02602275088429451, + 0.051810961216688156, + 0.10142763704061508, + 0.2607860565185547, + 0.08066456764936447, + 0.07457571476697922, + 0.07169373333454132, + 0.15939421951770782 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004631387535482645 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_1/index_tensor([148, 148])_group_1_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_1/index_tensor([148, 148])_group_1_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..3b292887dcbd03a96d2c3c01b20bbfef5fcb95b8 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_1/index_tensor([148, 148])_group_1_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "low, wide-angle shot, shot from above, slowly pulls back to reveal a moment of monumental and devastating collapse. At the center of the frame is an ancient, massive stone wall perched on the edge of a precipitous cliff. Composed of massive, weathered granite blocks of varying sizes, its surface covered in dark green moss and withered vines, its cracks brimming with weathered mortar. Under a dark, overcast sky, the cool, evenly diffused light accentuates the wall's weathered texture. Suddenly, with a deep, teeth-grinding crack, a crucial upper support stone, under immense pressure, thrusts outward, setting off an unstoppable chain reaction. Tons of boulders seemed to have broken free from the constraints of thousands of years and were violently peeled off from the wall. They rolled heavily in the air and collided violently with each other, emitting sporadic sparks, and then carried a cloud of yellow-brown smoke and dust that swallowed the sky and the earth, rolling down the cliff with the force of thunder. The smoke and dust rose up in an instant, blurring the outline of the valley. The whole scene was full of awe-inspiring, primitive destructive power.", + "seed": 22588, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_1/index_148_seed_22588_dp_2_rank_4_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.23750159405171872, + "vlm_logprob": -0.23750159405171872, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.275, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.23750159405171872, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low, wide-angle view taken from above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pull back to reveal the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an ancient massive stone wall made of weathered granite blocks covered in dark green moss and withered vines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the wall collapse with a crucial upper support stone thrusting outward, causing boulders to break free, roll, collide with sparks, and generate yellow-brown smoke and dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting cool and evenly diffused under a dark overcast sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3172161281108856 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.317216157913208 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3172161281108856, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3172161281108856, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08289266377687454, + 0.03426095470786095, + 0.028658652678132057, + 0.06907880306243896, + 0.022729482501745224, + 0.052049942314624786, + 0.012576786801218987, + 0.014302140101790428, + 0.6659204959869385, + 0.01753006875514984 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3172161281108856 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low, wide-angle view taken from above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pull back to reveal the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an ancient massive stone wall made of weathered granite blocks covered in dark green moss and withered vines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the wall collapse with a crucial upper support stone thrusting outward, causing boulders to break free, roll, collide with sparks, and generate yellow-brown smoke and dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting cool and evenly diffused under a dark overcast sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.693410336971283 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.693410336971283 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.693410336971283, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.693410336971283, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0382591150701046, + 0.04974290728569031, + 0.027626125141978264, + 0.03912825882434845, + 0.04343275725841522, + 0.3847845196723938, + 0.1882781684398651, + 0.02082718163728714, + 0.16495269536972046, + 0.042968276888132095 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.693410336971283 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low, wide-angle view taken from above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pull back to reveal the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an ancient massive stone wall made of weathered granite blocks covered in dark green moss and withered vines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the wall collapse with a crucial upper support stone thrusting outward, causing boulders to break free, roll, collide with sparks, and generate yellow-brown smoke and dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting cool and evenly diffused under a dark overcast sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026373015716671944 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513729095458984 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026373015716671944, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026373015716671944, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.33317166566848755, + 0.08451739698648453, + 0.24247920513153076, + 0.057167503982782364, + 0.029665686190128326, + 0.024188317358493805, + 0.057906221598386765, + 0.018791543319821358, + 0.10845103859901428, + 0.043661486357450485 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026373015716671944 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low, wide-angle view taken from above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pull back to reveal the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an ancient massive stone wall made of weathered granite blocks covered in dark green moss and withered vines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the wall collapse with a crucial upper support stone thrusting outward, causing boulders to break free, roll, collide with sparks, and generate yellow-brown smoke and dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting cool and evenly diffused under a dark overcast sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007641371339559555 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882641315460205 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007641371339559555, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007641371339559555, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04242570325732231, + 0.09113717824220657, + 0.06899283826351166, + 0.16030459105968475, + 0.1046258807182312, + 0.24441693723201752, + 0.02794703096151352, + 0.03268402814865112, + 0.19717571139335632, + 0.030290089547634125 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 8, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007641371339559555 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low, wide-angle view taken from above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pull back to reveal the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an ancient massive stone wall made of weathered granite blocks covered in dark green moss and withered vines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the wall collapse with a crucial upper support stone thrusting outward, causing boulders to break free, roll, collide with sparks, and generate yellow-brown smoke and dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting cool and evenly diffused under a dark overcast sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14286711812019348 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.017867088317871 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14286711812019348, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14286711812019348, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16513946652412415, + 0.06472402811050415, + 0.05292876064777374, + 0.05470456928014755, + 0.025574753060936928, + 0.18109875917434692, + 0.01649574376642704, + 0.02166754938662052, + 0.38620248436927795, + 0.03146391361951828 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14286711812019348 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low, wide-angle shot, shot from above, slowly pulls back to reveal a moment of monumental and devastating collapse. At the center of the frame is an ancient, massive stone wall perched on the edge of a precipitous cliff. Composed of massive, weathered granite blocks of varying sizes, its surface covered in dark green moss and withered vines, its cracks brimming with weathered mortar. Under a dark, overcast sky, the cool, evenly diffused light accentuates the wall's weathered texture. Suddenly, with a deep, teeth-grinding crack, a crucial upper support stone, under immense pressure, thrusts outward, setting off an unstoppable chain reaction. Tons of boulders seemed to have broken free from the constraints of thousands of years and were violently peeled off from the wall. They rolled heavily in the air and collided violently with each other, emitting sporadic sparks, and then carried a cloud of yellow-brown smoke and dust that swallowed the sky and the earth, rolling down the cliff with the force of thunder. The smoke and dust rose up in an instant, blurring the outline of the valley. The whole scene was full of awe-inspiring, primitive destructive power.", + "seed": 22589, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_1/index_148_seed_22589_dp_2_rank_4_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.12667241543531418, + "vlm_logprob": -0.12667241543531418, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.85, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.12667241543531418, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low, wide-angle view taken from above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pull back to reveal the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an ancient massive stone wall made of weathered granite blocks covered in dark green moss and withered vines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the wall collapse with a crucial upper support stone thrusting outward, causing boulders to break free, roll, collide with sparks, and generate yellow-brown smoke and dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting cool and evenly diffused under a dark overcast sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.25599581003189087 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.505995750427246 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.25599581003189087, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.25599581003189087, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08277710527181625, + 0.5626968145370483, + 0.04154955595731735, + 0.05941007286310196, + 0.046919893473386765, + 0.06336792558431625, + 0.03692547604441643, + 0.015436103567481041, + 0.04908013343811035, + 0.041836921125650406 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.25599581003189087 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low, wide-angle view taken from above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pull back to reveal the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an ancient massive stone wall made of weathered granite blocks covered in dark green moss and withered vines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the wall collapse with a crucial upper support stone thrusting outward, causing boulders to break free, roll, collide with sparks, and generate yellow-brown smoke and dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting cool and evenly diffused under a dark overcast sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2015831023454666 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7015831470489502 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2015831023454666, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2015831023454666, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1333760768175125, + 0.2559484541416168, + 0.04017625376582146, + 0.15169097483158112, + 0.03040817193686962, + 0.03628621995449066, + 0.056646961718797684, + 0.03968045860528946, + 0.09598739445209503, + 0.15979909896850586 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2015831023454666 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low, wide-angle view taken from above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pull back to reveal the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an ancient massive stone wall made of weathered granite blocks covered in dark green moss and withered vines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the wall collapse with a crucial upper support stone thrusting outward, causing boulders to break free, roll, collide with sparks, and generate yellow-brown smoke and dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting cool and evenly diffused under a dark overcast sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008645840920507908 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758646011352539 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008645840920507908, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008645840920507908, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15682998299598694, + 0.26152291893959045, + 0.075820691883564, + 0.03655445948243141, + 0.045333463698625565, + 0.13307705521583557, + 0.05636607110500336, + 0.03218846395611763, + 0.05758528411388397, + 0.1447216123342514 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008645840920507908 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low, wide-angle view taken from above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pull back to reveal the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an ancient massive stone wall made of weathered granite blocks covered in dark green moss and withered vines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the wall collapse with a crucial upper support stone thrusting outward, causing boulders to break free, roll, collide with sparks, and generate yellow-brown smoke and dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting cool and evenly diffused under a dark overcast sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006738557480275631 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006738662719727 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006738557480275631, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006738557480275631, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12671975791454315, + 0.3069310188293457, + 0.03186533600091934, + 0.04200431704521179, + 0.046615853905677795, + 0.20479366183280945, + 0.07337396591901779, + 0.02844986505806446, + 0.05860793963074684, + 0.0806383416056633 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006738557480275631 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low, wide-angle view taken from above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pull back to reveal the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an ancient massive stone wall made of weathered granite blocks covered in dark green moss and withered vines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the wall collapse with a crucial upper support stone thrusting outward, causing boulders to break free, roll, collide with sparks, and generate yellow-brown smoke and dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting cool and evenly diffused under a dark overcast sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16039876639842987 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9103987216949463 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16039876639842987, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16039876639842987, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07642309367656708, + 0.1319083571434021, + 0.045168258249759674, + 0.09933892637491226, + 0.31679731607437134, + 0.04671647772192955, + 0.045676954090595245, + 0.022558674216270447, + 0.059704605489969254, + 0.15570731461048126 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16039876639842987 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low, wide-angle shot, shot from above, slowly pulls back to reveal a moment of monumental and devastating collapse. At the center of the frame is an ancient, massive stone wall perched on the edge of a precipitous cliff. Composed of massive, weathered granite blocks of varying sizes, its surface covered in dark green moss and withered vines, its cracks brimming with weathered mortar. Under a dark, overcast sky, the cool, evenly diffused light accentuates the wall's weathered texture. Suddenly, with a deep, teeth-grinding crack, a crucial upper support stone, under immense pressure, thrusts outward, setting off an unstoppable chain reaction. Tons of boulders seemed to have broken free from the constraints of thousands of years and were violently peeled off from the wall. They rolled heavily in the air and collided violently with each other, emitting sporadic sparks, and then carried a cloud of yellow-brown smoke and dust that swallowed the sky and the earth, rolling down the cliff with the force of thunder. The smoke and dust rose up in an instant, blurring the outline of the valley. The whole scene was full of awe-inspiring, primitive destructive power.", + "seed": 22590, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_1/index_148_seed_22590_dp_3_rank_6_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.10972882844507695, + "vlm_logprob": -0.10972882844507695, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.775, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.10972882844507695, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low, wide-angle view taken from above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pull back to reveal the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an ancient massive stone wall made of weathered granite blocks covered in dark green moss and withered vines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the wall collapse with a crucial upper support stone thrusting outward, causing boulders to break free, roll, collide with sparks, and generate yellow-brown smoke and dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting cool and evenly diffused under a dark overcast sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20822541415691376 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7082253694534302 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20822541415691376, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20822541415691376, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09765981137752533, + 0.09635517746210098, + 0.026052024215459824, + 0.13882187008857727, + 0.3173682689666748, + 0.03039678931236267, + 0.03571664169430733, + 0.22603537142276764, + 0.014657322317361832, + 0.016936734318733215 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 7, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20822541415691376 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low, wide-angle view taken from above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pull back to reveal the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an ancient massive stone wall made of weathered granite blocks covered in dark green moss and withered vines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the wall collapse with a crucial upper support stone thrusting outward, causing boulders to break free, roll, collide with sparks, and generate yellow-brown smoke and dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting cool and evenly diffused under a dark overcast sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20159606635570526 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7015960216522217 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20159606635570526, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20159606635570526, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0580957792699337, + 0.32486969232559204, + 0.0249814223498106, + 0.1608545184135437, + 0.17706017196178436, + 0.06045406684279442, + 0.09259451180696487, + 0.04696853458881378, + 0.024354692548513412, + 0.029766593128442764 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20159606635570526 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low, wide-angle view taken from above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pull back to reveal the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an ancient massive stone wall made of weathered granite blocks covered in dark green moss and withered vines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the wall collapse with a crucial upper support stone thrusting outward, causing boulders to break free, roll, collide with sparks, and generate yellow-brown smoke and dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting cool and evenly diffused under a dark overcast sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01608162373304367 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141081809997559 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01608162373304367, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01608162373304367, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12963072955608368, + 0.3470763564109802, + 0.08033832162618637, + 0.18269453942775726, + 0.08268594741821289, + 0.04823005944490433, + 0.031162908300757408, + 0.05083589628338814, + 0.020421868190169334, + 0.02692335471510887 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01608162373304367 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low, wide-angle view taken from above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pull back to reveal the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an ancient massive stone wall made of weathered granite blocks covered in dark green moss and withered vines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the wall collapse with a crucial upper support stone thrusting outward, causing boulders to break free, roll, collide with sparks, and generate yellow-brown smoke and dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting cool and evenly diffused under a dark overcast sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009786011651158333 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634786128997803 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009786011651158333, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009786011651158333, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10584566742181778, + 0.06570558249950409, + 0.024638615548610687, + 0.12293541431427002, + 0.08029202371835709, + 0.07996256649494171, + 0.0840468630194664, + 0.33334654569625854, + 0.04586115479469299, + 0.057365577667951584 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009786011651158333 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low, wide-angle view taken from above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pull back to reveal the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an ancient massive stone wall made of weathered granite blocks covered in dark green moss and withered vines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the wall collapse with a crucial upper support stone thrusting outward, causing boulders to break free, roll, collide with sparks, and generate yellow-brown smoke and dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting cool and evenly diffused under a dark overcast sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11295502632856369 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.237955093383789 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11295502632856369, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11295502632856369, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14148303866386414, + 0.3180132210254669, + 0.17290116846561432, + 0.08320580422878265, + 0.051759347319602966, + 0.06307093799114227, + 0.04327549412846565, + 0.06980204582214355, + 0.020226821303367615, + 0.03626213222742081 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11295502632856369 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low, wide-angle shot, shot from above, slowly pulls back to reveal a moment of monumental and devastating collapse. At the center of the frame is an ancient, massive stone wall perched on the edge of a precipitous cliff. Composed of massive, weathered granite blocks of varying sizes, its surface covered in dark green moss and withered vines, its cracks brimming with weathered mortar. Under a dark, overcast sky, the cool, evenly diffused light accentuates the wall's weathered texture. Suddenly, with a deep, teeth-grinding crack, a crucial upper support stone, under immense pressure, thrusts outward, setting off an unstoppable chain reaction. Tons of boulders seemed to have broken free from the constraints of thousands of years and were violently peeled off from the wall. They rolled heavily in the air and collided violently with each other, emitting sporadic sparks, and then carried a cloud of yellow-brown smoke and dust that swallowed the sky and the earth, rolling down the cliff with the force of thunder. The smoke and dust rose up in an instant, blurring the outline of the valley. The whole scene was full of awe-inspiring, primitive destructive power.", + "seed": 22591, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_1/index_148_seed_22591_dp_3_rank_6_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.10781312352046371, + "vlm_logprob": -0.10781312352046371, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.2, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.10781312352046371, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low, wide-angle view taken from above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pull back to reveal the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an ancient massive stone wall made of weathered granite blocks covered in dark green moss and withered vines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the wall collapse with a crucial upper support stone thrusting outward, causing boulders to break free, roll, collide with sparks, and generate yellow-brown smoke and dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting cool and evenly diffused under a dark overcast sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.21011559665203094 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7101155519485474 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.21011559665203094, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.21011559665203094, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17119945585727692, + 0.12355736643075943, + 0.05286466330289841, + 0.10806632041931152, + 0.0927533283829689, + 0.04337321221828461, + 0.19457289576530457, + 0.04368278384208679, + 0.08938468247652054, + 0.0805453211069107 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.21011559665203094 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low, wide-angle view taken from above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pull back to reveal the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an ancient massive stone wall made of weathered granite blocks covered in dark green moss and withered vines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the wall collapse with a crucial upper support stone thrusting outward, causing boulders to break free, roll, collide with sparks, and generate yellow-brown smoke and dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting cool and evenly diffused under a dark overcast sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.28134313225746155 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4063431024551392 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.28134313225746155, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.28134313225746155, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09641897678375244, + 0.09423739463090897, + 0.0840160921216011, + 0.04345627874135971, + 0.05710459500551224, + 0.06609854102134705, + 0.15286356210708618, + 0.08271388709545135, + 0.1965974122285843, + 0.12649333477020264 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.28134313225746155 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low, wide-angle view taken from above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pull back to reveal the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an ancient massive stone wall made of weathered granite blocks covered in dark green moss and withered vines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the wall collapse with a crucial upper support stone thrusting outward, causing boulders to break free, roll, collide with sparks, and generate yellow-brown smoke and dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting cool and evenly diffused under a dark overcast sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005263755563646555 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255263805389404 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005263755563646555, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005263755563646555, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10973377525806427, + 0.1572866141796112, + 0.21963264048099518, + 0.024501454085111618, + 0.044051554054021835, + 0.09372776001691818, + 0.08658912777900696, + 0.06021823361515999, + 0.1010991632938385, + 0.10315966606140137 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005263755563646555 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low, wide-angle view taken from above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pull back to reveal the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an ancient massive stone wall made of weathered granite blocks covered in dark green moss and withered vines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the wall collapse with a crucial upper support stone thrusting outward, causing boulders to break free, roll, collide with sparks, and generate yellow-brown smoke and dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting cool and evenly diffused under a dark overcast sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00864111352711916 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758641242980957 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00864111352711916, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00864111352711916, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10382164269685745, + 0.17096537351608276, + 0.1344253420829773, + 0.01832052692770958, + 0.10142230987548828, + 0.057922475039958954, + 0.059988219290971756, + 0.07365349680185318, + 0.2085586041212082, + 0.0709221363067627 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00864111352711916 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low, wide-angle view taken from above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pull back to reveal the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an ancient massive stone wall made of weathered granite blocks covered in dark green moss and withered vines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the wall collapse with a crucial upper support stone thrusting outward, causing boulders to break free, roll, collide with sparks, and generate yellow-brown smoke and dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting cool and evenly diffused under a dark overcast sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03370201960206032 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4087021350860596 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03370201960206032, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03370201960206032, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5246012210845947, + 0.07557263225317001, + 0.0879819244146347, + 0.020584478974342346, + 0.04898802563548088, + 0.015582741238176823, + 0.06697991490364075, + 0.034458182752132416, + 0.0589197538793087, + 0.06633111089468002 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03370201960206032 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_10/index_tensor([7886, 7886])_group_10_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_10/index_tensor([7886, 7886])_group_10_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..4ab1aa7f29bdb929122373f2d3c98dcabfe423ac --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_10/index_tensor([7886, 7886])_group_10_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "This static, eye-level close-up captures a crystal-clear image of a downy duck adorably struggling in the calm waters of a sun-dappled pond. Its downy feathers, a vibrant lemon yellow, are rendered in surreal detail, with tufts of feathers slightly tangled in the water. Its beady black eyes widen with earnest concentration as it attempts to swim. Its movements are a series of clumsy micro-movements: it kicks its tiny webbed feet in a frantic, uncoordinated pattern, causing its entire body to sway precariously. Then, it stumbles through the water, pitching heavily to one side, flapping its crude, undeveloped wings in a futile, unbalanced attempt to steady itself before tentatively regaining its footing. The entire scene is illuminated by the warm golden glow of the afternoon sun, which filters through unseen trees, creating shimmering caustics on the water's surface and a soft, glowing rimlight on the duckling's body. The soft-focus blur of deep green water lilies and dark, reflective water in the background creates a tender and endearing atmosphere, focusing entirely on the young creature's innocent yet comical efforts.", + "seed": 1910, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_10/index_7886_seed_1910_dp_20_rank_40_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.5079620068892836, + "vlm_logprob": -0.5079620068892836, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.75, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.5079620068892836, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a downy duck with vibrant lemon yellow feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the duck performing clumsy micro-movements such as kicking tiny webbed feet and swaying precariously?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the duck flap crude, undeveloped wings in an unbalanced attempt to steady itself?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a warm golden glow creating shimmering caustics on the water and a soft rimlight on the duck?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned as a static, eye-level close-up with a soft-focus background of deep green water lilies?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6008660793304443 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22586601972579956 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.6008660793304443, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -1.6008660793304443, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09257087856531143, + 0.08150584250688553, + 0.3050398826599121, + 0.0956876128911972, + 0.03202182054519653, + 0.029191892594099045, + 0.0414029024541378, + 0.015756459906697273, + 0.2790587544441223, + 0.027763929218053818 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 8, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.6008660793304443 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a downy duck with vibrant lemon yellow feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the duck performing clumsy micro-movements such as kicking tiny webbed feet and swaying precariously?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the duck flap crude, undeveloped wings in an unbalanced attempt to steady itself?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a warm golden glow creating shimmering caustics on the water and a soft rimlight on the duck?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned as a static, eye-level close-up with a soft-focus background of deep green water lilies?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6328586339950562 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7578586339950562 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.6328586339950562, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.6328586339950562, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.028902722522616386, + 0.19392931461334229, + 0.1030016615986824, + 0.13246430456638336, + 0.05269058421254158, + 0.023069599643349648, + 0.0578886978328228, + 0.06382119655609131, + 0.05604548752307892, + 0.2881864607334137 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.6328586339950562 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a downy duck with vibrant lemon yellow feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the duck performing clumsy micro-movements such as kicking tiny webbed feet and swaying precariously?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the duck flap crude, undeveloped wings in an unbalanced attempt to steady itself?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a warm golden glow creating shimmering caustics on the water and a soft rimlight on the duck?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned as a static, eye-level close-up with a soft-focus background of deep green water lilies?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2813630998134613 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4063631296157837 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2813630998134613, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2813630998134613, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05657591670751572, + 0.2053966522216797, + 0.11047932505607605, + 0.05438980460166931, + 0.06033874303102493, + 0.01794476807117462, + 0.07772663235664368, + 0.016103090718388557, + 0.04420357942581177, + 0.35684147477149963 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2813630998134613 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a downy duck with vibrant lemon yellow feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the duck performing clumsy micro-movements such as kicking tiny webbed feet and swaying precariously?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the duck flap crude, undeveloped wings in an unbalanced attempt to steady itself?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a warm golden glow creating shimmering caustics on the water and a soft rimlight on the duck?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned as a static, eye-level close-up with a soft-focus background of deep green water lilies?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008650568313896656 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758650779724121 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008650568313896656, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008650568313896656, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05735202133655548, + 0.08920230716466904, + 0.13977274298667908, + 0.07373147457838058, + 0.02313065342605114, + 0.015319833531975746, + 0.11099780350923538, + 0.04335175082087517, + 0.11816418170928955, + 0.3289772570133209 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 2, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008650568313896656 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a downy duck with vibrant lemon yellow feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the duck performing clumsy micro-movements such as kicking tiny webbed feet and swaying precariously?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the duck flap crude, undeveloped wings in an unbalanced attempt to steady itself?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a warm golden glow creating shimmering caustics on the water and a soft rimlight on the duck?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned as a static, eye-level close-up with a soft-focus background of deep green water lilies?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016071652993559837 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141071796417236 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016071652993559837, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016071652993559837, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10173316299915314, + 0.09209637343883514, + 0.18650321662425995, + 0.04574747011065483, + 0.13893575966358185, + 0.02188989333808422, + 0.07693234831094742, + 0.020302748307585716, + 0.10295243561267853, + 0.2129065841436386 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016071652993559837 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "This static, eye-level close-up captures a crystal-clear image of a downy duck adorably struggling in the calm waters of a sun-dappled pond. Its downy feathers, a vibrant lemon yellow, are rendered in surreal detail, with tufts of feathers slightly tangled in the water. Its beady black eyes widen with earnest concentration as it attempts to swim. Its movements are a series of clumsy micro-movements: it kicks its tiny webbed feet in a frantic, uncoordinated pattern, causing its entire body to sway precariously. Then, it stumbles through the water, pitching heavily to one side, flapping its crude, undeveloped wings in a futile, unbalanced attempt to steady itself before tentatively regaining its footing. The entire scene is illuminated by the warm golden glow of the afternoon sun, which filters through unseen trees, creating shimmering caustics on the water's surface and a soft, glowing rimlight on the duckling's body. The soft-focus blur of deep green water lilies and dark, reflective water in the background creates a tender and endearing atmosphere, focusing entirely on the young creature's innocent yet comical efforts.", + "seed": 1911, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_10/index_7886_seed_1911_dp_20_rank_40_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.31197011545300485, + "vlm_logprob": -0.31197011545300485, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.4, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.31197011545300485, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a downy duck with vibrant lemon yellow feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the duck performing clumsy micro-movements such as kicking tiny webbed feet and swaying precariously?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the duck flap crude, undeveloped wings in an unbalanced attempt to steady itself?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a warm golden glow creating shimmering caustics on the water and a soft rimlight on the duck?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned as a static, eye-level close-up with a soft-focus background of deep green water lilies?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.0548077821731567 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.42980775237083435 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.0548077821731567, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.625, + "token_credit_reward": -1.0548077821731567, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21727107465267181, + 0.028101760894060135, + 0.03250499442219734, + 0.4027184247970581, + 0.045683328062295914, + 0.034212492406368256, + 0.10930966585874557, + 0.07494855672121048, + 0.04042961448431015, + 0.01482013426721096 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.0548077821731567 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a downy duck with vibrant lemon yellow feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the duck performing clumsy micro-movements such as kicking tiny webbed feet and swaying precariously?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the duck flap crude, undeveloped wings in an unbalanced attempt to steady itself?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a warm golden glow creating shimmering caustics on the water and a soft rimlight on the duck?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned as a static, eye-level close-up with a soft-focus background of deep green water lilies?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4289077818393707 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.0539077520370483 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.4289077818393707, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.4289077818393707, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1985567808151245, + 0.06413237750530243, + 0.04335140809416771, + 0.44814878702163696, + 0.03283616155385971, + 0.02300376445055008, + 0.03596554324030876, + 0.0693558007478714, + 0.0619012750685215, + 0.022748133167624474 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.4289077818393707 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a downy duck with vibrant lemon yellow feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the duck performing clumsy micro-movements such as kicking tiny webbed feet and swaying precariously?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the duck flap crude, undeveloped wings in an unbalanced attempt to steady itself?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a warm golden glow creating shimmering caustics on the water and a soft rimlight on the duck?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned as a static, eye-level close-up with a soft-focus background of deep green water lilies?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.054959487169981 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929959535598755 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.054959487169981, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.054959487169981, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20977097749710083, + 0.05554169788956642, + 0.04864943400025368, + 0.46921753883361816, + 0.031393952667713165, + 0.028033694252371788, + 0.016840413212776184, + 0.05778418853878975, + 0.06015898287296295, + 0.022609122097492218 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.054959487169981 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a downy duck with vibrant lemon yellow feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the duck performing clumsy micro-movements such as kicking tiny webbed feet and swaying precariously?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the duck flap crude, undeveloped wings in an unbalanced attempt to steady itself?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a warm golden glow creating shimmering caustics on the water and a soft rimlight on the duck?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned as a static, eye-level close-up with a soft-focus background of deep green water lilies?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008641350083053112 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758641242980957 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008641350083053112, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008641350083053112, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10920897126197815, + 0.05394895002245903, + 0.01826651580631733, + 0.5834967494010925, + 0.024004139006137848, + 0.05058644339442253, + 0.06404877454042435, + 0.04263820871710777, + 0.04270421713590622, + 0.0110970763489604 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008641350083053112 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a downy duck with vibrant lemon yellow feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the duck performing clumsy micro-movements such as kicking tiny webbed feet and swaying precariously?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the duck flap crude, undeveloped wings in an unbalanced attempt to steady itself?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a warm golden glow creating shimmering caustics on the water and a soft rimlight on the duck?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned as a static, eye-level close-up with a soft-focus background of deep green water lilies?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012534175999462605 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387534141540527 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012534175999462605, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012534175999462605, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0631517618894577, + 0.034773025661706924, + 0.0377197191119194, + 0.6542961597442627, + 0.027727019041776657, + 0.026313720270991325, + 0.02346712537109852, + 0.0762619897723198, + 0.035326819866895676, + 0.020962610840797424 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012534175999462605 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "This static, eye-level close-up captures a crystal-clear image of a downy duck adorably struggling in the calm waters of a sun-dappled pond. Its downy feathers, a vibrant lemon yellow, are rendered in surreal detail, with tufts of feathers slightly tangled in the water. Its beady black eyes widen with earnest concentration as it attempts to swim. Its movements are a series of clumsy micro-movements: it kicks its tiny webbed feet in a frantic, uncoordinated pattern, causing its entire body to sway precariously. Then, it stumbles through the water, pitching heavily to one side, flapping its crude, undeveloped wings in a futile, unbalanced attempt to steady itself before tentatively regaining its footing. The entire scene is illuminated by the warm golden glow of the afternoon sun, which filters through unseen trees, creating shimmering caustics on the water's surface and a soft, glowing rimlight on the duckling's body. The soft-focus blur of deep green water lilies and dark, reflective water in the background creates a tender and endearing atmosphere, focusing entirely on the young creature's innocent yet comical efforts.", + "seed": 1912, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_10/index_7886_seed_1912_dp_21_rank_42_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.3899466373026371, + "vlm_logprob": -0.3899466373026371, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.025, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.3899466373026371, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a downy duck with vibrant lemon yellow feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the duck performing clumsy micro-movements such as kicking tiny webbed feet and swaying precariously?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the duck flap crude, undeveloped wings in an unbalanced attempt to steady itself?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a warm golden glow creating shimmering caustics on the water and a soft rimlight on the duck?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned as a static, eye-level close-up with a soft-focus background of deep green water lilies?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2241722345352173 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3491722643375397 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.2241722345352173, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -1.2241722345352173, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09412471204996109, + 0.048744555562734604, + 0.12093833833932877, + 0.16740378737449646, + 0.13969285786151886, + 0.06860194355249405, + 0.02364698052406311, + 0.037280552089214325, + 0.22272734344005585, + 0.0768389031291008 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.2241722345352173 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a downy duck with vibrant lemon yellow feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the duck performing clumsy micro-movements such as kicking tiny webbed feet and swaying precariously?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the duck flap crude, undeveloped wings in an unbalanced attempt to steady itself?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a warm golden glow creating shimmering caustics on the water and a soft rimlight on the duck?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned as a static, eye-level close-up with a soft-focus background of deep green water lilies?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5233290791511536 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8983290791511536 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5233290791511536, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5233290791511536, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0748656690120697, + 0.11173068732023239, + 0.13077065348625183, + 0.06190391629934311, + 0.09186223149299622, + 0.20799650251865387, + 0.031298860907554626, + 0.10360682755708694, + 0.08790220320224762, + 0.09806250780820847 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5233290791511536 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a downy duck with vibrant lemon yellow feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the duck performing clumsy micro-movements such as kicking tiny webbed feet and swaying precariously?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the duck flap crude, undeveloped wings in an unbalanced attempt to steady itself?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a warm golden glow creating shimmering caustics on the water and a soft rimlight on the duck?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned as a static, eye-level close-up with a soft-focus background of deep green water lilies?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17991027235984802 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8049103021621704 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17991027235984802, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17991027235984802, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12531951069831848, + 0.09476558119058609, + 0.06439550966024399, + 0.08037326484918594, + 0.12489436566829681, + 0.16495968401432037, + 0.06525327265262604, + 0.0909973755478859, + 0.05991029366850853, + 0.12913109362125397 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17991027235984802 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a downy duck with vibrant lemon yellow feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the duck performing clumsy micro-movements such as kicking tiny webbed feet and swaying precariously?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the duck flap crude, undeveloped wings in an unbalanced attempt to steady itself?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a warm golden glow creating shimmering caustics on the water and a soft rimlight on the duck?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned as a static, eye-level close-up with a soft-focus background of deep green water lilies?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00978624727576971 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634786128997803 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00978624727576971, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00978624727576971, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09076282382011414, + 0.08552821725606918, + 0.22044123709201813, + 0.08955066651105881, + 0.15840646624565125, + 0.04664802923798561, + 0.02707420289516449, + 0.11418887227773666, + 0.08949176967144012, + 0.0779077336192131 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 4, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00978624727576971 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a downy duck with vibrant lemon yellow feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the duck performing clumsy micro-movements such as kicking tiny webbed feet and swaying precariously?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the duck flap crude, undeveloped wings in an unbalanced attempt to steady itself?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a warm golden glow creating shimmering caustics on the water and a soft rimlight on the duck?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned as a static, eye-level close-up with a soft-focus background of deep green water lilies?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012535353191196918 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387535572052002 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012535353191196918, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012535353191196918, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07108743488788605, + 0.0802011638879776, + 0.055263567715883255, + 0.14779527485370636, + 0.20325464010238647, + 0.08724085986614227, + 0.030714407563209534, + 0.20279072225093842, + 0.08134359866380692, + 0.0403083860874176 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 7, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012535353191196918 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "This static, eye-level close-up captures a crystal-clear image of a downy duck adorably struggling in the calm waters of a sun-dappled pond. Its downy feathers, a vibrant lemon yellow, are rendered in surreal detail, with tufts of feathers slightly tangled in the water. Its beady black eyes widen with earnest concentration as it attempts to swim. Its movements are a series of clumsy micro-movements: it kicks its tiny webbed feet in a frantic, uncoordinated pattern, causing its entire body to sway precariously. Then, it stumbles through the water, pitching heavily to one side, flapping its crude, undeveloped wings in a futile, unbalanced attempt to steady itself before tentatively regaining its footing. The entire scene is illuminated by the warm golden glow of the afternoon sun, which filters through unseen trees, creating shimmering caustics on the water's surface and a soft, glowing rimlight on the duckling's body. The soft-focus blur of deep green water lilies and dark, reflective water in the background creates a tender and endearing atmosphere, focusing entirely on the young creature's innocent yet comical efforts.", + "seed": 1913, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_10/index_7886_seed_1913_dp_21_rank_42_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.3495506036095321, + "vlm_logprob": -0.3495506036095321, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.225, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.3495506036095321, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a downy duck with vibrant lemon yellow feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the duck performing clumsy micro-movements such as kicking tiny webbed feet and swaying precariously?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the duck flap crude, undeveloped wings in an unbalanced attempt to steady itself?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a warm golden glow creating shimmering caustics on the water and a soft rimlight on the duck?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned as a static, eye-level close-up with a soft-focus background of deep green water lilies?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.899007260799408 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.524007260799408 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.899007260799408, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.899007260799408, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5338964462280273, + 0.05093282833695412, + 0.06637223809957504, + 0.07150933891534805, + 0.04830564931035042, + 0.008863115683197975, + 0.08456158638000488, + 0.019689029082655907, + 0.09926018863916397, + 0.016609475016593933 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.899007260799408 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a downy duck with vibrant lemon yellow feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the duck performing clumsy micro-movements such as kicking tiny webbed feet and swaying precariously?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the duck flap crude, undeveloped wings in an unbalanced attempt to steady itself?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a warm golden glow creating shimmering caustics on the water and a soft rimlight on the duck?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned as a static, eye-level close-up with a soft-focus background of deep green water lilies?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6328157186508179 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7578157186508179 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.6328157186508179, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.6328157186508179, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2640451192855835, + 0.2855788469314575, + 0.04894806444644928, + 0.06153150275349617, + 0.08273740112781525, + 0.08005153387784958, + 0.08103787899017334, + 0.032822079956531525, + 0.03496348112821579, + 0.02828410640358925 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.6328157186508179 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a downy duck with vibrant lemon yellow feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the duck performing clumsy micro-movements such as kicking tiny webbed feet and swaying precariously?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the duck flap crude, undeveloped wings in an unbalanced attempt to steady itself?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a warm golden glow creating shimmering caustics on the water and a soft rimlight on the duck?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned as a static, eye-level close-up with a soft-focus background of deep green water lilies?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20156750082969666 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.701567530632019 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20156750082969666, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20156750082969666, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.6763975620269775, + 0.11146924644708633, + 0.02072305791079998, + 0.03345223516225815, + 0.03837157040834427, + 0.012578777968883514, + 0.030137158930301666, + 0.015886757522821426, + 0.030873296782374382, + 0.030110381543636322 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20156750082969666 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a downy duck with vibrant lemon yellow feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the duck performing clumsy micro-movements such as kicking tiny webbed feet and swaying precariously?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the duck flap crude, undeveloped wings in an unbalanced attempt to steady itself?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a warm golden glow creating shimmering caustics on the water and a soft rimlight on the duck?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned as a static, eye-level close-up with a soft-focus background of deep green water lilies?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006738320458680391 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006738185882568 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006738320458680391, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006738320458680391, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5780542492866516, + 0.04514625668525696, + 0.03787471726536751, + 0.04252594709396362, + 0.10616292804479599, + 0.051534026861190796, + 0.031378235667943954, + 0.06634483486413956, + 0.03108832612633705, + 0.009890496730804443 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006738320458680391 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a downy duck with vibrant lemon yellow feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the duck performing clumsy micro-movements such as kicking tiny webbed feet and swaying precariously?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the duck flap crude, undeveloped wings in an unbalanced attempt to steady itself?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a warm golden glow creating shimmering caustics on the water and a soft rimlight on the duck?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned as a static, eye-level close-up with a soft-focus background of deep green water lilies?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0076242173090577126 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.88262414932251 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0076242173090577126, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0076242173090577126, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5578574538230896, + 0.12338405847549438, + 0.09001674503087997, + 0.02761363983154297, + 0.0778338685631752, + 0.02357185259461403, + 0.028390776365995407, + 0.04430230334401131, + 0.0155298737809062, + 0.011499439366161823 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0076242173090577126 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_11/index_tensor([7039, 7039])_group_11_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_11/index_tensor([7039, 7039])_group_11_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..affac7a7f65eebed36cc57a0ac5dad8f791c2582 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_11/index_tensor([7039, 7039])_group_11_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "An extremely slow-motion macro close-up, captured from a slightly overhead perspective, focuses on a pair of slender, white hands carefully cradling a creamy white, pebble-shaped electric hand warmer. The hands, with their neatly manicured nails and gentle gestures, seem to be protecting a treasure. The hand warmer's smooth, rounded, matte finish reflects a soft, warm glow under the warm yellow light of the cafe's vintage tungsten lamps, which cast a sideways cast. As the camera zooms in at an almost imperceptible pace, the heat radiating from the hand warmer's surface becomes concrete in the extreme slow motion: the air around it undergoes a visible, transparent distortion, forming gentle ripples that slowly and gracefully rise and dissipate, like heat waves on an asphalt road on a summer afternoon. The background is rendered extremely blurred by a shallow depth of field, barely discernible enough to distinguish the texture of the dark wood tabletop and the curl of steam from a latte in the distance. Together, they create an intimate atmosphere of profound tranquility, warmth, healing, and exquisite detail.", + "seed": 23289, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_11/index_7039_seed_23289_dp_22_rank_44_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.034630329627543685, + "vlm_logprob": -0.034630329627543685, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.875, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.034630329627543685, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of slender, white hands with neatly manicured nails visible cradling an object?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the object being held a creamy white, pebble-shaped electric hand warmer with a smooth, rounded, matte finish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in extreme slow motion showing visible, transparent air ripples rising from the hand warmer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera zoom in at an almost imperceptible pace from a slightly overhead perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background extremely blurred with a shallow depth of field, revealing only a dark wood tabletop and distant steam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04392580687999725 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1689257621765137 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04392580687999725, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04392580687999725, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22476458549499512, + 0.15259121358394623, + 0.09464085102081299, + 0.07951197773218155, + 0.14630980789661407, + 0.0705370083451271, + 0.04419150575995445, + 0.0875399187207222, + 0.04474982991814613, + 0.05516326427459717 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04392580687999725 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of slender, white hands with neatly manicured nails visible cradling an object?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the object being held a creamy white, pebble-shaped electric hand warmer with a smooth, rounded, matte finish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in extreme slow motion showing visible, transparent air ripples rising from the hand warmer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera zoom in at an almost imperceptible pace from a slightly overhead perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background extremely blurred with a shallow depth of field, revealing only a dark wood tabletop and distant steam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011101856827735901 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511101722717285 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011101856827735901, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011101856827735901, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23315751552581787, + 0.24419298768043518, + 0.07656724005937576, + 0.05364760756492615, + 0.030169717967510223, + 0.041404400020837784, + 0.025068895891308784, + 0.0674579069018364, + 0.11676675081253052, + 0.11156702786684036 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011101856827735901 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of slender, white hands with neatly manicured nails visible cradling an object?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the object being held a creamy white, pebble-shaped electric hand warmer with a smooth, rounded, matte finish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in extreme slow motion showing visible, transparent air ripples rising from the hand warmer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera zoom in at an almost imperceptible pace from a slightly overhead perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background extremely blurred with a shallow depth of field, revealing only a dark wood tabletop and distant steam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1003112941980362 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.350311279296875 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1003112941980362, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1003112941980362, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18953591585159302, + 0.3289200961589813, + 0.08932135999202728, + 0.03852366656064987, + 0.08164410293102264, + 0.05694882199168205, + 0.043817564845085144, + 0.06867635995149612, + 0.07614412158727646, + 0.02646796591579914 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1003112941980362 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of slender, white hands with neatly manicured nails visible cradling an object?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the object being held a creamy white, pebble-shaped electric hand warmer with a smooth, rounded, matte finish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in extreme slow motion showing visible, transparent air ripples rising from the hand warmer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera zoom in at an almost imperceptible pace from a slightly overhead perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background extremely blurred with a shallow depth of field, revealing only a dark wood tabletop and distant steam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011078514158725739 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511078357696533 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011078514158725739, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011078514158725739, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16079553961753845, + 0.18914224207401276, + 0.09764306992292404, + 0.08603943139314651, + 0.0969831570982933, + 0.040021445602178574, + 0.07512295991182327, + 0.05585062876343727, + 0.17826628684997559, + 0.020135177299380302 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011078514158725739 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of slender, white hands with neatly manicured nails visible cradling an object?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the object being held a creamy white, pebble-shaped electric hand warmer with a smooth, rounded, matte finish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in extreme slow motion showing visible, transparent air ripples rising from the hand warmer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera zoom in at an almost imperceptible pace from a slightly overhead perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background extremely blurred with a shallow depth of field, revealing only a dark wood tabletop and distant steam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006734176073223352 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006734371185303 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006734176073223352, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006734176073223352, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16651667654514313, + 0.3321459889411926, + 0.24256938695907593, + 0.0844409316778183, + 0.03358987346291542, + 0.04480349272489548, + 0.02068105712532997, + 0.03337593376636505, + 0.010947585105895996, + 0.030929049476981163 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006734176073223352 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extremely slow-motion macro close-up, captured from a slightly overhead perspective, focuses on a pair of slender, white hands carefully cradling a creamy white, pebble-shaped electric hand warmer. The hands, with their neatly manicured nails and gentle gestures, seem to be protecting a treasure. The hand warmer's smooth, rounded, matte finish reflects a soft, warm glow under the warm yellow light of the cafe's vintage tungsten lamps, which cast a sideways cast. As the camera zooms in at an almost imperceptible pace, the heat radiating from the hand warmer's surface becomes concrete in the extreme slow motion: the air around it undergoes a visible, transparent distortion, forming gentle ripples that slowly and gracefully rise and dissipate, like heat waves on an asphalt road on a summer afternoon. The background is rendered extremely blurred by a shallow depth of field, barely discernible enough to distinguish the texture of the dark wood tabletop and the curl of steam from a latte in the distance. Together, they create an intimate atmosphere of profound tranquility, warmth, healing, and exquisite detail.", + "seed": 23290, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_11/index_7039_seed_23290_dp_22_rank_44_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.044698945619165896, + "vlm_logprob": -0.044698945619165896, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.15, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.044698945619165896, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of slender, white hands with neatly manicured nails visible cradling an object?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the object being held a creamy white, pebble-shaped electric hand warmer with a smooth, rounded, matte finish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in extreme slow motion showing visible, transparent air ripples rising from the hand warmer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera zoom in at an almost imperceptible pace from a slightly overhead perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background extremely blurred with a shallow depth of field, revealing only a dark wood tabletop and distant steam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.010364989750087261 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.635365009307861 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.010364989750087261, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.010364989750087261, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09473790228366852, + 0.08817914873361588, + 0.08524010330438614, + 0.02105827070772648, + 0.01904771290719509, + 0.02930254489183426, + 0.017455043271183968, + 0.06802572309970856, + 0.4077391028404236, + 0.16921445727348328 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.010364989750087261 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of slender, white hands with neatly manicured nails visible cradling an object?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the object being held a creamy white, pebble-shaped electric hand warmer with a smooth, rounded, matte finish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in extreme slow motion showing visible, transparent air ripples rising from the hand warmer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera zoom in at an almost imperceptible pace from a slightly overhead perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background extremely blurred with a shallow depth of field, revealing only a dark wood tabletop and distant steam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023324061185121536 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7733240127563477 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023324061185121536, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023324061185121536, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06312494724988937, + 0.0284151341766119, + 0.09407182037830353, + 0.01698390766978264, + 0.014234882779419422, + 0.024704089388251305, + 0.030387694016098976, + 0.034464314579963684, + 0.2918245196342468, + 0.4017886817455292 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023324061185121536 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of slender, white hands with neatly manicured nails visible cradling an object?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the object being held a creamy white, pebble-shaped electric hand warmer with a smooth, rounded, matte finish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in extreme slow motion showing visible, transparent air ripples rising from the hand warmer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera zoom in at an almost imperceptible pace from a slightly overhead perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background extremely blurred with a shallow depth of field, revealing only a dark wood tabletop and distant steam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17987491190433502 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8048748970031738 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17987491190433502, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17987491190433502, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0750502422451973, + 0.03140060603618622, + 0.027498219162225723, + 0.016433110460639, + 0.01899595744907856, + 0.021267469972372055, + 0.025619110092520714, + 0.039253685623407364, + 0.6136854887008667, + 0.1307961791753769 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17987491190433502 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of slender, white hands with neatly manicured nails visible cradling an object?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the object being held a creamy white, pebble-shaped electric hand warmer with a smooth, rounded, matte finish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in extreme slow motion showing visible, transparent air ripples rising from the hand warmer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera zoom in at an almost imperceptible pace from a slightly overhead perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background extremely blurred with a shallow depth of field, revealing only a dark wood tabletop and distant steam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006739622913300991 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006739616394043 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006739622913300991, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006739622913300991, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10728802531957626, + 0.04898801073431969, + 0.12199508398771286, + 0.019828077405691147, + 0.02788539044559002, + 0.03132089972496033, + 0.05414104834198952, + 0.08893812447786331, + 0.34497103095054626, + 0.15464431047439575 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006739622913300991 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of slender, white hands with neatly manicured nails visible cradling an object?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the object being held a creamy white, pebble-shaped electric hand warmer with a smooth, rounded, matte finish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in extreme slow motion showing visible, transparent air ripples rising from the hand warmer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera zoom in at an almost imperceptible pace from a slightly overhead perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background extremely blurred with a shallow depth of field, revealing only a dark wood tabletop and distant steam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0031911423429846764 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753190994262695 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0031911423429846764, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0031911423429846764, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15651121735572815, + 0.03605988621711731, + 0.12098521739244461, + 0.045540452003479004, + 0.03563103452324867, + 0.15591317415237427, + 0.032260309904813766, + 0.038855791091918945, + 0.19667768478393555, + 0.18156522512435913 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0031911423429846764 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extremely slow-motion macro close-up, captured from a slightly overhead perspective, focuses on a pair of slender, white hands carefully cradling a creamy white, pebble-shaped electric hand warmer. The hands, with their neatly manicured nails and gentle gestures, seem to be protecting a treasure. The hand warmer's smooth, rounded, matte finish reflects a soft, warm glow under the warm yellow light of the cafe's vintage tungsten lamps, which cast a sideways cast. As the camera zooms in at an almost imperceptible pace, the heat radiating from the hand warmer's surface becomes concrete in the extreme slow motion: the air around it undergoes a visible, transparent distortion, forming gentle ripples that slowly and gracefully rise and dissipate, like heat waves on an asphalt road on a summer afternoon. The background is rendered extremely blurred by a shallow depth of field, barely discernible enough to distinguish the texture of the dark wood tabletop and the curl of steam from a latte in the distance. Together, they create an intimate atmosphere of profound tranquility, warmth, healing, and exquisite detail.", + "seed": 23291, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_11/index_7039_seed_23291_dp_23_rank_46_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.011260304367169738, + "vlm_logprob": -0.011260304367169738, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.875, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.011260304367169738, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of slender, white hands with neatly manicured nails visible cradling an object?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the object being held a creamy white, pebble-shaped electric hand warmer with a smooth, rounded, matte finish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in extreme slow motion showing visible, transparent air ripples rising from the hand warmer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera zoom in at an almost imperceptible pace from a slightly overhead perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background extremely blurred with a shallow depth of field, revealing only a dark wood tabletop and distant steam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006520661525428295 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.131520748138428 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006520661525428295, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006520661525428295, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21429020166397095, + 0.1388280689716339, + 0.04086737334728241, + 0.07119819521903992, + 0.12723754346370697, + 0.04697052016854286, + 0.06959063559770584, + 0.05486106500029564, + 0.10674457252025604, + 0.12941181659698486 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006520661525428295 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of slender, white hands with neatly manicured nails visible cradling an object?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the object being held a creamy white, pebble-shaped electric hand warmer with a smooth, rounded, matte finish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in extreme slow motion showing visible, transparent air ripples rising from the hand warmer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera zoom in at an almost imperceptible pace from a slightly overhead perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background extremely blurred with a shallow depth of field, revealing only a dark wood tabletop and distant steam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005268024746328592 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255268096923828 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005268024746328592, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005268024746328592, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1530851572751999, + 0.07877066731452942, + 0.03245729207992554, + 0.03841589763760567, + 0.182079017162323, + 0.18884466588497162, + 0.03152494877576828, + 0.07716330140829086, + 0.05527129024267197, + 0.16238775849342346 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005268024746328592 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of slender, white hands with neatly manicured nails visible cradling an object?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the object being held a creamy white, pebble-shaped electric hand warmer with a smooth, rounded, matte finish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in extreme slow motion showing visible, transparent air ripples rising from the hand warmer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera zoom in at an almost imperceptible pace from a slightly overhead perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background extremely blurred with a shallow depth of field, revealing only a dark wood tabletop and distant steam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03369452804327011 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4086945056915283 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03369452804327011, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03369452804327011, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20072193443775177, + 0.0613413043320179, + 0.023590989410877228, + 0.035896990448236465, + 0.0653972253203392, + 0.05994030088186264, + 0.0426088385283947, + 0.17215773463249207, + 0.05053601413965225, + 0.2878085970878601 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03369452804327011 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of slender, white hands with neatly manicured nails visible cradling an object?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the object being held a creamy white, pebble-shaped electric hand warmer with a smooth, rounded, matte finish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in extreme slow motion showing visible, transparent air ripples rising from the hand warmer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera zoom in at an almost imperceptible pace from a slightly overhead perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background extremely blurred with a shallow depth of field, revealing only a dark wood tabletop and distant steam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007629304192960262 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.88262939453125 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007629304192960262, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007629304192960262, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14668874442577362, + 0.0968489795923233, + 0.03603793680667877, + 0.1465063989162445, + 0.13305920362472534, + 0.05746474862098694, + 0.047233544290065765, + 0.06205914542078972, + 0.06310281902551651, + 0.2109985202550888 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007629304192960262 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of slender, white hands with neatly manicured nails visible cradling an object?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the object being held a creamy white, pebble-shaped electric hand warmer with a smooth, rounded, matte finish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in extreme slow motion showing visible, transparent air ripples rising from the hand warmer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera zoom in at an almost imperceptible pace from a slightly overhead perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background extremely blurred with a shallow depth of field, revealing only a dark wood tabletop and distant steam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0031890033278614283 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.7531890869140625 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0031890033278614283, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0031890033278614283, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3821944296360016, + 0.14659899473190308, + 0.04038841649889946, + 0.02667183242738247, + 0.17568646371364594, + 0.060667481273412704, + 0.02710115723311901, + 0.030341431498527527, + 0.013724463060498238, + 0.09662535041570663 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0031890033278614283 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extremely slow-motion macro close-up, captured from a slightly overhead perspective, focuses on a pair of slender, white hands carefully cradling a creamy white, pebble-shaped electric hand warmer. The hands, with their neatly manicured nails and gentle gestures, seem to be protecting a treasure. The hand warmer's smooth, rounded, matte finish reflects a soft, warm glow under the warm yellow light of the cafe's vintage tungsten lamps, which cast a sideways cast. As the camera zooms in at an almost imperceptible pace, the heat radiating from the hand warmer's surface becomes concrete in the extreme slow motion: the air around it undergoes a visible, transparent distortion, forming gentle ripples that slowly and gracefully rise and dissipate, like heat waves on an asphalt road on a summer afternoon. The background is rendered extremely blurred by a shallow depth of field, barely discernible enough to distinguish the texture of the dark wood tabletop and the curl of steam from a latte in the distance. Together, they create an intimate atmosphere of profound tranquility, warmth, healing, and exquisite detail.", + "seed": 23292, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_11/index_7039_seed_23292_dp_23_rank_46_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.06605868898332119, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06605868898332119, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.775, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06605868898332119, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of slender, white hands with neatly manicured nails visible cradling an object?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the object being held a creamy white, pebble-shaped electric hand warmer with a smooth, rounded, matte finish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in extreme slow motion showing visible, transparent air ripples rising from the hand warmer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera zoom in at an almost imperceptible pace from a slightly overhead perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background extremely blurred with a shallow depth of field, revealing only a dark wood tabletop and distant steam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016721799969673157 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141721725463867 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016721799969673157, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016721799969673157, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.061114780604839325, + 0.04902440682053566, + 0.07182110846042633, + 0.10612038522958755, + 0.0719335600733757, + 0.07578190416097641, + 0.05623365566134453, + 0.07300756871700287, + 0.05731630325317383, + 0.3776463270187378 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016721799969673157 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of slender, white hands with neatly manicured nails visible cradling an object?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the object being held a creamy white, pebble-shaped electric hand warmer with a smooth, rounded, matte finish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in extreme slow motion showing visible, transparent air ripples rising from the hand warmer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera zoom in at an almost imperceptible pace from a slightly overhead perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background extremely blurred with a shallow depth of field, revealing only a dark wood tabletop and distant steam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011102564632892609 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511102676391602 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011102564632892609, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011102564632892609, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24903495609760284, + 0.12758253514766693, + 0.06417924910783768, + 0.10854312032461166, + 0.028020432218909264, + 0.04186286777257919, + 0.11252786219120026, + 0.05736106261610985, + 0.0782899409532547, + 0.13259796798229218 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011102564632892609 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of slender, white hands with neatly manicured nails visible cradling an object?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the object being held a creamy white, pebble-shaped electric hand warmer with a smooth, rounded, matte finish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in extreme slow motion showing visible, transparent air ripples rising from the hand warmer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera zoom in at an almost imperceptible pace from a slightly overhead perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background extremely blurred with a shallow depth of field, revealing only a dark wood tabletop and distant steam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2812995910644531 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4062995910644531 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2812995910644531, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2812995910644531, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09569196403026581, + 0.059565749019384384, + 0.12405776232481003, + 0.11172205954790115, + 0.16681404411792755, + 0.06785384565591812, + 0.13143539428710938, + 0.08328542113304138, + 0.047030575573444366, + 0.11254321038722992 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2812995910644531 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of slender, white hands with neatly manicured nails visible cradling an object?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the object being held a creamy white, pebble-shaped electric hand warmer with a smooth, rounded, matte finish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in extreme slow motion showing visible, transparent air ripples rising from the hand warmer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera zoom in at an almost imperceptible pace from a slightly overhead perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background extremely blurred with a shallow depth of field, revealing only a dark wood tabletop and distant steam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012536648660898209 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387536525726318 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012536648660898209, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012536648660898209, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12717686593532562, + 0.1256614327430725, + 0.11210323125123978, + 0.07995487749576569, + 0.08782666176557541, + 0.07509248703718185, + 0.04348564147949219, + 0.23181113600730896, + 0.07918225973844528, + 0.03770549222826958 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012536648660898209 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of slender, white hands with neatly manicured nails visible cradling an object?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the object being held a creamy white, pebble-shaped electric hand warmer with a smooth, rounded, matte finish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in extreme slow motion showing visible, transparent air ripples rising from the hand warmer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera zoom in at an almost imperceptible pace from a slightly overhead perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background extremely blurred with a shallow depth of field, revealing only a dark wood tabletop and distant steam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00863284058868885 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758632659912109 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00863284058868885, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00863284058868885, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06013573333621025, + 0.05792994052171707, + 0.14302793145179749, + 0.2020197957754135, + 0.17346592247486115, + 0.11319635063409805, + 0.09196918457746506, + 0.046722184866666794, + 0.042018163949251175, + 0.06951482594013214 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00863284058868885 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_12/index_tensor([1891, 1891])_group_12_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_12/index_tensor([1891, 1891])_group_12_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..418de813c7f990461d6745ebb965ac52c3d6db24 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_12/index_tensor([1891, 1891])_group_12_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "hyperreal 3D rendering captures a time-lapse sequence from a static, low-angle macro shot focused on a desert rose (Adenium obesum). The plant's gnarled, swollen stem base, resembling aged, rugged bark, is firmly rooted in fine, pale, sandy soil. A single, powerful light source moves across the scene, creating dramatic, deep shadows that constantly shift and lengthen, emphasizing the plant's form. As the time-lapse progresses, a single, magnificent flower begins to unfold from a tight bud; its petals, boasting a realistic waxy texture, steadily and gracefully open, revealing a vibrant color gradient from a saturated, deep pink at the edges to a soft, pure white near the flower's throat. Dynamic light flickers from the petals' waxy surface, capturing tiny grains of crystallized sand scattered along the stem and highlighting every minute detail, creating a focused and dramatic atmosphere that celebrates the slow, beautiful spectacle of life.", + "seed": 18721, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_12/index_1891_seed_18721_dp_24_rank_48_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.16074360040947794, + "vlm_logprob": -0.16074360040947794, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.725, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.16074360040947794, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, low-angle macro view focused on a desert rose (Adenium obesum)?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the plant's gnarled, swollen stem base resemble aged, rugged bark rooted in fine, pale, sandy soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a single flower unfold from a tight bud, revealing petals with a realistic waxy texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the flower petals display a color gradient from saturated deep pink at the edges to soft pure white near the throat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a single powerful light source move across the scene, creating shifting deep shadows and highlighting crystallized sand grains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03890403360128403 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4139039516448975 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03890403360128403, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03890403360128403, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16645869612693787, + 0.0712481364607811, + 0.05745351314544678, + 0.13051557540893555, + 0.09589188545942307, + 0.20770232379436493, + 0.02769402787089348, + 0.046424511820077896, + 0.07495434582233429, + 0.12165700644254684 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03890403360128403 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, low-angle macro view focused on a desert rose (Adenium obesum)?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the plant's gnarled, swollen stem base resemble aged, rugged bark rooted in fine, pale, sandy soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a single flower unfold from a tight bud, revealing petals with a realistic waxy texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the flower petals display a color gradient from saturated deep pink at the edges to soft pure white near the throat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a single powerful light source move across the scene, creating shifting deep shadows and highlighting crystallized sand grains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007659116294234991 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882658958435059 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007659116294234991, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007659116294234991, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12086877971887589, + 0.08567538857460022, + 0.03359100967645645, + 0.06876321136951447, + 0.060897666960954666, + 0.4038366377353668, + 0.015406235121190548, + 0.04148745536804199, + 0.060358233749866486, + 0.10911542177200317 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007659116294234991 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, low-angle macro view focused on a desert rose (Adenium obesum)?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the plant's gnarled, swollen stem base resemble aged, rugged bark rooted in fine, pale, sandy soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a single flower unfold from a tight bud, revealing petals with a realistic waxy texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the flower petals display a color gradient from saturated deep pink at the edges to soft pure white near the throat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a single powerful light source move across the scene, creating shifting deep shadows and highlighting crystallized sand grains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.038133904337882996 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881338596343994 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.038133904337882996, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.038133904337882996, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13331130146980286, + 0.08265259116888046, + 0.06561505794525146, + 0.11893384158611298, + 0.05372356250882149, + 0.10548346489667892, + 0.057079508900642395, + 0.06831865012645721, + 0.22060520946979523, + 0.0942767858505249 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.038133904337882996 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, low-angle macro view focused on a desert rose (Adenium obesum)?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the plant's gnarled, swollen stem base resemble aged, rugged bark rooted in fine, pale, sandy soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a single flower unfold from a tight bud, revealing petals with a realistic waxy texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the flower petals display a color gradient from saturated deep pink at the edges to soft pure white near the throat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a single powerful light source move across the scene, creating shifting deep shadows and highlighting crystallized sand grains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1428363174200058 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.017836332321167 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1428363174200058, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1428363174200058, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1231362447142601, + 0.05794421210885048, + 0.03465041518211365, + 0.05480942130088806, + 0.06741359084844589, + 0.2247072011232376, + 0.07608861476182938, + 0.07104665040969849, + 0.19165699183940887, + 0.09854660928249359 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1428363174200058 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, low-angle macro view focused on a desert rose (Adenium obesum)?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the plant's gnarled, swollen stem base resemble aged, rugged bark rooted in fine, pale, sandy soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a single flower unfold from a tight bud, revealing petals with a realistic waxy texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the flower petals display a color gradient from saturated deep pink at the edges to soft pure white near the throat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a single powerful light source move across the scene, creating shifting deep shadows and highlighting crystallized sand grains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5761846303939819 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8261846303939819 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5761846303939819, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5761846303939819, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10746189951896667, + 0.08830556273460388, + 0.059362780302762985, + 0.05968637391924858, + 0.06127014383673668, + 0.27572986483573914, + 0.04056354984641075, + 0.04351351410150528, + 0.15810945630073547, + 0.10599685460329056 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5761846303939819 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "hyperreal 3D rendering captures a time-lapse sequence from a static, low-angle macro shot focused on a desert rose (Adenium obesum). The plant's gnarled, swollen stem base, resembling aged, rugged bark, is firmly rooted in fine, pale, sandy soil. A single, powerful light source moves across the scene, creating dramatic, deep shadows that constantly shift and lengthen, emphasizing the plant's form. As the time-lapse progresses, a single, magnificent flower begins to unfold from a tight bud; its petals, boasting a realistic waxy texture, steadily and gracefully open, revealing a vibrant color gradient from a saturated, deep pink at the edges to a soft, pure white near the flower's throat. Dynamic light flickers from the petals' waxy surface, capturing tiny grains of crystallized sand scattered along the stem and highlighting every minute detail, creating a focused and dramatic atmosphere that celebrates the slow, beautiful spectacle of life.", + "seed": 18722, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_12/index_1891_seed_18722_dp_24_rank_48_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.05845315605401993, + "vlm_logprob": -0.05845315605401993, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.15, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.05845315605401993, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, low-angle macro view focused on a desert rose (Adenium obesum)?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the plant's gnarled, swollen stem base resemble aged, rugged bark rooted in fine, pale, sandy soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a single flower unfold from a tight bud, revealing petals with a realistic waxy texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the flower petals display a color gradient from saturated deep pink at the edges to soft pure white near the throat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a single powerful light source move across the scene, creating shifting deep shadows and highlighting crystallized sand grains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01046727318316698 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.885467052459717 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01046727318316698, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01046727318316698, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17059625685214996, + 0.09732817858457565, + 0.1458704024553299, + 0.15835584700107574, + 0.0729270651936531, + 0.0855008140206337, + 0.08691003918647766, + 0.059706371277570724, + 0.052377551794052124, + 0.07042749226093292 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01046727318316698 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, low-angle macro view focused on a desert rose (Adenium obesum)?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the plant's gnarled, swollen stem base resemble aged, rugged bark rooted in fine, pale, sandy soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a single flower unfold from a tight bud, revealing petals with a realistic waxy texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the flower petals display a color gradient from saturated deep pink at the edges to soft pure white near the throat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a single powerful light source move across the scene, creating shifting deep shadows and highlighting crystallized sand grains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002508828416466713 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002508640289307 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002508828416466713, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002508828416466713, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1439489722251892, + 0.23022718727588654, + 0.1297440230846405, + 0.19860921800136566, + 0.04393872618675232, + 0.050561532378196716, + 0.022185660898685455, + 0.051215820014476776, + 0.06462761014699936, + 0.06494124233722687 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002508828416466713 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, low-angle macro view focused on a desert rose (Adenium obesum)?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the plant's gnarled, swollen stem base resemble aged, rugged bark rooted in fine, pale, sandy soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a single flower unfold from a tight bud, revealing petals with a realistic waxy texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the flower petals display a color gradient from saturated deep pink at the edges to soft pure white near the throat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a single powerful light source move across the scene, creating shifting deep shadows and highlighting crystallized sand grains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011089124716818333 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511089324951172 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011089124716818333, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011089124716818333, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08207182586193085, + 0.05632723122835159, + 0.2365185022354126, + 0.22213079035282135, + 0.04526636749505997, + 0.0788383036851883, + 0.06731902062892914, + 0.1189718246459961, + 0.06242668256163597, + 0.03012937121093273 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011089124716818333 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, low-angle macro view focused on a desert rose (Adenium obesum)?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the plant's gnarled, swollen stem base resemble aged, rugged bark rooted in fine, pale, sandy soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a single flower unfold from a tight bud, revealing petals with a realistic waxy texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the flower petals display a color gradient from saturated deep pink at the edges to soft pure white near the throat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a single powerful light source move across the scene, creating shifting deep shadows and highlighting crystallized sand grains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01607704907655716 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141077041625977 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01607704907655716, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01607704907655716, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13990949094295502, + 0.08392546325922012, + 0.13690006732940674, + 0.08266937732696533, + 0.034740496426820755, + 0.03768014907836914, + 0.05519396439194679, + 0.1690169721841812, + 0.10761751979589462, + 0.15234655141830444 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01607704907655716 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, low-angle macro view focused on a desert rose (Adenium obesum)?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the plant's gnarled, swollen stem base resemble aged, rugged bark rooted in fine, pale, sandy soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a single flower unfold from a tight bud, revealing petals with a realistic waxy texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the flower petals display a color gradient from saturated deep pink at the edges to soft pure white near the throat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a single powerful light source move across the scene, creating shifting deep shadows and highlighting crystallized sand grains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.25212350487709045 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.502123475074768 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.25212350487709045, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.25212350487709045, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08940016478300095, + 0.11168716102838516, + 0.07285967469215393, + 0.10091617703437805, + 0.06396371126174927, + 0.06500917673110962, + 0.07690568268299103, + 0.13052204251289368, + 0.20751629769802094, + 0.08121994137763977 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.25212350487709045 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "hyperreal 3D rendering captures a time-lapse sequence from a static, low-angle macro shot focused on a desert rose (Adenium obesum). The plant's gnarled, swollen stem base, resembling aged, rugged bark, is firmly rooted in fine, pale, sandy soil. A single, powerful light source moves across the scene, creating dramatic, deep shadows that constantly shift and lengthen, emphasizing the plant's form. As the time-lapse progresses, a single, magnificent flower begins to unfold from a tight bud; its petals, boasting a realistic waxy texture, steadily and gracefully open, revealing a vibrant color gradient from a saturated, deep pink at the edges to a soft, pure white near the flower's throat. Dynamic light flickers from the petals' waxy surface, capturing tiny grains of crystallized sand scattered along the stem and highlighting every minute detail, creating a focused and dramatic atmosphere that celebrates the slow, beautiful spectacle of life.", + "seed": 18723, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_12/index_1891_seed_18723_dp_25_rank_50_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.05435443320311606, + "vlm_logprob": -0.05435443320311606, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.2, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.05435443320311606, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, low-angle macro view focused on a desert rose (Adenium obesum)?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the plant's gnarled, swollen stem base resemble aged, rugged bark rooted in fine, pale, sandy soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a single flower unfold from a tight bud, revealing petals with a realistic waxy texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the flower petals display a color gradient from saturated deep pink at the edges to soft pure white near the throat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a single powerful light source move across the scene, creating shifting deep shadows and highlighting crystallized sand grains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014387323521077633 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.889387130737305 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014387323521077633, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014387323521077633, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.35046061873435974, + 0.05627443268895149, + 0.14792078733444214, + 0.06314032524824142, + 0.03912213444709778, + 0.10839622467756271, + 0.02963515929877758, + 0.06304459273815155, + 0.03967279940843582, + 0.10233292728662491 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014387323521077633 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, low-angle macro view focused on a desert rose (Adenium obesum)?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the plant's gnarled, swollen stem base resemble aged, rugged bark rooted in fine, pale, sandy soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a single flower unfold from a tight bud, revealing petals with a realistic waxy texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the flower petals display a color gradient from saturated deep pink at the edges to soft pure white near the throat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a single powerful light source move across the scene, creating shifting deep shadows and highlighting crystallized sand grains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003217878518626094 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753217697143555 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003217878518626094, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003217878518626094, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.6737299561500549, + 0.048400551080703735, + 0.05639999359846115, + 0.04885092377662659, + 0.01753496192395687, + 0.030994273722171783, + 0.015901289880275726, + 0.024665309116244316, + 0.01942005567252636, + 0.0641026571393013 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003217878518626094 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, low-angle macro view focused on a desert rose (Adenium obesum)?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the plant's gnarled, swollen stem base resemble aged, rugged bark rooted in fine, pale, sandy soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a single flower unfold from a tight bud, revealing petals with a realistic waxy texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the flower petals display a color gradient from saturated deep pink at the edges to soft pure white near the throat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a single powerful light source move across the scene, creating shifting deep shadows and highlighting crystallized sand grains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005265416111797094 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255265235900879 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005265416111797094, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005265416111797094, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1438951939344406, + 0.15235011279582977, + 0.05152231082320213, + 0.022104620933532715, + 0.03171836584806442, + 0.1691754162311554, + 0.014640913344919682, + 0.09784713387489319, + 0.22792130708694458, + 0.08882464468479156 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005265416111797094 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, low-angle macro view focused on a desert rose (Adenium obesum)?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the plant's gnarled, swollen stem base resemble aged, rugged bark rooted in fine, pale, sandy soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a single flower unfold from a tight bud, revealing petals with a realistic waxy texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the flower petals display a color gradient from saturated deep pink at the edges to soft pure white near the throat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a single powerful light source move across the scene, creating shifting deep shadows and highlighting crystallized sand grains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023299487307667732 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732994556427 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023299487307667732, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023299487307667732, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.6537832021713257, + 0.026223333552479744, + 0.05749248340725899, + 0.029796503484249115, + 0.022978875786066055, + 0.04979299008846283, + 0.03563065454363823, + 0.042037248611450195, + 0.02306799776852131, + 0.05919663980603218 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023299487307667732 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, low-angle macro view focused on a desert rose (Adenium obesum)?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the plant's gnarled, swollen stem base resemble aged, rugged bark rooted in fine, pale, sandy soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a single flower unfold from a tight bud, revealing petals with a realistic waxy texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the flower petals display a color gradient from saturated deep pink at the edges to soft pure white near the throat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a single powerful light source move across the scene, creating shifting deep shadows and highlighting crystallized sand grains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22560206055641174 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6006020307540894 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.22560206055641174, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.22560206055641174, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3357858955860138, + 0.1297193318605423, + 0.05091378837823868, + 0.03802262619137764, + 0.04591047018766403, + 0.15008841454982758, + 0.17233985662460327, + 0.02039947174489498, + 0.02045069821178913, + 0.03636941686272621 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.22560206055641174 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "hyperreal 3D rendering captures a time-lapse sequence from a static, low-angle macro shot focused on a desert rose (Adenium obesum). The plant's gnarled, swollen stem base, resembling aged, rugged bark, is firmly rooted in fine, pale, sandy soil. A single, powerful light source moves across the scene, creating dramatic, deep shadows that constantly shift and lengthen, emphasizing the plant's form. As the time-lapse progresses, a single, magnificent flower begins to unfold from a tight bud; its petals, boasting a realistic waxy texture, steadily and gracefully open, revealing a vibrant color gradient from a saturated, deep pink at the edges to a soft, pure white near the flower's throat. Dynamic light flickers from the petals' waxy surface, capturing tiny grains of crystallized sand scattered along the stem and highlighting every minute detail, creating a focused and dramatic atmosphere that celebrates the slow, beautiful spectacle of life.", + "seed": 18724, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_12/index_1891_seed_18724_dp_25_rank_50_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.0658982016146183, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0658982016146183, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.575, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0658982016146183, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, low-angle macro view focused on a desert rose (Adenium obesum)?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the plant's gnarled, swollen stem base resemble aged, rugged bark rooted in fine, pale, sandy soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a single flower unfold from a tight bud, revealing petals with a realistic waxy texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the flower petals display a color gradient from saturated deep pink at the edges to soft pure white near the throat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a single powerful light source move across the scene, creating shifting deep shadows and highlighting crystallized sand grains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.025815550237894058 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.150815486907959 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.025815550237894058, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.025815550237894058, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.7581850290298462, + 0.03620369732379913, + 0.029784943908452988, + 0.032696034759283066, + 0.054884009063243866, + 0.017179418355226517, + 0.013604437932372093, + 0.023861242458224297, + 0.01340535469353199, + 0.020195845514535904 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.025815550237894058 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, low-angle macro view focused on a desert rose (Adenium obesum)?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the plant's gnarled, swollen stem base resemble aged, rugged bark rooted in fine, pale, sandy soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a single flower unfold from a tight bud, revealing petals with a realistic waxy texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the flower petals display a color gradient from saturated deep pink at the edges to soft pure white near the throat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a single powerful light source move across the scene, creating shifting deep shadows and highlighting crystallized sand grains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007657341659069061 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882657527923584 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007657341659069061, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007657341659069061, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5464725494384766, + 0.05750959366559982, + 0.015481529757380486, + 0.013411859050393105, + 0.08493504673242569, + 0.019598640501499176, + 0.015964163467288017, + 0.0531064011156559, + 0.13973239064216614, + 0.05378784239292145 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007657341659069061 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, low-angle macro view focused on a desert rose (Adenium obesum)?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the plant's gnarled, swollen stem base resemble aged, rugged bark rooted in fine, pale, sandy soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a single flower unfold from a tight bud, revealing petals with a realistic waxy texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the flower petals display a color gradient from saturated deep pink at the edges to soft pure white near the throat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a single powerful light source move across the scene, creating shifting deep shadows and highlighting crystallized sand grains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020600058138370514 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8956000804901123 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020600058138370514, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020600058138370514, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.42647385597229004, + 0.09895820915699005, + 0.03248784691095352, + 0.05836881697177887, + 0.05880504101514816, + 0.09570979326963425, + 0.029885485768318176, + 0.03096049651503563, + 0.1013387143611908, + 0.06701178103685379 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020600058138370514 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, low-angle macro view focused on a desert rose (Adenium obesum)?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the plant's gnarled, swollen stem base resemble aged, rugged bark rooted in fine, pale, sandy soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a single flower unfold from a tight bud, revealing petals with a realistic waxy texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the flower petals display a color gradient from saturated deep pink at the edges to soft pure white near the throat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a single powerful light source move across the scene, creating shifting deep shadows and highlighting crystallized sand grains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023300185799598694 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7733001708984375 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023300185799598694, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023300185799598694, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3449467718601227, + 0.06275983899831772, + 0.04671141505241394, + 0.10046596080064774, + 0.055531684309244156, + 0.02912892960011959, + 0.041159529238939285, + 0.06214894354343414, + 0.18137283623218536, + 0.07577401399612427 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023300185799598694 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, low-angle macro view focused on a desert rose (Adenium obesum)?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the plant's gnarled, swollen stem base resemble aged, rugged bark rooted in fine, pale, sandy soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a single flower unfold from a tight bud, revealing petals with a realistic waxy texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the flower petals display a color gradient from saturated deep pink at the edges to soft pure white near the throat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a single powerful light source move across the scene, creating shifting deep shadows and highlighting crystallized sand grains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2521178722381592 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5021178722381592 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2521178722381592, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2521178722381592, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5745153427124023, + 0.06282103806734085, + 0.04030766710639, + 0.03002360090613365, + 0.015205577947199345, + 0.07236430048942566, + 0.03913357853889465, + 0.06659156084060669, + 0.04139314964413643, + 0.057644158601760864 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2521178722381592 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_13/index_tensor([4883, 4883])_group_13_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_13/index_tensor([4883, 4883])_group_13_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..dfa2179cd54c6632a7be1b1fe18e446724955d93 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_13/index_tensor([4883, 4883])_group_13_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "full-body, horizontal tracking shot follows a sleek, multi-rotor manned aircraft as it travels at a steady pace, on a straight course, from left to right through a nighttime urban canyon shrouded in torrential rain. Towering skyscrapers, with a distinctly pixelated texture, appear to be composed of giant, glowing blocks, their surfaces gleaming with low-resolution, animated advertisements. The aircraft's dark, composite hue gleams clammy in the rain, its outline sharply illuminated by the bright blue and magenta neon strips etched across its fuselage. As it advances, these neon lights cast long, digital-like trails through the humid air, hovering briefly between the pixelated buildings. The dense stream of rain streaks across the camera, intertwining with the equally pixelated, flickering lights of billboards atop the massive buildings in the background, blurring distant details. The scene is dominated by deep blue and purple hues, creating a cyberpunk atmosphere that feels both retro and futuristic, steeped in the aesthetics of 8-bit video games.", + "seed": 5496, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_13/index_4883_seed_5496_dp_26_rank_52_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.06691727205179632, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06691727205179632, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.35, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06691727205179632, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, multi-rotor manned aircraft traveling at a steady pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a nighttime urban canyon with towering skyscrapers featuring a distinctly pixelated texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene characterized by torrential rain with streaks crossing the camera and deep blue and purple hues?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the aircraft display bright blue and magenta neon strips on its fuselage casting long digital-like trails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a horizontal tracking shot moving from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1623457819223404 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9123457670211792 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1623457819223404, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1623457819223404, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0711783617734909, + 0.10241817682981491, + 0.03835184499621391, + 0.04265416041016579, + 0.022302720695734024, + 0.1082388386130333, + 0.43848124146461487, + 0.07005908340215683, + 0.056021153926849365, + 0.05029444023966789 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1623457819223404 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, multi-rotor manned aircraft traveling at a steady pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a nighttime urban canyon with towering skyscrapers featuring a distinctly pixelated texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene characterized by torrential rain with streaks crossing the camera and deep blue and purple hues?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the aircraft display bright blue and magenta neon strips on its fuselage casting long digital-like trails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a horizontal tracking shot moving from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026347355917096138 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513473987579346 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026347355917096138, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026347355917096138, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.264067143201828, + 0.06297177821397781, + 0.027327178046107292, + 0.03271003067493439, + 0.02927624247968197, + 0.0934147834777832, + 0.33711469173431396, + 0.07305590808391571, + 0.04693613573908806, + 0.033126115798950195 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026347355917096138 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, multi-rotor manned aircraft traveling at a steady pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a nighttime urban canyon with towering skyscrapers featuring a distinctly pixelated texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene characterized by torrential rain with streaks crossing the camera and deep blue and purple hues?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the aircraft display bright blue and magenta neon strips on its fuselage casting long digital-like trails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a horizontal tracking shot moving from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029804455116391182 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298044681549072 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029804455116391182, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029804455116391182, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1964409500360489, + 0.050199318677186966, + 0.06232867017388344, + 0.1521448940038681, + 0.04535127058625221, + 0.12233151495456696, + 0.2540660798549652, + 0.03672151267528534, + 0.03708289563655853, + 0.04333290457725525 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029804455116391182 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, multi-rotor manned aircraft traveling at a steady pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a nighttime urban canyon with towering skyscrapers featuring a distinctly pixelated texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene characterized by torrential rain with streaks crossing the camera and deep blue and purple hues?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the aircraft display bright blue and magenta neon strips on its fuselage casting long digital-like trails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a horizontal tracking shot moving from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003194113029167056 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753194332122803 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003194113029167056, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003194113029167056, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05824004486203194, + 0.037771716713905334, + 0.022424491122364998, + 0.039747338742017746, + 0.029245857149362564, + 0.04294805973768234, + 0.6891293525695801, + 0.032030053436756134, + 0.01840389519929886, + 0.030059201642870903 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003194113029167056 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, multi-rotor manned aircraft traveling at a steady pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a nighttime urban canyon with towering skyscrapers featuring a distinctly pixelated texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene characterized by torrential rain with streaks crossing the camera and deep blue and purple hues?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the aircraft display bright blue and magenta neon strips on its fuselage casting long digital-like trails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a horizontal tracking shot moving from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11289465427398682 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2378945350646973 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11289465427398682, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11289465427398682, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.044566426426172256, + 0.030723759904503822, + 0.010159013792872429, + 0.033601049333810806, + 0.011138616129755974, + 0.027281539514660835, + 0.8051639199256897, + 0.013389053754508495, + 0.005669091362506151, + 0.01830756664276123 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11289465427398682 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "full-body, horizontal tracking shot follows a sleek, multi-rotor manned aircraft as it travels at a steady pace, on a straight course, from left to right through a nighttime urban canyon shrouded in torrential rain. Towering skyscrapers, with a distinctly pixelated texture, appear to be composed of giant, glowing blocks, their surfaces gleaming with low-resolution, animated advertisements. The aircraft's dark, composite hue gleams clammy in the rain, its outline sharply illuminated by the bright blue and magenta neon strips etched across its fuselage. As it advances, these neon lights cast long, digital-like trails through the humid air, hovering briefly between the pixelated buildings. The dense stream of rain streaks across the camera, intertwining with the equally pixelated, flickering lights of billboards atop the massive buildings in the background, blurring distant details. The scene is dominated by deep blue and purple hues, creating a cyberpunk atmosphere that feels both retro and futuristic, steeped in the aesthetics of 8-bit video games.", + "seed": 5497, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_13/index_4883_seed_5497_dp_26_rank_52_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.10976632242091, + "vlm_logprob": -0.10976632242091, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.224999988079071, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.10976632242091, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, multi-rotor manned aircraft traveling at a steady pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a nighttime urban canyon with towering skyscrapers featuring a distinctly pixelated texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene characterized by torrential rain with streaks crossing the camera and deep blue and purple hues?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the aircraft display bright blue and magenta neon strips on its fuselage casting long digital-like trails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a horizontal tracking shot moving from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3182712197303772 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3182711601257324 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3182712197303772, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.9999999403953552, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3182712197303772, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0781853199005127, + 0.040065422654151917, + 0.4905492961406708, + 0.03131968155503273, + 0.09624414891004562, + 0.07668589055538177, + 0.11624212563037872, + 0.02875685691833496, + 0.023211179301142693, + 0.01874002255499363 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3182712197303772 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, multi-rotor manned aircraft traveling at a steady pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a nighttime urban canyon with towering skyscrapers featuring a distinctly pixelated texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene characterized by torrential rain with streaks crossing the camera and deep blue and purple hues?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the aircraft display bright blue and magenta neon strips on its fuselage casting long digital-like trails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a horizontal tracking shot moving from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0336962565779686 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408696174621582 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0336962565779686, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0336962565779686, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15860667824745178, + 0.05497264117002487, + 0.33420491218566895, + 0.0493185929954052, + 0.05907631292939186, + 0.07215885818004608, + 0.15231160819530487, + 0.04206468164920807, + 0.042679574340581894, + 0.03460617735981941 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0336962565779686 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, multi-rotor manned aircraft traveling at a steady pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a nighttime urban canyon with towering skyscrapers featuring a distinctly pixelated texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene characterized by torrential rain with streaks crossing the camera and deep blue and purple hues?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the aircraft display bright blue and magenta neon strips on its fuselage casting long digital-like trails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a horizontal tracking shot moving from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014196004718542099 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264195919036865 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014196004718542099, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014196004718542099, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12552350759506226, + 0.04749953746795654, + 0.22361575067043304, + 0.024596020579338074, + 0.1333235800266266, + 0.05355453118681908, + 0.19708393514156342, + 0.1123376190662384, + 0.06848932802677155, + 0.013976161368191242 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014196004718542099 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, multi-rotor manned aircraft traveling at a steady pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a nighttime urban canyon with towering skyscrapers featuring a distinctly pixelated texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene characterized by torrential rain with streaks crossing the camera and deep blue and purple hues?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the aircraft display bright blue and magenta neon strips on its fuselage casting long digital-like trails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a horizontal tracking shot moving from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0028208012226969004 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.87782096862793 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0028208012226969004, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0028208012226969004, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11459168046712875, + 0.034735389053821564, + 0.381268709897995, + 0.03986851125955582, + 0.13524454832077026, + 0.038134295493364334, + 0.17463496327400208, + 0.028571462258696556, + 0.01206835638731718, + 0.04088204354047775 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0028208012226969004 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, multi-rotor manned aircraft traveling at a steady pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a nighttime urban canyon with towering skyscrapers featuring a distinctly pixelated texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene characterized by torrential rain with streaks crossing the camera and deep blue and purple hues?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the aircraft display bright blue and magenta neon strips on its fuselage casting long digital-like trails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a horizontal tracking shot moving from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1798473298549652 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8048473596572876 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1798473298549652, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1798473298549652, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.048947498202323914, + 0.04255435988306999, + 0.21265366673469543, + 0.020176183432340622, + 0.34452587366104126, + 0.0771246999502182, + 0.08834032714366913, + 0.11599588394165039, + 0.03049052134156227, + 0.019190963357686996 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 2, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1798473298549652 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "full-body, horizontal tracking shot follows a sleek, multi-rotor manned aircraft as it travels at a steady pace, on a straight course, from left to right through a nighttime urban canyon shrouded in torrential rain. Towering skyscrapers, with a distinctly pixelated texture, appear to be composed of giant, glowing blocks, their surfaces gleaming with low-resolution, animated advertisements. The aircraft's dark, composite hue gleams clammy in the rain, its outline sharply illuminated by the bright blue and magenta neon strips etched across its fuselage. As it advances, these neon lights cast long, digital-like trails through the humid air, hovering briefly between the pixelated buildings. The dense stream of rain streaks across the camera, intertwining with the equally pixelated, flickering lights of billboards atop the massive buildings in the background, blurring distant details. The scene is dominated by deep blue and purple hues, creating a cyberpunk atmosphere that feels both retro and futuristic, steeped in the aesthetics of 8-bit video games.", + "seed": 5498, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_13/index_4883_seed_5498_dp_27_rank_54_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.2869100760202855, + "vlm_logprob": -0.2869100760202855, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.55, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.2869100760202855, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, multi-rotor manned aircraft traveling at a steady pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a nighttime urban canyon with towering skyscrapers featuring a distinctly pixelated texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene characterized by torrential rain with streaks crossing the camera and deep blue and purple hues?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the aircraft display bright blue and magenta neon strips on its fuselage casting long digital-like trails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a horizontal tracking shot moving from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1379601955413818 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.38796019554138184 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.1379601955413818, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -1.1379601955413818, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09621812403202057, + 0.037112247198820114, + 0.050965771079063416, + 0.5394116640090942, + 0.0737227275967598, + 0.026134951040148735, + 0.012699556536972523, + 0.08678673952817917, + 0.03907226398587227, + 0.03787597641348839 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.1379601955413818 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, multi-rotor manned aircraft traveling at a steady pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a nighttime urban canyon with towering skyscrapers featuring a distinctly pixelated texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene characterized by torrential rain with streaks crossing the camera and deep blue and purple hues?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the aircraft display bright blue and magenta neon strips on its fuselage casting long digital-like trails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a horizontal tracking shot moving from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06205511838197708 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120551109313965 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06205511838197708, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06205511838197708, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2070131003856659, + 0.1730954349040985, + 0.0712052658200264, + 0.2933236062526703, + 0.09812340885400772, + 0.03472243994474411, + 0.03399498015642166, + 0.03743680566549301, + 0.015245376154780388, + 0.03583959490060806 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06205511838197708 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, multi-rotor manned aircraft traveling at a steady pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a nighttime urban canyon with towering skyscrapers featuring a distinctly pixelated texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene characterized by torrential rain with streaks crossing the camera and deep blue and purple hues?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the aircraft display bright blue and magenta neon strips on its fuselage casting long digital-like trails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a horizontal tracking shot moving from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029810123145580292 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298101902008057 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029810123145580292, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029810123145580292, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10360891371965408, + 0.13064518570899963, + 0.07144403457641602, + 0.27096739411354065, + 0.07160315662622452, + 0.08530890196561813, + 0.08316469937562943, + 0.07865355908870697, + 0.033948954194784164, + 0.0706552267074585 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029810123145580292 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, multi-rotor manned aircraft traveling at a steady pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a nighttime urban canyon with towering skyscrapers featuring a distinctly pixelated texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene characterized by torrential rain with streaks crossing the camera and deep blue and purple hues?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the aircraft display bright blue and magenta neon strips on its fuselage casting long digital-like trails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a horizontal tracking shot moving from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003193875541910529 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.7531938552856445 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003193875541910529, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003193875541910529, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09295785427093506, + 0.09937091171741486, + 0.05210927501320839, + 0.43766865134239197, + 0.08616021275520325, + 0.022462328895926476, + 0.03698315843939781, + 0.08074972033500671, + 0.038220085203647614, + 0.0533178485929966 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003193875541910529 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, multi-rotor manned aircraft traveling at a steady pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a nighttime urban canyon with towering skyscrapers featuring a distinctly pixelated texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene characterized by torrential rain with streaks crossing the camera and deep blue and purple hues?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the aircraft display bright blue and magenta neon strips on its fuselage casting long digital-like trails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a horizontal tracking shot moving from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2015310674905777 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7015310525894165 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2015310674905777, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2015310674905777, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1423000693321228, + 0.20180216431617737, + 0.07242420315742493, + 0.17739121615886688, + 0.06966464966535568, + 0.040734946727752686, + 0.06339751183986664, + 0.12390286475419998, + 0.06192201003432274, + 0.046460337936878204 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2015310674905777 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "full-body, horizontal tracking shot follows a sleek, multi-rotor manned aircraft as it travels at a steady pace, on a straight course, from left to right through a nighttime urban canyon shrouded in torrential rain. Towering skyscrapers, with a distinctly pixelated texture, appear to be composed of giant, glowing blocks, their surfaces gleaming with low-resolution, animated advertisements. The aircraft's dark, composite hue gleams clammy in the rain, its outline sharply illuminated by the bright blue and magenta neon strips etched across its fuselage. As it advances, these neon lights cast long, digital-like trails through the humid air, hovering briefly between the pixelated buildings. The dense stream of rain streaks across the camera, intertwining with the equally pixelated, flickering lights of billboards atop the massive buildings in the background, blurring distant details. The scene is dominated by deep blue and purple hues, creating a cyberpunk atmosphere that feels both retro and futuristic, steeped in the aesthetics of 8-bit video games.", + "seed": 5499, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_13/index_4883_seed_5499_dp_27_rank_54_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.11672550491057336, + "vlm_logprob": -0.11672550491057336, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.45, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.11672550491057336, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, multi-rotor manned aircraft traveling at a steady pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a nighttime urban canyon with towering skyscrapers featuring a distinctly pixelated texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene characterized by torrential rain with streaks crossing the camera and deep blue and purple hues?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the aircraft display bright blue and magenta neon strips on its fuselage casting long digital-like trails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a horizontal tracking shot moving from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.35112425684928894 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2261242866516113 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.35112425684928894, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.35112425684928894, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11018671095371246, + 0.08184155076742172, + 0.04978081211447716, + 0.1388583779335022, + 0.09758555889129639, + 0.041767459362745285, + 0.118451789021492, + 0.13885597884655, + 0.11569005250930786, + 0.10698164999485016 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.35112425684928894 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, multi-rotor manned aircraft traveling at a steady pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a nighttime urban canyon with towering skyscrapers featuring a distinctly pixelated texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene characterized by torrential rain with streaks crossing the camera and deep blue and purple hues?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the aircraft display bright blue and magenta neon strips on its fuselage casting long digital-like trails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a horizontal tracking shot moving from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036162238102406263 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.6286163330078125 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036162238102406263, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036162238102406263, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21438845992088318, + 0.05634266510605812, + 0.06676830351352692, + 0.05978574976325035, + 0.03109596110880375, + 0.07851406931877136, + 0.03775864467024803, + 0.056338392198085785, + 0.2386854887008667, + 0.16032232344150543 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036162238102406263 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, multi-rotor manned aircraft traveling at a steady pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a nighttime urban canyon with towering skyscrapers featuring a distinctly pixelated texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene characterized by torrential rain with streaks crossing the camera and deep blue and purple hues?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the aircraft display bright blue and magenta neon strips on its fuselage casting long digital-like trails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a horizontal tracking shot moving from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023288540542125702 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732884883880615 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023288540542125702, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023288540542125702, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11539802700281143, + 0.07394099235534668, + 0.06774168461561203, + 0.11232613027095795, + 0.038788020610809326, + 0.05153287202119827, + 0.043046899139881134, + 0.2182350605726242, + 0.11143963783979416, + 0.1675507128238678 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023288540542125702 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, multi-rotor manned aircraft traveling at a steady pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a nighttime urban canyon with towering skyscrapers featuring a distinctly pixelated texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene characterized by torrential rain with streaks crossing the camera and deep blue and purple hues?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the aircraft display bright blue and magenta neon strips on its fuselage casting long digital-like trails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a horizontal tracking shot moving from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004093363881111145 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504093170166016 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004093363881111145, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004093363881111145, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1077817976474762, + 0.13408257067203522, + 0.08249756693840027, + 0.04141358658671379, + 0.08345133066177368, + 0.11948937922716141, + 0.07503895461559296, + 0.178108811378479, + 0.05043337866663933, + 0.12770257890224457 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004093363881111145 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, multi-rotor manned aircraft traveling at a steady pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a nighttime urban canyon with towering skyscrapers featuring a distinctly pixelated texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene characterized by torrential rain with streaks crossing the camera and deep blue and purple hues?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the aircraft display bright blue and magenta neon strips on its fuselage casting long digital-like trails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a horizontal tracking shot moving from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2015051394701004 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.701505184173584 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2015051394701004, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2015051394701004, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10557354986667633, + 0.09600909054279327, + 0.04116344451904297, + 0.083645299077034, + 0.06398502737283707, + 0.10370249301195145, + 0.05263466387987137, + 0.05386044457554817, + 0.06902401894330978, + 0.3304020166397095 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2015051394701004 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_14/index_tensor([287, 287])_group_14_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_14/index_tensor([287, 287])_group_14_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..14be409ded10f65a4d6bbdf8a0824fb47c0f5b8c --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_14/index_tensor([287, 287])_group_14_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "In the style of Ghibli animation, a sweeping wide shot, like that from a low-flying drone, glides gracefully across a vast expanse of sun-drenched, rolling meadows. The camera slowly pans right, revealing a massive, hill-sized pumpkin perched in the center of the field, its vibrant orange rind deeply grooved and textured with a soft, painterly texture. The pumpkin is meticulously carved into a rustic, whimsical house, with a small, round wooden door and several circular windows. Flanked by dense, leafy green vines, they curl around a curving, chimney-like stem at the top. The entire scene is bathed in warm, golden afternoon light, casting long, soft shadows across the tall, emerald green grass, which sways hypnotically in the breeze. A massive, sea urchin-like creature, curled up asleep on the pumpkin's roof; its spines are not sharp but soft and plush, like velvety tendrils covered in a layer of delicate green moss. As the camera settles into position, the creature begins to stir, slowly and deliberately emerging from its slumber. Its mossy spine trembles gently, and then its body unfolds section by section, a gentle and peaceful awakening that perfectly captures the serene and magical atmosphere.", + "seed": 11781, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_14/index_287_seed_11781_dp_28_rank_56_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.6313575260341168, + "vlm_logprob": -0.6313575260341168, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.0, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.6313575260341168, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.6, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast expanse of sun-drenched, rolling meadows with tall emerald green grass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, hill-sized pumpkin carved into a rustic house with a wooden door and circular windows visible in the center of the field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, sea urchin-like creature with soft, plush, moss-covered spines sleeping on the pumpkin's roof?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the creature slowly emerge from its slumber by unfolding its body section by section?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a sweeping wide shot and slowly pan right before settling into position?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6343972682952881 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7593972682952881 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.6343972682952881, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.6343972682952881, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18418462574481964, + 0.044697314500808716, + 0.03171204403042793, + 0.028652571141719818, + 0.02716539241373539, + 0.017103245481848717, + 0.11861567944288254, + 0.04535931348800659, + 0.09615682065486908, + 0.4063529670238495 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.6343972682952881 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast expanse of sun-drenched, rolling meadows with tall emerald green grass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, hill-sized pumpkin carved into a rustic house with a wooden door and circular windows visible in the center of the field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, sea urchin-like creature with soft, plush, moss-covered spines sleeping on the pumpkin's roof?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the creature slowly emerge from its slumber by unfolding its body section by section?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a sweeping wide shot and slowly pan right before settling into position?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1371017694473267 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3871017396450043 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.1371017694473267, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -1.1371017694473267, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10731451958417892, + 0.0837007388472557, + 0.03918428346514702, + 0.05192023143172264, + 0.0458771213889122, + 0.09696025401353836, + 0.1151273101568222, + 0.11145245283842087, + 0.13605695962905884, + 0.21240609884262085 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.1371017694473267 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast expanse of sun-drenched, rolling meadows with tall emerald green grass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, hill-sized pumpkin carved into a rustic house with a wooden door and circular windows visible in the center of the field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, sea urchin-like creature with soft, plush, moss-covered spines sleeping on the pumpkin's roof?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the creature slowly emerge from its slumber by unfolding its body section by section?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a sweeping wide shot and slowly pan right before settling into position?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03374984860420227 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.40874981880188 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03374984860420227, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03374984860420227, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17686660587787628, + 0.04955580085515976, + 0.036337852478027344, + 0.049802668392658234, + 0.039805348962545395, + 0.155748650431633, + 0.19043445587158203, + 0.10661624372005463, + 0.13074877858161926, + 0.06408360600471497 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03374984860420227 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast expanse of sun-drenched, rolling meadows with tall emerald green grass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, hill-sized pumpkin carved into a rustic house with a wooden door and circular windows visible in the center of the field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, sea urchin-like creature with soft, plush, moss-covered spines sleeping on the pumpkin's roof?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the creature slowly emerge from its slumber by unfolding its body section by section?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a sweeping wide shot and slowly pan right before settling into position?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03812679275870323 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881267070770264 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03812679275870323, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03812679275870323, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12622319161891937, + 0.03651270642876625, + 0.041151128709316254, + 0.028924785554409027, + 0.049714114516973495, + 0.05157102271914482, + 0.23045316338539124, + 0.15068934857845306, + 0.04441676661372185, + 0.24034380912780762 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03812679275870323 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast expanse of sun-drenched, rolling meadows with tall emerald green grass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, hill-sized pumpkin carved into a rustic house with a wooden door and circular windows visible in the center of the field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, sea urchin-like creature with soft, plush, moss-covered spines sleeping on the pumpkin's roof?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the creature slowly emerge from its slumber by unfolding its body section by section?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a sweeping wide shot and slowly pan right before settling into position?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3134119510650635 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3134118914604187 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.3134119510650635, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -1.3134119510650635, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12045781314373016, + 0.07840826362371445, + 0.0337793305516243, + 0.03383064270019531, + 0.048077087849378586, + 0.10047704726457596, + 0.16574455797672272, + 0.08219891786575317, + 0.08950059115886688, + 0.24752575159072876 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.3134119510650635 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In the style of Ghibli animation, a sweeping wide shot, like that from a low-flying drone, glides gracefully across a vast expanse of sun-drenched, rolling meadows. The camera slowly pans right, revealing a massive, hill-sized pumpkin perched in the center of the field, its vibrant orange rind deeply grooved and textured with a soft, painterly texture. The pumpkin is meticulously carved into a rustic, whimsical house, with a small, round wooden door and several circular windows. Flanked by dense, leafy green vines, they curl around a curving, chimney-like stem at the top. The entire scene is bathed in warm, golden afternoon light, casting long, soft shadows across the tall, emerald green grass, which sways hypnotically in the breeze. A massive, sea urchin-like creature, curled up asleep on the pumpkin's roof; its spines are not sharp but soft and plush, like velvety tendrils covered in a layer of delicate green moss. As the camera settles into position, the creature begins to stir, slowly and deliberately emerging from its slumber. Its mossy spine trembles gently, and then its body unfolds section by section, a gentle and peaceful awakening that perfectly captures the serene and magical atmosphere.", + "seed": 11782, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_14/index_287_seed_11782_dp_28_rank_56_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.19617589861154555, + "vlm_logprob": -0.19617589861154555, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.5, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.19617589861154555, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast expanse of sun-drenched, rolling meadows with tall emerald green grass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, hill-sized pumpkin carved into a rustic house with a wooden door and circular windows visible in the center of the field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, sea urchin-like creature with soft, plush, moss-covered spines sleeping on the pumpkin's roof?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the creature slowly emerge from its slumber by unfolding its body section by section?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a sweeping wide shot and slowly pan right before settling into position?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.021245751529932022 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8962457180023193 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.021245751529932022, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.021245751529932022, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2613475024700165, + 0.05675474926829338, + 0.03508955240249634, + 0.036332085728645325, + 0.2957562208175659, + 0.05095991492271423, + 0.03674151748418808, + 0.022526569664478302, + 0.030181773006916046, + 0.17431014776229858 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.021245751529932022 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast expanse of sun-drenched, rolling meadows with tall emerald green grass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, hill-sized pumpkin carved into a rustic house with a wooden door and circular windows visible in the center of the field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, sea urchin-like creature with soft, plush, moss-covered spines sleeping on the pumpkin's roof?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the creature slowly emerge from its slumber by unfolding its body section by section?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a sweeping wide shot and slowly pan right before settling into position?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.048696450889110565 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048696517944336 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.048696450889110565, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.048696450889110565, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11601106822490692, + 0.06467834860086441, + 0.05309072136878967, + 0.060760438442230225, + 0.13796328008174896, + 0.07809166610240936, + 0.08702301979064941, + 0.0329132005572319, + 0.15927919745445251, + 0.21018898487091064 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.048696450889110565 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast expanse of sun-drenched, rolling meadows with tall emerald green grass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, hill-sized pumpkin carved into a rustic house with a wooden door and circular windows visible in the center of the field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, sea urchin-like creature with soft, plush, moss-covered spines sleeping on the pumpkin's roof?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the creature slowly emerge from its slumber by unfolding its body section by section?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a sweeping wide shot and slowly pan right before settling into position?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01608232781291008 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141082286834717 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01608232781291008, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01608232781291008, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09669142961502075, + 0.04580047354102135, + 0.03274312615394592, + 0.1207229346036911, + 0.18778622150421143, + 0.027888216078281403, + 0.26677757501602173, + 0.0684145987033844, + 0.06150666996836662, + 0.0916687548160553 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01608232781291008 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast expanse of sun-drenched, rolling meadows with tall emerald green grass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, hill-sized pumpkin carved into a rustic house with a wooden door and circular windows visible in the center of the field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, sea urchin-like creature with soft, plush, moss-covered spines sleeping on the pumpkin's roof?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the creature slowly emerge from its slumber by unfolding its body section by section?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a sweeping wide shot and slowly pan right before settling into position?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20155328512191772 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7015533447265625 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20155328512191772, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20155328512191772, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16822850704193115, + 0.04779842123389244, + 0.06277109682559967, + 0.07181119918823242, + 0.15850283205509186, + 0.038604043424129486, + 0.3212980031967163, + 0.06995636224746704, + 0.0300641730427742, + 0.030965395271778107 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20155328512191772 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast expanse of sun-drenched, rolling meadows with tall emerald green grass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, hill-sized pumpkin carved into a rustic house with a wooden door and circular windows visible in the center of the field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, sea urchin-like creature with soft, plush, moss-covered spines sleeping on the pumpkin's roof?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the creature slowly emerge from its slumber by unfolding its body section by section?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a sweeping wide shot and slowly pan right before settling into position?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6933016777038574 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6933016777038574 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.6933016777038574, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.6933016777038574, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3118401765823364, + 0.08120835572481155, + 0.06950747221708298, + 0.13526472449302673, + 0.10406932234764099, + 0.08862441033124924, + 0.06760435551404953, + 0.043512262403964996, + 0.021479124203324318, + 0.076889768242836 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.6933016777038574 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In the style of Ghibli animation, a sweeping wide shot, like that from a low-flying drone, glides gracefully across a vast expanse of sun-drenched, rolling meadows. The camera slowly pans right, revealing a massive, hill-sized pumpkin perched in the center of the field, its vibrant orange rind deeply grooved and textured with a soft, painterly texture. The pumpkin is meticulously carved into a rustic, whimsical house, with a small, round wooden door and several circular windows. Flanked by dense, leafy green vines, they curl around a curving, chimney-like stem at the top. The entire scene is bathed in warm, golden afternoon light, casting long, soft shadows across the tall, emerald green grass, which sways hypnotically in the breeze. A massive, sea urchin-like creature, curled up asleep on the pumpkin's roof; its spines are not sharp but soft and plush, like velvety tendrils covered in a layer of delicate green moss. As the camera settles into position, the creature begins to stir, slowly and deliberately emerging from its slumber. Its mossy spine trembles gently, and then its body unfolds section by section, a gentle and peaceful awakening that perfectly captures the serene and magical atmosphere.", + "seed": 11783, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_14/index_287_seed_11783_dp_29_rank_58_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.20465172422118486, + "vlm_logprob": -0.20465172422118486, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.0, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.20465172422118486, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast expanse of sun-drenched, rolling meadows with tall emerald green grass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, hill-sized pumpkin carved into a rustic house with a wooden door and circular windows visible in the center of the field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, sea urchin-like creature with soft, plush, moss-covered spines sleeping on the pumpkin's roof?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the creature slowly emerge from its slumber by unfolding its body section by section?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a sweeping wide shot and slowly pan right before settling into position?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023750683292746544 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7737507820129395 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023750683292746544, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023750683292746544, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2645379602909088, + 0.2602745294570923, + 0.0332229882478714, + 0.02440759912133217, + 0.051561880856752396, + 0.04651275649666786, + 0.01178611908107996, + 0.13230451941490173, + 0.06297468394041061, + 0.11241701990365982 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023750683292746544 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast expanse of sun-drenched, rolling meadows with tall emerald green grass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, hill-sized pumpkin carved into a rustic house with a wooden door and circular windows visible in the center of the field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, sea urchin-like creature with soft, plush, moss-covered spines sleeping on the pumpkin's roof?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the creature slowly emerge from its slumber by unfolding its body section by section?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a sweeping wide shot and slowly pan right before settling into position?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036340404767543077 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628633975982666 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036340404767543077, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036340404767543077, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12481613457202911, + 0.08389458805322647, + 0.033768415451049805, + 0.020027395337820053, + 0.04385434463620186, + 0.03977499157190323, + 0.006358427926898003, + 0.4145536720752716, + 0.1765703707933426, + 0.056381627917289734 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036340404767543077 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast expanse of sun-drenched, rolling meadows with tall emerald green grass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, hill-sized pumpkin carved into a rustic house with a wooden door and circular windows visible in the center of the field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, sea urchin-like creature with soft, plush, moss-covered spines sleeping on the pumpkin's roof?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the creature slowly emerge from its slumber by unfolding its body section by section?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a sweeping wide shot and slowly pan right before settling into position?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012544064782559872 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.38754415512085 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012544064782559872, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012544064782559872, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09574772417545319, + 0.05649831146001816, + 0.019460225477814674, + 0.02538197673857212, + 0.06230832263827324, + 0.019229311496019363, + 0.021234190091490746, + 0.6360598206520081, + 0.027208460494875908, + 0.03687170520424843 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012544064782559872 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast expanse of sun-drenched, rolling meadows with tall emerald green grass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, hill-sized pumpkin carved into a rustic house with a wooden door and circular windows visible in the center of the field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, sea urchin-like creature with soft, plush, moss-covered spines sleeping on the pumpkin's roof?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the creature slowly emerge from its slumber by unfolding its body section by section?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a sweeping wide shot and slowly pan right before settling into position?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22557437419891357 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6005743741989136 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.22557437419891357, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.22557437419891357, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03412657976150513, + 0.02686387673020363, + 0.029766928404569626, + 0.03261041268706322, + 0.023542534559965134, + 0.014788986183702946, + 0.007160224486142397, + 0.7786250114440918, + 0.02557181753218174, + 0.02694355510175228 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.22557437419891357 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast expanse of sun-drenched, rolling meadows with tall emerald green grass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, hill-sized pumpkin carved into a rustic house with a wooden door and circular windows visible in the center of the field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, sea urchin-like creature with soft, plush, moss-covered spines sleeping on the pumpkin's roof?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the creature slowly emerge from its slumber by unfolding its body section by section?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a sweeping wide shot and slowly pan right before settling into position?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.75775545835495 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.63275545835495 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.75775545835495, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.75775545835495, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14025527238845825, + 0.0719885602593422, + 0.026101479306817055, + 0.028333567082881927, + 0.04939031973481178, + 0.015419685281813145, + 0.048345983028411865, + 0.52806556224823, + 0.028892232105135918, + 0.06320733577013016 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.75775545835495 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In the style of Ghibli animation, a sweeping wide shot, like that from a low-flying drone, glides gracefully across a vast expanse of sun-drenched, rolling meadows. The camera slowly pans right, revealing a massive, hill-sized pumpkin perched in the center of the field, its vibrant orange rind deeply grooved and textured with a soft, painterly texture. The pumpkin is meticulously carved into a rustic, whimsical house, with a small, round wooden door and several circular windows. Flanked by dense, leafy green vines, they curl around a curving, chimney-like stem at the top. The entire scene is bathed in warm, golden afternoon light, casting long, soft shadows across the tall, emerald green grass, which sways hypnotically in the breeze. A massive, sea urchin-like creature, curled up asleep on the pumpkin's roof; its spines are not sharp but soft and plush, like velvety tendrils covered in a layer of delicate green moss. As the camera settles into position, the creature begins to stir, slowly and deliberately emerging from its slumber. Its mossy spine trembles gently, and then its body unfolds section by section, a gentle and peaceful awakening that perfectly captures the serene and magical atmosphere.", + "seed": 11784, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_14/index_287_seed_11784_dp_29_rank_58_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.2481925528496504, + "vlm_logprob": -0.2481925528496504, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.45, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.2481925528496504, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast expanse of sun-drenched, rolling meadows with tall emerald green grass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, hill-sized pumpkin carved into a rustic house with a wooden door and circular windows visible in the center of the field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, sea urchin-like creature with soft, plush, moss-covered spines sleeping on the pumpkin's roof?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the creature slowly emerge from its slumber by unfolding its body section by section?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a sweeping wide shot and slowly pan right before settling into position?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0798097625374794 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5798096656799316 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0798097625374794, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0798097625374794, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08028435707092285, + 0.19239306449890137, + 0.08117949217557907, + 0.05988607555627823, + 0.4476277828216553, + 0.03489403799176216, + 0.0221725907176733, + 0.01834995672106743, + 0.019846627488732338, + 0.04336594417691231 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0798097625374794 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast expanse of sun-drenched, rolling meadows with tall emerald green grass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, hill-sized pumpkin carved into a rustic house with a wooden door and circular windows visible in the center of the field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, sea urchin-like creature with soft, plush, moss-covered spines sleeping on the pumpkin's roof?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the creature slowly emerge from its slumber by unfolding its body section by section?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a sweeping wide shot and slowly pan right before settling into position?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1428680419921875 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0178680419921875 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1428680419921875, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1428680419921875, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15130077302455902, + 0.19141562283039093, + 0.028939753770828247, + 0.06260104477405548, + 0.09760087728500366, + 0.05070693790912628, + 0.02167906053364277, + 0.051676247268915176, + 0.03250427544116974, + 0.31157544255256653 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1428680419921875 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast expanse of sun-drenched, rolling meadows with tall emerald green grass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, hill-sized pumpkin carved into a rustic house with a wooden door and circular windows visible in the center of the field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, sea urchin-like creature with soft, plush, moss-covered spines sleeping on the pumpkin's roof?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the creature slowly emerge from its slumber by unfolding its body section by section?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a sweeping wide shot and slowly pan right before settling into position?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0059571098536252975 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130957126617432 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0059571098536252975, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0059571098536252975, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20963622629642487, + 0.1519860476255417, + 0.032157596200704575, + 0.1043931394815445, + 0.2526600956916809, + 0.014519129879772663, + 0.01115400716662407, + 0.06787888705730438, + 0.05617843195796013, + 0.09943640977144241 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0059571098536252975 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast expanse of sun-drenched, rolling meadows with tall emerald green grass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, hill-sized pumpkin carved into a rustic house with a wooden door and circular windows visible in the center of the field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, sea urchin-like creature with soft, plush, moss-covered spines sleeping on the pumpkin's roof?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the creature slowly emerge from its slumber by unfolding its body section by section?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a sweeping wide shot and slowly pan right before settling into position?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.038096725940704346 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2880966663360596 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.038096725940704346, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.038096725940704346, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04649810865521431, + 0.14800633490085602, + 0.04006868973374367, + 0.06499993056058884, + 0.38906383514404297, + 0.03043803572654724, + 0.02141139656305313, + 0.047088637948036194, + 0.03888760879635811, + 0.17353741824626923 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.038096725940704346 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast expanse of sun-drenched, rolling meadows with tall emerald green grass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, hill-sized pumpkin carved into a rustic house with a wooden door and circular windows visible in the center of the field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, sea urchin-like creature with soft, plush, moss-covered spines sleeping on the pumpkin's roof?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the creature slowly emerge from its slumber by unfolding its body section by section?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a sweeping wide shot and slowly pan right before settling into position?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9742311239242554 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.474231094121933 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.9742311239242554, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.9742311239242554, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.051126424223184586, + 0.1669589728116989, + 0.017225852236151695, + 0.13412119448184967, + 0.1182546392083168, + 0.07169561833143234, + 0.028516124933958054, + 0.04275282844901085, + 0.023032967001199722, + 0.3463153839111328 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.9742311239242554 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_15/index_tensor([7943, 7943])_group_15_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_15/index_tensor([7943, 7943])_group_15_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..e9f26c56a4ddb0d9843e067826eab430bcc2df5b --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_15/index_tensor([7943, 7943])_group_15_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up, static shot meticulously depicts the dangling end of a thin, flexible, translucent plastic ruler, resting on the smooth, rounded edge of a flat wooden table with a rich, dark oak finish. Warm, soft light, as if from a nearby desk lamp, illuminates the scene from the side, capturing the subtle sheen of the polished texture and creating bright, reflective highlights along the ruler's length, revealing faint wear marks and precise black measurement markings. The movement begins when gravity deliberately pulls downward on the unsupported end, causing the plastic to gracefully bend into a smooth, continuous curve. Upon reaching its lowest point, the ruler's tip generates a brief, rapid vertical oscillation, quivering up and down as its energy wanes. Captured in hyper-detail, the movement shows the plastic vibrating before steadily and deliberately settling into its final, stable, drooping position, its elegantly curved form held in silent tension, creating a focused, almost meditative atmosphere centered on the simple physics of movement.", + "seed": 2336, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_15/index_7943_seed_2336_dp_30_rank_60_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.11665037209168076, + "vlm_logprob": -0.11665037209168076, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.6, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.11665037209168076, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a thin, flexible, translucent plastic ruler?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the ruler resting on the smooth, rounded edge of a flat wooden table with a dark oak finish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature warm, soft side lighting that creates bright reflective highlights and reveals black measurement markings on the ruler?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the ruler bend into a smooth curve, quiver vertically at its lowest point, and then settle into a stable drooping position?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static throughout the entire sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.028536060824990273 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.653536081314087 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.028536060824990273, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.028536060824990273, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04667672887444496, + 0.03352219983935356, + 0.025571543723344803, + 0.4604671895503998, + 0.36891117691993713, + 0.022181270644068718, + 0.017818139865994453, + 0.01065982598811388, + 0.007019453216344118, + 0.007172564975917339 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.028536060824990273 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a thin, flexible, translucent plastic ruler?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the ruler resting on the smooth, rounded edge of a flat wooden table with a dark oak finish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature warm, soft side lighting that creates bright reflective highlights and reveals black measurement markings on the ruler?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the ruler bend into a smooth curve, quiver vertically at its lowest point, and then settle into a stable drooping position?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static throughout the entire sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014201998710632324 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264202117919922 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014201998710632324, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014201998710632324, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09991879761219025, + 0.09227336198091507, + 0.04935888200998306, + 0.3048163950443268, + 0.20479169487953186, + 0.06039304658770561, + 0.02622530236840248, + 0.09133347123861313, + 0.035654082894325256, + 0.0352349616587162 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014201998710632324 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a thin, flexible, translucent plastic ruler?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the ruler resting on the smooth, rounded edge of a flat wooden table with a dark oak finish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature warm, soft side lighting that creates bright reflective highlights and reveals black measurement markings on the ruler?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the ruler bend into a smooth curve, quiver vertically at its lowest point, and then settle into a stable drooping position?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static throughout the entire sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00464135454967618 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379641532897949 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00464135454967618, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00464135454967618, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07508490234613419, + 0.09866069257259369, + 0.056049901992082596, + 0.5411063432693481, + 0.13125678896903992, + 0.026683984324336052, + 0.019509470090270042, + 0.024975532665848732, + 0.011132197454571724, + 0.015540163032710552 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00464135454967618 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a thin, flexible, translucent plastic ruler?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the ruler resting on the smooth, rounded edge of a flat wooden table with a dark oak finish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature warm, soft side lighting that creates bright reflective highlights and reveals black measurement markings on the ruler?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the ruler bend into a smooth curve, quiver vertically at its lowest point, and then settle into a stable drooping position?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static throughout the entire sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012537943199276924 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387537956237793 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012537943199276924, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012537943199276924, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.024226628243923187, + 0.01193285919725895, + 0.008305525407195091, + 0.8309418559074402, + 0.08351817727088928, + 0.02284928224980831, + 0.005562292877584696, + 0.003432920668274164, + 0.00425669364631176, + 0.004973832052201033 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012537943199276924 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a thin, flexible, translucent plastic ruler?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the ruler resting on the smooth, rounded edge of a flat wooden table with a dark oak finish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature warm, soft side lighting that creates bright reflective highlights and reveals black measurement markings on the ruler?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the ruler bend into a smooth curve, quiver vertically at its lowest point, and then settle into a stable drooping position?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static throughout the entire sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5233345031738281 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8983345031738281 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5233345031738281, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5233345031738281, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.026714297011494637, + 0.0662631094455719, + 0.014067916199564934, + 0.29857224225997925, + 0.5627195239067078, + 0.014583898708224297, + 0.00346375722438097, + 0.0031519196927547455, + 0.004451482556760311, + 0.006011886987835169 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5233345031738281 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up, static shot meticulously depicts the dangling end of a thin, flexible, translucent plastic ruler, resting on the smooth, rounded edge of a flat wooden table with a rich, dark oak finish. Warm, soft light, as if from a nearby desk lamp, illuminates the scene from the side, capturing the subtle sheen of the polished texture and creating bright, reflective highlights along the ruler's length, revealing faint wear marks and precise black measurement markings. The movement begins when gravity deliberately pulls downward on the unsupported end, causing the plastic to gracefully bend into a smooth, continuous curve. Upon reaching its lowest point, the ruler's tip generates a brief, rapid vertical oscillation, quivering up and down as its energy wanes. Captured in hyper-detail, the movement shows the plastic vibrating before steadily and deliberately settling into its final, stable, drooping position, its elegantly curved form held in silent tension, creating a focused, almost meditative atmosphere centered on the simple physics of movement.", + "seed": 2337, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_15/index_7943_seed_2337_dp_30_rank_60_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.1081678002141416, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1081678002141416, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.65, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1081678002141416, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a thin, flexible, translucent plastic ruler?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the ruler resting on the smooth, rounded edge of a flat wooden table with a dark oak finish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature warm, soft side lighting that creates bright reflective highlights and reveals black measurement markings on the ruler?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the ruler bend into a smooth curve, quiver vertically at its lowest point, and then settle into a stable drooping position?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static throughout the entire sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08170592784881592 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5817060470581055 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08170592784881592, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08170592784881592, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08166243880987167, + 0.42352503538131714, + 0.038717661052942276, + 0.025530992075800896, + 0.0671994760632515, + 0.1449887603521347, + 0.025810372084379196, + 0.13951073586940765, + 0.0347931869328022, + 0.018261322751641273 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08170592784881592 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a thin, flexible, translucent plastic ruler?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the ruler resting on the smooth, rounded edge of a flat wooden table with a dark oak finish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature warm, soft side lighting that creates bright reflective highlights and reveals black measurement markings on the ruler?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the ruler bend into a smooth curve, quiver vertically at its lowest point, and then settle into a stable drooping position?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static throughout the entire sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004107017070055008 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.5041069984436035 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004107017070055008, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004107017070055008, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21171356737613678, + 0.2996891736984253, + 0.10407278686761856, + 0.03146227449178696, + 0.051289867609739304, + 0.1508597880601883, + 0.03419218957424164, + 0.08230173587799072, + 0.016100961714982986, + 0.018317580223083496 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004107017070055008 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a thin, flexible, translucent plastic ruler?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the ruler resting on the smooth, rounded edge of a flat wooden table with a dark oak finish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature warm, soft side lighting that creates bright reflective highlights and reveals black measurement markings on the ruler?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the ruler bend into a smooth curve, quiver vertically at its lowest point, and then settle into a stable drooping position?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static throughout the entire sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0028236540965735912 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877823829650879 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0028236540965735912, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0028236540965735912, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12518815696239471, + 0.37064221501350403, + 0.032623302191495895, + 0.015595258213579655, + 0.10500406473875046, + 0.13845957815647125, + 0.046663373708724976, + 0.13907751441001892, + 0.023026879876852036, + 0.0037197291385382414 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 7, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0028236540965735912 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a thin, flexible, translucent plastic ruler?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the ruler resting on the smooth, rounded edge of a flat wooden table with a dark oak finish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature warm, soft side lighting that creates bright reflective highlights and reveals black measurement markings on the ruler?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the ruler bend into a smooth curve, quiver vertically at its lowest point, and then settle into a stable drooping position?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static throughout the entire sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023292265832424164 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773292303085327 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023292265832424164, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023292265832424164, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08083407580852509, + 0.3281248211860657, + 0.020856399089097977, + 0.016873691231012344, + 0.17760075628757477, + 0.021018171682953835, + 0.06724574416875839, + 0.14870677888393402, + 0.12946829199790955, + 0.009271197021007538 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 4, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023292265832424164 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a thin, flexible, translucent plastic ruler?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the ruler resting on the smooth, rounded edge of a flat wooden table with a dark oak finish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature warm, soft side lighting that creates bright reflective highlights and reveals black measurement markings on the ruler?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the ruler bend into a smooth curve, quiver vertically at its lowest point, and then settle into a stable drooping position?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static throughout the entire sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.42891013622283936 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.0539101362228394 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.42891013622283936, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.42891013622283936, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.01921415515244007, + 0.29389309883117676, + 0.046327415853738785, + 0.026333283632993698, + 0.3210515081882477, + 0.19793692231178284, + 0.012007717043161392, + 0.023760726675391197, + 0.04386402294039726, + 0.015611094422638416 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.42891013622283936 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up, static shot meticulously depicts the dangling end of a thin, flexible, translucent plastic ruler, resting on the smooth, rounded edge of a flat wooden table with a rich, dark oak finish. Warm, soft light, as if from a nearby desk lamp, illuminates the scene from the side, capturing the subtle sheen of the polished texture and creating bright, reflective highlights along the ruler's length, revealing faint wear marks and precise black measurement markings. The movement begins when gravity deliberately pulls downward on the unsupported end, causing the plastic to gracefully bend into a smooth, continuous curve. Upon reaching its lowest point, the ruler's tip generates a brief, rapid vertical oscillation, quivering up and down as its energy wanes. Captured in hyper-detail, the movement shows the plastic vibrating before steadily and deliberately settling into its final, stable, drooping position, its elegantly curved form held in silent tension, creating a focused, almost meditative atmosphere centered on the simple physics of movement.", + "seed": 2338, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_15/index_7943_seed_2338_dp_31_rank_62_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.1280769594013691, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1280769594013691, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.6, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1280769594013691, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a thin, flexible, translucent plastic ruler?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the ruler resting on the smooth, rounded edge of a flat wooden table with a dark oak finish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature warm, soft side lighting that creates bright reflective highlights and reveals black measurement markings on the ruler?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the ruler bend into a smooth curve, quiver vertically at its lowest point, and then settle into a stable drooping position?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static throughout the entire sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026494689285755157 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7764947414398193 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026494689285755157, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026494689285755157, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19395838677883148, + 0.12054280936717987, + 0.09288003295660019, + 0.05959450826048851, + 0.05356227234005928, + 0.06918025016784668, + 0.1388598531484604, + 0.11789772659540176, + 0.07134901732206345, + 0.08217518031597137 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026494689285755157 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a thin, flexible, translucent plastic ruler?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the ruler resting on the smooth, rounded edge of a flat wooden table with a dark oak finish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature warm, soft side lighting that creates bright reflective highlights and reveals black measurement markings on the ruler?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the ruler bend into a smooth curve, quiver vertically at its lowest point, and then settle into a stable drooping position?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static throughout the entire sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02636779099702835 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513679027557373 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02636779099702835, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02636779099702835, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.28226444125175476, + 0.09813175350427628, + 0.04472504183650017, + 0.09767771512269974, + 0.1481398344039917, + 0.02982972003519535, + 0.0893499106168747, + 0.06527618318796158, + 0.08715128153562546, + 0.057454053312540054 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02636779099702835 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a thin, flexible, translucent plastic ruler?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the ruler resting on the smooth, rounded edge of a flat wooden table with a dark oak finish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature warm, soft side lighting that creates bright reflective highlights and reveals black measurement markings on the ruler?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the ruler bend into a smooth curve, quiver vertically at its lowest point, and then settle into a stable drooping position?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static throughout the entire sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004645033273845911 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379644870758057 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004645033273845911, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004645033273845911, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20182885229587555, + 0.060286715626716614, + 0.08814822137355804, + 0.13980093598365784, + 0.042295604944229126, + 0.07177338004112244, + 0.17163412272930145, + 0.11418872326612473, + 0.04955664649605751, + 0.06048675999045372 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004645033273845911 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a thin, flexible, translucent plastic ruler?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the ruler resting on the smooth, rounded edge of a flat wooden table with a dark oak finish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature warm, soft side lighting that creates bright reflective highlights and reveals black measurement markings on the ruler?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the ruler bend into a smooth curve, quiver vertically at its lowest point, and then settle into a stable drooping position?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static throughout the entire sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006739859934896231 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006740093231201 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006739859934896231, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006739859934896231, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10414959490299225, + 0.04342373088002205, + 0.12666843831539154, + 0.0628022700548172, + 0.08581484109163284, + 0.05951298400759697, + 0.04311608895659447, + 0.11834941059350967, + 0.04607119411230087, + 0.310091495513916 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 2, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006739859934896231 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a thin, flexible, translucent plastic ruler?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the ruler resting on the smooth, rounded edge of a flat wooden table with a dark oak finish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature warm, soft side lighting that creates bright reflective highlights and reveals black measurement markings on the ruler?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the ruler bend into a smooth curve, quiver vertically at its lowest point, and then settle into a stable drooping position?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static throughout the entire sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5761374235153198 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8261374235153198 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5761374235153198, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5761374235153198, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08653444051742554, + 0.06636267900466919, + 0.20977143943309784, + 0.04977255314588547, + 0.068585105240345, + 0.06998667865991592, + 0.1582545042037964, + 0.14001311361789703, + 0.05821586027741432, + 0.09250357747077942 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5761374235153198 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up, static shot meticulously depicts the dangling end of a thin, flexible, translucent plastic ruler, resting on the smooth, rounded edge of a flat wooden table with a rich, dark oak finish. Warm, soft light, as if from a nearby desk lamp, illuminates the scene from the side, capturing the subtle sheen of the polished texture and creating bright, reflective highlights along the ruler's length, revealing faint wear marks and precise black measurement markings. The movement begins when gravity deliberately pulls downward on the unsupported end, causing the plastic to gracefully bend into a smooth, continuous curve. Upon reaching its lowest point, the ruler's tip generates a brief, rapid vertical oscillation, quivering up and down as its energy wanes. Captured in hyper-detail, the movement shows the plastic vibrating before steadily and deliberately settling into its final, stable, drooping position, its elegantly curved form held in silent tension, creating a focused, almost meditative atmosphere centered on the simple physics of movement.", + "seed": 2339, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_15/index_7943_seed_2339_dp_31_rank_62_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.10492549045011401, + "vlm_logprob": -0.10492549045011401, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.8, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.10492549045011401, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a thin, flexible, translucent plastic ruler?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the ruler resting on the smooth, rounded edge of a flat wooden table with a dark oak finish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature warm, soft side lighting that creates bright reflective highlights and reveals black measurement markings on the ruler?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the ruler bend into a smooth curve, quiver vertically at its lowest point, and then settle into a stable drooping position?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static throughout the entire sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22807465493679047 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6030746698379517 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.22807465493679047, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.22807465493679047, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20098170638084412, + 0.10802418738603592, + 0.09361425042152405, + 0.13079877197742462, + 0.07769440859556198, + 0.02972208894789219, + 0.025441940873861313, + 0.02959269843995571, + 0.16047051548957825, + 0.14365950226783752 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.22807465493679047 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a thin, flexible, translucent plastic ruler?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the ruler resting on the smooth, rounded edge of a flat wooden table with a dark oak finish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature warm, soft side lighting that creates bright reflective highlights and reveals black measurement markings on the ruler?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the ruler bend into a smooth curve, quiver vertically at its lowest point, and then settle into a stable drooping position?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static throughout the entire sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.062073830515146255 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120739459991455 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.062073830515146255, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.062073830515146255, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12569881975650787, + 0.4865359961986542, + 0.04584402218461037, + 0.08678901195526123, + 0.07182327657938004, + 0.019014721736311913, + 0.01242962945252657, + 0.06282348185777664, + 0.050631653517484665, + 0.03840937837958336 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.062073830515146255 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a thin, flexible, translucent plastic ruler?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the ruler resting on the smooth, rounded edge of a flat wooden table with a dark oak finish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature warm, soft side lighting that creates bright reflective highlights and reveals black measurement markings on the ruler?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the ruler bend into a smooth curve, quiver vertically at its lowest point, and then settle into a stable drooping position?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static throughout the entire sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004103930201381445 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504104137420654 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004103930201381445, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004103930201381445, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18478812277317047, + 0.16302913427352905, + 0.04439449682831764, + 0.14970406889915466, + 0.13870865106582642, + 0.058733340352773666, + 0.06287699937820435, + 0.03316561132669449, + 0.0953814834356308, + 0.06921811401844025 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004103930201381445 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a thin, flexible, translucent plastic ruler?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the ruler resting on the smooth, rounded edge of a flat wooden table with a dark oak finish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature warm, soft side lighting that creates bright reflective highlights and reveals black measurement markings on the ruler?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the ruler bend into a smooth curve, quiver vertically at its lowest point, and then settle into a stable drooping position?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static throughout the entire sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1603645533323288 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9103645086288452 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1603645533323288, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1603645533323288, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10578060150146484, + 0.09858371317386627, + 0.03945053741335869, + 0.13843175768852234, + 0.07602569460868835, + 0.05042611062526703, + 0.05701843649148941, + 0.06201411783695221, + 0.27081945538520813, + 0.10144957900047302 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1603645533323288 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a thin, flexible, translucent plastic ruler?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the ruler resting on the smooth, rounded edge of a flat wooden table with a dark oak finish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature warm, soft side lighting that creates bright reflective highlights and reveals black measurement markings on the ruler?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the ruler bend into a smooth curve, quiver vertically at its lowest point, and then settle into a stable drooping position?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static throughout the entire sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0700104832649231 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950104236602783 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0700104832649231, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0700104832649231, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.055891796946525574, + 0.39864638447761536, + 0.0643395185470581, + 0.13324835896492004, + 0.022584423422813416, + 0.09049320966005325, + 0.031176231801509857, + 0.027302108705043793, + 0.08362612128257751, + 0.09269185364246368 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0700104832649231 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_2/index_tensor([8949, 8949])_group_2_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_2/index_tensor([8949, 8949])_group_2_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..a8145385e95b7422200f91fa516928ac4de71e56 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_2/index_tensor([8949, 8949])_group_2_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "low-angle, slow-motion, tracking shot captures a bizarre fashion show taking place in a surreal hotel. Amidst a maze of intense beams of light, alternating crimson, royal blue, and eerie green, several tall, androgynous models slowly march along an endlessly long corridor with a vaulted ceiling. Clad in avant-garde, dramatically structured garments in vibrant, saturated colors, some embellished with shimmering metal, others crafted from translucent tulle, they move steadily forward in a ritualistic, almost hypnotic rhythm, their faces expressionless, their eyes vacant and piercing. As they move, light streaming through the gaps between the ceiling and floor dramatically elongates and distorts their figures, casting sharp, dancing shadows across the smooth, obsidian floor. The walls of the corridor are made up of countless mirrors of different sizes and angles, which continuously reflect the fragmented and overlapping images of the models, as if countless clones are moving simultaneously in different dimensions. The whole scene is full of Jodorowsky-style dramatic tension and visual symbolism, creating a dream atmosphere that is both gorgeous and unsettling.", + "seed": 21966, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_2/index_8949_seed_21966_dp_4_rank_8_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.07689224416390061, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07689224416390061, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.15, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07689224416390061, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low and is the shot a slow-motion tracking shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are tall, androgynous models marching in a corridor with a vaulted ceiling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the models wearing avant-garde garments with shimmering metal or translucent tulle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the walls consist of countless mirrors of different sizes and angles reflecting the models?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the floor smooth and obsidian black with sharp, dancing shadows cast by the light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.18881337344646454 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.813813328742981 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.18881337344646454, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.18881337344646454, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22129768133163452, + 0.03721405565738678, + 0.07037230581045151, + 0.0804024413228035, + 0.05986379459500313, + 0.10703013837337494, + 0.10950814932584763, + 0.12307596206665039, + 0.09526000916957855, + 0.09597542881965637 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.18881337344646454 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low and is the shot a slow-motion tracking shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are tall, androgynous models marching in a corridor with a vaulted ceiling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the models wearing avant-garde garments with shimmering metal or translucent tulle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the walls consist of countless mirrors of different sizes and angles reflecting the models?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the floor smooth and obsidian black with sharp, dancing shadows cast by the light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10036682337522507 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3503668308258057 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10036682337522507, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10036682337522507, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08973464369773865, + 0.09903497993946075, + 0.08784754574298859, + 0.17034626007080078, + 0.14979776740074158, + 0.0623379647731781, + 0.08880692720413208, + 0.05882272496819496, + 0.12328670918941498, + 0.0699845477938652 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10036682337522507 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low and is the shot a slow-motion tracking shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are tall, androgynous models marching in a corridor with a vaulted ceiling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the models wearing avant-garde garments with shimmering metal or translucent tulle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the walls consist of countless mirrors of different sizes and angles reflecting the models?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the floor smooth and obsidian black with sharp, dancing shadows cast by the light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004652983043342829 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379652976989746 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004652983043342829, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004652983043342829, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09794321656227112, + 0.14150261878967285, + 0.10883449763059616, + 0.04953674599528313, + 0.04197320714592934, + 0.08268727362155914, + 0.046632200479507446, + 0.02752029150724411, + 0.10551401227712631, + 0.297855943441391 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004652983043342829 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low and is the shot a slow-motion tracking shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are tall, androgynous models marching in a corridor with a vaulted ceiling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the models wearing avant-garde garments with shimmering metal or translucent tulle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the walls consist of countless mirrors of different sizes and angles reflecting the models?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the floor smooth and obsidian black with sharp, dancing shadows cast by the light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07004760205745697 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695047616958618 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07004760205745697, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07004760205745697, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09387373179197311, + 0.08639209717512131, + 0.12944039702415466, + 0.1131594181060791, + 0.08675307035446167, + 0.12681728601455688, + 0.08855881541967392, + 0.06345188617706299, + 0.08354710787534714, + 0.12800627946853638 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07004760205745697 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low and is the shot a slow-motion tracking shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are tall, androgynous models marching in a corridor with a vaulted ceiling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the models wearing avant-garde garments with shimmering metal or translucent tulle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the walls consist of countless mirrors of different sizes and angles reflecting the models?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the floor smooth and obsidian black with sharp, dancing shadows cast by the light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020580438897013664 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895580530166626 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020580438897013664, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020580438897013664, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10261251777410507, + 0.04717596620321274, + 0.07251061499118805, + 0.05895781144499779, + 0.05582316219806671, + 0.05720648914575577, + 0.05123245343565941, + 0.024693431332707405, + 0.08323638886213303, + 0.44655126333236694 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020580438897013664 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, slow-motion, tracking shot captures a bizarre fashion show taking place in a surreal hotel. Amidst a maze of intense beams of light, alternating crimson, royal blue, and eerie green, several tall, androgynous models slowly march along an endlessly long corridor with a vaulted ceiling. Clad in avant-garde, dramatically structured garments in vibrant, saturated colors, some embellished with shimmering metal, others crafted from translucent tulle, they move steadily forward in a ritualistic, almost hypnotic rhythm, their faces expressionless, their eyes vacant and piercing. As they move, light streaming through the gaps between the ceiling and floor dramatically elongates and distorts their figures, casting sharp, dancing shadows across the smooth, obsidian floor. The walls of the corridor are made up of countless mirrors of different sizes and angles, which continuously reflect the fragmented and overlapping images of the models, as if countless clones are moving simultaneously in different dimensions. The whole scene is full of Jodorowsky-style dramatic tension and visual symbolism, creating a dream atmosphere that is both gorgeous and unsettling.", + "seed": 21967, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_2/index_8949_seed_21967_dp_4_rank_8_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.04150563688017428, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04150563688017428, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.8999999523162843, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04150563688017428, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low and is the shot a slow-motion tracking shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are tall, androgynous models marching in a corridor with a vaulted ceiling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the models wearing avant-garde garments with shimmering metal or translucent tulle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the walls consist of countless mirrors of different sizes and angles reflecting the models?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the floor smooth and obsidian black with sharp, dancing shadows cast by the light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14632844924926758 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1463284492492676 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14632844924926758, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14632844924926758, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2001420259475708, + 0.03673470765352249, + 0.08017004281282425, + 0.08965376764535904, + 0.10161491483449936, + 0.05447721481323242, + 0.0655975341796875, + 0.1358640342950821, + 0.17578017711639404, + 0.059965573251247406 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14632844924926758 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low and is the shot a slow-motion tracking shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are tall, androgynous models marching in a corridor with a vaulted ceiling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the models wearing avant-garde garments with shimmering metal or translucent tulle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the walls consist of countless mirrors of different sizes and angles reflecting the models?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the floor smooth and obsidian black with sharp, dancing shadows cast by the light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018216803669929504 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018216609954834 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018216803669929504, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018216803669929504, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2776404321193695, + 0.045448917895555496, + 0.02174493670463562, + 0.14990387856960297, + 0.1410515457391739, + 0.062422607094049454, + 0.051395483314991, + 0.05031047761440277, + 0.09937264770269394, + 0.10070903599262238 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018216803669929504 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low and is the shot a slow-motion tracking shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are tall, androgynous models marching in a corridor with a vaulted ceiling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the models wearing avant-garde garments with shimmering metal or translucent tulle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the walls consist of countless mirrors of different sizes and angles reflecting the models?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the floor smooth and obsidian black with sharp, dancing shadows cast by the light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003627388970926404 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628627300262451 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003627388970926404, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003627388970926404, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23070169985294342, + 0.03716309741139412, + 0.06579715013504028, + 0.3627403676509857, + 0.07418061792850494, + 0.03925124928355217, + 0.03117986209690571, + 0.05799248814582825, + 0.037981439381837845, + 0.06301196664571762 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003627388970926404 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low and is the shot a slow-motion tracking shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are tall, androgynous models marching in a corridor with a vaulted ceiling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the models wearing avant-garde garments with shimmering metal or translucent tulle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the walls consist of countless mirrors of different sizes and angles reflecting the models?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the floor smooth and obsidian black with sharp, dancing shadows cast by the light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01607270911335945 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141072750091553 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01607270911335945, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01607270911335945, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20194150507450104, + 0.04771651700139046, + 0.030353235080838203, + 0.2660374343395233, + 0.14727844297885895, + 0.051974788308143616, + 0.08172310888767242, + 0.07519975304603577, + 0.04392299801111221, + 0.053852178156375885 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01607270911335945 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low and is the shot a slow-motion tracking shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are tall, androgynous models marching in a corridor with a vaulted ceiling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the models wearing avant-garde garments with shimmering metal or translucent tulle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the walls consist of countless mirrors of different sizes and angles reflecting the models?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the floor smooth and obsidian black with sharp, dancing shadows cast by the light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023282833397388458 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773282766342163 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023282833397388458, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023282833397388458, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.28057074546813965, + 0.06003691628575325, + 0.05148179084062576, + 0.05652954429388046, + 0.08323854207992554, + 0.04947426915168762, + 0.1060628890991211, + 0.14447367191314697, + 0.04770329222083092, + 0.1204284206032753 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023282833397388458 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, slow-motion, tracking shot captures a bizarre fashion show taking place in a surreal hotel. Amidst a maze of intense beams of light, alternating crimson, royal blue, and eerie green, several tall, androgynous models slowly march along an endlessly long corridor with a vaulted ceiling. Clad in avant-garde, dramatically structured garments in vibrant, saturated colors, some embellished with shimmering metal, others crafted from translucent tulle, they move steadily forward in a ritualistic, almost hypnotic rhythm, their faces expressionless, their eyes vacant and piercing. As they move, light streaming through the gaps between the ceiling and floor dramatically elongates and distorts their figures, casting sharp, dancing shadows across the smooth, obsidian floor. The walls of the corridor are made up of countless mirrors of different sizes and angles, which continuously reflect the fragmented and overlapping images of the models, as if countless clones are moving simultaneously in different dimensions. The whole scene is full of Jodorowsky-style dramatic tension and visual symbolism, creating a dream atmosphere that is both gorgeous and unsettling.", + "seed": 21968, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_2/index_8949_seed_21968_dp_5_rank_10_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.09126617535948753, + "vlm_logprob": -0.09126617535948753, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.1, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.09126617535948753, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low and is the shot a slow-motion tracking shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are tall, androgynous models marching in a corridor with a vaulted ceiling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the models wearing avant-garde garments with shimmering metal or translucent tulle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the walls consist of countless mirrors of different sizes and angles reflecting the models?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the floor smooth and obsidian black with sharp, dancing shadows cast by the light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.32830652594566345 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3283065557479858 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.32830652594566345, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.32830652594566345, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3205689787864685, + 0.0917324423789978, + 0.05234011262655258, + 0.09333603829145432, + 0.050521887838840485, + 0.09360824525356293, + 0.03597791865468025, + 0.12003737688064575, + 0.05897442623972893, + 0.08290253579616547 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.32830652594566345 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low and is the shot a slow-motion tracking shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are tall, androgynous models marching in a corridor with a vaulted ceiling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the models wearing avant-garde garments with shimmering metal or translucent tulle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the walls consist of countless mirrors of different sizes and angles reflecting the models?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the floor smooth and obsidian black with sharp, dancing shadows cast by the light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026378124952316284 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513781547546387 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026378124952316284, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026378124952316284, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1686498075723648, + 0.025612840428948402, + 0.019599126651883125, + 0.07857530564069748, + 0.0356464646756649, + 0.20014701783657074, + 0.04010114073753357, + 0.04664425924420357, + 0.34259945154190063, + 0.042424578219652176 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026378124952316284 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low and is the shot a slow-motion tracking shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are tall, androgynous models marching in a corridor with a vaulted ceiling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the models wearing avant-garde garments with shimmering metal or translucent tulle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the walls consist of countless mirrors of different sizes and angles reflecting the models?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the floor smooth and obsidian black with sharp, dancing shadows cast by the light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009799469262361526 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634799480438232 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009799469262361526, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009799469262361526, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19748415052890778, + 0.0316053181886673, + 0.020133081823587418, + 0.11877423524856567, + 0.05023772269487381, + 0.37772879004478455, + 0.05908127501606941, + 0.029149791225790977, + 0.054175931960344315, + 0.061629701405763626 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009799469262361526 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low and is the shot a slow-motion tracking shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are tall, androgynous models marching in a corridor with a vaulted ceiling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the models wearing avant-garde garments with shimmering metal or translucent tulle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the walls consist of countless mirrors of different sizes and angles reflecting the models?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the floor smooth and obsidian black with sharp, dancing shadows cast by the light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029810123145580292 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298101902008057 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029810123145580292, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029810123145580292, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15297286212444305, + 0.06986381858587265, + 0.042655181139707565, + 0.12908856570720673, + 0.06987744569778442, + 0.18817196786403656, + 0.036448974162340164, + 0.07770600914955139, + 0.1364874243736267, + 0.09672777354717255 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029810123145580292 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low and is the shot a slow-motion tracking shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are tall, androgynous models marching in a corridor with a vaulted ceiling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the models wearing avant-garde garments with shimmering metal or translucent tulle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the walls consist of countless mirrors of different sizes and angles reflecting the models?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the floor smooth and obsidian black with sharp, dancing shadows cast by the light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06203663349151611 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120365142822266 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06203663349151611, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06203663349151611, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13132500648498535, + 0.054188892245292664, + 0.029108481481671333, + 0.058464400470256805, + 0.023306405171751976, + 0.2996380925178528, + 0.03477855399250984, + 0.10390084236860275, + 0.09265801310539246, + 0.17263132333755493 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06203663349151611 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, slow-motion, tracking shot captures a bizarre fashion show taking place in a surreal hotel. Amidst a maze of intense beams of light, alternating crimson, royal blue, and eerie green, several tall, androgynous models slowly march along an endlessly long corridor with a vaulted ceiling. Clad in avant-garde, dramatically structured garments in vibrant, saturated colors, some embellished with shimmering metal, others crafted from translucent tulle, they move steadily forward in a ritualistic, almost hypnotic rhythm, their faces expressionless, their eyes vacant and piercing. As they move, light streaming through the gaps between the ceiling and floor dramatically elongates and distorts their figures, casting sharp, dancing shadows across the smooth, obsidian floor. The walls of the corridor are made up of countless mirrors of different sizes and angles, which continuously reflect the fragmented and overlapping images of the models, as if countless clones are moving simultaneously in different dimensions. The whole scene is full of Jodorowsky-style dramatic tension and visual symbolism, creating a dream atmosphere that is both gorgeous and unsettling.", + "seed": 21969, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_2/index_8949_seed_21969_dp_5_rank_10_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.048248854978010056, + "vlm_logprob": -0.048248854978010056, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.775, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.048248854978010056, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low and is the shot a slow-motion tracking shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are tall, androgynous models marching in a corridor with a vaulted ceiling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the models wearing avant-garde garments with shimmering metal or translucent tulle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the walls consist of countless mirrors of different sizes and angles reflecting the models?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the floor smooth and obsidian black with sharp, dancing shadows cast by the light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.15445448458194733 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.029454469680786 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.15445448458194733, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.15445448458194733, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12030128389596939, + 0.10317814350128174, + 0.0646202564239502, + 0.12945209443569183, + 0.02618039958178997, + 0.03260708972811699, + 0.03719364106655121, + 0.053387001156806946, + 0.10611008107662201, + 0.32697004079818726 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.15445448458194733 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low and is the shot a slow-motion tracking shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are tall, androgynous models marching in a corridor with a vaulted ceiling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the models wearing avant-garde garments with shimmering metal or translucent tulle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the walls consist of countless mirrors of different sizes and angles reflecting the models?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the floor smooth and obsidian black with sharp, dancing shadows cast by the light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04310404881834984 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1681039333343506 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04310404881834984, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04310404881834984, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10569389909505844, + 0.06310319155454636, + 0.10625038295984268, + 0.07413782924413681, + 0.027912909165024757, + 0.06484726071357727, + 0.04208505153656006, + 0.052998557686805725, + 0.03816396743059158, + 0.42480695247650146 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04310404881834984 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low and is the shot a slow-motion tracking shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are tall, androgynous models marching in a corridor with a vaulted ceiling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the models wearing avant-garde garments with shimmering metal or translucent tulle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the walls consist of countless mirrors of different sizes and angles reflecting the models?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the floor smooth and obsidian black with sharp, dancing shadows cast by the light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002208415186032653 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127208232879639 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002208415186032653, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002208415186032653, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10853215306997299, + 0.059388745576143265, + 0.07596402615308762, + 0.04417143017053604, + 0.03155587986111641, + 0.0399848110973835, + 0.03383861109614372, + 0.02916582301259041, + 0.447643518447876, + 0.1297549605369568 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002208415186032653 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low and is the shot a slow-motion tracking shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are tall, androgynous models marching in a corridor with a vaulted ceiling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the models wearing avant-garde garments with shimmering metal or translucent tulle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the walls consist of countless mirrors of different sizes and angles reflecting the models?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the floor smooth and obsidian black with sharp, dancing shadows cast by the light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02329622581601143 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732961177825928 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02329622581601143, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02329622581601143, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10001363605260849, + 0.09590340405702591, + 0.06118253618478775, + 0.04469173029065132, + 0.023409996181726456, + 0.034447647631168365, + 0.06047932058572769, + 0.06989110261201859, + 0.3283351957798004, + 0.1816454827785492 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02329622581601143 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low and is the shot a slow-motion tracking shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are tall, androgynous models marching in a corridor with a vaulted ceiling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the models wearing avant-garde garments with shimmering metal or translucent tulle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the walls consist of countless mirrors of different sizes and angles reflecting the models?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the floor smooth and obsidian black with sharp, dancing shadows cast by the light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018181100487709045 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018181324005127 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018181100487709045, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018181100487709045, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14518246054649353, + 0.09455445408821106, + 0.0553920604288578, + 0.21100926399230957, + 0.02487948350608349, + 0.037650447338819504, + 0.03266873583197594, + 0.07956472039222717, + 0.15486633777618408, + 0.16423200070858002 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018181100487709045 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_3/index_tensor([1957, 1957])_group_3_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_3/index_tensor([1957, 1957])_group_3_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..8a88773f4d57c0fbc45b3fdf5f0b3a323acb0600 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_3/index_tensor([1957, 1957])_group_3_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "medium shot, filmed from a low angle, slowly and steadily moves forward, capturing a female warrior clad in a full suit of crimson armor. She stands at the edge of a windswept rocky cliff, a vast, blazing sunset sinking into the distant mountains behind her. The intense backlight casts a dazzling golden rim around her entire form, making the edges of her crimson lacquer armor gleam like molten gold, while the front of the armor is plunged into deep shadow. Her long, raven hair, braided into a thick braid, swirls in the air as she moves, revealing scattered strands. She wields a slender katana, the blade reflecting the last rays of the setting sun with each swing, slicing brilliant arcs. Her sword dance is fluid and powerful: she begins in a low, calm stance, her body like a drawn bow, then swivels swiftly and gracefully, her wide red culottes unfurling, followed by a series of precise and deadly slashes and blocks, each movement seamlessly connected, full of rhythm and control, as if she were engaging in a solemn duel with an invisible opponent. The entire scene is painted in warm and saturated tones, with the sky stained in a gradient of deep purple and fiery orange, creating an epic, majestic and lonely atmosphere.", + "seed": 30413, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_3/index_1957_seed_30413_dp_6_rank_12_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.20406009098514916, + "vlm_logprob": -0.20406009098514916, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.725, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.20406009098514916, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filmed from a low angle in a medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move slowly and steadily forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the female warrior wearing a full suit of crimson armor with a thick braid of raven hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior performing a fluid sword dance with a katana, including a low stance, swivels, and precise slashes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a windswept rocky cliff with a vast sunset over distant mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17750298976898193 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3025031089782715 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17750298976898193, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17750298976898193, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1374405026435852, + 0.036308497190475464, + 0.051495183259248734, + 0.13179482519626617, + 0.34646281599998474, + 0.13761915266513824, + 0.047732338309288025, + 0.032890524715185165, + 0.04045296460390091, + 0.037803180515766144 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17750298976898193 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filmed from a low angle in a medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move slowly and steadily forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the female warrior wearing a full suit of crimson armor with a thick braid of raven hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior performing a fluid sword dance with a katana, including a low stance, swivels, and precise slashes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a windswept rocky cliff with a vast sunset over distant mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7578076720237732 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6328076720237732 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.7578076720237732, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.7578076720237732, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09575837850570679, + 0.09829729795455933, + 0.06121234595775604, + 0.27529874444007874, + 0.11160952597856522, + 0.06575006991624832, + 0.06512537598609924, + 0.08120966702699661, + 0.049169380217790604, + 0.0965692400932312 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.7578076720237732 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filmed from a low angle in a medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move slowly and steadily forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the female warrior wearing a full suit of crimson armor with a thick braid of raven hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior performing a fluid sword dance with a katana, including a low stance, swivels, and precise slashes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a windswept rocky cliff with a vast sunset over distant mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05496998131275177 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299700260162354 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05496998131275177, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05496998131275177, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17257389426231384, + 0.056054580956697464, + 0.12311994284391403, + 0.20290467143058777, + 0.14372476935386658, + 0.060898713767528534, + 0.11316429823637009, + 0.04694261774420738, + 0.05656355619430542, + 0.024052921682596207 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05496998131275177 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filmed from a low angle in a medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move slowly and steadily forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the female warrior wearing a full suit of crimson armor with a thick braid of raven hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior performing a fluid sword dance with a katana, including a low stance, swivels, and precise slashes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a windswept rocky cliff with a vast sunset over distant mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006741754245012999 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006741523742676 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006741754245012999, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006741754245012999, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06644079834222794, + 0.020991209894418716, + 0.05731277912855148, + 0.07837633043527603, + 0.44026774168014526, + 0.09512339532375336, + 0.06542257964611053, + 0.052270613610744476, + 0.09084194898605347, + 0.032952629029750824 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006741754245012999 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filmed from a low angle in a medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move slowly and steadily forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the female warrior wearing a full suit of crimson armor with a thick braid of raven hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior performing a fluid sword dance with a katana, including a low stance, swivels, and precise slashes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a windswept rocky cliff with a vast sunset over distant mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02327805757522583 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773277997970581 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02327805757522583, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02327805757522583, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12466412037611008, + 0.050673920661211014, + 0.04307219386100769, + 0.05322699621319771, + 0.10373622924089432, + 0.4493500590324402, + 0.07097915560007095, + 0.04007410258054733, + 0.030458617955446243, + 0.03376460075378418 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02327805757522583 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "medium shot, filmed from a low angle, slowly and steadily moves forward, capturing a female warrior clad in a full suit of crimson armor. She stands at the edge of a windswept rocky cliff, a vast, blazing sunset sinking into the distant mountains behind her. The intense backlight casts a dazzling golden rim around her entire form, making the edges of her crimson lacquer armor gleam like molten gold, while the front of the armor is plunged into deep shadow. Her long, raven hair, braided into a thick braid, swirls in the air as she moves, revealing scattered strands. She wields a slender katana, the blade reflecting the last rays of the setting sun with each swing, slicing brilliant arcs. Her sword dance is fluid and powerful: she begins in a low, calm stance, her body like a drawn bow, then swivels swiftly and gracefully, her wide red culottes unfurling, followed by a series of precise and deadly slashes and blocks, each movement seamlessly connected, full of rhythm and control, as if she were engaging in a solemn duel with an invisible opponent. The entire scene is painted in warm and saturated tones, with the sky stained in a gradient of deep purple and fiery orange, creating an epic, majestic and lonely atmosphere.", + "seed": 30414, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_3/index_1957_seed_30414_dp_6_rank_12_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.08130403836257756, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08130403836257756, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.5, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08130403836257756, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filmed from a low angle in a medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move slowly and steadily forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the female warrior wearing a full suit of crimson armor with a thick braid of raven hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior performing a fluid sword dance with a katana, including a low stance, swivels, and precise slashes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a windswept rocky cliff with a vast sunset over distant mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12961964309215546 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.504619598388672 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12961964309215546, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12961964309215546, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.6232500076293945, + 0.038708992302417755, + 0.01402201596647501, + 0.013199620880186558, + 0.037354130297899246, + 0.033196642994880676, + 0.010483202524483204, + 0.017575083300471306, + 0.049292419105768204, + 0.1629178822040558 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12961964309215546 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filmed from a low angle in a medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move slowly and steadily forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the female warrior wearing a full suit of crimson armor with a thick braid of raven hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior performing a fluid sword dance with a katana, including a low stance, swivels, and precise slashes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a windswept rocky cliff with a vast sunset over distant mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.225557342171669 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6005573272705078 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.225557342171669, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.225557342171669, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04258812218904495, + 0.09415287524461746, + 0.03223877400159836, + 0.05003179982304573, + 0.1883039027452469, + 0.02003553882241249, + 0.03630400821566582, + 0.1499927043914795, + 0.13008926808834076, + 0.25626304745674133 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.225557342171669 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filmed from a low angle in a medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move slowly and steadily forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the female warrior wearing a full suit of crimson armor with a thick braid of raven hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior performing a fluid sword dance with a katana, including a low stance, swivels, and precise slashes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a windswept rocky cliff with a vast sunset over distant mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026347588747739792 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513476371765137 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026347588747739792, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026347588747739792, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5115588307380676, + 0.05092431977391243, + 0.011359653435647488, + 0.012801355682313442, + 0.06464006006717682, + 0.0094350166618824, + 0.013334494084119797, + 0.0439116545021534, + 0.057469915598630905, + 0.22456464171409607 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026347588747739792 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filmed from a low angle in a medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move slowly and steadily forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the female warrior wearing a full suit of crimson armor with a thick braid of raven hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior performing a fluid sword dance with a katana, including a low stance, swivels, and precise slashes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a windswept rocky cliff with a vast sunset over distant mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02328725904226303 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773287296295166 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02328725904226303, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02328725904226303, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5035520195960999, + 0.01951548270881176, + 0.011716310866177082, + 0.017663946375250816, + 0.18895024061203003, + 0.03260999172925949, + 0.06835290789604187, + 0.012175234965980053, + 0.04316822439432144, + 0.10229571908712387 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02328725904226303 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filmed from a low angle in a medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move slowly and steadily forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the female warrior wearing a full suit of crimson armor with a thick braid of raven hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior performing a fluid sword dance with a katana, including a low stance, swivels, and precise slashes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a windswept rocky cliff with a vast sunset over distant mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.001708358759060502 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.376708507537842 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.001708358759060502, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.001708358759060502, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.7854480147361755, + 0.03530683368444443, + 0.008029630407691002, + 0.04212501645088196, + 0.041138261556625366, + 0.006798975169658661, + 0.0103842718526721, + 0.020086204633116722, + 0.0086442856118083, + 0.042038485407829285 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.001708358759060502 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "medium shot, filmed from a low angle, slowly and steadily moves forward, capturing a female warrior clad in a full suit of crimson armor. She stands at the edge of a windswept rocky cliff, a vast, blazing sunset sinking into the distant mountains behind her. The intense backlight casts a dazzling golden rim around her entire form, making the edges of her crimson lacquer armor gleam like molten gold, while the front of the armor is plunged into deep shadow. Her long, raven hair, braided into a thick braid, swirls in the air as she moves, revealing scattered strands. She wields a slender katana, the blade reflecting the last rays of the setting sun with each swing, slicing brilliant arcs. Her sword dance is fluid and powerful: she begins in a low, calm stance, her body like a drawn bow, then swivels swiftly and gracefully, her wide red culottes unfurling, followed by a series of precise and deadly slashes and blocks, each movement seamlessly connected, full of rhythm and control, as if she were engaging in a solemn duel with an invisible opponent. The entire scene is painted in warm and saturated tones, with the sky stained in a gradient of deep purple and fiery orange, creating an epic, majestic and lonely atmosphere.", + "seed": 30415, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_3/index_1957_seed_30415_dp_7_rank_14_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.16500900350511075, + "vlm_logprob": -0.16500900350511075, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.5, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.16500900350511075, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filmed from a low angle in a medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move slowly and steadily forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the female warrior wearing a full suit of crimson armor with a thick braid of raven hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior performing a fluid sword dance with a katana, including a low stance, swivels, and precise slashes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a windswept rocky cliff with a vast sunset over distant mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1440614014863968 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.269061326980591 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1440614014863968, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1440614014863968, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.6313803195953369, + 0.024277305230498314, + 0.018005264922976494, + 0.013613656163215637, + 0.0638355016708374, + 0.042101651430130005, + 0.11720830947160721, + 0.02302982285618782, + 0.0455932579934597, + 0.020954934880137444 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1440614014863968 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filmed from a low angle in a medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move slowly and steadily forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the female warrior wearing a full suit of crimson armor with a thick braid of raven hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior performing a fluid sword dance with a katana, including a low stance, swivels, and precise slashes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a windswept rocky cliff with a vast sunset over distant mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5761648416519165 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8261648416519165 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5761648416519165, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5761648416519165, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09498103708028793, + 0.037365712225437164, + 0.042628008872270584, + 0.016977664083242416, + 0.12138820439577103, + 0.051078688353300095, + 0.10023080557584763, + 0.03997562825679779, + 0.4471011161804199, + 0.04827322065830231 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5761648416519165 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filmed from a low angle in a medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move slowly and steadily forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the female warrior wearing a full suit of crimson armor with a thick braid of raven hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior performing a fluid sword dance with a katana, including a low stance, swivels, and precise slashes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a windswept rocky cliff with a vast sunset over distant mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04866783693432808 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486679077148438 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04866783693432808, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04866783693432808, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3817773461341858, + 0.03874804452061653, + 0.016535846516489983, + 0.024486886337399483, + 0.2398727685213089, + 0.006512512918561697, + 0.08753249049186707, + 0.0730477049946785, + 0.09745410829782486, + 0.034032322466373444 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04866783693432808 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filmed from a low angle in a medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move slowly and steadily forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the female warrior wearing a full suit of crimson armor with a thick braid of raven hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior performing a fluid sword dance with a katana, including a low stance, swivels, and precise slashes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a windswept rocky cliff with a vast sunset over distant mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026363030076026917 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513631343841553 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026363030076026917, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026363030076026917, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3778928816318512, + 0.04628618434071541, + 0.035168275237083435, + 0.07060859352350235, + 0.12338563799858093, + 0.015125260688364506, + 0.04786308854818344, + 0.031127676367759705, + 0.22165116667747498, + 0.03089122287929058 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026363030076026917 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filmed from a low angle in a medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move slowly and steadily forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the female warrior wearing a full suit of crimson armor with a thick braid of raven hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior performing a fluid sword dance with a katana, including a low stance, swivels, and precise slashes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a windswept rocky cliff with a vast sunset over distant mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029787907376885414 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529788017272949 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029787907376885414, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029787907376885414, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.37542760372161865, + 0.022518670186400414, + 0.012842406518757343, + 0.013639470562338829, + 0.47821351885795593, + 0.020823117345571518, + 0.037782225757837296, + 0.012829022482037544, + 0.012349615804851055, + 0.013574385084211826 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029787907376885414 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "medium shot, filmed from a low angle, slowly and steadily moves forward, capturing a female warrior clad in a full suit of crimson armor. She stands at the edge of a windswept rocky cliff, a vast, blazing sunset sinking into the distant mountains behind her. The intense backlight casts a dazzling golden rim around her entire form, making the edges of her crimson lacquer armor gleam like molten gold, while the front of the armor is plunged into deep shadow. Her long, raven hair, braided into a thick braid, swirls in the air as she moves, revealing scattered strands. She wields a slender katana, the blade reflecting the last rays of the setting sun with each swing, slicing brilliant arcs. Her sword dance is fluid and powerful: she begins in a low, calm stance, her body like a drawn bow, then swivels swiftly and gracefully, her wide red culottes unfurling, followed by a series of precise and deadly slashes and blocks, each movement seamlessly connected, full of rhythm and control, as if she were engaging in a solemn duel with an invisible opponent. The entire scene is painted in warm and saturated tones, with the sky stained in a gradient of deep purple and fiery orange, creating an epic, majestic and lonely atmosphere.", + "seed": 30416, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_3/index_1957_seed_30416_dp_7_rank_14_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.17604567743837835, + "vlm_logprob": -0.17604567743837835, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.025, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.17604567743837835, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filmed from a low angle in a medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move slowly and steadily forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the female warrior wearing a full suit of crimson armor with a thick braid of raven hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior performing a fluid sword dance with a katana, including a low stance, swivels, and precise slashes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a windswept rocky cliff with a vast sunset over distant mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14079809188842773 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3907980918884277 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14079809188842773, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14079809188842773, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12626855075359344, + 0.08530524373054504, + 0.09684940427541733, + 0.1321866661310196, + 0.07682882249355316, + 0.17756009101867676, + 0.09812267869710922, + 0.0780496746301651, + 0.04517332464456558, + 0.08365555852651596 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14079809188842773 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filmed from a low angle in a medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move slowly and steadily forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the female warrior wearing a full suit of crimson armor with a thick braid of raven hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior performing a fluid sword dance with a katana, including a low stance, swivels, and precise slashes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a windswept rocky cliff with a vast sunset over distant mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6933615207672119 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6933615207672119 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.6933615207672119, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.6933615207672119, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13341258466243744, + 0.11986107379198074, + 0.041946712881326675, + 0.11584286391735077, + 0.06758152693510056, + 0.08993186056613922, + 0.22451889514923096, + 0.10270389169454575, + 0.051987357437610626, + 0.05221327394247055 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.6933615207672119 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filmed from a low angle in a medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move slowly and steadily forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the female warrior wearing a full suit of crimson armor with a thick braid of raven hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior performing a fluid sword dance with a katana, including a low stance, swivels, and precise slashes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a windswept rocky cliff with a vast sunset over distant mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02635931596159935 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513593196868896 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02635931596159935, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02635931596159935, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.129871666431427, + 0.03857702389359474, + 0.041868217289447784, + 0.03074791468679905, + 0.030284909531474113, + 0.41240209341049194, + 0.06481882929801941, + 0.09978985786437988, + 0.0794680193066597, + 0.07217143476009369 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02635931596159935 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filmed from a low angle in a medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move slowly and steadily forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the female warrior wearing a full suit of crimson armor with a thick braid of raven hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior performing a fluid sword dance with a katana, including a low stance, swivels, and precise slashes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a windswept rocky cliff with a vast sunset over distant mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011080518364906311 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511080741882324 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011080518364906311, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011080518364906311, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11003991961479187, + 0.08197568356990814, + 0.05986252427101135, + 0.04444563388824463, + 0.127152219414711, + 0.10864898562431335, + 0.31273889541625977, + 0.056367505341768265, + 0.05171741545200348, + 0.04705127328634262 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011080518364906311 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filmed from a low angle in a medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move slowly and steadily forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the female warrior wearing a full suit of crimson armor with a thick braid of raven hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior performing a fluid sword dance with a katana, including a low stance, swivels, and precise slashes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a windswept rocky cliff with a vast sunset over distant mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00862894020974636 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758628845214844 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00862894020974636, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00862894020974636, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23925238847732544, + 0.11898193508386612, + 0.12458796799182892, + 0.051968563348054886, + 0.06878333538770676, + 0.14789064228534698, + 0.11935900896787643, + 0.04336404427886009, + 0.03437680006027222, + 0.051435284316539764 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00862894020974636 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_4/index_tensor([1745, 1745])_group_4_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_4/index_tensor([1745, 1745])_group_4_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..3c2f7febb5f5a78845bcf02947752b10e5fc0429 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_4/index_tensor([1745, 1745])_group_4_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "medium shot, the camera gently and fluidly tilting downward to follow the subject's movements, captures a vibrant orange tabby cat taking a swift and graceful leap from the top of a towering, dark wood bookshelf. In a warm study bathed in soft afternoon sunlight, light slanted in through a side window, illuminating tiny dust particles floating in the air and outlining a golden rim across the cat's short, dense fur. With a sudden kick of its hind legs, its body stretched out in mid-air, a fluid orange arc. Its emerald green eyes fixed intently on its target below, its tail balancing steadily behind it. In its leap, its hind paws inevitably swept across several misaligned books on the edge of the shelf, causing the heavy hardcovers to sway violently back and forth. One volume even slipped halfway out, its pages scattering in mid-air, as if poised to fall at any moment, adding a sense of chaotic tension to the graceful leap. The whole picture is painted in warm tones, juxtaposing the agility of cats with the tranquility of the home environment, full of dynamic beauty and storytelling.", + "seed": 12472, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_4/index_1745_seed_12472_dp_8_rank_16_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.34370714239776134, + "vlm_logprob": -0.34370714239776134, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.2, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.34370714239776134, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot of an orange tabby cat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera gently and fluidly tilt downward to follow the subject's movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cat leaping from the top of a towering dark wood bookshelf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are books on the shelf shown swaying violently and one volume slipping with pages scattering?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a warm study with soft afternoon sunlight streaming through a side window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.025225922465324402 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.775225877761841 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.025225922465324402, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.025225922465324402, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13679136335849762, + 0.11738335341215134, + 0.134017676115036, + 0.10749407112598419, + 0.056818172335624695, + 0.16153396666049957, + 0.05918467417359352, + 0.05411972478032112, + 0.058136049658060074, + 0.11452093720436096 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.025225922465324402 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot of an orange tabby cat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera gently and fluidly tilt downward to follow the subject's movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cat leaping from the top of a towering dark wood bookshelf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are books on the shelf shown swaying violently and one volume slipping with pages scattering?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a warm study with soft afternoon sunlight streaming through a side window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03811153024435043 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288111448287964 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03811153024435043, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03811153024435043, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12171663343906403, + 0.12568126618862152, + 0.1734766811132431, + 0.12606416642665863, + 0.07287086546421051, + 0.11997494101524353, + 0.10157693922519684, + 0.08034108579158783, + 0.03553140535950661, + 0.042765989899635315 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03811153024435043 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot of an orange tabby cat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera gently and fluidly tilt downward to follow the subject's movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cat leaping from the top of a towering dark wood bookshelf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are books on the shelf shown swaying violently and one volume slipping with pages scattering?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a warm study with soft afternoon sunlight streaming through a side window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22559158504009247 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6005915403366089 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.22559158504009247, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.22559158504009247, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05620728060603142, + 0.13327325880527496, + 0.10716263204813004, + 0.12432479858398438, + 0.08478962630033493, + 0.22657321393489838, + 0.10217814147472382, + 0.04859009385108948, + 0.03666837885975838, + 0.08023256063461304 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.22559158504009247 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot of an orange tabby cat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera gently and fluidly tilt downward to follow the subject's movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cat leaping from the top of a towering dark wood bookshelf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are books on the shelf shown swaying violently and one volume slipping with pages scattering?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a warm study with soft afternoon sunlight streaming through a side window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4063057899475098 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.28130578994750977 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.4063057899475098, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -1.4063057899475098, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09142285585403442, + 0.08739005029201508, + 0.0746624618768692, + 0.08866944164037704, + 0.13195519149303436, + 0.07130320370197296, + 0.07163725793361664, + 0.08761155605316162, + 0.13212373852729797, + 0.1632242500782013 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.4063057899475098 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot of an orange tabby cat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera gently and fluidly tilt downward to follow the subject's movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cat leaping from the top of a towering dark wood bookshelf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are books on the shelf shown swaying violently and one volume slipping with pages scattering?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a warm study with soft afternoon sunlight streaming through a side window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023300884291529655 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773300886154175 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023300884291529655, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023300884291529655, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16779594123363495, + 0.05451583489775658, + 0.04128522798418999, + 0.07881799340248108, + 0.09657461941242218, + 0.05457228794693947, + 0.05831918865442276, + 0.09466799348592758, + 0.05561378225684166, + 0.29783713817596436 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023300884291529655 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "medium shot, the camera gently and fluidly tilting downward to follow the subject's movements, captures a vibrant orange tabby cat taking a swift and graceful leap from the top of a towering, dark wood bookshelf. In a warm study bathed in soft afternoon sunlight, light slanted in through a side window, illuminating tiny dust particles floating in the air and outlining a golden rim across the cat's short, dense fur. With a sudden kick of its hind legs, its body stretched out in mid-air, a fluid orange arc. Its emerald green eyes fixed intently on its target below, its tail balancing steadily behind it. In its leap, its hind paws inevitably swept across several misaligned books on the edge of the shelf, causing the heavy hardcovers to sway violently back and forth. One volume even slipped halfway out, its pages scattering in mid-air, as if poised to fall at any moment, adding a sense of chaotic tension to the graceful leap. The whole picture is painted in warm tones, juxtaposing the agility of cats with the tranquility of the home environment, full of dynamic beauty and storytelling.", + "seed": 12473, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_4/index_1745_seed_12473_dp_8_rank_16_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.34054980576038363, + "vlm_logprob": -0.34054980576038363, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.275, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.34054980576038363, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot of an orange tabby cat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera gently and fluidly tilt downward to follow the subject's movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cat leaping from the top of a towering dark wood bookshelf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are books on the shelf shown swaying violently and one volume slipping with pages scattering?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a warm study with soft afternoon sunlight streaming through a side window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06366737186908722 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8136672973632812 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06366737186908722, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06366737186908722, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13330405950546265, + 0.1971087008714676, + 0.09453074634075165, + 0.102315753698349, + 0.08626525104045868, + 0.05204392224550247, + 0.06621254235506058, + 0.06602656096220016, + 0.05589691549539566, + 0.14629556238651276 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06366737186908722 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot of an orange tabby cat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera gently and fluidly tilt downward to follow the subject's movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cat leaping from the top of a towering dark wood bookshelf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are books on the shelf shown swaying violently and one volume slipping with pages scattering?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a warm study with soft afternoon sunlight streaming through a side window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029810240492224693 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298101902008057 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029810240492224693, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029810240492224693, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.48106908798217773, + 0.03564762324094772, + 0.019846616312861443, + 0.025832032784819603, + 0.052579641342163086, + 0.04233519732952118, + 0.053979434072971344, + 0.021625524386763573, + 0.048328522592782974, + 0.21875639259815216 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029810240492224693 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot of an orange tabby cat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera gently and fluidly tilt downward to follow the subject's movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cat leaping from the top of a towering dark wood bookshelf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are books on the shelf shown swaying violently and one volume slipping with pages scattering?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a warm study with soft afternoon sunlight streaming through a side window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08902910351753235 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.46402907371521 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08902910351753235, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08902910351753235, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1396324783563614, + 0.23717164993286133, + 0.038485024124383926, + 0.08453910797834396, + 0.07464957982301712, + 0.06599821895360947, + 0.0967177227139473, + 0.05056699365377426, + 0.0701814815402031, + 0.14205777645111084 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08902910351753235 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot of an orange tabby cat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera gently and fluidly tilt downward to follow the subject's movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cat leaping from the top of a towering dark wood bookshelf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are books on the shelf shown swaying violently and one volume slipping with pages scattering?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a warm study with soft afternoon sunlight streaming through a side window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5020527839660645 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2520527243614197 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.5020527839660645, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -1.5020527839660645, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07310878485441208, + 0.05742594972252846, + 0.05210372060537338, + 0.040022555738687515, + 0.10819649696350098, + 0.056962620466947556, + 0.10762099921703339, + 0.054096467792987823, + 0.0766761526465416, + 0.3737863600254059 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.5020527839660645 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot of an orange tabby cat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera gently and fluidly tilt downward to follow the subject's movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cat leaping from the top of a towering dark wood bookshelf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are books on the shelf shown swaying violently and one volume slipping with pages scattering?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a warm study with soft afternoon sunlight streaming through a side window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018189528957009315 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018189430236816 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018189528957009315, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018189528957009315, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.8160810470581055, + 0.022044885903596878, + 0.009279705584049225, + 0.004489841405302286, + 0.035320207476615906, + 0.008898844011127949, + 0.01146715972572565, + 0.006270754151046276, + 0.011658146977424622, + 0.07448943704366684 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018189528957009315 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "medium shot, the camera gently and fluidly tilting downward to follow the subject's movements, captures a vibrant orange tabby cat taking a swift and graceful leap from the top of a towering, dark wood bookshelf. In a warm study bathed in soft afternoon sunlight, light slanted in through a side window, illuminating tiny dust particles floating in the air and outlining a golden rim across the cat's short, dense fur. With a sudden kick of its hind legs, its body stretched out in mid-air, a fluid orange arc. Its emerald green eyes fixed intently on its target below, its tail balancing steadily behind it. In its leap, its hind paws inevitably swept across several misaligned books on the edge of the shelf, causing the heavy hardcovers to sway violently back and forth. One volume even slipped halfway out, its pages scattering in mid-air, as if poised to fall at any moment, adding a sense of chaotic tension to the graceful leap. The whole picture is painted in warm tones, juxtaposing the agility of cats with the tranquility of the home environment, full of dynamic beauty and storytelling.", + "seed": 12474, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_4/index_1745_seed_12474_dp_9_rank_18_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.35379274571314456, + "vlm_logprob": -0.35379274571314456, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.7, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.35379274571314456, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot of an orange tabby cat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera gently and fluidly tilt downward to follow the subject's movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cat leaping from the top of a towering dark wood bookshelf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are books on the shelf shown swaying violently and one volume slipping with pages scattering?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a warm study with soft afternoon sunlight streaming through a side window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026430951431393623 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.77643084526062 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026430951431393623, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026430951431393623, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09867393225431442, + 0.08895209431648254, + 0.0382474921643734, + 0.05760418623685837, + 0.03287110477685928, + 0.05887412652373314, + 0.017952270805835724, + 0.2946883738040924, + 0.2648104131221771, + 0.04732599854469299 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026430951431393623 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot of an orange tabby cat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera gently and fluidly tilt downward to follow the subject's movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cat leaping from the top of a towering dark wood bookshelf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are books on the shelf shown swaying violently and one volume slipping with pages scattering?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a warm study with soft afternoon sunlight streaming through a side window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.038104645907878876 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.28810453414917 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.038104645907878876, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.038104645907878876, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08283297717571259, + 0.0731796994805336, + 0.031861238181591034, + 0.04653189331293106, + 0.027292726561427116, + 0.022963155061006546, + 0.030408289283514023, + 0.1897232085466385, + 0.4531152546405792, + 0.04209155589342117 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.038104645907878876 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot of an orange tabby cat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera gently and fluidly tilt downward to follow the subject's movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cat leaping from the top of a towering dark wood bookshelf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are books on the shelf shown swaying violently and one volume slipping with pages scattering?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a warm study with soft afternoon sunlight streaming through a side window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10029080510139465 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3502907752990723 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10029080510139465, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10029080510139465, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.050789058208465576, + 0.06146802753210068, + 0.033532023429870605, + 0.03342963010072708, + 0.04600432515144348, + 0.03444848954677582, + 0.045998070389032364, + 0.31714126467704773, + 0.34730544686317444, + 0.029883626848459244 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10029080510139465 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot of an orange tabby cat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera gently and fluidly tilt downward to follow the subject's movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cat leaping from the top of a towering dark wood bookshelf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are books on the shelf shown swaying violently and one volume slipping with pages scattering?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a warm study with soft afternoon sunlight streaming through a side window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.600525140762329 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22552518546581268 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.600525140762329, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -1.600525140762329, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09230992197990417, + 0.07916184514760971, + 0.09660163521766663, + 0.03840862959623337, + 0.07320774346590042, + 0.06643011420965195, + 0.10133136808872223, + 0.10040809959173203, + 0.11319200694561005, + 0.23894861340522766 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.600525140762329 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot of an orange tabby cat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera gently and fluidly tilt downward to follow the subject's movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cat leaping from the top of a towering dark wood bookshelf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are books on the shelf shown swaying violently and one volume slipping with pages scattering?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a warm study with soft afternoon sunlight streaming through a side window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00361218536272645 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628612041473389 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00361218536272645, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00361218536272645, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1169092208147049, + 0.04054519534111023, + 0.0453110933303833, + 0.04545838385820389, + 0.030711127445101738, + 0.03999732807278633, + 0.06044735386967659, + 0.38951465487480164, + 0.08159933984279633, + 0.14950627088546753 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00361218536272645 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "medium shot, the camera gently and fluidly tilting downward to follow the subject's movements, captures a vibrant orange tabby cat taking a swift and graceful leap from the top of a towering, dark wood bookshelf. In a warm study bathed in soft afternoon sunlight, light slanted in through a side window, illuminating tiny dust particles floating in the air and outlining a golden rim across the cat's short, dense fur. With a sudden kick of its hind legs, its body stretched out in mid-air, a fluid orange arc. Its emerald green eyes fixed intently on its target below, its tail balancing steadily behind it. In its leap, its hind paws inevitably swept across several misaligned books on the edge of the shelf, causing the heavy hardcovers to sway violently back and forth. One volume even slipped halfway out, its pages scattering in mid-air, as if poised to fall at any moment, adding a sense of chaotic tension to the graceful leap. The whole picture is painted in warm tones, juxtaposing the agility of cats with the tranquility of the home environment, full of dynamic beauty and storytelling.", + "seed": 12475, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_4/index_1745_seed_12475_dp_9_rank_18_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.2857248105108738, + "vlm_logprob": -0.2857248105108738, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.200000023841858, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.2857248105108738, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot of an orange tabby cat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera gently and fluidly tilt downward to follow the subject's movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cat leaping from the top of a towering dark wood bookshelf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are books on the shelf shown swaying violently and one volume slipping with pages scattering?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a warm study with soft afternoon sunlight streaming through a side window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016610775142908096 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.391610622406006 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016610775142908096, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016610775142908096, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.46335503458976746, + 0.07294182479381561, + 0.03379204124212265, + 0.02050246298313141, + 0.03137916326522827, + 0.03723149374127388, + 0.1089385375380516, + 0.05942036211490631, + 0.06255026906728745, + 0.10988876968622208 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016610775142908096 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot of an orange tabby cat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera gently and fluidly tilt downward to follow the subject's movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cat leaping from the top of a towering dark wood bookshelf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are books on the shelf shown swaying violently and one volume slipping with pages scattering?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a warm study with soft afternoon sunlight streaming through a side window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04307687282562256 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168076992034912 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04307687282562256, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04307687282562256, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1620529145002365, + 0.039562687277793884, + 0.05405532568693161, + 0.013012432493269444, + 0.02945059910416603, + 0.07887788861989975, + 0.18176941573619843, + 0.10036449134349823, + 0.25181102752685547, + 0.08904320746660233 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04307687282562256 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot of an orange tabby cat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera gently and fluidly tilt downward to follow the subject's movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cat leaping from the top of a towering dark wood bookshelf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are books on the shelf shown swaying violently and one volume slipping with pages scattering?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a warm study with soft afternoon sunlight streaming through a side window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.142801895737648 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0178020000457764 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.142801895737648, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.8750001192092896, + "token_credit_reward": -0.142801895737648, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19571049511432648, + 0.0981178805232048, + 0.07121296972036362, + 0.08143747597932816, + 0.042941849678754807, + 0.11569008231163025, + 0.08052152395248413, + 0.06503145396709442, + 0.124173104763031, + 0.12516318261623383 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.142801895737648 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot of an orange tabby cat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera gently and fluidly tilt downward to follow the subject's movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cat leaping from the top of a towering dark wood bookshelf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are books on the shelf shown swaying violently and one volume slipping with pages scattering?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a warm study with soft afternoon sunlight streaming through a side window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1370625495910645 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.38706257939338684 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.1370625495910645, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -1.1370625495910645, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15557768940925598, + 0.046221163123846054, + 0.021111322566866875, + 0.013582390733063221, + 0.01936819776892662, + 0.11935572326183319, + 0.10561542212963104, + 0.09278780966997147, + 0.05450164154171944, + 0.37187856435775757 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.1370625495910645 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot of an orange tabby cat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera gently and fluidly tilt downward to follow the subject's movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cat leaping from the top of a towering dark wood bookshelf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are books on the shelf shown swaying violently and one volume slipping with pages scattering?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a warm study with soft afternoon sunlight streaming through a side window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08907195925712585 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4640719890594482 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08907195925712585, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08907195925712585, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17475545406341553, + 0.048315927386283875, + 0.02541169337928295, + 0.019479982554912567, + 0.10697830468416214, + 0.04165279120206833, + 0.1419415920972824, + 0.04213865473866463, + 0.08435679972171783, + 0.3149687647819519 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08907195925712585 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_5/index_tensor([8541, 8541])_group_5_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_5/index_tensor([8541, 8541])_group_5_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..09651387f5ed02546805abcafb0f626046319427 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_5/index_tensor([8541, 8541])_group_5_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "high-angle drone shot unfolds across a multi-lane highway, its dark, wet asphalt carving a steep path across the landscape. The camera then begins a slow, graceful vertical ascent to reveal a wider bird's-eye view. The entire scene is blanketed by a thick, low-hanging white mist, creating an ethereal, diffuse glow that eliminates harsh shadows. This mist lingers over the surrounding fields, softening the outlines of distant trees and rendering the background a soft, desaturated palette of greens and browns. A steady, rhythmic stream of vehicles, including large semi-trucks with long trailers and various cars, moves smoothly in both directions along the highway. Their headlights and taillights pierce the dense air, appearing as soft, glowing white and red spheres gliding along the pavement. As the camera steadily and deliberately pans upward, the individual vehicles shrink, their orderly procession becoming part of a larger, hypnotic pattern, intensifying the profound tranquility and slightly misty atmosphere of the still morning.", + "seed": 11452, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_5/index_8541_seed_11452_dp_10_rank_20_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.022173208510503174, + "vlm_logprob": -0.022173208510503174, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.6, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.022173208510503174, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a multi-lane highway with dark, wet asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment blanketed by a thick, low-hanging white mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are large semi-trucks with long trailers and various cars visible moving in both directions?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the vehicle headlights and taillights appear as soft, glowing white and red spheres?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, graceful vertical ascent to reveal a wider bird's-eye view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009209178388118744 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.009209156036377 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009209178388118744, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009209178388118744, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13011208176612854, + 0.2741589844226837, + 0.21029454469680786, + 0.05904802680015564, + 0.043423429131507874, + 0.08642541617155075, + 0.04138322174549103, + 0.049179624766111374, + 0.030895348638296127, + 0.0750792920589447 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009209178388118744 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a multi-lane highway with dark, wet asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment blanketed by a thick, low-hanging white mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are large semi-trucks with long trailers and various cars visible moving in both directions?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the vehicle headlights and taillights appear as soft, glowing white and red spheres?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, graceful vertical ascent to reveal a wider bird's-eye view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0022067499812692404 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127206802368164 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0022067499812692404, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0022067499812692404, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1794840395450592, + 0.24229112267494202, + 0.17223337292671204, + 0.08603683114051819, + 0.06063214689493179, + 0.019612427800893784, + 0.042822133749723434, + 0.08771994709968567, + 0.07668991386890411, + 0.03247803449630737 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0022067499812692404 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a multi-lane highway with dark, wet asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment blanketed by a thick, low-hanging white mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are large semi-trucks with long trailers and various cars visible moving in both directions?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the vehicle headlights and taillights appear as soft, glowing white and red spheres?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, graceful vertical ascent to reveal a wider bird's-eye view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011081107892096043 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511081218719482 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011081107892096043, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011081107892096043, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20778866112232208, + 0.1832013577222824, + 0.10430493950843811, + 0.03933793306350708, + 0.06371013075113297, + 0.17098014056682587, + 0.06057640537619591, + 0.052579209208488464, + 0.04524383693933487, + 0.07227741181850433 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011081107892096043 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a multi-lane highway with dark, wet asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment blanketed by a thick, low-hanging white mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are large semi-trucks with long trailers and various cars visible moving in both directions?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the vehicle headlights and taillights appear as soft, glowing white and red spheres?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, graceful vertical ascent to reveal a wider bird's-eye view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02634178288280964 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651341676712036 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02634178288280964, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02634178288280964, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11379595100879669, + 0.2847518026828766, + 0.1365138441324234, + 0.04933985322713852, + 0.11000366508960724, + 0.05681677162647247, + 0.08048223704099655, + 0.0506943017244339, + 0.08656155318021774, + 0.03104001097381115 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02634178288280964 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a multi-lane highway with dark, wet asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment blanketed by a thick, low-hanging white mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are large semi-trucks with long trailers and various cars visible moving in both directions?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the vehicle headlights and taillights appear as soft, glowing white and red spheres?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, graceful vertical ascent to reveal a wider bird's-eye view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0620272234082222 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120272159576416 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0620272234082222, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0620272234082222, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19756747782230377, + 0.28406068682670593, + 0.052400313317775726, + 0.06429216265678406, + 0.07327920943498611, + 0.09100160747766495, + 0.037685129791498184, + 0.09952693432569504, + 0.04409210756421089, + 0.056094419211149216 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0620272234082222 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "high-angle drone shot unfolds across a multi-lane highway, its dark, wet asphalt carving a steep path across the landscape. The camera then begins a slow, graceful vertical ascent to reveal a wider bird's-eye view. The entire scene is blanketed by a thick, low-hanging white mist, creating an ethereal, diffuse glow that eliminates harsh shadows. This mist lingers over the surrounding fields, softening the outlines of distant trees and rendering the background a soft, desaturated palette of greens and browns. A steady, rhythmic stream of vehicles, including large semi-trucks with long trailers and various cars, moves smoothly in both directions along the highway. Their headlights and taillights pierce the dense air, appearing as soft, glowing white and red spheres gliding along the pavement. As the camera steadily and deliberately pans upward, the individual vehicles shrink, their orderly procession becoming part of a larger, hypnotic pattern, intensifying the profound tranquility and slightly misty atmosphere of the still morning.", + "seed": 11453, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_5/index_8541_seed_11453_dp_10_rank_20_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.07899177521467209, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07899177521467209, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.050000023841858, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07899177521467209, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a multi-lane highway with dark, wet asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment blanketed by a thick, low-hanging white mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are large semi-trucks with long trailers and various cars visible moving in both directions?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the vehicle headlights and taillights appear as soft, glowing white and red spheres?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, graceful vertical ascent to reveal a wider bird's-eye view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14654602110385895 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0215461254119873 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14654602110385895, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.8750001192092896, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14654602110385895, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23181982338428497, + 0.0889766663312912, + 0.17119711637496948, + 0.12786529958248138, + 0.10161632299423218, + 0.08378878980875015, + 0.07564695924520493, + 0.053617991507053375, + 0.02361348830163479, + 0.0418575182557106 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14654602110385895 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a multi-lane highway with dark, wet asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment blanketed by a thick, low-hanging white mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are large semi-trucks with long trailers and various cars visible moving in both directions?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the vehicle headlights and taillights appear as soft, glowing white and red spheres?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, graceful vertical ascent to reveal a wider bird's-eye view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02061477117240429 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8956148624420166 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02061477117240429, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02061477117240429, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15079481899738312, + 0.29438453912734985, + 0.0659106969833374, + 0.03381657227873802, + 0.16944465041160583, + 0.076789990067482, + 0.10203734785318375, + 0.07156707346439362, + 0.009272673167288303, + 0.025981590151786804 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02061477117240429 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a multi-lane highway with dark, wet asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment blanketed by a thick, low-hanging white mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are large semi-trucks with long trailers and various cars visible moving in both directions?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the vehicle headlights and taillights appear as soft, glowing white and red spheres?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, graceful vertical ascent to reveal a wider bird's-eye view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03812460973858833 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881245613098145 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03812460973858833, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03812460973858833, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22876527905464172, + 0.09821122139692307, + 0.0536615252494812, + 0.04197011888027191, + 0.06703720986843109, + 0.1571355015039444, + 0.09722212702035904, + 0.09585477411746979, + 0.03425140678882599, + 0.1258908212184906 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03812460973858833 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a multi-lane highway with dark, wet asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment blanketed by a thick, low-hanging white mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are large semi-trucks with long trailers and various cars visible moving in both directions?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the vehicle headlights and taillights appear as soft, glowing white and red spheres?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, graceful vertical ascent to reveal a wider bird's-eye view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009784122928977013 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.63478422164917 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009784122928977013, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009784122928977013, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1313699185848236, + 0.1649763137102127, + 0.06298638135194778, + 0.09507500380277634, + 0.13211065530776978, + 0.10110855102539062, + 0.10334844887256622, + 0.05790475383400917, + 0.056179579347372055, + 0.09494032710790634 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009784122928977013 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a multi-lane highway with dark, wet asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment blanketed by a thick, low-hanging white mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are large semi-trucks with long trailers and various cars visible moving in both directions?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the vehicle headlights and taillights appear as soft, glowing white and red spheres?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, graceful vertical ascent to reveal a wider bird's-eye view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17988935112953186 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8048893213272095 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17988935112953186, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17988935112953186, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22960889339447021, + 0.13617321848869324, + 0.06773781031370163, + 0.10676993429660797, + 0.09185531735420227, + 0.10236036777496338, + 0.054542362689971924, + 0.06767597049474716, + 0.054812632501125336, + 0.0884634479880333 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17988935112953186 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "high-angle drone shot unfolds across a multi-lane highway, its dark, wet asphalt carving a steep path across the landscape. The camera then begins a slow, graceful vertical ascent to reveal a wider bird's-eye view. The entire scene is blanketed by a thick, low-hanging white mist, creating an ethereal, diffuse glow that eliminates harsh shadows. This mist lingers over the surrounding fields, softening the outlines of distant trees and rendering the background a soft, desaturated palette of greens and browns. A steady, rhythmic stream of vehicles, including large semi-trucks with long trailers and various cars, moves smoothly in both directions along the highway. Their headlights and taillights pierce the dense air, appearing as soft, glowing white and red spheres gliding along the pavement. As the camera steadily and deliberately pans upward, the individual vehicles shrink, their orderly procession becoming part of a larger, hypnotic pattern, intensifying the profound tranquility and slightly misty atmosphere of the still morning.", + "seed": 11454, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_5/index_8541_seed_11454_dp_11_rank_22_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.03173965476453304, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03173965476453304, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.925, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03173965476453304, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a multi-lane highway with dark, wet asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment blanketed by a thick, low-hanging white mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are large semi-trucks with long trailers and various cars visible moving in both directions?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the vehicle headlights and taillights appear as soft, glowing white and red spheres?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, graceful vertical ascent to reveal a wider bird's-eye view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011885304003953934 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.136885166168213 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011885304003953934, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011885304003953934, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13883499801158905, + 0.06809359043836594, + 0.026986416429281235, + 0.05501849204301834, + 0.05789664015173912, + 0.07499571144580841, + 0.14848415553569794, + 0.10147794336080551, + 0.20393715798854828, + 0.12427488714456558 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011885304003953934 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a multi-lane highway with dark, wet asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment blanketed by a thick, low-hanging white mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are large semi-trucks with long trailers and various cars visible moving in both directions?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the vehicle headlights and taillights appear as soft, glowing white and red spheres?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, graceful vertical ascent to reveal a wider bird's-eye view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0097922682762146 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634792327880859 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0097922682762146, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0097922682762146, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04653391242027283, + 0.07242095470428467, + 0.03692861273884773, + 0.06077670678496361, + 0.0748715028166771, + 0.07131519168615341, + 0.21369627118110657, + 0.1560543179512024, + 0.0855434238910675, + 0.1818590611219406 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0097922682762146 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a multi-lane highway with dark, wet asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment blanketed by a thick, low-hanging white mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are large semi-trucks with long trailers and various cars visible moving in both directions?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the vehicle headlights and taillights appear as soft, glowing white and red spheres?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, graceful vertical ascent to reveal a wider bird's-eye view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029813826084136963 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529813766479492 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029813826084136963, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029813826084136963, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15410350263118744, + 0.041524309664964676, + 0.04071088507771492, + 0.08345036953687668, + 0.04697658121585846, + 0.2147441804409027, + 0.11116014420986176, + 0.16653862595558167, + 0.0537433996796608, + 0.08704796433448792 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029813826084136963 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a multi-lane highway with dark, wet asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment blanketed by a thick, low-hanging white mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are large semi-trucks with long trailers and various cars visible moving in both directions?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the vehicle headlights and taillights appear as soft, glowing white and red spheres?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, graceful vertical ascent to reveal a wider bird's-eye view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018185080960392952 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018185138702393 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018185080960392952, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018185080960392952, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11051606386899948, + 0.13133126497268677, + 0.06358116120100021, + 0.12097716331481934, + 0.05256900563836098, + 0.0880758985877037, + 0.12905532121658325, + 0.04288225993514061, + 0.0733928456902504, + 0.18761904537677765 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018185080960392952 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a multi-lane highway with dark, wet asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment blanketed by a thick, low-hanging white mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are large semi-trucks with long trailers and various cars visible moving in both directions?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the vehicle headlights and taillights appear as soft, glowing white and red spheres?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, graceful vertical ascent to reveal a wider bird's-eye view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08902179449796677 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.464021682739258 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08902179449796677, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08902179449796677, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12804268300533295, + 0.06550265848636627, + 0.05273369699716568, + 0.05028613284230232, + 0.04626379907131195, + 0.15387459099292755, + 0.19465911388397217, + 0.14904572069644928, + 0.055391576141119, + 0.10419996827840805 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08902179449796677 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "high-angle drone shot unfolds across a multi-lane highway, its dark, wet asphalt carving a steep path across the landscape. The camera then begins a slow, graceful vertical ascent to reveal a wider bird's-eye view. The entire scene is blanketed by a thick, low-hanging white mist, creating an ethereal, diffuse glow that eliminates harsh shadows. This mist lingers over the surrounding fields, softening the outlines of distant trees and rendering the background a soft, desaturated palette of greens and browns. A steady, rhythmic stream of vehicles, including large semi-trucks with long trailers and various cars, moves smoothly in both directions along the highway. Their headlights and taillights pierce the dense air, appearing as soft, glowing white and red spheres gliding along the pavement. As the camera steadily and deliberately pans upward, the individual vehicles shrink, their orderly procession becoming part of a larger, hypnotic pattern, intensifying the profound tranquility and slightly misty atmosphere of the still morning.", + "seed": 11455, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_5/index_8541_seed_11455_dp_11_rank_22_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.012517869006842375, + "vlm_logprob": -0.012517869006842375, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.6, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.012517869006842375, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a multi-lane highway with dark, wet asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment blanketed by a thick, low-hanging white mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are large semi-trucks with long trailers and various cars visible moving in both directions?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the vehicle headlights and taillights appear as soft, glowing white and red spheres?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, graceful vertical ascent to reveal a wider bird's-eye view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016487659886479378 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.6414875984191895 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016487659886479378, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016487659886479378, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06245351582765579, + 0.028083419427275658, + 0.1251884400844574, + 0.09697359055280685, + 0.13576245307922363, + 0.03819141536951065, + 0.23901134729385376, + 0.025606710463762283, + 0.21451984345912933, + 0.03420927748084068 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016487659886479378 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a multi-lane highway with dark, wet asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment blanketed by a thick, low-hanging white mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are large semi-trucks with long trailers and various cars visible moving in both directions?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the vehicle headlights and taillights appear as soft, glowing white and red spheres?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, graceful vertical ascent to reveal a wider bird's-eye view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009806079789996147 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634806156158447 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009806079789996147, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009806079789996147, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.017273377627134323, + 0.016600249335169792, + 0.5483441352844238, + 0.030464159324765205, + 0.07102058082818985, + 0.018711965531110764, + 0.07447527348995209, + 0.009831760078668594, + 0.20831410586833954, + 0.004964351654052734 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009806079789996147 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a multi-lane highway with dark, wet asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment blanketed by a thick, low-hanging white mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are large semi-trucks with long trailers and various cars visible moving in both directions?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the vehicle headlights and taillights appear as soft, glowing white and red spheres?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, graceful vertical ascent to reveal a wider bird's-eye view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004644558299332857 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379644393920898 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004644558299332857, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004644558299332857, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14239256083965302, + 0.06840281188488007, + 0.2138281911611557, + 0.0766042098402977, + 0.06951865553855896, + 0.04642127454280853, + 0.20784273743629456, + 0.05258401855826378, + 0.07079978287220001, + 0.05160573869943619 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004644558299332857 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a multi-lane highway with dark, wet asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment blanketed by a thick, low-hanging white mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are large semi-trucks with long trailers and various cars visible moving in both directions?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the vehicle headlights and taillights appear as soft, glowing white and red spheres?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, graceful vertical ascent to reveal a wider bird's-eye view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020581021904945374 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895581007003784 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020581021904945374, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020581021904945374, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0795489177107811, + 0.028037119656801224, + 0.3196500837802887, + 0.04889177158474922, + 0.07455001771450043, + 0.03797835484147072, + 0.05145673453807831, + 0.018140902742743492, + 0.3226804733276367, + 0.01906557008624077 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020581021904945374 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a multi-lane highway with dark, wet asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment blanketed by a thick, low-hanging white mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are large semi-trucks with long trailers and various cars visible moving in both directions?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the vehicle headlights and taillights appear as soft, glowing white and red spheres?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, graceful vertical ascent to reveal a wider bird's-eye view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011070025153458118 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511070251464844 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011070025153458118, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011070025153458118, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04249364137649536, + 0.051413219422101974, + 0.6114137172698975, + 0.042835719883441925, + 0.0837181881070137, + 0.04972640424966812, + 0.02556103840470314, + 0.04315797612071037, + 0.02768203616142273, + 0.02199808694422245 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011070025153458118 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_6/index_tensor([9698, 9698])_group_6_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_6/index_tensor([9698, 9698])_group_6_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..1cfa8b87b056f45527eab4fe2c7e0a976706b6cd --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_6/index_tensor([9698, 9698])_group_6_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "single, static, low-angle, tightly framed shot captures the scene of a massive natural force with stark documentary realism, captured with a high-speed camera. The sky is plunged into the mysterious twilight of a total solar eclipse, a deep, ominous indigo. The sun is a perfect black disk, haloed by the ghostly, shimmering white tendrils of the corona. A massive bolt of lightning tears through this backdrop, descending in breathtaking slow motion. Its core channel is a searing, overexposed white, from which intricate filaments of purple plasma branch out, like crystalline structures, deliberately crawling across the dark sky. The bolt's trajectory terminates precisely on the slender metal antenna spire of a towering skyscraper, its steel structure silhouetted against the strange light. The moment the main tendril makes contact, a violent and silent eruption of fiery white and orange sparks erupts from the tip, cascading down like a fiery waterfall, landing on the building's dark facade, each molten particle rendered in surreal clarity. The entire event unfolds with a sense of detached observation, creating an atmosphere of awe-inspiring and terrifying beauty that underscores the raw, untamed physics of the phenomenon.", + "seed": 14948, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_6/index_9698_seed_14948_dp_12_rank_24_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.19198237266391516, + "vlm_logprob": -0.19198237266391516, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.524999976158142, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.19198237266391516, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low and tightly framed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sky depicted as a deep indigo color with a perfect black disk sun surrounded by a white corona?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive bolt of lightning shown descending in slow motion with a white core and purple plasma filaments?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lightning strike a slender metal antenna spire on a towering skyscraper, causing an eruption of white and orange sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered with stark documentary realism and surreal clarity?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7233564257621765 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7233564257621765 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.7233564257621765, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.7233564257621765, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13314691185951233, + 0.32928499579429626, + 0.05068650469183922, + 0.04689561203122139, + 0.12765227258205414, + 0.05598494037985802, + 0.10173770040273666, + 0.0852796658873558, + 0.0318036824464798, + 0.03752772882580757 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.7233564257621765 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low and tightly framed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sky depicted as a deep indigo color with a perfect black disk sun surrounded by a white corona?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive bolt of lightning shown descending in slow motion with a white core and purple plasma filaments?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lightning strike a slender metal antenna spire on a towering skyscraper, causing an eruption of white and orange sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered with stark documentary realism and surreal clarity?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03813711926341057 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288137197494507 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03813711926341057, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03813711926341057, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10779134184122086, + 0.5442295074462891, + 0.022077325731515884, + 0.01998940110206604, + 0.04052901268005371, + 0.1625037044286728, + 0.036825988441705704, + 0.04009527713060379, + 0.014743216335773468, + 0.011215213686227798 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03813711926341057 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low and tightly framed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sky depicted as a deep indigo color with a perfect black disk sun surrounded by a white corona?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive bolt of lightning shown descending in slow motion with a white core and purple plasma filaments?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lightning strike a slender metal antenna spire on a towering skyscraper, causing an eruption of white and orange sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered with stark documentary realism and surreal clarity?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012544064782559872 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.38754415512085 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012544064782559872, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012544064782559872, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0740073025226593, + 0.4707950949668884, + 0.05566292628645897, + 0.036282215267419815, + 0.05043713003396988, + 0.030952462926506996, + 0.03650594502687454, + 0.18359708786010742, + 0.02723737433552742, + 0.034522440284490585 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012544064782559872 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low and tightly framed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sky depicted as a deep indigo color with a perfect black disk sun surrounded by a white corona?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive bolt of lightning shown descending in slow motion with a white core and purple plasma filaments?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lightning strike a slender metal antenna spire on a towering skyscraper, causing an eruption of white and orange sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered with stark documentary realism and surreal clarity?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04306739568710327 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168067455291748 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04306739568710327, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04306739568710327, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0723608210682869, + 0.5209499001502991, + 0.019872276112437248, + 0.05428621545433998, + 0.028765665367245674, + 0.024366773664951324, + 0.05338502302765846, + 0.11264962702989578, + 0.06651511788368225, + 0.04684856906533241 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04306739568710327 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low and tightly framed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sky depicted as a deep indigo color with a perfect black disk sun surrounded by a white corona?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive bolt of lightning shown descending in slow motion with a white core and purple plasma filaments?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lightning strike a slender metal antenna spire on a towering skyscraper, causing an eruption of white and orange sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered with stark documentary realism and surreal clarity?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14280685782432556 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0178067684173584 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14280685782432556, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.8749998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14280685782432556, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.040361106395721436, + 0.6037930250167847, + 0.03239339217543602, + 0.028319191187620163, + 0.04988328740000725, + 0.03384847193956375, + 0.02577226236462593, + 0.07707955688238144, + 0.06177018582820892, + 0.046779513359069824 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14280685782432556 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "single, static, low-angle, tightly framed shot captures the scene of a massive natural force with stark documentary realism, captured with a high-speed camera. The sky is plunged into the mysterious twilight of a total solar eclipse, a deep, ominous indigo. The sun is a perfect black disk, haloed by the ghostly, shimmering white tendrils of the corona. A massive bolt of lightning tears through this backdrop, descending in breathtaking slow motion. Its core channel is a searing, overexposed white, from which intricate filaments of purple plasma branch out, like crystalline structures, deliberately crawling across the dark sky. The bolt's trajectory terminates precisely on the slender metal antenna spire of a towering skyscraper, its steel structure silhouetted against the strange light. The moment the main tendril makes contact, a violent and silent eruption of fiery white and orange sparks erupts from the tip, cascading down like a fiery waterfall, landing on the building's dark facade, each molten particle rendered in surreal clarity. The entire event unfolds with a sense of detached observation, creating an atmosphere of awe-inspiring and terrifying beauty that underscores the raw, untamed physics of the phenomenon.", + "seed": 14949, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_6/index_9698_seed_14949_dp_12_rank_24_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.14611809817142785, + "vlm_logprob": -0.14611809817142785, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.950000011920929, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.14611809817142785, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low and tightly framed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sky depicted as a deep indigo color with a perfect black disk sun surrounded by a white corona?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive bolt of lightning shown descending in slow motion with a white core and purple plasma filaments?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lightning strike a slender metal antenna spire on a towering skyscraper, causing an eruption of white and orange sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered with stark documentary realism and surreal clarity?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.48634523153305054 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1113452911376953 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.48634523153305054, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.6250000596046448, + "token_credit_reward": -0.48634523153305054, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11535326391458511, + 0.029950372874736786, + 0.05626606196165085, + 0.07372041046619415, + 0.18100079894065857, + 0.17748889327049255, + 0.09552593529224396, + 0.02751249447464943, + 0.0406353585422039, + 0.20254644751548767 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.48634523153305054 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low and tightly framed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sky depicted as a deep indigo color with a perfect black disk sun surrounded by a white corona?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive bolt of lightning shown descending in slow motion with a white core and purple plasma filaments?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lightning strike a slender metal antenna spire on a towering skyscraper, causing an eruption of white and orange sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered with stark documentary realism and surreal clarity?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01822218857705593 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018222332000732 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01822218857705593, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01822218857705593, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19793321192264557, + 0.07911662012338638, + 0.12125436216592789, + 0.030809618532657623, + 0.08025655150413513, + 0.19506840407848358, + 0.050977300852537155, + 0.15919987857341766, + 0.04123804718255997, + 0.04414597153663635 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01822218857705593 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low and tightly framed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sky depicted as a deep indigo color with a perfect black disk sun surrounded by a white corona?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive bolt of lightning shown descending in slow motion with a white core and purple plasma filaments?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lightning strike a slender metal antenna spire on a towering skyscraper, causing an eruption of white and orange sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered with stark documentary realism and surreal clarity?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003618955845013261 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628619194030762 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003618955845013261, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003618955845013261, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15324623882770538, + 0.058872904628515244, + 0.11303714662790298, + 0.10427896678447723, + 0.10993218421936035, + 0.046309590339660645, + 0.06595107167959213, + 0.06790842860937119, + 0.06787627190351486, + 0.2125871479511261 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003618955845013261 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low and tightly framed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sky depicted as a deep indigo color with a perfect black disk sun surrounded by a white corona?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive bolt of lightning shown descending in slow motion with a white core and purple plasma filaments?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lightning strike a slender metal antenna spire on a towering skyscraper, causing an eruption of white and orange sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered with stark documentary realism and surreal clarity?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06206139177083969 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812061309814453 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06206139177083969, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06206139177083969, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05926643684506416, + 0.042971983551979065, + 0.11729838699102402, + 0.15510547161102295, + 0.1245729923248291, + 0.0350785106420517, + 0.0761689618229866, + 0.06061438098549843, + 0.03393033519387245, + 0.29499247670173645 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06206139177083969 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low and tightly framed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sky depicted as a deep indigo color with a perfect black disk sun surrounded by a white corona?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive bolt of lightning shown descending in slow motion with a white core and purple plasma filaments?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lightning strike a slender metal antenna spire on a towering skyscraper, causing an eruption of white and orange sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered with stark documentary realism and surreal clarity?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1603427231311798 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9103426933288574 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1603427231311798, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1603427231311798, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18619932234287262, + 0.061362799257040024, + 0.04140055179595947, + 0.06692173331975937, + 0.14125683903694153, + 0.1613573431968689, + 0.04955757409334183, + 0.07355725765228271, + 0.04501323029398918, + 0.17337334156036377 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1603427231311798 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "single, static, low-angle, tightly framed shot captures the scene of a massive natural force with stark documentary realism, captured with a high-speed camera. The sky is plunged into the mysterious twilight of a total solar eclipse, a deep, ominous indigo. The sun is a perfect black disk, haloed by the ghostly, shimmering white tendrils of the corona. A massive bolt of lightning tears through this backdrop, descending in breathtaking slow motion. Its core channel is a searing, overexposed white, from which intricate filaments of purple plasma branch out, like crystalline structures, deliberately crawling across the dark sky. The bolt's trajectory terminates precisely on the slender metal antenna spire of a towering skyscraper, its steel structure silhouetted against the strange light. The moment the main tendril makes contact, a violent and silent eruption of fiery white and orange sparks erupts from the tip, cascading down like a fiery waterfall, landing on the building's dark facade, each molten particle rendered in surreal clarity. The entire event unfolds with a sense of detached observation, creating an atmosphere of awe-inspiring and terrifying beauty that underscores the raw, untamed physics of the phenomenon.", + "seed": 14950, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_6/index_9698_seed_14950_dp_13_rank_26_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.18782730880193413, + "vlm_logprob": -0.18782730880193413, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.5, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.18782730880193413, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low and tightly framed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sky depicted as a deep indigo color with a perfect black disk sun surrounded by a white corona?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive bolt of lightning shown descending in slow motion with a white core and purple plasma filaments?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lightning strike a slender metal antenna spire on a towering skyscraper, causing an eruption of white and orange sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered with stark documentary realism and surreal clarity?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5139821767807007 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.0139821767807007 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5139821767807007, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5139821767807007, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18313105404376984, + 0.08268190175294876, + 0.06424558907747269, + 0.06323593854904175, + 0.11383400857448578, + 0.06429225951433182, + 0.10833901911973953, + 0.1995050460100174, + 0.06376148015260696, + 0.05697371065616608 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5139821767807007 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low and tightly framed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sky depicted as a deep indigo color with a perfect black disk sun surrounded by a white corona?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive bolt of lightning shown descending in slow motion with a white core and purple plasma filaments?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lightning strike a slender metal antenna spire on a towering skyscraper, causing an eruption of white and orange sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered with stark documentary realism and surreal clarity?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.28147709369659424 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4064770936965942 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.28147709369659424, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.28147709369659424, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2068287879228592, + 0.07103844732046127, + 0.17294339835643768, + 0.11447477340698242, + 0.2114090919494629, + 0.046793363988399506, + 0.03446590155363083, + 0.05185411870479584, + 0.029581476002931595, + 0.06061062216758728 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.28147709369659424 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low and tightly framed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sky depicted as a deep indigo color with a perfect black disk sun surrounded by a white corona?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive bolt of lightning shown descending in slow motion with a white core and purple plasma filaments?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lightning strike a slender metal antenna spire on a towering skyscraper, causing an eruption of white and orange sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered with stark documentary realism and surreal clarity?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003622637828812003 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628622531890869 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003622637828812003, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003622637828812003, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14267034828662872, + 0.07544471323490143, + 0.2150195837020874, + 0.08647318184375763, + 0.17762339115142822, + 0.08261366933584213, + 0.0802517905831337, + 0.05411125719547272, + 0.05049966275691986, + 0.035292353481054306 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003622637828812003 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low and tightly framed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sky depicted as a deep indigo color with a perfect black disk sun surrounded by a white corona?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive bolt of lightning shown descending in slow motion with a white core and purple plasma filaments?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lightning strike a slender metal antenna spire on a towering skyscraper, causing an eruption of white and orange sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered with stark documentary realism and surreal clarity?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07002592831850052 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.69502592086792 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07002592831850052, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07002592831850052, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.26906412839889526, + 0.15680734813213348, + 0.06333474069833755, + 0.07575324922800064, + 0.09405858814716339, + 0.10698122531175613, + 0.055381301790475845, + 0.09204095602035522, + 0.0394214503467083, + 0.047157056629657745 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07002592831850052 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low and tightly framed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sky depicted as a deep indigo color with a perfect black disk sun surrounded by a white corona?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive bolt of lightning shown descending in slow motion with a white core and purple plasma filaments?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lightning strike a slender metal antenna spire on a towering skyscraper, causing an eruption of white and orange sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered with stark documentary realism and surreal clarity?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07002870738506317 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695028781890869 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07002870738506317, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07002870738506317, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2035239189863205, + 0.0890057384967804, + 0.17662778496742249, + 0.0745328888297081, + 0.19968381524085999, + 0.09353161603212357, + 0.033072330057621, + 0.07032059878110886, + 0.019213033840060234, + 0.040488243103027344 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07002870738506317 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "single, static, low-angle, tightly framed shot captures the scene of a massive natural force with stark documentary realism, captured with a high-speed camera. The sky is plunged into the mysterious twilight of a total solar eclipse, a deep, ominous indigo. The sun is a perfect black disk, haloed by the ghostly, shimmering white tendrils of the corona. A massive bolt of lightning tears through this backdrop, descending in breathtaking slow motion. Its core channel is a searing, overexposed white, from which intricate filaments of purple plasma branch out, like crystalline structures, deliberately crawling across the dark sky. The bolt's trajectory terminates precisely on the slender metal antenna spire of a towering skyscraper, its steel structure silhouetted against the strange light. The moment the main tendril makes contact, a violent and silent eruption of fiery white and orange sparks erupts from the tip, cascading down like a fiery waterfall, landing on the building's dark facade, each molten particle rendered in surreal clarity. The entire event unfolds with a sense of detached observation, creating an atmosphere of awe-inspiring and terrifying beauty that underscores the raw, untamed physics of the phenomenon.", + "seed": 14951, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_6/index_9698_seed_14951_dp_13_rank_26_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.3914875111542642, + "vlm_logprob": -0.3914875111542642, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.85, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.3914875111542642, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low and tightly framed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sky depicted as a deep indigo color with a perfect black disk sun surrounded by a white corona?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive bolt of lightning shown descending in slow motion with a white core and purple plasma filaments?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lightning strike a slender metal antenna spire on a towering skyscraper, causing an eruption of white and orange sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered with stark documentary realism and surreal clarity?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.41274866461753845 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1627486944198608 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.41274866461753845, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.41274866461753845, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.7351394891738892, + 0.04964514821767807, + 0.02507590502500534, + 0.03710198029875755, + 0.03398565202951431, + 0.023567961528897285, + 0.008941831067204475, + 0.050955258309841156, + 0.02249407395720482, + 0.013092691078782082 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.41274866461753845 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low and tightly framed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sky depicted as a deep indigo color with a perfect black disk sun surrounded by a white corona?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive bolt of lightning shown descending in slow motion with a white core and purple plasma filaments?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lightning strike a slender metal antenna spire on a towering skyscraper, causing an eruption of white and orange sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered with stark documentary realism and surreal clarity?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3134894371032715 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3134894371032715 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.3134894371032715, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -1.3134894371032715, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4680446684360504, + 0.30676811933517456, + 0.00961427204310894, + 0.08972524106502533, + 0.026011237874627113, + 0.01129784993827343, + 0.025693273171782494, + 0.011641626246273518, + 0.01790754683315754, + 0.033296138048172 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.3134894371032715 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low and tightly framed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sky depicted as a deep indigo color with a perfect black disk sun surrounded by a white corona?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive bolt of lightning shown descending in slow motion with a white core and purple plasma filaments?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lightning strike a slender metal antenna spire on a towering skyscraper, causing an eruption of white and orange sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered with stark documentary realism and surreal clarity?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005263637285679579 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255263805389404 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005263637285679579, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005263637285679579, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5416412949562073, + 0.14363409578800201, + 0.015595975331962109, + 0.1040801852941513, + 0.06050018593668938, + 0.05911104008555412, + 0.017932428047060966, + 0.011668006889522076, + 0.015683360397815704, + 0.03015345148742199 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005263637285679579 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low and tightly framed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sky depicted as a deep indigo color with a perfect black disk sun surrounded by a white corona?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive bolt of lightning shown descending in slow motion with a white core and purple plasma filaments?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lightning strike a slender metal antenna spire on a towering skyscraper, causing an eruption of white and orange sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered with stark documentary realism and surreal clarity?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11297227442264557 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2379722595214844 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11297227442264557, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11297227442264557, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.058019302785396576, + 0.07054070383310318, + 0.07875525951385498, + 0.053227219730615616, + 0.13229018449783325, + 0.14374138414859772, + 0.026014506816864014, + 0.08381115645170212, + 0.23042723536491394, + 0.12317296862602234 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11297227442264557 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low and tightly framed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sky depicted as a deep indigo color with a perfect black disk sun surrounded by a white corona?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive bolt of lightning shown descending in slow motion with a white core and purple plasma filaments?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lightning strike a slender metal antenna spire on a towering skyscraper, causing an eruption of white and orange sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered with stark documentary realism and surreal clarity?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11296354234218597 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2379634380340576 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11296354234218597, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11296354234218597, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23806466162204742, + 0.41999679803848267, + 0.022427259013056755, + 0.05102163553237915, + 0.07255744934082031, + 0.048448413610458374, + 0.023958105593919754, + 0.04484759271144867, + 0.04878231883049011, + 0.02989579550921917 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11296354234218597 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_7/index_tensor([8665, 8665])_group_7_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_7/index_tensor([8665, 8665])_group_7_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..2904b9d0553539ed416706c12dda86f875d657a1 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_7/index_tensor([8665, 8665])_group_7_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "In an extreme close-up, the camera rapidly tilts upward, capturing a flag made of heavy, faded crimson cotton and linen fabric. Initially still and drooping, the flag is coated in a thick layer of grayish-white dust, deeply embedded in its rough texture, its edges frayed and minutely torn. Suddenly, a powerful gust of wind sweeps in, lifting the flag uncontrollably upward, instantly dispersing the accumulated dust and forming a fleeting, murky cloud beneath the harsh, desolate sunlight. In this moment, the camera focuses on the fabric's microscopic details, clearly showing each individual fiber trembling and vibrating at high frequency, as if in a silent scream. The entire flag billows and twitches violently in the wind, while light pierces the dense dust, forming distinct beams of light, creating a dramatic atmosphere imbued with power, desolation, and a profound sense of historical vicissitudes.", + "seed": 15911, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_7/index_8665_seed_15911_dp_14_rank_28_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.17998461611568928, + "vlm_logprob": -0.17998461611568928, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.05, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.17998461611568928, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as an extreme close-up of a flag?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the flag made of heavy, faded crimson cotton and linen fabric?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the flag initially shown still, drooping, and coated in a thick layer of grayish-white dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a powerful gust of wind lift the flag uncontrollably upward and disperse the dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly tilt upward during the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01951751671731472 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.019517421722412 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01951751671731472, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01951751671731472, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14396564662456512, + 0.038587942719459534, + 0.10004422068595886, + 0.04596204683184624, + 0.1044459268450737, + 0.12887823581695557, + 0.12017489224672318, + 0.02680080011487007, + 0.062284521758556366, + 0.22885574400424957 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01951751671731472 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as an extreme close-up of a flag?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the flag made of heavy, faded crimson cotton and linen fabric?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the flag initially shown still, drooping, and coated in a thick layer of grayish-white dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a powerful gust of wind lift the flag uncontrollably upward and disperse the dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly tilt upward during the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16057319939136505 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9105732440948486 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16057319939136505, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16057319939136505, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10228560119867325, + 0.08767150342464447, + 0.18236806988716125, + 0.030292725190520287, + 0.06741859763860703, + 0.08023837953805923, + 0.08776732534170151, + 0.027554195374250412, + 0.06938453763723373, + 0.26501911878585815 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16057319939136505 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as an extreme close-up of a flag?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the flag made of heavy, faded crimson cotton and linen fabric?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the flag initially shown still, drooping, and coated in a thick layer of grayish-white dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a powerful gust of wind lift the flag uncontrollably upward and disperse the dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly tilt upward during the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023303912952542305 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773303985595703 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023303912952542305, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023303912952542305, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11177794635295868, + 0.04472850263118744, + 0.3251522481441498, + 0.0211477130651474, + 0.09437297284603119, + 0.20679789781570435, + 0.012678666971623898, + 0.01933152601122856, + 0.029075637459754944, + 0.13493694365024567 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023303912952542305 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as an extreme close-up of a flag?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the flag made of heavy, faded crimson cotton and linen fabric?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the flag initially shown still, drooping, and coated in a thick layer of grayish-white dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a powerful gust of wind lift the flag uncontrollably upward and disperse the dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly tilt upward during the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0031949449330568314 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753194808959961 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0031949449330568314, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0031949449330568314, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17149485647678375, + 0.0427003912627697, + 0.08832471072673798, + 0.06384801119565964, + 0.15844538807868958, + 0.13392125070095062, + 0.07031284272670746, + 0.03659346327185631, + 0.04923483729362488, + 0.1851242631673813 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0031949449330568314 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as an extreme close-up of a flag?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the flag made of heavy, faded crimson cotton and linen fabric?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the flag initially shown still, drooping, and coated in a thick layer of grayish-white dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a powerful gust of wind lift the flag uncontrollably upward and disperse the dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly tilt upward during the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6933335065841675 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6933335065841675 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.6933335065841675, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.6933335065841675, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14276130497455597, + 0.05893921107053757, + 0.09425058960914612, + 0.07834792137145996, + 0.17568035423755646, + 0.25281932950019836, + 0.039754681289196014, + 0.021017305552959442, + 0.03807559236884117, + 0.09835369884967804 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.6933335065841675 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In an extreme close-up, the camera rapidly tilts upward, capturing a flag made of heavy, faded crimson cotton and linen fabric. Initially still and drooping, the flag is coated in a thick layer of grayish-white dust, deeply embedded in its rough texture, its edges frayed and minutely torn. Suddenly, a powerful gust of wind sweeps in, lifting the flag uncontrollably upward, instantly dispersing the accumulated dust and forming a fleeting, murky cloud beneath the harsh, desolate sunlight. In this moment, the camera focuses on the fabric's microscopic details, clearly showing each individual fiber trembling and vibrating at high frequency, as if in a silent scream. The entire flag billows and twitches violently in the wind, while light pierces the dense dust, forming distinct beams of light, creating a dramatic atmosphere imbued with power, desolation, and a profound sense of historical vicissitudes.", + "seed": 15912, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_7/index_8665_seed_15912_dp_14_rank_28_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.18201694157905876, + "vlm_logprob": -0.18201694157905876, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.25, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.18201694157905876, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as an extreme close-up of a flag?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the flag made of heavy, faded crimson cotton and linen fabric?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the flag initially shown still, drooping, and coated in a thick layer of grayish-white dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a powerful gust of wind lift the flag uncontrollably upward and disperse the dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly tilt upward during the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02445926144719124 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7744593620300293 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02445926144719124, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02445926144719124, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2036140263080597, + 0.28888389468193054, + 0.024733347818255424, + 0.07789016515016556, + 0.02644358202815056, + 0.035996630787849426, + 0.0289665088057518, + 0.15789686143398285, + 0.12525105476379395, + 0.03032384067773819 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02445926144719124 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as an extreme close-up of a flag?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the flag made of heavy, faded crimson cotton and linen fabric?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the flag initially shown still, drooping, and coated in a thick layer of grayish-white dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a powerful gust of wind lift the flag uncontrollably upward and disperse the dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly tilt upward during the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11308491975069046 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2380850315093994 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11308491975069046, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11308491975069046, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12784381210803986, + 0.21032074093818665, + 0.035806335508823395, + 0.04632357135415077, + 0.07230913639068604, + 0.1169656440615654, + 0.14074385166168213, + 0.11890466511249542, + 0.09305794537067413, + 0.037724241614341736 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11308491975069046 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as an extreme close-up of a flag?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the flag made of heavy, faded crimson cotton and linen fabric?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the flag initially shown still, drooping, and coated in a thick layer of grayish-white dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a powerful gust of wind lift the flag uncontrollably upward and disperse the dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly tilt upward during the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012547126039862633 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387547016143799 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012547126039862633, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012547126039862633, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.40986165404319763, + 0.05494936555624008, + 0.03436941280961037, + 0.09140639752149582, + 0.03392842411994934, + 0.0160245131701231, + 0.04903865605592728, + 0.2221692055463791, + 0.0737718865275383, + 0.014480502344667912 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012547126039862633 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as an extreme close-up of a flag?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the flag made of heavy, faded crimson cotton and linen fabric?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the flag initially shown still, drooping, and coated in a thick layer of grayish-white dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a powerful gust of wind lift the flag uncontrollably upward and disperse the dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly tilt upward during the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002198066795244813 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127198219299316 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002198066795244813, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002198066795244813, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0678187906742096, + 0.0641266331076622, + 0.034888751804828644, + 0.21787303686141968, + 0.09473680704832077, + 0.042997732758522034, + 0.08884662389755249, + 0.24551589787006378, + 0.1183425635099411, + 0.024853205308318138 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 3, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002198066795244813 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as an extreme close-up of a flag?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the flag made of heavy, faded crimson cotton and linen fabric?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the flag initially shown still, drooping, and coated in a thick layer of grayish-white dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a powerful gust of wind lift the flag uncontrollably upward and disperse the dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly tilt upward during the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7577953338623047 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6327953338623047 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.7577953338623047, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.7577953338623047, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22314275801181793, + 0.10176356881856918, + 0.04012442007660866, + 0.2530342936515808, + 0.03794100508093834, + 0.048240646719932556, + 0.04574516788125038, + 0.1004791334271431, + 0.11371169239282608, + 0.03581730276346207 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.7577953338623047 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In an extreme close-up, the camera rapidly tilts upward, capturing a flag made of heavy, faded crimson cotton and linen fabric. Initially still and drooping, the flag is coated in a thick layer of grayish-white dust, deeply embedded in its rough texture, its edges frayed and minutely torn. Suddenly, a powerful gust of wind sweeps in, lifting the flag uncontrollably upward, instantly dispersing the accumulated dust and forming a fleeting, murky cloud beneath the harsh, desolate sunlight. In this moment, the camera focuses on the fabric's microscopic details, clearly showing each individual fiber trembling and vibrating at high frequency, as if in a silent scream. The entire flag billows and twitches violently in the wind, while light pierces the dense dust, forming distinct beams of light, creating a dramatic atmosphere imbued with power, desolation, and a profound sense of historical vicissitudes.", + "seed": 15913, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_7/index_8665_seed_15913_dp_15_rank_30_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.19999046376906335, + "vlm_logprob": -0.19999046376906335, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.025, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.19999046376906335, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as an extreme close-up of a flag?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the flag made of heavy, faded crimson cotton and linen fabric?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the flag initially shown still, drooping, and coated in a thick layer of grayish-white dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a powerful gust of wind lift the flag uncontrollably upward and disperse the dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly tilt upward during the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.041252732276916504 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.291252613067627 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.041252732276916504, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.041252732276916504, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04998905956745148, + 0.012850943952798843, + 0.009451184421777725, + 0.016657331958413124, + 0.011697990819811821, + 0.010773762129247189, + 0.7905709147453308, + 0.034878071397542953, + 0.016050176694989204, + 0.04708046466112137 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.041252732276916504 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as an extreme close-up of a flag?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the flag made of heavy, faded crimson cotton and linen fabric?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the flag initially shown still, drooping, and coated in a thick layer of grayish-white dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a powerful gust of wind lift the flag uncontrollably upward and disperse the dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly tilt upward during the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3139054775238037 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3139054775238037 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3139054775238037, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3139054775238037, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04561200365424156, + 0.031047997996211052, + 0.031172405928373337, + 0.011916895397007465, + 0.04617045074701309, + 0.049371492117643356, + 0.6558802723884583, + 0.02927532233297825, + 0.02287891134619713, + 0.0766742154955864 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3139054775238037 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as an extreme close-up of a flag?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the flag made of heavy, faded crimson cotton and linen fabric?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the flag initially shown still, drooping, and coated in a thick layer of grayish-white dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a powerful gust of wind lift the flag uncontrollably upward and disperse the dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly tilt upward during the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009793566539883614 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634793758392334 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009793566539883614, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009793566539883614, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04649296775460243, + 0.020998483523726463, + 0.01626083254814148, + 0.0302107073366642, + 0.033144403249025345, + 0.030533652752637863, + 0.7413839101791382, + 0.03373075649142265, + 0.023933211341500282, + 0.023310985416173935 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009793566539883614 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as an extreme close-up of a flag?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the flag made of heavy, faded crimson cotton and linen fabric?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the flag initially shown still, drooping, and coated in a thick layer of grayish-white dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a powerful gust of wind lift the flag uncontrollably upward and disperse the dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly tilt upward during the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002202943665906787 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127202987670898 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002202943665906787, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002202943665906787, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10149617493152618, + 0.05091217905282974, + 0.05061938986182213, + 0.05982927605509758, + 0.07790109515190125, + 0.05733366683125496, + 0.3298293650150299, + 0.08578565716743469, + 0.122536800801754, + 0.06375633925199509 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002202943665906787 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as an extreme close-up of a flag?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the flag made of heavy, faded crimson cotton and linen fabric?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the flag initially shown still, drooping, and coated in a thick layer of grayish-white dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a powerful gust of wind lift the flag uncontrollably upward and disperse the dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly tilt upward during the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6327975988388062 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7577975988388062 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.6327975988388062, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.6327975988388062, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.017581213265657425, + 0.01033693365752697, + 0.007114562671631575, + 0.019637245684862137, + 0.019895236939191818, + 0.013377252034842968, + 0.7846104502677917, + 0.08394553512334824, + 0.008099483326077461, + 0.03540203720331192 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.6327975988388062 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In an extreme close-up, the camera rapidly tilts upward, capturing a flag made of heavy, faded crimson cotton and linen fabric. Initially still and drooping, the flag is coated in a thick layer of grayish-white dust, deeply embedded in its rough texture, its edges frayed and minutely torn. Suddenly, a powerful gust of wind sweeps in, lifting the flag uncontrollably upward, instantly dispersing the accumulated dust and forming a fleeting, murky cloud beneath the harsh, desolate sunlight. In this moment, the camera focuses on the fabric's microscopic details, clearly showing each individual fiber trembling and vibrating at high frequency, as if in a silent scream. The entire flag billows and twitches violently in the wind, while light pierces the dense dust, forming distinct beams of light, creating a dramatic atmosphere imbued with power, desolation, and a profound sense of historical vicissitudes.", + "seed": 15914, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_7/index_8665_seed_15914_dp_15_rank_30_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.20502092295791954, + "vlm_logprob": -0.20502092295791954, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.275, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.20502092295791954, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as an extreme close-up of a flag?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the flag made of heavy, faded crimson cotton and linen fabric?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the flag initially shown still, drooping, and coated in a thick layer of grayish-white dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a powerful gust of wind lift the flag uncontrollably upward and disperse the dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly tilt upward during the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.027374861761927605 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.652374744415283 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.027374861761927605, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.027374861761927605, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0843372792005539, + 0.0512731708586216, + 0.2398306429386139, + 0.07998582720756531, + 0.13072966039180756, + 0.1691889762878418, + 0.03974509611725807, + 0.03871695697307587, + 0.14038679003715515, + 0.025805534794926643 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 5, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.027374861761927605 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as an extreme close-up of a flag?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the flag made of heavy, faded crimson cotton and linen fabric?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the flag initially shown still, drooping, and coated in a thick layer of grayish-white dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a powerful gust of wind lift the flag uncontrollably upward and disperse the dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly tilt upward during the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16048477590084076 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.910484790802002 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16048477590084076, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16048477590084076, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08245544135570526, + 0.04500712454319, + 0.13800562918186188, + 0.19593186676502228, + 0.1869521141052246, + 0.11738931387662888, + 0.02162752114236355, + 0.022749533876776695, + 0.128127321600914, + 0.06175411120057106 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16048477590084076 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as an extreme close-up of a flag?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the flag made of heavy, faded crimson cotton and linen fabric?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the flag initially shown still, drooping, and coated in a thick layer of grayish-white dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a powerful gust of wind lift the flag uncontrollably upward and disperse the dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly tilt upward during the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00978719163686037 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634787082672119 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00978719163686037, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00978719163686037, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.28883302211761475, + 0.1080038845539093, + 0.08307178318500519, + 0.08351535350084305, + 0.0457443967461586, + 0.1949930638074875, + 0.020426787436008453, + 0.03227764740586281, + 0.07728196680545807, + 0.06585203856229782 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00978719163686037 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as an extreme close-up of a flag?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the flag made of heavy, faded crimson cotton and linen fabric?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the flag initially shown still, drooping, and coated in a thick layer of grayish-white dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a powerful gust of wind lift the flag uncontrollably upward and disperse the dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly tilt upward during the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0013369916705414653 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.626337051391602 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0013369916705414653, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0013369916705414653, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11197524517774582, + 0.13424895703792572, + 0.05110320821404457, + 0.07865773141384125, + 0.2589893043041229, + 0.1014024168252945, + 0.031570643186569214, + 0.03419557586312294, + 0.10427309572696686, + 0.09358379989862442 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0013369916705414653 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as an extreme close-up of a flag?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the flag made of heavy, faded crimson cotton and linen fabric?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the flag initially shown still, drooping, and coated in a thick layer of grayish-white dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a powerful gust of wind lift the flag uncontrollably upward and disperse the dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly tilt upward during the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8261207938194275 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5761207938194275 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.8261207938194275, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.8261207938194275, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09080472588539124, + 0.04232959821820259, + 0.1195724606513977, + 0.06080546975135803, + 0.09497013688087463, + 0.052526820451021194, + 0.08695799112319946, + 0.08058799058198929, + 0.2809746563434601, + 0.09047014266252518 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.8261207938194275 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_8/index_tensor([2759, 2759])_group_8_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_8/index_tensor([2759, 2759])_group_8_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..2ad59682a5c465a853e5c84f805b6cc0b6a8bd01 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_8/index_tensor([2759, 2759])_group_8_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "low-angle, side-on tracking shot, held close to the ground, captures the breathtaking moment of a magnificent tiger charging through the humid, dense rainforest. The tiger's vibrant orange-yellow fur is streaked with deep, irregular black stripes, and its muscles bulge, each one tense and rippled with explosive force. It lunges forward with breathtaking force, its body stretched to its limit, its spine like a fully drawn bow, its four powerful paws alternately striking the ground. Each stomp sends dirt and debris from the humus and dead leaves cascading violently backward, creating a fleeting, chaotic trail through the air. Dappled sunlight filters through the layers of treetops, casting rapidly shifting light and shadows on its body and the ground, further heightening the sense of speed. Its extreme speed stretches the massive ferns and tangled vines in the background into a motion-blur of deep greens and browns, dramatically amplifying the visual impact. Its eyes are wide open, its expression fierce and focused, and the whole picture is full of tension, wildness and unstoppable vitality.", + "seed": 21859, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_8/index_2759_seed_21859_dp_16_rank_32_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.06456520515494049, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06456520515494049, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.1, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06456520515494049, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle, held close to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a side-on tracking shot of a tiger charging?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger's fur vibrant orange-yellow with deep, irregular black stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a humid, dense rainforest with dappled sunlight filtering through treetops?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the massive ferns and tangled vines in the background rendered as a motion-blur of deep greens and browns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16738039255142212 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9173803329467773 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16738039255142212, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16738039255142212, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18854311108589172, + 0.1498897224664688, + 0.14890988171100616, + 0.17566856741905212, + 0.0841137021780014, + 0.038885798305273056, + 0.05284209921956062, + 0.02525511384010315, + 0.028865167871117592, + 0.10702687501907349 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16738039255142212 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle, held close to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a side-on tracking shot of a tiger charging?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger's fur vibrant orange-yellow with deep, irregular black stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a humid, dense rainforest with dappled sunlight filtering through treetops?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the massive ferns and tangled vines in the background rendered as a motion-blur of deep greens and browns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14279745519161224 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0177974700927734 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14279745519161224, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14279745519161224, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11514350026845932, + 0.08232825249433517, + 0.14766599237918854, + 0.39208656549453735, + 0.06581924110651016, + 0.025572799146175385, + 0.04284020513296127, + 0.036851104348897934, + 0.055998072028160095, + 0.035694193094968796 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14279745519161224 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle, held close to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a side-on tracking shot of a tiger charging?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger's fur vibrant orange-yellow with deep, irregular black stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a humid, dense rainforest with dappled sunlight filtering through treetops?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the massive ferns and tangled vines in the background rendered as a motion-blur of deep greens and browns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0022019920870661736 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127202033996582 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0022019920870661736, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0022019920870661736, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24737823009490967, + 0.08073075860738754, + 0.07380452752113342, + 0.14093348383903503, + 0.07422471791505814, + 0.0613897331058979, + 0.13445018231868744, + 0.045838598161935806, + 0.041527047753334045, + 0.09972270578145981 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0022019920870661736 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle, held close to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a side-on tracking shot of a tiger charging?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger's fur vibrant orange-yellow with deep, irregular black stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a humid, dense rainforest with dappled sunlight filtering through treetops?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the massive ferns and tangled vines in the background rendered as a motion-blur of deep greens and browns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007628594525158405 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882628440856934 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007628594525158405, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007628594525158405, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1289094090461731, + 0.18118466436862946, + 0.1214798092842102, + 0.12381725758314133, + 0.1608426868915558, + 0.025066960602998734, + 0.10329209268093109, + 0.06720202416181564, + 0.012982749380171299, + 0.07522229850292206 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007628594525158405 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle, held close to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a side-on tracking shot of a tiger charging?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger's fur vibrant orange-yellow with deep, irregular black stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a humid, dense rainforest with dappled sunlight filtering through treetops?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the massive ferns and tangled vines in the background rendered as a motion-blur of deep greens and browns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002817591419443488 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877817630767822 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002817591419443488, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002817591419443488, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1396770179271698, + 0.07804236561059952, + 0.2946213185787201, + 0.14816902577877045, + 0.07640557736158371, + 0.04568975791335106, + 0.08716337382793427, + 0.03945270553231239, + 0.03796197101473808, + 0.05281687155365944 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002817591419443488 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, side-on tracking shot, held close to the ground, captures the breathtaking moment of a magnificent tiger charging through the humid, dense rainforest. The tiger's vibrant orange-yellow fur is streaked with deep, irregular black stripes, and its muscles bulge, each one tense and rippled with explosive force. It lunges forward with breathtaking force, its body stretched to its limit, its spine like a fully drawn bow, its four powerful paws alternately striking the ground. Each stomp sends dirt and debris from the humus and dead leaves cascading violently backward, creating a fleeting, chaotic trail through the air. Dappled sunlight filters through the layers of treetops, casting rapidly shifting light and shadows on its body and the ground, further heightening the sense of speed. Its extreme speed stretches the massive ferns and tangled vines in the background into a motion-blur of deep greens and browns, dramatically amplifying the visual impact. Its eyes are wide open, its expression fierce and focused, and the whole picture is full of tension, wildness and unstoppable vitality.", + "seed": 21860, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_8/index_2759_seed_21860_dp_16_rank_32_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.07517709897365421, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07517709897365421, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.925, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07517709897365421, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle, held close to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a side-on tracking shot of a tiger charging?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger's fur vibrant orange-yellow with deep, irregular black stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a humid, dense rainforest with dappled sunlight filtering through treetops?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the massive ferns and tangled vines in the background rendered as a motion-blur of deep greens and browns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2660890817642212 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5160890817642212 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2660890817642212, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2660890817642212, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1694875955581665, + 0.07702623307704926, + 0.048542432487010956, + 0.07213503122329712, + 0.054252989590168, + 0.021674320101737976, + 0.02880631759762764, + 0.15050755441188812, + 0.3497057259082794, + 0.02786179445683956 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2660890817642212 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle, held close to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a side-on tracking shot of a tiger charging?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger's fur vibrant orange-yellow with deep, irregular black stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a humid, dense rainforest with dappled sunlight filtering through treetops?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the massive ferns and tangled vines in the background rendered as a motion-blur of deep greens and browns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07899902760982513 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5789990425109863 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07899902760982513, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07899902760982513, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05233268439769745, + 0.14511437714099884, + 0.10589605569839478, + 0.04839491471648216, + 0.09434932470321655, + 0.06570187956094742, + 0.060264505445957184, + 0.11286196112632751, + 0.2763325870037079, + 0.03875165432691574 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07899902760982513 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle, held close to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a side-on tracking shot of a tiger charging?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger's fur vibrant orange-yellow with deep, irregular black stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a humid, dense rainforest with dappled sunlight filtering through treetops?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the massive ferns and tangled vines in the background rendered as a motion-blur of deep greens and browns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002498126355931163 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002498149871826 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002498126355931163, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002498126355931163, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10089261829853058, + 0.2723923921585083, + 0.05683673545718193, + 0.03737884759902954, + 0.05147119611501694, + 0.017989207059144974, + 0.06171000003814697, + 0.17300769686698914, + 0.19656801223754883, + 0.031753212213516235 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002498126355931163 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle, held close to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a side-on tracking shot of a tiger charging?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger's fur vibrant orange-yellow with deep, irregular black stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a humid, dense rainforest with dappled sunlight filtering through treetops?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the massive ferns and tangled vines in the background rendered as a motion-blur of deep greens and browns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02635827101767063 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513583660125732 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02635827101767063, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02635827101767063, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16026732325553894, + 0.16731584072113037, + 0.10656780749559402, + 0.11052949726581573, + 0.039619699120521545, + 0.025435524061322212, + 0.044586412608623505, + 0.15925398468971252, + 0.13099969923496246, + 0.055424198508262634 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02635827101767063 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle, held close to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a side-on tracking shot of a tiger charging?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger's fur vibrant orange-yellow with deep, irregular black stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a humid, dense rainforest with dappled sunlight filtering through treetops?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the massive ferns and tangled vines in the background rendered as a motion-blur of deep greens and browns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.001940988120622933 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.251941204071045 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.001940988120622933, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.001940988120622933, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13487838208675385, + 0.09365244209766388, + 0.08462692052125931, + 0.053262144327163696, + 0.0549946129322052, + 0.027632752433419228, + 0.08520660549402237, + 0.09175555408000946, + 0.35223308205604553, + 0.021757513284683228 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.001940988120622933 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, side-on tracking shot, held close to the ground, captures the breathtaking moment of a magnificent tiger charging through the humid, dense rainforest. The tiger's vibrant orange-yellow fur is streaked with deep, irregular black stripes, and its muscles bulge, each one tense and rippled with explosive force. It lunges forward with breathtaking force, its body stretched to its limit, its spine like a fully drawn bow, its four powerful paws alternately striking the ground. Each stomp sends dirt and debris from the humus and dead leaves cascading violently backward, creating a fleeting, chaotic trail through the air. Dappled sunlight filters through the layers of treetops, casting rapidly shifting light and shadows on its body and the ground, further heightening the sense of speed. Its extreme speed stretches the massive ferns and tangled vines in the background into a motion-blur of deep greens and browns, dramatically amplifying the visual impact. Its eyes are wide open, its expression fierce and focused, and the whole picture is full of tension, wildness and unstoppable vitality.", + "seed": 21861, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_8/index_2759_seed_21861_dp_17_rank_34_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.09082741965539753, + "vlm_logprob": -0.09082741965539753, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.775, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.09082741965539753, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle, held close to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a side-on tracking shot of a tiger charging?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger's fur vibrant orange-yellow with deep, irregular black stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a humid, dense rainforest with dappled sunlight filtering through treetops?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the massive ferns and tangled vines in the background rendered as a motion-blur of deep greens and browns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2630041837692261 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.513004183769226 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2630041837692261, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2630041837692261, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18420633673667908, + 0.05225396901369095, + 0.06868265569210052, + 0.025695262476801872, + 0.04690176248550415, + 0.2594614326953888, + 0.22156104445457458, + 0.04266643524169922, + 0.04379658028483391, + 0.05477451905608177 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2630041837692261 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle, held close to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a side-on tracking shot of a tiger charging?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger's fur vibrant orange-yellow with deep, irregular black stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a humid, dense rainforest with dappled sunlight filtering through treetops?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the massive ferns and tangled vines in the background rendered as a motion-blur of deep greens and browns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16036535799503326 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.910365343093872 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16036535799503326, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16036535799503326, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10172035545110703, + 0.16488774120807648, + 0.052729424089193344, + 0.07621211558580399, + 0.07865536957979202, + 0.18598908185958862, + 0.06852885335683823, + 0.1403118073940277, + 0.055867359042167664, + 0.07509782165288925 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16036535799503326 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle, held close to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a side-on tracking shot of a tiger charging?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger's fur vibrant orange-yellow with deep, irregular black stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a humid, dense rainforest with dappled sunlight filtering through treetops?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the massive ferns and tangled vines in the background rendered as a motion-blur of deep greens and browns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0022082962095737457 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127208232879639 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0022082962095737457, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0022082962095737457, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10428405553102493, + 0.08222202211618423, + 0.08197201043367386, + 0.038274846971035004, + 0.03706028684973717, + 0.10652980953454971, + 0.38714468479156494, + 0.07325702160596848, + 0.03674411028623581, + 0.05251116305589676 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0022082962095737457 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle, held close to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a side-on tracking shot of a tiger charging?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger's fur vibrant orange-yellow with deep, irregular black stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a humid, dense rainforest with dappled sunlight filtering through treetops?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the massive ferns and tangled vines in the background rendered as a motion-blur of deep greens and browns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02636036090552807 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651360273361206 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02636036090552807, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02636036090552807, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2337965965270996, + 0.07914910465478897, + 0.1398560106754303, + 0.04402238130569458, + 0.022270098328590393, + 0.08917288482189178, + 0.18078456819057465, + 0.04445872828364372, + 0.08276141434907913, + 0.08372825384140015 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02636036090552807 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle, held close to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a side-on tracking shot of a tiger charging?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger's fur vibrant orange-yellow with deep, irregular black stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a humid, dense rainforest with dappled sunlight filtering through treetops?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the massive ferns and tangled vines in the background rendered as a motion-blur of deep greens and browns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002198899397626519 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127198696136475 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002198899397626519, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002198899397626519, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12019263207912445, + 0.08275844901800156, + 0.10065782070159912, + 0.038078200072050095, + 0.020841754972934723, + 0.17826107144355774, + 0.2765296697616577, + 0.059890326112508774, + 0.03553298860788345, + 0.08725716173648834 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002198899397626519 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, side-on tracking shot, held close to the ground, captures the breathtaking moment of a magnificent tiger charging through the humid, dense rainforest. The tiger's vibrant orange-yellow fur is streaked with deep, irregular black stripes, and its muscles bulge, each one tense and rippled with explosive force. It lunges forward with breathtaking force, its body stretched to its limit, its spine like a fully drawn bow, its four powerful paws alternately striking the ground. Each stomp sends dirt and debris from the humus and dead leaves cascading violently backward, creating a fleeting, chaotic trail through the air. Dappled sunlight filters through the layers of treetops, casting rapidly shifting light and shadows on its body and the ground, further heightening the sense of speed. Its extreme speed stretches the massive ferns and tangled vines in the background into a motion-blur of deep greens and browns, dramatically amplifying the visual impact. Its eyes are wide open, its expression fierce and focused, and the whole picture is full of tension, wildness and unstoppable vitality.", + "seed": 21862, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_8/index_2759_seed_21862_dp_17_rank_34_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.062435840652324257, + "vlm_logprob": -0.062435840652324257, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.05, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.062435840652324257, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle, held close to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a side-on tracking shot of a tiger charging?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger's fur vibrant orange-yellow with deep, irregular black stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a humid, dense rainforest with dappled sunlight filtering through treetops?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the massive ferns and tangled vines in the background rendered as a motion-blur of deep greens and browns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16936138272285461 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9193613529205322 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16936138272285461, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16936138272285461, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20224805176258087, + 0.10119739919900894, + 0.11664575338363647, + 0.06188437342643738, + 0.08889848738908768, + 0.1413625031709671, + 0.11028752475976944, + 0.030395857989788055, + 0.033230118453502655, + 0.11384982615709305 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16936138272285461 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle, held close to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a side-on tracking shot of a tiger charging?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger's fur vibrant orange-yellow with deep, irregular black stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a humid, dense rainforest with dappled sunlight filtering through treetops?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the massive ferns and tangled vines in the background rendered as a motion-blur of deep greens and browns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1129339411854744 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.237933874130249 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1129339411854744, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1129339411854744, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07401881366968155, + 0.09665796905755997, + 0.19008854031562805, + 0.0703800693154335, + 0.13074031472206116, + 0.07659079134464264, + 0.22501014173030853, + 0.044033586978912354, + 0.0717211663722992, + 0.0207586158066988 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1129339411854744 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle, held close to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a side-on tracking shot of a tiger charging?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger's fur vibrant orange-yellow with deep, irregular black stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a humid, dense rainforest with dappled sunlight filtering through treetops?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the massive ferns and tangled vines in the background rendered as a motion-blur of deep greens and browns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.001341158407740295 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.626341342926025 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.001341158407740295, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.001341158407740295, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05927779898047447, + 0.048704594373703, + 0.05347483232617378, + 0.04354952648282051, + 0.15394215285778046, + 0.09333042800426483, + 0.06748002767562866, + 0.03048204816877842, + 0.10578873008489609, + 0.34396985173225403 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.001341158407740295 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle, held close to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a side-on tracking shot of a tiger charging?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger's fur vibrant orange-yellow with deep, irregular black stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a humid, dense rainforest with dappled sunlight filtering through treetops?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the massive ferns and tangled vines in the background rendered as a motion-blur of deep greens and browns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026345962658524513 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.65134596824646 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026345962658524513, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026345962658524513, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3592830002307892, + 0.08352386206388474, + 0.060378458350896835, + 0.10910558700561523, + 0.10314102470874786, + 0.06957928836345673, + 0.057497162371873856, + 0.02556970715522766, + 0.049705587327480316, + 0.0822163075208664 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026345962658524513 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle, held close to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a side-on tracking shot of a tiger charging?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger's fur vibrant orange-yellow with deep, irregular black stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a humid, dense rainforest with dappled sunlight filtering through treetops?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the massive ferns and tangled vines in the background rendered as a motion-blur of deep greens and browns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0021967582870274782 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127196788787842 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0021967582870274782, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0021967582870274782, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1889965683221817, + 0.08094429224729538, + 0.06702961027622223, + 0.051928430795669556, + 0.10183189064264297, + 0.09711004793643951, + 0.1257333755493164, + 0.06610935926437378, + 0.081830233335495, + 0.13848614692687988 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0021967582870274782 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_9/index_tensor([3799, 3799])_group_9_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_9/index_tensor([3799, 3799])_group_9_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..a961af186dfb7c4d459312a0400ab35ce71aea3b --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_9/index_tensor([3799, 3799])_group_9_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "dynamic slow-motion close-up captures the action from a slightly elevated angle as a dark blue six-sided die falls into the frame. Made of polished, slightly translucent acrylic, the die impacts the warm, wood-textured surface of the kitchen table with a sharp impact. Under the soft, realistic overhead kitchen light, it bounces erratically, spinning in mid-air, causing the white, concave dots to blur into fleeting streaks. The camera remains static, allowing dynamic movement to fill the scene as the die loses momentum, gliding across the polished wood before swaying to a final, tense moment. It settles decisively, completely at rest, shifting the feel of the scene from chaotic energy to stillness. The final frame fixates on the perfectly still die, its top surface clearly displaying the number six. The warm light casts soft, fleeting shadows alongside it and creates subtle highlights along its smooth edges, creating a quiet, defined atmosphere. High resolution.", + "seed": 21612, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_9/index_3799_seed_21612_dp_18_rank_36_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.02271720450371504, + "vlm_logprob": -0.02271720450371504, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.95, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.02271720450371504, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a dark blue six-sided die made of polished, slightly translucent acrylic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the die fall into the frame and impact a warm, wood-textured kitchen table surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the die bounce erratically, spin in mid-air, and glide across the table before coming to a complete rest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by soft, realistic overhead kitchen light, casting soft shadows and highlights on the die?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static throughout the shot, capturing the die's movement from a slightly elevated angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.032287947833538055 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.532287836074829 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.032287947833538055, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.032287947833538055, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07182123512029648, + 0.09287702292203903, + 0.05387434363365173, + 0.10268303006887436, + 0.14460211992263794, + 0.13261333107948303, + 0.07619376480579376, + 0.2411520779132843, + 0.05698121339082718, + 0.027201933786273003 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.032287947833538055 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a dark blue six-sided die made of polished, slightly translucent acrylic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the die fall into the frame and impact a warm, wood-textured kitchen table surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the die bounce erratically, spin in mid-air, and glide across the table before coming to a complete rest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by soft, realistic overhead kitchen light, casting soft shadows and highlights on the die?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static throughout the shot, capturing the die's movement from a slightly elevated angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011095255613327026 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.51109504699707 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011095255613327026, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011095255613327026, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07767920941114426, + 0.07499486953020096, + 0.06127290427684784, + 0.2551708221435547, + 0.03385564312338829, + 0.20893777906894684, + 0.012643522582948208, + 0.1990358531475067, + 0.06279116868972778, + 0.013618186116218567 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011095255613327026 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a dark blue six-sided die made of polished, slightly translucent acrylic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the die fall into the frame and impact a warm, wood-textured kitchen table surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the die bounce erratically, spin in mid-air, and glide across the table before coming to a complete rest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by soft, realistic overhead kitchen light, casting soft shadows and highlights on the die?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static throughout the shot, capturing the die's movement from a slightly elevated angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016073880717158318 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141073703765869 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016073880717158318, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016073880717158318, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07900634407997131, + 0.061797380447387695, + 0.07691944390535355, + 0.03808195888996124, + 0.04608798399567604, + 0.24678079783916473, + 0.07536192238330841, + 0.3266332149505615, + 0.031648315489292145, + 0.01768268086016178 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016073880717158318 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a dark blue six-sided die made of polished, slightly translucent acrylic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the die fall into the frame and impact a warm, wood-textured kitchen table surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the die bounce erratically, spin in mid-air, and glide across the table before coming to a complete rest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by soft, realistic overhead kitchen light, casting soft shadows and highlights on the die?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static throughout the shot, capturing the die's movement from a slightly elevated angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01108712051063776 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511086940765381 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01108712051063776, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01108712051063776, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11114942282438278, + 0.049178797751665115, + 0.05647425353527069, + 0.1388767659664154, + 0.041308894753456116, + 0.39502856135368347, + 0.07945512235164642, + 0.0554400198161602, + 0.05263672024011612, + 0.020451456308364868 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01108712051063776 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a dark blue six-sided die made of polished, slightly translucent acrylic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the die fall into the frame and impact a warm, wood-textured kitchen table surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the die bounce erratically, spin in mid-air, and glide across the table before coming to a complete rest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by soft, realistic overhead kitchen light, casting soft shadows and highlights on the die?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static throughout the shot, capturing the die's movement from a slightly elevated angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04304181784391403 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168041706085205 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04304181784391403, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04304181784391403, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06485313177108765, + 0.11756035685539246, + 0.10195629298686981, + 0.24324384331703186, + 0.038473520427942276, + 0.14015939831733704, + 0.12399538606405258, + 0.09951368719339371, + 0.057394497096538544, + 0.012849930673837662 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04304181784391403 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dynamic slow-motion close-up captures the action from a slightly elevated angle as a dark blue six-sided die falls into the frame. Made of polished, slightly translucent acrylic, the die impacts the warm, wood-textured surface of the kitchen table with a sharp impact. Under the soft, realistic overhead kitchen light, it bounces erratically, spinning in mid-air, causing the white, concave dots to blur into fleeting streaks. The camera remains static, allowing dynamic movement to fill the scene as the die loses momentum, gliding across the polished wood before swaying to a final, tense moment. It settles decisively, completely at rest, shifting the feel of the scene from chaotic energy to stillness. The final frame fixates on the perfectly still die, its top surface clearly displaying the number six. The warm light casts soft, fleeting shadows alongside it and creates subtle highlights along its smooth edges, creating a quiet, defined atmosphere. High resolution.", + "seed": 21613, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_9/index_3799_seed_21613_dp_18_rank_36_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.029307207092642784, + "vlm_logprob": -0.029307207092642784, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.7, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.029307207092642784, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a dark blue six-sided die made of polished, slightly translucent acrylic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the die fall into the frame and impact a warm, wood-textured kitchen table surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the die bounce erratically, spin in mid-air, and glide across the table before coming to a complete rest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by soft, realistic overhead kitchen light, casting soft shadows and highlights on the die?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static throughout the shot, capturing the die's movement from a slightly elevated angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.045237623155117035 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1702375411987305 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.045237623155117035, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.045237623155117035, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09840120375156403, + 0.09928098320960999, + 0.07555306702852249, + 0.5090188980102539, + 0.05171394720673561, + 0.03566109016537666, + 0.04831486567854881, + 0.030735444277524948, + 0.022346818819642067, + 0.028973650187253952 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.045237623155117035 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a dark blue six-sided die made of polished, slightly translucent acrylic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the die fall into the frame and impact a warm, wood-textured kitchen table surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the die bounce erratically, spin in mid-air, and glide across the table before coming to a complete rest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by soft, realistic overhead kitchen light, casting soft shadows and highlights on the die?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static throughout the shot, capturing the die's movement from a slightly elevated angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016085494309663773 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141085624694824 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016085494309663773, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016085494309663773, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12038499116897583, + 0.06492166221141815, + 0.2855699956417084, + 0.30578115582466125, + 0.0734548345208168, + 0.058739274740219116, + 0.02482859417796135, + 0.021561119705438614, + 0.03426152095198631, + 0.010496917180716991 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016085494309663773 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a dark blue six-sided die made of polished, slightly translucent acrylic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the die fall into the frame and impact a warm, wood-textured kitchen table surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the die bounce erratically, spin in mid-air, and glide across the table before coming to a complete rest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by soft, realistic overhead kitchen light, casting soft shadows and highlights on the die?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static throughout the shot, capturing the die's movement from a slightly elevated angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014200588688254356 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264200687408447 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014200588688254356, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014200588688254356, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1619536578655243, + 0.1421797126531601, + 0.06711996346712112, + 0.37453824281692505, + 0.04547363519668579, + 0.07519133388996124, + 0.0347352959215641, + 0.035855356603860855, + 0.04233685880899429, + 0.02061598002910614 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014200588688254356 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a dark blue six-sided die made of polished, slightly translucent acrylic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the die fall into the frame and impact a warm, wood-textured kitchen table surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the die bounce erratically, spin in mid-air, and glide across the table before coming to a complete rest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by soft, realistic overhead kitchen light, casting soft shadows and highlights on the die?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static throughout the shot, capturing the die's movement from a slightly elevated angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016078457236289978 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141078472137451 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016078457236289978, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016078457236289978, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15947207808494568, + 0.067924864590168, + 0.05976816266775131, + 0.34824371337890625, + 0.1655605286359787, + 0.03444372117519379, + 0.08925016969442368, + 0.02274429239332676, + 0.02571720816195011, + 0.026875246316194534 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016078457236289978 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a dark blue six-sided die made of polished, slightly translucent acrylic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the die fall into the frame and impact a warm, wood-textured kitchen table surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the die bounce erratically, spin in mid-air, and glide across the table before coming to a complete rest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by soft, realistic overhead kitchen light, casting soft shadows and highlights on the die?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static throughout the shot, capturing the die's movement from a slightly elevated angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05493387207388878 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929933786392212 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05493387207388878, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05493387207388878, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10081533342599869, + 0.04542078822851181, + 0.025332272052764893, + 0.5941808223724365, + 0.06025385856628418, + 0.04922591522336006, + 0.08089026063680649, + 0.016152240335941315, + 0.015825524926185608, + 0.011903011240065098 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05493387207388878 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dynamic slow-motion close-up captures the action from a slightly elevated angle as a dark blue six-sided die falls into the frame. Made of polished, slightly translucent acrylic, the die impacts the warm, wood-textured surface of the kitchen table with a sharp impact. Under the soft, realistic overhead kitchen light, it bounces erratically, spinning in mid-air, causing the white, concave dots to blur into fleeting streaks. The camera remains static, allowing dynamic movement to fill the scene as the die loses momentum, gliding across the polished wood before swaying to a final, tense moment. It settles decisively, completely at rest, shifting the feel of the scene from chaotic energy to stillness. The final frame fixates on the perfectly still die, its top surface clearly displaying the number six. The warm light casts soft, fleeting shadows alongside it and creates subtle highlights along its smooth edges, creating a quiet, defined atmosphere. High resolution.", + "seed": 21614, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_9/index_3799_seed_21614_dp_19_rank_38_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.037013767287135124, + "vlm_logprob": -0.037013767287135124, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.5, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.037013767287135124, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a dark blue six-sided die made of polished, slightly translucent acrylic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the die fall into the frame and impact a warm, wood-textured kitchen table surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the die bounce erratically, spin in mid-air, and glide across the table before coming to a complete rest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by soft, realistic overhead kitchen light, casting soft shadows and highlights on the die?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static throughout the shot, capturing the die's movement from a slightly elevated angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03541019186377525 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.410410165786743 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03541019186377525, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03541019186377525, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2538948059082031, + 0.0906878262758255, + 0.18473468720912933, + 0.07159353047609329, + 0.04213244095444679, + 0.03168659657239914, + 0.03792370483279228, + 0.04515121132135391, + 0.04382792115211487, + 0.19836720824241638 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03541019186377525 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a dark blue six-sided die made of polished, slightly translucent acrylic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the die fall into the frame and impact a warm, wood-textured kitchen table surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the die bounce erratically, spin in mid-air, and glide across the table before coming to a complete rest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by soft, realistic overhead kitchen light, casting soft shadows and highlights on the die?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static throughout the shot, capturing the die's movement from a slightly elevated angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01820462942123413 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018204689025879 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01820462942123413, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01820462942123413, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16852787137031555, + 0.05209548771381378, + 0.3918534219264984, + 0.05716107413172722, + 0.03334983065724373, + 0.03609071671962738, + 0.044165465980768204, + 0.05511397495865822, + 0.020145030692219734, + 0.14149706065654755 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01820462942123413 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a dark blue six-sided die made of polished, slightly translucent acrylic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the die fall into the frame and impact a warm, wood-textured kitchen table surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the die bounce erratically, spin in mid-air, and glide across the table before coming to a complete rest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by soft, realistic overhead kitchen light, casting soft shadows and highlights on the die?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static throughout the shot, capturing the die's movement from a slightly elevated angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016075406223535538 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141075611114502 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016075406223535538, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016075406223535538, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09510473906993866, + 0.04764542356133461, + 0.17615489661693573, + 0.15460625290870667, + 0.06361491978168488, + 0.08711965382099152, + 0.04309425130486488, + 0.17585249245166779, + 0.04572561755776405, + 0.11108175665140152 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 7, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016075406223535538 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a dark blue six-sided die made of polished, slightly translucent acrylic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the die fall into the frame and impact a warm, wood-textured kitchen table surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the die bounce erratically, spin in mid-air, and glide across the table before coming to a complete rest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by soft, realistic overhead kitchen light, casting soft shadows and highlights on the die?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static throughout the shot, capturing the die's movement from a slightly elevated angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026361173018813133 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513612270355225 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026361173018813133, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026361173018813133, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.31768420338630676, + 0.11263217031955719, + 0.08174558728933334, + 0.11356200277805328, + 0.05148804932832718, + 0.07756473869085312, + 0.02832348644733429, + 0.07597934454679489, + 0.051280584186315536, + 0.08973980695009232 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026361173018813133 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a dark blue six-sided die made of polished, slightly translucent acrylic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the die fall into the frame and impact a warm, wood-textured kitchen table surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the die bounce erratically, spin in mid-air, and glide across the table before coming to a complete rest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by soft, realistic overhead kitchen light, casting soft shadows and highlights on the die?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static throughout the shot, capturing the die's movement from a slightly elevated angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08901743590831757 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.464017391204834 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08901743590831757, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08901743590831757, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.061918847262859344, + 0.1310875117778778, + 0.10668500512838364, + 0.049018144607543945, + 0.08572041243314743, + 0.12089687585830688, + 0.0362621434032917, + 0.018294425681233406, + 0.03925178200006485, + 0.3508649170398712 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08901743590831757 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dynamic slow-motion close-up captures the action from a slightly elevated angle as a dark blue six-sided die falls into the frame. Made of polished, slightly translucent acrylic, the die impacts the warm, wood-textured surface of the kitchen table with a sharp impact. Under the soft, realistic overhead kitchen light, it bounces erratically, spinning in mid-air, causing the white, concave dots to blur into fleeting streaks. The camera remains static, allowing dynamic movement to fill the scene as the die loses momentum, gliding across the polished wood before swaying to a final, tense moment. It settles decisively, completely at rest, shifting the feel of the scene from chaotic energy to stillness. The final frame fixates on the perfectly still die, its top surface clearly displaying the number six. The warm light casts soft, fleeting shadows alongside it and creates subtle highlights along its smooth edges, creating a quiet, defined atmosphere. High resolution.", + "seed": 21615, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000020/group_9/index_3799_seed_21615_dp_19_rank_38_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.02582883443683386, + "vlm_logprob": -0.02582883443683386, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.85, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.02582883443683386, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a dark blue six-sided die made of polished, slightly translucent acrylic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the die fall into the frame and impact a warm, wood-textured kitchen table surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the die bounce erratically, spin in mid-air, and glide across the table before coming to a complete rest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by soft, realistic overhead kitchen light, casting soft shadows and highlights on the die?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static throughout the shot, capturing the die's movement from a slightly elevated angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0350184440612793 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5350184440612793 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0350184440612793, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0350184440612793, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13333381712436676, + 0.09515000879764557, + 0.0895652323961258, + 0.09490041434764862, + 0.12911339104175568, + 0.12028715759515762, + 0.12426811456680298, + 0.11718188226222992, + 0.05825231224298477, + 0.037947751581668854 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0350184440612793 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a dark blue six-sided die made of polished, slightly translucent acrylic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the die fall into the frame and impact a warm, wood-textured kitchen table surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the die bounce erratically, spin in mid-air, and glide across the table before coming to a complete rest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by soft, realistic overhead kitchen light, casting soft shadows and highlights on the die?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static throughout the shot, capturing the die's movement from a slightly elevated angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011098791845142841 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511098861694336 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011098791845142841, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011098791845142841, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24687309563159943, + 0.1204678937792778, + 0.09189727157354355, + 0.09219832718372345, + 0.22783778607845306, + 0.0640428215265274, + 0.03777891770005226, + 0.05483391880989075, + 0.039336059242486954, + 0.0247338879853487 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011098791845142841 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a dark blue six-sided die made of polished, slightly translucent acrylic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the die fall into the frame and impact a warm, wood-textured kitchen table surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the die bounce erratically, spin in mid-air, and glide across the table before coming to a complete rest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by soft, realistic overhead kitchen light, casting soft shadows and highlights on the die?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static throughout the shot, capturing the die's movement from a slightly elevated angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023300651460886 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7733006477355957 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023300651460886, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023300651460886, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14504456520080566, + 0.1008327379822731, + 0.11607321351766586, + 0.06890299916267395, + 0.22827453911304474, + 0.06407104432582855, + 0.1602494865655899, + 0.044675447046756744, + 0.04320809990167618, + 0.028667841106653214 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023300651460886 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a dark blue six-sided die made of polished, slightly translucent acrylic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the die fall into the frame and impact a warm, wood-textured kitchen table surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the die bounce erratically, spin in mid-air, and glide across the table before coming to a complete rest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by soft, realistic overhead kitchen light, casting soft shadows and highlights on the die?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static throughout the shot, capturing the die's movement from a slightly elevated angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011091718450188637 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511091709136963 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011091718450188637, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011091718450188637, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1636478155851364, + 0.42549213767051697, + 0.06792618334293365, + 0.02694721333682537, + 0.10405503213405609, + 0.04912671819329262, + 0.05108571797609329, + 0.04720601812005043, + 0.022980382665991783, + 0.0415327325463295 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011091718450188637 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a dark blue six-sided die made of polished, slightly translucent acrylic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the die fall into the frame and impact a warm, wood-textured kitchen table surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the die bounce erratically, spin in mid-air, and glide across the table before coming to a complete rest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by soft, realistic overhead kitchen light, casting soft shadows and highlights on the die?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static throughout the shot, capturing the die's movement from a slightly elevated angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.048634566366672516 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486345291137695 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.048634566366672516, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.048634566366672516, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4674381613731384, + 0.08979427069425583, + 0.08071614056825638, + 0.022000428289175034, + 0.11439237743616104, + 0.030785350129008293, + 0.05116156488656998, + 0.07709378749132156, + 0.0473494753241539, + 0.019268451258540154 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.048634566366672516 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_0/index_tensor([113, 113])_group_0_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_0/index_tensor([113, 113])_group_0_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..c8764d29776c1960dcc7baca1d8e30a016a8f756 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_0/index_tensor([113, 113])_group_0_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "Shot from a slightly upward angle, the camera moves forward at a slow, contemplative pace, passing through a dense, tranquil bamboo forest. Sunlight, filtered by the towering leaves, creates dappled shadows, gently swaying across the ground in the breeze. In front of the camera, a simple house, its whitewashed walls and gray tiles slightly weathered, looms deep within the forest. An ancient stone staircase, paved with natural stone and covered in emerald green moss, winds its way to the door. The slender green grass beside the steps sways gently in the breeze. As the camera steadily moves forward, past the stone steps, its focus finally settles on a half-rolled curtain woven from dried reeds beneath the door's lintel, swaying subtly in the air. Through the gaps in the curtains and the rolled-up parts, one can glimpse the dim and elegant scene inside the room: on a quaint dark wooden table, lies a guqin with a warm lacquer finish and distinct strings. Beside it are scattered several yellowed paper scrolls, some of which have been unfolded, revealing calligraphy in ink, while others are tied with ribbons. The whole scene presents a cool tranquility under the soft diffuse light, and is filled with a secluded, focused and poetic atmosphere of books. It seems as if one can hear the low voice-over \"Mountains are not famous for their height, but for the immortals who live there; water is not magical because of its depth, but for the dragons who live there...\" echoing in the air.", + "seed": 5468, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_0/index_113_seed_5468_dp_0_rank_0_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.07386517152190208, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07386517152190208, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.9749999761581423, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07386517152190208, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving forward through a dense bamboo forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a house with whitewashed walls and gray tiles visible deep within the forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an ancient stone staircase covered in emerald green moss winding to the house door?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a half-rolled curtain woven from dried reeds visible beneath the door's lintel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a guqin with a warm lacquer finish visible on a dark wooden table inside the room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05266847088932991 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.052668571472168 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05266847088932991, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05266847088932991, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10305042564868927, + 0.14167271554470062, + 0.1281455159187317, + 0.12825515866279602, + 0.1321425884962082, + 0.05502401292324066, + 0.10134030133485794, + 0.08125770092010498, + 0.07903249561786652, + 0.050079070031642914 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05266847088932991 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving forward through a dense bamboo forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a house with whitewashed walls and gray tiles visible deep within the forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an ancient stone staircase covered in emerald green moss winding to the house door?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a half-rolled curtain woven from dried reeds visible beneath the door's lintel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a guqin with a warm lacquer finish visible on a dark wooden table inside the room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00865836814045906 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758658409118652 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00865836814045906, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00865836814045906, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12578870356082916, + 0.1858762800693512, + 0.12020566314458847, + 0.20012129843235016, + 0.021046189591288567, + 0.026098530739545822, + 0.20751066505908966, + 0.050278760492801666, + 0.037571679800748825, + 0.025502270087599754 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00865836814045906 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving forward through a dense bamboo forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a house with whitewashed walls and gray tiles visible deep within the forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an ancient stone staircase covered in emerald green moss winding to the house door?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a half-rolled curtain woven from dried reeds visible beneath the door's lintel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a guqin with a warm lacquer finish visible on a dark wooden table inside the room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14283321797847748 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0178332328796387 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14283321797847748, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14283321797847748, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0886373296380043, + 0.12010709196329117, + 0.1819790154695511, + 0.15438681840896606, + 0.1221516951918602, + 0.06335598975419998, + 0.11255352944135666, + 0.07687544822692871, + 0.050195664167404175, + 0.02975744940340519 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14283321797847748 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving forward through a dense bamboo forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a house with whitewashed walls and gray tiles visible deep within the forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an ancient stone staircase covered in emerald green moss winding to the house door?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a half-rolled curtain woven from dried reeds visible beneath the door's lintel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a guqin with a warm lacquer finish visible on a dark wooden table inside the room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03810315206646919 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881031036376953 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03810315206646919, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03810315206646919, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10465395450592041, + 0.1419622004032135, + 0.24398298561573029, + 0.10257260501384735, + 0.07964404672384262, + 0.057619523257017136, + 0.14455066621303558, + 0.055342257022857666, + 0.045107606798410416, + 0.024564113467931747 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03810315206646919 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving forward through a dense bamboo forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a house with whitewashed walls and gray tiles visible deep within the forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an ancient stone staircase covered in emerald green moss winding to the house door?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a half-rolled curtain woven from dried reeds visible beneath the door's lintel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a guqin with a warm lacquer finish visible on a dark wooden table inside the room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12706264853477478 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1270625591278076 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12706264853477478, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.9999998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12706264853477478, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08899510651826859, + 0.04019922763109207, + 0.17243017256259918, + 0.07393606752157211, + 0.10254480689764023, + 0.06031843647360802, + 0.08723394572734833, + 0.10621122270822525, + 0.22997571527957916, + 0.03815523907542229 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 2, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12706264853477478 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "Shot from a slightly upward angle, the camera moves forward at a slow, contemplative pace, passing through a dense, tranquil bamboo forest. Sunlight, filtered by the towering leaves, creates dappled shadows, gently swaying across the ground in the breeze. In front of the camera, a simple house, its whitewashed walls and gray tiles slightly weathered, looms deep within the forest. An ancient stone staircase, paved with natural stone and covered in emerald green moss, winds its way to the door. The slender green grass beside the steps sways gently in the breeze. As the camera steadily moves forward, past the stone steps, its focus finally settles on a half-rolled curtain woven from dried reeds beneath the door's lintel, swaying subtly in the air. Through the gaps in the curtains and the rolled-up parts, one can glimpse the dim and elegant scene inside the room: on a quaint dark wooden table, lies a guqin with a warm lacquer finish and distinct strings. Beside it are scattered several yellowed paper scrolls, some of which have been unfolded, revealing calligraphy in ink, while others are tied with ribbons. The whole scene presents a cool tranquility under the soft diffuse light, and is filled with a secluded, focused and poetic atmosphere of books. It seems as if one can hear the low voice-over \"Mountains are not famous for their height, but for the immortals who live there; water is not magical because of its depth, but for the dragons who live there...\" echoing in the air.", + "seed": 5469, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_0/index_113_seed_5469_dp_0_rank_0_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.02179800169542432, + "vlm_logprob": -0.02179800169542432, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.125, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.02179800169542432, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving forward through a dense bamboo forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a house with whitewashed walls and gray tiles visible deep within the forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an ancient stone staircase covered in emerald green moss winding to the house door?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a half-rolled curtain woven from dried reeds visible beneath the door's lintel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a guqin with a warm lacquer finish visible on a dark wooden table inside the room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.057701773941516876 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.932701826095581 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.057701773941516876, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.057701773941516876, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.33174023032188416, + 0.11296476423740387, + 0.06964651495218277, + 0.09754780679941177, + 0.08220065385103226, + 0.045311182737350464, + 0.10427352786064148, + 0.024556180462241173, + 0.049661826342344284, + 0.0820973664522171 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.057701773941516876 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving forward through a dense bamboo forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a house with whitewashed walls and gray tiles visible deep within the forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an ancient stone staircase covered in emerald green moss winding to the house door?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a half-rolled curtain woven from dried reeds visible beneath the door's lintel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a guqin with a warm lacquer finish visible on a dark wooden table inside the room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005955806467682123 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130955696105957 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005955806467682123, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005955806467682123, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17499171197414398, + 0.1370418816804886, + 0.13796547055244446, + 0.10547412186861038, + 0.1327560842037201, + 0.03571546450257301, + 0.08576308935880661, + 0.05617733299732208, + 0.05730487406253815, + 0.07681003957986832 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005955806467682123 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving forward through a dense bamboo forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a house with whitewashed walls and gray tiles visible deep within the forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an ancient stone staircase covered in emerald green moss winding to the house door?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a half-rolled curtain woven from dried reeds visible beneath the door's lintel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a guqin with a warm lacquer finish visible on a dark wooden table inside the room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011078514158725739 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511078357696533 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011078514158725739, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011078514158725739, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2811284363269806, + 0.05547525733709335, + 0.23822738230228424, + 0.054728638380765915, + 0.06276289373636246, + 0.04978593438863754, + 0.03224586322903633, + 0.05182865634560585, + 0.0898478627204895, + 0.0839691236615181 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011078514158725739 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving forward through a dense bamboo forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a house with whitewashed walls and gray tiles visible deep within the forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an ancient stone staircase covered in emerald green moss winding to the house door?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a half-rolled curtain woven from dried reeds visible beneath the door's lintel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a guqin with a warm lacquer finish visible on a dark wooden table inside the room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01818707026541233 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018187046051025 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01818707026541233, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01818707026541233, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1756667047739029, + 0.09345356374979019, + 0.05032624676823616, + 0.09847971051931381, + 0.07616040855646133, + 0.04755610227584839, + 0.12365277111530304, + 0.10553991049528122, + 0.08748442679643631, + 0.14168010652065277 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01818707026541233 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving forward through a dense bamboo forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a house with whitewashed walls and gray tiles visible deep within the forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an ancient stone staircase covered in emerald green moss winding to the house door?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a half-rolled curtain woven from dried reeds visible beneath the door's lintel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a guqin with a warm lacquer finish visible on a dark wooden table inside the room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016066843643784523 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141067028045654 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016066843643784523, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016066843643784523, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10018899291753769, + 0.061400432139635086, + 0.04233739897608757, + 0.04570980742573738, + 0.04119083285331726, + 0.04451513662934303, + 0.04220043122768402, + 0.07073058933019638, + 0.3928056061267853, + 0.15892073512077332 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016066843643784523 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "Shot from a slightly upward angle, the camera moves forward at a slow, contemplative pace, passing through a dense, tranquil bamboo forest. Sunlight, filtered by the towering leaves, creates dappled shadows, gently swaying across the ground in the breeze. In front of the camera, a simple house, its whitewashed walls and gray tiles slightly weathered, looms deep within the forest. An ancient stone staircase, paved with natural stone and covered in emerald green moss, winds its way to the door. The slender green grass beside the steps sways gently in the breeze. As the camera steadily moves forward, past the stone steps, its focus finally settles on a half-rolled curtain woven from dried reeds beneath the door's lintel, swaying subtly in the air. Through the gaps in the curtains and the rolled-up parts, one can glimpse the dim and elegant scene inside the room: on a quaint dark wooden table, lies a guqin with a warm lacquer finish and distinct strings. Beside it are scattered several yellowed paper scrolls, some of which have been unfolded, revealing calligraphy in ink, while others are tied with ribbons. The whole scene presents a cool tranquility under the soft diffuse light, and is filled with a secluded, focused and poetic atmosphere of books. It seems as if one can hear the low voice-over \"Mountains are not famous for their height, but for the immortals who live there; water is not magical because of its depth, but for the dragons who live there...\" echoing in the air.", + "seed": 5470, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_0/index_113_seed_5470_dp_1_rank_2_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.036742588877677916, + "vlm_logprob": -0.036742588877677916, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.425, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.036742588877677916, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving forward through a dense bamboo forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a house with whitewashed walls and gray tiles visible deep within the forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an ancient stone staircase covered in emerald green moss winding to the house door?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a half-rolled curtain woven from dried reeds visible beneath the door's lintel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a guqin with a warm lacquer finish visible on a dark wooden table inside the room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05447869747877121 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.054478645324707 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05447869747877121, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05447869747877121, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09609497338533401, + 0.03506111726164818, + 0.17405614256858826, + 0.19528420269489288, + 0.03440152853727341, + 0.12083923816680908, + 0.020038973540067673, + 0.033390361815690994, + 0.26309847831726074, + 0.027734965085983276 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05447869747877121 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving forward through a dense bamboo forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a house with whitewashed walls and gray tiles visible deep within the forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an ancient stone staircase covered in emerald green moss winding to the house door?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a half-rolled curtain woven from dried reeds visible beneath the door's lintel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a guqin with a warm lacquer finish visible on a dark wooden table inside the room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014215279370546341 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264215469360352 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014215279370546341, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014215279370546341, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05368660390377045, + 0.03732645884156227, + 0.7018895149230957, + 0.03247242420911789, + 0.009536783210933208, + 0.023975742980837822, + 0.014403163455426693, + 0.010781926102936268, + 0.06300181895494461, + 0.05292557552456856 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014215279370546341 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving forward through a dense bamboo forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a house with whitewashed walls and gray tiles visible deep within the forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an ancient stone staircase covered in emerald green moss winding to the house door?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a half-rolled curtain woven from dried reeds visible beneath the door's lintel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a guqin with a warm lacquer finish visible on a dark wooden table inside the room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04867101460695267 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048671007156372 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04867101460695267, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04867101460695267, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13561084866523743, + 0.2087981402873993, + 0.37537482380867004, + 0.06224812939763069, + 0.016497576609253883, + 0.06793127954006195, + 0.03188161179423332, + 0.02206968143582344, + 0.036720242351293564, + 0.04286770895123482 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04867101460695267 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving forward through a dense bamboo forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a house with whitewashed walls and gray tiles visible deep within the forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an ancient stone staircase covered in emerald green moss winding to the house door?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a half-rolled curtain woven from dried reeds visible beneath the door's lintel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a guqin with a warm lacquer finish visible on a dark wooden table inside the room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02328900620341301 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732889652252197 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02328900620341301, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02328900620341301, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07362750172615051, + 0.04090650752186775, + 0.2616244852542877, + 0.08256987482309341, + 0.027522599324584007, + 0.11238089203834534, + 0.04528767615556717, + 0.024101708084344864, + 0.20481151342391968, + 0.12716726958751678 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02328900620341301 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving forward through a dense bamboo forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a house with whitewashed walls and gray tiles visible deep within the forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an ancient stone staircase covered in emerald green moss winding to the house door?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a half-rolled curtain woven from dried reeds visible beneath the door's lintel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a guqin with a warm lacquer finish visible on a dark wooden table inside the room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04305894672870636 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680588722229004 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04305894672870636, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04305894672870636, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09332513809204102, + 0.08581545948982239, + 0.11391433328390121, + 0.07240128517150879, + 0.059460755437612534, + 0.05828538537025452, + 0.028642861172556877, + 0.026471653953194618, + 0.07304373383522034, + 0.3886394500732422 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04305894672870636 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "Shot from a slightly upward angle, the camera moves forward at a slow, contemplative pace, passing through a dense, tranquil bamboo forest. Sunlight, filtered by the towering leaves, creates dappled shadows, gently swaying across the ground in the breeze. In front of the camera, a simple house, its whitewashed walls and gray tiles slightly weathered, looms deep within the forest. An ancient stone staircase, paved with natural stone and covered in emerald green moss, winds its way to the door. The slender green grass beside the steps sways gently in the breeze. As the camera steadily moves forward, past the stone steps, its focus finally settles on a half-rolled curtain woven from dried reeds beneath the door's lintel, swaying subtly in the air. Through the gaps in the curtains and the rolled-up parts, one can glimpse the dim and elegant scene inside the room: on a quaint dark wooden table, lies a guqin with a warm lacquer finish and distinct strings. Beside it are scattered several yellowed paper scrolls, some of which have been unfolded, revealing calligraphy in ink, while others are tied with ribbons. The whole scene presents a cool tranquility under the soft diffuse light, and is filled with a secluded, focused and poetic atmosphere of books. It seems as if one can hear the low voice-over \"Mountains are not famous for their height, but for the immortals who live there; water is not magical because of its depth, but for the dragons who live there...\" echoing in the air.", + "seed": 5471, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_0/index_113_seed_5471_dp_1_rank_2_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.05084477383643389, + "vlm_logprob": -0.05084477383643389, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.525, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.05084477383643389, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving forward through a dense bamboo forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a house with whitewashed walls and gray tiles visible deep within the forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an ancient stone staircase covered in emerald green moss winding to the house door?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a half-rolled curtain woven from dried reeds visible beneath the door's lintel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a guqin with a warm lacquer finish visible on a dark wooden table inside the room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14610907435417175 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.021109104156494 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14610907435417175, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14610907435417175, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4368992745876312, + 0.10281749814748764, + 0.09846869111061096, + 0.07883483916521072, + 0.04046674445271492, + 0.04567243158817291, + 0.06274937093257904, + 0.052871525287628174, + 0.043520864099264145, + 0.037698812782764435 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14610907435417175 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving forward through a dense bamboo forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a house with whitewashed walls and gray tiles visible deep within the forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an ancient stone staircase covered in emerald green moss winding to the house door?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a half-rolled curtain woven from dried reeds visible beneath the door's lintel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a guqin with a warm lacquer finish visible on a dark wooden table inside the room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005264941602945328 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255264759063721 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005264941602945328, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005264941602945328, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21322079002857208, + 0.09598427265882492, + 0.08410981297492981, + 0.0412006750702858, + 0.061299871653318405, + 0.24357014894485474, + 0.1033032014966011, + 0.05849047005176544, + 0.027335150167346, + 0.07148563116788864 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005264941602945328 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving forward through a dense bamboo forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a house with whitewashed walls and gray tiles visible deep within the forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an ancient stone staircase covered in emerald green moss winding to the house door?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a half-rolled curtain woven from dried reeds visible beneath the door's lintel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a guqin with a warm lacquer finish visible on a dark wooden table inside the room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03370559215545654 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408705711364746 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03370559215545654, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03370559215545654, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3206880986690521, + 0.10702631622552872, + 0.07813539355993271, + 0.071341373026371, + 0.12945356965065002, + 0.03744455799460411, + 0.07354731112718582, + 0.05408042296767235, + 0.07217119634151459, + 0.05611179769039154 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03370559215545654 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving forward through a dense bamboo forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a house with whitewashed walls and gray tiles visible deep within the forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an ancient stone staircase covered in emerald green moss winding to the house door?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a half-rolled curtain woven from dried reeds visible beneath the door's lintel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a guqin with a warm lacquer finish visible on a dark wooden table inside the room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01419729832559824 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.26419734954834 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01419729832559824, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01419729832559824, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14008228480815887, + 0.025253478437662125, + 0.03472021222114563, + 0.02405887097120285, + 0.13069090247154236, + 0.08435263484716415, + 0.05062776803970337, + 0.12770111858844757, + 0.17188183963298798, + 0.21063093841075897 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01419729832559824 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving forward through a dense bamboo forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a house with whitewashed walls and gray tiles visible deep within the forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an ancient stone staircase covered in emerald green moss winding to the house door?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a half-rolled curtain woven from dried reeds visible beneath the door's lintel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a guqin with a warm lacquer finish visible on a dark wooden table inside the room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.054946962743997574 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299468994140625 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.054946962743997574, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.054946962743997574, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07857091724872589, + 0.04025135561823845, + 0.019988909363746643, + 0.035846102982759476, + 0.060190778225660324, + 0.08526328206062317, + 0.06213505566120148, + 0.035310640931129456, + 0.4519833028316498, + 0.13045965135097504 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.054946962743997574 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_1/index_tensor([3402, 3402])_group_1_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_1/index_tensor([3402, 3402])_group_1_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..81587a5ad303a7a1aa329585ef2a9ca574edc51e --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_1/index_tensor([3402, 3402])_group_1_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "single, still, high-definition macro shot, rendered in a delicate watercolor style inspired by traditional Korean aesthetics, captures a long, slender, tube-shaped millipede. Initially, the creature appears in a tight, perfect spiral, its pale, almost pearly body gracefully coiled around a gnarled, weathered branch covered in furry, damp moss. The scene is illuminated by soft, diffuse light that filters through the invisible tree canopy, casting a gentle glow on the millipede's segmented form and eliminating any harsh shadows. With a calm, fluid movement, the millipede begins to unfurl; its head deliberately lifts, and the rest of its body follows in a single, unbroken, mesmerizing wave. As it extends, its countless, slender, hair-like legs cascade in hypnotic, coordinated ripples along its length. The background, a minimalist, out-of-focus palette of pale greens and earthy browns, suggests a misty forest backdrop while keeping the focus squarely on the creature's graceful movements, creating a tranquil, contemplative atmosphere of profound natural beauty.", + "seed": 29781, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_1/index_3402_seed_29781_dp_2_rank_4_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.3453322721645236, + "vlm_logprob": -0.3453322721645236, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.375, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.3453322721645236, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a delicate watercolor style inspired by traditional Korean aesthetics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a long, slender, tube-shaped millipede with a pale, pearly body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the millipede start in a tight, perfect spiral coiled around a gnarled, weathered branch covered in furry, damp moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the millipede unfurl with a calm, fluid movement where its head lifts first and the body follows in a single, unbroken wave?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a minimalist, out-of-focus palette of pale greens and earthy browns suggesting a misty forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3141742944717407 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3141742944717407 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.3141742944717407, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -1.3141742944717407, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1982719600200653, + 0.14965544641017914, + 0.09450904279947281, + 0.08398125320672989, + 0.07188481092453003, + 0.12584403157234192, + 0.06156914681196213, + 0.020088298246264458, + 0.08085237443447113, + 0.11334364116191864 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.3141742944717407 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a delicate watercolor style inspired by traditional Korean aesthetics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a long, slender, tube-shaped millipede with a pale, pearly body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the millipede start in a tight, perfect spiral coiled around a gnarled, weathered branch covered in furry, damp moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the millipede unfurl with a calm, fluid movement where its head lifts first and the body follows in a single, unbroken wave?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a minimalist, out-of-focus palette of pale greens and earthy browns suggesting a misty forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029823893681168556 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298237800598145 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029823893681168556, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029823893681168556, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04785589873790741, + 0.042164016515016556, + 0.07738719135522842, + 0.06484853476285934, + 0.16137045621871948, + 0.06876427680253983, + 0.08669797331094742, + 0.10250349342823029, + 0.10576280206441879, + 0.24264530837535858 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029823893681168556 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a delicate watercolor style inspired by traditional Korean aesthetics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a long, slender, tube-shaped millipede with a pale, pearly body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the millipede start in a tight, perfect spiral coiled around a gnarled, weathered branch covered in furry, damp moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the millipede unfurl with a calm, fluid movement where its head lifts first and the body follows in a single, unbroken wave?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a minimalist, out-of-focus palette of pale greens and earthy browns suggesting a misty forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3486727178096771 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2236727476119995 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3486727178096771, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3486727178096771, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12904314696788788, + 0.0690460354089737, + 0.07592237740755081, + 0.11214377731084824, + 0.11072059720754623, + 0.07204155623912811, + 0.1534578949213028, + 0.040968701243400574, + 0.05645124986767769, + 0.18020467460155487 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3486727178096771 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a delicate watercolor style inspired by traditional Korean aesthetics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a long, slender, tube-shaped millipede with a pale, pearly body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the millipede start in a tight, perfect spiral coiled around a gnarled, weathered branch covered in furry, damp moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the millipede unfurl with a calm, fluid movement where its head lifts first and the body follows in a single, unbroken wave?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a minimalist, out-of-focus palette of pale greens and earthy browns suggesting a misty forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026362333446741104 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651362419128418 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026362333446741104, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026362333446741104, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07818867266178131, + 0.07209862768650055, + 0.07192572951316833, + 0.054204847663640976, + 0.08164013922214508, + 0.11445944011211395, + 0.08266203105449677, + 0.09022188186645508, + 0.0725533589720726, + 0.28204527497291565 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026362333446741104 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a delicate watercolor style inspired by traditional Korean aesthetics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a long, slender, tube-shaped millipede with a pale, pearly body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the millipede start in a tight, perfect spiral coiled around a gnarled, weathered branch covered in furry, damp moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the millipede unfurl with a calm, fluid movement where its head lifts first and the body follows in a single, unbroken wave?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a minimalist, out-of-focus palette of pale greens and earthy browns suggesting a misty forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007628121413290501 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882627964019775 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007628121413290501, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007628121413290501, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14668622612953186, + 0.14573465287685394, + 0.05958975851535797, + 0.047361843287944794, + 0.1543196588754654, + 0.11699656397104263, + 0.03372220695018768, + 0.041532743722200394, + 0.07015001028776169, + 0.18390639126300812 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007628121413290501 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "single, still, high-definition macro shot, rendered in a delicate watercolor style inspired by traditional Korean aesthetics, captures a long, slender, tube-shaped millipede. Initially, the creature appears in a tight, perfect spiral, its pale, almost pearly body gracefully coiled around a gnarled, weathered branch covered in furry, damp moss. The scene is illuminated by soft, diffuse light that filters through the invisible tree canopy, casting a gentle glow on the millipede's segmented form and eliminating any harsh shadows. With a calm, fluid movement, the millipede begins to unfurl; its head deliberately lifts, and the rest of its body follows in a single, unbroken, mesmerizing wave. As it extends, its countless, slender, hair-like legs cascade in hypnotic, coordinated ripples along its length. The background, a minimalist, out-of-focus palette of pale greens and earthy browns, suggests a misty forest backdrop while keeping the focus squarely on the creature's graceful movements, creating a tranquil, contemplative atmosphere of profound natural beauty.", + "seed": 29782, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_1/index_3402_seed_29782_dp_2_rank_4_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.08148604321759194, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08148604321759194, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.8500000119209288, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08148604321759194, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a delicate watercolor style inspired by traditional Korean aesthetics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a long, slender, tube-shaped millipede with a pale, pearly body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the millipede start in a tight, perfect spiral coiled around a gnarled, weathered branch covered in furry, damp moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the millipede unfurl with a calm, fluid movement where its head lifts first and the body follows in a single, unbroken wave?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a minimalist, out-of-focus palette of pale greens and earthy browns suggesting a misty forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.35034340620040894 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2253434658050537 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.35034340620040894, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.8750000596046448, + "token_credit_reward": -0.35034340620040894, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16413092613220215, + 0.16529889404773712, + 0.06433796137571335, + 0.024462595582008362, + 0.04593954607844353, + 0.04696236550807953, + 0.10348906368017197, + 0.028147274628281593, + 0.0846557766199112, + 0.27257561683654785 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.35034340620040894 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a delicate watercolor style inspired by traditional Korean aesthetics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a long, slender, tube-shaped millipede with a pale, pearly body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the millipede start in a tight, perfect spiral coiled around a gnarled, weathered branch covered in furry, damp moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the millipede unfurl with a calm, fluid movement where its head lifts first and the body follows in a single, unbroken wave?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a minimalist, out-of-focus palette of pale greens and earthy browns suggesting a misty forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014202586375176907 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.26420259475708 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014202586375176907, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014202586375176907, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12986411154270172, + 0.10598575323820114, + 0.2015153020620346, + 0.06642623245716095, + 0.037809208035469055, + 0.0821598470211029, + 0.08940310031175613, + 0.09973758459091187, + 0.11714334040880203, + 0.0699554979801178 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014202586375176907 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a delicate watercolor style inspired by traditional Korean aesthetics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a long, slender, tube-shaped millipede with a pale, pearly body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the millipede start in a tight, perfect spiral coiled around a gnarled, weathered branch covered in furry, damp moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the millipede unfurl with a calm, fluid movement where its head lifts first and the body follows in a single, unbroken wave?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a minimalist, out-of-focus palette of pale greens and earthy browns suggesting a misty forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020590247586369514 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895590305328369 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020590247586369514, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020590247586369514, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22437383234500885, + 0.07683912664651871, + 0.0958930253982544, + 0.11587684601545334, + 0.12311504781246185, + 0.04903567582368851, + 0.0753578320145607, + 0.07379458099603653, + 0.07391098141670227, + 0.09180305153131485 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020590247586369514 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a delicate watercolor style inspired by traditional Korean aesthetics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a long, slender, tube-shaped millipede with a pale, pearly body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the millipede start in a tight, perfect spiral coiled around a gnarled, weathered branch covered in furry, damp moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the millipede unfurl with a calm, fluid movement where its head lifts first and the body follows in a single, unbroken wave?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a minimalist, out-of-focus palette of pale greens and earthy browns suggesting a misty forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02058347500860691 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895583391189575 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02058347500860691, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02058347500860691, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22002634406089783, + 0.11051236838102341, + 0.07806189358234406, + 0.06058602035045624, + 0.09395276010036469, + 0.0977337434887886, + 0.09350569546222687, + 0.05899703502655029, + 0.05645173415541649, + 0.13017244637012482 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02058347500860691 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a delicate watercolor style inspired by traditional Korean aesthetics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a long, slender, tube-shaped millipede with a pale, pearly body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the millipede start in a tight, perfect spiral coiled around a gnarled, weathered branch covered in furry, damp moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the millipede unfurl with a calm, fluid movement where its head lifts first and the body follows in a single, unbroken wave?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a minimalist, out-of-focus palette of pale greens and earthy browns suggesting a misty forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0017105009173974395 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.376710414886475 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0017105009173974395, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0017105009173974395, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.209272563457489, + 0.07934611290693283, + 0.045393142849206924, + 0.0350792221724987, + 0.11244821548461914, + 0.03826417773962021, + 0.06044579669833183, + 0.04926558956503868, + 0.09842412918806076, + 0.2720610201358795 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0017105009173974395 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "single, still, high-definition macro shot, rendered in a delicate watercolor style inspired by traditional Korean aesthetics, captures a long, slender, tube-shaped millipede. Initially, the creature appears in a tight, perfect spiral, its pale, almost pearly body gracefully coiled around a gnarled, weathered branch covered in furry, damp moss. The scene is illuminated by soft, diffuse light that filters through the invisible tree canopy, casting a gentle glow on the millipede's segmented form and eliminating any harsh shadows. With a calm, fluid movement, the millipede begins to unfurl; its head deliberately lifts, and the rest of its body follows in a single, unbroken, mesmerizing wave. As it extends, its countless, slender, hair-like legs cascade in hypnotic, coordinated ripples along its length. The background, a minimalist, out-of-focus palette of pale greens and earthy browns, suggests a misty forest backdrop while keeping the focus squarely on the creature's graceful movements, creating a tranquil, contemplative atmosphere of profound natural beauty.", + "seed": 29783, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_1/index_3402_seed_29783_dp_3_rank_6_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.03380983739625663, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03380983739625663, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.4, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03380983739625663, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a delicate watercolor style inspired by traditional Korean aesthetics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a long, slender, tube-shaped millipede with a pale, pearly body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the millipede start in a tight, perfect spiral coiled around a gnarled, weathered branch covered in furry, damp moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the millipede unfurl with a calm, fluid movement where its head lifts first and the body follows in a single, unbroken wave?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a minimalist, out-of-focus palette of pale greens and earthy browns suggesting a misty forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.13188984990119934 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.131889820098877 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.13188984990119934, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.13188984990119934, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16609323024749756, + 0.09006133675575256, + 0.05172388255596161, + 0.06540580838918686, + 0.04807810112833977, + 0.040716830641031265, + 0.11247752606868744, + 0.10799174755811691, + 0.20064140856266022, + 0.11681019514799118 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.13188984990119934 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a delicate watercolor style inspired by traditional Korean aesthetics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a long, slender, tube-shaped millipede with a pale, pearly body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the millipede start in a tight, perfect spiral coiled around a gnarled, weathered branch covered in furry, damp moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the millipede unfurl with a calm, fluid movement where its head lifts first and the body follows in a single, unbroken wave?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a minimalist, out-of-focus palette of pale greens and earthy browns suggesting a misty forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016089249402284622 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.14108943939209 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016089249402284622, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016089249402284622, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11648747324943542, + 0.062249451875686646, + 0.1588646024465561, + 0.03738601878285408, + 0.1609378457069397, + 0.036985401064157486, + 0.08483409136533737, + 0.09812625497579575, + 0.12892243266105652, + 0.11520642042160034 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 2, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016089249402284622 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a delicate watercolor style inspired by traditional Korean aesthetics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a long, slender, tube-shaped millipede with a pale, pearly body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the millipede start in a tight, perfect spiral coiled around a gnarled, weathered branch covered in furry, damp moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the millipede unfurl with a calm, fluid movement where its head lifts first and the body follows in a single, unbroken wave?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a minimalist, out-of-focus palette of pale greens and earthy browns suggesting a misty forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008653995580971241 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.7586541175842285 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008653995580971241, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008653995580971241, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16225780546665192, + 0.03797096386551857, + 0.05023152381181717, + 0.11969345062971115, + 0.1760130673646927, + 0.04205668345093727, + 0.04627743735909462, + 0.11139232665300369, + 0.20658743381500244, + 0.0475192666053772 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008653995580971241 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a delicate watercolor style inspired by traditional Korean aesthetics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a long, slender, tube-shaped millipede with a pale, pearly body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the millipede start in a tight, perfect spiral coiled around a gnarled, weathered branch covered in furry, damp moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the millipede unfurl with a calm, fluid movement where its head lifts first and the body follows in a single, unbroken wave?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a minimalist, out-of-focus palette of pale greens and earthy browns suggesting a misty forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011079457588493824 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.51107931137085 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011079457588493824, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011079457588493824, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11144927144050598, + 0.033422138541936874, + 0.04636329039931297, + 0.034671638160943985, + 0.07796245068311691, + 0.033710017800331116, + 0.10229037702083588, + 0.1821109801530838, + 0.2957209646701813, + 0.0822988823056221 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011079457588493824 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a delicate watercolor style inspired by traditional Korean aesthetics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a long, slender, tube-shaped millipede with a pale, pearly body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the millipede start in a tight, perfect spiral coiled around a gnarled, weathered branch covered in furry, damp moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the millipede unfurl with a calm, fluid movement where its head lifts first and the body follows in a single, unbroken wave?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a minimalist, out-of-focus palette of pale greens and earthy browns suggesting a misty forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0013366345083341002 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.626336574554443 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0013366345083341002, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0013366345083341002, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10926838964223862, + 0.14586281776428223, + 0.08237847685813904, + 0.10057207942008972, + 0.055455416440963745, + 0.0722620040178299, + 0.07513001561164856, + 0.16078926622867584, + 0.10208731144666672, + 0.09619428217411041 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0013366345083341002 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "single, still, high-definition macro shot, rendered in a delicate watercolor style inspired by traditional Korean aesthetics, captures a long, slender, tube-shaped millipede. Initially, the creature appears in a tight, perfect spiral, its pale, almost pearly body gracefully coiled around a gnarled, weathered branch covered in furry, damp moss. The scene is illuminated by soft, diffuse light that filters through the invisible tree canopy, casting a gentle glow on the millipede's segmented form and eliminating any harsh shadows. With a calm, fluid movement, the millipede begins to unfurl; its head deliberately lifts, and the rest of its body follows in a single, unbroken, mesmerizing wave. As it extends, its countless, slender, hair-like legs cascade in hypnotic, coordinated ripples along its length. The background, a minimalist, out-of-focus palette of pale greens and earthy browns, suggests a misty forest backdrop while keeping the focus squarely on the creature's graceful movements, creating a tranquil, contemplative atmosphere of profound natural beauty.", + "seed": 29784, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_1/index_3402_seed_29784_dp_3_rank_6_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.015045571653172374, + "vlm_logprob": -0.015045571653172374, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.9, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.015045571653172374, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a delicate watercolor style inspired by traditional Korean aesthetics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a long, slender, tube-shaped millipede with a pale, pearly body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the millipede start in a tight, perfect spiral coiled around a gnarled, weathered branch covered in furry, damp moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the millipede unfurl with a calm, fluid movement where its head lifts first and the body follows in a single, unbroken wave?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a minimalist, out-of-focus palette of pale greens and earthy browns suggesting a misty forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05108017474412918 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0510802268981934 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05108017474412918, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05108017474412918, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3534621298313141, + 0.06146072596311569, + 0.028318075463175774, + 0.04735346883535385, + 0.06099427118897438, + 0.028285803273320198, + 0.05145756155252457, + 0.04050877317786217, + 0.07272949069738388, + 0.2554297149181366 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05108017474412918 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a delicate watercolor style inspired by traditional Korean aesthetics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a long, slender, tube-shaped millipede with a pale, pearly body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the millipede start in a tight, perfect spiral coiled around a gnarled, weathered branch covered in furry, damp moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the millipede unfurl with a calm, fluid movement where its head lifts first and the body follows in a single, unbroken wave?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a minimalist, out-of-focus palette of pale greens and earthy browns suggesting a misty forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011081579141318798 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511081695556641 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011081579141318798, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011081579141318798, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.242187038064003, + 0.11771191656589508, + 0.04627511650323868, + 0.03721391037106514, + 0.04568645358085632, + 0.030387649312615395, + 0.027769697830080986, + 0.05031188577413559, + 0.1775813102722168, + 0.22487503290176392 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011081579141318798 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a delicate watercolor style inspired by traditional Korean aesthetics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a long, slender, tube-shaped millipede with a pale, pearly body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the millipede start in a tight, perfect spiral coiled around a gnarled, weathered branch covered in furry, damp moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the millipede unfurl with a calm, fluid movement where its head lifts first and the body follows in a single, unbroken wave?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a minimalist, out-of-focus palette of pale greens and earthy browns suggesting a misty forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0024925374891608953 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002492427825928 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0024925374891608953, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0024925374891608953, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2712964415550232, + 0.08741547167301178, + 0.05450049042701721, + 0.10255596786737442, + 0.0456223264336586, + 0.05300530791282654, + 0.05647513270378113, + 0.055828653275966644, + 0.15294000506401062, + 0.12036024034023285 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0024925374891608953 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a delicate watercolor style inspired by traditional Korean aesthetics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a long, slender, tube-shaped millipede with a pale, pearly body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the millipede start in a tight, perfect spiral coiled around a gnarled, weathered branch covered in furry, damp moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the millipede unfurl with a calm, fluid movement where its head lifts first and the body follows in a single, unbroken wave?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a minimalist, out-of-focus palette of pale greens and earthy browns suggesting a misty forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008636386133730412 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758636474609375 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008636386133730412, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008636386133730412, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16680243611335754, + 0.06630092859268188, + 0.040940478444099426, + 0.07899311929941177, + 0.020380299538373947, + 0.0414649061858654, + 0.03420587256550789, + 0.03666533902287483, + 0.07438194006681442, + 0.4398646354675293 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008636386133730412 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a delicate watercolor style inspired by traditional Korean aesthetics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a long, slender, tube-shaped millipede with a pale, pearly body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the millipede start in a tight, perfect spiral coiled around a gnarled, weathered branch covered in furry, damp moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the millipede unfurl with a calm, fluid movement where its head lifts first and the body follows in a single, unbroken wave?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a minimalist, out-of-focus palette of pale greens and earthy browns suggesting a misty forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.001937180757522583 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.251937389373779 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.001937180757522583, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.001937180757522583, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3096989095211029, + 0.04878120869398117, + 0.04574379697442055, + 0.026725152507424355, + 0.03510240092873573, + 0.03858337551355362, + 0.08459599316120148, + 0.0522020198404789, + 0.08464750647544861, + 0.2739197015762329 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.001937180757522583 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_10/index_tensor([5034, 5034])_group_10_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_10/index_tensor([5034, 5034])_group_10_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..f3eb396c415f73fe0efc68f7b85b5b606d5e84f7 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_10/index_tensor([5034, 5034])_group_10_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up, low-angle tracking shot moves perfectly parallel to a bicycle tire, keeping it perfectly centered in the frame as it rolls endlessly forward. The camera captures the tire's rugged black rubber texture in exquisite detail, showcasing the profound geometric pattern of its knobby tread, crusted with a thin layer of dry earth. In exquisite slow motion, the tire rotates with hypnotic, steady grace. As each section of the tread presses into the dry, cracked dirt path, it deliberately kicks up plumes of fine, golden dust. Low, warm late afternoon sunlight streams in from the side, capturing the metallic gleam of the wheel spokes as they blur into a circular pattern and backlighting the dust cloud, causing each suspended particle to glitter like glowing embers against the soft, out-of-focus backdrop of dry, yellowed grass. The entire scene is suffused with warm, earthy colors, creating an atmosphere of tranquility, concentration, and almost meditative concentration centered on the simple, timeless beauty of movement.", + "seed": 20722, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_10/index_5034_seed_20722_dp_20_rank_40_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.06770642618648708, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06770642618648708, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.9, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06770642618648708, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focused on a bicycle tire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving parallel to the tire while keeping it centered in the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tire's black rubber texture and knobby tread pattern visible in detail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tire kick up plumes of fine golden dust as it rolls on the dry cracked dirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by low warm late afternoon sunlight creating a soft out-of-focus background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008863510563969612 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.25886344909668 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008863510563969612, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008863510563969612, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0938597172498703, + 0.09680856019258499, + 0.12938988208770752, + 0.04987277463078499, + 0.13327759504318237, + 0.1976146250963211, + 0.0937485471367836, + 0.05161929503083229, + 0.06673068553209305, + 0.08707831054925919 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008863510563969612 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focused on a bicycle tire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving parallel to the tire while keeping it centered in the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tire's black rubber texture and knobby tread pattern visible in detail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tire kick up plumes of fine golden dust as it rolls on the dry cracked dirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by low warm late afternoon sunlight creating a soft out-of-focus background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.25216659903526306 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5021666288375854 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.25216659903526306, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.25216659903526306, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13777713477611542, + 0.1380176544189453, + 0.07863539457321167, + 0.11843569576740265, + 0.08563050627708435, + 0.17504335939884186, + 0.1160549521446228, + 0.04479091241955757, + 0.05014573410153389, + 0.05546864494681358 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.25216659903526306 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focused on a bicycle tire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving parallel to the tire while keeping it centered in the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tire's black rubber texture and knobby tread pattern visible in detail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tire kick up plumes of fine golden dust as it rolls on the dry cracked dirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by low warm late afternoon sunlight creating a soft out-of-focus background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02058861404657364 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955886363983154 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02058861404657364, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02058861404657364, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08847060054540634, + 0.17449618875980377, + 0.05574178323149681, + 0.027015244588255882, + 0.0992203801870346, + 0.22091706097126007, + 0.058727409690618515, + 0.12246333062648773, + 0.11114183813333511, + 0.04180614650249481 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02058861404657364 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focused on a bicycle tire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving parallel to the tire while keeping it centered in the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tire's black rubber texture and knobby tread pattern visible in detail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tire kick up plumes of fine golden dust as it rolls on the dry cracked dirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by low warm late afternoon sunlight creating a soft out-of-focus background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05497325211763382 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299733638763428 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05497325211763382, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05497325211763382, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1345980316400528, + 0.2119649052619934, + 0.06721024960279465, + 0.04316583275794983, + 0.06437911838293076, + 0.05276704207062721, + 0.14172227680683136, + 0.039328061044216156, + 0.20635466277599335, + 0.03850986063480377 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05497325211763382 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focused on a bicycle tire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving parallel to the tire while keeping it centered in the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tire's black rubber texture and knobby tread pattern visible in detail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tire kick up plumes of fine golden dust as it rolls on the dry cracked dirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by low warm late afternoon sunlight creating a soft out-of-focus background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0019401551689952612 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.2519402503967285 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0019401551689952612, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0019401551689952612, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07746238261461258, + 0.12068011611700058, + 0.08482681214809418, + 0.04611066356301308, + 0.12789569795131683, + 0.17518199980258942, + 0.04192778468132019, + 0.1103392094373703, + 0.1611388474702835, + 0.05443645641207695 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0019401551689952612 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up, low-angle tracking shot moves perfectly parallel to a bicycle tire, keeping it perfectly centered in the frame as it rolls endlessly forward. The camera captures the tire's rugged black rubber texture in exquisite detail, showcasing the profound geometric pattern of its knobby tread, crusted with a thin layer of dry earth. In exquisite slow motion, the tire rotates with hypnotic, steady grace. As each section of the tread presses into the dry, cracked dirt path, it deliberately kicks up plumes of fine, golden dust. Low, warm late afternoon sunlight streams in from the side, capturing the metallic gleam of the wheel spokes as they blur into a circular pattern and backlighting the dust cloud, causing each suspended particle to glitter like glowing embers against the soft, out-of-focus backdrop of dry, yellowed grass. The entire scene is suffused with warm, earthy colors, creating an atmosphere of tranquility, concentration, and almost meditative concentration centered on the simple, timeless beauty of movement.", + "seed": 20723, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_10/index_5034_seed_20723_dp_20_rank_40_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.2990190632641315, + "vlm_logprob": -0.2990190632641315, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.95, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.2990190632641315, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focused on a bicycle tire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving parallel to the tire while keeping it centered in the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tire's black rubber texture and knobby tread pattern visible in detail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tire kick up plumes of fine golden dust as it rolls on the dry cracked dirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by low warm late afternoon sunlight creating a soft out-of-focus background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009571612812578678 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.884571552276611 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009571612812578678, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009571612812578678, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07349082827568054, + 0.30069273710250854, + 0.10854636132717133, + 0.06903170794248581, + 0.10712559521198273, + 0.059419672936201096, + 0.09523773193359375, + 0.08311992138624191, + 0.04755989834666252, + 0.055775586515665054 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009571612812578678 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focused on a bicycle tire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving parallel to the tire while keeping it centered in the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tire's black rubber texture and knobby tread pattern visible in detail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tire kick up plumes of fine golden dust as it rolls on the dry cracked dirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by low warm late afternoon sunlight creating a soft out-of-focus background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.053963541984558 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4289635419845581 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.053963541984558, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.625, + "token_credit_reward": -1.053963541984558, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08006135374307632, + 0.08782785385847092, + 0.13303136825561523, + 0.08229172229766846, + 0.03653724491596222, + 0.07226073741912842, + 0.04163198173046112, + 0.07259492576122284, + 0.17175647616386414, + 0.2220064103603363 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.053963541984558 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focused on a bicycle tire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving parallel to the tire while keeping it centered in the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tire's black rubber texture and knobby tread pattern visible in detail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tire kick up plumes of fine golden dust as it rolls on the dry cracked dirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by low warm late afternoon sunlight creating a soft out-of-focus background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04307881370186806 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168078899383545 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04307881370186806, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04307881370186806, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11837581545114517, + 0.3290821611881256, + 0.09470190107822418, + 0.09388980269432068, + 0.11514931172132492, + 0.07986633479595184, + 0.02030685730278492, + 0.054052259773015976, + 0.06874854862689972, + 0.025826994329690933 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04307881370186806 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focused on a bicycle tire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving parallel to the tire while keeping it centered in the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tire's black rubber texture and knobby tread pattern visible in detail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tire kick up plumes of fine golden dust as it rolls on the dry cracked dirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by low warm late afternoon sunlight creating a soft out-of-focus background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3871437609195709 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1371437311172485 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3871437609195709, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3871437609195709, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06035524979233742, + 0.11430007219314575, + 0.062981978058815, + 0.10739950090646744, + 0.2187042236328125, + 0.09771871566772461, + 0.04241526499390602, + 0.07521254569292068, + 0.06936182826757431, + 0.1515505164861679 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3871437609195709 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focused on a bicycle tire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving parallel to the tire while keeping it centered in the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tire's black rubber texture and knobby tread pattern visible in detail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tire kick up plumes of fine golden dust as it rolls on the dry cracked dirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by low warm late afternoon sunlight creating a soft out-of-focus background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0013375869020819664 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.62633752822876 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0013375869020819664, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0013375869020819664, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05429013445973396, + 0.06070106849074364, + 0.04990816488862038, + 0.048676759004592896, + 0.09624771028757095, + 0.20390111207962036, + 0.18842215836048126, + 0.08347243815660477, + 0.02699362300336361, + 0.1873868703842163 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0013375869020819664 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up, low-angle tracking shot moves perfectly parallel to a bicycle tire, keeping it perfectly centered in the frame as it rolls endlessly forward. The camera captures the tire's rugged black rubber texture in exquisite detail, showcasing the profound geometric pattern of its knobby tread, crusted with a thin layer of dry earth. In exquisite slow motion, the tire rotates with hypnotic, steady grace. As each section of the tread presses into the dry, cracked dirt path, it deliberately kicks up plumes of fine, golden dust. Low, warm late afternoon sunlight streams in from the side, capturing the metallic gleam of the wheel spokes as they blur into a circular pattern and backlighting the dust cloud, causing each suspended particle to glitter like glowing embers against the soft, out-of-focus backdrop of dry, yellowed grass. The entire scene is suffused with warm, earthy colors, creating an atmosphere of tranquility, concentration, and almost meditative concentration centered on the simple, timeless beauty of movement.", + "seed": 20724, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_10/index_5034_seed_20724_dp_21_rank_42_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.12146156576927751, + "vlm_logprob": -0.12146156576927751, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.925, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.12146156576927751, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focused on a bicycle tire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving parallel to the tire while keeping it centered in the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tire's black rubber texture and knobby tread pattern visible in detail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tire kick up plumes of fine golden dust as it rolls on the dry cracked dirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by low warm late afternoon sunlight creating a soft out-of-focus background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005675274413079023 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.755675315856934 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005675274413079023, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005675274413079023, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.054307129234075546, + 0.1993873417377472, + 0.026871610432863235, + 0.026498129591345787, + 0.02384394407272339, + 0.014302845112979412, + 0.5985965132713318, + 0.013195250183343887, + 0.03343629464507103, + 0.009560974314808846 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005675274413079023 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focused on a bicycle tire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving parallel to the tire while keeping it centered in the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tire's black rubber texture and knobby tread pattern visible in detail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tire kick up plumes of fine golden dust as it rolls on the dry cracked dirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by low warm late afternoon sunlight creating a soft out-of-focus background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2813909947872162 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4063910245895386 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2813909947872162, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2813909947872162, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0736626386642456, + 0.4546613395214081, + 0.04056234285235405, + 0.0829128548502922, + 0.0200970321893692, + 0.014932378195226192, + 0.24746783077716827, + 0.02417314425110817, + 0.027146490290760994, + 0.014383923262357712 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 6, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2813909947872162 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focused on a bicycle tire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving parallel to the tire while keeping it centered in the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tire's black rubber texture and knobby tread pattern visible in detail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tire kick up plumes of fine golden dust as it rolls on the dry cracked dirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by low warm late afternoon sunlight creating a soft out-of-focus background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0015169790713116527 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.501516819000244 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0015169790713116527, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0015169790713116527, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04775796830654144, + 0.1068483516573906, + 0.048568837344646454, + 0.021711274981498718, + 0.046191733330488205, + 0.01798781380057335, + 0.6644221544265747, + 0.020191838964819908, + 0.00859888643026352, + 0.017721129581332207 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0015169790713116527 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focused on a bicycle tire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving parallel to the tire while keeping it centered in the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tire's black rubber texture and knobby tread pattern visible in detail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tire kick up plumes of fine golden dust as it rolls on the dry cracked dirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by low warm late afternoon sunlight creating a soft out-of-focus background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3134717345237732 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.313471794128418 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3134717345237732, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3134717345237732, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.021005135029554367, + 0.06518163532018661, + 0.01653490588068962, + 0.010990851558744907, + 0.015497277490794659, + 0.008683538064360619, + 0.8221448063850403, + 0.018215268850326538, + 0.007415276952087879, + 0.014331222511827946 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3134717345237732 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focused on a bicycle tire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving parallel to the tire while keeping it centered in the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tire's black rubber texture and knobby tread pattern visible in detail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tire kick up plumes of fine golden dust as it rolls on the dry cracked dirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by low warm late afternoon sunlight creating a soft out-of-focus background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005252846051007509 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255252838134766 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005252846051007509, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005252846051007509, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.02006537653505802, + 0.12086599320173264, + 0.006206912454217672, + 0.010771234519779682, + 0.009614097885787487, + 0.005400972440838814, + 0.805243194103241, + 0.005650878883898258, + 0.010954787954688072, + 0.005226552952080965 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005252846051007509 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up, low-angle tracking shot moves perfectly parallel to a bicycle tire, keeping it perfectly centered in the frame as it rolls endlessly forward. The camera captures the tire's rugged black rubber texture in exquisite detail, showcasing the profound geometric pattern of its knobby tread, crusted with a thin layer of dry earth. In exquisite slow motion, the tire rotates with hypnotic, steady grace. As each section of the tread presses into the dry, cracked dirt path, it deliberately kicks up plumes of fine, golden dust. Low, warm late afternoon sunlight streams in from the side, capturing the metallic gleam of the wheel spokes as they blur into a circular pattern and backlighting the dust cloud, causing each suspended particle to glitter like glowing embers against the soft, out-of-focus backdrop of dry, yellowed grass. The entire scene is suffused with warm, earthy colors, creating an atmosphere of tranquility, concentration, and almost meditative concentration centered on the simple, timeless beauty of movement.", + "seed": 20725, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_10/index_5034_seed_20725_dp_21_rank_42_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.08344731712713838, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08344731712713838, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.525, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08344731712713838, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focused on a bicycle tire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving parallel to the tire while keeping it centered in the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tire's black rubber texture and knobby tread pattern visible in detail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tire kick up plumes of fine golden dust as it rolls on the dry cracked dirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by low warm late afternoon sunlight creating a soft out-of-focus background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00495171407237649 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.629951477050781 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00495171407237649, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00495171407237649, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10064347833395004, + 0.07251156866550446, + 0.2851709723472595, + 0.0742977038025856, + 0.06091831251978874, + 0.10906960815191269, + 0.09220704436302185, + 0.059072740375995636, + 0.033411916345357895, + 0.11269660294055939 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00495171407237649 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focused on a bicycle tire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving parallel to the tire while keeping it centered in the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tire's black rubber texture and knobby tread pattern visible in detail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tire kick up plumes of fine golden dust as it rolls on the dry cracked dirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by low warm late afternoon sunlight creating a soft out-of-focus background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.252164363861084 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.502164363861084 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.252164363861084, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.252164363861084, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12495866417884827, + 0.1196681410074234, + 0.15564925968647003, + 0.05762338638305664, + 0.08414170891046524, + 0.27612826228141785, + 0.044016942381858826, + 0.03465588390827179, + 0.04696840047836304, + 0.05618929862976074 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.252164363861084 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focused on a bicycle tire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving parallel to the tire while keeping it centered in the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tire's black rubber texture and knobby tread pattern visible in detail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tire kick up plumes of fine golden dust as it rolls on the dry cracked dirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by low warm late afternoon sunlight creating a soft out-of-focus background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04306260123848915 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168062686920166 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04306260123848915, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04306260123848915, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10008945316076279, + 0.13846684992313385, + 0.36970892548561096, + 0.04308347776532173, + 0.034995391964912415, + 0.13021491467952728, + 0.059065788984298706, + 0.057137519121170044, + 0.0260374303907156, + 0.041200216859579086 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04306260123848915 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focused on a bicycle tire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving parallel to the tire while keeping it centered in the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tire's black rubber texture and knobby tread pattern visible in detail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tire kick up plumes of fine golden dust as it rolls on the dry cracked dirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by low warm late afternoon sunlight creating a soft out-of-focus background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11296311765909195 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2379631996154785 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11296311765909195, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11296311765909195, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07330852001905441, + 0.2630889415740967, + 0.027676381170749664, + 0.05732128024101257, + 0.034472644329071045, + 0.24676506221294403, + 0.017524177208542824, + 0.018623467534780502, + 0.022235779091715813, + 0.23898380994796753 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11296311765909195 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focused on a bicycle tire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving parallel to the tire while keeping it centered in the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tire's black rubber texture and knobby tread pattern visible in detail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tire kick up plumes of fine golden dust as it rolls on the dry cracked dirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by low warm late afternoon sunlight creating a soft out-of-focus background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004094788804650307 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.50409460067749 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004094788804650307, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004094788804650307, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03442621976137161, + 0.06134379655122757, + 0.07689777761697769, + 0.029725002124905586, + 0.1503792256116867, + 0.19890151917934418, + 0.05433553829789162, + 0.3160240948200226, + 0.01985827460885048, + 0.058108553290367126 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004094788804650307 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_11/index_tensor([3987, 3987])_group_11_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_11/index_tensor([3987, 3987])_group_11_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..8667f941d427eaa5e515ebef4dd9f3a57e7206da --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_11/index_tensor([3987, 3987])_group_11_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "low-angle close-up of the water, captured in a grainy, vintage-style style with soft vignettes, captures a dramatic moment. A llama, with fluffy, creamy-white fur, its long neck gracefully curved, dips its soft muzzle into the crystal-clear stream to drink. The surface is as calm as a mirror. Suddenly, as if startled, it jerks its head from the water. This sudden, almost braking motion shatters the stillness, sending a spectacular and graceful curtain of water cascading from the surface. In extreme slow motion, countless crystalline droplets are flung into the air, seemingly frozen in time. Each drop is clearly visible, suspended, swirling, and transforming into a shimmering crown surrounding the llama's head. Slanting golden afternoon sunlight filters through the tiny droplets, refracting a warm amber glow and softly outlining the llama's dark eyes, slightly widened in surprise, and its ears, pricked with alertness. The main tones of the entire picture are nostalgic and warm. The slightly less saturated gold and cream white are intertwined with the emerald green of the moss on the shore, creating a timeless beauty that is both thrilling and poetic, as if frozen on old film.", + "seed": 227, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_11/index_3987_seed_227_dp_22_rank_44_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.055981103982776406, + "vlm_logprob": -0.055981103982776406, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.6, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.055981103982776406, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle close-up of a llama drinking from a stream?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the llama have fluffy creamy-white fur and a long neck gracefully curved?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the llama jerking its head suddenly to shatter the still water surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in extreme slow motion with visible crystalline water droplets forming a crown around the llama's head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style grainy and vintage with soft vignettes, featuring slanting golden sunlight and emerald green moss on the shore?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0551706925034523 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.055170774459839 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0551706925034523, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0551706925034523, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2829214930534363, + 0.203706294298172, + 0.04746437445282936, + 0.10231669247150421, + 0.10414713621139526, + 0.0361618809401989, + 0.07031507045030594, + 0.0781567394733429, + 0.035636141896247864, + 0.03917424753308296 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0551706925034523 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle close-up of a llama drinking from a stream?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the llama have fluffy creamy-white fur and a long neck gracefully curved?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the llama jerking its head suddenly to shatter the still water surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in extreme slow motion with visible crystalline water droplets forming a crown around the llama's head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style grainy and vintage with soft vignettes, featuring slanting golden sunlight and emerald green moss on the shore?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00979935098439455 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634799480438232 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00979935098439455, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00979935098439455, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.28427425026893616, + 0.148197740316391, + 0.12225937843322754, + 0.048807866871356964, + 0.06816451251506805, + 0.03848739340901375, + 0.09348317980766296, + 0.09504590928554535, + 0.03563730791211128, + 0.06564247608184814 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00979935098439455 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle close-up of a llama drinking from a stream?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the llama have fluffy creamy-white fur and a long neck gracefully curved?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the llama jerking its head suddenly to shatter the still water surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in extreme slow motion with visible crystalline water droplets forming a crown around the llama's head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style grainy and vintage with soft vignettes, featuring slanting golden sunlight and emerald green moss on the shore?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17988039553165436 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8048803806304932 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17988039553165436, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17988039553165436, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03169160708785057, + 0.015982098877429962, + 0.02452913671731949, + 0.08261566609144211, + 0.0466163195669651, + 0.05304887518286705, + 0.6778876185417175, + 0.0115133635699749, + 0.037763938307762146, + 0.018351320177316666 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17988039553165436 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle close-up of a llama drinking from a stream?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the llama have fluffy creamy-white fur and a long neck gracefully curved?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the llama jerking its head suddenly to shatter the still water surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in extreme slow motion with visible crystalline water droplets forming a crown around the llama's head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style grainy and vintage with soft vignettes, featuring slanting golden sunlight and emerald green moss on the shore?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0052567594684660435 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255256652832031 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0052567594684660435, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0052567594684660435, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17270204424858093, + 0.05887864530086517, + 0.0474383682012558, + 0.08109674602746964, + 0.0399036668241024, + 0.023107731714844704, + 0.3977424204349518, + 0.03426129370927811, + 0.022292861714959145, + 0.1225762739777565 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0052567594684660435 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle close-up of a llama drinking from a stream?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the llama have fluffy creamy-white fur and a long neck gracefully curved?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the llama jerking its head suddenly to shatter the still water surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in extreme slow motion with visible crystalline water droplets forming a crown around the llama's head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style grainy and vintage with soft vignettes, featuring slanting golden sunlight and emerald green moss on the shore?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029798321425914764 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5297982692718506 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029798321425914764, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029798321425914764, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15671472251415253, + 0.07077745348215103, + 0.1064358726143837, + 0.06325060874223709, + 0.057952288538217545, + 0.03413478285074234, + 0.2903452515602112, + 0.04714929312467575, + 0.07531829923391342, + 0.09792142361402512 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029798321425914764 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle close-up of the water, captured in a grainy, vintage-style style with soft vignettes, captures a dramatic moment. A llama, with fluffy, creamy-white fur, its long neck gracefully curved, dips its soft muzzle into the crystal-clear stream to drink. The surface is as calm as a mirror. Suddenly, as if startled, it jerks its head from the water. This sudden, almost braking motion shatters the stillness, sending a spectacular and graceful curtain of water cascading from the surface. In extreme slow motion, countless crystalline droplets are flung into the air, seemingly frozen in time. Each drop is clearly visible, suspended, swirling, and transforming into a shimmering crown surrounding the llama's head. Slanting golden afternoon sunlight filters through the tiny droplets, refracting a warm amber glow and softly outlining the llama's dark eyes, slightly widened in surprise, and its ears, pricked with alertness. The main tones of the entire picture are nostalgic and warm. The slightly less saturated gold and cream white are intertwined with the emerald green of the moss on the shore, creating a timeless beauty that is both thrilling and poetic, as if frozen on old film.", + "seed": 228, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_11/index_3987_seed_228_dp_22_rank_44_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.16079302430152892, + "vlm_logprob": -0.16079302430152892, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.025, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.16079302430152892, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle close-up of a llama drinking from a stream?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the llama have fluffy creamy-white fur and a long neck gracefully curved?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the llama jerking its head suddenly to shatter the still water surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in extreme slow motion with visible crystalline water droplets forming a crown around the llama's head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style grainy and vintage with soft vignettes, featuring slanting golden sunlight and emerald green moss on the shore?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.041662171483039856 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2916622161865234 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.041662171483039856, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.041662171483039856, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17954900860786438, + 0.1987488865852356, + 0.1292509138584137, + 0.04511857405304909, + 0.056137874722480774, + 0.11616984009742737, + 0.07286672294139862, + 0.018495742231607437, + 0.056246478110551834, + 0.1274159699678421 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.041662171483039856 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle close-up of a llama drinking from a stream?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the llama have fluffy creamy-white fur and a long neck gracefully curved?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the llama jerking its head suddenly to shatter the still water surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in extreme slow motion with visible crystalline water droplets forming a crown around the llama's head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style grainy and vintage with soft vignettes, featuring slanting golden sunlight and emerald green moss on the shore?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009803010150790215 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.63480281829834 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009803010150790215, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009803010150790215, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13143490254878998, + 0.14952696859836578, + 0.26329565048217773, + 0.11254630982875824, + 0.0414394736289978, + 0.036359015852212906, + 0.08883992582559586, + 0.055514104664325714, + 0.036011647433042526, + 0.08503197878599167 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009803010150790215 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle close-up of a llama drinking from a stream?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the llama have fluffy creamy-white fur and a long neck gracefully curved?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the llama jerking its head suddenly to shatter the still water surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in extreme slow motion with visible crystalline water droplets forming a crown around the llama's head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style grainy and vintage with soft vignettes, featuring slanting golden sunlight and emerald green moss on the shore?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6933482885360718 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6933482885360718 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.6933482885360718, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.6933482885360718, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10799768567085266, + 0.03547960892319679, + 0.4765903651714325, + 0.14003701508045197, + 0.06484010070562363, + 0.04327504709362984, + 0.02509150467813015, + 0.04086630791425705, + 0.04352201521396637, + 0.0223003588616848 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.6933482885360718 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle close-up of a llama drinking from a stream?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the llama have fluffy creamy-white fur and a long neck gracefully curved?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the llama jerking its head suddenly to shatter the still water surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in extreme slow motion with visible crystalline water droplets forming a crown around the llama's head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style grainy and vintage with soft vignettes, featuring slanting golden sunlight and emerald green moss on the shore?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016081741079688072 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141081809997559 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016081741079688072, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016081741079688072, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1325579136610031, + 0.08219418674707413, + 0.24839459359645844, + 0.23825761675834656, + 0.08372173458337784, + 0.05000893399119377, + 0.0646282508969307, + 0.03041202388703823, + 0.023700810968875885, + 0.04612388834357262 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016081741079688072 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle close-up of a llama drinking from a stream?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the llama have fluffy creamy-white fur and a long neck gracefully curved?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the llama jerking its head suddenly to shatter the still water surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in extreme slow motion with visible crystalline water droplets forming a crown around the llama's head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style grainy and vintage with soft vignettes, featuring slanting golden sunlight and emerald green moss on the shore?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04306991025805473 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168069839477539 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04306991025805473, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04306991025805473, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1792319267988205, + 0.07161639630794525, + 0.09034696966409683, + 0.1068141758441925, + 0.12612098455429077, + 0.06411023437976837, + 0.07754973322153091, + 0.1368759721517563, + 0.030423352494835854, + 0.1169101819396019 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04306991025805473 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle close-up of the water, captured in a grainy, vintage-style style with soft vignettes, captures a dramatic moment. A llama, with fluffy, creamy-white fur, its long neck gracefully curved, dips its soft muzzle into the crystal-clear stream to drink. The surface is as calm as a mirror. Suddenly, as if startled, it jerks its head from the water. This sudden, almost braking motion shatters the stillness, sending a spectacular and graceful curtain of water cascading from the surface. In extreme slow motion, countless crystalline droplets are flung into the air, seemingly frozen in time. Each drop is clearly visible, suspended, swirling, and transforming into a shimmering crown surrounding the llama's head. Slanting golden afternoon sunlight filters through the tiny droplets, refracting a warm amber glow and softly outlining the llama's dark eyes, slightly widened in surprise, and its ears, pricked with alertness. The main tones of the entire picture are nostalgic and warm. The slightly less saturated gold and cream white are intertwined with the emerald green of the moss on the shore, creating a timeless beauty that is both thrilling and poetic, as if frozen on old film.", + "seed": 229, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_11/index_3987_seed_229_dp_23_rank_46_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.030377149954438208, + "vlm_logprob": -0.030377149954438208, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.95, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.030377149954438208, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle close-up of a llama drinking from a stream?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the llama have fluffy creamy-white fur and a long neck gracefully curved?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the llama jerking its head suddenly to shatter the still water surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in extreme slow motion with visible crystalline water droplets forming a crown around the llama's head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style grainy and vintage with soft vignettes, featuring slanting golden sunlight and emerald green moss on the shore?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.051752787083387375 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.051752805709839 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.051752787083387375, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.051752787083387375, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07009189575910568, + 0.5723684430122375, + 0.033248092979192734, + 0.04789190739393234, + 0.0209076926112175, + 0.04167220741510391, + 0.10982346534729004, + 0.03116399422287941, + 0.022409414872527122, + 0.05042291805148125 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.051752787083387375 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle close-up of a llama drinking from a stream?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the llama have fluffy creamy-white fur and a long neck gracefully curved?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the llama jerking its head suddenly to shatter the still water surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in extreme slow motion with visible crystalline water droplets forming a crown around the llama's head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style grainy and vintage with soft vignettes, featuring slanting golden sunlight and emerald green moss on the shore?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0076462216675281525 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882646083831787 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0076462216675281525, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0076462216675281525, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09773482382297516, + 0.19905152916908264, + 0.0337771438062191, + 0.11238346248865128, + 0.152632474899292, + 0.05279507860541344, + 0.035349976271390915, + 0.03314720839262009, + 0.07620460540056229, + 0.2069236934185028 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0076462216675281525 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle close-up of a llama drinking from a stream?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the llama have fluffy creamy-white fur and a long neck gracefully curved?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the llama jerking its head suddenly to shatter the still water surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in extreme slow motion with visible crystalline water droplets forming a crown around the llama's head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style grainy and vintage with soft vignettes, featuring slanting golden sunlight and emerald green moss on the shore?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06204301863908768 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120429515838623 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06204301863908768, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06204301863908768, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10671298950910568, + 0.09382800757884979, + 0.08367210626602173, + 0.26816844940185547, + 0.0457560271024704, + 0.06897343695163727, + 0.21512393653392792, + 0.0702597126364708, + 0.027667701244354248, + 0.01983766257762909 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06204301863908768 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle close-up of a llama drinking from a stream?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the llama have fluffy creamy-white fur and a long neck gracefully curved?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the llama jerking its head suddenly to shatter the still water surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in extreme slow motion with visible crystalline water droplets forming a crown around the llama's head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style grainy and vintage with soft vignettes, featuring slanting golden sunlight and emerald green moss on the shore?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004097875207662582 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504097938537598 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004097875207662582, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004097875207662582, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05888073518872261, + 0.3304000794887543, + 0.03571336343884468, + 0.057728394865989685, + 0.02759491838514805, + 0.02561882883310318, + 0.22927606105804443, + 0.055969905108213425, + 0.05293449014425278, + 0.12588320672512054 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004097875207662582 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle close-up of a llama drinking from a stream?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the llama have fluffy creamy-white fur and a long neck gracefully curved?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the llama jerking its head suddenly to shatter the still water surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in extreme slow motion with visible crystalline water droplets forming a crown around the llama's head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style grainy and vintage with soft vignettes, featuring slanting golden sunlight and emerald green moss on the shore?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02634584717452526 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651345729827881 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02634584717452526, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02634584717452526, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06614883989095688, + 0.5908582210540771, + 0.02789071947336197, + 0.06139689311385155, + 0.037786245346069336, + 0.02742609940469265, + 0.04430288076400757, + 0.031406063586473465, + 0.06277001649141312, + 0.05001404508948326 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02634584717452526 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle close-up of the water, captured in a grainy, vintage-style style with soft vignettes, captures a dramatic moment. A llama, with fluffy, creamy-white fur, its long neck gracefully curved, dips its soft muzzle into the crystal-clear stream to drink. The surface is as calm as a mirror. Suddenly, as if startled, it jerks its head from the water. This sudden, almost braking motion shatters the stillness, sending a spectacular and graceful curtain of water cascading from the surface. In extreme slow motion, countless crystalline droplets are flung into the air, seemingly frozen in time. Each drop is clearly visible, suspended, swirling, and transforming into a shimmering crown surrounding the llama's head. Slanting golden afternoon sunlight filters through the tiny droplets, refracting a warm amber glow and softly outlining the llama's dark eyes, slightly widened in surprise, and its ears, pricked with alertness. The main tones of the entire picture are nostalgic and warm. The slightly less saturated gold and cream white are intertwined with the emerald green of the moss on the shore, creating a timeless beauty that is both thrilling and poetic, as if frozen on old film.", + "seed": 230, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_11/index_3987_seed_230_dp_23_rank_46_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.19233293868601323, + "vlm_logprob": -0.19233293868601323, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.425, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.19233293868601323, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle close-up of a llama drinking from a stream?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the llama have fluffy creamy-white fur and a long neck gracefully curved?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the llama jerking its head suddenly to shatter the still water surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in extreme slow motion with visible crystalline water droplets forming a crown around the llama's head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style grainy and vintage with soft vignettes, featuring slanting golden sunlight and emerald green moss on the shore?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03337117284536362 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5333712100982666 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03337117284536362, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03337117284536362, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4083351492881775, + 0.22977657616138458, + 0.03197801113128662, + 0.06665407121181488, + 0.0804772898554802, + 0.025428151711821556, + 0.028393758460879326, + 0.027859199792146683, + 0.06369270384311676, + 0.03740515187382698 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03337117284536362 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle close-up of a llama drinking from a stream?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the llama have fluffy creamy-white fur and a long neck gracefully curved?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the llama jerking its head suddenly to shatter the still water surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in extreme slow motion with visible crystalline water droplets forming a crown around the llama's head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style grainy and vintage with soft vignettes, featuring slanting golden sunlight and emerald green moss on the shore?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009798997081816196 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634799003601074 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009798997081816196, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009798997081816196, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5817878842353821, + 0.17749422788619995, + 0.018393132835626602, + 0.04358517751097679, + 0.04009108245372772, + 0.03275701403617859, + 0.016669966280460358, + 0.019888393580913544, + 0.030214695259928703, + 0.03911839798092842 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009798997081816196 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle close-up of a llama drinking from a stream?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the llama have fluffy creamy-white fur and a long neck gracefully curved?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the llama jerking its head suddenly to shatter the still water surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in extreme slow motion with visible crystalline water droplets forming a crown around the llama's head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style grainy and vintage with soft vignettes, featuring slanting golden sunlight and emerald green moss on the shore?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8983416557312012 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5233416557312012 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.8983416557312012, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.8983416557312012, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.6773294806480408, + 0.09184325486421585, + 0.0745210275053978, + 0.03542276844382286, + 0.026696888729929924, + 0.023251140490174294, + 0.012480279430747032, + 0.008245626464486122, + 0.023260295391082764, + 0.026949221268296242 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.8983416557312012 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle close-up of a llama drinking from a stream?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the llama have fluffy creamy-white fur and a long neck gracefully curved?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the llama jerking its head suddenly to shatter the still water surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in extreme slow motion with visible crystalline water droplets forming a crown around the llama's head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style grainy and vintage with soft vignettes, featuring slanting golden sunlight and emerald green moss on the shore?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0059555694460868835 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130955696105957 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0059555694460868835, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0059555694460868835, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.716478705406189, + 0.06067492067813873, + 0.05021762102842331, + 0.05104218050837517, + 0.02620704099535942, + 0.018593981862068176, + 0.010360457934439182, + 0.01970740221440792, + 0.02611396089196205, + 0.020603762939572334 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0059555694460868835 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle close-up of a llama drinking from a stream?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the llama have fluffy creamy-white fur and a long neck gracefully curved?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the llama jerking its head suddenly to shatter the still water surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in extreme slow motion with visible crystalline water droplets forming a crown around the llama's head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style grainy and vintage with soft vignettes, featuring slanting golden sunlight and emerald green moss on the shore?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01419729832559824 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.26419734954834 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01419729832559824, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01419729832559824, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.48029693961143494, + 0.08923348784446716, + 0.05927553400397301, + 0.0901254341006279, + 0.10308961570262909, + 0.030504776164889336, + 0.023909656330943108, + 0.0325743667781353, + 0.06212998554110527, + 0.028860239312052727 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01419729832559824 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_12/index_tensor([8642, 8642])_group_12_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_12/index_tensor([8642, 8642])_group_12_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..305c5a4679f7cbf75eddbb59dcdae7f1f7fd4862 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_12/index_tensor([8642, 8642])_group_12_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "striking drone shot, swooping down from high above at breakneck speed, glides close to the cool, metallic-gray hull of a sleek frigate. The warship pitches violently on a turbulent sea shrouded by thick, dark clouds, repeatedly tossed high and slammed down by mountains of dark green waves. In a violent roll, the ship's sides are nearly engulfed by the roiling white foam, only to be lifted by another immense force. Its razor-sharp bow pierces the waves, sending torrents of water cascading across a deck crisscrossed with intricate piping and close-in weapon systems. The high-speed camera, combined with the violent swaying of the ship, creates a dynamic blur of splashing water and pouring rain across the frame, while the mottled marks of weather and erosion on the hull stand out vividly in the cold, bleak light. The entire picture presents a cold blue-gray tone, full of a sense of epic confrontation between human creations and furious nature, creating a suffocating tension and thrilling speed aesthetics.", + "seed": 1997, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_12/index_8642_seed_1997_dp_24_rank_48_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.14644763264805077, + "vlm_logprob": -0.14644763264805077, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.1, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.14644763264805077, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek frigate warship with a metallic-gray hull?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the ship on a turbulent sea with dark green waves and thick dark clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the ship exhibit violent motion, including pitching, rolling, and being engulfed by white foam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the ship's deck visible with intricate piping and close-in weapon systems?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a high-speed swooping motion from above while creating a dynamic blur of water and rain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5777878165245056 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8277878165245056 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5777878165245056, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5777878165245056, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06006477773189545, + 0.015867752954363823, + 0.09029185771942139, + 0.059824053198099136, + 0.02574988268315792, + 0.014806374907493591, + 0.023166712373495102, + 0.33955177664756775, + 0.1326616257429123, + 0.23801517486572266 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5777878165245056 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek frigate warship with a metallic-gray hull?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the ship on a turbulent sea with dark green waves and thick dark clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the ship exhibit violent motion, including pitching, rolling, and being engulfed by white foam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the ship's deck visible with intricate piping and close-in weapon systems?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a high-speed swooping motion from above while creating a dynamic blur of water and rain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1129455491900444 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.237945556640625 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1129455491900444, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1129455491900444, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1173543632030487, + 0.11247129738330841, + 0.1108480766415596, + 0.15986976027488708, + 0.043554436415433884, + 0.1093558520078659, + 0.10428428649902344, + 0.08695551007986069, + 0.04227805882692337, + 0.11302836239337921 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1129455491900444 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek frigate warship with a metallic-gray hull?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the ship on a turbulent sea with dark green waves and thick dark clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the ship exhibit violent motion, including pitching, rolling, and being engulfed by white foam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the ship's deck visible with intricate piping and close-in weapon systems?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a high-speed swooping motion from above while creating a dynamic blur of water and rain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006735478527843952 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006735324859619 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006735478527843952, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006735478527843952, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08902662247419357, + 0.05927988514304161, + 0.1365833729505539, + 0.40243223309516907, + 0.033523015677928925, + 0.036270447075366974, + 0.025586942210793495, + 0.044035542756319046, + 0.06351199746131897, + 0.10974989086389542 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006735478527843952 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek frigate warship with a metallic-gray hull?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the ship on a turbulent sea with dark green waves and thick dark clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the ship exhibit violent motion, including pitching, rolling, and being engulfed by white foam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the ship's deck visible with intricate piping and close-in weapon systems?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a high-speed swooping motion from above while creating a dynamic blur of water and rain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014195887371897697 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264195919036865 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014195887371897697, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014195887371897697, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06506543606519699, + 0.025121048092842102, + 0.06810472905635834, + 0.1066938266158104, + 0.02275105193257332, + 0.08809502422809601, + 0.0697350800037384, + 0.26519086956977844, + 0.055032964795827866, + 0.23420999944210052 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014195887371897697 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek frigate warship with a metallic-gray hull?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the ship on a turbulent sea with dark green waves and thick dark clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the ship exhibit violent motion, including pitching, rolling, and being engulfed by white foam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the ship's deck visible with intricate piping and close-in weapon systems?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a high-speed swooping motion from above while creating a dynamic blur of water and rain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020573431625962257 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895573377609253 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020573431625962257, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020573431625962257, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13990868628025055, + 0.031042873859405518, + 0.1297764778137207, + 0.15257082879543304, + 0.09036030620336533, + 0.22011105716228485, + 0.02093249000608921, + 0.13315722346305847, + 0.03280375152826309, + 0.04933629557490349 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020573431625962257 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "striking drone shot, swooping down from high above at breakneck speed, glides close to the cool, metallic-gray hull of a sleek frigate. The warship pitches violently on a turbulent sea shrouded by thick, dark clouds, repeatedly tossed high and slammed down by mountains of dark green waves. In a violent roll, the ship's sides are nearly engulfed by the roiling white foam, only to be lifted by another immense force. Its razor-sharp bow pierces the waves, sending torrents of water cascading across a deck crisscrossed with intricate piping and close-in weapon systems. The high-speed camera, combined with the violent swaying of the ship, creates a dynamic blur of splashing water and pouring rain across the frame, while the mottled marks of weather and erosion on the hull stand out vividly in the cold, bleak light. The entire picture presents a cold blue-gray tone, full of a sense of epic confrontation between human creations and furious nature, creating a suffocating tension and thrilling speed aesthetics.", + "seed": 1998, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_12/index_8642_seed_1998_dp_24_rank_48_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.03756565805524588, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03756565805524588, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.199999976158142, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03756565805524588, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek frigate warship with a metallic-gray hull?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the ship on a turbulent sea with dark green waves and thick dark clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the ship exhibit violent motion, including pitching, rolling, and being engulfed by white foam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the ship's deck visible with intricate piping and close-in weapon systems?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a high-speed swooping motion from above while creating a dynamic blur of water and rain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14374840259552002 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0187482833862305 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14374840259552002, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.8749998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14374840259552002, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0494108684360981, + 0.11788693815469742, + 0.03109855204820633, + 0.06103012338280678, + 0.2310691624879837, + 0.07580496370792389, + 0.09373865276575089, + 0.08467020094394684, + 0.12433245033025742, + 0.13095806539058685 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14374840259552002 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek frigate warship with a metallic-gray hull?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the ship on a turbulent sea with dark green waves and thick dark clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the ship exhibit violent motion, including pitching, rolling, and being engulfed by white foam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the ship's deck visible with intricate piping and close-in weapon systems?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a high-speed swooping motion from above while creating a dynamic blur of water and rain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007634746376425028 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.88263463973999 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007634746376425028, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007634746376425028, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07702290266752243, + 0.12804970145225525, + 0.10441123694181442, + 0.09036993980407715, + 0.08858585357666016, + 0.053689662367105484, + 0.08393370360136032, + 0.06100904941558838, + 0.06812978535890579, + 0.24479813873767853 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007634746376425028 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek frigate warship with a metallic-gray hull?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the ship on a turbulent sea with dark green waves and thick dark clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the ship exhibit violent motion, including pitching, rolling, and being engulfed by white foam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the ship's deck visible with intricate piping and close-in weapon systems?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a high-speed swooping motion from above while creating a dynamic blur of water and rain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002195450011640787 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127195358276367 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002195450011640787, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002195450011640787, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07758116722106934, + 0.044912904500961304, + 0.054588355123996735, + 0.044351134449243546, + 0.11233986914157867, + 0.09256419539451599, + 0.048505716025829315, + 0.03910800814628601, + 0.08592432737350464, + 0.40012431144714355 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002195450011640787 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek frigate warship with a metallic-gray hull?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the ship on a turbulent sea with dark green waves and thick dark clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the ship exhibit violent motion, including pitching, rolling, and being engulfed by white foam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the ship's deck visible with intricate piping and close-in weapon systems?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a high-speed swooping motion from above while creating a dynamic blur of water and rain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018186133354902267 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018186092376709 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018186133354902267, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018186133354902267, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03607506677508354, + 0.044332921504974365, + 0.014147424139082432, + 0.026002755388617516, + 0.15904085338115692, + 0.0956873744726181, + 0.16991916298866272, + 0.048714492470026016, + 0.08695381879806519, + 0.3191261887550354 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018186133354902267 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek frigate warship with a metallic-gray hull?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the ship on a turbulent sea with dark green waves and thick dark clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the ship exhibit violent motion, including pitching, rolling, and being engulfed by white foam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the ship's deck visible with intricate piping and close-in weapon systems?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a high-speed swooping motion from above while creating a dynamic blur of water and rain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01606355793774128 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141063690185547 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01606355793774128, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01606355793774128, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08951855450868607, + 0.10122549533843994, + 0.026834499090909958, + 0.06518357247114182, + 0.1261073648929596, + 0.10068421810865402, + 0.06712990999221802, + 0.08312258869409561, + 0.1639236956834793, + 0.17627009749412537 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01606355793774128 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "striking drone shot, swooping down from high above at breakneck speed, glides close to the cool, metallic-gray hull of a sleek frigate. The warship pitches violently on a turbulent sea shrouded by thick, dark clouds, repeatedly tossed high and slammed down by mountains of dark green waves. In a violent roll, the ship's sides are nearly engulfed by the roiling white foam, only to be lifted by another immense force. Its razor-sharp bow pierces the waves, sending torrents of water cascading across a deck crisscrossed with intricate piping and close-in weapon systems. The high-speed camera, combined with the violent swaying of the ship, creates a dynamic blur of splashing water and pouring rain across the frame, while the mottled marks of weather and erosion on the hull stand out vividly in the cold, bleak light. The entire picture presents a cold blue-gray tone, full of a sense of epic confrontation between human creations and furious nature, creating a suffocating tension and thrilling speed aesthetics.", + "seed": 1999, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_12/index_8642_seed_1999_dp_25_rank_50_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.06913064597174526, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06913064597174526, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.724999952316284, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06913064597174526, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek frigate warship with a metallic-gray hull?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the ship on a turbulent sea with dark green waves and thick dark clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the ship exhibit violent motion, including pitching, rolling, and being engulfed by white foam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the ship's deck visible with intricate piping and close-in weapon systems?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a high-speed swooping motion from above while creating a dynamic blur of water and rain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.25395357608795166 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5039535760879517 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.25395357608795166, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.25395357608795166, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15799511969089508, + 0.07269002497196198, + 0.29633525013923645, + 0.07567588984966278, + 0.04959002882242203, + 0.0301565732806921, + 0.04294535145163536, + 0.15785939991474152, + 0.04374953359365463, + 0.073002889752388 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.25395357608795166 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek frigate warship with a metallic-gray hull?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the ship on a turbulent sea with dark green waves and thick dark clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the ship exhibit violent motion, including pitching, rolling, and being engulfed by white foam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the ship's deck visible with intricate piping and close-in weapon systems?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a high-speed swooping motion from above while creating a dynamic blur of water and rain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06205568090081215 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120555877685547 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06205568090081215, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06205568090081215, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1727370321750641, + 0.15886089205741882, + 0.1906687319278717, + 0.0747801885008812, + 0.10329899191856384, + 0.038000885397195816, + 0.04958273470401764, + 0.1413722038269043, + 0.034890517592430115, + 0.035807859152555466 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06205568090081215 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek frigate warship with a metallic-gray hull?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the ship on a turbulent sea with dark green waves and thick dark clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the ship exhibit violent motion, including pitching, rolling, and being engulfed by white foam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the ship's deck visible with intricate piping and close-in weapon systems?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a high-speed swooping motion from above while creating a dynamic blur of water and rain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0028190179727971554 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877819061279297 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0028190179727971554, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0028190179727971554, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1267082244157791, + 0.1097097396850586, + 0.16149485111236572, + 0.17571239173412323, + 0.057038333266973495, + 0.05936336889863014, + 0.08576680719852448, + 0.1400243043899536, + 0.04410813748836517, + 0.04007379710674286 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0028190179727971554 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek frigate warship with a metallic-gray hull?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the ship on a turbulent sea with dark green waves and thick dark clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the ship exhibit violent motion, including pitching, rolling, and being engulfed by white foam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the ship's deck visible with intricate piping and close-in weapon systems?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a high-speed swooping motion from above while creating a dynamic blur of water and rain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018191050738096237 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018190860748291 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018191050738096237, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018191050738096237, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17371347546577454, + 0.06623057276010513, + 0.2027439922094345, + 0.10135442018508911, + 0.03144202008843422, + 0.10122538357973099, + 0.10515807569026947, + 0.09296602010726929, + 0.0604831837117672, + 0.06468277424573898 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018191050738096237 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek frigate warship with a metallic-gray hull?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the ship on a turbulent sea with dark green waves and thick dark clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the ship exhibit violent motion, including pitching, rolling, and being engulfed by white foam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the ship's deck visible with intricate piping and close-in weapon systems?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a high-speed swooping motion from above while creating a dynamic blur of water and rain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008633904159069061 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758634090423584 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008633904159069061, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008633904159069061, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1208573579788208, + 0.06653910130262375, + 0.08626005798578262, + 0.07441999763250351, + 0.07090464979410172, + 0.08804741501808167, + 0.12325673550367355, + 0.23985761404037476, + 0.06464437395334244, + 0.065212681889534 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008633904159069061 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "striking drone shot, swooping down from high above at breakneck speed, glides close to the cool, metallic-gray hull of a sleek frigate. The warship pitches violently on a turbulent sea shrouded by thick, dark clouds, repeatedly tossed high and slammed down by mountains of dark green waves. In a violent roll, the ship's sides are nearly engulfed by the roiling white foam, only to be lifted by another immense force. Its razor-sharp bow pierces the waves, sending torrents of water cascading across a deck crisscrossed with intricate piping and close-in weapon systems. The high-speed camera, combined with the violent swaying of the ship, creates a dynamic blur of splashing water and pouring rain across the frame, while the mottled marks of weather and erosion on the hull stand out vividly in the cold, bleak light. The entire picture presents a cold blue-gray tone, full of a sense of epic confrontation between human creations and furious nature, creating a suffocating tension and thrilling speed aesthetics.", + "seed": 2000, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_12/index_8642_seed_2000_dp_25_rank_50_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.024021938524674623, + "vlm_logprob": -0.024021938524674623, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.7, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.024021938524674623, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek frigate warship with a metallic-gray hull?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the ship on a turbulent sea with dark green waves and thick dark clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the ship exhibit violent motion, including pitching, rolling, and being engulfed by white foam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the ship's deck visible with intricate piping and close-in weapon systems?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a high-speed swooping motion from above while creating a dynamic blur of water and rain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08023122698068619 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.580231189727783 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08023122698068619, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08023122698068619, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07884776592254639, + 0.7569627165794373, + 0.017780447378754616, + 0.02131163887679577, + 0.0190243199467659, + 0.02211184613406658, + 0.020402271300554276, + 0.028730491176247597, + 0.01632341556251049, + 0.01850503869354725 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08023122698068619 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek frigate warship with a metallic-gray hull?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the ship on a turbulent sea with dark green waves and thick dark clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the ship exhibit violent motion, including pitching, rolling, and being engulfed by white foam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the ship's deck visible with intricate piping and close-in weapon systems?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a high-speed swooping motion from above while creating a dynamic blur of water and rain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0040968069806694984 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504096984863281 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0040968069806694984, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0040968069806694984, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11702743917703629, + 0.5206060409545898, + 0.03811699151992798, + 0.04638104885816574, + 0.036172594875097275, + 0.08212985843420029, + 0.09742380678653717, + 0.018473252654075623, + 0.011649031192064285, + 0.032019972801208496 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0040968069806694984 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek frigate warship with a metallic-gray hull?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the ship on a turbulent sea with dark green waves and thick dark clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the ship exhibit violent motion, including pitching, rolling, and being engulfed by white foam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the ship's deck visible with intricate piping and close-in weapon systems?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a high-speed swooping motion from above while creating a dynamic blur of water and rain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0008102948195300996 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.125810146331787 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0008102948195300996, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0008102948195300996, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24056647717952728, + 0.07860959321260452, + 0.07306955754756927, + 0.04587694630026817, + 0.1878884881734848, + 0.12993307411670685, + 0.056571897119283676, + 0.09206536412239075, + 0.03553829342126846, + 0.05988030880689621 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0008102948195300996 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek frigate warship with a metallic-gray hull?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the ship on a turbulent sea with dark green waves and thick dark clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the ship exhibit violent motion, including pitching, rolling, and being engulfed by white foam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the ship's deck visible with intricate piping and close-in weapon systems?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a high-speed swooping motion from above while creating a dynamic blur of water and rain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02633899636566639 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651339054107666 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02633899636566639, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02633899636566639, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13103662431240082, + 0.5026522874832153, + 0.04626072943210602, + 0.019672667607665062, + 0.046332813799381256, + 0.07890543341636658, + 0.0354544073343277, + 0.04974738508462906, + 0.04722458869218826, + 0.04271304979920387 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02633899636566639 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek frigate warship with a metallic-gray hull?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the ship on a turbulent sea with dark green waves and thick dark clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the ship exhibit violent motion, including pitching, rolling, and being engulfed by white foam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the ship's deck visible with intricate piping and close-in weapon systems?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a high-speed swooping motion from above while creating a dynamic blur of water and rain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008632367476820946 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758632183074951 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008632367476820946, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008632367476820946, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0594901479780674, + 0.5277675986289978, + 0.021698441356420517, + 0.04357500746846199, + 0.03574882447719574, + 0.13459216058254242, + 0.05093378573656082, + 0.0672391951084137, + 0.024414822459220886, + 0.03454010188579559 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008632367476820946 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_13/index_tensor([3436, 3436])_group_13_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_13/index_tensor([3436, 3436])_group_13_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..500887d733244781e23101154b6805f505ac0810 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_13/index_tensor([3436, 3436])_group_13_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "static, slightly low-angle extreme close-up focuses on the smoldering tip of a thin, dark incense stick. A tiny crimson glows steadily atop its delicate white-ash crown. The stick rests firmly on a minimalist, unglazed, dark ceramic stand, which rests on the rich, grainy surface of a low wooden coffee table. From within its luminous dragonfly, a delicate tendril of pale white smoke rises lazily, twisting and curling in a hypnotic, ever-shifting pattern, slowly drifting upward. A sharp ray of sunlight, late in the afternoon, filters through the dimly lit living room, capturing the ethereal smoke and making it stand out vividly against the softly blurred background. This interplay of light and shadow, combined with the smoke's slow, graceful movement, creates an atmosphere of profound tranquility and meditation.", + "seed": 10812, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_13/index_3436_seed_10812_dp_26_rank_52_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.26749806297011675, + "vlm_logprob": -0.26749806297011675, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.525, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.26749806297011675, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focusing on the tip of a thin, dark incense stick?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a tiny crimson glow on a delicate white-ash crown atop the incense stick?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a tendril of pale white smoke rise lazily from the incense tip and twist upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a sharp ray of late afternoon sunlight filtering through a dimly lit room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background softly blurred while the incense stick and smoke remain in sharp focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5775932669639587 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8275932669639587 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5775932669639587, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5775932669639587, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4407530426979065, + 0.10985416918992996, + 0.08000274002552032, + 0.04301527515053749, + 0.12128490209579468, + 0.019072625786066055, + 0.03313438221812248, + 0.04550444334745407, + 0.018475547432899475, + 0.08890290558338165 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5775932669639587 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focusing on the tip of a thin, dark incense stick?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a tiny crimson glow on a delicate white-ash crown atop the incense stick?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a tendril of pale white smoke rise lazily from the incense tip and twist upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a sharp ray of late afternoon sunlight filtering through a dimly lit room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background softly blurred while the incense stick and smoke remain in sharp focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.31346625089645386 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3134663105010986 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.31346625089645386, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.31346625089645386, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.38935449719429016, + 0.2527179718017578, + 0.062005188316106796, + 0.0338229164481163, + 0.0900178998708725, + 0.026842178776860237, + 0.016802508383989334, + 0.017778726294636726, + 0.035656578838825226, + 0.0750015527009964 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.31346625089645386 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focusing on the tip of a thin, dark incense stick?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a tiny crimson glow on a delicate white-ash crown atop the incense stick?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a tendril of pale white smoke rise lazily from the incense tip and twist upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a sharp ray of late afternoon sunlight filtering through a dimly lit room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background softly blurred while the incense stick and smoke remain in sharp focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0013394916895776987 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.626339435577393 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0013394916895776987, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0013394916895776987, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25056159496307373, + 0.1539953649044037, + 0.10135992616415024, + 0.11094922572374344, + 0.2348184585571289, + 0.01855499856173992, + 0.024518482387065887, + 0.034087467938661575, + 0.034175772219896317, + 0.03697873651981354 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0013394916895776987 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focusing on the tip of a thin, dark incense stick?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a tiny crimson glow on a delicate white-ash crown atop the incense stick?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a tendril of pale white smoke rise lazily from the incense tip and twist upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a sharp ray of late afternoon sunlight filtering through a dimly lit room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background softly blurred while the incense stick and smoke remain in sharp focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4290100336074829 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.054010033607483 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.4290100336074829, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.4290100336074829, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2329326570034027, + 0.15780171751976013, + 0.09437132626771927, + 0.05174554884433746, + 0.2805770933628082, + 0.029530035331845284, + 0.012684096582233906, + 0.056891486048698425, + 0.023834502324461937, + 0.05963154509663582 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.4290100336074829 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focusing on the tip of a thin, dark incense stick?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a tiny crimson glow on a delicate white-ash crown atop the incense stick?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a tendril of pale white smoke rise lazily from the incense tip and twist upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a sharp ray of late afternoon sunlight filtering through a dimly lit room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background softly blurred while the incense stick and smoke remain in sharp focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016081271693110466 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.1410813331604 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016081271693110466, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016081271693110466, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1862291544675827, + 0.037013836205005646, + 0.10274985432624817, + 0.07598593086004257, + 0.1834925413131714, + 0.037910208106040955, + 0.03786306828260422, + 0.08097739517688751, + 0.058748356997966766, + 0.19902966916561127 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016081271693110466 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, slightly low-angle extreme close-up focuses on the smoldering tip of a thin, dark incense stick. A tiny crimson glows steadily atop its delicate white-ash crown. The stick rests firmly on a minimalist, unglazed, dark ceramic stand, which rests on the rich, grainy surface of a low wooden coffee table. From within its luminous dragonfly, a delicate tendril of pale white smoke rises lazily, twisting and curling in a hypnotic, ever-shifting pattern, slowly drifting upward. A sharp ray of sunlight, late in the afternoon, filters through the dimly lit living room, capturing the ethereal smoke and making it stand out vividly against the softly blurred background. This interplay of light and shadow, combined with the smoke's slow, graceful movement, creates an atmosphere of profound tranquility and meditation.", + "seed": 10813, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_13/index_3436_seed_10813_dp_26_rank_52_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.02790198808070272, + "vlm_logprob": -0.02790198808070272, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.35, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.02790198808070272, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focusing on the tip of a thin, dark incense stick?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a tiny crimson glow on a delicate white-ash crown atop the incense stick?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a tendril of pale white smoke rise lazily from the incense tip and twist upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a sharp ray of late afternoon sunlight filtering through a dimly lit room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background softly blurred while the incense stick and smoke remain in sharp focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.015366730280220509 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.265366554260254 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.015366730280220509, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.015366730280220509, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14091433584690094, + 0.16653874516487122, + 0.08971711993217468, + 0.17814044654369354, + 0.0773627832531929, + 0.07683441787958145, + 0.12073121964931488, + 0.05000849813222885, + 0.018521659076213837, + 0.08123072981834412 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.015366730280220509 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focusing on the tip of a thin, dark incense stick?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a tiny crimson glow on a delicate white-ash crown atop the incense stick?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a tendril of pale white smoke rise lazily from the incense tip and twist upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a sharp ray of late afternoon sunlight filtering through a dimly lit room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background softly blurred while the incense stick and smoke remain in sharp focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.062045373022556305 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120453357696533 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.062045373022556305, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.062045373022556305, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2776746153831482, + 0.11893878132104874, + 0.03631871938705444, + 0.14149679243564606, + 0.04845072329044342, + 0.08587154000997543, + 0.17320598661899567, + 0.05945061147212982, + 0.02565401792526245, + 0.03293820843100548 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.062045373022556305 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focusing on the tip of a thin, dark incense stick?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a tiny crimson glow on a delicate white-ash crown atop the incense stick?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a tendril of pale white smoke rise lazily from the incense tip and twist upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a sharp ray of late afternoon sunlight filtering through a dimly lit room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background softly blurred while the incense stick and smoke remain in sharp focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0011806668480858207 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.751180648803711 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0011806668480858207, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0011806668480858207, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13169169425964355, + 0.11160866916179657, + 0.04020266234874725, + 0.12947805225849152, + 0.0781138613820076, + 0.1084042564034462, + 0.06259024888277054, + 0.22798122465610504, + 0.04669070988893509, + 0.06323862820863724 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0011806668480858207 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focusing on the tip of a thin, dark incense stick?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a tiny crimson glow on a delicate white-ash crown atop the incense stick?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a tendril of pale white smoke rise lazily from the incense tip and twist upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a sharp ray of late afternoon sunlight filtering through a dimly lit room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background softly blurred while the incense stick and smoke remain in sharp focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05496930330991745 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929969310760498 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05496930330991745, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05496930330991745, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.133262500166893, + 0.15080468356609344, + 0.03666104003787041, + 0.23999415338039398, + 0.12384109199047089, + 0.043608278036117554, + 0.07491331547498703, + 0.03249908611178398, + 0.08398564159870148, + 0.08043012768030167 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05496930330991745 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focusing on the tip of a thin, dark incense stick?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a tiny crimson glow on a delicate white-ash crown atop the incense stick?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a tendril of pale white smoke rise lazily from the incense tip and twist upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a sharp ray of late afternoon sunlight filtering through a dimly lit room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background softly blurred while the incense stick and smoke remain in sharp focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005947866942733526 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130948066711426 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005947866942733526, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005947866942733526, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18460816144943237, + 0.08326604217290878, + 0.0761948972940445, + 0.2838596999645233, + 0.09158732742071152, + 0.03416072949767113, + 0.07315610349178314, + 0.061200354248285294, + 0.055036529898643494, + 0.05693012848496437 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005947866942733526 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, slightly low-angle extreme close-up focuses on the smoldering tip of a thin, dark incense stick. A tiny crimson glows steadily atop its delicate white-ash crown. The stick rests firmly on a minimalist, unglazed, dark ceramic stand, which rests on the rich, grainy surface of a low wooden coffee table. From within its luminous dragonfly, a delicate tendril of pale white smoke rises lazily, twisting and curling in a hypnotic, ever-shifting pattern, slowly drifting upward. A sharp ray of sunlight, late in the afternoon, filters through the dimly lit living room, capturing the ethereal smoke and making it stand out vividly against the softly blurred background. This interplay of light and shadow, combined with the smoke's slow, graceful movement, creates an atmosphere of profound tranquility and meditation.", + "seed": 10814, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_13/index_3436_seed_10814_dp_27_rank_54_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.07119374414905906, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07119374414905906, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.35, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07119374414905906, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focusing on the tip of a thin, dark incense stick?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a tiny crimson glow on a delicate white-ash crown atop the incense stick?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a tendril of pale white smoke rise lazily from the incense tip and twist upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a sharp ray of late afternoon sunlight filtering through a dimly lit room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background softly blurred while the incense stick and smoke remain in sharp focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05682853236794472 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.931828498840332 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05682853236794472, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05682853236794472, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.37976041436195374, + 0.048238884657621384, + 0.06431802362203598, + 0.12596198916435242, + 0.028355222195386887, + 0.17095385491847992, + 0.023934753611683846, + 0.10523907095193863, + 0.03340715914964676, + 0.01983058638870716 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05682853236794472 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focusing on the tip of a thin, dark incense stick?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a tiny crimson glow on a delicate white-ash crown atop the incense stick?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a tendril of pale white smoke rise lazily from the incense tip and twist upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a sharp ray of late afternoon sunlight filtering through a dimly lit room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background softly blurred while the incense stick and smoke remain in sharp focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10031646490097046 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3503165245056152 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10031646490097046, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10031646490097046, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4952821135520935, + 0.06412450224161148, + 0.045853253453969955, + 0.08810237050056458, + 0.09987061470746994, + 0.05032933130860329, + 0.035572946071624756, + 0.041446149349212646, + 0.0532599501311779, + 0.02615884691476822 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10031646490097046 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focusing on the tip of a thin, dark incense stick?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a tiny crimson glow on a delicate white-ash crown atop the incense stick?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a tendril of pale white smoke rise lazily from the incense tip and twist upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a sharp ray of late afternoon sunlight filtering through a dimly lit room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background softly blurred while the incense stick and smoke remain in sharp focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0028203255496919155 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.8778204917907715 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0028203255496919155, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0028203255496919155, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.205797016620636, + 0.18351098895072937, + 0.13351821899414062, + 0.22332333028316498, + 0.033701881766319275, + 0.055349163711071014, + 0.040232304483652115, + 0.057712942361831665, + 0.029859349131584167, + 0.036994773894548416 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0028203255496919155 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focusing on the tip of a thin, dark incense stick?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a tiny crimson glow on a delicate white-ash crown atop the incense stick?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a tendril of pale white smoke rise lazily from the incense tip and twist upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a sharp ray of late afternoon sunlight filtering through a dimly lit room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background softly blurred while the incense stick and smoke remain in sharp focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17992998659610748 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8049299716949463 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17992998659610748, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17992998659610748, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08431568741798401, + 0.2243083119392395, + 0.06797998398542404, + 0.10840137302875519, + 0.08448033779859543, + 0.11595284938812256, + 0.0885431319475174, + 0.057163387537002563, + 0.0741955041885376, + 0.09465945512056351 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17992998659610748 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focusing on the tip of a thin, dark incense stick?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a tiny crimson glow on a delicate white-ash crown atop the incense stick?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a tendril of pale white smoke rise lazily from the incense tip and twist upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a sharp ray of late afternoon sunlight filtering through a dimly lit room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background softly blurred while the incense stick and smoke remain in sharp focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01607341133058071 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141073226928711 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01607341133058071, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01607341133058071, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08506002277135849, + 0.08523793518543243, + 0.2074134200811386, + 0.14466845989227295, + 0.0460318922996521, + 0.13783589005470276, + 0.058026645332574844, + 0.11701826751232147, + 0.0773085504770279, + 0.041398897767066956 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01607341133058071 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, slightly low-angle extreme close-up focuses on the smoldering tip of a thin, dark incense stick. A tiny crimson glows steadily atop its delicate white-ash crown. The stick rests firmly on a minimalist, unglazed, dark ceramic stand, which rests on the rich, grainy surface of a low wooden coffee table. From within its luminous dragonfly, a delicate tendril of pale white smoke rises lazily, twisting and curling in a hypnotic, ever-shifting pattern, slowly drifting upward. A sharp ray of sunlight, late in the afternoon, filters through the dimly lit living room, capturing the ethereal smoke and making it stand out vividly against the softly blurred background. This interplay of light and shadow, combined with the smoke's slow, graceful movement, creates an atmosphere of profound tranquility and meditation.", + "seed": 10815, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_13/index_3436_seed_10815_dp_27_rank_54_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.07226980880368501, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07226980880368501, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.775, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07226980880368501, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focusing on the tip of a thin, dark incense stick?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a tiny crimson glow on a delicate white-ash crown atop the incense stick?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a tendril of pale white smoke rise lazily from the incense tip and twist upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a sharp ray of late afternoon sunlight filtering through a dimly lit room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background softly blurred while the incense stick and smoke remain in sharp focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026875514537096024 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7768754959106445 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026875514537096024, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026875514537096024, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.059885986149311066, + 0.07033167779445648, + 0.06367047876119614, + 0.2688750922679901, + 0.17191897332668304, + 0.2731940746307373, + 0.02239946462213993, + 0.018896156921982765, + 0.006886422634124756, + 0.043941691517829895 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026875514537096024 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focusing on the tip of a thin, dark incense stick?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a tiny crimson glow on a delicate white-ash crown atop the incense stick?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a tendril of pale white smoke rise lazily from the incense tip and twist upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a sharp ray of late afternoon sunlight filtering through a dimly lit room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background softly blurred while the incense stick and smoke remain in sharp focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0700470507144928 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.69504714012146 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0700470507144928, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0700470507144928, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03603176027536392, + 0.03663651645183563, + 0.07613787800073624, + 0.27519214153289795, + 0.28338930010795593, + 0.2126798927783966, + 0.01584179513156414, + 0.010842417366802692, + 0.012995763681828976, + 0.040252551436424255 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0700470507144928 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focusing on the tip of a thin, dark incense stick?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a tiny crimson glow on a delicate white-ash crown atop the incense stick?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a tendril of pale white smoke rise lazily from the incense tip and twist upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a sharp ray of late afternoon sunlight filtering through a dimly lit room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background softly blurred while the incense stick and smoke remain in sharp focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0011819765204563737 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.7511820793151855 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0011819765204563737, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0011819765204563737, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05646945536136627, + 0.11787030845880508, + 0.07663201540708542, + 0.06994140148162842, + 0.3579871356487274, + 0.13768954575061798, + 0.015231577679514885, + 0.03646229952573776, + 0.022208675742149353, + 0.10950759798288345 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0011819765204563737 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focusing on the tip of a thin, dark incense stick?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a tiny crimson glow on a delicate white-ash crown atop the incense stick?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a tendril of pale white smoke rise lazily from the incense tip and twist upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a sharp ray of late afternoon sunlight filtering through a dimly lit room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background softly blurred while the incense stick and smoke remain in sharp focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.25216197967529297 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.502161979675293 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.25216197967529297, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.25216197967529297, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11205808073282242, + 0.0585949644446373, + 0.07351929694414139, + 0.14436617493629456, + 0.4208027422428131, + 0.045828673988580704, + 0.0396827794611454, + 0.03422527015209198, + 0.018182750791311264, + 0.05273917689919472 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.25216197967529297 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focusing on the tip of a thin, dark incense stick?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a tiny crimson glow on a delicate white-ash crown atop the incense stick?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a tendril of pale white smoke rise lazily from the incense tip and twist upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a sharp ray of late afternoon sunlight filtering through a dimly lit room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background softly blurred while the incense stick and smoke remain in sharp focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011082522571086884 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511082649230957 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011082522571086884, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011082522571086884, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03318516165018082, + 0.03413300961256027, + 0.03290368989109993, + 0.1733565330505371, + 0.6284463405609131, + 0.032736293971538544, + 0.009030066430568695, + 0.00886604841798544, + 0.019488757476210594, + 0.027854131534695625 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011082522571086884 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_14/index_tensor([2032, 2032])_group_14_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_14/index_tensor([2032, 2032])_group_14_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..d1fff731b75a59170ba4d7fa46bc0474044fc9a3 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_14/index_tensor([2032, 2032])_group_14_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up locks onto the subject's face, rapidly tilting to the side, perfectly matching his frantic forward momentum. The frame is filled with the features of a tall, East Asian man, his short black hair plastered to his forehead and temples by a steady drizzle. His expression is a mask of pure rage; his forehead is deeply furrowed, his jaw clenched, his muscles bulging, and his dark eyes narrowed with intense, focused fury. Glittering raindrops cling to his eyelashes, trailing along his high cheekbones, capturing the chaotic city lights. The collar of a thick, dark charcoal-gray knit sweater is visible at the bottom of the frame, and on his wrist, a simple black digital watch flashes momentarily. He is actively riding a BMX bicycle, an action conveyed through the violent, rhythmic tension of his neck and the slight, discordant movements of his head. The camera's tight follow-up shots blur the background into an impressionistic smudge of a rain-slicked street at dusk. The wet asphalt acts like a dark mirror, reflecting a symphony of artificial light—cold, sterile white streetlights and vibrant neon storefront signs. This high-contrast, dynamic lighting casts fleeting, sharp shadows across his furious features, creating an atmosphere of tension, urgency, and aggressive desperation on the cool, damp evening.", + "seed": 8316, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_14/index_2032_seed_8316_dp_28_rank_56_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.35767855644226076, + "vlm_logprob": -0.35767855644226076, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.175, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.35767855644226076, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a tall East Asian man with short black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a thick dark charcoal-gray knit sweater and a black digital watch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man actively riding a BMX bicycle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a rainy city at dusk with wet asphalt reflecting white streetlights and neon signs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start as an extreme close-up on the face and rapidly tilt to the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06289168447256088 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812891721725464 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06289168447256088, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06289168447256088, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11853157728910446, + 0.3513755202293396, + 0.0699891746044159, + 0.019993122667074203, + 0.0471637025475502, + 0.07337047904729843, + 0.03235684335231781, + 0.20720425248146057, + 0.03513297066092491, + 0.04488244280219078 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06289168447256088 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a tall East Asian man with short black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a thick dark charcoal-gray knit sweater and a black digital watch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man actively riding a BMX bicycle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a rainy city at dusk with wet asphalt reflecting white streetlights and neon signs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start as an extreme close-up on the face and rapidly tilt to the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03813287243247032 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288132905960083 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03813287243247032, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03813287243247032, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05334986746311188, + 0.11727523058652878, + 0.21494023501873016, + 0.03751131892204285, + 0.05483345687389374, + 0.1803765445947647, + 0.05423588305711746, + 0.09290744364261627, + 0.05833671987056732, + 0.13623329997062683 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03813287243247032 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a tall East Asian man with short black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a thick dark charcoal-gray knit sweater and a black digital watch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man actively riding a BMX bicycle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a rainy city at dusk with wet asphalt reflecting white streetlights and neon signs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start as an extreme close-up on the face and rapidly tilt to the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6005727052688599 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22557266056537628 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.6005727052688599, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -1.6005727052688599, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09066953510046005, + 0.09352581202983856, + 0.3785996735095978, + 0.0280107781291008, + 0.06547302007675171, + 0.07855776697397232, + 0.0399022251367569, + 0.11137259751558304, + 0.07394886016845703, + 0.039939697831869125 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.6005727052688599 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a tall East Asian man with short black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a thick dark charcoal-gray knit sweater and a black digital watch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man actively riding a BMX bicycle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a rainy city at dusk with wet asphalt reflecting white streetlights and neon signs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start as an extreme close-up on the face and rapidly tilt to the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03813619911670685 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881362438201904 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03813619911670685, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03813619911670685, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06719399988651276, + 0.18221589922904968, + 0.21102917194366455, + 0.025101076811552048, + 0.044065214693546295, + 0.06129446253180504, + 0.05695537105202675, + 0.20299990475177765, + 0.05915309861302376, + 0.0899917408823967 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03813619911670685 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a tall East Asian man with short black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a thick dark charcoal-gray knit sweater and a black digital watch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man actively riding a BMX bicycle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a rainy city at dusk with wet asphalt reflecting white streetlights and neon signs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start as an extreme close-up on the face and rapidly tilt to the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.048659320920705795 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048659324645996 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.048659320920705795, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.048659320920705795, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11785629391670227, + 0.06507192552089691, + 0.09772343933582306, + 0.07450617849826813, + 0.04339034482836723, + 0.03573254123330116, + 0.022332439199090004, + 0.28267353773117065, + 0.23161587119102478, + 0.02909744903445244 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.048659320920705795 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up locks onto the subject's face, rapidly tilting to the side, perfectly matching his frantic forward momentum. The frame is filled with the features of a tall, East Asian man, his short black hair plastered to his forehead and temples by a steady drizzle. His expression is a mask of pure rage; his forehead is deeply furrowed, his jaw clenched, his muscles bulging, and his dark eyes narrowed with intense, focused fury. Glittering raindrops cling to his eyelashes, trailing along his high cheekbones, capturing the chaotic city lights. The collar of a thick, dark charcoal-gray knit sweater is visible at the bottom of the frame, and on his wrist, a simple black digital watch flashes momentarily. He is actively riding a BMX bicycle, an action conveyed through the violent, rhythmic tension of his neck and the slight, discordant movements of his head. The camera's tight follow-up shots blur the background into an impressionistic smudge of a rain-slicked street at dusk. The wet asphalt acts like a dark mirror, reflecting a symphony of artificial light—cold, sterile white streetlights and vibrant neon storefront signs. This high-contrast, dynamic lighting casts fleeting, sharp shadows across his furious features, creating an atmosphere of tension, urgency, and aggressive desperation on the cool, damp evening.", + "seed": 8317, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_14/index_2032_seed_8317_dp_28_rank_56_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.48812987878918646, + "vlm_logprob": -0.48812987878918646, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.075, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.48812987878918646, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a tall East Asian man with short black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a thick dark charcoal-gray knit sweater and a black digital watch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man actively riding a BMX bicycle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a rainy city at dusk with wet asphalt reflecting white streetlights and neon signs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start as an extreme close-up on the face and rapidly tilt to the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.038678355515003204 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2886784076690674 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.038678355515003204, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.038678355515003204, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.6282416582107544, + 0.029272668063640594, + 0.02853996865451336, + 0.05238678678870201, + 0.10925055295228958, + 0.030581656843423843, + 0.03449413925409317, + 0.020249148830771446, + 0.013838252983987331, + 0.053145188838243484 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.038678355515003204 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a tall East Asian man with short black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a thick dark charcoal-gray knit sweater and a black digital watch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man actively riding a BMX bicycle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a rainy city at dusk with wet asphalt reflecting white streetlights and neon signs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start as an extreme close-up on the face and rapidly tilt to the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04309719800949097 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680972576141357 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04309719800949097, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04309719800949097, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19755952060222626, + 0.0747210830450058, + 0.07154018431901932, + 0.0686744973063469, + 0.07093873620033264, + 0.18081118166446686, + 0.09040777385234833, + 0.05364757031202316, + 0.03160436823964119, + 0.16009503602981567 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04309719800949097 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a tall East Asian man with short black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a thick dark charcoal-gray knit sweater and a black digital watch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man actively riding a BMX bicycle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a rainy city at dusk with wet asphalt reflecting white streetlights and neon signs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start as an extreme close-up on the face and rapidly tilt to the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2379238605499268 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11292393505573273 + ], + "logprob_reward": -2.2379238605499268, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -2.2379238605499268, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4137294292449951, + 0.053113020956516266, + 0.05785510316491127, + 0.0380643755197525, + 0.03355288505554199, + 0.05837130546569824, + 0.04893315210938454, + 0.03390144184231758, + 0.0260050967335701, + 0.2364741414785385 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -2.2379238605499268 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a tall East Asian man with short black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a thick dark charcoal-gray knit sweater and a black digital watch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man actively riding a BMX bicycle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a rainy city at dusk with wet asphalt reflecting white streetlights and neon signs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start as an extreme close-up on the face and rapidly tilt to the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020608816295862198 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895608901977539 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020608816295862198, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020608816295862198, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4176078140735626, + 0.03317490965127945, + 0.06404343992471695, + 0.06594961881637573, + 0.038015738129615784, + 0.08801646530628204, + 0.0791182741522789, + 0.07343539595603943, + 0.04619119316339493, + 0.09444712847471237 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020608816295862198 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a tall East Asian man with short black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a thick dark charcoal-gray knit sweater and a black digital watch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man actively riding a BMX bicycle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a rainy city at dusk with wet asphalt reflecting white streetlights and neon signs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start as an extreme close-up on the face and rapidly tilt to the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10034116357564926 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3503410816192627 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10034116357564926, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10034116357564926, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18351559340953827, + 0.07143822312355042, + 0.04871349781751633, + 0.07305535674095154, + 0.07912614196538925, + 0.11903940886259079, + 0.14688995480537415, + 0.049094308167696, + 0.0320955291390419, + 0.1970319151878357 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10034116357564926 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up locks onto the subject's face, rapidly tilting to the side, perfectly matching his frantic forward momentum. The frame is filled with the features of a tall, East Asian man, his short black hair plastered to his forehead and temples by a steady drizzle. His expression is a mask of pure rage; his forehead is deeply furrowed, his jaw clenched, his muscles bulging, and his dark eyes narrowed with intense, focused fury. Glittering raindrops cling to his eyelashes, trailing along his high cheekbones, capturing the chaotic city lights. The collar of a thick, dark charcoal-gray knit sweater is visible at the bottom of the frame, and on his wrist, a simple black digital watch flashes momentarily. He is actively riding a BMX bicycle, an action conveyed through the violent, rhythmic tension of his neck and the slight, discordant movements of his head. The camera's tight follow-up shots blur the background into an impressionistic smudge of a rain-slicked street at dusk. The wet asphalt acts like a dark mirror, reflecting a symphony of artificial light—cold, sterile white streetlights and vibrant neon storefront signs. This high-contrast, dynamic lighting casts fleeting, sharp shadows across his furious features, creating an atmosphere of tension, urgency, and aggressive desperation on the cool, damp evening.", + "seed": 8318, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_14/index_2032_seed_8318_dp_29_rank_58_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.3426853805780411, + "vlm_logprob": -0.3426853805780411, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.125, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.3426853805780411, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a tall East Asian man with short black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a thick dark charcoal-gray knit sweater and a black digital watch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man actively riding a BMX bicycle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a rainy city at dusk with wet asphalt reflecting white streetlights and neon signs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start as an extreme close-up on the face and rapidly tilt to the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07074523717164993 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6957452297210693 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07074523717164993, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07074523717164993, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2971423268318176, + 0.12046604603528976, + 0.2560482323169708, + 0.04528287425637245, + 0.08741623163223267, + 0.03056456334888935, + 0.027061112225055695, + 0.0394187830388546, + 0.05045269429683685, + 0.04614707827568054 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07074523717164993 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a tall East Asian man with short black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a thick dark charcoal-gray knit sweater and a black digital watch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man actively riding a BMX bicycle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a rainy city at dusk with wet asphalt reflecting white streetlights and neon signs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start as an extreme close-up on the face and rapidly tilt to the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029833033680915833 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298330783843994 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029833033680915833, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029833033680915833, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10719041526317596, + 0.060788799077272415, + 0.0773792713880539, + 0.03925697132945061, + 0.11878307908773422, + 0.05177021399140358, + 0.058605436235666275, + 0.10140171647071838, + 0.1978268325328827, + 0.18699729442596436 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029833033680915833 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a tall East Asian man with short black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a thick dark charcoal-gray knit sweater and a black digital watch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man actively riding a BMX bicycle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a rainy city at dusk with wet asphalt reflecting white streetlights and neon signs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start as an extreme close-up on the face and rapidly tilt to the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.50209379196167 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2520937919616699 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.50209379196167, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -1.50209379196167, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08870633691549301, + 0.06438163667917252, + 0.03036217950284481, + 0.026245638728141785, + 0.5007243156433105, + 0.022695079445838928, + 0.027216626331210136, + 0.06335914134979248, + 0.09502049535512924, + 0.08128846436738968 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.50209379196167 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a tall East Asian man with short black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a thick dark charcoal-gray knit sweater and a black digital watch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man actively riding a BMX bicycle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a rainy city at dusk with wet asphalt reflecting white streetlights and neon signs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start as an extreme close-up on the face and rapidly tilt to the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06209063529968262 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120906352996826 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06209063529968262, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06209063529968262, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1652129590511322, + 0.15497063100337982, + 0.2577335238456726, + 0.049005553126335144, + 0.032669972628355026, + 0.0359458364546299, + 0.03165959566831589, + 0.16725915670394897, + 0.062090251594781876, + 0.04345263913273811 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06209063529968262 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a tall East Asian man with short black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a thick dark charcoal-gray knit sweater and a black digital watch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man actively riding a BMX bicycle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a rainy city at dusk with wet asphalt reflecting white streetlights and neon signs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start as an extreme close-up on the face and rapidly tilt to the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04866420477628708 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048664093017578 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04866420477628708, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04866420477628708, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0700206309556961, + 0.027934666723012924, + 0.027962764725089073, + 0.03203634172677994, + 0.6348543167114258, + 0.12544207274913788, + 0.019406767562031746, + 0.017302509397268295, + 0.022579727694392204, + 0.022460240870714188 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04866420477628708 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up locks onto the subject's face, rapidly tilting to the side, perfectly matching his frantic forward momentum. The frame is filled with the features of a tall, East Asian man, his short black hair plastered to his forehead and temples by a steady drizzle. His expression is a mask of pure rage; his forehead is deeply furrowed, his jaw clenched, his muscles bulging, and his dark eyes narrowed with intense, focused fury. Glittering raindrops cling to his eyelashes, trailing along his high cheekbones, capturing the chaotic city lights. The collar of a thick, dark charcoal-gray knit sweater is visible at the bottom of the frame, and on his wrist, a simple black digital watch flashes momentarily. He is actively riding a BMX bicycle, an action conveyed through the violent, rhythmic tension of his neck and the slight, discordant movements of his head. The camera's tight follow-up shots blur the background into an impressionistic smudge of a rain-slicked street at dusk. The wet asphalt acts like a dark mirror, reflecting a symphony of artificial light—cold, sterile white streetlights and vibrant neon storefront signs. This high-contrast, dynamic lighting casts fleeting, sharp shadows across his furious features, creating an atmosphere of tension, urgency, and aggressive desperation on the cool, damp evening.", + "seed": 8319, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_14/index_2032_seed_8319_dp_29_rank_58_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.4440902952104807, + "vlm_logprob": -0.4440902952104807, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.125, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.4440902952104807, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a tall East Asian man with short black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a thick dark charcoal-gray knit sweater and a black digital watch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man actively riding a BMX bicycle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a rainy city at dusk with wet asphalt reflecting white streetlights and neon signs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start as an extreme close-up on the face and rapidly tilt to the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023803066462278366 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7738029956817627 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023803066462278366, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023803066462278366, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06576304882764816, + 0.45132574439048767, + 0.05134062096476555, + 0.0342070572078228, + 0.053302716463804245, + 0.03118068538606167, + 0.037877004593610764, + 0.06211027875542641, + 0.04752768576145172, + 0.16536517441272736 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023803066462278366 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a tall East Asian man with short black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a thick dark charcoal-gray knit sweater and a black digital watch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man actively riding a BMX bicycle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a rainy city at dusk with wet asphalt reflecting white streetlights and neon signs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start as an extreme close-up on the face and rapidly tilt to the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04869508743286133 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486950874328613 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04869508743286133, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04869508743286133, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0761503130197525, + 0.5669002532958984, + 0.04013298079371452, + 0.014858176000416279, + 0.04780041053891182, + 0.01649102382361889, + 0.014251326210796833, + 0.03268198296427727, + 0.021201729774475098, + 0.16953177750110626 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04869508743286133 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a tall East Asian man with short black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a thick dark charcoal-gray knit sweater and a black digital watch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man actively riding a BMX bicycle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a rainy city at dusk with wet asphalt reflecting white streetlights and neon signs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start as an extreme close-up on the face and rapidly tilt to the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.017796039581299 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14279600977897644 + ], + "logprob_reward": -2.017796039581299, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -2.017796039581299, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09846571087837219, + 0.34632590413093567, + 0.09718415141105652, + 0.0425785593688488, + 0.0575992651283741, + 0.05158710107207298, + 0.10477118194103241, + 0.04433062672615051, + 0.05643226206302643, + 0.10072528570890427 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -2.017796039581299 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a tall East Asian man with short black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a thick dark charcoal-gray knit sweater and a black digital watch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man actively riding a BMX bicycle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a rainy city at dusk with wet asphalt reflecting white streetlights and neon signs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start as an extreme close-up on the face and rapidly tilt to the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029823778197169304 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298237800598145 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029823778197169304, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029823778197169304, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06319408863782883, + 0.4968438446521759, + 0.0390787236392498, + 0.03243756666779518, + 0.03941180929541588, + 0.04256913438439369, + 0.03933281823992729, + 0.11444338411092758, + 0.03649825230240822, + 0.0961904227733612 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029823778197169304 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a tall East Asian man with short black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a thick dark charcoal-gray knit sweater and a black digital watch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man actively riding a BMX bicycle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a rainy city at dusk with wet asphalt reflecting white streetlights and neon signs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start as an extreme close-up on the face and rapidly tilt to the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10033350437879562 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3503334522247314 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10033350437879562, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10033350437879562, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11185339093208313, + 0.28715160489082336, + 0.04097090661525726, + 0.04997307062149048, + 0.13213567435741425, + 0.04780985414981842, + 0.07574351876974106, + 0.11153735965490341, + 0.04833285138010979, + 0.09449177235364914 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10033350437879562 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_15/index_tensor([3370, 3370])_group_15_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_15/index_tensor([3370, 3370])_group_15_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..1d292e1914c6b67fa5713abd84b69736d7fe6fb4 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_15/index_tensor([3370, 3370])_group_15_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "close-up, static shot captured from a level angle focuses on a slightly rough-textured white wall, a canvas for light and shadow. Bright, warm afternoon sunlight filters through the bamboo forest beyond the frame, casting shadows of slender leaves and intertwined bamboo stalks, creating a dappled pattern of light and shadow. Gentle breezes bring these softly contoured, varying shades of gray to life, slowly and rhythmically swaying and flowing across the wall, sometimes stretching, sometimes overlapping, the edges of light and shadow constantly shifting in this fluid movement, creating a dynamic, almost breathing visual effect. The entire image exudes a sense of profound tranquility and poetry, dominated by a palette of pure white and rich shades of gray. The warm tones of light imbue this silent, dynamic painting with a sense of leisure and peaceful Zen.", + "seed": 27562, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_15/index_3370_seed_27562_dp_30_rank_60_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.037345892982557416, + "vlm_logprob": -0.037345892982557416, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.925, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.037345892982557416, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a slightly rough-textured white wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are shadows of slender leaves and intertwined bamboo stalks visible on the wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the shadows on the wall sway and flow rhythmically due to a gentle breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting dominated by a palette of pure white and rich shades of gray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up captured from a static camera at a level angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05052044615149498 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.050520420074463 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05052044615149498, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05052044615149498, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10182520747184753, + 0.05215534195303917, + 0.10690945386886597, + 0.21966709196567535, + 0.1734122931957245, + 0.06559871882200241, + 0.03373081982135773, + 0.06556546688079834, + 0.07378368824720383, + 0.10735192149877548 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05052044615149498 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a slightly rough-textured white wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are shadows of slender leaves and intertwined bamboo stalks visible on the wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the shadows on the wall sway and flow rhythmically due to a gentle breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting dominated by a palette of pure white and rich shades of gray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up captured from a static camera at a level angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036272702272981405 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628627300262451 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036272702272981405, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036272702272981405, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20050998032093048, + 0.17816081643104553, + 0.06488355249166489, + 0.06198786199092865, + 0.03490626811981201, + 0.05288103222846985, + 0.15682777762413025, + 0.13013392686843872, + 0.05165187269449234, + 0.06805688887834549 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036272702272981405 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a slightly rough-textured white wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are shadows of slender leaves and intertwined bamboo stalks visible on the wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the shadows on the wall sway and flow rhythmically due to a gentle breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting dominated by a palette of pure white and rich shades of gray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up captured from a static camera at a level angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10030018538236618 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3503000736236572 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10030018538236618, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10030018538236618, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19444012641906738, + 0.14958196878433228, + 0.04902186244726181, + 0.04846483841538429, + 0.05262337625026703, + 0.05736489221453667, + 0.12992198765277863, + 0.2381802797317505, + 0.05751009285449982, + 0.022890593856573105 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10030018538236618 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a slightly rough-textured white wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are shadows of slender leaves and intertwined bamboo stalks visible on the wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the shadows on the wall sway and flow rhythmically due to a gentle breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting dominated by a palette of pure white and rich shades of gray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up captured from a static camera at a level angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0059498813934624195 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130949974060059 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0059498813934624195, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0059498813934624195, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2987503409385681, + 0.17623861134052277, + 0.04742046818137169, + 0.07848726212978363, + 0.11632917076349258, + 0.05089852958917618, + 0.06694269180297852, + 0.10154653340578079, + 0.0377807691693306, + 0.025605596601963043 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0059498813934624195 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a slightly rough-textured white wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are shadows of slender leaves and intertwined bamboo stalks visible on the wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the shadows on the wall sway and flow rhythmically due to a gentle breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting dominated by a palette of pure white and rich shades of gray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up captured from a static camera at a level angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02633168175816536 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651331663131714 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02633168175816536, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02633168175816536, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3177725672721863, + 0.0891062542796135, + 0.03333431854844093, + 0.12998676300048828, + 0.1164691299200058, + 0.0733998566865921, + 0.09463869780302048, + 0.08575163781642914, + 0.03310905024409294, + 0.026431724429130554 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02633168175816536 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up, static shot captured from a level angle focuses on a slightly rough-textured white wall, a canvas for light and shadow. Bright, warm afternoon sunlight filters through the bamboo forest beyond the frame, casting shadows of slender leaves and intertwined bamboo stalks, creating a dappled pattern of light and shadow. Gentle breezes bring these softly contoured, varying shades of gray to life, slowly and rhythmically swaying and flowing across the wall, sometimes stretching, sometimes overlapping, the edges of light and shadow constantly shifting in this fluid movement, creating a dynamic, almost breathing visual effect. The entire image exudes a sense of profound tranquility and poetry, dominated by a palette of pure white and rich shades of gray. The warm tones of light imbue this silent, dynamic painting with a sense of leisure and peaceful Zen.", + "seed": 27563, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_15/index_3370_seed_27563_dp_30_rank_60_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.08496155459433793, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08496155459433793, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.8, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08496155459433793, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a slightly rough-textured white wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are shadows of slender leaves and intertwined bamboo stalks visible on the wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the shadows on the wall sway and flow rhythmically due to a gentle breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting dominated by a palette of pure white and rich shades of gray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up captured from a static camera at a level angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20273248851299286 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7027324438095093 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20273248851299286, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20273248851299286, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11352347582578659, + 0.05059302598237991, + 0.03113063983619213, + 0.11815844476222992, + 0.05853979289531708, + 0.06639211624860764, + 0.12952733039855957, + 0.14561156928539276, + 0.230096697807312, + 0.056426867842674255 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20273248851299286 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a slightly rough-textured white wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are shadows of slender leaves and intertwined bamboo stalks visible on the wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the shadows on the wall sway and flow rhythmically due to a gentle breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting dominated by a palette of pure white and rich shades of gray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up captured from a static camera at a level angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011095491237938404 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.5110955238342285 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011095491237938404, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011095491237938404, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08995216339826584, + 0.05952690914273262, + 0.04555966332554817, + 0.09593842178583145, + 0.04108225926756859, + 0.02764330990612507, + 0.12139216810464859, + 0.2754448652267456, + 0.20399998128414154, + 0.03946032002568245 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011095491237938404 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a slightly rough-textured white wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are shadows of slender leaves and intertwined bamboo stalks visible on the wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the shadows on the wall sway and flow rhythmically due to a gentle breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting dominated by a palette of pure white and rich shades of gray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up captured from a static camera at a level angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10030891746282578 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.350308895111084 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10030891746282578, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10030891746282578, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0847865417599678, + 0.046335551887750626, + 0.03961597755551338, + 0.18361623585224152, + 0.08086062222719193, + 0.19749915599822998, + 0.09008457511663437, + 0.11011985689401627, + 0.14011159539222717, + 0.02696990594267845 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 3, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10030891746282578 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a slightly rough-textured white wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are shadows of slender leaves and intertwined bamboo stalks visible on the wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the shadows on the wall sway and flow rhythmically due to a gentle breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting dominated by a palette of pure white and rich shades of gray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up captured from a static camera at a level angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0486522801220417 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048652172088623 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0486522801220417, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0486522801220417, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17751336097717285, + 0.041412800550460815, + 0.02185254544019699, + 0.09006386995315552, + 0.13353502750396729, + 0.10280454903841019, + 0.11719139665365219, + 0.0722406730055809, + 0.1373906284570694, + 0.10599514842033386 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0486522801220417 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a slightly rough-textured white wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are shadows of slender leaves and intertwined bamboo stalks visible on the wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the shadows on the wall sway and flow rhythmically due to a gentle breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting dominated by a palette of pure white and rich shades of gray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up captured from a static camera at a level angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06201859563589096 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812018632888794 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06201859563589096, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06201859563589096, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04924579709768295, + 0.02682328410446644, + 0.011854130774736404, + 0.029005706310272217, + 0.02886359579861164, + 0.01697917841374874, + 0.04159422591328621, + 0.2616689205169678, + 0.5286442041397095, + 0.00532096903771162 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06201859563589096 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up, static shot captured from a level angle focuses on a slightly rough-textured white wall, a canvas for light and shadow. Bright, warm afternoon sunlight filters through the bamboo forest beyond the frame, casting shadows of slender leaves and intertwined bamboo stalks, creating a dappled pattern of light and shadow. Gentle breezes bring these softly contoured, varying shades of gray to life, slowly and rhythmically swaying and flowing across the wall, sometimes stretching, sometimes overlapping, the edges of light and shadow constantly shifting in this fluid movement, creating a dynamic, almost breathing visual effect. The entire image exudes a sense of profound tranquility and poetry, dominated by a palette of pure white and rich shades of gray. The warm tones of light imbue this silent, dynamic painting with a sense of leisure and peaceful Zen.", + "seed": 27564, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_15/index_3370_seed_27564_dp_31_rank_62_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.01843253499828279, + "vlm_logprob": -0.01843253499828279, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.375, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.01843253499828279, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a slightly rough-textured white wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are shadows of slender leaves and intertwined bamboo stalks visible on the wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the shadows on the wall sway and flow rhythmically due to a gentle breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting dominated by a palette of pure white and rich shades of gray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up captured from a static camera at a level angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02207866683602333 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8970787525177 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02207866683602333, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02207866683602333, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18963411450386047, + 0.10671034455299377, + 0.07733319699764252, + 0.09729275852441788, + 0.24813824892044067, + 0.09637296199798584, + 0.07167404890060425, + 0.035280242562294006, + 0.040221430361270905, + 0.037342675030231476 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02207866683602333 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a slightly rough-textured white wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are shadows of slender leaves and intertwined bamboo stalks visible on the wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the shadows on the wall sway and flow rhythmically due to a gentle breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting dominated by a palette of pure white and rich shades of gray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up captured from a static camera at a level angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0017313265707343817 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.3767313957214355 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0017313265707343817, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0017313265707343817, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10534553229808807, + 0.06636635959148407, + 0.044932540506124496, + 0.07792263478040695, + 0.15742193162441254, + 0.07419558614492416, + 0.12727554142475128, + 0.16772405803203583, + 0.09557526558637619, + 0.08324052393436432 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0017313265707343817 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a slightly rough-textured white wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are shadows of slender leaves and intertwined bamboo stalks visible on the wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the shadows on the wall sway and flow rhythmically due to a gentle breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting dominated by a palette of pure white and rich shades of gray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up captured from a static camera at a level angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01606742851436138 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.1410675048828125 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01606742851436138, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01606742851436138, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05033078044652939, + 0.02928774245083332, + 0.04620238393545151, + 0.025336386635899544, + 0.18140317499637604, + 0.054832104593515396, + 0.47347214818000793, + 0.06924493610858917, + 0.03380410373210907, + 0.03608623892068863 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 4, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01606742851436138 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a slightly rough-textured white wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are shadows of slender leaves and intertwined bamboo stalks visible on the wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the shadows on the wall sway and flow rhythmically due to a gentle breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting dominated by a palette of pure white and rich shades of gray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up captured from a static camera at a level angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014200001023709774 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264200210571289 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014200001023709774, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014200001023709774, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0888037160038948, + 0.20823702216148376, + 0.06870035827159882, + 0.048001524060964584, + 0.05766692012548447, + 0.23117132484912872, + 0.11806000024080276, + 0.032039206475019455, + 0.10984481871128082, + 0.03747519105672836 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014200001023709774 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a slightly rough-textured white wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are shadows of slender leaves and intertwined bamboo stalks visible on the wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the shadows on the wall sway and flow rhythmically due to a gentle breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting dominated by a palette of pure white and rich shades of gray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up captured from a static camera at a level angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03808525204658508 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2880852222442627 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03808525204658508, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03808525204658508, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07480387389659882, + 0.0724959746003151, + 0.04641890525817871, + 0.04331086948513985, + 0.25117939710617065, + 0.09714048355817795, + 0.2259191870689392, + 0.042346157133579254, + 0.11832912266254425, + 0.028056055307388306 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03808525204658508 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up, static shot captured from a level angle focuses on a slightly rough-textured white wall, a canvas for light and shadow. Bright, warm afternoon sunlight filters through the bamboo forest beyond the frame, casting shadows of slender leaves and intertwined bamboo stalks, creating a dappled pattern of light and shadow. Gentle breezes bring these softly contoured, varying shades of gray to life, slowly and rhythmically swaying and flowing across the wall, sometimes stretching, sometimes overlapping, the edges of light and shadow constantly shifting in this fluid movement, creating a dynamic, almost breathing visual effect. The entire image exudes a sense of profound tranquility and poetry, dominated by a palette of pure white and rich shades of gray. The warm tones of light imbue this silent, dynamic painting with a sense of leisure and peaceful Zen.", + "seed": 27565, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_15/index_3370_seed_27565_dp_31_rank_62_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.019266867265105247, + "vlm_logprob": -0.019266867265105247, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.45, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.019266867265105247, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a slightly rough-textured white wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are shadows of slender leaves and intertwined bamboo stalks visible on the wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the shadows on the wall sway and flow rhythmically due to a gentle breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting dominated by a palette of pure white and rich shades of gray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up captured from a static camera at a level angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00945010781288147 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.7594499588012695 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00945010781288147, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00945010781288147, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23855075240135193, + 0.05485999584197998, + 0.09686847031116486, + 0.08369917422533035, + 0.043230146169662476, + 0.015376991592347622, + 0.03072737157344818, + 0.3236472010612488, + 0.06478127837181091, + 0.048258598893880844 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00945010781288147 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a slightly rough-textured white wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are shadows of slender leaves and intertwined bamboo stalks visible on the wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the shadows on the wall sway and flow rhythmically due to a gentle breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting dominated by a palette of pure white and rich shades of gray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up captured from a static camera at a level angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0032007675617933273 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753200531005859 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0032007675617933273, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0032007675617933273, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24045096337795258, + 0.03458701819181442, + 0.15777231752872467, + 0.049795329570770264, + 0.08810865879058838, + 0.018923472613096237, + 0.01847599633038044, + 0.2936570346355438, + 0.05346601456403732, + 0.044763173907995224 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0032007675617933273 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a slightly rough-textured white wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are shadows of slender leaves and intertwined bamboo stalks visible on the wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the shadows on the wall sway and flow rhythmically due to a gentle breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting dominated by a palette of pure white and rich shades of gray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up captured from a static camera at a level angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02979542873799801 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5297954082489014 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02979542873799801, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02979542873799801, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2655436396598816, + 0.011453026905655861, + 0.16148602962493896, + 0.04678983613848686, + 0.14158952236175537, + 0.019540149718523026, + 0.02390723116695881, + 0.21273447573184967, + 0.10474684089422226, + 0.012209217064082623 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02979542873799801 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a slightly rough-textured white wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are shadows of slender leaves and intertwined bamboo stalks visible on the wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the shadows on the wall sway and flow rhythmically due to a gentle breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting dominated by a palette of pure white and rich shades of gray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up captured from a static camera at a level angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005254032090306282 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.25525426864624 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005254032090306282, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005254032090306282, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22217760980129242, + 0.05250971391797066, + 0.1270899474620819, + 0.07091426104307175, + 0.08790066093206406, + 0.02367512509226799, + 0.018145859241485596, + 0.21238258481025696, + 0.1602831929922104, + 0.02492106519639492 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005254032090306282 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a slightly rough-textured white wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are shadows of slender leaves and intertwined bamboo stalks visible on the wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the shadows on the wall sway and flow rhythmically due to a gentle breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting dominated by a palette of pure white and rich shades of gray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up captured from a static camera at a level angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04863400012254715 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486340522766113 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04863400012254715, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04863400012254715, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25962191820144653, + 0.036501094698905945, + 0.15240636467933655, + 0.035992152988910675, + 0.0680747851729393, + 0.01561218872666359, + 0.017276102676987648, + 0.15661072731018066, + 0.2448219656944275, + 0.013082673773169518 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04863400012254715 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_2/index_tensor([7896, 7896])_group_2_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_2/index_tensor([7896, 7896])_group_2_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..c16e3cbec3445f32b03a17d768ceaf8a70721bcd --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_2/index_tensor([7896, 7896])_group_2_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "In a slow, solemn downward tilt, the camera begins in a medium shot, capturing an athlete undergoing rehabilitation exercises on an empty outdoor training field. The image is saturated in the classic Annie Leibovitz portraiture, with theatrical lighting, as if cast by a carefully placed softbox, sculpting the subject's silhouette. He struggles to propel himself on a tandem bicycle designed for people with disabilities. The matte black carbon fiber frame gleams discreetly in the soft, sidelight morning light, and the front seat has been converted into a sophisticated hand-crank system. The athlete, clad in a tight, dark gray, technical long-sleeved sports shirt, his back drenched in sweat, highlights the strain of his shoulders and back muscles from the constant exertion. He drives the handlebars with focused, rhythmic movement, his arms conveying a sense of power and control with each turn. As the camera descends steadily and silently, the frame gradually tightens, ultimately settling on a dramatic close-up of his face. At this moment, a glistening bead of sweat begins beside his furrowed brow, delicately sliding across his weathered temple and angular cheek, its trail shimmering in the soft light. His lips are pursed, his jawline hardened by clenched teeth. Yet, within his deep eyes, a gleam of unwavering determination and an indelible glimmer of hope, gazed into the distance. This complex and profound emotion is precisely captured in the silent light and shadow, imbuing the entire scene with a sense of tranquility and strength that transcends the limits of the body and touches the depths of the soul.", + "seed": 16688, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_2/index_7896_seed_16688_dp_4_rank_8_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.05330472756177187, + "vlm_logprob": -0.05330472756177187, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.5, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.05330472756177187, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an athlete riding a tandem bicycle designed for people with disabilities?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bicycle frame matte black carbon fiber with a front seat converted into a hand-crank system?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete wearing a tight, dark gray, technical long-sleeved sports shirt with visible sweat on his back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on an empty outdoor training field with theatrical softbox-style lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start in a medium shot and perform a slow, solemn downward tilt that ends in a close-up of the athlete's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11675020307302475 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2417502403259277 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11675020307302475, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11675020307302475, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0885036438703537, + 0.07144199311733246, + 0.046651050448417664, + 0.21930202841758728, + 0.06907761842012405, + 0.04636375978589058, + 0.350082665681839, + 0.05427538603544235, + 0.018485177308321, + 0.03581663593649864 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11675020307302475 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an athlete riding a tandem bicycle designed for people with disabilities?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bicycle frame matte black carbon fiber with a front seat converted into a hand-crank system?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete wearing a tight, dark gray, technical long-sleeved sports shirt with visible sweat on his back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on an empty outdoor training field with theatrical softbox-style lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start in a medium shot and perform a slow, solemn downward tilt that ends in a close-up of the athlete's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.033742934465408325 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408742904663086 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.033742934465408325, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.033742934465408325, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1564667820930481, + 0.09729675948619843, + 0.1024053692817688, + 0.15850304067134857, + 0.07427065819501877, + 0.08906254172325134, + 0.18672046065330505, + 0.056015294045209885, + 0.03541628271341324, + 0.04384283348917961 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.033742934465408325 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an athlete riding a tandem bicycle designed for people with disabilities?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bicycle frame matte black carbon fiber with a front seat converted into a hand-crank system?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete wearing a tight, dark gray, technical long-sleeved sports shirt with visible sweat on his back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on an empty outdoor training field with theatrical softbox-style lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start in a medium shot and perform a slow, solemn downward tilt that ends in a close-up of the athlete's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00978624727576971 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634786128997803 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00978624727576971, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00978624727576971, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0956936702132225, + 0.04998713359236717, + 0.0639152005314827, + 0.1781044900417328, + 0.06695901602506638, + 0.14830224215984344, + 0.2662598788738251, + 0.0698874294757843, + 0.036773648113012314, + 0.024117326363921165 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00978624727576971 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an athlete riding a tandem bicycle designed for people with disabilities?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bicycle frame matte black carbon fiber with a front seat converted into a hand-crank system?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete wearing a tight, dark gray, technical long-sleeved sports shirt with visible sweat on his back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on an empty outdoor training field with theatrical softbox-style lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start in a medium shot and perform a slow, solemn downward tilt that ends in a close-up of the athlete's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10030148178339005 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.350301504135132 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10030148178339005, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10030148178339005, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1430598944425583, + 0.17240528762340546, + 0.04255380854010582, + 0.2268959879875183, + 0.04574237018823624, + 0.08971741050481796, + 0.12097016721963882, + 0.04397539049386978, + 0.06391901522874832, + 0.05076061189174652 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10030148178339005 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an athlete riding a tandem bicycle designed for people with disabilities?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bicycle frame matte black carbon fiber with a front seat converted into a hand-crank system?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete wearing a tight, dark gray, technical long-sleeved sports shirt with visible sweat on his back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on an empty outdoor training field with theatrical softbox-style lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start in a medium shot and perform a slow, solemn downward tilt that ends in a close-up of the athlete's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005942771211266518 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.1309428215026855 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005942771211266518, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005942771211266518, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07180868834257126, + 0.0793905183672905, + 0.039156120270490646, + 0.15512937307357788, + 0.0582779198884964, + 0.07098701596260071, + 0.31533342599868774, + 0.09139566868543625, + 0.08245977014303207, + 0.03606146201491356 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 3, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005942771211266518 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a slow, solemn downward tilt, the camera begins in a medium shot, capturing an athlete undergoing rehabilitation exercises on an empty outdoor training field. The image is saturated in the classic Annie Leibovitz portraiture, with theatrical lighting, as if cast by a carefully placed softbox, sculpting the subject's silhouette. He struggles to propel himself on a tandem bicycle designed for people with disabilities. The matte black carbon fiber frame gleams discreetly in the soft, sidelight morning light, and the front seat has been converted into a sophisticated hand-crank system. The athlete, clad in a tight, dark gray, technical long-sleeved sports shirt, his back drenched in sweat, highlights the strain of his shoulders and back muscles from the constant exertion. He drives the handlebars with focused, rhythmic movement, his arms conveying a sense of power and control with each turn. As the camera descends steadily and silently, the frame gradually tightens, ultimately settling on a dramatic close-up of his face. At this moment, a glistening bead of sweat begins beside his furrowed brow, delicately sliding across his weathered temple and angular cheek, its trail shimmering in the soft light. His lips are pursed, his jawline hardened by clenched teeth. Yet, within his deep eyes, a gleam of unwavering determination and an indelible glimmer of hope, gazed into the distance. This complex and profound emotion is precisely captured in the silent light and shadow, imbuing the entire scene with a sense of tranquility and strength that transcends the limits of the body and touches the depths of the soul.", + "seed": 16689, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_2/index_7896_seed_16689_dp_4_rank_8_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.049936795700341464, + "vlm_logprob": -0.049936795700341464, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.45, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.049936795700341464, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an athlete riding a tandem bicycle designed for people with disabilities?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bicycle frame matte black carbon fiber with a front seat converted into a hand-crank system?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete wearing a tight, dark gray, technical long-sleeved sports shirt with visible sweat on his back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on an empty outdoor training field with theatrical softbox-style lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start in a medium shot and perform a slow, solemn downward tilt that ends in a close-up of the athlete's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.09469825029373169 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.469698190689087 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.09469825029373169, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.09469825029373169, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2156173288822174, + 0.044685784727334976, + 0.125502347946167, + 0.11448988318443298, + 0.0734882727265358, + 0.2509040832519531, + 0.03359763324260712, + 0.023264531046152115, + 0.06041823700070381, + 0.05803193897008896 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.09469825029373169 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an athlete riding a tandem bicycle designed for people with disabilities?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bicycle frame matte black carbon fiber with a front seat converted into a hand-crank system?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete wearing a tight, dark gray, technical long-sleeved sports shirt with visible sweat on his back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on an empty outdoor training field with theatrical softbox-style lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start in a medium shot and perform a slow, solemn downward tilt that ends in a close-up of the athlete's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03375999256968498 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4087600708007812 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03375999256968498, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03375999256968498, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19961880147457123, + 0.21870708465576172, + 0.1137704849243164, + 0.048863884061574936, + 0.04568878561258316, + 0.13091586530208588, + 0.058663129806518555, + 0.026758678257465363, + 0.07521241158246994, + 0.0818009153008461 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03375999256968498 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an athlete riding a tandem bicycle designed for people with disabilities?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bicycle frame matte black carbon fiber with a front seat converted into a hand-crank system?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete wearing a tight, dark gray, technical long-sleeved sports shirt with visible sweat on his back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on an empty outdoor training field with theatrical softbox-style lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start in a medium shot and perform a slow, solemn downward tilt that ends in a close-up of the athlete's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006739267613738775 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006739139556885 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006739267613738775, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006739267613738775, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21912270784378052, + 0.045763738453388214, + 0.07369816303253174, + 0.026832744479179382, + 0.09786450862884521, + 0.12840142846107483, + 0.20084209740161896, + 0.07601752132177353, + 0.06406089663505554, + 0.06739617139101028 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006739267613738775 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an athlete riding a tandem bicycle designed for people with disabilities?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bicycle frame matte black carbon fiber with a front seat converted into a hand-crank system?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete wearing a tight, dark gray, technical long-sleeved sports shirt with visible sweat on his back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on an empty outdoor training field with theatrical softbox-style lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start in a medium shot and perform a slow, solemn downward tilt that ends in a close-up of the athlete's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10029986500740051 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.350299835205078 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10029986500740051, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10029986500740051, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3828833997249603, + 0.0860050842165947, + 0.060374271124601364, + 0.0339675173163414, + 0.04943074658513069, + 0.1909366399049759, + 0.028230411931872368, + 0.027016563341021538, + 0.10744571685791016, + 0.03370967134833336 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10029986500740051 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an athlete riding a tandem bicycle designed for people with disabilities?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bicycle frame matte black carbon fiber with a front seat converted into a hand-crank system?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete wearing a tight, dark gray, technical long-sleeved sports shirt with visible sweat on his back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on an empty outdoor training field with theatrical softbox-style lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start in a medium shot and perform a slow, solemn downward tilt that ends in a close-up of the athlete's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014186603017151356 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264186382293701 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014186603017151356, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014186603017151356, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1586780846118927, + 0.06487299501895905, + 0.07590191066265106, + 0.024743376299738884, + 0.041266392916440964, + 0.23047812283039093, + 0.12053802609443665, + 0.11500871926546097, + 0.13188180327415466, + 0.03663057088851929 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014186603017151356 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a slow, solemn downward tilt, the camera begins in a medium shot, capturing an athlete undergoing rehabilitation exercises on an empty outdoor training field. The image is saturated in the classic Annie Leibovitz portraiture, with theatrical lighting, as if cast by a carefully placed softbox, sculpting the subject's silhouette. He struggles to propel himself on a tandem bicycle designed for people with disabilities. The matte black carbon fiber frame gleams discreetly in the soft, sidelight morning light, and the front seat has been converted into a sophisticated hand-crank system. The athlete, clad in a tight, dark gray, technical long-sleeved sports shirt, his back drenched in sweat, highlights the strain of his shoulders and back muscles from the constant exertion. He drives the handlebars with focused, rhythmic movement, his arms conveying a sense of power and control with each turn. As the camera descends steadily and silently, the frame gradually tightens, ultimately settling on a dramatic close-up of his face. At this moment, a glistening bead of sweat begins beside his furrowed brow, delicately sliding across his weathered temple and angular cheek, its trail shimmering in the soft light. His lips are pursed, his jawline hardened by clenched teeth. Yet, within his deep eyes, a gleam of unwavering determination and an indelible glimmer of hope, gazed into the distance. This complex and profound emotion is precisely captured in the silent light and shadow, imbuing the entire scene with a sense of tranquility and strength that transcends the limits of the body and touches the depths of the soul.", + "seed": 16690, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_2/index_7896_seed_16690_dp_5_rank_10_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.06476907273754477, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06476907273754477, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.375, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06476907273754477, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an athlete riding a tandem bicycle designed for people with disabilities?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bicycle frame matte black carbon fiber with a front seat converted into a hand-crank system?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete wearing a tight, dark gray, technical long-sleeved sports shirt with visible sweat on his back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on an empty outdoor training field with theatrical softbox-style lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start in a medium shot and perform a slow, solemn downward tilt that ends in a close-up of the athlete's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20559701323509216 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7055970430374146 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20559701323509216, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20559701323509216, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20978644490242004, + 0.06012585014104843, + 0.0377570241689682, + 0.1617686003446579, + 0.06233001872897148, + 0.08506456017494202, + 0.1559268832206726, + 0.04532567411661148, + 0.06504051387310028, + 0.11687446385622025 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20559701323509216 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an athlete riding a tandem bicycle designed for people with disabilities?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bicycle frame matte black carbon fiber with a front seat converted into a hand-crank system?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete wearing a tight, dark gray, technical long-sleeved sports shirt with visible sweat on his back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on an empty outdoor training field with theatrical softbox-style lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start in a medium shot and perform a slow, solemn downward tilt that ends in a close-up of the athlete's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023328136652708054 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7733280658721924 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023328136652708054, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023328136652708054, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17292475700378418, + 0.1270969659090042, + 0.06124439835548401, + 0.2243734896183014, + 0.07026874274015427, + 0.06727928668260574, + 0.08535902947187424, + 0.03442397713661194, + 0.09449577331542969, + 0.06253354996442795 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023328136652708054 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an athlete riding a tandem bicycle designed for people with disabilities?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bicycle frame matte black carbon fiber with a front seat converted into a hand-crank system?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete wearing a tight, dark gray, technical long-sleeved sports shirt with visible sweat on his back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on an empty outdoor training field with theatrical softbox-style lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start in a medium shot and perform a slow, solemn downward tilt that ends in a close-up of the athlete's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0067384387366473675 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006738662719727 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0067384387366473675, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0067384387366473675, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08846782147884369, + 0.04025522246956825, + 0.03659263625741005, + 0.08875035494565964, + 0.16167721152305603, + 0.3811991810798645, + 0.05753779411315918, + 0.05272126570343971, + 0.043758612126111984, + 0.049039848148822784 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0067384387366473675 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an athlete riding a tandem bicycle designed for people with disabilities?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bicycle frame matte black carbon fiber with a front seat converted into a hand-crank system?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete wearing a tight, dark gray, technical long-sleeved sports shirt with visible sweat on his back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on an empty outdoor training field with theatrical softbox-style lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start in a medium shot and perform a slow, solemn downward tilt that ends in a close-up of the athlete's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0700078159570694 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695007801055908 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0700078159570694, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0700078159570694, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12999270856380463, + 0.031786952167749405, + 0.06511903554201126, + 0.05527856945991516, + 0.03978109732270241, + 0.08171156793832779, + 0.08386757969856262, + 0.03744399547576904, + 0.13951456546783447, + 0.3355039358139038 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0700078159570694 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an athlete riding a tandem bicycle designed for people with disabilities?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bicycle frame matte black carbon fiber with a front seat converted into a hand-crank system?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete wearing a tight, dark gray, technical long-sleeved sports shirt with visible sweat on his back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on an empty outdoor training field with theatrical softbox-style lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start in a medium shot and perform a slow, solemn downward tilt that ends in a close-up of the athlete's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018173959106206894 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018174171447754 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018173959106206894, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018173959106206894, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08617652207612991, + 0.0725623294711113, + 0.05796098709106445, + 0.267453134059906, + 0.07727856189012527, + 0.17782992124557495, + 0.09204499423503876, + 0.06276754289865494, + 0.0688641294836998, + 0.03706188127398491 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018173959106206894 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a slow, solemn downward tilt, the camera begins in a medium shot, capturing an athlete undergoing rehabilitation exercises on an empty outdoor training field. The image is saturated in the classic Annie Leibovitz portraiture, with theatrical lighting, as if cast by a carefully placed softbox, sculpting the subject's silhouette. He struggles to propel himself on a tandem bicycle designed for people with disabilities. The matte black carbon fiber frame gleams discreetly in the soft, sidelight morning light, and the front seat has been converted into a sophisticated hand-crank system. The athlete, clad in a tight, dark gray, technical long-sleeved sports shirt, his back drenched in sweat, highlights the strain of his shoulders and back muscles from the constant exertion. He drives the handlebars with focused, rhythmic movement, his arms conveying a sense of power and control with each turn. As the camera descends steadily and silently, the frame gradually tightens, ultimately settling on a dramatic close-up of his face. At this moment, a glistening bead of sweat begins beside his furrowed brow, delicately sliding across his weathered temple and angular cheek, its trail shimmering in the soft light. His lips are pursed, his jawline hardened by clenched teeth. Yet, within his deep eyes, a gleam of unwavering determination and an indelible glimmer of hope, gazed into the distance. This complex and profound emotion is precisely captured in the silent light and shadow, imbuing the entire scene with a sense of tranquility and strength that transcends the limits of the body and touches the depths of the soul.", + "seed": 16691, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_2/index_7896_seed_16691_dp_5_rank_10_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.04185619186609983, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04185619186609983, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.725, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04185619186609983, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an athlete riding a tandem bicycle designed for people with disabilities?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bicycle frame matte black carbon fiber with a front seat converted into a hand-crank system?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete wearing a tight, dark gray, technical long-sleeved sports shirt with visible sweat on his back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on an empty outdoor training field with theatrical softbox-style lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start in a medium shot and perform a slow, solemn downward tilt that ends in a close-up of the athlete's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08137432485818863 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.581374406814575 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08137432485818863, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08137432485818863, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.28632432222366333, + 0.09064017981290817, + 0.06532789766788483, + 0.13584297895431519, + 0.13553209602832794, + 0.06817111372947693, + 0.06277810782194138, + 0.04890139028429985, + 0.04553252458572388, + 0.06094934418797493 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08137432485818863 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an athlete riding a tandem bicycle designed for people with disabilities?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bicycle frame matte black carbon fiber with a front seat converted into a hand-crank system?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete wearing a tight, dark gray, technical long-sleeved sports shirt with visible sweat on his back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on an empty outdoor training field with theatrical softbox-style lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start in a medium shot and perform a slow, solemn downward tilt that ends in a close-up of the athlete's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.055038467049598694 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9300384521484375 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.055038467049598694, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.055038467049598694, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.279494971036911, + 0.0703287199139595, + 0.09763754159212112, + 0.22414050996303558, + 0.08971867710351944, + 0.057410407811403275, + 0.05868266150355339, + 0.04982716962695122, + 0.019964609295129776, + 0.052794672548770905 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.055038467049598694 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an athlete riding a tandem bicycle designed for people with disabilities?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bicycle frame matte black carbon fiber with a front seat converted into a hand-crank system?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete wearing a tight, dark gray, technical long-sleeved sports shirt with visible sweat on his back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on an empty outdoor training field with theatrical softbox-style lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start in a medium shot and perform a slow, solemn downward tilt that ends in a close-up of the athlete's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006739741191267967 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006739616394043 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006739741191267967, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006739741191267967, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12388147413730621, + 0.04190229997038841, + 0.03830651566386223, + 0.43216925859451294, + 0.11044701188802719, + 0.12790939211845398, + 0.028829287737607956, + 0.04389452934265137, + 0.029148254543542862, + 0.02351192943751812 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006739741191267967 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an athlete riding a tandem bicycle designed for people with disabilities?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bicycle frame matte black carbon fiber with a front seat converted into a hand-crank system?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete wearing a tight, dark gray, technical long-sleeved sports shirt with visible sweat on his back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on an empty outdoor training field with theatrical softbox-style lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start in a medium shot and perform a slow, solemn downward tilt that ends in a close-up of the athlete's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06203708052635193 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120369911193848 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06203708052635193, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06203708052635193, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17287027835845947, + 0.23062343895435333, + 0.0801137387752533, + 0.06864465028047562, + 0.049374114722013474, + 0.06400500982999802, + 0.037338145077228546, + 0.09766373783349991, + 0.15943172574043274, + 0.03993521258234978 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06203708052635193 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an athlete riding a tandem bicycle designed for people with disabilities?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bicycle frame matte black carbon fiber with a front seat converted into a hand-crank system?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete wearing a tight, dark gray, technical long-sleeved sports shirt with visible sweat on his back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on an empty outdoor training field with theatrical softbox-style lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start in a medium shot and perform a slow, solemn downward tilt that ends in a close-up of the athlete's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004091345705091953 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504091262817383 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004091345705091953, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004091345705091953, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14213542640209198, + 0.05021216347813606, + 0.12138880789279938, + 0.13120655715465546, + 0.0965871512889862, + 0.13780832290649414, + 0.06547512114048004, + 0.12380671501159668, + 0.05821692943572998, + 0.07316280156373978 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004091345705091953 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_3/index_tensor([3201, 3201])_group_3_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_3/index_tensor([3201, 3201])_group_3_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..3bc94de51c08e4fa379827297843b0f7a56acab8 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_3/index_tensor([3201, 3201])_group_3_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "panoramic shot, executed with a high-speed, bullet-time effect, begins in a medium shot, capturing a tragic moment frozen in time. On a wet city street corner, thousands of raindrops solidify in the air, each one like a tiny, crystal-clear glass bead, capturing and refracting the neon lights from all directions, forming a shimmering matrix of light suspended in the air. The shot focuses on a utterly devastated Joker, kneeling on the cold asphalt, his back hunched in agony. His signature white face paint is cracked and stained by sweat and rain, revealing the texture of fatigue beneath. The exaggerated red smile is blurred by silent tears, and a blue teardrop pattern slides down his cheek, leaving a wet mark. He wears a once vibrant, now faded, polka-dot suit, his enormous bow tie drooping limply across his chest. He clutches his head tightly in his hands, his fingers digging into his cheap, damp, bright green wig, as if suppressing the inner collapse and screams within his skull. As the camera quickly sweeps across his tense back, sweeps across his hands whose knuckles are white from exertion, and finally returns to his face distorted by makeup and pain, the whole scene, interwoven with the cold street lights and the warm neon light in the background (without any specific text), presents a highly saturated and contrasting visual effect, creating an extreme, cinematic, tragic atmosphere of isolation and despair.", + "seed": 7521, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_3/index_3201_seed_7521_dp_6_rank_12_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.052851738128811124, + "vlm_logprob": -0.052851738128811124, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.675, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.052851738128811124, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a wet city street corner with thousands of raindrops solidified in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central character a Joker kneeling on the asphalt with cracked white face paint and a blurred red smile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a faded polka-dot suit with a drooping bow tie and a bright green wig?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a quick sweep across the character's back and hands before returning to his face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style highly saturated with contrasting cold street lights and warm neon lights in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1804381012916565 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8054380416870117 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1804381012916565, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1804381012916565, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22643767297267914, + 0.20755787193775177, + 0.03400089964270592, + 0.03892449662089348, + 0.033101096749305725, + 0.251237154006958, + 0.05725519731640816, + 0.0719335526227951, + 0.018722614273428917, + 0.06082945317029953 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1804381012916565 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a wet city street corner with thousands of raindrops solidified in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central character a Joker kneeling on the asphalt with cracked white face paint and a blurred red smile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a faded polka-dot suit with a drooping bow tie and a bright green wig?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a quick sweep across the character's back and hands before returning to his face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style highly saturated with contrasting cold street lights and warm neon lights in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04306123033165932 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680612564086914 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04306123033165932, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04306123033165932, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.097582146525383, + 0.37563902139663696, + 0.06169426068663597, + 0.06436987221240997, + 0.07927612960338593, + 0.04459613561630249, + 0.03571677953004837, + 0.052101317793130875, + 0.08650520443916321, + 0.10251913964748383 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04306123033165932 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a wet city street corner with thousands of raindrops solidified in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central character a Joker kneeling on the asphalt with cracked white face paint and a blurred red smile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a faded polka-dot suit with a drooping bow tie and a bright green wig?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a quick sweep across the character's back and hands before returning to his face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style highly saturated with contrasting cold street lights and warm neon lights in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009782824665307999 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634782791137695 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009782824665307999, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009782824665307999, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0765148252248764, + 0.14643266797065735, + 0.08947428315877914, + 0.13367655873298645, + 0.14088013768196106, + 0.06121814623475075, + 0.05304194614291191, + 0.07638780772686005, + 0.08055293560028076, + 0.14182068407535553 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009782824665307999 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a wet city street corner with thousands of raindrops solidified in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central character a Joker kneeling on the asphalt with cracked white face paint and a blurred red smile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a faded polka-dot suit with a drooping bow tie and a bright green wig?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a quick sweep across the character's back and hands before returning to his face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style highly saturated with contrasting cold street lights and warm neon lights in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026339925825595856 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513400077819824 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026339925825595856, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026339925825595856, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12314214557409286, + 0.09498205780982971, + 0.06656427681446075, + 0.1415879875421524, + 0.06156293302774429, + 0.09502900391817093, + 0.2738695740699768, + 0.036107540130615234, + 0.037330616265535355, + 0.06982393562793732 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026339925825595856 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a wet city street corner with thousands of raindrops solidified in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central character a Joker kneeling on the asphalt with cracked white face paint and a blurred red smile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a faded polka-dot suit with a drooping bow tie and a bright green wig?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a quick sweep across the character's back and hands before returning to his face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style highly saturated with contrasting cold street lights and warm neon lights in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004636608529835939 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379636764526367 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004636608529835939, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004636608529835939, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3067295551300049, + 0.09698287397623062, + 0.04520351067185402, + 0.05002257972955704, + 0.03237495571374893, + 0.19644108414649963, + 0.07479186356067657, + 0.0650855004787445, + 0.08591803163290024, + 0.046450018882751465 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004636608529835939 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "panoramic shot, executed with a high-speed, bullet-time effect, begins in a medium shot, capturing a tragic moment frozen in time. On a wet city street corner, thousands of raindrops solidify in the air, each one like a tiny, crystal-clear glass bead, capturing and refracting the neon lights from all directions, forming a shimmering matrix of light suspended in the air. The shot focuses on a utterly devastated Joker, kneeling on the cold asphalt, his back hunched in agony. His signature white face paint is cracked and stained by sweat and rain, revealing the texture of fatigue beneath. The exaggerated red smile is blurred by silent tears, and a blue teardrop pattern slides down his cheek, leaving a wet mark. He wears a once vibrant, now faded, polka-dot suit, his enormous bow tie drooping limply across his chest. He clutches his head tightly in his hands, his fingers digging into his cheap, damp, bright green wig, as if suppressing the inner collapse and screams within his skull. As the camera quickly sweeps across his tense back, sweeps across his hands whose knuckles are white from exertion, and finally returns to his face distorted by makeup and pain, the whole scene, interwoven with the cold street lights and the warm neon light in the background (without any specific text), presents a highly saturated and contrasting visual effect, creating an extreme, cinematic, tragic atmosphere of isolation and despair.", + "seed": 7522, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_3/index_3201_seed_7522_dp_6_rank_12_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.06613598796539008, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06613598796539008, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.5, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06613598796539008, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a wet city street corner with thousands of raindrops solidified in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central character a Joker kneeling on the asphalt with cracked white face paint and a blurred red smile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a faded polka-dot suit with a drooping bow tie and a bright green wig?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a quick sweep across the character's back and hands before returning to his face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style highly saturated with contrasting cold street lights and warm neon lights in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.18060320615768433 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.805603265762329 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.18060320615768433, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.18060320615768433, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19705034792423248, + 0.1293286681175232, + 0.10383788496255875, + 0.2814391255378723, + 0.09451714158058167, + 0.0527612529695034, + 0.03587184473872185, + 0.035564932972192764, + 0.03846020996570587, + 0.031168630346655846 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.18060320615768433 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a wet city street corner with thousands of raindrops solidified in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central character a Joker kneeling on the asphalt with cracked white face paint and a blurred red smile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a faded polka-dot suit with a drooping bow tie and a bright green wig?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a quick sweep across the character's back and hands before returning to his face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style highly saturated with contrasting cold street lights and warm neon lights in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04306066036224365 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168060779571533 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04306066036224365, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04306066036224365, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13781218230724335, + 0.08227135986089706, + 0.10468245297670364, + 0.1029871478676796, + 0.08940649032592773, + 0.051257096230983734, + 0.07418159395456314, + 0.22650158405303955, + 0.06646931916475296, + 0.06443079560995102 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04306066036224365 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a wet city street corner with thousands of raindrops solidified in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central character a Joker kneeling on the asphalt with cracked white face paint and a blurred red smile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a faded polka-dot suit with a drooping bow tie and a bright green wig?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a quick sweep across the character's back and hands before returning to his face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style highly saturated with contrasting cold street lights and warm neon lights in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016062384471297264 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141062259674072 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016062384471297264, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016062384471297264, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08612516522407532, + 0.08669397234916687, + 0.037794649600982666, + 0.1245943233370781, + 0.09205548465251923, + 0.08858980983495712, + 0.11081722378730774, + 0.13322600722312927, + 0.1853960007429123, + 0.05470733344554901 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016062384471297264 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a wet city street corner with thousands of raindrops solidified in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central character a Joker kneeling on the asphalt with cracked white face paint and a blurred red smile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a faded polka-dot suit with a drooping bow tie and a bright green wig?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a quick sweep across the character's back and hands before returning to his face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style highly saturated with contrasting cold street lights and warm neon lights in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08901448547840118 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4640145301818848 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08901448547840118, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08901448547840118, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09251639991998672, + 0.17125976085662842, + 0.0496496856212616, + 0.17553916573524475, + 0.2096310406923294, + 0.056277915835380554, + 0.04359762370586395, + 0.10687370598316193, + 0.061025578528642654, + 0.033629160374403 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08901448547840118 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a wet city street corner with thousands of raindrops solidified in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central character a Joker kneeling on the asphalt with cracked white face paint and a blurred red smile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a faded polka-dot suit with a drooping bow tie and a bright green wig?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a quick sweep across the character's back and hands before returning to his face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style highly saturated with contrasting cold street lights and warm neon lights in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0019392033573240042 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.251939296722412 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0019392033573240042, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0019392033573240042, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.31984516978263855, + 0.17107746005058289, + 0.06713224947452545, + 0.03813391551375389, + 0.04811251163482666, + 0.025380592793226242, + 0.09770703315734863, + 0.08758866041898727, + 0.0816057100892067, + 0.06341667473316193 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0019392033573240042 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "panoramic shot, executed with a high-speed, bullet-time effect, begins in a medium shot, capturing a tragic moment frozen in time. On a wet city street corner, thousands of raindrops solidify in the air, each one like a tiny, crystal-clear glass bead, capturing and refracting the neon lights from all directions, forming a shimmering matrix of light suspended in the air. The shot focuses on a utterly devastated Joker, kneeling on the cold asphalt, his back hunched in agony. His signature white face paint is cracked and stained by sweat and rain, revealing the texture of fatigue beneath. The exaggerated red smile is blurred by silent tears, and a blue teardrop pattern slides down his cheek, leaving a wet mark. He wears a once vibrant, now faded, polka-dot suit, his enormous bow tie drooping limply across his chest. He clutches his head tightly in his hands, his fingers digging into his cheap, damp, bright green wig, as if suppressing the inner collapse and screams within his skull. As the camera quickly sweeps across his tense back, sweeps across his hands whose knuckles are white from exertion, and finally returns to his face distorted by makeup and pain, the whole scene, interwoven with the cold street lights and the warm neon light in the background (without any specific text), presents a highly saturated and contrasting visual effect, creating an extreme, cinematic, tragic atmosphere of isolation and despair.", + "seed": 7523, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_3/index_3201_seed_7523_dp_7_rank_14_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.06707484154030681, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06707484154030681, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.125, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06707484154030681, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a wet city street corner with thousands of raindrops solidified in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central character a Joker kneeling on the asphalt with cracked white face paint and a blurred red smile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a faded polka-dot suit with a drooping bow tie and a bright green wig?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a quick sweep across the character's back and hands before returning to his face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style highly saturated with contrasting cold street lights and warm neon lights in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16128839552402496 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9112883806228638 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16128839552402496, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16128839552402496, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09197811782360077, + 0.07340622693300247, + 0.04841851443052292, + 0.5099113583564758, + 0.08544469624757767, + 0.05740173161029816, + 0.02074074000120163, + 0.04123638942837715, + 0.03893912956118584, + 0.03252317011356354 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16128839552402496 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a wet city street corner with thousands of raindrops solidified in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central character a Joker kneeling on the asphalt with cracked white face paint and a blurred red smile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a faded polka-dot suit with a drooping bow tie and a bright green wig?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a quick sweep across the character's back and hands before returning to his face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style highly saturated with contrasting cold street lights and warm neon lights in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06204133853316307 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120412826538086 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06204133853316307, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06204133853316307, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07937074452638626, + 0.11725376546382904, + 0.0623808391392231, + 0.3879489600658417, + 0.028368903324007988, + 0.028724119067192078, + 0.039483003318309784, + 0.05354555696249008, + 0.16561219096183777, + 0.037311945110559464 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06204133853316307 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a wet city street corner with thousands of raindrops solidified in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central character a Joker kneeling on the asphalt with cracked white face paint and a blurred red smile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a faded polka-dot suit with a drooping bow tie and a bright green wig?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a quick sweep across the character's back and hands before returning to his face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style highly saturated with contrasting cold street lights and warm neon lights in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07896972447633743 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.578969717025757 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07896972447633743, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07896972447633743, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06950856000185013, + 0.15366870164871216, + 0.055981699377298355, + 0.17596833407878876, + 0.04587610065937042, + 0.07429220527410507, + 0.08778685331344604, + 0.09715612977743149, + 0.05587052181363106, + 0.18389087915420532 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07896972447633743 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a wet city street corner with thousands of raindrops solidified in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central character a Joker kneeling on the asphalt with cracked white face paint and a blurred red smile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a faded polka-dot suit with a drooping bow tie and a bright green wig?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a quick sweep across the character's back and hands before returning to his face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style highly saturated with contrasting cold street lights and warm neon lights in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026337139308452606 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651337146759033 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026337139308452606, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026337139308452606, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0888441726565361, + 0.17917710542678833, + 0.04690586030483246, + 0.15760447084903717, + 0.19372427463531494, + 0.07814563810825348, + 0.14083679020404816, + 0.029701383784413338, + 0.04018215835094452, + 0.044878095388412476 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026337139308452606 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a wet city street corner with thousands of raindrops solidified in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central character a Joker kneeling on the asphalt with cracked white face paint and a blurred red smile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a faded polka-dot suit with a drooping bow tie and a bright green wig?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a quick sweep across the character's back and hands before returning to his face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style highly saturated with contrasting cold street lights and warm neon lights in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00673760985955596 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.00673770904541 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00673760985955596, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00673760985955596, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07586885988712311, + 0.07473555207252502, + 0.04132768139243126, + 0.21862483024597168, + 0.252610445022583, + 0.05876351147890091, + 0.06729983538389206, + 0.08239912986755371, + 0.04048320651054382, + 0.08788693696260452 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00673760985955596 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "panoramic shot, executed with a high-speed, bullet-time effect, begins in a medium shot, capturing a tragic moment frozen in time. On a wet city street corner, thousands of raindrops solidify in the air, each one like a tiny, crystal-clear glass bead, capturing and refracting the neon lights from all directions, forming a shimmering matrix of light suspended in the air. The shot focuses on a utterly devastated Joker, kneeling on the cold asphalt, his back hunched in agony. His signature white face paint is cracked and stained by sweat and rain, revealing the texture of fatigue beneath. The exaggerated red smile is blurred by silent tears, and a blue teardrop pattern slides down his cheek, leaving a wet mark. He wears a once vibrant, now faded, polka-dot suit, his enormous bow tie drooping limply across his chest. He clutches his head tightly in his hands, his fingers digging into his cheap, damp, bright green wig, as if suppressing the inner collapse and screams within his skull. As the camera quickly sweeps across his tense back, sweeps across his hands whose knuckles are white from exertion, and finally returns to his face distorted by makeup and pain, the whole scene, interwoven with the cold street lights and the warm neon light in the background (without any specific text), presents a highly saturated and contrasting visual effect, creating an extreme, cinematic, tragic atmosphere of isolation and despair.", + "seed": 7524, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_3/index_3201_seed_7524_dp_7_rank_14_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.09547668297309428, + "vlm_logprob": -0.09547668297309428, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.6, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.09547668297309428, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a wet city street corner with thousands of raindrops solidified in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central character a Joker kneeling on the asphalt with cracked white face paint and a blurred red smile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a faded polka-dot suit with a drooping bow tie and a bright green wig?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a quick sweep across the character's back and hands before returning to his face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style highly saturated with contrasting cold street lights and warm neon lights in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.18142473697662354 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8064247369766235 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.18142473697662354, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.18142473697662354, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21368616819381714, + 0.047360293567180634, + 0.04758641496300697, + 0.06441422551870346, + 0.166974276304245, + 0.03998586907982826, + 0.1111612394452095, + 0.2408352643251419, + 0.04063715785741806, + 0.02735917456448078 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.18142473697662354 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a wet city street corner with thousands of raindrops solidified in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central character a Joker kneeling on the asphalt with cracked white face paint and a blurred red smile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a faded polka-dot suit with a drooping bow tie and a bright green wig?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a quick sweep across the character's back and hands before returning to his face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style highly saturated with contrasting cold street lights and warm neon lights in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.038100630044937134 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881007194519043 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.038100630044937134, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.038100630044937134, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.28594541549682617, + 0.13288144767284393, + 0.04289535805583, + 0.08176209032535553, + 0.12496911734342575, + 0.07003126293420792, + 0.04074222594499588, + 0.06640506535768509, + 0.07772230356931686, + 0.07664579153060913 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.038100630044937134 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a wet city street corner with thousands of raindrops solidified in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central character a Joker kneeling on the asphalt with cracked white face paint and a blurred red smile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a faded polka-dot suit with a drooping bow tie and a bright green wig?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a quick sweep across the character's back and hands before returning to his face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style highly saturated with contrasting cold street lights and warm neon lights in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004092888906598091 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504092693328857 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004092888906598091, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004092888906598091, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16743701696395874, + 0.17106638848781586, + 0.04543428122997284, + 0.2667994499206543, + 0.09131326526403427, + 0.05100545659661293, + 0.03286006301641464, + 0.042498063296079636, + 0.09021846204996109, + 0.041367579251527786 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004092888906598091 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a wet city street corner with thousands of raindrops solidified in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central character a Joker kneeling on the asphalt with cracked white face paint and a blurred red smile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a faded polka-dot suit with a drooping bow tie and a bright green wig?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a quick sweep across the character's back and hands before returning to his face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style highly saturated with contrasting cold street lights and warm neon lights in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2520526349544525 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.502052664756775 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2520526349544525, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2520526349544525, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08672882616519928, + 0.09231384098529816, + 0.07476820051670074, + 0.09097165614366531, + 0.21302549540996552, + 0.03109048865735531, + 0.2148178666830063, + 0.07120873779058456, + 0.06787410378456116, + 0.057200778275728226 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2520526349544525 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a wet city street corner with thousands of raindrops solidified in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central character a Joker kneeling on the asphalt with cracked white face paint and a blurred red smile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a faded polka-dot suit with a drooping bow tie and a bright green wig?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a quick sweep across the character's back and hands before returning to his face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style highly saturated with contrasting cold street lights and warm neon lights in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.001712523982860148 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.376712322235107 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.001712523982860148, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.001712523982860148, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2266245186328888, + 0.04014674574136734, + 0.026717551052570343, + 0.022760087624192238, + 0.07568912953138351, + 0.05504164099693298, + 0.12507487833499908, + 0.07077237218618393, + 0.32965970039367676, + 0.027513358741998672 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.001712523982860148 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_4/index_tensor([1824, 1824])_group_4_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_4/index_tensor([1824, 1824])_group_4_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..31ff37e97394fd13bbc5bfc3d270441f2d8ff845 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_4/index_tensor([1824, 1824])_group_4_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "high-speed drone tracking shot, shot from a slightly upward angle, captures in cinematic slow motion a resolute, elderly man with a striking resemblance to Charles de Gaulle. Clad in a professional, windproof, bright red and black gliding suit, he grips the controls, steady and confidently steering a massive blue and white paraglider as it soars over the towering snow-capped peaks. The dazzling afternoon sun, just behind him, casts a golden, star-like halo in the shot, while the strong backlighting sharply defines his silhouette. Meanwhile, the massive, sharp shadows of him and his paraglider streak across the pristine snow slopes below, contrasting sharply with his deliberate demeanor in the slow motion and highlighting his breathtaking speed. On his wide, mirrored ski goggles, a close-up and clear reflection of a panoramic view of majestic, rolling, snow-capped mountains complements his focused and resolute eyes, creating a visual atmosphere of conquering nature, full of epic grandeur and indestructible willpower.", + "seed": 23096, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_4/index_1824_seed_23096_dp_8_rank_16_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.16009844858199357, + "vlm_logprob": -0.16009844858199357, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.5249999880790712, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.16009844858199357, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly man wearing a bright red and black gliding suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man steering a massive blue and white paraglider over snow-capped peaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in cinematic slow motion with a high-speed drone tracking from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature strong backlighting from the sun creating a golden halo and sharp shadows on the snow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a clear reflection of snow-capped mountains visible on the man's wide, mirrored ski goggles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.035194773226976395 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4101948738098145 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.035194773226976395, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.035194773226976395, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2989329695701599, + 0.09672918170690536, + 0.08994127064943314, + 0.1992321014404297, + 0.10016453266143799, + 0.07425130903720856, + 0.04659726098179817, + 0.037834689021110535, + 0.019705723971128464, + 0.036610882729291916 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.035194773226976395 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly man wearing a bright red and black gliding suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man steering a massive blue and white paraglider over snow-capped peaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in cinematic slow motion with a high-speed drone tracking from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature strong backlighting from the sun creating a golden halo and sharp shadows on the snow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a clear reflection of snow-capped mountains visible on the man's wide, mirrored ski goggles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.38713008165359497 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1371300220489502 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.38713008165359497, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.7499999403953552, + "token_credit_reward": -0.38713008165359497, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15593218803405762, + 0.09985024482011795, + 0.11285640299320221, + 0.13374434411525726, + 0.12127282470464706, + 0.09617459028959274, + 0.04180242121219635, + 0.07634523510932922, + 0.05967992544174194, + 0.1023419201374054 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.38713008165359497 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly man wearing a bright red and black gliding suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man steering a massive blue and white paraglider over snow-capped peaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in cinematic slow motion with a high-speed drone tracking from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature strong backlighting from the sun creating a golden halo and sharp shadows on the snow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a clear reflection of snow-capped mountains visible on the man's wide, mirrored ski goggles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.31343165040016174 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3134316205978394 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.31343165040016174, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.31343165040016174, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.262418657541275, + 0.110204316675663, + 0.09197598695755005, + 0.058189358562231064, + 0.15234476327896118, + 0.17143021523952484, + 0.052070252597332, + 0.020792635157704353, + 0.04505534842610359, + 0.035518448799848557 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.31343165040016174 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly man wearing a bright red and black gliding suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man steering a massive blue and white paraglider over snow-capped peaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in cinematic slow motion with a high-speed drone tracking from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature strong backlighting from the sun creating a golden halo and sharp shadows on the snow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a clear reflection of snow-capped mountains visible on the man's wide, mirrored ski goggles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00977963674813509 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634779453277588 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00977963674813509, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00977963674813509, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16396725177764893, + 0.07420570403337479, + 0.16860023140907288, + 0.07341118156909943, + 0.19038715958595276, + 0.14760294556617737, + 0.026749854907393456, + 0.02645205892622471, + 0.01426197774708271, + 0.11436164379119873 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00977963674813509 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly man wearing a bright red and black gliding suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man steering a massive blue and white paraglider over snow-capped peaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in cinematic slow motion with a high-speed drone tracking from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature strong backlighting from the sun creating a golden halo and sharp shadows on the snow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a clear reflection of snow-capped mountains visible on the man's wide, mirrored ski goggles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0549561008810997 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299561977386475 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0549561008810997, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0549561008810997, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18041187524795532, + 0.08431083709001541, + 0.06612203270196915, + 0.14153914153575897, + 0.09698908776044846, + 0.16513381898403168, + 0.029611287638545036, + 0.044366270303726196, + 0.029869044199585915, + 0.16164661943912506 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0549561008810997 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "high-speed drone tracking shot, shot from a slightly upward angle, captures in cinematic slow motion a resolute, elderly man with a striking resemblance to Charles de Gaulle. Clad in a professional, windproof, bright red and black gliding suit, he grips the controls, steady and confidently steering a massive blue and white paraglider as it soars over the towering snow-capped peaks. The dazzling afternoon sun, just behind him, casts a golden, star-like halo in the shot, while the strong backlighting sharply defines his silhouette. Meanwhile, the massive, sharp shadows of him and his paraglider streak across the pristine snow slopes below, contrasting sharply with his deliberate demeanor in the slow motion and highlighting his breathtaking speed. On his wide, mirrored ski goggles, a close-up and clear reflection of a panoramic view of majestic, rolling, snow-capped mountains complements his focused and resolute eyes, creating a visual atmosphere of conquering nature, full of epic grandeur and indestructible willpower.", + "seed": 23097, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_4/index_1824_seed_23097_dp_8_rank_16_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.10551298018544912, + "vlm_logprob": -0.10551298018544912, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.325, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.10551298018544912, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly man wearing a bright red and black gliding suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man steering a massive blue and white paraglider over snow-capped peaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in cinematic slow motion with a high-speed drone tracking from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature strong backlighting from the sun creating a golden halo and sharp shadows on the snow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a clear reflection of snow-capped mountains visible on the man's wide, mirrored ski goggles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014249362051486969 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.389249324798584 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014249362051486969, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014249362051486969, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24162378907203674, + 0.089272141456604, + 0.06583819538354874, + 0.08236882835626602, + 0.19212915003299713, + 0.18678195774555206, + 0.030118757858872414, + 0.03703327104449272, + 0.03131129965186119, + 0.043522562831640244 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014249362051486969 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly man wearing a bright red and black gliding suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man steering a massive blue and white paraglider over snow-capped peaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in cinematic slow motion with a high-speed drone tracking from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature strong backlighting from the sun creating a golden halo and sharp shadows on the snow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a clear reflection of snow-capped mountains visible on the man's wide, mirrored ski goggles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0486886166036129 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486886501312256 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0486886166036129, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0486886166036129, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09147916734218597, + 0.05325447767972946, + 0.17475400865077972, + 0.11018400639295578, + 0.25059017539024353, + 0.11853490769863129, + 0.042370859533548355, + 0.040541958063840866, + 0.03715015947818756, + 0.08114026486873627 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0486886166036129 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly man wearing a bright red and black gliding suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man steering a massive blue and white paraglider over snow-capped peaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in cinematic slow motion with a high-speed drone tracking from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature strong backlighting from the sun creating a golden halo and sharp shadows on the snow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a clear reflection of snow-capped mountains visible on the man's wide, mirrored ski goggles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.42887893319129944 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.053878903388977 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.42887893319129944, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.42887893319129944, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2970576286315918, + 0.06481130421161652, + 0.10590983927249908, + 0.17866046726703644, + 0.0772513672709465, + 0.1605817675590515, + 0.027107486501336098, + 0.024800332263112068, + 0.031079597771167755, + 0.03274024650454521 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.42887893319129944 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly man wearing a bright red and black gliding suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man steering a massive blue and white paraglider over snow-capped peaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in cinematic slow motion with a high-speed drone tracking from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature strong backlighting from the sun creating a golden halo and sharp shadows on the snow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a clear reflection of snow-capped mountains visible on the man's wide, mirrored ski goggles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0059457337483763695 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130945682525635 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0059457337483763695, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0059457337483763695, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16663269698619843, + 0.05812637880444527, + 0.13114069402217865, + 0.06038820371031761, + 0.2417515069246292, + 0.161346897482872, + 0.056793637573719025, + 0.08034880459308624, + 0.013649174012243748, + 0.029822025448083878 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0059457337483763695 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly man wearing a bright red and black gliding suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man steering a massive blue and white paraglider over snow-capped peaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in cinematic slow motion with a high-speed drone tracking from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature strong backlighting from the sun creating a golden halo and sharp shadows on the snow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a clear reflection of snow-capped mountains visible on the man's wide, mirrored ski goggles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02980225533246994 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298023223876953 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02980225533246994, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02980225533246994, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1419253796339035, + 0.05406863987445831, + 0.057033948600292206, + 0.19124943017959595, + 0.10167441517114639, + 0.26864558458328247, + 0.05449310690164566, + 0.04192258417606354, + 0.03331352770328522, + 0.05567338690161705 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02980225533246994 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "high-speed drone tracking shot, shot from a slightly upward angle, captures in cinematic slow motion a resolute, elderly man with a striking resemblance to Charles de Gaulle. Clad in a professional, windproof, bright red and black gliding suit, he grips the controls, steady and confidently steering a massive blue and white paraglider as it soars over the towering snow-capped peaks. The dazzling afternoon sun, just behind him, casts a golden, star-like halo in the shot, while the strong backlighting sharply defines his silhouette. Meanwhile, the massive, sharp shadows of him and his paraglider streak across the pristine snow slopes below, contrasting sharply with his deliberate demeanor in the slow motion and highlighting his breathtaking speed. On his wide, mirrored ski goggles, a close-up and clear reflection of a panoramic view of majestic, rolling, snow-capped mountains complements his focused and resolute eyes, creating a visual atmosphere of conquering nature, full of epic grandeur and indestructible willpower.", + "seed": 23098, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_4/index_1824_seed_23098_dp_9_rank_18_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.043711489625275136, + "vlm_logprob": -0.043711489625275136, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.45, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.043711489625275136, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly man wearing a bright red and black gliding suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man steering a massive blue and white paraglider over snow-capped peaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in cinematic slow motion with a high-speed drone tracking from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature strong backlighting from the sun creating a golden halo and sharp shadows on the snow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a clear reflection of snow-capped mountains visible on the man's wide, mirrored ski goggles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04620220139622688 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1712021827697754 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04620220139622688, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04620220139622688, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14960357546806335, + 0.4737932085990906, + 0.0298884529620409, + 0.09001106768846512, + 0.03535541519522667, + 0.052340712398290634, + 0.03504325449466705, + 0.03755607083439827, + 0.06512045860290527, + 0.03128782659769058 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04620220139622688 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly man wearing a bright red and black gliding suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man steering a massive blue and white paraglider over snow-capped peaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in cinematic slow motion with a high-speed drone tracking from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature strong backlighting from the sun creating a golden halo and sharp shadows on the snow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a clear reflection of snow-capped mountains visible on the man's wide, mirrored ski goggles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023309968411922455 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7733099460601807 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023309968411922455, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023309968411922455, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14595039188861847, + 0.4687805771827698, + 0.04875647649168968, + 0.06934047490358353, + 0.05699276179075241, + 0.050558868795633316, + 0.039008717983961105, + 0.052195705473423004, + 0.03729553893208504, + 0.031120434403419495 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023309968411922455 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly man wearing a bright red and black gliding suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man steering a massive blue and white paraglider over snow-capped peaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in cinematic slow motion with a high-speed drone tracking from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature strong backlighting from the sun creating a golden halo and sharp shadows on the snow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a clear reflection of snow-capped mountains visible on the man's wide, mirrored ski goggles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11291711777448654 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.237917184829712 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11291711777448654, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11291711777448654, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.40817463397979736, + 0.1351926177740097, + 0.04997270926833153, + 0.2211962789297104, + 0.01978245936334133, + 0.017041444778442383, + 0.030231788754463196, + 0.04671333730220795, + 0.04988637939095497, + 0.02180834673345089 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11291711777448654 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly man wearing a bright red and black gliding suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man steering a massive blue and white paraglider over snow-capped peaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in cinematic slow motion with a high-speed drone tracking from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature strong backlighting from the sun creating a golden halo and sharp shadows on the snow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a clear reflection of snow-capped mountains visible on the man's wide, mirrored ski goggles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009779990650713444 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634779930114746 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009779990650713444, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009779990650713444, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.39114058017730713, + 0.09363161772489548, + 0.04156646877527237, + 0.06187678128480911, + 0.022066755220294, + 0.034961067140102386, + 0.21886365115642548, + 0.06884630024433136, + 0.02027222141623497, + 0.04677456617355347 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009779990650713444 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly man wearing a bright red and black gliding suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man steering a massive blue and white paraglider over snow-capped peaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in cinematic slow motion with a high-speed drone tracking from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature strong backlighting from the sun creating a golden halo and sharp shadows on the snow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a clear reflection of snow-capped mountains visible on the man's wide, mirrored ski goggles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026348169893026352 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651348114013672 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026348169893026352, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026348169893026352, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13662412762641907, + 0.28633517026901245, + 0.10196685791015625, + 0.15157335996627808, + 0.024478796869516373, + 0.050151560455560684, + 0.09672069549560547, + 0.04142797365784645, + 0.04029328376054764, + 0.07042814046144485 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026348169893026352 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "high-speed drone tracking shot, shot from a slightly upward angle, captures in cinematic slow motion a resolute, elderly man with a striking resemblance to Charles de Gaulle. Clad in a professional, windproof, bright red and black gliding suit, he grips the controls, steady and confidently steering a massive blue and white paraglider as it soars over the towering snow-capped peaks. The dazzling afternoon sun, just behind him, casts a golden, star-like halo in the shot, while the strong backlighting sharply defines his silhouette. Meanwhile, the massive, sharp shadows of him and his paraglider streak across the pristine snow slopes below, contrasting sharply with his deliberate demeanor in the slow motion and highlighting his breathtaking speed. On his wide, mirrored ski goggles, a close-up and clear reflection of a panoramic view of majestic, rolling, snow-capped mountains complements his focused and resolute eyes, creating a visual atmosphere of conquering nature, full of epic grandeur and indestructible willpower.", + "seed": 23099, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_4/index_1824_seed_23099_dp_9_rank_18_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.04540655687451363, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04540655687451363, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.299999952316284, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04540655687451363, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly man wearing a bright red and black gliding suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man steering a massive blue and white paraglider over snow-capped peaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in cinematic slow motion with a high-speed drone tracking from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature strong backlighting from the sun creating a golden halo and sharp shadows on the snow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a clear reflection of snow-capped mountains visible on the man's wide, mirrored ski goggles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03539339080452919 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.410393476486206 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03539339080452919, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03539339080452919, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11978651583194733, + 0.1957850605249405, + 0.04319576546549797, + 0.03355005756020546, + 0.07227116823196411, + 0.047387272119522095, + 0.18274462223052979, + 0.08742813020944595, + 0.06856485456228256, + 0.14928659796714783 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03539339080452919 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly man wearing a bright red and black gliding suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man steering a massive blue and white paraglider over snow-capped peaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in cinematic slow motion with a high-speed drone tracking from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature strong backlighting from the sun creating a golden halo and sharp shadows on the snow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a clear reflection of snow-capped mountains visible on the man's wide, mirrored ski goggles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018202990293502808 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018202781677246 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018202990293502808, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018202990293502808, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15624940395355225, + 0.31210482120513916, + 0.02918199449777603, + 0.03683677688241005, + 0.03537733480334282, + 0.052283819764852524, + 0.06201698258519173, + 0.0476229153573513, + 0.04671245813369751, + 0.22161349654197693 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018202990293502808 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly man wearing a bright red and black gliding suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man steering a massive blue and white paraglider over snow-capped peaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in cinematic slow motion with a high-speed drone tracking from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature strong backlighting from the sun creating a golden halo and sharp shadows on the snow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a clear reflection of snow-capped mountains visible on the man's wide, mirrored ski goggles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1002984568476677 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3502984046936035 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1002984568476677, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1002984568476677, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13848869502544403, + 0.13340014219284058, + 0.04056238755583763, + 0.08131281286478043, + 0.11691547930240631, + 0.053153954446315765, + 0.09926985204219818, + 0.09978114068508148, + 0.1381380259990692, + 0.09897752106189728 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1002984568476677 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly man wearing a bright red and black gliding suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man steering a massive blue and white paraglider over snow-capped peaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in cinematic slow motion with a high-speed drone tracking from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature strong backlighting from the sun creating a golden halo and sharp shadows on the snow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a clear reflection of snow-capped mountains visible on the man's wide, mirrored ski goggles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018179811537265778 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018179893493652 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018179811537265778, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018179811537265778, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1653023064136505, + 0.1803625077009201, + 0.028877433389425278, + 0.04048672690987587, + 0.1620936244726181, + 0.03026854805648327, + 0.0533476285636425, + 0.09435693174600601, + 0.04735058546066284, + 0.19755369424819946 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018179811537265778 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly man wearing a bright red and black gliding suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man steering a massive blue and white paraglider over snow-capped peaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in cinematic slow motion with a high-speed drone tracking from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature strong backlighting from the sun creating a golden halo and sharp shadows on the snow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a clear reflection of snow-capped mountains visible on the man's wide, mirrored ski goggles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05495813488960266 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299581050872803 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05495813488960266, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05495813488960266, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1027442067861557, + 0.061773210763931274, + 0.037167567759752274, + 0.037208035588264465, + 0.21637113392353058, + 0.02791893668472767, + 0.11458974331617355, + 0.19024710357189178, + 0.06080128252506256, + 0.1511787474155426 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05495813488960266 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_5/index_tensor([457, 457])_group_5_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_5/index_tensor([457, 457])_group_5_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..fa2f769d47c54b740707f17dcba960cdcc73e5fc --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_5/index_tensor([457, 457])_group_5_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "slow, long shot, moving forward, captures a tranquil and poetic scene in a nostalgic, retro style: in an ancient lakeside pavilion, a woman dressed in classical attire kneels on an intricately woven cushion. She wears an elegant turquoise silk Hanfu (Chinese traditional dress), its wide sleeves embroidered with delicate silver lotus patterns that flow gently with her slight movements. Her long, jet-black hair is elegantly tied up with a simple wooden hairpin, with strands falling across her fair face. Her profile appears remarkably serene in the soft light. She is absorbed in stroking a guqin (a Chinese zither) at her knees, its deep, warm wood sculpted into a rhythmic rhythm. Her slender fingers gracefully press, glide, pluck, and pick at the strings with a steady and deliberate rhythm, each subtle movement imbued with concentration and emotion. The entire scene is bathed in the soft, diffuse light of an overcast afternoon, devoid of distinct shadows, creating a hazy beauty. The main colors of the picture are low-saturation blue, gray and brown, showing a faded film-like texture. The air seems to be filled with a light mist, which together create a distant, quiet and slightly sad nostalgic atmosphere.", + "seed": 4302, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_5/index_457_seed_4302_dp_10_rank_20_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.08392957979813218, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08392957979813218, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.65, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08392957979813218, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a slow, long shot with the camera moving forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a woman wearing a turquoise silk Hanfu with silver lotus embroidery kneeling on a woven cushion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman playing a guqin (Chinese zither) with her fingers pressing and plucking the strings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an ancient lakeside pavilion with a low-saturation blue, gray, and brown color palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the image characterized by a faded film-like texture and a hazy atmosphere with light mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.35555341839790344 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.230553388595581 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.35555341839790344, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.35555341839790344, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14699813723564148, + 0.056905459612607956, + 0.08577980846166611, + 0.07515886425971985, + 0.033582303673028946, + 0.06867599487304688, + 0.29890748858451843, + 0.07620052993297577, + 0.06459564715623856, + 0.09319576621055603 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.35555341839790344 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a slow, long shot with the camera moving forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a woman wearing a turquoise silk Hanfu with silver lotus embroidery kneeling on a woven cushion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman playing a guqin (Chinese zither) with her fingers pressing and plucking the strings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an ancient lakeside pavilion with a low-saturation blue, gray, and brown color palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the image characterized by a faded film-like texture and a hazy atmosphere with light mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023314278572797775 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7733142375946045 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023314278572797775, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023314278572797775, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2490645796060562, + 0.05994555354118347, + 0.097567118704319, + 0.07376036792993546, + 0.051200516521930695, + 0.07654372602701187, + 0.17849190533161163, + 0.08589351922273636, + 0.027184555307030678, + 0.10034818947315216 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023314278572797775 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a slow, long shot with the camera moving forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a woman wearing a turquoise silk Hanfu with silver lotus embroidery kneeling on a woven cushion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman playing a guqin (Chinese zither) with her fingers pressing and plucking the strings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an ancient lakeside pavilion with a low-saturation blue, gray, and brown color palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the image characterized by a faded film-like texture and a hazy atmosphere with light mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02636372670531273 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513636112213135 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02636372670531273, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02636372670531273, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.30109903216362, + 0.20887763798236847, + 0.08735645562410355, + 0.035694364458322525, + 0.04096904769539833, + 0.07038508355617523, + 0.12091127783060074, + 0.019837552681565285, + 0.030080165714025497, + 0.08478941768407822 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02636372670531273 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a slow, long shot with the camera moving forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a woman wearing a turquoise silk Hanfu with silver lotus embroidery kneeling on a woven cushion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman playing a guqin (Chinese zither) with her fingers pressing and plucking the strings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an ancient lakeside pavilion with a low-saturation blue, gray, and brown color palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the image characterized by a faded film-like texture and a hazy atmosphere with light mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004635422024875879 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379635334014893 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004635422024875879, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004635422024875879, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2853561341762543, + 0.055856168270111084, + 0.06582113355398178, + 0.04906681180000305, + 0.16229119896888733, + 0.04745834693312645, + 0.11132228374481201, + 0.09239791333675385, + 0.03168543800711632, + 0.09874455630779266 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004635422024875879 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a slow, long shot with the camera moving forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a woman wearing a turquoise silk Hanfu with silver lotus embroidery kneeling on a woven cushion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman playing a guqin (Chinese zither) with her fingers pressing and plucking the strings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an ancient lakeside pavilion with a low-saturation blue, gray, and brown color palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the image characterized by a faded film-like texture and a hazy atmosphere with light mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00978105328977108 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.6347808837890625 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00978105328977108, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00978105328977108, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25971102714538574, + 0.051420532166957855, + 0.04061561077833176, + 0.06147424504160881, + 0.10491618514060974, + 0.049776144325733185, + 0.20311371982097626, + 0.12518493831157684, + 0.024737589061260223, + 0.07905001193284988 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00978105328977108 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow, long shot, moving forward, captures a tranquil and poetic scene in a nostalgic, retro style: in an ancient lakeside pavilion, a woman dressed in classical attire kneels on an intricately woven cushion. She wears an elegant turquoise silk Hanfu (Chinese traditional dress), its wide sleeves embroidered with delicate silver lotus patterns that flow gently with her slight movements. Her long, jet-black hair is elegantly tied up with a simple wooden hairpin, with strands falling across her fair face. Her profile appears remarkably serene in the soft light. She is absorbed in stroking a guqin (a Chinese zither) at her knees, its deep, warm wood sculpted into a rhythmic rhythm. Her slender fingers gracefully press, glide, pluck, and pick at the strings with a steady and deliberate rhythm, each subtle movement imbued with concentration and emotion. The entire scene is bathed in the soft, diffuse light of an overcast afternoon, devoid of distinct shadows, creating a hazy beauty. The main colors of the picture are low-saturation blue, gray and brown, showing a faded film-like texture. The air seems to be filled with a light mist, which together create a distant, quiet and slightly sad nostalgic atmosphere.", + "seed": 4303, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_5/index_457_seed_4303_dp_10_rank_20_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.07808073880150915, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07808073880150915, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.124999988079071, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07808073880150915, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a slow, long shot with the camera moving forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a woman wearing a turquoise silk Hanfu with silver lotus embroidery kneeling on a woven cushion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman playing a guqin (Chinese zither) with her fingers pressing and plucking the strings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an ancient lakeside pavilion with a low-saturation blue, gray, and brown color palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the image characterized by a faded film-like texture and a hazy atmosphere with light mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.35345250368118286 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.228452444076538 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.35345250368118286, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.8749999403953552, + "token_credit_reward": -0.35345250368118286, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24692924320697784, + 0.0593586340546608, + 0.04116759076714516, + 0.053664520382881165, + 0.16597968339920044, + 0.07806561142206192, + 0.048000022768974304, + 0.061418935656547546, + 0.15119493007659912, + 0.09422088414430618 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.35345250368118286 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a slow, long shot with the camera moving forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a woman wearing a turquoise silk Hanfu with silver lotus embroidery kneeling on a woven cushion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman playing a guqin (Chinese zither) with her fingers pressing and plucking the strings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an ancient lakeside pavilion with a low-saturation blue, gray, and brown color palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the image characterized by a faded film-like texture and a hazy atmosphere with light mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008656359277665615 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.7586565017700195 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008656359277665615, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008656359277665615, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.29886481165885925, + 0.10235138982534409, + 0.07059533149003983, + 0.08282168954610825, + 0.1516115665435791, + 0.02587985061109066, + 0.04498646408319473, + 0.04318717122077942, + 0.08967327326536179, + 0.09002836048603058 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008656359277665615 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a slow, long shot with the camera moving forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a woman wearing a turquoise silk Hanfu with silver lotus embroidery kneeling on a woven cushion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman playing a guqin (Chinese zither) with her fingers pressing and plucking the strings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an ancient lakeside pavilion with a low-saturation blue, gray, and brown color palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the image characterized by a faded film-like texture and a hazy atmosphere with light mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02059129998087883 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955912590026855 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02059129998087883, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02059129998087883, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2620626986026764, + 0.058751679956912994, + 0.09088361263275146, + 0.09565502405166626, + 0.2451765388250351, + 0.03444330766797066, + 0.03467102348804474, + 0.03449565917253494, + 0.07715904712677002, + 0.06670137494802475 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02059129998087883 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a slow, long shot with the camera moving forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a woman wearing a turquoise silk Hanfu with silver lotus embroidery kneeling on a woven cushion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman playing a guqin (Chinese zither) with her fingers pressing and plucking the strings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an ancient lakeside pavilion with a low-saturation blue, gray, and brown color palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the image characterized by a faded film-like texture and a hazy atmosphere with light mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00361218536272645 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628612041473389 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00361218536272645, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00361218536272645, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3005845248699188, + 0.06656306982040405, + 0.04919150099158287, + 0.05048742890357971, + 0.0396893285214901, + 0.04714175686240196, + 0.07388745248317719, + 0.10559972375631332, + 0.15678037703037262, + 0.11007482558488846 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00361218536272645 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a slow, long shot with the camera moving forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a woman wearing a turquoise silk Hanfu with silver lotus embroidery kneeling on a woven cushion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman playing a guqin (Chinese zither) with her fingers pressing and plucking the strings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an ancient lakeside pavilion with a low-saturation blue, gray, and brown color palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the image characterized by a faded film-like texture and a hazy atmosphere with light mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004091345705091953 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504091262817383 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004091345705091953, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004091345705091953, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12256433069705963, + 0.05883476138114929, + 0.06506900489330292, + 0.04984685033559799, + 0.04376832768321037, + 0.07490892708301544, + 0.12236861884593964, + 0.1866011768579483, + 0.22312898933887482, + 0.05290903151035309 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004091345705091953 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow, long shot, moving forward, captures a tranquil and poetic scene in a nostalgic, retro style: in an ancient lakeside pavilion, a woman dressed in classical attire kneels on an intricately woven cushion. She wears an elegant turquoise silk Hanfu (Chinese traditional dress), its wide sleeves embroidered with delicate silver lotus patterns that flow gently with her slight movements. Her long, jet-black hair is elegantly tied up with a simple wooden hairpin, with strands falling across her fair face. Her profile appears remarkably serene in the soft light. She is absorbed in stroking a guqin (a Chinese zither) at her knees, its deep, warm wood sculpted into a rhythmic rhythm. Her slender fingers gracefully press, glide, pluck, and pick at the strings with a steady and deliberate rhythm, each subtle movement imbued with concentration and emotion. The entire scene is bathed in the soft, diffuse light of an overcast afternoon, devoid of distinct shadows, creating a hazy beauty. The main colors of the picture are low-saturation blue, gray and brown, showing a faded film-like texture. The air seems to be filled with a light mist, which together create a distant, quiet and slightly sad nostalgic atmosphere.", + "seed": 4304, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_5/index_457_seed_4304_dp_11_rank_22_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.18978660115972162, + "vlm_logprob": -0.18978660115972162, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.625, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.18978660115972162, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a slow, long shot with the camera moving forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a woman wearing a turquoise silk Hanfu with silver lotus embroidery kneeling on a woven cushion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman playing a guqin (Chinese zither) with her fingers pressing and plucking the strings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an ancient lakeside pavilion with a low-saturation blue, gray, and brown color palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the image characterized by a faded film-like texture and a hazy atmosphere with light mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9049437642097473 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5299437642097473 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.9049437642097473, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.9049437642097473, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04539932310581207, + 0.01688264310359955, + 0.009908112697303295, + 0.024466505274176598, + 0.014859220013022423, + 0.8389405012130737, + 0.03052765689790249, + 0.0052431984804570675, + 0.006149980705231428, + 0.007622819393873215 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.9049437642097473 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a slow, long shot with the camera moving forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a woman wearing a turquoise silk Hanfu with silver lotus embroidery kneeling on a woven cushion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman playing a guqin (Chinese zither) with her fingers pressing and plucking the strings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an ancient lakeside pavilion with a low-saturation blue, gray, and brown color palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the image characterized by a faded film-like texture and a hazy atmosphere with light mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02061874233186245 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8956186771392822 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02061874233186245, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02061874233186245, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10793504118919373, + 0.08047611266374588, + 0.036525554955005646, + 0.04535190388560295, + 0.0384845994412899, + 0.60964435338974, + 0.0232306569814682, + 0.025273708626627922, + 0.01415681466460228, + 0.018921231850981712 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02061874233186245 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a slow, long shot with the camera moving forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a woman wearing a turquoise silk Hanfu with silver lotus embroidery kneeling on a woven cushion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman playing a guqin (Chinese zither) with her fingers pressing and plucking the strings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an ancient lakeside pavilion with a low-saturation blue, gray, and brown color palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the image characterized by a faded film-like texture and a hazy atmosphere with light mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009794038720428944 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634794235229492 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009794038720428944, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009794038720428944, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1532408744096756, + 0.0981222614645958, + 0.03882910683751106, + 0.08070541173219681, + 0.2628049850463867, + 0.2161586433649063, + 0.03422829881310463, + 0.017040258273482323, + 0.03255101665854454, + 0.06631908565759659 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009794038720428944 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a slow, long shot with the camera moving forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a woman wearing a turquoise silk Hanfu with silver lotus embroidery kneeling on a woven cushion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman playing a guqin (Chinese zither) with her fingers pressing and plucking the strings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an ancient lakeside pavilion with a low-saturation blue, gray, and brown color palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the image characterized by a faded film-like texture and a hazy atmosphere with light mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00762906763702631 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882628917694092 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00762906763702631, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00762906763702631, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12502621114253998, + 0.06417790800333023, + 0.0180172361433506, + 0.013998769223690033, + 0.01216273382306099, + 0.6973894834518433, + 0.039006609469652176, + 0.009796138852834702, + 0.009560344740748405, + 0.01086458284407854 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00762906763702631 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a slow, long shot with the camera moving forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a woman wearing a turquoise silk Hanfu with silver lotus embroidery kneeling on a woven cushion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman playing a guqin (Chinese zither) with her fingers pressing and plucking the strings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an ancient lakeside pavilion with a low-saturation blue, gray, and brown color palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the image characterized by a faded film-like texture and a hazy atmosphere with light mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005947392899543047 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130947589874268 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005947392899543047, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005947392899543047, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08511927723884583, + 0.0793728232383728, + 0.027112148702144623, + 0.08124728500843048, + 0.020889071747660637, + 0.6386131644248962, + 0.028568511828780174, + 0.010586482472717762, + 0.008628098294138908, + 0.019863124936819077 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005947392899543047 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow, long shot, moving forward, captures a tranquil and poetic scene in a nostalgic, retro style: in an ancient lakeside pavilion, a woman dressed in classical attire kneels on an intricately woven cushion. She wears an elegant turquoise silk Hanfu (Chinese traditional dress), its wide sleeves embroidered with delicate silver lotus patterns that flow gently with her slight movements. Her long, jet-black hair is elegantly tied up with a simple wooden hairpin, with strands falling across her fair face. Her profile appears remarkably serene in the soft light. She is absorbed in stroking a guqin (a Chinese zither) at her knees, its deep, warm wood sculpted into a rhythmic rhythm. Her slender fingers gracefully press, glide, pluck, and pick at the strings with a steady and deliberate rhythm, each subtle movement imbued with concentration and emotion. The entire scene is bathed in the soft, diffuse light of an overcast afternoon, devoid of distinct shadows, creating a hazy beauty. The main colors of the picture are low-saturation blue, gray and brown, showing a faded film-like texture. The air seems to be filled with a light mist, which together create a distant, quiet and slightly sad nostalgic atmosphere.", + "seed": 4305, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_5/index_457_seed_4305_dp_11_rank_22_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.09367672107182443, + "vlm_logprob": -0.09367672107182443, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.125, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.09367672107182443, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a slow, long shot with the camera moving forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a woman wearing a turquoise silk Hanfu with silver lotus embroidery kneeling on a woven cushion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman playing a guqin (Chinese zither) with her fingers pressing and plucking the strings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an ancient lakeside pavilion with a low-saturation blue, gray, and brown color palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the image characterized by a faded film-like texture and a hazy atmosphere with light mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4324115216732025 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.057411551475525 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.4324115216732025, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.4324115216732025, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22215861082077026, + 0.08649484813213348, + 0.05561264976859093, + 0.07406705617904663, + 0.06489990651607513, + 0.09240105748176575, + 0.11004751175642014, + 0.08298859745264053, + 0.14663071930408478, + 0.06469904631376266 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.4324115216732025 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a slow, long shot with the camera moving forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a woman wearing a turquoise silk Hanfu with silver lotus embroidery kneeling on a woven cushion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman playing a guqin (Chinese zither) with her fingers pressing and plucking the strings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an ancient lakeside pavilion with a low-saturation blue, gray, and brown color palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the image characterized by a faded film-like texture and a hazy atmosphere with light mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007644683588296175 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.8826446533203125 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007644683588296175, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007644683588296175, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3813869059085846, + 0.10879628360271454, + 0.04546704143285751, + 0.036743368953466415, + 0.060264263302087784, + 0.07403984665870667, + 0.0896659567952156, + 0.047016121447086334, + 0.07121283560991287, + 0.0854073241353035 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007644683588296175 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a slow, long shot with the camera moving forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a woman wearing a turquoise silk Hanfu with silver lotus embroidery kneeling on a woven cushion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman playing a guqin (Chinese zither) with her fingers pressing and plucking the strings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an ancient lakeside pavilion with a low-saturation blue, gray, and brown color palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the image characterized by a faded film-like texture and a hazy atmosphere with light mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020592350512742996 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895592451095581 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020592350512742996, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020592350512742996, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.29226985573768616, + 0.10499725490808487, + 0.06097295507788658, + 0.07396599650382996, + 0.09871770441532135, + 0.1401423066854477, + 0.030133964493870735, + 0.03739640489220619, + 0.097101591527462, + 0.0643019750714302 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020592350512742996 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a slow, long shot with the camera moving forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a woman wearing a turquoise silk Hanfu with silver lotus embroidery kneeling on a woven cushion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman playing a guqin (Chinese zither) with her fingers pressing and plucking the strings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an ancient lakeside pavilion with a low-saturation blue, gray, and brown color palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the image characterized by a faded film-like texture and a hazy atmosphere with light mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002486353972926736 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002486228942871 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002486353972926736, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002486353972926736, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21143153309822083, + 0.12979353964328766, + 0.07294370234012604, + 0.060112979263067245, + 0.10392783582210541, + 0.09039679914712906, + 0.06130872294306755, + 0.0950835794210434, + 0.08852832764387131, + 0.08647297322750092 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002486353972926736 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a slow, long shot with the camera moving forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a woman wearing a turquoise silk Hanfu with silver lotus embroidery kneeling on a woven cushion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman playing a guqin (Chinese zither) with her fingers pressing and plucking the strings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an ancient lakeside pavilion with a low-saturation blue, gray, and brown color palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the image characterized by a faded film-like texture and a hazy atmosphere with light mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005248695611953735 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255248546600342 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005248695611953735, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005248695611953735, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2549712657928467, + 0.11167620122432709, + 0.04924962297081947, + 0.04175639525055885, + 0.12308899313211441, + 0.16227982938289642, + 0.04388751834630966, + 0.05921468883752823, + 0.08293736726045609, + 0.07093805819749832 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005248695611953735 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_6/index_tensor([1178, 1178])_group_6_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_6/index_tensor([1178, 1178])_group_6_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..b3605bf51e868ac2c86bbf5cd3384d0a5ee49c0e --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_6/index_tensor([1178, 1178])_group_6_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "powerful overhead close-up shot places the viewer at the prey's perspective, capturing a breathtaking moment in nature. On the edge of a broad, emerald leaf, rendered translucent by bright natural light, its veins clearly visible, a mantis, its emerald green like a finely sculpted jade, stands poised for action. Its triangular head tilts slightly downward, its enormous compound eyes gleaming with the deep luster of obsidian. Its signature sickle-shaped forelegs, lined with sharp spines, are fully extended, revealing their deadly predatory features and creating a menacing frame for the camera. Suddenly, with a powerful kick of its hind legs, its slender body transforms into a flash of green lightning, launching itself from the leaf with swiftness and determination, hurtling straight towards the camera. As it rapidly zooms in on the screen, the highlights on its smooth exoskeleton and the details of its thin wings become extremely clear. The soft bokeh of the green vegetation in the background further highlights the focus and power of its killing action. The whole scene, with a bright green tone, creates a tense, primitive and dynamic atmosphere.", + "seed": 12370, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_6/index_1178_seed_12370_dp_12_rank_24_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.009227688796818257, + "vlm_logprob": -0.009227688796818257, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.85, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.009227688796818257, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at an overhead close-up angle simulating the prey's perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the mantis standing on the edge of a broad, emerald leaf with visible translucent veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the mantis have emerald green coloring resembling jade, with obsidian-like compound eyes and sickle-shaped forelegs lined with sharp spines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the mantis launch itself from the leaf towards the camera with a powerful kick of its hind legs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly zoom in on the mantis as it approaches, showing clear details of its smooth exoskeleton and thin wings against a soft bokeh background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.015725063160061836 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.640725135803223 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.015725063160061836, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.015725063160061836, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1390770971775055, + 0.06604059040546417, + 0.022866830229759216, + 0.033530332148075104, + 0.21412433683872223, + 0.05376638099551201, + 0.09958167374134064, + 0.05664325878024101, + 0.13036806881427765, + 0.1840014010667801 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.015725063160061836 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at an overhead close-up angle simulating the prey's perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the mantis standing on the edge of a broad, emerald leaf with visible translucent veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the mantis have emerald green coloring resembling jade, with obsidian-like compound eyes and sickle-shaped forelegs lined with sharp spines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the mantis launch itself from the leaf towards the camera with a powerful kick of its hind legs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly zoom in on the mantis as it approaches, showing clear details of its smooth exoskeleton and thin wings against a soft bokeh background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005263518542051315 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255263328552246 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005263518542051315, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005263518542051315, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.160410538315773, + 0.0694785788655281, + 0.0751633495092392, + 0.09651550650596619, + 0.08537240326404572, + 0.09390956908464432, + 0.10120867937803268, + 0.04526349529623985, + 0.09911613166332245, + 0.1735616773366928 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005263518542051315 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at an overhead close-up angle simulating the prey's perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the mantis standing on the edge of a broad, emerald leaf with visible translucent veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the mantis have emerald green coloring resembling jade, with obsidian-like compound eyes and sickle-shaped forelegs lined with sharp spines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the mantis launch itself from the leaf towards the camera with a powerful kick of its hind legs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly zoom in on the mantis as it approaches, showing clear details of its smooth exoskeleton and thin wings against a soft bokeh background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006741044111549854 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006741046905518 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006741044111549854, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006741044111549854, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17303283512592316, + 0.15530399978160858, + 0.022404665127396584, + 0.03362267091870308, + 0.1150585189461708, + 0.05314267799258232, + 0.07782980799674988, + 0.0934528186917305, + 0.1283532679080963, + 0.14779870212078094 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006741044111549854 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at an overhead close-up angle simulating the prey's perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the mantis standing on the edge of a broad, emerald leaf with visible translucent veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the mantis have emerald green coloring resembling jade, with obsidian-like compound eyes and sickle-shaped forelegs lined with sharp spines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the mantis launch itself from the leaf towards the camera with a powerful kick of its hind legs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly zoom in on the mantis as it approaches, showing clear details of its smooth exoskeleton and thin wings against a soft bokeh background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009775505401194096 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634775638580322 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009775505401194096, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009775505401194096, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03572678193449974, + 0.07710874825716019, + 0.0183414313942194, + 0.05623931810259819, + 0.10193042457103729, + 0.02839186042547226, + 0.397878497838974, + 0.07103370130062103, + 0.15562371909618378, + 0.057725485414266586 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009775505401194096 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at an overhead close-up angle simulating the prey's perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the mantis standing on the edge of a broad, emerald leaf with visible translucent veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the mantis have emerald green coloring resembling jade, with obsidian-like compound eyes and sickle-shaped forelegs lined with sharp spines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the mantis launch itself from the leaf towards the camera with a powerful kick of its hind legs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly zoom in on the mantis as it approaches, showing clear details of its smooth exoskeleton and thin wings against a soft bokeh background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00863331276923418 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758633136749268 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00863331276923418, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00863331276923418, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.127747043967247, + 0.1375524252653122, + 0.07243985682725906, + 0.016869476065039635, + 0.029713338240981102, + 0.03799711540341377, + 0.11703269183635712, + 0.0402212031185627, + 0.18567821383476257, + 0.23474866151809692 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00863331276923418 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "powerful overhead close-up shot places the viewer at the prey's perspective, capturing a breathtaking moment in nature. On the edge of a broad, emerald leaf, rendered translucent by bright natural light, its veins clearly visible, a mantis, its emerald green like a finely sculpted jade, stands poised for action. Its triangular head tilts slightly downward, its enormous compound eyes gleaming with the deep luster of obsidian. Its signature sickle-shaped forelegs, lined with sharp spines, are fully extended, revealing their deadly predatory features and creating a menacing frame for the camera. Suddenly, with a powerful kick of its hind legs, its slender body transforms into a flash of green lightning, launching itself from the leaf with swiftness and determination, hurtling straight towards the camera. As it rapidly zooms in on the screen, the highlights on its smooth exoskeleton and the details of its thin wings become extremely clear. The soft bokeh of the green vegetation in the background further highlights the focus and power of its killing action. The whole scene, with a bright green tone, creates a tense, primitive and dynamic atmosphere.", + "seed": 12371, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_6/index_1178_seed_12371_dp_12_rank_24_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.021850389242172242, + "vlm_logprob": -0.021850389242172242, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.099999952316284, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.021850389242172242, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at an overhead close-up angle simulating the prey's perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the mantis standing on the edge of a broad, emerald leaf with visible translucent veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the mantis have emerald green coloring resembling jade, with obsidian-like compound eyes and sickle-shaped forelegs lined with sharp spines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the mantis launch itself from the leaf towards the camera with a powerful kick of its hind legs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly zoom in on the mantis as it approaches, showing clear details of its smooth exoskeleton and thin wings against a soft bokeh background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029259780421853065 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.02925968170166 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029259780421853065, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029259780421853065, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23798617720603943, + 0.10360898077487946, + 0.10501094907522202, + 0.037366919219493866, + 0.1311626434326172, + 0.04106726497411728, + 0.10853315889835358, + 0.024443604052066803, + 0.05908435955643654, + 0.15173593163490295 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029259780421853065 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at an overhead close-up angle simulating the prey's perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the mantis standing on the edge of a broad, emerald leaf with visible translucent veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the mantis have emerald green coloring resembling jade, with obsidian-like compound eyes and sickle-shaped forelegs lined with sharp spines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the mantis launch itself from the leaf towards the camera with a powerful kick of its hind legs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly zoom in on the mantis as it approaches, showing clear details of its smooth exoskeleton and thin wings against a soft bokeh background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007655922323465347 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882656097412109 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007655922323465347, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007655922323465347, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.6228341460227966, + 0.07069101184606552, + 0.05823347344994545, + 0.026058046147227287, + 0.03770860657095909, + 0.0460263192653656, + 0.06023963913321495, + 0.01091323047876358, + 0.02174300141632557, + 0.04555254057049751 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007655922323465347 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at an overhead close-up angle simulating the prey's perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the mantis standing on the edge of a broad, emerald leaf with visible translucent veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the mantis have emerald green coloring resembling jade, with obsidian-like compound eyes and sickle-shaped forelegs lined with sharp spines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the mantis launch itself from the leaf towards the camera with a powerful kick of its hind legs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly zoom in on the mantis as it approaches, showing clear details of its smooth exoskeleton and thin wings against a soft bokeh background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011093251407146454 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.5110931396484375 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011093251407146454, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011093251407146454, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.38219839334487915, + 0.15215590596199036, + 0.12788884341716766, + 0.05433417111635208, + 0.030848773196339607, + 0.037576500326395035, + 0.0401492565870285, + 0.02706768922507763, + 0.031235283240675926, + 0.1165451928973198 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011093251407146454 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at an overhead close-up angle simulating the prey's perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the mantis standing on the edge of a broad, emerald leaf with visible translucent veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the mantis have emerald green coloring resembling jade, with obsidian-like compound eyes and sickle-shaped forelegs lined with sharp spines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the mantis launch itself from the leaf towards the camera with a powerful kick of its hind legs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly zoom in on the mantis as it approaches, showing clear details of its smooth exoskeleton and thin wings against a soft bokeh background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01818484626710415 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018184661865234 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01818484626710415, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01818484626710415, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.361630380153656, + 0.03142175450921059, + 0.0433364063501358, + 0.01928347907960415, + 0.045665524899959564, + 0.12228737026453018, + 0.15066061913967133, + 0.026034686714410782, + 0.10232684016227722, + 0.09735293686389923 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01818484626710415 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at an overhead close-up angle simulating the prey's perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the mantis standing on the edge of a broad, emerald leaf with visible translucent veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the mantis have emerald green coloring resembling jade, with obsidian-like compound eyes and sickle-shaped forelegs lined with sharp spines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the mantis launch itself from the leaf towards the camera with a powerful kick of its hind legs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly zoom in on the mantis as it approaches, showing clear details of its smooth exoskeleton and thin wings against a soft bokeh background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04305814579129219 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168058156967163 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04305814579129219, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04305814579129219, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.26621752977371216, + 0.04240621626377106, + 0.020642288029193878, + 0.04090788960456848, + 0.06197226420044899, + 0.10260992497205734, + 0.27032020688056946, + 0.012694125063717365, + 0.062356822192668915, + 0.11987273395061493 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04305814579129219 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "powerful overhead close-up shot places the viewer at the prey's perspective, capturing a breathtaking moment in nature. On the edge of a broad, emerald leaf, rendered translucent by bright natural light, its veins clearly visible, a mantis, its emerald green like a finely sculpted jade, stands poised for action. Its triangular head tilts slightly downward, its enormous compound eyes gleaming with the deep luster of obsidian. Its signature sickle-shaped forelegs, lined with sharp spines, are fully extended, revealing their deadly predatory features and creating a menacing frame for the camera. Suddenly, with a powerful kick of its hind legs, its slender body transforms into a flash of green lightning, launching itself from the leaf with swiftness and determination, hurtling straight towards the camera. As it rapidly zooms in on the screen, the highlights on its smooth exoskeleton and the details of its thin wings become extremely clear. The soft bokeh of the green vegetation in the background further highlights the focus and power of its killing action. The whole scene, with a bright green tone, creates a tense, primitive and dynamic atmosphere.", + "seed": 12372, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_6/index_1178_seed_12372_dp_13_rank_26_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.01181201976723969, + "vlm_logprob": -0.01181201976723969, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.775, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.01181201976723969, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at an overhead close-up angle simulating the prey's perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the mantis standing on the edge of a broad, emerald leaf with visible translucent veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the mantis have emerald green coloring resembling jade, with obsidian-like compound eyes and sickle-shaped forelegs lined with sharp spines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the mantis launch itself from the leaf towards the camera with a powerful kick of its hind legs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly zoom in on the mantis as it approaches, showing clear details of its smooth exoskeleton and thin wings against a soft bokeh background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01518393587321043 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.515183925628662 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01518393587321043, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01518393587321043, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04709535464644432, + 0.019545530900359154, + 0.07503243535757065, + 0.07755418121814728, + 0.05254357308149338, + 0.029599221423268318, + 0.37155160307884216, + 0.1438993662595749, + 0.11363022029399872, + 0.06954853981733322 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01518393587321043 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at an overhead close-up angle simulating the prey's perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the mantis standing on the edge of a broad, emerald leaf with visible translucent veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the mantis have emerald green coloring resembling jade, with obsidian-like compound eyes and sickle-shaped forelegs lined with sharp spines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the mantis launch itself from the leaf towards the camera with a powerful kick of its hind legs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly zoom in on the mantis as it approaches, showing clear details of its smooth exoskeleton and thin wings against a soft bokeh background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003634990891441703 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628634929656982 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003634990891441703, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003634990891441703, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09040401130914688, + 0.042434778064489365, + 0.19908957183361053, + 0.1585155874490738, + 0.08614278584718704, + 0.03893004730343819, + 0.03244355693459511, + 0.20002318918704987, + 0.08360657840967178, + 0.06840978562831879 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003634990891441703 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at an overhead close-up angle simulating the prey's perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the mantis standing on the edge of a broad, emerald leaf with visible translucent veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the mantis have emerald green coloring resembling jade, with obsidian-like compound eyes and sickle-shaped forelegs lined with sharp spines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the mantis launch itself from the leaf towards the camera with a powerful kick of its hind legs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly zoom in on the mantis as it approaches, showing clear details of its smooth exoskeleton and thin wings against a soft bokeh background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009800177067518234 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634799957275391 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009800177067518234, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009800177067518234, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07553573697805405, + 0.031633082777261734, + 0.10403702408075333, + 0.2099878340959549, + 0.0311374943703413, + 0.029454516246914864, + 0.03235859051346779, + 0.25917112827301025, + 0.11977904289960861, + 0.1069054827094078 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 3, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009800177067518234 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at an overhead close-up angle simulating the prey's perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the mantis standing on the edge of a broad, emerald leaf with visible translucent veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the mantis have emerald green coloring resembling jade, with obsidian-like compound eyes and sickle-shaped forelegs lined with sharp spines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the mantis launch itself from the leaf towards the camera with a powerful kick of its hind legs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly zoom in on the mantis as it approaches, showing clear details of its smooth exoskeleton and thin wings against a soft bokeh background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004095263313502073 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504095077514648 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004095263313502073, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004095263313502073, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04286494478583336, + 0.029677938669919968, + 0.11729986220598221, + 0.024087736383080482, + 0.09406038373708725, + 0.08107137680053711, + 0.18940477073192596, + 0.28653034567832947, + 0.05033639818429947, + 0.08466620743274689 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004095263313502073 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at an overhead close-up angle simulating the prey's perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the mantis standing on the edge of a broad, emerald leaf with visible translucent veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the mantis have emerald green coloring resembling jade, with obsidian-like compound eyes and sickle-shaped forelegs lined with sharp spines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the mantis launch itself from the leaf towards the camera with a powerful kick of its hind legs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly zoom in on the mantis as it approaches, showing clear details of its smooth exoskeleton and thin wings against a soft bokeh background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02634573169052601 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651345729827881 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02634573169052601, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02634573169052601, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.017392007634043694, + 0.014003268443048, + 0.02401304431259632, + 0.018558533862233162, + 0.2513662874698639, + 0.023326527327299118, + 0.13720108568668365, + 0.1660420447587967, + 0.2608637809753418, + 0.08723336458206177 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 4, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02634573169052601 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "powerful overhead close-up shot places the viewer at the prey's perspective, capturing a breathtaking moment in nature. On the edge of a broad, emerald leaf, rendered translucent by bright natural light, its veins clearly visible, a mantis, its emerald green like a finely sculpted jade, stands poised for action. Its triangular head tilts slightly downward, its enormous compound eyes gleaming with the deep luster of obsidian. Its signature sickle-shaped forelegs, lined with sharp spines, are fully extended, revealing their deadly predatory features and creating a menacing frame for the camera. Suddenly, with a powerful kick of its hind legs, its slender body transforms into a flash of green lightning, launching itself from the leaf with swiftness and determination, hurtling straight towards the camera. As it rapidly zooms in on the screen, the highlights on its smooth exoskeleton and the details of its thin wings become extremely clear. The soft bokeh of the green vegetation in the background further highlights the focus and power of its killing action. The whole scene, with a bright green tone, creates a tense, primitive and dynamic atmosphere.", + "seed": 12373, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_6/index_1178_seed_12373_dp_13_rank_26_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.018151378724724054, + "vlm_logprob": -0.018151378724724054, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.275, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.018151378724724054, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at an overhead close-up angle simulating the prey's perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the mantis standing on the edge of a broad, emerald leaf with visible translucent veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the mantis have emerald green coloring resembling jade, with obsidian-like compound eyes and sickle-shaped forelegs lined with sharp spines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the mantis launch itself from the leaf towards the camera with a powerful kick of its hind legs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly zoom in on the mantis as it approaches, showing clear details of its smooth exoskeleton and thin wings against a soft bokeh background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014431857503950596 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.639431953430176 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014431857503950596, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014431857503950596, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21537189185619354, + 0.34077751636505127, + 0.06305377185344696, + 0.02233634516596794, + 0.027673687785863876, + 0.02890849858522415, + 0.035796355456113815, + 0.1717538982629776, + 0.06715965270996094, + 0.02716841921210289 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014431857503950596 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at an overhead close-up angle simulating the prey's perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the mantis standing on the edge of a broad, emerald leaf with visible translucent veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the mantis have emerald green coloring resembling jade, with obsidian-like compound eyes and sickle-shaped forelegs lined with sharp spines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the mantis launch itself from the leaf towards the camera with a powerful kick of its hind legs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly zoom in on the mantis as it approaches, showing clear details of its smooth exoskeleton and thin wings against a soft bokeh background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004112122114747763 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504112243652344 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004112122114747763, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004112122114747763, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19459575414657593, + 0.4636702835559845, + 0.08047507703304291, + 0.02562817931175232, + 0.018850725144147873, + 0.012677164748311043, + 0.020888198167085648, + 0.08934877812862396, + 0.057193394750356674, + 0.036672431975603104 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004112122114747763 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at an overhead close-up angle simulating the prey's perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the mantis standing on the edge of a broad, emerald leaf with visible translucent veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the mantis have emerald green coloring resembling jade, with obsidian-like compound eyes and sickle-shaped forelegs lined with sharp spines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the mantis launch itself from the leaf towards the camera with a powerful kick of its hind legs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly zoom in on the mantis as it approaches, showing clear details of its smooth exoskeleton and thin wings against a soft bokeh background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016080450266599655 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141080379486084 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016080450266599655, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016080450266599655, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18550457060337067, + 0.3851422369480133, + 0.04868553206324577, + 0.013256024569272995, + 0.017127329483628273, + 0.021215826272964478, + 0.04324779659509659, + 0.19091659784317017, + 0.04564444720745087, + 0.049259621649980545 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016080450266599655 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at an overhead close-up angle simulating the prey's perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the mantis standing on the edge of a broad, emerald leaf with visible translucent veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the mantis have emerald green coloring resembling jade, with obsidian-like compound eyes and sickle-shaped forelegs lined with sharp spines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the mantis launch itself from the leaf towards the camera with a powerful kick of its hind legs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly zoom in on the mantis as it approaches, showing clear details of its smooth exoskeleton and thin wings against a soft bokeh background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02979184128344059 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529791831970215 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02979184128344059, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02979184128344059, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09417636692523956, + 0.32072439789772034, + 0.11583338677883148, + 0.024765800684690475, + 0.038637105375528336, + 0.027496611699461937, + 0.1048901155591011, + 0.16188590228557587, + 0.059050656855106354, + 0.052539724856615067 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 7, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02979184128344059 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at an overhead close-up angle simulating the prey's perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the mantis standing on the edge of a broad, emerald leaf with visible translucent veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the mantis have emerald green coloring resembling jade, with obsidian-like compound eyes and sickle-shaped forelegs lined with sharp spines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the mantis launch itself from the leaf towards the camera with a powerful kick of its hind legs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly zoom in on the mantis as it approaches, showing clear details of its smooth exoskeleton and thin wings against a soft bokeh background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026340622454881668 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513407230377197 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026340622454881668, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026340622454881668, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1166573092341423, + 0.3306373953819275, + 0.04908759146928787, + 0.02328350767493248, + 0.049854230135679245, + 0.05537056177854538, + 0.04362259805202484, + 0.20377403497695923, + 0.07389717549085617, + 0.05381559208035469 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026340622454881668 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_7/index_tensor([1567, 1567])_group_7_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_7/index_tensor([1567, 1567])_group_7_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..104b6a8ea88156ef42261d293f84e05c63b5f41d --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_7/index_tensor([1567, 1567])_group_7_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "low-angle, side-on tracking shot, shot in high-speed with a subtle slow-motion effect, follows a sleek, deep chestnut horse at full gallop along a winding dirt path through a tranquil forest. The path is carpeted with a thick blanket of white acacia blossoms, resembling fresh snow. The soft afternoon sun filters through the lush branches of the towering acacia trees on either side, casting dappled shadows on the ground. The horse is muscular and agile, its dark mane and long tail billowing in the wind. Its powerful hooves strike in rhythmic rhythm, each landing with precision and force, whipping up the accumulated white petals on the ground, creating a shower of vibrant, snow-like petals that tumble and dance behind the horse. Sunlight filters through these fluttering petals, making each one appear crystal clear. The entire scene, bathed in warm natural light, exudes a poetic atmosphere of power, freedom, and profound romance.", + "seed": 29388, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_7/index_1567_seed_29388_dp_14_rank_28_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.15064145978540183, + "vlm_logprob": -0.15064145978540183, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.975, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.15064145978540183, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a side-on tracking shot following a deep chestnut horse at full gallop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a winding dirt path through a forest carpeted with white acacia blossoms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the horse have a dark mane and long tail that billow in the wind while striking the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the horse's hooves whip up a shower of white petals that tumble and dance behind it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6174516081809998 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8674516081809998 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.6174516081809998, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.6174516081809998, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09248381108045578, + 0.026243949308991432, + 0.07452140748500824, + 0.015130085870623589, + 0.3712822496891022, + 0.1742052137851715, + 0.04417777061462402, + 0.030488094314932823, + 0.028303777799010277, + 0.14316365122795105 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.6174516081809998 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a side-on tracking shot following a deep chestnut horse at full gallop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a winding dirt path through a forest carpeted with white acacia blossoms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the horse have a dark mane and long tail that billow in the wind while striking the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the horse's hooves whip up a shower of white petals that tumble and dance behind it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07903284579515457 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5790328979492188 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07903284579515457, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07903284579515457, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.037929367274045944, + 0.02068951539695263, + 0.02151397429406643, + 0.0414699949324131, + 0.043410252779722214, + 0.650921106338501, + 0.05644021928310394, + 0.03261131793260574, + 0.03457833454012871, + 0.06043587252497673 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07903284579515457 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a side-on tracking shot following a deep chestnut horse at full gallop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a winding dirt path through a forest carpeted with white acacia blossoms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the horse have a dark mane and long tail that billow in the wind while striking the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the horse's hooves whip up a shower of white petals that tumble and dance behind it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026351187378168106 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513512134552 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026351187378168106, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026351187378168106, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12708018720149994, + 0.02930130623281002, + 0.11821115016937256, + 0.04588069021701813, + 0.373565673828125, + 0.19344300031661987, + 0.01632886938750744, + 0.017247242853045464, + 0.02761598490178585, + 0.051325879991054535 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026351187378168106 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a side-on tracking shot following a deep chestnut horse at full gallop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a winding dirt path through a forest carpeted with white acacia blossoms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the horse have a dark mane and long tail that billow in the wind while striking the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the horse's hooves whip up a shower of white petals that tumble and dance behind it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009792386554181576 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634792327880859 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009792386554181576, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009792386554181576, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05547517165541649, + 0.013395039364695549, + 0.05797288939356804, + 0.019841982051730156, + 0.010579612106084824, + 0.6819543242454529, + 0.0523655042052269, + 0.027292851358652115, + 0.02122596465051174, + 0.05989670753479004 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009792386554181576 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a side-on tracking shot following a deep chestnut horse at full gallop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a winding dirt path through a forest carpeted with white acacia blossoms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the horse have a dark mane and long tail that billow in the wind while striking the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the horse's hooves whip up a shower of white petals that tumble and dance behind it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020579271018505096 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955793380737305 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020579271018505096, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020579271018505096, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05548439547419548, + 0.017798926681280136, + 0.046163786202669144, + 0.023633670061826706, + 0.2906777262687683, + 0.4128170609474182, + 0.03878868743777275, + 0.026841022074222565, + 0.016580544412136078, + 0.07121424376964569 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020579271018505096 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, side-on tracking shot, shot in high-speed with a subtle slow-motion effect, follows a sleek, deep chestnut horse at full gallop along a winding dirt path through a tranquil forest. The path is carpeted with a thick blanket of white acacia blossoms, resembling fresh snow. The soft afternoon sun filters through the lush branches of the towering acacia trees on either side, casting dappled shadows on the ground. The horse is muscular and agile, its dark mane and long tail billowing in the wind. Its powerful hooves strike in rhythmic rhythm, each landing with precision and force, whipping up the accumulated white petals on the ground, creating a shower of vibrant, snow-like petals that tumble and dance behind the horse. Sunlight filters through these fluttering petals, making each one appear crystal clear. The entire scene, bathed in warm natural light, exudes a poetic atmosphere of power, freedom, and profound romance.", + "seed": 29389, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_7/index_1567_seed_29389_dp_14_rank_28_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.22674335725605488, + "vlm_logprob": -0.22674335725605488, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.95, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.22674335725605488, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a side-on tracking shot following a deep chestnut horse at full gallop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a winding dirt path through a forest carpeted with white acacia blossoms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the horse have a dark mane and long tail that billow in the wind while striking the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the horse's hooves whip up a shower of white petals that tumble and dance behind it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.48704835772514343 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1120483875274658 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.48704835772514343, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.48704835772514343, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08862901479005814, + 0.08553754538297653, + 0.04748113453388214, + 0.14982765913009644, + 0.15588213503360748, + 0.028180886059999466, + 0.04595926031470299, + 0.047987863421440125, + 0.2971162796020508, + 0.05339821055531502 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.48704835772514343 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a side-on tracking shot following a deep chestnut horse at full gallop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a winding dirt path through a forest carpeted with white acacia blossoms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the horse have a dark mane and long tail that billow in the wind while striking the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the horse's hooves whip up a shower of white petals that tumble and dance behind it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07006382942199707 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695063829421997 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07006382942199707, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07006382942199707, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07134080678224564, + 0.08578940480947495, + 0.06197260692715645, + 0.11903811246156693, + 0.21785153448581696, + 0.0497426874935627, + 0.19574309885501862, + 0.042741674929857254, + 0.04664120078086853, + 0.1091388687491417 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07006382942199707 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a side-on tracking shot following a deep chestnut horse at full gallop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a winding dirt path through a forest carpeted with white acacia blossoms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the horse have a dark mane and long tail that billow in the wind while striking the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the horse's hooves whip up a shower of white petals that tumble and dance behind it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4289233982563019 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.0539233684539795 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.4289233982563019, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.4289233982563019, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09674645960330963, + 0.056071434170007706, + 0.04864497482776642, + 0.06888776272535324, + 0.4979948401451111, + 0.03218333423137665, + 0.04044928029179573, + 0.043796781450510025, + 0.027558673173189163, + 0.08766645193099976 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.4289233982563019 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a side-on tracking shot following a deep chestnut horse at full gallop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a winding dirt path through a forest carpeted with white acacia blossoms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the horse have a dark mane and long tail that billow in the wind while striking the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the horse's hooves whip up a shower of white petals that tumble and dance behind it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020601341500878334 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895601272583008 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020601341500878334, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020601341500878334, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07470595091581345, + 0.022860094904899597, + 0.03311924263834953, + 0.1898748278617859, + 0.2959303855895996, + 0.05438430234789848, + 0.09459997713565826, + 0.023214681074023247, + 0.06961490213871002, + 0.14169560372829437 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020601341500878334 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a side-on tracking shot following a deep chestnut horse at full gallop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a winding dirt path through a forest carpeted with white acacia blossoms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the horse have a dark mane and long tail that billow in the wind while striking the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the horse's hooves whip up a shower of white petals that tumble and dance behind it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12707985937595367 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.127079963684082 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12707985937595367, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12707985937595367, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06992822140455246, + 0.05601616948843002, + 0.029732445254921913, + 0.15572138130664825, + 0.3769732713699341, + 0.020730141550302505, + 0.03023410588502884, + 0.031929004937410355, + 0.060132984071969986, + 0.16860225796699524 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12707985937595367 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, side-on tracking shot, shot in high-speed with a subtle slow-motion effect, follows a sleek, deep chestnut horse at full gallop along a winding dirt path through a tranquil forest. The path is carpeted with a thick blanket of white acacia blossoms, resembling fresh snow. The soft afternoon sun filters through the lush branches of the towering acacia trees on either side, casting dappled shadows on the ground. The horse is muscular and agile, its dark mane and long tail billowing in the wind. Its powerful hooves strike in rhythmic rhythm, each landing with precision and force, whipping up the accumulated white petals on the ground, creating a shower of vibrant, snow-like petals that tumble and dance behind the horse. Sunlight filters through these fluttering petals, making each one appear crystal clear. The entire scene, bathed in warm natural light, exudes a poetic atmosphere of power, freedom, and profound romance.", + "seed": 29390, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_7/index_1567_seed_29390_dp_15_rank_30_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.15691438969224691, + "vlm_logprob": -0.15691438969224691, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.975, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.15691438969224691, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a side-on tracking shot following a deep chestnut horse at full gallop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a winding dirt path through a forest carpeted with white acacia blossoms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the horse have a dark mane and long tail that billow in the wind while striking the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the horse's hooves whip up a shower of white petals that tumble and dance behind it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6719017028808594 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7969017028808594 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.6719017028808594, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.6719017028808594, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20945005118846893, + 0.12803857028484344, + 0.06621602922677994, + 0.06032128259539604, + 0.1479525864124298, + 0.04785936325788498, + 0.05726815387606621, + 0.07787256687879562, + 0.11026134341955185, + 0.09476006776094437 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.6719017028808594 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a side-on tracking shot following a deep chestnut horse at full gallop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a winding dirt path through a forest carpeted with white acacia blossoms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the horse have a dark mane and long tail that billow in the wind while striking the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the horse's hooves whip up a shower of white petals that tumble and dance behind it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04869440570473671 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048694372177124 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04869440570473671, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04869440570473671, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13520285487174988, + 0.16589422523975372, + 0.06389105319976807, + 0.22075359523296356, + 0.06438710540533066, + 0.025191325694322586, + 0.08847171068191528, + 0.06644238531589508, + 0.06669098138809204, + 0.10307478904724121 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04869440570473671 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a side-on tracking shot following a deep chestnut horse at full gallop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a winding dirt path through a forest carpeted with white acacia blossoms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the horse have a dark mane and long tail that billow in the wind while striking the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the horse's hooves whip up a shower of white petals that tumble and dance behind it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03370478376746178 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4087047576904297 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03370478376746178, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03370478376746178, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2826541066169739, + 0.1620103269815445, + 0.043019961565732956, + 0.03128884732723236, + 0.01654837280511856, + 0.017258647829294205, + 0.04709959030151367, + 0.019443226978182793, + 0.3613003194332123, + 0.01937662996351719 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03370478376746178 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a side-on tracking shot following a deep chestnut horse at full gallop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a winding dirt path through a forest carpeted with white acacia blossoms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the horse have a dark mane and long tail that billow in the wind while striking the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the horse's hooves whip up a shower of white petals that tumble and dance behind it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01607704907655716 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141077041625977 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01607704907655716, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01607704907655716, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17799457907676697, + 0.09275781363248825, + 0.07076428830623627, + 0.1337640881538391, + 0.05214320868253708, + 0.06522354483604431, + 0.035343945026397705, + 0.09869256615638733, + 0.16781118512153625, + 0.10550478845834732 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01607704907655716 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a side-on tracking shot following a deep chestnut horse at full gallop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a winding dirt path through a forest carpeted with white acacia blossoms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the horse have a dark mane and long tail that billow in the wind while striking the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the horse's hooves whip up a shower of white petals that tumble and dance behind it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014194007031619549 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264194011688232 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014194007031619549, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014194007031619549, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19876685738563538, + 0.2105473428964615, + 0.06462566554546356, + 0.27302977442741394, + 0.0383443608880043, + 0.03736773505806923, + 0.026742929592728615, + 0.026338543742895126, + 0.05013606324791908, + 0.07410077750682831 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014194007031619549 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, side-on tracking shot, shot in high-speed with a subtle slow-motion effect, follows a sleek, deep chestnut horse at full gallop along a winding dirt path through a tranquil forest. The path is carpeted with a thick blanket of white acacia blossoms, resembling fresh snow. The soft afternoon sun filters through the lush branches of the towering acacia trees on either side, casting dappled shadows on the ground. The horse is muscular and agile, its dark mane and long tail billowing in the wind. Its powerful hooves strike in rhythmic rhythm, each landing with precision and force, whipping up the accumulated white petals on the ground, creating a shower of vibrant, snow-like petals that tumble and dance behind the horse. Sunlight filters through these fluttering petals, making each one appear crystal clear. The entire scene, bathed in warm natural light, exudes a poetic atmosphere of power, freedom, and profound romance.", + "seed": 29391, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_7/index_1567_seed_29391_dp_15_rank_30_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.13708569295704365, + "vlm_logprob": -0.13708569295704365, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.174999952316284, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.13708569295704365, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a side-on tracking shot following a deep chestnut horse at full gallop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a winding dirt path through a forest carpeted with white acacia blossoms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the horse have a dark mane and long tail that billow in the wind while striking the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the horse's hooves whip up a shower of white petals that tumble and dance behind it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5929315686225891 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9679315686225891 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5929315686225891, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5929315686225891, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11917909234762192, + 0.03795647993683815, + 0.029454633593559265, + 0.13629162311553955, + 0.01830548420548439, + 0.06143961846828461, + 0.2965296804904938, + 0.05490729212760925, + 0.20433349907398224, + 0.04160262271761894 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5929315686225891 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a side-on tracking shot following a deep chestnut horse at full gallop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a winding dirt path through a forest carpeted with white acacia blossoms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the horse have a dark mane and long tail that billow in the wind while striking the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the horse's hooves whip up a shower of white petals that tumble and dance behind it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.038161903619766235 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881619930267334 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.038161903619766235, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.038161903619766235, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09679164737462997, + 0.057071980088949203, + 0.047285739332437515, + 0.0673147514462471, + 0.08457702398300171, + 0.12819239497184753, + 0.2380177080631256, + 0.04156867414712906, + 0.08223239332437515, + 0.15694759786128998 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.038161903619766235 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a side-on tracking shot following a deep chestnut horse at full gallop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a winding dirt path through a forest carpeted with white acacia blossoms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the horse have a dark mane and long tail that billow in the wind while striking the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the horse's hooves whip up a shower of white petals that tumble and dance behind it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01819479651749134 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018194675445557 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01819479651749134, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01819479651749134, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13726434111595154, + 0.06922496855258942, + 0.028954848647117615, + 0.06299854069948196, + 0.056411679834127426, + 0.05381538346409798, + 0.31584492325782776, + 0.19184847176074982, + 0.021318336948752403, + 0.06231849268078804 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01819479651749134 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a side-on tracking shot following a deep chestnut horse at full gallop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a winding dirt path through a forest carpeted with white acacia blossoms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the horse have a dark mane and long tail that billow in the wind while striking the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the horse's hooves whip up a shower of white petals that tumble and dance behind it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009791677817702293 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634791851043701 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009791677817702293, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009791677817702293, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12224456667900085, + 0.04792067036032677, + 0.07146558910608292, + 0.13793648779392242, + 0.07007760554552078, + 0.08720613270998001, + 0.13710205256938934, + 0.09518734365701675, + 0.0778244212269783, + 0.15303513407707214 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 3, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009791677817702293 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a side-on tracking shot following a deep chestnut horse at full gallop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a winding dirt path through a forest carpeted with white acacia blossoms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the horse have a dark mane and long tail that billow in the wind while striking the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the horse's hooves whip up a shower of white petals that tumble and dance behind it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026348518207669258 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.65134859085083 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026348518207669258, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026348518207669258, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10374988615512848, + 0.06480306386947632, + 0.02969050221145153, + 0.027211869135499, + 0.08862371742725372, + 0.06643332540988922, + 0.19506125152111053, + 0.16597233712673187, + 0.10166056454181671, + 0.156793475151062 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026348518207669258 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_8/index_tensor([8455, 8455])_group_8_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_8/index_tensor([8455, 8455])_group_8_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..4ee7eec90242af26f42c83792f97512812b2f5e5 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_8/index_tensor([8455, 8455])_group_8_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "dramatic low-angle wide shot captures the immense scale of a massive, ancient stone bridge spanning a bottomless chasm shrouded in thick, swirling fog. Constructed of massive, moss-covered blocks of black, decomposed granite, the bridge features a series of magnificent Gothic arches that appear as if they have stood for millennia. The camera remains still for a moment, emphasizing the structure's silent majesty, before a deep, resonant groan shatters the stillness. The central arch begins to bow dramatically downward, its perfect curve catastrophically twisted. Cobwebs crack across the stone's surface with terrifying speed, and then, with a deafening roar, the relentless cascade begins. Chunks of stone, some as large as small wheelbarrows, and thick layers of broken mortar break free from the curved arches, raining down and tumbling end over end into the white, ethereal mist below. Dim, diffused light from an unseen, cloudy sky filters through the mist, creating a cool, monochromatic palette of gray and damp earth tones that lends the scene a somber, epic quality. The atmosphere is filled with tense, breathtaking destruction, capturing a powerful and irreversible moment of ancient decay.", + "seed": 990, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_8/index_8455_seed_990_dp_16_rank_32_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.032144661992788315, + "vlm_logprob": -0.032144661992788315, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.6499999523162843, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.032144661992788315, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle wide shot capturing a massive ancient stone bridge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bridge constructed of moss-covered black decomposed granite blocks with Gothic arches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a bottomless chasm shrouded in thick swirling fog below the bridge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the central arch bow downward and twist catastrophically while cobwebs crack across the stone surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do chunks of stone and broken mortar rain down into the mist below the collapsing arch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01687665283679962 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141876697540283 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01687665283679962, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01687665283679962, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14691762626171112, + 0.034851595759391785, + 0.06636293232440948, + 0.0704309269785881, + 0.06391209363937378, + 0.027361789718270302, + 0.06397376954555511, + 0.2580296993255615, + 0.02699115313589573, + 0.24116842448711395 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01687665283679962 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle wide shot capturing a massive ancient stone bridge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bridge constructed of moss-covered black decomposed granite blocks with Gothic arches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a bottomless chasm shrouded in thick swirling fog below the bridge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the central arch bow downward and twist catastrophically while cobwebs crack across the stone surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do chunks of stone and broken mortar rain down into the mist below the collapsing arch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07003781944513321 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695037841796875 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07003781944513321, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07003781944513321, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11631200462579727, + 0.07952326536178589, + 0.026032455265522003, + 0.08501759171485901, + 0.05116445571184158, + 0.06945795565843582, + 0.05492547154426575, + 0.17077209055423737, + 0.021114008501172066, + 0.3256806433200836 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07003781944513321 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle wide shot capturing a massive ancient stone bridge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bridge constructed of moss-covered black decomposed granite blocks with Gothic arches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a bottomless chasm shrouded in thick swirling fog below the bridge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the central arch bow downward and twist catastrophically while cobwebs crack across the stone surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do chunks of stone and broken mortar rain down into the mist below the collapsing arch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012544889003038406 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387545108795166 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012544889003038406, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012544889003038406, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.37995555996894836, + 0.08682134002447128, + 0.045219987630844116, + 0.05576673895120621, + 0.040001362562179565, + 0.043326471000909805, + 0.021192749962210655, + 0.1360076367855072, + 0.05002585053443909, + 0.14168226718902588 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012544889003038406 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle wide shot capturing a massive ancient stone bridge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bridge constructed of moss-covered black decomposed granite blocks with Gothic arches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a bottomless chasm shrouded in thick swirling fog below the bridge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the central arch bow downward and twist catastrophically while cobwebs crack across the stone surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do chunks of stone and broken mortar rain down into the mist below the collapsing arch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.043076761066913605 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168076753616333 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.043076761066913605, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.043076761066913605, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11972325295209885, + 0.06628090888261795, + 0.03957256302237511, + 0.06264108419418335, + 0.028508329764008522, + 0.09545553475618362, + 0.04570522531867027, + 0.24697959423065186, + 0.037154294550418854, + 0.25797921419143677 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.043076761066913605 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle wide shot capturing a massive ancient stone bridge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bridge constructed of moss-covered black decomposed granite blocks with Gothic arches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a bottomless chasm shrouded in thick swirling fog below the bridge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the central arch bow downward and twist catastrophically while cobwebs crack across the stone surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do chunks of stone and broken mortar rain down into the mist below the collapsing arch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018187187612056732 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018187046051025 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018187187612056732, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018187187612056732, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09030900150537491, + 0.11122224479913712, + 0.05764639750123024, + 0.06610111892223358, + 0.047345127910375595, + 0.0747760459780693, + 0.0421876460313797, + 0.2625891864299774, + 0.09070475399494171, + 0.15711840987205505 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018187187612056732 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dramatic low-angle wide shot captures the immense scale of a massive, ancient stone bridge spanning a bottomless chasm shrouded in thick, swirling fog. Constructed of massive, moss-covered blocks of black, decomposed granite, the bridge features a series of magnificent Gothic arches that appear as if they have stood for millennia. The camera remains still for a moment, emphasizing the structure's silent majesty, before a deep, resonant groan shatters the stillness. The central arch begins to bow dramatically downward, its perfect curve catastrophically twisted. Cobwebs crack across the stone's surface with terrifying speed, and then, with a deafening roar, the relentless cascade begins. Chunks of stone, some as large as small wheelbarrows, and thick layers of broken mortar break free from the curved arches, raining down and tumbling end over end into the white, ethereal mist below. Dim, diffused light from an unseen, cloudy sky filters through the mist, creating a cool, monochromatic palette of gray and damp earth tones that lends the scene a somber, epic quality. The atmosphere is filled with tense, breathtaking destruction, capturing a powerful and irreversible moment of ancient decay.", + "seed": 991, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_8/index_8455_seed_991_dp_16_rank_32_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.05254287365823984, + "vlm_logprob": -0.05254287365823984, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.2, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.05254287365823984, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle wide shot capturing a massive ancient stone bridge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bridge constructed of moss-covered black decomposed granite blocks with Gothic arches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a bottomless chasm shrouded in thick swirling fog below the bridge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the central arch bow downward and twist catastrophically while cobwebs crack across the stone surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do chunks of stone and broken mortar rain down into the mist below the collapsing arch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10153163224458694 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.351531744003296 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10153163224458694, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10153163224458694, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21301934123039246, + 0.11321339756250381, + 0.27577391266822815, + 0.06778313964605331, + 0.10136771202087402, + 0.049682311713695526, + 0.026515398174524307, + 0.022026779130101204, + 0.10982813686132431, + 0.02078988216817379 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10153163224458694 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle wide shot capturing a massive ancient stone bridge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bridge constructed of moss-covered black decomposed granite blocks with Gothic arches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a bottomless chasm shrouded in thick swirling fog below the bridge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the central arch bow downward and twist catastrophically while cobwebs crack across the stone surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do chunks of stone and broken mortar rain down into the mist below the collapsing arch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07006294280290604 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950628757476807 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07006294280290604, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07006294280290604, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08912789821624756, + 0.07217961549758911, + 0.4108324944972992, + 0.05717786028981209, + 0.08740061521530151, + 0.09153074771165848, + 0.024946218356490135, + 0.019970471039414406, + 0.05431598052382469, + 0.09251820296049118 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07006294280290604 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle wide shot capturing a massive ancient stone bridge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bridge constructed of moss-covered black decomposed granite blocks with Gothic arches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a bottomless chasm shrouded in thick swirling fog below the bridge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the central arch bow downward and twist catastrophically while cobwebs crack across the stone surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do chunks of stone and broken mortar rain down into the mist below the collapsing arch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026362333446741104 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651362419128418 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026362333446741104, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026362333446741104, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17984738945960999, + 0.06958626955747604, + 0.4762583076953888, + 0.05373838171362877, + 0.10187503695487976, + 0.038761038333177567, + 0.01416282169520855, + 0.01436032634228468, + 0.037650708109140396, + 0.013759655877947807 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026362333446741104 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle wide shot capturing a massive ancient stone bridge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bridge constructed of moss-covered black decomposed granite blocks with Gothic arches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a bottomless chasm shrouded in thick swirling fog below the bridge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the central arch bow downward and twist catastrophically while cobwebs crack across the stone surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do chunks of stone and broken mortar rain down into the mist below the collapsing arch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00979368481785059 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634793758392334 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00979368481785059, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00979368481785059, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.26688075065612793, + 0.058660153299570084, + 0.08635398745536804, + 0.09100352227687836, + 0.09468512237071991, + 0.13095341622829437, + 0.08359253406524658, + 0.042715635150671005, + 0.061315421015024185, + 0.0838395208120346 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00979368481785059 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle wide shot capturing a massive ancient stone bridge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bridge constructed of moss-covered black decomposed granite blocks with Gothic arches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a bottomless chasm shrouded in thick swirling fog below the bridge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the central arch bow downward and twist catastrophically while cobwebs crack across the stone surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do chunks of stone and broken mortar rain down into the mist below the collapsing arch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05496377497911453 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299638271331787 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05496377497911453, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05496377497911453, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15783503651618958, + 0.0853152647614479, + 0.08131750673055649, + 0.10091593116521835, + 0.10884024202823639, + 0.17866180837154388, + 0.088626928627491, + 0.059549469500780106, + 0.08345673978328705, + 0.05548108369112015 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05496377497911453 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dramatic low-angle wide shot captures the immense scale of a massive, ancient stone bridge spanning a bottomless chasm shrouded in thick, swirling fog. Constructed of massive, moss-covered blocks of black, decomposed granite, the bridge features a series of magnificent Gothic arches that appear as if they have stood for millennia. The camera remains still for a moment, emphasizing the structure's silent majesty, before a deep, resonant groan shatters the stillness. The central arch begins to bow dramatically downward, its perfect curve catastrophically twisted. Cobwebs crack across the stone's surface with terrifying speed, and then, with a deafening roar, the relentless cascade begins. Chunks of stone, some as large as small wheelbarrows, and thick layers of broken mortar break free from the curved arches, raining down and tumbling end over end into the white, ethereal mist below. Dim, diffused light from an unseen, cloudy sky filters through the mist, creating a cool, monochromatic palette of gray and damp earth tones that lends the scene a somber, epic quality. The atmosphere is filled with tense, breathtaking destruction, capturing a powerful and irreversible moment of ancient decay.", + "seed": 992, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_8/index_8455_seed_992_dp_17_rank_34_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.024538671225309373, + "vlm_logprob": -0.024538671225309373, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.8, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.024538671225309373, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle wide shot capturing a massive ancient stone bridge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bridge constructed of moss-covered black decomposed granite blocks with Gothic arches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a bottomless chasm shrouded in thick swirling fog below the bridge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the central arch bow downward and twist catastrophically while cobwebs crack across the stone surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do chunks of stone and broken mortar rain down into the mist below the collapsing arch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.019088266417384148 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.019088268280029 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.019088266417384148, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.019088266417384148, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07138334959745407, + 0.04322349280118942, + 0.025309083983302116, + 0.010930130258202553, + 0.15427333116531372, + 0.17847582697868347, + 0.06829043477773666, + 0.2645935118198395, + 0.05066573619842529, + 0.13285505771636963 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.019088266417384148 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle wide shot capturing a massive ancient stone bridge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bridge constructed of moss-covered black decomposed granite blocks with Gothic arches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a bottomless chasm shrouded in thick swirling fog below the bridge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the central arch bow downward and twist catastrophically while cobwebs crack across the stone surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do chunks of stone and broken mortar rain down into the mist below the collapsing arch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.043073106557130814 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680731773376465 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.043073106557130814, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.043073106557130814, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.042631495743989944, + 0.04101620987057686, + 0.02736796997487545, + 0.0279936995357275, + 0.22279107570648193, + 0.0751325860619545, + 0.20050953328609467, + 0.24992255866527557, + 0.03733644261956215, + 0.07529840618371964 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.043073106557130814 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle wide shot capturing a massive ancient stone bridge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bridge constructed of moss-covered black decomposed granite blocks with Gothic arches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a bottomless chasm shrouded in thick swirling fog below the bridge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the central arch bow downward and twist catastrophically while cobwebs crack across the stone surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do chunks of stone and broken mortar rain down into the mist below the collapsing arch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012538060545921326 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387537956237793 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012538060545921326, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012538060545921326, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2597591280937195, + 0.0616159550845623, + 0.018676448613405228, + 0.01601957529783249, + 0.09676190465688705, + 0.16518501937389374, + 0.04575074464082718, + 0.1618366241455078, + 0.0321713387966156, + 0.1422232687473297 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012538060545921326 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle wide shot capturing a massive ancient stone bridge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bridge constructed of moss-covered black decomposed granite blocks with Gothic arches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a bottomless chasm shrouded in thick swirling fog below the bridge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the central arch bow downward and twist catastrophically while cobwebs crack across the stone surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do chunks of stone and broken mortar rain down into the mist below the collapsing arch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029809661209583282 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298097133636475 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029809661209583282, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029809661209583282, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08253492414951324, + 0.03360119089484215, + 0.020123524591326714, + 0.02097606286406517, + 0.16191339492797852, + 0.25182870030403137, + 0.1293463557958603, + 0.12122013419866562, + 0.08347062766551971, + 0.09498504549264908 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029809661209583282 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle wide shot capturing a massive ancient stone bridge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bridge constructed of moss-covered black decomposed granite blocks with Gothic arches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a bottomless chasm shrouded in thick swirling fog below the bridge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the central arch bow downward and twist catastrophically while cobwebs crack across the stone surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do chunks of stone and broken mortar rain down into the mist below the collapsing arch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01818426139652729 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018184185028076 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01818426139652729, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01818426139652729, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04787813872098923, + 0.04090433195233345, + 0.02822919376194477, + 0.025825416669249535, + 0.07739634811878204, + 0.040531206876039505, + 0.32370689511299133, + 0.08973627537488937, + 0.23463919758796692, + 0.09115296602249146 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01818426139652729 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dramatic low-angle wide shot captures the immense scale of a massive, ancient stone bridge spanning a bottomless chasm shrouded in thick, swirling fog. Constructed of massive, moss-covered blocks of black, decomposed granite, the bridge features a series of magnificent Gothic arches that appear as if they have stood for millennia. The camera remains still for a moment, emphasizing the structure's silent majesty, before a deep, resonant groan shatters the stillness. The central arch begins to bow dramatically downward, its perfect curve catastrophically twisted. Cobwebs crack across the stone's surface with terrifying speed, and then, with a deafening roar, the relentless cascade begins. Chunks of stone, some as large as small wheelbarrows, and thick layers of broken mortar break free from the curved arches, raining down and tumbling end over end into the white, ethereal mist below. Dim, diffused light from an unseen, cloudy sky filters through the mist, creating a cool, monochromatic palette of gray and damp earth tones that lends the scene a somber, epic quality. The atmosphere is filled with tense, breathtaking destruction, capturing a powerful and irreversible moment of ancient decay.", + "seed": 993, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_8/index_8455_seed_993_dp_17_rank_34_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.02922317311167717, + "vlm_logprob": -0.02922317311167717, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.825, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.02922317311167717, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle wide shot capturing a massive ancient stone bridge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bridge constructed of moss-covered black decomposed granite blocks with Gothic arches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a bottomless chasm shrouded in thick swirling fog below the bridge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the central arch bow downward and twist catastrophically while cobwebs crack across the stone surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do chunks of stone and broken mortar rain down into the mist below the collapsing arch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016980499029159546 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.1419806480407715 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016980499029159546, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016980499029159546, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3288462460041046, + 0.04485999047756195, + 0.029632769525051117, + 0.029300719499588013, + 0.10120570659637451, + 0.13737085461616516, + 0.0744829848408699, + 0.079513780772686, + 0.11804422736167908, + 0.05674278363585472 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016980499029159546 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle wide shot capturing a massive ancient stone bridge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bridge constructed of moss-covered black decomposed granite blocks with Gothic arches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a bottomless chasm shrouded in thick swirling fog below the bridge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the central arch bow downward and twist catastrophically while cobwebs crack across the stone surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do chunks of stone and broken mortar rain down into the mist below the collapsing arch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07900211215019226 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5790021419525146 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07900211215019226, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07900211215019226, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19081489741802216, + 0.0416557602584362, + 0.02938823215663433, + 0.05122268572449684, + 0.08940906822681427, + 0.16906613111495972, + 0.1284889429807663, + 0.0975043922662735, + 0.11723345518112183, + 0.08521643280982971 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07900211215019226 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle wide shot capturing a massive ancient stone bridge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bridge constructed of moss-covered black decomposed granite blocks with Gothic arches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a bottomless chasm shrouded in thick swirling fog below the bridge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the central arch bow downward and twist catastrophically while cobwebs crack across the stone surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do chunks of stone and broken mortar rain down into the mist below the collapsing arch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008640522137284279 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758640289306641 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008640522137284279, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008640522137284279, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16871799528598785, + 0.05753947049379349, + 0.019700488075613976, + 0.04576292261481285, + 0.15838000178337097, + 0.11448892205953598, + 0.06001801788806915, + 0.14068856835365295, + 0.10629572719335556, + 0.12840794026851654 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008640522137284279 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle wide shot capturing a massive ancient stone bridge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bridge constructed of moss-covered black decomposed granite blocks with Gothic arches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a bottomless chasm shrouded in thick swirling fog below the bridge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the central arch bow downward and twist catastrophically while cobwebs crack across the stone surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do chunks of stone and broken mortar rain down into the mist below the collapsing arch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023305194452404976 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7733051776885986 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023305194452404976, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023305194452404976, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21993495523929596, + 0.021632783114910126, + 0.017959626391530037, + 0.03845813125371933, + 0.055601637810468674, + 0.062212809920310974, + 0.2597149908542633, + 0.11481591314077377, + 0.10479478538036346, + 0.1048743724822998 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023305194452404976 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle wide shot capturing a massive ancient stone bridge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bridge constructed of moss-covered black decomposed granite blocks with Gothic arches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a bottomless chasm shrouded in thick swirling fog below the bridge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the central arch bow downward and twist catastrophically while cobwebs crack across the stone surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do chunks of stone and broken mortar rain down into the mist below the collapsing arch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018187537789344788 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018187522888184 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018187537789344788, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018187537789344788, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19715650379657745, + 0.03533194586634636, + 0.037825241684913635, + 0.05450201779603958, + 0.10356928408145905, + 0.0598587691783905, + 0.17218522727489471, + 0.04584677144885063, + 0.07241134345531464, + 0.22131288051605225 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018187537789344788 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_9/index_tensor([1851, 1851])_group_9_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_9/index_tensor([1851, 1851])_group_9_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..b99276c7797d7570a0af3d53ca4eb0e94a517f77 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_9/index_tensor([1851, 1851])_group_9_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "surreal, eye-level handheld shot transports the viewer directly into the heart of a dense thicket of Yunnan camphor trees as a strong wind blows through. The camera, whipped violently by the gusts, its frame wobbles with brief, jarring jolts and erratic drifts, perfectly capturing the struggle to maintain stability amid the fury of the storm. Beneath a cool, overcast sky, an entire tangle of slender, vibrant green stems, their smooth surfaces glistening with moisture, sway violently. They whip and flap uncontrollably in the turbulent air, bending to near breaking point before springing back and colliding with sharp, leaping clicks. A deafening, chaotic roar fills the audio space as countless lance-shaped leaves rustle, many ripped from their stems and transformed into a frantic blur of green confetti swept into the wind. The scene is a claustrophobic maelstrom of movement, creating a raw and deeply immersive atmosphere that conveys the untamed and overwhelming power of nature.", + "seed": 27956, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_9/index_1851_seed_27956_dp_18_rank_36_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.38859953805804254, + "vlm_logprob": -0.38859953805804254, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.3, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.38859953805804254, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the main subjects slender, vibrant green stems with smooth, moisture-glistening surfaces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the stems sway violently, bend to near breaking point, and spring back with sharp, leaping clicks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are lance-shaped leaves visible as a frantic blur of green confetti swept by the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot handheld with a frame that wobbles with brief, jarring jolts and erratic drifts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky cool and overcast above the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16196902096271515 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9119690656661987 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16196902096271515, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16196902096271515, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08556677401065826, + 0.05030978098511696, + 0.025169681757688522, + 0.26632705330848694, + 0.01625818945467472, + 0.03470468148589134, + 0.02583162859082222, + 0.4307704567909241, + 0.03567110747098923, + 0.029390612617135048 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16196902096271515 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the main subjects slender, vibrant green stems with smooth, moisture-glistening surfaces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the stems sway violently, bend to near breaking point, and spring back with sharp, leaping clicks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are lance-shaped leaves visible as a frantic blur of green confetti swept by the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot handheld with a frame that wobbles with brief, jarring jolts and erratic drifts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky cool and overcast above the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.313432216644287 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3134321868419647 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.313432216644287, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -1.313432216644287, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03966500610113144, + 0.06195521727204323, + 0.021117806434631348, + 0.08829201757907867, + 0.024349112063646317, + 0.2038298100233078, + 0.024308882653713226, + 0.47143182158470154, + 0.0488160215318203, + 0.016234252601861954 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.313432216644287 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the main subjects slender, vibrant green stems with smooth, moisture-glistening surfaces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the stems sway violently, bend to near breaking point, and spring back with sharp, leaping clicks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are lance-shaped leaves visible as a frantic blur of green confetti swept by the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot handheld with a frame that wobbles with brief, jarring jolts and erratic drifts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky cool and overcast above the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06206856295466423 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812068462371826 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06206856295466423, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06206856295466423, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.038794293999671936, + 0.04594855383038521, + 0.026351848617196083, + 0.05026644095778465, + 0.08694726973772049, + 0.12097298353910446, + 0.05618337169289589, + 0.546424925327301, + 0.015002314932644367, + 0.013108027167618275 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06206856295466423 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the main subjects slender, vibrant green stems with smooth, moisture-glistening surfaces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the stems sway violently, bend to near breaking point, and spring back with sharp, leaping clicks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are lance-shaped leaves visible as a frantic blur of green confetti swept by the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot handheld with a frame that wobbles with brief, jarring jolts and erratic drifts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky cool and overcast above the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1799202263355255 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8049201965332031 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1799202263355255, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1799202263355255, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15411773324012756, + 0.0541895367205143, + 0.044062111526727676, + 0.28381121158599854, + 0.07849058508872986, + 0.06043761968612671, + 0.26025840640068054, + 0.026080500334501266, + 0.023294271901249886, + 0.015257975086569786 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1799202263355255 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the main subjects slender, vibrant green stems with smooth, moisture-glistening surfaces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the stems sway violently, bend to near breaking point, and spring back with sharp, leaping clicks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are lance-shaped leaves visible as a frantic blur of green confetti swept by the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot handheld with a frame that wobbles with brief, jarring jolts and erratic drifts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky cool and overcast above the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22560766339302063 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6006076335906982 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.22560766339302063, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.22560766339302063, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05216287449002266, + 0.07024907320737839, + 0.10033176839351654, + 0.11976832896471024, + 0.14692150056362152, + 0.018650146201252937, + 0.02831795997917652, + 0.37411588430404663, + 0.02434169314801693, + 0.06514078378677368 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.22560766339302063 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "surreal, eye-level handheld shot transports the viewer directly into the heart of a dense thicket of Yunnan camphor trees as a strong wind blows through. The camera, whipped violently by the gusts, its frame wobbles with brief, jarring jolts and erratic drifts, perfectly capturing the struggle to maintain stability amid the fury of the storm. Beneath a cool, overcast sky, an entire tangle of slender, vibrant green stems, their smooth surfaces glistening with moisture, sway violently. They whip and flap uncontrollably in the turbulent air, bending to near breaking point before springing back and colliding with sharp, leaping clicks. A deafening, chaotic roar fills the audio space as countless lance-shaped leaves rustle, many ripped from their stems and transformed into a frantic blur of green confetti swept into the wind. The scene is a claustrophobic maelstrom of movement, creating a raw and deeply immersive atmosphere that conveys the untamed and overwhelming power of nature.", + "seed": 27957, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_9/index_1851_seed_27957_dp_18_rank_36_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.5305464044213295, + "vlm_logprob": -0.5305464044213295, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 0.9499999761581421, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.5305464044213295, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the main subjects slender, vibrant green stems with smooth, moisture-glistening surfaces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the stems sway violently, bend to near breaking point, and spring back with sharp, leaping clicks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are lance-shaped leaves visible as a frantic blur of green confetti swept by the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot handheld with a frame that wobbles with brief, jarring jolts and erratic drifts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky cool and overcast above the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1286986619234085 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1286985874176025 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1286986619234085, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.9999998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1286986619234085, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.6992248892784119, + 0.05036766454577446, + 0.048228420317173004, + 0.019670939072966576, + 0.013514384627342224, + 0.03328687325119972, + 0.06562590599060059, + 0.03441857174038887, + 0.02158994786441326, + 0.014072355814278126 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1286986619234085 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the main subjects slender, vibrant green stems with smooth, moisture-glistening surfaces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the stems sway violently, bend to near breaking point, and spring back with sharp, leaping clicks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are lance-shaped leaves visible as a frantic blur of green confetti swept by the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot handheld with a frame that wobbles with brief, jarring jolts and erratic drifts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky cool and overcast above the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.804875373840332 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17987531423568726 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.804875373840332, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -1.804875373840332, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.37525883316993713, + 0.04596709832549095, + 0.05125407874584198, + 0.04988236725330353, + 0.13764433562755585, + 0.1365148425102234, + 0.040673546493053436, + 0.024103354662656784, + 0.040551211684942245, + 0.0981503278017044 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.804875373840332 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the main subjects slender, vibrant green stems with smooth, moisture-glistening surfaces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the stems sway violently, bend to near breaking point, and spring back with sharp, leaping clicks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are lance-shaped leaves visible as a frantic blur of green confetti swept by the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot handheld with a frame that wobbles with brief, jarring jolts and erratic drifts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky cool and overcast above the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08909409493207932 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4640941619873047 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08909409493207932, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08909409493207932, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.44400423765182495, + 0.039048194885253906, + 0.06177050247788429, + 0.07905064523220062, + 0.05503574386239052, + 0.04408305883407593, + 0.09245758503675461, + 0.05657358095049858, + 0.05127371475100517, + 0.076702781021595 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08909409493207932 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the main subjects slender, vibrant green stems with smooth, moisture-glistening surfaces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the stems sway violently, bend to near breaking point, and spring back with sharp, leaping clicks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are lance-shaped leaves visible as a frantic blur of green confetti swept by the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot handheld with a frame that wobbles with brief, jarring jolts and erratic drifts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky cool and overcast above the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.28136274218559265 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.406362771987915 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.28136274218559265, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.28136274218559265, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.512304961681366, + 0.01362149603664875, + 0.035895101726055145, + 0.05990796536207199, + 0.03180403634905815, + 0.029481980949640274, + 0.05838150903582573, + 0.024227898567914963, + 0.1580355316400528, + 0.07633960992097855 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.28136274218559265 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the main subjects slender, vibrant green stems with smooth, moisture-glistening surfaces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the stems sway violently, bend to near breaking point, and spring back with sharp, leaping clicks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are lance-shaped leaves visible as a frantic blur of green confetti swept by the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot handheld with a frame that wobbles with brief, jarring jolts and erratic drifts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky cool and overcast above the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.348701149225235 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2237011194229126 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.348701149225235, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.348701149225235, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.301841139793396, + 0.02680889517068863, + 0.08537939190864563, + 0.02673271857202053, + 0.06951258331537247, + 0.06617379933595657, + 0.12645013630390167, + 0.022014150395989418, + 0.24074554443359375, + 0.03434154763817787 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.348701149225235 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "surreal, eye-level handheld shot transports the viewer directly into the heart of a dense thicket of Yunnan camphor trees as a strong wind blows through. The camera, whipped violently by the gusts, its frame wobbles with brief, jarring jolts and erratic drifts, perfectly capturing the struggle to maintain stability amid the fury of the storm. Beneath a cool, overcast sky, an entire tangle of slender, vibrant green stems, their smooth surfaces glistening with moisture, sway violently. They whip and flap uncontrollably in the turbulent air, bending to near breaking point before springing back and colliding with sharp, leaping clicks. A deafening, chaotic roar fills the audio space as countless lance-shaped leaves rustle, many ripped from their stems and transformed into a frantic blur of green confetti swept into the wind. The scene is a claustrophobic maelstrom of movement, creating a raw and deeply immersive atmosphere that conveys the untamed and overwhelming power of nature.", + "seed": 27958, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_9/index_1851_seed_27958_dp_19_rank_38_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.4611687853932381, + "vlm_logprob": -0.4611687853932381, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.15, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.4611687853932381, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the main subjects slender, vibrant green stems with smooth, moisture-glistening surfaces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the stems sway violently, bend to near breaking point, and spring back with sharp, leaping clicks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are lance-shaped leaves visible as a frantic blur of green confetti swept by the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot handheld with a frame that wobbles with brief, jarring jolts and erratic drifts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky cool and overcast above the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07118851691484451 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.696188449859619 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07118851691484451, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07118851691484451, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3337457776069641, + 0.14869581162929535, + 0.05516369268298149, + 0.05215463787317276, + 0.0681726485490799, + 0.04371199384331703, + 0.028519049286842346, + 0.04891626536846161, + 0.056093405932188034, + 0.16482675075531006 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07118851691484451 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the main subjects slender, vibrant green stems with smooth, moisture-glistening surfaces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the stems sway violently, bend to near breaking point, and spring back with sharp, leaping clicks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are lance-shaped leaves visible as a frantic blur of green confetti swept by the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot handheld with a frame that wobbles with brief, jarring jolts and erratic drifts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky cool and overcast above the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6005630493164062 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22556304931640625 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.6005630493164062, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -1.6005630493164062, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4372853636741638, + 0.10167676955461502, + 0.0504181943833828, + 0.0533604696393013, + 0.06570161134004593, + 0.046153705567121506, + 0.039473164826631546, + 0.10963480174541473, + 0.03537139669060707, + 0.0609244741499424 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.6005630493164062 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the main subjects slender, vibrant green stems with smooth, moisture-glistening surfaces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the stems sway violently, bend to near breaking point, and spring back with sharp, leaping clicks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are lance-shaped leaves visible as a frantic blur of green confetti swept by the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot handheld with a frame that wobbles with brief, jarring jolts and erratic drifts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky cool and overcast above the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12710516154766083 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.127105236053467 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12710516154766083, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12710516154766083, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21472620964050293, + 0.2643376886844635, + 0.06047159433364868, + 0.04598359018564224, + 0.05795174837112427, + 0.02461186796426773, + 0.026716502383351326, + 0.13211175799369812, + 0.03918735310435295, + 0.13390173017978668 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12710516154766083 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the main subjects slender, vibrant green stems with smooth, moisture-glistening surfaces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the stems sway violently, bend to near breaking point, and spring back with sharp, leaping clicks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are lance-shaped leaves visible as a frantic blur of green confetti swept by the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot handheld with a frame that wobbles with brief, jarring jolts and erratic drifts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky cool and overcast above the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2813621163368225 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4063620567321777 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2813621163368225, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2813621163368225, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21815268695354462, + 0.11104893684387207, + 0.06940189749002457, + 0.08374148607254028, + 0.08404432237148285, + 0.05559061840176582, + 0.08505918830633163, + 0.05067424103617668, + 0.11917470395565033, + 0.12311193346977234 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2813621163368225 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the main subjects slender, vibrant green stems with smooth, moisture-glistening surfaces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the stems sway violently, bend to near breaking point, and spring back with sharp, leaping clicks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are lance-shaped leaves visible as a frantic blur of green confetti swept by the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot handheld with a frame that wobbles with brief, jarring jolts and erratic drifts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky cool and overcast above the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22562508285045624 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6006250381469727 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.22562508285045624, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.22562508285045624, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19775547087192535, + 0.19947487115859985, + 0.06340675801038742, + 0.12029226869344711, + 0.24670450389385223, + 0.03222719579935074, + 0.011254212819039822, + 0.03147556632757187, + 0.05893385037779808, + 0.038475316017866135 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.22562508285045624 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "surreal, eye-level handheld shot transports the viewer directly into the heart of a dense thicket of Yunnan camphor trees as a strong wind blows through. The camera, whipped violently by the gusts, its frame wobbles with brief, jarring jolts and erratic drifts, perfectly capturing the struggle to maintain stability amid the fury of the storm. Beneath a cool, overcast sky, an entire tangle of slender, vibrant green stems, their smooth surfaces glistening with moisture, sway violently. They whip and flap uncontrollably in the turbulent air, bending to near breaking point before springing back and colliding with sharp, leaping clicks. A deafening, chaotic roar fills the audio space as countless lance-shaped leaves rustle, many ripped from their stems and transformed into a frantic blur of green confetti swept into the wind. The scene is a claustrophobic maelstrom of movement, creating a raw and deeply immersive atmosphere that conveys the untamed and overwhelming power of nature.", + "seed": 27959, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000033/group_9/index_1851_seed_27959_dp_19_rank_38_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.5420366957783699, + "vlm_logprob": -0.5420366957783699, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.025000023841858, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.5420366957783699, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the main subjects slender, vibrant green stems with smooth, moisture-glistening surfaces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the stems sway violently, bend to near breaking point, and spring back with sharp, leaping clicks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are lance-shaped leaves visible as a frantic blur of green confetti swept by the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot handheld with a frame that wobbles with brief, jarring jolts and erratic drifts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky cool and overcast above the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10161972790956497 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3516197204589844 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10161972790956497, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10161972790956497, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07657717168331146, + 0.14339269697666168, + 0.03169862553477287, + 0.061317652463912964, + 0.07268305122852325, + 0.060826994478702545, + 0.035747189074754715, + 0.43257683515548706, + 0.03831671550869942, + 0.046863049268722534 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10161972790956497 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the main subjects slender, vibrant green stems with smooth, moisture-glistening surfaces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the stems sway violently, bend to near breaking point, and spring back with sharp, leaping clicks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are lance-shaped leaves visible as a frantic blur of green confetti swept by the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot handheld with a frame that wobbles with brief, jarring jolts and erratic drifts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky cool and overcast above the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0177929401397705 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14279301464557648 + ], + "logprob_reward": -2.0177929401397705, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.8749998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -2.0177929401397705, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07123665511608124, + 0.4019806385040283, + 0.03850233554840088, + 0.00958875473588705, + 0.03504256159067154, + 0.03787968307733536, + 0.047257356345653534, + 0.034668173640966415, + 0.3027554750442505, + 0.021088343113660812 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -2.0177929401397705 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the main subjects slender, vibrant green stems with smooth, moisture-glistening surfaces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the stems sway violently, bend to near breaking point, and spring back with sharp, leaping clicks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are lance-shaped leaves visible as a frantic blur of green confetti swept by the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot handheld with a frame that wobbles with brief, jarring jolts and erratic drifts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky cool and overcast above the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11299867928028107 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2379987239837646 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11299867928028107, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11299867928028107, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03456415235996246, + 0.10031744092702866, + 0.01726173236966133, + 0.011506106704473495, + 0.013463077135384083, + 0.06884805113077164, + 0.20452356338500977, + 0.09055648744106293, + 0.4363878667354584, + 0.022571418434381485 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11299867928028107 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the main subjects slender, vibrant green stems with smooth, moisture-glistening surfaces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the stems sway violently, bend to near breaking point, and spring back with sharp, leaping clicks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are lance-shaped leaves visible as a frantic blur of green confetti swept by the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot handheld with a frame that wobbles with brief, jarring jolts and erratic drifts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky cool and overcast above the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.25215446949005127 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5021544694900513 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.25215446949005127, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.25215446949005127, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04552276059985161, + 0.11463965475559235, + 0.04169563204050064, + 0.01579449139535427, + 0.022621726617217064, + 0.03453521803021431, + 0.19788813591003418, + 0.06338747590780258, + 0.43984368443489075, + 0.02407124452292919 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.25215446949005127 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the main subjects slender, vibrant green stems with smooth, moisture-glistening surfaces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the stems sway violently, bend to near breaking point, and spring back with sharp, leaping clicks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are lance-shaped leaves visible as a frantic blur of green confetti swept by the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot handheld with a frame that wobbles with brief, jarring jolts and erratic drifts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky cool and overcast above the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2256176620721817 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6006176471710205 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2256176620721817, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2256176620721817, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11102738231420517, + 0.4134175479412079, + 0.14944329857826233, + 0.01707867719233036, + 0.0742201954126358, + 0.04461121931672096, + 0.05345815047621727, + 0.06439797580242157, + 0.06270091980695724, + 0.009644675068557262 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2256176620721817 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_0/index_tensor([7124, 7124])_group_0_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_0/index_tensor([7124, 7124])_group_0_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..b10ec98627166f03f0d07ddb08dce6ef69147ca1 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_0/index_tensor([7124, 7124])_group_0_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "static close-up shot, shot from a slightly overhead perspective and with a shallow depth of field, focuses sharply on a futuristic electric hot pot. The pot boasts a streamlined, one-piece, matte titanium-gray alloy shell, devoid of unnecessary seams or buttons. A thin blue LED light strip on the side of the pot blinks in a steady, breathing rhythm, indicating its operating status. Illuminated by a soft, yet bright, cool overhead light from directly above, the pot's smooth black nano-coating reflects a faint luminescence, blurring the background into soft patches of light and blurred geometric shapes, suggesting a high-tech laboratory or high-end kitchen. The pot contains a crystal-clear liquid, initially as calm as a mirror. Then, countless tiny bubbles rapidly form at the bottom, rising at an astonishing rate and instantly churning the liquid into a violent, turbulent flow. At the moment the boiling reaches its peak, the liquid in the entire pot seems to be drained by an invisible force, instantly transforming into an extremely thick, boiling white steam. This steam gushes upward violently, filling the entire screen, and its edges show complex curling and dissipation dynamics. Light penetrates it, creating a light and shadow effect with a sense of layering and volume. The entire dynamic process is presented through extremely realistic fluid simulation technology. Every bubble burst and steam curl shows unparalleled realism, creating a focused, high-tech and powerful visual atmosphere.", + "seed": 13630, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_0/index_7124_seed_13630_dp_0_rank_0_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.05693619269877672, + "vlm_logprob": -0.05693619269877672, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.475, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.05693619269877672, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static close-up from a slightly overhead perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hot pot a streamlined, one-piece matte titanium-gray alloy shell without visible seams or buttons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a thin blue LED light strip on the side of the pot blink in a steady, breathing rhythm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the liquid inside the pot transition from calm to violent boiling bubbles and then instantly transform into thick white steam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the steam gush upward violently to fill the entire screen with complex curling and dissipation dynamics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020146619528532028 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.39514684677124 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020146619528532028, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020146619528532028, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.029072673991322517, + 0.021442148834466934, + 0.52766352891922, + 0.04380491375923157, + 0.14500649273395538, + 0.054689448326826096, + 0.030498791486024857, + 0.05110209435224533, + 0.05981753021478653, + 0.03690239042043686 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 4, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020146619528532028 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static close-up from a slightly overhead perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hot pot a streamlined, one-piece matte titanium-gray alloy shell without visible seams or buttons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a thin blue LED light strip on the side of the pot blink in a steady, breathing rhythm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the liquid inside the pot transition from calm to violent boiling bubbles and then instantly transform into thick white steam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the steam gush upward violently to fill the entire screen with complex curling and dissipation dynamics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16038821637630463 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9103882312774658 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16038821637630463, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16038821637630463, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.031244942918419838, + 0.04046411067247391, + 0.7150837779045105, + 0.03049481473863125, + 0.02168429084122181, + 0.013962997123599052, + 0.01822722889482975, + 0.01698971539735794, + 0.04916130751371384, + 0.06268688291311264 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16038821637630463 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static close-up from a slightly overhead perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hot pot a streamlined, one-piece matte titanium-gray alloy shell without visible seams or buttons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a thin blue LED light strip on the side of the pot blink in a steady, breathing rhythm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the liquid inside the pot transition from calm to violent boiling bubbles and then instantly transform into thick white steam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the steam gush upward violently to fill the entire screen with complex curling and dissipation dynamics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.079041987657547 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5790419578552246 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.079041987657547, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.079041987657547, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.042751993983983994, + 0.04469340294599533, + 0.4187428057193756, + 0.0338972732424736, + 0.058864884078502655, + 0.0620233528316021, + 0.05588565394282341, + 0.05035312473773956, + 0.05528349429368973, + 0.17750392854213715 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.079041987657547 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static close-up from a slightly overhead perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hot pot a streamlined, one-piece matte titanium-gray alloy shell without visible seams or buttons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a thin blue LED light strip on the side of the pot blink in a steady, breathing rhythm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the liquid inside the pot transition from calm to violent boiling bubbles and then instantly transform into thick white steam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the steam gush upward violently to fill the entire screen with complex curling and dissipation dynamics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012554659508168697 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.38755464553833 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012554659508168697, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012554659508168697, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07476650923490524, + 0.046733006834983826, + 0.15664663910865784, + 0.047372967004776, + 0.16128338873386383, + 0.027094561606645584, + 0.04786137118935585, + 0.18314220011234283, + 0.1607063263654709, + 0.09439296275377274 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 4, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012554659508168697 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static close-up from a slightly overhead perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hot pot a streamlined, one-piece matte titanium-gray alloy shell without visible seams or buttons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a thin blue LED light strip on the side of the pot blink in a steady, breathing rhythm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the liquid inside the pot transition from calm to violent boiling bubbles and then instantly transform into thick white steam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the steam gush upward violently to fill the entire screen with complex curling and dissipation dynamics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01254948042333126 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.38754940032959 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01254948042333126, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01254948042333126, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.060802798718214035, + 0.02861243672668934, + 0.15700633823871613, + 0.03458629921078682, + 0.026746224611997604, + 0.03515740483999252, + 0.053640447556972504, + 0.09809831529855728, + 0.21670956909656525, + 0.2886401414871216 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01254948042333126 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static close-up shot, shot from a slightly overhead perspective and with a shallow depth of field, focuses sharply on a futuristic electric hot pot. The pot boasts a streamlined, one-piece, matte titanium-gray alloy shell, devoid of unnecessary seams or buttons. A thin blue LED light strip on the side of the pot blinks in a steady, breathing rhythm, indicating its operating status. Illuminated by a soft, yet bright, cool overhead light from directly above, the pot's smooth black nano-coating reflects a faint luminescence, blurring the background into soft patches of light and blurred geometric shapes, suggesting a high-tech laboratory or high-end kitchen. The pot contains a crystal-clear liquid, initially as calm as a mirror. Then, countless tiny bubbles rapidly form at the bottom, rising at an astonishing rate and instantly churning the liquid into a violent, turbulent flow. At the moment the boiling reaches its peak, the liquid in the entire pot seems to be drained by an invisible force, instantly transforming into an extremely thick, boiling white steam. This steam gushes upward violently, filling the entire screen, and its edges show complex curling and dissipation dynamics. Light penetrates it, creating a light and shadow effect with a sense of layering and volume. The entire dynamic process is presented through extremely realistic fluid simulation technology. Every bubble burst and steam curl shows unparalleled realism, creating a focused, high-tech and powerful visual atmosphere.", + "seed": 13631, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_0/index_7124_seed_13631_dp_0_rank_0_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.045025568827986716, + "vlm_logprob": -0.045025568827986716, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.55, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.045025568827986716, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static close-up from a slightly overhead perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hot pot a streamlined, one-piece matte titanium-gray alloy shell without visible seams or buttons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a thin blue LED light strip on the side of the pot blink in a steady, breathing rhythm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the liquid inside the pot transition from calm to violent boiling bubbles and then instantly transform into thick white steam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the steam gush upward violently to fill the entire screen with complex curling and dissipation dynamics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023401621729135513 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.023401737213135 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023401621729135513, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023401621729135513, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09950987249612808, + 0.08268926292657852, + 0.0658935010433197, + 0.1457119733095169, + 0.24999891221523285, + 0.0841328427195549, + 0.0726543590426445, + 0.07919376343488693, + 0.09887563437223434, + 0.021339865401387215 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023401621729135513 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static close-up from a slightly overhead perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hot pot a streamlined, one-piece matte titanium-gray alloy shell without visible seams or buttons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a thin blue LED light strip on the side of the pot blink in a steady, breathing rhythm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the liquid inside the pot transition from calm to violent boiling bubbles and then instantly transform into thick white steam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the steam gush upward violently to fill the entire screen with complex curling and dissipation dynamics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07900717854499817 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.579007148742676 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07900717854499817, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07900717854499817, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.094502292573452, + 0.17812976241111755, + 0.25615692138671875, + 0.08663981407880783, + 0.09324806928634644, + 0.021410152316093445, + 0.10048072785139084, + 0.041832633316516876, + 0.060997337102890015, + 0.06660234183073044 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07900717854499817 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static close-up from a slightly overhead perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hot pot a streamlined, one-piece matte titanium-gray alloy shell without visible seams or buttons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a thin blue LED light strip on the side of the pot blink in a steady, breathing rhythm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the liquid inside the pot transition from calm to violent boiling bubbles and then instantly transform into thick white steam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the steam gush upward violently to fill the entire screen with complex curling and dissipation dynamics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10037965327501297 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.350379705429077 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10037965327501297, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10037965327501297, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.054057009518146515, + 0.05744801461696625, + 0.11986766755580902, + 0.13794440031051636, + 0.24769823253154755, + 0.02981403097510338, + 0.05744612216949463, + 0.09119709581136703, + 0.06658035516738892, + 0.13794709742069244 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10037965327501297 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static close-up from a slightly overhead perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hot pot a streamlined, one-piece matte titanium-gray alloy shell without visible seams or buttons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a thin blue LED light strip on the side of the pot blink in a steady, breathing rhythm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the liquid inside the pot transition from calm to violent boiling bubbles and then instantly transform into thick white steam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the steam gush upward violently to fill the entire screen with complex curling and dissipation dynamics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009791205637156963 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634791374206543 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009791205637156963, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009791205637156963, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07614411413669586, + 0.05363515764474869, + 0.09620869159698486, + 0.08025012165307999, + 0.1304340660572052, + 0.1391071230173111, + 0.08736616373062134, + 0.10683844983577728, + 0.09159006178379059, + 0.1384260356426239 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009791205637156963 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static close-up from a slightly overhead perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hot pot a streamlined, one-piece matte titanium-gray alloy shell without visible seams or buttons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a thin blue LED light strip on the side of the pot blink in a steady, breathing rhythm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the liquid inside the pot transition from calm to violent boiling bubbles and then instantly transform into thick white steam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the steam gush upward violently to fill the entire screen with complex curling and dissipation dynamics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01254818495362997 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387547969818115 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01254818495362997, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01254818495362997, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.061471547931432724, + 0.05139331519603729, + 0.05621101334691048, + 0.10809719562530518, + 0.10955299437046051, + 0.12255468964576721, + 0.11990786343812943, + 0.16829323768615723, + 0.08991266787052155, + 0.11260554194450378 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01254818495362997 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static close-up shot, shot from a slightly overhead perspective and with a shallow depth of field, focuses sharply on a futuristic electric hot pot. The pot boasts a streamlined, one-piece, matte titanium-gray alloy shell, devoid of unnecessary seams or buttons. A thin blue LED light strip on the side of the pot blinks in a steady, breathing rhythm, indicating its operating status. Illuminated by a soft, yet bright, cool overhead light from directly above, the pot's smooth black nano-coating reflects a faint luminescence, blurring the background into soft patches of light and blurred geometric shapes, suggesting a high-tech laboratory or high-end kitchen. The pot contains a crystal-clear liquid, initially as calm as a mirror. Then, countless tiny bubbles rapidly form at the bottom, rising at an astonishing rate and instantly churning the liquid into a violent, turbulent flow. At the moment the boiling reaches its peak, the liquid in the entire pot seems to be drained by an invisible force, instantly transforming into an extremely thick, boiling white steam. This steam gushes upward violently, filling the entire screen, and its edges show complex curling and dissipation dynamics. Light penetrates it, creating a light and shadow effect with a sense of layering and volume. The entire dynamic process is presented through extremely realistic fluid simulation technology. Every bubble burst and steam curl shows unparalleled realism, creating a focused, high-tech and powerful visual atmosphere.", + "seed": 13632, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_0/index_7124_seed_13632_dp_1_rank_2_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.04176215599291026, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04176215599291026, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.15, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04176215599291026, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static close-up from a slightly overhead perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hot pot a streamlined, one-piece matte titanium-gray alloy shell without visible seams or buttons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a thin blue LED light strip on the side of the pot blink in a steady, breathing rhythm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the liquid inside the pot transition from calm to violent boiling bubbles and then instantly transform into thick white steam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the steam gush upward violently to fill the entire screen with complex curling and dissipation dynamics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.013273918069899082 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.5132737159729 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.013273918069899082, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.013273918069899082, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16183048486709595, + 0.08579368889331818, + 0.0514279305934906, + 0.052721962332725525, + 0.2244035005569458, + 0.12743227183818817, + 0.06942205876111984, + 0.05394398421049118, + 0.07684020698070526, + 0.0961839035153389 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.013273918069899082 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static close-up from a slightly overhead perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hot pot a streamlined, one-piece matte titanium-gray alloy shell without visible seams or buttons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a thin blue LED light strip on the side of the pot blink in a steady, breathing rhythm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the liquid inside the pot transition from calm to violent boiling bubbles and then instantly transform into thick white steam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the steam gush upward violently to fill the entire screen with complex curling and dissipation dynamics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10033652186393738 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3503365516662598 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10033652186393738, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10033652186393738, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05170155689120293, + 0.03505074605345726, + 0.020406804978847504, + 0.04396427422761917, + 0.28858980536460876, + 0.05696645751595497, + 0.05226593092083931, + 0.3093715012073517, + 0.06578264385461807, + 0.07590030878782272 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10033652186393738 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static close-up from a slightly overhead perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hot pot a streamlined, one-piece matte titanium-gray alloy shell without visible seams or buttons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a thin blue LED light strip on the side of the pot blink in a steady, breathing rhythm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the liquid inside the pot transition from calm to violent boiling bubbles and then instantly transform into thick white steam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the steam gush upward violently to fill the entire screen with complex curling and dissipation dynamics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08908896893262863 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4640889167785645 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08908896893262863, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08908896893262863, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0291199441999197, + 0.01441109087318182, + 0.01264134980738163, + 0.08505091816186905, + 0.4206547737121582, + 0.061270181089639664, + 0.044989898800849915, + 0.2562022805213928, + 0.04243709519505501, + 0.03322253003716469 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 7, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08908896893262863 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static close-up from a slightly overhead perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hot pot a streamlined, one-piece matte titanium-gray alloy shell without visible seams or buttons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a thin blue LED light strip on the side of the pot blink in a steady, breathing rhythm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the liquid inside the pot transition from calm to violent boiling bubbles and then instantly transform into thick white steam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the steam gush upward violently to fill the entire screen with complex curling and dissipation dynamics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003621806390583515 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628621578216553 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003621806390583515, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003621806390583515, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03458205610513687, + 0.014784279279410839, + 0.007980352267622948, + 0.026834528893232346, + 0.3726598620414734, + 0.03418862447142601, + 0.3366623818874359, + 0.02813750132918358, + 0.10003679990768433, + 0.04413355886936188 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003621806390583515 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static close-up from a slightly overhead perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hot pot a streamlined, one-piece matte titanium-gray alloy shell without visible seams or buttons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a thin blue LED light strip on the side of the pot blink in a steady, breathing rhythm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the liquid inside the pot transition from calm to violent boiling bubbles and then instantly transform into thick white steam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the steam gush upward violently to fill the entire screen with complex curling and dissipation dynamics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0024895647075027227 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.0024895668029785 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0024895647075027227, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0024895647075027227, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04514060914516449, + 0.023771993815898895, + 0.00792797189205885, + 0.020488979294896126, + 0.11605560779571533, + 0.0943511500954628, + 0.15887537598609924, + 0.32194218039512634, + 0.12326630204916, + 0.0881798043847084 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0024895647075027227 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static close-up shot, shot from a slightly overhead perspective and with a shallow depth of field, focuses sharply on a futuristic electric hot pot. The pot boasts a streamlined, one-piece, matte titanium-gray alloy shell, devoid of unnecessary seams or buttons. A thin blue LED light strip on the side of the pot blinks in a steady, breathing rhythm, indicating its operating status. Illuminated by a soft, yet bright, cool overhead light from directly above, the pot's smooth black nano-coating reflects a faint luminescence, blurring the background into soft patches of light and blurred geometric shapes, suggesting a high-tech laboratory or high-end kitchen. The pot contains a crystal-clear liquid, initially as calm as a mirror. Then, countless tiny bubbles rapidly form at the bottom, rising at an astonishing rate and instantly churning the liquid into a violent, turbulent flow. At the moment the boiling reaches its peak, the liquid in the entire pot seems to be drained by an invisible force, instantly transforming into an extremely thick, boiling white steam. This steam gushes upward violently, filling the entire screen, and its edges show complex curling and dissipation dynamics. Light penetrates it, creating a light and shadow effect with a sense of layering and volume. The entire dynamic process is presented through extremely realistic fluid simulation technology. Every bubble burst and steam curl shows unparalleled realism, creating a focused, high-tech and powerful visual atmosphere.", + "seed": 13633, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_0/index_7124_seed_13633_dp_1_rank_2_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.12981054587289692, + "vlm_logprob": -0.12981054587289692, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.1, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.12981054587289692, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static close-up from a slightly overhead perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hot pot a streamlined, one-piece matte titanium-gray alloy shell without visible seams or buttons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a thin blue LED light strip on the side of the pot blink in a steady, breathing rhythm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the liquid inside the pot transition from calm to violent boiling bubbles and then instantly transform into thick white steam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the steam gush upward violently to fill the entire screen with complex curling and dissipation dynamics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03184901922941208 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.781848907470703 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03184901922941208, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03184901922941208, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09590206295251846, + 0.057812076061964035, + 0.06674785912036896, + 0.0899965688586235, + 0.13571611046791077, + 0.05542510002851486, + 0.18102894723415375, + 0.09469778090715408, + 0.0633784681558609, + 0.1592950075864792 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03184901922941208 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static close-up from a slightly overhead perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hot pot a streamlined, one-piece matte titanium-gray alloy shell without visible seams or buttons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a thin blue LED light strip on the side of the pot blink in a steady, breathing rhythm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the liquid inside the pot transition from calm to violent boiling bubbles and then instantly transform into thick white steam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the steam gush upward violently to fill the entire screen with complex curling and dissipation dynamics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.34868577122688293 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2236857414245605 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.34868577122688293, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.34868577122688293, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24856770038604736, + 0.12572850286960602, + 0.08857275545597076, + 0.06631584465503693, + 0.062034185975790024, + 0.0542747937142849, + 0.0660296082496643, + 0.09336293488740921, + 0.1335868090391159, + 0.061526838690042496 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.34868577122688293 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static close-up from a slightly overhead perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hot pot a streamlined, one-piece matte titanium-gray alloy shell without visible seams or buttons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a thin blue LED light strip on the side of the pot blink in a steady, breathing rhythm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the liquid inside the pot transition from calm to violent boiling bubbles and then instantly transform into thick white steam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the steam gush upward violently to fill the entire screen with complex curling and dissipation dynamics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.25222328305244446 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.502223253250122 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.25222328305244446, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.25222328305244446, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3136816918849945, + 0.16081063449382782, + 0.1627587378025055, + 0.06470423936843872, + 0.030274948105216026, + 0.05822642892599106, + 0.035942863672971725, + 0.044255517423152924, + 0.10632313042879105, + 0.02302190102636814 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.25222328305244446 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static close-up from a slightly overhead perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hot pot a streamlined, one-piece matte titanium-gray alloy shell without visible seams or buttons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a thin blue LED light strip on the side of the pot blink in a steady, breathing rhythm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the liquid inside the pot transition from calm to violent boiling bubbles and then instantly transform into thick white steam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the steam gush upward violently to fill the entire screen with complex curling and dissipation dynamics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008655059151351452 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758655071258545 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008655059151351452, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008655059151351452, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0627954751253128, + 0.09687583148479462, + 0.12567926943302155, + 0.05679216608405113, + 0.03711184486746788, + 0.03979872912168503, + 0.023679163306951523, + 0.07070539146661758, + 0.3852696716785431, + 0.10129240900278091 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 2, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008655059151351452 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static close-up from a slightly overhead perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hot pot a streamlined, one-piece matte titanium-gray alloy shell without visible seams or buttons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a thin blue LED light strip on the side of the pot blink in a steady, breathing rhythm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the liquid inside the pot transition from calm to violent boiling bubbles and then instantly transform into thick white steam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the steam gush upward violently to fill the entire screen with complex curling and dissipation dynamics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007639596704393625 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882639408111572 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007639596704393625, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007639596704393625, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08398570865392685, + 0.036095015704631805, + 0.059059470891952515, + 0.04096906632184982, + 0.030574921518564224, + 0.02325984463095665, + 0.031319573521614075, + 0.11234167963266373, + 0.4075809419155121, + 0.17481380701065063 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007639596704393625 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_1/index_tensor([7722, 7722])_group_1_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_1/index_tensor([7722, 7722])_group_1_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..0193350dffb157ff889c9fe77ebde945c8525d1c --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_1/index_tensor([7722, 7722])_group_1_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "At dawn, a slow, steady, and stable 360-degree orbiting drone shot begins, circling a massive, monolithic hydroelectric dam. Composed of weathered gray concrete, punctuated by faint vertical water stains, this massive structure majestically winds its way through a deep gorge. The first rays of sunlight, catching the distant pine-clad mountains, cast a warm golden glow, kissing the top edge of the massive walls, while the lower reaches remain shrouded in a cool blue shade. Below, a powerful spillway relentlessly churns the dark river water into turbulent white foam and powerful whirlpools, from which rises a perpetual, gentle mist. This ethereal mist catches the emerging sunlight, forming a luminous, shimmering veil around the structure's base. The camera's deliberate, sweeping movements highlight the stark contrast between the calm, glassy surface of the vast reservoir, held serenely behind the dam, and the raw, kinetic energy unleashed below, creating an atmosphere of tranquility and focus that conveys the immense, quiet power of this engineering marvel.", + "seed": 22546, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_1/index_7722_seed_22546_dp_2_rank_4_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.32975127357058226, + "vlm_logprob": -0.32975127357058226, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.825, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.32975127357058226, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a slow, steady, 360-degree orbiting shot around the dam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the dam constructed of weathered gray concrete with faint vertical water stains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show the dam winding through a deep gorge with pine-clad mountains in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by warm golden sunlight on the top edges and cool blue shades on the lower reaches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a powerful spillway churning dark river water into turbulent white foam and a rising mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3162096738815308 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3162096440792084 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.3162096738815308, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -1.3162096738815308, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17327363789081573, + 0.11143432557582855, + 0.11452118307352066, + 0.09945600479841232, + 0.10989604145288467, + 0.04808977618813515, + 0.06410615146160126, + 0.07146330177783966, + 0.10414216667413712, + 0.10361739248037338 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.3162096738815308 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a slow, steady, 360-degree orbiting shot around the dam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the dam constructed of weathered gray concrete with faint vertical water stains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show the dam winding through a deep gorge with pine-clad mountains in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by warm golden sunlight on the top edges and cool blue shades on the lower reaches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a powerful spillway churning dark river water into turbulent white foam and a rising mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10035194456577301 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3503520488739014 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10035194456577301, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10035194456577301, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15140296518802643, + 0.14633040130138397, + 0.10556208342313766, + 0.09394128620624542, + 0.1468399614095688, + 0.1343088448047638, + 0.0502399280667305, + 0.04650452733039856, + 0.035062454640865326, + 0.08980754017829895 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10035194456577301 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a slow, steady, 360-degree orbiting shot around the dam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the dam constructed of weathered gray concrete with faint vertical water stains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show the dam winding through a deep gorge with pine-clad mountains in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by warm golden sunlight on the top edges and cool blue shades on the lower reaches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a powerful spillway churning dark river water into turbulent white foam and a rising mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2256048172712326 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.600604772567749 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2256048172712326, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2256048172712326, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11961524188518524, + 0.1167772188782692, + 0.05839676409959793, + 0.15485340356826782, + 0.12552563846111298, + 0.04504571855068207, + 0.07348454743623734, + 0.14350123703479767, + 0.06848679482936859, + 0.09431339055299759 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 7, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2256048172712326 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a slow, steady, 360-degree orbiting shot around the dam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the dam constructed of weathered gray concrete with faint vertical water stains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show the dam winding through a deep gorge with pine-clad mountains in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by warm golden sunlight on the top edges and cool blue shades on the lower reaches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a powerful spillway churning dark river water into turbulent white foam and a rising mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004100962076336145 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504100799560547 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004100962076336145, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004100962076336145, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14155808091163635, + 0.30916696786880493, + 0.028149733319878578, + 0.10423740744590759, + 0.06456483900547028, + 0.0652904212474823, + 0.12826666235923767, + 0.05678025260567665, + 0.045725397765636444, + 0.05626020208001137 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004100962076336145 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a slow, steady, 360-degree orbiting shot around the dam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the dam constructed of weathered gray concrete with faint vertical water stains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show the dam winding through a deep gorge with pine-clad mountains in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by warm golden sunlight on the top edges and cool blue shades on the lower reaches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a powerful spillway churning dark river water into turbulent white foam and a rising mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0024889700580388308 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.00248908996582 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0024889700580388308, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0024889700580388308, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08138507604598999, + 0.12725459039211273, + 0.058544788509607315, + 0.06204894930124283, + 0.10470627248287201, + 0.12131652981042862, + 0.1377607136964798, + 0.08622071892023087, + 0.05363760143518448, + 0.1671246886253357 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0024889700580388308 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "At dawn, a slow, steady, and stable 360-degree orbiting drone shot begins, circling a massive, monolithic hydroelectric dam. Composed of weathered gray concrete, punctuated by faint vertical water stains, this massive structure majestically winds its way through a deep gorge. The first rays of sunlight, catching the distant pine-clad mountains, cast a warm golden glow, kissing the top edge of the massive walls, while the lower reaches remain shrouded in a cool blue shade. Below, a powerful spillway relentlessly churns the dark river water into turbulent white foam and powerful whirlpools, from which rises a perpetual, gentle mist. This ethereal mist catches the emerging sunlight, forming a luminous, shimmering veil around the structure's base. The camera's deliberate, sweeping movements highlight the stark contrast between the calm, glassy surface of the vast reservoir, held serenely behind the dam, and the raw, kinetic energy unleashed below, creating an atmosphere of tranquility and focus that conveys the immense, quiet power of this engineering marvel.", + "seed": 22547, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_1/index_7722_seed_22547_dp_2_rank_4_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.3378022968769073, + "vlm_logprob": -0.3378022968769073, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.3, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.3378022968769073, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a slow, steady, 360-degree orbiting shot around the dam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the dam constructed of weathered gray concrete with faint vertical water stains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show the dam winding through a deep gorge with pine-clad mountains in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by warm golden sunlight on the top edges and cool blue shades on the lower reaches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a powerful spillway churning dark river water into turbulent white foam and a rising mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2249499559402466 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.34994998574256897 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.2249499559402466, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -1.2249499559402466, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.42089253664016724, + 0.3256280720233917, + 0.034315984696149826, + 0.024118587374687195, + 0.03921487554907799, + 0.03251807019114494, + 0.053319524973630905, + 0.03253308683633804, + 0.012299031019210815, + 0.025160251185297966 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.2249499559402466 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a slow, steady, 360-degree orbiting shot around the dam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the dam constructed of weathered gray concrete with faint vertical water stains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show the dam winding through a deep gorge with pine-clad mountains in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by warm golden sunlight on the top edges and cool blue shades on the lower reaches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a powerful spillway churning dark river water into turbulent white foam and a rising mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16041186451911926 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9104118347167969 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16041186451911926, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16041186451911926, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06534581631422043, + 0.663067638874054, + 0.015238807536661625, + 0.04010967165231705, + 0.05086519196629524, + 0.045123904943466187, + 0.03392625227570534, + 0.028426483273506165, + 0.012194514274597168, + 0.045701730996370316 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16041186451911926 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a slow, steady, 360-degree orbiting shot around the dam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the dam constructed of weathered gray concrete with faint vertical water stains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show the dam winding through a deep gorge with pine-clad mountains in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by warm golden sunlight on the top edges and cool blue shades on the lower reaches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a powerful spillway churning dark river water into turbulent white foam and a rising mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.28135788440704346 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4063578844070435 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.28135788440704346, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.28135788440704346, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08634182065725327, + 0.5504235029220581, + 0.0343417190015316, + 0.03839951008558273, + 0.11006368696689606, + 0.05186087265610695, + 0.04214995726943016, + 0.02566838636994362, + 0.024079130962491035, + 0.036671411246061325 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.28135788440704346 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a slow, steady, 360-degree orbiting shot around the dam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the dam constructed of weathered gray concrete with faint vertical water stains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show the dam winding through a deep gorge with pine-clad mountains in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by warm golden sunlight on the top edges and cool blue shades on the lower reaches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a powerful spillway churning dark river water into turbulent white foam and a rising mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004101080819964409 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504101276397705 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004101080819964409, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004101080819964409, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.27176785469055176, + 0.10415460169315338, + 0.044294573366642, + 0.12175209075212479, + 0.17974257469177246, + 0.049812767654657364, + 0.10737881809473038, + 0.04303954914212227, + 0.010679989121854305, + 0.06737717986106873 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004101080819964409 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a slow, steady, 360-degree orbiting shot around the dam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the dam constructed of weathered gray concrete with faint vertical water stains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show the dam winding through a deep gorge with pine-clad mountains in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by warm golden sunlight on the top edges and cool blue shades on the lower reaches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a powerful spillway churning dark river water into turbulent white foam and a rising mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018190698698163033 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018190860748291 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018190698698163033, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018190698698163033, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2351517677307129, + 0.36658862233161926, + 0.04124123975634575, + 0.05284203961491585, + 0.07997995615005493, + 0.10238225013017654, + 0.03178359940648079, + 0.025258895009756088, + 0.017407165840268135, + 0.047364506870508194 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018190698698163033 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "At dawn, a slow, steady, and stable 360-degree orbiting drone shot begins, circling a massive, monolithic hydroelectric dam. Composed of weathered gray concrete, punctuated by faint vertical water stains, this massive structure majestically winds its way through a deep gorge. The first rays of sunlight, catching the distant pine-clad mountains, cast a warm golden glow, kissing the top edge of the massive walls, while the lower reaches remain shrouded in a cool blue shade. Below, a powerful spillway relentlessly churns the dark river water into turbulent white foam and powerful whirlpools, from which rises a perpetual, gentle mist. This ethereal mist catches the emerging sunlight, forming a luminous, shimmering veil around the structure's base. The camera's deliberate, sweeping movements highlight the stark contrast between the calm, glassy surface of the vast reservoir, held serenely behind the dam, and the raw, kinetic energy unleashed below, creating an atmosphere of tranquility and focus that conveys the immense, quiet power of this engineering marvel.", + "seed": 22548, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_1/index_7722_seed_22548_dp_3_rank_6_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.3616727983113378, + "vlm_logprob": -0.3616727983113378, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.725, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.3616727983113378, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a slow, steady, 360-degree orbiting shot around the dam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the dam constructed of weathered gray concrete with faint vertical water stains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show the dam winding through a deep gorge with pine-clad mountains in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by warm golden sunlight on the top edges and cool blue shades on the lower reaches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a powerful spillway churning dark river water into turbulent white foam and a rising mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6025002002716064 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22750015556812286 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.6025002002716064, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -1.6025002002716064, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09642504155635834, + 0.08525613695383072, + 0.20399518311023712, + 0.08577343076467514, + 0.09341585636138916, + 0.09546318650245667, + 0.11649247258901596, + 0.10390239953994751, + 0.05270377919077873, + 0.06657250970602036 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.6025002002716064 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a slow, steady, 360-degree orbiting shot around the dam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the dam constructed of weathered gray concrete with faint vertical water stains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show the dam winding through a deep gorge with pine-clad mountains in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by warm golden sunlight on the top edges and cool blue shades on the lower reaches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a powerful spillway churning dark river water into turbulent white foam and a rising mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08910848945379257 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.464108467102051 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08910848945379257, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08910848945379257, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.134491428732872, + 0.12166111916303635, + 0.20263244211673737, + 0.15755274891853333, + 0.10282842814922333, + 0.049799829721450806, + 0.05868891254067421, + 0.04606487974524498, + 0.021338194608688354, + 0.10494201630353928 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08910848945379257 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a slow, steady, 360-degree orbiting shot around the dam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the dam constructed of weathered gray concrete with faint vertical water stains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show the dam winding through a deep gorge with pine-clad mountains in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by warm golden sunlight on the top edges and cool blue shades on the lower reaches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a powerful spillway churning dark river water into turbulent white foam and a rising mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10034558176994324 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3503456115722656 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10034558176994324, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10034558176994324, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18456943333148956, + 0.11407430469989777, + 0.2979060113430023, + 0.09529680013656616, + 0.06608042865991592, + 0.02084355242550373, + 0.04255983233451843, + 0.05954144895076752, + 0.03640950471162796, + 0.08271868526935577 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10034558176994324 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a slow, steady, 360-degree orbiting shot around the dam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the dam constructed of weathered gray concrete with faint vertical water stains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show the dam winding through a deep gorge with pine-clad mountains in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by warm golden sunlight on the top edges and cool blue shades on the lower reaches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a powerful spillway churning dark river water into turbulent white foam and a rising mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014210226014256477 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264210224151611 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014210226014256477, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014210226014256477, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18608011305332184, + 0.10159943997859955, + 0.20472869277000427, + 0.15224884450435638, + 0.04066579043865204, + 0.06562098115682602, + 0.07144908607006073, + 0.07370893657207489, + 0.026882003992795944, + 0.07701613008975983 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014210226014256477 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a slow, steady, 360-degree orbiting shot around the dam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the dam constructed of weathered gray concrete with faint vertical water stains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show the dam winding through a deep gorge with pine-clad mountains in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by warm golden sunlight on the top edges and cool blue shades on the lower reaches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a powerful spillway churning dark river water into turbulent white foam and a rising mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002199494047090411 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127199649810791 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002199494047090411, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002199494047090411, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07579513639211655, + 0.08402596414089203, + 0.15041017532348633, + 0.09663861989974976, + 0.11038392782211304, + 0.0915033221244812, + 0.08388391882181168, + 0.07604020088911057, + 0.11444537341594696, + 0.11687338352203369 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002199494047090411 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "At dawn, a slow, steady, and stable 360-degree orbiting drone shot begins, circling a massive, monolithic hydroelectric dam. Composed of weathered gray concrete, punctuated by faint vertical water stains, this massive structure majestically winds its way through a deep gorge. The first rays of sunlight, catching the distant pine-clad mountains, cast a warm golden glow, kissing the top edge of the massive walls, while the lower reaches remain shrouded in a cool blue shade. Below, a powerful spillway relentlessly churns the dark river water into turbulent white foam and powerful whirlpools, from which rises a perpetual, gentle mist. This ethereal mist catches the emerging sunlight, forming a luminous, shimmering veil around the structure's base. The camera's deliberate, sweeping movements highlight the stark contrast between the calm, glassy surface of the vast reservoir, held serenely behind the dam, and the raw, kinetic energy unleashed below, creating an atmosphere of tranquility and focus that conveys the immense, quiet power of this engineering marvel.", + "seed": 22549, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_1/index_7722_seed_22549_dp_3_rank_6_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.5739675972610712, + "vlm_logprob": -0.5739675972610712, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.3, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.5739675972610712, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a slow, steady, 360-degree orbiting shot around the dam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the dam constructed of weathered gray concrete with faint vertical water stains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show the dam winding through a deep gorge with pine-clad mountains in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by warm golden sunlight on the top edges and cool blue shades on the lower reaches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a powerful spillway churning dark river water into turbulent white foam and a rising mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4653258323669434 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.09032590687274933 + ], + "logprob_reward": -2.4653258323669434, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -2.4653258323669434, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1269548386335373, + 0.0423571951687336, + 0.034065838903188705, + 0.09007743746042252, + 0.23349758982658386, + 0.050133317708969116, + 0.07300665229558945, + 0.04685455560684204, + 0.2503525912761688, + 0.0526999868452549 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -2.4653258323669434 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a slow, steady, 360-degree orbiting shot around the dam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the dam constructed of weathered gray concrete with faint vertical water stains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show the dam winding through a deep gorge with pine-clad mountains in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by warm golden sunlight on the top edges and cool blue shades on the lower reaches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a powerful spillway churning dark river water into turbulent white foam and a rising mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11304999887943268 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2380499839782715 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11304999887943268, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11304999887943268, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17789216339588165, + 0.07402049750089645, + 0.05769946053624153, + 0.1323314905166626, + 0.14614062011241913, + 0.03134634718298912, + 0.04804034158587456, + 0.08128073811531067, + 0.20412983000278473, + 0.047118473798036575 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11304999887943268 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a slow, steady, 360-degree orbiting shot around the dam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the dam constructed of weathered gray concrete with faint vertical water stains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show the dam winding through a deep gorge with pine-clad mountains in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by warm golden sunlight on the top edges and cool blue shades on the lower reaches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a powerful spillway churning dark river water into turbulent white foam and a rising mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2814001739025116 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.406400203704834 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2814001739025116, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2814001739025116, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3982219398021698, + 0.07925717532634735, + 0.08668440580368042, + 0.06256450712680817, + 0.0860181674361229, + 0.07282177358865738, + 0.03021099977195263, + 0.11106373369693756, + 0.04542475566267967, + 0.02773244120180607 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2814001739025116 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a slow, steady, 360-degree orbiting shot around the dam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the dam constructed of weathered gray concrete with faint vertical water stains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show the dam winding through a deep gorge with pine-clad mountains in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by warm golden sunlight on the top edges and cool blue shades on the lower reaches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a powerful spillway churning dark river water into turbulent white foam and a rising mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005961849819868803 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130961894989014 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005961849819868803, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005961849819868803, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18371093273162842, + 0.06846445053815842, + 0.06431548297405243, + 0.12286270409822464, + 0.1320648044347763, + 0.04151136800646782, + 0.05777224153280258, + 0.05821625888347626, + 0.2225588709115982, + 0.04852292314171791 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005961849819868803 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a slow, steady, 360-degree orbiting shot around the dam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the dam constructed of weathered gray concrete with faint vertical water stains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show the dam winding through a deep gorge with pine-clad mountains in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by warm golden sunlight on the top edges and cool blue shades on the lower reaches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a powerful spillway churning dark river water into turbulent white foam and a rising mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004100131336599588 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504100322723389 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004100131336599588, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004100131336599588, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19093024730682373, + 0.12115269899368286, + 0.03600314259529114, + 0.11462116986513138, + 0.0626518651843071, + 0.11331643164157867, + 0.055704038590192795, + 0.05675917863845825, + 0.21422487497329712, + 0.03463641181588173 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004100131336599588 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_10/index_tensor([6145, 6145])_group_10_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_10/index_tensor([6145, 6145])_group_10_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..fe481ad1d2cdd049abe00ce72fe8e0407a0e776a --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_10/index_tensor([6145, 6145])_group_10_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "breathtaking first-person panoramic shot whisks viewers along the steep, winding cobblestone streets of a vibrant, sun-drenched European village, perfectly rendered in the delicate, expressive, and richly detailed animation style of Pixar films. The camera shakes slightly, conveying high-speed vibrations as it hurtles past cheerful stucco buildings with terracotta roofs and cast-iron balconies. A whirlwind of golden and crimson autumn leaves, each with visible texture, dances and shimmers in a dynamic motion blur. Looking down, the view captures a pair of sleek, minimalist skateboards—their low-profile, matte-black frames devoid of any visible brakes—gliding effortlessly over the worn, rounded stones. In one decisive, fluid motion, the skaters attempt to stop with a dramatic slide; the camera tilts and lowers as the skates pivot vertically, their translucent wheels biting the cobblestones, kicking up a trail of faint, seemingly magical sparks. Warm golden hours spill across the scene, casting long, playful shadows that stretch and twist as the slides create a breathtaking atmosphere of joyous, high-speed indulgence.", + "seed": 22801, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_10/index_6145_seed_22801_dp_20_rank_40_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.06462511150166392, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06462511150166392, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.575, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06462511150166392, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the viewpoint a first-person perspective looking down at a pair of sleek, minimalist skateboards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the skateboards matte-black with low-profile frames and no visible brakes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the environment feature steep, winding cobblestone streets with cheerful stucco buildings, terracotta roofs, and cast-iron balconies?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are there golden and crimson autumn leaves with visible texture dancing in a dynamic motion blur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera shake slightly and tilt/lower as the skaters slide, kicking up faint magical sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20349647104740143 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7034964561462402 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20349647104740143, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20349647104740143, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07726704329252243, + 0.05416800454258919, + 0.13766175508499146, + 0.06302811950445175, + 0.18668004870414734, + 0.02608439140021801, + 0.06363387405872345, + 0.22491323947906494, + 0.11804809421300888, + 0.048515383154153824 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20349647104740143 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the viewpoint a first-person perspective looking down at a pair of sleek, minimalist skateboards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the skateboards matte-black with low-profile frames and no visible brakes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the environment feature steep, winding cobblestone streets with cheerful stucco buildings, terracotta roofs, and cast-iron balconies?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are there golden and crimson autumn leaves with visible texture dancing in a dynamic motion blur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera shake slightly and tilt/lower as the skaters slide, kicking up faint magical sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08909333497285843 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4640934467315674 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08909333497285843, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08909333497285843, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07509016990661621, + 0.044044431298971176, + 0.05884872376918793, + 0.10868816822767258, + 0.2167026251554489, + 0.06813742220401764, + 0.06214521825313568, + 0.18421755731105804, + 0.12881942093372345, + 0.053306322544813156 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08909333497285843 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the viewpoint a first-person perspective looking down at a pair of sleek, minimalist skateboards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the skateboards matte-black with low-profile frames and no visible brakes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the environment feature steep, winding cobblestone streets with cheerful stucco buildings, terracotta roofs, and cast-iron balconies?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are there golden and crimson autumn leaves with visible texture dancing in a dynamic motion blur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera shake slightly and tilt/lower as the skaters slide, kicking up faint magical sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005254269111901522 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.25525426864624 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005254269111901522, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005254269111901522, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19205017387866974, + 0.14137712121009827, + 0.06405790150165558, + 0.08062569051980972, + 0.047962486743927, + 0.09839428961277008, + 0.07321159541606903, + 0.0791957899928093, + 0.17297160625457764, + 0.05015331134200096 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005254269111901522 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the viewpoint a first-person perspective looking down at a pair of sleek, minimalist skateboards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the skateboards matte-black with low-profile frames and no visible brakes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the environment feature steep, winding cobblestone streets with cheerful stucco buildings, terracotta roofs, and cast-iron balconies?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are there golden and crimson autumn leaves with visible texture dancing in a dynamic motion blur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera shake slightly and tilt/lower as the skaters slide, kicking up faint magical sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011087710037827492 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511087894439697 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011087710037827492, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011087710037827492, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0726710855960846, + 0.13258278369903564, + 0.17305894196033478, + 0.1703297346830368, + 0.10601936280727386, + 0.1233428493142128, + 0.040361419320106506, + 0.04274967312812805, + 0.06939385831356049, + 0.06949026882648468 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011087710037827492 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the viewpoint a first-person perspective looking down at a pair of sleek, minimalist skateboards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the skateboards matte-black with low-profile frames and no visible brakes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the environment feature steep, winding cobblestone streets with cheerful stucco buildings, terracotta roofs, and cast-iron balconies?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are there golden and crimson autumn leaves with visible texture dancing in a dynamic motion blur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera shake slightly and tilt/lower as the skaters slide, kicking up faint magical sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014193772338330746 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264193534851074 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014193772338330746, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014193772338330746, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08949825167655945, + 0.0734734758734703, + 0.09625556319952011, + 0.06387457251548767, + 0.11313220113515854, + 0.08632045239210129, + 0.04271037131547928, + 0.052816715091466904, + 0.13096332550048828, + 0.2509550452232361 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014193772338330746 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "breathtaking first-person panoramic shot whisks viewers along the steep, winding cobblestone streets of a vibrant, sun-drenched European village, perfectly rendered in the delicate, expressive, and richly detailed animation style of Pixar films. The camera shakes slightly, conveying high-speed vibrations as it hurtles past cheerful stucco buildings with terracotta roofs and cast-iron balconies. A whirlwind of golden and crimson autumn leaves, each with visible texture, dances and shimmers in a dynamic motion blur. Looking down, the view captures a pair of sleek, minimalist skateboards—their low-profile, matte-black frames devoid of any visible brakes—gliding effortlessly over the worn, rounded stones. In one decisive, fluid motion, the skaters attempt to stop with a dramatic slide; the camera tilts and lowers as the skates pivot vertically, their translucent wheels biting the cobblestones, kicking up a trail of faint, seemingly magical sparks. Warm golden hours spill across the scene, casting long, playful shadows that stretch and twist as the slides create a breathtaking atmosphere of joyous, high-speed indulgence.", + "seed": 22802, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_10/index_6145_seed_22802_dp_20_rank_40_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.06577918753027916, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06577918753027916, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.625, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06577918753027916, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the viewpoint a first-person perspective looking down at a pair of sleek, minimalist skateboards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the skateboards matte-black with low-profile frames and no visible brakes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the environment feature steep, winding cobblestone streets with cheerful stucco buildings, terracotta roofs, and cast-iron balconies?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are there golden and crimson autumn leaves with visible texture dancing in a dynamic motion blur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera shake slightly and tilt/lower as the skaters slide, kicking up faint magical sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20285628736019135 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7028563022613525 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20285628736019135, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20285628736019135, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17138731479644775, + 0.08569715917110443, + 0.1562516987323761, + 0.07562445849180222, + 0.08811460435390472, + 0.032694488763809204, + 0.09110847115516663, + 0.059503331780433655, + 0.058193158358335495, + 0.18142524361610413 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20285628736019135 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the viewpoint a first-person perspective looking down at a pair of sleek, minimalist skateboards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the skateboards matte-black with low-profile frames and no visible brakes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the environment feature steep, winding cobblestone streets with cheerful stucco buildings, terracotta roofs, and cast-iron balconies?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are there golden and crimson autumn leaves with visible texture dancing in a dynamic motion blur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera shake slightly and tilt/lower as the skaters slide, kicking up faint magical sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10036272555589676 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.350362777709961 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10036272555589676, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10036272555589676, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13616029918193817, + 0.11602949351072311, + 0.23635584115982056, + 0.06237577274441719, + 0.12770554423332214, + 0.05110234022140503, + 0.06577833741903305, + 0.04879577457904816, + 0.045908961445093155, + 0.1097877025604248 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10036272555589676 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the viewpoint a first-person perspective looking down at a pair of sleek, minimalist skateboards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the skateboards matte-black with low-profile frames and no visible brakes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the environment feature steep, winding cobblestone streets with cheerful stucco buildings, terracotta roofs, and cast-iron balconies?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are there golden and crimson autumn leaves with visible texture dancing in a dynamic motion blur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera shake slightly and tilt/lower as the skaters slide, kicking up faint magical sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00594964437186718 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.1309494972229 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00594964437186718, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00594964437186718, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1581847071647644, + 0.08238838613033295, + 0.14642685651779175, + 0.05856455862522125, + 0.08614019304513931, + 0.0355844721198082, + 0.17379143834114075, + 0.04849452152848244, + 0.1006692573428154, + 0.10975562781095505 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00594964437186718 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the viewpoint a first-person perspective looking down at a pair of sleek, minimalist skateboards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the skateboards matte-black with low-profile frames and no visible brakes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the environment feature steep, winding cobblestone streets with cheerful stucco buildings, terracotta roofs, and cast-iron balconies?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are there golden and crimson autumn leaves with visible texture dancing in a dynamic motion blur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera shake slightly and tilt/lower as the skaters slide, kicking up faint magical sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01109065767377615 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.5110907554626465 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01109065767377615, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01109065767377615, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.061462413519620895, + 0.03419455513358116, + 0.09791727364063263, + 0.045764341950416565, + 0.0302124060690403, + 0.026754362508654594, + 0.1154397651553154, + 0.049363814294338226, + 0.4440874755382538, + 0.094803586602211 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01109065767377615 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the viewpoint a first-person perspective looking down at a pair of sleek, minimalist skateboards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the skateboards matte-black with low-profile frames and no visible brakes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the environment feature steep, winding cobblestone streets with cheerful stucco buildings, terracotta roofs, and cast-iron balconies?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are there golden and crimson autumn leaves with visible texture dancing in a dynamic motion blur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera shake slightly and tilt/lower as the skaters slide, kicking up faint magical sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008636622689664364 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758636474609375 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008636622689664364, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008636622689664364, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17221710085868835, + 0.23374342918395996, + 0.13517238199710846, + 0.040280550718307495, + 0.027747591957449913, + 0.029213210567831993, + 0.10695966333150864, + 0.042481523007154465, + 0.13429400324821472, + 0.07789053022861481 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008636622689664364 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "breathtaking first-person panoramic shot whisks viewers along the steep, winding cobblestone streets of a vibrant, sun-drenched European village, perfectly rendered in the delicate, expressive, and richly detailed animation style of Pixar films. The camera shakes slightly, conveying high-speed vibrations as it hurtles past cheerful stucco buildings with terracotta roofs and cast-iron balconies. A whirlwind of golden and crimson autumn leaves, each with visible texture, dances and shimmers in a dynamic motion blur. Looking down, the view captures a pair of sleek, minimalist skateboards—their low-profile, matte-black frames devoid of any visible brakes—gliding effortlessly over the worn, rounded stones. In one decisive, fluid motion, the skaters attempt to stop with a dramatic slide; the camera tilts and lowers as the skates pivot vertically, their translucent wheels biting the cobblestones, kicking up a trail of faint, seemingly magical sparks. Warm golden hours spill across the scene, casting long, playful shadows that stretch and twist as the slides create a breathtaking atmosphere of joyous, high-speed indulgence.", + "seed": 22803, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_10/index_6145_seed_22803_dp_21_rank_42_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.3089924436993897, + "vlm_logprob": -0.3089924436993897, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.7, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.3089924436993897, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the viewpoint a first-person perspective looking down at a pair of sleek, minimalist skateboards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the skateboards matte-black with low-profile frames and no visible brakes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the environment feature steep, winding cobblestone streets with cheerful stucco buildings, terracotta roofs, and cast-iron balconies?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are there golden and crimson autumn leaves with visible texture dancing in a dynamic motion blur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera shake slightly and tilt/lower as the skaters slide, kicking up faint magical sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.313806176185608 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3138061761856079 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.313806176185608, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -1.313806176185608, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05254083871841431, + 0.014205181039869785, + 0.009194456040859222, + 0.021762168034911156, + 0.04920431971549988, + 0.04192714765667915, + 0.05599690228700638, + 0.05311329662799835, + 0.5803598165512085, + 0.12169583886861801 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.313806176185608 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the viewpoint a first-person perspective looking down at a pair of sleek, minimalist skateboards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the skateboards matte-black with low-profile frames and no visible brakes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the environment feature steep, winding cobblestone streets with cheerful stucco buildings, terracotta roofs, and cast-iron balconies?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are there golden and crimson autumn leaves with visible texture dancing in a dynamic motion blur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera shake slightly and tilt/lower as the skaters slide, kicking up faint magical sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16045817732810974 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9104582071304321 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16045817732810974, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16045817732810974, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.032269660383462906, + 0.010761283338069916, + 0.007566917221993208, + 0.018275683745741844, + 0.023787228390574455, + 0.027402617037296295, + 0.03997866436839104, + 0.06036819890141487, + 0.7173258066177368, + 0.062263865023851395 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16045817732810974 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the viewpoint a first-person perspective looking down at a pair of sleek, minimalist skateboards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the skateboards matte-black with low-profile frames and no visible brakes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the environment feature steep, winding cobblestone streets with cheerful stucco buildings, terracotta roofs, and cast-iron balconies?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are there golden and crimson autumn leaves with visible texture dancing in a dynamic motion blur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera shake slightly and tilt/lower as the skaters slide, kicking up faint magical sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004642778541892767 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379642963409424 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004642778541892767, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004642778541892767, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08981476724147797, + 0.02532931976020336, + 0.028480280190706253, + 0.06701209396123886, + 0.04278818517923355, + 0.061019446700811386, + 0.06328342854976654, + 0.08462930470705032, + 0.45788729190826416, + 0.07975590229034424 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004642778541892767 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the viewpoint a first-person perspective looking down at a pair of sleek, minimalist skateboards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the skateboards matte-black with low-profile frames and no visible brakes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the environment feature steep, winding cobblestone streets with cheerful stucco buildings, terracotta roofs, and cast-iron balconies?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are there golden and crimson autumn leaves with visible texture dancing in a dynamic motion blur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera shake slightly and tilt/lower as the skaters slide, kicking up faint magical sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011092779226601124 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511092662811279 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011092779226601124, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011092779226601124, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09522102773189545, + 0.04101897403597832, + 0.021493490785360336, + 0.049017284065485, + 0.025343986228108406, + 0.04529225826263428, + 0.0717214047908783, + 0.10418771952390671, + 0.45255047082901, + 0.09415339678525925 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011092779226601124 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the viewpoint a first-person perspective looking down at a pair of sleek, minimalist skateboards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the skateboards matte-black with low-profile frames and no visible brakes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the environment feature steep, winding cobblestone streets with cheerful stucco buildings, terracotta roofs, and cast-iron balconies?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are there golden and crimson autumn leaves with visible texture dancing in a dynamic motion blur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera shake slightly and tilt/lower as the skaters slide, kicking up faint magical sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05496230721473694 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929962396621704 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05496230721473694, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05496230721473694, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06478530168533325, + 0.03138163313269615, + 0.01372460275888443, + 0.04819164797663689, + 0.028924742713570595, + 0.05117952078580856, + 0.0713687464594841, + 0.042283181101083755, + 0.5680093169212341, + 0.08015130460262299 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05496230721473694 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "breathtaking first-person panoramic shot whisks viewers along the steep, winding cobblestone streets of a vibrant, sun-drenched European village, perfectly rendered in the delicate, expressive, and richly detailed animation style of Pixar films. The camera shakes slightly, conveying high-speed vibrations as it hurtles past cheerful stucco buildings with terracotta roofs and cast-iron balconies. A whirlwind of golden and crimson autumn leaves, each with visible texture, dances and shimmers in a dynamic motion blur. Looking down, the view captures a pair of sleek, minimalist skateboards—their low-profile, matte-black frames devoid of any visible brakes—gliding effortlessly over the worn, rounded stones. In one decisive, fluid motion, the skaters attempt to stop with a dramatic slide; the camera tilts and lowers as the skates pivot vertically, their translucent wheels biting the cobblestones, kicking up a trail of faint, seemingly magical sparks. Warm golden hours spill across the scene, casting long, playful shadows that stretch and twist as the slides create a breathtaking atmosphere of joyous, high-speed indulgence.", + "seed": 22804, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_10/index_6145_seed_22804_dp_21_rank_42_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.051868930272758004, + "vlm_logprob": -0.051868930272758004, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.575, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.051868930272758004, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the viewpoint a first-person perspective looking down at a pair of sleek, minimalist skateboards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the skateboards matte-black with low-profile frames and no visible brakes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the environment feature steep, winding cobblestone streets with cheerful stucco buildings, terracotta roofs, and cast-iron balconies?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are there golden and crimson autumn leaves with visible texture dancing in a dynamic motion blur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera shake slightly and tilt/lower as the skaters slide, kicking up faint magical sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11366082727909088 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2386608123779297 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11366082727909088, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11366082727909088, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.26451918482780457, + 0.08154409378767014, + 0.05867895856499672, + 0.07246793061494827, + 0.04796196147799492, + 0.03646494075655937, + 0.060621727257966995, + 0.24603067338466644, + 0.07154221087694168, + 0.06016833707690239 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11366082727909088 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the viewpoint a first-person perspective looking down at a pair of sleek, minimalist skateboards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the skateboards matte-black with low-profile frames and no visible brakes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the environment feature steep, winding cobblestone streets with cheerful stucco buildings, terracotta roofs, and cast-iron balconies?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are there golden and crimson autumn leaves with visible texture dancing in a dynamic motion blur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera shake slightly and tilt/lower as the skaters slide, kicking up faint magical sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11296822875738144 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2379682064056396 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11296822875738144, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11296822875738144, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1376732438802719, + 0.09436645358800888, + 0.05166371166706085, + 0.031020360067486763, + 0.042557474225759506, + 0.038602206856012344, + 0.09350183606147766, + 0.3608592450618744, + 0.06431537866592407, + 0.08544011414051056 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11296822875738144 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the viewpoint a first-person perspective looking down at a pair of sleek, minimalist skateboards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the skateboards matte-black with low-profile frames and no visible brakes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the environment feature steep, winding cobblestone streets with cheerful stucco buildings, terracotta roofs, and cast-iron balconies?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are there golden and crimson autumn leaves with visible texture dancing in a dynamic motion blur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera shake slightly and tilt/lower as the skaters slide, kicking up faint magical sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012540415860712528 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387540340423584 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012540415860712528, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012540415860712528, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.26431912183761597, + 0.05564664304256439, + 0.05693922936916351, + 0.13607829809188843, + 0.021215306594967842, + 0.02704576961696148, + 0.28181686997413635, + 0.09694676846265793, + 0.020094256848096848, + 0.03989768400788307 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012540415860712528 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the viewpoint a first-person perspective looking down at a pair of sleek, minimalist skateboards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the skateboards matte-black with low-profile frames and no visible brakes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the environment feature steep, winding cobblestone streets with cheerful stucco buildings, terracotta roofs, and cast-iron balconies?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are there golden and crimson autumn leaves with visible texture dancing in a dynamic motion blur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera shake slightly and tilt/lower as the skaters slide, kicking up faint magical sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007638413459062576 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882638454437256 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007638413459062576, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007638413459062576, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14266447722911835, + 0.02910025417804718, + 0.04894150793552399, + 0.24800415337085724, + 0.04282839223742485, + 0.0315251350402832, + 0.26840630173683167, + 0.07863262295722961, + 0.03633049875497818, + 0.07356671243906021 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007638413459062576 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the viewpoint a first-person perspective looking down at a pair of sleek, minimalist skateboards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the skateboards matte-black with low-profile frames and no visible brakes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the environment feature steep, winding cobblestone streets with cheerful stucco buildings, terracotta roofs, and cast-iron balconies?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are there golden and crimson autumn leaves with visible texture dancing in a dynamic motion blur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera shake slightly and tilt/lower as the skaters slide, kicking up faint magical sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01253676600754261 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387537002563477 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01253676600754261, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01253676600754261, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23380739986896515, + 0.06835712492465973, + 0.12997440993785858, + 0.06570224463939667, + 0.04478735104203224, + 0.059614021331071854, + 0.0840509682893753, + 0.06353655457496643, + 0.12052492052316666, + 0.1296449899673462 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01253676600754261 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_11/index_tensor([4774, 4774])_group_11_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_11/index_tensor([4774, 4774])_group_11_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..f561f8277a81c8fb803e675b9645b1cd5e67a0a8 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_11/index_tensor([4774, 4774])_group_11_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "This extreme close-up, rendered with a hyper-real, high-fidelity digital look, focuses on a meticulously crafted black leather wallet as it tumbles through an infinite void. A single, crisp key light follows the object, capturing the leather's intricate, veined grain and the perfectly even stitching along its edges, creating striking highlights against the deep black. The wallet's initial rotation is chaotic yet graceful, but as it slowly loses angular momentum, its movement becomes more deliberate. Simultaneously, the camera begins to roll out, a smooth, steady, dolly-like rollout that gradually reveals the wallet's solitary descent into the vast, empty space. This shift enhances the film's sense of clarity, capturing the object's graceful descent into profound darkness and establishing an atmosphere of refinement, minimalism, and focus.", + "seed": 8904, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_11/index_4774_seed_8904_dp_22_rank_44_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.10754720009863376, + "vlm_logprob": -0.10754720009863376, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.925, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.10754720009863376, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a black leather wallet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the wallet's surface texture showing intricate veined grain and even stitching?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the wallet tumble with an initial chaotic rotation that transitions to a deliberate, slower descent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment an infinite void with a single crisp key light creating highlights on the wallet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a smooth, steady dolly-like rollout revealing the wallet's descent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.31482526659965515 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3148252964019775 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.31482526659965515, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.31482526659965515, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07985426485538483, + 0.04956028610467911, + 0.04326437786221504, + 0.14532406628131866, + 0.04734818637371063, + 0.02992713823914528, + 0.06131385639309883, + 0.27107012271881104, + 0.08456528931856155, + 0.18777239322662354 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.31482526659965515 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a black leather wallet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the wallet's surface texture showing intricate veined grain and even stitching?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the wallet tumble with an initial chaotic rotation that transitions to a deliberate, slower descent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment an infinite void with a single crisp key light creating highlights on the wallet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a smooth, steady dolly-like rollout revealing the wallet's descent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08910674601793289 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.464106798171997 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08910674601793289, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08910674601793289, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06634309887886047, + 0.03909128159284592, + 0.33782753348350525, + 0.07997576892375946, + 0.11069414764642715, + 0.055920206010341644, + 0.06295835226774216, + 0.10946108400821686, + 0.041897259652614594, + 0.09583128243684769 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 4, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08910674601793289 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a black leather wallet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the wallet's surface texture showing intricate veined grain and even stitching?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the wallet tumble with an initial chaotic rotation that transitions to a deliberate, slower descent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment an infinite void with a single crisp key light creating highlights on the wallet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a smooth, steady dolly-like rollout revealing the wallet's descent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00979557354003191 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634795665740967 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00979557354003191, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00979557354003191, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.043698158115148544, + 0.04899412766098976, + 0.29593756794929504, + 0.08444079756736755, + 0.06029948592185974, + 0.04518516734242439, + 0.0695873349905014, + 0.14029215276241302, + 0.15562553703784943, + 0.0559396930038929 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00979557354003191 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a black leather wallet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the wallet's surface texture showing intricate veined grain and even stitching?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the wallet tumble with an initial chaotic rotation that transitions to a deliberate, slower descent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment an infinite void with a single crisp key light creating highlights on the wallet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a smooth, steady dolly-like rollout revealing the wallet's descent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011080753989517689 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511080741882324 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011080753989517689, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011080753989517689, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.031947363168001175, + 0.18426354229450226, + 0.31115731596946716, + 0.1088862493634224, + 0.13476058840751648, + 0.03614579141139984, + 0.043749578297138214, + 0.05536936968564987, + 0.05418917164206505, + 0.03953104838728905 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011080753989517689 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a black leather wallet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the wallet's surface texture showing intricate veined grain and even stitching?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the wallet tumble with an initial chaotic rotation that transitions to a deliberate, slower descent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment an infinite void with a single crisp key light creating highlights on the wallet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a smooth, steady dolly-like rollout revealing the wallet's descent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11292766034603119 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2379276752471924 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11292766034603119, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11292766034603119, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06018780544400215, + 0.07728039473295212, + 0.18211625516414642, + 0.10312601178884506, + 0.20856930315494537, + 0.07504914700984955, + 0.051446497440338135, + 0.10081036388874054, + 0.07543933391571045, + 0.06597490608692169 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11292766034603119 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "This extreme close-up, rendered with a hyper-real, high-fidelity digital look, focuses on a meticulously crafted black leather wallet as it tumbles through an infinite void. A single, crisp key light follows the object, capturing the leather's intricate, veined grain and the perfectly even stitching along its edges, creating striking highlights against the deep black. The wallet's initial rotation is chaotic yet graceful, but as it slowly loses angular momentum, its movement becomes more deliberate. Simultaneously, the camera begins to roll out, a smooth, steady, dolly-like rollout that gradually reveals the wallet's solitary descent into the vast, empty space. This shift enhances the film's sense of clarity, capturing the object's graceful descent into profound darkness and establishing an atmosphere of refinement, minimalism, and focus.", + "seed": 8905, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_11/index_4774_seed_8905_dp_22_rank_44_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.046806186251342294, + "vlm_logprob": -0.046806186251342294, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.4, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.046806186251342294, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a black leather wallet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the wallet's surface texture showing intricate veined grain and even stitching?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the wallet tumble with an initial chaotic rotation that transitions to a deliberate, slower descent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment an infinite void with a single crisp key light creating highlights on the wallet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a smooth, steady dolly-like rollout revealing the wallet's descent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10116538405418396 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.351165294647217 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10116538405418396, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10116538405418396, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.26051050424575806, + 0.08360407501459122, + 0.030185481533408165, + 0.10625883936882019, + 0.0774521678686142, + 0.2107677161693573, + 0.053892333060503006, + 0.06410453468561172, + 0.046811483800411224, + 0.06641287356615067 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10116538405418396 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a black leather wallet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the wallet's surface texture showing intricate veined grain and even stitching?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the wallet tumble with an initial chaotic rotation that transitions to a deliberate, slower descent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment an infinite void with a single crisp key light creating highlights on the wallet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a smooth, steady dolly-like rollout revealing the wallet's descent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.048681460320949554 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486814975738525 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.048681460320949554, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.048681460320949554, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15678468346595764, + 0.10971464961767197, + 0.20206482708454132, + 0.15266861021518707, + 0.034943774342536926, + 0.15612424910068512, + 0.028618602082133293, + 0.09037370979785919, + 0.03389068692922592, + 0.03481621667742729 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.048681460320949554 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a black leather wallet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the wallet's surface texture showing intricate veined grain and even stitching?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the wallet tumble with an initial chaotic rotation that transitions to a deliberate, slower descent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment an infinite void with a single crisp key light creating highlights on the wallet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a smooth, steady dolly-like rollout revealing the wallet's descent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011078514158725739 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511078357696533 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011078514158725739, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011078514158725739, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13290448486804962, + 0.08221269398927689, + 0.07894422113895416, + 0.17428308725357056, + 0.07151573151350021, + 0.22098888456821442, + 0.11170010268688202, + 0.04452402889728546, + 0.060452770441770554, + 0.022473983466625214 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011078514158725739 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a black leather wallet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the wallet's surface texture showing intricate veined grain and even stitching?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the wallet tumble with an initial chaotic rotation that transitions to a deliberate, slower descent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment an infinite void with a single crisp key light creating highlights on the wallet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a smooth, steady dolly-like rollout revealing the wallet's descent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011075212620198727 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511075019836426 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011075212620198727, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011075212620198727, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.36822426319122314, + 0.04937078803777695, + 0.06652244180440903, + 0.06484204530715942, + 0.1112179383635521, + 0.1322283297777176, + 0.023967284709215164, + 0.09320822358131409, + 0.06634213030338287, + 0.02407648414373398 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011075212620198727 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a black leather wallet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the wallet's surface texture showing intricate veined grain and even stitching?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the wallet tumble with an initial chaotic rotation that transitions to a deliberate, slower descent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment an infinite void with a single crisp key light creating highlights on the wallet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a smooth, steady dolly-like rollout revealing the wallet's descent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0620303601026535 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.81203031539917 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0620303601026535, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0620303601026535, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17731645703315735, + 0.06762496381998062, + 0.07678209245204926, + 0.1806560456752777, + 0.08045961707830429, + 0.1413414627313614, + 0.06032458692789078, + 0.06195541098713875, + 0.07901756465435028, + 0.07452180981636047 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0620303601026535 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "This extreme close-up, rendered with a hyper-real, high-fidelity digital look, focuses on a meticulously crafted black leather wallet as it tumbles through an infinite void. A single, crisp key light follows the object, capturing the leather's intricate, veined grain and the perfectly even stitching along its edges, creating striking highlights against the deep black. The wallet's initial rotation is chaotic yet graceful, but as it slowly loses angular momentum, its movement becomes more deliberate. Simultaneously, the camera begins to roll out, a smooth, steady, dolly-like rollout that gradually reveals the wallet's solitary descent into the vast, empty space. This shift enhances the film's sense of clarity, capturing the object's graceful descent into profound darkness and establishing an atmosphere of refinement, minimalism, and focus.", + "seed": 8906, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_11/index_4774_seed_8906_dp_23_rank_46_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.15414252346381546, + "vlm_logprob": -0.15414252346381546, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.9, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.15414252346381546, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a black leather wallet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the wallet's surface texture showing intricate veined grain and even stitching?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the wallet tumble with an initial chaotic rotation that transitions to a deliberate, slower descent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment an infinite void with a single crisp key light creating highlights on the wallet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a smooth, steady dolly-like rollout revealing the wallet's descent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5246907472610474 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8996907472610474 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5246907472610474, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5246907472610474, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13885578513145447, + 0.03685012087225914, + 0.02994539588689804, + 0.2407752126455307, + 0.05939105898141861, + 0.11406394094228745, + 0.08792499452829361, + 0.06580065935850143, + 0.1263430267572403, + 0.10004983097314835 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5246907472610474 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a black leather wallet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the wallet's surface texture showing intricate veined grain and even stitching?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the wallet tumble with an initial chaotic rotation that transitions to a deliberate, slower descent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment an infinite void with a single crisp key light creating highlights on the wallet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a smooth, steady dolly-like rollout revealing the wallet's descent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.179961159825325 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8049612045288086 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.179961159825325, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.179961159825325, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11620599031448364, + 0.06498528271913528, + 0.16408409178256989, + 0.11571609228849411, + 0.05586894601583481, + 0.09914756566286087, + 0.06711520999670029, + 0.07174360752105713, + 0.1234900951385498, + 0.1216430589556694 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.179961159825325 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a black leather wallet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the wallet's surface texture showing intricate veined grain and even stitching?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the wallet tumble with an initial chaotic rotation that transitions to a deliberate, slower descent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment an infinite void with a single crisp key light creating highlights on the wallet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a smooth, steady dolly-like rollout revealing the wallet's descent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0076352194882929325 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882635116577148 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0076352194882929325, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0076352194882929325, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14306214451789856, + 0.06954788416624069, + 0.07035285234451294, + 0.06977219879627228, + 0.1536993384361267, + 0.13966810703277588, + 0.09019407629966736, + 0.049209337681531906, + 0.07857108116149902, + 0.13592295348644257 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0076352194882929325 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a black leather wallet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the wallet's surface texture showing intricate veined grain and even stitching?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the wallet tumble with an initial chaotic rotation that transitions to a deliberate, slower descent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment an infinite void with a single crisp key light creating highlights on the wallet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a smooth, steady dolly-like rollout revealing the wallet's descent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009780817665159702 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.6347808837890625 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009780817665159702, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009780817665159702, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09764349460601807, + 0.03620701655745506, + 0.08874821662902832, + 0.5053250789642334, + 0.07491379976272583, + 0.030384277924895287, + 0.059213366359472275, + 0.03124304860830307, + 0.02973879501223564, + 0.046582937240600586 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009780817665159702 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a black leather wallet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the wallet's surface texture showing intricate veined grain and even stitching?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the wallet tumble with an initial chaotic rotation that transitions to a deliberate, slower descent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment an infinite void with a single crisp key light creating highlights on the wallet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a smooth, steady dolly-like rollout revealing the wallet's descent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04864467307925224 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048644781112671 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04864467307925224, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04864467307925224, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.058963898569345474, + 0.047921594232320786, + 0.03833368793129921, + 0.4458702504634857, + 0.03386612609028816, + 0.06391596049070358, + 0.0973542109131813, + 0.06463440507650375, + 0.09502200782299042, + 0.054117877036333084 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04864467307925224 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "This extreme close-up, rendered with a hyper-real, high-fidelity digital look, focuses on a meticulously crafted black leather wallet as it tumbles through an infinite void. A single, crisp key light follows the object, capturing the leather's intricate, veined grain and the perfectly even stitching along its edges, creating striking highlights against the deep black. The wallet's initial rotation is chaotic yet graceful, but as it slowly loses angular momentum, its movement becomes more deliberate. Simultaneously, the camera begins to roll out, a smooth, steady, dolly-like rollout that gradually reveals the wallet's solitary descent into the vast, empty space. This shift enhances the film's sense of clarity, capturing the object's graceful descent into profound darkness and establishing an atmosphere of refinement, minimalism, and focus.", + "seed": 8907, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_11/index_4774_seed_8907_dp_23_rank_46_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.05312761124223471, + "vlm_logprob": -0.05312761124223471, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.4, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.05312761124223471, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a black leather wallet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the wallet's surface texture showing intricate veined grain and even stitching?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the wallet tumble with an initial chaotic rotation that transitions to a deliberate, slower descent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment an infinite void with a single crisp key light creating highlights on the wallet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a smooth, steady dolly-like rollout revealing the wallet's descent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07148333638906479 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6964833736419678 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07148333638906479, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07148333638906479, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.014093601144850254, + 0.11732818931341171, + 0.058374982327222824, + 0.01224447600543499, + 0.011624622158706188, + 0.012603238224983215, + 0.7017618417739868, + 0.046491120010614395, + 0.017350422218441963, + 0.008127533830702305 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07148333638906479 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a black leather wallet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the wallet's surface texture showing intricate veined grain and even stitching?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the wallet tumble with an initial chaotic rotation that transitions to a deliberate, slower descent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment an infinite void with a single crisp key light creating highlights on the wallet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a smooth, steady dolly-like rollout revealing the wallet's descent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1270849108695984 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.127084970474243 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1270849108695984, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1270849108695984, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.007584471255540848, + 0.6956903338432312, + 0.02574213221669197, + 0.055753856897354126, + 0.014903905801475048, + 0.008773819543421268, + 0.14232918620109558, + 0.0322672501206398, + 0.008403548039495945, + 0.008551486767828465 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 6, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1270849108695984 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a black leather wallet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the wallet's surface texture showing intricate veined grain and even stitching?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the wallet tumble with an initial chaotic rotation that transitions to a deliberate, slower descent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment an infinite void with a single crisp key light creating highlights on the wallet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a smooth, steady dolly-like rollout revealing the wallet's descent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009786365553736687 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634786128997803 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009786365553736687, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009786365553736687, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0029035923071205616, + 0.8750574588775635, + 0.01087324321269989, + 0.014357875101268291, + 0.0025345063768327236, + 0.003050493076443672, + 0.08578047901391983, + 0.0032716530840843916, + 0.0012931512901559472, + 0.0008774643647484481 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 6, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009786365553736687 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a black leather wallet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the wallet's surface texture showing intricate veined grain and even stitching?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the wallet tumble with an initial chaotic rotation that transitions to a deliberate, slower descent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment an infinite void with a single crisp key light creating highlights on the wallet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a smooth, steady dolly-like rollout revealing the wallet's descent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008639340288937092 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758639335632324 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008639340288937092, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008639340288937092, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.006176312919706106, + 0.7066391706466675, + 0.009764989838004112, + 0.04796113446354866, + 0.00743627455085516, + 0.03682691603899002, + 0.1535535752773285, + 0.01192856952548027, + 0.0035011048894375563, + 0.01621191017329693 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 6, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008639340288937092 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a black leather wallet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the wallet's surface texture showing intricate veined grain and even stitching?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the wallet tumble with an initial chaotic rotation that transitions to a deliberate, slower descent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment an infinite void with a single crisp key light creating highlights on the wallet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a smooth, steady dolly-like rollout revealing the wallet's descent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04864410310983658 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486440658569336 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04864410310983658, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04864410310983658, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.007417743094265461, + 0.6929418444633484, + 0.015881061553955078, + 0.010650672018527985, + 0.011761178262531757, + 0.007024633698165417, + 0.22101044654846191, + 0.01322075817734003, + 0.005859028082340956, + 0.014232559129595757 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 6, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04864410310983658 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_12/index_tensor([6876, 6876])_group_12_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_12/index_tensor([6876, 6876])_group_12_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..6275a95104c6fd1e17ccd542e5965b9e1141739c --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_12/index_tensor([6876, 6876])_group_12_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "static, eye-level medium shot captures a dramatic kitchen moment with intense focus. A well-used stainless steel saucepan, its metal surface faintly scratched and reflecting ambient light, sits at the center of the searing red-orange glow of an electric stove coil. Inside, water has reached a violent rolling boil; large, turbulent bubbles erupt continuously, stirring the surface into a chaotic froth. The liquid expands relentlessly, rising until it surges over the pan's silver rim in a clear, thick stream. As the overflow cascades down the side of the pan and meets the hot, black surface of the stovetop, it instantly vaporizes with a sharp hiss and erupts into a thick, billowing cloud of white steam that rises and dissipates quickly, creating a tense atmosphere of uncontrolled energy and imminent overflow.", + "seed": 6625, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_12/index_6876_seed_6625_dp_24_rank_48_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.08413415402173996, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08413415402173996, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.825, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08413415402173996, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static, eye-level medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a well-used stainless steel saucepan with a scratched surface visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the water inside the saucepan boiling violently with large, turbulent bubbles and a chaotic froth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the boiling water surge over the pan's rim and cascade down the side onto the stovetop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the overflowing water instantly vaporize into a thick, billowing cloud of white steam upon hitting the hot stovetop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22183798253536224 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7218379974365234 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.22183798253536224, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.22183798253536224, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.7474822402000427, + 0.020207401365041733, + 0.01731269061565399, + 0.015569503419101238, + 0.018381094560027122, + 0.019762976095080376, + 0.056535203009843826, + 0.056843988597393036, + 0.03965580463409424, + 0.008248996920883656 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.22183798253536224 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static, eye-level medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a well-used stainless steel saucepan with a scratched surface visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the water inside the saucepan boiling violently with large, turbulent bubbles and a chaotic froth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the boiling water surge over the pan's rim and cascade down the side onto the stovetop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the overflowing water instantly vaporize into a thick, billowing cloud of white steam upon hitting the hot stovetop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07006638497114182 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695066452026367 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07006638497114182, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07006638497114182, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.29467111825942993, + 0.11443807929754257, + 0.054671868681907654, + 0.057195134460926056, + 0.03369715064764023, + 0.1150314062833786, + 0.10117127001285553, + 0.07003644108772278, + 0.13350819051265717, + 0.025579361245036125 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07006638497114182 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static, eye-level medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a well-used stainless steel saucepan with a scratched surface visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the water inside the saucepan boiling violently with large, turbulent bubbles and a chaotic froth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the boiling water surge over the pan's rim and cascade down the side onto the stovetop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the overflowing water instantly vaporize into a thick, billowing cloud of white steam upon hitting the hot stovetop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.033713314682245255 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4087133407592773 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.033713314682245255, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.033713314682245255, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1627471148967743, + 0.051287051290273666, + 0.09594708681106567, + 0.07307503372430801, + 0.2421562224626541, + 0.09017572551965714, + 0.06694566458463669, + 0.03873303160071373, + 0.0785272940993309, + 0.10040585696697235 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.033713314682245255 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static, eye-level medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a well-used stainless steel saucepan with a scratched surface visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the water inside the saucepan boiling violently with large, turbulent bubbles and a chaotic froth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the boiling water surge over the pan's rim and cascade down the side onto the stovetop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the overflowing water instantly vaporize into a thick, billowing cloud of white steam upon hitting the hot stovetop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01607036218047142 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141070365905762 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01607036218047142, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01607036218047142, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07646169513463974, + 0.06958119571208954, + 0.0838703140616417, + 0.05777015909552574, + 0.15691712498664856, + 0.17950615286827087, + 0.20106279850006104, + 0.05012236163020134, + 0.06674064695835114, + 0.057967521250247955 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01607036218047142 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static, eye-level medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a well-used stainless steel saucepan with a scratched surface visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the water inside the saucepan boiling violently with large, turbulent bubbles and a chaotic froth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the boiling water surge over the pan's rim and cascade down the side onto the stovetop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the overflowing water instantly vaporize into a thick, billowing cloud of white steam upon hitting the hot stovetop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07898272573947906 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5789828300476074 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07898272573947906, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07898272573947906, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25421032309532166, + 0.04548140615224838, + 0.08857489377260208, + 0.06732255965471268, + 0.08117787539958954, + 0.2311340570449829, + 0.0642993152141571, + 0.033903028815984726, + 0.08187974244356155, + 0.05201684311032295 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07898272573947906 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, eye-level medium shot captures a dramatic kitchen moment with intense focus. A well-used stainless steel saucepan, its metal surface faintly scratched and reflecting ambient light, sits at the center of the searing red-orange glow of an electric stove coil. Inside, water has reached a violent rolling boil; large, turbulent bubbles erupt continuously, stirring the surface into a chaotic froth. The liquid expands relentlessly, rising until it surges over the pan's silver rim in a clear, thick stream. As the overflow cascades down the side of the pan and meets the hot, black surface of the stovetop, it instantly vaporizes with a sharp hiss and erupts into a thick, billowing cloud of white steam that rises and dissipates quickly, creating a tense atmosphere of uncontrolled energy and imminent overflow.", + "seed": 6626, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_12/index_6876_seed_6626_dp_24_rank_48_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.16964959353208542, + "vlm_logprob": -0.16964959353208542, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.05, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.16964959353208542, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static, eye-level medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a well-used stainless steel saucepan with a scratched surface visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the water inside the saucepan boiling violently with large, turbulent bubbles and a chaotic froth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the boiling water surge over the pan's rim and cascade down the side onto the stovetop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the overflowing water instantly vaporize into a thick, billowing cloud of white steam upon hitting the hot stovetop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.28048771619796753 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5304877758026123 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.28048771619796753, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.28048771619796753, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06481167674064636, + 0.09696466475725174, + 0.03384547308087349, + 0.04003455117344856, + 0.026525499299168587, + 0.08307234197854996, + 0.31876468658447266, + 0.1417096108198166, + 0.06413976848125458, + 0.13013173639774323 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.28048771619796753 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static, eye-level medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a well-used stainless steel saucepan with a scratched surface visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the water inside the saucepan boiling violently with large, turbulent bubbles and a chaotic froth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the boiling water surge over the pan's rim and cascade down the side onto the stovetop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the overflowing water instantly vaporize into a thick, billowing cloud of white steam upon hitting the hot stovetop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2813926041126251 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4063925743103027 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2813926041126251, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2813926041126251, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13401103019714355, + 0.11362425237894058, + 0.03964986279606819, + 0.064858578145504, + 0.07037536799907684, + 0.16865454614162445, + 0.09103407710790634, + 0.09146754443645477, + 0.06861846894025803, + 0.15770626068115234 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2813926041126251 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static, eye-level medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a well-used stainless steel saucepan with a scratched surface visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the water inside the saucepan boiling violently with large, turbulent bubbles and a chaotic froth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the boiling water surge over the pan's rim and cascade down the side onto the stovetop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the overflowing water instantly vaporize into a thick, billowing cloud of white steam upon hitting the hot stovetop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.054973479360342026 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299733638763428 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.054973479360342026, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.054973479360342026, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15463921427726746, + 0.06433448195457458, + 0.07069619745016098, + 0.04190468788146973, + 0.04407932609319687, + 0.0934024304151535, + 0.2474641650915146, + 0.10647973418235779, + 0.04289819300174713, + 0.1341015100479126 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.054973479360342026 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static, eye-level medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a well-used stainless steel saucepan with a scratched surface visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the water inside the saucepan boiling violently with large, turbulent bubbles and a chaotic froth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the boiling water surge over the pan's rim and cascade down the side onto the stovetop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the overflowing water instantly vaporize into a thick, billowing cloud of white steam upon hitting the hot stovetop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029805611819028854 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298056602478027 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029805611819028854, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029805611819028854, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20575620234012604, + 0.26755037903785706, + 0.05128121003508568, + 0.024579370394349098, + 0.07590243965387344, + 0.16121995449066162, + 0.08672700822353363, + 0.019015662372112274, + 0.06914135813713074, + 0.038826484233140945 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029805611819028854 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static, eye-level medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a well-used stainless steel saucepan with a scratched surface visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the water inside the saucepan boiling violently with large, turbulent bubbles and a chaotic froth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the boiling water surge over the pan's rim and cascade down the side onto the stovetop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the overflowing water instantly vaporize into a thick, billowing cloud of white steam upon hitting the hot stovetop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20158855617046356 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.70158851146698 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20158855617046356, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20158855617046356, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.468217134475708, + 0.09958682954311371, + 0.035335052758455276, + 0.03770294040441513, + 0.035314783453941345, + 0.063759446144104, + 0.10498090833425522, + 0.037914592772722244, + 0.08292463421821594, + 0.034263648092746735 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20158855617046356 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, eye-level medium shot captures a dramatic kitchen moment with intense focus. A well-used stainless steel saucepan, its metal surface faintly scratched and reflecting ambient light, sits at the center of the searing red-orange glow of an electric stove coil. Inside, water has reached a violent rolling boil; large, turbulent bubbles erupt continuously, stirring the surface into a chaotic froth. The liquid expands relentlessly, rising until it surges over the pan's silver rim in a clear, thick stream. As the overflow cascades down the side of the pan and meets the hot, black surface of the stovetop, it instantly vaporizes with a sharp hiss and erupts into a thick, billowing cloud of white steam that rises and dissipates quickly, creating a tense atmosphere of uncontrolled energy and imminent overflow.", + "seed": 6627, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_12/index_6876_seed_6627_dp_25_rank_50_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.16491371989250184, + "vlm_logprob": -0.16491371989250184, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.9, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.16491371989250184, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static, eye-level medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a well-used stainless steel saucepan with a scratched surface visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the water inside the saucepan boiling violently with large, turbulent bubbles and a chaotic froth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the boiling water surge over the pan's rim and cascade down the side onto the stovetop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the overflowing water instantly vaporize into a thick, billowing cloud of white steam upon hitting the hot stovetop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2045770287513733 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9545769691467285 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2045770287513733, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2045770287513733, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.043553177267313004, + 0.1924816220998764, + 0.04296267032623291, + 0.22344830632209778, + 0.20492151379585266, + 0.15471632778644562, + 0.04267250373959541, + 0.02703227289021015, + 0.03475888445973396, + 0.033452682197093964 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2045770287513733 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static, eye-level medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a well-used stainless steel saucepan with a scratched surface visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the water inside the saucepan boiling violently with large, turbulent bubbles and a chaotic froth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the boiling water surge over the pan's rim and cascade down the side onto the stovetop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the overflowing water instantly vaporize into a thick, billowing cloud of white steam upon hitting the hot stovetop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10038116574287415 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3503811359405518 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10038116574287415, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10038116574287415, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04911321774125099, + 0.2402835190296173, + 0.033971257507801056, + 0.06771623343229294, + 0.04975399747490883, + 0.32983824610710144, + 0.08690416067838669, + 0.03316840901970863, + 0.07862070947885513, + 0.03063019923865795 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10038116574287415 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static, eye-level medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a well-used stainless steel saucepan with a scratched surface visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the water inside the saucepan boiling violently with large, turbulent bubbles and a chaotic froth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the boiling water surge over the pan's rim and cascade down the side onto the stovetop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the overflowing water instantly vaporize into a thick, billowing cloud of white steam upon hitting the hot stovetop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12709446251392365 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1270945072174072 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12709446251392365, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12709446251392365, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11568477749824524, + 0.16947557032108307, + 0.05756131559610367, + 0.24680548906326294, + 0.10067998617887497, + 0.1183118000626564, + 0.051758427172899246, + 0.033002592623233795, + 0.04929023236036301, + 0.057429827749729156 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12709446251392365 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static, eye-level medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a well-used stainless steel saucepan with a scratched surface visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the water inside the saucepan boiling violently with large, turbulent bubbles and a chaotic froth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the boiling water surge over the pan's rim and cascade down the side onto the stovetop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the overflowing water instantly vaporize into a thick, billowing cloud of white steam upon hitting the hot stovetop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07900585234165192 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5790059566497803 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07900585234165192, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07900585234165192, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09933950006961823, + 0.17589280009269714, + 0.041380830109119415, + 0.06035403162240982, + 0.07573512941598892, + 0.409439355134964, + 0.05131452903151512, + 0.029039477929472923, + 0.03840941935777664, + 0.019095027819275856 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07900585234165192 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static, eye-level medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a well-used stainless steel saucepan with a scratched surface visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the water inside the saucepan boiling violently with large, turbulent bubbles and a chaotic froth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the boiling water surge over the pan's rim and cascade down the side onto the stovetop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the overflowing water instantly vaporize into a thick, billowing cloud of white steam upon hitting the hot stovetop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.31351009011268616 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3135100603103638 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.31351009011268616, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.31351009011268616, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23315870761871338, + 0.19095993041992188, + 0.05793086439371109, + 0.067108154296875, + 0.09629197418689728, + 0.20029966533184052, + 0.04659426584839821, + 0.028212107717990875, + 0.052420616149902344, + 0.02702372334897518 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.31351009011268616 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, eye-level medium shot captures a dramatic kitchen moment with intense focus. A well-used stainless steel saucepan, its metal surface faintly scratched and reflecting ambient light, sits at the center of the searing red-orange glow of an electric stove coil. Inside, water has reached a violent rolling boil; large, turbulent bubbles erupt continuously, stirring the surface into a chaotic froth. The liquid expands relentlessly, rising until it surges over the pan's silver rim in a clear, thick stream. As the overflow cascades down the side of the pan and meets the hot, black surface of the stovetop, it instantly vaporizes with a sharp hiss and erupts into a thick, billowing cloud of white steam that rises and dissipates quickly, creating a tense atmosphere of uncontrolled energy and imminent overflow.", + "seed": 6628, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_12/index_6876_seed_6628_dp_25_rank_50_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.2549081057310104, + "vlm_logprob": -0.2549081057310104, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.45, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.2549081057310104, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static, eye-level medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a well-used stainless steel saucepan with a scratched surface visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the water inside the saucepan boiling violently with large, turbulent bubbles and a chaotic froth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the boiling water surge over the pan's rim and cascade down the side onto the stovetop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the overflowing water instantly vaporize into a thick, billowing cloud of white steam upon hitting the hot stovetop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2582548260688782 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6332547664642334 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2582548260688782, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2582548260688782, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17107844352722168, + 0.05219465121626854, + 0.057247430086135864, + 0.048764485865831375, + 0.09976131469011307, + 0.027987580746412277, + 0.0879557728767395, + 0.0689854547381401, + 0.26305529475212097, + 0.12296953052282333 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2582548260688782 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static, eye-level medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a well-used stainless steel saucepan with a scratched surface visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the water inside the saucepan boiling violently with large, turbulent bubbles and a chaotic froth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the boiling water surge over the pan's rim and cascade down the side onto the stovetop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the overflowing water instantly vaporize into a thick, billowing cloud of white steam upon hitting the hot stovetop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06210687756538391 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8121068477630615 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06210687756538391, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06210687756538391, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12414044886827469, + 0.08285292237997055, + 0.10067842900753021, + 0.05149379000067711, + 0.07875549793243408, + 0.043517518788576126, + 0.05540139228105545, + 0.027353573590517044, + 0.19024479389190674, + 0.2455616146326065 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06210687756538391 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static, eye-level medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a well-used stainless steel saucepan with a scratched surface visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the water inside the saucepan boiling violently with large, turbulent bubbles and a chaotic froth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the boiling water surge over the pan's rim and cascade down the side onto the stovetop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the overflowing water instantly vaporize into a thick, billowing cloud of white steam upon hitting the hot stovetop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.38710740208625793 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1371073722839355 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.38710740208625793, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.38710740208625793, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.027755534276366234, + 0.0223540011793375, + 0.037544894963502884, + 0.02912568859755993, + 0.059949371963739395, + 0.0786370038986206, + 0.02350759506225586, + 0.01629706099629402, + 0.10950937122106552, + 0.5953195095062256 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.38710740208625793 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static, eye-level medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a well-used stainless steel saucepan with a scratched surface visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the water inside the saucepan boiling violently with large, turbulent bubbles and a chaotic froth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the boiling water surge over the pan's rim and cascade down the side onto the stovetop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the overflowing water instantly vaporize into a thick, billowing cloud of white steam upon hitting the hot stovetop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17991195619106293 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8049119710922241 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17991195619106293, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17991195619106293, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11807624995708466, + 0.04809984937310219, + 0.11020022630691528, + 0.12519653141498566, + 0.0815938264131546, + 0.060722317546606064, + 0.15210892260074615, + 0.06120915338397026, + 0.13994543254375458, + 0.10284746438264847 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17991195619106293 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static, eye-level medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a well-used stainless steel saucepan with a scratched surface visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the water inside the saucepan boiling violently with large, turbulent bubbles and a chaotic froth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the boiling water surge over the pan's rim and cascade down the side onto the stovetop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the overflowing water instantly vaporize into a thick, billowing cloud of white steam upon hitting the hot stovetop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.38715946674346924 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1371594667434692 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.38715946674346924, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.38715946674346924, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.029706040397286415, + 0.022969502955675125, + 0.023122021928429604, + 0.10923067480325699, + 0.05205380916595459, + 0.06483842432498932, + 0.01872451975941658, + 0.019227154552936554, + 0.16975685954093933, + 0.4903710186481476 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.38715946674346924 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_13/index_tensor([5221, 5221])_group_13_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_13/index_tensor([5221, 5221])_group_13_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..5254d8a587490ada7616c5cb5dab736e3eefa44f --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_13/index_tensor([5221, 5221])_group_13_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "wide-angle, fixed shot, captured from a slightly upward angle, captures a precipitous cliff face reminiscent of an ancient martial arts world. A bottomless chasm, shrouded in mist, adds a touch of mystery to the breathtaking scene. A wooden suspension bridge, under construction, spans two peaks. Its structure is incomplete, consisting solely of a few thick hemp ropes supporting the structure and a few scattered planks. Several craftsmen, dressed in dark blue and gray-brown coarse shirts, risk their lives working on the cliff edge and the bridge itself. Among them, an experienced craftsman, his face deeply wrinkled by the frost, stood firmly on the cliff's edge, carefully handing a heavy log to his companion dangling from the cables. Another young, muscular craftsman, clinging to the ropes with the dexterity of an ape, reached out his calloused hands to take the plank. Then, with a heavy mallet, he steadily and powerfully hammered the tenon into the prepared mortise, his movements precise and decisive. Under the soft, diffuse light of an overcast sky, the entire scene took on a hushed and solemn hue. The cool gray of the rock, the warm brown of the wood, and the dark hues of the craftsmen's clothing intertwined. Sweat shimmered on their bronzed skin. Their expressions were remarkably focused, without a trace of fear. Together, they created an atmosphere of tension and solemnity, akin to humanity's remarkable skill and courage in the face of majestic nature, a magnificent creation wrought with immense skill and courage.", + "seed": 2865, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_13/index_5221_seed_2865_dp_26_rank_52_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.08320328027475625, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08320328027475625, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.4, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08320328027475625, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a precipitous cliff face with a bottomless chasm shrouded in mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a wooden suspension bridge under construction visible, consisting of thick hemp ropes and scattered planks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are several craftsmen visible wearing dark blue and gray-brown coarse shirts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a young muscular craftsman shown hammering a tenon into a mortise with a heavy mallet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured as a wide-angle, fixed shot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.127337247133255 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1273372173309326 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.127337247133255, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.127337247133255, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19530555605888367, + 0.2546653747558594, + 0.06872963160276413, + 0.042886942625045776, + 0.037342462688684464, + 0.10067758709192276, + 0.0304892435669899, + 0.07913333177566528, + 0.055688731372356415, + 0.13508111238479614 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.127337247133255 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a precipitous cliff face with a bottomless chasm shrouded in mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a wooden suspension bridge under construction visible, consisting of thick hemp ropes and scattered planks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are several craftsmen visible wearing dark blue and gray-brown coarse shirts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a young muscular craftsman shown hammering a tenon into a mortise with a heavy mallet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured as a wide-angle, fixed shot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012551834806799889 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387551784515381 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012551834806799889, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012551834806799889, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07119479030370712, + 0.0262265894562006, + 0.17849719524383545, + 0.1369740217924118, + 0.04330716282129288, + 0.075241819024086, + 0.02096601203083992, + 0.24252058565616608, + 0.09761372208595276, + 0.10745802521705627 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012551834806799889 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a precipitous cliff face with a bottomless chasm shrouded in mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a wooden suspension bridge under construction visible, consisting of thick hemp ropes and scattered planks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are several craftsmen visible wearing dark blue and gray-brown coarse shirts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a young muscular craftsman shown hammering a tenon into a mortise with a heavy mallet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured as a wide-angle, fixed shot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0019412260735407472 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.251941204071045 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0019412260735407472, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0019412260735407472, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.081257164478302, + 0.08225342631340027, + 0.02767929434776306, + 0.09566745162010193, + 0.15302713215351105, + 0.05997597798705101, + 0.04810697212815285, + 0.3091461956501007, + 0.07445571571588516, + 0.06843075156211853 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0019412260735407472 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a precipitous cliff face with a bottomless chasm shrouded in mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a wooden suspension bridge under construction visible, consisting of thick hemp ropes and scattered planks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are several craftsmen visible wearing dark blue and gray-brown coarse shirts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a young muscular craftsman shown hammering a tenon into a mortise with a heavy mallet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured as a wide-angle, fixed shot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04865739122033119 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486574172973633 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04865739122033119, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04865739122033119, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08899636566638947, + 0.0490993931889534, + 0.10532349348068237, + 0.04581597074866295, + 0.19099220633506775, + 0.02228710986673832, + 0.03464096412062645, + 0.31172123551368713, + 0.0751289427280426, + 0.0759943351149559 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04865739122033119 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a precipitous cliff face with a bottomless chasm shrouded in mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a wooden suspension bridge under construction visible, consisting of thick hemp ropes and scattered planks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are several craftsmen visible wearing dark blue and gray-brown coarse shirts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a young muscular craftsman shown hammering a tenon into a mortise with a heavy mallet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured as a wide-angle, fixed shot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22552870213985443 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6005287170410156 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.22552870213985443, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.22552870213985443, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10175670683383942, + 0.09273052960634232, + 0.06859312206506729, + 0.05534352734684944, + 0.045023396611213684, + 0.052377283573150635, + 0.10772231221199036, + 0.25485143065452576, + 0.14344637095928192, + 0.07815535366535187 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.22552870213985443 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "wide-angle, fixed shot, captured from a slightly upward angle, captures a precipitous cliff face reminiscent of an ancient martial arts world. A bottomless chasm, shrouded in mist, adds a touch of mystery to the breathtaking scene. A wooden suspension bridge, under construction, spans two peaks. Its structure is incomplete, consisting solely of a few thick hemp ropes supporting the structure and a few scattered planks. Several craftsmen, dressed in dark blue and gray-brown coarse shirts, risk their lives working on the cliff edge and the bridge itself. Among them, an experienced craftsman, his face deeply wrinkled by the frost, stood firmly on the cliff's edge, carefully handing a heavy log to his companion dangling from the cables. Another young, muscular craftsman, clinging to the ropes with the dexterity of an ape, reached out his calloused hands to take the plank. Then, with a heavy mallet, he steadily and powerfully hammered the tenon into the prepared mortise, his movements precise and decisive. Under the soft, diffuse light of an overcast sky, the entire scene took on a hushed and solemn hue. The cool gray of the rock, the warm brown of the wood, and the dark hues of the craftsmen's clothing intertwined. Sweat shimmered on their bronzed skin. Their expressions were remarkably focused, without a trace of fear. Together, they created an atmosphere of tension and solemnity, akin to humanity's remarkable skill and courage in the face of majestic nature, a magnificent creation wrought with immense skill and courage.", + "seed": 2866, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_13/index_5221_seed_2866_dp_26_rank_52_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.07494059009477497, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07494059009477497, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.25, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07494059009477497, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a precipitous cliff face with a bottomless chasm shrouded in mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a wooden suspension bridge under construction visible, consisting of thick hemp ropes and scattered planks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are several craftsmen visible wearing dark blue and gray-brown coarse shirts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a young muscular craftsman shown hammering a tenon into a mortise with a heavy mallet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured as a wide-angle, fixed shot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.18002846837043762 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8050284385681152 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.18002846837043762, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.18002846837043762, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24943339824676514, + 0.14512169361114502, + 0.08816218376159668, + 0.09163948148488998, + 0.10093758255243301, + 0.059651099145412445, + 0.07012748718261719, + 0.027654511854052544, + 0.1011798158288002, + 0.06609275192022324 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.18002846837043762 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a precipitous cliff face with a bottomless chasm shrouded in mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a wooden suspension bridge under construction visible, consisting of thick hemp ropes and scattered planks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are several craftsmen visible wearing dark blue and gray-brown coarse shirts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a young muscular craftsman shown hammering a tenon into a mortise with a heavy mallet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured as a wide-angle, fixed shot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004102386999875307 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.5041022300720215 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004102386999875307, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004102386999875307, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.31087538599967957, + 0.16736732423305511, + 0.04852748289704323, + 0.1311502605676651, + 0.06190843880176544, + 0.0411493293941021, + 0.1267816722393036, + 0.02500978671014309, + 0.03792262449860573, + 0.049307771027088165 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004102386999875307 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a precipitous cliff face with a bottomless chasm shrouded in mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a wooden suspension bridge under construction visible, consisting of thick hemp ropes and scattered planks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are several craftsmen visible wearing dark blue and gray-brown coarse shirts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a young muscular craftsman shown hammering a tenon into a mortise with a heavy mallet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured as a wide-angle, fixed shot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012534175999462605 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387534141540527 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012534175999462605, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012534175999462605, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2861076295375824, + 0.06034430116415024, + 0.036609988659620285, + 0.106557197868824, + 0.10037427395582199, + 0.09283047169446945, + 0.05139414593577385, + 0.05621205270290375, + 0.03003990650177002, + 0.17952996492385864 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012534175999462605 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a precipitous cliff face with a bottomless chasm shrouded in mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a wooden suspension bridge under construction visible, consisting of thick hemp ropes and scattered planks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are several craftsmen visible wearing dark blue and gray-brown coarse shirts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a young muscular craftsman shown hammering a tenon into a mortise with a heavy mallet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured as a wide-angle, fixed shot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08903073519468307 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4640307426452637 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08903073519468307, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08903073519468307, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.27850645780563354, + 0.04537444934248924, + 0.07077658921480179, + 0.0720459446310997, + 0.06707695126533508, + 0.0580868273973465, + 0.08741579949855804, + 0.16308480501174927, + 0.05511076748371124, + 0.1025213748216629 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08903073519468307 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a precipitous cliff face with a bottomless chasm shrouded in mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a wooden suspension bridge under construction visible, consisting of thick hemp ropes and scattered planks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are several craftsmen visible wearing dark blue and gray-brown coarse shirts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a young muscular craftsman shown hammering a tenon into a mortise with a heavy mallet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured as a wide-angle, fixed shot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0890071839094162 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4640071392059326 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0890071839094162, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0890071839094162, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.30424779653549194, + 0.06166376546025276, + 0.03686487302184105, + 0.03557094931602478, + 0.0759667158126831, + 0.09243738651275635, + 0.05222285911440849, + 0.0830225721001625, + 0.22414451837539673, + 0.03385863080620766 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0890071839094162 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "wide-angle, fixed shot, captured from a slightly upward angle, captures a precipitous cliff face reminiscent of an ancient martial arts world. A bottomless chasm, shrouded in mist, adds a touch of mystery to the breathtaking scene. A wooden suspension bridge, under construction, spans two peaks. Its structure is incomplete, consisting solely of a few thick hemp ropes supporting the structure and a few scattered planks. Several craftsmen, dressed in dark blue and gray-brown coarse shirts, risk their lives working on the cliff edge and the bridge itself. Among them, an experienced craftsman, his face deeply wrinkled by the frost, stood firmly on the cliff's edge, carefully handing a heavy log to his companion dangling from the cables. Another young, muscular craftsman, clinging to the ropes with the dexterity of an ape, reached out his calloused hands to take the plank. Then, with a heavy mallet, he steadily and powerfully hammered the tenon into the prepared mortise, his movements precise and decisive. Under the soft, diffuse light of an overcast sky, the entire scene took on a hushed and solemn hue. The cool gray of the rock, the warm brown of the wood, and the dark hues of the craftsmen's clothing intertwined. Sweat shimmered on their bronzed skin. Their expressions were remarkably focused, without a trace of fear. Together, they created an atmosphere of tension and solemnity, akin to humanity's remarkable skill and courage in the face of majestic nature, a magnificent creation wrought with immense skill and courage.", + "seed": 2867, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_13/index_5221_seed_2867_dp_27_rank_54_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.11312494538724423, + "vlm_logprob": -0.11312494538724423, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.550000023841858, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.11312494538724423, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a precipitous cliff face with a bottomless chasm shrouded in mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a wooden suspension bridge under construction visible, consisting of thick hemp ropes and scattered planks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are several craftsmen visible wearing dark blue and gray-brown coarse shirts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a young muscular craftsman shown hammering a tenon into a mortise with a heavy mallet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured as a wide-angle, fixed shot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1800657957792282 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8050657510757446 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1800657957792282, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1800657957792282, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13040590286254883, + 0.101909339427948, + 0.12720440328121185, + 0.07026595622301102, + 0.09230756759643555, + 0.17824089527130127, + 0.0700199231505394, + 0.032619427889585495, + 0.11135499179363251, + 0.08567161113023758 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1800657957792282 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a precipitous cliff face with a bottomless chasm shrouded in mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a wooden suspension bridge under construction visible, consisting of thick hemp ropes and scattered planks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are several craftsmen visible wearing dark blue and gray-brown coarse shirts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a young muscular craftsman shown hammering a tenon into a mortise with a heavy mallet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured as a wide-angle, fixed shot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020600758492946625 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8956007957458496 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020600758492946625, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020600758492946625, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.061922647058963776, + 0.1146925762295723, + 0.05883294343948364, + 0.05146404728293419, + 0.09325144439935684, + 0.0475902184844017, + 0.09600458294153214, + 0.08157477527856827, + 0.18182021379470825, + 0.21284648776054382 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020600758492946625 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a precipitous cliff face with a bottomless chasm shrouded in mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a wooden suspension bridge under construction visible, consisting of thick hemp ropes and scattered planks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are several craftsmen visible wearing dark blue and gray-brown coarse shirts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a young muscular craftsman shown hammering a tenon into a mortise with a heavy mallet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured as a wide-angle, fixed shot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020584410056471825 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955843448638916 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020584410056471825, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020584410056471825, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10796909034252167, + 0.09923700988292694, + 0.030982427299022675, + 0.029762564226984978, + 0.0972442552447319, + 0.09051579236984253, + 0.16020792722702026, + 0.18534180521965027, + 0.0986068844795227, + 0.10013221204280853 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020584410056471825 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a precipitous cliff face with a bottomless chasm shrouded in mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a wooden suspension bridge under construction visible, consisting of thick hemp ropes and scattered planks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are several craftsmen visible wearing dark blue and gray-brown coarse shirts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a young muscular craftsman shown hammering a tenon into a mortise with a heavy mallet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured as a wide-angle, fixed shot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14282360672950745 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0178236961364746 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14282360672950745, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.8750001192092896, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14282360672950745, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03911142796278, + 0.05865425616502762, + 0.022058961912989616, + 0.06174987927079201, + 0.07469990104436874, + 0.16581015288829803, + 0.1329861879348755, + 0.13861344754695892, + 0.057760439813137054, + 0.24855534732341766 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14282360672950745 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a precipitous cliff face with a bottomless chasm shrouded in mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a wooden suspension bridge under construction visible, consisting of thick hemp ropes and scattered planks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are several craftsmen visible wearing dark blue and gray-brown coarse shirts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a young muscular craftsman shown hammering a tenon into a mortise with a heavy mallet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured as a wide-angle, fixed shot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20155015587806702 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7015501260757446 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20155015587806702, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20155015587806702, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.037071894854307175, + 0.034222785383462906, + 0.04150654003024101, + 0.09013751894235611, + 0.24256235361099243, + 0.17245374619960785, + 0.03984636440873146, + 0.09525556862354279, + 0.1452600061893463, + 0.10168325155973434 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20155015587806702 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "wide-angle, fixed shot, captured from a slightly upward angle, captures a precipitous cliff face reminiscent of an ancient martial arts world. A bottomless chasm, shrouded in mist, adds a touch of mystery to the breathtaking scene. A wooden suspension bridge, under construction, spans two peaks. Its structure is incomplete, consisting solely of a few thick hemp ropes supporting the structure and a few scattered planks. Several craftsmen, dressed in dark blue and gray-brown coarse shirts, risk their lives working on the cliff edge and the bridge itself. Among them, an experienced craftsman, his face deeply wrinkled by the frost, stood firmly on the cliff's edge, carefully handing a heavy log to his companion dangling from the cables. Another young, muscular craftsman, clinging to the ropes with the dexterity of an ape, reached out his calloused hands to take the plank. Then, with a heavy mallet, he steadily and powerfully hammered the tenon into the prepared mortise, his movements precise and decisive. Under the soft, diffuse light of an overcast sky, the entire scene took on a hushed and solemn hue. The cool gray of the rock, the warm brown of the wood, and the dark hues of the craftsmen's clothing intertwined. Sweat shimmered on their bronzed skin. Their expressions were remarkably focused, without a trace of fear. Together, they created an atmosphere of tension and solemnity, akin to humanity's remarkable skill and courage in the face of majestic nature, a magnificent creation wrought with immense skill and courage.", + "seed": 2868, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_13/index_5221_seed_2868_dp_27_rank_54_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.03950814509298652, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03950814509298652, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.8, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03950814509298652, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a precipitous cliff face with a bottomless chasm shrouded in mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a wooden suspension bridge under construction visible, consisting of thick hemp ropes and scattered planks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are several craftsmen visible wearing dark blue and gray-brown coarse shirts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a young muscular craftsman shown hammering a tenon into a mortise with a heavy mallet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured as a wide-angle, fixed shot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07925114035606384 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5792510509490967 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07925114035606384, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07925114035606384, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17890040576457977, + 0.10752241313457489, + 0.05549192801117897, + 0.09546172618865967, + 0.0651148110628128, + 0.03861561045050621, + 0.04176250472664833, + 0.16757404804229736, + 0.2004237323999405, + 0.0491328164935112 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07925114035606384 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a precipitous cliff face with a bottomless chasm shrouded in mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a wooden suspension bridge under construction visible, consisting of thick hemp ropes and scattered planks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are several craftsmen visible wearing dark blue and gray-brown coarse shirts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a young muscular craftsman shown hammering a tenon into a mortise with a heavy mallet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured as a wide-angle, fixed shot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023297041654586792 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773297071456909 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023297041654586792, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023297041654586792, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.28934574127197266, + 0.1282711625099182, + 0.07868393510580063, + 0.07207836955785751, + 0.09379684180021286, + 0.048257432878017426, + 0.12032908946275711, + 0.04445699602365494, + 0.07572977989912033, + 0.04905068501830101 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023297041654586792 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a precipitous cliff face with a bottomless chasm shrouded in mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a wooden suspension bridge under construction visible, consisting of thick hemp ropes and scattered planks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are several craftsmen visible wearing dark blue and gray-brown coarse shirts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a young muscular craftsman shown hammering a tenon into a mortise with a heavy mallet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured as a wide-angle, fixed shot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0017145470483228564 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.376714706420898 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0017145470483228564, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0017145470483228564, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16948211193084717, + 0.10339456051588058, + 0.15960368514060974, + 0.08778734505176544, + 0.04852963984012604, + 0.041435472667217255, + 0.0797102227807045, + 0.08251798152923584, + 0.13683053851127625, + 0.09070843458175659 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0017145470483228564 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a precipitous cliff face with a bottomless chasm shrouded in mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a wooden suspension bridge under construction visible, consisting of thick hemp ropes and scattered planks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are several craftsmen visible wearing dark blue and gray-brown coarse shirts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a young muscular craftsman shown hammering a tenon into a mortise with a heavy mallet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured as a wide-angle, fixed shot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023285744711756706 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732856273651123 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023285744711756706, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023285744711756706, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18942829966545105, + 0.1083722934126854, + 0.1872652918100357, + 0.13290272653102875, + 0.06904833018779755, + 0.018741119652986526, + 0.049329984933137894, + 0.10368052124977112, + 0.06579361110925674, + 0.07543785125017166 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023285744711756706 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a precipitous cliff face with a bottomless chasm shrouded in mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a wooden suspension bridge under construction visible, consisting of thick hemp ropes and scattered planks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are several craftsmen visible wearing dark blue and gray-brown coarse shirts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a young muscular craftsman shown hammering a tenon into a mortise with a heavy mallet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured as a wide-angle, fixed shot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06999225169420242 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6949923038482666 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06999225169420242, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06999225169420242, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12414547801017761, + 0.057862963527441025, + 0.09857001900672913, + 0.06816070526838303, + 0.07054789364337921, + 0.12642885744571686, + 0.241287961602211, + 0.05257783085107803, + 0.05225522816181183, + 0.10816309601068497 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06999225169420242 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_14/index_tensor([598, 598])_group_14_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_14/index_tensor([598, 598])_group_14_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..987bba88e0fb77639ebba70205c392165d8bb1af --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_14/index_tensor([598, 598])_group_14_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "long shot, taken slightly from above, pans smoothly to the right to capture the full action. Under the glaring yet clear sunlight of the highlands, a robust adult snow leopard leaps decisively and swiftly from the edge of a steep, dark, snow-covered rock face. Its body unfurls in a graceful, nearly horizontal arc as it soars over a precipitous abyss, its limbs fully extended. Its powerful hind legs have just completed their final push, and its front paws are already aimed at the rock platform on the other side. Its thick, pale fur, speckled with smoky gray rings, rustles gently in the thin air, and its signature long, thick tail, like a furry rudder, gracefully swings behind it to maintain perfect balance. The sunlight casts sharp shadows on the jagged rock face and the white snow, contrasting sharply against the thin, azure sky. The entire image is imbued with a cold, pure hue, creating an atmosphere of grandeur, pristine beauty, and a vibrant vitality.", + "seed": 24257, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_14/index_598_seed_24257_dp_28_rank_56_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.0154995669843629, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0154995669843629, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 5.175, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0154995669843629, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a robust adult snow leopard with thick pale fur speckled with smoky gray rings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the snow leopard leaping from a steep, dark, snow-covered rock face towards another rock platform across an abyss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the snow leopard's body in a nearly horizontal arc with fully extended limbs, hind legs pushing off, and front paws aimed at the landing platform?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a highland setting with glaring clear sunlight, sharp shadows on jagged rocks, and a thin azure sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a long shot taken slightly from above that pans smoothly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.013603601604700089 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.388603687286377 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.013603601604700089, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.013603601604700089, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10221648216247559, + 0.10964802652597427, + 0.1461029052734375, + 0.056978799402713776, + 0.06553833931684494, + 0.07924246042966843, + 0.18455833196640015, + 0.0617404505610466, + 0.06522184610366821, + 0.12875238060951233 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 2, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.013603601604700089 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a robust adult snow leopard with thick pale fur speckled with smoky gray rings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the snow leopard leaping from a steep, dark, snow-covered rock face towards another rock platform across an abyss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the snow leopard's body in a nearly horizontal arc with fully extended limbs, hind legs pushing off, and front paws aimed at the landing platform?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a highland setting with glaring clear sunlight, sharp shadows on jagged rocks, and a thin azure sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a long shot taken slightly from above that pans smoothly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006752174347639084 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006752014160156 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006752174347639084, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006752174347639084, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09337299317121506, + 0.12103240191936493, + 0.28311121463775635, + 0.03625280782580376, + 0.05373981222510338, + 0.03699735924601555, + 0.03626009821891785, + 0.2129032462835312, + 0.04827732965350151, + 0.07805279642343521 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006752174347639084 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a robust adult snow leopard with thick pale fur speckled with smoky gray rings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the snow leopard leaping from a steep, dark, snow-covered rock face towards another rock platform across an abyss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the snow leopard's body in a nearly horizontal arc with fully extended limbs, hind legs pushing off, and front paws aimed at the landing platform?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a highland setting with glaring clear sunlight, sharp shadows on jagged rocks, and a thin azure sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a long shot taken slightly from above that pans smoothly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.001042656716890633 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.87604284286499 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.001042656716890633, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.001042656716890633, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16528937220573425, + 0.1251513808965683, + 0.13592058420181274, + 0.04474029317498207, + 0.055558860301971436, + 0.052113424986600876, + 0.09318089485168457, + 0.1869782656431198, + 0.047410231083631516, + 0.09365665912628174 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.001042656716890633 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a robust adult snow leopard with thick pale fur speckled with smoky gray rings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the snow leopard leaping from a steep, dark, snow-covered rock face towards another rock platform across an abyss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the snow leopard's body in a nearly horizontal arc with fully extended limbs, hind legs pushing off, and front paws aimed at the landing platform?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a highland setting with glaring clear sunlight, sharp shadows on jagged rocks, and a thin azure sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a long shot taken slightly from above that pans smoothly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0011781663633883 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.75117826461792 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0011781663633883, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0011781663633883, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.37912794947624207, + 0.09299010783433914, + 0.16937367618083954, + 0.029015041887760162, + 0.07945003360509872, + 0.04286068677902222, + 0.05130903795361519, + 0.07201451063156128, + 0.02292875200510025, + 0.060930151492357254 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0011781663633883 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a robust adult snow leopard with thick pale fur speckled with smoky gray rings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the snow leopard leaping from a steep, dark, snow-covered rock face towards another rock platform across an abyss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the snow leopard's body in a nearly horizontal arc with fully extended limbs, hind legs pushing off, and front paws aimed at the landing platform?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a highland setting with glaring clear sunlight, sharp shadows on jagged rocks, and a thin azure sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a long shot taken slightly from above that pans smoothly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.054921235889196396 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299211502075195 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.054921235889196396, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.054921235889196396, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1720668077468872, + 0.16746889054775238, + 0.11921782046556473, + 0.07064688205718994, + 0.10277431458234787, + 0.07887540012598038, + 0.08787623792886734, + 0.0672273263335228, + 0.07453881949186325, + 0.059307508170604706 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.054921235889196396 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "long shot, taken slightly from above, pans smoothly to the right to capture the full action. Under the glaring yet clear sunlight of the highlands, a robust adult snow leopard leaps decisively and swiftly from the edge of a steep, dark, snow-covered rock face. Its body unfurls in a graceful, nearly horizontal arc as it soars over a precipitous abyss, its limbs fully extended. Its powerful hind legs have just completed their final push, and its front paws are already aimed at the rock platform on the other side. Its thick, pale fur, speckled with smoky gray rings, rustles gently in the thin air, and its signature long, thick tail, like a furry rudder, gracefully swings behind it to maintain perfect balance. The sunlight casts sharp shadows on the jagged rock face and the white snow, contrasting sharply against the thin, azure sky. The entire image is imbued with a cold, pure hue, creating an atmosphere of grandeur, pristine beauty, and a vibrant vitality.", + "seed": 24258, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_14/index_598_seed_24258_dp_28_rank_56_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.017042834125459195, + "vlm_logprob": -0.017042834125459195, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.7, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.017042834125459195, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a robust adult snow leopard with thick pale fur speckled with smoky gray rings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the snow leopard leaping from a steep, dark, snow-covered rock face towards another rock platform across an abyss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the snow leopard's body in a nearly horizontal arc with fully extended limbs, hind legs pushing off, and front paws aimed at the landing platform?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a highland setting with glaring clear sunlight, sharp shadows on jagged rocks, and a thin azure sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a long shot taken slightly from above that pans smoothly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02433571219444275 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7743356227874756 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02433571219444275, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02433571219444275, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11790429055690765, + 0.10914650559425354, + 0.022993722930550575, + 0.050861258059740067, + 0.030290046706795692, + 0.04933057725429535, + 0.1823592483997345, + 0.17800888419151306, + 0.1890496015548706, + 0.07005587220191956 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02433571219444275 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a robust adult snow leopard with thick pale fur speckled with smoky gray rings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the snow leopard leaping from a steep, dark, snow-covered rock face towards another rock platform across an abyss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the snow leopard's body in a nearly horizontal arc with fully extended limbs, hind legs pushing off, and front paws aimed at the landing platform?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a highland setting with glaring clear sunlight, sharp shadows on jagged rocks, and a thin azure sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a long shot taken slightly from above that pans smoothly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00595770264044404 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.13095760345459 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00595770264044404, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00595770264044404, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12350211292505264, + 0.0940149798989296, + 0.04689174145460129, + 0.0551806204020977, + 0.09382651746273041, + 0.1043267697095871, + 0.11898735165596008, + 0.12030855566263199, + 0.14152421057224274, + 0.10143707692623138 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00595770264044404 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a robust adult snow leopard with thick pale fur speckled with smoky gray rings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the snow leopard leaping from a steep, dark, snow-covered rock face towards another rock platform across an abyss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the snow leopard's body in a nearly horizontal arc with fully extended limbs, hind legs pushing off, and front paws aimed at the landing platform?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a highland setting with glaring clear sunlight, sharp shadows on jagged rocks, and a thin azure sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a long shot taken slightly from above that pans smoothly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0021974719129502773 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127197265625 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0021974719129502773, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0021974719129502773, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.163225457072258, + 0.06558331847190857, + 0.03206266462802887, + 0.057398974895477295, + 0.09081993997097015, + 0.06785344332456589, + 0.10827172547578812, + 0.13874690234661102, + 0.138814777135849, + 0.13722287118434906 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0021974719129502773 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a robust adult snow leopard with thick pale fur speckled with smoky gray rings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the snow leopard leaping from a steep, dark, snow-covered rock face towards another rock platform across an abyss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the snow leopard's body in a nearly horizontal arc with fully extended limbs, hind legs pushing off, and front paws aimed at the landing platform?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a highland setting with glaring clear sunlight, sharp shadows on jagged rocks, and a thin azure sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a long shot taken slightly from above that pans smoothly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004093601368367672 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504093647003174 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004093601368367672, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004093601368367672, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18954412639141083, + 0.09203774482011795, + 0.033805664628744125, + 0.05340378358960152, + 0.03995046392083168, + 0.08130911737680435, + 0.09241028130054474, + 0.2193310260772705, + 0.08502769470214844, + 0.11318011581897736 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004093601368367672 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a robust adult snow leopard with thick pale fur speckled with smoky gray rings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the snow leopard leaping from a steep, dark, snow-covered rock face towards another rock platform across an abyss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the snow leopard's body in a nearly horizontal arc with fully extended limbs, hind legs pushing off, and front paws aimed at the landing platform?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a highland setting with glaring clear sunlight, sharp shadows on jagged rocks, and a thin azure sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a long shot taken slightly from above that pans smoothly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04862968251109123 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486297607421875 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04862968251109123, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04862968251109123, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1779615879058838, + 0.08907493948936462, + 0.07812348008155823, + 0.15271200239658356, + 0.06638134270906448, + 0.15424424409866333, + 0.07199454307556152, + 0.08739688247442245, + 0.0592096745967865, + 0.06290137767791748 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04862968251109123 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "long shot, taken slightly from above, pans smoothly to the right to capture the full action. Under the glaring yet clear sunlight of the highlands, a robust adult snow leopard leaps decisively and swiftly from the edge of a steep, dark, snow-covered rock face. Its body unfurls in a graceful, nearly horizontal arc as it soars over a precipitous abyss, its limbs fully extended. Its powerful hind legs have just completed their final push, and its front paws are already aimed at the rock platform on the other side. Its thick, pale fur, speckled with smoky gray rings, rustles gently in the thin air, and its signature long, thick tail, like a furry rudder, gracefully swings behind it to maintain perfect balance. The sunlight casts sharp shadows on the jagged rock face and the white snow, contrasting sharply against the thin, azure sky. The entire image is imbued with a cold, pure hue, creating an atmosphere of grandeur, pristine beauty, and a vibrant vitality.", + "seed": 24259, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_14/index_598_seed_24259_dp_29_rank_58_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.016539761377498508, + "vlm_logprob": -0.016539761377498508, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.8, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.016539761377498508, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a robust adult snow leopard with thick pale fur speckled with smoky gray rings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the snow leopard leaping from a steep, dark, snow-covered rock face towards another rock platform across an abyss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the snow leopard's body in a nearly horizontal arc with fully extended limbs, hind legs pushing off, and front paws aimed at the landing platform?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a highland setting with glaring clear sunlight, sharp shadows on jagged rocks, and a thin azure sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a long shot taken slightly from above that pans smoothly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012002037838101387 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.512001991271973 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012002037838101387, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012002037838101387, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5920155644416809, + 0.03640824928879738, + 0.025624556466937065, + 0.02625579945743084, + 0.10651244968175888, + 0.033344149589538574, + 0.02279147505760193, + 0.050627488642930984, + 0.05779583379626274, + 0.04862435907125473 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012002037838101387 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a robust adult snow leopard with thick pale fur speckled with smoky gray rings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the snow leopard leaping from a steep, dark, snow-covered rock face towards another rock platform across an abyss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the snow leopard's body in a nearly horizontal arc with fully extended limbs, hind legs pushing off, and front paws aimed at the landing platform?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a highland setting with glaring clear sunlight, sharp shadows on jagged rocks, and a thin azure sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a long shot taken slightly from above that pans smoothly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011088181287050247 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.5110883712768555 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011088181287050247, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011088181287050247, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.6183102130889893, + 0.01948481611907482, + 0.022099634632468224, + 0.05293206870555878, + 0.04552936553955078, + 0.03552227467298508, + 0.023917850106954575, + 0.09091509878635406, + 0.04069804772734642, + 0.05059060826897621 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011088181287050247 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a robust adult snow leopard with thick pale fur speckled with smoky gray rings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the snow leopard leaping from a steep, dark, snow-covered rock face towards another rock platform across an abyss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the snow leopard's body in a nearly horizontal arc with fully extended limbs, hind legs pushing off, and front paws aimed at the landing platform?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a highland setting with glaring clear sunlight, sharp shadows on jagged rocks, and a thin azure sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a long shot taken slightly from above that pans smoothly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00248873233795166 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002488613128662 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00248873233795166, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00248873233795166, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.6296480298042297, + 0.05670895054936409, + 0.018926234915852547, + 0.018432708457112312, + 0.03861382231116295, + 0.04851962625980377, + 0.017803112044930458, + 0.09348472207784653, + 0.01782570220530033, + 0.06003708764910698 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00248873233795166 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a robust adult snow leopard with thick pale fur speckled with smoky gray rings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the snow leopard leaping from a steep, dark, snow-covered rock face towards another rock platform across an abyss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the snow leopard's body in a nearly horizontal arc with fully extended limbs, hind legs pushing off, and front paws aimed at the landing platform?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a highland setting with glaring clear sunlight, sharp shadows on jagged rocks, and a thin azure sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a long shot taken slightly from above that pans smoothly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0021956877317279577 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127195835113525 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0021956877317279577, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0021956877317279577, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.635890543460846, + 0.05363154411315918, + 0.03888143226504326, + 0.06820885837078094, + 0.03596242517232895, + 0.026037558913230896, + 0.0484510101377964, + 0.024571767076849937, + 0.024569548666477203, + 0.04379531368613243 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0021956877317279577 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a robust adult snow leopard with thick pale fur speckled with smoky gray rings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the snow leopard leaping from a steep, dark, snow-covered rock face towards another rock platform across an abyss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the snow leopard's body in a nearly horizontal arc with fully extended limbs, hind legs pushing off, and front paws aimed at the landing platform?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a highland setting with glaring clear sunlight, sharp shadows on jagged rocks, and a thin azure sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a long shot taken slightly from above that pans smoothly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.054924167692661285 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929924249649048 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.054924167692661285, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.054924167692661285, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5913562774658203, + 0.1402929127216339, + 0.037337061017751694, + 0.02934432402253151, + 0.06498034298419952, + 0.023859914392232895, + 0.015489843674004078, + 0.029774852097034454, + 0.024270007386803627, + 0.04329447075724602 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.054924167692661285 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "long shot, taken slightly from above, pans smoothly to the right to capture the full action. Under the glaring yet clear sunlight of the highlands, a robust adult snow leopard leaps decisively and swiftly from the edge of a steep, dark, snow-covered rock face. Its body unfurls in a graceful, nearly horizontal arc as it soars over a precipitous abyss, its limbs fully extended. Its powerful hind legs have just completed their final push, and its front paws are already aimed at the rock platform on the other side. Its thick, pale fur, speckled with smoky gray rings, rustles gently in the thin air, and its signature long, thick tail, like a furry rudder, gracefully swings behind it to maintain perfect balance. The sunlight casts sharp shadows on the jagged rock face and the white snow, contrasting sharply against the thin, azure sky. The entire image is imbued with a cold, pure hue, creating an atmosphere of grandeur, pristine beauty, and a vibrant vitality.", + "seed": 24260, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_14/index_598_seed_24260_dp_29_rank_58_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.0312887845095247, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0312887845095247, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.425, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0312887845095247, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a robust adult snow leopard with thick pale fur speckled with smoky gray rings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the snow leopard leaping from a steep, dark, snow-covered rock face towards another rock platform across an abyss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the snow leopard's body in a nearly horizontal arc with fully extended limbs, hind legs pushing off, and front paws aimed at the landing platform?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a highland setting with glaring clear sunlight, sharp shadows on jagged rocks, and a thin azure sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a long shot taken slightly from above that pans smoothly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10138870030641556 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.351388692855835 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10138870030641556, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10138870030641556, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10023509711027145, + 0.029736116528511047, + 0.3025674819946289, + 0.012205083854496479, + 0.039781078696250916, + 0.07020896673202515, + 0.041445229202508926, + 0.03305842727422714, + 0.1625170111656189, + 0.20824545621871948 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10138870030641556 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a robust adult snow leopard with thick pale fur speckled with smoky gray rings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the snow leopard leaping from a steep, dark, snow-covered rock face towards another rock platform across an abyss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the snow leopard's body in a nearly horizontal arc with fully extended limbs, hind legs pushing off, and front paws aimed at the landing platform?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a highland setting with glaring clear sunlight, sharp shadows on jagged rocks, and a thin azure sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a long shot taken slightly from above that pans smoothly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020610684528946877 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8956105709075928 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020610684528946877, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020610684528946877, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23785282671451569, + 0.09190338850021362, + 0.276456743478775, + 0.0479925237596035, + 0.043909963220357895, + 0.03328925743699074, + 0.05700818821787834, + 0.02700969949364662, + 0.08162049204111099, + 0.10295695811510086 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020610684528946877 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a robust adult snow leopard with thick pale fur speckled with smoky gray rings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the snow leopard leaping from a steep, dark, snow-covered rock face towards another rock platform across an abyss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the snow leopard's body in a nearly horizontal arc with fully extended limbs, hind legs pushing off, and front paws aimed at the landing platform?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a highland setting with glaring clear sunlight, sharp shadows on jagged rocks, and a thin azure sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a long shot taken slightly from above that pans smoothly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036202622577548027 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628620147705078 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036202622577548027, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036202622577548027, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21276473999023438, + 0.04473091661930084, + 0.3313935101032257, + 0.041359253227710724, + 0.07446838915348053, + 0.09495570510625839, + 0.04944715276360512, + 0.04119023308157921, + 0.06944549828767776, + 0.04024466499686241 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036202622577548027 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a robust adult snow leopard with thick pale fur speckled with smoky gray rings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the snow leopard leaping from a steep, dark, snow-covered rock face towards another rock platform across an abyss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the snow leopard's body in a nearly horizontal arc with fully extended limbs, hind legs pushing off, and front paws aimed at the landing platform?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a highland setting with glaring clear sunlight, sharp shadows on jagged rocks, and a thin azure sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a long shot taken slightly from above that pans smoothly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0010412277188152075 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.876041412353516 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0010412277188152075, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0010412277188152075, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20984430611133575, + 0.07679008692502975, + 0.2779904901981354, + 0.02603810839354992, + 0.03224710002541542, + 0.036772388964891434, + 0.061913710087537766, + 0.049882203340530396, + 0.12445922940969467, + 0.10406237840652466 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0010412277188152075 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a robust adult snow leopard with thick pale fur speckled with smoky gray rings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the snow leopard leaping from a steep, dark, snow-covered rock face towards another rock platform across an abyss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the snow leopard's body in a nearly horizontal arc with fully extended limbs, hind legs pushing off, and front paws aimed at the landing platform?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a highland setting with glaring clear sunlight, sharp shadows on jagged rocks, and a thin azure sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a long shot taken slightly from above that pans smoothly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02978304773569107 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529783010482788 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02978304773569107, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02978304773569107, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2652169167995453, + 0.06146078556776047, + 0.1013745591044426, + 0.08658497780561447, + 0.03822670131921768, + 0.07439929246902466, + 0.05772961303591728, + 0.1528986543416977, + 0.09661602228879929, + 0.06549248844385147 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02978304773569107 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_15/index_tensor([1020, 1020])_group_15_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_15/index_tensor([1020, 1020])_group_15_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..ecd7a729144c3a0354c05b859d66cee0deae085e --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_15/index_tensor([1020, 1020])_group_15_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "Beginning with a wide-angle lens, the camera begins a slow, majestic forward trajectory, gliding through the silent, inky darkness of the infinite void, with only the faintest pinpricks of light from distant, out-of-focus stars hinting at the sheer scale of the emptiness. A luminous, ethereal tendril of pure energy gracefully enters the frame, emitting a vibrant inner glow that seamlessly shifts between electric blue, soft magenta, and shimmering gold. Rather than being solid, it resembles a translucent, flowing ribbon of light, composed of countless shimmering particles and trailing fine, wispy threads. This primary tendril soars purposefully through deep space, its movement a fluid, serpentine dance, steadily and purposefully tracing an invisible, complex path, tilting and curving as if sailing on a cosmic current. As it moves, the volumetric light it emits casts soft, colored glow into the immediate void, creating a breathtaking atmosphere of serene, mystical awe. Just as the viewer is completely captivated by this celestial ballet, the tendril's glow begins to gently dim, and the entire image, along with the last fading spark, smoothly and completely dissolves into absolute black.", + "seed": 28647, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_15/index_1020_seed_28647_dp_30_rank_60_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.2921221286058426, + "vlm_logprob": -0.2921221286058426, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.675, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.2921221286058426, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a wide-angle lens perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow forward trajectory through a dark void with distant out-of-focus stars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a luminous tendril of energy visible that shifts colors between electric blue, soft magenta, and shimmering gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tendril move in a fluid, serpentine motion while casting a volumetric glow into the void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the image and the tendril's glow smoothly dissolving into absolute black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7054607272148132 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7054607272148132 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.7054607272148132, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.7054607272148132, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11554094403982162, + 0.022058457136154175, + 0.03885630890727043, + 0.09235557168722153, + 0.19591058790683746, + 0.050521526485681534, + 0.04870646819472313, + 0.07368285953998566, + 0.28676387667655945, + 0.07560337334871292 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.7054607272148132 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a wide-angle lens perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow forward trajectory through a dark void with distant out-of-focus stars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a luminous tendril of energy visible that shifts colors between electric blue, soft magenta, and shimmering gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tendril move in a fluid, serpentine motion while casting a volumetric glow into the void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the image and the tendril's glow smoothly dissolving into absolute black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22567425668239594 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6006742715835571 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.22567425668239594, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.22567425668239594, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12644074857234955, + 0.053591832518577576, + 0.3175455629825592, + 0.0368569940328598, + 0.05698709934949875, + 0.11219615489244461, + 0.0640292540192604, + 0.14746591448783875, + 0.05254253000020981, + 0.03234387934207916 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.22567425668239594 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a wide-angle lens perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow forward trajectory through a dark void with distant out-of-focus stars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a luminous tendril of energy visible that shifts colors between electric blue, soft magenta, and shimmering gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tendril move in a fluid, serpentine motion while casting a volumetric glow into the void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the image and the tendril's glow smoothly dissolving into absolute black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036272702272981405 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628627300262451 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036272702272981405, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036272702272981405, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05905342847108841, + 0.05832973122596741, + 0.22006618976593018, + 0.036271482706069946, + 0.022699667140841484, + 0.10349549353122711, + 0.03647003322839737, + 0.36652007699012756, + 0.02555490843951702, + 0.07153896987438202 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036272702272981405 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a wide-angle lens perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow forward trajectory through a dark void with distant out-of-focus stars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a luminous tendril of energy visible that shifts colors between electric blue, soft magenta, and shimmering gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tendril move in a fluid, serpentine motion while casting a volumetric glow into the void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the image and the tendril's glow smoothly dissolving into absolute black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002488613361492753 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002488613128662 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002488613361492753, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002488613361492753, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07664676010608673, + 0.03733791038393974, + 0.0863570123910904, + 0.021622855216264725, + 0.05129975453019142, + 0.053666312247514725, + 0.061661336570978165, + 0.36459505558013916, + 0.06116858869791031, + 0.18564437329769135 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002488613361492753 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a wide-angle lens perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow forward trajectory through a dark void with distant out-of-focus stars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a luminous tendril of energy visible that shifts colors between electric blue, soft magenta, and shimmering gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tendril move in a fluid, serpentine motion while casting a volumetric glow into the void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the image and the tendril's glow smoothly dissolving into absolute black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5233597755432129 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8983597755432129 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5233597755432129, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5233597755432129, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.036225639283657074, + 0.02084934152662754, + 0.03691176697611809, + 0.08644803613424301, + 0.06951084733009338, + 0.10062995553016663, + 0.06569816917181015, + 0.27673614025115967, + 0.05964856967329979, + 0.24734145402908325 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5233597755432129 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "Beginning with a wide-angle lens, the camera begins a slow, majestic forward trajectory, gliding through the silent, inky darkness of the infinite void, with only the faintest pinpricks of light from distant, out-of-focus stars hinting at the sheer scale of the emptiness. A luminous, ethereal tendril of pure energy gracefully enters the frame, emitting a vibrant inner glow that seamlessly shifts between electric blue, soft magenta, and shimmering gold. Rather than being solid, it resembles a translucent, flowing ribbon of light, composed of countless shimmering particles and trailing fine, wispy threads. This primary tendril soars purposefully through deep space, its movement a fluid, serpentine dance, steadily and purposefully tracing an invisible, complex path, tilting and curving as if sailing on a cosmic current. As it moves, the volumetric light it emits casts soft, colored glow into the immediate void, creating a breathtaking atmosphere of serene, mystical awe. Just as the viewer is completely captivated by this celestial ballet, the tendril's glow begins to gently dim, and the entire image, along with the last fading spark, smoothly and completely dissolves into absolute black.", + "seed": 28648, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_15/index_1020_seed_28648_dp_30_rank_60_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.38516554404050113, + "vlm_logprob": -0.38516554404050113, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.65, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.38516554404050113, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.6, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a wide-angle lens perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow forward trajectory through a dark void with distant out-of-focus stars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a luminous tendril of energy visible that shifts colors between electric blue, soft magenta, and shimmering gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tendril move in a fluid, serpentine motion while casting a volumetric glow into the void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the image and the tendril's glow smoothly dissolving into absolute black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8415506482124329 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5915506482124329 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.8415506482124329, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.8415506482124329, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2296275794506073, + 0.06196035444736481, + 0.03688894212245941, + 0.0402691513299942, + 0.04313070699572563, + 0.07910886406898499, + 0.12583591043949127, + 0.2391280084848404, + 0.08421226590871811, + 0.059838153421878815 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.8415506482124329 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a wide-angle lens perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow forward trajectory through a dark void with distant out-of-focus stars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a luminous tendril of energy visible that shifts colors between electric blue, soft magenta, and shimmering gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tendril move in a fluid, serpentine motion while casting a volumetric glow into the void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the image and the tendril's glow smoothly dissolving into absolute black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3871987760066986 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.137198805809021 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3871987760066986, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3871987760066986, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08723215758800507, + 0.17546691000461578, + 0.08527884632349014, + 0.059674590826034546, + 0.1054677739739418, + 0.04974941536784172, + 0.11611358076334, + 0.06228787451982498, + 0.20437490940093994, + 0.05435388907790184 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3871987760066986 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a wide-angle lens perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow forward trajectory through a dark void with distant out-of-focus stars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a luminous tendril of energy visible that shifts colors between electric blue, soft magenta, and shimmering gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tendril move in a fluid, serpentine motion while casting a volumetric glow into the void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the image and the tendril's glow smoothly dissolving into absolute black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.001189954113215208 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.751190185546875 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.001189954113215208, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.001189954113215208, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15994104743003845, + 0.1739121824502945, + 0.035591430962085724, + 0.05176745355129242, + 0.07420716434717178, + 0.11061757057905197, + 0.06847745925188065, + 0.0596688911318779, + 0.06774239987134933, + 0.19807446002960205 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.001189954113215208 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a wide-angle lens perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow forward trajectory through a dark void with distant out-of-focus stars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a luminous tendril of energy visible that shifts colors between electric blue, soft magenta, and shimmering gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tendril move in a fluid, serpentine motion while casting a volumetric glow into the void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the image and the tendril's glow smoothly dissolving into absolute black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002488137688487768 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002488136291504 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002488137688487768, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002488137688487768, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1314449906349182, + 0.10599660873413086, + 0.035713594406843185, + 0.02533639408648014, + 0.0889071598649025, + 0.12821047008037567, + 0.20913010835647583, + 0.09662246704101562, + 0.11006143689155579, + 0.06857677549123764 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002488137688487768 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a wide-angle lens perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow forward trajectory through a dark void with distant out-of-focus stars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a luminous tendril of energy visible that shifts colors between electric blue, soft magenta, and shimmering gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tendril move in a fluid, serpentine motion while casting a volumetric glow into the void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the image and the tendril's glow smoothly dissolving into absolute black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6934002041816711 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6934002041816711 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.6934002041816711, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.6934002041816711, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05181240662932396, + 0.09053927659988403, + 0.04441719502210617, + 0.019985707476735115, + 0.10060498863458633, + 0.041903384029865265, + 0.42633751034736633, + 0.03903934359550476, + 0.03560798242688179, + 0.14975230395793915 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.6934002041816711 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "Beginning with a wide-angle lens, the camera begins a slow, majestic forward trajectory, gliding through the silent, inky darkness of the infinite void, with only the faintest pinpricks of light from distant, out-of-focus stars hinting at the sheer scale of the emptiness. A luminous, ethereal tendril of pure energy gracefully enters the frame, emitting a vibrant inner glow that seamlessly shifts between electric blue, soft magenta, and shimmering gold. Rather than being solid, it resembles a translucent, flowing ribbon of light, composed of countless shimmering particles and trailing fine, wispy threads. This primary tendril soars purposefully through deep space, its movement a fluid, serpentine dance, steadily and purposefully tracing an invisible, complex path, tilting and curving as if sailing on a cosmic current. As it moves, the volumetric light it emits casts soft, colored glow into the immediate void, creating a breathtaking atmosphere of serene, mystical awe. Just as the viewer is completely captivated by this celestial ballet, the tendril's glow begins to gently dim, and the entire image, along with the last fading spark, smoothly and completely dissolves into absolute black.", + "seed": 28649, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_15/index_1020_seed_28649_dp_31_rank_62_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.2985651113092899, + "vlm_logprob": -0.2985651113092899, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.875, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.2985651113092899, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a wide-angle lens perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow forward trajectory through a dark void with distant out-of-focus stars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a luminous tendril of energy visible that shifts colors between electric blue, soft magenta, and shimmering gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tendril move in a fluid, serpentine motion while casting a volumetric glow into the void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the image and the tendril's glow smoothly dissolving into absolute black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.0687586069107056 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4437585771083832 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.0687586069107056, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.625, + "token_credit_reward": -1.0687586069107056, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12171928584575653, + 0.09603473544120789, + 0.062111273407936096, + 0.048706162720918655, + 0.07834911346435547, + 0.28709641098976135, + 0.05050848796963692, + 0.07461041212081909, + 0.06880538165569305, + 0.11205875128507614 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.0687586069107056 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a wide-angle lens perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow forward trajectory through a dark void with distant out-of-focus stars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a luminous tendril of energy visible that shifts colors between electric blue, soft magenta, and shimmering gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tendril move in a fluid, serpentine motion while casting a volumetric glow into the void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the image and the tendril's glow smoothly dissolving into absolute black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.38720300793647766 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1372029781341553 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.38720300793647766, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.38720300793647766, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10182592272758484, + 0.03006410226225853, + 0.026920514181256294, + 0.035928573459386826, + 0.05969540402293205, + 0.022667134180665016, + 0.09620606154203415, + 0.08091863244771957, + 0.12578310072422028, + 0.419990599155426 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.38720300793647766 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a wide-angle lens perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow forward trajectory through a dark void with distant out-of-focus stars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a luminous tendril of energy visible that shifts colors between electric blue, soft magenta, and shimmering gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tendril move in a fluid, serpentine motion while casting a volumetric glow into the void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the image and the tendril's glow smoothly dissolving into absolute black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023298323154449463 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732982635498047 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023298323154449463, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023298323154449463, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1112397313117981, + 0.056526947766542435, + 0.06779077649116516, + 0.0632963478565216, + 0.03431304916739464, + 0.04307522624731064, + 0.19293539226055145, + 0.1864074319601059, + 0.13606345653533936, + 0.10835162550210953 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023298323154449463 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a wide-angle lens perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow forward trajectory through a dark void with distant out-of-focus stars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a luminous tendril of energy visible that shifts colors between electric blue, soft magenta, and shimmering gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tendril move in a fluid, serpentine motion while casting a volumetric glow into the void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the image and the tendril's glow smoothly dissolving into absolute black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002491348423063755 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002491474151611 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002491348423063755, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002491348423063755, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22197042405605316, + 0.05032362788915634, + 0.036261141300201416, + 0.08935711532831192, + 0.029585538432002068, + 0.06279949098825455, + 0.12616366147994995, + 0.06659355759620667, + 0.1605416089296341, + 0.1564038097858429 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002491348423063755 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a wide-angle lens perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow forward trajectory through a dark void with distant out-of-focus stars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a luminous tendril of energy visible that shifts colors between electric blue, soft magenta, and shimmering gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tendril move in a fluid, serpentine motion while casting a volumetric glow into the void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the image and the tendril's glow smoothly dissolving into absolute black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011074270121753216 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511074066162109 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011074270121753216, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011074270121753216, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.021187158301472664, + 0.020969301462173462, + 0.026847822591662407, + 0.018688762560486794, + 0.011300992220640182, + 0.019613051787018776, + 0.27635449171066284, + 0.06995414942502975, + 0.15377624332904816, + 0.38130804896354675 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011074270121753216 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "Beginning with a wide-angle lens, the camera begins a slow, majestic forward trajectory, gliding through the silent, inky darkness of the infinite void, with only the faintest pinpricks of light from distant, out-of-focus stars hinting at the sheer scale of the emptiness. A luminous, ethereal tendril of pure energy gracefully enters the frame, emitting a vibrant inner glow that seamlessly shifts between electric blue, soft magenta, and shimmering gold. Rather than being solid, it resembles a translucent, flowing ribbon of light, composed of countless shimmering particles and trailing fine, wispy threads. This primary tendril soars purposefully through deep space, its movement a fluid, serpentine dance, steadily and purposefully tracing an invisible, complex path, tilting and curving as if sailing on a cosmic current. As it moves, the volumetric light it emits casts soft, colored glow into the immediate void, creating a breathtaking atmosphere of serene, mystical awe. Just as the viewer is completely captivated by this celestial ballet, the tendril's glow begins to gently dim, and the entire image, along with the last fading spark, smoothly and completely dissolves into absolute black.", + "seed": 28650, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_15/index_1020_seed_28650_dp_31_rank_62_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.3856655786628835, + "vlm_logprob": -0.3856655786628835, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.7750000238418577, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.3856655786628835, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a wide-angle lens perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow forward trajectory through a dark void with distant out-of-focus stars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a luminous tendril of energy visible that shifts colors between electric blue, soft magenta, and shimmering gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tendril move in a fluid, serpentine motion while casting a volumetric glow into the void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the image and the tendril's glow smoothly dissolving into absolute black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.43945521116256714 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.064455270767212 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.43945521116256714, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.6250000596046448, + "token_credit_reward": -0.43945521116256714, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.29756978154182434, + 0.10891520231962204, + 0.04517412930727005, + 0.03402189537882805, + 0.1613747626543045, + 0.23528438806533813, + 0.047641269862651825, + 0.029791347682476044, + 0.01989194005727768, + 0.020335247740149498 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.43945521116256714 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a wide-angle lens perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow forward trajectory through a dark void with distant out-of-focus stars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a luminous tendril of energy visible that shifts colors between electric blue, soft magenta, and shimmering gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tendril move in a fluid, serpentine motion while casting a volumetric glow into the void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the image and the tendril's glow smoothly dissolving into absolute black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1370875835418701 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3870876431465149 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.1370875835418701, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.7499999403953552, + "token_credit_reward": -1.1370875835418701, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15191417932510376, + 0.07799042761325836, + 0.10713404417037964, + 0.10792997479438782, + 0.14462345838546753, + 0.07954026758670807, + 0.1794343888759613, + 0.06542529910802841, + 0.058910246938467026, + 0.027097653597593307 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.1370875835418701 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a wide-angle lens perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow forward trajectory through a dark void with distant out-of-focus stars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a luminous tendril of energy visible that shifts colors between electric blue, soft magenta, and shimmering gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tendril move in a fluid, serpentine motion while casting a volumetric glow into the void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the image and the tendril's glow smoothly dissolving into absolute black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.000934045237954706 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.00093412399292 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.000934045237954706, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.000934045237954706, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1250593364238739, + 0.12141594290733337, + 0.09959279000759125, + 0.06549952179193497, + 0.2379612922668457, + 0.19193243980407715, + 0.07527457177639008, + 0.02388683706521988, + 0.02848644368350506, + 0.030890820547938347 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.000934045237954706 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a wide-angle lens perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow forward trajectory through a dark void with distant out-of-focus stars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a luminous tendril of energy visible that shifts colors between electric blue, soft magenta, and shimmering gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tendril move in a fluid, serpentine motion while casting a volumetric glow into the void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the image and the tendril's glow smoothly dissolving into absolute black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0021990183740854263 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127199172973633 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0021990183740854263, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0021990183740854263, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13870495557785034, + 0.1286056786775589, + 0.08542134612798691, + 0.07357475906610489, + 0.06356263905763626, + 0.20160047709941864, + 0.17692811787128448, + 0.03397081419825554, + 0.05852639302611351, + 0.039104774594306946 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0021990183740854263 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a wide-angle lens perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow forward trajectory through a dark void with distant out-of-focus stars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a luminous tendril of energy visible that shifts colors between electric blue, soft magenta, and shimmering gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tendril move in a fluid, serpentine motion while casting a volumetric glow into the void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the image and the tendril's glow smoothly dissolving into absolute black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.34865203499794006 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2236520051956177 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.34865203499794006, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.34865203499794006, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16943509876728058, + 0.06540340930223465, + 0.0875878632068634, + 0.0968545451760292, + 0.11092400550842285, + 0.06499841064214706, + 0.07322992384433746, + 0.03134387731552124, + 0.20657360553741455, + 0.0936492308974266 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.34865203499794006 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_2/index_tensor([440, 440])_group_2_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_2/index_tensor([440, 440])_group_2_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..76914c8c434032a9cf40b8c11ca07133c3574744 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_2/index_tensor([440, 440])_group_2_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "An unsteady, handheld medium shot, shot from a low angle, captures a primal struggle for survival in a bleak, desaturated palette of washed-out colors. The scene focuses on a desolate beach, its wet, dark sand strewn with tangled seaweed and white seafoam, set against a brooding, oppressive gray sky. Two seagulls, their gray and white feathers disheveled in the frenzy of combat, ferociously beat against each other, each powerful beat sending up tiny grains of sand and icy spray. Their sharp yellow beaks open, their shrill, desperate screams echoing across the empty beach, their undivided attention focused on a tiny scrap of food in the sand—perhaps a scrap of fish washed ashore by the waves. The camera's movements are synchronized with the birds' frantic movements, sometimes swaying sharply due to their sudden impact, and sometimes zooming in briefly so that you can almost see the fierce gleam in their small black eyes, perfectly capturing every tense moment of this battle of primal power and creating an atmosphere of harsh, unvarnished realism.", + "seed": 8373, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_2/index_440_seed_8373_dp_4_rank_8_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.026257935725152493, + "vlm_logprob": -0.026257935725152493, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.925, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.026257935725152493, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two seagulls visible in the scene engaging in a fight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a desolate beach with wet dark sand, tangled seaweed, and white seafoam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the color palette desaturated, bleak, and washed-out with a brooding gray sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the seagulls' beaks open and are they sending up tiny grains of sand and icy spray while fighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot handheld from a low angle with movements synchronized to the birds' frantic actions?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04409543797373772 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.169095516204834 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04409543797373772, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04409543797373772, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07181774824857712, + 0.11055527627468109, + 0.11247459799051285, + 0.029117656871676445, + 0.08106335252523422, + 0.05618000775575638, + 0.15513257682323456, + 0.16200439631938934, + 0.03947792947292328, + 0.18217648565769196 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04409543797373772 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two seagulls visible in the scene engaging in a fight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a desolate beach with wet dark sand, tangled seaweed, and white seafoam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the color palette desaturated, bleak, and washed-out with a brooding gray sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the seagulls' beaks open and are they sending up tiny grains of sand and icy spray while fighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot handheld from a low angle with movements synchronized to the birds' frantic actions?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008642295375466347 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758642196655273 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008642295375466347, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008642295375466347, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12075428664684296, + 0.2220235913991928, + 0.062025830149650574, + 0.13550981879234314, + 0.05930466949939728, + 0.024118104949593544, + 0.11756812781095505, + 0.04762646183371544, + 0.10203129053115845, + 0.10903778672218323 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008642295375466347 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two seagulls visible in the scene engaging in a fight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a desolate beach with wet dark sand, tangled seaweed, and white seafoam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the color palette desaturated, bleak, and washed-out with a brooding gray sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the seagulls' beaks open and are they sending up tiny grains of sand and icy spray while fighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot handheld from a low angle with movements synchronized to the birds' frantic actions?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012543593533337116 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387543678283691 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012543593533337116, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012543593533337116, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11576519161462784, + 0.10905622690916061, + 0.059069547802209854, + 0.04348452389240265, + 0.10838700830936432, + 0.020022964105010033, + 0.3533572554588318, + 0.05053401738405228, + 0.06765879690647125, + 0.07266446202993393 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012543593533337116 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two seagulls visible in the scene engaging in a fight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a desolate beach with wet dark sand, tangled seaweed, and white seafoam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the color palette desaturated, bleak, and washed-out with a brooding gray sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the seagulls' beaks open and are they sending up tiny grains of sand and icy spray while fighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot handheld from a low angle with movements synchronized to the birds' frantic actions?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011076509952545166 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.5110764503479 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011076509952545166, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011076509952545166, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13444000482559204, + 0.11213195323944092, + 0.13021935522556305, + 0.04397634044289589, + 0.06745587289333344, + 0.028351198881864548, + 0.20992301404476166, + 0.08025556057691574, + 0.07630060613155365, + 0.1169460341334343 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011076509952545166 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two seagulls visible in the scene engaging in a fight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a desolate beach with wet dark sand, tangled seaweed, and white seafoam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the color palette desaturated, bleak, and washed-out with a brooding gray sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the seagulls' beaks open and are they sending up tiny grains of sand and icy spray while fighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot handheld from a low angle with movements synchronized to the birds' frantic actions?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05493184179067612 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929931879043579 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05493184179067612, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05493184179067612, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10246650874614716, + 0.18464195728302002, + 0.03950826823711395, + 0.033578719943761826, + 0.05672647804021835, + 0.07376797497272491, + 0.33898627758026123, + 0.05974005535244942, + 0.04285018518567085, + 0.06773356348276138 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05493184179067612 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An unsteady, handheld medium shot, shot from a low angle, captures a primal struggle for survival in a bleak, desaturated palette of washed-out colors. The scene focuses on a desolate beach, its wet, dark sand strewn with tangled seaweed and white seafoam, set against a brooding, oppressive gray sky. Two seagulls, their gray and white feathers disheveled in the frenzy of combat, ferociously beat against each other, each powerful beat sending up tiny grains of sand and icy spray. Their sharp yellow beaks open, their shrill, desperate screams echoing across the empty beach, their undivided attention focused on a tiny scrap of food in the sand—perhaps a scrap of fish washed ashore by the waves. The camera's movements are synchronized with the birds' frantic movements, sometimes swaying sharply due to their sudden impact, and sometimes zooming in briefly so that you can almost see the fierce gleam in their small black eyes, perfectly capturing every tense moment of this battle of primal power and creating an atmosphere of harsh, unvarnished realism.", + "seed": 8374, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_2/index_440_seed_8374_dp_4_rank_8_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.022550063487142325, + "vlm_logprob": -0.022550063487142325, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.075, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.022550063487142325, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two seagulls visible in the scene engaging in a fight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a desolate beach with wet dark sand, tangled seaweed, and white seafoam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the color palette desaturated, bleak, and washed-out with a brooding gray sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the seagulls' beaks open and are they sending up tiny grains of sand and icy spray while fighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot handheld from a low angle with movements synchronized to the birds' frantic actions?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03520766273140907 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.410207748413086 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03520766273140907, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03520766273140907, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1462278962135315, + 0.08520352840423584, + 0.1453915387392044, + 0.1248941570520401, + 0.1320873349905014, + 0.053027573972940445, + 0.11649707704782486, + 0.06219746544957161, + 0.07722321152687073, + 0.057250212877988815 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03520766273140907 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two seagulls visible in the scene engaging in a fight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a desolate beach with wet dark sand, tangled seaweed, and white seafoam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the color palette desaturated, bleak, and washed-out with a brooding gray sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the seagulls' beaks open and are they sending up tiny grains of sand and icy spray while fighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot handheld from a low angle with movements synchronized to the birds' frantic actions?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01108134351670742 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511081218719482 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01108134351670742, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01108134351670742, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20574477314949036, + 0.24321110546588898, + 0.04780540242791176, + 0.14040839672088623, + 0.10659714043140411, + 0.06200551986694336, + 0.035010360181331635, + 0.025966985151171684, + 0.03607999160885811, + 0.0971703976392746 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01108134351670742 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two seagulls visible in the scene engaging in a fight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a desolate beach with wet dark sand, tangled seaweed, and white seafoam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the color palette desaturated, bleak, and washed-out with a brooding gray sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the seagulls' beaks open and are they sending up tiny grains of sand and icy spray while fighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot handheld from a low angle with movements synchronized to the birds' frantic actions?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00674353027716279 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006743431091309 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00674353027716279, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00674353027716279, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2632264494895935, + 0.1456271857023239, + 0.06410998106002808, + 0.08655458688735962, + 0.142315074801445, + 0.07876606285572052, + 0.03560815751552582, + 0.057322196662425995, + 0.049047764390707016, + 0.07742256671190262 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00674353027716279 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two seagulls visible in the scene engaging in a fight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a desolate beach with wet dark sand, tangled seaweed, and white seafoam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the color palette desaturated, bleak, and washed-out with a brooding gray sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the seagulls' beaks open and are they sending up tiny grains of sand and icy spray while fighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot handheld from a low angle with movements synchronized to the birds' frantic actions?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011076628230512142 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.5110764503479 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011076628230512142, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011076628230512142, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.178793802857399, + 0.2013119012117386, + 0.0486425943672657, + 0.09260106831789017, + 0.1498299241065979, + 0.08304383605718613, + 0.06815452873706818, + 0.058451972901821136, + 0.06346889585256577, + 0.055701419711112976 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011076628230512142 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two seagulls visible in the scene engaging in a fight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a desolate beach with wet dark sand, tangled seaweed, and white seafoam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the color palette desaturated, bleak, and washed-out with a brooding gray sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the seagulls' beaks open and are they sending up tiny grains of sand and icy spray while fighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot handheld from a low angle with movements synchronized to the birds' frantic actions?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0486411526799202 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486412048339844 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0486411526799202, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0486411526799202, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07504604011774063, + 0.09249217063188553, + 0.07386985421180725, + 0.07827917486429214, + 0.11878643184900284, + 0.2971217632293701, + 0.11311248689889908, + 0.0324799083173275, + 0.05213649943470955, + 0.06667564809322357 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0486411526799202 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An unsteady, handheld medium shot, shot from a low angle, captures a primal struggle for survival in a bleak, desaturated palette of washed-out colors. The scene focuses on a desolate beach, its wet, dark sand strewn with tangled seaweed and white seafoam, set against a brooding, oppressive gray sky. Two seagulls, their gray and white feathers disheveled in the frenzy of combat, ferociously beat against each other, each powerful beat sending up tiny grains of sand and icy spray. Their sharp yellow beaks open, their shrill, desperate screams echoing across the empty beach, their undivided attention focused on a tiny scrap of food in the sand—perhaps a scrap of fish washed ashore by the waves. The camera's movements are synchronized with the birds' frantic movements, sometimes swaying sharply due to their sudden impact, and sometimes zooming in briefly so that you can almost see the fierce gleam in their small black eyes, perfectly capturing every tense moment of this battle of primal power and creating an atmosphere of harsh, unvarnished realism.", + "seed": 8375, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_2/index_440_seed_8375_dp_5_rank_10_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.03121758149936795, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03121758149936795, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.875, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03121758149936795, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two seagulls visible in the scene engaging in a fight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a desolate beach with wet dark sand, tangled seaweed, and white seafoam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the color palette desaturated, bleak, and washed-out with a brooding gray sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the seagulls' beaks open and are they sending up tiny grains of sand and icy spray while fighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot handheld from a low angle with movements synchronized to the birds' frantic actions?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05629207566380501 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9312920570373535 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05629207566380501, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05629207566380501, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12990666925907135, + 0.04665791988372803, + 0.07385049760341644, + 0.03824075683951378, + 0.06242559105157852, + 0.15473325550556183, + 0.24224528670310974, + 0.07469628006219864, + 0.11783750355243683, + 0.05940627306699753 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05629207566380501 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two seagulls visible in the scene engaging in a fight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a desolate beach with wet dark sand, tangled seaweed, and white seafoam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the color palette desaturated, bleak, and washed-out with a brooding gray sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the seagulls' beaks open and are they sending up tiny grains of sand and icy spray while fighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot handheld from a low angle with movements synchronized to the birds' frantic actions?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007634864654392004 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.88263463973999 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007634864654392004, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007634864654392004, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13479922711849213, + 0.08526978641748428, + 0.19157375395298004, + 0.19695302844047546, + 0.051939480006694794, + 0.046354640275239944, + 0.09866604208946228, + 0.06922786682844162, + 0.08156944811344147, + 0.04364675655961037 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007634864654392004 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two seagulls visible in the scene engaging in a fight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a desolate beach with wet dark sand, tangled seaweed, and white seafoam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the color palette desaturated, bleak, and washed-out with a brooding gray sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the seagulls' beaks open and are they sending up tiny grains of sand and icy spray while fighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot handheld from a low angle with movements synchronized to the birds' frantic actions?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01108216866850853 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511082172393799 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01108216866850853, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01108216866850853, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2774010896682739, + 0.08534636348485947, + 0.07857516407966614, + 0.06102335825562477, + 0.04704704508185387, + 0.031135471537709236, + 0.23422233760356903, + 0.05841955915093422, + 0.09235892444849014, + 0.03447064012289047 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01108216866850853 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two seagulls visible in the scene engaging in a fight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a desolate beach with wet dark sand, tangled seaweed, and white seafoam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the color palette desaturated, bleak, and washed-out with a brooding gray sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the seagulls' beaks open and are they sending up tiny grains of sand and icy spray while fighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot handheld from a low angle with movements synchronized to the birds' frantic actions?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01107910368591547 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.51107931137085 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01107910368591547, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01107910368591547, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21522922813892365, + 0.07249270379543304, + 0.08882784843444824, + 0.11889170110225677, + 0.05941907688975334, + 0.1061687096953392, + 0.09173443168401718, + 0.06855136901140213, + 0.133716881275177, + 0.04496803507208824 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01107910368591547 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two seagulls visible in the scene engaging in a fight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a desolate beach with wet dark sand, tangled seaweed, and white seafoam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the color palette desaturated, bleak, and washed-out with a brooding gray sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the seagulls' beaks open and are they sending up tiny grains of sand and icy spray while fighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot handheld from a low angle with movements synchronized to the birds' frantic actions?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06999969482421875 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6949996948242188 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06999969482421875, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06999969482421875, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.28507429361343384, + 0.03811195492744446, + 0.03671364486217499, + 0.0482509508728981, + 0.03466978296637535, + 0.05253569781780243, + 0.35892653465270996, + 0.09294970333576202, + 0.02582048438489437, + 0.026946987956762314 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06999969482421875 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An unsteady, handheld medium shot, shot from a low angle, captures a primal struggle for survival in a bleak, desaturated palette of washed-out colors. The scene focuses on a desolate beach, its wet, dark sand strewn with tangled seaweed and white seafoam, set against a brooding, oppressive gray sky. Two seagulls, their gray and white feathers disheveled in the frenzy of combat, ferociously beat against each other, each powerful beat sending up tiny grains of sand and icy spray. Their sharp yellow beaks open, their shrill, desperate screams echoing across the empty beach, their undivided attention focused on a tiny scrap of food in the sand—perhaps a scrap of fish washed ashore by the waves. The camera's movements are synchronized with the birds' frantic movements, sometimes swaying sharply due to their sudden impact, and sometimes zooming in briefly so that you can almost see the fierce gleam in their small black eyes, perfectly capturing every tense moment of this battle of primal power and creating an atmosphere of harsh, unvarnished realism.", + "seed": 8376, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_2/index_440_seed_8376_dp_5_rank_10_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.025876825489103795, + "vlm_logprob": -0.025876825489103795, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.825, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.025876825489103795, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two seagulls visible in the scene engaging in a fight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a desolate beach with wet dark sand, tangled seaweed, and white seafoam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the color palette desaturated, bleak, and washed-out with a brooding gray sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the seagulls' beaks open and are they sending up tiny grains of sand and icy spray while fighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot handheld from a low angle with movements synchronized to the birds' frantic actions?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03979432210326195 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2897942066192627 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03979432210326195, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03979432210326195, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06753963977098465, + 0.029600653797388077, + 0.05745506286621094, + 0.12998652458190918, + 0.053893376141786575, + 0.09464876353740692, + 0.02010129578411579, + 0.3526061475276947, + 0.09839999675750732, + 0.0957685187458992 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 3, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03979432210326195 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two seagulls visible in the scene engaging in a fight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a desolate beach with wet dark sand, tangled seaweed, and white seafoam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the color palette desaturated, bleak, and washed-out with a brooding gray sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the seagulls' beaks open and are they sending up tiny grains of sand and icy spray while fighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot handheld from a low angle with movements synchronized to the birds' frantic actions?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014203174039721489 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264203071594238 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014203174039721489, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014203174039721489, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06503624469041824, + 0.07564425468444824, + 0.1609230935573578, + 0.13339655101299286, + 0.1478351652622223, + 0.08136483281850815, + 0.03933130204677582, + 0.14709360897541046, + 0.0598033107817173, + 0.08957159519195557 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 4, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014203174039721489 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two seagulls visible in the scene engaging in a fight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a desolate beach with wet dark sand, tangled seaweed, and white seafoam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the color palette desaturated, bleak, and washed-out with a brooding gray sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the seagulls' beaks open and are they sending up tiny grains of sand and icy spray while fighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot handheld from a low angle with movements synchronized to the birds' frantic actions?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01420846302062273 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.2642083168029785 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01420846302062273, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01420846302062273, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12438778579235077, + 0.034708887338638306, + 0.05007435008883476, + 0.20453651249408722, + 0.06397081166505814, + 0.07704927772283554, + 0.03637976199388504, + 0.2257663905620575, + 0.0967903882265091, + 0.08633581548929214 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01420846302062273 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two seagulls visible in the scene engaging in a fight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a desolate beach with wet dark sand, tangled seaweed, and white seafoam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the color palette desaturated, bleak, and washed-out with a brooding gray sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the seagulls' beaks open and are they sending up tiny grains of sand and icy spray while fighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot handheld from a low angle with movements synchronized to the birds' frantic actions?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012543829157948494 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387543678283691 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012543829157948494, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012543829157948494, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06677597761154175, + 0.03155791386961937, + 0.04271945357322693, + 0.18216459453105927, + 0.041739001870155334, + 0.10306782275438309, + 0.02547619491815567, + 0.2696192264556885, + 0.07897865772247314, + 0.15790115296840668 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012543829157948494 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two seagulls visible in the scene engaging in a fight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a desolate beach with wet dark sand, tangled seaweed, and white seafoam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the color palette desaturated, bleak, and washed-out with a brooding gray sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the seagulls' beaks open and are they sending up tiny grains of sand and icy spray while fighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot handheld from a low angle with movements synchronized to the birds' frantic actions?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04863433912396431 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486342906951904 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04863433912396431, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04863433912396431, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18099252879619598, + 0.05611710250377655, + 0.040328215807676315, + 0.3888716995716095, + 0.07703037559986115, + 0.041563838720321655, + 0.04007785767316818, + 0.03277342766523361, + 0.05849681422114372, + 0.08374819159507751 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04863433912396431 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_3/index_tensor([2742, 2742])_group_3_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_3/index_tensor([2742, 2742])_group_3_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..1a2b0fc216b6df08f5e22ed02839b47d55cdd730 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_3/index_tensor([2742, 2742])_group_3_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "dramatic medium shot begins a slow, deliberate 180-degree pan around the emperor, standing atop a high, ornately carved stone balcony. The scene is rendered as a hyperrealistic 3D animation, featuring photorealistic textures and physically based lighting. The emperor, a man of stern and timeless features, remains completely impassive, his dark eyes fixed on the horizon. He wears an incredibly elaborate robe of multi-layered crimson and gold silk, the fabric embroidered with shimmering golden dragons that appear to twist as the wind gently tugs at the hem. As the camera smoothly glides around him, it reveals the epic scale of the catastrophe unfolding in the background: a devastating tsunami wave of unimaginable height, its crest billowing with white foam, suspended for a moment in the dark, turbulent sky. The vast, deep blue walls dwarf the sprawling imperial city below, its intricate towers and delicate bridges rendered as if in miniature. The eerie rays of the storm-choked sun catch on the crests of the waves and the thin gold threads of the emperor's garments, creating a stark and terrifying contrast between the monarch's profound serenity and nature's overwhelming destructive power, culminating in a sublime and somber atmosphere of awe.", + "seed": 4806, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_3/index_2742_seed_4806_dp_6_rank_12_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.2661622568964958, + "vlm_logprob": -0.2661622568964958, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.925, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.2661622568964958, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a slow, deliberate 180-degree pan around the emperor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the emperor standing atop a high, ornately carved stone balcony?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the emperor wearing an elaborate robe of multi-layered crimson and gold silk with embroidered golden dragons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a massive tsunami wave with white foam visible in the background behind the emperor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered as a hyperrealistic 3D animation with photorealistic textures and physically based lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4820714592933655 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9820714592933655 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.4820714592933655, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.4820714592933655, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3482401669025421, + 0.03085128776729107, + 0.03205377981066704, + 0.018986934795975685, + 0.028970712795853615, + 0.02218032069504261, + 0.02807696908712387, + 0.01140518393367529, + 0.4576937258243561, + 0.021540863439440727 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.4820714592933655 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a slow, deliberate 180-degree pan around the emperor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the emperor standing atop a high, ornately carved stone balcony?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the emperor wearing an elaborate robe of multi-layered crimson and gold silk with embroidered golden dragons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a massive tsunami wave with white foam visible in the background behind the emperor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered as a hyperrealistic 3D animation with photorealistic textures and physically based lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22560462355613708 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6006046533584595 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.22560462355613708, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.22560462355613708, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.42444902658462524, + 0.09353575110435486, + 0.06061429902911186, + 0.0354316420853138, + 0.029042212292551994, + 0.043450161814689636, + 0.019152294844388962, + 0.019863316789269447, + 0.23703189194202423, + 0.03742944449186325 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.22560462355613708 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a slow, deliberate 180-degree pan around the emperor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the emperor standing atop a high, ornately carved stone balcony?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the emperor wearing an elaborate robe of multi-layered crimson and gold silk with embroidered golden dragons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a massive tsunami wave with white foam visible in the background behind the emperor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered as a hyperrealistic 3D animation with photorealistic textures and physically based lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026369649916887283 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651369571685791 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026369649916887283, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026369649916887283, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08453627675771713, + 0.08324678242206573, + 0.1477859914302826, + 0.034340210258960724, + 0.04732763394713402, + 0.019116992130875587, + 0.024139363318681717, + 0.014533530920743942, + 0.5237681269645691, + 0.021205075085163116 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026369649916887283 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a slow, deliberate 180-degree pan around the emperor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the emperor standing atop a high, ornately carved stone balcony?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the emperor wearing an elaborate robe of multi-layered crimson and gold silk with embroidered golden dragons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a massive tsunami wave with white foam visible in the background behind the emperor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered as a hyperrealistic 3D animation with photorealistic textures and physically based lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02058020606637001 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895580291748047 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02058020606637001, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02058020606637001, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5083871483802795, + 0.08286438882350922, + 0.04730020835995674, + 0.02102857269346714, + 0.15984511375427246, + 0.02721063792705536, + 0.029849357903003693, + 0.019297154620289803, + 0.08468786627054214, + 0.019529514014720917 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02058020606637001 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a slow, deliberate 180-degree pan around the emperor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the emperor standing atop a high, ornately carved stone balcony?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the emperor wearing an elaborate robe of multi-layered crimson and gold silk with embroidered golden dragons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a massive tsunami wave with white foam visible in the background behind the emperor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered as a hyperrealistic 3D animation with photorealistic textures and physically based lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5761853456497192 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8261853456497192 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5761853456497192, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5761853456497192, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3636716604232788, + 0.10707972943782806, + 0.11037439107894897, + 0.06769884377717972, + 0.04896135255694389, + 0.027293648570775986, + 0.04969890043139458, + 0.0334482304751873, + 0.14649876952171326, + 0.04527444392442703 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5761853456497192 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dramatic medium shot begins a slow, deliberate 180-degree pan around the emperor, standing atop a high, ornately carved stone balcony. The scene is rendered as a hyperrealistic 3D animation, featuring photorealistic textures and physically based lighting. The emperor, a man of stern and timeless features, remains completely impassive, his dark eyes fixed on the horizon. He wears an incredibly elaborate robe of multi-layered crimson and gold silk, the fabric embroidered with shimmering golden dragons that appear to twist as the wind gently tugs at the hem. As the camera smoothly glides around him, it reveals the epic scale of the catastrophe unfolding in the background: a devastating tsunami wave of unimaginable height, its crest billowing with white foam, suspended for a moment in the dark, turbulent sky. The vast, deep blue walls dwarf the sprawling imperial city below, its intricate towers and delicate bridges rendered as if in miniature. The eerie rays of the storm-choked sun catch on the crests of the waves and the thin gold threads of the emperor's garments, creating a stark and terrifying contrast between the monarch's profound serenity and nature's overwhelming destructive power, culminating in a sublime and somber atmosphere of awe.", + "seed": 4807, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_3/index_2742_seed_4807_dp_6_rank_12_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.3702452786266804, + "vlm_logprob": -0.3702452786266804, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.875, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.3702452786266804, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a slow, deliberate 180-degree pan around the emperor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the emperor standing atop a high, ornately carved stone balcony?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the emperor wearing an elaborate robe of multi-layered crimson and gold silk with embroidered golden dragons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a massive tsunami wave with white foam visible in the background behind the emperor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered as a hyperrealistic 3D animation with photorealistic textures and physically based lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.0593202114105225 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4343201816082001 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.0593202114105225, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.625, + "token_credit_reward": -1.0593202114105225, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0816386491060257, + 0.0253565926104784, + 0.6527034044265747, + 0.03120996616780758, + 0.029566030949354172, + 0.02488401159644127, + 0.03813867270946503, + 0.014486294239759445, + 0.06858467310667038, + 0.03343169763684273 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.0593202114105225 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a slow, deliberate 180-degree pan around the emperor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the emperor standing atop a high, ornately carved stone balcony?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the emperor wearing an elaborate robe of multi-layered crimson and gold silk with embroidered golden dragons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a massive tsunami wave with white foam visible in the background behind the emperor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered as a hyperrealistic 3D animation with photorealistic textures and physically based lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17991603910923004 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8049160242080688 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17991603910923004, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17991603910923004, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0742870569229126, + 0.10966182500123978, + 0.5206239819526672, + 0.04990241304039955, + 0.025195324793457985, + 0.03213486447930336, + 0.014042981900274754, + 0.0306390430778265, + 0.0707201138138771, + 0.07279237359762192 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17991603910923004 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a slow, deliberate 180-degree pan around the emperor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the emperor standing atop a high, ornately carved stone balcony?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the emperor wearing an elaborate robe of multi-layered crimson and gold silk with embroidered golden dragons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a massive tsunami wave with white foam visible in the background behind the emperor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered as a hyperrealistic 3D animation with photorealistic textures and physically based lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012546772137284279 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387546539306641 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012546772137284279, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012546772137284279, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0865941047668457, + 0.11085091531276703, + 0.6389897465705872, + 0.0349627323448658, + 0.019894110038876534, + 0.012308701872825623, + 0.02902192622423172, + 0.025334523990750313, + 0.025572238489985466, + 0.016471000388264656 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012546772137284279 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a slow, deliberate 180-degree pan around the emperor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the emperor standing atop a high, ornately carved stone balcony?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the emperor wearing an elaborate robe of multi-layered crimson and gold silk with embroidered golden dragons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a massive tsunami wave with white foam visible in the background behind the emperor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered as a hyperrealistic 3D animation with photorealistic textures and physically based lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023278290405869484 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.77327823638916 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023278290405869484, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023278290405869484, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08386092633008957, + 0.052931107580661774, + 0.43874990940093994, + 0.039917681366205215, + 0.03777756914496422, + 0.09451038390398026, + 0.06277617067098618, + 0.08636478334665298, + 0.06325603276491165, + 0.039855360984802246 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023278290405869484 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a slow, deliberate 180-degree pan around the emperor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the emperor standing atop a high, ornately carved stone balcony?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the emperor wearing an elaborate robe of multi-layered crimson and gold silk with embroidered golden dragons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a massive tsunami wave with white foam visible in the background behind the emperor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered as a hyperrealistic 3D animation with photorealistic textures and physically based lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5761650800704956 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8261650800704956 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5761650800704956, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5761650800704956, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25196370482444763, + 0.058881327509880066, + 0.4160420894622803, + 0.062079910188913345, + 0.02563689835369587, + 0.01620924100279808, + 0.04997008666396141, + 0.031743429601192474, + 0.05629156157374382, + 0.03118172474205494 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5761650800704956 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dramatic medium shot begins a slow, deliberate 180-degree pan around the emperor, standing atop a high, ornately carved stone balcony. The scene is rendered as a hyperrealistic 3D animation, featuring photorealistic textures and physically based lighting. The emperor, a man of stern and timeless features, remains completely impassive, his dark eyes fixed on the horizon. He wears an incredibly elaborate robe of multi-layered crimson and gold silk, the fabric embroidered with shimmering golden dragons that appear to twist as the wind gently tugs at the hem. As the camera smoothly glides around him, it reveals the epic scale of the catastrophe unfolding in the background: a devastating tsunami wave of unimaginable height, its crest billowing with white foam, suspended for a moment in the dark, turbulent sky. The vast, deep blue walls dwarf the sprawling imperial city below, its intricate towers and delicate bridges rendered as if in miniature. The eerie rays of the storm-choked sun catch on the crests of the waves and the thin gold threads of the emperor's garments, creating a stark and terrifying contrast between the monarch's profound serenity and nature's overwhelming destructive power, culminating in a sublime and somber atmosphere of awe.", + "seed": 4808, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_3/index_2742_seed_4808_dp_7_rank_14_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.22668671756982803, + "vlm_logprob": -0.22668671756982803, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.125000023841858, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.22668671756982803, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a slow, deliberate 180-degree pan around the emperor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the emperor standing atop a high, ornately carved stone balcony?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the emperor wearing an elaborate robe of multi-layered crimson and gold silk with embroidered golden dragons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a massive tsunami wave with white foam visible in the background behind the emperor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered as a hyperrealistic 3D animation with photorealistic textures and physically based lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.15205326676368713 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0270533561706543 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.15205326676368713, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.8750001192092896, + "token_credit_reward": -0.15205326676368713, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12893034517765045, + 0.08462733775377274, + 0.10159394145011902, + 0.13213768601417542, + 0.09345810860395432, + 0.23089836537837982, + 0.09437079727649689, + 0.048979561775922775, + 0.05559389665722847, + 0.029409969225525856 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.15205326676368713 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a slow, deliberate 180-degree pan around the emperor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the emperor standing atop a high, ornately carved stone balcony?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the emperor wearing an elaborate robe of multi-layered crimson and gold silk with embroidered golden dragons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a massive tsunami wave with white foam visible in the background behind the emperor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered as a hyperrealistic 3D animation with photorealistic textures and physically based lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07899913936853409 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5789990425109863 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07899913936853409, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07899913936853409, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13405263423919678, + 0.08175555616617203, + 0.2049686312675476, + 0.06292629987001419, + 0.022396951913833618, + 0.35234901309013367, + 0.02069750986993313, + 0.04668305441737175, + 0.04777726158499718, + 0.026393085718154907 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07899913936853409 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a slow, deliberate 180-degree pan around the emperor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the emperor standing atop a high, ornately carved stone balcony?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the emperor wearing an elaborate robe of multi-layered crimson and gold silk with embroidered golden dragons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a massive tsunami wave with white foam visible in the background behind the emperor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered as a hyperrealistic 3D animation with photorealistic textures and physically based lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.038126904517412186 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881269454956055 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.038126904517412186, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.038126904517412186, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1144864410161972, + 0.04827238991856575, + 0.1290266513824463, + 0.03520707041025162, + 0.0354907363653183, + 0.5472210645675659, + 0.025377782061696053, + 0.037353917956352234, + 0.015595786273479462, + 0.011968132108449936 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.038126904517412186 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a slow, deliberate 180-degree pan around the emperor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the emperor standing atop a high, ornately carved stone balcony?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the emperor wearing an elaborate robe of multi-layered crimson and gold silk with embroidered golden dragons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a massive tsunami wave with white foam visible in the background behind the emperor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered as a hyperrealistic 3D animation with photorealistic textures and physically based lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03809110447764397 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2880911827087402 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03809110447764397, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03809110447764397, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0952209085226059, + 0.04653041437268257, + 0.2576010227203369, + 0.036307208240032196, + 0.10073143243789673, + 0.3337486684322357, + 0.018841300159692764, + 0.039050593972206116, + 0.04416707903146744, + 0.027801360934972763 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03809110447764397 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a slow, deliberate 180-degree pan around the emperor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the emperor standing atop a high, ornately carved stone balcony?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the emperor wearing an elaborate robe of multi-layered crimson and gold silk with embroidered golden dragons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a massive tsunami wave with white foam visible in the background behind the emperor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered as a hyperrealistic 3D animation with photorealistic textures and physically based lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8261631727218628 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5761631727218628 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.8261631727218628, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.8261631727218628, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2516474723815918, + 0.14052167534828186, + 0.15591004490852356, + 0.10169188678264618, + 0.03626776859164238, + 0.049967411905527115, + 0.049595076590776443, + 0.0992857962846756, + 0.07188419252634048, + 0.0432286411523819 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.8261631727218628 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dramatic medium shot begins a slow, deliberate 180-degree pan around the emperor, standing atop a high, ornately carved stone balcony. The scene is rendered as a hyperrealistic 3D animation, featuring photorealistic textures and physically based lighting. The emperor, a man of stern and timeless features, remains completely impassive, his dark eyes fixed on the horizon. He wears an incredibly elaborate robe of multi-layered crimson and gold silk, the fabric embroidered with shimmering golden dragons that appear to twist as the wind gently tugs at the hem. As the camera smoothly glides around him, it reveals the epic scale of the catastrophe unfolding in the background: a devastating tsunami wave of unimaginable height, its crest billowing with white foam, suspended for a moment in the dark, turbulent sky. The vast, deep blue walls dwarf the sprawling imperial city below, its intricate towers and delicate bridges rendered as if in miniature. The eerie rays of the storm-choked sun catch on the crests of the waves and the thin gold threads of the emperor's garments, creating a stark and terrifying contrast between the monarch's profound serenity and nature's overwhelming destructive power, culminating in a sublime and somber atmosphere of awe.", + "seed": 4809, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_3/index_2742_seed_4809_dp_7_rank_14_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.1667519923299551, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1667519923299551, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.449999976158142, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1667519923299551, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a slow, deliberate 180-degree pan around the emperor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the emperor standing atop a high, ornately carved stone balcony?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the emperor wearing an elaborate robe of multi-layered crimson and gold silk with embroidered golden dragons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a massive tsunami wave with white foam visible in the background behind the emperor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered as a hyperrealistic 3D animation with photorealistic textures and physically based lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14669571816921234 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.021695613861084 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14669571816921234, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.8749998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14669571816921234, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05446235090494156, + 0.04041179642081261, + 0.055098362267017365, + 0.03296548128128052, + 0.042070161551237106, + 0.04077760502696037, + 0.048187315464019775, + 0.19892778992652893, + 0.45398181676864624, + 0.03311723843216896 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14669571816921234 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a slow, deliberate 180-degree pan around the emperor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the emperor standing atop a high, ornately carved stone balcony?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the emperor wearing an elaborate robe of multi-layered crimson and gold silk with embroidered golden dragons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a massive tsunami wave with white foam visible in the background behind the emperor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered as a hyperrealistic 3D animation with photorealistic textures and physically based lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1270674765110016 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1270675659179688 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1270674765110016, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1270674765110016, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10137465596199036, + 0.07319983839988708, + 0.2705843150615692, + 0.021860390901565552, + 0.04872645437717438, + 0.03563912585377693, + 0.04794693365693092, + 0.1742260456085205, + 0.1533789187669754, + 0.07306337356567383 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1270674765110016 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a slow, deliberate 180-degree pan around the emperor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the emperor standing atop a high, ornately carved stone balcony?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the emperor wearing an elaborate robe of multi-layered crimson and gold silk with embroidered golden dragons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a massive tsunami wave with white foam visible in the background behind the emperor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered as a hyperrealistic 3D animation with photorealistic textures and physically based lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020599007606506348 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895598888397217 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020599007606506348, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020599007606506348, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1471448689699173, + 0.19588354229927063, + 0.14205969870090485, + 0.05009391903877258, + 0.06768683344125748, + 0.04733888804912567, + 0.05625839903950691, + 0.11921031773090363, + 0.08036743849515915, + 0.09395601600408554 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020599007606506348 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a slow, deliberate 180-degree pan around the emperor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the emperor standing atop a high, ornately carved stone balcony?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the emperor wearing an elaborate robe of multi-layered crimson and gold silk with embroidered golden dragons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a massive tsunami wave with white foam visible in the background behind the emperor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered as a hyperrealistic 3D animation with photorealistic textures and physically based lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016063792631030083 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141063690185547 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016063792631030083, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016063792631030083, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1926358938217163, + 0.10038170218467712, + 0.13758252561092377, + 0.01683679036796093, + 0.027776222676038742, + 0.034842707216739655, + 0.030541613698005676, + 0.32717710733413696, + 0.08362272381782532, + 0.04860270023345947 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016063792631030083 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a slow, deliberate 180-degree pan around the emperor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the emperor standing atop a high, ornately carved stone balcony?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the emperor wearing an elaborate robe of multi-layered crimson and gold silk with embroidered golden dragons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a massive tsunami wave with white foam visible in the background behind the emperor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered as a hyperrealistic 3D animation with photorealistic textures and physically based lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5233339667320251 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8983339667320251 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5233339667320251, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5233339667320251, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20359647274017334, + 0.08214283734560013, + 0.07457306981086731, + 0.06093810126185417, + 0.08486178517341614, + 0.10643776506185532, + 0.053705066442489624, + 0.06795281171798706, + 0.1677049845457077, + 0.09808709472417831 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5233339667320251 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_4/index_tensor([994, 994])_group_4_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_4/index_tensor([994, 994])_group_4_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..74daa6bbe14b0369f26982271222150fc6421b0c --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_4/index_tensor([994, 994])_group_4_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "close-up shot, shot from a level angle, focuses on a slender hand, its skin pale and its knuckles distinct, carefully grasping the cool metal handle of an antique brass oil lamp. The lampshade is made of clear glass, and within it, a small, warm, orange-yellow flame flickers restlessly. As the hand steadily yet gently lifts the lamp from the dark wooden tabletop, the flame's flickering motion intensifies, casting a vast, oscillating shadow on the off-white background, which has the texture of rice paper. These shadows stretch, contract, and morph in real time, their edges blurred and soft, like ink washes of varying shades swiftly flowing across a scroll, forming a dynamic, poetic visual composition. The entire scene, illuminated by this single, warm light source, creates an atmosphere of profound tranquility, contemplation, and a classical Eastern aesthetic.", + "seed": 16337, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_4/index_994_seed_16337_dp_8_rank_16_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.06419706381857396, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06419706381857396, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.525, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06419706381857396, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focusing on a slender hand with pale skin and distinct knuckles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hand grasping the handle of an antique brass oil lamp with a clear glass lampshade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the hand steadily lift the lamp from a dark wooden tabletop while the flame flickers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are large, oscillating shadows cast on an off-white background with a rice paper texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a level angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016697533428668976 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141697406768799 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016697533428668976, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016697533428668976, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3716546893119812, + 0.06704538315534592, + 0.025672709569334984, + 0.04455438256263733, + 0.19475027918815613, + 0.06467896699905396, + 0.03439764305949211, + 0.05960516259074211, + 0.0579119436442852, + 0.07972890138626099 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016697533428668976 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focusing on a slender hand with pale skin and distinct knuckles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hand grasping the handle of an antique brass oil lamp with a clear glass lampshade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the hand steadily lift the lamp from a dark wooden tabletop while the flame flickers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are large, oscillating shadows cast on an off-white background with a rice paper texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a level angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02059386856853962 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955938816070557 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02059386856853962, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02059386856853962, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.30216509103775024, + 0.18776477873325348, + 0.037884049117565155, + 0.026800505816936493, + 0.17554672062397003, + 0.057843614369630814, + 0.02383306622505188, + 0.07125886529684067, + 0.04394571855664253, + 0.0729575902223587 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02059386856853962 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focusing on a slender hand with pale skin and distinct knuckles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hand grasping the handle of an antique brass oil lamp with a clear glass lampshade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the hand steadily lift the lamp from a dark wooden tabletop while the flame flickers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are large, oscillating shadows cast on an off-white background with a rice paper texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a level angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020581606775522232 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955817222595215 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020581606775522232, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020581606775522232, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.302151620388031, + 0.087047278881073, + 0.06494716554880142, + 0.12731251120567322, + 0.09900104254484177, + 0.09450482577085495, + 0.04222343489527702, + 0.11898713558912277, + 0.021087417379021645, + 0.04273759201169014 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020581606775522232 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focusing on a slender hand with pale skin and distinct knuckles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hand grasping the handle of an antique brass oil lamp with a clear glass lampshade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the hand steadily lift the lamp from a dark wooden tabletop while the flame flickers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are large, oscillating shadows cast on an off-white background with a rice paper texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a level angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011076156049966812 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511075973510742 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011076156049966812, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011076156049966812, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19946426153182983, + 0.07059488445520401, + 0.06516534835100174, + 0.061913568526506424, + 0.2189461886882782, + 0.023771438747644424, + 0.07630753517150879, + 0.16825436055660248, + 0.04579048976302147, + 0.06979194283485413 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011076156049966812 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focusing on a slender hand with pale skin and distinct knuckles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hand grasping the handle of an antique brass oil lamp with a clear glass lampshade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the hand steadily lift the lamp from a dark wooden tabletop while the flame flickers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are large, oscillating shadows cast on an off-white background with a rice paper texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a level angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2520361542701721 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5020360946655273 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2520361542701721, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2520361542701721, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2002834677696228, + 0.06775519996881485, + 0.054145198315382004, + 0.11894788593053818, + 0.10058719664812088, + 0.10475822538137436, + 0.04278172180056572, + 0.0915972962975502, + 0.04980553686618805, + 0.16933833062648773 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2520361542701721 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up shot, shot from a level angle, focuses on a slender hand, its skin pale and its knuckles distinct, carefully grasping the cool metal handle of an antique brass oil lamp. The lampshade is made of clear glass, and within it, a small, warm, orange-yellow flame flickers restlessly. As the hand steadily yet gently lifts the lamp from the dark wooden tabletop, the flame's flickering motion intensifies, casting a vast, oscillating shadow on the off-white background, which has the texture of rice paper. These shadows stretch, contract, and morph in real time, their edges blurred and soft, like ink washes of varying shades swiftly flowing across a scroll, forming a dynamic, poetic visual composition. The entire scene, illuminated by this single, warm light source, creates an atmosphere of profound tranquility, contemplation, and a classical Eastern aesthetic.", + "seed": 16338, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_4/index_994_seed_16338_dp_8_rank_16_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.040551739651709794, + "vlm_logprob": -0.040551739651709794, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.05, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.040551739651709794, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focusing on a slender hand with pale skin and distinct knuckles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hand grasping the handle of an antique brass oil lamp with a clear glass lampshade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the hand steadily lift the lamp from a dark wooden tabletop while the flame flickers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are large, oscillating shadows cast on an off-white background with a rice paper texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a level angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014681164175271988 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264681339263916 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014681164175271988, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014681164175271988, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22937613725662231, + 0.09800643473863602, + 0.033193331211805344, + 0.05423419922590256, + 0.03607836365699768, + 0.03933018818497658, + 0.10147008299827576, + 0.16262078285217285, + 0.20036537945270538, + 0.045325081795454025 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014681164175271988 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focusing on a slender hand with pale skin and distinct knuckles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hand grasping the handle of an antique brass oil lamp with a clear glass lampshade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the hand steadily lift the lamp from a dark wooden tabletop while the flame flickers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are large, oscillating shadows cast on an off-white background with a rice paper texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a level angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014206582680344582 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264206409454346 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014206582680344582, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014206582680344582, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19789721071720123, + 0.0568544939160347, + 0.10676541179418564, + 0.056102409958839417, + 0.05141311511397362, + 0.07540127635002136, + 0.16217786073684692, + 0.15560804307460785, + 0.06398976594209671, + 0.07379044592380524 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014206582680344582 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focusing on a slender hand with pale skin and distinct knuckles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hand grasping the handle of an antique brass oil lamp with a clear glass lampshade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the hand steadily lift the lamp from a dark wooden tabletop while the flame flickers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are large, oscillating shadows cast on an off-white background with a rice paper texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a level angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005946444813162088 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130946636199951 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005946444813162088, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005946444813162088, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11241935938596725, + 0.11395811289548874, + 0.06182333081960678, + 0.06265050172805786, + 0.10691022872924805, + 0.07348205894231796, + 0.11324808746576309, + 0.14939607679843903, + 0.07107119262218475, + 0.13504111766815186 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005946444813162088 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focusing on a slender hand with pale skin and distinct knuckles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hand grasping the handle of an antique brass oil lamp with a clear glass lampshade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the hand steadily lift the lamp from a dark wooden tabletop while the flame flickers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are large, oscillating shadows cast on an off-white background with a rice paper texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a level angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0076294224709272385 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.88262939453125 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0076294224709272385, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0076294224709272385, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13190332055091858, + 0.18719030916690826, + 0.06177994981408119, + 0.07554073631763458, + 0.0784301906824112, + 0.21011054515838623, + 0.06090391427278519, + 0.10896961390972137, + 0.059448253363370895, + 0.025723161175847054 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0076294224709272385 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focusing on a slender hand with pale skin and distinct knuckles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hand grasping the handle of an antique brass oil lamp with a clear glass lampshade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the hand steadily lift the lamp from a dark wooden tabletop while the flame flickers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are large, oscillating shadows cast on an off-white background with a rice paper texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a level angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16029508411884308 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9102951288223267 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16029508411884308, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16029508411884308, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16065318882465363, + 0.07183266431093216, + 0.04551631212234497, + 0.07073630392551422, + 0.05242174118757248, + 0.08033949136734009, + 0.09689635038375854, + 0.11872558295726776, + 0.2469734400510788, + 0.05590489134192467 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16029508411884308 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up shot, shot from a level angle, focuses on a slender hand, its skin pale and its knuckles distinct, carefully grasping the cool metal handle of an antique brass oil lamp. The lampshade is made of clear glass, and within it, a small, warm, orange-yellow flame flickers restlessly. As the hand steadily yet gently lifts the lamp from the dark wooden tabletop, the flame's flickering motion intensifies, casting a vast, oscillating shadow on the off-white background, which has the texture of rice paper. These shadows stretch, contract, and morph in real time, their edges blurred and soft, like ink washes of varying shades swiftly flowing across a scroll, forming a dynamic, poetic visual composition. The entire scene, illuminated by this single, warm light source, creates an atmosphere of profound tranquility, contemplation, and a classical Eastern aesthetic.", + "seed": 16339, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_4/index_994_seed_16339_dp_9_rank_18_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.08280716743320227, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08280716743320227, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.525, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08280716743320227, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focusing on a slender hand with pale skin and distinct knuckles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hand grasping the handle of an antique brass oil lamp with a clear glass lampshade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the hand steadily lift the lamp from a dark wooden tabletop while the flame flickers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are large, oscillating shadows cast on an off-white background with a rice paper texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a level angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02129313349723816 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8962931632995605 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02129313349723816, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02129313349723816, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.31751105189323425, + 0.06014068052172661, + 0.0487632155418396, + 0.06038559973239899, + 0.10262226313352585, + 0.11071310937404633, + 0.07277638465166092, + 0.08106882870197296, + 0.09470871090888977, + 0.05131017044186592 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02129313349723816 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focusing on a slender hand with pale skin and distinct knuckles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hand grasping the handle of an antique brass oil lamp with a clear glass lampshade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the hand steadily lift the lamp from a dark wooden tabletop while the flame flickers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are large, oscillating shadows cast on an off-white background with a rice paper texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a level angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0110840555280447 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511084079742432 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0110840555280447, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0110840555280447, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14659252762794495, + 0.05255196988582611, + 0.062387045472860336, + 0.05754244327545166, + 0.40152207016944885, + 0.056516773998737335, + 0.05403212085366249, + 0.05126459524035454, + 0.048365164548158646, + 0.06922531127929688 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0110840555280447 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focusing on a slender hand with pale skin and distinct knuckles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hand grasping the handle of an antique brass oil lamp with a clear glass lampshade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the hand steadily lift the lamp from a dark wooden tabletop while the flame flickers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are large, oscillating shadows cast on an off-white background with a rice paper texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a level angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009778928942978382 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.63477897644043 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009778928942978382, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009778928942978382, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13740384578704834, + 0.08577801287174225, + 0.15923932194709778, + 0.22478459775447845, + 0.07586678862571716, + 0.06329094618558884, + 0.07156133651733398, + 0.061343953013420105, + 0.07825490832328796, + 0.04247622191905975 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009778928942978382 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focusing on a slender hand with pale skin and distinct knuckles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hand grasping the handle of an antique brass oil lamp with a clear glass lampshade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the hand steadily lift the lamp from a dark wooden tabletop while the flame flickers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are large, oscillating shadows cast on an off-white background with a rice paper texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a level angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023293547332286835 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732934951782227 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023293547332286835, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023293547332286835, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.060966555029153824, + 0.06123413145542145, + 0.024891259148716927, + 0.06725401431322098, + 0.059781212359666824, + 0.053215235471725464, + 0.2747676372528076, + 0.0825730636715889, + 0.235268235206604, + 0.080048568546772 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023293547332286835 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focusing on a slender hand with pale skin and distinct knuckles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hand grasping the handle of an antique brass oil lamp with a clear glass lampshade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the hand steadily lift the lamp from a dark wooden tabletop while the flame flickers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are large, oscillating shadows cast on an off-white background with a rice paper texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a level angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.34858617186546326 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2235862016677856 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.34858617186546326, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.34858617186546326, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1565985232591629, + 0.03584924340248108, + 0.0998515710234642, + 0.07172881811857224, + 0.03695555031299591, + 0.04801991954445839, + 0.3900464177131653, + 0.07797854393720627, + 0.06559503823518753, + 0.017376428470015526 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.34858617186546326 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up shot, shot from a level angle, focuses on a slender hand, its skin pale and its knuckles distinct, carefully grasping the cool metal handle of an antique brass oil lamp. The lampshade is made of clear glass, and within it, a small, warm, orange-yellow flame flickers restlessly. As the hand steadily yet gently lifts the lamp from the dark wooden tabletop, the flame's flickering motion intensifies, casting a vast, oscillating shadow on the off-white background, which has the texture of rice paper. These shadows stretch, contract, and morph in real time, their edges blurred and soft, like ink washes of varying shades swiftly flowing across a scroll, forming a dynamic, poetic visual composition. The entire scene, illuminated by this single, warm light source, creates an atmosphere of profound tranquility, contemplation, and a classical Eastern aesthetic.", + "seed": 16340, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_4/index_994_seed_16340_dp_9_rank_18_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.07905232477933169, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07905232477933169, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.35, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07905232477933169, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focusing on a slender hand with pale skin and distinct knuckles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hand grasping the handle of an antique brass oil lamp with a clear glass lampshade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the hand steadily lift the lamp from a dark wooden tabletop while the flame flickers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are large, oscillating shadows cast on an off-white background with a rice paper texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a level angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02383694052696228 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773836851119995 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02383694052696228, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02383694052696228, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11126544326543808, + 0.07085961103439331, + 0.04737244173884392, + 0.06207145377993584, + 0.08082344383001328, + 0.30009135603904724, + 0.12231877446174622, + 0.034505248069763184, + 0.054439980536699295, + 0.11625221371650696 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02383694052696228 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focusing on a slender hand with pale skin and distinct knuckles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hand grasping the handle of an antique brass oil lamp with a clear glass lampshade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the hand steadily lift the lamp from a dark wooden tabletop while the flame flickers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are large, oscillating shadows cast on an off-white background with a rice paper texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a level angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02059725485742092 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895597219467163 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02059725485742092, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02059725485742092, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09110461175441742, + 0.14623691141605377, + 0.07292526960372925, + 0.06877549737691879, + 0.13100838661193848, + 0.242228701710701, + 0.1159079521894455, + 0.04255084693431854, + 0.025782637298107147, + 0.06347912549972534 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02059725485742092 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focusing on a slender hand with pale skin and distinct knuckles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hand grasping the handle of an antique brass oil lamp with a clear glass lampshade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the hand steadily lift the lamp from a dark wooden tabletop while the flame flickers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are large, oscillating shadows cast on an off-white background with a rice paper texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a level angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01107556652277708 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511075496673584 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01107556652277708, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01107556652277708, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1317187249660492, + 0.07933980226516724, + 0.1155371144413948, + 0.0644705519080162, + 0.1142549142241478, + 0.08214817196130753, + 0.1525844782590866, + 0.0655694305896759, + 0.058236412703990936, + 0.13614048063755035 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01107556652277708 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focusing on a slender hand with pale skin and distinct knuckles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hand grasping the handle of an antique brass oil lamp with a clear glass lampshade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the hand steadily lift the lamp from a dark wooden tabletop while the flame flickers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are large, oscillating shadows cast on an off-white background with a rice paper texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a level angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026357226073741913 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513571739196777 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026357226073741913, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026357226073741913, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10057263821363449, + 0.07333619892597198, + 0.02026323415338993, + 0.29553309082984924, + 0.043983038514852524, + 0.21072706580162048, + 0.06214417144656181, + 0.05324423313140869, + 0.036542054265737534, + 0.10365426540374756 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026357226073741913 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focusing on a slender hand with pale skin and distinct knuckles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hand grasping the handle of an antique brass oil lamp with a clear glass lampshade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the hand steadily lift the lamp from a dark wooden tabletop while the flame flickers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are large, oscillating shadows cast on an off-white background with a rice paper texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a level angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3133946359157562 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3133946657180786 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3133946359157562, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3133946359157562, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11173118650913239, + 0.03815184161067009, + 0.024542728438973427, + 0.053351905196905136, + 0.13779166340827942, + 0.4478968679904938, + 0.03193846717476845, + 0.07894132286310196, + 0.03306300565600395, + 0.042590998113155365 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3133946359157562 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_5/index_tensor([4402, 4402])_group_5_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_5/index_tensor([4402, 4402])_group_5_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..6c270fffc267ee1b28803eff7740d378ec7289a5 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_5/index_tensor([4402, 4402])_group_5_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "In the stark, expressive style of Chinese ink painting, a static, tightly framed close-up captures the profound ideological struggle of an elderly scholar. His face is a landscape of deep concentration, brow furrowed, lips pressed tightly together, every wrinkle and age mark like a deliberate brushstroke. A wisp of long, thin white hair escapes from a simple topknot, framing his features. The camera's unwavering gaze focuses on his hand; his knuckles are pure white, veins prominent as he grips a dark bamboo brush with immense pressure. The tip of the brush, drenched in glistening black ink, hovers precariously just a millimeter above a pristine, blank scroll of rice paper that fills the lower half of the frame. The scene is illuminated by a soft, diffuse light from an unseen source, creating a dramatic play of light and shadow, emphasizing the texture of his simple gray silk robe and the grain of the dark wooden table beneath the scroll. The background is a depthless, graded gray, ensuring absolute focus on the scholar's internal conflict. The whole atmosphere was one of great, silent tension, the air thick with the weight of philosophical questions as he hesitated, caught in moments of profound creativity and intellectual paralysis.", + "seed": 18697, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_5/index_4402_seed_18697_dp_10_rank_20_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.1388002851046622, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1388002851046622, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.325, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1388002851046622, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video presented in the style of Chinese ink painting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, tightly framed close-up of an elderly scholar's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scholar's hand gripping a dark bamboo brush with visible white knuckles and prominent veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a blank rice paper scroll visible in the lower half of the frame with the brush tip hovering just above it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a depthless, graded gray ensuring focus on the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5792156457901001 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8292156457901001 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5792156457901001, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5792156457901001, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1819838434457779, + 0.17796477675437927, + 0.10343637317419052, + 0.20934592187404633, + 0.11463943123817444, + 0.060879550874233246, + 0.01995525322854519, + 0.05387277156114578, + 0.04847295954823494, + 0.029449088498950005 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5792156457901001 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video presented in the style of Chinese ink painting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, tightly framed close-up of an elderly scholar's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scholar's hand gripping a dark bamboo brush with visible white knuckles and prominent veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a blank rice paper scroll visible in the lower half of the frame with the brush tip hovering just above it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a depthless, graded gray ensuring focus on the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07902887463569641 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.579028844833374 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07902887463569641, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07902887463569641, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2036900818347931, + 0.43638721108436584, + 0.0619458369910717, + 0.0645347535610199, + 0.036843713372945786, + 0.06431461870670319, + 0.01667630672454834, + 0.026410650461912155, + 0.0587557889521122, + 0.030441032722592354 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07902887463569641 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video presented in the style of Chinese ink painting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, tightly framed close-up of an elderly scholar's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scholar's hand gripping a dark bamboo brush with visible white knuckles and prominent veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a blank rice paper scroll visible in the lower half of the frame with the brush tip hovering just above it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a depthless, graded gray ensuring focus on the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011086649261415005 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511086463928223 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011086649261415005, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011086649261415005, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1161266565322876, + 0.34433335065841675, + 0.09122906625270844, + 0.06536296010017395, + 0.07557971030473709, + 0.1053924486041069, + 0.056345969438552856, + 0.040567945688962936, + 0.07604715973138809, + 0.029014673084020615 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011086649261415005 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video presented in the style of Chinese ink painting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, tightly framed close-up of an elderly scholar's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scholar's hand gripping a dark bamboo brush with visible white knuckles and prominent veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a blank rice paper scroll visible in the lower half of the frame with the brush tip hovering just above it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a depthless, graded gray ensuring focus on the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02057950384914875 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955795764923096 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02057950384914875, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02057950384914875, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17202994227409363, + 0.11825168877840042, + 0.12870551645755768, + 0.08478869497776031, + 0.06762384623289108, + 0.10431735217571259, + 0.038219861686229706, + 0.10393383353948593, + 0.05830905959010124, + 0.1238202303647995 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02057950384914875 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video presented in the style of Chinese ink painting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, tightly framed close-up of an elderly scholar's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scholar's hand gripping a dark bamboo brush with visible white knuckles and prominent veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a blank rice paper scroll visible in the lower half of the frame with the brush tip hovering just above it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a depthless, graded gray ensuring focus on the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004090751986950636 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504090785980225 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004090751986950636, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004090751986950636, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20001985132694244, + 0.31609582901000977, + 0.07183047384023666, + 0.04350001737475395, + 0.16816076636314392, + 0.06438705325126648, + 0.02068730816245079, + 0.038785941898822784, + 0.026517046615481377, + 0.05001574382185936 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004090751986950636 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In the stark, expressive style of Chinese ink painting, a static, tightly framed close-up captures the profound ideological struggle of an elderly scholar. His face is a landscape of deep concentration, brow furrowed, lips pressed tightly together, every wrinkle and age mark like a deliberate brushstroke. A wisp of long, thin white hair escapes from a simple topknot, framing his features. The camera's unwavering gaze focuses on his hand; his knuckles are pure white, veins prominent as he grips a dark bamboo brush with immense pressure. The tip of the brush, drenched in glistening black ink, hovers precariously just a millimeter above a pristine, blank scroll of rice paper that fills the lower half of the frame. The scene is illuminated by a soft, diffuse light from an unseen source, creating a dramatic play of light and shadow, emphasizing the texture of his simple gray silk robe and the grain of the dark wooden table beneath the scroll. The background is a depthless, graded gray, ensuring absolute focus on the scholar's internal conflict. The whole atmosphere was one of great, silent tension, the air thick with the weight of philosophical questions as he hesitated, caught in moments of profound creativity and intellectual paralysis.", + "seed": 18698, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_5/index_4402_seed_18698_dp_10_rank_20_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.09345606490969657, + "vlm_logprob": -0.09345606490969657, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.0, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.09345606490969657, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video presented in the style of Chinese ink painting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, tightly framed close-up of an elderly scholar's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scholar's hand gripping a dark bamboo brush with visible white knuckles and prominent veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a blank rice paper scroll visible in the lower half of the frame with the brush tip hovering just above it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a depthless, graded gray ensuring focus on the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.43279901146888733 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.057798981666565 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.43279901146888733, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.43279901146888733, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4720965027809143, + 0.17231309413909912, + 0.03636246547102928, + 0.039249517023563385, + 0.022387802600860596, + 0.026730913668870926, + 0.0950142964720726, + 0.03664669394493103, + 0.028620094060897827, + 0.07057859003543854 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.43279901146888733 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video presented in the style of Chinese ink painting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, tightly framed close-up of an elderly scholar's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scholar's hand gripping a dark bamboo brush with visible white knuckles and prominent veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a blank rice paper scroll visible in the lower half of the frame with the brush tip hovering just above it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a depthless, graded gray ensuring focus on the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012584090232849121 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387584209442139 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012584090232849121, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012584090232849121, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09556904435157776, + 0.12700539827346802, + 0.08568613231182098, + 0.06191786751151085, + 0.04311162233352661, + 0.07063508033752441, + 0.22724753618240356, + 0.20299524068832397, + 0.04072146862745285, + 0.045110613107681274 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012584090232849121 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video presented in the style of Chinese ink painting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, tightly framed close-up of an elderly scholar's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scholar's hand gripping a dark bamboo brush with visible white knuckles and prominent veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a blank rice paper scroll visible in the lower half of the frame with the brush tip hovering just above it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a depthless, graded gray ensuring focus on the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004098231438547373 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504098415374756 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004098231438547373, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004098231438547373, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.45029720664024353, + 0.17962580919265747, + 0.08005206286907196, + 0.04200422018766403, + 0.032625291496515274, + 0.031772445887327194, + 0.05680792033672333, + 0.0315563902258873, + 0.030444541946053505, + 0.06481406837701797 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004098231438547373 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video presented in the style of Chinese ink painting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, tightly framed close-up of an elderly scholar's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scholar's hand gripping a dark bamboo brush with visible white knuckles and prominent veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a blank rice paper scroll visible in the lower half of the frame with the brush tip hovering just above it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a depthless, graded gray ensuring focus on the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011070025153458118 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511070251464844 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011070025153458118, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011070025153458118, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.27924343943595886, + 0.09703221172094345, + 0.06056253984570503, + 0.03402169421315193, + 0.05122879520058632, + 0.027255896478891373, + 0.16997313499450684, + 0.12182316184043884, + 0.046504952013492584, + 0.11235413700342178 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011070025153458118 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video presented in the style of Chinese ink painting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, tightly framed close-up of an elderly scholar's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scholar's hand gripping a dark bamboo brush with visible white knuckles and prominent veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a blank rice paper scroll visible in the lower half of the frame with the brush tip hovering just above it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a depthless, graded gray ensuring focus on the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0067289662547409534 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.0067291259765625 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0067289662547409534, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0067289662547409534, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.29434868693351746, + 0.09754472970962524, + 0.12543725967407227, + 0.07679255306720734, + 0.08991263061761856, + 0.0662737712264061, + 0.0692523792386055, + 0.06971991062164307, + 0.035801514983177185, + 0.07491660863161087 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0067289662547409534 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In the stark, expressive style of Chinese ink painting, a static, tightly framed close-up captures the profound ideological struggle of an elderly scholar. His face is a landscape of deep concentration, brow furrowed, lips pressed tightly together, every wrinkle and age mark like a deliberate brushstroke. A wisp of long, thin white hair escapes from a simple topknot, framing his features. The camera's unwavering gaze focuses on his hand; his knuckles are pure white, veins prominent as he grips a dark bamboo brush with immense pressure. The tip of the brush, drenched in glistening black ink, hovers precariously just a millimeter above a pristine, blank scroll of rice paper that fills the lower half of the frame. The scene is illuminated by a soft, diffuse light from an unseen source, creating a dramatic play of light and shadow, emphasizing the texture of his simple gray silk robe and the grain of the dark wooden table beneath the scroll. The background is a depthless, graded gray, ensuring absolute focus on the scholar's internal conflict. The whole atmosphere was one of great, silent tension, the air thick with the weight of philosophical questions as he hesitated, caught in moments of profound creativity and intellectual paralysis.", + "seed": 18699, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_5/index_4402_seed_18699_dp_11_rank_22_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.35662741847336293, + "vlm_logprob": -0.35662741847336293, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.9, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.35662741847336293, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video presented in the style of Chinese ink painting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, tightly framed close-up of an elderly scholar's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scholar's hand gripping a dark bamboo brush with visible white knuckles and prominent veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a blank rice paper scroll visible in the lower half of the frame with the brush tip hovering just above it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a depthless, graded gray ensuring focus on the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7033145427703857 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20331448316574097 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.7033145427703857, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -1.7033145427703857, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20923642814159393, + 0.031460363417863846, + 0.023314189165830612, + 0.033766310662031174, + 0.06964501738548279, + 0.03209459036588669, + 0.04548720642924309, + 0.1180986613035202, + 0.24598132073879242, + 0.19091594219207764 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.7033145427703857 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video presented in the style of Chinese ink painting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, tightly framed close-up of an elderly scholar's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scholar's hand gripping a dark bamboo brush with visible white knuckles and prominent veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a blank rice paper scroll visible in the lower half of the frame with the brush tip hovering just above it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a depthless, graded gray ensuring focus on the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02986138127744198 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298614501953125 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02986138127744198, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02986138127744198, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05937298387289047, + 0.031162958592176437, + 0.027849894016981125, + 0.022137228399515152, + 0.02294844761490822, + 0.023104265332221985, + 0.037028443068265915, + 0.0698467567563057, + 0.6436223983764648, + 0.06292661279439926 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02986138127744198 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video presented in the style of Chinese ink painting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, tightly framed close-up of an elderly scholar's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scholar's hand gripping a dark bamboo brush with visible white knuckles and prominent veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a blank rice paper scroll visible in the lower half of the frame with the brush tip hovering just above it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a depthless, graded gray ensuring focus on the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012551010586321354 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.3875508308410645 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012551010586321354, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012551010586321354, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17278191447257996, + 0.06153145059943199, + 0.02375228889286518, + 0.03810988739132881, + 0.19947779178619385, + 0.04693053662776947, + 0.05799610912799835, + 0.0710960403084755, + 0.20553351938724518, + 0.12279044091701508 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012551010586321354 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video presented in the style of Chinese ink painting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, tightly framed close-up of an elderly scholar's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scholar's hand gripping a dark bamboo brush with visible white knuckles and prominent veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a blank rice paper scroll visible in the lower half of the frame with the brush tip hovering just above it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a depthless, graded gray ensuring focus on the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02634178288280964 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651341676712036 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02634178288280964, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02634178288280964, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09230934828519821, + 0.04329584166407585, + 0.04532310366630554, + 0.027558650821447372, + 0.07850654423236847, + 0.03687942400574684, + 0.045952752232551575, + 0.08313426375389099, + 0.5122909545898438, + 0.034749120473861694 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02634178288280964 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video presented in the style of Chinese ink painting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, tightly framed close-up of an elderly scholar's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scholar's hand gripping a dark bamboo brush with visible white knuckles and prominent veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a blank rice paper scroll visible in the lower half of the frame with the brush tip hovering just above it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a depthless, graded gray ensuring focus on the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0110683748498559 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511068344116211 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0110683748498559, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0110683748498559, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2143445760011673, + 0.05126571282744408, + 0.036053888499736786, + 0.045966871082782745, + 0.05805966630578041, + 0.04675746709108353, + 0.0464322455227375, + 0.07581651210784912, + 0.34461742639541626, + 0.08068554848432541 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0110683748498559 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In the stark, expressive style of Chinese ink painting, a static, tightly framed close-up captures the profound ideological struggle of an elderly scholar. His face is a landscape of deep concentration, brow furrowed, lips pressed tightly together, every wrinkle and age mark like a deliberate brushstroke. A wisp of long, thin white hair escapes from a simple topknot, framing his features. The camera's unwavering gaze focuses on his hand; his knuckles are pure white, veins prominent as he grips a dark bamboo brush with immense pressure. The tip of the brush, drenched in glistening black ink, hovers precariously just a millimeter above a pristine, blank scroll of rice paper that fills the lower half of the frame. The scene is illuminated by a soft, diffuse light from an unseen source, creating a dramatic play of light and shadow, emphasizing the texture of his simple gray silk robe and the grain of the dark wooden table beneath the scroll. The background is a depthless, graded gray, ensuring absolute focus on the scholar's internal conflict. The whole atmosphere was one of great, silent tension, the air thick with the weight of philosophical questions as he hesitated, caught in moments of profound creativity and intellectual paralysis.", + "seed": 18700, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_5/index_4402_seed_18700_dp_11_rank_22_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.14527790611609817, + "vlm_logprob": -0.14527790611609817, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.25, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.14527790611609817, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video presented in the style of Chinese ink painting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, tightly framed close-up of an elderly scholar's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scholar's hand gripping a dark bamboo brush with visible white knuckles and prominent veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a blank rice paper scroll visible in the lower half of the frame with the brush tip hovering just above it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a depthless, graded gray ensuring focus on the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3522801399230957 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2272801399230957 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3522801399230957, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3522801399230957, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2220364212989807, + 0.14835742115974426, + 0.08742616325616837, + 0.06399478018283844, + 0.14130106568336487, + 0.0962393507361412, + 0.04606010019779205, + 0.054020944982767105, + 0.07487243413925171, + 0.0656912699341774 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3522801399230957 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video presented in the style of Chinese ink painting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, tightly framed close-up of an elderly scholar's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scholar's hand gripping a dark bamboo brush with visible white knuckles and prominent veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a blank rice paper scroll visible in the lower half of the frame with the brush tip hovering just above it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a depthless, graded gray ensuring focus on the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3486765921115875 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2236765623092651 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3486765921115875, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3486765921115875, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17417293787002563, + 0.06759840995073318, + 0.07225419580936432, + 0.08233614265918732, + 0.11967190355062485, + 0.09843026101589203, + 0.1437065154314041, + 0.07604014873504639, + 0.06717759370803833, + 0.09861193597316742 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3486765921115875 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video presented in the style of Chinese ink painting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, tightly framed close-up of an elderly scholar's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scholar's hand gripping a dark bamboo brush with visible white knuckles and prominent veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a blank rice paper scroll visible in the lower half of the frame with the brush tip hovering just above it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a depthless, graded gray ensuring focus on the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005266720429062843 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.2552666664123535 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005266720429062843, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005266720429062843, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10036551207304001, + 0.16783666610717773, + 0.10939972847700119, + 0.06777314841747284, + 0.07971452921628952, + 0.10008499026298523, + 0.08493410050868988, + 0.05796991288661957, + 0.04513801634311676, + 0.18678344786167145 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005266720429062843 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video presented in the style of Chinese ink painting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, tightly framed close-up of an elderly scholar's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scholar's hand gripping a dark bamboo brush with visible white knuckles and prominent veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a blank rice paper scroll visible in the lower half of the frame with the brush tip hovering just above it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a depthless, graded gray ensuring focus on the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00763084227219224 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882630825042725 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00763084227219224, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00763084227219224, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08118037134408951, + 0.055298589169979095, + 0.04112644121050835, + 0.03402270749211311, + 0.2696356773376465, + 0.1625550389289856, + 0.08240146934986115, + 0.19203893840312958, + 0.03947233036160469, + 0.042268432676792145 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 7, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00763084227219224 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video presented in the style of Chinese ink painting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, tightly framed close-up of an elderly scholar's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scholar's hand gripping a dark bamboo brush with visible white knuckles and prominent veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a blank rice paper scroll visible in the lower half of the frame with the brush tip hovering just above it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a depthless, graded gray ensuring focus on the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012535235844552517 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387535095214844 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012535235844552517, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012535235844552517, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13156764209270477, + 0.07254325598478317, + 0.04955916851758957, + 0.054724570363759995, + 0.15012748539447784, + 0.20878095924854279, + 0.09802813082933426, + 0.06755844503641129, + 0.07682634145021439, + 0.09028401225805283 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012535235844552517 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_6/index_tensor([7150, 7150])_group_6_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_6/index_tensor([7150, 7150])_group_6_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..9c6dd049be8e6fc04161e8aab0f0077aab235043 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_6/index_tensor([7150, 7150])_group_6_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "close-up shot from a slightly downward angle, the camera held still, precisely capturing a perfectly spherical drop of vibrant, self-luminous magenta digital paint suspended directly above a pristine white canvas affixed to a classic dark wooden easel. Surrounding the minimalist studio, which is dimly lit and nearly pitch black, the canvas's rough weave is faintly visible in the dim light. The drop of paint falls silently, and upon contact with the surface, it immediately spreads with astonishing speed. Unlike traditional ink, it permeates the canvas, but rather, like a living algorithm, rapidly and decisively spreading complex and delicate veins, resembling fractal structures. This stream of magenta light, with its sharp, fluid edges, steadily and deliberately infuses the ancient fabric with digital light, casting a vibrant, pulsating glow in the darkness and tinging the surrounding air with a soft aura. The scene, defined by its striking contrasts of light and dark, creates an atmosphere of focused tranquility, imbued with a sense of wonder, a fusion of classical art and futuristic technology.", + "seed": 4010, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_6/index_7150_seed_4010_dp_12_rank_24_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.02160110352560878, + "vlm_logprob": -0.02160110352560878, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.475, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.02160110352560878, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a slightly downward angle with the camera held still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a perfectly spherical drop of vibrant, self-luminous magenta digital paint suspended above a pristine white canvas on a dark wooden easel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the surrounding environment a dimly lit, nearly pitch black minimalist studio where the canvas's rough weave is faintly visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the magenta paint fall, spread rapidly upon contact, and form complex, delicate veins resembling fractal structures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the spreading paint cast a vibrant, pulsating glow that tinges the surrounding air with a soft aura?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05614433437585831 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0561442375183105 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05614433437585831, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05614433437585831, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1283504217863083, + 0.04971320554614067, + 0.09514350444078445, + 0.06961486488580704, + 0.026704667136073112, + 0.041923340409994125, + 0.13926950097084045, + 0.3029886782169342, + 0.13380613923072815, + 0.012485602870583534 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05614433437585831 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a slightly downward angle with the camera held still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a perfectly spherical drop of vibrant, self-luminous magenta digital paint suspended above a pristine white canvas on a dark wooden easel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the surrounding environment a dimly lit, nearly pitch black minimalist studio where the canvas's rough weave is faintly visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the magenta paint fall, spread rapidly upon contact, and form complex, delicate veins resembling fractal structures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the spreading paint cast a vibrant, pulsating glow that tinges the surrounding air with a soft aura?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023337803781032562 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7733378410339355 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023337803781032562, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023337803781032562, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3405453860759735, + 0.08547987788915634, + 0.0876886248588562, + 0.07132429629564285, + 0.04627300426363945, + 0.06634049862623215, + 0.08727826178073883, + 0.06639466434717178, + 0.11614856123924255, + 0.032526832073926926 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023337803781032562 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a slightly downward angle with the camera held still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a perfectly spherical drop of vibrant, self-luminous magenta digital paint suspended above a pristine white canvas on a dark wooden easel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the surrounding environment a dimly lit, nearly pitch black minimalist studio where the canvas's rough weave is faintly visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the magenta paint fall, spread rapidly upon contact, and form complex, delicate veins resembling fractal structures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the spreading paint cast a vibrant, pulsating glow that tinges the surrounding air with a soft aura?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02060437947511673 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895604372024536 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02060437947511673, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02060437947511673, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22121314704418182, + 0.1180938184261322, + 0.2200990468263626, + 0.1534130573272705, + 0.05335414782166481, + 0.05557399243116379, + 0.04138828068971634, + 0.09480219334363937, + 0.027222855016589165, + 0.014839480631053448 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02060437947511673 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a slightly downward angle with the camera held still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a perfectly spherical drop of vibrant, self-luminous magenta digital paint suspended above a pristine white canvas on a dark wooden easel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the surrounding environment a dimly lit, nearly pitch black minimalist studio where the canvas's rough weave is faintly visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the magenta paint fall, spread rapidly upon contact, and form complex, delicate veins resembling fractal structures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the spreading paint cast a vibrant, pulsating glow that tinges the surrounding air with a soft aura?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0011829291470348835 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.751183032989502 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0011829291470348835, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0011829291470348835, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1615259051322937, + 0.07160676270723343, + 0.1509162336587906, + 0.10088042914867401, + 0.07943784445524216, + 0.06301475316286087, + 0.07014066725969315, + 0.1518438458442688, + 0.10477500408887863, + 0.04585859924554825 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0011829291470348835 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a slightly downward angle with the camera held still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a perfectly spherical drop of vibrant, self-luminous magenta digital paint suspended above a pristine white canvas on a dark wooden easel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the surrounding environment a dimly lit, nearly pitch black minimalist studio where the canvas's rough weave is faintly visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the magenta paint fall, spread rapidly upon contact, and form complex, delicate veins resembling fractal structures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the spreading paint cast a vibrant, pulsating glow that tinges the surrounding air with a soft aura?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006736070849001408 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.0067362785339355 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006736070849001408, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006736070849001408, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06977999210357666, + 0.09408508241176605, + 0.24739547073841095, + 0.20346255600452423, + 0.054285988211631775, + 0.038059983402490616, + 0.07089844346046448, + 0.10778743773698807, + 0.03413427993655205, + 0.08011071383953094 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006736070849001408 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up shot from a slightly downward angle, the camera held still, precisely capturing a perfectly spherical drop of vibrant, self-luminous magenta digital paint suspended directly above a pristine white canvas affixed to a classic dark wooden easel. Surrounding the minimalist studio, which is dimly lit and nearly pitch black, the canvas's rough weave is faintly visible in the dim light. The drop of paint falls silently, and upon contact with the surface, it immediately spreads with astonishing speed. Unlike traditional ink, it permeates the canvas, but rather, like a living algorithm, rapidly and decisively spreading complex and delicate veins, resembling fractal structures. This stream of magenta light, with its sharp, fluid edges, steadily and deliberately infuses the ancient fabric with digital light, casting a vibrant, pulsating glow in the darkness and tinging the surrounding air with a soft aura. The scene, defined by its striking contrasts of light and dark, creates an atmosphere of focused tranquility, imbued with a sense of wonder, a fusion of classical art and futuristic technology.", + "seed": 4011, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_6/index_7150_seed_4011_dp_12_rank_24_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.02591569849755615, + "vlm_logprob": -0.02591569849755615, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.175, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.02591569849755615, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a slightly downward angle with the camera held still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a perfectly spherical drop of vibrant, self-luminous magenta digital paint suspended above a pristine white canvas on a dark wooden easel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the surrounding environment a dimly lit, nearly pitch black minimalist studio where the canvas's rough weave is faintly visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the magenta paint fall, spread rapidly upon contact, and form complex, delicate veins resembling fractal structures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the spreading paint cast a vibrant, pulsating glow that tinges the surrounding air with a soft aura?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.024698637425899506 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.149698734283447 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.024698637425899506, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.024698637425899506, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19141100347042084, + 0.0991058349609375, + 0.04090190306305885, + 0.09329816699028015, + 0.10085335373878479, + 0.10932924598455429, + 0.051632847636938095, + 0.17655456066131592, + 0.026291582733392715, + 0.11062148213386536 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.024698637425899506 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a slightly downward angle with the camera held still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a perfectly spherical drop of vibrant, self-luminous magenta digital paint suspended above a pristine white canvas on a dark wooden easel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the surrounding environment a dimly lit, nearly pitch black minimalist studio where the canvas's rough weave is faintly visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the magenta paint fall, spread rapidly upon contact, and form complex, delicate veins resembling fractal structures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the spreading paint cast a vibrant, pulsating glow that tinges the surrounding air with a soft aura?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014239019714295864 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.2642388343811035 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014239019714295864, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014239019714295864, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15209703147411346, + 0.17018172144889832, + 0.043383508920669556, + 0.12496361136436462, + 0.16098573803901672, + 0.04033045470714569, + 0.029468465596437454, + 0.119000643491745, + 0.11411526054143906, + 0.04547356814146042 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014239019714295864 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a slightly downward angle with the camera held still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a perfectly spherical drop of vibrant, self-luminous magenta digital paint suspended above a pristine white canvas on a dark wooden easel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the surrounding environment a dimly lit, nearly pitch black minimalist studio where the canvas's rough weave is faintly visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the magenta paint fall, spread rapidly upon contact, and form complex, delicate veins resembling fractal structures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the spreading paint cast a vibrant, pulsating glow that tinges the surrounding air with a soft aura?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05499931797385216 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929999351501465 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05499931797385216, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05499931797385216, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2949870526790619, + 0.21472516655921936, + 0.04585860297083855, + 0.046679168939590454, + 0.13070650398731232, + 0.05743604898452759, + 0.08375150710344315, + 0.027729887515306473, + 0.037298768758773804, + 0.0608273409307003 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05499931797385216 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a slightly downward angle with the camera held still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a perfectly spherical drop of vibrant, self-luminous magenta digital paint suspended above a pristine white canvas on a dark wooden easel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the surrounding environment a dimly lit, nearly pitch black minimalist studio where the canvas's rough weave is faintly visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the magenta paint fall, spread rapidly upon contact, and form complex, delicate veins resembling fractal structures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the spreading paint cast a vibrant, pulsating glow that tinges the surrounding air with a soft aura?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0019449143437668681 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.2519450187683105 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0019449143437668681, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0019449143437668681, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11105577647686005, + 0.10671351104974747, + 0.04690791666507721, + 0.09650330990552902, + 0.10809989273548126, + 0.05719240382313728, + 0.10985150188207626, + 0.13764688372612, + 0.09238332509994507, + 0.13364538550376892 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0019449143437668681 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a slightly downward angle with the camera held still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a perfectly spherical drop of vibrant, self-luminous magenta digital paint suspended above a pristine white canvas on a dark wooden easel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the surrounding environment a dimly lit, nearly pitch black minimalist studio where the canvas's rough weave is faintly visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the magenta paint fall, spread rapidly upon contact, and form complex, delicate veins resembling fractal structures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the spreading paint cast a vibrant, pulsating glow that tinges the surrounding air with a soft aura?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.033696603029966354 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4086966514587402 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.033696603029966354, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.033696603029966354, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1271386295557022, + 0.1366901993751526, + 0.05745517089962959, + 0.08306047320365906, + 0.08023906499147415, + 0.20923632383346558, + 0.14489884674549103, + 0.031506795436143875, + 0.04186796024441719, + 0.08790650218725204 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.033696603029966354 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up shot from a slightly downward angle, the camera held still, precisely capturing a perfectly spherical drop of vibrant, self-luminous magenta digital paint suspended directly above a pristine white canvas affixed to a classic dark wooden easel. Surrounding the minimalist studio, which is dimly lit and nearly pitch black, the canvas's rough weave is faintly visible in the dim light. The drop of paint falls silently, and upon contact with the surface, it immediately spreads with astonishing speed. Unlike traditional ink, it permeates the canvas, but rather, like a living algorithm, rapidly and decisively spreading complex and delicate veins, resembling fractal structures. This stream of magenta light, with its sharp, fluid edges, steadily and deliberately infuses the ancient fabric with digital light, casting a vibrant, pulsating glow in the darkness and tinging the surrounding air with a soft aura. The scene, defined by its striking contrasts of light and dark, creates an atmosphere of focused tranquility, imbued with a sense of wonder, a fusion of classical art and futuristic technology.", + "seed": 4012, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_6/index_7150_seed_4012_dp_13_rank_26_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.023545161075890064, + "vlm_logprob": -0.023545161075890064, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.3, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.023545161075890064, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a slightly downward angle with the camera held still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a perfectly spherical drop of vibrant, self-luminous magenta digital paint suspended above a pristine white canvas on a dark wooden easel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the surrounding environment a dimly lit, nearly pitch black minimalist studio where the canvas's rough weave is faintly visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the magenta paint fall, spread rapidly upon contact, and form complex, delicate veins resembling fractal structures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the spreading paint cast a vibrant, pulsating glow that tinges the surrounding air with a soft aura?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02728879265487194 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.9022886753082275 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02728879265487194, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02728879265487194, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09916188567876816, + 0.06684693694114685, + 0.2935054302215576, + 0.07601585239171982, + 0.03373170644044876, + 0.11780746281147003, + 0.11061104387044907, + 0.05635753646492958, + 0.06094176322221756, + 0.08502037078142166 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02728879265487194 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a slightly downward angle with the camera held still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a perfectly spherical drop of vibrant, self-luminous magenta digital paint suspended above a pristine white canvas on a dark wooden easel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the surrounding environment a dimly lit, nearly pitch black minimalist studio where the canvas's rough weave is faintly visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the magenta paint fall, spread rapidly upon contact, and form complex, delicate veins resembling fractal structures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the spreading paint cast a vibrant, pulsating glow that tinges the surrounding air with a soft aura?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018229912966489792 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018229961395264 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018229912966489792, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018229912966489792, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14698559045791626, + 0.08711707592010498, + 0.19531835615634918, + 0.20038311183452606, + 0.05810327082872391, + 0.13284355401992798, + 0.05358682945370674, + 0.0321236178278923, + 0.06223241239786148, + 0.03130615875124931 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018229912966489792 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a slightly downward angle with the camera held still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a perfectly spherical drop of vibrant, self-luminous magenta digital paint suspended above a pristine white canvas on a dark wooden easel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the surrounding environment a dimly lit, nearly pitch black minimalist studio where the canvas's rough weave is faintly visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the magenta paint fall, spread rapidly upon contact, and form complex, delicate veins resembling fractal structures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the spreading paint cast a vibrant, pulsating glow that tinges the surrounding air with a soft aura?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.062087271362543106 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812087297439575 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.062087271362543106, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.062087271362543106, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15936069190502167, + 0.06377846002578735, + 0.27272650599479675, + 0.11575475335121155, + 0.054594963788986206, + 0.093589648604393, + 0.13313226401805878, + 0.019238559529185295, + 0.029958324506878853, + 0.05786578729748726 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.062087271362543106 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a slightly downward angle with the camera held still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a perfectly spherical drop of vibrant, self-luminous magenta digital paint suspended above a pristine white canvas on a dark wooden easel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the surrounding environment a dimly lit, nearly pitch black minimalist studio where the canvas's rough weave is faintly visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the magenta paint fall, spread rapidly upon contact, and form complex, delicate veins resembling fractal structures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the spreading paint cast a vibrant, pulsating glow that tinges the surrounding air with a soft aura?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0024920618161559105 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.0024919509887695 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0024920618161559105, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0024920618161559105, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07808060944080353, + 0.0355481281876564, + 0.226991668343544, + 0.16270585358142853, + 0.08650363236665726, + 0.1274406462907791, + 0.0760032907128334, + 0.033967968076467514, + 0.0580061711370945, + 0.11475208401679993 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0024920618161559105 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a slightly downward angle with the camera held still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a perfectly spherical drop of vibrant, self-luminous magenta digital paint suspended above a pristine white canvas on a dark wooden easel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the surrounding environment a dimly lit, nearly pitch black minimalist studio where the canvas's rough weave is faintly visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the magenta paint fall, spread rapidly upon contact, and form complex, delicate veins resembling fractal structures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the spreading paint cast a vibrant, pulsating glow that tinges the surrounding air with a soft aura?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007627766579389572 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882627964019775 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007627766579389572, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007627766579389572, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07337112724781036, + 0.02465239353477955, + 0.05070418119430542, + 0.16346438229084015, + 0.06287460029125214, + 0.08278321474790573, + 0.24458777904510498, + 0.03433631733059883, + 0.047095149755477905, + 0.21613086760044098 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007627766579389572 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up shot from a slightly downward angle, the camera held still, precisely capturing a perfectly spherical drop of vibrant, self-luminous magenta digital paint suspended directly above a pristine white canvas affixed to a classic dark wooden easel. Surrounding the minimalist studio, which is dimly lit and nearly pitch black, the canvas's rough weave is faintly visible in the dim light. The drop of paint falls silently, and upon contact with the surface, it immediately spreads with astonishing speed. Unlike traditional ink, it permeates the canvas, but rather, like a living algorithm, rapidly and decisively spreading complex and delicate veins, resembling fractal structures. This stream of magenta light, with its sharp, fluid edges, steadily and deliberately infuses the ancient fabric with digital light, casting a vibrant, pulsating glow in the darkness and tinging the surrounding air with a soft aura. The scene, defined by its striking contrasts of light and dark, creates an atmosphere of focused tranquility, imbued with a sense of wonder, a fusion of classical art and futuristic technology.", + "seed": 4013, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_6/index_7150_seed_4013_dp_13_rank_26_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.014686213247478009, + "vlm_logprob": -0.014686213247478009, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.875, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.014686213247478009, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a slightly downward angle with the camera held still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a perfectly spherical drop of vibrant, self-luminous magenta digital paint suspended above a pristine white canvas on a dark wooden easel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the surrounding environment a dimly lit, nearly pitch black minimalist studio where the canvas's rough weave is faintly visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the magenta paint fall, spread rapidly upon contact, and form complex, delicate veins resembling fractal structures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the spreading paint cast a vibrant, pulsating glow that tinges the surrounding air with a soft aura?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020177580416202545 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.395177364349365 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020177580416202545, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020177580416202545, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04720474034547806, + 0.03226484730839729, + 0.020192161202430725, + 0.04089301452040672, + 0.03138350695371628, + 0.028832154348492622, + 0.021061522886157036, + 0.04216324910521507, + 0.716292679309845, + 0.01971215382218361 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020177580416202545 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a slightly downward angle with the camera held still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a perfectly spherical drop of vibrant, self-luminous magenta digital paint suspended above a pristine white canvas on a dark wooden easel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the surrounding environment a dimly lit, nearly pitch black minimalist studio where the canvas's rough weave is faintly visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the magenta paint fall, spread rapidly upon contact, and form complex, delicate veins resembling fractal structures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the spreading paint cast a vibrant, pulsating glow that tinges the surrounding air with a soft aura?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0086794039234519 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758679389953613 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0086794039234519, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0086794039234519, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1998845785856247, + 0.08964165300130844, + 0.06474762409925461, + 0.024279708042740822, + 0.0657716691493988, + 0.018450886011123657, + 0.038125067949295044, + 0.013795658946037292, + 0.4485114514827728, + 0.03679170459508896 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0086794039234519 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a slightly downward angle with the camera held still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a perfectly spherical drop of vibrant, self-luminous magenta digital paint suspended above a pristine white canvas on a dark wooden easel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the surrounding environment a dimly lit, nearly pitch black minimalist studio where the canvas's rough weave is faintly visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the magenta paint fall, spread rapidly upon contact, and form complex, delicate veins resembling fractal structures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the spreading paint cast a vibrant, pulsating glow that tinges the surrounding air with a soft aura?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03813711926341057 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288137197494507 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03813711926341057, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03813711926341057, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06556963920593262, + 0.09462231397628784, + 0.025007741525769234, + 0.018417522311210632, + 0.017082512378692627, + 0.027216393500566483, + 0.02431674115359783, + 0.02491762489080429, + 0.5615326166152954, + 0.14131693542003632 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03813711926341057 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a slightly downward angle with the camera held still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a perfectly spherical drop of vibrant, self-luminous magenta digital paint suspended above a pristine white canvas on a dark wooden easel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the surrounding environment a dimly lit, nearly pitch black minimalist studio where the canvas's rough weave is faintly visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the magenta paint fall, spread rapidly upon contact, and form complex, delicate veins resembling fractal structures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the spreading paint cast a vibrant, pulsating glow that tinges the surrounding air with a soft aura?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0011832863092422485 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.75118350982666 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0011832863092422485, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0011832863092422485, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06238974630832672, + 0.035452939569950104, + 0.05019250884652138, + 0.027914736419916153, + 0.06462394446134567, + 0.029470574110746384, + 0.01469770073890686, + 0.008800187148153782, + 0.5926186442375183, + 0.1138390377163887 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0011832863092422485 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a slightly downward angle with the camera held still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a perfectly spherical drop of vibrant, self-luminous magenta digital paint suspended above a pristine white canvas on a dark wooden easel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the surrounding environment a dimly lit, nearly pitch black minimalist studio where the canvas's rough weave is faintly visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the magenta paint fall, spread rapidly upon contact, and form complex, delicate veins resembling fractal structures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the spreading paint cast a vibrant, pulsating glow that tinges the surrounding air with a soft aura?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005253676325082779 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255253791809082 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005253676325082779, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005253676325082779, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04907446354627609, + 0.05506793409585953, + 0.020821282640099525, + 0.027234870940446854, + 0.04112917184829712, + 0.01211482286453247, + 0.010836220346391201, + 0.020808815956115723, + 0.5841711759567261, + 0.17874126136302948 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005253676325082779 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_7/index_tensor([3930, 3930])_group_7_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_7/index_tensor([3930, 3930])_group_7_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..0d881f2e818ca61933f8625b80d41b10946a4298 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_7/index_tensor([3930, 3930])_group_7_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "slow, eye-level camera drifts across a sprawling post-apocalyptic market, huddled beneath a patchwork canopy of rusted corrugated metal shelters. Sharp, bright sunlight pierces a series of bullet holes in the roof, piercing the dim, shadowy space and illuminating the thick, swirling dust. The camera's steady movement focuses on a central exchange, where a gaunt, weathered scavenger with a scraggly gray beard, dressed in a tattered ensemble of canvas and leather, carefully pulls out a green fiberglass circuit board, its intricate silver paths gleaming. Opposite him, a young scavenger, his eyes wary, his face smeared with grime, clutches a dirty plastic bottle of clear water in his hands, his posture tense. The transaction proceeds with a slow, deliberate gravity; hands hover, inspecting the goods, and then the circuit board is eventually exchanged for the bottle in a silent, desperate exchange. In the background, other figures shuttle between stalls filled with recycled solar panels and the faded, torn remnants of faded banners. At the edge of the makeshift settlement, a massive wind turbine cobbled together from scrap metal churns with a rhythmic clatter, stirring up dust on the ground and underscoring the scene’s pervasive atmosphere of quiet despair, all rendered in a desaturated, earthy palette of rusty orange, dusty brown, and metallic gray.", + "seed": 13380, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_7/index_3930_seed_13380_dp_14_rank_28_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.03550653927959502, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03550653927959502, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.85, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03550653927959502, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at eye-level and drifting slowly across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a post-apocalyptic market with rusted corrugated metal shelters and bullet holes in the roof?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a gaunt scavenger with a scraggly gray beard wearing tattered canvas and leather visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the central action involve a transaction where a green fiberglass circuit board is exchanged for a dirty plastic bottle of clear water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style desaturated with an earthy palette of rusty orange, dusty brown, and metallic gray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06879443675279617 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1937944889068604 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06879443675279617, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06879443675279617, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15692128241062164, + 0.08446098864078522, + 0.0664604976773262, + 0.11044950038194656, + 0.055543452501297, + 0.10332392901182175, + 0.05965350195765495, + 0.10210320353507996, + 0.05192277953028679, + 0.20916087925434113 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06879443675279617 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at eye-level and drifting slowly across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a post-apocalyptic market with rusted corrugated metal shelters and bullet holes in the roof?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a gaunt scavenger with a scraggly gray beard wearing tattered canvas and leather visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the central action involve a transaction where a green fiberglass circuit board is exchanged for a dirty plastic bottle of clear water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style desaturated with an earthy palette of rusty orange, dusty brown, and metallic gray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02980491705238819 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298049449920654 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02980491705238819, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02980491705238819, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15057113766670227, + 0.06333660334348679, + 0.06942684948444366, + 0.07158620655536652, + 0.06300046294927597, + 0.08324524760246277, + 0.22657795250415802, + 0.032785024493932724, + 0.07952360808849335, + 0.1599469929933548 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02980491705238819 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at eye-level and drifting slowly across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a post-apocalyptic market with rusted corrugated metal shelters and bullet holes in the roof?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a gaunt scavenger with a scraggly gray beard wearing tattered canvas and leather visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the central action involve a transaction where a green fiberglass circuit board is exchanged for a dirty plastic bottle of clear water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style desaturated with an earthy palette of rusty orange, dusty brown, and metallic gray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04304227605462074 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680421829223633 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04304227605462074, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04304227605462074, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06353610754013062, + 0.1217220202088356, + 0.11878325045108795, + 0.07721047103404999, + 0.12777765095233917, + 0.05842820182442665, + 0.26179853081703186, + 0.029866544529795647, + 0.08624565601348877, + 0.054631557315588 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04304227605462074 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at eye-level and drifting slowly across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a post-apocalyptic market with rusted corrugated metal shelters and bullet holes in the roof?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a gaunt scavenger with a scraggly gray beard wearing tattered canvas and leather visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the central action involve a transaction where a green fiberglass circuit board is exchanged for a dirty plastic bottle of clear water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style desaturated with an earthy palette of rusty orange, dusty brown, and metallic gray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03369763866066933 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4086976051330566 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03369763866066933, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03369763866066933, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07248081266880035, + 0.04536180570721626, + 0.06293552368879318, + 0.05743304267525673, + 0.10508138686418533, + 0.21183523535728455, + 0.04544641450047493, + 0.23888970911502838, + 0.04534899815917015, + 0.11518711596727371 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03369763866066933 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at eye-level and drifting slowly across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a post-apocalyptic market with rusted corrugated metal shelters and bullet holes in the roof?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a gaunt scavenger with a scraggly gray beard wearing tattered canvas and leather visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the central action involve a transaction where a green fiberglass circuit board is exchanged for a dirty plastic bottle of clear water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style desaturated with an earthy palette of rusty orange, dusty brown, and metallic gray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0021934278775006533 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127193450927734 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0021934278775006533, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0021934278775006533, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07435822486877441, + 0.03966914489865303, + 0.02824690006673336, + 0.04966891184449196, + 0.058921460062265396, + 0.02230372652411461, + 0.4847904443740845, + 0.13509567081928253, + 0.06938110291957855, + 0.03756449744105339 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0021934278775006533 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow, eye-level camera drifts across a sprawling post-apocalyptic market, huddled beneath a patchwork canopy of rusted corrugated metal shelters. Sharp, bright sunlight pierces a series of bullet holes in the roof, piercing the dim, shadowy space and illuminating the thick, swirling dust. The camera's steady movement focuses on a central exchange, where a gaunt, weathered scavenger with a scraggly gray beard, dressed in a tattered ensemble of canvas and leather, carefully pulls out a green fiberglass circuit board, its intricate silver paths gleaming. Opposite him, a young scavenger, his eyes wary, his face smeared with grime, clutches a dirty plastic bottle of clear water in his hands, his posture tense. The transaction proceeds with a slow, deliberate gravity; hands hover, inspecting the goods, and then the circuit board is eventually exchanged for the bottle in a silent, desperate exchange. In the background, other figures shuttle between stalls filled with recycled solar panels and the faded, torn remnants of faded banners. At the edge of the makeshift settlement, a massive wind turbine cobbled together from scrap metal churns with a rhythmic clatter, stirring up dust on the ground and underscoring the scene’s pervasive atmosphere of quiet despair, all rendered in a desaturated, earthy palette of rusty orange, dusty brown, and metallic gray.", + "seed": 13381, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_7/index_3930_seed_13381_dp_14_rank_28_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.08878346648998559, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08878346648998559, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.375, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08878346648998559, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at eye-level and drifting slowly across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a post-apocalyptic market with rusted corrugated metal shelters and bullet holes in the roof?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a gaunt scavenger with a scraggly gray beard wearing tattered canvas and leather visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the central action involve a transaction where a green fiberglass circuit board is exchanged for a dirty plastic bottle of clear water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style desaturated with an earthy palette of rusty orange, dusty brown, and metallic gray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3263704776763916 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4513704776763916 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3263704776763916, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3263704776763916, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18353137373924255, + 0.04689065366983414, + 0.03662572056055069, + 0.027651749551296234, + 0.4108806252479553, + 0.022680021822452545, + 0.047312717884778976, + 0.01795634999871254, + 0.11418283730745316, + 0.09228786826133728 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3263704776763916 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at eye-level and drifting slowly across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a post-apocalyptic market with rusted corrugated metal shelters and bullet holes in the roof?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a gaunt scavenger with a scraggly gray beard wearing tattered canvas and leather visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the central action involve a transaction where a green fiberglass circuit board is exchanged for a dirty plastic bottle of clear water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style desaturated with an earthy palette of rusty orange, dusty brown, and metallic gray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03371366113424301 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4087135791778564 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03371366113424301, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03371366113424301, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20228174328804016, + 0.07088838517665863, + 0.09766371548175812, + 0.032349348068237305, + 0.3265441060066223, + 0.03347799926996231, + 0.025403091683983803, + 0.12710101902484894, + 0.036515552550554276, + 0.0477750338613987 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03371366113424301 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at eye-level and drifting slowly across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a post-apocalyptic market with rusted corrugated metal shelters and bullet holes in the roof?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a gaunt scavenger with a scraggly gray beard wearing tattered canvas and leather visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the central action involve a transaction where a green fiberglass circuit board is exchanged for a dirty plastic bottle of clear water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style desaturated with an earthy palette of rusty orange, dusty brown, and metallic gray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06203114241361618 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120310306549072 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06203114241361618, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06203114241361618, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07963598519563675, + 0.029438795521855354, + 0.04056386649608612, + 0.016923755407333374, + 0.663284957408905, + 0.013355139642953873, + 0.03826696425676346, + 0.028235498815774918, + 0.02318604849278927, + 0.06710901111364365 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06203114241361618 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at eye-level and drifting slowly across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a post-apocalyptic market with rusted corrugated metal shelters and bullet holes in the roof?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a gaunt scavenger with a scraggly gray beard wearing tattered canvas and leather visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the central action involve a transaction where a green fiberglass circuit board is exchanged for a dirty plastic bottle of clear water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style desaturated with an earthy palette of rusty orange, dusty brown, and metallic gray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018190816044807434 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018190860748291 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018190816044807434, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018190816044807434, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1637636423110962, + 0.2641852796077728, + 0.041210517287254333, + 0.0504831001162529, + 0.2929246425628662, + 0.020070131868124008, + 0.049511078745126724, + 0.02212676592171192, + 0.03456996753811836, + 0.061154864728450775 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018190816044807434 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at eye-level and drifting slowly across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a post-apocalyptic market with rusted corrugated metal shelters and bullet holes in the roof?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a gaunt scavenger with a scraggly gray beard wearing tattered canvas and leather visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the central action involve a transaction where a green fiberglass circuit board is exchanged for a dirty plastic bottle of clear water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style desaturated with an earthy palette of rusty orange, dusty brown, and metallic gray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036112351808696985 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628611087799072 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036112351808696985, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036112351808696985, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21312052011489868, + 0.034136515110731125, + 0.05923297628760338, + 0.01989630237221718, + 0.27799564599990845, + 0.03169797733426094, + 0.057340655475854874, + 0.055783599615097046, + 0.035422418266534805, + 0.21537341177463531 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036112351808696985 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow, eye-level camera drifts across a sprawling post-apocalyptic market, huddled beneath a patchwork canopy of rusted corrugated metal shelters. Sharp, bright sunlight pierces a series of bullet holes in the roof, piercing the dim, shadowy space and illuminating the thick, swirling dust. The camera's steady movement focuses on a central exchange, where a gaunt, weathered scavenger with a scraggly gray beard, dressed in a tattered ensemble of canvas and leather, carefully pulls out a green fiberglass circuit board, its intricate silver paths gleaming. Opposite him, a young scavenger, his eyes wary, his face smeared with grime, clutches a dirty plastic bottle of clear water in his hands, his posture tense. The transaction proceeds with a slow, deliberate gravity; hands hover, inspecting the goods, and then the circuit board is eventually exchanged for the bottle in a silent, desperate exchange. In the background, other figures shuttle between stalls filled with recycled solar panels and the faded, torn remnants of faded banners. At the edge of the makeshift settlement, a massive wind turbine cobbled together from scrap metal churns with a rhythmic clatter, stirring up dust on the ground and underscoring the scene’s pervasive atmosphere of quiet despair, all rendered in a desaturated, earthy palette of rusty orange, dusty brown, and metallic gray.", + "seed": 13382, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_7/index_3930_seed_13382_dp_15_rank_30_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.06775306165218353, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06775306165218353, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.45, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06775306165218353, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at eye-level and drifting slowly across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a post-apocalyptic market with rusted corrugated metal shelters and bullet holes in the roof?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a gaunt scavenger with a scraggly gray beard wearing tattered canvas and leather visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the central action involve a transaction where a green fiberglass circuit board is exchanged for a dirty plastic bottle of clear water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style desaturated with an earthy palette of rusty orange, dusty brown, and metallic gray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2351953685283661 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8601953983306885 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2351953685283661, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2351953685283661, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11474946141242981, + 0.056525714695453644, + 0.08323652297258377, + 0.15909028053283691, + 0.11512106657028198, + 0.09941713511943817, + 0.11894135922193527, + 0.07824797928333282, + 0.04108017310500145, + 0.13359029591083527 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2351953685283661 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at eye-level and drifting slowly across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a post-apocalyptic market with rusted corrugated metal shelters and bullet holes in the roof?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a gaunt scavenger with a scraggly gray beard wearing tattered canvas and leather visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the central action involve a transaction where a green fiberglass circuit board is exchanged for a dirty plastic bottle of clear water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style desaturated with an earthy palette of rusty orange, dusty brown, and metallic gray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04868486896157265 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.04868483543396 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04868486896157265, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04868486896157265, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.41590404510498047, + 0.063848577439785, + 0.0653257817029953, + 0.07208098471164703, + 0.08593443781137466, + 0.048300307244062424, + 0.0490618571639061, + 0.06688407808542252, + 0.024831455200910568, + 0.10782842338085175 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04868486896157265 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at eye-level and drifting slowly across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a post-apocalyptic market with rusted corrugated metal shelters and bullet holes in the roof?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a gaunt scavenger with a scraggly gray beard wearing tattered canvas and leather visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the central action involve a transaction where a green fiberglass circuit board is exchanged for a dirty plastic bottle of clear water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style desaturated with an earthy palette of rusty orange, dusty brown, and metallic gray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023283764719963074 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732837200164795 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023283764719963074, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023283764719963074, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1604660600423813, + 0.10347358882427216, + 0.1889236569404602, + 0.08008933812379837, + 0.2314683347940445, + 0.03722402825951576, + 0.03124813549220562, + 0.07198213040828705, + 0.051292937248945236, + 0.043831825256347656 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023283764719963074 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at eye-level and drifting slowly across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a post-apocalyptic market with rusted corrugated metal shelters and bullet holes in the roof?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a gaunt scavenger with a scraggly gray beard wearing tattered canvas and leather visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the central action involve a transaction where a green fiberglass circuit board is exchanged for a dirty plastic bottle of clear water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style desaturated with an earthy palette of rusty orange, dusty brown, and metallic gray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026351187378168106 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513512134552 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026351187378168106, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026351187378168106, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2113715410232544, + 0.08141594380140305, + 0.06232227757573128, + 0.05251358449459076, + 0.10587135702371597, + 0.11781743913888931, + 0.06753604114055634, + 0.10981724411249161, + 0.1316285878419876, + 0.0597059391438961 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026351187378168106 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at eye-level and drifting slowly across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a post-apocalyptic market with rusted corrugated metal shelters and bullet holes in the roof?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a gaunt scavenger with a scraggly gray beard wearing tattered canvas and leather visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the central action involve a transaction where a green fiberglass circuit board is exchanged for a dirty plastic bottle of clear water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style desaturated with an earthy palette of rusty orange, dusty brown, and metallic gray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005250118672847748 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255249977111816 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005250118672847748, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005250118672847748, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.32428622245788574, + 0.07903120666742325, + 0.053515080362558365, + 0.043371912091970444, + 0.09810241311788559, + 0.0613744780421257, + 0.07690442353487015, + 0.06956346333026886, + 0.053897663950920105, + 0.13995327055454254 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005250118672847748 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow, eye-level camera drifts across a sprawling post-apocalyptic market, huddled beneath a patchwork canopy of rusted corrugated metal shelters. Sharp, bright sunlight pierces a series of bullet holes in the roof, piercing the dim, shadowy space and illuminating the thick, swirling dust. The camera's steady movement focuses on a central exchange, where a gaunt, weathered scavenger with a scraggly gray beard, dressed in a tattered ensemble of canvas and leather, carefully pulls out a green fiberglass circuit board, its intricate silver paths gleaming. Opposite him, a young scavenger, his eyes wary, his face smeared with grime, clutches a dirty plastic bottle of clear water in his hands, his posture tense. The transaction proceeds with a slow, deliberate gravity; hands hover, inspecting the goods, and then the circuit board is eventually exchanged for the bottle in a silent, desperate exchange. In the background, other figures shuttle between stalls filled with recycled solar panels and the faded, torn remnants of faded banners. At the edge of the makeshift settlement, a massive wind turbine cobbled together from scrap metal churns with a rhythmic clatter, stirring up dust on the ground and underscoring the scene’s pervasive atmosphere of quiet despair, all rendered in a desaturated, earthy palette of rusty orange, dusty brown, and metallic gray.", + "seed": 13383, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_7/index_3930_seed_13383_dp_15_rank_30_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.049132464174181226, + "vlm_logprob": -0.049132464174181226, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.5, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.049132464174181226, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at eye-level and drifting slowly across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a post-apocalyptic market with rusted corrugated metal shelters and bullet holes in the roof?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a gaunt scavenger with a scraggly gray beard wearing tattered canvas and leather visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the central action involve a transaction where a green fiberglass circuit board is exchanged for a dirty plastic bottle of clear water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style desaturated with an earthy palette of rusty orange, dusty brown, and metallic gray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14078618586063385 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3907861709594727 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14078618586063385, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14078618586063385, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5045095086097717, + 0.17739303410053253, + 0.0786212831735611, + 0.05669713020324707, + 0.03438924625515938, + 0.01731056347489357, + 0.03580576926469803, + 0.03884519636631012, + 0.02590743824839592, + 0.030520839616656303 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14078618586063385 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at eye-level and drifting slowly across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a post-apocalyptic market with rusted corrugated metal shelters and bullet holes in the roof?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a gaunt scavenger with a scraggly gray beard wearing tattered canvas and leather visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the central action involve a transaction where a green fiberglass circuit board is exchanged for a dirty plastic bottle of clear water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style desaturated with an earthy palette of rusty orange, dusty brown, and metallic gray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03810705617070198 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.28810715675354 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03810705617070198, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03810705617070198, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.731938362121582, + 0.06852647662162781, + 0.035509929060935974, + 0.014684364199638367, + 0.011693628504872322, + 0.009208918549120426, + 0.059589654207229614, + 0.032263562083244324, + 0.011670171283185482, + 0.02491491660475731 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03810705617070198 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at eye-level and drifting slowly across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a post-apocalyptic market with rusted corrugated metal shelters and bullet holes in the roof?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a gaunt scavenger with a scraggly gray beard wearing tattered canvas and leather visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the central action involve a transaction where a green fiberglass circuit board is exchanged for a dirty plastic bottle of clear water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style desaturated with an earthy palette of rusty orange, dusty brown, and metallic gray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03368726745247841 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4086873531341553 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03368726745247841, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03368726745247841, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.32194769382476807, + 0.055504899471998215, + 0.0896032378077507, + 0.11098438501358032, + 0.13929322361946106, + 0.05373293533921242, + 0.09609020501375198, + 0.04683317989110947, + 0.02341492660343647, + 0.06259524077177048 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03368726745247841 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at eye-level and drifting slowly across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a post-apocalyptic market with rusted corrugated metal shelters and bullet holes in the roof?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a gaunt scavenger with a scraggly gray beard wearing tattered canvas and leather visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the central action involve a transaction where a green fiberglass circuit board is exchanged for a dirty plastic bottle of clear water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style desaturated with an earthy palette of rusty orange, dusty brown, and metallic gray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026351187378168106 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513512134552 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026351187378168106, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026351187378168106, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5081965923309326, + 0.05674843117594719, + 0.05725717544555664, + 0.05951337888836861, + 0.06101350113749504, + 0.04696880280971527, + 0.06795009970664978, + 0.043541327118873596, + 0.054560303688049316, + 0.0442504920065403 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026351187378168106 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at eye-level and drifting slowly across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a post-apocalyptic market with rusted corrugated metal shelters and bullet holes in the roof?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a gaunt scavenger with a scraggly gray beard wearing tattered canvas and leather visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the central action involve a transaction where a green fiberglass circuit board is exchanged for a dirty plastic bottle of clear water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style desaturated with an earthy palette of rusty orange, dusty brown, and metallic gray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006730624008923769 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006730556488037 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006730624008923769, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006730624008923769, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.6762641668319702, + 0.15236859023571014, + 0.018796877935528755, + 0.020752834156155586, + 0.01632414199411869, + 0.009946332313120365, + 0.062986359000206, + 0.020770004019141197, + 0.009576383046805859, + 0.01221432164311409 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006730624008923769 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_8/index_tensor([5748, 5748])_group_8_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_8/index_tensor([5748, 5748])_group_8_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..b6146dc156f1a8eca61d16318463759cf29134a1 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_8/index_tensor([5748, 5748])_group_8_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "long shot, shot from a slightly overhead angle, slowly and steadily pans left, sweeping across a vast, tall factory floor. In the dim afternoon light, massive, dark gray metal stamping machines punch thick steel plates into shape with a heavy, powerful rhythm, each impact causing the ground to vibrate slightly. Immediately below, a long, black rubber conveyor belt, carrying freshly formed metal parts, slowly glides under rows of cool, white industrial fluorescent lights overhead, its surface reflecting a cold, monotonous luster. The camera shifts to reveal a robotic welding arm fusing steel plates together with precise speed. A burst of dazzling orange-yellow sparks briefly illuminates the surrounding shadows, creating a stark contrast to the overall cool tones of the factory floor. Between these automated machines, several workers in dark blue overalls, yellow hard hats, and heavy, steel-toed safety boots move methodically along the smooth, shimmering concrete aisles, their expressions focused. The entire scene is filled with the roar and rhythm of machinery, creating an atmosphere of focused, efficient and powerful industrial production.", + "seed": 21476, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_8/index_5748_seed_21476_dp_16_rank_32_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.0334782775491476, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0334782775491476, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.575, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0334782775491476, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a long shot from a slightly overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily pan left across the factory floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are massive dark gray metal stamping machines punching thick steel plates with a heavy rhythm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a long black rubber conveyor belt carrying metal parts under rows of white industrial fluorescent lights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are workers in dark blue overalls, yellow hard hats, and steel-toed boots moving methodically between the machines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026440123096108437 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.776440143585205 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026440123096108437, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026440123096108437, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20051994919776917, + 0.10993897169828415, + 0.06485231220722198, + 0.1211690753698349, + 0.09000079333782196, + 0.054481636732816696, + 0.08485075831413269, + 0.0742340087890625, + 0.11272095888853073, + 0.08723151683807373 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026440123096108437 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a long shot from a slightly overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily pan left across the factory floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are massive dark gray metal stamping machines punching thick steel plates with a heavy rhythm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a long black rubber conveyor belt carrying metal parts under rows of white industrial fluorescent lights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are workers in dark blue overalls, yellow hard hats, and steel-toed boots moving methodically between the machines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.062047723680734634 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120477199554443 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.062047723680734634, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.062047723680734634, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11285844445228577, + 0.11195625364780426, + 0.2617143392562866, + 0.17879080772399902, + 0.05668671056628227, + 0.03795945271849632, + 0.028294719755649567, + 0.09281637519598007, + 0.03370599448680878, + 0.0852169319987297 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.062047723680734634 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a long shot from a slightly overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily pan left across the factory floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are massive dark gray metal stamping machines punching thick steel plates with a heavy rhythm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a long black rubber conveyor belt carrying metal parts under rows of white industrial fluorescent lights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are workers in dark blue overalls, yellow hard hats, and steel-toed boots moving methodically between the machines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01606954075396061 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141069412231445 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01606954075396061, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01606954075396061, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15167753398418427, + 0.09833314269781113, + 0.15927904844284058, + 0.18404588103294373, + 0.06655801832675934, + 0.03733953833580017, + 0.05267496779561043, + 0.09468686580657959, + 0.09260400384664536, + 0.06280099600553513 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01606954075396061 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a long shot from a slightly overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily pan left across the factory floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are massive dark gray metal stamping machines punching thick steel plates with a heavy rhythm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a long black rubber conveyor belt carrying metal parts under rows of white industrial fluorescent lights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are workers in dark blue overalls, yellow hard hats, and steel-toed boots moving methodically between the machines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014193302020430565 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264193534851074 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014193302020430565, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014193302020430565, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09099812060594559, + 0.04915571212768555, + 0.28050798177719116, + 0.08433844149112701, + 0.10914141684770584, + 0.0780520886182785, + 0.07363838702440262, + 0.058444734662771225, + 0.12045073509216309, + 0.055272363126277924 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014193302020430565 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a long shot from a slightly overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily pan left across the factory floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are massive dark gray metal stamping machines punching thick steel plates with a heavy rhythm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a long black rubber conveyor belt carrying metal parts under rows of white industrial fluorescent lights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are workers in dark blue overalls, yellow hard hats, and steel-toed boots moving methodically between the machines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.048640698194503784 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048640727996826 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.048640698194503784, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.048640698194503784, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12167873233556747, + 0.06187110021710396, + 0.11078434437513351, + 0.13499315083026886, + 0.14872290194034576, + 0.02547163888812065, + 0.22853395342826843, + 0.06352236866950989, + 0.03147125244140625, + 0.0729505643248558 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.048640698194503784 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "long shot, shot from a slightly overhead angle, slowly and steadily pans left, sweeping across a vast, tall factory floor. In the dim afternoon light, massive, dark gray metal stamping machines punch thick steel plates into shape with a heavy, powerful rhythm, each impact causing the ground to vibrate slightly. Immediately below, a long, black rubber conveyor belt, carrying freshly formed metal parts, slowly glides under rows of cool, white industrial fluorescent lights overhead, its surface reflecting a cold, monotonous luster. The camera shifts to reveal a robotic welding arm fusing steel plates together with precise speed. A burst of dazzling orange-yellow sparks briefly illuminates the surrounding shadows, creating a stark contrast to the overall cool tones of the factory floor. Between these automated machines, several workers in dark blue overalls, yellow hard hats, and heavy, steel-toed safety boots move methodically along the smooth, shimmering concrete aisles, their expressions focused. The entire scene is filled with the roar and rhythm of machinery, creating an atmosphere of focused, efficient and powerful industrial production.", + "seed": 21477, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_8/index_5748_seed_21477_dp_16_rank_32_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.045349230989813805, + "vlm_logprob": -0.045349230989813805, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.4, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.045349230989813805, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a long shot from a slightly overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily pan left across the factory floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are massive dark gray metal stamping machines punching thick steel plates with a heavy rhythm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a long black rubber conveyor belt carrying metal parts under rows of white industrial fluorescent lights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are workers in dark blue overalls, yellow hard hats, and steel-toed boots moving methodically between the machines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.025731787085533142 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7757318019866943 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.025731787085533142, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.025731787085533142, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20066532492637634, + 0.10460396111011505, + 0.09910786151885986, + 0.07765213400125504, + 0.11966582387685776, + 0.1385585516691208, + 0.06978379189968109, + 0.09286021441221237, + 0.024337364360690117, + 0.07276492565870285 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.025731787085533142 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a long shot from a slightly overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily pan left across the factory floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are massive dark gray metal stamping machines punching thick steel plates with a heavy rhythm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a long black rubber conveyor belt carrying metal parts under rows of white industrial fluorescent lights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are workers in dark blue overalls, yellow hard hats, and steel-toed boots moving methodically between the machines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07001148164272308 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950113773345947 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07001148164272308, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07001148164272308, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20665882527828217, + 0.08793243020772934, + 0.045356400310993195, + 0.06127375736832619, + 0.08334293961524963, + 0.1830439418554306, + 0.08641301095485687, + 0.11796838045120239, + 0.05026189237833023, + 0.07774833589792252 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07001148164272308 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a long shot from a slightly overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily pan left across the factory floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are massive dark gray metal stamping machines punching thick steel plates with a heavy rhythm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a long black rubber conveyor belt carrying metal parts under rows of white industrial fluorescent lights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are workers in dark blue overalls, yellow hard hats, and steel-toed boots moving methodically between the machines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01817922666668892 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018179416656494 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01817922666668892, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01817922666668892, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23189428448677063, + 0.1048194020986557, + 0.08506030589342117, + 0.06793913245201111, + 0.14012481272220612, + 0.07298023253679276, + 0.0757037028670311, + 0.15818935632705688, + 0.02408936247229576, + 0.039199348539114 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01817922666668892 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a long shot from a slightly overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily pan left across the factory floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are massive dark gray metal stamping machines punching thick steel plates with a heavy rhythm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a long black rubber conveyor belt carrying metal parts under rows of white industrial fluorescent lights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are workers in dark blue overalls, yellow hard hats, and steel-toed boots moving methodically between the machines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012533823028206825 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387533664703369 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012533823028206825, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012533823028206825, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17206166684627533, + 0.08477862179279327, + 0.047060031443834305, + 0.07766521722078323, + 0.07985062152147293, + 0.07142442464828491, + 0.0756370797753334, + 0.1881456971168518, + 0.03891506791114807, + 0.16446156799793243 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012533823028206825 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a long shot from a slightly overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily pan left across the factory floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are massive dark gray metal stamping machines punching thick steel plates with a heavy rhythm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a long black rubber conveyor belt carrying metal parts under rows of white industrial fluorescent lights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are workers in dark blue overalls, yellow hard hats, and steel-toed boots moving methodically between the machines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10028983652591705 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.350289821624756 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10028983652591705, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10028983652591705, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09538412094116211, + 0.07803133875131607, + 0.023995518684387207, + 0.032834336161613464, + 0.18426552414894104, + 0.06223541870713234, + 0.14269320666790009, + 0.33312004804611206, + 0.014504874125123024, + 0.03293563798069954 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10028983652591705 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "long shot, shot from a slightly overhead angle, slowly and steadily pans left, sweeping across a vast, tall factory floor. In the dim afternoon light, massive, dark gray metal stamping machines punch thick steel plates into shape with a heavy, powerful rhythm, each impact causing the ground to vibrate slightly. Immediately below, a long, black rubber conveyor belt, carrying freshly formed metal parts, slowly glides under rows of cool, white industrial fluorescent lights overhead, its surface reflecting a cold, monotonous luster. The camera shifts to reveal a robotic welding arm fusing steel plates together with precise speed. A burst of dazzling orange-yellow sparks briefly illuminates the surrounding shadows, creating a stark contrast to the overall cool tones of the factory floor. Between these automated machines, several workers in dark blue overalls, yellow hard hats, and heavy, steel-toed safety boots move methodically along the smooth, shimmering concrete aisles, their expressions focused. The entire scene is filled with the roar and rhythm of machinery, creating an atmosphere of focused, efficient and powerful industrial production.", + "seed": 21478, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_8/index_5748_seed_21478_dp_17_rank_34_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.04291736390441656, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04291736390441656, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.55, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04291736390441656, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a long shot from a slightly overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily pan left across the factory floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are massive dark gray metal stamping machines punching thick steel plates with a heavy rhythm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a long black rubber conveyor belt carrying metal parts under rows of white industrial fluorescent lights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are workers in dark blue overalls, yellow hard hats, and steel-toed boots moving methodically between the machines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020657043904066086 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.020657062530518 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020657043904066086, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020657043904066086, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10780340433120728, + 0.09503563493490219, + 0.06525721400976181, + 0.04644075036048889, + 0.24156454205513, + 0.16383039951324463, + 0.08492599427700043, + 0.06631609052419662, + 0.06725876033306122, + 0.06156722456216812 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020657043904066086 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a long shot from a slightly overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily pan left across the factory floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are massive dark gray metal stamping machines punching thick steel plates with a heavy rhythm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a long black rubber conveyor belt carrying metal parts under rows of white industrial fluorescent lights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are workers in dark blue overalls, yellow hard hats, and steel-toed boots moving methodically between the machines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07002004235982895 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950199604034424 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07002004235982895, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07002004235982895, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11523624509572983, + 0.055428214371204376, + 0.053472746163606644, + 0.0742780864238739, + 0.08828514069318771, + 0.16958092153072357, + 0.07317887246608734, + 0.1433674544095993, + 0.16696514189243317, + 0.06020718067884445 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07002004235982895 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a long shot from a slightly overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily pan left across the factory floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are massive dark gray metal stamping machines punching thick steel plates with a heavy rhythm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a long black rubber conveyor belt carrying metal parts under rows of white industrial fluorescent lights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are workers in dark blue overalls, yellow hard hats, and steel-toed boots moving methodically between the machines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012537237256765366 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387537002563477 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012537237256765366, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012537237256765366, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06891027092933655, + 0.047270115464925766, + 0.05738672614097595, + 0.03842189162969589, + 0.17467424273490906, + 0.09936945885419846, + 0.08578867465257645, + 0.09367059916257858, + 0.26541218161582947, + 0.06909587234258652 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012537237256765366 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a long shot from a slightly overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily pan left across the factory floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are massive dark gray metal stamping machines punching thick steel plates with a heavy rhythm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a long black rubber conveyor belt carrying metal parts under rows of white industrial fluorescent lights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are workers in dark blue overalls, yellow hard hats, and steel-toed boots moving methodically between the machines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011071558110415936 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511071681976318 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011071558110415936, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011071558110415936, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06625762581825256, + 0.03914323449134827, + 0.055892691016197205, + 0.020321907475590706, + 0.36066073179244995, + 0.035768087953329086, + 0.04647688940167427, + 0.16773223876953125, + 0.16750533878803253, + 0.04024124518036842 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011071558110415936 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a long shot from a slightly overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily pan left across the factory floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are massive dark gray metal stamping machines punching thick steel plates with a heavy rhythm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a long black rubber conveyor belt carrying metal parts under rows of white industrial fluorescent lights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are workers in dark blue overalls, yellow hard hats, and steel-toed boots moving methodically between the machines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10030093789100647 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3503010272979736 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10030093789100647, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10030093789100647, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08234098553657532, + 0.029825344681739807, + 0.03716142475605011, + 0.02653239667415619, + 0.20399029552936554, + 0.16085675358772278, + 0.07867032289505005, + 0.0888456329703331, + 0.2425413280725479, + 0.04923548549413681 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10030093789100647 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "long shot, shot from a slightly overhead angle, slowly and steadily pans left, sweeping across a vast, tall factory floor. In the dim afternoon light, massive, dark gray metal stamping machines punch thick steel plates into shape with a heavy, powerful rhythm, each impact causing the ground to vibrate slightly. Immediately below, a long, black rubber conveyor belt, carrying freshly formed metal parts, slowly glides under rows of cool, white industrial fluorescent lights overhead, its surface reflecting a cold, monotonous luster. The camera shifts to reveal a robotic welding arm fusing steel plates together with precise speed. A burst of dazzling orange-yellow sparks briefly illuminates the surrounding shadows, creating a stark contrast to the overall cool tones of the factory floor. Between these automated machines, several workers in dark blue overalls, yellow hard hats, and heavy, steel-toed safety boots move methodically along the smooth, shimmering concrete aisles, their expressions focused. The entire scene is filled with the roar and rhythm of machinery, creating an atmosphere of focused, efficient and powerful industrial production.", + "seed": 21479, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_8/index_5748_seed_21479_dp_17_rank_34_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.03213803181424737, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03213803181424737, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.825, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03213803181424737, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a long shot from a slightly overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily pan left across the factory floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are massive dark gray metal stamping machines punching thick steel plates with a heavy rhythm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a long black rubber conveyor belt carrying metal parts under rows of white industrial fluorescent lights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are workers in dark blue overalls, yellow hard hats, and steel-toed boots moving methodically between the machines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01853608526289463 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.14353609085083 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01853608526289463, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01853608526289463, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13709291815757751, + 0.19804947078227997, + 0.1868010014295578, + 0.0980391725897789, + 0.04136098548769951, + 0.12778766453266144, + 0.03887704014778137, + 0.05056734010577202, + 0.0658184066414833, + 0.05560601130127907 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01853608526289463 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a long shot from a slightly overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily pan left across the factory floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are massive dark gray metal stamping machines punching thick steel plates with a heavy rhythm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a long black rubber conveyor belt carrying metal parts under rows of white industrial fluorescent lights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are workers in dark blue overalls, yellow hard hats, and steel-toed boots moving methodically between the machines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07897358387708664 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5789735317230225 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07897358387708664, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07897358387708664, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15996499359607697, + 0.13032710552215576, + 0.054948363453149796, + 0.10326576977968216, + 0.12424573302268982, + 0.26550641655921936, + 0.019800908863544464, + 0.04646884649991989, + 0.03587094321846962, + 0.05960102006793022 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07897358387708664 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a long shot from a slightly overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily pan left across the factory floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are massive dark gray metal stamping machines punching thick steel plates with a heavy rhythm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a long black rubber conveyor belt carrying metal parts under rows of white industrial fluorescent lights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are workers in dark blue overalls, yellow hard hats, and steel-toed boots moving methodically between the machines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00594549672678113 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130945682525635 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00594549672678113, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00594549672678113, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22085779905319214, + 0.14841267466545105, + 0.060331303626298904, + 0.0889267772436142, + 0.06258337944746017, + 0.07616700232028961, + 0.0900115892291069, + 0.1428850144147873, + 0.0582241415977478, + 0.05160033330321312 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00594549672678113 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a long shot from a slightly overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily pan left across the factory floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are massive dark gray metal stamping machines punching thick steel plates with a heavy rhythm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a long black rubber conveyor belt carrying metal parts under rows of white industrial fluorescent lights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are workers in dark blue overalls, yellow hard hats, and steel-toed boots moving methodically between the machines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014188835397362709 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264188766479492 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014188835397362709, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014188835397362709, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23998025059700012, + 0.12234466522932053, + 0.06545118987560272, + 0.10507605224847794, + 0.09724269062280655, + 0.07315469533205032, + 0.06933476030826569, + 0.05116984248161316, + 0.10663579404354095, + 0.06961002945899963 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014188835397362709 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a long shot from a slightly overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily pan left across the factory floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are massive dark gray metal stamping machines punching thick steel plates with a heavy rhythm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a long black rubber conveyor belt carrying metal parts under rows of white industrial fluorescent lights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are workers in dark blue overalls, yellow hard hats, and steel-toed boots moving methodically between the machines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04304615780711174 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168046236038208 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04304615780711174, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04304615780711174, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3508765697479248, + 0.15133129060268402, + 0.09947478026151657, + 0.08855088800191879, + 0.04456234723329544, + 0.030916322022676468, + 0.05069538950920105, + 0.049095384776592255, + 0.06366775184869766, + 0.07082927227020264 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04304615780711174 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_9/index_tensor([9923, 9923])_group_9_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_9/index_tensor([9923, 9923])_group_9_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..d71ea11b43c90cfa36bb4e8cfa4d2de4c3fc21c1 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_9/index_tensor([9923, 9923])_group_9_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "static, eye-level shot peers through the diamond pattern of a teal mesh fence, which remains slightly blurred in the foreground, creating a voyeuristic perspective. The camera's focus is fixed on a woman with thick, dark, curly hair, partly tucked into a vibrant red knitted beanie. She sits on the left side of the frame, wearing a heavy, dark blue wool coat, standing outside the white-painted, paneled front door of a house. To her left, the house's beige stucco wall stretches into the background, punctuated by a window with a clean white frame that softly reflects the overcast sky. At first, her expression remains one of cautious observation, glancing around and turning her head deliberately. Then, she begins steadily walking toward the camera, her body moving from the center, closer to the foreground mesh. As she walks, her gaze shifts rapidly to the right and then to the left, as if searching for someone or ensuring she's not being watched. Her pace gradually slows until she halts hesitantly, her proximity to the camera and obstructed view creating a tense and intimate atmosphere of quiet suspense in the soft, unfocused daylight.", + "seed": 8142, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_9/index_9923_seed_8142_dp_18_rank_36_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.26272027189843355, + "vlm_logprob": -0.26272027189843355, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.075, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.26272027189843355, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static, eye-level view looking through a teal mesh fence in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a woman with thick, dark, curly hair wearing a vibrant red knitted beanie visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a heavy, dark blue wool coat and standing near a white-painted paneled front door?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the woman walk steadily toward the camera, slowing down until she halts hesitantly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman shift her gaze rapidly to the right and then to the left while moving?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01729736290872097 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.767297267913818 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01729736290872097, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01729736290872097, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07466436177492142, + 0.12174694985151291, + 0.030455946922302246, + 0.11791329830884933, + 0.2178545743227005, + 0.23202919960021973, + 0.03283647820353508, + 0.10254231840372086, + 0.0470082052052021, + 0.022948643192648888 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01729736290872097 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static, eye-level view looking through a teal mesh fence in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a woman with thick, dark, curly hair wearing a vibrant red knitted beanie visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a heavy, dark blue wool coat and standing near a white-painted paneled front door?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the woman walk steadily toward the camera, slowing down until she halts hesitantly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman shift her gaze rapidly to the right and then to the left while moving?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0025100174825638533 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002510070800781 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0025100174825638533, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0025100174825638533, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.061526261270046234, + 0.01946447230875492, + 0.01910371333360672, + 0.01964673586189747, + 0.7211366295814514, + 0.08738739788532257, + 0.018823184072971344, + 0.023579807952046394, + 0.019717885181307793, + 0.0096139470115304 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0025100174825638533 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static, eye-level view looking through a teal mesh fence in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a woman with thick, dark, curly hair wearing a vibrant red knitted beanie visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a heavy, dark blue wool coat and standing near a white-painted paneled front door?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the woman walk steadily toward the camera, slowing down until she halts hesitantly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman shift her gaze rapidly to the right and then to the left while moving?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012569728307425976 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387569904327393 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012569728307425976, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012569728307425976, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13730669021606445, + 0.037469275295734406, + 0.06474103778600693, + 0.13209319114685059, + 0.412802129983902, + 0.11292444914579391, + 0.026646526530385017, + 0.0432419590651989, + 0.019778447225689888, + 0.012996342033147812 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012569728307425976 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static, eye-level view looking through a teal mesh fence in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a woman with thick, dark, curly hair wearing a vibrant red knitted beanie visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a heavy, dark blue wool coat and standing near a white-painted paneled front door?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the woman walk steadily toward the camera, slowing down until she halts hesitantly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman shift her gaze rapidly to the right and then to the left while moving?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5233418345451355 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8983418345451355 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5233418345451355, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5233418345451355, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0403047576546669, + 0.020933711901307106, + 0.038735534995794296, + 0.03763105720281601, + 0.6057106852531433, + 0.10852101445198059, + 0.04343794658780098, + 0.04784349724650383, + 0.04644731804728508, + 0.010434489697217941 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5233418345451355 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static, eye-level view looking through a teal mesh fence in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a woman with thick, dark, curly hair wearing a vibrant red knitted beanie visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a heavy, dark blue wool coat and standing near a white-painted paneled front door?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the woman walk steadily toward the camera, slowing down until she halts hesitantly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman shift her gaze rapidly to the right and then to the left while moving?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7578824162483215 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6328824162483215 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.7578824162483215, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.7578824162483215, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06365399807691574, + 0.052679359912872314, + 0.05276507884263992, + 0.0626576691865921, + 0.4161636233329773, + 0.05950632691383362, + 0.044167496263980865, + 0.0873575359582901, + 0.1298583745956421, + 0.03119049407541752 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.7578824162483215 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, eye-level shot peers through the diamond pattern of a teal mesh fence, which remains slightly blurred in the foreground, creating a voyeuristic perspective. The camera's focus is fixed on a woman with thick, dark, curly hair, partly tucked into a vibrant red knitted beanie. She sits on the left side of the frame, wearing a heavy, dark blue wool coat, standing outside the white-painted, paneled front door of a house. To her left, the house's beige stucco wall stretches into the background, punctuated by a window with a clean white frame that softly reflects the overcast sky. At first, her expression remains one of cautious observation, glancing around and turning her head deliberately. Then, she begins steadily walking toward the camera, her body moving from the center, closer to the foreground mesh. As she walks, her gaze shifts rapidly to the right and then to the left, as if searching for someone or ensuring she's not being watched. Her pace gradually slows until she halts hesitantly, her proximity to the camera and obstructed view creating a tense and intimate atmosphere of quiet suspense in the soft, unfocused daylight.", + "seed": 8143, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_9/index_9923_seed_8143_dp_18_rank_36_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.19987107873894275, + "vlm_logprob": -0.19987107873894275, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.1, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.19987107873894275, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static, eye-level view looking through a teal mesh fence in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a woman with thick, dark, curly hair wearing a vibrant red knitted beanie visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a heavy, dark blue wool coat and standing near a white-painted paneled front door?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the woman walk steadily toward the camera, slowing down until she halts hesitantly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman shift her gaze rapidly to the right and then to the left while moving?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02018575742840767 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.395185947418213 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02018575742840767, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02018575742840767, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1272965967655182, + 0.2931772768497467, + 0.029277049005031586, + 0.10051228106021881, + 0.07446227222681046, + 0.0393691286444664, + 0.1530562788248062, + 0.10045085847377777, + 0.0388585664331913, + 0.043539758771657944 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02018575742840767 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static, eye-level view looking through a teal mesh fence in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a woman with thick, dark, curly hair wearing a vibrant red knitted beanie visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a heavy, dark blue wool coat and standing near a white-painted paneled front door?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the woman walk steadily toward the camera, slowing down until she halts hesitantly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman shift her gaze rapidly to the right and then to the left while moving?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00363558460958302 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628635406494141 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00363558460958302, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00363558460958302, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.27248701453208923, + 0.17560505867004395, + 0.06227017939090729, + 0.026635345071554184, + 0.06367228925228119, + 0.049043335020542145, + 0.08006123453378677, + 0.09473784267902374, + 0.02958519198000431, + 0.14590246975421906 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00363558460958302 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static, eye-level view looking through a teal mesh fence in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a woman with thick, dark, curly hair wearing a vibrant red knitted beanie visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a heavy, dark blue wool coat and standing near a white-painted paneled front door?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the woman walk steadily toward the camera, slowing down until she halts hesitantly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman shift her gaze rapidly to the right and then to the left while moving?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016094058752059937 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141094207763672 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016094058752059937, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016094058752059937, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14577852189540863, + 0.3528219163417816, + 0.0514744371175766, + 0.036985110491514206, + 0.06788600236177444, + 0.06502825766801834, + 0.07612630724906921, + 0.08305177837610245, + 0.02583908848464489, + 0.09500862658023834 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016094058752059937 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static, eye-level view looking through a teal mesh fence in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a woman with thick, dark, curly hair wearing a vibrant red knitted beanie visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a heavy, dark blue wool coat and standing near a white-painted paneled front door?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the woman walk steadily toward the camera, slowing down until she halts hesitantly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman shift her gaze rapidly to the right and then to the left while moving?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20156234502792358 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7015624046325684 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20156234502792358, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20156234502792358, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10471239686012268, + 0.07410389184951782, + 0.24345865845680237, + 0.13387741148471832, + 0.08479204028844833, + 0.05431682616472244, + 0.05040138214826584, + 0.13037782907485962, + 0.03667744994163513, + 0.08728208392858505 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20156234502792358 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static, eye-level view looking through a teal mesh fence in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a woman with thick, dark, curly hair wearing a vibrant red knitted beanie visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a heavy, dark blue wool coat and standing near a white-painted paneled front door?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the woman walk steadily toward the camera, slowing down until she halts hesitantly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman shift her gaze rapidly to the right and then to the left while moving?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7578776478767395 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6328776478767395 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.7578776478767395, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.7578776478767395, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17757974565029144, + 0.15778717398643494, + 0.06281689554452896, + 0.03790842369198799, + 0.03206278011202812, + 0.05719439685344696, + 0.07675231993198395, + 0.15201936662197113, + 0.03709990903735161, + 0.2087789624929428 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.7578776478767395 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, eye-level shot peers through the diamond pattern of a teal mesh fence, which remains slightly blurred in the foreground, creating a voyeuristic perspective. The camera's focus is fixed on a woman with thick, dark, curly hair, partly tucked into a vibrant red knitted beanie. She sits on the left side of the frame, wearing a heavy, dark blue wool coat, standing outside the white-painted, paneled front door of a house. To her left, the house's beige stucco wall stretches into the background, punctuated by a window with a clean white frame that softly reflects the overcast sky. At first, her expression remains one of cautious observation, glancing around and turning her head deliberately. Then, she begins steadily walking toward the camera, her body moving from the center, closer to the foreground mesh. As she walks, her gaze shifts rapidly to the right and then to the left, as if searching for someone or ensuring she's not being watched. Her pace gradually slows until she halts hesitantly, her proximity to the camera and obstructed view creating a tense and intimate atmosphere of quiet suspense in the soft, unfocused daylight.", + "seed": 8144, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_9/index_9923_seed_8144_dp_19_rank_38_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.2250425260979682, + "vlm_logprob": -0.2250425260979682, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.35, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.2250425260979682, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static, eye-level view looking through a teal mesh fence in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a woman with thick, dark, curly hair wearing a vibrant red knitted beanie visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a heavy, dark blue wool coat and standing near a white-painted paneled front door?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the woman walk steadily toward the camera, slowing down until she halts hesitantly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman shift her gaze rapidly to the right and then to the left while moving?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.015291127376258373 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.890291213989258 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.015291127376258373, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.015291127376258373, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11580856889486313, + 0.05917678028345108, + 0.030660158023238182, + 0.03717062994837761, + 0.047084320336580276, + 0.11854017525911331, + 0.12061472982168198, + 0.10756438970565796, + 0.16155657172203064, + 0.20182360708713531 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.015291127376258373 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static, eye-level view looking through a teal mesh fence in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a woman with thick, dark, curly hair wearing a vibrant red knitted beanie visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a heavy, dark blue wool coat and standing near a white-painted paneled front door?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the woman walk steadily toward the camera, slowing down until she halts hesitantly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman shift her gaze rapidly to the right and then to the left while moving?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0032124125864356756 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.7532124519348145 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0032124125864356756, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0032124125864356756, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1280142068862915, + 0.054454293102025986, + 0.07673007249832153, + 0.03326371684670448, + 0.0395258292555809, + 0.07121592015028, + 0.3761208951473236, + 0.028768004849553108, + 0.07285644859075546, + 0.11905062943696976 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0032124125864356756 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static, eye-level view looking through a teal mesh fence in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a woman with thick, dark, curly hair wearing a vibrant red knitted beanie visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a heavy, dark blue wool coat and standing near a white-painted paneled front door?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the woman walk steadily toward the camera, slowing down until she halts hesitantly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman shift her gaze rapidly to the right and then to the left while moving?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006751937326043844 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006752014160156 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006751937326043844, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006751937326043844, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18725858628749847, + 0.03344285115599632, + 0.04810984060168266, + 0.02583087980747223, + 0.06581088155508041, + 0.08044396340847015, + 0.2525067627429962, + 0.05061750486493111, + 0.09529369324445724, + 0.16068509221076965 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006751937326043844 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static, eye-level view looking through a teal mesh fence in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a woman with thick, dark, curly hair wearing a vibrant red knitted beanie visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a heavy, dark blue wool coat and standing near a white-painted paneled front door?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the woman walk steadily toward the camera, slowing down until she halts hesitantly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman shift her gaze rapidly to the right and then to the left while moving?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20157413184642792 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7015740871429443 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20157413184642792, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20157413184642792, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0720628947019577, + 0.04287124425172806, + 0.052340056747198105, + 0.041999995708465576, + 0.08270039409399033, + 0.06702271103858948, + 0.4362604022026062, + 0.014965014532208443, + 0.019834816455841064, + 0.16994249820709229 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20157413184642792 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static, eye-level view looking through a teal mesh fence in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a woman with thick, dark, curly hair wearing a vibrant red knitted beanie visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a heavy, dark blue wool coat and standing near a white-painted paneled front door?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the woman walk steadily toward the camera, slowing down until she halts hesitantly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman shift her gaze rapidly to the right and then to the left while moving?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8983830213546753 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5233830213546753 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.8983830213546753, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.8983830213546753, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07128433138132095, + 0.05227762088179588, + 0.05033370852470398, + 0.029861848801374435, + 0.060257673263549805, + 0.07990242540836334, + 0.2801540493965149, + 0.0543079674243927, + 0.09977331757545471, + 0.2218470722436905 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.8983830213546753 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, eye-level shot peers through the diamond pattern of a teal mesh fence, which remains slightly blurred in the foreground, creating a voyeuristic perspective. The camera's focus is fixed on a woman with thick, dark, curly hair, partly tucked into a vibrant red knitted beanie. She sits on the left side of the frame, wearing a heavy, dark blue wool coat, standing outside the white-painted, paneled front door of a house. To her left, the house's beige stucco wall stretches into the background, punctuated by a window with a clean white frame that softly reflects the overcast sky. At first, her expression remains one of cautious observation, glancing around and turning her head deliberately. Then, she begins steadily walking toward the camera, her body moving from the center, closer to the foreground mesh. As she walks, her gaze shifts rapidly to the right and then to the left, as if searching for someone or ensuring she's not being watched. Her pace gradually slows until she halts hesitantly, her proximity to the camera and obstructed view creating a tense and intimate atmosphere of quiet suspense in the soft, unfocused daylight.", + "seed": 8145, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000039/group_9/index_9923_seed_8145_dp_19_rank_38_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.16655101161450148, + "vlm_logprob": -0.16655101161450148, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.825, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.16655101161450148, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static, eye-level view looking through a teal mesh fence in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a woman with thick, dark, curly hair wearing a vibrant red knitted beanie visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a heavy, dark blue wool coat and standing near a white-painted paneled front door?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the woman walk steadily toward the camera, slowing down until she halts hesitantly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman shift her gaze rapidly to the right and then to the left while moving?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02414454147219658 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.024144649505615 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02414454147219658, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02414454147219658, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04391113668680191, + 0.014783218502998352, + 0.011158342473208904, + 0.012959596700966358, + 0.15703921020030975, + 0.6475591063499451, + 0.02306380681693554, + 0.03314001113176346, + 0.035279177129268646, + 0.02110634371638298 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02414454147219658 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static, eye-level view looking through a teal mesh fence in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a woman with thick, dark, curly hair wearing a vibrant red knitted beanie visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a heavy, dark blue wool coat and standing near a white-painted paneled front door?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the woman walk steadily toward the camera, slowing down until she halts hesitantly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman shift her gaze rapidly to the right and then to the left while moving?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007647286169230938 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882647514343262 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007647286169230938, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007647286169230938, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0814376100897789, + 0.048974256962537766, + 0.022184643894433975, + 0.03329429402947426, + 0.11570040881633759, + 0.5955572724342346, + 0.02750753052532673, + 0.03323479741811752, + 0.014707614667713642, + 0.027401631698012352 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007647286169230938 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static, eye-level view looking through a teal mesh fence in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a woman with thick, dark, curly hair wearing a vibrant red knitted beanie visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a heavy, dark blue wool coat and standing near a white-painted paneled front door?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the woman walk steadily toward the camera, slowing down until she halts hesitantly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman shift her gaze rapidly to the right and then to the left while moving?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023338384926319122 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7733383178710938 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023338384926319122, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023338384926319122, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03648275136947632, + 0.013407011516392231, + 0.006022268440574408, + 0.0105839092284441, + 0.12519904971122742, + 0.7605148553848267, + 0.016522157937288284, + 0.011131842620670795, + 0.006282126531004906, + 0.013854004442691803 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023338384926319122 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static, eye-level view looking through a teal mesh fence in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a woman with thick, dark, curly hair wearing a vibrant red knitted beanie visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a heavy, dark blue wool coat and standing near a white-painted paneled front door?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the woman walk steadily toward the camera, slowing down until she halts hesitantly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman shift her gaze rapidly to the right and then to the left while moving?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.34863436222076416 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2236343622207642 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.34863436222076416, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.34863436222076416, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0476435124874115, + 0.024195246398448944, + 0.02164434641599655, + 0.038902655243873596, + 0.3802427053451538, + 0.33517926931381226, + 0.055001482367515564, + 0.030915332958102226, + 0.026180002838373184, + 0.04009554535150528 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.34863436222076416 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static, eye-level view looking through a teal mesh fence in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a woman with thick, dark, curly hair wearing a vibrant red knitted beanie visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a heavy, dark blue wool coat and standing near a white-painted paneled front door?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the woman walk steadily toward the camera, slowing down until she halts hesitantly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman shift her gaze rapidly to the right and then to the left while moving?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4289904832839966 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.0539904832839966 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.4289904832839966, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.4289904832839966, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.058232031762599945, + 0.020935513079166412, + 0.01822485588490963, + 0.044221196323633194, + 0.498237669467926, + 0.25738686323165894, + 0.04375065863132477, + 0.016872556880116463, + 0.029035354033112526, + 0.013103227131068707 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.4289904832839966 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_0/index_tensor([7316, 7316])_group_0_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_0/index_tensor([7316, 7316])_group_0_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..82956aef3d8c97607dd5bbb02b0f9d7a9bd8b629 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_0/index_tensor([7316, 7316])_group_0_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "high-frame-rate, documentary-style shot, shot from a low, close-up perspective, follows an anthropomorphic shark chef. He sits in the center of a spacious, modern stainless steel kitchen, perched on a gleaming metal floor. The chef, with his sleek dark gray skin and white underbelly, wears a pristine double-breasted chef's jacket with sleeves rolled up to the elbows. Atop his head, a towering, crisp white chef's hat sways dramatically and rhythmically to his dynamic beats. Illuminated by the cool LED lights of the ceiling, the stainless steel reflects a sharp, clear light. He is absorbed in a masterful breakdance routine, his movements precise and powerful, transitioning seamlessly from fluid floorwork to a breathtaking one-handed spin. His massive frame displays a remarkable agility and control that belies his size. High-speed photography captures the breeze created by his every spin and the moment when beads of sweat splash from his skin, shining like diamonds under the light. The whole scene perfectly blends the rigor of cooking with the free and unrestrainedness of street dance in a surreal atmosphere of concentration.", + "seed": 27300, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_0/index_7316_seed_27300_dp_0_rank_0_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.10428461581468582, + "vlm_logprob": -0.10428461581468582, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.75, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.10428461581468582, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an anthropomorphic shark with dark gray skin and a white underbelly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shark wearing a pristine double-breasted chef's jacket with sleeves rolled up to the elbows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the shark wearing a towering, crisp white chef's hat that sways rhythmically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a spacious modern stainless steel kitchen with a gleaming metal floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shark performing a breakdance routine including floorwork and a one-handed spin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0491960272192955 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0491960048675537 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0491960272192955, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0491960272192955, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2221217155456543, + 0.08706129342317581, + 0.05954600125551224, + 0.03691734001040459, + 0.021283216774463654, + 0.02510829083621502, + 0.08205529302358627, + 0.32794252038002014, + 0.04640795290470123, + 0.09155634045600891 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0491960272192955 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an anthropomorphic shark with dark gray skin and a white underbelly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shark wearing a pristine double-breasted chef's jacket with sleeves rolled up to the elbows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the shark wearing a towering, crisp white chef's hat that sways rhythmically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a spacious modern stainless steel kitchen with a gleaming metal floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shark performing a breakdance routine including floorwork and a one-handed spin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11292798072099686 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2379279136657715 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11292798072099686, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11292798072099686, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06544061005115509, + 0.33355385065078735, + 0.08862675726413727, + 0.03846883773803711, + 0.16592982411384583, + 0.0553060881793499, + 0.1289585828781128, + 0.03525036573410034, + 0.03173576295375824, + 0.05672931298613548 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11292798072099686 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an anthropomorphic shark with dark gray skin and a white underbelly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shark wearing a pristine double-breasted chef's jacket with sleeves rolled up to the elbows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the shark wearing a towering, crisp white chef's hat that sways rhythmically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a spacious modern stainless steel kitchen with a gleaming metal floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shark performing a breakdance routine including floorwork and a one-handed spin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02980225533246994 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298023223876953 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02980225533246994, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02980225533246994, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06234075129032135, + 0.46044921875, + 0.049677297472953796, + 0.022365616634488106, + 0.026588577777147293, + 0.03665008395910263, + 0.20899009704589844, + 0.03015471249818802, + 0.022433193400502205, + 0.08035041391849518 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02980225533246994 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an anthropomorphic shark with dark gray skin and a white underbelly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shark wearing a pristine double-breasted chef's jacket with sleeves rolled up to the elbows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the shark wearing a towering, crisp white chef's hat that sways rhythmically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a spacious modern stainless steel kitchen with a gleaming metal floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shark performing a breakdance routine including floorwork and a one-handed spin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01606367528438568 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141063690185547 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01606367528438568, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01606367528438568, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09329584985971451, + 0.39760541915893555, + 0.05999681353569031, + 0.027695126831531525, + 0.07345109432935715, + 0.033299971371889114, + 0.1617468148469925, + 0.03297661244869232, + 0.03522738814353943, + 0.08470490574836731 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01606367528438568 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an anthropomorphic shark with dark gray skin and a white underbelly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shark wearing a pristine double-breasted chef's jacket with sleeves rolled up to the elbows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the shark wearing a towering, crisp white chef's hat that sways rhythmically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a spacious modern stainless steel kitchen with a gleaming metal floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shark performing a breakdance routine including floorwork and a one-handed spin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.31343314051628113 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3134331703186035 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.31343314051628113, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.31343314051628113, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11136862635612488, + 0.20840506255626678, + 0.1364581286907196, + 0.10535019636154175, + 0.03705192729830742, + 0.08919219672679901, + 0.04938856512308121, + 0.08780516684055328, + 0.05240447446703911, + 0.12257570773363113 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.31343314051628113 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "high-frame-rate, documentary-style shot, shot from a low, close-up perspective, follows an anthropomorphic shark chef. He sits in the center of a spacious, modern stainless steel kitchen, perched on a gleaming metal floor. The chef, with his sleek dark gray skin and white underbelly, wears a pristine double-breasted chef's jacket with sleeves rolled up to the elbows. Atop his head, a towering, crisp white chef's hat sways dramatically and rhythmically to his dynamic beats. Illuminated by the cool LED lights of the ceiling, the stainless steel reflects a sharp, clear light. He is absorbed in a masterful breakdance routine, his movements precise and powerful, transitioning seamlessly from fluid floorwork to a breathtaking one-handed spin. His massive frame displays a remarkable agility and control that belies his size. High-speed photography captures the breeze created by his every spin and the moment when beads of sweat splash from his skin, shining like diamonds under the light. The whole scene perfectly blends the rigor of cooking with the free and unrestrainedness of street dance in a surreal atmosphere of concentration.", + "seed": 27301, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_0/index_7316_seed_27301_dp_0_rank_0_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.26688400786370037, + "vlm_logprob": -0.26688400786370037, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.1500000238418577, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.26688400786370037, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an anthropomorphic shark with dark gray skin and a white underbelly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shark wearing a pristine double-breasted chef's jacket with sleeves rolled up to the elbows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the shark wearing a towering, crisp white chef's hat that sways rhythmically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a spacious modern stainless steel kitchen with a gleaming metal floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shark performing a breakdance routine including floorwork and a one-handed spin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2523907721042633 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.502390742301941 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2523907721042633, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2523907721042633, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.044886283576488495, + 0.06463037431240082, + 0.12567870318889618, + 0.30634960532188416, + 0.06400391459465027, + 0.07450614869594574, + 0.24246294796466827, + 0.016194231808185577, + 0.04473688453435898, + 0.016550879925489426 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 6, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2523907721042633 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an anthropomorphic shark with dark gray skin and a white underbelly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shark wearing a pristine double-breasted chef's jacket with sleeves rolled up to the elbows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the shark wearing a towering, crisp white chef's hat that sways rhythmically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a spacious modern stainless steel kitchen with a gleaming metal floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shark performing a breakdance routine including floorwork and a one-handed spin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14281430840492249 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0178143978118896 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14281430840492249, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.8750001192092896, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14281430840492249, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06590759009122849, + 0.0492338128387928, + 0.12492799013853073, + 0.05188550427556038, + 0.09971379488706589, + 0.14558273553848267, + 0.09695320576429367, + 0.038435906171798706, + 0.3033248484134674, + 0.024034615606069565 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 5, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14281430840492249 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an anthropomorphic shark with dark gray skin and a white underbelly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shark wearing a pristine double-breasted chef's jacket with sleeves rolled up to the elbows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the shark wearing a towering, crisp white chef's hat that sways rhythmically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a spacious modern stainless steel kitchen with a gleaming metal floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shark performing a breakdance routine including floorwork and a one-handed spin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011082404293119907 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511082172393799 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011082404293119907, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011082404293119907, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05019515007734299, + 0.026210719719529152, + 0.20008182525634766, + 0.23906490206718445, + 0.12750378251075745, + 0.13277538120746613, + 0.05358334258198738, + 0.03652696684002876, + 0.09510236978530884, + 0.03895556554198265 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011082404293119907 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an anthropomorphic shark with dark gray skin and a white underbelly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shark wearing a pristine double-breasted chef's jacket with sleeves rolled up to the elbows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the shark wearing a towering, crisp white chef's hat that sways rhythmically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a spacious modern stainless steel kitchen with a gleaming metal floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shark performing a breakdance routine including floorwork and a one-handed spin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029807230457663536 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298073291778564 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029807230457663536, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029807230457663536, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11239399015903473, + 0.07519372552633286, + 0.07119031995534897, + 0.32038095593452454, + 0.12209172546863556, + 0.06668014079332352, + 0.062208157032728195, + 0.055084194988012314, + 0.09015252441167831, + 0.02462422475218773 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029807230457663536 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an anthropomorphic shark with dark gray skin and a white underbelly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shark wearing a pristine double-breasted chef's jacket with sleeves rolled up to the elbows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the shark wearing a towering, crisp white chef's hat that sways rhythmically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a spacious modern stainless steel kitchen with a gleaming metal floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shark performing a breakdance routine including floorwork and a one-handed spin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8983253240585327 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5233253240585327 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.8983253240585327, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.8983253240585327, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05413428321480751, + 0.06044190376996994, + 0.1091458648443222, + 0.32956695556640625, + 0.043339163064956665, + 0.04805609583854675, + 0.1087990328669548, + 0.05600918456912041, + 0.13855178654193878, + 0.0519556999206543 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.8983253240585327 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "high-frame-rate, documentary-style shot, shot from a low, close-up perspective, follows an anthropomorphic shark chef. He sits in the center of a spacious, modern stainless steel kitchen, perched on a gleaming metal floor. The chef, with his sleek dark gray skin and white underbelly, wears a pristine double-breasted chef's jacket with sleeves rolled up to the elbows. Atop his head, a towering, crisp white chef's hat sways dramatically and rhythmically to his dynamic beats. Illuminated by the cool LED lights of the ceiling, the stainless steel reflects a sharp, clear light. He is absorbed in a masterful breakdance routine, his movements precise and powerful, transitioning seamlessly from fluid floorwork to a breathtaking one-handed spin. His massive frame displays a remarkable agility and control that belies his size. High-speed photography captures the breeze created by his every spin and the moment when beads of sweat splash from his skin, shining like diamonds under the light. The whole scene perfectly blends the rigor of cooking with the free and unrestrainedness of street dance in a surreal atmosphere of concentration.", + "seed": 27302, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_0/index_7316_seed_27302_dp_1_rank_2_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.1166737156920135, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1166737156920135, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.3, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1166737156920135, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an anthropomorphic shark with dark gray skin and a white underbelly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shark wearing a pristine double-breasted chef's jacket with sleeves rolled up to the elbows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the shark wearing a towering, crisp white chef's hat that sways rhythmically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a spacious modern stainless steel kitchen with a gleaming metal floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shark performing a breakdance routine including floorwork and a one-handed spin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.024006638675928116 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7740066051483154 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.024006638675928116, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.024006638675928116, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06136075034737587, + 0.08890361338853836, + 0.10004875808954239, + 0.08316519856452942, + 0.03963235393166542, + 0.20492342114448547, + 0.3167118430137634, + 0.038634687662124634, + 0.044193897396326065, + 0.022425424307584763 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.024006638675928116 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an anthropomorphic shark with dark gray skin and a white underbelly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shark wearing a pristine double-breasted chef's jacket with sleeves rolled up to the elbows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the shark wearing a towering, crisp white chef's hat that sways rhythmically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a spacious modern stainless steel kitchen with a gleaming metal floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shark performing a breakdance routine including floorwork and a one-handed spin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1603425145149231 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9103424549102783 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1603425145149231, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1603425145149231, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0573834590613842, + 0.09369765967130661, + 0.07142499089241028, + 0.07258683443069458, + 0.02581397444009781, + 0.10105468332767487, + 0.4741378724575043, + 0.042389824986457825, + 0.033217985183000565, + 0.02829275093972683 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1603425145149231 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an anthropomorphic shark with dark gray skin and a white underbelly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shark wearing a pristine double-breasted chef's jacket with sleeves rolled up to the elbows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the shark wearing a towering, crisp white chef's hat that sways rhythmically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a spacious modern stainless steel kitchen with a gleaming metal floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shark performing a breakdance routine including floorwork and a one-handed spin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006740333512425423 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006740570068359 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006740333512425423, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006740333512425423, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.031000960618257523, + 0.048968248069286346, + 0.03744335472583771, + 0.018173595890402794, + 0.02059711515903473, + 0.020231474190950394, + 0.7540555000305176, + 0.03200817108154297, + 0.020148945972323418, + 0.01737251877784729 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006740333512425423 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an anthropomorphic shark with dark gray skin and a white underbelly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shark wearing a pristine double-breasted chef's jacket with sleeves rolled up to the elbows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the shark wearing a towering, crisp white chef's hat that sways rhythmically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a spacious modern stainless steel kitchen with a gleaming metal floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shark performing a breakdance routine including floorwork and a one-handed spin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005248102825134993 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255248069763184 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005248102825134993, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005248102825134993, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10912981629371643, + 0.2198699712753296, + 0.06338417530059814, + 0.11268328130245209, + 0.09640784561634064, + 0.09583833813667297, + 0.037180349230766296, + 0.07714837044477463, + 0.05637333542108536, + 0.13198451697826385 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005248102825134993 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an anthropomorphic shark with dark gray skin and a white underbelly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shark wearing a pristine double-breasted chef's jacket with sleeves rolled up to the elbows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the shark wearing a towering, crisp white chef's hat that sways rhythmically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a spacious modern stainless steel kitchen with a gleaming metal floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shark performing a breakdance routine including floorwork and a one-handed spin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3870309889316559 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1370309591293335 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3870309889316559, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3870309889316559, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06523330509662628, + 0.1180068701505661, + 0.05966459587216377, + 0.0457117073237896, + 0.036930594593286514, + 0.09288645535707474, + 0.4912468194961548, + 0.03284275159239769, + 0.04127613455057144, + 0.01620076410472393 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3870309889316559 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "high-frame-rate, documentary-style shot, shot from a low, close-up perspective, follows an anthropomorphic shark chef. He sits in the center of a spacious, modern stainless steel kitchen, perched on a gleaming metal floor. The chef, with his sleek dark gray skin and white underbelly, wears a pristine double-breasted chef's jacket with sleeves rolled up to the elbows. Atop his head, a towering, crisp white chef's hat sways dramatically and rhythmically to his dynamic beats. Illuminated by the cool LED lights of the ceiling, the stainless steel reflects a sharp, clear light. He is absorbed in a masterful breakdance routine, his movements precise and powerful, transitioning seamlessly from fluid floorwork to a breathtaking one-handed spin. His massive frame displays a remarkable agility and control that belies his size. High-speed photography captures the breeze created by his every spin and the moment when beads of sweat splash from his skin, shining like diamonds under the light. The whole scene perfectly blends the rigor of cooking with the free and unrestrainedness of street dance in a surreal atmosphere of concentration.", + "seed": 27303, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_0/index_7316_seed_27303_dp_1_rank_2_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.15289900694042444, + "vlm_logprob": -0.15289900694042444, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.9, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.15289900694042444, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an anthropomorphic shark with dark gray skin and a white underbelly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shark wearing a pristine double-breasted chef's jacket with sleeves rolled up to the elbows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the shark wearing a towering, crisp white chef's hat that sways rhythmically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a spacious modern stainless steel kitchen with a gleaming metal floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shark performing a breakdance routine including floorwork and a one-handed spin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06306640803813934 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8130664825439453 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06306640803813934, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06306640803813934, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.27390018105506897, + 0.033940430730581284, + 0.14402097463607788, + 0.16392318904399872, + 0.07954447716474533, + 0.04008335992693901, + 0.10365723818540573, + 0.024764029309153557, + 0.056309089064598083, + 0.0798569768667221 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06306640803813934 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an anthropomorphic shark with dark gray skin and a white underbelly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shark wearing a pristine double-breasted chef's jacket with sleeves rolled up to the elbows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the shark wearing a towering, crisp white chef's hat that sways rhythmically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a spacious modern stainless steel kitchen with a gleaming metal floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shark performing a breakdance routine including floorwork and a one-handed spin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16034820675849915 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9103481769561768 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16034820675849915, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16034820675849915, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1849960833787918, + 0.10211603343486786, + 0.10959640890359879, + 0.08929391950368881, + 0.07077866047620773, + 0.08848483115434647, + 0.12891975045204163, + 0.09766747802495956, + 0.05470666289329529, + 0.07344017922878265 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16034820675849915 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an anthropomorphic shark with dark gray skin and a white underbelly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shark wearing a pristine double-breasted chef's jacket with sleeves rolled up to the elbows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the shark wearing a towering, crisp white chef's hat that sways rhythmically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a spacious modern stainless steel kitchen with a gleaming metal floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shark performing a breakdance routine including floorwork and a one-handed spin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005252964794635773 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255252838134766 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005252964794635773, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005252964794635773, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1513555943965912, + 0.09087071567773819, + 0.2711542844772339, + 0.0833231508731842, + 0.08952578157186508, + 0.1109657809138298, + 0.045795321464538574, + 0.04394599795341492, + 0.04616740345954895, + 0.06689585000276566 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005252964794635773 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an anthropomorphic shark with dark gray skin and a white underbelly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shark wearing a pristine double-breasted chef's jacket with sleeves rolled up to the elbows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the shark wearing a towering, crisp white chef's hat that sways rhythmically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a spacious modern stainless steel kitchen with a gleaming metal floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shark performing a breakdance routine including floorwork and a one-handed spin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012532410211861134 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.3875322341918945 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012532410211861134, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012532410211861134, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23122699558734894, + 0.10047366470098495, + 0.12111769616603851, + 0.08676965534687042, + 0.13712739944458008, + 0.11800873279571533, + 0.05700228363275528, + 0.06009739264845848, + 0.05115024372935295, + 0.037025995552539825 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012532410211861134 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an anthropomorphic shark with dark gray skin and a white underbelly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shark wearing a pristine double-breasted chef's jacket with sleeves rolled up to the elbows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the shark wearing a towering, crisp white chef's hat that sways rhythmically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a spacious modern stainless steel kitchen with a gleaming metal floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shark performing a breakdance routine including floorwork and a one-handed spin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5232950448989868 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8982950448989868 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5232950448989868, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5232950448989868, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23672066628932953, + 0.040793951600790024, + 0.10894688963890076, + 0.05883214622735977, + 0.08431760221719742, + 0.15206368267536163, + 0.03344320133328438, + 0.10270586609840393, + 0.09231875836849213, + 0.08985717594623566 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5232950448989868 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_1/index_tensor([1638, 1638])_group_1_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_1/index_tensor([1638, 1638])_group_1_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..12dd61b2950f73fcb8ef0d1ed7891cdf8731fe2c --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_1/index_tensor([1638, 1638])_group_1_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "In Pixar style, a medium, eye-level shot captures a friendly dragon sitting quietly in a sun-dappled forest clearing. The camera immediately begins a slow, continuous zoom, zooming in on the creature. The dragon's body is composed of smooth, light-blue scales and a gentle, rounded snout, and its large, expressive emerald eyes gleam with a sense of calm wonder. It rests on soft, lush green grass dotted with small purple and yellow wildflowers, while warm, golden sunlight filtering through the dense forest canopy above casts shifting patterns of light and shadow across its form. As the camera moves closer, a magical transformation begins; the dragon's neck and spine begin to calmly and magically lengthen. This movement is not abrupt, but incredibly fluid, its body unfurling with ethereal grace, unfurling like a ribbon across the clearing. Each intricately designed scale captures the shifting sunlight, creating a mesmerizing, shimmering ripple effect along its elongated form, evoking a powerful atmosphere of pure, tranquil magic and awe.", + "seed": 30336, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_1/index_1638_seed_30336_dp_2_rank_4_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.00984102631919086, + "vlm_logprob": -0.00984102631919086, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.9, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.00984102631919086, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a friendly dragon with smooth, light-blue scales and a rounded snout?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the dragon sitting quietly on soft, lush green grass dotted with small purple and yellow wildflowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a medium, eye-level shot and immediately perform a slow, continuous zoom in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the dragon's neck and spine calmly lengthen and unfurl like a ribbon as the camera moves closer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a sun-dappled forest clearing with warm, golden sunlight filtering through the canopy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0038006706163287163 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628800868988037 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0038006706163287163, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0038006706163287163, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0881471037864685, + 0.0469568707048893, + 0.02644411288201809, + 0.025488313287496567, + 0.03516272082924843, + 0.031887561082839966, + 0.195024311542511, + 0.11977219581604004, + 0.24982763826847076, + 0.18128910660743713 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0038006706163287163 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a friendly dragon with smooth, light-blue scales and a rounded snout?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the dragon sitting quietly on soft, lush green grass dotted with small purple and yellow wildflowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a medium, eye-level shot and immediately perform a slow, continuous zoom in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the dragon's neck and spine calmly lengthen and unfurl like a ribbon as the camera moves closer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a sun-dappled forest clearing with warm, golden sunlight filtering through the canopy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036188371013849974 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.6286187171936035 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036188371013849974, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036188371013849974, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13736717402935028, + 0.07831629365682602, + 0.045290734618902206, + 0.01734635978937149, + 0.06656855344772339, + 0.0452980138361454, + 0.11901124566793442, + 0.13634316623210907, + 0.11765870451927185, + 0.23679974675178528 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036188371013849974 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a friendly dragon with smooth, light-blue scales and a rounded snout?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the dragon sitting quietly on soft, lush green grass dotted with small purple and yellow wildflowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a medium, eye-level shot and immediately perform a slow, continuous zoom in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the dragon's neck and spine calmly lengthen and unfurl like a ribbon as the camera moves closer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a sun-dappled forest clearing with warm, golden sunlight filtering through the canopy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005945852026343346 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130945682525635 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005945852026343346, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005945852026343346, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07725130021572113, + 0.03085087426006794, + 0.018960384652018547, + 0.024710770696401596, + 0.022495165467262268, + 0.05348605290055275, + 0.19243177771568298, + 0.20015066862106323, + 0.24635370075702667, + 0.13330931961536407 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005945852026343346 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a friendly dragon with smooth, light-blue scales and a rounded snout?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the dragon sitting quietly on soft, lush green grass dotted with small purple and yellow wildflowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a medium, eye-level shot and immediately perform a slow, continuous zoom in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the dragon's neck and spine calmly lengthen and unfurl like a ribbon as the camera moves closer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a sun-dappled forest clearing with warm, golden sunlight filtering through the canopy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012539120391011238 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387538909912109 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012539120391011238, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012539120391011238, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.02813003398478031, + 0.01258836779743433, + 0.007245174143463373, + 0.007862918078899384, + 0.016270922496914864, + 0.030535850673913956, + 0.12291198968887329, + 0.16711318492889404, + 0.3246384561061859, + 0.28270310163497925 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012539120391011238 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a friendly dragon with smooth, light-blue scales and a rounded snout?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the dragon sitting quietly on soft, lush green grass dotted with small purple and yellow wildflowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a medium, eye-level shot and immediately perform a slow, continuous zoom in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the dragon's neck and spine calmly lengthen and unfurl like a ribbon as the camera moves closer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a sun-dappled forest clearing with warm, golden sunlight filtering through the canopy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023300651460886 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7733006477355957 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023300651460886, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023300651460886, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15282417833805084, + 0.04657367244362831, + 0.01818820647895336, + 0.014085735194385052, + 0.045753363519907, + 0.09205947071313858, + 0.06554485112428665, + 0.09833783656358719, + 0.1435449719429016, + 0.3230876326560974 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023300651460886 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In Pixar style, a medium, eye-level shot captures a friendly dragon sitting quietly in a sun-dappled forest clearing. The camera immediately begins a slow, continuous zoom, zooming in on the creature. The dragon's body is composed of smooth, light-blue scales and a gentle, rounded snout, and its large, expressive emerald eyes gleam with a sense of calm wonder. It rests on soft, lush green grass dotted with small purple and yellow wildflowers, while warm, golden sunlight filtering through the dense forest canopy above casts shifting patterns of light and shadow across its form. As the camera moves closer, a magical transformation begins; the dragon's neck and spine begin to calmly and magically lengthen. This movement is not abrupt, but incredibly fluid, its body unfurling with ethereal grace, unfurling like a ribbon across the clearing. Each intricately designed scale captures the shifting sunlight, creating a mesmerizing, shimmering ripple effect along its elongated form, evoking a powerful atmosphere of pure, tranquil magic and awe.", + "seed": 30337, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_1/index_1638_seed_30337_dp_2_rank_4_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.10108267506584526, + "vlm_logprob": -0.10108267506584526, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.7, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.10108267506584526, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a friendly dragon with smooth, light-blue scales and a rounded snout?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the dragon sitting quietly on soft, lush green grass dotted with small purple and yellow wildflowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a medium, eye-level shot and immediately perform a slow, continuous zoom in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the dragon's neck and spine calmly lengthen and unfurl like a ribbon as the camera moves closer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a sun-dappled forest clearing with warm, golden sunlight filtering through the canopy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004283182788640261 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.5042829513549805 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004283182788640261, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004283182788640261, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17812307178974152, + 0.13586215674877167, + 0.08747752010822296, + 0.07040630280971527, + 0.10628534108400345, + 0.15503434836864471, + 0.06385456770658493, + 0.0319196991622448, + 0.10549867898225784, + 0.06553839892148972 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004283182788640261 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a friendly dragon with smooth, light-blue scales and a rounded snout?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the dragon sitting quietly on soft, lush green grass dotted with small purple and yellow wildflowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a medium, eye-level shot and immediately perform a slow, continuous zoom in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the dragon's neck and spine calmly lengthen and unfurl like a ribbon as the camera moves closer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a sun-dappled forest clearing with warm, golden sunlight filtering through the canopy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008645249530673027 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758645057678223 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008645249530673027, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008645249530673027, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08799242973327637, + 0.07795899361371994, + 0.08261871337890625, + 0.11613863706588745, + 0.1747640073299408, + 0.12358003854751587, + 0.07080302387475967, + 0.050409991294145584, + 0.16444776952266693, + 0.05128641799092293 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008645249530673027 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a friendly dragon with smooth, light-blue scales and a rounded snout?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the dragon sitting quietly on soft, lush green grass dotted with small purple and yellow wildflowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a medium, eye-level shot and immediately perform a slow, continuous zoom in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the dragon's neck and spine calmly lengthen and unfurl like a ribbon as the camera moves closer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a sun-dappled forest clearing with warm, golden sunlight filtering through the canopy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4288480281829834 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.0538480281829834 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.4288480281829834, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.4288480281829834, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09302596747875214, + 0.16171489655971527, + 0.06642871350049973, + 0.07687747478485107, + 0.28487011790275574, + 0.12643514573574066, + 0.0334351547062397, + 0.036876823753118515, + 0.07142261415719986, + 0.04891312122344971 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.4288480281829834 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a friendly dragon with smooth, light-blue scales and a rounded snout?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the dragon sitting quietly on soft, lush green grass dotted with small purple and yellow wildflowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a medium, eye-level shot and immediately perform a slow, continuous zoom in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the dragon's neck and spine calmly lengthen and unfurl like a ribbon as the camera moves closer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a sun-dappled forest clearing with warm, golden sunlight filtering through the canopy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008643240667879581 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.75864315032959 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008643240667879581, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008643240667879581, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09538936614990234, + 0.0923079252243042, + 0.04088530316948891, + 0.05556153506040573, + 0.08623894304037094, + 0.10927070677280426, + 0.05662141740322113, + 0.10145760327577591, + 0.1941949725151062, + 0.1680721938610077 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008643240667879581 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a friendly dragon with smooth, light-blue scales and a rounded snout?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the dragon sitting quietly on soft, lush green grass dotted with small purple and yellow wildflowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a medium, eye-level shot and immediately perform a slow, continuous zoom in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the dragon's neck and spine calmly lengthen and unfurl like a ribbon as the camera moves closer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a sun-dappled forest clearing with warm, golden sunlight filtering through the canopy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05499367415904999 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299936294555664 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05499367415904999, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05499367415904999, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08274451643228531, + 0.051870036870241165, + 0.02623835578560829, + 0.053036678582429886, + 0.2418220043182373, + 0.09725285321474075, + 0.08771790564060211, + 0.021496698260307312, + 0.31527477502822876, + 0.022546133026480675 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05499367415904999 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In Pixar style, a medium, eye-level shot captures a friendly dragon sitting quietly in a sun-dappled forest clearing. The camera immediately begins a slow, continuous zoom, zooming in on the creature. The dragon's body is composed of smooth, light-blue scales and a gentle, rounded snout, and its large, expressive emerald eyes gleam with a sense of calm wonder. It rests on soft, lush green grass dotted with small purple and yellow wildflowers, while warm, golden sunlight filtering through the dense forest canopy above casts shifting patterns of light and shadow across its form. As the camera moves closer, a magical transformation begins; the dragon's neck and spine begin to calmly and magically lengthen. This movement is not abrupt, but incredibly fluid, its body unfurling with ethereal grace, unfurling like a ribbon across the clearing. Each intricately designed scale captures the shifting sunlight, creating a mesmerizing, shimmering ripple effect along its elongated form, evoking a powerful atmosphere of pure, tranquil magic and awe.", + "seed": 30338, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_1/index_1638_seed_30338_dp_3_rank_6_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.010028820345178246, + "vlm_logprob": -0.010028820345178246, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 5.025, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.010028820345178246, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a friendly dragon with smooth, light-blue scales and a rounded snout?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the dragon sitting quietly on soft, lush green grass dotted with small purple and yellow wildflowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a medium, eye-level shot and immediately perform a slow, continuous zoom in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the dragon's neck and spine calmly lengthen and unfurl like a ribbon as the camera moves closer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a sun-dappled forest clearing with warm, golden sunlight filtering through the canopy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005524131003767252 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255524158477783 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005524131003767252, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005524131003767252, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09432584792375565, + 0.02958788350224495, + 0.018893621861934662, + 0.473777174949646, + 0.0415211096405983, + 0.019922776147723198, + 0.09213634580373764, + 0.02449609711766243, + 0.02263842336833477, + 0.18270081281661987 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005524131003767252 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a friendly dragon with smooth, light-blue scales and a rounded snout?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the dragon sitting quietly on soft, lush green grass dotted with small purple and yellow wildflowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a medium, eye-level shot and immediately perform a slow, continuous zoom in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the dragon's neck and spine calmly lengthen and unfurl like a ribbon as the camera moves closer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a sun-dappled forest clearing with warm, golden sunlight filtering through the canopy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005253676325082779 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255253791809082 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005253676325082779, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005253676325082779, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09964455664157867, + 0.06593199819326401, + 0.046719882637262344, + 0.5341649055480957, + 0.025439610704779625, + 0.02870386652648449, + 0.051536355167627335, + 0.01767866127192974, + 0.02328079752624035, + 0.10689938068389893 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005253676325082779 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a friendly dragon with smooth, light-blue scales and a rounded snout?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the dragon sitting quietly on soft, lush green grass dotted with small purple and yellow wildflowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a medium, eye-level shot and immediately perform a slow, continuous zoom in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the dragon's neck and spine calmly lengthen and unfurl like a ribbon as the camera moves closer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a sun-dappled forest clearing with warm, golden sunlight filtering through the canopy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007627766579389572 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882627964019775 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007627766579389572, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007627766579389572, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.055044762790203094, + 0.021018460392951965, + 0.024304231628775597, + 0.7079611420631409, + 0.053102124482393265, + 0.010303230956196785, + 0.07143320888280869, + 0.012656562961637974, + 0.0030294028110802174, + 0.041146859526634216 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007627766579389572 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a friendly dragon with smooth, light-blue scales and a rounded snout?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the dragon sitting quietly on soft, lush green grass dotted with small purple and yellow wildflowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a medium, eye-level shot and immediately perform a slow, continuous zoom in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the dragon's neck and spine calmly lengthen and unfurl like a ribbon as the camera moves closer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a sun-dappled forest clearing with warm, golden sunlight filtering through the canopy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02980075217783451 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298006534576416 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02980075217783451, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02980075217783451, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.02863149158656597, + 0.03784368932247162, + 0.017416484653949738, + 0.463001549243927, + 0.038479600101709366, + 0.023709597066044807, + 0.09063932299613953, + 0.018654709681868553, + 0.028192561119794846, + 0.2534309923648834 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02980075217783451 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a friendly dragon with smooth, light-blue scales and a rounded snout?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the dragon sitting quietly on soft, lush green grass dotted with small purple and yellow wildflowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a medium, eye-level shot and immediately perform a slow, continuous zoom in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the dragon's neck and spine calmly lengthen and unfurl like a ribbon as the camera moves closer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a sun-dappled forest clearing with warm, golden sunlight filtering through the canopy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0019377756398171186 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.2519378662109375 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0019377756398171186, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0019377756398171186, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11122525483369827, + 0.10781387984752655, + 0.019632888957858086, + 0.16888824105262756, + 0.027523383498191833, + 0.007629887200891972, + 0.48550793528556824, + 0.010246621444821358, + 0.010874862782657146, + 0.050656989216804504 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0019377756398171186 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In Pixar style, a medium, eye-level shot captures a friendly dragon sitting quietly in a sun-dappled forest clearing. The camera immediately begins a slow, continuous zoom, zooming in on the creature. The dragon's body is composed of smooth, light-blue scales and a gentle, rounded snout, and its large, expressive emerald eyes gleam with a sense of calm wonder. It rests on soft, lush green grass dotted with small purple and yellow wildflowers, while warm, golden sunlight filtering through the dense forest canopy above casts shifting patterns of light and shadow across its form. As the camera moves closer, a magical transformation begins; the dragon's neck and spine begin to calmly and magically lengthen. This movement is not abrupt, but incredibly fluid, its body unfurling with ethereal grace, unfurling like a ribbon across the clearing. Each intricately designed scale captures the shifting sunlight, creating a mesmerizing, shimmering ripple effect along its elongated form, evoking a powerful atmosphere of pure, tranquil magic and awe.", + "seed": 30339, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_1/index_1638_seed_30339_dp_3_rank_6_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.03510233201086521, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03510233201086521, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.875, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03510233201086521, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a friendly dragon with smooth, light-blue scales and a rounded snout?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the dragon sitting quietly on soft, lush green grass dotted with small purple and yellow wildflowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a medium, eye-level shot and immediately perform a slow, continuous zoom in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the dragon's neck and spine calmly lengthen and unfurl like a ribbon as the camera moves closer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a sun-dappled forest clearing with warm, golden sunlight filtering through the canopy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016428442671895027 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141428470611572 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016428442671895027, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016428442671895027, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14709757268428802, + 0.048576440662145615, + 0.018456267192959785, + 0.0747755691409111, + 0.044211264699697495, + 0.02178618498146534, + 0.01981380023062229, + 0.08530383557081223, + 0.09239982068538666, + 0.44757920503616333 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016428442671895027 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a friendly dragon with smooth, light-blue scales and a rounded snout?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the dragon sitting quietly on soft, lush green grass dotted with small purple and yellow wildflowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a medium, eye-level shot and immediately perform a slow, continuous zoom in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the dragon's neck and spine calmly lengthen and unfurl like a ribbon as the camera moves closer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a sun-dappled forest clearing with warm, golden sunlight filtering through the canopy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00864548608660698 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758645534515381 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00864548608660698, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00864548608660698, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15940625965595245, + 0.03358389064669609, + 0.03390398621559143, + 0.03331465274095535, + 0.027577834203839302, + 0.03173774853348732, + 0.01482901256531477, + 0.10865628719329834, + 0.14468006789684296, + 0.4123101830482483 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00864548608660698 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a friendly dragon with smooth, light-blue scales and a rounded snout?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the dragon sitting quietly on soft, lush green grass dotted with small purple and yellow wildflowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a medium, eye-level shot and immediately perform a slow, continuous zoom in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the dragon's neck and spine calmly lengthen and unfurl like a ribbon as the camera moves closer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a sun-dappled forest clearing with warm, golden sunlight filtering through the canopy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007632380351424217 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882632255554199 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007632380351424217, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007632380351424217, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05981573089957237, + 0.030530961230397224, + 0.0329182967543602, + 0.03182612732052803, + 0.03306398540735245, + 0.01655878685414791, + 0.03439972177147865, + 0.08283214271068573, + 0.2784808576107025, + 0.3995733857154846 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007632380351424217 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a friendly dragon with smooth, light-blue scales and a rounded snout?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the dragon sitting quietly on soft, lush green grass dotted with small purple and yellow wildflowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a medium, eye-level shot and immediately perform a slow, continuous zoom in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the dragon's neck and spine calmly lengthen and unfurl like a ribbon as the camera moves closer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a sun-dappled forest clearing with warm, golden sunlight filtering through the canopy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029814867302775383 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298149585723877 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029814867302775383, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029814867302775383, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.01628505066037178, + 0.018133029341697693, + 0.007839248515665531, + 0.008344851434230804, + 0.010338881984353065, + 0.006643144879490137, + 0.010752814821898937, + 0.0787385106086731, + 0.11446401476860046, + 0.7284603714942932 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029814867302775383 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a friendly dragon with smooth, light-blue scales and a rounded snout?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the dragon sitting quietly on soft, lush green grass dotted with small purple and yellow wildflowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a medium, eye-level shot and immediately perform a slow, continuous zoom in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the dragon's neck and spine calmly lengthen and unfurl like a ribbon as the camera moves closer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a sun-dappled forest clearing with warm, golden sunlight filtering through the canopy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11299048364162445 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.237990379333496 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11299048364162445, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11299048364162445, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.31646838784217834, + 0.040344320237636566, + 0.025700919330120087, + 0.03634956106543541, + 0.020931167528033257, + 0.025986097753047943, + 0.02957778237760067, + 0.06264011561870575, + 0.1208881363272667, + 0.3211134970188141 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11299048364162445 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_10/index_tensor([3851, 3851])_group_10_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_10/index_tensor([3851, 3851])_group_10_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..8f072853296b04018079fa6bb0d77ee8e6d79fcb --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_10/index_tensor([3851, 3851])_group_10_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "powerful first-person perspective shot, captured in ultra-high-speed slow motion, perfectly recreates the dynamic cinematography of top-tier sports broadcasts. With a resounding, muffled pop, the dark green champagne bottle you clutch, its rim slippery and cold with condensation, suddenly recoils backward with a powerful force. Beneath the torn golden foil, the white, mushroom-shaped cork disappears, replaced by a surging, almost explosive, gush of dense, white foam. Illuminated by the glaring locker room overhead lights, this torrent of foam transforms into a magnificent arc of roiling golden bubbles, powerfully slicing through the air, rising and traversing the frame. Each splashing droplet penetrated by the light reflects a diamond-like brilliance. The golden wine and white foam intertwine and roll in the air, forming a grand dynamic picture full of ecstasy, victory and ultimate release. The blurred cheering figures and waving arms of teammates in the background together set off the glory and passion of this summit moment.", + "seed": 25212, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_10/index_3851_seed_25212_dp_20_rank_40_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.22157450565136969, + "vlm_logprob": -0.22157450565136969, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.425, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.22157450565136969, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in ultra-high-speed slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a dark green champagne bottle with a slippery, condensation-covered rim visible in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the cork disappear and a gush of dense white foam erupt from the bottle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are blurred cheering figures and waving arms of teammates visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7738120555877686 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6488120555877686 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.7738120555877686, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.7738120555877686, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2358250916004181, + 0.11548301577568054, + 0.24416106939315796, + 0.07614126056432724, + 0.0584251806139946, + 0.04526177793741226, + 0.046197276562452316, + 0.0580332987010479, + 0.04984648898243904, + 0.07062551379203796 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.7738120555877686 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in ultra-high-speed slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a dark green champagne bottle with a slippery, condensation-covered rim visible in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the cork disappear and a gush of dense white foam erupt from the bottle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are blurred cheering figures and waving arms of teammates visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3134235441684723 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.31342351436615 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3134235441684723, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3134235441684723, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1270233541727066, + 0.08588565140962601, + 0.08774221688508987, + 0.10030727833509445, + 0.27817416191101074, + 0.11218874156475067, + 0.09029288589954376, + 0.05057334527373314, + 0.025950539857149124, + 0.04186192899942398 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3134235441684723 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in ultra-high-speed slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a dark green champagne bottle with a slippery, condensation-covered rim visible in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the cork disappear and a gush of dense white foam erupt from the bottle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are blurred cheering figures and waving arms of teammates visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005265060346573591 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255265235900879 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005265060346573591, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005265060346573591, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2048949897289276, + 0.10849680751562119, + 0.26798319816589355, + 0.14138095080852509, + 0.13600361347198486, + 0.042844630777835846, + 0.026026979088783264, + 0.03518887609243393, + 0.019236266613006592, + 0.01794370263814926 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005265060346573591 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in ultra-high-speed slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a dark green champagne bottle with a slippery, condensation-covered rim visible in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the cork disappear and a gush of dense white foam erupt from the bottle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are blurred cheering figures and waving arms of teammates visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0011818574275821447 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.7511820793151855 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0011818574275821447, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0011818574275821447, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07672201097011566, + 0.08345001190900803, + 0.11450759321451187, + 0.0633326843380928, + 0.32631707191467285, + 0.1303485780954361, + 0.08569694310426712, + 0.06399872899055481, + 0.02773546613752842, + 0.02789088897407055 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0011818574275821447 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in ultra-high-speed slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a dark green champagne bottle with a slippery, condensation-covered rim visible in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the cork disappear and a gush of dense white foam erupt from the bottle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are blurred cheering figures and waving arms of teammates visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014190010726451874 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264190196990967 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014190010726451874, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014190010726451874, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24747969210147858, + 0.0611819364130497, + 0.0996212363243103, + 0.0896906852722168, + 0.1485069990158081, + 0.0929563045501709, + 0.10831815004348755, + 0.043947916477918625, + 0.058557137846946716, + 0.049739960581064224 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014190010726451874 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "powerful first-person perspective shot, captured in ultra-high-speed slow motion, perfectly recreates the dynamic cinematography of top-tier sports broadcasts. With a resounding, muffled pop, the dark green champagne bottle you clutch, its rim slippery and cold with condensation, suddenly recoils backward with a powerful force. Beneath the torn golden foil, the white, mushroom-shaped cork disappears, replaced by a surging, almost explosive, gush of dense, white foam. Illuminated by the glaring locker room overhead lights, this torrent of foam transforms into a magnificent arc of roiling golden bubbles, powerfully slicing through the air, rising and traversing the frame. Each splashing droplet penetrated by the light reflects a diamond-like brilliance. The golden wine and white foam intertwine and roll in the air, forming a grand dynamic picture full of ecstasy, victory and ultimate release. The blurred cheering figures and waving arms of teammates in the background together set off the glory and passion of this summit moment.", + "seed": 25213, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_10/index_3851_seed_25213_dp_20_rank_40_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.13809144394472242, + "vlm_logprob": -0.13809144394472242, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.225, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.13809144394472242, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in ultra-high-speed slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a dark green champagne bottle with a slippery, condensation-covered rim visible in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the cork disappear and a gush of dense white foam erupt from the bottle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are blurred cheering figures and waving arms of teammates visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4426417052745819 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.0676417350769043 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.4426417052745819, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.4426417052745819, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20824222266674042, + 0.05976136401295662, + 0.020762529224157333, + 0.08920115232467651, + 0.27042070031166077, + 0.11847249418497086, + 0.03639614209532738, + 0.12835228443145752, + 0.029254624620079994, + 0.03913649544119835 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.4426417052745819 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in ultra-high-speed slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a dark green champagne bottle with a slippery, condensation-covered rim visible in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the cork disappear and a gush of dense white foam erupt from the bottle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are blurred cheering figures and waving arms of teammates visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2015509456396103 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7015509605407715 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2015509456396103, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2015509456396103, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0420355498790741, + 0.07696527987718582, + 0.015045463107526302, + 0.036840301007032394, + 0.10713639855384827, + 0.5178583860397339, + 0.05214747041463852, + 0.04138929024338722, + 0.04828333109617233, + 0.062298547476530075 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2015509456396103 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in ultra-high-speed slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a dark green champagne bottle with a slippery, condensation-covered rim visible in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the cork disappear and a gush of dense white foam erupt from the bottle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are blurred cheering figures and waving arms of teammates visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026363030076026917 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513631343841553 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026363030076026917, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026363030076026917, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08112706989049911, + 0.06885948777198792, + 0.04267636686563492, + 0.2460525780916214, + 0.12754783034324646, + 0.09484998136758804, + 0.04766670614480972, + 0.19595010578632355, + 0.041546184569597244, + 0.05372370034456253 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 7, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026363030076026917 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in ultra-high-speed slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a dark green champagne bottle with a slippery, condensation-covered rim visible in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the cork disappear and a gush of dense white foam erupt from the bottle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are blurred cheering figures and waving arms of teammates visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0017169271595776081 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.3767170906066895 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0017169271595776081, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0017169271595776081, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11992751806974411, + 0.0756666362285614, + 0.032915886491537094, + 0.09042063355445862, + 0.13370810449123383, + 0.21115174889564514, + 0.0402555987238884, + 0.19516804814338684, + 0.03454882279038429, + 0.0662369579076767 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 7, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0017169271595776081 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in ultra-high-speed slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a dark green champagne bottle with a slippery, condensation-covered rim visible in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the cork disappear and a gush of dense white foam erupt from the bottle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are blurred cheering figures and waving arms of teammates visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018184611573815346 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018184661865234 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018184611573815346, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018184611573815346, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19368931651115417, + 0.04425524175167084, + 0.029840609058737755, + 0.0371762290596962, + 0.0682566910982132, + 0.08519447594881058, + 0.14896613359451294, + 0.2809266746044159, + 0.025728687644004822, + 0.08596586436033249 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018184611573815346 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "powerful first-person perspective shot, captured in ultra-high-speed slow motion, perfectly recreates the dynamic cinematography of top-tier sports broadcasts. With a resounding, muffled pop, the dark green champagne bottle you clutch, its rim slippery and cold with condensation, suddenly recoils backward with a powerful force. Beneath the torn golden foil, the white, mushroom-shaped cork disappears, replaced by a surging, almost explosive, gush of dense, white foam. Illuminated by the glaring locker room overhead lights, this torrent of foam transforms into a magnificent arc of roiling golden bubbles, powerfully slicing through the air, rising and traversing the frame. Each splashing droplet penetrated by the light reflects a diamond-like brilliance. The golden wine and white foam intertwine and roll in the air, forming a grand dynamic picture full of ecstasy, victory and ultimate release. The blurred cheering figures and waving arms of teammates in the background together set off the glory and passion of this summit moment.", + "seed": 25214, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_10/index_3851_seed_25214_dp_21_rank_42_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.09979084774386138, + "vlm_logprob": -0.09979084774386138, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.3, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.09979084774386138, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in ultra-high-speed slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a dark green champagne bottle with a slippery, condensation-covered rim visible in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the cork disappear and a gush of dense white foam erupt from the bottle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are blurred cheering figures and waving arms of teammates visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2803429067134857 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.530342936515808 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2803429067134857, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2803429067134857, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22122858464717865, + 0.07838156074285507, + 0.12672071158885956, + 0.1079641580581665, + 0.07943477481603622, + 0.10237397998571396, + 0.05394051596522331, + 0.1141209751367569, + 0.06611968576908112, + 0.049715038388967514 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2803429067134857 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in ultra-high-speed slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a dark green champagne bottle with a slippery, condensation-covered rim visible in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the cork disappear and a gush of dense white foam erupt from the bottle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are blurred cheering figures and waving arms of teammates visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16036251187324524 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9103624820709229 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16036251187324524, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16036251187324524, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19279608130455017, + 0.06106377765536308, + 0.08187095075845718, + 0.08272537589073181, + 0.07292406260967255, + 0.06546064466238022, + 0.2250567227602005, + 0.09538298100233078, + 0.03699284791946411, + 0.08572658151388168 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16036251187324524 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in ultra-high-speed slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a dark green champagne bottle with a slippery, condensation-covered rim visible in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the cork disappear and a gush of dense white foam erupt from the bottle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are blurred cheering figures and waving arms of teammates visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.038116808980703354 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288116693496704 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.038116808980703354, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.038116808980703354, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3249050974845886, + 0.05095341056585312, + 0.04961679130792618, + 0.029424447566270828, + 0.04318465664982796, + 0.08045665919780731, + 0.1590425968170166, + 0.06461557000875473, + 0.09217194467782974, + 0.10562882572412491 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.038116808980703354 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in ultra-high-speed slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a dark green champagne bottle with a slippery, condensation-covered rim visible in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the cork disappear and a gush of dense white foam erupt from the bottle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are blurred cheering figures and waving arms of teammates visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.001946580014191568 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.251946449279785 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.001946580014191568, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.001946580014191568, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09062203019857407, + 0.07935373485088348, + 0.04572466015815735, + 0.05259665101766586, + 0.07488615810871124, + 0.06536998599767685, + 0.05536479875445366, + 0.270664244890213, + 0.08343472331762314, + 0.18198302388191223 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.001946580014191568 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in ultra-high-speed slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a dark green champagne bottle with a slippery, condensation-covered rim visible in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the cork disappear and a gush of dense white foam erupt from the bottle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are blurred cheering figures and waving arms of teammates visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018185431137681007 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018185615539551 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018185431137681007, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018185431137681007, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05937397480010986, + 0.02037002146244049, + 0.15800952911376953, + 0.5495256781578064, + 0.03502625599503517, + 0.020893311128020287, + 0.024153072386980057, + 0.03117128647863865, + 0.06489867717027664, + 0.036578238010406494 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018185431137681007 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "powerful first-person perspective shot, captured in ultra-high-speed slow motion, perfectly recreates the dynamic cinematography of top-tier sports broadcasts. With a resounding, muffled pop, the dark green champagne bottle you clutch, its rim slippery and cold with condensation, suddenly recoils backward with a powerful force. Beneath the torn golden foil, the white, mushroom-shaped cork disappears, replaced by a surging, almost explosive, gush of dense, white foam. Illuminated by the glaring locker room overhead lights, this torrent of foam transforms into a magnificent arc of roiling golden bubbles, powerfully slicing through the air, rising and traversing the frame. Each splashing droplet penetrated by the light reflects a diamond-like brilliance. The golden wine and white foam intertwine and roll in the air, forming a grand dynamic picture full of ecstasy, victory and ultimate release. The blurred cheering figures and waving arms of teammates in the background together set off the glory and passion of this summit moment.", + "seed": 25215, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_10/index_3851_seed_25215_dp_21_rank_42_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.08559437147341668, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08559437147341668, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.6, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08559437147341668, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in ultra-high-speed slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a dark green champagne bottle with a slippery, condensation-covered rim visible in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the cork disappear and a gush of dense white foam erupt from the bottle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are blurred cheering figures and waving arms of teammates visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.30294331908226013 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4279433488845825 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.30294331908226013, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.30294331908226013, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1816251277923584, + 0.2589215040206909, + 0.19397489726543427, + 0.09008856117725372, + 0.032454438507556915, + 0.0661252811551094, + 0.05140075087547302, + 0.02949371561408043, + 0.07226374000310898, + 0.023651888594031334 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.30294331908226013 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in ultra-high-speed slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a dark green champagne bottle with a slippery, condensation-covered rim visible in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the cork disappear and a gush of dense white foam erupt from the bottle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are blurred cheering figures and waving arms of teammates visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08904818445444107 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.464048147201538 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08904818445444107, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08904818445444107, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12602002918720245, + 0.0774524137377739, + 0.11281352490186691, + 0.16333793103694916, + 0.0510370135307312, + 0.14770549535751343, + 0.1290374994277954, + 0.03129737451672554, + 0.13668949902057648, + 0.024609221145510674 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 5, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08904818445444107 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in ultra-high-speed slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a dark green champagne bottle with a slippery, condensation-covered rim visible in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the cork disappear and a gush of dense white foam erupt from the bottle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are blurred cheering figures and waving arms of teammates visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016082797199487686 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141082763671875 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016082797199487686, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016082797199487686, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4487224519252777, + 0.0546247772872448, + 0.17011059820652008, + 0.08068844676017761, + 0.024243604391813278, + 0.019905727356672287, + 0.03891332074999809, + 0.05318239703774452, + 0.07708372175693512, + 0.03252499923110008 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016082797199487686 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in ultra-high-speed slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a dark green champagne bottle with a slippery, condensation-covered rim visible in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the cork disappear and a gush of dense white foam erupt from the bottle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are blurred cheering figures and waving arms of teammates visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.001716808183118701 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.376716613769531 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.001716808183118701, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.001716808183118701, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2683616876602173, + 0.05134773254394531, + 0.11687906086444855, + 0.06281343847513199, + 0.07595223188400269, + 0.07734023779630661, + 0.06728550046682358, + 0.06955448538064957, + 0.18371176719665527, + 0.02675381489098072 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.001716808183118701 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in ultra-high-speed slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a dark green champagne bottle with a slippery, condensation-covered rim visible in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the cork disappear and a gush of dense white foam erupt from the bottle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are blurred cheering figures and waving arms of teammates visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01818074844777584 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018180847167969 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01818074844777584, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01818074844777584, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10299569368362427, + 0.05680624023079872, + 0.08857281506061554, + 0.06762280315160751, + 0.014516377821564674, + 0.03609858825802803, + 0.059000421315431595, + 0.15142516791820526, + 0.38665345311164856, + 0.036308422684669495 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01818074844777584 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_11/index_tensor([5769, 5769])_group_11_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_11/index_tensor([5769, 5769])_group_11_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..bd59b157fcc5df4cfe9175739c62dacfc9749aac --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_11/index_tensor([5769, 5769])_group_11_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "long shot, shot from a low angle, the camera slowly and steadily moves forward, gradually zooming in. In a desolate open-air forge, a massive, muscular giant stood barefoot on the cracked concrete. His tanned skin was crisscrossed with old scars, each one a testament to past battles. He wore only a worn, dark brown leather loincloth around his waist. His teeth were clenched, his face a grimace of intense concentration and unleashed power. His massive hands gripped a thick, dark gray industrial I-beam, channeling all his strength into his arms. Every muscle tensed and bulged like granite, veins bulging across his arms and neck. Under this terrifying force, the solid steel groaned harshly as it slowly but irreversibly bent and twisted. The immense pressure wrinkled and cracked the metal's surface, and tiny sparks could be seen erupting at the points of compression. The dim afterglow of the setting sun shines through the industrial dust in the air, giving the entire scene a hard and rough warm tone, casting deep shadows on the giant's undulating muscle lines, intensifying the power of his outline, and creating a primitive, wild and awe-inspiring atmosphere of tension.", + "seed": 63, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_11/index_5769_seed_63_dp_22_rank_44_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.01318345800973475, + "vlm_logprob": -0.01318345800973475, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.55, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.01318345800973475, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a desolate open-air forge with cracked concrete ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive muscular giant standing barefoot wearing only a worn dark brown leather loincloth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the giant gripping a thick dark gray industrial I-beam with his hands?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the I-beam visibly bending, twisting, and cracking with sparks erupting from the compression points?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a long shot from a low angle and slowly move forward while gradually zooming in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009551186114549637 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.759551048278809 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009551186114549637, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009551186114549637, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.30271098017692566, + 0.029330728575587273, + 0.03171485662460327, + 0.035244327038526535, + 0.18095092475414276, + 0.04375796765089035, + 0.06373238563537598, + 0.1851443648338318, + 0.0764591321349144, + 0.05095436051487923 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009551186114549637 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a desolate open-air forge with cracked concrete ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive muscular giant standing barefoot wearing only a worn dark brown leather loincloth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the giant gripping a thick dark gray industrial I-beam with his hands?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the I-beam visibly bending, twisting, and cracking with sparks erupting from the compression points?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a long shot from a low angle and slowly move forward while gradually zooming in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0028217521030455828 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877821922302246 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0028217521030455828, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0028217521030455828, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14422254264354706, + 0.051082711666822433, + 0.03520049527287483, + 0.05238424241542816, + 0.09755562245845795, + 0.045034512877464294, + 0.06499224156141281, + 0.33188697695732117, + 0.10047832876443863, + 0.07716231048107147 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0028217521030455828 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a desolate open-air forge with cracked concrete ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive muscular giant standing barefoot wearing only a worn dark brown leather loincloth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the giant gripping a thick dark gray industrial I-beam with his hands?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the I-beam visibly bending, twisting, and cracking with sparks erupting from the compression points?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a long shot from a low angle and slowly move forward while gradually zooming in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023285627365112305 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732856273651123 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023285627365112305, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023285627365112305, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14232517778873444, + 0.04460252821445465, + 0.028868308290839195, + 0.08300898969173431, + 0.09375317394733429, + 0.03996778279542923, + 0.0911688581109047, + 0.15152664482593536, + 0.11093340069055557, + 0.21384507417678833 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023285627365112305 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a desolate open-air forge with cracked concrete ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive muscular giant standing barefoot wearing only a worn dark brown leather loincloth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the giant gripping a thick dark gray industrial I-beam with his hands?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the I-beam visibly bending, twisting, and cracking with sparks erupting from the compression points?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a long shot from a low angle and slowly move forward while gradually zooming in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016072357073426247 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.1410722732543945 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016072357073426247, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016072357073426247, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10165093094110489, + 0.04113907366991043, + 0.05108589679002762, + 0.036979325115680695, + 0.0933312326669693, + 0.1128409132361412, + 0.07682359218597412, + 0.2688140571117401, + 0.06996099650859833, + 0.1473739892244339 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016072357073426247 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a desolate open-air forge with cracked concrete ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive muscular giant standing barefoot wearing only a worn dark brown leather loincloth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the giant gripping a thick dark gray industrial I-beam with his hands?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the I-beam visibly bending, twisting, and cracking with sparks erupting from the compression points?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a long shot from a low angle and slowly move forward while gradually zooming in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014186367392539978 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264186382293701 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014186367392539978, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014186367392539978, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08060403168201447, + 0.0300381388515234, + 0.03681745007634163, + 0.04298901930451393, + 0.0718693807721138, + 0.06646143645048141, + 0.06886669993400574, + 0.2604334354400635, + 0.08016413450241089, + 0.2617563009262085 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014186367392539978 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "long shot, shot from a low angle, the camera slowly and steadily moves forward, gradually zooming in. In a desolate open-air forge, a massive, muscular giant stood barefoot on the cracked concrete. His tanned skin was crisscrossed with old scars, each one a testament to past battles. He wore only a worn, dark brown leather loincloth around his waist. His teeth were clenched, his face a grimace of intense concentration and unleashed power. His massive hands gripped a thick, dark gray industrial I-beam, channeling all his strength into his arms. Every muscle tensed and bulged like granite, veins bulging across his arms and neck. Under this terrifying force, the solid steel groaned harshly as it slowly but irreversibly bent and twisted. The immense pressure wrinkled and cracked the metal's surface, and tiny sparks could be seen erupting at the points of compression. The dim afterglow of the setting sun shines through the industrial dust in the air, giving the entire scene a hard and rough warm tone, casting deep shadows on the giant's undulating muscle lines, intensifying the power of his outline, and creating a primitive, wild and awe-inspiring atmosphere of tension.", + "seed": 64, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_11/index_5769_seed_64_dp_22_rank_44_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.011169800977222621, + "vlm_logprob": -0.011169800977222621, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.775, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.011169800977222621, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a desolate open-air forge with cracked concrete ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive muscular giant standing barefoot wearing only a worn dark brown leather loincloth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the giant gripping a thick dark gray industrial I-beam with his hands?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the I-beam visibly bending, twisting, and cracking with sparks erupting from the compression points?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a long shot from a low angle and slowly move forward while gradually zooming in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009445265866816044 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.7594451904296875 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009445265866816044, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009445265866816044, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18746311962604523, + 0.06409832090139389, + 0.0607982762157917, + 0.10173919051885605, + 0.07810091227293015, + 0.09070295840501785, + 0.16223569214344025, + 0.0980396494269371, + 0.09786708652973175, + 0.05895482748746872 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009445265866816044 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a desolate open-air forge with cracked concrete ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive muscular giant standing barefoot wearing only a worn dark brown leather loincloth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the giant gripping a thick dark gray industrial I-beam with his hands?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the I-beam visibly bending, twisting, and cracking with sparks erupting from the compression points?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a long shot from a low angle and slowly move forward while gradually zooming in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0019427727675065398 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.2519426345825195 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0019427727675065398, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0019427727675065398, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17347286641597748, + 0.10896977037191391, + 0.07479380071163177, + 0.06047207489609718, + 0.07378582656383514, + 0.046756498515605927, + 0.0870903953909874, + 0.1024894043803215, + 0.06787411868572235, + 0.20429523289203644 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0019427727675065398 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a desolate open-air forge with cracked concrete ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive muscular giant standing barefoot wearing only a worn dark brown leather loincloth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the giant gripping a thick dark gray industrial I-beam with his hands?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the I-beam visibly bending, twisting, and cracking with sparks erupting from the compression points?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a long shot from a low angle and slowly move forward while gradually zooming in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00863863155245781 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758638858795166 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00863863155245781, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00863863155245781, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11669375747442245, + 0.06696389615535736, + 0.03419312834739685, + 0.04708414152264595, + 0.06416887044906616, + 0.054912518709897995, + 0.16564325988292694, + 0.22082732617855072, + 0.10920914262533188, + 0.12030402570962906 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00863863155245781 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a desolate open-air forge with cracked concrete ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive muscular giant standing barefoot wearing only a worn dark brown leather loincloth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the giant gripping a thick dark gray industrial I-beam with his hands?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the I-beam visibly bending, twisting, and cracking with sparks erupting from the compression points?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a long shot from a low angle and slowly move forward while gradually zooming in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023291219025850296 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732911109924316 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023291219025850296, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023291219025850296, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07948017120361328, + 0.06657133251428604, + 0.03784221410751343, + 0.07897622883319855, + 0.04399615153670311, + 0.08662840723991394, + 0.09684768319129944, + 0.16651536524295807, + 0.20775046944618225, + 0.1353919804096222 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023291219025850296 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a desolate open-air forge with cracked concrete ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive muscular giant standing barefoot wearing only a worn dark brown leather loincloth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the giant gripping a thick dark gray industrial I-beam with his hands?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the I-beam visibly bending, twisting, and cracking with sparks erupting from the compression points?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a long shot from a low angle and slowly move forward while gradually zooming in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012531115673482418 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387531280517578 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012531115673482418, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012531115673482418, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1350729763507843, + 0.06738384813070297, + 0.08497457206249237, + 0.12861476838588715, + 0.07436936348676682, + 0.07482650130987167, + 0.12784729897975922, + 0.11700697988271713, + 0.1301022619009018, + 0.0598013661801815 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012531115673482418 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "long shot, shot from a low angle, the camera slowly and steadily moves forward, gradually zooming in. In a desolate open-air forge, a massive, muscular giant stood barefoot on the cracked concrete. His tanned skin was crisscrossed with old scars, each one a testament to past battles. He wore only a worn, dark brown leather loincloth around his waist. His teeth were clenched, his face a grimace of intense concentration and unleashed power. His massive hands gripped a thick, dark gray industrial I-beam, channeling all his strength into his arms. Every muscle tensed and bulged like granite, veins bulging across his arms and neck. Under this terrifying force, the solid steel groaned harshly as it slowly but irreversibly bent and twisted. The immense pressure wrinkled and cracked the metal's surface, and tiny sparks could be seen erupting at the points of compression. The dim afterglow of the setting sun shines through the industrial dust in the air, giving the entire scene a hard and rough warm tone, casting deep shadows on the giant's undulating muscle lines, intensifying the power of his outline, and creating a primitive, wild and awe-inspiring atmosphere of tension.", + "seed": 65, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_11/index_5769_seed_65_dp_23_rank_46_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.01099636652506888, + "vlm_logprob": -0.01099636652506888, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.85, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.01099636652506888, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a desolate open-air forge with cracked concrete ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive muscular giant standing barefoot wearing only a worn dark brown leather loincloth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the giant gripping a thick dark gray industrial I-beam with his hands?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the I-beam visibly bending, twisting, and cracking with sparks erupting from the compression points?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a long shot from a low angle and slowly move forward while gradually zooming in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006578337401151657 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.13157844543457 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006578337401151657, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006578337401151657, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17189359664916992, + 0.08263884484767914, + 0.09658364951610565, + 0.03727337718009949, + 0.04919052869081497, + 0.08141134679317474, + 0.13721169531345367, + 0.056129928678274155, + 0.13596822321414948, + 0.15169879794120789 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006578337401151657 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a desolate open-air forge with cracked concrete ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive muscular giant standing barefoot wearing only a worn dark brown leather loincloth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the giant gripping a thick dark gray industrial I-beam with his hands?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the I-beam visibly bending, twisting, and cracking with sparks erupting from the compression points?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a long shot from a low angle and slowly move forward while gradually zooming in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.001515550771728158 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.5015153884887695 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.001515550771728158, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.001515550771728158, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1361253410577774, + 0.07246425747871399, + 0.039027076214551926, + 0.04836020618677139, + 0.027931759133934975, + 0.041174598038196564, + 0.027799835428595543, + 0.04502581059932709, + 0.24523966014385223, + 0.316851407289505 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.001515550771728158 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a desolate open-air forge with cracked concrete ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive muscular giant standing barefoot wearing only a worn dark brown leather loincloth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the giant gripping a thick dark gray industrial I-beam with his hands?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the I-beam visibly bending, twisting, and cracking with sparks erupting from the compression points?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a long shot from a low angle and slowly move forward while gradually zooming in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011072029359638691 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511072158813477 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011072029359638691, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011072029359638691, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07242747396230698, + 0.04724033176898956, + 0.057622186839580536, + 0.035807088017463684, + 0.034241944551467896, + 0.04597878083586693, + 0.03398763760924339, + 0.11098318547010422, + 0.23662503063678741, + 0.325086385011673 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011072029359638691 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a desolate open-air forge with cracked concrete ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive muscular giant standing barefoot wearing only a worn dark brown leather loincloth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the giant gripping a thick dark gray industrial I-beam with his hands?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the I-beam visibly bending, twisting, and cracking with sparks erupting from the compression points?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a long shot from a low angle and slowly move forward while gradually zooming in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02328597754240036 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732858657836914 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02328597754240036, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02328597754240036, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09465855360031128, + 0.06556493043899536, + 0.12696382403373718, + 0.0471821129322052, + 0.03727905452251434, + 0.08533849567174911, + 0.0520407110452652, + 0.15882724523544312, + 0.13197128474712372, + 0.20017382502555847 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02328597754240036 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a desolate open-air forge with cracked concrete ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive muscular giant standing barefoot wearing only a worn dark brown leather loincloth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the giant gripping a thick dark gray industrial I-beam with his hands?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the I-beam visibly bending, twisting, and cracking with sparks erupting from the compression points?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a long shot from a low angle and slowly move forward while gradually zooming in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01252993755042553 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.3875298500061035 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01252993755042553, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01252993755042553, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11124339699745178, + 0.04137788340449333, + 0.05452648922801018, + 0.034702103585004807, + 0.038624390959739685, + 0.10467883199453354, + 0.0788513645529747, + 0.29486319422721863, + 0.186891108751297, + 0.054241202771663666 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01252993755042553 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "long shot, shot from a low angle, the camera slowly and steadily moves forward, gradually zooming in. In a desolate open-air forge, a massive, muscular giant stood barefoot on the cracked concrete. His tanned skin was crisscrossed with old scars, each one a testament to past battles. He wore only a worn, dark brown leather loincloth around his waist. His teeth were clenched, his face a grimace of intense concentration and unleashed power. His massive hands gripped a thick, dark gray industrial I-beam, channeling all his strength into his arms. Every muscle tensed and bulged like granite, veins bulging across his arms and neck. Under this terrifying force, the solid steel groaned harshly as it slowly but irreversibly bent and twisted. The immense pressure wrinkled and cracked the metal's surface, and tiny sparks could be seen erupting at the points of compression. The dim afterglow of the setting sun shines through the industrial dust in the air, giving the entire scene a hard and rough warm tone, casting deep shadows on the giant's undulating muscle lines, intensifying the power of his outline, and creating a primitive, wild and awe-inspiring atmosphere of tension.", + "seed": 66, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_11/index_5769_seed_66_dp_23_rank_46_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.010404220339842141, + "vlm_logprob": -0.010404220339842141, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.875, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.010404220339842141, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a desolate open-air forge with cracked concrete ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive muscular giant standing barefoot wearing only a worn dark brown leather loincloth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the giant gripping a thick dark gray industrial I-beam with his hands?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the I-beam visibly bending, twisting, and cracking with sparks erupting from the compression points?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a long shot from a low angle and slowly move forward while gradually zooming in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005807668901979923 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255807876586914 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005807668901979923, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005807668901979923, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09648576378822327, + 0.057434454560279846, + 0.06621283292770386, + 0.5709072351455688, + 0.046013202518224716, + 0.04050897806882858, + 0.038311731070280075, + 0.026132524013519287, + 0.01322105061262846, + 0.0447722002863884 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005807668901979923 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a desolate open-air forge with cracked concrete ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive muscular giant standing barefoot wearing only a worn dark brown leather loincloth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the giant gripping a thick dark gray industrial I-beam with his hands?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the I-beam visibly bending, twisting, and cracking with sparks erupting from the compression points?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a long shot from a low angle and slowly move forward while gradually zooming in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0019431296968832612 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.251943111419678 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0019431296968832612, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0019431296968832612, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05581019073724747, + 0.0466332770884037, + 0.24886812269687653, + 0.20249195396900177, + 0.07244231551885605, + 0.06949811428785324, + 0.15486681461334229, + 0.0512809194624424, + 0.037962403148412704, + 0.06014584004878998 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0019431296968832612 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a desolate open-air forge with cracked concrete ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive muscular giant standing barefoot wearing only a worn dark brown leather loincloth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the giant gripping a thick dark gray industrial I-beam with his hands?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the I-beam visibly bending, twisting, and cracking with sparks erupting from the compression points?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a long shot from a low angle and slowly move forward while gradually zooming in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020579738542437553 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955798149108887 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020579738542437553, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020579738542437553, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10020045936107635, + 0.033603232353925705, + 0.11482704430818558, + 0.36307621002197266, + 0.023081080988049507, + 0.046411607414484024, + 0.16650155186653137, + 0.06281778216362, + 0.038555849343538284, + 0.050925202667713165 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 6, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020579738542437553 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a desolate open-air forge with cracked concrete ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive muscular giant standing barefoot wearing only a worn dark brown leather loincloth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the giant gripping a thick dark gray industrial I-beam with his hands?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the I-beam visibly bending, twisting, and cracking with sparks erupting from the compression points?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a long shot from a low angle and slowly move forward while gradually zooming in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016069423407316208 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141069412231445 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016069423407316208, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016069423407316208, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0432298481464386, + 0.021898647770285606, + 0.026309672743082047, + 0.5793272256851196, + 0.08310431987047195, + 0.024354800581932068, + 0.012101263739168644, + 0.07037051022052765, + 0.04119563847780228, + 0.09810808300971985 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016069423407316208 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a desolate open-air forge with cracked concrete ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive muscular giant standing barefoot wearing only a worn dark brown leather loincloth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the giant gripping a thick dark gray industrial I-beam with his hands?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the I-beam visibly bending, twisting, and cracking with sparks erupting from the compression points?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a long shot from a low angle and slowly move forward while gradually zooming in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007621141150593758 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.8826212882995605 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007621141150593758, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007621141150593758, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.041408345103263855, + 0.0280115008354187, + 0.10718593746423721, + 0.28318092226982117, + 0.06084462255239487, + 0.12320601940155029, + 0.30276918411254883, + 0.020861955359578133, + 0.008002707734704018, + 0.024528872221708298 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007621141150593758 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_12/index_tensor([6658, 6658])_group_12_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_12/index_tensor([6658, 6658])_group_12_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..6ba4443b4fdb02bcbb6cb847dd7b3c03e4486553 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_12/index_tensor([6658, 6658])_group_12_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "low-angle, static close-up, rendered in the neoclassical style of a classical oil painting with subtle film grain, captures a moment of intense, primal conflict. On a bed of dark, damp, velvety moss, shimmering and glistening with tiny dewdrops, two enormous centipedes engage in a dramatic battle. Their vibrant, segmented bodies curl together in a tense, writhing knot of attack. One centipede is a crimson viscera, its chitin plates separated by softer, paler membranes, while the other is a stark, polished obsidian, its exoskeleton reflecting light like black volcanic glass. The lighting is dramatic, Caravaggesque, with a single, harsh light source from the side casting deep, impenetrable shadows and creating brilliant, mirrored highlights that capture the damp sheen on their armored bodies and the menacing, venomous curves of their powerful tips. The scarlet centipede arches its upper body, its tentacles twitching wildly as it tries to sink its fangs into its opponent, while the obsidian centipede powerfully contracts, its dozens of yellow legs digging deep into the moss in search of leverage, in a silent and brutal struggle for dominance, creating an atmosphere of primal, violent tension and grotesque beauty.", + "seed": 18243, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_12/index_6658_seed_18243_dp_24_rank_48_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.04422240657731891, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04422240657731891, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.05, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04422240657731891, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style that of a classical oil painting with subtle film grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are two enormous centipedes visible engaging in a battle on a bed of dark, damp, velvety moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is one centipede crimson with separated chitin plates and paler membranes, while the other is polished obsidian reflecting light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting dramatic and Caravaggesque with a single harsh side light source casting deep shadows and brilliant highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle in a static close-up shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.18077684938907623 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.805776834487915 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.18077684938907623, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.18077684938907623, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10370460897684097, + 0.033033668994903564, + 0.0406879223883152, + 0.4661434292793274, + 0.12554702162742615, + 0.0407075397670269, + 0.03521978110074997, + 0.02298392541706562, + 0.07859288901090622, + 0.05337918922305107 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.18077684938907623 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style that of a classical oil painting with subtle film grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are two enormous centipedes visible engaging in a battle on a bed of dark, damp, velvety moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is one centipede crimson with separated chitin plates and paler membranes, while the other is polished obsidian reflecting light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting dramatic and Caravaggesque with a single harsh side light source casting deep shadows and brilliant highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle in a static close-up shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005964220035821199 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130964279174805 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005964220035821199, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005964220035821199, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10506866872310638, + 0.0573236420750618, + 0.02898576483130455, + 0.27330175042152405, + 0.06809638440608978, + 0.026478899642825127, + 0.16739381849765778, + 0.03335339576005936, + 0.13369080424308777, + 0.10630689561367035 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005964220035821199 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style that of a classical oil painting with subtle film grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are two enormous centipedes visible engaging in a battle on a bed of dark, damp, velvety moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is one centipede crimson with separated chitin plates and paler membranes, while the other is polished obsidian reflecting light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting dramatic and Caravaggesque with a single harsh side light source casting deep shadows and brilliant highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle in a static close-up shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0076385317370295525 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882638454437256 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0076385317370295525, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0076385317370295525, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0996818020939827, + 0.045291390269994736, + 0.08012953400611877, + 0.3063601553440094, + 0.09607473015785217, + 0.0533631406724453, + 0.05833793058991432, + 0.0394207201898098, + 0.1692943572998047, + 0.0520462691783905 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0076385317370295525 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style that of a classical oil painting with subtle film grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are two enormous centipedes visible engaging in a battle on a bed of dark, damp, velvety moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is one centipede crimson with separated chitin plates and paler membranes, while the other is polished obsidian reflecting light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting dramatic and Caravaggesque with a single harsh side light source casting deep shadows and brilliant highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle in a static close-up shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012544183060526848 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.38754415512085 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012544183060526848, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012544183060526848, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07515785843133926, + 0.0787053033709526, + 0.05100367218255997, + 0.14270217716693878, + 0.3495134711265564, + 0.044645946472883224, + 0.05643986165523529, + 0.050615761429071426, + 0.11187946796417236, + 0.03933653235435486 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012544183060526848 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style that of a classical oil painting with subtle film grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are two enormous centipedes visible engaging in a battle on a bed of dark, damp, velvety moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is one centipede crimson with separated chitin plates and paler membranes, while the other is polished obsidian reflecting light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting dramatic and Caravaggesque with a single harsh side light source casting deep shadows and brilliant highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle in a static close-up shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014188248664140701 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264188289642334 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014188248664140701, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014188248664140701, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.119721420109272, + 0.09696589410305023, + 0.11158885061740875, + 0.1942068189382553, + 0.10219419002532959, + 0.07701806724071503, + 0.04297424480319023, + 0.03515131026506424, + 0.09946684539318085, + 0.12071238458156586 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014188248664140701 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, static close-up, rendered in the neoclassical style of a classical oil painting with subtle film grain, captures a moment of intense, primal conflict. On a bed of dark, damp, velvety moss, shimmering and glistening with tiny dewdrops, two enormous centipedes engage in a dramatic battle. Their vibrant, segmented bodies curl together in a tense, writhing knot of attack. One centipede is a crimson viscera, its chitin plates separated by softer, paler membranes, while the other is a stark, polished obsidian, its exoskeleton reflecting light like black volcanic glass. The lighting is dramatic, Caravaggesque, with a single, harsh light source from the side casting deep, impenetrable shadows and creating brilliant, mirrored highlights that capture the damp sheen on their armored bodies and the menacing, venomous curves of their powerful tips. The scarlet centipede arches its upper body, its tentacles twitching wildly as it tries to sink its fangs into its opponent, while the obsidian centipede powerfully contracts, its dozens of yellow legs digging deep into the moss in search of leverage, in a silent and brutal struggle for dominance, creating an atmosphere of primal, violent tension and grotesque beauty.", + "seed": 18244, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_12/index_6658_seed_18244_dp_24_rank_48_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.14130264688283206, + "vlm_logprob": -0.14130264688283206, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.3, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.14130264688283206, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style that of a classical oil painting with subtle film grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are two enormous centipedes visible engaging in a battle on a bed of dark, damp, velvety moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is one centipede crimson with separated chitin plates and paler membranes, while the other is polished obsidian reflecting light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting dramatic and Caravaggesque with a single harsh side light source casting deep shadows and brilliant highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle in a static close-up shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6333286166191101 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7583286166191101 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.6333286166191101, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.6333286166191101, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.26251059770584106, + 0.08663134276866913, + 0.0744376853108406, + 0.02836756408214569, + 0.11942336708307266, + 0.08194063603878021, + 0.07607294619083405, + 0.10844306647777557, + 0.07726367563009262, + 0.08490912616252899 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.6333286166191101 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style that of a classical oil painting with subtle film grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are two enormous centipedes visible engaging in a battle on a bed of dark, damp, velvety moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is one centipede crimson with separated chitin plates and paler membranes, while the other is polished obsidian reflecting light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting dramatic and Caravaggesque with a single harsh side light source casting deep shadows and brilliant highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle in a static close-up shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011092307977378368 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511092185974121 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011092307977378368, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011092307977378368, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21223555505275726, + 0.1959715187549591, + 0.08577446639537811, + 0.030745601281523705, + 0.06324749439954758, + 0.09459654241800308, + 0.06948438286781311, + 0.067132368683815, + 0.11801566183567047, + 0.06279636174440384 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011092307977378368 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style that of a classical oil painting with subtle film grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are two enormous centipedes visible engaging in a battle on a bed of dark, damp, velvety moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is one centipede crimson with separated chitin plates and paler membranes, while the other is polished obsidian reflecting light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting dramatic and Caravaggesque with a single harsh side light source casting deep shadows and brilliant highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle in a static close-up shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014203879982233047 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264204025268555 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014203879982233047, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014203879982233047, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10080907493829727, + 0.22708788514137268, + 0.06710611283779144, + 0.04576265066862106, + 0.1192043274641037, + 0.1904296875, + 0.07293887436389923, + 0.048984553664922714, + 0.04751237481832504, + 0.08016446977853775 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014203879982233047 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style that of a classical oil painting with subtle film grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are two enormous centipedes visible engaging in a battle on a bed of dark, damp, velvety moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is one centipede crimson with separated chitin plates and paler membranes, while the other is polished obsidian reflecting light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting dramatic and Caravaggesque with a single harsh side light source casting deep shadows and brilliant highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle in a static close-up shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014200588688254356 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264200687408447 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014200588688254356, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014200588688254356, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2076665610074997, + 0.11846590787172318, + 0.04355199635028839, + 0.029649045318365097, + 0.20645658671855927, + 0.09168466925621033, + 0.08687901496887207, + 0.059483181685209274, + 0.05140295252203941, + 0.10476010292768478 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014200588688254356 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style that of a classical oil painting with subtle film grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are two enormous centipedes visible engaging in a battle on a bed of dark, damp, velvety moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is one centipede crimson with separated chitin plates and paler membranes, while the other is polished obsidian reflecting light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting dramatic and Caravaggesque with a single harsh side light source casting deep shadows and brilliant highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle in a static close-up shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03368784114718437 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4086878299713135 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03368784114718437, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03368784114718437, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2398764044046402, + 0.2022896558046341, + 0.15146780014038086, + 0.0562085285782814, + 0.06006661802530289, + 0.028414906933903694, + 0.04792333394289017, + 0.029444275423884392, + 0.04786735028028488, + 0.136441171169281 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03368784114718437 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, static close-up, rendered in the neoclassical style of a classical oil painting with subtle film grain, captures a moment of intense, primal conflict. On a bed of dark, damp, velvety moss, shimmering and glistening with tiny dewdrops, two enormous centipedes engage in a dramatic battle. Their vibrant, segmented bodies curl together in a tense, writhing knot of attack. One centipede is a crimson viscera, its chitin plates separated by softer, paler membranes, while the other is a stark, polished obsidian, its exoskeleton reflecting light like black volcanic glass. The lighting is dramatic, Caravaggesque, with a single, harsh light source from the side casting deep, impenetrable shadows and creating brilliant, mirrored highlights that capture the damp sheen on their armored bodies and the menacing, venomous curves of their powerful tips. The scarlet centipede arches its upper body, its tentacles twitching wildly as it tries to sink its fangs into its opponent, while the obsidian centipede powerfully contracts, its dozens of yellow legs digging deep into the moss in search of leverage, in a silent and brutal struggle for dominance, creating an atmosphere of primal, violent tension and grotesque beauty.", + "seed": 18245, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_12/index_6658_seed_18245_dp_25_rank_50_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.11558472495526076, + "vlm_logprob": -0.11558472495526076, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.525, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.11558472495526076, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style that of a classical oil painting with subtle film grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are two enormous centipedes visible engaging in a battle on a bed of dark, damp, velvety moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is one centipede crimson with separated chitin plates and paler membranes, while the other is polished obsidian reflecting light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting dramatic and Caravaggesque with a single harsh side light source casting deep shadows and brilliant highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle in a static close-up shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5240006446838379 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8990006446838379 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5240006446838379, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5240006446838379, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14697584509849548, + 0.024010898545384407, + 0.021618280559778214, + 0.023990755900740623, + 0.37036851048469543, + 0.24982807040214539, + 0.026006381958723068, + 0.022989440709352493, + 0.022711990401148796, + 0.09149983525276184 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5240006446838379 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style that of a classical oil painting with subtle film grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are two enormous centipedes visible engaging in a battle on a bed of dark, damp, velvety moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is one centipede crimson with separated chitin plates and paler membranes, while the other is polished obsidian reflecting light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting dramatic and Caravaggesque with a single harsh side light source casting deep shadows and brilliant highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle in a static close-up shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01609499752521515 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141095161437988 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01609499752521515, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01609499752521515, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09993425756692886, + 0.04571584612131119, + 0.11725442856550217, + 0.031940311193466187, + 0.07535945624113083, + 0.34870901703834534, + 0.02141808345913887, + 0.174565389752388, + 0.04025929793715477, + 0.044843848794698715 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 7, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01609499752521515 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style that of a classical oil painting with subtle film grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are two enormous centipedes visible engaging in a battle on a bed of dark, damp, velvety moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is one centipede crimson with separated chitin plates and paler membranes, while the other is polished obsidian reflecting light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting dramatic and Caravaggesque with a single harsh side light source casting deep shadows and brilliant highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle in a static close-up shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012557249516248703 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387557029724121 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012557249516248703, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012557249516248703, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08818544447422028, + 0.12546254694461823, + 0.0551578588783741, + 0.02500465139746666, + 0.23715022206306458, + 0.3455350399017334, + 0.023116517812013626, + 0.05716242268681526, + 0.010902104899287224, + 0.03232322260737419 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012557249516248703 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style that of a classical oil painting with subtle film grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are two enormous centipedes visible engaging in a battle on a bed of dark, damp, velvety moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is one centipede crimson with separated chitin plates and paler membranes, while the other is polished obsidian reflecting light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting dramatic and Caravaggesque with a single harsh side light source casting deep shadows and brilliant highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle in a static close-up shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014200235716998577 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264200210571289 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014200235716998577, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014200235716998577, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12518851459026337, + 0.047850023955106735, + 0.022468840703368187, + 0.021927660331130028, + 0.1451365202665329, + 0.5134040117263794, + 0.01757362298667431, + 0.04089578613638878, + 0.016830522567033768, + 0.04872453957796097 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014200235716998577 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style that of a classical oil painting with subtle film grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are two enormous centipedes visible engaging in a battle on a bed of dark, damp, velvety moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is one centipede crimson with separated chitin plates and paler membranes, while the other is polished obsidian reflecting light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting dramatic and Caravaggesque with a single harsh side light source casting deep shadows and brilliant highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle in a static close-up shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011070497334003448 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511070728302002 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011070497334003448, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011070497334003448, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06364110857248306, + 0.062639020383358, + 0.03622962534427643, + 0.04756100848317146, + 0.08189041912555695, + 0.6098070740699768, + 0.024092748761177063, + 0.01601319946348667, + 0.016166672110557556, + 0.04195917397737503 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011070497334003448 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, static close-up, rendered in the neoclassical style of a classical oil painting with subtle film grain, captures a moment of intense, primal conflict. On a bed of dark, damp, velvety moss, shimmering and glistening with tiny dewdrops, two enormous centipedes engage in a dramatic battle. Their vibrant, segmented bodies curl together in a tense, writhing knot of attack. One centipede is a crimson viscera, its chitin plates separated by softer, paler membranes, while the other is a stark, polished obsidian, its exoskeleton reflecting light like black volcanic glass. The lighting is dramatic, Caravaggesque, with a single, harsh light source from the side casting deep, impenetrable shadows and creating brilliant, mirrored highlights that capture the damp sheen on their armored bodies and the menacing, venomous curves of their powerful tips. The scarlet centipede arches its upper body, its tentacles twitching wildly as it tries to sink its fangs into its opponent, while the obsidian centipede powerfully contracts, its dozens of yellow legs digging deep into the moss in search of leverage, in a silent and brutal struggle for dominance, creating an atmosphere of primal, violent tension and grotesque beauty.", + "seed": 18246, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_12/index_6658_seed_18246_dp_25_rank_50_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.14454541355371475, + "vlm_logprob": -0.14454541355371475, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.075, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.14454541355371475, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style that of a classical oil painting with subtle film grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are two enormous centipedes visible engaging in a battle on a bed of dark, damp, velvety moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is one centipede crimson with separated chitin plates and paler membranes, while the other is polished obsidian reflecting light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting dramatic and Caravaggesque with a single harsh side light source casting deep shadows and brilliant highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle in a static close-up shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6335309743881226 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7585309743881226 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.6335309743881226, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.6335309743881226, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0787668377161026, + 0.1449424773454666, + 0.05059173330664635, + 0.027477333322167397, + 0.039259497076272964, + 0.1458265781402588, + 0.024288231506943703, + 0.08438099175691605, + 0.36877962946891785, + 0.03568673133850098 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.6335309743881226 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style that of a classical oil painting with subtle film grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are two enormous centipedes visible engaging in a battle on a bed of dark, damp, velvety moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is one centipede crimson with separated chitin plates and paler membranes, while the other is polished obsidian reflecting light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting dramatic and Caravaggesque with a single harsh side light source casting deep shadows and brilliant highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle in a static close-up shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020611152052879333 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895611047744751 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020611152052879333, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020611152052879333, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1266832947731018, + 0.05957656726241112, + 0.10058793425559998, + 0.069756418466568, + 0.0475350059568882, + 0.21146130561828613, + 0.04118761792778969, + 0.04870032146573067, + 0.23517157137393951, + 0.059339940547943115 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020611152052879333 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style that of a classical oil painting with subtle film grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are two enormous centipedes visible engaging in a battle on a bed of dark, damp, velvety moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is one centipede crimson with separated chitin plates and paler membranes, while the other is polished obsidian reflecting light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting dramatic and Caravaggesque with a single harsh side light source casting deep shadows and brilliant highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle in a static close-up shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018203575164079666 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.0182037353515625 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018203575164079666, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018203575164079666, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14828242361545563, + 0.09015275537967682, + 0.21785785257816315, + 0.06599218398332596, + 0.031459566205739975, + 0.08729709684848785, + 0.01569865271449089, + 0.019815929234027863, + 0.28224635124206543, + 0.04119721055030823 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018203575164079666 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style that of a classical oil painting with subtle film grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are two enormous centipedes visible engaging in a battle on a bed of dark, damp, velvety moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is one centipede crimson with separated chitin plates and paler membranes, while the other is polished obsidian reflecting light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting dramatic and Caravaggesque with a single harsh side light source casting deep shadows and brilliant highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle in a static close-up shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02980699948966503 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298070907592773 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02980699948966503, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02980699948966503, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07614418119192123, + 0.05609321966767311, + 0.08836132287979126, + 0.019276730716228485, + 0.022325821220874786, + 0.06619644910097122, + 0.02086699567735195, + 0.04172581806778908, + 0.5790286660194397, + 0.029980825260281563 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02980699948966503 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style that of a classical oil painting with subtle film grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are two enormous centipedes visible engaging in a battle on a bed of dark, damp, velvety moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is one centipede crimson with separated chitin plates and paler membranes, while the other is polished obsidian reflecting light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting dramatic and Caravaggesque with a single harsh side light source casting deep shadows and brilliant highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle in a static close-up shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02057436667382717 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955743312835693 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02057436667382717, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02057436667382717, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0688602402806282, + 0.08634981513023376, + 0.06175888702273369, + 0.021892322227358818, + 0.08857692033052444, + 0.08361350744962692, + 0.05334065482020378, + 0.06766953319311142, + 0.384331613779068, + 0.08360663801431656 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02057436667382717 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_13/index_tensor([4019, 4019])_group_13_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_13/index_tensor([4019, 4019])_group_13_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..deac64fa1e9fdb845fa1a3dbdc7d851fcef98759 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_13/index_tensor([4019, 4019])_group_13_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "dynamic low-angle wide shot, panning rapidly to the right, closely follows a heavy, modern main battle tank as it sprints at breakneck speed across a wide asphalt road shrouded in darkness. The tank's hull is coated in a matte, dark olive green camouflage, its thick composite armor stained with weathered scratches and dirt, betraying its battle-worn credentials. Suddenly, the steel behemoth twists, initiating a powerful lateral drift that defies the laws of physics. Its heavy metal tracks scrape fiercely against the rough asphalt, accompanied by a sharp, scraping sound, and instantly unleashing a cascade of dazzling orange-red sparks. These sparks, like a burning trail, leave streaks of scorching white across the dark road. The sparks briefly illuminated the tank's side armor, the rotating road wheels, and the long gun barrel that trembled slightly due to the high-speed movement. The lights of the industrial area in the distance cast a cold and faint light. The whole scene formed a sharp contrast between the cold dark tones and the hot sparks, full of primitive power, mechanical violent aesthetics and a tense atmosphere that makes your adrenaline rush.", + "seed": 18657, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_13/index_4019_seed_18657_dp_26_rank_52_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.013406208576634526, + "vlm_logprob": -0.013406208576634526, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.625, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.013406208576634526, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavy, modern main battle tank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tank's hull coated in matte, dark olive green camouflage with weathered scratches and dirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tank perform a powerful lateral drift while sprinting at high speed across a wide asphalt road?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the tank's tracks scrape against the road, creating a cascade of orange-red sparks and streaks of scorching white light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a dynamic low-angle wide shot that pans rapidly to the right following the tank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.010152839124202728 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.760152816772461 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.010152839124202728, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.010152839124202728, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21856585144996643, + 0.05468349903821945, + 0.2277417927980423, + 0.18050551414489746, + 0.0511857271194458, + 0.045683395117521286, + 0.01267290860414505, + 0.012826829217374325, + 0.030363205820322037, + 0.16577129065990448 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.010152839124202728 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavy, modern main battle tank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tank's hull coated in matte, dark olive green camouflage with weathered scratches and dirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tank perform a powerful lateral drift while sprinting at high speed across a wide asphalt road?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the tank's tracks scrape against the road, creating a cascade of orange-red sparks and streaks of scorching white light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a dynamic low-angle wide shot that pans rapidly to the right following the tank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026353510096669197 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651353597640991 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026353510096669197, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026353510096669197, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06695408374071121, + 0.17198453843593597, + 0.5394918918609619, + 0.027279043570160866, + 0.07022224366664886, + 0.04402047395706177, + 0.013388263061642647, + 0.007727212738245726, + 0.02688840590417385, + 0.03204379975795746 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026353510096669197 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavy, modern main battle tank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tank's hull coated in matte, dark olive green camouflage with weathered scratches and dirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tank perform a powerful lateral drift while sprinting at high speed across a wide asphalt road?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the tank's tracks scrape against the road, creating a cascade of orange-red sparks and streaks of scorching white light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a dynamic low-angle wide shot that pans rapidly to the right following the tank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016060274094343185 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.1410603523254395 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016060274094343185, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016060274094343185, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2055746614933014, + 0.20283830165863037, + 0.2188476026058197, + 0.1441134214401245, + 0.02195318229496479, + 0.09948980808258057, + 0.028871474787592888, + 0.012239247560501099, + 0.027142493054270744, + 0.0389297753572464 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016060274094343185 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavy, modern main battle tank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tank's hull coated in matte, dark olive green camouflage with weathered scratches and dirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tank perform a powerful lateral drift while sprinting at high speed across a wide asphalt road?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the tank's tracks scrape against the road, creating a cascade of orange-red sparks and streaks of scorching white light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a dynamic low-angle wide shot that pans rapidly to the right following the tank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.001938013592734933 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.2519378662109375 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.001938013592734933, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.001938013592734933, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11421961337327957, + 0.051754843443632126, + 0.13471050560474396, + 0.1937410533428192, + 0.06633885204792023, + 0.11774308979511261, + 0.07307128608226776, + 0.02315584011375904, + 0.039138130843639374, + 0.18612681329250336 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.001938013592734933 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavy, modern main battle tank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tank's hull coated in matte, dark olive green camouflage with weathered scratches and dirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tank perform a powerful lateral drift while sprinting at high speed across a wide asphalt road?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the tank's tracks scrape against the road, creating a cascade of orange-red sparks and streaks of scorching white light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a dynamic low-angle wide shot that pans rapidly to the right following the tank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012526405975222588 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387526512145996 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012526405975222588, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012526405975222588, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08219336718320847, + 0.08972989022731781, + 0.4312386214733124, + 0.1554880142211914, + 0.06601086258888245, + 0.030098004266619682, + 0.03982855752110481, + 0.028814123943448067, + 0.02851949632167816, + 0.04807901009917259 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012526405975222588 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dynamic low-angle wide shot, panning rapidly to the right, closely follows a heavy, modern main battle tank as it sprints at breakneck speed across a wide asphalt road shrouded in darkness. The tank's hull is coated in a matte, dark olive green camouflage, its thick composite armor stained with weathered scratches and dirt, betraying its battle-worn credentials. Suddenly, the steel behemoth twists, initiating a powerful lateral drift that defies the laws of physics. Its heavy metal tracks scrape fiercely against the rough asphalt, accompanied by a sharp, scraping sound, and instantly unleashing a cascade of dazzling orange-red sparks. These sparks, like a burning trail, leave streaks of scorching white across the dark road. The sparks briefly illuminated the tank's side armor, the rotating road wheels, and the long gun barrel that trembled slightly due to the high-speed movement. The lights of the industrial area in the distance cast a cold and faint light. The whole scene formed a sharp contrast between the cold dark tones and the hot sparks, full of primitive power, mechanical violent aesthetics and a tense atmosphere that makes your adrenaline rush.", + "seed": 18658, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_13/index_4019_seed_18658_dp_26_rank_52_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.03018337404355407, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03018337404355407, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.975, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03018337404355407, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavy, modern main battle tank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tank's hull coated in matte, dark olive green camouflage with weathered scratches and dirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tank perform a powerful lateral drift while sprinting at high speed across a wide asphalt road?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the tank's tracks scrape against the road, creating a cascade of orange-red sparks and streaks of scorching white light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a dynamic low-angle wide shot that pans rapidly to the right following the tank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06552714854478836 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8155272006988525 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06552714854478836, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06552714854478836, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1494029015302658, + 0.08674456179141998, + 0.362802654504776, + 0.03371405601501465, + 0.050291791558265686, + 0.02213171124458313, + 0.07753734290599823, + 0.05105198919773102, + 0.11998974531888962, + 0.04633325710892677 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06552714854478836 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavy, modern main battle tank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tank's hull coated in matte, dark olive green camouflage with weathered scratches and dirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tank perform a powerful lateral drift while sprinting at high speed across a wide asphalt road?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the tank's tracks scrape against the road, creating a cascade of orange-red sparks and streaks of scorching white light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a dynamic low-angle wide shot that pans rapidly to the right following the tank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01608596369624138 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141086101531982 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01608596369624138, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01608596369624138, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12105641514062881, + 0.05967001989483833, + 0.47645267844200134, + 0.04082096740603447, + 0.03062542714178562, + 0.03262105956673622, + 0.08004959672689438, + 0.02211509831249714, + 0.0535229928791523, + 0.08306574076414108 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01608596369624138 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavy, modern main battle tank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tank's hull coated in matte, dark olive green camouflage with weathered scratches and dirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tank perform a powerful lateral drift while sprinting at high speed across a wide asphalt road?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the tank's tracks scrape against the road, creating a cascade of orange-red sparks and streaks of scorching white light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a dynamic low-angle wide shot that pans rapidly to the right following the tank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04863990470767021 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048640012741089 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04863990470767021, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04863990470767021, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15810537338256836, + 0.13621875643730164, + 0.09261050075292587, + 0.06778717786073685, + 0.056468408554792404, + 0.07494888454675674, + 0.0606192946434021, + 0.05619689077138901, + 0.17185217142105103, + 0.12519261240959167 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04863990470767021 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavy, modern main battle tank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tank's hull coated in matte, dark olive green camouflage with weathered scratches and dirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tank perform a powerful lateral drift while sprinting at high speed across a wide asphalt road?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the tank's tracks scrape against the road, creating a cascade of orange-red sparks and streaks of scorching white light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a dynamic low-angle wide shot that pans rapidly to the right following the tank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002488137688487768 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002488136291504 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002488137688487768, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002488137688487768, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06452130526304245, + 0.030690589919686317, + 0.03731122612953186, + 0.05002898722887039, + 0.05412145331501961, + 0.02674095146358013, + 0.02121828682720661, + 0.015387952327728271, + 0.18115273118019104, + 0.5188265442848206 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002488137688487768 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavy, modern main battle tank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tank's hull coated in matte, dark olive green camouflage with weathered scratches and dirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tank perform a powerful lateral drift while sprinting at high speed across a wide asphalt road?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the tank's tracks scrape against the road, creating a cascade of orange-red sparks and streaks of scorching white light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a dynamic low-angle wide shot that pans rapidly to the right following the tank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01817571558058262 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.0181756019592285 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01817571558058262, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01817571558058262, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1088801696896553, + 0.08248665928840637, + 0.07977286726236343, + 0.0654374361038208, + 0.15343452990055084, + 0.15445764362812042, + 0.11189679056406021, + 0.05104424059391022, + 0.08948103338479996, + 0.10310862958431244 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01817571558058262 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dynamic low-angle wide shot, panning rapidly to the right, closely follows a heavy, modern main battle tank as it sprints at breakneck speed across a wide asphalt road shrouded in darkness. The tank's hull is coated in a matte, dark olive green camouflage, its thick composite armor stained with weathered scratches and dirt, betraying its battle-worn credentials. Suddenly, the steel behemoth twists, initiating a powerful lateral drift that defies the laws of physics. Its heavy metal tracks scrape fiercely against the rough asphalt, accompanied by a sharp, scraping sound, and instantly unleashing a cascade of dazzling orange-red sparks. These sparks, like a burning trail, leave streaks of scorching white across the dark road. The sparks briefly illuminated the tank's side armor, the rotating road wheels, and the long gun barrel that trembled slightly due to the high-speed movement. The lights of the industrial area in the distance cast a cold and faint light. The whole scene formed a sharp contrast between the cold dark tones and the hot sparks, full of primitive power, mechanical violent aesthetics and a tense atmosphere that makes your adrenaline rush.", + "seed": 18659, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_13/index_4019_seed_18659_dp_27_rank_54_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.02831130949780345, + "vlm_logprob": -0.02831130949780345, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.0, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.02831130949780345, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavy, modern main battle tank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tank's hull coated in matte, dark olive green camouflage with weathered scratches and dirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tank perform a powerful lateral drift while sprinting at high speed across a wide asphalt road?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the tank's tracks scrape against the road, creating a cascade of orange-red sparks and streaks of scorching white light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a dynamic low-angle wide shot that pans rapidly to the right following the tank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06415852159261703 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8141584396362305 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06415852159261703, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06415852159261703, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06034787371754646, + 0.025390109047293663, + 0.06505384296178818, + 0.7047977447509766, + 0.007524929009377956, + 0.0631316751241684, + 0.040421538054943085, + 0.020986929535865784, + 0.003997196909040213, + 0.008348195813596249 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06415852159261703 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavy, modern main battle tank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tank's hull coated in matte, dark olive green camouflage with weathered scratches and dirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tank perform a powerful lateral drift while sprinting at high speed across a wide asphalt road?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the tank's tracks scrape against the road, creating a cascade of orange-red sparks and streaks of scorching white light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a dynamic low-angle wide shot that pans rapidly to the right following the tank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.033719077706336975 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408719062805176 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.033719077706336975, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.033719077706336975, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2239437699317932, + 0.10342751443386078, + 0.02922266535460949, + 0.13307766616344452, + 0.018055099993944168, + 0.15997739136219025, + 0.11294136196374893, + 0.11181142926216125, + 0.022672569379210472, + 0.08487054705619812 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.033719077706336975 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavy, modern main battle tank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tank's hull coated in matte, dark olive green camouflage with weathered scratches and dirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tank perform a powerful lateral drift while sprinting at high speed across a wide asphalt road?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the tank's tracks scrape against the road, creating a cascade of orange-red sparks and streaks of scorching white light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a dynamic low-angle wide shot that pans rapidly to the right following the tank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02979450300335884 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529794454574585 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02979450300335884, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02979450300335884, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05406123027205467, + 0.028312768787145615, + 0.06096136197447777, + 0.09629131853580475, + 0.022400885820388794, + 0.09916315227746964, + 0.5716985464096069, + 0.022671230137348175, + 0.012223456986248493, + 0.03221597522497177 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02979450300335884 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavy, modern main battle tank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tank's hull coated in matte, dark olive green camouflage with weathered scratches and dirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tank perform a powerful lateral drift while sprinting at high speed across a wide asphalt road?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the tank's tracks scrape against the road, creating a cascade of orange-red sparks and streaks of scorching white light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a dynamic low-angle wide shot that pans rapidly to the right following the tank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0028190179727971554 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877819061279297 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0028190179727971554, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0028190179727971554, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0515700988471508, + 0.08178909868001938, + 0.06316417455673218, + 0.2585515081882477, + 0.01993539370596409, + 0.15831348299980164, + 0.05602312833070755, + 0.11624974012374878, + 0.02831287682056427, + 0.16609041392803192 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0028190179727971554 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavy, modern main battle tank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tank's hull coated in matte, dark olive green camouflage with weathered scratches and dirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tank perform a powerful lateral drift while sprinting at high speed across a wide asphalt road?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the tank's tracks scrape against the road, creating a cascade of orange-red sparks and streaks of scorching white light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a dynamic low-angle wide shot that pans rapidly to the right following the tank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011065427213907242 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511065483093262 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011065427213907242, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011065427213907242, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.01782945543527603, + 0.023365989327430725, + 0.043030157685279846, + 0.5655229091644287, + 0.0214178878813982, + 0.20304930210113525, + 0.07347670197486877, + 0.010591426864266396, + 0.023621654137969017, + 0.01809450425207615 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011065427213907242 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dynamic low-angle wide shot, panning rapidly to the right, closely follows a heavy, modern main battle tank as it sprints at breakneck speed across a wide asphalt road shrouded in darkness. The tank's hull is coated in a matte, dark olive green camouflage, its thick composite armor stained with weathered scratches and dirt, betraying its battle-worn credentials. Suddenly, the steel behemoth twists, initiating a powerful lateral drift that defies the laws of physics. Its heavy metal tracks scrape fiercely against the rough asphalt, accompanied by a sharp, scraping sound, and instantly unleashing a cascade of dazzling orange-red sparks. These sparks, like a burning trail, leave streaks of scorching white across the dark road. The sparks briefly illuminated the tank's side armor, the rotating road wheels, and the long gun barrel that trembled slightly due to the high-speed movement. The lights of the industrial area in the distance cast a cold and faint light. The whole scene formed a sharp contrast between the cold dark tones and the hot sparks, full of primitive power, mechanical violent aesthetics and a tense atmosphere that makes your adrenaline rush.", + "seed": 18660, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_13/index_4019_seed_18660_dp_27_rank_54_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.0194316656794399, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0194316656794399, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.275, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0194316656794399, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavy, modern main battle tank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tank's hull coated in matte, dark olive green camouflage with weathered scratches and dirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tank perform a powerful lateral drift while sprinting at high speed across a wide asphalt road?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the tank's tracks scrape against the road, creating a cascade of orange-red sparks and streaks of scorching white light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a dynamic low-angle wide shot that pans rapidly to the right following the tank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03538130968809128 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.410381317138672 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03538130968809128, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03538130968809128, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06143680959939957, + 0.08459275215864182, + 0.07673197239637375, + 0.31162378191947937, + 0.19165447354316711, + 0.060678426176309586, + 0.05839928239583969, + 0.0609431192278862, + 0.025807058438658714, + 0.06813231855630875 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03538130968809128 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavy, modern main battle tank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tank's hull coated in matte, dark olive green camouflage with weathered scratches and dirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tank perform a powerful lateral drift while sprinting at high speed across a wide asphalt road?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the tank's tracks scrape against the road, creating a cascade of orange-red sparks and streaks of scorching white light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a dynamic low-angle wide shot that pans rapidly to the right following the tank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03370962664484978 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4087095260620117 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03370962664484978, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03370962664484978, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10176394134759903, + 0.0981486588716507, + 0.053607262670993805, + 0.09203168749809265, + 0.35169222950935364, + 0.04112962260842323, + 0.0903109759092331, + 0.06904279440641403, + 0.03338954970240593, + 0.06888327747583389 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03370962664484978 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavy, modern main battle tank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tank's hull coated in matte, dark olive green camouflage with weathered scratches and dirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tank perform a powerful lateral drift while sprinting at high speed across a wide asphalt road?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the tank's tracks scrape against the road, creating a cascade of orange-red sparks and streaks of scorching white light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a dynamic low-angle wide shot that pans rapidly to the right following the tank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011069907806813717 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.5110697746276855 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011069907806813717, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011069907806813717, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13296405971050262, + 0.06691364198923111, + 0.1543150693178177, + 0.08407308161258698, + 0.21109341084957123, + 0.04917148873209953, + 0.11520309001207352, + 0.049319855868816376, + 0.04830110818147659, + 0.08864514529705048 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011069907806813717 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavy, modern main battle tank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tank's hull coated in matte, dark olive green camouflage with weathered scratches and dirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tank perform a powerful lateral drift while sprinting at high speed across a wide asphalt road?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the tank's tracks scrape against the road, creating a cascade of orange-red sparks and streaks of scorching white light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a dynamic low-angle wide shot that pans rapidly to the right following the tank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0028166405390948057 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877816677093506 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0028166405390948057, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0028166405390948057, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06811098009347916, + 0.03717460855841637, + 0.08515586704015732, + 0.07780276983976364, + 0.11136732250452042, + 0.025913957506418228, + 0.10084764659404755, + 0.031264059245586395, + 0.16590318083763123, + 0.2964596748352051 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0028166405390948057 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavy, modern main battle tank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tank's hull coated in matte, dark olive green camouflage with weathered scratches and dirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tank perform a powerful lateral drift while sprinting at high speed across a wide asphalt road?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the tank's tracks scrape against the road, creating a cascade of orange-red sparks and streaks of scorching white light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a dynamic low-angle wide shot that pans rapidly to the right following the tank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014180843718349934 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264180660247803 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014180843718349934, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014180843718349934, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10527083277702332, + 0.061321940273046494, + 0.10428927093744278, + 0.07706044614315033, + 0.30883729457855225, + 0.061639510095119476, + 0.06271229684352875, + 0.04928412288427353, + 0.061497002840042114, + 0.10808731615543365 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014180843718349934 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_14/index_tensor([4687, 4687])_group_14_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_14/index_tensor([4687, 4687])_group_14_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..2d9f70f319211e2e4a219b8686afdc074f763bf5 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_14/index_tensor([4687, 4687])_group_14_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "dynamic high-angle shot, rendered with a vibrant, high-fidelity digital aesthetic, initially peers down from the precipice of a massive skyscraper, then swoops downward, seamlessly transitioning into a breathtaking tracking shot that follows a young woman as she plummets headfirst. The woman, sporting a sharp, asymmetrical silver bob that whips violently in the air currents, has large, expressive eyes the color of luminous amethyst, wide open with a mixture of excitement and intense focus. Her biological arms, replaced below the shoulders, have been replaced by complex cybernetic prosthetics made of polished obsidian polymer and interwoven with streams of glowing cyan data, their segmented plates shifting subtly to maintain aerodynamic stability. She wears a form-fitting matte black bodysuit made of nanowoven fabric that shimmers with oily iridescence in the city lights. As she plummets through a dense, futuristic cityscape—a vertical canyon of chrome and lye-soaked glass—the camera swirls around her, capturing her descent with surreal clarity. Wind forces become visible, distorting the air around her streamlined form, while the background blurs from holographic billboards and light trails of aircraft into dazzling streaks of electric blue, fuchsia, and orange, emphasizing the sheer, breathtaking speed of her fall and creating a thrilling, high-adrenaline atmosphere.", + "seed": 10169, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_14/index_4687_seed_10169_dp_28_rank_56_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.0962910946458578, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0962910946458578, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.475, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0962910946458578, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera initially positioned at a high angle, peering down from a skyscraper precipice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera transition into a tracking shot that follows a young woman plummeting headfirst?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman have a sharp, asymmetrical silver bob hairstyle that whips in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the woman's arms below the shoulders replaced by cybernetic prosthetics made of polished obsidian polymer with glowing cyan data?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman wear a form-fitting matte black bodysuit that shimmers with oily iridescence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11480005085468292 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.239799976348877 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11480005085468292, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11480005085468292, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09673034399747849, + 0.47304996848106384, + 0.07411913573741913, + 0.08578585833311081, + 0.09691975265741348, + 0.04357337951660156, + 0.0510803684592247, + 0.02532726339995861, + 0.024296440184116364, + 0.029117446392774582 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11480005085468292 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera initially positioned at a high angle, peering down from a skyscraper precipice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera transition into a tracking shot that follows a young woman plummeting headfirst?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman have a sharp, asymmetrical silver bob hairstyle that whips in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the woman's arms below the shoulders replaced by cybernetic prosthetics made of polished obsidian polymer with glowing cyan data?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman wear a form-fitting matte black bodysuit that shimmers with oily iridescence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023303097113966942 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7733030319213867 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023303097113966942, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023303097113966942, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1386026293039322, + 0.11822742968797684, + 0.1114131361246109, + 0.05410359799861908, + 0.06954385340213776, + 0.04359601065516472, + 0.08999787271022797, + 0.10565774887800217, + 0.15253973007202148, + 0.11631789058446884 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023303097113966942 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera initially positioned at a high angle, peering down from a skyscraper precipice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera transition into a tracking shot that follows a young woman plummeting headfirst?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman have a sharp, asymmetrical silver bob hairstyle that whips in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the woman's arms below the shoulders replaced by cybernetic prosthetics made of polished obsidian polymer with glowing cyan data?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman wear a form-fitting matte black bodysuit that shimmers with oily iridescence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16037185490131378 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9103718996047974 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16037185490131378, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16037185490131378, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05849398300051689, + 0.07746458053588867, + 0.1453874111175537, + 0.13189521431922913, + 0.06483469158411026, + 0.03822687268257141, + 0.0890277624130249, + 0.11697309464216232, + 0.2117842137813568, + 0.06591217964887619 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16037185490131378 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera initially positioned at a high angle, peering down from a skyscraper precipice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera transition into a tracking shot that follows a young woman plummeting headfirst?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman have a sharp, asymmetrical silver bob hairstyle that whips in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the woman's arms below the shoulders replaced by cybernetic prosthetics made of polished obsidian polymer with glowing cyan data?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman wear a form-fitting matte black bodysuit that shimmers with oily iridescence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07004482299089432 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695044755935669 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07004482299089432, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07004482299089432, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04301557317376137, + 0.07922690361738205, + 0.09727777540683746, + 0.33768078684806824, + 0.08201701939105988, + 0.027633067220449448, + 0.03464295342564583, + 0.028520025312900543, + 0.030515892431139946, + 0.23947004973888397 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07004482299089432 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera initially positioned at a high angle, peering down from a skyscraper precipice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera transition into a tracking shot that follows a young woman plummeting headfirst?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman have a sharp, asymmetrical silver bob hairstyle that whips in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the woman's arms below the shoulders replaced by cybernetic prosthetics made of polished obsidian polymer with glowing cyan data?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman wear a form-fitting matte black bodysuit that shimmers with oily iridescence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11293564736843109 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2379355430603027 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11293564736843109, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11293564736843109, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.055709026753902435, + 0.05781333148479462, + 0.09658657014369965, + 0.43316543102264404, + 0.09394972771406174, + 0.023732870817184448, + 0.047342848032712936, + 0.04560348019003868, + 0.08634680509567261, + 0.05974993109703064 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11293564736843109 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dynamic high-angle shot, rendered with a vibrant, high-fidelity digital aesthetic, initially peers down from the precipice of a massive skyscraper, then swoops downward, seamlessly transitioning into a breathtaking tracking shot that follows a young woman as she plummets headfirst. The woman, sporting a sharp, asymmetrical silver bob that whips violently in the air currents, has large, expressive eyes the color of luminous amethyst, wide open with a mixture of excitement and intense focus. Her biological arms, replaced below the shoulders, have been replaced by complex cybernetic prosthetics made of polished obsidian polymer and interwoven with streams of glowing cyan data, their segmented plates shifting subtly to maintain aerodynamic stability. She wears a form-fitting matte black bodysuit made of nanowoven fabric that shimmers with oily iridescence in the city lights. As she plummets through a dense, futuristic cityscape—a vertical canyon of chrome and lye-soaked glass—the camera swirls around her, capturing her descent with surreal clarity. Wind forces become visible, distorting the air around her streamlined form, while the background blurs from holographic billboards and light trails of aircraft into dazzling streaks of electric blue, fuchsia, and orange, emphasizing the sheer, breathtaking speed of her fall and creating a thrilling, high-adrenaline atmosphere.", + "seed": 10170, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_14/index_4687_seed_10170_dp_28_rank_56_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.0724775493144989, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0724775493144989, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.825, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0724775493144989, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera initially positioned at a high angle, peering down from a skyscraper precipice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera transition into a tracking shot that follows a young woman plummeting headfirst?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman have a sharp, asymmetrical silver bob hairstyle that whips in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the woman's arms below the shoulders replaced by cybernetic prosthetics made of polished obsidian polymer with glowing cyan data?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman wear a form-fitting matte black bodysuit that shimmers with oily iridescence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05082232877612114 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0508222579956055 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05082232877612114, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05082232877612114, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3853282332420349, + 0.15914469957351685, + 0.05568528175354004, + 0.08672221750020981, + 0.0473414771258831, + 0.018121985718607903, + 0.0185611043125391, + 0.07694918662309647, + 0.09956879913806915, + 0.05257699638605118 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05082232877612114 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera initially positioned at a high angle, peering down from a skyscraper precipice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera transition into a tracking shot that follows a young woman plummeting headfirst?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman have a sharp, asymmetrical silver bob hairstyle that whips in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the woman's arms below the shoulders replaced by cybernetic prosthetics made of polished obsidian polymer with glowing cyan data?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman wear a form-fitting matte black bodysuit that shimmers with oily iridescence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014204349368810654 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264204502105713 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014204349368810654, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014204349368810654, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2049768716096878, + 0.05072293058037758, + 0.06578637659549713, + 0.21211858093738556, + 0.11860638111829758, + 0.02605198509991169, + 0.029337625950574875, + 0.14013829827308655, + 0.10325199365615845, + 0.04900893196463585 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014204349368810654 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera initially positioned at a high angle, peering down from a skyscraper precipice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera transition into a tracking shot that follows a young woman plummeting headfirst?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman have a sharp, asymmetrical silver bob hairstyle that whips in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the woman's arms below the shoulders replaced by cybernetic prosthetics made of polished obsidian polymer with glowing cyan data?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman wear a form-fitting matte black bodysuit that shimmers with oily iridescence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10031064599752426 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3503105640411377 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10031064599752426, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10031064599752426, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10551157593727112, + 0.037118181586265564, + 0.04137835279107094, + 0.07811868190765381, + 0.4054628610610962, + 0.05072691664099693, + 0.02271484211087227, + 0.10001374781131744, + 0.09789629280567169, + 0.06105853244662285 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10031064599752426 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera initially positioned at a high angle, peering down from a skyscraper precipice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera transition into a tracking shot that follows a young woman plummeting headfirst?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman have a sharp, asymmetrical silver bob hairstyle that whips in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the woman's arms below the shoulders replaced by cybernetic prosthetics made of polished obsidian polymer with glowing cyan data?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman wear a form-fitting matte black bodysuit that shimmers with oily iridescence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07002314925193787 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950230598449707 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07002314925193787, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07002314925193787, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1643829047679901, + 0.05713111534714699, + 0.06870952248573303, + 0.16158130764961243, + 0.07387945801019669, + 0.05198241397738457, + 0.07057420164346695, + 0.12321818619966507, + 0.10163264721632004, + 0.12690819799900055 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07002314925193787 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera initially positioned at a high angle, peering down from a skyscraper precipice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera transition into a tracking shot that follows a young woman plummeting headfirst?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman have a sharp, asymmetrical silver bob hairstyle that whips in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the woman's arms below the shoulders replaced by cybernetic prosthetics made of polished obsidian polymer with glowing cyan data?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman wear a form-fitting matte black bodysuit that shimmers with oily iridescence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12702727317810059 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1270272731781006 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12702727317810059, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12702727317810059, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13431572914123535, + 0.038869962096214294, + 0.07106467336416245, + 0.08244314044713974, + 0.09556689858436584, + 0.06567702442407608, + 0.13256093859672546, + 0.11453869938850403, + 0.06871546059846878, + 0.1962474286556244 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12702727317810059 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dynamic high-angle shot, rendered with a vibrant, high-fidelity digital aesthetic, initially peers down from the precipice of a massive skyscraper, then swoops downward, seamlessly transitioning into a breathtaking tracking shot that follows a young woman as she plummets headfirst. The woman, sporting a sharp, asymmetrical silver bob that whips violently in the air currents, has large, expressive eyes the color of luminous amethyst, wide open with a mixture of excitement and intense focus. Her biological arms, replaced below the shoulders, have been replaced by complex cybernetic prosthetics made of polished obsidian polymer and interwoven with streams of glowing cyan data, their segmented plates shifting subtly to maintain aerodynamic stability. She wears a form-fitting matte black bodysuit made of nanowoven fabric that shimmers with oily iridescence in the city lights. As she plummets through a dense, futuristic cityscape—a vertical canyon of chrome and lye-soaked glass—the camera swirls around her, capturing her descent with surreal clarity. Wind forces become visible, distorting the air around her streamlined form, while the background blurs from holographic billboards and light trails of aircraft into dazzling streaks of electric blue, fuchsia, and orange, emphasizing the sheer, breathtaking speed of her fall and creating a thrilling, high-adrenaline atmosphere.", + "seed": 10171, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_14/index_4687_seed_10171_dp_29_rank_58_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.1074163407087326, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1074163407087326, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.3, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1074163407087326, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera initially positioned at a high angle, peering down from a skyscraper precipice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera transition into a tracking shot that follows a young woman plummeting headfirst?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman have a sharp, asymmetrical silver bob hairstyle that whips in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the woman's arms below the shoulders replaced by cybernetic prosthetics made of polished obsidian polymer with glowing cyan data?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman wear a form-fitting matte black bodysuit that shimmers with oily iridescence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14378000795841217 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.018779993057251 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14378000795841217, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14378000795841217, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3133874833583832, + 0.051947060972452164, + 0.17450293898582458, + 0.04008454456925392, + 0.051029350608587265, + 0.05003323778510094, + 0.06249351426959038, + 0.054419539868831635, + 0.159626767039299, + 0.042475536465644836 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14378000795841217 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera initially positioned at a high angle, peering down from a skyscraper precipice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera transition into a tracking shot that follows a young woman plummeting headfirst?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman have a sharp, asymmetrical silver bob hairstyle that whips in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the woman's arms below the shoulders replaced by cybernetic prosthetics made of polished obsidian polymer with glowing cyan data?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman wear a form-fitting matte black bodysuit that shimmers with oily iridescence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0430665984749794 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680665016174316 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0430665984749794, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0430665984749794, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13897515833377838, + 0.06991613656282425, + 0.18673621118068695, + 0.04221578314900398, + 0.03408382087945938, + 0.06085249409079552, + 0.0955849215388298, + 0.07082817703485489, + 0.25845474004745483, + 0.04235253110527992 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0430665984749794 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera initially positioned at a high angle, peering down from a skyscraper precipice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera transition into a tracking shot that follows a young woman plummeting headfirst?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman have a sharp, asymmetrical silver bob hairstyle that whips in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the woman's arms below the shoulders replaced by cybernetic prosthetics made of polished obsidian polymer with glowing cyan data?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman wear a form-fitting matte black bodysuit that shimmers with oily iridescence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1003270372748375 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3503270149230957 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1003270372748375, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1003270372748375, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14692988991737366, + 0.04809655621647835, + 0.06501191854476929, + 0.048025038093328476, + 0.06083940342068672, + 0.2503933906555176, + 0.08128723502159119, + 0.059693288058042526, + 0.20046092569828033, + 0.0392623171210289 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1003270372748375 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera initially positioned at a high angle, peering down from a skyscraper precipice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera transition into a tracking shot that follows a young woman plummeting headfirst?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman have a sharp, asymmetrical silver bob hairstyle that whips in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the woman's arms below the shoulders replaced by cybernetic prosthetics made of polished obsidian polymer with glowing cyan data?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman wear a form-fitting matte black bodysuit that shimmers with oily iridescence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07002915441989899 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950292587280273 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07002915441989899, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07002915441989899, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12920266389846802, + 0.04166775569319725, + 0.04436289519071579, + 0.15632125735282898, + 0.07235170900821686, + 0.07691692560911179, + 0.1432551145553589, + 0.07294048368930817, + 0.19251635670661926, + 0.07046487927436829 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 3, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07002915441989899 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera initially positioned at a high angle, peering down from a skyscraper precipice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera transition into a tracking shot that follows a young woman plummeting headfirst?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman have a sharp, asymmetrical silver bob hairstyle that whips in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the woman's arms below the shoulders replaced by cybernetic prosthetics made of polished obsidian polymer with glowing cyan data?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman wear a form-fitting matte black bodysuit that shimmers with oily iridescence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17987890541553497 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8048789501190186 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17987890541553497, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17987890541553497, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1450403928756714, + 0.11666364967823029, + 0.052331484854221344, + 0.04147157073020935, + 0.06792029738426208, + 0.07186371833086014, + 0.12686583399772644, + 0.05113658308982849, + 0.2254728376865387, + 0.10123362392187119 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17987890541553497 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dynamic high-angle shot, rendered with a vibrant, high-fidelity digital aesthetic, initially peers down from the precipice of a massive skyscraper, then swoops downward, seamlessly transitioning into a breathtaking tracking shot that follows a young woman as she plummets headfirst. The woman, sporting a sharp, asymmetrical silver bob that whips violently in the air currents, has large, expressive eyes the color of luminous amethyst, wide open with a mixture of excitement and intense focus. Her biological arms, replaced below the shoulders, have been replaced by complex cybernetic prosthetics made of polished obsidian polymer and interwoven with streams of glowing cyan data, their segmented plates shifting subtly to maintain aerodynamic stability. She wears a form-fitting matte black bodysuit made of nanowoven fabric that shimmers with oily iridescence in the city lights. As she plummets through a dense, futuristic cityscape—a vertical canyon of chrome and lye-soaked glass—the camera swirls around her, capturing her descent with surreal clarity. Wind forces become visible, distorting the air around her streamlined form, while the background blurs from holographic billboards and light trails of aircraft into dazzling streaks of electric blue, fuchsia, and orange, emphasizing the sheer, breathtaking speed of her fall and creating a thrilling, high-adrenaline atmosphere.", + "seed": 10172, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_14/index_4687_seed_10172_dp_29_rank_58_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.08235029838979244, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08235029838979244, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.575, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08235029838979244, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera initially positioned at a high angle, peering down from a skyscraper precipice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera transition into a tracking shot that follows a young woman plummeting headfirst?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman have a sharp, asymmetrical silver bob hairstyle that whips in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the woman's arms below the shoulders replaced by cybernetic prosthetics made of polished obsidian polymer with glowing cyan data?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman wear a form-fitting matte black bodysuit that shimmers with oily iridescence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10214629769325256 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3521463871002197 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10214629769325256, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10214629769325256, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.42183953523635864, + 0.047629740089178085, + 0.020223187282681465, + 0.05962943658232689, + 0.035812024027109146, + 0.018592223525047302, + 0.08747310936450958, + 0.027489088475704193, + 0.24600830674171448, + 0.03530333563685417 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10214629769325256 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera initially positioned at a high angle, peering down from a skyscraper precipice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera transition into a tracking shot that follows a young woman plummeting headfirst?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman have a sharp, asymmetrical silver bob hairstyle that whips in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the woman's arms below the shoulders replaced by cybernetic prosthetics made of polished obsidian polymer with glowing cyan data?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman wear a form-fitting matte black bodysuit that shimmers with oily iridescence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026356181129813194 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513562202453613 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026356181129813194, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026356181129813194, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3009674549102783, + 0.11476674675941467, + 0.03344939649105072, + 0.08274121582508087, + 0.052192267030477524, + 0.021022189408540726, + 0.04620528593659401, + 0.041132766753435135, + 0.1901935636997223, + 0.11732903867959976 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026356181129813194 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera initially positioned at a high angle, peering down from a skyscraper precipice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera transition into a tracking shot that follows a young woman plummeting headfirst?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman have a sharp, asymmetrical silver bob hairstyle that whips in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the woman's arms below the shoulders replaced by cybernetic prosthetics made of polished obsidian polymer with glowing cyan data?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman wear a form-fitting matte black bodysuit that shimmers with oily iridescence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11293554306030273 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2379355430603027 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11293554306030273, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11293554306030273, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05076177790760994, + 0.036344725638628006, + 0.04767213389277458, + 0.33656203746795654, + 0.026105783879756927, + 0.017607184126973152, + 0.028215765953063965, + 0.027141384780406952, + 0.4023109972476959, + 0.02727813832461834 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11293554306030273 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera initially positioned at a high angle, peering down from a skyscraper precipice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera transition into a tracking shot that follows a young woman plummeting headfirst?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman have a sharp, asymmetrical silver bob hairstyle that whips in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the woman's arms below the shoulders replaced by cybernetic prosthetics made of polished obsidian polymer with glowing cyan data?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman wear a form-fitting matte black bodysuit that shimmers with oily iridescence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07002870738506317 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695028781890869 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07002870738506317, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07002870738506317, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12882240116596222, + 0.09021665155887604, + 0.06311089545488358, + 0.03633049502968788, + 0.06945580989122391, + 0.03685786575078964, + 0.1360245794057846, + 0.010558058507740498, + 0.37893304228782654, + 0.049690186977386475 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07002870738506317 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera initially positioned at a high angle, peering down from a skyscraper precipice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera transition into a tracking shot that follows a young woman plummeting headfirst?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman have a sharp, asymmetrical silver bob hairstyle that whips in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the woman's arms below the shoulders replaced by cybernetic prosthetics made of polished obsidian polymer with glowing cyan data?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman wear a form-fitting matte black bodysuit that shimmers with oily iridescence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10028476268053055 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3502848148345947 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10028476268053055, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10028476268053055, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0734434723854065, + 0.08407596498727798, + 0.027712572365999222, + 0.03369437903165817, + 0.050911709666252136, + 0.04369594156742096, + 0.054061539471149445, + 0.03705890104174614, + 0.4497067332267761, + 0.14563874900341034 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10028476268053055 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_15/index_tensor([1789, 1789])_group_15_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_15/index_tensor([1789, 1789])_group_15_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..cfa15cdd154b867219d3d60b67aa783f604add1b --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_15/index_tensor([1789, 1789])_group_15_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "low-angle shot, slowly moving forward and tilting slightly upward, focuses on a heroic woman atop a rugged, rocky mountaintop. Her long, black hair, tied high in a bun, dances wildly in the sharp mountain breeze, a few strands brushing against her stern, focused face. She clad in a meticulously crafted suit of silver metal plate armor, intricately engraved with ancient runes. The edges of the shoulder and breastplate, battle-worn from countless battles, reflect a cold, dazzling light in the rising sun. The first rays of dawn's sun burst forth from behind her, creating a powerful backlight that casts a dazzling golden edge across her entire form, from her flowing hair to every edge of her armor. In her hands, she clutched a slender, two-handed sword, its broad blade marked by a deep, blood-tinged groove. She engaged in a fluid and deadly sword dance, her body swirling steadily and gracefully in time with the blade's momentum, her crimson cape rustling behind her. Every slash and parry was imbued with power and rhythm. Beneath her feet lay a roiling sea of clouds, a surging white ocean. The distant skyline was dyed a brilliant gradient of orange, red, and purple. The entire scene was imbued with a sense of epic grandeur and aloof, cold heroism.", + "seed": 31675, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_15/index_1789_seed_31675_dp_30_rank_60_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.031219327170401812, + "vlm_logprob": -0.031219327170401812, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.5, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.031219327170401812, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a low angle, moving forward and tilting slightly upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a woman wearing silver metal plate armor engraved with ancient runes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman performing a fluid sword dance with a two-handed sword that has a blood-tinged groove?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a roiling sea of clouds beneath a distant skyline with an orange, red, and purple gradient?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a powerful backlight from the rising sun creating a golden edge on the woman's hair and armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08543310314416885 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.585433006286621 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08543310314416885, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08543310314416885, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3872152864933014, + 0.06606151163578033, + 0.01995731331408024, + 0.02400825172662735, + 0.012573606334626675, + 0.006845560390502214, + 0.216941699385643, + 0.22270351648330688, + 0.02316892519593239, + 0.02052430249750614 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08543310314416885 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a low angle, moving forward and tilting slightly upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a woman wearing silver metal plate armor engraved with ancient runes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman performing a fluid sword dance with a two-handed sword that has a blood-tinged groove?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a roiling sea of clouds beneath a distant skyline with an orange, red, and purple gradient?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a powerful backlight from the rising sun creating a golden edge on the woman's hair and armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03811187297105789 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288111925125122 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03811187297105789, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03811187297105789, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5268179774284363, + 0.03632325679063797, + 0.02395986020565033, + 0.01738991029560566, + 0.04591567441821098, + 0.02214125730097294, + 0.1729382872581482, + 0.07554089277982712, + 0.031444162130355835, + 0.04752873256802559 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03811187297105789 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a low angle, moving forward and tilting slightly upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a woman wearing silver metal plate armor engraved with ancient runes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman performing a fluid sword dance with a two-handed sword that has a blood-tinged groove?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a roiling sea of clouds beneath a distant skyline with an orange, red, and purple gradient?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a powerful backlight from the rising sun creating a golden edge on the woman's hair and armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029804455116391182 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298044681549072 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029804455116391182, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029804455116391182, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05111541226506233, + 0.07025204598903656, + 0.015832098200917244, + 0.05405319482088089, + 0.05152267590165138, + 0.020215682685375214, + 0.23793865740299225, + 0.38030654191970825, + 0.06701866537332535, + 0.05174506828188896 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029804455116391182 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a low angle, moving forward and tilting slightly upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a woman wearing silver metal plate armor engraved with ancient runes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman performing a fluid sword dance with a two-handed sword that has a blood-tinged groove?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a roiling sea of clouds beneath a distant skyline with an orange, red, and purple gradient?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a powerful backlight from the rising sun creating a golden edge on the woman's hair and armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0010386077919974923 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.876038551330566 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0010386077919974923, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0010386077919974923, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.42532867193222046, + 0.2653352916240692, + 0.01922389306128025, + 0.011860285885632038, + 0.025611773133277893, + 0.035138633102178574, + 0.05425494909286499, + 0.10689800977706909, + 0.014297149144113064, + 0.042051367461681366 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0010386077919974923 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a low angle, moving forward and tilting slightly upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a woman wearing silver metal plate armor engraved with ancient runes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman performing a fluid sword dance with a two-handed sword that has a blood-tinged groove?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a roiling sea of clouds beneath a distant skyline with an orange, red, and purple gradient?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a powerful backlight from the rising sun creating a golden edge on the woman's hair and armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0017085968283936381 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.376708507537842 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0017085968283936381, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0017085968283936381, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.79526686668396, + 0.021054338663816452, + 0.011101225391030312, + 0.011922276578843594, + 0.019064372405409813, + 0.014321284368634224, + 0.03972805663943291, + 0.05494416877627373, + 0.009492619894444942, + 0.023104745894670486 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0017085968283936381 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle shot, slowly moving forward and tilting slightly upward, focuses on a heroic woman atop a rugged, rocky mountaintop. Her long, black hair, tied high in a bun, dances wildly in the sharp mountain breeze, a few strands brushing against her stern, focused face. She clad in a meticulously crafted suit of silver metal plate armor, intricately engraved with ancient runes. The edges of the shoulder and breastplate, battle-worn from countless battles, reflect a cold, dazzling light in the rising sun. The first rays of dawn's sun burst forth from behind her, creating a powerful backlight that casts a dazzling golden edge across her entire form, from her flowing hair to every edge of her armor. In her hands, she clutched a slender, two-handed sword, its broad blade marked by a deep, blood-tinged groove. She engaged in a fluid and deadly sword dance, her body swirling steadily and gracefully in time with the blade's momentum, her crimson cape rustling behind her. Every slash and parry was imbued with power and rhythm. Beneath her feet lay a roiling sea of clouds, a surging white ocean. The distant skyline was dyed a brilliant gradient of orange, red, and purple. The entire scene was imbued with a sense of epic grandeur and aloof, cold heroism.", + "seed": 31676, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_15/index_1789_seed_31676_dp_30_rank_60_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.06459744209423661, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06459744209423661, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.775, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06459744209423661, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a low angle, moving forward and tilting slightly upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a woman wearing silver metal plate armor engraved with ancient runes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman performing a fluid sword dance with a two-handed sword that has a blood-tinged groove?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a roiling sea of clouds beneath a distant skyline with an orange, red, and purple gradient?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a powerful backlight from the rising sun creating a golden edge on the woman's hair and armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05700545012950897 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0570054054260254 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05700545012950897, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05700545012950897, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13408944010734558, + 0.051508840173482895, + 0.07433713972568512, + 0.10554949939250946, + 0.08531998842954636, + 0.034075040370225906, + 0.15063880383968353, + 0.22250038385391235, + 0.08187682181596756, + 0.06010402739048004 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05700545012950897 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a low angle, moving forward and tilting slightly upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a woman wearing silver metal plate armor engraved with ancient runes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman performing a fluid sword dance with a two-handed sword that has a blood-tinged groove?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a roiling sea of clouds beneath a distant skyline with an orange, red, and purple gradient?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a powerful backlight from the rising sun creating a golden edge on the woman's hair and armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10032056272029877 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.35032057762146 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10032056272029877, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10032056272029877, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1099039614200592, + 0.11067764461040497, + 0.10727310180664062, + 0.06719162315130234, + 0.07445662468671799, + 0.05428021401166916, + 0.2904500365257263, + 0.09417293220758438, + 0.062063440680503845, + 0.029530413448810577 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10032056272029877 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a low angle, moving forward and tilting slightly upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a woman wearing silver metal plate armor engraved with ancient runes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman performing a fluid sword dance with a two-handed sword that has a blood-tinged groove?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a roiling sea of clouds beneath a distant skyline with an orange, red, and purple gradient?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a powerful backlight from the rising sun creating a golden edge on the woman's hair and armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16036272048950195 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.910362720489502 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16036272048950195, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16036272048950195, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12454041838645935, + 0.15277989208698273, + 0.08773636817932129, + 0.1246095523238182, + 0.08709549158811569, + 0.03401600569486618, + 0.1995011866092682, + 0.07018887251615524, + 0.06084655597805977, + 0.05868569388985634 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16036272048950195 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a low angle, moving forward and tilting slightly upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a woman wearing silver metal plate armor engraved with ancient runes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman performing a fluid sword dance with a two-handed sword that has a blood-tinged groove?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a roiling sea of clouds beneath a distant skyline with an orange, red, and purple gradient?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a powerful backlight from the rising sun creating a golden edge on the woman's hair and armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00248540285974741 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002485275268555 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00248540285974741, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00248540285974741, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09933300316333771, + 0.023796960711479187, + 0.06585557758808136, + 0.025562569499015808, + 0.08361458778381348, + 0.021730415523052216, + 0.1270170658826828, + 0.4911005198955536, + 0.021137958392500877, + 0.040851328521966934 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00248540285974741 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a low angle, moving forward and tilting slightly upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a woman wearing silver metal plate armor engraved with ancient runes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman performing a fluid sword dance with a two-handed sword that has a blood-tinged groove?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a roiling sea of clouds beneath a distant skyline with an orange, red, and purple gradient?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a powerful backlight from the rising sun creating a golden edge on the woman's hair and armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0028130742721259594 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.87781286239624 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0028130742721259594, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0028130742721259594, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4511689841747284, + 0.046550579369068146, + 0.0266745463013649, + 0.08890949189662933, + 0.029985478147864342, + 0.028085047379136086, + 0.08306457847356796, + 0.05339508131146431, + 0.045025430619716644, + 0.1471407562494278 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0028130742721259594 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle shot, slowly moving forward and tilting slightly upward, focuses on a heroic woman atop a rugged, rocky mountaintop. Her long, black hair, tied high in a bun, dances wildly in the sharp mountain breeze, a few strands brushing against her stern, focused face. She clad in a meticulously crafted suit of silver metal plate armor, intricately engraved with ancient runes. The edges of the shoulder and breastplate, battle-worn from countless battles, reflect a cold, dazzling light in the rising sun. The first rays of dawn's sun burst forth from behind her, creating a powerful backlight that casts a dazzling golden edge across her entire form, from her flowing hair to every edge of her armor. In her hands, she clutched a slender, two-handed sword, its broad blade marked by a deep, blood-tinged groove. She engaged in a fluid and deadly sword dance, her body swirling steadily and gracefully in time with the blade's momentum, her crimson cape rustling behind her. Every slash and parry was imbued with power and rhythm. Beneath her feet lay a roiling sea of clouds, a surging white ocean. The distant skyline was dyed a brilliant gradient of orange, red, and purple. The entire scene was imbued with a sense of epic grandeur and aloof, cold heroism.", + "seed": 31677, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_15/index_1789_seed_31677_dp_31_rank_62_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.026225528377108277, + "vlm_logprob": -0.026225528377108277, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.375, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.026225528377108277, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a low angle, moving forward and tilting slightly upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a woman wearing silver metal plate armor engraved with ancient runes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman performing a fluid sword dance with a two-handed sword that has a blood-tinged groove?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a roiling sea of clouds beneath a distant skyline with an orange, red, and purple gradient?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a powerful backlight from the rising sun creating a golden edge on the woman's hair and armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0538378469645977 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.178837776184082 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0538378469645977, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0538378469645977, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09295013546943665, + 0.11345245689153671, + 0.037476107478141785, + 0.06335067749023438, + 0.03055010922253132, + 0.03132948651909828, + 0.24736009538173676, + 0.0993262529373169, + 0.06458596140146255, + 0.2196187674999237 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0538378469645977 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a low angle, moving forward and tilting slightly upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a woman wearing silver metal plate armor engraved with ancient runes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman performing a fluid sword dance with a two-handed sword that has a blood-tinged groove?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a roiling sea of clouds beneath a distant skyline with an orange, red, and purple gradient?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a powerful backlight from the rising sun creating a golden edge on the woman's hair and armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.048671357333660126 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048671245574951 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.048671357333660126, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.048671357333660126, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1495240479707718, + 0.18167316913604736, + 0.01214650645852089, + 0.10757902264595032, + 0.024802332744002342, + 0.029491553083062172, + 0.19120678305625916, + 0.06212250888347626, + 0.08805908262729645, + 0.15339498221874237 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.048671357333660126 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a low angle, moving forward and tilting slightly upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a woman wearing silver metal plate armor engraved with ancient runes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman performing a fluid sword dance with a two-handed sword that has a blood-tinged groove?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a roiling sea of clouds beneath a distant skyline with an orange, red, and purple gradient?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a powerful backlight from the rising sun creating a golden edge on the woman's hair and armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02329622581601143 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732961177825928 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02329622581601143, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02329622581601143, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07947338372468948, + 0.2799382209777832, + 0.046073295176029205, + 0.10152158886194229, + 0.043200407177209854, + 0.08638469874858856, + 0.16151605546474457, + 0.03916504606604576, + 0.0320863351225853, + 0.13064084947109222 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02329622581601143 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a low angle, moving forward and tilting slightly upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a woman wearing silver metal plate armor engraved with ancient runes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman performing a fluid sword dance with a two-handed sword that has a blood-tinged groove?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a roiling sea of clouds beneath a distant skyline with an orange, red, and purple gradient?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a powerful backlight from the rising sun creating a golden edge on the woman's hair and armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0017108578467741609 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.376710891723633 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0017108578467741609, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0017108578467741609, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15677697956562042, + 0.27586305141448975, + 0.025966588407754898, + 0.1175156831741333, + 0.029574118554592133, + 0.035767387598752975, + 0.07260486483573914, + 0.06031378358602524, + 0.05851367488503456, + 0.16710391640663147 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0017108578467741609 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a low angle, moving forward and tilting slightly upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a woman wearing silver metal plate armor engraved with ancient runes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman performing a fluid sword dance with a two-handed sword that has a blood-tinged groove?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a roiling sea of clouds beneath a distant skyline with an orange, red, and purple gradient?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a powerful backlight from the rising sun creating a golden edge on the woman's hair and armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003611353924497962 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.6286115646362305 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003611353924497962, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003611353924497962, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09568239003419876, + 0.17593149840831757, + 0.053626012057065964, + 0.13458403944969177, + 0.04780713468790054, + 0.059749357402324677, + 0.09593874216079712, + 0.06615246087312698, + 0.20286083221435547, + 0.06766755133867264 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003611353924497962 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle shot, slowly moving forward and tilting slightly upward, focuses on a heroic woman atop a rugged, rocky mountaintop. Her long, black hair, tied high in a bun, dances wildly in the sharp mountain breeze, a few strands brushing against her stern, focused face. She clad in a meticulously crafted suit of silver metal plate armor, intricately engraved with ancient runes. The edges of the shoulder and breastplate, battle-worn from countless battles, reflect a cold, dazzling light in the rising sun. The first rays of dawn's sun burst forth from behind her, creating a powerful backlight that casts a dazzling golden edge across her entire form, from her flowing hair to every edge of her armor. In her hands, she clutched a slender, two-handed sword, its broad blade marked by a deep, blood-tinged groove. She engaged in a fluid and deadly sword dance, her body swirling steadily and gracefully in time with the blade's momentum, her crimson cape rustling behind her. Every slash and parry was imbued with power and rhythm. Beneath her feet lay a roiling sea of clouds, a surging white ocean. The distant skyline was dyed a brilliant gradient of orange, red, and purple. The entire scene was imbued with a sense of epic grandeur and aloof, cold heroism.", + "seed": 31678, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_15/index_1789_seed_31678_dp_31_rank_62_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.06888452391140162, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06888452391140162, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.675, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06888452391140162, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a low angle, moving forward and tilting slightly upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a woman wearing silver metal plate armor engraved with ancient runes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman performing a fluid sword dance with a two-handed sword that has a blood-tinged groove?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a roiling sea of clouds beneath a distant skyline with an orange, red, and purple gradient?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a powerful backlight from the rising sun creating a golden edge on the woman's hair and armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0685051679611206 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.81850528717041 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0685051679611206, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0685051679611206, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04336928948760033, + 0.0904645174741745, + 0.07701271027326584, + 0.034575045108795166, + 0.030420245602726936, + 0.02758897840976715, + 0.025783810764551163, + 0.628277599811554, + 0.022894607856869698, + 0.019613154232501984 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0685051679611206 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a low angle, moving forward and tilting slightly upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a woman wearing silver metal plate armor engraved with ancient runes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman performing a fluid sword dance with a two-handed sword that has a blood-tinged groove?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a roiling sea of clouds beneath a distant skyline with an orange, red, and purple gradient?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a powerful backlight from the rising sun creating a golden edge on the woman's hair and armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14281368255615234 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0178136825561523 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14281368255615234, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14281368255615234, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07192444801330566, + 0.10029315948486328, + 0.03443119674921036, + 0.026316994801163673, + 0.015937531366944313, + 0.025633253157138824, + 0.022695038467645645, + 0.6696940064430237, + 0.020930802449584007, + 0.012143541127443314 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14281368255615234 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a low angle, moving forward and tilting slightly upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a woman wearing silver metal plate armor engraved with ancient runes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman performing a fluid sword dance with a two-handed sword that has a blood-tinged groove?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a roiling sea of clouds beneath a distant skyline with an orange, red, and purple gradient?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a powerful backlight from the rising sun creating a golden edge on the woman's hair and armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12707535922527313 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.127075433731079 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12707535922527313, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12707535922527313, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.032084330916404724, + 0.1173999086022377, + 0.05606341361999512, + 0.04980040341615677, + 0.018162548542022705, + 0.02086692862212658, + 0.02785923331975937, + 0.6382442712783813, + 0.029023529961705208, + 0.010495465248823166 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12707535922527313 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a low angle, moving forward and tilting slightly upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a woman wearing silver metal plate armor engraved with ancient runes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman performing a fluid sword dance with a two-handed sword that has a blood-tinged groove?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a roiling sea of clouds beneath a distant skyline with an orange, red, and purple gradient?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a powerful backlight from the rising sun creating a golden edge on the woman's hair and armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0019382515456527472 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.251938343048096 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0019382515456527472, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0019382515456527472, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1315544992685318, + 0.06139899417757988, + 0.20547586679458618, + 0.07117798924446106, + 0.1057450994849205, + 0.043873921036720276, + 0.07929772138595581, + 0.08682485669851303, + 0.11136450618505478, + 0.10328661650419235 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0019382515456527472 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a low angle, moving forward and tilting slightly upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a woman wearing silver metal plate armor engraved with ancient runes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman performing a fluid sword dance with a two-handed sword that has a blood-tinged groove?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a roiling sea of clouds beneath a distant skyline with an orange, red, and purple gradient?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a powerful backlight from the rising sun creating a golden edge on the woman's hair and armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0040901582688093185 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504090309143066 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0040901582688093185, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0040901582688093185, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06750471889972687, + 0.07242489606142044, + 0.041067689657211304, + 0.028958691284060478, + 0.03165552392601967, + 0.033795278519392014, + 0.03197287768125534, + 0.5922471880912781, + 0.05310731753706932, + 0.047265857458114624 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0040901582688093185 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_2/index_tensor([6995, 6995])_group_2_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_2/index_tensor([6995, 6995])_group_2_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..4e75a6840a962a262f2e821b124685f65c9447f5 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_2/index_tensor([6995, 6995])_group_2_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "static shot, captured from a medium close-up and slightly upward, focuses firmly on a Taoist priest standing in a dense, ancient forest, deep in the night. His long, jet-black hair hangs down behind his shoulders, his hair tied in a simple, wooden hairpin. His face is resolute, his brows slightly furrowed, and his gaze fixed sharply ahead. He wears a dark blue, coarse linen robe. The wide cuffs flutter in the night breeze, and the intricately embroidered eight-trigram pattern on the cuffs, inlaid with silver thread, is faintly visible in the dim light. His right hand, steady and firm, grips the hilt of an aged, crimson peachwood sword, the blade extended horizontally forward, engraved with intricate runes. Most strikingly, the sword's tip trembles not from hand tremor but rather with a high-pitched, subtle vibration, as if resonating with some unseen, sinister force emanating from the endless darkness ahead. Cold moonlight filtered through the intertwined, lifeless branches, casting eerie, mottled shadows on the leaf-strewn ground. Wisps of mist swirled around his feet. The only warm light came from the mahogany sword itself, emitting a faint, warm golden halo, illuminating his focused expression and the ancient patterns on the blade. The entire scene was gloomy, filled with tension, solemnity, and a sense of imminent confrontation, completely drawing the viewer's attention to the humming sword tip pointing into the unknown darkness.", + "seed": 28986, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_2/index_6995_seed_28986_dp_4_rank_8_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.054069480299949645, + "vlm_logprob": -0.054069480299949645, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.55, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.054069480299949645, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static medium close-up filmed from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character a Taoist priest wearing a dark blue coarse linen robe with wide cuffs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the priest holding an aged crimson peachwood sword with a horizontally extended blade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sword tip exhibit a high-pitched subtle vibration while the rest of the hand remains steady?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by cold moonlight and a faint warm golden halo emitting from the sword?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.025045618414878845 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.400045394897461 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.025045618414878845, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.025045618414878845, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.208307147026062, + 0.13788314163684845, + 0.08231848478317261, + 0.1464827060699463, + 0.07800612598657608, + 0.05759655684232712, + 0.0951201468706131, + 0.05481095612049103, + 0.08092999458312988, + 0.058544717729091644 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.025045618414878845 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static medium close-up filmed from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character a Taoist priest wearing a dark blue coarse linen robe with wide cuffs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the priest holding an aged crimson peachwood sword with a horizontally extended blade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sword tip exhibit a high-pitched subtle vibration while the rest of the hand remains steady?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by cold moonlight and a faint warm golden halo emitting from the sword?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.033725302666425705 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4087252616882324 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.033725302666425705, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.033725302666425705, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.26429590582847595, + 0.31736937165260315, + 0.05024690926074982, + 0.03270334750413895, + 0.09030743688344955, + 0.05632821097970009, + 0.05277226120233536, + 0.02871653065085411, + 0.04284016788005829, + 0.0644199401140213 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.033725302666425705 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static medium close-up filmed from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character a Taoist priest wearing a dark blue coarse linen robe with wide cuffs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the priest holding an aged crimson peachwood sword with a horizontally extended blade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sword tip exhibit a high-pitched subtle vibration while the rest of the hand remains steady?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by cold moonlight and a faint warm golden halo emitting from the sword?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020584993064403534 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895585060119629 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020584993064403534, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020584993064403534, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16265493631362915, + 0.12644989788532257, + 0.10566475242376328, + 0.06328579783439636, + 0.0851626992225647, + 0.0676700621843338, + 0.16123080253601074, + 0.06929747760295868, + 0.05344028025865555, + 0.10514324903488159 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020584993064403534 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static medium close-up filmed from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character a Taoist priest wearing a dark blue coarse linen robe with wide cuffs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the priest holding an aged crimson peachwood sword with a horizontally extended blade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sword tip exhibit a high-pitched subtle vibration while the rest of the hand remains steady?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by cold moonlight and a faint warm golden halo emitting from the sword?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1799173355102539 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.804917335510254 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1799173355102539, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1799173355102539, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16858752071857452, + 0.0774356871843338, + 0.05782608687877655, + 0.055621109902858734, + 0.03215378522872925, + 0.07418570667505264, + 0.12305361032485962, + 0.12473201006650925, + 0.09867047518491745, + 0.18773403763771057 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1799173355102539 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static medium close-up filmed from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character a Taoist priest wearing a dark blue coarse linen robe with wide cuffs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the priest holding an aged crimson peachwood sword with a horizontally extended blade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sword tip exhibit a high-pitched subtle vibration while the rest of the hand remains steady?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by cold moonlight and a faint warm golden halo emitting from the sword?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01107415184378624 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511074066162109 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01107415184378624, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01107415184378624, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1876029670238495, + 0.10854709148406982, + 0.09298405796289444, + 0.06195454299449921, + 0.11380667239427567, + 0.06525396555662155, + 0.1495339274406433, + 0.06413394957780838, + 0.08791996538639069, + 0.06826288253068924 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01107415184378624 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static shot, captured from a medium close-up and slightly upward, focuses firmly on a Taoist priest standing in a dense, ancient forest, deep in the night. His long, jet-black hair hangs down behind his shoulders, his hair tied in a simple, wooden hairpin. His face is resolute, his brows slightly furrowed, and his gaze fixed sharply ahead. He wears a dark blue, coarse linen robe. The wide cuffs flutter in the night breeze, and the intricately embroidered eight-trigram pattern on the cuffs, inlaid with silver thread, is faintly visible in the dim light. His right hand, steady and firm, grips the hilt of an aged, crimson peachwood sword, the blade extended horizontally forward, engraved with intricate runes. Most strikingly, the sword's tip trembles not from hand tremor but rather with a high-pitched, subtle vibration, as if resonating with some unseen, sinister force emanating from the endless darkness ahead. Cold moonlight filtered through the intertwined, lifeless branches, casting eerie, mottled shadows on the leaf-strewn ground. Wisps of mist swirled around his feet. The only warm light came from the mahogany sword itself, emitting a faint, warm golden halo, illuminating his focused expression and the ancient patterns on the blade. The entire scene was gloomy, filled with tension, solemnity, and a sense of imminent confrontation, completely drawing the viewer's attention to the humming sword tip pointing into the unknown darkness.", + "seed": 28987, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_2/index_6995_seed_28987_dp_4_rank_8_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.03765607587993145, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03765607587993145, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.55, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03765607587993145, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static medium close-up filmed from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character a Taoist priest wearing a dark blue coarse linen robe with wide cuffs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the priest holding an aged crimson peachwood sword with a horizontally extended blade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sword tip exhibit a high-pitched subtle vibration while the rest of the hand remains steady?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by cold moonlight and a faint warm golden halo emitting from the sword?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.030408503487706184 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6554086208343506 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.030408503487706184, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.030408503487706184, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07266206294298172, + 0.15283694863319397, + 0.3576427698135376, + 0.07975861430168152, + 0.034039970487356186, + 0.07519841194152832, + 0.0819568783044815, + 0.05871430039405823, + 0.060403116047382355, + 0.026786910369992256 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.030408503487706184 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static medium close-up filmed from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character a Taoist priest wearing a dark blue coarse linen robe with wide cuffs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the priest holding an aged crimson peachwood sword with a horizontally extended blade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sword tip exhibit a high-pitched subtle vibration while the rest of the hand remains steady?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by cold moonlight and a faint warm golden halo emitting from the sword?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018204979598522186 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018205165863037 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018204979598522186, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018204979598522186, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17101286351680756, + 0.0854109600186348, + 0.09291929751634598, + 0.05661347880959511, + 0.06394104659557343, + 0.041253961622714996, + 0.356436163187027, + 0.02459961734712124, + 0.05629592761397362, + 0.05151674151420593 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018204979598522186 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static medium close-up filmed from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character a Taoist priest wearing a dark blue coarse linen robe with wide cuffs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the priest holding an aged crimson peachwood sword with a horizontally extended blade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sword tip exhibit a high-pitched subtle vibration while the rest of the hand remains steady?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by cold moonlight and a faint warm golden halo emitting from the sword?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016063088551163673 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141063213348389 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016063088551163673, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016063088551163673, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.055566128343343735, + 0.13756035268306732, + 0.15521416068077087, + 0.026993080973625183, + 0.0573485791683197, + 0.09482231736183167, + 0.3700878918170929, + 0.029226163402199745, + 0.03986687585711479, + 0.03331444412469864 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016063088551163673 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static medium close-up filmed from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character a Taoist priest wearing a dark blue coarse linen robe with wide cuffs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the priest holding an aged crimson peachwood sword with a horizontally extended blade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sword tip exhibit a high-pitched subtle vibration while the rest of the hand remains steady?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by cold moonlight and a faint warm golden halo emitting from the sword?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10031981021165848 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3503198623657227 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10031981021165848, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10031981021165848, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0832824856042862, + 0.0646180734038353, + 0.07122886180877686, + 0.02222701907157898, + 0.03464693948626518, + 0.03832722082734108, + 0.48822274804115295, + 0.08510416746139526, + 0.07460397481918335, + 0.03773856908082962 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10031981021165848 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static medium close-up filmed from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character a Taoist priest wearing a dark blue coarse linen robe with wide cuffs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the priest holding an aged crimson peachwood sword with a horizontally extended blade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sword tip exhibit a high-pitched subtle vibration while the rest of the hand remains steady?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by cold moonlight and a faint warm golden halo emitting from the sword?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023283997550606728 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732839584350586 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023283997550606728, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023283997550606728, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15093441307544708, + 0.17752689123153687, + 0.07201168686151505, + 0.06644807755947113, + 0.0820668563246727, + 0.05879978463053703, + 0.2475845217704773, + 0.020304085686802864, + 0.08701068162918091, + 0.03731299936771393 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023283997550606728 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static shot, captured from a medium close-up and slightly upward, focuses firmly on a Taoist priest standing in a dense, ancient forest, deep in the night. His long, jet-black hair hangs down behind his shoulders, his hair tied in a simple, wooden hairpin. His face is resolute, his brows slightly furrowed, and his gaze fixed sharply ahead. He wears a dark blue, coarse linen robe. The wide cuffs flutter in the night breeze, and the intricately embroidered eight-trigram pattern on the cuffs, inlaid with silver thread, is faintly visible in the dim light. His right hand, steady and firm, grips the hilt of an aged, crimson peachwood sword, the blade extended horizontally forward, engraved with intricate runes. Most strikingly, the sword's tip trembles not from hand tremor but rather with a high-pitched, subtle vibration, as if resonating with some unseen, sinister force emanating from the endless darkness ahead. Cold moonlight filtered through the intertwined, lifeless branches, casting eerie, mottled shadows on the leaf-strewn ground. Wisps of mist swirled around his feet. The only warm light came from the mahogany sword itself, emitting a faint, warm golden halo, illuminating his focused expression and the ancient patterns on the blade. The entire scene was gloomy, filled with tension, solemnity, and a sense of imminent confrontation, completely drawing the viewer's attention to the humming sword tip pointing into the unknown darkness.", + "seed": 28988, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_2/index_6995_seed_28988_dp_5_rank_10_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.03261274266988039, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03261274266988039, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.875, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03261274266988039, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static medium close-up filmed from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character a Taoist priest wearing a dark blue coarse linen robe with wide cuffs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the priest holding an aged crimson peachwood sword with a horizontally extended blade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sword tip exhibit a high-pitched subtle vibration while the rest of the hand remains steady?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by cold moonlight and a faint warm golden halo emitting from the sword?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02128729782998562 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.146287441253662 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02128729782998562, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02128729782998562, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1627882719039917, + 0.05333184078335762, + 0.06248517706990242, + 0.050258927047252655, + 0.057713668793439865, + 0.12847626209259033, + 0.054962459951639175, + 0.08424627035856247, + 0.038520634174346924, + 0.3072165548801422 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02128729782998562 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static medium close-up filmed from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character a Taoist priest wearing a dark blue coarse linen robe with wide cuffs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the priest holding an aged crimson peachwood sword with a horizontally extended blade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sword tip exhibit a high-pitched subtle vibration while the rest of the hand remains steady?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by cold moonlight and a faint warm golden halo emitting from the sword?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020597022026777267 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895596981048584 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020597022026777267, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020597022026777267, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.29211705923080444, + 0.06775276362895966, + 0.04612814262509346, + 0.1018640398979187, + 0.03500218316912651, + 0.07332447171211243, + 0.03541601449251175, + 0.1802213042974472, + 0.09428183734416962, + 0.07389218360185623 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020597022026777267 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static medium close-up filmed from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character a Taoist priest wearing a dark blue coarse linen robe with wide cuffs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the priest holding an aged crimson peachwood sword with a horizontally extended blade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sword tip exhibit a high-pitched subtle vibration while the rest of the hand remains steady?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by cold moonlight and a faint warm golden halo emitting from the sword?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009781407192349434 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634781360626221 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009781407192349434, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009781407192349434, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11615247279405594, + 0.07326743751764297, + 0.02349025197327137, + 0.10063280165195465, + 0.026961272582411766, + 0.48402634263038635, + 0.017345335334539413, + 0.07246760278940201, + 0.05331391096115112, + 0.03234256058931351 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009781407192349434 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static medium close-up filmed from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character a Taoist priest wearing a dark blue coarse linen robe with wide cuffs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the priest holding an aged crimson peachwood sword with a horizontally extended blade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sword tip exhibit a high-pitched subtle vibration while the rest of the hand remains steady?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by cold moonlight and a faint warm golden halo emitting from the sword?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10032595694065094 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3503260612487793 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10032595694065094, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10032595694065094, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16614960134029388, + 0.06619354337453842, + 0.04966641589999199, + 0.03747446835041046, + 0.03688425570726395, + 0.19612327218055725, + 0.04835072159767151, + 0.07537385076284409, + 0.2104092538356781, + 0.11337462812662125 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10032595694065094 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static medium close-up filmed from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character a Taoist priest wearing a dark blue coarse linen robe with wide cuffs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the priest holding an aged crimson peachwood sword with a horizontally extended blade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sword tip exhibit a high-pitched subtle vibration while the rest of the hand remains steady?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by cold moonlight and a faint warm golden halo emitting from the sword?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011072029359638691 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511072158813477 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011072029359638691, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011072029359638691, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21060724556446075, + 0.1312866359949112, + 0.08999127894639969, + 0.05526360869407654, + 0.04605493322014809, + 0.09834630787372589, + 0.08483793586492538, + 0.1116449385881424, + 0.0694916844367981, + 0.10247540473937988 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011072029359638691 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static shot, captured from a medium close-up and slightly upward, focuses firmly on a Taoist priest standing in a dense, ancient forest, deep in the night. His long, jet-black hair hangs down behind his shoulders, his hair tied in a simple, wooden hairpin. His face is resolute, his brows slightly furrowed, and his gaze fixed sharply ahead. He wears a dark blue, coarse linen robe. The wide cuffs flutter in the night breeze, and the intricately embroidered eight-trigram pattern on the cuffs, inlaid with silver thread, is faintly visible in the dim light. His right hand, steady and firm, grips the hilt of an aged, crimson peachwood sword, the blade extended horizontally forward, engraved with intricate runes. Most strikingly, the sword's tip trembles not from hand tremor but rather with a high-pitched, subtle vibration, as if resonating with some unseen, sinister force emanating from the endless darkness ahead. Cold moonlight filtered through the intertwined, lifeless branches, casting eerie, mottled shadows on the leaf-strewn ground. Wisps of mist swirled around his feet. The only warm light came from the mahogany sword itself, emitting a faint, warm golden halo, illuminating his focused expression and the ancient patterns on the blade. The entire scene was gloomy, filled with tension, solemnity, and a sense of imminent confrontation, completely drawing the viewer's attention to the humming sword tip pointing into the unknown darkness.", + "seed": 28989, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_2/index_6995_seed_28989_dp_5_rank_10_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.0334237327799201, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0334237327799201, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.825, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0334237327799201, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static medium close-up filmed from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character a Taoist priest wearing a dark blue coarse linen robe with wide cuffs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the priest holding an aged crimson peachwood sword with a horizontally extended blade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sword tip exhibit a high-pitched subtle vibration while the rest of the hand remains steady?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by cold moonlight and a faint warm golden halo emitting from the sword?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.027883928269147873 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.777884006500244 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.027883928269147873, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.027883928269147873, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1927301585674286, + 0.08591419458389282, + 0.044808078557252884, + 0.12894108891487122, + 0.05371274799108505, + 0.0590398833155632, + 0.07727530598640442, + 0.07677440345287323, + 0.10378029942512512, + 0.17702384293079376 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.027883928269147873 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static medium close-up filmed from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character a Taoist priest wearing a dark blue coarse linen robe with wide cuffs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the priest holding an aged crimson peachwood sword with a horizontally extended blade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sword tip exhibit a high-pitched subtle vibration while the rest of the hand remains steady?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by cold moonlight and a faint warm golden halo emitting from the sword?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014212223701179028 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264212131500244 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014212223701179028, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014212223701179028, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21713854372501373, + 0.08212058246135712, + 0.05885933339595795, + 0.10460503399372101, + 0.03363555669784546, + 0.06354904174804688, + 0.05611441284418106, + 0.11271266639232635, + 0.21865086257457733, + 0.05261402204632759 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014212223701179028 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static medium close-up filmed from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character a Taoist priest wearing a dark blue coarse linen robe with wide cuffs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the priest holding an aged crimson peachwood sword with a horizontally extended blade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sword tip exhibit a high-pitched subtle vibration while the rest of the hand remains steady?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by cold moonlight and a faint warm golden halo emitting from the sword?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008637567982077599 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758637428283691 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008637567982077599, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008637567982077599, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04159369319677353, + 0.03630080074071884, + 0.04041581600904465, + 0.40144315361976624, + 0.02934994362294674, + 0.03771518915891647, + 0.03666239231824875, + 0.06284665316343307, + 0.17701290547847748, + 0.13665951788425446 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008637567982077599 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static medium close-up filmed from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character a Taoist priest wearing a dark blue coarse linen robe with wide cuffs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the priest holding an aged crimson peachwood sword with a horizontally extended blade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sword tip exhibit a high-pitched subtle vibration while the rest of the hand remains steady?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by cold moonlight and a faint warm golden halo emitting from the sword?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1003192737698555 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3503193855285645 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1003192737698555, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1003192737698555, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15271002054214478, + 0.05361149087548256, + 0.13575021922588348, + 0.2104073464870453, + 0.03215010464191437, + 0.04814114794135094, + 0.0663304552435875, + 0.03982018306851387, + 0.13291139900684357, + 0.12816762924194336 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1003192737698555 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static medium close-up filmed from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character a Taoist priest wearing a dark blue coarse linen robe with wide cuffs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the priest holding an aged crimson peachwood sword with a horizontally extended blade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sword tip exhibit a high-pitched subtle vibration while the rest of the hand remains steady?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by cold moonlight and a faint warm golden halo emitting from the sword?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016065670177340508 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.14106559753418 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016065670177340508, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016065670177340508, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1944732964038849, + 0.07036479562520981, + 0.09803371131420135, + 0.08603610098361969, + 0.04546063765883446, + 0.02474576234817505, + 0.047928158193826675, + 0.07214590907096863, + 0.1364775449037552, + 0.22433403134346008 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016065670177340508 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_3/index_tensor([4033, 4033])_group_3_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_3/index_tensor([4033, 4033])_group_3_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..1e2a4464c88201fff7b0a7c4022fee3f017a176c --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_3/index_tensor([4033, 4033])_group_3_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up, accompanied by violent camera shake, thrusts the viewer into a space engulfed by endless darkness. The sole illumination comes from a single, icy, glaring overhead light, sculpting a row of teeth of unsettling whiteness. Rather than being neatly arranged, these teeth interlock like broken daggers, their roots a sickly yellow, their gums a swollen, dark red. Without warning, the jaw snaps open in an anatomically unnatural manner, creating a bottomless, silent abyss. The muscles on either side of the jaw twitch frantically, as if engaged in a silent, all-consuming roar. The entire image, trembling with a constant throbbing, is filled with a primal, suffocating sense of terror, as if confronting a voiceless nightmare.", + "seed": 20684, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_3/index_4033_seed_20684_dp_6_rank_12_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.37156895026564596, + "vlm_logprob": -0.37156895026564596, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.175, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.37156895026564596, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as an extreme close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene engulfed by endless darkness with a single icy overhead light as the sole illumination?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the teeth arranged in an interlocking, broken pattern with sickly yellow roots and swollen dark red gums?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the jaw snap open in an anatomically unnatural manner to reveal a bottomless abyss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit violent shake and constant throbbing motion throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01701073721051216 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.517010688781738 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01701073721051216, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01701073721051216, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20228733122348785, + 0.2346264272928238, + 0.04959854483604431, + 0.09047191590070724, + 0.04372353106737137, + 0.1574334055185318, + 0.050233397632837296, + 0.04722066596150398, + 0.031383223831653595, + 0.09302162379026413 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01701073721051216 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as an extreme close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene engulfed by endless darkness with a single icy overhead light as the sole illumination?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the teeth arranged in an interlocking, broken pattern with sickly yellow roots and swollen dark red gums?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the jaw snap open in an anatomically unnatural manner to reveal a bottomless abyss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit violent shake and constant throbbing motion throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6005876064300537 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22558759152889252 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.6005876064300537, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -1.6005876064300537, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09501438587903976, + 0.09612677991390228, + 0.09382573515176773, + 0.07411401718854904, + 0.014429647475481033, + 0.08442424982786179, + 0.3252890110015869, + 0.041990865021944046, + 0.02664070390164852, + 0.1481446623802185 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.6005876064300537 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as an extreme close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene engulfed by endless darkness with a single icy overhead light as the sole illumination?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the teeth arranged in an interlocking, broken pattern with sickly yellow roots and swollen dark red gums?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the jaw snap open in an anatomically unnatural manner to reveal a bottomless abyss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit violent shake and constant throbbing motion throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04310210794210434 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1681020259857178 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04310210794210434, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04310210794210434, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.054257832467556, + 0.4288015067577362, + 0.07443764805793762, + 0.04091169685125351, + 0.02824581041932106, + 0.18129703402519226, + 0.07009764015674591, + 0.03313664719462395, + 0.015868086367845535, + 0.07294610142707825 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 5, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04310210794210434 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as an extreme close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene engulfed by endless darkness with a single icy overhead light as the sole illumination?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the teeth arranged in an interlocking, broken pattern with sickly yellow roots and swollen dark red gums?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the jaw snap open in an anatomically unnatural manner to reveal a bottomless abyss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit violent shake and constant throbbing motion throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07005193829536438 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695051908493042 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07005193829536438, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07005193829536438, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05413488671183586, + 0.20301267504692078, + 0.09116572141647339, + 0.06610383838415146, + 0.019115081056952477, + 0.10776699334383011, + 0.2064584493637085, + 0.08981356769800186, + 0.027259070426225662, + 0.13516974449157715 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07005193829536438 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as an extreme close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene engulfed by endless darkness with a single icy overhead light as the sole illumination?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the teeth arranged in an interlocking, broken pattern with sickly yellow roots and swollen dark red gums?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the jaw snap open in an anatomically unnatural manner to reveal a bottomless abyss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit violent shake and constant throbbing motion throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1270923614501953 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1270923614501953 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1270923614501953, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1270923614501953, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0878399983048439, + 0.10171746462583542, + 0.04147172346711159, + 0.05990293249487877, + 0.09600147604942322, + 0.1202649176120758, + 0.2034354954957962, + 0.07895324379205704, + 0.09422653168439865, + 0.11618620157241821 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1270923614501953 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up, accompanied by violent camera shake, thrusts the viewer into a space engulfed by endless darkness. The sole illumination comes from a single, icy, glaring overhead light, sculpting a row of teeth of unsettling whiteness. Rather than being neatly arranged, these teeth interlock like broken daggers, their roots a sickly yellow, their gums a swollen, dark red. Without warning, the jaw snaps open in an anatomically unnatural manner, creating a bottomless, silent abyss. The muscles on either side of the jaw twitch frantically, as if engaged in a silent, all-consuming roar. The entire image, trembling with a constant throbbing, is filled with a primal, suffocating sense of terror, as if confronting a voiceless nightmare.", + "seed": 20685, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_3/index_4033_seed_20685_dp_6_rank_12_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.1373088862746954, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1373088862746954, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.625, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1373088862746954, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as an extreme close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene engulfed by endless darkness with a single icy overhead light as the sole illumination?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the teeth arranged in an interlocking, broken pattern with sickly yellow roots and swollen dark red gums?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the jaw snap open in an anatomically unnatural manner to reveal a bottomless abyss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit violent shake and constant throbbing motion throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.019427144899964333 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.269427299499512 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.019427144899964333, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.019427144899964333, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1387476772069931, + 0.34699422121047974, + 0.05781707912683487, + 0.12289128452539444, + 0.024535322561860085, + 0.021246539428830147, + 0.01585828699171543, + 0.01618724688887596, + 0.011124289594590664, + 0.24459801614284515 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.019427144899964333 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as an extreme close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene engulfed by endless darkness with a single icy overhead light as the sole illumination?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the teeth arranged in an interlocking, broken pattern with sickly yellow roots and swollen dark red gums?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the jaw snap open in an anatomically unnatural manner to reveal a bottomless abyss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit violent shake and constant throbbing motion throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.47432589530944824 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9743258953094482 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.47432589530944824, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.47432589530944824, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19387465715408325, + 0.20061485469341278, + 0.07402744144201279, + 0.10862193256616592, + 0.0669940784573555, + 0.09148187935352325, + 0.01791612058877945, + 0.07908295094966888, + 0.02903890796005726, + 0.13834719359874725 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.47432589530944824 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as an extreme close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene engulfed by endless darkness with a single icy overhead light as the sole illumination?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the teeth arranged in an interlocking, broken pattern with sickly yellow roots and swollen dark red gums?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the jaw snap open in an anatomically unnatural manner to reveal a bottomless abyss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit violent shake and constant throbbing motion throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03371677175164223 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4087166786193848 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03371677175164223, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03371677175164223, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.040843360126018524, + 0.2133738398551941, + 0.09309765696525574, + 0.10467410832643509, + 0.07587844133377075, + 0.04457514360547066, + 0.01751285418868065, + 0.16681896150112152, + 0.03124278411269188, + 0.21198290586471558 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03371677175164223 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as an extreme close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene engulfed by endless darkness with a single icy overhead light as the sole illumination?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the teeth arranged in an interlocking, broken pattern with sickly yellow roots and swollen dark red gums?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the jaw snap open in an anatomically unnatural manner to reveal a bottomless abyss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit violent shake and constant throbbing motion throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07002370804548264 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695023775100708 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07002370804548264, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07002370804548264, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03275960683822632, + 0.09325968474149704, + 0.09426534175872803, + 0.08171118050813675, + 0.11110053211450577, + 0.04865596815943718, + 0.03431621193885803, + 0.04069444537162781, + 0.030489396303892136, + 0.43274763226509094 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07002370804548264 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as an extreme close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene engulfed by endless darkness with a single icy overhead light as the sole illumination?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the teeth arranged in an interlocking, broken pattern with sickly yellow roots and swollen dark red gums?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the jaw snap open in an anatomically unnatural manner to reveal a bottomless abyss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit violent shake and constant throbbing motion throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08905091136693954 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4640510082244873 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08905091136693954, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08905091136693954, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07709229737520218, + 0.14587952196598053, + 0.08947031199932098, + 0.06284142285585403, + 0.050128549337387085, + 0.028140973299741745, + 0.01347891055047512, + 0.039088908582925797, + 0.012790470384061337, + 0.4810887277126312 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08905091136693954 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up, accompanied by violent camera shake, thrusts the viewer into a space engulfed by endless darkness. The sole illumination comes from a single, icy, glaring overhead light, sculpting a row of teeth of unsettling whiteness. Rather than being neatly arranged, these teeth interlock like broken daggers, their roots a sickly yellow, their gums a swollen, dark red. Without warning, the jaw snaps open in an anatomically unnatural manner, creating a bottomless, silent abyss. The muscles on either side of the jaw twitch frantically, as if engaged in a silent, all-consuming roar. The entire image, trembling with a constant throbbing, is filled with a primal, suffocating sense of terror, as if confronting a voiceless nightmare.", + "seed": 20686, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_3/index_4033_seed_20686_dp_7_rank_14_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.3414571875706315, + "vlm_logprob": -0.3414571875706315, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.4, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.3414571875706315, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as an extreme close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene engulfed by endless darkness with a single icy overhead light as the sole illumination?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the teeth arranged in an interlocking, broken pattern with sickly yellow roots and swollen dark red gums?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the jaw snap open in an anatomically unnatural manner to reveal a bottomless abyss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit violent shake and constant throbbing motion throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00956228468567133 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.2595624923706055 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00956228468567133, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00956228468567133, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18354108929634094, + 0.11090651899576187, + 0.05777803435921669, + 0.12144694477319717, + 0.10356426239013672, + 0.07100161910057068, + 0.13310541212558746, + 0.05941808596253395, + 0.11101368069648743, + 0.048224303871393204 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00956228468567133 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as an extreme close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene engulfed by endless darkness with a single icy overhead light as the sole illumination?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the teeth arranged in an interlocking, broken pattern with sickly yellow roots and swollen dark red gums?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the jaw snap open in an anatomically unnatural manner to reveal a bottomless abyss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit violent shake and constant throbbing motion throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3134486675262451 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3134486675262451 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.3134486675262451, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -1.3134486675262451, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1689632087945938, + 0.0707358792424202, + 0.1554427593946457, + 0.24934732913970947, + 0.08946577459573746, + 0.04484431445598602, + 0.05410831421613693, + 0.05809124931693077, + 0.06481224298477173, + 0.04418887943029404 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.3134486675262451 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as an extreme close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene engulfed by endless darkness with a single icy overhead light as the sole illumination?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the teeth arranged in an interlocking, broken pattern with sickly yellow roots and swollen dark red gums?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the jaw snap open in an anatomically unnatural manner to reveal a bottomless abyss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit violent shake and constant throbbing motion throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04309308901429176 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168093204498291 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04309308901429176, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04309308901429176, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10453550517559052, + 0.05488578602671623, + 0.3780389428138733, + 0.08213905245065689, + 0.05154675245285034, + 0.06001782417297363, + 0.14212866127490997, + 0.059159055352211, + 0.044618528336286545, + 0.0229298397898674 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04309308901429176 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as an extreme close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene engulfed by endless darkness with a single icy overhead light as the sole illumination?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the teeth arranged in an interlocking, broken pattern with sickly yellow roots and swollen dark red gums?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the jaw snap open in an anatomically unnatural manner to reveal a bottomless abyss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit violent shake and constant throbbing motion throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08905255049467087 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.464052438735962 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08905255049467087, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08905255049467087, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09545068442821503, + 0.049415480345487595, + 0.11294721812009811, + 0.07278566807508469, + 0.1051754355430603, + 0.047216035425662994, + 0.19749018549919128, + 0.0647793635725975, + 0.23374395072460175, + 0.020996004343032837 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08905255049467087 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as an extreme close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene engulfed by endless darkness with a single icy overhead light as the sole illumination?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the teeth arranged in an interlocking, broken pattern with sickly yellow roots and swollen dark red gums?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the jaw snap open in an anatomically unnatural manner to reveal a bottomless abyss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit violent shake and constant throbbing motion throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.25212934613227844 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.502129316329956 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.25212934613227844, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.25212934613227844, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11804285645484924, + 0.07476307451725006, + 0.06756974756717682, + 0.1510162502527237, + 0.18716268241405487, + 0.10752394795417786, + 0.0821097120642662, + 0.12233022600412369, + 0.04421206936240196, + 0.04526938498020172 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.25212934613227844 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up, accompanied by violent camera shake, thrusts the viewer into a space engulfed by endless darkness. The sole illumination comes from a single, icy, glaring overhead light, sculpting a row of teeth of unsettling whiteness. Rather than being neatly arranged, these teeth interlock like broken daggers, their roots a sickly yellow, their gums a swollen, dark red. Without warning, the jaw snaps open in an anatomically unnatural manner, creating a bottomless, silent abyss. The muscles on either side of the jaw twitch frantically, as if engaged in a silent, all-consuming roar. The entire image, trembling with a constant throbbing, is filled with a primal, suffocating sense of terror, as if confronting a voiceless nightmare.", + "seed": 20687, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_3/index_4033_seed_20687_dp_7_rank_14_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.2189846456050873, + "vlm_logprob": -0.2189846456050873, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.7249999761581423, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.2189846456050873, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as an extreme close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene engulfed by endless darkness with a single icy overhead light as the sole illumination?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the teeth arranged in an interlocking, broken pattern with sickly yellow roots and swollen dark red gums?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the jaw snap open in an anatomically unnatural manner to reveal a bottomless abyss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit violent shake and constant throbbing motion throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.010815335437655449 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.885815143585205 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.010815335437655449, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.010815335437655449, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.26713988184928894, + 0.26971638202667236, + 0.0761462077498436, + 0.06891000270843506, + 0.09244154393672943, + 0.11759940534830093, + 0.02823174186050892, + 0.029168015345931053, + 0.02318749390542507, + 0.02745932526886463 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.010815335437655449 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as an extreme close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene engulfed by endless darkness with a single icy overhead light as the sole illumination?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the teeth arranged in an interlocking, broken pattern with sickly yellow roots and swollen dark red gums?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the jaw snap open in an anatomically unnatural manner to reveal a bottomless abyss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit violent shake and constant throbbing motion throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8983525633811951 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5233525633811951 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.8983525633811951, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.8983525633811951, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16317778825759888, + 0.0826186016201973, + 0.22815734148025513, + 0.08750065416097641, + 0.09396661072969437, + 0.10312490910291672, + 0.05165821686387062, + 0.09612251818180084, + 0.045903827995061874, + 0.047769561409950256 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.8983525633811951 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as an extreme close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene engulfed by endless darkness with a single icy overhead light as the sole illumination?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the teeth arranged in an interlocking, broken pattern with sickly yellow roots and swollen dark red gums?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the jaw snap open in an anatomically unnatural manner to reveal a bottomless abyss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit violent shake and constant throbbing motion throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020597605034708977 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955976963043213 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020597605034708977, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020597605034708977, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.099699005484581, + 0.20883281528949738, + 0.04260017350316048, + 0.0945025309920311, + 0.21866275370121002, + 0.15691985189914703, + 0.031093211844563484, + 0.056823648512363434, + 0.02967740036547184, + 0.06118862330913544 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020597605034708977 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as an extreme close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene engulfed by endless darkness with a single icy overhead light as the sole illumination?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the teeth arranged in an interlocking, broken pattern with sickly yellow roots and swollen dark red gums?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the jaw snap open in an anatomically unnatural manner to reveal a bottomless abyss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit violent shake and constant throbbing motion throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.038102004677057266 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881019115448 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.038102004677057266, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.038102004677057266, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09915821999311447, + 0.19397735595703125, + 0.1070716381072998, + 0.07019120454788208, + 0.10067597776651382, + 0.07137726247310638, + 0.05892488360404968, + 0.07347265630960464, + 0.1252761036157608, + 0.09987465292215347 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.038102004677057266 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as an extreme close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene engulfed by endless darkness with a single icy overhead light as the sole illumination?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the teeth arranged in an interlocking, broken pattern with sickly yellow roots and swollen dark red gums?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the jaw snap open in an anatomically unnatural manner to reveal a bottomless abyss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit violent shake and constant throbbing motion throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12705571949481964 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1270556449890137 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12705571949481964, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.9999998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12705571949481964, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15492656826972961, + 0.08049275726079941, + 0.07199152559041977, + 0.13048864901065826, + 0.305850625038147, + 0.06866990774869919, + 0.037816133350133896, + 0.06619812548160553, + 0.050658680498600006, + 0.03290710598230362 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12705571949481964 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_4/index_tensor([4707, 4707])_group_4_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_4/index_tensor([4707, 4707])_group_4_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..c8a549e7f32ed005018ca4d539d93bdf98ea50ec --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_4/index_tensor([4707, 4707])_group_4_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "static, perfectly composed wide-angle shot captures a vibrant moment of tranquility after a brief rain shower. The scene is rendered in a modern illustrative style characterized by clean lines and a bold, graphic color palette. A bright, fully formed rainbow dominates the upper frame, its luminous arc of saturated reds, oranges, yellows, greens, blues, and violets carving a clean path across a clear sky of pale blue and soft, retreating clouds. The rainbow's curves perfectly outline the dense, painted bamboo forest below, its thick, glossy yellow stalks patterned with elegant, vertical green streaks that feel like deliberate, stylized brushstrokes. The ground below is a flat surface, its dark, damp soil shimmering with recent rainfall, while the bamboo's feathery leaves are shimmering with water droplets. The crisp, clean sunlight makes every color pop with graphic intensity, and the fixed camera remains steady, creating an atmosphere of pristine, serene beauty and preserving the perfect and colorful composition.", + "seed": 7734, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_4/index_4707_seed_7734_dp_8_rank_16_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.14716057181358339, + "vlm_logprob": -0.14716057181358339, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.1, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.14716057181358339, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a modern illustrative style with clean lines and a bold, graphic color palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a bright, fully formed rainbow visible in the upper frame with saturated red, orange, yellow, green, blue, and violet colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a dense bamboo forest visible below the rainbow with thick, glossy yellow stalks patterned with vertical green streaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the ground depicted as a flat surface of dark, damp soil shimmering with recent rainfall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera fixed and steady throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.010964502580463886 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.635964393615723 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.010964502580463886, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.010964502580463886, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0428110808134079, + 0.035132646560668945, + 0.7595289945602417, + 0.01613011583685875, + 0.027056662365794182, + 0.054294295608997345, + 0.04565288871526718, + 0.0058172293938696384, + 0.006198071874678135, + 0.007377965841442347 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.010964502580463886 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a modern illustrative style with clean lines and a bold, graphic color palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a bright, fully formed rainbow visible in the upper frame with saturated red, orange, yellow, green, blue, and violet colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a dense bamboo forest visible below the rainbow with thick, glossy yellow stalks patterned with vertical green streaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the ground depicted as a flat surface of dark, damp soil shimmering with recent rainfall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera fixed and steady throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004658441059291363 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379658222198486 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004658441059291363, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004658441059291363, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.026690742000937462, + 0.030747588723897934, + 0.830953061580658, + 0.01325722225010395, + 0.03200816363096237, + 0.03045530430972576, + 0.022614432498812675, + 0.004025032743811607, + 0.005705320741981268, + 0.00354319647885859 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004658441059291363 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a modern illustrative style with clean lines and a bold, graphic color palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a bright, fully formed rainbow visible in the upper frame with saturated red, orange, yellow, green, blue, and violet colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a dense bamboo forest visible below the rainbow with thick, glossy yellow stalks patterned with vertical green streaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the ground depicted as a flat surface of dark, damp soil shimmering with recent rainfall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera fixed and steady throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05495666712522507 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299566745758057 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05495666712522507, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05495666712522507, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.045498233288526535, + 0.04836112633347511, + 0.6365582346916199, + 0.01556788757443428, + 0.1370064616203308, + 0.045046452432870865, + 0.03814581409096718, + 0.01376496721059084, + 0.01088416576385498, + 0.009166632778942585 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05495666712522507 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a modern illustrative style with clean lines and a bold, graphic color palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a bright, fully formed rainbow visible in the upper frame with saturated red, orange, yellow, green, blue, and violet colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a dense bamboo forest visible below the rainbow with thick, glossy yellow stalks patterned with vertical green streaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the ground depicted as a flat surface of dark, damp soil shimmering with recent rainfall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera fixed and steady throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5761798620223999 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8261798620223999 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5761798620223999, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5761798620223999, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22160755097866058, + 0.05656927451491356, + 0.10281966626644135, + 0.07952249050140381, + 0.1516491025686264, + 0.1441582590341568, + 0.13054145872592926, + 0.030674565583467484, + 0.04817205294966698, + 0.03428560122847557 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5761798620223999 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a modern illustrative style with clean lines and a bold, graphic color palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a bright, fully formed rainbow visible in the upper frame with saturated red, orange, yellow, green, blue, and violet colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a dense bamboo forest visible below the rainbow with thick, glossy yellow stalks patterned with vertical green streaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the ground depicted as a flat surface of dark, damp soil shimmering with recent rainfall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera fixed and steady throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08904338628053665 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.464043378829956 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08904338628053665, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08904338628053665, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.013986111618578434, + 0.06077665835618973, + 0.8930169343948364, + 0.004792317282408476, + 0.015208808705210686, + 0.0034100650809705257, + 0.0016010182444006205, + 0.0022587948478758335, + 0.003022033255547285, + 0.0019271747441962361 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08904338628053665 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, perfectly composed wide-angle shot captures a vibrant moment of tranquility after a brief rain shower. The scene is rendered in a modern illustrative style characterized by clean lines and a bold, graphic color palette. A bright, fully formed rainbow dominates the upper frame, its luminous arc of saturated reds, oranges, yellows, greens, blues, and violets carving a clean path across a clear sky of pale blue and soft, retreating clouds. The rainbow's curves perfectly outline the dense, painted bamboo forest below, its thick, glossy yellow stalks patterned with elegant, vertical green streaks that feel like deliberate, stylized brushstrokes. The ground below is a flat surface, its dark, damp soil shimmering with recent rainfall, while the bamboo's feathery leaves are shimmering with water droplets. The crisp, clean sunlight makes every color pop with graphic intensity, and the fixed camera remains steady, creating an atmosphere of pristine, serene beauty and preserving the perfect and colorful composition.", + "seed": 7735, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_4/index_4707_seed_7735_dp_8_rank_16_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.11302330694161355, + "vlm_logprob": -0.11302330694161355, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.075, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.11302330694161355, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a modern illustrative style with clean lines and a bold, graphic color palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a bright, fully formed rainbow visible in the upper frame with saturated red, orange, yellow, green, blue, and violet colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a dense bamboo forest visible below the rainbow with thick, glossy yellow stalks patterned with vertical green streaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the ground depicted as a flat surface of dark, damp soil shimmering with recent rainfall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera fixed and steady throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0061564091593027115 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.3811564445495605 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0061564091593027115, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0061564091593027115, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22273634374141693, + 0.07766947895288467, + 0.14637164771556854, + 0.09926589578390121, + 0.0603487454354763, + 0.16846439242362976, + 0.043193381279706955, + 0.06655609607696533, + 0.07690387964248657, + 0.038490138947963715 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0061564091593027115 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a modern illustrative style with clean lines and a bold, graphic color palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a bright, fully formed rainbow visible in the upper frame with saturated red, orange, yellow, green, blue, and violet colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a dense bamboo forest visible below the rainbow with thick, glossy yellow stalks patterned with vertical green streaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the ground depicted as a flat surface of dark, damp soil shimmering with recent rainfall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera fixed and steady throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0025057366583496332 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002505779266357 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0025057366583496332, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0025057366583496332, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16413183510303497, + 0.0673932209610939, + 0.11665935069322586, + 0.09398455917835236, + 0.07862398028373718, + 0.1859995275735855, + 0.08943630754947662, + 0.06709069013595581, + 0.038724131882190704, + 0.09795641899108887 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0025057366583496332 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a modern illustrative style with clean lines and a bold, graphic color palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a bright, fully formed rainbow visible in the upper frame with saturated red, orange, yellow, green, blue, and violet colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a dense bamboo forest visible below the rainbow with thick, glossy yellow stalks patterned with vertical green streaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the ground depicted as a flat surface of dark, damp soil shimmering with recent rainfall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera fixed and steady throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006738083902746439 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006738185882568 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006738083902746439, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006738083902746439, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2239474058151245, + 0.07000362873077393, + 0.08681480586528778, + 0.05218729376792908, + 0.09497089684009552, + 0.19250239431858063, + 0.1196063682436943, + 0.09234359860420227, + 0.033325616270303726, + 0.03429803252220154 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006738083902746439 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a modern illustrative style with clean lines and a bold, graphic color palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a bright, fully formed rainbow visible in the upper frame with saturated red, orange, yellow, green, blue, and violet colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a dense bamboo forest visible below the rainbow with thick, glossy yellow stalks patterned with vertical green streaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the ground depicted as a flat surface of dark, damp soil shimmering with recent rainfall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera fixed and steady throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5233709216117859 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8983709216117859 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5233709216117859, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5233709216117859, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2264830470085144, + 0.11800804734230042, + 0.07482215017080307, + 0.0842907503247261, + 0.07557513564825058, + 0.14874422550201416, + 0.16064204275608063, + 0.03036295808851719, + 0.029336892068386078, + 0.05173470079898834 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5233709216117859 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a modern illustrative style with clean lines and a bold, graphic color palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a bright, fully formed rainbow visible in the upper frame with saturated red, orange, yellow, green, blue, and violet colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a dense bamboo forest visible below the rainbow with thick, glossy yellow stalks patterned with vertical green streaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the ground depicted as a flat surface of dark, damp soil shimmering with recent rainfall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera fixed and steady throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026345383375883102 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513454914093018 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026345383375883102, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026345383375883102, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13130949437618256, + 0.08683663606643677, + 0.31116169691085815, + 0.08207032829523087, + 0.06712912023067474, + 0.10896305739879608, + 0.04241740331053734, + 0.021790433675050735, + 0.04658888652920723, + 0.10173290967941284 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026345383375883102 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, perfectly composed wide-angle shot captures a vibrant moment of tranquility after a brief rain shower. The scene is rendered in a modern illustrative style characterized by clean lines and a bold, graphic color palette. A bright, fully formed rainbow dominates the upper frame, its luminous arc of saturated reds, oranges, yellows, greens, blues, and violets carving a clean path across a clear sky of pale blue and soft, retreating clouds. The rainbow's curves perfectly outline the dense, painted bamboo forest below, its thick, glossy yellow stalks patterned with elegant, vertical green streaks that feel like deliberate, stylized brushstrokes. The ground below is a flat surface, its dark, damp soil shimmering with recent rainfall, while the bamboo's feathery leaves are shimmering with water droplets. The crisp, clean sunlight makes every color pop with graphic intensity, and the fixed camera remains steady, creating an atmosphere of pristine, serene beauty and preserving the perfect and colorful composition.", + "seed": 7736, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_4/index_4707_seed_7736_dp_9_rank_18_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.12627578102983533, + "vlm_logprob": -0.12627578102983533, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.95, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.12627578102983533, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a modern illustrative style with clean lines and a bold, graphic color palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a bright, fully formed rainbow visible in the upper frame with saturated red, orange, yellow, green, blue, and violet colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a dense bamboo forest visible below the rainbow with thick, glossy yellow stalks patterned with vertical green streaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the ground depicted as a flat surface of dark, damp soil shimmering with recent rainfall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera fixed and steady throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.010964266024529934 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.635964393615723 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.010964266024529934, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.010964266024529934, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23931878805160522, + 0.05759201943874359, + 0.12149643898010254, + 0.15497584640979767, + 0.0400933213531971, + 0.05016673728823662, + 0.14182047545909882, + 0.0243828184902668, + 0.028245601803064346, + 0.14190788567066193 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.010964266024529934 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a modern illustrative style with clean lines and a bold, graphic color palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a bright, fully formed rainbow visible in the upper frame with saturated red, orange, yellow, green, blue, and violet colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a dense bamboo forest visible below the rainbow with thick, glossy yellow stalks patterned with vertical green streaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the ground depicted as a flat surface of dark, damp soil shimmering with recent rainfall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera fixed and steady throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0025038341991603374 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002503871917725 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0025038341991603374, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0025038341991603374, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.056286223232746124, + 0.0786711797118187, + 0.06406518816947937, + 0.16053713858127594, + 0.05341692268848419, + 0.02701154537498951, + 0.23592416942119598, + 0.027358172461390495, + 0.032151173800230026, + 0.264578253030777 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0025038341991603374 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a modern illustrative style with clean lines and a bold, graphic color palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a bright, fully formed rainbow visible in the upper frame with saturated red, orange, yellow, green, blue, and violet colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a dense bamboo forest visible below the rainbow with thick, glossy yellow stalks patterned with vertical green streaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the ground depicted as a flat surface of dark, damp soil shimmering with recent rainfall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera fixed and steady throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00362038123421371 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628620147705078 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00362038123421371, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00362038123421371, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25271371006965637, + 0.06685329973697662, + 0.09591159969568253, + 0.09283335506916046, + 0.11344271153211594, + 0.020489227026700974, + 0.23400570452213287, + 0.03218739479780197, + 0.0340142659842968, + 0.057548731565475464 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00362038123421371 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a modern illustrative style with clean lines and a bold, graphic color palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a bright, fully formed rainbow visible in the upper frame with saturated red, orange, yellow, green, blue, and violet colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a dense bamboo forest visible below the rainbow with thick, glossy yellow stalks patterned with vertical green streaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the ground depicted as a flat surface of dark, damp soil shimmering with recent rainfall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera fixed and steady throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5761862397193909 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8261862397193909 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5761862397193909, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5761862397193909, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23688940703868866, + 0.12021913379430771, + 0.0563315786421299, + 0.06696499139070511, + 0.21108821034431458, + 0.10812537372112274, + 0.03759795054793358, + 0.024294303730130196, + 0.021180782467126846, + 0.11730829626321793 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5761862397193909 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a modern illustrative style with clean lines and a bold, graphic color palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a bright, fully formed rainbow visible in the upper frame with saturated red, orange, yellow, green, blue, and violet colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a dense bamboo forest visible below the rainbow with thick, glossy yellow stalks patterned with vertical green streaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the ground depicted as a flat surface of dark, damp soil shimmering with recent rainfall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera fixed and steady throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.038104183971881866 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288104295730591 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.038104183971881866, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.038104183971881866, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1782824546098709, + 0.021454937756061554, + 0.03187846764922142, + 0.16858063638210297, + 0.09117713570594788, + 0.058237116783857346, + 0.17936912178993225, + 0.020993473008275032, + 0.02131965383887291, + 0.22870706021785736 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.038104183971881866 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, perfectly composed wide-angle shot captures a vibrant moment of tranquility after a brief rain shower. The scene is rendered in a modern illustrative style characterized by clean lines and a bold, graphic color palette. A bright, fully formed rainbow dominates the upper frame, its luminous arc of saturated reds, oranges, yellows, greens, blues, and violets carving a clean path across a clear sky of pale blue and soft, retreating clouds. The rainbow's curves perfectly outline the dense, painted bamboo forest below, its thick, glossy yellow stalks patterned with elegant, vertical green streaks that feel like deliberate, stylized brushstrokes. The ground below is a flat surface, its dark, damp soil shimmering with recent rainfall, while the bamboo's feathery leaves are shimmering with water droplets. The crisp, clean sunlight makes every color pop with graphic intensity, and the fixed camera remains steady, creating an atmosphere of pristine, serene beauty and preserving the perfect and colorful composition.", + "seed": 7737, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_4/index_4707_seed_7737_dp_9_rank_18_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.12001817524433137, + "vlm_logprob": -0.12001817524433137, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.9499999940395356, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.12001817524433137, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a modern illustrative style with clean lines and a bold, graphic color palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a bright, fully formed rainbow visible in the upper frame with saturated red, orange, yellow, green, blue, and violet colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a dense bamboo forest visible below the rainbow with thick, glossy yellow stalks patterned with vertical green streaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the ground depicted as a flat surface of dark, damp soil shimmering with recent rainfall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera fixed and steady throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018901238217949867 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018901348114014 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018901238217949867, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018901238217949867, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3327045440673828, + 0.2097432166337967, + 0.08941096812486649, + 0.02682945691049099, + 0.03982426971197128, + 0.046305011957883835, + 0.03062334656715393, + 0.0695558711886406, + 0.059059590101242065, + 0.09594371169805527 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018901238217949867 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a modern illustrative style with clean lines and a bold, graphic color palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a bright, fully formed rainbow visible in the upper frame with saturated red, orange, yellow, green, blue, and violet colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a dense bamboo forest visible below the rainbow with thick, glossy yellow stalks patterned with vertical green streaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the ground depicted as a flat surface of dark, damp soil shimmering with recent rainfall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera fixed and steady throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018211184069514275 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018211364746094 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018211184069514275, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018211184069514275, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16259397566318512, + 0.16565166413784027, + 0.14363352954387665, + 0.056449875235557556, + 0.055731210857629776, + 0.04865243285894394, + 0.10282406210899353, + 0.10790951550006866, + 0.12262021005153656, + 0.03393351286649704 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018211184069514275 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a modern illustrative style with clean lines and a bold, graphic color palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a bright, fully formed rainbow visible in the upper frame with saturated red, orange, yellow, green, blue, and violet colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a dense bamboo forest visible below the rainbow with thick, glossy yellow stalks patterned with vertical green streaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the ground depicted as a flat surface of dark, damp soil shimmering with recent rainfall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera fixed and steady throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03370363265275955 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408703565597534 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03370363265275955, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03370363265275955, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1702125072479248, + 0.12423180788755417, + 0.08343153446912766, + 0.08049452304840088, + 0.05388212576508522, + 0.08148715645074844, + 0.0993109866976738, + 0.10589393228292465, + 0.12961536645889282, + 0.07144000381231308 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03370363265275955 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a modern illustrative style with clean lines and a bold, graphic color palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a bright, fully formed rainbow visible in the upper frame with saturated red, orange, yellow, green, blue, and violet colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a dense bamboo forest visible below the rainbow with thick, glossy yellow stalks patterned with vertical green streaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the ground depicted as a flat surface of dark, damp soil shimmering with recent rainfall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera fixed and steady throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.47430720925331116 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9743071794509888 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.47430720925331116, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.4999999701976776, + "token_credit_reward": -0.47430720925331116, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19852811098098755, + 0.13086234033107758, + 0.08893042802810669, + 0.11515061557292938, + 0.08593194931745529, + 0.0799752026796341, + 0.06536513566970825, + 0.0949692353606224, + 0.05624021962285042, + 0.08404668420553207 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.47430720925331116 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a modern illustrative style with clean lines and a bold, graphic color palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a bright, fully formed rainbow visible in the upper frame with saturated red, orange, yellow, green, blue, and violet colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a dense bamboo forest visible below the rainbow with thick, glossy yellow stalks patterned with vertical green streaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the ground depicted as a flat surface of dark, damp soil shimmering with recent rainfall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera fixed and steady throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05496761202812195 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299676418304443 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05496761202812195, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05496761202812195, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23970195651054382, + 0.13170254230499268, + 0.054744865745306015, + 0.05358101427555084, + 0.0811508521437645, + 0.04636005684733391, + 0.10842397809028625, + 0.06387180089950562, + 0.17322179675102234, + 0.047241147607564926 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05496761202812195 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_5/index_tensor([5082, 5082])_group_5_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_5/index_tensor([5082, 5082])_group_5_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..4d6d9467a57d5b32c133b7c6286bda703a6983d4 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_5/index_tensor([5082, 5082])_group_5_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "low-angle, static, full-body shot establishes a scene of pure biomechanical horror, meticulously rendered in H.R. Giger's stark, nightmarish style. The central figure is a massive wolf spider, its form a grotesque synthesis of organic tissue and cold machinery, crouching low in a predatory pose. Its bulky abdomen and cephalothorax feature a velvety black texture, while its eight powerful, sinuous legs are connected by joints that glow a hellish red-orange. A pair of polished chrome fangs drip a viscous black fluid from its intricate metal jaw structure, slowly pooling on the ground below. The creature stands on a floor composed of a grotesque mosaic of fused metal bones and gleaming, cable-like sinews, all seamlessly integrated. A single, cold, blue light from an unseen source carves the creature out of the oppressive darkness, casting long, sharp shadows that wriggle with every subtle movement. A thin, oily mist swirled around its legs, catching the harsh light and emphasizing the damp, carapace-like sheen of its terrifying exoskeleton, creating a distinctly silent, alien atmosphere of menace.", + "seed": 23720, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_5/index_5082_seed_23720_dp_10_rank_20_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.017732028290629386, + "vlm_logprob": -0.017732028290629386, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.375, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.017732028290629386, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure a massive wolf spider with a grotesque synthesis of organic tissue and machinery?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the creature have a velvety black abdomen and cephalothorax with eight sinuous legs featuring joints that glow red-orange?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are polished chrome fangs visible dripping viscous black fluid onto a floor of fused metal bones and cable-like sinews?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single cold blue light casting long, sharp shadows in an oppressive darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle in a static, full-body shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0039175208657979965 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628917694091797 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0039175208657979965, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0039175208657979965, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3245594799518585, + 0.08522354811429977, + 0.0627007707953453, + 0.09603496640920639, + 0.09445624053478241, + 0.048755839467048645, + 0.05030810460448265, + 0.039703018963336945, + 0.041004445403814316, + 0.15725363790988922 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0039175208657979965 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure a massive wolf spider with a grotesque synthesis of organic tissue and machinery?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the creature have a velvety black abdomen and cephalothorax with eight sinuous legs featuring joints that glow red-orange?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are polished chrome fangs visible dripping viscous black fluid onto a floor of fused metal bones and cable-like sinews?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single cold blue light casting long, sharp shadows in an oppressive darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle in a static, full-body shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008640522137284279 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758640289306641 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008640522137284279, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008640522137284279, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17315888404846191, + 0.059300366789102554, + 0.07469473779201508, + 0.1394968330860138, + 0.05969373136758804, + 0.058454275131225586, + 0.10277523100376129, + 0.04730750247836113, + 0.06190583109855652, + 0.22321262955665588 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008640522137284279 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure a massive wolf spider with a grotesque synthesis of organic tissue and machinery?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the creature have a velvety black abdomen and cephalothorax with eight sinuous legs featuring joints that glow red-orange?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are polished chrome fangs visible dripping viscous black fluid onto a floor of fused metal bones and cable-like sinews?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single cold blue light casting long, sharp shadows in an oppressive darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle in a static, full-body shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009779755026102066 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634779930114746 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009779755026102066, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009779755026102066, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12057945877313614, + 0.06334282457828522, + 0.08856172859668732, + 0.08189325034618378, + 0.15003155171871185, + 0.1956033855676651, + 0.06178794056177139, + 0.037621717900037766, + 0.05914647877216339, + 0.14143167436122894 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009779755026102066 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure a massive wolf spider with a grotesque synthesis of organic tissue and machinery?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the creature have a velvety black abdomen and cephalothorax with eight sinuous legs featuring joints that glow red-orange?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are polished chrome fangs visible dripping viscous black fluid onto a floor of fused metal bones and cable-like sinews?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single cold blue light casting long, sharp shadows in an oppressive darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle in a static, full-body shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04305243864655495 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680524349212646 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04305243864655495, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04305243864655495, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2743533253669739, + 0.06419660896062851, + 0.13969853520393372, + 0.047691572457551956, + 0.09943890571594238, + 0.03918018192052841, + 0.1123267114162445, + 0.06906488537788391, + 0.04334007203578949, + 0.11070914566516876 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04305243864655495 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure a massive wolf spider with a grotesque synthesis of organic tissue and machinery?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the creature have a velvety black abdomen and cephalothorax with eight sinuous legs featuring joints that glow red-orange?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are polished chrome fangs visible dripping viscous black fluid onto a floor of fused metal bones and cable-like sinews?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single cold blue light casting long, sharp shadows in an oppressive darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle in a static, full-body shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023269904777407646 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732698917388916 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023269904777407646, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023269904777407646, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1148628443479538, + 0.046377573162317276, + 0.0926588624715805, + 0.05820654705166817, + 0.0807158425450325, + 0.027545085176825523, + 0.044961459934711456, + 0.07748259603977203, + 0.060440897941589355, + 0.39674830436706543 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023269904777407646 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, static, full-body shot establishes a scene of pure biomechanical horror, meticulously rendered in H.R. Giger's stark, nightmarish style. The central figure is a massive wolf spider, its form a grotesque synthesis of organic tissue and cold machinery, crouching low in a predatory pose. Its bulky abdomen and cephalothorax feature a velvety black texture, while its eight powerful, sinuous legs are connected by joints that glow a hellish red-orange. A pair of polished chrome fangs drip a viscous black fluid from its intricate metal jaw structure, slowly pooling on the ground below. The creature stands on a floor composed of a grotesque mosaic of fused metal bones and gleaming, cable-like sinews, all seamlessly integrated. A single, cold, blue light from an unseen source carves the creature out of the oppressive darkness, casting long, sharp shadows that wriggle with every subtle movement. A thin, oily mist swirled around its legs, catching the harsh light and emphasizing the damp, carapace-like sheen of its terrifying exoskeleton, creating a distinctly silent, alien atmosphere of menace.", + "seed": 23721, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_5/index_5082_seed_23721_dp_10_rank_20_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.016521347174420952, + "vlm_logprob": -0.016521347174420952, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.45, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.016521347174420952, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure a massive wolf spider with a grotesque synthesis of organic tissue and machinery?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the creature have a velvety black abdomen and cephalothorax with eight sinuous legs featuring joints that glow red-orange?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are polished chrome fangs visible dripping viscous black fluid onto a floor of fused metal bones and cable-like sinews?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single cold blue light casting long, sharp shadows in an oppressive darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle in a static, full-body shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002380515681579709 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.12738037109375 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002380515681579709, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002380515681579709, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12786999344825745, + 0.15593387186527252, + 0.0749521255493164, + 0.2589539885520935, + 0.1276129186153412, + 0.024969665333628654, + 0.09872434288263321, + 0.051402244716882706, + 0.04571297764778137, + 0.033867865800857544 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002380515681579709 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure a massive wolf spider with a grotesque synthesis of organic tissue and machinery?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the creature have a velvety black abdomen and cephalothorax with eight sinuous legs featuring joints that glow red-orange?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are polished chrome fangs visible dripping viscous black fluid onto a floor of fused metal bones and cable-like sinews?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single cold blue light casting long, sharp shadows in an oppressive darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle in a static, full-body shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009782234206795692 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634782314300537 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009782234206795692, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009782234206795692, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11459602415561676, + 0.10459243506193161, + 0.09386694431304932, + 0.30540332198143005, + 0.17987565696239471, + 0.0341484509408474, + 0.07014840841293335, + 0.03555018827319145, + 0.03538159281015396, + 0.02643696218729019 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009782234206795692 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure a massive wolf spider with a grotesque synthesis of organic tissue and machinery?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the creature have a velvety black abdomen and cephalothorax with eight sinuous legs featuring joints that glow red-orange?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are polished chrome fangs visible dripping viscous black fluid onto a floor of fused metal bones and cable-like sinews?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single cold blue light casting long, sharp shadows in an oppressive darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle in a static, full-body shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014191891998052597 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.2641921043396 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014191891998052597, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014191891998052597, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17596974968910217, + 0.08691722899675369, + 0.15279020369052887, + 0.1353103518486023, + 0.10237299650907516, + 0.040379203855991364, + 0.12813566625118256, + 0.07382756471633911, + 0.04600360989570618, + 0.05829339101910591 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014191891998052597 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure a massive wolf spider with a grotesque synthesis of organic tissue and machinery?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the creature have a velvety black abdomen and cephalothorax with eight sinuous legs featuring joints that glow red-orange?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are polished chrome fangs visible dripping viscous black fluid onto a floor of fused metal bones and cable-like sinews?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single cold blue light casting long, sharp shadows in an oppressive darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle in a static, full-body shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03808410465717316 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288084030151367 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03808410465717316, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03808410465717316, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3210146725177765, + 0.07905298471450806, + 0.05979776009917259, + 0.08927034586668015, + 0.19680634140968323, + 0.04353269189596176, + 0.09781517833471298, + 0.045704830437898636, + 0.026267752051353455, + 0.04073740541934967 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03808410465717316 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure a massive wolf spider with a grotesque synthesis of organic tissue and machinery?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the creature have a velvety black abdomen and cephalothorax with eight sinuous legs featuring joints that glow red-orange?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are polished chrome fangs visible dripping viscous black fluid onto a floor of fused metal bones and cable-like sinews?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single cold blue light casting long, sharp shadows in an oppressive darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle in a static, full-body shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01816798932850361 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018167972564697 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01816798932850361, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01816798932850361, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12604942917823792, + 0.1075759008526802, + 0.07068777084350586, + 0.0678471252322197, + 0.24118348956108093, + 0.06652016192674637, + 0.23301835358142853, + 0.018307453021407127, + 0.040193889290094376, + 0.028616448864340782 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01816798932850361 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, static, full-body shot establishes a scene of pure biomechanical horror, meticulously rendered in H.R. Giger's stark, nightmarish style. The central figure is a massive wolf spider, its form a grotesque synthesis of organic tissue and cold machinery, crouching low in a predatory pose. Its bulky abdomen and cephalothorax feature a velvety black texture, while its eight powerful, sinuous legs are connected by joints that glow a hellish red-orange. A pair of polished chrome fangs drip a viscous black fluid from its intricate metal jaw structure, slowly pooling on the ground below. The creature stands on a floor composed of a grotesque mosaic of fused metal bones and gleaming, cable-like sinews, all seamlessly integrated. A single, cold, blue light from an unseen source carves the creature out of the oppressive darkness, casting long, sharp shadows that wriggle with every subtle movement. A thin, oily mist swirled around its legs, catching the harsh light and emphasizing the damp, carapace-like sheen of its terrifying exoskeleton, creating a distinctly silent, alien atmosphere of menace.", + "seed": 23722, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_5/index_5082_seed_23722_dp_11_rank_22_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.026648489013314246, + "vlm_logprob": -0.026648489013314246, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.35, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.026648489013314246, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure a massive wolf spider with a grotesque synthesis of organic tissue and machinery?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the creature have a velvety black abdomen and cephalothorax with eight sinuous legs featuring joints that glow red-orange?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are polished chrome fangs visible dripping viscous black fluid onto a floor of fused metal bones and cable-like sinews?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single cold blue light casting long, sharp shadows in an oppressive darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle in a static, full-body shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005077681038528681 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.380077838897705 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005077681038528681, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005077681038528681, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3128126859664917, + 0.07949334383010864, + 0.11583539843559265, + 0.11749967932701111, + 0.1503509283065796, + 0.039249759167432785, + 0.049582067877054214, + 0.029284339398145676, + 0.025676356628537178, + 0.0802154541015625 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005077681038528681 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure a massive wolf spider with a grotesque synthesis of organic tissue and machinery?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the creature have a velvety black abdomen and cephalothorax with eight sinuous legs featuring joints that glow red-orange?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are polished chrome fangs visible dripping viscous black fluid onto a floor of fused metal bones and cable-like sinews?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single cold blue light casting long, sharp shadows in an oppressive darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle in a static, full-body shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008640285581350327 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758640289306641 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008640285581350327, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008640285581350327, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19654899835586548, + 0.1492447555065155, + 0.23052164912223816, + 0.08160865306854248, + 0.1296909898519516, + 0.03831296041607857, + 0.04205329716205597, + 0.06033078581094742, + 0.02571040205657482, + 0.04597746580839157 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008640285581350327 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure a massive wolf spider with a grotesque synthesis of organic tissue and machinery?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the creature have a velvety black abdomen and cephalothorax with eight sinuous legs featuring joints that glow red-orange?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are polished chrome fangs visible dripping viscous black fluid onto a floor of fused metal bones and cable-like sinews?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single cold blue light casting long, sharp shadows in an oppressive darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle in a static, full-body shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012534528970718384 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.3875346183776855 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012534528970718384, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012534528970718384, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1698579043149948, + 0.25974857807159424, + 0.06784523278474808, + 0.052797768265008926, + 0.07098086923360825, + 0.04408596456050873, + 0.17772276699543, + 0.0723809078335762, + 0.044037871062755585, + 0.04054216295480728 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012534528970718384 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure a massive wolf spider with a grotesque synthesis of organic tissue and machinery?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the creature have a velvety black abdomen and cephalothorax with eight sinuous legs featuring joints that glow red-orange?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are polished chrome fangs visible dripping viscous black fluid onto a floor of fused metal bones and cable-like sinews?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single cold blue light casting long, sharp shadows in an oppressive darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle in a static, full-body shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006730742286890745 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006730556488037 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006730742286890745, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006730742286890745, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09788406640291214, + 0.20115666091442108, + 0.15665921568870544, + 0.03531966358423233, + 0.1242932379245758, + 0.05036664009094238, + 0.048399049788713455, + 0.18956536054611206, + 0.046639591455459595, + 0.04971649870276451 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 7, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006730742286890745 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure a massive wolf spider with a grotesque synthesis of organic tissue and machinery?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the creature have a velvety black abdomen and cephalothorax with eight sinuous legs featuring joints that glow red-orange?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are polished chrome fangs visible dripping viscous black fluid onto a floor of fused metal bones and cable-like sinews?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single cold blue light casting long, sharp shadows in an oppressive darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle in a static, full-body shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1002592071890831 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.350259304046631 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1002592071890831, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1002592071890831, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18038220703601837, + 0.13785643875598907, + 0.2148793637752533, + 0.06475580483675003, + 0.1117631271481514, + 0.04090074449777603, + 0.06047787144780159, + 0.04731849208474159, + 0.08347714692354202, + 0.0581887848675251 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1002592071890831 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, static, full-body shot establishes a scene of pure biomechanical horror, meticulously rendered in H.R. Giger's stark, nightmarish style. The central figure is a massive wolf spider, its form a grotesque synthesis of organic tissue and cold machinery, crouching low in a predatory pose. Its bulky abdomen and cephalothorax feature a velvety black texture, while its eight powerful, sinuous legs are connected by joints that glow a hellish red-orange. A pair of polished chrome fangs drip a viscous black fluid from its intricate metal jaw structure, slowly pooling on the ground below. The creature stands on a floor composed of a grotesque mosaic of fused metal bones and gleaming, cable-like sinews, all seamlessly integrated. A single, cold, blue light from an unseen source carves the creature out of the oppressive darkness, casting long, sharp shadows that wriggle with every subtle movement. A thin, oily mist swirled around its legs, catching the harsh light and emphasizing the damp, carapace-like sheen of its terrifying exoskeleton, creating a distinctly silent, alien atmosphere of menace.", + "seed": 23723, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_5/index_5082_seed_23723_dp_11_rank_22_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.019894248666241766, + "vlm_logprob": -0.019894248666241766, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.425, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.019894248666241766, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure a massive wolf spider with a grotesque synthesis of organic tissue and machinery?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the creature have a velvety black abdomen and cephalothorax with eight sinuous legs featuring joints that glow red-orange?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are polished chrome fangs visible dripping viscous black fluid onto a floor of fused metal bones and cable-like sinews?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single cold blue light casting long, sharp shadows in an oppressive darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle in a static, full-body shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0027550619561225176 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002755165100098 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0027550619561225176, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0027550619561225176, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22360678017139435, + 0.11502595990896225, + 0.052039507776498795, + 0.04948499798774719, + 0.11484675109386444, + 0.1115221455693245, + 0.11196007579565048, + 0.029487840831279755, + 0.1079564169049263, + 0.08406953513622284 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0027550619561225176 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure a massive wolf spider with a grotesque synthesis of organic tissue and machinery?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the creature have a velvety black abdomen and cephalothorax with eight sinuous legs featuring joints that glow red-orange?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are polished chrome fangs visible dripping viscous black fluid onto a floor of fused metal bones and cable-like sinews?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single cold blue light casting long, sharp shadows in an oppressive darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle in a static, full-body shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011078868061304092 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511078834533691 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011078868061304092, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011078868061304092, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2466777265071869, + 0.08714862167835236, + 0.028193404898047447, + 0.09386128187179565, + 0.23211078345775604, + 0.08514386415481567, + 0.051616404205560684, + 0.03663584217429161, + 0.03119637630879879, + 0.10741569101810455 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011078868061304092 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure a massive wolf spider with a grotesque synthesis of organic tissue and machinery?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the creature have a velvety black abdomen and cephalothorax with eight sinuous legs featuring joints that glow red-orange?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are polished chrome fangs visible dripping viscous black fluid onto a floor of fused metal bones and cable-like sinews?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single cold blue light casting long, sharp shadows in an oppressive darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle in a static, full-body shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012536060065031052 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.38753604888916 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012536060065031052, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012536060065031052, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2776372730731964, + 0.11563626676797867, + 0.038881219923496246, + 0.04628603905439377, + 0.25518277287483215, + 0.0813518613576889, + 0.026460131630301476, + 0.04233456030488014, + 0.0361446887254715, + 0.08008521795272827 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012536060065031052 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure a massive wolf spider with a grotesque synthesis of organic tissue and machinery?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the creature have a velvety black abdomen and cephalothorax with eight sinuous legs featuring joints that glow red-orange?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are polished chrome fangs visible dripping viscous black fluid onto a floor of fused metal bones and cable-like sinews?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single cold blue light casting long, sharp shadows in an oppressive darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle in a static, full-body shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06203853711485863 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120384216308594 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06203853711485863, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06203853711485863, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21910476684570312, + 0.07619163393974304, + 0.14387866854667664, + 0.02413785643875599, + 0.09809655696153641, + 0.22486068308353424, + 0.06284551322460175, + 0.054598402231931686, + 0.023502275347709656, + 0.07278361916542053 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06203853711485863 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure a massive wolf spider with a grotesque synthesis of organic tissue and machinery?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the creature have a velvety black abdomen and cephalothorax with eight sinuous legs featuring joints that glow red-orange?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are polished chrome fangs visible dripping viscous black fluid onto a floor of fused metal bones and cable-like sinews?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single cold blue light casting long, sharp shadows in an oppressive darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle in a static, full-body shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011062716133892536 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.5110626220703125 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011062716133892536, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011062716133892536, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1414882242679596, + 0.06203002482652664, + 0.04412650316953659, + 0.07796652615070343, + 0.2653205394744873, + 0.11129965633153915, + 0.054860036820173264, + 0.0524127334356308, + 0.06619370728731155, + 0.12430200725793839 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011062716133892536 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_6/index_tensor([3332, 3332])_group_6_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_6/index_tensor([3332, 3332])_group_6_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..7c2e52b1e0e69628c810ceacfdef9bcb55799b5b --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_6/index_tensor([3332, 3332])_group_6_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "In a close-up shot imbued with the cinematic quality of Wong Kar-wai, the camera, looking up slightly, slowly but steadily, zooms in on a man in a dark, meticulously tailored suit jacket. His meticulously slicked-back hair gleams faintly in the dim light, and his profile, defined in the gloom, reveals a focused expression tinged with melancholy. He occupies a dimly lit room, the sole source of light coming from a high, off-screen blind. A rich, golden beam of afternoon sunlight filters through the gap, slanting down like a stage spotlight, precisely illuminating countless slowly drifting, swirling dust particles in the air and imbuing the beam with a tangible weight. His hands carefully hold an antique brass pocket watch, its case, mellow with age, reflecting a warm, aged patina in the light. As his thumb steadily and slowly pressed the crown, accompanied by a barely audible click, the cover of the pocket watch slowly popped open, and light instantly captured the delicate Roman numerals on the dial and the slender, steadily moving hands. The entire scene was filled with an extremely rich color palette, dominated by warm yellows, while the shadows appeared to be a deep dark green, creating an atmosphere of inextricable nostalgia and tranquility, as if time had been infinitely stretched and frozen in this moment.", + "seed": 8323, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_6/index_3332_seed_8323_dp_12_rank_24_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.037537389900535345, + "vlm_logprob": -0.037537389900535345, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.1, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.037537389900535345, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a close-up looking slightly up at a man in a dark suit jacket?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily zoom in on the man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single golden beam of sunlight filtering through a high off-screen blind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man hold an antique brass pocket watch that opens to reveal Roman numerals and moving hands?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color palette dominated by warm yellows and deep dark green shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.017411358654499054 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.142411231994629 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.017411358654499054, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.017411358654499054, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1033349260687828, + 0.04434693977236748, + 0.027236629277467728, + 0.03770565241575241, + 0.061439964920282364, + 0.05294997617602348, + 0.14308130741119385, + 0.19956143200397491, + 0.17948698997497559, + 0.15085619688034058 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.017411358654499054 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a close-up looking slightly up at a man in a dark suit jacket?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily zoom in on the man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single golden beam of sunlight filtering through a high off-screen blind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man hold an antique brass pocket watch that opens to reveal Roman numerals and moving hands?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color palette dominated by warm yellows and deep dark green shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1428193598985672 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.017819404602051 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1428193598985672, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1428193598985672, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06144123524427414, + 0.042405977845191956, + 0.06855317205190659, + 0.03322821110486984, + 0.03848977014422417, + 0.04072362184524536, + 0.1287744641304016, + 0.09506963193416595, + 0.15948423743247986, + 0.331829696893692 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1428193598985672 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a close-up looking slightly up at a man in a dark suit jacket?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily zoom in on the man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single golden beam of sunlight filtering through a high off-screen blind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man hold an antique brass pocket watch that opens to reveal Roman numerals and moving hands?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color palette dominated by warm yellows and deep dark green shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006740451790392399 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006740570068359 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006740451790392399, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006740451790392399, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.32245588302612305, + 0.1170724555850029, + 0.07212422043085098, + 0.05923442542552948, + 0.024844754487276077, + 0.0635078176856041, + 0.038571055978536606, + 0.061915844678878784, + 0.06369506567716599, + 0.17657844722270966 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006740451790392399 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a close-up looking slightly up at a man in a dark suit jacket?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily zoom in on the man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single golden beam of sunlight filtering through a high off-screen blind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man hold an antique brass pocket watch that opens to reveal Roman numerals and moving hands?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color palette dominated by warm yellows and deep dark green shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016078339889645576 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141078472137451 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016078339889645576, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016078339889645576, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24466480314731598, + 0.06619906425476074, + 0.032860442996025085, + 0.03334827721118927, + 0.030663393437862396, + 0.02648322656750679, + 0.03626209497451782, + 0.043590277433395386, + 0.18569637835025787, + 0.30023202300071716 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016078339889645576 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a close-up looking slightly up at a man in a dark suit jacket?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily zoom in on the man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single golden beam of sunlight filtering through a high off-screen blind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man hold an antique brass pocket watch that opens to reveal Roman numerals and moving hands?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color palette dominated by warm yellows and deep dark green shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004637439269572496 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379637241363525 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004637439269572496, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004637439269572496, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18370367586612701, + 0.038812167942523956, + 0.026440177112817764, + 0.02388397417962551, + 0.021101368591189384, + 0.041353240609169006, + 0.06514865905046463, + 0.058845747262239456, + 0.19766093790531158, + 0.34304994344711304 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004637439269572496 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a close-up shot imbued with the cinematic quality of Wong Kar-wai, the camera, looking up slightly, slowly but steadily, zooms in on a man in a dark, meticulously tailored suit jacket. His meticulously slicked-back hair gleams faintly in the dim light, and his profile, defined in the gloom, reveals a focused expression tinged with melancholy. He occupies a dimly lit room, the sole source of light coming from a high, off-screen blind. A rich, golden beam of afternoon sunlight filters through the gap, slanting down like a stage spotlight, precisely illuminating countless slowly drifting, swirling dust particles in the air and imbuing the beam with a tangible weight. His hands carefully hold an antique brass pocket watch, its case, mellow with age, reflecting a warm, aged patina in the light. As his thumb steadily and slowly pressed the crown, accompanied by a barely audible click, the cover of the pocket watch slowly popped open, and light instantly captured the delicate Roman numerals on the dial and the slender, steadily moving hands. The entire scene was filled with an extremely rich color palette, dominated by warm yellows, while the shadows appeared to be a deep dark green, creating an atmosphere of inextricable nostalgia and tranquility, as if time had been infinitely stretched and frozen in this moment.", + "seed": 8324, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_6/index_3332_seed_8324_dp_12_rank_24_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.07679320198949427, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07679320198949427, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.175, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07679320198949427, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a close-up looking slightly up at a man in a dark suit jacket?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily zoom in on the man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single golden beam of sunlight filtering through a high off-screen blind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man hold an antique brass pocket watch that opens to reveal Roman numerals and moving hands?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color palette dominated by warm yellows and deep dark green shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.015542215667665005 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.265542030334473 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.015542215667665005, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.015542215667665005, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2668073773384094, + 0.08323889225721359, + 0.02514874003827572, + 0.04666591435670853, + 0.33189132809638977, + 0.11806469410657883, + 0.018154384568333626, + 0.03860080987215042, + 0.03832102566957474, + 0.03310692310333252 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.015542215667665005 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a close-up looking slightly up at a man in a dark suit jacket?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily zoom in on the man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single golden beam of sunlight filtering through a high off-screen blind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man hold an antique brass pocket watch that opens to reveal Roman numerals and moving hands?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color palette dominated by warm yellows and deep dark green shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.34865036606788635 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.223650336265564 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.34865036606788635, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.34865036606788635, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19630806148052216, + 0.07137744873762131, + 0.11120487004518509, + 0.0847415179014206, + 0.13868451118469238, + 0.13085661828517914, + 0.04652691259980202, + 0.05185099318623543, + 0.1240784078836441, + 0.0443706177175045 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.34865036606788635 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a close-up looking slightly up at a man in a dark suit jacket?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily zoom in on the man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single golden beam of sunlight filtering through a high off-screen blind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man hold an antique brass pocket watch that opens to reveal Roman numerals and moving hands?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color palette dominated by warm yellows and deep dark green shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0067427014000713825 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006742477416992 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0067427014000713825, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0067427014000713825, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15715700387954712, + 0.16076825559139252, + 0.035234563052654266, + 0.15297891199588776, + 0.421454519033432, + 0.02082897163927555, + 0.008754302747547626, + 0.010303321294486523, + 0.019277174025774002, + 0.013242965564131737 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0067427014000713825 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a close-up looking slightly up at a man in a dark suit jacket?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily zoom in on the man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single golden beam of sunlight filtering through a high off-screen blind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man hold an antique brass pocket watch that opens to reveal Roman numerals and moving hands?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color palette dominated by warm yellows and deep dark green shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011087002232670784 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511086940765381 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011087002232670784, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011087002232670784, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14708451926708221, + 0.1458878070116043, + 0.02561686933040619, + 0.02400670014321804, + 0.30983099341392517, + 0.03510135039687157, + 0.07654464989900589, + 0.08009486645460129, + 0.05052931606769562, + 0.10530289262533188 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011087002232670784 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a close-up looking slightly up at a man in a dark suit jacket?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily zoom in on the man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single golden beam of sunlight filtering through a high off-screen blind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man hold an antique brass pocket watch that opens to reveal Roman numerals and moving hands?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color palette dominated by warm yellows and deep dark green shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0019437245791777968 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.251943588256836 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0019437245791777968, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0019437245791777968, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08537614345550537, + 0.0648573786020279, + 0.02000187337398529, + 0.061627715826034546, + 0.5713417530059814, + 0.05106300488114357, + 0.016519827768206596, + 0.0719102993607521, + 0.031710006296634674, + 0.02559196762740612 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0019437245791777968 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a close-up shot imbued with the cinematic quality of Wong Kar-wai, the camera, looking up slightly, slowly but steadily, zooms in on a man in a dark, meticulously tailored suit jacket. His meticulously slicked-back hair gleams faintly in the dim light, and his profile, defined in the gloom, reveals a focused expression tinged with melancholy. He occupies a dimly lit room, the sole source of light coming from a high, off-screen blind. A rich, golden beam of afternoon sunlight filters through the gap, slanting down like a stage spotlight, precisely illuminating countless slowly drifting, swirling dust particles in the air and imbuing the beam with a tangible weight. His hands carefully hold an antique brass pocket watch, its case, mellow with age, reflecting a warm, aged patina in the light. As his thumb steadily and slowly pressed the crown, accompanied by a barely audible click, the cover of the pocket watch slowly popped open, and light instantly captured the delicate Roman numerals on the dial and the slender, steadily moving hands. The entire scene was filled with an extremely rich color palette, dominated by warm yellows, while the shadows appeared to be a deep dark green, creating an atmosphere of inextricable nostalgia and tranquility, as if time had been infinitely stretched and frozen in this moment.", + "seed": 8325, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_6/index_3332_seed_8325_dp_13_rank_26_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.019886032841168345, + "vlm_logprob": -0.019886032841168345, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.7, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.019886032841168345, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a close-up looking slightly up at a man in a dark suit jacket?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily zoom in on the man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single golden beam of sunlight filtering through a high off-screen blind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man hold an antique brass pocket watch that opens to reveal Roman numerals and moving hands?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color palette dominated by warm yellows and deep dark green shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012795725837349892 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.512795925140381 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012795725837349892, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012795725837349892, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2618178427219391, + 0.044957537204027176, + 0.04578035697340965, + 0.06874246895313263, + 0.06135137751698494, + 0.08787499368190765, + 0.17109480500221252, + 0.153850257396698, + 0.038237664848566055, + 0.06629269570112228 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012795725837349892 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a close-up looking slightly up at a man in a dark suit jacket?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily zoom in on the man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single golden beam of sunlight filtering through a high off-screen blind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man hold an antique brass pocket watch that opens to reveal Roman numerals and moving hands?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color palette dominated by warm yellows and deep dark green shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07002948969602585 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950294971466064 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07002948969602585, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07002948969602585, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11653958261013031, + 0.03523501753807068, + 0.030221888795495033, + 0.1995459496974945, + 0.0463239848613739, + 0.10357381403446198, + 0.10512096434831619, + 0.1372322142124176, + 0.10528264939785004, + 0.12092391401529312 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07002948969602585 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a close-up looking slightly up at a man in a dark suit jacket?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily zoom in on the man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single golden beam of sunlight filtering through a high off-screen blind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man hold an antique brass pocket watch that opens to reveal Roman numerals and moving hands?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color palette dominated by warm yellows and deep dark green shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0076326169073581696 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882632732391357 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0076326169073581696, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0076326169073581696, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1435030996799469, + 0.06568901240825653, + 0.1567120999097824, + 0.17241384088993073, + 0.09670285880565643, + 0.20062902569770813, + 0.05313977971673012, + 0.02672373317182064, + 0.03995421528816223, + 0.04453234747052193 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0076326169073581696 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a close-up looking slightly up at a man in a dark suit jacket?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily zoom in on the man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single golden beam of sunlight filtering through a high off-screen blind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man hold an antique brass pocket watch that opens to reveal Roman numerals and moving hands?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color palette dominated by warm yellows and deep dark green shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00763498293235898 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882635116577148 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00763498293235898, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00763498293235898, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11860708147287369, + 0.03125256299972534, + 0.022075364366173744, + 0.07734624296426773, + 0.09297464042901993, + 0.05707348510622978, + 0.03814929723739624, + 0.24855370819568634, + 0.20973162353038788, + 0.10423599928617477 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00763498293235898 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a close-up looking slightly up at a man in a dark suit jacket?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily zoom in on the man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single golden beam of sunlight filtering through a high off-screen blind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man hold an antique brass pocket watch that opens to reveal Roman numerals and moving hands?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color palette dominated by warm yellows and deep dark green shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0013373488327488303 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.62633752822876 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0013373488327488303, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0013373488327488303, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2070203721523285, + 0.07379224896430969, + 0.07603210210800171, + 0.10363859683275223, + 0.08936703205108643, + 0.08152032643556595, + 0.08013682067394257, + 0.06340909749269485, + 0.09375344216823578, + 0.13132989406585693 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0013373488327488303 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a close-up shot imbued with the cinematic quality of Wong Kar-wai, the camera, looking up slightly, slowly but steadily, zooms in on a man in a dark, meticulously tailored suit jacket. His meticulously slicked-back hair gleams faintly in the dim light, and his profile, defined in the gloom, reveals a focused expression tinged with melancholy. He occupies a dimly lit room, the sole source of light coming from a high, off-screen blind. A rich, golden beam of afternoon sunlight filters through the gap, slanting down like a stage spotlight, precisely illuminating countless slowly drifting, swirling dust particles in the air and imbuing the beam with a tangible weight. His hands carefully hold an antique brass pocket watch, its case, mellow with age, reflecting a warm, aged patina in the light. As his thumb steadily and slowly pressed the crown, accompanied by a barely audible click, the cover of the pocket watch slowly popped open, and light instantly captured the delicate Roman numerals on the dial and the slender, steadily moving hands. The entire scene was filled with an extremely rich color palette, dominated by warm yellows, while the shadows appeared to be a deep dark green, creating an atmosphere of inextricable nostalgia and tranquility, as if time had been infinitely stretched and frozen in this moment.", + "seed": 8326, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_6/index_3332_seed_8326_dp_13_rank_26_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.044806873961351815, + "vlm_logprob": -0.044806873961351815, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.325, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.044806873961351815, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a close-up looking slightly up at a man in a dark suit jacket?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily zoom in on the man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single golden beam of sunlight filtering through a high off-screen blind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man hold an antique brass pocket watch that opens to reveal Roman numerals and moving hands?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color palette dominated by warm yellows and deep dark green shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.017117030918598175 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.142117023468018 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.017117030918598175, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.017117030918598175, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19535724818706512, + 0.029161248356103897, + 0.05331368371844292, + 0.06997047364711761, + 0.03469845652580261, + 0.04709495231509209, + 0.11484785377979279, + 0.29625535011291504, + 0.06632853299379349, + 0.09297215938568115 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.017117030918598175 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a close-up looking slightly up at a man in a dark suit jacket?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily zoom in on the man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single golden beam of sunlight filtering through a high off-screen blind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man hold an antique brass pocket watch that opens to reveal Roman numerals and moving hands?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color palette dominated by warm yellows and deep dark green shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1798904538154602 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8048903942108154 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1798904538154602, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1798904538154602, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07039546221494675, + 0.06710296124219894, + 0.07963024824857712, + 0.03601455315947533, + 0.06770617514848709, + 0.25128135085105896, + 0.12631654739379883, + 0.15223342180252075, + 0.09264536201953888, + 0.05667391046881676 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1798904538154602 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a close-up looking slightly up at a man in a dark suit jacket?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily zoom in on the man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single golden beam of sunlight filtering through a high off-screen blind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man hold an antique brass pocket watch that opens to reveal Roman numerals and moving hands?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color palette dominated by warm yellows and deep dark green shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020587561652064323 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.89558744430542 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020587561652064323, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020587561652064323, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11141891032457352, + 0.38642627000808716, + 0.08508723974227905, + 0.04179343581199646, + 0.02142396755516529, + 0.0753616988658905, + 0.04224656894803047, + 0.0691252127289772, + 0.07994123548269272, + 0.08717536926269531 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020587561652064323 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a close-up looking slightly up at a man in a dark suit jacket?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily zoom in on the man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single golden beam of sunlight filtering through a high off-screen blind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man hold an antique brass pocket watch that opens to reveal Roman numerals and moving hands?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color palette dominated by warm yellows and deep dark green shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005258656572550535 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255258560180664 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005258656572550535, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005258656572550535, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05035484582185745, + 0.02064540609717369, + 0.05649983137845993, + 0.06088428944349289, + 0.013643456622958183, + 0.2177511304616928, + 0.09270936250686646, + 0.0734182819724083, + 0.21509581804275513, + 0.1989975869655609 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005258656572550535 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a close-up looking slightly up at a man in a dark suit jacket?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily zoom in on the man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single golden beam of sunlight filtering through a high off-screen blind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man hold an antique brass pocket watch that opens to reveal Roman numerals and moving hands?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color palette dominated by warm yellows and deep dark green shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0011806668480858207 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.751180648803711 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0011806668480858207, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0011806668480858207, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0950022041797638, + 0.04552675783634186, + 0.0533316470682621, + 0.06530315428972244, + 0.18782280385494232, + 0.16314411163330078, + 0.06949345022439957, + 0.1266450732946396, + 0.0862298235297203, + 0.10750094056129456 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0011806668480858207 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_7/index_tensor([8774, 8774])_group_7_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_7/index_tensor([8774, 8774])_group_7_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..abc4f3c9ae397b520fb61d57881601bd7bdffef2 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_7/index_tensor([8774, 8774])_group_7_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "tense, low-angle tracking shot follows, the camera darting through waist-high waves of golden wheat, its frame fixed on a figure, bent low and struggling forward. This is a young woman with long, dark brown hair, sweat-soaked, matted tousled against her cheeks and neck. Her face is a mixture of fear and determination, her lower lip bitten, her eyes scanning the horizon warily. She wears a faded gray cotton T-shirt, clinging to her body, outlining her chest, which rises and falls with rapid breathing, and dark blue jeans, slightly frayed at the knees. She lowers herself to the ground, almost level with the tops of the wheat ears, to avoid possible sight. Her hands instinctively push aside the dense stalks in front of her, their movements swift and a touch panicky. The golden sunlight of dusk slants down at a low angle, tinting the endless wheat fields into a brilliant golden ocean. Each ear of wheat glows dazzlingly in the backlight, casting long, swaying shadows on and around her. A gentle breeze whips through the wheat fields, undulating like waves. The entire scene, a stunning pastoral landscape with an almost oil-painting quality, is permeated with a silent, breathtaking atmosphere of pursuit, filled with a stark contrast between idyllic tranquility and a tense, volatile atmosphere.", + "seed": 17447, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_7/index_8774_seed_17447_dp_14_rank_28_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.1082693625241518, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1082693625241518, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.6, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1082693625241518, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving in a tracking motion through waist-high waves of golden wheat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure a young woman with long, dark brown hair that is sweat-soaked and matted?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a faded gray cotton T-shirt and dark blue jeans that are slightly frayed at the knees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman lower herself to the ground to avoid sight while pushing aside dense wheat stalks with panicky movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3107762038707733 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6857762336730957 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3107762038707733, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3107762038707733, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12245295196771622, + 0.3157602846622467, + 0.06833633780479431, + 0.056013643741607666, + 0.030632054433226585, + 0.0659196600317955, + 0.049902185797691345, + 0.13352066278457642, + 0.0485384464263916, + 0.1089237853884697 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3107762038707733 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving in a tracking motion through waist-high waves of golden wheat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure a young woman with long, dark brown hair that is sweat-soaked and matted?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a faded gray cotton T-shirt and dark blue jeans that are slightly frayed at the knees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman lower herself to the ground to avoid sight while pushing aside dense wheat stalks with panicky movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.055085740983486176 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9300856590270996 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.055085740983486176, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.055085740983486176, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06829175353050232, + 0.33309364318847656, + 0.07678770273923874, + 0.0835268422961235, + 0.03125224635004997, + 0.061027828603982925, + 0.05611168220639229, + 0.13685476779937744, + 0.02092943899333477, + 0.13212411105632782 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.055085740983486176 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving in a tracking motion through waist-high waves of golden wheat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure a young woman with long, dark brown hair that is sweat-soaked and matted?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a faded gray cotton T-shirt and dark blue jeans that are slightly frayed at the knees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman lower herself to the ground to avoid sight while pushing aside dense wheat stalks with panicky movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07006616145372391 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695066213607788 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07006616145372391, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07006616145372391, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05320271849632263, + 0.3529185950756073, + 0.11900676786899567, + 0.08249986171722412, + 0.05312419310212135, + 0.066323421895504, + 0.022471832111477852, + 0.12898564338684082, + 0.018611185252666473, + 0.10285582393407822 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 7, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07006616145372391 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving in a tracking motion through waist-high waves of golden wheat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure a young woman with long, dark brown hair that is sweat-soaked and matted?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a faded gray cotton T-shirt and dark blue jeans that are slightly frayed at the knees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman lower herself to the ground to avoid sight while pushing aside dense wheat stalks with panicky movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07906577736139297 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5790657997131348 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07906577736139297, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07906577736139297, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0463491827249527, + 0.24994808435440063, + 0.12011410295963287, + 0.06498424708843231, + 0.10364607721567154, + 0.05122436210513115, + 0.05930796638131142, + 0.12003414332866669, + 0.08511489629745483, + 0.09927696734666824 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07906577736139297 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving in a tracking motion through waist-high waves of golden wheat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure a young woman with long, dark brown hair that is sweat-soaked and matted?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a faded gray cotton T-shirt and dark blue jeans that are slightly frayed at the knees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman lower herself to the ground to avoid sight while pushing aside dense wheat stalks with panicky movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026352928951382637 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651352882385254 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026352928951382637, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026352928951382637, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07428263872861862, + 0.20406180620193481, + 0.04850538820028305, + 0.05113719776272774, + 0.08475027233362198, + 0.1090008020401001, + 0.03424863889813423, + 0.20944219827651978, + 0.09787504374980927, + 0.08669600635766983 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026352928951382637 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "tense, low-angle tracking shot follows, the camera darting through waist-high waves of golden wheat, its frame fixed on a figure, bent low and struggling forward. This is a young woman with long, dark brown hair, sweat-soaked, matted tousled against her cheeks and neck. Her face is a mixture of fear and determination, her lower lip bitten, her eyes scanning the horizon warily. She wears a faded gray cotton T-shirt, clinging to her body, outlining her chest, which rises and falls with rapid breathing, and dark blue jeans, slightly frayed at the knees. She lowers herself to the ground, almost level with the tops of the wheat ears, to avoid possible sight. Her hands instinctively push aside the dense stalks in front of her, their movements swift and a touch panicky. The golden sunlight of dusk slants down at a low angle, tinting the endless wheat fields into a brilliant golden ocean. Each ear of wheat glows dazzlingly in the backlight, casting long, swaying shadows on and around her. A gentle breeze whips through the wheat fields, undulating like waves. The entire scene, a stunning pastoral landscape with an almost oil-painting quality, is permeated with a silent, breathtaking atmosphere of pursuit, filled with a stark contrast between idyllic tranquility and a tense, volatile atmosphere.", + "seed": 17448, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_7/index_8774_seed_17448_dp_14_rank_28_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.08231315426528454, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08231315426528454, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.825, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08231315426528454, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving in a tracking motion through waist-high waves of golden wheat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure a young woman with long, dark brown hair that is sweat-soaked and matted?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a faded gray cotton T-shirt and dark blue jeans that are slightly frayed at the knees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman lower herself to the ground to avoid sight while pushing aside dense wheat stalks with panicky movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.21568122506141663 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9656811952590942 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.21568122506141663, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.21568122506141663, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.8267536759376526, + 0.0547325424849987, + 0.04414151981472969, + 0.01316771563142538, + 0.007388838101178408, + 0.006439282093197107, + 0.024338487535715103, + 0.010034257546067238, + 0.0062028393149375916, + 0.006800880189985037 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.21568122506141663 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving in a tracking motion through waist-high waves of golden wheat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure a young woman with long, dark brown hair that is sweat-soaked and matted?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a faded gray cotton T-shirt and dark blue jeans that are slightly frayed at the knees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman lower herself to the ground to avoid sight while pushing aside dense wheat stalks with panicky movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04315325990319252 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1681532859802246 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04315325990319252, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04315325990319252, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.703960657119751, + 0.08368533849716187, + 0.050620511174201965, + 0.017556674778461456, + 0.02328501082956791, + 0.024300456047058105, + 0.05548717826604843, + 0.014540120959281921, + 0.007890257984399796, + 0.018673747777938843 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04315325990319252 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving in a tracking motion through waist-high waves of golden wheat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure a young woman with long, dark brown hair that is sweat-soaked and matted?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a faded gray cotton T-shirt and dark blue jeans that are slightly frayed at the knees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman lower herself to the ground to avoid sight while pushing aside dense wheat stalks with panicky movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.062076181173324585 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120760917663574 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.062076181173324585, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.062076181173324585, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.9721794724464417, + 0.013903334736824036, + 0.0010482976213097572, + 0.0020719817839562893, + 0.00531715527176857, + 0.0017857288476079702, + 0.0009802961722016335, + 0.0008521770359948277, + 0.00034750154009088874, + 0.0015141000039875507 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.062076181173324585 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving in a tracking motion through waist-high waves of golden wheat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure a young woman with long, dark brown hair that is sweat-soaked and matted?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a faded gray cotton T-shirt and dark blue jeans that are slightly frayed at the knees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman lower herself to the ground to avoid sight while pushing aside dense wheat stalks with panicky movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.070071280002594 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695071220397949 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.070071280002594, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.070071280002594, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.8778594136238098, + 0.056014660745859146, + 0.007597281131893396, + 0.0041699036955833435, + 0.02994128130376339, + 0.008234316483139992, + 0.004463746678084135, + 0.005927917081862688, + 0.0021113811526447535, + 0.003680093213915825 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.070071280002594 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving in a tracking motion through waist-high waves of golden wheat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure a young woman with long, dark brown hair that is sweat-soaked and matted?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a faded gray cotton T-shirt and dark blue jeans that are slightly frayed at the knees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman lower herself to the ground to avoid sight while pushing aside dense wheat stalks with panicky movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020583825185894966 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955838680267334 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020583825185894966, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020583825185894966, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.83013916015625, + 0.03369353339076042, + 0.014770500361919403, + 0.009292635135352612, + 0.032665908336639404, + 0.017121771350502968, + 0.015491548925638199, + 0.01879780739545822, + 0.021143149584531784, + 0.006884044501930475 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020583825185894966 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "tense, low-angle tracking shot follows, the camera darting through waist-high waves of golden wheat, its frame fixed on a figure, bent low and struggling forward. This is a young woman with long, dark brown hair, sweat-soaked, matted tousled against her cheeks and neck. Her face is a mixture of fear and determination, her lower lip bitten, her eyes scanning the horizon warily. She wears a faded gray cotton T-shirt, clinging to her body, outlining her chest, which rises and falls with rapid breathing, and dark blue jeans, slightly frayed at the knees. She lowers herself to the ground, almost level with the tops of the wheat ears, to avoid possible sight. Her hands instinctively push aside the dense stalks in front of her, their movements swift and a touch panicky. The golden sunlight of dusk slants down at a low angle, tinting the endless wheat fields into a brilliant golden ocean. Each ear of wheat glows dazzlingly in the backlight, casting long, swaying shadows on and around her. A gentle breeze whips through the wheat fields, undulating like waves. The entire scene, a stunning pastoral landscape with an almost oil-painting quality, is permeated with a silent, breathtaking atmosphere of pursuit, filled with a stark contrast between idyllic tranquility and a tense, volatile atmosphere.", + "seed": 17449, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_7/index_8774_seed_17449_dp_15_rank_30_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.15244180709123611, + "vlm_logprob": -0.15244180709123611, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.474999988079071, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.15244180709123611, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving in a tracking motion through waist-high waves of golden wheat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure a young woman with long, dark brown hair that is sweat-soaked and matted?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a faded gray cotton T-shirt and dark blue jeans that are slightly frayed at the knees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman lower herself to the ground to avoid sight while pushing aside dense wheat stalks with panicky movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.47448474168777466 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3494846820831299 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.47448474168777466, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.8749999403953552, + "token_credit_reward": -0.47448474168777466, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1861109882593155, + 0.18106694519519806, + 0.0644850954413414, + 0.1204226091504097, + 0.08361046761274338, + 0.18407230079174042, + 0.05361352488398552, + 0.04153411090373993, + 0.03139110282063484, + 0.05369286239147186 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.47448474168777466 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving in a tracking motion through waist-high waves of golden wheat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure a young woman with long, dark brown hair that is sweat-soaked and matted?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a faded gray cotton T-shirt and dark blue jeans that are slightly frayed at the knees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman lower herself to the ground to avoid sight while pushing aside dense wheat stalks with panicky movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07016362994909286 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6951637268066406 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07016362994909286, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07016362994909286, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18602555990219116, + 0.08992074429988861, + 0.18318971991539001, + 0.12971219420433044, + 0.056374453008174896, + 0.04991021007299423, + 0.054061006754636765, + 0.07196918874979019, + 0.0618070550262928, + 0.11702986061573029 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07016362994909286 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving in a tracking motion through waist-high waves of golden wheat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure a young woman with long, dark brown hair that is sweat-soaked and matted?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a faded gray cotton T-shirt and dark blue jeans that are slightly frayed at the knees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman lower herself to the ground to avoid sight while pushing aside dense wheat stalks with panicky movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023312881588935852 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.77331280708313 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023312881588935852, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023312881588935852, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08548115193843842, + 0.31093573570251465, + 0.14053085446357727, + 0.04426419362425804, + 0.07074666768312454, + 0.057386573404073715, + 0.05281725153326988, + 0.030228951945900917, + 0.0545133613049984, + 0.15309523046016693 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023312881588935852 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving in a tracking motion through waist-high waves of golden wheat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure a young woman with long, dark brown hair that is sweat-soaked and matted?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a faded gray cotton T-shirt and dark blue jeans that are slightly frayed at the knees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman lower herself to the ground to avoid sight while pushing aside dense wheat stalks with panicky movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1605391949415207 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.910539150238037 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1605391949415207, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1605391949415207, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1344568431377411, + 0.17811919748783112, + 0.15311594307422638, + 0.05318094789981842, + 0.0840546265244484, + 0.07417422533035278, + 0.07126853615045547, + 0.042301151901483536, + 0.05089434236288071, + 0.1584341675043106 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1605391949415207 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving in a tracking motion through waist-high waves of golden wheat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure a young woman with long, dark brown hair that is sweat-soaked and matted?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a faded gray cotton T-shirt and dark blue jeans that are slightly frayed at the knees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman lower herself to the ground to avoid sight while pushing aside dense wheat stalks with panicky movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.033708587288856506 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4087085723876953 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.033708587288856506, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.033708587288856506, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11737112700939178, + 0.22969231009483337, + 0.027575362473726273, + 0.04995405673980713, + 0.08584658801555634, + 0.04766753315925598, + 0.05911498889327049, + 0.024872329086065292, + 0.04637538269162178, + 0.31153035163879395 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.033708587288856506 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "tense, low-angle tracking shot follows, the camera darting through waist-high waves of golden wheat, its frame fixed on a figure, bent low and struggling forward. This is a young woman with long, dark brown hair, sweat-soaked, matted tousled against her cheeks and neck. Her face is a mixture of fear and determination, her lower lip bitten, her eyes scanning the horizon warily. She wears a faded gray cotton T-shirt, clinging to her body, outlining her chest, which rises and falls with rapid breathing, and dark blue jeans, slightly frayed at the knees. She lowers herself to the ground, almost level with the tops of the wheat ears, to avoid possible sight. Her hands instinctively push aside the dense stalks in front of her, their movements swift and a touch panicky. The golden sunlight of dusk slants down at a low angle, tinting the endless wheat fields into a brilliant golden ocean. Each ear of wheat glows dazzlingly in the backlight, casting long, swaying shadows on and around her. A gentle breeze whips through the wheat fields, undulating like waves. The entire scene, a stunning pastoral landscape with an almost oil-painting quality, is permeated with a silent, breathtaking atmosphere of pursuit, filled with a stark contrast between idyllic tranquility and a tense, volatile atmosphere.", + "seed": 17450, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_7/index_8774_seed_17450_dp_15_rank_30_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.07787205129861832, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07787205129861832, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.0, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07787205129861832, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving in a tracking motion through waist-high waves of golden wheat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure a young woman with long, dark brown hair that is sweat-soaked and matted?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a faded gray cotton T-shirt and dark blue jeans that are slightly frayed at the knees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman lower herself to the ground to avoid sight while pushing aside dense wheat stalks with panicky movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2418806552886963 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8668806552886963 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2418806552886963, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2418806552886963, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09181082993745804, + 0.6360077261924744, + 0.04072481393814087, + 0.08750823885202408, + 0.03456064313650131, + 0.01707012951374054, + 0.01926768198609352, + 0.011564123444259167, + 0.03211218863725662, + 0.029373647645115852 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2418806552886963 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving in a tracking motion through waist-high waves of golden wheat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure a young woman with long, dark brown hair that is sweat-soaked and matted?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a faded gray cotton T-shirt and dark blue jeans that are slightly frayed at the knees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman lower herself to the ground to avoid sight while pushing aside dense wheat stalks with panicky movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.055055391043424606 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9300553798675537 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.055055391043424606, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.055055391043424606, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03716191276907921, + 0.727429211139679, + 0.10073329508304596, + 0.03497650474309921, + 0.03607069328427315, + 0.01177763007581234, + 0.011520661413669586, + 0.014770598150789738, + 0.007781187538057566, + 0.017778271809220314 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.055055391043424606 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving in a tracking motion through waist-high waves of golden wheat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure a young woman with long, dark brown hair that is sweat-soaked and matted?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a faded gray cotton T-shirt and dark blue jeans that are slightly frayed at the knees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman lower herself to the ground to avoid sight while pushing aside dense wheat stalks with panicky movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02059071511030197 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955907821655273 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02059071511030197, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02059071511030197, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.029923034831881523, + 0.7839123606681824, + 0.03039020299911499, + 0.035046547651290894, + 0.023083029314875603, + 0.01602538675069809, + 0.010980723425745964, + 0.01622406393289566, + 0.0391039215028286, + 0.015310739167034626 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 8, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02059071511030197 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving in a tracking motion through waist-high waves of golden wheat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure a young woman with long, dark brown hair that is sweat-soaked and matted?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a faded gray cotton T-shirt and dark blue jeans that are slightly frayed at the knees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman lower herself to the ground to avoid sight while pushing aside dense wheat stalks with panicky movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03813574090600014 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881357669830322 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03813574090600014, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03813574090600014, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.02730594389140606, + 0.6882826685905457, + 0.03546786308288574, + 0.04570159688591957, + 0.014395760372281075, + 0.018664250150322914, + 0.02617889828979969, + 0.035589419305324554, + 0.053726617246866226, + 0.05468691885471344 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03813574090600014 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving in a tracking motion through waist-high waves of golden wheat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure a young woman with long, dark brown hair that is sweat-soaked and matted?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a faded gray cotton T-shirt and dark blue jeans that are slightly frayed at the knees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman lower herself to the ground to avoid sight while pushing aside dense wheat stalks with panicky movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03369775414466858 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4086978435516357 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03369775414466858, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03369775414466858, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03858276829123497, + 0.6346672773361206, + 0.027604548260569572, + 0.03298934921622276, + 0.016919633373618126, + 0.03405574709177017, + 0.025805026292800903, + 0.037402812391519547, + 0.1312679946422577, + 0.02070474810898304 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03369775414466858 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_8/index_tensor([4320, 4320])_group_8_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_8/index_tensor([4320, 4320])_group_8_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..792701e1e5ebd4c0d82dea9b13650cd7a4c70a7d --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_8/index_tensor([4320, 4320])_group_8_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "slow, panning macro shot slides from left to right, revealing a tiny, jewel-like tree frog clinging tenaciously to the surface of a broad, waxy tropical leaf. The frog's skin is a vibrant, almost luminous green, shimmering like freshly sprayed mist, and each tiny water droplet on its back catches the light like a tiny prism. Its large, bulbous eyes are a striking liquid gold, with dark, vertical pupils, gazing calmly ahead. Its delicate limbs are spread, its sticky, rounded toe pads pressed firmly against the leaf, showcasing the incredible texture that allows it to defy gravity. The leaf itself is a deep green, its prominent veins creating channels for larger water droplets, which tremble with the slightest movement. A soft, diffuse light, like that filtering through the dense rainforest canopy after a recent downpour, illuminates the scene, creating soft highlights on the frog's damp skin and the damp leaf, while the background dissolves into a soft-focus tapestry of lush foliage. The atmosphere is one of serene focus and quiet wonder, the camera's deliberate, fluid movements inviting the viewer to closely observe the subtle beauty of this small creature in its natural, moist habitat.", + "seed": 24275, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_8/index_4320_seed_24275_dp_16_rank_32_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.14079824583604933, + "vlm_logprob": -0.14079824583604933, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.125, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.14079824583604933, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro view of a tiny tree frog on a broad leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the frog's skin a vibrant green with visible water droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the frog's eyes liquid gold with dark vertical pupils?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf deep green with prominent veins and water droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan slowly from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05449246987700462 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.054492473602295 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05449246987700462, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05449246987700462, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0666978508234024, + 0.030433660373091698, + 0.1171611100435257, + 0.036297619342803955, + 0.13173405826091766, + 0.06575348973274231, + 0.4928029179573059, + 0.029699362814426422, + 0.01541137509047985, + 0.014008539728820324 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05449246987700462 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro view of a tiny tree frog on a broad leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the frog's skin a vibrant green with visible water droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the frog's eyes liquid gold with dark vertical pupils?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf deep green with prominent veins and water droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan slowly from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020611969754099846 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8956120014190674 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020611969754099846, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020611969754099846, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2392958104610443, + 0.12687817215919495, + 0.17298486828804016, + 0.041708700358867645, + 0.11283507198095322, + 0.022367607802152634, + 0.16867244243621826, + 0.03590869531035423, + 0.05820431187748909, + 0.02114427462220192 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020611969754099846 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro view of a tiny tree frog on a broad leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the frog's skin a vibrant green with visible water droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the frog's eyes liquid gold with dark vertical pupils?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf deep green with prominent veins and water droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan slowly from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04866091161966324 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.04866099357605 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04866091161966324, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04866091161966324, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07163587212562561, + 0.12704123556613922, + 0.1175171434879303, + 0.03217489272356033, + 0.05284322053194046, + 0.03885822370648384, + 0.4009762108325958, + 0.04566722735762596, + 0.08765067905187607, + 0.025635289028286934 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04866091161966324 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro view of a tiny tree frog on a broad leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the frog's skin a vibrant green with visible water droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the frog's eyes liquid gold with dark vertical pupils?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf deep green with prominent veins and water droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan slowly from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004098706413060427 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504098892211914 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004098706413060427, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004098706413060427, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14990080893039703, + 0.06767608225345612, + 0.040101174265146255, + 0.02279919572174549, + 0.02766875922679901, + 0.01455878559499979, + 0.5801944732666016, + 0.027926938608288765, + 0.04483161121606827, + 0.024342164397239685 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004098706413060427 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro view of a tiny tree frog on a broad leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the frog's skin a vibrant green with visible water droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the frog's eyes liquid gold with dark vertical pupils?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf deep green with prominent veins and water droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan slowly from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5761271715164185 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8261271715164185 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5761271715164185, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5761271715164185, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03846662491559982, + 0.04675222188234329, + 0.04734471067786217, + 0.04704314097762108, + 0.02379150688648224, + 0.02561892941594124, + 0.28159064054489136, + 0.12593434751033783, + 0.3177438974380493, + 0.04571394994854927 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5761271715164185 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow, panning macro shot slides from left to right, revealing a tiny, jewel-like tree frog clinging tenaciously to the surface of a broad, waxy tropical leaf. The frog's skin is a vibrant, almost luminous green, shimmering like freshly sprayed mist, and each tiny water droplet on its back catches the light like a tiny prism. Its large, bulbous eyes are a striking liquid gold, with dark, vertical pupils, gazing calmly ahead. Its delicate limbs are spread, its sticky, rounded toe pads pressed firmly against the leaf, showcasing the incredible texture that allows it to defy gravity. The leaf itself is a deep green, its prominent veins creating channels for larger water droplets, which tremble with the slightest movement. A soft, diffuse light, like that filtering through the dense rainforest canopy after a recent downpour, illuminates the scene, creating soft highlights on the frog's damp skin and the damp leaf, while the background dissolves into a soft-focus tapestry of lush foliage. The atmosphere is one of serene focus and quiet wonder, the camera's deliberate, fluid movements inviting the viewer to closely observe the subtle beauty of this small creature in its natural, moist habitat.", + "seed": 24276, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_8/index_4320_seed_24276_dp_16_rank_32_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.08342924802564085, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08342924802564085, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.825, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08342924802564085, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro view of a tiny tree frog on a broad leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the frog's skin a vibrant green with visible water droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the frog's eyes liquid gold with dark vertical pupils?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf deep green with prominent veins and water droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan slowly from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.017162498086690903 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.392162322998047 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.017162498086690903, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.017162498086690903, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23457475006580353, + 0.18453854322433472, + 0.19321082532405853, + 0.08447820693254471, + 0.20588542520999908, + 0.010211066342890263, + 0.013945002108812332, + 0.015110037289559841, + 0.019734399393200874, + 0.03831178694963455 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.017162498086690903 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro view of a tiny tree frog on a broad leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the frog's skin a vibrant green with visible water droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the frog's eyes liquid gold with dark vertical pupils?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf deep green with prominent veins and water droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan slowly from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011099145747721195 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511099338531494 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011099145747721195, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011099145747721195, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3320969343185425, + 0.1303059309720993, + 0.08787024766206741, + 0.06944185495376587, + 0.0699099451303482, + 0.029242821037769318, + 0.033078569918870926, + 0.09912752360105515, + 0.07636359333992004, + 0.07256264984607697 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011099145747721195 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro view of a tiny tree frog on a broad leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the frog's skin a vibrant green with visible water droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the frog's eyes liquid gold with dark vertical pupils?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf deep green with prominent veins and water droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan slowly from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03809374198317528 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2880938053131104 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03809374198317528, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03809374198317528, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.36994022130966187, + 0.043932538479566574, + 0.39652019739151, + 0.09765921533107758, + 0.023839080706238747, + 0.02051066793501377, + 0.004324207082390785, + 0.006601675879210234, + 0.016596782952547073, + 0.02007545717060566 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03809374198317528 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro view of a tiny tree frog on a broad leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the frog's skin a vibrant green with visible water droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the frog's eyes liquid gold with dark vertical pupils?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf deep green with prominent veins and water droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan slowly from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0021983047481626272 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127198219299316 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0021983047481626272, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0021983047481626272, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12263687700033188, + 0.5343226790428162, + 0.0849696472287178, + 0.10778037458658218, + 0.021000511944293976, + 0.013630902394652367, + 0.021523652598261833, + 0.019667400047183037, + 0.026492340490221977, + 0.047975603491067886 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0021983047481626272 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro view of a tiny tree frog on a broad leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the frog's skin a vibrant green with visible water droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the frog's eyes liquid gold with dark vertical pupils?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf deep green with prominent veins and water droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan slowly from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3485925495624542 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2235925197601318 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3485925495624542, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3485925495624542, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19441385567188263, + 0.20750389993190765, + 0.16726168990135193, + 0.10413334518671036, + 0.05730205774307251, + 0.028082700446248055, + 0.03077276051044464, + 0.016125449910759926, + 0.12025970220565796, + 0.07414452731609344 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3485925495624542 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow, panning macro shot slides from left to right, revealing a tiny, jewel-like tree frog clinging tenaciously to the surface of a broad, waxy tropical leaf. The frog's skin is a vibrant, almost luminous green, shimmering like freshly sprayed mist, and each tiny water droplet on its back catches the light like a tiny prism. Its large, bulbous eyes are a striking liquid gold, with dark, vertical pupils, gazing calmly ahead. Its delicate limbs are spread, its sticky, rounded toe pads pressed firmly against the leaf, showcasing the incredible texture that allows it to defy gravity. The leaf itself is a deep green, its prominent veins creating channels for larger water droplets, which tremble with the slightest movement. A soft, diffuse light, like that filtering through the dense rainforest canopy after a recent downpour, illuminates the scene, creating soft highlights on the frog's damp skin and the damp leaf, while the background dissolves into a soft-focus tapestry of lush foliage. The atmosphere is one of serene focus and quiet wonder, the camera's deliberate, fluid movements inviting the viewer to closely observe the subtle beauty of this small creature in its natural, moist habitat.", + "seed": 24277, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_8/index_4320_seed_24277_dp_17_rank_34_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.25970761505886913, + "vlm_logprob": -0.25970761505886913, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.3500000119209288, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.25970761505886913, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro view of a tiny tree frog on a broad leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the frog's skin a vibrant green with visible water droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the frog's eyes liquid gold with dark vertical pupils?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf deep green with prominent veins and water droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan slowly from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0161437951028347 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.391143798828125 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0161437951028347, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0161437951028347, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14720679819583893, + 0.07841218262910843, + 0.11777176707983017, + 0.20055921375751495, + 0.058963220566511154, + 0.11373110860586166, + 0.052166897803545, + 0.12841175496578217, + 0.03083879128098488, + 0.07193826138973236 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0161437951028347 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro view of a tiny tree frog on a broad leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the frog's skin a vibrant green with visible water droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the frog's eyes liquid gold with dark vertical pupils?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf deep green with prominent veins and water droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan slowly from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018216218799352646 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018216133117676 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018216218799352646, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018216218799352646, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08199562877416611, + 0.08088331669569016, + 0.05502203479409218, + 0.10630404949188232, + 0.06329696625471115, + 0.2925877571105957, + 0.04190422594547272, + 0.16946764290332794, + 0.0663735643029213, + 0.04216481372714043 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 7, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018216218799352646 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro view of a tiny tree frog on a broad leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the frog's skin a vibrant green with visible water droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the frog's eyes liquid gold with dark vertical pupils?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf deep green with prominent veins and water droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan slowly from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03809133172035217 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2880914211273193 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03809133172035217, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03809133172035217, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3009400963783264, + 0.09179377555847168, + 0.04400031268596649, + 0.09818191826343536, + 0.05983225628733635, + 0.11529439687728882, + 0.11470188200473785, + 0.07612800598144531, + 0.04256134852766991, + 0.056565944105386734 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03809133172035217 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro view of a tiny tree frog on a broad leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the frog's skin a vibrant green with visible water droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the frog's eyes liquid gold with dark vertical pupils?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf deep green with prominent veins and water droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan slowly from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0024911104701459408 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002490997314453 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0024911104701459408, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0024911104701459408, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14931431412696838, + 0.0918092280626297, + 0.09311831742525101, + 0.07357752323150635, + 0.0747748613357544, + 0.26124468445777893, + 0.06797394156455994, + 0.07858429104089737, + 0.08485225588083267, + 0.02475065365433693 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0024911104701459408 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro view of a tiny tree frog on a broad leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the frog's skin a vibrant green with visible water droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the frog's eyes liquid gold with dark vertical pupils?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf deep green with prominent veins and water droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan slowly from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2235956192016602 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.34859567880630493 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.2235956192016602, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.8749999403953552, + "token_credit_reward": -1.2235956192016602, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24529658257961273, + 0.08351074159145355, + 0.06302585452795029, + 0.06494350731372833, + 0.0315215066075325, + 0.12683609127998352, + 0.12686963379383087, + 0.08771880716085434, + 0.03128191828727722, + 0.13899531960487366 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.2235956192016602 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow, panning macro shot slides from left to right, revealing a tiny, jewel-like tree frog clinging tenaciously to the surface of a broad, waxy tropical leaf. The frog's skin is a vibrant, almost luminous green, shimmering like freshly sprayed mist, and each tiny water droplet on its back catches the light like a tiny prism. Its large, bulbous eyes are a striking liquid gold, with dark, vertical pupils, gazing calmly ahead. Its delicate limbs are spread, its sticky, rounded toe pads pressed firmly against the leaf, showcasing the incredible texture that allows it to defy gravity. The leaf itself is a deep green, its prominent veins creating channels for larger water droplets, which tremble with the slightest movement. A soft, diffuse light, like that filtering through the dense rainforest canopy after a recent downpour, illuminates the scene, creating soft highlights on the frog's damp skin and the damp leaf, while the background dissolves into a soft-focus tapestry of lush foliage. The atmosphere is one of serene focus and quiet wonder, the camera's deliberate, fluid movements inviting the viewer to closely observe the subtle beauty of this small creature in its natural, moist habitat.", + "seed": 24278, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_8/index_4320_seed_24278_dp_17_rank_34_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.12571471971459686, + "vlm_logprob": -0.12571471971459686, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.85, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.12571471971459686, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro view of a tiny tree frog on a broad leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the frog's skin a vibrant green with visible water droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the frog's eyes liquid gold with dark vertical pupils?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf deep green with prominent veins and water droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan slowly from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01272769644856453 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.762727737426758 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01272769644856453, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01272769644856453, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1663293093442917, + 0.0502585805952549, + 0.12161760777235031, + 0.07240094244480133, + 0.04676710441708565, + 0.02052299492061138, + 0.1820663958787918, + 0.17347608506679535, + 0.08825854957103729, + 0.0783022940158844 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01272769644856453 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro view of a tiny tree frog on a broad leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the frog's skin a vibrant green with visible water droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the frog's eyes liquid gold with dark vertical pupils?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf deep green with prominent veins and water droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan slowly from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006753950379788876 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006753921508789 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006753950379788876, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006753950379788876, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14364999532699585, + 0.10014714300632477, + 0.05500061437487602, + 0.05390048027038574, + 0.044612739235162735, + 0.023725947365164757, + 0.16327635943889618, + 0.24099840223789215, + 0.11511608213186264, + 0.05957229435443878 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006753950379788876 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro view of a tiny tree frog on a broad leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the frog's skin a vibrant green with visible water droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the frog's eyes liquid gold with dark vertical pupils?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf deep green with prominent veins and water droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan slowly from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029798321425914764 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5297982692718506 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029798321425914764, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029798321425914764, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19843840599060059, + 0.16151078045368195, + 0.07643990218639374, + 0.060098107904195786, + 0.03637886792421341, + 0.021841544657945633, + 0.148603618144989, + 0.17788679897785187, + 0.06291201710700989, + 0.055889956653118134 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029798321425914764 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro view of a tiny tree frog on a broad leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the frog's skin a vibrant green with visible water droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the frog's eyes liquid gold with dark vertical pupils?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf deep green with prominent veins and water droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan slowly from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003193400101736188 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753193378448486 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003193400101736188, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003193400101736188, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17584413290023804, + 0.10942143201828003, + 0.056075531989336014, + 0.05479022487998009, + 0.04495450481772423, + 0.05580669268965721, + 0.1171698346734047, + 0.1538361757993698, + 0.14449214935302734, + 0.08760938793420792 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003193400101736188 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro view of a tiny tree frog on a broad leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the frog's skin a vibrant green with visible water droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the frog's eyes liquid gold with dark vertical pupils?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf deep green with prominent veins and water droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan slowly from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.57610023021698 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.82610023021698 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.57610023021698, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.57610023021698, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11983031779527664, + 0.09047476202249527, + 0.06308916956186295, + 0.09694229811429977, + 0.059697482734918594, + 0.06271936744451523, + 0.14512726664543152, + 0.04642181470990181, + 0.11189284920692444, + 0.203804612159729 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.57610023021698 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_9/index_tensor([3282, 3282])_group_9_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_9/index_tensor([3282, 3282])_group_9_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..c0acfe531ee0a23ab7c105580d231570943c6f31 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_9/index_tensor([3282, 3282])_group_9_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "low-angle, sideways tracking shot follows a monk at full gallop, the camera moving in sync with the horse's rapid movements, creating a powerful sense of speed. The central figure is a stern-faced monk, his shiny head gleaming in the twilight. He leans forward, gripping the reins tightly, merging with the muscular, mane-filled black steed beneath him. His magnificent brocade robes flutter like banners in the fierce wind, their intricate patterns of lotus and auspicious clouds woven with gold and multicolored silk threads shimmering in the rapid motion. The horse's hooves stamp vigorously on the cracked loess path, stirring up a trail of dust. Because the camera closely follows the subject, the outlines of the monk and his steed remain relatively clear, while the withered trees and weeds on either side of them, as well as the distant mountains, are stretched into blurred, flowing lines of color due to the extreme relative speed of the camera, greatly enhancing the visual impact of the lightning-fast speed. The entire scene is stained with a warm and dramatic golden hue by the setting sun. The light outlines the golden edges of the man and horse, casting long, swaying shadows, and creating an atmosphere of loneliness, determination, and epic spirit.", + "seed": 3305, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_9/index_3282_seed_3305_dp_18_rank_36_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.1361975316423923, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1361975316423923, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.25, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1361975316423923, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure a monk riding a black horse at full gallop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the monk's robes brocade with intricate patterns of lotus and auspicious clouds woven with gold and multicolored silk threads?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a cracked loess path with withered trees, weeds, and distant mountains in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene stained with a warm golden hue by the setting sun, outlining the subjects and casting long swaying shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle sideways tracking shot that moves in sync with the horse, causing the background to blur into flowing lines of color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11419875174760818 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.239198684692383 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11419875174760818, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11419875174760818, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08276081085205078, + 0.0401446670293808, + 0.037310242652893066, + 0.08625686913728714, + 0.06876692920923233, + 0.07701583951711655, + 0.29317161440849304, + 0.15805484354496002, + 0.0740303099155426, + 0.08248795568943024 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11419875174760818 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure a monk riding a black horse at full gallop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the monk's robes brocade with intricate patterns of lotus and auspicious clouds woven with gold and multicolored silk threads?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a cracked loess path with withered trees, weeds, and distant mountains in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene stained with a warm golden hue by the setting sun, outlining the subjects and casting long swaying shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle sideways tracking shot that moves in sync with the horse, causing the background to blur into flowing lines of color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5235947370529175 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8985947370529175 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5235947370529175, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5235947370529175, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1517779678106308, + 0.2164643555879593, + 0.05481213331222534, + 0.14167501032352448, + 0.04041695222258568, + 0.045476626604795456, + 0.12104533612728119, + 0.06881457567214966, + 0.0464431531727314, + 0.11307389289140701 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5235947370529175 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure a monk riding a black horse at full gallop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the monk's robes brocade with intricate patterns of lotus and auspicious clouds woven with gold and multicolored silk threads?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a cracked loess path with withered trees, weeds, and distant mountains in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene stained with a warm golden hue by the setting sun, outlining the subjects and casting long swaying shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle sideways tracking shot that moves in sync with the horse, causing the background to blur into flowing lines of color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00978671945631504 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634786605834961 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00978671945631504, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00978671945631504, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.061613135039806366, + 0.054860930889844894, + 0.03974509984254837, + 0.10135987401008606, + 0.044775623828172684, + 0.15832240879535675, + 0.03979798033833504, + 0.2573763430118561, + 0.1626988649368286, + 0.07944972068071365 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00978671945631504 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure a monk riding a black horse at full gallop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the monk's robes brocade with intricate patterns of lotus and auspicious clouds woven with gold and multicolored silk threads?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a cracked loess path with withered trees, weeds, and distant mountains in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene stained with a warm golden hue by the setting sun, outlining the subjects and casting long swaying shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle sideways tracking shot that moves in sync with the horse, causing the background to blur into flowing lines of color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036147984210401773 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628614902496338 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036147984210401773, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036147984210401773, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08931966125965118, + 0.05624109134078026, + 0.07991406321525574, + 0.14645817875862122, + 0.14329393208026886, + 0.04768223315477371, + 0.08959101885557175, + 0.15411873161792755, + 0.1123632863163948, + 0.08101779222488403 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036147984210401773 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure a monk riding a black horse at full gallop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the monk's robes brocade with intricate patterns of lotus and auspicious clouds woven with gold and multicolored silk threads?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a cracked loess path with withered trees, weeds, and distant mountains in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene stained with a warm golden hue by the setting sun, outlining the subjects and casting long swaying shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle sideways tracking shot that moves in sync with the horse, causing the background to blur into flowing lines of color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029792651534080505 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529792547225952 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029792651534080505, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029792651534080505, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15612775087356567, + 0.04109247773885727, + 0.0620901919901371, + 0.11142881214618683, + 0.08204013854265213, + 0.0686851367354393, + 0.09432877600193024, + 0.0751078873872757, + 0.1701059490442276, + 0.13899286091327667 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029792651534080505 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, sideways tracking shot follows a monk at full gallop, the camera moving in sync with the horse's rapid movements, creating a powerful sense of speed. The central figure is a stern-faced monk, his shiny head gleaming in the twilight. He leans forward, gripping the reins tightly, merging with the muscular, mane-filled black steed beneath him. His magnificent brocade robes flutter like banners in the fierce wind, their intricate patterns of lotus and auspicious clouds woven with gold and multicolored silk threads shimmering in the rapid motion. The horse's hooves stamp vigorously on the cracked loess path, stirring up a trail of dust. Because the camera closely follows the subject, the outlines of the monk and his steed remain relatively clear, while the withered trees and weeds on either side of them, as well as the distant mountains, are stretched into blurred, flowing lines of color due to the extreme relative speed of the camera, greatly enhancing the visual impact of the lightning-fast speed. The entire scene is stained with a warm and dramatic golden hue by the setting sun. The light outlines the golden edges of the man and horse, casting long, swaying shadows, and creating an atmosphere of loneliness, determination, and epic spirit.", + "seed": 3306, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_9/index_3282_seed_3306_dp_18_rank_36_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.26372362934052945, + "vlm_logprob": -0.26372362934052945, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.725, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.26372362934052945, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure a monk riding a black horse at full gallop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the monk's robes brocade with intricate patterns of lotus and auspicious clouds woven with gold and multicolored silk threads?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a cracked loess path with withered trees, weeds, and distant mountains in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene stained with a warm golden hue by the setting sun, outlining the subjects and casting long swaying shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle sideways tracking shot that moves in sync with the horse, causing the background to blur into flowing lines of color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20408062636852264 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.704080581665039 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20408062636852264, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20408062636852264, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.520521879196167, + 0.0934327244758606, + 0.037256624549627304, + 0.07384130358695984, + 0.04352344945073128, + 0.03549708425998688, + 0.028235744684934616, + 0.04101702570915222, + 0.03556099534034729, + 0.09111315757036209 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20408062636852264 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure a monk riding a black horse at full gallop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the monk's robes brocade with intricate patterns of lotus and auspicious clouds woven with gold and multicolored silk threads?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a cracked loess path with withered trees, weeds, and distant mountains in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene stained with a warm golden hue by the setting sun, outlining the subjects and casting long swaying shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle sideways tracking shot that moves in sync with the horse, causing the background to blur into flowing lines of color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.0541422367095947 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.42914220690727234 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.0541422367095947, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.625, + "token_credit_reward": -1.0541422367095947, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.49904003739356995, + 0.07078374922275543, + 0.07765942066907883, + 0.04016270488500595, + 0.027089374139904976, + 0.037565626204013824, + 0.026201460510492325, + 0.06034793332219124, + 0.09634988754987717, + 0.0647997111082077 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.0541422367095947 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure a monk riding a black horse at full gallop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the monk's robes brocade with intricate patterns of lotus and auspicious clouds woven with gold and multicolored silk threads?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a cracked loess path with withered trees, weeds, and distant mountains in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene stained with a warm golden hue by the setting sun, outlining the subjects and casting long swaying shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle sideways tracking shot that moves in sync with the horse, causing the background to blur into flowing lines of color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03811703622341156 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288116931915283 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03811703622341156, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03811703622341156, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.7556092143058777, + 0.028823183849453926, + 0.03761766478419304, + 0.05766204744577408, + 0.03360340744256973, + 0.013895711861550808, + 0.009983853437006474, + 0.03393933176994324, + 0.017914680764079094, + 0.01095083262771368 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03811703622341156 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure a monk riding a black horse at full gallop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the monk's robes brocade with intricate patterns of lotus and auspicious clouds woven with gold and multicolored silk threads?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a cracked loess path with withered trees, weeds, and distant mountains in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene stained with a warm golden hue by the setting sun, outlining the subjects and casting long swaying shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle sideways tracking shot that moves in sync with the horse, causing the background to blur into flowing lines of color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004096094518899918 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504096031188965 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004096094518899918, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004096094518899918, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.43539050221443176, + 0.12453128397464752, + 0.1302781105041504, + 0.048798758536577225, + 0.03295687213540077, + 0.06203920766711235, + 0.022668037563562393, + 0.04716606065630913, + 0.05017445608973503, + 0.04599670320749283 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004096094518899918 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure a monk riding a black horse at full gallop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the monk's robes brocade with intricate patterns of lotus and auspicious clouds woven with gold and multicolored silk threads?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a cracked loess path with withered trees, weeds, and distant mountains in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene stained with a warm golden hue by the setting sun, outlining the subjects and casting long swaying shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle sideways tracking shot that moves in sync with the horse, causing the background to blur into flowing lines of color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01818215288221836 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018182277679443 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01818215288221836, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01818215288221836, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.36275428533554077, + 0.09757599234580994, + 0.08518386632204056, + 0.03253592923283577, + 0.25563904643058777, + 0.038076844066381454, + 0.03501436114311218, + 0.027288660407066345, + 0.0319734551012516, + 0.033957451581954956 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01818215288221836 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, sideways tracking shot follows a monk at full gallop, the camera moving in sync with the horse's rapid movements, creating a powerful sense of speed. The central figure is a stern-faced monk, his shiny head gleaming in the twilight. He leans forward, gripping the reins tightly, merging with the muscular, mane-filled black steed beneath him. His magnificent brocade robes flutter like banners in the fierce wind, their intricate patterns of lotus and auspicious clouds woven with gold and multicolored silk threads shimmering in the rapid motion. The horse's hooves stamp vigorously on the cracked loess path, stirring up a trail of dust. Because the camera closely follows the subject, the outlines of the monk and his steed remain relatively clear, while the withered trees and weeds on either side of them, as well as the distant mountains, are stretched into blurred, flowing lines of color due to the extreme relative speed of the camera, greatly enhancing the visual impact of the lightning-fast speed. The entire scene is stained with a warm and dramatic golden hue by the setting sun. The light outlines the golden edges of the man and horse, casting long, swaying shadows, and creating an atmosphere of loneliness, determination, and epic spirit.", + "seed": 3307, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_9/index_3282_seed_3307_dp_19_rank_38_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.08542399127036333, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08542399127036333, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.625, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08542399127036333, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure a monk riding a black horse at full gallop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the monk's robes brocade with intricate patterns of lotus and auspicious clouds woven with gold and multicolored silk threads?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a cracked loess path with withered trees, weeds, and distant mountains in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene stained with a warm golden hue by the setting sun, outlining the subjects and casting long swaying shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle sideways tracking shot that moves in sync with the horse, causing the background to blur into flowing lines of color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08085164427757263 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5808515548706055 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08085164427757263, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08085164427757263, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08738179504871368, + 0.1143389418721199, + 0.049523670226335526, + 0.39324459433555603, + 0.045364998281002045, + 0.038482725620269775, + 0.06621203571557999, + 0.06879209727048874, + 0.08451849967241287, + 0.05214059725403786 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08085164427757263 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure a monk riding a black horse at full gallop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the monk's robes brocade with intricate patterns of lotus and auspicious clouds woven with gold and multicolored silk threads?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a cracked loess path with withered trees, weeds, and distant mountains in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene stained with a warm golden hue by the setting sun, outlining the subjects and casting long swaying shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle sideways tracking shot that moves in sync with the horse, causing the background to blur into flowing lines of color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3136105239391327 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.313610553741455 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3136105239391327, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3136105239391327, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15520969033241272, + 0.11394306272268295, + 0.06299154460430145, + 0.10402590781450272, + 0.03745247423648834, + 0.083879254758358, + 0.07495641708374023, + 0.08775661140680313, + 0.20043392479419708, + 0.07935111224651337 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3136105239391327 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure a monk riding a black horse at full gallop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the monk's robes brocade with intricate patterns of lotus and auspicious clouds woven with gold and multicolored silk threads?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a cracked loess path with withered trees, weeds, and distant mountains in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene stained with a warm golden hue by the setting sun, outlining the subjects and casting long swaying shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle sideways tracking shot that moves in sync with the horse, causing the background to blur into flowing lines of color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012539827264845371 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387539863586426 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012539827264845371, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012539827264845371, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22692590951919556, + 0.14157448709011078, + 0.04277397692203522, + 0.2948547601699829, + 0.062149133533239365, + 0.059231314808130264, + 0.03774328529834747, + 0.049999263137578964, + 0.049419429153203964, + 0.03532841429114342 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012539827264845371 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure a monk riding a black horse at full gallop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the monk's robes brocade with intricate patterns of lotus and auspicious clouds woven with gold and multicolored silk threads?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a cracked loess path with withered trees, weeds, and distant mountains in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene stained with a warm golden hue by the setting sun, outlining the subjects and casting long swaying shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle sideways tracking shot that moves in sync with the horse, causing the background to blur into flowing lines of color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.001939084380865097 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.251939296722412 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.001939084380865097, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.001939084380865097, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17985470592975616, + 0.3950011432170868, + 0.03115108422935009, + 0.16807147860527039, + 0.050632864236831665, + 0.04415181651711464, + 0.020425571128726006, + 0.04549732804298401, + 0.02837834693491459, + 0.03683559596538544 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.001939084380865097 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure a monk riding a black horse at full gallop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the monk's robes brocade with intricate patterns of lotus and auspicious clouds woven with gold and multicolored silk threads?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a cracked loess path with withered trees, weeds, and distant mountains in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene stained with a warm golden hue by the setting sun, outlining the subjects and casting long swaying shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle sideways tracking shot that moves in sync with the horse, causing the background to blur into flowing lines of color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018178876489400864 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018178939819336 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018178876489400864, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018178876489400864, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11502567678689957, + 0.2645227313041687, + 0.07664456218481064, + 0.08291739225387573, + 0.07459676265716553, + 0.038853295147418976, + 0.09169655293226242, + 0.09340064227581024, + 0.10019416362047195, + 0.06214819476008415 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018178876489400864 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, sideways tracking shot follows a monk at full gallop, the camera moving in sync with the horse's rapid movements, creating a powerful sense of speed. The central figure is a stern-faced monk, his shiny head gleaming in the twilight. He leans forward, gripping the reins tightly, merging with the muscular, mane-filled black steed beneath him. His magnificent brocade robes flutter like banners in the fierce wind, their intricate patterns of lotus and auspicious clouds woven with gold and multicolored silk threads shimmering in the rapid motion. The horse's hooves stamp vigorously on the cracked loess path, stirring up a trail of dust. Because the camera closely follows the subject, the outlines of the monk and his steed remain relatively clear, while the withered trees and weeds on either side of them, as well as the distant mountains, are stretched into blurred, flowing lines of color due to the extreme relative speed of the camera, greatly enhancing the visual impact of the lightning-fast speed. The entire scene is stained with a warm and dramatic golden hue by the setting sun. The light outlines the golden edges of the man and horse, casting long, swaying shadows, and creating an atmosphere of loneliness, determination, and epic spirit.", + "seed": 3308, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000044/group_9/index_3282_seed_3308_dp_19_rank_38_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.06510316729545593, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06510316729545593, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.575, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06510316729545593, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure a monk riding a black horse at full gallop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the monk's robes brocade with intricate patterns of lotus and auspicious clouds woven with gold and multicolored silk threads?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a cracked loess path with withered trees, weeds, and distant mountains in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene stained with a warm golden hue by the setting sun, outlining the subjects and casting long swaying shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle sideways tracking shot that moves in sync with the horse, causing the background to blur into flowing lines of color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.09031958878040314 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4653196334838867 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.09031958878040314, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.09031958878040314, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08021838217973709, + 0.024104217067360878, + 0.032137371599674225, + 0.07076968997716904, + 0.46777698397636414, + 0.05494208261370659, + 0.09279372543096542, + 0.020467134192585945, + 0.0716003030538559, + 0.08519014716148376 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.09031958878040314 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure a monk riding a black horse at full gallop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the monk's robes brocade with intricate patterns of lotus and auspicious clouds woven with gold and multicolored silk threads?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a cracked loess path with withered trees, weeds, and distant mountains in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene stained with a warm golden hue by the setting sun, outlining the subjects and casting long swaying shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle sideways tracking shot that moves in sync with the horse, causing the background to blur into flowing lines of color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.201743483543396 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.701743483543396 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.201743483543396, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.201743483543396, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05054119601845741, + 0.05211261287331581, + 0.02082759514451027, + 0.033452730625867844, + 0.072545625269413, + 0.03871200978755951, + 0.08167636394500732, + 0.10236601531505585, + 0.389172226190567, + 0.15859371423721313 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.201743483543396 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure a monk riding a black horse at full gallop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the monk's robes brocade with intricate patterns of lotus and auspicious clouds woven with gold and multicolored silk threads?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a cracked loess path with withered trees, weeds, and distant mountains in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene stained with a warm golden hue by the setting sun, outlining the subjects and casting long swaying shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle sideways tracking shot that moves in sync with the horse, causing the background to blur into flowing lines of color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007630250882357359 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882630348205566 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007630250882357359, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007630250882357359, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19553905725479126, + 0.10196162760257721, + 0.051481399685144424, + 0.06413708627223969, + 0.07637163996696472, + 0.08692736178636551, + 0.07097472995519638, + 0.08300948143005371, + 0.18396782875061035, + 0.08562975376844406 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007630250882357359 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure a monk riding a black horse at full gallop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the monk's robes brocade with intricate patterns of lotus and auspicious clouds woven with gold and multicolored silk threads?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a cracked loess path with withered trees, weeds, and distant mountains in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene stained with a warm golden hue by the setting sun, outlining the subjects and casting long swaying shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle sideways tracking shot that moves in sync with the horse, causing the background to blur into flowing lines of color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005251067224889994 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255250930786133 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005251067224889994, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005251067224889994, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12921498715877533, + 0.03263091295957565, + 0.05884161219000816, + 0.06637272983789444, + 0.12546950578689575, + 0.06692329794168472, + 0.12646202743053436, + 0.15714651346206665, + 0.10412535816431046, + 0.13281306624412537 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005251067224889994 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure a monk riding a black horse at full gallop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the monk's robes brocade with intricate patterns of lotus and auspicious clouds woven with gold and multicolored silk threads?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a cracked loess path with withered trees, weeds, and distant mountains in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene stained with a warm golden hue by the setting sun, outlining the subjects and casting long swaying shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle sideways tracking shot that moves in sync with the horse, causing the background to blur into flowing lines of color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020571446046233177 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.89557147026062 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020571446046233177, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020571446046233177, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10702884942293167, + 0.02949562668800354, + 0.024010786786675453, + 0.07578816264867783, + 0.13628242909908295, + 0.07393012195825577, + 0.17201852798461914, + 0.11444872617721558, + 0.10147804766893387, + 0.16551879048347473 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020571446046233177 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_0/index_tensor([7324, 7324])_group_0_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_0/index_tensor([7324, 7324])_group_0_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..323f83ab95a38fd194303ef86ea24fb965dafcb2 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_0/index_tensor([7324, 7324])_group_0_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "static, first-person perspective shot looks directly down upon a massive architectural blueprint, spread across a dark, matte drafting table. The design's intricate, sharp lines represent complex structures and pathways, glowing a brilliant, inner cyan against the deep indigo paper. This perfect digital precision dissolves as the luminescent ink begins to accumulate, forming shimmering beads of liquid directly onto the glowing carrier lines. Then, slowly and relentlessly, these droplets of pure light begin to leak outward, smudged from their defined paths as the glowing liquid bleeds across the surface of the paper, smudged the clear geometric patterns into a soft, ethereal blur, and coalesced at intersections to create even brighter nodes of light before spilling out in fragile, uncontrolled tendrils. This self-luminous ink casts a cool, otherworldly glow, contrasting starkly with the warm, dim ambient light of the surrounding, unseen room, creating a focused, captivating atmosphere of magical transformation.", + "seed": 9609, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_0/index_7324_seed_9609_dp_0_rank_0_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.061568094044923784, + "vlm_logprob": -0.061568094044923784, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.925, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.061568094044923784, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, first-person perspective looking directly down at a massive architectural blueprint?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the blueprint spread across a dark, matte drafting table with sharp lines glowing brilliant cyan against deep indigo paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the glowing ink dissolve into shimmering beads of liquid that leak outward and smudge the geometric patterns into a soft blur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the smudged lines coalesce at intersections to create brighter nodes of light before spilling out in fragile, uncontrolled tendrils?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the self-luminous ink cast a cool, otherworldly glow that contrasts with the warm, dim ambient light of the surrounding room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04004139453172684 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.290041446685791 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04004139453172684, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04004139453172684, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22393439710140228, + 0.07570187747478485, + 0.05158606544137001, + 0.11713940650224686, + 0.09079638868570328, + 0.11747360974550247, + 0.05552615970373154, + 0.07064484804868698, + 0.08998890966176987, + 0.10720834881067276 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04004139453172684 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, first-person perspective looking directly down at a massive architectural blueprint?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the blueprint spread across a dark, matte drafting table with sharp lines glowing brilliant cyan against deep indigo paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the glowing ink dissolve into shimmering beads of liquid that leak outward and smudge the geometric patterns into a soft blur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the smudged lines coalesce at intersections to create brighter nodes of light before spilling out in fragile, uncontrolled tendrils?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the self-luminous ink cast a cool, otherworldly glow that contrasts with the warm, dim ambient light of the surrounding room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.038130808621644974 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288130760192871 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.038130808621644974, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.038130808621644974, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.228652685880661, + 0.1649535447359085, + 0.07266441732645035, + 0.0655321553349495, + 0.08911705762147903, + 0.0848931074142456, + 0.0309109166264534, + 0.047917865216732025, + 0.08729981631040573, + 0.12805843353271484 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.038130808621644974 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, first-person perspective looking directly down at a massive architectural blueprint?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the blueprint spread across a dark, matte drafting table with sharp lines glowing brilliant cyan against deep indigo paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the glowing ink dissolve into shimmering beads of liquid that leak outward and smudge the geometric patterns into a soft blur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the smudged lines coalesce at intersections to create brighter nodes of light before spilling out in fragile, uncontrolled tendrils?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the self-luminous ink cast a cool, otherworldly glow that contrasts with the warm, dim ambient light of the surrounding room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03811325132846832 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881133556365967 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03811325132846832, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03811325132846832, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08371740579605103, + 0.026022490113973618, + 0.036349110305309296, + 0.18287746608257294, + 0.06600841879844666, + 0.06409772485494614, + 0.09583789110183716, + 0.10725171118974686, + 0.20983144640922546, + 0.12800627946853638 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03811325132846832 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, first-person perspective looking directly down at a massive architectural blueprint?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the blueprint spread across a dark, matte drafting table with sharp lines glowing brilliant cyan against deep indigo paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the glowing ink dissolve into shimmering beads of liquid that leak outward and smudge the geometric patterns into a soft blur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the smudged lines coalesce at intersections to create brighter nodes of light before spilling out in fragile, uncontrolled tendrils?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the self-luminous ink cast a cool, otherworldly glow that contrasts with the warm, dim ambient light of the surrounding room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14282484352588654 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.01782488822937 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14282484352588654, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14282484352588654, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14609064161777496, + 0.07676049321889877, + 0.038984254002571106, + 0.08127596974372864, + 0.11881235986948013, + 0.05301937088370323, + 0.07642683386802673, + 0.1037314385175705, + 0.17662331461906433, + 0.12827524542808533 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14282484352588654 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, first-person perspective looking directly down at a massive architectural blueprint?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the blueprint spread across a dark, matte drafting table with sharp lines glowing brilliant cyan against deep indigo paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the glowing ink dissolve into shimmering beads of liquid that leak outward and smudge the geometric patterns into a soft blur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the smudged lines coalesce at intersections to create brighter nodes of light before spilling out in fragile, uncontrolled tendrils?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the self-luminous ink cast a cool, otherworldly glow that contrasts with the warm, dim ambient light of the surrounding room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04873017221689224 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0487301349639893 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04873017221689224, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04873017221689224, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22009088099002838, + 0.09824525564908981, + 0.1259598433971405, + 0.0608336478471756, + 0.0638909861445427, + 0.042616311460733414, + 0.0370250828564167, + 0.061582401394844055, + 0.0869767889380455, + 0.20277883112430573 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04873017221689224 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, first-person perspective shot looks directly down upon a massive architectural blueprint, spread across a dark, matte drafting table. The design's intricate, sharp lines represent complex structures and pathways, glowing a brilliant, inner cyan against the deep indigo paper. This perfect digital precision dissolves as the luminescent ink begins to accumulate, forming shimmering beads of liquid directly onto the glowing carrier lines. Then, slowly and relentlessly, these droplets of pure light begin to leak outward, smudged from their defined paths as the glowing liquid bleeds across the surface of the paper, smudged the clear geometric patterns into a soft, ethereal blur, and coalesced at intersections to create even brighter nodes of light before spilling out in fragile, uncontrolled tendrils. This self-luminous ink casts a cool, otherworldly glow, contrasting starkly with the warm, dim ambient light of the surrounding, unseen room, creating a focused, captivating atmosphere of magical transformation.", + "seed": 9610, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_0/index_7324_seed_9610_dp_0_rank_0_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.09292620643973351, + "vlm_logprob": -0.09292620643973351, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.475, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.09292620643973351, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, first-person perspective looking directly down at a massive architectural blueprint?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the blueprint spread across a dark, matte drafting table with sharp lines glowing brilliant cyan against deep indigo paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the glowing ink dissolve into shimmering beads of liquid that leak outward and smudge the geometric patterns into a soft blur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the smudged lines coalesce at intersections to create brighter nodes of light before spilling out in fragile, uncontrolled tendrils?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the self-luminous ink cast a cool, otherworldly glow that contrasts with the warm, dim ambient light of the surrounding room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11391402781009674 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2389140129089355 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11391402781009674, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11391402781009674, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.30433189868927, + 0.056886013597249985, + 0.13812094926834106, + 0.052823930978775024, + 0.0595979243516922, + 0.042480409145355225, + 0.06602746993303299, + 0.11083166301250458, + 0.05461316183209419, + 0.11428651213645935 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11391402781009674 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, first-person perspective looking directly down at a massive architectural blueprint?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the blueprint spread across a dark, matte drafting table with sharp lines glowing brilliant cyan against deep indigo paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the glowing ink dissolve into shimmering beads of liquid that leak outward and smudge the geometric patterns into a soft blur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the smudged lines coalesce at intersections to create brighter nodes of light before spilling out in fragile, uncontrolled tendrils?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the self-luminous ink cast a cool, otherworldly glow that contrasts with the warm, dim ambient light of the surrounding room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17993636429309845 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.804936408996582 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17993636429309845, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17993636429309845, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24991878867149353, + 0.0662621259689331, + 0.09075663983821869, + 0.12281098961830139, + 0.07438421994447708, + 0.05524105578660965, + 0.04523177817463875, + 0.1265176683664322, + 0.050031546503305435, + 0.11884516477584839 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17993636429309845 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, first-person perspective looking directly down at a massive architectural blueprint?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the blueprint spread across a dark, matte drafting table with sharp lines glowing brilliant cyan against deep indigo paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the glowing ink dissolve into shimmering beads of liquid that leak outward and smudge the geometric patterns into a soft blur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the smudged lines coalesce at intersections to create brighter nodes of light before spilling out in fragile, uncontrolled tendrils?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the self-luminous ink cast a cool, otherworldly glow that contrasts with the warm, dim ambient light of the surrounding room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04867181181907654 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486717224121094 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04867181181907654, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04867181181907654, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.27243107557296753, + 0.09027322381734848, + 0.11466360837221146, + 0.05175668001174927, + 0.05887032672762871, + 0.04309628903865814, + 0.049858514219522476, + 0.07079605013132095, + 0.06176760047674179, + 0.18648670613765717 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04867181181907654 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, first-person perspective looking directly down at a massive architectural blueprint?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the blueprint spread across a dark, matte drafting table with sharp lines glowing brilliant cyan against deep indigo paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the glowing ink dissolve into shimmering beads of liquid that leak outward and smudge the geometric patterns into a soft blur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the smudged lines coalesce at intersections to create brighter nodes of light before spilling out in fragile, uncontrolled tendrils?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the self-luminous ink cast a cool, otherworldly glow that contrasts with the warm, dim ambient light of the surrounding room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07899781316518784 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.578997850418091 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07899781316518784, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07899781316518784, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3995157480239868, + 0.040791090577840805, + 0.06042975187301636, + 0.055795617401599884, + 0.036451756954193115, + 0.06645243614912033, + 0.0388941764831543, + 0.03629348799586296, + 0.05348911136388779, + 0.21188680827617645 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07899781316518784 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, first-person perspective looking directly down at a massive architectural blueprint?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the blueprint spread across a dark, matte drafting table with sharp lines glowing brilliant cyan against deep indigo paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the glowing ink dissolve into shimmering beads of liquid that leak outward and smudge the geometric patterns into a soft blur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the smudged lines coalesce at intersections to create brighter nodes of light before spilling out in fragile, uncontrolled tendrils?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the self-luminous ink cast a cool, otherworldly glow that contrasts with the warm, dim ambient light of the surrounding room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04311101511120796 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1681110858917236 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04311101511120796, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04311101511120796, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13917505741119385, + 0.06220544874668121, + 0.34506186842918396, + 0.08481881022453308, + 0.021816665306687355, + 0.023564478382468224, + 0.021616660058498383, + 0.06891758739948273, + 0.021909082308411598, + 0.21091429889202118 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04311101511120796 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, first-person perspective shot looks directly down upon a massive architectural blueprint, spread across a dark, matte drafting table. The design's intricate, sharp lines represent complex structures and pathways, glowing a brilliant, inner cyan against the deep indigo paper. This perfect digital precision dissolves as the luminescent ink begins to accumulate, forming shimmering beads of liquid directly onto the glowing carrier lines. Then, slowly and relentlessly, these droplets of pure light begin to leak outward, smudged from their defined paths as the glowing liquid bleeds across the surface of the paper, smudged the clear geometric patterns into a soft, ethereal blur, and coalesced at intersections to create even brighter nodes of light before spilling out in fragile, uncontrolled tendrils. This self-luminous ink casts a cool, otherworldly glow, contrasting starkly with the warm, dim ambient light of the surrounding, unseen room, creating a focused, captivating atmosphere of magical transformation.", + "seed": 9611, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_0/index_7324_seed_9611_dp_1_rank_2_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.17120208367705345, + "vlm_logprob": -0.17120208367705345, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.675, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.17120208367705345, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, first-person perspective looking directly down at a massive architectural blueprint?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the blueprint spread across a dark, matte drafting table with sharp lines glowing brilliant cyan against deep indigo paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the glowing ink dissolve into shimmering beads of liquid that leak outward and smudge the geometric patterns into a soft blur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the smudged lines coalesce at intersections to create brighter nodes of light before spilling out in fragile, uncontrolled tendrils?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the self-luminous ink cast a cool, otherworldly glow that contrasts with the warm, dim ambient light of the surrounding room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03980623558163643 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2898061275482178 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03980623558163643, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03980623558163643, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25845450162887573, + 0.09359036386013031, + 0.0633433610200882, + 0.04618058726191521, + 0.12924987077713013, + 0.09019432216882706, + 0.09677621722221375, + 0.09278043359518051, + 0.07174443453550339, + 0.057685866951942444 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03980623558163643 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, first-person perspective looking directly down at a massive architectural blueprint?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the blueprint spread across a dark, matte drafting table with sharp lines glowing brilliant cyan against deep indigo paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the glowing ink dissolve into shimmering beads of liquid that leak outward and smudge the geometric patterns into a soft blur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the smudged lines coalesce at intersections to create brighter nodes of light before spilling out in fragile, uncontrolled tendrils?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the self-luminous ink cast a cool, otherworldly glow that contrasts with the warm, dim ambient light of the surrounding room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05497878044843674 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929978847503662 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05497878044843674, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05497878044843674, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11748582869768143, + 0.04359092563390732, + 0.06854210048913956, + 0.04871109127998352, + 0.11198832094669342, + 0.11421916633844376, + 0.24172624945640564, + 0.05351606383919716, + 0.14778193831443787, + 0.05243830755352974 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05497878044843674 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, first-person perspective looking directly down at a massive architectural blueprint?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the blueprint spread across a dark, matte drafting table with sharp lines glowing brilliant cyan against deep indigo paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the glowing ink dissolve into shimmering beads of liquid that leak outward and smudge the geometric patterns into a soft blur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the smudged lines coalesce at intersections to create brighter nodes of light before spilling out in fragile, uncontrolled tendrils?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the self-luminous ink cast a cool, otherworldly glow that contrasts with the warm, dim ambient light of the surrounding room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012554306536912918 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387554168701172 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012554306536912918, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012554306536912918, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1152641624212265, + 0.038179583847522736, + 0.05077651888132095, + 0.036652110517024994, + 0.22761468589305878, + 0.08219024538993835, + 0.07053486257791519, + 0.04434402287006378, + 0.07387994974851608, + 0.26056379079818726 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012554306536912918 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, first-person perspective looking directly down at a massive architectural blueprint?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the blueprint spread across a dark, matte drafting table with sharp lines glowing brilliant cyan against deep indigo paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the glowing ink dissolve into shimmering beads of liquid that leak outward and smudge the geometric patterns into a soft blur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the smudged lines coalesce at intersections to create brighter nodes of light before spilling out in fragile, uncontrolled tendrils?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the self-luminous ink cast a cool, otherworldly glow that contrasts with the warm, dim ambient light of the surrounding room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05499796196818352 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299979209899902 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05499796196818352, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05499796196818352, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12003882974386215, + 0.058163389563560486, + 0.08679398149251938, + 0.03207526355981827, + 0.2142694741487503, + 0.09926104545593262, + 0.04784982278943062, + 0.10213200002908707, + 0.09065070748329163, + 0.14876554906368256 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05499796196818352 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, first-person perspective looking directly down at a massive architectural blueprint?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the blueprint spread across a dark, matte drafting table with sharp lines glowing brilliant cyan against deep indigo paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the glowing ink dissolve into shimmering beads of liquid that leak outward and smudge the geometric patterns into a soft blur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the smudged lines coalesce at intersections to create brighter nodes of light before spilling out in fragile, uncontrolled tendrils?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the self-luminous ink cast a cool, otherworldly glow that contrasts with the warm, dim ambient light of the surrounding room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6936731338500977 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6936731338500977 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.6936731338500977, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.6936731338500977, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3512546122074127, + 0.16158953309059143, + 0.03958454728126526, + 0.03484451025724411, + 0.06714410334825516, + 0.07473776489496231, + 0.05598843842744827, + 0.051819294691085815, + 0.05306916683912277, + 0.10996799916028976 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.6936731338500977 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, first-person perspective shot looks directly down upon a massive architectural blueprint, spread across a dark, matte drafting table. The design's intricate, sharp lines represent complex structures and pathways, glowing a brilliant, inner cyan against the deep indigo paper. This perfect digital precision dissolves as the luminescent ink begins to accumulate, forming shimmering beads of liquid directly onto the glowing carrier lines. Then, slowly and relentlessly, these droplets of pure light begin to leak outward, smudged from their defined paths as the glowing liquid bleeds across the surface of the paper, smudged the clear geometric patterns into a soft, ethereal blur, and coalesced at intersections to create even brighter nodes of light before spilling out in fragile, uncontrolled tendrils. This self-luminous ink casts a cool, otherworldly glow, contrasting starkly with the warm, dim ambient light of the surrounding, unseen room, creating a focused, captivating atmosphere of magical transformation.", + "seed": 9612, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_0/index_7324_seed_9612_dp_1_rank_2_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.16659847572445868, + "vlm_logprob": -0.16659847572445868, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.875, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.16659847572445868, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, first-person perspective looking directly down at a massive architectural blueprint?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the blueprint spread across a dark, matte drafting table with sharp lines glowing brilliant cyan against deep indigo paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the glowing ink dissolve into shimmering beads of liquid that leak outward and smudge the geometric patterns into a soft blur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the smudged lines coalesce at intersections to create brighter nodes of light before spilling out in fragile, uncontrolled tendrils?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the self-luminous ink cast a cool, otherworldly glow that contrasts with the warm, dim ambient light of the surrounding room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3508630096912384 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.225862979888916 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3508630096912384, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3508630096912384, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10825978219509125, + 0.05045293644070625, + 0.023349624127149582, + 0.10198690742254257, + 0.04766993224620819, + 0.3243297040462494, + 0.06857582926750183, + 0.09138675034046173, + 0.153461754322052, + 0.03052668273448944 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3508630096912384 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, first-person perspective looking directly down at a massive architectural blueprint?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the blueprint spread across a dark, matte drafting table with sharp lines glowing brilliant cyan against deep indigo paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the glowing ink dissolve into shimmering beads of liquid that leak outward and smudge the geometric patterns into a soft blur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the smudged lines coalesce at intersections to create brighter nodes of light before spilling out in fragile, uncontrolled tendrils?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the self-luminous ink cast a cool, otherworldly glow that contrasts with the warm, dim ambient light of the surrounding room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1271038055419922 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.127103805541992 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1271038055419922, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1271038055419922, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14654046297073364, + 0.09705280512571335, + 0.04082994535565376, + 0.055570490658283234, + 0.04551568627357483, + 0.29836350679397583, + 0.045838553458452225, + 0.15505605936050415, + 0.04609258472919464, + 0.06913997232913971 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1271038055419922 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, first-person perspective looking directly down at a massive architectural blueprint?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the blueprint spread across a dark, matte drafting table with sharp lines glowing brilliant cyan against deep indigo paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the glowing ink dissolve into shimmering beads of liquid that leak outward and smudge the geometric patterns into a soft blur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the smudged lines coalesce at intersections to create brighter nodes of light before spilling out in fragile, uncontrolled tendrils?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the self-luminous ink cast a cool, otherworldly glow that contrasts with the warm, dim ambient light of the surrounding room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.062068674713373184 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120687007904053 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.062068674713373184, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.062068674713373184, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08298688381910324, + 0.022168489173054695, + 0.023144148290157318, + 0.6303334832191467, + 0.06111519783735275, + 0.03895255923271179, + 0.038277823477983475, + 0.04338408261537552, + 0.039043109863996506, + 0.020594170317053795 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.062068674713373184 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, first-person perspective looking directly down at a massive architectural blueprint?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the blueprint spread across a dark, matte drafting table with sharp lines glowing brilliant cyan against deep indigo paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the glowing ink dissolve into shimmering beads of liquid that leak outward and smudge the geometric patterns into a soft blur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the smudged lines coalesce at intersections to create brighter nodes of light before spilling out in fragile, uncontrolled tendrils?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the self-luminous ink cast a cool, otherworldly glow that contrasts with the warm, dim ambient light of the surrounding room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11296695470809937 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.237967014312744 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11296695470809937, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11296695470809937, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09272036701440811, + 0.03591541200876236, + 0.025524485856294632, + 0.5805500745773315, + 0.056115083396434784, + 0.06582815200090408, + 0.03674551099538803, + 0.031637080013751984, + 0.05150701478123665, + 0.0234568752348423 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11296695470809937 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, first-person perspective looking directly down at a massive architectural blueprint?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the blueprint spread across a dark, matte drafting table with sharp lines glowing brilliant cyan against deep indigo paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the glowing ink dissolve into shimmering beads of liquid that leak outward and smudge the geometric patterns into a soft blur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the smudged lines coalesce at intersections to create brighter nodes of light before spilling out in fragile, uncontrolled tendrils?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the self-luminous ink cast a cool, otherworldly glow that contrasts with the warm, dim ambient light of the surrounding room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17998993396759033 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8049899339675903 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17998993396759033, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17998993396759033, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17729823291301727, + 0.04615132883191109, + 0.03473644703626633, + 0.3986758291721344, + 0.04865388199687004, + 0.12655040621757507, + 0.027439095079898834, + 0.026346100494265556, + 0.07265741378068924, + 0.041491251438856125 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17998993396759033 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_1/index_tensor([6560, 6560])_group_1_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_1/index_tensor([6560, 6560])_group_1_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..c64354bcc06384aa4b386a4b3804bda481e50680 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_1/index_tensor([6560, 6560])_group_1_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "static, high-angle close-up captures a meticulously orchestrated scientific procedure on a sterile stainless steel workbench, beneath bright, even overhead fluorescent lighting. A pair of hands, clad in tight-fitting blue butyl gloves, manipulate with precision. The gloved right hand first firmly grasps a clear plastic syringe with black measurement markings and shakes it quickly and deliberately to mix the clear liquid within. Simultaneously, the gloved left hand steadily slides a clear, round Petri dish across the reflective steel surface and into the center of the frame. The right hand then moves to a small glass bottle, deftly unscrewing the plastic cap and carefully placing it on a plain white cardboard box nearby. After another quick shake of the syringe, the right hand guides the needle, decisively inserting it into the bottle's rubber stopper. The left hand then carefully lifts the lid of the Petri dish and secures it above the base. The right hand tilts the syringe over the open Petri dish, carefully pressing the plunger with its thumb, releasing a few drops of clear liquid onto the culture medium within, keeping it steady. The syringe is then smoothly lifted, and the left hand instantly and precisely closes the cap, sealing the Petri dish, creating a clinical and highly professional atmosphere throughout the entire process.", + "seed": 22396, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_1/index_6560_seed_22396_dp_2_rank_4_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.03684135042130947, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03684135042130947, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.475, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03684135042130947, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a static high-angle close-up perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the hands wearing tight-fitting blue butyl gloves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the right hand shake a clear plastic syringe with black measurement markings to mix liquid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the right hand insert the syringe needle into a small glass bottle with a rubber stopper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the right hand release clear liquid from the syringe into a clear round Petri dish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07306163758039474 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.69806170463562 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07306163758039474, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07306163758039474, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22221224009990692, + 0.10787142813205719, + 0.1096513569355011, + 0.06450525671243668, + 0.09479282796382904, + 0.03642559424042702, + 0.11197967082262039, + 0.09391885995864868, + 0.05161428824067116, + 0.1070285439491272 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07306163758039474 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a static high-angle close-up perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the hands wearing tight-fitting blue butyl gloves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the right hand shake a clear plastic syringe with black measurement markings to mix liquid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the right hand insert the syringe needle into a small glass bottle with a rubber stopper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the right hand release clear liquid from the syringe into a clear round Petri dish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011091010645031929 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511091232299805 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011091010645031929, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011091010645031929, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5706796646118164, + 0.03106379322707653, + 0.06374035030603409, + 0.03994873911142349, + 0.02143886126577854, + 0.05760787054896355, + 0.03833526372909546, + 0.05604174733161926, + 0.03952161595225334, + 0.08162209391593933 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011091010645031929 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a static high-angle close-up perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the hands wearing tight-fitting blue butyl gloves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the right hand shake a clear plastic syringe with black measurement markings to mix liquid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the right hand insert the syringe needle into a small glass bottle with a rubber stopper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the right hand release clear liquid from the syringe into a clear round Petri dish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023301001638174057 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773300886154175 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023301001638174057, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023301001638174057, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24838313460350037, + 0.14707119762897491, + 0.10699834674596786, + 0.0807768777012825, + 0.09364289790391922, + 0.051073357462882996, + 0.047481831163167953, + 0.08825138956308365, + 0.09178753197193146, + 0.04453336447477341 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023301001638174057 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a static high-angle close-up perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the hands wearing tight-fitting blue butyl gloves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the right hand shake a clear plastic syringe with black measurement markings to mix liquid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the right hand insert the syringe needle into a small glass bottle with a rubber stopper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the right hand release clear liquid from the syringe into a clear round Petri dish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.043062031269073486 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680619716644287 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.043062031269073486, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.043062031269073486, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22509080171585083, + 0.0864909440279007, + 0.16885390877723694, + 0.17692947387695312, + 0.03661927580833435, + 0.1030222550034523, + 0.055609628558158875, + 0.08015020191669464, + 0.03531514108181, + 0.03191831707954407 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.043062031269073486 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a static high-angle close-up perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the hands wearing tight-fitting blue butyl gloves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the right hand shake a clear plastic syringe with black measurement markings to mix liquid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the right hand insert the syringe needle into a small glass bottle with a rubber stopper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the right hand release clear liquid from the syringe into a clear round Petri dish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03369107097387314 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408691167831421 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03369107097387314, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03369107097387314, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3595987558364868, + 0.04735637456178665, + 0.04124798625707626, + 0.036658644676208496, + 0.08053790777921677, + 0.06190061941742897, + 0.043933574110269547, + 0.17082479596138, + 0.11954306811094284, + 0.03839822858572006 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03369107097387314 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, high-angle close-up captures a meticulously orchestrated scientific procedure on a sterile stainless steel workbench, beneath bright, even overhead fluorescent lighting. A pair of hands, clad in tight-fitting blue butyl gloves, manipulate with precision. The gloved right hand first firmly grasps a clear plastic syringe with black measurement markings and shakes it quickly and deliberately to mix the clear liquid within. Simultaneously, the gloved left hand steadily slides a clear, round Petri dish across the reflective steel surface and into the center of the frame. The right hand then moves to a small glass bottle, deftly unscrewing the plastic cap and carefully placing it on a plain white cardboard box nearby. After another quick shake of the syringe, the right hand guides the needle, decisively inserting it into the bottle's rubber stopper. The left hand then carefully lifts the lid of the Petri dish and secures it above the base. The right hand tilts the syringe over the open Petri dish, carefully pressing the plunger with its thumb, releasing a few drops of clear liquid onto the culture medium within, keeping it steady. The syringe is then smoothly lifted, and the left hand instantly and precisely closes the cap, sealing the Petri dish, creating a clinical and highly professional atmosphere throughout the entire process.", + "seed": 22397, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_1/index_6560_seed_22397_dp_2_rank_4_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.0811084896326065, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0811084896326065, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.725, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0811084896326065, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a static high-angle close-up perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the hands wearing tight-fitting blue butyl gloves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the right hand shake a clear plastic syringe with black measurement markings to mix liquid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the right hand insert the syringe needle into a small glass bottle with a rubber stopper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the right hand release clear liquid from the syringe into a clear round Petri dish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1664271354675293 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9164271354675293 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1664271354675293, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1664271354675293, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07595854252576828, + 0.02823403850197792, + 0.03781615197658539, + 0.026894062757492065, + 0.14315015077590942, + 0.038328226655721664, + 0.1449909508228302, + 0.08352302014827728, + 0.05511899292469025, + 0.3659859001636505 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1664271354675293 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a static high-angle close-up perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the hands wearing tight-fitting blue butyl gloves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the right hand shake a clear plastic syringe with black measurement markings to mix liquid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the right hand insert the syringe needle into a small glass bottle with a rubber stopper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the right hand release clear liquid from the syringe into a clear round Petri dish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01609194651246071 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141091823577881 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01609194651246071, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01609194651246071, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0739913359284401, + 0.038257669657468796, + 0.05477327108383179, + 0.05103312432765961, + 0.08339808881282806, + 0.0225300844758749, + 0.07221408188343048, + 0.04823177307844162, + 0.19702976942062378, + 0.35854074358940125 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01609194651246071 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a static high-angle close-up perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the hands wearing tight-fitting blue butyl gloves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the right hand shake a clear plastic syringe with black measurement markings to mix liquid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the right hand insert the syringe needle into a small glass bottle with a rubber stopper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the right hand release clear liquid from the syringe into a clear round Petri dish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07902171462774277 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.579021692276001 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07902171462774277, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07902171462774277, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15817050635814667, + 0.06148674711585045, + 0.09083843231201172, + 0.09099110215902328, + 0.08280647546052933, + 0.04729583486914635, + 0.07522877305746078, + 0.06525030732154846, + 0.07392820715904236, + 0.2540035843849182 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07902171462774277 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a static high-angle close-up perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the hands wearing tight-fitting blue butyl gloves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the right hand shake a clear plastic syringe with black measurement markings to mix liquid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the right hand insert the syringe needle into a small glass bottle with a rubber stopper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the right hand release clear liquid from the syringe into a clear round Petri dish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05496196821331978 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929961919784546 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05496196821331978, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05496196821331978, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09116312116384506, + 0.09667123109102249, + 0.14836573600769043, + 0.05510524660348892, + 0.09457330405712128, + 0.0976838618516922, + 0.12790325284004211, + 0.025116514414548874, + 0.15815414488315582, + 0.1052636206150055 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 2, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05496196821331978 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a static high-angle close-up perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the hands wearing tight-fitting blue butyl gloves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the right hand shake a clear plastic syringe with black measurement markings to mix liquid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the right hand insert the syringe needle into a small glass bottle with a rubber stopper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the right hand release clear liquid from the syringe into a clear round Petri dish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08903968334197998 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4640398025512695 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08903968334197998, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08903968334197998, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06998685002326965, + 0.051266659051179886, + 0.03646769002079964, + 0.06519749760627747, + 0.13696525990962982, + 0.07041885703802109, + 0.11569427698850632, + 0.0691365972161293, + 0.07686277478933334, + 0.3080035448074341 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08903968334197998 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, high-angle close-up captures a meticulously orchestrated scientific procedure on a sterile stainless steel workbench, beneath bright, even overhead fluorescent lighting. A pair of hands, clad in tight-fitting blue butyl gloves, manipulate with precision. The gloved right hand first firmly grasps a clear plastic syringe with black measurement markings and shakes it quickly and deliberately to mix the clear liquid within. Simultaneously, the gloved left hand steadily slides a clear, round Petri dish across the reflective steel surface and into the center of the frame. The right hand then moves to a small glass bottle, deftly unscrewing the plastic cap and carefully placing it on a plain white cardboard box nearby. After another quick shake of the syringe, the right hand guides the needle, decisively inserting it into the bottle's rubber stopper. The left hand then carefully lifts the lid of the Petri dish and secures it above the base. The right hand tilts the syringe over the open Petri dish, carefully pressing the plunger with its thumb, releasing a few drops of clear liquid onto the culture medium within, keeping it steady. The syringe is then smoothly lifted, and the left hand instantly and precisely closes the cap, sealing the Petri dish, creating a clinical and highly professional atmosphere throughout the entire process.", + "seed": 22398, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_1/index_6560_seed_22398_dp_3_rank_6_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.055568433552980426, + "vlm_logprob": -0.055568433552980426, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.275, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.055568433552980426, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a static high-angle close-up perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the hands wearing tight-fitting blue butyl gloves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the right hand shake a clear plastic syringe with black measurement markings to mix liquid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the right hand insert the syringe needle into a small glass bottle with a rubber stopper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the right hand release clear liquid from the syringe into a clear round Petri dish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.163202702999115 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9132027626037598 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.163202702999115, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.163202702999115, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15847882628440857, + 0.11264405399560928, + 0.12910710275173187, + 0.03718211501836777, + 0.14961837232112885, + 0.04393123835325241, + 0.06570319086313248, + 0.17397873103618622, + 0.08351359516382217, + 0.045842792838811874 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.163202702999115 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a static high-angle close-up perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the hands wearing tight-fitting blue butyl gloves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the right hand shake a clear plastic syringe with black measurement markings to mix liquid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the right hand insert the syringe needle into a small glass bottle with a rubber stopper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the right hand release clear liquid from the syringe into a clear round Petri dish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018203575164079666 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.0182037353515625 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018203575164079666, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018203575164079666, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1335814893245697, + 0.2160732001066208, + 0.0693998634815216, + 0.07499504089355469, + 0.1737765669822693, + 0.05557858571410179, + 0.05045543611049652, + 0.03419651836156845, + 0.05778065323829651, + 0.13416263461112976 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018203575164079666 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a static high-angle close-up perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the hands wearing tight-fitting blue butyl gloves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the right hand shake a clear plastic syringe with black measurement markings to mix liquid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the right hand insert the syringe needle into a small glass bottle with a rubber stopper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the right hand release clear liquid from the syringe into a clear round Petri dish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01820041425526142 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018200397491455 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01820041425526142, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01820041425526142, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.035830069333314896, + 0.3391757309436798, + 0.051261238753795624, + 0.03621136397123337, + 0.29694777727127075, + 0.02134287729859352, + 0.03715188801288605, + 0.04786199703812599, + 0.03439301252365112, + 0.09982398897409439 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01820041425526142 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a static high-angle close-up perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the hands wearing tight-fitting blue butyl gloves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the right hand shake a clear plastic syringe with black measurement markings to mix liquid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the right hand insert the syringe needle into a small glass bottle with a rubber stopper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the right hand release clear liquid from the syringe into a clear round Petri dish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05495497211813927 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929955005645752 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05495497211813927, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05495497211813927, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07548374682664871, + 0.08842439204454422, + 0.060803502798080444, + 0.040144722908735275, + 0.26433172821998596, + 0.0387798547744751, + 0.24656984210014343, + 0.061541710048913956, + 0.03293420746922493, + 0.09098624438047409 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05495497211813927 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a static high-angle close-up perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the hands wearing tight-fitting blue butyl gloves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the right hand shake a clear plastic syringe with black measurement markings to mix liquid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the right hand insert the syringe needle into a small glass bottle with a rubber stopper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the right hand release clear liquid from the syringe into a clear round Petri dish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02328050322830677 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773280620574951 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02328050322830677, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02328050322830677, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09063434600830078, + 0.09089870750904083, + 0.01402224786579609, + 0.02105400525033474, + 0.502591073513031, + 0.022233908995985985, + 0.03461190685629845, + 0.10828329622745514, + 0.07136503607034683, + 0.044305406510829926 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02328050322830677 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, high-angle close-up captures a meticulously orchestrated scientific procedure on a sterile stainless steel workbench, beneath bright, even overhead fluorescent lighting. A pair of hands, clad in tight-fitting blue butyl gloves, manipulate with precision. The gloved right hand first firmly grasps a clear plastic syringe with black measurement markings and shakes it quickly and deliberately to mix the clear liquid within. Simultaneously, the gloved left hand steadily slides a clear, round Petri dish across the reflective steel surface and into the center of the frame. The right hand then moves to a small glass bottle, deftly unscrewing the plastic cap and carefully placing it on a plain white cardboard box nearby. After another quick shake of the syringe, the right hand guides the needle, decisively inserting it into the bottle's rubber stopper. The left hand then carefully lifts the lid of the Petri dish and secures it above the base. The right hand tilts the syringe over the open Petri dish, carefully pressing the plunger with its thumb, releasing a few drops of clear liquid onto the culture medium within, keeping it steady. The syringe is then smoothly lifted, and the left hand instantly and precisely closes the cap, sealing the Petri dish, creating a clinical and highly professional atmosphere throughout the entire process.", + "seed": 22399, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_1/index_6560_seed_22399_dp_3_rank_6_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.10557774472981692, + "vlm_logprob": -0.10557774472981692, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.55, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.10557774472981692, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a static high-angle close-up perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the hands wearing tight-fitting blue butyl gloves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the right hand shake a clear plastic syringe with black measurement markings to mix liquid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the right hand insert the syringe needle into a small glass bottle with a rubber stopper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the right hand release clear liquid from the syringe into a clear round Petri dish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07644746452569962 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.7014474868774414 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07644746452569962, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07644746452569962, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.018635395914316177, + 0.012118841521441936, + 0.008002943359315395, + 0.011330228298902512, + 0.8420127034187317, + 0.03949530050158501, + 0.013342317193746567, + 0.016014011576771736, + 0.012731551192700863, + 0.0263166856020689 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07644746452569962 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a static high-angle close-up perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the hands wearing tight-fitting blue butyl gloves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the right hand shake a clear plastic syringe with black measurement markings to mix liquid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the right hand insert the syringe needle into a small glass bottle with a rubber stopper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the right hand release clear liquid from the syringe into a clear round Petri dish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012560428120195866 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.3875603675842285 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012560428120195866, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012560428120195866, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06989670544862747, + 0.07838569581508636, + 0.06502248346805573, + 0.09644190967082977, + 0.4320245087146759, + 0.09200116991996765, + 0.057319123297929764, + 0.04287390410900116, + 0.03465399146080017, + 0.03138052299618721 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012560428120195866 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a static high-angle close-up perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the hands wearing tight-fitting blue butyl gloves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the right hand shake a clear plastic syringe with black measurement markings to mix liquid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the right hand insert the syringe needle into a small glass bottle with a rubber stopper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the right hand release clear liquid from the syringe into a clear round Petri dish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1003418117761612 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.350341796875 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1003418117761612, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1003418117761612, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.038027044385671616, + 0.0180121511220932, + 0.08066918700933456, + 0.04798009619116783, + 0.643989086151123, + 0.043436240404844284, + 0.03295862674713135, + 0.04661032184958458, + 0.030014462769031525, + 0.01830269768834114 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1003418117761612 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a static high-angle close-up perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the hands wearing tight-fitting blue butyl gloves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the right hand shake a clear plastic syringe with black measurement markings to mix liquid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the right hand insert the syringe needle into a small glass bottle with a rubber stopper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the right hand release clear liquid from the syringe into a clear round Petri dish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22560177743434906 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6006017923355103 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.22560177743434906, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.22560177743434906, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0617489255964756, + 0.14660866558551788, + 0.0647348165512085, + 0.06936975568532944, + 0.28452640771865845, + 0.03832035884261131, + 0.024620579555630684, + 0.0848732739686966, + 0.18435949087142944, + 0.04083772003650665 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.22560177743434906 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a static high-angle close-up perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the hands wearing tight-fitting blue butyl gloves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the right hand shake a clear plastic syringe with black measurement markings to mix liquid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the right hand insert the syringe needle into a small glass bottle with a rubber stopper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the right hand release clear liquid from the syringe into a clear round Petri dish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11293724179267883 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2379372119903564 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11293724179267883, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11293724179267883, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10877395421266556, + 0.13467633724212646, + 0.040378063917160034, + 0.026384128257632256, + 0.26941317319869995, + 0.07263723760843277, + 0.0833996906876564, + 0.11245419830083847, + 0.11699813604354858, + 0.034885112196207047 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11293724179267883 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_10/index_tensor([2988, 2988])_group_10_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_10/index_tensor([2988, 2988])_group_10_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..52390db2b62c045cd2d8878a28679fc636772d51 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_10/index_tensor([2988, 2988])_group_10_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "An extreme macro close-up, shot at an extremely slow speed, tilted upwards from below, focuses on a massive jeweled egg, carved from a material resembling moonstone or translucent crystal. Captured at a high frame rate, the scene appears as extreme slow motion. The eggshell, polished to a mirror-smooth finish, is meticulously engraved with intricate, ancient runes. From within, a warm, soft white light steadily emanates, illuminating the entire egg and making the grooves within the runes seem to flow with a faint energy. Several fine, natural cracks dot the eggshell, through which crystal-clear water slowly and steadily seeps. Each plump droplet slides carefully along the graceful curve of the eggshell, its surface tension maintaining its perfect spherical shape and clearly reflecting the detailed runes and the soft light filtering through. As it slides, the droplet leaves a fleeting, slightly damp mark on the smooth surface. Set against a pure black background, the entire image is completely illuminated by the inner light of the egg, presenting an extremely pure texture and an otherworldly luster, creating an atmosphere that is sacred, quiet and full of the miracle of life.", + "seed": 32816, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_10/index_2988_seed_32816_dp_20_rank_40_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.1011281169950962, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1011281169950962, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.3499999761581423, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1011281169950962, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro close-up of a massive egg carved from a material resembling moonstone or translucent crystal?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the eggshell polished to a mirror-smooth finish and engraved with intricate, ancient runes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a warm, soft white light emanate from within the egg, illuminating the grooves in the runes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are fine, natural cracks visible on the eggshell with crystal-clear water seeping through them and forming spherical droplets that slide along the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background pure black while the scene is tilted upwards from below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.044394250959157944 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1693942546844482 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.044394250959157944, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.044394250959157944, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10414617508649826, + 0.04818063974380493, + 0.04152783006429672, + 0.35752496123313904, + 0.08834601193666458, + 0.1375405192375183, + 0.0580759234726429, + 0.04462633281946182, + 0.08113731443881989, + 0.03889434412121773 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.044394250959157944 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro close-up of a massive egg carved from a material resembling moonstone or translucent crystal?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the eggshell polished to a mirror-smooth finish and engraved with intricate, ancient runes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a warm, soft white light emanate from within the egg, illuminating the grooves in the runes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are fine, natural cracks visible on the eggshell with crystal-clear water seeping through them and forming spherical droplets that slide along the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background pure black while the scene is tilted upwards from below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16041186451911926 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9104118347167969 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16041186451911926, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16041186451911926, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.027095841243863106, + 0.014931874349713326, + 0.02143239788711071, + 0.8088796138763428, + 0.054730936884880066, + 0.009205550886690617, + 0.010274816304445267, + 0.028114402666687965, + 0.015012342482805252, + 0.010322154499590397 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16041186451911926 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro close-up of a massive egg carved from a material resembling moonstone or translucent crystal?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the eggshell polished to a mirror-smooth finish and engraved with intricate, ancient runes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a warm, soft white light emanate from within the egg, illuminating the grooves in the runes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are fine, natural cracks visible on the eggshell with crystal-clear water seeping through them and forming spherical droplets that slide along the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background pure black while the scene is tilted upwards from below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07900112122297287 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5790011882781982 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07900112122297287, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07900112122297287, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13094677031040192, + 0.049849383533000946, + 0.04733135551214218, + 0.08364652842283249, + 0.15103104710578918, + 0.17054477334022522, + 0.07199558615684509, + 0.15317729115486145, + 0.05465100333094597, + 0.08682633191347122 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 7, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07900112122297287 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro close-up of a massive egg carved from a material resembling moonstone or translucent crystal?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the eggshell polished to a mirror-smooth finish and engraved with intricate, ancient runes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a warm, soft white light emanate from within the egg, illuminating the grooves in the runes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are fine, natural cracks visible on the eggshell with crystal-clear water seeping through them and forming spherical droplets that slide along the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background pure black while the scene is tilted upwards from below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0790102630853653 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.579010248184204 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0790102630853653, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0790102630853653, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07655107229948044, + 0.046947985887527466, + 0.033934857696294785, + 0.38602134585380554, + 0.058184895664453506, + 0.0727897584438324, + 0.03039323166012764, + 0.11591584980487823, + 0.05310240015387535, + 0.12615853548049927 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0790102630853653 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro close-up of a massive egg carved from a material resembling moonstone or translucent crystal?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the eggshell polished to a mirror-smooth finish and engraved with intricate, ancient runes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a warm, soft white light emanate from within the egg, illuminating the grooves in the runes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are fine, natural cracks visible on the eggshell with crystal-clear water seeping through them and forming spherical droplets that slide along the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background pure black while the scene is tilted upwards from below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14282308518886566 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0178229808807373 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14282308518886566, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.8749998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14282308518886566, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2837352454662323, + 0.025297872722148895, + 0.0699952095746994, + 0.18535204231739044, + 0.036297742277383804, + 0.06694182753562927, + 0.04442264884710312, + 0.21880824863910675, + 0.03846113383769989, + 0.030688058584928513 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14282308518886566 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extreme macro close-up, shot at an extremely slow speed, tilted upwards from below, focuses on a massive jeweled egg, carved from a material resembling moonstone or translucent crystal. Captured at a high frame rate, the scene appears as extreme slow motion. The eggshell, polished to a mirror-smooth finish, is meticulously engraved with intricate, ancient runes. From within, a warm, soft white light steadily emanates, illuminating the entire egg and making the grooves within the runes seem to flow with a faint energy. Several fine, natural cracks dot the eggshell, through which crystal-clear water slowly and steadily seeps. Each plump droplet slides carefully along the graceful curve of the eggshell, its surface tension maintaining its perfect spherical shape and clearly reflecting the detailed runes and the soft light filtering through. As it slides, the droplet leaves a fleeting, slightly damp mark on the smooth surface. Set against a pure black background, the entire image is completely illuminated by the inner light of the egg, presenting an extremely pure texture and an otherworldly luster, creating an atmosphere that is sacred, quiet and full of the miracle of life.", + "seed": 32817, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_10/index_2988_seed_32817_dp_20_rank_40_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.05139259304851294, + "vlm_logprob": -0.05139259304851294, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.525, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.05139259304851294, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro close-up of a massive egg carved from a material resembling moonstone or translucent crystal?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the eggshell polished to a mirror-smooth finish and engraved with intricate, ancient runes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a warm, soft white light emanate from within the egg, illuminating the grooves in the runes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are fine, natural cracks visible on the eggshell with crystal-clear water seeping through them and forming spherical droplets that slide along the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background pure black while the scene is tilted upwards from below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.010366168804466724 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.760365962982178 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.010366168804466724, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.010366168804466724, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14519694447517395, + 0.0487932488322258, + 0.5395469665527344, + 0.13060428202152252, + 0.014227894134819508, + 0.018679941073060036, + 0.03628046438097954, + 0.017933420836925507, + 0.030888868495821953, + 0.01784801296889782 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.010366168804466724 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro close-up of a massive egg carved from a material resembling moonstone or translucent crystal?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the eggshell polished to a mirror-smooth finish and engraved with intricate, ancient runes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a warm, soft white light emanate from within the egg, illuminating the grooves in the runes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are fine, natural cracks visible on the eggshell with crystal-clear water seeping through them and forming spherical droplets that slide along the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background pure black while the scene is tilted upwards from below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1604713648557663 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9104713201522827 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1604713648557663, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1604713648557663, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2722978889942169, + 0.024296339601278305, + 0.5452861189842224, + 0.08264628797769547, + 0.019499830901622772, + 0.00702648377045989, + 0.01434029545634985, + 0.008225223049521446, + 0.010398305021226406, + 0.01598324067890644 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1604713648557663 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro close-up of a massive egg carved from a material resembling moonstone or translucent crystal?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the eggshell polished to a mirror-smooth finish and engraved with intricate, ancient runes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a warm, soft white light emanate from within the egg, illuminating the grooves in the runes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are fine, natural cracks visible on the eggshell with crystal-clear water seeping through them and forming spherical droplets that slide along the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background pure black while the scene is tilted upwards from below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026370229199528694 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513702869415283 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026370229199528694, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026370229199528694, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.29091399908065796, + 0.15426909923553467, + 0.06483291834592819, + 0.39859333634376526, + 0.009191694669425488, + 0.012543763034045696, + 0.022563733160495758, + 0.023960188031196594, + 0.012944028712809086, + 0.010187246836721897 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026370229199528694 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro close-up of a massive egg carved from a material resembling moonstone or translucent crystal?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the eggshell polished to a mirror-smooth finish and engraved with intricate, ancient runes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a warm, soft white light emanate from within the egg, illuminating the grooves in the runes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are fine, natural cracks visible on the eggshell with crystal-clear water seeping through them and forming spherical droplets that slide along the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background pure black while the scene is tilted upwards from below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011084526777267456 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.51108455657959 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011084526777267456, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011084526777267456, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0798272117972374, + 0.022913528606295586, + 0.35240137577056885, + 0.033865008503198624, + 0.009773874655365944, + 0.060359176248311996, + 0.23227061331272125, + 0.036973658949136734, + 0.14981332421302795, + 0.02180223912000656 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011084526777267456 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro close-up of a massive egg carved from a material resembling moonstone or translucent crystal?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the eggshell polished to a mirror-smooth finish and engraved with intricate, ancient runes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a warm, soft white light emanate from within the egg, illuminating the grooves in the runes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are fine, natural cracks visible on the eggshell with crystal-clear water seeping through them and forming spherical droplets that slide along the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background pure black while the scene is tilted upwards from below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04867067560553551 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048670768737793 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04867067560553551, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04867067560553551, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11670355498790741, + 0.37382426857948303, + 0.3044642210006714, + 0.010224930942058563, + 0.04408201947808266, + 0.010653446428477764, + 0.03241698816418648, + 0.0410902239382267, + 0.053963374346494675, + 0.012577054090797901 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04867067560553551 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extreme macro close-up, shot at an extremely slow speed, tilted upwards from below, focuses on a massive jeweled egg, carved from a material resembling moonstone or translucent crystal. Captured at a high frame rate, the scene appears as extreme slow motion. The eggshell, polished to a mirror-smooth finish, is meticulously engraved with intricate, ancient runes. From within, a warm, soft white light steadily emanates, illuminating the entire egg and making the grooves within the runes seem to flow with a faint energy. Several fine, natural cracks dot the eggshell, through which crystal-clear water slowly and steadily seeps. Each plump droplet slides carefully along the graceful curve of the eggshell, its surface tension maintaining its perfect spherical shape and clearly reflecting the detailed runes and the soft light filtering through. As it slides, the droplet leaves a fleeting, slightly damp mark on the smooth surface. Set against a pure black background, the entire image is completely illuminated by the inner light of the egg, presenting an extremely pure texture and an otherworldly luster, creating an atmosphere that is sacred, quiet and full of the miracle of life.", + "seed": 32818, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_10/index_2988_seed_32818_dp_21_rank_42_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.1494344651699066, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1494344651699066, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.05, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1494344651699066, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro close-up of a massive egg carved from a material resembling moonstone or translucent crystal?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the eggshell polished to a mirror-smooth finish and engraved with intricate, ancient runes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a warm, soft white light emanate from within the egg, illuminating the grooves in the runes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are fine, natural cracks visible on the eggshell with crystal-clear water seeping through them and forming spherical droplets that slide along the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background pure black while the scene is tilted upwards from below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05588903650641441 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.930889129638672 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05588903650641441, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05588903650641441, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1853257119655609, + 0.05472615361213684, + 0.3279760479927063, + 0.12329713255167007, + 0.028927015140652657, + 0.0400305837392807, + 0.04985111206769943, + 0.03845497593283653, + 0.06572224944829941, + 0.08568906784057617 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05588903650641441 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro close-up of a massive egg carved from a material resembling moonstone or translucent crystal?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the eggshell polished to a mirror-smooth finish and engraved with intricate, ancient runes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a warm, soft white light emanate from within the egg, illuminating the grooves in the runes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are fine, natural cracks visible on the eggshell with crystal-clear water seeping through them and forming spherical droplets that slide along the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background pure black while the scene is tilted upwards from below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.31353890895843506 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.313538908958435 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.31353890895843506, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.31353890895843506, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07751373946666718, + 0.0344490148127079, + 0.2563176453113556, + 0.16349653899669647, + 0.042063795030117035, + 0.02141053043305874, + 0.04874323308467865, + 0.06955688446760178, + 0.2315472811460495, + 0.054901305586099625 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 8, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.31353890895843506 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro close-up of a massive egg carved from a material resembling moonstone or translucent crystal?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the eggshell polished to a mirror-smooth finish and engraved with intricate, ancient runes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a warm, soft white light emanate from within the egg, illuminating the grooves in the runes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are fine, natural cracks visible on the eggshell with crystal-clear water seeping through them and forming spherical droplets that slide along the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background pure black while the scene is tilted upwards from below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14284653961658478 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0178465843200684 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14284653961658478, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14284653961658478, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12918305397033691, + 0.06042148545384407, + 0.3051835298538208, + 0.18826952576637268, + 0.02993849851191044, + 0.02231324091553688, + 0.06282312422990799, + 0.06335406750440598, + 0.08380556106567383, + 0.05470788851380348 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14284653961658478 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro close-up of a massive egg carved from a material resembling moonstone or translucent crystal?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the eggshell polished to a mirror-smooth finish and engraved with intricate, ancient runes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a warm, soft white light emanate from within the egg, illuminating the grooves in the runes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are fine, natural cracks visible on the eggshell with crystal-clear water seeping through them and forming spherical droplets that slide along the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background pure black while the scene is tilted upwards from below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.054992545396089554 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929992437362671 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.054992545396089554, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.054992545396089554, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15844176709651947, + 0.0569365918636322, + 0.06287185102701187, + 0.2862573266029358, + 0.06472231447696686, + 0.08467796444892883, + 0.04105561599135399, + 0.053271085023880005, + 0.06364583224058151, + 0.12811966240406036 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.054992545396089554 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro close-up of a massive egg carved from a material resembling moonstone or translucent crystal?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the eggshell polished to a mirror-smooth finish and engraved with intricate, ancient runes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a warm, soft white light emanate from within the egg, illuminating the grooves in the runes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are fine, natural cracks visible on the eggshell with crystal-clear water seeping through them and forming spherical droplets that slide along the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background pure black while the scene is tilted upwards from below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17990529537200928 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8049052953720093 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17990529537200928, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17990529537200928, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18707387149333954, + 0.11134127527475357, + 0.14502429962158203, + 0.19510257244110107, + 0.05324969068169594, + 0.021542808040976524, + 0.04771044850349426, + 0.07326030731201172, + 0.04378962889313698, + 0.12190510332584381 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17990529537200928 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extreme macro close-up, shot at an extremely slow speed, tilted upwards from below, focuses on a massive jeweled egg, carved from a material resembling moonstone or translucent crystal. Captured at a high frame rate, the scene appears as extreme slow motion. The eggshell, polished to a mirror-smooth finish, is meticulously engraved with intricate, ancient runes. From within, a warm, soft white light steadily emanates, illuminating the entire egg and making the grooves within the runes seem to flow with a faint energy. Several fine, natural cracks dot the eggshell, through which crystal-clear water slowly and steadily seeps. Each plump droplet slides carefully along the graceful curve of the eggshell, its surface tension maintaining its perfect spherical shape and clearly reflecting the detailed runes and the soft light filtering through. As it slides, the droplet leaves a fleeting, slightly damp mark on the smooth surface. Set against a pure black background, the entire image is completely illuminated by the inner light of the egg, presenting an extremely pure texture and an otherworldly luster, creating an atmosphere that is sacred, quiet and full of the miracle of life.", + "seed": 32819, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_10/index_2988_seed_32819_dp_21_rank_42_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.06951050795614719, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06951050795614719, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.8, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06951050795614719, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro close-up of a massive egg carved from a material resembling moonstone or translucent crystal?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the eggshell polished to a mirror-smooth finish and engraved with intricate, ancient runes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a warm, soft white light emanate from within the egg, illuminating the grooves in the runes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are fine, natural cracks visible on the eggshell with crystal-clear water seeping through them and forming spherical droplets that slide along the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background pure black while the scene is tilted upwards from below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.022788895294070244 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8977890014648438 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.022788895294070244, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.022788895294070244, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3201722502708435, + 0.04353809729218483, + 0.05398712307214737, + 0.0552898570895195, + 0.22180131077766418, + 0.06565561890602112, + 0.029583144932985306, + 0.028591463342308998, + 0.043127767741680145, + 0.13825340569019318 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.022788895294070244 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro close-up of a massive egg carved from a material resembling moonstone or translucent crystal?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the eggshell polished to a mirror-smooth finish and engraved with intricate, ancient runes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a warm, soft white light emanate from within the egg, illuminating the grooves in the runes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are fine, natural cracks visible on the eggshell with crystal-clear water seeping through them and forming spherical droplets that slide along the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background pure black while the scene is tilted upwards from below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04868168756365776 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486817359924316 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04868168756365776, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04868168756365776, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17617341876029968, + 0.15058980882167816, + 0.08632142841815948, + 0.09103482216596603, + 0.11324717104434967, + 0.1885012835264206, + 0.030924201011657715, + 0.05500752106308937, + 0.04901767149567604, + 0.059182681143283844 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04868168756365776 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro close-up of a massive egg carved from a material resembling moonstone or translucent crystal?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the eggshell polished to a mirror-smooth finish and engraved with intricate, ancient runes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a warm, soft white light emanate from within the egg, illuminating the grooves in the runes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are fine, natural cracks visible on the eggshell with crystal-clear water seeping through them and forming spherical droplets that slide along the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background pure black while the scene is tilted upwards from below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07003248482942581 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950325965881348 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07003248482942581, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07003248482942581, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16682830452919006, + 0.09902920573949814, + 0.13639195263385773, + 0.062122080475091934, + 0.19593164324760437, + 0.0873393639922142, + 0.058580465614795685, + 0.058041926473379135, + 0.0431649275124073, + 0.09257017076015472 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07003248482942581 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro close-up of a massive egg carved from a material resembling moonstone or translucent crystal?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the eggshell polished to a mirror-smooth finish and engraved with intricate, ancient runes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a warm, soft white light emanate from within the egg, illuminating the grooves in the runes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are fine, natural cracks visible on the eggshell with crystal-clear water seeping through them and forming spherical droplets that slide along the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background pure black while the scene is tilted upwards from below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0790029913187027 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.579003095626831 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0790029913187027, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0790029913187027, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2295142263174057, + 0.10592606663703918, + 0.0849333107471466, + 0.05172320082783699, + 0.1362176537513733, + 0.03871148079633713, + 0.05023587495088577, + 0.040086716413497925, + 0.13568484783172607, + 0.12696650624275208 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0790029913187027 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro close-up of a massive egg carved from a material resembling moonstone or translucent crystal?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the eggshell polished to a mirror-smooth finish and engraved with intricate, ancient runes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a warm, soft white light emanate from within the egg, illuminating the grooves in the runes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are fine, natural cracks visible on the eggshell with crystal-clear water seeping through them and forming spherical droplets that slide along the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background pure black while the scene is tilted upwards from below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12704648077487946 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.127046585083008 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12704648077487946, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12704648077487946, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.46018004417419434, + 0.052686117589473724, + 0.16211803257465363, + 0.0837908461689949, + 0.021930651739239693, + 0.02745981700718403, + 0.06490008533000946, + 0.019719742238521576, + 0.04262297973036766, + 0.06459169089794159 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12704648077487946 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_11/index_tensor([9007, 9007])_group_11_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_11/index_tensor([9007, 9007])_group_11_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..3fb26bee26bfe0cf576cb39368949a9a0e79ae8c --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_11/index_tensor([9007, 9007])_group_11_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "close-up shot, using head-tracking technology, locked onto a cyborg speaking on a news commentary program. His serious, focused face dominated the frame. He had immaculately combed dark short hair, eagle-like eyes, a faint blue data halo glimmering in his pupils. A high nose bridge and a chiseled jawline revealed faint seams of silver metal that blended seamlessly into his skin. He wore a high-collared, slim-fitting charcoal gray shirt over a well-tailored black blazer. The fabric shone subtly under the cool studio lighting. As he calmly delivered his analysis, the camera smoothly adjusted with his slightest head movements, maintaining perfect composition. At the bottom edge of the frame, one of his hands rested on the sleek black glass tabletop. Its mechanical fingers, composed entirely of polished chrome and carbon fiber, tapped the surface with a steady, deliberate rhythm, producing a barely audible, crisp sound as their fingertips made contact. The background is a huge, slightly out-of-focus LED screen with abstract blue data flow graphics flowing on it. Precise top light and contour light outline his clear silhouette and reflect sharp highlights on the joints of his metal fingers. The whole scene creates an extremely calm, professional analytical atmosphere full of wisdom and futuristic technology.", + "seed": 4146, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_11/index_9007_seed_4146_dp_22_rank_44_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.025288667483255266, + "vlm_logprob": -0.025288667483255266, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.825, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.025288667483255266, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focused on a cyborg's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the cyborg have dark short hair, eagle-like eyes, and a faint blue data halo in his pupils?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cyborg wearing a high-collared charcoal gray shirt under a black blazer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a large, out-of-focus LED screen displaying abstract blue data flow graphics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly adjust to the cyborg's head movements to maintain composition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0029167274478822947 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.1279168128967285 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0029167274478822947, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0029167274478822947, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.32551878690719604, + 0.11133931577205658, + 0.10396729409694672, + 0.074507936835289, + 0.04177220165729523, + 0.059468548744916916, + 0.06538170576095581, + 0.07639732956886292, + 0.08929474651813507, + 0.052352167665958405 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0029167274478822947 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focused on a cyborg's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the cyborg have dark short hair, eagle-like eyes, and a faint blue data halo in his pupils?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cyborg wearing a high-collared charcoal gray shirt under a black blazer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a large, out-of-focus LED screen displaying abstract blue data flow graphics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly adjust to the cyborg's head movements to maintain composition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0022109129931777716 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127211093902588 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0022109129931777716, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0022109129931777716, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19510556757450104, + 0.17277592420578003, + 0.12667784094810486, + 0.042076487094163895, + 0.07735184580087662, + 0.08329819142818451, + 0.04384976997971535, + 0.1463378518819809, + 0.041060928255319595, + 0.07146559655666351 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0022109129931777716 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focused on a cyborg's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the cyborg have dark short hair, eagle-like eyes, and a faint blue data halo in his pupils?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cyborg wearing a high-collared charcoal gray shirt under a black blazer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a large, out-of-focus LED screen displaying abstract blue data flow graphics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly adjust to the cyborg's head movements to maintain composition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029803412035107613 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529803514480591 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029803412035107613, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029803412035107613, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24138399958610535, + 0.18013553321361542, + 0.11261948198080063, + 0.12345763295888901, + 0.0415467694401741, + 0.03860485553741455, + 0.05291961878538132, + 0.06973549723625183, + 0.09639857709407806, + 0.04319804161787033 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029803412035107613 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focused on a cyborg's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the cyborg have dark short hair, eagle-like eyes, and a faint blue data halo in his pupils?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cyborg wearing a high-collared charcoal gray shirt under a black blazer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a large, out-of-focus LED screen displaying abstract blue data flow graphics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly adjust to the cyborg's head movements to maintain composition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0024888513144105673 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002488613128662 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0024888513144105673, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0024888513144105673, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1722775399684906, + 0.37502482533454895, + 0.14118093252182007, + 0.05894611030817032, + 0.05892921984195709, + 0.04937019571661949, + 0.026915593072772026, + 0.02351260557770729, + 0.07193207740783691, + 0.021910937502980232 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0024888513144105673 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focused on a cyborg's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the cyborg have dark short hair, eagle-like eyes, and a faint blue data halo in his pupils?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cyborg wearing a high-collared charcoal gray shirt under a black blazer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a large, out-of-focus LED screen displaying abstract blue data flow graphics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly adjust to the cyborg's head movements to maintain composition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08902343362569809 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4640233516693115 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08902343362569809, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08902343362569809, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24065788090229034, + 0.06942920386791229, + 0.10161947458982468, + 0.07530273497104645, + 0.06716815382242203, + 0.14107152819633484, + 0.08942045271396637, + 0.0802382081747055, + 0.042962219566106796, + 0.0921301320195198 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08902343362569809 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up shot, using head-tracking technology, locked onto a cyborg speaking on a news commentary program. His serious, focused face dominated the frame. He had immaculately combed dark short hair, eagle-like eyes, a faint blue data halo glimmering in his pupils. A high nose bridge and a chiseled jawline revealed faint seams of silver metal that blended seamlessly into his skin. He wore a high-collared, slim-fitting charcoal gray shirt over a well-tailored black blazer. The fabric shone subtly under the cool studio lighting. As he calmly delivered his analysis, the camera smoothly adjusted with his slightest head movements, maintaining perfect composition. At the bottom edge of the frame, one of his hands rested on the sleek black glass tabletop. Its mechanical fingers, composed entirely of polished chrome and carbon fiber, tapped the surface with a steady, deliberate rhythm, producing a barely audible, crisp sound as their fingertips made contact. The background is a huge, slightly out-of-focus LED screen with abstract blue data flow graphics flowing on it. Precise top light and contour light outline his clear silhouette and reflect sharp highlights on the joints of his metal fingers. The whole scene creates an extremely calm, professional analytical atmosphere full of wisdom and futuristic technology.", + "seed": 4147, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_11/index_9007_seed_4147_dp_22_rank_44_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.006491673400159925, + "vlm_logprob": -0.006491673400159925, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 5.55, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.006491673400159925, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focused on a cyborg's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the cyborg have dark short hair, eagle-like eyes, and a faint blue data halo in his pupils?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cyborg wearing a high-collared charcoal gray shirt under a black blazer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a large, out-of-focus LED screen displaying abstract blue data flow graphics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly adjust to the cyborg's head movements to maintain composition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003414635546505451 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.003414630889893 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003414635546505451, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003414635546505451, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0706246867775917, + 0.22412940859794617, + 0.02429066225886345, + 0.09289433807134628, + 0.09524667263031006, + 0.026843853294849396, + 0.026602309197187424, + 0.33954766392707825, + 0.06683904677629471, + 0.03298136591911316 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003414635546505451 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focused on a cyborg's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the cyborg have dark short hair, eagle-like eyes, and a faint blue data halo in his pupils?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cyborg wearing a high-collared charcoal gray shirt under a black blazer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a large, out-of-focus LED screen displaying abstract blue data flow graphics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly adjust to the cyborg's head movements to maintain composition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004109272733330727 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.5041093826293945 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004109272733330727, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004109272733330727, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15555937588214874, + 0.09706397354602814, + 0.04288429394364357, + 0.0601046085357666, + 0.1304405778646469, + 0.03435416519641876, + 0.11358829587697983, + 0.20735853910446167, + 0.08282460272312164, + 0.07582147419452667 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004109272733330727 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focused on a cyborg's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the cyborg have dark short hair, eagle-like eyes, and a faint blue data halo in his pupils?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cyborg wearing a high-collared charcoal gray shirt under a black blazer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a large, out-of-focus LED screen displaying abstract blue data flow graphics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly adjust to the cyborg's head movements to maintain composition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005946444813162088 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130946636199951 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005946444813162088, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005946444813162088, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0806163102388382, + 0.0990450531244278, + 0.04706548526883125, + 0.04044816270470619, + 0.33140474557876587, + 0.13795045018196106, + 0.03313199430704117, + 0.12397107481956482, + 0.03817899525165558, + 0.06818770617246628 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005946444813162088 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focused on a cyborg's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the cyborg have dark short hair, eagle-like eyes, and a faint blue data halo in his pupils?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cyborg wearing a high-collared charcoal gray shirt under a black blazer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a large, out-of-focus LED screen displaying abstract blue data flow graphics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly adjust to the cyborg's head movements to maintain composition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0008111285860650241 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.1258111000061035 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0008111285860650241, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0008111285860650241, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14393512904644012, + 0.1516657918691635, + 0.11298574507236481, + 0.09911664575338364, + 0.06637508422136307, + 0.07604583352804184, + 0.02387101948261261, + 0.07186491042375565, + 0.1659521907567978, + 0.08818763494491577 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0008111285860650241 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focused on a cyborg's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the cyborg have dark short hair, eagle-like eyes, and a faint blue data halo in his pupils?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cyborg wearing a high-collared charcoal gray shirt under a black blazer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a large, out-of-focus LED screen displaying abstract blue data flow graphics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly adjust to the cyborg's head movements to maintain composition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018176885321736336 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018177032470703 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018176885321736336, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018176885321736336, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15359431505203247, + 0.17561814188957214, + 0.07635287195444107, + 0.05702131241559982, + 0.06383400410413742, + 0.05554310604929924, + 0.04707696661353111, + 0.10646017640829086, + 0.22236429154872894, + 0.04213486611843109 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018176885321736336 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up shot, using head-tracking technology, locked onto a cyborg speaking on a news commentary program. His serious, focused face dominated the frame. He had immaculately combed dark short hair, eagle-like eyes, a faint blue data halo glimmering in his pupils. A high nose bridge and a chiseled jawline revealed faint seams of silver metal that blended seamlessly into his skin. He wore a high-collared, slim-fitting charcoal gray shirt over a well-tailored black blazer. The fabric shone subtly under the cool studio lighting. As he calmly delivered his analysis, the camera smoothly adjusted with his slightest head movements, maintaining perfect composition. At the bottom edge of the frame, one of his hands rested on the sleek black glass tabletop. Its mechanical fingers, composed entirely of polished chrome and carbon fiber, tapped the surface with a steady, deliberate rhythm, producing a barely audible, crisp sound as their fingertips made contact. The background is a huge, slightly out-of-focus LED screen with abstract blue data flow graphics flowing on it. Precise top light and contour light outline his clear silhouette and reflect sharp highlights on the joints of his metal fingers. The whole scene creates an extremely calm, professional analytical atmosphere full of wisdom and futuristic technology.", + "seed": 4148, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_11/index_9007_seed_4148_dp_23_rank_46_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.011376032722182572, + "vlm_logprob": -0.011376032722182572, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.875, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.011376032722182572, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focused on a cyborg's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the cyborg have dark short hair, eagle-like eyes, and a faint blue data halo in his pupils?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cyborg wearing a high-collared charcoal gray shirt under a black blazer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a large, out-of-focus LED screen displaying abstract blue data flow graphics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly adjust to the cyborg's head movements to maintain composition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.010297856293618679 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.635297775268555 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.010297856293618679, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.010297856293618679, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10349304974079132, + 0.1113177016377449, + 0.03129184618592262, + 0.02725899964570999, + 0.05468392372131348, + 0.1174309253692627, + 0.29646047949790955, + 0.08926419913768768, + 0.07595964521169662, + 0.09283924847841263 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.010297856293618679 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focused on a cyborg's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the cyborg have dark short hair, eagle-like eyes, and a faint blue data halo in his pupils?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cyborg wearing a high-collared charcoal gray shirt under a black blazer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a large, out-of-focus LED screen displaying abstract blue data flow graphics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly adjust to the cyborg's head movements to maintain composition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0067610545083880424 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006761074066162 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0067610545083880424, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0067610545083880424, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10054940730333328, + 0.0834716409444809, + 0.04787778481841087, + 0.031412914395332336, + 0.3250676989555359, + 0.05383090674877167, + 0.16300144791603088, + 0.0677676871418953, + 0.05372638627886772, + 0.07329410314559937 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0067610545083880424 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focused on a cyborg's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the cyborg have dark short hair, eagle-like eyes, and a faint blue data halo in his pupils?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cyborg wearing a high-collared charcoal gray shirt under a black blazer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a large, out-of-focus LED screen displaying abstract blue data flow graphics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly adjust to the cyborg's head movements to maintain composition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02059118263423443 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955912590026855 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02059118263423443, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02059118263423443, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20910702645778656, + 0.11770803481340408, + 0.05128312110900879, + 0.04375686123967171, + 0.24189622700214386, + 0.06685201823711395, + 0.13542219996452332, + 0.04596688225865364, + 0.041169919073581696, + 0.04683776944875717 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02059118263423443 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focused on a cyborg's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the cyborg have dark short hair, eagle-like eyes, and a faint blue data halo in his pupils?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cyborg wearing a high-collared charcoal gray shirt under a black blazer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a large, out-of-focus LED screen displaying abstract blue data flow graphics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly adjust to the cyborg's head movements to maintain composition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0010421803453937173 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.876042366027832 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0010421803453937173, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0010421803453937173, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0919341966509819, + 0.056770507246255875, + 0.14871704578399658, + 0.05087416246533394, + 0.158145934343338, + 0.041445985436439514, + 0.1875576674938202, + 0.1801067590713501, + 0.026858072727918625, + 0.057589638978242874 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0010421803453937173 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focused on a cyborg's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the cyborg have dark short hair, eagle-like eyes, and a faint blue data halo in his pupils?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cyborg wearing a high-collared charcoal gray shirt under a black blazer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a large, out-of-focus LED screen displaying abstract blue data flow graphics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly adjust to the cyborg's head movements to maintain composition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018187889829277992 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018187999725342 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018187889829277992, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018187889829277992, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06232161447405815, + 0.09618493169546127, + 0.09919208288192749, + 0.026276959106326103, + 0.1813865602016449, + 0.06320159882307053, + 0.18103137612342834, + 0.1208353117108345, + 0.037083886563777924, + 0.13248565793037415 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018187889829277992 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up shot, using head-tracking technology, locked onto a cyborg speaking on a news commentary program. His serious, focused face dominated the frame. He had immaculately combed dark short hair, eagle-like eyes, a faint blue data halo glimmering in his pupils. A high nose bridge and a chiseled jawline revealed faint seams of silver metal that blended seamlessly into his skin. He wore a high-collared, slim-fitting charcoal gray shirt over a well-tailored black blazer. The fabric shone subtly under the cool studio lighting. As he calmly delivered his analysis, the camera smoothly adjusted with his slightest head movements, maintaining perfect composition. At the bottom edge of the frame, one of his hands rested on the sleek black glass tabletop. Its mechanical fingers, composed entirely of polished chrome and carbon fiber, tapped the surface with a steady, deliberate rhythm, producing a barely audible, crisp sound as their fingertips made contact. The background is a huge, slightly out-of-focus LED screen with abstract blue data flow graphics flowing on it. Precise top light and contour light outline his clear silhouette and reflect sharp highlights on the joints of his metal fingers. The whole scene creates an extremely calm, professional analytical atmosphere full of wisdom and futuristic technology.", + "seed": 4149, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_11/index_9007_seed_4149_dp_23_rank_46_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.031162146478891373, + "vlm_logprob": -0.031162146478891373, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.35, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.031162146478891373, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focused on a cyborg's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the cyborg have dark short hair, eagle-like eyes, and a faint blue data halo in his pupils?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cyborg wearing a high-collared charcoal gray shirt under a black blazer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a large, out-of-focus LED screen displaying abstract blue data flow graphics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly adjust to the cyborg's head movements to maintain composition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004916364327073097 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504916191101074 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004916364327073097, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004916364327073097, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16691666841506958, + 0.1434164047241211, + 0.050534144043922424, + 0.06192602217197418, + 0.07675594091415405, + 0.09080611914396286, + 0.08307380229234695, + 0.18692559003829956, + 0.06976482272148132, + 0.06988043338060379 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004916364327073097 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focused on a cyborg's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the cyborg have dark short hair, eagle-like eyes, and a faint blue data halo in his pupils?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cyborg wearing a high-collared charcoal gray shirt under a black blazer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a large, out-of-focus LED screen displaying abstract blue data flow graphics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly adjust to the cyborg's head movements to maintain composition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007654029410332441 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882654190063477 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007654029410332441, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007654029410332441, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22249792516231537, + 0.11873841285705566, + 0.08844388276338577, + 0.03916130214929581, + 0.05995142087340355, + 0.047038570046424866, + 0.05705055966973305, + 0.2565254867076874, + 0.06208846718072891, + 0.04850400239229202 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007654029410332441 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focused on a cyborg's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the cyborg have dark short hair, eagle-like eyes, and a faint blue data halo in his pupils?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cyborg wearing a high-collared charcoal gray shirt under a black blazer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a large, out-of-focus LED screen displaying abstract blue data flow graphics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly adjust to the cyborg's head movements to maintain composition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06206710636615753 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120670318603516 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06206710636615753, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06206710636615753, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4508143365383148, + 0.10369214415550232, + 0.05025975778698921, + 0.05447549372911453, + 0.04597809165716171, + 0.024524837732315063, + 0.0790451243519783, + 0.1440514773130417, + 0.02805457077920437, + 0.019104251638054848 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06206710636615753 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focused on a cyborg's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the cyborg have dark short hair, eagle-like eyes, and a faint blue data halo in his pupils?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cyborg wearing a high-collared charcoal gray shirt under a black blazer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a large, out-of-focus LED screen displaying abstract blue data flow graphics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly adjust to the cyborg's head movements to maintain composition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0021971152164041996 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127197265625 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0021971152164041996, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0021971152164041996, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23206499218940735, + 0.1849910020828247, + 0.11581376940011978, + 0.11527944356203079, + 0.04336888715624809, + 0.04406079649925232, + 0.03352833166718483, + 0.18275517225265503, + 0.025470314547419548, + 0.022667333483695984 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0021971152164041996 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focused on a cyborg's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the cyborg have dark short hair, eagle-like eyes, and a faint blue data halo in his pupils?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cyborg wearing a high-collared charcoal gray shirt under a black blazer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a large, out-of-focus LED screen displaying abstract blue data flow graphics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly adjust to the cyborg's head movements to maintain composition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0789761170744896 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5789761543273926 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0789761170744896, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0789761170744896, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13061797618865967, + 0.05660787224769592, + 0.04076625779271126, + 0.04023738205432892, + 0.042375534772872925, + 0.08688758313655853, + 0.10465752333402634, + 0.39016783237457275, + 0.020910313352942467, + 0.08677172660827637 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0789761170744896 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_12/index_tensor([2840, 2840])_group_12_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_12/index_tensor([2840, 2840])_group_12_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..910e01a516a76039bfb4b381dc3c695e885aa075 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_12/index_tensor([2840, 2840])_group_12_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "static shot captured from a medium close-up angle, using high-frame-rate slow-motion cinematography, focuses on a middle-aged Asian male chef. He wears a dark gray cotton headscarf, his face stained with grease and sweat from a hard day's work in the kitchen. He has just paused from his rapid chopping, one hand still tightly gripping a heavy kitchen knife, the blade hovering a few millimeters above the flour-stained wooden cutting board, the other resting on the stainless steel countertop. A strong overhead light streams down from above, sculpting the sharp lines of his face and highlighting the beads of sweat on his forehead and the oily sheen on his cheeks. His brow is slightly furrowed, his eyes sharp and focused, as if piercing the air before him, fixated on a single point beyond the camera. The slow-motion effect captures the countless tiny particles of flour dust and oil smoke floating in the air, dancing slowly within the beam of light like shimmering stardust. The background is a slightly blurred professional kitchen, and the stainless steel kitchenware reflects a cold luster. The whole scene creates an atmosphere of extreme concentration, tension and power in realistic and slightly warm colors.", + "seed": 14360, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_12/index_2840_seed_14360_dp_24_rank_48_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.03584578204900026, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03584578204900026, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.5, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03584578204900026, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a middle-aged Asian male chef?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the chef wearing a dark gray cotton headscarf with grease and sweat stains on his face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the chef holding a heavy kitchen knife above a flour-stained wooden cutting board with one hand on a stainless steel countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot as a static medium close-up with high-frame-rate slow-motion capturing floating flour dust and oil smoke?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a slightly blurred professional kitchen with stainless steel kitchenware reflecting a cold luster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06304144859313965 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8130414485931396 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06304144859313965, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06304144859313965, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13486891984939575, + 0.047880154103040695, + 0.38453209400177, + 0.08773843199014664, + 0.07417631149291992, + 0.05595500394701958, + 0.0732407346367836, + 0.03072907030582428, + 0.05371894687414169, + 0.057160355150699615 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06304144859313965 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a middle-aged Asian male chef?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the chef wearing a dark gray cotton headscarf with grease and sweat stains on his face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the chef holding a heavy kitchen knife above a flour-stained wooden cutting board with one hand on a stainless steel countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot as a static medium close-up with high-frame-rate slow-motion capturing floating flour dust and oil smoke?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a slightly blurred professional kitchen with stainless steel kitchenware reflecting a cold luster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03813459351658821 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881345748901367 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03813459351658821, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03813459351658821, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1481490284204483, + 0.08892576396465302, + 0.39856523275375366, + 0.05187080055475235, + 0.047172412276268005, + 0.016243712976574898, + 0.07638400048017502, + 0.03709946572780609, + 0.06403962522745132, + 0.0715499147772789 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03813459351658821 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a middle-aged Asian male chef?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the chef wearing a dark gray cotton headscarf with grease and sweat stains on his face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the chef holding a heavy kitchen knife above a flour-stained wooden cutting board with one hand on a stainless steel countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot as a static medium close-up with high-frame-rate slow-motion capturing floating flour dust and oil smoke?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a slightly blurred professional kitchen with stainless steel kitchenware reflecting a cold luster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04307584464550018 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680757999420166 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04307584464550018, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04307584464550018, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19341418147087097, + 0.05484207347035408, + 0.4358453154563904, + 0.11306232213973999, + 0.02258554846048355, + 0.023634599521756172, + 0.0994722917675972, + 0.020266331732273102, + 0.025881249457597733, + 0.010996093042194843 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04307584464550018 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a middle-aged Asian male chef?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the chef wearing a dark gray cotton headscarf with grease and sweat stains on his face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the chef holding a heavy kitchen knife above a flour-stained wooden cutting board with one hand on a stainless steel countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot as a static medium close-up with high-frame-rate slow-motion capturing floating flour dust and oil smoke?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a slightly blurred professional kitchen with stainless steel kitchenware reflecting a cold luster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02634642831981182 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651346445083618 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02634642831981182, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02634642831981182, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1879248470067978, + 0.054492250084877014, + 0.12211287766695023, + 0.14785368740558624, + 0.04131215438246727, + 0.018109578639268875, + 0.18346217274665833, + 0.10335773229598999, + 0.08726862072944641, + 0.05410604923963547 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02634642831981182 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a middle-aged Asian male chef?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the chef wearing a dark gray cotton headscarf with grease and sweat stains on his face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the chef holding a heavy kitchen knife above a flour-stained wooden cutting board with one hand on a stainless steel countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot as a static medium close-up with high-frame-rate slow-motion capturing floating flour dust and oil smoke?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a slightly blurred professional kitchen with stainless steel kitchenware reflecting a cold luster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008630595169961452 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758630752563477 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008630595169961452, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008630595169961452, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16594047844409943, + 0.02920449525117874, + 0.1801687330007553, + 0.04789723828434944, + 0.08168599009513855, + 0.03269464895129204, + 0.15867646038532257, + 0.033568382263183594, + 0.21336989104747772, + 0.05679366737604141 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008630595169961452 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static shot captured from a medium close-up angle, using high-frame-rate slow-motion cinematography, focuses on a middle-aged Asian male chef. He wears a dark gray cotton headscarf, his face stained with grease and sweat from a hard day's work in the kitchen. He has just paused from his rapid chopping, one hand still tightly gripping a heavy kitchen knife, the blade hovering a few millimeters above the flour-stained wooden cutting board, the other resting on the stainless steel countertop. A strong overhead light streams down from above, sculpting the sharp lines of his face and highlighting the beads of sweat on his forehead and the oily sheen on his cheeks. His brow is slightly furrowed, his eyes sharp and focused, as if piercing the air before him, fixated on a single point beyond the camera. The slow-motion effect captures the countless tiny particles of flour dust and oil smoke floating in the air, dancing slowly within the beam of light like shimmering stardust. The background is a slightly blurred professional kitchen, and the stainless steel kitchenware reflects a cold luster. The whole scene creates an atmosphere of extreme concentration, tension and power in realistic and slightly warm colors.", + "seed": 14361, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_12/index_2840_seed_14361_dp_24_rank_48_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.017569634318351745, + "vlm_logprob": -0.017569634318351745, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.0749999523162845, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.017569634318351745, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a middle-aged Asian male chef?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the chef wearing a dark gray cotton headscarf with grease and sweat stains on his face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the chef holding a heavy kitchen knife above a flour-stained wooden cutting board with one hand on a stainless steel countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot as a static medium close-up with high-frame-rate slow-motion capturing floating flour dust and oil smoke?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a slightly blurred professional kitchen with stainless steel kitchenware reflecting a cold luster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018681179732084274 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018681049346924 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018681179732084274, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018681179732084274, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2770027220249176, + 0.060459062457084656, + 0.05919181555509567, + 0.052032601088285446, + 0.10857722908258438, + 0.07523185759782791, + 0.036034390330314636, + 0.1007976084947586, + 0.04966780170798302, + 0.18100495636463165 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018681179732084274 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a middle-aged Asian male chef?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the chef wearing a dark gray cotton headscarf with grease and sweat stains on his face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the chef holding a heavy kitchen knife above a flour-stained wooden cutting board with one hand on a stainless steel countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot as a static medium close-up with high-frame-rate slow-motion capturing floating flour dust and oil smoke?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a slightly blurred professional kitchen with stainless steel kitchenware reflecting a cold luster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026370229199528694 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513702869415283 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026370229199528694, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026370229199528694, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20608273148536682, + 0.0881739929318428, + 0.046308886259794235, + 0.059874437749385834, + 0.0794558897614479, + 0.1179545596241951, + 0.07064011693000793, + 0.05067696422338486, + 0.08044345676898956, + 0.20038896799087524 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026370229199528694 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a middle-aged Asian male chef?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the chef wearing a dark gray cotton headscarf with grease and sweat stains on his face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the chef holding a heavy kitchen knife above a flour-stained wooden cutting board with one hand on a stainless steel countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot as a static medium close-up with high-frame-rate slow-motion capturing floating flour dust and oil smoke?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a slightly blurred professional kitchen with stainless steel kitchenware reflecting a cold luster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016074584797024727 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.1410746574401855 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016074584797024727, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016074584797024727, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08965787291526794, + 0.047881659120321274, + 0.06727124005556107, + 0.054716769605875015, + 0.04755306616425514, + 0.053351081907749176, + 0.1560501605272293, + 0.04549866169691086, + 0.30899578332901, + 0.1290237307548523 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016074584797024727 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a middle-aged Asian male chef?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the chef wearing a dark gray cotton headscarf with grease and sweat stains on his face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the chef holding a heavy kitchen knife above a flour-stained wooden cutting board with one hand on a stainless steel countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot as a static medium close-up with high-frame-rate slow-motion capturing floating flour dust and oil smoke?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a slightly blurred professional kitchen with stainless steel kitchenware reflecting a cold luster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014194594696164131 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264194488525391 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014194594696164131, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014194594696164131, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11419253796339035, + 0.06571327894926071, + 0.05668427050113678, + 0.06581529229879379, + 0.03689612075686455, + 0.12829795479774475, + 0.03873977065086365, + 0.06055942550301552, + 0.1301000565290451, + 0.3030012547969818 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014194594696164131 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a middle-aged Asian male chef?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the chef wearing a dark gray cotton headscarf with grease and sweat stains on his face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the chef holding a heavy kitchen knife above a flour-stained wooden cutting board with one hand on a stainless steel countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot as a static medium close-up with high-frame-rate slow-motion capturing floating flour dust and oil smoke?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a slightly blurred professional kitchen with stainless steel kitchenware reflecting a cold luster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012527583166956902 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.3875274658203125 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012527583166956902, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012527583166956902, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2955314815044403, + 0.04277946427464485, + 0.02198632061481476, + 0.025081561878323555, + 0.049997493624687195, + 0.0641307681798935, + 0.025377297773957253, + 0.05367318540811539, + 0.042664650827646255, + 0.37877774238586426 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012527583166956902 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static shot captured from a medium close-up angle, using high-frame-rate slow-motion cinematography, focuses on a middle-aged Asian male chef. He wears a dark gray cotton headscarf, his face stained with grease and sweat from a hard day's work in the kitchen. He has just paused from his rapid chopping, one hand still tightly gripping a heavy kitchen knife, the blade hovering a few millimeters above the flour-stained wooden cutting board, the other resting on the stainless steel countertop. A strong overhead light streams down from above, sculpting the sharp lines of his face and highlighting the beads of sweat on his forehead and the oily sheen on his cheeks. His brow is slightly furrowed, his eyes sharp and focused, as if piercing the air before him, fixated on a single point beyond the camera. The slow-motion effect captures the countless tiny particles of flour dust and oil smoke floating in the air, dancing slowly within the beam of light like shimmering stardust. The background is a slightly blurred professional kitchen, and the stainless steel kitchenware reflects a cold luster. The whole scene creates an atmosphere of extreme concentration, tension and power in realistic and slightly warm colors.", + "seed": 14362, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_12/index_2840_seed_14362_dp_25_rank_50_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.03310916125774384, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03310916125774384, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.525, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03310916125774384, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a middle-aged Asian male chef?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the chef wearing a dark gray cotton headscarf with grease and sweat stains on his face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the chef holding a heavy kitchen knife above a flour-stained wooden cutting board with one hand on a stainless steel countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot as a static medium close-up with high-frame-rate slow-motion capturing floating flour dust and oil smoke?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a slightly blurred professional kitchen with stainless steel kitchenware reflecting a cold luster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03501729294657707 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.410017251968384 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03501729294657707, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03501729294657707, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3090350031852722, + 0.1711309403181076, + 0.04521429166197777, + 0.04267803207039833, + 0.04115324467420578, + 0.08877293020486832, + 0.08437542617321014, + 0.07164574414491653, + 0.08914928883314133, + 0.056845057755708694 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03501729294657707 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a middle-aged Asian male chef?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the chef wearing a dark gray cotton headscarf with grease and sweat stains on his face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the chef holding a heavy kitchen knife above a flour-stained wooden cutting board with one hand on a stainless steel countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot as a static medium close-up with high-frame-rate slow-motion capturing floating flour dust and oil smoke?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a slightly blurred professional kitchen with stainless steel kitchenware reflecting a cold luster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02638416178524494 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651384115219116 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02638416178524494, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02638416178524494, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3194408118724823, + 0.33388790488243103, + 0.04722293093800545, + 0.01853039860725403, + 0.02809031866490841, + 0.028873542323708534, + 0.05003749951720238, + 0.07147903740406036, + 0.0446874275803566, + 0.05775010958313942 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02638416178524494 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a middle-aged Asian male chef?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the chef wearing a dark gray cotton headscarf with grease and sweat stains on his face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the chef holding a heavy kitchen knife above a flour-stained wooden cutting board with one hand on a stainless steel countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot as a static medium close-up with high-frame-rate slow-motion capturing floating flour dust and oil smoke?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a slightly blurred professional kitchen with stainless steel kitchenware reflecting a cold luster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03811738267540932 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881174087524414 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03811738267540932, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03811738267540932, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2390715628862381, + 0.2022440880537033, + 0.08545607328414917, + 0.07543991506099701, + 0.029875751584768295, + 0.11751675605773926, + 0.09221609681844711, + 0.055462855845689774, + 0.06681539118289948, + 0.03590156137943268 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03811738267540932 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a middle-aged Asian male chef?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the chef wearing a dark gray cotton headscarf with grease and sweat stains on his face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the chef holding a heavy kitchen knife above a flour-stained wooden cutting board with one hand on a stainless steel countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot as a static medium close-up with high-frame-rate slow-motion capturing floating flour dust and oil smoke?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a slightly blurred professional kitchen with stainless steel kitchenware reflecting a cold luster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05495835840702057 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299583435058594 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05495835840702057, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05495835840702057, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19609686732292175, + 0.311064749956131, + 0.08473706990480423, + 0.041529107838869095, + 0.019660059362649918, + 0.08466523885726929, + 0.02711041085422039, + 0.11652591079473495, + 0.0607319176197052, + 0.05787859484553337 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05495835840702057 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a middle-aged Asian male chef?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the chef wearing a dark gray cotton headscarf with grease and sweat stains on his face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the chef holding a heavy kitchen knife above a flour-stained wooden cutting board with one hand on a stainless steel countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot as a static medium close-up with high-frame-rate slow-motion capturing floating flour dust and oil smoke?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a slightly blurred professional kitchen with stainless steel kitchenware reflecting a cold luster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011068610474467278 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511068820953369 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011068610474467278, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011068610474467278, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18358208239078522, + 0.5763287544250488, + 0.03824014961719513, + 0.01045100949704647, + 0.02737380377948284, + 0.025723077356815338, + 0.029978148639202118, + 0.02849002555012703, + 0.04456666111946106, + 0.035266295075416565 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011068610474467278 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static shot captured from a medium close-up angle, using high-frame-rate slow-motion cinematography, focuses on a middle-aged Asian male chef. He wears a dark gray cotton headscarf, his face stained with grease and sweat from a hard day's work in the kitchen. He has just paused from his rapid chopping, one hand still tightly gripping a heavy kitchen knife, the blade hovering a few millimeters above the flour-stained wooden cutting board, the other resting on the stainless steel countertop. A strong overhead light streams down from above, sculpting the sharp lines of his face and highlighting the beads of sweat on his forehead and the oily sheen on his cheeks. His brow is slightly furrowed, his eyes sharp and focused, as if piercing the air before him, fixated on a single point beyond the camera. The slow-motion effect captures the countless tiny particles of flour dust and oil smoke floating in the air, dancing slowly within the beam of light like shimmering stardust. The background is a slightly blurred professional kitchen, and the stainless steel kitchenware reflects a cold luster. The whole scene creates an atmosphere of extreme concentration, tension and power in realistic and slightly warm colors.", + "seed": 14363, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_12/index_2840_seed_14363_dp_25_rank_50_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.025271349400281907, + "vlm_logprob": -0.025271349400281907, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.0, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.025271349400281907, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a middle-aged Asian male chef?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the chef wearing a dark gray cotton headscarf with grease and sweat stains on his face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the chef holding a heavy kitchen knife above a flour-stained wooden cutting board with one hand on a stainless steel countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot as a static medium close-up with high-frame-rate slow-motion capturing floating flour dust and oil smoke?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a slightly blurred professional kitchen with stainless steel kitchenware reflecting a cold luster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.030617786571383476 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5306177139282227 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.030617786571383476, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.030617786571383476, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3315809965133667, + 0.20828326046466827, + 0.09286444634199142, + 0.041941605508327484, + 0.02729659155011177, + 0.10292808711528778, + 0.015780482441186905, + 0.11368890851736069, + 0.01991589553654194, + 0.04571973904967308 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.030617786571383476 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a middle-aged Asian male chef?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the chef wearing a dark gray cotton headscarf with grease and sweat stains on his face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the chef holding a heavy kitchen knife above a flour-stained wooden cutting board with one hand on a stainless steel countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot as a static medium close-up with high-frame-rate slow-motion capturing floating flour dust and oil smoke?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a slightly blurred professional kitchen with stainless steel kitchenware reflecting a cold luster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03375042602419853 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408750534057617 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03375042602419853, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03375042602419853, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18665441870689392, + 0.18665066361427307, + 0.047691863030195236, + 0.0407295860350132, + 0.0394643098115921, + 0.06532272696495056, + 0.11035946011543274, + 0.23815466463565826, + 0.03647391498088837, + 0.04849838837981224 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03375042602419853 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a middle-aged Asian male chef?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the chef wearing a dark gray cotton headscarf with grease and sweat stains on his face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the chef holding a heavy kitchen knife above a flour-stained wooden cutting board with one hand on a stainless steel countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot as a static medium close-up with high-frame-rate slow-motion capturing floating flour dust and oil smoke?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a slightly blurred professional kitchen with stainless steel kitchenware reflecting a cold luster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04310062527656555 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168100595474243 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04310062527656555, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04310062527656555, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0651240274310112, + 0.6571111083030701, + 0.07783792167901993, + 0.03360440954566002, + 0.01814502477645874, + 0.032512117177248, + 0.016136735677719116, + 0.056890811771154404, + 0.027899427339434624, + 0.014738539233803749 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04310062527656555 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a middle-aged Asian male chef?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the chef wearing a dark gray cotton headscarf with grease and sweat stains on his face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the chef holding a heavy kitchen knife above a flour-stained wooden cutting board with one hand on a stainless steel countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot as a static medium close-up with high-frame-rate slow-motion capturing floating flour dust and oil smoke?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a slightly blurred professional kitchen with stainless steel kitchenware reflecting a cold luster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016073646023869514 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141073703765869 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016073646023869514, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016073646023869514, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10745345056056976, + 0.08153009414672852, + 0.1967901885509491, + 0.06347925961017609, + 0.03836937993764877, + 0.027461733669042587, + 0.0509103387594223, + 0.36460718512535095, + 0.029393021017313004, + 0.04000536724925041 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016073646023869514 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a middle-aged Asian male chef?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the chef wearing a dark gray cotton headscarf with grease and sweat stains on his face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the chef holding a heavy kitchen knife above a flour-stained wooden cutting board with one hand on a stainless steel countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot as a static medium close-up with high-frame-rate slow-motion capturing floating flour dust and oil smoke?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a slightly blurred professional kitchen with stainless steel kitchenware reflecting a cold luster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002814263105392456 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877814292907715 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002814263105392456, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002814263105392456, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.29240262508392334, + 0.1105533093214035, + 0.07713820040225983, + 0.04901107773184776, + 0.045003555715084076, + 0.030246367678046227, + 0.03641565516591072, + 0.26725685596466064, + 0.027665065601468086, + 0.06430726498365402 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002814263105392456 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_13/index_tensor([7125, 7125])_group_13_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_13/index_tensor([7125, 7125])_group_13_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..0b67f51ff86ce10c7842bacf6a0b7a4f7346f322 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_13/index_tensor([7125, 7125])_group_13_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "medium, static shot, shot from a horizontal angle, depicts a world constructed in a refined pixel art style, with sharp, blocky edges. At the center of the frame is an elderly man with a graying beard and hair, his sparse white hair pulled back in a small bun. His face is lined with deep wrinkles, created by pixelated blocks, and his eyes are focused and serene. He wears a traditional dark gray coarse Chinese robe, its folds rendered with varying shades of gray. He stands in a quaint Chinese courtyard, his ground paved with bluestone slabs, interspersed between the cracks of the slabs with a profusion of golden and crimson pixelated fallen leaves. The elderly man is slightly bent over, his hands tightly gripping a long-handled bamboo broom—the handle rendered as a long string of brown pixels, the end of the broom a cluster of scattered yellow pixels. He methodically and unhurriedly swept the fallen leaves to one side. Each sweep was slow and rhythmic. The tip of the bamboo broom gently brushed the ground, sending pixelated leaves fluttering briefly in the air before gathering into a small pile. A soft, diffuse light evenly bathed the courtyard, devoid of harsh highlights, casting only soft, jagged, blocky shadows around the figures and the corners of the walls. The scene, dominated by earth tones and grays, was punctuated by the vibrant, warm colors of the fallen leaves, creating a tranquil and focused atmosphere that blended the nostalgia of retro gaming with the essence of Eastern Zen.", + "seed": 23362, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_13/index_7125_seed_23362_dp_26_rank_52_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.127756071370095, + "vlm_logprob": -0.127756071370095, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.525, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.127756071370095, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a refined pixel art style with sharp, blocky edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an elderly man with a graying beard, sparse white hair in a bun, and deep wrinkles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a traditional dark gray coarse Chinese robe and holding a long-handled bamboo broom with yellow bristles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a Chinese courtyard with bluestone slab paving and golden and crimson fallen leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static, shot from a horizontal angle, showing the man sweeping leaves methodically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5798133015632629 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8298133015632629 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5798133015632629, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5798133015632629, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4995265603065491, + 0.1193685531616211, + 0.05448973551392555, + 0.030423210933804512, + 0.03047221712768078, + 0.06402485817670822, + 0.06147732213139534, + 0.03715748339891434, + 0.048617467284202576, + 0.05444259196519852 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5798133015632629 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a refined pixel art style with sharp, blocky edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an elderly man with a graying beard, sparse white hair in a bun, and deep wrinkles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a traditional dark gray coarse Chinese robe and holding a long-handled bamboo broom with yellow bristles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a Chinese courtyard with bluestone slab paving and golden and crimson fallen leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static, shot from a horizontal angle, showing the man sweeping leaves methodically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012555483728647232 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.3875555992126465 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012555483728647232, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012555483728647232, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.45127421617507935, + 0.1932772845029831, + 0.0405387207865715, + 0.05888934060931206, + 0.027643954381346703, + 0.04946780204772949, + 0.038391247391700745, + 0.03717264533042908, + 0.06084053963422775, + 0.04250425472855568 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012555483728647232 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a refined pixel art style with sharp, blocky edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an elderly man with a graying beard, sparse white hair in a bun, and deep wrinkles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a traditional dark gray coarse Chinese robe and holding a long-handled bamboo broom with yellow bristles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a Chinese courtyard with bluestone slab paving and golden and crimson fallen leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static, shot from a horizontal angle, showing the man sweeping leaves methodically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005257233511656523 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.2552571296691895 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005257233511656523, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005257233511656523, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3937489986419678, + 0.08018828183412552, + 0.10269298404455185, + 0.038014091551303864, + 0.04160158336162567, + 0.05841894820332527, + 0.04257974773645401, + 0.11546266824007034, + 0.03370349109172821, + 0.0935891792178154 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005257233511656523 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a refined pixel art style with sharp, blocky edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an elderly man with a graying beard, sparse white hair in a bun, and deep wrinkles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a traditional dark gray coarse Chinese robe and holding a long-handled bamboo broom with yellow bristles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a Chinese courtyard with bluestone slab paving and golden and crimson fallen leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static, shot from a horizontal angle, showing the man sweeping leaves methodically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02057565003633499 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895575761795044 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02057565003633499, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02057565003633499, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.36586645245552063, + 0.11965238302946091, + 0.08040445297956467, + 0.030380979180336, + 0.030060289427638054, + 0.1073417067527771, + 0.02213987149298191, + 0.14041706919670105, + 0.03090238757431507, + 0.07283444702625275 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02057565003633499 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a refined pixel art style with sharp, blocky edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an elderly man with a graying beard, sparse white hair in a bun, and deep wrinkles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a traditional dark gray coarse Chinese robe and holding a long-handled bamboo broom with yellow bristles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a Chinese courtyard with bluestone slab paving and golden and crimson fallen leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static, shot from a horizontal angle, showing the man sweeping leaves methodically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020578688010573387 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895578622817993 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020578688010573387, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020578688010573387, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2583763301372528, + 0.1591951847076416, + 0.08670338988304138, + 0.0812290832400322, + 0.05476871132850647, + 0.048566073179244995, + 0.04560881108045578, + 0.09495425224304199, + 0.06656120717525482, + 0.10403706878423691 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020578688010573387 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "medium, static shot, shot from a horizontal angle, depicts a world constructed in a refined pixel art style, with sharp, blocky edges. At the center of the frame is an elderly man with a graying beard and hair, his sparse white hair pulled back in a small bun. His face is lined with deep wrinkles, created by pixelated blocks, and his eyes are focused and serene. He wears a traditional dark gray coarse Chinese robe, its folds rendered with varying shades of gray. He stands in a quaint Chinese courtyard, his ground paved with bluestone slabs, interspersed between the cracks of the slabs with a profusion of golden and crimson pixelated fallen leaves. The elderly man is slightly bent over, his hands tightly gripping a long-handled bamboo broom—the handle rendered as a long string of brown pixels, the end of the broom a cluster of scattered yellow pixels. He methodically and unhurriedly swept the fallen leaves to one side. Each sweep was slow and rhythmic. The tip of the bamboo broom gently brushed the ground, sending pixelated leaves fluttering briefly in the air before gathering into a small pile. A soft, diffuse light evenly bathed the courtyard, devoid of harsh highlights, casting only soft, jagged, blocky shadows around the figures and the corners of the walls. The scene, dominated by earth tones and grays, was punctuated by the vibrant, warm colors of the fallen leaves, creating a tranquil and focused atmosphere that blended the nostalgia of retro gaming with the essence of Eastern Zen.", + "seed": 23363, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_13/index_7125_seed_23363_dp_26_rank_52_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.026696498831734063, + "vlm_logprob": -0.026696498831734063, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.325, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.026696498831734063, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a refined pixel art style with sharp, blocky edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an elderly man with a graying beard, sparse white hair in a bun, and deep wrinkles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a traditional dark gray coarse Chinese robe and holding a long-handled bamboo broom with yellow bristles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a Chinese courtyard with bluestone slab paving and golden and crimson fallen leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static, shot from a horizontal angle, showing the man sweeping leaves methodically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.09110607951879501 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4661061763763428 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.09110607951879501, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.09110607951879501, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05946782976388931, + 0.018210330978035927, + 0.037386830896139145, + 0.030508767813444138, + 0.017845042049884796, + 0.013788067735731602, + 0.01289000641554594, + 0.05415615439414978, + 0.14964401721954346, + 0.6061029434204102 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.09110607951879501 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a refined pixel art style with sharp, blocky edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an elderly man with a graying beard, sparse white hair in a bun, and deep wrinkles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a traditional dark gray coarse Chinese robe and holding a long-handled bamboo broom with yellow bristles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a Chinese courtyard with bluestone slab paving and golden and crimson fallen leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static, shot from a horizontal angle, showing the man sweeping leaves methodically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00764006981626153 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.8826398849487305 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00764006981626153, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00764006981626153, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07784625887870789, + 0.0350671261548996, + 0.06387580931186676, + 0.08646657317876816, + 0.020324308425188065, + 0.017246760427951813, + 0.014271853491663933, + 0.06313101202249527, + 0.22361305356025696, + 0.3981572985649109 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00764006981626153 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a refined pixel art style with sharp, blocky edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an elderly man with a graying beard, sparse white hair in a bun, and deep wrinkles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a traditional dark gray coarse Chinese robe and holding a long-handled bamboo broom with yellow bristles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a Chinese courtyard with bluestone slab paving and golden and crimson fallen leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static, shot from a horizontal angle, showing the man sweeping leaves methodically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0028191369492560625 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877819061279297 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0028191369492560625, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0028191369492560625, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10238586366176605, + 0.06739982217550278, + 0.1042182445526123, + 0.04153534770011902, + 0.0385005846619606, + 0.026719102635979652, + 0.03012375347316265, + 0.15945830941200256, + 0.18704745173454285, + 0.24261151254177094 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0028191369492560625 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a refined pixel art style with sharp, blocky edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an elderly man with a graying beard, sparse white hair in a bun, and deep wrinkles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a traditional dark gray coarse Chinese robe and holding a long-handled bamboo broom with yellow bristles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a Chinese courtyard with bluestone slab paving and golden and crimson fallen leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static, shot from a horizontal angle, showing the man sweeping leaves methodically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00863425899296999 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758634090423584 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00863425899296999, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00863425899296999, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20042261481285095, + 0.08866659551858902, + 0.14893874526023865, + 0.12470049411058426, + 0.05508488044142723, + 0.03653956949710846, + 0.02918374165892601, + 0.07082542777061462, + 0.052373964339494705, + 0.1932639479637146 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00863425899296999 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a refined pixel art style with sharp, blocky edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an elderly man with a graying beard, sparse white hair in a bun, and deep wrinkles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a traditional dark gray coarse Chinese robe and holding a long-handled bamboo broom with yellow bristles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a Chinese courtyard with bluestone slab paving and golden and crimson fallen leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static, shot from a horizontal angle, showing the man sweeping leaves methodically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02328294888138771 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773283004760742 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02328294888138771, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02328294888138771, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17309390008449554, + 0.03377795219421387, + 0.034958239644765854, + 0.02088972181081772, + 0.026272473856806755, + 0.027982672676444054, + 0.017163734883069992, + 0.07227639108896255, + 0.05595713108778, + 0.5376277565956116 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02328294888138771 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "medium, static shot, shot from a horizontal angle, depicts a world constructed in a refined pixel art style, with sharp, blocky edges. At the center of the frame is an elderly man with a graying beard and hair, his sparse white hair pulled back in a small bun. His face is lined with deep wrinkles, created by pixelated blocks, and his eyes are focused and serene. He wears a traditional dark gray coarse Chinese robe, its folds rendered with varying shades of gray. He stands in a quaint Chinese courtyard, his ground paved with bluestone slabs, interspersed between the cracks of the slabs with a profusion of golden and crimson pixelated fallen leaves. The elderly man is slightly bent over, his hands tightly gripping a long-handled bamboo broom—the handle rendered as a long string of brown pixels, the end of the broom a cluster of scattered yellow pixels. He methodically and unhurriedly swept the fallen leaves to one side. Each sweep was slow and rhythmic. The tip of the bamboo broom gently brushed the ground, sending pixelated leaves fluttering briefly in the air before gathering into a small pile. A soft, diffuse light evenly bathed the courtyard, devoid of harsh highlights, casting only soft, jagged, blocky shadows around the figures and the corners of the walls. The scene, dominated by earth tones and grays, was punctuated by the vibrant, warm colors of the fallen leaves, creating a tranquil and focused atmosphere that blended the nostalgia of retro gaming with the essence of Eastern Zen.", + "seed": 23364, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_13/index_7125_seed_23364_dp_27_rank_54_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.027690061228349806, + "vlm_logprob": -0.027690061228349806, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.3, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.027690061228349806, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a refined pixel art style with sharp, blocky edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an elderly man with a graying beard, sparse white hair in a bun, and deep wrinkles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a traditional dark gray coarse Chinese robe and holding a long-handled bamboo broom with yellow bristles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a Chinese courtyard with bluestone slab paving and golden and crimson fallen leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static, shot from a horizontal angle, showing the man sweeping leaves methodically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0904594287276268 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4654593467712402 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0904594287276268, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0904594287276268, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1546996533870697, + 0.14738714694976807, + 0.044194307178258896, + 0.053966227918863297, + 0.32886308431625366, + 0.0534977950155735, + 0.08702059090137482, + 0.044443581253290176, + 0.038794342428445816, + 0.04713331162929535 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0904594287276268 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a refined pixel art style with sharp, blocky edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an elderly man with a graying beard, sparse white hair in a bun, and deep wrinkles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a traditional dark gray coarse Chinese robe and holding a long-handled bamboo broom with yellow bristles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a Chinese courtyard with bluestone slab paving and golden and crimson fallen leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static, shot from a horizontal angle, showing the man sweeping leaves methodically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008645840920507908 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758646011352539 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008645840920507908, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008645840920507908, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14682593941688538, + 0.12115682661533356, + 0.06541534513235092, + 0.03599478676915169, + 0.40074580907821655, + 0.06903839856386185, + 0.08705899864435196, + 0.013174098916351795, + 0.02491024136543274, + 0.03567960485816002 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008645840920507908 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a refined pixel art style with sharp, blocky edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an elderly man with a graying beard, sparse white hair in a bun, and deep wrinkles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a traditional dark gray coarse Chinese robe and holding a long-handled bamboo broom with yellow bristles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a Chinese courtyard with bluestone slab paving and golden and crimson fallen leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static, shot from a horizontal angle, showing the man sweeping leaves methodically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0028199690859764814 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877820014953613 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0028199690859764814, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0028199690859764814, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1177598237991333, + 0.049659717828035355, + 0.07735082507133484, + 0.04459448158740997, + 0.4233880043029785, + 0.0755038857460022, + 0.07748182862997055, + 0.03538564220070839, + 0.05048113316297531, + 0.04839466139674187 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0028199690859764814 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a refined pixel art style with sharp, blocky edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an elderly man with a graying beard, sparse white hair in a bun, and deep wrinkles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a traditional dark gray coarse Chinese robe and holding a long-handled bamboo broom with yellow bristles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a Chinese courtyard with bluestone slab paving and golden and crimson fallen leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static, shot from a horizontal angle, showing the man sweeping leaves methodically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006733110640197992 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006732940673828 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006733110640197992, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006733110640197992, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2447364330291748, + 0.12321805208921432, + 0.09617902338504791, + 0.042240191251039505, + 0.23871910572052002, + 0.06732572615146637, + 0.07294373214244843, + 0.03542989864945412, + 0.033046476542949677, + 0.04616137593984604 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006733110640197992 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a refined pixel art style with sharp, blocky edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an elderly man with a graying beard, sparse white hair in a bun, and deep wrinkles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a traditional dark gray coarse Chinese robe and holding a long-handled bamboo broom with yellow bristles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a Chinese courtyard with bluestone slab paving and golden and crimson fallen leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static, shot from a horizontal angle, showing the man sweeping leaves methodically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029791956767439842 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529792070388794 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029791956767439842, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029791956767439842, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12431112676858902, + 0.09607285261154175, + 0.10096082836389542, + 0.03175880387425423, + 0.40339088439941406, + 0.05490424484014511, + 0.056856442242860794, + 0.03464210405945778, + 0.02910648286342621, + 0.06799623370170593 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029791956767439842 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "medium, static shot, shot from a horizontal angle, depicts a world constructed in a refined pixel art style, with sharp, blocky edges. At the center of the frame is an elderly man with a graying beard and hair, his sparse white hair pulled back in a small bun. His face is lined with deep wrinkles, created by pixelated blocks, and his eyes are focused and serene. He wears a traditional dark gray coarse Chinese robe, its folds rendered with varying shades of gray. He stands in a quaint Chinese courtyard, his ground paved with bluestone slabs, interspersed between the cracks of the slabs with a profusion of golden and crimson pixelated fallen leaves. The elderly man is slightly bent over, his hands tightly gripping a long-handled bamboo broom—the handle rendered as a long string of brown pixels, the end of the broom a cluster of scattered yellow pixels. He methodically and unhurriedly swept the fallen leaves to one side. Each sweep was slow and rhythmic. The tip of the bamboo broom gently brushed the ground, sending pixelated leaves fluttering briefly in the air before gathering into a small pile. A soft, diffuse light evenly bathed the courtyard, devoid of harsh highlights, casting only soft, jagged, blocky shadows around the figures and the corners of the walls. The scene, dominated by earth tones and grays, was punctuated by the vibrant, warm colors of the fallen leaves, creating a tranquil and focused atmosphere that blended the nostalgia of retro gaming with the essence of Eastern Zen.", + "seed": 23365, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_13/index_7125_seed_23365_dp_27_rank_54_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.0223331137560308, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0223331137560308, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.575, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0223331137560308, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a refined pixel art style with sharp, blocky edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an elderly man with a graying beard, sparse white hair in a bun, and deep wrinkles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a traditional dark gray coarse Chinese robe and holding a long-handled bamboo broom with yellow bristles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a Chinese courtyard with bluestone slab paving and golden and crimson fallen leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static, shot from a horizontal angle, showing the man sweeping leaves methodically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07445753365755081 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6994576454162598 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07445753365755081, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07445753365755081, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3077579140663147, + 0.23846609890460968, + 0.01954149268567562, + 0.02621845155954361, + 0.03552741929888725, + 0.06633150577545166, + 0.158392071723938, + 0.028379589319229126, + 0.023072905838489532, + 0.09631259739398956 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07445753365755081 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a refined pixel art style with sharp, blocky edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an elderly man with a graying beard, sparse white hair in a bun, and deep wrinkles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a traditional dark gray coarse Chinese robe and holding a long-handled bamboo broom with yellow bristles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a Chinese courtyard with bluestone slab paving and golden and crimson fallen leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static, shot from a horizontal angle, showing the man sweeping leaves methodically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004103455226868391 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504103660583496 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004103455226868391, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004103455226868391, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.28401386737823486, + 0.0797656774520874, + 0.12469219416379929, + 0.05257534980773926, + 0.06475058197975159, + 0.041411735117435455, + 0.17095893621444702, + 0.037540335208177567, + 0.09404655545949936, + 0.05024470388889313 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004103455226868391 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a refined pixel art style with sharp, blocky edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an elderly man with a graying beard, sparse white hair in a bun, and deep wrinkles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a traditional dark gray coarse Chinese robe and holding a long-handled bamboo broom with yellow bristles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a Chinese courtyard with bluestone slab paving and golden and crimson fallen leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static, shot from a horizontal angle, showing the man sweeping leaves methodically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002200683578848839 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127200603485107 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002200683578848839, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002200683578848839, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3038572371006012, + 0.05918499454855919, + 0.09903687983751297, + 0.10408546030521393, + 0.07948736101388931, + 0.049038276076316833, + 0.03256092220544815, + 0.0373208187520504, + 0.11911410838365555, + 0.11631394177675247 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002200683578848839 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a refined pixel art style with sharp, blocky edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an elderly man with a graying beard, sparse white hair in a bun, and deep wrinkles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a traditional dark gray coarse Chinese robe and holding a long-handled bamboo broom with yellow bristles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a Chinese courtyard with bluestone slab paving and golden and crimson fallen leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static, shot from a horizontal angle, showing the man sweeping leaves methodically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007623625919222832 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882623672485352 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007623625919222832, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007623625919222832, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.220406174659729, + 0.12029485404491425, + 0.03620871528983116, + 0.07489392161369324, + 0.15183092653751373, + 0.11841163784265518, + 0.029611965641379356, + 0.07004554569721222, + 0.06756714731454849, + 0.11072909832000732 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007623625919222832 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a refined pixel art style with sharp, blocky edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an elderly man with a graying beard, sparse white hair in a bun, and deep wrinkles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a traditional dark gray coarse Chinese robe and holding a long-handled bamboo broom with yellow bristles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a Chinese courtyard with bluestone slab paving and golden and crimson fallen leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static, shot from a horizontal angle, showing the man sweeping leaves methodically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023280270397663116 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773280382156372 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023280270397663116, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023280270397663116, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3915029764175415, + 0.19671668112277985, + 0.03542884439229965, + 0.036620352417230606, + 0.07674646377563477, + 0.03638121113181114, + 0.05353878065943718, + 0.04648326337337494, + 0.03687344864010811, + 0.08970802277326584 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023280270397663116 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_14/index_tensor([1522, 1522])_group_14_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_14/index_tensor([1522, 1522])_group_14_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..4a0189fbfdffeaf149854622cd671ce74a902af2 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_14/index_tensor([1522, 1522])_group_14_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up, macro-style shot remains perfectly static, focusing on the complex landscape of a human face. The frame is dominated by a gleaming eye with a crystal-like pale blue iris, its intricate fibrous pattern visible in ultra-fine detail. A single, cold-toned key light from a high side angle illuminates the scene, giving the cornea a damp sheen and revealing its delicate network of capillaries. From the delicate inner corner of the eye, a viscous black liquid begins to gush, accumulating erratically before steadily and deliberately seeping down to the lower lash line. This dark liquid, with its oily, reflective surface, captures the single light source, following a slow, uninterrupted path along pale skin, navigating the fine, almost invisible fuzz and delicate texture of pores. The stark contrast between the dark liquid, pale skin, and bright eye, combined with the subject's unblinking stillness, creates a deeply unsettling and surreal atmosphere, filled with unspoken tension.", + "seed": 11722, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_14/index_1522_seed_11722_dp_28_rank_56_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.25275258657056837, + "vlm_logprob": -0.25275258657056837, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.6749999046325685, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.25275258657056837, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up, macro-style view of a human eye?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the iris pale blue with a visible crystal-like fibrous pattern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a single cold-toned key light from a high side angle illuminate the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a viscous black liquid gush from the inner corner of the eye and seep down to the lower lash line?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perfectly static throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0015232876176014543 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -8.0015230178833 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0015232876176014543, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.999999523162842, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0015232876176014543, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08427401632070541, + 0.034718673676252365, + 0.0429641418159008, + 0.33382245898246765, + 0.12864182889461517, + 0.11817032843828201, + 0.05418989062309265, + 0.06813636422157288, + 0.0698198601603508, + 0.06526237726211548 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0015232876176014543 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up, macro-style view of a human eye?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the iris pale blue with a visible crystal-like fibrous pattern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a single cold-toned key light from a high side angle illuminate the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a viscous black liquid gush from the inner corner of the eye and seep down to the lower lash line?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perfectly static throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016102386638522148 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141102313995361 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016102386638522148, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016102386638522148, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08856093138456345, + 0.057315584272146225, + 0.08287743479013443, + 0.13868829607963562, + 0.11893455684185028, + 0.09838391840457916, + 0.11104810237884521, + 0.16620470583438873, + 0.08705165237188339, + 0.05093482509255409 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016102386638522148 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up, macro-style view of a human eye?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the iris pale blue with a visible crystal-like fibrous pattern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a single cold-toned key light from a high side angle illuminate the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a viscous black liquid gush from the inner corner of the eye and seep down to the lower lash line?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perfectly static throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10037512332201004 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.350375175476074 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10037512332201004, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10037512332201004, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14156566560268402, + 0.1253499686717987, + 0.055992837995290756, + 0.1253013163805008, + 0.09461165964603424, + 0.08043859153985977, + 0.08743293583393097, + 0.05997684597969055, + 0.06389731168746948, + 0.16543282568454742 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10037512332201004 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up, macro-style view of a human eye?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the iris pale blue with a visible crystal-like fibrous pattern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a single cold-toned key light from a high side angle illuminate the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a viscous black liquid gush from the inner corner of the eye and seep down to the lower lash line?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perfectly static throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00864796806126833 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758647918701172 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00864796806126833, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00864796806126833, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.045659855008125305, + 0.0436420775949955, + 0.05008743703365326, + 0.287808358669281, + 0.28198564052581787, + 0.17133070528507233, + 0.023406580090522766, + 0.024693762883543968, + 0.050233788788318634, + 0.021151838824152946 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00864796806126833 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up, macro-style view of a human eye?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the iris pale blue with a visible crystal-like fibrous pattern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a single cold-toned key light from a high side angle illuminate the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a viscous black liquid gush from the inner corner of the eye and seep down to the lower lash line?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perfectly static throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.13711416721344 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.38711413741111755 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.13711416721344, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -1.13711416721344, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05573275685310364, + 0.04657860845327377, + 0.03642987087368965, + 0.2340880185365677, + 0.15710406005382538, + 0.13530698418617249, + 0.0686340183019638, + 0.04395061358809471, + 0.19307804107666016, + 0.029097000136971474 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.13711416721344 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up, macro-style shot remains perfectly static, focusing on the complex landscape of a human face. The frame is dominated by a gleaming eye with a crystal-like pale blue iris, its intricate fibrous pattern visible in ultra-fine detail. A single, cold-toned key light from a high side angle illuminates the scene, giving the cornea a damp sheen and revealing its delicate network of capillaries. From the delicate inner corner of the eye, a viscous black liquid begins to gush, accumulating erratically before steadily and deliberately seeping down to the lower lash line. This dark liquid, with its oily, reflective surface, captures the single light source, following a slow, uninterrupted path along pale skin, navigating the fine, almost invisible fuzz and delicate texture of pores. The stark contrast between the dark liquid, pale skin, and bright eye, combined with the subject's unblinking stillness, creates a deeply unsettling and surreal atmosphere, filled with unspoken tension.", + "seed": 11723, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_14/index_1522_seed_11723_dp_28_rank_56_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.2860084392130375, + "vlm_logprob": -0.2860084392130375, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.574999976158142, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.2860084392130375, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up, macro-style view of a human eye?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the iris pale blue with a visible crystal-like fibrous pattern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a single cold-toned key light from a high side angle illuminate the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a viscous black liquid gush from the inner corner of the eye and seep down to the lower lash line?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perfectly static throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002153698354959488 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.1271538734436035 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002153698354959488, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002153698354959488, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17789585888385773, + 0.05556304007768631, + 0.06818483024835587, + 0.05359615385532379, + 0.05516367405653, + 0.3010634183883667, + 0.07728193700313568, + 0.06261459738016129, + 0.04399914667010307, + 0.10463736951351166 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002153698354959488 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up, macro-style view of a human eye?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the iris pale blue with a visible crystal-like fibrous pattern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a single cold-toned key light from a high side angle illuminate the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a viscous black liquid gush from the inner corner of the eye and seep down to the lower lash line?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perfectly static throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029842406511306763 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298423767089844 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029842406511306763, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029842406511306763, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08986691385507584, + 0.0902351438999176, + 0.09549777954816818, + 0.03854992985725403, + 0.0784502625465393, + 0.45664775371551514, + 0.04226219654083252, + 0.037435274571180344, + 0.03870641067624092, + 0.032348353415727615 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029842406511306763 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up, macro-style view of a human eye?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the iris pale blue with a visible crystal-like fibrous pattern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a single cold-toned key light from a high side angle illuminate the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a viscous black liquid gush from the inner corner of the eye and seep down to the lower lash line?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perfectly static throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14289604127407074 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0178959369659424 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14289604127407074, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.8749998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14289604127407074, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20922811329364777, + 0.07424314320087433, + 0.11213183403015137, + 0.09174696356058121, + 0.057478081434965134, + 0.2086808979511261, + 0.144918292760849, + 0.03349447250366211, + 0.043967362493276596, + 0.024110792204737663 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14289604127407074 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up, macro-style view of a human eye?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the iris pale blue with a visible crystal-like fibrous pattern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a single cold-toned key light from a high side angle illuminate the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a viscous black liquid gush from the inner corner of the eye and seep down to the lower lash line?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perfectly static throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4289341866970062 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.0539342164993286 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.4289341866970062, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.4289341866970062, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06462753564119339, + 0.049285825341939926, + 0.027398731559515, + 0.02634332701563835, + 0.14732126891613007, + 0.5915193557739258, + 0.041532669216394424, + 0.02924627624452114, + 0.010542619973421097, + 0.012182475998997688 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.4289341866970062 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up, macro-style view of a human eye?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the iris pale blue with a visible crystal-like fibrous pattern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a single cold-toned key light from a high side angle illuminate the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a viscous black liquid gush from the inner corner of the eye and seep down to the lower lash line?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perfectly static throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8262158632278442 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5762158632278442 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.8262158632278442, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.8262158632278442, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09313318133354187, + 0.06685129553079605, + 0.0333484522998333, + 0.04051515832543373, + 0.14957931637763977, + 0.5189921259880066, + 0.04851868003606796, + 0.0207691453397274, + 0.01883791945874691, + 0.009454683400690556 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.8262158632278442 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up, macro-style shot remains perfectly static, focusing on the complex landscape of a human face. The frame is dominated by a gleaming eye with a crystal-like pale blue iris, its intricate fibrous pattern visible in ultra-fine detail. A single, cold-toned key light from a high side angle illuminates the scene, giving the cornea a damp sheen and revealing its delicate network of capillaries. From the delicate inner corner of the eye, a viscous black liquid begins to gush, accumulating erratically before steadily and deliberately seeping down to the lower lash line. This dark liquid, with its oily, reflective surface, captures the single light source, following a slow, uninterrupted path along pale skin, navigating the fine, almost invisible fuzz and delicate texture of pores. The stark contrast between the dark liquid, pale skin, and bright eye, combined with the subject's unblinking stillness, creates a deeply unsettling and surreal atmosphere, filled with unspoken tension.", + "seed": 11724, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_14/index_1522_seed_11724_dp_29_rank_58_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.23976061693392695, + "vlm_logprob": -0.23976061693392695, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.5999999046325684, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.23976061693392695, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up, macro-style view of a human eye?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the iris pale blue with a visible crystal-like fibrous pattern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a single cold-toned key light from a high side angle illuminate the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a viscous black liquid gush from the inner corner of the eye and seep down to the lower lash line?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perfectly static throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002538080094382167 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -8.002537727355957 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002538080094382167, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.999999523162842, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002538080094382167, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10071159154176712, + 0.04472948983311653, + 0.05864372476935387, + 0.06904646754264832, + 0.1500554233789444, + 0.13826186954975128, + 0.20954343676567078, + 0.1282099187374115, + 0.057863749563694, + 0.04293425753712654 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002538080094382167 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up, macro-style view of a human eye?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the iris pale blue with a visible crystal-like fibrous pattern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a single cold-toned key light from a high side angle illuminate the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a viscous black liquid gush from the inner corner of the eye and seep down to the lower lash line?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perfectly static throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018228158354759216 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018228054046631 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018228158354759216, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018228158354759216, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12612730264663696, + 0.0835098922252655, + 0.06835025548934937, + 0.045743972063064575, + 0.19918431341648102, + 0.08255954086780548, + 0.14432598650455475, + 0.06033782288432121, + 0.08219821006059647, + 0.1076626256108284 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018228158354759216 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up, macro-style view of a human eye?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the iris pale blue with a visible crystal-like fibrous pattern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a single cold-toned key light from a high side angle illuminate the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a viscous black liquid gush from the inner corner of the eye and seep down to the lower lash line?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perfectly static throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1130019798874855 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.238002061843872 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1130019798874855, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1130019798874855, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1600078046321869, + 0.10036741197109222, + 0.04962550476193428, + 0.16874445974826813, + 0.08491712063550949, + 0.10037627816200256, + 0.0731598436832428, + 0.11171719431877136, + 0.05096692964434624, + 0.1001175045967102 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1130019798874855 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up, macro-style view of a human eye?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the iris pale blue with a visible crystal-like fibrous pattern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a single cold-toned key light from a high side angle illuminate the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a viscous black liquid gush from the inner corner of the eye and seep down to the lower lash line?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perfectly static throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011081814765930176 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511081695556641 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011081814765930176, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011081814765930176, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06318026036024094, + 0.025014763697981834, + 0.06457078456878662, + 0.1805706024169922, + 0.3253784775733948, + 0.10617472976446152, + 0.05004562437534332, + 0.07676596939563751, + 0.05213514342904091, + 0.056163687258958817 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011081814765930176 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up, macro-style view of a human eye?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the iris pale blue with a visible crystal-like fibrous pattern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a single cold-toned key light from a high side angle illuminate the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a viscous black liquid gush from the inner corner of the eye and seep down to the lower lash line?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perfectly static throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.0539530515670776 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.42895305156707764 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.0539530515670776, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.625, + "token_credit_reward": -1.0539530515670776, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1032911017537117, + 0.1274304986000061, + 0.09111709892749786, + 0.14048339426517487, + 0.09510139375925064, + 0.14559292793273926, + 0.08753765374422073, + 0.1564062386751175, + 0.031928665935993195, + 0.021110903471708298 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.0539530515670776 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up, macro-style shot remains perfectly static, focusing on the complex landscape of a human face. The frame is dominated by a gleaming eye with a crystal-like pale blue iris, its intricate fibrous pattern visible in ultra-fine detail. A single, cold-toned key light from a high side angle illuminates the scene, giving the cornea a damp sheen and revealing its delicate network of capillaries. From the delicate inner corner of the eye, a viscous black liquid begins to gush, accumulating erratically before steadily and deliberately seeping down to the lower lash line. This dark liquid, with its oily, reflective surface, captures the single light source, following a slow, uninterrupted path along pale skin, navigating the fine, almost invisible fuzz and delicate texture of pores. The stark contrast between the dark liquid, pale skin, and bright eye, combined with the subject's unblinking stillness, creates a deeply unsettling and surreal atmosphere, filled with unspoken tension.", + "seed": 11725, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_14/index_1522_seed_11725_dp_29_rank_58_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.19795042341575025, + "vlm_logprob": -0.19795042341575025, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.549999976158142, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.19795042341575025, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up, macro-style view of a human eye?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the iris pale blue with a visible crystal-like fibrous pattern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a single cold-toned key light from a high side angle illuminate the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a viscous black liquid gush from the inner corner of the eye and seep down to the lower lash line?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perfectly static throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0015679220668971539 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.876567840576172 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0015679220668971539, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0015679220668971539, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15215866267681122, + 0.14761033654212952, + 0.06920964270830154, + 0.07107044011354446, + 0.07704467326402664, + 0.08582543581724167, + 0.07625488936901093, + 0.11779166013002396, + 0.10606487095355988, + 0.09696950018405914 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0015679220668971539 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up, macro-style view of a human eye?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the iris pale blue with a visible crystal-like fibrous pattern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a single cold-toned key light from a high side angle illuminate the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a viscous black liquid gush from the inner corner of the eye and seep down to the lower lash line?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perfectly static throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020617341622710228 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8956172466278076 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020617341622710228, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020617341622710228, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15831616520881653, + 0.21570734679698944, + 0.08691414445638657, + 0.06346645206212997, + 0.05501712113618851, + 0.07384426891803741, + 0.08743598312139511, + 0.1355431079864502, + 0.08517379313707352, + 0.038581643253564835 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020617341622710228 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up, macro-style view of a human eye?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the iris pale blue with a visible crystal-like fibrous pattern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a single cold-toned key light from a high side angle illuminate the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a viscous black liquid gush from the inner corner of the eye and seep down to the lower lash line?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perfectly static throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1271260529756546 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1271259784698486 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1271260529756546, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.9999998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1271260529756546, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20131193101406097, + 0.18198147416114807, + 0.10617174953222275, + 0.0716027170419693, + 0.0911300852894783, + 0.052441954612731934, + 0.07158137112855911, + 0.08710581064224243, + 0.07117549329996109, + 0.06549737602472305 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1271260529756546 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up, macro-style view of a human eye?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the iris pale blue with a visible crystal-like fibrous pattern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a single cold-toned key light from a high side angle illuminate the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a viscous black liquid gush from the inner corner of the eye and seep down to the lower lash line?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perfectly static throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014206817373633385 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264206886291504 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014206817373633385, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014206817373633385, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.37258514761924744, + 0.18354196846485138, + 0.02897525765001774, + 0.094467394053936, + 0.05330834165215492, + 0.06579504907131195, + 0.08540964126586914, + 0.06566112488508224, + 0.0260438472032547, + 0.02421223744750023 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014206817373633385 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up, macro-style view of a human eye?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the iris pale blue with a visible crystal-like fibrous pattern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a single cold-toned key light from a high side angle illuminate the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a viscous black liquid gush from the inner corner of the eye and seep down to the lower lash line?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perfectly static throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.826233983039856 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.576233983039856 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.826233983039856, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.826233983039856, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2931314706802368, + 0.13571684062480927, + 0.0493137426674366, + 0.11413857340812683, + 0.06848730891942978, + 0.04247609153389931, + 0.04411884397268295, + 0.08287185430526733, + 0.1021447405219078, + 0.06760053336620331 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.826233983039856 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_15/index_tensor([6060, 6060])_group_15_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_15/index_tensor([6060, 6060])_group_15_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..ccdf9181fe656362a41eb6fbf2970d576d1b5c8c --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_15/index_tensor([6060, 6060])_group_15_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "gentle downward tilt begins, following and capturing an elegant celadon wine jug as it spins slowly and gracefully in mid-air, seemingly defying gravity. A classic Longquan kiln creation, the jug boasts a long neck and rounded belly. Its glaze is a soft, jade-like pale green, its surface adorned with delicate, natural ice cracks, shimmering with a restrained luster under the soft, diffuse light filtering through the paper window. As the camera descends, the jug's trajectory is precise, until its base, with near-silent grace, touches the deep-grained, richly colored pearwood table, stirring up a barely perceptible puff of dust. In the background, an elegant Song Dynasty study emerges. Through a latticed window, a few sparse, slanting plum blossoms peek through the courtyard, permeating the space with a tranquil, Zen-like atmosphere. The entire picture strictly follows the style of Song Dynasty court painting, with precise composition, elegant colors, even and soft lighting, no strong contrast between light and dark, and emphasis on the outline and texture of objects, creating an ultimate classical aesthetic and a quiet atmosphere of forgetting oneself and the world.", + "seed": 15365, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_15/index_6060_seed_15365_dp_30_rank_60_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.020359910558909178, + "vlm_logprob": -0.020359910558909178, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.375, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.020359910558909178, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a celadon wine jug with a long neck and rounded belly visible in the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the jug spinning slowly in mid-air before touching a pearwood table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the jug feature a soft jade-like pale green glaze with delicate ice cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background an elegant Song Dynasty study with a latticed window showing plum blossoms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with Song Dynasty court painting, featuring soft diffuse light and no strong contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003958842717111111 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628958702087402 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003958842717111111, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003958842717111111, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.6267601847648621, + 0.034208472818136215, + 0.17766420543193817, + 0.049060847610235214, + 0.02689395844936371, + 0.011375291272997856, + 0.022873202338814735, + 0.00972649548202753, + 0.028560681268572807, + 0.012876681052148342 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003958842717111111 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a celadon wine jug with a long neck and rounded belly visible in the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the jug spinning slowly in mid-air before touching a pearwood table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the jug feature a soft jade-like pale green glaze with delicate ice cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background an elegant Song Dynasty study with a latticed window showing plum blossoms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with Song Dynasty court painting, featuring soft diffuse light and no strong contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.038111183792352676 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881112098693848 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.038111183792352676, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.038111183792352676, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.7935724258422852, + 0.010459166951477528, + 0.06684891879558563, + 0.01265372708439827, + 0.023946695029735565, + 0.015985094010829926, + 0.011878817342221737, + 0.009429385885596275, + 0.02882743440568447, + 0.026398353278636932 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.038111183792352676 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a celadon wine jug with a long neck and rounded belly visible in the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the jug spinning slowly in mid-air before touching a pearwood table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the jug feature a soft jade-like pale green glaze with delicate ice cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background an elegant Song Dynasty study with a latticed window showing plum blossoms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with Song Dynasty court painting, featuring soft diffuse light and no strong contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0040998938493430614 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.5040998458862305 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0040998938493430614, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0040998938493430614, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3587212562561035, + 0.11155987530946732, + 0.2141754925251007, + 0.08190689235925674, + 0.055975787341594696, + 0.018023572862148285, + 0.042039450258016586, + 0.013538962230086327, + 0.036601483821868896, + 0.06745726615190506 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0040998938493430614 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a celadon wine jug with a long neck and rounded belly visible in the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the jug spinning slowly in mid-air before touching a pearwood table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the jug feature a soft jade-like pale green glaze with delicate ice cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background an elegant Song Dynasty study with a latticed window showing plum blossoms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with Song Dynasty court painting, featuring soft diffuse light and no strong contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04309263080358505 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168092727661133 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04309263080358505, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04309263080358505, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.7104416489601135, + 0.020585672929883003, + 0.03983074799180031, + 0.13432250916957855, + 0.013448904268443584, + 0.007965006865561008, + 0.018956080079078674, + 0.003513715462759137, + 0.013557104393839836, + 0.037378642708063126 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04309263080358505 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a celadon wine jug with a long neck and rounded belly visible in the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the jug spinning slowly in mid-air before touching a pearwood table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the jug feature a soft jade-like pale green glaze with delicate ice cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background an elegant Song Dynasty study with a latticed window showing plum blossoms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with Song Dynasty court painting, featuring soft diffuse light and no strong contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012537001632153988 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387537002563477 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012537001632153988, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012537001632153988, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.7459768056869507, + 0.018097296357154846, + 0.10329616814851761, + 0.019662676379084587, + 0.012821963988244534, + 0.013404108583927155, + 0.009757506661117077, + 0.00915875006467104, + 0.022632546722888947, + 0.0451921783387661 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012537001632153988 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "gentle downward tilt begins, following and capturing an elegant celadon wine jug as it spins slowly and gracefully in mid-air, seemingly defying gravity. A classic Longquan kiln creation, the jug boasts a long neck and rounded belly. Its glaze is a soft, jade-like pale green, its surface adorned with delicate, natural ice cracks, shimmering with a restrained luster under the soft, diffuse light filtering through the paper window. As the camera descends, the jug's trajectory is precise, until its base, with near-silent grace, touches the deep-grained, richly colored pearwood table, stirring up a barely perceptible puff of dust. In the background, an elegant Song Dynasty study emerges. Through a latticed window, a few sparse, slanting plum blossoms peek through the courtyard, permeating the space with a tranquil, Zen-like atmosphere. The entire picture strictly follows the style of Song Dynasty court painting, with precise composition, elegant colors, even and soft lighting, no strong contrast between light and dark, and emphasis on the outline and texture of objects, creating an ultimate classical aesthetic and a quiet atmosphere of forgetting oneself and the world.", + "seed": 15366, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_15/index_6060_seed_15366_dp_30_rank_60_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.02030097199603915, + "vlm_logprob": -0.02030097199603915, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.3, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.02030097199603915, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a celadon wine jug with a long neck and rounded belly visible in the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the jug spinning slowly in mid-air before touching a pearwood table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the jug feature a soft jade-like pale green glaze with delicate ice cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background an elegant Song Dynasty study with a latticed window showing plum blossoms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with Song Dynasty court painting, featuring soft diffuse light and no strong contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00395813025534153 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628958225250244 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00395813025534153, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00395813025534153, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.27000758051872253, + 0.06466389447450638, + 0.03241731598973274, + 0.2107500433921814, + 0.10089530795812607, + 0.09775961935520172, + 0.08336544781923294, + 0.0512225516140461, + 0.046421051025390625, + 0.042497169226408005 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00395813025534153 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a celadon wine jug with a long neck and rounded belly visible in the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the jug spinning slowly in mid-air before touching a pearwood table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the jug feature a soft jade-like pale green glaze with delicate ice cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background an elegant Song Dynasty study with a latticed window showing plum blossoms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with Song Dynasty court painting, featuring soft diffuse light and no strong contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03810969367623329 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.28810977935791 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03810969367623329, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03810969367623329, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14621450006961823, + 0.04475037381052971, + 0.03939550742506981, + 0.1653164029121399, + 0.07965252548456192, + 0.15081411600112915, + 0.10709255933761597, + 0.10264530777931213, + 0.10046692192554474, + 0.06365182250738144 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03810969367623329 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a celadon wine jug with a long neck and rounded belly visible in the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the jug spinning slowly in mid-air before touching a pearwood table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the jug feature a soft jade-like pale green glaze with delicate ice cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background an elegant Song Dynasty study with a latticed window showing plum blossoms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with Song Dynasty court painting, featuring soft diffuse light and no strong contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005257589276880026 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255257606506348 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005257589276880026, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005257589276880026, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20493921637535095, + 0.11432445794343948, + 0.07843799889087677, + 0.09458673745393753, + 0.06630914658308029, + 0.16979104280471802, + 0.10100092738866806, + 0.058883726596832275, + 0.0770329087972641, + 0.03469385579228401 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005257589276880026 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a celadon wine jug with a long neck and rounded belly visible in the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the jug spinning slowly in mid-air before touching a pearwood table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the jug feature a soft jade-like pale green glaze with delicate ice cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background an elegant Song Dynasty study with a latticed window showing plum blossoms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with Song Dynasty court painting, featuring soft diffuse light and no strong contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.038115888833999634 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288115978240967 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.038115888833999634, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.038115888833999634, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21844519674777985, + 0.26494038105010986, + 0.05419163778424263, + 0.11035346984863281, + 0.10151182860136032, + 0.0935487449169159, + 0.049222543835639954, + 0.03575367480516434, + 0.03509753197431564, + 0.03693491593003273 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.038115888833999634 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a celadon wine jug with a long neck and rounded belly visible in the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the jug spinning slowly in mid-air before touching a pearwood table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the jug feature a soft jade-like pale green glaze with delicate ice cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background an elegant Song Dynasty study with a latticed window showing plum blossoms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with Song Dynasty court painting, featuring soft diffuse light and no strong contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01606355793774128 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141063690185547 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01606355793774128, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01606355793774128, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20477354526519775, + 0.07271569222211838, + 0.039814114570617676, + 0.13222330808639526, + 0.16017790138721466, + 0.11056462675333023, + 0.07704563438892365, + 0.07073526829481125, + 0.06785044074058533, + 0.06409945338964462 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01606355793774128 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "gentle downward tilt begins, following and capturing an elegant celadon wine jug as it spins slowly and gracefully in mid-air, seemingly defying gravity. A classic Longquan kiln creation, the jug boasts a long neck and rounded belly. Its glaze is a soft, jade-like pale green, its surface adorned with delicate, natural ice cracks, shimmering with a restrained luster under the soft, diffuse light filtering through the paper window. As the camera descends, the jug's trajectory is precise, until its base, with near-silent grace, touches the deep-grained, richly colored pearwood table, stirring up a barely perceptible puff of dust. In the background, an elegant Song Dynasty study emerges. Through a latticed window, a few sparse, slanting plum blossoms peek through the courtyard, permeating the space with a tranquil, Zen-like atmosphere. The entire picture strictly follows the style of Song Dynasty court painting, with precise composition, elegant colors, even and soft lighting, no strong contrast between light and dark, and emphasis on the outline and texture of objects, creating an ultimate classical aesthetic and a quiet atmosphere of forgetting oneself and the world.", + "seed": 15367, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_15/index_6060_seed_15367_dp_31_rank_62_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.03779353899881244, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03779353899881244, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.125, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03779353899881244, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a celadon wine jug with a long neck and rounded belly visible in the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the jug spinning slowly in mid-air before touching a pearwood table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the jug feature a soft jade-like pale green glaze with delicate ice cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background an elegant Song Dynasty study with a latticed window showing plum blossoms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with Song Dynasty court painting, featuring soft diffuse light and no strong contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004943054635077715 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379942893981934 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004943054635077715, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004943054635077715, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21859046816825867, + 0.0705273225903511, + 0.07060599327087402, + 0.10026015341281891, + 0.0856337621808052, + 0.07692418992519379, + 0.09864547103643417, + 0.12512139976024628, + 0.04780548810958862, + 0.10588568449020386 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004943054635077715 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a celadon wine jug with a long neck and rounded belly visible in the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the jug spinning slowly in mid-air before touching a pearwood table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the jug feature a soft jade-like pale green glaze with delicate ice cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background an elegant Song Dynasty study with a latticed window showing plum blossoms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with Song Dynasty court painting, featuring soft diffuse light and no strong contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12707199156284332 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1270720958709717 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12707199156284332, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12707199156284332, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14510005712509155, + 0.03673476725816727, + 0.041231606155633926, + 0.12949897348880768, + 0.05670882388949394, + 0.05292023718357086, + 0.08610517531633377, + 0.31137779355049133, + 0.01790032908320427, + 0.1224222257733345 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12707199156284332 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a celadon wine jug with a long neck and rounded belly visible in the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the jug spinning slowly in mid-air before touching a pearwood table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the jug feature a soft jade-like pale green glaze with delicate ice cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background an elegant Song Dynasty study with a latticed window showing plum blossoms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with Song Dynasty court painting, featuring soft diffuse light and no strong contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004098350182175636 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504098415374756 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004098350182175636, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004098350182175636, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.35202085971832275, + 0.06688617169857025, + 0.050666410475969315, + 0.212765634059906, + 0.06638237833976746, + 0.03012201003730297, + 0.03660401329398155, + 0.08822790533304214, + 0.033557988703250885, + 0.0627666562795639 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004098350182175636 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a celadon wine jug with a long neck and rounded belly visible in the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the jug spinning slowly in mid-air before touching a pearwood table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the jug feature a soft jade-like pale green glaze with delicate ice cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background an elegant Song Dynasty study with a latticed window showing plum blossoms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with Song Dynasty court painting, featuring soft diffuse light and no strong contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.043075960129499435 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680760383605957 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.043075960129499435, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.043075960129499435, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12665943801403046, + 0.1534656435251236, + 0.028334591537714005, + 0.04412301629781723, + 0.0926017239689827, + 0.06601918488740921, + 0.0746142566204071, + 0.1071983128786087, + 0.117795929312706, + 0.1891878843307495 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.043075960129499435 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a celadon wine jug with a long neck and rounded belly visible in the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the jug spinning slowly in mid-air before touching a pearwood table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the jug feature a soft jade-like pale green glaze with delicate ice cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background an elegant Song Dynasty study with a latticed window showing plum blossoms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with Song Dynasty court painting, featuring soft diffuse light and no strong contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009778338484466076 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.6347784996032715 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009778338484466076, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009778338484466076, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3299984633922577, + 0.05492577329277992, + 0.031995438039302826, + 0.033326856791973114, + 0.05080076679587364, + 0.026331603527069092, + 0.029983360320329666, + 0.17645704746246338, + 0.0425558015704155, + 0.22362491488456726 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009778338484466076 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "gentle downward tilt begins, following and capturing an elegant celadon wine jug as it spins slowly and gracefully in mid-air, seemingly defying gravity. A classic Longquan kiln creation, the jug boasts a long neck and rounded belly. Its glaze is a soft, jade-like pale green, its surface adorned with delicate, natural ice cracks, shimmering with a restrained luster under the soft, diffuse light filtering through the paper window. As the camera descends, the jug's trajectory is precise, until its base, with near-silent grace, touches the deep-grained, richly colored pearwood table, stirring up a barely perceptible puff of dust. In the background, an elegant Song Dynasty study emerges. Through a latticed window, a few sparse, slanting plum blossoms peek through the courtyard, permeating the space with a tranquil, Zen-like atmosphere. The entire picture strictly follows the style of Song Dynasty court painting, with precise composition, elegant colors, even and soft lighting, no strong contrast between light and dark, and emphasis on the outline and texture of objects, creating an ultimate classical aesthetic and a quiet atmosphere of forgetting oneself and the world.", + "seed": 15368, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_15/index_6060_seed_15368_dp_31_rank_62_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.030001186206936835, + "vlm_logprob": -0.030001186206936835, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.05, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.030001186206936835, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a celadon wine jug with a long neck and rounded belly visible in the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the jug spinning slowly in mid-air before touching a pearwood table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the jug feature a soft jade-like pale green glaze with delicate ice cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background an elegant Song Dynasty study with a latticed window showing plum blossoms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with Song Dynasty court painting, featuring soft diffuse light and no strong contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007010149769484997 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.007009983062744 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007010149769484997, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007010149769484997, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3066764771938324, + 0.1649928092956543, + 0.24818313121795654, + 0.0548863559961319, + 0.017331743612885475, + 0.03387310355901718, + 0.023021211847662926, + 0.11378204822540283, + 0.016506148502230644, + 0.020746959373354912 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007010149769484997 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a celadon wine jug with a long neck and rounded belly visible in the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the jug spinning slowly in mid-air before touching a pearwood table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the jug feature a soft jade-like pale green glaze with delicate ice cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background an elegant Song Dynasty study with a latticed window showing plum blossoms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with Song Dynasty court painting, featuring soft diffuse light and no strong contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04867328703403473 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048673391342163 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04867328703403473, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04867328703403473, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.214666485786438, + 0.07866393774747849, + 0.2985100746154785, + 0.018066978082060814, + 0.01644621044397354, + 0.16556985676288605, + 0.07767684012651443, + 0.0782834142446518, + 0.02505596913397312, + 0.027060238644480705 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04867328703403473 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a celadon wine jug with a long neck and rounded belly visible in the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the jug spinning slowly in mid-air before touching a pearwood table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the jug feature a soft jade-like pale green glaze with delicate ice cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background an elegant Song Dynasty study with a latticed window showing plum blossoms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with Song Dynasty court painting, featuring soft diffuse light and no strong contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007639951538294554 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.8826398849487305 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007639951538294554, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007639951538294554, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09100280702114105, + 0.2523098289966583, + 0.24831755459308624, + 0.05702340975403786, + 0.06392879784107208, + 0.10026094317436218, + 0.06362683326005936, + 0.05441964417695999, + 0.027010438963770866, + 0.04209975525736809 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007639951538294554 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a celadon wine jug with a long neck and rounded belly visible in the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the jug spinning slowly in mid-air before touching a pearwood table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the jug feature a soft jade-like pale green glaze with delicate ice cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background an elegant Song Dynasty study with a latticed window showing plum blossoms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with Song Dynasty court painting, featuring soft diffuse light and no strong contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07905619591474533 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5790562629699707 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07905619591474533, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07905619591474533, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20319324731826782, + 0.16128213703632355, + 0.5667788982391357, + 0.01152709312736988, + 0.01145534124225378, + 0.01598145067691803, + 0.010691080242395401, + 0.008402523584663868, + 0.004621022846549749, + 0.006067126523703337 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07905619591474533 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a celadon wine jug with a long neck and rounded belly visible in the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the jug spinning slowly in mid-air before touching a pearwood table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the jug feature a soft jade-like pale green glaze with delicate ice cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background an elegant Song Dynasty study with a latticed window showing plum blossoms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with Song Dynasty court painting, featuring soft diffuse light and no strong contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007626346778124571 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882626533508301 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007626346778124571, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007626346778124571, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3566135764122009, + 0.11522646248340607, + 0.13679897785186768, + 0.05259304493665695, + 0.040503617376089096, + 0.05140102654695511, + 0.0946262776851654, + 0.07609398663043976, + 0.04223369061946869, + 0.03390926495194435 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007626346778124571 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_2/index_tensor([6957, 6957])_group_2_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_2/index_tensor([6957, 6957])_group_2_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..53efa6302aa9b5a5344d2ba51b9896199e55f60b --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_2/index_tensor([6957, 6957])_group_2_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "static, slightly low-angle close-up captures a modern, minimalist gooseneck table lamp resting on a lightly textured wooden surface. Finished in a uniformly smooth matte black, the lamp features a slender, flexible neck that gracefully transitions from a heavy, round base to a simple, disc-shaped LED head. When on, the lamp casts a focused, circular beam of bright, cool white light onto the table, highlighting the subtle grain of the wood. Following a faint, invisible surface vibration, the lamp's head and upper neck begin to vibrate gently from side to side. The movement is fluid and subtle, a brief, silent dance that rapidly diminishes as the amplitude of the vibration steadily decreases, until, in an instant, all movement ceases and the lamp returns to a perfect state of stillness, its elegant form a stark, silent silhouette against the softly lit, out-of-focus background of the quiet study. The atmosphere is one of focused tranquility and minimalist calm, the fleeting movements only emphasizing the scene's profound stillness.", + "seed": 16210, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_2/index_6957_seed_16210_dp_4_rank_8_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.054144436866045, + "vlm_logprob": -0.054144436866045, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.175, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.054144436866045, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a modern, minimalist gooseneck table lamp with a matte black finish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the lamp resting on a lightly textured wooden surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the lamp cast a focused, circular beam of bright, cool white light onto the table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lamp's head and upper neck vibrate gently from side to side before coming to a complete stop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, slightly low-angle close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004532895982265472 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504532814025879 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004532895982265472, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004532895982265472, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.37189021706581116, + 0.0956500694155693, + 0.026454932987689972, + 0.0610516257584095, + 0.0476335734128952, + 0.025239186361432076, + 0.1309809386730194, + 0.03343426436185837, + 0.16245707869529724, + 0.04520809277892113 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004532895982265472 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a modern, minimalist gooseneck table lamp with a matte black finish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the lamp resting on a lightly textured wooden surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the lamp cast a focused, circular beam of bright, cool white light onto the table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lamp's head and upper neck vibrate gently from side to side before coming to a complete stop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, slightly low-angle close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004097993951290846 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504097938537598 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004097993951290846, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004097993951290846, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.36544519662857056, + 0.13076141476631165, + 0.04886535182595253, + 0.05600430816411972, + 0.06964077055454254, + 0.07840428501367569, + 0.0627216026186943, + 0.10730335116386414, + 0.030362850055098534, + 0.05049087107181549 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004097993951290846 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a modern, minimalist gooseneck table lamp with a matte black finish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the lamp resting on a lightly textured wooden surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the lamp cast a focused, circular beam of bright, cool white light onto the table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lamp's head and upper neck vibrate gently from side to side before coming to a complete stop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, slightly low-angle close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029805496335029602 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298054218292236 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029805496335029602, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029805496335029602, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4159824848175049, + 0.09725894778966904, + 0.036828260868787766, + 0.09340378642082214, + 0.051636673510074615, + 0.034679707139730453, + 0.07705555856227875, + 0.03963020443916321, + 0.07726847380399704, + 0.07625588029623032 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029805496335029602 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a modern, minimalist gooseneck table lamp with a matte black finish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the lamp resting on a lightly textured wooden surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the lamp cast a focused, circular beam of bright, cool white light onto the table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lamp's head and upper neck vibrate gently from side to side before coming to a complete stop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, slightly low-angle close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22555410861968994 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.60055410861969 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.22555410861968994, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.22555410861968994, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17969933152198792, + 0.07688488066196442, + 0.05995651334524155, + 0.12706422805786133, + 0.1929108202457428, + 0.042870454490184784, + 0.07407641410827637, + 0.09212903678417206, + 0.10716554522514343, + 0.04724271222949028 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.22555410861968994 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a modern, minimalist gooseneck table lamp with a matte black finish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the lamp resting on a lightly textured wooden surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the lamp cast a focused, circular beam of bright, cool white light onto the table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lamp's head and upper neck vibrate gently from side to side before coming to a complete stop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, slightly low-angle close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006731689441949129 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.0067315101623535 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006731689441949129, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006731689441949129, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4503915011882782, + 0.06254700571298599, + 0.041504960507154465, + 0.06107426434755325, + 0.06836941838264465, + 0.036445699632167816, + 0.08106380701065063, + 0.017042061313986778, + 0.09243907034397125, + 0.08912228047847748 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006731689441949129 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, slightly low-angle close-up captures a modern, minimalist gooseneck table lamp resting on a lightly textured wooden surface. Finished in a uniformly smooth matte black, the lamp features a slender, flexible neck that gracefully transitions from a heavy, round base to a simple, disc-shaped LED head. When on, the lamp casts a focused, circular beam of bright, cool white light onto the table, highlighting the subtle grain of the wood. Following a faint, invisible surface vibration, the lamp's head and upper neck begin to vibrate gently from side to side. The movement is fluid and subtle, a brief, silent dance that rapidly diminishes as the amplitude of the vibration steadily decreases, until, in an instant, all movement ceases and the lamp returns to a perfect state of stillness, its elegant form a stark, silent silhouette against the softly lit, out-of-focus background of the quiet study. The atmosphere is one of focused tranquility and minimalist calm, the fleeting movements only emphasizing the scene's profound stillness.", + "seed": 16211, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_2/index_6957_seed_16211_dp_4_rank_8_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.03168240087106824, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03168240087106824, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.125, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03168240087106824, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a modern, minimalist gooseneck table lamp with a matte black finish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the lamp resting on a lightly textured wooden surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the lamp cast a focused, circular beam of bright, cool white light onto the table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lamp's head and upper neck vibrate gently from side to side before coming to a complete stop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, slightly low-angle close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007124495226889849 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.007124423980713 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007124495226889849, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007124495226889849, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19590450823307037, + 0.08347757905721664, + 0.045792050659656525, + 0.03612019866704941, + 0.12548574805259705, + 0.06925532966852188, + 0.17693500220775604, + 0.1501213014125824, + 0.054142825305461884, + 0.0627654492855072 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007124495226889849 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a modern, minimalist gooseneck table lamp with a matte black finish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the lamp resting on a lightly textured wooden surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the lamp cast a focused, circular beam of bright, cool white light onto the table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lamp's head and upper neck vibrate gently from side to side before coming to a complete stop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, slightly low-angle close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02057763561606407 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955776691436768 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02057763561606407, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02057763561606407, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23358646035194397, + 0.12513110041618347, + 0.050073977559804916, + 0.028416968882083893, + 0.09178569912910461, + 0.14839088916778564, + 0.14997988939285278, + 0.08281239867210388, + 0.03214974328875542, + 0.05767283961176872 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02057763561606407 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a modern, minimalist gooseneck table lamp with a matte black finish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the lamp resting on a lightly textured wooden surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the lamp cast a focused, circular beam of bright, cool white light onto the table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lamp's head and upper neck vibrate gently from side to side before coming to a complete stop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, slightly low-angle close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012541593052446842 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387541770935059 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012541593052446842, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012541593052446842, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.34295153617858887, + 0.08479472249746323, + 0.04386581853032112, + 0.040695033967494965, + 0.14344359934329987, + 0.0856442004442215, + 0.12081544101238251, + 0.07797829806804657, + 0.02480432204902172, + 0.03500709682703018 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012541593052446842 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a modern, minimalist gooseneck table lamp with a matte black finish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the lamp resting on a lightly textured wooden surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the lamp cast a focused, circular beam of bright, cool white light onto the table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lamp's head and upper neck vibrate gently from side to side before coming to a complete stop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, slightly low-angle close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11291839927434921 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2379183769226074 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11291839927434921, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11291839927434921, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24070508778095245, + 0.07550586014986038, + 0.05820683017373085, + 0.1430625021457672, + 0.10692348331212997, + 0.07298489660024643, + 0.10800773650407791, + 0.06675171107053757, + 0.09541767835617065, + 0.03243415430188179 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11291839927434921 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a modern, minimalist gooseneck table lamp with a matte black finish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the lamp resting on a lightly textured wooden surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the lamp cast a focused, circular beam of bright, cool white light onto the table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lamp's head and upper neck vibrate gently from side to side before coming to a complete stop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, slightly low-angle close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005249881185591221 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255249977111816 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005249881185591221, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005249881185591221, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1399872899055481, + 0.089937224984169, + 0.07160795480012894, + 0.1991402804851532, + 0.023476891219615936, + 0.028958985581994057, + 0.255586713552475, + 0.04803812503814697, + 0.10788602381944656, + 0.03538047894835472 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005249881185591221 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, slightly low-angle close-up captures a modern, minimalist gooseneck table lamp resting on a lightly textured wooden surface. Finished in a uniformly smooth matte black, the lamp features a slender, flexible neck that gracefully transitions from a heavy, round base to a simple, disc-shaped LED head. When on, the lamp casts a focused, circular beam of bright, cool white light onto the table, highlighting the subtle grain of the wood. Following a faint, invisible surface vibration, the lamp's head and upper neck begin to vibrate gently from side to side. The movement is fluid and subtle, a brief, silent dance that rapidly diminishes as the amplitude of the vibration steadily decreases, until, in an instant, all movement ceases and the lamp returns to a perfect state of stillness, its elegant form a stark, silent silhouette against the softly lit, out-of-focus background of the quiet study. The atmosphere is one of focused tranquility and minimalist calm, the fleeting movements only emphasizing the scene's profound stillness.", + "seed": 16212, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_2/index_6957_seed_16212_dp_5_rank_10_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.023315915558487176, + "vlm_logprob": -0.023315915558487176, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.65, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.023315915558487176, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a modern, minimalist gooseneck table lamp with a matte black finish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the lamp resting on a lightly textured wooden surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the lamp cast a focused, circular beam of bright, cool white light onto the table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lamp's head and upper neck vibrate gently from side to side before coming to a complete stop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, slightly low-angle close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0028271013870835304 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002827167510986 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0028271013870835304, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0028271013870835304, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10664490610361099, + 0.015035553835332394, + 0.035444919019937515, + 0.011706131510436535, + 0.12302782386541367, + 0.04000207036733627, + 0.097682423889637, + 0.027617380023002625, + 0.023380203172564507, + 0.5194585919380188 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0028271013870835304 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a modern, minimalist gooseneck table lamp with a matte black finish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the lamp resting on a lightly textured wooden surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the lamp cast a focused, circular beam of bright, cool white light onto the table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lamp's head and upper neck vibrate gently from side to side before coming to a complete stop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, slightly low-angle close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00248873233795166 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002488613128662 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00248873233795166, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00248873233795166, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2206910401582718, + 0.0782390907406807, + 0.018208006396889687, + 0.013170517981052399, + 0.08812349289655685, + 0.1455220729112625, + 0.035155318677425385, + 0.059811342507600784, + 0.027737248688936234, + 0.31334182620048523 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00248873233795166 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a modern, minimalist gooseneck table lamp with a matte black finish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the lamp resting on a lightly textured wooden surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the lamp cast a focused, circular beam of bright, cool white light onto the table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lamp's head and upper neck vibrate gently from side to side before coming to a complete stop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, slightly low-angle close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02635188400745392 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513519287109375 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02635188400745392, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02635188400745392, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07499607652425766, + 0.017877919599413872, + 0.012098262086510658, + 0.017079398036003113, + 0.6153784394264221, + 0.02548450045287609, + 0.04398701712489128, + 0.02828756347298622, + 0.03091244585812092, + 0.13389848172664642 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02635188400745392 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a modern, minimalist gooseneck table lamp with a matte black finish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the lamp resting on a lightly textured wooden surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the lamp cast a focused, circular beam of bright, cool white light onto the table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lamp's head and upper neck vibrate gently from side to side before coming to a complete stop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, slightly low-angle close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07896873354911804 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5789687633514404 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07896873354911804, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07896873354911804, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.036889366805553436, + 0.022590449079871178, + 0.01409788429737091, + 0.03607982397079468, + 0.2111462950706482, + 0.058967918157577515, + 0.042856890708208084, + 0.03638994321227074, + 0.02176581509411335, + 0.5192155838012695 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07896873354911804 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a modern, minimalist gooseneck table lamp with a matte black finish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the lamp resting on a lightly textured wooden surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the lamp cast a focused, circular beam of bright, cool white light onto the table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lamp's head and upper neck vibrate gently from side to side before coming to a complete stop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, slightly low-angle close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0059431265108287334 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130943298339844 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0059431265108287334, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0059431265108287334, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10023383796215057, + 0.043247610330581665, + 0.0176918376237154, + 0.05809735879302025, + 0.19373413920402527, + 0.05039645731449127, + 0.03560808673501015, + 0.05367235466837883, + 0.054428715258836746, + 0.3928896188735962 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0059431265108287334 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, slightly low-angle close-up captures a modern, minimalist gooseneck table lamp resting on a lightly textured wooden surface. Finished in a uniformly smooth matte black, the lamp features a slender, flexible neck that gracefully transitions from a heavy, round base to a simple, disc-shaped LED head. When on, the lamp casts a focused, circular beam of bright, cool white light onto the table, highlighting the subtle grain of the wood. Following a faint, invisible surface vibration, the lamp's head and upper neck begin to vibrate gently from side to side. The movement is fluid and subtle, a brief, silent dance that rapidly diminishes as the amplitude of the vibration steadily decreases, until, in an instant, all movement ceases and the lamp returns to a perfect state of stillness, its elegant form a stark, silent silhouette against the softly lit, out-of-focus background of the quiet study. The atmosphere is one of focused tranquility and minimalist calm, the fleeting movements only emphasizing the scene's profound stillness.", + "seed": 16213, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_2/index_6957_seed_16213_dp_5_rank_10_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.023462033458054067, + "vlm_logprob": -0.023462033458054067, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.55, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.023462033458054067, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a modern, minimalist gooseneck table lamp with a matte black finish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the lamp resting on a lightly textured wooden surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the lamp cast a focused, circular beam of bright, cool white light onto the table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lamp's head and upper neck vibrate gently from side to side before coming to a complete stop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, slightly low-angle close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036297645419836044 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.878629684448242 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036297645419836044, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036297645419836044, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11437080055475235, + 0.29612624645233154, + 0.1517019271850586, + 0.05955108255147934, + 0.03672751039266586, + 0.06948966532945633, + 0.03619247302412987, + 0.10207825154066086, + 0.07240862399339676, + 0.06135338544845581 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036297645419836044 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a modern, minimalist gooseneck table lamp with a matte black finish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the lamp resting on a lightly textured wooden surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the lamp cast a focused, circular beam of bright, cool white light onto the table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lamp's head and upper neck vibrate gently from side to side before coming to a complete stop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, slightly low-angle close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0110772168263793 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511077404022217 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0110772168263793, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0110772168263793, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5010530948638916, + 0.0701831728219986, + 0.030585814267396927, + 0.05775660276412964, + 0.050642918795347214, + 0.035361338406801224, + 0.026425911113619804, + 0.05632904917001724, + 0.028815239667892456, + 0.14284686744213104 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0110772168263793 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a modern, minimalist gooseneck table lamp with a matte black finish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the lamp resting on a lightly textured wooden surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the lamp cast a focused, circular beam of bright, cool white light onto the table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lamp's head and upper neck vibrate gently from side to side before coming to a complete stop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, slightly low-angle close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00595355499535799 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130953788757324 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00595355499535799, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00595355499535799, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15852919220924377, + 0.25271686911582947, + 0.07477919012308121, + 0.08029287308454514, + 0.10904407501220703, + 0.07992550730705261, + 0.07656557112932205, + 0.07013416290283203, + 0.06461631506681442, + 0.03339632228016853 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00595355499535799 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a modern, minimalist gooseneck table lamp with a matte black finish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the lamp resting on a lightly textured wooden surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the lamp cast a focused, circular beam of bright, cool white light onto the table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lamp's head and upper neck vibrate gently from side to side before coming to a complete stop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, slightly low-angle close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08902517706155777 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4640252590179443 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08902517706155777, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08902517706155777, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12835682928562164, + 0.11250407248735428, + 0.08183447271585464, + 0.06616420298814774, + 0.13529124855995178, + 0.11779789626598358, + 0.08264981210231781, + 0.049105070531368256, + 0.1849481463432312, + 0.041348230093717575 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08902517706155777 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a modern, minimalist gooseneck table lamp with a matte black finish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the lamp resting on a lightly textured wooden surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the lamp cast a focused, circular beam of bright, cool white light onto the table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lamp's head and upper neck vibrate gently from side to side before coming to a complete stop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, slightly low-angle close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007624453864991665 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882624626159668 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007624453864991665, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007624453864991665, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15102386474609375, + 0.05449625477194786, + 0.03924012929201126, + 0.037901442497968674, + 0.04184993728995323, + 0.09898409992456436, + 0.2875516712665558, + 0.1170368641614914, + 0.14215798676013947, + 0.02975778467953205 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007624453864991665 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_3/index_tensor([9871, 9871])_group_3_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_3/index_tensor([9871, 9871])_group_3_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..3dceac3cba090a851cea037fdcaffd302e8fb338 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_3/index_tensor([9871, 9871])_group_3_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "slow, horizontal, medium close-up shot focuses on an elderly craftsman sitting in a dimly lit, yet orderly, restoration studio. His graying hair is meticulously combed back, his face deeply wrinkled. A pair of old-fashioned round magnifying glasses rest on his nose, his gaze focused and serene. He wears a faded indigo cotton work shirt and a brown leather apron stained with white dust and the marks of time. Before him, fixed to his workbench, is a dusty marble bust of a classical woman. The statue's face is elegant and peaceful, but a tiny crack mars its integrity. A beam of warm afternoon sunlight, streaming from a high window to the side, penetrates the fine dust particles floating in the air, forming distinct beams (a Tyndall effect), softly illuminating the craftsman's profile and the marble surface, revealing its veins and flaws. The craftsman holds the statue's shoulder steadily with one hand, while the other carefully grips a delicate scraper. With a near-meditative focus, he gently scrapes away the old, solidified filling from the cracks with the tip of the scraper. Fine white powder slowly flakes off as he moves. The dominant tones of the painting are warm brown, off-white, and vintage blue, creating a soft, retro aesthetic and a tranquil, focused, and timeless artistic atmosphere.", + "seed": 13576, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_3/index_9871_seed_13576_dp_6_rank_12_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.03590864930301905, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03590864930301905, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.875, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03590864930301905, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up focusing on an elderly craftsman with graying hair combed back and deep wrinkles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the craftsman wearing a faded indigo cotton work shirt and a brown leather apron stained with white dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a dusty marble bust of a classical woman fixed to the workbench in front of the craftsman?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the craftsman using a delicate scraper to remove old filling from a tiny crack in the statue's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a beam of warm afternoon sunlight streaming from a high window, illuminating dust particles and the statue's surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007667042315006256 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.132667064666748 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007667042315006256, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007667042315006256, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.30144330859184265, + 0.08812552690505981, + 0.06646541506052017, + 0.08258668333292007, + 0.059447795152664185, + 0.1029127985239029, + 0.0963817909359932, + 0.05352747440338135, + 0.06309497356414795, + 0.08601419627666473 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007667042315006256 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up focusing on an elderly craftsman with graying hair combed back and deep wrinkles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the craftsman wearing a faded indigo cotton work shirt and a brown leather apron stained with white dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a dusty marble bust of a classical woman fixed to the workbench in front of the craftsman?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the craftsman using a delicate scraper to remove old filling from a tiny crack in the statue's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a beam of warm afternoon sunlight streaming from a high window, illuminating dust particles and the statue's surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014214927330613136 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264214992523193 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014214927330613136, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014214927330613136, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23158809542655945, + 0.11338909715414047, + 0.07295745611190796, + 0.11340894550085068, + 0.10019208490848541, + 0.10695839673280716, + 0.06273343414068222, + 0.04169813171029091, + 0.09347459673881531, + 0.06359981000423431 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014214927330613136 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up focusing on an elderly craftsman with graying hair combed back and deep wrinkles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the craftsman wearing a faded indigo cotton work shirt and a brown leather apron stained with white dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a dusty marble bust of a classical woman fixed to the workbench in front of the craftsman?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the craftsman using a delicate scraper to remove old filling from a tiny crack in the statue's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a beam of warm afternoon sunlight streaming from a high window, illuminating dust particles and the statue's surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008646431379020214 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758646488189697 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008646431379020214, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008646431379020214, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2061915099620819, + 0.12904603779315948, + 0.1056579127907753, + 0.10119999945163727, + 0.03683152422308922, + 0.08131741732358932, + 0.19814720749855042, + 0.0782882571220398, + 0.0329732708632946, + 0.03034694865345955 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008646431379020214 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up focusing on an elderly craftsman with graying hair combed back and deep wrinkles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the craftsman wearing a faded indigo cotton work shirt and a brown leather apron stained with white dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a dusty marble bust of a classical woman fixed to the workbench in front of the craftsman?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the craftsman using a delicate scraper to remove old filling from a tiny crack in the statue's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a beam of warm afternoon sunlight streaming from a high window, illuminating dust particles and the statue's surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0486704483628273 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048670530319214 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0486704483628273, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0486704483628273, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1783536821603775, + 0.08860310912132263, + 0.05771065503358841, + 0.06594593077898026, + 0.062242455780506134, + 0.21099764108657837, + 0.1117267906665802, + 0.09142424911260605, + 0.08050531893968582, + 0.05249016359448433 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0486704483628273 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up focusing on an elderly craftsman with graying hair combed back and deep wrinkles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the craftsman wearing a faded indigo cotton work shirt and a brown leather apron stained with white dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a dusty marble bust of a classical woman fixed to the workbench in front of the craftsman?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the craftsman using a delicate scraper to remove old filling from a tiny crack in the statue's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a beam of warm afternoon sunlight streaming from a high window, illuminating dust particles and the statue's surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10034439712762833 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.35034441947937 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10034439712762833, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10034439712762833, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2592896521091461, + 0.10794639587402344, + 0.07337900251150131, + 0.045510433614254, + 0.05540473014116287, + 0.09402987360954285, + 0.07657349854707718, + 0.07755476236343384, + 0.1297052651643753, + 0.0806063711643219 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10034439712762833 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow, horizontal, medium close-up shot focuses on an elderly craftsman sitting in a dimly lit, yet orderly, restoration studio. His graying hair is meticulously combed back, his face deeply wrinkled. A pair of old-fashioned round magnifying glasses rest on his nose, his gaze focused and serene. He wears a faded indigo cotton work shirt and a brown leather apron stained with white dust and the marks of time. Before him, fixed to his workbench, is a dusty marble bust of a classical woman. The statue's face is elegant and peaceful, but a tiny crack mars its integrity. A beam of warm afternoon sunlight, streaming from a high window to the side, penetrates the fine dust particles floating in the air, forming distinct beams (a Tyndall effect), softly illuminating the craftsman's profile and the marble surface, revealing its veins and flaws. The craftsman holds the statue's shoulder steadily with one hand, while the other carefully grips a delicate scraper. With a near-meditative focus, he gently scrapes away the old, solidified filling from the cracks with the tip of the scraper. Fine white powder slowly flakes off as he moves. The dominant tones of the painting are warm brown, off-white, and vintage blue, creating a soft, retro aesthetic and a tranquil, focused, and timeless artistic atmosphere.", + "seed": 13577, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_3/index_9871_seed_13577_dp_6_rank_12_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.08078408725559712, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08078408725559712, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.3, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08078408725559712, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up focusing on an elderly craftsman with graying hair combed back and deep wrinkles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the craftsman wearing a faded indigo cotton work shirt and a brown leather apron stained with white dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a dusty marble bust of a classical woman fixed to the workbench in front of the craftsman?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the craftsman using a delicate scraper to remove old filling from a tiny crack in the statue's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a beam of warm afternoon sunlight streaming from a high window, illuminating dust particles and the statue's surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006841212511062622 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.38184118270874 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006841212511062622, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006841212511062622, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1918228566646576, + 0.07586970925331116, + 0.05599304661154747, + 0.08627213537693024, + 0.352791965007782, + 0.040541112422943115, + 0.03439564257860184, + 0.03132956102490425, + 0.04874362796545029, + 0.08224031329154968 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006841212511062622 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up focusing on an elderly craftsman with graying hair combed back and deep wrinkles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the craftsman wearing a faded indigo cotton work shirt and a brown leather apron stained with white dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a dusty marble bust of a classical woman fixed to the workbench in front of the craftsman?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the craftsman using a delicate scraper to remove old filling from a tiny crack in the statue's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a beam of warm afternoon sunlight streaming from a high window, illuminating dust particles and the statue's surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018203692510724068 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.0182037353515625 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018203692510724068, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018203692510724068, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09178650379180908, + 0.11739657819271088, + 0.10342437028884888, + 0.03928733244538307, + 0.4869024455547333, + 0.021505385637283325, + 0.03371192142367363, + 0.034800317138433456, + 0.02796829678118229, + 0.043216779828071594 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018203692510724068 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up focusing on an elderly craftsman with graying hair combed back and deep wrinkles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the craftsman wearing a faded indigo cotton work shirt and a brown leather apron stained with white dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a dusty marble bust of a classical woman fixed to the workbench in front of the craftsman?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the craftsman using a delicate scraper to remove old filling from a tiny crack in the statue's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a beam of warm afternoon sunlight streaming from a high window, illuminating dust particles and the statue's surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026362217962741852 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651362180709839 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026362217962741852, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026362217962741852, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07115178555250168, + 0.04503200948238373, + 0.11760015040636063, + 0.09301622956991196, + 0.17845968902111053, + 0.07711701095104218, + 0.07197948545217514, + 0.1574544906616211, + 0.08649825304746628, + 0.10169090330600739 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 7, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026362217962741852 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up focusing on an elderly craftsman with graying hair combed back and deep wrinkles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the craftsman wearing a faded indigo cotton work shirt and a brown leather apron stained with white dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a dusty marble bust of a classical woman fixed to the workbench in front of the craftsman?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the craftsman using a delicate scraper to remove old filling from a tiny crack in the statue's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a beam of warm afternoon sunlight streaming from a high window, illuminating dust particles and the statue's surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10034698247909546 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3503470420837402 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10034698247909546, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10034698247909546, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13387709856033325, + 0.06352677941322327, + 0.0977158471941948, + 0.12604139745235443, + 0.09726136177778244, + 0.09875669330358505, + 0.04663414508104324, + 0.18331609666347504, + 0.07302505522966385, + 0.07984549552202225 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10034698247909546 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up focusing on an elderly craftsman with graying hair combed back and deep wrinkles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the craftsman wearing a faded indigo cotton work shirt and a brown leather apron stained with white dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a dusty marble bust of a classical woman fixed to the workbench in front of the craftsman?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the craftsman using a delicate scraper to remove old filling from a tiny crack in the statue's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a beam of warm afternoon sunlight streaming from a high window, illuminating dust particles and the statue's surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2521663308143616 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5021662712097168 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2521663308143616, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2521663308143616, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.31641966104507446, + 0.1107436865568161, + 0.13053783774375916, + 0.06459996104240417, + 0.20036780834197998, + 0.03598687797784805, + 0.03729353845119476, + 0.04526415839791298, + 0.024611299857497215, + 0.03417520225048065 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2521663308143616 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow, horizontal, medium close-up shot focuses on an elderly craftsman sitting in a dimly lit, yet orderly, restoration studio. His graying hair is meticulously combed back, his face deeply wrinkled. A pair of old-fashioned round magnifying glasses rest on his nose, his gaze focused and serene. He wears a faded indigo cotton work shirt and a brown leather apron stained with white dust and the marks of time. Before him, fixed to his workbench, is a dusty marble bust of a classical woman. The statue's face is elegant and peaceful, but a tiny crack mars its integrity. A beam of warm afternoon sunlight, streaming from a high window to the side, penetrates the fine dust particles floating in the air, forming distinct beams (a Tyndall effect), softly illuminating the craftsman's profile and the marble surface, revealing its veins and flaws. The craftsman holds the statue's shoulder steadily with one hand, while the other carefully grips a delicate scraper. With a near-meditative focus, he gently scrapes away the old, solidified filling from the cracks with the tip of the scraper. Fine white powder slowly flakes off as he moves. The dominant tones of the painting are warm brown, off-white, and vintage blue, creating a soft, retro aesthetic and a tranquil, focused, and timeless artistic atmosphere.", + "seed": 13578, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_3/index_9871_seed_13578_dp_7_rank_14_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.029878568556159734, + "vlm_logprob": -0.029878568556159734, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.1, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.029878568556159734, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up focusing on an elderly craftsman with graying hair combed back and deep wrinkles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the craftsman wearing a faded indigo cotton work shirt and a brown leather apron stained with white dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a dusty marble bust of a classical woman fixed to the workbench in front of the craftsman?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the craftsman using a delicate scraper to remove old filling from a tiny crack in the statue's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a beam of warm afternoon sunlight streaming from a high window, illuminating dust particles and the statue's surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005454656668007374 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.3804545402526855 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005454656668007374, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005454656668007374, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4290331304073334, + 0.08568412810564041, + 0.06285430490970612, + 0.08674982935190201, + 0.07558508962392807, + 0.032962433993816376, + 0.027373677119612694, + 0.09420458227396011, + 0.04797111824154854, + 0.057581689208745956 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005454656668007374 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up focusing on an elderly craftsman with graying hair combed back and deep wrinkles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the craftsman wearing a faded indigo cotton work shirt and a brown leather apron stained with white dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a dusty marble bust of a classical woman fixed to the workbench in front of the craftsman?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the craftsman using a delicate scraper to remove old filling from a tiny crack in the statue's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a beam of warm afternoon sunlight streaming from a high window, illuminating dust particles and the statue's surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007641016039997339 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882640838623047 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007641016039997339, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007641016039997339, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.28385499119758606, + 0.11778070777654648, + 0.10158225148916245, + 0.060957204550504684, + 0.08941221982240677, + 0.06269190460443497, + 0.05298374220728874, + 0.07852651923894882, + 0.07975106686353683, + 0.072459377348423 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007641016039997339 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up focusing on an elderly craftsman with graying hair combed back and deep wrinkles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the craftsman wearing a faded indigo cotton work shirt and a brown leather apron stained with white dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a dusty marble bust of a classical woman fixed to the workbench in front of the craftsman?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the craftsman using a delicate scraper to remove old filling from a tiny crack in the statue's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a beam of warm afternoon sunlight streaming from a high window, illuminating dust particles and the statue's surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008639931678771973 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758639812469482 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008639931678771973, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008639931678771973, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2616015374660492, + 0.10132274031639099, + 0.10170167684555054, + 0.2058643251657486, + 0.06817925721406937, + 0.08491311222314835, + 0.04819778725504875, + 0.04030328243970871, + 0.060081981122493744, + 0.027834301814436913 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008639931678771973 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up focusing on an elderly craftsman with graying hair combed back and deep wrinkles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the craftsman wearing a faded indigo cotton work shirt and a brown leather apron stained with white dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a dusty marble bust of a classical woman fixed to the workbench in front of the craftsman?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the craftsman using a delicate scraper to remove old filling from a tiny crack in the statue's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a beam of warm afternoon sunlight streaming from a high window, illuminating dust particles and the statue's surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0789908766746521 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.578990936279297 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0789908766746521, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0789908766746521, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3557468056678772, + 0.08265776187181473, + 0.04391968622803688, + 0.0987854152917862, + 0.08056255429983139, + 0.10071545094251633, + 0.03857486695051193, + 0.04706159606575966, + 0.07124124467372894, + 0.08073459565639496 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0789908766746521 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up focusing on an elderly craftsman with graying hair combed back and deep wrinkles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the craftsman wearing a faded indigo cotton work shirt and a brown leather apron stained with white dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a dusty marble bust of a classical woman fixed to the workbench in front of the craftsman?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the craftsman using a delicate scraper to remove old filling from a tiny crack in the statue's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a beam of warm afternoon sunlight streaming from a high window, illuminating dust particles and the statue's surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04866636171936989 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048666477203369 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04866636171936989, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04866636171936989, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16581040620803833, + 0.19750761985778809, + 0.0550997219979763, + 0.09169801324605942, + 0.2261616438627243, + 0.03893380984663963, + 0.058582764118909836, + 0.0979449525475502, + 0.03376861661672592, + 0.03449247032403946 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04866636171936989 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow, horizontal, medium close-up shot focuses on an elderly craftsman sitting in a dimly lit, yet orderly, restoration studio. His graying hair is meticulously combed back, his face deeply wrinkled. A pair of old-fashioned round magnifying glasses rest on his nose, his gaze focused and serene. He wears a faded indigo cotton work shirt and a brown leather apron stained with white dust and the marks of time. Before him, fixed to his workbench, is a dusty marble bust of a classical woman. The statue's face is elegant and peaceful, but a tiny crack mars its integrity. A beam of warm afternoon sunlight, streaming from a high window to the side, penetrates the fine dust particles floating in the air, forming distinct beams (a Tyndall effect), softly illuminating the craftsman's profile and the marble surface, revealing its veins and flaws. The craftsman holds the statue's shoulder steadily with one hand, while the other carefully grips a delicate scraper. With a near-meditative focus, he gently scrapes away the old, solidified filling from the cracks with the tip of the scraper. Fine white powder slowly flakes off as he moves. The dominant tones of the painting are warm brown, off-white, and vintage blue, creating a soft, retro aesthetic and a tranquil, focused, and timeless artistic atmosphere.", + "seed": 13579, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_3/index_9871_seed_13579_dp_7_rank_14_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.03313788827508688, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03313788827508688, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.05, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03313788827508688, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up focusing on an elderly craftsman with graying hair combed back and deep wrinkles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the craftsman wearing a faded indigo cotton work shirt and a brown leather apron stained with white dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a dusty marble bust of a classical woman fixed to the workbench in front of the craftsman?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the craftsman using a delicate scraper to remove old filling from a tiny crack in the statue's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a beam of warm afternoon sunlight streaming from a high window, illuminating dust particles and the statue's surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0053344289772212505 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.630334377288818 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0053344289772212505, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0053344289772212505, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2551042139530182, + 0.12100096791982651, + 0.09257453680038452, + 0.042560651898384094, + 0.04684566706418991, + 0.056133296340703964, + 0.10675797611474991, + 0.051929306238889694, + 0.09593693912029266, + 0.13115647435188293 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0053344289772212505 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up focusing on an elderly craftsman with graying hair combed back and deep wrinkles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the craftsman wearing a faded indigo cotton work shirt and a brown leather apron stained with white dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a dusty marble bust of a classical woman fixed to the workbench in front of the craftsman?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the craftsman using a delicate scraper to remove old filling from a tiny crack in the statue's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a beam of warm afternoon sunlight streaming from a high window, illuminating dust particles and the statue's surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006751937326043844 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006752014160156 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006751937326043844, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006751937326043844, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23978912830352783, + 0.12237196415662766, + 0.07515512406826019, + 0.03171619400382042, + 0.049098677933216095, + 0.03973010554909706, + 0.07508400082588196, + 0.053840406239032745, + 0.2184310406446457, + 0.09478339552879333 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006751937326043844 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up focusing on an elderly craftsman with graying hair combed back and deep wrinkles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the craftsman wearing a faded indigo cotton work shirt and a brown leather apron stained with white dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a dusty marble bust of a classical woman fixed to the workbench in front of the craftsman?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the craftsman using a delicate scraper to remove old filling from a tiny crack in the statue's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a beam of warm afternoon sunlight streaming from a high window, illuminating dust particles and the statue's surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012540886178612709 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387540817260742 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012540886178612709, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012540886178612709, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.29159095883369446, + 0.10331641882658005, + 0.06401485204696655, + 0.14171209931373596, + 0.043320491909980774, + 0.13417531549930573, + 0.03837068751454353, + 0.05594955012202263, + 0.051303841173648834, + 0.07624578475952148 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012540886178612709 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up focusing on an elderly craftsman with graying hair combed back and deep wrinkles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the craftsman wearing a faded indigo cotton work shirt and a brown leather apron stained with white dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a dusty marble bust of a classical woman fixed to the workbench in front of the craftsman?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the craftsman using a delicate scraper to remove old filling from a tiny crack in the statue's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a beam of warm afternoon sunlight streaming from a high window, illuminating dust particles and the statue's surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06206173077225685 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120617866516113 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06206173077225685, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06206173077225685, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2655738592147827, + 0.06514953821897507, + 0.043518342077732086, + 0.032337941229343414, + 0.09571023285388947, + 0.04059688001871109, + 0.10292515903711319, + 0.07114933431148529, + 0.1411396861076355, + 0.141898974776268 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06206173077225685 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up focusing on an elderly craftsman with graying hair combed back and deep wrinkles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the craftsman wearing a faded indigo cotton work shirt and a brown leather apron stained with white dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a dusty marble bust of a classical woman fixed to the workbench in front of the craftsman?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the craftsman using a delicate scraper to remove old filling from a tiny crack in the statue's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a beam of warm afternoon sunlight streaming from a high window, illuminating dust particles and the statue's surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07900045812129974 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.579000473022461 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07900045812129974, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07900045812129974, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2621799409389496, + 0.1740550994873047, + 0.03669213503599167, + 0.0279668178409338, + 0.07314318418502808, + 0.04660977050662041, + 0.0945577397942543, + 0.13329681754112244, + 0.06682464480400085, + 0.08467387408018112 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07900045812129974 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_4/index_tensor([5565, 5565])_group_4_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_4/index_tensor([5565, 5565])_group_4_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..31a586f5afb56d786e97f41a334b7e67a0cba8e5 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_4/index_tensor([5565, 5565])_group_4_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "This stunning, cinematic macro shot begins in extreme close-up, depicting the intricate, sun-bleached pattern of a shell necklace against the warm, sun-kissed skin of a teenage Pacific Islander girl's collarbone. Each small, off-white shell, varying in shape and texture, is strung together to create a striking, matte-like effect of natural imperfections. As she confidently and steadily walks along a city sidewalk, the camera slowly and steadily pans left, maintaining a shallow depth of field. This deliberate movement gradually reveals her profile, then her full face, defined by high cheekbones and a resolute expression; her dark, focused eyes gaze straight ahead, her jaw quietly firm. Her long, wavy black hair, streaked with sun-lit strands, lifts slightly in the city breeze, framing her face. She wears a simple coral cotton tank top, providing a vibrant pop of color. The background fades into a vibrant, out-of-focus bokeh of bustling city life—the blurred figures of pedestrians, the blurred glow of storefronts, and the fleeting flashes of passing cars in the bright afternoon sun. This warm light casts a golden glow on her skin and creates a soft rim light around her hair, enhancing the rich, cinematic quality of the scene and creating a powerful, focused atmosphere amidst the chaos of the city.", + "seed": 30180, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_4/index_5565_seed_30180_dp_8_rank_16_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.022748250979930162, + "vlm_logprob": -0.022748250979930162, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.124999952316284, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.022748250979930162, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a teenage Pacific Islander girl with high cheekbones and a resolute expression?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the girl wearing a simple coral cotton tank top?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the girl wearing a shell necklace with small, off-white shells strung against her collarbone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan left while maintaining a shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vibrant, out-of-focus bokeh of a city sidewalk with blurred pedestrians and storefronts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.034608691930770874 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4096086025238037 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.034608691930770874, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.034608691930770874, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1260402947664261, + 0.08635371923446655, + 0.017707541584968567, + 0.0639224573969841, + 0.035546571016311646, + 0.16581997275352478, + 0.11674686521291733, + 0.15598326921463013, + 0.06725531816482544, + 0.16462399065494537 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.034608691930770874 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a teenage Pacific Islander girl with high cheekbones and a resolute expression?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the girl wearing a simple coral cotton tank top?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the girl wearing a shell necklace with small, off-white shells strung against her collarbone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan left while maintaining a shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vibrant, out-of-focus bokeh of a city sidewalk with blurred pedestrians and storefronts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04868203029036522 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486819744110107 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04868203029036522, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04868203029036522, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.39426320791244507, + 0.12977765500545502, + 0.027300961315631866, + 0.09796010702848434, + 0.05898583307862282, + 0.13822990655899048, + 0.04566157981753349, + 0.03150198236107826, + 0.03553516045212746, + 0.040783610194921494 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04868203029036522 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a teenage Pacific Islander girl with high cheekbones and a resolute expression?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the girl wearing a simple coral cotton tank top?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the girl wearing a shell necklace with small, off-white shells strung against her collarbone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan left while maintaining a shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vibrant, out-of-focus bokeh of a city sidewalk with blurred pedestrians and storefronts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004642066545784473 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379642009735107 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004642066545784473, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004642066545784473, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2687505781650543, + 0.2646063268184662, + 0.05158819258213043, + 0.09729839116334915, + 0.022988336160779, + 0.09380800276994705, + 0.05697445943951607, + 0.05518484115600586, + 0.03482290357351303, + 0.053977951407432556 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004642066545784473 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a teenage Pacific Islander girl with high cheekbones and a resolute expression?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the girl wearing a simple coral cotton tank top?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the girl wearing a shell necklace with small, off-white shells strung against her collarbone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan left while maintaining a shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vibrant, out-of-focus bokeh of a city sidewalk with blurred pedestrians and storefronts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018185313791036606 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018185138702393 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018185313791036606, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018185313791036606, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.33381202816963196, + 0.05049232020974159, + 0.04790396988391876, + 0.07067488878965378, + 0.04961394891142845, + 0.09541083127260208, + 0.14263194799423218, + 0.07520924508571625, + 0.10719417780637741, + 0.02705659531056881 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018185313791036606 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a teenage Pacific Islander girl with high cheekbones and a resolute expression?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the girl wearing a simple coral cotton tank top?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the girl wearing a shell necklace with small, off-white shells strung against her collarbone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan left while maintaining a shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vibrant, out-of-focus bokeh of a city sidewalk with blurred pedestrians and storefronts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00762315234169364 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882623195648193 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00762315234169364, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00762315234169364, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.32091057300567627, + 0.04121924191713333, + 0.02219611033797264, + 0.029164137318730354, + 0.021340787410736084, + 0.13036894798278809, + 0.21425499022006989, + 0.06881348043680191, + 0.07530251145362854, + 0.07642928510904312 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00762315234169364 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "This stunning, cinematic macro shot begins in extreme close-up, depicting the intricate, sun-bleached pattern of a shell necklace against the warm, sun-kissed skin of a teenage Pacific Islander girl's collarbone. Each small, off-white shell, varying in shape and texture, is strung together to create a striking, matte-like effect of natural imperfections. As she confidently and steadily walks along a city sidewalk, the camera slowly and steadily pans left, maintaining a shallow depth of field. This deliberate movement gradually reveals her profile, then her full face, defined by high cheekbones and a resolute expression; her dark, focused eyes gaze straight ahead, her jaw quietly firm. Her long, wavy black hair, streaked with sun-lit strands, lifts slightly in the city breeze, framing her face. She wears a simple coral cotton tank top, providing a vibrant pop of color. The background fades into a vibrant, out-of-focus bokeh of bustling city life—the blurred figures of pedestrians, the blurred glow of storefronts, and the fleeting flashes of passing cars in the bright afternoon sun. This warm light casts a golden glow on her skin and creates a soft rim light around her hair, enhancing the rich, cinematic quality of the scene and creating a powerful, focused atmosphere amidst the chaos of the city.", + "seed": 30181, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_4/index_5565_seed_30181_dp_8_rank_16_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.0423747624270618, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0423747624270618, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.825, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0423747624270618, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a teenage Pacific Islander girl with high cheekbones and a resolute expression?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the girl wearing a simple coral cotton tank top?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the girl wearing a shell necklace with small, off-white shells strung against her collarbone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan left while maintaining a shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vibrant, out-of-focus bokeh of a city sidewalk with blurred pedestrians and storefronts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11342436820268631 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.238424301147461 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11342436820268631, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11342436820268631, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17575979232788086, + 0.021225351840257645, + 0.06356178224086761, + 0.05673859640955925, + 0.24731042981147766, + 0.043511781841516495, + 0.05046283081173897, + 0.07929342240095139, + 0.18125620484352112, + 0.08087977021932602 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11342436820268631 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a teenage Pacific Islander girl with high cheekbones and a resolute expression?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the girl wearing a simple coral cotton tank top?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the girl wearing a shell necklace with small, off-white shells strung against her collarbone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan left while maintaining a shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vibrant, out-of-focus bokeh of a city sidewalk with blurred pedestrians and storefronts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02635873481631279 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513588428497314 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02635873481631279, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02635873481631279, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24903424084186554, + 0.03564208000898361, + 0.19035528600215912, + 0.17203395068645477, + 0.11038268357515335, + 0.06107911467552185, + 0.07207085937261581, + 0.042226869612932205, + 0.03344189375638962, + 0.03373302146792412 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02635873481631279 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a teenage Pacific Islander girl with high cheekbones and a resolute expression?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the girl wearing a simple coral cotton tank top?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the girl wearing a shell necklace with small, off-white shells strung against her collarbone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan left while maintaining a shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vibrant, out-of-focus bokeh of a city sidewalk with blurred pedestrians and storefronts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004100131336599588 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504100322723389 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004100131336599588, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004100131336599588, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3107175827026367, + 0.06805671751499176, + 0.1967504620552063, + 0.05741998925805092, + 0.12336878478527069, + 0.044651348143815994, + 0.0674397274851799, + 0.04030384495854378, + 0.05437123402953148, + 0.036920372396707535 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004100131336599588 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a teenage Pacific Islander girl with high cheekbones and a resolute expression?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the girl wearing a simple coral cotton tank top?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the girl wearing a shell necklace with small, off-white shells strung against her collarbone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan left while maintaining a shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vibrant, out-of-focus bokeh of a city sidewalk with blurred pedestrians and storefronts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06204425171017647 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812044143676758 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06204425171017647, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06204425171017647, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04055570438504219, + 0.02349851280450821, + 0.16591520607471466, + 0.09599728882312775, + 0.346428781747818, + 0.06060047075152397, + 0.16209283471107483, + 0.02249891683459282, + 0.06127427890896797, + 0.021138012409210205 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 2, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06204425171017647 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a teenage Pacific Islander girl with high cheekbones and a resolute expression?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the girl wearing a simple coral cotton tank top?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the girl wearing a shell necklace with small, off-white shells strung against her collarbone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan left while maintaining a shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vibrant, out-of-focus bokeh of a city sidewalk with blurred pedestrians and storefronts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005946326069533825 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130946159362793 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005946326069533825, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005946326069533825, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09203795343637466, + 0.019950127229094505, + 0.11129183322191238, + 0.07849086076021194, + 0.13882598280906677, + 0.01981617510318756, + 0.043312810361385345, + 0.15942417085170746, + 0.3089905381202698, + 0.027859561145305634 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005946326069533825 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "This stunning, cinematic macro shot begins in extreme close-up, depicting the intricate, sun-bleached pattern of a shell necklace against the warm, sun-kissed skin of a teenage Pacific Islander girl's collarbone. Each small, off-white shell, varying in shape and texture, is strung together to create a striking, matte-like effect of natural imperfections. As she confidently and steadily walks along a city sidewalk, the camera slowly and steadily pans left, maintaining a shallow depth of field. This deliberate movement gradually reveals her profile, then her full face, defined by high cheekbones and a resolute expression; her dark, focused eyes gaze straight ahead, her jaw quietly firm. Her long, wavy black hair, streaked with sun-lit strands, lifts slightly in the city breeze, framing her face. She wears a simple coral cotton tank top, providing a vibrant pop of color. The background fades into a vibrant, out-of-focus bokeh of bustling city life—the blurred figures of pedestrians, the blurred glow of storefronts, and the fleeting flashes of passing cars in the bright afternoon sun. This warm light casts a golden glow on her skin and creates a soft rim light around her hair, enhancing the rich, cinematic quality of the scene and creating a powerful, focused atmosphere amidst the chaos of the city.", + "seed": 30182, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_4/index_5565_seed_30182_dp_9_rank_18_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.026017075497657062, + "vlm_logprob": -0.026017075497657062, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.875, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.026017075497657062, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a teenage Pacific Islander girl with high cheekbones and a resolute expression?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the girl wearing a simple coral cotton tank top?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the girl wearing a shell necklace with small, off-white shells strung against her collarbone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan left while maintaining a shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vibrant, out-of-focus bokeh of a city sidewalk with blurred pedestrians and storefronts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03029019758105278 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.530290126800537 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03029019758105278, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03029019758105278, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13508804142475128, + 0.06355040520429611, + 0.07080013304948807, + 0.4050285220146179, + 0.044547189027071, + 0.036683518439531326, + 0.06667481362819672, + 0.05783693492412567, + 0.035928916186094284, + 0.08386148512363434 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03029019758105278 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a teenage Pacific Islander girl with high cheekbones and a resolute expression?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the girl wearing a simple coral cotton tank top?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the girl wearing a shell necklace with small, off-white shells strung against her collarbone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan left while maintaining a shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vibrant, out-of-focus bokeh of a city sidewalk with blurred pedestrians and storefronts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.048674989491701126 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048675060272217 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.048674989491701126, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.048674989491701126, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2750075161457062, + 0.016124969348311424, + 0.024287940934300423, + 0.5901090502738953, + 0.011235418729484081, + 0.013160284608602524, + 0.05003370717167854, + 0.007020683027803898, + 0.004739637486636639, + 0.0082808006554842 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.048674989491701126 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a teenage Pacific Islander girl with high cheekbones and a resolute expression?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the girl wearing a simple coral cotton tank top?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the girl wearing a shell necklace with small, off-white shells strung against her collarbone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan left while maintaining a shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vibrant, out-of-focus bokeh of a city sidewalk with blurred pedestrians and storefronts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005258894059807062 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255259037017822 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005258894059807062, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005258894059807062, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16277338564395905, + 0.06106794252991676, + 0.0910872370004654, + 0.549160897731781, + 0.024671034887433052, + 0.020731190219521523, + 0.024742450565099716, + 0.02043980360031128, + 0.012829509563744068, + 0.03249659761786461 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005258894059807062 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a teenage Pacific Islander girl with high cheekbones and a resolute expression?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the girl wearing a simple coral cotton tank top?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the girl wearing a shell necklace with small, off-white shells strung against her collarbone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan left while maintaining a shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vibrant, out-of-focus bokeh of a city sidewalk with blurred pedestrians and storefronts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02979809045791626 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5297980308532715 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02979809045791626, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02979809045791626, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2851855158805847, + 0.11594208329916, + 0.12371540814638138, + 0.21178267896175385, + 0.04340848699212074, + 0.033145371824502945, + 0.12140718847513199, + 0.019123047590255737, + 0.02731270156800747, + 0.018977509811520576 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02979809045791626 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a teenage Pacific Islander girl with high cheekbones and a resolute expression?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the girl wearing a simple coral cotton tank top?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the girl wearing a shell necklace with small, off-white shells strung against her collarbone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan left while maintaining a shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vibrant, out-of-focus bokeh of a city sidewalk with blurred pedestrians and storefronts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016063205897808075 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141063213348389 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016063205897808075, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016063205897808075, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13596902787685394, + 0.027748635038733482, + 0.03391106799244881, + 0.30140069127082825, + 0.04951654002070427, + 0.08609112352132797, + 0.06898047029972076, + 0.13713885843753815, + 0.10216522961854935, + 0.057078372687101364 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016063205897808075 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "This stunning, cinematic macro shot begins in extreme close-up, depicting the intricate, sun-bleached pattern of a shell necklace against the warm, sun-kissed skin of a teenage Pacific Islander girl's collarbone. Each small, off-white shell, varying in shape and texture, is strung together to create a striking, matte-like effect of natural imperfections. As she confidently and steadily walks along a city sidewalk, the camera slowly and steadily pans left, maintaining a shallow depth of field. This deliberate movement gradually reveals her profile, then her full face, defined by high cheekbones and a resolute expression; her dark, focused eyes gaze straight ahead, her jaw quietly firm. Her long, wavy black hair, streaked with sun-lit strands, lifts slightly in the city breeze, framing her face. She wears a simple coral cotton tank top, providing a vibrant pop of color. The background fades into a vibrant, out-of-focus bokeh of bustling city life—the blurred figures of pedestrians, the blurred glow of storefronts, and the fleeting flashes of passing cars in the bright afternoon sun. This warm light casts a golden glow on her skin and creates a soft rim light around her hair, enhancing the rich, cinematic quality of the scene and creating a powerful, focused atmosphere amidst the chaos of the city.", + "seed": 30183, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_4/index_5565_seed_30183_dp_9_rank_18_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.01945788338780403, + "vlm_logprob": -0.01945788338780403, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.2, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.01945788338780403, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a teenage Pacific Islander girl with high cheekbones and a resolute expression?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the girl wearing a simple coral cotton tank top?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the girl wearing a shell necklace with small, off-white shells strung against her collarbone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan left while maintaining a shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vibrant, out-of-focus bokeh of a city sidewalk with blurred pedestrians and storefronts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03419693186879158 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4091968536376953 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03419693186879158, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03419693186879158, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11398614943027496, + 0.09429163485765457, + 0.06396891176700592, + 0.0674486756324768, + 0.11149917542934418, + 0.06741215288639069, + 0.152839794754982, + 0.08599703758955002, + 0.08866722881793976, + 0.15388920903205872 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03419693186879158 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a teenage Pacific Islander girl with high cheekbones and a resolute expression?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the girl wearing a simple coral cotton tank top?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the girl wearing a shell necklace with small, off-white shells strung against her collarbone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan left while maintaining a shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vibrant, out-of-focus bokeh of a city sidewalk with blurred pedestrians and storefronts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011097141541540623 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511096954345703 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011097141541540623, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011097141541540623, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12403161078691483, + 0.07402761280536652, + 0.16168475151062012, + 0.06922449916601181, + 0.05666935816407204, + 0.12201892584562302, + 0.08872096985578537, + 0.10466530919075012, + 0.04279361665248871, + 0.1561633050441742 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011097141541540623 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a teenage Pacific Islander girl with high cheekbones and a resolute expression?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the girl wearing a simple coral cotton tank top?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the girl wearing a shell necklace with small, off-white shells strung against her collarbone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan left while maintaining a shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vibrant, out-of-focus bokeh of a city sidewalk with blurred pedestrians and storefronts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014205877669155598 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.2642059326171875 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014205877669155598, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014205877669155598, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24313984811306, + 0.150862917304039, + 0.06314777582883835, + 0.03936488926410675, + 0.08783406764268875, + 0.08459004014730453, + 0.06674425303936005, + 0.08563604205846786, + 0.09081004559993744, + 0.0878700464963913 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014205877669155598 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a teenage Pacific Islander girl with high cheekbones and a resolute expression?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the girl wearing a simple coral cotton tank top?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the girl wearing a shell necklace with small, off-white shells strung against her collarbone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan left while maintaining a shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vibrant, out-of-focus bokeh of a city sidewalk with blurred pedestrians and storefronts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03369740769267082 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4086973667144775 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03369740769267082, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03369740769267082, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08945811539888382, + 0.12505371868610382, + 0.0539773665368557, + 0.08048509806394577, + 0.09329778701066971, + 0.023802708834409714, + 0.11187673360109329, + 0.12450505793094635, + 0.26555126905441284, + 0.03199213370680809 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03369740769267082 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a teenage Pacific Islander girl with high cheekbones and a resolute expression?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the girl wearing a simple coral cotton tank top?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the girl wearing a shell necklace with small, off-white shells strung against her collarbone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan left while maintaining a shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vibrant, out-of-focus bokeh of a city sidewalk with blurred pedestrians and storefronts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004092058166861534 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504092216491699 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004092058166861534, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004092058166861534, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1368941366672516, + 0.31377217173576355, + 0.07698195427656174, + 0.16211344301700592, + 0.08698705583810806, + 0.018571076914668083, + 0.05971943587064743, + 0.06202492117881775, + 0.0442039854824543, + 0.03873184323310852 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004092058166861534 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_5/index_tensor([435, 435])_group_5_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_5/index_tensor([435, 435])_group_5_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..a6f62946f9e7852b17af7981b95cbb8fe7ccfb18 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_5/index_tensor([435, 435])_group_5_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "static close-up captures a confident teenage African-American woman of average build, her black hair slicked back, wet and clinging to her scalp, droplets of water tracking along her strong jawline. She sits in an indoor swimming pool, treading water so vigorously that her shoulders and head remain elevated and steady above the shimmering surface, a testament to her athleticism, allowing small, concentric ripples to spread around her. In her right hand, she expertly holds a bright yellow, textured water ball, her fingers gripping its dimpled surface. The entire scene is bathed in the intense, warm golden glow of the overhead natatorium lights, which shimmer on her skin and create brilliant highlights on the disturbed water. She makes a slight, deliberate motion to lift the ball, a subtle but controlled movement, her head tilted steadily, her focused eyes scanning the length of the pool with strategic intent. The interplay of the warm light, the deep blue water, and her determined expression creates a dynamic, high-contrast visual that encapsulates the atmosphere of peak athletic focus and poised power.", + "seed": 18080, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_5/index_435_seed_18080_dp_10_rank_20_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.043476952612400054, + "vlm_logprob": -0.043476952612400054, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.375, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.043476952612400054, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a confident teenage African-American woman with black hair slicked back and wet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman sitting in an indoor swimming pool and treading water vigorously?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman holding a bright yellow, textured water ball in her right hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature intense warm golden overhead lighting creating highlights on the water and skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman make a slight, deliberate motion to lift the water ball while her head remains tilted steadily?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07192518562078476 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.696925163269043 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07192518562078476, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07192518562078476, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16004663705825806, + 0.04206100106239319, + 0.036203715950250626, + 0.049700211733579636, + 0.039920296519994736, + 0.11465311050415039, + 0.2522403299808502, + 0.1333942413330078, + 0.05680523067712784, + 0.11497518420219421 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07192518562078476 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a confident teenage African-American woman with black hair slicked back and wet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman sitting in an indoor swimming pool and treading water vigorously?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman holding a bright yellow, textured water ball in her right hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature intense warm golden overhead lighting creating highlights on the water and skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman make a slight, deliberate motion to lift the water ball while her head remains tilted steadily?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.048684414476156235 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486843585968018 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.048684414476156235, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.048684414476156235, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05425058677792549, + 0.03237065672874451, + 0.015867402777075768, + 0.01985201984643936, + 0.02263517491519451, + 0.052292339503765106, + 0.6658363342285156, + 0.025647873058915138, + 0.022358734160661697, + 0.08888889104127884 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.048684414476156235 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a confident teenage African-American woman with black hair slicked back and wet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman sitting in an indoor swimming pool and treading water vigorously?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman holding a bright yellow, textured water ball in her right hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature intense warm golden overhead lighting creating highlights on the water and skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman make a slight, deliberate motion to lift the water ball while her head remains tilted steadily?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014212341979146004 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264212131500244 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014212341979146004, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014212341979146004, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06391577422618866, + 0.05770525336265564, + 0.08559656143188477, + 0.08463992923498154, + 0.03884902223944664, + 0.03386034443974495, + 0.5482696294784546, + 0.035296663641929626, + 0.030997389927506447, + 0.02086942084133625 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014212341979146004 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a confident teenage African-American woman with black hair slicked back and wet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman sitting in an indoor swimming pool and treading water vigorously?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman holding a bright yellow, textured water ball in her right hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature intense warm golden overhead lighting creating highlights on the water and skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman make a slight, deliberate motion to lift the water ball while her head remains tilted steadily?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012545006349682808 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387545108795166 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012545006349682808, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012545006349682808, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.27013662457466125, + 0.04109558090567589, + 0.03138216957449913, + 0.0385684110224247, + 0.022001875564455986, + 0.03618396818637848, + 0.37745118141174316, + 0.03511585667729378, + 0.04989694803953171, + 0.09816734492778778 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012545006349682808 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a confident teenage African-American woman with black hair slicked back and wet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman sitting in an indoor swimming pool and treading water vigorously?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman holding a bright yellow, textured water ball in her right hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature intense warm golden overhead lighting creating highlights on the water and skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman make a slight, deliberate motion to lift the water ball while her head remains tilted steadily?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07001781463623047 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950178146362305 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07001781463623047, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07001781463623047, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08238876610994339, + 0.05391538143157959, + 0.052363503724336624, + 0.06035858392715454, + 0.025318367406725883, + 0.04164532944560051, + 0.3927011489868164, + 0.045339763164520264, + 0.0852213203907013, + 0.16074784100055695 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07001781463623047 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static close-up captures a confident teenage African-American woman of average build, her black hair slicked back, wet and clinging to her scalp, droplets of water tracking along her strong jawline. She sits in an indoor swimming pool, treading water so vigorously that her shoulders and head remain elevated and steady above the shimmering surface, a testament to her athleticism, allowing small, concentric ripples to spread around her. In her right hand, she expertly holds a bright yellow, textured water ball, her fingers gripping its dimpled surface. The entire scene is bathed in the intense, warm golden glow of the overhead natatorium lights, which shimmer on her skin and create brilliant highlights on the disturbed water. She makes a slight, deliberate motion to lift the ball, a subtle but controlled movement, her head tilted steadily, her focused eyes scanning the length of the pool with strategic intent. The interplay of the warm light, the deep blue water, and her determined expression creates a dynamic, high-contrast visual that encapsulates the atmosphere of peak athletic focus and poised power.", + "seed": 18081, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_5/index_435_seed_18081_dp_10_rank_20_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.07404264863580465, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07404264863580465, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.1, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07404264863580465, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a confident teenage African-American woman with black hair slicked back and wet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman sitting in an indoor swimming pool and treading water vigorously?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman holding a bright yellow, textured water ball in her right hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature intense warm golden overhead lighting creating highlights on the water and skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman make a slight, deliberate motion to lift the water ball while her head remains tilted steadily?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03902682662010193 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2890267372131348 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03902682662010193, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03902682662010193, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23424291610717773, + 0.061620473861694336, + 0.1844976246356964, + 0.08932919800281525, + 0.08932142704725266, + 0.06371496617794037, + 0.07141351699829102, + 0.0851026400923729, + 0.08829952776432037, + 0.032457709312438965 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03902682662010193 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a confident teenage African-American woman with black hair slicked back and wet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman sitting in an indoor swimming pool and treading water vigorously?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman holding a bright yellow, textured water ball in her right hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature intense warm golden overhead lighting creating highlights on the water and skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman make a slight, deliberate motion to lift the water ball while her head remains tilted steadily?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2015998661518097 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7015998363494873 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2015998661518097, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2015998661518097, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3649861514568329, + 0.088456891477108, + 0.058871686458587646, + 0.02088569477200508, + 0.09498759359121323, + 0.05611421540379524, + 0.04436108097434044, + 0.042360518127679825, + 0.20269569754600525, + 0.026280460879206657 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2015998661518097 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a confident teenage African-American woman with black hair slicked back and wet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman sitting in an indoor swimming pool and treading water vigorously?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman holding a bright yellow, textured water ball in her right hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature intense warm golden overhead lighting creating highlights on the water and skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman make a slight, deliberate motion to lift the water ball while her head remains tilted steadily?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018200883641839027 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018200874328613 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018200883641839027, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018200883641839027, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09773164242506027, + 0.11778039485216141, + 0.07697304338216782, + 0.10910788178443909, + 0.3545120060443878, + 0.07322922348976135, + 0.05172214284539223, + 0.03038860112428665, + 0.05681922659277916, + 0.031735777854919434 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018200883641839027 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a confident teenage African-American woman with black hair slicked back and wet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman sitting in an indoor swimming pool and treading water vigorously?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman holding a bright yellow, textured water ball in her right hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature intense warm golden overhead lighting creating highlights on the water and skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman make a slight, deliberate motion to lift the water ball while her head remains tilted steadily?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011083112098276615 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511083126068115 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011083112098276615, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011083112098276615, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.29546916484832764, + 0.06812310218811035, + 0.03586208075284958, + 0.07560373842716217, + 0.11668135225772858, + 0.039131082594394684, + 0.2574394941329956, + 0.01519162580370903, + 0.07130569964647293, + 0.025192705914378166 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011083112098276615 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a confident teenage African-American woman with black hair slicked back and wet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman sitting in an indoor swimming pool and treading water vigorously?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman holding a bright yellow, textured water ball in her right hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature intense warm golden overhead lighting creating highlights on the water and skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman make a slight, deliberate motion to lift the water ball while her head remains tilted steadily?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.100302554666996 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3503024578094482 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.100302554666996, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.100302554666996, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11534739285707474, + 0.11804171651601791, + 0.0492345355451107, + 0.07856220752000809, + 0.133102685213089, + 0.09716949611902237, + 0.1574547439813614, + 0.037995848804712296, + 0.07544919848442078, + 0.13764217495918274 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.100302554666996 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static close-up captures a confident teenage African-American woman of average build, her black hair slicked back, wet and clinging to her scalp, droplets of water tracking along her strong jawline. She sits in an indoor swimming pool, treading water so vigorously that her shoulders and head remain elevated and steady above the shimmering surface, a testament to her athleticism, allowing small, concentric ripples to spread around her. In her right hand, she expertly holds a bright yellow, textured water ball, her fingers gripping its dimpled surface. The entire scene is bathed in the intense, warm golden glow of the overhead natatorium lights, which shimmer on her skin and create brilliant highlights on the disturbed water. She makes a slight, deliberate motion to lift the ball, a subtle but controlled movement, her head tilted steadily, her focused eyes scanning the length of the pool with strategic intent. The interplay of the warm light, the deep blue water, and her determined expression creates a dynamic, high-contrast visual that encapsulates the atmosphere of peak athletic focus and poised power.", + "seed": 18082, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_5/index_435_seed_18082_dp_11_rank_22_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.04858159339055419, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04858159339055419, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.375, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04858159339055419, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a confident teenage African-American woman with black hair slicked back and wet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman sitting in an indoor swimming pool and treading water vigorously?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman holding a bright yellow, textured water ball in her right hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature intense warm golden overhead lighting creating highlights on the water and skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman make a slight, deliberate motion to lift the water ball while her head remains tilted steadily?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08001115918159485 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5800111293792725 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08001115918159485, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08001115918159485, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.26275721192359924, + 0.18066677451133728, + 0.08107893168926239, + 0.07784197479486465, + 0.06569039076566696, + 0.11440425366163254, + 0.06794983148574829, + 0.04464353993535042, + 0.05075327306985855, + 0.05421380326151848 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08001115918159485 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a confident teenage African-American woman with black hair slicked back and wet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman sitting in an indoor swimming pool and treading water vigorously?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman holding a bright yellow, textured water ball in her right hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature intense warm golden overhead lighting creating highlights on the water and skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman make a slight, deliberate motion to lift the water ball while her head remains tilted steadily?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07901180535554886 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.579011917114258 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07901180535554886, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07901180535554886, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23611146211624146, + 0.315548837184906, + 0.05064055696129799, + 0.08002542704343796, + 0.02710961550474167, + 0.03305570036172867, + 0.045675404369831085, + 0.08603398501873016, + 0.06859995424747467, + 0.05719905346632004 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07901180535554886 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a confident teenage African-American woman with black hair slicked back and wet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman sitting in an indoor swimming pool and treading water vigorously?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman holding a bright yellow, textured water ball in her right hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature intense warm golden overhead lighting creating highlights on the water and skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman make a slight, deliberate motion to lift the water ball while her head remains tilted steadily?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007640661206096411 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882640838623047 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007640661206096411, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007640661206096411, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12047028541564941, + 0.4054929316043854, + 0.17181283235549927, + 0.06461308151483536, + 0.01600027084350586, + 0.018874431028962135, + 0.06391850858926773, + 0.013446907512843609, + 0.11625343561172485, + 0.0091173704713583 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007640661206096411 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a confident teenage African-American woman with black hair slicked back and wet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman sitting in an indoor swimming pool and treading water vigorously?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman holding a bright yellow, textured water ball in her right hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature intense warm golden overhead lighting creating highlights on the water and skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman make a slight, deliberate motion to lift the water ball while her head remains tilted steadily?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014201881363987923 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264202117919922 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014201881363987923, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014201881363987923, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10111650824546814, + 0.6439834833145142, + 0.02586575783789158, + 0.08534161001443863, + 0.03649568185210228, + 0.026082579046487808, + 0.014411014504730701, + 0.03656010702252388, + 0.015479717403650284, + 0.014663608744740486 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014201881363987923 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a confident teenage African-American woman with black hair slicked back and wet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman sitting in an indoor swimming pool and treading water vigorously?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman holding a bright yellow, textured water ball in her right hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature intense warm golden overhead lighting creating highlights on the water and skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman make a slight, deliberate motion to lift the water ball while her head remains tilted steadily?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06204245984554291 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812042474746704 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06204245984554291, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06204245984554291, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08946674317121506, + 0.2935912311077118, + 0.09632031619548798, + 0.0967242494225502, + 0.056009769439697266, + 0.058672092854976654, + 0.07149525731801987, + 0.05447354540228844, + 0.08629502356052399, + 0.09695179015398026 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06204245984554291 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static close-up captures a confident teenage African-American woman of average build, her black hair slicked back, wet and clinging to her scalp, droplets of water tracking along her strong jawline. She sits in an indoor swimming pool, treading water so vigorously that her shoulders and head remain elevated and steady above the shimmering surface, a testament to her athleticism, allowing small, concentric ripples to spread around her. In her right hand, she expertly holds a bright yellow, textured water ball, her fingers gripping its dimpled surface. The entire scene is bathed in the intense, warm golden glow of the overhead natatorium lights, which shimmer on her skin and create brilliant highlights on the disturbed water. She makes a slight, deliberate motion to lift the ball, a subtle but controlled movement, her head tilted steadily, her focused eyes scanning the length of the pool with strategic intent. The interplay of the warm light, the deep blue water, and her determined expression creates a dynamic, high-contrast visual that encapsulates the atmosphere of peak athletic focus and poised power.", + "seed": 18083, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_5/index_435_seed_18083_dp_11_rank_22_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.037741404958069324, + "vlm_logprob": -0.037741404958069324, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.575, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.037741404958069324, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a confident teenage African-American woman with black hair slicked back and wet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman sitting in an indoor swimming pool and treading water vigorously?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman holding a bright yellow, textured water ball in her right hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature intense warm golden overhead lighting creating highlights on the water and skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman make a slight, deliberate motion to lift the water ball while her head remains tilted steadily?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04398820921778679 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1689882278442383 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04398820921778679, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04398820921778679, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10605712234973907, + 0.047239210456609726, + 0.03558116778731346, + 0.03699587285518646, + 0.48283588886260986, + 0.067600317299366, + 0.03347719460725784, + 0.054651033133268356, + 0.02784477174282074, + 0.10771737992763519 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04398820921778679 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a confident teenage African-American woman with black hair slicked back and wet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman sitting in an indoor swimming pool and treading water vigorously?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman holding a bright yellow, textured water ball in her right hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature intense warm golden overhead lighting creating highlights on the water and skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman make a slight, deliberate motion to lift the water ball while her head remains tilted steadily?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07004260271787643 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695042610168457 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07004260271787643, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07004260271787643, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18692903220653534, + 0.040843505412340164, + 0.01651575416326523, + 0.07151032239198685, + 0.42714571952819824, + 0.09113391488790512, + 0.03743957355618477, + 0.05369863659143448, + 0.025368569418787956, + 0.04941495135426521 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07004260271787643 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a confident teenage African-American woman with black hair slicked back and wet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman sitting in an indoor swimming pool and treading water vigorously?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman holding a bright yellow, textured water ball in her right hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature intense warm golden overhead lighting creating highlights on the water and skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman make a slight, deliberate motion to lift the water ball while her head remains tilted steadily?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008648322895169258 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.75864839553833 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008648322895169258, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008648322895169258, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07391972094774246, + 0.09462697058916092, + 0.03318733721971512, + 0.031172676011919975, + 0.17265653610229492, + 0.03805415704846382, + 0.12653130292892456, + 0.2621636688709259, + 0.08195224404335022, + 0.08573539555072784 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008648322895169258 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a confident teenage African-American woman with black hair slicked back and wet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman sitting in an indoor swimming pool and treading water vigorously?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman holding a bright yellow, textured water ball in her right hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature intense warm golden overhead lighting creating highlights on the water and skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman make a slight, deliberate motion to lift the water ball while her head remains tilted steadily?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011079574935138226 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511079788208008 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011079574935138226, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011079574935138226, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09360406547784805, + 0.057124871760606766, + 0.09371628612279892, + 0.058397628366947174, + 0.5469738841056824, + 0.025481365621089935, + 0.021043486893177032, + 0.04214731603860855, + 0.021861765533685684, + 0.03964933380484581 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011079574935138226 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a confident teenage African-American woman with black hair slicked back and wet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman sitting in an indoor swimming pool and treading water vigorously?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman holding a bright yellow, textured water ball in her right hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature intense warm golden overhead lighting creating highlights on the water and skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman make a slight, deliberate motion to lift the water ball while her head remains tilted steadily?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.054948315024375916 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929948329925537 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.054948315024375916, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.054948315024375916, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17871123552322388, + 0.2104267179965973, + 0.040384937077760696, + 0.08658865839242935, + 0.09635397046804428, + 0.05791088938713074, + 0.09894385188817978, + 0.06303539127111435, + 0.0612916573882103, + 0.10635267198085785 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.054948315024375916 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_6/index_tensor([846, 846])_group_6_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_6/index_tensor([846, 846])_group_6_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..f6070e84adf21f680ef523076c84c203e3ad2184 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_6/index_tensor([846, 846])_group_6_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "powerful low-angle tracking shot follows a heavy steel freight train, its charcoal-black front covered in riveted steel and mottled with rust, as it hurtles forward with unstoppable momentum. The lone round headlight casts a glaring beam through the gathering twilight, illuminating the abandoned, overgrown tracks ahead. The massive steel wheels relentlessly grind against the rusted track, emitting a dull metallic thud, shaking the splintered railroad ties and the surrounding gravel roadbed slightly and violently pushing the overgrown weeds to the sides. The low-slanting sunset casts long, twisting shadows across the barren landscape, gilding the weathered sides of the train with a fleeting warm golden hue. Overhead, dark clouds gather, foreshadowing a storm. The dramatic interplay of light and shadow imbues the entire scene with a heavy, resolute, and desolate atmosphere.", + "seed": 23252, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_6/index_846_seed_23252_dp_12_rank_24_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.33592009246349336, + "vlm_logprob": -0.33592009246349336, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.2, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.33592009246349336, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavy steel freight train with a charcoal-black front covered in riveted steel and rust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the train moving forward with high speed and unstoppable momentum?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a lone round headlight visible casting a glaring beam through the twilight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on abandoned, overgrown tracks with splintered railroad ties and gravel roadbed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low angle with a low-slanting sunset casting long, twisting shadows and a warm golden hue on the train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.161387100815773 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9113870859146118 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.161387100815773, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.161387100815773, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06432551145553589, + 0.04129509627819061, + 0.11142758280038834, + 0.08253300935029984, + 0.07280618697404861, + 0.03644399717450142, + 0.08463037014007568, + 0.09292379021644592, + 0.10259705036878586, + 0.3110174238681793 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 2, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.161387100815773 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavy steel freight train with a charcoal-black front covered in riveted steel and rust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the train moving forward with high speed and unstoppable momentum?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a lone round headlight visible casting a glaring beam through the twilight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on abandoned, overgrown tracks with splintered railroad ties and gravel roadbed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low angle with a low-slanting sunset casting long, twisting shadows and a warm golden hue on the train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8983187675476074 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5233187675476074 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.8983187675476074, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.8983187675476074, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.147051140666008, + 0.040757130831480026, + 0.06536681950092316, + 0.06808465719223022, + 0.15121354162693024, + 0.05237455293536186, + 0.05798666924238205, + 0.06540244817733765, + 0.07524505257606506, + 0.27651798725128174 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.8983187675476074 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavy steel freight train with a charcoal-black front covered in riveted steel and rust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the train moving forward with high speed and unstoppable momentum?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a lone round headlight visible casting a glaring beam through the twilight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on abandoned, overgrown tracks with splintered railroad ties and gravel roadbed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low angle with a low-slanting sunset casting long, twisting shadows and a warm golden hue on the train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2255866378545761 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6005866527557373 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2255866378545761, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2255866378545761, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18125298619270325, + 0.0707658976316452, + 0.10028522461652756, + 0.12438509613275528, + 0.13720521330833435, + 0.05900946632027626, + 0.05548536032438278, + 0.12025025486946106, + 0.10191801190376282, + 0.04944249615073204 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2255866378545761 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavy steel freight train with a charcoal-black front covered in riveted steel and rust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the train moving forward with high speed and unstoppable momentum?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a lone round headlight visible casting a glaring beam through the twilight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on abandoned, overgrown tracks with splintered railroad ties and gravel roadbed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low angle with a low-slanting sunset casting long, twisting shadows and a warm golden hue on the train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.281357079744339 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4063570499420166 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.281357079744339, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.281357079744339, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10516252368688583, + 0.044397421181201935, + 0.2170250564813614, + 0.12314556539058685, + 0.08042294532060623, + 0.060973141342401505, + 0.10679729282855988, + 0.04891738295555115, + 0.10534512996673584, + 0.10781358927488327 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.281357079744339 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavy steel freight train with a charcoal-black front covered in riveted steel and rust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the train moving forward with high speed and unstoppable momentum?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a lone round headlight visible casting a glaring beam through the twilight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on abandoned, overgrown tracks with splintered railroad ties and gravel roadbed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low angle with a low-slanting sunset casting long, twisting shadows and a warm golden hue on the train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1129508763551712 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2379508018493652 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1129508763551712, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1129508763551712, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22893153131008148, + 0.06931000202894211, + 0.08273717015981674, + 0.07394682615995407, + 0.055553026497364044, + 0.03247331082820892, + 0.026471760123968124, + 0.12293753027915955, + 0.14869768917560577, + 0.1589411199092865 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1129508763551712 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "powerful low-angle tracking shot follows a heavy steel freight train, its charcoal-black front covered in riveted steel and mottled with rust, as it hurtles forward with unstoppable momentum. The lone round headlight casts a glaring beam through the gathering twilight, illuminating the abandoned, overgrown tracks ahead. The massive steel wheels relentlessly grind against the rusted track, emitting a dull metallic thud, shaking the splintered railroad ties and the surrounding gravel roadbed slightly and violently pushing the overgrown weeds to the sides. The low-slanting sunset casts long, twisting shadows across the barren landscape, gilding the weathered sides of the train with a fleeting warm golden hue. Overhead, dark clouds gather, foreshadowing a storm. The dramatic interplay of light and shadow imbues the entire scene with a heavy, resolute, and desolate atmosphere.", + "seed": 23253, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_6/index_846_seed_23253_dp_12_rank_24_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.2757657593116164, + "vlm_logprob": -0.2757657593116164, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.225, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.2757657593116164, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavy steel freight train with a charcoal-black front covered in riveted steel and rust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the train moving forward with high speed and unstoppable momentum?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a lone round headlight visible casting a glaring beam through the twilight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on abandoned, overgrown tracks with splintered railroad ties and gravel roadbed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low angle with a low-slanting sunset casting long, twisting shadows and a warm golden hue on the train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.31374138593673706 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3137414455413818 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.31374138593673706, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.31374138593673706, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09571954607963562, + 0.04338783398270607, + 0.035725031048059464, + 0.031626515090465546, + 0.030897390097379684, + 0.09158235788345337, + 0.06173723191022873, + 0.2203442007303238, + 0.210728257894516, + 0.17825160920619965 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.31374138593673706 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavy steel freight train with a charcoal-black front covered in riveted steel and rust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the train moving forward with high speed and unstoppable momentum?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a lone round headlight visible casting a glaring beam through the twilight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on abandoned, overgrown tracks with splintered railroad ties and gravel roadbed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low angle with a low-slanting sunset casting long, twisting shadows and a warm golden hue on the train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8983350396156311 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5233350396156311 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.8983350396156311, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.8983350396156311, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14500905573368073, + 0.031764235347509384, + 0.017071515321731567, + 0.03799160197377205, + 0.027213234454393387, + 0.17597714066505432, + 0.09618817269802094, + 0.18385684490203857, + 0.10566084831953049, + 0.1792673021554947 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.8983350396156311 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavy steel freight train with a charcoal-black front covered in riveted steel and rust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the train moving forward with high speed and unstoppable momentum?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a lone round headlight visible casting a glaring beam through the twilight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on abandoned, overgrown tracks with splintered railroad ties and gravel roadbed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low angle with a low-slanting sunset casting long, twisting shadows and a warm golden hue on the train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.033726684749126434 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408726692199707 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.033726684749126434, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.033726684749126434, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08159833401441574, + 0.05161299929022789, + 0.10640885680913925, + 0.05853366106748581, + 0.039726827293634415, + 0.16339081525802612, + 0.06924326717853546, + 0.16884969174861908, + 0.1532467007637024, + 0.10738877952098846 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 5, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.033726684749126434 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavy steel freight train with a charcoal-black front covered in riveted steel and rust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the train moving forward with high speed and unstoppable momentum?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a lone round headlight visible casting a glaring beam through the twilight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on abandoned, overgrown tracks with splintered railroad ties and gravel roadbed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low angle with a low-slanting sunset casting long, twisting shadows and a warm golden hue on the train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12707556784152985 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.127075672149658 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12707556784152985, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12707556784152985, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2345130741596222, + 0.03862735256552696, + 0.03685498610138893, + 0.05335526168346405, + 0.036659885197877884, + 0.11948332190513611, + 0.06299446523189545, + 0.08080766350030899, + 0.23398350179195404, + 0.10272053629159927 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12707556784152985 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavy steel freight train with a charcoal-black front covered in riveted steel and rust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the train moving forward with high speed and unstoppable momentum?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a lone round headlight visible casting a glaring beam through the twilight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on abandoned, overgrown tracks with splintered railroad ties and gravel roadbed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low angle with a low-slanting sunset casting long, twisting shadows and a warm golden hue on the train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005950118415057659 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130949974060059 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005950118415057659, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005950118415057659, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13910578191280365, + 0.06783610582351685, + 0.029660619795322418, + 0.05251174792647362, + 0.05382375791668892, + 0.04110700637102127, + 0.057670094072818756, + 0.11427969485521317, + 0.3566611707210541, + 0.0873439833521843 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005950118415057659 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "powerful low-angle tracking shot follows a heavy steel freight train, its charcoal-black front covered in riveted steel and mottled with rust, as it hurtles forward with unstoppable momentum. The lone round headlight casts a glaring beam through the gathering twilight, illuminating the abandoned, overgrown tracks ahead. The massive steel wheels relentlessly grind against the rusted track, emitting a dull metallic thud, shaking the splintered railroad ties and the surrounding gravel roadbed slightly and violently pushing the overgrown weeds to the sides. The low-slanting sunset casts long, twisting shadows across the barren landscape, gilding the weathered sides of the train with a fleeting warm golden hue. Overhead, dark clouds gather, foreshadowing a storm. The dramatic interplay of light and shadow imbues the entire scene with a heavy, resolute, and desolate atmosphere.", + "seed": 23254, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_6/index_846_seed_23254_dp_13_rank_26_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.2385242059826851, + "vlm_logprob": -0.2385242059826851, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.95, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.2385242059826851, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavy steel freight train with a charcoal-black front covered in riveted steel and rust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the train moving forward with high speed and unstoppable momentum?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a lone round headlight visible casting a glaring beam through the twilight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on abandoned, overgrown tracks with splintered railroad ties and gravel roadbed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low angle with a low-slanting sunset casting long, twisting shadows and a warm golden hue on the train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16083043813705444 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9108304977416992 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16083043813705444, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16083043813705444, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13961245119571686, + 0.04314529523253441, + 0.07399670034646988, + 0.06878474354743958, + 0.10850196331739426, + 0.13321846723556519, + 0.2319604456424713, + 0.11219104379415512, + 0.026873620226979256, + 0.0617152564227581 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16083043813705444 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavy steel freight train with a charcoal-black front covered in riveted steel and rust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the train moving forward with high speed and unstoppable momentum?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a lone round headlight visible casting a glaring beam through the twilight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on abandoned, overgrown tracks with splintered railroad ties and gravel roadbed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low angle with a low-slanting sunset casting long, twisting shadows and a warm golden hue on the train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.693347692489624 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.693347692489624 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.693347692489624, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.693347692489624, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1640435755252838, + 0.051911890506744385, + 0.24550209939479828, + 0.10456595569849014, + 0.05884536728262901, + 0.18698853254318237, + 0.0787130817770958, + 0.07715766876935959, + 0.013038602657616138, + 0.01923323981463909 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.693347692489624 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavy steel freight train with a charcoal-black front covered in riveted steel and rust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the train moving forward with high speed and unstoppable momentum?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a lone round headlight visible casting a glaring beam through the twilight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on abandoned, overgrown tracks with splintered railroad ties and gravel roadbed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low angle with a low-slanting sunset casting long, twisting shadows and a warm golden hue on the train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10032045841217041 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.350320339202881 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10032045841217041, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10032045841217041, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13691391050815582, + 0.04585082828998566, + 0.1847483515739441, + 0.06718048453330994, + 0.08164967596530914, + 0.08327118307352066, + 0.22943806648254395, + 0.04100671410560608, + 0.08343987166881561, + 0.04650089517235756 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10032045841217041 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavy steel freight train with a charcoal-black front covered in riveted steel and rust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the train moving forward with high speed and unstoppable momentum?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a lone round headlight visible casting a glaring beam through the twilight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on abandoned, overgrown tracks with splintered railroad ties and gravel roadbed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low angle with a low-slanting sunset casting long, twisting shadows and a warm golden hue on the train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22558379173278809 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.600583791732788 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.22558379173278809, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.22558379173278809, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12666338682174683, + 0.04591147229075432, + 0.05066092312335968, + 0.05293043702840805, + 0.05950913578271866, + 0.20362406969070435, + 0.27287429571151733, + 0.06400547176599503, + 0.08084491640329361, + 0.042975910007953644 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.22558379173278809 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavy steel freight train with a charcoal-black front covered in riveted steel and rust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the train moving forward with high speed and unstoppable momentum?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a lone round headlight visible casting a glaring beam through the twilight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on abandoned, overgrown tracks with splintered railroad ties and gravel roadbed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low angle with a low-slanting sunset casting long, twisting shadows and a warm golden hue on the train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012538649141788483 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387538433074951 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012538649141788483, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012538649141788483, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20593582093715668, + 0.04612362012267113, + 0.07718134671449661, + 0.0511077381670475, + 0.041930802166461945, + 0.0993654802441597, + 0.13589496910572052, + 0.1332324594259262, + 0.17364676296710968, + 0.03558104485273361 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012538649141788483 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "powerful low-angle tracking shot follows a heavy steel freight train, its charcoal-black front covered in riveted steel and mottled with rust, as it hurtles forward with unstoppable momentum. The lone round headlight casts a glaring beam through the gathering twilight, illuminating the abandoned, overgrown tracks ahead. The massive steel wheels relentlessly grind against the rusted track, emitting a dull metallic thud, shaking the splintered railroad ties and the surrounding gravel roadbed slightly and violently pushing the overgrown weeds to the sides. The low-slanting sunset casts long, twisting shadows across the barren landscape, gilding the weathered sides of the train with a fleeting warm golden hue. Overhead, dark clouds gather, foreshadowing a storm. The dramatic interplay of light and shadow imbues the entire scene with a heavy, resolute, and desolate atmosphere.", + "seed": 23255, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_6/index_846_seed_23255_dp_13_rank_26_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.138259488157928, + "vlm_logprob": -0.138259488157928, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.575, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.138259488157928, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavy steel freight train with a charcoal-black front covered in riveted steel and rust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the train moving forward with high speed and unstoppable momentum?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a lone round headlight visible casting a glaring beam through the twilight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on abandoned, overgrown tracks with splintered railroad ties and gravel roadbed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low angle with a low-slanting sunset casting long, twisting shadows and a warm golden hue on the train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01698307693004608 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.1419830322265625 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01698307693004608, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01698307693004608, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12659934163093567, + 0.07590416073799133, + 0.03490287810564041, + 0.0828603133559227, + 0.0890774056315422, + 0.07749096304178238, + 0.165179044008255, + 0.040631771087646484, + 0.1566384881734848, + 0.150715634226799 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01698307693004608 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavy steel freight train with a charcoal-black front covered in riveted steel and rust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the train moving forward with high speed and unstoppable momentum?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a lone round headlight visible casting a glaring beam through the twilight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on abandoned, overgrown tracks with splintered railroad ties and gravel roadbed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low angle with a low-slanting sunset casting long, twisting shadows and a warm golden hue on the train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6327892541885376 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7577892541885376 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.6327892541885376, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.6327892541885376, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21530622243881226, + 0.043168094009160995, + 0.01853765733540058, + 0.15831555426120758, + 0.14462631940841675, + 0.051808539777994156, + 0.06104482710361481, + 0.047813549637794495, + 0.23678649961948395, + 0.022592728957533836 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.6327892541885376 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavy steel freight train with a charcoal-black front covered in riveted steel and rust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the train moving forward with high speed and unstoppable momentum?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a lone round headlight visible casting a glaring beam through the twilight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on abandoned, overgrown tracks with splintered railroad ties and gravel roadbed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low angle with a low-slanting sunset casting long, twisting shadows and a warm golden hue on the train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011084291152656078 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511084079742432 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011084291152656078, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011084291152656078, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.26818332076072693, + 0.034899547696113586, + 0.04203806445002556, + 0.09344901144504547, + 0.17441843450069427, + 0.04967290163040161, + 0.03908100351691246, + 0.03225867822766304, + 0.1600961834192276, + 0.10590288788080215 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011084291152656078 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavy steel freight train with a charcoal-black front covered in riveted steel and rust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the train moving forward with high speed and unstoppable momentum?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a lone round headlight visible casting a glaring beam through the twilight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on abandoned, overgrown tracks with splintered railroad ties and gravel roadbed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low angle with a low-slanting sunset casting long, twisting shadows and a warm golden hue on the train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026348285377025604 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651348352432251 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026348285377025604, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026348285377025604, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15307065844535828, + 0.05372540280222893, + 0.040099065750837326, + 0.10974222421646118, + 0.07446103543043137, + 0.05719432979822159, + 0.12978635728359222, + 0.043844595551490784, + 0.05962802842259407, + 0.27844828367233276 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026348285377025604 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavy steel freight train with a charcoal-black front covered in riveted steel and rust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the train moving forward with high speed and unstoppable momentum?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a lone round headlight visible casting a glaring beam through the twilight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on abandoned, overgrown tracks with splintered railroad ties and gravel roadbed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low angle with a low-slanting sunset casting long, twisting shadows and a warm golden hue on the train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004092533141374588 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504092693328857 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004092533141374588, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004092533141374588, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1661311388015747, + 0.02456086315214634, + 0.021125804632902145, + 0.08409706503152847, + 0.06654903292655945, + 0.018085859715938568, + 0.0376797690987587, + 0.034613270312547684, + 0.4916854202747345, + 0.05547188222408295 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004092533141374588 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_7/index_tensor([9633, 9633])_group_7_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_7/index_tensor([9633, 9633])_group_7_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..b7a2226fa378db652e97f05cb2b65cc14753bcbe --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_7/index_tensor([9633, 9633])_group_7_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "dynamic, sweeping camera shot arcs around a fearsome warrior as he meticulously scales a sheer, treacherous cliff face. Rendered in a detailed, heroic fantasy illustration reminiscent of classic Dungeons & Dragons art, the scene is a study in tension and determination. The warrior, a man of heroic stature, has long, black braids blown by the high-altitude wind. His face is a mask of intense concentration, his jaw set, his eyes fixed on his next handhold. His muscular body is clad in worn dark leather armor and iron-studded pauldrons that have seen many battles. Strapped to his back is a massive, double-headed battle axe, its polished steel edge gleaming in the light, its heavy wooden handle intricately carved with patterns. His gloved hands dig into the jagged, unforgiving rock, his body moving with a steady and deliberate rhythm that demonstrates his immense strength. As the camera continues to sweep, it captures the dramatic interplay of shadow and light cast by the low-angle sun, highlighting the rough texture of the granite and the climber's strained muscles. The camera zooms out slightly to reveal the abyss below, a vertiginous chasm filled with swirling mist that obscures the bottom, creating a powerful and heroic atmosphere of a lonely struggle against an epic, unforgiving landscape.", + "seed": 23391, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_7/index_9633_seed_23391_dp_14_rank_28_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.021663380041718482, + "vlm_logprob": -0.021663380041718482, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.975, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.021663380041718482, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a man wearing worn dark leather armor and iron-studded pauldrons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior scaling a sheer cliff face with his gloved hands digging into jagged rock?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive double-headed battle axe strapped to the warrior's back with a polished steel edge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera arc around the warrior and zoom out to reveal a vertiginous chasm filled with swirling mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a detailed heroic fantasy illustration reminiscent of classic Dungeons & Dragons art?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016874777153134346 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.14187479019165 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016874777153134346, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016874777153134346, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19494715332984924, + 0.16841821372509003, + 0.17674170434474945, + 0.09227260202169418, + 0.03578067943453789, + 0.044468969106674194, + 0.08649542927742004, + 0.08249790966510773, + 0.046158626675605774, + 0.07221878319978714 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016874777153134346 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a man wearing worn dark leather armor and iron-studded pauldrons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior scaling a sheer cliff face with his gloved hands digging into jagged rock?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive double-headed battle axe strapped to the warrior's back with a polished steel edge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera arc around the warrior and zoom out to reveal a vertiginous chasm filled with swirling mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a detailed heroic fantasy illustration reminiscent of classic Dungeons & Dragons art?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016073646023869514 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141073703765869 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016073646023869514, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016073646023869514, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1082984209060669, + 0.054528649896383286, + 0.1950758695602417, + 0.10585059225559235, + 0.08665554225444794, + 0.05837676674127579, + 0.10249246656894684, + 0.1298900544643402, + 0.07893932610750198, + 0.07989227026700974 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016073646023869514 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a man wearing worn dark leather armor and iron-studded pauldrons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior scaling a sheer cliff face with his gloved hands digging into jagged rock?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive double-headed battle axe strapped to the warrior's back with a polished steel edge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera arc around the warrior and zoom out to reveal a vertiginous chasm filled with swirling mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a detailed heroic fantasy illustration reminiscent of classic Dungeons & Dragons art?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04864887520670891 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486488342285156 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04864887520670891, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04864887520670891, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4303094446659088, + 0.09191583096981049, + 0.035556185990571976, + 0.1024126410484314, + 0.029138851910829544, + 0.03560703620314598, + 0.08959800750017166, + 0.044450655579566956, + 0.05391193926334381, + 0.08709938079118729 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04864887520670891 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a man wearing worn dark leather armor and iron-studded pauldrons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior scaling a sheer cliff face with his gloved hands digging into jagged rock?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive double-headed battle axe strapped to the warrior's back with a polished steel edge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera arc around the warrior and zoom out to reveal a vertiginous chasm filled with swirling mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a detailed heroic fantasy illustration reminiscent of classic Dungeons & Dragons art?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01253299880772829 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387533187866211 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01253299880772829, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01253299880772829, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06204060837626457, + 0.06013447418808937, + 0.07483642548322678, + 0.09335709363222122, + 0.12172041833400726, + 0.0891144648194313, + 0.17289115488529205, + 0.11939047276973724, + 0.1652706414461136, + 0.041244301944971085 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01253299880772829 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a man wearing worn dark leather armor and iron-studded pauldrons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior scaling a sheer cliff face with his gloved hands digging into jagged rock?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive double-headed battle axe strapped to the warrior's back with a polished steel edge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera arc around the warrior and zoom out to reveal a vertiginous chasm filled with swirling mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a detailed heroic fantasy illustration reminiscent of classic Dungeons & Dragons art?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014186603017151356 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264186382293701 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014186603017151356, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014186603017151356, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3477287292480469, + 0.05955560505390167, + 0.04098094627261162, + 0.14641234278678894, + 0.06658811867237091, + 0.035330791026353836, + 0.06364067643880844, + 0.1493496149778366, + 0.02893596701323986, + 0.06147725135087967 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014186603017151356 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dynamic, sweeping camera shot arcs around a fearsome warrior as he meticulously scales a sheer, treacherous cliff face. Rendered in a detailed, heroic fantasy illustration reminiscent of classic Dungeons & Dragons art, the scene is a study in tension and determination. The warrior, a man of heroic stature, has long, black braids blown by the high-altitude wind. His face is a mask of intense concentration, his jaw set, his eyes fixed on his next handhold. His muscular body is clad in worn dark leather armor and iron-studded pauldrons that have seen many battles. Strapped to his back is a massive, double-headed battle axe, its polished steel edge gleaming in the light, its heavy wooden handle intricately carved with patterns. His gloved hands dig into the jagged, unforgiving rock, his body moving with a steady and deliberate rhythm that demonstrates his immense strength. As the camera continues to sweep, it captures the dramatic interplay of shadow and light cast by the low-angle sun, highlighting the rough texture of the granite and the climber's strained muscles. The camera zooms out slightly to reveal the abyss below, a vertiginous chasm filled with swirling mist that obscures the bottom, creating a powerful and heroic atmosphere of a lonely struggle against an epic, unforgiving landscape.", + "seed": 23392, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_7/index_9633_seed_23392_dp_14_rank_28_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.025119814649224283, + "vlm_logprob": -0.025119814649224283, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.825, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.025119814649224283, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a man wearing worn dark leather armor and iron-studded pauldrons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior scaling a sheer cliff face with his gloved hands digging into jagged rock?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive double-headed battle axe strapped to the warrior's back with a polished steel edge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera arc around the warrior and zoom out to reveal a vertiginous chasm filled with swirling mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a detailed heroic fantasy illustration reminiscent of classic Dungeons & Dragons art?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011998150497674942 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511998176574707 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011998150497674942, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011998150497674942, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09712419658899307, + 0.050967250019311905, + 0.04984234645962715, + 0.04686256870627403, + 0.05204297602176666, + 0.05468928441405296, + 0.062071479856967926, + 0.11687959730625153, + 0.35635432600975037, + 0.11316598206758499 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011998150497674942 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a man wearing worn dark leather armor and iron-studded pauldrons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior scaling a sheer cliff face with his gloved hands digging into jagged rock?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive double-headed battle axe strapped to the warrior's back with a polished steel edge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera arc around the warrior and zoom out to reveal a vertiginous chasm filled with swirling mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a detailed heroic fantasy illustration reminiscent of classic Dungeons & Dragons art?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03810246288776398 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288102388381958 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03810246288776398, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03810246288776398, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09754932671785355, + 0.061386361718177795, + 0.11787108331918716, + 0.08100084960460663, + 0.10038622468709946, + 0.048429571092128754, + 0.09012904018163681, + 0.12100373208522797, + 0.20405618846416473, + 0.07818756997585297 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03810246288776398 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a man wearing worn dark leather armor and iron-studded pauldrons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior scaling a sheer cliff face with his gloved hands digging into jagged rock?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive double-headed battle axe strapped to the warrior's back with a polished steel edge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera arc around the warrior and zoom out to reveal a vertiginous chasm filled with swirling mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a detailed heroic fantasy illustration reminiscent of classic Dungeons & Dragons art?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03809133172035217 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2880914211273193 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03809133172035217, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03809133172035217, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19790156185626984, + 0.06848374009132385, + 0.04104337468743324, + 0.041191406548023224, + 0.040442924946546555, + 0.05459698662161827, + 0.016773846000432968, + 0.15319332480430603, + 0.20903052389621735, + 0.17734234035015106 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03809133172035217 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a man wearing worn dark leather armor and iron-studded pauldrons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior scaling a sheer cliff face with his gloved hands digging into jagged rock?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive double-headed battle axe strapped to the warrior's back with a polished steel edge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera arc around the warrior and zoom out to reveal a vertiginous chasm filled with swirling mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a detailed heroic fantasy illustration reminiscent of classic Dungeons & Dragons art?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026339460164308548 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651339530944824 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026339460164308548, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026339460164308548, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19075269997119904, + 0.07857025414705276, + 0.0828002393245697, + 0.08929040282964706, + 0.035905010998249054, + 0.11465968191623688, + 0.049576349556446075, + 0.12038345634937286, + 0.13302657008171082, + 0.10503539443016052 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026339460164308548 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a man wearing worn dark leather armor and iron-studded pauldrons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior scaling a sheer cliff face with his gloved hands digging into jagged rock?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive double-headed battle axe strapped to the warrior's back with a polished steel edge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera arc around the warrior and zoom out to reveal a vertiginous chasm filled with swirling mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a detailed heroic fantasy illustration reminiscent of classic Dungeons & Dragons art?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011067667976021767 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511067867279053 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011067667976021767, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011067667976021767, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06408664584159851, + 0.0550202839076519, + 0.04151665419340134, + 0.06998904049396515, + 0.05452590435743332, + 0.05655660107731819, + 0.04405388608574867, + 0.07537023723125458, + 0.24456536769866943, + 0.2943154275417328 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011067667976021767 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dynamic, sweeping camera shot arcs around a fearsome warrior as he meticulously scales a sheer, treacherous cliff face. Rendered in a detailed, heroic fantasy illustration reminiscent of classic Dungeons & Dragons art, the scene is a study in tension and determination. The warrior, a man of heroic stature, has long, black braids blown by the high-altitude wind. His face is a mask of intense concentration, his jaw set, his eyes fixed on his next handhold. His muscular body is clad in worn dark leather armor and iron-studded pauldrons that have seen many battles. Strapped to his back is a massive, double-headed battle axe, its polished steel edge gleaming in the light, its heavy wooden handle intricately carved with patterns. His gloved hands dig into the jagged, unforgiving rock, his body moving with a steady and deliberate rhythm that demonstrates his immense strength. As the camera continues to sweep, it captures the dramatic interplay of shadow and light cast by the low-angle sun, highlighting the rough texture of the granite and the climber's strained muscles. The camera zooms out slightly to reveal the abyss below, a vertiginous chasm filled with swirling mist that obscures the bottom, creating a powerful and heroic atmosphere of a lonely struggle against an epic, unforgiving landscape.", + "seed": 23393, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_7/index_9633_seed_23393_dp_15_rank_30_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.01714868415147066, + "vlm_logprob": -0.01714868415147066, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.125, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.01714868415147066, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a man wearing worn dark leather armor and iron-studded pauldrons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior scaling a sheer cliff face with his gloved hands digging into jagged rock?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive double-headed battle axe strapped to the warrior's back with a polished steel edge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera arc around the warrior and zoom out to reveal a vertiginous chasm filled with swirling mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a detailed heroic fantasy illustration reminiscent of classic Dungeons & Dragons art?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01669483631849289 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141695022583008 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01669483631849289, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01669483631849289, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1306070238351822, + 0.046776942908763885, + 0.04926086962223053, + 0.015888262540102005, + 0.15257182717323303, + 0.04783526062965393, + 0.03767279535531998, + 0.14843475818634033, + 0.2613161504268646, + 0.10963612049818039 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 4, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01669483631849289 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a man wearing worn dark leather armor and iron-studded pauldrons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior scaling a sheer cliff face with his gloved hands digging into jagged rock?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive double-headed battle axe strapped to the warrior's back with a polished steel edge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera arc around the warrior and zoom out to reveal a vertiginous chasm filled with swirling mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a detailed heroic fantasy illustration reminiscent of classic Dungeons & Dragons art?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012541593052446842 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387541770935059 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012541593052446842, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012541593052446842, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11621023714542389, + 0.031827546656131744, + 0.06970740109682083, + 0.01580437831580639, + 0.09024527668952942, + 0.12104029208421707, + 0.030003894120454788, + 0.047654543071985245, + 0.2872512936592102, + 0.19025525450706482 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012541593052446842 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a man wearing worn dark leather armor and iron-studded pauldrons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior scaling a sheer cliff face with his gloved hands digging into jagged rock?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive double-headed battle axe strapped to the warrior's back with a polished steel edge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera arc around the warrior and zoom out to reveal a vertiginous chasm filled with swirling mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a detailed heroic fantasy illustration reminiscent of classic Dungeons & Dragons art?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029790684580802917 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5297906398773193 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029790684580802917, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029790684580802917, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09723586589097977, + 0.04906423017382622, + 0.11610201001167297, + 0.04585487022995949, + 0.15371224284172058, + 0.047862038016319275, + 0.08393904566764832, + 0.0751277282834053, + 0.1471448391675949, + 0.18395717442035675 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029790684580802917 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a man wearing worn dark leather armor and iron-studded pauldrons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior scaling a sheer cliff face with his gloved hands digging into jagged rock?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive double-headed battle axe strapped to the warrior's back with a polished steel edge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera arc around the warrior and zoom out to reveal a vertiginous chasm filled with swirling mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a detailed heroic fantasy illustration reminiscent of classic Dungeons & Dragons art?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014185898005962372 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264185905456543 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014185898005962372, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014185898005962372, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07920533418655396, + 0.017088286578655243, + 0.06979607045650482, + 0.019862530753016472, + 0.04514182358980179, + 0.022936154156923294, + 0.04040711745619774, + 0.15340980887413025, + 0.27242743968963623, + 0.27972540259361267 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014185898005962372 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a man wearing worn dark leather armor and iron-studded pauldrons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior scaling a sheer cliff face with his gloved hands digging into jagged rock?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive double-headed battle axe strapped to the warrior's back with a polished steel edge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera arc around the warrior and zoom out to reveal a vertiginous chasm filled with swirling mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a detailed heroic fantasy illustration reminiscent of classic Dungeons & Dragons art?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012530408799648285 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387530326843262 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012530408799648285, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012530408799648285, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1359688937664032, + 0.03876642510294914, + 0.09594626724720001, + 0.023569678887724876, + 0.05414997786283493, + 0.04953012242913246, + 0.14659175276756287, + 0.17862044274806976, + 0.19282878935337067, + 0.08402765542268753 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012530408799648285 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dynamic, sweeping camera shot arcs around a fearsome warrior as he meticulously scales a sheer, treacherous cliff face. Rendered in a detailed, heroic fantasy illustration reminiscent of classic Dungeons & Dragons art, the scene is a study in tension and determination. The warrior, a man of heroic stature, has long, black braids blown by the high-altitude wind. His face is a mask of intense concentration, his jaw set, his eyes fixed on his next handhold. His muscular body is clad in worn dark leather armor and iron-studded pauldrons that have seen many battles. Strapped to his back is a massive, double-headed battle axe, its polished steel edge gleaming in the light, its heavy wooden handle intricately carved with patterns. His gloved hands dig into the jagged, unforgiving rock, his body moving with a steady and deliberate rhythm that demonstrates his immense strength. As the camera continues to sweep, it captures the dramatic interplay of shadow and light cast by the low-angle sun, highlighting the rough texture of the granite and the climber's strained muscles. The camera zooms out slightly to reveal the abyss below, a vertiginous chasm filled with swirling mist that obscures the bottom, creating a powerful and heroic atmosphere of a lonely struggle against an epic, unforgiving landscape.", + "seed": 23394, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_7/index_9633_seed_23394_dp_15_rank_30_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.04183931034058332, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04183931034058332, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.35, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04183931034058332, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a man wearing worn dark leather armor and iron-studded pauldrons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior scaling a sheer cliff face with his gloved hands digging into jagged rock?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive double-headed battle axe strapped to the warrior's back with a polished steel edge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera arc around the warrior and zoom out to reveal a vertiginous chasm filled with swirling mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a detailed heroic fantasy illustration reminiscent of classic Dungeons & Dragons art?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.024200744926929474 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.774200677871704 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.024200744926929474, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.024200744926929474, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19257844984531403, + 0.12622123956680298, + 0.062464918941259384, + 0.06161065027117729, + 0.07953743636608124, + 0.10110465437173843, + 0.0748702809214592, + 0.08664562553167343, + 0.10121478140354156, + 0.11375189572572708 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.024200744926929474 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a man wearing worn dark leather armor and iron-studded pauldrons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior scaling a sheer cliff face with his gloved hands digging into jagged rock?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive double-headed battle axe strapped to the warrior's back with a polished steel edge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera arc around the warrior and zoom out to reveal a vertiginous chasm filled with swirling mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a detailed heroic fantasy illustration reminiscent of classic Dungeons & Dragons art?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02980167791247368 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529801607131958 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02980167791247368, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02980167791247368, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07720262557268143, + 0.0783030092716217, + 0.07782548666000366, + 0.07036825269460678, + 0.07158646732568741, + 0.11958850175142288, + 0.09733814746141434, + 0.059738606214523315, + 0.14651483297348022, + 0.20153404772281647 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02980167791247368 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a man wearing worn dark leather armor and iron-studded pauldrons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior scaling a sheer cliff face with his gloved hands digging into jagged rock?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive double-headed battle axe strapped to the warrior's back with a polished steel edge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera arc around the warrior and zoom out to reveal a vertiginous chasm filled with swirling mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a detailed heroic fantasy illustration reminiscent of classic Dungeons & Dragons art?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06203853711485863 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120384216308594 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06203853711485863, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06203853711485863, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13027215003967285, + 0.07422822713851929, + 0.04494808241724968, + 0.08801185339689255, + 0.04504537209868431, + 0.16937369108200073, + 0.10029371082782745, + 0.13523276150226593, + 0.07178209722042084, + 0.14081202447414398 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06203853711485863 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a man wearing worn dark leather armor and iron-studded pauldrons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior scaling a sheer cliff face with his gloved hands digging into jagged rock?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive double-headed battle axe strapped to the warrior's back with a polished steel edge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera arc around the warrior and zoom out to reveal a vertiginous chasm filled with swirling mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a detailed heroic fantasy illustration reminiscent of classic Dungeons & Dragons art?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07897016406059265 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.578970193862915 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07897016406059265, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07897016406059265, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06037587672472, + 0.06056572124361992, + 0.05877193436026573, + 0.06974591314792633, + 0.04737572371959686, + 0.1079624816775322, + 0.0379142239689827, + 0.08835072815418243, + 0.3632303476333618, + 0.10570704936981201 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07897016406059265 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a man wearing worn dark leather armor and iron-studded pauldrons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior scaling a sheer cliff face with his gloved hands digging into jagged rock?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive double-headed battle axe strapped to the warrior's back with a polished steel edge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera arc around the warrior and zoom out to reveal a vertiginous chasm filled with swirling mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a detailed heroic fantasy illustration reminiscent of classic Dungeons & Dragons art?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014185427688062191 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264185428619385 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014185427688062191, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014185427688062191, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19793325662612915, + 0.14484265446662903, + 0.05083957687020302, + 0.09137521684169769, + 0.07318317145109177, + 0.13875316083431244, + 0.04019390791654587, + 0.04380159080028534, + 0.0826067253947258, + 0.1364707052707672 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014185427688062191 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_8/index_tensor([409, 409])_group_8_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_8/index_tensor([409, 409])_group_8_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..fcb2f6511385b865a1a7c285e9cf6cd28bba19b0 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_8/index_tensor([409, 409])_group_8_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "static, mid-range shot from a horizontal angle focuses firmly on the tuning dial of an old radio. The radio, with its dark brown wooden case, bears subtle scratches and a patina of age. It sits on a wooden tabletop, its background softly blurred, the outlines of a bookshelf barely visible. The space is dimly lit. The dial is a rectangular glass panel, with a yellowed frequency scale and city names printed behind it. A slender red hand motionlessly points to a specific frequency. A soft, warm amber light filters through from within the dial, gradually pulsating from a faint glow to a bright, then slowly fading in a steady, soothing rhythm. Each time the light illuminates, it not only clearly illuminates the details on the dial but also casts dynamic shadows on the wooden case. This rhythmic light, combined with the texture of the old object, creates a profoundly tranquil, warm, and nostalgic atmosphere of contemplation.", + "seed": 32477, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_8/index_409_seed_32477_dp_16_rank_32_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.020581900607794523, + "vlm_logprob": -0.020581900607794523, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.35, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.020581900607794523, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a close-up of the tuning dial of an old radio?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the radio case dark brown wood with visible scratches and signs of age?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the dial a rectangular glass panel with a yellowed frequency scale and city names?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a slender red hand point motionlessly to a specific frequency?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a soft warm amber light inside the dial pulse rhythmically from faint to bright and then fade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04496630281209946 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.169966220855713 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04496630281209946, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04496630281209946, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4367310404777527, + 0.23097145557403564, + 0.08233664184808731, + 0.06178656220436096, + 0.04527686536312103, + 0.0102927777916193, + 0.027545185759663582, + 0.032610710710287094, + 0.04952823743224144, + 0.02292049489915371 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04496630281209946 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a close-up of the tuning dial of an old radio?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the radio case dark brown wood with visible scratches and signs of age?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the dial a rectangular glass panel with a yellowed frequency scale and city names?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a slender red hand point motionlessly to a specific frequency?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a soft warm amber light inside the dial pulse rhythmically from faint to bright and then fade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009799469262361526 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634799480438232 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009799469262361526, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009799469262361526, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.48236513137817383, + 0.0437820740044117, + 0.06060802564024925, + 0.10709897428750992, + 0.03369394689798355, + 0.04588611051440239, + 0.029560180380940437, + 0.06915141642093658, + 0.09585142135620117, + 0.032002728432416916 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009799469262361526 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a close-up of the tuning dial of an old radio?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the radio case dark brown wood with visible scratches and signs of age?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the dial a rectangular glass panel with a yellowed frequency scale and city names?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a slender red hand point motionlessly to a specific frequency?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a soft warm amber light inside the dial pulse rhythmically from faint to bright and then fade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0015197168104350567 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.501519680023193 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0015197168104350567, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0015197168104350567, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25648683309555054, + 0.13623902201652527, + 0.11191613227128983, + 0.11477190256118774, + 0.14212432503700256, + 0.03943871706724167, + 0.04163696989417076, + 0.07957912981510162, + 0.043348733335733414, + 0.034458182752132416 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0015197168104350567 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a close-up of the tuning dial of an old radio?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the radio case dark brown wood with visible scratches and signs of age?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the dial a rectangular glass panel with a yellowed frequency scale and city names?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a slender red hand point motionlessly to a specific frequency?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a soft warm amber light inside the dial pulse rhythmically from faint to bright and then fade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02332068420946598 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7733206748962402 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02332068420946598, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02332068420946598, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3594910800457001, + 0.26905256509780884, + 0.02985532581806183, + 0.07774858921766281, + 0.03441772982478142, + 0.0423944927752018, + 0.03150719404220581, + 0.06588004529476166, + 0.06066061556339264, + 0.0289923008531332 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02332068420946598 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a close-up of the tuning dial of an old radio?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the radio case dark brown wood with visible scratches and signs of age?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the dial a rectangular glass panel with a yellowed frequency scale and city names?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a slender red hand point motionlessly to a specific frequency?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a soft warm amber light inside the dial pulse rhythmically from faint to bright and then fade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023303329944610596 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773303270339966 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023303329944610596, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023303329944610596, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.46629950404167175, + 0.07605288177728653, + 0.052066028118133545, + 0.037943147122859955, + 0.06440488249063492, + 0.07465406507253647, + 0.040353428572416306, + 0.058772820979356766, + 0.10015043616294861, + 0.02930276095867157 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023303329944610596 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, mid-range shot from a horizontal angle focuses firmly on the tuning dial of an old radio. The radio, with its dark brown wooden case, bears subtle scratches and a patina of age. It sits on a wooden tabletop, its background softly blurred, the outlines of a bookshelf barely visible. The space is dimly lit. The dial is a rectangular glass panel, with a yellowed frequency scale and city names printed behind it. A slender red hand motionlessly points to a specific frequency. A soft, warm amber light filters through from within the dial, gradually pulsating from a faint glow to a bright, then slowly fading in a steady, soothing rhythm. Each time the light illuminates, it not only clearly illuminates the details on the dial but also casts dynamic shadows on the wooden case. This rhythmic light, combined with the texture of the old object, creates a profoundly tranquil, warm, and nostalgic atmosphere of contemplation.", + "seed": 32478, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_8/index_409_seed_32478_dp_16_rank_32_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.018619079026393592, + "vlm_logprob": -0.018619079026393592, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.325, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.018619079026393592, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a close-up of the tuning dial of an old radio?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the radio case dark brown wood with visible scratches and signs of age?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the dial a rectangular glass panel with a yellowed frequency scale and city names?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a slender red hand point motionlessly to a specific frequency?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a soft warm amber light inside the dial pulse rhythmically from faint to bright and then fade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02498597651720047 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7749860286712646 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02498597651720047, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02498597651720047, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.34483954310417175, + 0.05008715018630028, + 0.03802308812737465, + 0.05209317058324814, + 0.049611277878284454, + 0.14263159036636353, + 0.16011033952236176, + 0.058837760239839554, + 0.045568618923425674, + 0.058197543025016785 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02498597651720047 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a close-up of the tuning dial of an old radio?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the radio case dark brown wood with visible scratches and signs of age?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the dial a rectangular glass panel with a yellowed frequency scale and city names?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a slender red hand point motionlessly to a specific frequency?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a soft warm amber light inside the dial pulse rhythmically from faint to bright and then fade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014218688011169434 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264218807220459 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014218688011169434, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014218688011169434, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4133812189102173, + 0.10680845379829407, + 0.09706743061542511, + 0.0543803870677948, + 0.03439294174313545, + 0.05076569691300392, + 0.04305461049079895, + 0.053520604968070984, + 0.08724590390920639, + 0.059382759034633636 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014218688011169434 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a close-up of the tuning dial of an old radio?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the radio case dark brown wood with visible scratches and signs of age?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the dial a rectangular glass panel with a yellowed frequency scale and city names?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a slender red hand point motionlessly to a specific frequency?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a soft warm amber light inside the dial pulse rhythmically from faint to bright and then fade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0019489595433697104 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.251948833465576 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0019489595433697104, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0019489595433697104, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2141089141368866, + 0.10496310144662857, + 0.059326015412807465, + 0.09120847284793854, + 0.08987759798765182, + 0.1641513854265213, + 0.10188691318035126, + 0.04052755609154701, + 0.07616829127073288, + 0.057781778275966644 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0019489595433697104 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a close-up of the tuning dial of an old radio?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the radio case dark brown wood with visible scratches and signs of age?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the dial a rectangular glass panel with a yellowed frequency scale and city names?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a slender red hand point motionlessly to a specific frequency?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a soft warm amber light inside the dial pulse rhythmically from faint to bright and then fade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.033739130944013596 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4087390899658203 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.033739130944013596, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.033739130944013596, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11801261454820633, + 0.06753814220428467, + 0.07747737318277359, + 0.08591695874929428, + 0.14271748065948486, + 0.21369118988513947, + 0.022244153544306755, + 0.027429591864347458, + 0.03127621114253998, + 0.21369630098342896 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.033739130944013596 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a close-up of the tuning dial of an old radio?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the radio case dark brown wood with visible scratches and signs of age?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the dial a rectangular glass panel with a yellowed frequency scale and city names?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a slender red hand point motionlessly to a specific frequency?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a soft warm amber light inside the dial pulse rhythmically from faint to bright and then fade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018202640116214752 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018202781677246 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018202640116214752, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018202640116214752, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.27282068133354187, + 0.05868297815322876, + 0.07372070848941803, + 0.04359794780611992, + 0.03644770383834839, + 0.2155652940273285, + 0.02722354792058468, + 0.061810288578271866, + 0.045254532247781754, + 0.16487641632556915 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018202640116214752 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, mid-range shot from a horizontal angle focuses firmly on the tuning dial of an old radio. The radio, with its dark brown wooden case, bears subtle scratches and a patina of age. It sits on a wooden tabletop, its background softly blurred, the outlines of a bookshelf barely visible. The space is dimly lit. The dial is a rectangular glass panel, with a yellowed frequency scale and city names printed behind it. A slender red hand motionlessly points to a specific frequency. A soft, warm amber light filters through from within the dial, gradually pulsating from a faint glow to a bright, then slowly fading in a steady, soothing rhythm. Each time the light illuminates, it not only clearly illuminates the details on the dial but also casts dynamic shadows on the wooden case. This rhythmic light, combined with the texture of the old object, creates a profoundly tranquil, warm, and nostalgic atmosphere of contemplation.", + "seed": 32479, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_8/index_409_seed_32479_dp_17_rank_34_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.2865343946963549, + "vlm_logprob": -0.2865343946963549, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.725, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.2865343946963549, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a close-up of the tuning dial of an old radio?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the radio case dark brown wood with visible scratches and signs of age?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the dial a rectangular glass panel with a yellowed frequency scale and city names?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a slender red hand point motionlessly to a specific frequency?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a soft warm amber light inside the dial pulse rhythmically from faint to bright and then fade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3151997327804565 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.31519970297813416 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.3151997327804565, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -1.3151997327804565, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3746054172515869, + 0.045112594962120056, + 0.022905662655830383, + 0.06750809401273727, + 0.09705158323049545, + 0.04008008912205696, + 0.1218784973025322, + 0.06822854280471802, + 0.15460781753063202, + 0.008021626621484756 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.3151997327804565 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a close-up of the tuning dial of an old radio?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the radio case dark brown wood with visible scratches and signs of age?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the dial a rectangular glass panel with a yellowed frequency scale and city names?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a slender red hand point motionlessly to a specific frequency?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a soft warm amber light inside the dial pulse rhythmically from faint to bright and then fade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04314572364091873 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1681456565856934 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04314572364091873, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04314572364091873, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4278404116630554, + 0.12052259594202042, + 0.029034102335572243, + 0.07611048221588135, + 0.0902765542268753, + 0.03882131353020668, + 0.09313569962978363, + 0.0074257077649235725, + 0.10064037889242172, + 0.016192741692066193 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04314572364091873 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a close-up of the tuning dial of an old radio?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the radio case dark brown wood with visible scratches and signs of age?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the dial a rectangular glass panel with a yellowed frequency scale and city names?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a slender red hand point motionlessly to a specific frequency?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a soft warm amber light inside the dial pulse rhythmically from faint to bright and then fade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009796399623155594 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634796619415283 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009796399623155594, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009796399623155594, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.45342347025871277, + 0.0692892074584961, + 0.04160588979721069, + 0.06177979335188866, + 0.1404857486486435, + 0.06885404884815216, + 0.06727899610996246, + 0.009501190856099129, + 0.07290253043174744, + 0.014879133552312851 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009796399623155594 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a close-up of the tuning dial of an old radio?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the radio case dark brown wood with visible scratches and signs of age?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the dial a rectangular glass panel with a yellowed frequency scale and city names?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a slender red hand point motionlessly to a specific frequency?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a soft warm amber light inside the dial pulse rhythmically from faint to bright and then fade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0381559394299984 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288156032562256 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0381559394299984, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0381559394299984, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.28504133224487305, + 0.04752958565950394, + 0.02457251213490963, + 0.10162032395601273, + 0.04298029839992523, + 0.044185932725667953, + 0.12198854237794876, + 0.13664743304252625, + 0.17467419803142548, + 0.020759832113981247 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0381559394299984 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a close-up of the tuning dial of an old radio?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the radio case dark brown wood with visible scratches and signs of age?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the dial a rectangular glass panel with a yellowed frequency scale and city names?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a slender red hand point motionlessly to a specific frequency?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a soft warm amber light inside the dial pulse rhythmically from faint to bright and then fade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026374178007245064 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651374101638794 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026374178007245064, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026374178007245064, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.31165027618408203, + 0.05095786228775978, + 0.07765896618366241, + 0.07551943510770798, + 0.13945676386356354, + 0.04135555773973465, + 0.10941512882709503, + 0.07973582297563553, + 0.07813673466444016, + 0.03611339256167412 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026374178007245064 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, mid-range shot from a horizontal angle focuses firmly on the tuning dial of an old radio. The radio, with its dark brown wooden case, bears subtle scratches and a patina of age. It sits on a wooden tabletop, its background softly blurred, the outlines of a bookshelf barely visible. The space is dimly lit. The dial is a rectangular glass panel, with a yellowed frequency scale and city names printed behind it. A slender red hand motionlessly points to a specific frequency. A soft, warm amber light filters through from within the dial, gradually pulsating from a faint glow to a bright, then slowly fading in a steady, soothing rhythm. Each time the light illuminates, it not only clearly illuminates the details on the dial but also casts dynamic shadows on the wooden case. This rhythmic light, combined with the texture of the old object, creates a profoundly tranquil, warm, and nostalgic atmosphere of contemplation.", + "seed": 32480, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_8/index_409_seed_32480_dp_17_rank_34_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.027464975975453852, + "vlm_logprob": -0.027464975975453852, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.1, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.027464975975453852, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a close-up of the tuning dial of an old radio?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the radio case dark brown wood with visible scratches and signs of age?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the dial a rectangular glass panel with a yellowed frequency scale and city names?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a slender red hand point motionlessly to a specific frequency?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a soft warm amber light inside the dial pulse rhythmically from faint to bright and then fade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07213450223207474 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.697134494781494 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07213450223207474, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07213450223207474, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.35312792658805847, + 0.14975331723690033, + 0.12555786967277527, + 0.07778117060661316, + 0.03150886669754982, + 0.04635996371507645, + 0.03643978387117386, + 0.03634822741150856, + 0.10464645177125931, + 0.03847640007734299 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07213450223207474 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a close-up of the tuning dial of an old radio?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the radio case dark brown wood with visible scratches and signs of age?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the dial a rectangular glass panel with a yellowed frequency scale and city names?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a slender red hand point motionlessly to a specific frequency?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a soft warm amber light inside the dial pulse rhythmically from faint to bright and then fade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01255783811211586 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.3875579833984375 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01255783811211586, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01255783811211586, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3125587999820709, + 0.16563501954078674, + 0.07179014384746552, + 0.06941116601228714, + 0.03343537822365761, + 0.04115983843803406, + 0.12711523473262787, + 0.10745975375175476, + 0.04342860355973244, + 0.028006115928292274 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01255783811211586 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a close-up of the tuning dial of an old radio?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the radio case dark brown wood with visible scratches and signs of age?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the dial a rectangular glass panel with a yellowed frequency scale and city names?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a slender red hand point motionlessly to a specific frequency?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a soft warm amber light inside the dial pulse rhythmically from faint to bright and then fade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0022019920870661736 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127202033996582 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0022019920870661736, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0022019920870661736, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.35086721181869507, + 0.11855379492044449, + 0.10281200706958771, + 0.058659717440605164, + 0.08210311830043793, + 0.027919210493564606, + 0.08722995221614838, + 0.047744762152433395, + 0.0916212871670723, + 0.03248889744281769 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0022019920870661736 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a close-up of the tuning dial of an old radio?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the radio case dark brown wood with visible scratches and signs of age?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the dial a rectangular glass panel with a yellowed frequency scale and city names?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a slender red hand point motionlessly to a specific frequency?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a soft warm amber light inside the dial pulse rhythmically from faint to bright and then fade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029830489307641983 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298304557800293 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029830489307641983, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029830489307641983, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2447562962770462, + 0.10797245800495148, + 0.11993716657161713, + 0.14641858637332916, + 0.11261598020792007, + 0.10665072500705719, + 0.051822371780872345, + 0.03740886226296425, + 0.04518807679414749, + 0.027229415252804756 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029830489307641983 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a close-up of the tuning dial of an old radio?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the radio case dark brown wood with visible scratches and signs of age?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the dial a rectangular glass panel with a yellowed frequency scale and city names?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a slender red hand point motionlessly to a specific frequency?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a soft warm amber light inside the dial pulse rhythmically from faint to bright and then fade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020600058138370514 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8956000804901123 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020600058138370514, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020600058138370514, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20139309763908386, + 0.13903991878032684, + 0.0678739845752716, + 0.12865428626537323, + 0.11261411756277084, + 0.08343391120433807, + 0.07170184701681137, + 0.08314114809036255, + 0.07117120176553726, + 0.040976591408252716 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020600058138370514 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_9/index_tensor([3097, 3097])_group_9_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_9/index_tensor([3097, 3097])_group_9_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..a756e568f76690545bad15948ad7c5b46b44cc13 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_9/index_tensor([3097, 3097])_group_9_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "static, high-angle, wide-angle shot captures the surreal and expansive transformation of Millennium City Park, rendered entirely in the distinctive artistic style of a David Hockney painting. The scene is defined by clean lines, planes of vibrant, saturated color, and a slightly distorted, flattened perspective. A traditional Chinese pagoda, with its ornate terracotta tile roof and an ornate pavilion with imperial yellow accents, stands majestically above the surface of a vast, incredibly clear lake that fills the park's basin. Beneath the tranquil, azure waters, the underwater forms of tranquil gardens, intricate stone paths, and manicured trees are clearly visible. The central element is the gentle, rhythmic pulsation of the water itself; the water level rises steadily and smoothly, clinging to the pavilion's wooden latticework, then gracefully recedes, allowing the building's surfaces to shimmer in bright, shadowless sunlight against the azure sky. This constant, hypnotic fluctuation creates an atmosphere of dreamlike tranquility, a beautiful yet melancholic natural landscape restored to its man-made splendor in brilliant, serene colors.", + "seed": 27246, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_9/index_3097_seed_27246_dp_18_rank_36_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.09529468631371855, + "vlm_logprob": -0.09529468631371855, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.775, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.09529468631371855, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in the distinctive artistic style of a David Hockney painting with clean lines and vibrant, saturated colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a traditional Chinese pagoda with an ornate terracotta tile roof and imperial yellow accents visible above the lake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are underwater forms of gardens, stone paths, and trees clearly visible beneath the tranquil, azure waters?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the water level rise steadily and smoothly to cling to the pavilion's wooden latticework before receding?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a static, high-angle, wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007370068226009607 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.0073699951171875 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007370068226009607, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007370068226009607, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07774540781974792, + 0.25286975502967834, + 0.07886270433664322, + 0.11812181770801544, + 0.1505330204963684, + 0.15062199532985687, + 0.03485759347677231, + 0.02246246300637722, + 0.061332497745752335, + 0.05259266495704651 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007370068226009607 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in the distinctive artistic style of a David Hockney painting with clean lines and vibrant, saturated colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a traditional Chinese pagoda with an ornate terracotta tile roof and imperial yellow accents visible above the lake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are underwater forms of gardens, stone paths, and trees clearly visible beneath the tranquil, azure waters?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the water level rise steadily and smoothly to cling to the pavilion's wooden latticework before receding?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a static, high-angle, wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0059619685634970665 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130961894989014 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0059619685634970665, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0059619685634970665, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1811589002609253, + 0.15158334374427795, + 0.09123164415359497, + 0.1041649803519249, + 0.07244495302438736, + 0.09079649299383163, + 0.06855805963277817, + 0.11019744724035263, + 0.08049418032169342, + 0.04937001317739487 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0059619685634970665 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in the distinctive artistic style of a David Hockney painting with clean lines and vibrant, saturated colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a traditional Chinese pagoda with an ornate terracotta tile roof and imperial yellow accents visible above the lake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are underwater forms of gardens, stone paths, and trees clearly visible beneath the tranquil, azure waters?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the water level rise steadily and smoothly to cling to the pavilion's wooden latticework before receding?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a static, high-angle, wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016072941944003105 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141072750091553 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016072941944003105, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016072941944003105, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1618720144033432, + 0.08743182569742203, + 0.07567465305328369, + 0.061671461910009384, + 0.06155186891555786, + 0.15700171887874603, + 0.2347075343132019, + 0.04622974619269371, + 0.04362103343009949, + 0.0702381506562233 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016072941944003105 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in the distinctive artistic style of a David Hockney painting with clean lines and vibrant, saturated colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a traditional Chinese pagoda with an ornate terracotta tile roof and imperial yellow accents visible above the lake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are underwater forms of gardens, stone paths, and trees clearly visible beneath the tranquil, azure waters?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the water level rise steadily and smoothly to cling to the pavilion's wooden latticework before receding?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a static, high-angle, wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.428884893655777 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.0538848638534546 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.428884893655777, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.428884893655777, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2412453442811966, + 0.10732059925794601, + 0.1070440262556076, + 0.07810511440038681, + 0.07357854396104813, + 0.1288938820362091, + 0.06488149613142014, + 0.03740152344107628, + 0.1010834351181984, + 0.060446012765169144 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.428884893655777 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in the distinctive artistic style of a David Hockney painting with clean lines and vibrant, saturated colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a traditional Chinese pagoda with an ornate terracotta tile roof and imperial yellow accents visible above the lake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are underwater forms of gardens, stone paths, and trees clearly visible beneath the tranquil, azure waters?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the water level rise steadily and smoothly to cling to the pavilion's wooden latticework before receding?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a static, high-angle, wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01818355917930603 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018183708190918 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01818355917930603, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01818355917930603, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19090527296066284, + 0.1681704968214035, + 0.09955023974180222, + 0.09328218549489975, + 0.04710129275918007, + 0.092165507376194, + 0.16387706995010376, + 0.05250370875000954, + 0.051572032272815704, + 0.040872134268283844 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01818355917930603 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, high-angle, wide-angle shot captures the surreal and expansive transformation of Millennium City Park, rendered entirely in the distinctive artistic style of a David Hockney painting. The scene is defined by clean lines, planes of vibrant, saturated color, and a slightly distorted, flattened perspective. A traditional Chinese pagoda, with its ornate terracotta tile roof and an ornate pavilion with imperial yellow accents, stands majestically above the surface of a vast, incredibly clear lake that fills the park's basin. Beneath the tranquil, azure waters, the underwater forms of tranquil gardens, intricate stone paths, and manicured trees are clearly visible. The central element is the gentle, rhythmic pulsation of the water itself; the water level rises steadily and smoothly, clinging to the pavilion's wooden latticework, then gracefully recedes, allowing the building's surfaces to shimmer in bright, shadowless sunlight against the azure sky. This constant, hypnotic fluctuation creates an atmosphere of dreamlike tranquility, a beautiful yet melancholic natural landscape restored to its man-made splendor in brilliant, serene colors.", + "seed": 27247, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_9/index_3097_seed_27247_dp_18_rank_36_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.048746717348694804, + "vlm_logprob": -0.048746717348694804, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.349999952316284, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.048746717348694804, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in the distinctive artistic style of a David Hockney painting with clean lines and vibrant, saturated colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a traditional Chinese pagoda with an ornate terracotta tile roof and imperial yellow accents visible above the lake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are underwater forms of gardens, stone paths, and trees clearly visible beneath the tranquil, azure waters?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the water level rise steadily and smoothly to cling to the pavilion's wooden latticework before receding?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a static, high-angle, wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018823327496647835 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018823146820068 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018823327496647835, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018823327496647835, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1243394985795021, + 0.050314612686634064, + 0.021146738901734352, + 0.027369946241378784, + 0.08599327504634857, + 0.05079447850584984, + 0.10728541016578674, + 0.3988146483898163, + 0.029378840699791908, + 0.10456252843141556 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018823327496647835 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in the distinctive artistic style of a David Hockney painting with clean lines and vibrant, saturated colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a traditional Chinese pagoda with an ornate terracotta tile roof and imperial yellow accents visible above the lake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are underwater forms of gardens, stone paths, and trees clearly visible beneath the tranquil, azure waters?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the water level rise steadily and smoothly to cling to the pavilion's wooden latticework before receding?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a static, high-angle, wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011102564632892609 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511102676391602 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011102564632892609, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011102564632892609, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09731150418519974, + 0.08819951862096786, + 0.048487886786460876, + 0.07398035377264023, + 0.22993990778923035, + 0.07206649333238602, + 0.11591015756130219, + 0.1174033060669899, + 0.07260013371706009, + 0.08410072326660156 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011102564632892609 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in the distinctive artistic style of a David Hockney painting with clean lines and vibrant, saturated colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a traditional Chinese pagoda with an ornate terracotta tile roof and imperial yellow accents visible above the lake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are underwater forms of gardens, stone paths, and trees clearly visible beneath the tranquil, azure waters?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the water level rise steadily and smoothly to cling to the pavilion's wooden latticework before receding?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a static, high-angle, wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03811141476035118 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288111448287964 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03811141476035118, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03811141476035118, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14968925714492798, + 0.045586615800857544, + 0.02835749089717865, + 0.04572608321905136, + 0.15743930637836456, + 0.08416126668453217, + 0.05347367748618126, + 0.3339449167251587, + 0.04645770043134689, + 0.05516371503472328 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03811141476035118 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in the distinctive artistic style of a David Hockney painting with clean lines and vibrant, saturated colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a traditional Chinese pagoda with an ornate terracotta tile roof and imperial yellow accents visible above the lake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are underwater forms of gardens, stone paths, and trees clearly visible beneath the tranquil, azure waters?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the water level rise steadily and smoothly to cling to the pavilion's wooden latticework before receding?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a static, high-angle, wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12704627215862274 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1270463466644287 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12704627215862274, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12704627215862274, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1350243240594864, + 0.029803214594721794, + 0.02981768175959587, + 0.054414257407188416, + 0.10493814945220947, + 0.10726088285446167, + 0.15514960885047913, + 0.23488092422485352, + 0.04280397668480873, + 0.10590705275535583 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12704627215862274 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in the distinctive artistic style of a David Hockney painting with clean lines and vibrant, saturated colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a traditional Chinese pagoda with an ornate terracotta tile roof and imperial yellow accents visible above the lake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are underwater forms of gardens, stone paths, and trees clearly visible beneath the tranquil, azure waters?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the water level rise steadily and smoothly to cling to the pavilion's wooden latticework before receding?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a static, high-angle, wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04865000769495964 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048650026321411 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04865000769495964, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04865000769495964, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1310049593448639, + 0.053304776549339294, + 0.03739771991968155, + 0.09714080393314362, + 0.2187584936618805, + 0.04394830763339996, + 0.13203974068164825, + 0.10826529562473297, + 0.07158101350069046, + 0.10655892640352249 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04865000769495964 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, high-angle, wide-angle shot captures the surreal and expansive transformation of Millennium City Park, rendered entirely in the distinctive artistic style of a David Hockney painting. The scene is defined by clean lines, planes of vibrant, saturated color, and a slightly distorted, flattened perspective. A traditional Chinese pagoda, with its ornate terracotta tile roof and an ornate pavilion with imperial yellow accents, stands majestically above the surface of a vast, incredibly clear lake that fills the park's basin. Beneath the tranquil, azure waters, the underwater forms of tranquil gardens, intricate stone paths, and manicured trees are clearly visible. The central element is the gentle, rhythmic pulsation of the water itself; the water level rises steadily and smoothly, clinging to the pavilion's wooden latticework, then gracefully recedes, allowing the building's surfaces to shimmer in bright, shadowless sunlight against the azure sky. This constant, hypnotic fluctuation creates an atmosphere of dreamlike tranquility, a beautiful yet melancholic natural landscape restored to its man-made splendor in brilliant, serene colors.", + "seed": 27248, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_9/index_3097_seed_27248_dp_19_rank_38_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.04432918694801628, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04432918694801628, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.974999952316284, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04432918694801628, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in the distinctive artistic style of a David Hockney painting with clean lines and vibrant, saturated colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a traditional Chinese pagoda with an ornate terracotta tile roof and imperial yellow accents visible above the lake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are underwater forms of gardens, stone paths, and trees clearly visible beneath the tranquil, azure waters?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the water level rise steadily and smoothly to cling to the pavilion's wooden latticework before receding?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a static, high-angle, wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.010280275717377663 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.635280132293701 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.010280275717377663, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.010280275717377663, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16879497468471527, + 0.10260654240846634, + 0.13958938419818878, + 0.21439477801322937, + 0.12010538578033447, + 0.02989461086690426, + 0.03566797077655792, + 0.04116388410329819, + 0.10432812571525574, + 0.043454382568597794 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.010280275717377663 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in the distinctive artistic style of a David Hockney painting with clean lines and vibrant, saturated colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a traditional Chinese pagoda with an ornate terracotta tile roof and imperial yellow accents visible above the lake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are underwater forms of gardens, stone paths, and trees clearly visible beneath the tranquil, azure waters?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the water level rise steadily and smoothly to cling to the pavilion's wooden latticework before receding?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a static, high-angle, wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0017268045339733362 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.3767266273498535 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0017268045339733362, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0017268045339733362, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1373126208782196, + 0.21829575300216675, + 0.08780398219823837, + 0.1993979662656784, + 0.044916197657585144, + 0.06539938598871231, + 0.07951349020004272, + 0.08356153964996338, + 0.04292446747422218, + 0.04087464138865471 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0017268045339733362 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in the distinctive artistic style of a David Hockney painting with clean lines and vibrant, saturated colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a traditional Chinese pagoda with an ornate terracotta tile roof and imperial yellow accents visible above the lake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are underwater forms of gardens, stone paths, and trees clearly visible beneath the tranquil, azure waters?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the water level rise steadily and smoothly to cling to the pavilion's wooden latticework before receding?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a static, high-angle, wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0181919876486063 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018191814422607 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0181919876486063, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0181919876486063, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13140356540679932, + 0.12728695571422577, + 0.1028285101056099, + 0.228385329246521, + 0.12046045809984207, + 0.03562556207180023, + 0.025560928508639336, + 0.07855120301246643, + 0.08262746781110764, + 0.06727001816034317 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0181919876486063 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in the distinctive artistic style of a David Hockney painting with clean lines and vibrant, saturated colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a traditional Chinese pagoda with an ornate terracotta tile roof and imperial yellow accents visible above the lake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are underwater forms of gardens, stone paths, and trees clearly visible beneath the tranquil, azure waters?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the water level rise steadily and smoothly to cling to the pavilion's wooden latticework before receding?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a static, high-angle, wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1427932232618332 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0177931785583496 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1427932232618332, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1427932232618332, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10065940767526627, + 0.09494157880544662, + 0.061164263635873795, + 0.2034190595149994, + 0.056145358830690384, + 0.04164271429181099, + 0.053229257464408875, + 0.11412294209003448, + 0.16393931210041046, + 0.11073603481054306 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1427932232618332 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in the distinctive artistic style of a David Hockney painting with clean lines and vibrant, saturated colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a traditional Chinese pagoda with an ornate terracotta tile roof and imperial yellow accents visible above the lake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are underwater forms of gardens, stone paths, and trees clearly visible beneath the tranquil, azure waters?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the water level rise steadily and smoothly to cling to the pavilion's wooden latticework before receding?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a static, high-angle, wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04865364357829094 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486536026000977 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04865364357829094, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04865364357829094, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06041818857192993, + 0.0893438383936882, + 0.09896183013916016, + 0.31277430057525635, + 0.04052481800317764, + 0.0552099384367466, + 0.034313514828681946, + 0.08810794353485107, + 0.16484525799751282, + 0.05550039932131767 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04865364357829094 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, high-angle, wide-angle shot captures the surreal and expansive transformation of Millennium City Park, rendered entirely in the distinctive artistic style of a David Hockney painting. The scene is defined by clean lines, planes of vibrant, saturated color, and a slightly distorted, flattened perspective. A traditional Chinese pagoda, with its ornate terracotta tile roof and an ornate pavilion with imperial yellow accents, stands majestically above the surface of a vast, incredibly clear lake that fills the park's basin. Beneath the tranquil, azure waters, the underwater forms of tranquil gardens, intricate stone paths, and manicured trees are clearly visible. The central element is the gentle, rhythmic pulsation of the water itself; the water level rises steadily and smoothly, clinging to the pavilion's wooden latticework, then gracefully recedes, allowing the building's surfaces to shimmer in bright, shadowless sunlight against the azure sky. This constant, hypnotic fluctuation creates an atmosphere of dreamlike tranquility, a beautiful yet melancholic natural landscape restored to its man-made splendor in brilliant, serene colors.", + "seed": 27249, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000057/group_9/index_3097_seed_27249_dp_19_rank_38_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.06582379988394678, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06582379988394678, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.65, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06582379988394678, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in the distinctive artistic style of a David Hockney painting with clean lines and vibrant, saturated colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a traditional Chinese pagoda with an ornate terracotta tile roof and imperial yellow accents visible above the lake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are underwater forms of gardens, stone paths, and trees clearly visible beneath the tranquil, azure waters?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the water level rise steadily and smoothly to cling to the pavilion's wooden latticework before receding?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a static, high-angle, wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.021081537008285522 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8960814476013184 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.021081537008285522, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.021081537008285522, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16623103618621826, + 0.13824036717414856, + 0.024189449846744537, + 0.06871121376752853, + 0.10933556407690048, + 0.09799806028604507, + 0.25238507986068726, + 0.025427648797631264, + 0.03928353264927864, + 0.07819809019565582 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.021081537008285522 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in the distinctive artistic style of a David Hockney painting with clean lines and vibrant, saturated colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a traditional Chinese pagoda with an ornate terracotta tile roof and imperial yellow accents visible above the lake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are underwater forms of gardens, stone paths, and trees clearly visible beneath the tranquil, azure waters?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the water level rise steadily and smoothly to cling to the pavilion's wooden latticework before receding?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a static, high-angle, wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036305959802120924 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628630638122559 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036305959802120924, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036305959802120924, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14836378395557404, + 0.1022050604224205, + 0.053812772035598755, + 0.18492522835731506, + 0.0659434050321579, + 0.08370636403560638, + 0.23867115378379822, + 0.018521705642342567, + 0.037002187222242355, + 0.06684836745262146 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036305959802120924 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in the distinctive artistic style of a David Hockney painting with clean lines and vibrant, saturated colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a traditional Chinese pagoda with an ornate terracotta tile roof and imperial yellow accents visible above the lake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are underwater forms of gardens, stone paths, and trees clearly visible beneath the tranquil, azure waters?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the water level rise steadily and smoothly to cling to the pavilion's wooden latticework before receding?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a static, high-angle, wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01420881599187851 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264208793640137 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01420881599187851, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01420881599187851, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1341688185930252, + 0.05185283347964287, + 0.03811706602573395, + 0.04199060797691345, + 0.1259259283542633, + 0.08375459164381027, + 0.2902713418006897, + 0.06445872038602829, + 0.036841731518507004, + 0.13261832296848297 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01420881599187851 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in the distinctive artistic style of a David Hockney painting with clean lines and vibrant, saturated colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a traditional Chinese pagoda with an ornate terracotta tile roof and imperial yellow accents visible above the lake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are underwater forms of gardens, stone paths, and trees clearly visible beneath the tranquil, azure waters?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the water level rise steadily and smoothly to cling to the pavilion's wooden latticework before receding?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a static, high-angle, wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2520934045314789 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5020934343338013 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2520934045314789, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2520934045314789, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18652565777301788, + 0.06267235428094864, + 0.131794273853302, + 0.0851062461733818, + 0.15671172738075256, + 0.033092934638261795, + 0.05032449588179588, + 0.04954015836119652, + 0.07567552477121353, + 0.16855667531490326 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2520934045314789 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in the distinctive artistic style of a David Hockney painting with clean lines and vibrant, saturated colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a traditional Chinese pagoda with an ornate terracotta tile roof and imperial yellow accents visible above the lake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are underwater forms of gardens, stone paths, and trees clearly visible beneath the tranquil, azure waters?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the water level rise steadily and smoothly to cling to the pavilion's wooden latticework before receding?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a static, high-angle, wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.038104645907878876 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.28810453414917 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.038104645907878876, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.038104645907878876, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13402557373046875, + 0.13834112882614136, + 0.08954615890979767, + 0.0697067528963089, + 0.06528822332620621, + 0.034621428698301315, + 0.26278454065322876, + 0.03627929463982582, + 0.09664596617221832, + 0.0727609246969223 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.038104645907878876 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_0/index_tensor([9828, 9828])_group_0_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_0/index_tensor([9828, 9828])_group_0_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..418c79aa34cc9ca763283e692ed4318316287ba6 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_0/index_tensor([9828, 9828])_group_0_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "slow, majestic drone shot, sweeping in an elegant arc, slowly circles a massive stone Buddha statue carved directly into a towering crimson mountainside. Seated in a lotus position, its massive form almost merges with the mountain. In the golden afterglow of sunset, the weathered stone surface takes on a unique matte texture, reminiscent of the ancient Dunhuang murals. As the camera steadily pans, the Buddha's solemn features gradually reveal themselves: his eyes slightly closed, revealing a deep compassion and introspection. A high nose bridge and full lips frame a serene smile, and a full white hair rests between his brows. The statue's monotonous stone color is not the only hue. Mottled traces of mineral pigments—faded ochre, russet, and a faint turquoise—still linger in the deep folds of the monk's robe and the crevices of his body. These colors appear remarkably soft under the low-angle, warm light, casting long, sharply defined shadows within the carved recesses, dramatically enhancing the statue's three-dimensionality and the sense of its age. The camera hovers steadily, taking in the grandeur of the Buddha statue and the surrounding desolate and magnificent mountain landscape, creating a sacred and peaceful atmosphere that transcends time and space.", + "seed": 19026, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_0/index_9828_seed_19026_dp_0_rank_0_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.1396070856601, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1396070856601, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.45, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1396070856601, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive stone Buddha statue carved directly into a towering crimson mountainside?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the Buddha statue seated in a lotus position with a full white hair resting between his brows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the stone surface show mottled traces of faded ochre, russet, and faint turquoise mineral pigments in the folds and crevices?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, sweeping arc that circles the statue while steadily panning to reveal the face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by the golden afterglow of sunset, casting long, sharply defined shadows within the carved recesses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4292711913585663 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.0542712211608887 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.4292711913585663, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.4292711913585663, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.35760292410850525, + 0.20387938618659973, + 0.04392136260867119, + 0.06704919040203094, + 0.046116046607494354, + 0.038627441972494125, + 0.015935547649860382, + 0.018521400168538094, + 0.14349375665187836, + 0.06485292315483093 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.4292711913585663 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive stone Buddha statue carved directly into a towering crimson mountainside?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the Buddha statue seated in a lotus position with a full white hair resting between his brows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the stone surface show mottled traces of faded ochre, russet, and faint turquoise mineral pigments in the folds and crevices?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, sweeping arc that circles the statue while steadily panning to reveal the face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by the golden afterglow of sunset, casting long, sharply defined shadows within the carved recesses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08905669301748276 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4640567302703857 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08905669301748276, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08905669301748276, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.28431278467178345, + 0.11344330757856369, + 0.11825424432754517, + 0.04921193793416023, + 0.048749662935733795, + 0.05611250549554825, + 0.07550741732120514, + 0.06664948910474777, + 0.1349993497133255, + 0.05275930464267731 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08905669301748276 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive stone Buddha statue carved directly into a towering crimson mountainside?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the Buddha statue seated in a lotus position with a full white hair resting between his brows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the stone surface show mottled traces of faded ochre, russet, and faint turquoise mineral pigments in the folds and crevices?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, sweeping arc that circles the statue while steadily panning to reveal the face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by the golden afterglow of sunset, casting long, sharply defined shadows within the carved recesses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026352928951382637 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651352882385254 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026352928951382637, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026352928951382637, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.38797059655189514, + 0.16367962956428528, + 0.07112980633974075, + 0.09245242923498154, + 0.0626227930188179, + 0.054094456136226654, + 0.05172275751829147, + 0.01914045214653015, + 0.05361747741699219, + 0.04356954246759415 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026352928951382637 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive stone Buddha statue carved directly into a towering crimson mountainside?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the Buddha statue seated in a lotus position with a full white hair resting between his brows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the stone surface show mottled traces of faded ochre, russet, and faint turquoise mineral pigments in the folds and crevices?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, sweeping arc that circles the statue while steadily panning to reveal the face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by the golden afterglow of sunset, casting long, sharply defined shadows within the carved recesses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02633574604988098 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513357162475586 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02633574604988098, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02633574604988098, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25634869933128357, + 0.1665346622467041, + 0.11855624616146088, + 0.03155577555298805, + 0.08201080560684204, + 0.055428728461265564, + 0.05258297547698021, + 0.04687600955367088, + 0.08342640846967697, + 0.10667970031499863 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02633574604988098 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive stone Buddha statue carved directly into a towering crimson mountainside?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the Buddha statue seated in a lotus position with a full white hair resting between his brows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the stone surface show mottled traces of faded ochre, russet, and faint turquoise mineral pigments in the folds and crevices?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, sweeping arc that circles the statue while steadily panning to reveal the face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by the golden afterglow of sunset, casting long, sharply defined shadows within the carved recesses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12701886892318726 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.127018928527832 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12701886892318726, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12701886892318726, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19124571979045868, + 0.17216439545154572, + 0.046740107238292694, + 0.07088368386030197, + 0.060137029737234116, + 0.11102236807346344, + 0.0294936690479517, + 0.06446482986211777, + 0.0764693096280098, + 0.17737892270088196 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12701886892318726 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow, majestic drone shot, sweeping in an elegant arc, slowly circles a massive stone Buddha statue carved directly into a towering crimson mountainside. Seated in a lotus position, its massive form almost merges with the mountain. In the golden afterglow of sunset, the weathered stone surface takes on a unique matte texture, reminiscent of the ancient Dunhuang murals. As the camera steadily pans, the Buddha's solemn features gradually reveal themselves: his eyes slightly closed, revealing a deep compassion and introspection. A high nose bridge and full lips frame a serene smile, and a full white hair rests between his brows. The statue's monotonous stone color is not the only hue. Mottled traces of mineral pigments—faded ochre, russet, and a faint turquoise—still linger in the deep folds of the monk's robe and the crevices of his body. These colors appear remarkably soft under the low-angle, warm light, casting long, sharply defined shadows within the carved recesses, dramatically enhancing the statue's three-dimensionality and the sense of its age. The camera hovers steadily, taking in the grandeur of the Buddha statue and the surrounding desolate and magnificent mountain landscape, creating a sacred and peaceful atmosphere that transcends time and space.", + "seed": 19027, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_0/index_9828_seed_19027_dp_0_rank_0_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.06834587454795837, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06834587454795837, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.925, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06834587454795837, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive stone Buddha statue carved directly into a towering crimson mountainside?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the Buddha statue seated in a lotus position with a full white hair resting between his brows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the stone surface show mottled traces of faded ochre, russet, and faint turquoise mineral pigments in the folds and crevices?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, sweeping arc that circles the statue while steadily panning to reveal the face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by the golden afterglow of sunset, casting long, sharply defined shadows within the carved recesses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03846742585301399 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2884674072265625 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03846742585301399, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03846742585301399, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2879847586154938, + 0.045000720769166946, + 0.10204042494297028, + 0.0717620998620987, + 0.05241287127137184, + 0.022419560700654984, + 0.053742025047540665, + 0.14345841109752655, + 0.09450890123844147, + 0.12667018175125122 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03846742585301399 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive stone Buddha statue carved directly into a towering crimson mountainside?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the Buddha statue seated in a lotus position with a full white hair resting between his brows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the stone surface show mottled traces of faded ochre, russet, and faint turquoise mineral pigments in the folds and crevices?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, sweeping arc that circles the statue while steadily panning to reveal the face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by the golden afterglow of sunset, casting long, sharply defined shadows within the carved recesses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06204559653997421 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120455741882324 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06204559653997421, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06204559653997421, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.30851566791534424, + 0.07945973426103592, + 0.18257169425487518, + 0.05011027678847313, + 0.04993718862533569, + 0.023228535428643227, + 0.022166982293128967, + 0.05690767988562584, + 0.11821042746305466, + 0.10889188945293427 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06204559653997421 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive stone Buddha statue carved directly into a towering crimson mountainside?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the Buddha statue seated in a lotus position with a full white hair resting between his brows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the stone surface show mottled traces of faded ochre, russet, and faint turquoise mineral pigments in the folds and crevices?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, sweeping arc that circles the statue while steadily panning to reveal the face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by the golden afterglow of sunset, casting long, sharply defined shadows within the carved recesses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023288656026124954 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732887268066406 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023288656026124954, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023288656026124954, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16556693613529205, + 0.08485700190067291, + 0.1969202756881714, + 0.04747956246137619, + 0.05705493316054344, + 0.0470925010740757, + 0.06429702788591385, + 0.04763142019510269, + 0.1675282120704651, + 0.1215721145272255 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023288656026124954 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive stone Buddha statue carved directly into a towering crimson mountainside?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the Buddha statue seated in a lotus position with a full white hair resting between his brows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the stone surface show mottled traces of faded ochre, russet, and faint turquoise mineral pigments in the folds and crevices?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, sweeping arc that circles the statue while steadily panning to reveal the face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by the golden afterglow of sunset, casting long, sharply defined shadows within the carved recesses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03808215260505676 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2880821228027344 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03808215260505676, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03808215260505676, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25860247015953064, + 0.10205301642417908, + 0.14321723580360413, + 0.06669135391712189, + 0.029347959905862808, + 0.03480469807982445, + 0.044669877737760544, + 0.04724583402276039, + 0.23109911382198334, + 0.042268384248018265 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03808215260505676 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive stone Buddha statue carved directly into a towering crimson mountainside?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the Buddha statue seated in a lotus position with a full white hair resting between his brows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the stone surface show mottled traces of faded ochre, russet, and faint turquoise mineral pigments in the folds and crevices?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, sweeping arc that circles the statue while steadily panning to reveal the face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by the golden afterglow of sunset, casting long, sharply defined shadows within the carved recesses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17984554171562195 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8048455715179443 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17984554171562195, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17984554171562195, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.32034364342689514, + 0.04387683793902397, + 0.22253857553005219, + 0.06428258866071701, + 0.03106166236102581, + 0.0129641592502594, + 0.020702729001641273, + 0.03954927250742912, + 0.10365346074104309, + 0.14102709293365479 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17984554171562195 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow, majestic drone shot, sweeping in an elegant arc, slowly circles a massive stone Buddha statue carved directly into a towering crimson mountainside. Seated in a lotus position, its massive form almost merges with the mountain. In the golden afterglow of sunset, the weathered stone surface takes on a unique matte texture, reminiscent of the ancient Dunhuang murals. As the camera steadily pans, the Buddha's solemn features gradually reveal themselves: his eyes slightly closed, revealing a deep compassion and introspection. A high nose bridge and full lips frame a serene smile, and a full white hair rests between his brows. The statue's monotonous stone color is not the only hue. Mottled traces of mineral pigments—faded ochre, russet, and a faint turquoise—still linger in the deep folds of the monk's robe and the crevices of his body. These colors appear remarkably soft under the low-angle, warm light, casting long, sharply defined shadows within the carved recesses, dramatically enhancing the statue's three-dimensionality and the sense of its age. The camera hovers steadily, taking in the grandeur of the Buddha statue and the surrounding desolate and magnificent mountain landscape, creating a sacred and peaceful atmosphere that transcends time and space.", + "seed": 19028, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_0/index_9828_seed_19028_dp_1_rank_2_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.030121645890176296, + "vlm_logprob": -0.030121645890176296, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.6, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.030121645890176296, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive stone Buddha statue carved directly into a towering crimson mountainside?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the Buddha statue seated in a lotus position with a full white hair resting between his brows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the stone surface show mottled traces of faded ochre, russet, and faint turquoise mineral pigments in the folds and crevices?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, sweeping arc that circles the statue while steadily panning to reveal the face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by the golden afterglow of sunset, casting long, sharply defined shadows within the carved recesses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04325098916888237 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1682510375976562 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04325098916888237, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04325098916888237, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.35352325439453125, + 0.1341891586780548, + 0.08125957101583481, + 0.05246077477931976, + 0.03527875617146492, + 0.02747351862490177, + 0.10539230704307556, + 0.06062696874141693, + 0.04542543366551399, + 0.10437024384737015 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04325098916888237 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive stone Buddha statue carved directly into a towering crimson mountainside?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the Buddha statue seated in a lotus position with a full white hair resting between his brows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the stone surface show mottled traces of faded ochre, russet, and faint turquoise mineral pigments in the folds and crevices?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, sweeping arc that circles the statue while steadily panning to reveal the face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by the golden afterglow of sunset, casting long, sharply defined shadows within the carved recesses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04865727573633194 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048657178878784 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04865727573633194, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04865727573633194, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2467234581708908, + 0.10265802592039108, + 0.05190407857298851, + 0.03692149370908737, + 0.0677771046757698, + 0.050393689423799515, + 0.11580383777618408, + 0.10950905084609985, + 0.0843290239572525, + 0.13398024439811707 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04865727573633194 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive stone Buddha statue carved directly into a towering crimson mountainside?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the Buddha statue seated in a lotus position with a full white hair resting between his brows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the stone surface show mottled traces of faded ochre, russet, and faint turquoise mineral pigments in the folds and crevices?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, sweeping arc that circles the statue while steadily panning to reveal the face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by the golden afterglow of sunset, casting long, sharply defined shadows within the carved recesses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01818414404988289 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018184185028076 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01818414404988289, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01818414404988289, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3073624074459076, + 0.06832876801490784, + 0.07155401259660721, + 0.05905682593584061, + 0.1461256891489029, + 0.05099058523774147, + 0.06340629607439041, + 0.09594614058732986, + 0.0538015179336071, + 0.08342769742012024 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01818414404988289 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive stone Buddha statue carved directly into a towering crimson mountainside?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the Buddha statue seated in a lotus position with a full white hair resting between his brows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the stone surface show mottled traces of faded ochre, russet, and faint turquoise mineral pigments in the folds and crevices?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, sweeping arc that circles the statue while steadily panning to reveal the face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by the golden afterglow of sunset, casting long, sharply defined shadows within the carved recesses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026331333443522453 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513314247131348 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026331333443522453, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026331333443522453, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06502673774957657, + 0.057778250426054, + 0.06221787631511688, + 0.07747560739517212, + 0.12907613813877106, + 0.09337422996759415, + 0.11473970115184784, + 0.20380708575248718, + 0.07976076751947403, + 0.11674358695745468 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026331333443522453 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive stone Buddha statue carved directly into a towering crimson mountainside?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the Buddha statue seated in a lotus position with a full white hair resting between his brows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the stone surface show mottled traces of faded ochre, russet, and faint turquoise mineral pigments in the folds and crevices?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, sweeping arc that circles the statue while steadily panning to reveal the face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by the golden afterglow of sunset, casting long, sharply defined shadows within the carved recesses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01418448705226183 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264184474945068 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01418448705226183, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01418448705226183, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22798573970794678, + 0.17913416028022766, + 0.15330998599529266, + 0.10253309458494186, + 0.14490172266960144, + 0.02667033113539219, + 0.03563368692994118, + 0.07702760398387909, + 0.0225677527487278, + 0.03023591823875904 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01418448705226183 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow, majestic drone shot, sweeping in an elegant arc, slowly circles a massive stone Buddha statue carved directly into a towering crimson mountainside. Seated in a lotus position, its massive form almost merges with the mountain. In the golden afterglow of sunset, the weathered stone surface takes on a unique matte texture, reminiscent of the ancient Dunhuang murals. As the camera steadily pans, the Buddha's solemn features gradually reveal themselves: his eyes slightly closed, revealing a deep compassion and introspection. A high nose bridge and full lips frame a serene smile, and a full white hair rests between his brows. The statue's monotonous stone color is not the only hue. Mottled traces of mineral pigments—faded ochre, russet, and a faint turquoise—still linger in the deep folds of the monk's robe and the crevices of his body. These colors appear remarkably soft under the low-angle, warm light, casting long, sharply defined shadows within the carved recesses, dramatically enhancing the statue's three-dimensionality and the sense of its age. The camera hovers steadily, taking in the grandeur of the Buddha statue and the surrounding desolate and magnificent mountain landscape, creating a sacred and peaceful atmosphere that transcends time and space.", + "seed": 19029, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_0/index_9828_seed_19029_dp_1_rank_2_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.028786712139844895, + "vlm_logprob": -0.028786712139844895, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.724999952316284, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.028786712139844895, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive stone Buddha statue carved directly into a towering crimson mountainside?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the Buddha statue seated in a lotus position with a full white hair resting between his brows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the stone surface show mottled traces of faded ochre, russet, and faint turquoise mineral pigments in the folds and crevices?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, sweeping arc that circles the statue while steadily panning to reveal the face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by the golden afterglow of sunset, casting long, sharply defined shadows within the carved recesses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.055556654930114746 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9305567741394043 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.055556654930114746, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.055556654930114746, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19595366716384888, + 0.06763368844985962, + 0.10463443398475647, + 0.07425107806921005, + 0.02102663926780224, + 0.024472801014780998, + 0.04761296883225441, + 0.03544868156313896, + 0.0451328419148922, + 0.38383322954177856 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.055556654930114746 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive stone Buddha statue carved directly into a towering crimson mountainside?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the Buddha statue seated in a lotus position with a full white hair resting between his brows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the stone surface show mottled traces of faded ochre, russet, and faint turquoise mineral pigments in the folds and crevices?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, sweeping arc that circles the statue while steadily panning to reveal the face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by the golden afterglow of sunset, casting long, sharply defined shadows within the carved recesses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04306728392839432 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168067216873169 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04306728392839432, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04306728392839432, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0838296189904213, + 0.07137323170900345, + 0.03430505469441414, + 0.1868603527545929, + 0.03665678948163986, + 0.04201940447092056, + 0.04098665714263916, + 0.07655177265405655, + 0.0856233537197113, + 0.3417937159538269 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 3, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04306728392839432 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive stone Buddha statue carved directly into a towering crimson mountainside?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the Buddha statue seated in a lotus position with a full white hair resting between his brows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the stone surface show mottled traces of faded ochre, russet, and faint turquoise mineral pigments in the folds and crevices?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, sweeping arc that circles the statue while steadily panning to reveal the face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by the golden afterglow of sunset, casting long, sharply defined shadows within the carved recesses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016067897900938988 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141067981719971 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016067897900938988, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016067897900938988, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25873464345932007, + 0.09295512735843658, + 0.029620226472616196, + 0.09783336520195007, + 0.07290533185005188, + 0.09479711949825287, + 0.023460905998945236, + 0.07156411558389664, + 0.0659402385354042, + 0.19218896329402924 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016067897900938988 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive stone Buddha statue carved directly into a towering crimson mountainside?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the Buddha statue seated in a lotus position with a full white hair resting between his brows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the stone surface show mottled traces of faded ochre, russet, and faint turquoise mineral pigments in the folds and crevices?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, sweeping arc that circles the statue while steadily panning to reveal the face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by the golden afterglow of sunset, casting long, sharply defined shadows within the carved recesses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018176767975091934 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018176555633545 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018176767975091934, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018176767975091934, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4164682924747467, + 0.23225723206996918, + 0.023247558623552322, + 0.053891345858573914, + 0.0694597065448761, + 0.03470969200134277, + 0.03391813859343529, + 0.021220345050096512, + 0.07598233968019485, + 0.03884534910321236 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018176767975091934 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive stone Buddha statue carved directly into a towering crimson mountainside?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the Buddha statue seated in a lotus position with a full white hair resting between his brows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the stone surface show mottled traces of faded ochre, russet, and faint turquoise mineral pigments in the folds and crevices?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, sweeping arc that circles the statue while steadily panning to reveal the face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by the golden afterglow of sunset, casting long, sharply defined shadows within the carved recesses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011064955964684486 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.5110650062561035 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011064955964684486, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011064955964684486, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13419580459594727, + 0.19997763633728027, + 0.2940790057182312, + 0.07947669923305511, + 0.022740863263607025, + 0.04928096756339073, + 0.014149106107652187, + 0.030872365459799767, + 0.04065720736980438, + 0.1345703899860382 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011064955964684486 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_1/index_tensor([7647, 7647])_group_1_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_1/index_tensor([7647, 7647])_group_1_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..3bc45ae6a797e2770651f002b245a3f47f633da0 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_1/index_tensor([7647, 7647])_group_1_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "static, eye-level, full-body shot establishes a scene of profound tranquility, styled with calm and concentration, within a minimalist dojo. In the center of the frame, a practitioner, her long black hair neatly tied back, wears loose, flowing off-white silk garments that ripple with their every movement. The dojo's floor, crafted from highly polished, light-colored wood, perfectly reflects the soft, golden glow of early morning sunlight streaming through a large shoji paper screen window closed to the camera. This diffuse light casts long, soft shadows that stretch across the floor and brightly illuminates countless motes dancing in the air, creating an atmosphere of intimacy and introspection. With expressions of focused calm, the practitioners move deliberately in a continuous, circular pattern, their feet gliding across the polished surface. Their bodies turn fluidly from the waist, guiding their arms in a seamless, serpentine motion as their open palms constantly change direction, carving into the air as if in a silent and graceful dialogue with an unseen force.", + "seed": 28568, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_1/index_7647_seed_28568_dp_2_rank_4_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.028140437509864568, + "vlm_logprob": -0.028140437509864568, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.075, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.028140437509864568, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a minimalist dojo with a highly polished, light-colored wooden floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the practitioner wearing loose, flowing off-white silk garments with long black hair tied back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show soft, golden sunlight streaming through a large shoji paper screen window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the practitioners moving in a continuous, circular pattern with fluid, serpentine arm motions?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static, eye-level, and full-body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009132045321166515 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.884131908416748 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009132045321166515, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009132045321166515, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1088344156742096, + 0.09128008037805557, + 0.038315605372190475, + 0.17744320631027222, + 0.2666245400905609, + 0.033487554639577866, + 0.07153724133968353, + 0.021005047485232353, + 0.13731954991817474, + 0.05415276810526848 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009132045321166515 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a minimalist dojo with a highly polished, light-colored wooden floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the practitioner wearing loose, flowing off-white silk garments with long black hair tied back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show soft, golden sunlight streaming through a large shoji paper screen window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the practitioners moving in a continuous, circular pattern with fluid, serpentine arm motions?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static, eye-level, and full-body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008656359277665615 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.7586565017700195 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008656359277665615, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008656359277665615, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07944346219301224, + 0.07817655056715012, + 0.027327748015522957, + 0.05211392417550087, + 0.36448079347610474, + 0.03486565127968788, + 0.03885423764586449, + 0.07079944759607315, + 0.1379604935646057, + 0.11597767472267151 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008656359277665615 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a minimalist dojo with a highly polished, light-colored wooden floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the practitioner wearing loose, flowing off-white silk garments with long black hair tied back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show soft, golden sunlight streaming through a large shoji paper screen window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the practitioners moving in a continuous, circular pattern with fluid, serpentine arm motions?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static, eye-level, and full-body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005948459263890982 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130948543548584 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005948459263890982, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005948459263890982, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14164836704730988, + 0.13712958991527557, + 0.14649152755737305, + 0.07866695523262024, + 0.17811404168605804, + 0.06817729026079178, + 0.021570676937699318, + 0.03442908823490143, + 0.07755160331726074, + 0.11622082442045212 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005948459263890982 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a minimalist dojo with a highly polished, light-colored wooden floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the practitioner wearing loose, flowing off-white silk garments with long black hair tied back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show soft, golden sunlight streaming through a large shoji paper screen window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the practitioners moving in a continuous, circular pattern with fluid, serpentine arm motions?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static, eye-level, and full-body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.054945383220911026 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929945468902588 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.054945383220911026, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.054945383220911026, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0815451368689537, + 0.07529802620410919, + 0.017620129510760307, + 0.08709096163511276, + 0.17132361233234406, + 0.029262110590934753, + 0.02397296577692032, + 0.03760392218828201, + 0.11190539598464966, + 0.3643777072429657 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.054945383220911026 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a minimalist dojo with a highly polished, light-colored wooden floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the practitioner wearing loose, flowing off-white silk garments with long black hair tied back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show soft, golden sunlight streaming through a large shoji paper screen window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the practitioners moving in a continuous, circular pattern with fluid, serpentine arm motions?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static, eye-level, and full-body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.062019940465688705 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120198249816895 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.062019940465688705, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.062019940465688705, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08958983421325684, + 0.036599673330783844, + 0.052293431013822556, + 0.04775698855519295, + 0.15043123066425323, + 0.09178373962640762, + 0.05338120087981224, + 0.02172890678048134, + 0.15496258437633514, + 0.30147236585617065 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.062019940465688705 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, eye-level, full-body shot establishes a scene of profound tranquility, styled with calm and concentration, within a minimalist dojo. In the center of the frame, a practitioner, her long black hair neatly tied back, wears loose, flowing off-white silk garments that ripple with their every movement. The dojo's floor, crafted from highly polished, light-colored wood, perfectly reflects the soft, golden glow of early morning sunlight streaming through a large shoji paper screen window closed to the camera. This diffuse light casts long, soft shadows that stretch across the floor and brightly illuminates countless motes dancing in the air, creating an atmosphere of intimacy and introspection. With expressions of focused calm, the practitioners move deliberately in a continuous, circular pattern, their feet gliding across the polished surface. Their bodies turn fluidly from the waist, guiding their arms in a seamless, serpentine motion as their open palms constantly change direction, carving into the air as if in a silent and graceful dialogue with an unseen force.", + "seed": 28569, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_1/index_7647_seed_28569_dp_2_rank_4_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.05300272684544325, + "vlm_logprob": -0.05300272684544325, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.4, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.05300272684544325, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a minimalist dojo with a highly polished, light-colored wooden floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the practitioner wearing loose, flowing off-white silk garments with long black hair tied back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show soft, golden sunlight streaming through a large shoji paper screen window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the practitioners moving in a continuous, circular pattern with fluid, serpentine arm motions?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static, eye-level, and full-body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05176003277301788 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.051759958267212 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05176003277301788, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05176003277301788, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.28643661737442017, + 0.05378091707825661, + 0.04158672317862511, + 0.18258056044578552, + 0.02518797107040882, + 0.11135748028755188, + 0.03446393460035324, + 0.15257996320724487, + 0.05392588675022125, + 0.05809996277093887 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05176003277301788 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a minimalist dojo with a highly polished, light-colored wooden floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the practitioner wearing loose, flowing off-white silk garments with long black hair tied back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show soft, golden sunlight streaming through a large shoji paper screen window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the practitioners moving in a continuous, circular pattern with fluid, serpentine arm motions?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static, eye-level, and full-body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016097459942102432 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141097545623779 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016097459942102432, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016097459942102432, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04833827167749405, + 0.028517894446849823, + 0.06738752126693726, + 0.5214921236038208, + 0.03423890843987465, + 0.0889413058757782, + 0.06005631014704704, + 0.08259658515453339, + 0.04205309599637985, + 0.026378007605671883 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016097459942102432 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a minimalist dojo with a highly polished, light-colored wooden floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the practitioner wearing loose, flowing off-white silk garments with long black hair tied back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show soft, golden sunlight streaming through a large shoji paper screen window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the practitioners moving in a continuous, circular pattern with fluid, serpentine arm motions?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static, eye-level, and full-body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005253794603049755 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255253791809082 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005253794603049755, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005253794603049755, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14044189453125, + 0.052711326628923416, + 0.053985998034477234, + 0.169244185090065, + 0.029798176139593124, + 0.12418277561664581, + 0.10864736884832382, + 0.1943574696779251, + 0.08669433742761612, + 0.03993644937872887 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005253794603049755 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a minimalist dojo with a highly polished, light-colored wooden floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the practitioner wearing loose, flowing off-white silk garments with long black hair tied back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show soft, golden sunlight streaming through a large shoji paper screen window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the practitioners moving in a continuous, circular pattern with fluid, serpentine arm motions?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static, eye-level, and full-body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11293405294418335 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.237934112548828 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11293405294418335, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11293405294418335, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11684421449899673, + 0.03403697907924652, + 0.038741953670978546, + 0.2508997619152069, + 0.009785335510969162, + 0.20701941847801208, + 0.08001847565174103, + 0.13665449619293213, + 0.10117165744304657, + 0.02482764422893524 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11293405294418335 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a minimalist dojo with a highly polished, light-colored wooden floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the practitioner wearing loose, flowing off-white silk garments with long black hair tied back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show soft, golden sunlight streaming through a large shoji paper screen window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the practitioners moving in a continuous, circular pattern with fluid, serpentine arm motions?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static, eye-level, and full-body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07896829396486282 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5789682865142822 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07896829396486282, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07896829396486282, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06658808887004852, + 0.055686116218566895, + 0.041003428399562836, + 0.45739665627479553, + 0.02042675018310547, + 0.10901141166687012, + 0.026527266949415207, + 0.07199476659297943, + 0.06356777250766754, + 0.08779771625995636 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07896829396486282 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, eye-level, full-body shot establishes a scene of profound tranquility, styled with calm and concentration, within a minimalist dojo. In the center of the frame, a practitioner, her long black hair neatly tied back, wears loose, flowing off-white silk garments that ripple with their every movement. The dojo's floor, crafted from highly polished, light-colored wood, perfectly reflects the soft, golden glow of early morning sunlight streaming through a large shoji paper screen window closed to the camera. This diffuse light casts long, soft shadows that stretch across the floor and brightly illuminates countless motes dancing in the air, creating an atmosphere of intimacy and introspection. With expressions of focused calm, the practitioners move deliberately in a continuous, circular pattern, their feet gliding across the polished surface. Their bodies turn fluidly from the waist, guiding their arms in a seamless, serpentine motion as their open palms constantly change direction, carving into the air as if in a silent and graceful dialogue with an unseen force.", + "seed": 28570, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_1/index_7647_seed_28570_dp_3_rank_6_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.05776293640956283, + "vlm_logprob": -0.05776293640956283, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.525, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.05776293640956283, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a minimalist dojo with a highly polished, light-colored wooden floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the practitioner wearing loose, flowing off-white silk garments with long black hair tied back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show soft, golden sunlight streaming through a large shoji paper screen window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the practitioners moving in a continuous, circular pattern with fluid, serpentine arm motions?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static, eye-level, and full-body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07210366427898407 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.69710373878479 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07210366427898407, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07210366427898407, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08063900470733643, + 0.0947996973991394, + 0.19903171062469482, + 0.11930960416793823, + 0.02498512901365757, + 0.010772207751870155, + 0.12478780001401901, + 0.058814119547605515, + 0.14611327648162842, + 0.14074744284152985 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07210366427898407 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a minimalist dojo with a highly polished, light-colored wooden floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the practitioner wearing loose, flowing off-white silk garments with long black hair tied back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show soft, golden sunlight streaming through a large shoji paper screen window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the practitioners moving in a continuous, circular pattern with fluid, serpentine arm motions?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static, eye-level, and full-body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00866604968905449 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758666038513184 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00866604968905449, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00866604968905449, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03181900456547737, + 0.06319239735603333, + 0.04596377909183502, + 0.032589539885520935, + 0.03935166075825691, + 0.03804725781083107, + 0.10525686293840408, + 0.09551386535167694, + 0.0866941586136818, + 0.46157148480415344 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00866604968905449 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a minimalist dojo with a highly polished, light-colored wooden floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the practitioner wearing loose, flowing off-white silk garments with long black hair tied back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show soft, golden sunlight streaming through a large shoji paper screen window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the practitioners moving in a continuous, circular pattern with fluid, serpentine arm motions?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static, eye-level, and full-body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00463838828727603 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379638195037842 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00463838828727603, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00463838828727603, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08976073563098907, + 0.13316720724105835, + 0.07255452871322632, + 0.19789831340312958, + 0.03115835413336754, + 0.022041765972971916, + 0.05187715217471123, + 0.07947812974452972, + 0.04149647429585457, + 0.28056731820106506 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00463838828727603 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a minimalist dojo with a highly polished, light-colored wooden floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the practitioner wearing loose, flowing off-white silk garments with long black hair tied back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show soft, golden sunlight streaming through a large shoji paper screen window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the practitioners moving in a continuous, circular pattern with fluid, serpentine arm motions?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static, eye-level, and full-body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.043061114847660065 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680610179901123 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.043061114847660065, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.043061114847660065, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06044473126530647, + 0.03786667063832283, + 0.19417007267475128, + 0.04575413838028908, + 0.027887945994734764, + 0.10208927094936371, + 0.02712070755660534, + 0.1168191060423851, + 0.05099449306726456, + 0.3368528187274933 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 2, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.043061114847660065 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a minimalist dojo with a highly polished, light-colored wooden floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the practitioner wearing loose, flowing off-white silk garments with long black hair tied back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show soft, golden sunlight streaming through a large shoji paper screen window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the practitioners moving in a continuous, circular pattern with fluid, serpentine arm motions?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static, eye-level, and full-body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16034546494483948 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.910345435142517 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16034546494483948, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16034546494483948, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06131069362163544, + 0.06115993857383728, + 0.1169070303440094, + 0.035330213606357574, + 0.06389681994915009, + 0.08606184273958206, + 0.19503220915794373, + 0.1975504457950592, + 0.09054446220397949, + 0.09220638126134872 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16034546494483948 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, eye-level, full-body shot establishes a scene of profound tranquility, styled with calm and concentration, within a minimalist dojo. In the center of the frame, a practitioner, her long black hair neatly tied back, wears loose, flowing off-white silk garments that ripple with their every movement. The dojo's floor, crafted from highly polished, light-colored wood, perfectly reflects the soft, golden glow of early morning sunlight streaming through a large shoji paper screen window closed to the camera. This diffuse light casts long, soft shadows that stretch across the floor and brightly illuminates countless motes dancing in the air, creating an atmosphere of intimacy and introspection. With expressions of focused calm, the practitioners move deliberately in a continuous, circular pattern, their feet gliding across the polished surface. Their bodies turn fluidly from the waist, guiding their arms in a seamless, serpentine motion as their open palms constantly change direction, carving into the air as if in a silent and graceful dialogue with an unseen force.", + "seed": 28571, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_1/index_7647_seed_28571_dp_3_rank_6_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.0817933740094304, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0817933740094304, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.25, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0817933740094304, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a minimalist dojo with a highly polished, light-colored wooden floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the practitioner wearing loose, flowing off-white silk garments with long black hair tied back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show soft, golden sunlight streaming through a large shoji paper screen window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the practitioners moving in a continuous, circular pattern with fluid, serpentine arm motions?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static, eye-level, and full-body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023989880457520485 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7739899158477783 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023989880457520485, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023989880457520485, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1099599152803421, + 0.24415741860866547, + 0.08359096944332123, + 0.14557678997516632, + 0.06673786789178848, + 0.10646049678325653, + 0.04984458535909653, + 0.03420308977365494, + 0.030175836756825447, + 0.1292930543422699 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023989880457520485 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a minimalist dojo with a highly polished, light-colored wooden floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the practitioner wearing loose, flowing off-white silk garments with long black hair tied back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show soft, golden sunlight streaming through a large shoji paper screen window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the practitioners moving in a continuous, circular pattern with fluid, serpentine arm motions?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static, eye-level, and full-body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020601926371455193 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895601987838745 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020601926371455193, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020601926371455193, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08388111740350723, + 0.21819354593753815, + 0.17395220696926117, + 0.07047349959611893, + 0.043287888169288635, + 0.14452578127384186, + 0.049684908241033554, + 0.09261420369148254, + 0.08600830286741257, + 0.03737858682870865 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020601926371455193 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a minimalist dojo with a highly polished, light-colored wooden floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the practitioner wearing loose, flowing off-white silk garments with long black hair tied back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show soft, golden sunlight streaming through a large shoji paper screen window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the practitioners moving in a continuous, circular pattern with fluid, serpentine arm motions?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static, eye-level, and full-body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004636489786207676 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379636287689209 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004636489786207676, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004636489786207676, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10786054283380508, + 0.4177957773208618, + 0.06846630573272705, + 0.09031690657138824, + 0.03749623894691467, + 0.09044971317052841, + 0.06238394230604172, + 0.04708624258637428, + 0.028198344632983208, + 0.04994599148631096 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004636489786207676 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a minimalist dojo with a highly polished, light-colored wooden floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the practitioner wearing loose, flowing off-white silk garments with long black hair tied back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show soft, golden sunlight streaming through a large shoji paper screen window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the practitioners moving in a continuous, circular pattern with fluid, serpentine arm motions?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static, eye-level, and full-body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17986644804477692 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8048664331436157 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17986644804477692, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17986644804477692, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11367791146039963, + 0.3365171253681183, + 0.08563321083784103, + 0.1032572090625763, + 0.05730169266462326, + 0.020410964265465736, + 0.08282138407230377, + 0.05767679959535599, + 0.04909025877714157, + 0.09361344575881958 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17986644804477692 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a minimalist dojo with a highly polished, light-colored wooden floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the practitioner wearing loose, flowing off-white silk garments with long black hair tied back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show soft, golden sunlight streaming through a large shoji paper screen window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the practitioners moving in a continuous, circular pattern with fluid, serpentine arm motions?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static, eye-level, and full-body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17987212538719177 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8048721551895142 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17987212538719177, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17987212538719177, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08922963589429855, + 0.4006844460964203, + 0.044846709817647934, + 0.12891355156898499, + 0.049347374588251114, + 0.03681802377104759, + 0.10115405917167664, + 0.05570043995976448, + 0.06495951861143112, + 0.0283462256193161 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 3, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17987212538719177 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_10/index_tensor([6743, 6743])_group_10_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_10/index_tensor([6743, 6743])_group_10_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..e11ee770f97e524876e55ee25950091704362d11 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_10/index_tensor([6743, 6743])_group_10_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "dynamic, low-angle drone shot captures a tightly knit group of professional cyclists accelerating down a winding country road, the camera gliding smoothly to keep pace with the lead rider and emphasize their speed. The cyclists, wearing skin-tight jerseys in a range of vibrant, saturated colors like electric blue, neon yellow, and fiery red, hunch low in an aggressive, aerodynamic stance, perched atop the drop bars of their sleek carbon fiber racing bikes. Their legs beat in a powerful, synchronized rhythm, and blurs of motion propel them forward as they lean into a sweeping bend in perfect unison. The road itself is a smooth, dark ribbon of asphalt, carving sinuous curves through a breathtaking landscape of winding, lush green hills beneath a clear blue sky. The entire scene is bathed in the warm golden rays of the afternoon sun, which gleams off the polished bicycle frames and casts long, dramatic shadows that race alongside the bikes, creating an exhilarating atmosphere of speed, focus, and competition as the pack moves like a single, fluid organism against a serene, verdant backdrop.", + "seed": 3159, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_10/index_6743_seed_3159_dp_20_rank_40_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.06002636826597154, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06002636826597154, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.549999976158142, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06002636826597154, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a low-angle drone perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are professional cyclists wearing skin-tight jerseys in vibrant colors like electric blue, neon yellow, or fiery red?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the cyclists hunched in an aggressive, aerodynamic stance on drop bars of carbon fiber bikes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a winding country road with lush green hills under a clear blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera glide smoothly to keep pace with the lead rider while the cyclists accelerate into a sweeping bend?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17712460458278656 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.052124500274658 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17712460458278656, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.8749998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17712460458278656, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15564577281475067, + 0.07293540984392166, + 0.04443313181400299, + 0.2511236071586609, + 0.12414858490228653, + 0.11688646674156189, + 0.12405093759298325, + 0.040363531559705734, + 0.033515118062496185, + 0.036897387355566025 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17712460458278656 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a low-angle drone perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are professional cyclists wearing skin-tight jerseys in vibrant colors like electric blue, neon yellow, or fiery red?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the cyclists hunched in an aggressive, aerodynamic stance on drop bars of carbon fiber bikes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a winding country road with lush green hills under a clear blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera glide smoothly to keep pace with the lead rider while the cyclists accelerate into a sweeping bend?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07005449384450912 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695054531097412 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07005449384450912, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07005449384450912, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09111020714044571, + 0.09640999138355255, + 0.33144599199295044, + 0.23572441935539246, + 0.056697484105825424, + 0.038818515837192535, + 0.04768100008368492, + 0.04517466574907303, + 0.02902841754257679, + 0.02790924720466137 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07005449384450912 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a low-angle drone perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are professional cyclists wearing skin-tight jerseys in vibrant colors like electric blue, neon yellow, or fiery red?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the cyclists hunched in an aggressive, aerodynamic stance on drop bars of carbon fiber bikes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a winding country road with lush green hills under a clear blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera glide smoothly to keep pace with the lead rider while the cyclists accelerate into a sweeping bend?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03370098024606705 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408700942993164 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03370098024606705, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03370098024606705, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13075898587703705, + 0.16926147043704987, + 0.03782781958580017, + 0.31011319160461426, + 0.07120242714881897, + 0.059140484780073166, + 0.06660488247871399, + 0.03958309814333916, + 0.06106209382414818, + 0.05444556847214699 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03370098024606705 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a low-angle drone perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are professional cyclists wearing skin-tight jerseys in vibrant colors like electric blue, neon yellow, or fiery red?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the cyclists hunched in an aggressive, aerodynamic stance on drop bars of carbon fiber bikes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a winding country road with lush green hills under a clear blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera glide smoothly to keep pace with the lead rider while the cyclists accelerate into a sweeping bend?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003190667135640979 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753190517425537 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003190667135640979, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003190667135640979, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1184597760438919, + 0.14554782211780548, + 0.06830663979053497, + 0.09906848520040512, + 0.14329777657985687, + 0.09210760146379471, + 0.11590398848056793, + 0.08635659515857697, + 0.06168769672513008, + 0.06926366686820984 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003190667135640979 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a low-angle drone perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are professional cyclists wearing skin-tight jerseys in vibrant colors like electric blue, neon yellow, or fiery red?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the cyclists hunched in an aggressive, aerodynamic stance on drop bars of carbon fiber bikes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a winding country road with lush green hills under a clear blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera glide smoothly to keep pace with the lead rider while the cyclists accelerate into a sweeping bend?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016061095520853996 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141061305999756 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016061095520853996, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016061095520853996, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09086322039365768, + 0.19464851915836334, + 0.08678261935710907, + 0.1790115088224411, + 0.0678485706448555, + 0.06286635994911194, + 0.1428970992565155, + 0.06558039039373398, + 0.039548151195049286, + 0.06995358318090439 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 3, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016061095520853996 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dynamic, low-angle drone shot captures a tightly knit group of professional cyclists accelerating down a winding country road, the camera gliding smoothly to keep pace with the lead rider and emphasize their speed. The cyclists, wearing skin-tight jerseys in a range of vibrant, saturated colors like electric blue, neon yellow, and fiery red, hunch low in an aggressive, aerodynamic stance, perched atop the drop bars of their sleek carbon fiber racing bikes. Their legs beat in a powerful, synchronized rhythm, and blurs of motion propel them forward as they lean into a sweeping bend in perfect unison. The road itself is a smooth, dark ribbon of asphalt, carving sinuous curves through a breathtaking landscape of winding, lush green hills beneath a clear blue sky. The entire scene is bathed in the warm golden rays of the afternoon sun, which gleams off the polished bicycle frames and casts long, dramatic shadows that race alongside the bikes, creating an exhilarating atmosphere of speed, focus, and competition as the pack moves like a single, fluid organism against a serene, verdant backdrop.", + "seed": 3160, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_10/index_6743_seed_3160_dp_20_rank_40_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.15129805095493792, + "vlm_logprob": -0.15129805095493792, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.924999988079071, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.15129805095493792, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a low-angle drone perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are professional cyclists wearing skin-tight jerseys in vibrant colors like electric blue, neon yellow, or fiery red?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the cyclists hunched in an aggressive, aerodynamic stance on drop bars of carbon fiber bikes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a winding country road with lush green hills under a clear blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera glide smoothly to keep pace with the lead rider while the cyclists accelerate into a sweeping bend?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3024548590183258 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4274548292160034 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3024548590183258, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3024548590183258, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16784456372261047, + 0.0581170879304409, + 0.04428820684552193, + 0.242242231965065, + 0.11300177127122879, + 0.18614694476127625, + 0.11152277886867523, + 0.02204788103699684, + 0.032563067972660065, + 0.022225547581911087 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3024548590183258 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a low-angle drone perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are professional cyclists wearing skin-tight jerseys in vibrant colors like electric blue, neon yellow, or fiery red?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the cyclists hunched in an aggressive, aerodynamic stance on drop bars of carbon fiber bikes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a winding country road with lush green hills under a clear blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera glide smoothly to keep pace with the lead rider while the cyclists accelerate into a sweeping bend?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3870864510536194 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1370863914489746 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3870864510536194, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.7499999403953552, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3870864510536194, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.317583829164505, + 0.05505478009581566, + 0.06129083409905434, + 0.09421148151159286, + 0.04035719856619835, + 0.08864744752645493, + 0.08292324841022491, + 0.17170318961143494, + 0.04764045402407646, + 0.04058758541941643 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3870864510536194 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a low-angle drone perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are professional cyclists wearing skin-tight jerseys in vibrant colors like electric blue, neon yellow, or fiery red?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the cyclists hunched in an aggressive, aerodynamic stance on drop bars of carbon fiber bikes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a winding country road with lush green hills under a clear blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera glide smoothly to keep pace with the lead rider while the cyclists accelerate into a sweeping bend?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.048662614077329636 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486626625061035 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.048662614077329636, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.048662614077329636, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16947463154792786, + 0.04361790418624878, + 0.06591065227985382, + 0.06705771386623383, + 0.13983376324176788, + 0.11252212524414062, + 0.09270234405994415, + 0.17964638769626617, + 0.061773281544446945, + 0.06746124476194382 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.048662614077329636 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a low-angle drone perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are professional cyclists wearing skin-tight jerseys in vibrant colors like electric blue, neon yellow, or fiery red?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the cyclists hunched in an aggressive, aerodynamic stance on drop bars of carbon fiber bikes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a winding country road with lush green hills under a clear blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera glide smoothly to keep pace with the lead rider while the cyclists accelerate into a sweeping bend?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004095026291906834 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504095077514648 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004095026291906834, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004095026291906834, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1133570447564125, + 0.04977984353899956, + 0.14422640204429626, + 0.04183942824602127, + 0.15562312304973602, + 0.022879980504512787, + 0.0533425398170948, + 0.33215460181236267, + 0.06013918295502663, + 0.02665785700082779 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004095026291906834 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a low-angle drone perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are professional cyclists wearing skin-tight jerseys in vibrant colors like electric blue, neon yellow, or fiery red?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the cyclists hunched in an aggressive, aerodynamic stance on drop bars of carbon fiber bikes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a winding country road with lush green hills under a clear blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera glide smoothly to keep pace with the lead rider while the cyclists accelerate into a sweeping bend?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014191304333508015 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264191150665283 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014191304333508015, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014191304333508015, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0922623723745346, + 0.04770372807979584, + 0.04980390891432762, + 0.20976009964942932, + 0.1039368286728859, + 0.0782451406121254, + 0.03139340505003929, + 0.34735989570617676, + 0.01625666953623295, + 0.02327791415154934 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014191304333508015 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dynamic, low-angle drone shot captures a tightly knit group of professional cyclists accelerating down a winding country road, the camera gliding smoothly to keep pace with the lead rider and emphasize their speed. The cyclists, wearing skin-tight jerseys in a range of vibrant, saturated colors like electric blue, neon yellow, and fiery red, hunch low in an aggressive, aerodynamic stance, perched atop the drop bars of their sleek carbon fiber racing bikes. Their legs beat in a powerful, synchronized rhythm, and blurs of motion propel them forward as they lean into a sweeping bend in perfect unison. The road itself is a smooth, dark ribbon of asphalt, carving sinuous curves through a breathtaking landscape of winding, lush green hills beneath a clear blue sky. The entire scene is bathed in the warm golden rays of the afternoon sun, which gleams off the polished bicycle frames and casts long, dramatic shadows that race alongside the bikes, creating an exhilarating atmosphere of speed, focus, and competition as the pack moves like a single, fluid organism against a serene, verdant backdrop.", + "seed": 3161, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_10/index_6743_seed_3161_dp_21_rank_42_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.06685810405761003, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06685810405761003, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.8, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06685810405761003, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a low-angle drone perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are professional cyclists wearing skin-tight jerseys in vibrant colors like electric blue, neon yellow, or fiery red?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the cyclists hunched in an aggressive, aerodynamic stance on drop bars of carbon fiber bikes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a winding country road with lush green hills under a clear blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera glide smoothly to keep pace with the lead rider while the cyclists accelerate into a sweeping bend?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.24808846414089203 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6230884790420532 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.24808846414089203, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.24808846414089203, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09783260524272919, + 0.33210259675979614, + 0.13129670917987823, + 0.07699008285999298, + 0.06685006618499756, + 0.1101955771446228, + 0.03382154926657677, + 0.07690980285406113, + 0.044721800833940506, + 0.029279204085469246 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.24808846414089203 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a low-angle drone perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are professional cyclists wearing skin-tight jerseys in vibrant colors like electric blue, neon yellow, or fiery red?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the cyclists hunched in an aggressive, aerodynamic stance on drop bars of carbon fiber bikes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a winding country road with lush green hills under a clear blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera glide smoothly to keep pace with the lead rider while the cyclists accelerate into a sweeping bend?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.054999541491270065 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929999589920044 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.054999541491270065, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.054999541491270065, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07041031867265701, + 0.20140457153320312, + 0.4456881880760193, + 0.09799835085868835, + 0.07107461988925934, + 0.04829724133014679, + 0.0059488085098564625, + 0.03836408257484436, + 0.007745373994112015, + 0.013068456202745438 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.054999541491270065 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a low-angle drone perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are professional cyclists wearing skin-tight jerseys in vibrant colors like electric blue, neon yellow, or fiery red?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the cyclists hunched in an aggressive, aerodynamic stance on drop bars of carbon fiber bikes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a winding country road with lush green hills under a clear blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera glide smoothly to keep pace with the lead rider while the cyclists accelerate into a sweeping bend?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018191400915384293 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018191337585449 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018191400915384293, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018191400915384293, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06206078082323074, + 0.26513007283210754, + 0.4569028317928314, + 0.0670677125453949, + 0.013376278802752495, + 0.03792419284582138, + 0.011348732747137547, + 0.06276128441095352, + 0.008292775601148605, + 0.01513533852994442 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018191400915384293 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a low-angle drone perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are professional cyclists wearing skin-tight jerseys in vibrant colors like electric blue, neon yellow, or fiery red?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the cyclists hunched in an aggressive, aerodynamic stance on drop bars of carbon fiber bikes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a winding country road with lush green hills under a clear blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera glide smoothly to keep pace with the lead rider while the cyclists accelerate into a sweeping bend?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.001939084380865097 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.251939296722412 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.001939084380865097, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.001939084380865097, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09613319486379623, + 0.45035576820373535, + 0.2286357879638672, + 0.0738338753581047, + 0.019681822508573532, + 0.030686527490615845, + 0.022693265229463577, + 0.022506406530737877, + 0.02668931521475315, + 0.02878396585583687 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.001939084380865097 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a low-angle drone perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are professional cyclists wearing skin-tight jerseys in vibrant colors like electric blue, neon yellow, or fiery red?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the cyclists hunched in an aggressive, aerodynamic stance on drop bars of carbon fiber bikes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a winding country road with lush green hills under a clear blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera glide smoothly to keep pace with the lead rider while the cyclists accelerate into a sweeping bend?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011072029359638691 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511072158813477 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011072029359638691, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011072029359638691, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06296664476394653, + 0.5696882009506226, + 0.06816079467535019, + 0.049121271818876266, + 0.046079620718955994, + 0.04624257981777191, + 0.02019762434065342, + 0.08861495554447174, + 0.024540076032280922, + 0.0243882667273283 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 7, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011072029359638691 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dynamic, low-angle drone shot captures a tightly knit group of professional cyclists accelerating down a winding country road, the camera gliding smoothly to keep pace with the lead rider and emphasize their speed. The cyclists, wearing skin-tight jerseys in a range of vibrant, saturated colors like electric blue, neon yellow, and fiery red, hunch low in an aggressive, aerodynamic stance, perched atop the drop bars of their sleek carbon fiber racing bikes. Their legs beat in a powerful, synchronized rhythm, and blurs of motion propel them forward as they lean into a sweeping bend in perfect unison. The road itself is a smooth, dark ribbon of asphalt, carving sinuous curves through a breathtaking landscape of winding, lush green hills beneath a clear blue sky. The entire scene is bathed in the warm golden rays of the afternoon sun, which gleams off the polished bicycle frames and casts long, dramatic shadows that race alongside the bikes, creating an exhilarating atmosphere of speed, focus, and competition as the pack moves like a single, fluid organism against a serene, verdant backdrop.", + "seed": 3162, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_10/index_6743_seed_3162_dp_21_rank_42_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.06688640678767115, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06688640678767115, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.874999976158142, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06688640678767115, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a low-angle drone perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are professional cyclists wearing skin-tight jerseys in vibrant colors like electric blue, neon yellow, or fiery red?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the cyclists hunched in an aggressive, aerodynamic stance on drop bars of carbon fiber bikes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a winding country road with lush green hills under a clear blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera glide smoothly to keep pace with the lead rider while the cyclists accelerate into a sweeping bend?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16628895699977875 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1662888526916504 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16628895699977875, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.9999998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16628895699977875, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.048071324825286865, + 0.02971646562218666, + 0.1493472158908844, + 0.047374922782182693, + 0.03164001554250717, + 0.05262233689427376, + 0.01817932166159153, + 0.01662009209394455, + 0.028249364346265793, + 0.578178882598877 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16628895699977875 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a low-angle drone perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are professional cyclists wearing skin-tight jerseys in vibrant colors like electric blue, neon yellow, or fiery red?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the cyclists hunched in an aggressive, aerodynamic stance on drop bars of carbon fiber bikes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a winding country road with lush green hills under a clear blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera glide smoothly to keep pace with the lead rider while the cyclists accelerate into a sweeping bend?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14283083379268646 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0178308486938477 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14283083379268646, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14283083379268646, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08065464347600937, + 0.012737179175019264, + 0.045831672847270966, + 0.04608980938792229, + 0.050338294357061386, + 0.04455156624317169, + 0.10493959486484528, + 0.03140469267964363, + 0.04128082096576691, + 0.5421717762947083 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14283083379268646 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a low-angle drone perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are professional cyclists wearing skin-tight jerseys in vibrant colors like electric blue, neon yellow, or fiery red?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the cyclists hunched in an aggressive, aerodynamic stance on drop bars of carbon fiber bikes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a winding country road with lush green hills under a clear blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera glide smoothly to keep pace with the lead rider while the cyclists accelerate into a sweeping bend?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014200001023709774 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264200210571289 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014200001023709774, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014200001023709774, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0734686627984047, + 0.020549625158309937, + 0.060795869678258896, + 0.029773708432912827, + 0.031178468838334084, + 0.025842685252428055, + 0.06510462611913681, + 0.026534035801887512, + 0.04456429183483124, + 0.6221879720687866 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014200001023709774 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a low-angle drone perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are professional cyclists wearing skin-tight jerseys in vibrant colors like electric blue, neon yellow, or fiery red?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the cyclists hunched in an aggressive, aerodynamic stance on drop bars of carbon fiber bikes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a winding country road with lush green hills under a clear blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera glide smoothly to keep pace with the lead rider while the cyclists accelerate into a sweeping bend?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.001334729720838368 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.6263346672058105 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.001334729720838368, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.001334729720838368, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12680982053279877, + 0.0938272699713707, + 0.09635399281978607, + 0.05108204483985901, + 0.05501920357346535, + 0.08374319970607758, + 0.1575472503900528, + 0.049400076270103455, + 0.031699296087026596, + 0.2545178532600403 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.001334729720838368 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a low-angle drone perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are professional cyclists wearing skin-tight jerseys in vibrant colors like electric blue, neon yellow, or fiery red?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the cyclists hunched in an aggressive, aerodynamic stance on drop bars of carbon fiber bikes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a winding country road with lush green hills under a clear blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera glide smoothly to keep pace with the lead rider while the cyclists accelerate into a sweeping bend?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009777512401342392 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634777545928955 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009777512401342392, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009777512401342392, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12045485526323318, + 0.04041939973831177, + 0.10628186911344528, + 0.05290403217077255, + 0.05523696169257164, + 0.16402511298656464, + 0.04290567338466644, + 0.04086877778172493, + 0.06640894711017609, + 0.3104943633079529 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009777512401342392 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_11/index_tensor([3035, 3035])_group_11_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_11/index_tensor([3035, 3035])_group_11_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..be041a50d0b644b63f8b120d41a216f3f5d42ce5 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_11/index_tensor([3035, 3035])_group_11_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "locked, wide-angle lens, held steady at eye level, captures a dynamic, unfolding Chinese ink painting, imbued with the artistic conception of traditional aesthetics. The background is a minimalist, blank composition. Within the vast expanse of rice paper, a few strokes of varying shades of ink outline the distant mountain range, its peaks looming in the misty void. At the center of this ethereal landscape, an anthropomorphic figure with a plump pig face, large ears, and a rotund belly, clad in a tight, blue short coat, grins with a gleaming gaze, vigorously wielding a heavy, nine-toothed rake. He is not fighting, but rather, swaying clumsily in intense excitement and greed, his body tumbling and swaying, the heavy rake slicing irregular arcs in his hands, further unbalancing his already massive frame. His whirlwind is directed with unmistakable purpose: a dreamlike cloud swirling to one side of the painting. This is no ordinary cloud, but a vortex formed by countless large, juicy, pink peaches, steaming white flour buns, and glossy roasted poultry. The vibrant colors of the food contrast sharply with the elegant ink painting of the background. A soft, diffuse light evenly casts the scene, devoid of clear shadows, highlighting its scroll-like quality. The scene, strikingly contrasting the solemnity of traditional aesthetics with the comical greed of the characters, creates a sense of mythical wonder and humor.", + "seed": 6461, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_11/index_3035_seed_6461_dp_22_rank_44_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.025201332941651344, + "vlm_logprob": -0.025201332941651344, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.1, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.025201332941651344, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style that of a Chinese ink painting on rice paper with a minimalist, blank background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central character an anthropomorphic figure with a plump pig face, large ears, and a rotund belly wearing a tight blue short coat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character vigorously wielding a heavy, nine-toothed rake while swaying and tumbling in excitement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a swirling vortex of large pink peaches, steaming white flour buns, and glossy roasted poultry to the side of the character?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting soft and diffuse with no clear shadows, highlighting the scroll-like quality of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07054885476827621 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6955487728118896 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07054885476827621, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07054885476827621, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4327716827392578, + 0.07402841001749039, + 0.10291101038455963, + 0.057192254811525345, + 0.05415264144539833, + 0.07644248753786087, + 0.10527638345956802, + 0.04058448597788811, + 0.0375354140996933, + 0.019105227664113045 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07054885476827621 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style that of a Chinese ink painting on rice paper with a minimalist, blank background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central character an anthropomorphic figure with a plump pig face, large ears, and a rotund belly wearing a tight blue short coat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character vigorously wielding a heavy, nine-toothed rake while swaying and tumbling in excitement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a swirling vortex of large pink peaches, steaming white flour buns, and glossy roasted poultry to the side of the character?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting soft and diffuse with no clear shadows, highlighting the scroll-like quality of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008648676797747612 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758648872375488 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008648676797747612, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008648676797747612, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2555280923843384, + 0.13205017149448395, + 0.1226794496178627, + 0.11347272992134094, + 0.14173941314220428, + 0.04980896785855293, + 0.03476232290267944, + 0.03305142745375633, + 0.061115916818380356, + 0.05579156428575516 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008648676797747612 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style that of a Chinese ink painting on rice paper with a minimalist, blank background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central character an anthropomorphic figure with a plump pig face, large ears, and a rotund belly wearing a tight blue short coat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character vigorously wielding a heavy, nine-toothed rake while swaying and tumbling in excitement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a swirling vortex of large pink peaches, steaming white flour buns, and glossy roasted poultry to the side of the character?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting soft and diffuse with no clear shadows, highlighting the scroll-like quality of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029791610315442085 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5297915935516357 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029791610315442085, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029791610315442085, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2857583165168762, + 0.0790264829993248, + 0.04926740750670433, + 0.09833483397960663, + 0.13908416032791138, + 0.0556042306125164, + 0.03544686362147331, + 0.09884734451770782, + 0.12832610309123993, + 0.03030424378812313 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029791610315442085 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style that of a Chinese ink painting on rice paper with a minimalist, blank background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central character an anthropomorphic figure with a plump pig face, large ears, and a rotund belly wearing a tight blue short coat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character vigorously wielding a heavy, nine-toothed rake while swaying and tumbling in excitement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a swirling vortex of large pink peaches, steaming white flour buns, and glossy roasted poultry to the side of the character?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting soft and diffuse with no clear shadows, highlighting the scroll-like quality of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011072737164795399 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511072635650635 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011072737164795399, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011072737164795399, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18361987173557281, + 0.10413254052400589, + 0.12612462043762207, + 0.06925611943006516, + 0.2651503086090088, + 0.03627372160553932, + 0.06812126934528351, + 0.03069162555038929, + 0.05697949230670929, + 0.05965036898851395 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011072737164795399 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style that of a Chinese ink painting on rice paper with a minimalist, blank background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central character an anthropomorphic figure with a plump pig face, large ears, and a rotund belly wearing a tight blue short coat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character vigorously wielding a heavy, nine-toothed rake while swaying and tumbling in excitement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a swirling vortex of large pink peaches, steaming white flour buns, and glossy roasted poultry to the side of the character?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting soft and diffuse with no clear shadows, highlighting the scroll-like quality of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005944785661995411 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130944728851318 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005944785661995411, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005944785661995411, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3933957517147064, + 0.08634829521179199, + 0.11157044023275375, + 0.047467608004808426, + 0.07458777725696564, + 0.06374885141849518, + 0.07862458378076553, + 0.0353517085313797, + 0.06342539936304092, + 0.04547955468297005 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005944785661995411 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "locked, wide-angle lens, held steady at eye level, captures a dynamic, unfolding Chinese ink painting, imbued with the artistic conception of traditional aesthetics. The background is a minimalist, blank composition. Within the vast expanse of rice paper, a few strokes of varying shades of ink outline the distant mountain range, its peaks looming in the misty void. At the center of this ethereal landscape, an anthropomorphic figure with a plump pig face, large ears, and a rotund belly, clad in a tight, blue short coat, grins with a gleaming gaze, vigorously wielding a heavy, nine-toothed rake. He is not fighting, but rather, swaying clumsily in intense excitement and greed, his body tumbling and swaying, the heavy rake slicing irregular arcs in his hands, further unbalancing his already massive frame. His whirlwind is directed with unmistakable purpose: a dreamlike cloud swirling to one side of the painting. This is no ordinary cloud, but a vortex formed by countless large, juicy, pink peaches, steaming white flour buns, and glossy roasted poultry. The vibrant colors of the food contrast sharply with the elegant ink painting of the background. A soft, diffuse light evenly casts the scene, devoid of clear shadows, highlighting its scroll-like quality. The scene, strikingly contrasting the solemnity of traditional aesthetics with the comical greed of the characters, creates a sense of mythical wonder and humor.", + "seed": 6462, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_11/index_3035_seed_6462_dp_22_rank_44_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.00698381825350225, + "vlm_logprob": -0.00698381825350225, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 5.075, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.00698381825350225, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style that of a Chinese ink painting on rice paper with a minimalist, blank background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central character an anthropomorphic figure with a plump pig face, large ears, and a rotund belly wearing a tight blue short coat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character vigorously wielding a heavy, nine-toothed rake while swaying and tumbling in excitement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a swirling vortex of large pink peaches, steaming white flour buns, and glossy roasted poultry to the side of the character?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting soft and diffuse with no clear shadows, highlighting the scroll-like quality of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01034339889883995 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.635343551635742 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01034339889883995, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01034339889883995, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19118541479110718, + 0.24468398094177246, + 0.0518728569149971, + 0.10681543499231339, + 0.061275627464056015, + 0.03090520389378071, + 0.10400758683681488, + 0.057165298610925674, + 0.13484852015972137, + 0.017240075394511223 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01034339889883995 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style that of a Chinese ink painting on rice paper with a minimalist, blank background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central character an anthropomorphic figure with a plump pig face, large ears, and a rotund belly wearing a tight blue short coat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character vigorously wielding a heavy, nine-toothed rake while swaying and tumbling in excitement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a swirling vortex of large pink peaches, steaming white flour buns, and glossy roasted poultry to the side of the character?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting soft and diffuse with no clear shadows, highlighting the scroll-like quality of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0046440837904810905 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.37964391708374 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0046440837904810905, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0046440837904810905, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06954824179410934, + 0.15431605279445648, + 0.04512268677353859, + 0.10174165666103363, + 0.07963240146636963, + 0.18343931436538696, + 0.12906458973884583, + 0.1572495549917221, + 0.05160706862807274, + 0.02827848680317402 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0046440837904810905 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style that of a Chinese ink painting on rice paper with a minimalist, blank background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central character an anthropomorphic figure with a plump pig face, large ears, and a rotund belly wearing a tight blue short coat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character vigorously wielding a heavy, nine-toothed rake while swaying and tumbling in excitement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a swirling vortex of large pink peaches, steaming white flour buns, and glossy roasted poultry to the side of the character?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting soft and diffuse with no clear shadows, highlighting the scroll-like quality of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011071440763771534 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.51107120513916 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011071440763771534, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011071440763771534, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16381539404392242, + 0.34494173526763916, + 0.05982906371355057, + 0.07819170504808426, + 0.08709947764873505, + 0.07940687984228134, + 0.05288024619221687, + 0.05260463058948517, + 0.02945617027580738, + 0.05177469551563263 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011071440763771534 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style that of a Chinese ink painting on rice paper with a minimalist, blank background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central character an anthropomorphic figure with a plump pig face, large ears, and a rotund belly wearing a tight blue short coat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character vigorously wielding a heavy, nine-toothed rake while swaying and tumbling in excitement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a swirling vortex of large pink peaches, steaming white flour buns, and glossy roasted poultry to the side of the character?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting soft and diffuse with no clear shadows, highlighting the scroll-like quality of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005248932633548975 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.2552490234375 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005248932633548975, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005248932633548975, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12312585115432739, + 0.21466532349586487, + 0.044492606073617935, + 0.12418315559625626, + 0.16922210156917572, + 0.10285676270723343, + 0.07263576984405518, + 0.06275253742933273, + 0.027925819158554077, + 0.0581400990486145 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005248932633548975 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style that of a Chinese ink painting on rice paper with a minimalist, blank background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central character an anthropomorphic figure with a plump pig face, large ears, and a rotund belly wearing a tight blue short coat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character vigorously wielding a heavy, nine-toothed rake while swaying and tumbling in excitement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a swirling vortex of large pink peaches, steaming white flour buns, and glossy roasted poultry to the side of the character?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting soft and diffuse with no clear shadows, highlighting the scroll-like quality of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036112351808696985 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628611087799072 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036112351808696985, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036112351808696985, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15641401708126068, + 0.18779389560222626, + 0.049776896834373474, + 0.09733941406011581, + 0.08137290179729462, + 0.12101133167743683, + 0.09350936859846115, + 0.06742258369922638, + 0.09734105318784714, + 0.04801858216524124 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036112351808696985 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "locked, wide-angle lens, held steady at eye level, captures a dynamic, unfolding Chinese ink painting, imbued with the artistic conception of traditional aesthetics. The background is a minimalist, blank composition. Within the vast expanse of rice paper, a few strokes of varying shades of ink outline the distant mountain range, its peaks looming in the misty void. At the center of this ethereal landscape, an anthropomorphic figure with a plump pig face, large ears, and a rotund belly, clad in a tight, blue short coat, grins with a gleaming gaze, vigorously wielding a heavy, nine-toothed rake. He is not fighting, but rather, swaying clumsily in intense excitement and greed, his body tumbling and swaying, the heavy rake slicing irregular arcs in his hands, further unbalancing his already massive frame. His whirlwind is directed with unmistakable purpose: a dreamlike cloud swirling to one side of the painting. This is no ordinary cloud, but a vortex formed by countless large, juicy, pink peaches, steaming white flour buns, and glossy roasted poultry. The vibrant colors of the food contrast sharply with the elegant ink painting of the background. A soft, diffuse light evenly casts the scene, devoid of clear shadows, highlighting its scroll-like quality. The scene, strikingly contrasting the solemnity of traditional aesthetics with the comical greed of the characters, creates a sense of mythical wonder and humor.", + "seed": 6463, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_11/index_3035_seed_6463_dp_23_rank_46_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.011658741813153028, + "vlm_logprob": -0.011658741813153028, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.625, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.011658741813153028, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style that of a Chinese ink painting on rice paper with a minimalist, blank background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central character an anthropomorphic figure with a plump pig face, large ears, and a rotund belly wearing a tight blue short coat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character vigorously wielding a heavy, nine-toothed rake while swaying and tumbling in excitement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a swirling vortex of large pink peaches, steaming white flour buns, and glossy roasted poultry to the side of the character?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting soft and diffuse with no clear shadows, highlighting the scroll-like quality of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008980833925306797 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758980751037598 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008980833925306797, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008980833925306797, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21103300154209137, + 0.06958416849374771, + 0.048433974385261536, + 0.17985282838344574, + 0.1986164152622223, + 0.18299679458141327, + 0.010572580620646477, + 0.02096889726817608, + 0.018313826993107796, + 0.05962751433253288 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008980833925306797 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style that of a Chinese ink painting on rice paper with a minimalist, blank background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central character an anthropomorphic figure with a plump pig face, large ears, and a rotund belly wearing a tight blue short coat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character vigorously wielding a heavy, nine-toothed rake while swaying and tumbling in excitement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a swirling vortex of large pink peaches, steaming white flour buns, and glossy roasted poultry to the side of the character?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting soft and diffuse with no clear shadows, highlighting the scroll-like quality of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0059562805108726025 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130956172943115 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0059562805108726025, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0059562805108726025, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10464800149202347, + 0.08202088624238968, + 0.20538856089115143, + 0.06242489814758301, + 0.20291809737682343, + 0.1429314911365509, + 0.026634082198143005, + 0.029294416308403015, + 0.024333883076906204, + 0.11940564960241318 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0059562805108726025 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style that of a Chinese ink painting on rice paper with a minimalist, blank background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central character an anthropomorphic figure with a plump pig face, large ears, and a rotund belly wearing a tight blue short coat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character vigorously wielding a heavy, nine-toothed rake while swaying and tumbling in excitement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a swirling vortex of large pink peaches, steaming white flour buns, and glossy roasted poultry to the side of the character?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting soft and diffuse with no clear shadows, highlighting the scroll-like quality of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026341086253523827 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651341199874878 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026341086253523827, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026341086253523827, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17648795247077942, + 0.08741632848978043, + 0.0632716491818428, + 0.1462211161851883, + 0.19931726157665253, + 0.1896849274635315, + 0.03658219054341316, + 0.019532611593604088, + 0.03303641453385353, + 0.0484495535492897 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026341086253523827 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style that of a Chinese ink painting on rice paper with a minimalist, blank background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central character an anthropomorphic figure with a plump pig face, large ears, and a rotund belly wearing a tight blue short coat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character vigorously wielding a heavy, nine-toothed rake while swaying and tumbling in excitement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a swirling vortex of large pink peaches, steaming white flour buns, and glossy roasted poultry to the side of the character?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting soft and diffuse with no clear shadows, highlighting the scroll-like quality of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011072618886828423 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511072635650635 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011072618886828423, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011072618886828423, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.48951485753059387, + 0.08868137747049332, + 0.05477163568139076, + 0.06903917342424393, + 0.08689464628696442, + 0.07079733908176422, + 0.0205142293125391, + 0.026811383664608, + 0.02102440409362316, + 0.07195097953081131 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011072618886828423 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style that of a Chinese ink painting on rice paper with a minimalist, blank background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central character an anthropomorphic figure with a plump pig face, large ears, and a rotund belly wearing a tight blue short coat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character vigorously wielding a heavy, nine-toothed rake while swaying and tumbling in excitement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a swirling vortex of large pink peaches, steaming white flour buns, and glossy roasted poultry to the side of the character?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting soft and diffuse with no clear shadows, highlighting the scroll-like quality of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005942889489233494 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.1309428215026855 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005942889489233494, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005942889489233494, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.38352328538894653, + 0.11111979931592941, + 0.040965136140584946, + 0.07390516996383667, + 0.10306990146636963, + 0.07571277022361755, + 0.040132589638233185, + 0.04600994288921356, + 0.024586055427789688, + 0.10097528994083405 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005942889489233494 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "locked, wide-angle lens, held steady at eye level, captures a dynamic, unfolding Chinese ink painting, imbued with the artistic conception of traditional aesthetics. The background is a minimalist, blank composition. Within the vast expanse of rice paper, a few strokes of varying shades of ink outline the distant mountain range, its peaks looming in the misty void. At the center of this ethereal landscape, an anthropomorphic figure with a plump pig face, large ears, and a rotund belly, clad in a tight, blue short coat, grins with a gleaming gaze, vigorously wielding a heavy, nine-toothed rake. He is not fighting, but rather, swaying clumsily in intense excitement and greed, his body tumbling and swaying, the heavy rake slicing irregular arcs in his hands, further unbalancing his already massive frame. His whirlwind is directed with unmistakable purpose: a dreamlike cloud swirling to one side of the painting. This is no ordinary cloud, but a vortex formed by countless large, juicy, pink peaches, steaming white flour buns, and glossy roasted poultry. The vibrant colors of the food contrast sharply with the elegant ink painting of the background. A soft, diffuse light evenly casts the scene, devoid of clear shadows, highlighting its scroll-like quality. The scene, strikingly contrasting the solemnity of traditional aesthetics with the comical greed of the characters, creates a sense of mythical wonder and humor.", + "seed": 6464, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_11/index_3035_seed_6464_dp_23_rank_46_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.017432705126702787, + "vlm_logprob": -0.017432705126702787, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.4, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.017432705126702787, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style that of a Chinese ink painting on rice paper with a minimalist, blank background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central character an anthropomorphic figure with a plump pig face, large ears, and a rotund belly wearing a tight blue short coat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character vigorously wielding a heavy, nine-toothed rake while swaying and tumbling in excitement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a swirling vortex of large pink peaches, steaming white flour buns, and glossy roasted poultry to the side of the character?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting soft and diffuse with no clear shadows, highlighting the scroll-like quality of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04359889775514603 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1685988903045654 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04359889775514603, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04359889775514603, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.33101460337638855, + 0.027453238144516945, + 0.29016363620758057, + 0.026858069002628326, + 0.0750642791390419, + 0.03813391551375389, + 0.07562150061130524, + 0.0604747049510479, + 0.0066878898069262505, + 0.06852814555168152 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04359889775514603 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style that of a Chinese ink painting on rice paper with a minimalist, blank background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central character an anthropomorphic figure with a plump pig face, large ears, and a rotund belly wearing a tight blue short coat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character vigorously wielding a heavy, nine-toothed rake while swaying and tumbling in excitement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a swirling vortex of large pink peaches, steaming white flour buns, and glossy roasted poultry to the side of the character?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting soft and diffuse with no clear shadows, highlighting the scroll-like quality of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0052580637857317924 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255258083343506 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0052580637857317924, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0052580637857317924, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.41525498032569885, + 0.0321015790104866, + 0.2191430777311325, + 0.012117176316678524, + 0.01411205343902111, + 0.08687949925661087, + 0.08986083418130875, + 0.0671522319316864, + 0.008973698131740093, + 0.05440489947795868 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0052580637857317924 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style that of a Chinese ink painting on rice paper with a minimalist, blank background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central character an anthropomorphic figure with a plump pig face, large ears, and a rotund belly wearing a tight blue short coat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character vigorously wielding a heavy, nine-toothed rake while swaying and tumbling in excitement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a swirling vortex of large pink peaches, steaming white flour buns, and glossy roasted poultry to the side of the character?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting soft and diffuse with no clear shadows, highlighting the scroll-like quality of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02328236773610115 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773282289505005 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02328236773610115, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02328236773610115, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09261687099933624, + 0.03928512707352638, + 0.2202885001897812, + 0.010495060123503208, + 0.0210806205868721, + 0.08353251218795776, + 0.3499590754508972, + 0.019970284774899483, + 0.006992179900407791, + 0.15577979385852814 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 2, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02328236773610115 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style that of a Chinese ink painting on rice paper with a minimalist, blank background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central character an anthropomorphic figure with a plump pig face, large ears, and a rotund belly wearing a tight blue short coat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character vigorously wielding a heavy, nine-toothed rake while swaying and tumbling in excitement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a swirling vortex of large pink peaches, steaming white flour buns, and glossy roasted poultry to the side of the character?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting soft and diffuse with no clear shadows, highlighting the scroll-like quality of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009776568040251732 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634776592254639 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009776568040251732, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009776568040251732, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2637167274951935, + 0.014417337253689766, + 0.10771480947732925, + 0.008027240633964539, + 0.013045537285506725, + 0.11716120690107346, + 0.33675479888916016, + 0.06884989142417908, + 0.007186808157712221, + 0.0631256103515625 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009776568040251732 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style that of a Chinese ink painting on rice paper with a minimalist, blank background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central character an anthropomorphic figure with a plump pig face, large ears, and a rotund belly wearing a tight blue short coat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character vigorously wielding a heavy, nine-toothed rake while swaying and tumbling in excitement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a swirling vortex of large pink peaches, steaming white flour buns, and glossy roasted poultry to the side of the character?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting soft and diffuse with no clear shadows, highlighting the scroll-like quality of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005247628316283226 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255247592926025 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005247628316283226, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005247628316283226, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15264521539211273, + 0.03728969022631645, + 0.08708711713552475, + 0.016503969207406044, + 0.04032210260629654, + 0.10545474290847778, + 0.23292550444602966, + 0.23380005359649658, + 0.012006568722426891, + 0.08196501433849335 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005247628316283226 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_12/index_tensor([904, 904])_group_12_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_12/index_tensor([904, 904])_group_12_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..5c7d14a0d1f913bc32bed1818eb19cbe8d4c28c5 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_12/index_tensor([904, 904])_group_12_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "In a static, ultra-high-definition, vertical medium shot shot from a slight upward angle, the delicate brushstrokes of Japanese theatrical animation are brought to full effect. A plump wax apple fruit, transformed into a spirit, stands gracefully amidst a vast, emerald lotus leaf with distinct veins. Her figure is elegant and slender, her skin embodying the wax apple's characteristic luminous hue, gradating from ivory white at the top to ruby red at the base. Her smooth, porcelain-like surface reflects a soft luster. Her face is delicate and ethereal, her eyes gently closed, her expression serene. Her hair is artfully shaped to resemble the calyx of the wax apple, seamlessly blending with the fruit itself. A soft, pearly, warm aura emanates from her, enveloping her and imbuing the scene with a sacred and dreamy aura. The background is a tranquil lake shrouded in morning mist. Soft, diffused light from the sky penetrates the fog, intertwining with the spirit's own radiance, casting a faint, blurred shadow on the lotus leaf. A large, crystalline drop of water slowly glides down the graceful curve of her side, subtly distorting the colors beneath it as it moves, leaving a fleeting trail of moisture before silently landing on the surface of a lotus leaf, creating a circle of tiny, perfectly formed ripples. The entire image is filled with exquisite detail, from the translucent texture of the elf's skin to the velvety texture of the lotus leaf. Each frame resembles a meticulously crafted illustration, creating an atmosphere of profound tranquility and pure poetry.", + "seed": 24632, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_12/index_904_seed_24632_dp_24_rank_48_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.04492638818919659, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04492638818919659, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.55, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04492638818919659, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a vertical medium shot taken from a slight upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main character a spirit resembling a plump wax apple with skin gradating from ivory white to ruby red?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character standing on a vast emerald lotus leaf with distinct veins in a tranquil lake shrouded in morning mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a large crystalline drop of water slowly glide down the character's side and land on a lotus leaf creating ripples?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the character's hair artfully shaped to resemble the calyx of a wax apple?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05614117905497551 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0561411380767822 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05614117905497551, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05614117905497551, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23686575889587402, + 0.08502360433340073, + 0.12315427511930466, + 0.14473579823970795, + 0.14346443116664886, + 0.05254111811518669, + 0.06985528767108917, + 0.05865803360939026, + 0.029900941997766495, + 0.055800799280405045 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05614117905497551 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a vertical medium shot taken from a slight upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main character a spirit resembling a plump wax apple with skin gradating from ivory white to ruby red?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character standing on a vast emerald lotus leaf with distinct veins in a tranquil lake shrouded in morning mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a large crystalline drop of water slowly glide down the character's side and land on a lotus leaf creating ripples?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the character's hair artfully shaped to resemble the calyx of a wax apple?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005274783819913864 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255274772644043 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005274783819913864, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005274783819913864, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12330327183008194, + 0.12841682136058807, + 0.12812623381614685, + 0.28944385051727295, + 0.19472558796405792, + 0.04680050536990166, + 0.02716226875782013, + 0.012430266477167606, + 0.029275642707943916, + 0.020315494388341904 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005274783819913864 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a vertical medium shot taken from a slight upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main character a spirit resembling a plump wax apple with skin gradating from ivory white to ruby red?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character standing on a vast emerald lotus leaf with distinct veins in a tranquil lake shrouded in morning mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a large crystalline drop of water slowly glide down the character's side and land on a lotus leaf creating ripples?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the character's hair artfully shaped to resemble the calyx of a wax apple?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.048677489161491394 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048677444458008 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.048677489161491394, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.048677489161491394, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2165122628211975, + 0.10451620817184448, + 0.120201975107193, + 0.20486998558044434, + 0.09289685636758804, + 0.10803183913230896, + 0.042584989219903946, + 0.0371391661465168, + 0.03436817601323128, + 0.038878537714481354 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.048677489161491394 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a vertical medium shot taken from a slight upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main character a spirit resembling a plump wax apple with skin gradating from ivory white to ruby red?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character standing on a vast emerald lotus leaf with distinct veins in a tranquil lake shrouded in morning mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a large crystalline drop of water slowly glide down the character's side and land on a lotus leaf creating ripples?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the character's hair artfully shaped to resemble the calyx of a wax apple?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10033425688743591 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3503341674804688 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10033425688743591, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10033425688743591, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08824814110994339, + 0.08427125960588455, + 0.026666898280382156, + 0.20391783118247986, + 0.08217970281839371, + 0.1108304038643837, + 0.06303656101226807, + 0.0906212255358696, + 0.1865541636943817, + 0.06367375701665878 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10033425688743591 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a vertical medium shot taken from a slight upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main character a spirit resembling a plump wax apple with skin gradating from ivory white to ruby red?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character standing on a vast emerald lotus leaf with distinct veins in a tranquil lake shrouded in morning mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a large crystalline drop of water slowly glide down the character's side and land on a lotus leaf creating ripples?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the character's hair artfully shaped to resemble the calyx of a wax apple?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014204232022166252 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264204025268555 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014204232022166252, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014204232022166252, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0828152671456337, + 0.11184493452310562, + 0.046581294387578964, + 0.28929927945137024, + 0.32219547033309937, + 0.04037636145949364, + 0.019634852185845375, + 0.02040339820086956, + 0.014231063425540924, + 0.0526181124150753 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014204232022166252 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a static, ultra-high-definition, vertical medium shot shot from a slight upward angle, the delicate brushstrokes of Japanese theatrical animation are brought to full effect. A plump wax apple fruit, transformed into a spirit, stands gracefully amidst a vast, emerald lotus leaf with distinct veins. Her figure is elegant and slender, her skin embodying the wax apple's characteristic luminous hue, gradating from ivory white at the top to ruby red at the base. Her smooth, porcelain-like surface reflects a soft luster. Her face is delicate and ethereal, her eyes gently closed, her expression serene. Her hair is artfully shaped to resemble the calyx of the wax apple, seamlessly blending with the fruit itself. A soft, pearly, warm aura emanates from her, enveloping her and imbuing the scene with a sacred and dreamy aura. The background is a tranquil lake shrouded in morning mist. Soft, diffused light from the sky penetrates the fog, intertwining with the spirit's own radiance, casting a faint, blurred shadow on the lotus leaf. A large, crystalline drop of water slowly glides down the graceful curve of her side, subtly distorting the colors beneath it as it moves, leaving a fleeting trail of moisture before silently landing on the surface of a lotus leaf, creating a circle of tiny, perfectly formed ripples. The entire image is filled with exquisite detail, from the translucent texture of the elf's skin to the velvety texture of the lotus leaf. Each frame resembles a meticulously crafted illustration, creating an atmosphere of profound tranquility and pure poetry.", + "seed": 24633, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_12/index_904_seed_24633_dp_24_rank_48_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.02066461816430092, + "vlm_logprob": -0.02066461816430092, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.525, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.02066461816430092, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a vertical medium shot taken from a slight upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main character a spirit resembling a plump wax apple with skin gradating from ivory white to ruby red?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character standing on a vast emerald lotus leaf with distinct veins in a tranquil lake shrouded in morning mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a large crystalline drop of water slowly glide down the character's side and land on a lotus leaf creating ripples?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the character's hair artfully shaped to resemble the calyx of a wax apple?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.022792158648371696 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.147792339324951 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.022792158648371696, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.022792158648371696, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.304773211479187, + 0.05779041722416878, + 0.05423632636666298, + 0.1113872155547142, + 0.046529389917850494, + 0.12712794542312622, + 0.07297443598508835, + 0.10208599269390106, + 0.05955590680241585, + 0.06353911757469177 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.022792158648371696 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a vertical medium shot taken from a slight upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main character a spirit resembling a plump wax apple with skin gradating from ivory white to ruby red?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character standing on a vast emerald lotus leaf with distinct veins in a tranquil lake shrouded in morning mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a large crystalline drop of water slowly glide down the character's side and land on a lotus leaf creating ripples?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the character's hair artfully shaped to resemble the calyx of a wax apple?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002212697174400091 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.1272125244140625 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002212697174400091, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002212697174400091, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.28913813829421997, + 0.11547484993934631, + 0.08730308711528778, + 0.08783308416604996, + 0.046433936804533005, + 0.09399917721748352, + 0.09216802567243576, + 0.03216251730918884, + 0.09192023426294327, + 0.06356693059206009 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002212697174400091 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a vertical medium shot taken from a slight upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main character a spirit resembling a plump wax apple with skin gradating from ivory white to ruby red?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character standing on a vast emerald lotus leaf with distinct veins in a tranquil lake shrouded in morning mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a large crystalline drop of water slowly glide down the character's side and land on a lotus leaf creating ripples?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the character's hair artfully shaped to resemble the calyx of a wax apple?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008640285581350327 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758640289306641 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008640285581350327, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008640285581350327, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.37958019971847534, + 0.14195547997951508, + 0.05328990891575813, + 0.08648620545864105, + 0.03898649662733078, + 0.066974937915802, + 0.12841491401195526, + 0.021629873663187027, + 0.042900677770376205, + 0.03978126868605614 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008640285581350327 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a vertical medium shot taken from a slight upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main character a spirit resembling a plump wax apple with skin gradating from ivory white to ruby red?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character standing on a vast emerald lotus leaf with distinct veins in a tranquil lake shrouded in morning mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a large crystalline drop of water slowly glide down the character's side and land on a lotus leaf creating ripples?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the character's hair artfully shaped to resemble the calyx of a wax apple?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06205030158162117 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120503425598145 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06205030158162117, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06205030158162117, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2337905615568161, + 0.08498233556747437, + 0.057736244052648544, + 0.04888492822647095, + 0.04250340163707733, + 0.07336726784706116, + 0.09993281960487366, + 0.07003457844257355, + 0.18850989639759064, + 0.1002579927444458 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06205030158162117 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a vertical medium shot taken from a slight upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main character a spirit resembling a plump wax apple with skin gradating from ivory white to ruby red?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character standing on a vast emerald lotus leaf with distinct veins in a tranquil lake shrouded in morning mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a large crystalline drop of water slowly glide down the character's side and land on a lotus leaf creating ripples?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the character's hair artfully shaped to resemble the calyx of a wax apple?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007627647835761309 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882627487182617 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007627647835761309, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007627647835761309, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21770738065242767, + 0.1195567175745964, + 0.06600909680128098, + 0.07770603895187378, + 0.044291455298662186, + 0.11876829713582993, + 0.12135962396860123, + 0.06306935101747513, + 0.08872485905885696, + 0.08280715346336365 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007627647835761309 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a static, ultra-high-definition, vertical medium shot shot from a slight upward angle, the delicate brushstrokes of Japanese theatrical animation are brought to full effect. A plump wax apple fruit, transformed into a spirit, stands gracefully amidst a vast, emerald lotus leaf with distinct veins. Her figure is elegant and slender, her skin embodying the wax apple's characteristic luminous hue, gradating from ivory white at the top to ruby red at the base. Her smooth, porcelain-like surface reflects a soft luster. Her face is delicate and ethereal, her eyes gently closed, her expression serene. Her hair is artfully shaped to resemble the calyx of the wax apple, seamlessly blending with the fruit itself. A soft, pearly, warm aura emanates from her, enveloping her and imbuing the scene with a sacred and dreamy aura. The background is a tranquil lake shrouded in morning mist. Soft, diffused light from the sky penetrates the fog, intertwining with the spirit's own radiance, casting a faint, blurred shadow on the lotus leaf. A large, crystalline drop of water slowly glides down the graceful curve of her side, subtly distorting the colors beneath it as it moves, leaving a fleeting trail of moisture before silently landing on the surface of a lotus leaf, creating a circle of tiny, perfectly formed ripples. The entire image is filled with exquisite detail, from the translucent texture of the elf's skin to the velvety texture of the lotus leaf. Each frame resembles a meticulously crafted illustration, creating an atmosphere of profound tranquility and pure poetry.", + "seed": 24634, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_12/index_904_seed_24634_dp_25_rank_50_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.0250526730902493, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0250526730902493, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.125, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0250526730902493, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a vertical medium shot taken from a slight upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main character a spirit resembling a plump wax apple with skin gradating from ivory white to ruby red?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character standing on a vast emerald lotus leaf with distinct veins in a tranquil lake shrouded in morning mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a large crystalline drop of water slowly glide down the character's side and land on a lotus leaf creating ripples?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the character's hair artfully shaped to resemble the calyx of a wax apple?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03430740535259247 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7843074798583984 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03430740535259247, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03430740535259247, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18828009068965912, + 0.1954852193593979, + 0.10527825355529785, + 0.03607228398323059, + 0.1461477130651474, + 0.027756154537200928, + 0.04286358505487442, + 0.09642838686704636, + 0.06412675976753235, + 0.0975615605711937 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03430740535259247 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a vertical medium shot taken from a slight upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main character a spirit resembling a plump wax apple with skin gradating from ivory white to ruby red?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character standing on a vast emerald lotus leaf with distinct veins in a tranquil lake shrouded in morning mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a large crystalline drop of water slowly glide down the character's side and land on a lotus leaf creating ripples?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the character's hair artfully shaped to resemble the calyx of a wax apple?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005275258328765631 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255275249481201 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005275258328765631, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005275258328765631, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07773569971323013, + 0.22191651165485382, + 0.1614435762166977, + 0.041524793952703476, + 0.04854905232787132, + 0.017686842009425163, + 0.05076893791556358, + 0.12581714987754822, + 0.0938308984041214, + 0.16072644293308258 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005275258328765631 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a vertical medium shot taken from a slight upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main character a spirit resembling a plump wax apple with skin gradating from ivory white to ruby red?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character standing on a vast emerald lotus leaf with distinct veins in a tranquil lake shrouded in morning mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a large crystalline drop of water slowly glide down the character's side and land on a lotus leaf creating ripples?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the character's hair artfully shaped to resemble the calyx of a wax apple?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012544183060526848 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.38754415512085 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012544183060526848, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012544183060526848, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18157418072223663, + 0.0711742714047432, + 0.16897422075271606, + 0.049980610609054565, + 0.04137570783495903, + 0.05723818019032478, + 0.07017197459936142, + 0.1901935189962387, + 0.10109789669513702, + 0.06821943074464798 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012544183060526848 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a vertical medium shot taken from a slight upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main character a spirit resembling a plump wax apple with skin gradating from ivory white to ruby red?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character standing on a vast emerald lotus leaf with distinct veins in a tranquil lake shrouded in morning mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a large crystalline drop of water slowly glide down the character's side and land on a lotus leaf creating ripples?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the character's hair artfully shaped to resemble the calyx of a wax apple?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.062058594077825546 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812058687210083 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.062058594077825546, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.062058594077825546, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14148543775081635, + 0.13340140879154205, + 0.14749860763549805, + 0.10011410713195801, + 0.07746415585279465, + 0.03794180229306221, + 0.07940129935741425, + 0.06835847347974777, + 0.1054215282201767, + 0.10891319811344147 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.062058594077825546 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a vertical medium shot taken from a slight upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main character a spirit resembling a plump wax apple with skin gradating from ivory white to ruby red?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character standing on a vast emerald lotus leaf with distinct veins in a tranquil lake shrouded in morning mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a large crystalline drop of water slowly glide down the character's side and land on a lotus leaf creating ripples?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the character's hair artfully shaped to resemble the calyx of a wax apple?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011077924631536007 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511077880859375 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011077924631536007, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011077924631536007, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11750240623950958, + 0.1846276968717575, + 0.06432691961526871, + 0.053422849625349045, + 0.15910354256629944, + 0.026499683037400246, + 0.0418875627219677, + 0.09876178205013275, + 0.08496659994125366, + 0.16890092194080353 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011077924631536007 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a static, ultra-high-definition, vertical medium shot shot from a slight upward angle, the delicate brushstrokes of Japanese theatrical animation are brought to full effect. A plump wax apple fruit, transformed into a spirit, stands gracefully amidst a vast, emerald lotus leaf with distinct veins. Her figure is elegant and slender, her skin embodying the wax apple's characteristic luminous hue, gradating from ivory white at the top to ruby red at the base. Her smooth, porcelain-like surface reflects a soft luster. Her face is delicate and ethereal, her eyes gently closed, her expression serene. Her hair is artfully shaped to resemble the calyx of the wax apple, seamlessly blending with the fruit itself. A soft, pearly, warm aura emanates from her, enveloping her and imbuing the scene with a sacred and dreamy aura. The background is a tranquil lake shrouded in morning mist. Soft, diffused light from the sky penetrates the fog, intertwining with the spirit's own radiance, casting a faint, blurred shadow on the lotus leaf. A large, crystalline drop of water slowly glides down the graceful curve of her side, subtly distorting the colors beneath it as it moves, leaving a fleeting trail of moisture before silently landing on the surface of a lotus leaf, creating a circle of tiny, perfectly formed ripples. The entire image is filled with exquisite detail, from the translucent texture of the elf's skin to the velvety texture of the lotus leaf. Each frame resembles a meticulously crafted illustration, creating an atmosphere of profound tranquility and pure poetry.", + "seed": 24635, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_12/index_904_seed_24635_dp_25_rank_50_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.03384514953941107, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03384514953941107, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.775, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03384514953941107, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a vertical medium shot taken from a slight upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main character a spirit resembling a plump wax apple with skin gradating from ivory white to ruby red?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character standing on a vast emerald lotus leaf with distinct veins in a tranquil lake shrouded in morning mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a large crystalline drop of water slowly glide down the character's side and land on a lotus leaf creating ripples?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the character's hair artfully shaped to resemble the calyx of a wax apple?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05452768877148628 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.054527759552002 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05452768877148628, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05452768877148628, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25088563561439514, + 0.08554656058549881, + 0.10110963881015778, + 0.11762827634811401, + 0.13506805896759033, + 0.050334010273218155, + 0.04580983147025108, + 0.07448341697454453, + 0.0894944965839386, + 0.04964003711938858 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05452768877148628 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a vertical medium shot taken from a slight upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main character a spirit resembling a plump wax apple with skin gradating from ivory white to ruby red?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character standing on a vast emerald lotus leaf with distinct veins in a tranquil lake shrouded in morning mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a large crystalline drop of water slowly glide down the character's side and land on a lotus leaf creating ripples?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the character's hair artfully shaped to resemble the calyx of a wax apple?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004114259034395218 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504114151000977 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004114259034395218, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004114259034395218, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.411508709192276, + 0.10286200791597366, + 0.08792159706354141, + 0.06715704500675201, + 0.03535355255007744, + 0.026031797751784325, + 0.08620399981737137, + 0.0626712515950203, + 0.08208558708429337, + 0.03820440545678139 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004114259034395218 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a vertical medium shot taken from a slight upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main character a spirit resembling a plump wax apple with skin gradating from ivory white to ruby red?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character standing on a vast emerald lotus leaf with distinct veins in a tranquil lake shrouded in morning mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a large crystalline drop of water slowly glide down the character's side and land on a lotus leaf creating ripples?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the character's hair artfully shaped to resemble the calyx of a wax apple?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04307139292359352 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680715084075928 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04307139292359352, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04307139292359352, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2459416687488556, + 0.1904769390821457, + 0.10890534520149231, + 0.050572510808706284, + 0.08101359754800797, + 0.04674280807375908, + 0.09519509971141815, + 0.09393025934696198, + 0.05626264587044716, + 0.03095908649265766 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04307139292359352 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a vertical medium shot taken from a slight upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main character a spirit resembling a plump wax apple with skin gradating from ivory white to ruby red?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character standing on a vast emerald lotus leaf with distinct veins in a tranquil lake shrouded in morning mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a large crystalline drop of water slowly glide down the character's side and land on a lotus leaf creating ripples?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the character's hair artfully shaped to resemble the calyx of a wax apple?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.054972462356090546 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299724102020264 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.054972462356090546, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.054972462356090546, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2668701708316803, + 0.05830790102481842, + 0.07166452705860138, + 0.12483770400285721, + 0.049530237913131714, + 0.0494193360209465, + 0.16578388214111328, + 0.04358133673667908, + 0.10879514366388321, + 0.06120971590280533 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.054972462356090546 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a vertical medium shot taken from a slight upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main character a spirit resembling a plump wax apple with skin gradating from ivory white to ruby red?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character standing on a vast emerald lotus leaf with distinct veins in a tranquil lake shrouded in morning mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a large crystalline drop of water slowly glide down the character's side and land on a lotus leaf creating ripples?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the character's hair artfully shaped to resemble the calyx of a wax apple?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012539944611489773 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387539863586426 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012539944611489773, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012539944611489773, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3895189166069031, + 0.06962279230356216, + 0.10199432820081711, + 0.05105563998222351, + 0.04896523803472519, + 0.05105382949113846, + 0.08946534991264343, + 0.06882470101118088, + 0.09211612492799759, + 0.037383079528808594 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012539944611489773 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_13/index_tensor([2062, 2062])_group_13_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_13/index_tensor([2062, 2062])_group_13_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..02f2f06fc0f8a27b75a6f759a17a9d9b29157da2 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_13/index_tensor([2062, 2062])_group_13_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "grand, long, static shot places us on a desolate mountaintop shrouded in a torrential downpour. Shot in a stunning slow motion, the world seems frozen in time. At the center of the frame, a red-clad swordsman stands alone on the rugged, slippery rocks. He wears a rain-soaked crimson suit, the damp fabric clinging to his muscular frame, outlining his defined muscles. His long, dark hair, dampened by the rain, tangled strands plastered to his forehead and cheeks, highlighting his hawk-like eyes and furrowed brow, a fierce, untouchable aura woven between them. With a calm and resolute gesture, he slowly raises his arm, draws a gleaming ancient sword from his waist, and holds it firmly across his chest. During this process, every massive raindrop falling from the sky is clearly visible, like suspended transparent crystals, reflecting a faint light against the gray sky. Some slowly streak across the camera, while others collide and explode on his resolute face, scarlet clothes, and the mirror-like blade of his sword, splashing out circles of miniature, crystal-clear water crowns. The entire scene is gloomy, with only that hint of red, like a burning flame, forming a sharp contrast with the cold rain and gray rocks, creating a lonely, tense, and epic atmosphere of fate.", + "seed": 32649, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_13/index_2062_seed_32649_dp_26_rank_52_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.10486288312822581, + "vlm_logprob": -0.10486288312822581, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.299999988079071, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.10486288312822581, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a desolate mountaintop with rugged, slippery rocks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a red-clad swordsman standing alone in the center of the frame wearing a rain-soaked crimson suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the swordsman slowly raise his arm to draw a gleaming ancient sword from his waist and hold it across his chest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are massive raindrops clearly visible as suspended transparent crystals reflecting light against a gray sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static frame captured in slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03588321432471275 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4108831882476807 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03588321432471275, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03588321432471275, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2574416697025299, + 0.10799387842416763, + 0.13929808139801025, + 0.07003674656152725, + 0.14453549683094025, + 0.07311443984508514, + 0.04617268219590187, + 0.028974464163184166, + 0.048753153532743454, + 0.08367940038442612 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03588321432471275 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a desolate mountaintop with rugged, slippery rocks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a red-clad swordsman standing alone in the center of the frame wearing a rain-soaked crimson suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the swordsman slowly raise his arm to draw a gleaming ancient sword from his waist and hold it across his chest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are massive raindrops clearly visible as suspended transparent crystals reflecting light against a gray sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static frame captured in slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008650331757962704 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758650302886963 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008650331757962704, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008650331757962704, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11061513423919678, + 0.18150034546852112, + 0.10462861508131027, + 0.05481059104204178, + 0.12085577100515366, + 0.11015234887599945, + 0.03129354119300842, + 0.08451660722494125, + 0.08557593077421188, + 0.11605103313922882 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008650331757962704 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a desolate mountaintop with rugged, slippery rocks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a red-clad swordsman standing alone in the center of the frame wearing a rain-soaked crimson suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the swordsman slowly raise his arm to draw a gleaming ancient sword from his waist and hold it across his chest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are massive raindrops clearly visible as suspended transparent crystals reflecting light against a gray sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static frame captured in slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12706369161605835 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.127063751220703 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12706369161605835, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12706369161605835, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1286449283361435, + 0.07877717167139053, + 0.07593580335378647, + 0.06316264718770981, + 0.06864219158887863, + 0.09101010113954544, + 0.06980038434267044, + 0.10598181933164597, + 0.210740327835083, + 0.10730458796024323 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12706369161605835 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a desolate mountaintop with rugged, slippery rocks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a red-clad swordsman standing alone in the center of the frame wearing a rain-soaked crimson suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the swordsman slowly raise his arm to draw a gleaming ancient sword from his waist and hold it across his chest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are massive raindrops clearly visible as suspended transparent crystals reflecting light against a gray sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static frame captured in slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004092888906598091 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504092693328857 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004092888906598091, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004092888906598091, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2955341041088104, + 0.14101354777812958, + 0.0458383746445179, + 0.0354037806391716, + 0.04919452592730522, + 0.05157594755291939, + 0.03955082967877388, + 0.04514903202652931, + 0.04314840957522392, + 0.25359147787094116 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004092888906598091 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a desolate mountaintop with rugged, slippery rocks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a red-clad swordsman standing alone in the center of the frame wearing a rain-soaked crimson suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the swordsman slowly raise his arm to draw a gleaming ancient sword from his waist and hold it across his chest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are massive raindrops clearly visible as suspended transparent crystals reflecting light against a gray sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static frame captured in slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3486242890357971 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2236242294311523 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3486242890357971, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.8749999403953552, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3486242890357971, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14027433097362518, + 0.1489882618188858, + 0.06893149763345718, + 0.07182780653238297, + 0.1887071132659912, + 0.05494992062449455, + 0.039296653121709824, + 0.05365442857146263, + 0.14141421020030975, + 0.0919557437300682 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3486242890357971 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "grand, long, static shot places us on a desolate mountaintop shrouded in a torrential downpour. Shot in a stunning slow motion, the world seems frozen in time. At the center of the frame, a red-clad swordsman stands alone on the rugged, slippery rocks. He wears a rain-soaked crimson suit, the damp fabric clinging to his muscular frame, outlining his defined muscles. His long, dark hair, dampened by the rain, tangled strands plastered to his forehead and cheeks, highlighting his hawk-like eyes and furrowed brow, a fierce, untouchable aura woven between them. With a calm and resolute gesture, he slowly raises his arm, draws a gleaming ancient sword from his waist, and holds it firmly across his chest. During this process, every massive raindrop falling from the sky is clearly visible, like suspended transparent crystals, reflecting a faint light against the gray sky. Some slowly streak across the camera, while others collide and explode on his resolute face, scarlet clothes, and the mirror-like blade of his sword, splashing out circles of miniature, crystal-clear water crowns. The entire scene is gloomy, with only that hint of red, like a burning flame, forming a sharp contrast with the cold rain and gray rocks, creating a lonely, tense, and epic atmosphere of fate.", + "seed": 32650, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_13/index_2062_seed_32650_dp_26_rank_52_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.17769420966506005, + "vlm_logprob": -0.17769420966506005, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.675, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.17769420966506005, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a desolate mountaintop with rugged, slippery rocks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a red-clad swordsman standing alone in the center of the frame wearing a rain-soaked crimson suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the swordsman slowly raise his arm to draw a gleaming ancient sword from his waist and hold it across his chest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are massive raindrops clearly visible as suspended transparent crystals reflecting light against a gray sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static frame captured in slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06448078900575638 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.814480781555176 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06448078900575638, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06448078900575638, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.36942559480667114, + 0.058135539293289185, + 0.01677682250738144, + 0.047270290553569794, + 0.13242797553539276, + 0.040456660091876984, + 0.06069917976856232, + 0.036432698369026184, + 0.19377142190933228, + 0.04460376128554344 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06448078900575638 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a desolate mountaintop with rugged, slippery rocks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a red-clad swordsman standing alone in the center of the frame wearing a rain-soaked crimson suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the swordsman slowly raise his arm to draw a gleaming ancient sword from his waist and hold it across his chest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are massive raindrops clearly visible as suspended transparent crystals reflecting light against a gray sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static frame captured in slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016091007739305496 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.1410908699035645 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016091007739305496, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016091007739305496, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3969936668872833, + 0.029515232890844345, + 0.021451134234666824, + 0.034489184617996216, + 0.05336887389421463, + 0.08363942056894302, + 0.05830511078238487, + 0.024317806586623192, + 0.13170143961906433, + 0.16621817648410797 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016091007739305496 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a desolate mountaintop with rugged, slippery rocks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a red-clad swordsman standing alone in the center of the frame wearing a rain-soaked crimson suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the swordsman slowly raise his arm to draw a gleaming ancient sword from his waist and hold it across his chest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are massive raindrops clearly visible as suspended transparent crystals reflecting light against a gray sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static frame captured in slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10033037513494492 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.350330352783203 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10033037513494492, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10033037513494492, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15937232971191406, + 0.03081635944545269, + 0.019159143790602684, + 0.02200428396463394, + 0.02056916430592537, + 0.046016957610845566, + 0.025064237415790558, + 0.019656717777252197, + 0.4469572901725769, + 0.21038344502449036 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10033037513494492 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a desolate mountaintop with rugged, slippery rocks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a red-clad swordsman standing alone in the center of the frame wearing a rain-soaked crimson suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the swordsman slowly raise his arm to draw a gleaming ancient sword from his waist and hold it across his chest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are massive raindrops clearly visible as suspended transparent crystals reflecting light against a gray sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static frame captured in slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014194242656230927 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264194011688232 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014194242656230927, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014194242656230927, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12229487299919128, + 0.05107870325446129, + 0.014430324546992779, + 0.03804313391447067, + 0.05828579142689705, + 0.11410143226385117, + 0.11355934292078018, + 0.20626398921012878, + 0.1802586317062378, + 0.10168380290269852 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014194242656230927 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a desolate mountaintop with rugged, slippery rocks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a red-clad swordsman standing alone in the center of the frame wearing a rain-soaked crimson suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the swordsman slowly raise his arm to draw a gleaming ancient sword from his waist and hold it across his chest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are massive raindrops clearly visible as suspended transparent crystals reflecting light against a gray sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static frame captured in slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6933746337890625 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6933746337890625 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.6933746337890625, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.6933746337890625, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07993468642234802, + 0.032727472484111786, + 0.0386851541697979, + 0.03504664823412895, + 0.21376217901706696, + 0.16711263358592987, + 0.04754849895834923, + 0.15613599121570587, + 0.13378167152404785, + 0.09526510536670685 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.6933746337890625 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "grand, long, static shot places us on a desolate mountaintop shrouded in a torrential downpour. Shot in a stunning slow motion, the world seems frozen in time. At the center of the frame, a red-clad swordsman stands alone on the rugged, slippery rocks. He wears a rain-soaked crimson suit, the damp fabric clinging to his muscular frame, outlining his defined muscles. His long, dark hair, dampened by the rain, tangled strands plastered to his forehead and cheeks, highlighting his hawk-like eyes and furrowed brow, a fierce, untouchable aura woven between them. With a calm and resolute gesture, he slowly raises his arm, draws a gleaming ancient sword from his waist, and holds it firmly across his chest. During this process, every massive raindrop falling from the sky is clearly visible, like suspended transparent crystals, reflecting a faint light against the gray sky. Some slowly streak across the camera, while others collide and explode on his resolute face, scarlet clothes, and the mirror-like blade of his sword, splashing out circles of miniature, crystal-clear water crowns. The entire scene is gloomy, with only that hint of red, like a burning flame, forming a sharp contrast with the cold rain and gray rocks, creating a lonely, tense, and epic atmosphere of fate.", + "seed": 32651, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_13/index_2062_seed_32651_dp_27_rank_54_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.12851104158908128, + "vlm_logprob": -0.12851104158908128, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.7, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.12851104158908128, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a desolate mountaintop with rugged, slippery rocks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a red-clad swordsman standing alone in the center of the frame wearing a rain-soaked crimson suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the swordsman slowly raise his arm to draw a gleaming ancient sword from his waist and hold it across his chest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are massive raindrops clearly visible as suspended transparent crystals reflecting light against a gray sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static frame captured in slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10221432149410248 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3522143363952637 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10221432149410248, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10221432149410248, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10916609317064285, + 0.07803281396627426, + 0.08178924024105072, + 0.5320202708244324, + 0.034248922020196915, + 0.055432360619306564, + 0.02640528418123722, + 0.031733717769384384, + 0.013747166842222214, + 0.03742419183254242 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10221432149410248 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a desolate mountaintop with rugged, slippery rocks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a red-clad swordsman standing alone in the center of the frame wearing a rain-soaked crimson suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the swordsman slowly raise his arm to draw a gleaming ancient sword from his waist and hold it across his chest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are massive raindrops clearly visible as suspended transparent crystals reflecting light against a gray sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static frame captured in slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014217277988791466 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264217376708984 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014217277988791466, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014217277988791466, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15732696652412415, + 0.1275763213634491, + 0.03616774082183838, + 0.09136021137237549, + 0.10318801552057266, + 0.07879723608493805, + 0.24922822415828705, + 0.09099080413579941, + 0.03614963963627815, + 0.029214810580015182 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014217277988791466 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a desolate mountaintop with rugged, slippery rocks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a red-clad swordsman standing alone in the center of the frame wearing a rain-soaked crimson suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the swordsman slowly raise his arm to draw a gleaming ancient sword from his waist and hold it across his chest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are massive raindrops clearly visible as suspended transparent crystals reflecting light against a gray sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static frame captured in slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3134787082672119 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.313478708267212 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3134787082672119, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3134787082672119, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06113564223051071, + 0.04753660783171654, + 0.025590145960450172, + 0.017505303025245667, + 0.05453334376215935, + 0.042689982801675797, + 0.4418427050113678, + 0.16841550171375275, + 0.08738182485103607, + 0.053368911147117615 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3134787082672119 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a desolate mountaintop with rugged, slippery rocks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a red-clad swordsman standing alone in the center of the frame wearing a rain-soaked crimson suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the swordsman slowly raise his arm to draw a gleaming ancient sword from his waist and hold it across his chest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are massive raindrops clearly visible as suspended transparent crystals reflecting light against a gray sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static frame captured in slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011074270121753216 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511074066162109 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011074270121753216, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011074270121753216, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09082922339439392, + 0.040479984134435654, + 0.05253642797470093, + 0.14501354098320007, + 0.051281969994306564, + 0.12158945947885513, + 0.27784109115600586, + 0.10313752293586731, + 0.0541461817920208, + 0.06314464658498764 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011074270121753216 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a desolate mountaintop with rugged, slippery rocks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a red-clad swordsman standing alone in the center of the frame wearing a rain-soaked crimson suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the swordsman slowly raise his arm to draw a gleaming ancient sword from his waist and hold it across his chest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are massive raindrops clearly visible as suspended transparent crystals reflecting light against a gray sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static frame captured in slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20157063007354736 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7015706300735474 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20157063007354736, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20157063007354736, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07276541739702225, + 0.1157747209072113, + 0.051741693168878555, + 0.04218478500843048, + 0.09834791719913483, + 0.048847924917936325, + 0.26432037353515625, + 0.15077999234199524, + 0.06535632163286209, + 0.08988089859485626 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20157063007354736 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "grand, long, static shot places us on a desolate mountaintop shrouded in a torrential downpour. Shot in a stunning slow motion, the world seems frozen in time. At the center of the frame, a red-clad swordsman stands alone on the rugged, slippery rocks. He wears a rain-soaked crimson suit, the damp fabric clinging to his muscular frame, outlining his defined muscles. His long, dark hair, dampened by the rain, tangled strands plastered to his forehead and cheeks, highlighting his hawk-like eyes and furrowed brow, a fierce, untouchable aura woven between them. With a calm and resolute gesture, he slowly raises his arm, draws a gleaming ancient sword from his waist, and holds it firmly across his chest. During this process, every massive raindrop falling from the sky is clearly visible, like suspended transparent crystals, reflecting a faint light against the gray sky. Some slowly streak across the camera, while others collide and explode on his resolute face, scarlet clothes, and the mirror-like blade of his sword, splashing out circles of miniature, crystal-clear water crowns. The entire scene is gloomy, with only that hint of red, like a burning flame, forming a sharp contrast with the cold rain and gray rocks, creating a lonely, tense, and epic atmosphere of fate.", + "seed": 32652, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_13/index_2062_seed_32652_dp_27_rank_54_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.10832354174926877, + "vlm_logprob": -0.10832354174926877, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.175, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.10832354174926877, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a desolate mountaintop with rugged, slippery rocks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a red-clad swordsman standing alone in the center of the frame wearing a rain-soaked crimson suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the swordsman slowly raise his arm to draw a gleaming ancient sword from his waist and hold it across his chest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are massive raindrops clearly visible as suspended transparent crystals reflecting light against a gray sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static frame captured in slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029523706063628197 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6545236110687256 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029523706063628197, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029523706063628197, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3884091377258301, + 0.09515120834112167, + 0.04958238825201988, + 0.075447678565979, + 0.11240699887275696, + 0.02848641201853752, + 0.05701129883527756, + 0.04644374921917915, + 0.06225714087486267, + 0.08480405807495117 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029523706063628197 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a desolate mountaintop with rugged, slippery rocks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a red-clad swordsman standing alone in the center of the frame wearing a rain-soaked crimson suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the swordsman slowly raise his arm to draw a gleaming ancient sword from his waist and hold it across his chest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are massive raindrops clearly visible as suspended transparent crystals reflecting light against a gray sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static frame captured in slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00764515670016408 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882645130157471 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00764515670016408, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00764515670016408, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16941267251968384, + 0.11211855709552765, + 0.11304321885108948, + 0.2480027675628662, + 0.10265481472015381, + 0.042476627975702286, + 0.04166339337825775, + 0.06093684956431389, + 0.04379918798804283, + 0.06589189916849136 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00764515670016408 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a desolate mountaintop with rugged, slippery rocks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a red-clad swordsman standing alone in the center of the frame wearing a rain-soaked crimson suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the swordsman slowly raise his arm to draw a gleaming ancient sword from his waist and hold it across his chest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are massive raindrops clearly visible as suspended transparent crystals reflecting light against a gray sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static frame captured in slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.054969415068626404 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929969310760498 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.054969415068626404, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.054969415068626404, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13568773865699768, + 0.09225514531135559, + 0.1030745729804039, + 0.13516315817832947, + 0.1291656792163849, + 0.04770141467452049, + 0.01983005180954933, + 0.07225485146045685, + 0.18382562696933746, + 0.08104176074266434 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.054969415068626404 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a desolate mountaintop with rugged, slippery rocks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a red-clad swordsman standing alone in the center of the frame wearing a rain-soaked crimson suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the swordsman slowly raise his arm to draw a gleaming ancient sword from his waist and hold it across his chest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are massive raindrops clearly visible as suspended transparent crystals reflecting light against a gray sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static frame captured in slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02057892084121704 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955788612365723 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02057892084121704, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02057892084121704, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21468116343021393, + 0.403190940618515, + 0.046637874096632004, + 0.12544360756874084, + 0.031578656286001205, + 0.016309380531311035, + 0.026086024940013885, + 0.022564172744750977, + 0.02694055624306202, + 0.08656759560108185 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02057892084121704 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a desolate mountaintop with rugged, slippery rocks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a red-clad swordsman standing alone in the center of the frame wearing a rain-soaked crimson suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the swordsman slowly raise his arm to draw a gleaming ancient sword from his waist and hold it across his chest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are massive raindrops clearly visible as suspended transparent crystals reflecting light against a gray sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static frame captured in slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.42890051007270813 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.0539004802703857 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.42890051007270813, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.42890051007270813, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09869343042373657, + 0.087884321808815, + 0.08813977241516113, + 0.13800713419914246, + 0.17224211990833282, + 0.055403802543878555, + 0.028725406154990196, + 0.06123089790344238, + 0.08880467712879181, + 0.18086837232112885 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.42890051007270813 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_14/index_tensor([767, 767])_group_14_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_14/index_tensor([767, 767])_group_14_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..0029b08d38c6494f210aef7a67996337227a9bd3 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_14/index_tensor([767, 767])_group_14_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "static, low-angle, wide-angle shot captures the emptiness of a late-night grocery store aisle. The floor, made of highly polished white linoleum, reflects the cold, buzzing green-white glare of the overhead fluorescent lights, creating a sterile and unsettling environment. Towering shelves line the aisles, perfectly stocked with generic, unlabeled boxes and cans, casting long, dark shadows that stretch into the deep background. In the very center of the frame sits a lone, slightly worn metal shopping cart, its chrome wire basket gleaming in the harsh light, its red plastic handle faded. Initially completely still, the cart begins to tremble slightly, a faint vibration that develops into a violent, convulsive shudder. Its entire metal frame wobbles unsteadily, and its small, black wheels begin to rattle violently and loudly against the polished floor. The sharp, rattling sound echoes uncomfortably throughout the desolate space, creating a tense and deeply unsettling atmosphere of unseen forces at work.", + "seed": 10782, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_14/index_767_seed_10782_dp_28_rank_56_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.12772522475570441, + "vlm_logprob": -0.12772522475570441, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.15, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.12772522475570441, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an empty late-night grocery store aisle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the floor made of highly polished white linoleum reflecting green-white light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a lone, slightly worn metal shopping cart with a red plastic handle visible in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the shopping cart begin to tremble and shudder violently while its wheels rattle against the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a static, low-angle, wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05625815689563751 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.931258201599121 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05625815689563751, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05625815689563751, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1981690376996994, + 0.09718085080385208, + 0.06455626338720322, + 0.08791976422071457, + 0.05542333424091339, + 0.03979986533522606, + 0.09733887761831284, + 0.1371058225631714, + 0.14324668049812317, + 0.07925951480865479 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05625815689563751 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an empty late-night grocery store aisle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the floor made of highly polished white linoleum reflecting green-white light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a lone, slightly worn metal shopping cart with a red plastic handle visible in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the shopping cart begin to tremble and shudder violently while its wheels rattle against the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a static, low-angle, wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.038118645548820496 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288118600845337 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.038118645548820496, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.038118645548820496, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09900876879692078, + 0.054446376860141754, + 0.03816753625869751, + 0.012062886729836464, + 0.018444012850522995, + 0.020283112302422523, + 0.03957496955990791, + 0.11321159452199936, + 0.5251278877258301, + 0.07967288792133331 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.038118645548820496 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an empty late-night grocery store aisle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the floor made of highly polished white linoleum reflecting green-white light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a lone, slightly worn metal shopping cart with a red plastic handle visible in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the shopping cart begin to tremble and shudder violently while its wheels rattle against the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a static, low-angle, wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006742938421666622 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.00674295425415 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006742938421666622, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006742938421666622, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1643127202987671, + 0.08861222118139267, + 0.04624233394861221, + 0.029758771881461143, + 0.03782391920685768, + 0.04853007569909096, + 0.07121314108371735, + 0.12402821332216263, + 0.3173915445804596, + 0.07208704203367233 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006742938421666622 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an empty late-night grocery store aisle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the floor made of highly polished white linoleum reflecting green-white light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a lone, slightly worn metal shopping cart with a red plastic handle visible in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the shopping cart begin to tremble and shudder violently while its wheels rattle against the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a static, low-angle, wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.523307204246521 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.898307204246521 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.523307204246521, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.523307204246521, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1550350934267044, + 0.13238537311553955, + 0.08955970406532288, + 0.053459711372852325, + 0.026248423382639885, + 0.031638652086257935, + 0.07581045478582382, + 0.2562186121940613, + 0.08321215212345123, + 0.09643188118934631 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.523307204246521 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an empty late-night grocery store aisle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the floor made of highly polished white linoleum reflecting green-white light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a lone, slightly worn metal shopping cart with a red plastic handle visible in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the shopping cart begin to tremble and shudder violently while its wheels rattle against the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a static, low-angle, wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014199178665876389 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264199256896973 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014199178665876389, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014199178665876389, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15606635808944702, + 0.09385302662849426, + 0.05879702419042587, + 0.0404018834233284, + 0.07296431809663773, + 0.031202631071209908, + 0.08922960609197617, + 0.1552034318447113, + 0.20499350130558014, + 0.09728819876909256 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014199178665876389 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, low-angle, wide-angle shot captures the emptiness of a late-night grocery store aisle. The floor, made of highly polished white linoleum, reflects the cold, buzzing green-white glare of the overhead fluorescent lights, creating a sterile and unsettling environment. Towering shelves line the aisles, perfectly stocked with generic, unlabeled boxes and cans, casting long, dark shadows that stretch into the deep background. In the very center of the frame sits a lone, slightly worn metal shopping cart, its chrome wire basket gleaming in the harsh light, its red plastic handle faded. Initially completely still, the cart begins to tremble slightly, a faint vibration that develops into a violent, convulsive shudder. Its entire metal frame wobbles unsteadily, and its small, black wheels begin to rattle violently and loudly against the polished floor. The sharp, rattling sound echoes uncomfortably throughout the desolate space, creating a tense and deeply unsettling atmosphere of unseen forces at work.", + "seed": 10783, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_14/index_767_seed_10783_dp_28_rank_56_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.09483897136524319, + "vlm_logprob": -0.09483897136524319, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.474999988079071, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.09483897136524319, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an empty late-night grocery store aisle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the floor made of highly polished white linoleum reflecting green-white light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a lone, slightly worn metal shopping cart with a red plastic handle visible in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the shopping cart begin to tremble and shudder violently while its wheels rattle against the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a static, low-angle, wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.049358073621988297 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0493581295013428 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.049358073621988297, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.049358073621988297, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14786362648010254, + 0.11870896816253662, + 0.056881945580244064, + 0.02262772247195244, + 0.03664322569966316, + 0.048331886529922485, + 0.4238899350166321, + 0.10376942157745361, + 0.019157789647579193, + 0.022125551477074623 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.049358073621988297 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an empty late-night grocery store aisle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the floor made of highly polished white linoleum reflecting green-white light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a lone, slightly worn metal shopping cart with a red plastic handle visible in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the shopping cart begin to tremble and shudder violently while its wheels rattle against the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a static, low-angle, wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02060040831565857 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8956003189086914 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02060040831565857, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02060040831565857, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10364311188459396, + 0.06125699728727341, + 0.03199217468500137, + 0.015199614688754082, + 0.025732561945915222, + 0.07324256002902985, + 0.5307612419128418, + 0.10353963077068329, + 0.017215203493833542, + 0.03741687536239624 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02060040831565857 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an empty late-night grocery store aisle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the floor made of highly polished white linoleum reflecting green-white light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a lone, slightly worn metal shopping cart with a red plastic handle visible in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the shopping cart begin to tremble and shudder violently while its wheels rattle against the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a static, low-angle, wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004642778541892767 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379642963409424 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004642778541892767, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004642778541892767, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15212704241275787, + 0.07280684262514114, + 0.03099777363240719, + 0.02701488882303238, + 0.020914312452077866, + 0.08108041435480118, + 0.4172722101211548, + 0.12464481592178345, + 0.03338737413287163, + 0.03975430503487587 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004642778541892767 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an empty late-night grocery store aisle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the floor made of highly polished white linoleum reflecting green-white light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a lone, slightly worn metal shopping cart with a red plastic handle visible in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the shopping cart begin to tremble and shudder violently while its wheels rattle against the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a static, low-angle, wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.38705235719680786 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.137052297592163 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.38705235719680786, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.7499999403953552, + "token_credit_reward": -0.38705235719680786, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15388046205043793, + 0.08177173137664795, + 0.049176186323165894, + 0.055668581277132034, + 0.07687542587518692, + 0.04269372299313545, + 0.13389499485492706, + 0.2077924907207489, + 0.052316151559352875, + 0.14593030512332916 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.38705235719680786 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an empty late-night grocery store aisle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the floor made of highly polished white linoleum reflecting green-white light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a lone, slightly worn metal shopping cart with a red plastic handle visible in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the shopping cart begin to tremble and shudder violently while its wheels rattle against the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a static, low-angle, wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012541239149868488 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.3875412940979 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012541239149868488, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012541239149868488, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13705557584762573, + 0.05218805745244026, + 0.026551060378551483, + 0.050195932388305664, + 0.08325190097093582, + 0.059479717165231705, + 0.453760027885437, + 0.06948482990264893, + 0.04476189240813255, + 0.02327103354036808 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012541239149868488 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, low-angle, wide-angle shot captures the emptiness of a late-night grocery store aisle. The floor, made of highly polished white linoleum, reflects the cold, buzzing green-white glare of the overhead fluorescent lights, creating a sterile and unsettling environment. Towering shelves line the aisles, perfectly stocked with generic, unlabeled boxes and cans, casting long, dark shadows that stretch into the deep background. In the very center of the frame sits a lone, slightly worn metal shopping cart, its chrome wire basket gleaming in the harsh light, its red plastic handle faded. Initially completely still, the cart begins to tremble slightly, a faint vibration that develops into a violent, convulsive shudder. Its entire metal frame wobbles unsteadily, and its small, black wheels begin to rattle violently and loudly against the polished floor. The sharp, rattling sound echoes uncomfortably throughout the desolate space, creating a tense and deeply unsettling atmosphere of unseen forces at work.", + "seed": 10784, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_14/index_767_seed_10784_dp_29_rank_58_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.10711763426661491, + "vlm_logprob": -0.10711763426661491, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.1499999523162843, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.10711763426661491, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an empty late-night grocery store aisle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the floor made of highly polished white linoleum reflecting green-white light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a lone, slightly worn metal shopping cart with a red plastic handle visible in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the shopping cart begin to tremble and shudder violently while its wheels rattle against the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a static, low-angle, wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07129553705453873 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6962954998016357 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07129553705453873, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07129553705453873, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.264192134141922, + 0.042345836758613586, + 0.08158176392316818, + 0.025021342560648918, + 0.07644850760698318, + 0.021470284089446068, + 0.028036950156092644, + 0.06316856294870377, + 0.3342985510826111, + 0.06343600898981094 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07129553705453873 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an empty late-night grocery store aisle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the floor made of highly polished white linoleum reflecting green-white light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a lone, slightly worn metal shopping cart with a red plastic handle visible in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the shopping cart begin to tremble and shudder violently while its wheels rattle against the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a static, low-angle, wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.054967496544122696 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299674034118652 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.054967496544122696, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.054967496544122696, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14180530607700348, + 0.04311845079064369, + 0.026211736723780632, + 0.031172914430499077, + 0.024816319346427917, + 0.025868622586131096, + 0.047337695956230164, + 0.2093830704689026, + 0.34848281741142273, + 0.10180303454399109 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.054967496544122696 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an empty late-night grocery store aisle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the floor made of highly polished white linoleum reflecting green-white light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a lone, slightly worn metal shopping cart with a red plastic handle visible in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the shopping cart begin to tremble and shudder violently while its wheels rattle against the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a static, low-angle, wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004095619544386864 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504095554351807 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004095619544386864, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004095619544386864, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18399330973625183, + 0.12899619340896606, + 0.10803943872451782, + 0.06316529959440231, + 0.062998928129673, + 0.05307982861995697, + 0.041452955454587936, + 0.0917586088180542, + 0.1843651682138443, + 0.08215025067329407 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004095619544386864 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an empty late-night grocery store aisle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the floor made of highly polished white linoleum reflecting green-white light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a lone, slightly worn metal shopping cart with a red plastic handle visible in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the shopping cart begin to tremble and shudder violently while its wheels rattle against the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a static, low-angle, wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.38704654574394226 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1370465755462646 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.38704654574394226, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.38704654574394226, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12462474405765533, + 0.09186587482690811, + 0.09562414139509201, + 0.029035234823822975, + 0.05601648986339569, + 0.03730121627449989, + 0.02428397350013256, + 0.05413563922047615, + 0.4406628906726837, + 0.04644981771707535 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.38704654574394226 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an empty late-night grocery store aisle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the floor made of highly polished white linoleum reflecting green-white light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a lone, slightly worn metal shopping cart with a red plastic handle visible in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the shopping cart begin to tremble and shudder violently while its wheels rattle against the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a static, low-angle, wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018182972446084023 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018182754516602 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018182972446084023, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018182972446084023, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2666845917701721, + 0.05348486825823784, + 0.07027915865182877, + 0.02562108263373375, + 0.04190840572118759, + 0.030090127140283585, + 0.07966936379671097, + 0.10707588493824005, + 0.25433024764060974, + 0.07085627317428589 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018182972446084023 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, low-angle, wide-angle shot captures the emptiness of a late-night grocery store aisle. The floor, made of highly polished white linoleum, reflects the cold, buzzing green-white glare of the overhead fluorescent lights, creating a sterile and unsettling environment. Towering shelves line the aisles, perfectly stocked with generic, unlabeled boxes and cans, casting long, dark shadows that stretch into the deep background. In the very center of the frame sits a lone, slightly worn metal shopping cart, its chrome wire basket gleaming in the harsh light, its red plastic handle faded. Initially completely still, the cart begins to tremble slightly, a faint vibration that develops into a violent, convulsive shudder. Its entire metal frame wobbles unsteadily, and its small, black wheels begin to rattle violently and loudly against the polished floor. The sharp, rattling sound echoes uncomfortably throughout the desolate space, creating a tense and deeply unsettling atmosphere of unseen forces at work.", + "seed": 10785, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_14/index_767_seed_10785_dp_29_rank_58_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.0887652832083404, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0887652832083404, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.225, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0887652832083404, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an empty late-night grocery store aisle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the floor made of highly polished white linoleum reflecting green-white light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a lone, slightly worn metal shopping cart with a red plastic handle visible in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the shopping cart begin to tremble and shudder violently while its wheels rattle against the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a static, low-angle, wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07130630314350128 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6963062286376953 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07130630314350128, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07130630314350128, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.37888455390930176, + 0.15529057383537292, + 0.01613759435713291, + 0.0563691109418869, + 0.049757666885852814, + 0.03428604081273079, + 0.12064298987388611, + 0.07416247576475143, + 0.053294260054826736, + 0.061174701899290085 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07130630314350128 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an empty late-night grocery store aisle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the floor made of highly polished white linoleum reflecting green-white light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a lone, slightly worn metal shopping cart with a red plastic handle visible in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the shopping cart begin to tremble and shudder violently while its wheels rattle against the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a static, low-angle, wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.038126446306705475 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881264686584473 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.038126446306705475, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.038126446306705475, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4350404739379883, + 0.1718548685312271, + 0.12345238029956818, + 0.024845151230692863, + 0.03406750038266182, + 0.06981075555086136, + 0.04108013957738876, + 0.025147737935185432, + 0.04167325794696808, + 0.0330277681350708 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.038126446306705475 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an empty late-night grocery store aisle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the floor made of highly polished white linoleum reflecting green-white light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a lone, slightly worn metal shopping cart with a red plastic handle visible in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the shopping cart begin to tremble and shudder violently while its wheels rattle against the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a static, low-angle, wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00674353027716279 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006743431091309 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00674353027716279, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00674353027716279, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.404593288898468, + 0.1617979258298874, + 0.09596914798021317, + 0.021458204835653305, + 0.04349285736680031, + 0.04643453657627106, + 0.06276429444551468, + 0.04459739103913307, + 0.0819859728217125, + 0.0369064137339592 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00674353027716279 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an empty late-night grocery store aisle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the floor made of highly polished white linoleum reflecting green-white light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a lone, slightly worn metal shopping cart with a red plastic handle visible in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the shopping cart begin to tremble and shudder violently while its wheels rattle against the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a static, low-angle, wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.31345483660697937 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3134548664093018 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.31345483660697937, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.31345483660697937, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08476967364549637, + 0.09239604324102402, + 0.18058890104293823, + 0.08614972978830338, + 0.04732554405927658, + 0.17587974667549133, + 0.0966564193367958, + 0.02847099117934704, + 0.07556481659412384, + 0.13219815492630005 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.31345483660697937 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an empty late-night grocery store aisle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the floor made of highly polished white linoleum reflecting green-white light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a lone, slightly worn metal shopping cart with a red plastic handle visible in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the shopping cart begin to tremble and shudder violently while its wheels rattle against the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a static, low-angle, wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014195299707353115 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264195442199707 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014195299707353115, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014195299707353115, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.137959823012352, + 0.04755496606230736, + 0.02875535376369953, + 0.14311663806438446, + 0.09441813826560974, + 0.06691402941942215, + 0.016230696812272072, + 0.22811558842658997, + 0.037226200103759766, + 0.19970858097076416 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014195299707353115 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_15/index_tensor([6735, 6735])_group_15_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_15/index_tensor([6735, 6735])_group_15_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..b44d213fb30b3825fe9d214a70d9a81186f8a525 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_15/index_tensor([6735, 6735])_group_15_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "stunning, static macro shot immerses the viewer in a scene of culinary artistry, focusing on a whole braised grouper presented in an exotic, high-end setting. The fish, its form intact from head to tail, rests on a minimalist, dark gray stone platter. Under a warm, focused spotlight, its skin gleams, its deep red soy glaze so smooth it reflects the light like polished varnish. Below the glaze, the flesh is pearlescent, delicate and tender, its jagged veins visible in minute detail. From just out of the frame, the curved bowl of a dark ceramic spoon enters the shot, steadily and deliberately tilted, pouring a fresh layer of rich sauce. The thick, syrupy liquid cascades down, creating slow, mesmerizing ripples that expand in concentric circles across the fish's shimmering surface and flow lazily along its sides. Set against a softly blurred background that suggests a luxurious dining setting, the entire scene evokes a powerful sense of sensual indulgence and dedicated craftsmanship, climaxing with the hypnotic movement of the sauce coating the pearly flesh before the visual sequence abruptly ends.", + "seed": 18145, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_15/index_6735_seed_18145_dp_30_rank_60_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.04292681682854891, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04292681682854891, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.799999976158142, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04292681682854891, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a whole braised grouper with its form intact from head to tail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the grouper resting on a minimalist, dark gray stone platter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a dark ceramic spoon enter the frame from the side to pour a fresh layer of rich sauce?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the poured sauce create slow, mesmerizing ripples that expand in concentric circles across the fish's surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background softly blurred to suggest a luxurious dining setting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04002764821052551 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.290027618408203 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04002764821052551, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04002764821052551, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1629849374294281, + 0.06013023853302002, + 0.12351581454277039, + 0.12061432749032974, + 0.06067796051502228, + 0.030809614807367325, + 0.1583252102136612, + 0.1919621378183365, + 0.027408458292484283, + 0.06357134878635406 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04002764821052551 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a whole braised grouper with its form intact from head to tail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the grouper resting on a minimalist, dark gray stone platter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a dark ceramic spoon enter the frame from the side to pour a fresh layer of rich sauce?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the poured sauce create slow, mesmerizing ripples that expand in concentric circles across the fish's surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background softly blurred to suggest a luxurious dining setting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1428004503250122 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0178003311157227 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1428004503250122, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.8749998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1428004503250122, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10105369985103607, + 0.09275665134191513, + 0.06089940294623375, + 0.08031708747148514, + 0.050508514046669006, + 0.024793218821287155, + 0.1240994781255722, + 0.3832319378852844, + 0.028225289657711983, + 0.05411474406719208 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1428004503250122 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a whole braised grouper with its form intact from head to tail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the grouper resting on a minimalist, dark gray stone platter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a dark ceramic spoon enter the frame from the side to pour a fresh layer of rich sauce?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the poured sauce create slow, mesmerizing ripples that expand in concentric circles across the fish's surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background softly blurred to suggest a luxurious dining setting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009788726456463337 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634788513183594 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009788726456463337, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009788726456463337, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10717228055000305, + 0.17102079093456268, + 0.03775054216384888, + 0.08122475445270538, + 0.17459452152252197, + 0.026624182239174843, + 0.22798191010951996, + 0.1171160340309143, + 0.033366817981004715, + 0.023148108273744583 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009788726456463337 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a whole braised grouper with its form intact from head to tail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the grouper resting on a minimalist, dark gray stone platter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a dark ceramic spoon enter the frame from the side to pour a fresh layer of rich sauce?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the poured sauce create slow, mesmerizing ripples that expand in concentric circles across the fish's surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background softly blurred to suggest a luxurious dining setting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01607259176671505 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141072750091553 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01607259176671505, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01607259176671505, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11984751373529434, + 0.12562818825244904, + 0.0706123635172844, + 0.05235564336180687, + 0.12600530683994293, + 0.028991296887397766, + 0.1790906935930252, + 0.25224772095680237, + 0.02258698083460331, + 0.02263423055410385 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01607259176671505 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a whole braised grouper with its form intact from head to tail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the grouper resting on a minimalist, dark gray stone platter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a dark ceramic spoon enter the frame from the side to pour a fresh layer of rich sauce?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the poured sauce create slow, mesmerizing ripples that expand in concentric circles across the fish's surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background softly blurred to suggest a luxurious dining setting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005944667384028435 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130944728851318 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005944667384028435, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005944667384028435, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.01789025403559208, + 0.03133704140782356, + 0.05317842960357666, + 0.13066557049751282, + 0.017154959961771965, + 0.03432922437787056, + 0.3007570207118988, + 0.3009900152683258, + 0.027152087539434433, + 0.0865454450249672 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005944667384028435 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "stunning, static macro shot immerses the viewer in a scene of culinary artistry, focusing on a whole braised grouper presented in an exotic, high-end setting. The fish, its form intact from head to tail, rests on a minimalist, dark gray stone platter. Under a warm, focused spotlight, its skin gleams, its deep red soy glaze so smooth it reflects the light like polished varnish. Below the glaze, the flesh is pearlescent, delicate and tender, its jagged veins visible in minute detail. From just out of the frame, the curved bowl of a dark ceramic spoon enters the shot, steadily and deliberately tilted, pouring a fresh layer of rich sauce. The thick, syrupy liquid cascades down, creating slow, mesmerizing ripples that expand in concentric circles across the fish's shimmering surface and flow lazily along its sides. Set against a softly blurred background that suggests a luxurious dining setting, the entire scene evokes a powerful sense of sensual indulgence and dedicated craftsmanship, climaxing with the hypnotic movement of the sauce coating the pearly flesh before the visual sequence abruptly ends.", + "seed": 18146, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_15/index_6735_seed_18146_dp_30_rank_60_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.17549209902063012, + "vlm_logprob": -0.17549209902063012, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.75, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.17549209902063012, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a whole braised grouper with its form intact from head to tail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the grouper resting on a minimalist, dark gray stone platter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a dark ceramic spoon enter the frame from the side to pour a fresh layer of rich sauce?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the poured sauce create slow, mesmerizing ripples that expand in concentric circles across the fish's surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background softly blurred to suggest a luxurious dining setting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2308001071214676 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6058001518249512 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2308001071214676, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2308001071214676, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17008709907531738, + 0.05762835592031479, + 0.05912806838750839, + 0.06662334501743317, + 0.09731171280145645, + 0.17212985455989838, + 0.09492337703704834, + 0.0740744024515152, + 0.05777481570839882, + 0.1503189355134964 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2308001071214676 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a whole braised grouper with its form intact from head to tail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the grouper resting on a minimalist, dark gray stone platter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a dark ceramic spoon enter the frame from the side to pour a fresh layer of rich sauce?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the poured sauce create slow, mesmerizing ripples that expand in concentric circles across the fish's surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background softly blurred to suggest a luxurious dining setting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5761463642120361 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8261463642120361 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5761463642120361, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5761463642120361, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10034143924713135, + 0.09273520112037659, + 0.07863523066043854, + 0.032077252864837646, + 0.05775246396660805, + 0.05821438506245613, + 0.03415877744555473, + 0.021767793223261833, + 0.04793928936123848, + 0.4763782024383545 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5761463642120361 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a whole braised grouper with its form intact from head to tail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the grouper resting on a minimalist, dark gray stone platter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a dark ceramic spoon enter the frame from the side to pour a fresh layer of rich sauce?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the poured sauce create slow, mesmerizing ripples that expand in concentric circles across the fish's surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background softly blurred to suggest a luxurious dining setting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007644447032362223 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.8826446533203125 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007644447032362223, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007644447032362223, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12183713912963867, + 0.1294640749692917, + 0.0961029976606369, + 0.08526694774627686, + 0.058502621948719025, + 0.10594067722558975, + 0.03711593896150589, + 0.14742419123649597, + 0.02157333865761757, + 0.19677209854125977 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007644447032362223 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a whole braised grouper with its form intact from head to tail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the grouper resting on a minimalist, dark gray stone platter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a dark ceramic spoon enter the frame from the side to pour a fresh layer of rich sauce?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the poured sauce create slow, mesmerizing ripples that expand in concentric circles across the fish's surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background softly blurred to suggest a luxurious dining setting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04867521673440933 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048675298690796 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04867521673440933, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04867521673440933, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06780310720205307, + 0.12501096725463867, + 0.13400447368621826, + 0.049283452332019806, + 0.13178420066833496, + 0.10656583309173584, + 0.06057626008987427, + 0.15537874400615692, + 0.05538128316402435, + 0.11421163380146027 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04867521673440933 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a whole braised grouper with its form intact from head to tail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the grouper resting on a minimalist, dark gray stone platter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a dark ceramic spoon enter the frame from the side to pour a fresh layer of rich sauce?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the poured sauce create slow, mesmerizing ripples that expand in concentric circles across the fish's surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background softly blurred to suggest a luxurious dining setting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014194360002875328 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264194488525391 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014194360002875328, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014194360002875328, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18881376087665558, + 0.09906593710184097, + 0.07735581696033478, + 0.07607343047857285, + 0.051960527896881104, + 0.09753187745809555, + 0.07138843089342117, + 0.039495136588811874, + 0.059747517108917236, + 0.2385675460100174 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014194360002875328 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "stunning, static macro shot immerses the viewer in a scene of culinary artistry, focusing on a whole braised grouper presented in an exotic, high-end setting. The fish, its form intact from head to tail, rests on a minimalist, dark gray stone platter. Under a warm, focused spotlight, its skin gleams, its deep red soy glaze so smooth it reflects the light like polished varnish. Below the glaze, the flesh is pearlescent, delicate and tender, its jagged veins visible in minute detail. From just out of the frame, the curved bowl of a dark ceramic spoon enters the shot, steadily and deliberately tilted, pouring a fresh layer of rich sauce. The thick, syrupy liquid cascades down, creating slow, mesmerizing ripples that expand in concentric circles across the fish's shimmering surface and flow lazily along its sides. Set against a softly blurred background that suggests a luxurious dining setting, the entire scene evokes a powerful sense of sensual indulgence and dedicated craftsmanship, climaxing with the hypnotic movement of the sauce coating the pearly flesh before the visual sequence abruptly ends.", + "seed": 18147, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_15/index_6735_seed_18147_dp_31_rank_62_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.06787448879331351, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06787448879331351, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.25, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06787448879331351, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a whole braised grouper with its form intact from head to tail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the grouper resting on a minimalist, dark gray stone platter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a dark ceramic spoon enter the frame from the side to pour a fresh layer of rich sauce?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the poured sauce create slow, mesmerizing ripples that expand in concentric circles across the fish's surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background softly blurred to suggest a luxurious dining setting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05086798965930939 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.050868034362793 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05086798965930939, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05086798965930939, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3941912353038788, + 0.24224454164505005, + 0.06667548418045044, + 0.027421068400144577, + 0.026868345215916634, + 0.044936299324035645, + 0.10422667860984802, + 0.02932042069733143, + 0.04050425440073013, + 0.023611687123775482 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05086798965930939 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a whole braised grouper with its form intact from head to tail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the grouper resting on a minimalist, dark gray stone platter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a dark ceramic spoon enter the frame from the side to pour a fresh layer of rich sauce?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the poured sauce create slow, mesmerizing ripples that expand in concentric circles across the fish's surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background softly blurred to suggest a luxurious dining setting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22559453547000885 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6005945205688477 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.22559453547000885, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.22559453547000885, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15288959443569183, + 0.29093530774116516, + 0.13191623985767365, + 0.03412257507443428, + 0.0838097482919693, + 0.05222748965024948, + 0.04148000851273537, + 0.1549834907054901, + 0.026342643424868584, + 0.0312928669154644 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.22559453547000885 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a whole braised grouper with its form intact from head to tail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the grouper resting on a minimalist, dark gray stone platter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a dark ceramic spoon enter the frame from the side to pour a fresh layer of rich sauce?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the poured sauce create slow, mesmerizing ripples that expand in concentric circles across the fish's surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background softly blurred to suggest a luxurious dining setting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029824240133166313 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298242568969727 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029824240133166313, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029824240133166313, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18578925728797913, + 0.0871223658323288, + 0.24216191470623016, + 0.07274288684129715, + 0.14161235094070435, + 0.07281769812107086, + 0.0389908105134964, + 0.06355047971010208, + 0.03724534809589386, + 0.05796689912676811 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029824240133166313 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a whole braised grouper with its form intact from head to tail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the grouper resting on a minimalist, dark gray stone platter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a dark ceramic spoon enter the frame from the side to pour a fresh layer of rich sauce?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the poured sauce create slow, mesmerizing ripples that expand in concentric circles across the fish's surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background softly blurred to suggest a luxurious dining setting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02330356277525425 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773303508758545 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02330356277525425, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02330356277525425, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19934481382369995, + 0.2030647099018097, + 0.16044138371944427, + 0.0613747164607048, + 0.05179709196090698, + 0.08192490041255951, + 0.04574710130691528, + 0.07166443765163422, + 0.07929645478725433, + 0.04534437507390976 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02330356277525425 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a whole braised grouper with its form intact from head to tail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the grouper resting on a minimalist, dark gray stone platter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a dark ceramic spoon enter the frame from the side to pour a fresh layer of rich sauce?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the poured sauce create slow, mesmerizing ripples that expand in concentric circles across the fish's surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background softly blurred to suggest a luxurious dining setting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009782115928828716 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634782314300537 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009782115928828716, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009782115928828716, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3427611291408539, + 0.0665324479341507, + 0.06997891515493393, + 0.046146459877491, + 0.13813824951648712, + 0.042694155126810074, + 0.08727077394723892, + 0.11803676933050156, + 0.0547221377491951, + 0.033718887716531754 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009782115928828716 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "stunning, static macro shot immerses the viewer in a scene of culinary artistry, focusing on a whole braised grouper presented in an exotic, high-end setting. The fish, its form intact from head to tail, rests on a minimalist, dark gray stone platter. Under a warm, focused spotlight, its skin gleams, its deep red soy glaze so smooth it reflects the light like polished varnish. Below the glaze, the flesh is pearlescent, delicate and tender, its jagged veins visible in minute detail. From just out of the frame, the curved bowl of a dark ceramic spoon enters the shot, steadily and deliberately tilted, pouring a fresh layer of rich sauce. The thick, syrupy liquid cascades down, creating slow, mesmerizing ripples that expand in concentric circles across the fish's shimmering surface and flow lazily along its sides. Set against a softly blurred background that suggests a luxurious dining setting, the entire scene evokes a powerful sense of sensual indulgence and dedicated craftsmanship, climaxing with the hypnotic movement of the sauce coating the pearly flesh before the visual sequence abruptly ends.", + "seed": 18148, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_15/index_6735_seed_18148_dp_31_rank_62_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.0680895283818245, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0680895283818245, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.35, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0680895283818245, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a whole braised grouper with its form intact from head to tail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the grouper resting on a minimalist, dark gray stone platter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a dark ceramic spoon enter the frame from the side to pour a fresh layer of rich sauce?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the poured sauce create slow, mesmerizing ripples that expand in concentric circles across the fish's surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background softly blurred to suggest a luxurious dining setting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02919008396565914 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6541900634765625 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02919008396565914, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02919008396565914, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18986736238002777, + 0.09232645481824875, + 0.09386838972568512, + 0.0794350653886795, + 0.09070586413145065, + 0.052870623767375946, + 0.09883049130439758, + 0.0463075190782547, + 0.16256588697433472, + 0.09322232007980347 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02919008396565914 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a whole braised grouper with its form intact from head to tail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the grouper resting on a minimalist, dark gray stone platter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a dark ceramic spoon enter the frame from the side to pour a fresh layer of rich sauce?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the poured sauce create slow, mesmerizing ripples that expand in concentric circles across the fish's surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background softly blurred to suggest a luxurious dining setting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.252105176448822 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5021052360534668 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.252105176448822, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.252105176448822, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.26274657249450684, + 0.2587510347366333, + 0.03839521110057831, + 0.05836915224790573, + 0.041367314755916595, + 0.05139535292983055, + 0.04856731370091438, + 0.12220118939876556, + 0.04966168850660324, + 0.06854517757892609 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.252105176448822 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a whole braised grouper with its form intact from head to tail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the grouper resting on a minimalist, dark gray stone platter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a dark ceramic spoon enter the frame from the side to pour a fresh layer of rich sauce?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the poured sauce create slow, mesmerizing ripples that expand in concentric circles across the fish's surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background softly blurred to suggest a luxurious dining setting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023317305371165276 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773317337036133 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023317305371165276, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023317305371165276, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08792605251073837, + 0.15167829394340515, + 0.12063959240913391, + 0.15740548074245453, + 0.1620149314403534, + 0.04035017266869545, + 0.034114494919776917, + 0.041376058012247086, + 0.14806793630123138, + 0.05642694607377052 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023317305371165276 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a whole braised grouper with its form intact from head to tail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the grouper resting on a minimalist, dark gray stone platter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a dark ceramic spoon enter the frame from the side to pour a fresh layer of rich sauce?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the poured sauce create slow, mesmerizing ripples that expand in concentric circles across the fish's surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background softly blurred to suggest a luxurious dining setting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023299487307667732 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732994556427 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023299487307667732, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023299487307667732, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1676172912120819, + 0.11531730741262436, + 0.09692659974098206, + 0.1089150607585907, + 0.06284806877374649, + 0.024310415610671043, + 0.09776163846254349, + 0.07121327519416809, + 0.1544910967350006, + 0.10059918463230133 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023299487307667732 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a whole braised grouper with its form intact from head to tail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the grouper resting on a minimalist, dark gray stone platter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a dark ceramic spoon enter the frame from the side to pour a fresh layer of rich sauce?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the poured sauce create slow, mesmerizing ripples that expand in concentric circles across the fish's surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background softly blurred to suggest a luxurious dining setting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012535588815808296 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387535572052002 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012535588815808296, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012535588815808296, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17856982350349426, + 0.0760137140750885, + 0.03582403436303139, + 0.02349488064646721, + 0.037254448980093, + 0.03786194324493408, + 0.06792345643043518, + 0.04098048806190491, + 0.4620622992515564, + 0.04001493752002716 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012535588815808296 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_2/index_tensor([4872, 4872])_group_2_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_2/index_tensor([4872, 4872])_group_2_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..b946919f27bd26f016920067719e3e076bd95d69 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_2/index_tensor([4872, 4872])_group_2_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "low-angle, wide-angle shot captures a vast, sun-scorched landscape as the camera begins a slow, deliberate movement forward, tracking a lone figure on their journey. Their features are obscured by the deep hood of a heavy, forest-green wool cloak, its frayed hems, as they walk away from the camera with a steady, determined gait. They hold a rough wooden staff in one hand and carry a worn leather bag slung across their body, foreshadowing the long journey ahead. They are approaching a massive, ancient stone archway, constructed from massive blocks of weathered gray granite, carved with faded, intricate carvings and dotted with patches of green moss. The archway towers above the statues, silhouetted against a brilliant, clear blue sky. The entire scene is drenched in the bright, cinematic sunlight characteristic of the late afternoon golden hour, casting the travelers' long, sharp shadows across the dusty, ochre-colored path. As the figure steadily makes its way through the vast opening, their body briefly silhouetted against the light, falling into the cool, deep shadows of the archway before they emerge on the other side, bathed once more in warm, brilliant light, creating a powerful, epic atmosphere of the beginning of a momentous quest.", + "seed": 28177, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_2/index_4872_seed_28177_dp_4_rank_8_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.07356747835874558, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07356747835874558, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.65, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07356747835874558, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle with a wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure wearing a heavy forest-green wool cloak with frayed hems and a deep hood obscuring their face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the figure holding a rough wooden staff and carrying a worn leather bag slung across their body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background dominated by a massive ancient stone archway made of weathered gray granite with faded carvings and green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move slowly and deliberately forward, tracking the figure as they walk away from the viewer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11371785402297974 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.363717794418335 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11371785402297974, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11371785402297974, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20329347252845764, + 0.11572085320949554, + 0.07813410460948944, + 0.06664472073316574, + 0.09968282282352448, + 0.09346333146095276, + 0.03621387109160423, + 0.07054885476827621, + 0.12290563434362411, + 0.11339239776134491 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11371785402297974 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle with a wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure wearing a heavy forest-green wool cloak with frayed hems and a deep hood obscuring their face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the figure holding a rough wooden staff and carrying a worn leather bag slung across their body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background dominated by a massive ancient stone archway made of weathered gray granite with faded carvings and green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move slowly and deliberately forward, tracking the figure as they walk away from the viewer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07004782557487488 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950478553771973 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07004782557487488, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07004782557487488, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15193092823028564, + 0.1067575141787529, + 0.14291733503341675, + 0.094240203499794, + 0.11390448361635208, + 0.05779126659035683, + 0.08415200561285019, + 0.08385352045297623, + 0.09907553344964981, + 0.06537724286317825 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07004782557487488 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle with a wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure wearing a heavy forest-green wool cloak with frayed hems and a deep hood obscuring their face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the figure holding a rough wooden staff and carrying a worn leather bag slung across their body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background dominated by a massive ancient stone archway made of weathered gray granite with faded carvings and green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move slowly and deliberately forward, tracking the figure as they walk away from the viewer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04307013750076294 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168070077896118 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04307013750076294, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04307013750076294, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18188151717185974, + 0.133604034781456, + 0.06269895285367966, + 0.10278310626745224, + 0.09354566782712936, + 0.13614235818386078, + 0.05078209191560745, + 0.08724971115589142, + 0.078218013048172, + 0.07309453934431076 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04307013750076294 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle with a wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure wearing a heavy forest-green wool cloak with frayed hems and a deep hood obscuring their face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the figure holding a rough wooden staff and carrying a worn leather bag slung across their body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background dominated by a massive ancient stone archway made of weathered gray granite with faded carvings and green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move slowly and deliberately forward, tracking the figure as they walk away from the viewer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07897412776947021 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5789742469787598 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07897412776947021, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07897412776947021, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1571619212627411, + 0.1981109082698822, + 0.059337370097637177, + 0.04614461213350296, + 0.12689998745918274, + 0.13408781588077545, + 0.06947454065084457, + 0.05180090665817261, + 0.061134885996580124, + 0.09584705531597137 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07897412776947021 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle with a wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure wearing a heavy forest-green wool cloak with frayed hems and a deep hood obscuring their face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the figure holding a rough wooden staff and carrying a worn leather bag slung across their body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background dominated by a massive ancient stone archway made of weathered gray granite with faded carvings and green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move slowly and deliberately forward, tracking the figure as they walk away from the viewer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.062027446925640106 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120274543762207 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.062027446925640106, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.062027446925640106, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08736585080623627, + 0.06988249719142914, + 0.04400387406349182, + 0.08796065300703049, + 0.08738231658935547, + 0.09589538723230362, + 0.07405751943588257, + 0.21689505875110626, + 0.12140975892543793, + 0.11514701694250107 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.062027446925640106 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, wide-angle shot captures a vast, sun-scorched landscape as the camera begins a slow, deliberate movement forward, tracking a lone figure on their journey. Their features are obscured by the deep hood of a heavy, forest-green wool cloak, its frayed hems, as they walk away from the camera with a steady, determined gait. They hold a rough wooden staff in one hand and carry a worn leather bag slung across their body, foreshadowing the long journey ahead. They are approaching a massive, ancient stone archway, constructed from massive blocks of weathered gray granite, carved with faded, intricate carvings and dotted with patches of green moss. The archway towers above the statues, silhouetted against a brilliant, clear blue sky. The entire scene is drenched in the bright, cinematic sunlight characteristic of the late afternoon golden hour, casting the travelers' long, sharp shadows across the dusty, ochre-colored path. As the figure steadily makes its way through the vast opening, their body briefly silhouetted against the light, falling into the cool, deep shadows of the archway before they emerge on the other side, bathed once more in warm, brilliant light, creating a powerful, epic atmosphere of the beginning of a momentous quest.", + "seed": 28178, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_2/index_4872_seed_28178_dp_4_rank_8_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.14363848343491553, + "vlm_logprob": -0.14363848343491553, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.049999976158142, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.14363848343491553, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle with a wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure wearing a heavy forest-green wool cloak with frayed hems and a deep hood obscuring their face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the figure holding a rough wooden staff and carrying a worn leather bag slung across their body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background dominated by a massive ancient stone archway made of weathered gray granite with faded carvings and green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move slowly and deliberately forward, tracking the figure as they walk away from the viewer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.09435737133026123 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.594357490539551 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.09435737133026123, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.09435737133026123, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15070997178554535, + 0.14368076622486115, + 0.11019109934568405, + 0.10178466141223907, + 0.23079149425029755, + 0.06596498936414719, + 0.052483003586530685, + 0.04735440015792847, + 0.067330002784729, + 0.029709601774811745 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.09435737133026123 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle with a wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure wearing a heavy forest-green wool cloak with frayed hems and a deep hood obscuring their face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the figure holding a rough wooden staff and carrying a worn leather bag slung across their body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background dominated by a massive ancient stone archway made of weathered gray granite with faded carvings and green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move slowly and deliberately forward, tracking the figure as they walk away from the viewer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.28140097856521606 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4064009189605713 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.28140097856521606, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.28140097856521606, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23575721681118011, + 0.387588232755661, + 0.07213223725557327, + 0.06397958844900131, + 0.08975735306739807, + 0.042778100818395615, + 0.03461047261953354, + 0.02549535594880581, + 0.029091089963912964, + 0.01881033554673195 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.28140097856521606 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle with a wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure wearing a heavy forest-green wool cloak with frayed hems and a deep hood obscuring their face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the figure holding a rough wooden staff and carrying a worn leather bag slung across their body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background dominated by a massive ancient stone archway made of weathered gray granite with faded carvings and green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move slowly and deliberately forward, tracking the figure as they walk away from the viewer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12710747122764587 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1271073818206787 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12710747122764587, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.9999998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12710747122764587, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08323579281568527, + 0.16680462658405304, + 0.12559150159358978, + 0.2477356642484665, + 0.04264561086893082, + 0.04152218997478485, + 0.11621814221143723, + 0.058070842176675797, + 0.0938120111823082, + 0.024363527074456215 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12710747122764587 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle with a wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure wearing a heavy forest-green wool cloak with frayed hems and a deep hood obscuring their face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the figure holding a rough wooden staff and carrying a worn leather bag slung across their body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background dominated by a massive ancient stone archway made of weathered gray granite with faded carvings and green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move slowly and deliberately forward, tracking the figure as they walk away from the viewer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16037805378437042 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.910378098487854 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16037805378437042, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16037805378437042, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11781422048807144, + 0.11051143705844879, + 0.058768708258867264, + 0.07863238453865051, + 0.27041834592819214, + 0.23958246409893036, + 0.03873584046959877, + 0.020192142575979233, + 0.0372074693441391, + 0.028136946260929108 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16037805378437042 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle with a wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure wearing a heavy forest-green wool cloak with frayed hems and a deep hood obscuring their face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the figure holding a rough wooden staff and carrying a worn leather bag slung across their body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background dominated by a massive ancient stone archway made of weathered gray granite with faded carvings and green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move slowly and deliberately forward, tracking the figure as they walk away from the viewer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05494854226708412 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929948568344116 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05494854226708412, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05494854226708412, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06341711431741714, + 0.09885908663272858, + 0.06528765708208084, + 0.08976910263299942, + 0.2626093626022339, + 0.03630879893898964, + 0.17232850193977356, + 0.10399847477674484, + 0.08605536073446274, + 0.021366572007536888 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05494854226708412 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, wide-angle shot captures a vast, sun-scorched landscape as the camera begins a slow, deliberate movement forward, tracking a lone figure on their journey. Their features are obscured by the deep hood of a heavy, forest-green wool cloak, its frayed hems, as they walk away from the camera with a steady, determined gait. They hold a rough wooden staff in one hand and carry a worn leather bag slung across their body, foreshadowing the long journey ahead. They are approaching a massive, ancient stone archway, constructed from massive blocks of weathered gray granite, carved with faded, intricate carvings and dotted with patches of green moss. The archway towers above the statues, silhouetted against a brilliant, clear blue sky. The entire scene is drenched in the bright, cinematic sunlight characteristic of the late afternoon golden hour, casting the travelers' long, sharp shadows across the dusty, ochre-colored path. As the figure steadily makes its way through the vast opening, their body briefly silhouetted against the light, falling into the cool, deep shadows of the archway before they emerge on the other side, bathed once more in warm, brilliant light, creating a powerful, epic atmosphere of the beginning of a momentous quest.", + "seed": 28179, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_2/index_4872_seed_28179_dp_5_rank_10_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.11505979746580124, + "vlm_logprob": -0.11505979746580124, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.35, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.11505979746580124, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle with a wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure wearing a heavy forest-green wool cloak with frayed hems and a deep hood obscuring their face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the figure holding a rough wooden staff and carrying a worn leather bag slung across their body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background dominated by a massive ancient stone archway made of weathered gray granite with faded carvings and green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move slowly and deliberately forward, tracking the figure as they walk away from the viewer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06713850051164627 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.942138433456421 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06713850051164627, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06713850051164627, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16240236163139343, + 0.03997935354709625, + 0.05630906671285629, + 0.2716558873653412, + 0.07158862799406052, + 0.058616697788238525, + 0.15056374669075012, + 0.0639866515994072, + 0.08601272851228714, + 0.03888478875160217 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06713850051164627 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle with a wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure wearing a heavy forest-green wool cloak with frayed hems and a deep hood obscuring their face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the figure holding a rough wooden staff and carrying a worn leather bag slung across their body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background dominated by a massive ancient stone archway made of weathered gray granite with faded carvings and green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move slowly and deliberately forward, tracking the figure as they walk away from the viewer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.28141385316848755 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4064137935638428 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.28141385316848755, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.28141385316848755, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17060887813568115, + 0.05344369634985924, + 0.04494158551096916, + 0.4341036379337311, + 0.03830457106232643, + 0.036604393273591995, + 0.06472818553447723, + 0.1014770045876503, + 0.03326131030917168, + 0.02252672240138054 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.28141385316848755 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle with a wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure wearing a heavy forest-green wool cloak with frayed hems and a deep hood obscuring their face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the figure holding a rough wooden staff and carrying a worn leather bag slung across their body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background dominated by a massive ancient stone archway made of weathered gray granite with faded carvings and green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move slowly and deliberately forward, tracking the figure as they walk away from the viewer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08907588571310043 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.464075803756714 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08907588571310043, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08907588571310043, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20082299411296844, + 0.048760607838630676, + 0.06842266023159027, + 0.43316909670829773, + 0.03978327661752701, + 0.044774945825338364, + 0.04462751746177673, + 0.0422249399125576, + 0.0483953133225441, + 0.029018687084317207 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08907588571310043 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle with a wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure wearing a heavy forest-green wool cloak with frayed hems and a deep hood obscuring their face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the figure holding a rough wooden staff and carrying a worn leather bag slung across their body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background dominated by a massive ancient stone archway made of weathered gray granite with faded carvings and green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move slowly and deliberately forward, tracking the figure as they walk away from the viewer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08903095871210098 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4640309810638428 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08903095871210098, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08903095871210098, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16609139740467072, + 0.07156465947628021, + 0.041572995483875275, + 0.2360585331916809, + 0.04616827517747879, + 0.04115023463964462, + 0.15333962440490723, + 0.15590953826904297, + 0.06048991531133652, + 0.027654830366373062 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08903095871210098 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle with a wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure wearing a heavy forest-green wool cloak with frayed hems and a deep hood obscuring their face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the figure holding a rough wooden staff and carrying a worn leather bag slung across their body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background dominated by a massive ancient stone archway made of weathered gray granite with faded carvings and green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move slowly and deliberately forward, tracking the figure as they walk away from the viewer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04863978922367096 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486397743225098 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04863978922367096, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04863978922367096, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15721748769283295, + 0.03623215854167938, + 0.08733707666397095, + 0.2257152497768402, + 0.07304271310567856, + 0.10149399191141129, + 0.1819114238023758, + 0.06790255010128021, + 0.029294749721884727, + 0.039852600544691086 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04863978922367096 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, wide-angle shot captures a vast, sun-scorched landscape as the camera begins a slow, deliberate movement forward, tracking a lone figure on their journey. Their features are obscured by the deep hood of a heavy, forest-green wool cloak, its frayed hems, as they walk away from the camera with a steady, determined gait. They hold a rough wooden staff in one hand and carry a worn leather bag slung across their body, foreshadowing the long journey ahead. They are approaching a massive, ancient stone archway, constructed from massive blocks of weathered gray granite, carved with faded, intricate carvings and dotted with patches of green moss. The archway towers above the statues, silhouetted against a brilliant, clear blue sky. The entire scene is drenched in the bright, cinematic sunlight characteristic of the late afternoon golden hour, casting the travelers' long, sharp shadows across the dusty, ochre-colored path. As the figure steadily makes its way through the vast opening, their body briefly silhouetted against the light, falling into the cool, deep shadows of the archway before they emerge on the other side, bathed once more in warm, brilliant light, creating a powerful, epic atmosphere of the beginning of a momentous quest.", + "seed": 28180, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_2/index_4872_seed_28180_dp_5_rank_10_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.0822795819491148, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0822795819491148, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.85, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0822795819491148, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle with a wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure wearing a heavy forest-green wool cloak with frayed hems and a deep hood obscuring their face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the figure holding a rough wooden staff and carrying a worn leather bag slung across their body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background dominated by a massive ancient stone archway made of weathered gray granite with faded carvings and green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move slowly and deliberately forward, tracking the figure as they walk away from the viewer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04328717663884163 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2932872772216797 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04328717663884163, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04328717663884163, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.059645071625709534, + 0.05185001716017723, + 0.023095063865184784, + 0.4371727705001831, + 0.024747157469391823, + 0.13956928253173828, + 0.07140198349952698, + 0.1302385926246643, + 0.03684120625257492, + 0.02543877437710762 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04328717663884163 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle with a wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure wearing a heavy forest-green wool cloak with frayed hems and a deep hood obscuring their face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the figure holding a rough wooden staff and carrying a worn leather bag slung across their body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background dominated by a massive ancient stone archway made of weathered gray granite with faded carvings and green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move slowly and deliberately forward, tracking the figure as they walk away from the viewer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2521612346172333 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5021612644195557 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2521612346172333, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2521612346172333, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0988556444644928, + 0.11219517141580582, + 0.0653197169303894, + 0.23014792799949646, + 0.032670337706804276, + 0.11678963154554367, + 0.09619586914777756, + 0.09420876204967499, + 0.055445946753025055, + 0.09817098081111908 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2521612346172333 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle with a wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure wearing a heavy forest-green wool cloak with frayed hems and a deep hood obscuring their face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the figure holding a rough wooden staff and carrying a worn leather bag slung across their body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background dominated by a massive ancient stone archway made of weathered gray granite with faded carvings and green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move slowly and deliberately forward, tracking the figure as they walk away from the viewer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.043099138885736465 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680991649627686 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.043099138885736465, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.043099138885736465, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13828574120998383, + 0.036763619631528854, + 0.03625151142477989, + 0.5432993769645691, + 0.027615675702691078, + 0.07351059466600418, + 0.022367041558027267, + 0.053193334490060806, + 0.030962979421019554, + 0.03775010630488396 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.043099138885736465 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle with a wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure wearing a heavy forest-green wool cloak with frayed hems and a deep hood obscuring their face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the figure holding a rough wooden staff and carrying a worn leather bag slung across their body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background dominated by a massive ancient stone archway made of weathered gray granite with faded carvings and green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move slowly and deliberately forward, tracking the figure as they walk away from the viewer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029802603647112846 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298025608062744 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029802603647112846, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029802603647112846, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09622985869646072, + 0.15269693732261658, + 0.050865497440099716, + 0.40755191445350647, + 0.032617826014757156, + 0.04081044718623161, + 0.10332377254962921, + 0.04886365681886673, + 0.028978148475289345, + 0.03806199133396149 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029802603647112846 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle with a wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure wearing a heavy forest-green wool cloak with frayed hems and a deep hood obscuring their face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the figure holding a rough wooden staff and carrying a worn leather bag slung across their body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background dominated by a massive ancient stone archway made of weathered gray granite with faded carvings and green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move slowly and deliberately forward, tracking the figure as they walk away from the viewer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04304775595664978 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680476665496826 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04304775595664978, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04304775595664978, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07300100475549698, + 0.06048259511590004, + 0.029904745519161224, + 0.2578198313713074, + 0.05511818453669548, + 0.1394919753074646, + 0.12193206697702408, + 0.11307898908853531, + 0.09481201320886612, + 0.054358623921871185 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04304775595664978 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_3/index_tensor([2873, 2873])_group_3_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_3/index_tensor([2873, 2873])_group_3_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..9aa611d2882de8aa2ff93d863865d95455edf12d --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_3/index_tensor([2873, 2873])_group_3_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "dynamic medium tracking shot follows the skier in a smooth, fluid motion, keeping pace with him. The skier is dressed in a vibrant royal blue ski suit, black ski pants, and a protective white helmet, the visor lenses reflecting a rainbow of colors in the sunlight. He is speeding down a vast, untouched slope, the deep snow shimmering in the bright winter sun. The skier shifts his weight from side to side with a powerful and beautiful rhythm. With each clean turn, the wide edges of his skis carve deep into the soft snow, unleashing a spectacular curtain of white powder behind him. The mist briefly fills the air, catching the sunlight and creating a translucent halo. As he accelerates downward, the mist he stirs up grows thicker, nearly engulfing his lower body. The entire scene is filled with a sense of speed, freedom, and exhilarating energy, creating the atmosphere of an ultimate, immersive skiing experience.", + "seed": 22350, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_3/index_2873_seed_22350_dp_6_rank_12_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.09631083179265261, + "vlm_logprob": -0.09631083179265261, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.65, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.09631083179265261, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a dynamic medium tracking shot that follows the skier?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the skier wearing a royal blue ski suit, black ski pants, and a white helmet with rainbow-reflecting visor lenses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the skier speeding down a vast, untouched slope with deep snow shimmering in bright sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the skier shift his weight from side to side while carving deep turns that create a curtain of white powder?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does mist briefly fill the air creating a translucent halo and grow thicker to nearly engulf the skier's lower body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05204999819397926 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.3020501136779785 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05204999819397926, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05204999819397926, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16145427525043488, + 0.05267709493637085, + 0.03818458318710327, + 0.12373926490545273, + 0.19673460721969604, + 0.07478649169206619, + 0.05728941783308983, + 0.013612772338092327, + 0.03759431093931198, + 0.2439272105693817 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05204999819397926 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a dynamic medium tracking shot that follows the skier?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the skier wearing a royal blue ski suit, black ski pants, and a white helmet with rainbow-reflecting visor lenses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the skier speeding down a vast, untouched slope with deep snow shimmering in bright sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the skier shift his weight from side to side while carving deep turns that create a curtain of white powder?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does mist briefly fill the air creating a translucent halo and grow thicker to nearly engulf the skier's lower body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.38707518577575684 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1370751857757568 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.38707518577575684, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.38707518577575684, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1836310178041458, + 0.07677978277206421, + 0.13018152117729187, + 0.09099772572517395, + 0.08474139124155045, + 0.0866130068898201, + 0.039027608931064606, + 0.058984529227018356, + 0.05694682523608208, + 0.192096546292305 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.38707518577575684 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a dynamic medium tracking shot that follows the skier?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the skier wearing a royal blue ski suit, black ski pants, and a white helmet with rainbow-reflecting visor lenses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the skier speeding down a vast, untouched slope with deep snow shimmering in bright sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the skier shift his weight from side to side while carving deep turns that create a curtain of white powder?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does mist briefly fill the air creating a translucent halo and grow thicker to nearly engulf the skier's lower body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004638269543647766 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379638195037842 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004638269543647766, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004638269543647766, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08272160589694977, + 0.08586303889751434, + 0.12899614870548248, + 0.1280575692653656, + 0.1744106411933899, + 0.1716262400150299, + 0.02943011373281479, + 0.017891544848680496, + 0.03431481868028641, + 0.1466883271932602 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004638269543647766 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a dynamic medium tracking shot that follows the skier?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the skier wearing a royal blue ski suit, black ski pants, and a white helmet with rainbow-reflecting visor lenses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the skier speeding down a vast, untouched slope with deep snow shimmering in bright sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the skier shift his weight from side to side while carving deep turns that create a curtain of white powder?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does mist briefly fill the air creating a translucent halo and grow thicker to nearly engulf the skier's lower body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004095026291906834 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504095077514648 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004095026291906834, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004095026291906834, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06967081129550934, + 0.13172191381454468, + 0.07503481209278107, + 0.0850231945514679, + 0.2739216685295105, + 0.05505850911140442, + 0.04313761368393898, + 0.037054527550935745, + 0.07750876992940903, + 0.15186813473701477 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004095026291906834 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a dynamic medium tracking shot that follows the skier?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the skier wearing a royal blue ski suit, black ski pants, and a white helmet with rainbow-reflecting visor lenses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the skier speeding down a vast, untouched slope with deep snow shimmering in bright sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the skier shift his weight from side to side while carving deep turns that create a curtain of white powder?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does mist briefly fill the air creating a translucent halo and grow thicker to nearly engulf the skier's lower body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.033695679157972336 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408695697784424 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.033695679157972336, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.033695679157972336, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1333772838115692, + 0.11366627365350723, + 0.04794159159064293, + 0.0791480764746666, + 0.11249208450317383, + 0.07110904157161713, + 0.042196884751319885, + 0.026436371728777885, + 0.22919270396232605, + 0.1444396674633026 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.033695679157972336 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dynamic medium tracking shot follows the skier in a smooth, fluid motion, keeping pace with him. The skier is dressed in a vibrant royal blue ski suit, black ski pants, and a protective white helmet, the visor lenses reflecting a rainbow of colors in the sunlight. He is speeding down a vast, untouched slope, the deep snow shimmering in the bright winter sun. The skier shifts his weight from side to side with a powerful and beautiful rhythm. With each clean turn, the wide edges of his skis carve deep into the soft snow, unleashing a spectacular curtain of white powder behind him. The mist briefly fills the air, catching the sunlight and creating a translucent halo. As he accelerates downward, the mist he stirs up grows thicker, nearly engulfing his lower body. The entire scene is filled with a sense of speed, freedom, and exhilarating energy, creating the atmosphere of an ultimate, immersive skiing experience.", + "seed": 22351, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_3/index_2873_seed_22351_dp_6_rank_12_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.10948339598253369, + "vlm_logprob": -0.10948339598253369, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.375, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.10948339598253369, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a dynamic medium tracking shot that follows the skier?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the skier wearing a royal blue ski suit, black ski pants, and a white helmet with rainbow-reflecting visor lenses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the skier speeding down a vast, untouched slope with deep snow shimmering in bright sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the skier shift his weight from side to side while carving deep turns that create a curtain of white powder?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does mist briefly fill the air creating a translucent halo and grow thicker to nearly engulf the skier's lower body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06258077174425125 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0625808238983154 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06258077174425125, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06258077174425125, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12381159514188766, + 0.1722017526626587, + 0.05738740786910057, + 0.08885503560304642, + 0.03352155536413193, + 0.11741693317890167, + 0.05910947546362877, + 0.23922471702098846, + 0.053215496242046356, + 0.055256061255931854 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06258077174425125 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a dynamic medium tracking shot that follows the skier?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the skier wearing a royal blue ski suit, black ski pants, and a white helmet with rainbow-reflecting visor lenses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the skier speeding down a vast, untouched slope with deep snow shimmering in bright sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the skier shift his weight from side to side while carving deep turns that create a curtain of white powder?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does mist briefly fill the air creating a translucent halo and grow thicker to nearly engulf the skier's lower body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.42889848351478577 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.0538984537124634 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.42889848351478577, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.42889848351478577, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1939169317483902, + 0.23408828675746918, + 0.16459065675735474, + 0.11558935046195984, + 0.02677520364522934, + 0.09573822468519211, + 0.0659523755311966, + 0.061355751007795334, + 0.013098695315420628, + 0.028894485905766487 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.42889848351478577 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a dynamic medium tracking shot that follows the skier?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the skier wearing a royal blue ski suit, black ski pants, and a white helmet with rainbow-reflecting visor lenses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the skier speeding down a vast, untouched slope with deep snow shimmering in bright sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the skier shift his weight from side to side while carving deep turns that create a curtain of white powder?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does mist briefly fill the air creating a translucent halo and grow thicker to nearly engulf the skier's lower body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0076287128031253815 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882628917694092 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0076287128031253815, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0076287128031253815, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19469954073429108, + 0.12997367978096008, + 0.09568781405687332, + 0.04963359981775284, + 0.02427661046385765, + 0.12927503883838654, + 0.17977264523506165, + 0.1130802109837532, + 0.05176428705453873, + 0.03183659538626671 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0076287128031253815 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a dynamic medium tracking shot that follows the skier?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the skier wearing a royal blue ski suit, black ski pants, and a white helmet with rainbow-reflecting visor lenses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the skier speeding down a vast, untouched slope with deep snow shimmering in bright sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the skier shift his weight from side to side while carving deep turns that create a curtain of white powder?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does mist briefly fill the air creating a translucent halo and grow thicker to nearly engulf the skier's lower body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005251778755337 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255251884460449 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005251778755337, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005251778755337, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09554755687713623, + 0.20470839738845825, + 0.18434208631515503, + 0.061484649777412415, + 0.04526278376579285, + 0.0407603457570076, + 0.13063205778598785, + 0.11093930155038834, + 0.0965157300233841, + 0.029807090759277344 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005251778755337 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a dynamic medium tracking shot that follows the skier?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the skier wearing a royal blue ski suit, black ski pants, and a white helmet with rainbow-reflecting visor lenses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the skier speeding down a vast, untouched slope with deep snow shimmering in bright sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the skier shift his weight from side to side while carving deep turns that create a curtain of white powder?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does mist briefly fill the air creating a translucent halo and grow thicker to nearly engulf the skier's lower body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04305723309516907 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680572032928467 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04305723309516907, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04305723309516907, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14868713915348053, + 0.144461527466774, + 0.36487558484077454, + 0.03381608426570892, + 0.028921253979206085, + 0.05976172536611557, + 0.06231896951794624, + 0.08637610077857971, + 0.04854913428425789, + 0.022232554852962494 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04305723309516907 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dynamic medium tracking shot follows the skier in a smooth, fluid motion, keeping pace with him. The skier is dressed in a vibrant royal blue ski suit, black ski pants, and a protective white helmet, the visor lenses reflecting a rainbow of colors in the sunlight. He is speeding down a vast, untouched slope, the deep snow shimmering in the bright winter sun. The skier shifts his weight from side to side with a powerful and beautiful rhythm. With each clean turn, the wide edges of his skis carve deep into the soft snow, unleashing a spectacular curtain of white powder behind him. The mist briefly fills the air, catching the sunlight and creating a translucent halo. As he accelerates downward, the mist he stirs up grows thicker, nearly engulfing his lower body. The entire scene is filled with a sense of speed, freedom, and exhilarating energy, creating the atmosphere of an ultimate, immersive skiing experience.", + "seed": 22352, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_3/index_2873_seed_22352_dp_7_rank_14_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.10203187558799982, + "vlm_logprob": -0.10203187558799982, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.224999988079071, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.10203187558799982, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a dynamic medium tracking shot that follows the skier?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the skier wearing a royal blue ski suit, black ski pants, and a white helmet with rainbow-reflecting visor lenses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the skier speeding down a vast, untouched slope with deep snow shimmering in bright sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the skier shift his weight from side to side while carving deep turns that create a curtain of white powder?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does mist briefly fill the air creating a translucent halo and grow thicker to nearly engulf the skier's lower body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07269123941659927 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9476912021636963 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07269123941659927, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07269123941659927, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1457492858171463, + 0.04671768471598625, + 0.037970975041389465, + 0.049818381667137146, + 0.1071629449725151, + 0.3333835005760193, + 0.0580005943775177, + 0.027852347120642662, + 0.04311728850007057, + 0.15022701025009155 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07269123941659927 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a dynamic medium tracking shot that follows the skier?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the skier wearing a royal blue ski suit, black ski pants, and a white helmet with rainbow-reflecting visor lenses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the skier speeding down a vast, untouched slope with deep snow shimmering in bright sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the skier shift his weight from side to side while carving deep turns that create a curtain of white powder?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does mist briefly fill the air creating a translucent halo and grow thicker to nearly engulf the skier's lower body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.42888933420181274 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.053889274597168 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.42888933420181274, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.6249999403953552, + "token_credit_reward": -0.42888933420181274, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1844983994960785, + 0.058372613042593, + 0.07988062500953674, + 0.06586644053459167, + 0.1362154334783554, + 0.16866691410541534, + 0.08105688542127609, + 0.052060194313526154, + 0.07554803043603897, + 0.09783442318439484 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.42888933420181274 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a dynamic medium tracking shot that follows the skier?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the skier wearing a royal blue ski suit, black ski pants, and a white helmet with rainbow-reflecting visor lenses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the skier speeding down a vast, untouched slope with deep snow shimmering in bright sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the skier shift his weight from side to side while carving deep turns that create a curtain of white powder?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does mist briefly fill the air creating a translucent halo and grow thicker to nearly engulf the skier's lower body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003191023599356413 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753190994262695 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003191023599356413, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003191023599356413, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17864595353603363, + 0.11275090277194977, + 0.08751663565635681, + 0.07243135571479797, + 0.08059578388929367, + 0.19750264286994934, + 0.07614191621541977, + 0.039828576147556305, + 0.05649781972169876, + 0.09808843582868576 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003191023599356413 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a dynamic medium tracking shot that follows the skier?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the skier wearing a royal blue ski suit, black ski pants, and a white helmet with rainbow-reflecting visor lenses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the skier speeding down a vast, untouched slope with deep snow shimmering in bright sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the skier shift his weight from side to side while carving deep turns that create a curtain of white powder?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does mist briefly fill the air creating a translucent halo and grow thicker to nearly engulf the skier's lower body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0021956877317279577 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127195835113525 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0021956877317279577, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0021956877317279577, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17768806219100952, + 0.040603574365377426, + 0.042776837944984436, + 0.11555618792772293, + 0.06617527455091476, + 0.0637582540512085, + 0.19968768954277039, + 0.057183220982551575, + 0.13072630763053894, + 0.10584454983472824 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0021956877317279577 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a dynamic medium tracking shot that follows the skier?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the skier wearing a royal blue ski suit, black ski pants, and a white helmet with rainbow-reflecting visor lenses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the skier speeding down a vast, untouched slope with deep snow shimmering in bright sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the skier shift his weight from side to side while carving deep turns that create a curtain of white powder?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does mist briefly fill the air creating a translucent halo and grow thicker to nearly engulf the skier's lower body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003192092990502715 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753191947937012 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003192092990502715, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003192092990502715, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0932331457734108, + 0.0300009585916996, + 0.037130601704120636, + 0.0426415391266346, + 0.07540082186460495, + 0.07396548241376877, + 0.17347843945026398, + 0.1469767838716507, + 0.1578318476676941, + 0.1693403273820877 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003192092990502715 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dynamic medium tracking shot follows the skier in a smooth, fluid motion, keeping pace with him. The skier is dressed in a vibrant royal blue ski suit, black ski pants, and a protective white helmet, the visor lenses reflecting a rainbow of colors in the sunlight. He is speeding down a vast, untouched slope, the deep snow shimmering in the bright winter sun. The skier shifts his weight from side to side with a powerful and beautiful rhythm. With each clean turn, the wide edges of his skis carve deep into the soft snow, unleashing a spectacular curtain of white powder behind him. The mist briefly fills the air, catching the sunlight and creating a translucent halo. As he accelerates downward, the mist he stirs up grows thicker, nearly engulfing his lower body. The entire scene is filled with a sense of speed, freedom, and exhilarating energy, creating the atmosphere of an ultimate, immersive skiing experience.", + "seed": 22353, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_3/index_2873_seed_22353_dp_7_rank_14_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.09101939466781914, + "vlm_logprob": -0.09101939466781914, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.900000011920929, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.09101939466781914, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a dynamic medium tracking shot that follows the skier?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the skier wearing a royal blue ski suit, black ski pants, and a white helmet with rainbow-reflecting visor lenses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the skier speeding down a vast, untouched slope with deep snow shimmering in bright sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the skier shift his weight from side to side while carving deep turns that create a curtain of white powder?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does mist briefly fill the air creating a translucent halo and grow thicker to nearly engulf the skier's lower body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.038331713527441025 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5383317470550537 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.038331713527441025, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.038331713527441025, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07539226114749908, + 0.1727162003517151, + 0.10727247595787048, + 0.06947227567434311, + 0.13991929590702057, + 0.10270950943231583, + 0.07518362998962402, + 0.028728431090712547, + 0.0907922238111496, + 0.13781364262104034 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.038331713527441025 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a dynamic medium tracking shot that follows the skier?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the skier wearing a royal blue ski suit, black ski pants, and a white helmet with rainbow-reflecting visor lenses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the skier speeding down a vast, untouched slope with deep snow shimmering in bright sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the skier shift his weight from side to side while carving deep turns that create a curtain of white powder?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does mist briefly fill the air creating a translucent halo and grow thicker to nearly engulf the skier's lower body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.38704913854599 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1370491981506348 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.38704913854599, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.7500000596046448, + "token_credit_reward": -0.38704913854599, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11324944347143173, + 0.16314008831977844, + 0.08094586431980133, + 0.16740840673446655, + 0.04841623082756996, + 0.06291981041431427, + 0.03469022735953331, + 0.03651168942451477, + 0.13056954741477966, + 0.16214868426322937 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.38704913854599 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a dynamic medium tracking shot that follows the skier?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the skier wearing a royal blue ski suit, black ski pants, and a white helmet with rainbow-reflecting visor lenses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the skier speeding down a vast, untouched slope with deep snow shimmering in bright sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the skier shift his weight from side to side while carving deep turns that create a curtain of white powder?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does mist briefly fill the air creating a translucent halo and grow thicker to nearly engulf the skier's lower body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0028169972356408834 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877817153930664 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0028169972356408834, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0028169972356408834, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19923239946365356, + 0.10647299140691757, + 0.09978700429201126, + 0.07977436482906342, + 0.0913190245628357, + 0.06897356361150742, + 0.07856319099664688, + 0.08238885551691055, + 0.1254139095544815, + 0.06807474046945572 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0028169972356408834 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a dynamic medium tracking shot that follows the skier?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the skier wearing a royal blue ski suit, black ski pants, and a white helmet with rainbow-reflecting visor lenses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the skier speeding down a vast, untouched slope with deep snow shimmering in bright sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the skier shift his weight from side to side while carving deep turns that create a curtain of white powder?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does mist briefly fill the air creating a translucent halo and grow thicker to nearly engulf the skier's lower body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036137294955551624 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.6286139488220215 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036137294955551624, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036137294955551624, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.106085866689682, + 0.09119559824466705, + 0.04460158199071884, + 0.1301831305027008, + 0.19630968570709229, + 0.05648915469646454, + 0.07912424951791763, + 0.06505861133337021, + 0.16805869340896606, + 0.06289344280958176 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 8, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036137294955551624 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a dynamic medium tracking shot that follows the skier?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the skier wearing a royal blue ski suit, black ski pants, and a white helmet with rainbow-reflecting visor lenses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the skier speeding down a vast, untouched slope with deep snow shimmering in bright sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the skier shift his weight from side to side while carving deep turns that create a curtain of white powder?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does mist briefly fill the air creating a translucent halo and grow thicker to nearly engulf the skier's lower body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02328539453446865 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773285388946533 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02328539453446865, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02328539453446865, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08998829871416092, + 0.07601210474967957, + 0.024792257696390152, + 0.0352591909468174, + 0.09645308554172516, + 0.11301811039447784, + 0.020907528698444366, + 0.026109199970960617, + 0.4027540981769562, + 0.1147061362862587 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02328539453446865 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_4/index_tensor([2597, 2597])_group_4_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_4/index_tensor([2597, 2597])_group_4_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..d132f6466dd13485ae232881e312cc31c97fd1eb --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_4/index_tensor([2597, 2597])_group_4_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "low-angle, static, extreme close-up captures the rocket engine's massive bell-shaped nozzle, its black, soot-stained metal surface covered in a complex network of pipes and thermal insulation. For a brief moment, the scene is utterly silent. Then, a dazzling flash of pure white instantly erupts from the engine's throat, dramatically expanding into a supersonic plume of incandescent plasma. The core of the exhaust burns with a bluish-white electrical intensity, clearly revealing the repetitive diamond-shaped shockwaves known as Mach diamonds. This core is surrounded by a roiling, surging torrent of flame, its color shifting from golden yellow to a deep, fiery orange, tumbling downward and outward at a ferocious pace. The flames engulf the vast, charred concrete launch pad below, while the flood system simultaneously unleashes a massive spray, producing a vast, billowing cloud of white steam that violently clashes and intermingles with the fire and smoke. The entire frame trembles intensely with the sheer acoustic force of the ignition, creating a visceral, chaotic, and awe-inspiring atmosphere of unleashing immense raw power.", + "seed": 18180, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_4/index_2597_seed_18180_dp_8_rank_16_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.017527605034410955, + "vlm_logprob": -0.017527605034410955, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.225, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.017527605034410955, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle, static, extreme close-up of a rocket engine nozzle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the nozzle black, soot-stained, and covered in pipes and thermal insulation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the exhaust core show bluish-white intensity with visible diamond-shaped shockwaves (Mach diamonds)?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a massive spray of white steam clashing with fire and smoke on a charred concrete launch pad?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the frame tremble intensely to simulate the acoustic force of the ignition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02071344293653965 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.0207133293151855 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02071344293653965, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02071344293653965, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04722999408841133, + 0.06634963303804398, + 0.07843412458896637, + 0.018552711233496666, + 0.04640341177582741, + 0.010537045076489449, + 0.012895173393189907, + 0.039277784526348114, + 0.6621596217155457, + 0.018160592764616013 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02071344293653965 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle, static, extreme close-up of a rocket engine nozzle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the nozzle black, soot-stained, and covered in pipes and thermal insulation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the exhaust core show bluish-white intensity with visible diamond-shaped shockwaves (Mach diamonds)?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a massive spray of white steam clashing with fire and smoke on a charred concrete launch pad?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the frame tremble intensely to simulate the acoustic force of the ignition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026404596865177155 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651404619216919 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026404596865177155, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026404596865177155, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10026654601097107, + 0.2433638870716095, + 0.05210889130830765, + 0.05827072635293007, + 0.02520548552274704, + 0.01326539646834135, + 0.011925536207854748, + 0.028327569365501404, + 0.4402351379394531, + 0.027030808851122856 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026404596865177155 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle, static, extreme close-up of a rocket engine nozzle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the nozzle black, soot-stained, and covered in pipes and thermal insulation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the exhaust core show bluish-white intensity with visible diamond-shaped shockwaves (Mach diamonds)?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a massive spray of white steam clashing with fire and smoke on a charred concrete launch pad?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the frame tremble intensely to simulate the acoustic force of the ignition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004657847806811333 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379657745361328 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004657847806811333, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004657847806811333, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03743373975157738, + 0.04365382343530655, + 0.04045166075229645, + 0.0341157428920269, + 0.04516173154115677, + 0.044247642159461975, + 0.03129672631621361, + 0.021360263228416443, + 0.682002604007721, + 0.020276078954339027 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004657847806811333 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle, static, extreme close-up of a rocket engine nozzle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the nozzle black, soot-stained, and covered in pipes and thermal insulation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the exhaust core show bluish-white intensity with visible diamond-shaped shockwaves (Mach diamonds)?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a massive spray of white steam clashing with fire and smoke on a charred concrete launch pad?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the frame tremble intensely to simulate the acoustic force of the ignition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023311715573072433 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7733116149902344 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023311715573072433, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023311715573072433, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06927241384983063, + 0.055419329553842545, + 0.03638463467359543, + 0.014286832883954048, + 0.013837640173733234, + 0.010747857391834259, + 0.040098872035741806, + 0.06394924968481064, + 0.6700076460838318, + 0.025995533913373947 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023311715573072433 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle, static, extreme close-up of a rocket engine nozzle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the nozzle black, soot-stained, and covered in pipes and thermal insulation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the exhaust core show bluish-white intensity with visible diamond-shaped shockwaves (Mach diamonds)?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a massive spray of white steam clashing with fire and smoke on a charred concrete launch pad?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the frame tremble intensely to simulate the acoustic force of the ignition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012550421990454197 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387550354003906 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012550421990454197, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012550421990454197, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18099933862686157, + 0.0662655159831047, + 0.05131429806351662, + 0.03024373948574066, + 0.03225043788552284, + 0.043184392154216766, + 0.027474943548440933, + 0.10331861674785614, + 0.3821057975292206, + 0.08284297585487366 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012550421990454197 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, static, extreme close-up captures the rocket engine's massive bell-shaped nozzle, its black, soot-stained metal surface covered in a complex network of pipes and thermal insulation. For a brief moment, the scene is utterly silent. Then, a dazzling flash of pure white instantly erupts from the engine's throat, dramatically expanding into a supersonic plume of incandescent plasma. The core of the exhaust burns with a bluish-white electrical intensity, clearly revealing the repetitive diamond-shaped shockwaves known as Mach diamonds. This core is surrounded by a roiling, surging torrent of flame, its color shifting from golden yellow to a deep, fiery orange, tumbling downward and outward at a ferocious pace. The flames engulf the vast, charred concrete launch pad below, while the flood system simultaneously unleashes a massive spray, producing a vast, billowing cloud of white steam that violently clashes and intermingles with the fire and smoke. The entire frame trembles intensely with the sheer acoustic force of the ignition, creating a visceral, chaotic, and awe-inspiring atmosphere of unleashing immense raw power.", + "seed": 18181, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_4/index_2597_seed_18181_dp_8_rank_16_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.025604972429573537, + "vlm_logprob": -0.025604972429573537, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.0, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.025604972429573537, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle, static, extreme close-up of a rocket engine nozzle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the nozzle black, soot-stained, and covered in pipes and thermal insulation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the exhaust core show bluish-white intensity with visible diamond-shaped shockwaves (Mach diamonds)?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a massive spray of white steam clashing with fire and smoke on a charred concrete launch pad?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the frame tremble intensely to simulate the acoustic force of the ignition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06780575215816498 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.817805767059326 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06780575215816498, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06780575215816498, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11139991879463196, + 0.0531003437936306, + 0.031929705291986465, + 0.12145663797855377, + 0.05476345866918564, + 0.38559314608573914, + 0.06413571536540985, + 0.04449406638741493, + 0.07067260146141052, + 0.06245436891913414 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06780575215816498 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle, static, extreme close-up of a rocket engine nozzle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the nozzle black, soot-stained, and covered in pipes and thermal insulation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the exhaust core show bluish-white intensity with visible diamond-shaped shockwaves (Mach diamonds)?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a massive spray of white steam clashing with fire and smoke on a charred concrete launch pad?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the frame tremble intensely to simulate the acoustic force of the ignition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02333395928144455 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.77333402633667 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02333395928144455, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02333395928144455, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14615091681480408, + 0.10760246962308884, + 0.0646086186170578, + 0.08065038174390793, + 0.055328045040369034, + 0.07016206532716751, + 0.07144807279109955, + 0.06306379288434982, + 0.15192164480686188, + 0.18906399607658386 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02333395928144455 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle, static, extreme close-up of a rocket engine nozzle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the nozzle black, soot-stained, and covered in pipes and thermal insulation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the exhaust core show bluish-white intensity with visible diamond-shaped shockwaves (Mach diamonds)?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a massive spray of white steam clashing with fire and smoke on a charred concrete launch pad?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the frame tremble intensely to simulate the acoustic force of the ignition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007645866833627224 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882646083831787 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007645866833627224, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007645866833627224, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11849034577608109, + 0.10994399338960648, + 0.13345718383789062, + 0.06276946514844894, + 0.08119552582502365, + 0.07941573858261108, + 0.07243415713310242, + 0.08195182681083679, + 0.05292702838778496, + 0.20741473138332367 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007645866833627224 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle, static, extreme close-up of a rocket engine nozzle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the nozzle black, soot-stained, and covered in pipes and thermal insulation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the exhaust core show bluish-white intensity with visible diamond-shaped shockwaves (Mach diamonds)?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a massive spray of white steam clashing with fire and smoke on a charred concrete launch pad?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the frame tremble intensely to simulate the acoustic force of the ignition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008649386465549469 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.7586493492126465 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008649386465549469, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008649386465549469, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13481272757053375, + 0.10227243602275848, + 0.049368277192115784, + 0.09703918546438217, + 0.11249616742134094, + 0.052892040461301804, + 0.05736888572573662, + 0.1769224852323532, + 0.08487465232610703, + 0.1319531351327896 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008649386465549469 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle, static, extreme close-up of a rocket engine nozzle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the nozzle black, soot-stained, and covered in pipes and thermal insulation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the exhaust core show bluish-white intensity with visible diamond-shaped shockwaves (Mach diamonds)?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a massive spray of white steam clashing with fire and smoke on a charred concrete launch pad?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the frame tremble intensely to simulate the acoustic force of the ignition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02058989740908146 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895589828491211 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02058989740908146, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02058989740908146, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1789063662290573, + 0.22088280320167542, + 0.06186354532837868, + 0.06705270707607269, + 0.0696520283818245, + 0.03422081097960472, + 0.12108643352985382, + 0.04316224157810211, + 0.0629819706082344, + 0.14019106328487396 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02058989740908146 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, static, extreme close-up captures the rocket engine's massive bell-shaped nozzle, its black, soot-stained metal surface covered in a complex network of pipes and thermal insulation. For a brief moment, the scene is utterly silent. Then, a dazzling flash of pure white instantly erupts from the engine's throat, dramatically expanding into a supersonic plume of incandescent plasma. The core of the exhaust burns with a bluish-white electrical intensity, clearly revealing the repetitive diamond-shaped shockwaves known as Mach diamonds. This core is surrounded by a roiling, surging torrent of flame, its color shifting from golden yellow to a deep, fiery orange, tumbling downward and outward at a ferocious pace. The flames engulf the vast, charred concrete launch pad below, while the flood system simultaneously unleashes a massive spray, producing a vast, billowing cloud of white steam that violently clashes and intermingles with the fire and smoke. The entire frame trembles intensely with the sheer acoustic force of the ignition, creating a visceral, chaotic, and awe-inspiring atmosphere of unleashing immense raw power.", + "seed": 18182, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_4/index_2597_seed_18182_dp_9_rank_18_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.023370427265763282, + "vlm_logprob": -0.023370427265763282, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.925, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.023370427265763282, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle, static, extreme close-up of a rocket engine nozzle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the nozzle black, soot-stained, and covered in pipes and thermal insulation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the exhaust core show bluish-white intensity with visible diamond-shaped shockwaves (Mach diamonds)?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a massive spray of white steam clashing with fire and smoke on a charred concrete launch pad?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the frame tremble intensely to simulate the acoustic force of the ignition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04267772287130356 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.292677640914917 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04267772287130356, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04267772287130356, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19781188666820526, + 0.08941908180713654, + 0.08538227528333664, + 0.028831258416175842, + 0.07197084277868271, + 0.06613149493932724, + 0.05603194981813431, + 0.3047230839729309, + 0.03662028908729553, + 0.06307784467935562 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04267772287130356 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle, static, extreme close-up of a rocket engine nozzle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the nozzle black, soot-stained, and covered in pipes and thermal insulation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the exhaust core show bluish-white intensity with visible diamond-shaped shockwaves (Mach diamonds)?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a massive spray of white steam clashing with fire and smoke on a charred concrete launch pad?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the frame tremble intensely to simulate the acoustic force of the ignition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0298469178378582 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298469066619873 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0298469178378582, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0298469178378582, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1740444153547287, + 0.054100219160318375, + 0.028474822640419006, + 0.03347305580973625, + 0.07535142451524734, + 0.0454505980014801, + 0.07428697496652603, + 0.32369253039360046, + 0.04577132686972618, + 0.14535459876060486 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0298469178378582 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle, static, extreme close-up of a rocket engine nozzle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the nozzle black, soot-stained, and covered in pipes and thermal insulation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the exhaust core show bluish-white intensity with visible diamond-shaped shockwaves (Mach diamonds)?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a massive spray of white steam clashing with fire and smoke on a charred concrete launch pad?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the frame tremble intensely to simulate the acoustic force of the ignition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016093119978904724 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.1410932540893555 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016093119978904724, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016093119978904724, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2655121386051178, + 0.13044220209121704, + 0.044454049319028854, + 0.06876438111066818, + 0.09362620860338211, + 0.026107849553227425, + 0.06666196882724762, + 0.13981260359287262, + 0.06889265775680542, + 0.09572593122720718 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016093119978904724 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle, static, extreme close-up of a rocket engine nozzle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the nozzle black, soot-stained, and covered in pipes and thermal insulation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the exhaust core show bluish-white intensity with visible diamond-shaped shockwaves (Mach diamonds)?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a massive spray of white steam clashing with fire and smoke on a charred concrete launch pad?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the frame tremble intensely to simulate the acoustic force of the ignition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007637703791260719 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.8826375007629395 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007637703791260719, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007637703791260719, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2575235664844513, + 0.05735492333769798, + 0.03152952715754509, + 0.043261513113975525, + 0.10788552463054657, + 0.14521658420562744, + 0.07458019256591797, + 0.07496984302997589, + 0.09967710822820663, + 0.10800126194953918 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007637703791260719 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle, static, extreme close-up of a rocket engine nozzle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the nozzle black, soot-stained, and covered in pipes and thermal insulation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the exhaust core show bluish-white intensity with visible diamond-shaped shockwaves (Mach diamonds)?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a massive spray of white steam clashing with fire and smoke on a charred concrete launch pad?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the frame tremble intensely to simulate the acoustic force of the ignition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020596671849489212 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895596742630005 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020596671849489212, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020596671849489212, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.34782204031944275, + 0.05541755259037018, + 0.032057978212833405, + 0.06367708742618561, + 0.1609216183423996, + 0.06571769714355469, + 0.039670299738645554, + 0.06019023433327675, + 0.05360865220427513, + 0.12091685086488724 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020596671849489212 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, static, extreme close-up captures the rocket engine's massive bell-shaped nozzle, its black, soot-stained metal surface covered in a complex network of pipes and thermal insulation. For a brief moment, the scene is utterly silent. Then, a dazzling flash of pure white instantly erupts from the engine's throat, dramatically expanding into a supersonic plume of incandescent plasma. The core of the exhaust burns with a bluish-white electrical intensity, clearly revealing the repetitive diamond-shaped shockwaves known as Mach diamonds. This core is surrounded by a roiling, surging torrent of flame, its color shifting from golden yellow to a deep, fiery orange, tumbling downward and outward at a ferocious pace. The flames engulf the vast, charred concrete launch pad below, while the flood system simultaneously unleashes a massive spray, producing a vast, billowing cloud of white steam that violently clashes and intermingles with the fire and smoke. The entire frame trembles intensely with the sheer acoustic force of the ignition, creating a visceral, chaotic, and awe-inspiring atmosphere of unleashing immense raw power.", + "seed": 18183, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_4/index_2597_seed_18183_dp_9_rank_18_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.028282771445810796, + "vlm_logprob": -0.028282771445810796, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.725, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.028282771445810796, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle, static, extreme close-up of a rocket engine nozzle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the nozzle black, soot-stained, and covered in pipes and thermal insulation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the exhaust core show bluish-white intensity with visible diamond-shaped shockwaves (Mach diamonds)?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a massive spray of white steam clashing with fire and smoke on a charred concrete launch pad?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the frame tremble intensely to simulate the acoustic force of the ignition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.051445070654153824 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0514450073242188 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.051445070654153824, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.051445070654153824, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.6094039082527161, + 0.06555823981761932, + 0.04438748583197594, + 0.029342854395508766, + 0.043151985853910446, + 0.014593597501516342, + 0.04160402715206146, + 0.06501835584640503, + 0.03890049457550049, + 0.04803898185491562 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.051445070654153824 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle, static, extreme close-up of a rocket engine nozzle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the nozzle black, soot-stained, and covered in pipes and thermal insulation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the exhaust core show bluish-white intensity with visible diamond-shaped shockwaves (Mach diamonds)?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a massive spray of white steam clashing with fire and smoke on a charred concrete launch pad?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the frame tremble intensely to simulate the acoustic force of the ignition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04311763495206833 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1681175231933594 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04311763495206833, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04311763495206833, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.7990683913230896, + 0.016317447647452354, + 0.02947751246392727, + 0.029900388792157173, + 0.03505135327577591, + 0.015011115930974483, + 0.01728501170873642, + 0.020304592326283455, + 0.016274530440568924, + 0.021309660747647285 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04311763495206833 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle, static, extreme close-up of a rocket engine nozzle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the nozzle black, soot-stained, and covered in pipes and thermal insulation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the exhaust core show bluish-white intensity with visible diamond-shaped shockwaves (Mach diamonds)?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a massive spray of white steam clashing with fire and smoke on a charred concrete launch pad?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the frame tremble intensely to simulate the acoustic force of the ignition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012562076561152935 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387562274932861 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012562076561152935, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012562076561152935, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5298230051994324, + 0.06491187959909439, + 0.0532987155020237, + 0.030170712620019913, + 0.056128885596990585, + 0.052814651280641556, + 0.0424136258661747, + 0.08186034858226776, + 0.04106435924768448, + 0.04751378297805786 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012562076561152935 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle, static, extreme close-up of a rocket engine nozzle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the nozzle black, soot-stained, and covered in pipes and thermal insulation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the exhaust core show bluish-white intensity with visible diamond-shaped shockwaves (Mach diamonds)?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a massive spray of white steam clashing with fire and smoke on a charred concrete launch pad?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the frame tremble intensely to simulate the acoustic force of the ignition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016087723895907402 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141087532043457 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016087723895907402, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016087723895907402, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.6571692824363708, + 0.03178112208843231, + 0.041587818413972855, + 0.029127035290002823, + 0.04320487380027771, + 0.025278134271502495, + 0.05706758424639702, + 0.04760616272687912, + 0.032916922122240067, + 0.0342610664665699 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016087723895907402 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle, static, extreme close-up of a rocket engine nozzle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the nozzle black, soot-stained, and covered in pipes and thermal insulation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the exhaust core show bluish-white intensity with visible diamond-shaped shockwaves (Mach diamonds)?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a massive spray of white steam clashing with fire and smoke on a charred concrete launch pad?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the frame tremble intensely to simulate the acoustic force of the ignition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018201351165771484 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.0182013511657715 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018201351165771484, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018201351165771484, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.31715404987335205, + 0.0249205082654953, + 0.05023207142949104, + 0.028026580810546875, + 0.07179568707942963, + 0.028157847002148628, + 0.09515340626239777, + 0.18103668093681335, + 0.12985196709632874, + 0.07367130368947983 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018201351165771484 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_5/index_tensor([9855, 9855])_group_5_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_5/index_tensor([9855, 9855])_group_5_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..aa93224b978a019316e3a199a42f113f8fbb7e8a --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_5/index_tensor([9855, 9855])_group_5_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "dynamic tracking shot begins from a low angle behind the sports car. The camera follows closely behind it as a sleek, liquid-metal silver sports car speeds at breakneck speed across a multi-level elevated overpass constructed of sleek carbon and transparent forcefield guardrails. Its blazing red LED taillights create long, light-filled trails with a subtle particle effect. As the camera steadily and smoothly ascends and slowly zooms out, the car's silhouette gradually shrinks, becoming a mere point of light darting across the complex network of roads. The camera then widens, revealing the bottomless urban canyon below. The headlights and taillights of countless autonomous vehicles and small aircraft converge into rivers of gold, white, and blue light, flowing continuously through the intricate interchange structure. Finally, the camera rises to a breathtakingly magnificent bird's-eye view, taking in the entire panoramic view of the futuristic city under the night sky - huge dynamic holographic advertisements are projected on the exterior walls of skyscrapers with strange structures that soar into the clouds. The entire picture is dotted with countless dynamic light sources under the cold cyberpunk blue and purple main colors, creating a futuristic atmosphere that is both high-speed and dynamic, magnificent and awe-inspiring.", + "seed": 16682, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_5/index_9855_seed_16682_dp_10_rank_20_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.02064333064481616, + "vlm_logprob": -0.02064333064481616, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.475, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.02064333064481616, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, liquid-metal silver sports car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the scene take place on a multi-level elevated overpass with carbon and transparent forcefield guardrails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the car's taillights appear as blazing red LED trails with a subtle particle effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at a low angle behind the car, ascend, zoom out, and finally rise to a bird's-eye view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a futuristic city at night with holographic advertisements and a cold cyberpunk blue and purple color palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06252074986696243 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812520742416382 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06252074986696243, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06252074986696243, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09316609054803848, + 0.07202044129371643, + 0.04032568261027336, + 0.10447067022323608, + 0.05195551738142967, + 0.03039362281560898, + 0.2566896080970764, + 0.031202372163534164, + 0.054566413164138794, + 0.2652096152305603 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06252074986696243 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, liquid-metal silver sports car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the scene take place on a multi-level elevated overpass with carbon and transparent forcefield guardrails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the car's taillights appear as blazing red LED trails with a subtle particle effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at a low angle behind the car, ascend, zoom out, and finally rise to a bird's-eye view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a futuristic city at night with holographic advertisements and a cold cyberpunk blue and purple color palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01820240542292595 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018202304840088 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01820240542292595, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01820240542292595, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07815822958946228, + 0.01515126507729292, + 0.04403352364897728, + 0.01353458222001791, + 0.027505982667207718, + 0.01646578498184681, + 0.3334364891052246, + 0.05886460095643997, + 0.03351913392543793, + 0.3793303370475769 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01820240542292595 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, liquid-metal silver sports car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the scene take place on a multi-level elevated overpass with carbon and transparent forcefield guardrails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the car's taillights appear as blazing red LED trails with a subtle particle effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at a low angle behind the car, ascend, zoom out, and finally rise to a bird's-eye view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a futuristic city at night with holographic advertisements and a cold cyberpunk blue and purple color palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036183618940413 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628618240356445 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036183618940413, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036183618940413, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22676272690296173, + 0.058160800486803055, + 0.2585248649120331, + 0.05209721252322197, + 0.07170972973108292, + 0.04735266789793968, + 0.15432724356651306, + 0.03580823913216591, + 0.02494293451309204, + 0.07031356543302536 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036183618940413 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, liquid-metal silver sports car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the scene take place on a multi-level elevated overpass with carbon and transparent forcefield guardrails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the car's taillights appear as blazing red LED trails with a subtle particle effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at a low angle behind the car, ascend, zoom out, and finally rise to a bird's-eye view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a futuristic city at night with holographic advertisements and a cold cyberpunk blue and purple color palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01605992205440998 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141059875488281 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01605992205440998, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01605992205440998, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08269441872835159, + 0.023882832378149033, + 0.0452568419277668, + 0.016075698658823967, + 0.03860800340771675, + 0.028289610520005226, + 0.5011271238327026, + 0.06021307781338692, + 0.035375360399484634, + 0.16847699880599976 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01605992205440998 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, liquid-metal silver sports car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the scene take place on a multi-level elevated overpass with carbon and transparent forcefield guardrails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the car's taillights appear as blazing red LED trails with a subtle particle effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at a low angle behind the car, ascend, zoom out, and finally rise to a bird's-eye view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a futuristic city at night with holographic advertisements and a cold cyberpunk blue and purple color palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0028152139857411385 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877815246582031 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0028152139857411385, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0028152139857411385, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12375663965940475, + 0.05361184477806091, + 0.22129493951797485, + 0.03867049142718315, + 0.039343420416116714, + 0.08367592096328735, + 0.14794538915157318, + 0.06895274668931961, + 0.027636907994747162, + 0.19511178135871887 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0028152139857411385 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dynamic tracking shot begins from a low angle behind the sports car. The camera follows closely behind it as a sleek, liquid-metal silver sports car speeds at breakneck speed across a multi-level elevated overpass constructed of sleek carbon and transparent forcefield guardrails. Its blazing red LED taillights create long, light-filled trails with a subtle particle effect. As the camera steadily and smoothly ascends and slowly zooms out, the car's silhouette gradually shrinks, becoming a mere point of light darting across the complex network of roads. The camera then widens, revealing the bottomless urban canyon below. The headlights and taillights of countless autonomous vehicles and small aircraft converge into rivers of gold, white, and blue light, flowing continuously through the intricate interchange structure. Finally, the camera rises to a breathtakingly magnificent bird's-eye view, taking in the entire panoramic view of the futuristic city under the night sky - huge dynamic holographic advertisements are projected on the exterior walls of skyscrapers with strange structures that soar into the clouds. The entire picture is dotted with countless dynamic light sources under the cold cyberpunk blue and purple main colors, creating a futuristic atmosphere that is both high-speed and dynamic, magnificent and awe-inspiring.", + "seed": 16683, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_5/index_9855_seed_16683_dp_10_rank_20_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.03877231697551906, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03877231697551906, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.325, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03877231697551906, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, liquid-metal silver sports car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the scene take place on a multi-level elevated overpass with carbon and transparent forcefield guardrails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the car's taillights appear as blazing red LED trails with a subtle particle effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at a low angle behind the car, ascend, zoom out, and finally rise to a bird's-eye view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a futuristic city at night with holographic advertisements and a cold cyberpunk blue and purple color palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16093720495700836 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9109371900558472 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16093720495700836, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16093720495700836, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15452103316783905, + 0.12764045596122742, + 0.042106471955776215, + 0.07015930861234665, + 0.0592484287917614, + 0.017450282350182533, + 0.21933984756469727, + 0.030385302379727364, + 0.24914276599884033, + 0.03000611998140812 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16093720495700836 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, liquid-metal silver sports car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the scene take place on a multi-level elevated overpass with carbon and transparent forcefield guardrails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the car's taillights appear as blazing red LED trails with a subtle particle effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at a low angle behind the car, ascend, zoom out, and finally rise to a bird's-eye view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a futuristic city at night with holographic advertisements and a cold cyberpunk blue and purple color palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012561134994029999 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387561321258545 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012561134994029999, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012561134994029999, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03642474114894867, + 0.0433143675327301, + 0.06877300143241882, + 0.11715161800384521, + 0.03942623361945152, + 0.04602120444178581, + 0.09429769963026047, + 0.1871550977230072, + 0.3106676936149597, + 0.05676833167672157 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012561134994029999 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, liquid-metal silver sports car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the scene take place on a multi-level elevated overpass with carbon and transparent forcefield guardrails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the car's taillights appear as blazing red LED trails with a subtle particle effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at a low angle behind the car, ascend, zoom out, and finally rise to a bird's-eye view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a futuristic city at night with holographic advertisements and a cold cyberpunk blue and purple color palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004641473293304443 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379641532897949 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004641473293304443, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004641473293304443, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10804269462823868, + 0.08859264105558395, + 0.07956865429878235, + 0.055864088237285614, + 0.039990462362766266, + 0.03504597768187523, + 0.2545703649520874, + 0.11152080446481705, + 0.19460147619247437, + 0.03220284730195999 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004641473293304443 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, liquid-metal silver sports car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the scene take place on a multi-level elevated overpass with carbon and transparent forcefield guardrails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the car's taillights appear as blazing red LED trails with a subtle particle effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at a low angle behind the car, ascend, zoom out, and finally rise to a bird's-eye view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a futuristic city at night with holographic advertisements and a cold cyberpunk blue and purple color palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012532292865216732 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.3875322341918945 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012532292865216732, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012532292865216732, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07314217835664749, + 0.060377299785614014, + 0.03976345807313919, + 0.023321693763136864, + 0.043621260672807693, + 0.03880665823817253, + 0.18589580059051514, + 0.07715226709842682, + 0.41261380910873413, + 0.04530556872487068 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012532292865216732 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, liquid-metal silver sports car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the scene take place on a multi-level elevated overpass with carbon and transparent forcefield guardrails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the car's taillights appear as blazing red LED trails with a subtle particle effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at a low angle behind the car, ascend, zoom out, and finally rise to a bird's-eye view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a futuristic city at night with holographic advertisements and a cold cyberpunk blue and purple color palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0031894787680357695 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753189563751221 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0031894787680357695, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0031894787680357695, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10031644999980927, + 0.0832189992070198, + 0.04146929457783699, + 0.02526969276368618, + 0.035019051283597946, + 0.043177440762519836, + 0.23505057394504547, + 0.1464463174343109, + 0.24383313953876495, + 0.046199049800634384 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0031894787680357695 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dynamic tracking shot begins from a low angle behind the sports car. The camera follows closely behind it as a sleek, liquid-metal silver sports car speeds at breakneck speed across a multi-level elevated overpass constructed of sleek carbon and transparent forcefield guardrails. Its blazing red LED taillights create long, light-filled trails with a subtle particle effect. As the camera steadily and smoothly ascends and slowly zooms out, the car's silhouette gradually shrinks, becoming a mere point of light darting across the complex network of roads. The camera then widens, revealing the bottomless urban canyon below. The headlights and taillights of countless autonomous vehicles and small aircraft converge into rivers of gold, white, and blue light, flowing continuously through the intricate interchange structure. Finally, the camera rises to a breathtakingly magnificent bird's-eye view, taking in the entire panoramic view of the futuristic city under the night sky - huge dynamic holographic advertisements are projected on the exterior walls of skyscrapers with strange structures that soar into the clouds. The entire picture is dotted with countless dynamic light sources under the cold cyberpunk blue and purple main colors, creating a futuristic atmosphere that is both high-speed and dynamic, magnificent and awe-inspiring.", + "seed": 16684, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_5/index_9855_seed_16684_dp_11_rank_22_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.018367659673094748, + "vlm_logprob": -0.018367659673094748, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.575, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.018367659673094748, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, liquid-metal silver sports car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the scene take place on a multi-level elevated overpass with carbon and transparent forcefield guardrails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the car's taillights appear as blazing red LED trails with a subtle particle effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at a low angle behind the car, ascend, zoom out, and finally rise to a bird's-eye view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a futuristic city at night with holographic advertisements and a cold cyberpunk blue and purple color palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06320317089557648 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8132030963897705 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06320317089557648, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06320317089557648, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22190476953983307, + 0.08856406062841415, + 0.09450877457857132, + 0.14374405145645142, + 0.23391255736351013, + 0.04641093313694, + 0.04681380093097687, + 0.05281468853354454, + 0.019923586398363113, + 0.051402799785137177 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06320317089557648 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, liquid-metal silver sports car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the scene take place on a multi-level elevated overpass with carbon and transparent forcefield guardrails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the car's taillights appear as blazing red LED trails with a subtle particle effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at a low angle behind the car, ascend, zoom out, and finally rise to a bird's-eye view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a futuristic city at night with holographic advertisements and a cold cyberpunk blue and purple color palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012559957802295685 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.38755989074707 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012559957802295685, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012559957802295685, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1217115968465805, + 0.12016133964061737, + 0.035248469561338425, + 0.10882394760847092, + 0.18943126499652863, + 0.06180322542786598, + 0.058216873556375504, + 0.21976102888584137, + 0.043653566390275955, + 0.041188694536685944 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012559957802295685 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, liquid-metal silver sports car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the scene take place on a multi-level elevated overpass with carbon and transparent forcefield guardrails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the car's taillights appear as blazing red LED trails with a subtle particle effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at a low angle behind the car, ascend, zoom out, and finally rise to a bird's-eye view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a futuristic city at night with holographic advertisements and a cold cyberpunk blue and purple color palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005253794603049755 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255253791809082 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005253794603049755, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005253794603049755, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1880970448255539, + 0.17060820758342743, + 0.14865262806415558, + 0.0725826844573021, + 0.24332626163959503, + 0.028355201706290245, + 0.02068016119301319, + 0.03223486244678497, + 0.03681362420320511, + 0.058649320155382156 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005253794603049755 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, liquid-metal silver sports car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the scene take place on a multi-level elevated overpass with carbon and transparent forcefield guardrails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the car's taillights appear as blazing red LED trails with a subtle particle effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at a low angle behind the car, ascend, zoom out, and finally rise to a bird's-eye view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a futuristic city at night with holographic advertisements and a cold cyberpunk blue and purple color palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006730979308485985 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006731033325195 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006730979308485985, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006730979308485985, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14608104526996613, + 0.056680452078580856, + 0.06105600669980049, + 0.043692540377378464, + 0.1546318531036377, + 0.060882922261953354, + 0.04073686897754669, + 0.07397300750017166, + 0.29214465618133545, + 0.07012059539556503 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006730979308485985 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, liquid-metal silver sports car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the scene take place on a multi-level elevated overpass with carbon and transparent forcefield guardrails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the car's taillights appear as blazing red LED trails with a subtle particle effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at a low angle behind the car, ascend, zoom out, and finally rise to a bird's-eye view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a futuristic city at night with holographic advertisements and a cold cyberpunk blue and purple color palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0040903957560658455 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504090309143066 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0040903957560658455, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0040903957560658455, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2251681089401245, + 0.04248926788568497, + 0.09583050012588501, + 0.05002850294113159, + 0.1960296481847763, + 0.08406350761651993, + 0.11361655592918396, + 0.07059959322214127, + 0.0650627538561821, + 0.057111628353595734 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0040903957560658455 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dynamic tracking shot begins from a low angle behind the sports car. The camera follows closely behind it as a sleek, liquid-metal silver sports car speeds at breakneck speed across a multi-level elevated overpass constructed of sleek carbon and transparent forcefield guardrails. Its blazing red LED taillights create long, light-filled trails with a subtle particle effect. As the camera steadily and smoothly ascends and slowly zooms out, the car's silhouette gradually shrinks, becoming a mere point of light darting across the complex network of roads. The camera then widens, revealing the bottomless urban canyon below. The headlights and taillights of countless autonomous vehicles and small aircraft converge into rivers of gold, white, and blue light, flowing continuously through the intricate interchange structure. Finally, the camera rises to a breathtakingly magnificent bird's-eye view, taking in the entire panoramic view of the futuristic city under the night sky - huge dynamic holographic advertisements are projected on the exterior walls of skyscrapers with strange structures that soar into the clouds. The entire picture is dotted with countless dynamic light sources under the cold cyberpunk blue and purple main colors, creating a futuristic atmosphere that is both high-speed and dynamic, magnificent and awe-inspiring.", + "seed": 16685, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_5/index_9855_seed_16685_dp_11_rank_22_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.013213726226240396, + "vlm_logprob": -0.013213726226240396, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.575, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.013213726226240396, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, liquid-metal silver sports car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the scene take place on a multi-level elevated overpass with carbon and transparent forcefield guardrails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the car's taillights appear as blazing red LED trails with a subtle particle effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at a low angle behind the car, ascend, zoom out, and finally rise to a bird's-eye view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a futuristic city at night with holographic advertisements and a cold cyberpunk blue and purple color palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.027067439630627632 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6520674228668213 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.027067439630627632, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.027067439630627632, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4001100957393646, + 0.10890977829694748, + 0.03388223424553871, + 0.054034844040870667, + 0.06600917875766754, + 0.05897526070475578, + 0.10635149478912354, + 0.04734979197382927, + 0.04370259493589401, + 0.08067478239536285 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.027067439630627632 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, liquid-metal silver sports car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the scene take place on a multi-level elevated overpass with carbon and transparent forcefield guardrails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the car's taillights appear as blazing red LED trails with a subtle particle effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at a low angle behind the car, ascend, zoom out, and finally rise to a bird's-eye view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a futuristic city at night with holographic advertisements and a cold cyberpunk blue and purple color palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014211518689990044 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264211654663086 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014211518689990044, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014211518689990044, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19381433725357056, + 0.20646391808986664, + 0.07494733482599258, + 0.07036131620407104, + 0.2520078420639038, + 0.04607480391860008, + 0.043437324464321136, + 0.03875051066279411, + 0.03091251291334629, + 0.04323006421327591 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014211518689990044 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, liquid-metal silver sports car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the scene take place on a multi-level elevated overpass with carbon and transparent forcefield guardrails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the car's taillights appear as blazing red LED trails with a subtle particle effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at a low angle behind the car, ascend, zoom out, and finally rise to a bird's-eye view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a futuristic city at night with holographic advertisements and a cold cyberpunk blue and purple color palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004097993951290846 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504097938537598 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004097993951290846, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004097993951290846, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17590494453907013, + 0.12890899181365967, + 0.12055077403783798, + 0.06568696349859238, + 0.1893354207277298, + 0.0654374286532402, + 0.03946337476372719, + 0.08339569717645645, + 0.09784866124391556, + 0.03346780315041542 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004097993951290846 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, liquid-metal silver sports car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the scene take place on a multi-level elevated overpass with carbon and transparent forcefield guardrails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the car's taillights appear as blazing red LED trails with a subtle particle effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at a low angle behind the car, ascend, zoom out, and finally rise to a bird's-eye view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a futuristic city at night with holographic advertisements and a cold cyberpunk blue and purple color palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016058748587965965 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141058921813965 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016058748587965965, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016058748587965965, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08462151139974594, + 0.05499415099620819, + 0.02443145401775837, + 0.08116108179092407, + 0.38082048296928406, + 0.07147616147994995, + 0.05797811597585678, + 0.14991451799869537, + 0.024465065449476242, + 0.07013749331235886 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016058748587965965 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, liquid-metal silver sports car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the scene take place on a multi-level elevated overpass with carbon and transparent forcefield guardrails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the car's taillights appear as blazing red LED trails with a subtle particle effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at a low angle behind the car, ascend, zoom out, and finally rise to a bird's-eye view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a futuristic city at night with holographic advertisements and a cold cyberpunk blue and purple color palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004632930271327496 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379632949829102 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004632930271327496, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004632930271327496, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3987305164337158, + 0.11628545075654984, + 0.02915896102786064, + 0.049340978264808655, + 0.06377077847719193, + 0.07503489404916763, + 0.07872755080461502, + 0.05296342447400093, + 0.06395970284938812, + 0.0720277726650238 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004632930271327496 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_6/index_tensor([744, 744])_group_6_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_6/index_tensor([744, 744])_group_6_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..ba907d5ba8000a7b72b09d37f10c8dafb1af54d0 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_6/index_tensor([744, 744])_group_6_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "slow, upward tilt begins at a very low angle, capturing the sturdy lower body of a woman, perfectly balanced in a difficult handstand yoga pose. Her hands, fingers spread wide, rest firmly on the sunlit, light-polished wooden floor, the muscular contours of her arms defined and graceful. As the camera smoothly and steadily moves upward, the image gradually reveals her signature form-fitting tracksuit: a vibrant red top with simple, pure white stripes along the sides and arms. The highly stretchy fabric clings to her powerful curves. The background is a minimalist room, where large floor-to-ceiling windows slice the warm afternoon sunlight into brilliant beams, casting them onto the floor and her body, creating a stark contrast of light and shadow. Even tiny particles of dust can be seen dancing peacefully in the air. The camera continued to rise, passing over her black hair tied into a neat high ponytail, the hair glowing softly in the backlight, and finally, the camera slowly fixed on her calm and focused face, her eyes lightly closed, her facial muscles completely relaxed, with a faint smile of satisfaction at the corners of her mouth, and a few tiny beads of sweat oozing from her forehead crystal clear in the sunlight. The whole picture was filled with the Zen spirit of harmonious coexistence of strength and softness, exuding an atmosphere of extreme concentration and peace.", + "seed": 1535, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_6/index_744_seed_1535_dp_12_rank_24_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.0640916190110147, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0640916190110147, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.3, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0640916190110147, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a woman performing a handstand yoga pose?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a form-fitting tracksuit with a vibrant red top and white stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a minimalist room with large floor-to-ceiling windows and visible dust particles in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at a low angle and smoothly tilt upward to reveal the subject's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the woman's face visible at the end with her eyes closed, a faint smile, and beads of sweat on her forehead?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2892928123474121 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.414292812347412 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2892928123474121, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2892928123474121, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1902330070734024, + 0.10950358957052231, + 0.08574693650007248, + 0.04268209636211395, + 0.03970511257648468, + 0.10942922532558441, + 0.09933563321828842, + 0.13866299390792847, + 0.07412419468164444, + 0.11057718843221664 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2892928123474121 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a woman performing a handstand yoga pose?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a form-fitting tracksuit with a vibrant red top and white stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a minimalist room with large floor-to-ceiling windows and visible dust particles in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at a low angle and smoothly tilt upward to reveal the subject's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the woman's face visible at the end with her eyes closed, a faint smile, and beads of sweat on her forehead?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01609734259545803 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141097545623779 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01609734259545803, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01609734259545803, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.26856958866119385, + 0.15618765354156494, + 0.08062615990638733, + 0.03429132327437401, + 0.1027219146490097, + 0.06569002568721771, + 0.11774351447820663, + 0.06479056924581528, + 0.04462023079395294, + 0.0647590234875679 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01609734259545803 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a woman performing a handstand yoga pose?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a form-fitting tracksuit with a vibrant red top and white stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a minimalist room with large floor-to-ceiling windows and visible dust particles in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at a low angle and smoothly tilt upward to reveal the subject's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the woman's face visible at the end with her eyes closed, a faint smile, and beads of sweat on her forehead?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008637567982077599 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758637428283691 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008637567982077599, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008637567982077599, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13814280927181244, + 0.07533764094114304, + 0.059082306921482086, + 0.015120946802198887, + 0.08278229832649231, + 0.15584851801395416, + 0.15554627776145935, + 0.19251684844493866, + 0.08881950378417969, + 0.03680285066366196 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008637567982077599 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a woman performing a handstand yoga pose?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a form-fitting tracksuit with a vibrant red top and white stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a minimalist room with large floor-to-ceiling windows and visible dust particles in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at a low angle and smoothly tilt upward to reveal the subject's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the woman's face visible at the end with her eyes closed, a faint smile, and beads of sweat on her forehead?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0028191369492560625 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877819061279297 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0028191369492560625, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0028191369492560625, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22772397100925446, + 0.1293959617614746, + 0.039257995784282684, + 0.035012755542993546, + 0.04186450317502022, + 0.05461474135518074, + 0.14399319887161255, + 0.17533938586711884, + 0.08081091940402985, + 0.07198654115200043 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0028191369492560625 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a woman performing a handstand yoga pose?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a form-fitting tracksuit with a vibrant red top and white stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a minimalist room with large floor-to-ceiling windows and visible dust particles in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at a low angle and smoothly tilt upward to reveal the subject's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the woman's face visible at the end with her eyes closed, a faint smile, and beads of sweat on her forehead?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036112351808696985 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628611087799072 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036112351808696985, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036112351808696985, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13028843700885773, + 0.07111862301826477, + 0.030436355620622635, + 0.016362762078642845, + 0.02843024954199791, + 0.037117984145879745, + 0.09463458508253098, + 0.10066019743680954, + 0.2875578701496124, + 0.2033928483724594 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036112351808696985 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow, upward tilt begins at a very low angle, capturing the sturdy lower body of a woman, perfectly balanced in a difficult handstand yoga pose. Her hands, fingers spread wide, rest firmly on the sunlit, light-polished wooden floor, the muscular contours of her arms defined and graceful. As the camera smoothly and steadily moves upward, the image gradually reveals her signature form-fitting tracksuit: a vibrant red top with simple, pure white stripes along the sides and arms. The highly stretchy fabric clings to her powerful curves. The background is a minimalist room, where large floor-to-ceiling windows slice the warm afternoon sunlight into brilliant beams, casting them onto the floor and her body, creating a stark contrast of light and shadow. Even tiny particles of dust can be seen dancing peacefully in the air. The camera continued to rise, passing over her black hair tied into a neat high ponytail, the hair glowing softly in the backlight, and finally, the camera slowly fixed on her calm and focused face, her eyes lightly closed, her facial muscles completely relaxed, with a faint smile of satisfaction at the corners of her mouth, and a few tiny beads of sweat oozing from her forehead crystal clear in the sunlight. The whole picture was filled with the Zen spirit of harmonious coexistence of strength and softness, exuding an atmosphere of extreme concentration and peace.", + "seed": 1536, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_6/index_744_seed_1536_dp_12_rank_24_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.07512006727047264, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07512006727047264, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.6, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07512006727047264, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a woman performing a handstand yoga pose?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a form-fitting tracksuit with a vibrant red top and white stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a minimalist room with large floor-to-ceiling windows and visible dust particles in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at a low angle and smoothly tilt upward to reveal the subject's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the woman's face visible at the end with her eyes closed, a faint smile, and beads of sweat on her forehead?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2876208424568176 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4126207828521729 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2876208424568176, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2876208424568176, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.29717862606048584, + 0.10487787425518036, + 0.04464341700077057, + 0.05658472329378128, + 0.1645316630601883, + 0.06059406325221062, + 0.04386189952492714, + 0.06294505298137665, + 0.07192829251289368, + 0.09285444021224976 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2876208424568176 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a woman performing a handstand yoga pose?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a form-fitting tracksuit with a vibrant red top and white stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a minimalist room with large floor-to-ceiling windows and visible dust particles in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at a low angle and smoothly tilt upward to reveal the subject's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the woman's face visible at the end with her eyes closed, a faint smile, and beads of sweat on her forehead?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016097459942102432 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141097545623779 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016097459942102432, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016097459942102432, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09300123155117035, + 0.027960043400526047, + 0.05468912050127983, + 0.03210705518722534, + 0.05112103745341301, + 0.03518977388739586, + 0.022166544571518898, + 0.10951592773199081, + 0.2361227124929428, + 0.3381265699863434 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016097459942102432 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a woman performing a handstand yoga pose?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a form-fitting tracksuit with a vibrant red top and white stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a minimalist room with large floor-to-ceiling windows and visible dust particles in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at a low angle and smoothly tilt upward to reveal the subject's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the woman's face visible at the end with her eyes closed, a faint smile, and beads of sweat on her forehead?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04305848851799965 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168058395385742 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04305848851799965, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04305848851799965, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17402777075767517, + 0.09552381187677383, + 0.25252702832221985, + 0.022545460611581802, + 0.04759807139635086, + 0.02812769263982773, + 0.009799427352845669, + 0.023837286978960037, + 0.2771787941455841, + 0.06883461773395538 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04305848851799965 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a woman performing a handstand yoga pose?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a form-fitting tracksuit with a vibrant red top and white stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a minimalist room with large floor-to-ceiling windows and visible dust particles in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at a low angle and smoothly tilt upward to reveal the subject's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the woman's face visible at the end with her eyes closed, a faint smile, and beads of sweat on her forehead?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002488613361492753 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002488613128662 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002488613361492753, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002488613361492753, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13673505187034607, + 0.056290414184331894, + 0.04602823033928871, + 0.07595773786306381, + 0.18547239899635315, + 0.10117194801568985, + 0.05886814370751381, + 0.09753012657165527, + 0.07318838685750961, + 0.16875755786895752 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002488613361492753 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a woman performing a handstand yoga pose?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a form-fitting tracksuit with a vibrant red top and white stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a minimalist room with large floor-to-ceiling windows and visible dust particles in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at a low angle and smoothly tilt upward to reveal the subject's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the woman's face visible at the end with her eyes closed, a faint smile, and beads of sweat on her forehead?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026334932073950768 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513350009918213 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026334932073950768, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026334932073950768, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07674025744199753, + 0.18037739396095276, + 0.026720067486166954, + 0.041151124984025955, + 0.06140695512294769, + 0.04635355994105339, + 0.05041252449154854, + 0.02874542586505413, + 0.1927952617406845, + 0.29529744386672974 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026334932073950768 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow, upward tilt begins at a very low angle, capturing the sturdy lower body of a woman, perfectly balanced in a difficult handstand yoga pose. Her hands, fingers spread wide, rest firmly on the sunlit, light-polished wooden floor, the muscular contours of her arms defined and graceful. As the camera smoothly and steadily moves upward, the image gradually reveals her signature form-fitting tracksuit: a vibrant red top with simple, pure white stripes along the sides and arms. The highly stretchy fabric clings to her powerful curves. The background is a minimalist room, where large floor-to-ceiling windows slice the warm afternoon sunlight into brilliant beams, casting them onto the floor and her body, creating a stark contrast of light and shadow. Even tiny particles of dust can be seen dancing peacefully in the air. The camera continued to rise, passing over her black hair tied into a neat high ponytail, the hair glowing softly in the backlight, and finally, the camera slowly fixed on her calm and focused face, her eyes lightly closed, her facial muscles completely relaxed, with a faint smile of satisfaction at the corners of her mouth, and a few tiny beads of sweat oozing from her forehead crystal clear in the sunlight. The whole picture was filled with the Zen spirit of harmonious coexistence of strength and softness, exuding an atmosphere of extreme concentration and peace.", + "seed": 1537, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_6/index_744_seed_1537_dp_13_rank_26_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.07100786231458187, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07100786231458187, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.0, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07100786231458187, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a woman performing a handstand yoga pose?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a form-fitting tracksuit with a vibrant red top and white stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a minimalist room with large floor-to-ceiling windows and visible dust particles in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at a low angle and smoothly tilt upward to reveal the subject's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the woman's face visible at the end with her eyes closed, a faint smile, and beads of sweat on her forehead?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3176908493041992 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3176908493041992 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3176908493041992, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3176908493041992, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06670961529016495, + 0.06967376172542572, + 0.06720694899559021, + 0.3254314959049225, + 0.06516324728727341, + 0.031111503019928932, + 0.17447416484355927, + 0.1043478399515152, + 0.0382339246571064, + 0.0576474592089653 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3176908493041992 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a woman performing a handstand yoga pose?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a form-fitting tracksuit with a vibrant red top and white stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a minimalist room with large floor-to-ceiling windows and visible dust particles in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at a low angle and smoothly tilt upward to reveal the subject's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the woman's face visible at the end with her eyes closed, a faint smile, and beads of sweat on her forehead?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007645866833627224 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882646083831787 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007645866833627224, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007645866833627224, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07945410907268524, + 0.07016710937023163, + 0.043231844902038574, + 0.19565406441688538, + 0.1350252330303192, + 0.09203752875328064, + 0.13974370062351227, + 0.11998890340328217, + 0.06800676137208939, + 0.056690823286771774 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007645866833627224 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a woman performing a handstand yoga pose?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a form-fitting tracksuit with a vibrant red top and white stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a minimalist room with large floor-to-ceiling windows and visible dust particles in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at a low angle and smoothly tilt upward to reveal the subject's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the woman's face visible at the end with her eyes closed, a faint smile, and beads of sweat on her forehead?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012537471950054169 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387537479400635 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012537471950054169, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012537471950054169, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23720493912696838, + 0.04931611195206642, + 0.18078047037124634, + 0.04149278625845909, + 0.12846286594867706, + 0.12992584705352783, + 0.08000142872333527, + 0.06339264661073685, + 0.03827543184161186, + 0.05114743113517761 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012537471950054169 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a woman performing a handstand yoga pose?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a form-fitting tracksuit with a vibrant red top and white stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a minimalist room with large floor-to-ceiling windows and visible dust particles in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at a low angle and smoothly tilt upward to reveal the subject's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the woman's face visible at the end with her eyes closed, a faint smile, and beads of sweat on her forehead?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004635303281247616 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379635334014893 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004635303281247616, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004635303281247616, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07443628460168839, + 0.06519695371389389, + 0.03924854099750519, + 0.1217685267329216, + 0.0664227157831192, + 0.06036994606256485, + 0.156529039144516, + 0.20905035734176636, + 0.05697805806994438, + 0.14999955892562866 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004635303281247616 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a woman performing a handstand yoga pose?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a form-fitting tracksuit with a vibrant red top and white stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a minimalist room with large floor-to-ceiling windows and visible dust particles in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at a low angle and smoothly tilt upward to reveal the subject's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the woman's face visible at the end with her eyes closed, a faint smile, and beads of sweat on her forehead?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012529820203781128 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.3875298500061035 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012529820203781128, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012529820203781128, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07196806371212006, + 0.05507618188858032, + 0.06675239652395248, + 0.057327255606651306, + 0.0985744372010231, + 0.08288995176553726, + 0.06886371225118637, + 0.09722194075584412, + 0.05339096486568451, + 0.3479350507259369 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012529820203781128 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow, upward tilt begins at a very low angle, capturing the sturdy lower body of a woman, perfectly balanced in a difficult handstand yoga pose. Her hands, fingers spread wide, rest firmly on the sunlit, light-polished wooden floor, the muscular contours of her arms defined and graceful. As the camera smoothly and steadily moves upward, the image gradually reveals her signature form-fitting tracksuit: a vibrant red top with simple, pure white stripes along the sides and arms. The highly stretchy fabric clings to her powerful curves. The background is a minimalist room, where large floor-to-ceiling windows slice the warm afternoon sunlight into brilliant beams, casting them onto the floor and her body, creating a stark contrast of light and shadow. Even tiny particles of dust can be seen dancing peacefully in the air. The camera continued to rise, passing over her black hair tied into a neat high ponytail, the hair glowing softly in the backlight, and finally, the camera slowly fixed on her calm and focused face, her eyes lightly closed, her facial muscles completely relaxed, with a faint smile of satisfaction at the corners of her mouth, and a few tiny beads of sweat oozing from her forehead crystal clear in the sunlight. The whole picture was filled with the Zen spirit of harmonious coexistence of strength and softness, exuding an atmosphere of extreme concentration and peace.", + "seed": 1538, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_6/index_744_seed_1538_dp_13_rank_26_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.037085703248158096, + "vlm_logprob": -0.037085703248158096, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.3250000238418576, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.037085703248158096, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a woman performing a handstand yoga pose?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a form-fitting tracksuit with a vibrant red top and white stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a minimalist room with large floor-to-ceiling windows and visible dust particles in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at a low angle and smoothly tilt upward to reveal the subject's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the woman's face visible at the end with her eyes closed, a faint smile, and beads of sweat on her forehead?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.15169040858745575 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0266904830932617 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.15169040858745575, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.8750001192092896, + "token_credit_reward": -0.15169040858745575, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10651808977127075, + 0.1777428835630417, + 0.06092623248696327, + 0.066677525639534, + 0.11251380294561386, + 0.11894803494215012, + 0.13980679214000702, + 0.047540221363306046, + 0.1255551427602768, + 0.04377130791544914 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.15169040858745575 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a woman performing a handstand yoga pose?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a form-fitting tracksuit with a vibrant red top and white stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a minimalist room with large floor-to-ceiling windows and visible dust particles in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at a low angle and smoothly tilt upward to reveal the subject's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the woman's face visible at the end with her eyes closed, a faint smile, and beads of sweat on her forehead?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014221626333892345 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264221668243408 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014221626333892345, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014221626333892345, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1750078797340393, + 0.14098143577575684, + 0.052507996559143066, + 0.10939926654100418, + 0.0635213777422905, + 0.05796871706843376, + 0.12704311311244965, + 0.06369713693857193, + 0.17326359450817108, + 0.03660948947072029 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014221626333892345 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a woman performing a handstand yoga pose?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a form-fitting tracksuit with a vibrant red top and white stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a minimalist room with large floor-to-ceiling windows and visible dust particles in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at a low angle and smoothly tilt upward to reveal the subject's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the woman's face visible at the end with her eyes closed, a faint smile, and beads of sweat on her forehead?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011074623093008995 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511074542999268 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011074623093008995, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011074623093008995, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3870532214641571, + 0.06296277046203613, + 0.23660285770893097, + 0.07062821835279465, + 0.0604737251996994, + 0.034268029034137726, + 0.04304775223135948, + 0.03459344431757927, + 0.033265043050050735, + 0.03710487112402916 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011074623093008995 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a woman performing a handstand yoga pose?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a form-fitting tracksuit with a vibrant red top and white stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a minimalist room with large floor-to-ceiling windows and visible dust particles in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at a low angle and smoothly tilt upward to reveal the subject's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the woman's face visible at the end with her eyes closed, a faint smile, and beads of sweat on her forehead?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0031932813581079245 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753193378448486 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0031932813581079245, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0031932813581079245, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2757355272769928, + 0.16465017199516296, + 0.07006748765707016, + 0.1230844035744667, + 0.07881275564432144, + 0.07563278824090958, + 0.034616876393556595, + 0.038988254964351654, + 0.10683021694421768, + 0.03158148378133774 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0031932813581079245 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a woman performing a handstand yoga pose?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a form-fitting tracksuit with a vibrant red top and white stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a minimalist room with large floor-to-ceiling windows and visible dust particles in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at a low angle and smoothly tilt upward to reveal the subject's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the woman's face visible at the end with her eyes closed, a faint smile, and beads of sweat on her forehead?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005248576868325472 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255248546600342 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005248576868325472, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005248576868325472, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.288335919380188, + 0.11586213111877441, + 0.043772902339696884, + 0.04415155202150345, + 0.07209985703229904, + 0.055180903524160385, + 0.07077129185199738, + 0.04972667619585991, + 0.17738406360149384, + 0.0827147513628006 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005248576868325472 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_7/index_tensor([9382, 9382])_group_7_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_7/index_tensor([9382, 9382])_group_7_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..fd0574af5286fc870b869ad951100ef846e859fc --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_7/index_tensor([9382, 9382])_group_7_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "slow-motion tracking shot, shot upward from a low angle, captures this breathtaking moment with a strikingly cinematic composition. On a futuristic asphalt street, lashed by dense rain and reflecting off the vibrant neon lights, Sheriff Black Cat, in his police uniform, is at the apex of his leap from his motorcycle. His jet-black fur gleams wetly under the shimmering cyan and magenta billboards, and raindrops sling off his body in shimmering arcs. He wears a tight-fitting navy blue uniform, the gold shield-shaped badge on his chest reflecting a sharp highlight, and the stiff collar of his white shirt remains crisp in the rain. His body is fully extended in the air, his muscles clearly defined. One front paw thrusts forward with thunderous force, pointed at a target off-screen. His eyes are focused and sharp, their yellow pupils like two bright lights in the darkness. Behind him, the futuristic police motorcycle remains tilted, its red and blue lights spinning silently, casting intermittent halos of light on the wet road. The entire scene is filled with razor-sharp detail, from the distinct hair on his beard to the texture of the fabric of his uniform, while a subtle layer of film grain covers the image, creating an atmosphere of tension, movement, and classic action cinema.", + "seed": 28302, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_7/index_9382_seed_28302_dp_14_rank_28_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.05607363730669022, + "vlm_logprob": -0.05607363730669022, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.325, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.05607363730669022, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a black cat wearing a navy blue police uniform with a gold shield badge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the cat captured in mid-air at the apex of a leap from a motorcycle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a futuristic asphalt street with dense rain and vibrant neon lights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a low angle looking upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a slow-motion effect with visible film grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12734858691692352 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1273486614227295 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12734858691692352, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12734858691692352, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2288762629032135, + 0.08203615993261337, + 0.03826170042157173, + 0.11812755465507507, + 0.04425385966897011, + 0.04253381863236427, + 0.2912621796131134, + 0.013381327502429485, + 0.03018663078546524, + 0.11108047515153885 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12734858691692352 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a black cat wearing a navy blue police uniform with a gold shield badge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the cat captured in mid-air at the apex of a leap from a motorcycle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a futuristic asphalt street with dense rain and vibrant neon lights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a low angle looking upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a slow-motion effect with visible film grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06207147613167763 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120715618133545 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06207147613167763, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06207147613167763, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18846094608306885, + 0.13848741352558136, + 0.11554465442895889, + 0.09584581851959229, + 0.052254822105169296, + 0.06920437514781952, + 0.1621246337890625, + 0.04312023147940636, + 0.031305015087127686, + 0.10365215688943863 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06207147613167763 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a black cat wearing a navy blue police uniform with a gold shield badge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the cat captured in mid-air at the apex of a leap from a motorcycle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a futuristic asphalt street with dense rain and vibrant neon lights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a low angle looking upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a slow-motion effect with visible film grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006739504635334015 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006739616394043 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006739504635334015, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006739504635334015, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13506749272346497, + 0.054855864495038986, + 0.06884709000587463, + 0.07098933309316635, + 0.10710325092077255, + 0.04808465391397476, + 0.31832727789878845, + 0.0644024983048439, + 0.0571550615131855, + 0.07516749948263168 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006739504635334015 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a black cat wearing a navy blue police uniform with a gold shield badge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the cat captured in mid-air at the apex of a leap from a motorcycle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a futuristic asphalt street with dense rain and vibrant neon lights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a low angle looking upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a slow-motion effect with visible film grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07001625746488571 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950161457061768 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07001625746488571, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07001625746488571, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12959864735603333, + 0.06687197834253311, + 0.09812411665916443, + 0.10626504570245743, + 0.09663096070289612, + 0.09087827056646347, + 0.1494612842798233, + 0.03341079130768776, + 0.07405668497085571, + 0.15470217168331146 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07001625746488571 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a black cat wearing a navy blue police uniform with a gold shield badge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the cat captured in mid-air at the apex of a leap from a motorcycle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a futuristic asphalt street with dense rain and vibrant neon lights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a low angle looking upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a slow-motion effect with visible film grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014192361384630203 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264192581176758 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014192361384630203, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014192361384630203, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23846599459648132, + 0.08226268738508224, + 0.06227239966392517, + 0.13814274966716766, + 0.12773440778255463, + 0.06696297228336334, + 0.0855264663696289, + 0.03874265030026436, + 0.046217795461416245, + 0.11367185413837433 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014192361384630203 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow-motion tracking shot, shot upward from a low angle, captures this breathtaking moment with a strikingly cinematic composition. On a futuristic asphalt street, lashed by dense rain and reflecting off the vibrant neon lights, Sheriff Black Cat, in his police uniform, is at the apex of his leap from his motorcycle. His jet-black fur gleams wetly under the shimmering cyan and magenta billboards, and raindrops sling off his body in shimmering arcs. He wears a tight-fitting navy blue uniform, the gold shield-shaped badge on his chest reflecting a sharp highlight, and the stiff collar of his white shirt remains crisp in the rain. His body is fully extended in the air, his muscles clearly defined. One front paw thrusts forward with thunderous force, pointed at a target off-screen. His eyes are focused and sharp, their yellow pupils like two bright lights in the darkness. Behind him, the futuristic police motorcycle remains tilted, its red and blue lights spinning silently, casting intermittent halos of light on the wet road. The entire scene is filled with razor-sharp detail, from the distinct hair on his beard to the texture of the fabric of his uniform, while a subtle layer of film grain covers the image, creating an atmosphere of tension, movement, and classic action cinema.", + "seed": 28303, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_7/index_9382_seed_28303_dp_14_rank_28_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.15900938361883163, + "vlm_logprob": -0.15900938361883163, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.975, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.15900938361883163, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a black cat wearing a navy blue police uniform with a gold shield badge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the cat captured in mid-air at the apex of a leap from a motorcycle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a futuristic asphalt street with dense rain and vibrant neon lights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a low angle looking upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a slow-motion effect with visible film grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6332638263702393 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7582638263702393 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.6332638263702393, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.6332638263702393, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15512296557426453, + 0.050153784453868866, + 0.05714697018265724, + 0.09253744035959244, + 0.19098854064941406, + 0.08064001053571701, + 0.24299632012844086, + 0.048780716955661774, + 0.032243408262729645, + 0.049389831721782684 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.6332638263702393 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a black cat wearing a navy blue police uniform with a gold shield badge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the cat captured in mid-air at the apex of a leap from a motorcycle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a futuristic asphalt street with dense rain and vibrant neon lights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a low angle looking upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a slow-motion effect with visible film grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07902832329273224 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.579028367996216 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07902832329273224, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07902832329273224, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25398826599121094, + 0.0376826673746109, + 0.1066252589225769, + 0.11489463597536087, + 0.07370717078447342, + 0.06455332785844803, + 0.20195789635181427, + 0.08177226036787033, + 0.027857543900609016, + 0.03696100413799286 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07902832329273224 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a black cat wearing a navy blue police uniform with a gold shield badge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the cat captured in mid-air at the apex of a leap from a motorcycle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a futuristic asphalt street with dense rain and vibrant neon lights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a low angle looking upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a slow-motion effect with visible film grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00464111752808094 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379641056060791 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00464111752808094, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00464111752808094, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2793614864349365, + 0.05448104441165924, + 0.07232623547315598, + 0.11106588691473007, + 0.052161213010549545, + 0.08335402607917786, + 0.2023659348487854, + 0.04544190689921379, + 0.029243620112538338, + 0.0701986774802208 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00464111752808094 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a black cat wearing a navy blue police uniform with a gold shield badge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the cat captured in mid-air at the apex of a leap from a motorcycle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a futuristic asphalt street with dense rain and vibrant neon lights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a low angle looking upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a slow-motion effect with visible film grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06204727664589882 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812047243118286 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06204727664589882, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06204727664589882, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3344951272010803, + 0.10299146920442581, + 0.06208766996860504, + 0.11597556620836258, + 0.06474172323942184, + 0.10922884941101074, + 0.061108410358428955, + 0.05550197511911392, + 0.03728017956018448, + 0.05658895522356033 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06204727664589882 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a black cat wearing a navy blue police uniform with a gold shield badge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the cat captured in mid-air at the apex of a leap from a motorcycle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a futuristic asphalt street with dense rain and vibrant neon lights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a low angle looking upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a slow-motion effect with visible film grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016066374257206917 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141066551208496 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016066374257206917, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016066374257206917, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1517026573419571, + 0.1069900244474411, + 0.06660807877779007, + 0.1020621731877327, + 0.07234160602092743, + 0.057836465537548065, + 0.1711214929819107, + 0.1577223539352417, + 0.0500757172703743, + 0.06353943794965744 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016066374257206917 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow-motion tracking shot, shot upward from a low angle, captures this breathtaking moment with a strikingly cinematic composition. On a futuristic asphalt street, lashed by dense rain and reflecting off the vibrant neon lights, Sheriff Black Cat, in his police uniform, is at the apex of his leap from his motorcycle. His jet-black fur gleams wetly under the shimmering cyan and magenta billboards, and raindrops sling off his body in shimmering arcs. He wears a tight-fitting navy blue uniform, the gold shield-shaped badge on his chest reflecting a sharp highlight, and the stiff collar of his white shirt remains crisp in the rain. His body is fully extended in the air, his muscles clearly defined. One front paw thrusts forward with thunderous force, pointed at a target off-screen. His eyes are focused and sharp, their yellow pupils like two bright lights in the darkness. Behind him, the futuristic police motorcycle remains tilted, its red and blue lights spinning silently, casting intermittent halos of light on the wet road. The entire scene is filled with razor-sharp detail, from the distinct hair on his beard to the texture of the fabric of his uniform, while a subtle layer of film grain covers the image, creating an atmosphere of tension, movement, and classic action cinema.", + "seed": 28304, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_7/index_9382_seed_28304_dp_15_rank_30_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.11476566237397492, + "vlm_logprob": -0.11476566237397492, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.375, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.11476566237397492, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a black cat wearing a navy blue police uniform with a gold shield badge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the cat captured in mid-air at the apex of a leap from a motorcycle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a futuristic asphalt street with dense rain and vibrant neon lights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a low angle looking upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a slow-motion effect with visible film grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.47450488805770874 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9745048880577087 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.47450488805770874, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.47450488805770874, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1502237170934677, + 0.14729493856430054, + 0.16337066888809204, + 0.17059509456157684, + 0.06249897927045822, + 0.03280455246567726, + 0.08008766919374466, + 0.049997907131910324, + 0.04469190910458565, + 0.09843453764915466 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.47450488805770874 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a black cat wearing a navy blue police uniform with a gold shield badge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the cat captured in mid-air at the apex of a leap from a motorcycle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a futuristic asphalt street with dense rain and vibrant neon lights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a low angle looking upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a slow-motion effect with visible film grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05498284474015236 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929982900619507 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05498284474015236, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05498284474015236, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24541084468364716, + 0.13628432154655457, + 0.10308369249105453, + 0.13586708903312683, + 0.16463913023471832, + 0.02763528749346733, + 0.054916296154260635, + 0.03607415035367012, + 0.06275433301925659, + 0.03333485126495361 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05498284474015236 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a black cat wearing a navy blue police uniform with a gold shield badge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the cat captured in mid-air at the apex of a leap from a motorcycle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a futuristic asphalt street with dense rain and vibrant neon lights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a low angle looking upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a slow-motion effect with visible film grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003191380063071847 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.7531914710998535 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003191380063071847, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003191380063071847, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24974758923053741, + 0.06680922210216522, + 0.15263833105564117, + 0.10253206640481949, + 0.1814277470111847, + 0.10626288503408432, + 0.05488526076078415, + 0.03153879567980766, + 0.02103842794895172, + 0.033119749277830124 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003191380063071847 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a black cat wearing a navy blue police uniform with a gold shield badge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the cat captured in mid-air at the apex of a leap from a motorcycle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a futuristic asphalt street with dense rain and vibrant neon lights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a low angle looking upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a slow-motion effect with visible film grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020573314279317856 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895573377609253 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020573314279317856, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020573314279317856, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18257944285869598, + 0.0900883749127388, + 0.1584508717060089, + 0.15340715646743774, + 0.06071091443300247, + 0.07063000649213791, + 0.06694820523262024, + 0.05086977407336235, + 0.09292975813150406, + 0.0733855813741684 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020573314279317856 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a black cat wearing a navy blue police uniform with a gold shield badge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the cat captured in mid-air at the apex of a leap from a motorcycle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a futuristic asphalt street with dense rain and vibrant neon lights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a low angle looking upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a slow-motion effect with visible film grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020575884729623795 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895576000213623 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020575884729623795, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020575884729623795, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21438157558441162, + 0.23005999624729156, + 0.04155357927083969, + 0.05931617692112923, + 0.1419440060853958, + 0.1090138629078865, + 0.055375467985868454, + 0.0398605577647686, + 0.03658341243863106, + 0.07191140949726105 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020575884729623795 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow-motion tracking shot, shot upward from a low angle, captures this breathtaking moment with a strikingly cinematic composition. On a futuristic asphalt street, lashed by dense rain and reflecting off the vibrant neon lights, Sheriff Black Cat, in his police uniform, is at the apex of his leap from his motorcycle. His jet-black fur gleams wetly under the shimmering cyan and magenta billboards, and raindrops sling off his body in shimmering arcs. He wears a tight-fitting navy blue uniform, the gold shield-shaped badge on his chest reflecting a sharp highlight, and the stiff collar of his white shirt remains crisp in the rain. His body is fully extended in the air, his muscles clearly defined. One front paw thrusts forward with thunderous force, pointed at a target off-screen. His eyes are focused and sharp, their yellow pupils like two bright lights in the darkness. Behind him, the futuristic police motorcycle remains tilted, its red and blue lights spinning silently, casting intermittent halos of light on the wet road. The entire scene is filled with razor-sharp detail, from the distinct hair on his beard to the texture of the fabric of his uniform, while a subtle layer of film grain covers the image, creating an atmosphere of tension, movement, and classic action cinema.", + "seed": 28305, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_7/index_9382_seed_28305_dp_15_rank_30_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.04441517977975309, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04441517977975309, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.725, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04441517977975309, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a black cat wearing a navy blue police uniform with a gold shield badge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the cat captured in mid-air at the apex of a leap from a motorcycle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a futuristic asphalt street with dense rain and vibrant neon lights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a low angle looking upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a slow-motion effect with visible film grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08917032182216644 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.464170217514038 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08917032182216644, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08917032182216644, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0306316539645195, + 0.0175249595195055, + 0.03046308271586895, + 0.03356432542204857, + 0.050106920301914215, + 0.06481209397315979, + 0.024451494216918945, + 0.07653449475765228, + 0.19274845719337463, + 0.4791624844074249 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08917032182216644 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a black cat wearing a navy blue police uniform with a gold shield badge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the cat captured in mid-air at the apex of a leap from a motorcycle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a futuristic asphalt street with dense rain and vibrant neon lights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a low angle looking upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a slow-motion effect with visible film grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05496659502387047 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929966688156128 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05496659502387047, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05496659502387047, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.059393975883722305, + 0.016590720042586327, + 0.02470916323363781, + 0.044130731374025345, + 0.04097789153456688, + 0.06481830775737762, + 0.03979020565748215, + 0.05008295178413391, + 0.2115509957075119, + 0.44795507192611694 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05496659502387047 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a black cat wearing a navy blue police uniform with a gold shield badge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the cat captured in mid-air at the apex of a leap from a motorcycle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a futuristic asphalt street with dense rain and vibrant neon lights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a low angle looking upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a slow-motion effect with visible film grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0017130000051110983 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.376712799072266 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0017130000051110983, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0017130000051110983, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24810166656970978, + 0.06869541853666306, + 0.055138085037469864, + 0.09738047420978546, + 0.05783252418041229, + 0.09751962125301361, + 0.030030332505702972, + 0.04258899390697479, + 0.12917619943618774, + 0.17353667318820953 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0017130000051110983 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a black cat wearing a navy blue police uniform with a gold shield badge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the cat captured in mid-air at the apex of a leap from a motorcycle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a futuristic asphalt street with dense rain and vibrant neon lights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a low angle looking upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a slow-motion effect with visible film grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.062035735696554184 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120357990264893 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.062035735696554184, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.062035735696554184, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.059171076864004135, + 0.0206945538520813, + 0.015357177704572678, + 0.036527227610349655, + 0.07407219707965851, + 0.0848788172006607, + 0.04450472071766853, + 0.0669563040137291, + 0.05769951269030571, + 0.5401384234428406 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.062035735696554184 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a black cat wearing a navy blue police uniform with a gold shield badge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the cat captured in mid-air at the apex of a leap from a motorcycle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a futuristic asphalt street with dense rain and vibrant neon lights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a low angle looking upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a slow-motion effect with visible film grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014190246351063251 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264190196990967 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014190246351063251, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014190246351063251, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1280183643102646, + 0.06610217690467834, + 0.05667731910943985, + 0.038539376109838486, + 0.04451039060950279, + 0.08600354194641113, + 0.03316627815365791, + 0.09800013899803162, + 0.31132984161376953, + 0.13765259087085724 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014190246351063251 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_8/index_tensor([2556, 2556])_group_8_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_8/index_tensor([2556, 2556])_group_8_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..47cff75fcaf08c8c1025b4f7e3ce5385caf57a9a --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_8/index_tensor([2556, 2556])_group_8_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "An elegant, sweeping, high-angle drone shot gracefully tracks a vibrant metallic red Corvette C8 Stingray, its signature mid-engine silhouette defined by sharp aerodynamic lines and large side air intakes, as it effortlessly cruises along a winding coastal highway. The entire scene is bathed in the warm, saturated light of golden hour, with the low-hanging sun casting long, dramatic shadows stretching across the smooth asphalt. The intense golden glow gleams off the car's immaculate, highly polished paint and multi-spoke alloy wheels. On one side of the road, rugged, sun-bathed cliffs rise dramatically, their earthy hues gleaming in the afternoon sun. On the other side, a vast expanse of deep blue ocean shimmers endlessly toward the horizon, gentle white waves lapping against the rocky coastline below. The Corvette navigates the road's graceful S-curves with smooth, powerful precision, its motion creating a breathtaking aura of freedom and high-performance elegance.", + "seed": 11508, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_8/index_2556_seed_11508_dp_16_rank_32_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.022748801205307246, + "vlm_logprob": -0.022748801205307246, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.1, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.022748801205307246, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a metallic red Corvette C8 Stingray with a mid-engine silhouette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the car driving along a winding coastal highway with smooth, powerful motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by the warm, saturated light of golden hour with long shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background feature rugged sun-bathed cliffs on one side and a deep blue ocean on the other?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a high-angle drone perspective that tracks the car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.015710745006799698 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.390710830688477 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.015710745006799698, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.015710745006799698, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19491444528102875, + 0.04779645800590515, + 0.04926285892724991, + 0.07586660236120224, + 0.13517305254936218, + 0.06973480433225632, + 0.03823310136795044, + 0.11003388464450836, + 0.10039136558771133, + 0.17859336733818054 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.015710745006799698 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a metallic red Corvette C8 Stingray with a mid-engine silhouette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the car driving along a winding coastal highway with smooth, powerful motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by the warm, saturated light of golden hour with long shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background feature rugged sun-bathed cliffs on one side and a deep blue ocean on the other?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a high-angle drone perspective that tracks the car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014202586375176907 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.26420259475708 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014202586375176907, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014202586375176907, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2207006812095642, + 0.03996863216161728, + 0.05468357726931572, + 0.23441259562969208, + 0.10315683484077454, + 0.05826680362224579, + 0.02484261989593506, + 0.07279716432094574, + 0.09801433980464935, + 0.09315670281648636 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014202586375176907 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a metallic red Corvette C8 Stingray with a mid-engine silhouette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the car driving along a winding coastal highway with smooth, powerful motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by the warm, saturated light of golden hour with long shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background feature rugged sun-bathed cliffs on one side and a deep blue ocean on the other?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a high-angle drone perspective that tracks the car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007627647835761309 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882627487182617 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007627647835761309, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007627647835761309, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10006590187549591, + 0.04371005296707153, + 0.029432110488414764, + 0.06914152204990387, + 0.07161688804626465, + 0.06424646079540253, + 0.03414153680205345, + 0.20876376330852509, + 0.054675742983818054, + 0.32420608401298523 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007627647835761309 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a metallic red Corvette C8 Stingray with a mid-engine silhouette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the car driving along a winding coastal highway with smooth, powerful motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by the warm, saturated light of golden hour with long shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background feature rugged sun-bathed cliffs on one side and a deep blue ocean on the other?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a high-angle drone perspective that tracks the car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014190481044352055 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264190673828125 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014190481044352055, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014190481044352055, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18014448881149292, + 0.14009903371334076, + 0.04097013920545578, + 0.08232145011425018, + 0.21143323183059692, + 0.04660673066973686, + 0.042112648487091064, + 0.14582449197769165, + 0.04072790965437889, + 0.06975992769002914 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014190481044352055 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a metallic red Corvette C8 Stingray with a mid-engine silhouette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the car driving along a winding coastal highway with smooth, powerful motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by the warm, saturated light of golden hour with long shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background feature rugged sun-bathed cliffs on one side and a deep blue ocean on the other?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a high-angle drone perspective that tracks the car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06201254576444626 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120124340057373 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06201254576444626, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06201254576444626, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1221165806055069, + 0.09502119570970535, + 0.0654374286532402, + 0.15311552584171295, + 0.0503697544336319, + 0.07524263113737106, + 0.06230245158076286, + 0.11037576198577881, + 0.027171574532985687, + 0.23884710669517517 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06201254576444626 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An elegant, sweeping, high-angle drone shot gracefully tracks a vibrant metallic red Corvette C8 Stingray, its signature mid-engine silhouette defined by sharp aerodynamic lines and large side air intakes, as it effortlessly cruises along a winding coastal highway. The entire scene is bathed in the warm, saturated light of golden hour, with the low-hanging sun casting long, dramatic shadows stretching across the smooth asphalt. The intense golden glow gleams off the car's immaculate, highly polished paint and multi-spoke alloy wheels. On one side of the road, rugged, sun-bathed cliffs rise dramatically, their earthy hues gleaming in the afternoon sun. On the other side, a vast expanse of deep blue ocean shimmers endlessly toward the horizon, gentle white waves lapping against the rocky coastline below. The Corvette navigates the road's graceful S-curves with smooth, powerful precision, its motion creating a breathtaking aura of freedom and high-performance elegance.", + "seed": 11509, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_8/index_2556_seed_11509_dp_16_rank_32_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.023920568148605527, + "vlm_logprob": -0.023920568148605527, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.425, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.023920568148605527, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a metallic red Corvette C8 Stingray with a mid-engine silhouette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the car driving along a winding coastal highway with smooth, powerful motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by the warm, saturated light of golden hour with long shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background feature rugged sun-bathed cliffs on one side and a deep blue ocean on the other?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a high-angle drone perspective that tracks the car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014243955723941326 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.389244079589844 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014243955723941326, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014243955723941326, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1855941116809845, + 0.01032655593007803, + 0.010940446518361568, + 0.023188093677163124, + 0.0884314477443695, + 0.07339492440223694, + 0.012573540210723877, + 0.029175862669944763, + 0.5534001588821411, + 0.012974769808351994 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014243955723941326 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a metallic red Corvette C8 Stingray with a mid-engine silhouette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the car driving along a winding coastal highway with smooth, powerful motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by the warm, saturated light of golden hour with long shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background feature rugged sun-bathed cliffs on one side and a deep blue ocean on the other?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a high-angle drone perspective that tracks the car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008646667934954166 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758646488189697 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008646667934954166, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008646667934954166, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11884842067956924, + 0.14337067306041718, + 0.022973334416747093, + 0.08779456466436386, + 0.08021119236946106, + 0.10637874901294708, + 0.02560429833829403, + 0.1276511549949646, + 0.250861257314682, + 0.03630632534623146 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008646667934954166 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a metallic red Corvette C8 Stingray with a mid-engine silhouette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the car driving along a winding coastal highway with smooth, powerful motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by the warm, saturated light of golden hour with long shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background feature rugged sun-bathed cliffs on one side and a deep blue ocean on the other?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a high-angle drone perspective that tracks the car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01606074348092079 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141060829162598 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01606074348092079, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01606074348092079, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0917840227484703, + 0.05360857769846916, + 0.02950294502079487, + 0.0574667863547802, + 0.37013134360313416, + 0.21290956437587738, + 0.0356292687356472, + 0.039648883044719696, + 0.07800918817520142, + 0.03130943328142166 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01606074348092079 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a metallic red Corvette C8 Stingray with a mid-engine silhouette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the car driving along a winding coastal highway with smooth, powerful motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by the warm, saturated light of golden hour with long shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background feature rugged sun-bathed cliffs on one side and a deep blue ocean on the other?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a high-angle drone perspective that tracks the car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0017105009173974395 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.376710414886475 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0017105009173974395, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0017105009173974395, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2485525757074356, + 0.024059655144810677, + 0.0068155815824866295, + 0.023099537938833237, + 0.1858365535736084, + 0.024908196181058884, + 0.03270404785871506, + 0.025400817394256592, + 0.3565603494644165, + 0.0720626562833786 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0017105009173974395 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a metallic red Corvette C8 Stingray with a mid-engine silhouette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the car driving along a winding coastal highway with smooth, powerful motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by the warm, saturated light of golden hour with long shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background feature rugged sun-bathed cliffs on one side and a deep blue ocean on the other?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a high-angle drone perspective that tracks the car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0789409726858139 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5789408683776855 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0789409726858139, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0789409726858139, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5920765995979309, + 0.010241706855595112, + 0.008071263320744038, + 0.00838423054665327, + 0.1947764903306961, + 0.056759677827358246, + 0.007634448818862438, + 0.03868914023041725, + 0.06788668036460876, + 0.015479686670005322 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0789409726858139 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An elegant, sweeping, high-angle drone shot gracefully tracks a vibrant metallic red Corvette C8 Stingray, its signature mid-engine silhouette defined by sharp aerodynamic lines and large side air intakes, as it effortlessly cruises along a winding coastal highway. The entire scene is bathed in the warm, saturated light of golden hour, with the low-hanging sun casting long, dramatic shadows stretching across the smooth asphalt. The intense golden glow gleams off the car's immaculate, highly polished paint and multi-spoke alloy wheels. On one side of the road, rugged, sun-bathed cliffs rise dramatically, their earthy hues gleaming in the afternoon sun. On the other side, a vast expanse of deep blue ocean shimmers endlessly toward the horizon, gentle white waves lapping against the rocky coastline below. The Corvette navigates the road's graceful S-curves with smooth, powerful precision, its motion creating a breathtaking aura of freedom and high-performance elegance.", + "seed": 11510, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_8/index_2556_seed_11510_dp_17_rank_34_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.021667570900171997, + "vlm_logprob": -0.021667570900171997, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.175, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.021667570900171997, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a metallic red Corvette C8 Stingray with a mid-engine silhouette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the car driving along a winding coastal highway with smooth, powerful motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by the warm, saturated light of golden hour with long shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background feature rugged sun-bathed cliffs on one side and a deep blue ocean on the other?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a high-angle drone perspective that tracks the car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.028518103063106537 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6535181999206543 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.028518103063106537, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.028518103063106537, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14156626164913177, + 0.04953976720571518, + 0.09858256578445435, + 0.07812349498271942, + 0.16481482982635498, + 0.061783380806446075, + 0.12976409494876862, + 0.12410343438386917, + 0.08103931695222855, + 0.07068277150392532 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.028518103063106537 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a metallic red Corvette C8 Stingray with a mid-engine silhouette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the car driving along a winding coastal highway with smooth, powerful motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by the warm, saturated light of golden hour with long shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background feature rugged sun-bathed cliffs on one side and a deep blue ocean on the other?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a high-angle drone perspective that tracks the car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007635574322193861 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882635593414307 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007635574322193861, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007635574322193861, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3988821804523468, + 0.08927298337221146, + 0.12781038880348206, + 0.08966723084449768, + 0.1007423922419548, + 0.035317663103342056, + 0.056257206946611404, + 0.047316960990428925, + 0.01727418042719364, + 0.03745884820818901 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007635574322193861 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a metallic red Corvette C8 Stingray with a mid-engine silhouette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the car driving along a winding coastal highway with smooth, powerful motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by the warm, saturated light of golden hour with long shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background feature rugged sun-bathed cliffs on one side and a deep blue ocean on the other?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a high-angle drone perspective that tracks the car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008630595169961452 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758630752563477 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008630595169961452, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008630595169961452, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21669472754001617, + 0.05697759985923767, + 0.10515659302473068, + 0.24223962426185608, + 0.09279343485832214, + 0.08341845870018005, + 0.0676037073135376, + 0.06338653713464737, + 0.04974643886089325, + 0.02198288030922413 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008630595169961452 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a metallic red Corvette C8 Stingray with a mid-engine silhouette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the car driving along a winding coastal highway with smooth, powerful motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by the warm, saturated light of golden hour with long shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background feature rugged sun-bathed cliffs on one side and a deep blue ocean on the other?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a high-angle drone perspective that tracks the car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008631895296275616 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758631706237793 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008631895296275616, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008631895296275616, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25988706946372986, + 0.11502955853939056, + 0.10426712036132812, + 0.06950952112674713, + 0.03187461197376251, + 0.11308452486991882, + 0.0602736622095108, + 0.13387401401996613, + 0.05178826302289963, + 0.06041168048977852 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008631895296275616 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a metallic red Corvette C8 Stingray with a mid-engine silhouette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the car driving along a winding coastal highway with smooth, powerful motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by the warm, saturated light of golden hour with long shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background feature rugged sun-bathed cliffs on one side and a deep blue ocean on the other?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a high-angle drone perspective that tracks the car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05492168664932251 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299216270446777 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05492168664932251, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05492168664932251, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13292038440704346, + 0.1100807785987854, + 0.1236855760216713, + 0.1407015174627304, + 0.1690264493227005, + 0.05119125545024872, + 0.05120706185698509, + 0.11371387541294098, + 0.05148812383413315, + 0.055984947830438614 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05492168664932251 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An elegant, sweeping, high-angle drone shot gracefully tracks a vibrant metallic red Corvette C8 Stingray, its signature mid-engine silhouette defined by sharp aerodynamic lines and large side air intakes, as it effortlessly cruises along a winding coastal highway. The entire scene is bathed in the warm, saturated light of golden hour, with the low-hanging sun casting long, dramatic shadows stretching across the smooth asphalt. The intense golden glow gleams off the car's immaculate, highly polished paint and multi-spoke alloy wheels. On one side of the road, rugged, sun-bathed cliffs rise dramatically, their earthy hues gleaming in the afternoon sun. On the other side, a vast expanse of deep blue ocean shimmers endlessly toward the horizon, gentle white waves lapping against the rocky coastline below. The Corvette navigates the road's graceful S-curves with smooth, powerful precision, its motion creating a breathtaking aura of freedom and high-performance elegance.", + "seed": 11511, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_8/index_2556_seed_11511_dp_17_rank_34_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.015505403140559792, + "vlm_logprob": -0.015505403140559792, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.474999952316284, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.015505403140559792, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a metallic red Corvette C8 Stingray with a mid-engine silhouette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the car driving along a winding coastal highway with smooth, powerful motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by the warm, saturated light of golden hour with long shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background feature rugged sun-bathed cliffs on one side and a deep blue ocean on the other?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a high-angle drone perspective that tracks the car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02224983088672161 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.022249698638916 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02224983088672161, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02224983088672161, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12598639726638794, + 0.02990548685193062, + 0.05418635904788971, + 0.4662726819515228, + 0.05079001560807228, + 0.036678802222013474, + 0.04728568345308304, + 0.016642697155475616, + 0.07914484292268753, + 0.0931069552898407 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02224983088672161 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a metallic red Corvette C8 Stingray with a mid-engine silhouette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the car driving along a winding coastal highway with smooth, powerful motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by the warm, saturated light of golden hour with long shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background feature rugged sun-bathed cliffs on one side and a deep blue ocean on the other?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a high-angle drone perspective that tracks the car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014211754314601421 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264211654663086 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014211754314601421, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014211754314601421, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.021317914128303528, + 0.026802262291312218, + 0.0145356310531497, + 0.6239409446716309, + 0.23241443932056427, + 0.0277315191924572, + 0.015776967629790306, + 0.009533131495118141, + 0.016954248771071434, + 0.010992937721312046 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014211754314601421 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a metallic red Corvette C8 Stingray with a mid-engine silhouette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the car driving along a winding coastal highway with smooth, powerful motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by the warm, saturated light of golden hour with long shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background feature rugged sun-bathed cliffs on one side and a deep blue ocean on the other?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a high-angle drone perspective that tracks the car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012537707574665546 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387537479400635 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012537707574665546, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012537707574665546, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12297278642654419, + 0.07797103375196457, + 0.034936416894197464, + 0.1466173380613327, + 0.23150920867919922, + 0.07076440751552582, + 0.17861856520175934, + 0.023682041093707085, + 0.04693761467933655, + 0.06599059700965881 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012537707574665546 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a metallic red Corvette C8 Stingray with a mid-engine silhouette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the car driving along a winding coastal highway with smooth, powerful motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by the warm, saturated light of golden hour with long shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background feature rugged sun-bathed cliffs on one side and a deep blue ocean on the other?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a high-angle drone perspective that tracks the car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002195925684645772 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127195835113525 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002195925684645772, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002195925684645772, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12171061336994171, + 0.044983379542827606, + 0.03884076699614525, + 0.050761155784130096, + 0.4067314565181732, + 0.06229759380221367, + 0.15306325256824493, + 0.02999841794371605, + 0.057754408568143845, + 0.033858899027109146 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002195925684645772 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a metallic red Corvette C8 Stingray with a mid-engine silhouette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the car driving along a winding coastal highway with smooth, powerful motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by the warm, saturated light of golden hour with long shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background feature rugged sun-bathed cliffs on one side and a deep blue ocean on the other?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a high-angle drone perspective that tracks the car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026331797242164612 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651331901550293 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026331797242164612, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026331797242164612, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08083941042423248, + 0.016025280579924583, + 0.01980533078312874, + 0.35663366317749023, + 0.39668506383895874, + 0.04606844112277031, + 0.051812175661325455, + 0.009517750702798367, + 0.007783557754009962, + 0.014829439111053944 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026331797242164612 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_9/index_tensor([9491, 9491])_group_9_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_9/index_tensor([9491, 9491])_group_9_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..34c451ec35def392877edd363698cde3bfce464d --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_9/index_tensor([9491, 9491])_group_9_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "sweeping, high-angle drone shot tracks smoothly alongside a lone rider clad in full, matte-black futuristic motocross armor, its articulated composite panels gleaming subtly in the sunlight. The rider's posture is focused and low on a powerful, angular dirt bike, a matching matte black and gunmetal gray machine with exposed, heavy-duty suspension. As they relentlessly traverse the landscape, the bike's oversized rear tire aggressively kicks up a thick, billowing cloud of ochre dust that hangs suspended in the air. The camera follows, capturing their swift and decisive navigation across the rugged terrain: a vast, sun-scorched wasteland stretching to a jagged mesa on the distant horizon. The entire scene is bathed in the warm, harsh light of the late afternoon sun, casting long, dramatic shadows and brightly backlit, swirling clouds of dust, creating a golden haze against the deep blue sky. The warm tones, predominantly earthy reds and browns, contrast sharply with the rider's dark, anonymous silhouette, evoking a powerful atmosphere of solitary, high-speed determination on this epic, unfolding journey.", + "seed": 24986, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_9/index_9491_seed_24986_dp_18_rank_36_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.03797569184098393, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03797569184098393, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.375, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03797569184098393, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a lone rider wearing full matte-black futuristic motocross armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the rider on a powerful, angular dirt bike with exposed heavy-duty suspension?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bike kick up a thick, billowing cloud of ochre dust while moving?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a vast, sun-scorched wasteland with a jagged mesa on the horizon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a sweeping high-angle drone view that tracks smoothly alongside the rider?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06391341984272003 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.813913345336914 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06391341984272003, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06391341984272003, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1340552717447281, + 0.08514949679374695, + 0.17446091771125793, + 0.048222508281469345, + 0.07805484533309937, + 0.025801904499530792, + 0.22337694466114044, + 0.12798167765140533, + 0.02836505137383938, + 0.07453130930662155 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06391341984272003 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a lone rider wearing full matte-black futuristic motocross armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the rider on a powerful, angular dirt bike with exposed heavy-duty suspension?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bike kick up a thick, billowing cloud of ochre dust while moving?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a vast, sun-scorched wasteland with a jagged mesa on the horizon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a sweeping high-angle drone view that tracks smoothly alongside the rider?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005949999671429396 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130949974060059 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005949999671429396, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005949999671429396, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06757992506027222, + 0.05757956579327583, + 0.05613784119486809, + 0.04681764170527458, + 0.0339815728366375, + 0.010967760346829891, + 0.13899286091327667, + 0.026187673211097717, + 0.007641841657459736, + 0.5541133284568787 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005949999671429396 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a lone rider wearing full matte-black futuristic motocross armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the rider on a powerful, angular dirt bike with exposed heavy-duty suspension?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bike kick up a thick, billowing cloud of ochre dust while moving?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a vast, sun-scorched wasteland with a jagged mesa on the horizon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a sweeping high-angle drone view that tracks smoothly alongside the rider?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0011792379664257169 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.751179218292236 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0011792379664257169, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0011792379664257169, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12779507040977478, + 0.13387686014175415, + 0.14063628017902374, + 0.20629695057868958, + 0.08587219566106796, + 0.07009156048297882, + 0.06173611432313919, + 0.10880886763334274, + 0.03103349357843399, + 0.03385256230831146 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0011792379664257169 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a lone rider wearing full matte-black futuristic motocross armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the rider on a powerful, angular dirt bike with exposed heavy-duty suspension?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bike kick up a thick, billowing cloud of ochre dust while moving?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a vast, sun-scorched wasteland with a jagged mesa on the horizon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a sweeping high-angle drone view that tracks smoothly alongside the rider?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005941467825323343 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130941390991211 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005941467825323343, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005941467825323343, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.016602791845798492, + 0.011333778500556946, + 0.012136908248066902, + 0.009417256340384483, + 0.0197447519749403, + 0.0031091622076928616, + 0.02352873422205448, + 0.003788819769397378, + 0.003929842729121447, + 0.8964079022407532 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005941467825323343 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a lone rider wearing full matte-black futuristic motocross armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the rider on a powerful, angular dirt bike with exposed heavy-duty suspension?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bike kick up a thick, billowing cloud of ochre dust while moving?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a vast, sun-scorched wasteland with a jagged mesa on the horizon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a sweeping high-angle drone view that tracks smoothly alongside the rider?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11289433389902115 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.237894296646118 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11289433389902115, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11289433389902115, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09140925854444504, + 0.11779969930648804, + 0.09451756626367569, + 0.06792391836643219, + 0.1736251711845398, + 0.010534120723605156, + 0.21265992522239685, + 0.013082988560199738, + 0.013694298453629017, + 0.20475299656391144 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11289433389902115 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "sweeping, high-angle drone shot tracks smoothly alongside a lone rider clad in full, matte-black futuristic motocross armor, its articulated composite panels gleaming subtly in the sunlight. The rider's posture is focused and low on a powerful, angular dirt bike, a matching matte black and gunmetal gray machine with exposed, heavy-duty suspension. As they relentlessly traverse the landscape, the bike's oversized rear tire aggressively kicks up a thick, billowing cloud of ochre dust that hangs suspended in the air. The camera follows, capturing their swift and decisive navigation across the rugged terrain: a vast, sun-scorched wasteland stretching to a jagged mesa on the distant horizon. The entire scene is bathed in the warm, harsh light of the late afternoon sun, casting long, dramatic shadows and brightly backlit, swirling clouds of dust, creating a golden haze against the deep blue sky. The warm tones, predominantly earthy reds and browns, contrast sharply with the rider's dark, anonymous silhouette, evoking a powerful atmosphere of solitary, high-speed determination on this epic, unfolding journey.", + "seed": 24987, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_9/index_9491_seed_24987_dp_18_rank_36_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.05649351483443752, + "vlm_logprob": -0.05649351483443752, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.3, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.05649351483443752, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a lone rider wearing full matte-black futuristic motocross armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the rider on a powerful, angular dirt bike with exposed heavy-duty suspension?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bike kick up a thick, billowing cloud of ochre dust while moving?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a vast, sun-scorched wasteland with a jagged mesa on the horizon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a sweeping high-angle drone view that tracks smoothly alongside the rider?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.09112577140331268 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.466125726699829 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.09112577140331268, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.09112577140331268, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09367820620536804, + 0.0837511494755745, + 0.05906115472316742, + 0.036968082189559937, + 0.1139753982424736, + 0.16969332098960876, + 0.23999816179275513, + 0.05118236318230629, + 0.06868026405572891, + 0.08301189541816711 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.09112577140331268 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a lone rider wearing full matte-black futuristic motocross armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the rider on a powerful, angular dirt bike with exposed heavy-duty suspension?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bike kick up a thick, billowing cloud of ochre dust while moving?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a vast, sun-scorched wasteland with a jagged mesa on the horizon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a sweeping high-angle drone view that tracks smoothly alongside the rider?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004641592036932707 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379641532897949 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004641592036932707, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004641592036932707, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09283760190010071, + 0.08255585283041, + 0.10510870814323425, + 0.059744492173194885, + 0.11509745568037033, + 0.1346103698015213, + 0.09929507970809937, + 0.14918795228004456, + 0.10489364713430405, + 0.05666882172226906 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004641592036932707 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a lone rider wearing full matte-black futuristic motocross armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the rider on a powerful, angular dirt bike with exposed heavy-duty suspension?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bike kick up a thick, billowing cloud of ochre dust while moving?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a vast, sun-scorched wasteland with a jagged mesa on the horizon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a sweeping high-angle drone view that tracks smoothly alongside the rider?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0009201106731779873 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.000920295715332 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0009201106731779873, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0009201106731779873, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10295982658863068, + 0.06870780885219574, + 0.05105376988649368, + 0.0967697948217392, + 0.06386812776327133, + 0.040936172008514404, + 0.07545093446969986, + 0.31631559133529663, + 0.09618140757083893, + 0.08775649964809418 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0009201106731779873 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a lone rider wearing full matte-black futuristic motocross armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the rider on a powerful, angular dirt bike with exposed heavy-duty suspension?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bike kick up a thick, billowing cloud of ochre dust while moving?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a vast, sun-scorched wasteland with a jagged mesa on the horizon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a sweeping high-angle drone view that tracks smoothly alongside the rider?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005940638016909361 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.1309404373168945 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005940638016909361, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005940638016909361, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12476891279220581, + 0.28191256523132324, + 0.05028502270579338, + 0.039572007954120636, + 0.03983210772275925, + 0.03429024666547775, + 0.08112446963787079, + 0.11815910786390305, + 0.14159128069877625, + 0.08846424520015717 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005940638016909361 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a lone rider wearing full matte-black futuristic motocross armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the rider on a powerful, angular dirt bike with exposed heavy-duty suspension?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bike kick up a thick, billowing cloud of ochre dust while moving?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a vast, sun-scorched wasteland with a jagged mesa on the horizon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a sweeping high-angle drone view that tracks smoothly alongside the rider?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17983946204185486 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8048394918441772 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17983946204185486, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17983946204185486, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1490585207939148, + 0.08478399366140366, + 0.06737135350704193, + 0.049991875886917114, + 0.1315719485282898, + 0.04761425778269768, + 0.08201070129871368, + 0.1905638426542282, + 0.09770629554986954, + 0.09932713210582733 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17983946204185486 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "sweeping, high-angle drone shot tracks smoothly alongside a lone rider clad in full, matte-black futuristic motocross armor, its articulated composite panels gleaming subtly in the sunlight. The rider's posture is focused and low on a powerful, angular dirt bike, a matching matte black and gunmetal gray machine with exposed, heavy-duty suspension. As they relentlessly traverse the landscape, the bike's oversized rear tire aggressively kicks up a thick, billowing cloud of ochre dust that hangs suspended in the air. The camera follows, capturing their swift and decisive navigation across the rugged terrain: a vast, sun-scorched wasteland stretching to a jagged mesa on the distant horizon. The entire scene is bathed in the warm, harsh light of the late afternoon sun, casting long, dramatic shadows and brightly backlit, swirling clouds of dust, creating a golden haze against the deep blue sky. The warm tones, predominantly earthy reds and browns, contrast sharply with the rider's dark, anonymous silhouette, evoking a powerful atmosphere of solitary, high-speed determination on this epic, unfolding journey.", + "seed": 24988, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_9/index_9491_seed_24988_dp_19_rank_38_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.04883631041739136, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04883631041739136, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.1, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04883631041739136, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a lone rider wearing full matte-black futuristic motocross armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the rider on a powerful, angular dirt bike with exposed heavy-duty suspension?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bike kick up a thick, billowing cloud of ochre dust while moving?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a vast, sun-scorched wasteland with a jagged mesa on the horizon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a sweeping high-angle drone view that tracks smoothly alongside the rider?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11453165858983994 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2395317554473877 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11453165858983994, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11453165858983994, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.29256322979927063, + 0.06326166540384293, + 0.07934296876192093, + 0.13372771441936493, + 0.10285338759422302, + 0.0766889899969101, + 0.07800497114658356, + 0.06254256516695023, + 0.0556936115026474, + 0.05532088875770569 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11453165858983994 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a lone rider wearing full matte-black futuristic motocross armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the rider on a powerful, angular dirt bike with exposed heavy-duty suspension?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bike kick up a thick, billowing cloud of ochre dust while moving?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a vast, sun-scorched wasteland with a jagged mesa on the horizon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a sweeping high-angle drone view that tracks smoothly alongside the rider?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00978577509522438 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.6347856521606445 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00978577509522438, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00978577509522438, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.8084321618080139, + 0.011261122301220894, + 0.02392641268670559, + 0.025274628773331642, + 0.021740932017564774, + 0.01723361201584339, + 0.01741188019514084, + 0.01616014540195465, + 0.04244755953550339, + 0.016111578792333603 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00978577509522438 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a lone rider wearing full matte-black futuristic motocross armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the rider on a powerful, angular dirt bike with exposed heavy-duty suspension?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bike kick up a thick, billowing cloud of ochre dust while moving?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a vast, sun-scorched wasteland with a jagged mesa on the horizon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a sweeping high-angle drone view that tracks smoothly alongside the rider?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0017133570509031415 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.376713275909424 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0017133570509031415, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0017133570509031415, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.6061098575592041, + 0.03790530189871788, + 0.04480220749974251, + 0.03574233874678612, + 0.04173593968153, + 0.10274018347263336, + 0.01605088636279106, + 0.023669138550758362, + 0.0648755133152008, + 0.02636866830289364 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0017133570509031415 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a lone rider wearing full matte-black futuristic motocross armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the rider on a powerful, angular dirt bike with exposed heavy-duty suspension?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bike kick up a thick, billowing cloud of ochre dust while moving?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a vast, sun-scorched wasteland with a jagged mesa on the horizon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a sweeping high-angle drone view that tracks smoothly alongside the rider?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0052462052553892136 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255246162414551 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0052462052553892136, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0052462052553892136, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.8245165348052979, + 0.03686027601361275, + 0.01659327931702137, + 0.024537410587072372, + 0.017566636204719543, + 0.019900036975741386, + 0.01120989490300417, + 0.018085209652781487, + 0.021271582692861557, + 0.009459205903112888 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0052462052553892136 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a lone rider wearing full matte-black futuristic motocross armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the rider on a powerful, angular dirt bike with exposed heavy-duty suspension?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bike kick up a thick, billowing cloud of ochre dust while moving?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a vast, sun-scorched wasteland with a jagged mesa on the horizon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a sweeping high-angle drone view that tracks smoothly alongside the rider?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11290455609560013 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2379045486450195 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11290455609560013, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11290455609560013, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.644451916217804, + 0.05834130197763443, + 0.0294522512704134, + 0.03369399160146713, + 0.03718359023332596, + 0.06391321122646332, + 0.017254887148737907, + 0.04857290908694267, + 0.04455657675862312, + 0.022579316049814224 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11290455609560013 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "sweeping, high-angle drone shot tracks smoothly alongside a lone rider clad in full, matte-black futuristic motocross armor, its articulated composite panels gleaming subtly in the sunlight. The rider's posture is focused and low on a powerful, angular dirt bike, a matching matte black and gunmetal gray machine with exposed, heavy-duty suspension. As they relentlessly traverse the landscape, the bike's oversized rear tire aggressively kicks up a thick, billowing cloud of ochre dust that hangs suspended in the air. The camera follows, capturing their swift and decisive navigation across the rugged terrain: a vast, sun-scorched wasteland stretching to a jagged mesa on the distant horizon. The entire scene is bathed in the warm, harsh light of the late afternoon sun, casting long, dramatic shadows and brightly backlit, swirling clouds of dust, creating a golden haze against the deep blue sky. The warm tones, predominantly earthy reds and browns, contrast sharply with the rider's dark, anonymous silhouette, evoking a powerful atmosphere of solitary, high-speed determination on this epic, unfolding journey.", + "seed": 24989, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000065/group_9/index_9491_seed_24989_dp_19_rank_38_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.04579473795602098, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04579473795602098, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.275, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04579473795602098, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a lone rider wearing full matte-black futuristic motocross armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the rider on a powerful, angular dirt bike with exposed heavy-duty suspension?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bike kick up a thick, billowing cloud of ochre dust while moving?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a vast, sun-scorched wasteland with a jagged mesa on the horizon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a sweeping high-angle drone view that tracks smoothly alongside the rider?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1621214896440506 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9121215343475342 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1621214896440506, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1621214896440506, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23272641003131866, + 0.04814637079834938, + 0.08804094791412354, + 0.062304601073265076, + 0.05232575163245201, + 0.16709169745445251, + 0.08728191256523132, + 0.06324286758899689, + 0.16775798797607422, + 0.031081482768058777 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1621214896440506 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a lone rider wearing full matte-black futuristic motocross armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the rider on a powerful, angular dirt bike with exposed heavy-duty suspension?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bike kick up a thick, billowing cloud of ochre dust while moving?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a vast, sun-scorched wasteland with a jagged mesa on the horizon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a sweeping high-angle drone view that tracks smoothly alongside the rider?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009786602109670639 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634786605834961 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009786602109670639, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009786602109670639, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24878568947315216, + 0.041453126817941666, + 0.0655858963727951, + 0.06282521784305573, + 0.04748506844043732, + 0.10684102028608322, + 0.07097676396369934, + 0.05951150134205818, + 0.15114015340805054, + 0.14539554715156555 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009786602109670639 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a lone rider wearing full matte-black futuristic motocross armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the rider on a powerful, angular dirt bike with exposed heavy-duty suspension?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bike kick up a thick, billowing cloud of ochre dust while moving?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a vast, sun-scorched wasteland with a jagged mesa on the horizon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a sweeping high-angle drone view that tracks smoothly alongside the rider?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0008138681878335774 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.125813961029053 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0008138681878335774, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0008138681878335774, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13533122837543488, + 0.09449303895235062, + 0.18192194402217865, + 0.044488780200481415, + 0.07812467217445374, + 0.05821189284324646, + 0.0868663638830185, + 0.09662380814552307, + 0.07522933185100555, + 0.14870889484882355 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0008138681878335774 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a lone rider wearing full matte-black futuristic motocross armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the rider on a powerful, angular dirt bike with exposed heavy-duty suspension?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bike kick up a thick, billowing cloud of ochre dust while moving?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a vast, sun-scorched wasteland with a jagged mesa on the horizon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a sweeping high-angle drone view that tracks smoothly alongside the rider?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0076210228726267815 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882620811462402 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0076210228726267815, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0076210228726267815, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16163106262683868, + 0.06152904033660889, + 0.07721206545829773, + 0.18758125603199005, + 0.029090607538819313, + 0.07159868627786636, + 0.049495384097099304, + 0.04059545695781708, + 0.054436225444078445, + 0.266830176115036 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0076210228726267815 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a lone rider wearing full matte-black futuristic motocross armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the rider on a powerful, angular dirt bike with exposed heavy-duty suspension?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bike kick up a thick, billowing cloud of ochre dust while moving?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a vast, sun-scorched wasteland with a jagged mesa on the horizon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a sweeping high-angle drone view that tracks smoothly alongside the rider?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04863070696592331 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048630714416504 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04863070696592331, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04863070696592331, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24841342866420746, + 0.03942139819264412, + 0.048337191343307495, + 0.12203013151884079, + 0.09869974851608276, + 0.0879623144865036, + 0.08203288167715073, + 0.11346390098333359, + 0.11902863532304764, + 0.04061036556959152 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04863070696592331 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_0/index_tensor([6482, 6482])_group_0_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_0/index_tensor([6482, 6482])_group_0_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..c1221833b74c43ddbcd5277af0c26f969e620b5c --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_0/index_tensor([6482, 6482])_group_0_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "In a slow-motion shot captured at a high frame rate, the camera begins a majestic spiral climb, gliding upwards along the skeleton of a massive, unfinished ship. The evening sun shone with a warm golden glow, penetrating a dense forest of metal scaffolding. Casting ever-shifting, elongated shadows across the cold, dark-gray steel ribs of the ship, a dynamic chessboard of light and shadow. As the camera gracefully swirls, light plays across rough welds and exposed rivets, evoking the raw texture of industrial construction. Deep within the hull structure, welding torches operated by unseen workers occasionally ignite with fleeting, brilliant sparks. These fiery orange sparks, like stars in the night sky, shimmer briefly in the twilight, momentarily illuminating a small patch of rusted steel before fading into deep shadow. This imposing yet tranquil industrial landscape imbued with a vibrant sense of movement, imbuing the image with the grand, poetic, and majestic beauty of industrial construction.", + "seed": 17570, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_0/index_6482_seed_17570_dp_0_rank_0_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.2517292473465204, + "vlm_logprob": -0.2517292473465204, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.175, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.2517292473465204, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive, unfinished ship structure made of metal scaffolding?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by an evening sun with a warm golden glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are there visible welding torches igniting with fiery orange sparks inside the hull?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a spiral climb gliding upwards along the ship's skeleton?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in slow motion with a high frame rate?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02420877292752266 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7742087841033936 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02420877292752266, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02420877292752266, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04828166589140892, + 0.26411744952201843, + 0.13848115503787994, + 0.05266093835234642, + 0.10672818124294281, + 0.08681367337703705, + 0.033557917922735214, + 0.06496504694223404, + 0.05737252160906792, + 0.14702145755290985 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02420877292752266 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive, unfinished ship structure made of metal scaffolding?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by an evening sun with a warm golden glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are there visible welding torches igniting with fiery orange sparks inside the hull?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a spiral climb gliding upwards along the ship's skeleton?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in slow motion with a high frame rate?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05499570816755295 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299957752227783 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05499570816755295, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05499570816755295, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09513475000858307, + 0.2065863162279129, + 0.06419464200735092, + 0.06063424050807953, + 0.09605703502893448, + 0.28393545746803284, + 0.028203969821333885, + 0.04726376011967659, + 0.030178755521774292, + 0.08781112730503082 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05499570816755295 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive, unfinished ship structure made of metal scaffolding?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by an evening sun with a warm golden glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are there visible welding torches igniting with fiery orange sparks inside the hull?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a spiral climb gliding upwards along the ship's skeleton?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in slow motion with a high frame rate?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5233135223388672 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8983135223388672 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5233135223388672, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5233135223388672, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1001083254814148, + 0.16211362183094025, + 0.14116081595420837, + 0.06522827595472336, + 0.1016828641295433, + 0.12562201917171478, + 0.10230807960033417, + 0.044767796993255615, + 0.05025842785835266, + 0.10674973577260971 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5233135223388672 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive, unfinished ship structure made of metal scaffolding?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by an evening sun with a warm golden glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are there visible welding torches igniting with fiery orange sparks inside the hull?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a spiral climb gliding upwards along the ship's skeleton?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in slow motion with a high frame rate?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023290520533919334 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732906341552734 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023290520533919334, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023290520533919334, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05292752385139465, + 0.14153926074504852, + 0.07478233426809311, + 0.03830670565366745, + 0.12746703624725342, + 0.12338664382696152, + 0.040329333394765854, + 0.07281865179538727, + 0.11277990788221359, + 0.21566259860992432 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023290520533919334 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive, unfinished ship structure made of metal scaffolding?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by an evening sun with a warm golden glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are there visible welding torches igniting with fiery orange sparks inside the hull?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a spiral climb gliding upwards along the ship's skeleton?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in slow motion with a high frame rate?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.63283771276474 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.75783771276474 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.63283771276474, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.63283771276474, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05584564805030823, + 0.12154644727706909, + 0.2023911327123642, + 0.021216729655861855, + 0.09479698538780212, + 0.10397180914878845, + 0.03492707386612892, + 0.047502949833869934, + 0.0525892898440361, + 0.26521188020706177 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.63283771276474 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a slow-motion shot captured at a high frame rate, the camera begins a majestic spiral climb, gliding upwards along the skeleton of a massive, unfinished ship. The evening sun shone with a warm golden glow, penetrating a dense forest of metal scaffolding. Casting ever-shifting, elongated shadows across the cold, dark-gray steel ribs of the ship, a dynamic chessboard of light and shadow. As the camera gracefully swirls, light plays across rough welds and exposed rivets, evoking the raw texture of industrial construction. Deep within the hull structure, welding torches operated by unseen workers occasionally ignite with fleeting, brilliant sparks. These fiery orange sparks, like stars in the night sky, shimmer briefly in the twilight, momentarily illuminating a small patch of rusted steel before fading into deep shadow. This imposing yet tranquil industrial landscape imbued with a vibrant sense of movement, imbuing the image with the grand, poetic, and majestic beauty of industrial construction.", + "seed": 17571, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_0/index_6482_seed_17571_dp_0_rank_0_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.22038445044308902, + "vlm_logprob": -0.22038445044308902, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.5, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.22038445044308902, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive, unfinished ship structure made of metal scaffolding?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by an evening sun with a warm golden glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are there visible welding torches igniting with fiery orange sparks inside the hull?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a spiral climb gliding upwards along the ship's skeleton?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in slow motion with a high frame rate?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00902466382831335 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.759024620056152 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00902466382831335, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00902466382831335, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09255867451429367, + 0.33790552616119385, + 0.02576838992536068, + 0.04353144392371178, + 0.08876382559537888, + 0.09810122847557068, + 0.01476607471704483, + 0.024343203753232956, + 0.20687368512153625, + 0.06738803535699844 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00902466382831335 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive, unfinished ship structure made of metal scaffolding?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by an evening sun with a warm golden glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are there visible welding torches igniting with fiery orange sparks inside the hull?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a spiral climb gliding upwards along the ship's skeleton?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in slow motion with a high frame rate?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07004760205745697 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695047616958618 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07004760205745697, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07004760205745697, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10849171876907349, + 0.48944973945617676, + 0.10285227000713348, + 0.01849854737520218, + 0.06769311428070068, + 0.07882969081401825, + 0.009933555498719215, + 0.05533495545387268, + 0.025617774575948715, + 0.04329860582947731 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07004760205745697 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive, unfinished ship structure made of metal scaffolding?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by an evening sun with a warm golden glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are there visible welding torches igniting with fiery orange sparks inside the hull?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a spiral climb gliding upwards along the ship's skeleton?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in slow motion with a high frame rate?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.31343400478363037 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3134340047836304 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.31343400478363037, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.31343400478363037, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3140907287597656, + 0.34440866112709045, + 0.040710438042879105, + 0.10388045012950897, + 0.055379245430231094, + 0.037675511091947556, + 0.008536096662282944, + 0.015513758175075054, + 0.051176924258470535, + 0.02862822264432907 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.31343400478363037 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive, unfinished ship structure made of metal scaffolding?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by an evening sun with a warm golden glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are there visible welding torches igniting with fiery orange sparks inside the hull?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a spiral climb gliding upwards along the ship's skeleton?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in slow motion with a high frame rate?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01606590487062931 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141066074371338 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01606590487062931, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01606590487062931, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14021426439285278, + 0.09572627395391464, + 0.023401299491524696, + 0.05588548630475998, + 0.047224126756191254, + 0.04557367041707039, + 0.0273558609187603, + 0.0662304162979126, + 0.3434562385082245, + 0.15493234992027283 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01606590487062931 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive, unfinished ship structure made of metal scaffolding?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by an evening sun with a warm golden glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are there visible welding torches igniting with fiery orange sparks inside the hull?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a spiral climb gliding upwards along the ship's skeleton?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in slow motion with a high frame rate?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.693350076675415 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.693350076675415 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.693350076675415, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.693350076675415, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16784784197807312, + 0.26925134658813477, + 0.02348012663424015, + 0.04385603591799736, + 0.04792982339859009, + 0.194699227809906, + 0.013746513985097408, + 0.02330070547759533, + 0.1617509424686432, + 0.05413750186562538 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.693350076675415 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a slow-motion shot captured at a high frame rate, the camera begins a majestic spiral climb, gliding upwards along the skeleton of a massive, unfinished ship. The evening sun shone with a warm golden glow, penetrating a dense forest of metal scaffolding. Casting ever-shifting, elongated shadows across the cold, dark-gray steel ribs of the ship, a dynamic chessboard of light and shadow. As the camera gracefully swirls, light plays across rough welds and exposed rivets, evoking the raw texture of industrial construction. Deep within the hull structure, welding torches operated by unseen workers occasionally ignite with fleeting, brilliant sparks. These fiery orange sparks, like stars in the night sky, shimmer briefly in the twilight, momentarily illuminating a small patch of rusted steel before fading into deep shadow. This imposing yet tranquil industrial landscape imbued with a vibrant sense of movement, imbuing the image with the grand, poetic, and majestic beauty of industrial construction.", + "seed": 17572, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_0/index_6482_seed_17572_dp_1_rank_2_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.3328172514215112, + "vlm_logprob": -0.3328172514215112, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.8, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.3328172514215112, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive, unfinished ship structure made of metal scaffolding?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by an evening sun with a warm golden glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are there visible welding torches igniting with fiery orange sparks inside the hull?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a spiral climb gliding upwards along the ship's skeleton?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in slow motion with a high frame rate?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06319153308868408 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8131914138793945 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06319153308868408, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06319153308868408, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18593613803386688, + 0.13829077780246735, + 0.030423779040575027, + 0.2226170152425766, + 0.03391850367188454, + 0.13866986334323883, + 0.04317796602845192, + 0.0202445387840271, + 0.10412093251943588, + 0.08260045200586319 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06319153308868408 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive, unfinished ship structure made of metal scaffolding?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by an evening sun with a warm golden glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are there visible welding torches igniting with fiery orange sparks inside the hull?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a spiral climb gliding upwards along the ship's skeleton?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in slow motion with a high frame rate?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20161379873752594 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7016137838363647 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20161379873752594, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20161379873752594, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3544304072856903, + 0.07727082073688507, + 0.02112191542983055, + 0.05467628687620163, + 0.10271842032670975, + 0.06627249717712402, + 0.07509617507457733, + 0.051524817943573, + 0.048108357936143875, + 0.1487802416086197 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20161379873752594 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive, unfinished ship structure made of metal scaffolding?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by an evening sun with a warm golden glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are there visible welding torches igniting with fiery orange sparks inside the hull?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a spiral climb gliding upwards along the ship's skeleton?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in slow motion with a high frame rate?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7577845454216003 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6327845454216003 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.7577845454216003, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.7577845454216003, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13507580757141113, + 0.17613022029399872, + 0.10375917702913284, + 0.1757132112979889, + 0.031267181038856506, + 0.09189269691705704, + 0.03645912557840347, + 0.039174407720565796, + 0.038569264113903046, + 0.171958789229393 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.7577845454216003 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive, unfinished ship structure made of metal scaffolding?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by an evening sun with a warm golden glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are there visible welding torches igniting with fiery orange sparks inside the hull?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a spiral climb gliding upwards along the ship's skeleton?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in slow motion with a high frame rate?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008644540794193745 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.7586445808410645 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008644540794193745, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008644540794193745, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09230954945087433, + 0.07146181911230087, + 0.05481782928109169, + 0.19940075278282166, + 0.1552107334136963, + 0.1312650442123413, + 0.06930878013372421, + 0.049986764788627625, + 0.06826935708522797, + 0.10796938836574554 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008644540794193745 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive, unfinished ship structure made of metal scaffolding?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by an evening sun with a warm golden glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are there visible welding torches igniting with fiery orange sparks inside the hull?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a spiral climb gliding upwards along the ship's skeleton?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in slow motion with a high frame rate?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6328518390655518 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7578518390655518 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.6328518390655518, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.6328518390655518, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16162338852882385, + 0.0838392972946167, + 0.04051882401108742, + 0.10717152804136276, + 0.13543857634067535, + 0.07926841825246811, + 0.1448121964931488, + 0.0582764558494091, + 0.048195142298936844, + 0.14085619151592255 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.6328518390655518 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a slow-motion shot captured at a high frame rate, the camera begins a majestic spiral climb, gliding upwards along the skeleton of a massive, unfinished ship. The evening sun shone with a warm golden glow, penetrating a dense forest of metal scaffolding. Casting ever-shifting, elongated shadows across the cold, dark-gray steel ribs of the ship, a dynamic chessboard of light and shadow. As the camera gracefully swirls, light plays across rough welds and exposed rivets, evoking the raw texture of industrial construction. Deep within the hull structure, welding torches operated by unseen workers occasionally ignite with fleeting, brilliant sparks. These fiery orange sparks, like stars in the night sky, shimmer briefly in the twilight, momentarily illuminating a small patch of rusted steel before fading into deep shadow. This imposing yet tranquil industrial landscape imbued with a vibrant sense of movement, imbuing the image with the grand, poetic, and majestic beauty of industrial construction.", + "seed": 17573, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_0/index_6482_seed_17573_dp_1_rank_2_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.21007393542677164, + "vlm_logprob": -0.21007393542677164, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.3, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.21007393542677164, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive, unfinished ship structure made of metal scaffolding?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by an evening sun with a warm golden glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are there visible welding torches igniting with fiery orange sparks inside the hull?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a spiral climb gliding upwards along the ship's skeleton?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in slow motion with a high frame rate?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026965215802192688 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6519651412963867 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026965215802192688, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026965215802192688, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22724668681621552, + 0.17702117562294006, + 0.04270961135625839, + 0.12812264263629913, + 0.07244856655597687, + 0.060954779386520386, + 0.04568084701895714, + 0.13632091879844666, + 0.047379303723573685, + 0.06211546063423157 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026965215802192688 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive, unfinished ship structure made of metal scaffolding?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by an evening sun with a warm golden glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are there visible welding torches igniting with fiery orange sparks inside the hull?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a spiral climb gliding upwards along the ship's skeleton?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in slow motion with a high frame rate?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14283227920532227 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0178322792053223 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14283227920532227, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14283227920532227, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18679186701774597, + 0.1781073659658432, + 0.05461712181568146, + 0.1068858802318573, + 0.18710364401340485, + 0.044234346598386765, + 0.026640649884939194, + 0.03871127590537071, + 0.04023465886712074, + 0.13667316734790802 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14283227920532227 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive, unfinished ship structure made of metal scaffolding?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by an evening sun with a warm golden glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are there visible welding torches igniting with fiery orange sparks inside the hull?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a spiral climb gliding upwards along the ship's skeleton?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in slow motion with a high frame rate?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.34861478209495544 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2236148118972778 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.34861478209495544, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.34861478209495544, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2211037278175354, + 0.16171035170555115, + 0.05425182729959488, + 0.18487349152565002, + 0.15110859274864197, + 0.041059888899326324, + 0.048119183629751205, + 0.029430441558361053, + 0.05253966525197029, + 0.05580282211303711 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.34861478209495544 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive, unfinished ship structure made of metal scaffolding?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by an evening sun with a warm golden glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are there visible welding torches igniting with fiery orange sparks inside the hull?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a spiral climb gliding upwards along the ship's skeleton?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in slow motion with a high frame rate?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008638513274490833 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758638381958008 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008638513274490833, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008638513274490833, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.30361050367355347, + 0.12482407689094543, + 0.12787607312202454, + 0.09285113215446472, + 0.04694623127579689, + 0.0260423943400383, + 0.03144456446170807, + 0.12929977476596832, + 0.05682910233736038, + 0.06027616932988167 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008638513274490833 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive, unfinished ship structure made of metal scaffolding?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by an evening sun with a warm golden glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are there visible welding torches igniting with fiery orange sparks inside the hull?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a spiral climb gliding upwards along the ship's skeleton?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in slow motion with a high frame rate?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.523318886756897 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.898318886756897 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.523318886756897, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.523318886756897, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1834287792444229, + 0.29370182752609253, + 0.0643128827214241, + 0.07527697086334229, + 0.07321027666330338, + 0.03422312065958977, + 0.04382369667291641, + 0.06725916266441345, + 0.10990039259195328, + 0.05486292764544487 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.523318886756897 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_1/index_tensor([8381, 8381])_group_1_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_1/index_tensor([8381, 8381])_group_1_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..0a6c5a2afa4ba6c46a9a394d87e06a9b21da172a --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_1/index_tensor([8381, 8381])_group_1_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "dramatic time-lapse sequence, shot from a low angle and kept largely static to emphasize the epic scale, documents the silent, slow-motion battle between two antagonistic trees. In the foreground, a gnarled, ancient oak tree with dark, deeply furrowed bark covered in patches of green moss aggressively extends its thick, muscular limbs. Beside it, a taller, thinner birch tree, its pale bark peeling, twists its branches in a sinuous, relentless pursuit of any available gap in the canopy. The camera captures their gradual intertwining growth over many seasons; branches jostling, encircling, and strategically blocking each other in a relentless struggle for sunlight. The background reveals a dense, out-of-focus forest, while the forest floor below rapidly blurs from a carpet of summer ferns to autumnal leaves and a winter blanket of snow and ice. Golden light penetrates the treetops, moving swiftly as the sun arcs across the sky, creating a high-contrast, dramatic play of light and shadow, highlighting the texture of the bark and the slow, deliberate dance of the branches. The overall atmosphere is one of fierce, silent and primal competition, a beautiful yet brutal natural ballet of growth and survival.", + "seed": 13650, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_1/index_8381_seed_13650_dp_2_rank_4_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.21641758615151047, + "vlm_logprob": -0.21641758615151047, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.7250000119209288, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.21641758615151047, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera largely static throughout the sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a gnarled ancient oak tree with dark, deeply furrowed bark and green moss visible in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a taller, thinner birch tree with pale, peeling bark visible beside the oak?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background show the forest floor changing from summer ferns to autumn leaves and then to a winter blanket of snow and ice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5243000388145447 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1493000984191895 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5243000388145447, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.6250000596046448, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5243000388145447, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21771715581417084, + 0.05463002622127533, + 0.10555195063352585, + 0.2208028882741928, + 0.030875101685523987, + 0.04450620338320732, + 0.035465408116579056, + 0.04231027141213417, + 0.1200493797659874, + 0.12809161841869354 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5243000388145447 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera largely static throughout the sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a gnarled ancient oak tree with dark, deeply furrowed bark and green moss visible in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a taller, thinner birch tree with pale, peeling bark visible beside the oak?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background show the forest floor changing from summer ferns to autumn leaves and then to a winter blanket of snow and ice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4743478000164032 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9743478298187256 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.4743478000164032, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.4743478000164032, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06566646695137024, + 0.029523685574531555, + 0.11962324380874634, + 0.16810978949069977, + 0.0249907486140728, + 0.025273378938436508, + 0.015273643657565117, + 0.20738765597343445, + 0.2644146680831909, + 0.07973672449588776 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.4743478000164032 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera largely static throughout the sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a gnarled ancient oak tree with dark, deeply furrowed bark and green moss visible in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a taller, thinner birch tree with pale, peeling bark visible beside the oak?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background show the forest floor changing from summer ferns to autumn leaves and then to a winter blanket of snow and ice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0032208492048084736 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753221035003662 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0032208492048084736, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0032208492048084736, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13640527427196503, + 0.07234838604927063, + 0.12660987675189972, + 0.09715273231267929, + 0.13636793196201324, + 0.06221324950456619, + 0.049306079745292664, + 0.16044160723686218, + 0.11232992261648178, + 0.04682488366961479 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0032208492048084736 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera largely static throughout the sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a gnarled ancient oak tree with dark, deeply furrowed bark and green moss visible in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a taller, thinner birch tree with pale, peeling bark visible beside the oak?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background show the forest floor changing from summer ferns to autumn leaves and then to a winter blanket of snow and ice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01818496361374855 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018185138702393 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01818496361374855, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01818496361374855, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1160811334848404, + 0.05395511910319328, + 0.04317733645439148, + 0.07766932994127274, + 0.10840176790952682, + 0.06235339120030403, + 0.11952795088291168, + 0.18339213728904724, + 0.2060709148645401, + 0.029370909556746483 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01818496361374855 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera largely static throughout the sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a gnarled ancient oak tree with dark, deeply furrowed bark and green moss visible in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a taller, thinner birch tree with pale, peeling bark visible beside the oak?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background show the forest floor changing from summer ferns to autumn leaves and then to a winter blanket of snow and ice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.062034279108047485 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120343685150146 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.062034279108047485, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.062034279108047485, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09335821866989136, + 0.04783817380666733, + 0.13481871783733368, + 0.04144144058227539, + 0.020199375227093697, + 0.05067962408065796, + 0.017390694469213486, + 0.11751915514469147, + 0.45390886068344116, + 0.0228456798940897 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 2, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.062034279108047485 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dramatic time-lapse sequence, shot from a low angle and kept largely static to emphasize the epic scale, documents the silent, slow-motion battle between two antagonistic trees. In the foreground, a gnarled, ancient oak tree with dark, deeply furrowed bark covered in patches of green moss aggressively extends its thick, muscular limbs. Beside it, a taller, thinner birch tree, its pale bark peeling, twists its branches in a sinuous, relentless pursuit of any available gap in the canopy. The camera captures their gradual intertwining growth over many seasons; branches jostling, encircling, and strategically blocking each other in a relentless struggle for sunlight. The background reveals a dense, out-of-focus forest, while the forest floor below rapidly blurs from a carpet of summer ferns to autumnal leaves and a winter blanket of snow and ice. Golden light penetrates the treetops, moving swiftly as the sun arcs across the sky, creating a high-contrast, dramatic play of light and shadow, highlighting the texture of the bark and the slow, deliberate dance of the branches. The overall atmosphere is one of fierce, silent and primal competition, a beautiful yet brutal natural ballet of growth and survival.", + "seed": 13651, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_1/index_8381_seed_13651_dp_2_rank_4_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.24823163263499737, + "vlm_logprob": -0.24823163263499737, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.725, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.24823163263499737, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera largely static throughout the sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a gnarled ancient oak tree with dark, deeply furrowed bark and green moss visible in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a taller, thinner birch tree with pale, peeling bark visible beside the oak?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background show the forest floor changing from summer ferns to autumn leaves and then to a winter blanket of snow and ice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.727801501750946 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.852801501750946 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.727801501750946, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.727801501750946, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.28054481744766235, + 0.09666542708873749, + 0.0771697536110878, + 0.0646122619509697, + 0.06293250620365143, + 0.09405943751335144, + 0.05091976746916771, + 0.16071538627147675, + 0.040936216711997986, + 0.07144443690776825 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.727801501750946 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera largely static throughout the sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a gnarled ancient oak tree with dark, deeply furrowed bark and green moss visible in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a taller, thinner birch tree with pale, peeling bark visible beside the oak?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background show the forest floor changing from summer ferns to autumn leaves and then to a winter blanket of snow and ice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3871403634548187 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1371403932571411 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3871403634548187, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3871403634548187, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17399373650550842, + 0.13793900609016418, + 0.12201844900846481, + 0.17248094081878662, + 0.08617445826530457, + 0.10444574803113937, + 0.026290029287338257, + 0.02475734055042267, + 0.10921352356672287, + 0.042686738073825836 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3871403634548187 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera largely static throughout the sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a gnarled ancient oak tree with dark, deeply furrowed bark and green moss visible in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a taller, thinner birch tree with pale, peeling bark visible beside the oak?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background show the forest floor changing from summer ferns to autumn leaves and then to a winter blanket of snow and ice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002223402261734009 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127223491668701 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002223402261734009, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002223402261734009, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.30308839678764343, + 0.1582881063222885, + 0.06965884566307068, + 0.11766011267900467, + 0.06251406669616699, + 0.05089043453335762, + 0.02955823577940464, + 0.06954419612884521, + 0.045940056443214417, + 0.0928574949502945 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002223402261734009 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera largely static throughout the sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a gnarled ancient oak tree with dark, deeply furrowed bark and green moss visible in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a taller, thinner birch tree with pale, peeling bark visible beside the oak?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background show the forest floor changing from summer ferns to autumn leaves and then to a winter blanket of snow and ice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01107332669198513 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511073112487793 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01107332669198513, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01107332669198513, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1634126901626587, + 0.10985520482063293, + 0.1038021370768547, + 0.1850806325674057, + 0.15253588557243347, + 0.06926894932985306, + 0.049322083592414856, + 0.07407131046056747, + 0.04619891196489334, + 0.04645213112235069 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01107332669198513 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera largely static throughout the sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a gnarled ancient oak tree with dark, deeply furrowed bark and green moss visible in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a taller, thinner birch tree with pale, peeling bark visible beside the oak?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background show the forest floor changing from summer ferns to autumn leaves and then to a winter blanket of snow and ice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11291956901550293 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.237919569015503 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11291956901550293, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11291956901550293, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11702608317136765, + 0.1265413612127304, + 0.13122881948947906, + 0.2251434177160263, + 0.0773719996213913, + 0.04401302710175514, + 0.047846127301454544, + 0.12281086295843124, + 0.05580013617873192, + 0.05221821740269661 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11291956901550293 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dramatic time-lapse sequence, shot from a low angle and kept largely static to emphasize the epic scale, documents the silent, slow-motion battle between two antagonistic trees. In the foreground, a gnarled, ancient oak tree with dark, deeply furrowed bark covered in patches of green moss aggressively extends its thick, muscular limbs. Beside it, a taller, thinner birch tree, its pale bark peeling, twists its branches in a sinuous, relentless pursuit of any available gap in the canopy. The camera captures their gradual intertwining growth over many seasons; branches jostling, encircling, and strategically blocking each other in a relentless struggle for sunlight. The background reveals a dense, out-of-focus forest, while the forest floor below rapidly blurs from a carpet of summer ferns to autumnal leaves and a winter blanket of snow and ice. Golden light penetrates the treetops, moving swiftly as the sun arcs across the sky, creating a high-contrast, dramatic play of light and shadow, highlighting the texture of the bark and the slow, deliberate dance of the branches. The overall atmosphere is one of fierce, silent and primal competition, a beautiful yet brutal natural ballet of growth and survival.", + "seed": 13652, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_1/index_8381_seed_13652_dp_3_rank_6_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.3459774020127952, + "vlm_logprob": -0.3459774020127952, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.000000011920929, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.3459774020127952, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera largely static throughout the sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a gnarled ancient oak tree with dark, deeply furrowed bark and green moss visible in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a taller, thinner birch tree with pale, peeling bark visible beside the oak?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background show the forest floor changing from summer ferns to autumn leaves and then to a winter blanket of snow and ice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.28684374690055847 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6618437767028809 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.28684374690055847, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.28684374690055847, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15874573588371277, + 0.38536858558654785, + 0.09080788493156433, + 0.0867907926440239, + 0.09903338551521301, + 0.040086787194013596, + 0.051395758986473083, + 0.05003165081143379, + 0.017138399183750153, + 0.020601052790880203 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.28684374690055847 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera largely static throughout the sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a gnarled ancient oak tree with dark, deeply furrowed bark and green moss visible in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a taller, thinner birch tree with pale, peeling bark visible beside the oak?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background show the forest floor changing from summer ferns to autumn leaves and then to a winter blanket of snow and ice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.34870806336402893 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2237080335617065 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.34870806336402893, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.34870806336402893, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08352744579315186, + 0.28231048583984375, + 0.07809113711118698, + 0.1544143706560135, + 0.09434409439563751, + 0.05202145501971245, + 0.07158534973859787, + 0.071586973965168, + 0.04606058448553085, + 0.06605813652276993 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.34870806336402893 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera largely static throughout the sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a gnarled ancient oak tree with dark, deeply furrowed bark and green moss visible in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a taller, thinner birch tree with pale, peeling bark visible beside the oak?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background show the forest floor changing from summer ferns to autumn leaves and then to a winter blanket of snow and ice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.033727262169122696 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4087271690368652 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.033727262169122696, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.033727262169122696, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16013292968273163, + 0.10528440773487091, + 0.039677053689956665, + 0.2224346250295639, + 0.18910741806030273, + 0.055116359144449234, + 0.03187745809555054, + 0.10887453705072403, + 0.019881457090377808, + 0.06761372834444046 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.033727262169122696 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera largely static throughout the sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a gnarled ancient oak tree with dark, deeply furrowed bark and green moss visible in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a taller, thinner birch tree with pale, peeling bark visible beside the oak?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background show the forest floor changing from summer ferns to autumn leaves and then to a winter blanket of snow and ice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0067365444265306 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006736755371094 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0067365444265306, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0067365444265306, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23878099024295807, + 0.08243115991353989, + 0.06823867559432983, + 0.13630366325378418, + 0.22282131016254425, + 0.052541449666023254, + 0.04731357470154762, + 0.10287205874919891, + 0.017082499340176582, + 0.031614676117897034 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0067365444265306 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera largely static throughout the sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a gnarled ancient oak tree with dark, deeply furrowed bark and green moss visible in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a taller, thinner birch tree with pale, peeling bark visible beside the oak?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background show the forest floor changing from summer ferns to autumn leaves and then to a winter blanket of snow and ice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.0538713932037354 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4288714528083801 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.0538713932037354, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.6249999403953552, + "token_credit_reward": -1.0538713932037354, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17495882511138916, + 0.19234715402126312, + 0.06235666945576668, + 0.2105417400598526, + 0.15935710072517395, + 0.06229571998119354, + 0.023852413520216942, + 0.04575067386031151, + 0.02056555263698101, + 0.0479741245508194 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.0538713932037354 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dramatic time-lapse sequence, shot from a low angle and kept largely static to emphasize the epic scale, documents the silent, slow-motion battle between two antagonistic trees. In the foreground, a gnarled, ancient oak tree with dark, deeply furrowed bark covered in patches of green moss aggressively extends its thick, muscular limbs. Beside it, a taller, thinner birch tree, its pale bark peeling, twists its branches in a sinuous, relentless pursuit of any available gap in the canopy. The camera captures their gradual intertwining growth over many seasons; branches jostling, encircling, and strategically blocking each other in a relentless struggle for sunlight. The background reveals a dense, out-of-focus forest, while the forest floor below rapidly blurs from a carpet of summer ferns to autumnal leaves and a winter blanket of snow and ice. Golden light penetrates the treetops, moving swiftly as the sun arcs across the sky, creating a high-contrast, dramatic play of light and shadow, highlighting the texture of the bark and the slow, deliberate dance of the branches. The overall atmosphere is one of fierce, silent and primal competition, a beautiful yet brutal natural ballet of growth and survival.", + "seed": 13653, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_1/index_8381_seed_13653_dp_3_rank_6_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.204273423505947, + "vlm_logprob": -0.204273423505947, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.85, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.204273423505947, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera largely static throughout the sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a gnarled ancient oak tree with dark, deeply furrowed bark and green moss visible in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a taller, thinner birch tree with pale, peeling bark visible beside the oak?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background show the forest floor changing from summer ferns to autumn leaves and then to a winter blanket of snow and ice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5379539728164673 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1629539728164673 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5379539728164673, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5379539728164673, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.37656402587890625, + 0.041394107043743134, + 0.11557195335626602, + 0.08363848179578781, + 0.023252857849001884, + 0.09033332020044327, + 0.021625332534313202, + 0.02584894187748432, + 0.024318620562553406, + 0.19745244085788727 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5379539728164673 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera largely static throughout the sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a gnarled ancient oak tree with dark, deeply furrowed bark and green moss visible in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a taller, thinner birch tree with pale, peeling bark visible beside the oak?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background show the forest floor changing from summer ferns to autumn leaves and then to a winter blanket of snow and ice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16042008996009827 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9104200601577759 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16042008996009827, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16042008996009827, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.080404132604599, + 0.02023724839091301, + 0.05633385479450226, + 0.04519573971629143, + 0.03501250967383385, + 0.037446219474077225, + 0.024079110473394394, + 0.05334676429629326, + 0.08605815470218658, + 0.5618863105773926 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16042008996009827 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera largely static throughout the sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a gnarled ancient oak tree with dark, deeply furrowed bark and green moss visible in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a taller, thinner birch tree with pale, peeling bark visible beside the oak?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background show the forest floor changing from summer ferns to autumn leaves and then to a winter blanket of snow and ice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0028433867264539003 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877843379974365 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0028433867264539003, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0028433867264539003, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11746364086866379, + 0.05385732278227806, + 0.1692221313714981, + 0.05599581450223923, + 0.03025634214282036, + 0.07860923558473587, + 0.04912541061639786, + 0.031196046620607376, + 0.061669908463954926, + 0.3526041507720947 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0028433867264539003 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera largely static throughout the sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a gnarled ancient oak tree with dark, deeply furrowed bark and green moss visible in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a taller, thinner birch tree with pale, peeling bark visible beside the oak?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background show the forest floor changing from summer ferns to autumn leaves and then to a winter blanket of snow and ice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00673500495031476 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006734848022461 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00673500495031476, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00673500495031476, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1658780723810196, + 0.09545811265707016, + 0.1318262815475464, + 0.04462466016411781, + 0.03242141753435135, + 0.11014275997877121, + 0.029399659484624863, + 0.05216620862483978, + 0.05363694578409195, + 0.2844459116458893 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00673500495031476 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera largely static throughout the sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a gnarled ancient oak tree with dark, deeply furrowed bark and green moss visible in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a taller, thinner birch tree with pale, peeling bark visible beside the oak?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background show the forest floor changing from summer ferns to autumn leaves and then to a winter blanket of snow and ice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.31341466307640076 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3134146928787231 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.31341466307640076, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.31341466307640076, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10272765159606934, + 0.029402654618024826, + 0.11678733676671982, + 0.03208982199430466, + 0.024091098457574844, + 0.08242172747850418, + 0.028328170999884605, + 0.051083486527204514, + 0.071280337870121, + 0.46178773045539856 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.31341466307640076 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_10/index_tensor([4405, 4405])_group_10_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_10/index_tensor([4405, 4405])_group_10_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..c9edaf2816652584ba8e0fd045e554d068a6e345 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_10/index_tensor([4405, 4405])_group_10_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "wide-angle tracking shot slowly pans right across the icy landscape of a remote Arctic research station. A golden polar sun hangs high above the horizon, its slanting rays casting long blue shadows across the vast, pristine expanse of ice, outlining the texture of each snowdrift with remarkable clarity. In the foreground, a scientist, clad in a thick, bright orange thermal suit, a fully enclosed hood, and goggles that reflect the golden sunlight, stands out. Half-kneeling in the snow, he methodically adjusts the angle of a large solar panel, its deep blue photovoltaic surface coated with a thin layer of frost. One thickly gloved hand steadying the panel's cool metal frame, the other carefully tightening a connection point on the bracket with a tool, his movements steady and focused. Fine snowflakes swirl in the biting wind, some landing gently on the scientist's dark goggles and the black surface of the solar panel before being blown away. In the background, the research station’s silver geodesic dome and several communication antennas gleam with metallic luster in the golden afterglow. The whole scene forms a sharp contrast between the majestic nature and the tenacious technology of mankind, creating a tranquil atmosphere that is both lonely and full of hope.", + "seed": 25280, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_10/index_4405_seed_25280_dp_20_rank_40_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.1262053359299898, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1262053359299898, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.25, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1262053359299898, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a wide-angle tracking shot that pans slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a scientist wearing a thick bright orange thermal suit with a fully enclosed hood and goggles visible in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scientist half-kneeling in the snow while adjusting a large solar panel with a deep blue photovoltaic surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background featuring a silver geodesic dome and communication antennas gleaming in the golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are fine snowflakes visible swirling in the wind and landing on the scientist's goggles and the solar panel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5277164578437805 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9027164578437805 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5277164578437805, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5277164578437805, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08045387268066406, + 0.06922701001167297, + 0.08149144053459167, + 0.07851438224315643, + 0.157094806432724, + 0.1635330617427826, + 0.07048345357179642, + 0.05543406307697296, + 0.07560312747955322, + 0.1681647151708603 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5277164578437805 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a wide-angle tracking shot that pans slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a scientist wearing a thick bright orange thermal suit with a fully enclosed hood and goggles visible in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scientist half-kneeling in the snow while adjusting a large solar panel with a deep blue photovoltaic surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background featuring a silver geodesic dome and communication antennas gleaming in the golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are fine snowflakes visible swirling in the wind and landing on the scientist's goggles and the solar panel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009805017150938511 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634805202484131 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009805017150938511, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009805017150938511, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2146645039319992, + 0.09362655878067017, + 0.06574572622776031, + 0.11980891972780228, + 0.0557975172996521, + 0.05356473848223686, + 0.05308660864830017, + 0.0886741429567337, + 0.08378653228282928, + 0.1712447553873062 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009805017150938511 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a wide-angle tracking shot that pans slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a scientist wearing a thick bright orange thermal suit with a fully enclosed hood and goggles visible in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scientist half-kneeling in the snow while adjusting a large solar panel with a deep blue photovoltaic surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background featuring a silver geodesic dome and communication antennas gleaming in the golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are fine snowflakes visible swirling in the wind and landing on the scientist's goggles and the solar panel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0067454250529408455 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006745338439941 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0067454250529408455, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0067454250529408455, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14703021943569183, + 0.0863974541425705, + 0.10007957369089127, + 0.14727070927619934, + 0.06812983006238937, + 0.04052946716547012, + 0.03853317350149155, + 0.1520090252161026, + 0.04823186993598938, + 0.17178869247436523 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0067454250529408455 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a wide-angle tracking shot that pans slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a scientist wearing a thick bright orange thermal suit with a fully enclosed hood and goggles visible in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scientist half-kneeling in the snow while adjusting a large solar panel with a deep blue photovoltaic surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background featuring a silver geodesic dome and communication antennas gleaming in the golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are fine snowflakes visible swirling in the wind and landing on the scientist's goggles and the solar panel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03810625150799751 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881062030792236 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03810625150799751, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03810625150799751, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25150176882743835, + 0.07078694552183151, + 0.05549488589167595, + 0.08476162701845169, + 0.07347510010004044, + 0.24845366179943085, + 0.07825180888175964, + 0.035438187420368195, + 0.07050726562738419, + 0.031328748911619186 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03810625150799751 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a wide-angle tracking shot that pans slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a scientist wearing a thick bright orange thermal suit with a fully enclosed hood and goggles visible in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scientist half-kneeling in the snow while adjusting a large solar panel with a deep blue photovoltaic surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background featuring a silver geodesic dome and communication antennas gleaming in the golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are fine snowflakes visible swirling in the wind and landing on the scientist's goggles and the solar panel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04865352809429169 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486536026000977 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04865352809429169, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04865352809429169, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.27373743057250977, + 0.08780726790428162, + 0.06797977536916733, + 0.05836135149002075, + 0.09690079838037491, + 0.0631098672747612, + 0.07212021201848984, + 0.12550242245197296, + 0.047511398792266846, + 0.1069694459438324 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04865352809429169 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "wide-angle tracking shot slowly pans right across the icy landscape of a remote Arctic research station. A golden polar sun hangs high above the horizon, its slanting rays casting long blue shadows across the vast, pristine expanse of ice, outlining the texture of each snowdrift with remarkable clarity. In the foreground, a scientist, clad in a thick, bright orange thermal suit, a fully enclosed hood, and goggles that reflect the golden sunlight, stands out. Half-kneeling in the snow, he methodically adjusts the angle of a large solar panel, its deep blue photovoltaic surface coated with a thin layer of frost. One thickly gloved hand steadying the panel's cool metal frame, the other carefully tightening a connection point on the bracket with a tool, his movements steady and focused. Fine snowflakes swirl in the biting wind, some landing gently on the scientist's dark goggles and the black surface of the solar panel before being blown away. In the background, the research station’s silver geodesic dome and several communication antennas gleam with metallic luster in the golden afterglow. The whole scene forms a sharp contrast between the majestic nature and the tenacious technology of mankind, creating a tranquil atmosphere that is both lonely and full of hope.", + "seed": 25281, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_10/index_4405_seed_25281_dp_20_rank_40_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.07979892739094793, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07979892739094793, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.4, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07979892739094793, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a wide-angle tracking shot that pans slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a scientist wearing a thick bright orange thermal suit with a fully enclosed hood and goggles visible in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scientist half-kneeling in the snow while adjusting a large solar panel with a deep blue photovoltaic surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background featuring a silver geodesic dome and communication antennas gleaming in the golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are fine snowflakes visible swirling in the wind and landing on the scientist's goggles and the solar panel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2863747477531433 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.411374807357788 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2863747477531433, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2863747477531433, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1723918914794922, + 0.04927293583750725, + 0.02989671751856804, + 0.057573091238737106, + 0.07504988461732864, + 0.041464291512966156, + 0.02182902954518795, + 0.09174986928701401, + 0.40438222885131836, + 0.05639005824923515 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2863747477531433 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a wide-angle tracking shot that pans slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a scientist wearing a thick bright orange thermal suit with a fully enclosed hood and goggles visible in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scientist half-kneeling in the snow while adjusting a large solar panel with a deep blue photovoltaic surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background featuring a silver geodesic dome and communication antennas gleaming in the golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are fine snowflakes visible swirling in the wind and landing on the scientist's goggles and the solar panel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06207326799631119 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812073230743408 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06207326799631119, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06207326799631119, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21930797398090363, + 0.09837643802165985, + 0.03753480687737465, + 0.0282729621976614, + 0.01678781397640705, + 0.033414628356695175, + 0.0736580491065979, + 0.15003186464309692, + 0.2884995937347412, + 0.05411583185195923 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06207326799631119 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a wide-angle tracking shot that pans slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a scientist wearing a thick bright orange thermal suit with a fully enclosed hood and goggles visible in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scientist half-kneeling in the snow while adjusting a large solar panel with a deep blue photovoltaic surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background featuring a silver geodesic dome and communication antennas gleaming in the golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are fine snowflakes visible swirling in the wind and landing on the scientist's goggles and the solar panel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003623825730755925 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628623962402344 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003623825730755925, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003623825730755925, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22002029418945312, + 0.04347965121269226, + 0.074706070125103, + 0.07448727637529373, + 0.03357057645916939, + 0.0177481546998024, + 0.04357421398162842, + 0.0834307000041008, + 0.3582591116428375, + 0.05072392150759697 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003623825730755925 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a wide-angle tracking shot that pans slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a scientist wearing a thick bright orange thermal suit with a fully enclosed hood and goggles visible in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scientist half-kneeling in the snow while adjusting a large solar panel with a deep blue photovoltaic surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background featuring a silver geodesic dome and communication antennas gleaming in the golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are fine snowflakes visible swirling in the wind and landing on the scientist's goggles and the solar panel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020579271018505096 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955793380737305 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020579271018505096, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020579271018505096, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.28563788533210754, + 0.1605578511953354, + 0.06124527007341385, + 0.049638502299785614, + 0.048113610595464706, + 0.0333453007042408, + 0.015794461593031883, + 0.029772287234663963, + 0.2696938216686249, + 0.046201031655073166 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020579271018505096 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a wide-angle tracking shot that pans slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a scientist wearing a thick bright orange thermal suit with a fully enclosed hood and goggles visible in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scientist half-kneeling in the snow while adjusting a large solar panel with a deep blue photovoltaic surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background featuring a silver geodesic dome and communication antennas gleaming in the golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are fine snowflakes visible swirling in the wind and landing on the scientist's goggles and the solar panel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02634352445602417 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651343584060669 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02634352445602417, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02634352445602417, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.35351717472076416, + 0.08585157245397568, + 0.025999221950769424, + 0.14788687229156494, + 0.04455644264817238, + 0.01675836741924286, + 0.03410470113158226, + 0.051242440938949585, + 0.1952592134475708, + 0.044823963195085526 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02634352445602417 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "wide-angle tracking shot slowly pans right across the icy landscape of a remote Arctic research station. A golden polar sun hangs high above the horizon, its slanting rays casting long blue shadows across the vast, pristine expanse of ice, outlining the texture of each snowdrift with remarkable clarity. In the foreground, a scientist, clad in a thick, bright orange thermal suit, a fully enclosed hood, and goggles that reflect the golden sunlight, stands out. Half-kneeling in the snow, he methodically adjusts the angle of a large solar panel, its deep blue photovoltaic surface coated with a thin layer of frost. One thickly gloved hand steadying the panel's cool metal frame, the other carefully tightening a connection point on the bracket with a tool, his movements steady and focused. Fine snowflakes swirl in the biting wind, some landing gently on the scientist's dark goggles and the black surface of the solar panel before being blown away. In the background, the research station’s silver geodesic dome and several communication antennas gleam with metallic luster in the golden afterglow. The whole scene forms a sharp contrast between the majestic nature and the tenacious technology of mankind, creating a tranquil atmosphere that is both lonely and full of hope.", + "seed": 25282, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_10/index_4405_seed_25282_dp_21_rank_42_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.19808816188015044, + "vlm_logprob": -0.19808816188015044, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.125, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.19808816188015044, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a wide-angle tracking shot that pans slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a scientist wearing a thick bright orange thermal suit with a fully enclosed hood and goggles visible in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scientist half-kneeling in the snow while adjusting a large solar panel with a deep blue photovoltaic surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background featuring a silver geodesic dome and communication antennas gleaming in the golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are fine snowflakes visible swirling in the wind and landing on the scientist's goggles and the solar panel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7628481388092041 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6378481388092041 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.7628481388092041, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.7628481388092041, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08322341740131378, + 0.0908389538526535, + 0.06815703958272934, + 0.2860431671142578, + 0.06557351350784302, + 0.09282227605581284, + 0.10601082444190979, + 0.030744753777980804, + 0.14811550080776215, + 0.028470536693930626 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.7628481388092041 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a wide-angle tracking shot that pans slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a scientist wearing a thick bright orange thermal suit with a fully enclosed hood and goggles visible in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scientist half-kneeling in the snow while adjusting a large solar panel with a deep blue photovoltaic surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background featuring a silver geodesic dome and communication antennas gleaming in the golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are fine snowflakes visible swirling in the wind and landing on the scientist's goggles and the solar panel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00284077157266438 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877840995788574 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00284077157266438, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00284077157266438, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11040883511304855, + 0.12654349207878113, + 0.11311211436986923, + 0.318922221660614, + 0.08299142867326736, + 0.030489016324281693, + 0.04116610810160637, + 0.05788648873567581, + 0.0544356033205986, + 0.0640447735786438 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00284077157266438 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a wide-angle tracking shot that pans slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a scientist wearing a thick bright orange thermal suit with a fully enclosed hood and goggles visible in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scientist half-kneeling in the snow while adjusting a large solar panel with a deep blue photovoltaic surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background featuring a silver geodesic dome and communication antennas gleaming in the golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are fine snowflakes visible swirling in the wind and landing on the scientist's goggles and the solar panel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006743649020791054 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006743431091309 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006743649020791054, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006743649020791054, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14150618016719818, + 0.13609670102596283, + 0.08171110600233078, + 0.21553581953048706, + 0.052440058439970016, + 0.04231620207428932, + 0.15528427064418793, + 0.057479485869407654, + 0.06707873195409775, + 0.05055144056677818 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006743649020791054 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a wide-angle tracking shot that pans slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a scientist wearing a thick bright orange thermal suit with a fully enclosed hood and goggles visible in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scientist half-kneeling in the snow while adjusting a large solar panel with a deep blue photovoltaic surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background featuring a silver geodesic dome and communication antennas gleaming in the golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are fine snowflakes visible swirling in the wind and landing on the scientist's goggles and the solar panel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17990727722644806 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8049073219299316 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17990727722644806, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17990727722644806, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24185077846050262, + 0.2510773539543152, + 0.06598709523677826, + 0.11231566965579987, + 0.18159569799900055, + 0.06822571158409119, + 0.027672072872519493, + 0.010151810012757778, + 0.022315585985779762, + 0.01880822516977787 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17990727722644806 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a wide-angle tracking shot that pans slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a scientist wearing a thick bright orange thermal suit with a fully enclosed hood and goggles visible in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scientist half-kneeling in the snow while adjusting a large solar panel with a deep blue photovoltaic surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background featuring a silver geodesic dome and communication antennas gleaming in the golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are fine snowflakes visible swirling in the wind and landing on the scientist's goggles and the solar panel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03810097277164459 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881009578704834 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03810097277164459, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03810097277164459, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08677945286035538, + 0.09223613888025284, + 0.05633314698934555, + 0.4160670340061188, + 0.08281989395618439, + 0.02017524652183056, + 0.0429181307554245, + 0.017300060018897057, + 0.13425107300281525, + 0.05111990496516228 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03810097277164459 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "wide-angle tracking shot slowly pans right across the icy landscape of a remote Arctic research station. A golden polar sun hangs high above the horizon, its slanting rays casting long blue shadows across the vast, pristine expanse of ice, outlining the texture of each snowdrift with remarkable clarity. In the foreground, a scientist, clad in a thick, bright orange thermal suit, a fully enclosed hood, and goggles that reflect the golden sunlight, stands out. Half-kneeling in the snow, he methodically adjusts the angle of a large solar panel, its deep blue photovoltaic surface coated with a thin layer of frost. One thickly gloved hand steadying the panel's cool metal frame, the other carefully tightening a connection point on the bracket with a tool, his movements steady and focused. Fine snowflakes swirl in the biting wind, some landing gently on the scientist's dark goggles and the black surface of the solar panel before being blown away. In the background, the research station’s silver geodesic dome and several communication antennas gleam with metallic luster in the golden afterglow. The whole scene forms a sharp contrast between the majestic nature and the tenacious technology of mankind, creating a tranquil atmosphere that is both lonely and full of hope.", + "seed": 25283, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_10/index_4405_seed_25283_dp_21_rank_42_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.19047255525365472, + "vlm_logprob": -0.19047255525365472, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.075, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.19047255525365472, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a wide-angle tracking shot that pans slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a scientist wearing a thick bright orange thermal suit with a fully enclosed hood and goggles visible in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scientist half-kneeling in the snow while adjusting a large solar panel with a deep blue photovoltaic surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background featuring a silver geodesic dome and communication antennas gleaming in the golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are fine snowflakes visible swirling in the wind and landing on the scientist's goggles and the solar panel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8314884901046753 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5814884901046753 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.8314884901046753, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.8314884901046753, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2597726583480835, + 0.1150655597448349, + 0.046510033309459686, + 0.044266991317272186, + 0.06062627583742142, + 0.04534139856696129, + 0.24760623276233673, + 0.08561408519744873, + 0.058489780873060226, + 0.036707088351249695 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.8314884901046753 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a wide-angle tracking shot that pans slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a scientist wearing a thick bright orange thermal suit with a fully enclosed hood and goggles visible in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scientist half-kneeling in the snow while adjusting a large solar panel with a deep blue photovoltaic surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background featuring a silver geodesic dome and communication antennas gleaming in the golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are fine snowflakes visible swirling in the wind and landing on the scientist's goggles and the solar panel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009807850234210491 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.63480806350708 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009807850234210491, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009807850234210491, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2887297570705414, + 0.18768733739852905, + 0.11586903780698776, + 0.031535401940345764, + 0.06495174765586853, + 0.038756489753723145, + 0.1096460372209549, + 0.04190725088119507, + 0.058738015592098236, + 0.06217892840504646 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009807850234210491 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a wide-angle tracking shot that pans slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a scientist wearing a thick bright orange thermal suit with a fully enclosed hood and goggles visible in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scientist half-kneeling in the snow while adjusting a large solar panel with a deep blue photovoltaic surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background featuring a silver geodesic dome and communication antennas gleaming in the golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are fine snowflakes visible swirling in the wind and landing on the scientist's goggles and the solar panel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005955332424491644 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130955219268799 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005955332424491644, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005955332424491644, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.40194442868232727, + 0.11593590676784515, + 0.08622250705957413, + 0.038600217550992966, + 0.11527375131845474, + 0.04378166049718857, + 0.08982927352190018, + 0.04488464444875717, + 0.032604116946458817, + 0.030923470854759216 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005955332424491644 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a wide-angle tracking shot that pans slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a scientist wearing a thick bright orange thermal suit with a fully enclosed hood and goggles visible in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scientist half-kneeling in the snow while adjusting a large solar panel with a deep blue photovoltaic surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background featuring a silver geodesic dome and communication antennas gleaming in the golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are fine snowflakes visible swirling in the wind and landing on the scientist's goggles and the solar panel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06204884499311447 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.81204891204834 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06204884499311447, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06204884499311447, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3360694348812103, + 0.09822764992713928, + 0.03473125398159027, + 0.05015057697892189, + 0.15732236206531525, + 0.09433022141456604, + 0.10342840850353241, + 0.06882898509502411, + 0.018747376278042793, + 0.03816375508904457 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06204884499311447 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a wide-angle tracking shot that pans slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a scientist wearing a thick bright orange thermal suit with a fully enclosed hood and goggles visible in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scientist half-kneeling in the snow while adjusting a large solar panel with a deep blue photovoltaic surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background featuring a silver geodesic dome and communication antennas gleaming in the golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are fine snowflakes visible swirling in the wind and landing on the scientist's goggles and the solar panel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04306225851178169 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168062210083008 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04306225851178169, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04306225851178169, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.41969144344329834, + 0.12187314033508301, + 0.03582464158535004, + 0.04479261860251427, + 0.07271091639995575, + 0.036169927567243576, + 0.05598853528499603, + 0.09218747913837433, + 0.06224896013736725, + 0.058512281626462936 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04306225851178169 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_11/index_tensor([212, 212])_group_11_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_11/index_tensor([212, 212])_group_11_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..682271f0c2edc38018738aa8ddc7640996a427ee --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_11/index_tensor([212, 212])_group_11_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "Cinematic, high-speed macro footage, shot in ultra-slow motion, remains static in extreme close-up, perfectly aligned with the point of violent impact. A massive gauntlet, constructed of dark, riveted steel and thick, battle-worn leather, encases a powerfully clenched fist. The knuckles are fitted with heavy, tarnished brass dust collectors, their surface bearing the marks of countless altercations. As the fist collides with the rough, dark granite wall, the moment of impact is deconstructed with startling clarity. The brass gauntlet visibly compresses for a microsecond before releasing its force, causing a spiderweb of crystalline cracks to run across the stone surface. Simultaneously, a dazzling shower of white-hot sparks erupts from the friction, arcing gracefully through the air. A dense, billowing cloud of fine dust and grit erupts from the point of impact, its swirling particles caught in a single, harsh keylight, casting deep shadows and brightly illuminating the chaotic ballet of destruction. The atmosphere is tense and visceral, dominated by a cool, desaturated palette of dark stone and metal, with only brief, fiery sparks of raw power creating a surreal and awe-inspiring spectacle.", + "seed": 16283, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_11/index_212_seed_16283_dp_22_rank_44_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.20625048950314523, + "vlm_logprob": -0.20625048950314523, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.025, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.20625048950314523, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro view of a fist colliding with a wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the gauntlet constructed of dark riveted steel and thick battle-worn leather?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the knuckles fitted with heavy tarnished brass dust collectors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the impact cause a spiderweb of crystalline cracks on the dark granite wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a harsh keylight casting deep shadows on a billowing cloud of dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11455972492694855 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2395596504211426 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11455972492694855, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11455972492694855, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3434460461139679, + 0.07235416024923325, + 0.04873588681221008, + 0.03807790204882622, + 0.02610655128955841, + 0.033491455018520355, + 0.10071167349815369, + 0.18347971141338348, + 0.04513389989733696, + 0.10846274346113205 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11455972492694855 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro view of a fist colliding with a wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the gauntlet constructed of dark riveted steel and thick battle-worn leather?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the knuckles fitted with heavy tarnished brass dust collectors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the impact cause a spiderweb of crystalline cracks on the dark granite wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a harsh keylight casting deep shadows on a billowing cloud of dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10043000429868698 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3504300117492676 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10043000429868698, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10043000429868698, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.40954509377479553, + 0.10941942036151886, + 0.07401368767023087, + 0.04260602220892906, + 0.056458644568920135, + 0.04748225957155228, + 0.05359828099608421, + 0.08440569043159485, + 0.046308621764183044, + 0.07616236805915833 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10043000429868698 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro view of a fist colliding with a wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the gauntlet constructed of dark riveted steel and thick battle-worn leather?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the knuckles fitted with heavy tarnished brass dust collectors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the impact cause a spiderweb of crystalline cracks on the dark granite wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a harsh keylight casting deep shadows on a billowing cloud of dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6934525370597839 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6934525370597839 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.6934525370597839, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.6934525370597839, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2064090222120285, + 0.11199191957712173, + 0.05207546055316925, + 0.08268522471189499, + 0.028065241873264313, + 0.0925932303071022, + 0.1064075380563736, + 0.07839461416006088, + 0.05703284218907356, + 0.18434485793113708 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.6934525370597839 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro view of a fist colliding with a wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the gauntlet constructed of dark riveted steel and thick battle-worn leather?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the knuckles fitted with heavy tarnished brass dust collectors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the impact cause a spiderweb of crystalline cracks on the dark granite wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a harsh keylight casting deep shadows on a billowing cloud of dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0337202288210392 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4087202548980713 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0337202288210392, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0337202288210392, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11123701930046082, + 0.05230959504842758, + 0.03732449933886528, + 0.02966785430908203, + 0.043605223298072815, + 0.1843418926000595, + 0.08081309497356415, + 0.09250760823488235, + 0.0403791107237339, + 0.3278140723705292 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0337202288210392 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro view of a fist colliding with a wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the gauntlet constructed of dark riveted steel and thick battle-worn leather?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the knuckles fitted with heavy tarnished brass dust collectors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the impact cause a spiderweb of crystalline cracks on the dark granite wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a harsh keylight casting deep shadows on a billowing cloud of dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08908995240926743 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.464089870452881 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08908995240926743, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08908995240926743, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12438255548477173, + 0.06342510879039764, + 0.06315506994724274, + 0.038990192115306854, + 0.08415617048740387, + 0.07833362370729446, + 0.11219979077577591, + 0.26548948884010315, + 0.06758294999599457, + 0.10228512436151505 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08908995240926743 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "Cinematic, high-speed macro footage, shot in ultra-slow motion, remains static in extreme close-up, perfectly aligned with the point of violent impact. A massive gauntlet, constructed of dark, riveted steel and thick, battle-worn leather, encases a powerfully clenched fist. The knuckles are fitted with heavy, tarnished brass dust collectors, their surface bearing the marks of countless altercations. As the fist collides with the rough, dark granite wall, the moment of impact is deconstructed with startling clarity. The brass gauntlet visibly compresses for a microsecond before releasing its force, causing a spiderweb of crystalline cracks to run across the stone surface. Simultaneously, a dazzling shower of white-hot sparks erupts from the friction, arcing gracefully through the air. A dense, billowing cloud of fine dust and grit erupts from the point of impact, its swirling particles caught in a single, harsh keylight, casting deep shadows and brightly illuminating the chaotic ballet of destruction. The atmosphere is tense and visceral, dominated by a cool, desaturated palette of dark stone and metal, with only brief, fiery sparks of raw power creating a surreal and awe-inspiring spectacle.", + "seed": 16284, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_11/index_212_seed_16284_dp_22_rank_44_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.2179316647350788, + "vlm_logprob": -0.2179316647350788, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.425, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.2179316647350788, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro view of a fist colliding with a wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the gauntlet constructed of dark riveted steel and thick battle-worn leather?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the knuckles fitted with heavy tarnished brass dust collectors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the impact cause a spiderweb of crystalline cracks on the dark granite wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a harsh keylight casting deep shadows on a billowing cloud of dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05597876384854317 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.930978775024414 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05597876384854317, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05597876384854317, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13390670716762543, + 0.15001171827316284, + 0.19201336801052094, + 0.03515436872839928, + 0.053731855005025864, + 0.03212842345237732, + 0.022577399387955666, + 0.030415209010243416, + 0.07011734694242477, + 0.2799436151981354 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05597876384854317 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro view of a fist colliding with a wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the gauntlet constructed of dark riveted steel and thick battle-worn leather?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the knuckles fitted with heavy tarnished brass dust collectors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the impact cause a spiderweb of crystalline cracks on the dark granite wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a harsh keylight casting deep shadows on a billowing cloud of dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06211427226662636 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8121142387390137 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06211427226662636, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06211427226662636, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10294773429632187, + 0.26042959094047546, + 0.1122397929430008, + 0.034862276166677475, + 0.07449164986610413, + 0.03748214989900589, + 0.015732891857624054, + 0.022367870435118675, + 0.04011303931474686, + 0.29933300614356995 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06211427226662636 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro view of a fist colliding with a wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the gauntlet constructed of dark riveted steel and thick battle-worn leather?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the knuckles fitted with heavy tarnished brass dust collectors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the impact cause a spiderweb of crystalline cracks on the dark granite wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a harsh keylight casting deep shadows on a billowing cloud of dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8983966112136841 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5233966112136841 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.8983966112136841, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.8983966112136841, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21696674823760986, + 0.0573757104575634, + 0.27968907356262207, + 0.037020422518253326, + 0.027501391246914864, + 0.025963125750422478, + 0.023663822561502457, + 0.03286271542310715, + 0.05336744338274002, + 0.24558953940868378 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.8983966112136841 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro view of a fist colliding with a wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the gauntlet constructed of dark riveted steel and thick battle-worn leather?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the knuckles fitted with heavy tarnished brass dust collectors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the impact cause a spiderweb of crystalline cracks on the dark granite wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a harsh keylight casting deep shadows on a billowing cloud of dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018196552991867065 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.0181965827941895 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018196552991867065, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018196552991867065, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08275594562292099, + 0.09434422850608826, + 0.05994439125061035, + 0.015350565314292908, + 0.07464563101530075, + 0.0540274940431118, + 0.04152924194931984, + 0.04290945827960968, + 0.0730363130569458, + 0.4614567160606384 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018196552991867065 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro view of a fist colliding with a wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the gauntlet constructed of dark riveted steel and thick battle-worn leather?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the knuckles fitted with heavy tarnished brass dust collectors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the impact cause a spiderweb of crystalline cracks on the dark granite wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a harsh keylight casting deep shadows on a billowing cloud of dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.054972123354673386 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299721717834473 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.054972123354673386, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.054972123354673386, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03363531082868576, + 0.046140529215335846, + 0.029398666694760323, + 0.01750093698501587, + 0.16659818589687347, + 0.05658674240112305, + 0.032092902809381485, + 0.028306078165769577, + 0.034317292273044586, + 0.555423378944397 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.054972123354673386 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "Cinematic, high-speed macro footage, shot in ultra-slow motion, remains static in extreme close-up, perfectly aligned with the point of violent impact. A massive gauntlet, constructed of dark, riveted steel and thick, battle-worn leather, encases a powerfully clenched fist. The knuckles are fitted with heavy, tarnished brass dust collectors, their surface bearing the marks of countless altercations. As the fist collides with the rough, dark granite wall, the moment of impact is deconstructed with startling clarity. The brass gauntlet visibly compresses for a microsecond before releasing its force, causing a spiderweb of crystalline cracks to run across the stone surface. Simultaneously, a dazzling shower of white-hot sparks erupts from the friction, arcing gracefully through the air. A dense, billowing cloud of fine dust and grit erupts from the point of impact, its swirling particles caught in a single, harsh keylight, casting deep shadows and brightly illuminating the chaotic ballet of destruction. The atmosphere is tense and visceral, dominated by a cool, desaturated palette of dark stone and metal, with only brief, fiery sparks of raw power creating a surreal and awe-inspiring spectacle.", + "seed": 16285, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_11/index_212_seed_16285_dp_23_rank_46_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.2091147057712078, + "vlm_logprob": -0.2091147057712078, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.9999999761581422, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.2091147057712078, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro view of a fist colliding with a wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the gauntlet constructed of dark riveted steel and thick battle-worn leather?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the knuckles fitted with heavy tarnished brass dust collectors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the impact cause a spiderweb of crystalline cracks on the dark granite wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a harsh keylight casting deep shadows on a billowing cloud of dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12886938452720642 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1288692951202393 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12886938452720642, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.9999998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12886938452720642, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14688076078891754, + 0.06861788779497147, + 0.0824783593416214, + 0.04605771601200104, + 0.17618349194526672, + 0.08592510223388672, + 0.09523624926805496, + 0.07047078013420105, + 0.0918358787894249, + 0.136313796043396 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12886938452720642 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro view of a fist colliding with a wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the gauntlet constructed of dark riveted steel and thick battle-worn leather?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the knuckles fitted with heavy tarnished brass dust collectors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the impact cause a spiderweb of crystalline cracks on the dark granite wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a harsh keylight casting deep shadows on a billowing cloud of dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08916465193033218 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4641647338867188 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08916465193033218, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08916465193033218, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0996641218662262, + 0.05935712903738022, + 0.05937839671969414, + 0.06738057732582092, + 0.0379505380988121, + 0.04435644671320915, + 0.3719293177127838, + 0.04001610726118088, + 0.13173408806324005, + 0.08823338150978088 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08916465193033218 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro view of a fist colliding with a wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the gauntlet constructed of dark riveted steel and thick battle-worn leather?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the knuckles fitted with heavy tarnished brass dust collectors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the impact cause a spiderweb of crystalline cracks on the dark granite wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a harsh keylight casting deep shadows on a billowing cloud of dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6934540867805481 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6934540867805481 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.6934540867805481, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.6934540867805481, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12243328243494034, + 0.0695277750492096, + 0.10116942971944809, + 0.08881961554288864, + 0.06146110221743584, + 0.0751589685678482, + 0.04685848578810692, + 0.11206504702568054, + 0.12485089153051376, + 0.19765539467334747 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.6934540867805481 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro view of a fist colliding with a wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the gauntlet constructed of dark riveted steel and thick battle-worn leather?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the knuckles fitted with heavy tarnished brass dust collectors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the impact cause a spiderweb of crystalline cracks on the dark granite wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a harsh keylight casting deep shadows on a billowing cloud of dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10035388171672821 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.350353956222534 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10035388171672821, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10035388171672821, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04989078268408775, + 0.036063872277736664, + 0.24909469485282898, + 0.10358598083257675, + 0.13433048129081726, + 0.13513337075710297, + 0.014920918270945549, + 0.051219645887613297, + 0.17811571061611176, + 0.04764457046985626 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10035388171672821 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro view of a fist colliding with a wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the gauntlet constructed of dark riveted steel and thick battle-worn leather?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the knuckles fitted with heavy tarnished brass dust collectors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the impact cause a spiderweb of crystalline cracks on the dark granite wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a harsh keylight casting deep shadows on a billowing cloud of dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.033731523901224136 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408731460571289 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.033731523901224136, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.033731523901224136, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10174063593149185, + 0.04939056187868118, + 0.047886140644550323, + 0.08720213174819946, + 0.09346304088830948, + 0.07171784341335297, + 0.3285183012485504, + 0.06743436306715012, + 0.06326226890087128, + 0.0893847644329071 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.033731523901224136 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "Cinematic, high-speed macro footage, shot in ultra-slow motion, remains static in extreme close-up, perfectly aligned with the point of violent impact. A massive gauntlet, constructed of dark, riveted steel and thick, battle-worn leather, encases a powerfully clenched fist. The knuckles are fitted with heavy, tarnished brass dust collectors, their surface bearing the marks of countless altercations. As the fist collides with the rough, dark granite wall, the moment of impact is deconstructed with startling clarity. The brass gauntlet visibly compresses for a microsecond before releasing its force, causing a spiderweb of crystalline cracks to run across the stone surface. Simultaneously, a dazzling shower of white-hot sparks erupts from the friction, arcing gracefully through the air. A dense, billowing cloud of fine dust and grit erupts from the point of impact, its swirling particles caught in a single, harsh keylight, casting deep shadows and brightly illuminating the chaotic ballet of destruction. The atmosphere is tense and visceral, dominated by a cool, desaturated palette of dark stone and metal, with only brief, fiery sparks of raw power creating a surreal and awe-inspiring spectacle.", + "seed": 16286, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_11/index_212_seed_16286_dp_23_rank_46_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.2669948451220989, + "vlm_logprob": -0.2669948451220989, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.9, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.2669948451220989, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro view of a fist colliding with a wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the gauntlet constructed of dark riveted steel and thick battle-worn leather?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the knuckles fitted with heavy tarnished brass dust collectors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the impact cause a spiderweb of crystalline cracks on the dark granite wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a harsh keylight casting deep shadows on a billowing cloud of dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.43033984303474426 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.0553398132324219 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.43033984303474426, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.43033984303474426, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21523906290531158, + 0.10278167575597763, + 0.09235237538814545, + 0.049821022897958755, + 0.040705032646656036, + 0.18797911703586578, + 0.06658504903316498, + 0.05836942419409752, + 0.05582156777381897, + 0.1303456872701645 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.43033984303474426 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro view of a fist colliding with a wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the gauntlet constructed of dark riveted steel and thick battle-worn leather?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the knuckles fitted with heavy tarnished brass dust collectors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the impact cause a spiderweb of crystalline cracks on the dark granite wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a harsh keylight casting deep shadows on a billowing cloud of dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05499796196818352 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299979209899902 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05499796196818352, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05499796196818352, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2384202480316162, + 0.13127495348453522, + 0.09029222279787064, + 0.046519361436367035, + 0.042703576385974884, + 0.1929457038640976, + 0.05476491525769234, + 0.05181754007935524, + 0.061174314469099045, + 0.0900871604681015 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05499796196818352 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro view of a fist colliding with a wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the gauntlet constructed of dark riveted steel and thick battle-worn leather?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the knuckles fitted with heavy tarnished brass dust collectors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the impact cause a spiderweb of crystalline cracks on the dark granite wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a harsh keylight casting deep shadows on a billowing cloud of dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7578928470611572 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6328928470611572 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.7578928470611572, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.7578928470611572, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1373780220746994, + 0.09220603853464127, + 0.08077062666416168, + 0.05941782891750336, + 0.04291721433401108, + 0.17184677720069885, + 0.11053813993930817, + 0.042741235345602036, + 0.10281263291835785, + 0.1593714952468872 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.7578928470611572 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro view of a fist colliding with a wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the gauntlet constructed of dark riveted steel and thick battle-worn leather?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the knuckles fitted with heavy tarnished brass dust collectors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the impact cause a spiderweb of crystalline cracks on the dark granite wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a harsh keylight casting deep shadows on a billowing cloud of dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04866670072078705 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486667156219482 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04866670072078705, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04866670072078705, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1504276543855667, + 0.11018384248018265, + 0.1859278529882431, + 0.03407491371035576, + 0.05342044308781624, + 0.043292392045259476, + 0.10756722837686539, + 0.10012805461883545, + 0.08255524933338165, + 0.13242237269878387 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04866670072078705 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro view of a fist colliding with a wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the gauntlet constructed of dark riveted steel and thick battle-worn leather?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the knuckles fitted with heavy tarnished brass dust collectors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the impact cause a spiderweb of crystalline cracks on the dark granite wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a harsh keylight casting deep shadows on a billowing cloud of dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04307687282562256 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168076992034912 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04307687282562256, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04307687282562256, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2928864657878876, + 0.09943380951881409, + 0.07407669723033905, + 0.04598430544137955, + 0.042329393327236176, + 0.087471142411232, + 0.0641172006726265, + 0.1280299872159958, + 0.06748488545417786, + 0.09818612784147263 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04307687282562256 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_12/index_tensor([4800, 4800])_group_12_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_12/index_tensor([4800, 4800])_group_12_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..c02496e23e260ec6cbaa1d71abdec73df2478c0f --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_12/index_tensor([4800, 4800])_group_12_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "shot begins in extreme close-up, focusing on the long, flowing sleeves of a gorgeous Jin Opera costume, crafted from bright pink silk. The cuffs are delicately embroidered with intricate peony and phoenix motifs in gold thread, resting quietly on the actress's lap. Then, with an incredibly slow and smooth rhythm, the camera tilts upward, sweeping across the layers of vibrantly embroidered bodice, finally settling firmly on the face of the Hua Dan actress. She wears an exquisitely crafted phoenix crown inlaid with kingfisher feathers and gemstones, but our gaze is drawn to her face, painted with delicate opera makeup: beneath a snow-white foundation, a deep sense of fatigue can't be concealed. Her dramatically painted eyes are slightly downcast, their gaze vacant, devoid of their stage presence. A beam of direct light from a side-mounted vanity mirror sharply outlines the contours of her cheeks and makes the strands of pearl tassels dangling limply from either side of her phoenix coronet appear especially distinct. They rest motionlessly against her temples, no longer swaying with her movements, as if they, along with their host, have fallen into the silence and ennui that follows the performance. The entire scene takes place in a dimly lit, slightly cluttered backstage corner, with faint traces of hangers and prop boxes visible in the background. This creates an intimate and sentimental atmosphere, a fusion of glamour and reality, a stark contrast between on-stage splendor and backstage exhaustion.", + "seed": 7822, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_12/index_4800_seed_7822_dp_24_rank_48_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.021611787332221865, + "vlm_logprob": -0.021611787332221865, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.45, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.021611787332221865, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an extreme close-up of long, flowing pink silk sleeves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the sleeves embroidered with gold thread peony and phoenix motifs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward from the sleeves to reveal a Hua Dan actress wearing a phoenix crown with kingfisher feathers and gemstones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the actress's face painted with white foundation makeup, downcast eyes, and pearl tassels hanging limply from her crown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a dimly lit, cluttered backstage corner with visible hangers and prop boxes in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005522115621715784 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.25552225112915 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005522115621715784, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005522115621715784, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11630422621965408, + 0.2129334658384323, + 0.11123168468475342, + 0.07001689821481705, + 0.04966747388243675, + 0.07427458465099335, + 0.09627388417720795, + 0.0648675486445427, + 0.17400825023651123, + 0.030422022566199303 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005522115621715784 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an extreme close-up of long, flowing pink silk sleeves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the sleeves embroidered with gold thread peony and phoenix motifs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward from the sleeves to reveal a Hua Dan actress wearing a phoenix crown with kingfisher feathers and gemstones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the actress's face painted with white foundation makeup, downcast eyes, and pearl tassels hanging limply from her crown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a dimly lit, cluttered backstage corner with visible hangers and prop boxes in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.038172345608472824 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881722450256348 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.038172345608472824, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.038172345608472824, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10638035833835602, + 0.15732388198375702, + 0.08185532689094543, + 0.14449937641620636, + 0.14808423817157745, + 0.11445041000843048, + 0.1351637840270996, + 0.03484971448779106, + 0.03694569692015648, + 0.04044719785451889 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.038172345608472824 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an extreme close-up of long, flowing pink silk sleeves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the sleeves embroidered with gold thread peony and phoenix motifs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward from the sleeves to reveal a Hua Dan actress wearing a phoenix crown with kingfisher feathers and gemstones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the actress's face painted with white foundation makeup, downcast eyes, and pearl tassels hanging limply from her crown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a dimly lit, cluttered backstage corner with visible hangers and prop boxes in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0015149556566029787 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.501514911651611 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0015149556566029787, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0015149556566029787, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09690427035093307, + 0.11847689002752304, + 0.08105909079313278, + 0.03786333650350571, + 0.0859287679195404, + 0.09391728788614273, + 0.13196507096290588, + 0.06439630687236786, + 0.16649287939071655, + 0.12299606949090958 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0015149556566029787 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an extreme close-up of long, flowing pink silk sleeves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the sleeves embroidered with gold thread peony and phoenix motifs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward from the sleeves to reveal a Hua Dan actress wearing a phoenix crown with kingfisher feathers and gemstones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the actress's face painted with white foundation makeup, downcast eyes, and pearl tassels hanging limply from her crown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a dimly lit, cluttered backstage corner with visible hangers and prop boxes in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014208933338522911 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264208793640137 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014208933338522911, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014208933338522911, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09680643677711487, + 0.09125159680843353, + 0.047431349754333496, + 0.09661871194839478, + 0.055756110697984695, + 0.1462569683790207, + 0.0675470232963562, + 0.0702836737036705, + 0.1486799120903015, + 0.17936815321445465 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014208933338522911 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an extreme close-up of long, flowing pink silk sleeves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the sleeves embroidered with gold thread peony and phoenix motifs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward from the sleeves to reveal a Hua Dan actress wearing a phoenix crown with kingfisher feathers and gemstones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the actress's face painted with white foundation makeup, downcast eyes, and pearl tassels hanging limply from her crown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a dimly lit, cluttered backstage corner with visible hangers and prop boxes in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04864058643579483 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048640489578247 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04864058643579483, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04864058643579483, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2722875773906708, + 0.17353758215904236, + 0.04158763587474823, + 0.030925370752811432, + 0.04900123551487923, + 0.056954577565193176, + 0.09558369219303131, + 0.06134902685880661, + 0.16260844469070435, + 0.05616486445069313 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04864058643579483 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "shot begins in extreme close-up, focusing on the long, flowing sleeves of a gorgeous Jin Opera costume, crafted from bright pink silk. The cuffs are delicately embroidered with intricate peony and phoenix motifs in gold thread, resting quietly on the actress's lap. Then, with an incredibly slow and smooth rhythm, the camera tilts upward, sweeping across the layers of vibrantly embroidered bodice, finally settling firmly on the face of the Hua Dan actress. She wears an exquisitely crafted phoenix crown inlaid with kingfisher feathers and gemstones, but our gaze is drawn to her face, painted with delicate opera makeup: beneath a snow-white foundation, a deep sense of fatigue can't be concealed. Her dramatically painted eyes are slightly downcast, their gaze vacant, devoid of their stage presence. A beam of direct light from a side-mounted vanity mirror sharply outlines the contours of her cheeks and makes the strands of pearl tassels dangling limply from either side of her phoenix coronet appear especially distinct. They rest motionlessly against her temples, no longer swaying with her movements, as if they, along with their host, have fallen into the silence and ennui that follows the performance. The entire scene takes place in a dimly lit, slightly cluttered backstage corner, with faint traces of hangers and prop boxes visible in the background. This creates an intimate and sentimental atmosphere, a fusion of glamour and reality, a stark contrast between on-stage splendor and backstage exhaustion.", + "seed": 7823, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_12/index_4800_seed_7823_dp_24_rank_48_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.06159233001526445, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06159233001526445, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.5, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06159233001526445, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an extreme close-up of long, flowing pink silk sleeves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the sleeves embroidered with gold thread peony and phoenix motifs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward from the sleeves to reveal a Hua Dan actress wearing a phoenix crown with kingfisher feathers and gemstones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the actress's face painted with white foundation makeup, downcast eyes, and pearl tassels hanging limply from her crown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a dimly lit, cluttered backstage corner with visible hangers and prop boxes in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03413333743810654 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4091334342956543 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03413333743810654, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03413333743810654, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17382150888442993, + 0.09801851212978363, + 0.09339170902967453, + 0.09467890113592148, + 0.0988398939371109, + 0.11596053838729858, + 0.1514192372560501, + 0.061567522585392, + 0.0454263836145401, + 0.06687579303979874 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03413333743810654 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an extreme close-up of long, flowing pink silk sleeves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the sleeves embroidered with gold thread peony and phoenix motifs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward from the sleeves to reveal a Hua Dan actress wearing a phoenix crown with kingfisher feathers and gemstones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the actress's face painted with white foundation makeup, downcast eyes, and pearl tassels hanging limply from her crown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a dimly lit, cluttered backstage corner with visible hangers and prop boxes in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06215639412403107 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8121564388275146 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06215639412403107, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06215639412403107, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09113506227731705, + 0.06624250113964081, + 0.1244315579533577, + 0.12196081876754761, + 0.1691230833530426, + 0.04987924173474312, + 0.05897750332951546, + 0.19983944296836853, + 0.06150604039430618, + 0.05690474063158035 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06215639412403107 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an extreme close-up of long, flowing pink silk sleeves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the sleeves embroidered with gold thread peony and phoenix motifs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward from the sleeves to reveal a Hua Dan actress wearing a phoenix crown with kingfisher feathers and gemstones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the actress's face painted with white foundation makeup, downcast eyes, and pearl tassels hanging limply from her crown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a dimly lit, cluttered backstage corner with visible hangers and prop boxes in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.001943010720424354 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.251943111419678 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.001943010720424354, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.001943010720424354, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08902481943368912, + 0.04005945101380348, + 0.0648902952671051, + 0.07269740849733353, + 0.046717092394828796, + 0.09970705956220627, + 0.2235279083251953, + 0.15755771100521088, + 0.11655775457620621, + 0.08926049619913101 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.001943010720424354 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an extreme close-up of long, flowing pink silk sleeves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the sleeves embroidered with gold thread peony and phoenix motifs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward from the sleeves to reveal a Hua Dan actress wearing a phoenix crown with kingfisher feathers and gemstones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the actress's face painted with white foundation makeup, downcast eyes, and pearl tassels hanging limply from her crown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a dimly lit, cluttered backstage corner with visible hangers and prop boxes in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029824819415807724 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529824733734131 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029824819415807724, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029824819415807724, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1343218982219696, + 0.055623482912778854, + 0.09564805775880814, + 0.06300854682922363, + 0.053848959505558014, + 0.055776625871658325, + 0.07441485673189163, + 0.17985519766807556, + 0.0595780648291111, + 0.22792434692382812 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029824819415807724 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an extreme close-up of long, flowing pink silk sleeves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the sleeves embroidered with gold thread peony and phoenix motifs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward from the sleeves to reveal a Hua Dan actress wearing a phoenix crown with kingfisher feathers and gemstones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the actress's face painted with white foundation makeup, downcast eyes, and pearl tassels hanging limply from her crown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a dimly lit, cluttered backstage corner with visible hangers and prop boxes in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17990408837795258 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8049041032791138 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17990408837795258, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17990408837795258, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08136484026908875, + 0.08683761954307556, + 0.18853868544101715, + 0.05599115788936615, + 0.04756912961602211, + 0.049651648849248886, + 0.06548067927360535, + 0.2900104820728302, + 0.0371917262673378, + 0.09736399352550507 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 2, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17990408837795258 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "shot begins in extreme close-up, focusing on the long, flowing sleeves of a gorgeous Jin Opera costume, crafted from bright pink silk. The cuffs are delicately embroidered with intricate peony and phoenix motifs in gold thread, resting quietly on the actress's lap. Then, with an incredibly slow and smooth rhythm, the camera tilts upward, sweeping across the layers of vibrantly embroidered bodice, finally settling firmly on the face of the Hua Dan actress. She wears an exquisitely crafted phoenix crown inlaid with kingfisher feathers and gemstones, but our gaze is drawn to her face, painted with delicate opera makeup: beneath a snow-white foundation, a deep sense of fatigue can't be concealed. Her dramatically painted eyes are slightly downcast, their gaze vacant, devoid of their stage presence. A beam of direct light from a side-mounted vanity mirror sharply outlines the contours of her cheeks and makes the strands of pearl tassels dangling limply from either side of her phoenix coronet appear especially distinct. They rest motionlessly against her temples, no longer swaying with her movements, as if they, along with their host, have fallen into the silence and ennui that follows the performance. The entire scene takes place in a dimly lit, slightly cluttered backstage corner, with faint traces of hangers and prop boxes visible in the background. This creates an intimate and sentimental atmosphere, a fusion of glamour and reality, a stark contrast between on-stage splendor and backstage exhaustion.", + "seed": 7824, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_12/index_4800_seed_7824_dp_25_rank_50_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.03381272363476455, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03381272363476455, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.949999952316284, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03381272363476455, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an extreme close-up of long, flowing pink silk sleeves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the sleeves embroidered with gold thread peony and phoenix motifs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward from the sleeves to reveal a Hua Dan actress wearing a phoenix crown with kingfisher feathers and gemstones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the actress's face painted with white foundation makeup, downcast eyes, and pearl tassels hanging limply from her crown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a dimly lit, cluttered backstage corner with visible hangers and prop boxes in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014592469669878483 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.26459264755249 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014592469669878483, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014592469669878483, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2854624390602112, + 0.08988771587610245, + 0.09976629167795181, + 0.12195627391338348, + 0.05661289766430855, + 0.09055977314710617, + 0.08305715024471283, + 0.044552333652973175, + 0.089949831366539, + 0.03819531202316284 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014592469669878483 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an extreme close-up of long, flowing pink silk sleeves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the sleeves embroidered with gold thread peony and phoenix motifs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward from the sleeves to reveal a Hua Dan actress wearing a phoenix crown with kingfisher feathers and gemstones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the actress's face painted with white foundation makeup, downcast eyes, and pearl tassels hanging limply from her crown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a dimly lit, cluttered backstage corner with visible hangers and prop boxes in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.055099278688430786 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9300992488861084 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.055099278688430786, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.055099278688430786, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1781785637140274, + 0.28072598576545715, + 0.04802669212222099, + 0.028818128630518913, + 0.08110193908214569, + 0.07591130584478378, + 0.03575174883008003, + 0.0981549471616745, + 0.12127361446619034, + 0.05205705761909485 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.055099278688430786 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an extreme close-up of long, flowing pink silk sleeves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the sleeves embroidered with gold thread peony and phoenix motifs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward from the sleeves to reveal a Hua Dan actress wearing a phoenix crown with kingfisher feathers and gemstones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the actress's face painted with white foundation makeup, downcast eyes, and pearl tassels hanging limply from her crown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a dimly lit, cluttered backstage corner with visible hangers and prop boxes in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002199494047090411 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127199649810791 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002199494047090411, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002199494047090411, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10116840898990631, + 0.039122045040130615, + 0.04051097109913826, + 0.04725918546319008, + 0.050475675612688065, + 0.05159379169344902, + 0.05710933357477188, + 0.22674068808555603, + 0.30090492963790894, + 0.08511493355035782 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002199494047090411 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an extreme close-up of long, flowing pink silk sleeves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the sleeves embroidered with gold thread peony and phoenix motifs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward from the sleeves to reveal a Hua Dan actress wearing a phoenix crown with kingfisher feathers and gemstones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the actress's face painted with white foundation makeup, downcast eyes, and pearl tassels hanging limply from her crown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a dimly lit, cluttered backstage corner with visible hangers and prop boxes in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018199127167463303 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.0181989669799805 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018199127167463303, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018199127167463303, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10988453775644302, + 0.06332318484783173, + 0.07800809293985367, + 0.03038226068019867, + 0.050915271043777466, + 0.1607942432165146, + 0.09839622676372528, + 0.12463680654764175, + 0.11729738116264343, + 0.1663619726896286 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018199127167463303 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an extreme close-up of long, flowing pink silk sleeves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the sleeves embroidered with gold thread peony and phoenix motifs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward from the sleeves to reveal a Hua Dan actress wearing a phoenix crown with kingfisher feathers and gemstones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the actress's face painted with white foundation makeup, downcast eyes, and pearl tassels hanging limply from her crown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a dimly lit, cluttered backstage corner with visible hangers and prop boxes in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07897324860095978 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5789732933044434 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07897324860095978, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07897324860095978, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.053626369684934616, + 0.04830537363886833, + 0.023287860676646233, + 0.016443921253085136, + 0.04291851073503494, + 0.06900103390216827, + 0.17093820869922638, + 0.29421865940093994, + 0.13491937518119812, + 0.14634069800376892 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07897324860095978 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "shot begins in extreme close-up, focusing on the long, flowing sleeves of a gorgeous Jin Opera costume, crafted from bright pink silk. The cuffs are delicately embroidered with intricate peony and phoenix motifs in gold thread, resting quietly on the actress's lap. Then, with an incredibly slow and smooth rhythm, the camera tilts upward, sweeping across the layers of vibrantly embroidered bodice, finally settling firmly on the face of the Hua Dan actress. She wears an exquisitely crafted phoenix crown inlaid with kingfisher feathers and gemstones, but our gaze is drawn to her face, painted with delicate opera makeup: beneath a snow-white foundation, a deep sense of fatigue can't be concealed. Her dramatically painted eyes are slightly downcast, their gaze vacant, devoid of their stage presence. A beam of direct light from a side-mounted vanity mirror sharply outlines the contours of her cheeks and makes the strands of pearl tassels dangling limply from either side of her phoenix coronet appear especially distinct. They rest motionlessly against her temples, no longer swaying with her movements, as if they, along with their host, have fallen into the silence and ennui that follows the performance. The entire scene takes place in a dimly lit, slightly cluttered backstage corner, with faint traces of hangers and prop boxes visible in the background. This creates an intimate and sentimental atmosphere, a fusion of glamour and reality, a stark contrast between on-stage splendor and backstage exhaustion.", + "seed": 7825, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_12/index_4800_seed_7825_dp_25_rank_50_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.03667971258983016, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03667971258983016, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.825, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03667971258983016, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an extreme close-up of long, flowing pink silk sleeves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the sleeves embroidered with gold thread peony and phoenix motifs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward from the sleeves to reveal a Hua Dan actress wearing a phoenix crown with kingfisher feathers and gemstones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the actress's face painted with white foundation makeup, downcast eyes, and pearl tassels hanging limply from her crown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a dimly lit, cluttered backstage corner with visible hangers and prop boxes in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.089317187666893 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4643170833587646 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.089317187666893, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.089317187666893, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1970197707414627, + 0.33781376481056213, + 0.03448548913002014, + 0.03860385715961456, + 0.03426163271069527, + 0.054230280220508575, + 0.0453750379383564, + 0.13002139329910278, + 0.0576958954334259, + 0.07049292325973511 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.089317187666893 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an extreme close-up of long, flowing pink silk sleeves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the sleeves embroidered with gold thread peony and phoenix motifs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward from the sleeves to reveal a Hua Dan actress wearing a phoenix crown with kingfisher feathers and gemstones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the actress's face painted with white foundation makeup, downcast eyes, and pearl tassels hanging limply from her crown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a dimly lit, cluttered backstage corner with visible hangers and prop boxes in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.055060919374227524 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.930060863494873 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.055060919374227524, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.055060919374227524, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0578438974916935, + 0.4194403290748596, + 0.06707826256752014, + 0.013189580291509628, + 0.012803666293621063, + 0.035719938576221466, + 0.03308335319161415, + 0.11304031312465668, + 0.16750015318393707, + 0.08030048757791519 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.055060919374227524 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an extreme close-up of long, flowing pink silk sleeves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the sleeves embroidered with gold thread peony and phoenix motifs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward from the sleeves to reveal a Hua Dan actress wearing a phoenix crown with kingfisher feathers and gemstones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the actress's face painted with white foundation makeup, downcast eyes, and pearl tassels hanging limply from her crown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a dimly lit, cluttered backstage corner with visible hangers and prop boxes in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00319446949288249 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753194332122803 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00319446949288249, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00319446949288249, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14836135506629944, + 0.20625032484531403, + 0.15711255371570587, + 0.04466867074370384, + 0.0284412894397974, + 0.05589038506150246, + 0.04141673445701599, + 0.12270888686180115, + 0.0567183643579483, + 0.13843145966529846 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00319446949288249 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an extreme close-up of long, flowing pink silk sleeves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the sleeves embroidered with gold thread peony and phoenix motifs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward from the sleeves to reveal a Hua Dan actress wearing a phoenix crown with kingfisher feathers and gemstones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the actress's face painted with white foundation makeup, downcast eyes, and pearl tassels hanging limply from her crown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a dimly lit, cluttered backstage corner with visible hangers and prop boxes in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012545948848128319 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387546062469482 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012545948848128319, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012545948848128319, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10661936551332474, + 0.5323606729507446, + 0.03533081337809563, + 0.03925281763076782, + 0.01972028613090515, + 0.0243449155241251, + 0.04339093714952469, + 0.11110258847475052, + 0.03239293769001961, + 0.05548465996980667 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012545948848128319 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an extreme close-up of long, flowing pink silk sleeves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the sleeves embroidered with gold thread peony and phoenix motifs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward from the sleeves to reveal a Hua Dan actress wearing a phoenix crown with kingfisher feathers and gemstones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the actress's face painted with white foundation makeup, downcast eyes, and pearl tassels hanging limply from her crown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a dimly lit, cluttered backstage corner with visible hangers and prop boxes in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023280037567019463 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773280143737793 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023280037567019463, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023280037567019463, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11991236358880997, + 0.2478601634502411, + 0.06545845419168472, + 0.05158307030797005, + 0.027899647131562233, + 0.12045430392026901, + 0.14729930460453033, + 0.09588409215211868, + 0.06550513207912445, + 0.058143485337495804 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023280037567019463 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_13/index_tensor([3919, 3919])_group_13_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_13/index_tensor([3919, 3919])_group_13_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..a39ffe06651e06c3aeac068488a26ac41c110a33 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_13/index_tensor([3919, 3919])_group_13_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "stunning high-angle drone shot, gliding smoothly forward and slowly panning to the right, reveals a breathtaking spectacle. A dense, serpentine stream of thousands of runners flows like a vibrant river along the scenic coastal highway, a long human procession stretching for miles until it disappears around a distant, sun-bleached cape. The collective is a moving mosaic of color, the athletes clad in a dazzling array of high-performance gear: neon yellow vests, electric blue leggings, and hot pink shorts create a stark and beautiful contrast against the dark gray asphalt. To the right, the azure ocean gleams in the bright morning sun, gentle waves breaking into white foam on the rocky shoreline. The runners move with a unified, rhythmic pulse, their arms pumping and their feet tapping the pavement in a steady, determined rhythm. Their diverse faces blend with intense focus and shared struggle. The entire scene is bathed in crisp, clear light, casting long, dynamic shadows, creating an epic, vibrant atmosphere of human endurance and collective will.", + "seed": 699, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_13/index_3919_seed_699_dp_26_rank_52_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.26689792722463607, + "vlm_logprob": -0.26689792722463607, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.625, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.26689792722463607, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a high-angle drone perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera glide smoothly forward and slowly pan to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a dense stream of thousands of runners flowing along a scenic coastal highway?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the runners wearing neon yellow vests, electric blue leggings, and hot pink shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the azure ocean visible to the right with gentle waves breaking into white foam on a rocky shoreline?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7004238963127136 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7004238963127136 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.7004238963127136, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.7004238963127136, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1875874549150467, + 0.08808505535125732, + 0.10097797214984894, + 0.07708130776882172, + 0.062957763671875, + 0.017115281894803047, + 0.02567492239177227, + 0.06549505144357681, + 0.03903363645076752, + 0.33599159121513367 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.7004238963127136 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a high-angle drone perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera glide smoothly forward and slowly pan to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a dense stream of thousands of runners flowing along a scenic coastal highway?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the runners wearing neon yellow vests, electric blue leggings, and hot pink shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the azure ocean visible to the right with gentle waves breaking into white foam on a rocky shoreline?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.055004507303237915 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.930004596710205 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.055004507303237915, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.055004507303237915, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.40457361936569214, + 0.08375551551580429, + 0.08358889073133469, + 0.042939137667417526, + 0.027227098122239113, + 0.012201879173517227, + 0.032084498554468155, + 0.07931041717529297, + 0.05539285019040108, + 0.17892606556415558 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.055004507303237915 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a high-angle drone perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera glide smoothly forward and slowly pan to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a dense stream of thousands of runners flowing along a scenic coastal highway?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the runners wearing neon yellow vests, electric blue leggings, and hot pink shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the azure ocean visible to the right with gentle waves breaking into white foam on a rocky shoreline?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07001570612192154 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950156688690186 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07001570612192154, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07001570612192154, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05228377878665924, + 0.05786237120628357, + 0.034441035240888596, + 0.008673371747136116, + 0.01612662896513939, + 0.005682537332177162, + 0.020380627363920212, + 0.04663902148604393, + 0.01362447440624237, + 0.744286060333252 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07001570612192154 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a high-angle drone perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera glide smoothly forward and slowly pan to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a dense stream of thousands of runners flowing along a scenic coastal highway?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the runners wearing neon yellow vests, electric blue leggings, and hot pink shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the azure ocean visible to the right with gentle waves breaking into white foam on a rocky shoreline?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3487332761287689 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2237333059310913 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3487332761287689, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3487332761287689, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08748428523540497, + 0.09294702857732773, + 0.5068867802619934, + 0.016588320955634117, + 0.021264372393488884, + 0.014205390587449074, + 0.028387073427438736, + 0.07187795639038086, + 0.05410182103514671, + 0.10625703632831573 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3487332761287689 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a high-angle drone perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera glide smoothly forward and slowly pan to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a dense stream of thousands of runners flowing along a scenic coastal highway?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the runners wearing neon yellow vests, electric blue leggings, and hot pink shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the azure ocean visible to the right with gentle waves breaking into white foam on a rocky shoreline?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1603122502565384 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.910312294960022 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1603122502565384, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1603122502565384, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0780029147863388, + 0.11638827621936798, + 0.2158500850200653, + 0.12511684000492096, + 0.15295380353927612, + 0.04935365542769432, + 0.04787060245871544, + 0.06531170755624771, + 0.05084264278411865, + 0.09830949455499649 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1603122502565384 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "stunning high-angle drone shot, gliding smoothly forward and slowly panning to the right, reveals a breathtaking spectacle. A dense, serpentine stream of thousands of runners flows like a vibrant river along the scenic coastal highway, a long human procession stretching for miles until it disappears around a distant, sun-bleached cape. The collective is a moving mosaic of color, the athletes clad in a dazzling array of high-performance gear: neon yellow vests, electric blue leggings, and hot pink shorts create a stark and beautiful contrast against the dark gray asphalt. To the right, the azure ocean gleams in the bright morning sun, gentle waves breaking into white foam on the rocky shoreline. The runners move with a unified, rhythmic pulse, their arms pumping and their feet tapping the pavement in a steady, determined rhythm. Their diverse faces blend with intense focus and shared struggle. The entire scene is bathed in crisp, clear light, casting long, dynamic shadows, creating an epic, vibrant atmosphere of human endurance and collective will.", + "seed": 700, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_13/index_3919_seed_700_dp_26_rank_52_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.1520070604979992, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1520070604979992, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.55, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1520070604979992, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a high-angle drone perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera glide smoothly forward and slowly pan to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a dense stream of thousands of runners flowing along a scenic coastal highway?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the runners wearing neon yellow vests, electric blue leggings, and hot pink shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the azure ocean visible to the right with gentle waves breaking into white foam on a rocky shoreline?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4890148639678955 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9890148639678955 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.4890148639678955, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.4890148639678955, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3042740523815155, + 0.044887155294418335, + 0.09401767700910568, + 0.12477065622806549, + 0.09856267273426056, + 0.027521075680851936, + 0.11753549426794052, + 0.11432730406522751, + 0.023489581421017647, + 0.05061430484056473 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.4890148639678955 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a high-angle drone perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera glide smoothly forward and slowly pan to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a dense stream of thousands of runners flowing along a scenic coastal highway?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the runners wearing neon yellow vests, electric blue leggings, and hot pink shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the azure ocean visible to the right with gentle waves breaking into white foam on a rocky shoreline?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07008661329746246 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695086717605591 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07008661329746246, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07008661329746246, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1468321681022644, + 0.05165876820683479, + 0.04144659638404846, + 0.13059291243553162, + 0.06664995849132538, + 0.07028474658727646, + 0.33739906549453735, + 0.04999056085944176, + 0.06519447267055511, + 0.03995069861412048 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07008661329746246 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a high-angle drone perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera glide smoothly forward and slowly pan to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a dense stream of thousands of runners flowing along a scenic coastal highway?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the runners wearing neon yellow vests, electric blue leggings, and hot pink shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the azure ocean visible to the right with gentle waves breaking into white foam on a rocky shoreline?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026339808478951454 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513397693634033 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026339808478951454, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026339808478951454, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13753679394721985, + 0.19056124985218048, + 0.13223275542259216, + 0.05856243148446083, + 0.06947670131921768, + 0.056423697620630264, + 0.16681163012981415, + 0.07304549962282181, + 0.04558864235877991, + 0.06976056098937988 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026339808478951454 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a high-angle drone perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera glide smoothly forward and slowly pan to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a dense stream of thousands of runners flowing along a scenic coastal highway?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the runners wearing neon yellow vests, electric blue leggings, and hot pink shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the azure ocean visible to the right with gentle waves breaking into white foam on a rocky shoreline?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16040882468223572 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.910408854484558 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16040882468223572, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16040882468223572, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06688182055950165, + 0.067977674305439, + 0.03767948970198631, + 0.14623086154460907, + 0.02521018125116825, + 0.07895755022764206, + 0.4637000560760498, + 0.05194062367081642, + 0.0213204063475132, + 0.040101323276758194 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16040882468223572 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a high-angle drone perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera glide smoothly forward and slowly pan to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a dense stream of thousands of runners flowing along a scenic coastal highway?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the runners wearing neon yellow vests, electric blue leggings, and hot pink shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the azure ocean visible to the right with gentle waves breaking into white foam on a rocky shoreline?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014185192063450813 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264185428619385 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014185192063450813, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014185192063450813, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3015874922275543, + 0.2257257103919983, + 0.046352118253707886, + 0.10191421955823898, + 0.042829979211091995, + 0.012131428346037865, + 0.03387526795268059, + 0.028580935671925545, + 0.17727482318878174, + 0.02972801774740219 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014185192063450813 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "stunning high-angle drone shot, gliding smoothly forward and slowly panning to the right, reveals a breathtaking spectacle. A dense, serpentine stream of thousands of runners flows like a vibrant river along the scenic coastal highway, a long human procession stretching for miles until it disappears around a distant, sun-bleached cape. The collective is a moving mosaic of color, the athletes clad in a dazzling array of high-performance gear: neon yellow vests, electric blue leggings, and hot pink shorts create a stark and beautiful contrast against the dark gray asphalt. To the right, the azure ocean gleams in the bright morning sun, gentle waves breaking into white foam on the rocky shoreline. The runners move with a unified, rhythmic pulse, their arms pumping and their feet tapping the pavement in a steady, determined rhythm. Their diverse faces blend with intense focus and shared struggle. The entire scene is bathed in crisp, clear light, casting long, dynamic shadows, creating an epic, vibrant atmosphere of human endurance and collective will.", + "seed": 701, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_13/index_3919_seed_701_dp_27_rank_54_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.1832839570939541, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1832839570939541, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.025, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1832839570939541, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a high-angle drone perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera glide smoothly forward and slowly pan to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a dense stream of thousands of runners flowing along a scenic coastal highway?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the runners wearing neon yellow vests, electric blue leggings, and hot pink shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the azure ocean visible to the right with gentle waves breaking into white foam on a rocky shoreline?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2914103865623474 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4164104461669922 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2914103865623474, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2914103865623474, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.45227086544036865, + 0.057027533650398254, + 0.031244462355971336, + 0.03940967097878456, + 0.033439841121435165, + 0.13572514057159424, + 0.06789705902338028, + 0.030479149892926216, + 0.0433897040784359, + 0.10911653190851212 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2914103865623474 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a high-angle drone perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera glide smoothly forward and slowly pan to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a dense stream of thousands of runners flowing along a scenic coastal highway?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the runners wearing neon yellow vests, electric blue leggings, and hot pink shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the azure ocean visible to the right with gentle waves breaking into white foam on a rocky shoreline?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.062086042016744614 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120861053466797 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.062086042016744614, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.062086042016744614, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14458444714546204, + 0.04650098457932472, + 0.03207344561815262, + 0.04841521754860878, + 0.04294028505682945, + 0.08451033383607864, + 0.05710950493812561, + 0.045938603579998016, + 0.11879713088274002, + 0.3791300356388092 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.062086042016744614 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a high-angle drone perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera glide smoothly forward and slowly pan to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a dense stream of thousands of runners flowing along a scenic coastal highway?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the runners wearing neon yellow vests, electric blue leggings, and hot pink shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the azure ocean visible to the right with gentle waves breaking into white foam on a rocky shoreline?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03369107097387314 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408691167831421 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03369107097387314, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03369107097387314, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19197605550289154, + 0.05370662361383438, + 0.042086947709321976, + 0.02499832771718502, + 0.04640638828277588, + 0.32182973623275757, + 0.029041489586234093, + 0.05527115240693092, + 0.025628799572587013, + 0.20905449986457825 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03369107097387314 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a high-angle drone perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera glide smoothly forward and slowly pan to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a dense stream of thousands of runners flowing along a scenic coastal highway?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the runners wearing neon yellow vests, electric blue leggings, and hot pink shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the azure ocean visible to the right with gentle waves breaking into white foam on a rocky shoreline?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4289626181125641 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.0539625883102417 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.4289626181125641, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.4289626181125641, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07165978103876114, + 0.025964537635445595, + 0.017694417387247086, + 0.02910023368895054, + 0.01492093876004219, + 0.4733993113040924, + 0.010664925910532475, + 0.030216695740818977, + 0.008296985179185867, + 0.31808221340179443 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.4289626181125641 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a high-angle drone perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera glide smoothly forward and slowly pan to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a dense stream of thousands of runners flowing along a scenic coastal highway?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the runners wearing neon yellow vests, electric blue leggings, and hot pink shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the azure ocean visible to the right with gentle waves breaking into white foam on a rocky shoreline?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10026966780424118 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3502695560455322 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10026966780424118, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10026966780424118, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24775612354278564, + 0.15186381340026855, + 0.10218576341867447, + 0.046762071549892426, + 0.07376793026924133, + 0.04754931107163429, + 0.07335837930440903, + 0.04049163684248924, + 0.07015489041805267, + 0.14611010253429413 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10026966780424118 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "stunning high-angle drone shot, gliding smoothly forward and slowly panning to the right, reveals a breathtaking spectacle. A dense, serpentine stream of thousands of runners flows like a vibrant river along the scenic coastal highway, a long human procession stretching for miles until it disappears around a distant, sun-bleached cape. The collective is a moving mosaic of color, the athletes clad in a dazzling array of high-performance gear: neon yellow vests, electric blue leggings, and hot pink shorts create a stark and beautiful contrast against the dark gray asphalt. To the right, the azure ocean gleams in the bright morning sun, gentle waves breaking into white foam on the rocky shoreline. The runners move with a unified, rhythmic pulse, their arms pumping and their feet tapping the pavement in a steady, determined rhythm. Their diverse faces blend with intense focus and shared struggle. The entire scene is bathed in crisp, clear light, casting long, dynamic shadows, creating an epic, vibrant atmosphere of human endurance and collective will.", + "seed": 702, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_13/index_3919_seed_702_dp_27_rank_54_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.20335303004831076, + "vlm_logprob": -0.20335303004831076, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.5249999523162843, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.20335303004831076, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a high-angle drone perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera glide smoothly forward and slowly pan to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a dense stream of thousands of runners flowing along a scenic coastal highway?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the runners wearing neon yellow vests, electric blue leggings, and hot pink shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the azure ocean visible to the right with gentle waves breaking into white foam on a rocky shoreline?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12781311571598053 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2528131008148193 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12781311571598053, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12781311571598053, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19195012748241425, + 0.18019194900989532, + 0.17557191848754883, + 0.07558473199605942, + 0.03445861488580704, + 0.07758260518312454, + 0.035716019570827484, + 0.04633600637316704, + 0.11099951714277267, + 0.07160850614309311 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12781311571598053 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a high-angle drone perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera glide smoothly forward and slowly pan to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a dense stream of thousands of runners flowing along a scenic coastal highway?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the runners wearing neon yellow vests, electric blue leggings, and hot pink shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the azure ocean visible to the right with gentle waves breaking into white foam on a rocky shoreline?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10036790370941162 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.350368022918701 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10036790370941162, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10036790370941162, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16749313473701477, + 0.1700199991464615, + 0.06610662490129471, + 0.06622926890850067, + 0.10547643899917603, + 0.08279921114444733, + 0.0641508474946022, + 0.07122374325990677, + 0.12010738998651505, + 0.08639325946569443 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10036790370941162 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a high-angle drone perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera glide smoothly forward and slowly pan to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a dense stream of thousands of runners flowing along a scenic coastal highway?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the runners wearing neon yellow vests, electric blue leggings, and hot pink shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the azure ocean visible to the right with gentle waves breaking into white foam on a rocky shoreline?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018184378743171692 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018184185028076 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018184378743171692, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018184378743171692, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21443696320056915, + 0.1415504366159439, + 0.08738124370574951, + 0.04381684586405754, + 0.026251865550875664, + 0.06163392961025238, + 0.039871565997600555, + 0.04225021228194237, + 0.3114728629589081, + 0.031334150582551956 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018184378743171692 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a high-angle drone perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera glide smoothly forward and slowly pan to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a dense stream of thousands of runners flowing along a scenic coastal highway?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the runners wearing neon yellow vests, electric blue leggings, and hot pink shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the azure ocean visible to the right with gentle waves breaking into white foam on a rocky shoreline?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7578678131103516 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6328678131103516 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.7578678131103516, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.7578678131103516, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18851618468761444, + 0.10424499958753586, + 0.07942026853561401, + 0.04631983861327171, + 0.04321005567908287, + 0.19252999126911163, + 0.06445245444774628, + 0.05509217083454132, + 0.1996411234140396, + 0.02657296508550644 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.7578678131103516 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a high-angle drone perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera glide smoothly forward and slowly pan to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a dense stream of thousands of runners flowing along a scenic coastal highway?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the runners wearing neon yellow vests, electric blue leggings, and hot pink shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the azure ocean visible to the right with gentle waves breaking into white foam on a rocky shoreline?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012531938962638378 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387531757354736 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012531938962638378, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012531938962638378, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13077645003795624, + 0.06286691874265671, + 0.09750182926654816, + 0.06597030162811279, + 0.07587897777557373, + 0.084572434425354, + 0.07728567719459534, + 0.044098518788814545, + 0.18916408717632294, + 0.17188483476638794 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012531938962638378 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_14/index_tensor([6594, 6594])_group_14_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_14/index_tensor([6594, 6594])_group_14_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..d2746a32c29e4d85e9d910cfbdd13b3a6a16fbf3 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_14/index_tensor([6594, 6594])_group_14_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "An epic, aerial drone shot captures a wide, viscous stream of molten rock, cascading from fissures atop a rugged, black volcano, against the backdrop of deep night. This stream of molten rock cascades from a dazzling white-hot center to a deep, blood-red rim, its surface roiling and bubbling, its intense heat sending ripples of distortion through the air. With a slow, inexorable flow, it initially diverges into intertwining tributaries that cling to the dark mountain like vast, luminous roots, before gradually converging into a broad, main stream. As the camera slowly pulls out, the image becomes dominated by this magnificent, flaming river, carving a sinuous lifeline through the inky landscape. The magma itself becomes the sole source of light, tinting the thick ash plume an ominous orange-red, creating an atmosphere both awe-inspiring and imbued with a primal, destructive force.", + "seed": 12856, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_14/index_6594_seed_12856_dp_28_rank_56_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.09758893623948098, + "vlm_logprob": -0.09758893623948098, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.45, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.09758893623948098, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at night on a rugged black volcano?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a wide viscous stream of molten rock cascading from fissures on the volcano?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the molten rock stream transition from a white-hot center to a deep blood-red rim?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pull out to reveal the magma stream as the dominant light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the magma stream shown initially diverging into tributaries before converging into a broad main stream?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009565000422298908 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.1345648765563965 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009565000422298908, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009565000422298908, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24094223976135254, + 0.10605745762586594, + 0.06425493210554123, + 0.08644941449165344, + 0.1016751229763031, + 0.05650896951556206, + 0.1150430366396904, + 0.046575434505939484, + 0.12741854786872864, + 0.055074866861104965 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009565000422298908 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at night on a rugged black volcano?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a wide viscous stream of molten rock cascading from fissures on the volcano?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the molten rock stream transition from a white-hot center to a deep blood-red rim?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pull out to reveal the magma stream as the dominant light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the magma stream shown initially diverging into tributaries before converging into a broad main stream?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008664277382194996 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758664131164551 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008664277382194996, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008664277382194996, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06260762363672256, + 0.12048555165529251, + 0.11191174387931824, + 0.033830828964710236, + 0.05921695753931999, + 0.033519092947244644, + 0.2524166703224182, + 0.07472006231546402, + 0.11678723245859146, + 0.13450421392917633 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008664277382194996 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at night on a rugged black volcano?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a wide viscous stream of molten rock cascading from fissures on the volcano?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the molten rock stream transition from a white-hot center to a deep blood-red rim?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pull out to reveal the magma stream as the dominant light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the magma stream shown initially diverging into tributaries before converging into a broad main stream?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020596204325556755 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955962657928467 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020596204325556755, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020596204325556755, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1776665300130844, + 0.1532995104789734, + 0.0892382264137268, + 0.04230319336056709, + 0.10191930830478668, + 0.06579826772212982, + 0.11764080822467804, + 0.04386892169713974, + 0.06578272581100464, + 0.14248254895210266 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020596204325556755 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at night on a rugged black volcano?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a wide viscous stream of molten rock cascading from fissures on the volcano?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the molten rock stream transition from a white-hot center to a deep blood-red rim?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pull out to reveal the magma stream as the dominant light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the magma stream shown initially diverging into tributaries before converging into a broad main stream?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.062059152871370316 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812059164047241 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.062059152871370316, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.062059152871370316, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15179534256458282, + 0.13143396377563477, + 0.07600639760494232, + 0.06130934879183769, + 0.04901222139596939, + 0.04651181399822235, + 0.14614209532737732, + 0.06108187511563301, + 0.19876503944396973, + 0.07794191688299179 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.062059152871370316 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at night on a rugged black volcano?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a wide viscous stream of molten rock cascading from fissures on the volcano?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the molten rock stream transition from a white-hot center to a deep blood-red rim?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pull out to reveal the magma stream as the dominant light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the magma stream shown initially diverging into tributaries before converging into a broad main stream?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3870600461959839 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1370600461959839 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3870600461959839, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3870600461959839, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1495010107755661, + 0.10641221702098846, + 0.10001010447740555, + 0.042491983622312546, + 0.052203644067049026, + 0.052821654826402664, + 0.2187090814113617, + 0.048734165728092194, + 0.0686008557677269, + 0.1605152189731598 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3870600461959839 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An epic, aerial drone shot captures a wide, viscous stream of molten rock, cascading from fissures atop a rugged, black volcano, against the backdrop of deep night. This stream of molten rock cascades from a dazzling white-hot center to a deep, blood-red rim, its surface roiling and bubbling, its intense heat sending ripples of distortion through the air. With a slow, inexorable flow, it initially diverges into intertwining tributaries that cling to the dark mountain like vast, luminous roots, before gradually converging into a broad, main stream. As the camera slowly pulls out, the image becomes dominated by this magnificent, flaming river, carving a sinuous lifeline through the inky landscape. The magma itself becomes the sole source of light, tinting the thick ash plume an ominous orange-red, creating an atmosphere both awe-inspiring and imbued with a primal, destructive force.", + "seed": 12857, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_14/index_6594_seed_12857_dp_28_rank_56_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.07000292339362205, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07000292339362205, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.15, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07000292339362205, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at night on a rugged black volcano?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a wide viscous stream of molten rock cascading from fissures on the volcano?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the molten rock stream transition from a white-hot center to a deep blood-red rim?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pull out to reveal the magma stream as the dominant light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the magma stream shown initially diverging into tributaries before converging into a broad main stream?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009339334443211555 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.259339332580566 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009339334443211555, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009339334443211555, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22166837751865387, + 0.0460195429623127, + 0.02765844762325287, + 0.08702144771814346, + 0.05385700613260269, + 0.11766707897186279, + 0.19677038490772247, + 0.08730639517307281, + 0.0683705061674118, + 0.09366080909967422 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009339334443211555 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at night on a rugged black volcano?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a wide viscous stream of molten rock cascading from fissures on the volcano?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the molten rock stream transition from a white-hot center to a deep blood-red rim?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pull out to reveal the magma stream as the dominant light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the magma stream shown initially diverging into tributaries before converging into a broad main stream?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036284581292420626 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628628253936768 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036284581292420626, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036284581292420626, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11454997956752777, + 0.17618636786937714, + 0.05751219391822815, + 0.07734601944684982, + 0.09428203105926514, + 0.21847233176231384, + 0.048268772661685944, + 0.05202675983309746, + 0.029272116720676422, + 0.132083460688591 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036284581292420626 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at night on a rugged black volcano?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a wide viscous stream of molten rock cascading from fissures on the volcano?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the molten rock stream transition from a white-hot center to a deep blood-red rim?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pull out to reveal the magma stream as the dominant light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the magma stream shown initially diverging into tributaries before converging into a broad main stream?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012543593533337116 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387543678283691 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012543593533337116, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012543593533337116, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.43428078293800354, + 0.1064465194940567, + 0.0538204126060009, + 0.06249473616480827, + 0.05853744223713875, + 0.06391477584838867, + 0.06656130403280258, + 0.045765943825244904, + 0.03732629492878914, + 0.07085182517766953 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012543593533337116 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at night on a rugged black volcano?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a wide viscous stream of molten rock cascading from fissures on the volcano?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the molten rock stream transition from a white-hot center to a deep blood-red rim?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pull out to reveal the magma stream as the dominant light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the magma stream shown initially diverging into tributaries before converging into a broad main stream?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011077570728957653 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511077404022217 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011077570728957653, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011077570728957653, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12585735321044922, + 0.02686070278286934, + 0.04601551592350006, + 0.11429408937692642, + 0.22152665257453918, + 0.31753474473953247, + 0.07569639384746552, + 0.021131310611963272, + 0.014561997726559639, + 0.036521170288324356 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011077570728957653 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at night on a rugged black volcano?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a wide viscous stream of molten rock cascading from fissures on the volcano?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the molten rock stream transition from a white-hot center to a deep blood-red rim?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pull out to reveal the magma stream as the dominant light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the magma stream shown initially diverging into tributaries before converging into a broad main stream?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3134256601333618 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3134256601333618 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3134256601333618, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3134256601333618, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18394428491592407, + 0.1003432497382164, + 0.03630582615733147, + 0.07862827181816101, + 0.19187825918197632, + 0.19702064990997314, + 0.049663245677948, + 0.056613292545080185, + 0.053757715970277786, + 0.05184521526098251 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3134256601333618 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An epic, aerial drone shot captures a wide, viscous stream of molten rock, cascading from fissures atop a rugged, black volcano, against the backdrop of deep night. This stream of molten rock cascades from a dazzling white-hot center to a deep, blood-red rim, its surface roiling and bubbling, its intense heat sending ripples of distortion through the air. With a slow, inexorable flow, it initially diverges into intertwining tributaries that cling to the dark mountain like vast, luminous roots, before gradually converging into a broad, main stream. As the camera slowly pulls out, the image becomes dominated by this magnificent, flaming river, carving a sinuous lifeline through the inky landscape. The magma itself becomes the sole source of light, tinting the thick ash plume an ominous orange-red, creating an atmosphere both awe-inspiring and imbued with a primal, destructive force.", + "seed": 12858, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_14/index_6594_seed_12858_dp_29_rank_58_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.10590303987264633, + "vlm_logprob": -0.10590303987264633, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.7, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.10590303987264633, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at night on a rugged black volcano?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a wide viscous stream of molten rock cascading from fissures on the volcano?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the molten rock stream transition from a white-hot center to a deep blood-red rim?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pull out to reveal the magma stream as the dominant light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the magma stream shown initially diverging into tributaries before converging into a broad main stream?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00913488119840622 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.134134769439697 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00913488119840622, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00913488119840622, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21124139428138733, + 0.09909771382808685, + 0.05481782555580139, + 0.09523268789052963, + 0.05687196925282478, + 0.10269051790237427, + 0.027967168018221855, + 0.11425279825925827, + 0.09091133624315262, + 0.14691656827926636 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00913488119840622 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at night on a rugged black volcano?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a wide viscous stream of molten rock cascading from fissures on the volcano?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the molten rock stream transition from a white-hot center to a deep blood-red rim?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pull out to reveal the magma stream as the dominant light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the magma stream shown initially diverging into tributaries before converging into a broad main stream?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00866522267460823 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758665084838867 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00866522267460823, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00866522267460823, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2049781233072281, + 0.11025051772594452, + 0.03681624308228493, + 0.045791786164045334, + 0.07436589151620865, + 0.08035094290971756, + 0.04487823322415352, + 0.0705961361527443, + 0.08458077162504196, + 0.24739143252372742 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00866522267460823 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at night on a rugged black volcano?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a wide viscous stream of molten rock cascading from fissures on the volcano?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the molten rock stream transition from a white-hot center to a deep blood-red rim?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pull out to reveal the magma stream as the dominant light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the magma stream shown initially diverging into tributaries before converging into a broad main stream?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011088063940405846 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511087894439697 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011088063940405846, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011088063940405846, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1958373486995697, + 0.16983455419540405, + 0.08564108610153198, + 0.06279387325048447, + 0.052701435983181, + 0.0901608020067215, + 0.06512990593910217, + 0.04436061158776283, + 0.0514514222741127, + 0.18208900094032288 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011088063940405846 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at night on a rugged black volcano?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a wide viscous stream of molten rock cascading from fissures on the volcano?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the molten rock stream transition from a white-hot center to a deep blood-red rim?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pull out to reveal the magma stream as the dominant light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the magma stream shown initially diverging into tributaries before converging into a broad main stream?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026350608095526695 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651350498199463 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026350608095526695, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026350608095526695, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09000412374734879, + 0.04387155547738075, + 0.06279061734676361, + 0.06626217067241669, + 0.07458532601594925, + 0.15399615466594696, + 0.029759416356682777, + 0.11391571909189224, + 0.039779942482709885, + 0.3250349462032318 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026350608095526695 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at night on a rugged black volcano?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a wide viscous stream of molten rock cascading from fissures on the volcano?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the molten rock stream transition from a white-hot center to a deep blood-red rim?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pull out to reveal the magma stream as the dominant light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the magma stream shown initially diverging into tributaries before converging into a broad main stream?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.47427642345428467 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9742764234542847 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.47427642345428467, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.47427642345428467, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18655911087989807, + 0.12103738635778427, + 0.041035834699869156, + 0.04537989944219589, + 0.0487423874437809, + 0.09405376762151718, + 0.09805364161729813, + 0.05631856620311737, + 0.11028434336185455, + 0.1985349953174591 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.47427642345428467 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An epic, aerial drone shot captures a wide, viscous stream of molten rock, cascading from fissures atop a rugged, black volcano, against the backdrop of deep night. This stream of molten rock cascades from a dazzling white-hot center to a deep, blood-red rim, its surface roiling and bubbling, its intense heat sending ripples of distortion through the air. With a slow, inexorable flow, it initially diverges into intertwining tributaries that cling to the dark mountain like vast, luminous roots, before gradually converging into a broad, main stream. As the camera slowly pulls out, the image becomes dominated by this magnificent, flaming river, carving a sinuous lifeline through the inky landscape. The magma itself becomes the sole source of light, tinting the thick ash plume an ominous orange-red, creating an atmosphere both awe-inspiring and imbued with a primal, destructive force.", + "seed": 12859, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_14/index_6594_seed_12859_dp_29_rank_58_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.17467475347220898, + "vlm_logprob": -0.17467475347220898, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.1, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.17467475347220898, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at night on a rugged black volcano?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a wide viscous stream of molten rock cascading from fissures on the volcano?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the molten rock stream transition from a white-hot center to a deep blood-red rim?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pull out to reveal the magma stream as the dominant light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the magma stream shown initially diverging into tributaries before converging into a broad main stream?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04209647327661514 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2920963764190674 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04209647327661514, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04209647327661514, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3119334876537323, + 0.10222858190536499, + 0.12773115932941437, + 0.12130391597747803, + 0.06403833627700806, + 0.04031149670481682, + 0.07113274186849594, + 0.08446116000413895, + 0.039718836545944214, + 0.03714030981063843 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04209647327661514 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at night on a rugged black volcano?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a wide viscous stream of molten rock cascading from fissures on the volcano?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the molten rock stream transition from a white-hot center to a deep blood-red rim?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pull out to reveal the magma stream as the dominant light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the magma stream shown initially diverging into tributaries before converging into a broad main stream?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012563606724143028 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387563705444336 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012563606724143028, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012563606724143028, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1391913741827011, + 0.04698346555233002, + 0.09502764046192169, + 0.1078854575753212, + 0.09473372995853424, + 0.14371754229068756, + 0.04096721485257149, + 0.08640021830797195, + 0.17790447175502777, + 0.06718893349170685 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012563606724143028 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at night on a rugged black volcano?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a wide viscous stream of molten rock cascading from fissures on the volcano?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the molten rock stream transition from a white-hot center to a deep blood-red rim?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pull out to reveal the magma stream as the dominant light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the magma stream shown initially diverging into tributaries before converging into a broad main stream?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005957465618848801 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.13095760345459 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005957465618848801, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005957465618848801, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14851821959018707, + 0.08551282435655594, + 0.1496000736951828, + 0.05589716508984566, + 0.04003813862800598, + 0.08308685570955276, + 0.1114986389875412, + 0.2572784423828125, + 0.038871463388204575, + 0.029698152095079422 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005957465618848801 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at night on a rugged black volcano?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a wide viscous stream of molten rock cascading from fissures on the volcano?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the molten rock stream transition from a white-hot center to a deep blood-red rim?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pull out to reveal the magma stream as the dominant light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the magma stream shown initially diverging into tributaries before converging into a broad main stream?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05496106669306755 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299609661102295 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05496106669306755, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05496106669306755, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08936870843172073, + 0.03447948023676872, + 0.07377226650714874, + 0.05078667774796486, + 0.09017989784479141, + 0.45929741859436035, + 0.09546725451946259, + 0.04038206487894058, + 0.045922521501779556, + 0.02034364454448223 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05496106669306755 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at night on a rugged black volcano?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a wide viscous stream of molten rock cascading from fissures on the volcano?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the molten rock stream transition from a white-hot center to a deep blood-red rim?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pull out to reveal the magma stream as the dominant light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the magma stream shown initially diverging into tributaries before converging into a broad main stream?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7577951550483704 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6327951550483704 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.7577951550483704, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.7577951550483704, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1198456659913063, + 0.04348994418978691, + 0.03449215739965439, + 0.02918974682688713, + 0.1139260083436966, + 0.2001424878835678, + 0.05633123964071274, + 0.09182168543338776, + 0.2591227889060974, + 0.05163829028606415 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.7577951550483704 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_15/index_tensor([1061, 1061])_group_15_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_15/index_tensor([1061, 1061])_group_15_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..4136818c45900573f9b578939931b99c1c8d640e --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_15/index_tensor([1061, 1061])_group_15_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "low-angle, dynamic tracking shot, filmed from the side, follows an ancient, massive bronze chariot, ablaze with ghostly blue flames, as it soars at breathtaking speed across a vast, bottomless chasm. Shrouded in dusk, thin mist lingers across the canyon. The chariot's body, intricately carved with war and mythological totems, is engulfed in a shimmering blue flame, emitting no smoke and stretching backward in a fiery wake as it soars. At that moment, the chariot's massive bronze wheels rub violently against a sharp rock protruding from the canyon's edge, instantly unleashing a series of dazzling orange-yellow sparks. These sparks, like lightning, pierce the darkness, clearly illuminating the rough texture of the rock and the ancient inscriptions on the chariot's wheel hubs. The striking contrast between the cool blue halo and the fiery orange-yellow sparks creates an atmosphere of epic mythical grandeur, power, and danger.", + "seed": 10633, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_15/index_1061_seed_10633_dp_30_rank_60_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.12768697077408434, + "vlm_logprob": -0.12768697077408434, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.55, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.12768697077408434, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an ancient, massive bronze chariot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the chariot engulfed in ghostly blue flames that emit no smoke?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the chariot rub against a sharp rock, creating orange-yellow sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the sparks illuminating rough rock texture and ancient inscriptions on the wheel hubs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot filmed from a low-angle, dynamic tracking perspective from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5778272151947021 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8278272151947021 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5778272151947021, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5778272151947021, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08420558273792267, + 0.042185816913843155, + 0.15535029768943787, + 0.23714293539524078, + 0.13188454508781433, + 0.07797645777463913, + 0.07989375293254852, + 0.054274965077638626, + 0.0769936740398407, + 0.060092050582170486 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5778272151947021 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an ancient, massive bronze chariot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the chariot engulfed in ghostly blue flames that emit no smoke?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the chariot rub against a sharp rock, creating orange-yellow sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the sparks illuminating rough rock texture and ancient inscriptions on the wheel hubs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot filmed from a low-angle, dynamic tracking perspective from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023333610966801643 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7733335494995117 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023333610966801643, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023333610966801643, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08033319562673569, + 0.13894762098789215, + 0.2076845020055771, + 0.06589387357234955, + 0.06991327553987503, + 0.06812427192926407, + 0.09812241047620773, + 0.07293707132339478, + 0.06336766481399536, + 0.13467611372470856 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023333610966801643 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an ancient, massive bronze chariot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the chariot engulfed in ghostly blue flames that emit no smoke?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the chariot rub against a sharp rock, creating orange-yellow sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the sparks illuminating rough rock texture and ancient inscriptions on the wheel hubs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot filmed from a low-angle, dynamic tracking perspective from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0206122025847435 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8956122398376465 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0206122025847435, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0206122025847435, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10993282496929169, + 0.08101864904165268, + 0.04920005053281784, + 0.035766009241342545, + 0.04267910122871399, + 0.046108778566122055, + 0.2232806235551834, + 0.08583340048789978, + 0.08667311817407608, + 0.23950743675231934 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0206122025847435 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an ancient, massive bronze chariot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the chariot engulfed in ghostly blue flames that emit no smoke?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the chariot rub against a sharp rock, creating orange-yellow sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the sparks illuminating rough rock texture and ancient inscriptions on the wheel hubs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot filmed from a low-angle, dynamic tracking perspective from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012565136887133121 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.3875651359558105 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012565136887133121, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012565136887133121, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10376862436532974, + 0.06242278218269348, + 0.09917471557855606, + 0.10506876558065414, + 0.09064707159996033, + 0.08611907064914703, + 0.13211938738822937, + 0.03833172842860222, + 0.09297141432762146, + 0.18937642872333527 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012565136887133121 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an ancient, massive bronze chariot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the chariot engulfed in ghostly blue flames that emit no smoke?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the chariot rub against a sharp rock, creating orange-yellow sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the sparks illuminating rough rock texture and ancient inscriptions on the wheel hubs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot filmed from a low-angle, dynamic tracking perspective from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004096688237041235 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504096508026123 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004096688237041235, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004096688237041235, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08258204162120819, + 0.08108820766210556, + 0.049915850162506104, + 0.15974454581737518, + 0.2558143138885498, + 0.09247852116823196, + 0.062294598668813705, + 0.07073749601840973, + 0.047477032989263535, + 0.09786734730005264 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004096688237041235 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, dynamic tracking shot, filmed from the side, follows an ancient, massive bronze chariot, ablaze with ghostly blue flames, as it soars at breathtaking speed across a vast, bottomless chasm. Shrouded in dusk, thin mist lingers across the canyon. The chariot's body, intricately carved with war and mythological totems, is engulfed in a shimmering blue flame, emitting no smoke and stretching backward in a fiery wake as it soars. At that moment, the chariot's massive bronze wheels rub violently against a sharp rock protruding from the canyon's edge, instantly unleashing a series of dazzling orange-yellow sparks. These sparks, like lightning, pierce the darkness, clearly illuminating the rough texture of the rock and the ancient inscriptions on the chariot's wheel hubs. The striking contrast between the cool blue halo and the fiery orange-yellow sparks creates an atmosphere of epic mythical grandeur, power, and danger.", + "seed": 10634, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_15/index_1061_seed_10634_dp_30_rank_60_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.06944197765551507, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06944197765551507, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.825, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06944197765551507, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an ancient, massive bronze chariot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the chariot engulfed in ghostly blue flames that emit no smoke?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the chariot rub against a sharp rock, creating orange-yellow sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the sparks illuminating rough rock texture and ancient inscriptions on the wheel hubs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot filmed from a low-angle, dynamic tracking perspective from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2821313440799713 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.407131314277649 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2821313440799713, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2821313440799713, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24812434613704681, + 0.1358448714017868, + 0.11150308698415756, + 0.03211646154522896, + 0.07050403207540512, + 0.02514233998954296, + 0.01878860965371132, + 0.19302481412887573, + 0.03933880850672722, + 0.12561261653900146 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2821313440799713 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an ancient, massive bronze chariot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the chariot engulfed in ghostly blue flames that emit no smoke?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the chariot rub against a sharp rock, creating orange-yellow sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the sparks illuminating rough rock texture and ancient inscriptions on the wheel hubs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot filmed from a low-angle, dynamic tracking perspective from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026381375268101692 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651381492614746 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026381375268101692, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026381375268101692, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0733189582824707, + 0.5189783573150635, + 0.03880266100168228, + 0.03768320381641388, + 0.03670370206236839, + 0.035335879772901535, + 0.02301858365535736, + 0.0873691514134407, + 0.017922747880220413, + 0.13086670637130737 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026381375268101692 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an ancient, massive bronze chariot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the chariot engulfed in ghostly blue flames that emit no smoke?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the chariot rub against a sharp rock, creating orange-yellow sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the sparks illuminating rough rock texture and ancient inscriptions on the wheel hubs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot filmed from a low-angle, dynamic tracking perspective from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029822157695889473 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298221111297607 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029822157695889473, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029822157695889473, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11640739440917969, + 0.12368477135896683, + 0.054759204387664795, + 0.03157307952642441, + 0.07496870309114456, + 0.021687878295779228, + 0.03042312152683735, + 0.37865614891052246, + 0.05115951970219612, + 0.11668020486831665 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029822157695889473 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an ancient, massive bronze chariot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the chariot engulfed in ghostly blue flames that emit no smoke?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the chariot rub against a sharp rock, creating orange-yellow sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the sparks illuminating rough rock texture and ancient inscriptions on the wheel hubs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot filmed from a low-angle, dynamic tracking perspective from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036237069871276617 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.6286234855651855 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036237069871276617, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036237069871276617, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1857205629348755, + 0.03523411974310875, + 0.04950687661767006, + 0.021893424913287163, + 0.06472478806972504, + 0.0343036875128746, + 0.023685909807682037, + 0.3978552222251892, + 0.052534300833940506, + 0.13454113900661469 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036237069871276617 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an ancient, massive bronze chariot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the chariot engulfed in ghostly blue flames that emit no smoke?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the chariot rub against a sharp rock, creating orange-yellow sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the sparks illuminating rough rock texture and ancient inscriptions on the wheel hubs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot filmed from a low-angle, dynamic tracking perspective from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005251304246485233 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255251407623291 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005251304246485233, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005251304246485233, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2725568413734436, + 0.04437562823295593, + 0.05274604260921478, + 0.04647712782025337, + 0.02799450419843197, + 0.023507962003350258, + 0.02082766219973564, + 0.41828653216362, + 0.045440446585416794, + 0.04778725281357765 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005251304246485233 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, dynamic tracking shot, filmed from the side, follows an ancient, massive bronze chariot, ablaze with ghostly blue flames, as it soars at breathtaking speed across a vast, bottomless chasm. Shrouded in dusk, thin mist lingers across the canyon. The chariot's body, intricately carved with war and mythological totems, is engulfed in a shimmering blue flame, emitting no smoke and stretching backward in a fiery wake as it soars. At that moment, the chariot's massive bronze wheels rub violently against a sharp rock protruding from the canyon's edge, instantly unleashing a series of dazzling orange-yellow sparks. These sparks, like lightning, pierce the darkness, clearly illuminating the rough texture of the rock and the ancient inscriptions on the chariot's wheel hubs. The striking contrast between the cool blue halo and the fiery orange-yellow sparks creates an atmosphere of epic mythical grandeur, power, and danger.", + "seed": 10635, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_15/index_1061_seed_10635_dp_31_rank_62_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.056294905859977006, + "vlm_logprob": -0.056294905859977006, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.475, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.056294905859977006, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an ancient, massive bronze chariot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the chariot engulfed in ghostly blue flames that emit no smoke?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the chariot rub against a sharp rock, creating orange-yellow sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the sparks illuminating rough rock texture and ancient inscriptions on the wheel hubs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot filmed from a low-angle, dynamic tracking perspective from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2533635199069977 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5033634901046753 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2533635199069977, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2533635199069977, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10082753002643585, + 0.10254593938589096, + 0.07434780150651932, + 0.13826489448547363, + 0.013971896842122078, + 0.03213798999786377, + 0.0698438510298729, + 0.08621140569448471, + 0.08978314697742462, + 0.2920655608177185 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2533635199069977 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an ancient, massive bronze chariot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the chariot engulfed in ghostly blue flames that emit no smoke?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the chariot rub against a sharp rock, creating orange-yellow sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the sparks illuminating rough rock texture and ancient inscriptions on the wheel hubs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot filmed from a low-angle, dynamic tracking perspective from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01608608104288578 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141086101531982 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01608608104288578, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01608608104288578, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07565091550350189, + 0.07733800262212753, + 0.04254372790455818, + 0.24112045764923096, + 0.0390331856906414, + 0.04318680241703987, + 0.03141886740922928, + 0.15750890970230103, + 0.05651789531111717, + 0.23568129539489746 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01608608104288578 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an ancient, massive bronze chariot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the chariot engulfed in ghostly blue flames that emit no smoke?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the chariot rub against a sharp rock, creating orange-yellow sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the sparks illuminating rough rock texture and ancient inscriptions on the wheel hubs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot filmed from a low-angle, dynamic tracking perspective from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.001518169417977333 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.501518249511719 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.001518169417977333, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.001518169417977333, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.02333115041255951, + 0.022301960736513138, + 0.02211923711001873, + 0.06443054974079132, + 0.007114788517355919, + 0.012901336885988712, + 0.02204105630517006, + 0.0793684795498848, + 0.015622993931174278, + 0.7307684421539307 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.001518169417977333 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an ancient, massive bronze chariot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the chariot engulfed in ghostly blue flames that emit no smoke?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the chariot rub against a sharp rock, creating orange-yellow sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the sparks illuminating rough rock texture and ancient inscriptions on the wheel hubs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot filmed from a low-angle, dynamic tracking perspective from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005259249359369278 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255259037017822 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005259249359369278, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005259249359369278, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06385928392410278, + 0.020704390481114388, + 0.02636980079114437, + 0.23113860189914703, + 0.02623189613223076, + 0.031986139714717865, + 0.07189388573169708, + 0.09990781545639038, + 0.04919879510998726, + 0.37870943546295166 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 3, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005259249359369278 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an ancient, massive bronze chariot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the chariot engulfed in ghostly blue flames that emit no smoke?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the chariot rub against a sharp rock, creating orange-yellow sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the sparks illuminating rough rock texture and ancient inscriptions on the wheel hubs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot filmed from a low-angle, dynamic tracking perspective from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0052475095726549625 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255247592926025 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0052475095726549625, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0052475095726549625, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03727041557431221, + 0.05453643575310707, + 0.0798291563987732, + 0.07114329934120178, + 0.01964581198990345, + 0.18602433800697327, + 0.11969713121652603, + 0.07861127704381943, + 0.1196548119187355, + 0.2335873246192932 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0052475095726549625 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, dynamic tracking shot, filmed from the side, follows an ancient, massive bronze chariot, ablaze with ghostly blue flames, as it soars at breathtaking speed across a vast, bottomless chasm. Shrouded in dusk, thin mist lingers across the canyon. The chariot's body, intricately carved with war and mythological totems, is engulfed in a shimmering blue flame, emitting no smoke and stretching backward in a fiery wake as it soars. At that moment, the chariot's massive bronze wheels rub violently against a sharp rock protruding from the canyon's edge, instantly unleashing a series of dazzling orange-yellow sparks. These sparks, like lightning, pierce the darkness, clearly illuminating the rough texture of the rock and the ancient inscriptions on the chariot's wheel hubs. The striking contrast between the cool blue halo and the fiery orange-yellow sparks creates an atmosphere of epic mythical grandeur, power, and danger.", + "seed": 10636, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_15/index_1061_seed_10636_dp_31_rank_62_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.05096204387955368, + "vlm_logprob": -0.05096204387955368, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.575, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.05096204387955368, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an ancient, massive bronze chariot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the chariot engulfed in ghostly blue flames that emit no smoke?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the chariot rub against a sharp rock, creating orange-yellow sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the sparks illuminating rough rock texture and ancient inscriptions on the wheel hubs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot filmed from a low-angle, dynamic tracking perspective from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22770144045352936 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6027014255523682 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.22770144045352936, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.22770144045352936, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24438895285129547, + 0.07440777868032455, + 0.07757590711116791, + 0.02360665239393711, + 0.2602267563343048, + 0.03372230753302574, + 0.05784099921584129, + 0.022330567240715027, + 0.12253805994987488, + 0.08336199074983597 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.22770144045352936 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an ancient, massive bronze chariot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the chariot engulfed in ghostly blue flames that emit no smoke?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the chariot rub against a sharp rock, creating orange-yellow sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the sparks illuminating rough rock texture and ancient inscriptions on the wheel hubs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot filmed from a low-angle, dynamic tracking perspective from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01821434497833252 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018214225769043 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01821434497833252, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01821434497833252, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.053346410393714905, + 0.057132281363010406, + 0.11583712697029114, + 0.026119938120245934, + 0.26597461104393005, + 0.08334182947874069, + 0.19815659523010254, + 0.033593710511922836, + 0.13373668491840363, + 0.0327608585357666 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01821434497833252 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an ancient, massive bronze chariot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the chariot engulfed in ghostly blue flames that emit no smoke?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the chariot rub against a sharp rock, creating orange-yellow sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the sparks illuminating rough rock texture and ancient inscriptions on the wheel hubs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot filmed from a low-angle, dynamic tracking perspective from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002499791095033288 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002499580383301 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002499791095033288, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002499791095033288, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04069328308105469, + 0.08640289306640625, + 0.04321584850549698, + 0.013373843394219875, + 0.05065116286277771, + 0.06955063343048096, + 0.022672906517982483, + 0.016692329198122025, + 0.5879414677619934, + 0.06880559772253036 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002499791095033288 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an ancient, massive bronze chariot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the chariot engulfed in ghostly blue flames that emit no smoke?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the chariot rub against a sharp rock, creating orange-yellow sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the sparks illuminating rough rock texture and ancient inscriptions on the wheel hubs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot filmed from a low-angle, dynamic tracking perspective from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0032014804892241955 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753201484680176 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0032014804892241955, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0032014804892241955, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09125813841819763, + 0.11302538216114044, + 0.06617431342601776, + 0.14087775349617004, + 0.10259909182786942, + 0.05702041834592819, + 0.06342169642448425, + 0.0611698180437088, + 0.2577190399169922, + 0.046734295785427094 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0032014804892241955 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an ancient, massive bronze chariot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the chariot engulfed in ghostly blue flames that emit no smoke?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the chariot rub against a sharp rock, creating orange-yellow sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the sparks illuminating rough rock texture and ancient inscriptions on the wheel hubs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot filmed from a low-angle, dynamic tracking perspective from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0031931623816490173 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753193378448486 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0031931623816490173, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0031931623816490173, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11113738268613815, + 0.06280004233121872, + 0.09801920503377914, + 0.0726638212800026, + 0.2424132525920868, + 0.12904562056064606, + 0.056134454905986786, + 0.02661954239010811, + 0.05472670868039131, + 0.14643993973731995 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0031931623816490173 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_2/index_tensor([6516, 6516])_group_2_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_2/index_tensor([6516, 6516])_group_2_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..516283297e4a4cc30376b9d92617d917d5d98a3d --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_2/index_tensor([6516, 6516])_group_2_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "wide, static shot, shot from a level angle, captures the center of an empty circus tent. A single spotlight shines vertically from the soaring canvas dome, casting a bright circle of light on the sawdust-strewn floor, illuminating the surrounding rows of empty wooden benches and deep shadows. In the center of this luminous light, a performer in classic clown makeup—a large, exaggerated red smile framed by a pale base, with blue teardrop patterns adorning the corners of his eyes—wears a slightly askew, curly orange wig and pedals a unicycle that is comically small and contrasts sharply with his body. He wears a saturated, incongruous outfit: a loose, bright yellow silk shirt tied with a large blue and white striped bow at the collar, and baggy trousers held up by red suspenders, one leg adorned with white dots on a red background, the other with yellow stripes on a green background. He leans forward, his brows furrowed beneath the paint, beads of sweat oozing from his forehead. His legs pedal ferociously and clumsily, his entire body swaying violently with every jolt of the unicycle, his arms stretched out to the sides to maintain his precarious balance. Although the smile on his face remains constant, his focused and strained posture contrasts sharply with the vast emptiness around him, creating a surreal atmosphere that blends the comical, the poignant, and the obsessive.", + "seed": 25872, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_2/index_6516_seed_25872_dp_4_rank_8_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.03732746262103319, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03732746262103319, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.375, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03732746262103319, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a wide, static view from a level angle capturing the center of an empty circus tent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a single spotlight shining vertically from the dome, casting a bright circle on a sawdust-strewn floor with rows of empty wooden benches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the performer wearing classic clown makeup with a large red smile, pale base, and blue teardrop patterns, along with a curly orange wig?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the performer wearing a loose yellow silk shirt with a blue and white striped bow, baggy trousers with red suspenders, and mismatched patterned legs (one red with white dots, one green with yellow stripes)?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the performer pedaling a comically small unicycle with ferocious, clumsy motion while swaying violently to maintain balance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03901604935526848 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.289016008377075 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03901604935526848, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03901604935526848, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3787062466144562, + 0.06939196586608887, + 0.15624751150608063, + 0.057206738740205765, + 0.07919779419898987, + 0.08233427256345749, + 0.025911467149853706, + 0.01748800463974476, + 0.11720119416713715, + 0.016314851120114326 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03901604935526848 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a wide, static view from a level angle capturing the center of an empty circus tent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a single spotlight shining vertically from the dome, casting a bright circle on a sawdust-strewn floor with rows of empty wooden benches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the performer wearing classic clown makeup with a large red smile, pale base, and blue teardrop patterns, along with a curly orange wig?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the performer wearing a loose yellow silk shirt with a blue and white striped bow, baggy trousers with red suspenders, and mismatched patterned legs (one red with white dots, one green with yellow stripes)?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the performer pedaling a comically small unicycle with ferocious, clumsy motion while swaying violently to maintain balance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.048674196004867554 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486741065979004 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.048674196004867554, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.048674196004867554, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16879373788833618, + 0.06382452696561813, + 0.4919489622116089, + 0.056762680411338806, + 0.04543495550751686, + 0.034610211849212646, + 0.01839005947113037, + 0.025847943499684334, + 0.0695052295923233, + 0.02488166093826294 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.048674196004867554 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a wide, static view from a level angle capturing the center of an empty circus tent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a single spotlight shining vertically from the dome, casting a bright circle on a sawdust-strewn floor with rows of empty wooden benches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the performer wearing classic clown makeup with a large red smile, pale base, and blue teardrop patterns, along with a curly orange wig?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the performer wearing a loose yellow silk shirt with a blue and white striped bow, baggy trousers with red suspenders, and mismatched patterned legs (one red with white dots, one green with yellow stripes)?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the performer pedaling a comically small unicycle with ferocious, clumsy motion while swaying violently to maintain balance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029802603647112846 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298025608062744 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029802603647112846, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029802603647112846, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1227186992764473, + 0.02282765321433544, + 0.7166841626167297, + 0.01965799555182457, + 0.012624339200556278, + 0.027070827782154083, + 0.016513966023921967, + 0.029895858839154243, + 0.01579255610704422, + 0.016213906928896904 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029802603647112846 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a wide, static view from a level angle capturing the center of an empty circus tent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a single spotlight shining vertically from the dome, casting a bright circle on a sawdust-strewn floor with rows of empty wooden benches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the performer wearing classic clown makeup with a large red smile, pale base, and blue teardrop patterns, along with a curly orange wig?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the performer wearing a loose yellow silk shirt with a blue and white striped bow, baggy trousers with red suspenders, and mismatched patterned legs (one red with white dots, one green with yellow stripes)?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the performer pedaling a comically small unicycle with ferocious, clumsy motion while swaying violently to maintain balance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014202351681888103 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264202117919922 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014202351681888103, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014202351681888103, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09229610860347748, + 0.0357687771320343, + 0.6335339546203613, + 0.017863979563117027, + 0.01578548736870289, + 0.04380517825484276, + 0.03228021413087845, + 0.05105097219347954, + 0.04271689057350159, + 0.034898482263088226 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014202351681888103 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a wide, static view from a level angle capturing the center of an empty circus tent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a single spotlight shining vertically from the dome, casting a bright circle on a sawdust-strewn floor with rows of empty wooden benches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the performer wearing classic clown makeup with a large red smile, pale base, and blue teardrop patterns, along with a curly orange wig?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the performer wearing a loose yellow silk shirt with a blue and white striped bow, baggy trousers with red suspenders, and mismatched patterned legs (one red with white dots, one green with yellow stripes)?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the performer pedaling a comically small unicycle with ferocious, clumsy motion while swaying violently to maintain balance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.054942112416028976 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299421310424805 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.054942112416028976, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.054942112416028976, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1446545124053955, + 0.05670681223273277, + 0.4351828396320343, + 0.05633312091231346, + 0.02075294405221939, + 0.044738538563251495, + 0.082472063601017, + 0.07042784243822098, + 0.04692356288433075, + 0.04180782288312912 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.054942112416028976 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "wide, static shot, shot from a level angle, captures the center of an empty circus tent. A single spotlight shines vertically from the soaring canvas dome, casting a bright circle of light on the sawdust-strewn floor, illuminating the surrounding rows of empty wooden benches and deep shadows. In the center of this luminous light, a performer in classic clown makeup—a large, exaggerated red smile framed by a pale base, with blue teardrop patterns adorning the corners of his eyes—wears a slightly askew, curly orange wig and pedals a unicycle that is comically small and contrasts sharply with his body. He wears a saturated, incongruous outfit: a loose, bright yellow silk shirt tied with a large blue and white striped bow at the collar, and baggy trousers held up by red suspenders, one leg adorned with white dots on a red background, the other with yellow stripes on a green background. He leans forward, his brows furrowed beneath the paint, beads of sweat oozing from his forehead. His legs pedal ferociously and clumsily, his entire body swaying violently with every jolt of the unicycle, his arms stretched out to the sides to maintain his precarious balance. Although the smile on his face remains constant, his focused and strained posture contrasts sharply with the vast emptiness around him, creating a surreal atmosphere that blends the comical, the poignant, and the obsessive.", + "seed": 25873, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_2/index_6516_seed_25873_dp_4_rank_8_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.023876798525452613, + "vlm_logprob": -0.023876798525452613, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.925, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.023876798525452613, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a wide, static view from a level angle capturing the center of an empty circus tent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a single spotlight shining vertically from the dome, casting a bright circle on a sawdust-strewn floor with rows of empty wooden benches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the performer wearing classic clown makeup with a large red smile, pale base, and blue teardrop patterns, along with a curly orange wig?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the performer wearing a loose yellow silk shirt with a blue and white striped bow, baggy trousers with red suspenders, and mismatched patterned legs (one red with white dots, one green with yellow stripes)?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the performer pedaling a comically small unicycle with ferocious, clumsy motion while swaying violently to maintain balance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.024207260459661484 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.774207353591919 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.024207260459661484, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.024207260459661484, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5918155312538147, + 0.04619152471423149, + 0.14132213592529297, + 0.04166899248957634, + 0.04454759880900383, + 0.037991516292095184, + 0.0436415895819664, + 0.01946384459733963, + 0.023949870839715004, + 0.00940735638141632 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.024207260459661484 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a wide, static view from a level angle capturing the center of an empty circus tent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a single spotlight shining vertically from the dome, casting a bright circle on a sawdust-strewn floor with rows of empty wooden benches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the performer wearing classic clown makeup with a large red smile, pale base, and blue teardrop patterns, along with a curly orange wig?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the performer wearing a loose yellow silk shirt with a blue and white striped bow, baggy trousers with red suspenders, and mismatched patterned legs (one red with white dots, one green with yellow stripes)?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the performer pedaling a comically small unicycle with ferocious, clumsy motion while swaying violently to maintain balance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008652458898723125 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758652687072754 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008652458898723125, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008652458898723125, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.6006472706794739, + 0.08984771370887756, + 0.09429414570331573, + 0.03232625871896744, + 0.08205550909042358, + 0.02720172330737114, + 0.03029605560004711, + 0.014852830208837986, + 0.01946905441582203, + 0.009009351022541523 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008652458898723125 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a wide, static view from a level angle capturing the center of an empty circus tent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a single spotlight shining vertically from the dome, casting a bright circle on a sawdust-strewn floor with rows of empty wooden benches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the performer wearing classic clown makeup with a large red smile, pale base, and blue teardrop patterns, along with a curly orange wig?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the performer wearing a loose yellow silk shirt with a blue and white striped bow, baggy trousers with red suspenders, and mismatched patterned legs (one red with white dots, one green with yellow stripes)?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the performer pedaling a comically small unicycle with ferocious, clumsy motion while swaying violently to maintain balance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03369337320327759 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408693313598633 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03369337320327759, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03369337320327759, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3329160809516907, + 0.035076893866062164, + 0.22148752212524414, + 0.052558533847332, + 0.13982048630714417, + 0.06385630369186401, + 0.03525319695472717, + 0.017201950773596764, + 0.06979049742221832, + 0.03203855827450752 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03369337320327759 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a wide, static view from a level angle capturing the center of an empty circus tent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a single spotlight shining vertically from the dome, casting a bright circle on a sawdust-strewn floor with rows of empty wooden benches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the performer wearing classic clown makeup with a large red smile, pale base, and blue teardrop patterns, along with a curly orange wig?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the performer wearing a loose yellow silk shirt with a blue and white striped bow, baggy trousers with red suspenders, and mismatched patterned legs (one red with white dots, one green with yellow stripes)?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the performer pedaling a comically small unicycle with ferocious, clumsy motion while swaying violently to maintain balance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009782115928828716 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634782314300537 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009782115928828716, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009782115928828716, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.6282210946083069, + 0.03567684069275856, + 0.027574878185987473, + 0.04207858443260193, + 0.14086955785751343, + 0.03772703558206558, + 0.02447189949452877, + 0.017362646758556366, + 0.02390722557902336, + 0.02211027778685093 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009782115928828716 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a wide, static view from a level angle capturing the center of an empty circus tent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a single spotlight shining vertically from the dome, casting a bright circle on a sawdust-strewn floor with rows of empty wooden benches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the performer wearing classic clown makeup with a large red smile, pale base, and blue teardrop patterns, along with a curly orange wig?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the performer wearing a loose yellow silk shirt with a blue and white striped bow, baggy trousers with red suspenders, and mismatched patterned legs (one red with white dots, one green with yellow stripes)?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the performer pedaling a comically small unicycle with ferocious, clumsy motion while swaying violently to maintain balance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.043048784136772156 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168048858642578 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.043048784136772156, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.043048784136772156, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.48692259192466736, + 0.034259017556905746, + 0.07653576135635376, + 0.05073804408311844, + 0.13941244781017303, + 0.016637543216347694, + 0.050485339015722275, + 0.050269268453121185, + 0.039807457476854324, + 0.054932478815317154 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.043048784136772156 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "wide, static shot, shot from a level angle, captures the center of an empty circus tent. A single spotlight shines vertically from the soaring canvas dome, casting a bright circle of light on the sawdust-strewn floor, illuminating the surrounding rows of empty wooden benches and deep shadows. In the center of this luminous light, a performer in classic clown makeup—a large, exaggerated red smile framed by a pale base, with blue teardrop patterns adorning the corners of his eyes—wears a slightly askew, curly orange wig and pedals a unicycle that is comically small and contrasts sharply with his body. He wears a saturated, incongruous outfit: a loose, bright yellow silk shirt tied with a large blue and white striped bow at the collar, and baggy trousers held up by red suspenders, one leg adorned with white dots on a red background, the other with yellow stripes on a green background. He leans forward, his brows furrowed beneath the paint, beads of sweat oozing from his forehead. His legs pedal ferociously and clumsily, his entire body swaying violently with every jolt of the unicycle, his arms stretched out to the sides to maintain his precarious balance. Although the smile on his face remains constant, his focused and strained posture contrasts sharply with the vast emptiness around him, creating a surreal atmosphere that blends the comical, the poignant, and the obsessive.", + "seed": 25874, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_2/index_6516_seed_25874_dp_5_rank_10_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.0644077405333519, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0644077405333519, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.199999952316284, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0644077405333519, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a wide, static view from a level angle capturing the center of an empty circus tent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a single spotlight shining vertically from the dome, casting a bright circle on a sawdust-strewn floor with rows of empty wooden benches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the performer wearing classic clown makeup with a large red smile, pale base, and blue teardrop patterns, along with a curly orange wig?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the performer wearing a loose yellow silk shirt with a blue and white striped bow, baggy trousers with red suspenders, and mismatched patterned legs (one red with white dots, one green with yellow stripes)?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the performer pedaling a comically small unicycle with ferocious, clumsy motion while swaying violently to maintain balance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20290280878543854 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7029027938842773 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20290280878543854, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20290280878543854, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.32200998067855835, + 0.025858448818325996, + 0.20272837579250336, + 0.024980701506137848, + 0.030127236619591713, + 0.015149599872529507, + 0.01998494192957878, + 0.28907090425491333, + 0.028527015820145607, + 0.041562795639038086 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20290280878543854 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a wide, static view from a level angle capturing the center of an empty circus tent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a single spotlight shining vertically from the dome, casting a bright circle on a sawdust-strewn floor with rows of empty wooden benches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the performer wearing classic clown makeup with a large red smile, pale base, and blue teardrop patterns, along with a curly orange wig?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the performer wearing a loose yellow silk shirt with a blue and white striped bow, baggy trousers with red suspenders, and mismatched patterned legs (one red with white dots, one green with yellow stripes)?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the performer pedaling a comically small unicycle with ferocious, clumsy motion while swaying violently to maintain balance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03811921924352646 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288119316101074 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03811921924352646, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03811921924352646, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.32753878831863403, + 0.0821985974907875, + 0.1681997925043106, + 0.0321863628923893, + 0.054060567170381546, + 0.017741389572620392, + 0.014211641624569893, + 0.2361813187599182, + 0.03423647955060005, + 0.03344498947262764 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03811921924352646 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a wide, static view from a level angle capturing the center of an empty circus tent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a single spotlight shining vertically from the dome, casting a bright circle on a sawdust-strewn floor with rows of empty wooden benches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the performer wearing classic clown makeup with a large red smile, pale base, and blue teardrop patterns, along with a curly orange wig?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the performer wearing a loose yellow silk shirt with a blue and white striped bow, baggy trousers with red suspenders, and mismatched patterned legs (one red with white dots, one green with yellow stripes)?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the performer pedaling a comically small unicycle with ferocious, clumsy motion while swaying violently to maintain balance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018183909356594086 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018183708190918 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018183909356594086, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018183909356594086, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3417937159538269, + 0.06625817716121674, + 0.04265325143933296, + 0.13281044363975525, + 0.029221581295132637, + 0.08379271626472473, + 0.00950989406555891, + 0.22754156589508057, + 0.04719125106930733, + 0.01922745443880558 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018183909356594086 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a wide, static view from a level angle capturing the center of an empty circus tent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a single spotlight shining vertically from the dome, casting a bright circle on a sawdust-strewn floor with rows of empty wooden benches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the performer wearing classic clown makeup with a large red smile, pale base, and blue teardrop patterns, along with a curly orange wig?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the performer wearing a loose yellow silk shirt with a blue and white striped bow, baggy trousers with red suspenders, and mismatched patterned legs (one red with white dots, one green with yellow stripes)?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the performer pedaling a comically small unicycle with ferocious, clumsy motion while swaying violently to maintain balance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014197062700986862 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264196872711182 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014197062700986862, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014197062700986862, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3436753451824188, + 0.11800782382488251, + 0.03964811563491821, + 0.05992325395345688, + 0.023600341752171516, + 0.056686270982027054, + 0.028672652319073677, + 0.22523708641529083, + 0.024205002933740616, + 0.08034415543079376 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014197062700986862 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a wide, static view from a level angle capturing the center of an empty circus tent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a single spotlight shining vertically from the dome, casting a bright circle on a sawdust-strewn floor with rows of empty wooden benches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the performer wearing classic clown makeup with a large red smile, pale base, and blue teardrop patterns, along with a curly orange wig?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the performer wearing a loose yellow silk shirt with a blue and white striped bow, baggy trousers with red suspenders, and mismatched patterned legs (one red with white dots, one green with yellow stripes)?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the performer pedaling a comically small unicycle with ferocious, clumsy motion while swaying violently to maintain balance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04863570258021355 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048635721206665 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04863570258021355, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04863570258021355, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.29527074098587036, + 0.09576521068811417, + 0.12063433974981308, + 0.05305441841483116, + 0.07708122581243515, + 0.15345802903175354, + 0.03281893581151962, + 0.04377727583050728, + 0.045551251620054245, + 0.0825885757803917 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04863570258021355 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "wide, static shot, shot from a level angle, captures the center of an empty circus tent. A single spotlight shines vertically from the soaring canvas dome, casting a bright circle of light on the sawdust-strewn floor, illuminating the surrounding rows of empty wooden benches and deep shadows. In the center of this luminous light, a performer in classic clown makeup—a large, exaggerated red smile framed by a pale base, with blue teardrop patterns adorning the corners of his eyes—wears a slightly askew, curly orange wig and pedals a unicycle that is comically small and contrasts sharply with his body. He wears a saturated, incongruous outfit: a loose, bright yellow silk shirt tied with a large blue and white striped bow at the collar, and baggy trousers held up by red suspenders, one leg adorned with white dots on a red background, the other with yellow stripes on a green background. He leans forward, his brows furrowed beneath the paint, beads of sweat oozing from his forehead. His legs pedal ferociously and clumsily, his entire body swaying violently with every jolt of the unicycle, his arms stretched out to the sides to maintain his precarious balance. Although the smile on his face remains constant, his focused and strained posture contrasts sharply with the vast emptiness around him, creating a surreal atmosphere that blends the comical, the poignant, and the obsessive.", + "seed": 25875, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_2/index_6516_seed_25875_dp_5_rank_10_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.1381943043321371, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1381943043321371, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.025, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1381943043321371, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a wide, static view from a level angle capturing the center of an empty circus tent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a single spotlight shining vertically from the dome, casting a bright circle on a sawdust-strewn floor with rows of empty wooden benches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the performer wearing classic clown makeup with a large red smile, pale base, and blue teardrop patterns, along with a curly orange wig?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the performer wearing a loose yellow silk shirt with a blue and white striped bow, baggy trousers with red suspenders, and mismatched patterned legs (one red with white dots, one green with yellow stripes)?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the performer pedaling a comically small unicycle with ferocious, clumsy motion while swaying violently to maintain balance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5769309401512146 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8269309401512146 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5769309401512146, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5769309401512146, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22057820856571198, + 0.04963940754532814, + 0.07864923030138016, + 0.08746911585330963, + 0.0618768036365509, + 0.10730519145727158, + 0.20319408178329468, + 0.10157652199268341, + 0.043805159628391266, + 0.045906201004981995 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5769309401512146 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a wide, static view from a level angle capturing the center of an empty circus tent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a single spotlight shining vertically from the dome, casting a bright circle on a sawdust-strewn floor with rows of empty wooden benches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the performer wearing classic clown makeup with a large red smile, pale base, and blue teardrop patterns, along with a curly orange wig?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the performer wearing a loose yellow silk shirt with a blue and white striped bow, baggy trousers with red suspenders, and mismatched patterned legs (one red with white dots, one green with yellow stripes)?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the performer pedaling a comically small unicycle with ferocious, clumsy motion while swaying violently to maintain balance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05498114973306656 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929981231689453 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05498114973306656, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05498114973306656, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2119337022304535, + 0.11092470586299896, + 0.15877872705459595, + 0.049178436398506165, + 0.06612752377986908, + 0.08545948565006256, + 0.14324934780597687, + 0.10338256508111954, + 0.02754013054072857, + 0.04342534393072128 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05498114973306656 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a wide, static view from a level angle capturing the center of an empty circus tent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a single spotlight shining vertically from the dome, casting a bright circle on a sawdust-strewn floor with rows of empty wooden benches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the performer wearing classic clown makeup with a large red smile, pale base, and blue teardrop patterns, along with a curly orange wig?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the performer wearing a loose yellow silk shirt with a blue and white striped bow, baggy trousers with red suspenders, and mismatched patterned legs (one red with white dots, one green with yellow stripes)?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the performer pedaling a comically small unicycle with ferocious, clumsy motion while swaying violently to maintain balance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01818835735321045 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.0181884765625 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01818835735321045, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01818835735321045, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18631725013256073, + 0.11936046183109283, + 0.06336469948291779, + 0.05728543922305107, + 0.06173752248287201, + 0.15296997129917145, + 0.04470399394631386, + 0.20902304351329803, + 0.06340335309505463, + 0.04183419421315193 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01818835735321045 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a wide, static view from a level angle capturing the center of an empty circus tent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a single spotlight shining vertically from the dome, casting a bright circle on a sawdust-strewn floor with rows of empty wooden benches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the performer wearing classic clown makeup with a large red smile, pale base, and blue teardrop patterns, along with a curly orange wig?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the performer wearing a loose yellow silk shirt with a blue and white striped bow, baggy trousers with red suspenders, and mismatched patterned legs (one red with white dots, one green with yellow stripes)?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the performer pedaling a comically small unicycle with ferocious, clumsy motion while swaying violently to maintain balance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011079810559749603 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511079788208008 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011079810559749603, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011079810559749603, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19413812458515167, + 0.07205484807491302, + 0.060544054955244064, + 0.028537293896079063, + 0.12994468212127686, + 0.14986754953861237, + 0.09468302875757217, + 0.17179186642169952, + 0.06256020814180374, + 0.03587835654616356 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011079810559749603 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a wide, static view from a level angle capturing the center of an empty circus tent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a single spotlight shining vertically from the dome, casting a bright circle on a sawdust-strewn floor with rows of empty wooden benches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the performer wearing classic clown makeup with a large red smile, pale base, and blue teardrop patterns, along with a curly orange wig?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the performer wearing a loose yellow silk shirt with a blue and white striped bow, baggy trousers with red suspenders, and mismatched patterned legs (one red with white dots, one green with yellow stripes)?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the performer pedaling a comically small unicycle with ferocious, clumsy motion while swaying violently to maintain balance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02979126386344433 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5297913551330566 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02979126386344433, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02979126386344433, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1387806385755539, + 0.07960318773984909, + 0.05401211231946945, + 0.07364800572395325, + 0.048296499997377396, + 0.10540348291397095, + 0.2589091956615448, + 0.09780899435281754, + 0.051516782492399216, + 0.09202105551958084 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02979126386344433 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_3/index_tensor([3026, 3026])_group_3_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_3/index_tensor([3026, 3026])_group_3_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..799f04c3d65c5ebff36a8f77adde9c252b3f529d --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_3/index_tensor([3026, 3026])_group_3_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "close-up shot from an overhead angle focuses on the corner of a dark wood desk. A pair of young, knuckled hands, trembling slightly with excitement and nervousness, hover over a thick, textured, off-white envelope containing an acceptance letter. A soft, yellow desk lamp casts a soft, warm hue from the side, highlighting the intricately designed, gilded school emblem at the center, which gleams metallically in the light. As if performing a sacred ritual, the hands carefully touch the seal of the envelope. With steady, measured movements, they firmly tear open the seal and slowly extract the neatly folded white letter paper. The entire scene is bathed in warm tones, with light and shadow delicately framing every detail. A complex mix of breathless anticipation and the joy of impending revelation permeates the air, a private moment filled with hope and dreams captured with pinpoint precision.", + "seed": 22237, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_3/index_3026_seed_22237_dp_6_rank_12_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.00892598347272724, + "vlm_logprob": -0.00892598347272724, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 5.8, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.00892598347272724, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a close-up from an overhead angle focusing on the corner of a dark wood desk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of young, knuckled hands visible hovering over a thick, textured, off-white envelope?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a soft, yellow desk lamp casting a warm hue that highlights a gilded school emblem on the envelope?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the hands perform the action of tearing open the envelope seal and extracting a neatly folded white letter paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene bathed in warm tones with light and shadow delicately framing the details?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0031194856856018305 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.003119468688965 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0031194856856018305, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0031194856856018305, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14414085447788239, + 0.1456221491098404, + 0.11056171357631683, + 0.09508372843265533, + 0.043307121843099594, + 0.03753157705068588, + 0.03955044969916344, + 0.15858665108680725, + 0.09884844720363617, + 0.12676729261875153 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0031194856856018305 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a close-up from an overhead angle focusing on the corner of a dark wood desk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of young, knuckled hands visible hovering over a thick, textured, off-white envelope?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a soft, yellow desk lamp casting a warm hue that highlights a gilded school emblem on the envelope?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the hands perform the action of tearing open the envelope seal and extracting a neatly folded white letter paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene bathed in warm tones with light and shadow delicately framing the details?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005961849819868803 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130961894989014 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005961849819868803, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005961849819868803, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10840683430433273, + 0.06790722906589508, + 0.10790524631738663, + 0.022969834506511688, + 0.15674737095832825, + 0.153741717338562, + 0.04787549376487732, + 0.09373904019594193, + 0.08987420797348022, + 0.15083298087120056 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005961849819868803 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a close-up from an overhead angle focusing on the corner of a dark wood desk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of young, knuckled hands visible hovering over a thick, textured, off-white envelope?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a soft, yellow desk lamp casting a warm hue that highlights a gilded school emblem on the envelope?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the hands perform the action of tearing open the envelope seal and extracting a neatly folded white letter paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene bathed in warm tones with light and shadow delicately framing the details?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0015136463334783912 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.501513481140137 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0015136463334783912, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0015136463334783912, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16086135804653168, + 0.14671455323696136, + 0.06798526644706726, + 0.10359799861907959, + 0.06488416343927383, + 0.036517731845378876, + 0.10725855082273483, + 0.0988936498761177, + 0.09454630315303802, + 0.11874043196439743 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0015136463334783912 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a close-up from an overhead angle focusing on the corner of a dark wood desk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of young, knuckled hands visible hovering over a thick, textured, off-white envelope?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a soft, yellow desk lamp casting a warm hue that highlights a gilded school emblem on the envelope?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the hands perform the action of tearing open the envelope seal and extracting a neatly folded white letter paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene bathed in warm tones with light and shadow delicately framing the details?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03369441255927086 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4086945056915283 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03369441255927086, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03369441255927086, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07779490202665329, + 0.0760388895869255, + 0.03837563842535019, + 0.0481698215007782, + 0.02602529525756836, + 0.05466654896736145, + 0.052671901881694794, + 0.15523384511470795, + 0.17365390062332153, + 0.2973692715167999 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03369441255927086 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a close-up from an overhead angle focusing on the corner of a dark wood desk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of young, knuckled hands visible hovering over a thick, textured, off-white envelope?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a soft, yellow desk lamp casting a warm hue that highlights a gilded school emblem on the envelope?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the hands perform the action of tearing open the envelope seal and extracting a neatly folded white letter paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene bathed in warm tones with light and shadow delicately framing the details?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0003405229654163122 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -8.000340461730957 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0003405229654163122, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 8.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0003405229654163122, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13211070001125336, + 0.1256781965494156, + 0.13253599405288696, + 0.0616132952272892, + 0.11755822598934174, + 0.04071598872542381, + 0.062198903411626816, + 0.11062339693307877, + 0.05036453530192375, + 0.16660074889659882 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0003405229654163122 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up shot from an overhead angle focuses on the corner of a dark wood desk. A pair of young, knuckled hands, trembling slightly with excitement and nervousness, hover over a thick, textured, off-white envelope containing an acceptance letter. A soft, yellow desk lamp casts a soft, warm hue from the side, highlighting the intricately designed, gilded school emblem at the center, which gleams metallically in the light. As if performing a sacred ritual, the hands carefully touch the seal of the envelope. With steady, measured movements, they firmly tear open the seal and slowly extract the neatly folded white letter paper. The entire scene is bathed in warm tones, with light and shadow delicately framing every detail. A complex mix of breathless anticipation and the joy of impending revelation permeates the air, a private moment filled with hope and dreams captured with pinpoint precision.", + "seed": 22238, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_3/index_3026_seed_22238_dp_6_rank_12_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.011913763929624111, + "vlm_logprob": -0.011913763929624111, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 5.65, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.011913763929624111, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a close-up from an overhead angle focusing on the corner of a dark wood desk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of young, knuckled hands visible hovering over a thick, textured, off-white envelope?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a soft, yellow desk lamp casting a warm hue that highlights a gilded school emblem on the envelope?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the hands perform the action of tearing open the envelope seal and extracting a neatly folded white letter paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene bathed in warm tones with light and shadow delicately framing the details?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004533607978373766 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.629533767700195 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004533607978373766, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004533607978373766, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3195182979106903, + 0.095584437251091, + 0.05236672982573509, + 0.09331632405519485, + 0.056925222277641296, + 0.10949075222015381, + 0.061578165739774704, + 0.0906449630856514, + 0.05654902011156082, + 0.06402607262134552 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004533607978373766 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a close-up from an overhead angle focusing on the corner of a dark wood desk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of young, knuckled hands visible hovering over a thick, textured, off-white envelope?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a soft, yellow desk lamp casting a warm hue that highlights a gilded school emblem on the envelope?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the hands perform the action of tearing open the envelope seal and extracting a neatly folded white letter paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene bathed in warm tones with light and shadow delicately framing the details?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0046508475206792355 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379651069641113 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0046508475206792355, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0046508475206792355, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12607413530349731, + 0.06979434937238693, + 0.16682878136634827, + 0.10457773506641388, + 0.06482401490211487, + 0.07007534056901932, + 0.06930156797170639, + 0.08397872000932693, + 0.14081592857837677, + 0.10372938960790634 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0046508475206792355 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a close-up from an overhead angle focusing on the corner of a dark wood desk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of young, knuckled hands visible hovering over a thick, textured, off-white envelope?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a soft, yellow desk lamp casting a warm hue that highlights a gilded school emblem on the envelope?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the hands perform the action of tearing open the envelope seal and extracting a neatly folded white letter paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene bathed in warm tones with light and shadow delicately framing the details?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0011781663633883 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.75117826461792 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0011781663633883, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0011781663633883, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19118070602416992, + 0.07512914389371872, + 0.18739815056324005, + 0.36145052313804626, + 0.044628433883190155, + 0.016133081167936325, + 0.016229793429374695, + 0.02186773717403412, + 0.046873174607753754, + 0.039109278470277786 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0011781663633883 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a close-up from an overhead angle focusing on the corner of a dark wood desk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of young, knuckled hands visible hovering over a thick, textured, off-white envelope?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a soft, yellow desk lamp casting a warm hue that highlights a gilded school emblem on the envelope?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the hands perform the action of tearing open the envelope seal and extracting a neatly folded white letter paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene bathed in warm tones with light and shadow delicately framing the details?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04864773899316788 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.04864764213562 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04864773899316788, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04864773899316788, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07077377289533615, + 0.03525804728269577, + 0.12165936082601547, + 0.15872400999069214, + 0.054715707898139954, + 0.0664432942867279, + 0.03921465575695038, + 0.06510832905769348, + 0.16325441002845764, + 0.22484846413135529 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04864773899316788 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a close-up from an overhead angle focusing on the corner of a dark wood desk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of young, knuckled hands visible hovering over a thick, textured, off-white envelope?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a soft, yellow desk lamp casting a warm hue that highlights a gilded school emblem on the envelope?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the hands perform the action of tearing open the envelope seal and extracting a neatly folded white letter paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene bathed in warm tones with light and shadow delicately framing the details?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0005584587925113738 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.500558376312256 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0005584587925113738, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0005584587925113738, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2271742820739746, + 0.051407765597105026, + 0.0726175457239151, + 0.09955952316522598, + 0.07038594037294388, + 0.0770195871591568, + 0.04416272044181824, + 0.08819001168012619, + 0.08896853774785995, + 0.1805141270160675 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0005584587925113738 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up shot from an overhead angle focuses on the corner of a dark wood desk. A pair of young, knuckled hands, trembling slightly with excitement and nervousness, hover over a thick, textured, off-white envelope containing an acceptance letter. A soft, yellow desk lamp casts a soft, warm hue from the side, highlighting the intricately designed, gilded school emblem at the center, which gleams metallically in the light. As if performing a sacred ritual, the hands carefully touch the seal of the envelope. With steady, measured movements, they firmly tear open the seal and slowly extract the neatly folded white letter paper. The entire scene is bathed in warm tones, with light and shadow delicately framing every detail. A complex mix of breathless anticipation and the joy of impending revelation permeates the air, a private moment filled with hope and dreams captured with pinpoint precision.", + "seed": 22239, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_3/index_3026_seed_22239_dp_7_rank_14_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.03405797338346019, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03405797338346019, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.8, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03405797338346019, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a close-up from an overhead angle focusing on the corner of a dark wood desk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of young, knuckled hands visible hovering over a thick, textured, off-white envelope?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a soft, yellow desk lamp casting a warm hue that highlights a gilded school emblem on the envelope?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the hands perform the action of tearing open the envelope seal and extracting a neatly folded white letter paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene bathed in warm tones with light and shadow delicately framing the details?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008072134107351303 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.0080718994140625 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008072134107351303, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008072134107351303, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14675945043563843, + 0.05685194581747055, + 0.06379731744527817, + 0.032447218894958496, + 0.14104758203029633, + 0.08147791773080826, + 0.24185432493686676, + 0.036626823246479034, + 0.13440151512622833, + 0.06473587453365326 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008072134107351303 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a close-up from an overhead angle focusing on the corner of a dark wood desk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of young, knuckled hands visible hovering over a thick, textured, off-white envelope?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a soft, yellow desk lamp casting a warm hue that highlights a gilded school emblem on the envelope?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the hands perform the action of tearing open the envelope seal and extracting a neatly folded white letter paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene bathed in warm tones with light and shadow delicately framing the details?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01421281136572361 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264212608337402 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01421281136572361, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01421281136572361, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18839147686958313, + 0.07886046916246414, + 0.08979227393865585, + 0.06734394282102585, + 0.08478367328643799, + 0.2579423785209656, + 0.08286655694246292, + 0.03356477618217468, + 0.08858837932348251, + 0.027866076678037643 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01421281136572361 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a close-up from an overhead angle focusing on the corner of a dark wood desk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of young, knuckled hands visible hovering over a thick, textured, off-white envelope?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a soft, yellow desk lamp casting a warm hue that highlights a gilded school emblem on the envelope?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the hands perform the action of tearing open the envelope seal and extracting a neatly folded white letter paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene bathed in warm tones with light and shadow delicately framing the details?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00463933777064085 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379639148712158 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00463933777064085, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00463933777064085, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10854523628950119, + 0.07242248207330704, + 0.06680598109960556, + 0.030154677107930183, + 0.07779457420110703, + 0.3215174078941345, + 0.14675037562847137, + 0.04055464640259743, + 0.056229472160339355, + 0.07922514528036118 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00463933777064085 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a close-up from an overhead angle focusing on the corner of a dark wood desk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of young, knuckled hands visible hovering over a thick, textured, off-white envelope?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a soft, yellow desk lamp casting a warm hue that highlights a gilded school emblem on the envelope?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the hands perform the action of tearing open the envelope seal and extracting a neatly folded white letter paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene bathed in warm tones with light and shadow delicately framing the details?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1428050994873047 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0178050994873047 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1428050994873047, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1428050994873047, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1475764513015747, + 0.052306417375802994, + 0.03443610668182373, + 0.06735723465681076, + 0.170165553689003, + 0.24959316849708557, + 0.12533478438854218, + 0.05139922723174095, + 0.05302904546260834, + 0.04880194738507271 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1428050994873047 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a close-up from an overhead angle focusing on the corner of a dark wood desk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of young, knuckled hands visible hovering over a thick, textured, off-white envelope?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a soft, yellow desk lamp casting a warm hue that highlights a gilded school emblem on the envelope?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the hands perform the action of tearing open the envelope seal and extracting a neatly folded white letter paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene bathed in warm tones with light and shadow delicately framing the details?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0005604841862805188 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.500560283660889 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0005604841862805188, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0005604841862805188, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20575833320617676, + 0.06734781712293625, + 0.05042648687958717, + 0.025899995118379593, + 0.14885252714157104, + 0.11249630898237228, + 0.1342483013868332, + 0.038314469158649445, + 0.1000666469335556, + 0.11658907681703568 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0005604841862805188 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up shot from an overhead angle focuses on the corner of a dark wood desk. A pair of young, knuckled hands, trembling slightly with excitement and nervousness, hover over a thick, textured, off-white envelope containing an acceptance letter. A soft, yellow desk lamp casts a soft, warm hue from the side, highlighting the intricately designed, gilded school emblem at the center, which gleams metallically in the light. As if performing a sacred ritual, the hands carefully touch the seal of the envelope. With steady, measured movements, they firmly tear open the seal and slowly extract the neatly folded white letter paper. The entire scene is bathed in warm tones, with light and shadow delicately framing every detail. A complex mix of breathless anticipation and the joy of impending revelation permeates the air, a private moment filled with hope and dreams captured with pinpoint precision.", + "seed": 22240, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_3/index_3026_seed_22240_dp_7_rank_14_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.0065338780172169205, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0065338780172169205, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 5.375, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0065338780172169205, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a close-up from an overhead angle focusing on the corner of a dark wood desk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of young, knuckled hands visible hovering over a thick, textured, off-white envelope?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a soft, yellow desk lamp casting a warm hue that highlights a gilded school emblem on the envelope?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the hands perform the action of tearing open the envelope seal and extracting a neatly folded white letter paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene bathed in warm tones with light and shadow delicately framing the details?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0028254371136426926 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.0028252601623535 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0028254371136426926, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0028254371136426926, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21752460300922394, + 0.09449826925992966, + 0.05927135795354843, + 0.07505432516336441, + 0.08811985701322556, + 0.09504825621843338, + 0.11824887990951538, + 0.03675618767738342, + 0.04740391671657562, + 0.16807428002357483 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0028254371136426926 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a close-up from an overhead angle focusing on the corner of a dark wood desk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of young, knuckled hands visible hovering over a thick, textured, off-white envelope?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a soft, yellow desk lamp casting a warm hue that highlights a gilded school emblem on the envelope?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the hands perform the action of tearing open the envelope seal and extracting a neatly folded white letter paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene bathed in warm tones with light and shadow delicately framing the details?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004644795786589384 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379644870758057 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004644795786589384, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004644795786589384, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07378682494163513, + 0.07862386107444763, + 0.04136354848742485, + 0.026091089472174644, + 0.07469819486141205, + 0.04862532764673233, + 0.12279482930898666, + 0.015190454199910164, + 0.027136918157339096, + 0.491688996553421 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004644795786589384 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a close-up from an overhead angle focusing on the corner of a dark wood desk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of young, knuckled hands visible hovering over a thick, textured, off-white envelope?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a soft, yellow desk lamp casting a warm hue that highlights a gilded school emblem on the envelope?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the hands perform the action of tearing open the envelope seal and extracting a neatly folded white letter paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene bathed in warm tones with light and shadow delicately framing the details?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007626583334058523 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882626533508301 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007626583334058523, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007626583334058523, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4788070023059845, + 0.06044812127947807, + 0.04626234993338585, + 0.03496592119336128, + 0.01721443235874176, + 0.033989716321229935, + 0.012805040925741196, + 0.022951923310756683, + 0.02456977218389511, + 0.2679857313632965 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007626583334058523 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a close-up from an overhead angle focusing on the corner of a dark wood desk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of young, knuckled hands visible hovering over a thick, textured, off-white envelope?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a soft, yellow desk lamp casting a warm hue that highlights a gilded school emblem on the envelope?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the hands perform the action of tearing open the envelope seal and extracting a neatly folded white letter paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene bathed in warm tones with light and shadow delicately framing the details?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01606273651123047 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.1410627365112305 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01606273651123047, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01606273651123047, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04390186071395874, + 0.0320800319314003, + 0.01727142371237278, + 0.04459221288561821, + 0.027863260358572006, + 0.01614048331975937, + 0.03859708830714226, + 0.022320007905364037, + 0.07872292399406433, + 0.6785106658935547 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01606273651123047 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a close-up from an overhead angle focusing on the corner of a dark wood desk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of young, knuckled hands visible hovering over a thick, textured, off-white envelope?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a soft, yellow desk lamp casting a warm hue that highlights a gilded school emblem on the envelope?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the hands perform the action of tearing open the envelope seal and extracting a neatly folded white letter paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene bathed in warm tones with light and shadow delicately framing the details?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0015098373405635357 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.501509666442871 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0015098373405635357, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0015098373405635357, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17402775585651398, + 0.06293651461601257, + 0.05559425428509712, + 0.03396230563521385, + 0.03718254715204239, + 0.05024315416812897, + 0.03917736932635307, + 0.02617989107966423, + 0.03827262669801712, + 0.4824236333370209 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0015098373405635357 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_4/index_tensor([4090, 4090])_group_4_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_4/index_tensor([4090, 4090])_group_4_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..106b56ba3f8ec8bf67e17228e05dbeff05129874 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_4/index_tensor([4090, 4090])_group_4_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "slightly high-angle, static, extreme close-up focuses on a single, thick, ivory pillar candle standing on a dark, indeterminate surface. Its solitary flame flickers with a warm orange glow, forming a small, translucent pool of melted wax around its blackened wick and casting deep, dancing shadows, creating an atmosphere of tranquility and peace. Suddenly, this tranquility is shattered by an unseen weight plummeting from above. The entire frame trembles chaotically under the violent impact, simulating the brutal force of the impact. In an instant, the candle's form collapses, its flame extinguished in a final, bright puff of smoke, and the molten wax erupts explosively, splashing outward in a radial burst of golden liquid lines and droplets against the dark background, capturing the moment of shocking, destructive transformation.", + "seed": 30473, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_4/index_4090_seed_30473_dp_8_rank_16_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.022405574470758437, + "vlm_logprob": -0.022405574470758437, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.375, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.022405574470758437, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a slightly high-angle static shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the framing an extreme close-up of a single thick ivory pillar candle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the candle have a blackened wick and a small pool of melted wax around it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show an unseen weight plummeting from above causing the frame to tremble chaotically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the candle collapse with its flame extinguished in a puff of smoke and molten wax erupting in a radial burst?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02137073315680027 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.021370887756348 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02137073315680027, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02137073315680027, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1395125389099121, + 0.056902918964624405, + 0.02741936966776848, + 0.0649460032582283, + 0.03205101937055588, + 0.24949543178081512, + 0.17386232316493988, + 0.11608342826366425, + 0.0600581131875515, + 0.07966885715723038 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02137073315680027 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a slightly high-angle static shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the framing an extreme close-up of a single thick ivory pillar candle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the candle have a blackened wick and a small pool of melted wax around it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show an unseen weight plummeting from above causing the frame to tremble chaotically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the candle collapse with its flame extinguished in a puff of smoke and molten wax erupting in a radial burst?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006747792940586805 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006747722625732 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006747792940586805, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006747792940586805, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12348267436027527, + 0.07099776715040207, + 0.055768776684999466, + 0.035451874136924744, + 0.02779802493751049, + 0.1810653805732727, + 0.32892972230911255, + 0.08131266385316849, + 0.058401111513376236, + 0.036791954189538956 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006747792940586805 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a slightly high-angle static shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the framing an extreme close-up of a single thick ivory pillar candle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the candle have a blackened wick and a small pool of melted wax around it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show an unseen weight plummeting from above causing the frame to tremble chaotically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the candle collapse with its flame extinguished in a puff of smoke and molten wax erupting in a radial burst?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.033716656267642975 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4087166786193848 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.033716656267642975, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.033716656267642975, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09519530087709427, + 0.04010457172989845, + 0.058760274201631546, + 0.04829844459891319, + 0.07615891844034195, + 0.18319493532180786, + 0.27084651589393616, + 0.11558642238378525, + 0.0512830875813961, + 0.0605715773999691 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.033716656267642975 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a slightly high-angle static shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the framing an extreme close-up of a single thick ivory pillar candle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the candle have a blackened wick and a small pool of melted wax around it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show an unseen weight plummeting from above causing the frame to tremble chaotically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the candle collapse with its flame extinguished in a puff of smoke and molten wax erupting in a radial burst?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04867975786328316 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048679828643799 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04867975786328316, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04867975786328316, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07055219262838364, + 0.022678399458527565, + 0.015104744583368301, + 0.022627422586083412, + 0.023114969953894615, + 0.0780523344874382, + 0.4471169412136078, + 0.21641768515110016, + 0.06034517660737038, + 0.04399006441235542 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04867975786328316 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a slightly high-angle static shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the framing an extreme close-up of a single thick ivory pillar candle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the candle have a blackened wick and a small pool of melted wax around it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show an unseen weight plummeting from above causing the frame to tremble chaotically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the candle collapse with its flame extinguished in a puff of smoke and molten wax erupting in a radial burst?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.001512932125478983 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.5015130043029785 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.001512932125478983, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.001512932125478983, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.047541625797748566, + 0.019154684618115425, + 0.011927610263228416, + 0.02489195391535759, + 0.022651929408311844, + 0.056373514235019684, + 0.48273351788520813, + 0.13911229372024536, + 0.14072252810001373, + 0.05489031970500946 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.001512932125478983 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slightly high-angle, static, extreme close-up focuses on a single, thick, ivory pillar candle standing on a dark, indeterminate surface. Its solitary flame flickers with a warm orange glow, forming a small, translucent pool of melted wax around its blackened wick and casting deep, dancing shadows, creating an atmosphere of tranquility and peace. Suddenly, this tranquility is shattered by an unseen weight plummeting from above. The entire frame trembles chaotically under the violent impact, simulating the brutal force of the impact. In an instant, the candle's form collapses, its flame extinguished in a final, bright puff of smoke, and the molten wax erupts explosively, splashing outward in a radial burst of golden liquid lines and droplets against the dark background, capturing the moment of shocking, destructive transformation.", + "seed": 30474, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_4/index_4090_seed_30474_dp_8_rank_16_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.11510878363624215, + "vlm_logprob": -0.11510878363624215, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.1, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.11510878363624215, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a slightly high-angle static shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the framing an extreme close-up of a single thick ivory pillar candle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the candle have a blackened wick and a small pool of melted wax around it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show an unseen weight plummeting from above causing the frame to tremble chaotically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the candle collapse with its flame extinguished in a puff of smoke and molten wax erupting in a radial burst?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11066507548093796 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3606650829315186 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11066507548093796, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11066507548093796, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06235991790890694, + 0.022743459790945053, + 0.017445117235183716, + 0.02198612317442894, + 0.08702141046524048, + 0.04530009627342224, + 0.4543561339378357, + 0.049264393746852875, + 0.20727093517780304, + 0.032252371311187744 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11066507548093796 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a slightly high-angle static shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the framing an extreme close-up of a single thick ivory pillar candle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the candle have a blackened wick and a small pool of melted wax around it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show an unseen weight plummeting from above causing the frame to tremble chaotically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the candle collapse with its flame extinguished in a puff of smoke and molten wax erupting in a radial burst?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00980218406766653 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634802341461182 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00980218406766653, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00980218406766653, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.021040674299001694, + 0.01277237944304943, + 0.0072461324743926525, + 0.008272795006632805, + 0.04935188591480255, + 0.022251984104514122, + 0.5037825703620911, + 0.09449486434459686, + 0.2613033354282379, + 0.019483419135212898 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00980218406766653 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a slightly high-angle static shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the framing an extreme close-up of a single thick ivory pillar candle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the candle have a blackened wick and a small pool of melted wax around it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show an unseen weight plummeting from above causing the frame to tremble chaotically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the candle collapse with its flame extinguished in a puff of smoke and molten wax erupting in a radial burst?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06207270920276642 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.81207275390625 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06207270920276642, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06207270920276642, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.027773145586252213, + 0.018813278526067734, + 0.02579313889145851, + 0.012164275161921978, + 0.044006723910570145, + 0.027930347248911858, + 0.5748456120491028, + 0.08514560759067535, + 0.15136414766311646, + 0.03216378018260002 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06207270920276642 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a slightly high-angle static shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the framing an extreme close-up of a single thick ivory pillar candle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the candle have a blackened wick and a small pool of melted wax around it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show an unseen weight plummeting from above causing the frame to tremble chaotically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the candle collapse with its flame extinguished in a puff of smoke and molten wax erupting in a radial burst?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3870560824871063 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1370561122894287 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3870560824871063, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3870560824871063, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03081194870173931, + 0.01656654290854931, + 0.009840679354965687, + 0.008424379862844944, + 0.07061825692653656, + 0.06666290014982224, + 0.4842132031917572, + 0.10129912942647934, + 0.17245569825172424, + 0.03910728171467781 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3870560824871063 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a slightly high-angle static shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the framing an extreme close-up of a single thick ivory pillar candle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the candle have a blackened wick and a small pool of melted wax around it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show an unseen weight plummeting from above causing the frame to tremble chaotically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the candle collapse with its flame extinguished in a puff of smoke and molten wax erupting in a radial burst?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005947866942733526 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130948066711426 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005947866942733526, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005947866942733526, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.013473591767251492, + 0.008848244324326515, + 0.005618771072477102, + 0.006708761211484671, + 0.05789552256464958, + 0.02612096443772316, + 0.5242899656295776, + 0.08771774172782898, + 0.2396717071533203, + 0.029654759913682938 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005947866942733526 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slightly high-angle, static, extreme close-up focuses on a single, thick, ivory pillar candle standing on a dark, indeterminate surface. Its solitary flame flickers with a warm orange glow, forming a small, translucent pool of melted wax around its blackened wick and casting deep, dancing shadows, creating an atmosphere of tranquility and peace. Suddenly, this tranquility is shattered by an unseen weight plummeting from above. The entire frame trembles chaotically under the violent impact, simulating the brutal force of the impact. In an instant, the candle's form collapses, its flame extinguished in a final, bright puff of smoke, and the molten wax erupts explosively, splashing outward in a radial burst of golden liquid lines and droplets against the dark background, capturing the moment of shocking, destructive transformation.", + "seed": 30475, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_4/index_4090_seed_30475_dp_9_rank_18_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.1429880746640265, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1429880746640265, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.325, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1429880746640265, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a slightly high-angle static shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the framing an extreme close-up of a single thick ivory pillar candle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the candle have a blackened wick and a small pool of melted wax around it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show an unseen weight plummeting from above causing the frame to tremble chaotically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the candle collapse with its flame extinguished in a puff of smoke and molten wax erupting in a radial burst?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03955257311463356 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.414552688598633 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03955257311463356, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03955257311463356, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1323591023683548, + 0.0447465181350708, + 0.027880946174263954, + 0.10711102187633514, + 0.05908490717411041, + 0.1289253979921341, + 0.2860473692417145, + 0.1090606227517128, + 0.06307199597358704, + 0.04171209782361984 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03955257311463356 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a slightly high-angle static shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the framing an extreme close-up of a single thick ivory pillar candle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the candle have a blackened wick and a small pool of melted wax around it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show an unseen weight plummeting from above causing the frame to tremble chaotically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the candle collapse with its flame extinguished in a puff of smoke and molten wax erupting in a radial burst?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0067553711123764515 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006755352020264 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0067553711123764515, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0067553711123764515, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20367707312107086, + 0.07847427576780319, + 0.04494762420654297, + 0.07768088579177856, + 0.050220657140016556, + 0.15672653913497925, + 0.14812590181827545, + 0.10813505947589874, + 0.06677277386188507, + 0.06523913890123367 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0067553711123764515 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a slightly high-angle static shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the framing an extreme close-up of a single thick ivory pillar candle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the candle have a blackened wick and a small pool of melted wax around it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show an unseen weight plummeting from above causing the frame to tremble chaotically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the candle collapse with its flame extinguished in a puff of smoke and molten wax erupting in a radial burst?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023310668766498566 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773310661315918 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023310668766498566, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023310668766498566, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1739010363817215, + 0.06464801728725433, + 0.08976753801107407, + 0.06027144566178322, + 0.11781388521194458, + 0.12646736204624176, + 0.08971281349658966, + 0.042220212519168854, + 0.153947114944458, + 0.08125060796737671 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023310668766498566 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a slightly high-angle static shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the framing an extreme close-up of a single thick ivory pillar candle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the candle have a blackened wick and a small pool of melted wax around it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show an unseen weight plummeting from above causing the frame to tremble chaotically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the candle collapse with its flame extinguished in a puff of smoke and molten wax erupting in a radial burst?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6327780485153198 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7577780485153198 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.6327780485153198, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.6327780485153198, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12359445542097092, + 0.029394900426268578, + 0.023079119622707367, + 0.027671800926327705, + 0.03987779840826988, + 0.2192011922597885, + 0.2914852499961853, + 0.09622872620820999, + 0.0720573142170906, + 0.07740950584411621 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.6327780485153198 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a slightly high-angle static shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the framing an extreme close-up of a single thick ivory pillar candle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the candle have a blackened wick and a small pool of melted wax around it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show an unseen weight plummeting from above causing the frame to tremble chaotically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the candle collapse with its flame extinguished in a puff of smoke and molten wax erupting in a radial burst?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012543711811304092 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387543678283691 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012543711811304092, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012543711811304092, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10517609119415283, + 0.024954790249466896, + 0.019001292064785957, + 0.03081783838570118, + 0.04115607216954231, + 0.14239473640918732, + 0.3657645285129547, + 0.12776021659374237, + 0.0869969055056572, + 0.05597755312919617 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012543711811304092 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slightly high-angle, static, extreme close-up focuses on a single, thick, ivory pillar candle standing on a dark, indeterminate surface. Its solitary flame flickers with a warm orange glow, forming a small, translucent pool of melted wax around its blackened wick and casting deep, dancing shadows, creating an atmosphere of tranquility and peace. Suddenly, this tranquility is shattered by an unseen weight plummeting from above. The entire frame trembles chaotically under the violent impact, simulating the brutal force of the impact. In an instant, the candle's form collapses, its flame extinguished in a final, bright puff of smoke, and the molten wax erupts explosively, splashing outward in a radial burst of golden liquid lines and droplets against the dark background, capturing the moment of shocking, destructive transformation.", + "seed": 30476, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_4/index_4090_seed_30476_dp_9_rank_18_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.03884054217487574, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03884054217487574, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.575, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03884054217487574, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a slightly high-angle static shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the framing an extreme close-up of a single thick ivory pillar candle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the candle have a blackened wick and a small pool of melted wax around it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show an unseen weight plummeting from above causing the frame to tremble chaotically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the candle collapse with its flame extinguished in a puff of smoke and molten wax erupting in a radial burst?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.038274578750133514 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4132745265960693 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.038274578750133514, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.038274578750133514, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0681532770395279, + 0.034834884107112885, + 0.04560006782412529, + 0.03976287320256233, + 0.06124423071742058, + 0.0994851291179657, + 0.4164014160633087, + 0.09599022567272186, + 0.10980576276779175, + 0.028722155839204788 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.038274578750133514 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a slightly high-angle static shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the framing an extreme close-up of a single thick ivory pillar candle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the candle have a blackened wick and a small pool of melted wax around it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show an unseen weight plummeting from above causing the frame to tremble chaotically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the candle collapse with its flame extinguished in a puff of smoke and molten wax erupting in a radial burst?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008655649609863758 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758655548095703 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008655649609863758, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008655649609863758, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09454389661550522, + 0.043343063443899155, + 0.03488336503505707, + 0.04790337011218071, + 0.0819530189037323, + 0.13328240811824799, + 0.33854106068611145, + 0.07714813947677612, + 0.0727076381444931, + 0.07569408416748047 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008655649609863758 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a slightly high-angle static shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the framing an extreme close-up of a single thick ivory pillar candle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the candle have a blackened wick and a small pool of melted wax around it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show an unseen weight plummeting from above causing the frame to tremble chaotically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the candle collapse with its flame extinguished in a puff of smoke and molten wax erupting in a radial burst?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026361754164099693 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513617038726807 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026361754164099693, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026361754164099693, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11081921309232712, + 0.04755478724837303, + 0.0418025441467762, + 0.06009797751903534, + 0.16297204792499542, + 0.12669387459754944, + 0.34758612513542175, + 0.04999756067991257, + 0.027870383113622665, + 0.02460552379488945 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026361754164099693 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a slightly high-angle static shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the framing an extreme close-up of a single thick ivory pillar candle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the candle have a blackened wick and a small pool of melted wax around it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show an unseen weight plummeting from above causing the frame to tremble chaotically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the candle collapse with its flame extinguished in a puff of smoke and molten wax erupting in a radial burst?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10032585263252258 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3503258228302 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10032585263252258, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10032585263252258, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.057557497173547745, + 0.03538477048277855, + 0.0207186471670866, + 0.03678128495812416, + 0.0308004692196846, + 0.15834400057792664, + 0.42999616265296936, + 0.12588681280612946, + 0.05577503889799118, + 0.048755303025245667 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10032585263252258 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a slightly high-angle static shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the framing an extreme close-up of a single thick ivory pillar candle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the candle have a blackened wick and a small pool of melted wax around it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show an unseen weight plummeting from above causing the frame to tremble chaotically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the candle collapse with its flame extinguished in a puff of smoke and molten wax erupting in a radial burst?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020584875717759132 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.89558482170105 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020584875717759132, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020584875717759132, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03354483097791672, + 0.028523266315460205, + 0.025410417467355728, + 0.025651609525084496, + 0.021456686779856682, + 0.14590363204479218, + 0.5706453919410706, + 0.03613542765378952, + 0.051725707948207855, + 0.061003074049949646 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020584875717759132 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_5/index_tensor([170, 170])_group_5_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_5/index_tensor([170, 170])_group_5_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..5365e51601ef22d02c6957fc7329c690983e9b66 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_5/index_tensor([170, 170])_group_5_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "static, eye-level medium shot captures a scene of profound tranquility, rendered in the ethereal style of classical ink painting. A magnificent black blade hangs horizontally, mere inches above the surface of perfectly still water, floating serenely. Its body, crafted from a material resembling polished black obsidian, absorbs the soft ambient light, imparting a deep matte finish. Intricate, enigmatic carvings, like ancient, fluid figures, are meticulously sculpted along the length of the blade, seemingly harboring a dormant energy. Beneath the enchanted weapon, the water is an undisturbed mirror, reflecting a hazy, gray-white void. From a point directly below the blade's tip, soft ripples expand outward, less like disturbed water than like delicate ink spread across rice paper; these concentric circles move with a slow, hypnotic grace, their feathered edges dissolving into the tranquil surface. The entire composition is defined by a heavily desaturated color grading, creating a monochromatic world of black, white, and infinite shades of gray, enhancing the minimalist atmosphere and evoking a powerful sense of calm and ancient power.", + "seed": 23160, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_5/index_170_seed_23160_dp_10_rank_20_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.37111049629747866, + "vlm_logprob": -0.37111049629747866, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.125000011920929, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.37111049629747866, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in the style of classical ink painting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a black blade hanging horizontally above a surface of still water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the blade have a matte finish with intricate carvings along its length?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are soft ripples expanding outward from directly below the blade's tip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color grading heavily desaturated, creating a monochromatic world of black, white, and gray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3135887384414673 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3135887384414673 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.3135887384414673, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -1.3135887384414673, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5351120829582214, + 0.09260603785514832, + 0.03589656576514244, + 0.06320957839488983, + 0.04385171830654144, + 0.025717541575431824, + 0.027502350509166718, + 0.060030363500118256, + 0.04699951782822609, + 0.06907420605421066 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.3135887384414673 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in the style of classical ink painting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a black blade hanging horizontally above a surface of still water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the blade have a matte finish with intricate carvings along its length?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are soft ripples expanding outward from directly below the blade's tip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color grading heavily desaturated, creating a monochromatic world of black, white, and gray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026384975761175156 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513850688934326 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026384975761175156, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026384975761175156, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5201573967933655, + 0.06133866682648659, + 0.03190929815173149, + 0.029836904257535934, + 0.06530874967575073, + 0.0637882798910141, + 0.02018466219305992, + 0.049897946417331696, + 0.058014240115880966, + 0.09956376254558563 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026384975761175156 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in the style of classical ink painting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a black blade hanging horizontally above a surface of still water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the blade have a matte finish with intricate carvings along its length?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are soft ripples expanding outward from directly below the blade's tip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color grading heavily desaturated, creating a monochromatic world of black, white, and gray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07901742309331894 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.579017400741577 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07901742309331894, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07901742309331894, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2505266070365906, + 0.13583560287952423, + 0.10099920630455017, + 0.07604942470788956, + 0.04068730026483536, + 0.03469020128250122, + 0.03314133733510971, + 0.19441650807857513, + 0.07018277049064636, + 0.06347102671861649 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07901742309331894 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in the style of classical ink painting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a black blade hanging horizontally above a surface of still water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the blade have a matte finish with intricate carvings along its length?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are soft ripples expanding outward from directly below the blade's tip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color grading heavily desaturated, creating a monochromatic world of black, white, and gray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4289202094078064 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.0539202690124512 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.4289202094078064, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.6250000596046448, + "token_credit_reward": -0.4289202094078064, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22481143474578857, + 0.09521256387233734, + 0.060586560517549515, + 0.05747058615088463, + 0.07630936056375504, + 0.12496791779994965, + 0.060916248708963394, + 0.05529706925153732, + 0.05463726818561554, + 0.18979093432426453 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.4289202094078064 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in the style of classical ink painting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a black blade hanging horizontally above a surface of still water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the blade have a matte finish with intricate carvings along its length?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are soft ripples expanding outward from directly below the blade's tip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color grading heavily desaturated, creating a monochromatic world of black, white, and gray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007641134783625603 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882641315460205 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007641134783625603, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007641134783625603, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4171912372112274, + 0.08417768031358719, + 0.050972867757081985, + 0.07256337255239487, + 0.06122425198554993, + 0.05683249235153198, + 0.02300403267145157, + 0.06476432830095291, + 0.050200361758470535, + 0.11906937509775162 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007641134783625603 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, eye-level medium shot captures a scene of profound tranquility, rendered in the ethereal style of classical ink painting. A magnificent black blade hangs horizontally, mere inches above the surface of perfectly still water, floating serenely. Its body, crafted from a material resembling polished black obsidian, absorbs the soft ambient light, imparting a deep matte finish. Intricate, enigmatic carvings, like ancient, fluid figures, are meticulously sculpted along the length of the blade, seemingly harboring a dormant energy. Beneath the enchanted weapon, the water is an undisturbed mirror, reflecting a hazy, gray-white void. From a point directly below the blade's tip, soft ripples expand outward, less like disturbed water than like delicate ink spread across rice paper; these concentric circles move with a slow, hypnotic grace, their feathered edges dissolving into the tranquil surface. The entire composition is defined by a heavily desaturated color grading, creating a monochromatic world of black, white, and infinite shades of gray, enhancing the minimalist atmosphere and evoking a powerful sense of calm and ancient power.", + "seed": 23161, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_5/index_170_seed_23161_dp_10_rank_20_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.062151990830898285, + "vlm_logprob": -0.062151990830898285, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.125, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.062151990830898285, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in the style of classical ink painting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a black blade hanging horizontally above a surface of still water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the blade have a matte finish with intricate carvings along its length?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are soft ripples expanding outward from directly below the blade's tip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color grading heavily desaturated, creating a monochromatic world of black, white, and gray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11415717005729675 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.239157199859619 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11415717005729675, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11415717005729675, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4380147457122803, + 0.2458779513835907, + 0.015869997441768646, + 0.10429717600345612, + 0.04757186770439148, + 0.031980276107788086, + 0.022449588403105736, + 0.06378986686468124, + 0.015208378434181213, + 0.014940152876079082 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11415717005729675 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in the style of classical ink painting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a black blade hanging horizontally above a surface of still water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the blade have a matte finish with intricate carvings along its length?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are soft ripples expanding outward from directly below the blade's tip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color grading heavily desaturated, creating a monochromatic world of black, white, and gray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016096755862236023 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141096591949463 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016096755862236023, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016096755862236023, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.254698246717453, + 0.40777456760406494, + 0.05836949124932289, + 0.07941413670778275, + 0.03825302794575691, + 0.022257577627897263, + 0.03660912066698074, + 0.05419224128127098, + 0.03224804997444153, + 0.016183558851480484 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016096755862236023 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in the style of classical ink painting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a black blade hanging horizontally above a surface of still water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the blade have a matte finish with intricate carvings along its length?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are soft ripples expanding outward from directly below the blade's tip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color grading heavily desaturated, creating a monochromatic world of black, white, and gray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11299654841423035 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2379965782165527 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11299654841423035, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11299654841423035, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2385362684726715, + 0.24443617463111877, + 0.033432818949222565, + 0.08517727255821228, + 0.036736734211444855, + 0.05474412441253662, + 0.028899887576699257, + 0.09340052306652069, + 0.11868651956319809, + 0.06594962626695633 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11299654841423035 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in the style of classical ink painting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a black blade hanging horizontally above a surface of still water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the blade have a matte finish with intricate carvings along its length?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are soft ripples expanding outward from directly below the blade's tip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color grading heavily desaturated, creating a monochromatic world of black, white, and gray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05495576187968254 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299557209014893 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05495576187968254, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05495576187968254, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3640443980693817, + 0.15629634261131287, + 0.028135474771261215, + 0.05098328739404678, + 0.07389036566019058, + 0.21046367287635803, + 0.028381967917084694, + 0.041746947914361954, + 0.03502042964100838, + 0.011037121526896954 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05495576187968254 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in the style of classical ink painting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a black blade hanging horizontally above a surface of still water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the blade have a matte finish with intricate carvings along its length?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are soft ripples expanding outward from directly below the blade's tip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color grading heavily desaturated, creating a monochromatic world of black, white, and gray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012553717941045761 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387553691864014 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012553717941045761, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012553717941045761, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4623657166957855, + 0.17119759321212769, + 0.02066710963845253, + 0.059870395809412, + 0.05428934469819069, + 0.040383681654930115, + 0.015284503810107708, + 0.07406682521104813, + 0.04922889173030853, + 0.052645958960056305 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012553717941045761 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, eye-level medium shot captures a scene of profound tranquility, rendered in the ethereal style of classical ink painting. A magnificent black blade hangs horizontally, mere inches above the surface of perfectly still water, floating serenely. Its body, crafted from a material resembling polished black obsidian, absorbs the soft ambient light, imparting a deep matte finish. Intricate, enigmatic carvings, like ancient, fluid figures, are meticulously sculpted along the length of the blade, seemingly harboring a dormant energy. Beneath the enchanted weapon, the water is an undisturbed mirror, reflecting a hazy, gray-white void. From a point directly below the blade's tip, soft ripples expand outward, less like disturbed water than like delicate ink spread across rice paper; these concentric circles move with a slow, hypnotic grace, their feathered edges dissolving into the tranquil surface. The entire composition is defined by a heavily desaturated color grading, creating a monochromatic world of black, white, and infinite shades of gray, enhancing the minimalist atmosphere and evoking a powerful sense of calm and ancient power.", + "seed": 23162, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_5/index_170_seed_23162_dp_11_rank_22_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.05624477630481124, + "vlm_logprob": -0.05624477630481124, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.7, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.05624477630481124, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in the style of classical ink painting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a black blade hanging horizontally above a surface of still water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the blade have a matte finish with intricate carvings along its length?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are soft ripples expanding outward from directly below the blade's tip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color grading heavily desaturated, creating a monochromatic world of black, white, and gray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.039096761494874954 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2890968322753906 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.039096761494874954, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.039096761494874954, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3271242678165436, + 0.10145788639783859, + 0.06589749455451965, + 0.12855246663093567, + 0.08173014968633652, + 0.06094755604863167, + 0.11750879138708115, + 0.022623633965849876, + 0.06679482758045197, + 0.027362944558262825 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.039096761494874954 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in the style of classical ink painting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a black blade hanging horizontally above a surface of still water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the blade have a matte finish with intricate carvings along its length?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are soft ripples expanding outward from directly below the blade's tip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color grading heavily desaturated, creating a monochromatic world of black, white, and gray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009802891872823238 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.63480281829834 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009802891872823238, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009802891872823238, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1437106877565384, + 0.2239178866147995, + 0.07635583728551865, + 0.2648784816265106, + 0.025963691994547844, + 0.1301218718290329, + 0.0376286543905735, + 0.025156693533062935, + 0.03046276606619358, + 0.04180345684289932 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009802891872823238 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in the style of classical ink painting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a black blade hanging horizontally above a surface of still water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the blade have a matte finish with intricate carvings along its length?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are soft ripples expanding outward from directly below the blade's tip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color grading heavily desaturated, creating a monochromatic world of black, white, and gray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07003781944513321 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695037841796875 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07003781944513321, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07003781944513321, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23103481531143188, + 0.36003464460372925, + 0.07111296057701111, + 0.1082412376999855, + 0.028452550992369652, + 0.04927463084459305, + 0.047713667154312134, + 0.02254447340965271, + 0.03743419051170349, + 0.04415688291192055 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07003781944513321 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in the style of classical ink painting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a black blade hanging horizontally above a surface of still water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the blade have a matte finish with intricate carvings along its length?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are soft ripples expanding outward from directly below the blade's tip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color grading heavily desaturated, creating a monochromatic world of black, white, and gray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.160345658659935 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9103456735610962 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.160345658659935, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.160345658659935, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23745808005332947, + 0.13705264031887054, + 0.10453581064939499, + 0.08298070728778839, + 0.09393077343702316, + 0.050188418477773666, + 0.04670543223619461, + 0.07538232207298279, + 0.11181379854679108, + 0.05995212495326996 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.160345658659935 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in the style of classical ink painting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a black blade hanging horizontally above a surface of still water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the blade have a matte finish with intricate carvings along its length?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are soft ripples expanding outward from directly below the blade's tip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color grading heavily desaturated, creating a monochromatic world of black, white, and gray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0019407500512897968 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.251940727233887 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0019407500512897968, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0019407500512897968, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.44536224007606506, + 0.10678541660308838, + 0.04673832282423973, + 0.1053277999162674, + 0.05590968579053879, + 0.06195546314120293, + 0.055695999413728714, + 0.02520802617073059, + 0.04937708377838135, + 0.04763996601104736 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0019407500512897968 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, eye-level medium shot captures a scene of profound tranquility, rendered in the ethereal style of classical ink painting. A magnificent black blade hangs horizontally, mere inches above the surface of perfectly still water, floating serenely. Its body, crafted from a material resembling polished black obsidian, absorbs the soft ambient light, imparting a deep matte finish. Intricate, enigmatic carvings, like ancient, fluid figures, are meticulously sculpted along the length of the blade, seemingly harboring a dormant energy. Beneath the enchanted weapon, the water is an undisturbed mirror, reflecting a hazy, gray-white void. From a point directly below the blade's tip, soft ripples expand outward, less like disturbed water than like delicate ink spread across rice paper; these concentric circles move with a slow, hypnotic grace, their feathered edges dissolving into the tranquil surface. The entire composition is defined by a heavily desaturated color grading, creating a monochromatic world of black, white, and infinite shades of gray, enhancing the minimalist atmosphere and evoking a powerful sense of calm and ancient power.", + "seed": 23163, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_5/index_170_seed_23163_dp_11_rank_22_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.07571685137227177, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07571685137227177, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.25, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07571685137227177, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in the style of classical ink painting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a black blade hanging horizontally above a surface of still water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the blade have a matte finish with intricate carvings along its length?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are soft ripples expanding outward from directly below the blade's tip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color grading heavily desaturated, creating a monochromatic world of black, white, and gray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07163182646036148 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.696631908416748 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07163182646036148, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07163182646036148, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2289462834596634, + 0.06276700645685196, + 0.04772872105240822, + 0.01938210055232048, + 0.04262048378586769, + 0.5124736428260803, + 0.017852503806352615, + 0.021206224337220192, + 0.02114073932170868, + 0.02588225156068802 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07163182646036148 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in the style of classical ink painting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a black blade hanging horizontally above a surface of still water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the blade have a matte finish with intricate carvings along its length?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are soft ripples expanding outward from directly below the blade's tip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color grading heavily desaturated, creating a monochromatic world of black, white, and gray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011105512268841267 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511105537414551 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011105512268841267, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011105512268841267, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3177604079246521, + 0.10340406745672226, + 0.037828098982572556, + 0.07414831221103668, + 0.13739871978759766, + 0.13254466652870178, + 0.07422477006912231, + 0.03468582034111023, + 0.05354708433151245, + 0.03445803374052048 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011105512268841267 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in the style of classical ink painting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a black blade hanging horizontally above a surface of still water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the blade have a matte finish with intricate carvings along its length?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are soft ripples expanding outward from directly below the blade's tip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color grading heavily desaturated, creating a monochromatic world of black, white, and gray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08904611319303513 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.464046001434326 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08904611319303513, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08904611319303513, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10663940757513046, + 0.07860404998064041, + 0.013968901708722115, + 0.0278652124106884, + 0.05657261610031128, + 0.6335698962211609, + 0.02164124883711338, + 0.016693348065018654, + 0.015512173064053059, + 0.028933096677064896 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08904611319303513 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in the style of classical ink painting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a black blade hanging horizontally above a surface of still water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the blade have a matte finish with intricate carvings along its length?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are soft ripples expanding outward from directly below the blade's tip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color grading heavily desaturated, creating a monochromatic world of black, white, and gray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.201543927192688 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.701543927192688 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.201543927192688, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.201543927192688, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03972857445478439, + 0.12028324604034424, + 0.03346022218465805, + 0.04157882556319237, + 0.06407985091209412, + 0.5774230360984802, + 0.035574182868003845, + 0.026827888563275337, + 0.02230641432106495, + 0.038737718015909195 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.201543927192688 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in the style of classical ink painting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a black blade hanging horizontally above a surface of still water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the blade have a matte finish with intricate carvings along its length?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are soft ripples expanding outward from directly below the blade's tip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color grading heavily desaturated, creating a monochromatic world of black, white, and gray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00525687774643302 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255256652832031 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00525687774643302, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00525687774643302, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11313160508871078, + 0.03399213030934334, + 0.015823213383555412, + 0.03473082557320595, + 0.05776682868599892, + 0.6727232336997986, + 0.01565113663673401, + 0.014798658899962902, + 0.022784143686294556, + 0.018598195165395737 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00525687774643302 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_6/index_tensor([7556, 7556])_group_6_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_6/index_tensor([7556, 7556])_group_6_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..35688f47e3e0159bd073e11294269746829852cc --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_6/index_tensor([7556, 7556])_group_6_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "Shot with the shaky, visceral movement of a handheld camera, low-angle shots slowly tilt upwards from a shattered, barren landscape, following the rise of a vast, surreal vortex that inexorably distorts the sky. This spiraling vortex is a chaotic amalgamation of melting clocks and stretched canvases; classic pocket watches with tarnished brass casings and luxurious clocks with dark wood frames twist and drip like hot wax, their numbered faces blurred as their hands droop lifelessly. Interwoven with this temporal decay are vast expanses of raw fiber canvas, stretched so tight they appear to tear, their pale, textured surfaces contrasting starkly against the viscous flow. The entire impossible structure is illuminated from within by solid, glassy tendrils of lightning, which emit a cold, inner glow as they snake through the vortex, casting sharp, crystalline highlights across its molten surface. Above, the sky itself roils in an unnatural, dancing aurora, its ever-shifting veil of sickly yellows, deep purples, and blood-reds creating a chaotic and malevolent celestial backdrop, completing a profoundly nightmarish vision, the erratic camerawork immersing the viewer directly into a waking dream of a decaying reality.", + "seed": 27041, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_6/index_7556_seed_27041_dp_12_rank_24_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.3630754415877163, + "vlm_logprob": -0.3630754415877163, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.925, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.3630754415877163, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot handheld with shaky movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low angle and slowly tilt upwards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central structure a vortex composed of melting clocks and stretched canvases?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the clocks depicted with tarnished brass casings and dark wood frames that appear to twist and drip like hot wax?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by solid, glassy tendrils of lightning emitting a cold inner glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.407268762588501 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2822687327861786 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.407268762588501, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -1.407268762588501, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1617712825536728, + 0.09419284760951996, + 0.04128505289554596, + 0.13599853217601776, + 0.3073567748069763, + 0.05905688554048538, + 0.06920275837182999, + 0.06251642107963562, + 0.033427171409130096, + 0.03519224748015404 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.407268762588501 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot handheld with shaky movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low angle and slowly tilt upwards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central structure a vortex composed of melting clocks and stretched canvases?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the clocks depicted with tarnished brass casings and dark wood frames that appear to twist and drip like hot wax?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by solid, glassy tendrils of lightning emitting a cold inner glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1271049529314041 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1271049976348877 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1271049529314041, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1271049529314041, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15646135807037354, + 0.08286464214324951, + 0.06601770222187042, + 0.066460981965065, + 0.16059841215610504, + 0.21899531781673431, + 0.0687006413936615, + 0.051641207188367844, + 0.10055229812860489, + 0.027707457542419434 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1271049529314041 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot handheld with shaky movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low angle and slowly tilt upwards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central structure a vortex composed of melting clocks and stretched canvases?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the clocks depicted with tarnished brass casings and dark wood frames that appear to twist and drip like hot wax?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by solid, glassy tendrils of lightning emitting a cold inner glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007640542928129435 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882640361785889 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007640542928129435, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007640542928129435, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24340470135211945, + 0.11021944135427475, + 0.12788435816764832, + 0.119724340736866, + 0.12647172808647156, + 0.052577439695596695, + 0.06113851070404053, + 0.061993759125471115, + 0.059253960847854614, + 0.037331774830818176 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007640542928129435 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot handheld with shaky movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low angle and slowly tilt upwards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central structure a vortex composed of melting clocks and stretched canvases?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the clocks depicted with tarnished brass casings and dark wood frames that appear to twist and drip like hot wax?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by solid, glassy tendrils of lightning emitting a cold inner glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11297515034675598 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2379751205444336 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11297515034675598, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11297515034675598, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24424338340759277, + 0.09318281710147858, + 0.11938556283712387, + 0.08067599684000015, + 0.17861297726631165, + 0.11330919712781906, + 0.051078911870718, + 0.03277258574962616, + 0.060275882482528687, + 0.026462754234671593 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11297515034675598 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot handheld with shaky movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low angle and slowly tilt upwards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central structure a vortex composed of melting clocks and stretched canvases?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the clocks depicted with tarnished brass casings and dark wood frames that appear to twist and drip like hot wax?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by solid, glassy tendrils of lightning emitting a cold inner glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1603877991437912 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9103877544403076 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1603877991437912, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1603877991437912, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1144712045788765, + 0.09233858436346054, + 0.12159185856580734, + 0.07919551432132721, + 0.0614958256483078, + 0.09947517514228821, + 0.09442472457885742, + 0.09535034745931625, + 0.10937218368053436, + 0.13228455185890198 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1603877991437912 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "Shot with the shaky, visceral movement of a handheld camera, low-angle shots slowly tilt upwards from a shattered, barren landscape, following the rise of a vast, surreal vortex that inexorably distorts the sky. This spiraling vortex is a chaotic amalgamation of melting clocks and stretched canvases; classic pocket watches with tarnished brass casings and luxurious clocks with dark wood frames twist and drip like hot wax, their numbered faces blurred as their hands droop lifelessly. Interwoven with this temporal decay are vast expanses of raw fiber canvas, stretched so tight they appear to tear, their pale, textured surfaces contrasting starkly against the viscous flow. The entire impossible structure is illuminated from within by solid, glassy tendrils of lightning, which emit a cold, inner glow as they snake through the vortex, casting sharp, crystalline highlights across its molten surface. Above, the sky itself roils in an unnatural, dancing aurora, its ever-shifting veil of sickly yellows, deep purples, and blood-reds creating a chaotic and malevolent celestial backdrop, completing a profoundly nightmarish vision, the erratic camerawork immersing the viewer directly into a waking dream of a decaying reality.", + "seed": 27042, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_6/index_7556_seed_27042_dp_12_rank_24_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.5861087342724204, + "vlm_logprob": -0.5861087342724204, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.45, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.5861087342724204, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.6, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot handheld with shaky movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low angle and slowly tilt upwards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central structure a vortex composed of melting clocks and stretched canvases?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the clocks depicted with tarnished brass casings and dark wood frames that appear to twist and drip like hot wax?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by solid, glassy tendrils of lightning emitting a cold inner glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4079688787460327 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2829689085483551 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.4079688787460327, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -1.4079688787460327, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14969606697559357, + 0.10798316448926926, + 0.11054565757513046, + 0.13642798364162445, + 0.1296648234128952, + 0.06822141259908676, + 0.04183971881866455, + 0.04638170823454857, + 0.145721435546875, + 0.06351805478334427 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.4079688787460327 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot handheld with shaky movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low angle and slowly tilt upwards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central structure a vortex composed of melting clocks and stretched canvases?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the clocks depicted with tarnished brass casings and dark wood frames that appear to twist and drip like hot wax?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by solid, glassy tendrils of lightning emitting a cold inner glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2236474752426147 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.34864750504493713 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.2236474752426147, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -1.2236474752426147, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1582772135734558, + 0.07177924364805222, + 0.045481231063604355, + 0.16766080260276794, + 0.0925290510058403, + 0.05600881204009056, + 0.04546300694346428, + 0.05644965171813965, + 0.27320268750190735, + 0.033148348331451416 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.2236474752426147 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot handheld with shaky movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low angle and slowly tilt upwards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central structure a vortex composed of melting clocks and stretched canvases?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the clocks depicted with tarnished brass casings and dark wood frames that appear to twist and drip like hot wax?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by solid, glassy tendrils of lightning emitting a cold inner glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008654586039483547 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758654594421387 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008654586039483547, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008654586039483547, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.228562593460083, + 0.041303034871816635, + 0.06305575370788574, + 0.14568109810352325, + 0.11392347514629364, + 0.11378838866949081, + 0.047655533999204636, + 0.04799368232488632, + 0.14437280595302582, + 0.053663697093725204 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008654586039483547 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot handheld with shaky movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low angle and slowly tilt upwards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central structure a vortex composed of melting clocks and stretched canvases?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the clocks depicted with tarnished brass casings and dark wood frames that appear to twist and drip like hot wax?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by solid, glassy tendrils of lightning emitting a cold inner glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.038136888295412064 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881369590759277 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.038136888295412064, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.038136888295412064, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1588427573442459, + 0.04916555434465408, + 0.0874987542629242, + 0.13597485423088074, + 0.054280541837215424, + 0.09768929332494736, + 0.03528102487325668, + 0.044669922441244125, + 0.2686225473880768, + 0.06797471642494202 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.038136888295412064 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot handheld with shaky movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low angle and slowly tilt upwards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central structure a vortex composed of melting clocks and stretched canvases?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the clocks depicted with tarnished brass casings and dark wood frames that appear to twist and drip like hot wax?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by solid, glassy tendrils of lightning emitting a cold inner glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.25213584303855896 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5021358728408813 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.25213584303855896, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.25213584303855896, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09225325286388397, + 0.11394409090280533, + 0.06907333433628082, + 0.12822166085243225, + 0.1066126748919487, + 0.12103356420993805, + 0.04370393231511116, + 0.08997044712305069, + 0.08292136341333389, + 0.15226568281650543 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.25213584303855896 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "Shot with the shaky, visceral movement of a handheld camera, low-angle shots slowly tilt upwards from a shattered, barren landscape, following the rise of a vast, surreal vortex that inexorably distorts the sky. This spiraling vortex is a chaotic amalgamation of melting clocks and stretched canvases; classic pocket watches with tarnished brass casings and luxurious clocks with dark wood frames twist and drip like hot wax, their numbered faces blurred as their hands droop lifelessly. Interwoven with this temporal decay are vast expanses of raw fiber canvas, stretched so tight they appear to tear, their pale, textured surfaces contrasting starkly against the viscous flow. The entire impossible structure is illuminated from within by solid, glassy tendrils of lightning, which emit a cold, inner glow as they snake through the vortex, casting sharp, crystalline highlights across its molten surface. Above, the sky itself roils in an unnatural, dancing aurora, its ever-shifting veil of sickly yellows, deep purples, and blood-reds creating a chaotic and malevolent celestial backdrop, completing a profoundly nightmarish vision, the erratic camerawork immersing the viewer directly into a waking dream of a decaying reality.", + "seed": 27043, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_6/index_7556_seed_27043_dp_13_rank_26_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.5802642852067947, + "vlm_logprob": -0.5802642852067947, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.175, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.5802642852067947, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.6, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot handheld with shaky movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low angle and slowly tilt upwards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central structure a vortex composed of melting clocks and stretched canvases?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the clocks depicted with tarnished brass casings and dark wood frames that appear to twist and drip like hot wax?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by solid, glassy tendrils of lightning emitting a cold inner glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8058630228042603 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.18086300790309906 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.8058630228042603, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -1.8058630228042603, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1244305968284607, + 0.20795823633670807, + 0.1290128082036972, + 0.10036163777112961, + 0.034659773111343384, + 0.12111109495162964, + 0.03018653206527233, + 0.035831063985824585, + 0.030650155618786812, + 0.18579815328121185 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.8058630228042603 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot handheld with shaky movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low angle and slowly tilt upwards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central structure a vortex composed of melting clocks and stretched canvases?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the clocks depicted with tarnished brass casings and dark wood frames that appear to twist and drip like hot wax?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by solid, glassy tendrils of lightning emitting a cold inner glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8262190222740173 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5762190222740173 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.8262190222740173, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.8262190222740173, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17491468787193298, + 0.21280242502689362, + 0.056884974241256714, + 0.14054922759532928, + 0.06365100294351578, + 0.11178023368120193, + 0.05157790705561638, + 0.03822534531354904, + 0.03576614335179329, + 0.11384803801774979 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.8262190222740173 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot handheld with shaky movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low angle and slowly tilt upwards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central structure a vortex composed of melting clocks and stretched canvases?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the clocks depicted with tarnished brass casings and dark wood frames that appear to twist and drip like hot wax?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by solid, glassy tendrils of lightning emitting a cold inner glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029833033680915833 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298330783843994 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029833033680915833, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029833033680915833, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17080138623714447, + 0.1458185762166977, + 0.04661210998892784, + 0.18167775869369507, + 0.02084175869822502, + 0.05403292924165726, + 0.13266301155090332, + 0.05002067610621452, + 0.11398561298847198, + 0.08354619145393372 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029833033680915833 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot handheld with shaky movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low angle and slowly tilt upwards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central structure a vortex composed of melting clocks and stretched canvases?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the clocks depicted with tarnished brass casings and dark wood frames that appear to twist and drip like hot wax?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by solid, glassy tendrils of lightning emitting a cold inner glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0790201723575592 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5790202617645264 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0790201723575592, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0790201723575592, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.238631471991539, + 0.17396415770053864, + 0.12722313404083252, + 0.1328805685043335, + 0.03746873885393143, + 0.02793726697564125, + 0.09314986318349838, + 0.04619252681732178, + 0.0339125394821167, + 0.08863971382379532 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0790201723575592 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot handheld with shaky movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low angle and slowly tilt upwards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central structure a vortex composed of melting clocks and stretched canvases?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the clocks depicted with tarnished brass casings and dark wood frames that appear to twist and drip like hot wax?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by solid, glassy tendrils of lightning emitting a cold inner glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16038617491722107 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9103862047195435 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16038617491722107, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16038617491722107, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09115768224000931, + 0.08865547925233841, + 0.08123912662267685, + 0.06581076234579086, + 0.026424380019307137, + 0.03619656339287758, + 0.13388918340206146, + 0.11519420892000198, + 0.11051364243030548, + 0.250918984413147 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16038617491722107 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "Shot with the shaky, visceral movement of a handheld camera, low-angle shots slowly tilt upwards from a shattered, barren landscape, following the rise of a vast, surreal vortex that inexorably distorts the sky. This spiraling vortex is a chaotic amalgamation of melting clocks and stretched canvases; classic pocket watches with tarnished brass casings and luxurious clocks with dark wood frames twist and drip like hot wax, their numbered faces blurred as their hands droop lifelessly. Interwoven with this temporal decay are vast expanses of raw fiber canvas, stretched so tight they appear to tear, their pale, textured surfaces contrasting starkly against the viscous flow. The entire impossible structure is illuminated from within by solid, glassy tendrils of lightning, which emit a cold, inner glow as they snake through the vortex, casting sharp, crystalline highlights across its molten surface. Above, the sky itself roils in an unnatural, dancing aurora, its ever-shifting veil of sickly yellows, deep purples, and blood-reds creating a chaotic and malevolent celestial backdrop, completing a profoundly nightmarish vision, the erratic camerawork immersing the viewer directly into a waking dream of a decaying reality.", + "seed": 27044, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_6/index_7556_seed_27044_dp_13_rank_26_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.6481201017275453, + "vlm_logprob": -0.6481201017275453, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.25, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.6481201017275453, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.6, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot handheld with shaky movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low angle and slowly tilt upwards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central structure a vortex composed of melting clocks and stretched canvases?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the clocks depicted with tarnished brass casings and dark wood frames that appear to twist and drip like hot wax?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by solid, glassy tendrils of lightning emitting a cold inner glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7035162448883057 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20351621508598328 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.7035162448883057, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -1.7035162448883057, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08712906390428543, + 0.06525787711143494, + 0.09125062823295593, + 0.07178205251693726, + 0.14608116447925568, + 0.23056264221668243, + 0.0623539537191391, + 0.0996396392583847, + 0.0814313217997551, + 0.06451169401407242 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.7035162448883057 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot handheld with shaky movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low angle and slowly tilt upwards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central structure a vortex composed of melting clocks and stretched canvases?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the clocks depicted with tarnished brass casings and dark wood frames that appear to twist and drip like hot wax?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by solid, glassy tendrils of lightning emitting a cold inner glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2236710786819458 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3486710488796234 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.2236710786819458, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -1.2236710786819458, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06684188544750214, + 0.04794706776738167, + 0.12404968589544296, + 0.06242665275931358, + 0.19607208669185638, + 0.0606502890586853, + 0.12532725930213928, + 0.16461853682994843, + 0.08305157721042633, + 0.0690150111913681 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.2236710786819458 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot handheld with shaky movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low angle and slowly tilt upwards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central structure a vortex composed of melting clocks and stretched canvases?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the clocks depicted with tarnished brass casings and dark wood frames that appear to twist and drip like hot wax?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by solid, glassy tendrils of lightning emitting a cold inner glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012566314078867435 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387566089630127 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012566314078867435, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012566314078867435, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1686352789402008, + 0.08683383464813232, + 0.09234236925840378, + 0.0644276887178421, + 0.08901875466108322, + 0.12041289359331131, + 0.10219413787126541, + 0.10698166489601135, + 0.09816204756498337, + 0.07099129259586334 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012566314078867435 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot handheld with shaky movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low angle and slowly tilt upwards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central structure a vortex composed of melting clocks and stretched canvases?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the clocks depicted with tarnished brass casings and dark wood frames that appear to twist and drip like hot wax?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by solid, glassy tendrils of lightning emitting a cold inner glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.048707690089941025 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0487077236175537 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.048707690089941025, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.048707690089941025, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14176271855831146, + 0.05034169927239418, + 0.24601374566555023, + 0.03896363079547882, + 0.09518547356128693, + 0.05840102210640907, + 0.06644635647535324, + 0.08487308770418167, + 0.08859104663133621, + 0.1294211745262146 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.048707690089941025 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot handheld with shaky movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low angle and slowly tilt upwards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central structure a vortex composed of melting clocks and stretched canvases?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the clocks depicted with tarnished brass casings and dark wood frames that appear to twist and drip like hot wax?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by solid, glassy tendrils of lightning emitting a cold inner glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2521391808986664 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5021392107009888 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2521391808986664, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2521391808986664, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10344458371400833, + 0.0631226897239685, + 0.04572764039039612, + 0.09531915932893753, + 0.13589663803577423, + 0.04107740893959999, + 0.12657363712787628, + 0.20629985630512238, + 0.1465505212545395, + 0.03598786145448685 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2521391808986664 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_7/index_tensor([8865, 8865])_group_7_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_7/index_tensor([8865, 8865])_group_7_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..a643f68075b082211df671e75b24b81942418834 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_7/index_tensor([8865, 8865])_group_7_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up, static shot frames a lone candlelight against a deep, blurred black background, creating a scene of profound intimacy. Initially, the flame burns with a steady, teardrop-shaped glow, the main body of the flame a vibrant yellow-orange, gradually fading to a soft blue, licking the blackened wick. The process of extinguishing begins gracefully, the flame beginning to wither like a dying flower; its strong, bright edges soften and curl inward, while its tip teeters and droops downward. The pulses of light it emits are erratic, weakening with each flicker. With a final spasm, the flame collapses in on itself and disappears entirely, plunging the scene into near-total darkness. A tiny, glowing red spur on the wick is the final trace of light, before a thin, ethereal puff of white smoke rises deliberately, twisting and unfurling, melting into the void, leaving behind a palpable sense of quiet and finality.", + "seed": 16004, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_7/index_8865_seed_16004_dp_14_rank_28_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.005286970408633351, + "vlm_logprob": -0.005286970408633351, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 6.075, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.005286970408633351, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up with a static camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background deep and blurred black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the flame start as a steady, teardrop-shaped glow with a yellow-orange body fading to blue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the flame eventually collapse and disappear, leaving only a tiny glowing red spur on the wick?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a thin, ethereal puff of white smoke rise, twist, and melt into the void after the flame disappears?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.015235595405101776 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.890235424041748 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.015235595405101776, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.015235595405101776, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08005745708942413, + 0.09164300560951233, + 0.044332269579172134, + 0.11184891313314438, + 0.07104716449975967, + 0.061775047332048416, + 0.1058025136590004, + 0.16016700863838196, + 0.092483289539814, + 0.18084335327148438 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.015235595405101776 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up with a static camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background deep and blurred black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the flame start as a steady, teardrop-shaped glow with a yellow-orange body fading to blue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the flame eventually collapse and disappear, leaving only a tiny glowing red spur on the wick?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a thin, ethereal puff of white smoke rise, twist, and melt into the void after the flame disappears?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0076462216675281525 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882646083831787 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0076462216675281525, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0076462216675281525, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17436596751213074, + 0.05810528248548508, + 0.11731128394603729, + 0.02566174976527691, + 0.22683867812156677, + 0.04064066335558891, + 0.1255655586719513, + 0.08887479454278946, + 0.037935927510261536, + 0.10470005869865417 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0076462216675281525 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up with a static camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background deep and blurred black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the flame start as a steady, teardrop-shaped glow with a yellow-orange body fading to blue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the flame eventually collapse and disappear, leaving only a tiny glowing red spur on the wick?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a thin, ethereal puff of white smoke rise, twist, and melt into the void after the flame disappears?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0017245433991774917 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.376724720001221 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0017245433991774917, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0017245433991774917, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05672280490398407, + 0.0631607323884964, + 0.04837954416871071, + 0.03115866519510746, + 0.03708963096141815, + 0.07025466859340668, + 0.3107761740684509, + 0.110040582716465, + 0.10793807357549667, + 0.16447913646697998 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0017245433991774917 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up with a static camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background deep and blurred black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the flame start as a steady, teardrop-shaped glow with a yellow-orange body fading to blue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the flame eventually collapse and disappear, leaving only a tiny glowing red spur on the wick?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a thin, ethereal puff of white smoke rise, twist, and melt into the void after the flame disappears?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.001335086883045733 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.626335144042969 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.001335086883045733, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.001335086883045733, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.031435027718544006, + 0.016184797510504723, + 0.011167659424245358, + 0.023439355194568634, + 0.02234451100230217, + 0.0821499302983284, + 0.09506173431873322, + 0.21097758412361145, + 0.4097598195075989, + 0.09747961163520813 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.001335086883045733 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up with a static camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background deep and blurred black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the flame start as a steady, teardrop-shaped glow with a yellow-orange body fading to blue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the flame eventually collapse and disappear, leaving only a tiny glowing red spur on the wick?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a thin, ethereal puff of white smoke rise, twist, and melt into the void after the flame disappears?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0004934046883136034 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.62549352645874 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0004934046883136034, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0004934046883136034, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05100875720381737, + 0.01681048423051834, + 0.008698525838553905, + 0.0322997085750103, + 0.03473909571766853, + 0.05010104551911354, + 0.23740407824516296, + 0.12628225982189178, + 0.12145207077264786, + 0.32120391726493835 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0004934046883136034 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up, static shot frames a lone candlelight against a deep, blurred black background, creating a scene of profound intimacy. Initially, the flame burns with a steady, teardrop-shaped glow, the main body of the flame a vibrant yellow-orange, gradually fading to a soft blue, licking the blackened wick. The process of extinguishing begins gracefully, the flame beginning to wither like a dying flower; its strong, bright edges soften and curl inward, while its tip teeters and droops downward. The pulses of light it emits are erratic, weakening with each flicker. With a final spasm, the flame collapses in on itself and disappears entirely, plunging the scene into near-total darkness. A tiny, glowing red spur on the wick is the final trace of light, before a thin, ethereal puff of white smoke rises deliberately, twisting and unfurling, melting into the void, leaving behind a palpable sense of quiet and finality.", + "seed": 16005, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_7/index_8865_seed_16005_dp_14_rank_28_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.018429634999483822, + "vlm_logprob": -0.018429634999483822, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.475, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.018429634999483822, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up with a static camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background deep and blurred black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the flame start as a steady, teardrop-shaped glow with a yellow-orange body fading to blue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the flame eventually collapse and disappear, leaving only a tiny glowing red spur on the wick?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a thin, ethereal puff of white smoke rise, twist, and melt into the void after the flame disappears?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.044247936457395554 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.044248104095459 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.044247936457395554, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.044247936457395554, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.27133968472480774, + 0.05651533976197243, + 0.06173579394817352, + 0.10205177217721939, + 0.09598284959793091, + 0.05151714012026787, + 0.05223552882671356, + 0.07253118604421616, + 0.11172722280025482, + 0.12436351180076599 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.044247936457395554 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up with a static camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background deep and blurred black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the flame start as a steady, teardrop-shaped glow with a yellow-orange body fading to blue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the flame eventually collapse and disappear, leaving only a tiny glowing red spur on the wick?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a thin, ethereal puff of white smoke rise, twist, and melt into the void after the flame disappears?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016108721494674683 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141108512878418 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016108721494674683, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016108721494674683, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20188137888908386, + 0.14840587973594666, + 0.24937929213047028, + 0.05171368643641472, + 0.07619602233171463, + 0.07225219905376434, + 0.048531413078308105, + 0.06847167015075684, + 0.03455854952335358, + 0.048609886318445206 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016108721494674683 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up with a static camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background deep and blurred black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the flame start as a steady, teardrop-shaped glow with a yellow-orange body fading to blue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the flame eventually collapse and disappear, leaving only a tiny glowing red spur on the wick?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a thin, ethereal puff of white smoke rise, twist, and melt into the void after the flame disappears?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005268143489956856 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255268096923828 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005268143489956856, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005268143489956856, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1233118325471878, + 0.10743900388479233, + 0.10243254899978638, + 0.19240547716617584, + 0.09563500434160233, + 0.07519636303186417, + 0.0678391382098198, + 0.06203079968690872, + 0.09229942411184311, + 0.0814104750752449 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005268143489956856 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up with a static camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background deep and blurred black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the flame start as a steady, teardrop-shaped glow with a yellow-orange body fading to blue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the flame eventually collapse and disappear, leaving only a tiny glowing red spur on the wick?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a thin, ethereal puff of white smoke rise, twist, and melt into the void after the flame disappears?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005945970769971609 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130946159362793 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005945970769971609, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005945970769971609, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10407065600156784, + 0.04111018776893616, + 0.07640670239925385, + 0.11608313769102097, + 0.07765915244817734, + 0.027397189289331436, + 0.2001260221004486, + 0.026680145412683487, + 0.15199144184589386, + 0.17847537994384766 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005945970769971609 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up with a static camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background deep and blurred black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the flame start as a steady, teardrop-shaped glow with a yellow-orange body fading to blue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the flame eventually collapse and disappear, leaving only a tiny glowing red spur on the wick?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a thin, ethereal puff of white smoke rise, twist, and melt into the void after the flame disappears?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020577402785420418 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955774307250977 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020577402785420418, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020577402785420418, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18055744469165802, + 0.056455351412296295, + 0.037570904940366745, + 0.03864235803484917, + 0.11698387563228607, + 0.03540489450097084, + 0.06049927696585655, + 0.031656719744205475, + 0.26900750398635864, + 0.1732216626405716 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020577402785420418 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up, static shot frames a lone candlelight against a deep, blurred black background, creating a scene of profound intimacy. Initially, the flame burns with a steady, teardrop-shaped glow, the main body of the flame a vibrant yellow-orange, gradually fading to a soft blue, licking the blackened wick. The process of extinguishing begins gracefully, the flame beginning to wither like a dying flower; its strong, bright edges soften and curl inward, while its tip teeters and droops downward. The pulses of light it emits are erratic, weakening with each flicker. With a final spasm, the flame collapses in on itself and disappears entirely, plunging the scene into near-total darkness. A tiny, glowing red spur on the wick is the final trace of light, before a thin, ethereal puff of white smoke rises deliberately, twisting and unfurling, melting into the void, leaving behind a palpable sense of quiet and finality.", + "seed": 16006, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_7/index_8865_seed_16006_dp_15_rank_30_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.017089504306204616, + "vlm_logprob": -0.017089504306204616, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 5.125, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.017089504306204616, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up with a static camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background deep and blurred black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the flame start as a steady, teardrop-shaped glow with a yellow-orange body fading to blue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the flame eventually collapse and disappear, leaving only a tiny glowing red spur on the wick?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a thin, ethereal puff of white smoke rise, twist, and melt into the void after the flame disappears?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.030602872371673584 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.030602931976318 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.030602872371673584, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.030602872371673584, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.006859778426587582, + 0.8700613379478455, + 0.025111708790063858, + 0.006909614894539118, + 0.006128150504082441, + 0.002770147053524852, + 0.003980344161391258, + 0.045813653618097305, + 0.01870083436369896, + 0.013664446771144867 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 7, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.030602872371673584 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up with a static camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background deep and blurred black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the flame start as a steady, teardrop-shaped glow with a yellow-orange body fading to blue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the flame eventually collapse and disappear, leaving only a tiny glowing red spur on the wick?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a thin, ethereal puff of white smoke rise, twist, and melt into the void after the flame disappears?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04869622364640236 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048696279525757 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04869622364640236, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04869622364640236, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.054151471704244614, + 0.0070672547444701195, + 0.5432992577552795, + 0.03188532963395119, + 0.006217659451067448, + 0.003920018672943115, + 0.0019176896894350648, + 0.3082488477230072, + 0.031157782301306725, + 0.01213466003537178 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04869622364640236 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up with a static camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background deep and blurred black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the flame start as a steady, teardrop-shaped glow with a yellow-orange body fading to blue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the flame eventually collapse and disappear, leaving only a tiny glowing red spur on the wick?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a thin, ethereal puff of white smoke rise, twist, and melt into the void after the flame disappears?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002498839981853962 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002498626708984 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002498839981853962, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002498839981853962, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.007954210974276066, + 0.7538222670555115, + 0.1613541692495346, + 0.004961866419762373, + 0.0050577628426253796, + 0.0039359694346785545, + 0.003670449834316969, + 0.01579921692609787, + 0.033806778490543365, + 0.009637359529733658 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002498839981853962 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up with a static camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background deep and blurred black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the flame start as a steady, teardrop-shaped glow with a yellow-orange body fading to blue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the flame eventually collapse and disappear, leaving only a tiny glowing red spur on the wick?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a thin, ethereal puff of white smoke rise, twist, and melt into the void after the flame disappears?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0017118098912760615 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.376711845397949 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0017118098912760615, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0017118098912760615, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.018585290759801865, + 0.3439106345176697, + 0.026313798502087593, + 0.01061317604035139, + 0.016324851661920547, + 0.009400906972587109, + 0.009087949059903622, + 0.2307989001274109, + 0.16756778955459595, + 0.16739670932292938 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0017118098912760615 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up with a static camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background deep and blurred black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the flame start as a steady, teardrop-shaped glow with a yellow-orange body fading to blue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the flame eventually collapse and disappear, leaving only a tiny glowing red spur on the wick?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a thin, ethereal puff of white smoke rise, twist, and melt into the void after the flame disappears?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0019377756398171186 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.2519378662109375 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0019377756398171186, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0019377756398171186, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.012221855111420155, + 0.6618541479110718, + 0.0320710688829422, + 0.012429140508174896, + 0.010073059238493443, + 0.006595077458769083, + 0.004686406347900629, + 0.13531123101711273, + 0.06507179141044617, + 0.059686195105314255 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0019377756398171186 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up, static shot frames a lone candlelight against a deep, blurred black background, creating a scene of profound intimacy. Initially, the flame burns with a steady, teardrop-shaped glow, the main body of the flame a vibrant yellow-orange, gradually fading to a soft blue, licking the blackened wick. The process of extinguishing begins gracefully, the flame beginning to wither like a dying flower; its strong, bright edges soften and curl inward, while its tip teeters and droops downward. The pulses of light it emits are erratic, weakening with each flicker. With a final spasm, the flame collapses in on itself and disappears entirely, plunging the scene into near-total darkness. A tiny, glowing red spur on the wick is the final trace of light, before a thin, ethereal puff of white smoke rises deliberately, twisting and unfurling, melting into the void, leaving behind a palpable sense of quiet and finality.", + "seed": 16007, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_7/index_8865_seed_16007_dp_15_rank_30_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.07025145422667264, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07025145422667264, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.2, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07025145422667264, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up with a static camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background deep and blurred black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the flame start as a steady, teardrop-shaped glow with a yellow-orange body fading to blue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the flame eventually collapse and disappear, leaving only a tiny glowing red spur on the wick?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a thin, ethereal puff of white smoke rise, twist, and melt into the void after the flame disappears?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06333286315202713 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9383327960968018 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06333286315202713, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06333286315202713, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17230184376239777, + 0.07750461995601654, + 0.05008881911635399, + 0.14601485431194305, + 0.30327507853507996, + 0.11182913929224014, + 0.022676359862089157, + 0.03315348923206329, + 0.025082310661673546, + 0.058073464781045914 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06333286315202713 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up with a static camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background deep and blurred black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the flame start as a steady, teardrop-shaped glow with a yellow-orange body fading to blue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the flame eventually collapse and disappear, leaving only a tiny glowing red spur on the wick?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a thin, ethereal puff of white smoke rise, twist, and melt into the void after the flame disappears?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2257094532251358 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6007094383239746 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2257094532251358, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2257094532251358, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15578590333461761, + 0.15204955637454987, + 0.09104949980974197, + 0.03791029751300812, + 0.07126671820878983, + 0.26329249143600464, + 0.04149788245558739, + 0.052036404609680176, + 0.06992707401514053, + 0.06518415361642838 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2257094532251358 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up with a static camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background deep and blurred black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the flame start as a steady, teardrop-shaped glow with a yellow-orange body fading to blue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the flame eventually collapse and disappear, leaving only a tiny glowing red spur on the wick?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a thin, ethereal puff of white smoke rise, twist, and melt into the void after the flame disappears?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014225269667804241 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264225482940674 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014225269667804241, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014225269667804241, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10869002342224121, + 0.10154812037944794, + 0.05319854989647865, + 0.0404316745698452, + 0.12507039308547974, + 0.2054051011800766, + 0.06534302234649658, + 0.09881912916898727, + 0.0852145254611969, + 0.11627950519323349 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014225269667804241 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up with a static camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background deep and blurred black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the flame start as a steady, teardrop-shaped glow with a yellow-orange body fading to blue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the flame eventually collapse and disappear, leaving only a tiny glowing red spur on the wick?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a thin, ethereal puff of white smoke rise, twist, and melt into the void after the flame disappears?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029801445081830025 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529801368713379 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029801445081830025, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029801445081830025, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.37302538752555847, + 0.04775593429803848, + 0.02938322350382805, + 0.024907466024160385, + 0.06796588748693466, + 0.08758080005645752, + 0.07281864434480667, + 0.030173733830451965, + 0.12126898020505905, + 0.14511990547180176 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029801445081830025 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up with a static camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background deep and blurred black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the flame start as a steady, teardrop-shaped glow with a yellow-orange body fading to blue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the flame eventually collapse and disappear, leaving only a tiny glowing red spur on the wick?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a thin, ethereal puff of white smoke rise, twist, and melt into the void after the flame disappears?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018188240006566048 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.0181884765625 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018188240006566048, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018188240006566048, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4163665771484375, + 0.02960038371384144, + 0.029385490342974663, + 0.03634592518210411, + 0.047726985067129135, + 0.14320555329322815, + 0.02913062833249569, + 0.10525816679000854, + 0.03361758589744568, + 0.1293628215789795 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018188240006566048 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_8/index_tensor([7361, 7361])_group_8_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_8/index_tensor([7361, 7361])_group_8_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..32ef22aa9da5d7e7bc0c89dc1aedf4f35879fcfb --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_8/index_tensor([7361, 7361])_group_8_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "Viewed from a static, slightly high-angle close-up, the scene focuses intensely on the patients' faces as they regain consciousness. Their eyelids, thin and translucent, flutter with a series of rapid, involuntary tremors before slowly, heavily peeling back. The exposed irises are a hazy, unfocused blue that darts aimlessly under the cool, sterile glare of the overhead fluorescent lights, casting soft shadows across their pale features. They lie on starched white hospital pillows, a few wisps of damp light brown hair clinging to their foreheads, their expressions one of pure disorientation. The fabric of their pale blue, wrinkled hospital gowns tightens as their chests begin to slowly and unsteadily rise, culminating in a low, trembling, audible breath that visibly swirls through their bodies, creating a powerful and intimate atmosphere of vulnerability and bewildered re-entry into the world.", + "seed": 5677, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_8/index_7361_seed_5677_dp_16_rank_32_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.09209368117153645, + "vlm_logprob": -0.09209368117153645, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.85, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.09209368117153645, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the patients lying on starched white hospital pillows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the patients' eyelids flutter with rapid tremors before slowly peeling back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the exposed irises a hazy, unfocused blue color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the patients wearing pale blue, wrinkled hospital gowns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera maintain a static, slightly high-angle close-up shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06663386523723602 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.816633939743042 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06663386523723602, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06663386523723602, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14486730098724365, + 0.27518796920776367, + 0.11194492131471634, + 0.09567619860172272, + 0.1337575614452362, + 0.044557586312294006, + 0.08302924036979675, + 0.025217896327376366, + 0.049577727913856506, + 0.03618350252509117 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06663386523723602 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the patients lying on starched white hospital pillows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the patients' eyelids flutter with rapid tremors before slowly peeling back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the exposed irises a hazy, unfocused blue color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the patients wearing pale blue, wrinkled hospital gowns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera maintain a static, slightly high-angle close-up shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.25216326117515564 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.502163290977478 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.25216326117515564, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.25216326117515564, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23811152577400208, + 0.08832024782896042, + 0.1717604398727417, + 0.03979397937655449, + 0.07369226962327957, + 0.04434231296181679, + 0.1911422163248062, + 0.039296943694353104, + 0.0906379222869873, + 0.02290215529501438 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.25216326117515564 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the patients lying on starched white hospital pillows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the patients' eyelids flutter with rapid tremors before slowly peeling back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the exposed irises a hazy, unfocused blue color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the patients wearing pale blue, wrinkled hospital gowns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera maintain a static, slightly high-angle close-up shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05499480292201042 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929994821548462 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05499480292201042, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05499480292201042, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0465618371963501, + 0.6411858797073364, + 0.019696615636348724, + 0.02091197483241558, + 0.18538956344127655, + 0.01809350587427616, + 0.01352849043905735, + 0.04439368471503258, + 0.0059484802186489105, + 0.004289965610951185 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05499480292201042 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the patients lying on starched white hospital pillows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the patients' eyelids flutter with rapid tremors before slowly peeling back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the exposed irises a hazy, unfocused blue color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the patients wearing pale blue, wrinkled hospital gowns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera maintain a static, slightly high-angle close-up shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0790470540523529 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5790469646453857 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0790470540523529, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0790470540523529, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07919705659151077, + 0.2099248468875885, + 0.08096733689308167, + 0.15234804153442383, + 0.3064238131046295, + 0.03207356855273247, + 0.04324839264154434, + 0.05607575178146362, + 0.02524600550532341, + 0.014495193026959896 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0790470540523529 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the patients lying on starched white hospital pillows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the patients' eyelids flutter with rapid tremors before slowly peeling back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the exposed irises a hazy, unfocused blue color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the patients wearing pale blue, wrinkled hospital gowns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera maintain a static, slightly high-angle close-up shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0076294224709272385 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.88262939453125 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0076294224709272385, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0076294224709272385, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16898617148399353, + 0.12674391269683838, + 0.06930658221244812, + 0.11900775134563446, + 0.2335468828678131, + 0.1158730611205101, + 0.04413546621799469, + 0.05987142026424408, + 0.03699040785431862, + 0.025538310408592224 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0076294224709272385 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "Viewed from a static, slightly high-angle close-up, the scene focuses intensely on the patients' faces as they regain consciousness. Their eyelids, thin and translucent, flutter with a series of rapid, involuntary tremors before slowly, heavily peeling back. The exposed irises are a hazy, unfocused blue that darts aimlessly under the cool, sterile glare of the overhead fluorescent lights, casting soft shadows across their pale features. They lie on starched white hospital pillows, a few wisps of damp light brown hair clinging to their foreheads, their expressions one of pure disorientation. The fabric of their pale blue, wrinkled hospital gowns tightens as their chests begin to slowly and unsteadily rise, culminating in a low, trembling, audible breath that visibly swirls through their bodies, creating a powerful and intimate atmosphere of vulnerability and bewildered re-entry into the world.", + "seed": 5678, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_8/index_7361_seed_5678_dp_16_rank_32_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.11865608897060156, + "vlm_logprob": -0.11865608897060156, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.775, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.11865608897060156, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the patients lying on starched white hospital pillows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the patients' eyelids flutter with rapid tremors before slowly peeling back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the exposed irises a hazy, unfocused blue color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the patients wearing pale blue, wrinkled hospital gowns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera maintain a static, slightly high-angle close-up shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.25460198521614075 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5046019554138184 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.25460198521614075, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.25460198521614075, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09444595873355865, + 0.23704984784126282, + 0.03366037458181381, + 0.07107069343328476, + 0.07058052718639374, + 0.18339531123638153, + 0.0711156353354454, + 0.1362534463405609, + 0.0721191018819809, + 0.03030913881957531 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.25460198521614075 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the patients lying on starched white hospital pillows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the patients' eyelids flutter with rapid tremors before slowly peeling back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the exposed irises a hazy, unfocused blue color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the patients wearing pale blue, wrinkled hospital gowns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera maintain a static, slightly high-angle close-up shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22562402486801147 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6006240844726562 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.22562402486801147, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.22562402486801147, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14128053188323975, + 0.13517023622989655, + 0.05720701441168785, + 0.04728405177593231, + 0.045609015971422195, + 0.11307758837938309, + 0.07392007857561111, + 0.04036979749798775, + 0.2826576232910156, + 0.06342411041259766 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.22562402486801147 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the patients lying on starched white hospital pillows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the patients' eyelids flutter with rapid tremors before slowly peeling back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the exposed irises a hazy, unfocused blue color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the patients wearing pale blue, wrinkled hospital gowns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera maintain a static, slightly high-angle close-up shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08906727284193039 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.464067220687866 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08906727284193039, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08906727284193039, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10037369281053543, + 0.16082845628261566, + 0.088503398001194, + 0.030714353546500206, + 0.08542020618915558, + 0.09866555780172348, + 0.0475955456495285, + 0.07686088979244232, + 0.23213018476963043, + 0.07890772819519043 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08906727284193039 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the patients lying on starched white hospital pillows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the patients' eyelids flutter with rapid tremors before slowly peeling back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the exposed irises a hazy, unfocused blue color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the patients wearing pale blue, wrinkled hospital gowns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera maintain a static, slightly high-angle close-up shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014207052998244762 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264206886291504 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014207052998244762, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014207052998244762, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15145742893218994, + 0.4423597753047943, + 0.03980366513133049, + 0.035235676914453506, + 0.049189262092113495, + 0.030982844531536102, + 0.0898924171924591, + 0.0431656688451767, + 0.08641347289085388, + 0.031499817967414856 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014207052998244762 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the patients lying on starched white hospital pillows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the patients' eyelids flutter with rapid tremors before slowly peeling back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the exposed irises a hazy, unfocused blue color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the patients wearing pale blue, wrinkled hospital gowns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera maintain a static, slightly high-angle close-up shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00978010892868042 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634779930114746 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00978010892868042, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00978010892868042, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06261392682790756, + 0.07403697073459625, + 0.06318682432174683, + 0.03249293565750122, + 0.03555697947740555, + 0.16909174621105194, + 0.06381155550479889, + 0.04605307802557945, + 0.3577772378921509, + 0.09537875652313232 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00978010892868042 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "Viewed from a static, slightly high-angle close-up, the scene focuses intensely on the patients' faces as they regain consciousness. Their eyelids, thin and translucent, flutter with a series of rapid, involuntary tremors before slowly, heavily peeling back. The exposed irises are a hazy, unfocused blue that darts aimlessly under the cool, sterile glare of the overhead fluorescent lights, casting soft shadows across their pale features. They lie on starched white hospital pillows, a few wisps of damp light brown hair clinging to their foreheads, their expressions one of pure disorientation. The fabric of their pale blue, wrinkled hospital gowns tightens as their chests begin to slowly and unsteadily rise, culminating in a low, trembling, audible breath that visibly swirls through their bodies, creating a powerful and intimate atmosphere of vulnerability and bewildered re-entry into the world.", + "seed": 5679, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_8/index_7361_seed_5679_dp_17_rank_34_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.22975773438811303, + "vlm_logprob": -0.22975773438811303, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.2, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.22975773438811303, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the patients lying on starched white hospital pillows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the patients' eyelids flutter with rapid tremors before slowly peeling back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the exposed irises a hazy, unfocused blue color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the patients wearing pale blue, wrinkled hospital gowns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera maintain a static, slightly high-angle close-up shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5799863934516907 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8299863934516907 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5799863934516907, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5799863934516907, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05577478185296059, + 0.043596480041742325, + 0.06692904978990555, + 0.144516721367836, + 0.06261985003948212, + 0.09797053784132004, + 0.03797636926174164, + 0.021687079221010208, + 0.1312524974346161, + 0.33767664432525635 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 3, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5799863934516907 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the patients lying on starched white hospital pillows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the patients' eyelids flutter with rapid tremors before slowly peeling back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the exposed irises a hazy, unfocused blue color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the patients wearing pale blue, wrinkled hospital gowns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera maintain a static, slightly high-angle close-up shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.42897066473960876 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.0539706945419312 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.42897066473960876, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.42897066473960876, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06743451207876205, + 0.053108323365449905, + 0.03445490077137947, + 0.16547182202339172, + 0.01862161234021187, + 0.05682994797825813, + 0.03579200804233551, + 0.30974194407463074, + 0.17137186229228973, + 0.08717299997806549 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.42897066473960876 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the patients lying on starched white hospital pillows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the patients' eyelids flutter with rapid tremors before slowly peeling back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the exposed irises a hazy, unfocused blue color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the patients wearing pale blue, wrinkled hospital gowns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera maintain a static, slightly high-angle close-up shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1004253700375557 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3504254817962646 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1004253700375557, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1004253700375557, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07418505847454071, + 0.22200334072113037, + 0.05321688950061798, + 0.12526845932006836, + 0.016340674832463264, + 0.22760118544101715, + 0.0407162569463253, + 0.13427698612213135, + 0.040005508810281754, + 0.0663856491446495 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1004253700375557 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the patients lying on starched white hospital pillows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the patients' eyelids flutter with rapid tremors before slowly peeling back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the exposed irises a hazy, unfocused blue color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the patients wearing pale blue, wrinkled hospital gowns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera maintain a static, slightly high-angle close-up shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0233279038220644 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7733278274536133 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0233279038220644, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0233279038220644, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0255991593003273, + 0.04123545065522194, + 0.023002976551651955, + 0.030920706689357758, + 0.04670022428035736, + 0.03809347003698349, + 0.07181715965270996, + 0.2655683159828186, + 0.26075875759124756, + 0.19630371034145355 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0233279038220644 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the patients lying on starched white hospital pillows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the patients' eyelids flutter with rapid tremors before slowly peeling back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the exposed irises a hazy, unfocused blue color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the patients wearing pale blue, wrinkled hospital gowns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera maintain a static, slightly high-angle close-up shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016078339889645576 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141078472137451 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016078339889645576, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016078339889645576, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03081648424267769, + 0.02103652060031891, + 0.03316456452012062, + 0.20515495538711548, + 0.04107700288295746, + 0.1850060373544693, + 0.04503027722239494, + 0.2048882395029068, + 0.17617259919643402, + 0.0576532818377018 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 7, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016078339889645576 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "Viewed from a static, slightly high-angle close-up, the scene focuses intensely on the patients' faces as they regain consciousness. Their eyelids, thin and translucent, flutter with a series of rapid, involuntary tremors before slowly, heavily peeling back. The exposed irises are a hazy, unfocused blue that darts aimlessly under the cool, sterile glare of the overhead fluorescent lights, casting soft shadows across their pale features. They lie on starched white hospital pillows, a few wisps of damp light brown hair clinging to their foreheads, their expressions one of pure disorientation. The fabric of their pale blue, wrinkled hospital gowns tightens as their chests begin to slowly and unsteadily rise, culminating in a low, trembling, audible breath that visibly swirls through their bodies, creating a powerful and intimate atmosphere of vulnerability and bewildered re-entry into the world.", + "seed": 5680, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_8/index_7361_seed_5680_dp_17_rank_34_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.2943934819661081, + "vlm_logprob": -0.2943934819661081, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.2, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.2943934819661081, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the patients lying on starched white hospital pillows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the patients' eyelids flutter with rapid tremors before slowly peeling back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the exposed irises a hazy, unfocused blue color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the patients wearing pale blue, wrinkled hospital gowns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera maintain a static, slightly high-angle close-up shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7669960856437683 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6419960856437683 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.7669960856437683, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.7669960856437683, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.39906635880470276, + 0.06880374252796173, + 0.1077803522348404, + 0.03606986626982689, + 0.06874555349349976, + 0.12232489883899689, + 0.073442742228508, + 0.024508662521839142, + 0.07300451397895813, + 0.026253264397382736 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.7669960856437683 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the patients lying on starched white hospital pillows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the patients' eyelids flutter with rapid tremors before slowly peeling back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the exposed irises a hazy, unfocused blue color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the patients wearing pale blue, wrinkled hospital gowns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera maintain a static, slightly high-angle close-up shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5762056708335876 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8262056708335876 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5762056708335876, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5762056708335876, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13933034241199493, + 0.07762614637613297, + 0.08728563040494919, + 0.1832280308008194, + 0.0905342847108841, + 0.08487474173307419, + 0.20206299424171448, + 0.053806569427251816, + 0.037106890231370926, + 0.04414438456296921 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5762056708335876 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the patients lying on starched white hospital pillows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the patients' eyelids flutter with rapid tremors before slowly peeling back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the exposed irises a hazy, unfocused blue color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the patients wearing pale blue, wrinkled hospital gowns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera maintain a static, slightly high-angle close-up shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08908766508102417 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.464087724685669 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08908766508102417, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08908766508102417, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22346915304660797, + 0.12744536995887756, + 0.10124840587377548, + 0.060044314712285995, + 0.10859766602516174, + 0.11077361553907394, + 0.10761270672082901, + 0.05712028220295906, + 0.06253790110349655, + 0.04115057364106178 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08908766508102417 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the patients lying on starched white hospital pillows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the patients' eyelids flutter with rapid tremors before slowly peeling back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the exposed irises a hazy, unfocused blue color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the patients wearing pale blue, wrinkled hospital gowns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera maintain a static, slightly high-angle close-up shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.033726684749126434 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408726692199707 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.033726684749126434, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.033726684749126434, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11562982201576233, + 0.2071075588464737, + 0.28283974528312683, + 0.09836050122976303, + 0.05774233862757683, + 0.048367615789175034, + 0.10504435002803802, + 0.012801887467503548, + 0.059406958520412445, + 0.012699203565716743 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.033726684749126434 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the patients lying on starched white hospital pillows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the patients' eyelids flutter with rapid tremors before slowly peeling back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the exposed irises a hazy, unfocused blue color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the patients wearing pale blue, wrinkled hospital gowns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera maintain a static, slightly high-angle close-up shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005951303523033857 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130951404571533 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005951303523033857, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005951303523033857, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18985244631767273, + 0.10157253593206406, + 0.08631366491317749, + 0.13955454528331757, + 0.10000844299793243, + 0.0478040985763073, + 0.1573381870985031, + 0.04487229138612747, + 0.07776232808828354, + 0.054921481758356094 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005951303523033857 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_9/index_tensor([4892, 4892])_group_9_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_9/index_tensor([4892, 4892])_group_9_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..fa15da87410acd24bb05d4d2536c38a28153828f --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_9/index_tensor([4892, 4892])_group_9_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "static, low-angle, wide-angle shot establishes a remarkably tranquil seascape from the perspective of the coast, looking directly out to sea at sunset. In the immediate foreground, the coastline offers a rich texture, composed of damp, dark sand, interspersed with a variety of smooth, wet rocks and colorful pebbles that shimmer under the night sky. The central region is dominated by the deep blue ocean, its surface brimming with gentle, relentless energy. Small waves rhythmically roll towards the land, their crests catching the last rays of light in shimmering golden ripples. On the distant horizon, the sun, a fiery, molten orb, is partially obscured as it sinks majestically, casting a spectacular, warm glow across the sky in a gradation of fiery orange, deep burgundy, and soft purple. This golden, hour-long light creates a shimmering path across the water, guiding the viewer's gaze from shore to horizon, bathing the entire scene in a warm, tranquil glow, evoking a powerful atmosphere of quiet contemplation and the vast beauty of nature.", + "seed": 25407, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_9/index_4892_seed_25407_dp_18_rank_36_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.04776202621869743, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04776202621869743, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.025, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04776202621869743, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a seascape viewed from the coast looking out to sea?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the foreground composed of damp dark sand with smooth wet rocks and colorful pebbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the ocean deep blue with small waves rolling towards the land?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the sun a fiery molten orb partially obscured on the horizon casting orange, burgundy, and purple light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static low-angle wide-angle view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0030171608086675406 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.503016948699951 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0030171608086675406, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0030171608086675406, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22090749442577362, + 0.118246890604496, + 0.12393276393413544, + 0.06378129124641418, + 0.05819913372397423, + 0.06705324351787567, + 0.09583252668380737, + 0.1129269078373909, + 0.0669475570321083, + 0.07217217236757278 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0030171608086675406 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a seascape viewed from the coast looking out to sea?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the foreground composed of damp dark sand with smooth wet rocks and colorful pebbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the ocean deep blue with small waves rolling towards the land?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the sun a fiery molten orb partially obscured on the horizon casting orange, burgundy, and purple light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static low-angle wide-angle view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011079574935138226 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511079788208008 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011079574935138226, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011079574935138226, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22848768532276154, + 0.05232394486665726, + 0.09100204706192017, + 0.04092973843216896, + 0.11980660259723663, + 0.23892654478549957, + 0.043909575790166855, + 0.08711405098438263, + 0.02893953211605549, + 0.06856024265289307 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011079574935138226 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a seascape viewed from the coast looking out to sea?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the foreground composed of damp dark sand with smooth wet rocks and colorful pebbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the ocean deep blue with small waves rolling towards the land?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the sun a fiery molten orb partially obscured on the horizon casting orange, burgundy, and purple light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static low-angle wide-angle view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12705005705356598 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1270501613616943 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12705005705356598, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12705005705356598, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13338500261306763, + 0.24741947650909424, + 0.08557681739330292, + 0.02675255760550499, + 0.04238162562251091, + 0.11438193917274475, + 0.09730558097362518, + 0.10243869572877884, + 0.08300674706697464, + 0.0673515647649765 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12705005705356598 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a seascape viewed from the coast looking out to sea?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the foreground composed of damp dark sand with smooth wet rocks and colorful pebbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the ocean deep blue with small waves rolling towards the land?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the sun a fiery molten orb partially obscured on the horizon casting orange, burgundy, and purple light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static low-angle wide-angle view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008643831126391888 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758643627166748 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008643831126391888, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008643831126391888, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17243506014347076, + 0.07256370782852173, + 0.19480715692043304, + 0.053577445447444916, + 0.2067999541759491, + 0.07273885607719421, + 0.06356000900268555, + 0.04701085388660431, + 0.03977911174297333, + 0.07672787457704544 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008643831126391888 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a seascape viewed from the coast looking out to sea?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the foreground composed of damp dark sand with smooth wet rocks and colorful pebbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the ocean deep blue with small waves rolling towards the land?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the sun a fiery molten orb partially obscured on the horizon casting orange, burgundy, and purple light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static low-angle wide-angle view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08901950716972351 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.464019536972046 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08901950716972351, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08901950716972351, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14514188468456268, + 0.11125139147043228, + 0.06236130744218826, + 0.03667410463094711, + 0.09075921028852463, + 0.08547943085432053, + 0.06756071001291275, + 0.3038826584815979, + 0.026269612833857536, + 0.07061967998743057 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08901950716972351 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, low-angle, wide-angle shot establishes a remarkably tranquil seascape from the perspective of the coast, looking directly out to sea at sunset. In the immediate foreground, the coastline offers a rich texture, composed of damp, dark sand, interspersed with a variety of smooth, wet rocks and colorful pebbles that shimmer under the night sky. The central region is dominated by the deep blue ocean, its surface brimming with gentle, relentless energy. Small waves rhythmically roll towards the land, their crests catching the last rays of light in shimmering golden ripples. On the distant horizon, the sun, a fiery, molten orb, is partially obscured as it sinks majestically, casting a spectacular, warm glow across the sky in a gradation of fiery orange, deep burgundy, and soft purple. This golden, hour-long light creates a shimmering path across the water, guiding the viewer's gaze from shore to horizon, bathing the entire scene in a warm, tranquil glow, evoking a powerful atmosphere of quiet contemplation and the vast beauty of nature.", + "seed": 25408, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_9/index_4892_seed_25408_dp_18_rank_36_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.06369762900285422, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06369762900285422, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.825, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06369762900285422, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a seascape viewed from the coast looking out to sea?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the foreground composed of damp dark sand with smooth wet rocks and colorful pebbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the ocean deep blue with small waves rolling towards the land?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the sun a fiery molten orb partially obscured on the horizon casting orange, burgundy, and purple light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static low-angle wide-angle view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0035263041500002146 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.128526210784912 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0035263041500002146, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0035263041500002146, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.31141817569732666, + 0.11844009906053543, + 0.1832495927810669, + 0.05012553930282593, + 0.07239515334367752, + 0.03856973722577095, + 0.03600361570715904, + 0.06250976771116257, + 0.08331792056560516, + 0.04397032782435417 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0035263041500002146 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a seascape viewed from the coast looking out to sea?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the foreground composed of damp dark sand with smooth wet rocks and colorful pebbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the ocean deep blue with small waves rolling towards the land?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the sun a fiery molten orb partially obscured on the horizon casting orange, burgundy, and purple light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static low-angle wide-angle view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020586861297488213 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955869674682617 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020586861297488213, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020586861297488213, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11338180303573608, + 0.10895827412605286, + 0.25462067127227783, + 0.08906067162752151, + 0.08715303242206573, + 0.14812710881233215, + 0.03800647705793381, + 0.057086437940597534, + 0.06576318293809891, + 0.03784235194325447 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020586861297488213 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a seascape viewed from the coast looking out to sea?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the foreground composed of damp dark sand with smooth wet rocks and colorful pebbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the ocean deep blue with small waves rolling towards the land?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the sun a fiery molten orb partially obscured on the horizon casting orange, burgundy, and purple light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static low-angle wide-angle view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22560006380081177 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.600600004196167 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.22560006380081177, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.22560006380081177, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.30772119760513306, + 0.10063086450099945, + 0.22538067400455475, + 0.11758711189031601, + 0.04263132065534592, + 0.05312199518084526, + 0.022257309406995773, + 0.04710400477051735, + 0.02878904715180397, + 0.05477649345993996 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.22560006380081177 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a seascape viewed from the coast looking out to sea?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the foreground composed of damp dark sand with smooth wet rocks and colorful pebbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the ocean deep blue with small waves rolling towards the land?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the sun a fiery molten orb partially obscured on the horizon casting orange, burgundy, and purple light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static low-angle wide-angle view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006741754245012999 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006741523742676 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006741754245012999, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006741754245012999, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2199729084968567, + 0.06823331117630005, + 0.212127223610878, + 0.14517611265182495, + 0.0485389307141304, + 0.05417574942111969, + 0.059184104204177856, + 0.07656247168779373, + 0.029560858383774757, + 0.08646834641695023 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006741754245012999 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a seascape viewed from the coast looking out to sea?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the foreground composed of damp dark sand with smooth wet rocks and colorful pebbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the ocean deep blue with small waves rolling towards the land?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the sun a fiery molten orb partially obscured on the horizon casting orange, burgundy, and purple light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static low-angle wide-angle view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06203316152095795 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812033176422119 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06203316152095795, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06203316152095795, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15848973393440247, + 0.0842636376619339, + 0.20685864984989166, + 0.06734969466924667, + 0.06823255866765976, + 0.071151003241539, + 0.1462404429912567, + 0.07383905351161957, + 0.03294697776436806, + 0.09062820672988892 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06203316152095795 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, low-angle, wide-angle shot establishes a remarkably tranquil seascape from the perspective of the coast, looking directly out to sea at sunset. In the immediate foreground, the coastline offers a rich texture, composed of damp, dark sand, interspersed with a variety of smooth, wet rocks and colorful pebbles that shimmer under the night sky. The central region is dominated by the deep blue ocean, its surface brimming with gentle, relentless energy. Small waves rhythmically roll towards the land, their crests catching the last rays of light in shimmering golden ripples. On the distant horizon, the sun, a fiery, molten orb, is partially obscured as it sinks majestically, casting a spectacular, warm glow across the sky in a gradation of fiery orange, deep burgundy, and soft purple. This golden, hour-long light creates a shimmering path across the water, guiding the viewer's gaze from shore to horizon, bathing the entire scene in a warm, tranquil glow, evoking a powerful atmosphere of quiet contemplation and the vast beauty of nature.", + "seed": 25409, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_9/index_4892_seed_25409_dp_19_rank_38_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.05684373476542533, + "vlm_logprob": -0.05684373476542533, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.05, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.05684373476542533, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a seascape viewed from the coast looking out to sea?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the foreground composed of damp dark sand with smooth wet rocks and colorful pebbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the ocean deep blue with small waves rolling towards the land?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the sun a fiery molten orb partially obscured on the horizon casting orange, burgundy, and purple light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static low-angle wide-angle view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0032170468475669622 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.5032172203063965 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0032170468475669622, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0032170468475669622, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23181243240833282, + 0.07728825509548187, + 0.05485215783119202, + 0.06621710956096649, + 0.10687781125307083, + 0.17160576581954956, + 0.10359952598810196, + 0.05284736678004265, + 0.04343796521425247, + 0.09146159887313843 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0032170468475669622 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a seascape viewed from the coast looking out to sea?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the foreground composed of damp dark sand with smooth wet rocks and colorful pebbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the ocean deep blue with small waves rolling towards the land?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the sun a fiery molten orb partially obscured on the horizon casting orange, burgundy, and purple light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static low-angle wide-angle view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0097829420119524 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634782791137695 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0097829420119524, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0097829420119524, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.42348700761795044, + 0.1510540097951889, + 0.059854719787836075, + 0.049572817981243134, + 0.06814805418252945, + 0.06488601118326187, + 0.057839591056108475, + 0.03249579668045044, + 0.02738739736378193, + 0.06527465581893921 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0097829420119524 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a seascape viewed from the coast looking out to sea?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the foreground composed of damp dark sand with smooth wet rocks and colorful pebbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the ocean deep blue with small waves rolling towards the land?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the sun a fiery molten orb partially obscured on the horizon casting orange, burgundy, and purple light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static low-angle wide-angle view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2015630304813385 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7015630006790161 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2015630304813385, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2015630304813385, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2205154001712799, + 0.09195435047149658, + 0.05437753349542618, + 0.04749344661831856, + 0.24744108319282532, + 0.12072371691465378, + 0.11735084652900696, + 0.03112570010125637, + 0.03235664218664169, + 0.03666133061051369 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2015630304813385 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a seascape viewed from the coast looking out to sea?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the foreground composed of damp dark sand with smooth wet rocks and colorful pebbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the ocean deep blue with small waves rolling towards the land?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the sun a fiery molten orb partially obscured on the horizon casting orange, burgundy, and purple light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static low-angle wide-angle view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007631906773895025 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882631778717041 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007631906773895025, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007631906773895025, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22986777126789093, + 0.060150668025016785, + 0.10266119241714478, + 0.07726681977510452, + 0.11866305768489838, + 0.11935202777385712, + 0.12977389991283417, + 0.055573198944330215, + 0.03036954067647457, + 0.07632181793451309 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007631906773895025 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a seascape viewed from the coast looking out to sea?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the foreground composed of damp dark sand with smooth wet rocks and colorful pebbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the ocean deep blue with small waves rolling towards the land?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the sun a fiery molten orb partially obscured on the horizon casting orange, burgundy, and purple light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static low-angle wide-angle view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.062023747712373734 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812023639678955 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.062023747712373734, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.062023747712373734, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11397534608840942, + 0.11039188504219055, + 0.16991908848285675, + 0.06507907062768936, + 0.13718228042125702, + 0.034208837896585464, + 0.2052299827337265, + 0.06150389462709427, + 0.05202188342809677, + 0.05048779025673866 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.062023747712373734 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, low-angle, wide-angle shot establishes a remarkably tranquil seascape from the perspective of the coast, looking directly out to sea at sunset. In the immediate foreground, the coastline offers a rich texture, composed of damp, dark sand, interspersed with a variety of smooth, wet rocks and colorful pebbles that shimmer under the night sky. The central region is dominated by the deep blue ocean, its surface brimming with gentle, relentless energy. Small waves rhythmically roll towards the land, their crests catching the last rays of light in shimmering golden ripples. On the distant horizon, the sun, a fiery, molten orb, is partially obscured as it sinks majestically, casting a spectacular, warm glow across the sky in a gradation of fiery orange, deep burgundy, and soft purple. This golden, hour-long light creates a shimmering path across the water, guiding the viewer's gaze from shore to horizon, bathing the entire scene in a warm, tranquil glow, evoking a powerful atmosphere of quiet contemplation and the vast beauty of nature.", + "seed": 25410, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000081/group_9/index_4892_seed_25410_dp_19_rank_38_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.030334409046918153, + "vlm_logprob": -0.030334409046918153, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.225, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.030334409046918153, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a seascape viewed from the coast looking out to sea?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the foreground composed of damp dark sand with smooth wet rocks and colorful pebbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the ocean deep blue with small waves rolling towards the land?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the sun a fiery molten orb partially obscured on the horizon casting orange, burgundy, and purple light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static low-angle wide-angle view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0028852284885942936 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.752885341644287 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0028852284885942936, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0028852284885942936, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25834959745407104, + 0.20906393229961395, + 0.05173276364803314, + 0.030701614916324615, + 0.04378088191151619, + 0.043727245181798935, + 0.09383625537157059, + 0.13649335503578186, + 0.07676809281110764, + 0.055546268820762634 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0028852284885942936 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a seascape viewed from the coast looking out to sea?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the foreground composed of damp dark sand with smooth wet rocks and colorful pebbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the ocean deep blue with small waves rolling towards the land?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the sun a fiery molten orb partially obscured on the horizon casting orange, burgundy, and purple light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static low-angle wide-angle view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016069306060671806 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141069412231445 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016069306060671806, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016069306060671806, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1487264782190323, + 0.4284172058105469, + 0.042907487601041794, + 0.02621246688067913, + 0.03463936969637871, + 0.021815909072756767, + 0.07333061844110489, + 0.1454361528158188, + 0.024603942409157753, + 0.05391034856438637 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016069306060671806 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a seascape viewed from the coast looking out to sea?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the foreground composed of damp dark sand with smooth wet rocks and colorful pebbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the ocean deep blue with small waves rolling towards the land?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the sun a fiery molten orb partially obscured on the horizon casting orange, burgundy, and purple light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static low-angle wide-angle view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06205209344625473 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812052011489868 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06205209344625473, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06205209344625473, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.46877941489219666, + 0.12382049858570099, + 0.06935738772153854, + 0.039403993636369705, + 0.049472060054540634, + 0.03231528773903847, + 0.040498387068510056, + 0.04714757204055786, + 0.05504941567778587, + 0.07415597140789032 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06205209344625473 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a seascape viewed from the coast looking out to sea?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the foreground composed of damp dark sand with smooth wet rocks and colorful pebbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the ocean deep blue with small waves rolling towards the land?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the sun a fiery molten orb partially obscured on the horizon casting orange, burgundy, and purple light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static low-angle wide-angle view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008638868108391762 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758638858795166 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008638868108391762, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008638868108391762, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3090668320655823, + 0.11586017906665802, + 0.0701962262392044, + 0.06166154146194458, + 0.05527888238430023, + 0.052557941526174545, + 0.05175788328051567, + 0.1713988482952118, + 0.050958722829818726, + 0.061262957751750946 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008638868108391762 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a seascape viewed from the coast looking out to sea?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the foreground composed of damp dark sand with smooth wet rocks and colorful pebbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the ocean deep blue with small waves rolling towards the land?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the sun a fiery molten orb partially obscured on the horizon casting orange, burgundy, and purple light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static low-angle wide-angle view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06202654913067818 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120265007019043 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06202654913067818, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06202654913067818, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16330263018608093, + 0.12862257659435272, + 0.04063727706670761, + 0.02217274159193039, + 0.025703391060233116, + 0.03525902330875397, + 0.06820537149906158, + 0.06932936608791351, + 0.41862812638282776, + 0.028139501810073853 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06202654913067818 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_0/index_tensor([9465, 9465])_group_0_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_0/index_tensor([9465, 9465])_group_0_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..a15128ba78263342a5805c22f82ba3a27239a295 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_0/index_tensor([9465, 9465])_group_0_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "close-up shot from an extremely low angle, using high-speed photography to create a slow-motion effect, focuses on an old, dark brown wooden dining chair, its paint chipped, careening down at breakneck speed onto a rough, dusty concrete floor. The moment the chair legs impact the ground, the immense force of the impact causes it to shatter, sending countless shards of wood, sawdust, and dust scattering in all directions from the point of impact like a volcanic eruption. The slow motion capture clearly reveals the trajectory of each fragment, tumbling and spinning through the air, creating a still image imbued with a violent aesthetic. A cold, overhead spotlight pierces the dense dust, sharply illuminating the flying fragments and casting rapidly shifting shadows across their irregular surfaces. The scene's grim tone evokes a sense of primal destructive force and a momentary tension. The camera vibrates slightly yet violently at the moment of impact, further heightening the impact's realism.", + "seed": 28033, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_0/index_9465_seed_28033_dp_0_rank_0_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.12846759436652064, + "vlm_logprob": -0.12846759436652064, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.325, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.12846759436652064, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an old, dark brown wooden dining chair with chipped paint?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the chair careen down at breakneck speed onto a rough, dusty concrete floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the chair shatter upon impact, sending wood shards, sawdust, and dust scattering in all directions?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a cold, overhead spotlight that pierces the dust and illuminates the flying fragments?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit slight yet violent vibration at the moment of impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.42964842915534973 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.0546483993530273 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.42964842915534973, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.42964842915534973, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.052059605717659, + 0.2399396449327469, + 0.06815171986818314, + 0.019882407039403915, + 0.03197607398033142, + 0.014428587630391121, + 0.05679209530353546, + 0.44704359769821167, + 0.031356796622276306, + 0.03836953639984131 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.42964842915534973 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an old, dark brown wooden dining chair with chipped paint?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the chair careen down at breakneck speed onto a rough, dusty concrete floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the chair shatter upon impact, sending wood shards, sawdust, and dust scattering in all directions?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a cold, overhead spotlight that pierces the dust and illuminates the flying fragments?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit slight yet violent vibration at the moment of impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01608901470899582 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141088962554932 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01608901470899582, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01608901470899582, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0475100539624691, + 0.13623839616775513, + 0.032524384558200836, + 0.020834460854530334, + 0.02415482886135578, + 0.017388230189681053, + 0.030145246535539627, + 0.6409260034561157, + 0.03207594156265259, + 0.01820247434079647 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01608901470899582 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an old, dark brown wooden dining chair with chipped paint?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the chair careen down at breakneck speed onto a rough, dusty concrete floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the chair shatter upon impact, sending wood shards, sawdust, and dust scattering in all directions?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a cold, overhead spotlight that pierces the dust and illuminates the flying fragments?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit slight yet violent vibration at the moment of impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002488494385033846 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002488613128662 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002488494385033846, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002488494385033846, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.019187038764357567, + 0.008694780059158802, + 0.030480463057756424, + 0.010140120051801205, + 0.018936045467853546, + 0.010720031335949898, + 0.020777525380253792, + 0.8597077131271362, + 0.013353163376450539, + 0.00800304301083088 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 2, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002488494385033846 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an old, dark brown wooden dining chair with chipped paint?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the chair careen down at breakneck speed onto a rough, dusty concrete floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the chair shatter upon impact, sending wood shards, sawdust, and dust scattering in all directions?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a cold, overhead spotlight that pierces the dust and illuminates the flying fragments?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit slight yet violent vibration at the moment of impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17992261052131653 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8049225807189941 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17992261052131653, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17992261052131653, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.036805812269449234, + 0.06524013727903366, + 0.09454530477523804, + 0.12008850276470184, + 0.06487362831830978, + 0.032947324216365814, + 0.05831022933125496, + 0.4496191143989563, + 0.03204351291060448, + 0.045526500791311264 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17992261052131653 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an old, dark brown wooden dining chair with chipped paint?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the chair careen down at breakneck speed onto a rough, dusty concrete floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the chair shatter upon impact, sending wood shards, sawdust, and dust scattering in all directions?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a cold, overhead spotlight that pierces the dust and illuminates the flying fragments?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit slight yet violent vibration at the moment of impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014189423061907291 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.26418924331665 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014189423061907291, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014189423061907291, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04359034448862076, + 0.08783751726150513, + 0.15488171577453613, + 0.024626562371850014, + 0.07007350027561188, + 0.03576822951436043, + 0.04905154928565025, + 0.4407895505428314, + 0.06125931814312935, + 0.03212171047925949 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014189423061907291 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up shot from an extremely low angle, using high-speed photography to create a slow-motion effect, focuses on an old, dark brown wooden dining chair, its paint chipped, careening down at breakneck speed onto a rough, dusty concrete floor. The moment the chair legs impact the ground, the immense force of the impact causes it to shatter, sending countless shards of wood, sawdust, and dust scattering in all directions from the point of impact like a volcanic eruption. The slow motion capture clearly reveals the trajectory of each fragment, tumbling and spinning through the air, creating a still image imbued with a violent aesthetic. A cold, overhead spotlight pierces the dense dust, sharply illuminating the flying fragments and casting rapidly shifting shadows across their irregular surfaces. The scene's grim tone evokes a sense of primal destructive force and a momentary tension. The camera vibrates slightly yet violently at the moment of impact, further heightening the impact's realism.", + "seed": 28034, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_0/index_9465_seed_28034_dp_0_rank_0_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.17331025060266256, + "vlm_logprob": -0.17331025060266256, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.225, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.17331025060266256, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an old, dark brown wooden dining chair with chipped paint?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the chair careen down at breakneck speed onto a rough, dusty concrete floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the chair shatter upon impact, sending wood shards, sawdust, and dust scattering in all directions?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a cold, overhead spotlight that pierces the dust and illuminates the flying fragments?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit slight yet violent vibration at the moment of impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.38795244693756104 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.137952446937561 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.38795244693756104, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.38795244693756104, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1469772607088089, + 0.18175943195819855, + 0.07343272119760513, + 0.03531743213534355, + 0.07147303223609924, + 0.11700282990932465, + 0.14272353053092957, + 0.07403335720300674, + 0.05383269116282463, + 0.10344770550727844 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.38795244693756104 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an old, dark brown wooden dining chair with chipped paint?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the chair careen down at breakneck speed onto a rough, dusty concrete floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the chair shatter upon impact, sending wood shards, sawdust, and dust scattering in all directions?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a cold, overhead spotlight that pierces the dust and illuminates the flying fragments?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit slight yet violent vibration at the moment of impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16042517125606537 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9104251861572266 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16042517125606537, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16042517125606537, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06405794620513916, + 0.10842755436897278, + 0.04477246478199959, + 0.05065598711371422, + 0.32464778423309326, + 0.1815616488456726, + 0.05691647157073021, + 0.09123245626688004, + 0.03665974363684654, + 0.04106791317462921 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16042517125606537 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an old, dark brown wooden dining chair with chipped paint?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the chair careen down at breakneck speed onto a rough, dusty concrete floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the chair shatter upon impact, sending wood shards, sawdust, and dust scattering in all directions?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a cold, overhead spotlight that pierces the dust and illuminates the flying fragments?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit slight yet violent vibration at the moment of impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01108358334749937 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511083602905273 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01108358334749937, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01108358334749937, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06677205860614777, + 0.13425813615322113, + 0.11427486687898636, + 0.06041909009218216, + 0.14724744856357574, + 0.08443015813827515, + 0.17053736746311188, + 0.08459243923425674, + 0.034852951765060425, + 0.10261544585227966 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01108358334749937 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an old, dark brown wooden dining chair with chipped paint?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the chair careen down at breakneck speed onto a rough, dusty concrete floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the chair shatter upon impact, sending wood shards, sawdust, and dust scattering in all directions?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a cold, overhead spotlight that pierces the dust and illuminates the flying fragments?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit slight yet violent vibration at the moment of impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.25213000178337097 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5021300315856934 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.25213000178337097, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.25213000178337097, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09888941794633865, + 0.11447327584028244, + 0.10343227535486221, + 0.06434276700019836, + 0.13497097790241241, + 0.07371048629283905, + 0.18372702598571777, + 0.05996016040444374, + 0.05213615670800209, + 0.11435752362012863 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.25213000178337097 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an old, dark brown wooden dining chair with chipped paint?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the chair careen down at breakneck speed onto a rough, dusty concrete floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the chair shatter upon impact, sending wood shards, sawdust, and dust scattering in all directions?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a cold, overhead spotlight that pierces the dust and illuminates the flying fragments?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit slight yet violent vibration at the moment of impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05496004968881607 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929960012435913 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05496004968881607, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05496004968881607, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11777377128601074, + 0.10819962620735168, + 0.07730569690465927, + 0.06782687455415726, + 0.21342043578624725, + 0.026940707117319107, + 0.13868583738803864, + 0.04044003039598465, + 0.0877617821097374, + 0.12164519727230072 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05496004968881607 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up shot from an extremely low angle, using high-speed photography to create a slow-motion effect, focuses on an old, dark brown wooden dining chair, its paint chipped, careening down at breakneck speed onto a rough, dusty concrete floor. The moment the chair legs impact the ground, the immense force of the impact causes it to shatter, sending countless shards of wood, sawdust, and dust scattering in all directions from the point of impact like a volcanic eruption. The slow motion capture clearly reveals the trajectory of each fragment, tumbling and spinning through the air, creating a still image imbued with a violent aesthetic. A cold, overhead spotlight pierces the dense dust, sharply illuminating the flying fragments and casting rapidly shifting shadows across their irregular surfaces. The scene's grim tone evokes a sense of primal destructive force and a momentary tension. The camera vibrates slightly yet violently at the moment of impact, further heightening the impact's realism.", + "seed": 28035, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_0/index_9465_seed_28035_dp_1_rank_2_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.034725624765269456, + "vlm_logprob": -0.034725624765269456, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.85, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.034725624765269456, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an old, dark brown wooden dining chair with chipped paint?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the chair careen down at breakneck speed onto a rough, dusty concrete floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the chair shatter upon impact, sending wood shards, sawdust, and dust scattering in all directions?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a cold, overhead spotlight that pierces the dust and illuminates the flying fragments?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit slight yet violent vibration at the moment of impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06267012655735016 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8126702308654785 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06267012655735016, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06267012655735016, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.33435866236686707, + 0.03260517492890358, + 0.043844129890203476, + 0.07922914624214172, + 0.20738261938095093, + 0.08527030050754547, + 0.039624717086553574, + 0.07595207542181015, + 0.0436512790620327, + 0.05808195471763611 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06267012655735016 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an old, dark brown wooden dining chair with chipped paint?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the chair careen down at breakneck speed onto a rough, dusty concrete floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the chair shatter upon impact, sending wood shards, sawdust, and dust scattering in all directions?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a cold, overhead spotlight that pierces the dust and illuminates the flying fragments?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit slight yet violent vibration at the moment of impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020609049126505852 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895609140396118 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020609049126505852, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020609049126505852, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14974278211593628, + 0.06059559807181358, + 0.08008769899606705, + 0.07081391662359238, + 0.276547908782959, + 0.17143800854682922, + 0.037299416959285736, + 0.06453651934862137, + 0.045489151030778885, + 0.0434490330517292 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020609049126505852 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an old, dark brown wooden dining chair with chipped paint?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the chair careen down at breakneck speed onto a rough, dusty concrete floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the chair shatter upon impact, sending wood shards, sawdust, and dust scattering in all directions?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a cold, overhead spotlight that pierces the dust and illuminates the flying fragments?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit slight yet violent vibration at the moment of impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0019408691441640258 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.251940727233887 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0019408691441640258, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0019408691441640258, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04270893335342407, + 0.016947776079177856, + 0.030341533944010735, + 0.040276750922203064, + 0.15205305814743042, + 0.5733659863471985, + 0.020451299846172333, + 0.06941629946231842, + 0.03575286641716957, + 0.01868549734354019 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0019408691441640258 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an old, dark brown wooden dining chair with chipped paint?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the chair careen down at breakneck speed onto a rough, dusty concrete floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the chair shatter upon impact, sending wood shards, sawdust, and dust scattering in all directions?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a cold, overhead spotlight that pierces the dust and illuminates the flying fragments?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit slight yet violent vibration at the moment of impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06207024306058884 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.81207013130188 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06207024306058884, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06207024306058884, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13132141530513763, + 0.05229641869664192, + 0.06387311220169067, + 0.07093765586614609, + 0.28040874004364014, + 0.06321939826011658, + 0.04853681102395058, + 0.09074629843235016, + 0.11820393055677414, + 0.0804562196135521 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06207024306058884 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an old, dark brown wooden dining chair with chipped paint?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the chair careen down at breakneck speed onto a rough, dusty concrete floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the chair shatter upon impact, sending wood shards, sawdust, and dust scattering in all directions?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a cold, overhead spotlight that pierces the dust and illuminates the flying fragments?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit slight yet violent vibration at the moment of impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02633783593773842 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513378620147705 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02633783593773842, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02633783593773842, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11036495864391327, + 0.0323009230196476, + 0.032954517751932144, + 0.06766774505376816, + 0.30744293332099915, + 0.24805475771427155, + 0.030882207676768303, + 0.04974951595067978, + 0.07131563872098923, + 0.04926678538322449 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02633783593773842 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up shot from an extremely low angle, using high-speed photography to create a slow-motion effect, focuses on an old, dark brown wooden dining chair, its paint chipped, careening down at breakneck speed onto a rough, dusty concrete floor. The moment the chair legs impact the ground, the immense force of the impact causes it to shatter, sending countless shards of wood, sawdust, and dust scattering in all directions from the point of impact like a volcanic eruption. The slow motion capture clearly reveals the trajectory of each fragment, tumbling and spinning through the air, creating a still image imbued with a violent aesthetic. A cold, overhead spotlight pierces the dense dust, sharply illuminating the flying fragments and casting rapidly shifting shadows across their irregular surfaces. The scene's grim tone evokes a sense of primal destructive force and a momentary tension. The camera vibrates slightly yet violently at the moment of impact, further heightening the impact's realism.", + "seed": 28036, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_0/index_9465_seed_28036_dp_1_rank_2_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.20322061963379384, + "vlm_logprob": -0.20322061963379384, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.725, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.20322061963379384, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an old, dark brown wooden dining chair with chipped paint?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the chair careen down at breakneck speed onto a rough, dusty concrete floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the chair shatter upon impact, sending wood shards, sawdust, and dust scattering in all directions?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a cold, overhead spotlight that pierces the dust and illuminates the flying fragments?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit slight yet violent vibration at the moment of impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8266043663024902 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5766043663024902 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.8266043663024902, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.8266043663024902, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1514623761177063, + 0.14283102750778198, + 0.10229116678237915, + 0.1323852837085724, + 0.15255701541900635, + 0.08923058211803436, + 0.037501927465200424, + 0.1070965901017189, + 0.02902011200785637, + 0.05562397837638855 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.8266043663024902 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an old, dark brown wooden dining chair with chipped paint?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the chair careen down at breakneck speed onto a rough, dusty concrete floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the chair shatter upon impact, sending wood shards, sawdust, and dust scattering in all directions?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a cold, overhead spotlight that pierces the dust and illuminates the flying fragments?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit slight yet violent vibration at the moment of impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.062089961022138596 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120899200439453 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.062089961022138596, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.062089961022138596, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10455460101366043, + 0.15216198563575745, + 0.09463921934366226, + 0.1821621209383011, + 0.09781155735254288, + 0.0751073807477951, + 0.05811181291937828, + 0.10523886978626251, + 0.0914282277226448, + 0.03878416493535042 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.062089961022138596 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an old, dark brown wooden dining chair with chipped paint?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the chair careen down at breakneck speed onto a rough, dusty concrete floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the chair shatter upon impact, sending wood shards, sawdust, and dust scattering in all directions?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a cold, overhead spotlight that pierces the dust and illuminates the flying fragments?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit slight yet violent vibration at the moment of impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004639456048607826 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379639625549316 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004639456048607826, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004639456048607826, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07340563833713531, + 0.10063407570123672, + 0.08110333979129791, + 0.3565964996814728, + 0.0629555955529213, + 0.07189302891492844, + 0.0789555013179779, + 0.07456587255001068, + 0.06037843972444534, + 0.039511971175670624 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004639456048607826 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an old, dark brown wooden dining chair with chipped paint?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the chair careen down at breakneck speed onto a rough, dusty concrete floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the chair shatter upon impact, sending wood shards, sawdust, and dust scattering in all directions?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a cold, overhead spotlight that pierces the dust and illuminates the flying fragments?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit slight yet violent vibration at the moment of impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08907294273376465 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4640729427337646 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08907294273376465, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08907294273376465, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10881567001342773, + 0.08064017444849014, + 0.13691206276416779, + 0.0583156943321228, + 0.09230966120958328, + 0.1515517383813858, + 0.11329817026853561, + 0.1046563982963562, + 0.07794149965047836, + 0.0755588710308075 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 2, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08907294273376465 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an old, dark brown wooden dining chair with chipped paint?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the chair careen down at breakneck speed onto a rough, dusty concrete floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the chair shatter upon impact, sending wood shards, sawdust, and dust scattering in all directions?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a cold, overhead spotlight that pierces the dust and illuminates the flying fragments?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit slight yet violent vibration at the moment of impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03369637206196785 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408696413040161 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03369637206196785, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03369637206196785, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07955221831798553, + 0.1250944286584854, + 0.09976352006196976, + 0.22009961307048798, + 0.19990625977516174, + 0.03650563210248947, + 0.0722547248005867, + 0.08891656994819641, + 0.02965257316827774, + 0.048254501074552536 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03369637206196785 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_1/index_tensor([7123, 7123])_group_1_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_1/index_tensor([7123, 7123])_group_1_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..cdb7343f607996a9e6ffa331746047ea87f105ed --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_1/index_tensor([7123, 7123])_group_1_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "close-up shot from above, captured in extreme slow motion using an ultra-high-speed camera, captures the decisive moment. A pristine, flat, unfolded $100 bill rests against a matte black background. Benjamin Franklin's portrait, the blue security thread, and the delicate engravings are strikingly clear under the soft overhead light. Suddenly, a rapidly spinning bullet pierces the frame vertically from above. The intense friction between the brass tip and the air produces a fiery, almost incandescent orange glow, the sole dynamic source of light in the otherwise dark scene. The moment the bullet's tip contacts the bill, the paper fibers stretch and deform at a visible speed, then violently tear apart, creating a widening tear. Countless tiny paper and ink particles are blasted in all directions by the impact, the edges of the tear slightly curling and charring from the scorching heat of the bullet. The bullet penetrates effortlessly, continuing its unstoppable trajectory, leaving a rough-edged but perfectly shaped circular hole in the center of the banknote. The entire banknote trembles and undulates violently due to this instantaneous violent impact, forming ripples. The entire picture is full of power and the aesthetics of destruction, and the atmosphere is tense and shocking.", + "seed": 21057, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_1/index_7123_seed_21057_dp_2_rank_4_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.05555493752472103, + "vlm_logprob": -0.05555493752472103, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.8, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.05555493752472103, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from above of a pristine, flat, unfolded $100 bill on a matte black background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a rapidly spinning bullet piercing the frame vertically from above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bullet's brass tip produce a fiery, incandescent orange glow upon contact with the bill?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the paper fibers stretch, deform, and tear apart with tiny particles blasting in all directions upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in extreme slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16220328211784363 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.912203311920166 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16220328211784363, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16220328211784363, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14772100746631622, + 0.07062792778015137, + 0.0898609608411789, + 0.21156899631023407, + 0.06741119921207428, + 0.05196578800678253, + 0.0437922328710556, + 0.023521531373262405, + 0.21258489787578583, + 0.08094547688961029 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16220328211784363 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from above of a pristine, flat, unfolded $100 bill on a matte black background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a rapidly spinning bullet piercing the frame vertically from above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bullet's brass tip produce a fiery, incandescent orange glow upon contact with the bill?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the paper fibers stretch, deform, and tear apart with tiny particles blasting in all directions upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in extreme slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01609042100608349 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141090393066406 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01609042100608349, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01609042100608349, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4139774739742279, + 0.10218079388141632, + 0.05374092608690262, + 0.17697109282016754, + 0.036617379635572433, + 0.06209056079387665, + 0.020299484953284264, + 0.02404535934329033, + 0.051119256764650345, + 0.05895768851041794 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01609042100608349 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from above of a pristine, flat, unfolded $100 bill on a matte black background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a rapidly spinning bullet piercing the frame vertically from above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bullet's brass tip produce a fiery, incandescent orange glow upon contact with the bill?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the paper fibers stretch, deform, and tear apart with tiny particles blasting in all directions upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in extreme slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007632380351424217 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882632255554199 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007632380351424217, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007632380351424217, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21037566661834717, + 0.07573331892490387, + 0.12759162485599518, + 0.10853186994791031, + 0.0297517329454422, + 0.019343994557857513, + 0.019378865137696266, + 0.023140814155340195, + 0.10271498560905457, + 0.2834371030330658 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007632380351424217 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from above of a pristine, flat, unfolded $100 bill on a matte black background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a rapidly spinning bullet piercing the frame vertically from above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bullet's brass tip produce a fiery, incandescent orange glow upon contact with the bill?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the paper fibers stretch, deform, and tear apart with tiny particles blasting in all directions upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in extreme slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002822227543219924 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877822399139404 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002822227543219924, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002822227543219924, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12918131053447723, + 0.07798747718334198, + 0.09487093240022659, + 0.2077488899230957, + 0.04725024104118347, + 0.048442576080560684, + 0.028202712535858154, + 0.03448106348514557, + 0.12164310365915298, + 0.21019166707992554 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002822227543219924 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from above of a pristine, flat, unfolded $100 bill on a matte black background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a rapidly spinning bullet piercing the frame vertically from above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bullet's brass tip produce a fiery, incandescent orange glow upon contact with the bill?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the paper fibers stretch, deform, and tear apart with tiny particles blasting in all directions upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in extreme slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08902637660503387 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.46402645111084 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08902637660503387, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08902637660503387, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15715545415878296, + 0.04766663536429405, + 0.13257181644439697, + 0.055456049740314484, + 0.07072900235652924, + 0.13041111826896667, + 0.04370003193616867, + 0.03347493335604668, + 0.12655292451381683, + 0.20228207111358643 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08902637660503387 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up shot from above, captured in extreme slow motion using an ultra-high-speed camera, captures the decisive moment. A pristine, flat, unfolded $100 bill rests against a matte black background. Benjamin Franklin's portrait, the blue security thread, and the delicate engravings are strikingly clear under the soft overhead light. Suddenly, a rapidly spinning bullet pierces the frame vertically from above. The intense friction between the brass tip and the air produces a fiery, almost incandescent orange glow, the sole dynamic source of light in the otherwise dark scene. The moment the bullet's tip contacts the bill, the paper fibers stretch and deform at a visible speed, then violently tear apart, creating a widening tear. Countless tiny paper and ink particles are blasted in all directions by the impact, the edges of the tear slightly curling and charring from the scorching heat of the bullet. The bullet penetrates effortlessly, continuing its unstoppable trajectory, leaving a rough-edged but perfectly shaped circular hole in the center of the banknote. The entire banknote trembles and undulates violently due to this instantaneous violent impact, forming ripples. The entire picture is full of power and the aesthetics of destruction, and the atmosphere is tense and shocking.", + "seed": 21058, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_1/index_7123_seed_21058_dp_2_rank_4_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.7351556512527168, + "vlm_logprob": -0.7351556512527168, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.25, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.7351556512527168, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from above of a pristine, flat, unfolded $100 bill on a matte black background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a rapidly spinning bullet piercing the frame vertically from above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bullet's brass tip produce a fiery, incandescent orange glow upon contact with the bill?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the paper fibers stretch, deform, and tear apart with tiny particles blasting in all directions upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in extreme slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.530230760574341 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.030230749398469925 + ], + "logprob_reward": -3.530230760574341, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -3.530230760574341, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11986038833856583, + 0.11203273385763168, + 0.34151342511177063, + 0.06079544872045517, + 0.08289160579442978, + 0.03326486796140671, + 0.07603611052036285, + 0.02740796096622944, + 0.03855909779667854, + 0.1076384112238884 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -3.530230760574341 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from above of a pristine, flat, unfolded $100 bill on a matte black background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a rapidly spinning bullet piercing the frame vertically from above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bullet's brass tip produce a fiery, incandescent orange glow upon contact with the bill?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the paper fibers stretch, deform, and tear apart with tiny particles blasting in all directions upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in extreme slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.055237021297216415 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.930237054824829 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.055237021297216415, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.055237021297216415, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13130243122577667, + 0.08321000635623932, + 0.34856972098350525, + 0.04905237630009651, + 0.049604058265686035, + 0.027608312666416168, + 0.08001156151294708, + 0.0403943732380867, + 0.06446276605129242, + 0.12578439712524414 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.055237021297216415 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from above of a pristine, flat, unfolded $100 bill on a matte black background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a rapidly spinning bullet piercing the frame vertically from above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bullet's brass tip produce a fiery, incandescent orange glow upon contact with the bill?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the paper fibers stretch, deform, and tear apart with tiny particles blasting in all directions upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in extreme slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012584207579493523 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387584209442139 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012584207579493523, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012584207579493523, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10279227793216705, + 0.06942406296730042, + 0.3378147482872009, + 0.04851368069648743, + 0.03679884970188141, + 0.047352198511362076, + 0.15069709718227386, + 0.03782700374722481, + 0.06566585600376129, + 0.10311415791511536 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012584207579493523 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from above of a pristine, flat, unfolded $100 bill on a matte black background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a rapidly spinning bullet piercing the frame vertically from above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bullet's brass tip produce a fiery, incandescent orange glow upon contact with the bill?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the paper fibers stretch, deform, and tear apart with tiny particles blasting in all directions upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in extreme slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007649652194231749 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.8826494216918945 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007649652194231749, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007649652194231749, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15029029548168182, + 0.09716752171516418, + 0.2790583074092865, + 0.048706937581300735, + 0.08526643365621567, + 0.05952339246869087, + 0.055628977715969086, + 0.034866150468587875, + 0.062403444200754166, + 0.1270885318517685 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007649652194231749 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from above of a pristine, flat, unfolded $100 bill on a matte black background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a rapidly spinning bullet piercing the frame vertically from above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bullet's brass tip produce a fiery, incandescent orange glow upon contact with the bill?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the paper fibers stretch, deform, and tear apart with tiny particles blasting in all directions upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in extreme slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07007661461830139 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950767040252686 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07007661461830139, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07007661461830139, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09670957922935486, + 0.11096567660570145, + 0.27949485182762146, + 0.03882211819291115, + 0.034089747816324234, + 0.07491666078567505, + 0.08780322223901749, + 0.09108783304691315, + 0.07910522818565369, + 0.10700508952140808 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07007661461830139 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up shot from above, captured in extreme slow motion using an ultra-high-speed camera, captures the decisive moment. A pristine, flat, unfolded $100 bill rests against a matte black background. Benjamin Franklin's portrait, the blue security thread, and the delicate engravings are strikingly clear under the soft overhead light. Suddenly, a rapidly spinning bullet pierces the frame vertically from above. The intense friction between the brass tip and the air produces a fiery, almost incandescent orange glow, the sole dynamic source of light in the otherwise dark scene. The moment the bullet's tip contacts the bill, the paper fibers stretch and deform at a visible speed, then violently tear apart, creating a widening tear. Countless tiny paper and ink particles are blasted in all directions by the impact, the edges of the tear slightly curling and charring from the scorching heat of the bullet. The bullet penetrates effortlessly, continuing its unstoppable trajectory, leaving a rough-edged but perfectly shaped circular hole in the center of the banknote. The entire banknote trembles and undulates violently due to this instantaneous violent impact, forming ripples. The entire picture is full of power and the aesthetics of destruction, and the atmosphere is tense and shocking.", + "seed": 21059, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_1/index_7123_seed_21059_dp_3_rank_6_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.049419344030320646, + "vlm_logprob": -0.049419344030320646, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.75, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.049419344030320646, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from above of a pristine, flat, unfolded $100 bill on a matte black background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a rapidly spinning bullet piercing the frame vertically from above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bullet's brass tip produce a fiery, incandescent orange glow upon contact with the bill?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the paper fibers stretch, deform, and tear apart with tiny particles blasting in all directions upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in extreme slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16300897300243378 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9130089282989502 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16300897300243378, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16300897300243378, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3274039328098297, + 0.09682679176330566, + 0.07743117958307266, + 0.03491637483239174, + 0.06334736943244934, + 0.11313899606466293, + 0.04765555262565613, + 0.12450447678565979, + 0.04507891833782196, + 0.06969635933637619 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16300897300243378 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from above of a pristine, flat, unfolded $100 bill on a matte black background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a rapidly spinning bullet piercing the frame vertically from above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bullet's brass tip produce a fiery, incandescent orange glow upon contact with the bill?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the paper fibers stretch, deform, and tear apart with tiny particles blasting in all directions upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in extreme slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029820885509252548 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298209190368652 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029820885509252548, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029820885509252548, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25003424286842346, + 0.17013676464557648, + 0.08328650146722794, + 0.06062759459018707, + 0.017662515863776207, + 0.06262987852096558, + 0.05037929490208626, + 0.14143137633800507, + 0.11058588325977325, + 0.053225841373205185 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029820885509252548 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from above of a pristine, flat, unfolded $100 bill on a matte black background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a rapidly spinning bullet piercing the frame vertically from above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bullet's brass tip produce a fiery, incandescent orange glow upon contact with the bill?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the paper fibers stretch, deform, and tear apart with tiny particles blasting in all directions upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in extreme slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005953910294920206 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130953788757324 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005953910294920206, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005953910294920206, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2781105041503906, + 0.36085444688796997, + 0.052823878824710846, + 0.029073117300868034, + 0.02077767625451088, + 0.04976921156048775, + 0.0637197494506836, + 0.03785308077931404, + 0.03311026096343994, + 0.07390810549259186 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005953910294920206 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from above of a pristine, flat, unfolded $100 bill on a matte black background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a rapidly spinning bullet piercing the frame vertically from above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bullet's brass tip produce a fiery, incandescent orange glow upon contact with the bill?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the paper fibers stretch, deform, and tear apart with tiny particles blasting in all directions upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in extreme slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00525640370324254 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255256175994873 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00525640370324254, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00525640370324254, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2898117005825043, + 0.1651425063610077, + 0.04345294460654259, + 0.08580809831619263, + 0.02896963432431221, + 0.14002488553524017, + 0.08078756928443909, + 0.031057903543114662, + 0.06615705788135529, + 0.06878768652677536 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00525640370324254 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from above of a pristine, flat, unfolded $100 bill on a matte black background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a rapidly spinning bullet piercing the frame vertically from above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bullet's brass tip produce a fiery, incandescent orange glow upon contact with the bill?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the paper fibers stretch, deform, and tear apart with tiny particles blasting in all directions upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in extreme slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04305654764175415 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680564880371094 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04305654764175415, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04305654764175415, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1332339197397232, + 0.12855537235736847, + 0.07400241494178772, + 0.07811400294303894, + 0.03488743305206299, + 0.07041538506746292, + 0.12449193000793457, + 0.12408056855201721, + 0.13837291300296783, + 0.09384605288505554 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04305654764175415 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up shot from above, captured in extreme slow motion using an ultra-high-speed camera, captures the decisive moment. A pristine, flat, unfolded $100 bill rests against a matte black background. Benjamin Franklin's portrait, the blue security thread, and the delicate engravings are strikingly clear under the soft overhead light. Suddenly, a rapidly spinning bullet pierces the frame vertically from above. The intense friction between the brass tip and the air produces a fiery, almost incandescent orange glow, the sole dynamic source of light in the otherwise dark scene. The moment the bullet's tip contacts the bill, the paper fibers stretch and deform at a visible speed, then violently tear apart, creating a widening tear. Countless tiny paper and ink particles are blasted in all directions by the impact, the edges of the tear slightly curling and charring from the scorching heat of the bullet. The bullet penetrates effortlessly, continuing its unstoppable trajectory, leaving a rough-edged but perfectly shaped circular hole in the center of the banknote. The entire banknote trembles and undulates violently due to this instantaneous violent impact, forming ripples. The entire picture is full of power and the aesthetics of destruction, and the atmosphere is tense and shocking.", + "seed": 21060, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_1/index_7123_seed_21060_dp_3_rank_6_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.06566770360805094, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06566770360805094, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.575, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06566770360805094, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from above of a pristine, flat, unfolded $100 bill on a matte black background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a rapidly spinning bullet piercing the frame vertically from above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bullet's brass tip produce a fiery, incandescent orange glow upon contact with the bill?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the paper fibers stretch, deform, and tear apart with tiny particles blasting in all directions upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in extreme slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1814860850572586 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8064861297607422 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1814860850572586, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1814860850572586, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2696573734283447, + 0.1190614104270935, + 0.056831102818250656, + 0.0979747474193573, + 0.0464136078953743, + 0.09930925816297531, + 0.16944564878940582, + 0.04369373247027397, + 0.05436025932431221, + 0.0432528480887413 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1814860850572586 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from above of a pristine, flat, unfolded $100 bill on a matte black background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a rapidly spinning bullet piercing the frame vertically from above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bullet's brass tip produce a fiery, incandescent orange glow upon contact with the bill?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the paper fibers stretch, deform, and tear apart with tiny particles blasting in all directions upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in extreme slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04868850111961365 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486884117126465 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04868850111961365, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04868850111961365, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10322657972574234, + 0.09386463463306427, + 0.26009052991867065, + 0.06702717393636703, + 0.14542661607265472, + 0.07615325599908829, + 0.09092008322477341, + 0.05314360186457634, + 0.0655880719423294, + 0.044559501111507416 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04868850111961365 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from above of a pristine, flat, unfolded $100 bill on a matte black background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a rapidly spinning bullet piercing the frame vertically from above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bullet's brass tip produce a fiery, incandescent orange glow upon contact with the bill?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the paper fibers stretch, deform, and tear apart with tiny particles blasting in all directions upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in extreme slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005950473714619875 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130950450897217 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005950473714619875, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005950473714619875, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10018064826726913, + 0.08494306355714798, + 0.15860910713672638, + 0.21527689695358276, + 0.025823235511779785, + 0.055998124182224274, + 0.2151884287595749, + 0.0329492911696434, + 0.05488651618361473, + 0.05614469200372696 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 6, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005950473714619875 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from above of a pristine, flat, unfolded $100 bill on a matte black background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a rapidly spinning bullet piercing the frame vertically from above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bullet's brass tip produce a fiery, incandescent orange glow upon contact with the bill?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the paper fibers stretch, deform, and tear apart with tiny particles blasting in all directions upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in extreme slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0031935188453644514 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753193378448486 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0031935188453644514, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0031935188453644514, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08655440807342529, + 0.050368815660476685, + 0.04262546822428703, + 0.09797929227352142, + 0.05668477341532707, + 0.11013689637184143, + 0.24687348306179047, + 0.08141026645898819, + 0.14653557538986206, + 0.08083094656467438 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0031935188453644514 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from above of a pristine, flat, unfolded $100 bill on a matte black background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a rapidly spinning bullet piercing the frame vertically from above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bullet's brass tip produce a fiery, incandescent orange glow upon contact with the bill?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the paper fibers stretch, deform, and tear apart with tiny particles blasting in all directions upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in extreme slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08901993930339813 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.464020013809204 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08901993930339813, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08901993930339813, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2768131196498871, + 0.11672265827655792, + 0.0787290409207344, + 0.07250276207923889, + 0.06367906928062439, + 0.06530831754207611, + 0.18986748158931732, + 0.02951081097126007, + 0.0756276324391365, + 0.031239168718457222 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08901993930339813 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_10/index_tensor([2646, 2646])_group_10_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_10/index_tensor([2646, 2646])_group_10_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..c522eaeacbc64a841a5de8200b8830571fdad9aa --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_10/index_tensor([2646, 2646])_group_10_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "stunning close-up, statically captured in a 16:9 aspect ratio, captures the digital miracle of life, steeped in a refined, nostalgic gaming aesthetic. Against a solid background of dark blue and purple pixels, a compact, spherical bud, its surface composed of crimson and magenta pixels, is the sole focal point. Its surface, composed of blocks of crimson and magenta pixels, is subtly dithered to create a subtle three-dimensional effect. With a silent start, the outermost layer of pixelated petals at the bud's tip cautiously pokes open, revealing the more vibrant layers of color within. Then, with a fluid, yet distinctly digital rhythm, the entire flower visibly unfolds, layer upon layer of pixelated petals unfolding one by one, each with a distinct pixelated outline, as if meticulously painted by a skilled pixel artist. A soft, analog overhead light illuminates this slow blossoming process, casting simple, yet defined pixel shadows across the petals. Eventually, the flower fully opens into a perfect, symmetrical blossom with a vintage digital aesthetic, its limited yet saturated color palette contrasting beautifully with the deep background, creating a high-definition pixel art atmosphere that is both serene and captivating.", + "seed": 7989, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_10/index_2646_seed_7989_dp_20_rank_40_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.041070919833146036, + "vlm_logprob": -0.041070919833146036, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.65, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.041070919833146036, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in a static close-up shot with a 16:9 aspect ratio?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a solid dark blue and purple pixelated surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the flower bud initially compact and spherical with a surface of crimson and magenta pixels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the flower unfold layer by layer from a closed bud into a fully open symmetrical blossom?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a soft overhead light casting defined pixel shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.09086672961711884 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.465866804122925 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.09086672961711884, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.09086672961711884, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.230857253074646, + 0.1435461938381195, + 0.046793382614851, + 0.550668478012085, + 0.003862316021695733, + 0.0056798807345330715, + 0.005240229424089193, + 0.006187152583152056, + 0.004777010064572096, + 0.002388069638982415 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.09086672961711884 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in a static close-up shot with a 16:9 aspect ratio?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a solid dark blue and purple pixelated surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the flower bud initially compact and spherical with a surface of crimson and magenta pixels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the flower unfold layer by layer from a closed bud into a fully open symmetrical blossom?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a soft overhead light casting defined pixel shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04306728392839432 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168067216873169 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04306728392839432, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04306728392839432, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.40314286947250366, + 0.3187505900859833, + 0.11568622291088104, + 0.04326752945780754, + 0.06710319221019745, + 0.01735244132578373, + 0.005958838853985071, + 0.017796166241168976, + 0.004001265857368708, + 0.006940935738384724 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04306728392839432 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in a static close-up shot with a 16:9 aspect ratio?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a solid dark blue and purple pixelated surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the flower bud initially compact and spherical with a surface of crimson and magenta pixels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the flower unfold layer by layer from a closed bud into a fully open symmetrical blossom?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a soft overhead light casting defined pixel shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0011801904765889049 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.751180171966553 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0011801904765889049, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0011801904765889049, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3153376877307892, + 0.23972879350185394, + 0.04883702099323273, + 0.2746756970882416, + 0.010593860410153866, + 0.04316003993153572, + 0.01288379356265068, + 0.03435925766825676, + 0.007399577647447586, + 0.013024318031966686 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0011801904765889049 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in a static close-up shot with a 16:9 aspect ratio?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a solid dark blue and purple pixelated surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the flower bud initially compact and spherical with a surface of crimson and magenta pixels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the flower unfold layer by layer from a closed bud into a fully open symmetrical blossom?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a soft overhead light casting defined pixel shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00023636408150196075 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -8.375236511230469 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00023636408150196075, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 8.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00023636408150196075, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2545434236526489, + 0.16300615668296814, + 0.035396259278059006, + 0.3547770082950592, + 0.006370858289301395, + 0.10313402861356735, + 0.015663616359233856, + 0.032362159341573715, + 0.01634591445326805, + 0.018400609493255615 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00023636408150196075 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in a static close-up shot with a 16:9 aspect ratio?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a solid dark blue and purple pixelated surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the flower bud initially compact and spherical with a surface of crimson and magenta pixels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the flower unfold layer by layer from a closed bud into a fully open symmetrical blossom?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a soft overhead light casting defined pixel shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07000403106212616 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950039863586426 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07000403106212616, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07000403106212616, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5023303031921387, + 0.10935749113559723, + 0.07265151292085648, + 0.0811610072851181, + 0.021931007504463196, + 0.023827921599149704, + 0.05615060031414032, + 0.10563554614782333, + 0.012346012517809868, + 0.014608589932322502 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07000403106212616 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "stunning close-up, statically captured in a 16:9 aspect ratio, captures the digital miracle of life, steeped in a refined, nostalgic gaming aesthetic. Against a solid background of dark blue and purple pixels, a compact, spherical bud, its surface composed of crimson and magenta pixels, is the sole focal point. Its surface, composed of blocks of crimson and magenta pixels, is subtly dithered to create a subtle three-dimensional effect. With a silent start, the outermost layer of pixelated petals at the bud's tip cautiously pokes open, revealing the more vibrant layers of color within. Then, with a fluid, yet distinctly digital rhythm, the entire flower visibly unfolds, layer upon layer of pixelated petals unfolding one by one, each with a distinct pixelated outline, as if meticulously painted by a skilled pixel artist. A soft, analog overhead light illuminates this slow blossoming process, casting simple, yet defined pixel shadows across the petals. Eventually, the flower fully opens into a perfect, symmetrical blossom with a vintage digital aesthetic, its limited yet saturated color palette contrasting beautifully with the deep background, creating a high-definition pixel art atmosphere that is both serene and captivating.", + "seed": 7990, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_10/index_2646_seed_7990_dp_20_rank_40_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.03904635065700859, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03904635065700859, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.85, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03904635065700859, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in a static close-up shot with a 16:9 aspect ratio?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a solid dark blue and purple pixelated surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the flower bud initially compact and spherical with a surface of crimson and magenta pixels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the flower unfold layer by layer from a closed bud into a fully open symmetrical blossom?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a soft overhead light casting defined pixel shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.028041698038578033 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6530416011810303 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.028041698038578033, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.028041698038578033, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0963606908917427, + 0.04050792008638382, + 0.07979769259691238, + 0.06819429993629456, + 0.04490198194980621, + 0.1289599984884262, + 0.26600784063339233, + 0.10563972592353821, + 0.13704811036586761, + 0.032581694424152374 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.028041698038578033 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in a static close-up shot with a 16:9 aspect ratio?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a solid dark blue and purple pixelated surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the flower bud initially compact and spherical with a surface of crimson and magenta pixels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the flower unfold layer by layer from a closed bud into a fully open symmetrical blossom?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a soft overhead light casting defined pixel shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023291101679205894 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732911109924316 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023291101679205894, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023291101679205894, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20026077330112457, + 0.11028073728084564, + 0.061166729778051376, + 0.07429879158735275, + 0.07671665400266647, + 0.0698266252875328, + 0.04845592379570007, + 0.03185258433222771, + 0.21695224940776825, + 0.11018886417150497 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023291101679205894 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in a static close-up shot with a 16:9 aspect ratio?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a solid dark blue and purple pixelated surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the flower bud initially compact and spherical with a surface of crimson and magenta pixels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the flower unfold layer by layer from a closed bud into a fully open symmetrical blossom?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a soft overhead light casting defined pixel shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.000633992429357022 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.37563419342041 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.000633992429357022, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.000633992429357022, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2078249603509903, + 0.07974112033843994, + 0.17513751983642578, + 0.055111438035964966, + 0.08721574395895004, + 0.13828527927398682, + 0.07600913196802139, + 0.047361988574266434, + 0.08185352385044098, + 0.051459312438964844 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.000633992429357022 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in a static close-up shot with a 16:9 aspect ratio?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a solid dark blue and purple pixelated surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the flower bud initially compact and spherical with a surface of crimson and magenta pixels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the flower unfold layer by layer from a closed bud into a fully open symmetrical blossom?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a soft overhead light casting defined pixel shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0004944770480506122 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.625494480133057 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0004944770480506122, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0004944770480506122, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07492617517709732, + 0.0366533026099205, + 0.07284551858901978, + 0.044905886054039, + 0.06096287816762924, + 0.10364635288715363, + 0.07526915520429611, + 0.02756473980844021, + 0.4264753460884094, + 0.07675065100193024 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0004944770480506122 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in a static close-up shot with a 16:9 aspect ratio?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a solid dark blue and purple pixelated surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the flower bud initially compact and spherical with a surface of crimson and magenta pixels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the flower unfold layer by layer from a closed bud into a fully open symmetrical blossom?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a soft overhead light casting defined pixel shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14277048408985138 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.017770528793335 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14277048408985138, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14277048408985138, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09386830031871796, + 0.0367504246532917, + 0.04793857783079147, + 0.1049332469701767, + 0.06642545014619827, + 0.14053550362586975, + 0.07628919929265976, + 0.13752295076847076, + 0.24248936772346497, + 0.05324694886803627 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14277048408985138 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "stunning close-up, statically captured in a 16:9 aspect ratio, captures the digital miracle of life, steeped in a refined, nostalgic gaming aesthetic. Against a solid background of dark blue and purple pixels, a compact, spherical bud, its surface composed of crimson and magenta pixels, is the sole focal point. Its surface, composed of blocks of crimson and magenta pixels, is subtly dithered to create a subtle three-dimensional effect. With a silent start, the outermost layer of pixelated petals at the bud's tip cautiously pokes open, revealing the more vibrant layers of color within. Then, with a fluid, yet distinctly digital rhythm, the entire flower visibly unfolds, layer upon layer of pixelated petals unfolding one by one, each with a distinct pixelated outline, as if meticulously painted by a skilled pixel artist. A soft, analog overhead light illuminates this slow blossoming process, casting simple, yet defined pixel shadows across the petals. Eventually, the flower fully opens into a perfect, symmetrical blossom with a vintage digital aesthetic, its limited yet saturated color palette contrasting beautifully with the deep background, creating a high-definition pixel art atmosphere that is both serene and captivating.", + "seed": 7991, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_10/index_2646_seed_7991_dp_21_rank_42_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.16250916111748664, + "vlm_logprob": -0.16250916111748664, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.75, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.16250916111748664, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in a static close-up shot with a 16:9 aspect ratio?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a solid dark blue and purple pixelated surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the flower bud initially compact and spherical with a surface of crimson and magenta pixels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the flower unfold layer by layer from a closed bud into a fully open symmetrical blossom?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a soft overhead light casting defined pixel shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06475938111543655 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8147594928741455 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06475938111543655, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06475938111543655, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06388311833143234, + 0.03238760307431221, + 0.06791041046380997, + 0.029268644750118256, + 0.034466858953237534, + 0.15301114320755005, + 0.36645692586898804, + 0.09049877524375916, + 0.13797278702259064, + 0.024143721908330917 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06475938111543655 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in a static close-up shot with a 16:9 aspect ratio?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a solid dark blue and purple pixelated surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the flower bud initially compact and spherical with a surface of crimson and magenta pixels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the flower unfold layer by layer from a closed bud into a fully open symmetrical blossom?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a soft overhead light casting defined pixel shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6327765583992004 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7577765583992004 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.6327765583992004, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.6327765583992004, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3643401563167572, + 0.2075623720884323, + 0.05923264101147652, + 0.08740232139825821, + 0.027695855125784874, + 0.13693742454051971, + 0.04045175760984421, + 0.028709465637803078, + 0.03224285691976547, + 0.015425180085003376 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.6327765583992004 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in a static close-up shot with a 16:9 aspect ratio?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a solid dark blue and purple pixelated surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the flower bud initially compact and spherical with a surface of crimson and magenta pixels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the flower unfold layer by layer from a closed bud into a fully open symmetrical blossom?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a soft overhead light casting defined pixel shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0010434903670102358 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.876043319702148 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0010434903670102358, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0010434903670102358, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15794850885868073, + 0.08022686839103699, + 0.08603399991989136, + 0.06232652813196182, + 0.024202678352594376, + 0.059192705899477005, + 0.05252934992313385, + 0.3587544560432434, + 0.08126601576805115, + 0.03751886263489723 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0010434903670102358 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in a static close-up shot with a 16:9 aspect ratio?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a solid dark blue and purple pixelated surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the flower bud initially compact and spherical with a surface of crimson and magenta pixels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the flower unfold layer by layer from a closed bud into a fully open symmetrical blossom?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a soft overhead light casting defined pixel shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.001042656716890633 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.87604284286499 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.001042656716890633, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.001042656716890633, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06258301436901093, + 0.04279633238911629, + 0.06195274367928505, + 0.03602850064635277, + 0.02655286341905594, + 0.03811994567513466, + 0.09831815212965012, + 0.1634773463010788, + 0.39018309116363525, + 0.0799880102276802 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.001042656716890633 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in a static close-up shot with a 16:9 aspect ratio?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a solid dark blue and purple pixelated surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the flower bud initially compact and spherical with a surface of crimson and magenta pixels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the flower unfold layer by layer from a closed bud into a fully open symmetrical blossom?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a soft overhead light casting defined pixel shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11292371898889542 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2379236221313477 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11292371898889542, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11292371898889542, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07448726147413254, + 0.04917391389608383, + 0.02285217121243477, + 0.027123412117362022, + 0.02793305367231369, + 0.08701667934656143, + 0.2399599254131317, + 0.09117259085178375, + 0.30370020866394043, + 0.0765807256102562 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11292371898889542 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "stunning close-up, statically captured in a 16:9 aspect ratio, captures the digital miracle of life, steeped in a refined, nostalgic gaming aesthetic. Against a solid background of dark blue and purple pixels, a compact, spherical bud, its surface composed of crimson and magenta pixels, is the sole focal point. Its surface, composed of blocks of crimson and magenta pixels, is subtly dithered to create a subtle three-dimensional effect. With a silent start, the outermost layer of pixelated petals at the bud's tip cautiously pokes open, revealing the more vibrant layers of color within. Then, with a fluid, yet distinctly digital rhythm, the entire flower visibly unfolds, layer upon layer of pixelated petals unfolding one by one, each with a distinct pixelated outline, as if meticulously painted by a skilled pixel artist. A soft, analog overhead light illuminates this slow blossoming process, casting simple, yet defined pixel shadows across the petals. Eventually, the flower fully opens into a perfect, symmetrical blossom with a vintage digital aesthetic, its limited yet saturated color palette contrasting beautifully with the deep background, creating a high-definition pixel art atmosphere that is both serene and captivating.", + "seed": 7992, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_10/index_2646_seed_7992_dp_21_rank_42_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.0740338780276943, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0740338780276943, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.85, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0740338780276943, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in a static close-up shot with a 16:9 aspect ratio?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a solid dark blue and purple pixelated surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the flower bud initially compact and spherical with a surface of crimson and magenta pixels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the flower unfold layer by layer from a closed bud into a fully open symmetrical blossom?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a soft overhead light casting defined pixel shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08040735125541687 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5804073810577393 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08040735125541687, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08040735125541687, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06033329665660858, + 0.18340261280536652, + 0.2206602245569229, + 0.029635924845933914, + 0.011754828505218029, + 0.043010953813791275, + 0.2854941487312317, + 0.1484326422214508, + 0.012165410444140434, + 0.005110025871545076 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08040735125541687 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in a static close-up shot with a 16:9 aspect ratio?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a solid dark blue and purple pixelated surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the flower bud initially compact and spherical with a surface of crimson and magenta pixels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the flower unfold layer by layer from a closed bud into a fully open symmetrical blossom?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a soft overhead light casting defined pixel shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00763652054592967 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882636547088623 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00763652054592967, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00763652054592967, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.290339857339859, + 0.1919034868478775, + 0.06900016963481903, + 0.1086796373128891, + 0.039479948580265045, + 0.04762827977538109, + 0.14303915202617645, + 0.047669798135757446, + 0.03343556448817253, + 0.0288240909576416 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00763652054592967 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in a static close-up shot with a 16:9 aspect ratio?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a solid dark blue and purple pixelated surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the flower bud initially compact and spherical with a surface of crimson and magenta pixels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the flower unfold layer by layer from a closed bud into a fully open symmetrical blossom?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a soft overhead light casting defined pixel shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0005609607324004173 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.500560760498047 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0005609607324004173, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0005609607324004173, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08648216724395752, + 0.16029676795005798, + 0.5049765706062317, + 0.032959144562482834, + 0.05697246268391609, + 0.017780352383852005, + 0.028349565342068672, + 0.07976388186216354, + 0.017281536012887955, + 0.015137611888349056 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0005609607324004173 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in a static close-up shot with a 16:9 aspect ratio?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a solid dark blue and purple pixelated surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the flower bud initially compact and spherical with a surface of crimson and magenta pixels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the flower unfold layer by layer from a closed bud into a fully open symmetrical blossom?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a soft overhead light casting defined pixel shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00026723151677288115 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -8.250267028808594 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00026723151677288115, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 8.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00026723151677288115, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07011574506759644, + 0.2148706167936325, + 0.25227004289627075, + 0.05623726546764374, + 0.04632222652435303, + 0.053461890667676926, + 0.12242553383111954, + 0.14104683697223663, + 0.02060515433549881, + 0.022644687443971634 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00026723151677288115 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in a static close-up shot with a 16:9 aspect ratio?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a solid dark blue and purple pixelated surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the flower bud initially compact and spherical with a surface of crimson and magenta pixels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the flower unfold layer by layer from a closed bud into a fully open symmetrical blossom?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a soft overhead light casting defined pixel shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.28129732608795166 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4062973260879517 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.28129732608795166, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.28129732608795166, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10436969250440598, + 0.20826515555381775, + 0.02759762667119503, + 0.03924384340643883, + 0.08690911531448364, + 0.08368272334337234, + 0.039377547800540924, + 0.36605456471443176, + 0.01882661134004593, + 0.025673123076558113 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.28129732608795166 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_11/index_tensor([2874, 2874])_group_11_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_11/index_tensor([2874, 2874])_group_11_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..278d980048abf9ecf51cb0c301cf50657e85e31a --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_11/index_tensor([2874, 2874])_group_11_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "This extreme close-up, rendered in a hyperrealistic style, begins with the camera holding static over a glistening, translucent pool of melted wax on a thick, cream-colored candle. The liquid wax, emitting a warm golden glow from the invisible flame above, gently overflows its cratered edges. A small amount of wax is meticulously gathered into a perfect, viscous bead, its surface tension momentarily holding it together before the camera begins a slow, deliberate downward tilt, following the irresistible pull of gravity. The droplet begins to slide slowly along the textured, uneven side of the candle, leaving a shimmering, translucent trail behind the previously solidified droplet. As it nears the bottom edge, the droplet's own weight causes it to elongate, stretching into a teardrop shape, its neck tapering. The warm candlelight beautifully refracts through its increasingly elongated form. In the final moments, the connection breaks cleanly, and the droplet separates, plummeting a short distance to a dark, polished wooden tabletop below. Its rich texture is visible in the soft, flickering ambient light, creating an atmosphere of tranquility and concentration captured with intense macroscopic detail and physically accurate fluid dynamics.", + "seed": 6240, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_11/index_2874_seed_6240_dp_22_rank_44_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.032334601134061815, + "vlm_logprob": -0.032334601134061815, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.85, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.032334601134061815, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a glistening, translucent pool of melted wax on a thick, cream-colored candle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the liquid wax overflow its cratered edges and form a viscous bead held by surface tension?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a static hold and then perform a slow, deliberate downward tilt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the wax droplet slide down the textured candle side, elongate into a teardrop shape, and separate cleanly to fall onto a dark, polished wooden tabletop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a hyperrealistic style with intense macroscopic detail and physically accurate fluid dynamics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.017818963155150414 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.267818927764893 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.017818963155150414, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.017818963155150414, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03018595464527607, + 0.027563773095607758, + 0.00635543605312705, + 0.00631306366994977, + 0.015988612547516823, + 0.011221894063055515, + 0.05158557742834091, + 0.035444844514131546, + 0.6595137715339661, + 0.1558271199464798 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.017818963155150414 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a glistening, translucent pool of melted wax on a thick, cream-colored candle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the liquid wax overflow its cratered edges and form a viscous bead held by surface tension?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a static hold and then perform a slow, deliberate downward tilt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the wax droplet slide down the textured candle side, elongate into a teardrop shape, and separate cleanly to fall onto a dark, polished wooden tabletop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a hyperrealistic style with intense macroscopic detail and physically accurate fluid dynamics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10036294162273407 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.35036301612854 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10036294162273407, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10036294162273407, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.009853451512753963, + 0.008246212266385555, + 0.004718376323580742, + 0.002288372255861759, + 0.02981559745967388, + 0.003776228055357933, + 0.38930371403694153, + 0.03596026450395584, + 0.4322107136249542, + 0.08382710069417953 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10036294162273407 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a glistening, translucent pool of melted wax on a thick, cream-colored candle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the liquid wax overflow its cratered edges and form a viscous bead held by surface tension?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a static hold and then perform a slow, deliberate downward tilt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the wax droplet slide down the textured candle side, elongate into a teardrop shape, and separate cleanly to fall onto a dark, polished wooden tabletop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a hyperrealistic style with intense macroscopic detail and physically accurate fluid dynamics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01819128356873989 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018191337585449 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01819128356873989, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01819128356873989, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.008717671036720276, + 0.009761813096702099, + 0.006634850986301899, + 0.005071672145277262, + 0.028860483318567276, + 0.008910591714084148, + 0.7855435013771057, + 0.05274639278650284, + 0.06493297219276428, + 0.028819993138313293 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01819128356873989 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a glistening, translucent pool of melted wax on a thick, cream-colored candle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the liquid wax overflow its cratered edges and form a viscous bead held by surface tension?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a static hold and then perform a slow, deliberate downward tilt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the wax droplet slide down the textured candle side, elongate into a teardrop shape, and separate cleanly to fall onto a dark, polished wooden tabletop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a hyperrealistic style with intense macroscopic detail and physically accurate fluid dynamics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011088181287050247 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.5110883712768555 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011088181287050247, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011088181287050247, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.019326984882354736, + 0.009499788284301758, + 0.00382909900508821, + 0.004960852209478617, + 0.005135032348334789, + 0.008802813477814198, + 0.37548041343688965, + 0.04154490679502487, + 0.41344141960144043, + 0.11797863990068436 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011088181287050247 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a glistening, translucent pool of melted wax on a thick, cream-colored candle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the liquid wax overflow its cratered edges and form a viscous bead held by surface tension?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a static hold and then perform a slow, deliberate downward tilt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the wax droplet slide down the textured candle side, elongate into a teardrop shape, and separate cleanly to fall onto a dark, polished wooden tabletop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a hyperrealistic style with intense macroscopic detail and physically accurate fluid dynamics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014211636036634445 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264211654663086 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014211636036634445, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014211636036634445, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.023458480834960938, + 0.018222225829958916, + 0.004065416287630796, + 0.004253859631717205, + 0.022194581106305122, + 0.0072594597004354, + 0.3311925232410431, + 0.07255090773105621, + 0.403391569852829, + 0.11341097950935364 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014211636036634445 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "This extreme close-up, rendered in a hyperrealistic style, begins with the camera holding static over a glistening, translucent pool of melted wax on a thick, cream-colored candle. The liquid wax, emitting a warm golden glow from the invisible flame above, gently overflows its cratered edges. A small amount of wax is meticulously gathered into a perfect, viscous bead, its surface tension momentarily holding it together before the camera begins a slow, deliberate downward tilt, following the irresistible pull of gravity. The droplet begins to slide slowly along the textured, uneven side of the candle, leaving a shimmering, translucent trail behind the previously solidified droplet. As it nears the bottom edge, the droplet's own weight causes it to elongate, stretching into a teardrop shape, its neck tapering. The warm candlelight beautifully refracts through its increasingly elongated form. In the final moments, the connection breaks cleanly, and the droplet separates, plummeting a short distance to a dark, polished wooden tabletop below. Its rich texture is visible in the soft, flickering ambient light, creating an atmosphere of tranquility and concentration captured with intense macroscopic detail and physically accurate fluid dynamics.", + "seed": 6241, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_11/index_2874_seed_6241_dp_22_rank_44_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.03520823111757636, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03520823111757636, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.9, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03520823111757636, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a glistening, translucent pool of melted wax on a thick, cream-colored candle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the liquid wax overflow its cratered edges and form a viscous bead held by surface tension?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a static hold and then perform a slow, deliberate downward tilt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the wax droplet slide down the textured candle side, elongate into a teardrop shape, and separate cleanly to fall onto a dark, polished wooden tabletop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a hyperrealistic style with intense macroscopic detail and physically accurate fluid dynamics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01702011190354824 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.267020225524902 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01702011190354824, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01702011190354824, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15328235924243927, + 0.1444482058286667, + 0.08414527028799057, + 0.050826817750930786, + 0.0759526863694191, + 0.09441471099853516, + 0.06722328066825867, + 0.1126440018415451, + 0.09298916161060333, + 0.12407346069812775 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01702011190354824 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a glistening, translucent pool of melted wax on a thick, cream-colored candle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the liquid wax overflow its cratered edges and form a viscous bead held by surface tension?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a static hold and then perform a slow, deliberate downward tilt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the wax droplet slide down the textured candle side, elongate into a teardrop shape, and separate cleanly to fall onto a dark, polished wooden tabletop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a hyperrealistic style with intense macroscopic detail and physically accurate fluid dynamics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029821693897247314 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298216342926025 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029821693897247314, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029821693897247314, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11919454485177994, + 0.09903989732265472, + 0.06768856942653656, + 0.06883960217237473, + 0.06728695333003998, + 0.11409403383731842, + 0.05896822735667229, + 0.07222771644592285, + 0.10446447134017944, + 0.228195920586586 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029821693897247314 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a glistening, translucent pool of melted wax on a thick, cream-colored candle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the liquid wax overflow its cratered edges and form a viscous bead held by surface tension?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a static hold and then perform a slow, deliberate downward tilt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the wax droplet slide down the textured candle side, elongate into a teardrop shape, and separate cleanly to fall onto a dark, polished wooden tabletop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a hyperrealistic style with intense macroscopic detail and physically accurate fluid dynamics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11291509866714478 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2379150390625 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11291509866714478, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11291509866714478, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24140870571136475, + 0.055747680366039276, + 0.0775366723537445, + 0.06565114855766296, + 0.09775889664888382, + 0.048964738845825195, + 0.0576607845723629, + 0.14205269515514374, + 0.15118370950222015, + 0.062034972012043 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11291509866714478 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a glistening, translucent pool of melted wax on a thick, cream-colored candle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the liquid wax overflow its cratered edges and form a viscous bead held by surface tension?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a static hold and then perform a slow, deliberate downward tilt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the wax droplet slide down the textured candle side, elongate into a teardrop shape, and separate cleanly to fall onto a dark, polished wooden tabletop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a hyperrealistic style with intense macroscopic detail and physically accurate fluid dynamics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007635101210325956 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882635116577148 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007635101210325956, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007635101210325956, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16582033038139343, + 0.148070827126503, + 0.049269307404756546, + 0.0685921236872673, + 0.0800701156258583, + 0.10309059917926788, + 0.03411466255784035, + 0.09315317124128342, + 0.07476432621479034, + 0.18305452167987823 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007635101210325956 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a glistening, translucent pool of melted wax on a thick, cream-colored candle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the liquid wax overflow its cratered edges and form a viscous bead held by surface tension?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a static hold and then perform a slow, deliberate downward tilt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the wax droplet slide down the textured candle side, elongate into a teardrop shape, and separate cleanly to fall onto a dark, polished wooden tabletop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a hyperrealistic style with intense macroscopic detail and physically accurate fluid dynamics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008649149909615517 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.7586493492126465 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008649149909615517, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008649149909615517, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3163784444332123, + 0.11225621402263641, + 0.052520882338285446, + 0.03744868189096451, + 0.05927184224128723, + 0.03245237469673157, + 0.08267582952976227, + 0.10549367964267731, + 0.061243630945682526, + 0.14025840163230896 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008649149909615517 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "This extreme close-up, rendered in a hyperrealistic style, begins with the camera holding static over a glistening, translucent pool of melted wax on a thick, cream-colored candle. The liquid wax, emitting a warm golden glow from the invisible flame above, gently overflows its cratered edges. A small amount of wax is meticulously gathered into a perfect, viscous bead, its surface tension momentarily holding it together before the camera begins a slow, deliberate downward tilt, following the irresistible pull of gravity. The droplet begins to slide slowly along the textured, uneven side of the candle, leaving a shimmering, translucent trail behind the previously solidified droplet. As it nears the bottom edge, the droplet's own weight causes it to elongate, stretching into a teardrop shape, its neck tapering. The warm candlelight beautifully refracts through its increasingly elongated form. In the final moments, the connection breaks cleanly, and the droplet separates, plummeting a short distance to a dark, polished wooden tabletop below. Its rich texture is visible in the soft, flickering ambient light, creating an atmosphere of tranquility and concentration captured with intense macroscopic detail and physically accurate fluid dynamics.", + "seed": 6242, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_11/index_2874_seed_6242_dp_23_rank_46_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.030990708246827127, + "vlm_logprob": -0.030990708246827127, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.675, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.030990708246827127, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a glistening, translucent pool of melted wax on a thick, cream-colored candle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the liquid wax overflow its cratered edges and form a viscous bead held by surface tension?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a static hold and then perform a slow, deliberate downward tilt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the wax droplet slide down the textured candle side, elongate into a teardrop shape, and separate cleanly to fall onto a dark, polished wooden tabletop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a hyperrealistic style with intense macroscopic detail and physically accurate fluid dynamics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016155289486050606 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.266155242919922 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016155289486050606, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016155289486050606, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07172037661075592, + 0.2268100380897522, + 0.01960093341767788, + 0.05154764652252197, + 0.05968056619167328, + 0.1553124636411667, + 0.10839740186929703, + 0.06376197189092636, + 0.1320754885673523, + 0.11109312623739243 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 5, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016155289486050606 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a glistening, translucent pool of melted wax on a thick, cream-colored candle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the liquid wax overflow its cratered edges and form a viscous bead held by surface tension?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a static hold and then perform a slow, deliberate downward tilt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the wax droplet slide down the textured candle side, elongate into a teardrop shape, and separate cleanly to fall onto a dark, polished wooden tabletop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a hyperrealistic style with intense macroscopic detail and physically accurate fluid dynamics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07006482779979706 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950647830963135 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07006482779979706, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07006482779979706, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03294740244746208, + 0.28982314467430115, + 0.014061682857573032, + 0.044590264558792114, + 0.022758301347494125, + 0.021290073171257973, + 0.1557885855436325, + 0.18894270062446594, + 0.07381315529346466, + 0.15598468482494354 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07006482779979706 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a glistening, translucent pool of melted wax on a thick, cream-colored candle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the liquid wax overflow its cratered edges and form a viscous bead held by surface tension?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a static hold and then perform a slow, deliberate downward tilt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the wax droplet slide down the textured candle side, elongate into a teardrop shape, and separate cleanly to fall onto a dark, polished wooden tabletop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a hyperrealistic style with intense macroscopic detail and physically accurate fluid dynamics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012543829157948494 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387543678283691 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012543829157948494, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012543829157948494, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04732714593410492, + 0.19604602456092834, + 0.0258274357765913, + 0.06425022333860397, + 0.0520629808306694, + 0.05152495950460434, + 0.1779172718524933, + 0.13019095361232758, + 0.12057281285524368, + 0.13428016006946564 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012543829157948494 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a glistening, translucent pool of melted wax on a thick, cream-colored candle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the liquid wax overflow its cratered edges and form a viscous bead held by surface tension?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a static hold and then perform a slow, deliberate downward tilt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the wax droplet slide down the textured candle side, elongate into a teardrop shape, and separate cleanly to fall onto a dark, polished wooden tabletop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a hyperrealistic style with intense macroscopic detail and physically accurate fluid dynamics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02636547014117241 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513655185699463 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02636547014117241, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02636547014117241, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.029182374477386475, + 0.4813563823699951, + 0.010255028493702412, + 0.01792132668197155, + 0.009777762927114964, + 0.016472795978188515, + 0.04525955766439438, + 0.13733385503292084, + 0.04671011492609978, + 0.20573076605796814 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02636547014117241 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a glistening, translucent pool of melted wax on a thick, cream-colored candle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the liquid wax overflow its cratered edges and form a viscous bead held by surface tension?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a static hold and then perform a slow, deliberate downward tilt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the wax droplet slide down the textured candle side, elongate into a teardrop shape, and separate cleanly to fall onto a dark, polished wooden tabletop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a hyperrealistic style with intense macroscopic detail and physically accurate fluid dynamics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02982412464916706 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298240184783936 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02982412464916706, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02982412464916706, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.030458800494670868, + 0.08314060419797897, + 0.016564004123210907, + 0.07620766758918762, + 0.02750656008720398, + 0.04589281231164932, + 0.47139444947242737, + 0.03927335515618324, + 0.13491925597190857, + 0.07464244961738586 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02982412464916706 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "This extreme close-up, rendered in a hyperrealistic style, begins with the camera holding static over a glistening, translucent pool of melted wax on a thick, cream-colored candle. The liquid wax, emitting a warm golden glow from the invisible flame above, gently overflows its cratered edges. A small amount of wax is meticulously gathered into a perfect, viscous bead, its surface tension momentarily holding it together before the camera begins a slow, deliberate downward tilt, following the irresistible pull of gravity. The droplet begins to slide slowly along the textured, uneven side of the candle, leaving a shimmering, translucent trail behind the previously solidified droplet. As it nears the bottom edge, the droplet's own weight causes it to elongate, stretching into a teardrop shape, its neck tapering. The warm candlelight beautifully refracts through its increasingly elongated form. In the final moments, the connection breaks cleanly, and the droplet separates, plummeting a short distance to a dark, polished wooden tabletop below. Its rich texture is visible in the soft, flickering ambient light, creating an atmosphere of tranquility and concentration captured with intense macroscopic detail and physically accurate fluid dynamics.", + "seed": 6243, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_11/index_2874_seed_6243_dp_23_rank_46_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.09563893545418978, + "vlm_logprob": -0.09563893545418978, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.125, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.09563893545418978, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a glistening, translucent pool of melted wax on a thick, cream-colored candle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the liquid wax overflow its cratered edges and form a viscous bead held by surface tension?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a static hold and then perform a slow, deliberate downward tilt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the wax droplet slide down the textured candle side, elongate into a teardrop shape, and separate cleanly to fall onto a dark, polished wooden tabletop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a hyperrealistic style with intense macroscopic detail and physically accurate fluid dynamics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02648574858903885 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7764856815338135 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02648574858903885, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02648574858903885, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07753868401050568, + 0.043944600969552994, + 0.027437841519713402, + 0.045019131153821945, + 0.09163567423820496, + 0.1551688313484192, + 0.3604550361633301, + 0.1234300434589386, + 0.026148464530706406, + 0.04922163486480713 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02648574858903885 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a glistening, translucent pool of melted wax on a thick, cream-colored candle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the liquid wax overflow its cratered edges and form a viscous bead held by surface tension?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a static hold and then perform a slow, deliberate downward tilt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the wax droplet slide down the textured candle side, elongate into a teardrop shape, and separate cleanly to fall onto a dark, polished wooden tabletop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a hyperrealistic style with intense macroscopic detail and physically accurate fluid dynamics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11298058182001114 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.237980604171753 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11298058182001114, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11298058182001114, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1254206746816635, + 0.04682186245918274, + 0.08893207460641861, + 0.050794389098882675, + 0.2421349436044693, + 0.15915147960186005, + 0.10888060182332993, + 0.055107954889535904, + 0.07451453059911728, + 0.04824147745966911 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11298058182001114 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a glistening, translucent pool of melted wax on a thick, cream-colored candle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the liquid wax overflow its cratered edges and form a viscous bead held by surface tension?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a static hold and then perform a slow, deliberate downward tilt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the wax droplet slide down the textured candle side, elongate into a teardrop shape, and separate cleanly to fall onto a dark, polished wooden tabletop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a hyperrealistic style with intense macroscopic detail and physically accurate fluid dynamics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3134312331676483 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3134312629699707 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3134312331676483, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3134312331676483, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03868087753653526, + 0.022659270092844963, + 0.03480527549982071, + 0.03560647368431091, + 0.5233574509620667, + 0.16555964946746826, + 0.02505633980035782, + 0.09808405488729477, + 0.04815211892127991, + 0.008038533851504326 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3134312331676483 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a glistening, translucent pool of melted wax on a thick, cream-colored candle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the liquid wax overflow its cratered edges and form a viscous bead held by surface tension?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a static hold and then perform a slow, deliberate downward tilt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the wax droplet slide down the textured candle side, elongate into a teardrop shape, and separate cleanly to fall onto a dark, polished wooden tabletop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a hyperrealistic style with intense macroscopic detail and physically accurate fluid dynamics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01108794566243887 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511087894439697 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01108794566243887, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01108794566243887, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.29455918073654175, + 0.04630916193127632, + 0.04550488665699959, + 0.024220092222094536, + 0.12967215478420258, + 0.06492632627487183, + 0.0966724082827568, + 0.19179891049861908, + 0.06772909313440323, + 0.038607798516750336 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01108794566243887 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a glistening, translucent pool of melted wax on a thick, cream-colored candle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the liquid wax overflow its cratered edges and form a viscous bead held by surface tension?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a static hold and then perform a slow, deliberate downward tilt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the wax droplet slide down the textured candle side, elongate into a teardrop shape, and separate cleanly to fall onto a dark, polished wooden tabletop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a hyperrealistic style with intense macroscopic detail and physically accurate fluid dynamics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014209168031811714 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264209270477295 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014209168031811714, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014209168031811714, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4410604238510132, + 0.04529557377099991, + 0.020758600905537605, + 0.026580380275845528, + 0.03442893549799919, + 0.12717102468013763, + 0.06957123428583145, + 0.13760246336460114, + 0.053144585341215134, + 0.0443868488073349 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014209168031811714 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_12/index_tensor([9961, 9961])_group_12_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_12/index_tensor([9961, 9961])_group_12_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..dde9896f4819c3286f0fa6afa0a5ec6ddf6543ab --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_12/index_tensor([9961, 9961])_group_12_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "slow, forward-moving close-up, framed by the dramatic contrast of classic black and white light and shadow, precisely captures a dancer twirling gracefully and seamlessly. Her hair is styled in a sleek, delicate ballet bun, a few strands of sweat-soaked black hair freed by the centrifugal force of the spin, gently brushing against her closed eyes and high nose. Her head tilts back slightly in time with the twirl, her jawline gracefully tensed, a faint, utterly captivated smile playing at the corners of her mouth, as if completely absorbed in the silent melody. A powerful spotlight from above and side, like Rembrandt's brush, sculpts the three-dimensional contours of her face, illuminating the curve of her cheekbones and her sweat-beaded forehead in the highlights while casting deep, soft shadows on the other side, intensifying her intense concentration and selflessness in her art. Her simple dark dance dress reveals a silky luster under the strong light, forming an extreme contrast with her fair skin. The whole picture presents a sculptural sense of tranquility in the dynamic, solidifying the momentary passion and emotion into a timeless portrait full of classical aesthetics and inner monologue.", + "seed": 11394, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_12/index_9961_seed_11394_dp_24_rank_48_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.24774017855525016, + "vlm_logprob": -0.24774017855525016, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.55, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.24774017855525016, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot as a slow, forward-moving close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the dancer wearing a simple dark dance dress with a silky luster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the dancer's hair styled in a sleek ballet bun with a few sweat-soaked strands brushing against her face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a powerful spotlight from above and side creating high contrast between highlights and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the dancer twirling gracefully with her head tilted back and a faint smile on her face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2660788595676422 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5160788297653198 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2660788595676422, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2660788595676422, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1502746343612671, + 0.13997498154640198, + 0.1118302047252655, + 0.11442530155181885, + 0.07524515688419342, + 0.08559048920869827, + 0.14861838519573212, + 0.06921564042568207, + 0.06827576458454132, + 0.036549463868141174 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2660788595676422 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot as a slow, forward-moving close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the dancer wearing a simple dark dance dress with a silky luster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the dancer's hair styled in a sleek ballet bun with a few sweat-soaked strands brushing against her face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a powerful spotlight from above and side creating high contrast between highlights and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the dancer twirling gracefully with her head tilted back and a faint smile on her face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8992152810096741 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5242152810096741 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.8992152810096741, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.8992152810096741, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20095515251159668, + 0.14333903789520264, + 0.07934065908193588, + 0.13924428820610046, + 0.13501685857772827, + 0.0373646579682827, + 0.07528229057788849, + 0.06589416414499283, + 0.03589976206421852, + 0.08766307681798935 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.8992152810096741 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot as a slow, forward-moving close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the dancer wearing a simple dark dance dress with a silky luster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the dancer's hair styled in a sleek ballet bun with a few sweat-soaked strands brushing against her face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a powerful spotlight from above and side creating high contrast between highlights and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the dancer twirling gracefully with her head tilted back and a faint smile on her face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008659668266773224 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758659839630127 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008659668266773224, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008659668266773224, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22660650312900543, + 0.10021886229515076, + 0.11119849979877472, + 0.07447545975446701, + 0.11797552555799484, + 0.05631374195218086, + 0.1162305548787117, + 0.06920607388019562, + 0.04751454293727875, + 0.08026018738746643 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008659668266773224 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot as a slow, forward-moving close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the dancer wearing a simple dark dance dress with a silky luster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the dancer's hair styled in a sleek ballet bun with a few sweat-soaked strands brushing against her face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a powerful spotlight from above and side creating high contrast between highlights and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the dancer twirling gracefully with her head tilted back and a faint smile on her face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016081858426332474 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141081809997559 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016081858426332474, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016081858426332474, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22951361536979675, + 0.058458320796489716, + 0.04818218573927879, + 0.06136627867817879, + 0.12263542413711548, + 0.101495161652565, + 0.18616504967212677, + 0.1019819900393486, + 0.037871140986680984, + 0.05233083292841911 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016081858426332474 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot as a slow, forward-moving close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the dancer wearing a simple dark dance dress with a silky luster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the dancer's hair styled in a sleek ballet bun with a few sweat-soaked strands brushing against her face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a powerful spotlight from above and side creating high contrast between highlights and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the dancer twirling gracefully with her head tilted back and a faint smile on her face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04866522550582886 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486652851104736 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04866522550582886, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04866522550582886, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12940341234207153, + 0.09018901735544205, + 0.10975098609924316, + 0.07992008328437805, + 0.08621987700462341, + 0.05644208565354347, + 0.08347131311893463, + 0.09078852832317352, + 0.051575105637311935, + 0.22223953902721405 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04866522550582886 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow, forward-moving close-up, framed by the dramatic contrast of classic black and white light and shadow, precisely captures a dancer twirling gracefully and seamlessly. Her hair is styled in a sleek, delicate ballet bun, a few strands of sweat-soaked black hair freed by the centrifugal force of the spin, gently brushing against her closed eyes and high nose. Her head tilts back slightly in time with the twirl, her jawline gracefully tensed, a faint, utterly captivated smile playing at the corners of her mouth, as if completely absorbed in the silent melody. A powerful spotlight from above and side, like Rembrandt's brush, sculpts the three-dimensional contours of her face, illuminating the curve of her cheekbones and her sweat-beaded forehead in the highlights while casting deep, soft shadows on the other side, intensifying her intense concentration and selflessness in her art. Her simple dark dance dress reveals a silky luster under the strong light, forming an extreme contrast with her fair skin. The whole picture presents a sculptural sense of tranquility in the dynamic, solidifying the momentary passion and emotion into a timeless portrait full of classical aesthetics and inner monologue.", + "seed": 11395, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_12/index_9961_seed_11395_dp_24_rank_48_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.233014402911067, + "vlm_logprob": -0.233014402911067, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.35, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.233014402911067, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot as a slow, forward-moving close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the dancer wearing a simple dark dance dress with a silky luster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the dancer's hair styled in a sleek ballet bun with a few sweat-soaked strands brushing against her face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a powerful spotlight from above and side creating high contrast between highlights and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the dancer twirling gracefully with her head tilted back and a faint smile on her face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1926262229681015 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8176262378692627 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1926262229681015, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1926262229681015, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.035011857748031616, + 0.4136343002319336, + 0.27519747614860535, + 0.0840793177485466, + 0.06941989809274673, + 0.031798116862773895, + 0.03238803148269653, + 0.015950540080666542, + 0.01701793447136879, + 0.0255025252699852 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1926262229681015 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot as a slow, forward-moving close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the dancer wearing a simple dark dance dress with a silky luster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the dancer's hair styled in a sleek ballet bun with a few sweat-soaked strands brushing against her face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a powerful spotlight from above and side creating high contrast between highlights and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the dancer twirling gracefully with her head tilted back and a faint smile on her face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.827050507068634 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.577050507068634 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.827050507068634, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.827050507068634, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05385890230536461, + 0.5896630883216858, + 0.09422915428876877, + 0.03147345408797264, + 0.06035728007555008, + 0.040638517588377, + 0.05812538415193558, + 0.01706531271338463, + 0.013382532633841038, + 0.04120636731386185 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.827050507068634 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot as a slow, forward-moving close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the dancer wearing a simple dark dance dress with a silky luster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the dancer's hair styled in a sleek ballet bun with a few sweat-soaked strands brushing against her face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a powerful spotlight from above and side creating high contrast between highlights and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the dancer twirling gracefully with her head tilted back and a faint smile on her face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01822078227996826 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018220901489258 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01822078227996826, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01822078227996826, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05829406529664993, + 0.5408845543861389, + 0.13399896025657654, + 0.06366775929927826, + 0.07290845364332199, + 0.025077754631638527, + 0.04236280173063278, + 0.01126298401504755, + 0.013227934017777443, + 0.038314659148454666 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01822078227996826 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot as a slow, forward-moving close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the dancer wearing a simple dark dance dress with a silky luster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the dancer's hair styled in a sleek ballet bun with a few sweat-soaked strands brushing against her face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a powerful spotlight from above and side creating high contrast between highlights and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the dancer twirling gracefully with her head tilted back and a faint smile on her face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014208933338522911 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264208793640137 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014208933338522911, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014208933338522911, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.015025121159851551, + 0.8255021572113037, + 0.05966690182685852, + 0.010691818781197071, + 0.022829949855804443, + 0.006401917897164822, + 0.016773831099271774, + 0.018453462049365044, + 0.005264996085315943, + 0.01938997209072113 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014208933338522911 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot as a slow, forward-moving close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the dancer wearing a simple dark dance dress with a silky luster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the dancer's hair styled in a sleek ballet bun with a few sweat-soaked strands brushing against her face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a powerful spotlight from above and side creating high contrast between highlights and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the dancer twirling gracefully with her head tilted back and a faint smile on her face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11296556890010834 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2379655838012695 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11296556890010834, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11296556890010834, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.02140984684228897, + 0.5972025394439697, + 0.2369011789560318, + 0.020245322957634926, + 0.0325692780315876, + 0.011579860001802444, + 0.033842749893665314, + 0.010168266482651234, + 0.004851260222494602, + 0.0312296524643898 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11296556890010834 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow, forward-moving close-up, framed by the dramatic contrast of classic black and white light and shadow, precisely captures a dancer twirling gracefully and seamlessly. Her hair is styled in a sleek, delicate ballet bun, a few strands of sweat-soaked black hair freed by the centrifugal force of the spin, gently brushing against her closed eyes and high nose. Her head tilts back slightly in time with the twirl, her jawline gracefully tensed, a faint, utterly captivated smile playing at the corners of her mouth, as if completely absorbed in the silent melody. A powerful spotlight from above and side, like Rembrandt's brush, sculpts the three-dimensional contours of her face, illuminating the curve of her cheekbones and her sweat-beaded forehead in the highlights while casting deep, soft shadows on the other side, intensifying her intense concentration and selflessness in her art. Her simple dark dance dress reveals a silky luster under the strong light, forming an extreme contrast with her fair skin. The whole picture presents a sculptural sense of tranquility in the dynamic, solidifying the momentary passion and emotion into a timeless portrait full of classical aesthetics and inner monologue.", + "seed": 11396, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_12/index_9961_seed_11396_dp_25_rank_50_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.11545664938166737, + "vlm_logprob": -0.11545664938166737, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.075, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.11545664938166737, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot as a slow, forward-moving close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the dancer wearing a simple dark dance dress with a silky luster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the dancer's hair styled in a sleek ballet bun with a few sweat-soaked strands brushing against her face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a powerful spotlight from above and side creating high contrast between highlights and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the dancer twirling gracefully with her head tilted back and a faint smile on her face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3327985107898712 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3327984809875488 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3327985107898712, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3327985107898712, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04440957307815552, + 0.06507086008787155, + 0.04992716386914253, + 0.04923142120242119, + 0.25395533442497253, + 0.08356029540300369, + 0.06974264979362488, + 0.27955228090286255, + 0.029247108846902847, + 0.07530339807271957 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3327985107898712 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot as a slow, forward-moving close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the dancer wearing a simple dark dance dress with a silky luster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the dancer's hair styled in a sleek ballet bun with a few sweat-soaked strands brushing against her face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a powerful spotlight from above and side creating high contrast between highlights and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the dancer twirling gracefully with her head tilted back and a faint smile on her face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1800711750984192 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8050711154937744 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1800711750984192, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1800711750984192, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1542946696281433, + 0.17516855895519257, + 0.04531126096844673, + 0.06106190010905266, + 0.22691911458969116, + 0.07536664605140686, + 0.03540676832199097, + 0.08444692939519882, + 0.08338232338428497, + 0.058641862124204636 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1800711750984192 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot as a slow, forward-moving close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the dancer wearing a simple dark dance dress with a silky luster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the dancer's hair styled in a sleek ballet bun with a few sweat-soaked strands brushing against her face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a powerful spotlight from above and side creating high contrast between highlights and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the dancer twirling gracefully with her head tilted back and a faint smile on her face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009800649248063564 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634800434112549 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009800649248063564, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009800649248063564, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06775753200054169, + 0.16899676620960236, + 0.069959357380867, + 0.03332352638244629, + 0.23242774605751038, + 0.10197317600250244, + 0.05565159395337105, + 0.09976416081190109, + 0.07128012925386429, + 0.0988660529255867 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009800649248063564 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot as a slow, forward-moving close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the dancer wearing a simple dark dance dress with a silky luster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the dancer's hair styled in a sleek ballet bun with a few sweat-soaked strands brushing against her face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a powerful spotlight from above and side creating high contrast between highlights and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the dancer twirling gracefully with her head tilted back and a faint smile on her face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005954384338110685 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130954265594482 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005954384338110685, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005954384338110685, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10710934549570084, + 0.29021698236465454, + 0.09860661625862122, + 0.08190125226974487, + 0.15783803164958954, + 0.10685241967439651, + 0.02419726364314556, + 0.025181299075484276, + 0.02690410241484642, + 0.08119270950555801 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005954384338110685 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot as a slow, forward-moving close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the dancer wearing a simple dark dance dress with a silky luster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the dancer's hair styled in a sleek ballet bun with a few sweat-soaked strands brushing against her face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a powerful spotlight from above and side creating high contrast between highlights and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the dancer twirling gracefully with her head tilted back and a faint smile on her face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04865852743387222 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048658609390259 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04865852743387222, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04865852743387222, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09147114306688309, + 0.05332973226904869, + 0.035510145127773285, + 0.030851148068904877, + 0.3505084812641144, + 0.04500756785273552, + 0.05873386561870575, + 0.13341087102890015, + 0.08345112204551697, + 0.11772587150335312 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04865852743387222 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow, forward-moving close-up, framed by the dramatic contrast of classic black and white light and shadow, precisely captures a dancer twirling gracefully and seamlessly. Her hair is styled in a sleek, delicate ballet bun, a few strands of sweat-soaked black hair freed by the centrifugal force of the spin, gently brushing against her closed eyes and high nose. Her head tilts back slightly in time with the twirl, her jawline gracefully tensed, a faint, utterly captivated smile playing at the corners of her mouth, as if completely absorbed in the silent melody. A powerful spotlight from above and side, like Rembrandt's brush, sculpts the three-dimensional contours of her face, illuminating the curve of her cheekbones and her sweat-beaded forehead in the highlights while casting deep, soft shadows on the other side, intensifying her intense concentration and selflessness in her art. Her simple dark dance dress reveals a silky luster under the strong light, forming an extreme contrast with her fair skin. The whole picture presents a sculptural sense of tranquility in the dynamic, solidifying the momentary passion and emotion into a timeless portrait full of classical aesthetics and inner monologue.", + "seed": 11397, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_12/index_9961_seed_11397_dp_25_rank_50_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.18993236422538756, + "vlm_logprob": -0.18993236422538756, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.85, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.18993236422538756, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot as a slow, forward-moving close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the dancer wearing a simple dark dance dress with a silky luster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the dancer's hair styled in a sleek ballet bun with a few sweat-soaked strands brushing against her face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a powerful spotlight from above and side creating high contrast between highlights and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the dancer twirling gracefully with her head tilted back and a faint smile on her face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5910112261772156 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8410112261772156 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5910112261772156, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5910112261772156, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07472243905067444, + 0.12267091125249863, + 0.043277546763420105, + 0.2517901659011841, + 0.09092296659946442, + 0.07073221355676651, + 0.05326849967241287, + 0.12016507238149643, + 0.11028691381216049, + 0.06216326355934143 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5910112261772156 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot as a slow, forward-moving close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the dancer wearing a simple dark dance dress with a silky luster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the dancer's hair styled in a sleek ballet bun with a few sweat-soaked strands brushing against her face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a powerful spotlight from above and side creating high contrast between highlights and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the dancer twirling gracefully with her head tilted back and a faint smile on her face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.31356191635131836 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3135619163513184 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.31356191635131836, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.31356191635131836, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05639064684510231, + 0.0379779078066349, + 0.03355264291167259, + 0.562820315361023, + 0.028004154562950134, + 0.02260040119290352, + 0.018839778378605843, + 0.0649682953953743, + 0.05367607995867729, + 0.12116976827383041 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.31356191635131836 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot as a slow, forward-moving close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the dancer wearing a simple dark dance dress with a silky luster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the dancer's hair styled in a sleek ballet bun with a few sweat-soaked strands brushing against her face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a powerful spotlight from above and side creating high contrast between highlights and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the dancer twirling gracefully with her head tilted back and a faint smile on her face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011095608584582806 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.5110955238342285 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011095608584582806, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011095608584582806, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07422607392072678, + 0.051651496440172195, + 0.1244574636220932, + 0.20873962342739105, + 0.11535631865262985, + 0.05706682428717613, + 0.03892035409808159, + 0.07735247910022736, + 0.1951669305562973, + 0.05706241726875305 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011095608584582806 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot as a slow, forward-moving close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the dancer wearing a simple dark dance dress with a silky luster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the dancer's hair styled in a sleek ballet bun with a few sweat-soaked strands brushing against her face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a powerful spotlight from above and side creating high contrast between highlights and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the dancer twirling gracefully with her head tilted back and a faint smile on her face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007637585513293743 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.8826375007629395 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007637585513293743, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007637585513293743, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.27745985984802246, + 0.036232493817806244, + 0.05519424378871918, + 0.18761366605758667, + 0.13260865211486816, + 0.04989394545555115, + 0.017794674262404442, + 0.03649381920695305, + 0.14691147208213806, + 0.059797145426273346 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007637585513293743 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot as a slow, forward-moving close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the dancer wearing a simple dark dance dress with a silky luster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the dancer's hair styled in a sleek ballet bun with a few sweat-soaked strands brushing against her face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a powerful spotlight from above and side creating high contrast between highlights and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the dancer twirling gracefully with her head tilted back and a faint smile on her face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026355484500527382 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651355504989624 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026355484500527382, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026355484500527382, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13803668320178986, + 0.11906500160694122, + 0.06610988825559616, + 0.13047480583190918, + 0.09752689301967621, + 0.11180421710014343, + 0.03612068295478821, + 0.14518989622592926, + 0.08848962932825089, + 0.067182257771492 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026355484500527382 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_13/index_tensor([5278, 5278])_group_13_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_13/index_tensor([5278, 5278])_group_13_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..8b2cdc3d7ba7d6e57d2eaec024d2d69ab38a01ce --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_13/index_tensor([5278, 5278])_group_13_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "In a high-definition vertical video blog shot, captured from a steady, mid-range still, the image focuses on the Baidu Bear Paw logo, composed precisely of countless luminous blue data blocks. It hovers quietly in the center of a deep, nearly black digital space. Each translucent cube emits a soft digital glow, creating a sense of high-tech sophistication. As the shot continues, the logo slowly disintegrates, its constituent blocks seemingly freed from their invisible constraints, gracefully and effortlessly drifting outwards, forming a dynamic nebula of countless blue points of light that flickers and flows in the darkness. Then, as if drawn by a central gravitational force, these scattered points of light begin to converge smoothly and orderly toward the center of the frame, swirling and rearranging, ultimately seamlessly reconstructing into a delicate model of the Earth. The contours of the land and ocean are clearly delineated by the data blocks of varying densities. The entire Earth model rotates in a gentle, steady rhythm at the center of the frame, its own light casting a faint, dynamic halo against the inky black background. The entire process is carried out under cool light and shadow, full of a sense of the future, technology and a quiet evolutionary beauty, creating a focused and poetic visual atmosphere.", + "seed": 32104, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_13/index_5278_seed_32104_dp_26_rank_52_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.3392445074394345, + "vlm_logprob": -0.3392445074394345, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.95, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.3392445074394345, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in a vertical aspect ratio?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the initial scene focused on the Baidu Bear Paw logo composed of luminous blue data blocks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the logo disintegrate into scattered blue points of light that drift outwards before converging to form a model of the Earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the final Earth model clearly delineated with visible contours of land and ocean?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned as a steady, mid-range still shot throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.189971923828125 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4399718940258026 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.189971923828125, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -1.189971923828125, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04336084425449371, + 0.023897431790828705, + 0.026156025007367134, + 0.039754342287778854, + 0.34661951661109924, + 0.33292534947395325, + 0.033959727734327316, + 0.09510846436023712, + 0.036481842398643494, + 0.021736422553658485 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.189971923828125 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in a vertical aspect ratio?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the initial scene focused on the Baidu Bear Paw logo composed of luminous blue data blocks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the logo disintegrate into scattered blue points of light that drift outwards before converging to form a model of the Earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the final Earth model clearly delineated with visible contours of land and ocean?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned as a steady, mid-range still shot throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014259939081966877 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.2642598152160645 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014259939081966877, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014259939081966877, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.049883998930454254, + 0.026208283379673958, + 0.03939636051654816, + 0.017972908914089203, + 0.6708024144172668, + 0.05532912164926529, + 0.026877064257860184, + 0.07704320549964905, + 0.02098211832344532, + 0.01550452783703804 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 7, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014259939081966877 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in a vertical aspect ratio?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the initial scene focused on the Baidu Bear Paw logo composed of luminous blue data blocks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the logo disintegrate into scattered blue points of light that drift outwards before converging to form a model of the Earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the final Earth model clearly delineated with visible contours of land and ocean?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned as a steady, mid-range still shot throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04305883124470711 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680588722229004 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04305883124470711, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04305883124470711, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.026728959754109383, + 0.017646266147494316, + 0.017967110499739647, + 0.023568961769342422, + 0.16373378038406372, + 0.24125219881534576, + 0.028549734503030777, + 0.43470513820648193, + 0.023872099816799164, + 0.02197577804327011 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04305883124470711 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in a vertical aspect ratio?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the initial scene focused on the Baidu Bear Paw logo composed of luminous blue data blocks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the logo disintegrate into scattered blue points of light that drift outwards before converging to form a model of the Earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the final Earth model clearly delineated with visible contours of land and ocean?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned as a steady, mid-range still shot throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10031086206436157 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.350310802459717 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10031086206436157, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10031086206436157, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07483062893152237, + 0.02608991041779518, + 0.05642328038811684, + 0.01725447177886963, + 0.46458062529563904, + 0.04985349625349045, + 0.034396059811115265, + 0.21744631230831146, + 0.027854306623339653, + 0.031270917505025864 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10031086206436157 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in a vertical aspect ratio?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the initial scene focused on the Baidu Bear Paw logo composed of luminous blue data blocks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the logo disintegrate into scattered blue points of light that drift outwards before converging to form a model of the Earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the final Earth model clearly delineated with visible contours of land and ocean?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned as a steady, mid-range still shot throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3486209809780121 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2236210107803345 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3486209809780121, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3486209809780121, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06961624324321747, + 0.024873606860637665, + 0.024348795413970947, + 0.03165745735168457, + 0.05521640554070473, + 0.5029059648513794, + 0.028375834226608276, + 0.15304730832576752, + 0.055351290851831436, + 0.05460706353187561 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3486209809780121 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a high-definition vertical video blog shot, captured from a steady, mid-range still, the image focuses on the Baidu Bear Paw logo, composed precisely of countless luminous blue data blocks. It hovers quietly in the center of a deep, nearly black digital space. Each translucent cube emits a soft digital glow, creating a sense of high-tech sophistication. As the shot continues, the logo slowly disintegrates, its constituent blocks seemingly freed from their invisible constraints, gracefully and effortlessly drifting outwards, forming a dynamic nebula of countless blue points of light that flickers and flows in the darkness. Then, as if drawn by a central gravitational force, these scattered points of light begin to converge smoothly and orderly toward the center of the frame, swirling and rearranging, ultimately seamlessly reconstructing into a delicate model of the Earth. The contours of the land and ocean are clearly delineated by the data blocks of varying densities. The entire Earth model rotates in a gentle, steady rhythm at the center of the frame, its own light casting a faint, dynamic halo against the inky black background. The entire process is carried out under cool light and shadow, full of a sense of the future, technology and a quiet evolutionary beauty, creating a focused and poetic visual atmosphere.", + "seed": 32105, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_13/index_5278_seed_32105_dp_26_rank_52_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.5512836550362408, + "vlm_logprob": -0.5512836550362408, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.5249999523162843, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.5512836550362408, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in a vertical aspect ratio?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the initial scene focused on the Baidu Bear Paw logo composed of luminous blue data blocks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the logo disintegrate into scattered blue points of light that drift outwards before converging to form a model of the Earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the final Earth model clearly delineated with visible contours of land and ocean?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned as a steady, mid-range still shot throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1508004665374756 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1508004069328308 + ], + "logprob_reward": -2.1508004665374756, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -2.1508004665374756, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15361419320106506, + 0.049711477011442184, + 0.3128179907798767, + 0.03287748247385025, + 0.034247949719429016, + 0.1050122007727623, + 0.07785775512456894, + 0.04675620421767235, + 0.03304998576641083, + 0.15405473113059998 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -2.1508004665374756 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in a vertical aspect ratio?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the initial scene focused on the Baidu Bear Paw logo composed of luminous blue data blocks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the logo disintegrate into scattered blue points of light that drift outwards before converging to form a model of the Earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the final Earth model clearly delineated with visible contours of land and ocean?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned as a steady, mid-range still shot throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006004390772432089 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.131004333496094 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006004390772432089, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006004390772432089, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5029360055923462, + 0.04851271212100983, + 0.11814741045236588, + 0.022249579429626465, + 0.025605101138353348, + 0.0893322303891182, + 0.07122252136468887, + 0.035257671028375626, + 0.015051988884806633, + 0.0716848149895668 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006004390772432089 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in a vertical aspect ratio?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the initial scene focused on the Baidu Bear Paw logo composed of luminous blue data blocks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the logo disintegrate into scattered blue points of light that drift outwards before converging to form a model of the Earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the final Earth model clearly delineated with visible contours of land and ocean?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned as a steady, mid-range still shot throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005260554142296314 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255260467529297 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005260554142296314, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005260554142296314, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1762148141860962, + 0.04374179244041443, + 0.5247897505760193, + 0.017813218757510185, + 0.03407978266477585, + 0.07882630079984665, + 0.027868783101439476, + 0.021727990359067917, + 0.0181271955370903, + 0.056810393929481506 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005260554142296314 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in a vertical aspect ratio?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the initial scene focused on the Baidu Bear Paw logo composed of luminous blue data blocks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the logo disintegrate into scattered blue points of light that drift outwards before converging to form a model of the Earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the final Earth model clearly delineated with visible contours of land and ocean?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned as a steady, mid-range still shot throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018187187612056732 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018187046051025 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018187187612056732, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018187187612056732, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1823197454214096, + 0.030610576272010803, + 0.35260364413261414, + 0.010431376285851002, + 0.055492985993623734, + 0.14674000442028046, + 0.10695075988769531, + 0.03688902407884598, + 0.046890370547771454, + 0.03107156790792942 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018187187612056732 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in a vertical aspect ratio?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the initial scene focused on the Baidu Bear Paw logo composed of luminous blue data blocks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the logo disintegrate into scattered blue points of light that drift outwards before converging to form a model of the Earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the final Earth model clearly delineated with visible contours of land and ocean?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned as a steady, mid-range still shot throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5761656761169434 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8261656761169434 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5761656761169434, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5761656761169434, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1627059280872345, + 0.031462378799915314, + 0.4512704908847809, + 0.018498841673135757, + 0.038971852511167526, + 0.06456968933343887, + 0.03690628334879875, + 0.029192045331001282, + 0.01594359427690506, + 0.15047889947891235 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5761656761169434 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a high-definition vertical video blog shot, captured from a steady, mid-range still, the image focuses on the Baidu Bear Paw logo, composed precisely of countless luminous blue data blocks. It hovers quietly in the center of a deep, nearly black digital space. Each translucent cube emits a soft digital glow, creating a sense of high-tech sophistication. As the shot continues, the logo slowly disintegrates, its constituent blocks seemingly freed from their invisible constraints, gracefully and effortlessly drifting outwards, forming a dynamic nebula of countless blue points of light that flickers and flows in the darkness. Then, as if drawn by a central gravitational force, these scattered points of light begin to converge smoothly and orderly toward the center of the frame, swirling and rearranging, ultimately seamlessly reconstructing into a delicate model of the Earth. The contours of the land and ocean are clearly delineated by the data blocks of varying densities. The entire Earth model rotates in a gentle, steady rhythm at the center of the frame, its own light casting a faint, dynamic halo against the inky black background. The entire process is carried out under cool light and shadow, full of a sense of the future, technology and a quiet evolutionary beauty, creating a focused and poetic visual atmosphere.", + "seed": 32106, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_13/index_5278_seed_32106_dp_27_rank_54_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.4613116456195712, + "vlm_logprob": -0.4613116456195712, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.775, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.4613116456195712, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in a vertical aspect ratio?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the initial scene focused on the Baidu Bear Paw logo composed of luminous blue data blocks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the logo disintegrate into scattered blue points of light that drift outwards before converging to form a model of the Earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the final Earth model clearly delineated with visible contours of land and ocean?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned as a steady, mid-range still shot throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.931740164756775 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1817401796579361 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.931740164756775, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -1.931740164756775, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3301312029361725, + 0.20629703998565674, + 0.049755144864320755, + 0.039993494749069214, + 0.03972546383738518, + 0.04489082843065262, + 0.063393235206604, + 0.03610315918922424, + 0.0812264233827591, + 0.10848402231931686 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.931740164756775 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in a vertical aspect ratio?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the initial scene focused on the Baidu Bear Paw logo composed of luminous blue data blocks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the logo disintegrate into scattered blue points of light that drift outwards before converging to form a model of the Earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the final Earth model clearly delineated with visible contours of land and ocean?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned as a steady, mid-range still shot throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005999532528221607 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130999565124512 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005999532528221607, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005999532528221607, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.45856088399887085, + 0.05640041083097458, + 0.023439859971404076, + 0.018608588725328445, + 0.02215089090168476, + 0.038917168974876404, + 0.018127767369151115, + 0.08971365541219711, + 0.03709138557314873, + 0.23698940873146057 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005999532528221607 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in a vertical aspect ratio?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the initial scene focused on the Baidu Bear Paw logo composed of luminous blue data blocks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the logo disintegrate into scattered blue points of light that drift outwards before converging to form a model of the Earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the final Earth model clearly delineated with visible contours of land and ocean?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned as a steady, mid-range still shot throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004102030768990517 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.5041022300720215 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004102030768990517, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004102030768990517, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06996692717075348, + 0.15717366337776184, + 0.036125894635915756, + 0.021717136725783348, + 0.021028617396950722, + 0.04803888872265816, + 0.03459866717457771, + 0.08439605683088303, + 0.050717663019895554, + 0.47623658180236816 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004102030768990517 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in a vertical aspect ratio?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the initial scene focused on the Baidu Bear Paw logo composed of luminous blue data blocks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the logo disintegrate into scattered blue points of light that drift outwards before converging to form a model of the Earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the final Earth model clearly delineated with visible contours of land and ocean?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned as a steady, mid-range still shot throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01606649160385132 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141066551208496 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01606649160385132, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01606649160385132, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20948363840579987, + 0.08866899460554123, + 0.05196046456694603, + 0.025818200781941414, + 0.021322645246982574, + 0.03587958961725235, + 0.07751882076263428, + 0.23135749995708466, + 0.03834119066596031, + 0.21964895725250244 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01606649160385132 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in a vertical aspect ratio?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the initial scene focused on the Baidu Bear Paw logo composed of luminous blue data blocks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the logo disintegrate into scattered blue points of light that drift outwards before converging to form a model of the Earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the final Earth model clearly delineated with visible contours of land and ocean?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned as a steady, mid-range still shot throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3486500084400177 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2236499786376953 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3486500084400177, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3486500084400177, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.35309839248657227, + 0.27712470293045044, + 0.04257747158408165, + 0.022266274318099022, + 0.020613957196474075, + 0.043221697211265564, + 0.058334678411483765, + 0.11601514369249344, + 0.03052167035639286, + 0.03622598946094513 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3486500084400177 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a high-definition vertical video blog shot, captured from a steady, mid-range still, the image focuses on the Baidu Bear Paw logo, composed precisely of countless luminous blue data blocks. It hovers quietly in the center of a deep, nearly black digital space. Each translucent cube emits a soft digital glow, creating a sense of high-tech sophistication. As the shot continues, the logo slowly disintegrates, its constituent blocks seemingly freed from their invisible constraints, gracefully and effortlessly drifting outwards, forming a dynamic nebula of countless blue points of light that flickers and flows in the darkness. Then, as if drawn by a central gravitational force, these scattered points of light begin to converge smoothly and orderly toward the center of the frame, swirling and rearranging, ultimately seamlessly reconstructing into a delicate model of the Earth. The contours of the land and ocean are clearly delineated by the data blocks of varying densities. The entire Earth model rotates in a gentle, steady rhythm at the center of the frame, its own light casting a faint, dynamic halo against the inky black background. The entire process is carried out under cool light and shadow, full of a sense of the future, technology and a quiet evolutionary beauty, creating a focused and poetic visual atmosphere.", + "seed": 32107, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_13/index_5278_seed_32107_dp_27_rank_54_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.4482815622352064, + "vlm_logprob": -0.4482815622352064, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.7, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.4482815622352064, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in a vertical aspect ratio?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the initial scene focused on the Baidu Bear Paw logo composed of luminous blue data blocks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the logo disintegrate into scattered blue points of light that drift outwards before converging to form a model of the Earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the final Earth model clearly delineated with visible contours of land and ocean?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned as a steady, mid-range still shot throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6353203058242798 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2603202760219574 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.6353203058242798, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -1.6353203058242798, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10613800585269928, + 0.05142669379711151, + 0.08330940455198288, + 0.037561047822237015, + 0.2734275460243225, + 0.10727772116661072, + 0.1026291474699974, + 0.069539375603199, + 0.09484459459781647, + 0.07384642958641052 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.6353203058242798 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in a vertical aspect ratio?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the initial scene focused on the Baidu Bear Paw logo composed of luminous blue data blocks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the logo disintegrate into scattered blue points of light that drift outwards before converging to form a model of the Earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the final Earth model clearly delineated with visible contours of land and ocean?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned as a steady, mid-range still shot throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004704953171312809 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.37970495223999 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004704953171312809, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004704953171312809, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12068638205528259, + 0.23204614222049713, + 0.10840241611003876, + 0.1411149799823761, + 0.05417698994278908, + 0.051099855452775955, + 0.04487639665603638, + 0.05912501737475395, + 0.11491898447275162, + 0.07355285435914993 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004704953171312809 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in a vertical aspect ratio?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the initial scene focused on the Baidu Bear Paw logo composed of luminous blue data blocks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the logo disintegrate into scattered blue points of light that drift outwards before converging to form a model of the Earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the final Earth model clearly delineated with visible contours of land and ocean?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned as a steady, mid-range still shot throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004643846768885851 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.37964391708374 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004643846768885851, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004643846768885851, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07280134409666061, + 0.14328405261039734, + 0.057076625525951385, + 0.08962417393922806, + 0.27956756949424744, + 0.09898959845304489, + 0.07462939620018005, + 0.03184141591191292, + 0.1219402402639389, + 0.03024560958147049 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004643846768885851 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in a vertical aspect ratio?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the initial scene focused on the Baidu Bear Paw logo composed of luminous blue data blocks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the logo disintegrate into scattered blue points of light that drift outwards before converging to form a model of the Earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the final Earth model clearly delineated with visible contours of land and ocean?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned as a steady, mid-range still shot throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020581373944878578 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955814838409424 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020581373944878578, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020581373944878578, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13749614357948303, + 0.042792294174432755, + 0.038670312613248825, + 0.08323884755373001, + 0.16911683976650238, + 0.17960602045059204, + 0.09388067573308945, + 0.04230901226401329, + 0.1247512623667717, + 0.0881386548280716 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020581373944878578 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in a vertical aspect ratio?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the initial scene focused on the Baidu Bear Paw logo composed of luminous blue data blocks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the logo disintegrate into scattered blue points of light that drift outwards before converging to form a model of the Earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the final Earth model clearly delineated with visible contours of land and ocean?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned as a steady, mid-range still shot throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5761573314666748 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8261573314666748 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5761573314666748, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5761573314666748, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08064233511686325, + 0.03595060855150223, + 0.03892635554075241, + 0.06497379392385483, + 0.2874470055103302, + 0.1688797026872635, + 0.07080239802598953, + 0.06065541133284569, + 0.10479319840669632, + 0.08692920953035355 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5761573314666748 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_14/index_tensor([601, 601])_group_14_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_14/index_tensor([601, 601])_group_14_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..2093ae6cf7b7238a79604deeb837d2caa0a53ae6 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_14/index_tensor([601, 601])_group_14_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "high-angle, static, extreme close-up depicts an intricately patterned small lizard, its body a detailed mosaic of sandy beige and russet scales, perfectly mimicking the sun-drenched sandstone rock below. The midday sun casts sharp, microscopic shadows across the rock's weathered ochre surface. The lizard freezes mid-step, one delicate front leg suspended above the stone's grainy texture, its entire body lowered in a posture of pure, primal instinct. As a large, amorphous shadow glides swiftly and silently across the scene, the lizard, momentarily trapped in cool darkness, remains completely petrified. Its muscles tense, its beady black eyes wide and unblinking, its breath held as it desperately and silently attempts to merge with the stone, creating a palpable atmosphere of high-stakes tension and a frozen moment of survival.", + "seed": 28202, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_14/index_601_seed_28202_dp_28_rank_56_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.17923432514071463, + "vlm_logprob": -0.17923432514071463, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.125, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.17923432514071463, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle high-angle and static throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a small lizard with sandy beige and russet scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lizard frozen mid-step with one front leg suspended above the stone surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a large, amorphous shadow glide swiftly and silently across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the lizard's beady black eyes wide and unblinking while it remains petrified?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.39396241307258606 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1439623832702637 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.39396241307258606, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.39396241307258606, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16530844569206238, + 0.08557768911123276, + 0.03741080313920975, + 0.10952961444854736, + 0.07384058088064194, + 0.13060443103313446, + 0.11730256676673889, + 0.08320006728172302, + 0.0669955462217331, + 0.13023024797439575 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.39396241307258606 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle high-angle and static throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a small lizard with sandy beige and russet scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lizard frozen mid-step with one front leg suspended above the stone surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a large, amorphous shadow glide swiftly and silently across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the lizard's beady black eyes wide and unblinking while it remains petrified?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018214110285043716 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018214225769043 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018214110285043716, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018214110285043716, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10938964039087296, + 0.0628184899687767, + 0.041461456567049026, + 0.07109750062227249, + 0.059614866971969604, + 0.06620641052722931, + 0.11895203590393066, + 0.07377003133296967, + 0.34573638439178467, + 0.05095324292778969 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018214110285043716 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle high-angle and static throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a small lizard with sandy beige and russet scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lizard frozen mid-step with one front leg suspended above the stone surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a large, amorphous shadow glide swiftly and silently across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the lizard's beady black eyes wide and unblinking while it remains petrified?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3135530352592468 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3135530948638916 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3135530352592468, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3135530352592468, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0774216502904892, + 0.03180906921625137, + 0.05816712975502014, + 0.10996890813112259, + 0.03910107910633087, + 0.03151194378733635, + 0.03899141401052475, + 0.10997841507196426, + 0.42151856422424316, + 0.08153179287910461 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3135530352592468 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle high-angle and static throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a small lizard with sandy beige and russet scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lizard frozen mid-step with one front leg suspended above the stone surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a large, amorphous shadow glide swiftly and silently across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the lizard's beady black eyes wide and unblinking while it remains petrified?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07004182040691376 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950418949127197 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07004182040691376, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07004182040691376, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05565224587917328, + 0.11801513284444809, + 0.045461397618055344, + 0.14746366441249847, + 0.02465781755745411, + 0.024966921657323837, + 0.02091473713517189, + 0.01929837092757225, + 0.5039273500442505, + 0.03964236378669739 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07004182040691376 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle high-angle and static throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a small lizard with sandy beige and russet scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lizard frozen mid-step with one front leg suspended above the stone surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a large, amorphous shadow glide swiftly and silently across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the lizard's beady black eyes wide and unblinking while it remains petrified?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10040024667978287 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.35040020942688 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10040024667978287, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10040024667978287, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14731547236442566, + 0.13238415122032166, + 0.03866325691342354, + 0.11813759803771973, + 0.03534248471260071, + 0.028018279001116753, + 0.02234756574034691, + 0.12789200246334076, + 0.24290738999843597, + 0.10699177533388138 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10040024667978287 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "high-angle, static, extreme close-up depicts an intricately patterned small lizard, its body a detailed mosaic of sandy beige and russet scales, perfectly mimicking the sun-drenched sandstone rock below. The midday sun casts sharp, microscopic shadows across the rock's weathered ochre surface. The lizard freezes mid-step, one delicate front leg suspended above the stone's grainy texture, its entire body lowered in a posture of pure, primal instinct. As a large, amorphous shadow glides swiftly and silently across the scene, the lizard, momentarily trapped in cool darkness, remains completely petrified. Its muscles tense, its beady black eyes wide and unblinking, its breath held as it desperately and silently attempts to merge with the stone, creating a palpable atmosphere of high-stakes tension and a frozen moment of survival.", + "seed": 28203, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_14/index_601_seed_28203_dp_28_rank_56_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.08285324787721038, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08285324787721038, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.1, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08285324787721038, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle high-angle and static throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a small lizard with sandy beige and russet scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lizard frozen mid-step with one front leg suspended above the stone surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a large, amorphous shadow glide swiftly and silently across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the lizard's beady black eyes wide and unblinking while it remains petrified?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.09835925698280334 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4733593463897705 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.09835925698280334, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.09835925698280334, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1953212171792984, + 0.054060351103544235, + 0.23575419187545776, + 0.09135600179433823, + 0.03289373964071274, + 0.054802391678094864, + 0.047729384154081345, + 0.11561635136604309, + 0.060154467821121216, + 0.11231187731027603 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.09835925698280334 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle high-angle and static throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a small lizard with sandy beige and russet scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lizard frozen mid-step with one front leg suspended above the stone surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a large, amorphous shadow glide swiftly and silently across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the lizard's beady black eyes wide and unblinking while it remains petrified?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0046503725461661816 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379650592803955 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0046503725461661816, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0046503725461661816, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18353545665740967, + 0.17179298400878906, + 0.11104480922222137, + 0.08653124421834946, + 0.03132142499089241, + 0.07641247659921646, + 0.03683460131287575, + 0.09351912885904312, + 0.1116722822189331, + 0.09733563661575317 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0046503725461661816 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle high-angle and static throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a small lizard with sandy beige and russet scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lizard frozen mid-step with one front leg suspended above the stone surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a large, amorphous shadow glide swiftly and silently across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the lizard's beady black eyes wide and unblinking while it remains petrified?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20163241028785706 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7016323804855347 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20163241028785706, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20163241028785706, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10760630667209625, + 0.08918364346027374, + 0.2069934904575348, + 0.11634347587823868, + 0.1343107372522354, + 0.05768619105219841, + 0.030399281531572342, + 0.07871678471565247, + 0.05241115391254425, + 0.12634900212287903 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20163241028785706 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle high-angle and static throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a small lizard with sandy beige and russet scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lizard frozen mid-step with one front leg suspended above the stone surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a large, amorphous shadow glide swiftly and silently across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the lizard's beady black eyes wide and unblinking while it remains petrified?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08903313428163528 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4640331268310547 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08903313428163528, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08903313428163528, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12327422201633453, + 0.04762738570570946, + 0.24944564700126648, + 0.17564886808395386, + 0.04023100063204765, + 0.036564137786626816, + 0.028580155223608017, + 0.07882263511419296, + 0.1542934775352478, + 0.06551241129636765 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08903313428163528 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle high-angle and static throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a small lizard with sandy beige and russet scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lizard frozen mid-step with one front leg suspended above the stone surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a large, amorphous shadow glide swiftly and silently across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the lizard's beady black eyes wide and unblinking while it remains petrified?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020591065287590027 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955910205841064 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020591065287590027, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020591065287590027, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1236356571316719, + 0.034899529069662094, + 0.39962103962898254, + 0.15299127995967865, + 0.046379003673791885, + 0.04534291848540306, + 0.020959654822945595, + 0.07377421855926514, + 0.027528954669833183, + 0.07486771047115326 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020591065287590027 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "high-angle, static, extreme close-up depicts an intricately patterned small lizard, its body a detailed mosaic of sandy beige and russet scales, perfectly mimicking the sun-drenched sandstone rock below. The midday sun casts sharp, microscopic shadows across the rock's weathered ochre surface. The lizard freezes mid-step, one delicate front leg suspended above the stone's grainy texture, its entire body lowered in a posture of pure, primal instinct. As a large, amorphous shadow glides swiftly and silently across the scene, the lizard, momentarily trapped in cool darkness, remains completely petrified. Its muscles tense, its beady black eyes wide and unblinking, its breath held as it desperately and silently attempts to merge with the stone, creating a palpable atmosphere of high-stakes tension and a frozen moment of survival.", + "seed": 28204, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_14/index_601_seed_28204_dp_29_rank_58_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.09050864856690169, + "vlm_logprob": -0.09050864856690169, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.775, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.09050864856690169, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle high-angle and static throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a small lizard with sandy beige and russet scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lizard frozen mid-step with one front leg suspended above the stone surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a large, amorphous shadow glide swiftly and silently across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the lizard's beady black eyes wide and unblinking while it remains petrified?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.13869427144527435 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1386942863464355 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.13869427144527435, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.13869427144527435, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03267189860343933, + 0.021649498492479324, + 0.0496239997446537, + 0.5913987159729004, + 0.033573996275663376, + 0.12034714967012405, + 0.030935663729906082, + 0.056327298283576965, + 0.03274623677134514, + 0.030725562945008278 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.13869427144527435 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle high-angle and static throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a small lizard with sandy beige and russet scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lizard frozen mid-step with one front leg suspended above the stone surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a large, amorphous shadow glide swiftly and silently across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the lizard's beady black eyes wide and unblinking while it remains petrified?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011097612790763378 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511097431182861 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011097612790763378, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011097612790763378, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.44260373711586, + 0.04085606336593628, + 0.05458745360374451, + 0.3256323039531708, + 0.018278999254107475, + 0.031003523617982864, + 0.013231305405497551, + 0.03022322990000248, + 0.019650857895612717, + 0.023932520300149918 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011097612790763378 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle high-angle and static throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a small lizard with sandy beige and russet scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lizard frozen mid-step with one front leg suspended above the stone surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a large, amorphous shadow glide swiftly and silently across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the lizard's beady black eyes wide and unblinking while it remains petrified?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17997528612613678 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8049752712249756 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17997528612613678, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17997528612613678, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22608236968517303, + 0.03886767849326134, + 0.05561922490596771, + 0.2912089228630066, + 0.07873537391424179, + 0.09447578340768814, + 0.11163925379514694, + 0.0526605099439621, + 0.02508295513689518, + 0.02562793530523777 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17997528612613678 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle high-angle and static throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a small lizard with sandy beige and russet scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lizard frozen mid-step with one front leg suspended above the stone surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a large, amorphous shadow glide swiftly and silently across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the lizard's beady black eyes wide and unblinking while it remains petrified?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08904535323381424 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.464045286178589 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08904535323381424, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08904535323381424, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0378144346177578, + 0.019757768139243126, + 0.08219674974679947, + 0.5944992303848267, + 0.036736730486154556, + 0.03016459196805954, + 0.03366903215646744, + 0.1209782138466835, + 0.013724341057240963, + 0.030458834022283554 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 7, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08904535323381424 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle high-angle and static throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a small lizard with sandy beige and russet scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lizard frozen mid-step with one front leg suspended above the stone surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a large, amorphous shadow glide swiftly and silently across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the lizard's beady black eyes wide and unblinking while it remains petrified?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03373071923851967 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4087307453155518 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03373071923851967, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03373071923851967, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.35039201378822327, + 0.02895044907927513, + 0.025313973426818848, + 0.243740051984787, + 0.06804464012384415, + 0.06372911483049393, + 0.07128846645355225, + 0.08389393240213394, + 0.032757021486759186, + 0.031890396028757095 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03373071923851967 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "high-angle, static, extreme close-up depicts an intricately patterned small lizard, its body a detailed mosaic of sandy beige and russet scales, perfectly mimicking the sun-drenched sandstone rock below. The midday sun casts sharp, microscopic shadows across the rock's weathered ochre surface. The lizard freezes mid-step, one delicate front leg suspended above the stone's grainy texture, its entire body lowered in a posture of pure, primal instinct. As a large, amorphous shadow glides swiftly and silently across the scene, the lizard, momentarily trapped in cool darkness, remains completely petrified. Its muscles tense, its beady black eyes wide and unblinking, its breath held as it desperately and silently attempts to merge with the stone, creating a palpable atmosphere of high-stakes tension and a frozen moment of survival.", + "seed": 28205, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_14/index_601_seed_28205_dp_29_rank_58_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.15105233788490297, + "vlm_logprob": -0.15105233788490297, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.499999976158142, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.15105233788490297, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle high-angle and static throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a small lizard with sandy beige and russet scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lizard frozen mid-step with one front leg suspended above the stone surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a large, amorphous shadow glide swiftly and silently across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the lizard's beady black eyes wide and unblinking while it remains petrified?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10754567384719849 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3575456142425537 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10754567384719849, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10754567384719849, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2114216387271881, + 0.07503429800271988, + 0.062164854258298874, + 0.07863490283489227, + 0.061907168477773666, + 0.03590761497616768, + 0.0974566638469696, + 0.06278546899557114, + 0.2221541553735733, + 0.09253320097923279 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10754567384719849 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle high-angle and static throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a small lizard with sandy beige and russet scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lizard frozen mid-step with one front leg suspended above the stone surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a large, amorphous shadow glide swiftly and silently across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the lizard's beady black eyes wide and unblinking while it remains petrified?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012560192495584488 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.3875603675842285 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012560192495584488, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012560192495584488, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17755593359470367, + 0.08993396908044815, + 0.15417028963565826, + 0.2414286583662033, + 0.08603508770465851, + 0.03474067524075508, + 0.07317368686199188, + 0.05398071929812431, + 0.05420611798763275, + 0.034774862229824066 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012560192495584488 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle high-angle and static throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a small lizard with sandy beige and russet scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lizard frozen mid-step with one front leg suspended above the stone surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a large, amorphous shadow glide swiftly and silently across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the lizard's beady black eyes wide and unblinking while it remains petrified?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.47437411546707153 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9743741154670715 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.47437411546707153, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.47437411546707153, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10552679747343063, + 0.08403591811656952, + 0.11448812484741211, + 0.4158892035484314, + 0.12977348268032074, + 0.024588236585259438, + 0.02674867771565914, + 0.010977303609251976, + 0.04759090393781662, + 0.040381334722042084 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.47437411546707153 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle high-angle and static throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a small lizard with sandy beige and russet scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lizard frozen mid-step with one front leg suspended above the stone surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a large, amorphous shadow glide swiftly and silently across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the lizard's beady black eyes wide and unblinking while it remains petrified?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12706170976161957 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.127061605453491 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12706170976161957, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.9999998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12706170976161957, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16417820751667023, + 0.13531167805194855, + 0.04259742796421051, + 0.05773571506142616, + 0.08558395504951477, + 0.08707579225301743, + 0.08347693085670471, + 0.08866764605045319, + 0.16715294122695923, + 0.08821966499090195 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12706170976161957 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle high-angle and static throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a small lizard with sandy beige and russet scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lizard frozen mid-step with one front leg suspended above the stone surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a large, amorphous shadow glide swiftly and silently across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the lizard's beady black eyes wide and unblinking while it remains petrified?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.033719997853040695 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408720016479492 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.033719997853040695, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.033719997853040695, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09112876653671265, + 0.058481890708208084, + 0.09094960987567902, + 0.519555926322937, + 0.02745090052485466, + 0.023664791136980057, + 0.030916940420866013, + 0.024539245292544365, + 0.08448486775159836, + 0.048827044665813446 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.033719997853040695 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_15/index_tensor([7970, 7970])_group_15_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_15/index_tensor([7970, 7970])_group_15_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..edf3f95438c235337571c7598a8d012c2d52374b --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_15/index_tensor([7970, 7970])_group_15_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "high-angle, wide-angle lens slowly tilts right, revealing a surreal scene captured in stark, artistic black-and-white, 3D, Pixar-style. A vast, rolling sea, composed entirely of meticulously cultivated, high-standard farmland, stretches to the horizon. Rolling black cultivated hills and silvery crops mimic the undulations of waves beneath a high-contrast sky. A whimsical boat glides silently across this land-sea, its sleek, rounded hull of dark charcoal-gray wood and a friendly, stylized animal head perched on its prow. As the boat steadily approaches a distant village, its single, large, patchwork sail—a mosaic of various gray tones and textured fabrics—is gracefully and deliberately lowered, the canvas gently billowing before collapsing in neat folds onto the slightly bent mast. The destination, a village built in a distinctive ethnic minority style, becomes more clearly visible, its structures characterized by curved, dark-tiled roofs and intricate white gridwork, all organically nestled into the terraced slopes of the farmland hills. The entire dreamlike scene is defined by a dramatic play of light and shadow; vibrant white highlights the edges and rooftops of the boats, while deep, inky black pools in the furrows of the land, creating an atmosphere that is visually stunning and profoundly tranquil.", + "seed": 15875, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_15/index_7970_seed_15875_dp_30_rank_60_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.25538625866174697, + "vlm_logprob": -0.25538625866174697, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.4, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.25538625866174697, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in stark black-and-white with high contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a vast rolling sea composed entirely of cultivated farmland hills?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a boat with a dark charcoal-gray hull and a stylized animal head on the prow visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the boat's patchwork sail shown being lowered and collapsing onto the mast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a high-angle wide shot and slowly tilt right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005428573116660118 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.505428791046143 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005428573116660118, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005428573116660118, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10901182144880295, + 0.12861593067646027, + 0.02278406359255314, + 0.020583635196089745, + 0.13743694126605988, + 0.3169190287590027, + 0.0985703244805336, + 0.06507836282253265, + 0.021707501262426376, + 0.0792924091219902 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005428573116660118 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in stark black-and-white with high contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a vast rolling sea composed entirely of cultivated farmland hills?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a boat with a dark charcoal-gray hull and a stylized animal head on the prow visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the boat's patchwork sail shown being lowered and collapsing onto the mast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a high-angle wide shot and slowly tilt right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6328146457672119 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7578146457672119 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.6328146457672119, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.6328146457672119, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07058041542768478, + 0.04078863188624382, + 0.04846624284982681, + 0.011610712856054306, + 0.08199440687894821, + 0.2321876734495163, + 0.2439744919538498, + 0.03957795351743698, + 0.0203956738114357, + 0.2104237973690033 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.6328146457672119 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in stark black-and-white with high contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a vast rolling sea composed entirely of cultivated farmland hills?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a boat with a dark charcoal-gray hull and a stylized animal head on the prow visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the boat's patchwork sail shown being lowered and collapsing onto the mast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a high-angle wide shot and slowly tilt right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026348749175667763 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651348829269409 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026348749175667763, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026348749175667763, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.048817262053489685, + 0.2175038605928421, + 0.014892960898578167, + 0.023675797507166862, + 0.22617411613464355, + 0.3525830805301666, + 0.05029929801821709, + 0.02111373096704483, + 0.01211573276668787, + 0.032824140042066574 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026348749175667763 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in stark black-and-white with high contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a vast rolling sea composed entirely of cultivated farmland hills?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a boat with a dark charcoal-gray hull and a stylized animal head on the prow visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the boat's patchwork sail shown being lowered and collapsing onto the mast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a high-angle wide shot and slowly tilt right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08905494958162308 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.464055061340332 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08905494958162308, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08905494958162308, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.036370694637298584, + 0.02436249889433384, + 0.07250822335481644, + 0.030263351276516914, + 0.08512113243341446, + 0.4877557158470154, + 0.033278245478868484, + 0.10611999779939651, + 0.01731221191585064, + 0.1069079115986824 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08905494958162308 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in stark black-and-white with high contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a vast rolling sea composed entirely of cultivated farmland hills?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a boat with a dark charcoal-gray hull and a stylized animal head on the prow visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the boat's patchwork sail shown being lowered and collapsing onto the mast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a high-angle wide shot and slowly tilt right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.523284375667572 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.898284375667572 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.523284375667572, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.523284375667572, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.00575370155274868, + 0.008677258156239986, + 0.005764410365372896, + 0.0050620585680007935, + 0.027399295940995216, + 0.8372559547424316, + 0.050177909433841705, + 0.02307816781103611, + 0.010147454217076302, + 0.026683786883950233 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.523284375667572 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "high-angle, wide-angle lens slowly tilts right, revealing a surreal scene captured in stark, artistic black-and-white, 3D, Pixar-style. A vast, rolling sea, composed entirely of meticulously cultivated, high-standard farmland, stretches to the horizon. Rolling black cultivated hills and silvery crops mimic the undulations of waves beneath a high-contrast sky. A whimsical boat glides silently across this land-sea, its sleek, rounded hull of dark charcoal-gray wood and a friendly, stylized animal head perched on its prow. As the boat steadily approaches a distant village, its single, large, patchwork sail—a mosaic of various gray tones and textured fabrics—is gracefully and deliberately lowered, the canvas gently billowing before collapsing in neat folds onto the slightly bent mast. The destination, a village built in a distinctive ethnic minority style, becomes more clearly visible, its structures characterized by curved, dark-tiled roofs and intricate white gridwork, all organically nestled into the terraced slopes of the farmland hills. The entire dreamlike scene is defined by a dramatic play of light and shadow; vibrant white highlights the edges and rooftops of the boats, while deep, inky black pools in the furrows of the land, creating an atmosphere that is visually stunning and profoundly tranquil.", + "seed": 15876, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_15/index_7970_seed_15876_dp_30_rank_60_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.11434551202692092, + "vlm_logprob": -0.11434551202692092, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.3, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.11434551202692092, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in stark black-and-white with high contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a vast rolling sea composed entirely of cultivated farmland hills?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a boat with a dark charcoal-gray hull and a stylized animal head on the prow visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the boat's patchwork sail shown being lowered and collapsing onto the mast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a high-angle wide shot and slowly tilt right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003428179072216153 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.378427982330322 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003428179072216153, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003428179072216153, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10768096894025803, + 0.10150612890720367, + 0.039969801902770996, + 0.031678926199674606, + 0.029327766969799995, + 0.24577417969703674, + 0.031042583286762238, + 0.07390664517879486, + 0.054723624140024185, + 0.2843894064426422 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003428179072216153 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in stark black-and-white with high contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a vast rolling sea composed entirely of cultivated farmland hills?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a boat with a dark charcoal-gray hull and a stylized animal head on the prow visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the boat's patchwork sail shown being lowered and collapsing onto the mast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a high-angle wide shot and slowly tilt right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1270817518234253 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.127081871032715 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1270817518234253, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1270817518234253, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13295239210128784, + 0.08245040476322174, + 0.03322657570242882, + 0.08168847858905792, + 0.10428706556558609, + 0.1255502849817276, + 0.04170708730816841, + 0.07423281669616699, + 0.09474007785320282, + 0.22916480898857117 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1270817518234253 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in stark black-and-white with high contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a vast rolling sea composed entirely of cultivated farmland hills?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a boat with a dark charcoal-gray hull and a stylized animal head on the prow visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the boat's patchwork sail shown being lowered and collapsing onto the mast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a high-angle wide shot and slowly tilt right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016070010140538216 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.1410698890686035 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016070010140538216, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016070010140538216, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1980007141828537, + 0.09769067913293839, + 0.04676370322704315, + 0.03331500291824341, + 0.07674000412225723, + 0.06112304702401161, + 0.05115111172199249, + 0.10085726529359818, + 0.040753208100795746, + 0.2936052083969116 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016070010140538216 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in stark black-and-white with high contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a vast rolling sea composed entirely of cultivated farmland hills?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a boat with a dark charcoal-gray hull and a stylized animal head on the prow visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the boat's patchwork sail shown being lowered and collapsing onto the mast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a high-angle wide shot and slowly tilt right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.038113709539175034 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288113594055176 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.038113709539175034, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.038113709539175034, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13092921674251556, + 0.07164379954338074, + 0.03571227565407753, + 0.10879151523113251, + 0.16616956889629364, + 0.08921463787555695, + 0.06273343414068222, + 0.08439010381698608, + 0.05790157988667488, + 0.1925138235092163 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.038113709539175034 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in stark black-and-white with high contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a vast rolling sea composed entirely of cultivated farmland hills?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a boat with a dark charcoal-gray hull and a stylized animal head on the prow visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the boat's patchwork sail shown being lowered and collapsing onto the mast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a high-angle wide shot and slowly tilt right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3870339095592499 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1370339393615723 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3870339095592499, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3870339095592499, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22201772034168243, + 0.09949449449777603, + 0.05821885168552399, + 0.03488919511437416, + 0.06846223771572113, + 0.09485270828008652, + 0.1481446623802185, + 0.09077061712741852, + 0.0416400246322155, + 0.1415095180273056 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3870339095592499 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "high-angle, wide-angle lens slowly tilts right, revealing a surreal scene captured in stark, artistic black-and-white, 3D, Pixar-style. A vast, rolling sea, composed entirely of meticulously cultivated, high-standard farmland, stretches to the horizon. Rolling black cultivated hills and silvery crops mimic the undulations of waves beneath a high-contrast sky. A whimsical boat glides silently across this land-sea, its sleek, rounded hull of dark charcoal-gray wood and a friendly, stylized animal head perched on its prow. As the boat steadily approaches a distant village, its single, large, patchwork sail—a mosaic of various gray tones and textured fabrics—is gracefully and deliberately lowered, the canvas gently billowing before collapsing in neat folds onto the slightly bent mast. The destination, a village built in a distinctive ethnic minority style, becomes more clearly visible, its structures characterized by curved, dark-tiled roofs and intricate white gridwork, all organically nestled into the terraced slopes of the farmland hills. The entire dreamlike scene is defined by a dramatic play of light and shadow; vibrant white highlights the edges and rooftops of the boats, while deep, inky black pools in the furrows of the land, creating an atmosphere that is visually stunning and profoundly tranquil.", + "seed": 15877, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_15/index_7970_seed_15877_dp_31_rank_62_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.08836268549785017, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08836268549785017, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.775, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08836268549785017, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in stark black-and-white with high contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a vast rolling sea composed entirely of cultivated farmland hills?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a boat with a dark charcoal-gray hull and a stylized animal head on the prow visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the boat's patchwork sail shown being lowered and collapsing onto the mast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a high-angle wide shot and slowly tilt right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0022190012969076633 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.877219200134277 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0022190012969076633, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0022190012969076633, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0724240094423294, + 0.07232803851366043, + 0.024938682094216347, + 0.057830363512039185, + 0.36310839653015137, + 0.2059895098209381, + 0.030712351202964783, + 0.05873957648873329, + 0.05305458605289459, + 0.06087451055645943 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0022190012969076633 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in stark black-and-white with high contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a vast rolling sea composed entirely of cultivated farmland hills?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a boat with a dark charcoal-gray hull and a stylized animal head on the prow visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the boat's patchwork sail shown being lowered and collapsing onto the mast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a high-angle wide shot and slowly tilt right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03371630981564522 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4087162017822266 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03371630981564522, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03371630981564522, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0674268901348114, + 0.04974104091525078, + 0.028875799849629402, + 0.06820964813232422, + 0.4007091224193573, + 0.14353850483894348, + 0.02472928911447525, + 0.039611224085092545, + 0.012562831863760948, + 0.16459567844867706 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03371630981564522 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in stark black-and-white with high contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a vast rolling sea composed entirely of cultivated farmland hills?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a boat with a dark charcoal-gray hull and a stylized animal head on the prow visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the boat's patchwork sail shown being lowered and collapsing onto the mast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a high-angle wide shot and slowly tilt right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00863721314817667 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758637428283691 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00863721314817667, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00863721314817667, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1932458132505417, + 0.03751193732023239, + 0.08722280710935593, + 0.17415742576122284, + 0.23851434886455536, + 0.18625159561634064, + 0.012920055538415909, + 0.014316946268081665, + 0.01640547811985016, + 0.03945363312959671 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00863721314817667 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in stark black-and-white with high contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a vast rolling sea composed entirely of cultivated farmland hills?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a boat with a dark charcoal-gray hull and a stylized animal head on the prow visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the boat's patchwork sail shown being lowered and collapsing onto the mast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a high-angle wide shot and slowly tilt right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04865693673491478 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048656940460205 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04865693673491478, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04865693673491478, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09183839708566666, + 0.07226864993572235, + 0.04530655965209007, + 0.26758113503456116, + 0.1304352879524231, + 0.24882398545742035, + 0.020541831851005554, + 0.04352695867419243, + 0.014169042930006981, + 0.065508171916008 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04865693673491478 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in stark black-and-white with high contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a vast rolling sea composed entirely of cultivated farmland hills?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a boat with a dark charcoal-gray hull and a stylized animal head on the prow visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the boat's patchwork sail shown being lowered and collapsing onto the mast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a high-angle wide shot and slowly tilt right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.34858396649360657 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2235839366912842 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.34858396649360657, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.34858396649360657, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17656941711902618, + 0.28677836060523987, + 0.07511214166879654, + 0.1572796106338501, + 0.15104499459266663, + 0.060017917305231094, + 0.016912057995796204, + 0.030699273571372032, + 0.025427453219890594, + 0.020158786326646805 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.34858396649360657 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "high-angle, wide-angle lens slowly tilts right, revealing a surreal scene captured in stark, artistic black-and-white, 3D, Pixar-style. A vast, rolling sea, composed entirely of meticulously cultivated, high-standard farmland, stretches to the horizon. Rolling black cultivated hills and silvery crops mimic the undulations of waves beneath a high-contrast sky. A whimsical boat glides silently across this land-sea, its sleek, rounded hull of dark charcoal-gray wood and a friendly, stylized animal head perched on its prow. As the boat steadily approaches a distant village, its single, large, patchwork sail—a mosaic of various gray tones and textured fabrics—is gracefully and deliberately lowered, the canvas gently billowing before collapsing in neat folds onto the slightly bent mast. The destination, a village built in a distinctive ethnic minority style, becomes more clearly visible, its structures characterized by curved, dark-tiled roofs and intricate white gridwork, all organically nestled into the terraced slopes of the farmland hills. The entire dreamlike scene is defined by a dramatic play of light and shadow; vibrant white highlights the edges and rooftops of the boats, while deep, inky black pools in the furrows of the land, creating an atmosphere that is visually stunning and profoundly tranquil.", + "seed": 15878, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_15/index_7970_seed_15878_dp_31_rank_62_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.25501393326558175, + "vlm_logprob": -0.25501393326558175, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.275, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.25501393326558175, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in stark black-and-white with high contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a vast rolling sea composed entirely of cultivated farmland hills?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a boat with a dark charcoal-gray hull and a stylized animal head on the prow visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the boat's patchwork sail shown being lowered and collapsing onto the mast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a high-angle wide shot and slowly tilt right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0020816102623939514 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.877081394195557 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0020816102623939514, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0020816102623939514, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05696602538228035, + 0.06171559542417526, + 0.08757539093494415, + 0.0763968750834465, + 0.07101956754922867, + 0.057352930307388306, + 0.16218842566013336, + 0.12918061017990112, + 0.07306375354528427, + 0.22454088926315308 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0020816102623939514 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in stark black-and-white with high contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a vast rolling sea composed entirely of cultivated farmland hills?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a boat with a dark charcoal-gray hull and a stylized animal head on the prow visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the boat's patchwork sail shown being lowered and collapsing onto the mast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a high-angle wide shot and slowly tilt right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9742337465286255 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4742337465286255 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.9742337465286255, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.9742337465286255, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1043827086687088, + 0.12326162308454514, + 0.03961246460676193, + 0.06773051619529724, + 0.041428092867136, + 0.026448838412761688, + 0.283402681350708, + 0.06021265685558319, + 0.18660707771778107, + 0.06691338121891022 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.9742337465286255 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in stark black-and-white with high contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a vast rolling sea composed entirely of cultivated farmland hills?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a boat with a dark charcoal-gray hull and a stylized animal head on the prow visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the boat's patchwork sail shown being lowered and collapsing onto the mast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a high-angle wide shot and slowly tilt right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036176491994410753 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628617763519287 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036176491994410753, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036176491994410753, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08065373450517654, + 0.07254958897829056, + 0.14125272631645203, + 0.020724689587950706, + 0.08140324056148529, + 0.2711201310157776, + 0.14423434436321259, + 0.03572973608970642, + 0.0928400307893753, + 0.059491753578186035 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 6, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036176491994410753 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in stark black-and-white with high contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a vast rolling sea composed entirely of cultivated farmland hills?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a boat with a dark charcoal-gray hull and a stylized animal head on the prow visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the boat's patchwork sail shown being lowered and collapsing onto the mast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a high-angle wide shot and slowly tilt right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04306808114051819 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680681705474854 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04306808114051819, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04306808114051819, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06655410677194595, + 0.05778636783361435, + 0.11974265426397324, + 0.18892331421375275, + 0.061732493340969086, + 0.05629682168364525, + 0.18526341021060944, + 0.07677186280488968, + 0.1288662850856781, + 0.058062728494405746 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04306808114051819 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in stark black-and-white with high contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a vast rolling sea composed entirely of cultivated farmland hills?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a boat with a dark charcoal-gray hull and a stylized animal head on the prow visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the boat's patchwork sail shown being lowered and collapsing onto the mast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a high-angle wide shot and slowly tilt right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.25206857919692993 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5020685195922852 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.25206857919692993, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.25206857919692993, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18742059171199799, + 0.1303502917289734, + 0.1918051838874817, + 0.13019205629825592, + 0.02122713252902031, + 0.028128674253821373, + 0.10216019302606583, + 0.03546326607465744, + 0.15712833404541016, + 0.016124209389090538 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.25206857919692993 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_2/index_tensor([5087, 5087])_group_2_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_2/index_tensor([5087, 5087])_group_2_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..0eba66a102df184df3e8ff5f7f48815251674a4f --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_2/index_tensor([5087, 5087])_group_2_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "striking underwater close-up, panning downward and right in a smooth, steady rhythm, descends into the murky, green-brown waters of a river laden with suspended particles, focusing on a red-bellied piranha. Its silver-gray scales gleam with a cold metallic sheen in the faint light filtering through the surface, its belly a startling blood-red, a stark contrast to the gloomy surroundings. With a sudden, explosive snap, its powerful jaws flung open, revealing two rows of razor-sharp, tightly interlocked triangular teeth. This menacing movement churns the surrounding water, sending tiny particles of sand and mud forming a chaotic vortex in its path. As the camera pans, every subtle yet powerful twitch of its muscles beneath its gill covers and on its flanks is captured with pinpoint photorealism, vividly conveying the predator's primal, hair-trigger aggression and creating a breathtaking atmosphere of tension.", + "seed": 27712, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_2/index_5087_seed_27712_dp_4_rank_8_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.10066328831017017, + "vlm_logprob": -0.10066328831017017, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.7250000119209288, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.10066328831017017, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set underwater in murky, green-brown water with suspended particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a red-bellied piranha with silver-gray scales and a blood-red belly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the piranha open its jaws explosively to reveal two rows of razor-sharp, triangular teeth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the piranha's movement churn the water to create a chaotic vortex of sand and mud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan downward and right in a smooth, steady rhythm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004005861934274435 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.0040059089660645 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004005861934274435, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004005861934274435, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5469411611557007, + 0.06669219583272934, + 0.10095174610614777, + 0.048144999891519547, + 0.02161683514714241, + 0.03974214196205139, + 0.06754550337791443, + 0.06314337998628616, + 0.018424727022647858, + 0.02679736167192459 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004005861934274435 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set underwater in murky, green-brown water with suspended particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a red-bellied piranha with silver-gray scales and a blood-red belly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the piranha open its jaws explosively to reveal two rows of razor-sharp, triangular teeth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the piranha's movement churn the water to create a chaotic vortex of sand and mud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan downward and right in a smooth, steady rhythm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005955214146524668 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130955219268799 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005955214146524668, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005955214146524668, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13249525427818298, + 0.08052226901054382, + 0.13923683762550354, + 0.11766967177391052, + 0.0887613520026207, + 0.07565314322710037, + 0.10950741916894913, + 0.06941930949687958, + 0.16010569036006927, + 0.02662908099591732 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005955214146524668 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set underwater in murky, green-brown water with suspended particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a red-bellied piranha with silver-gray scales and a blood-red belly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the piranha open its jaws explosively to reveal two rows of razor-sharp, triangular teeth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the piranha's movement churn the water to create a chaotic vortex of sand and mud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan downward and right in a smooth, steady rhythm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02634247951209545 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513423919677734 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02634247951209545, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02634247951209545, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22016677260398865, + 0.10265779495239258, + 0.2580610513687134, + 0.0905165895819664, + 0.02553955465555191, + 0.04970651492476463, + 0.04651704430580139, + 0.037957023829221725, + 0.1358782947063446, + 0.032999396324157715 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02634247951209545 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set underwater in murky, green-brown water with suspended particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a red-bellied piranha with silver-gray scales and a blood-red belly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the piranha open its jaws explosively to reveal two rows of razor-sharp, triangular teeth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the piranha's movement churn the water to create a chaotic vortex of sand and mud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan downward and right in a smooth, steady rhythm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.038108889013528824 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881088256835938 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.038108889013528824, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.038108889013528824, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3721800446510315, + 0.05981133505702019, + 0.28443390130996704, + 0.04795709624886513, + 0.04828890413045883, + 0.03866986930370331, + 0.04399614408612251, + 0.020462676882743835, + 0.04912067577242851, + 0.03507942333817482 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.038108889013528824 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set underwater in murky, green-brown water with suspended particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a red-bellied piranha with silver-gray scales and a blood-red belly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the piranha open its jaws explosively to reveal two rows of razor-sharp, triangular teeth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the piranha's movement churn the water to create a chaotic vortex of sand and mud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan downward and right in a smooth, steady rhythm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4289039969444275 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.0539040565490723 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.4289039969444275, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.6250000596046448, + "token_credit_reward": -0.4289039969444275, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3125463128089905, + 0.060402438044548035, + 0.03748447820544243, + 0.11071303486824036, + 0.059493537992239, + 0.14680446684360504, + 0.09274252504110336, + 0.0774615928530693, + 0.07560279965400696, + 0.02674880065023899 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.4289039969444275 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "striking underwater close-up, panning downward and right in a smooth, steady rhythm, descends into the murky, green-brown waters of a river laden with suspended particles, focusing on a red-bellied piranha. Its silver-gray scales gleam with a cold metallic sheen in the faint light filtering through the surface, its belly a startling blood-red, a stark contrast to the gloomy surroundings. With a sudden, explosive snap, its powerful jaws flung open, revealing two rows of razor-sharp, tightly interlocked triangular teeth. This menacing movement churns the surrounding water, sending tiny particles of sand and mud forming a chaotic vortex in its path. As the camera pans, every subtle yet powerful twitch of its muscles beneath its gill covers and on its flanks is captured with pinpoint photorealism, vividly conveying the predator's primal, hair-trigger aggression and creating a breathtaking atmosphere of tension.", + "seed": 27713, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_2/index_5087_seed_27713_dp_4_rank_8_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.12680708495900034, + "vlm_logprob": -0.12680708495900034, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.325, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.12680708495900034, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set underwater in murky, green-brown water with suspended particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a red-bellied piranha with silver-gray scales and a blood-red belly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the piranha open its jaws explosively to reveal two rows of razor-sharp, triangular teeth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the piranha's movement churn the water to create a chaotic vortex of sand and mud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan downward and right in a smooth, steady rhythm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004055015742778778 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.629055023193359 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004055015742778778, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004055015742778778, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17066185176372528, + 0.34078386425971985, + 0.02564571052789688, + 0.06677413731813431, + 0.03826048597693443, + 0.10458884388208389, + 0.025829331949353218, + 0.028164595365524292, + 0.09232062101364136, + 0.10697048902511597 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004055015742778778 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set underwater in murky, green-brown water with suspended particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a red-bellied piranha with silver-gray scales and a blood-red belly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the piranha open its jaws explosively to reveal two rows of razor-sharp, triangular teeth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the piranha's movement churn the water to create a chaotic vortex of sand and mud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan downward and right in a smooth, steady rhythm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004641236271709204 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379641056060791 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004641236271709204, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004641236271709204, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06274448335170746, + 0.1728745698928833, + 0.04476431384682655, + 0.0699012503027916, + 0.06546955555677414, + 0.23613639175891876, + 0.10441076010465622, + 0.1167813092470169, + 0.05009813979268074, + 0.07681918889284134 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004641236271709204 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set underwater in murky, green-brown water with suspended particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a red-bellied piranha with silver-gray scales and a blood-red belly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the piranha open its jaws explosively to reveal two rows of razor-sharp, triangular teeth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the piranha's movement churn the water to create a chaotic vortex of sand and mud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan downward and right in a smooth, steady rhythm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06204884499311447 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.81204891204834 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06204884499311447, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06204884499311447, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06468640267848969, + 0.3321118652820587, + 0.04463975131511688, + 0.1199016273021698, + 0.02862088568508625, + 0.1303998827934265, + 0.07967530936002731, + 0.12386119365692139, + 0.0461951345205307, + 0.029907917603850365 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06204884499311447 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set underwater in murky, green-brown water with suspended particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a red-bellied piranha with silver-gray scales and a blood-red belly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the piranha open its jaws explosively to reveal two rows of razor-sharp, triangular teeth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the piranha's movement churn the water to create a chaotic vortex of sand and mud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan downward and right in a smooth, steady rhythm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08904513716697693 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4640450477600098 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08904513716697693, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08904513716697693, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13868585228919983, + 0.30683404207229614, + 0.03643840551376343, + 0.062102749943733215, + 0.016397418454289436, + 0.3291764557361603, + 0.015360940247774124, + 0.022276531904935837, + 0.05425455793738365, + 0.018473012372851372 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08904513716697693 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set underwater in murky, green-brown water with suspended particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a red-bellied piranha with silver-gray scales and a blood-red belly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the piranha open its jaws explosively to reveal two rows of razor-sharp, triangular teeth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the piranha's movement churn the water to create a chaotic vortex of sand and mud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan downward and right in a smooth, steady rhythm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.47424519062042236 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9742451906204224 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.47424519062042236, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.47424519062042236, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13897216320037842, + 0.08858570456504822, + 0.03205006942152977, + 0.1177387461066246, + 0.0894981250166893, + 0.3501783609390259, + 0.08519906550645828, + 0.027427751570940018, + 0.05133192241191864, + 0.019018113613128662 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.47424519062042236 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "striking underwater close-up, panning downward and right in a smooth, steady rhythm, descends into the murky, green-brown waters of a river laden with suspended particles, focusing on a red-bellied piranha. Its silver-gray scales gleam with a cold metallic sheen in the faint light filtering through the surface, its belly a startling blood-red, a stark contrast to the gloomy surroundings. With a sudden, explosive snap, its powerful jaws flung open, revealing two rows of razor-sharp, tightly interlocked triangular teeth. This menacing movement churns the surrounding water, sending tiny particles of sand and mud forming a chaotic vortex in its path. As the camera pans, every subtle yet powerful twitch of its muscles beneath its gill covers and on its flanks is captured with pinpoint photorealism, vividly conveying the predator's primal, hair-trigger aggression and creating a breathtaking atmosphere of tension.", + "seed": 27714, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_2/index_5087_seed_27714_dp_5_rank_10_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.09811453428119421, + "vlm_logprob": -0.09811453428119421, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.85, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.09811453428119421, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set underwater in murky, green-brown water with suspended particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a red-bellied piranha with silver-gray scales and a blood-red belly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the piranha open its jaws explosively to reveal two rows of razor-sharp, triangular teeth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the piranha's movement churn the water to create a chaotic vortex of sand and mud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan downward and right in a smooth, steady rhythm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004589144140481949 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504589080810547 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004589144140481949, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004589144140481949, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11552950739860535, + 0.11104708164930344, + 0.1213512271642685, + 0.04615755006670952, + 0.04030413553118706, + 0.11297160387039185, + 0.11966268718242645, + 0.17042657732963562, + 0.0733974277973175, + 0.0891522467136383 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 2, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004589144140481949 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set underwater in murky, green-brown water with suspended particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a red-bellied piranha with silver-gray scales and a blood-red belly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the piranha open its jaws explosively to reveal two rows of razor-sharp, triangular teeth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the piranha's movement churn the water to create a chaotic vortex of sand and mud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan downward and right in a smooth, steady rhythm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0028237728402018547 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877823829650879 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0028237728402018547, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0028237728402018547, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0919719859957695, + 0.07426738739013672, + 0.11009141057729721, + 0.1288796365261078, + 0.16384494304656982, + 0.05746425688266754, + 0.15181730687618256, + 0.09305049479007721, + 0.06687641143798828, + 0.06173614785075188 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0028237728402018547 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set underwater in murky, green-brown water with suspended particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a red-bellied piranha with silver-gray scales and a blood-red belly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the piranha open its jaws explosively to reveal two rows of razor-sharp, triangular teeth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the piranha's movement churn the water to create a chaotic vortex of sand and mud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan downward and right in a smooth, steady rhythm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020578335970640182 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895578384399414 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020578335970640182, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020578335970640182, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06755152344703674, + 0.05179208517074585, + 0.07237496972084045, + 0.061191290616989136, + 0.07461574673652649, + 0.05616852641105652, + 0.19297727942466736, + 0.12939327955245972, + 0.07603462785482407, + 0.21790073812007904 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020578335970640182 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set underwater in murky, green-brown water with suspended particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a red-bellied piranha with silver-gray scales and a blood-red belly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the piranha open its jaws explosively to reveal two rows of razor-sharp, triangular teeth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the piranha's movement churn the water to create a chaotic vortex of sand and mud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan downward and right in a smooth, steady rhythm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03370582312345505 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408705711364746 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03370582312345505, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03370582312345505, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1009896844625473, + 0.05438147857785225, + 0.22754693031311035, + 0.028961243107914925, + 0.08240670710802078, + 0.07477907836437225, + 0.0655640959739685, + 0.23348860442638397, + 0.07889758795499802, + 0.052984569221735 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03370582312345505 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set underwater in murky, green-brown water with suspended particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a red-bellied piranha with silver-gray scales and a blood-red belly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the piranha open its jaws explosively to reveal two rows of razor-sharp, triangular teeth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the piranha's movement churn the water to create a chaotic vortex of sand and mud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan downward and right in a smooth, steady rhythm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.428875595331192 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.0538755655288696 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.428875595331192, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.428875595331192, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11149653047323227, + 0.1234607845544815, + 0.09903881698846817, + 0.06834026426076889, + 0.10571199655532837, + 0.03270839899778366, + 0.06298480182886124, + 0.1543428748846054, + 0.03684031963348389, + 0.205075204372406 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.428875595331192 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "striking underwater close-up, panning downward and right in a smooth, steady rhythm, descends into the murky, green-brown waters of a river laden with suspended particles, focusing on a red-bellied piranha. Its silver-gray scales gleam with a cold metallic sheen in the faint light filtering through the surface, its belly a startling blood-red, a stark contrast to the gloomy surroundings. With a sudden, explosive snap, its powerful jaws flung open, revealing two rows of razor-sharp, tightly interlocked triangular teeth. This menacing movement churns the surrounding water, sending tiny particles of sand and mud forming a chaotic vortex in its path. As the camera pans, every subtle yet powerful twitch of its muscles beneath its gill covers and on its flanks is captured with pinpoint photorealism, vividly conveying the predator's primal, hair-trigger aggression and creating a breathtaking atmosphere of tension.", + "seed": 27715, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_2/index_5087_seed_27715_dp_5_rank_10_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.08184693437069654, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08184693437069654, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.7, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08184693437069654, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set underwater in murky, green-brown water with suspended particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a red-bellied piranha with silver-gray scales and a blood-red belly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the piranha open its jaws explosively to reveal two rows of razor-sharp, triangular teeth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the piranha's movement churn the water to create a chaotic vortex of sand and mud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan downward and right in a smooth, steady rhythm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008442427031695843 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.883442401885986 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008442427031695843, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008442427031695843, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12844710052013397, + 0.11405932158231735, + 0.14139345288276672, + 0.03315822780132294, + 0.08952951431274414, + 0.14964936673641205, + 0.05418916419148445, + 0.1326175481081009, + 0.06689370423555374, + 0.09006264805793762 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 2, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008442427031695843 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set underwater in murky, green-brown water with suspended particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a red-bellied piranha with silver-gray scales and a blood-red belly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the piranha open its jaws explosively to reveal two rows of razor-sharp, triangular teeth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the piranha's movement churn the water to create a chaotic vortex of sand and mud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan downward and right in a smooth, steady rhythm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005259249359369278 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255259037017822 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005259249359369278, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005259249359369278, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13916891813278198, + 0.04542364552617073, + 0.0888311117887497, + 0.04973793402314186, + 0.06749290227890015, + 0.025990573689341545, + 0.026966340839862823, + 0.09055425971746445, + 0.06487202644348145, + 0.40096232295036316 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005259249359369278 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set underwater in murky, green-brown water with suspended particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a red-bellied piranha with silver-gray scales and a blood-red belly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the piranha open its jaws explosively to reveal two rows of razor-sharp, triangular teeth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the piranha's movement churn the water to create a chaotic vortex of sand and mud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan downward and right in a smooth, steady rhythm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02634189836680889 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513419151306152 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02634189836680889, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02634189836680889, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14879149198532104, + 0.10021606087684631, + 0.05505846440792084, + 0.06554378569126129, + 0.05301298201084137, + 0.04607893154025078, + 0.037815432995557785, + 0.1746799647808075, + 0.06457869708538055, + 0.2542242109775543 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02634189836680889 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set underwater in murky, green-brown water with suspended particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a red-bellied piranha with silver-gray scales and a blood-red belly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the piranha open its jaws explosively to reveal two rows of razor-sharp, triangular teeth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the piranha's movement churn the water to create a chaotic vortex of sand and mud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan downward and right in a smooth, steady rhythm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020583825185894966 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955838680267334 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020583825185894966, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020583825185894966, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20277473330497742, + 0.14350126683712006, + 0.13332822918891907, + 0.081085205078125, + 0.05126100778579712, + 0.028471624478697777, + 0.019580533728003502, + 0.15381354093551636, + 0.06799164414405823, + 0.1181921735405922 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020583825185894966 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set underwater in murky, green-brown water with suspended particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a red-bellied piranha with silver-gray scales and a blood-red belly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the piranha open its jaws explosively to reveal two rows of razor-sharp, triangular teeth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the piranha's movement churn the water to create a chaotic vortex of sand and mud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan downward and right in a smooth, steady rhythm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.34860727190971375 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2236073017120361 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.34860727190971375, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.34860727190971375, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20364609360694885, + 0.2001407891511917, + 0.11074002087116241, + 0.07409439235925674, + 0.0890527293086052, + 0.08261433243751526, + 0.040898390114307404, + 0.11638418585062027, + 0.04028920829296112, + 0.04213986545801163 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.34860727190971375 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_3/index_tensor([9597, 9597])_group_3_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_3/index_tensor([9597, 9597])_group_3_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..4773429e221cd3d3fe083af28143689747c25f6b --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_3/index_tensor([9597, 9597])_group_3_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "slow, sweeping shot from left to right reveals a wide shot of an enchanting garden, rendered in the warm, detailed style of Pixar animation, with every leaf and petal perfectly formed. Ethereal tendrils of soft mist drift lazily across the frame, weaving between the stems of oversized ferns and soft-petaled flowers, catching the light as they move. The ground is completely enshrouded in a vibrant, velvety carpet of moss, its surface a rich tapestry of emerald and chartreuse that shimmers in the soft light. This lush moss extends to the edge of a tranquil pond, whose perfectly still, glassy surface perfectly reflects the soft golden light of the hidden sun and the contours of the surrounding foliage. The entire scene is bathed in a warm, diffused glow, creating an atmosphere of magical tranquility. A subtle layer of film grain has been applied to the original animation, adding a delicate, nostalgic texture and enhancing the feeling of a cherished, half-remembered dream.", + "seed": 6275, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_3/index_9597_seed_6275_dp_6_rank_12_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.14094760324805974, + "vlm_logprob": -0.14094760324805974, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.9, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.14094760324805974, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a slow, sweeping shot from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in the warm, detailed style of Pixar animation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are ethereal tendrils of soft mist drifting across the frame among oversized ferns and soft-petaled flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the ground covered in a vibrant, velvety carpet of moss with a rich tapestry of emerald and chartreuse colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a tranquil pond with a perfectly still, glassy surface reflecting the soft golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0840086117386818 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5840086936950684 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0840086117386818, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0840086117386818, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03350115939974785, + 0.2290569245815277, + 0.03193436563014984, + 0.0555456280708313, + 0.012655843049287796, + 0.015646638348698616, + 0.011107047088444233, + 0.5321994423866272, + 0.059793174266815186, + 0.018559865653514862 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0840086117386818 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a slow, sweeping shot from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in the warm, detailed style of Pixar animation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are ethereal tendrils of soft mist drifting across the frame among oversized ferns and soft-petaled flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the ground covered in a vibrant, velvety carpet of moss with a rich tapestry of emerald and chartreuse colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a tranquil pond with a perfectly still, glassy surface reflecting the soft golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4742562472820282 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9742562770843506 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.4742562472820282, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.4742562472820282, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07449182122945786, + 0.06938647478818893, + 0.03763512149453163, + 0.02689170278608799, + 0.0657920390367508, + 0.035917412489652634, + 0.024996645748615265, + 0.46510735154151917, + 0.03055969998240471, + 0.1692216992378235 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.4742562472820282 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a slow, sweeping shot from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in the warm, detailed style of Pixar animation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are ethereal tendrils of soft mist drifting across the frame among oversized ferns and soft-petaled flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the ground covered in a vibrant, velvety carpet of moss with a rich tapestry of emerald and chartreuse colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a tranquil pond with a perfectly still, glassy surface reflecting the soft golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0052610281854867935 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255260944366455 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0052610281854867935, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0052610281854867935, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0848463624715805, + 0.16375961899757385, + 0.06901102513074875, + 0.029631083831191063, + 0.053677722811698914, + 0.13204549252986908, + 0.03703838586807251, + 0.06195353344082832, + 0.10074084252119064, + 0.2672959268093109 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0052610281854867935 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a slow, sweeping shot from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in the warm, detailed style of Pixar animation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are ethereal tendrils of soft mist drifting across the frame among oversized ferns and soft-petaled flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the ground covered in a vibrant, velvety carpet of moss with a rich tapestry of emerald and chartreuse colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a tranquil pond with a perfectly still, glassy surface reflecting the soft golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014188953675329685 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264188766479492 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014188953675329685, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014188953675329685, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11499850451946259, + 0.1418733447790146, + 0.16256596148014069, + 0.0493062287569046, + 0.05436375364661217, + 0.032487012445926666, + 0.02036585472524166, + 0.2399977296590805, + 0.05893592908978462, + 0.125105619430542 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014188953675329685 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a slow, sweeping shot from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in the warm, detailed style of Pixar animation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are ethereal tendrils of soft mist drifting across the frame among oversized ferns and soft-petaled flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the ground covered in a vibrant, velvety carpet of moss with a rich tapestry of emerald and chartreuse colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a tranquil pond with a perfectly still, glassy surface reflecting the soft golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12702317535877228 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.127023220062256 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12702317535877228, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12702317535877228, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03735632821917534, + 0.03921886906027794, + 0.04745480790734291, + 0.03690557926893234, + 0.04181480407714844, + 0.02282240428030491, + 0.023135917261242867, + 0.46460363268852234, + 0.1973869800567627, + 0.08930057287216187 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12702317535877228 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow, sweeping shot from left to right reveals a wide shot of an enchanting garden, rendered in the warm, detailed style of Pixar animation, with every leaf and petal perfectly formed. Ethereal tendrils of soft mist drift lazily across the frame, weaving between the stems of oversized ferns and soft-petaled flowers, catching the light as they move. The ground is completely enshrouded in a vibrant, velvety carpet of moss, its surface a rich tapestry of emerald and chartreuse that shimmers in the soft light. This lush moss extends to the edge of a tranquil pond, whose perfectly still, glassy surface perfectly reflects the soft golden light of the hidden sun and the contours of the surrounding foliage. The entire scene is bathed in a warm, diffused glow, creating an atmosphere of magical tranquility. A subtle layer of film grain has been applied to the original animation, adding a delicate, nostalgic texture and enhancing the feeling of a cherished, half-remembered dream.", + "seed": 6276, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_3/index_9597_seed_6276_dp_6_rank_12_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.07493529482744635, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07493529482744635, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.525, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07493529482744635, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a slow, sweeping shot from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in the warm, detailed style of Pixar animation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are ethereal tendrils of soft mist drifting across the frame among oversized ferns and soft-petaled flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the ground covered in a vibrant, velvety carpet of moss with a rich tapestry of emerald and chartreuse colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a tranquil pond with a perfectly still, glassy surface reflecting the soft golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14580269157886505 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0208027362823486 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14580269157886505, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14580269157886505, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07855290919542313, + 0.13981547951698303, + 0.09161517024040222, + 0.046339474618434906, + 0.05651203915476799, + 0.15622271597385406, + 0.02909666672348976, + 0.062015023082494736, + 0.15891101956367493, + 0.1809195578098297 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14580269157886505 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a slow, sweeping shot from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in the warm, detailed style of Pixar animation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are ethereal tendrils of soft mist drifting across the frame among oversized ferns and soft-petaled flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the ground covered in a vibrant, velvety carpet of moss with a rich tapestry of emerald and chartreuse colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a tranquil pond with a perfectly still, glassy surface reflecting the soft golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14279228448867798 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.017792224884033 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14279228448867798, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14279228448867798, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1240990087389946, + 0.14989326894283295, + 0.019199414178729057, + 0.043074000626802444, + 0.029958045110106468, + 0.07588652521371841, + 0.02713415026664734, + 0.01252159383147955, + 0.45044365525245667, + 0.06779036670923233 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14279228448867798 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a slow, sweeping shot from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in the warm, detailed style of Pixar animation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are ethereal tendrils of soft mist drifting across the frame among oversized ferns and soft-petaled flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the ground covered in a vibrant, velvety carpet of moss with a rich tapestry of emerald and chartreuse colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a tranquil pond with a perfectly still, glassy surface reflecting the soft golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0024944401811808348 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.0024943351745605 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0024944401811808348, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0024944401811808348, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2034246176481247, + 0.04714680835604668, + 0.09257067739963531, + 0.06667816638946533, + 0.025095203891396523, + 0.04839931055903435, + 0.03264891356229782, + 0.016988834366202354, + 0.3801937401294708, + 0.0868537649512291 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0024944401811808348 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a slow, sweeping shot from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in the warm, detailed style of Pixar animation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are ethereal tendrils of soft mist drifting across the frame among oversized ferns and soft-petaled flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the ground covered in a vibrant, velvety carpet of moss with a rich tapestry of emerald and chartreuse colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a tranquil pond with a perfectly still, glassy surface reflecting the soft golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004633523523807526 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.37963342666626 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004633523523807526, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004633523523807526, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12749701738357544, + 0.07887595146894455, + 0.19350187480449677, + 0.052397724241018295, + 0.06292881816625595, + 0.05786062404513359, + 0.14925327897071838, + 0.07269126921892166, + 0.053145281970500946, + 0.1518481969833374 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004633523523807526 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a slow, sweeping shot from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in the warm, detailed style of Pixar animation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are ethereal tendrils of soft mist drifting across the frame among oversized ferns and soft-petaled flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the ground covered in a vibrant, velvety carpet of moss with a rich tapestry of emerald and chartreuse colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a tranquil pond with a perfectly still, glassy surface reflecting the soft golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07895353436470032 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.578953504562378 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07895353436470032, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07895353436470032, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07449489831924438, + 0.20971554517745972, + 0.20894145965576172, + 0.030713560059666634, + 0.022417716681957245, + 0.03786122798919678, + 0.25302863121032715, + 0.016288764774799347, + 0.04763012006878853, + 0.09890812635421753 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07895353436470032 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow, sweeping shot from left to right reveals a wide shot of an enchanting garden, rendered in the warm, detailed style of Pixar animation, with every leaf and petal perfectly formed. Ethereal tendrils of soft mist drift lazily across the frame, weaving between the stems of oversized ferns and soft-petaled flowers, catching the light as they move. The ground is completely enshrouded in a vibrant, velvety carpet of moss, its surface a rich tapestry of emerald and chartreuse that shimmers in the soft light. This lush moss extends to the edge of a tranquil pond, whose perfectly still, glassy surface perfectly reflects the soft golden light of the hidden sun and the contours of the surrounding foliage. The entire scene is bathed in a warm, diffused glow, creating an atmosphere of magical tranquility. A subtle layer of film grain has been applied to the original animation, adding a delicate, nostalgic texture and enhancing the feeling of a cherished, half-remembered dream.", + "seed": 6277, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_3/index_9597_seed_6277_dp_7_rank_14_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.4013070918619633, + "vlm_logprob": -0.4013070918619633, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.275, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.4013070918619633, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a slow, sweeping shot from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in the warm, detailed style of Pixar animation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are ethereal tendrils of soft mist drifting across the frame among oversized ferns and soft-petaled flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the ground covered in a vibrant, velvety carpet of moss with a rich tapestry of emerald and chartreuse colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a tranquil pond with a perfectly still, glassy surface reflecting the soft golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3547651469707489 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2297651767730713 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3547651469707489, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3547651469707489, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2525211572647095, + 0.05104678124189377, + 0.03840025141835213, + 0.11141840368509293, + 0.029863862320780754, + 0.06542135030031204, + 0.18520841002464294, + 0.031245768070220947, + 0.15430597960948944, + 0.08056808263063431 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3547651469707489 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a slow, sweeping shot from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in the warm, detailed style of Pixar animation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are ethereal tendrils of soft mist drifting across the frame among oversized ferns and soft-petaled flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the ground covered in a vibrant, velvety carpet of moss with a rich tapestry of emerald and chartreuse colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a tranquil pond with a perfectly still, glassy surface reflecting the soft golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1370400190353394 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.38704004883766174 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.1370400190353394, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -1.1370400190353394, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23537956178188324, + 0.09145373851060867, + 0.05099659040570259, + 0.06947199255228043, + 0.13175973296165466, + 0.032526444643735886, + 0.22602243721485138, + 0.023103870451450348, + 0.05553952232003212, + 0.08374611288309097 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.1370400190353394 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a slow, sweeping shot from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in the warm, detailed style of Pixar animation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are ethereal tendrils of soft mist drifting across the frame among oversized ferns and soft-petaled flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the ground covered in a vibrant, velvety carpet of moss with a rich tapestry of emerald and chartreuse colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a tranquil pond with a perfectly still, glassy surface reflecting the soft golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04868021234869957 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048680305480957 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04868021234869957, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04868021234869957, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.43601733446121216, + 0.08999889343976974, + 0.021193180233240128, + 0.03883124142885208, + 0.03885026276111603, + 0.026885347440838814, + 0.17630469799041748, + 0.03697866573929787, + 0.06495129317045212, + 0.06998908519744873 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04868021234869957 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a slow, sweeping shot from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in the warm, detailed style of Pixar animation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are ethereal tendrils of soft mist drifting across the frame among oversized ferns and soft-petaled flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the ground covered in a vibrant, velvety carpet of moss with a rich tapestry of emerald and chartreuse colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a tranquil pond with a perfectly still, glassy surface reflecting the soft golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07899495214223862 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5789949893951416 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07899495214223862, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07899495214223862, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.33149585127830505, + 0.1543148308992386, + 0.03836417198181152, + 0.030721647664904594, + 0.048739366233348846, + 0.08786330372095108, + 0.13695864379405975, + 0.044360458850860596, + 0.0867508128285408, + 0.04043102636933327 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07899495214223862 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a slow, sweeping shot from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in the warm, detailed style of Pixar animation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are ethereal tendrils of soft mist drifting across the frame among oversized ferns and soft-petaled flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the ground covered in a vibrant, velvety carpet of moss with a rich tapestry of emerald and chartreuse colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a tranquil pond with a perfectly still, glassy surface reflecting the soft golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3870551288127899 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1370551586151123 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3870551288127899, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3870551288127899, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09035077691078186, + 0.03702860325574875, + 0.025225818157196045, + 0.06332643330097198, + 0.0364433154463768, + 0.16647817194461823, + 0.244999960064888, + 0.037865523248910904, + 0.07462793588638306, + 0.22365346550941467 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3870551288127899 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow, sweeping shot from left to right reveals a wide shot of an enchanting garden, rendered in the warm, detailed style of Pixar animation, with every leaf and petal perfectly formed. Ethereal tendrils of soft mist drift lazily across the frame, weaving between the stems of oversized ferns and soft-petaled flowers, catching the light as they move. The ground is completely enshrouded in a vibrant, velvety carpet of moss, its surface a rich tapestry of emerald and chartreuse that shimmers in the soft light. This lush moss extends to the edge of a tranquil pond, whose perfectly still, glassy surface perfectly reflects the soft golden light of the hidden sun and the contours of the surrounding foliage. The entire scene is bathed in a warm, diffused glow, creating an atmosphere of magical tranquility. A subtle layer of film grain has been applied to the original animation, adding a delicate, nostalgic texture and enhancing the feeling of a cherished, half-remembered dream.", + "seed": 6278, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_3/index_9597_seed_6278_dp_7_rank_14_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.19065355639904738, + "vlm_logprob": -0.19065355639904738, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.375000011920929, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.19065355639904738, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a slow, sweeping shot from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in the warm, detailed style of Pixar animation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are ethereal tendrils of soft mist drifting across the frame among oversized ferns and soft-petaled flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the ground covered in a vibrant, velvety carpet of moss with a rich tapestry of emerald and chartreuse colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a tranquil pond with a perfectly still, glassy surface reflecting the soft golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.23076140880584717 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6057614088058472 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.23076140880584717, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.23076140880584717, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16456829011440277, + 0.3331625759601593, + 0.024800138548016548, + 0.16337381303310394, + 0.10458730161190033, + 0.04281583055853844, + 0.01968536339700222, + 0.038546349853277206, + 0.06980644911527634, + 0.03865388408303261 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.23076140880584717 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a slow, sweeping shot from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in the warm, detailed style of Pixar animation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are ethereal tendrils of soft mist drifting across the frame among oversized ferns and soft-petaled flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the ground covered in a vibrant, velvety carpet of moss with a rich tapestry of emerald and chartreuse colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a tranquil pond with a perfectly still, glassy surface reflecting the soft golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.34862107038497925 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.223621129989624 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.34862107038497925, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.8750000596046448, + "token_credit_reward": -0.34862107038497925, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23317426443099976, + 0.26333940029144287, + 0.025916729122400284, + 0.14942891895771027, + 0.11757851392030716, + 0.02023983933031559, + 0.05668660253286362, + 0.06660716980695724, + 0.0466201975941658, + 0.020408328622579575 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.34862107038497925 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a slow, sweeping shot from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in the warm, detailed style of Pixar animation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are ethereal tendrils of soft mist drifting across the frame among oversized ferns and soft-petaled flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the ground covered in a vibrant, velvety carpet of moss with a rich tapestry of emerald and chartreuse colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a tranquil pond with a perfectly still, glassy surface reflecting the soft golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01420646533370018 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264206409454346 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01420646533370018, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01420646533370018, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14547587931156158, + 0.6645063161849976, + 0.015348609536886215, + 0.09401082992553711, + 0.017163116484880447, + 0.009899791330099106, + 0.008113604038953781, + 0.012575211934745312, + 0.01663053035736084, + 0.01627611741423607 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01420646533370018 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a slow, sweeping shot from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in the warm, detailed style of Pixar animation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are ethereal tendrils of soft mist drifting across the frame among oversized ferns and soft-petaled flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the ground covered in a vibrant, velvety carpet of moss with a rich tapestry of emerald and chartreuse colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a tranquil pond with a perfectly still, glassy surface reflecting the soft golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011073562316596508 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511073589324951 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011073562316596508, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011073562316596508, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19372567534446716, + 0.3205047845840454, + 0.03652443364262581, + 0.1655232161283493, + 0.04549229145050049, + 0.028060633689165115, + 0.024825284257531166, + 0.13126373291015625, + 0.030338717624545097, + 0.02374119870364666 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011073562316596508 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a slow, sweeping shot from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in the warm, detailed style of Pixar animation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are ethereal tendrils of soft mist drifting across the frame among oversized ferns and soft-petaled flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the ground covered in a vibrant, velvety carpet of moss with a rich tapestry of emerald and chartreuse colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a tranquil pond with a perfectly still, glassy surface reflecting the soft golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.34860527515411377 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2236052751541138 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.34860527515411377, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.34860527515411377, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07584629207849503, + 0.33493563532829285, + 0.03358864039182663, + 0.18371036648750305, + 0.13495372235774994, + 0.02801026962697506, + 0.023697737604379654, + 0.1326645016670227, + 0.03206713870167732, + 0.020525753498077393 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.34860527515411377 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_4/index_tensor([3013, 3013])_group_4_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_4/index_tensor([3013, 3013])_group_4_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..040e4b2914d45b20838fea5dceb2aed8e67a1d4e --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_4/index_tensor([3013, 3013])_group_4_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "static, high-angle, bird's-eye view captures hyper-realistic CGI time-lapse footage of a massive Victoria Amazon water lily growing above still, dark water. The sequence begins with a tightly curled, spiky bud, its deep green form shimmering in soft, diffuse sunlight. The bud deliberately unfurls in a graceful, accelerated motion, revealing its intricately ribbed reddish-purple underside before its waxy, vibrant green topside begins its relentless expansion. As the leaf rapidly unfurls into a perfect circle, its surface reveals lifelike detail, every vein and subtle ripple rendered in 4K resolution, while its waxy texture causes tiny water droplets to dance and coalesce across its expanding surface. Finally, the massive, fully formed pad rests majestically on the water's surface, its raised edges forming sharp, clean edges against the dark liquid. Complex patterns of light filter through the surrounding clear water, creating a serene and awe-inspiring atmosphere of natural wonder.", + "seed": 31067, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_4/index_3013_seed_31067_dp_8_rank_16_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.0979156406596303, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0979156406596303, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.325, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0979156406596303, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a static high-angle bird's-eye view throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the sequence begin with a tightly curled, spiky deep green bud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bud unfurl to reveal a reddish-purple underside before expanding its green topside?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the final leaf a massive, fully formed circular pad with raised edges resting on dark water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are tiny water droplets visible dancing and coalescing on the waxy surface of the leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3881681263446808 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1381680965423584 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3881681263446808, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3881681263446808, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3834085762500763, + 0.04618934541940689, + 0.02485046535730362, + 0.024396736174821854, + 0.04846449941396713, + 0.10015183687210083, + 0.018957586959004402, + 0.2984110713005066, + 0.01890445500612259, + 0.036265403032302856 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3881681263446808 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a static high-angle bird's-eye view throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the sequence begin with a tightly curled, spiky deep green bud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bud unfurl to reveal a reddish-purple underside before expanding its green topside?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the final leaf a massive, fully formed circular pad with raised edges resting on dark water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are tiny water droplets visible dancing and coalescing on the waxy surface of the leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018193509429693222 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.01819372177124 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018193509429693222, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018193509429693222, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.6906234622001648, + 0.11003757268190384, + 0.01572323776781559, + 0.028651343658566475, + 0.03438478335738182, + 0.03882322087883949, + 0.005704491399228573, + 0.043685417622327805, + 0.017289044335484505, + 0.015077445656061172 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018193509429693222 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a static high-angle bird's-eye view throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the sequence begin with a tightly curled, spiky deep green bud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bud unfurl to reveal a reddish-purple underside before expanding its green topside?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the final leaf a massive, fully formed circular pad with raised edges resting on dark water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are tiny water droplets visible dancing and coalescing on the waxy surface of the leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008643477223813534 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758643627166748 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008643477223813534, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008643477223813534, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3815307915210724, + 0.08135034143924713, + 0.018687618896365166, + 0.023003168404102325, + 0.043354496359825134, + 0.0849442183971405, + 0.017774485051631927, + 0.30798789858818054, + 0.017537103965878487, + 0.02382981963455677 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008643477223813534 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a static high-angle bird's-eye view throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the sequence begin with a tightly curled, spiky deep green bud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bud unfurl to reveal a reddish-purple underside before expanding its green topside?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the final leaf a massive, fully formed circular pad with raised edges resting on dark water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are tiny water droplets visible dancing and coalescing on the waxy surface of the leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01253500021994114 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387535095214844 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01253500021994114, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01253500021994114, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09588274359703064, + 0.25067493319511414, + 0.04746019095182419, + 0.06894983351230621, + 0.05227172374725342, + 0.05520753934979439, + 0.028313206508755684, + 0.30073192715644836, + 0.021713798865675926, + 0.07879409939050674 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01253500021994114 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a static high-angle bird's-eye view throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the sequence begin with a tightly curled, spiky deep green bud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bud unfurl to reveal a reddish-purple underside before expanding its green topside?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the final leaf a massive, fully formed circular pad with raised edges resting on dark water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are tiny water droplets visible dancing and coalescing on the waxy surface of the leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06203809008002281 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120381832122803 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06203809008002281, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06203809008002281, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.6514667868614197, + 0.03347349539399147, + 0.012067976407706738, + 0.012038699351251125, + 0.03971949964761734, + 0.037039242684841156, + 0.008715836331248283, + 0.15066194534301758, + 0.015980668365955353, + 0.038835834711790085 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06203809008002281 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, high-angle, bird's-eye view captures hyper-realistic CGI time-lapse footage of a massive Victoria Amazon water lily growing above still, dark water. The sequence begins with a tightly curled, spiky bud, its deep green form shimmering in soft, diffuse sunlight. The bud deliberately unfurls in a graceful, accelerated motion, revealing its intricately ribbed reddish-purple underside before its waxy, vibrant green topside begins its relentless expansion. As the leaf rapidly unfurls into a perfect circle, its surface reveals lifelike detail, every vein and subtle ripple rendered in 4K resolution, while its waxy texture causes tiny water droplets to dance and coalesce across its expanding surface. Finally, the massive, fully formed pad rests majestically on the water's surface, its raised edges forming sharp, clean edges against the dark liquid. Complex patterns of light filter through the surrounding clear water, creating a serene and awe-inspiring atmosphere of natural wonder.", + "seed": 31068, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_4/index_3013_seed_31068_dp_8_rank_16_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.16498186914250254, + "vlm_logprob": -0.16498186914250254, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.55, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.16498186914250254, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a static high-angle bird's-eye view throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the sequence begin with a tightly curled, spiky deep green bud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bud unfurl to reveal a reddish-purple underside before expanding its green topside?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the final leaf a massive, fully formed circular pad with raised edges resting on dark water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are tiny water droplets visible dancing and coalescing on the waxy surface of the leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7587916851043701 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6337916851043701 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.7587916851043701, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.7587916851043701, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12148088961839676, + 0.11539745330810547, + 0.09581822156906128, + 0.042186059057712555, + 0.19685319066047668, + 0.07928955554962158, + 0.16836796700954437, + 0.044246606528759, + 0.02560434676706791, + 0.11075565963983536 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.7587916851043701 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a static high-angle bird's-eye view throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the sequence begin with a tightly curled, spiky deep green bud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bud unfurl to reveal a reddish-purple underside before expanding its green topside?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the final leaf a massive, fully formed circular pad with raised edges resting on dark water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are tiny water droplets visible dancing and coalescing on the waxy surface of the leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005261146929115057 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255260944366455 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005261146929115057, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005261146929115057, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2436429113149643, + 0.13455411791801453, + 0.054919466376304626, + 0.02962746098637581, + 0.052631571888923645, + 0.0574781633913517, + 0.30802294611930847, + 0.032714154571294785, + 0.033461179584264755, + 0.052948083728551865 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005261146929115057 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a static high-angle bird's-eye view throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the sequence begin with a tightly curled, spiky deep green bud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bud unfurl to reveal a reddish-purple underside before expanding its green topside?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the final leaf a massive, fully formed circular pad with raised edges resting on dark water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are tiny water droplets visible dancing and coalescing on the waxy surface of the leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006737136282026768 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006737232208252 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006737136282026768, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006737136282026768, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15642721951007843, + 0.13979758322238922, + 0.08670534193515778, + 0.05356266722083092, + 0.31546351313591003, + 0.05061563104391098, + 0.09612362086772919, + 0.04239639267325401, + 0.024236172437667847, + 0.03467186167836189 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006737136282026768 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a static high-angle bird's-eye view throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the sequence begin with a tightly curled, spiky deep green bud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bud unfurl to reveal a reddish-purple underside before expanding its green topside?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the final leaf a massive, fully formed circular pad with raised edges resting on dark water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are tiny water droplets visible dancing and coalescing on the waxy surface of the leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011069907806813717 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.5110697746276855 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011069907806813717, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011069907806813717, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11791537702083588, + 0.04897630214691162, + 0.055771857500076294, + 0.036463044583797455, + 0.14632396399974823, + 0.11146413534879684, + 0.3004901111125946, + 0.07701869308948517, + 0.02698345296084881, + 0.07859303802251816 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011069907806813717 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a static high-angle bird's-eye view throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the sequence begin with a tightly curled, spiky deep green bud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bud unfurl to reveal a reddish-purple underside before expanding its green topside?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the final leaf a massive, fully formed circular pad with raised edges resting on dark water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are tiny water droplets visible dancing and coalescing on the waxy surface of the leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04304946959018707 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680495738983154 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04304946959018707, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04304946959018707, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09828125685453415, + 0.01747617870569229, + 0.02576482482254505, + 0.03938658535480499, + 0.07785546034574509, + 0.03490869328379631, + 0.31651076674461365, + 0.1071959137916565, + 0.0428880900144577, + 0.23973216116428375 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04304946959018707 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, high-angle, bird's-eye view captures hyper-realistic CGI time-lapse footage of a massive Victoria Amazon water lily growing above still, dark water. The sequence begins with a tightly curled, spiky bud, its deep green form shimmering in soft, diffuse sunlight. The bud deliberately unfurls in a graceful, accelerated motion, revealing its intricately ribbed reddish-purple underside before its waxy, vibrant green topside begins its relentless expansion. As the leaf rapidly unfurls into a perfect circle, its surface reveals lifelike detail, every vein and subtle ripple rendered in 4K resolution, while its waxy texture causes tiny water droplets to dance and coalesce across its expanding surface. Finally, the massive, fully formed pad rests majestically on the water's surface, its raised edges forming sharp, clean edges against the dark liquid. Complex patterns of light filter through the surrounding clear water, creating a serene and awe-inspiring atmosphere of natural wonder.", + "seed": 31069, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_4/index_3013_seed_31069_dp_9_rank_18_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.04333686986938119, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04333686986938119, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.375, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04333686986938119, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a static high-angle bird's-eye view throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the sequence begin with a tightly curled, spiky deep green bud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bud unfurl to reveal a reddish-purple underside before expanding its green topside?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the final leaf a massive, fully formed circular pad with raised edges resting on dark water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are tiny water droplets visible dancing and coalescing on the waxy surface of the leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1618773639202118 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9118773937225342 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1618773639202118, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1618773639202118, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12679444253444672, + 0.07673942297697067, + 0.2380375862121582, + 0.07354959845542908, + 0.036336466670036316, + 0.04517005756497383, + 0.07904417812824249, + 0.11000890284776688, + 0.14622589945793152, + 0.06809340417385101 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1618773639202118 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a static high-angle bird's-eye view throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the sequence begin with a tightly curled, spiky deep green bud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bud unfurl to reveal a reddish-purple underside before expanding its green topside?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the final leaf a massive, fully formed circular pad with raised edges resting on dark water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are tiny water droplets visible dancing and coalescing on the waxy surface of the leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0022019920870661736 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127202033996582 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0022019920870661736, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0022019920870661736, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17682689428329468, + 0.17114433646202087, + 0.2125699520111084, + 0.03249895200133324, + 0.07618658989667892, + 0.03717136010527611, + 0.04117007181048393, + 0.12447937577962875, + 0.08823832124471664, + 0.03971409052610397 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0022019920870661736 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a static high-angle bird's-eye view throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the sequence begin with a tightly curled, spiky deep green bud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bud unfurl to reveal a reddish-purple underside before expanding its green topside?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the final leaf a massive, fully formed circular pad with raised edges resting on dark water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are tiny water droplets visible dancing and coalescing on the waxy surface of the leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006739267613738775 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006739139556885 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006739267613738775, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006739267613738775, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1230585128068924, + 0.105681411921978, + 0.4123918116092682, + 0.03536555543541908, + 0.04067075625061989, + 0.06227998062968254, + 0.0400439128279686, + 0.030157076194882393, + 0.07810714095830917, + 0.07224386930465698 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006739267613738775 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a static high-angle bird's-eye view throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the sequence begin with a tightly curled, spiky deep green bud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bud unfurl to reveal a reddish-purple underside before expanding its green topside?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the final leaf a massive, fully formed circular pad with raised edges resting on dark water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are tiny water droplets visible dancing and coalescing on the waxy surface of the leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002815570682287216 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.8778157234191895 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002815570682287216, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002815570682287216, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20164993405342102, + 0.11136727780103683, + 0.12450460344552994, + 0.04110054299235344, + 0.04533139243721962, + 0.06071684509515762, + 0.07022733986377716, + 0.03862452879548073, + 0.2072407305240631, + 0.09923677146434784 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002815570682287216 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a static high-angle bird's-eye view throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the sequence begin with a tightly curled, spiky deep green bud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bud unfurl to reveal a reddish-purple underside before expanding its green topside?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the final leaf a massive, fully formed circular pad with raised edges resting on dark water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are tiny water droplets visible dancing and coalescing on the waxy surface of the leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04305015504360199 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680500507354736 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04305015504360199, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04305015504360199, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18866412341594696, + 0.06970178335905075, + 0.1921754628419876, + 0.04640846326947212, + 0.0729374811053276, + 0.084982730448246, + 0.07706467062234879, + 0.04905489832162857, + 0.08507172018289566, + 0.13393869996070862 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04305015504360199 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, high-angle, bird's-eye view captures hyper-realistic CGI time-lapse footage of a massive Victoria Amazon water lily growing above still, dark water. The sequence begins with a tightly curled, spiky bud, its deep green form shimmering in soft, diffuse sunlight. The bud deliberately unfurls in a graceful, accelerated motion, revealing its intricately ribbed reddish-purple underside before its waxy, vibrant green topside begins its relentless expansion. As the leaf rapidly unfurls into a perfect circle, its surface reveals lifelike detail, every vein and subtle ripple rendered in 4K resolution, while its waxy texture causes tiny water droplets to dance and coalesce across its expanding surface. Finally, the massive, fully formed pad rests majestically on the water's surface, its raised edges forming sharp, clean edges against the dark liquid. Complex patterns of light filter through the surrounding clear water, creating a serene and awe-inspiring atmosphere of natural wonder.", + "seed": 31070, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_4/index_3013_seed_31070_dp_9_rank_18_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.03952601775527, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03952601775527, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.9, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03952601775527, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a static high-angle bird's-eye view throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the sequence begin with a tightly curled, spiky deep green bud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bud unfurl to reveal a reddish-purple underside before expanding its green topside?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the final leaf a massive, fully formed circular pad with raised edges resting on dark water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are tiny water droplets visible dancing and coalescing on the waxy surface of the leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12904542684555054 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1290454864501953 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12904542684555054, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12904542684555054, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16869549453258514, + 0.06587912142276764, + 0.08182906359434128, + 0.24383680522441864, + 0.18314401805400848, + 0.03263600170612335, + 0.13431254029273987, + 0.02091059647500515, + 0.028371943160891533, + 0.04038446396589279 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12904542684555054 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a static high-angle bird's-eye view throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the sequence begin with a tightly curled, spiky deep green bud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bud unfurl to reveal a reddish-purple underside before expanding its green topside?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the final leaf a massive, fully formed circular pad with raised edges resting on dark water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are tiny water droplets visible dancing and coalescing on the waxy surface of the leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009793920442461967 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634793758392334 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009793920442461967, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009793920442461967, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24988000094890594, + 0.11597201973199844, + 0.07103824615478516, + 0.10300783812999725, + 0.08022858202457428, + 0.04343157261610031, + 0.22557522356510162, + 0.025471648201346397, + 0.027872228994965553, + 0.05752263590693474 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009793920442461967 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a static high-angle bird's-eye view throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the sequence begin with a tightly curled, spiky deep green bud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bud unfurl to reveal a reddish-purple underside before expanding its green topside?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the final leaf a massive, fully formed circular pad with raised edges resting on dark water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are tiny water droplets visible dancing and coalescing on the waxy surface of the leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009786483831703663 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634786605834961 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009786483831703663, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009786483831703663, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1742650270462036, + 0.137684628367424, + 0.08533719927072525, + 0.11373672634363174, + 0.10402560979127884, + 0.08123895525932312, + 0.22190673649311066, + 0.034317854791879654, + 0.019522102549672127, + 0.027965154498815536 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009786483831703663 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a static high-angle bird's-eye view throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the sequence begin with a tightly curled, spiky deep green bud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bud unfurl to reveal a reddish-purple underside before expanding its green topside?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the final leaf a massive, fully formed circular pad with raised edges resting on dark water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are tiny water droplets visible dancing and coalescing on the waxy surface of the leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005946681834757328 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130946636199951 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005946681834757328, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005946681834757328, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10389886796474457, + 0.07543216645717621, + 0.07838301360607147, + 0.2363770306110382, + 0.10320167243480682, + 0.04501917585730553, + 0.2213820070028305, + 0.06338376551866531, + 0.025744415819644928, + 0.04717792943120003 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005946681834757328 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a static high-angle bird's-eye view throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the sequence begin with a tightly curled, spiky deep green bud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bud unfurl to reveal a reddish-purple underside before expanding its green topside?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the final leaf a massive, fully formed circular pad with raised edges resting on dark water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are tiny water droplets visible dancing and coalescing on the waxy surface of the leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.043057575821876526 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168057680130005 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.043057575821876526, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.043057575821876526, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17483384907245636, + 0.05288100615143776, + 0.06940937787294388, + 0.14834268391132355, + 0.1103924810886383, + 0.13777534663677216, + 0.14509281516075134, + 0.03630591556429863, + 0.030962280929088593, + 0.09400419145822525 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.043057575821876526 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_5/index_tensor([5985, 5985])_group_5_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_5/index_tensor([5985, 5985])_group_5_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..58d5b09c24c2d16b5795d69e4f1701c989724340 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_5/index_tensor([5985, 5985])_group_5_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "dynamic, low-angle tracking shot follows a motorcyclist clad in a black, high-tech armored suit, its carbon fiber joints gleaming with faint circuitry. A horizontal streak of neon blue light emanates from the dark visor of his full-face helmet. He's at the helm of an angular, futuristic black motorcycle, accelerating fiercely through a world saturated with digital noise. His wheels kick up not dust but pixelated particles gleaming with data errors. His surroundings are a vast ruined landscape, the sky a dark static field of pulsing green and purple data streams, the ground a blend of cracked asphalt and a digital ground that periodically dissolves into voxel blocks. As the camera follows closely and tilts upward, the rider decisively charges toward a crumbling ancient wall composed of massive, weathered stone blocks, their ancient surfaces digitally eroded, their textures shifting between stone and garbled text. Using a sloping cliff as a jumping platform, the motorcycle leaps into the air, carving a sharp arc against the chaotic digital sky, its body surfacing in an elegant and powerful silhouette at its peak. At this moment, the entire picture is occasionally torn apart by strong glitch art effects, with horizontal scan lines, color channel separation and brief mosaics appearing, as if the signal interference of this broken world, further intensifying the tense, psychedelic and surreal visual impact brought about by this high-speed leap between ancient ruins and future collapse.", + "seed": 13880, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_5/index_5985_seed_13880_dp_10_rank_20_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.04040700122714043, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04040700122714043, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.175, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04040700122714043, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a motorcyclist wearing a black high-tech armored suit with carbon fiber joints and circuitry?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the motorcycle angular, futuristic, and black, ridden by the motorcyclist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the environment feature a vast ruined landscape with a dark static sky of pulsing green and purple data streams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera follow the rider closely and tilt upward as the motorcycle leaps into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are strong glitch art effects visible, including horizontal scan lines, color channel separation, and mosaics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04395649582147598 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1689565181732178 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04395649582147598, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04395649582147598, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14664195477962494, + 0.13149763643741608, + 0.06231583654880524, + 0.1110582947731018, + 0.1075773760676384, + 0.09449118375778198, + 0.09872757643461227, + 0.05436479672789574, + 0.04917391762137413, + 0.14415138959884644 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04395649582147598 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a motorcyclist wearing a black high-tech armored suit with carbon fiber joints and circuitry?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the motorcycle angular, futuristic, and black, ridden by the motorcyclist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the environment feature a vast ruined landscape with a dark static sky of pulsing green and purple data streams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera follow the rider closely and tilt upward as the motorcycle leaps into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are strong glitch art effects visible, including horizontal scan lines, color channel separation, and mosaics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004096688237041235 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504096508026123 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004096688237041235, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004096688237041235, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17036743462085724, + 0.15055564045906067, + 0.1031283363699913, + 0.10216763615608215, + 0.08553812652826309, + 0.09730415046215057, + 0.04755064845085144, + 0.06037980318069458, + 0.061373449862003326, + 0.12163478136062622 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004096688237041235 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a motorcyclist wearing a black high-tech armored suit with carbon fiber joints and circuitry?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the motorcycle angular, futuristic, and black, ridden by the motorcyclist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the environment feature a vast ruined landscape with a dark static sky of pulsing green and purple data streams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera follow the rider closely and tilt upward as the motorcycle leaps into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are strong glitch art effects visible, including horizontal scan lines, color channel separation, and mosaics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1427917778491974 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.017791748046875 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1427917778491974, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1427917778491974, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16405364871025085, + 0.14352332055568695, + 0.08312097191810608, + 0.08515869081020355, + 0.0530095249414444, + 0.05139276757836342, + 0.051835689693689346, + 0.09172006696462631, + 0.11020544916391373, + 0.16597987711429596 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1427917778491974 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a motorcyclist wearing a black high-tech armored suit with carbon fiber joints and circuitry?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the motorcycle angular, futuristic, and black, ridden by the motorcyclist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the environment feature a vast ruined landscape with a dark static sky of pulsing green and purple data streams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera follow the rider closely and tilt upward as the motorcycle leaps into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are strong glitch art effects visible, including horizontal scan lines, color channel separation, and mosaics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005942178890109062 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130942344665527 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005942178890109062, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005942178890109062, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08496928215026855, + 0.07757575809955597, + 0.06850750744342804, + 0.08687272667884827, + 0.1572251170873642, + 0.1469428390264511, + 0.08834055811166763, + 0.1274740993976593, + 0.10741540789604187, + 0.054676782339811325 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005942178890109062 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a motorcyclist wearing a black high-tech armored suit with carbon fiber joints and circuitry?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the motorcycle angular, futuristic, and black, ridden by the motorcyclist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the environment feature a vast ruined landscape with a dark static sky of pulsing green and purple data streams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera follow the rider closely and tilt upward as the motorcycle leaps into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are strong glitch art effects visible, including horizontal scan lines, color channel separation, and mosaics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005247865337878466 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255248069763184 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005247865337878466, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005247865337878466, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07402463257312775, + 0.06399966776371002, + 0.08446972817182541, + 0.04858625680208206, + 0.040077079087495804, + 0.0928260087966919, + 0.16333913803100586, + 0.06670154631137848, + 0.10650651901960373, + 0.2594694495201111 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005247865337878466 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dynamic, low-angle tracking shot follows a motorcyclist clad in a black, high-tech armored suit, its carbon fiber joints gleaming with faint circuitry. A horizontal streak of neon blue light emanates from the dark visor of his full-face helmet. He's at the helm of an angular, futuristic black motorcycle, accelerating fiercely through a world saturated with digital noise. His wheels kick up not dust but pixelated particles gleaming with data errors. His surroundings are a vast ruined landscape, the sky a dark static field of pulsing green and purple data streams, the ground a blend of cracked asphalt and a digital ground that periodically dissolves into voxel blocks. As the camera follows closely and tilts upward, the rider decisively charges toward a crumbling ancient wall composed of massive, weathered stone blocks, their ancient surfaces digitally eroded, their textures shifting between stone and garbled text. Using a sloping cliff as a jumping platform, the motorcycle leaps into the air, carving a sharp arc against the chaotic digital sky, its body surfacing in an elegant and powerful silhouette at its peak. At this moment, the entire picture is occasionally torn apart by strong glitch art effects, with horizontal scan lines, color channel separation and brief mosaics appearing, as if the signal interference of this broken world, further intensifying the tense, psychedelic and surreal visual impact brought about by this high-speed leap between ancient ruins and future collapse.", + "seed": 13881, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_5/index_5985_seed_13881_dp_10_rank_20_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.027619730914011598, + "vlm_logprob": -0.027619730914011598, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.15, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.027619730914011598, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a motorcyclist wearing a black high-tech armored suit with carbon fiber joints and circuitry?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the motorcycle angular, futuristic, and black, ridden by the motorcyclist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the environment feature a vast ruined landscape with a dark static sky of pulsing green and purple data streams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera follow the rider closely and tilt upward as the motorcycle leaps into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are strong glitch art effects visible, including horizontal scan lines, color channel separation, and mosaics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0556500218808651 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.930649995803833 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0556500218808651, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0556500218808651, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06557464599609375, + 0.3630457818508148, + 0.06543269008398056, + 0.03816112503409386, + 0.20915599167346954, + 0.07615666091442108, + 0.0967385470867157, + 0.04424508288502693, + 0.014902079477906227, + 0.02658737450838089 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0556500218808651 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a motorcyclist wearing a black high-tech armored suit with carbon fiber joints and circuitry?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the motorcycle angular, futuristic, and black, ridden by the motorcyclist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the environment feature a vast ruined landscape with a dark static sky of pulsing green and purple data streams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera follow the rider closely and tilt upward as the motorcycle leaps into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are strong glitch art effects visible, including horizontal scan lines, color channel separation, and mosaics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026346659287810326 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513466835021973 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026346659287810326, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026346659287810326, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09553952515125275, + 0.41562098264694214, + 0.18506619334220886, + 0.04013410210609436, + 0.09385887533426285, + 0.044805970042943954, + 0.04944545403122902, + 0.02779550477862358, + 0.008491032756865025, + 0.039242327213287354 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026346659287810326 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a motorcyclist wearing a black high-tech armored suit with carbon fiber joints and circuitry?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the motorcycle angular, futuristic, and black, ridden by the motorcyclist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the environment feature a vast ruined landscape with a dark static sky of pulsing green and purple data streams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera follow the rider closely and tilt upward as the motorcycle leaps into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are strong glitch art effects visible, including horizontal scan lines, color channel separation, and mosaics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04865477979183197 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048654794692993 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04865477979183197, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04865477979183197, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0824299156665802, + 0.5510858297348022, + 0.019100598990917206, + 0.041898321360349655, + 0.02983914688229561, + 0.04624292999505997, + 0.05352383106946945, + 0.040931425988674164, + 0.020681820809841156, + 0.11426618695259094 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04865477979183197 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a motorcyclist wearing a black high-tech armored suit with carbon fiber joints and circuitry?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the motorcycle angular, futuristic, and black, ridden by the motorcyclist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the environment feature a vast ruined landscape with a dark static sky of pulsing green and purple data streams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera follow the rider closely and tilt upward as the motorcycle leaps into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are strong glitch art effects visible, including horizontal scan lines, color channel separation, and mosaics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004632574040442705 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379632472991943 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004632574040442705, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004632574040442705, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.02746797725558281, + 0.48448503017425537, + 0.014918429777026176, + 0.015502288937568665, + 0.028158225119113922, + 0.13399361073970795, + 0.0802663266658783, + 0.0748339593410492, + 0.023733768612146378, + 0.11664028465747833 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004632574040442705 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a motorcyclist wearing a black high-tech armored suit with carbon fiber joints and circuitry?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the motorcycle angular, futuristic, and black, ridden by the motorcyclist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the environment feature a vast ruined landscape with a dark static sky of pulsing green and purple data streams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera follow the rider closely and tilt upward as the motorcycle leaps into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are strong glitch art effects visible, including horizontal scan lines, color channel separation, and mosaics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00281461956910789 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877814769744873 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00281461956910789, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00281461956910789, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05597500875592232, + 0.5533097982406616, + 0.03880388289690018, + 0.03723091632127762, + 0.081098273396492, + 0.044243309646844864, + 0.06432181596755981, + 0.037281107157468796, + 0.03817981481552124, + 0.04955607280135155 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00281461956910789 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dynamic, low-angle tracking shot follows a motorcyclist clad in a black, high-tech armored suit, its carbon fiber joints gleaming with faint circuitry. A horizontal streak of neon blue light emanates from the dark visor of his full-face helmet. He's at the helm of an angular, futuristic black motorcycle, accelerating fiercely through a world saturated with digital noise. His wheels kick up not dust but pixelated particles gleaming with data errors. His surroundings are a vast ruined landscape, the sky a dark static field of pulsing green and purple data streams, the ground a blend of cracked asphalt and a digital ground that periodically dissolves into voxel blocks. As the camera follows closely and tilts upward, the rider decisively charges toward a crumbling ancient wall composed of massive, weathered stone blocks, their ancient surfaces digitally eroded, their textures shifting between stone and garbled text. Using a sloping cliff as a jumping platform, the motorcycle leaps into the air, carving a sharp arc against the chaotic digital sky, its body surfacing in an elegant and powerful silhouette at its peak. At this moment, the entire picture is occasionally torn apart by strong glitch art effects, with horizontal scan lines, color channel separation and brief mosaics appearing, as if the signal interference of this broken world, further intensifying the tense, psychedelic and surreal visual impact brought about by this high-speed leap between ancient ruins and future collapse.", + "seed": 13882, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_5/index_5985_seed_13882_dp_11_rank_22_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.014616699796169997, + "vlm_logprob": -0.014616699796169997, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.9, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.014616699796169997, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a motorcyclist wearing a black high-tech armored suit with carbon fiber joints and circuitry?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the motorcycle angular, futuristic, and black, ridden by the motorcyclist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the environment feature a vast ruined landscape with a dark static sky of pulsing green and purple data streams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera follow the rider closely and tilt upward as the motorcycle leaps into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are strong glitch art effects visible, including horizontal scan lines, color channel separation, and mosaics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01910405606031418 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.01910400390625 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01910405606031418, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01910405606031418, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24869433045387268, + 0.035556402057409286, + 0.0920092910528183, + 0.13646285235881805, + 0.08783454447984695, + 0.09106158465147018, + 0.09814774245023727, + 0.062491558492183685, + 0.06614647805690765, + 0.08159518986940384 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01910405606031418 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a motorcyclist wearing a black high-tech armored suit with carbon fiber joints and circuitry?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the motorcycle angular, futuristic, and black, ridden by the motorcyclist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the environment feature a vast ruined landscape with a dark static sky of pulsing green and purple data streams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera follow the rider closely and tilt upward as the motorcycle leaps into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are strong glitch art effects visible, including horizontal scan lines, color channel separation, and mosaics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0017150230705738068 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.376715183258057 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0017150230705738068, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0017150230705738068, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.209304541349411, + 0.07768649607896805, + 0.07128354161977768, + 0.11867582052946091, + 0.08503198623657227, + 0.16951040923595428, + 0.059369731694459915, + 0.07385354489088058, + 0.054235562682151794, + 0.08104832470417023 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0017150230705738068 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a motorcyclist wearing a black high-tech armored suit with carbon fiber joints and circuitry?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the motorcycle angular, futuristic, and black, ridden by the motorcyclist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the environment feature a vast ruined landscape with a dark static sky of pulsing green and purple data streams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera follow the rider closely and tilt upward as the motorcycle leaps into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are strong glitch art effects visible, including horizontal scan lines, color channel separation, and mosaics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04304969683289528 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680498123168945 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04304969683289528, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04304969683289528, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23377683758735657, + 0.2727128863334656, + 0.10180601477622986, + 0.1937381625175476, + 0.03541748970746994, + 0.028376799076795578, + 0.04297955706715584, + 0.03995156288146973, + 0.0307978093624115, + 0.020442858338356018 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04304969683289528 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a motorcyclist wearing a black high-tech armored suit with carbon fiber joints and circuitry?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the motorcycle angular, futuristic, and black, ridden by the motorcyclist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the environment feature a vast ruined landscape with a dark static sky of pulsing green and purple data streams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera follow the rider closely and tilt upward as the motorcycle leaps into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are strong glitch art effects visible, including horizontal scan lines, color channel separation, and mosaics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006729558110237122 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006729602813721 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006729558110237122, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006729558110237122, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25192999839782715, + 0.06075576692819595, + 0.06814724206924438, + 0.17036129534244537, + 0.030353985726833344, + 0.16967912018299103, + 0.06631812453269958, + 0.05913117900490761, + 0.061442095786333084, + 0.06188112869858742 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006729558110237122 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a motorcyclist wearing a black high-tech armored suit with carbon fiber joints and circuitry?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the motorcycle angular, futuristic, and black, ridden by the motorcyclist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the environment feature a vast ruined landscape with a dark static sky of pulsing green and purple data streams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera follow the rider closely and tilt upward as the motorcycle leaps into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are strong glitch art effects visible, including horizontal scan lines, color channel separation, and mosaics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0024851649068295956 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002485275268555 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0024851649068295956, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0024851649068295956, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.223471537232399, + 0.22828301787376404, + 0.055686574429273605, + 0.07589014619588852, + 0.06066195294260979, + 0.049827128648757935, + 0.03277844935655594, + 0.026589276269078255, + 0.14726035296916962, + 0.09955153614282608 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0024851649068295956 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dynamic, low-angle tracking shot follows a motorcyclist clad in a black, high-tech armored suit, its carbon fiber joints gleaming with faint circuitry. A horizontal streak of neon blue light emanates from the dark visor of his full-face helmet. He's at the helm of an angular, futuristic black motorcycle, accelerating fiercely through a world saturated with digital noise. His wheels kick up not dust but pixelated particles gleaming with data errors. His surroundings are a vast ruined landscape, the sky a dark static field of pulsing green and purple data streams, the ground a blend of cracked asphalt and a digital ground that periodically dissolves into voxel blocks. As the camera follows closely and tilts upward, the rider decisively charges toward a crumbling ancient wall composed of massive, weathered stone blocks, their ancient surfaces digitally eroded, their textures shifting between stone and garbled text. Using a sloping cliff as a jumping platform, the motorcycle leaps into the air, carving a sharp arc against the chaotic digital sky, its body surfacing in an elegant and powerful silhouette at its peak. At this moment, the entire picture is occasionally torn apart by strong glitch art effects, with horizontal scan lines, color channel separation and brief mosaics appearing, as if the signal interference of this broken world, further intensifying the tense, psychedelic and surreal visual impact brought about by this high-speed leap between ancient ruins and future collapse.", + "seed": 13883, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_5/index_5985_seed_13883_dp_11_rank_22_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.039997681695967915, + "vlm_logprob": -0.039997681695967915, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.175000023841858, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.039997681695967915, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a motorcyclist wearing a black high-tech armored suit with carbon fiber joints and circuitry?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the motorcycle angular, futuristic, and black, ridden by the motorcyclist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the environment feature a vast ruined landscape with a dark static sky of pulsing green and purple data streams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera follow the rider closely and tilt upward as the motorcycle leaps into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are strong glitch art effects visible, including horizontal scan lines, color channel separation, and mosaics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14481201767921448 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0198121070861816 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14481201767921448, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.8750001192092896, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14481201767921448, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13254939019680023, + 0.11604810506105423, + 0.1089044064283371, + 0.1860661655664444, + 0.04241802543401718, + 0.06345971673727036, + 0.03243594616651535, + 0.05338442325592041, + 0.14322999119758606, + 0.1215038001537323 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14481201767921448 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a motorcyclist wearing a black high-tech armored suit with carbon fiber joints and circuitry?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the motorcycle angular, futuristic, and black, ridden by the motorcyclist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the environment feature a vast ruined landscape with a dark static sky of pulsing green and purple data streams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera follow the rider closely and tilt upward as the motorcycle leaps into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are strong glitch art effects visible, including horizontal scan lines, color channel separation, and mosaics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0052567594684660435 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255256652832031 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0052567594684660435, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0052567594684660435, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2034754604101181, + 0.1799541711807251, + 0.07588377594947815, + 0.12944073975086212, + 0.03154303506016731, + 0.048376090824604034, + 0.021145565435290337, + 0.039907779544591904, + 0.1697365641593933, + 0.1005367785692215 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0052567594684660435 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a motorcyclist wearing a black high-tech armored suit with carbon fiber joints and circuitry?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the motorcycle angular, futuristic, and black, ridden by the motorcyclist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the environment feature a vast ruined landscape with a dark static sky of pulsing green and purple data streams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera follow the rider closely and tilt upward as the motorcycle leaps into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are strong glitch art effects visible, including horizontal scan lines, color channel separation, and mosaics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0380968414247036 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2880969047546387 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0380968414247036, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0380968414247036, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11055339127779007, + 0.04955204576253891, + 0.07476416230201721, + 0.07358270138502121, + 0.06149270758032799, + 0.05273198336362839, + 0.03193482756614685, + 0.050879210233688354, + 0.39894285798072815, + 0.09556619077920914 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0380968414247036 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a motorcyclist wearing a black high-tech armored suit with carbon fiber joints and circuitry?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the motorcycle angular, futuristic, and black, ridden by the motorcyclist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the environment feature a vast ruined landscape with a dark static sky of pulsing green and purple data streams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera follow the rider closely and tilt upward as the motorcycle leaps into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are strong glitch art effects visible, including horizontal scan lines, color channel separation, and mosaics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0031891223043203354 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.7531890869140625 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0031891223043203354, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0031891223043203354, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08885754644870758, + 0.05856681615114212, + 0.06756093353033066, + 0.042406193912029266, + 0.055403679609298706, + 0.03294795751571655, + 0.02606288343667984, + 0.04440367594361305, + 0.45521843433380127, + 0.12857183814048767 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0031891223043203354 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a motorcyclist wearing a black high-tech armored suit with carbon fiber joints and circuitry?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the motorcycle angular, futuristic, and black, ridden by the motorcyclist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the environment feature a vast ruined landscape with a dark static sky of pulsing green and purple data streams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera follow the rider closely and tilt upward as the motorcycle leaps into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are strong glitch art effects visible, including horizontal scan lines, color channel separation, and mosaics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008633667603135109 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758633613586426 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008633667603135109, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008633667603135109, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1002718135714531, + 0.045746345072984695, + 0.12072300910949707, + 0.07992975413799286, + 0.25619837641716003, + 0.06282387673854828, + 0.06702334433794022, + 0.05813193693757057, + 0.07248777896165848, + 0.13666382431983948 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008633667603135109 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_6/index_tensor([988, 988])_group_6_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_6/index_tensor([988, 988])_group_6_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..f1b7498ff88f1f8ca9add714019259b1d4dfe651 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_6/index_tensor([988, 988])_group_6_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "high-speed tracking shot, low to the ground, hurtles forward at dizzying speed along two parallel steel rails. In the golden late afternoon sun, the cold rails reflect a warm, dazzling glow, stretching endlessly into the distance before converging at a vanishing point on the horizon. Below the camera, the dark wooden sleepers and the gravel ballast between them transform into blurred, dynamic streaks, swiftly sweeping backwards, their individual forms barely discernible, leaving only a strong trail of movement. On either side of the tracks, withered grass sway gently in the breeze, bringing a touch of vitality to the vast, somewhat desolate landscape. The entire scene is imbued with a powerful sense of movement and visual impact. Through the extreme depiction of speed and the delicate capture of light and shadow, it creates a powerful sense of destiny and a dynamic aesthetic about journey, time, and endless progress.", + "seed": 15342, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_6/index_988_seed_15342_dp_12_rank_24_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.15361086428165435, + "vlm_logprob": -0.15361086428165435, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.75, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.15361086428165435, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned low to the ground and moving forward at high speed along parallel steel rails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the steel rails reflect a warm, dazzling glow from a golden late afternoon sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the dark wooden sleepers and gravel ballast visible as blurred, dynamic streaks moving backwards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is withered grass visible swaying gently on either side of the tracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the rails stretch into the distance and converge at a vanishing point on the horizon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11783982813358307 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.242839813232422 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11783982813358307, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11783982813358307, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1456274837255478, + 0.05665207654237747, + 0.07392385601997375, + 0.044827837496995926, + 0.14240288734436035, + 0.08594408631324768, + 0.05821146070957184, + 0.13456539809703827, + 0.17923502624034882, + 0.07860986143350601 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11783982813358307 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned low to the ground and moving forward at high speed along parallel steel rails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the steel rails reflect a warm, dazzling glow from a golden late afternoon sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the dark wooden sleepers and gravel ballast visible as blurred, dynamic streaks moving backwards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is withered grass visible swaying gently on either side of the tracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the rails stretch into the distance and converge at a vanishing point on the horizon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10033156722784042 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3503315448760986 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10033156722784042, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10033156722784042, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24622078239917755, + 0.05118207633495331, + 0.06157461553812027, + 0.01932055689394474, + 0.04552772641181946, + 0.0143370246514678, + 0.06739647686481476, + 0.04698387160897255, + 0.3888285458087921, + 0.058628298342227936 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10033156722784042 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned low to the ground and moving forward at high speed along parallel steel rails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the steel rails reflect a warm, dazzling glow from a golden late afternoon sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the dark wooden sleepers and gravel ballast visible as blurred, dynamic streaks moving backwards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is withered grass visible swaying gently on either side of the tracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the rails stretch into the distance and converge at a vanishing point on the horizon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005948696285486221 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130948543548584 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005948696285486221, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005948696285486221, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.48524975776672363, + 0.042423322796821594, + 0.04602457210421562, + 0.08476365357637405, + 0.08710762113332748, + 0.03773510456085205, + 0.06181357428431511, + 0.06773784011602402, + 0.051479510962963104, + 0.03566502407193184 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005948696285486221 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned low to the ground and moving forward at high speed along parallel steel rails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the steel rails reflect a warm, dazzling glow from a golden late afternoon sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the dark wooden sleepers and gravel ballast visible as blurred, dynamic streaks moving backwards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is withered grass visible swaying gently on either side of the tracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the rails stretch into the distance and converge at a vanishing point on the horizon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5233583450317383 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8983583450317383 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5233583450317383, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5233583450317383, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.37688392400741577, + 0.029404647648334503, + 0.04628933221101761, + 0.0425962433218956, + 0.38127410411834717, + 0.02029728703200817, + 0.028740782290697098, + 0.014349600300192833, + 0.03573360666632652, + 0.024430451914668083 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5233583450317383 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned low to the ground and moving forward at high speed along parallel steel rails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the steel rails reflect a warm, dazzling glow from a golden late afternoon sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the dark wooden sleepers and gravel ballast visible as blurred, dynamic streaks moving backwards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is withered grass visible swaying gently on either side of the tracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the rails stretch into the distance and converge at a vanishing point on the horizon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020575884729623795 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895576000213623 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020575884729623795, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020575884729623795, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15262408554553986, + 0.07481202483177185, + 0.08953644335269928, + 0.022541021928191185, + 0.05181392282247543, + 0.030037978664040565, + 0.09748375415802002, + 0.0686829462647438, + 0.2650066912174225, + 0.1474611461162567 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020575884729623795 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "high-speed tracking shot, low to the ground, hurtles forward at dizzying speed along two parallel steel rails. In the golden late afternoon sun, the cold rails reflect a warm, dazzling glow, stretching endlessly into the distance before converging at a vanishing point on the horizon. Below the camera, the dark wooden sleepers and the gravel ballast between them transform into blurred, dynamic streaks, swiftly sweeping backwards, their individual forms barely discernible, leaving only a strong trail of movement. On either side of the tracks, withered grass sway gently in the breeze, bringing a touch of vitality to the vast, somewhat desolate landscape. The entire scene is imbued with a powerful sense of movement and visual impact. Through the extreme depiction of speed and the delicate capture of light and shadow, it creates a powerful sense of destiny and a dynamic aesthetic about journey, time, and endless progress.", + "seed": 15343, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_6/index_988_seed_15343_dp_12_rank_24_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.12354909447021782, + "vlm_logprob": -0.12354909447021782, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.05, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.12354909447021782, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned low to the ground and moving forward at high speed along parallel steel rails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the steel rails reflect a warm, dazzling glow from a golden late afternoon sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the dark wooden sleepers and gravel ballast visible as blurred, dynamic streaks moving backwards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is withered grass visible swaying gently on either side of the tracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the rails stretch into the distance and converge at a vanishing point on the horizon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012586326338350773 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.5125861167907715 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012586326338350773, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012586326338350773, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14069412648677826, + 0.02616656944155693, + 0.018106475472450256, + 0.042930785566568375, + 0.03320355340838432, + 0.03654784336686134, + 0.25954705476760864, + 0.3855067789554596, + 0.013266288675367832, + 0.04403049126267433 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012586326338350773 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned low to the ground and moving forward at high speed along parallel steel rails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the steel rails reflect a warm, dazzling glow from a golden late afternoon sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the dark wooden sleepers and gravel ballast visible as blurred, dynamic streaks moving backwards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is withered grass visible swaying gently on either side of the tracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the rails stretch into the distance and converge at a vanishing point on the horizon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009790497832000256 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634790420532227 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009790497832000256, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009790497832000256, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1726667284965515, + 0.029688823968172073, + 0.11179040372371674, + 0.06221206486225128, + 0.0479157492518425, + 0.054917167872190475, + 0.13360002636909485, + 0.34534427523612976, + 0.013334867544472218, + 0.028529860079288483 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009790497832000256 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned low to the ground and moving forward at high speed along parallel steel rails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the steel rails reflect a warm, dazzling glow from a golden late afternoon sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the dark wooden sleepers and gravel ballast visible as blurred, dynamic streaks moving backwards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is withered grass visible swaying gently on either side of the tracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the rails stretch into the distance and converge at a vanishing point on the horizon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01818355917930603 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018183708190918 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01818355917930603, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01818355917930603, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.29397061467170715, + 0.03106052614748478, + 0.023635199293494225, + 0.018244892358779907, + 0.033654212951660156, + 0.05029790475964546, + 0.24770048260688782, + 0.26721885800361633, + 0.010032505728304386, + 0.024184787645936012 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01818355917930603 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned low to the ground and moving forward at high speed along parallel steel rails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the steel rails reflect a warm, dazzling glow from a golden late afternoon sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the dark wooden sleepers and gravel ballast visible as blurred, dynamic streaks moving backwards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is withered grass visible swaying gently on either side of the tracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the rails stretch into the distance and converge at a vanishing point on the horizon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5761443376541138 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8261443376541138 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5761443376541138, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5761443376541138, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2877935767173767, + 0.06641767919063568, + 0.048615626990795135, + 0.07794065028429031, + 0.08996409177780151, + 0.038932472467422485, + 0.04239840433001518, + 0.22291871905326843, + 0.053172480314970016, + 0.07184631377458572 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5761443376541138 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned low to the ground and moving forward at high speed along parallel steel rails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the steel rails reflect a warm, dazzling glow from a golden late afternoon sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the dark wooden sleepers and gravel ballast visible as blurred, dynamic streaks moving backwards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is withered grass visible swaying gently on either side of the tracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the rails stretch into the distance and converge at a vanishing point on the horizon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0010407513473182917 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.876040935516357 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0010407513473182917, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0010407513473182917, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12947247922420502, + 0.03277856111526489, + 0.028260625898838043, + 0.02485770732164383, + 0.03193630278110504, + 0.04461204633116722, + 0.1748649924993515, + 0.45838138461112976, + 0.019601279869675636, + 0.05523459613323212 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0010407513473182917 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "high-speed tracking shot, low to the ground, hurtles forward at dizzying speed along two parallel steel rails. In the golden late afternoon sun, the cold rails reflect a warm, dazzling glow, stretching endlessly into the distance before converging at a vanishing point on the horizon. Below the camera, the dark wooden sleepers and the gravel ballast between them transform into blurred, dynamic streaks, swiftly sweeping backwards, their individual forms barely discernible, leaving only a strong trail of movement. On either side of the tracks, withered grass sway gently in the breeze, bringing a touch of vitality to the vast, somewhat desolate landscape. The entire scene is imbued with a powerful sense of movement and visual impact. Through the extreme depiction of speed and the delicate capture of light and shadow, it creates a powerful sense of destiny and a dynamic aesthetic about journey, time, and endless progress.", + "seed": 15344, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_6/index_988_seed_15344_dp_13_rank_26_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.1363150558900088, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1363150558900088, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.3, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1363150558900088, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned low to the ground and moving forward at high speed along parallel steel rails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the steel rails reflect a warm, dazzling glow from a golden late afternoon sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the dark wooden sleepers and gravel ballast visible as blurred, dynamic streaks moving backwards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is withered grass visible swaying gently on either side of the tracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the rails stretch into the distance and converge at a vanishing point on the horizon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04617033153772354 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.171170234680176 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04617033153772354, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04617033153772354, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09411720931529999, + 0.04815805330872536, + 0.0378391332924366, + 0.05950140580534935, + 0.05580710247159004, + 0.4317692220211029, + 0.11198283731937408, + 0.07908355444669724, + 0.06932578235864639, + 0.012415751814842224 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04617033153772354 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned low to the ground and moving forward at high speed along parallel steel rails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the steel rails reflect a warm, dazzling glow from a golden late afternoon sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the dark wooden sleepers and gravel ballast visible as blurred, dynamic streaks moving backwards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is withered grass visible swaying gently on either side of the tracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the rails stretch into the distance and converge at a vanishing point on the horizon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04307904466986656 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168079137802124 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04307904466986656, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04307904466986656, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12859320640563965, + 0.026500282809138298, + 0.016125252470374107, + 0.09067203849554062, + 0.2585313320159912, + 0.33406054973602295, + 0.08387560397386551, + 0.017993690446019173, + 0.024088574573397636, + 0.019559398293495178 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04307904466986656 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned low to the ground and moving forward at high speed along parallel steel rails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the steel rails reflect a warm, dazzling glow from a golden late afternoon sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the dark wooden sleepers and gravel ballast visible as blurred, dynamic streaks moving backwards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is withered grass visible swaying gently on either side of the tracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the rails stretch into the distance and converge at a vanishing point on the horizon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012535824440419674 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.38753604888916 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012535824440419674, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012535824440419674, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4086160361766815, + 0.0735400915145874, + 0.03915434703230858, + 0.038512516766786575, + 0.053300872445106506, + 0.07387605309486389, + 0.19240128993988037, + 0.04947085306048393, + 0.04182934761047363, + 0.029298532754182816 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012535824440419674 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned low to the ground and moving forward at high speed along parallel steel rails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the steel rails reflect a warm, dazzling glow from a golden late afternoon sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the dark wooden sleepers and gravel ballast visible as blurred, dynamic streaks moving backwards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is withered grass visible swaying gently on either side of the tracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the rails stretch into the distance and converge at a vanishing point on the horizon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5761774182319641 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8261774182319641 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5761774182319641, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5761774182319641, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5695712566375732, + 0.0281927902251482, + 0.010677071288228035, + 0.042273472994565964, + 0.026196205988526344, + 0.1629292070865631, + 0.0778912603855133, + 0.03835178539156914, + 0.033036720007658005, + 0.010880278423428535 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5761774182319641 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned low to the ground and moving forward at high speed along parallel steel rails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the steel rails reflect a warm, dazzling glow from a golden late afternoon sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the dark wooden sleepers and gravel ballast visible as blurred, dynamic streaks moving backwards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is withered grass visible swaying gently on either side of the tracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the rails stretch into the distance and converge at a vanishing point on the horizon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036126605700701475 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628612518310547 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036126605700701475, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036126605700701475, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20971821248531342, + 0.021690981462597847, + 0.009223859757184982, + 0.028184961527585983, + 0.018670925870537758, + 0.6386045813560486, + 0.037610385566949844, + 0.019469456747174263, + 0.007926536723971367, + 0.008900139480829239 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036126605700701475 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "high-speed tracking shot, low to the ground, hurtles forward at dizzying speed along two parallel steel rails. In the golden late afternoon sun, the cold rails reflect a warm, dazzling glow, stretching endlessly into the distance before converging at a vanishing point on the horizon. Below the camera, the dark wooden sleepers and the gravel ballast between them transform into blurred, dynamic streaks, swiftly sweeping backwards, their individual forms barely discernible, leaving only a strong trail of movement. On either side of the tracks, withered grass sway gently in the breeze, bringing a touch of vitality to the vast, somewhat desolate landscape. The entire scene is imbued with a powerful sense of movement and visual impact. Through the extreme depiction of speed and the delicate capture of light and shadow, it creates a powerful sense of destiny and a dynamic aesthetic about journey, time, and endless progress.", + "seed": 15345, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_6/index_988_seed_15345_dp_13_rank_26_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.08176254164427518, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08176254164427518, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.775, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08176254164427518, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned low to the ground and moving forward at high speed along parallel steel rails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the steel rails reflect a warm, dazzling glow from a golden late afternoon sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the dark wooden sleepers and gravel ballast visible as blurred, dynamic streaks moving backwards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is withered grass visible swaying gently on either side of the tracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the rails stretch into the distance and converge at a vanishing point on the horizon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07649131119251251 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.701491355895996 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07649131119251251, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07649131119251251, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11562425643205643, + 0.06851159781217575, + 0.025120899081230164, + 0.05325984209775925, + 0.1320260465145111, + 0.04129409417510033, + 0.2849172055721283, + 0.031125400215387344, + 0.19478030502796173, + 0.053340379148721695 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07649131119251251 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned low to the ground and moving forward at high speed along parallel steel rails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the steel rails reflect a warm, dazzling glow from a golden late afternoon sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the dark wooden sleepers and gravel ballast visible as blurred, dynamic streaks moving backwards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is withered grass visible swaying gently on either side of the tracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the rails stretch into the distance and converge at a vanishing point on the horizon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007648232858628035 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882648468017578 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007648232858628035, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007648232858628035, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0792076364159584, + 0.06749652326107025, + 0.0882159098982811, + 0.05443492531776428, + 0.3295848071575165, + 0.061939869076013565, + 0.05828237533569336, + 0.03240940719842911, + 0.1602523922920227, + 0.06817616522312164 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007648232858628035 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned low to the ground and moving forward at high speed along parallel steel rails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the steel rails reflect a warm, dazzling glow from a golden late afternoon sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the dark wooden sleepers and gravel ballast visible as blurred, dynamic streaks moving backwards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is withered grass visible swaying gently on either side of the tracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the rails stretch into the distance and converge at a vanishing point on the horizon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005255098920315504 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255255222320557 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005255098920315504, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005255098920315504, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15205001831054688, + 0.047260113060474396, + 0.05791248753666878, + 0.08275926113128662, + 0.0622049942612648, + 0.0463261753320694, + 0.11869312077760696, + 0.10200677812099457, + 0.26946139335632324, + 0.06132564693689346 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005255098920315504 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned low to the ground and moving forward at high speed along parallel steel rails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the steel rails reflect a warm, dazzling glow from a golden late afternoon sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the dark wooden sleepers and gravel ballast visible as blurred, dynamic streaks moving backwards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is withered grass visible swaying gently on either side of the tracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the rails stretch into the distance and converge at a vanishing point on the horizon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3134724497795105 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3134725093841553 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3134724497795105, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3134724497795105, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10030145943164825, + 0.04881026968359947, + 0.04930872842669487, + 0.028782827779650688, + 0.05596325919032097, + 0.04286357760429382, + 0.09161123633384705, + 0.1055055782198906, + 0.20460361242294312, + 0.2722494304180145 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3134724497795105 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned low to the ground and moving forward at high speed along parallel steel rails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the steel rails reflect a warm, dazzling glow from a golden late afternoon sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the dark wooden sleepers and gravel ballast visible as blurred, dynamic streaks moving backwards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is withered grass visible swaying gently on either side of the tracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the rails stretch into the distance and converge at a vanishing point on the horizon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005945615470409393 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130945682525635 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005945615470409393, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005945615470409393, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18280768394470215, + 0.06507605314254761, + 0.0464770533144474, + 0.032867301255464554, + 0.14214256405830383, + 0.057532913982868195, + 0.09074366092681885, + 0.05833183974027634, + 0.2327764630317688, + 0.0912444144487381 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005945615470409393 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_7/index_tensor([4321, 4321])_group_7_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_7/index_tensor([4321, 4321])_group_7_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..2c3968bd85f75e95ddf71a4ac287540af98cec1f --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_7/index_tensor([4321, 4321])_group_7_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "In a world steeped in the hallmarks of Disney Pixar animation, a close-up of the polished chrome nozzle of a steam cleaner shifts dizzyingly rapidly between sharp ice crystal details and a blurred background. The steam cleaner itself boasts a sleek, friendly design, housed in a bright lemon-yellow plastic shell and fitted with a chunky, ergonomic black handle. When activated, a torrent of what should be high-temperature, high-pressure steam erupts from the nozzle. However, this swirling cloud of steam doesn't clean anything. Instead, upon contact with the surrounding air, it miraculously condenses into countless shimmering ice crystals. These crystals, intricately structured, take on the forms of geometrically perfect snowflakes and feathery, delicate frost patterns. They hang suspended in mid-air, shimmering with a translucent, prismatic brilliance like diamond dust. The camera rapidly locks onto the surreal details of a single ice crystal, rendering its edges sharp and clear, while the warm, slightly cluttered Pixar-esque garage background behind it (filled with wooden workbenches and colorful toolboxes) completely blurs into a soft mass of color. Then, the focus quickly pulls back to a blur, allowing the entire shimmering ice crystal cloud to take center stage. With each focus shift, a subtle, brief flicker appears across the screen, as if magic has disturbed the stability of reality, creating a strange atmosphere full of wonder, whimsy, and visual shock.", + "seed": 30348, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_7/index_4321_seed_30348_dp_14_rank_28_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.2036266510374844, + "vlm_logprob": -0.2036266510374844, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.55, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.2036266510374844, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a Disney Pixar animation style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the steam cleaner bright lemon-yellow with a chunky black handle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the steam emitted from the nozzle condense into geometrically perfect snowflakes and frost patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a warm, cluttered garage with wooden workbenches and colorful toolboxes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly shift focus between a sharp ice crystal and a blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3141789138317108 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3141789436340332 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3141789138317108, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3141789138317108, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21762487292289734, + 0.033714644610881805, + 0.03935737535357475, + 0.12855452299118042, + 0.04533831775188446, + 0.03292210027575493, + 0.024149004369974136, + 0.04912842810153961, + 0.3112107217311859, + 0.11799999326467514 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3141789138317108 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a Disney Pixar animation style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the steam cleaner bright lemon-yellow with a chunky black handle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the steam emitted from the nozzle condense into geometrically perfect snowflakes and frost patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a warm, cluttered garage with wooden workbenches and colorful toolboxes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly shift focus between a sharp ice crystal and a blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02331520989537239 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773315191268921 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02331520989537239, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02331520989537239, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.35538342595100403, + 0.03196652606129646, + 0.05262032896280289, + 0.1311691552400589, + 0.07119514048099518, + 0.06710205227136612, + 0.050859298557043076, + 0.07023108005523682, + 0.1309121698141098, + 0.038560882210731506 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02331520989537239 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a Disney Pixar animation style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the steam cleaner bright lemon-yellow with a chunky black handle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the steam emitted from the nozzle condense into geometrically perfect snowflakes and frost patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a warm, cluttered garage with wooden workbenches and colorful toolboxes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly shift focus between a sharp ice crystal and a blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004099181387573481 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504099369049072 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004099181387573481, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004099181387573481, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10835091024637222, + 0.018922459334135056, + 0.05023103207349777, + 0.21336233615875244, + 0.031861674040555954, + 0.036825377494096756, + 0.03863460198044777, + 0.046138543635606766, + 0.37138402462005615, + 0.08428900688886642 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004099181387573481 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a Disney Pixar animation style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the steam cleaner bright lemon-yellow with a chunky black handle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the steam emitted from the nozzle condense into geometrically perfect snowflakes and frost patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a warm, cluttered garage with wooden workbenches and colorful toolboxes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly shift focus between a sharp ice crystal and a blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5762205719947815 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8262205719947815 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5762205719947815, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5762205719947815, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15408955514431, + 0.039040207862854004, + 0.178395077586174, + 0.06046918034553528, + 0.03702320158481598, + 0.1889294981956482, + 0.021272657439112663, + 0.05613338202238083, + 0.22942809760570526, + 0.03521912917494774 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 5, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5762205719947815 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a Disney Pixar animation style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the steam cleaner bright lemon-yellow with a chunky black handle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the steam emitted from the nozzle condense into geometrically perfect snowflakes and frost patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a warm, cluttered garage with wooden workbenches and colorful toolboxes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly shift focus between a sharp ice crystal and a blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10031937807798386 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3503193855285645 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10031937807798386, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10031937807798386, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13564783334732056, + 0.013981458730995655, + 0.015573759563267231, + 0.041997238993644714, + 0.031055592000484467, + 0.01939840242266655, + 0.028291935101151466, + 0.12099118530750275, + 0.48613241314888, + 0.10693016648292542 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10031937807798386 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a world steeped in the hallmarks of Disney Pixar animation, a close-up of the polished chrome nozzle of a steam cleaner shifts dizzyingly rapidly between sharp ice crystal details and a blurred background. The steam cleaner itself boasts a sleek, friendly design, housed in a bright lemon-yellow plastic shell and fitted with a chunky, ergonomic black handle. When activated, a torrent of what should be high-temperature, high-pressure steam erupts from the nozzle. However, this swirling cloud of steam doesn't clean anything. Instead, upon contact with the surrounding air, it miraculously condenses into countless shimmering ice crystals. These crystals, intricately structured, take on the forms of geometrically perfect snowflakes and feathery, delicate frost patterns. They hang suspended in mid-air, shimmering with a translucent, prismatic brilliance like diamond dust. The camera rapidly locks onto the surreal details of a single ice crystal, rendering its edges sharp and clear, while the warm, slightly cluttered Pixar-esque garage background behind it (filled with wooden workbenches and colorful toolboxes) completely blurs into a soft mass of color. Then, the focus quickly pulls back to a blur, allowing the entire shimmering ice crystal cloud to take center stage. With each focus shift, a subtle, brief flicker appears across the screen, as if magic has disturbed the stability of reality, creating a strange atmosphere full of wonder, whimsy, and visual shock.", + "seed": 30349, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_7/index_4321_seed_30349_dp_14_rank_28_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.12101257024332882, + "vlm_logprob": -0.12101257024332882, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.975, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.12101257024332882, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a Disney Pixar animation style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the steam cleaner bright lemon-yellow with a chunky black handle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the steam emitted from the nozzle condense into geometrically perfect snowflakes and frost patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a warm, cluttered garage with wooden workbenches and colorful toolboxes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly shift focus between a sharp ice crystal and a blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3508286774158478 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2258286476135254 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3508286774158478, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3508286774158478, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16100937128067017, + 0.13337352871894836, + 0.0899687334895134, + 0.11208420246839523, + 0.099615678191185, + 0.20022819936275482, + 0.039519425481557846, + 0.12481555342674255, + 0.02531455084681511, + 0.014070720411837101 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3508286774158478 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a Disney Pixar animation style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the steam cleaner bright lemon-yellow with a chunky black handle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the steam emitted from the nozzle condense into geometrically perfect snowflakes and frost patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a warm, cluttered garage with wooden workbenches and colorful toolboxes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly shift focus between a sharp ice crystal and a blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07007849961519241 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950786113739014 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07007849961519241, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07007849961519241, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3743819296360016, + 0.2510274648666382, + 0.0820169746875763, + 0.1268865317106247, + 0.08295636624097824, + 0.029694121330976486, + 0.015470988117158413, + 0.019113654270768166, + 0.00672973832115531, + 0.011722209863364697 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07007849961519241 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a Disney Pixar animation style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the steam cleaner bright lemon-yellow with a chunky black handle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the steam emitted from the nozzle condense into geometrically perfect snowflakes and frost patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a warm, cluttered garage with wooden workbenches and colorful toolboxes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly shift focus between a sharp ice crystal and a blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0031996979378163815 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753199577331543 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0031996979378163815, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0031996979378163815, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.055545639246702194, + 0.0940878763794899, + 0.1002134159207344, + 0.15043650567531586, + 0.24214163422584534, + 0.21884167194366455, + 0.05636629834771156, + 0.04642185568809509, + 0.016742296516895294, + 0.01920284517109394 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0031996979378163815 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a Disney Pixar animation style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the steam cleaner bright lemon-yellow with a chunky black handle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the steam emitted from the nozzle condense into geometrically perfect snowflakes and frost patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a warm, cluttered garage with wooden workbenches and colorful toolboxes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly shift focus between a sharp ice crystal and a blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020595386624336243 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955953121185303 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020595386624336243, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020595386624336243, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10074524581432343, + 0.21989832818508148, + 0.06460563093423843, + 0.10727429389953613, + 0.1472870409488678, + 0.14142265915870667, + 0.038856662809848785, + 0.07902070134878159, + 0.017784522846341133, + 0.0831049233675003 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020595386624336243 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a Disney Pixar animation style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the steam cleaner bright lemon-yellow with a chunky black handle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the steam emitted from the nozzle condense into geometrically perfect snowflakes and frost patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a warm, cluttered garage with wooden workbenches and colorful toolboxes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly shift focus between a sharp ice crystal and a blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16036058962345123 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.91036057472229 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16036058962345123, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16036058962345123, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03110639564692974, + 0.024094607681035995, + 0.090810127556324, + 0.2555502951145172, + 0.5023512244224548, + 0.028197990730404854, + 0.021558554843068123, + 0.02891576662659645, + 0.01117649208754301, + 0.0062385969795286655 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16036058962345123 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a world steeped in the hallmarks of Disney Pixar animation, a close-up of the polished chrome nozzle of a steam cleaner shifts dizzyingly rapidly between sharp ice crystal details and a blurred background. The steam cleaner itself boasts a sleek, friendly design, housed in a bright lemon-yellow plastic shell and fitted with a chunky, ergonomic black handle. When activated, a torrent of what should be high-temperature, high-pressure steam erupts from the nozzle. However, this swirling cloud of steam doesn't clean anything. Instead, upon contact with the surrounding air, it miraculously condenses into countless shimmering ice crystals. These crystals, intricately structured, take on the forms of geometrically perfect snowflakes and feathery, delicate frost patterns. They hang suspended in mid-air, shimmering with a translucent, prismatic brilliance like diamond dust. The camera rapidly locks onto the surreal details of a single ice crystal, rendering its edges sharp and clear, while the warm, slightly cluttered Pixar-esque garage background behind it (filled with wooden workbenches and colorful toolboxes) completely blurs into a soft mass of color. Then, the focus quickly pulls back to a blur, allowing the entire shimmering ice crystal cloud to take center stage. With each focus shift, a subtle, brief flicker appears across the screen, as if magic has disturbed the stability of reality, creating a strange atmosphere full of wonder, whimsy, and visual shock.", + "seed": 30350, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_7/index_4321_seed_30350_dp_15_rank_30_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.04812335148453713, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04812335148453713, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.225, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04812335148453713, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a Disney Pixar animation style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the steam cleaner bright lemon-yellow with a chunky black handle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the steam emitted from the nozzle condense into geometrically perfect snowflakes and frost patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a warm, cluttered garage with wooden workbenches and colorful toolboxes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly shift focus between a sharp ice crystal and a blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.09065422415733337 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.465654134750366 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.09065422415733337, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.09065422415733337, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12452660501003265, + 0.06141991168260574, + 0.04011467099189758, + 0.10314346104860306, + 0.1303146630525589, + 0.03975144028663635, + 0.03251677379012108, + 0.07083921879529953, + 0.050832342356443405, + 0.34654101729393005 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.09065422415733337 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a Disney Pixar animation style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the steam cleaner bright lemon-yellow with a chunky black handle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the steam emitted from the nozzle condense into geometrically perfect snowflakes and frost patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a warm, cluttered garage with wooden workbenches and colorful toolboxes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly shift focus between a sharp ice crystal and a blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020599940791726112 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895599842071533 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020599940791726112, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020599940791726112, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2505136728286743, + 0.06750347465276718, + 0.05654352530837059, + 0.06084801256656647, + 0.06616733968257904, + 0.04264884442090988, + 0.06118881329894066, + 0.2176784723997116, + 0.05712736397981644, + 0.11978038400411606 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020599940791726112 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a Disney Pixar animation style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the steam cleaner bright lemon-yellow with a chunky black handle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the steam emitted from the nozzle condense into geometrically perfect snowflakes and frost patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a warm, cluttered garage with wooden workbenches and colorful toolboxes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly shift focus between a sharp ice crystal and a blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020589547231793404 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895589590072632 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020589547231793404, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020589547231793404, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07039918750524521, + 0.031189071014523506, + 0.014205403625965118, + 0.05461685732007027, + 0.0300842747092247, + 0.016818879172205925, + 0.029029330238699913, + 0.14734597504138947, + 0.12113457918167114, + 0.4851764738559723 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020589547231793404 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a Disney Pixar animation style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the steam cleaner bright lemon-yellow with a chunky black handle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the steam emitted from the nozzle condense into geometrically perfect snowflakes and frost patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a warm, cluttered garage with wooden workbenches and colorful toolboxes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly shift focus between a sharp ice crystal and a blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02980376034975052 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.52980375289917 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02980376034975052, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02980376034975052, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.152910977602005, + 0.1536654680967331, + 0.07675565034151077, + 0.13343502581119537, + 0.033232517540454865, + 0.10719519853591919, + 0.07502274215221405, + 0.08619169145822525, + 0.06458992511034012, + 0.11700081080198288 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02980376034975052 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a Disney Pixar animation style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the steam cleaner bright lemon-yellow with a chunky black handle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the steam emitted from the nozzle condense into geometrically perfect snowflakes and frost patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a warm, cluttered garage with wooden workbenches and colorful toolboxes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly shift focus between a sharp ice crystal and a blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07896928489208221 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5789692401885986 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07896928489208221, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07896928489208221, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08169948309659958, + 0.03205985203385353, + 0.02491510659456253, + 0.049393340945243835, + 0.03880102559924126, + 0.024487631395459175, + 0.08818872272968292, + 0.13670051097869873, + 0.14768442511558533, + 0.37606993317604065 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07896928489208221 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a world steeped in the hallmarks of Disney Pixar animation, a close-up of the polished chrome nozzle of a steam cleaner shifts dizzyingly rapidly between sharp ice crystal details and a blurred background. The steam cleaner itself boasts a sleek, friendly design, housed in a bright lemon-yellow plastic shell and fitted with a chunky, ergonomic black handle. When activated, a torrent of what should be high-temperature, high-pressure steam erupts from the nozzle. However, this swirling cloud of steam doesn't clean anything. Instead, upon contact with the surrounding air, it miraculously condenses into countless shimmering ice crystals. These crystals, intricately structured, take on the forms of geometrically perfect snowflakes and feathery, delicate frost patterns. They hang suspended in mid-air, shimmering with a translucent, prismatic brilliance like diamond dust. The camera rapidly locks onto the surreal details of a single ice crystal, rendering its edges sharp and clear, while the warm, slightly cluttered Pixar-esque garage background behind it (filled with wooden workbenches and colorful toolboxes) completely blurs into a soft mass of color. Then, the focus quickly pulls back to a blur, allowing the entire shimmering ice crystal cloud to take center stage. With each focus shift, a subtle, brief flicker appears across the screen, as if magic has disturbed the stability of reality, creating a strange atmosphere full of wonder, whimsy, and visual shock.", + "seed": 30351, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_7/index_4321_seed_30351_dp_15_rank_30_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.38186307428404687, + "vlm_logprob": -0.38186307428404687, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.375, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.38186307428404687, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a Disney Pixar animation style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the steam cleaner bright lemon-yellow with a chunky black handle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the steam emitted from the nozzle condense into geometrically perfect snowflakes and frost patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a warm, cluttered garage with wooden workbenches and colorful toolboxes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly shift focus between a sharp ice crystal and a blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22725382447242737 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.602253794670105 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.22725382447242737, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.22725382447242737, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07090798765420914, + 0.032799798995256424, + 0.027463681995868683, + 0.07538358867168427, + 0.13421860337257385, + 0.13703657686710358, + 0.2550053298473358, + 0.09213146567344666, + 0.11222720146179199, + 0.0628257691860199 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.22725382447242737 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a Disney Pixar animation style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the steam cleaner bright lemon-yellow with a chunky black handle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the steam emitted from the nozzle condense into geometrically perfect snowflakes and frost patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a warm, cluttered garage with wooden workbenches and colorful toolboxes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly shift focus between a sharp ice crystal and a blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.043105192482471466 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168105125427246 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.043105192482471466, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.043105192482471466, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09348337352275848, + 0.19006997346878052, + 0.09590957313776016, + 0.09736154228448868, + 0.050330750644207, + 0.19299469888210297, + 0.07315453886985779, + 0.13045424222946167, + 0.04018314555287361, + 0.03605816513299942 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.043105192482471466 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a Disney Pixar animation style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the steam cleaner bright lemon-yellow with a chunky black handle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the steam emitted from the nozzle condense into geometrically perfect snowflakes and frost patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a warm, cluttered garage with wooden workbenches and colorful toolboxes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly shift focus between a sharp ice crystal and a blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004642778541892767 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379642963409424 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004642778541892767, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004642778541892767, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05120500922203064, + 0.030952731147408485, + 0.03410946950316429, + 0.07114579528570175, + 0.08008895069360733, + 0.24495147168636322, + 0.12691955268383026, + 0.14399489760398865, + 0.09815546125173569, + 0.11847672611474991 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004642778541892767 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a Disney Pixar animation style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the steam cleaner bright lemon-yellow with a chunky black handle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the steam emitted from the nozzle condense into geometrically perfect snowflakes and frost patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a warm, cluttered garage with wooden workbenches and colorful toolboxes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly shift focus between a sharp ice crystal and a blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6005973815917969 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22559739649295807 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.6005973815917969, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -1.6005973815917969, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06594328582286835, + 0.0527951642870903, + 0.06380100548267365, + 0.04957544058561325, + 0.055506449192762375, + 0.39355140924453735, + 0.07802288234233856, + 0.11911003291606903, + 0.07576007395982742, + 0.04593424126505852 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.6005973815917969 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a Disney Pixar animation style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the steam cleaner bright lemon-yellow with a chunky black handle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the steam emitted from the nozzle condense into geometrically perfect snowflakes and frost patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a warm, cluttered garage with wooden workbenches and colorful toolboxes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly shift focus between a sharp ice crystal and a blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.033716194331645966 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4087162017822266 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.033716194331645966, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.033716194331645966, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06614662706851959, + 0.030950481072068214, + 0.04555867239832878, + 0.0776619017124176, + 0.22309453785419464, + 0.12471985816955566, + 0.20701642334461212, + 0.07490316033363342, + 0.07587584108114243, + 0.07407248020172119 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.033716194331645966 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_8/index_tensor([3688, 3688])_group_8_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_8/index_tensor([3688, 3688])_group_8_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..8da1f2a40682c773cc325c181cdaacf377ce456b --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_8/index_tensor([3688, 3688])_group_8_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "slightly low-angle close-up slowly zooms in on clusters of vibrant yellow wolfsbane flowers, rendered in Studio Ghibli's signature hand-drawn style. Set in a sun-drenched alpine meadow, lush green blades of grass, each with a soft watercolor texture, sway gently in the breeze. In the background, rolling hills fade into a hazy, distant mountain range, while the azure sky is dotted with fluffy, white Ghibli clouds. The camera focuses on the central flower head, a dense sphere of tightly closed buds. In incredibly smooth, high-frame-rate animation, each delicate petal begins to unfold in graceful, deliberate slowness, their movements as smooth as silk. The buttery yellow petals, outlined with delicate, organic brushstrokes, peel back one by one, revealing a soft, magical inner glow emanating from the core of each flower, as if painted with light itself. As the flowers fully open, this gentle, warm glow becomes more intense, casting a subtle radiance that contrasts beautifully with the bright, golden sunlight bathing the entire meadow, creating a profoundly serene, natural spectacle that captures life’s fleeting, magical moments in bloom in stunning detail.", + "seed": 3396, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_8/index_3688_seed_3396_dp_16_rank_32_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.014993535599205642, + "vlm_logprob": -0.014993535599205642, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.65, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.014993535599205642, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the main subjects clusters of vibrant yellow wolfsbane flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with Studio Ghibli's signature hand-drawn aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene take place in a sun-drenched alpine meadow with lush green grass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow zoom-in on the central flower head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the flower petals unfold slowly to reveal a soft inner glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014908094890415668 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264908313751221 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014908094890415668, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014908094890415668, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11733721196651459, + 0.028436392545700073, + 0.044395118951797485, + 0.25508618354797363, + 0.04127492010593414, + 0.06044190749526024, + 0.1621856540441513, + 0.20854994654655457, + 0.025275344029068947, + 0.057017356157302856 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014908094890415668 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the main subjects clusters of vibrant yellow wolfsbane flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with Studio Ghibli's signature hand-drawn aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene take place in a sun-drenched alpine meadow with lush green grass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow zoom-in on the central flower head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the flower petals unfold slowly to reveal a soft inner glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02058347500860691 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895583391189575 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02058347500860691, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02058347500860691, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4004286825656891, + 0.0282576996833086, + 0.03998930752277374, + 0.2363179326057434, + 0.08529139310121536, + 0.018524551764130592, + 0.08434640616178513, + 0.04715942591428757, + 0.02108899876475334, + 0.03859558328986168 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02058347500860691 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the main subjects clusters of vibrant yellow wolfsbane flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with Studio Ghibli's signature hand-drawn aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene take place in a sun-drenched alpine meadow with lush green grass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow zoom-in on the central flower head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the flower petals unfold slowly to reveal a soft inner glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0007165487040765584 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.250716686248779 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0007165487040765584, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0007165487040765584, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15099605917930603, + 0.04170016944408417, + 0.10262636840343475, + 0.12587502598762512, + 0.10994038730859756, + 0.059938475489616394, + 0.09887076169252396, + 0.06848989427089691, + 0.09101764857769012, + 0.150545135140419 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0007165487040765584 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the main subjects clusters of vibrant yellow wolfsbane flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with Studio Ghibli's signature hand-drawn aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene take place in a sun-drenched alpine meadow with lush green grass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow zoom-in on the central flower head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the flower petals unfold slowly to reveal a soft inner glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02057635225355625 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895576238632202 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02057635225355625, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02057635225355625, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11296796053647995, + 0.04002915695309639, + 0.050542980432510376, + 0.03579201176762581, + 0.18934805691242218, + 0.1545308530330658, + 0.1773403137922287, + 0.20175305008888245, + 0.02078591100871563, + 0.01690966635942459 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02057635225355625 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the main subjects clusters of vibrant yellow wolfsbane flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with Studio Ghibli's signature hand-drawn aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene take place in a sun-drenched alpine meadow with lush green grass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow zoom-in on the central flower head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the flower petals unfold slowly to reveal a soft inner glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018183207139372826 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.01818323135376 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018183207139372826, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018183207139372826, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07891066372394562, + 0.031177790835499763, + 0.045301828533411026, + 0.11590743809938431, + 0.16528673470020294, + 0.10355987399816513, + 0.12976261973381042, + 0.1594211459159851, + 0.12736521661281586, + 0.04330672696232796 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018183207139372826 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slightly low-angle close-up slowly zooms in on clusters of vibrant yellow wolfsbane flowers, rendered in Studio Ghibli's signature hand-drawn style. Set in a sun-drenched alpine meadow, lush green blades of grass, each with a soft watercolor texture, sway gently in the breeze. In the background, rolling hills fade into a hazy, distant mountain range, while the azure sky is dotted with fluffy, white Ghibli clouds. The camera focuses on the central flower head, a dense sphere of tightly closed buds. In incredibly smooth, high-frame-rate animation, each delicate petal begins to unfold in graceful, deliberate slowness, their movements as smooth as silk. The buttery yellow petals, outlined with delicate, organic brushstrokes, peel back one by one, revealing a soft, magical inner glow emanating from the core of each flower, as if painted with light itself. As the flowers fully open, this gentle, warm glow becomes more intense, casting a subtle radiance that contrasts beautifully with the bright, golden sunlight bathing the entire meadow, creating a profoundly serene, natural spectacle that captures life’s fleeting, magical moments in bloom in stunning detail.", + "seed": 3397, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_8/index_3688_seed_3397_dp_16_rank_32_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.008768618199974298, + "vlm_logprob": -0.008768618199974298, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 5.05, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.008768618199974298, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the main subjects clusters of vibrant yellow wolfsbane flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with Studio Ghibli's signature hand-drawn aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene take place in a sun-drenched alpine meadow with lush green grass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow zoom-in on the central flower head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the flower petals unfold slowly to reveal a soft inner glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009454948827624321 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.759454727172852 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009454948827624321, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009454948827624321, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11431777477264404, + 0.08596865832805634, + 0.16902485489845276, + 0.08629752695560455, + 0.12473402172327042, + 0.05626635253429413, + 0.13538630306720734, + 0.15044014155864716, + 0.04871194437146187, + 0.02885238640010357 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009454948827624321 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the main subjects clusters of vibrant yellow wolfsbane flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with Studio Ghibli's signature hand-drawn aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene take place in a sun-drenched alpine meadow with lush green grass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow zoom-in on the central flower head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the flower petals unfold slowly to reveal a soft inner glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016070831567049026 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.14107084274292 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016070831567049026, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016070831567049026, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21537494659423828, + 0.04249963164329529, + 0.05265166983008385, + 0.17499558627605438, + 0.1950921267271042, + 0.034199025481939316, + 0.036842744797468185, + 0.1413296014070511, + 0.07738814502954483, + 0.02962655760347843 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016070831567049026 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the main subjects clusters of vibrant yellow wolfsbane flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with Studio Ghibli's signature hand-drawn aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene take place in a sun-drenched alpine meadow with lush green grass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow zoom-in on the central flower head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the flower petals unfold slowly to reveal a soft inner glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0010414659045636654 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.876041412353516 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0010414659045636654, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0010414659045636654, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1900288611650467, + 0.18226438760757446, + 0.05412152037024498, + 0.06503625214099884, + 0.13990850746631622, + 0.03495378792285919, + 0.068477101624012, + 0.18944060802459717, + 0.03815438225865364, + 0.037614528089761734 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0010414659045636654 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the main subjects clusters of vibrant yellow wolfsbane flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with Studio Ghibli's signature hand-drawn aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene take place in a sun-drenched alpine meadow with lush green grass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow zoom-in on the central flower head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the flower petals unfold slowly to reveal a soft inner glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008636031299829483 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758635997772217 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008636031299829483, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008636031299829483, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08757615089416504, + 0.05910215899348259, + 0.05272917449474335, + 0.2705278694629669, + 0.17669343948364258, + 0.09999724477529526, + 0.038616031408309937, + 0.12255612015724182, + 0.03277168795466423, + 0.0594300851225853 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008636031299829483 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the main subjects clusters of vibrant yellow wolfsbane flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with Studio Ghibli's signature hand-drawn aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene take place in a sun-drenched alpine meadow with lush green grass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow zoom-in on the central flower head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the flower petals unfold slowly to reveal a soft inner glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008639813400804996 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758639812469482 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008639813400804996, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008639813400804996, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.040883295238018036, + 0.022416820749640465, + 0.03763265162706375, + 0.08597215265035629, + 0.06021115183830261, + 0.05180101841688156, + 0.03432723507285118, + 0.4754183888435364, + 0.09514472633600235, + 0.09619263559579849 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008639813400804996 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slightly low-angle close-up slowly zooms in on clusters of vibrant yellow wolfsbane flowers, rendered in Studio Ghibli's signature hand-drawn style. Set in a sun-drenched alpine meadow, lush green blades of grass, each with a soft watercolor texture, sway gently in the breeze. In the background, rolling hills fade into a hazy, distant mountain range, while the azure sky is dotted with fluffy, white Ghibli clouds. The camera focuses on the central flower head, a dense sphere of tightly closed buds. In incredibly smooth, high-frame-rate animation, each delicate petal begins to unfold in graceful, deliberate slowness, their movements as smooth as silk. The buttery yellow petals, outlined with delicate, organic brushstrokes, peel back one by one, revealing a soft, magical inner glow emanating from the core of each flower, as if painted with light itself. As the flowers fully open, this gentle, warm glow becomes more intense, casting a subtle radiance that contrasts beautifully with the bright, golden sunlight bathing the entire meadow, creating a profoundly serene, natural spectacle that captures life’s fleeting, magical moments in bloom in stunning detail.", + "seed": 3398, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_8/index_3688_seed_3398_dp_17_rank_34_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.02126652146689594, + "vlm_logprob": -0.02126652146689594, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.475, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.02126652146689594, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the main subjects clusters of vibrant yellow wolfsbane flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with Studio Ghibli's signature hand-drawn aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene take place in a sun-drenched alpine meadow with lush green grass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow zoom-in on the central flower head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the flower petals unfold slowly to reveal a soft inner glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011288817971944809 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.636288642883301 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011288817971944809, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011288817971944809, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22825902700424194, + 0.08863385021686554, + 0.04119574651122093, + 0.0518520288169384, + 0.04483470320701599, + 0.08295202255249023, + 0.12308444082736969, + 0.07082594186067581, + 0.19048230350017548, + 0.07787994295358658 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011288817971944809 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the main subjects clusters of vibrant yellow wolfsbane flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with Studio Ghibli's signature hand-drawn aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene take place in a sun-drenched alpine meadow with lush green grass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow zoom-in on the central flower head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the flower petals unfold slowly to reveal a soft inner glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014202704653143883 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.26420259475708 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014202704653143883, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014202704653143883, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17520089447498322, + 0.12787297368049622, + 0.040745384991168976, + 0.02712956629693508, + 0.0905861034989357, + 0.041128989309072495, + 0.0731905996799469, + 0.0403161346912384, + 0.10695908963680267, + 0.2768703103065491 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014202704653143883 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the main subjects clusters of vibrant yellow wolfsbane flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with Studio Ghibli's signature hand-drawn aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene take place in a sun-drenched alpine meadow with lush green grass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow zoom-in on the central flower head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the flower petals unfold slowly to reveal a soft inner glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0021969962399452925 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127196788787842 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0021969962399452925, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0021969962399452925, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11922960728406906, + 0.08610232919454575, + 0.06775375455617905, + 0.01951770856976509, + 0.03698977082967758, + 0.10780306905508041, + 0.1894492655992508, + 0.04248335584998131, + 0.19703547656536102, + 0.13363561034202576 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0021969962399452925 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the main subjects clusters of vibrant yellow wolfsbane flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with Studio Ghibli's signature hand-drawn aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene take place in a sun-drenched alpine meadow with lush green grass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow zoom-in on the central flower head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the flower petals unfold slowly to reveal a soft inner glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008638276718556881 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758638381958008 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008638276718556881, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008638276718556881, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16957807540893555, + 0.04624622315168381, + 0.025259895250201225, + 0.019493183121085167, + 0.09057828038930893, + 0.06162206083536148, + 0.13580788671970367, + 0.03523405268788338, + 0.2603488564491272, + 0.15583153069019318 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008638276718556881 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the main subjects clusters of vibrant yellow wolfsbane flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with Studio Ghibli's signature hand-drawn aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene take place in a sun-drenched alpine meadow with lush green grass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow zoom-in on the central flower head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the flower petals unfold slowly to reveal a soft inner glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07000581175088882 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950058937072754 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07000581175088882, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07000581175088882, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08410751074552536, + 0.030221736058592796, + 0.03085387498140335, + 0.022246787324547768, + 0.05940435454249382, + 0.05930158123373985, + 0.063461072742939, + 0.0621916688978672, + 0.40619269013404846, + 0.18201875686645508 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07000581175088882 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slightly low-angle close-up slowly zooms in on clusters of vibrant yellow wolfsbane flowers, rendered in Studio Ghibli's signature hand-drawn style. Set in a sun-drenched alpine meadow, lush green blades of grass, each with a soft watercolor texture, sway gently in the breeze. In the background, rolling hills fade into a hazy, distant mountain range, while the azure sky is dotted with fluffy, white Ghibli clouds. The camera focuses on the central flower head, a dense sphere of tightly closed buds. In incredibly smooth, high-frame-rate animation, each delicate petal begins to unfold in graceful, deliberate slowness, their movements as smooth as silk. The buttery yellow petals, outlined with delicate, organic brushstrokes, peel back one by one, revealing a soft, magical inner glow emanating from the core of each flower, as if painted with light itself. As the flowers fully open, this gentle, warm glow becomes more intense, casting a subtle radiance that contrasts beautifully with the bright, golden sunlight bathing the entire meadow, creating a profoundly serene, natural spectacle that captures life’s fleeting, magical moments in bloom in stunning detail.", + "seed": 3399, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_8/index_3688_seed_3399_dp_17_rank_34_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.02102584266103804, + "vlm_logprob": -0.02102584266103804, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.4, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.02102584266103804, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the main subjects clusters of vibrant yellow wolfsbane flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with Studio Ghibli's signature hand-drawn aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene take place in a sun-drenched alpine meadow with lush green grass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow zoom-in on the central flower head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the flower petals unfold slowly to reveal a soft inner glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.058075737208127975 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9330756664276123 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.058075737208127975, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.058075737208127975, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13391563296318054, + 0.05253911018371582, + 0.011275092139840126, + 0.1974218785762787, + 0.0519770085811615, + 0.10407309979200363, + 0.06449199467897415, + 0.19750747084617615, + 0.016273168846964836, + 0.17052555084228516 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.058075737208127975 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the main subjects clusters of vibrant yellow wolfsbane flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with Studio Ghibli's signature hand-drawn aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene take place in a sun-drenched alpine meadow with lush green grass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow zoom-in on the central flower head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the flower petals unfold slowly to reveal a soft inner glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023292500525712967 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732925415039062 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023292500525712967, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023292500525712967, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16696876287460327, + 0.09397329390048981, + 0.06399662792682648, + 0.11878886818885803, + 0.17752346396446228, + 0.13992437720298767, + 0.04344410076737404, + 0.045125070959329605, + 0.02387681044638157, + 0.1263786107301712 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023292500525712967 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the main subjects clusters of vibrant yellow wolfsbane flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with Studio Ghibli's signature hand-drawn aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene take place in a sun-drenched alpine meadow with lush green grass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow zoom-in on the central flower head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the flower petals unfold slowly to reveal a soft inner glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0019392033573240042 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.251939296722412 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0019392033573240042, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0019392033573240042, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14927150309085846, + 0.13937614858150482, + 0.0750095322728157, + 0.06168580427765846, + 0.0905570238828659, + 0.08082021027803421, + 0.04285873472690582, + 0.09164049476385117, + 0.04291683807969093, + 0.22586369514465332 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0019392033573240042 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the main subjects clusters of vibrant yellow wolfsbane flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with Studio Ghibli's signature hand-drawn aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene take place in a sun-drenched alpine meadow with lush green grass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow zoom-in on the central flower head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the flower petals unfold slowly to reveal a soft inner glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007627647835761309 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882627487182617 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007627647835761309, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007627647835761309, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17370691895484924, + 0.0304512158036232, + 0.012219222262501717, + 0.07533101737499237, + 0.03264138102531433, + 0.060181885957717896, + 0.02630220539867878, + 0.07116995751857758, + 0.04820290580391884, + 0.46979328989982605 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007627647835761309 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the main subjects clusters of vibrant yellow wolfsbane flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with Studio Ghibli's signature hand-drawn aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene take place in a sun-drenched alpine meadow with lush green grass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow zoom-in on the central flower head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the flower petals unfold slowly to reveal a soft inner glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01419412437826395 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264194011688232 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01419412437826395, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01419412437826395, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.056271158158779144, + 0.06471841037273407, + 0.05550125613808632, + 0.021521788090467453, + 0.3358170986175537, + 0.0677490085363388, + 0.05816476047039032, + 0.137858584523201, + 0.029896656051278114, + 0.17250128090381622 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01419412437826395 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_9/index_tensor([9507, 9507])_group_9_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_9/index_tensor([9507, 9507])_group_9_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..6139ca9b88e52a6a925cf78ed55cd9e3649e2f69 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_9/index_tensor([9507, 9507])_group_9_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "dramatic, overhead long shot, captured in Tim Burton's signature gothic fantasy style, shows a massive, distorted rocket slowly ascending from a crude launch pad constructed of rusted scaffolding and bizarre pipes. Rather than a smooth, streamlined form, the rocket's body takes on a grotesque, spiraling silhouette. Its deep black metal shell is studded with rivets of varying sizes and haphazard welds, like the work of a crazed blacksmith. As the camera slowly tilts upward, we see thick, inky black smoke billowing from the base of the rocket, rather than a bright flame. This plume stands out against the gloomy, deep purple sky, dotted with swirling clouds. The rocket climbs upwards with a heavy and laborious posture, trembling and shaking, casting a stretched, twisting, grotesque shadow on the barren and cracked ground. As the rocket rises, the shadow dances and deforms. The whole scene is filled with an absurd, grand and slightly uneasy industrial fairy tale atmosphere in desaturated cold colors.", + "seed": 32450, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_9/index_9507_seed_32450_dp_18_rank_36_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.29442506469786167, + "vlm_logprob": -0.29442506469786167, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.85, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.29442506469786167, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from an overhead long shot perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the rocket's body shaped as a grotesque, spiraling silhouette rather than a smooth streamlined form?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the rocket's shell deep black metal studded with rivets of varying sizes and haphazard welds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt upward while the rocket ascends?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky gloomy and deep purple with swirling clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6397957801818848 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7647957801818848 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.6397957801818848, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.6397957801818848, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12782162427902222, + 0.42744874954223633, + 0.032966047525405884, + 0.021085724234580994, + 0.027093948796391487, + 0.029697053134441376, + 0.0685148760676384, + 0.05133695900440216, + 0.07040619850158691, + 0.14362883567810059 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.6397957801818848 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from an overhead long shot perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the rocket's body shaped as a grotesque, spiraling silhouette rather than a smooth streamlined form?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the rocket's shell deep black metal studded with rivets of varying sizes and haphazard welds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt upward while the rocket ascends?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky gloomy and deep purple with swirling clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.47429245710372925 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9742924571037292 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.47429245710372925, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.47429245710372925, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06549325585365295, + 0.4799956679344177, + 0.022446133196353912, + 0.022806452587246895, + 0.017521554604172707, + 0.002741876058280468, + 0.018591511994600296, + 0.03111332096159458, + 0.026317333802580833, + 0.3129728138446808 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.47429245710372925 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from an overhead long shot perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the rocket's body shaped as a grotesque, spiraling silhouette rather than a smooth streamlined form?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the rocket's shell deep black metal studded with rivets of varying sizes and haphazard welds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt upward while the rocket ascends?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky gloomy and deep purple with swirling clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.31350231170654297 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.313502311706543 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.31350231170654297, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.31350231170654297, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2534879446029663, + 0.3684040307998657, + 0.0556645542383194, + 0.018193071708083153, + 0.011809326708316803, + 0.010788306593894958, + 0.019832294434309006, + 0.04542699456214905, + 0.03500862419605255, + 0.1813848465681076 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.31350231170654297 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from an overhead long shot perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the rocket's body shaped as a grotesque, spiraling silhouette rather than a smooth streamlined form?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the rocket's shell deep black metal studded with rivets of varying sizes and haphazard welds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt upward while the rocket ascends?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky gloomy and deep purple with swirling clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026347821578383446 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513478755950928 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026347821578383446, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026347821578383446, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1681613177061081, + 0.13170966506004333, + 0.045227568596601486, + 0.011396689340472221, + 0.0234910286962986, + 0.02980245091021061, + 0.06774704903364182, + 0.03289119154214859, + 0.12567353248596191, + 0.36389946937561035 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026347821578383446 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from an overhead long shot perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the rocket's body shaped as a grotesque, spiraling silhouette rather than a smooth streamlined form?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the rocket's shell deep black metal studded with rivets of varying sizes and haphazard welds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt upward while the rocket ascends?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky gloomy and deep purple with swirling clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01818695291876793 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018187046051025 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01818695291876793, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01818695291876793, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03460098057985306, + 0.17304259538650513, + 0.0942826047539711, + 0.015730882063508034, + 0.021548956632614136, + 0.04687323048710823, + 0.0773068517446518, + 0.0771944597363472, + 0.06684421747922897, + 0.3925751745700836 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01818695291876793 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dramatic, overhead long shot, captured in Tim Burton's signature gothic fantasy style, shows a massive, distorted rocket slowly ascending from a crude launch pad constructed of rusted scaffolding and bizarre pipes. Rather than a smooth, streamlined form, the rocket's body takes on a grotesque, spiraling silhouette. Its deep black metal shell is studded with rivets of varying sizes and haphazard welds, like the work of a crazed blacksmith. As the camera slowly tilts upward, we see thick, inky black smoke billowing from the base of the rocket, rather than a bright flame. This plume stands out against the gloomy, deep purple sky, dotted with swirling clouds. The rocket climbs upwards with a heavy and laborious posture, trembling and shaking, casting a stretched, twisting, grotesque shadow on the barren and cracked ground. As the rocket rises, the shadow dances and deforms. The whole scene is filled with an absurd, grand and slightly uneasy industrial fairy tale atmosphere in desaturated cold colors.", + "seed": 32451, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_9/index_9507_seed_32451_dp_18_rank_36_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.4317909173667431, + "vlm_logprob": -0.4317909173667431, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.024999976158142, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.4317909173667431, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from an overhead long shot perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the rocket's body shaped as a grotesque, spiraling silhouette rather than a smooth streamlined form?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the rocket's shell deep black metal studded with rivets of varying sizes and haphazard welds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt upward while the rocket ascends?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky gloomy and deep purple with swirling clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.0617902278900146 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4367901682853699 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.0617902278900146, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.6250000596046448, + "token_credit_reward": -1.0617902278900146, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20501956343650818, + 0.08584380149841309, + 0.045958757400512695, + 0.04437242075800896, + 0.12114841490983963, + 0.07166768610477448, + 0.12921085953712463, + 0.07042251527309418, + 0.1487278789281845, + 0.07762803137302399 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.0617902278900146 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from an overhead long shot perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the rocket's body shaped as a grotesque, spiraling silhouette rather than a smooth streamlined form?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the rocket's shell deep black metal studded with rivets of varying sizes and haphazard welds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt upward while the rocket ascends?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky gloomy and deep purple with swirling clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4742945432662964 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9742945432662964 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.4742945432662964, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.4742945432662964, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1684238314628601, + 0.10600375384092331, + 0.03877528756856918, + 0.2926824390888214, + 0.032450590282678604, + 0.09656257182359695, + 0.09268444776535034, + 0.08250357955694199, + 0.05204387754201889, + 0.03786959871649742 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.4742945432662964 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from an overhead long shot perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the rocket's body shaped as a grotesque, spiraling silhouette rather than a smooth streamlined form?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the rocket's shell deep black metal studded with rivets of varying sizes and haphazard welds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt upward while the rocket ascends?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky gloomy and deep purple with swirling clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.34867221117019653 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2236721515655518 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.34867221117019653, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.8749999403953552, + "token_credit_reward": -0.34867221117019653, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.26898688077926636, + 0.05720432475209236, + 0.07072380930185318, + 0.17220157384872437, + 0.05388098955154419, + 0.0518273189663887, + 0.10392683744430542, + 0.12544988095760345, + 0.0479934960603714, + 0.0478048175573349 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.34867221117019653 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from an overhead long shot perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the rocket's body shaped as a grotesque, spiraling silhouette rather than a smooth streamlined form?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the rocket's shell deep black metal studded with rivets of varying sizes and haphazard welds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt upward while the rocket ascends?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky gloomy and deep purple with swirling clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22554725408554077 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6005473136901855 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.22554725408554077, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.22554725408554077, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23155160248279572, + 0.11780648678541183, + 0.059531256556510925, + 0.05976197496056557, + 0.07797922939062119, + 0.14906150102615356, + 0.1220095083117485, + 0.04720879718661308, + 0.04394831880927086, + 0.09114136546850204 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.22554725408554077 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from an overhead long shot perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the rocket's body shaped as a grotesque, spiraling silhouette rather than a smooth streamlined form?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the rocket's shell deep black metal studded with rivets of varying sizes and haphazard welds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt upward while the rocket ascends?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky gloomy and deep purple with swirling clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0486503504216671 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486502647399902 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0486503504216671, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0486503504216671, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.44539573788642883, + 0.028033146634697914, + 0.09961983561515808, + 0.052067626267671585, + 0.11078859120607376, + 0.03937205299735069, + 0.02279958501458168, + 0.03710046783089638, + 0.1241515502333641, + 0.040671445429325104 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0486503504216671 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dramatic, overhead long shot, captured in Tim Burton's signature gothic fantasy style, shows a massive, distorted rocket slowly ascending from a crude launch pad constructed of rusted scaffolding and bizarre pipes. Rather than a smooth, streamlined form, the rocket's body takes on a grotesque, spiraling silhouette. Its deep black metal shell is studded with rivets of varying sizes and haphazard welds, like the work of a crazed blacksmith. As the camera slowly tilts upward, we see thick, inky black smoke billowing from the base of the rocket, rather than a bright flame. This plume stands out against the gloomy, deep purple sky, dotted with swirling clouds. The rocket climbs upwards with a heavy and laborious posture, trembling and shaking, casting a stretched, twisting, grotesque shadow on the barren and cracked ground. As the rocket rises, the shadow dances and deforms. The whole scene is filled with an absurd, grand and slightly uneasy industrial fairy tale atmosphere in desaturated cold colors.", + "seed": 32452, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_9/index_9507_seed_32452_dp_19_rank_38_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.2154402021318674, + "vlm_logprob": -0.2154402021318674, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.35, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.2154402021318674, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from an overhead long shot perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the rocket's body shaped as a grotesque, spiraling silhouette rather than a smooth streamlined form?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the rocket's shell deep black metal studded with rivets of varying sizes and haphazard welds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt upward while the rocket ascends?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky gloomy and deep purple with swirling clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7013479471206665 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7013479471206665 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.7013479471206665, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.7013479471206665, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04142264649271965, + 0.02979365549981594, + 0.04001051187515259, + 0.03088744357228279, + 0.044772449880838394, + 0.04212067276239395, + 0.04376703500747681, + 0.21287009119987488, + 0.48969918489456177, + 0.024656325578689575 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.7013479471206665 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from an overhead long shot perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the rocket's body shaped as a grotesque, spiraling silhouette rather than a smooth streamlined form?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the rocket's shell deep black metal studded with rivets of varying sizes and haphazard welds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt upward while the rocket ascends?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky gloomy and deep purple with swirling clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.048668064177036285 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048668146133423 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.048668064177036285, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.048668064177036285, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04921889305114746, + 0.01879659667611122, + 0.0655539408326149, + 0.03828158602118492, + 0.04660876840353012, + 0.06294657289981842, + 0.37489211559295654, + 0.20650388300418854, + 0.09531198441982269, + 0.041885681450366974 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.048668064177036285 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from an overhead long shot perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the rocket's body shaped as a grotesque, spiraling silhouette rather than a smooth streamlined form?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the rocket's shell deep black metal studded with rivets of varying sizes and haphazard welds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt upward while the rocket ascends?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky gloomy and deep purple with swirling clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2813270092010498 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4063270092010498 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2813270092010498, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2813270092010498, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05972910672426224, + 0.022633550688624382, + 0.04027552902698517, + 0.04142212122678757, + 0.05202329158782959, + 0.11825297772884369, + 0.4475477337837219, + 0.09202270209789276, + 0.050318751484155655, + 0.07577414065599442 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2813270092010498 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from an overhead long shot perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the rocket's body shaped as a grotesque, spiraling silhouette rather than a smooth streamlined form?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the rocket's shell deep black metal studded with rivets of varying sizes and haphazard welds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt upward while the rocket ascends?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky gloomy and deep purple with swirling clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01606672629714012 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141066551208496 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01606672629714012, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01606672629714012, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05227174237370491, + 0.03054155595600605, + 0.06534015387296677, + 0.03590872138738632, + 0.08032377064228058, + 0.11399568617343903, + 0.10898397117853165, + 0.18516474962234497, + 0.28864166140556335, + 0.03882797807455063 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01606672629714012 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from an overhead long shot perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the rocket's body shaped as a grotesque, spiraling silhouette rather than a smooth streamlined form?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the rocket's shell deep black metal studded with rivets of varying sizes and haphazard welds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt upward while the rocket ascends?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky gloomy and deep purple with swirling clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02979126386344433 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5297913551330566 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02979126386344433, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02979126386344433, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04286854341626167, + 0.03063615784049034, + 0.030156360939145088, + 0.04290015622973442, + 0.09586430341005325, + 0.2086501568555832, + 0.14496949315071106, + 0.1342410296201706, + 0.078422911465168, + 0.19129090011119843 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02979126386344433 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dramatic, overhead long shot, captured in Tim Burton's signature gothic fantasy style, shows a massive, distorted rocket slowly ascending from a crude launch pad constructed of rusted scaffolding and bizarre pipes. Rather than a smooth, streamlined form, the rocket's body takes on a grotesque, spiraling silhouette. Its deep black metal shell is studded with rivets of varying sizes and haphazard welds, like the work of a crazed blacksmith. As the camera slowly tilts upward, we see thick, inky black smoke billowing from the base of the rocket, rather than a bright flame. This plume stands out against the gloomy, deep purple sky, dotted with swirling clouds. The rocket climbs upwards with a heavy and laborious posture, trembling and shaking, casting a stretched, twisting, grotesque shadow on the barren and cracked ground. As the rocket rises, the shadow dances and deforms. The whole scene is filled with an absurd, grand and slightly uneasy industrial fairy tale atmosphere in desaturated cold colors.", + "seed": 32453, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000115/group_9/index_9507_seed_32453_dp_19_rank_38_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.16378899160772561, + "vlm_logprob": -0.16378899160772561, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.7749999523162843, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.16378899160772561, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from an overhead long shot perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the rocket's body shaped as a grotesque, spiraling silhouette rather than a smooth streamlined form?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the rocket's shell deep black metal studded with rivets of varying sizes and haphazard welds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt upward while the rocket ascends?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky gloomy and deep purple with swirling clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5833864808082581 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8333864808082581 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5833864808082581, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5833864808082581, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2906990647315979, + 0.09529632329940796, + 0.13129761815071106, + 0.0944695845246315, + 0.05395428463816643, + 0.04852890223264694, + 0.04068547114729881, + 0.11510277539491653, + 0.08402086794376373, + 0.04594513028860092 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5833864808082581 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from an overhead long shot perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the rocket's body shaped as a grotesque, spiraling silhouette rather than a smooth streamlined form?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the rocket's shell deep black metal studded with rivets of varying sizes and haphazard welds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt upward while the rocket ascends?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky gloomy and deep purple with swirling clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023305660113692284 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773305654525757 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023305660113692284, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023305660113692284, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08260373026132584, + 0.024524619802832603, + 0.012893236242234707, + 0.16939851641654968, + 0.05503508076071739, + 0.02473941259086132, + 0.06637895852327347, + 0.03817955404520035, + 0.4468627870082855, + 0.07938411831855774 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023305660113692284 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from an overhead long shot perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the rocket's body shaped as a grotesque, spiraling silhouette rather than a smooth streamlined form?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the rocket's shell deep black metal studded with rivets of varying sizes and haphazard welds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt upward while the rocket ascends?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky gloomy and deep purple with swirling clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17988218367099762 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8048821687698364 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17988218367099762, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17988218367099762, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1542128175497055, + 0.03601505607366562, + 0.039133328944444656, + 0.08159568905830383, + 0.022914130240678787, + 0.02469000779092312, + 0.13341578841209412, + 0.027707848697900772, + 0.44781067967414856, + 0.03250465169548988 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17988218367099762 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from an overhead long shot perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the rocket's body shaped as a grotesque, spiraling silhouette rather than a smooth streamlined form?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the rocket's shell deep black metal studded with rivets of varying sizes and haphazard welds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt upward while the rocket ascends?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky gloomy and deep purple with swirling clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018182972446084023 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018182754516602 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018182972446084023, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018182972446084023, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12521396577358246, + 0.04276212677359581, + 0.01915673352777958, + 0.03345716372132301, + 0.0218376312404871, + 0.022715099155902863, + 0.03428620472550392, + 0.10841783881187439, + 0.5226632952690125, + 0.0694899782538414 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018182972446084023 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from an overhead long shot perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the rocket's body shaped as a grotesque, spiraling silhouette rather than a smooth streamlined form?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the rocket's shell deep black metal studded with rivets of varying sizes and haphazard welds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt upward while the rocket ascends?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky gloomy and deep purple with swirling clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014187660999596119 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264187812805176 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014187660999596119, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014187660999596119, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.030232490971684456, + 0.050491973757743835, + 0.021973619237542152, + 0.07374326139688492, + 0.01749584637582302, + 0.021543970331549644, + 0.037362802773714066, + 0.17268873751163483, + 0.4600706398487091, + 0.11439666897058487 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014187660999596119 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000127/group_0/index_tensor([9926, 9926])_group_0_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000127/group_0/index_tensor([9926, 9926])_group_0_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..7636c8064a22ba720d62d83d0630022efa5fa8f8 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000127/group_0/index_tensor([9926, 9926])_group_0_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "static, mid-close-up shot from a horizontal angle, captured in a textured stop-motion style, captures a white-bearded grandfather sculpted entirely from clay. Fingerprints and traces of hand-molding are evident on his surface, and his lush, exaggerated white clay beard nearly covers half of his rounded cheeks. His face radiates pure, contented joy, his eyes narrowed into slits by a wide smile. He wears a handmade red clay sweater, its texture roughened with tooling, and sits on a simple, dark brown clay wooden chair. A soft, warm light slants down from the upper right of the frame, casting gentle, sharp shadows on his clay body and the chair, highlighting the texture of the miniature model. He holds a bright yellow clay corncob in his hands, its kernels distinct yet slightly irregular. With a pause and pause, typical of frame-by-frame animation, he clumsily and haltingly brings the corn to his mouth, then happily \"gnaws\" on it. His head sways slightly and discontinuously from side to side as he chews, his whole body trembling with happiness. The background is a solid, warm beige wall, and the overall scene is warm and bright, imbued with childlike innocence, warmth, and the simple joy of handicraft.", + "seed": 3387, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000127/group_0/index_9926_seed_3387_dp_0_rank_0_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.053066718578338626, + "vlm_logprob": -0.053066718578338626, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.375, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.053066718578338626, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a white-bearded grandfather sculpted entirely from clay?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the grandfather wearing a handmade red clay sweater with a roughened texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the grandfather sitting on a simple dark brown clay wooden chair while holding a bright yellow clay corncob?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the character perform the action of clumsily bringing the corn to his mouth and gnawing on it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a solid warm beige wall with soft warm light slanting from the upper right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16139918565750122 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9113991260528564 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16139918565750122, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16139918565750122, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21150898933410645, + 0.23462794721126556, + 0.04095454141497612, + 0.05125522240996361, + 0.12069561332464218, + 0.05856059491634369, + 0.07896596938371658, + 0.06462614238262177, + 0.09239475429058075, + 0.04641019552946091 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16139918565750122 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a white-bearded grandfather sculpted entirely from clay?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the grandfather wearing a handmade red clay sweater with a roughened texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the grandfather sitting on a simple dark brown clay wooden chair while holding a bright yellow clay corncob?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the character perform the action of clumsily bringing the corn to his mouth and gnawing on it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a solid warm beige wall with soft warm light slanting from the upper right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011093251407146454 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.5110931396484375 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011093251407146454, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011093251407146454, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04002615809440613, + 0.26962175965309143, + 0.03031144291162491, + 0.019322311505675316, + 0.40878358483314514, + 0.036276109516620636, + 0.01763741672039032, + 0.06828097999095917, + 0.021082254126667976, + 0.08865801244974136 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011093251407146454 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a white-bearded grandfather sculpted entirely from clay?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the grandfather wearing a handmade red clay sweater with a roughened texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the grandfather sitting on a simple dark brown clay wooden chair while holding a bright yellow clay corncob?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the character perform the action of clumsily bringing the corn to his mouth and gnawing on it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a solid warm beige wall with soft warm light slanting from the upper right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.043081097304821014 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168081045150757 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.043081097304821014, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.043081097304821014, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1424752175807953, + 0.11776638776063919, + 0.29999691247940063, + 0.07251977175474167, + 0.09939280152320862, + 0.03370917588472366, + 0.07989688217639923, + 0.03969103470444679, + 0.06983888149261475, + 0.04471288248896599 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.043081097304821014 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a white-bearded grandfather sculpted entirely from clay?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the grandfather wearing a handmade red clay sweater with a roughened texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the grandfather sitting on a simple dark brown clay wooden chair while holding a bright yellow clay corncob?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the character perform the action of clumsily bringing the corn to his mouth and gnawing on it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a solid warm beige wall with soft warm light slanting from the upper right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.033695679157972336 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408695697784424 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.033695679157972336, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.033695679157972336, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07120735198259354, + 0.1132163554430008, + 0.05456295236945152, + 0.07087934762239456, + 0.1747390180826187, + 0.1279512196779251, + 0.13456282019615173, + 0.05047673359513283, + 0.14615879952907562, + 0.05624539405107498 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.033695679157972336 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a white-bearded grandfather sculpted entirely from clay?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the grandfather wearing a handmade red clay sweater with a roughened texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the grandfather sitting on a simple dark brown clay wooden chair while holding a bright yellow clay corncob?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the character perform the action of clumsily bringing the corn to his mouth and gnawing on it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a solid warm beige wall with soft warm light slanting from the upper right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01606437936425209 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141064167022705 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01606437936425209, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01606437936425209, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24636152386665344, + 0.1700548380613327, + 0.16514921188354492, + 0.04015962779521942, + 0.08432412892580032, + 0.04928857460618019, + 0.040886376053094864, + 0.04349701106548309, + 0.045047301799058914, + 0.11523135006427765 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01606437936425209 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, mid-close-up shot from a horizontal angle, captured in a textured stop-motion style, captures a white-bearded grandfather sculpted entirely from clay. Fingerprints and traces of hand-molding are evident on his surface, and his lush, exaggerated white clay beard nearly covers half of his rounded cheeks. His face radiates pure, contented joy, his eyes narrowed into slits by a wide smile. He wears a handmade red clay sweater, its texture roughened with tooling, and sits on a simple, dark brown clay wooden chair. A soft, warm light slants down from the upper right of the frame, casting gentle, sharp shadows on his clay body and the chair, highlighting the texture of the miniature model. He holds a bright yellow clay corncob in his hands, its kernels distinct yet slightly irregular. With a pause and pause, typical of frame-by-frame animation, he clumsily and haltingly brings the corn to his mouth, then happily \"gnaws\" on it. His head sways slightly and discontinuously from side to side as he chews, his whole body trembling with happiness. The background is a solid, warm beige wall, and the overall scene is warm and bright, imbued with childlike innocence, warmth, and the simple joy of handicraft.", + "seed": 3388, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000127/group_0/index_9926_seed_3388_dp_0_rank_0_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.04339656513184309, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04339656513184309, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.699999976158142, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04339656513184309, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a white-bearded grandfather sculpted entirely from clay?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the grandfather wearing a handmade red clay sweater with a roughened texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the grandfather sitting on a simple dark brown clay wooden chair while holding a bright yellow clay corncob?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the character perform the action of clumsily bringing the corn to his mouth and gnawing on it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a solid warm beige wall with soft warm light slanting from the upper right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14415130019187927 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.019151210784912 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14415130019187927, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.8749998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14415130019187927, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1404823511838913, + 0.06704626232385635, + 0.032844241708517075, + 0.09829024225473404, + 0.07772906869649887, + 0.07472319900989532, + 0.35685795545578003, + 0.04753686860203743, + 0.04911081865429878, + 0.05537900701165199 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14415130019187927 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a white-bearded grandfather sculpted entirely from clay?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the grandfather wearing a handmade red clay sweater with a roughened texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the grandfather sitting on a simple dark brown clay wooden chair while holding a bright yellow clay corncob?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the character perform the action of clumsily bringing the corn to his mouth and gnawing on it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a solid warm beige wall with soft warm light slanting from the upper right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01820732094347477 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018207550048828 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01820732094347477, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01820732094347477, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11721930652856827, + 0.04118766635656357, + 0.04764659330248833, + 0.25697627663612366, + 0.044921260327100754, + 0.07142370939254761, + 0.22121718525886536, + 0.07716059684753418, + 0.045585017651319504, + 0.07666235417127609 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01820732094347477 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a white-bearded grandfather sculpted entirely from clay?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the grandfather wearing a handmade red clay sweater with a roughened texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the grandfather sitting on a simple dark brown clay wooden chair while holding a bright yellow clay corncob?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the character perform the action of clumsily bringing the corn to his mouth and gnawing on it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a solid warm beige wall with soft warm light slanting from the upper right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006746135652065277 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006746292114258 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006746135652065277, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006746135652065277, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11357993632555008, + 0.061891600489616394, + 0.06245986744761467, + 0.4405847191810608, + 0.05525309965014458, + 0.15985241532325745, + 0.030178455635905266, + 0.021858669817447662, + 0.01846340484917164, + 0.03587783873081207 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006746135652065277 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a white-bearded grandfather sculpted entirely from clay?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the grandfather wearing a handmade red clay sweater with a roughened texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the grandfather sitting on a simple dark brown clay wooden chair while holding a bright yellow clay corncob?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the character perform the action of clumsily bringing the corn to his mouth and gnawing on it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a solid warm beige wall with soft warm light slanting from the upper right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03368888050317764 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.40868878364563 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03368888050317764, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03368888050317764, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22271358966827393, + 0.08770740032196045, + 0.03092871978878975, + 0.2772008180618286, + 0.12219461053609848, + 0.05442504212260246, + 0.06914115697145462, + 0.08455310761928558, + 0.03292771056294441, + 0.01820782944560051 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03368888050317764 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a white-bearded grandfather sculpted entirely from clay?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the grandfather wearing a handmade red clay sweater with a roughened texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the grandfather sitting on a simple dark brown clay wooden chair while holding a bright yellow clay corncob?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the character perform the action of clumsily bringing the corn to his mouth and gnawing on it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a solid warm beige wall with soft warm light slanting from the upper right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014189188368618488 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.26418924331665 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014189188368618488, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014189188368618488, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22120973467826843, + 0.0636509507894516, + 0.04587699472904205, + 0.12783369421958923, + 0.13253553211688995, + 0.04758855327963829, + 0.041253916919231415, + 0.20763057470321655, + 0.05791608616709709, + 0.05450396239757538 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014189188368618488 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, mid-close-up shot from a horizontal angle, captured in a textured stop-motion style, captures a white-bearded grandfather sculpted entirely from clay. Fingerprints and traces of hand-molding are evident on his surface, and his lush, exaggerated white clay beard nearly covers half of his rounded cheeks. His face radiates pure, contented joy, his eyes narrowed into slits by a wide smile. He wears a handmade red clay sweater, its texture roughened with tooling, and sits on a simple, dark brown clay wooden chair. A soft, warm light slants down from the upper right of the frame, casting gentle, sharp shadows on his clay body and the chair, highlighting the texture of the miniature model. He holds a bright yellow clay corncob in his hands, its kernels distinct yet slightly irregular. With a pause and pause, typical of frame-by-frame animation, he clumsily and haltingly brings the corn to his mouth, then happily \"gnaws\" on it. His head sways slightly and discontinuously from side to side as he chews, his whole body trembling with happiness. The background is a solid, warm beige wall, and the overall scene is warm and bright, imbued with childlike innocence, warmth, and the simple joy of handicraft.", + "seed": 3389, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000127/group_0/index_9926_seed_3389_dp_1_rank_2_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.09773887265473605, + "vlm_logprob": -0.09773887265473605, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.175, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.09773887265473605, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a white-bearded grandfather sculpted entirely from clay?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the grandfather wearing a handmade red clay sweater with a roughened texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the grandfather sitting on a simple dark brown clay wooden chair while holding a bright yellow clay corncob?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the character perform the action of clumsily bringing the corn to his mouth and gnawing on it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a solid warm beige wall with soft warm light slanting from the upper right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.390230268239975 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1402302980422974 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.390230268239975, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.390230268239975, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0909411832690239, + 0.35329827666282654, + 0.08690918236970901, + 0.0466998890042305, + 0.037919383496046066, + 0.0648973286151886, + 0.04674266278743744, + 0.07990901172161102, + 0.0304005965590477, + 0.16228243708610535 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.390230268239975 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a white-bearded grandfather sculpted entirely from clay?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the grandfather wearing a handmade red clay sweater with a roughened texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the grandfather sitting on a simple dark brown clay wooden chair while holding a bright yellow clay corncob?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the character perform the action of clumsily bringing the corn to his mouth and gnawing on it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a solid warm beige wall with soft warm light slanting from the upper right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014221626333892345 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264221668243408 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014221626333892345, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014221626333892345, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07602110505104065, + 0.3842398226261139, + 0.061243560165166855, + 0.020498333498835564, + 0.023307904601097107, + 0.021574443206191063, + 0.04695893079042435, + 0.11079542338848114, + 0.0221708994358778, + 0.23318959772586823 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014221626333892345 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a white-bearded grandfather sculpted entirely from clay?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the grandfather wearing a handmade red clay sweater with a roughened texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the grandfather sitting on a simple dark brown clay wooden chair while holding a bright yellow clay corncob?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the character perform the action of clumsily bringing the corn to his mouth and gnawing on it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a solid warm beige wall with soft warm light slanting from the upper right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.043085094541311264 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680850982666016 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.043085094541311264, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.043085094541311264, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13136759400367737, + 0.2343941628932953, + 0.05446723848581314, + 0.117301806807518, + 0.04939412698149681, + 0.07513152807950974, + 0.11273694783449173, + 0.058230459690093994, + 0.040586259216070175, + 0.12638984620571136 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.043085094541311264 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a white-bearded grandfather sculpted entirely from clay?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the grandfather wearing a handmade red clay sweater with a roughened texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the grandfather sitting on a simple dark brown clay wooden chair while holding a bright yellow clay corncob?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the character perform the action of clumsily bringing the corn to his mouth and gnawing on it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a solid warm beige wall with soft warm light slanting from the upper right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02057950384914875 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955795764923096 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02057950384914875, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02057950384914875, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10726571083068848, + 0.2033262550830841, + 0.0506092868745327, + 0.20158275961875916, + 0.03886621445417404, + 0.02257004752755165, + 0.16489282250404358, + 0.05305817723274231, + 0.03197779506444931, + 0.12585096061229706 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 3, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02057950384914875 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a white-bearded grandfather sculpted entirely from clay?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the grandfather wearing a handmade red clay sweater with a roughened texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the grandfather sitting on a simple dark brown clay wooden chair while holding a bright yellow clay corncob?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the character perform the action of clumsily bringing the corn to his mouth and gnawing on it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a solid warm beige wall with soft warm light slanting from the upper right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020577870309352875 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895577907562256 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020577870309352875, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020577870309352875, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09671047329902649, + 0.3576069176197052, + 0.16898810863494873, + 0.07919047772884369, + 0.045743584632873535, + 0.03269532322883606, + 0.08004767447710037, + 0.028728961944580078, + 0.02505156397819519, + 0.08523697406053543 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020577870309352875 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, mid-close-up shot from a horizontal angle, captured in a textured stop-motion style, captures a white-bearded grandfather sculpted entirely from clay. Fingerprints and traces of hand-molding are evident on his surface, and his lush, exaggerated white clay beard nearly covers half of his rounded cheeks. His face radiates pure, contented joy, his eyes narrowed into slits by a wide smile. He wears a handmade red clay sweater, its texture roughened with tooling, and sits on a simple, dark brown clay wooden chair. A soft, warm light slants down from the upper right of the frame, casting gentle, sharp shadows on his clay body and the chair, highlighting the texture of the miniature model. He holds a bright yellow clay corncob in his hands, its kernels distinct yet slightly irregular. With a pause and pause, typical of frame-by-frame animation, he clumsily and haltingly brings the corn to his mouth, then happily \"gnaws\" on it. His head sways slightly and discontinuously from side to side as he chews, his whole body trembling with happiness. The background is a solid, warm beige wall, and the overall scene is warm and bright, imbued with childlike innocence, warmth, and the simple joy of handicraft.", + "seed": 3390, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000127/group_0/index_9926_seed_3390_dp_1_rank_2_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.10625404641032218, + "vlm_logprob": -0.10625404641032218, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.1000000119209288, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.10625404641032218, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a white-bearded grandfather sculpted entirely from clay?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the grandfather wearing a handmade red clay sweater with a roughened texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the grandfather sitting on a simple dark brown clay wooden chair while holding a bright yellow clay corncob?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the character perform the action of clumsily bringing the corn to his mouth and gnawing on it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a solid warm beige wall with soft warm light slanting from the upper right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4304952025413513 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.055495262145996 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.4304952025413513, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.6250000596046448, + "token_credit_reward": -0.4304952025413513, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.7304414510726929, + 0.052421875298023224, + 0.016365211457014084, + 0.013619886711239815, + 0.07018531113862991, + 0.026101626455783844, + 0.022506726905703545, + 0.024900447577238083, + 0.007964074611663818, + 0.035493332892656326 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.4304952025413513 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a white-bearded grandfather sculpted entirely from clay?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the grandfather wearing a handmade red clay sweater with a roughened texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the grandfather sitting on a simple dark brown clay wooden chair while holding a bright yellow clay corncob?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the character perform the action of clumsily bringing the corn to his mouth and gnawing on it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a solid warm beige wall with soft warm light slanting from the upper right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016094176098704338 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141094207763672 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016094176098704338, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016094176098704338, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24694402515888214, + 0.14816372096538544, + 0.0234388317912817, + 0.030423490330576897, + 0.37867262959480286, + 0.045200083404779434, + 0.017748624086380005, + 0.024443436414003372, + 0.025996865704655647, + 0.05896828696131706 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016094176098704338 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a white-bearded grandfather sculpted entirely from clay?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the grandfather wearing a handmade red clay sweater with a roughened texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the grandfather sitting on a simple dark brown clay wooden chair while holding a bright yellow clay corncob?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the character perform the action of clumsily bringing the corn to his mouth and gnawing on it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a solid warm beige wall with soft warm light slanting from the upper right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023303214460611343 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773303270339966 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023303214460611343, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023303214460611343, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2871418595314026, + 0.2637256979942322, + 0.01974192075431347, + 0.06603603810071945, + 0.2185884565114975, + 0.037937406450510025, + 0.03926818072795868, + 0.015959536656737328, + 0.024254344403743744, + 0.02734663523733616 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023303214460611343 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a white-bearded grandfather sculpted entirely from clay?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the grandfather wearing a handmade red clay sweater with a roughened texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the grandfather sitting on a simple dark brown clay wooden chair while holding a bright yellow clay corncob?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the character perform the action of clumsily bringing the corn to his mouth and gnawing on it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a solid warm beige wall with soft warm light slanting from the upper right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.038092825561761856 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288092851638794 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.038092825561761856, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.038092825561761856, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10322501510381699, + 0.1833166778087616, + 0.04752786457538605, + 0.03203224763274193, + 0.47064921259880066, + 0.01802506111562252, + 0.05098261684179306, + 0.043568920344114304, + 0.018420668318867683, + 0.03225162997841835 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.038092825561761856 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a white-bearded grandfather sculpted entirely from clay?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the grandfather wearing a handmade red clay sweater with a roughened texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the grandfather sitting on a simple dark brown clay wooden chair while holding a bright yellow clay corncob?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the character perform the action of clumsily bringing the corn to his mouth and gnawing on it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a solid warm beige wall with soft warm light slanting from the upper right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02328481338918209 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773284912109375 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02328481338918209, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02328481338918209, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20732231438159943, + 0.3140590786933899, + 0.04509173706173897, + 0.06406670063734055, + 0.24782240390777588, + 0.035419758409261703, + 0.01992163434624672, + 0.028325947001576424, + 0.023203136399388313, + 0.014767292886972427 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02328481338918209 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000127/group_1/index_tensor([4986, 4986])_group_1_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000127/group_1/index_tensor([4986, 4986])_group_1_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..c0c9c594b72596775a3eeeb2a911e82d15228a2f --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000127/group_1/index_tensor([4986, 4986])_group_1_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "steady, low-angle tracking shot follows a poet dressed in Tang Dynasty attire as he journeys through a vast, mist-shrouded bamboo forest. The poet's face is thin and pensive, his long, dark hair held in a bun with a simple wooden hairpin. He wears an indigo silk round-necked robe, its wide sleeves swaying gently with his leisurely steps. His left hand gently grasps a scroll of yellowed bamboo slips, while his right hand occasionally strokes the emerald green bamboo stalks beside him, dappled with morning dew. The key light source comes from above, with beams of golden sunlight penetrating the dense bamboo canopy and milky mist, creating a distinct Tyndall effect. The poet and the ground, carpeted with wet fallen leaves, are dappled with shifting, interplay of light and dark. In the background, the overlapping, varying shades of bamboo shadows, looming through the mist, create a sense of infinite depth. The entire picture is dominated by the cool green of the bamboo forest and the soft white of the mist, illuminated by the warm sunlight, presenting a tranquil, ethereal and cinematic atmosphere full of oriental classical aesthetics.", + "seed": 21727, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000127/group_1/index_4986_seed_21727_dp_2_rank_4_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.04908434050157666, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04908434050157666, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.35, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04908434050157666, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a steady, low-angle tracking shot following the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a poet wearing Tang Dynasty attire with a thin, pensive face and long dark hair in a bun with a wooden hairpin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the poet wearing an indigo silk round-necked robe with wide sleeves, holding a scroll of yellowed bamboo slips in his left hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast, mist-shrouded bamboo forest with wet fallen leaves on the ground and golden sunlight beams creating a Tyndall effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the poet's right hand occasionally stroking the emerald green bamboo stalks beside him?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.09974534064531326 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.474745273590088 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.09974534064531326, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.09974534064531326, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09623032063245773, + 0.07226269692182541, + 0.0720740556716919, + 0.09967684745788574, + 0.2797646224498749, + 0.041166048496961594, + 0.06299968808889389, + 0.04361019656062126, + 0.03602449223399162, + 0.1961909532546997 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.09974534064531326 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a steady, low-angle tracking shot following the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a poet wearing Tang Dynasty attire with a thin, pensive face and long dark hair in a bun with a wooden hairpin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the poet wearing an indigo silk round-necked robe with wide sleeves, holding a scroll of yellowed bamboo slips in his left hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast, mist-shrouded bamboo forest with wet fallen leaves on the ground and golden sunlight beams creating a Tyndall effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the poet's right hand occasionally stroking the emerald green bamboo stalks beside him?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.043106675148010254 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1681065559387207 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.043106675148010254, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.043106675148010254, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07207129895687103, + 0.03765352442860603, + 0.04114673286676407, + 0.025010770186781883, + 0.10069004446268082, + 0.02486398257315159, + 0.07410451769828796, + 0.10256821662187576, + 0.02114628441631794, + 0.500744640827179 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.043106675148010254 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a steady, low-angle tracking shot following the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a poet wearing Tang Dynasty attire with a thin, pensive face and long dark hair in a bun with a wooden hairpin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the poet wearing an indigo silk round-necked robe with wide sleeves, holding a scroll of yellowed bamboo slips in his left hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast, mist-shrouded bamboo forest with wet fallen leaves on the ground and golden sunlight beams creating a Tyndall effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the poet's right hand occasionally stroking the emerald green bamboo stalks beside him?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04865841194987297 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486583709716797 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04865841194987297, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04865841194987297, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05105838552117348, + 0.037906598299741745, + 0.03921952471137047, + 0.04727737978100777, + 0.3136433959007263, + 0.049813222140073776, + 0.05464732646942139, + 0.029942883178591728, + 0.029772700741887093, + 0.34671860933303833 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04865841194987297 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a steady, low-angle tracking shot following the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a poet wearing Tang Dynasty attire with a thin, pensive face and long dark hair in a bun with a wooden hairpin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the poet wearing an indigo silk round-necked robe with wide sleeves, holding a scroll of yellowed bamboo slips in his left hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast, mist-shrouded bamboo forest with wet fallen leaves on the ground and golden sunlight beams creating a Tyndall effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the poet's right hand occasionally stroking the emerald green bamboo stalks beside him?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005253201816231012 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255253314971924 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005253201816231012, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005253201816231012, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06462551653385162, + 0.08415146172046661, + 0.2619738280773163, + 0.06082082912325859, + 0.11735687404870987, + 0.04841263219714165, + 0.056122489273548126, + 0.06593012064695358, + 0.03851880878210068, + 0.20208744704723358 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005253201816231012 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a steady, low-angle tracking shot following the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a poet wearing Tang Dynasty attire with a thin, pensive face and long dark hair in a bun with a wooden hairpin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the poet wearing an indigo silk round-necked robe with wide sleeves, holding a scroll of yellowed bamboo slips in his left hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast, mist-shrouded bamboo forest with wet fallen leaves on the ground and golden sunlight beams creating a Tyndall effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the poet's right hand occasionally stroking the emerald green bamboo stalks beside him?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04865807294845581 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486581325531006 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04865807294845581, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04865807294845581, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09934588521718979, + 0.04910522699356079, + 0.1271822303533554, + 0.07839760184288025, + 0.09110654145479202, + 0.3175964057445526, + 0.08678631484508514, + 0.03404928743839264, + 0.05469941720366478, + 0.061731111258268356 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04865807294845581 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "steady, low-angle tracking shot follows a poet dressed in Tang Dynasty attire as he journeys through a vast, mist-shrouded bamboo forest. The poet's face is thin and pensive, his long, dark hair held in a bun with a simple wooden hairpin. He wears an indigo silk round-necked robe, its wide sleeves swaying gently with his leisurely steps. His left hand gently grasps a scroll of yellowed bamboo slips, while his right hand occasionally strokes the emerald green bamboo stalks beside him, dappled with morning dew. The key light source comes from above, with beams of golden sunlight penetrating the dense bamboo canopy and milky mist, creating a distinct Tyndall effect. The poet and the ground, carpeted with wet fallen leaves, are dappled with shifting, interplay of light and dark. In the background, the overlapping, varying shades of bamboo shadows, looming through the mist, create a sense of infinite depth. The entire picture is dominated by the cool green of the bamboo forest and the soft white of the mist, illuminated by the warm sunlight, presenting a tranquil, ethereal and cinematic atmosphere full of oriental classical aesthetics.", + "seed": 21728, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000127/group_1/index_4986_seed_21728_dp_2_rank_4_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.06906993528828025, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06906993528828025, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.05, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06906993528828025, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a steady, low-angle tracking shot following the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a poet wearing Tang Dynasty attire with a thin, pensive face and long dark hair in a bun with a wooden hairpin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the poet wearing an indigo silk round-necked robe with wide sleeves, holding a scroll of yellowed bamboo slips in his left hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast, mist-shrouded bamboo forest with wet fallen leaves on the ground and golden sunlight beams creating a Tyndall effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the poet's right hand occasionally stroking the emerald green bamboo stalks beside him?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16752146184444427 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9175214767456055 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16752146184444427, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16752146184444427, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2133103460073471, + 0.0370248518884182, + 0.486214816570282, + 0.03316360339522362, + 0.03355872258543968, + 0.031188249588012695, + 0.018936660140752792, + 0.08866006135940552, + 0.024022601544857025, + 0.0339200459420681 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16752146184444427 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a steady, low-angle tracking shot following the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a poet wearing Tang Dynasty attire with a thin, pensive face and long dark hair in a bun with a wooden hairpin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the poet wearing an indigo silk round-necked robe with wide sleeves, holding a scroll of yellowed bamboo slips in his left hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast, mist-shrouded bamboo forest with wet fallen leaves on the ground and golden sunlight beams creating a Tyndall effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the poet's right hand occasionally stroking the emerald green bamboo stalks beside him?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03813023492693901 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288130283355713 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03813023492693901, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03813023492693901, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3414727747440338, + 0.08821026980876923, + 0.08169747143983841, + 0.07550034672021866, + 0.044356610625982285, + 0.025332553312182426, + 0.019342755898833275, + 0.1318320482969284, + 0.03667018935084343, + 0.155584916472435 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03813023492693901 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a steady, low-angle tracking shot following the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a poet wearing Tang Dynasty attire with a thin, pensive face and long dark hair in a bun with a wooden hairpin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the poet wearing an indigo silk round-necked robe with wide sleeves, holding a scroll of yellowed bamboo slips in his left hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast, mist-shrouded bamboo forest with wet fallen leaves on the ground and golden sunlight beams creating a Tyndall effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the poet's right hand occasionally stroking the emerald green bamboo stalks beside him?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.062043581157922745 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120436668395996 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.062043581157922745, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.062043581157922745, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1995135247707367, + 0.10953592509031296, + 0.06806445121765137, + 0.05370212346315384, + 0.08452972769737244, + 0.06545007228851318, + 0.021301820874214172, + 0.18824750185012817, + 0.1216663122177124, + 0.08798849582672119 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.062043581157922745 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a steady, low-angle tracking shot following the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a poet wearing Tang Dynasty attire with a thin, pensive face and long dark hair in a bun with a wooden hairpin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the poet wearing an indigo silk round-necked robe with wide sleeves, holding a scroll of yellowed bamboo slips in his left hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast, mist-shrouded bamboo forest with wet fallen leaves on the ground and golden sunlight beams creating a Tyndall effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the poet's right hand occasionally stroking the emerald green bamboo stalks beside him?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007630250882357359 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882630348205566 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007630250882357359, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007630250882357359, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5218990445137024, + 0.030001185834407806, + 0.04915224015712738, + 0.03546599671244621, + 0.050263527780771255, + 0.03321029618382454, + 0.01827569678425789, + 0.18401624262332916, + 0.047645699232816696, + 0.03007001429796219 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007630250882357359 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a steady, low-angle tracking shot following the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a poet wearing Tang Dynasty attire with a thin, pensive face and long dark hair in a bun with a wooden hairpin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the poet wearing an indigo silk round-necked robe with wide sleeves, holding a scroll of yellowed bamboo slips in his left hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast, mist-shrouded bamboo forest with wet fallen leaves on the ground and golden sunlight beams creating a Tyndall effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the poet's right hand occasionally stroking the emerald green bamboo stalks beside him?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07002414762973785 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695024251937866 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07002414762973785, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07002414762973785, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1503562480211258, + 0.0973031297326088, + 0.21707122027873993, + 0.1415184885263443, + 0.0353681780397892, + 0.06258337944746017, + 0.067112036049366, + 0.0773712694644928, + 0.07895094901323318, + 0.07236511260271072 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07002414762973785 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "steady, low-angle tracking shot follows a poet dressed in Tang Dynasty attire as he journeys through a vast, mist-shrouded bamboo forest. The poet's face is thin and pensive, his long, dark hair held in a bun with a simple wooden hairpin. He wears an indigo silk round-necked robe, its wide sleeves swaying gently with his leisurely steps. His left hand gently grasps a scroll of yellowed bamboo slips, while his right hand occasionally strokes the emerald green bamboo stalks beside him, dappled with morning dew. The key light source comes from above, with beams of golden sunlight penetrating the dense bamboo canopy and milky mist, creating a distinct Tyndall effect. The poet and the ground, carpeted with wet fallen leaves, are dappled with shifting, interplay of light and dark. In the background, the overlapping, varying shades of bamboo shadows, looming through the mist, create a sense of infinite depth. The entire picture is dominated by the cool green of the bamboo forest and the soft white of the mist, illuminated by the warm sunlight, presenting a tranquil, ethereal and cinematic atmosphere full of oriental classical aesthetics.", + "seed": 21729, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000127/group_1/index_4986_seed_21729_dp_3_rank_6_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.046817550295963885, + "vlm_logprob": -0.046817550295963885, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.425, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.046817550295963885, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a steady, low-angle tracking shot following the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a poet wearing Tang Dynasty attire with a thin, pensive face and long dark hair in a bun with a wooden hairpin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the poet wearing an indigo silk round-necked robe with wide sleeves, holding a scroll of yellowed bamboo slips in his left hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast, mist-shrouded bamboo forest with wet fallen leaves on the ground and golden sunlight beams creating a Tyndall effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the poet's right hand occasionally stroking the emerald green bamboo stalks beside him?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05530334636569023 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0553033351898193 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05530334636569023, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05530334636569023, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12757839262485504, + 0.10520560294389725, + 0.08590089529752731, + 0.15229853987693787, + 0.060855746269226074, + 0.04553946852684021, + 0.08352631330490112, + 0.04731385037302971, + 0.05529504641890526, + 0.23648610711097717 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05530334636569023 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a steady, low-angle tracking shot following the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a poet wearing Tang Dynasty attire with a thin, pensive face and long dark hair in a bun with a wooden hairpin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the poet wearing an indigo silk round-necked robe with wide sleeves, holding a scroll of yellowed bamboo slips in his left hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast, mist-shrouded bamboo forest with wet fallen leaves on the ground and golden sunlight beams creating a Tyndall effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the poet's right hand occasionally stroking the emerald green bamboo stalks beside him?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04309377446770668 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168093681335449 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04309377446770668, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04309377446770668, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1467444896697998, + 0.17831206321716309, + 0.09952536970376968, + 0.18811015784740448, + 0.05279765650629997, + 0.0700768381357193, + 0.09889904409646988, + 0.05113247409462929, + 0.036921530961990356, + 0.07748035341501236 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04309377446770668 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a steady, low-angle tracking shot following the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a poet wearing Tang Dynasty attire with a thin, pensive face and long dark hair in a bun with a wooden hairpin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the poet wearing an indigo silk round-necked robe with wide sleeves, holding a scroll of yellowed bamboo slips in his left hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast, mist-shrouded bamboo forest with wet fallen leaves on the ground and golden sunlight beams creating a Tyndall effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the poet's right hand occasionally stroking the emerald green bamboo stalks beside him?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06204705312848091 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812047004699707 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06204705312848091, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06204705312848091, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15605086088180542, + 0.14575208723545074, + 0.11564464122056961, + 0.14690126478672028, + 0.04598613828420639, + 0.06960265338420868, + 0.15630830824375153, + 0.05833493173122406, + 0.05415049195289612, + 0.051268696784973145 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06204705312848091 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a steady, low-angle tracking shot following the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a poet wearing Tang Dynasty attire with a thin, pensive face and long dark hair in a bun with a wooden hairpin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the poet wearing an indigo silk round-necked robe with wide sleeves, holding a scroll of yellowed bamboo slips in his left hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast, mist-shrouded bamboo forest with wet fallen leaves on the ground and golden sunlight beams creating a Tyndall effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the poet's right hand occasionally stroking the emerald green bamboo stalks beside him?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036176491994410753 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628617763519287 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036176491994410753, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036176491994410753, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10523468255996704, + 0.06133611872792244, + 0.19251152873039246, + 0.24332144856452942, + 0.058683086186647415, + 0.02817509137094021, + 0.07810480892658234, + 0.021251019090414047, + 0.05086586996912956, + 0.16051632165908813 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036176491994410753 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a steady, low-angle tracking shot following the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a poet wearing Tang Dynasty attire with a thin, pensive face and long dark hair in a bun with a wooden hairpin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the poet wearing an indigo silk round-necked robe with wide sleeves, holding a scroll of yellowed bamboo slips in his left hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast, mist-shrouded bamboo forest with wet fallen leaves on the ground and golden sunlight beams creating a Tyndall effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the poet's right hand occasionally stroking the emerald green bamboo stalks beside him?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07002592831850052 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.69502592086792 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07002592831850052, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07002592831850052, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05733668431639671, + 0.0884120985865593, + 0.21229395270347595, + 0.25621581077575684, + 0.025754043832421303, + 0.08992861211299896, + 0.0920812115073204, + 0.07544814050197601, + 0.060396354645490646, + 0.04213310033082962 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07002592831850052 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "steady, low-angle tracking shot follows a poet dressed in Tang Dynasty attire as he journeys through a vast, mist-shrouded bamboo forest. The poet's face is thin and pensive, his long, dark hair held in a bun with a simple wooden hairpin. He wears an indigo silk round-necked robe, its wide sleeves swaying gently with his leisurely steps. His left hand gently grasps a scroll of yellowed bamboo slips, while his right hand occasionally strokes the emerald green bamboo stalks beside him, dappled with morning dew. The key light source comes from above, with beams of golden sunlight penetrating the dense bamboo canopy and milky mist, creating a distinct Tyndall effect. The poet and the ground, carpeted with wet fallen leaves, are dappled with shifting, interplay of light and dark. In the background, the overlapping, varying shades of bamboo shadows, looming through the mist, create a sense of infinite depth. The entire picture is dominated by the cool green of the bamboo forest and the soft white of the mist, illuminated by the warm sunlight, presenting a tranquil, ethereal and cinematic atmosphere full of oriental classical aesthetics.", + "seed": 21730, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000127/group_1/index_4986_seed_21730_dp_3_rank_6_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.06607763078063726, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06607763078063726, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.075, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06607763078063726, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a steady, low-angle tracking shot following the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a poet wearing Tang Dynasty attire with a thin, pensive face and long dark hair in a bun with a wooden hairpin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the poet wearing an indigo silk round-necked robe with wide sleeves, holding a scroll of yellowed bamboo slips in his left hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast, mist-shrouded bamboo forest with wet fallen leaves on the ground and golden sunlight beams creating a Tyndall effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the poet's right hand occasionally stroking the emerald green bamboo stalks beside him?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14046718180179596 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1404671669006348 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14046718180179596, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14046718180179596, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3685045838356018, + 0.12402496486902237, + 0.057824693620204926, + 0.0974355936050415, + 0.08945760130882263, + 0.04193864017724991, + 0.08319354802370071, + 0.06558167934417725, + 0.040865037590265274, + 0.031173638999462128 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14046718180179596 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a steady, low-angle tracking shot following the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a poet wearing Tang Dynasty attire with a thin, pensive face and long dark hair in a bun with a wooden hairpin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the poet wearing an indigo silk round-necked robe with wide sleeves, holding a scroll of yellowed bamboo slips in his left hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast, mist-shrouded bamboo forest with wet fallen leaves on the ground and golden sunlight beams creating a Tyndall effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the poet's right hand occasionally stroking the emerald green bamboo stalks beside him?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07008005678653717 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695080041885376 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07008005678653717, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07008005678653717, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18714524805545807, + 0.1728597730398178, + 0.18338041007518768, + 0.11627887934446335, + 0.04138679429888725, + 0.03989492356777191, + 0.07111936062574387, + 0.06856588274240494, + 0.08574240654706955, + 0.03362634405493736 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07008005678653717 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a steady, low-angle tracking shot following the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a poet wearing Tang Dynasty attire with a thin, pensive face and long dark hair in a bun with a wooden hairpin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the poet wearing an indigo silk round-necked robe with wide sleeves, holding a scroll of yellowed bamboo slips in his left hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast, mist-shrouded bamboo forest with wet fallen leaves on the ground and golden sunlight beams creating a Tyndall effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the poet's right hand occasionally stroking the emerald green bamboo stalks beside him?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07003092765808105 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695030927658081 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07003092765808105, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07003092765808105, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15223388373851776, + 0.17342959344387054, + 0.1539837270975113, + 0.10872210562229156, + 0.06389279663562775, + 0.04012017697095871, + 0.07193361222743988, + 0.0981428474187851, + 0.0959148183465004, + 0.04162637144327164 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07003092765808105 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a steady, low-angle tracking shot following the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a poet wearing Tang Dynasty attire with a thin, pensive face and long dark hair in a bun with a wooden hairpin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the poet wearing an indigo silk round-necked robe with wide sleeves, holding a scroll of yellowed bamboo slips in his left hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast, mist-shrouded bamboo forest with wet fallen leaves on the ground and golden sunlight beams creating a Tyndall effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the poet's right hand occasionally stroking the emerald green bamboo stalks beside him?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006739622913300991 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006739616394043 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006739622913300991, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006739622913300991, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5402005314826965, + 0.08859771490097046, + 0.06866322457790375, + 0.03588532283902168, + 0.07505786418914795, + 0.036521945148706436, + 0.040329642593860626, + 0.058197006583213806, + 0.02309512533247471, + 0.033451639115810394 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006739622913300991 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a steady, low-angle tracking shot following the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a poet wearing Tang Dynasty attire with a thin, pensive face and long dark hair in a bun with a wooden hairpin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the poet wearing an indigo silk round-necked robe with wide sleeves, holding a scroll of yellowed bamboo slips in his left hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast, mist-shrouded bamboo forest with wet fallen leaves on the ground and golden sunlight beams creating a Tyndall effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the poet's right hand occasionally stroking the emerald green bamboo stalks beside him?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.043070364743471146 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680703163146973 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.043070364743471146, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.043070364743471146, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11813270300626755, + 0.31572225689888, + 0.07186326384544373, + 0.10193685442209244, + 0.1797175109386444, + 0.056674644351005554, + 0.05235689878463745, + 0.02946750447154045, + 0.03404392674565315, + 0.040084417909383774 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.043070364743471146 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000127/group_11/index_tensor([472, 472])_group_11_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000127/group_11/index_tensor([472, 472])_group_11_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..9ce914f951f3b7faca305fd9f707ab1cd9fd844c --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000127/group_11/index_tensor([472, 472])_group_11_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "Rendered in hyperrealistic 3D animation, the film captures the intense culinary transformation in dramatic slow motion, with extreme close-up shots. The static camera focuses on a perfectly spherical drop of golden amber seasoning oil. As it descends to the scorching cast-iron grill below, its surface shimmers, revealing tiny flecks of suspended black vanilla. The grill's surface is a rough, matte-black metal landscape, its raised ribs a menacing cherry red from the intense heat. Visible, shimmering waves of heat radiate upward from the metal, distorting the air and creating a tangible sensation of intense heat. When the drop makes contact in exquisite slow motion, it vaporizes and evaporates instantly upon impact. Instead of exploding into a gentle puff of smoke, it forms a dramatic, billowing column of dense white smoke that expands violently upward and outward, swirling and churning in complex turbulent patterns. The entire scene is illuminated from below by incandescent metal, casting a powerful, warm glow that accentuates the translucent quality of the falling drop and the voluminous textures of the smoke, creating a visceral and powerful atmosphere of focused, elemental transformation.", + "seed": 29700, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000127/group_11/index_472_seed_29700_dp_22_rank_44_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.07688054740428925, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07688054740428925, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.025, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07688054740428925, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a perfectly spherical drop of golden amber seasoning oil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a rough, matte-black cast-iron grill with raised ribs glowing cherry red?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the oil drop contain visible tiny flecks of suspended black vanilla?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the oil drop vaporize instantly upon impact to form a dense, billowing column of white smoke with turbulent patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated from below by incandescent metal, casting a warm glow on the drop and smoke?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03502350673079491 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4100234508514404 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03502350673079491, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03502350673079491, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11947516351938248, + 0.08948009461164474, + 0.08244823664426804, + 0.08639352023601532, + 0.10331833362579346, + 0.0996745228767395, + 0.034476976841688156, + 0.07821710407733917, + 0.1687011420726776, + 0.13781492412090302 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03502350673079491 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a perfectly spherical drop of golden amber seasoning oil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a rough, matte-black cast-iron grill with raised ribs glowing cherry red?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the oil drop contain visible tiny flecks of suspended black vanilla?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the oil drop vaporize instantly upon impact to form a dense, billowing column of white smoke with turbulent patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated from below by incandescent metal, casting a warm glow on the drop and smoke?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03371204808354378 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408712148666382 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03371204808354378, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03371204808354378, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25874871015548706, + 0.08763520419597626, + 0.10398714989423752, + 0.05240103229880333, + 0.04518292844295502, + 0.07742428779602051, + 0.05291158705949783, + 0.12481361627578735, + 0.12589296698570251, + 0.07100248336791992 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03371204808354378 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a perfectly spherical drop of golden amber seasoning oil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a rough, matte-black cast-iron grill with raised ribs glowing cherry red?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the oil drop contain visible tiny flecks of suspended black vanilla?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the oil drop vaporize instantly upon impact to form a dense, billowing column of white smoke with turbulent patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated from below by incandescent metal, casting a warm glow on the drop and smoke?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2255944460630417 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.600594401359558 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2255944460630417, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2255944460630417, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1886078268289566, + 0.08326909691095352, + 0.06741073727607727, + 0.02734500728547573, + 0.05148262903094292, + 0.0993850827217102, + 0.08552130311727524, + 0.061957795172929764, + 0.2105698138475418, + 0.12445075064897537 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2255944460630417 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a perfectly spherical drop of golden amber seasoning oil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a rough, matte-black cast-iron grill with raised ribs glowing cherry red?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the oil drop contain visible tiny flecks of suspended black vanilla?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the oil drop vaporize instantly upon impact to form a dense, billowing column of white smoke with turbulent patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated from below by incandescent metal, casting a warm glow on the drop and smoke?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011075802147388458 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511075973510742 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011075802147388458, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011075802147388458, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06269647926092148, + 0.056224290281534195, + 0.044464949518442154, + 0.0237735528498888, + 0.044138792902231216, + 0.06433232128620148, + 0.08004576712846756, + 0.12260138988494873, + 0.21305431425571442, + 0.288668155670166 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011075802147388458 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a perfectly spherical drop of golden amber seasoning oil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a rough, matte-black cast-iron grill with raised ribs glowing cherry red?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the oil drop contain visible tiny flecks of suspended black vanilla?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the oil drop vaporize instantly upon impact to form a dense, billowing column of white smoke with turbulent patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated from below by incandescent metal, casting a warm glow on the drop and smoke?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0789969339966774 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5789968967437744 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0789969339966774, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0789969339966774, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.29568392038345337, + 0.0982477068901062, + 0.0682501271367073, + 0.04279366135597229, + 0.07826980948448181, + 0.059345029294490814, + 0.0653928816318512, + 0.06165482848882675, + 0.10613695532083511, + 0.12422508746385574 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0789969339966774 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "Rendered in hyperrealistic 3D animation, the film captures the intense culinary transformation in dramatic slow motion, with extreme close-up shots. The static camera focuses on a perfectly spherical drop of golden amber seasoning oil. As it descends to the scorching cast-iron grill below, its surface shimmers, revealing tiny flecks of suspended black vanilla. The grill's surface is a rough, matte-black metal landscape, its raised ribs a menacing cherry red from the intense heat. Visible, shimmering waves of heat radiate upward from the metal, distorting the air and creating a tangible sensation of intense heat. When the drop makes contact in exquisite slow motion, it vaporizes and evaporates instantly upon impact. Instead of exploding into a gentle puff of smoke, it forms a dramatic, billowing column of dense white smoke that expands violently upward and outward, swirling and churning in complex turbulent patterns. The entire scene is illuminated from below by incandescent metal, casting a powerful, warm glow that accentuates the translucent quality of the falling drop and the voluminous textures of the smoke, creating a visceral and powerful atmosphere of focused, elemental transformation.", + "seed": 29701, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000127/group_11/index_472_seed_29701_dp_22_rank_44_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.259371742233634, + "vlm_logprob": -0.259371742233634, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.475, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.259371742233634, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a perfectly spherical drop of golden amber seasoning oil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a rough, matte-black cast-iron grill with raised ribs glowing cherry red?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the oil drop contain visible tiny flecks of suspended black vanilla?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the oil drop vaporize instantly upon impact to form a dense, billowing column of white smoke with turbulent patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated from below by incandescent metal, casting a warm glow on the drop and smoke?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5785761475563049 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8285761475563049 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5785761475563049, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5785761475563049, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.7293781638145447, + 0.05760672315955162, + 0.028521252796053886, + 0.02827429585158825, + 0.04885786026716232, + 0.02039976604282856, + 0.014665786176919937, + 0.02014554664492607, + 0.03725627437233925, + 0.014894326217472553 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5785761475563049 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a perfectly spherical drop of golden amber seasoning oil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a rough, matte-black cast-iron grill with raised ribs glowing cherry red?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the oil drop contain visible tiny flecks of suspended black vanilla?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the oil drop vaporize instantly upon impact to form a dense, billowing column of white smoke with turbulent patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated from below by incandescent metal, casting a warm glow on the drop and smoke?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026363378390669823 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513633728027344 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026363378390669823, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026363378390669823, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.7601587772369385, + 0.034192994236946106, + 0.03146304562687874, + 0.016012806445360184, + 0.026864763349294662, + 0.02582603320479393, + 0.019645487889647484, + 0.03488520160317421, + 0.04440741240978241, + 0.0065435124561190605 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026363378390669823 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a perfectly spherical drop of golden amber seasoning oil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a rough, matte-black cast-iron grill with raised ribs glowing cherry red?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the oil drop contain visible tiny flecks of suspended black vanilla?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the oil drop vaporize instantly upon impact to form a dense, billowing column of white smoke with turbulent patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated from below by incandescent metal, casting a warm glow on the drop and smoke?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6328439712524414 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7578439712524414 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.6328439712524414, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.6328439712524414, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21841269731521606, + 0.3624092936515808, + 0.048404548317193985, + 0.024297984316945076, + 0.05811251699924469, + 0.051202502101659775, + 0.055715616792440414, + 0.06662281602621078, + 0.08185315132141113, + 0.032968875020742416 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.6328439712524414 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a perfectly spherical drop of golden amber seasoning oil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a rough, matte-black cast-iron grill with raised ribs glowing cherry red?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the oil drop contain visible tiny flecks of suspended black vanilla?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the oil drop vaporize instantly upon impact to form a dense, billowing column of white smoke with turbulent patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated from below by incandescent metal, casting a warm glow on the drop and smoke?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004100605845451355 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504100799560547 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004100605845451355, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004100605845451355, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.6566903591156006, + 0.03097211942076683, + 0.04309196025133133, + 0.06670449674129486, + 0.0577719621360302, + 0.015335715375840664, + 0.027310645207762718, + 0.01452162116765976, + 0.03921588137745857, + 0.04838523641228676 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004100605845451355 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a perfectly spherical drop of golden amber seasoning oil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a rough, matte-black cast-iron grill with raised ribs glowing cherry red?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the oil drop contain visible tiny flecks of suspended black vanilla?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the oil drop vaporize instantly upon impact to form a dense, billowing column of white smoke with turbulent patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated from below by incandescent metal, casting a warm glow on the drop and smoke?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05497460812330246 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299745559692383 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05497460812330246, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05497460812330246, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5304371118545532, + 0.13046421110630035, + 0.032384242862463, + 0.033880237489938736, + 0.025770917534828186, + 0.0518222376704216, + 0.04671540856361389, + 0.058182574808597565, + 0.04862179234623909, + 0.04172118753194809 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05497460812330246 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "Rendered in hyperrealistic 3D animation, the film captures the intense culinary transformation in dramatic slow motion, with extreme close-up shots. The static camera focuses on a perfectly spherical drop of golden amber seasoning oil. As it descends to the scorching cast-iron grill below, its surface shimmers, revealing tiny flecks of suspended black vanilla. The grill's surface is a rough, matte-black metal landscape, its raised ribs a menacing cherry red from the intense heat. Visible, shimmering waves of heat radiate upward from the metal, distorting the air and creating a tangible sensation of intense heat. When the drop makes contact in exquisite slow motion, it vaporizes and evaporates instantly upon impact. Instead of exploding into a gentle puff of smoke, it forms a dramatic, billowing column of dense white smoke that expands violently upward and outward, swirling and churning in complex turbulent patterns. The entire scene is illuminated from below by incandescent metal, casting a powerful, warm glow that accentuates the translucent quality of the falling drop and the voluminous textures of the smoke, creating a visceral and powerful atmosphere of focused, elemental transformation.", + "seed": 29702, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000127/group_11/index_472_seed_29702_dp_23_rank_46_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.16676654489710926, + "vlm_logprob": -0.16676654489710926, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.525, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.16676654489710926, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a perfectly spherical drop of golden amber seasoning oil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a rough, matte-black cast-iron grill with raised ribs glowing cherry red?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the oil drop contain visible tiny flecks of suspended black vanilla?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the oil drop vaporize instantly upon impact to form a dense, billowing column of white smoke with turbulent patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated from below by incandescent metal, casting a warm glow on the drop and smoke?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.35276681184768677 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.227766752243042 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.35276681184768677, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.8749999403953552, + "token_credit_reward": -0.35276681184768677, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09349241852760315, + 0.6404224634170532, + 0.06737954914569855, + 0.030883245170116425, + 0.029857171699404716, + 0.02199365571141243, + 0.030025290325284004, + 0.026661671698093414, + 0.013337187469005585, + 0.0459473580121994 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.35276681184768677 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a perfectly spherical drop of golden amber seasoning oil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a rough, matte-black cast-iron grill with raised ribs glowing cherry red?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the oil drop contain visible tiny flecks of suspended black vanilla?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the oil drop vaporize instantly upon impact to form a dense, billowing column of white smoke with turbulent patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated from below by incandescent metal, casting a warm glow on the drop and smoke?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0890434980392456 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.464043617248535 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0890434980392456, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0890434980392456, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08633674681186676, + 0.6297282576560974, + 0.026994170621037483, + 0.1784447580575943, + 0.008251568302512169, + 0.007909883745014668, + 0.012010406702756882, + 0.014424031600356102, + 0.008826599456369877, + 0.027073614299297333 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0890434980392456 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a perfectly spherical drop of golden amber seasoning oil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a rough, matte-black cast-iron grill with raised ribs glowing cherry red?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the oil drop contain visible tiny flecks of suspended black vanilla?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the oil drop vaporize instantly upon impact to form a dense, billowing column of white smoke with turbulent patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated from below by incandescent metal, casting a warm glow on the drop and smoke?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3486611247062683 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.223661184310913 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3486611247062683, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.8750000596046448, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3486611247062683, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05359887331724167, + 0.7717487215995789, + 0.018792739138007164, + 0.05821751803159714, + 0.0091610848903656, + 0.0077200960367918015, + 0.01257420890033245, + 0.00837578997015953, + 0.01414490770548582, + 0.04566609486937523 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3486611247062683 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a perfectly spherical drop of golden amber seasoning oil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a rough, matte-black cast-iron grill with raised ribs glowing cherry red?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the oil drop contain visible tiny flecks of suspended black vanilla?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the oil drop vaporize instantly upon impact to form a dense, billowing column of white smoke with turbulent patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated from below by incandescent metal, casting a warm glow on the drop and smoke?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0052567594684660435 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255256652832031 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0052567594684660435, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0052567594684660435, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07311028242111206, + 0.4271545112133026, + 0.015569884330034256, + 0.1372000128030777, + 0.027358684688806534, + 0.01338562648743391, + 0.036129485815763474, + 0.07246311008930206, + 0.043426983058452606, + 0.1542014628648758 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0052567594684660435 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a perfectly spherical drop of golden amber seasoning oil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a rough, matte-black cast-iron grill with raised ribs glowing cherry red?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the oil drop contain visible tiny flecks of suspended black vanilla?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the oil drop vaporize instantly upon impact to form a dense, billowing column of white smoke with turbulent patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated from below by incandescent metal, casting a warm glow on the drop and smoke?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03810453042387962 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.28810453414917 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03810453042387962, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03810453042387962, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04900045320391655, + 0.6978023648262024, + 0.03151746466755867, + 0.09250399470329285, + 0.028614403679966927, + 0.008667672984302044, + 0.010211549699306488, + 0.01884227618575096, + 0.017028314992785454, + 0.04581141844391823 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03810453042387962 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "Rendered in hyperrealistic 3D animation, the film captures the intense culinary transformation in dramatic slow motion, with extreme close-up shots. The static camera focuses on a perfectly spherical drop of golden amber seasoning oil. As it descends to the scorching cast-iron grill below, its surface shimmers, revealing tiny flecks of suspended black vanilla. The grill's surface is a rough, matte-black metal landscape, its raised ribs a menacing cherry red from the intense heat. Visible, shimmering waves of heat radiate upward from the metal, distorting the air and creating a tangible sensation of intense heat. When the drop makes contact in exquisite slow motion, it vaporizes and evaporates instantly upon impact. Instead of exploding into a gentle puff of smoke, it forms a dramatic, billowing column of dense white smoke that expands violently upward and outward, swirling and churning in complex turbulent patterns. The entire scene is illuminated from below by incandescent metal, casting a powerful, warm glow that accentuates the translucent quality of the falling drop and the voluminous textures of the smoke, creating a visceral and powerful atmosphere of focused, elemental transformation.", + "seed": 29703, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000127/group_11/index_472_seed_29703_dp_23_rank_46_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.2140969641506672, + "vlm_logprob": -0.2140969641506672, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.85, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.2140969641506672, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a perfectly spherical drop of golden amber seasoning oil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a rough, matte-black cast-iron grill with raised ribs glowing cherry red?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the oil drop contain visible tiny flecks of suspended black vanilla?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the oil drop vaporize instantly upon impact to form a dense, billowing column of white smoke with turbulent patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated from below by incandescent metal, casting a warm glow on the drop and smoke?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12008900940418243 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.245089054107666 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12008900940418243, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12008900940418243, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0722673237323761, + 0.11482331156730652, + 0.04779179021716118, + 0.07281354814767838, + 0.0569348968565464, + 0.2625574767589569, + 0.14687146246433258, + 0.08777498453855515, + 0.060402464121580124, + 0.07776274532079697 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12008900940418243 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a perfectly spherical drop of golden amber seasoning oil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a rough, matte-black cast-iron grill with raised ribs glowing cherry red?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the oil drop contain visible tiny flecks of suspended black vanilla?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the oil drop vaporize instantly upon impact to form a dense, billowing column of white smoke with turbulent patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated from below by incandescent metal, casting a warm glow on the drop and smoke?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0790005698800087 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.579000473022461 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0790005698800087, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0790005698800087, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09615031629800797, + 0.09960154443979263, + 0.2462044358253479, + 0.07902530580759048, + 0.11317980289459229, + 0.09024813026189804, + 0.07863879948854446, + 0.07309678196907043, + 0.04926677793264389, + 0.07458814233541489 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0790005698800087 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a perfectly spherical drop of golden amber seasoning oil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a rough, matte-black cast-iron grill with raised ribs glowing cherry red?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the oil drop contain visible tiny flecks of suspended black vanilla?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the oil drop vaporize instantly upon impact to form a dense, billowing column of white smoke with turbulent patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated from below by incandescent metal, casting a warm glow on the drop and smoke?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5761759281158447 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8261759281158447 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5761759281158447, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5761759281158447, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08810600638389587, + 0.09786684066057205, + 0.20365279912948608, + 0.19158554077148438, + 0.05862126499414444, + 0.0556512214243412, + 0.0462600514292717, + 0.09856594353914261, + 0.0999150201678276, + 0.059775304049253464 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5761759281158447 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a perfectly spherical drop of golden amber seasoning oil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a rough, matte-black cast-iron grill with raised ribs glowing cherry red?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the oil drop contain visible tiny flecks of suspended black vanilla?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the oil drop vaporize instantly upon impact to form a dense, billowing column of white smoke with turbulent patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated from below by incandescent metal, casting a warm glow on the drop and smoke?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.25213250517845154 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.502132534980774 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.25213250517845154, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.25213250517845154, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.055322274565696716, + 0.06239257752895355, + 0.14864110946655273, + 0.030946828424930573, + 0.03367651253938675, + 0.09718522429466248, + 0.20848064124584198, + 0.2134854793548584, + 0.04679671674966812, + 0.1030726358294487 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.25213250517845154 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a perfectly spherical drop of golden amber seasoning oil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a rough, matte-black cast-iron grill with raised ribs glowing cherry red?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the oil drop contain visible tiny flecks of suspended black vanilla?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the oil drop vaporize instantly upon impact to form a dense, billowing column of white smoke with turbulent patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated from below by incandescent metal, casting a warm glow on the drop and smoke?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.043086808174848557 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680867671966553 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.043086808174848557, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.043086808174848557, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06193481385707855, + 0.06453550606966019, + 0.18730446696281433, + 0.22257936000823975, + 0.04076677933335304, + 0.15889586508274078, + 0.06421559303998947, + 0.08046473562717438, + 0.04407443106174469, + 0.07522837817668915 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.043086808174848557 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000127/group_12/index_tensor([2627, 2627])_group_12_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000127/group_12/index_tensor([2627, 2627])_group_12_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..8ecc7503061c869437f2959b1a4b8db6ca70d85a --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000127/group_12/index_tensor([2627, 2627])_group_12_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "static, high-angle close-up captures a pristine, paper-thin sheet of ice nestled against a dark, damp landscape. The ice's surface, almost completely transparent, reveals the granular texture of the soil and a few trapped microscopic air bubbles beneath. In the cool, low-angle morning light, the ice shimmers and sparkles. The scene begins in absolute silence, a fragile moment of perfection. Then, driven by an unseen vibration, a thin crack appears silently and swiftly, bursting out from one side. This initial crack immediately spiders outward, spreading a complex network of interconnected fractures across the surface in a silent, explosive manner. The once-solid sheet shatters into dozens of jagged, geometric sections. These sections, as their momentum runs out, delicately shift and stabilize with a final, tiny crunch, settling into new positions on the exposed ground. Their freshly shattered edges catch the light, glittering like broken glass and creating a quietly beautiful atmosphere of destruction.", + "seed": 16082, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000127/group_12/index_2627_seed_16082_dp_24_rank_48_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.05564524135552347, + "vlm_logprob": -0.05564524135552347, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.025, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.05564524135552347, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, high-angle close-up of a paper-thin sheet of ice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the ice surface almost completely transparent, revealing granular soil texture and trapped air bubbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature cool, low-angle morning light causing the ice to shimmer and sparkle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a thin crack appear silently and swiftly, spreading outward to shatter the ice into dozens of jagged geometric sections?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the shattered ice sections shift and stabilize on the ground with glittering edges that catch the light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22769992053508759 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.602699875831604 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.22769992053508759, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.22769992053508759, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0792013630270958, + 0.10827380418777466, + 0.33588606119155884, + 0.03002318926155567, + 0.023196138441562653, + 0.10629173368215561, + 0.15711601078510284, + 0.07000595331192017, + 0.061267171055078506, + 0.02873862348496914 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.22769992053508759 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, high-angle close-up of a paper-thin sheet of ice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the ice surface almost completely transparent, revealing granular soil texture and trapped air bubbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature cool, low-angle morning light causing the ice to shimmer and sparkle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a thin crack appear silently and swiftly, spreading outward to shatter the ice into dozens of jagged geometric sections?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the shattered ice sections shift and stabilize on the ground with glittering edges that catch the light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01111918780952692 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511119365692139 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01111918780952692, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01111918780952692, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09684392809867859, + 0.14876101911067963, + 0.16718493402004242, + 0.0396336130797863, + 0.06764901429414749, + 0.03877212852239609, + 0.2945479154586792, + 0.043105002492666245, + 0.07619921863079071, + 0.027303235605359077 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01111918780952692 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, high-angle close-up of a paper-thin sheet of ice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the ice surface almost completely transparent, revealing granular soil texture and trapped air bubbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature cool, low-angle morning light causing the ice to shimmer and sparkle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a thin crack appear silently and swiftly, spreading outward to shatter the ice into dozens of jagged geometric sections?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the shattered ice sections shift and stabilize on the ground with glittering edges that catch the light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029837198555469513 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529837131500244 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029837198555469513, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029837198555469513, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19813193380832672, + 0.27651551365852356, + 0.09994233399629593, + 0.04730599373579025, + 0.05554305016994476, + 0.04631657153367996, + 0.14926353096961975, + 0.042172640562057495, + 0.049963872879743576, + 0.034844525158405304 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029837198555469513 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, high-angle close-up of a paper-thin sheet of ice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the ice surface almost completely transparent, revealing granular soil texture and trapped air bubbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature cool, low-angle morning light causing the ice to shimmer and sparkle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a thin crack appear silently and swiftly, spreading outward to shatter the ice into dozens of jagged geometric sections?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the shattered ice sections shift and stabilize on the ground with glittering edges that catch the light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005952606908977032 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130952835083008 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005952606908977032, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005952606908977032, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16267284750938416, + 0.06965164095163345, + 0.1130092591047287, + 0.07780799269676208, + 0.18804536759853363, + 0.02038917876780033, + 0.1854148507118225, + 0.03209643438458443, + 0.09137261658906937, + 0.059539780020713806 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005952606908977032 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, high-angle close-up of a paper-thin sheet of ice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the ice surface almost completely transparent, revealing granular soil texture and trapped air bubbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature cool, low-angle morning light causing the ice to shimmer and sparkle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a thin crack appear silently and swiftly, spreading outward to shatter the ice into dozens of jagged geometric sections?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the shattered ice sections shift and stabilize on the ground with glittering edges that catch the light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003617292968556285 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628617286682129 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003617292968556285, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003617292968556285, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.211958110332489, + 0.1469133496284485, + 0.14648233354091644, + 0.0826420933008194, + 0.04788890853524208, + 0.06235058605670929, + 0.11529801040887833, + 0.04881630837917328, + 0.08695186674594879, + 0.0506984181702137 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003617292968556285 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, high-angle close-up captures a pristine, paper-thin sheet of ice nestled against a dark, damp landscape. The ice's surface, almost completely transparent, reveals the granular texture of the soil and a few trapped microscopic air bubbles beneath. In the cool, low-angle morning light, the ice shimmers and sparkles. The scene begins in absolute silence, a fragile moment of perfection. Then, driven by an unseen vibration, a thin crack appears silently and swiftly, bursting out from one side. This initial crack immediately spiders outward, spreading a complex network of interconnected fractures across the surface in a silent, explosive manner. The once-solid sheet shatters into dozens of jagged, geometric sections. These sections, as their momentum runs out, delicately shift and stabilize with a final, tiny crunch, settling into new positions on the exposed ground. Their freshly shattered edges catch the light, glittering like broken glass and creating a quietly beautiful atmosphere of destruction.", + "seed": 16083, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000127/group_12/index_2627_seed_16083_dp_24_rank_48_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.058333041099831465, + "vlm_logprob": -0.058333041099831465, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.825, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.058333041099831465, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, high-angle close-up of a paper-thin sheet of ice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the ice surface almost completely transparent, revealing granular soil texture and trapped air bubbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature cool, low-angle morning light causing the ice to shimmer and sparkle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a thin crack appear silently and swiftly, spreading outward to shatter the ice into dozens of jagged geometric sections?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the shattered ice sections shift and stabilize on the ground with glittering edges that catch the light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22794899344444275 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6029490232467651 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.22794899344444275, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.22794899344444275, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06558441370725632, + 0.04421897605061531, + 0.11700333654880524, + 0.01885010488331318, + 0.05784374475479126, + 0.638295590877533, + 0.02111854776740074, + 0.0068111727014184, + 0.009112435393035412, + 0.021161777898669243 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.22794899344444275 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, high-angle close-up of a paper-thin sheet of ice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the ice surface almost completely transparent, revealing granular soil texture and trapped air bubbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature cool, low-angle morning light causing the ice to shimmer and sparkle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a thin crack appear silently and swiftly, spreading outward to shatter the ice into dozens of jagged geometric sections?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the shattered ice sections shift and stabilize on the ground with glittering edges that catch the light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012584325857460499 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387584209442139 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012584325857460499, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012584325857460499, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04420808330178261, + 0.06090610846877098, + 0.07307162135839462, + 0.038058266043663025, + 0.029361853376030922, + 0.6677234172821045, + 0.02535584568977356, + 0.016837049275636673, + 0.01861538365483284, + 0.025862334296107292 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012584325857460499 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, high-angle close-up of a paper-thin sheet of ice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the ice surface almost completely transparent, revealing granular soil texture and trapped air bubbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature cool, low-angle morning light causing the ice to shimmer and sparkle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a thin crack appear silently and swiftly, spreading outward to shatter the ice into dozens of jagged geometric sections?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the shattered ice sections shift and stabilize on the ground with glittering edges that catch the light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.033735789358615875 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408735752105713 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.033735789358615875, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.033735789358615875, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.26102685928344727, + 0.029679687693715096, + 0.07738091051578522, + 0.021488741040229797, + 0.04010602459311485, + 0.5063341856002808, + 0.02246149256825447, + 0.01076099369674921, + 0.008901157416403294, + 0.021859880536794662 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.033735789358615875 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, high-angle close-up of a paper-thin sheet of ice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the ice surface almost completely transparent, revealing granular soil texture and trapped air bubbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature cool, low-angle morning light causing the ice to shimmer and sparkle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a thin crack appear silently and swiftly, spreading outward to shatter the ice into dozens of jagged geometric sections?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the shattered ice sections shift and stabilize on the ground with glittering edges that catch the light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014203409664332867 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.2642035484313965 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014203409664332867, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014203409664332867, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2622510492801666, + 0.030168747529387474, + 0.05928582325577736, + 0.1022813618183136, + 0.026800507679581642, + 0.28908827900886536, + 0.11317582428455353, + 0.031656984239816666, + 0.043651118874549866, + 0.041640251874923706 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014203409664332867 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, high-angle close-up of a paper-thin sheet of ice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the ice surface almost completely transparent, revealing granular soil texture and trapped air bubbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature cool, low-angle morning light causing the ice to shimmer and sparkle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a thin crack appear silently and swiftly, spreading outward to shatter the ice into dozens of jagged geometric sections?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the shattered ice sections shift and stabilize on the ground with glittering edges that catch the light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00319268717430532 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753192901611328 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00319268717430532, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00319268717430532, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07386288791894913, + 0.04441395774483681, + 0.043956201523542404, + 0.06345837563276291, + 0.07330445945262909, + 0.5070699453353882, + 0.0807611420750618, + 0.03769049420952797, + 0.02769799716770649, + 0.047784533351659775 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00319268717430532 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, high-angle close-up captures a pristine, paper-thin sheet of ice nestled against a dark, damp landscape. The ice's surface, almost completely transparent, reveals the granular texture of the soil and a few trapped microscopic air bubbles beneath. In the cool, low-angle morning light, the ice shimmers and sparkles. The scene begins in absolute silence, a fragile moment of perfection. Then, driven by an unseen vibration, a thin crack appears silently and swiftly, bursting out from one side. This initial crack immediately spiders outward, spreading a complex network of interconnected fractures across the surface in a silent, explosive manner. The once-solid sheet shatters into dozens of jagged, geometric sections. These sections, as their momentum runs out, delicately shift and stabilize with a final, tiny crunch, settling into new positions on the exposed ground. Their freshly shattered edges catch the light, glittering like broken glass and creating a quietly beautiful atmosphere of destruction.", + "seed": 16084, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000127/group_12/index_2627_seed_16084_dp_25_rank_50_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.05057419985532761, + "vlm_logprob": -0.05057419985532761, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.775, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.05057419985532761, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, high-angle close-up of a paper-thin sheet of ice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the ice surface almost completely transparent, revealing granular soil texture and trapped air bubbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature cool, low-angle morning light causing the ice to shimmer and sparkle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a thin crack appear silently and swiftly, spreading outward to shatter the ice into dozens of jagged geometric sections?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the shattered ice sections shift and stabilize on the ground with glittering edges that catch the light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.18107567727565765 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8060756921768188 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.18107567727565765, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.18107567727565765, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13260267674922943, + 0.11809799820184708, + 0.04111907258629799, + 0.4281350374221802, + 0.04666873440146446, + 0.02944171242415905, + 0.08170929551124573, + 0.07106176018714905, + 0.028426971286535263, + 0.022736774757504463 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.18107567727565765 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, high-angle close-up of a paper-thin sheet of ice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the ice surface almost completely transparent, revealing granular soil texture and trapped air bubbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature cool, low-angle morning light causing the ice to shimmer and sparkle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a thin crack appear silently and swiftly, spreading outward to shatter the ice into dozens of jagged geometric sections?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the shattered ice sections shift and stabilize on the ground with glittering edges that catch the light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023345839232206345 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773345947265625 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023345839232206345, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023345839232206345, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06216302141547203, + 0.03959568962454796, + 0.0918039008975029, + 0.2556135356426239, + 0.06468159705400467, + 0.08595391362905502, + 0.19126443564891815, + 0.11193499714136124, + 0.045277826488018036, + 0.05171110853552818 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023345839232206345 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, high-angle close-up of a paper-thin sheet of ice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the ice surface almost completely transparent, revealing granular soil texture and trapped air bubbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature cool, low-angle morning light causing the ice to shimmer and sparkle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a thin crack appear silently and swiftly, spreading outward to shatter the ice into dozens of jagged geometric sections?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the shattered ice sections shift and stabilize on the ground with glittering edges that catch the light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03374328091740608 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408743381500244 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03374328091740608, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03374328091740608, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08701369166374207, + 0.07195023447275162, + 0.05543771758675575, + 0.25501200556755066, + 0.07338277250528336, + 0.1030939519405365, + 0.15501955151557922, + 0.07137936353683472, + 0.024559123441576958, + 0.10315162688493729 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03374328091740608 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, high-angle close-up of a paper-thin sheet of ice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the ice surface almost completely transparent, revealing granular soil texture and trapped air bubbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature cool, low-angle morning light causing the ice to shimmer and sparkle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a thin crack appear silently and swiftly, spreading outward to shatter the ice into dozens of jagged geometric sections?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the shattered ice sections shift and stabilize on the ground with glittering edges that catch the light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011086177080869675 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.5110859870910645 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011086177080869675, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011086177080869675, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06299566477537155, + 0.036714307963848114, + 0.06736762821674347, + 0.27495044469833374, + 0.0629253089427948, + 0.1418614536523819, + 0.1494227647781372, + 0.0430244617164135, + 0.02648230828344822, + 0.13425561785697937 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011086177080869675 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, high-angle close-up of a paper-thin sheet of ice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the ice surface almost completely transparent, revealing granular soil texture and trapped air bubbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature cool, low-angle morning light causing the ice to shimmer and sparkle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a thin crack appear silently and swiftly, spreading outward to shatter the ice into dozens of jagged geometric sections?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the shattered ice sections shift and stabilize on the ground with glittering edges that catch the light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036200247704982758 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628620147705078 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036200247704982758, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036200247704982758, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07002656906843185, + 0.07335165143013, + 0.04807678610086441, + 0.12916195392608643, + 0.04749403893947601, + 0.0808076411485672, + 0.3486784100532532, + 0.08045859634876251, + 0.03304107487201691, + 0.08890321850776672 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036200247704982758 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, high-angle close-up captures a pristine, paper-thin sheet of ice nestled against a dark, damp landscape. The ice's surface, almost completely transparent, reveals the granular texture of the soil and a few trapped microscopic air bubbles beneath. In the cool, low-angle morning light, the ice shimmers and sparkles. The scene begins in absolute silence, a fragile moment of perfection. Then, driven by an unseen vibration, a thin crack appears silently and swiftly, bursting out from one side. This initial crack immediately spiders outward, spreading a complex network of interconnected fractures across the surface in a silent, explosive manner. The once-solid sheet shatters into dozens of jagged, geometric sections. These sections, as their momentum runs out, delicately shift and stabilize with a final, tiny crunch, settling into new positions on the exposed ground. Their freshly shattered edges catch the light, glittering like broken glass and creating a quietly beautiful atmosphere of destruction.", + "seed": 16085, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000127/group_12/index_2627_seed_16085_dp_25_rank_50_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.015939761558547615, + "vlm_logprob": -0.015939761558547615, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.8, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.015939761558547615, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, high-angle close-up of a paper-thin sheet of ice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the ice surface almost completely transparent, revealing granular soil texture and trapped air bubbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature cool, low-angle morning light causing the ice to shimmer and sparkle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a thin crack appear silently and swiftly, spreading outward to shatter the ice into dozens of jagged geometric sections?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the shattered ice sections shift and stabilize on the ground with glittering edges that catch the light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.017574068158864975 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.142573833465576 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.017574068158864975, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.017574068158864975, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2245393693447113, + 0.08863648027181625, + 0.1205810084939003, + 0.04191490262746811, + 0.08089514076709747, + 0.05823788046836853, + 0.14687329530715942, + 0.05912549048662186, + 0.15952013432979584, + 0.01967630162835121 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.017574068158864975 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, high-angle close-up of a paper-thin sheet of ice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the ice surface almost completely transparent, revealing granular soil texture and trapped air bubbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature cool, low-angle morning light causing the ice to shimmer and sparkle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a thin crack appear silently and swiftly, spreading outward to shatter the ice into dozens of jagged geometric sections?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the shattered ice sections shift and stabilize on the ground with glittering edges that catch the light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00866569485515356 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758665561676025 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00866569485515356, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00866569485515356, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24862445890903473, + 0.09976573288440704, + 0.06695855408906937, + 0.08329697698354721, + 0.036341384053230286, + 0.06286226212978363, + 0.06148126348853111, + 0.2921435832977295, + 0.034650444984436035, + 0.013875373639166355 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00866569485515356 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, high-angle close-up of a paper-thin sheet of ice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the ice surface almost completely transparent, revealing granular soil texture and trapped air bubbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature cool, low-angle morning light causing the ice to shimmer and sparkle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a thin crack appear silently and swiftly, spreading outward to shatter the ice into dozens of jagged geometric sections?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the shattered ice sections shift and stabilize on the ground with glittering edges that catch the light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04870201274752617 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0487020015716553 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04870201274752617, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04870201274752617, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2669263184070587, + 0.10031622648239136, + 0.08836933970451355, + 0.08073636889457703, + 0.0863063782453537, + 0.031038910150527954, + 0.06422239542007446, + 0.17727720737457275, + 0.06754288822412491, + 0.03726397082209587 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04870201274752617 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, high-angle close-up of a paper-thin sheet of ice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the ice surface almost completely transparent, revealing granular soil texture and trapped air bubbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature cool, low-angle morning light causing the ice to shimmer and sparkle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a thin crack appear silently and swiftly, spreading outward to shatter the ice into dozens of jagged geometric sections?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the shattered ice sections shift and stabilize on the ground with glittering edges that catch the light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002818542532622814 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877818584442139 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002818542532622814, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002818542532622814, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3402843475341797, + 0.11117267608642578, + 0.07473153620958328, + 0.04068411514163017, + 0.07448690384626389, + 0.06078788638114929, + 0.055754292756319046, + 0.17905732989311218, + 0.04173589125275612, + 0.021305091679096222 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002818542532622814 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, high-angle close-up of a paper-thin sheet of ice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the ice surface almost completely transparent, revealing granular soil texture and trapped air bubbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature cool, low-angle morning light causing the ice to shimmer and sparkle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a thin crack appear silently and swiftly, spreading outward to shatter the ice into dozens of jagged geometric sections?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the shattered ice sections shift and stabilize on the ground with glittering edges that catch the light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0019384894985705614 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.251938343048096 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0019384894985705614, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0019384894985705614, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1607898473739624, + 0.16163796186447144, + 0.085105299949646, + 0.04719912260770798, + 0.06516950577497482, + 0.03845103830099106, + 0.05230033025145531, + 0.3082244098186493, + 0.054488979279994965, + 0.026633432134985924 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0019384894985705614 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000127/group_13/index_tensor([7377, 7377])_group_13_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000127/group_13/index_tensor([7377, 7377])_group_13_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..4630258a1b1ef2f87dad7d68a4af327f8951cb54 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000127/group_13/index_tensor([7377, 7377])_group_13_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "low-angle, long shot shot from near the surface, the camera tilts steadily upward to track a massive humpback whale as it breaks through the deep indigo water with explosive force. Its vast, water-soaked body, its dark gray skin dotted with barnacles and scars of time, twists gracefully through the air in a majestic, graceful arc, its enormous, wing-like white pectoral fins fully extended. The golden late-afternoon sun captures every stream of water pouring down from its body, painting the air of spray into a shimmering golden mist, where droplets hover momentarily like countless diamonds. As the whale reaches the apex of its arc and begins its unstoppable plunge back into the water, sending up a deafening wall of white foam, the scene is filled with awe at the power of nature and an atmosphere of breathtaking tranquility and grandeur.", + "seed": 27570, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000127/group_13/index_7377_seed_27570_dp_26_rank_52_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.1283065033145249, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1283065033145249, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.725, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1283065033145249, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle long shot taken from near the water surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt steadily upward to track a massive humpback whale?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the whale's skin dark gray, dotted with barnacles and scars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the whale's enormous white pectoral fins fully extended like wings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by golden late-afternoon sun creating a shimmering golden mist of water droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06076272577047348 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.185762643814087 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06076272577047348, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06076272577047348, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21674814820289612, + 0.05802372097969055, + 0.04488309845328331, + 0.36915233731269836, + 0.06344703584909439, + 0.03459059074521065, + 0.06474312394857407, + 0.07325749099254608, + 0.04701962321996689, + 0.02813487872481346 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06076272577047348 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle long shot taken from near the water surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt steadily upward to track a massive humpback whale?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the whale's skin dark gray, dotted with barnacles and scars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the whale's enormous white pectoral fins fully extended like wings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by golden late-afternoon sun creating a shimmering golden mist of water droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12707723677158356 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.127077341079712 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12707723677158356, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12707723677158356, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13829609751701355, + 0.06031467020511627, + 0.06813174486160278, + 0.15038248896598816, + 0.052694905549287796, + 0.02117587812244892, + 0.018496345728635788, + 0.3992141783237457, + 0.031687166541814804, + 0.05960647389292717 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12707723677158356 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle long shot taken from near the water surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt steadily upward to track a massive humpback whale?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the whale's skin dark gray, dotted with barnacles and scars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the whale's enormous white pectoral fins fully extended like wings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by golden late-afternoon sun creating a shimmering golden mist of water droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10036089271306992 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.350360870361328 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10036089271306992, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10036089271306992, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12753911316394806, + 0.07623615860939026, + 0.07788944989442825, + 0.17135673761367798, + 0.07896070182323456, + 0.14327660202980042, + 0.023683680221438408, + 0.1614932268857956, + 0.0579385980963707, + 0.08162572234869003 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 7, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10036089271306992 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle long shot taken from near the water surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt steadily upward to track a massive humpback whale?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the whale's skin dark gray, dotted with barnacles and scars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the whale's enormous white pectoral fins fully extended like wings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by golden late-afternoon sun creating a shimmering golden mist of water droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.34869149327278137 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.223691463470459 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.34869149327278137, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.34869149327278137, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16023890674114227, + 0.06476948410272598, + 0.07673010975122452, + 0.13479843735694885, + 0.14868438243865967, + 0.09745955467224121, + 0.06156539171934128, + 0.14691543579101562, + 0.04698684811592102, + 0.061851464211940765 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.34869149327278137 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle long shot taken from near the water surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt steadily upward to track a massive humpback whale?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the whale's skin dark gray, dotted with barnacles and scars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the whale's enormous white pectoral fins fully extended like wings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by golden late-afternoon sun creating a shimmering golden mist of water droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00464016804471612 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379640102386475 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00464016804471612, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00464016804471612, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3021678626537323, + 0.12461336702108383, + 0.07068240642547607, + 0.0713939368724823, + 0.07961681485176086, + 0.050003569573163986, + 0.04328106343746185, + 0.12009231746196747, + 0.05850953981280327, + 0.07963915914297104 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00464016804471612 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, long shot shot from near the surface, the camera tilts steadily upward to track a massive humpback whale as it breaks through the deep indigo water with explosive force. Its vast, water-soaked body, its dark gray skin dotted with barnacles and scars of time, twists gracefully through the air in a majestic, graceful arc, its enormous, wing-like white pectoral fins fully extended. The golden late-afternoon sun captures every stream of water pouring down from its body, painting the air of spray into a shimmering golden mist, where droplets hover momentarily like countless diamonds. As the whale reaches the apex of its arc and begins its unstoppable plunge back into the water, sending up a deafening wall of white foam, the scene is filled with awe at the power of nature and an atmosphere of breathtaking tranquility and grandeur.", + "seed": 27571, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000127/group_13/index_7377_seed_27571_dp_26_rank_52_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.06999856419861317, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06999856419861317, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.175, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06999856419861317, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle long shot taken from near the water surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt steadily upward to track a massive humpback whale?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the whale's skin dark gray, dotted with barnacles and scars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the whale's enormous white pectoral fins fully extended like wings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by golden late-afternoon sun creating a shimmering golden mist of water droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04032241180539131 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6653223037719727 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04032241180539131, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04032241180539131, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0976778119802475, + 0.03784605488181114, + 0.040919363498687744, + 0.06686002016067505, + 0.1476043313741684, + 0.045025430619716644, + 0.0791289433836937, + 0.2558847665786743, + 0.09286902844905853, + 0.13618427515029907 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04032241180539131 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle long shot taken from near the water surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt steadily upward to track a massive humpback whale?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the whale's skin dark gray, dotted with barnacles and scars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the whale's enormous white pectoral fins fully extended like wings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by golden late-afternoon sun creating a shimmering golden mist of water droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02983870357275009 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529838800430298 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02983870357275009, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02983870357275009, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09346567094326019, + 0.04174111410975456, + 0.0857180580496788, + 0.09873015433549881, + 0.0779930129647255, + 0.02354079857468605, + 0.06061069294810295, + 0.385785847902298, + 0.11241105198860168, + 0.020003674551844597 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02983870357275009 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle long shot taken from near the water surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt steadily upward to track a massive humpback whale?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the whale's skin dark gray, dotted with barnacles and scars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the whale's enormous white pectoral fins fully extended like wings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by golden late-afternoon sun creating a shimmering golden mist of water droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03812438249588013 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881243228912354 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03812438249588013, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03812438249588013, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07026012986898422, + 0.06142011657357216, + 0.05347270891070366, + 0.07348024845123291, + 0.2884054183959961, + 0.03378063067793846, + 0.1784331053495407, + 0.17258602380752563, + 0.02803702838718891, + 0.04012459143996239 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03812438249588013 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle long shot taken from near the water surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt steadily upward to track a massive humpback whale?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the whale's skin dark gray, dotted with barnacles and scars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the whale's enormous white pectoral fins fully extended like wings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by golden late-afternoon sun creating a shimmering golden mist of water droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.225633442401886 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6006333827972412 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.225633442401886, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.225633442401886, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13144978880882263, + 0.08771231770515442, + 0.03491772338747978, + 0.18363524973392487, + 0.04654822498559952, + 0.0384226031601429, + 0.11368892341852188, + 0.1531510204076767, + 0.15896357595920563, + 0.05151057243347168 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.225633442401886 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle long shot taken from near the water surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt steadily upward to track a massive humpback whale?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the whale's skin dark gray, dotted with barnacles and scars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the whale's enormous white pectoral fins fully extended like wings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by golden late-afternoon sun creating a shimmering golden mist of water droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016073880717158318 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141073703765869 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016073880717158318, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016073880717158318, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10355541855096817, + 0.03783748298883438, + 0.030519338324666023, + 0.033489637076854706, + 0.18123766779899597, + 0.028829555958509445, + 0.051473602652549744, + 0.16057829558849335, + 0.13838444650173187, + 0.234094500541687 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016073880717158318 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, long shot shot from near the surface, the camera tilts steadily upward to track a massive humpback whale as it breaks through the deep indigo water with explosive force. Its vast, water-soaked body, its dark gray skin dotted with barnacles and scars of time, twists gracefully through the air in a majestic, graceful arc, its enormous, wing-like white pectoral fins fully extended. The golden late-afternoon sun captures every stream of water pouring down from its body, painting the air of spray into a shimmering golden mist, where droplets hover momentarily like countless diamonds. As the whale reaches the apex of its arc and begins its unstoppable plunge back into the water, sending up a deafening wall of white foam, the scene is filled with awe at the power of nature and an atmosphere of breathtaking tranquility and grandeur.", + "seed": 27572, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000127/group_13/index_7377_seed_27572_dp_27_rank_54_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.062405772507190704, + "vlm_logprob": -0.062405772507190704, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.9749999761581423, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.062405772507190704, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle long shot taken from near the water surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt steadily upward to track a massive humpback whale?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the whale's skin dark gray, dotted with barnacles and scars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the whale's enormous white pectoral fins fully extended like wings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by golden late-afternoon sun creating a shimmering golden mist of water droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0662824958562851 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0662825107574463 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0662824958562851, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0662824958562851, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2295873612165451, + 0.16084779798984528, + 0.07665039598941803, + 0.060455989092588425, + 0.040168363600969315, + 0.17522062361240387, + 0.06234227865934372, + 0.06017537787556648, + 0.06986761093139648, + 0.0646841749548912 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0662824958562851 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle long shot taken from near the water surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt steadily upward to track a massive humpback whale?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the whale's skin dark gray, dotted with barnacles and scars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the whale's enormous white pectoral fins fully extended like wings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by golden late-afternoon sun creating a shimmering golden mist of water droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05498972535133362 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929989814758301 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05498972535133362, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05498972535133362, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1875665783882141, + 0.17411193251609802, + 0.05558725818991661, + 0.03373228758573532, + 0.02571224421262741, + 0.14141415059566498, + 0.11446401476860046, + 0.15010160207748413, + 0.06998229771852493, + 0.047327686101198196 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05498972535133362 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle long shot taken from near the water surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt steadily upward to track a massive humpback whale?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the whale's skin dark gray, dotted with barnacles and scars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the whale's enormous white pectoral fins fully extended like wings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by golden late-afternoon sun creating a shimmering golden mist of water droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04309582710266113 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168095827102661 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04309582710266113, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04309582710266113, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15068526566028595, + 0.2146996706724167, + 0.16177234053611755, + 0.07264603674411774, + 0.04385050758719444, + 0.07092104107141495, + 0.06818641722202301, + 0.04573383554816246, + 0.10820836573839188, + 0.06329656392335892 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04309582710266113 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle long shot taken from near the water surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt steadily upward to track a massive humpback whale?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the whale's skin dark gray, dotted with barnacles and scars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the whale's enormous white pectoral fins fully extended like wings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by golden late-afternoon sun creating a shimmering golden mist of water droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12707220017910004 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1270720958709717 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12707220017910004, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.9999998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12707220017910004, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08456239849328995, + 0.20943047106266022, + 0.0763331949710846, + 0.05647606775164604, + 0.0554194450378418, + 0.06896337866783142, + 0.2248457968235016, + 0.05235309898853302, + 0.1127064973115921, + 0.0589095875620842 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12707220017910004 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle long shot taken from near the water surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt steadily upward to track a massive humpback whale?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the whale's skin dark gray, dotted with barnacles and scars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the whale's enormous white pectoral fins fully extended like wings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by golden late-afternoon sun creating a shimmering golden mist of water droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02058861404657364 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955886363983154 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02058861404657364, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02058861404657364, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5804269909858704, + 0.03496961295604706, + 0.025943079963326454, + 0.04407098516821861, + 0.02217814326286316, + 0.05445049703121185, + 0.056189924478530884, + 0.04577856883406639, + 0.07771147042512894, + 0.05828069895505905 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02058861404657364 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, long shot shot from near the surface, the camera tilts steadily upward to track a massive humpback whale as it breaks through the deep indigo water with explosive force. Its vast, water-soaked body, its dark gray skin dotted with barnacles and scars of time, twists gracefully through the air in a majestic, graceful arc, its enormous, wing-like white pectoral fins fully extended. The golden late-afternoon sun captures every stream of water pouring down from its body, painting the air of spray into a shimmering golden mist, where droplets hover momentarily like countless diamonds. As the whale reaches the apex of its arc and begins its unstoppable plunge back into the water, sending up a deafening wall of white foam, the scene is filled with awe at the power of nature and an atmosphere of breathtaking tranquility and grandeur.", + "seed": 27573, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000127/group_13/index_7377_seed_27573_dp_27_rank_54_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.09997738748788834, + "vlm_logprob": -0.09997738748788834, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.9, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.09997738748788834, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle long shot taken from near the water surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt steadily upward to track a massive humpback whale?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the whale's skin dark gray, dotted with barnacles and scars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the whale's enormous white pectoral fins fully extended like wings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by golden late-afternoon sun creating a shimmering golden mist of water droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05653251335024834 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.431532621383667 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05653251335024834, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05653251335024834, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1078689768910408, + 0.05262408033013344, + 0.1834636628627777, + 0.06246691942214966, + 0.05880607292056084, + 0.2545623481273651, + 0.049009326845407486, + 0.04843541234731674, + 0.02601526863873005, + 0.1567479968070984 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 2, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05653251335024834 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle long shot taken from near the water surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt steadily upward to track a massive humpback whale?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the whale's skin dark gray, dotted with barnacles and scars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the whale's enormous white pectoral fins fully extended like wings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by golden late-afternoon sun creating a shimmering golden mist of water droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.048690203577280045 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486903190612793 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.048690203577280045, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.048690203577280045, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11225523054599762, + 0.05193030461668968, + 0.20358100533485413, + 0.1027345359325409, + 0.10222899168729782, + 0.07080788165330887, + 0.06412197649478912, + 0.0811372771859169, + 0.03934149444103241, + 0.17186130583286285 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.048690203577280045 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle long shot taken from near the water surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt steadily upward to track a massive humpback whale?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the whale's skin dark gray, dotted with barnacles and scars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the whale's enormous white pectoral fins fully extended like wings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by golden late-afternoon sun creating a shimmering golden mist of water droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07007494568824768 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695075035095215 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07007494568824768, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07007494568824768, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10009098798036575, + 0.0491977222263813, + 0.21702587604522705, + 0.10071353614330292, + 0.037968698889017105, + 0.26194196939468384, + 0.06679292768239975, + 0.03622336685657501, + 0.042085930705070496, + 0.08795896917581558 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07007494568824768 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle long shot taken from near the water surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt steadily upward to track a massive humpback whale?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the whale's skin dark gray, dotted with barnacles and scars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the whale's enormous white pectoral fins fully extended like wings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by golden late-afternoon sun creating a shimmering golden mist of water droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.313509464263916 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.313509464263916 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.313509464263916, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.313509464263916, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03160621598362923, + 0.03672359138727188, + 0.34621602296829224, + 0.1638626903295517, + 0.03933240845799446, + 0.06491678208112717, + 0.053048599511384964, + 0.034341905266046524, + 0.022982781752943993, + 0.2069689780473709 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.313509464263916 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle long shot taken from near the water surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt steadily upward to track a massive humpback whale?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the whale's skin dark gray, dotted with barnacles and scars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the whale's enormous white pectoral fins fully extended like wings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by golden late-afternoon sun creating a shimmering golden mist of water droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011079810559749603 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511079788208008 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011079810559749603, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011079810559749603, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.020199773833155632, + 0.01074306108057499, + 0.09644370526075363, + 0.48553383350372314, + 0.024292703717947006, + 0.2475060224533081, + 0.043680738657712936, + 0.03248336911201477, + 0.026628242805600166, + 0.012488523498177528 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 5, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011079810559749603 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000127/group_15/index_tensor([4063, 4063])_group_15_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000127/group_15/index_tensor([4063, 4063])_group_15_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..2c0e60b6e8159cafa400bd5a02656ec9a9134ffa --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000127/group_15/index_tensor([4063, 4063])_group_15_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "dramatic long-range shot, captured from a fixed-altitude drone, captures the first rays of golden sunlight piercing the mist, illuminating the majestic Great Wall nestled between towering mountains. The ancient, mottled gray brickwork of the wall winds its way like a giant dragon, its weathered surface richly textured and cast long, pale blue shadows in the slanting morning light. Against this majestic and timeless backdrop, two incredibly tiny figures advance along the broad path atop the wall. The leading figure, draped in a crimson cloak, stands out against the gray landscape, his gait steady. Following closely behind, a second figure, clad in dark clothing, maintains a few paces behind, following steadily and calmly. Their movements appear insignificant against the vast structure, like two slowly moving dots of ink. The entire image is imbued with an epic tranquility and the atmosphere of a lonely and determined journey.", + "seed": 634, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000127/group_15/index_4063_seed_634_dp_30_rank_60_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.10513485791161656, + "vlm_logprob": -0.10513485791161656, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.3, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.10513485791161656, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene captured from a fixed-altitude drone perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the Great Wall visible nestled between towering mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are two tiny figures visible advancing along the path atop the wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the leading figure wearing a crimson cloak and the following figure wearing dark clothing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the Great Wall illuminated by golden sunlight piercing through mist with long pale blue shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.429674357175827 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1796743869781494 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.429674357175827, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.429674357175827, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09160636365413666, + 0.21336403489112854, + 0.3567640781402588, + 0.04220746085047722, + 0.04932014271616936, + 0.05047905072569847, + 0.05680118501186371, + 0.054584819823503494, + 0.0319848470389843, + 0.05288795381784439 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.429674357175827 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene captured from a fixed-altitude drone perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the Great Wall visible nestled between towering mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are two tiny figures visible advancing along the path atop the wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the leading figure wearing a crimson cloak and the following figure wearing dark clothing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the Great Wall illuminated by golden sunlight piercing through mist with long pale blue shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005976662505418062 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130976676940918 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005976662505418062, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005976662505418062, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08886292576789856, + 0.39842984080314636, + 0.16963014006614685, + 0.03601224347949028, + 0.03728991001844406, + 0.026527367532253265, + 0.09282013028860092, + 0.08482658118009567, + 0.028476355597376823, + 0.03712449595332146 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005976662505418062 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene captured from a fixed-altitude drone perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the Great Wall visible nestled between towering mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are two tiny figures visible advancing along the path atop the wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the leading figure wearing a crimson cloak and the following figure wearing dark clothing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the Great Wall illuminated by golden sunlight piercing through mist with long pale blue shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018194211646914482 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018194198608398 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018194211646914482, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018194211646914482, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08943895995616913, + 0.14563219249248505, + 0.4161880612373352, + 0.04964751377701759, + 0.046498607844114304, + 0.07930506765842438, + 0.036465033888816833, + 0.026068346574902534, + 0.07109823077917099, + 0.03965790569782257 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018194211646914482 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene captured from a fixed-altitude drone perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the Great Wall visible nestled between towering mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are two tiny figures visible advancing along the path atop the wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the leading figure wearing a crimson cloak and the following figure wearing dark clothing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the Great Wall illuminated by golden sunlight piercing through mist with long pale blue shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03812231495976448 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881224155426025 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03812231495976448, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03812231495976448, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11379365622997284, + 0.16780458390712738, + 0.33597028255462646, + 0.028827756643295288, + 0.023097380995750427, + 0.07074428349733353, + 0.03557455167174339, + 0.05574264004826546, + 0.030211392790079117, + 0.1382334679365158 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03812231495976448 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene captured from a fixed-altitude drone perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the Great Wall visible nestled between towering mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are two tiny figures visible advancing along the path atop the wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the leading figure wearing a crimson cloak and the following figure wearing dark clothing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the Great Wall illuminated by golden sunlight piercing through mist with long pale blue shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03370674327015877 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4087066650390625 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03370674327015877, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03370674327015877, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5961199998855591, + 0.15080495178699493, + 0.04241760075092316, + 0.033463072031736374, + 0.02309498004615307, + 0.019135339185595512, + 0.03563666343688965, + 0.024577617645263672, + 0.02932772785425186, + 0.045422039926052094 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03370674327015877 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dramatic long-range shot, captured from a fixed-altitude drone, captures the first rays of golden sunlight piercing the mist, illuminating the majestic Great Wall nestled between towering mountains. The ancient, mottled gray brickwork of the wall winds its way like a giant dragon, its weathered surface richly textured and cast long, pale blue shadows in the slanting morning light. Against this majestic and timeless backdrop, two incredibly tiny figures advance along the broad path atop the wall. The leading figure, draped in a crimson cloak, stands out against the gray landscape, his gait steady. Following closely behind, a second figure, clad in dark clothing, maintains a few paces behind, following steadily and calmly. Their movements appear insignificant against the vast structure, like two slowly moving dots of ink. The entire image is imbued with an epic tranquility and the atmosphere of a lonely and determined journey.", + "seed": 635, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000127/group_15/index_4063_seed_635_dp_30_rank_60_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.11709791533648968, + "vlm_logprob": -0.11709791533648968, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.125, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.11709791533648968, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene captured from a fixed-altitude drone perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the Great Wall visible nestled between towering mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are two tiny figures visible advancing along the path atop the wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the leading figure wearing a crimson cloak and the following figure wearing dark clothing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the Great Wall illuminated by golden sunlight piercing through mist with long pale blue shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3716162145137787 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.621616244316101 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3716162145137787, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3716162145137787, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13142801821231842, + 0.05634677782654762, + 0.10797236114740372, + 0.11601025611162186, + 0.02514706365764141, + 0.04403005912899971, + 0.12035562843084335, + 0.05839987471699715, + 0.148463174700737, + 0.1918467879295349 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3716162145137787 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene captured from a fixed-altitude drone perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the Great Wall visible nestled between towering mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are two tiny figures visible advancing along the path atop the wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the leading figure wearing a crimson cloak and the following figure wearing dark clothing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the Great Wall illuminated by golden sunlight piercing through mist with long pale blue shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01113474927842617 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511134624481201 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01113474927842617, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01113474927842617, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10550649464130402, + 0.30025967955589294, + 0.07507536560297012, + 0.04156733676791191, + 0.00954173319041729, + 0.022987239062786102, + 0.07750270515680313, + 0.055797263979911804, + 0.019539685919880867, + 0.2922224700450897 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01113474927842617 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene captured from a fixed-altitude drone perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the Great Wall visible nestled between towering mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are two tiny figures visible advancing along the path atop the wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the leading figure wearing a crimson cloak and the following figure wearing dark clothing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the Great Wall illuminated by golden sunlight piercing through mist with long pale blue shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008652813732624054 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758652687072754 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008652813732624054, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008652813732624054, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23866985738277435, + 0.12449393421411514, + 0.08582306653261185, + 0.04495089873671532, + 0.05285823345184326, + 0.048502154648303986, + 0.025453416630625725, + 0.05938718840479851, + 0.08716405183076859, + 0.23269720375537872 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008652813732624054 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene captured from a fixed-altitude drone perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the Great Wall visible nestled between towering mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are two tiny figures visible advancing along the path atop the wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the leading figure wearing a crimson cloak and the following figure wearing dark clothing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the Great Wall illuminated by golden sunlight piercing through mist with long pale blue shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03372449427843094 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408724546432495 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03372449427843094, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03372449427843094, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3266829550266266, + 0.20270735025405884, + 0.04350462183356285, + 0.06312374025583267, + 0.05205569416284561, + 0.06621362268924713, + 0.03308001905679703, + 0.06508522480726242, + 0.033090002834796906, + 0.11445675045251846 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03372449427843094 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene captured from a fixed-altitude drone perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the Great Wall visible nestled between towering mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are two tiny figures visible advancing along the path atop the wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the leading figure wearing a crimson cloak and the following figure wearing dark clothing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the Great Wall illuminated by golden sunlight piercing through mist with long pale blue shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16036130487918854 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9103612899780273 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16036130487918854, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16036130487918854, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1685384213924408, + 0.16886506974697113, + 0.06737367808818817, + 0.03838435932993889, + 0.03100360929965973, + 0.021900828927755356, + 0.04341169819235802, + 0.13816770911216736, + 0.041039131581783295, + 0.2813154458999634 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16036130487918854 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dramatic long-range shot, captured from a fixed-altitude drone, captures the first rays of golden sunlight piercing the mist, illuminating the majestic Great Wall nestled between towering mountains. The ancient, mottled gray brickwork of the wall winds its way like a giant dragon, its weathered surface richly textured and cast long, pale blue shadows in the slanting morning light. Against this majestic and timeless backdrop, two incredibly tiny figures advance along the broad path atop the wall. The leading figure, draped in a crimson cloak, stands out against the gray landscape, his gait steady. Following closely behind, a second figure, clad in dark clothing, maintains a few paces behind, following steadily and calmly. Their movements appear insignificant against the vast structure, like two slowly moving dots of ink. The entire image is imbued with an epic tranquility and the atmosphere of a lonely and determined journey.", + "seed": 636, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000127/group_15/index_4063_seed_636_dp_31_rank_62_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.09498188411816955, + "vlm_logprob": -0.09498188411816955, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.525, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.09498188411816955, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene captured from a fixed-altitude drone perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the Great Wall visible nestled between towering mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are two tiny figures visible advancing along the path atop the wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the leading figure wearing a crimson cloak and the following figure wearing dark clothing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the Great Wall illuminated by golden sunlight piercing through mist with long pale blue shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4037904143333435 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4037904739379883 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.4037904143333435, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.4037904143333435, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05890071392059326, + 0.07080389559268951, + 0.06874223053455353, + 0.14023049175739288, + 0.08346467465162277, + 0.24823972582817078, + 0.17578747868537903, + 0.03320789337158203, + 0.03960486501455307, + 0.08101799339056015 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 6, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.4037904143333435 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene captured from a fixed-altitude drone perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the Great Wall visible nestled between towering mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are two tiny figures visible advancing along the path atop the wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the leading figure wearing a crimson cloak and the following figure wearing dark clothing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the Great Wall illuminated by golden sunlight piercing through mist with long pale blue shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020617924630641937 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895617961883545 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020617924630641937, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020617924630641937, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11641251295804977, + 0.052393145859241486, + 0.05567820370197296, + 0.09479528665542603, + 0.03413599357008934, + 0.08799407631158829, + 0.058681704103946686, + 0.033005375415086746, + 0.2482656091451645, + 0.21863804757595062 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020617924630641937 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene captured from a fixed-altitude drone perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the Great Wall visible nestled between towering mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are two tiny figures visible advancing along the path atop the wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the leading figure wearing a crimson cloak and the following figure wearing dark clothing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the Great Wall illuminated by golden sunlight piercing through mist with long pale blue shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005952843930572271 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130952835083008 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005952843930572271, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005952843930572271, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13325244188308716, + 0.09371256083250046, + 0.032263852655887604, + 0.20100842416286469, + 0.05287228897213936, + 0.11565733700990677, + 0.14702892303466797, + 0.024055955931544304, + 0.12840184569358826, + 0.0717463567852974 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005952843930572271 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene captured from a fixed-altitude drone perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the Great Wall visible nestled between towering mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are two tiny figures visible advancing along the path atop the wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the leading figure wearing a crimson cloak and the following figure wearing dark clothing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the Great Wall illuminated by golden sunlight piercing through mist with long pale blue shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026361869648098946 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513619422912598 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026361869648098946, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026361869648098946, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.258766233921051, + 0.10688409954309464, + 0.02593459002673626, + 0.09591179341077805, + 0.052235838025808334, + 0.14698728919029236, + 0.16782477498054504, + 0.01608785055577755, + 0.05512987822294235, + 0.0742376372218132 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026361869648098946 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene captured from a fixed-altitude drone perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the Great Wall visible nestled between towering mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are two tiny figures visible advancing along the path atop the wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the leading figure wearing a crimson cloak and the following figure wearing dark clothing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the Great Wall illuminated by golden sunlight piercing through mist with long pale blue shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01818636804819107 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018186569213867 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01818636804819107, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01818636804819107, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18982574343681335, + 0.13808345794677734, + 0.09397099912166595, + 0.10417654365301132, + 0.08075111359357834, + 0.16558723151683807, + 0.09654263406991959, + 0.026698939502239227, + 0.05241244286298752, + 0.05195087939500809 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01818636804819107 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dramatic long-range shot, captured from a fixed-altitude drone, captures the first rays of golden sunlight piercing the mist, illuminating the majestic Great Wall nestled between towering mountains. The ancient, mottled gray brickwork of the wall winds its way like a giant dragon, its weathered surface richly textured and cast long, pale blue shadows in the slanting morning light. Against this majestic and timeless backdrop, two incredibly tiny figures advance along the broad path atop the wall. The leading figure, draped in a crimson cloak, stands out against the gray landscape, his gait steady. Following closely behind, a second figure, clad in dark clothing, maintains a few paces behind, following steadily and calmly. Their movements appear insignificant against the vast structure, like two slowly moving dots of ink. The entire image is imbued with an epic tranquility and the atmosphere of a lonely and determined journey.", + "seed": 637, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000127/group_15/index_4063_seed_637_dp_31_rank_62_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.106775595061481, + "vlm_logprob": -0.106775595061481, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.925, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.106775595061481, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene captured from a fixed-altitude drone perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the Great Wall visible nestled between towering mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are two tiny figures visible advancing along the path atop the wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the leading figure wearing a crimson cloak and the following figure wearing dark clothing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the Great Wall illuminated by golden sunlight piercing through mist with long pale blue shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.37453824281692505 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4995381832122803 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.37453824281692505, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.37453824281692505, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2109186351299286, + 0.069740429520607, + 0.06208579242229462, + 0.08220693469047546, + 0.07441923767328262, + 0.20451819896697998, + 0.03125907480716705, + 0.07279910147190094, + 0.044165607541799545, + 0.14788703620433807 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.37453824281692505 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene captured from a fixed-altitude drone perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the Great Wall visible nestled between towering mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are two tiny figures visible advancing along the path atop the wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the leading figure wearing a crimson cloak and the following figure wearing dark clothing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the Great Wall illuminated by golden sunlight piercing through mist with long pale blue shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014252652414143085 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264252662658691 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014252652414143085, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014252652414143085, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09442130476236343, + 0.06758980453014374, + 0.03292451053857803, + 0.03119962103664875, + 0.07011492550373077, + 0.07329556345939636, + 0.024745117872953415, + 0.0320097915828228, + 0.008598965592682362, + 0.5651004314422607 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014252652414143085 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene captured from a fixed-altitude drone perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the Great Wall visible nestled between towering mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are two tiny figures visible advancing along the path atop the wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the leading figure wearing a crimson cloak and the following figure wearing dark clothing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the Great Wall illuminated by golden sunlight piercing through mist with long pale blue shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02636036090552807 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651360273361206 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02636036090552807, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02636036090552807, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15324237942695618, + 0.09418975561857224, + 0.07463862001895905, + 0.085871122777462, + 0.03242938965559006, + 0.18229500949382782, + 0.04293004795908928, + 0.05873352661728859, + 0.021370813250541687, + 0.2542993426322937 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02636036090552807 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene captured from a fixed-altitude drone perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the Great Wall visible nestled between towering mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are two tiny figures visible advancing along the path atop the wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the leading figure wearing a crimson cloak and the following figure wearing dark clothing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the Great Wall illuminated by golden sunlight piercing through mist with long pale blue shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04869145527482033 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048691511154175 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04869145527482033, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04869145527482033, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19558101892471313, + 0.09981372207403183, + 0.054031845182180405, + 0.08522800356149673, + 0.04913031682372093, + 0.17998260259628296, + 0.08259739726781845, + 0.0355372428894043, + 0.051523253321647644, + 0.16657456755638123 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04869145527482033 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene captured from a fixed-altitude drone perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the Great Wall visible nestled between towering mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are two tiny figures visible advancing along the path atop the wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the leading figure wearing a crimson cloak and the following figure wearing dark clothing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the Great Wall illuminated by golden sunlight piercing through mist with long pale blue shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07003526389598846 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695035219192505 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07003526389598846, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07003526389598846, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06985418498516083, + 0.02543870359659195, + 0.02590048499405384, + 0.028089597821235657, + 0.028098275884985924, + 0.0430813729763031, + 0.036107949912548065, + 0.05664653331041336, + 0.02230648696422577, + 0.6644765138626099 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07003526389598846 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000127/group_2/index_tensor([7506, 7506])_group_2_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000127/group_2/index_tensor([7506, 7506])_group_2_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..d8c4fc8d72e25c76ded775ab3bf5d72d16096359 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000127/group_2/index_tensor([7506, 7506])_group_2_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "An epic wide-angle shot, shot from a low angle and tilted upward, the camera violently vibrating, captures the apocalyptic collapse of Chentangguan Pass. The ancient city walls crumble under the immense pressure, and the traditional architectural structures with flying eaves and brackets shatter and collapse in a cloud of dust. Suddenly, the earth rips open, and several massive mechanical tentacles, incorporating elements of the Taotie from the Classic of Mountains and Seas, violently burst forth from the earth. Composed of a shimmering dark metal alloy, their surfaces etched with hideous Taotie motifs, their joints exposed cyborg tendons and energy conduits pulsing with a hellish red glow. These tentacles are topped with mechanical mouths resembling the maws of Taotie, their jaws, meshing with razor-sharp gears, ruthlessly devouring the fleeing, terrified civilians. At this moment of despair, a young Nezha, atop two flaming wind-fire wheels, roared across the gloomy sky. His gaze was steely, and he wore a form-fitting armor that blended classical aesthetics with futuristic technology. The delicately carved lotus patterns glowed a soft ethereal pink, while the circuit boards throughout his body pulsed with a constant stream of cool blue energy, like living meridians. As he arrived, the Hun Tian Ling behind him unfurled with incredible speed. The soft red silk quickly reconstructed in mid-air into chains of hardened metal, glowing red. These decisively and swiftly wrapped around a raging mechanical tentacle, emitting a harsh metallic scraping sound. Then, Nezha flipped mid-air, his hands tightly grasping his Fire Spear, its tip ablaze with white-hot flames. With thunderous force, he thrust the spear with unerring precision through a massive, pulsating mechanical core at the confluence of several tentacles. This blow instantly triggered a catastrophic chain reaction. A dazzling cyan energy pulse suddenly erupted from the core. The powerful shock wave disintegrated the mechanical tentacles layer by layer. The entire scene was transformed into daylight in the strong light, creating a tense, magnificent and mythical technological atmosphere of destruction and rebirth.", + "seed": 7505, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000127/group_2/index_7506_seed_7505_dp_4_rank_8_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.03663494251668453, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03663494251668453, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.5, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03663494251668453, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at Chentangguan Pass with ancient city walls crumbling and traditional structures with flying eaves shattering?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do massive mechanical tentacles composed of dark metal alloy with Taotie motifs and glowing red energy conduits burst from the earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a young Nezha visible riding two flaming wind-fire wheels while wearing armor with glowing pink lotus patterns and blue circuit boards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does Nezha use a Fire Spear with white-hot flames to pierce a mechanical core, triggering a cyan energy pulse that disintegrates the tentacles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a low angle with a tilted upward perspective and a violently vibrating camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04326251894235611 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168262481689453 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04326251894235611, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04326251894235611, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.43801718950271606, + 0.09641299396753311, + 0.055282268673181534, + 0.048041101545095444, + 0.04040706530213356, + 0.046007245779037476, + 0.027753153815865517, + 0.08282461762428284, + 0.05675599351525307, + 0.10849834233522415 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04326251894235611 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at Chentangguan Pass with ancient city walls crumbling and traditional structures with flying eaves shattering?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do massive mechanical tentacles composed of dark metal alloy with Taotie motifs and glowing red energy conduits burst from the earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a young Nezha visible riding two flaming wind-fire wheels while wearing armor with glowing pink lotus patterns and blue circuit boards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does Nezha use a Fire Spear with white-hot flames to pierce a mechanical core, triggering a cyan energy pulse that disintegrates the tentacles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a low angle with a tilted upward perspective and a violently vibrating camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02058662846684456 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955867290496826 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02058662846684456, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02058662846684456, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16257375478744507, + 0.08210445940494537, + 0.06531504541635513, + 0.13611310720443726, + 0.10919664055109024, + 0.0636260136961937, + 0.04812827706336975, + 0.07680626213550568, + 0.10264092683792114, + 0.15349550545215607 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02058662846684456 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at Chentangguan Pass with ancient city walls crumbling and traditional structures with flying eaves shattering?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do massive mechanical tentacles composed of dark metal alloy with Taotie motifs and glowing red energy conduits burst from the earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a young Nezha visible riding two flaming wind-fire wheels while wearing armor with glowing pink lotus patterns and blue circuit boards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does Nezha use a Fire Spear with white-hot flames to pierce a mechanical core, triggering a cyan energy pulse that disintegrates the tentacles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a low angle with a tilted upward perspective and a violently vibrating camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.062042124569416046 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812042236328125 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.062042124569416046, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.062042124569416046, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16167473793029785, + 0.04417949914932251, + 0.04244529828429222, + 0.09826893359422684, + 0.11641193181276321, + 0.030550692230463028, + 0.05315672233700752, + 0.16763275861740112, + 0.10828955471515656, + 0.1773899495601654 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.062042124569416046 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at Chentangguan Pass with ancient city walls crumbling and traditional structures with flying eaves shattering?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do massive mechanical tentacles composed of dark metal alloy with Taotie motifs and glowing red energy conduits burst from the earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a young Nezha visible riding two flaming wind-fire wheels while wearing armor with glowing pink lotus patterns and blue circuit boards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does Nezha use a Fire Spear with white-hot flames to pierce a mechanical core, triggering a cyan energy pulse that disintegrates the tentacles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a low angle with a tilted upward perspective and a violently vibrating camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008639222010970116 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758639335632324 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008639222010970116, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008639222010970116, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1198178306221962, + 0.050244517624378204, + 0.03125565126538277, + 0.08059314638376236, + 0.035171668976545334, + 0.02445606142282486, + 0.02228892222046852, + 0.20166678726673126, + 0.19997429847717285, + 0.23453114926815033 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008639222010970116 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at Chentangguan Pass with ancient city walls crumbling and traditional structures with flying eaves shattering?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do massive mechanical tentacles composed of dark metal alloy with Taotie motifs and glowing red energy conduits burst from the earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a young Nezha visible riding two flaming wind-fire wheels while wearing armor with glowing pink lotus patterns and blue circuit boards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does Nezha use a Fire Spear with white-hot flames to pierce a mechanical core, triggering a cyan energy pulse that disintegrates the tentacles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a low angle with a tilted upward perspective and a violently vibrating camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04864421859383583 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486443042755127 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04864421859383583, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04864421859383583, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09849011898040771, + 0.0732724666595459, + 0.04553084075450897, + 0.1102379783987999, + 0.09375777840614319, + 0.13852666318416595, + 0.03512215241789818, + 0.16364125907421112, + 0.06359545886516571, + 0.17782527208328247 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04864421859383583 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An epic wide-angle shot, shot from a low angle and tilted upward, the camera violently vibrating, captures the apocalyptic collapse of Chentangguan Pass. The ancient city walls crumble under the immense pressure, and the traditional architectural structures with flying eaves and brackets shatter and collapse in a cloud of dust. Suddenly, the earth rips open, and several massive mechanical tentacles, incorporating elements of the Taotie from the Classic of Mountains and Seas, violently burst forth from the earth. Composed of a shimmering dark metal alloy, their surfaces etched with hideous Taotie motifs, their joints exposed cyborg tendons and energy conduits pulsing with a hellish red glow. These tentacles are topped with mechanical mouths resembling the maws of Taotie, their jaws, meshing with razor-sharp gears, ruthlessly devouring the fleeing, terrified civilians. At this moment of despair, a young Nezha, atop two flaming wind-fire wheels, roared across the gloomy sky. His gaze was steely, and he wore a form-fitting armor that blended classical aesthetics with futuristic technology. The delicately carved lotus patterns glowed a soft ethereal pink, while the circuit boards throughout his body pulsed with a constant stream of cool blue energy, like living meridians. As he arrived, the Hun Tian Ling behind him unfurled with incredible speed. The soft red silk quickly reconstructed in mid-air into chains of hardened metal, glowing red. These decisively and swiftly wrapped around a raging mechanical tentacle, emitting a harsh metallic scraping sound. Then, Nezha flipped mid-air, his hands tightly grasping his Fire Spear, its tip ablaze with white-hot flames. With thunderous force, he thrust the spear with unerring precision through a massive, pulsating mechanical core at the confluence of several tentacles. This blow instantly triggered a catastrophic chain reaction. A dazzling cyan energy pulse suddenly erupted from the core. The powerful shock wave disintegrated the mechanical tentacles layer by layer. The entire scene was transformed into daylight in the strong light, creating a tense, magnificent and mythical technological atmosphere of destruction and rebirth.", + "seed": 7506, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000127/group_2/index_7506_seed_7506_dp_4_rank_8_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.15252824667841197, + "vlm_logprob": -0.15252824667841197, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.324999952316284, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.15252824667841197, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at Chentangguan Pass with ancient city walls crumbling and traditional structures with flying eaves shattering?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do massive mechanical tentacles composed of dark metal alloy with Taotie motifs and glowing red energy conduits burst from the earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a young Nezha visible riding two flaming wind-fire wheels while wearing armor with glowing pink lotus patterns and blue circuit boards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does Nezha use a Fire Spear with white-hot flames to pierce a mechanical core, triggering a cyan energy pulse that disintegrates the tentacles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a low angle with a tilted upward perspective and a violently vibrating camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6937981843948364 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6937981843948364 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.6937981843948364, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.6937981843948364, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2524816393852234, + 0.04072130098938942, + 0.025696326047182083, + 0.05969718471169472, + 0.053283415734767914, + 0.20137763023376465, + 0.04697883501648903, + 0.055533453822135925, + 0.031562939286231995, + 0.2326672375202179 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.6937981843948364 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at Chentangguan Pass with ancient city walls crumbling and traditional structures with flying eaves shattering?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do massive mechanical tentacles composed of dark metal alloy with Taotie motifs and glowing red energy conduits burst from the earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a young Nezha visible riding two flaming wind-fire wheels while wearing armor with glowing pink lotus patterns and blue circuit boards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does Nezha use a Fire Spear with white-hot flames to pierce a mechanical core, triggering a cyan energy pulse that disintegrates the tentacles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a low angle with a tilted upward perspective and a violently vibrating camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00979274045675993 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634792804718018 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00979274045675993, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00979274045675993, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12335272878408432, + 0.060363784432411194, + 0.06146696209907532, + 0.1100248321890831, + 0.0762123391032219, + 0.3058861196041107, + 0.022229010239243507, + 0.08407518267631531, + 0.05724697560071945, + 0.09914205968379974 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00979274045675993 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at Chentangguan Pass with ancient city walls crumbling and traditional structures with flying eaves shattering?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do massive mechanical tentacles composed of dark metal alloy with Taotie motifs and glowing red energy conduits burst from the earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a young Nezha visible riding two flaming wind-fire wheels while wearing armor with glowing pink lotus patterns and blue circuit boards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does Nezha use a Fire Spear with white-hot flames to pierce a mechanical core, triggering a cyan energy pulse that disintegrates the tentacles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a low angle with a tilted upward perspective and a violently vibrating camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02979704923927784 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529797077178955 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02979704923927784, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02979704923927784, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23830409348011017, + 0.03909260779619217, + 0.03594039008021355, + 0.09547148644924164, + 0.09726939350366592, + 0.1260593980550766, + 0.030102046206593513, + 0.05226202309131622, + 0.0555807501077652, + 0.22991783916950226 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02979704923927784 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at Chentangguan Pass with ancient city walls crumbling and traditional structures with flying eaves shattering?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do massive mechanical tentacles composed of dark metal alloy with Taotie motifs and glowing red energy conduits burst from the earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a young Nezha visible riding two flaming wind-fire wheels while wearing armor with glowing pink lotus patterns and blue circuit boards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does Nezha use a Fire Spear with white-hot flames to pierce a mechanical core, triggering a cyan energy pulse that disintegrates the tentacles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a low angle with a tilted upward perspective and a violently vibrating camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011073680594563484 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511073589324951 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011073680594563484, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011073680594563484, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.034767307341098785, + 0.02369913086295128, + 0.014939606189727783, + 0.022034620866179466, + 0.03581853210926056, + 0.02111181616783142, + 0.026345297694206238, + 0.038139477372169495, + 0.058097563683986664, + 0.7250466346740723 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011073680594563484 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at Chentangguan Pass with ancient city walls crumbling and traditional structures with flying eaves shattering?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do massive mechanical tentacles composed of dark metal alloy with Taotie motifs and glowing red energy conduits burst from the earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a young Nezha visible riding two flaming wind-fire wheels while wearing armor with glowing pink lotus patterns and blue circuit boards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does Nezha use a Fire Spear with white-hot flames to pierce a mechanical core, triggering a cyan energy pulse that disintegrates the tentacles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a low angle with a tilted upward perspective and a violently vibrating camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018179578706622124 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018179416656494 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018179578706622124, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018179578706622124, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.29435068368911743, + 0.10189300030469894, + 0.04375360906124115, + 0.03307657316327095, + 0.04354752600193024, + 0.057145338505506516, + 0.05239566043019295, + 0.09152641892433167, + 0.04312606900930405, + 0.2391851246356964 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018179578706622124 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An epic wide-angle shot, shot from a low angle and tilted upward, the camera violently vibrating, captures the apocalyptic collapse of Chentangguan Pass. The ancient city walls crumble under the immense pressure, and the traditional architectural structures with flying eaves and brackets shatter and collapse in a cloud of dust. Suddenly, the earth rips open, and several massive mechanical tentacles, incorporating elements of the Taotie from the Classic of Mountains and Seas, violently burst forth from the earth. Composed of a shimmering dark metal alloy, their surfaces etched with hideous Taotie motifs, their joints exposed cyborg tendons and energy conduits pulsing with a hellish red glow. These tentacles are topped with mechanical mouths resembling the maws of Taotie, their jaws, meshing with razor-sharp gears, ruthlessly devouring the fleeing, terrified civilians. At this moment of despair, a young Nezha, atop two flaming wind-fire wheels, roared across the gloomy sky. His gaze was steely, and he wore a form-fitting armor that blended classical aesthetics with futuristic technology. The delicately carved lotus patterns glowed a soft ethereal pink, while the circuit boards throughout his body pulsed with a constant stream of cool blue energy, like living meridians. As he arrived, the Hun Tian Ling behind him unfurled with incredible speed. The soft red silk quickly reconstructed in mid-air into chains of hardened metal, glowing red. These decisively and swiftly wrapped around a raging mechanical tentacle, emitting a harsh metallic scraping sound. Then, Nezha flipped mid-air, his hands tightly grasping his Fire Spear, its tip ablaze with white-hot flames. With thunderous force, he thrust the spear with unerring precision through a massive, pulsating mechanical core at the confluence of several tentacles. This blow instantly triggered a catastrophic chain reaction. A dazzling cyan energy pulse suddenly erupted from the core. The powerful shock wave disintegrated the mechanical tentacles layer by layer. The entire scene was transformed into daylight in the strong light, creating a tense, magnificent and mythical technological atmosphere of destruction and rebirth.", + "seed": 7507, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000127/group_2/index_7506_seed_7507_dp_5_rank_10_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.04661710187792778, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04661710187792778, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.4, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04661710187792778, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at Chentangguan Pass with ancient city walls crumbling and traditional structures with flying eaves shattering?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do massive mechanical tentacles composed of dark metal alloy with Taotie motifs and glowing red energy conduits burst from the earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a young Nezha visible riding two flaming wind-fire wheels while wearing armor with glowing pink lotus patterns and blue circuit boards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does Nezha use a Fire Spear with white-hot flames to pierce a mechanical core, triggering a cyan energy pulse that disintegrates the tentacles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a low angle with a tilted upward perspective and a violently vibrating camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04896903038024902 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048969030380249 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04896903038024902, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04896903038024902, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1714565008878708, + 0.13466818630695343, + 0.17400556802749634, + 0.10197500884532928, + 0.16449064016342163, + 0.03580835089087486, + 0.09239322692155838, + 0.023932749405503273, + 0.07599959522485733, + 0.025270169600844383 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04896903038024902 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at Chentangguan Pass with ancient city walls crumbling and traditional structures with flying eaves shattering?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do massive mechanical tentacles composed of dark metal alloy with Taotie motifs and glowing red energy conduits burst from the earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a young Nezha visible riding two flaming wind-fire wheels while wearing armor with glowing pink lotus patterns and blue circuit boards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does Nezha use a Fire Spear with white-hot flames to pierce a mechanical core, triggering a cyan energy pulse that disintegrates the tentacles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a low angle with a tilted upward perspective and a violently vibrating camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012544183060526848 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.38754415512085 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012544183060526848, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012544183060526848, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07435554265975952, + 0.08494269102811813, + 0.056793563067913055, + 0.10260029137134552, + 0.0883544385433197, + 0.0661393254995346, + 0.2809639871120453, + 0.07780380547046661, + 0.10176986455917358, + 0.06627648323774338 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 3, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012544183060526848 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at Chentangguan Pass with ancient city walls crumbling and traditional structures with flying eaves shattering?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do massive mechanical tentacles composed of dark metal alloy with Taotie motifs and glowing red energy conduits burst from the earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a young Nezha visible riding two flaming wind-fire wheels while wearing armor with glowing pink lotus patterns and blue circuit boards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does Nezha use a Fire Spear with white-hot flames to pierce a mechanical core, triggering a cyan energy pulse that disintegrates the tentacles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a low angle with a tilted upward perspective and a violently vibrating camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026344336569309235 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513442993164062 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026344336569309235, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026344336569309235, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1362842470407486, + 0.14726726710796356, + 0.18532824516296387, + 0.1845555156469345, + 0.059208862483501434, + 0.04849115014076233, + 0.09896335005760193, + 0.05560588091611862, + 0.035964593291282654, + 0.04833083227276802 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026344336569309235 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at Chentangguan Pass with ancient city walls crumbling and traditional structures with flying eaves shattering?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do massive mechanical tentacles composed of dark metal alloy with Taotie motifs and glowing red energy conduits burst from the earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a young Nezha visible riding two flaming wind-fire wheels while wearing armor with glowing pink lotus patterns and blue circuit boards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does Nezha use a Fire Spear with white-hot flames to pierce a mechanical core, triggering a cyan energy pulse that disintegrates the tentacles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a low angle with a tilted upward perspective and a violently vibrating camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12704721093177795 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.127047300338745 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12704721093177795, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12704721093177795, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14281122386455536, + 0.09152579307556152, + 0.10216641426086426, + 0.06144442781805992, + 0.15879465639591217, + 0.0607837550342083, + 0.1744133085012436, + 0.09421653300523758, + 0.05111676827073097, + 0.06272709369659424 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12704721093177795 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at Chentangguan Pass with ancient city walls crumbling and traditional structures with flying eaves shattering?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do massive mechanical tentacles composed of dark metal alloy with Taotie motifs and glowing red energy conduits burst from the earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a young Nezha visible riding two flaming wind-fire wheels while wearing armor with glowing pink lotus patterns and blue circuit boards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does Nezha use a Fire Spear with white-hot flames to pierce a mechanical core, triggering a cyan energy pulse that disintegrates the tentacles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a low angle with a tilted upward perspective and a violently vibrating camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01818074844777584 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018180847167969 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01818074844777584, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01818074844777584, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15413489937782288, + 0.12321466952562332, + 0.05910218134522438, + 0.11789198964834213, + 0.10626818984746933, + 0.19608674943447113, + 0.12174707651138306, + 0.05476798489689827, + 0.03797885403037071, + 0.0288073867559433 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01818074844777584 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An epic wide-angle shot, shot from a low angle and tilted upward, the camera violently vibrating, captures the apocalyptic collapse of Chentangguan Pass. The ancient city walls crumble under the immense pressure, and the traditional architectural structures with flying eaves and brackets shatter and collapse in a cloud of dust. Suddenly, the earth rips open, and several massive mechanical tentacles, incorporating elements of the Taotie from the Classic of Mountains and Seas, violently burst forth from the earth. Composed of a shimmering dark metal alloy, their surfaces etched with hideous Taotie motifs, their joints exposed cyborg tendons and energy conduits pulsing with a hellish red glow. These tentacles are topped with mechanical mouths resembling the maws of Taotie, their jaws, meshing with razor-sharp gears, ruthlessly devouring the fleeing, terrified civilians. At this moment of despair, a young Nezha, atop two flaming wind-fire wheels, roared across the gloomy sky. His gaze was steely, and he wore a form-fitting armor that blended classical aesthetics with futuristic technology. The delicately carved lotus patterns glowed a soft ethereal pink, while the circuit boards throughout his body pulsed with a constant stream of cool blue energy, like living meridians. As he arrived, the Hun Tian Ling behind him unfurled with incredible speed. The soft red silk quickly reconstructed in mid-air into chains of hardened metal, glowing red. These decisively and swiftly wrapped around a raging mechanical tentacle, emitting a harsh metallic scraping sound. Then, Nezha flipped mid-air, his hands tightly grasping his Fire Spear, its tip ablaze with white-hot flames. With thunderous force, he thrust the spear with unerring precision through a massive, pulsating mechanical core at the confluence of several tentacles. This blow instantly triggered a catastrophic chain reaction. A dazzling cyan energy pulse suddenly erupted from the core. The powerful shock wave disintegrated the mechanical tentacles layer by layer. The entire scene was transformed into daylight in the strong light, creating a tense, magnificent and mythical technological atmosphere of destruction and rebirth.", + "seed": 7508, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000127/group_2/index_7506_seed_7508_dp_5_rank_10_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.05448674745857716, + "vlm_logprob": -0.05448674745857716, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.25, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.05448674745857716, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at Chentangguan Pass with ancient city walls crumbling and traditional structures with flying eaves shattering?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do massive mechanical tentacles composed of dark metal alloy with Taotie motifs and glowing red energy conduits burst from the earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a young Nezha visible riding two flaming wind-fire wheels while wearing armor with glowing pink lotus patterns and blue circuit boards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does Nezha use a Fire Spear with white-hot flames to pierce a mechanical core, triggering a cyan energy pulse that disintegrates the tentacles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a low angle with a tilted upward perspective and a violently vibrating camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.043322451412677765 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1683225631713867 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.043322451412677765, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.043322451412677765, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3704327642917633, + 0.15126125514507294, + 0.05814237892627716, + 0.0720682293176651, + 0.06972642242908478, + 0.05419733747839928, + 0.056129954755306244, + 0.06829722970724106, + 0.038505446165800095, + 0.06123897060751915 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.043322451412677765 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at Chentangguan Pass with ancient city walls crumbling and traditional structures with flying eaves shattering?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do massive mechanical tentacles composed of dark metal alloy with Taotie motifs and glowing red energy conduits burst from the earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a young Nezha visible riding two flaming wind-fire wheels while wearing armor with glowing pink lotus patterns and blue circuit boards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does Nezha use a Fire Spear with white-hot flames to pierce a mechanical core, triggering a cyan energy pulse that disintegrates the tentacles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a low angle with a tilted upward perspective and a violently vibrating camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011078985407948494 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511078834533691 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011078985407948494, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011078985407948494, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.428490549325943, + 0.0689283087849617, + 0.05563616007566452, + 0.07032005488872528, + 0.04446183890104294, + 0.024437686428427696, + 0.051147133111953735, + 0.13990458846092224, + 0.06430333107709885, + 0.05237031728029251 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011078985407948494 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at Chentangguan Pass with ancient city walls crumbling and traditional structures with flying eaves shattering?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do massive mechanical tentacles composed of dark metal alloy with Taotie motifs and glowing red energy conduits burst from the earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a young Nezha visible riding two flaming wind-fire wheels while wearing armor with glowing pink lotus patterns and blue circuit boards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does Nezha use a Fire Spear with white-hot flames to pierce a mechanical core, triggering a cyan energy pulse that disintegrates the tentacles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a low angle with a tilted upward perspective and a violently vibrating camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11292713135480881 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.237927198410034 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11292713135480881, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11292713135480881, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0938752219080925, + 0.08392877131700516, + 0.18788772821426392, + 0.16370481252670288, + 0.19510126113891602, + 0.06940116733312607, + 0.0786537230014801, + 0.051291994750499725, + 0.03354571759700775, + 0.042609576135873795 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11292713135480881 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at Chentangguan Pass with ancient city walls crumbling and traditional structures with flying eaves shattering?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do massive mechanical tentacles composed of dark metal alloy with Taotie motifs and glowing red energy conduits burst from the earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a young Nezha visible riding two flaming wind-fire wheels while wearing armor with glowing pink lotus patterns and blue circuit boards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does Nezha use a Fire Spear with white-hot flames to pierce a mechanical core, triggering a cyan energy pulse that disintegrates the tentacles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a low angle with a tilted upward perspective and a violently vibrating camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08904055505990982 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.464040517807007 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08904055505990982, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08904055505990982, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22952905297279358, + 0.048541657626628876, + 0.11229931563138962, + 0.12094531208276749, + 0.07744809240102768, + 0.09707506746053696, + 0.044899143278598785, + 0.04709003120660782, + 0.04861199110746384, + 0.17356038093566895 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08904055505990982 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at Chentangguan Pass with ancient city walls crumbling and traditional structures with flying eaves shattering?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do massive mechanical tentacles composed of dark metal alloy with Taotie motifs and glowing red energy conduits burst from the earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a young Nezha visible riding two flaming wind-fire wheels while wearing armor with glowing pink lotus patterns and blue circuit boards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does Nezha use a Fire Spear with white-hot flames to pierce a mechanical core, triggering a cyan energy pulse that disintegrates the tentacles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a low angle with a tilted upward perspective and a violently vibrating camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016064614057540894 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141064643859863 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016064614057540894, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016064614057540894, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.33750051259994507, + 0.11805428564548492, + 0.05801958590745926, + 0.04578972980380058, + 0.10665007680654526, + 0.0857539251446724, + 0.0724928006529808, + 0.07393898069858551, + 0.05489642173051834, + 0.04690363258123398 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016064614057540894 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000127/group_5/index_tensor([2910, 2910])_group_5_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000127/group_5/index_tensor([2910, 2910])_group_5_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..9c0d2a56d757237ed39d5a2166c6462943519aeb --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000127/group_5/index_tensor([2910, 2910])_group_5_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "dynamic shot, shot from a low angle, follows closely behind, rapidly panning and tilting to capture the fierce confrontation between two men in ancient costumes. They stand on the edge of a steep, mist-shrouded mountaintop, a rolling sea of clouds at their feet. One man, clad in a flowing white robe, his long hair tied high with a simple jade hairpin, has a handsome face, his brow radiating a resolute determination. The other, clad in a dark blue suit, has a stern expression and eagle-like eyes. Their figures intertwine, their swords emanating countless arcs of silver light as they clash fiercely in the air, each block precise and powerful. The entire scene is imbued with the artistic charm of ink painting, employing a highly desaturated palette of varying shades of black, white, and gray, resembling a dynamic scroll painted on rice paper. Under the soft diffuse light, the rapid sword moves left ink-like afterimages in the air, and their fluttering clothes merged with the swirling clouds, creating an epic atmosphere of tension, loneliness and classical oriental aesthetics.", + "seed": 1615, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000127/group_5/index_2910_seed_1615_dp_10_rank_20_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.03217923110350966, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03217923110350966, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.8, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03217923110350966, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two men visible in the scene wearing ancient costumes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is one man wearing a flowing white robe with long hair tied by a jade hairpin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the other man wearing a dark blue suit with a stern expression?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the men clash swords emitting arcs of silver light in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a highly desaturated ink painting resembling a scroll on rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.017401518300175667 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.142401695251465 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.017401518300175667, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.017401518300175667, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.062084246426820755, + 0.07341185957193375, + 0.19737671315670013, + 0.08652427792549133, + 0.04951305687427521, + 0.05998356267809868, + 0.04440157115459442, + 0.08580829948186874, + 0.2736033499240875, + 0.06729307770729065 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.017401518300175667 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two men visible in the scene wearing ancient costumes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is one man wearing a flowing white robe with long hair tied by a jade hairpin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the other man wearing a dark blue suit with a stern expression?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the men clash swords emitting arcs of silver light in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a highly desaturated ink painting resembling a scroll on rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004106185864657164 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504106044769287 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004106185864657164, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004106185864657164, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09515121579170227, + 0.25106948614120483, + 0.12462118268013, + 0.06182744726538658, + 0.02858755551278591, + 0.07234130799770355, + 0.05716334283351898, + 0.05598381161689758, + 0.1798989474773407, + 0.07335569709539413 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004106185864657164 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two men visible in the scene wearing ancient costumes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is one man wearing a flowing white robe with long hair tied by a jade hairpin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the other man wearing a dark blue suit with a stern expression?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the men clash swords emitting arcs of silver light in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a highly desaturated ink painting resembling a scroll on rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0699901431798935 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6949901580810547 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0699901431798935, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0699901431798935, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07766584306955338, + 0.04176934435963631, + 0.06482317298650742, + 0.07548809796571732, + 0.03772672638297081, + 0.08904244005680084, + 0.03210146725177765, + 0.0542280450463295, + 0.284172922372818, + 0.24298197031021118 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0699901431798935 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two men visible in the scene wearing ancient costumes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is one man wearing a flowing white robe with long hair tied by a jade hairpin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the other man wearing a dark blue suit with a stern expression?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the men clash swords emitting arcs of silver light in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a highly desaturated ink painting resembling a scroll on rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026347355917096138 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513473987579346 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026347355917096138, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026347355917096138, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13426141440868378, + 0.053566012531518936, + 0.05123313143849373, + 0.14308618009090424, + 0.05661153420805931, + 0.07087360322475433, + 0.031796835362911224, + 0.044583991169929504, + 0.14659333229064941, + 0.26739397644996643 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026347355917096138 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two men visible in the scene wearing ancient costumes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is one man wearing a flowing white robe with long hair tied by a jade hairpin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the other man wearing a dark blue suit with a stern expression?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the men clash swords emitting arcs of silver light in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a highly desaturated ink painting resembling a scroll on rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04305095225572586 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.16805100440979 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04305095225572586, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04305095225572586, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11558368057012558, + 0.07802817970514297, + 0.1504761129617691, + 0.07066122442483902, + 0.11451466381549835, + 0.1094624325633049, + 0.041765715926885605, + 0.09193442761898041, + 0.1349436342716217, + 0.09262996912002563 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04305095225572586 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dynamic shot, shot from a low angle, follows closely behind, rapidly panning and tilting to capture the fierce confrontation between two men in ancient costumes. They stand on the edge of a steep, mist-shrouded mountaintop, a rolling sea of clouds at their feet. One man, clad in a flowing white robe, his long hair tied high with a simple jade hairpin, has a handsome face, his brow radiating a resolute determination. The other, clad in a dark blue suit, has a stern expression and eagle-like eyes. Their figures intertwine, their swords emanating countless arcs of silver light as they clash fiercely in the air, each block precise and powerful. The entire scene is imbued with the artistic charm of ink painting, employing a highly desaturated palette of varying shades of black, white, and gray, resembling a dynamic scroll painted on rice paper. Under the soft diffuse light, the rapid sword moves left ink-like afterimages in the air, and their fluttering clothes merged with the swirling clouds, creating an epic atmosphere of tension, loneliness and classical oriental aesthetics.", + "seed": 1616, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000127/group_5/index_2910_seed_1616_dp_10_rank_20_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.029647574480623006, + "vlm_logprob": -0.029647574480623006, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.424999952316284, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.029647574480623006, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two men visible in the scene wearing ancient costumes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is one man wearing a flowing white robe with long hair tied by a jade hairpin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the other man wearing a dark blue suit with a stern expression?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the men clash swords emitting arcs of silver light in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a highly desaturated ink painting resembling a scroll on rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003750553820282221 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753750324249268 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003750553820282221, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003750553820282221, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12002264708280563, + 0.13007207214832306, + 0.10459732264280319, + 0.1508343666791916, + 0.173996239900589, + 0.05302749201655388, + 0.04977070540189743, + 0.03352013975381851, + 0.05189745873212814, + 0.13226163387298584 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003750553820282221 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two men visible in the scene wearing ancient costumes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is one man wearing a flowing white robe with long hair tied by a jade hairpin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the other man wearing a dark blue suit with a stern expression?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the men clash swords emitting arcs of silver light in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a highly desaturated ink painting resembling a scroll on rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003624657168984413 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628624439239502 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003624657168984413, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003624657168984413, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21788489818572998, + 0.15204095840454102, + 0.06254513561725616, + 0.22857414186000824, + 0.055438924580812454, + 0.04246528074145317, + 0.08422964811325073, + 0.035206012427806854, + 0.038913238793611526, + 0.08270175755023956 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003624657168984413 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two men visible in the scene wearing ancient costumes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is one man wearing a flowing white robe with long hair tied by a jade hairpin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the other man wearing a dark blue suit with a stern expression?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the men clash swords emitting arcs of silver light in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a highly desaturated ink painting resembling a scroll on rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11290019005537033 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2379002571105957 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11290019005537033, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11290019005537033, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15699078142642975, + 0.07120689004659653, + 0.08668047934770584, + 0.3218829333782196, + 0.07074568420648575, + 0.03471352905035019, + 0.05409116670489311, + 0.04009682685136795, + 0.04721413925290108, + 0.11637752503156662 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11290019005537033 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two men visible in the scene wearing ancient costumes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is one man wearing a flowing white robe with long hair tied by a jade hairpin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the other man wearing a dark blue suit with a stern expression?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the men clash swords emitting arcs of silver light in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a highly desaturated ink painting resembling a scroll on rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018185313791036606 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018185138702393 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018185313791036606, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018185313791036606, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.33358046412467957, + 0.07202170044183731, + 0.08097369968891144, + 0.07328891009092331, + 0.07007820904254913, + 0.1127660870552063, + 0.06131799519062042, + 0.05171079933643341, + 0.07994212955236435, + 0.06432002037763596 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018185313791036606 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two men visible in the scene wearing ancient costumes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is one man wearing a flowing white robe with long hair tied by a jade hairpin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the other man wearing a dark blue suit with a stern expression?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the men clash swords emitting arcs of silver light in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a highly desaturated ink painting resembling a scroll on rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009777157567441463 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634777069091797 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009777157567441463, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009777157567441463, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18388886749744415, + 0.06542801856994629, + 0.0550614558160305, + 0.03683587908744812, + 0.10096879303455353, + 0.08789155632257462, + 0.03985728695988655, + 0.07040409743785858, + 0.14397653937339783, + 0.21568754315376282 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009777157567441463 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dynamic shot, shot from a low angle, follows closely behind, rapidly panning and tilting to capture the fierce confrontation between two men in ancient costumes. They stand on the edge of a steep, mist-shrouded mountaintop, a rolling sea of clouds at their feet. One man, clad in a flowing white robe, his long hair tied high with a simple jade hairpin, has a handsome face, his brow radiating a resolute determination. The other, clad in a dark blue suit, has a stern expression and eagle-like eyes. Their figures intertwine, their swords emanating countless arcs of silver light as they clash fiercely in the air, each block precise and powerful. The entire scene is imbued with the artistic charm of ink painting, employing a highly desaturated palette of varying shades of black, white, and gray, resembling a dynamic scroll painted on rice paper. Under the soft diffuse light, the rapid sword moves left ink-like afterimages in the air, and their fluttering clothes merged with the swirling clouds, creating an epic atmosphere of tension, loneliness and classical oriental aesthetics.", + "seed": 1617, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000127/group_5/index_2910_seed_1617_dp_11_rank_22_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.04555416032671929, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04555416032671929, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.8, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04555416032671929, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two men visible in the scene wearing ancient costumes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is one man wearing a flowing white robe with long hair tied by a jade hairpin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the other man wearing a dark blue suit with a stern expression?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the men clash swords emitting arcs of silver light in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a highly desaturated ink painting resembling a scroll on rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012411617673933506 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.512411594390869 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012411617673933506, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012411617673933506, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13125072419643402, + 0.06622566282749176, + 0.07378388196229935, + 0.10597410053014755, + 0.05932536721229553, + 0.10833106935024261, + 0.08628404885530472, + 0.18599513173103333, + 0.0751451700925827, + 0.1076848953962326 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012411617673933506 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two men visible in the scene wearing ancient costumes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is one man wearing a flowing white robe with long hair tied by a jade hairpin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the other man wearing a dark blue suit with a stern expression?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the men clash swords emitting arcs of silver light in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a highly desaturated ink painting resembling a scroll on rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004654050804674625 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.3796539306640625 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004654050804674625, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004654050804674625, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08889739960432053, + 0.06316347420215607, + 0.062418196350336075, + 0.048865996301174164, + 0.13654227554798126, + 0.05953991785645485, + 0.09059828519821167, + 0.19122272729873657, + 0.09876406937837601, + 0.1599876582622528 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004654050804674625 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two men visible in the scene wearing ancient costumes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is one man wearing a flowing white robe with long hair tied by a jade hairpin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the other man wearing a dark blue suit with a stern expression?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the men clash swords emitting arcs of silver light in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a highly desaturated ink painting resembling a scroll on rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16032931208610535 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9103293418884277 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16032931208610535, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16032931208610535, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1512598991394043, + 0.10968685150146484, + 0.09458483755588531, + 0.06359989196062088, + 0.14989569783210754, + 0.04756684973835945, + 0.06563406437635422, + 0.08475184440612793, + 0.049907099455595016, + 0.1831130087375641 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16032931208610535 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two men visible in the scene wearing ancient costumes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is one man wearing a flowing white robe with long hair tied by a jade hairpin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the other man wearing a dark blue suit with a stern expression?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the men clash swords emitting arcs of silver light in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a highly desaturated ink painting resembling a scroll on rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02980063669383526 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298006534576416 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02980063669383526, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02980063669383526, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21035021543502808, + 0.0629863366484642, + 0.14479278028011322, + 0.05375152453780174, + 0.03115924261510372, + 0.05838852375745773, + 0.054783061146736145, + 0.13054969906806946, + 0.14975164830684662, + 0.10348697006702423 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02980063669383526 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two men visible in the scene wearing ancient costumes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is one man wearing a flowing white robe with long hair tied by a jade hairpin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the other man wearing a dark blue suit with a stern expression?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the men clash swords emitting arcs of silver light in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a highly desaturated ink painting resembling a scroll on rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020575184375047684 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955752849578857 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020575184375047684, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020575184375047684, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2318202257156372, + 0.1345711350440979, + 0.09500949084758759, + 0.0702960416674614, + 0.0702129602432251, + 0.03947325050830841, + 0.02839936502277851, + 0.136103093624115, + 0.11987987160682678, + 0.07423458993434906 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020575184375047684 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dynamic shot, shot from a low angle, follows closely behind, rapidly panning and tilting to capture the fierce confrontation between two men in ancient costumes. They stand on the edge of a steep, mist-shrouded mountaintop, a rolling sea of clouds at their feet. One man, clad in a flowing white robe, his long hair tied high with a simple jade hairpin, has a handsome face, his brow radiating a resolute determination. The other, clad in a dark blue suit, has a stern expression and eagle-like eyes. Their figures intertwine, their swords emanating countless arcs of silver light as they clash fiercely in the air, each block precise and powerful. The entire scene is imbued with the artistic charm of ink painting, employing a highly desaturated palette of varying shades of black, white, and gray, resembling a dynamic scroll painted on rice paper. Under the soft diffuse light, the rapid sword moves left ink-like afterimages in the air, and their fluttering clothes merged with the swirling clouds, creating an epic atmosphere of tension, loneliness and classical oriental aesthetics.", + "seed": 1618, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000127/group_5/index_2910_seed_1618_dp_11_rank_22_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.020313576282933354, + "vlm_logprob": -0.020313576282933354, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.299999952316284, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.020313576282933354, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two men visible in the scene wearing ancient costumes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is one man wearing a flowing white robe with long hair tied by a jade hairpin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the other man wearing a dark blue suit with a stern expression?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the men clash swords emitting arcs of silver light in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a highly desaturated ink painting resembling a scroll on rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.019698821008205414 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.019698619842529 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.019698821008205414, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.019698821008205414, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22836247086524963, + 0.07393280416727066, + 0.06309208273887634, + 0.3256746828556061, + 0.02544751763343811, + 0.05008804053068161, + 0.028434516862034798, + 0.05514891818165779, + 0.05955226719379425, + 0.09026671200990677 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.019698821008205414 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two men visible in the scene wearing ancient costumes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is one man wearing a flowing white robe with long hair tied by a jade hairpin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the other man wearing a dark blue suit with a stern expression?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the men clash swords emitting arcs of silver light in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a highly desaturated ink painting resembling a scroll on rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0032058770302683115 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.7532057762146 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0032058770302683115, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0032058770302683115, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14770600199699402, + 0.0609004981815815, + 0.07265710830688477, + 0.19430047273635864, + 0.05538313090801239, + 0.04245149344205856, + 0.2660480737686157, + 0.047755178064107895, + 0.03680703788995743, + 0.07599100470542908 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0032058770302683115 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two men visible in the scene wearing ancient costumes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is one man wearing a flowing white robe with long hair tied by a jade hairpin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the other man wearing a dark blue suit with a stern expression?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the men clash swords emitting arcs of silver light in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a highly desaturated ink painting resembling a scroll on rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.048639677464962006 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486397743225098 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.048639677464962006, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.048639677464962006, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20283351838588715, + 0.10722042620182037, + 0.10890902578830719, + 0.05570201203227043, + 0.11895409226417542, + 0.09402824938297272, + 0.1270827054977417, + 0.07668132334947586, + 0.051490768790245056, + 0.05709788575768471 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.048639677464962006 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two men visible in the scene wearing ancient costumes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is one man wearing a flowing white robe with long hair tied by a jade hairpin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the other man wearing a dark blue suit with a stern expression?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the men clash swords emitting arcs of silver light in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a highly desaturated ink painting resembling a scroll on rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02329086884856224 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732908725738525 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02329086884856224, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02329086884856224, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.055253151804208755, + 0.06973341107368469, + 0.11052627861499786, + 0.0720411166548729, + 0.07122280448675156, + 0.1091846227645874, + 0.3483525812625885, + 0.04424019530415535, + 0.05655762925744057, + 0.06288818269968033 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02329086884856224 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two men visible in the scene wearing ancient costumes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is one man wearing a flowing white robe with long hair tied by a jade hairpin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the other man wearing a dark blue suit with a stern expression?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the men clash swords emitting arcs of silver light in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a highly desaturated ink painting resembling a scroll on rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0067326370626688 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.00673246383667 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0067326370626688, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0067326370626688, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.059449464082717896, + 0.02503947727382183, + 0.02194719947874546, + 0.03351951017975807, + 0.055028777569532394, + 0.030085410922765732, + 0.670468807220459, + 0.05513850599527359, + 0.027262330055236816, + 0.02206050232052803 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0067326370626688 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000127/group_6/index_tensor([1528, 1528])_group_6_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000127/group_6/index_tensor([1528, 1528])_group_6_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..61b490d44c86727c8f3cc98d8b959e156c208e47 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000127/group_6/index_tensor([1528, 1528])_group_6_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "single, static, macro-time-lapse shot meticulously documents the accelerated life cycle of a single Ulysses plant, compressing 45 distinct flowering stages over three years into a fluid visual sequence. As a small, green bud first pokes through a patch of dark, fertile soil, the camera remains perfectly still, focused in extreme detail. It rapidly unfolds, revealing a radiant flower with an intricate array of vibrant yellow petals. The time-lapse effect is striking, with the background light rapidly flickering, simulating the passage of countless days and nights as the flower blooms, gracefully withers, and re-blooms in a continuous, hypnotic cycle. In the final stage, the yellow petals shrink, miraculously replaced by a perfect, ethereal sphere of fluffy white seeds, each a delicate parachute with a tiny seed at its base, seemingly poised and ready to be dispersed by the breeze. The entire natural drama is set against a stark, contemplative backdrop: a vertical scroll crafted from ancient black paper, adorned with elegant hand-painted Eastern script, its black ink brushstrokes creating a striking contrast to the plant's organic evolution. The controlled lighting subtly changes as the “seasons” pass, casting dynamic shadows that highlight the delicate textures of pencil and calligraphy, creating a tranquil, philosophical atmosphere that contemplates the beauty of the fleeting life cycle.", + "seed": 25568, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000127/group_6/index_1528_seed_25568_dp_12_rank_24_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.11536648822948337, + "vlm_logprob": -0.11536648822948337, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.9, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.11536648822948337, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a single Ulysses plant growing from a green bud into a flower and then a sphere of white seeds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the plant's life cycle compressed into a time-lapse sequence covering multiple stages?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vertical scroll made of ancient black paper with hand-painted Eastern script?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background lighting flicker rapidly to simulate the passage of time while the camera remains perfectly still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the final seeds depicted as a perfect sphere of fluffy white structures resembling delicate parachutes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.032308146357536316 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5323081016540527 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.032308146357536316, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.032308146357536316, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10827368497848511, + 0.054113149642944336, + 0.03482063114643097, + 0.31194746494293213, + 0.06297468394041061, + 0.09312861412763596, + 0.09715517610311508, + 0.02057497575879097, + 0.17519454658031464, + 0.0418170690536499 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.032308146357536316 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a single Ulysses plant growing from a green bud into a flower and then a sphere of white seeds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the plant's life cycle compressed into a time-lapse sequence covering multiple stages?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vertical scroll made of ancient black paper with hand-painted Eastern script?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background lighting flicker rapidly to simulate the passage of time while the camera remains perfectly still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the final seeds depicted as a perfect sphere of fluffy white structures resembling delicate parachutes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004110459703952074 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504110336303711 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004110459703952074, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004110459703952074, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06597207486629486, + 0.029409637674689293, + 0.021692240610718727, + 0.5526819825172424, + 0.06639574468135834, + 0.11435658484697342, + 0.04462164267897606, + 0.016199568286538124, + 0.0347801111638546, + 0.0538904033601284 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004110459703952074 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a single Ulysses plant growing from a green bud into a flower and then a sphere of white seeds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the plant's life cycle compressed into a time-lapse sequence covering multiple stages?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vertical scroll made of ancient black paper with hand-painted Eastern script?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background lighting flicker rapidly to simulate the passage of time while the camera remains perfectly still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the final seeds depicted as a perfect sphere of fluffy white structures resembling delicate parachutes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01419647503644228 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264196395874023 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01419647503644228, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01419647503644228, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19592182338237762, + 0.013140857219696045, + 0.030905185267329216, + 0.39689773321151733, + 0.23884904384613037, + 0.05975249037146568, + 0.016675936058163643, + 0.013745259493589401, + 0.009742923080921173, + 0.02436879090964794 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01419647503644228 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a single Ulysses plant growing from a green bud into a flower and then a sphere of white seeds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the plant's life cycle compressed into a time-lapse sequence covering multiple stages?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vertical scroll made of ancient black paper with hand-painted Eastern script?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background lighting flicker rapidly to simulate the passage of time while the camera remains perfectly still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the final seeds depicted as a perfect sphere of fluffy white structures resembling delicate parachutes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5233991742134094 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8983991742134094 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5233991742134094, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5233991742134094, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12103157490491867, + 0.11433723568916321, + 0.03024393320083618, + 0.443935364484787, + 0.0715649276971817, + 0.09820665419101715, + 0.03005092591047287, + 0.014363358728587627, + 0.03493968024849892, + 0.04132634773850441 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5233991742134094 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a single Ulysses plant growing from a green bud into a flower and then a sphere of white seeds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the plant's life cycle compressed into a time-lapse sequence covering multiple stages?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vertical scroll made of ancient black paper with hand-painted Eastern script?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background lighting flicker rapidly to simulate the passage of time while the camera remains perfectly still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the final seeds depicted as a perfect sphere of fluffy white structures resembling delicate parachutes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0028181858360767365 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.8778181076049805 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0028181858360767365, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0028181858360767365, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15013107657432556, + 0.06012197583913803, + 0.04658811166882515, + 0.11314574629068375, + 0.0695282444357872, + 0.03736504167318344, + 0.20390935242176056, + 0.03542907536029816, + 0.1820000559091568, + 0.10178136080503464 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0028181858360767365 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "single, static, macro-time-lapse shot meticulously documents the accelerated life cycle of a single Ulysses plant, compressing 45 distinct flowering stages over three years into a fluid visual sequence. As a small, green bud first pokes through a patch of dark, fertile soil, the camera remains perfectly still, focused in extreme detail. It rapidly unfolds, revealing a radiant flower with an intricate array of vibrant yellow petals. The time-lapse effect is striking, with the background light rapidly flickering, simulating the passage of countless days and nights as the flower blooms, gracefully withers, and re-blooms in a continuous, hypnotic cycle. In the final stage, the yellow petals shrink, miraculously replaced by a perfect, ethereal sphere of fluffy white seeds, each a delicate parachute with a tiny seed at its base, seemingly poised and ready to be dispersed by the breeze. The entire natural drama is set against a stark, contemplative backdrop: a vertical scroll crafted from ancient black paper, adorned with elegant hand-painted Eastern script, its black ink brushstrokes creating a striking contrast to the plant's organic evolution. The controlled lighting subtly changes as the “seasons” pass, casting dynamic shadows that highlight the delicate textures of pencil and calligraphy, creating a tranquil, philosophical atmosphere that contemplates the beauty of the fleeting life cycle.", + "seed": 25569, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000127/group_6/index_1528_seed_25569_dp_12_rank_24_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.12129912739619612, + "vlm_logprob": -0.12129912739619612, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.25, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.12129912739619612, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a single Ulysses plant growing from a green bud into a flower and then a sphere of white seeds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the plant's life cycle compressed into a time-lapse sequence covering multiple stages?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vertical scroll made of ancient black paper with hand-painted Eastern script?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background lighting flicker rapidly to simulate the passage of time while the camera remains perfectly still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the final seeds depicted as a perfect sphere of fluffy white structures resembling delicate parachutes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012817969545722008 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.512817859649658 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012817969545722008, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012817969545722008, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13036207854747772, + 0.11815062165260315, + 0.09872426837682724, + 0.03340482339262962, + 0.2649438679218292, + 0.05937165021896362, + 0.04191569611430168, + 0.057549409568309784, + 0.053750187158584595, + 0.14182743430137634 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012817969545722008 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a single Ulysses plant growing from a green bud into a flower and then a sphere of white seeds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the plant's life cycle compressed into a time-lapse sequence covering multiple stages?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vertical scroll made of ancient black paper with hand-painted Eastern script?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background lighting flicker rapidly to simulate the passage of time while the camera remains perfectly still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the final seeds depicted as a perfect sphere of fluffy white structures resembling delicate parachutes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0032043324317783117 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753204345703125 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0032043324317783117, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0032043324317783117, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14105932414531708, + 0.11275257170200348, + 0.16948075592517853, + 0.08549848198890686, + 0.1110154464840889, + 0.09910019487142563, + 0.024579718708992004, + 0.05639205500483513, + 0.06896595656871796, + 0.13115546107292175 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0032043324317783117 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a single Ulysses plant growing from a green bud into a flower and then a sphere of white seeds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the plant's life cycle compressed into a time-lapse sequence covering multiple stages?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vertical scroll made of ancient black paper with hand-painted Eastern script?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background lighting flicker rapidly to simulate the passage of time while the camera remains perfectly still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the final seeds depicted as a perfect sphere of fluffy white structures resembling delicate parachutes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012540297582745552 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387540340423584 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012540297582745552, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012540297582745552, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15498347580432892, + 0.5056115388870239, + 0.08548203855752945, + 0.034537747502326965, + 0.03451601788401604, + 0.07848385721445084, + 0.014217358082532883, + 0.02619823068380356, + 0.026014968752861023, + 0.03995468467473984 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012540297582745552 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a single Ulysses plant growing from a green bud into a flower and then a sphere of white seeds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the plant's life cycle compressed into a time-lapse sequence covering multiple stages?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vertical scroll made of ancient black paper with hand-painted Eastern script?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background lighting flicker rapidly to simulate the passage of time while the camera remains perfectly still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the final seeds depicted as a perfect sphere of fluffy white structures resembling delicate parachutes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5762211084365845 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8262211084365845 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5762211084365845, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5762211084365845, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12403646856546402, + 0.13956469297409058, + 0.11199624836444855, + 0.1510062962770462, + 0.24771374464035034, + 0.0484854057431221, + 0.029467590153217316, + 0.031550467014312744, + 0.061579205095767975, + 0.05459989979863167 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5762211084365845 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a single Ulysses plant growing from a green bud into a flower and then a sphere of white seeds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the plant's life cycle compressed into a time-lapse sequence covering multiple stages?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vertical scroll made of ancient black paper with hand-painted Eastern script?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background lighting flicker rapidly to simulate the passage of time while the camera remains perfectly still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the final seeds depicted as a perfect sphere of fluffy white structures resembling delicate parachutes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0017119289841502905 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.376711845397949 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0017119289841502905, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0017119289841502905, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23380762338638306, + 0.0577990896999836, + 0.10246273875236511, + 0.0637580081820488, + 0.06258093565702438, + 0.03572762757539749, + 0.025003550574183464, + 0.09080535918474197, + 0.09072642773389816, + 0.23732861876487732 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0017119289841502905 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "single, static, macro-time-lapse shot meticulously documents the accelerated life cycle of a single Ulysses plant, compressing 45 distinct flowering stages over three years into a fluid visual sequence. As a small, green bud first pokes through a patch of dark, fertile soil, the camera remains perfectly still, focused in extreme detail. It rapidly unfolds, revealing a radiant flower with an intricate array of vibrant yellow petals. The time-lapse effect is striking, with the background light rapidly flickering, simulating the passage of countless days and nights as the flower blooms, gracefully withers, and re-blooms in a continuous, hypnotic cycle. In the final stage, the yellow petals shrink, miraculously replaced by a perfect, ethereal sphere of fluffy white seeds, each a delicate parachute with a tiny seed at its base, seemingly poised and ready to be dispersed by the breeze. The entire natural drama is set against a stark, contemplative backdrop: a vertical scroll crafted from ancient black paper, adorned with elegant hand-painted Eastern script, its black ink brushstrokes creating a striking contrast to the plant's organic evolution. The controlled lighting subtly changes as the “seasons” pass, casting dynamic shadows that highlight the delicate textures of pencil and calligraphy, creating a tranquil, philosophical atmosphere that contemplates the beauty of the fleeting life cycle.", + "seed": 25570, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000127/group_6/index_1528_seed_25570_dp_13_rank_26_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.1595885028131306, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1595885028131306, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.025, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1595885028131306, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a single Ulysses plant growing from a green bud into a flower and then a sphere of white seeds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the plant's life cycle compressed into a time-lapse sequence covering multiple stages?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vertical scroll made of ancient black paper with hand-painted Eastern script?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background lighting flicker rapidly to simulate the passage of time while the camera remains perfectly still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the final seeds depicted as a perfect sphere of fluffy white structures resembling delicate parachutes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.027692623436450958 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6526925563812256 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.027692623436450958, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.027692623436450958, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06038999184966087, + 0.05352496728301048, + 0.027645936235785484, + 0.006699607241898775, + 0.00961218774318695, + 0.02151080220937729, + 0.787392258644104, + 0.015126220881938934, + 0.005375647451728582, + 0.012722328305244446 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.027692623436450958 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a single Ulysses plant growing from a green bud into a flower and then a sphere of white seeds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the plant's life cycle compressed into a time-lapse sequence covering multiple stages?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vertical scroll made of ancient black paper with hand-painted Eastern script?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background lighting flicker rapidly to simulate the passage of time while the camera remains perfectly still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the final seeds depicted as a perfect sphere of fluffy white structures resembling delicate parachutes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004646456800401211 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379646301269531 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004646456800401211, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004646456800401211, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3083757162094116, + 0.1410968154668808, + 0.03382796794176102, + 0.01955481246113777, + 0.020012281835079193, + 0.03679801523685455, + 0.31195640563964844, + 0.053875863552093506, + 0.03654496371746063, + 0.03795725479722023 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004646456800401211 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a single Ulysses plant growing from a green bud into a flower and then a sphere of white seeds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the plant's life cycle compressed into a time-lapse sequence covering multiple stages?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vertical scroll made of ancient black paper with hand-painted Eastern script?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background lighting flicker rapidly to simulate the passage of time while the camera remains perfectly still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the final seeds depicted as a perfect sphere of fluffy white structures resembling delicate parachutes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005252727307379246 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255252838134766 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005252727307379246, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005252727307379246, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5627326965332031, + 0.047547485679388046, + 0.03292630985379219, + 0.02174011617898941, + 0.017198314890265465, + 0.027712970972061157, + 0.21625347435474396, + 0.037493955343961716, + 0.008502558805048466, + 0.027892043814063072 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005252727307379246 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a single Ulysses plant growing from a green bud into a flower and then a sphere of white seeds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the plant's life cycle compressed into a time-lapse sequence covering multiple stages?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vertical scroll made of ancient black paper with hand-painted Eastern script?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background lighting flicker rapidly to simulate the passage of time while the camera remains perfectly still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the final seeds depicted as a perfect sphere of fluffy white structures resembling delicate parachutes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.75786292552948 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.63286292552948 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.75786292552948, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.75786292552948, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3195231854915619, + 0.0977136567234993, + 0.022969737648963928, + 0.02061229944229126, + 0.011632014065980911, + 0.08082414418458939, + 0.37370991706848145, + 0.015127298422157764, + 0.02156643196940422, + 0.03632132709026337 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.75786292552948 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a single Ulysses plant growing from a green bud into a flower and then a sphere of white seeds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the plant's life cycle compressed into a time-lapse sequence covering multiple stages?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vertical scroll made of ancient black paper with hand-painted Eastern script?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background lighting flicker rapidly to simulate the passage of time while the camera remains perfectly still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the final seeds depicted as a perfect sphere of fluffy white structures resembling delicate parachutes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0024877809919416904 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002487659454346 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0024877809919416904, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0024877809919416904, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20842893421649933, + 0.08862410485744476, + 0.027823837473988533, + 0.006973433308303356, + 0.005142157897353172, + 0.03687828779220581, + 0.5781804919242859, + 0.02379641868174076, + 0.008639108389616013, + 0.015513219870626926 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0024877809919416904 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "single, static, macro-time-lapse shot meticulously documents the accelerated life cycle of a single Ulysses plant, compressing 45 distinct flowering stages over three years into a fluid visual sequence. As a small, green bud first pokes through a patch of dark, fertile soil, the camera remains perfectly still, focused in extreme detail. It rapidly unfolds, revealing a radiant flower with an intricate array of vibrant yellow petals. The time-lapse effect is striking, with the background light rapidly flickering, simulating the passage of countless days and nights as the flower blooms, gracefully withers, and re-blooms in a continuous, hypnotic cycle. In the final stage, the yellow petals shrink, miraculously replaced by a perfect, ethereal sphere of fluffy white seeds, each a delicate parachute with a tiny seed at its base, seemingly poised and ready to be dispersed by the breeze. The entire natural drama is set against a stark, contemplative backdrop: a vertical scroll crafted from ancient black paper, adorned with elegant hand-painted Eastern script, its black ink brushstrokes creating a striking contrast to the plant's organic evolution. The controlled lighting subtly changes as the “seasons” pass, casting dynamic shadows that highlight the delicate textures of pencil and calligraphy, creating a tranquil, philosophical atmosphere that contemplates the beauty of the fleeting life cycle.", + "seed": 25571, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000127/group_6/index_1528_seed_25571_dp_13_rank_26_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.23239454727154224, + "vlm_logprob": -0.23239454727154224, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.175000011920929, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.23239454727154224, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a single Ulysses plant growing from a green bud into a flower and then a sphere of white seeds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the plant's life cycle compressed into a time-lapse sequence covering multiple stages?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vertical scroll made of ancient black paper with hand-painted Eastern script?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background lighting flicker rapidly to simulate the passage of time while the camera remains perfectly still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the final seeds depicted as a perfect sphere of fluffy white structures resembling delicate parachutes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012274324893951416 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.512274265289307 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012274324893951416, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012274324893951416, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17489111423492432, + 0.08673747628927231, + 0.07303817570209503, + 0.04079214110970497, + 0.051570482552051544, + 0.04132266715168953, + 0.08756077289581299, + 0.038465630263090134, + 0.14972734451293945, + 0.25589409470558167 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012274324893951416 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a single Ulysses plant growing from a green bud into a flower and then a sphere of white seeds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the plant's life cycle compressed into a time-lapse sequence covering multiple stages?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vertical scroll made of ancient black paper with hand-painted Eastern script?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background lighting flicker rapidly to simulate the passage of time while the camera remains perfectly still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the final seeds depicted as a perfect sphere of fluffy white structures resembling delicate parachutes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036295270547270775 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628629684448242 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036295270547270775, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036295270547270775, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20850075781345367, + 0.09179990738630295, + 0.04480209946632385, + 0.06831996887922287, + 0.11373264342546463, + 0.04223556071519852, + 0.08187227696180344, + 0.04748503863811493, + 0.16973358392715454, + 0.1315182000398636 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036295270547270775 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a single Ulysses plant growing from a green bud into a flower and then a sphere of white seeds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the plant's life cycle compressed into a time-lapse sequence covering multiple stages?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vertical scroll made of ancient black paper with hand-painted Eastern script?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background lighting flicker rapidly to simulate the passage of time while the camera remains perfectly still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the final seeds depicted as a perfect sphere of fluffy white structures resembling delicate parachutes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007631197106093168 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882631301879883 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007631197106093168, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007631197106093168, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.6410744190216064, + 0.03533687815070152, + 0.03163200244307518, + 0.029955435544252396, + 0.04859357699751854, + 0.04103120416402817, + 0.07796225696802139, + 0.025253504514694214, + 0.038435809314250946, + 0.03072495572268963 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007631197106093168 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a single Ulysses plant growing from a green bud into a flower and then a sphere of white seeds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the plant's life cycle compressed into a time-lapse sequence covering multiple stages?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vertical scroll made of ancient black paper with hand-painted Eastern script?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background lighting flicker rapidly to simulate the passage of time while the camera remains perfectly still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the final seeds depicted as a perfect sphere of fluffy white structures resembling delicate parachutes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1370999813079834 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3871000409126282 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.1370999813079834, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.7499999403953552, + "token_credit_reward": -1.1370999813079834, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.31185322999954224, + 0.052957482635974884, + 0.04616906866431236, + 0.04826437681913376, + 0.07372625917196274, + 0.14361870288848877, + 0.08753158152103424, + 0.09447477012872696, + 0.08322610706090927, + 0.058178406208753586 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.1370999813079834 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a single Ulysses plant growing from a green bud into a flower and then a sphere of white seeds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the plant's life cycle compressed into a time-lapse sequence covering multiple stages?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vertical scroll made of ancient black paper with hand-painted Eastern script?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background lighting flicker rapidly to simulate the passage of time while the camera remains perfectly still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the final seeds depicted as a perfect sphere of fluffy white structures resembling delicate parachutes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0013377059949561954 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.62633752822876 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0013377059949561954, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0013377059949561954, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18070749938488007, + 0.057747889310121536, + 0.044458575546741486, + 0.049994271248579025, + 0.02110605500638485, + 0.03338177874684334, + 0.04207601398229599, + 0.02606170065701008, + 0.18047352135181427, + 0.3639926314353943 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0013377059949561954 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000127/group_8/index_tensor([3516, 3516])_group_8_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000127/group_8/index_tensor([3516, 3516])_group_8_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..a75df7f8d41784a8f94e5d63764053c970160699 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000127/group_8/index_tensor([3516, 3516])_group_8_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "The camera pans right, following a man in his early thirties as he enters a cluttered dining room, the camera at eye level. He has slightly tousled brown hair and wears a simple gray cotton hoodie and dark jeans, his brow furrowed in concentration. He clutches a sleek black tablet in both hands, his gaze fixed on its glowing screen, and walks purposefully toward a large wooden dining table buried beneath piles of books, loose papers, and a tangle of cables. He stops beside the table and carefully places the tablet on a small transparent surface. Then, his eyes scan the chaos, and with quick, decisive action, he picks up a closed silver laptop. He leaves the table and deliberately lowers himself to the hardwood floor, sitting cross-legged with his back against a plain off-white wall. He places the laptop on his lap, opens it, and immediately begins typing rapidly and intently, his face bathed in the cool, bluish-white glow of the screen. The entire scene is illuminated by soft, indirect morning light streaming through a large window, creating an atmosphere of quiet concentration that contrasts sharply with the room's visual chaos.", + "seed": 21355, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000127/group_8/index_3516_seed_21355_dp_16_rank_32_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.36191320829093454, + "vlm_logprob": -0.36191320829093454, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.9250000238418579, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.36191320829093454, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a man in his early thirties with slightly tousled brown hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the man wear a simple gray cotton hoodie and dark jeans?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show a cluttered dining room with a large wooden table buried under books, papers, and cables?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man sit cross-legged on the hardwood floor with his back against a plain off-white wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan right while maintaining an eye-level perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08970098197460175 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.464700937271118 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08970098197460175, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08970098197460175, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11765918880701065, + 0.04554736986756325, + 0.0976116880774498, + 0.08696366101503372, + 0.07334459573030472, + 0.13503813743591309, + 0.08639917522668839, + 0.128634974360466, + 0.16779325902462006, + 0.06100793927907944 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08970098197460175 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a man in his early thirties with slightly tousled brown hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the man wear a simple gray cotton hoodie and dark jeans?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show a cluttered dining room with a large wooden table buried under books, papers, and cables?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man sit cross-legged on the hardwood floor with his back against a plain off-white wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan right while maintaining an eye-level perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02635710872709751 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513571739196777 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02635710872709751, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02635710872709751, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08272494375705719, + 0.029643317684531212, + 0.08771239966154099, + 0.020202701911330223, + 0.07634608447551727, + 0.04453868791460991, + 0.07287891954183578, + 0.11437656730413437, + 0.3905147314071655, + 0.08106167614459991 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02635710872709751 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a man in his early thirties with slightly tousled brown hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the man wear a simple gray cotton hoodie and dark jeans?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show a cluttered dining room with a large wooden table buried under books, papers, and cables?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man sit cross-legged on the hardwood floor with his back against a plain off-white wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan right while maintaining an eye-level perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5020583868026733 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.25205838680267334 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.5020583868026733, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -1.5020583868026733, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12328822165727615, + 0.16490429639816284, + 0.07687557488679886, + 0.10560840368270874, + 0.15407738089561462, + 0.10498405992984772, + 0.03549614176154137, + 0.061050113290548325, + 0.127318874001503, + 0.04639686644077301 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 4, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.5020583868026733 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a man in his early thirties with slightly tousled brown hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the man wear a simple gray cotton hoodie and dark jeans?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show a cluttered dining room with a large wooden table buried under books, papers, and cables?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man sit cross-legged on the hardwood floor with his back against a plain off-white wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan right while maintaining an eye-level perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04866647347807884 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048666477203369 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04866647347807884, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04866647347807884, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09872431308031082, + 0.06450220942497253, + 0.03676515072584152, + 0.04192645102739334, + 0.068511463701725, + 0.07157609611749649, + 0.14971108734607697, + 0.08579196780920029, + 0.31049951910972595, + 0.07199174910783768 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04866647347807884 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a man in his early thirties with slightly tousled brown hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the man wear a simple gray cotton hoodie and dark jeans?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show a cluttered dining room with a large wooden table buried under books, papers, and cables?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man sit cross-legged on the hardwood floor with his back against a plain off-white wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan right while maintaining an eye-level perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14278309047222137 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0177831649780273 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14278309047222137, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.8750001192092896, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14278309047222137, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0842040404677391, + 0.04245733097195625, + 0.1208738312125206, + 0.02909453585743904, + 0.06517748534679413, + 0.042893387377262115, + 0.06090986728668213, + 0.12624256312847137, + 0.3924151062965393, + 0.03573187068104744 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14278309047222137 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "The camera pans right, following a man in his early thirties as he enters a cluttered dining room, the camera at eye level. He has slightly tousled brown hair and wears a simple gray cotton hoodie and dark jeans, his brow furrowed in concentration. He clutches a sleek black tablet in both hands, his gaze fixed on its glowing screen, and walks purposefully toward a large wooden dining table buried beneath piles of books, loose papers, and a tangle of cables. He stops beside the table and carefully places the tablet on a small transparent surface. Then, his eyes scan the chaos, and with quick, decisive action, he picks up a closed silver laptop. He leaves the table and deliberately lowers himself to the hardwood floor, sitting cross-legged with his back against a plain off-white wall. He places the laptop on his lap, opens it, and immediately begins typing rapidly and intently, his face bathed in the cool, bluish-white glow of the screen. The entire scene is illuminated by soft, indirect morning light streaming through a large window, creating an atmosphere of quiet concentration that contrasts sharply with the room's visual chaos.", + "seed": 21356, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000127/group_8/index_3516_seed_21356_dp_16_rank_32_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.26558870300650594, + "vlm_logprob": -0.26558870300650594, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.725, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.26558870300650594, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a man in his early thirties with slightly tousled brown hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the man wear a simple gray cotton hoodie and dark jeans?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show a cluttered dining room with a large wooden table buried under books, papers, and cables?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man sit cross-legged on the hardwood floor with his back against a plain off-white wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan right while maintaining an eye-level perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11403582245111465 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2390358448028564 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11403582245111465, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11403582245111465, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1611534059047699, + 0.08897764980792999, + 0.13365066051483154, + 0.11195293813943863, + 0.08532027900218964, + 0.08983659744262695, + 0.08970022946596146, + 0.07812689989805222, + 0.06568169593811035, + 0.09559962153434753 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11403582245111465 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a man in his early thirties with slightly tousled brown hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the man wear a simple gray cotton hoodie and dark jeans?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show a cluttered dining room with a large wooden table buried under books, papers, and cables?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man sit cross-legged on the hardwood floor with his back against a plain off-white wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan right while maintaining an eye-level perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1003321036696434 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.350332021713257 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1003321036696434, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1003321036696434, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14603085815906525, + 0.0899919793009758, + 0.1744210124015808, + 0.11491841822862625, + 0.11103769391775131, + 0.0809759572148323, + 0.08943706750869751, + 0.04008064419031143, + 0.06174416095018387, + 0.09136217832565308 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1003321036696434 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a man in his early thirties with slightly tousled brown hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the man wear a simple gray cotton hoodie and dark jeans?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show a cluttered dining room with a large wooden table buried under books, papers, and cables?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man sit cross-legged on the hardwood floor with his back against a plain off-white wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan right while maintaining an eye-level perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8982884287834167 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5232884287834167 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.8982884287834167, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.8982884287834167, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20415696501731873, + 0.042398616671562195, + 0.10031998157501221, + 0.05027731508016586, + 0.03494749590754509, + 0.05916053056716919, + 0.14595438539981842, + 0.07724330574274063, + 0.19123271107673645, + 0.09430869668722153 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.8982884287834167 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a man in his early thirties with slightly tousled brown hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the man wear a simple gray cotton hoodie and dark jeans?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show a cluttered dining room with a large wooden table buried under books, papers, and cables?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man sit cross-legged on the hardwood floor with his back against a plain off-white wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan right while maintaining an eye-level perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05495632812380791 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299564361572266 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05495632812380791, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05495632812380791, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13035741448402405, + 0.07927020639181137, + 0.13253267109394073, + 0.033828005194664, + 0.07547169178724289, + 0.060865551233291626, + 0.10301611572504044, + 0.11586315929889679, + 0.17012335360050201, + 0.09867186099290848 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05495632812380791 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a man in his early thirties with slightly tousled brown hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the man wear a simple gray cotton hoodie and dark jeans?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show a cluttered dining room with a large wooden table buried under books, papers, and cables?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man sit cross-legged on the hardwood floor with his back against a plain off-white wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan right while maintaining an eye-level perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16033083200454712 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9103307723999023 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16033083200454712, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16033083200454712, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11305922269821167, + 0.06683213263750076, + 0.11969397962093353, + 0.10391170531511307, + 0.10249177366495132, + 0.07404229044914246, + 0.1497446745634079, + 0.06930099427700043, + 0.16574448347091675, + 0.0351787693798542 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16033083200454712 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "The camera pans right, following a man in his early thirties as he enters a cluttered dining room, the camera at eye level. He has slightly tousled brown hair and wears a simple gray cotton hoodie and dark jeans, his brow furrowed in concentration. He clutches a sleek black tablet in both hands, his gaze fixed on its glowing screen, and walks purposefully toward a large wooden dining table buried beneath piles of books, loose papers, and a tangle of cables. He stops beside the table and carefully places the tablet on a small transparent surface. Then, his eyes scan the chaos, and with quick, decisive action, he picks up a closed silver laptop. He leaves the table and deliberately lowers himself to the hardwood floor, sitting cross-legged with his back against a plain off-white wall. He places the laptop on his lap, opens it, and immediately begins typing rapidly and intently, his face bathed in the cool, bluish-white glow of the screen. The entire scene is illuminated by soft, indirect morning light streaming through a large window, creating an atmosphere of quiet concentration that contrasts sharply with the room's visual chaos.", + "seed": 21357, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000127/group_8/index_3516_seed_21357_dp_17_rank_34_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.2266744315624237, + "vlm_logprob": -0.2266744315624237, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.85, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.2266744315624237, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a man in his early thirties with slightly tousled brown hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the man wear a simple gray cotton hoodie and dark jeans?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show a cluttered dining room with a large wooden table buried under books, papers, and cables?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man sit cross-legged on the hardwood floor with his back against a plain off-white wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan right while maintaining an eye-level perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11369220912456512 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.238692283630371 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11369220912456512, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11369220912456512, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1542917788028717, + 0.06433821469545364, + 0.07086456567049026, + 0.07539351284503937, + 0.1142486110329628, + 0.10113590210676193, + 0.13545383512973785, + 0.07887627184391022, + 0.07380548119544983, + 0.1315918266773224 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11369220912456512 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a man in his early thirties with slightly tousled brown hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the man wear a simple gray cotton hoodie and dark jeans?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show a cluttered dining room with a large wooden table buried under books, papers, and cables?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man sit cross-legged on the hardwood floor with his back against a plain off-white wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan right while maintaining an eye-level perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07003571093082428 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695035696029663 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07003571093082428, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07003571093082428, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06648293882608414, + 0.12913186848163605, + 0.05763167142868042, + 0.0690789520740509, + 0.14966973662376404, + 0.04828257113695145, + 0.13255630433559418, + 0.11721177399158478, + 0.10532527416944504, + 0.12462896853685379 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07003571093082428 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a man in his early thirties with slightly tousled brown hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the man wear a simple gray cotton hoodie and dark jeans?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show a cluttered dining room with a large wooden table buried under books, papers, and cables?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man sit cross-legged on the hardwood floor with his back against a plain off-white wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan right while maintaining an eye-level perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7577589750289917 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6327589750289917 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.7577589750289917, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.7577589750289917, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06822142004966736, + 0.06304482370615005, + 0.05047047138214111, + 0.0556899793446064, + 0.08343634754419327, + 0.08209346979856491, + 0.34142306447029114, + 0.04124457389116287, + 0.0813957154750824, + 0.13298016786575317 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.7577589750289917 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a man in his early thirties with slightly tousled brown hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the man wear a simple gray cotton hoodie and dark jeans?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show a cluttered dining room with a large wooden table buried under books, papers, and cables?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man sit cross-legged on the hardwood floor with his back against a plain off-white wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan right while maintaining an eye-level perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1129278764128685 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2379279136657715 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1129278764128685, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1129278764128685, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09159187227487564, + 0.04761488363146782, + 0.03559943288564682, + 0.06257519125938416, + 0.12371265143156052, + 0.06134328246116638, + 0.14681389927864075, + 0.12219499796628952, + 0.08765079826116562, + 0.2209029346704483 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1129278764128685 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a man in his early thirties with slightly tousled brown hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the man wear a simple gray cotton hoodie and dark jeans?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show a cluttered dining room with a large wooden table buried under books, papers, and cables?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man sit cross-legged on the hardwood floor with his back against a plain off-white wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan right while maintaining an eye-level perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07895738631486893 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5789573192596436 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07895738631486893, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07895738631486893, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.100770503282547, + 0.08021719753742218, + 0.03958768770098686, + 0.1037045419216156, + 0.1578807681798935, + 0.16133728623390198, + 0.1076003909111023, + 0.09597770869731903, + 0.10026633739471436, + 0.05265756696462631 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07895738631486893 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "The camera pans right, following a man in his early thirties as he enters a cluttered dining room, the camera at eye level. He has slightly tousled brown hair and wears a simple gray cotton hoodie and dark jeans, his brow furrowed in concentration. He clutches a sleek black tablet in both hands, his gaze fixed on its glowing screen, and walks purposefully toward a large wooden dining table buried beneath piles of books, loose papers, and a tangle of cables. He stops beside the table and carefully places the tablet on a small transparent surface. Then, his eyes scan the chaos, and with quick, decisive action, he picks up a closed silver laptop. He leaves the table and deliberately lowers himself to the hardwood floor, sitting cross-legged with his back against a plain off-white wall. He places the laptop on his lap, opens it, and immediately begins typing rapidly and intently, his face bathed in the cool, bluish-white glow of the screen. The entire scene is illuminated by soft, indirect morning light streaming through a large window, creating an atmosphere of quiet concentration that contrasts sharply with the room's visual chaos.", + "seed": 21358, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000127/group_8/index_3516_seed_21358_dp_17_rank_34_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.23660599142313005, + "vlm_logprob": -0.23660599142313005, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.8249999761581421, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.23660599142313005, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a man in his early thirties with slightly tousled brown hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the man wear a simple gray cotton hoodie and dark jeans?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show a cluttered dining room with a large wooden table buried under books, papers, and cables?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man sit cross-legged on the hardwood floor with his back against a plain off-white wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan right while maintaining an eye-level perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14401908218860626 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.01901912689209 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14401908218860626, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14401908218860626, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12431186437606812, + 0.12916380167007446, + 0.12299027293920517, + 0.0925067737698555, + 0.06515362858772278, + 0.06495889276266098, + 0.11658769100904465, + 0.06001716107130051, + 0.05159221589565277, + 0.17271767556667328 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14401908218860626 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a man in his early thirties with slightly tousled brown hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the man wear a simple gray cotton hoodie and dark jeans?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show a cluttered dining room with a large wooden table buried under books, papers, and cables?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man sit cross-legged on the hardwood floor with his back against a plain off-white wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan right while maintaining an eye-level perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10034191608428955 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.350341796875 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10034191608428955, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10034191608428955, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07913793623447418, + 0.15328824520111084, + 0.05334937572479248, + 0.17380289733409882, + 0.08484843373298645, + 0.048090483993291855, + 0.06405626982450485, + 0.08631187677383423, + 0.055825814604759216, + 0.20128870010375977 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10034191608428955 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a man in his early thirties with slightly tousled brown hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the man wear a simple gray cotton hoodie and dark jeans?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show a cluttered dining room with a large wooden table buried under books, papers, and cables?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man sit cross-legged on the hardwood floor with his back against a plain off-white wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan right while maintaining an eye-level perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7577864527702332 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6327864527702332 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.7577864527702332, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.7577864527702332, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06813527643680573, + 0.08267949521541595, + 0.1772993505001068, + 0.17154504358768463, + 0.04816843941807747, + 0.08140284568071365, + 0.03377089276909828, + 0.08925733715295792, + 0.06433931738138199, + 0.18340197205543518 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.7577864527702332 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a man in his early thirties with slightly tousled brown hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the man wear a simple gray cotton hoodie and dark jeans?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show a cluttered dining room with a large wooden table buried under books, papers, and cables?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man sit cross-legged on the hardwood floor with his back against a plain off-white wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan right while maintaining an eye-level perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.038104988634586334 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288105010986328 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.038104988634586334, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.038104988634586334, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25581952929496765, + 0.05808214098215103, + 0.09576499462127686, + 0.08704304695129395, + 0.06468605995178223, + 0.0674663633108139, + 0.061582062393426895, + 0.08806247264146805, + 0.05110042542219162, + 0.17039288580417633 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.038104988634586334 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a man in his early thirties with slightly tousled brown hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the man wear a simple gray cotton hoodie and dark jeans?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show a cluttered dining room with a large wooden table buried under books, papers, and cables?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man sit cross-legged on the hardwood floor with his back against a plain off-white wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan right while maintaining an eye-level perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14277751743793488 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.017777442932129 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14277751743793488, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.8749998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14277751743793488, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17640815675258636, + 0.14928826689720154, + 0.09080227464437485, + 0.1316915601491928, + 0.1306525319814682, + 0.0622299499809742, + 0.05531533062458038, + 0.10432738065719604, + 0.048568591475486755, + 0.05071595683693886 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14277751743793488 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_0/index_tensor([8760, 8760])_group_0_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_0/index_tensor([8760, 8760])_group_0_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..000bfe4c455b4ce7bd9db7244867d98bc62e5e2a --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_0/index_tensor([8760, 8760])_group_0_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "dynamic, slightly high-angle drone shot smoothly tracks a sleek, metallic charcoal gray Tesla Model S as it glides effortlessly along the center lane of a sprawling multi-lane highway. The car's glossy, aerodynamic body brilliantly reflects the vast, clear blue sky and bright midday sun, with the iconic silver Tesla logo gleaming on the trunk. Through the panoramic windshield, the steering wheel is visible, deftly turning the car itself to navigate the gentle curves of the road, emphasizing its autonomous operation. The dark asphalt stretches to the horizon, marked by crisp white lane dividing lines, while other vehicles in the distance appear as a blur. As the Tesla travels at a serene and steady pace, its wheels spinning and blurring against a backdrop of rolling green hills in the warm, high-contrast sunlight, creating a powerful atmosphere of futuristic tranquility and advanced engineering.", + "seed": 24004, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_0/index_8760_seed_24004_dp_0_rank_0_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.02655063378624618, + "vlm_logprob": -0.02655063378624618, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.25, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.02655063378624618, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, metallic charcoal gray Tesla Model S?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a slightly high angle and tracking the car smoothly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the car driving in the center lane of a sprawling multi-lane highway with dark asphalt and crisp white lane lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of rolling green hills under a vast, clear blue sky with bright midday sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the Tesla's autonomous operation emphasized by showing the steering wheel turning through the panoramic windshield?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02463722787797451 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.149637222290039 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02463722787797451, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02463722787797451, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5880297422409058, + 0.05309271812438965, + 0.056801196187734604, + 0.02320355549454689, + 0.09472987055778503, + 0.04871129244565964, + 0.047367703169584274, + 0.023484041914343834, + 0.04551898315548897, + 0.019060922786593437 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02463722787797451 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, metallic charcoal gray Tesla Model S?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a slightly high angle and tracking the car smoothly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the car driving in the center lane of a sprawling multi-lane highway with dark asphalt and crisp white lane lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of rolling green hills under a vast, clear blue sky with bright midday sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the Tesla's autonomous operation emphasized by showing the steering wheel turning through the panoramic windshield?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009802302345633507 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634802341461182 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009802302345633507, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009802302345633507, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4280240535736084, + 0.11874532699584961, + 0.08722048252820969, + 0.0790969729423523, + 0.057584330439567566, + 0.05226772278547287, + 0.028458192944526672, + 0.04646846652030945, + 0.054922785609960556, + 0.047211747616529465 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009802302345633507 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, metallic charcoal gray Tesla Model S?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a slightly high angle and tracking the car smoothly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the car driving in the center lane of a sprawling multi-lane highway with dark asphalt and crisp white lane lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of rolling green hills under a vast, clear blue sky with bright midday sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the Tesla's autonomous operation emphasized by showing the steering wheel turning through the panoramic windshield?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026340505108237267 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513404846191406 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026340505108237267, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026340505108237267, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1961299031972885, + 0.13411074876785278, + 0.1314443051815033, + 0.12104328721761703, + 0.08781418949365616, + 0.11814554780721664, + 0.048235710710287094, + 0.07567154616117477, + 0.034673117101192474, + 0.052731625735759735 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026340505108237267 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, metallic charcoal gray Tesla Model S?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a slightly high angle and tracking the car smoothly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the car driving in the center lane of a sprawling multi-lane highway with dark asphalt and crisp white lane lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of rolling green hills under a vast, clear blue sky with bright midday sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the Tesla's autonomous operation emphasized by showing the steering wheel turning through the panoramic windshield?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0019392033573240042 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.251939296722412 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0019392033573240042, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0019392033573240042, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3702634274959564, + 0.1920907348394394, + 0.10903044790029526, + 0.07650430500507355, + 0.04809834063053131, + 0.03315932676196098, + 0.03837823495268822, + 0.0437534935772419, + 0.019316881895065308, + 0.06940482556819916 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0019392033573240042 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, metallic charcoal gray Tesla Model S?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a slightly high angle and tracking the car smoothly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the car driving in the center lane of a sprawling multi-lane highway with dark asphalt and crisp white lane lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of rolling green hills under a vast, clear blue sky with bright midday sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the Tesla's autonomous operation emphasized by showing the steering wheel turning through the panoramic windshield?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07003393024206161 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950340270996094 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07003393024206161, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07003393024206161, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.26195085048675537, + 0.0700015127658844, + 0.11871479451656342, + 0.039318982511758804, + 0.05981576442718506, + 0.050157658755779266, + 0.05709391087293625, + 0.11979731917381287, + 0.17480064928531647, + 0.04834848642349243 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07003393024206161 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dynamic, slightly high-angle drone shot smoothly tracks a sleek, metallic charcoal gray Tesla Model S as it glides effortlessly along the center lane of a sprawling multi-lane highway. The car's glossy, aerodynamic body brilliantly reflects the vast, clear blue sky and bright midday sun, with the iconic silver Tesla logo gleaming on the trunk. Through the panoramic windshield, the steering wheel is visible, deftly turning the car itself to navigate the gentle curves of the road, emphasizing its autonomous operation. The dark asphalt stretches to the horizon, marked by crisp white lane dividing lines, while other vehicles in the distance appear as a blur. As the Tesla travels at a serene and steady pace, its wheels spinning and blurring against a backdrop of rolling green hills in the warm, high-contrast sunlight, creating a powerful atmosphere of futuristic tranquility and advanced engineering.", + "seed": 24005, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_0/index_8760_seed_24005_dp_0_rank_0_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.02444058479741216, + "vlm_logprob": -0.02444058479741216, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.25, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.02444058479741216, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, metallic charcoal gray Tesla Model S?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a slightly high angle and tracking the car smoothly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the car driving in the center lane of a sprawling multi-lane highway with dark asphalt and crisp white lane lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of rolling green hills under a vast, clear blue sky with bright midday sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the Tesla's autonomous operation emphasized by showing the steering wheel turning through the panoramic windshield?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0372961163520813 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5372960567474365 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0372961163520813, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0372961163520813, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07005628943443298, + 0.03732658550143242, + 0.009991418570280075, + 0.042995091527700424, + 0.04085524380207062, + 0.47976070642471313, + 0.07710016518831253, + 0.08638668805360794, + 0.045952171087265015, + 0.10957568883895874 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0372961163520813 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, metallic charcoal gray Tesla Model S?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a slightly high angle and tracking the car smoothly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the car driving in the center lane of a sprawling multi-lane highway with dark asphalt and crisp white lane lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of rolling green hills under a vast, clear blue sky with bright midday sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the Tesla's autonomous operation emphasized by showing the steering wheel turning through the panoramic windshield?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005961731541901827 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130961894989014 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005961731541901827, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005961731541901827, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1319272816181183, + 0.03684309870004654, + 0.022835196927189827, + 0.10735386610031128, + 0.03390070050954819, + 0.3913480043411255, + 0.06199634075164795, + 0.12442313879728317, + 0.05421466752886772, + 0.035157617181539536 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005961731541901827 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, metallic charcoal gray Tesla Model S?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a slightly high angle and tracking the car smoothly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the car driving in the center lane of a sprawling multi-lane highway with dark asphalt and crisp white lane lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of rolling green hills under a vast, clear blue sky with bright midday sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the Tesla's autonomous operation emphasized by showing the steering wheel turning through the panoramic windshield?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03368542343378067 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4086854457855225 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03368542343378067, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03368542343378067, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06661875545978546, + 0.039008188992738724, + 0.03550063818693161, + 0.10753898322582245, + 0.04812281206250191, + 0.46869421005249023, + 0.04402270168066025, + 0.06938532739877701, + 0.02999783866107464, + 0.09111056476831436 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03368542343378067 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, metallic charcoal gray Tesla Model S?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a slightly high angle and tracking the car smoothly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the car driving in the center lane of a sprawling multi-lane highway with dark asphalt and crisp white lane lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of rolling green hills under a vast, clear blue sky with bright midday sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the Tesla's autonomous operation emphasized by showing the steering wheel turning through the panoramic windshield?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0021955687552690506 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127195358276367 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0021955687552690506, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0021955687552690506, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0444449707865715, + 0.016154194250702858, + 0.016320737078785896, + 0.037905700504779816, + 0.03971074894070625, + 0.3457523286342621, + 0.020631851628422737, + 0.3470761477947235, + 0.03314528614282608, + 0.09885804355144501 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0021955687552690506 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, metallic charcoal gray Tesla Model S?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a slightly high angle and tracking the car smoothly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the car driving in the center lane of a sprawling multi-lane highway with dark asphalt and crisp white lane lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of rolling green hills under a vast, clear blue sky with bright midday sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the Tesla's autonomous operation emphasized by showing the steering wheel turning through the panoramic windshield?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04306408390402794 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680641174316406 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04306408390402794, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04306408390402794, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.024804560467600822, + 0.04848169907927513, + 0.017957907170057297, + 0.035454053431749344, + 0.039780840277671814, + 0.3888375461101532, + 0.024933669716119766, + 0.1740160584449768, + 0.09787590801715851, + 0.14785775542259216 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04306408390402794 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dynamic, slightly high-angle drone shot smoothly tracks a sleek, metallic charcoal gray Tesla Model S as it glides effortlessly along the center lane of a sprawling multi-lane highway. The car's glossy, aerodynamic body brilliantly reflects the vast, clear blue sky and bright midday sun, with the iconic silver Tesla logo gleaming on the trunk. Through the panoramic windshield, the steering wheel is visible, deftly turning the car itself to navigate the gentle curves of the road, emphasizing its autonomous operation. The dark asphalt stretches to the horizon, marked by crisp white lane dividing lines, while other vehicles in the distance appear as a blur. As the Tesla travels at a serene and steady pace, its wheels spinning and blurring against a backdrop of rolling green hills in the warm, high-contrast sunlight, creating a powerful atmosphere of futuristic tranquility and advanced engineering.", + "seed": 24006, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_0/index_8760_seed_24006_dp_1_rank_2_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.046835515392012896, + "vlm_logprob": -0.046835515392012896, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.85, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.046835515392012896, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, metallic charcoal gray Tesla Model S?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a slightly high angle and tracking the car smoothly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the car driving in the center lane of a sprawling multi-lane highway with dark asphalt and crisp white lane lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of rolling green hills under a vast, clear blue sky with bright midday sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the Tesla's autonomous operation emphasized by showing the steering wheel turning through the panoramic windshield?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05386699363589287 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1788671016693115 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05386699363589287, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05386699363589287, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08831902593374252, + 0.05085478350520134, + 0.07587993890047073, + 0.09791699051856995, + 0.17812296748161316, + 0.04788052663207054, + 0.11068816483020782, + 0.047651104629039764, + 0.033463332802057266, + 0.2692231237888336 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05386699363589287 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, metallic charcoal gray Tesla Model S?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a slightly high angle and tracking the car smoothly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the car driving in the center lane of a sprawling multi-lane highway with dark asphalt and crisp white lane lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of rolling green hills under a vast, clear blue sky with bright midday sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the Tesla's autonomous operation emphasized by showing the steering wheel turning through the panoramic windshield?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011105747893452644 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511105537414551 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011105747893452644, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011105747893452644, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10281489789485931, + 0.05683869495987892, + 0.04744740203022957, + 0.06405734270811081, + 0.09803769737482071, + 0.054954931139945984, + 0.13849163055419922, + 0.06206945329904556, + 0.10914034396409988, + 0.26614758372306824 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011105747893452644 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, metallic charcoal gray Tesla Model S?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a slightly high angle and tracking the car smoothly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the car driving in the center lane of a sprawling multi-lane highway with dark asphalt and crisp white lane lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of rolling green hills under a vast, clear blue sky with bright midday sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the Tesla's autonomous operation emphasized by showing the steering wheel turning through the panoramic windshield?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07896102219820023 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.578961133956909 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07896102219820023, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07896102219820023, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1494864672422409, + 0.23634843528270721, + 0.060825515538454056, + 0.18029139935970306, + 0.11334315687417984, + 0.03799783065915108, + 0.0884011909365654, + 0.06577228754758835, + 0.0470118373632431, + 0.020521845668554306 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07896102219820023 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, metallic charcoal gray Tesla Model S?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a slightly high angle and tracking the car smoothly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the car driving in the center lane of a sprawling multi-lane highway with dark asphalt and crisp white lane lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of rolling green hills under a vast, clear blue sky with bright midday sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the Tesla's autonomous operation emphasized by showing the steering wheel turning through the panoramic windshield?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.001179595128633082 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.7511796951293945 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.001179595128633082, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.001179595128633082, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13038019835948944, + 0.08200079947710037, + 0.04143417999148369, + 0.12741073966026306, + 0.21319794654846191, + 0.05463084951043129, + 0.1389102041721344, + 0.07971843332052231, + 0.0515657477080822, + 0.08075089752674103 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.001179595128633082 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, metallic charcoal gray Tesla Model S?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a slightly high angle and tracking the car smoothly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the car driving in the center lane of a sprawling multi-lane highway with dark asphalt and crisp white lane lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of rolling green hills under a vast, clear blue sky with bright midday sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the Tesla's autonomous operation emphasized by showing the steering wheel turning through the panoramic windshield?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08906421810388565 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.464064121246338 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08906421810388565, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08906421810388565, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15693463385105133, + 0.08411911875009537, + 0.0391879677772522, + 0.05335548520088196, + 0.05329512804746628, + 0.0817832499742508, + 0.14606907963752747, + 0.05689685046672821, + 0.06275735050439835, + 0.2656010687351227 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08906421810388565 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dynamic, slightly high-angle drone shot smoothly tracks a sleek, metallic charcoal gray Tesla Model S as it glides effortlessly along the center lane of a sprawling multi-lane highway. The car's glossy, aerodynamic body brilliantly reflects the vast, clear blue sky and bright midday sun, with the iconic silver Tesla logo gleaming on the trunk. Through the panoramic windshield, the steering wheel is visible, deftly turning the car itself to navigate the gentle curves of the road, emphasizing its autonomous operation. The dark asphalt stretches to the horizon, marked by crisp white lane dividing lines, while other vehicles in the distance appear as a blur. As the Tesla travels at a serene and steady pace, its wheels spinning and blurring against a backdrop of rolling green hills in the warm, high-contrast sunlight, creating a powerful atmosphere of futuristic tranquility and advanced engineering.", + "seed": 24007, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_0/index_8760_seed_24007_dp_1_rank_2_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.029829541314393283, + "vlm_logprob": -0.029829541314393283, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.25, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.029829541314393283, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, metallic charcoal gray Tesla Model S?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a slightly high angle and tracking the car smoothly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the car driving in the center lane of a sprawling multi-lane highway with dark asphalt and crisp white lane lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of rolling green hills under a vast, clear blue sky with bright midday sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the Tesla's autonomous operation emphasized by showing the steering wheel turning through the panoramic windshield?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03725511580705643 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.662255048751831 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03725511580705643, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03725511580705643, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12316649407148361, + 0.08101382106542587, + 0.11796769499778748, + 0.039288587868213654, + 0.09285690635442734, + 0.05550496652722359, + 0.11698152869939804, + 0.07578936964273453, + 0.09185999631881714, + 0.20557066798210144 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03725511580705643 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, metallic charcoal gray Tesla Model S?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a slightly high angle and tracking the car smoothly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the car driving in the center lane of a sprawling multi-lane highway with dark asphalt and crisp white lane lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of rolling green hills under a vast, clear blue sky with bright midday sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the Tesla's autonomous operation emphasized by showing the steering wheel turning through the panoramic windshield?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005275258328765631 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255275249481201 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005275258328765631, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005275258328765631, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05915958434343338, + 0.1179991140961647, + 0.11625441908836365, + 0.03493529185652733, + 0.2121565192937851, + 0.08634325116872787, + 0.0787479504942894, + 0.039377421140670776, + 0.1138930693268776, + 0.14113329350948334 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005275258328765631 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, metallic charcoal gray Tesla Model S?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a slightly high angle and tracking the car smoothly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the car driving in the center lane of a sprawling multi-lane highway with dark asphalt and crisp white lane lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of rolling green hills under a vast, clear blue sky with bright midday sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the Tesla's autonomous operation emphasized by showing the steering wheel turning through the panoramic windshield?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.043050382286310196 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680502891540527 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.043050382286310196, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.043050382286310196, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14656268060207367, + 0.0619765929877758, + 0.1972830444574356, + 0.06353620439767838, + 0.03409724682569504, + 0.05510121211409569, + 0.06296148896217346, + 0.10814197361469269, + 0.12819109857082367, + 0.1421484500169754 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.043050382286310196 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, metallic charcoal gray Tesla Model S?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a slightly high angle and tracking the car smoothly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the car driving in the center lane of a sprawling multi-lane highway with dark asphalt and crisp white lane lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of rolling green hills under a vast, clear blue sky with bright midday sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the Tesla's autonomous operation emphasized by showing the steering wheel turning through the panoramic windshield?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0015113847330212593 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.501511573791504 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0015113847330212593, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0015113847330212593, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19717518985271454, + 0.07603925466537476, + 0.12134125828742981, + 0.06647603213787079, + 0.055963508784770966, + 0.09807930886745453, + 0.1457187682390213, + 0.10730882734060287, + 0.05883953720331192, + 0.07305829226970673 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0015113847330212593 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, metallic charcoal gray Tesla Model S?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a slightly high angle and tracking the car smoothly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the car driving in the center lane of a sprawling multi-lane highway with dark asphalt and crisp white lane lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of rolling green hills under a vast, clear blue sky with bright midday sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the Tesla's autonomous operation emphasized by showing the steering wheel turning through the panoramic windshield?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0620555654168129 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120555877685547 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0620555654168129, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0620555654168129, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08637474477291107, + 0.040088873356580734, + 0.1506349891424179, + 0.0440840907394886, + 0.18171276152133942, + 0.05735680088400841, + 0.06763001531362534, + 0.04990170896053314, + 0.2002675086259842, + 0.12194853276014328 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0620555654168129 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_1/index_tensor([1546, 1546])_group_1_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_1/index_tensor([1546, 1546])_group_1_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..fcfe08e97668436dcfed46cfa3512e8906d78e20 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_1/index_tensor([1546, 1546])_group_1_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "static, ultra-macro shot, positioned at a slight high angle, immerses the viewer in a miniature world, focusing on a tiny snail perched on the vibrant green surface of a broad, damp leaf. Its perfectly shaped spiral shell is a masterpiece of natural geometry, shimmering with captivating iridescence, reflecting soft, shifting hues of purple, blue, and gold in the diffused morning light. Glittering, spherical water droplets cling to the leaf's waxy veins, amplifying their prominent textures and reflecting the soft-focus bokeh of the surrounding foliage. The snail's body remains coiled, almost completely hidden, a static form of profound stillness, but its two delicate, stem-like tentacles emerge, twitching subtly, almost imperceptibly, in slow, curious exploration, plucking the moist air. Bathed in cool, soft light, the scene creates an atmosphere of serene tranquility and absorbed wonder, highlighting the subtle beauty of this quiet moment in nature.", + "seed": 4750, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_1/index_1546_seed_4750_dp_2_rank_4_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.10376645317301154, + "vlm_logprob": -0.10376645317301154, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.3, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.10376645317301154, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, ultra-macro view of a tiny snail on a broad, damp leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the snail's shell a vibrant green spiral with iridescent reflections of purple, blue, and gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are glittering, spherical water droplets visible clinging to the leaf's waxy veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the snail's body coiled and hidden while only its two delicate tentacles emerge and twitch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in cool, soft light with a soft-focus bokeh background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.022308237850666046 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.897308349609375 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.022308237850666046, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.022308237850666046, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3261028230190277, + 0.13686327636241913, + 0.1686297506093979, + 0.029195168986916542, + 0.0966515839099884, + 0.03239913284778595, + 0.050354328006505966, + 0.05333095043897629, + 0.047361236065626144, + 0.05911169946193695 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.022308237850666046 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, ultra-macro view of a tiny snail on a broad, damp leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the snail's shell a vibrant green spiral with iridescent reflections of purple, blue, and gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are glittering, spherical water droplets visible clinging to the leaf's waxy veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the snail's body coiled and hidden while only its two delicate tentacles emerge and twitch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in cool, soft light with a soft-focus bokeh background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20158874988555908 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.701588749885559 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20158874988555908, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20158874988555908, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.31023213267326355, + 0.0690971240401268, + 0.366643488407135, + 0.04629907384514809, + 0.05566838011145592, + 0.020794840529561043, + 0.02609884925186634, + 0.04662040248513222, + 0.049506060779094696, + 0.009039584547281265 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20158874988555908 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, ultra-macro view of a tiny snail on a broad, damp leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the snail's shell a vibrant green spiral with iridescent reflections of purple, blue, and gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are glittering, spherical water droplets visible clinging to the leaf's waxy veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the snail's body coiled and hidden while only its two delicate tentacles emerge and twitch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in cool, soft light with a soft-focus bokeh background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007636283989995718 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882636070251465 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007636283989995718, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007636283989995718, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07054859399795532, + 0.04790983721613884, + 0.362201452255249, + 0.027824049815535545, + 0.03174601122736931, + 0.33221882581710815, + 0.033533528447151184, + 0.020031683146953583, + 0.019281059503555298, + 0.05470498651266098 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007636283989995718 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, ultra-macro view of a tiny snail on a broad, damp leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the snail's shell a vibrant green spiral with iridescent reflections of purple, blue, and gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are glittering, spherical water droplets visible clinging to the leaf's waxy veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the snail's body coiled and hidden while only its two delicate tentacles emerge and twitch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in cool, soft light with a soft-focus bokeh background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.28134745359420776 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4063475131988525 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.28134745359420776, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.28134745359420776, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20807990431785583, + 0.029909074306488037, + 0.46787670254707336, + 0.015111708082258701, + 0.10505026578903198, + 0.04196803644299507, + 0.08717438578605652, + 0.014249265193939209, + 0.016313742846250534, + 0.014266928657889366 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.28134745359420776 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, ultra-macro view of a tiny snail on a broad, damp leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the snail's shell a vibrant green spiral with iridescent reflections of purple, blue, and gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are glittering, spherical water droplets visible clinging to the leaf's waxy veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the snail's body coiled and hidden while only its two delicate tentacles emerge and twitch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in cool, soft light with a soft-focus bokeh background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005951540544629097 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130951404571533 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005951540544629097, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005951540544629097, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17362669110298157, + 0.1275547593832016, + 0.41416212916374207, + 0.02143005281686783, + 0.0756293311715126, + 0.03638637438416481, + 0.036662664264440536, + 0.037018582224845886, + 0.04266104847192764, + 0.034868352115154266 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005951540544629097 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, ultra-macro shot, positioned at a slight high angle, immerses the viewer in a miniature world, focusing on a tiny snail perched on the vibrant green surface of a broad, damp leaf. Its perfectly shaped spiral shell is a masterpiece of natural geometry, shimmering with captivating iridescence, reflecting soft, shifting hues of purple, blue, and gold in the diffused morning light. Glittering, spherical water droplets cling to the leaf's waxy veins, amplifying their prominent textures and reflecting the soft-focus bokeh of the surrounding foliage. The snail's body remains coiled, almost completely hidden, a static form of profound stillness, but its two delicate, stem-like tentacles emerge, twitching subtly, almost imperceptibly, in slow, curious exploration, plucking the moist air. Bathed in cool, soft light, the scene creates an atmosphere of serene tranquility and absorbed wonder, highlighting the subtle beauty of this quiet moment in nature.", + "seed": 4751, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_1/index_1546_seed_4751_dp_2_rank_4_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.25022100694477556, + "vlm_logprob": -0.25022100694477556, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.675, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.25022100694477556, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, ultra-macro view of a tiny snail on a broad, damp leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the snail's shell a vibrant green spiral with iridescent reflections of purple, blue, and gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are glittering, spherical water droplets visible clinging to the leaf's waxy veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the snail's body coiled and hidden while only its two delicate tentacles emerge and twitch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in cool, soft light with a soft-focus bokeh background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011742754839360714 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.63674259185791 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011742754839360714, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011742754839360714, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13230076432228088, + 0.09911131858825684, + 0.08642518520355225, + 0.0773283913731575, + 0.04003996402025223, + 0.04036487266421318, + 0.1271497905254364, + 0.21511618793010712, + 0.12532660365104675, + 0.056836940348148346 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011742754839360714 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, ultra-macro view of a tiny snail on a broad, damp leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the snail's shell a vibrant green spiral with iridescent reflections of purple, blue, and gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are glittering, spherical water droplets visible clinging to the leaf's waxy veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the snail's body coiled and hidden while only its two delicate tentacles emerge and twitch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in cool, soft light with a soft-focus bokeh background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6328775882720947 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7578775882720947 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.6328775882720947, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.6328775882720947, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04115600138902664, + 0.028223717585206032, + 0.040688078850507736, + 0.09186190366744995, + 0.046792831271886826, + 0.008707954548299313, + 0.05385706573724747, + 0.018221653997898102, + 0.631879448890686, + 0.03861134126782417 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 3, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.6328775882720947 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, ultra-macro view of a tiny snail on a broad, damp leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the snail's shell a vibrant green spiral with iridescent reflections of purple, blue, and gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are glittering, spherical water droplets visible clinging to the leaf's waxy veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the snail's body coiled and hidden while only its two delicate tentacles emerge and twitch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in cool, soft light with a soft-focus bokeh background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016093354672193527 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.1410932540893555 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016093354672193527, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016093354672193527, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3240426182746887, + 0.1330278217792511, + 0.09359989315271378, + 0.06586764752864838, + 0.06015849858522415, + 0.039777375757694244, + 0.020701982080936432, + 0.03579051420092583, + 0.06784090399742126, + 0.15919271111488342 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016093354672193527 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, ultra-macro view of a tiny snail on a broad, damp leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the snail's shell a vibrant green spiral with iridescent reflections of purple, blue, and gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are glittering, spherical water droplets visible clinging to the leaf's waxy veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the snail's body coiled and hidden while only its two delicate tentacles emerge and twitch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in cool, soft light with a soft-focus bokeh background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5761851072311401 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8261851072311401 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5761851072311401, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5761851072311401, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.061844248324632645, + 0.04038960486650467, + 0.10558910667896271, + 0.19222228229045868, + 0.03150961920619011, + 0.055884577333927155, + 0.03153100609779358, + 0.0675753727555275, + 0.2261686772108078, + 0.18728552758693695 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5761851072311401 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, ultra-macro view of a tiny snail on a broad, damp leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the snail's shell a vibrant green spiral with iridescent reflections of purple, blue, and gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are glittering, spherical water droplets visible clinging to the leaf's waxy veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the snail's body coiled and hidden while only its two delicate tentacles emerge and twitch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in cool, soft light with a soft-focus bokeh background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014206229709088802 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264206409454346 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014206229709088802, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014206229709088802, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1359328180551529, + 0.043224919587373734, + 0.06898898631334305, + 0.09681569039821625, + 0.061608538031578064, + 0.04564037173986435, + 0.040352191776037216, + 0.14346051216125488, + 0.2629186809062958, + 0.10105720162391663 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014206229709088802 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, ultra-macro shot, positioned at a slight high angle, immerses the viewer in a miniature world, focusing on a tiny snail perched on the vibrant green surface of a broad, damp leaf. Its perfectly shaped spiral shell is a masterpiece of natural geometry, shimmering with captivating iridescence, reflecting soft, shifting hues of purple, blue, and gold in the diffused morning light. Glittering, spherical water droplets cling to the leaf's waxy veins, amplifying their prominent textures and reflecting the soft-focus bokeh of the surrounding foliage. The snail's body remains coiled, almost completely hidden, a static form of profound stillness, but its two delicate, stem-like tentacles emerge, twitching subtly, almost imperceptibly, in slow, curious exploration, plucking the moist air. Bathed in cool, soft light, the scene creates an atmosphere of serene tranquility and absorbed wonder, highlighting the subtle beauty of this quiet moment in nature.", + "seed": 4752, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_1/index_1546_seed_4752_dp_3_rank_6_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.1936545024625957, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1936545024625957, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.25, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1936545024625957, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, ultra-macro view of a tiny snail on a broad, damp leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the snail's shell a vibrant green spiral with iridescent reflections of purple, blue, and gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are glittering, spherical water droplets visible clinging to the leaf's waxy veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the snail's body coiled and hidden while only its two delicate tentacles emerge and twitch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in cool, soft light with a soft-focus bokeh background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0074628377333283424 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.257462978363037 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0074628377333283424, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0074628377333283424, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.027431949973106384, + 0.017117783427238464, + 0.019266478717327118, + 0.010869973339140415, + 0.0693630650639534, + 0.02144942432641983, + 0.021386930719017982, + 0.010768603533506393, + 0.5664243698120117, + 0.2359214574098587 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0074628377333283424 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, ultra-macro view of a tiny snail on a broad, damp leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the snail's shell a vibrant green spiral with iridescent reflections of purple, blue, and gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are glittering, spherical water droplets visible clinging to the leaf's waxy veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the snail's body coiled and hidden while only its two delicate tentacles emerge and twitch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in cool, soft light with a soft-focus bokeh background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6934019923210144 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6934019923210144 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.6934019923210144, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.6934019923210144, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07248116284608841, + 0.03150944411754608, + 0.019404835999011993, + 0.010749555192887783, + 0.046682603657245636, + 0.010200527496635914, + 0.009766750037670135, + 0.020186571404337883, + 0.40178433060646057, + 0.37723422050476074 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.6934019923210144 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, ultra-macro view of a tiny snail on a broad, damp leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the snail's shell a vibrant green spiral with iridescent reflections of purple, blue, and gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are glittering, spherical water droplets visible clinging to the leaf's waxy veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the snail's body coiled and hidden while only its two delicate tentacles emerge and twitch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in cool, soft light with a soft-focus bokeh background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007645629812031984 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882645606994629 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007645629812031984, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007645629812031984, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06506957113742828, + 0.05232296511530876, + 0.14785894751548767, + 0.010435081087052822, + 0.014534329995512962, + 0.0151840690523386, + 0.01461203582584858, + 0.009034945629537106, + 0.2931022644042969, + 0.377845823764801 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007645629812031984 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, ultra-macro view of a tiny snail on a broad, damp leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the snail's shell a vibrant green spiral with iridescent reflections of purple, blue, and gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are glittering, spherical water droplets visible clinging to the leaf's waxy veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the snail's body coiled and hidden while only its two delicate tentacles emerge and twitch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in cool, soft light with a soft-focus bokeh background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2521294355392456 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5021294355392456 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2521294355392456, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2521294355392456, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0331345871090889, + 0.035751745104789734, + 0.03492556884884834, + 0.04266446828842163, + 0.0335213877260685, + 0.016778694465756416, + 0.011737474240362644, + 0.010953270830214024, + 0.6818950176239014, + 0.09863767772912979 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2521294355392456 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, ultra-macro view of a tiny snail on a broad, damp leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the snail's shell a vibrant green spiral with iridescent reflections of purple, blue, and gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are glittering, spherical water droplets visible clinging to the leaf's waxy veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the snail's body coiled and hidden while only its two delicate tentacles emerge and twitch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in cool, soft light with a soft-focus bokeh background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0076326169073581696 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882632732391357 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0076326169073581696, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0076326169073581696, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03297216072678566, + 0.013883376494050026, + 0.007293045520782471, + 0.00798303447663784, + 0.015127363614737988, + 0.0068245213478803635, + 0.006274427752941847, + 0.005200556479394436, + 0.15438757836818695, + 0.7500540018081665 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0076326169073581696 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, ultra-macro shot, positioned at a slight high angle, immerses the viewer in a miniature world, focusing on a tiny snail perched on the vibrant green surface of a broad, damp leaf. Its perfectly shaped spiral shell is a masterpiece of natural geometry, shimmering with captivating iridescence, reflecting soft, shifting hues of purple, blue, and gold in the diffused morning light. Glittering, spherical water droplets cling to the leaf's waxy veins, amplifying their prominent textures and reflecting the soft-focus bokeh of the surrounding foliage. The snail's body remains coiled, almost completely hidden, a static form of profound stillness, but its two delicate, stem-like tentacles emerge, twitching subtly, almost imperceptibly, in slow, curious exploration, plucking the moist air. Bathed in cool, soft light, the scene creates an atmosphere of serene tranquility and absorbed wonder, highlighting the subtle beauty of this quiet moment in nature.", + "seed": 4753, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_1/index_1546_seed_4753_dp_3_rank_6_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.19772711396217346, + "vlm_logprob": -0.19772711396217346, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.675, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.19772711396217346, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, ultra-macro view of a tiny snail on a broad, damp leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the snail's shell a vibrant green spiral with iridescent reflections of purple, blue, and gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are glittering, spherical water droplets visible clinging to the leaf's waxy veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the snail's body coiled and hidden while only its two delicate tentacles emerge and twitch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in cool, soft light with a soft-focus bokeh background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.017025504261255264 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.267025470733643 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.017025504261255264, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.017025504261255264, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13973897695541382, + 0.047567322850227356, + 0.059296268969774246, + 0.08233258128166199, + 0.09267304092645645, + 0.050233516842126846, + 0.1359335333108902, + 0.04893643781542778, + 0.2929416000843048, + 0.05034675821661949 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.017025504261255264 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, ultra-macro view of a tiny snail on a broad, damp leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the snail's shell a vibrant green spiral with iridescent reflections of purple, blue, and gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are glittering, spherical water droplets visible clinging to the leaf's waxy veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the snail's body coiled and hidden while only its two delicate tentacles emerge and twitch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in cool, soft light with a soft-focus bokeh background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.34867575764656067 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2236757278442383 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.34867575764656067, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.34867575764656067, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.057568516582250595, + 0.05406520515680313, + 0.2342360019683838, + 0.3186807930469513, + 0.12023655325174332, + 0.019587446004152298, + 0.06658374518156052, + 0.014364471659064293, + 0.08620569109916687, + 0.02847154811024666 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.34867575764656067 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, ultra-macro view of a tiny snail on a broad, damp leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the snail's shell a vibrant green spiral with iridescent reflections of purple, blue, and gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are glittering, spherical water droplets visible clinging to the leaf's waxy veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the snail's body coiled and hidden while only its two delicate tentacles emerge and twitch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in cool, soft light with a soft-focus bokeh background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03811853006482124 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288118600845337 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03811853006482124, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03811853006482124, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.31407466530799866, + 0.08380275964736938, + 0.11453965306282043, + 0.09455901384353638, + 0.07013238221406937, + 0.033624470233917236, + 0.043931715190410614, + 0.047347281128168106, + 0.15540559589862823, + 0.042582493275403976 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03811853006482124 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, ultra-macro view of a tiny snail on a broad, damp leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the snail's shell a vibrant green spiral with iridescent reflections of purple, blue, and gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are glittering, spherical water droplets visible clinging to the leaf's waxy veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the snail's body coiled and hidden while only its two delicate tentacles emerge and twitch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in cool, soft light with a soft-focus bokeh background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5761732459068298 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8261732459068298 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5761732459068298, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5761732459068298, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07610103487968445, + 0.24836736917495728, + 0.057624880224466324, + 0.07695769518613815, + 0.14908042550086975, + 0.034881267696619034, + 0.13969124853610992, + 0.06802347302436829, + 0.11464635282754898, + 0.034626226872205734 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5761732459068298 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, ultra-macro view of a tiny snail on a broad, damp leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the snail's shell a vibrant green spiral with iridescent reflections of purple, blue, and gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are glittering, spherical water droplets visible clinging to the leaf's waxy veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the snail's body coiled and hidden while only its two delicate tentacles emerge and twitch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in cool, soft light with a soft-focus bokeh background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008642531931400299 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758642673492432 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008642531931400299, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008642531931400299, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17769965529441833, + 0.06145789846777916, + 0.052770525217056274, + 0.06460218131542206, + 0.13321569561958313, + 0.03603202849626541, + 0.23980729281902313, + 0.0624866858124733, + 0.07908506691455841, + 0.09284289926290512 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008642531931400299 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_10/index_tensor([7801, 7801])_group_10_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_10/index_tensor([7801, 7801])_group_10_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..71c8f84635d87566a6bc3ec2b6af3a466de43c7d --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_10/index_tensor([7801, 7801])_group_10_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "static, low-angle shot immerses the viewer in the damp jungle floor, where a scene of primal awe unfolds. A massive snake begins to slowly unfurl, its body arranged into thick coils of muscle that dwarf the surrounding foliage. Its obsidian scales, each a perfectly formed piece of smooth, inky black armor, shimmer with a rainbow hue in the dim light of a few stray moonlight rays that penetrate the dense canopy above. The damp ground, a black tapestry of decaying leaves, gnarled roots, and vibrant green moss, releases a light mist that clings to the snake's lower coils. The unfurling is an inevitable, fluid movement; the powerful body rises steadily and deliberately, scales sliding silently against each other as the creature's form extends to the forest floor. As it raises its head, revealing eyes like molten amber that glow faintly in the darkness, a forked black tongue flicks out, savoring the humid air. The play of fragmented light and deep shadows creates a dramatic black-and-white contrast, accentuating the creatures’ immense size and creating a tense, majestic atmosphere of an ancient power awakening in the heart of the wilderness.", + "seed": 23890, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_10/index_7801_seed_23890_dp_20_rank_40_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.04960347907617688, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04960347907617688, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.55, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04960347907617688, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a damp jungle floor with decaying leaves, gnarled roots, and vibrant green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive snake with obsidian scales visible, arranged in thick coils that dwarf the surrounding foliage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the snake slowly unfurl its body in a fluid movement, rising steadily from the forest floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the snake's eyes visible as molten amber glowing faintly, and does a forked black tongue flick out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, low-angle view with a dramatic black-and-white contrast created by fragmented light and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009583420120179653 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.884583473205566 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009583420120179653, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009583420120179653, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05688111111521721, + 0.5964558720588684, + 0.03100421465933323, + 0.01737687923014164, + 0.06116288900375366, + 0.03341570124030113, + 0.13164043426513672, + 0.01735982671380043, + 0.03348752483725548, + 0.02121555060148239 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009583420120179653 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a damp jungle floor with decaying leaves, gnarled roots, and vibrant green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive snake with obsidian scales visible, arranged in thick coils that dwarf the surrounding foliage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the snake slowly unfurl its body in a fluid movement, rising steadily from the forest floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the snake's eyes visible as molten amber glowing faintly, and does a forked black tongue flick out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, low-angle view with a dramatic black-and-white contrast created by fragmented light and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00596374599263072 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.1309638023376465 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00596374599263072, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00596374599263072, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12981492280960083, + 0.13141316175460815, + 0.06172144040465355, + 0.04939988628029823, + 0.1823531836271286, + 0.02006668783724308, + 0.2824338376522064, + 0.056126777082681656, + 0.058384716510772705, + 0.028285393491387367 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00596374599263072 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a damp jungle floor with decaying leaves, gnarled roots, and vibrant green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive snake with obsidian scales visible, arranged in thick coils that dwarf the surrounding foliage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the snake slowly unfurl its body in a fluid movement, rising steadily from the forest floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the snake's eyes visible as molten amber glowing faintly, and does a forked black tongue flick out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, low-angle view with a dramatic black-and-white contrast created by fragmented light and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04306282848119736 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168062925338745 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04306282848119736, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04306282848119736, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07126232981681824, + 0.3313836455345154, + 0.040230538696050644, + 0.08961950987577438, + 0.02674972638487816, + 0.061786260455846786, + 0.08849181979894638, + 0.07290486991405487, + 0.1769852340221405, + 0.04058608412742615 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 8, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04306282848119736 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a damp jungle floor with decaying leaves, gnarled roots, and vibrant green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive snake with obsidian scales visible, arranged in thick coils that dwarf the surrounding foliage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the snake slowly unfurl its body in a fluid movement, rising steadily from the forest floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the snake's eyes visible as molten amber glowing faintly, and does a forked black tongue flick out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, low-angle view with a dramatic black-and-white contrast created by fragmented light and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10036510229110718 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.350365161895752 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10036510229110718, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10036510229110718, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03622930869460106, + 0.22219474613666534, + 0.05865572765469551, + 0.05431326478719711, + 0.033181332051754, + 0.05026869475841522, + 0.1836424171924591, + 0.11338839679956436, + 0.21778717637062073, + 0.030338943004608154 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10036510229110718 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a damp jungle floor with decaying leaves, gnarled roots, and vibrant green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive snake with obsidian scales visible, arranged in thick coils that dwarf the surrounding foliage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the snake slowly unfurl its body in a fluid movement, rising steadily from the forest floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the snake's eyes visible as molten amber glowing faintly, and does a forked black tongue flick out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, low-angle view with a dramatic black-and-white contrast created by fragmented light and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0890422984957695 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4640421867370605 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0890422984957695, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0890422984957695, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15485581755638123, + 0.1389368325471878, + 0.06300580501556396, + 0.08037219196557999, + 0.15373417735099792, + 0.040302470326423645, + 0.09331662952899933, + 0.18340197205543518, + 0.07209768146276474, + 0.019976455718278885 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0890422984957695 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, low-angle shot immerses the viewer in the damp jungle floor, where a scene of primal awe unfolds. A massive snake begins to slowly unfurl, its body arranged into thick coils of muscle that dwarf the surrounding foliage. Its obsidian scales, each a perfectly formed piece of smooth, inky black armor, shimmer with a rainbow hue in the dim light of a few stray moonlight rays that penetrate the dense canopy above. The damp ground, a black tapestry of decaying leaves, gnarled roots, and vibrant green moss, releases a light mist that clings to the snake's lower coils. The unfurling is an inevitable, fluid movement; the powerful body rises steadily and deliberately, scales sliding silently against each other as the creature's form extends to the forest floor. As it raises its head, revealing eyes like molten amber that glow faintly in the darkness, a forked black tongue flicks out, savoring the humid air. The play of fragmented light and deep shadows creates a dramatic black-and-white contrast, accentuating the creatures’ immense size and creating a tense, majestic atmosphere of an ancient power awakening in the heart of the wilderness.", + "seed": 23891, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_10/index_7801_seed_23891_dp_20_rank_40_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.07856389079242945, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07856389079242945, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.125, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07856389079242945, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a damp jungle floor with decaying leaves, gnarled roots, and vibrant green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive snake with obsidian scales visible, arranged in thick coils that dwarf the surrounding foliage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the snake slowly unfurl its body in a fluid movement, rising steadily from the forest floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the snake's eyes visible as molten amber glowing faintly, and does a forked black tongue flick out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, low-angle view with a dramatic black-and-white contrast created by fragmented light and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007939211092889309 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.007939338684082 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007939211092889309, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007939211092889309, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12396714091300964, + 0.05887472257018089, + 0.04359545558691025, + 0.052702438086271286, + 0.12748382985591888, + 0.20364630222320557, + 0.1273568719625473, + 0.0866767019033432, + 0.11633748561143875, + 0.05935906618833542 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007939211092889309 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a damp jungle floor with decaying leaves, gnarled roots, and vibrant green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive snake with obsidian scales visible, arranged in thick coils that dwarf the surrounding foliage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the snake slowly unfurl its body in a fluid movement, rising steadily from the forest floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the snake's eyes visible as molten amber glowing faintly, and does a forked black tongue flick out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, low-angle view with a dramatic black-and-white contrast created by fragmented light and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02636558562517166 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513655185699463 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02636558562517166, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02636558562517166, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05273447930812836, + 0.04172239825129509, + 0.09701744467020035, + 0.03445396199822426, + 0.09977950900793076, + 0.12901343405246735, + 0.2513781487941742, + 0.05103426054120064, + 0.1950153410434723, + 0.047850996255874634 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02636558562517166 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a damp jungle floor with decaying leaves, gnarled roots, and vibrant green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive snake with obsidian scales visible, arranged in thick coils that dwarf the surrounding foliage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the snake slowly unfurl its body in a fluid movement, rising steadily from the forest floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the snake's eyes visible as molten amber glowing faintly, and does a forked black tongue flick out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, low-angle view with a dramatic black-and-white contrast created by fragmented light and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1270616054534912 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.127061605453491 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1270616054534912, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1270616054534912, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0728592723608017, + 0.04450054466724396, + 0.24767576158046722, + 0.06071603670716286, + 0.04715576022863388, + 0.1148875281214714, + 0.19397872686386108, + 0.061588894575834274, + 0.06305272877216339, + 0.09358475357294083 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1270616054534912 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a damp jungle floor with decaying leaves, gnarled roots, and vibrant green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive snake with obsidian scales visible, arranged in thick coils that dwarf the surrounding foliage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the snake slowly unfurl its body in a fluid movement, rising steadily from the forest floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the snake's eyes visible as molten amber glowing faintly, and does a forked black tongue flick out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, low-angle view with a dramatic black-and-white contrast created by fragmented light and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2016497552394867 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.701649785041809 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2016497552394867, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2016497552394867, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17029964923858643, + 0.028617186471819878, + 0.06128544360399246, + 0.0372738316655159, + 0.14620818197727203, + 0.11097396910190582, + 0.29893314838409424, + 0.03267481178045273, + 0.06693196296691895, + 0.04680183529853821 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2016497552394867 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a damp jungle floor with decaying leaves, gnarled roots, and vibrant green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive snake with obsidian scales visible, arranged in thick coils that dwarf the surrounding foliage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the snake slowly unfurl its body in a fluid movement, rising steadily from the forest floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the snake's eyes visible as molten amber glowing faintly, and does a forked black tongue flick out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, low-angle view with a dramatic black-and-white contrast created by fragmented light and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02980329655110836 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298032760620117 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02980329655110836, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02980329655110836, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11024735867977142, + 0.0447213239967823, + 0.06735975295305252, + 0.10824593156576157, + 0.08614242076873779, + 0.23413792252540588, + 0.08147156238555908, + 0.07781956344842911, + 0.12313708662986755, + 0.0667169839143753 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02980329655110836 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, low-angle shot immerses the viewer in the damp jungle floor, where a scene of primal awe unfolds. A massive snake begins to slowly unfurl, its body arranged into thick coils of muscle that dwarf the surrounding foliage. Its obsidian scales, each a perfectly formed piece of smooth, inky black armor, shimmer with a rainbow hue in the dim light of a few stray moonlight rays that penetrate the dense canopy above. The damp ground, a black tapestry of decaying leaves, gnarled roots, and vibrant green moss, releases a light mist that clings to the snake's lower coils. The unfurling is an inevitable, fluid movement; the powerful body rises steadily and deliberately, scales sliding silently against each other as the creature's form extends to the forest floor. As it raises its head, revealing eyes like molten amber that glow faintly in the darkness, a forked black tongue flicks out, savoring the humid air. The play of fragmented light and deep shadows creates a dramatic black-and-white contrast, accentuating the creatures’ immense size and creating a tense, majestic atmosphere of an ancient power awakening in the heart of the wilderness.", + "seed": 23892, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_10/index_7801_seed_23892_dp_21_rank_42_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.053611107543110846, + "vlm_logprob": -0.053611107543110846, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.425000023841858, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.053611107543110846, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a damp jungle floor with decaying leaves, gnarled roots, and vibrant green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive snake with obsidian scales visible, arranged in thick coils that dwarf the surrounding foliage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the snake slowly unfurl its body in a fluid movement, rising steadily from the forest floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the snake's eyes visible as molten amber glowing faintly, and does a forked black tongue flick out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, low-angle view with a dramatic black-and-white contrast created by fragmented light and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00898733176290989 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.8839874267578125 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00898733176290989, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00898733176290989, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21804018318653107, + 0.11784236878156662, + 0.15618069469928741, + 0.05103270709514618, + 0.020360562950372696, + 0.05151129886507988, + 0.1024973914027214, + 0.07481648772954941, + 0.11467785388231277, + 0.09304043650627136 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00898733176290989 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a damp jungle floor with decaying leaves, gnarled roots, and vibrant green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive snake with obsidian scales visible, arranged in thick coils that dwarf the surrounding foliage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the snake slowly unfurl its body in a fluid movement, rising steadily from the forest floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the snake's eyes visible as molten amber glowing faintly, and does a forked black tongue flick out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, low-angle view with a dramatic black-and-white contrast created by fragmented light and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011085234582424164 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511085033416748 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011085234582424164, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011085234582424164, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10591863840818405, + 0.25062990188598633, + 0.24278436601161957, + 0.04414625093340874, + 0.047764040529727936, + 0.039880432188510895, + 0.07250965386629105, + 0.034600671380758286, + 0.08680376410484314, + 0.07496224343776703 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011085234582424164 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a damp jungle floor with decaying leaves, gnarled roots, and vibrant green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive snake with obsidian scales visible, arranged in thick coils that dwarf the surrounding foliage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the snake slowly unfurl its body in a fluid movement, rising steadily from the forest floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the snake's eyes visible as molten amber glowing faintly, and does a forked black tongue flick out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, low-angle view with a dramatic black-and-white contrast created by fragmented light and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06204940378665924 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812049388885498 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06204940378665924, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06204940378665924, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11887161433696747, + 0.12636183202266693, + 0.2043979912996292, + 0.04453672096133232, + 0.05982275307178497, + 0.057074785232543945, + 0.0832221508026123, + 0.13212764263153076, + 0.10036734491586685, + 0.07321716099977493 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06204940378665924 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a damp jungle floor with decaying leaves, gnarled roots, and vibrant green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive snake with obsidian scales visible, arranged in thick coils that dwarf the surrounding foliage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the snake slowly unfurl its body in a fluid movement, rising steadily from the forest floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the snake's eyes visible as molten amber glowing faintly, and does a forked black tongue flick out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, low-angle view with a dramatic black-and-white contrast created by fragmented light and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14287176728248596 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.017871856689453 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14287176728248596, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.8750001192092896, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14287176728248596, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11564286053180695, + 0.04612760245800018, + 0.46494442224502563, + 0.03241356834769249, + 0.031154688447713852, + 0.06418430060148239, + 0.07704376429319382, + 0.05045695975422859, + 0.06523609161376953, + 0.05279567837715149 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14287176728248596 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a damp jungle floor with decaying leaves, gnarled roots, and vibrant green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive snake with obsidian scales visible, arranged in thick coils that dwarf the surrounding foliage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the snake slowly unfurl its body in a fluid movement, rising steadily from the forest floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the snake's eyes visible as molten amber glowing faintly, and does a forked black tongue flick out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, low-angle view with a dramatic black-and-white contrast created by fragmented light and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04306180030107498 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680617332458496 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04306180030107498, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04306180030107498, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16027233004570007, + 0.12353785336017609, + 0.12763020396232605, + 0.14985233545303345, + 0.023274727165699005, + 0.04488205537199974, + 0.07648948580026627, + 0.06080044433474541, + 0.10085824877023697, + 0.13240230083465576 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04306180030107498 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, low-angle shot immerses the viewer in the damp jungle floor, where a scene of primal awe unfolds. A massive snake begins to slowly unfurl, its body arranged into thick coils of muscle that dwarf the surrounding foliage. Its obsidian scales, each a perfectly formed piece of smooth, inky black armor, shimmer with a rainbow hue in the dim light of a few stray moonlight rays that penetrate the dense canopy above. The damp ground, a black tapestry of decaying leaves, gnarled roots, and vibrant green moss, releases a light mist that clings to the snake's lower coils. The unfurling is an inevitable, fluid movement; the powerful body rises steadily and deliberately, scales sliding silently against each other as the creature's form extends to the forest floor. As it raises its head, revealing eyes like molten amber that glow faintly in the darkness, a forked black tongue flicks out, savoring the humid air. The play of fragmented light and deep shadows creates a dramatic black-and-white contrast, accentuating the creatures’ immense size and creating a tense, majestic atmosphere of an ancient power awakening in the heart of the wilderness.", + "seed": 23893, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_10/index_7801_seed_23893_dp_21_rank_42_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.08259740211069584, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08259740211069584, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.775, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08259740211069584, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a damp jungle floor with decaying leaves, gnarled roots, and vibrant green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive snake with obsidian scales visible, arranged in thick coils that dwarf the surrounding foliage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the snake slowly unfurl its body in a fluid movement, rising steadily from the forest floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the snake's eyes visible as molten amber glowing faintly, and does a forked black tongue flick out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, low-angle view with a dramatic black-and-white contrast created by fragmented light and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01116127334535122 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.6361613273620605 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01116127334535122, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01116127334535122, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15672214329242706, + 0.22540408372879028, + 0.0488867424428463, + 0.2561872601509094, + 0.09041561931371689, + 0.02542618289589882, + 0.06230225786566734, + 0.055236537009477615, + 0.025756454095244408, + 0.05366267263889313 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01116127334535122 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a damp jungle floor with decaying leaves, gnarled roots, and vibrant green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive snake with obsidian scales visible, arranged in thick coils that dwarf the surrounding foliage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the snake slowly unfurl its body in a fluid movement, rising steadily from the forest floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the snake's eyes visible as molten amber glowing faintly, and does a forked black tongue flick out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, low-angle view with a dramatic black-and-white contrast created by fragmented light and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10032649338245392 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3503265380859375 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10032649338245392, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10032649338245392, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1115417405962944, + 0.23894844949245453, + 0.04289181903004646, + 0.317927747964859, + 0.11129789799451828, + 0.04992934316396713, + 0.03794820234179497, + 0.030647367238998413, + 0.021850375458598137, + 0.03701696917414665 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10032649338245392 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a damp jungle floor with decaying leaves, gnarled roots, and vibrant green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive snake with obsidian scales visible, arranged in thick coils that dwarf the surrounding foliage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the snake slowly unfurl its body in a fluid movement, rising steadily from the forest floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the snake's eyes visible as molten amber glowing faintly, and does a forked black tongue flick out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, low-angle view with a dramatic black-and-white contrast created by fragmented light and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0620616190135479 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120615482330322 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0620616190135479, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0620616190135479, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3073159158229828, + 0.0586370974779129, + 0.08608236908912659, + 0.3239986002445221, + 0.037096623331308365, + 0.024319589138031006, + 0.03043288178741932, + 0.05248705670237541, + 0.021133974194526672, + 0.058495890349149704 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0620616190135479 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a damp jungle floor with decaying leaves, gnarled roots, and vibrant green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive snake with obsidian scales visible, arranged in thick coils that dwarf the surrounding foliage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the snake slowly unfurl its body in a fluid movement, rising steadily from the forest floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the snake's eyes visible as molten amber glowing faintly, and does a forked black tongue flick out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, low-angle view with a dramatic black-and-white contrast created by fragmented light and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16043826937675476 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9104382991790771 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16043826937675476, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16043826937675476, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11044366657733917, + 0.13451460003852844, + 0.12156480550765991, + 0.29178276658058167, + 0.07070623338222504, + 0.05197950825095177, + 0.026111209765076637, + 0.08141546696424484, + 0.04312474653124809, + 0.06835697591304779 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16043826937675476 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a damp jungle floor with decaying leaves, gnarled roots, and vibrant green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive snake with obsidian scales visible, arranged in thick coils that dwarf the surrounding foliage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the snake slowly unfurl its body in a fluid movement, rising steadily from the forest floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the snake's eyes visible as molten amber glowing faintly, and does a forked black tongue flick out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, low-angle view with a dramatic black-and-white contrast created by fragmented light and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0789993554353714 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5789992809295654 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0789993554353714, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0789993554353714, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.31977760791778564, + 0.14783799648284912, + 0.07336809486150742, + 0.09010710567235947, + 0.03966090828180313, + 0.04562855884432793, + 0.05085914582014084, + 0.09780815988779068, + 0.04319583252072334, + 0.09175660461187363 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0789993554353714 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_11/index_tensor([8920, 8920])_group_11_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_11/index_tensor([8920, 8920])_group_11_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..125bd5e69085e3c9369a5017f3d12b0269804ae7 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_11/index_tensor([8920, 8920])_group_11_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "In a minimalist, all-white studio setting, a 360-degree orbiting camera, filmed at a steady, constant speed, orbits the impending impact point from a level-headed perspective. The camera captures a sleek, cherry-red sports car with a streamlined silhouette and low body, its high-gloss paint reflecting a mirror-like sheen under even, shadowless diffuse light, hurtling at high speed towards a solid, pure white wall. Captured in ultra-slow motion, the moment of impact is elongated: At the moment of impact, ripples appear on the high-gloss paint, followed by the instant shattering of the front bumper. The hood, creased like paper under the immense force of the impact, buckles upward, revealing its intricate internal mechanisms. Metal shards and glass particles explode outward in the even, shadowless diffuse light, each fragment clearly reflecting light, while the windshield displays a spiderweb-like crack. As the camera continues to circle, we are able to observe from every angle the physical process of the car body metal twisting and tearing under pressure. The whole picture presents a cold and shocking visual effect, transforming the violent moment of the high-speed collision into a dynamic sculpture full of technological beauty.", + "seed": 23985, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_11/index_8920_seed_23985_dp_22_rank_44_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.14255886347964405, + "vlm_logprob": -0.14255886347964405, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.625, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.14255886347964405, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a minimalist, all-white studio environment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, cherry-red sports car with a low body and streamlined silhouette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a 360-degree orbit around the impact point at a steady, constant speed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in ultra-slow motion showing the car hitting a solid white wall and the subsequent shattering of the bumper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting even and shadowless diffuse, causing the car's paint to reflect a mirror-like sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.25365403294563293 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5036540031433105 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.25365403294563293, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.25365403294563293, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5515742301940918, + 0.08529099076986313, + 0.08486787229776382, + 0.026015741750597954, + 0.0351097397506237, + 0.02375411055982113, + 0.03374599665403366, + 0.05706996098160744, + 0.06087033823132515, + 0.041700929403305054 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.25365403294563293 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a minimalist, all-white studio environment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, cherry-red sports car with a low body and streamlined silhouette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a 360-degree orbit around the impact point at a steady, constant speed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in ultra-slow motion showing the car hitting a solid white wall and the subsequent shattering of the bumper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting even and shadowless diffuse, causing the car's paint to reflect a mirror-like sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00283316383138299 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877833366394043 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00283316383138299, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00283316383138299, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2848269045352936, + 0.061575908213853836, + 0.05347112566232681, + 0.06564078480005264, + 0.06427541375160217, + 0.07985834777355194, + 0.10177396237850189, + 0.13831187784671783, + 0.07640247046947479, + 0.07386316359043121 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00283316383138299 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a minimalist, all-white studio environment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, cherry-red sports car with a low body and streamlined silhouette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a 360-degree orbit around the impact point at a steady, constant speed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in ultra-slow motion showing the car hitting a solid white wall and the subsequent shattering of the bumper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting even and shadowless diffuse, causing the car's paint to reflect a mirror-like sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2813236117362976 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4063236713409424 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2813236117362976, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2813236117362976, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09357993304729462, + 0.07039827108383179, + 0.12516391277313232, + 0.07992429286241531, + 0.0793914943933487, + 0.10261940956115723, + 0.08987484872341156, + 0.2917487621307373, + 0.03471473976969719, + 0.03258434683084488 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2813236117362976 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a minimalist, all-white studio environment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, cherry-red sports car with a low body and streamlined silhouette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a 360-degree orbit around the impact point at a steady, constant speed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in ultra-slow motion showing the car hitting a solid white wall and the subsequent shattering of the bumper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting even and shadowless diffuse, causing the car's paint to reflect a mirror-like sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11292234063148499 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.237922430038452 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11292234063148499, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11292234063148499, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13622988760471344, + 0.07481694221496582, + 0.03678342327475548, + 0.07478804886341095, + 0.07938223332166672, + 0.07563617080450058, + 0.048322297632694244, + 0.40755319595336914, + 0.039109982550144196, + 0.027377789840102196 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11292234063148499 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a minimalist, all-white studio environment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, cherry-red sports car with a low body and streamlined silhouette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a 360-degree orbit around the impact point at a steady, constant speed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in ultra-slow motion showing the car hitting a solid white wall and the subsequent shattering of the bumper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting even and shadowless diffuse, causing the car's paint to reflect a mirror-like sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06206116825342178 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812061071395874 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06206116825342178, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06206116825342178, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.49254366755485535, + 0.042494870722293854, + 0.03807393088936806, + 0.03738068789243698, + 0.041380465030670166, + 0.045898426324129105, + 0.028175173327326775, + 0.16392061114311218, + 0.04922541603446007, + 0.06090676784515381 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06206116825342178 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a minimalist, all-white studio setting, a 360-degree orbiting camera, filmed at a steady, constant speed, orbits the impending impact point from a level-headed perspective. The camera captures a sleek, cherry-red sports car with a streamlined silhouette and low body, its high-gloss paint reflecting a mirror-like sheen under even, shadowless diffuse light, hurtling at high speed towards a solid, pure white wall. Captured in ultra-slow motion, the moment of impact is elongated: At the moment of impact, ripples appear on the high-gloss paint, followed by the instant shattering of the front bumper. The hood, creased like paper under the immense force of the impact, buckles upward, revealing its intricate internal mechanisms. Metal shards and glass particles explode outward in the even, shadowless diffuse light, each fragment clearly reflecting light, while the windshield displays a spiderweb-like crack. As the camera continues to circle, we are able to observe from every angle the physical process of the car body metal twisting and tearing under pressure. The whole picture presents a cold and shocking visual effect, transforming the violent moment of the high-speed collision into a dynamic sculpture full of technological beauty.", + "seed": 23986, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_11/index_8920_seed_23986_dp_22_rank_44_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.0807620784966275, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0807620784966275, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.5, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0807620784966275, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a minimalist, all-white studio environment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, cherry-red sports car with a low body and streamlined silhouette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a 360-degree orbit around the impact point at a steady, constant speed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in ultra-slow motion showing the car hitting a solid white wall and the subsequent shattering of the bumper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting even and shadowless diffuse, causing the car's paint to reflect a mirror-like sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.028062330558896065 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.653062343597412 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.028062330558896065, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.028062330558896065, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08811858296394348, + 0.031115619465708733, + 0.029958071187138557, + 0.10202420502901077, + 0.04246104136109352, + 0.14977456629276276, + 0.1919303834438324, + 0.3254392445087433, + 0.014034638181328773, + 0.025143617764115334 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.028062330558896065 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a minimalist, all-white studio environment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, cherry-red sports car with a low body and streamlined silhouette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a 360-degree orbit around the impact point at a steady, constant speed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in ultra-slow motion showing the car hitting a solid white wall and the subsequent shattering of the bumper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting even and shadowless diffuse, causing the car's paint to reflect a mirror-like sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0013442536583170295 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.626344203948975 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0013442536583170295, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0013442536583170295, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14128868281841278, + 0.11169534921646118, + 0.1260954737663269, + 0.06287635117769241, + 0.08356412500143051, + 0.13711993396282196, + 0.09990570694208145, + 0.10247335582971573, + 0.07019023597240448, + 0.06479079276323318 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0013442536583170295 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a minimalist, all-white studio environment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, cherry-red sports car with a low body and streamlined silhouette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a 360-degree orbit around the impact point at a steady, constant speed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in ultra-slow motion showing the car hitting a solid white wall and the subsequent shattering of the bumper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting even and shadowless diffuse, causing the car's paint to reflect a mirror-like sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2813447415828705 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4063447713851929 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2813447415828705, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2813447415828705, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11860764026641846, + 0.16106559336185455, + 0.05208727344870567, + 0.1071937307715416, + 0.04742598533630371, + 0.17045271396636963, + 0.14597190916538239, + 0.10431940853595734, + 0.0377490296959877, + 0.05512676388025284 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2813447415828705 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a minimalist, all-white studio environment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, cherry-red sports car with a low body and streamlined silhouette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a 360-degree orbit around the impact point at a steady, constant speed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in ultra-slow motion showing the car hitting a solid white wall and the subsequent shattering of the bumper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting even and shadowless diffuse, causing the car's paint to reflect a mirror-like sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03809179365634918 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2880918979644775 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03809179365634918, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03809179365634918, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06563769280910492, + 0.04890550300478935, + 0.032446715980768204, + 0.09510991722345352, + 0.10551021248102188, + 0.38284429907798767, + 0.07053906470537186, + 0.12323173880577087, + 0.04239371791481972, + 0.033381156623363495 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 7, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03809179365634918 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a minimalist, all-white studio environment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, cherry-red sports car with a low body and streamlined silhouette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a 360-degree orbit around the impact point at a steady, constant speed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in ultra-slow motion showing the car hitting a solid white wall and the subsequent shattering of the bumper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting even and shadowless diffuse, causing the car's paint to reflect a mirror-like sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05496727302670479 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929967164993286 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05496727302670479, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05496727302670479, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14568573236465454, + 0.055336397141218185, + 0.04251221567392349, + 0.1083134189248085, + 0.04592953622341156, + 0.2143922597169876, + 0.19525392353534698, + 0.1288299709558487, + 0.03269977867603302, + 0.031046736985445023 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05496727302670479 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a minimalist, all-white studio setting, a 360-degree orbiting camera, filmed at a steady, constant speed, orbits the impending impact point from a level-headed perspective. The camera captures a sleek, cherry-red sports car with a streamlined silhouette and low body, its high-gloss paint reflecting a mirror-like sheen under even, shadowless diffuse light, hurtling at high speed towards a solid, pure white wall. Captured in ultra-slow motion, the moment of impact is elongated: At the moment of impact, ripples appear on the high-gloss paint, followed by the instant shattering of the front bumper. The hood, creased like paper under the immense force of the impact, buckles upward, revealing its intricate internal mechanisms. Metal shards and glass particles explode outward in the even, shadowless diffuse light, each fragment clearly reflecting light, while the windshield displays a spiderweb-like crack. As the camera continues to circle, we are able to observe from every angle the physical process of the car body metal twisting and tearing under pressure. The whole picture presents a cold and shocking visual effect, transforming the violent moment of the high-speed collision into a dynamic sculpture full of technological beauty.", + "seed": 23987, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_11/index_8920_seed_23987_dp_23_rank_46_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.6442490900401026, + "vlm_logprob": -0.6442490900401026, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.3, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.6442490900401026, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.6, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a minimalist, all-white studio environment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, cherry-red sports car with a low body and streamlined silhouette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a 360-degree orbit around the impact point at a steady, constant speed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in ultra-slow motion showing the car hitting a solid white wall and the subsequent shattering of the bumper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting even and shadowless diffuse, causing the car's paint to reflect a mirror-like sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0195397287607193 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.019539833068848 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0195397287607193, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0195397287607193, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4768340289592743, + 0.05222508683800697, + 0.052740391343832016, + 0.0412018857896328, + 0.06399722397327423, + 0.11879409849643707, + 0.088614821434021, + 0.05784701555967331, + 0.017760222777724266, + 0.029985185712575912 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0195397287607193 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a minimalist, all-white studio environment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, cherry-red sports car with a low body and streamlined silhouette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a 360-degree orbit around the impact point at a steady, constant speed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in ultra-slow motion showing the car hitting a solid white wall and the subsequent shattering of the bumper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting even and shadowless diffuse, causing the car's paint to reflect a mirror-like sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0011917401570826769 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.75119161605835 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0011917401570826769, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0011917401570826769, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.47663021087646484, + 0.03965325281023979, + 0.07499566674232483, + 0.051504842936992645, + 0.08086457848548889, + 0.13159982860088348, + 0.05213521420955658, + 0.024270640686154366, + 0.020122425630688667, + 0.04822332039475441 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0011917401570826769 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a minimalist, all-white studio environment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, cherry-red sports car with a low body and streamlined silhouette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a 360-degree orbit around the impact point at a steady, constant speed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in ultra-slow motion showing the car hitting a solid white wall and the subsequent shattering of the bumper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting even and shadowless diffuse, causing the car's paint to reflect a mirror-like sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6933763027191162 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6933763027191162 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.6933763027191162, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.6933763027191162, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14259396493434906, + 0.07593193650245667, + 0.049600787460803986, + 0.08065170049667358, + 0.16167326271533966, + 0.24014462530612946, + 0.07385600358247757, + 0.08768171817064285, + 0.03490866720676422, + 0.05295732617378235 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.6933763027191162 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a minimalist, all-white studio environment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, cherry-red sports car with a low body and streamlined silhouette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a 360-degree orbit around the impact point at a steady, constant speed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in ultra-slow motion showing the car hitting a solid white wall and the subsequent shattering of the bumper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting even and shadowless diffuse, causing the car's paint to reflect a mirror-like sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4640071392059326 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0890071839094162 + ], + "logprob_reward": -2.4640071392059326, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -2.4640071392059326, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.35136568546295166, + 0.05155821889638901, + 0.029508017003536224, + 0.037384986877441406, + 0.12255866825580597, + 0.12319981306791306, + 0.08377756178379059, + 0.09045406430959702, + 0.058252137154340744, + 0.05194089934229851 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -2.4640071392059326 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a minimalist, all-white studio environment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, cherry-red sports car with a low body and streamlined silhouette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a 360-degree orbit around the impact point at a steady, constant speed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in ultra-slow motion showing the car hitting a solid white wall and the subsequent shattering of the bumper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting even and shadowless diffuse, causing the car's paint to reflect a mirror-like sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0431305393576622 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.16813063621521 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0431305393576622, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0431305393576622, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3171658515930176, + 0.020544447004795074, + 0.021474691107869148, + 0.02622261829674244, + 0.0796237587928772, + 0.34119364619255066, + 0.09134592860937119, + 0.0334429107606411, + 0.03943889960646629, + 0.02954723685979843 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0431305393576622 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No", + "No", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a minimalist, all-white studio setting, a 360-degree orbiting camera, filmed at a steady, constant speed, orbits the impending impact point from a level-headed perspective. The camera captures a sleek, cherry-red sports car with a streamlined silhouette and low body, its high-gloss paint reflecting a mirror-like sheen under even, shadowless diffuse light, hurtling at high speed towards a solid, pure white wall. Captured in ultra-slow motion, the moment of impact is elongated: At the moment of impact, ripples appear on the high-gloss paint, followed by the instant shattering of the front bumper. The hood, creased like paper under the immense force of the impact, buckles upward, revealing its intricate internal mechanisms. Metal shards and glass particles explode outward in the even, shadowless diffuse light, each fragment clearly reflecting light, while the windshield displays a spiderweb-like crack. As the camera continues to circle, we are able to observe from every angle the physical process of the car body metal twisting and tearing under pressure. The whole picture presents a cold and shocking visual effect, transforming the violent moment of the high-speed collision into a dynamic sculpture full of technological beauty.", + "seed": 23988, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_11/index_8920_seed_23988_dp_23_rank_46_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.3731145316269249, + "vlm_logprob": -0.3731145316269249, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.925, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.3731145316269249, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a minimalist, all-white studio environment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, cherry-red sports car with a low body and streamlined silhouette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a 360-degree orbit around the impact point at a steady, constant speed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in ultra-slow motion showing the car hitting a solid white wall and the subsequent shattering of the bumper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting even and shadowless diffuse, causing the car's paint to reflect a mirror-like sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5768401026725769 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8268401026725769 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5768401026725769, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5768401026725769, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11627577990293503, + 0.07398376613855362, + 0.04865368828177452, + 0.032770365476608276, + 0.031591664999723434, + 0.04437052831053734, + 0.18630877137184143, + 0.13029739260673523, + 0.06597690284252167, + 0.2697710394859314 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5768401026725769 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a minimalist, all-white studio environment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, cherry-red sports car with a low body and streamlined silhouette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a 360-degree orbit around the impact point at a steady, constant speed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in ultra-slow motion showing the car hitting a solid white wall and the subsequent shattering of the bumper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting even and shadowless diffuse, causing the car's paint to reflect a mirror-like sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036301210056990385 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.6286301612854 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036301210056990385, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036301210056990385, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.191964790225029, + 0.060154471546411514, + 0.0960531160235405, + 0.07739117741584778, + 0.06907311826944351, + 0.06821101903915405, + 0.06912800669670105, + 0.13533732295036316, + 0.08179830014705658, + 0.150888592004776 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036301210056990385 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a minimalist, all-white studio environment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, cherry-red sports car with a low body and streamlined silhouette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a 360-degree orbit around the impact point at a steady, constant speed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in ultra-slow motion showing the car hitting a solid white wall and the subsequent shattering of the bumper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting even and shadowless diffuse, causing the car's paint to reflect a mirror-like sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8983343243598938 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5233343243598938 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.8983343243598938, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.8983343243598938, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08107981830835342, + 0.07932137697935104, + 0.05232124403119087, + 0.0616740956902504, + 0.09739615768194199, + 0.18297310173511505, + 0.11168557405471802, + 0.13209189474582672, + 0.04930056631565094, + 0.15215614438056946 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.8983343243598938 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a minimalist, all-white studio environment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, cherry-red sports car with a low body and streamlined silhouette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a 360-degree orbit around the impact point at a steady, constant speed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in ultra-slow motion showing the car hitting a solid white wall and the subsequent shattering of the bumper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting even and shadowless diffuse, causing the car's paint to reflect a mirror-like sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.34865084290504456 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2236508131027222 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.34865084290504456, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.34865084290504456, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.060401394963264465, + 0.09870703518390656, + 0.04709838330745697, + 0.0703682005405426, + 0.06585866957902908, + 0.094987653195858, + 0.07609429955482483, + 0.08146466314792633, + 0.0782305970788002, + 0.3267890512943268 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.34865084290504456 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a minimalist, all-white studio environment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, cherry-red sports car with a low body and streamlined silhouette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a 360-degree orbit around the impact point at a steady, constant speed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in ultra-slow motion showing the car hitting a solid white wall and the subsequent shattering of the bumper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting even and shadowless diffuse, causing the car's paint to reflect a mirror-like sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.038117267191410065 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881171703338623 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.038117267191410065, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.038117267191410065, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1848604381084442, + 0.056641142815351486, + 0.08424779772758484, + 0.06388825923204422, + 0.09687579423189163, + 0.05964021384716034, + 0.1344514787197113, + 0.07106989622116089, + 0.05418529361486435, + 0.19413968920707703 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.038117267191410065 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_12/index_tensor([6071, 6071])_group_12_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_12/index_tensor([6071, 6071])_group_12_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..20f174d625cff762a74a885097f9397d516a2c80 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_12/index_tensor([6071, 6071])_group_12_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "shaky, low-angle, handheld shot, suffused with a grainy, high-contrast black and white, perfectly captures the raw, unsettling quality of Daido Moriyama's style. In a narrow, claustrophobic, and dank sewer, a multi-limbed humanoid creature lurks clinging to the rough concrete walls. Its pale, almost translucent skin gleams with a clammy sheen under the single, harsh light source. Its spindly, multi-jointed limbs splay like spiders, their sharp ends wedging deeply into the cracks of the wall. Its disproportionately large head, two hollow, black eyes, seems to absorb all light. The intense light, likely from a camera's floodlight, casts a violently oscillating pattern across the sticky, damp tunnel walls and the murky water below, creating deep, inky shadows and harsh, overexposed, pure white highlights. The creature itself remains uncomfortably still, with only one limb making slow, almost imperceptible twitches, which contrasts sharply with the nervous, erratic shaking of the camera, creating an atmosphere of suffocating tension that is about to explode.", + "seed": 8811, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_12/index_6071_seed_8811_dp_24_rank_48_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.009082057978957891, + "vlm_logprob": -0.009082057978957891, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 5.275, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.009082057978957891, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in black and white with a grainy, high-contrast appearance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a narrow, dank sewer with rough concrete walls and murky water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a multi-limbed humanoid creature with pale, translucent skin and spindly limbs visible clinging to the walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the creature have a disproportionately large head with two hollow, black eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot handheld and shaky, while the creature remains mostly still with only slight limb twitches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0023783750366419554 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.877378463745117 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0023783750366419554, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0023783750366419554, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19046175479888916, + 0.09141166508197784, + 0.0475868284702301, + 0.06998873502016068, + 0.17951346933841705, + 0.05127829313278198, + 0.04822084680199623, + 0.19646510481834412, + 0.05895860865712166, + 0.06611470133066177 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0023783750366419554 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in black and white with a grainy, high-contrast appearance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a narrow, dank sewer with rough concrete walls and murky water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a multi-limbed humanoid creature with pale, translucent skin and spindly limbs visible clinging to the walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the creature have a disproportionately large head with two hollow, black eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot handheld and shaky, while the creature remains mostly still with only slight limb twitches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016075171530246735 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141075134277344 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016075171530246735, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016075171530246735, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.31117093563079834, + 0.09107542037963867, + 0.05179088935256004, + 0.07342063635587692, + 0.10825766623020172, + 0.04503427818417549, + 0.024737326428294182, + 0.044402655214071274, + 0.07606343179941177, + 0.17404679954051971 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016075171530246735 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in black and white with a grainy, high-contrast appearance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a narrow, dank sewer with rough concrete walls and murky water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a multi-limbed humanoid creature with pale, translucent skin and spindly limbs visible clinging to the walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the creature have a disproportionately large head with two hollow, black eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot handheld and shaky, while the creature remains mostly still with only slight limb twitches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0031922117341309786 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.75319242477417 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0031922117341309786, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0031922117341309786, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1536029875278473, + 0.14056958258152008, + 0.12787185609340668, + 0.09394679218530655, + 0.06404587626457214, + 0.08459784090518951, + 0.1046019196510315, + 0.11418206989765167, + 0.06262669712305069, + 0.05395437031984329 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0031922117341309786 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in black and white with a grainy, high-contrast appearance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a narrow, dank sewer with rough concrete walls and murky water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a multi-limbed humanoid creature with pale, translucent skin and spindly limbs visible clinging to the walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the creature have a disproportionately large head with two hollow, black eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot handheld and shaky, while the creature remains mostly still with only slight limb twitches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003188646864145994 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753188610076904 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003188646864145994, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003188646864145994, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1279062181711197, + 0.12539629638195038, + 0.07332582026720047, + 0.08579273521900177, + 0.061206549406051636, + 0.19276408851146698, + 0.12403472512960434, + 0.13530990481376648, + 0.050538498908281326, + 0.023725144565105438 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003188646864145994 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in black and white with a grainy, high-contrast appearance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a narrow, dank sewer with rough concrete walls and murky water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a multi-limbed humanoid creature with pale, translucent skin and spindly limbs visible clinging to the walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the creature have a disproportionately large head with two hollow, black eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot handheld and shaky, while the creature remains mostly still with only slight limb twitches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020575884729623795 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895576000213623 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020575884729623795, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020575884729623795, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11779671162366867, + 0.09691832214593887, + 0.10668151825666428, + 0.05342714115977287, + 0.07490485161542892, + 0.16647471487522125, + 0.16134488582611084, + 0.11626523733139038, + 0.05893513560295105, + 0.047251489013433456 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020575884729623795 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "shaky, low-angle, handheld shot, suffused with a grainy, high-contrast black and white, perfectly captures the raw, unsettling quality of Daido Moriyama's style. In a narrow, claustrophobic, and dank sewer, a multi-limbed humanoid creature lurks clinging to the rough concrete walls. Its pale, almost translucent skin gleams with a clammy sheen under the single, harsh light source. Its spindly, multi-jointed limbs splay like spiders, their sharp ends wedging deeply into the cracks of the wall. Its disproportionately large head, two hollow, black eyes, seems to absorb all light. The intense light, likely from a camera's floodlight, casts a violently oscillating pattern across the sticky, damp tunnel walls and the murky water below, creating deep, inky shadows and harsh, overexposed, pure white highlights. The creature itself remains uncomfortably still, with only one limb making slow, almost imperceptible twitches, which contrasts sharply with the nervous, erratic shaking of the camera, creating an atmosphere of suffocating tension that is about to explode.", + "seed": 8812, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_12/index_6071_seed_8812_dp_24_rank_48_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.015939814364537598, + "vlm_logprob": -0.015939814364537598, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.649999952316284, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.015939814364537598, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in black and white with a grainy, high-contrast appearance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a narrow, dank sewer with rough concrete walls and murky water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a multi-limbed humanoid creature with pale, translucent skin and spindly limbs visible clinging to the walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the creature have a disproportionately large head with two hollow, black eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot handheld and shaky, while the creature remains mostly still with only slight limb twitches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003672998631373048 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.753673076629639 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003672998631373048, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003672998631373048, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19671744108200073, + 0.17151570320129395, + 0.08421659469604492, + 0.1049870103597641, + 0.10134163498878479, + 0.07675544917583466, + 0.0554671511054039, + 0.05788880214095116, + 0.03332485258579254, + 0.11778540909290314 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003672998631373048 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in black and white with a grainy, high-contrast appearance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a narrow, dank sewer with rough concrete walls and murky water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a multi-limbed humanoid creature with pale, translucent skin and spindly limbs visible clinging to the walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the creature have a disproportionately large head with two hollow, black eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot handheld and shaky, while the creature remains mostly still with only slight limb twitches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01819819025695324 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018198013305664 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01819819025695324, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01819819025695324, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12984909117221832, + 0.05790097266435623, + 0.15829360485076904, + 0.20601597428321838, + 0.04035292565822601, + 0.023302869871258736, + 0.14690859615802765, + 0.03491415083408356, + 0.12149106711149216, + 0.08097073435783386 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01819819025695324 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in black and white with a grainy, high-contrast appearance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a narrow, dank sewer with rough concrete walls and murky water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a multi-limbed humanoid creature with pale, translucent skin and spindly limbs visible clinging to the walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the creature have a disproportionately large head with two hollow, black eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot handheld and shaky, while the creature remains mostly still with only slight limb twitches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005949525628238916 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.1309494972229 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005949525628238916, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005949525628238916, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10056328773498535, + 0.33676597476005554, + 0.05813310295343399, + 0.07342678308486938, + 0.05047536641359329, + 0.04208244010806084, + 0.07669185101985931, + 0.11190752685070038, + 0.09038347005844116, + 0.05957018584012985 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005949525628238916 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in black and white with a grainy, high-contrast appearance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a narrow, dank sewer with rough concrete walls and murky water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a multi-limbed humanoid creature with pale, translucent skin and spindly limbs visible clinging to the walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the creature have a disproportionately large head with two hollow, black eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot handheld and shaky, while the creature remains mostly still with only slight limb twitches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018178759142756462 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018178939819336 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018178759142756462, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018178759142756462, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09230808168649673, + 0.18389354646205902, + 0.037447232753038406, + 0.056574754416942596, + 0.03644638508558273, + 0.034684594720602036, + 0.2830578088760376, + 0.09047594666481018, + 0.13405741751194, + 0.05105413869023323 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018178759142756462 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in black and white with a grainy, high-contrast appearance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a narrow, dank sewer with rough concrete walls and murky water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a multi-limbed humanoid creature with pale, translucent skin and spindly limbs visible clinging to the walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the creature have a disproportionately large head with two hollow, black eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot handheld and shaky, while the creature remains mostly still with only slight limb twitches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03369959816336632 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4086995124816895 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03369959816336632, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03369959816336632, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12681390345096588, + 0.12798312306404114, + 0.07469300925731659, + 0.07382549345493317, + 0.06749972701072693, + 0.05022667720913887, + 0.13491301238536835, + 0.16085883975028992, + 0.13214342296123505, + 0.05104280263185501 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03369959816336632 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "shaky, low-angle, handheld shot, suffused with a grainy, high-contrast black and white, perfectly captures the raw, unsettling quality of Daido Moriyama's style. In a narrow, claustrophobic, and dank sewer, a multi-limbed humanoid creature lurks clinging to the rough concrete walls. Its pale, almost translucent skin gleams with a clammy sheen under the single, harsh light source. Its spindly, multi-jointed limbs splay like spiders, their sharp ends wedging deeply into the cracks of the wall. Its disproportionately large head, two hollow, black eyes, seems to absorb all light. The intense light, likely from a camera's floodlight, casts a violently oscillating pattern across the sticky, damp tunnel walls and the murky water below, creating deep, inky shadows and harsh, overexposed, pure white highlights. The creature itself remains uncomfortably still, with only one limb making slow, almost imperceptible twitches, which contrasts sharply with the nervous, erratic shaking of the camera, creating an atmosphere of suffocating tension that is about to explode.", + "seed": 8813, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_12/index_6071_seed_8813_dp_25_rank_50_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.012237000628374517, + "vlm_logprob": -0.012237000628374517, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 5.175, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.012237000628374517, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in black and white with a grainy, high-contrast appearance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a narrow, dank sewer with rough concrete walls and murky water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a multi-limbed humanoid creature with pale, translucent skin and spindly limbs visible clinging to the walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the creature have a disproportionately large head with two hollow, black eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot handheld and shaky, while the creature remains mostly still with only slight limb twitches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002432247158139944 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.002432346343994 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002432247158139944, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002432247158139944, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2267863154411316, + 0.14451302587985992, + 0.08634445816278458, + 0.12004948407411575, + 0.06971202790737152, + 0.061268195509910583, + 0.08638004213571548, + 0.038703396916389465, + 0.07853963971138, + 0.08770342171192169 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002432247158139944 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in black and white with a grainy, high-contrast appearance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a narrow, dank sewer with rough concrete walls and murky water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a multi-limbed humanoid creature with pale, translucent skin and spindly limbs visible clinging to the walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the creature have a disproportionately large head with two hollow, black eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot handheld and shaky, while the creature remains mostly still with only slight limb twitches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.038112103939056396 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288112163543701 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.038112103939056396, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.038112103939056396, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.34563198685646057, + 0.10307066142559052, + 0.2060779184103012, + 0.11973285675048828, + 0.07765644788742065, + 0.02591744065284729, + 0.02439219132065773, + 0.06374654918909073, + 0.009058589115738869, + 0.024715332314372063 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.038112103939056396 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in black and white with a grainy, high-contrast appearance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a narrow, dank sewer with rough concrete walls and murky water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a multi-limbed humanoid creature with pale, translucent skin and spindly limbs visible clinging to the walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the creature have a disproportionately large head with two hollow, black eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot handheld and shaky, while the creature remains mostly still with only slight limb twitches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0019408691441640258 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.251940727233887 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0019408691441640258, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0019408691441640258, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11723657697439194, + 0.08181644976139069, + 0.21601495146751404, + 0.16286377608776093, + 0.06186097487807274, + 0.0501377210021019, + 0.080987349152565, + 0.04414087161421776, + 0.10305161774158478, + 0.08188971132040024 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0019408691441640258 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in black and white with a grainy, high-contrast appearance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a narrow, dank sewer with rough concrete walls and murky water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a multi-limbed humanoid creature with pale, translucent skin and spindly limbs visible clinging to the walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the creature have a disproportionately large head with two hollow, black eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot handheld and shaky, while the creature remains mostly still with only slight limb twitches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00762398075312376 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.88262414932251 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00762398075312376, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00762398075312376, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3004719018936157, + 0.04303479567170143, + 0.09773273766040802, + 0.14289118349552155, + 0.039666954427957535, + 0.09790629148483276, + 0.034149251878261566, + 0.02731925994157791, + 0.0685364305973053, + 0.14829127490520477 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00762398075312376 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in black and white with a grainy, high-contrast appearance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a narrow, dank sewer with rough concrete walls and murky water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a multi-limbed humanoid creature with pale, translucent skin and spindly limbs visible clinging to the walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the creature have a disproportionately large head with two hollow, black eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot handheld and shaky, while the creature remains mostly still with only slight limb twitches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011075802147388458 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511075973510742 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011075802147388458, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011075802147388458, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1785399466753006, + 0.05008309334516525, + 0.17305806279182434, + 0.09125125408172607, + 0.09396358579397202, + 0.09061484038829803, + 0.07004672288894653, + 0.06428197026252747, + 0.11932576447725296, + 0.06883478909730911 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011075802147388458 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "shaky, low-angle, handheld shot, suffused with a grainy, high-contrast black and white, perfectly captures the raw, unsettling quality of Daido Moriyama's style. In a narrow, claustrophobic, and dank sewer, a multi-limbed humanoid creature lurks clinging to the rough concrete walls. Its pale, almost translucent skin gleams with a clammy sheen under the single, harsh light source. Its spindly, multi-jointed limbs splay like spiders, their sharp ends wedging deeply into the cracks of the wall. Its disproportionately large head, two hollow, black eyes, seems to absorb all light. The intense light, likely from a camera's floodlight, casts a violently oscillating pattern across the sticky, damp tunnel walls and the murky water below, creating deep, inky shadows and harsh, overexposed, pure white highlights. The creature itself remains uncomfortably still, with only one limb making slow, almost imperceptible twitches, which contrasts sharply with the nervous, erratic shaking of the camera, creating an atmosphere of suffocating tension that is about to explode.", + "seed": 8814, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_12/index_6071_seed_8814_dp_25_rank_50_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.006587072089314461, + "vlm_logprob": -0.006587072089314461, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 5.325, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.006587072089314461, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in black and white with a grainy, high-contrast appearance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a narrow, dank sewer with rough concrete walls and murky water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a multi-limbed humanoid creature with pale, translucent skin and spindly limbs visible clinging to the walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the creature have a disproportionately large head with two hollow, black eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot handheld and shaky, while the creature remains mostly still with only slight limb twitches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002518935827538371 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.627519130706787 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002518935827538371, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002518935827538371, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.33611369132995605, + 0.03777773305773735, + 0.23256617784500122, + 0.09090364724397659, + 0.026439113542437553, + 0.06528889387845993, + 0.04300170764327049, + 0.023933852091431618, + 0.02723943442106247, + 0.11673576384782791 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002518935827538371 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in black and white with a grainy, high-contrast appearance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a narrow, dank sewer with rough concrete walls and murky water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a multi-limbed humanoid creature with pale, translucent skin and spindly limbs visible clinging to the walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the creature have a disproportionately large head with two hollow, black eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot handheld and shaky, while the creature remains mostly still with only slight limb twitches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011080164462327957 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511080265045166 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011080164462327957, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011080164462327957, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3617658317089081, + 0.05209799483418465, + 0.09893889725208282, + 0.14475156366825104, + 0.046165306121110916, + 0.04064916446805, + 0.09073502570390701, + 0.04037662595510483, + 0.0649544969201088, + 0.059565119445323944 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011080164462327957 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in black and white with a grainy, high-contrast appearance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a narrow, dank sewer with rough concrete walls and murky water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a multi-limbed humanoid creature with pale, translucent skin and spindly limbs visible clinging to the walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the creature have a disproportionately large head with two hollow, black eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot handheld and shaky, while the creature remains mostly still with only slight limb twitches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002820087829604745 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877820014953613 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002820087829604745, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002820087829604745, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3064807951450348, + 0.1329898089170456, + 0.061245426535606384, + 0.05057729035615921, + 0.0603647418320179, + 0.0682947114109993, + 0.1081208661198616, + 0.08790069073438644, + 0.04160713404417038, + 0.08241850137710571 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002820087829604745 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in black and white with a grainy, high-contrast appearance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a narrow, dank sewer with rough concrete walls and murky water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a multi-limbed humanoid creature with pale, translucent skin and spindly limbs visible clinging to the walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the creature have a disproportionately large head with two hollow, black eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot handheld and shaky, while the creature remains mostly still with only slight limb twitches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006733584217727184 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006733417510986 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006733584217727184, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006733584217727184, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17452216148376465, + 0.3308078348636627, + 0.06581632792949677, + 0.05145173519849777, + 0.06552596390247345, + 0.03955722227692604, + 0.06015223264694214, + 0.1136401891708374, + 0.02935531549155712, + 0.06917110830545425 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006733584217727184 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in black and white with a grainy, high-contrast appearance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a narrow, dank sewer with rough concrete walls and murky water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a multi-limbed humanoid creature with pale, translucent skin and spindly limbs visible clinging to the walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the creature have a disproportionately large head with two hollow, black eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot handheld and shaky, while the creature remains mostly still with only slight limb twitches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009782588109374046 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634782791137695 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009782588109374046, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009782588109374046, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10077011585235596, + 0.0854550302028656, + 0.15023760497570038, + 0.07219051569700241, + 0.10538115352392197, + 0.06009292975068092, + 0.17901396751403809, + 0.08028051257133484, + 0.10109764337539673, + 0.06548060476779938 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009782588109374046 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_13/index_tensor([769, 769])_group_13_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_13/index_tensor([769, 769])_group_13_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..c9b2e74cbb640a9e93e20a9822217b2fc22c4a24 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_13/index_tensor([769, 769])_group_13_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "bird's-eye view, taken from high above, slowly pans downward, focusing on a quaint and elegant Chinese courtyard. The ground is paved with blue-gray stone slabs, strewn with a brilliant layer of fallen leaves in gold and crimson. In the center of the frame, a woman dressed in a wide-sleeved, flowing fairy dress, a blend of pale blue and ink, dances with a sword. Her long, dark hair, partially held back by an ancient jade hairpin, wisps of it dancing in the air with her movements. In her hand, she clutches a long, gleaming sword, its blade long and sharp. With a graceful twirl, she begins her movement, the wide silk sleeves and hem of her skirt unfurling like a blooming lotus in ink. Her steps are light and precise, and with each swing of the sword, a powerful wind sweeps up the fallen leaves on the ground, sending countless fronds swirling and dancing around her, forming a dazzling vortex. As the sword's blade rapidly turns, it momentarily catches and reflects the soft afternoon sunlight, creating a brief, dazzling silver flash. The afternoon sun filters through the sparse branches of a maple tree in the corner of the courtyard, casting dappled shadows on the ground and illuminating the dancing leaves, making them appear like shimmering golden particles. The entire scene is shimmering in a warm autumnal hue. The woman's expression is focused and serene, perfectly blending the determination of a warrior with the graceful grace of a dancer, creating an otherworldly, poetic atmosphere of movement and stillness.", + "seed": 194, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_13/index_769_seed_194_dp_26_rank_52_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.3259891165420413, + "vlm_logprob": -0.3259891165420413, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.1000000119209288, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.3259891165420413, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a bird's-eye view taken from high above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan downward to focus on a Chinese courtyard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a woman wearing a wide-sleeved, flowing dress in pale blue and ink colors visible in the center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the woman perform a dance with a long, gleaming sword that causes fallen leaves to swirl in a vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by afternoon sunlight filtering through maple tree branches, casting dappled shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.0566658973693848 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.43166595697402954 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.0566658973693848, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.6249999403953552, + "token_credit_reward": -1.0566658973693848, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.084269680082798, + 0.07261902838945389, + 0.11954318732023239, + 0.5732737183570862, + 0.031293876469135284, + 0.017599880695343018, + 0.030674515292048454, + 0.016821160912513733, + 0.028801927343010902, + 0.025103028863668442 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.0566658973693848 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a bird's-eye view taken from high above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan downward to focus on a Chinese courtyard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a woman wearing a wide-sleeved, flowing dress in pale blue and ink colors visible in the center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the woman perform a dance with a long, gleaming sword that causes fallen leaves to swirl in a vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by afternoon sunlight filtering through maple tree branches, casting dappled shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3871264159679413 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1371264457702637 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3871264159679413, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3871264159679413, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0918687954545021, + 0.08360573649406433, + 0.06754657626152039, + 0.4821925759315491, + 0.08970793336629868, + 0.06874991208314896, + 0.014527118764817715, + 0.016647113487124443, + 0.04778718575835228, + 0.03736697509884834 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3871264159679413 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a bird's-eye view taken from high above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan downward to focus on a Chinese courtyard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a woman wearing a wide-sleeved, flowing dress in pale blue and ink colors visible in the center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the woman perform a dance with a long, gleaming sword that causes fallen leaves to swirl in a vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by afternoon sunlight filtering through maple tree branches, casting dappled shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004106304608285427 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504106521606445 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004106304608285427, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004106304608285427, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03374786674976349, + 0.0317976139485836, + 0.043998073786497116, + 0.6893100142478943, + 0.03073013946413994, + 0.04726589098572731, + 0.03101753443479538, + 0.014520218595862389, + 0.023172501474618912, + 0.05444019287824631 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004106304608285427 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a bird's-eye view taken from high above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan downward to focus on a Chinese courtyard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a woman wearing a wide-sleeved, flowing dress in pale blue and ink colors visible in the center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the woman perform a dance with a long, gleaming sword that causes fallen leaves to swirl in a vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by afternoon sunlight filtering through maple tree branches, casting dappled shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.054969415068626404 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929969310760498 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.054969415068626404, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.054969415068626404, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08366812020540237, + 0.07911095023155212, + 0.07509919255971909, + 0.20046737790107727, + 0.06953725963830948, + 0.0484289675951004, + 0.1996603012084961, + 0.07855331897735596, + 0.1026310846209526, + 0.06284335255622864 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.054969415068626404 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a bird's-eye view taken from high above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan downward to focus on a Chinese courtyard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a woman wearing a wide-sleeved, flowing dress in pale blue and ink colors visible in the center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the woman perform a dance with a long, gleaming sword that causes fallen leaves to swirl in a vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by afternoon sunlight filtering through maple tree branches, casting dappled shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12707754969596863 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.127077579498291 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12707754969596863, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12707754969596863, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09606122225522995, + 0.2807351350784302, + 0.02910683862864971, + 0.3216959834098816, + 0.03496607020497322, + 0.048373039811849594, + 0.022137103602290154, + 0.024157395586371422, + 0.10248307138681412, + 0.04028410091996193 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12707754969596863 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "bird's-eye view, taken from high above, slowly pans downward, focusing on a quaint and elegant Chinese courtyard. The ground is paved with blue-gray stone slabs, strewn with a brilliant layer of fallen leaves in gold and crimson. In the center of the frame, a woman dressed in a wide-sleeved, flowing fairy dress, a blend of pale blue and ink, dances with a sword. Her long, dark hair, partially held back by an ancient jade hairpin, wisps of it dancing in the air with her movements. In her hand, she clutches a long, gleaming sword, its blade long and sharp. With a graceful twirl, she begins her movement, the wide silk sleeves and hem of her skirt unfurling like a blooming lotus in ink. Her steps are light and precise, and with each swing of the sword, a powerful wind sweeps up the fallen leaves on the ground, sending countless fronds swirling and dancing around her, forming a dazzling vortex. As the sword's blade rapidly turns, it momentarily catches and reflects the soft afternoon sunlight, creating a brief, dazzling silver flash. The afternoon sun filters through the sparse branches of a maple tree in the corner of the courtyard, casting dappled shadows on the ground and illuminating the dancing leaves, making them appear like shimmering golden particles. The entire scene is shimmering in a warm autumnal hue. The woman's expression is focused and serene, perfectly blending the determination of a warrior with the graceful grace of a dancer, creating an otherworldly, poetic atmosphere of movement and stillness.", + "seed": 195, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_13/index_769_seed_195_dp_26_rank_52_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.2511772406054661, + "vlm_logprob": -0.2511772406054661, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.975, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.2511772406054661, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a bird's-eye view taken from high above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan downward to focus on a Chinese courtyard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a woman wearing a wide-sleeved, flowing dress in pale blue and ink colors visible in the center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the woman perform a dance with a long, gleaming sword that causes fallen leaves to swirl in a vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by afternoon sunlight filtering through maple tree branches, casting dappled shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.38944077491760254 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1394407749176025 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.38944077491760254, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.38944077491760254, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22135469317436218, + 0.0498531311750412, + 0.1418103724718094, + 0.21895912289619446, + 0.1199735477566719, + 0.1009369045495987, + 0.02745150774717331, + 0.03273553401231766, + 0.05631420016288757, + 0.03061096929013729 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.38944077491760254 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a bird's-eye view taken from high above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan downward to focus on a Chinese courtyard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a woman wearing a wide-sleeved, flowing dress in pale blue and ink colors visible in the center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the woman perform a dance with a long, gleaming sword that causes fallen leaves to swirl in a vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by afternoon sunlight filtering through maple tree branches, casting dappled shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8261452317237854 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5761452317237854 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.8261452317237854, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.8261452317237854, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14569233357906342, + 0.08060228079557419, + 0.12162696570158005, + 0.15530933439731598, + 0.16287364065647125, + 0.11299409717321396, + 0.05326647683978081, + 0.046989429742097855, + 0.06952676177024841, + 0.051118653267621994 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.8261452317237854 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a bird's-eye view taken from high above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan downward to focus on a Chinese courtyard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a woman wearing a wide-sleeved, flowing dress in pale blue and ink colors visible in the center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the woman perform a dance with a long, gleaming sword that causes fallen leaves to swirl in a vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by afternoon sunlight filtering through maple tree branches, casting dappled shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0015191215788945556 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.501519203186035 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0015191215788945556, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0015191215788945556, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15474198758602142, + 0.06113831698894501, + 0.13725028932094574, + 0.1759776771068573, + 0.09219089150428772, + 0.1926003396511078, + 0.02797270007431507, + 0.07768161594867706, + 0.06047965586185455, + 0.019966475665569305 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0015191215788945556 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a bird's-eye view taken from high above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan downward to focus on a Chinese courtyard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a woman wearing a wide-sleeved, flowing dress in pale blue and ink colors visible in the center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the woman perform a dance with a long, gleaming sword that causes fallen leaves to swirl in a vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by afternoon sunlight filtering through maple tree branches, casting dappled shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018195031210780144 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018195152282715 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018195031210780144, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018195031210780144, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06787316501140594, + 0.1206546202301979, + 0.3284708857536316, + 0.15410596132278442, + 0.1020427793264389, + 0.05860381945967674, + 0.01969863846898079, + 0.02711101993918419, + 0.08525728434324265, + 0.03618184104561806 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018195031210780144 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a bird's-eye view taken from high above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan downward to focus on a Chinese courtyard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a woman wearing a wide-sleeved, flowing dress in pale blue and ink colors visible in the center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the woman perform a dance with a long, gleaming sword that causes fallen leaves to swirl in a vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by afternoon sunlight filtering through maple tree branches, casting dappled shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0205860435962677 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955860137939453 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0205860435962677, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0205860435962677, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1215701773762703, + 0.07253759354352951, + 0.11681357026100159, + 0.047419674694538116, + 0.07885947823524475, + 0.444610059261322, + 0.01342337392270565, + 0.04524366930127144, + 0.025728968903422356, + 0.0337933711707592 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0205860435962677 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "bird's-eye view, taken from high above, slowly pans downward, focusing on a quaint and elegant Chinese courtyard. The ground is paved with blue-gray stone slabs, strewn with a brilliant layer of fallen leaves in gold and crimson. In the center of the frame, a woman dressed in a wide-sleeved, flowing fairy dress, a blend of pale blue and ink, dances with a sword. Her long, dark hair, partially held back by an ancient jade hairpin, wisps of it dancing in the air with her movements. In her hand, she clutches a long, gleaming sword, its blade long and sharp. With a graceful twirl, she begins her movement, the wide silk sleeves and hem of her skirt unfurling like a blooming lotus in ink. Her steps are light and precise, and with each swing of the sword, a powerful wind sweeps up the fallen leaves on the ground, sending countless fronds swirling and dancing around her, forming a dazzling vortex. As the sword's blade rapidly turns, it momentarily catches and reflects the soft afternoon sunlight, creating a brief, dazzling silver flash. The afternoon sun filters through the sparse branches of a maple tree in the corner of the courtyard, casting dappled shadows on the ground and illuminating the dancing leaves, making them appear like shimmering golden particles. The entire scene is shimmering in a warm autumnal hue. The woman's expression is focused and serene, perfectly blending the determination of a warrior with the graceful grace of a dancer, creating an otherworldly, poetic atmosphere of movement and stillness.", + "seed": 196, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_13/index_769_seed_196_dp_27_rank_54_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.2270980189088732, + "vlm_logprob": -0.2270980189088732, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.7, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.2270980189088732, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a bird's-eye view taken from high above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan downward to focus on a Chinese courtyard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a woman wearing a wide-sleeved, flowing dress in pale blue and ink colors visible in the center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the woman perform a dance with a long, gleaming sword that causes fallen leaves to swirl in a vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by afternoon sunlight filtering through maple tree branches, casting dappled shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.82851642370224 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.57851642370224 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.82851642370224, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.82851642370224, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.055191874504089355, + 0.06673067063093185, + 0.02660738304257393, + 0.17710885405540466, + 0.04381942003965378, + 0.04469888284802437, + 0.19985125958919525, + 0.090555340051651, + 0.14425119757652283, + 0.15118508040905 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.82851642370224 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a bird's-eye view taken from high above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan downward to focus on a Chinese courtyard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a woman wearing a wide-sleeved, flowing dress in pale blue and ink colors visible in the center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the woman perform a dance with a long, gleaming sword that causes fallen leaves to swirl in a vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by afternoon sunlight filtering through maple tree branches, casting dappled shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2016163319349289 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7016162872314453 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2016163319349289, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2016163319349289, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07038820534944534, + 0.020960228517651558, + 0.0898067057132721, + 0.2371344417333603, + 0.06340664625167847, + 0.09457802027463913, + 0.10141870379447937, + 0.14144425094127655, + 0.1082639992237091, + 0.07259874790906906 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2016163319349289 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a bird's-eye view taken from high above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan downward to focus on a Chinese courtyard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a woman wearing a wide-sleeved, flowing dress in pale blue and ink colors visible in the center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the woman perform a dance with a long, gleaming sword that causes fallen leaves to swirl in a vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by afternoon sunlight filtering through maple tree branches, casting dappled shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0017187122721225023 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.376718521118164 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0017187122721225023, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0017187122721225023, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.050147995352745056, + 0.07625170797109604, + 0.04575878754258156, + 0.10856746137142181, + 0.06802444159984589, + 0.051768746227025986, + 0.25233936309814453, + 0.09521403163671494, + 0.08598766475915909, + 0.1659398227930069 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0017187122721225023 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a bird's-eye view taken from high above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan downward to focus on a Chinese courtyard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a woman wearing a wide-sleeved, flowing dress in pale blue and ink colors visible in the center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the woman perform a dance with a long, gleaming sword that causes fallen leaves to swirl in a vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by afternoon sunlight filtering through maple tree branches, casting dappled shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0549677237868309 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299676418304443 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0549677237868309, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0549677237868309, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05921947583556175, + 0.013917423784732819, + 0.09315699338912964, + 0.09342102706432343, + 0.0384475477039814, + 0.2730964720249176, + 0.07757100462913513, + 0.14941219985485077, + 0.08111846446990967, + 0.12063942104578018 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0549677237868309 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a bird's-eye view taken from high above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan downward to focus on a Chinese courtyard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a woman wearing a wide-sleeved, flowing dress in pale blue and ink colors visible in the center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the woman perform a dance with a long, gleaming sword that causes fallen leaves to swirl in a vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by afternoon sunlight filtering through maple tree branches, casting dappled shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04867090284824371 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048671007156372 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04867090284824371, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04867090284824371, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.036451440304517746, + 0.0738285705447197, + 0.042872536927461624, + 0.03942079842090607, + 0.1100785955786705, + 0.1885128915309906, + 0.04974107816815376, + 0.22674520313739777, + 0.1316082626581192, + 0.10074058175086975 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 5, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04867090284824371 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "bird's-eye view, taken from high above, slowly pans downward, focusing on a quaint and elegant Chinese courtyard. The ground is paved with blue-gray stone slabs, strewn with a brilliant layer of fallen leaves in gold and crimson. In the center of the frame, a woman dressed in a wide-sleeved, flowing fairy dress, a blend of pale blue and ink, dances with a sword. Her long, dark hair, partially held back by an ancient jade hairpin, wisps of it dancing in the air with her movements. In her hand, she clutches a long, gleaming sword, its blade long and sharp. With a graceful twirl, she begins her movement, the wide silk sleeves and hem of her skirt unfurling like a blooming lotus in ink. Her steps are light and precise, and with each swing of the sword, a powerful wind sweeps up the fallen leaves on the ground, sending countless fronds swirling and dancing around her, forming a dazzling vortex. As the sword's blade rapidly turns, it momentarily catches and reflects the soft afternoon sunlight, creating a brief, dazzling silver flash. The afternoon sun filters through the sparse branches of a maple tree in the corner of the courtyard, casting dappled shadows on the ground and illuminating the dancing leaves, making them appear like shimmering golden particles. The entire scene is shimmering in a warm autumnal hue. The woman's expression is focused and serene, perfectly blending the determination of a warrior with the graceful grace of a dancer, creating an otherworldly, poetic atmosphere of movement and stillness.", + "seed": 197, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_13/index_769_seed_197_dp_27_rank_54_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.28169372864067554, + "vlm_logprob": -0.28169372864067554, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.35, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.28169372864067554, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a bird's-eye view taken from high above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan downward to focus on a Chinese courtyard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a woman wearing a wide-sleeved, flowing dress in pale blue and ink colors visible in the center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the woman perform a dance with a long, gleaming sword that causes fallen leaves to swirl in a vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by afternoon sunlight filtering through maple tree branches, casting dappled shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2260160446166992 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.35101601481437683 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.2260160446166992, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -1.2260160446166992, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.47429805994033813, + 0.025446662679314613, + 0.023498322814702988, + 0.01489953976124525, + 0.030674375593662262, + 0.041948750615119934, + 0.03670700266957283, + 0.02678198553621769, + 0.029724091291427612, + 0.2960212230682373 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.2260160446166992 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a bird's-eye view taken from high above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan downward to focus on a Chinese courtyard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a woman wearing a wide-sleeved, flowing dress in pale blue and ink colors visible in the center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the woman perform a dance with a long, gleaming sword that causes fallen leaves to swirl in a vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by afternoon sunlight filtering through maple tree branches, casting dappled shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16040688753128052 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9104068279266357 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16040688753128052, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16040688753128052, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0962579995393753, + 0.011412701569497585, + 0.046565741300582886, + 0.01484982855618, + 0.015286024659872055, + 0.02908237837255001, + 0.041947294026613235, + 0.03301536664366722, + 0.042071886360645294, + 0.6695108413696289 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16040688753128052 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a bird's-eye view taken from high above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan downward to focus on a Chinese courtyard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a woman wearing a wide-sleeved, flowing dress in pale blue and ink colors visible in the center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the woman perform a dance with a long, gleaming sword that causes fallen leaves to swirl in a vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by afternoon sunlight filtering through maple tree branches, casting dappled shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0011856677010655403 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.751185894012451 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0011856677010655403, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0011856677010655403, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24220716953277588, + 0.054024890065193176, + 0.028728220611810684, + 0.01218554750084877, + 0.017418188974261284, + 0.052921559661626816, + 0.05480446666479111, + 0.04459080100059509, + 0.023421335965394974, + 0.4696977734565735 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0011856677010655403 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a bird's-eye view taken from high above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan downward to focus on a Chinese courtyard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a woman wearing a wide-sleeved, flowing dress in pale blue and ink colors visible in the center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the woman perform a dance with a long, gleaming sword that causes fallen leaves to swirl in a vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by afternoon sunlight filtering through maple tree branches, casting dappled shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00978435855358839 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.63478422164917 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00978435855358839, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00978435855358839, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15614400804042816, + 0.06429692357778549, + 0.09529051184654236, + 0.02911433018743992, + 0.03016209602355957, + 0.17332760989665985, + 0.04225262999534607, + 0.021965857595205307, + 0.07824305444955826, + 0.3092029094696045 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00978435855358839 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a bird's-eye view taken from high above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan downward to focus on a Chinese courtyard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a woman wearing a wide-sleeved, flowing dress in pale blue and ink colors visible in the center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the woman perform a dance with a long, gleaming sword that causes fallen leaves to swirl in a vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by afternoon sunlight filtering through maple tree branches, casting dappled shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011075684800744057 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511075496673584 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011075684800744057, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011075684800744057, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17254392802715302, + 0.10488762706518173, + 0.13077668845653534, + 0.026753759011626244, + 0.04793941602110863, + 0.09223843365907669, + 0.0647798404097557, + 0.08123680204153061, + 0.0646977573633194, + 0.2141457200050354 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011075684800744057 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_14/index_tensor([1337, 1337])_group_14_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_14/index_tensor([1337, 1337])_group_14_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..66a0631b098afdcbf5d9f15f4b9d75d810f32926 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_14/index_tensor([1337, 1337])_group_14_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "In a photorealistic CGI rendering, the camera is positioned in a static, low-angle shot of an underwater foreground, a perspective that masterfully captures the immense scale of the tidal power station. A massive turbine blade, crafted from dark, weathered metal, sweeps past in a slow, powerful, and deliberate circular motion. Its vast surface is a tangible tapestry of long-soaked water, covered in clusters of white and gray barnacles and capped by long strands of vibrant green algae that gently sway in the water. Ethereal sunlight penetrates the distant sea surface, breaking into an ever-shifting, intricate network of corrosion patterns that dance across the blade's richly textured surface, while the monolithic concrete structure of the power station looms in a deep blue haze. As the leading edge of the blade advances, its motion generates a powerful, silent current, causing a dense school of small silver fish to scurry away in a unified, panicked pattern, their scales glittering as they disperse into the depths. This creates an awe-inspiring atmosphere of silent power, juxtaposing industrial might with the fragile beauty of marine life.", + "seed": 15402, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_14/index_1337_seed_15402_dp_28_rank_56_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.18138522244989871, + "vlm_logprob": -0.18138522244989871, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.0, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.18138522244989871, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a static, low-angle shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive turbine blade made of dark, weathered metal visible in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the turbine blade move in a slow, circular motion while being covered in white and gray barnacles and green algae?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a monolithic concrete power station structure visible in the background within a deep blue haze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do small silver fish scatter away in a panicked pattern as the turbine blade advances?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.35642552375793457 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2314255237579346 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.35642552375793457, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.35642552375793457, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19847485423088074, + 0.053356628865003586, + 0.04281221330165863, + 0.030515538528561592, + 0.4336310625076294, + 0.03362659737467766, + 0.02374889701604843, + 0.03741385415196419, + 0.07571355998516083, + 0.0707068219780922 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.35642552375793457 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a static, low-angle shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive turbine blade made of dark, weathered metal visible in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the turbine blade move in a slow, circular motion while being covered in white and gray barnacles and green algae?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a monolithic concrete power station structure visible in the background within a deep blue haze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do small silver fish scatter away in a panicked pattern as the turbine blade advances?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17990927398204803 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8049092292785645 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17990927398204803, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17990927398204803, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17950990796089172, + 0.1339177042245865, + 0.05834193900227547, + 0.030081478878855705, + 0.07040559500455856, + 0.1711820513010025, + 0.04698701202869415, + 0.07858596742153168, + 0.1250915378332138, + 0.10589682310819626 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17990927398204803 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a static, low-angle shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive turbine blade made of dark, weathered metal visible in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the turbine blade move in a slow, circular motion while being covered in white and gray barnacles and green algae?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a monolithic concrete power station structure visible in the background within a deep blue haze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do small silver fish scatter away in a panicked pattern as the turbine blade advances?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0182094294577837 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018209457397461 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0182094294577837, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0182094294577837, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11010880768299103, + 0.09678912907838821, + 0.05948374420404434, + 0.061372123658657074, + 0.13866759836673737, + 0.10483521223068237, + 0.038705967366695404, + 0.15660911798477173, + 0.1227445900440216, + 0.11068367958068848 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 4, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0182094294577837 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a static, low-angle shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive turbine blade made of dark, weathered metal visible in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the turbine blade move in a slow, circular motion while being covered in white and gray barnacles and green algae?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a monolithic concrete power station structure visible in the background within a deep blue haze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do small silver fish scatter away in a panicked pattern as the turbine blade advances?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10030320286750793 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3503031730651855 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10030320286750793, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10030320286750793, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22156541049480438, + 0.051880769431591034, + 0.03976145386695862, + 0.030563034117221832, + 0.39737483859062195, + 0.03727217763662338, + 0.04613623395562172, + 0.08170036971569061, + 0.04979139566421509, + 0.04395436495542526 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10030320286750793 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a static, low-angle shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive turbine blade made of dark, weathered metal visible in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the turbine blade move in a slow, circular motion while being covered in white and gray barnacles and green algae?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a monolithic concrete power station structure visible in the background within a deep blue haze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do small silver fish scatter away in a panicked pattern as the turbine blade advances?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.25207868218421936 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.502078652381897 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.25207868218421936, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.25207868218421936, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09498012810945511, + 0.07818640768527985, + 0.08654671162366867, + 0.07687442749738693, + 0.302135169506073, + 0.13693489134311676, + 0.03295105695724487, + 0.10016605257987976, + 0.05408225208520889, + 0.03714287653565407 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.25207868218421936 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a photorealistic CGI rendering, the camera is positioned in a static, low-angle shot of an underwater foreground, a perspective that masterfully captures the immense scale of the tidal power station. A massive turbine blade, crafted from dark, weathered metal, sweeps past in a slow, powerful, and deliberate circular motion. Its vast surface is a tangible tapestry of long-soaked water, covered in clusters of white and gray barnacles and capped by long strands of vibrant green algae that gently sway in the water. Ethereal sunlight penetrates the distant sea surface, breaking into an ever-shifting, intricate network of corrosion patterns that dance across the blade's richly textured surface, while the monolithic concrete structure of the power station looms in a deep blue haze. As the leading edge of the blade advances, its motion generates a powerful, silent current, causing a dense school of small silver fish to scurry away in a unified, panicked pattern, their scales glittering as they disperse into the depths. This creates an awe-inspiring atmosphere of silent power, juxtaposing industrial might with the fragile beauty of marine life.", + "seed": 15403, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_14/index_1337_seed_15403_dp_28_rank_56_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.18913770355284215, + "vlm_logprob": -0.18913770355284215, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.3, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.18913770355284215, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a static, low-angle shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive turbine blade made of dark, weathered metal visible in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the turbine blade move in a slow, circular motion while being covered in white and gray barnacles and green algae?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a monolithic concrete power station structure visible in the background within a deep blue haze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do small silver fish scatter away in a panicked pattern as the turbine blade advances?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.18667833507061005 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8116782903671265 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.18667833507061005, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.18667833507061005, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.044281456619501114, + 0.5944230556488037, + 0.057902202010154724, + 0.13535870611667633, + 0.022956211119890213, + 0.023750094696879387, + 0.032174427062273026, + 0.019887512549757957, + 0.05091146007180214, + 0.018354879692196846 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.18667833507061005 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a static, low-angle shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive turbine blade made of dark, weathered metal visible in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the turbine blade move in a slow, circular motion while being covered in white and gray barnacles and green algae?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a monolithic concrete power station structure visible in the background within a deep blue haze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do small silver fish scatter away in a panicked pattern as the turbine blade advances?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026369532570242882 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651369571685791 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026369532570242882, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026369532570242882, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.049509450793266296, + 0.5174809694290161, + 0.019223574548959732, + 0.04039030149579048, + 0.06452705711126328, + 0.028857512399554253, + 0.0400560162961483, + 0.0384928397834301, + 0.03546996787190437, + 0.1659923493862152 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026369532570242882 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a static, low-angle shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive turbine blade made of dark, weathered metal visible in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the turbine blade move in a slow, circular motion while being covered in white and gray barnacles and green algae?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a monolithic concrete power station structure visible in the background within a deep blue haze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do small silver fish scatter away in a panicked pattern as the turbine blade advances?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029825512319803238 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529825448989868 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029825512319803238, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029825512319803238, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21389035880565643, + 0.19024384021759033, + 0.02308867871761322, + 0.07523775100708008, + 0.09764285385608673, + 0.038149259984493256, + 0.12300843000411987, + 0.06399357318878174, + 0.04710845276713371, + 0.1276368647813797 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029825512319803238 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a static, low-angle shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive turbine blade made of dark, weathered metal visible in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the turbine blade move in a slow, circular motion while being covered in white and gray barnacles and green algae?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a monolithic concrete power station structure visible in the background within a deep blue haze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do small silver fish scatter away in a panicked pattern as the turbine blade advances?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07001670449972153 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695016622543335 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07001670449972153, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07001670449972153, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09868216514587402, + 0.23615697026252747, + 0.14020365476608276, + 0.10315393656492233, + 0.04419970512390137, + 0.10144729912281036, + 0.0681801289319992, + 0.07792036980390549, + 0.07405184954404831, + 0.056003883481025696 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07001670449972153 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a static, low-angle shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive turbine blade made of dark, weathered metal visible in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the turbine blade move in a slow, circular motion while being covered in white and gray barnacles and green algae?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a monolithic concrete power station structure visible in the background within a deep blue haze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do small silver fish scatter away in a panicked pattern as the turbine blade advances?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.632798433303833 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.757798433303833 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.632798433303833, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.632798433303833, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20405226945877075, + 0.3479602336883545, + 0.08879002928733826, + 0.030100852251052856, + 0.03296586126089096, + 0.0425921268761158, + 0.06098225712776184, + 0.07520485669374466, + 0.06187063455581665, + 0.05548081547021866 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.632798433303833 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a photorealistic CGI rendering, the camera is positioned in a static, low-angle shot of an underwater foreground, a perspective that masterfully captures the immense scale of the tidal power station. A massive turbine blade, crafted from dark, weathered metal, sweeps past in a slow, powerful, and deliberate circular motion. Its vast surface is a tangible tapestry of long-soaked water, covered in clusters of white and gray barnacles and capped by long strands of vibrant green algae that gently sway in the water. Ethereal sunlight penetrates the distant sea surface, breaking into an ever-shifting, intricate network of corrosion patterns that dance across the blade's richly textured surface, while the monolithic concrete structure of the power station looms in a deep blue haze. As the leading edge of the blade advances, its motion generates a powerful, silent current, causing a dense school of small silver fish to scurry away in a unified, panicked pattern, their scales glittering as they disperse into the depths. This creates an awe-inspiring atmosphere of silent power, juxtaposing industrial might with the fragile beauty of marine life.", + "seed": 15404, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_14/index_1337_seed_15404_dp_29_rank_58_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.3444634474813938, + "vlm_logprob": -0.3444634474813938, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.95, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.3444634474813938, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a static, low-angle shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive turbine blade made of dark, weathered metal visible in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the turbine blade move in a slow, circular motion while being covered in white and gray barnacles and green algae?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a monolithic concrete power station structure visible in the background within a deep blue haze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do small silver fish scatter away in a panicked pattern as the turbine blade advances?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2267383337020874 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.351738303899765 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.2267383337020874, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -1.2267383337020874, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14947594702243805, + 0.03474362567067146, + 0.09338228404521942, + 0.10423129051923752, + 0.06808284670114517, + 0.05112878605723381, + 0.09374852478504181, + 0.15662157535552979, + 0.1731652319431305, + 0.07541988044977188 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.2267383337020874 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a static, low-angle shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive turbine blade made of dark, weathered metal visible in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the turbine blade move in a slow, circular motion while being covered in white and gray barnacles and green algae?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a monolithic concrete power station structure visible in the background within a deep blue haze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do small silver fish scatter away in a panicked pattern as the turbine blade advances?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023320799693465233 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7733209133148193 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023320799693465233, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023320799693465233, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10550441592931747, + 0.1412731558084488, + 0.058499712496995926, + 0.04459689185023308, + 0.03739357739686966, + 0.029495183378458023, + 0.04175031930208206, + 0.4442411959171295, + 0.058143604546785355, + 0.039101921021938324 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023320799693465233 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a static, low-angle shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive turbine blade made of dark, weathered metal visible in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the turbine blade move in a slow, circular motion while being covered in white and gray barnacles and green algae?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a monolithic concrete power station structure visible in the background within a deep blue haze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do small silver fish scatter away in a panicked pattern as the turbine blade advances?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023313229903578758 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773313283920288 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023313229903578758, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023313229903578758, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09552576392889023, + 0.11901451647281647, + 0.06141534447669983, + 0.07148925215005875, + 0.0494256317615509, + 0.09532357007265091, + 0.07821274548768997, + 0.23968085646629333, + 0.08743499964475632, + 0.10247733443975449 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023313229903578758 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a static, low-angle shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive turbine blade made of dark, weathered metal visible in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the turbine blade move in a slow, circular motion while being covered in white and gray barnacles and green algae?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a monolithic concrete power station structure visible in the background within a deep blue haze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do small silver fish scatter away in a panicked pattern as the turbine blade advances?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10031387954950333 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.350313901901245 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10031387954950333, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10031387954950333, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11185316741466522, + 0.06024004518985748, + 0.066149041056633, + 0.057277798652648926, + 0.040055230259895325, + 0.017571421340107918, + 0.13744652271270752, + 0.3941667973995209, + 0.06693659722805023, + 0.04830342158675194 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10031387954950333 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a static, low-angle shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive turbine blade made of dark, weathered metal visible in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the turbine blade move in a slow, circular motion while being covered in white and gray barnacles and green algae?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a monolithic concrete power station structure visible in the background within a deep blue haze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do small silver fish scatter away in a panicked pattern as the turbine blade advances?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.34863099455833435 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2236310243606567 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.34863099455833435, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.34863099455833435, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1598389893770218, + 0.07955341041088104, + 0.05704166740179062, + 0.05719814822077751, + 0.058694787323474884, + 0.19380924105644226, + 0.06185225397348404, + 0.16173556447029114, + 0.07954799383878708, + 0.09072797000408173 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.34863099455833435 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a photorealistic CGI rendering, the camera is positioned in a static, low-angle shot of an underwater foreground, a perspective that masterfully captures the immense scale of the tidal power station. A massive turbine blade, crafted from dark, weathered metal, sweeps past in a slow, powerful, and deliberate circular motion. Its vast surface is a tangible tapestry of long-soaked water, covered in clusters of white and gray barnacles and capped by long strands of vibrant green algae that gently sway in the water. Ethereal sunlight penetrates the distant sea surface, breaking into an ever-shifting, intricate network of corrosion patterns that dance across the blade's richly textured surface, while the monolithic concrete structure of the power station looms in a deep blue haze. As the leading edge of the blade advances, its motion generates a powerful, silent current, causing a dense school of small silver fish to scurry away in a unified, panicked pattern, their scales glittering as they disperse into the depths. This creates an awe-inspiring atmosphere of silent power, juxtaposing industrial might with the fragile beauty of marine life.", + "seed": 15405, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_14/index_1337_seed_15405_dp_29_rank_58_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.14612007439136504, + "vlm_logprob": -0.14612007439136504, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.45, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.14612007439136504, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a static, low-angle shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive turbine blade made of dark, weathered metal visible in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the turbine blade move in a slow, circular motion while being covered in white and gray barnacles and green algae?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a monolithic concrete power station structure visible in the background within a deep blue haze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do small silver fish scatter away in a panicked pattern as the turbine blade advances?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2847226560115814 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4097226858139038 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2847226560115814, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2847226560115814, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1097271516919136, + 0.07549278438091278, + 0.07348117977380753, + 0.04747984558343887, + 0.2199638932943344, + 0.2772511839866638, + 0.09478318691253662, + 0.027318807318806648, + 0.050155799835920334, + 0.024346185848116875 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2847226560115814 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a static, low-angle shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive turbine blade made of dark, weathered metal visible in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the turbine blade move in a slow, circular motion while being covered in white and gray barnacles and green algae?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a monolithic concrete power station structure visible in the background within a deep blue haze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do small silver fish scatter away in a panicked pattern as the turbine blade advances?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03372610732913017 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408726215362549 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03372610732913017, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03372610732913017, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2239561527967453, + 0.1071757897734642, + 0.08415335416793823, + 0.039153993129730225, + 0.13907968997955322, + 0.22472336888313293, + 0.03270594775676727, + 0.03821156919002533, + 0.03594757616519928, + 0.07489249110221863 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03372610732913017 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a static, low-angle shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive turbine blade made of dark, weathered metal visible in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the turbine blade move in a slow, circular motion while being covered in white and gray barnacles and green algae?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a monolithic concrete power station structure visible in the background within a deep blue haze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do small silver fish scatter away in a panicked pattern as the turbine blade advances?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03372645378112793 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408726453781128 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03372645378112793, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03372645378112793, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16264209151268005, + 0.06466493755578995, + 0.09093631058931351, + 0.1388545036315918, + 0.13029614090919495, + 0.05832596868276596, + 0.1203344464302063, + 0.07648110389709473, + 0.055951256304979324, + 0.10151327401399612 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03372645378112793 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a static, low-angle shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive turbine blade made of dark, weathered metal visible in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the turbine blade move in a slow, circular motion while being covered in white and gray barnacles and green algae?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a monolithic concrete power station structure visible in the background within a deep blue haze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do small silver fish scatter away in a panicked pattern as the turbine blade advances?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029799941927194595 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5297999382019043 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029799941927194595, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029799941927194595, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14256541430950165, + 0.16025958955287933, + 0.10554056614637375, + 0.06914170831441879, + 0.09920421987771988, + 0.242379292845726, + 0.04031927138566971, + 0.051414377987384796, + 0.03927174210548401, + 0.04990379139780998 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029799941927194595 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a static, low-angle shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive turbine blade made of dark, weathered metal visible in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the turbine blade move in a slow, circular motion while being covered in white and gray barnacles and green algae?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a monolithic concrete power station structure visible in the background within a deep blue haze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do small silver fish scatter away in a panicked pattern as the turbine blade advances?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.34862521290779114 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2236251831054688 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.34862521290779114, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.34862521290779114, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1042286679148674, + 0.044136881828308105, + 0.1048683449625969, + 0.12311325967311859, + 0.10951957106590271, + 0.05999434366822243, + 0.03931623697280884, + 0.033794812858104706, + 0.05755244195461273, + 0.3234753906726837 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.34862521290779114 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_15/index_tensor([245, 245])_group_15_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_15/index_tensor([245, 245])_group_15_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..061d1a34c31d5866323f512dd941b7b9f405807c --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_15/index_tensor([245, 245])_group_15_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "The film begins with a slow, upward tilt, close-up shot of a yellowed ancient book spread out on a dark wooden desk. The texture of the paper is clearly visible, and vertical regular script written in rich, ink-stained ink appears on it. A pair of slender, bony hands gently twist the corner of the page, their movements steady and deliberate. As the camera pans upward, it sweeps across the figure, clad in a simple, moon-white, cross-collared Song Dynasty robe. Its wide sleeves drape over the edge of the desk, the silk gleaming softly in the soft sunlight filtering through the windowpanes. Finally, the camera settles on the scholar's lean, focused face. He wears a simple Dongpo scarf, his long hair neatly tied back. A deep, pensive expression etched between his brows, his gaze seemingly piercing the text within, immersed in ancient wisdom. The entire scene, shrouded in tranquil light and shadow, evokes a secluded, focused, and elegant atmosphere of scholarship.", + "seed": 13146, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_15/index_245_seed_13146_dp_30_rank_60_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.030528108589351177, + "vlm_logprob": -0.030528108589351177, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.575, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.030528108589351177, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a close-up of a yellowed ancient book on a dark wooden desk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of slender, bony hands visible twisting the corner of the page?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing a simple, moon-white, cross-collared Song Dynasty robe with wide sleeves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scholar wear a simple Dongpo scarf with long hair tied back and a pensive expression?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a slow upward tilt and then pan upward to reveal the figure's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05061768740415573 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0506176948547363 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05061768740415573, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05061768740415573, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5336293578147888, + 0.11538101732730865, + 0.017559820786118507, + 0.03160664439201355, + 0.0638464093208313, + 0.1037546694278717, + 0.02980961836874485, + 0.07546785473823547, + 0.01664431393146515, + 0.012300237081944942 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05061768740415573 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a close-up of a yellowed ancient book on a dark wooden desk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of slender, bony hands visible twisting the corner of the page?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing a simple, moon-white, cross-collared Song Dynasty robe with wide sleeves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scholar wear a simple Dongpo scarf with long hair tied back and a pensive expression?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a slow upward tilt and then pan upward to reveal the figure's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03814847767353058 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881484031677246 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03814847767353058, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03814847767353058, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.6081929206848145, + 0.05768096446990967, + 0.01188634056597948, + 0.046848542988300323, + 0.02804489992558956, + 0.10157651454210281, + 0.016731835901737213, + 0.07888535410165787, + 0.04121475666761398, + 0.008937833830714226 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03814847767353058 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a close-up of a yellowed ancient book on a dark wooden desk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of slender, bony hands visible twisting the corner of the page?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing a simple, moon-white, cross-collared Song Dynasty robe with wide sleeves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scholar wear a simple Dongpo scarf with long hair tied back and a pensive expression?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a slow upward tilt and then pan upward to reveal the figure's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014214339666068554 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264214515686035 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014214339666068554, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014214339666068554, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08457157760858536, + 0.0505654439330101, + 0.03283945843577385, + 0.02520144358277321, + 0.057197410613298416, + 0.28289318084716797, + 0.06252074241638184, + 0.11574524641036987, + 0.2557336091995239, + 0.03273184970021248 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014214339666068554 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a close-up of a yellowed ancient book on a dark wooden desk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of slender, bony hands visible twisting the corner of the page?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing a simple, moon-white, cross-collared Song Dynasty robe with wide sleeves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scholar wear a simple Dongpo scarf with long hair tied back and a pensive expression?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a slow upward tilt and then pan upward to reveal the figure's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02637452632188797 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651374578475952 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02637452632188797, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02637452632188797, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10342485457658768, + 0.05541662126779556, + 0.015303429216146469, + 0.04682350903749466, + 0.08990203589200974, + 0.22755837440490723, + 0.12979751825332642, + 0.23713506758213043, + 0.06755151599645615, + 0.027087083086371422 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02637452632188797 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a close-up of a yellowed ancient book on a dark wooden desk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of slender, bony hands visible twisting the corner of the page?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing a simple, moon-white, cross-collared Song Dynasty robe with wide sleeves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scholar wear a simple Dongpo scarf with long hair tied back and a pensive expression?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a slow upward tilt and then pan upward to reveal the figure's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023285511881113052 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732856273651123 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023285511881113052, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023285511881113052, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16317489743232727, + 0.18055330216884613, + 0.04955172538757324, + 0.07232826203107834, + 0.048145949840545654, + 0.18803244829177856, + 0.07217469066381454, + 0.08090828359127045, + 0.13126347959041595, + 0.01386705320328474 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023285511881113052 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "The film begins with a slow, upward tilt, close-up shot of a yellowed ancient book spread out on a dark wooden desk. The texture of the paper is clearly visible, and vertical regular script written in rich, ink-stained ink appears on it. A pair of slender, bony hands gently twist the corner of the page, their movements steady and deliberate. As the camera pans upward, it sweeps across the figure, clad in a simple, moon-white, cross-collared Song Dynasty robe. Its wide sleeves drape over the edge of the desk, the silk gleaming softly in the soft sunlight filtering through the windowpanes. Finally, the camera settles on the scholar's lean, focused face. He wears a simple Dongpo scarf, his long hair neatly tied back. A deep, pensive expression etched between his brows, his gaze seemingly piercing the text within, immersed in ancient wisdom. The entire scene, shrouded in tranquil light and shadow, evokes a secluded, focused, and elegant atmosphere of scholarship.", + "seed": 13147, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_15/index_245_seed_13147_dp_30_rank_60_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.01912000458687544, + "vlm_logprob": -0.01912000458687544, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.025, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.01912000458687544, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a close-up of a yellowed ancient book on a dark wooden desk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of slender, bony hands visible twisting the corner of the page?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing a simple, moon-white, cross-collared Song Dynasty robe with wide sleeves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scholar wear a simple Dongpo scarf with long hair tied back and a pensive expression?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a slow upward tilt and then pan upward to reveal the figure's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012277974747121334 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.637278079986572 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012277974747121334, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012277974747121334, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19703279435634613, + 0.05847472324967384, + 0.3011395037174225, + 0.046832066029310226, + 0.028828710317611694, + 0.08961918950080872, + 0.02345922589302063, + 0.09185827523469925, + 0.13393524289131165, + 0.028820298612117767 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012277974747121334 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a close-up of a yellowed ancient book on a dark wooden desk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of slender, bony hands visible twisting the corner of the page?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing a simple, moon-white, cross-collared Song Dynasty robe with wide sleeves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scholar wear a simple Dongpo scarf with long hair tied back and a pensive expression?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a slow upward tilt and then pan upward to reveal the figure's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02062014304101467 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895620107650757 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02062014304101467, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02062014304101467, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.228462353348732, + 0.0867445319890976, + 0.13442520797252655, + 0.0854102075099945, + 0.05322682112455368, + 0.21353930234909058, + 0.02441653423011303, + 0.03650510683655739, + 0.06180310994386673, + 0.07546689361333847 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02062014304101467 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a close-up of a yellowed ancient book on a dark wooden desk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of slender, bony hands visible twisting the corner of the page?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing a simple, moon-white, cross-collared Song Dynasty robe with wide sleeves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scholar wear a simple Dongpo scarf with long hair tied back and a pensive expression?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a slow upward tilt and then pan upward to reveal the figure's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02332126535475254 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7733211517333984 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02332126535475254, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02332126535475254, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07688383758068085, + 0.0427694171667099, + 0.07896671444177628, + 0.02281283028423786, + 0.034560732543468475, + 0.16335037350654602, + 0.058045241981744766, + 0.15868011116981506, + 0.22818401455879211, + 0.13574668765068054 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02332126535475254 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a close-up of a yellowed ancient book on a dark wooden desk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of slender, bony hands visible twisting the corner of the page?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing a simple, moon-white, cross-collared Song Dynasty robe with wide sleeves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scholar wear a simple Dongpo scarf with long hair tied back and a pensive expression?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a slow upward tilt and then pan upward to reveal the figure's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023315908387303352 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773315906524658 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023315908387303352, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023315908387303352, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07755188643932343, + 0.10204996168613434, + 0.03622676059603691, + 0.04202023521065712, + 0.02659357711672783, + 0.16582825779914856, + 0.025072632357478142, + 0.1442185938358307, + 0.23815251886844635, + 0.14228561520576477 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023315908387303352 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a close-up of a yellowed ancient book on a dark wooden desk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of slender, bony hands visible twisting the corner of the page?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing a simple, moon-white, cross-collared Song Dynasty robe with wide sleeves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scholar wear a simple Dongpo scarf with long hair tied back and a pensive expression?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a slow upward tilt and then pan upward to reveal the figure's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016064731404185295 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141064643859863 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016064731404185295, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016064731404185295, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08263900876045227, + 0.1923247128725052, + 0.12415499240159988, + 0.0666528046131134, + 0.04554734006524086, + 0.11206381022930145, + 0.04454469680786133, + 0.07925204932689667, + 0.12327151000499725, + 0.1295490860939026 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016064731404185295 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "The film begins with a slow, upward tilt, close-up shot of a yellowed ancient book spread out on a dark wooden desk. The texture of the paper is clearly visible, and vertical regular script written in rich, ink-stained ink appears on it. A pair of slender, bony hands gently twist the corner of the page, their movements steady and deliberate. As the camera pans upward, it sweeps across the figure, clad in a simple, moon-white, cross-collared Song Dynasty robe. Its wide sleeves drape over the edge of the desk, the silk gleaming softly in the soft sunlight filtering through the windowpanes. Finally, the camera settles on the scholar's lean, focused face. He wears a simple Dongpo scarf, his long hair neatly tied back. A deep, pensive expression etched between his brows, his gaze seemingly piercing the text within, immersed in ancient wisdom. The entire scene, shrouded in tranquil light and shadow, evokes a secluded, focused, and elegant atmosphere of scholarship.", + "seed": 13148, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_15/index_245_seed_13148_dp_31_rank_62_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.01787617113441229, + "vlm_logprob": -0.01787617113441229, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.125, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.01787617113441229, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a close-up of a yellowed ancient book on a dark wooden desk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of slender, bony hands visible twisting the corner of the page?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing a simple, moon-white, cross-collared Song Dynasty robe with wide sleeves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scholar wear a simple Dongpo scarf with long hair tied back and a pensive expression?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a slow upward tilt and then pan upward to reveal the figure's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008466540835797787 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.008466720581055 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008466540835797787, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008466540835797787, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24164123833179474, + 0.053099095821380615, + 0.04820132255554199, + 0.178968608379364, + 0.08237038552761078, + 0.16276778280735016, + 0.061557237058877945, + 0.07540860027074814, + 0.04116971790790558, + 0.05481594800949097 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008466540835797787 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a close-up of a yellowed ancient book on a dark wooden desk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of slender, bony hands visible twisting the corner of the page?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing a simple, moon-white, cross-collared Song Dynasty robe with wide sleeves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scholar wear a simple Dongpo scarf with long hair tied back and a pensive expression?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a slow upward tilt and then pan upward to reveal the figure's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01609804667532444 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.1410980224609375 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01609804667532444, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01609804667532444, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1896824687719345, + 0.11683280766010284, + 0.08123358339071274, + 0.3121699392795563, + 0.12906906008720398, + 0.06243659183382988, + 0.02650349587202072, + 0.020480483770370483, + 0.03010607697069645, + 0.03148556873202324 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01609804667532444 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a close-up of a yellowed ancient book on a dark wooden desk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of slender, bony hands visible twisting the corner of the page?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing a simple, moon-white, cross-collared Song Dynasty robe with wide sleeves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scholar wear a simple Dongpo scarf with long hair tied back and a pensive expression?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a slow upward tilt and then pan upward to reveal the figure's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01822136901319027 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018221378326416 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01822136901319027, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01822136901319027, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06394979357719421, + 0.047784820199012756, + 0.030835766345262527, + 0.32410693168640137, + 0.07792041450738907, + 0.13861922919750214, + 0.06621018797159195, + 0.07806814461946487, + 0.07089640945196152, + 0.10160833597183228 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01822136901319027 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a close-up of a yellowed ancient book on a dark wooden desk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of slender, bony hands visible twisting the corner of the page?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing a simple, moon-white, cross-collared Song Dynasty robe with wide sleeves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scholar wear a simple Dongpo scarf with long hair tied back and a pensive expression?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a slow upward tilt and then pan upward to reveal the figure's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02331276424229145 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.77331280708313 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02331276424229145, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02331276424229145, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11823779344558716, + 0.05396216735243797, + 0.034820374101400375, + 0.2612258493900299, + 0.07405106723308563, + 0.17804180085659027, + 0.05976616591215134, + 0.061990201473236084, + 0.057474274188280106, + 0.10043025761842728 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02331276424229145 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a close-up of a yellowed ancient book on a dark wooden desk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of slender, bony hands visible twisting the corner of the page?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing a simple, moon-white, cross-collared Song Dynasty robe with wide sleeves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scholar wear a simple Dongpo scarf with long hair tied back and a pensive expression?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a slow upward tilt and then pan upward to reveal the figure's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023282134905457497 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773282051086426 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023282134905457497, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023282134905457497, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.043292924761772156, + 0.04097185656428337, + 0.01436944492161274, + 0.3512669801712036, + 0.10295316576957703, + 0.316224604845047, + 0.047639355063438416, + 0.021563030779361725, + 0.028903678059577942, + 0.032815009355545044 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023282134905457497 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "The film begins with a slow, upward tilt, close-up shot of a yellowed ancient book spread out on a dark wooden desk. The texture of the paper is clearly visible, and vertical regular script written in rich, ink-stained ink appears on it. A pair of slender, bony hands gently twist the corner of the page, their movements steady and deliberate. As the camera pans upward, it sweeps across the figure, clad in a simple, moon-white, cross-collared Song Dynasty robe. Its wide sleeves drape over the edge of the desk, the silk gleaming softly in the soft sunlight filtering through the windowpanes. Finally, the camera settles on the scholar's lean, focused face. He wears a simple Dongpo scarf, his long hair neatly tied back. A deep, pensive expression etched between his brows, his gaze seemingly piercing the text within, immersed in ancient wisdom. The entire scene, shrouded in tranquil light and shadow, evokes a secluded, focused, and elegant atmosphere of scholarship.", + "seed": 13149, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_15/index_245_seed_13149_dp_31_rank_62_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.019715704955160618, + "vlm_logprob": -0.019715704955160618, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.025, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.019715704955160618, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a close-up of a yellowed ancient book on a dark wooden desk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of slender, bony hands visible twisting the corner of the page?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing a simple, moon-white, cross-collared Song Dynasty robe with wide sleeves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scholar wear a simple Dongpo scarf with long hair tied back and a pensive expression?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a slow upward tilt and then pan upward to reveal the figure's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011132980696856976 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.761133193969727 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011132980696856976, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011132980696856976, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07104676216840744, + 0.05772446095943451, + 0.7540527582168579, + 0.010545198805630207, + 0.025442548096179962, + 0.022412307560443878, + 0.03151610866189003, + 0.008600346744060516, + 0.011525096371769905, + 0.007134341634809971 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011132980696856976 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a close-up of a yellowed ancient book on a dark wooden desk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of slender, bony hands visible twisting the corner of the page?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing a simple, moon-white, cross-collared Song Dynasty robe with wide sleeves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scholar wear a simple Dongpo scarf with long hair tied back and a pensive expression?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a slow upward tilt and then pan upward to reveal the figure's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02332860231399536 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7733285427093506 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02332860231399536, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02332860231399536, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2194594293832779, + 0.03743008151650429, + 0.6056936979293823, + 0.028124505653977394, + 0.031856879591941833, + 0.03050321713089943, + 0.0058395336382091045, + 0.01091693714261055, + 0.014215249568223953, + 0.015960441902279854 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02332860231399536 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a close-up of a yellowed ancient book on a dark wooden desk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of slender, bony hands visible twisting the corner of the page?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing a simple, moon-white, cross-collared Song Dynasty robe with wide sleeves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scholar wear a simple Dongpo scarf with long hair tied back and a pensive expression?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a slow upward tilt and then pan upward to reveal the figure's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016097811982035637 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.1410980224609375 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016097811982035637, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016097811982035637, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04808048903942108, + 0.03890211880207062, + 0.39943927526474, + 0.03104296512901783, + 0.038144368678331375, + 0.22841791808605194, + 0.1274307668209076, + 0.03806911036372185, + 0.033206090331077576, + 0.017266876995563507 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016097811982035637 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a close-up of a yellowed ancient book on a dark wooden desk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of slender, bony hands visible twisting the corner of the page?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing a simple, moon-white, cross-collared Song Dynasty robe with wide sleeves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scholar wear a simple Dongpo scarf with long hair tied back and a pensive expression?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a slow upward tilt and then pan upward to reveal the figure's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029836272820830345 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298361778259277 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029836272820830345, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029836272820830345, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04822985827922821, + 0.03813169524073601, + 0.5760014653205872, + 0.03746941685676575, + 0.04434064030647278, + 0.07575491815805435, + 0.051198408007621765, + 0.04259076341986656, + 0.050000566989183426, + 0.03628228232264519 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029836272820830345 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a close-up of a yellowed ancient book on a dark wooden desk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of slender, bony hands visible twisting the corner of the page?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing a simple, moon-white, cross-collared Song Dynasty robe with wide sleeves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scholar wear a simple Dongpo scarf with long hair tied back and a pensive expression?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a slow upward tilt and then pan upward to reveal the figure's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01818285696208477 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018182754516602 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01818285696208477, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01818285696208477, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.051949240267276764, + 0.020949337631464005, + 0.7201070785522461, + 0.024784211069345474, + 0.02229646034538746, + 0.02918855845928192, + 0.07703325897455215, + 0.013915935531258583, + 0.014902320690453053, + 0.024873575195670128 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01818285696208477 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_2/index_tensor([5086, 5086])_group_2_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_2/index_tensor([5086, 5086])_group_2_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..c21881bbb3013bc6b9a61eb42bf75e36593071ff --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_2/index_tensor([5086, 5086])_group_2_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "Set in Makoto Shinkai's surreal anime-inspired style, the scene opens with a tight close-up, the camera static, focused on the neck of a clear glass bottle filled with fruit-flavored beer. Beads of condensation meticulously spread across the cool glass surface, capturing the ethereal glow of the setting sun. The action begins as an unseen hand decisively removes the lid, and instantly, a vibrant pink liquid erupts in a magnificent plume. The camera smoothly tilts upward after ascending as an explosive, dreamlike spray of liquid and foam shoots skyward. Detailed individual droplets separate from the main stream, suspended for a moment in the air, each a perfect, shimmering sphere. The low-angle twilight captures these droplets and the churning foam, creating a stream of brilliant anamorphic lens flares that streak across the frame. As the camera continues its upward crane motion, it reveals the breathtaking backdrop: a vast city skyline at a magical moment, rendered in photorealistic detail. The sky was a dramatic gradient of deep purple, fiery orange and soft rose, while in the distance skyscrapers and an intricate network of train lines began to shimmer in the first rays of electric light, creating an extremely beautiful and dreamy atmosphere.", + "seed": 21436, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_2/index_5086_seed_21436_dp_4_rank_8_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.08987075821496546, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08987075821496546, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.225, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08987075821496546, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a tight close-up of a clear glass bottle filled with fruit-flavored beer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does an unseen hand remove the bottle lid causing a vibrant pink liquid to erupt in a plume?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward and perform a crane motion to reveal a vast city skyline in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the sky depicted with a gradient of deep purple, fiery orange, and soft rose colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are there visible anamorphic lens flares streaking across the frame during the liquid eruption?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1805003136396408 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8055002689361572 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1805003136396408, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1805003136396408, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06798002123832703, + 0.1429392546415329, + 0.2874636948108673, + 0.057467006146907806, + 0.08185852319002151, + 0.07710020244121552, + 0.19782496988773346, + 0.03307955339550972, + 0.034150149673223495, + 0.020136605948209763 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1805003136396408 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a tight close-up of a clear glass bottle filled with fruit-flavored beer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does an unseen hand remove the bottle lid causing a vibrant pink liquid to erupt in a plume?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward and perform a crane motion to reveal a vast city skyline in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the sky depicted with a gradient of deep purple, fiery orange, and soft rose colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are there visible anamorphic lens flares streaking across the frame during the liquid eruption?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012570788152515888 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387570858001709 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012570788152515888, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012570788152515888, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05267392843961716, + 0.05190546438097954, + 0.05046326294541359, + 0.034952133893966675, + 0.04812178760766983, + 0.08476708084344864, + 0.55092453956604, + 0.042133696377277374, + 0.029250681400299072, + 0.054807454347610474 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012570788152515888 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a tight close-up of a clear glass bottle filled with fruit-flavored beer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does an unseen hand remove the bottle lid causing a vibrant pink liquid to erupt in a plume?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward and perform a crane motion to reveal a vast city skyline in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the sky depicted with a gradient of deep purple, fiery orange, and soft rose colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are there visible anamorphic lens flares streaking across the frame during the liquid eruption?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1270422786474228 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.127042293548584 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1270422786474228, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1270422786474228, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09404951333999634, + 0.08845050632953644, + 0.04598451405763626, + 0.05530688539147377, + 0.031789664179086685, + 0.06507797539234161, + 0.3805118799209595, + 0.026843609288334846, + 0.03363598510622978, + 0.17834946513175964 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1270422786474228 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a tight close-up of a clear glass bottle filled with fruit-flavored beer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does an unseen hand remove the bottle lid causing a vibrant pink liquid to erupt in a plume?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward and perform a crane motion to reveal a vast city skyline in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the sky depicted with a gradient of deep purple, fiery orange, and soft rose colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are there visible anamorphic lens flares streaking across the frame during the liquid eruption?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002202229807153344 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127202033996582 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002202229807153344, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002202229807153344, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08557243645191193, + 0.07428013533353806, + 0.06449351459741592, + 0.047533683478832245, + 0.019655583426356316, + 0.07387498021125793, + 0.43816351890563965, + 0.04656238481402397, + 0.03514657914638519, + 0.11471725255250931 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002202229807153344 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a tight close-up of a clear glass bottle filled with fruit-flavored beer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does an unseen hand remove the bottle lid causing a vibrant pink liquid to erupt in a plume?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward and perform a crane motion to reveal a vast city skyline in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the sky depicted with a gradient of deep purple, fiery orange, and soft rose colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are there visible anamorphic lens flares streaking across the frame during the liquid eruption?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12703818082809448 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1270382404327393 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12703818082809448, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12703818082809448, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04982003569602966, + 0.05032962188124657, + 0.057361993938684464, + 0.07875997573137283, + 0.05349265784025192, + 0.17266954481601715, + 0.1984407752752304, + 0.10718216747045517, + 0.048715006560087204, + 0.18322819471359253 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12703818082809448 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "Set in Makoto Shinkai's surreal anime-inspired style, the scene opens with a tight close-up, the camera static, focused on the neck of a clear glass bottle filled with fruit-flavored beer. Beads of condensation meticulously spread across the cool glass surface, capturing the ethereal glow of the setting sun. The action begins as an unseen hand decisively removes the lid, and instantly, a vibrant pink liquid erupts in a magnificent plume. The camera smoothly tilts upward after ascending as an explosive, dreamlike spray of liquid and foam shoots skyward. Detailed individual droplets separate from the main stream, suspended for a moment in the air, each a perfect, shimmering sphere. The low-angle twilight captures these droplets and the churning foam, creating a stream of brilliant anamorphic lens flares that streak across the frame. As the camera continues its upward crane motion, it reveals the breathtaking backdrop: a vast city skyline at a magical moment, rendered in photorealistic detail. The sky was a dramatic gradient of deep purple, fiery orange and soft rose, while in the distance skyscrapers and an intricate network of train lines began to shimmer in the first rays of electric light, creating an extremely beautiful and dreamy atmosphere.", + "seed": 21437, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_2/index_5086_seed_21437_dp_4_rank_8_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.044473396288231014, + "vlm_logprob": -0.044473396288231014, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.675, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.044473396288231014, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a tight close-up of a clear glass bottle filled with fruit-flavored beer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does an unseen hand remove the bottle lid causing a vibrant pink liquid to erupt in a plume?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward and perform a crane motion to reveal a vast city skyline in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the sky depicted with a gradient of deep purple, fiery orange, and soft rose colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are there visible anamorphic lens flares streaking across the frame during the liquid eruption?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.045002542436122894 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1700024604797363 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.045002542436122894, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.045002542436122894, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4146234095096588, + 0.07877518236637115, + 0.031869541853666306, + 0.08318385481834412, + 0.025904623791575432, + 0.16479983925819397, + 0.06924068927764893, + 0.02765732817351818, + 0.04923287034034729, + 0.0547126866877079 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.045002542436122894 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a tight close-up of a clear glass bottle filled with fruit-flavored beer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does an unseen hand remove the bottle lid causing a vibrant pink liquid to erupt in a plume?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward and perform a crane motion to reveal a vast city skyline in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the sky depicted with a gradient of deep purple, fiery orange, and soft rose colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are there visible anamorphic lens flares streaking across the frame during the liquid eruption?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016106491908431053 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141106605529785 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016106491908431053, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016106491908431053, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08807510137557983, + 0.17715661227703094, + 0.03865346685051918, + 0.22811783850193024, + 0.06128076836466789, + 0.19925767183303833, + 0.07464730739593506, + 0.02610539086163044, + 0.03506060317158699, + 0.07164531201124191 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016106491908431053 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a tight close-up of a clear glass bottle filled with fruit-flavored beer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does an unseen hand remove the bottle lid causing a vibrant pink liquid to erupt in a plume?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward and perform a crane motion to reveal a vast city skyline in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the sky depicted with a gradient of deep purple, fiery orange, and soft rose colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are there visible anamorphic lens flares streaking across the frame during the liquid eruption?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08903945982456207 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4640395641326904 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08903945982456207, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08903945982456207, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1439993977546692, + 0.06607940047979355, + 0.0633033737540245, + 0.09374520182609558, + 0.08161319047212601, + 0.08871249854564667, + 0.0409746915102005, + 0.03402286767959595, + 0.045416951179504395, + 0.34213244915008545 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08903945982456207 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a tight close-up of a clear glass bottle filled with fruit-flavored beer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does an unseen hand remove the bottle lid causing a vibrant pink liquid to erupt in a plume?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward and perform a crane motion to reveal a vast city skyline in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the sky depicted with a gradient of deep purple, fiery orange, and soft rose colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are there visible anamorphic lens flares streaking across the frame during the liquid eruption?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002202229807153344 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127202033996582 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002202229807153344, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002202229807153344, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1953468918800354, + 0.1090606227517128, + 0.08446343243122101, + 0.05971158668398857, + 0.13451923429965973, + 0.11761707067489624, + 0.06796583533287048, + 0.040620107203722, + 0.02464725822210312, + 0.16604794561862946 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002202229807153344 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a tight close-up of a clear glass bottle filled with fruit-flavored beer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does an unseen hand remove the bottle lid causing a vibrant pink liquid to erupt in a plume?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward and perform a crane motion to reveal a vast city skyline in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the sky depicted with a gradient of deep purple, fiery orange, and soft rose colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are there visible anamorphic lens flares streaking across the frame during the liquid eruption?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07001625746488571 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950161457061768 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07001625746488571, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07001625746488571, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11396608501672745, + 0.10205412656068802, + 0.20487195253372192, + 0.18197838962078094, + 0.039718661457300186, + 0.09850186854600906, + 0.140621155500412, + 0.026561500504612923, + 0.03613853082060814, + 0.055587757378816605 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07001625746488571 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "Set in Makoto Shinkai's surreal anime-inspired style, the scene opens with a tight close-up, the camera static, focused on the neck of a clear glass bottle filled with fruit-flavored beer. Beads of condensation meticulously spread across the cool glass surface, capturing the ethereal glow of the setting sun. The action begins as an unseen hand decisively removes the lid, and instantly, a vibrant pink liquid erupts in a magnificent plume. The camera smoothly tilts upward after ascending as an explosive, dreamlike spray of liquid and foam shoots skyward. Detailed individual droplets separate from the main stream, suspended for a moment in the air, each a perfect, shimmering sphere. The low-angle twilight captures these droplets and the churning foam, creating a stream of brilliant anamorphic lens flares that streak across the frame. As the camera continues its upward crane motion, it reveals the breathtaking backdrop: a vast city skyline at a magical moment, rendered in photorealistic detail. The sky was a dramatic gradient of deep purple, fiery orange and soft rose, while in the distance skyscrapers and an intricate network of train lines began to shimmer in the first rays of electric light, creating an extremely beautiful and dreamy atmosphere.", + "seed": 21438, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_2/index_5086_seed_21438_dp_5_rank_10_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.02991141243837774, + "vlm_logprob": -0.02991141243837774, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.925, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.02991141243837774, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a tight close-up of a clear glass bottle filled with fruit-flavored beer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does an unseen hand remove the bottle lid causing a vibrant pink liquid to erupt in a plume?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward and perform a crane motion to reveal a vast city skyline in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the sky depicted with a gradient of deep purple, fiery orange, and soft rose colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are there visible anamorphic lens flares streaking across the frame during the liquid eruption?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03055153787136078 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5305514335632324 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03055153787136078, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03055153787136078, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3211081624031067, + 0.1325414627790451, + 0.05553275719285011, + 0.10527998954057693, + 0.09033797681331635, + 0.037695370614528656, + 0.06436693668365479, + 0.02905581146478653, + 0.07519173622131348, + 0.08888975530862808 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03055153787136078 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a tight close-up of a clear glass bottle filled with fruit-flavored beer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does an unseen hand remove the bottle lid causing a vibrant pink liquid to erupt in a plume?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward and perform a crane motion to reveal a vast city skyline in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the sky depicted with a gradient of deep purple, fiery orange, and soft rose colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are there visible anamorphic lens flares streaking across the frame during the liquid eruption?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018219729885458946 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018219947814941 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018219729885458946, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018219729885458946, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13086745142936707, + 0.07582147419452667, + 0.16559810936450958, + 0.03280167281627655, + 0.12269461154937744, + 0.043464090675115585, + 0.08444944769144058, + 0.05987432226538658, + 0.15581689774990082, + 0.12861190736293793 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018219729885458946 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a tight close-up of a clear glass bottle filled with fruit-flavored beer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does an unseen hand remove the bottle lid causing a vibrant pink liquid to erupt in a plume?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward and perform a crane motion to reveal a vast city skyline in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the sky depicted with a gradient of deep purple, fiery orange, and soft rose colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are there visible anamorphic lens flares streaking across the frame during the liquid eruption?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018193157389760017 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018193244934082 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018193157389760017, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018193157389760017, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1877172887325287, + 0.0467434898018837, + 0.17330121994018555, + 0.05537671968340874, + 0.16442346572875977, + 0.06433601677417755, + 0.10184890031814575, + 0.058871421962976456, + 0.10917114466428757, + 0.03821037709712982 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018193157389760017 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a tight close-up of a clear glass bottle filled with fruit-flavored beer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does an unseen hand remove the bottle lid causing a vibrant pink liquid to erupt in a plume?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward and perform a crane motion to reveal a vast city skyline in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the sky depicted with a gradient of deep purple, fiery orange, and soft rose colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are there visible anamorphic lens flares streaking across the frame during the liquid eruption?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036188371013849974 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.6286187171936035 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036188371013849974, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036188371013849974, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17783038318157196, + 0.041544485837221146, + 0.056856703013181686, + 0.053300123661756516, + 0.23735885322093964, + 0.053638096898794174, + 0.12046746909618378, + 0.12789680063724518, + 0.033538978546857834, + 0.09756812453269958 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036188371013849974 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a tight close-up of a clear glass bottle filled with fruit-flavored beer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does an unseen hand remove the bottle lid causing a vibrant pink liquid to erupt in a plume?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward and perform a crane motion to reveal a vast city skyline in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the sky depicted with a gradient of deep purple, fiery orange, and soft rose colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are there visible anamorphic lens flares streaking across the frame during the liquid eruption?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07897379994392395 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5789737701416016 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07897379994392395, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07897379994392395, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11854469031095505, + 0.042069561779499054, + 0.035592470318078995, + 0.03303782269358635, + 0.10400182753801346, + 0.08805449306964874, + 0.07394324988126755, + 0.061557501554489136, + 0.04815893620252609, + 0.3950394093990326 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07897379994392395 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "Set in Makoto Shinkai's surreal anime-inspired style, the scene opens with a tight close-up, the camera static, focused on the neck of a clear glass bottle filled with fruit-flavored beer. Beads of condensation meticulously spread across the cool glass surface, capturing the ethereal glow of the setting sun. The action begins as an unseen hand decisively removes the lid, and instantly, a vibrant pink liquid erupts in a magnificent plume. The camera smoothly tilts upward after ascending as an explosive, dreamlike spray of liquid and foam shoots skyward. Detailed individual droplets separate from the main stream, suspended for a moment in the air, each a perfect, shimmering sphere. The low-angle twilight captures these droplets and the churning foam, creating a stream of brilliant anamorphic lens flares that streak across the frame. As the camera continues its upward crane motion, it reveals the breathtaking backdrop: a vast city skyline at a magical moment, rendered in photorealistic detail. The sky was a dramatic gradient of deep purple, fiery orange and soft rose, while in the distance skyscrapers and an intricate network of train lines began to shimmer in the first rays of electric light, creating an extremely beautiful and dreamy atmosphere.", + "seed": 21439, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_2/index_5086_seed_21439_dp_5_rank_10_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.052499193348921835, + "vlm_logprob": -0.052499193348921835, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.725, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.052499193348921835, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a tight close-up of a clear glass bottle filled with fruit-flavored beer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does an unseen hand remove the bottle lid causing a vibrant pink liquid to erupt in a plume?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward and perform a crane motion to reveal a vast city skyline in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the sky depicted with a gradient of deep purple, fiery orange, and soft rose colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are there visible anamorphic lens flares streaking across the frame during the liquid eruption?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.043882910162210464 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1688828468322754 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.043882910162210464, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.043882910162210464, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.35655641555786133, + 0.05370507389307022, + 0.022836603224277496, + 0.12128378450870514, + 0.040252797305583954, + 0.017064254730939865, + 0.07213175296783447, + 0.037237104028463364, + 0.22516469657421112, + 0.05376748740673065 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.043882910162210464 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a tight close-up of a clear glass bottle filled with fruit-flavored beer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does an unseen hand remove the bottle lid causing a vibrant pink liquid to erupt in a plume?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward and perform a crane motion to reveal a vast city skyline in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the sky depicted with a gradient of deep purple, fiery orange, and soft rose colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are there visible anamorphic lens flares streaking across the frame during the liquid eruption?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011094901710748672 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.51109504699707 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011094901710748672, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011094901710748672, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3262634575366974, + 0.02223130315542221, + 0.023189270868897438, + 0.0328124538064003, + 0.03241657093167305, + 0.015640635043382645, + 0.21395531296730042, + 0.03616192936897278, + 0.2569808065891266, + 0.04034821689128876 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011094901710748672 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a tight close-up of a clear glass bottle filled with fruit-flavored beer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does an unseen hand remove the bottle lid causing a vibrant pink liquid to erupt in a plume?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward and perform a crane motion to reveal a vast city skyline in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the sky depicted with a gradient of deep purple, fiery orange, and soft rose colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are there visible anamorphic lens flares streaking across the frame during the liquid eruption?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12703724205493927 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.127037286758423 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12703724205493927, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12703724205493927, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5267022252082825, + 0.0202060267329216, + 0.030196571722626686, + 0.06245500221848488, + 0.028191089630126953, + 0.01207154244184494, + 0.11544965207576752, + 0.08287595212459564, + 0.09003327786922455, + 0.03181866556406021 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12703724205493927 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a tight close-up of a clear glass bottle filled with fruit-flavored beer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does an unseen hand remove the bottle lid causing a vibrant pink liquid to erupt in a plume?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward and perform a crane motion to reveal a vast city skyline in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the sky depicted with a gradient of deep purple, fiery orange, and soft rose colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are there visible anamorphic lens flares streaking across the frame during the liquid eruption?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.001513170194812119 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.5015130043029785 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.001513170194812119, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.001513170194812119, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5338431000709534, + 0.04054433852434158, + 0.033076051622629166, + 0.040382493287324905, + 0.06318715214729309, + 0.025796376168727875, + 0.05936136841773987, + 0.06940455734729767, + 0.07331914454698563, + 0.061085399240255356 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.001513170194812119 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a tight close-up of a clear glass bottle filled with fruit-flavored beer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does an unseen hand remove the bottle lid causing a vibrant pink liquid to erupt in a plume?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward and perform a crane motion to reveal a vast city skyline in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the sky depicted with a gradient of deep purple, fiery orange, and soft rose colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are there visible anamorphic lens flares streaking across the frame during the liquid eruption?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07896774262189865 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.578967809677124 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07896774262189865, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07896774262189865, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19214007258415222, + 0.013817952014505863, + 0.02182978019118309, + 0.02979031763970852, + 0.025711605325341225, + 0.02767534740269184, + 0.07539280503988266, + 0.32305723428726196, + 0.2420828640460968, + 0.04850203916430473 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07896774262189865 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_3/index_tensor([3608, 3608])_group_3_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_3/index_tensor([3608, 3608])_group_3_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..887caf658f000a96fc6a068fb4bbb7b37589cf7d --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_3/index_tensor([3608, 3608])_group_3_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "An epic, slow-pulling, panoramic shot, shot from a slightly upward angle, captures the majestic moment of creation in the expressive style of Chinese ink painting. At the center of the frame, an ethereal goddess of creation stands tall amidst the chaotic void. Her form, rendered in fluid, shifting strokes of light and dark ink, possesses a translucent quality that makes her appear one with the universe itself. Her jet-black hair, rendered with vigorous brushstrokes, flows in the invisible cosmic wind. The goddess majestically and gracefully swings her right arm, tracing an arc imbued with power and beauty. As her slender fingertips slice through the void, a magnificent galaxy, composed of countless shimmering particles resembling splashes of gold and silver ink and swirling nebulae rendered in pale ink, cascades down from her fingertips like a waterfall of light, leaving a luminous, flowing trail across the profound background. The entire backdrop is the boundless universe, rendered in varying shades of gray ink to create a sense of infinite depth. The sole source of light comes from this newborn galaxy, its brilliant radiance illuminating the goddess's serene and focused profile and casting soft shadows on her wide, seemingly silken sleeves, creating a sacred, solemn, and vibrant atmosphere of creation.", + "seed": 17475, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_3/index_3608_seed_17475_dp_6_rank_12_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.049063966935500504, + "vlm_logprob": -0.049063966935500504, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.1999999523162845, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.049063966935500504, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style of the video consistent with Chinese ink painting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an ethereal goddess of creation visible standing at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the goddess have jet-black hair rendered with vigorous brushstrokes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a galaxy composed of gold and silver ink particles cascading down from the goddess's fingertips?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a slightly upward angle in a slow-pulling panoramic motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01056860201060772 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.135568618774414 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01056860201060772, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01056860201060772, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.34976518154144287, + 0.0768117755651474, + 0.07804775983095169, + 0.08124642074108124, + 0.06866100430488586, + 0.07117786258459091, + 0.0769326239824295, + 0.06987787038087845, + 0.06955231726169586, + 0.05792716145515442 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01056860201060772 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style of the video consistent with Chinese ink painting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an ethereal goddess of creation visible standing at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the goddess have jet-black hair rendered with vigorous brushstrokes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a galaxy composed of gold and silver ink particles cascading down from the goddess's fingertips?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a slightly upward angle in a slow-pulling panoramic motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018205799162387848 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018205642700195 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018205799162387848, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018205799162387848, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12465142458677292, + 0.03996516019105911, + 0.11715267598628998, + 0.1838451325893402, + 0.04638967663049698, + 0.052395787090063095, + 0.08742719888687134, + 0.09233036637306213, + 0.14898565411567688, + 0.10685695707798004 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018205799162387848 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style of the video consistent with Chinese ink painting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an ethereal goddess of creation visible standing at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the goddess have jet-black hair rendered with vigorous brushstrokes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a galaxy composed of gold and silver ink particles cascading down from the goddess's fingertips?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a slightly upward angle in a slow-pulling panoramic motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002494083484634757 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002493858337402 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002494083484634757, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002494083484634757, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1722525805234909, + 0.05352405458688736, + 0.23442690074443817, + 0.12692008912563324, + 0.06307809054851532, + 0.06668204069137573, + 0.10982540249824524, + 0.09371528774499893, + 0.051212918013334274, + 0.028362654149532318 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002494083484634757 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style of the video consistent with Chinese ink painting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an ethereal goddess of creation visible standing at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the goddess have jet-black hair rendered with vigorous brushstrokes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a galaxy composed of gold and silver ink particles cascading down from the goddess's fingertips?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a slightly upward angle in a slow-pulling panoramic motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012544064782559872 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.38754415512085 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012544064782559872, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012544064782559872, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3138975501060486, + 0.06665190309286118, + 0.11237744241952896, + 0.029485154896974564, + 0.1370576173067093, + 0.053896963596343994, + 0.062463633716106415, + 0.10351264476776123, + 0.07810112088918686, + 0.04255594685673714 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012544064782559872 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style of the video consistent with Chinese ink painting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an ethereal goddess of creation visible standing at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the goddess have jet-black hair rendered with vigorous brushstrokes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a galaxy composed of gold and silver ink particles cascading down from the goddess's fingertips?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a slightly upward angle in a slow-pulling panoramic motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20150728523731232 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.701507329940796 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20150728523731232, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20150728523731232, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.29500824213027954, + 0.04926043003797531, + 0.026795512065291405, + 0.055347952991724014, + 0.07480476796627045, + 0.026969321072101593, + 0.06725114583969116, + 0.029114244505763054, + 0.2732219696044922, + 0.1022263690829277 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20150728523731232 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An epic, slow-pulling, panoramic shot, shot from a slightly upward angle, captures the majestic moment of creation in the expressive style of Chinese ink painting. At the center of the frame, an ethereal goddess of creation stands tall amidst the chaotic void. Her form, rendered in fluid, shifting strokes of light and dark ink, possesses a translucent quality that makes her appear one with the universe itself. Her jet-black hair, rendered with vigorous brushstrokes, flows in the invisible cosmic wind. The goddess majestically and gracefully swings her right arm, tracing an arc imbued with power and beauty. As her slender fingertips slice through the void, a magnificent galaxy, composed of countless shimmering particles resembling splashes of gold and silver ink and swirling nebulae rendered in pale ink, cascades down from her fingertips like a waterfall of light, leaving a luminous, flowing trail across the profound background. The entire backdrop is the boundless universe, rendered in varying shades of gray ink to create a sense of infinite depth. The sole source of light comes from this newborn galaxy, its brilliant radiance illuminating the goddess's serene and focused profile and casting soft shadows on her wide, seemingly silken sleeves, creating a sacred, solemn, and vibrant atmosphere of creation.", + "seed": 17476, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_3/index_3608_seed_17476_dp_6_rank_12_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.06729446658864617, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06729446658864617, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.6, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06729446658864617, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style of the video consistent with Chinese ink painting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an ethereal goddess of creation visible standing at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the goddess have jet-black hair rendered with vigorous brushstrokes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a galaxy composed of gold and silver ink particles cascading down from the goddess's fingertips?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a slightly upward angle in a slow-pulling panoramic motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012954716570675373 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.6379547119140625 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012954716570675373, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012954716570675373, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12489553540945053, + 0.05237434804439545, + 0.09568304568529129, + 0.10267826914787292, + 0.139910489320755, + 0.05434534698724747, + 0.07835988700389862, + 0.04999976232647896, + 0.23031467199325562, + 0.07143861800432205 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012954716570675373 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style of the video consistent with Chinese ink painting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an ethereal goddess of creation visible standing at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the goddess have jet-black hair rendered with vigorous brushstrokes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a galaxy composed of gold and silver ink particles cascading down from the goddess's fingertips?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a slightly upward angle in a slow-pulling panoramic motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016083383932709694 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141083240509033 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016083383932709694, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016083383932709694, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1179022416472435, + 0.06687679886817932, + 0.1802537441253662, + 0.18775574862957, + 0.12083198875188828, + 0.03435034304857254, + 0.05606498569250107, + 0.04184681922197342, + 0.13934385776519775, + 0.0547734871506691 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016083383932709694 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style of the video consistent with Chinese ink painting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an ethereal goddess of creation visible standing at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the goddess have jet-black hair rendered with vigorous brushstrokes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a galaxy composed of gold and silver ink particles cascading down from the goddess's fingertips?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a slightly upward angle in a slow-pulling panoramic motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006743175443261862 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.00674295425415 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006743175443261862, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006743175443261862, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16818737983703613, + 0.046423833817243576, + 0.04773244634270668, + 0.08063840866088867, + 0.19276878237724304, + 0.11943703144788742, + 0.13495007157325745, + 0.03394826501607895, + 0.13100111484527588, + 0.04491269588470459 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006743175443261862 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style of the video consistent with Chinese ink painting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an ethereal goddess of creation visible standing at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the goddess have jet-black hair rendered with vigorous brushstrokes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a galaxy composed of gold and silver ink particles cascading down from the goddess's fingertips?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a slightly upward angle in a slow-pulling panoramic motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04866306856274605 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486631393432617 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04866306856274605, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04866306856274605, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.050300486385822296, + 0.04431925714015961, + 0.06772452592849731, + 0.10958589613437653, + 0.1418401151895523, + 0.08834797888994217, + 0.0449376255273819, + 0.04653935879468918, + 0.37745746970176697, + 0.028947271406650543 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04866306856274605 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style of the video consistent with Chinese ink painting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an ethereal goddess of creation visible standing at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the goddess have jet-black hair rendered with vigorous brushstrokes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a galaxy composed of gold and silver ink particles cascading down from the goddess's fingertips?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a slightly upward angle in a slow-pulling panoramic motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2520279884338379 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.502027988433838 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2520279884338379, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2520279884338379, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07848629355430603, + 0.03162449225783348, + 0.04521879181265831, + 0.08298202604055405, + 0.5199634432792664, + 0.03707215189933777, + 0.04539885371923447, + 0.04964952543377876, + 0.06710825860500336, + 0.04249608516693115 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2520279884338379 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An epic, slow-pulling, panoramic shot, shot from a slightly upward angle, captures the majestic moment of creation in the expressive style of Chinese ink painting. At the center of the frame, an ethereal goddess of creation stands tall amidst the chaotic void. Her form, rendered in fluid, shifting strokes of light and dark ink, possesses a translucent quality that makes her appear one with the universe itself. Her jet-black hair, rendered with vigorous brushstrokes, flows in the invisible cosmic wind. The goddess majestically and gracefully swings her right arm, tracing an arc imbued with power and beauty. As her slender fingertips slice through the void, a magnificent galaxy, composed of countless shimmering particles resembling splashes of gold and silver ink and swirling nebulae rendered in pale ink, cascades down from her fingertips like a waterfall of light, leaving a luminous, flowing trail across the profound background. The entire backdrop is the boundless universe, rendered in varying shades of gray ink to create a sense of infinite depth. The sole source of light comes from this newborn galaxy, its brilliant radiance illuminating the goddess's serene and focused profile and casting soft shadows on her wide, seemingly silken sleeves, creating a sacred, solemn, and vibrant atmosphere of creation.", + "seed": 17477, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_3/index_3608_seed_17477_dp_7_rank_14_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.04779253918677569, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04779253918677569, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.8, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04779253918677569, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style of the video consistent with Chinese ink painting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an ethereal goddess of creation visible standing at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the goddess have jet-black hair rendered with vigorous brushstrokes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a galaxy composed of gold and silver ink particles cascading down from the goddess's fingertips?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a slightly upward angle in a slow-pulling panoramic motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.015684811398386955 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.515684604644775 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.015684811398386955, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.015684811398386955, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13728687167167664, + 0.18206313252449036, + 0.12831763923168182, + 0.06601418554782867, + 0.0819467082619667, + 0.059663575142621994, + 0.10305683314800262, + 0.07119444012641907, + 0.06771078705787659, + 0.10274578630924225 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.015684811398386955 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style of the video consistent with Chinese ink painting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an ethereal goddess of creation visible standing at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the goddess have jet-black hair rendered with vigorous brushstrokes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a galaxy composed of gold and silver ink particles cascading down from the goddess's fingertips?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a slightly upward angle in a slow-pulling panoramic motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02060110867023468 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8956010341644287 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02060110867023468, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02060110867023468, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14038896560668945, + 0.19846731424331665, + 0.07484667748212814, + 0.15424837172031403, + 0.08731992542743683, + 0.04137049987912178, + 0.06583433598279953, + 0.09859872609376907, + 0.08644834160804749, + 0.05247686058282852 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02060110867023468 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style of the video consistent with Chinese ink painting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an ethereal goddess of creation visible standing at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the goddess have jet-black hair rendered with vigorous brushstrokes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a galaxy composed of gold and silver ink particles cascading down from the goddess's fingertips?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a slightly upward angle in a slow-pulling panoramic motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014202351681888103 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264202117919922 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014202351681888103, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014202351681888103, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.183881938457489, + 0.14681267738342285, + 0.22563886642456055, + 0.11409700661897659, + 0.03370707482099533, + 0.02074601501226425, + 0.13251078128814697, + 0.06184102222323418, + 0.03445984423160553, + 0.046304769814014435 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014202351681888103 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style of the video consistent with Chinese ink painting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an ethereal goddess of creation visible standing at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the goddess have jet-black hair rendered with vigorous brushstrokes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a galaxy composed of gold and silver ink particles cascading down from the goddess's fingertips?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a slightly upward angle in a slow-pulling panoramic motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008642531931400299 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758642673492432 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008642531931400299, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008642531931400299, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10617251694202423, + 0.10006177425384521, + 0.1293233036994934, + 0.2135755568742752, + 0.056779298931360245, + 0.07380670309066772, + 0.05336862429976463, + 0.0442190058529377, + 0.05842767655849457, + 0.16426557302474976 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008642531931400299 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style of the video consistent with Chinese ink painting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an ethereal goddess of creation visible standing at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the goddess have jet-black hair rendered with vigorous brushstrokes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a galaxy composed of gold and silver ink particles cascading down from the goddess's fingertips?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a slightly upward angle in a slow-pulling panoramic motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17983189225196838 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.804831862449646 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17983189225196838, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17983189225196838, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11685211956501007, + 0.15694886445999146, + 0.10064608603715897, + 0.16170579195022583, + 0.08370884507894516, + 0.11428217589855194, + 0.048192813992500305, + 0.07483874261379242, + 0.052055880427360535, + 0.09076866507530212 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17983189225196838 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An epic, slow-pulling, panoramic shot, shot from a slightly upward angle, captures the majestic moment of creation in the expressive style of Chinese ink painting. At the center of the frame, an ethereal goddess of creation stands tall amidst the chaotic void. Her form, rendered in fluid, shifting strokes of light and dark ink, possesses a translucent quality that makes her appear one with the universe itself. Her jet-black hair, rendered with vigorous brushstrokes, flows in the invisible cosmic wind. The goddess majestically and gracefully swings her right arm, tracing an arc imbued with power and beauty. As her slender fingertips slice through the void, a magnificent galaxy, composed of countless shimmering particles resembling splashes of gold and silver ink and swirling nebulae rendered in pale ink, cascades down from her fingertips like a waterfall of light, leaving a luminous, flowing trail across the profound background. The entire backdrop is the boundless universe, rendered in varying shades of gray ink to create a sense of infinite depth. The sole source of light comes from this newborn galaxy, its brilliant radiance illuminating the goddess's serene and focused profile and casting soft shadows on her wide, seemingly silken sleeves, creating a sacred, solemn, and vibrant atmosphere of creation.", + "seed": 17478, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_3/index_3608_seed_17478_dp_7_rank_14_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.03964830115437508, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03964830115437508, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.675, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03964830115437508, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style of the video consistent with Chinese ink painting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an ethereal goddess of creation visible standing at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the goddess have jet-black hair rendered with vigorous brushstrokes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a galaxy composed of gold and silver ink particles cascading down from the goddess's fingertips?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a slightly upward angle in a slow-pulling panoramic motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.024625016376376152 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.899625062942505 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.024625016376376152, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.024625016376376152, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1214510127902031, + 0.05150752514600754, + 0.024373888969421387, + 0.043711546808481216, + 0.11960506439208984, + 0.054866112768650055, + 0.07643496245145798, + 0.4368411898612976, + 0.039831943809986115, + 0.031376734375953674 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.024625016376376152 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style of the video consistent with Chinese ink painting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an ethereal goddess of creation visible standing at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the goddess have jet-black hair rendered with vigorous brushstrokes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a galaxy composed of gold and silver ink particles cascading down from the goddess's fingertips?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a slightly upward angle in a slow-pulling panoramic motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014218100346624851 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264218330383301 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014218100346624851, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014218100346624851, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17018218338489532, + 0.044892359524965286, + 0.05520983040332794, + 0.040887366980314255, + 0.15850438177585602, + 0.060145750641822815, + 0.057646915316581726, + 0.2800975441932678, + 0.09357686340808868, + 0.03885677084326744 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014218100346624851 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style of the video consistent with Chinese ink painting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an ethereal goddess of creation visible standing at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the goddess have jet-black hair rendered with vigorous brushstrokes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a galaxy composed of gold and silver ink particles cascading down from the goddess's fingertips?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a slightly upward angle in a slow-pulling panoramic motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014205877669155598 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.2642059326171875 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014205877669155598, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014205877669155598, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16686657071113586, + 0.09035621583461761, + 0.14550553262233734, + 0.06275944411754608, + 0.17311428487300873, + 0.056611448526382446, + 0.05800635367631912, + 0.10024488717317581, + 0.09478407353162766, + 0.051751215010881424 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014205877669155598 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style of the video consistent with Chinese ink painting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an ethereal goddess of creation visible standing at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the goddess have jet-black hair rendered with vigorous brushstrokes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a galaxy composed of gold and silver ink particles cascading down from the goddess's fingertips?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a slightly upward angle in a slow-pulling panoramic motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018195264041423798 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018195152282715 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018195264041423798, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018195264041423798, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1499045491218567, + 0.1016589030623436, + 0.09820231795310974, + 0.0905129685997963, + 0.07858724892139435, + 0.06484355032444, + 0.06777635216712952, + 0.17248870432376862, + 0.11721566319465637, + 0.058809760957956314 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018195264041423798 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style of the video consistent with Chinese ink painting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an ethereal goddess of creation visible standing at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the goddess have jet-black hair rendered with vigorous brushstrokes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a galaxy composed of gold and silver ink particles cascading down from the goddess's fingertips?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a slightly upward angle in a slow-pulling panoramic motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12699724733829498 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.126997232437134 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12699724733829498, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12699724733829498, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13729549944400787, + 0.0626847892999649, + 0.13118618726730347, + 0.11034347116947174, + 0.13516995310783386, + 0.09654486924409866, + 0.05392931401729584, + 0.15156826376914978, + 0.042203936725854874, + 0.07907365262508392 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12699724733829498 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_4/index_tensor([6073, 6073])_group_4_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_4/index_tensor([6073, 6073])_group_4_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..d26c40c385ce1bb34da59501eb58d7503c77ef93 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_4/index_tensor([6073, 6073])_group_4_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "powerful overhead shot, the camera gently vibrating as the ground ripples with the energy generated by the beast's movements, places the mountain-like mass of Godzilla squarely at the center of the frame. Against the backdrop of a modern city shrouded in darkness, its massive, reptilian head snaps back, covered in rough, hard, dark gray scales resembling ancient rock. While the imagery has the texture of vintage film, with a slight grain and faded saturation, the focus is remarkably sharp, revealing the edges and textures of each scale. As its massive, toothy jaws open, deep within its throat, a faint blue energy converges and compresses at a visible speed, forming a fiery core. Light even shimmers through the cracks between its scales. Immediately afterwards, a thick, dazzling atomic breath violently tore through the night sky. The core of this beam of pure energy was blinding pure white, and the outer layer was wrapped in jumping blue arcs and energy particles, instantly illuminating the entire city like daylight and casting dynamic and distorted shadows on Godzilla's huge body. The energy beam produced a signature anamorphic widescreen lens flare on the lens. The whole scene, in the retro film style, created a doomsday-like, spectacular and awe-inspiring tense atmosphere.", + "seed": 24700, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_4/index_6073_seed_24700_dp_8_rank_16_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.3917248204816133, + "vlm_logprob": -0.3917248204816133, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.3500000119209288, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.3917248204816133, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned as an overhead shot looking down at the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is Godzilla depicted as a massive, mountain-like reptilian creature centered in the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a modern city shrouded in darkness with Godzilla's head snapping back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a thick atomic breath beam erupt from Godzilla's mouth, featuring a white core and blue arcs that illuminate the city?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a vintage film style with slight grain, faded saturation, and anamorphic lens flares?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.316619634628296 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3166196048259735 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.316619634628296, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -1.316619634628296, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0833853930234909, + 0.19961638748645782, + 0.25341567397117615, + 0.04109955206513405, + 0.14288300275802612, + 0.05520620942115784, + 0.16789700090885162, + 0.009037390351295471, + 0.024903301149606705, + 0.02255607582628727 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.316619634628296 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned as an overhead shot looking down at the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is Godzilla depicted as a massive, mountain-like reptilian creature centered in the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a modern city shrouded in darkness with Godzilla's head snapping back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a thick atomic breath beam erupt from Godzilla's mouth, featuring a white core and blue arcs that illuminate the city?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a vintage film style with slight grain, faded saturation, and anamorphic lens flares?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009806079789996147 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634806156158447 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009806079789996147, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009806079789996147, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.058324821293354034, + 0.19462424516677856, + 0.2181718647480011, + 0.04935677349567413, + 0.16431768238544464, + 0.048982586711645126, + 0.18319571018218994, + 0.01875583827495575, + 0.033479902893304825, + 0.030790619552135468 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009806079789996147 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned as an overhead shot looking down at the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is Godzilla depicted as a massive, mountain-like reptilian creature centered in the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a modern city shrouded in darkness with Godzilla's head snapping back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a thick atomic breath beam erupt from Godzilla's mouth, featuring a white core and blue arcs that illuminate the city?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a vintage film style with slight grain, faded saturation, and anamorphic lens flares?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.34866851568222046 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2236685752868652 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.34866851568222046, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.8750000596046448, + "token_credit_reward": -0.34866851568222046, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10666725784540176, + 0.06547509878873825, + 0.11024691164493561, + 0.1053885892033577, + 0.12128735333681107, + 0.04963214322924614, + 0.3149203956127167, + 0.0405801497399807, + 0.03518301248550415, + 0.05061909928917885 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.34866851568222046 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned as an overhead shot looking down at the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is Godzilla depicted as a massive, mountain-like reptilian creature centered in the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a modern city shrouded in darkness with Godzilla's head snapping back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a thick atomic breath beam erupt from Godzilla's mouth, featuring a white core and blue arcs that illuminate the city?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a vintage film style with slight grain, faded saturation, and anamorphic lens flares?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002198899397626519 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127198696136475 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002198899397626519, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002198899397626519, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12523917853832245, + 0.15740761160850525, + 0.21004638075828552, + 0.06882323324680328, + 0.0770396888256073, + 0.057203780859708786, + 0.15013360977172852, + 0.03817413002252579, + 0.04559022933244705, + 0.07034209370613098 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002198899397626519 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned as an overhead shot looking down at the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is Godzilla depicted as a massive, mountain-like reptilian creature centered in the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a modern city shrouded in darkness with Godzilla's head snapping back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a thick atomic breath beam erupt from Godzilla's mouth, featuring a white core and blue arcs that illuminate the city?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a vintage film style with slight grain, faded saturation, and anamorphic lens flares?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.28133097290992737 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.406330943107605 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.28133097290992737, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.28133097290992737, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.055757395923137665, + 0.04867997020483017, + 0.09111384302377701, + 0.09433060884475708, + 0.054494015872478485, + 0.1248679980635643, + 0.30393707752227783, + 0.0637063980102539, + 0.06506533175706863, + 0.0980474203824997 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.28133097290992737 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "powerful overhead shot, the camera gently vibrating as the ground ripples with the energy generated by the beast's movements, places the mountain-like mass of Godzilla squarely at the center of the frame. Against the backdrop of a modern city shrouded in darkness, its massive, reptilian head snaps back, covered in rough, hard, dark gray scales resembling ancient rock. While the imagery has the texture of vintage film, with a slight grain and faded saturation, the focus is remarkably sharp, revealing the edges and textures of each scale. As its massive, toothy jaws open, deep within its throat, a faint blue energy converges and compresses at a visible speed, forming a fiery core. Light even shimmers through the cracks between its scales. Immediately afterwards, a thick, dazzling atomic breath violently tore through the night sky. The core of this beam of pure energy was blinding pure white, and the outer layer was wrapped in jumping blue arcs and energy particles, instantly illuminating the entire city like daylight and casting dynamic and distorted shadows on Godzilla's huge body. The energy beam produced a signature anamorphic widescreen lens flare on the lens. The whole scene, in the retro film style, created a doomsday-like, spectacular and awe-inspiring tense atmosphere.", + "seed": 24701, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_4/index_6073_seed_24701_dp_8_rank_16_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.2540171366650611, + "vlm_logprob": -0.2540171366650611, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.7249999761581423, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.2540171366650611, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned as an overhead shot looking down at the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is Godzilla depicted as a massive, mountain-like reptilian creature centered in the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a modern city shrouded in darkness with Godzilla's head snapping back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a thick atomic breath beam erupt from Godzilla's mouth, featuring a white core and blue arcs that illuminate the city?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a vintage film style with slight grain, faded saturation, and anamorphic lens flares?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3579502999782562 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2329503297805786 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3579502999782562, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3579502999782562, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18731532990932465, + 0.03633186221122742, + 0.20916211605072021, + 0.1943458616733551, + 0.058500986546278, + 0.06159340217709541, + 0.047059498727321625, + 0.09430569410324097, + 0.061541177332401276, + 0.04984400421380997 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3579502999782562 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned as an overhead shot looking down at the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is Godzilla depicted as a massive, mountain-like reptilian creature centered in the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a modern city shrouded in darkness with Godzilla's head snapping back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a thick atomic breath beam erupt from Godzilla's mouth, featuring a white core and blue arcs that illuminate the city?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a vintage film style with slight grain, faded saturation, and anamorphic lens flares?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00980076752603054 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634800910949707 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00980076752603054, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00980076752603054, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07340895384550095, + 0.05126363784074783, + 0.08079767227172852, + 0.10730452835559845, + 0.02916141413152218, + 0.022690685465931892, + 0.5352112054824829, + 0.05002345144748688, + 0.03061649389564991, + 0.019521920010447502 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00980076752603054 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned as an overhead shot looking down at the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is Godzilla depicted as a massive, mountain-like reptilian creature centered in the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a modern city shrouded in darkness with Godzilla's head snapping back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a thick atomic breath beam erupt from Godzilla's mouth, featuring a white core and blue arcs that illuminate the city?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a vintage film style with slight grain, faded saturation, and anamorphic lens flares?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7578107118606567 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6328107118606567 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.7578107118606567, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.7578107118606567, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3063546121120453, + 0.23107950389385223, + 0.10045783221721649, + 0.07410552352666855, + 0.024615762755274773, + 0.05789228156208992, + 0.0348629392683506, + 0.07158493250608444, + 0.06848075240850449, + 0.030565835535526276 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.7578107118606567 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned as an overhead shot looking down at the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is Godzilla depicted as a massive, mountain-like reptilian creature centered in the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a modern city shrouded in darkness with Godzilla's head snapping back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a thick atomic breath beam erupt from Godzilla's mouth, featuring a white core and blue arcs that illuminate the city?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a vintage film style with slight grain, faded saturation, and anamorphic lens flares?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0017170461360365152 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.3767170906066895 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0017170461360365152, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0017170461360365152, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24104522168636322, + 0.20828931033611298, + 0.13452470302581787, + 0.11209086328744888, + 0.02017395757138729, + 0.030397465452551842, + 0.0444134846329689, + 0.0856877863407135, + 0.07423107326030731, + 0.04914616048336029 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0017170461360365152 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned as an overhead shot looking down at the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is Godzilla depicted as a massive, mountain-like reptilian creature centered in the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a modern city shrouded in darkness with Godzilla's head snapping back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a thick atomic breath beam erupt from Godzilla's mouth, featuring a white core and blue arcs that illuminate the city?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a vintage film style with slight grain, faded saturation, and anamorphic lens flares?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14280685782432556 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0178067684173584 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14280685782432556, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.8749998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14280685782432556, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17951281368732452, + 0.044827044010162354, + 0.09913061559200287, + 0.08982491493225098, + 0.03870430588722229, + 0.04434114322066307, + 0.10727491974830627, + 0.12449543923139572, + 0.14392788708209991, + 0.1279609352350235 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14280685782432556 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "powerful overhead shot, the camera gently vibrating as the ground ripples with the energy generated by the beast's movements, places the mountain-like mass of Godzilla squarely at the center of the frame. Against the backdrop of a modern city shrouded in darkness, its massive, reptilian head snaps back, covered in rough, hard, dark gray scales resembling ancient rock. While the imagery has the texture of vintage film, with a slight grain and faded saturation, the focus is remarkably sharp, revealing the edges and textures of each scale. As its massive, toothy jaws open, deep within its throat, a faint blue energy converges and compresses at a visible speed, forming a fiery core. Light even shimmers through the cracks between its scales. Immediately afterwards, a thick, dazzling atomic breath violently tore through the night sky. The core of this beam of pure energy was blinding pure white, and the outer layer was wrapped in jumping blue arcs and energy particles, instantly illuminating the entire city like daylight and casting dynamic and distorted shadows on Godzilla's huge body. The energy beam produced a signature anamorphic widescreen lens flare on the lens. The whole scene, in the retro film style, created a doomsday-like, spectacular and awe-inspiring tense atmosphere.", + "seed": 24702, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_4/index_6073_seed_24702_dp_9_rank_18_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.28630466205067934, + "vlm_logprob": -0.28630466205067934, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.625, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.28630466205067934, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned as an overhead shot looking down at the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is Godzilla depicted as a massive, mountain-like reptilian creature centered in the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a modern city shrouded in darkness with Godzilla's head snapping back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a thick atomic breath beam erupt from Godzilla's mouth, featuring a white core and blue arcs that illuminate the city?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a vintage film style with slight grain, faded saturation, and anamorphic lens flares?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8338948488235474 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5838948488235474 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.8338948488235474, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.8338948488235474, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.121604323387146, + 0.035564109683036804, + 0.06481579691171646, + 0.0841393992304802, + 0.13646014034748077, + 0.08257555216550827, + 0.217998668551445, + 0.05750512331724167, + 0.16306260228157043, + 0.03627431020140648 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.8338948488235474 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned as an overhead shot looking down at the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is Godzilla depicted as a massive, mountain-like reptilian creature centered in the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a modern city shrouded in darkness with Godzilla's head snapping back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a thick atomic breath beam erupt from Godzilla's mouth, featuring a white core and blue arcs that illuminate the city?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a vintage film style with slight grain, faded saturation, and anamorphic lens flares?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006757028866559267 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.0067572593688965 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006757028866559267, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006757028866559267, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10393998771905899, + 0.14900843799114227, + 0.22642512619495392, + 0.05592771992087364, + 0.04992188140749931, + 0.0786159560084343, + 0.13171418011188507, + 0.07746555656194687, + 0.09618375450372696, + 0.03079749085009098 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006757028866559267 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned as an overhead shot looking down at the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is Godzilla depicted as a massive, mountain-like reptilian creature centered in the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a modern city shrouded in darkness with Godzilla's head snapping back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a thick atomic breath beam erupt from Godzilla's mouth, featuring a white core and blue arcs that illuminate the city?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a vintage film style with slight grain, faded saturation, and anamorphic lens flares?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.38709211349487305 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.137092113494873 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.38709211349487305, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.38709211349487305, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10361024737358093, + 0.11358346045017242, + 0.059557486325502396, + 0.04108550399541855, + 0.06683430820703506, + 0.06082766503095627, + 0.046966228634119034, + 0.08819728344678879, + 0.36246076226234436, + 0.05687706917524338 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.38709211349487305 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned as an overhead shot looking down at the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is Godzilla depicted as a massive, mountain-like reptilian creature centered in the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a modern city shrouded in darkness with Godzilla's head snapping back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a thick atomic breath beam erupt from Godzilla's mouth, featuring a white core and blue arcs that illuminate the city?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a vintage film style with slight grain, faded saturation, and anamorphic lens flares?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0021991373505443335 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127199172973633 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0021991373505443335, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0021991373505443335, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0889115035533905, + 0.07387110590934753, + 0.07674266397953033, + 0.023503601551055908, + 0.0923071950674057, + 0.08665430545806885, + 0.09501799196004868, + 0.0618562214076519, + 0.3450045585632324, + 0.0561307892203331 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0021991373505443335 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned as an overhead shot looking down at the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is Godzilla depicted as a massive, mountain-like reptilian creature centered in the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a modern city shrouded in darkness with Godzilla's head snapping back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a thick atomic breath beam erupt from Godzilla's mouth, featuring a white core and blue arcs that illuminate the city?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a vintage film style with slight grain, faded saturation, and anamorphic lens flares?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20158018171787262 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7015801668167114 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20158018171787262, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20158018171787262, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08569083362817764, + 0.03478535637259483, + 0.10438873618841171, + 0.013796601444482803, + 0.08836425840854645, + 0.06688608974218369, + 0.043742746114730835, + 0.060575298964977264, + 0.4107407331466675, + 0.09102936089038849 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 2, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20158018171787262 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "powerful overhead shot, the camera gently vibrating as the ground ripples with the energy generated by the beast's movements, places the mountain-like mass of Godzilla squarely at the center of the frame. Against the backdrop of a modern city shrouded in darkness, its massive, reptilian head snaps back, covered in rough, hard, dark gray scales resembling ancient rock. While the imagery has the texture of vintage film, with a slight grain and faded saturation, the focus is remarkably sharp, revealing the edges and textures of each scale. As its massive, toothy jaws open, deep within its throat, a faint blue energy converges and compresses at a visible speed, forming a fiery core. Light even shimmers through the cracks between its scales. Immediately afterwards, a thick, dazzling atomic breath violently tore through the night sky. The core of this beam of pure energy was blinding pure white, and the outer layer was wrapped in jumping blue arcs and energy particles, instantly illuminating the entire city like daylight and casting dynamic and distorted shadows on Godzilla's huge body. The energy beam produced a signature anamorphic widescreen lens flare on the lens. The whole scene, in the retro film style, created a doomsday-like, spectacular and awe-inspiring tense atmosphere.", + "seed": 24703, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_4/index_6073_seed_24703_dp_9_rank_18_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.2232780138961971, + "vlm_logprob": -0.2232780138961971, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.7, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.2232780138961971, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned as an overhead shot looking down at the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is Godzilla depicted as a massive, mountain-like reptilian creature centered in the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a modern city shrouded in darkness with Godzilla's head snapping back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a thick atomic breath beam erupt from Godzilla's mouth, featuring a white core and blue arcs that illuminate the city?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a vintage film style with slight grain, faded saturation, and anamorphic lens flares?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5281550884246826 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9031550884246826 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5281550884246826, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5281550884246826, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14823833107948303, + 0.05566232278943062, + 0.09755194187164307, + 0.0666278675198555, + 0.10292551666498184, + 0.04846818000078201, + 0.04656478390097618, + 0.10107702016830444, + 0.11568605899810791, + 0.21719799935817719 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5281550884246826 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned as an overhead shot looking down at the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is Godzilla depicted as a massive, mountain-like reptilian creature centered in the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a modern city shrouded in darkness with Godzilla's head snapping back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a thick atomic breath beam erupt from Godzilla's mouth, featuring a white core and blue arcs that illuminate the city?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a vintage film style with slight grain, faded saturation, and anamorphic lens flares?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01820884272456169 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018208980560303 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01820884272456169, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01820884272456169, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11246488243341446, + 0.08970244228839874, + 0.07532252371311188, + 0.1634901612997055, + 0.024265723302960396, + 0.08497782051563263, + 0.023421412333846092, + 0.04425443708896637, + 0.058739546686410904, + 0.32336103916168213 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01820884272456169 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned as an overhead shot looking down at the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is Godzilla depicted as a massive, mountain-like reptilian creature centered in the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a modern city shrouded in darkness with Godzilla's head snapping back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a thick atomic breath beam erupt from Godzilla's mouth, featuring a white core and blue arcs that illuminate the city?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a vintage film style with slight grain, faded saturation, and anamorphic lens flares?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5233482122421265 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8983482122421265 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5233482122421265, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5233482122421265, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1040569543838501, + 0.04864102602005005, + 0.025127679109573364, + 0.21216504275798798, + 0.01887957751750946, + 0.020939571782946587, + 0.010367210954427719, + 0.01799163781106472, + 0.02505577728152275, + 0.5167754888534546 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5233482122421265 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned as an overhead shot looking down at the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is Godzilla depicted as a massive, mountain-like reptilian creature centered in the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a modern city shrouded in darkness with Godzilla's head snapping back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a thick atomic breath beam erupt from Godzilla's mouth, featuring a white core and blue arcs that illuminate the city?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a vintage film style with slight grain, faded saturation, and anamorphic lens flares?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036165802739560604 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628616809844971 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036165802739560604, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036165802739560604, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11118905246257782, + 0.041602328419685364, + 0.025529973208904266, + 0.1497681438922882, + 0.03166236728429794, + 0.015471290796995163, + 0.03144335001707077, + 0.041448865085840225, + 0.05282074958086014, + 0.4990639090538025 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036165802739560604 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned as an overhead shot looking down at the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is Godzilla depicted as a massive, mountain-like reptilian creature centered in the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a modern city shrouded in darkness with Godzilla's head snapping back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a thick atomic breath beam erupt from Godzilla's mouth, featuring a white core and blue arcs that illuminate the city?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a vintage film style with slight grain, faded saturation, and anamorphic lens flares?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04306134581565857 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680612564086914 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04306134581565857, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04306134581565857, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.49108970165252686, + 0.0780816525220871, + 0.030251720920205116, + 0.024038074538111687, + 0.03323450684547424, + 0.07337196171283722, + 0.038963448256254196, + 0.03111204132437706, + 0.050658099353313446, + 0.14919880032539368 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04306134581565857 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_5/index_tensor([1695, 1695])_group_5_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_5/index_tensor([1695, 1695])_group_5_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..250004f49183b4ccf0a33bb182e5171c046fb2e3 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_5/index_tensor([1695, 1695])_group_5_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "striking, high-contrast black-and-white medium shot, shot from a slightly elevated angle and panning steadily to the right, precisely captures a snow leopard making a breathtaking leap from the summit of a precipitous snow-capped mountain. The beast's body unfurls in mid-air, forming an explosively graceful arc. Its thick fur, shimmering in the harsh sunlight, creates a striking contrast from dazzling silver to deep inky black, its signature rosette markings defined as if by an ink painting. Its powerful limbs are stretched to their limits, the muscular contours of its hind legs clearly visible in the black and white, highlighting the immense force that propels this leap. Its long, sturdy tail curls dynamically behind it, maintaining perfect balance. The backdrop is a stark contrast between the rugged, wind-worn black rock and the pristine white of the snow. The shadows cast by the rock are a bottomless black, heightening the forbidding and majestic atmosphere. As it leaps, fine snow powder is shaken off the rock wall it steps on and flies in the air, adding a dynamic texture to this frozen moment. The whole picture is full of primitive vitality and wild beauty, conveying an awe-inspiring strength and determination to survive in extreme environments.", + "seed": 9583, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_5/index_1695_seed_9583_dp_10_rank_20_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.11109473337419332, + "vlm_logprob": -0.11109473337419332, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.625, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.11109473337419332, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in black and white with high contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a snow leopard making a leap from a snow-capped mountain summit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the snow leopard's fur display a contrast between silver and deep black with defined rosette markings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of rugged black rock and pristine white snow with deep black shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan steadily to the right while capturing the leopard's leap?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03564143925905228 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5356414318084717 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03564143925905228, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03564143925905228, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1123007982969284, + 0.050442613661289215, + 0.10430775582790375, + 0.11045993119478226, + 0.3170264661312103, + 0.1275588870048523, + 0.028552552685141563, + 0.02393028698861599, + 0.021134117618203163, + 0.10428660362958908 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03564143925905228 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in black and white with high contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a snow leopard making a leap from a snow-capped mountain summit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the snow leopard's fur display a contrast between silver and deep black with defined rosette markings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of rugged black rock and pristine white snow with deep black shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan steadily to the right while capturing the leopard's leap?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20153875648975372 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7015388011932373 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20153875648975372, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20153875648975372, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04986076429486275, + 0.1107165664434433, + 0.0336492583155632, + 0.019879823550581932, + 0.051708612591028214, + 0.6037589907646179, + 0.026194758713245392, + 0.04194808751344681, + 0.01300537958741188, + 0.049277741461992264 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20153875648975372 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in black and white with high contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a snow leopard making a leap from a snow-capped mountain summit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the snow leopard's fur display a contrast between silver and deep black with defined rosette markings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of rugged black rock and pristine white snow with deep black shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan steadily to the right while capturing the leopard's leap?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003193400101736188 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753193378448486 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003193400101736188, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003193400101736188, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1182146966457367, + 0.09736048430204391, + 0.07033494859933853, + 0.040092747658491135, + 0.23987902700901031, + 0.125897616147995, + 0.06679954379796982, + 0.08245518058538437, + 0.0702313631772995, + 0.08873441070318222 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003193400101736188 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in black and white with high contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a snow leopard making a leap from a snow-capped mountain summit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the snow leopard's fur display a contrast between silver and deep black with defined rosette markings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of rugged black rock and pristine white snow with deep black shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan steadily to the right while capturing the leopard's leap?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0017101438716053963 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.376709938049316 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0017101438716053963, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0017101438716053963, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04877672344446182, + 0.05461017042398453, + 0.06294318288564682, + 0.0275089330971241, + 0.06665695458650589, + 0.5990081429481506, + 0.06561554968357086, + 0.015104684978723526, + 0.020285064354538918, + 0.03949062526226044 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0017101438716053963 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in black and white with high contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a snow leopard making a leap from a snow-capped mountain summit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the snow leopard's fur display a contrast between silver and deep black with defined rosette markings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of rugged black rock and pristine white snow with deep black shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan steadily to the right while capturing the leopard's leap?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.31338992714881897 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3133898973464966 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.31338992714881897, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.31338992714881897, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12485913187265396, + 0.05532706528902054, + 0.06287476420402527, + 0.035765282809734344, + 0.1153721883893013, + 0.37414419651031494, + 0.1199919655919075, + 0.062338512390851974, + 0.013729920610785484, + 0.03559694066643715 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.31338992714881897 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "striking, high-contrast black-and-white medium shot, shot from a slightly elevated angle and panning steadily to the right, precisely captures a snow leopard making a breathtaking leap from the summit of a precipitous snow-capped mountain. The beast's body unfurls in mid-air, forming an explosively graceful arc. Its thick fur, shimmering in the harsh sunlight, creates a striking contrast from dazzling silver to deep inky black, its signature rosette markings defined as if by an ink painting. Its powerful limbs are stretched to their limits, the muscular contours of its hind legs clearly visible in the black and white, highlighting the immense force that propels this leap. Its long, sturdy tail curls dynamically behind it, maintaining perfect balance. The backdrop is a stark contrast between the rugged, wind-worn black rock and the pristine white of the snow. The shadows cast by the rock are a bottomless black, heightening the forbidding and majestic atmosphere. As it leaps, fine snow powder is shaken off the rock wall it steps on and flies in the air, adding a dynamic texture to this frozen moment. The whole picture is full of primitive vitality and wild beauty, conveying an awe-inspiring strength and determination to survive in extreme environments.", + "seed": 9584, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_5/index_1695_seed_9584_dp_10_rank_20_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.0636618610471487, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0636618610471487, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.825000023841858, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0636618610471487, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in black and white with high contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a snow leopard making a leap from a snow-capped mountain summit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the snow leopard's fur display a contrast between silver and deep black with defined rosette markings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of rugged black rock and pristine white snow with deep black shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan steadily to the right while capturing the leopard's leap?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026457654312253 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7764575481414795 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026457654312253, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026457654312253, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22474801540374756, + 0.09102092683315277, + 0.03530420362949371, + 0.058817967772483826, + 0.18200792372226715, + 0.10724974423646927, + 0.04592519626021385, + 0.04213633015751839, + 0.07424311339855194, + 0.1385466456413269 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026457654312253 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in black and white with high contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a snow leopard making a leap from a snow-capped mountain summit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the snow leopard's fur display a contrast between silver and deep black with defined rosette markings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of rugged black rock and pristine white snow with deep black shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan steadily to the right while capturing the leopard's leap?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1427847445011139 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.017784833908081 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1427847445011139, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.8750001192092896, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1427847445011139, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08278746902942657, + 0.0892006978392601, + 0.03766403719782829, + 0.03218650072813034, + 0.2205125391483307, + 0.09107962250709534, + 0.07267751544713974, + 0.17663484811782837, + 0.16042742133140564, + 0.03682946413755417 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1427847445011139 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in black and white with high contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a snow leopard making a leap from a snow-capped mountain summit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the snow leopard's fur display a contrast between silver and deep black with defined rosette markings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of rugged black rock and pristine white snow with deep black shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan steadily to the right while capturing the leopard's leap?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004098231438547373 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504098415374756 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004098231438547373, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004098231438547373, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11370895802974701, + 0.04721803590655327, + 0.020410198718309402, + 0.05118156224489212, + 0.4795198142528534, + 0.08944536000490189, + 0.044232018291950226, + 0.06622233986854553, + 0.03241701424121857, + 0.05564478412270546 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004098231438547373 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in black and white with high contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a snow leopard making a leap from a snow-capped mountain summit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the snow leopard's fur display a contrast between silver and deep black with defined rosette markings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of rugged black rock and pristine white snow with deep black shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan steadily to the right while capturing the leopard's leap?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002195806708186865 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127195835113525 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002195806708186865, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002195806708186865, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08225782960653305, + 0.1447880119085312, + 0.03501049801707268, + 0.0625225231051445, + 0.23528674244880676, + 0.0462798997759819, + 0.0814378410577774, + 0.1199602410197258, + 0.08691734075546265, + 0.10553912818431854 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002195806708186865 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in black and white with high contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a snow leopard making a leap from a snow-capped mountain summit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the snow leopard's fur display a contrast between silver and deep black with defined rosette markings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of rugged black rock and pristine white snow with deep black shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan steadily to the right while capturing the leopard's leap?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1427728682756424 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.017772912979126 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1427728682756424, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1427728682756424, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.047055572271347046, + 0.15550997853279114, + 0.04832319915294647, + 0.04655531793832779, + 0.33969879150390625, + 0.18334808945655823, + 0.03419429063796997, + 0.029524995014071465, + 0.08162213116884232, + 0.03416761755943298 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1427728682756424 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "striking, high-contrast black-and-white medium shot, shot from a slightly elevated angle and panning steadily to the right, precisely captures a snow leopard making a breathtaking leap from the summit of a precipitous snow-capped mountain. The beast's body unfurls in mid-air, forming an explosively graceful arc. Its thick fur, shimmering in the harsh sunlight, creates a striking contrast from dazzling silver to deep inky black, its signature rosette markings defined as if by an ink painting. Its powerful limbs are stretched to their limits, the muscular contours of its hind legs clearly visible in the black and white, highlighting the immense force that propels this leap. Its long, sturdy tail curls dynamically behind it, maintaining perfect balance. The backdrop is a stark contrast between the rugged, wind-worn black rock and the pristine white of the snow. The shadows cast by the rock are a bottomless black, heightening the forbidding and majestic atmosphere. As it leaps, fine snow powder is shaken off the rock wall it steps on and flies in the air, adding a dynamic texture to this frozen moment. The whole picture is full of primitive vitality and wild beauty, conveying an awe-inspiring strength and determination to survive in extreme environments.", + "seed": 9585, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_5/index_1695_seed_9585_dp_11_rank_22_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.08860712577588856, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08860712577588856, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.4, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08860712577588856, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in black and white with high contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a snow leopard making a leap from a snow-capped mountain summit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the snow leopard's fur display a contrast between silver and deep black with defined rosette markings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of rugged black rock and pristine white snow with deep black shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan steadily to the right while capturing the leopard's leap?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.09538529813289642 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4703853130340576 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.09538529813289642, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.09538529813289642, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2110459804534912, + 0.05344679206609726, + 0.06858202069997787, + 0.04844735190272331, + 0.22699818015098572, + 0.09291646629571915, + 0.08735044300556183, + 0.09637586027383804, + 0.05438977852463722, + 0.060447145253419876 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.09538529813289642 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in black and white with high contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a snow leopard making a leap from a snow-capped mountain summit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the snow leopard's fur display a contrast between silver and deep black with defined rosette markings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of rugged black rock and pristine white snow with deep black shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan steadily to the right while capturing the leopard's leap?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16034546494483948 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.910345435142517 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16034546494483948, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16034546494483948, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22023189067840576, + 0.05132954940199852, + 0.14854514598846436, + 0.04598810896277428, + 0.07789064943790436, + 0.04641960933804512, + 0.046725645661354065, + 0.20816858112812042, + 0.09945996105670929, + 0.05524086207151413 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16034546494483948 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in black and white with high contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a snow leopard making a leap from a snow-capped mountain summit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the snow leopard's fur display a contrast between silver and deep black with defined rosette markings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of rugged black rock and pristine white snow with deep black shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan steadily to the right while capturing the leopard's leap?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00464052427560091 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379640579223633 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00464052427560091, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00464052427560091, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06548966467380524, + 0.12681791186332703, + 0.035538118332624435, + 0.06836378574371338, + 0.09455429762601852, + 0.42733895778656006, + 0.044236212968826294, + 0.06598600745201111, + 0.037523303180933, + 0.034151796251535416 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00464052427560091 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in black and white with high contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a snow leopard making a leap from a snow-capped mountain summit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the snow leopard's fur display a contrast between silver and deep black with defined rosette markings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of rugged black rock and pristine white snow with deep black shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan steadily to the right while capturing the leopard's leap?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002817115979269147 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877817153930664 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002817115979269147, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002817115979269147, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2691194415092468, + 0.16502869129180908, + 0.04336553439497948, + 0.12702712416648865, + 0.06914612650871277, + 0.11208681762218475, + 0.05154780298471451, + 0.0651254653930664, + 0.05031825974583626, + 0.04723477363586426 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002817115979269147 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in black and white with high contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a snow leopard making a leap from a snow-capped mountain summit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the snow leopard's fur display a contrast between silver and deep black with defined rosette markings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of rugged black rock and pristine white snow with deep black shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan steadily to the right while capturing the leopard's leap?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17984722554683685 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.804847240447998 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17984722554683685, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17984722554683685, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.119357168674469, + 0.08567075431346893, + 0.07987964153289795, + 0.10866191983222961, + 0.07384967058897018, + 0.17290958762168884, + 0.0811014175415039, + 0.15518128871917725, + 0.04813777282834053, + 0.07525084167718887 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17984722554683685 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "striking, high-contrast black-and-white medium shot, shot from a slightly elevated angle and panning steadily to the right, precisely captures a snow leopard making a breathtaking leap from the summit of a precipitous snow-capped mountain. The beast's body unfurls in mid-air, forming an explosively graceful arc. Its thick fur, shimmering in the harsh sunlight, creates a striking contrast from dazzling silver to deep inky black, its signature rosette markings defined as if by an ink painting. Its powerful limbs are stretched to their limits, the muscular contours of its hind legs clearly visible in the black and white, highlighting the immense force that propels this leap. Its long, sturdy tail curls dynamically behind it, maintaining perfect balance. The backdrop is a stark contrast between the rugged, wind-worn black rock and the pristine white of the snow. The shadows cast by the rock are a bottomless black, heightening the forbidding and majestic atmosphere. As it leaps, fine snow powder is shaken off the rock wall it steps on and flies in the air, adding a dynamic texture to this frozen moment. The whole picture is full of primitive vitality and wild beauty, conveying an awe-inspiring strength and determination to survive in extreme environments.", + "seed": 9586, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_5/index_1695_seed_9586_dp_11_rank_22_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.05699592824093998, + "vlm_logprob": -0.05699592824093998, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.65, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.05699592824093998, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in black and white with high contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a snow leopard making a leap from a snow-capped mountain summit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the snow leopard's fur display a contrast between silver and deep black with defined rosette markings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of rugged black rock and pristine white snow with deep black shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan steadily to the right while capturing the leopard's leap?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11921792477369308 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.244217872619629 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11921792477369308, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11921792477369308, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10093424469232559, + 0.23449960350990295, + 0.05749386548995972, + 0.05785262584686279, + 0.04489880055189133, + 0.03361622616648674, + 0.11613571643829346, + 0.20869381725788116, + 0.053401168435811996, + 0.09247396886348724 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11921792477369308 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in black and white with high contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a snow leopard making a leap from a snow-capped mountain summit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the snow leopard's fur display a contrast between silver and deep black with defined rosette markings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of rugged black rock and pristine white snow with deep black shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan steadily to the right while capturing the leopard's leap?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07898063212633133 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5789806842803955 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07898063212633133, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07898063212633133, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07782751321792603, + 0.241551473736763, + 0.12046835571527481, + 0.06282273679971695, + 0.03488940745592117, + 0.06395140290260315, + 0.08752240240573883, + 0.08408243954181671, + 0.12723496556282043, + 0.09964925050735474 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07898063212633133 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in black and white with high contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a snow leopard making a leap from a snow-capped mountain summit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the snow leopard's fur display a contrast between silver and deep black with defined rosette markings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of rugged black rock and pristine white snow with deep black shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan steadily to the right while capturing the leopard's leap?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004641236271709204 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379641056060791 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004641236271709204, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004641236271709204, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09808424860239029, + 0.05394785851240158, + 0.048377782106399536, + 0.05020837485790253, + 0.020053191110491753, + 0.022094495594501495, + 0.05715389922261238, + 0.44592779874801636, + 0.1508013755083084, + 0.053350940346717834 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004641236271709204 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in black and white with high contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a snow leopard making a leap from a snow-capped mountain summit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the snow leopard's fur display a contrast between silver and deep black with defined rosette markings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of rugged black rock and pristine white snow with deep black shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan steadily to the right while capturing the leopard's leap?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003191380063071847 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.7531914710998535 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003191380063071847, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003191380063071847, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09995095431804657, + 0.13921533524990082, + 0.05237320438027382, + 0.17007742822170258, + 0.04378874599933624, + 0.028898876160383224, + 0.03991906717419624, + 0.1974017173051834, + 0.1803596019744873, + 0.048015106469392776 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003191380063071847 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in black and white with high contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a snow leopard making a leap from a snow-capped mountain summit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the snow leopard's fur display a contrast between silver and deep black with defined rosette markings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of rugged black rock and pristine white snow with deep black shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan steadily to the right while capturing the leopard's leap?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07894846796989441 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.578948497772217 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07894846796989441, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07894846796989441, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08686760067939758, + 0.13129861652851105, + 0.032880958169698715, + 0.22517655789852142, + 0.12758980691432953, + 0.02596578560769558, + 0.14384712278842926, + 0.14963828027248383, + 0.04547750577330589, + 0.0312577560544014 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07894846796989441 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_6/index_tensor([4824, 4824])_group_6_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_6/index_tensor([4824, 4824])_group_6_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..2d8577f685cb5908f00677db1c147b14581028aa --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_6/index_tensor([4824, 4824])_group_6_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up static shot, captured from a slightly low angle, focuses with microscopic clarity on the stainless steel tip of a medical syringe. Harsh, direct clinical lighting gleams on the polished metal, creating sharp, mirror-like highlights. From the needle's fine bore, a thick, pearlescent liquid oozes with deliberate slowness, steadily expanding into a perfect, trembling bead of viscous fluid. The milky liquid, with an almost syrupy consistency, shimmers, its opalescent surface catching the harsh light and refracting it in subtle iridescent hues of cool blue and pale pink. The background, a completely out-of-focus, sterile white, ensures that all attention is focused on the subtle drama of the droplet clinging precariously to the tip, stretching under its own weight. The entire scene, rendered in a cool, desaturated palette, evokes an atmosphere of intense, captivating, and meticulously clean clinical precision.", + "seed": 9836, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_6/index_4824_seed_9836_dp_12_rank_24_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.026189990900456907, + "vlm_logprob": -0.026189990900456907, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.924999952316284, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.026189990900456907, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a stainless steel medical syringe tip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle slightly low and static?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a thick, pearlescent liquid oozing from the needle's bore?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the liquid form a trembling bead with iridescent hues of cool blue and pale pink?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a completely out-of-focus, sterile white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020121734589338303 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.0201215744018555 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020121734589338303, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020121734589338303, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14212095737457275, + 0.10847983509302139, + 0.1051558181643486, + 0.07739454507827759, + 0.1059957966208458, + 0.06768123805522919, + 0.12216469645500183, + 0.054744113236665726, + 0.03917326405644417, + 0.17708967626094818 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020121734589338303 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a stainless steel medical syringe tip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle slightly low and static?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a thick, pearlescent liquid oozing from the needle's bore?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the liquid form a trembling bead with iridescent hues of cool blue and pale pink?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a completely out-of-focus, sterile white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04308178275823593 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168081760406494 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04308178275823593, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04308178275823593, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2226676344871521, + 0.05851568281650543, + 0.02352123148739338, + 0.04262254014611244, + 0.07583358883857727, + 0.12492751330137253, + 0.07533961534500122, + 0.08288176357746124, + 0.14454512298107147, + 0.14914534986019135 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04308178275823593 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a stainless steel medical syringe tip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle slightly low and static?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a thick, pearlescent liquid oozing from the needle's bore?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the liquid form a trembling bead with iridescent hues of cool blue and pale pink?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a completely out-of-focus, sterile white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020590132102370262 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.89559006690979 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020590132102370262, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020590132102370262, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11775791645050049, + 0.11080417037010193, + 0.3012921214103699, + 0.09252854436635971, + 0.02447977289557457, + 0.1132441833615303, + 0.050305310636758804, + 0.054387565702199936, + 0.042003192007541656, + 0.09319723397493362 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020590132102370262 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a stainless steel medical syringe tip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle slightly low and static?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a thick, pearlescent liquid oozing from the needle's bore?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the liquid form a trembling bead with iridescent hues of cool blue and pale pink?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a completely out-of-focus, sterile white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004102268256247044 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.5041022300720215 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004102268256247044, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004102268256247044, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10342923551797867, + 0.03947452828288078, + 0.057390257716178894, + 0.03152434155344963, + 0.14869661629199982, + 0.10893932729959488, + 0.08434238284826279, + 0.2519441545009613, + 0.06179676577448845, + 0.1124623715877533 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004102268256247044 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a stainless steel medical syringe tip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle slightly low and static?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a thick, pearlescent liquid oozing from the needle's bore?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the liquid form a trembling bead with iridescent hues of cool blue and pale pink?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a completely out-of-focus, sterile white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04305403679609299 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680541038513184 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04305403679609299, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04305403679609299, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21594084799289703, + 0.05212000012397766, + 0.04453866183757782, + 0.03404384106397629, + 0.04172024875879288, + 0.019832871854305267, + 0.04193234071135521, + 0.055548395961523056, + 0.09652936458587646, + 0.3977934420108795 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04305403679609299 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up static shot, captured from a slightly low angle, focuses with microscopic clarity on the stainless steel tip of a medical syringe. Harsh, direct clinical lighting gleams on the polished metal, creating sharp, mirror-like highlights. From the needle's fine bore, a thick, pearlescent liquid oozes with deliberate slowness, steadily expanding into a perfect, trembling bead of viscous fluid. The milky liquid, with an almost syrupy consistency, shimmers, its opalescent surface catching the harsh light and refracting it in subtle iridescent hues of cool blue and pale pink. The background, a completely out-of-focus, sterile white, ensures that all attention is focused on the subtle drama of the droplet clinging precariously to the tip, stretching under its own weight. The entire scene, rendered in a cool, desaturated palette, evokes an atmosphere of intense, captivating, and meticulously clean clinical precision.", + "seed": 9837, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_6/index_4824_seed_9837_dp_12_rank_24_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.04682087190449238, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04682087190449238, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.299999952316284, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04682087190449238, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a stainless steel medical syringe tip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle slightly low and static?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a thick, pearlescent liquid oozing from the needle's bore?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the liquid form a trembling bead with iridescent hues of cool blue and pale pink?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a completely out-of-focus, sterile white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018018020316958427 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.1430182456970215 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018018020316958427, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018018020316958427, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15468472242355347, + 0.060159437358379364, + 0.0756293386220932, + 0.09823305904865265, + 0.16198955476284027, + 0.04148932173848152, + 0.12353446334600449, + 0.13632091879844666, + 0.10121626406908035, + 0.04674293473362923 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018018020316958427 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a stainless steel medical syringe tip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle slightly low and static?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a thick, pearlescent liquid oozing from the needle's bore?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the liquid form a trembling bead with iridescent hues of cool blue and pale pink?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a completely out-of-focus, sterile white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08905887603759766 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4640588760375977 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08905887603759766, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08905887603759766, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13109642267227173, + 0.10494355857372284, + 0.13453005254268646, + 0.08204655349254608, + 0.15977279841899872, + 0.12522409856319427, + 0.044045548886060715, + 0.07601384818553925, + 0.10142084211111069, + 0.040906284004449844 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08905887603759766 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a stainless steel medical syringe tip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle slightly low and static?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a thick, pearlescent liquid oozing from the needle's bore?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the liquid form a trembling bead with iridescent hues of cool blue and pale pink?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a completely out-of-focus, sterile white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029813015833497047 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529813051223755 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029813015833497047, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029813015833497047, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.046837352216243744, + 0.04439094662666321, + 0.08427668362855911, + 0.02553001046180725, + 0.1997862160205841, + 0.07937242835760117, + 0.1750003844499588, + 0.1727728694677353, + 0.09088847786188126, + 0.08114463835954666 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029813015833497047 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a stainless steel medical syringe tip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle slightly low and static?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a thick, pearlescent liquid oozing from the needle's bore?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the liquid form a trembling bead with iridescent hues of cool blue and pale pink?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a completely out-of-focus, sterile white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018213877454400063 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018213748931885 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018213877454400063, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018213877454400063, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09023323655128479, + 0.09476611018180847, + 0.03710697963833809, + 0.04449966177344322, + 0.28901317715644836, + 0.09402099251747131, + 0.15867048501968384, + 0.03453310579061508, + 0.07532372325658798, + 0.08183253556489944 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018213877454400063 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a stainless steel medical syringe tip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle slightly low and static?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a thick, pearlescent liquid oozing from the needle's bore?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the liquid form a trembling bead with iridescent hues of cool blue and pale pink?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a completely out-of-focus, sterile white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0790005698800087 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.579000473022461 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0790005698800087, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0790005698800087, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07691098749637604, + 0.10004738718271255, + 0.06901233643293381, + 0.08278392255306244, + 0.23451249301433563, + 0.22668391466140747, + 0.05865967646241188, + 0.06826241314411163, + 0.0279859472066164, + 0.05514086037874222 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0790005698800087 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up static shot, captured from a slightly low angle, focuses with microscopic clarity on the stainless steel tip of a medical syringe. Harsh, direct clinical lighting gleams on the polished metal, creating sharp, mirror-like highlights. From the needle's fine bore, a thick, pearlescent liquid oozes with deliberate slowness, steadily expanding into a perfect, trembling bead of viscous fluid. The milky liquid, with an almost syrupy consistency, shimmers, its opalescent surface catching the harsh light and refracting it in subtle iridescent hues of cool blue and pale pink. The background, a completely out-of-focus, sterile white, ensures that all attention is focused on the subtle drama of the droplet clinging precariously to the tip, stretching under its own weight. The entire scene, rendered in a cool, desaturated palette, evokes an atmosphere of intense, captivating, and meticulously clean clinical precision.", + "seed": 9838, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_6/index_4824_seed_9838_dp_13_rank_26_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.04860581490211189, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04860581490211189, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.9, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04860581490211189, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a stainless steel medical syringe tip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle slightly low and static?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a thick, pearlescent liquid oozing from the needle's bore?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the liquid form a trembling bead with iridescent hues of cool blue and pale pink?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a completely out-of-focus, sterile white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04498396813869476 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1699838638305664 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04498396813869476, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04498396813869476, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.154245987534523, + 0.05623818561434746, + 0.11323368549346924, + 0.12082364410161972, + 0.16683104634284973, + 0.08347754925489426, + 0.06759843230247498, + 0.1011519730091095, + 0.07587552070617676, + 0.0605238638818264 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04498396813869476 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a stainless steel medical syringe tip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle slightly low and static?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a thick, pearlescent liquid oozing from the needle's bore?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the liquid form a trembling bead with iridescent hues of cool blue and pale pink?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a completely out-of-focus, sterile white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04309891164302826 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680989265441895 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04309891164302826, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04309891164302826, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09894125163555145, + 0.0409698449075222, + 0.059185899794101715, + 0.06656170636415482, + 0.23983646929264069, + 0.1726042777299881, + 0.04825730621814728, + 0.05711724981665611, + 0.15699313580989838, + 0.059532929211854935 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04309891164302826 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a stainless steel medical syringe tip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle slightly low and static?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a thick, pearlescent liquid oozing from the needle's bore?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the liquid form a trembling bead with iridescent hues of cool blue and pale pink?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a completely out-of-focus, sterile white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011080518364906311 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511080741882324 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011080518364906311, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011080518364906311, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10198212414979935, + 0.04882843792438507, + 0.12012499570846558, + 0.021697761490941048, + 0.05974165350198746, + 0.11625165492296219, + 0.06963852047920227, + 0.1303628832101822, + 0.17187757790088654, + 0.15949437022209167 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011080518364906311 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a stainless steel medical syringe tip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle slightly low and static?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a thick, pearlescent liquid oozing from the needle's bore?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the liquid form a trembling bead with iridescent hues of cool blue and pale pink?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a completely out-of-focus, sterile white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0010483728256076574 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.876048564910889 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0010483728256076574, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0010483728256076574, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06918392330408096, + 0.04461472108960152, + 0.06693963706493378, + 0.031743407249450684, + 0.12105369567871094, + 0.04651586711406708, + 0.09602676331996918, + 0.08690731972455978, + 0.08244407922029495, + 0.354570597410202 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0010483728256076574 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a stainless steel medical syringe tip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle slightly low and static?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a thick, pearlescent liquid oozing from the needle's bore?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the liquid form a trembling bead with iridescent hues of cool blue and pale pink?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a completely out-of-focus, sterile white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14281730353832245 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.017817258834839 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14281730353832245, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14281730353832245, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11376126855611801, + 0.0880436897277832, + 0.1521235704421997, + 0.09392132610082626, + 0.15468740463256836, + 0.06092183664441109, + 0.0778728798031807, + 0.05816226825118065, + 0.1262640655040741, + 0.07424168288707733 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 2, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14281730353832245 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up static shot, captured from a slightly low angle, focuses with microscopic clarity on the stainless steel tip of a medical syringe. Harsh, direct clinical lighting gleams on the polished metal, creating sharp, mirror-like highlights. From the needle's fine bore, a thick, pearlescent liquid oozes with deliberate slowness, steadily expanding into a perfect, trembling bead of viscous fluid. The milky liquid, with an almost syrupy consistency, shimmers, its opalescent surface catching the harsh light and refracting it in subtle iridescent hues of cool blue and pale pink. The background, a completely out-of-focus, sterile white, ensures that all attention is focused on the subtle drama of the droplet clinging precariously to the tip, stretching under its own weight. The entire scene, rendered in a cool, desaturated palette, evokes an atmosphere of intense, captivating, and meticulously clean clinical precision.", + "seed": 9839, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_6/index_4824_seed_9839_dp_13_rank_26_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.030380138475447894, + "vlm_logprob": -0.030380138475447894, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.8, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.030380138475447894, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a stainless steel medical syringe tip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle slightly low and static?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a thick, pearlescent liquid oozing from the needle's bore?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the liquid form a trembling bead with iridescent hues of cool blue and pale pink?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a completely out-of-focus, sterile white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.017247097566723824 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.142247200012207 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.017247097566723824, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.017247097566723824, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10819993168115616, + 0.0574764758348465, + 0.07064662128686905, + 0.13500666618347168, + 0.15878070890903473, + 0.043216273188591, + 0.05196721851825714, + 0.1007167249917984, + 0.06343232840299606, + 0.21055707335472107 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.017247097566723824 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a stainless steel medical syringe tip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle slightly low and static?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a thick, pearlescent liquid oozing from the needle's bore?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the liquid form a trembling bead with iridescent hues of cool blue and pale pink?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a completely out-of-focus, sterile white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04868282377719879 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048682928085327 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04868282377719879, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04868282377719879, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06270954757928848, + 0.03727738559246063, + 0.2061174511909485, + 0.08644144237041473, + 0.2775851786136627, + 0.0230865478515625, + 0.0270199254155159, + 0.09704870730638504, + 0.09187167882919312, + 0.09084208309650421 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 2, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04868282377719879 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a stainless steel medical syringe tip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle slightly low and static?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a thick, pearlescent liquid oozing from the needle's bore?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the liquid form a trembling bead with iridescent hues of cool blue and pale pink?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a completely out-of-focus, sterile white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02636604942381382 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513659954071045 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02636604942381382, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02636604942381382, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06763040274381638, + 0.1338578164577484, + 0.17701704800128937, + 0.12865564227104187, + 0.23732173442840576, + 0.04380078241229057, + 0.055479373782873154, + 0.038660626858472824, + 0.035358283668756485, + 0.08221820741891861 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02636604942381382 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a stainless steel medical syringe tip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle slightly low and static?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a thick, pearlescent liquid oozing from the needle's bore?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the liquid form a trembling bead with iridescent hues of cool blue and pale pink?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a completely out-of-focus, sterile white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0046514407731592655 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.3796515464782715 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0046514407731592655, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0046514407731592655, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06261054426431656, + 0.1613636314868927, + 0.2636248469352722, + 0.02439160645008087, + 0.20773030817508698, + 0.0740271806716919, + 0.027132896706461906, + 0.0586702823638916, + 0.028640415519475937, + 0.09180828183889389 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0046514407731592655 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a stainless steel medical syringe tip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle slightly low and static?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a thick, pearlescent liquid oozing from the needle's bore?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the liquid form a trembling bead with iridescent hues of cool blue and pale pink?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a completely out-of-focus, sterile white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.054953280836343765 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299533367156982 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.054953280836343765, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.054953280836343765, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.024528609588742256, + 0.025835268199443817, + 0.06144487485289574, + 0.09014176577329636, + 0.37650829553604126, + 0.015835875645279884, + 0.025006162002682686, + 0.15281230211257935, + 0.03582514077425003, + 0.1920616775751114 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.054953280836343765 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_7/index_tensor([6809, 6809])_group_7_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_7/index_tensor([6809, 6809])_group_7_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..40c1a9d977261acd53e71421a59a200248e2d69c --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_7/index_tensor([6809, 6809])_group_7_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "An extremely close-up, static shot, positioned at a slightly low angle, focuses intensely on the base of a paper milk carton resting on a brushed stainless steel kitchen countertop. The waxy paper surface of the carton is faintly condensed, its corners noticeably darkened and filled with moisture, suggesting impending failure. Suddenly, a tiny rupture occurs, and a high-pressure, needle-thin stream of opaque white milk blasts out with astonishing force. The stream is steady and precise, creating a nearly invisible mist over the rapidly forming puddle below. Under the cool, clinical glare of the overhead kitchen light, the puddle rapidly expands against the metal surface, its leading edge spreading outward in irregular, shiny shapes. Its stark white form contrasts sharply with the cool gray steel and reflects the distorted highlights of the kitchen surroundings. The entire scene is captured in surreal detail, creating an intense and captivating atmosphere focused on this small, contained, unfolding moment of domestic failure.", + "seed": 15950, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_7/index_6809_seed_15950_dp_14_rank_28_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.08656583277042955, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08656583277042955, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.475, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08656583277042955, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extremely close-up view of the base of a paper milk carton?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a slightly low angle and remains static throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a high-pressure, needle-thin stream of opaque white milk blast out from a tiny rupture in the carton?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by cool, clinical overhead kitchen light on a brushed stainless steel countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the milk puddle rapidly expand with a leading edge spreading outward in irregular, shiny shapes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07166478037834167 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.696664810180664 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07166478037834167, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07166478037834167, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2841295599937439, + 0.061445657163858414, + 0.035427555441856384, + 0.05498652905225754, + 0.0659332200884819, + 0.05074852332472801, + 0.13381947576999664, + 0.05506748706102371, + 0.06655311584472656, + 0.19188889861106873 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07166478037834167 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extremely close-up view of the base of a paper milk carton?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a slightly low angle and remains static throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a high-pressure, needle-thin stream of opaque white milk blast out from a tiny rupture in the carton?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by cool, clinical overhead kitchen light on a brushed stainless steel countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the milk puddle rapidly expand with a leading edge spreading outward in irregular, shiny shapes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2521277666091919 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.502127766609192 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2521277666091919, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2521277666091919, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09216567873954773, + 0.028002869337797165, + 0.0498405396938324, + 0.08894605189561844, + 0.0713413655757904, + 0.12485690414905548, + 0.27112188935279846, + 0.09308420866727829, + 0.07631446421146393, + 0.10432609170675278 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2521277666091919 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extremely close-up view of the base of a paper milk carton?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a slightly low angle and remains static throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a high-pressure, needle-thin stream of opaque white milk blast out from a tiny rupture in the carton?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by cool, clinical overhead kitchen light on a brushed stainless steel countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the milk puddle rapidly expand with a leading edge spreading outward in irregular, shiny shapes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006747082807123661 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006747245788574 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006747082807123661, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006747082807123661, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13469766080379486, + 0.029308287426829338, + 0.023019202053546906, + 0.019997620955109596, + 0.10257120430469513, + 0.0306080374866724, + 0.1511761099100113, + 0.21051660180091858, + 0.14501774311065674, + 0.1530875563621521 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006747082807123661 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extremely close-up view of the base of a paper milk carton?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a slightly low angle and remains static throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a high-pressure, needle-thin stream of opaque white milk blast out from a tiny rupture in the carton?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by cool, clinical overhead kitchen light on a brushed stainless steel countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the milk puddle rapidly expand with a leading edge spreading outward in irregular, shiny shapes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10034795105457306 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3503479957580566 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10034795105457306, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10034795105457306, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23529905080795288, + 0.0992899090051651, + 0.09286177158355713, + 0.08443081378936768, + 0.09507443010807037, + 0.06007854640483856, + 0.09685521572828293, + 0.04557981342077255, + 0.07847952097654343, + 0.11205100268125534 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10034795105457306 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extremely close-up view of the base of a paper milk carton?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a slightly low angle and remains static throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a high-pressure, needle-thin stream of opaque white milk blast out from a tiny rupture in the carton?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by cool, clinical overhead kitchen light on a brushed stainless steel countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the milk puddle rapidly expand with a leading edge spreading outward in irregular, shiny shapes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0019415830029174685 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.251941680908203 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0019415830029174685, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0019415830029174685, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08700345456600189, + 0.02442805841565132, + 0.022860759869217873, + 0.0333133265376091, + 0.09495555609464645, + 0.06247207522392273, + 0.12452981621026993, + 0.1940368115901947, + 0.12955054640769958, + 0.22684957087039948 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0019415830029174685 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extremely close-up, static shot, positioned at a slightly low angle, focuses intensely on the base of a paper milk carton resting on a brushed stainless steel kitchen countertop. The waxy paper surface of the carton is faintly condensed, its corners noticeably darkened and filled with moisture, suggesting impending failure. Suddenly, a tiny rupture occurs, and a high-pressure, needle-thin stream of opaque white milk blasts out with astonishing force. The stream is steady and precise, creating a nearly invisible mist over the rapidly forming puddle below. Under the cool, clinical glare of the overhead kitchen light, the puddle rapidly expands against the metal surface, its leading edge spreading outward in irregular, shiny shapes. Its stark white form contrasts sharply with the cool gray steel and reflects the distorted highlights of the kitchen surroundings. The entire scene is captured in surreal detail, creating an intense and captivating atmosphere focused on this small, contained, unfolding moment of domestic failure.", + "seed": 15951, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_7/index_6809_seed_15951_dp_14_rank_28_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.053011926263570784, + "vlm_logprob": -0.053011926263570784, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.7, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.053011926263570784, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extremely close-up view of the base of a paper milk carton?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a slightly low angle and remains static throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a high-pressure, needle-thin stream of opaque white milk blast out from a tiny rupture in the carton?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by cool, clinical overhead kitchen light on a brushed stainless steel countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the milk puddle rapidly expand with a leading edge spreading outward in irregular, shiny shapes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.034732475876808167 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4097325801849365 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.034732475876808167, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.034732475876808167, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05294281244277954, + 0.08321317285299301, + 0.03666456788778305, + 0.0858478769659996, + 0.07017551362514496, + 0.021561292931437492, + 0.03830873966217041, + 0.011806439608335495, + 0.5608478784561157, + 0.038631685078144073 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.034732475876808167 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extremely close-up view of the base of a paper milk carton?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a slightly low angle and remains static throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a high-pressure, needle-thin stream of opaque white milk blast out from a tiny rupture in the carton?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by cool, clinical overhead kitchen light on a brushed stainless steel countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the milk puddle rapidly expand with a leading edge spreading outward in irregular, shiny shapes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17992450296878815 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.804924488067627 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17992450296878815, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17992450296878815, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04521111398935318, + 0.06033093482255936, + 0.03849733993411064, + 0.010284971445798874, + 0.09389791637659073, + 0.04059267044067383, + 0.35860732197761536, + 0.07975966483354568, + 0.21465416252613068, + 0.05816388130187988 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17992450296878815 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extremely close-up view of the base of a paper milk carton?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a slightly low angle and remains static throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a high-pressure, needle-thin stream of opaque white milk blast out from a tiny rupture in the carton?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by cool, clinical overhead kitchen light on a brushed stainless steel countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the milk puddle rapidly expand with a leading edge spreading outward in irregular, shiny shapes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007640542928129435 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882640361785889 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007640542928129435, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007640542928129435, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2018813192844391, + 0.1333344280719757, + 0.10465465486049652, + 0.07939789444208145, + 0.06879078596830368, + 0.1718154102563858, + 0.024620646610856056, + 0.032036181539297104, + 0.1352684497833252, + 0.048200249671936035 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007640542928129435 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extremely close-up view of the base of a paper milk carton?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a slightly low angle and remains static throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a high-pressure, needle-thin stream of opaque white milk blast out from a tiny rupture in the carton?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by cool, clinical overhead kitchen light on a brushed stainless steel countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the milk puddle rapidly expand with a leading edge spreading outward in irregular, shiny shapes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03811933100223541 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288119316101074 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03811933100223541, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03811933100223541, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.31440791487693787, + 0.06588881462812424, + 0.12493705749511719, + 0.04413808882236481, + 0.04378528892993927, + 0.058442745357751846, + 0.060437072068452835, + 0.0350220650434494, + 0.21420319378376007, + 0.03873777762055397 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03811933100223541 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extremely close-up view of the base of a paper milk carton?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a slightly low angle and remains static throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a high-pressure, needle-thin stream of opaque white milk blast out from a tiny rupture in the carton?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by cool, clinical overhead kitchen light on a brushed stainless steel countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the milk puddle rapidly expand with a leading edge spreading outward in irregular, shiny shapes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004642778541892767 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379642963409424 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004642778541892767, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004642778541892767, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07651493698358536, + 0.054105933755636215, + 0.1307428926229477, + 0.029852434992790222, + 0.13462106883525848, + 0.1407005935907364, + 0.09118519723415375, + 0.0248905960470438, + 0.2670860290527344, + 0.05030030384659767 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004642778541892767 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extremely close-up, static shot, positioned at a slightly low angle, focuses intensely on the base of a paper milk carton resting on a brushed stainless steel kitchen countertop. The waxy paper surface of the carton is faintly condensed, its corners noticeably darkened and filled with moisture, suggesting impending failure. Suddenly, a tiny rupture occurs, and a high-pressure, needle-thin stream of opaque white milk blasts out with astonishing force. The stream is steady and precise, creating a nearly invisible mist over the rapidly forming puddle below. Under the cool, clinical glare of the overhead kitchen light, the puddle rapidly expands against the metal surface, its leading edge spreading outward in irregular, shiny shapes. Its stark white form contrasts sharply with the cool gray steel and reflects the distorted highlights of the kitchen surroundings. The entire scene is captured in surreal detail, creating an intense and captivating atmosphere focused on this small, contained, unfolding moment of domestic failure.", + "seed": 15952, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_7/index_6809_seed_15952_dp_15_rank_30_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.045182326319627465, + "vlm_logprob": -0.045182326319627465, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.925, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.045182326319627465, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extremely close-up view of the base of a paper milk carton?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a slightly low angle and remains static throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a high-pressure, needle-thin stream of opaque white milk blast out from a tiny rupture in the carton?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by cool, clinical overhead kitchen light on a brushed stainless steel countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the milk puddle rapidly expand with a leading edge spreading outward in irregular, shiny shapes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12812474370002747 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.128124713897705 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12812474370002747, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12812474370002747, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.33936458826065063, + 0.07820767909288406, + 0.05078979209065437, + 0.1616610735654831, + 0.07889199256896973, + 0.04201365262269974, + 0.07505249977111816, + 0.06460046023130417, + 0.038999930024147034, + 0.0704183280467987 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12812474370002747 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extremely close-up view of the base of a paper milk carton?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a slightly low angle and remains static throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a high-pressure, needle-thin stream of opaque white milk blast out from a tiny rupture in the carton?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by cool, clinical overhead kitchen light on a brushed stainless steel countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the milk puddle rapidly expand with a leading edge spreading outward in irregular, shiny shapes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06207405403256416 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120739459991455 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06207405403256416, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06207405403256416, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06670404970645905, + 0.2289419323205948, + 0.0758376270532608, + 0.07369673997163773, + 0.14573366940021515, + 0.04510669782757759, + 0.06886973977088928, + 0.06078547239303589, + 0.1676005870103836, + 0.06672344356775284 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06207405403256416 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extremely close-up view of the base of a paper milk carton?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a slightly low angle and remains static throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a high-pressure, needle-thin stream of opaque white milk blast out from a tiny rupture in the carton?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by cool, clinical overhead kitchen light on a brushed stainless steel countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the milk puddle rapidly expand with a leading edge spreading outward in irregular, shiny shapes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007633444853127003 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882633209228516 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007633444853127003, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007633444853127003, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06075402721762657, + 0.2942158579826355, + 0.06759173423051834, + 0.16215863823890686, + 0.030911417677998543, + 0.03104955516755581, + 0.11127065867185593, + 0.18335872888565063, + 0.030571212992072105, + 0.02811817079782486 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 7, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007633444853127003 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extremely close-up view of the base of a paper milk carton?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a slightly low angle and remains static throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a high-pressure, needle-thin stream of opaque white milk blast out from a tiny rupture in the carton?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by cool, clinical overhead kitchen light on a brushed stainless steel countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the milk puddle rapidly expand with a leading edge spreading outward in irregular, shiny shapes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026366746053099632 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651366710662842 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026366746053099632, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026366746053099632, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20613452792167664, + 0.13472142815589905, + 0.071111761033535, + 0.1337520331144333, + 0.12712323665618896, + 0.13003654778003693, + 0.0669671893119812, + 0.0555911548435688, + 0.04874204844236374, + 0.025820039212703705 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026366746053099632 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extremely close-up view of the base of a paper milk carton?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a slightly low angle and remains static throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a high-pressure, needle-thin stream of opaque white milk blast out from a tiny rupture in the carton?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by cool, clinical overhead kitchen light on a brushed stainless steel countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the milk puddle rapidly expand with a leading edge spreading outward in irregular, shiny shapes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.001712642959319055 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.376712799072266 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.001712642959319055, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.001712642959319055, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13207174837589264, + 0.13187070190906525, + 0.07049994170665741, + 0.09715274721384048, + 0.09856389462947845, + 0.02572738751769066, + 0.14850161969661713, + 0.23860055208206177, + 0.02227913588285446, + 0.034732311964035034 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.001712642959319055 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extremely close-up, static shot, positioned at a slightly low angle, focuses intensely on the base of a paper milk carton resting on a brushed stainless steel kitchen countertop. The waxy paper surface of the carton is faintly condensed, its corners noticeably darkened and filled with moisture, suggesting impending failure. Suddenly, a tiny rupture occurs, and a high-pressure, needle-thin stream of opaque white milk blasts out with astonishing force. The stream is steady and precise, creating a nearly invisible mist over the rapidly forming puddle below. Under the cool, clinical glare of the overhead kitchen light, the puddle rapidly expands against the metal surface, its leading edge spreading outward in irregular, shiny shapes. Its stark white form contrasts sharply with the cool gray steel and reflects the distorted highlights of the kitchen surroundings. The entire scene is captured in surreal detail, creating an intense and captivating atmosphere focused on this small, contained, unfolding moment of domestic failure.", + "seed": 15953, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_7/index_6809_seed_15953_dp_15_rank_30_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.08616070216521621, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08616070216521621, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.475, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08616070216521621, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extremely close-up view of the base of a paper milk carton?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a slightly low angle and remains static throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a high-pressure, needle-thin stream of opaque white milk blast out from a tiny rupture in the carton?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by cool, clinical overhead kitchen light on a brushed stainless steel countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the milk puddle rapidly expand with a leading edge spreading outward in irregular, shiny shapes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07187625765800476 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.696876287460327 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07187625765800476, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07187625765800476, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07960525155067444, + 0.08323957771062851, + 0.05485553666949272, + 0.20506452023983002, + 0.1370498687028885, + 0.14373430609703064, + 0.07562027126550674, + 0.1366119533777237, + 0.031180202960968018, + 0.053038518875837326 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07187625765800476 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extremely close-up view of the base of a paper milk carton?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a slightly low angle and remains static throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a high-pressure, needle-thin stream of opaque white milk blast out from a tiny rupture in the carton?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by cool, clinical overhead kitchen light on a brushed stainless steel countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the milk puddle rapidly expand with a leading edge spreading outward in irregular, shiny shapes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.31346747279167175 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3134675025939941 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.31346747279167175, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.31346747279167175, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1249922439455986, + 0.13601726293563843, + 0.07793489098548889, + 0.15475265681743622, + 0.10505128651857376, + 0.06831733882427216, + 0.08704975992441177, + 0.07705792039632797, + 0.11904726177453995, + 0.04977939650416374 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.31346747279167175 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extremely close-up view of the base of a paper milk carton?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a slightly low angle and remains static throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a high-pressure, needle-thin stream of opaque white milk blast out from a tiny rupture in the carton?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by cool, clinical overhead kitchen light on a brushed stainless steel countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the milk puddle rapidly expand with a leading edge spreading outward in irregular, shiny shapes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007639241870492697 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882639408111572 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007639241870492697, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007639241870492697, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06301043927669525, + 0.040572769939899445, + 0.024069026112556458, + 0.1554257571697235, + 0.0739857628941536, + 0.051684435456991196, + 0.08256760239601135, + 0.17039255797863007, + 0.1473391205072403, + 0.19095245003700256 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007639241870492697 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extremely close-up view of the base of a paper milk carton?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a slightly low angle and remains static throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a high-pressure, needle-thin stream of opaque white milk blast out from a tiny rupture in the carton?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by cool, clinical overhead kitchen light on a brushed stainless steel countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the milk puddle rapidly expand with a leading edge spreading outward in irregular, shiny shapes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03372218832373619 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408722162246704 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03372218832373619, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03372218832373619, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.325478732585907, + 0.22062630951404572, + 0.03000790812075138, + 0.07050694525241852, + 0.0694393515586853, + 0.06637129187583923, + 0.04407932236790657, + 0.08588185161352158, + 0.03902450576424599, + 0.048583805561065674 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03372218832373619 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extremely close-up view of the base of a paper milk carton?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a slightly low angle and remains static throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a high-pressure, needle-thin stream of opaque white milk blast out from a tiny rupture in the carton?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by cool, clinical overhead kitchen light on a brushed stainless steel countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the milk puddle rapidly expand with a leading edge spreading outward in irregular, shiny shapes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004098350182175636 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504098415374756 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004098350182175636, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004098350182175636, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06925360858440399, + 0.043297674506902695, + 0.025903452187776566, + 0.09278157353401184, + 0.06957030296325684, + 0.04427653178572655, + 0.13916507363319397, + 0.26093053817749023, + 0.13684438169002533, + 0.11797688901424408 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004098350182175636 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_8/index_tensor([2696, 2696])_group_8_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_8/index_tensor([2696, 2696])_group_8_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..5c6e32443d7cae626d5c4119c7274e205497096b --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_8/index_tensor([2696, 2696])_group_8_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up macro shot, captured in breathtaking super-slow motion, captures the decisive moment from a slight overhead angle. As the final spoonful of scalding, viscous dark chocolate is poured gracefully and calmly from a polished silver dessert spoon, it flows like a thick, glossy black ribbon, slowly pouring into a nearly overflowing white porcelain bowl. The moment the chocolate syrup meets the bowl's contents, the impact unleashes a spectacular crown of splendor. Illuminated by the concentrated, warm studio overhead light, the countless tiny chocolate particles flying up seem frozen in time, the plump curves of each droplet perfectly catching and reflecting the dazzling light. They hover and swirl against the dark background, like golden cannons exploding in the air at the crowning of a champion, radiating the glory of victory. The entire picture is rich in color, and the strong contrast between black and white highlights the mellow texture of the chocolate, creating an epic atmosphere of focus, precision and ritual, sublimating a simple cooking action into a moment of victory full of tension and sense of accomplishment.", + "seed": 33015, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_8/index_2696_seed_33015_dp_16_rank_32_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.02499993620440364, + "vlm_logprob": -0.02499993620440364, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.875, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.02499993620440364, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro view of dark chocolate being poured from a silver spoon into a white porcelain bowl?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in super-slow motion showing the chocolate flowing like a thick glossy ribbon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle positioned slightly overhead capturing the moment the chocolate hits the bowl?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are tiny chocolate particles frozen in mid-air, hovering and swirling against a dark background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm studio overhead light creating strong contrast between the black chocolate and white bowl?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.050368793308734894 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0503687858581543 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.050368793308734894, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.050368793308734894, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12780949473381042, + 0.16514915227890015, + 0.06273774802684784, + 0.08160120993852615, + 0.058808840811252594, + 0.05569785088300705, + 0.2311038225889206, + 0.03973579779267311, + 0.1489274948835373, + 0.02842853032052517 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.050368793308734894 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro view of dark chocolate being poured from a silver spoon into a white porcelain bowl?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in super-slow motion showing the chocolate flowing like a thick glossy ribbon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle positioned slightly overhead capturing the moment the chocolate hits the bowl?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are tiny chocolate particles frozen in mid-air, hovering and swirling against a dark background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm studio overhead light creating strong contrast between the black chocolate and white bowl?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006747792940586805 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006747722625732 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006747792940586805, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006747792940586805, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2912254333496094, + 0.06002751737833023, + 0.07308321446180344, + 0.14474061131477356, + 0.09505868703126907, + 0.08691839873790741, + 0.046017419546842575, + 0.01764526218175888, + 0.08567529916763306, + 0.09960823506116867 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006747792940586805 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro view of dark chocolate being poured from a silver spoon into a white porcelain bowl?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in super-slow motion showing the chocolate flowing like a thick glossy ribbon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle positioned slightly overhead capturing the moment the chocolate hits the bowl?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are tiny chocolate particles frozen in mid-air, hovering and swirling against a dark background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm studio overhead light creating strong contrast between the black chocolate and white bowl?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026372667402029037 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513726711273193 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026372667402029037, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026372667402029037, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.388926237821579, + 0.14417411386966705, + 0.04030533507466316, + 0.04370633140206337, + 0.05443479120731354, + 0.035499487072229385, + 0.17198821902275085, + 0.03154047951102257, + 0.05573738366365433, + 0.03368757665157318 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026372667402029037 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro view of dark chocolate being poured from a silver spoon into a white porcelain bowl?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in super-slow motion showing the chocolate flowing like a thick glossy ribbon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle positioned slightly overhead capturing the moment the chocolate hits the bowl?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are tiny chocolate particles frozen in mid-air, hovering and swirling against a dark background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm studio overhead light creating strong contrast between the black chocolate and white bowl?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018208960071206093 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018208980560303 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018208960071206093, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018208960071206093, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13020029664039612, + 0.10730443149805069, + 0.10724461823701859, + 0.14654813706874847, + 0.05683347210288048, + 0.08275431394577026, + 0.05886236950755119, + 0.030990179628133774, + 0.14277464151382446, + 0.13648763298988342 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018208960071206093 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro view of dark chocolate being poured from a silver spoon into a white porcelain bowl?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in super-slow motion showing the chocolate flowing like a thick glossy ribbon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle positioned slightly overhead capturing the moment the chocolate hits the bowl?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are tiny chocolate particles frozen in mid-air, hovering and swirling against a dark background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm studio overhead light creating strong contrast between the black chocolate and white bowl?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023301467299461365 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773301362991333 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023301467299461365, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023301467299461365, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16602589190006256, + 0.1307053416967392, + 0.03524729609489441, + 0.12196704745292664, + 0.1835741251707077, + 0.06017005816102028, + 0.06715206056833267, + 0.06205842271447182, + 0.06077245622873306, + 0.11232736706733704 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023301467299461365 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up macro shot, captured in breathtaking super-slow motion, captures the decisive moment from a slight overhead angle. As the final spoonful of scalding, viscous dark chocolate is poured gracefully and calmly from a polished silver dessert spoon, it flows like a thick, glossy black ribbon, slowly pouring into a nearly overflowing white porcelain bowl. The moment the chocolate syrup meets the bowl's contents, the impact unleashes a spectacular crown of splendor. Illuminated by the concentrated, warm studio overhead light, the countless tiny chocolate particles flying up seem frozen in time, the plump curves of each droplet perfectly catching and reflecting the dazzling light. They hover and swirl against the dark background, like golden cannons exploding in the air at the crowning of a champion, radiating the glory of victory. The entire picture is rich in color, and the strong contrast between black and white highlights the mellow texture of the chocolate, creating an epic atmosphere of focus, precision and ritual, sublimating a simple cooking action into a moment of victory full of tension and sense of accomplishment.", + "seed": 33016, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_8/index_2696_seed_33016_dp_16_rank_32_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.015731917601078747, + "vlm_logprob": -0.015731917601078747, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.45, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.015731917601078747, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro view of dark chocolate being poured from a silver spoon into a white porcelain bowl?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in super-slow motion showing the chocolate flowing like a thick glossy ribbon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle positioned slightly overhead capturing the moment the chocolate hits the bowl?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are tiny chocolate particles frozen in mid-air, hovering and swirling against a dark background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm studio overhead light creating strong contrast between the black chocolate and white bowl?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03564396873116493 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.410644054412842 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03564396873116493, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03564396873116493, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13629873096942902, + 0.05369769036769867, + 0.0510045625269413, + 0.0842980444431305, + 0.04553182050585747, + 0.06504663079977036, + 0.23119792342185974, + 0.20809850096702576, + 0.07658852636814117, + 0.048237547278404236 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03564396873116493 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro view of dark chocolate being poured from a silver spoon into a white porcelain bowl?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in super-slow motion showing the chocolate flowing like a thick glossy ribbon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle positioned slightly overhead capturing the moment the chocolate hits the bowl?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are tiny chocolate particles frozen in mid-air, hovering and swirling against a dark background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm studio overhead light creating strong contrast between the black chocolate and white bowl?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0032062334939837456 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753206253051758 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0032062334939837456, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0032062334939837456, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0852871760725975, + 0.05409619212150574, + 0.05038025230169296, + 0.09068482369184494, + 0.04705151543021202, + 0.13478311896324158, + 0.14127442240715027, + 0.11140154302120209, + 0.13940326869487762, + 0.14563773572444916 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0032062334939837456 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro view of dark chocolate being poured from a silver spoon into a white porcelain bowl?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in super-slow motion showing the chocolate flowing like a thick glossy ribbon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle positioned slightly overhead capturing the moment the chocolate hits the bowl?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are tiny chocolate particles frozen in mid-air, hovering and swirling against a dark background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm studio overhead light creating strong contrast between the black chocolate and white bowl?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016092650592327118 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141092777252197 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016092650592327118, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016092650592327118, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1477808654308319, + 0.050853267312049866, + 0.04176906868815422, + 0.1231129914522171, + 0.08509029448032379, + 0.0457846038043499, + 0.05927475914359093, + 0.22539980709552765, + 0.17590287327766418, + 0.04503140226006508 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016092650592327118 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro view of dark chocolate being poured from a silver spoon into a white porcelain bowl?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in super-slow motion showing the chocolate flowing like a thick glossy ribbon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle positioned slightly overhead capturing the moment the chocolate hits the bowl?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are tiny chocolate particles frozen in mid-air, hovering and swirling against a dark background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm studio overhead light creating strong contrast between the black chocolate and white bowl?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007636402267962694 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882636547088623 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007636402267962694, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007636402267962694, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06931808590888977, + 0.06633400171995163, + 0.10383669286966324, + 0.14388538897037506, + 0.06354158371686935, + 0.2581822872161865, + 0.06443202495574951, + 0.033221401274204254, + 0.07201320677995682, + 0.1252354234457016 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007636402267962694 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro view of dark chocolate being poured from a silver spoon into a white porcelain bowl?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in super-slow motion showing the chocolate flowing like a thick glossy ribbon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle positioned slightly overhead capturing the moment the chocolate hits the bowl?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are tiny chocolate particles frozen in mid-air, hovering and swirling against a dark background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm studio overhead light creating strong contrast between the black chocolate and white bowl?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016080332919955254 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141080379486084 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016080332919955254, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016080332919955254, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20356106758117676, + 0.053963810205459595, + 0.06591666489839554, + 0.06504785269498825, + 0.025667395442724228, + 0.06662976741790771, + 0.04561750590801239, + 0.35679465532302856, + 0.035466235131025314, + 0.08133498579263687 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016080332919955254 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up macro shot, captured in breathtaking super-slow motion, captures the decisive moment from a slight overhead angle. As the final spoonful of scalding, viscous dark chocolate is poured gracefully and calmly from a polished silver dessert spoon, it flows like a thick, glossy black ribbon, slowly pouring into a nearly overflowing white porcelain bowl. The moment the chocolate syrup meets the bowl's contents, the impact unleashes a spectacular crown of splendor. Illuminated by the concentrated, warm studio overhead light, the countless tiny chocolate particles flying up seem frozen in time, the plump curves of each droplet perfectly catching and reflecting the dazzling light. They hover and swirl against the dark background, like golden cannons exploding in the air at the crowning of a champion, radiating the glory of victory. The entire picture is rich in color, and the strong contrast between black and white highlights the mellow texture of the chocolate, creating an epic atmosphere of focus, precision and ritual, sublimating a simple cooking action into a moment of victory full of tension and sense of accomplishment.", + "seed": 33017, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_8/index_2696_seed_33017_dp_17_rank_34_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.014100383780896664, + "vlm_logprob": -0.014100383780896664, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.375, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.014100383780896664, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro view of dark chocolate being poured from a silver spoon into a white porcelain bowl?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in super-slow motion showing the chocolate flowing like a thick glossy ribbon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle positioned slightly overhead capturing the moment the chocolate hits the bowl?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are tiny chocolate particles frozen in mid-air, hovering and swirling against a dark background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm studio overhead light creating strong contrast between the black chocolate and white bowl?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0187691617757082 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018769264221191 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0187691617757082, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0187691617757082, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3064177930355072, + 0.13273531198501587, + 0.07268118113279343, + 0.03352077677845955, + 0.09478562325239182, + 0.11116194725036621, + 0.04953774809837341, + 0.03771710768342018, + 0.10402773320674896, + 0.057414814829826355 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0187691617757082 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro view of dark chocolate being poured from a silver spoon into a white porcelain bowl?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in super-slow motion showing the chocolate flowing like a thick glossy ribbon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle positioned slightly overhead capturing the moment the chocolate hits the bowl?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are tiny chocolate particles frozen in mid-air, hovering and swirling against a dark background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm studio overhead light creating strong contrast between the black chocolate and white bowl?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005261621437966824 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255261421203613 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005261621437966824, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005261621437966824, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1463485211133957, + 0.07199573516845703, + 0.10651374608278275, + 0.10724226385354996, + 0.08895501494407654, + 0.21716226637363434, + 0.13468573987483978, + 0.026604579761624336, + 0.06957720220088959, + 0.030914947390556335 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005261621437966824 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro view of dark chocolate being poured from a silver spoon into a white porcelain bowl?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in super-slow motion showing the chocolate flowing like a thick glossy ribbon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle positioned slightly overhead capturing the moment the chocolate hits the bowl?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are tiny chocolate particles frozen in mid-air, hovering and swirling against a dark background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm studio overhead light creating strong contrast between the black chocolate and white bowl?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020602043718099594 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895601987838745 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020602043718099594, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020602043718099594, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15156102180480957, + 0.14092065393924713, + 0.13504886627197266, + 0.08503041416406631, + 0.0949510857462883, + 0.09694913029670715, + 0.07994629442691803, + 0.02275010198354721, + 0.14330939948558807, + 0.04953307285904884 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020602043718099594 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro view of dark chocolate being poured from a silver spoon into a white porcelain bowl?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in super-slow motion showing the chocolate flowing like a thick glossy ribbon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle positioned slightly overhead capturing the moment the chocolate hits the bowl?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are tiny chocolate particles frozen in mid-air, hovering and swirling against a dark background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm studio overhead light creating strong contrast between the black chocolate and white bowl?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009793920442461967 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634793758392334 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009793920442461967, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009793920442461967, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12554363906383514, + 0.06941626220941544, + 0.19578798115253448, + 0.0576469711959362, + 0.10363618284463882, + 0.3358674943447113, + 0.02651115134358406, + 0.012524972669780254, + 0.03357088565826416, + 0.03949443995952606 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009793920442461967 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro view of dark chocolate being poured from a silver spoon into a white porcelain bowl?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in super-slow motion showing the chocolate flowing like a thick glossy ribbon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle positioned slightly overhead capturing the moment the chocolate hits the bowl?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are tiny chocolate particles frozen in mid-air, hovering and swirling against a dark background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm studio overhead light creating strong contrast between the black chocolate and white bowl?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016075171530246735 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141075134277344 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016075171530246735, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016075171530246735, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0744500607252121, + 0.344503253698349, + 0.07874610275030136, + 0.09960737079381943, + 0.04694729298353195, + 0.09349484741687775, + 0.06867159903049469, + 0.05233915522694588, + 0.058278657495975494, + 0.08296159654855728 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016075171530246735 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up macro shot, captured in breathtaking super-slow motion, captures the decisive moment from a slight overhead angle. As the final spoonful of scalding, viscous dark chocolate is poured gracefully and calmly from a polished silver dessert spoon, it flows like a thick, glossy black ribbon, slowly pouring into a nearly overflowing white porcelain bowl. The moment the chocolate syrup meets the bowl's contents, the impact unleashes a spectacular crown of splendor. Illuminated by the concentrated, warm studio overhead light, the countless tiny chocolate particles flying up seem frozen in time, the plump curves of each droplet perfectly catching and reflecting the dazzling light. They hover and swirl against the dark background, like golden cannons exploding in the air at the crowning of a champion, radiating the glory of victory. The entire picture is rich in color, and the strong contrast between black and white highlights the mellow texture of the chocolate, creating an epic atmosphere of focus, precision and ritual, sublimating a simple cooking action into a moment of victory full of tension and sense of accomplishment.", + "seed": 33018, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_8/index_2696_seed_33018_dp_17_rank_34_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.01897827088832855, + "vlm_logprob": -0.01897827088832855, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.2, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.01897827088832855, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro view of dark chocolate being poured from a silver spoon into a white porcelain bowl?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in super-slow motion showing the chocolate flowing like a thick glossy ribbon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle positioned slightly overhead capturing the moment the chocolate hits the bowl?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are tiny chocolate particles frozen in mid-air, hovering and swirling against a dark background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm studio overhead light creating strong contrast between the black chocolate and white bowl?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01554256770759821 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.265542507171631 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01554256770759821, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01554256770759821, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1967540681362152, + 0.07743564993143082, + 0.26722806692123413, + 0.20489907264709473, + 0.12120737880468369, + 0.031325940042734146, + 0.015893088653683662, + 0.02047562040388584, + 0.028828583657741547, + 0.03595253825187683 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01554256770759821 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro view of dark chocolate being poured from a silver spoon into a white porcelain bowl?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in super-slow motion showing the chocolate flowing like a thick glossy ribbon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle positioned slightly overhead capturing the moment the chocolate hits the bowl?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are tiny chocolate particles frozen in mid-air, hovering and swirling against a dark background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm studio overhead light creating strong contrast between the black chocolate and white bowl?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003624419681727886 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628624439239502 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003624419681727886, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003624419681727886, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23271484673023224, + 0.12082640081644058, + 0.16020715236663818, + 0.09470474720001221, + 0.21230629086494446, + 0.04101487249135971, + 0.024040136486291885, + 0.026752112433314323, + 0.03925016149878502, + 0.04818329960107803 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003624419681727886 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro view of dark chocolate being poured from a silver spoon into a white porcelain bowl?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in super-slow motion showing the chocolate flowing like a thick glossy ribbon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle positioned slightly overhead capturing the moment the chocolate hits the bowl?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are tiny chocolate particles frozen in mid-air, hovering and swirling against a dark background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm studio overhead light creating strong contrast between the black chocolate and white bowl?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02982400916516781 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298240184783936 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02982400916516781, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02982400916516781, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15208159387111664, + 0.0951293483376503, + 0.35892361402511597, + 0.07800295948982239, + 0.08848229795694351, + 0.0759730413556099, + 0.03783674165606499, + 0.021396152675151825, + 0.028307491913437843, + 0.0638667419552803 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02982400916516781 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro view of dark chocolate being poured from a silver spoon into a white porcelain bowl?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in super-slow motion showing the chocolate flowing like a thick glossy ribbon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle positioned slightly overhead capturing the moment the chocolate hits the bowl?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are tiny chocolate particles frozen in mid-air, hovering and swirling against a dark background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm studio overhead light creating strong contrast between the black chocolate and white bowl?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029823778197169304 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298237800598145 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029823778197169304, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029823778197169304, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05644621327519417, + 0.0956428274512291, + 0.34222161769866943, + 0.2628849148750305, + 0.052167799323797226, + 0.05796879529953003, + 0.021547771990299225, + 0.02522542141377926, + 0.0389801450073719, + 0.0469144731760025 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029823778197169304 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro view of dark chocolate being poured from a silver spoon into a white porcelain bowl?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in super-slow motion showing the chocolate flowing like a thick glossy ribbon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle positioned slightly overhead capturing the moment the chocolate hits the bowl?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are tiny chocolate particles frozen in mid-air, hovering and swirling against a dark background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm studio overhead light creating strong contrast between the black chocolate and white bowl?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016076579689979553 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141076564788818 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016076579689979553, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016076579689979553, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13671308755874634, + 0.08943493664264679, + 0.3647422194480896, + 0.12870042026042938, + 0.0959029272198677, + 0.046311069279909134, + 0.034387946128845215, + 0.026456106454133987, + 0.025297120213508606, + 0.052054163068532944 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016076579689979553 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_9/index_tensor([4963, 4963])_group_9_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_9/index_tensor([4963, 4963])_group_9_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..925f85722c9734bd36b51d84c2c4226c914a4702 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_9/index_tensor([4963, 4963])_group_9_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "static, extreme close-up shot from a slightly overhead angle, completely focused in dim candlelight, reveals a long, distinctly knuckled finger with neatly manicured nails, its tip steadily and deliberately tapping the forehead of an ancient human skull, coated in a thick layer of gray dust. The flickering candlelight off-screen provides the sole source of light, its warm, pulsing glow casting deep, dancing shadows on the skull's yellowed ivory surface, accentuating the hollows of the eye sockets and highlighting every tiny crack and mark of age. The finger falls rhythmically and unhurriedly, each stroke leaving a distinct indentation in the dust and stirring up a tiny, almost invisible cloud of dust that dances in the light, creating a dull, rhythmic \"knock, knock\" sound. The background fades completely into deep darkness, drawing all attention to this ritualistic, repetitive action. The entire scene is painted in warm amber and sepia tones, creating a deep, focused, and slightly eerie atmosphere.", + "seed": 33418, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_9/index_4963_seed_33418_dp_18_rank_36_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.29923432767391206, + "vlm_logprob": -0.29923432767391206, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.625, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.29923432767391206, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a long finger with neatly manicured nails tapping a human skull?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the skull ancient, yellowed ivory, and coated in a thick layer of gray dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit solely by off-screen flickering candlelight casting deep, dancing shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the finger tap rhythmically, leaving indentations in the dust and stirring up tiny clouds of dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background completely dark and the color palette dominated by warm amber and sepia tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8986235857009888 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5236235857009888 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.8986235857009888, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.8986235857009888, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.31222137808799744, + 0.07139386981725693, + 0.0710500106215477, + 0.036208175122737885, + 0.024060504510998726, + 0.05280288681387901, + 0.12850482761859894, + 0.17156457901000977, + 0.10481738299131393, + 0.02737634815275669 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.8986235857009888 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a long finger with neatly manicured nails tapping a human skull?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the skull ancient, yellowed ivory, and coated in a thick layer of gray dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit solely by off-screen flickering candlelight casting deep, dancing shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the finger tap rhythmically, leaving indentations in the dust and stirring up tiny clouds of dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background completely dark and the color palette dominated by warm amber and sepia tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3135180175304413 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3135180473327637 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3135180175304413, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3135180175304413, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1446937471628189, + 0.07154087722301483, + 0.13276296854019165, + 0.04058234021067619, + 0.029843151569366455, + 0.07287297397851944, + 0.16653050482273102, + 0.21950633823871613, + 0.07794427126646042, + 0.043722789734601974 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3135180175304413 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a long finger with neatly manicured nails tapping a human skull?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the skull ancient, yellowed ivory, and coated in a thick layer of gray dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit solely by off-screen flickering candlelight casting deep, dancing shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the finger tap rhythmically, leaving indentations in the dust and stirring up tiny clouds of dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background completely dark and the color palette dominated by warm amber and sepia tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12713193893432617 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.127131938934326 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12713193893432617, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12713193893432617, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16493679583072662, + 0.2130792737007141, + 0.03833145648241043, + 0.02038682997226715, + 0.034018274396657944, + 0.13703636825084686, + 0.09725115448236465, + 0.10212641209363937, + 0.1763945072889328, + 0.016438936814665794 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12713193893432617 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a long finger with neatly manicured nails tapping a human skull?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the skull ancient, yellowed ivory, and coated in a thick layer of gray dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit solely by off-screen flickering candlelight casting deep, dancing shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the finger tap rhythmically, leaving indentations in the dust and stirring up tiny clouds of dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background completely dark and the color palette dominated by warm amber and sepia tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1270764023065567 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1270763874053955 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1270764023065567, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1270764023065567, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.42756614089012146, + 0.02478606626391411, + 0.06920462846755981, + 0.03664616867899895, + 0.041822176426649094, + 0.060554008930921555, + 0.07276653498411179, + 0.11449328809976578, + 0.06408321857452393, + 0.08807778358459473 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1270764023065567 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a long finger with neatly manicured nails tapping a human skull?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the skull ancient, yellowed ivory, and coated in a thick layer of gray dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit solely by off-screen flickering candlelight casting deep, dancing shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the finger tap rhythmically, leaving indentations in the dust and stirring up tiny clouds of dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background completely dark and the color palette dominated by warm amber and sepia tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029821693897247314 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298216342926025 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029821693897247314, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029821693897247314, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.32356542348861694, + 0.1732938438653946, + 0.06463572382926941, + 0.05031733587384224, + 0.01626179926097393, + 0.10438965260982513, + 0.13025815784931183, + 0.048810917884111404, + 0.05084827542304993, + 0.037618882954120636 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029821693897247314 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, extreme close-up shot from a slightly overhead angle, completely focused in dim candlelight, reveals a long, distinctly knuckled finger with neatly manicured nails, its tip steadily and deliberately tapping the forehead of an ancient human skull, coated in a thick layer of gray dust. The flickering candlelight off-screen provides the sole source of light, its warm, pulsing glow casting deep, dancing shadows on the skull's yellowed ivory surface, accentuating the hollows of the eye sockets and highlighting every tiny crack and mark of age. The finger falls rhythmically and unhurriedly, each stroke leaving a distinct indentation in the dust and stirring up a tiny, almost invisible cloud of dust that dances in the light, creating a dull, rhythmic \"knock, knock\" sound. The background fades completely into deep darkness, drawing all attention to this ritualistic, repetitive action. The entire scene is painted in warm amber and sepia tones, creating a deep, focused, and slightly eerie atmosphere.", + "seed": 33419, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_9/index_4963_seed_33419_dp_18_rank_36_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.08963192962110042, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08963192962110042, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.725, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08963192962110042, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a long finger with neatly manicured nails tapping a human skull?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the skull ancient, yellowed ivory, and coated in a thick layer of gray dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit solely by off-screen flickering candlelight casting deep, dancing shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the finger tap rhythmically, leaving indentations in the dust and stirring up tiny clouds of dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background completely dark and the color palette dominated by warm amber and sepia tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.09068536758422852 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4656853675842285 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.09068536758422852, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.09068536758422852, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4848855435848236, + 0.06881679594516754, + 0.034390851855278015, + 0.025100499391555786, + 0.09562872350215912, + 0.025045624002814293, + 0.030731411650776863, + 0.17586085200309753, + 0.041919026523828506, + 0.017620665952563286 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.09068536758422852 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a long finger with neatly manicured nails tapping a human skull?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the skull ancient, yellowed ivory, and coated in a thick layer of gray dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit solely by off-screen flickering candlelight casting deep, dancing shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the finger tap rhythmically, leaving indentations in the dust and stirring up tiny clouds of dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background completely dark and the color palette dominated by warm amber and sepia tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14288829267024994 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.017888307571411 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14288829267024994, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14288829267024994, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23726880550384521, + 0.20535457134246826, + 0.04108552634716034, + 0.08661103993654251, + 0.08556558191776276, + 0.02269897051155567, + 0.026149259880185127, + 0.11550534516572952, + 0.12849409878253937, + 0.05126669630408287 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14288829267024994 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a long finger with neatly manicured nails tapping a human skull?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the skull ancient, yellowed ivory, and coated in a thick layer of gray dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit solely by off-screen flickering candlelight casting deep, dancing shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the finger tap rhythmically, leaving indentations in the dust and stirring up tiny clouds of dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background completely dark and the color palette dominated by warm amber and sepia tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1604325771331787 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9104325771331787 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1604325771331787, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1604325771331787, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2636460065841675, + 0.23836824297904968, + 0.07958158850669861, + 0.045593295246362686, + 0.09530139714479446, + 0.031401246786117554, + 0.041430797427892685, + 0.14361581206321716, + 0.03778883069753647, + 0.023272819817066193 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1604325771331787 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a long finger with neatly manicured nails tapping a human skull?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the skull ancient, yellowed ivory, and coated in a thick layer of gray dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit solely by off-screen flickering candlelight casting deep, dancing shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the finger tap rhythmically, leaving indentations in the dust and stirring up tiny clouds of dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background completely dark and the color palette dominated by warm amber and sepia tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0430724211037159 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168072462081909 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0430724211037159, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0430724211037159, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.39702674746513367, + 0.1325482726097107, + 0.04459952935576439, + 0.029638757929205894, + 0.05396268144249916, + 0.02362748049199581, + 0.06310256570577621, + 0.15582086145877838, + 0.08241917192935944, + 0.017253899946808815 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0430724211037159 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a long finger with neatly manicured nails tapping a human skull?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the skull ancient, yellowed ivory, and coated in a thick layer of gray dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit solely by off-screen flickering candlelight casting deep, dancing shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the finger tap rhythmically, leaving indentations in the dust and stirring up tiny clouds of dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background completely dark and the color palette dominated by warm amber and sepia tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011080989614129066 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511081218719482 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011080989614129066, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011080989614129066, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1634603887796402, + 0.274153470993042, + 0.10917943716049194, + 0.031195899471640587, + 0.07124356180429459, + 0.10257434099912643, + 0.04054967314004898, + 0.11031762510538101, + 0.053146570920944214, + 0.0441790334880352 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011080989614129066 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, extreme close-up shot from a slightly overhead angle, completely focused in dim candlelight, reveals a long, distinctly knuckled finger with neatly manicured nails, its tip steadily and deliberately tapping the forehead of an ancient human skull, coated in a thick layer of gray dust. The flickering candlelight off-screen provides the sole source of light, its warm, pulsing glow casting deep, dancing shadows on the skull's yellowed ivory surface, accentuating the hollows of the eye sockets and highlighting every tiny crack and mark of age. The finger falls rhythmically and unhurriedly, each stroke leaving a distinct indentation in the dust and stirring up a tiny, almost invisible cloud of dust that dances in the light, creating a dull, rhythmic \"knock, knock\" sound. The background fades completely into deep darkness, drawing all attention to this ritualistic, repetitive action. The entire scene is painted in warm amber and sepia tones, creating a deep, focused, and slightly eerie atmosphere.", + "seed": 33420, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_9/index_4963_seed_33420_dp_19_rank_38_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.22892790399491786, + "vlm_logprob": -0.22892790399491786, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.9749999523162842, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.22892790399491786, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a long finger with neatly manicured nails tapping a human skull?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the skull ancient, yellowed ivory, and coated in a thick layer of gray dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit solely by off-screen flickering candlelight casting deep, dancing shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the finger tap rhythmically, leaving indentations in the dust and stirring up tiny clouds of dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background completely dark and the color palette dominated by warm amber and sepia tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6942737698554993 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6942737698554993 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.6942737698554993, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.6942737698554993, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25977009534835815, + 0.1531105786561966, + 0.04065113514661789, + 0.08045408129692078, + 0.07970473915338516, + 0.08014223724603653, + 0.07732820510864258, + 0.10078709572553635, + 0.06682247668504715, + 0.06122935935854912 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.6942737698554993 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a long finger with neatly manicured nails tapping a human skull?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the skull ancient, yellowed ivory, and coated in a thick layer of gray dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit solely by off-screen flickering candlelight casting deep, dancing shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the finger tap rhythmically, leaving indentations in the dust and stirring up tiny clouds of dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background completely dark and the color palette dominated by warm amber and sepia tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2016611546278 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7016611099243164 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2016611546278, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2016611546278, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2591468393802643, + 0.11767955869436264, + 0.06334859132766724, + 0.09465960413217545, + 0.06925303488969803, + 0.042807526886463165, + 0.05074155703186989, + 0.1149851605296135, + 0.08947054296731949, + 0.09790755063295364 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2016611546278 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a long finger with neatly manicured nails tapping a human skull?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the skull ancient, yellowed ivory, and coated in a thick layer of gray dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit solely by off-screen flickering candlelight casting deep, dancing shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the finger tap rhythmically, leaving indentations in the dust and stirring up tiny clouds of dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background completely dark and the color palette dominated by warm amber and sepia tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1604519784450531 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9104520082473755 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1604519784450531, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1604519784450531, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11752749234437943, + 0.021717818453907967, + 0.025159364566206932, + 0.03791695460677147, + 0.0640459731221199, + 0.0850144624710083, + 0.13065950572490692, + 0.1342797577381134, + 0.3419125974178314, + 0.041766148060560226 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1604519784450531 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a long finger with neatly manicured nails tapping a human skull?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the skull ancient, yellowed ivory, and coated in a thick layer of gray dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit solely by off-screen flickering candlelight casting deep, dancing shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the finger tap rhythmically, leaving indentations in the dust and stirring up tiny clouds of dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background completely dark and the color palette dominated by warm amber and sepia tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07004915922880173 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950490474700928 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07004915922880173, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07004915922880173, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11492043733596802, + 0.0565030612051487, + 0.027674375101923943, + 0.03990655019879341, + 0.06264623254537582, + 0.025645840913057327, + 0.0788203775882721, + 0.07836778461933136, + 0.46214351058006287, + 0.0533718466758728 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07004915922880173 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a long finger with neatly manicured nails tapping a human skull?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the skull ancient, yellowed ivory, and coated in a thick layer of gray dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit solely by off-screen flickering candlelight casting deep, dancing shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the finger tap rhythmically, leaving indentations in the dust and stirring up tiny clouds of dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background completely dark and the color palette dominated by warm amber and sepia tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018203457817435265 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018203258514404 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018203457817435265, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018203457817435265, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2363835722208023, + 0.06861347705125809, + 0.0530916303396225, + 0.03739631921052933, + 0.07629010081291199, + 0.050789762288331985, + 0.11972904205322266, + 0.056709174066782, + 0.23313768208026886, + 0.0678592249751091 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018203457817435265 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, extreme close-up shot from a slightly overhead angle, completely focused in dim candlelight, reveals a long, distinctly knuckled finger with neatly manicured nails, its tip steadily and deliberately tapping the forehead of an ancient human skull, coated in a thick layer of gray dust. The flickering candlelight off-screen provides the sole source of light, its warm, pulsing glow casting deep, dancing shadows on the skull's yellowed ivory surface, accentuating the hollows of the eye sockets and highlighting every tiny crack and mark of age. The finger falls rhythmically and unhurriedly, each stroke leaving a distinct indentation in the dust and stirring up a tiny, almost invisible cloud of dust that dances in the light, creating a dull, rhythmic \"knock, knock\" sound. The background fades completely into deep darkness, drawing all attention to this ritualistic, repetitive action. The entire scene is painted in warm amber and sepia tones, creating a deep, focused, and slightly eerie atmosphere.", + "seed": 33421, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000134/group_9/index_4963_seed_33421_dp_19_rank_38_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.0856107821688056, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0856107821688056, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.875, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0856107821688056, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a long finger with neatly manicured nails tapping a human skull?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the skull ancient, yellowed ivory, and coated in a thick layer of gray dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit solely by off-screen flickering candlelight casting deep, dancing shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the finger tap rhythmically, leaving indentations in the dust and stirring up tiny clouds of dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background completely dark and the color palette dominated by warm amber and sepia tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12826494872570038 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.128264904022217 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12826494872570038, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12826494872570038, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17084789276123047, + 0.08388948440551758, + 0.30549564957618713, + 0.08355585485696793, + 0.07859288156032562, + 0.07116986066102982, + 0.03343714028596878, + 0.03246017545461655, + 0.06729701906442642, + 0.07325401157140732 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12826494872570038 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a long finger with neatly manicured nails tapping a human skull?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the skull ancient, yellowed ivory, and coated in a thick layer of gray dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit solely by off-screen flickering candlelight casting deep, dancing shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the finger tap rhythmically, leaving indentations in the dust and stirring up tiny clouds of dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background completely dark and the color palette dominated by warm amber and sepia tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17994293570518494 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8049429655075073 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17994293570518494, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17994293570518494, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25362542271614075, + 0.19062493741512299, + 0.17946788668632507, + 0.046872228384017944, + 0.08502920717000961, + 0.04378077760338783, + 0.027019821107387543, + 0.08379711210727692, + 0.05306999385356903, + 0.03671261668205261 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17994293570518494 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a long finger with neatly manicured nails tapping a human skull?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the skull ancient, yellowed ivory, and coated in a thick layer of gray dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit solely by off-screen flickering candlelight casting deep, dancing shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the finger tap rhythmically, leaving indentations in the dust and stirring up tiny clouds of dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background completely dark and the color palette dominated by warm amber and sepia tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0891014039516449 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4641013145446777 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0891014039516449, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0891014039516449, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1644936203956604, + 0.19864033162593842, + 0.12145662307739258, + 0.12885329127311707, + 0.05844593420624733, + 0.018617013469338417, + 0.026215333491563797, + 0.0609750933945179, + 0.1085771694779396, + 0.11372559517621994 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0891014039516449 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a long finger with neatly manicured nails tapping a human skull?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the skull ancient, yellowed ivory, and coated in a thick layer of gray dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit solely by off-screen flickering candlelight casting deep, dancing shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the finger tap rhythmically, leaving indentations in the dust and stirring up tiny clouds of dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background completely dark and the color palette dominated by warm amber and sepia tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018195966258645058 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018196105957031 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018195966258645058, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018195966258645058, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14761683344841003, + 0.2599298357963562, + 0.08700849115848541, + 0.10273914039134979, + 0.09815157949924469, + 0.051812466233968735, + 0.04297066107392311, + 0.05138339474797249, + 0.06529323011636734, + 0.09309432655572891 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018195966258645058 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a long finger with neatly manicured nails tapping a human skull?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the skull ancient, yellowed ivory, and coated in a thick layer of gray dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit solely by off-screen flickering candlelight casting deep, dancing shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the finger tap rhythmically, leaving indentations in the dust and stirring up tiny clouds of dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background completely dark and the color palette dominated by warm amber and sepia tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012548656202852726 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387548446655273 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012548656202852726, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012548656202852726, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4359654188156128, + 0.09154479205608368, + 0.1804484724998474, + 0.05664190649986267, + 0.03720393776893616, + 0.014290510676801205, + 0.026405569165945053, + 0.01885972172021866, + 0.08191538602113724, + 0.05672430992126465 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012548656202852726 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_0/index_tensor([5308, 5308])_group_0_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_0/index_tensor([5308, 5308])_group_0_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..7d1d9ba7c17cc64a4fbf943ba02f4f4b09d9abc7 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_0/index_tensor([5308, 5308])_group_0_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "dramatic low-angle close-up, filmed in the style of a high-speed sports documentary, with a slow, almost imperceptible zoom, gradually approaches an athlete, fresh from a strenuous workout, lying on his side on the ground, struggling to catch his breath. The scene is framed by a vibrant interplay of light and shadow, the sole source of illumination coming from a harsh, cold overhead spotlight, casting deep, sharply defined shadows on the dark, matte rubber floor. His dark gray, high-tech sports T-shirt, drenched in sweat, clings to his defined muscles like a second skin, outlining the powerful contours of his back and shoulders. As his chest rises and falls with deep, rapid breaths, the camera captures a startling detail: beneath the sweat-soaked, shimmering skin of his shoulders and upper arms, a complex network of countless golden, root-like veins pulses. These veins appear alive, pulsing with a soft, inner shimmer in rhythm with his gradually calming heartbeat, like liquid gold flowing through his biological circuits. Beads of sweat refracted this otherworldly light off his skin, contrasting the cold white light from above with the warm golden glow emanating from within him. The entire image was filled with awe-inspiring raw energy and a breathtaking sense of transcendent tranquility.", + "seed": 8721, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_0/index_5308_seed_8721_dp_0_rank_0_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.13752696923911573, + "vlm_logprob": -0.13752696923911573, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.475, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.13752696923911573, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle close-up of an athlete lying on his side on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete wearing a dark gray, high-tech sports T-shirt that is drenched in sweat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a single harsh, cold overhead spotlight casting deep shadows on a dark matte rubber floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are golden, root-like veins visible beneath the athlete's sweat-soaked skin on his shoulders and upper arms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, almost imperceptible zoom approaching the athlete?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12968958914279938 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1296896934509277 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12968958914279938, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12968958914279938, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10382694005966187, + 0.24550007283687592, + 0.06748876720666885, + 0.2653316855430603, + 0.04316956549882889, + 0.06695420295000076, + 0.03576238825917244, + 0.026446938514709473, + 0.03291017562150955, + 0.11260920763015747 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12968958914279938 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle close-up of an athlete lying on his side on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete wearing a dark gray, high-tech sports T-shirt that is drenched in sweat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a single harsh, cold overhead spotlight casting deep shadows on a dark matte rubber floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are golden, root-like veins visible beneath the athlete's sweat-soaked skin on his shoulders and upper arms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, almost imperceptible zoom approaching the athlete?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06209847703576088 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812098503112793 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06209847703576088, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06209847703576088, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13000226020812988, + 0.12111645191907883, + 0.14828719198703766, + 0.21557046473026276, + 0.0403558611869812, + 0.12562516331672668, + 0.04540659487247467, + 0.030623286962509155, + 0.042673509567976, + 0.10033920407295227 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06209847703576088 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle close-up of an athlete lying on his side on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete wearing a dark gray, high-tech sports T-shirt that is drenched in sweat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a single harsh, cold overhead spotlight casting deep shadows on a dark matte rubber floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are golden, root-like veins visible beneath the athlete's sweat-soaked skin on his shoulders and upper arms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, almost imperceptible zoom approaching the athlete?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.42898061871528625 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.0539805889129639 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.42898061871528625, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.42898061871528625, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05629657208919525, + 0.3361971378326416, + 0.07817592471837997, + 0.12440208345651627, + 0.0642504170536995, + 0.151788592338562, + 0.027445916086435318, + 0.045092713087797165, + 0.06135793775320053, + 0.054992612451314926 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.42898061871528625 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle close-up of an athlete lying on his side on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete wearing a dark gray, high-tech sports T-shirt that is drenched in sweat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a single harsh, cold overhead spotlight casting deep shadows on a dark matte rubber floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are golden, root-like veins visible beneath the athlete's sweat-soaked skin on his shoulders and upper arms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, almost imperceptible zoom approaching the athlete?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018195031210780144 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018195152282715 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018195031210780144, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018195031210780144, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12992477416992188, + 0.05939548462629318, + 0.051674842834472656, + 0.0604945607483387, + 0.06951756775379181, + 0.20920808613300323, + 0.0439128577709198, + 0.0506628081202507, + 0.1333356648683548, + 0.19187337160110474 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018195031210780144 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle close-up of an athlete lying on his side on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete wearing a dark gray, high-tech sports T-shirt that is drenched in sweat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a single harsh, cold overhead spotlight casting deep shadows on a dark matte rubber floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are golden, root-like veins visible beneath the athlete's sweat-soaked skin on his shoulders and upper arms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, almost imperceptible zoom approaching the athlete?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04867113009095192 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048671245574951 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04867113009095192, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04867113009095192, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.046298347413539886, + 0.0354192815721035, + 0.03278116136789322, + 0.034687258303165436, + 0.024420350790023804, + 0.15913058817386627, + 0.09012597054243088, + 0.03582744672894478, + 0.2541747987270355, + 0.2871348559856415 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04867113009095192 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dramatic low-angle close-up, filmed in the style of a high-speed sports documentary, with a slow, almost imperceptible zoom, gradually approaches an athlete, fresh from a strenuous workout, lying on his side on the ground, struggling to catch his breath. The scene is framed by a vibrant interplay of light and shadow, the sole source of illumination coming from a harsh, cold overhead spotlight, casting deep, sharply defined shadows on the dark, matte rubber floor. His dark gray, high-tech sports T-shirt, drenched in sweat, clings to his defined muscles like a second skin, outlining the powerful contours of his back and shoulders. As his chest rises and falls with deep, rapid breaths, the camera captures a startling detail: beneath the sweat-soaked, shimmering skin of his shoulders and upper arms, a complex network of countless golden, root-like veins pulses. These veins appear alive, pulsing with a soft, inner shimmer in rhythm with his gradually calming heartbeat, like liquid gold flowing through his biological circuits. Beads of sweat refracted this otherworldly light off his skin, contrasting the cold white light from above with the warm golden glow emanating from within him. The entire image was filled with awe-inspiring raw energy and a breathtaking sense of transcendent tranquility.", + "seed": 8722, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_0/index_5308_seed_8722_dp_0_rank_0_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.3065244730561972, + "vlm_logprob": -0.3065244730561972, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.85, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.3065244730561972, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle close-up of an athlete lying on his side on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete wearing a dark gray, high-tech sports T-shirt that is drenched in sweat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a single harsh, cold overhead spotlight casting deep shadows on a dark matte rubber floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are golden, root-like veins visible beneath the athlete's sweat-soaked skin on his shoulders and upper arms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, almost imperceptible zoom approaching the athlete?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6349838972091675 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7599838972091675 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.6349838972091675, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.6349838972091675, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15868154168128967, + 0.0899634063243866, + 0.41058599948883057, + 0.09030956774950027, + 0.03739551454782486, + 0.042116954922676086, + 0.052590180188417435, + 0.037024516612291336, + 0.04587332159280777, + 0.03545897826552391 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.6349838972091675 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle close-up of an athlete lying on his side on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete wearing a dark gray, high-tech sports T-shirt that is drenched in sweat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a single harsh, cold overhead spotlight casting deep shadows on a dark matte rubber floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are golden, root-like veins visible beneath the athlete's sweat-soaked skin on his shoulders and upper arms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, almost imperceptible zoom approaching the athlete?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05499615892767906 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299962520599365 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05499615892767906, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05499615892767906, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2218979150056839, + 0.16314001381397247, + 0.11654956638813019, + 0.07187918573617935, + 0.03821951523423195, + 0.07857605069875717, + 0.050363898277282715, + 0.0788373351097107, + 0.08098182827234268, + 0.099554643034935 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05499615892767906 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle close-up of an athlete lying on his side on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete wearing a dark gray, high-tech sports T-shirt that is drenched in sweat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a single harsh, cold overhead spotlight casting deep shadows on a dark matte rubber floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are golden, root-like veins visible beneath the athlete's sweat-soaked skin on his shoulders and upper arms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, almost imperceptible zoom approaching the athlete?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7578679919242859 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6328679919242859 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.7578679919242859, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.7578679919242859, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20651783049106598, + 0.26925933361053467, + 0.14778360724449158, + 0.08788466453552246, + 0.03368085250258446, + 0.0660390555858612, + 0.038085293024778366, + 0.029342046007514, + 0.04397936910390854, + 0.07742791622877121 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.7578679919242859 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle close-up of an athlete lying on his side on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete wearing a dark gray, high-tech sports T-shirt that is drenched in sweat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a single harsh, cold overhead spotlight casting deep shadows on a dark matte rubber floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are golden, root-like veins visible beneath the athlete's sweat-soaked skin on his shoulders and upper arms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, almost imperceptible zoom approaching the athlete?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029808735474944115 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529808759689331 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029808735474944115, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029808735474944115, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20460271835327148, + 0.10213296860456467, + 0.08089815080165863, + 0.06339015811681747, + 0.040070801973342896, + 0.04736711084842682, + 0.0657912865281105, + 0.0854424461722374, + 0.2462502121925354, + 0.0640542060136795 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029808735474944115 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle close-up of an athlete lying on his side on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete wearing a dark gray, high-tech sports T-shirt that is drenched in sweat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a single harsh, cold overhead spotlight casting deep shadows on a dark matte rubber floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are golden, root-like veins visible beneath the athlete's sweat-soaked skin on his shoulders and upper arms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, almost imperceptible zoom approaching the athlete?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.054965581744909286 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299654960632324 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.054965581744909286, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.054965581744909286, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1443067491054535, + 0.05417017266154289, + 0.0886499285697937, + 0.08485595136880875, + 0.059733714908361435, + 0.07108887284994125, + 0.1406136006116867, + 0.21201930940151215, + 0.11032881587743759, + 0.03423287346959114 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.054965581744909286 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dramatic low-angle close-up, filmed in the style of a high-speed sports documentary, with a slow, almost imperceptible zoom, gradually approaches an athlete, fresh from a strenuous workout, lying on his side on the ground, struggling to catch his breath. The scene is framed by a vibrant interplay of light and shadow, the sole source of illumination coming from a harsh, cold overhead spotlight, casting deep, sharply defined shadows on the dark, matte rubber floor. His dark gray, high-tech sports T-shirt, drenched in sweat, clings to his defined muscles like a second skin, outlining the powerful contours of his back and shoulders. As his chest rises and falls with deep, rapid breaths, the camera captures a startling detail: beneath the sweat-soaked, shimmering skin of his shoulders and upper arms, a complex network of countless golden, root-like veins pulses. These veins appear alive, pulsing with a soft, inner shimmer in rhythm with his gradually calming heartbeat, like liquid gold flowing through his biological circuits. Beads of sweat refracted this otherworldly light off his skin, contrasting the cold white light from above with the warm golden glow emanating from within him. The entire image was filled with awe-inspiring raw energy and a breathtaking sense of transcendent tranquility.", + "seed": 8723, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_0/index_5308_seed_8723_dp_1_rank_2_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.08293392732739449, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08293392732739449, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.85, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08293392732739449, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle close-up of an athlete lying on his side on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete wearing a dark gray, high-tech sports T-shirt that is drenched in sweat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a single harsh, cold overhead spotlight casting deep shadows on a dark matte rubber floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are golden, root-like veins visible beneath the athlete's sweat-soaked skin on his shoulders and upper arms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, almost imperceptible zoom approaching the athlete?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0514058917760849 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.051405906677246 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0514058917760849, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0514058917760849, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11677716672420502, + 0.21609602868556976, + 0.09747311472892761, + 0.08130154013633728, + 0.04014992341399193, + 0.07628316432237625, + 0.2774994671344757, + 0.04920269921422005, + 0.028279241174459457, + 0.0169376153498888 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0514058917760849 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle close-up of an athlete lying on his side on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete wearing a dark gray, high-tech sports T-shirt that is drenched in sweat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a single harsh, cold overhead spotlight casting deep shadows on a dark matte rubber floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are golden, root-like veins visible beneath the athlete's sweat-soaked skin on his shoulders and upper arms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, almost imperceptible zoom approaching the athlete?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029832687228918076 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529832601547241 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029832687228918076, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029832687228918076, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18417870998382568, + 0.14849042892456055, + 0.13351105153560638, + 0.04537013918161392, + 0.030352037400007248, + 0.08787046372890472, + 0.2162557691335678, + 0.05857369676232338, + 0.05773426964879036, + 0.03766338527202606 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029832687228918076 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle close-up of an athlete lying on his side on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete wearing a dark gray, high-tech sports T-shirt that is drenched in sweat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a single harsh, cold overhead spotlight casting deep shadows on a dark matte rubber floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are golden, root-like veins visible beneath the athlete's sweat-soaked skin on his shoulders and upper arms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, almost imperceptible zoom approaching the athlete?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05499277263879776 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.92999267578125 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05499277263879776, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05499277263879776, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.046310875564813614, + 0.44452187418937683, + 0.021695101633667946, + 0.08419967442750931, + 0.053773634135723114, + 0.03877618908882141, + 0.19294539093971252, + 0.025656849145889282, + 0.04975816607475281, + 0.04236229509115219 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 6, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05499277263879776 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle close-up of an athlete lying on his side on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete wearing a dark gray, high-tech sports T-shirt that is drenched in sweat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a single harsh, cold overhead spotlight casting deep shadows on a dark matte rubber floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are golden, root-like veins visible beneath the athlete's sweat-soaked skin on his shoulders and upper arms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, almost imperceptible zoom approaching the athlete?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02634967863559723 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513497829437256 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02634967863559723, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02634967863559723, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06972195208072662, + 0.18723401427268982, + 0.13556522130966187, + 0.023191558197140694, + 0.0732077807188034, + 0.07318060100078583, + 0.13081976771354675, + 0.07559289783239365, + 0.20746144652366638, + 0.024024726822972298 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02634967863559723 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle close-up of an athlete lying on his side on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete wearing a dark gray, high-tech sports T-shirt that is drenched in sweat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a single harsh, cold overhead spotlight casting deep shadows on a dark matte rubber floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are golden, root-like veins visible beneath the athlete's sweat-soaked skin on his shoulders and upper arms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, almost imperceptible zoom approaching the athlete?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.25208860635757446 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5020885467529297 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.25208860635757446, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.25208860635757446, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08169872313737869, + 0.17361144721508026, + 0.11100643128156662, + 0.028701024129986763, + 0.08188560605049133, + 0.08598742634057999, + 0.11255523562431335, + 0.10599632561206818, + 0.1882634460926056, + 0.030294332653284073 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.25208860635757446 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dramatic low-angle close-up, filmed in the style of a high-speed sports documentary, with a slow, almost imperceptible zoom, gradually approaches an athlete, fresh from a strenuous workout, lying on his side on the ground, struggling to catch his breath. The scene is framed by a vibrant interplay of light and shadow, the sole source of illumination coming from a harsh, cold overhead spotlight, casting deep, sharply defined shadows on the dark, matte rubber floor. His dark gray, high-tech sports T-shirt, drenched in sweat, clings to his defined muscles like a second skin, outlining the powerful contours of his back and shoulders. As his chest rises and falls with deep, rapid breaths, the camera captures a startling detail: beneath the sweat-soaked, shimmering skin of his shoulders and upper arms, a complex network of countless golden, root-like veins pulses. These veins appear alive, pulsing with a soft, inner shimmer in rhythm with his gradually calming heartbeat, like liquid gold flowing through his biological circuits. Beads of sweat refracted this otherworldly light off his skin, contrasting the cold white light from above with the warm golden glow emanating from within him. The entire image was filled with awe-inspiring raw energy and a breathtaking sense of transcendent tranquility.", + "seed": 8724, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_0/index_5308_seed_8724_dp_1_rank_2_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.061679566651582717, + "vlm_logprob": -0.061679566651582717, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.125, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.061679566651582717, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle close-up of an athlete lying on his side on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete wearing a dark gray, high-tech sports T-shirt that is drenched in sweat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a single harsh, cold overhead spotlight casting deep shadows on a dark matte rubber floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are golden, root-like veins visible beneath the athlete's sweat-soaked skin on his shoulders and upper arms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, almost imperceptible zoom approaching the athlete?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02688862755894661 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.776888608932495 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02688862755894661, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02688862755894661, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10942684859037399, + 0.10878131538629532, + 0.05711866170167923, + 0.09316643327474594, + 0.08204811066389084, + 0.12388963997364044, + 0.03979717195034027, + 0.08588875085115433, + 0.0879439264535904, + 0.21193920075893402 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02688862755894661 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle close-up of an athlete lying on his side on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete wearing a dark gray, high-tech sports T-shirt that is drenched in sweat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a single harsh, cold overhead spotlight casting deep shadows on a dark matte rubber floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are golden, root-like veins visible beneath the athlete's sweat-soaked skin on his shoulders and upper arms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, almost imperceptible zoom approaching the athlete?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018212705850601196 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018212795257568 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018212705850601196, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018212705850601196, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.038764599710702896, + 0.12947896122932434, + 0.03532657027244568, + 0.21947193145751953, + 0.06079714745283127, + 0.06146859750151634, + 0.04236871004104614, + 0.2989862263202667, + 0.08328455686569214, + 0.03005273826420307 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018212705850601196 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle close-up of an athlete lying on his side on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete wearing a dark gray, high-tech sports T-shirt that is drenched in sweat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a single harsh, cold overhead spotlight casting deep shadows on a dark matte rubber floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are golden, root-like veins visible beneath the athlete's sweat-soaked skin on his shoulders and upper arms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, almost imperceptible zoom approaching the athlete?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12708395719528198 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1270840167999268 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12708395719528198, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12708395719528198, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09360577911138535, + 0.2921561598777771, + 0.092778779566288, + 0.11794731020927429, + 0.06589476764202118, + 0.1023281142115593, + 0.025265123695135117, + 0.042938850820064545, + 0.04898952692747116, + 0.11809554696083069 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12708395719528198 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle close-up of an athlete lying on his side on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete wearing a dark gray, high-tech sports T-shirt that is drenched in sweat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a single harsh, cold overhead spotlight casting deep shadows on a dark matte rubber floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are golden, root-like veins visible beneath the athlete's sweat-soaked skin on his shoulders and upper arms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, almost imperceptible zoom approaching the athlete?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023285627365112305 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732856273651123 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023285627365112305, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023285627365112305, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12080935388803482, + 0.3073553144931793, + 0.08431198447942734, + 0.06440483778715134, + 0.09469868242740631, + 0.041194502264261246, + 0.08323370665311813, + 0.09945496171712875, + 0.05087227746844292, + 0.05366441607475281 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023285627365112305 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle close-up of an athlete lying on his side on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete wearing a dark gray, high-tech sports T-shirt that is drenched in sweat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a single harsh, cold overhead spotlight casting deep shadows on a dark matte rubber floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are golden, root-like veins visible beneath the athlete's sweat-soaked skin on his shoulders and upper arms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, almost imperceptible zoom approaching the athlete?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1129269152879715 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.237926959991455 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1129269152879715, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1129269152879715, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05819867178797722, + 0.49387311935424805, + 0.08291888982057571, + 0.07768546044826508, + 0.03900879621505737, + 0.0930514857172966, + 0.05198705941438675, + 0.05452299118041992, + 0.020226959139108658, + 0.028526583686470985 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 5, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1129269152879715 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_1/index_tensor([3359, 3359])_group_1_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_1/index_tensor([3359, 3359])_group_1_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..a131af666943fbae986af85cdd032473cc939764 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_1/index_tensor([3359, 3359])_group_1_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "slow, tracking, medium close-up captures an antique celadon teapot, steadily and calmly descending into the inky blackness of the water. The teapot, with its rounded body and curved spout, is covered in delicate ice cracks, revealing a warm texture in the dim light. A stream of tiny, crystal-clear bubbles gracefully and continuously escapes from the spout, spiraling upwards and forming a striking contrast with the teapot's downward trajectory. The only source of light comes from the distant surface, a gradually fading beam of light piercing the darkness, casting soft highlights on the teapot and illuminating the fleeting bubbles. The surrounding water is a pure, profound darkness, with only tiny suspended particles glimpsed in the light's path. As the teapot sinks deeper, the light on the surface becomes increasingly distant, casting a tranquil, mysterious, and slightly melancholic poetic atmosphere.", + "seed": 4890, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_1/index_3359_seed_4890_dp_2_rank_4_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.015450889500789345, + "vlm_logprob": -0.015450889500789345, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.725, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.015450889500789345, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an antique celadon teapot with a rounded body and curved spout?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the teapot covered in delicate ice cracks revealing a warm texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the teapot steadily and calmly descending into dark water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are tiny crystal-clear bubbles escaping from the spout and spiraling upwards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit only by a distant, gradually fading beam of light from the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005966945551335812 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255967140197754 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005966945551335812, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005966945551335812, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16025471687316895, + 0.11991970986127853, + 0.036542460322380066, + 0.03473122790455818, + 0.1821165233850479, + 0.02482512779533863, + 0.054747097194194794, + 0.28320345282554626, + 0.07120616734027863, + 0.03245345130562782 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005966945551335812 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an antique celadon teapot with a rounded body and curved spout?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the teapot covered in delicate ice cracks revealing a warm texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the teapot steadily and calmly descending into dark water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are tiny crystal-clear bubbles escaping from the spout and spiraling upwards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit only by a distant, gradually fading beam of light from the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01608971692621708 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141089916229248 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01608971692621708, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01608971692621708, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05214646831154823, + 0.05542017146945, + 0.03949519991874695, + 0.02568366378545761, + 0.41621971130371094, + 0.03727642819285393, + 0.05678192526102066, + 0.1678164005279541, + 0.08793903142213821, + 0.06122099235653877 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01608971692621708 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an antique celadon teapot with a rounded body and curved spout?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the teapot covered in delicate ice cracks revealing a warm texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the teapot steadily and calmly descending into dark water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are tiny crystal-clear bubbles escaping from the spout and spiraling upwards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit only by a distant, gradually fading beam of light from the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01606203243136406 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141062259674072 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01606203243136406, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01606203243136406, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03372013196349144, + 0.08440575003623962, + 0.051048096269369125, + 0.02811938151717186, + 0.2387896478176117, + 0.1495150476694107, + 0.0763838142156601, + 0.20363059639930725, + 0.09472561627626419, + 0.039661943912506104 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 7, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01606203243136406 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an antique celadon teapot with a rounded body and curved spout?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the teapot covered in delicate ice cracks revealing a warm texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the teapot steadily and calmly descending into dark water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are tiny crystal-clear bubbles escaping from the spout and spiraling upwards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit only by a distant, gradually fading beam of light from the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0010406322544440627 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.876040458679199 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0010406322544440627, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0010406322544440627, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09677640348672867, + 0.0909457802772522, + 0.04740801453590393, + 0.019796481356024742, + 0.26252153515815735, + 0.03787999227643013, + 0.06202365458011627, + 0.12945005297660828, + 0.20175643265247345, + 0.0514417327940464 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0010406322544440627 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an antique celadon teapot with a rounded body and curved spout?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the teapot covered in delicate ice cracks revealing a warm texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the teapot steadily and calmly descending into dark water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are tiny crystal-clear bubbles escaping from the spout and spiraling upwards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit only by a distant, gradually fading beam of light from the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03809512034058571 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288095235824585 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03809512034058571, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03809512034058571, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04197223484516144, + 0.060726139694452286, + 0.036364924162626266, + 0.029145563021302223, + 0.36229127645492554, + 0.048185743391513824, + 0.04800005257129669, + 0.10526467859745026, + 0.0919390469789505, + 0.17611029744148254 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03809512034058571 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow, tracking, medium close-up captures an antique celadon teapot, steadily and calmly descending into the inky blackness of the water. The teapot, with its rounded body and curved spout, is covered in delicate ice cracks, revealing a warm texture in the dim light. A stream of tiny, crystal-clear bubbles gracefully and continuously escapes from the spout, spiraling upwards and forming a striking contrast with the teapot's downward trajectory. The only source of light comes from the distant surface, a gradually fading beam of light piercing the darkness, casting soft highlights on the teapot and illuminating the fleeting bubbles. The surrounding water is a pure, profound darkness, with only tiny suspended particles glimpsed in the light's path. As the teapot sinks deeper, the light on the surface becomes increasingly distant, casting a tranquil, mysterious, and slightly melancholic poetic atmosphere.", + "seed": 4891, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_1/index_3359_seed_4891_dp_2_rank_4_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.04502387698739767, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04502387698739767, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.824999976158142, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04502387698739767, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an antique celadon teapot with a rounded body and curved spout?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the teapot covered in delicate ice cracks revealing a warm texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the teapot steadily and calmly descending into dark water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are tiny crystal-clear bubbles escaping from the spout and spiraling upwards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit only by a distant, gradually fading beam of light from the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011891193687915802 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.5118913650512695 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011891193687915802, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011891193687915802, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15557274222373962, + 0.19457381963729858, + 0.170505091547966, + 0.08890783786773682, + 0.04574121907353401, + 0.0657423734664917, + 0.05220544710755348, + 0.07083401829004288, + 0.11055061966180801, + 0.04536681994795799 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011891193687915802 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an antique celadon teapot with a rounded body and curved spout?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the teapot covered in delicate ice cracks revealing a warm texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the teapot steadily and calmly descending into dark water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are tiny crystal-clear bubbles escaping from the spout and spiraling upwards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit only by a distant, gradually fading beam of light from the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012558662332594395 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387558460235596 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012558662332594395, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012558662332594395, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1307133436203003, + 0.16001170873641968, + 0.06609570235013962, + 0.03218075633049011, + 0.05321912094950676, + 0.0811680257320404, + 0.12471313774585724, + 0.08525388687849045, + 0.15511232614517212, + 0.11153198778629303 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012558662332594395 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an antique celadon teapot with a rounded body and curved spout?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the teapot covered in delicate ice cracks revealing a warm texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the teapot steadily and calmly descending into dark water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are tiny crystal-clear bubbles escaping from the spout and spiraling upwards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit only by a distant, gradually fading beam of light from the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12702569365501404 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.127025604248047 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12702569365501404, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.9999998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12702569365501404, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1380121260881424, + 0.09430752694606781, + 0.04718119651079178, + 0.08525184541940689, + 0.09798267483711243, + 0.23411865532398224, + 0.052981022745370865, + 0.06964018195867538, + 0.13729391992092133, + 0.043230894953012466 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12702569365501404 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an antique celadon teapot with a rounded body and curved spout?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the teapot covered in delicate ice cracks revealing a warm texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the teapot steadily and calmly descending into dark water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are tiny crystal-clear bubbles escaping from the spout and spiraling upwards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit only by a distant, gradually fading beam of light from the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003616461530327797 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.6286163330078125 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003616461530327797, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003616461530327797, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07978203892707825, + 0.08954297006130219, + 0.05724359676241875, + 0.02562887594103813, + 0.04061168432235718, + 0.08251316100358963, + 0.30665427446365356, + 0.03415578231215477, + 0.12071924656629562, + 0.16314846277236938 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003616461530327797 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an antique celadon teapot with a rounded body and curved spout?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the teapot covered in delicate ice cracks revealing a warm texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the teapot steadily and calmly descending into dark water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are tiny crystal-clear bubbles escaping from the spout and spiraling upwards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit only by a distant, gradually fading beam of light from the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07002737373113632 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950273513793945 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07002737373113632, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07002737373113632, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19429419934749603, + 0.051767829805612564, + 0.046045899391174316, + 0.03794878348708153, + 0.0737050473690033, + 0.043529827147722244, + 0.031723059713840485, + 0.053313180804252625, + 0.17714504897594452, + 0.2905271649360657 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07002737373113632 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow, tracking, medium close-up captures an antique celadon teapot, steadily and calmly descending into the inky blackness of the water. The teapot, with its rounded body and curved spout, is covered in delicate ice cracks, revealing a warm texture in the dim light. A stream of tiny, crystal-clear bubbles gracefully and continuously escapes from the spout, spiraling upwards and forming a striking contrast with the teapot's downward trajectory. The only source of light comes from the distant surface, a gradually fading beam of light piercing the darkness, casting soft highlights on the teapot and illuminating the fleeting bubbles. The surrounding water is a pure, profound darkness, with only tiny suspended particles glimpsed in the light's path. As the teapot sinks deeper, the light on the surface becomes increasingly distant, casting a tranquil, mysterious, and slightly melancholic poetic atmosphere.", + "seed": 4892, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_1/index_3359_seed_4892_dp_3_rank_6_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.028763469122350217, + "vlm_logprob": -0.028763469122350217, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.95, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.028763469122350217, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an antique celadon teapot with a rounded body and curved spout?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the teapot covered in delicate ice cracks revealing a warm texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the teapot steadily and calmly descending into dark water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are tiny crystal-clear bubbles escaping from the spout and spiraling upwards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit only by a distant, gradually fading beam of light from the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.024463796988129616 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7744638919830322 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.024463796988129616, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.024463796988129616, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.061909712851047516, + 0.033364951610565186, + 0.041033484041690826, + 0.051667630672454834, + 0.016182120889425278, + 0.01206201035529375, + 0.5066343545913696, + 0.0265542883425951, + 0.16943861544132233, + 0.08115281164646149 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.024463796988129616 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an antique celadon teapot with a rounded body and curved spout?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the teapot covered in delicate ice cracks revealing a warm texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the teapot steadily and calmly descending into dark water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are tiny crystal-clear bubbles escaping from the spout and spiraling upwards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit only by a distant, gradually fading beam of light from the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04867362603545189 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048673629760742 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04867362603545189, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04867362603545189, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04221174493432045, + 0.05444200709462166, + 0.023358896374702454, + 0.022789688780903816, + 0.01948465406894684, + 0.020374657586216927, + 0.6082202196121216, + 0.012738809920847416, + 0.029711905866861343, + 0.16666743159294128 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04867362603545189 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an antique celadon teapot with a rounded body and curved spout?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the teapot covered in delicate ice cracks revealing a warm texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the teapot steadily and calmly descending into dark water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are tiny crystal-clear bubbles escaping from the spout and spiraling upwards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit only by a distant, gradually fading beam of light from the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.054950349032878876 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.92995023727417 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.054950349032878876, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.054950349032878876, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.023997221142053604, + 0.020126279443502426, + 0.015174398198723793, + 0.009771924465894699, + 0.0226335059851408, + 0.019261028617620468, + 0.6453851461410522, + 0.02797256037592888, + 0.1703181117773056, + 0.045359883457422256 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.054950349032878876 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an antique celadon teapot with a rounded body and curved spout?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the teapot covered in delicate ice cracks revealing a warm texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the teapot steadily and calmly descending into dark water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are tiny crystal-clear bubbles escaping from the spout and spiraling upwards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit only by a distant, gradually fading beam of light from the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0031929248943924904 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753192901611328 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0031929248943924904, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0031929248943924904, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.062241192907094955, + 0.020098472014069557, + 0.025571046397089958, + 0.03241696208715439, + 0.009583376348018646, + 0.045016176998615265, + 0.4473992586135864, + 0.16194215416908264, + 0.11997538059949875, + 0.07575595378875732 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0031929248943924904 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an antique celadon teapot with a rounded body and curved spout?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the teapot covered in delicate ice cracks revealing a warm texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the teapot steadily and calmly descending into dark water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are tiny crystal-clear bubbles escaping from the spout and spiraling upwards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit only by a distant, gradually fading beam of light from the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012536648660898209 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387536525726318 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012536648660898209, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012536648660898209, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06872644275426865, + 0.05250921845436096, + 0.014438706450164318, + 0.031046083196997643, + 0.025508394464850426, + 0.02655057981610298, + 0.665687084197998, + 0.016940245404839516, + 0.08049416542053223, + 0.018099065870046616 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012536648660898209 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow, tracking, medium close-up captures an antique celadon teapot, steadily and calmly descending into the inky blackness of the water. The teapot, with its rounded body and curved spout, is covered in delicate ice cracks, revealing a warm texture in the dim light. A stream of tiny, crystal-clear bubbles gracefully and continuously escapes from the spout, spiraling upwards and forming a striking contrast with the teapot's downward trajectory. The only source of light comes from the distant surface, a gradually fading beam of light piercing the darkness, casting soft highlights on the teapot and illuminating the fleeting bubbles. The surrounding water is a pure, profound darkness, with only tiny suspended particles glimpsed in the light's path. As the teapot sinks deeper, the light on the surface becomes increasingly distant, casting a tranquil, mysterious, and slightly melancholic poetic atmosphere.", + "seed": 4893, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_1/index_3359_seed_4893_dp_3_rank_6_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.04062512554228306, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04062512554228306, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.625, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04062512554228306, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an antique celadon teapot with a rounded body and curved spout?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the teapot covered in delicate ice cracks revealing a warm texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the teapot steadily and calmly descending into dark water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are tiny crystal-clear bubbles escaping from the spout and spiraling upwards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit only by a distant, gradually fading beam of light from the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.09137745946645737 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4663774967193604 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.09137745946645737, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.09137745946645737, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16187086701393127, + 0.076387919485569, + 0.04317658767104149, + 0.03753657639026642, + 0.041972484439611435, + 0.04600090533494949, + 0.05853550508618355, + 0.037640418857336044, + 0.17555062472820282, + 0.3213280737400055 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.09137745946645737 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an antique celadon teapot with a rounded body and curved spout?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the teapot covered in delicate ice cracks revealing a warm texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the teapot steadily and calmly descending into dark water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are tiny crystal-clear bubbles escaping from the spout and spiraling upwards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit only by a distant, gradually fading beam of light from the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07004204392433167 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695042133331299 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07004204392433167, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07004204392433167, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20436842739582062, + 0.08019894361495972, + 0.07584308832883835, + 0.05931440368294716, + 0.05468033626675606, + 0.0432460755109787, + 0.0690523087978363, + 0.040113404393196106, + 0.08828957378864288, + 0.2848934531211853 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07004204392433167 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an antique celadon teapot with a rounded body and curved spout?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the teapot covered in delicate ice cracks revealing a warm texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the teapot steadily and calmly descending into dark water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are tiny crystal-clear bubbles escaping from the spout and spiraling upwards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit only by a distant, gradually fading beam of light from the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023286793380975723 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773286819458008 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023286793380975723, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023286793380975723, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.27712738513946533, + 0.08004296571016312, + 0.07811379432678223, + 0.07137840986251831, + 0.04752933606505394, + 0.14165154099464417, + 0.04093209281563759, + 0.06366084516048431, + 0.08718428015708923, + 0.11237942427396774 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023286793380975723 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an antique celadon teapot with a rounded body and curved spout?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the teapot covered in delicate ice cracks revealing a warm texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the teapot steadily and calmly descending into dark water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are tiny crystal-clear bubbles escaping from the spout and spiraling upwards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit only by a distant, gradually fading beam of light from the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008639340288937092 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758639335632324 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008639340288937092, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008639340288937092, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23374804854393005, + 0.10477785766124725, + 0.06335072964429855, + 0.1967642456293106, + 0.10145319253206253, + 0.04736208915710449, + 0.04009721428155899, + 0.025017915293574333, + 0.06212818622589111, + 0.1253006011247635 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008639340288937092 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an antique celadon teapot with a rounded body and curved spout?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the teapot covered in delicate ice cracks revealing a warm texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the teapot steadily and calmly descending into dark water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are tiny crystal-clear bubbles escaping from the spout and spiraling upwards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit only by a distant, gradually fading beam of light from the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009779990650713444 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634779930114746 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009779990650713444, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009779990650713444, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12544548511505127, + 0.11322927474975586, + 0.06227738782763481, + 0.11462090164422989, + 0.03011028841137886, + 0.10135053098201752, + 0.083979532122612, + 0.11677299439907074, + 0.11710252612829208, + 0.13511110842227936 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009779990650713444 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_10/index_tensor([7268, 7268])_group_10_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_10/index_tensor([7268, 7268])_group_10_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..84dbb724e844f8868855681d0efd2c8df9f45654 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_10/index_tensor([7268, 7268])_group_10_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "Shot from a horizontal angle, the film unfolds in a fixed medium shot, imbued with the texture of soft watercolor brushstrokes. A dense bamboo forest stands serenely, its tall, turquoise bamboo stalks interwoven into a verdant canopy, their edges subtly blurred by the watercolor effect. Several slender bamboo leaves gently detach from the branches and begin to drift slowly down. Struck in stunning slow motion, each falling leaf does not touch the ground intact, but rather gracefully twirls and dances in mid-air, its emerald green form gradually disintegrating, starting at the tip and transforming into a cloud of countless shimmering golden dust particles. These luminous golden particles continue to swirl and dance in the air, carving graceful arcs as if possessing a life of their own. A soft, diffuse light penetrates the bamboo forest, illuminating the golden dust, creating a striking and harmonious contrast with the hazy green background, creating a tranquil, ethereal, and poetic dreamlike atmosphere.", + "seed": 17941, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_10/index_7268_seed_17941_dp_20_rank_40_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.2651365359313786, + "vlm_logprob": -0.2651365359313786, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.65, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.2651365359313786, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a dense bamboo forest with tall turquoise stalks and a verdant canopy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are slender bamboo leaves visible detaching from branches and drifting slowly downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the falling leaves twirl and dance in mid-air before disintegrating into shimmering golden dust particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered with a soft watercolor brushstroke texture and blurred edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera fixed in a horizontal medium shot without movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0022787100169807673 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.252278804779053 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0022787100169807673, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0022787100169807673, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12953980267047882, + 0.03447093814611435, + 0.018990663811564445, + 0.017580978572368622, + 0.04302207753062248, + 0.5496547818183899, + 0.08579809963703156, + 0.014885840937495232, + 0.06576908379793167, + 0.04028767719864845 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0022787100169807673 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a dense bamboo forest with tall turquoise stalks and a verdant canopy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are slender bamboo leaves visible detaching from branches and drifting slowly downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the falling leaves twirl and dance in mid-air before disintegrating into shimmering golden dust particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered with a soft watercolor brushstroke texture and blurred edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera fixed in a horizontal medium shot without movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002203062642365694 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127202987670898 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002203062642365694, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002203062642365694, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10121013969182968, + 0.04325262829661369, + 0.06545503437519073, + 0.05335269868373871, + 0.168770432472229, + 0.3888044059276581, + 0.05344655364751816, + 0.02465580590069294, + 0.072464719414711, + 0.02858753502368927 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002203062642365694 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a dense bamboo forest with tall turquoise stalks and a verdant canopy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are slender bamboo leaves visible detaching from branches and drifting slowly downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the falling leaves twirl and dance in mid-air before disintegrating into shimmering golden dust particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered with a soft watercolor brushstroke texture and blurred edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera fixed in a horizontal medium shot without movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006739741191267967 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006739616394043 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006739741191267967, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006739741191267967, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09505104273557663, + 0.05020846426486969, + 0.11751927435398102, + 0.259846031665802, + 0.07185901701450348, + 0.16098278760910034, + 0.08637842535972595, + 0.056988704949617386, + 0.06734221428632736, + 0.033824026584625244 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 5, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006739741191267967 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a dense bamboo forest with tall turquoise stalks and a verdant canopy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are slender bamboo leaves visible detaching from branches and drifting slowly downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the falling leaves twirl and dance in mid-air before disintegrating into shimmering golden dust particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered with a soft watercolor brushstroke texture and blurred edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera fixed in a horizontal medium shot without movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0010412277188152075 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.876041412353516 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0010412277188152075, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0010412277188152075, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1669941544532776, + 0.05247217044234276, + 0.06275688856840134, + 0.07024155557155609, + 0.06989925354719162, + 0.2200726717710495, + 0.15023104846477509, + 0.07647918164730072, + 0.08074129372835159, + 0.05011175945401192 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0010412277188152075 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a dense bamboo forest with tall turquoise stalks and a verdant canopy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are slender bamboo leaves visible detaching from branches and drifting slowly downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the falling leaves twirl and dance in mid-air before disintegrating into shimmering golden dust particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered with a soft watercolor brushstroke texture and blurred edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera fixed in a horizontal medium shot without movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3134199380874634 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.31341996788978577 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.3134199380874634, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -1.3134199380874634, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13819578289985657, + 0.062319763004779816, + 0.08845876902341843, + 0.18994857370853424, + 0.06854300945997238, + 0.09802154451608658, + 0.11215757578611374, + 0.09739377349615097, + 0.05853462591767311, + 0.08642654865980148 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.3134199380874634 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "Shot from a horizontal angle, the film unfolds in a fixed medium shot, imbued with the texture of soft watercolor brushstrokes. A dense bamboo forest stands serenely, its tall, turquoise bamboo stalks interwoven into a verdant canopy, their edges subtly blurred by the watercolor effect. Several slender bamboo leaves gently detach from the branches and begin to drift slowly down. Struck in stunning slow motion, each falling leaf does not touch the ground intact, but rather gracefully twirls and dances in mid-air, its emerald green form gradually disintegrating, starting at the tip and transforming into a cloud of countless shimmering golden dust particles. These luminous golden particles continue to swirl and dance in the air, carving graceful arcs as if possessing a life of their own. A soft, diffuse light penetrates the bamboo forest, illuminating the golden dust, creating a striking and harmonious contrast with the hazy green background, creating a tranquil, ethereal, and poetic dreamlike atmosphere.", + "seed": 17942, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_10/index_7268_seed_17942_dp_20_rank_40_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.2877758027520031, + "vlm_logprob": -0.2877758027520031, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.75, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.2877758027520031, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a dense bamboo forest with tall turquoise stalks and a verdant canopy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are slender bamboo leaves visible detaching from branches and drifting slowly downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the falling leaves twirl and dance in mid-air before disintegrating into shimmering golden dust particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered with a soft watercolor brushstroke texture and blurred edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera fixed in a horizontal medium shot without movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002998501295223832 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877998352050781 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002998501295223832, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002998501295223832, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.7085266709327698, + 0.08720565587282181, + 0.04018823802471161, + 0.018381217494606972, + 0.03356926888227463, + 0.023642176762223244, + 0.01346225943416357, + 0.019561296328902245, + 0.041257210075855255, + 0.01420602761209011 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002998501295223832 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a dense bamboo forest with tall turquoise stalks and a verdant canopy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are slender bamboo leaves visible detaching from branches and drifting slowly downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the falling leaves twirl and dance in mid-air before disintegrating into shimmering golden dust particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered with a soft watercolor brushstroke texture and blurred edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera fixed in a horizontal medium shot without movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012545948848128319 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387546062469482 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012545948848128319, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012545948848128319, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5784616470336914, + 0.08096441626548767, + 0.03416839987039566, + 0.041580669581890106, + 0.036742012947797775, + 0.05680985003709793, + 0.028564922511577606, + 0.023981871083378792, + 0.06565934419631958, + 0.05306684225797653 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012545948848128319 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a dense bamboo forest with tall turquoise stalks and a verdant canopy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are slender bamboo leaves visible detaching from branches and drifting slowly downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the falling leaves twirl and dance in mid-air before disintegrating into shimmering golden dust particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered with a soft watercolor brushstroke texture and blurred edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera fixed in a horizontal medium shot without movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0110772168263793 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511077404022217 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0110772168263793, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0110772168263793, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4882616698741913, + 0.03903449326753616, + 0.066738560795784, + 0.03650962933897972, + 0.05110668018460274, + 0.1386374533176422, + 0.0527782142162323, + 0.03513733670115471, + 0.05988690257072449, + 0.03190908581018448 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0110772168263793 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a dense bamboo forest with tall turquoise stalks and a verdant canopy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are slender bamboo leaves visible detaching from branches and drifting slowly downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the falling leaves twirl and dance in mid-air before disintegrating into shimmering golden dust particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered with a soft watercolor brushstroke texture and blurred edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera fixed in a horizontal medium shot without movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005948815029114485 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130949020385742 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005948815029114485, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005948815029114485, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14717186987400055, + 0.1493512988090515, + 0.06034715101122856, + 0.04069765284657478, + 0.11009973287582397, + 0.20556685328483582, + 0.05972838029265404, + 0.06193478778004646, + 0.13762518763542175, + 0.027477042749524117 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005948815029114485 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a dense bamboo forest with tall turquoise stalks and a verdant canopy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are slender bamboo leaves visible detaching from branches and drifting slowly downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the falling leaves twirl and dance in mid-air before disintegrating into shimmering golden dust particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered with a soft watercolor brushstroke texture and blurred edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera fixed in a horizontal medium shot without movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4063085317611694 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2813085615634918 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.4063085317611694, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -1.4063085317611694, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.6122311353683472, + 0.04573643207550049, + 0.03377843648195267, + 0.05966096371412277, + 0.031131111085414886, + 0.07682166993618011, + 0.03959314525127411, + 0.04438358545303345, + 0.039467986673116684, + 0.017195595428347588 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.4063085317611694 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "Shot from a horizontal angle, the film unfolds in a fixed medium shot, imbued with the texture of soft watercolor brushstrokes. A dense bamboo forest stands serenely, its tall, turquoise bamboo stalks interwoven into a verdant canopy, their edges subtly blurred by the watercolor effect. Several slender bamboo leaves gently detach from the branches and begin to drift slowly down. Struck in stunning slow motion, each falling leaf does not touch the ground intact, but rather gracefully twirls and dances in mid-air, its emerald green form gradually disintegrating, starting at the tip and transforming into a cloud of countless shimmering golden dust particles. These luminous golden particles continue to swirl and dance in the air, carving graceful arcs as if possessing a life of their own. A soft, diffuse light penetrates the bamboo forest, illuminating the golden dust, creating a striking and harmonious contrast with the hazy green background, creating a tranquil, ethereal, and poetic dreamlike atmosphere.", + "seed": 17943, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_10/index_7268_seed_17943_dp_21_rank_42_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.23115231723058968, + "vlm_logprob": -0.23115231723058968, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.35, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.23115231723058968, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a dense bamboo forest with tall turquoise stalks and a verdant canopy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are slender bamboo leaves visible detaching from branches and drifting slowly downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the falling leaves twirl and dance in mid-air before disintegrating into shimmering golden dust particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered with a soft watercolor brushstroke texture and blurred edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera fixed in a horizontal medium shot without movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0021503677126020193 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.377150535583496 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0021503677126020193, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0021503677126020193, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2294643670320511, + 0.059431444853544235, + 0.06903853267431259, + 0.07698313146829605, + 0.13050271570682526, + 0.08508952707052231, + 0.09616949409246445, + 0.15734484791755676, + 0.051075901836156845, + 0.04489998519420624 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0021503677126020193 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a dense bamboo forest with tall turquoise stalks and a verdant canopy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are slender bamboo leaves visible detaching from branches and drifting slowly downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the falling leaves twirl and dance in mid-air before disintegrating into shimmering golden dust particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered with a soft watercolor brushstroke texture and blurred edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera fixed in a horizontal medium shot without movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008652577176690102 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758652687072754 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008652577176690102, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008652577176690102, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2618013024330139, + 0.08500513434410095, + 0.11073240637779236, + 0.11188820749521255, + 0.11378262937068939, + 0.03339403122663498, + 0.08152132481336594, + 0.10307087749242783, + 0.047947220504283905, + 0.050856877118349075 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008652577176690102 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a dense bamboo forest with tall turquoise stalks and a verdant canopy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are slender bamboo leaves visible detaching from branches and drifting slowly downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the falling leaves twirl and dance in mid-air before disintegrating into shimmering golden dust particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered with a soft watercolor brushstroke texture and blurred edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera fixed in a horizontal medium shot without movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005953199230134487 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130953311920166 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005953199230134487, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005953199230134487, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2357509434223175, + 0.10763350874185562, + 0.09053461998701096, + 0.11835598200559616, + 0.1297544687986374, + 0.08609765022993088, + 0.0436103418469429, + 0.13317686319351196, + 0.025292614474892616, + 0.029793059453368187 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005953199230134487 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a dense bamboo forest with tall turquoise stalks and a verdant canopy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are slender bamboo leaves visible detaching from branches and drifting slowly downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the falling leaves twirl and dance in mid-air before disintegrating into shimmering golden dust particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered with a soft watercolor brushstroke texture and blurred edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera fixed in a horizontal medium shot without movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0019425348145887256 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.2519426345825195 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0019425348145887256, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0019425348145887256, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09504055976867676, + 0.06731464713811874, + 0.08345353603363037, + 0.17271488904953003, + 0.027632208541035652, + 0.054505039006471634, + 0.08385146409273148, + 0.2848900556564331, + 0.05448766425251961, + 0.07610993832349777 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0019425348145887256 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a dense bamboo forest with tall turquoise stalks and a verdant canopy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are slender bamboo leaves visible detaching from branches and drifting slowly downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the falling leaves twirl and dance in mid-air before disintegrating into shimmering golden dust particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered with a soft watercolor brushstroke texture and blurred edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera fixed in a horizontal medium shot without movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.137062907218933 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3870628774166107 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.137062907218933, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -1.137062907218933, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15368957817554474, + 0.08408239483833313, + 0.1319514513015747, + 0.02054453454911709, + 0.061676401644945145, + 0.16739694774150848, + 0.09599252045154572, + 0.13445903360843658, + 0.08945590257644653, + 0.06075124070048332 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.137062907218933 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "Shot from a horizontal angle, the film unfolds in a fixed medium shot, imbued with the texture of soft watercolor brushstrokes. A dense bamboo forest stands serenely, its tall, turquoise bamboo stalks interwoven into a verdant canopy, their edges subtly blurred by the watercolor effect. Several slender bamboo leaves gently detach from the branches and begin to drift slowly down. Struck in stunning slow motion, each falling leaf does not touch the ground intact, but rather gracefully twirls and dances in mid-air, its emerald green form gradually disintegrating, starting at the tip and transforming into a cloud of countless shimmering golden dust particles. These luminous golden particles continue to swirl and dance in the air, carving graceful arcs as if possessing a life of their own. A soft, diffuse light penetrates the bamboo forest, illuminating the golden dust, creating a striking and harmonious contrast with the hazy green background, creating a tranquil, ethereal, and poetic dreamlike atmosphere.", + "seed": 17944, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_10/index_7268_seed_17944_dp_21_rank_42_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.1826417615171522, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1826417615171522, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.8, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1826417615171522, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a dense bamboo forest with tall turquoise stalks and a verdant canopy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are slender bamboo leaves visible detaching from branches and drifting slowly downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the falling leaves twirl and dance in mid-air before disintegrating into shimmering golden dust particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered with a soft watercolor brushstroke texture and blurred edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera fixed in a horizontal medium shot without movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.001127441762946546 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.376127243041992 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.001127441762946546, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.001127441762946546, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05182972177863121, + 0.02584853209555149, + 0.02392617240548134, + 0.49090421199798584, + 0.04912445694208145, + 0.03957710787653923, + 0.050076697021722794, + 0.17345482110977173, + 0.038089998066425323, + 0.057168249040842056 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.001127441762946546 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a dense bamboo forest with tall turquoise stalks and a verdant canopy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are slender bamboo leaves visible detaching from branches and drifting slowly downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the falling leaves twirl and dance in mid-air before disintegrating into shimmering golden dust particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered with a soft watercolor brushstroke texture and blurred edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera fixed in a horizontal medium shot without movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006748266983777285 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006748199462891 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006748266983777285, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006748266983777285, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.040220826864242554, + 0.016588503494858742, + 0.017185229808092117, + 0.6979476809501648, + 0.10909450054168701, + 0.03567834198474884, + 0.01716662012040615, + 0.028386928141117096, + 0.007374492473900318, + 0.03035690449178219 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006748266983777285 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a dense bamboo forest with tall turquoise stalks and a verdant canopy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are slender bamboo leaves visible detaching from branches and drifting slowly downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the falling leaves twirl and dance in mid-air before disintegrating into shimmering golden dust particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered with a soft watercolor brushstroke texture and blurred edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera fixed in a horizontal medium shot without movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005953436251729727 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130953311920166 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005953436251729727, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005953436251729727, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1242232397198677, + 0.03734605759382248, + 0.02313206158578396, + 0.35085782408714294, + 0.16716565191745758, + 0.04107413813471794, + 0.06936929374933243, + 0.08562838286161423, + 0.048171233385801315, + 0.05303211137652397 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005953436251729727 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a dense bamboo forest with tall turquoise stalks and a verdant canopy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are slender bamboo leaves visible detaching from branches and drifting slowly downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the falling leaves twirl and dance in mid-air before disintegrating into shimmering golden dust particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered with a soft watercolor brushstroke texture and blurred edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera fixed in a horizontal medium shot without movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0010433712741360068 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.876043319702148 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0010433712741360068, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0010433712741360068, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.055329762399196625, + 0.04234824702143669, + 0.03495083749294281, + 0.2496536821126938, + 0.03973153978586197, + 0.03221461921930313, + 0.02539319545030594, + 0.43822410702705383, + 0.05015066638588905, + 0.03200334310531616 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0010433712741360068 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a dense bamboo forest with tall turquoise stalks and a verdant canopy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are slender bamboo leaves visible detaching from branches and drifting slowly downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the falling leaves twirl and dance in mid-air before disintegrating into shimmering golden dust particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered with a soft watercolor brushstroke texture and blurred edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera fixed in a horizontal medium shot without movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8983362913131714 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5233362913131714 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.8983362913131714, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.8983362913131714, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07791618257761002, + 0.0386335551738739, + 0.038819484412670135, + 0.07818207889795303, + 0.14423874020576477, + 0.031347792595624924, + 0.32014501094818115, + 0.1640213280916214, + 0.04737037792801857, + 0.05932541936635971 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.8983362913131714 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_11/index_tensor([7141, 7141])_group_11_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_11/index_tensor([7141, 7141])_group_11_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..e774451259f240cba2a0d124269aa69b291fbe29 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_11/index_tensor([7141, 7141])_group_11_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "sleek silver coupe glides effortlessly along a sunny coastal highway, maintaining a perfect medium frame in a fluid, eye-level tracking shot that delivers stunning photographic realism. The car's body, a masterpiece of aerodynamic design, is painted in Liquid Silver Metallic, with the bright afternoon sun creating sharp, mirror-like highlights that dance across its polished curves and sculpted panels. To the right, a vast, sparkling blue ocean stretches to the horizon, while to the left, rolling green hills gently rise from the pristine black asphalt road. As the coupe approaches an upcoming intersection, the central action unfolds with technological elegance: the modern LED traffic lights ahead seamlessly transition from vibrant red to vivid green, perfectly synchronized with the car's approach, clearly demonstrating the Green Wave coordination system at work. This allows the vehicle to maintain a smooth, uninterrupted speed, creating a powerful sense of fluid motion and harmony. The entire scene is bathed in the warm golden glow of a low sun, creating an atmosphere of tranquility, refinement, freedom, and effortless forward momentum.", + "seed": 19170, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_11/index_7141_seed_19170_dp_22_rank_44_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.2701974630355835, + "vlm_logprob": -0.2701974630355835, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.075, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.2701974630355835, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a sleek silver coupe visible driving on a coastal highway?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the car's paint color Liquid Silver Metallic with sharp mirror-like highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show a vast blue ocean to the right and rolling green hills to the left?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do modern LED traffic lights transition from red to green as the car approaches an intersection?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a fluid, eye-level tracking shot maintaining a medium frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04356340318918228 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1685633659362793 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04356340318918228, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04356340318918228, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04625977203249931, + 0.026332661509513855, + 0.043833669275045395, + 0.04892177879810333, + 0.2727670669555664, + 0.03589561581611633, + 0.01855640299618244, + 0.015378491021692753, + 0.46413761377334595, + 0.027916977182030678 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04356340318918228 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a sleek silver coupe visible driving on a coastal highway?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the car's paint color Liquid Silver Metallic with sharp mirror-like highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show a vast blue ocean to the right and rolling green hills to the left?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do modern LED traffic lights transition from red to green as the car approaches an intersection?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a fluid, eye-level tracking shot maintaining a medium frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16046284139156342 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9104628562927246 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16046284139156342, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16046284139156342, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06004306674003601, + 0.0886935144662857, + 0.049988143146038055, + 0.04047632962465286, + 0.41730475425720215, + 0.10669976472854614, + 0.049754831939935684, + 0.030023571103811264, + 0.0862475112080574, + 0.07076847553253174 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16046284139156342 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a sleek silver coupe visible driving on a coastal highway?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the car's paint color Liquid Silver Metallic with sharp mirror-like highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show a vast blue ocean to the right and rolling green hills to the left?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do modern LED traffic lights transition from red to green as the car approaches an intersection?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a fluid, eye-level tracking shot maintaining a medium frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05495012179017067 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.92995023727417 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05495012179017067, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05495012179017067, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15128469467163086, + 0.06278767436742783, + 0.03623301908373833, + 0.0745251327753067, + 0.09060902893543243, + 0.025855867192149162, + 0.059052299708127975, + 0.02936418354511261, + 0.3998248875141144, + 0.0704631507396698 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05495012179017067 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a sleek silver coupe visible driving on a coastal highway?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the car's paint color Liquid Silver Metallic with sharp mirror-like highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show a vast blue ocean to the right and rolling green hills to the left?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do modern LED traffic lights transition from red to green as the car approaches an intersection?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a fluid, eye-level tracking shot maintaining a medium frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.0539212226867676 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4289212226867676 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.0539212226867676, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.625, + "token_credit_reward": -1.0539212226867676, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0487101748585701, + 0.029090583324432373, + 0.03052826225757599, + 0.030124152079224586, + 0.031299274414777756, + 0.0523701012134552, + 0.0733514055609703, + 0.09769733250141144, + 0.4302001893520355, + 0.1766284704208374 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.0539212226867676 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a sleek silver coupe visible driving on a coastal highway?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the car's paint color Liquid Silver Metallic with sharp mirror-like highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show a vast blue ocean to the right and rolling green hills to the left?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do modern LED traffic lights transition from red to green as the car approaches an intersection?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a fluid, eye-level tracking shot maintaining a medium frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.038089726120233536 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2880897521972656 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.038089726120233536, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.038089726120233536, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0505288690328598, + 0.07603290677070618, + 0.05029869079589844, + 0.042541809380054474, + 0.14809980988502502, + 0.04600788280367851, + 0.03631209954619408, + 0.028034312650561333, + 0.4022294282913208, + 0.11991425603628159 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.038089726120233536 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "sleek silver coupe glides effortlessly along a sunny coastal highway, maintaining a perfect medium frame in a fluid, eye-level tracking shot that delivers stunning photographic realism. The car's body, a masterpiece of aerodynamic design, is painted in Liquid Silver Metallic, with the bright afternoon sun creating sharp, mirror-like highlights that dance across its polished curves and sculpted panels. To the right, a vast, sparkling blue ocean stretches to the horizon, while to the left, rolling green hills gently rise from the pristine black asphalt road. As the coupe approaches an upcoming intersection, the central action unfolds with technological elegance: the modern LED traffic lights ahead seamlessly transition from vibrant red to vivid green, perfectly synchronized with the car's approach, clearly demonstrating the Green Wave coordination system at work. This allows the vehicle to maintain a smooth, uninterrupted speed, creating a powerful sense of fluid motion and harmony. The entire scene is bathed in the warm golden glow of a low sun, creating an atmosphere of tranquility, refinement, freedom, and effortless forward momentum.", + "seed": 19171, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_11/index_7141_seed_19171_dp_22_rank_44_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.4490680616348982, + "vlm_logprob": -0.4490680616348982, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.925, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.4490680616348982, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a sleek silver coupe visible driving on a coastal highway?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the car's paint color Liquid Silver Metallic with sharp mirror-like highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show a vast blue ocean to the right and rolling green hills to the left?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do modern LED traffic lights transition from red to green as the car approaches an intersection?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a fluid, eye-level tracking shot maintaining a medium frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.049289196729660034 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0492892265319824 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.049289196729660034, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.049289196729660034, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19577208161354065, + 0.09736088663339615, + 0.22660870850086212, + 0.11343411356210709, + 0.04291563853621483, + 0.2006591111421585, + 0.02389289066195488, + 0.03454103320837021, + 0.03377636894583702, + 0.031039148569107056 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.049289196729660034 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a sleek silver coupe visible driving on a coastal highway?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the car's paint color Liquid Silver Metallic with sharp mirror-like highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show a vast blue ocean to the right and rolling green hills to the left?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do modern LED traffic lights transition from red to green as the car approaches an intersection?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a fluid, eye-level tracking shot maintaining a medium frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22563354671001434 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6006335020065308 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.22563354671001434, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.22563354671001434, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07449083775281906, + 0.14141982793807983, + 0.2325565665960312, + 0.05091716721653938, + 0.09478919208049774, + 0.13667072355747223, + 0.07709572464227676, + 0.03689908981323242, + 0.09423496574163437, + 0.060925886034965515 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.22563354671001434 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a sleek silver coupe visible driving on a coastal highway?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the car's paint color Liquid Silver Metallic with sharp mirror-like highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show a vast blue ocean to the right and rolling green hills to the left?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do modern LED traffic lights transition from red to green as the car approaches an intersection?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a fluid, eye-level tracking shot maintaining a medium frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02634468488395214 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513447761535645 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02634468488395214, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02634468488395214, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13740286231040955, + 0.258033812046051, + 0.11929324269294739, + 0.039163995534181595, + 0.05546371638774872, + 0.26592954993247986, + 0.03526066243648529, + 0.033027034252882004, + 0.016195964068174362, + 0.040229156613349915 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02634468488395214 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a sleek silver coupe visible driving on a coastal highway?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the car's paint color Liquid Silver Metallic with sharp mirror-like highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show a vast blue ocean to the right and rolling green hills to the left?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do modern LED traffic lights transition from red to green as the car approaches an intersection?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a fluid, eye-level tracking shot maintaining a medium frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9103683233261108 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16036830842494965 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.9103683233261108, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -1.9103683233261108, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0430559478700161, + 0.16343103349208832, + 0.10772547125816345, + 0.07059979438781738, + 0.04726722836494446, + 0.39014309644699097, + 0.02569575048983097, + 0.09118810296058655, + 0.03604878857731819, + 0.024844853207468987 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.9103683233261108 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a sleek silver coupe visible driving on a coastal highway?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the car's paint color Liquid Silver Metallic with sharp mirror-like highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show a vast blue ocean to the right and rolling green hills to the left?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do modern LED traffic lights transition from red to green as the car approaches an intersection?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a fluid, eye-level tracking shot maintaining a medium frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03370455652475357 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4087045192718506 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03370455652475357, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03370455652475357, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07179821282625198, + 0.1345098465681076, + 0.1399463266134262, + 0.09308408945798874, + 0.09766408056020737, + 0.23511406779289246, + 0.05670417472720146, + 0.11783329397439957, + 0.02608192153275013, + 0.02726396545767784 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03370455652475357 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "sleek silver coupe glides effortlessly along a sunny coastal highway, maintaining a perfect medium frame in a fluid, eye-level tracking shot that delivers stunning photographic realism. The car's body, a masterpiece of aerodynamic design, is painted in Liquid Silver Metallic, with the bright afternoon sun creating sharp, mirror-like highlights that dance across its polished curves and sculpted panels. To the right, a vast, sparkling blue ocean stretches to the horizon, while to the left, rolling green hills gently rise from the pristine black asphalt road. As the coupe approaches an upcoming intersection, the central action unfolds with technological elegance: the modern LED traffic lights ahead seamlessly transition from vibrant red to vivid green, perfectly synchronized with the car's approach, clearly demonstrating the Green Wave coordination system at work. This allows the vehicle to maintain a smooth, uninterrupted speed, creating a powerful sense of fluid motion and harmony. The entire scene is bathed in the warm golden glow of a low sun, creating an atmosphere of tranquility, refinement, freedom, and effortless forward momentum.", + "seed": 19172, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_11/index_7141_seed_19172_dp_23_rank_46_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.36865295469760895, + "vlm_logprob": -0.36865295469760895, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.375, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.36865295469760895, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a sleek silver coupe visible driving on a coastal highway?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the car's paint color Liquid Silver Metallic with sharp mirror-like highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show a vast blue ocean to the right and rolling green hills to the left?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do modern LED traffic lights transition from red to green as the car approaches an intersection?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a fluid, eye-level tracking shot maintaining a medium frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.021224629133939743 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8962247371673584 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.021224629133939743, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.021224629133939743, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13590507209300995, + 0.04485125467181206, + 0.07077515870332718, + 0.10478313267230988, + 0.13264569640159607, + 0.09540656208992004, + 0.09845321625471115, + 0.03483676537871361, + 0.08551474660634995, + 0.1968284398317337 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.021224629133939743 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a sleek silver coupe visible driving on a coastal highway?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the car's paint color Liquid Silver Metallic with sharp mirror-like highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show a vast blue ocean to the right and rolling green hills to the left?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do modern LED traffic lights transition from red to green as the car approaches an intersection?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a fluid, eye-level tracking shot maintaining a medium frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17998415231704712 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8049840927124023 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17998415231704712, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17998415231704712, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13596323132514954, + 0.09370054304599762, + 0.05063413456082344, + 0.10369465500116348, + 0.09428805857896805, + 0.18884538114070892, + 0.17080293595790863, + 0.04338845983147621, + 0.028421597555279732, + 0.09026096016168594 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17998415231704712 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a sleek silver coupe visible driving on a coastal highway?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the car's paint color Liquid Silver Metallic with sharp mirror-like highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show a vast blue ocean to the right and rolling green hills to the left?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do modern LED traffic lights transition from red to green as the car approaches an intersection?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a fluid, eye-level tracking shot maintaining a medium frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01818905957043171 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018188953399658 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01818905957043171, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01818905957043171, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16841048002243042, + 0.09681884199380875, + 0.07602539658546448, + 0.18479257822036743, + 0.15751197934150696, + 0.05112484470009804, + 0.05791636183857918, + 0.04058687388896942, + 0.044429901987314224, + 0.12238267064094543 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01818905957043171 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a sleek silver coupe visible driving on a coastal highway?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the car's paint color Liquid Silver Metallic with sharp mirror-like highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show a vast blue ocean to the right and rolling green hills to the left?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do modern LED traffic lights transition from red to green as the car approaches an intersection?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a fluid, eye-level tracking shot maintaining a medium frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6005820035934448 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22558198869228363 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.6005820035934448, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -1.6005820035934448, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1352832317352295, + 0.09662847965955734, + 0.08975068479776382, + 0.15548475086688995, + 0.05707569047808647, + 0.049849629402160645, + 0.03867863863706589, + 0.07397589087486267, + 0.09632690250873566, + 0.20694603025913239 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.6005820035934448 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a sleek silver coupe visible driving on a coastal highway?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the car's paint color Liquid Silver Metallic with sharp mirror-like highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show a vast blue ocean to the right and rolling green hills to the left?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do modern LED traffic lights transition from red to green as the car approaches an intersection?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a fluid, eye-level tracking shot maintaining a medium frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023284928873181343 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773284912109375 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023284928873181343, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023284928873181343, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12709105014801025, + 0.07600229233503342, + 0.07317464798688889, + 0.13148647546768188, + 0.123067706823349, + 0.14019224047660828, + 0.0662892684340477, + 0.04415222257375717, + 0.051441121846437454, + 0.16710294783115387 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023284928873181343 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "sleek silver coupe glides effortlessly along a sunny coastal highway, maintaining a perfect medium frame in a fluid, eye-level tracking shot that delivers stunning photographic realism. The car's body, a masterpiece of aerodynamic design, is painted in Liquid Silver Metallic, with the bright afternoon sun creating sharp, mirror-like highlights that dance across its polished curves and sculpted panels. To the right, a vast, sparkling blue ocean stretches to the horizon, while to the left, rolling green hills gently rise from the pristine black asphalt road. As the coupe approaches an upcoming intersection, the central action unfolds with technological elegance: the modern LED traffic lights ahead seamlessly transition from vibrant red to vivid green, perfectly synchronized with the car's approach, clearly demonstrating the Green Wave coordination system at work. This allows the vehicle to maintain a smooth, uninterrupted speed, creating a powerful sense of fluid motion and harmony. The entire scene is bathed in the warm golden glow of a low sun, creating an atmosphere of tranquility, refinement, freedom, and effortless forward momentum.", + "seed": 19173, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_11/index_7141_seed_19173_dp_23_rank_46_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.7030657142400741, + "vlm_logprob": -0.7030657142400741, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.175, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.7030657142400741, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a sleek silver coupe visible driving on a coastal highway?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the car's paint color Liquid Silver Metallic with sharp mirror-like highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show a vast blue ocean to the right and rolling green hills to the left?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do modern LED traffic lights transition from red to green as the car approaches an intersection?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a fluid, eye-level tracking shot maintaining a medium frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.034538790583610535 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.409538745880127 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.034538790583610535, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.034538790583610535, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1657961755990982, + 0.07154593616724014, + 0.10588020831346512, + 0.08725709468126297, + 0.1984320729970932, + 0.08498890697956085, + 0.14954644441604614, + 0.027563171461224556, + 0.0851602628827095, + 0.0238297488540411 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.034538790583610535 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a sleek silver coupe visible driving on a coastal highway?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the car's paint color Liquid Silver Metallic with sharp mirror-like highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show a vast blue ocean to the right and rolling green hills to the left?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do modern LED traffic lights transition from red to green as the car approaches an intersection?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a fluid, eye-level tracking shot maintaining a medium frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3488318622112274 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2238318920135498 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3488318622112274, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3488318622112274, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16914518177509308, + 0.03695204108953476, + 0.20436635613441467, + 0.061158452183008194, + 0.23199260234832764, + 0.06974499672651291, + 0.08851891756057739, + 0.05376001074910164, + 0.04791746288537979, + 0.03644397854804993 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3488318622112274 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a sleek silver coupe visible driving on a coastal highway?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the car's paint color Liquid Silver Metallic with sharp mirror-like highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show a vast blue ocean to the right and rolling green hills to the left?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do modern LED traffic lights transition from red to green as the car approaches an intersection?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a fluid, eye-level tracking shot maintaining a medium frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11291701346635818 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.237916946411133 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11291701346635818, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11291701346635818, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12101417034864426, + 0.08389204740524292, + 0.07321041822433472, + 0.05140075832605362, + 0.06742319464683533, + 0.25958511233329773, + 0.09692322462797165, + 0.04280341416597366, + 0.12204154580831528, + 0.08170616626739502 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11291701346635818 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a sleek silver coupe visible driving on a coastal highway?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the car's paint color Liquid Silver Metallic with sharp mirror-like highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show a vast blue ocean to the right and rolling green hills to the left?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do modern LED traffic lights transition from red to green as the car approaches an intersection?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a fluid, eye-level tracking shot maintaining a medium frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929965019226074 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05496501550078392 + ], + "logprob_reward": -2.929965019226074, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -2.929965019226074, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13489854335784912, + 0.0530615858733654, + 0.418753057718277, + 0.041686609387397766, + 0.1562301218509674, + 0.02122962474822998, + 0.0666038990020752, + 0.03811565414071083, + 0.025731734931468964, + 0.04368917644023895 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -2.929965019226074 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a sleek silver coupe visible driving on a coastal highway?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the car's paint color Liquid Silver Metallic with sharp mirror-like highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show a vast blue ocean to the right and rolling green hills to the left?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do modern LED traffic lights transition from red to green as the car approaches an intersection?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a fluid, eye-level tracking shot maintaining a medium frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08907588571310043 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.464075803756714 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08907588571310043, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08907588571310043, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11817341297864914, + 0.04480813443660736, + 0.26970380544662476, + 0.02709897793829441, + 0.2827395796775818, + 0.04261454939842224, + 0.10560539364814758, + 0.04381745308637619, + 0.03844282776117325, + 0.02699594385921955 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08907588571310043 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_12/index_tensor([1887, 1887])_group_12_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_12/index_tensor([1887, 1887])_group_12_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..899b227f1df9310282a87c2325ff36cd2c9b18f2 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_12/index_tensor([1887, 1887])_group_12_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "slow, smooth, low-angle, panoramic shot transports the viewer into a vast, futuristic laboratory, dimly lit and solemn. At the center of the frame, a vast, complex DNA double helix is projected holographically in mid-air. It is not a physical object, but rather a composite of pure light and data. Rendered with the ultimate fidelity of Octane, the helix appears to possess a near-solid glassy texture and crystalline clarity. Its two main strands intertwine a deep electric blue and a mysterious violet, while the connecting base pairs within pulse with a steady, soft white glow, like tiny stars. The entire structure rotates slowly around its vertical axis at a solemn and steady pace, each rotation casting a shifting brilliance through the light, its intricate internal structures and data nodes. The cool light it emits is the only main light source in the space, casting soft and dynamic reflections and spots of light on the mirror-polished black metal floor, and outlining the vague contours of the neatly arranged server arrays in the background, with only a few indicator lights flashing, creating an awe-inspiring atmosphere of tranquility and concentration brought by cutting-edge technology.", + "seed": 9311, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_12/index_1887_seed_9311_dp_24_rank_48_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.5189636820927263, + "vlm_logprob": -0.5189636820927263, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.450000023841858, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.5189636820927263, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast, futuristic laboratory with server arrays visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a holographic DNA double helix projected in mid-air at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the DNA helix appear as a composite of pure light with a glassy texture and crystalline clarity?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the two main strands of the helix colored deep electric blue and mysterious violet with white glowing base pairs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot low-angle and panoramic, with the floor being mirror-polished black metal?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1274051666259766 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12740525603294373 + ], + "logprob_reward": -2.1274051666259766, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.9999998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -2.1274051666259766, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06993862241506577, + 0.08188128471374512, + 0.2312612235546112, + 0.07918442785739899, + 0.16557449102401733, + 0.09110278636217117, + 0.08149640262126923, + 0.08377453684806824, + 0.03399819880723953, + 0.08178796619176865 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -2.1274051666259766 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast, futuristic laboratory with server arrays visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a holographic DNA double helix projected in mid-air at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the DNA helix appear as a composite of pure light with a glassy texture and crystalline clarity?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the two main strands of the helix colored deep electric blue and mysterious violet with white glowing base pairs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot low-angle and panoramic, with the floor being mirror-polished black metal?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005303598940372467 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255303382873535 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005303598940372467, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005303598940372467, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08157911151647568, + 0.08048999309539795, + 0.21657739579677582, + 0.10355465859174728, + 0.14702634513378143, + 0.09813240170478821, + 0.0781872570514679, + 0.0914258286356926, + 0.031309761106967926, + 0.0717172771692276 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005303598940372467 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast, futuristic laboratory with server arrays visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a holographic DNA double helix projected in mid-air at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the DNA helix appear as a composite of pure light with a glassy texture and crystalline clarity?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the two main strands of the helix colored deep electric blue and mysterious violet with white glowing base pairs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot low-angle and panoramic, with the floor being mirror-polished black metal?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02331392839550972 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7733139991760254 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02331392839550972, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02331392839550972, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19863960146903992, + 0.0837874710559845, + 0.14168518781661987, + 0.1081051155924797, + 0.1376124620437622, + 0.0756140798330307, + 0.06114110350608826, + 0.09854894131422043, + 0.035960640758275986, + 0.05890535190701485 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02331392839550972 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast, futuristic laboratory with server arrays visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a holographic DNA double helix projected in mid-air at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the DNA helix appear as a composite of pure light with a glassy texture and crystalline clarity?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the two main strands of the helix colored deep electric blue and mysterious violet with white glowing base pairs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot low-angle and panoramic, with the floor being mirror-polished black metal?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009798170067369938 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634798049926758 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009798170067369938, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009798170067369938, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0694357380270958, + 0.08715562522411346, + 0.17735882103443146, + 0.12588906288146973, + 0.14668071269989014, + 0.12115145474672318, + 0.054291460663080215, + 0.08198060095310211, + 0.041915666311979294, + 0.0941409021615982 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009798170067369938 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast, futuristic laboratory with server arrays visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a holographic DNA double helix projected in mid-air at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the DNA helix appear as a composite of pure light with a glassy texture and crystalline clarity?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the two main strands of the helix colored deep electric blue and mysterious violet with white glowing base pairs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot low-angle and panoramic, with the floor being mirror-polished black metal?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.42899754643440247 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.05399751663208 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.42899754643440247, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.42899754643440247, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16694721579551697, + 0.05043477565050125, + 0.09487529844045639, + 0.13269412517547607, + 0.04592802748084068, + 0.10470211505889893, + 0.08240446448326111, + 0.1294238567352295, + 0.05331941694021225, + 0.13927070796489716 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.42899754643440247 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow, smooth, low-angle, panoramic shot transports the viewer into a vast, futuristic laboratory, dimly lit and solemn. At the center of the frame, a vast, complex DNA double helix is projected holographically in mid-air. It is not a physical object, but rather a composite of pure light and data. Rendered with the ultimate fidelity of Octane, the helix appears to possess a near-solid glassy texture and crystalline clarity. Its two main strands intertwine a deep electric blue and a mysterious violet, while the connecting base pairs within pulse with a steady, soft white glow, like tiny stars. The entire structure rotates slowly around its vertical axis at a solemn and steady pace, each rotation casting a shifting brilliance through the light, its intricate internal structures and data nodes. The cool light it emits is the only main light source in the space, casting soft and dynamic reflections and spots of light on the mirror-polished black metal floor, and outlining the vague contours of the neatly arranged server arrays in the background, with only a few indicator lights flashing, creating an awe-inspiring atmosphere of tranquility and concentration brought by cutting-edge technology.", + "seed": 9312, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_12/index_1887_seed_9312_dp_24_rank_48_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.32909930860623715, + "vlm_logprob": -0.32909930860623715, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.175, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.32909930860623715, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast, futuristic laboratory with server arrays visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a holographic DNA double helix projected in mid-air at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the DNA helix appear as a composite of pure light with a glassy texture and crystalline clarity?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the two main strands of the helix colored deep electric blue and mysterious violet with white glowing base pairs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot low-angle and panoramic, with the floor being mirror-polished black metal?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3137924671173096 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.31379249691963196 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.3137924671173096, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -1.3137924671173096, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13522684574127197, + 0.11849406361579895, + 0.07206889241933823, + 0.07704651355743408, + 0.040810346603393555, + 0.19681505858898163, + 0.05438217148184776, + 0.0522318072617054, + 0.13731898367404938, + 0.11560527980327606 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.3137924671173096 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast, futuristic laboratory with server arrays visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a holographic DNA double helix projected in mid-air at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the DNA helix appear as a composite of pure light with a glassy texture and crystalline clarity?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the two main strands of the helix colored deep electric blue and mysterious violet with white glowing base pairs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot low-angle and panoramic, with the floor being mirror-polished black metal?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.001956336200237274 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.251956462860107 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.001956336200237274, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.001956336200237274, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13685062527656555, + 0.12556330859661102, + 0.08545597642660141, + 0.0778275802731514, + 0.04500839486718178, + 0.14833061397075653, + 0.0519973561167717, + 0.05691542103886604, + 0.1465054303407669, + 0.12554529309272766 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.001956336200237274 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast, futuristic laboratory with server arrays visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a holographic DNA double helix projected in mid-air at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the DNA helix appear as a composite of pure light with a glassy texture and crystalline clarity?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the two main strands of the helix colored deep electric blue and mysterious violet with white glowing base pairs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot low-angle and panoramic, with the floor being mirror-polished black metal?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007634628098458052 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.88263463973999 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007634628098458052, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007634628098458052, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12922726571559906, + 0.12193536758422852, + 0.08071405440568924, + 0.10835670679807663, + 0.03844081982970238, + 0.16422927379608154, + 0.03159179911017418, + 0.043386310338974, + 0.04335073381662369, + 0.23876769840717316 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007634628098458052 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast, futuristic laboratory with server arrays visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a holographic DNA double helix projected in mid-air at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the DNA helix appear as a composite of pure light with a glassy texture and crystalline clarity?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the two main strands of the helix colored deep electric blue and mysterious violet with white glowing base pairs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot low-angle and panoramic, with the floor being mirror-polished black metal?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00864844024181366 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.75864839553833 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00864844024181366, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00864844024181366, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08007290214300156, + 0.09064220637083054, + 0.05122246593236923, + 0.13302892446517944, + 0.061673931777477264, + 0.23429372906684875, + 0.03220104053616524, + 0.05438946932554245, + 0.12970413267612457, + 0.13277117908000946 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00864844024181366 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast, futuristic laboratory with server arrays visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a holographic DNA double helix projected in mid-air at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the DNA helix appear as a composite of pure light with a glassy texture and crystalline clarity?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the two main strands of the helix colored deep electric blue and mysterious violet with white glowing base pairs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot low-angle and panoramic, with the floor being mirror-polished black metal?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3134646713733673 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.313464641571045 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3134646713733673, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3134646713733673, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12626580893993378, + 0.027985678985714912, + 0.05402011051774025, + 0.0379202626645565, + 0.04291262850165367, + 0.2435869574546814, + 0.06137022376060486, + 0.05772482976317406, + 0.06877564638853073, + 0.2794378399848938 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3134646713733673 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow, smooth, low-angle, panoramic shot transports the viewer into a vast, futuristic laboratory, dimly lit and solemn. At the center of the frame, a vast, complex DNA double helix is projected holographically in mid-air. It is not a physical object, but rather a composite of pure light and data. Rendered with the ultimate fidelity of Octane, the helix appears to possess a near-solid glassy texture and crystalline clarity. Its two main strands intertwine a deep electric blue and a mysterious violet, while the connecting base pairs within pulse with a steady, soft white glow, like tiny stars. The entire structure rotates slowly around its vertical axis at a solemn and steady pace, each rotation casting a shifting brilliance through the light, its intricate internal structures and data nodes. The cool light it emits is the only main light source in the space, casting soft and dynamic reflections and spots of light on the mirror-polished black metal floor, and outlining the vague contours of the neatly arranged server arrays in the background, with only a few indicator lights flashing, creating an awe-inspiring atmosphere of tranquility and concentration brought by cutting-edge technology.", + "seed": 9313, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_12/index_1887_seed_9313_dp_25_rank_50_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.1022968572564423, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1022968572564423, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.95, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1022968572564423, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast, futuristic laboratory with server arrays visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a holographic DNA double helix projected in mid-air at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the DNA helix appear as a composite of pure light with a glassy texture and crystalline clarity?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the two main strands of the helix colored deep electric blue and mysterious violet with white glowing base pairs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot low-angle and panoramic, with the floor being mirror-polished black metal?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.38764941692352295 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.137649416923523 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.38764941692352295, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.38764941692352295, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15577107667922974, + 0.03973834216594696, + 0.038348738104104996, + 0.028218291699886322, + 0.41113197803497314, + 0.1344459354877472, + 0.04328416660428047, + 0.01709064468741417, + 0.09139017015695572, + 0.04058067500591278 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.38764941692352295 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast, futuristic laboratory with server arrays visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a holographic DNA double helix projected in mid-air at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the DNA helix appear as a composite of pure light with a glassy texture and crystalline clarity?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the two main strands of the helix colored deep electric blue and mysterious violet with white glowing base pairs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot low-angle and panoramic, with the floor being mirror-polished black metal?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003624657168984413 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628624439239502 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003624657168984413, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003624657168984413, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.30587613582611084, + 0.07160849869251251, + 0.04808085411787033, + 0.052669789642095566, + 0.17707794904708862, + 0.06371592730283737, + 0.05076109245419502, + 0.12171006202697754, + 0.05647863820195198, + 0.052021000534296036 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003624657168984413 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast, futuristic laboratory with server arrays visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a holographic DNA double helix projected in mid-air at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the DNA helix appear as a composite of pure light with a glassy texture and crystalline clarity?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the two main strands of the helix colored deep electric blue and mysterious violet with white glowing base pairs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot low-angle and panoramic, with the floor being mirror-polished black metal?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00409490754827857 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504095077514648 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00409490754827857, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00409490754827857, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21285000443458557, + 0.06063030660152435, + 0.04622970521450043, + 0.16347581148147583, + 0.08744359761476517, + 0.06020717695355415, + 0.12440483272075653, + 0.10157723724842072, + 0.09934650361537933, + 0.043834835290908813 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00409490754827857 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast, futuristic laboratory with server arrays visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a holographic DNA double helix projected in mid-air at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the DNA helix appear as a composite of pure light with a glassy texture and crystalline clarity?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the two main strands of the helix colored deep electric blue and mysterious violet with white glowing base pairs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot low-angle and panoramic, with the floor being mirror-polished black metal?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0031923307105898857 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.75319242477417 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0031923307105898857, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0031923307105898857, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10739611089229584, + 0.0252013448625803, + 0.033132437616586685, + 0.07305789738893509, + 0.47223812341690063, + 0.03637373074889183, + 0.04370661824941635, + 0.12172862142324448, + 0.055472809821367264, + 0.031692273914813995 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0031923307105898857 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast, futuristic laboratory with server arrays visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a holographic DNA double helix projected in mid-air at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the DNA helix appear as a composite of pure light with a glassy texture and crystalline clarity?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the two main strands of the helix colored deep electric blue and mysterious violet with white glowing base pairs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot low-angle and panoramic, with the floor being mirror-polished black metal?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11292297393083572 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2379229068756104 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11292297393083572, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11292297393083572, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24668505787849426, + 0.051893413066864014, + 0.07583194226026535, + 0.020270561799407005, + 0.2776017189025879, + 0.11065949499607086, + 0.05301382765173912, + 0.03576008602976799, + 0.05603576824069023, + 0.0722481831908226 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11292297393083572 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow, smooth, low-angle, panoramic shot transports the viewer into a vast, futuristic laboratory, dimly lit and solemn. At the center of the frame, a vast, complex DNA double helix is projected holographically in mid-air. It is not a physical object, but rather a composite of pure light and data. Rendered with the ultimate fidelity of Octane, the helix appears to possess a near-solid glassy texture and crystalline clarity. Its two main strands intertwine a deep electric blue and a mysterious violet, while the connecting base pairs within pulse with a steady, soft white glow, like tiny stars. The entire structure rotates slowly around its vertical axis at a solemn and steady pace, each rotation casting a shifting brilliance through the light, its intricate internal structures and data nodes. The cool light it emits is the only main light source in the space, casting soft and dynamic reflections and spots of light on the mirror-polished black metal floor, and outlining the vague contours of the neatly arranged server arrays in the background, with only a few indicator lights flashing, creating an awe-inspiring atmosphere of tranquility and concentration brought by cutting-edge technology.", + "seed": 9314, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_12/index_1887_seed_9314_dp_25_rank_50_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.12911280421540142, + "vlm_logprob": -0.12911280421540142, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.7, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.12911280421540142, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast, futuristic laboratory with server arrays visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a holographic DNA double helix projected in mid-air at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the DNA helix appear as a composite of pure light with a glassy texture and crystalline clarity?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the two main strands of the helix colored deep electric blue and mysterious violet with white glowing base pairs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot low-angle and panoramic, with the floor being mirror-polished black metal?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20242798328399658 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7024279832839966 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20242798328399658, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20242798328399658, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.061901845037937164, + 0.019949965178966522, + 0.04811425507068634, + 0.029661191627383232, + 0.07574429363012314, + 0.021573109552264214, + 0.628403902053833, + 0.0387568436563015, + 0.05523119866847992, + 0.020663432776927948 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20242798328399658 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast, futuristic laboratory with server arrays visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a holographic DNA double helix projected in mid-air at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the DNA helix appear as a composite of pure light with a glassy texture and crystalline clarity?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the two main strands of the helix colored deep electric blue and mysterious violet with white glowing base pairs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot low-angle and panoramic, with the floor being mirror-polished black metal?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0022093667648732662 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127209186553955 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0022093667648732662, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0022093667648732662, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03504474461078644, + 0.012405759654939175, + 0.014492426067590714, + 0.012087786570191383, + 0.08032262325286865, + 0.022756095975637436, + 0.765745222568512, + 0.01832488179206848, + 0.024047110229730606, + 0.014773360453546047 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0022093667648732662 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast, futuristic laboratory with server arrays visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a holographic DNA double helix projected in mid-air at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the DNA helix appear as a composite of pure light with a glassy texture and crystalline clarity?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the two main strands of the helix colored deep electric blue and mysterious violet with white glowing base pairs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot low-angle and panoramic, with the floor being mirror-polished black metal?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005254506133496761 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.25525426864624 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005254506133496761, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005254506133496761, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0677444115281105, + 0.05287417769432068, + 0.03823439031839371, + 0.03253282606601715, + 0.10142237693071365, + 0.026660310104489326, + 0.420566201210022, + 0.1709483116865158, + 0.06268700212240219, + 0.026330018416047096 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005254506133496761 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast, futuristic laboratory with server arrays visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a holographic DNA double helix projected in mid-air at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the DNA helix appear as a composite of pure light with a glassy texture and crystalline clarity?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the two main strands of the helix colored deep electric blue and mysterious violet with white glowing base pairs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot low-angle and panoramic, with the floor being mirror-polished black metal?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006740451790392399 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006740570068359 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006740451790392399, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006740451790392399, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03924364224076271, + 0.011194088496267796, + 0.030433528125286102, + 0.00796864740550518, + 0.5157755017280579, + 0.031069591641426086, + 0.29426559805870056, + 0.027851732447743416, + 0.025075627490878105, + 0.017121991142630577 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006740451790392399 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast, futuristic laboratory with server arrays visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a holographic DNA double helix projected in mid-air at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the DNA helix appear as a composite of pure light with a glassy texture and crystalline clarity?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the two main strands of the helix colored deep electric blue and mysterious violet with white glowing base pairs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot low-angle and panoramic, with the floor being mirror-polished black metal?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.42893171310424805 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.053931713104248 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.42893171310424805, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.42893171310424805, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.043999627232551575, + 0.028323059901595116, + 0.021849002689123154, + 0.015136398375034332, + 0.2352805733680725, + 0.027279291301965714, + 0.5637349486351013, + 0.02766355499625206, + 0.020651305094361305, + 0.016082273796200752 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.42893171310424805 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_13/index_tensor([4827, 4827])_group_13_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_13/index_tensor([4827, 4827])_group_13_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..748ada9bf30f15b93aceb3284a9389fdca410c0c --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_13/index_tensor([4827, 4827])_group_13_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "close-up shot from a fixed camera position, captured from a slightly off-center angle, depicts a story-filled moment: a slender, fair-skinned woman's hand carefully unties the ribbon tied around an old-fashioned wardrobe doorknob. The brass doorknob, engraved with a vintage pattern, has mellowed to a dark gold hue through the aging process. It sits atop a dark brown solid wood door, its surface lightly scratched and gleaming with a warm patina. A faded, pale pink silk ribbon, tied into a delicate bow, unravels as fingertips delicately grasp one end and gently, steadily pulling outward, the knot slowly unties, as if uncovering a forgotten memory. A soft, warm yellow light streams in from the side, illuminating the texture of the hand and the sheen of the ribbon, casting soft shadows across the door. The entire scene evokes a classic vintage aesthetic, with warm, desaturated tones, creating an atmosphere of tranquility, nostalgia, and a sense of secret ritual.", + "seed": 704, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_13/index_4827_seed_704_dp_26_rank_52_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.06040248200297356, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06040248200297356, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.2, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06040248200297356, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a slender, fair-skinned woman's hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hand untying a faded, pale pink silk ribbon tied in a bow around a brass doorknob?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the doorknob dark gold with a vintage engraved pattern on a dark brown, scratched wooden door?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does soft, warm yellow light stream from the side, casting shadows on the hand and ribbon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera fixed in a slightly off-center angle without moving?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009829452261328697 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.759829521179199 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009829452261328697, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009829452261328697, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10795949399471283, + 0.07674713432788849, + 0.0616665743291378, + 0.09737686067819595, + 0.0750652551651001, + 0.03255317360162735, + 0.3090311586856842, + 0.08946986496448517, + 0.026865409687161446, + 0.12326507270336151 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009829452261328697 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a slender, fair-skinned woman's hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hand untying a faded, pale pink silk ribbon tied in a bow around a brass doorknob?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the doorknob dark gold with a vintage engraved pattern on a dark brown, scratched wooden door?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does soft, warm yellow light stream from the side, casting shadows on the hand and ribbon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera fixed in a slightly off-center angle without moving?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07005293667316437 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950528621673584 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07005293667316437, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07005293667316437, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08065719902515411, + 0.11014949530363083, + 0.04723242297768593, + 0.10613563656806946, + 0.3256698250770569, + 0.042796507477760315, + 0.10671412199735641, + 0.04589638486504555, + 0.06686332821846008, + 0.06788502633571625 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07005293667316437 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a slender, fair-skinned woman's hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hand untying a faded, pale pink silk ribbon tied in a bow around a brass doorknob?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the doorknob dark gold with a vintage engraved pattern on a dark brown, scratched wooden door?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does soft, warm yellow light stream from the side, casting shadows on the hand and ribbon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera fixed in a slightly off-center angle without moving?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07901003956794739 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.579010009765625 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07901003956794739, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07901003956794739, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08976338803768158, + 0.15176410973072052, + 0.045721810311079025, + 0.0691300556063652, + 0.04164988920092583, + 0.12430918216705322, + 0.06623721867799759, + 0.18519484996795654, + 0.052710141986608505, + 0.1735193133354187 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07901003956794739 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a slender, fair-skinned woman's hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hand untying a faded, pale pink silk ribbon tied in a bow around a brass doorknob?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the doorknob dark gold with a vintage engraved pattern on a dark brown, scratched wooden door?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does soft, warm yellow light stream from the side, casting shadows on the hand and ribbon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera fixed in a slightly off-center angle without moving?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016075288876891136 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141075134277344 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016075288876891136, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016075288876891136, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10874210298061371, + 0.30076706409454346, + 0.08528609573841095, + 0.062358029186725616, + 0.08844971656799316, + 0.061821099370718, + 0.03171554580330849, + 0.13000702857971191, + 0.0378773994743824, + 0.0929759293794632 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016075288876891136 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a slender, fair-skinned woman's hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hand untying a faded, pale pink silk ribbon tied in a bow around a brass doorknob?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the doorknob dark gold with a vintage engraved pattern on a dark brown, scratched wooden door?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does soft, warm yellow light stream from the side, casting shadows on the hand and ribbon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera fixed in a slightly off-center angle without moving?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1270446926355362 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.127044677734375 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1270446926355362, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1270446926355362, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0552816167473793, + 0.05445859208703041, + 0.027643395587801933, + 0.0738125592470169, + 0.08915937691926956, + 0.06211834028363228, + 0.10917071253061295, + 0.11488796770572662, + 0.2649177610874176, + 0.14854969084262848 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1270446926355362 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up shot from a fixed camera position, captured from a slightly off-center angle, depicts a story-filled moment: a slender, fair-skinned woman's hand carefully unties the ribbon tied around an old-fashioned wardrobe doorknob. The brass doorknob, engraved with a vintage pattern, has mellowed to a dark gold hue through the aging process. It sits atop a dark brown solid wood door, its surface lightly scratched and gleaming with a warm patina. A faded, pale pink silk ribbon, tied into a delicate bow, unravels as fingertips delicately grasp one end and gently, steadily pulling outward, the knot slowly unties, as if uncovering a forgotten memory. A soft, warm yellow light streams in from the side, illuminating the texture of the hand and the sheen of the ribbon, casting soft shadows across the door. The entire scene evokes a classic vintage aesthetic, with warm, desaturated tones, creating an atmosphere of tranquility, nostalgia, and a sense of secret ritual.", + "seed": 705, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_13/index_4827_seed_705_dp_26_rank_52_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.08351897150278091, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08351897150278091, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.075, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08351897150278091, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a slender, fair-skinned woman's hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hand untying a faded, pale pink silk ribbon tied in a bow around a brass doorknob?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the doorknob dark gold with a vintage engraved pattern on a dark brown, scratched wooden door?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does soft, warm yellow light stream from the side, casting shadows on the hand and ribbon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera fixed in a slightly off-center angle without moving?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01189449243247509 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511894702911377 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01189449243247509, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01189449243247509, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.016848137602210045, + 0.017356567084789276, + 0.006836250890046358, + 0.8413837552070618, + 0.04884134978055954, + 0.007546361535787582, + 0.009804907254874706, + 0.012228518724441528, + 0.016322549432516098, + 0.022831548005342484 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01189449243247509 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a slender, fair-skinned woman's hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hand untying a faded, pale pink silk ribbon tied in a bow around a brass doorknob?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the doorknob dark gold with a vintage engraved pattern on a dark brown, scratched wooden door?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does soft, warm yellow light stream from the side, casting shadows on the hand and ribbon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera fixed in a slightly off-center angle without moving?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029832802712917328 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298328399658203 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029832802712917328, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029832802712917328, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0780324637889862, + 0.0393095426261425, + 0.044220034033060074, + 0.5882718563079834, + 0.048492182046175, + 0.01827497035264969, + 0.0177602581679821, + 0.03278331458568573, + 0.064490407705307, + 0.06836492568254471 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029832802712917328 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a slender, fair-skinned woman's hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hand untying a faded, pale pink silk ribbon tied in a bow around a brass doorknob?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the doorknob dark gold with a vintage engraved pattern on a dark brown, scratched wooden door?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does soft, warm yellow light stream from the side, casting shadows on the hand and ribbon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera fixed in a slightly off-center angle without moving?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17989832162857056 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8048982620239258 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17989832162857056, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17989832162857056, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08973027020692825, + 0.03370264917612076, + 0.030922655016183853, + 0.6121615171432495, + 0.045331668108701706, + 0.010434894822537899, + 0.021632907912135124, + 0.024880114942789078, + 0.038503844290971756, + 0.09269951283931732 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17989832162857056 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a slender, fair-skinned woman's hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hand untying a faded, pale pink silk ribbon tied in a bow around a brass doorknob?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the doorknob dark gold with a vintage engraved pattern on a dark brown, scratched wooden door?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does soft, warm yellow light stream from the side, casting shadows on the hand and ribbon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera fixed in a slightly off-center angle without moving?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016077401116490364 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141077518463135 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016077401116490364, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016077401116490364, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03389311954379082, + 0.02305028773844242, + 0.009825681336224079, + 0.7310236692428589, + 0.014489169232547283, + 0.08006113022565842, + 0.05826384574174881, + 0.016129087656736374, + 0.019876036792993546, + 0.01338798739016056 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016077401116490364 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a slender, fair-skinned woman's hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hand untying a faded, pale pink silk ribbon tied in a bow around a brass doorknob?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the doorknob dark gold with a vintage engraved pattern on a dark brown, scratched wooden door?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does soft, warm yellow light stream from the side, casting shadows on the hand and ribbon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera fixed in a slightly off-center angle without moving?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17989183962345123 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.80489182472229 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17989183962345123, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17989183962345123, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05614237114787102, + 0.05282856523990631, + 0.010982920415699482, + 0.542261004447937, + 0.03480883687734604, + 0.027644101530313492, + 0.03341877833008766, + 0.04081472381949425, + 0.15024583041667938, + 0.05085282772779465 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17989183962345123 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up shot from a fixed camera position, captured from a slightly off-center angle, depicts a story-filled moment: a slender, fair-skinned woman's hand carefully unties the ribbon tied around an old-fashioned wardrobe doorknob. The brass doorknob, engraved with a vintage pattern, has mellowed to a dark gold hue through the aging process. It sits atop a dark brown solid wood door, its surface lightly scratched and gleaming with a warm patina. A faded, pale pink silk ribbon, tied into a delicate bow, unravels as fingertips delicately grasp one end and gently, steadily pulling outward, the knot slowly unties, as if uncovering a forgotten memory. A soft, warm yellow light streams in from the side, illuminating the texture of the hand and the sheen of the ribbon, casting soft shadows across the door. The entire scene evokes a classic vintage aesthetic, with warm, desaturated tones, creating an atmosphere of tranquility, nostalgia, and a sense of secret ritual.", + "seed": 706, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_13/index_4827_seed_706_dp_27_rank_54_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.055448518693447114, + "vlm_logprob": -0.055448518693447114, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.425, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.055448518693447114, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a slender, fair-skinned woman's hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hand untying a faded, pale pink silk ribbon tied in a bow around a brass doorknob?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the doorknob dark gold with a vintage engraved pattern on a dark brown, scratched wooden door?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does soft, warm yellow light stream from the side, casting shadows on the hand and ribbon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera fixed in a slightly off-center angle without moving?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011899793520569801 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511899948120117 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011899793520569801, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011899793520569801, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1486411690711975, + 0.04604225233197212, + 0.04017368331551552, + 0.028765223920345306, + 0.040880922228097916, + 0.34744635224342346, + 0.035666052252054214, + 0.1378716379404068, + 0.10372759401798248, + 0.07078510522842407 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011899793520569801 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a slender, fair-skinned woman's hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hand untying a faded, pale pink silk ribbon tied in a bow around a brass doorknob?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the doorknob dark gold with a vintage engraved pattern on a dark brown, scratched wooden door?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does soft, warm yellow light stream from the side, casting shadows on the hand and ribbon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera fixed in a slightly off-center angle without moving?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0431046187877655 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168104648590088 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0431046187877655, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0431046187877655, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23393207788467407, + 0.06653046607971191, + 0.0458233579993248, + 0.03705299645662308, + 0.052150700241327286, + 0.08742295950651169, + 0.09592049568891525, + 0.045477014034986496, + 0.2964843213558197, + 0.03920565918087959 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0431046187877655 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a slender, fair-skinned woman's hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hand untying a faded, pale pink silk ribbon tied in a bow around a brass doorknob?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the doorknob dark gold with a vintage engraved pattern on a dark brown, scratched wooden door?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does soft, warm yellow light stream from the side, casting shadows on the hand and ribbon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera fixed in a slightly off-center angle without moving?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02981058694422245 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529810667037964 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02981058694422245, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02981058694422245, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13105300068855286, + 0.07239317893981934, + 0.13396045565605164, + 0.02829093486070633, + 0.09398555755615234, + 0.32646745443344116, + 0.026506226509809494, + 0.022393848747015, + 0.12273109704256058, + 0.042218167334795 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02981058694422245 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a slender, fair-skinned woman's hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hand untying a faded, pale pink silk ribbon tied in a bow around a brass doorknob?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the doorknob dark gold with a vintage engraved pattern on a dark brown, scratched wooden door?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does soft, warm yellow light stream from the side, casting shadows on the hand and ribbon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera fixed in a slightly off-center angle without moving?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012543711811304092 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387543678283691 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012543711811304092, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012543711811304092, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10035641491413116, + 0.09844806790351868, + 0.14893211424350739, + 0.0262923426926136, + 0.08654087781906128, + 0.07616159319877625, + 0.2535007894039154, + 0.09324432164430618, + 0.08045312762260437, + 0.03607036545872688 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012543711811304092 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a slender, fair-skinned woman's hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hand untying a faded, pale pink silk ribbon tied in a bow around a brass doorknob?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the doorknob dark gold with a vintage engraved pattern on a dark brown, scratched wooden door?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does soft, warm yellow light stream from the side, casting shadows on the hand and ribbon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera fixed in a slightly off-center angle without moving?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17988388240337372 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8048838376998901 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17988388240337372, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17988388240337372, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04747741296887398, + 0.04205447807908058, + 0.04667513817548752, + 0.08920471370220184, + 0.30558478832244873, + 0.13738223910331726, + 0.028356187045574188, + 0.030178843066096306, + 0.12795205414295197, + 0.14513421058654785 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17988388240337372 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up shot from a fixed camera position, captured from a slightly off-center angle, depicts a story-filled moment: a slender, fair-skinned woman's hand carefully unties the ribbon tied around an old-fashioned wardrobe doorknob. The brass doorknob, engraved with a vintage pattern, has mellowed to a dark gold hue through the aging process. It sits atop a dark brown solid wood door, its surface lightly scratched and gleaming with a warm patina. A faded, pale pink silk ribbon, tied into a delicate bow, unravels as fingertips delicately grasp one end and gently, steadily pulling outward, the knot slowly unties, as if uncovering a forgotten memory. A soft, warm yellow light streams in from the side, illuminating the texture of the hand and the sheen of the ribbon, casting soft shadows across the door. The entire scene evokes a classic vintage aesthetic, with warm, desaturated tones, creating an atmosphere of tranquility, nostalgia, and a sense of secret ritual.", + "seed": 707, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_13/index_4827_seed_707_dp_27_rank_54_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.042262046784162524, + "vlm_logprob": -0.042262046784162524, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.3, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.042262046784162524, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a slender, fair-skinned woman's hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hand untying a faded, pale pink silk ribbon tied in a bow around a brass doorknob?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the doorknob dark gold with a vintage engraved pattern on a dark brown, scratched wooden door?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does soft, warm yellow light stream from the side, casting shadows on the hand and ribbon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera fixed in a slightly off-center angle without moving?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01726057380437851 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.142260551452637 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01726057380437851, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01726057380437851, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3097340762615204, + 0.05220099911093712, + 0.035042326897382736, + 0.1591133028268814, + 0.036038536578416824, + 0.041603781282901764, + 0.16903255879878998, + 0.07304229587316513, + 0.07375810295343399, + 0.05043409764766693 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01726057380437851 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a slender, fair-skinned woman's hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hand untying a faded, pale pink silk ribbon tied in a bow around a brass doorknob?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the doorknob dark gold with a vintage engraved pattern on a dark brown, scratched wooden door?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does soft, warm yellow light stream from the side, casting shadows on the hand and ribbon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera fixed in a slightly off-center angle without moving?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04310736060142517 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168107271194458 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04310736060142517, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04310736060142517, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13390478491783142, + 0.043941181153059006, + 0.1295730024576187, + 0.16540272533893585, + 0.042724303901195526, + 0.08835312724113464, + 0.05051533505320549, + 0.2116726189851761, + 0.06644067168235779, + 0.06747230142354965 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04310736060142517 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a slender, fair-skinned woman's hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hand untying a faded, pale pink silk ribbon tied in a bow around a brass doorknob?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the doorknob dark gold with a vintage engraved pattern on a dark brown, scratched wooden door?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does soft, warm yellow light stream from the side, casting shadows on the hand and ribbon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera fixed in a slightly off-center angle without moving?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.048660341650247574 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486602783203125 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.048660341650247574, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.048660341650247574, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0850502997636795, + 0.049733806401491165, + 0.05245375633239746, + 0.06213531270623207, + 0.0778888463973999, + 0.1634432077407837, + 0.2547221779823303, + 0.15466350317001343, + 0.049317460507154465, + 0.050591565668582916 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.048660341650247574 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a slender, fair-skinned woman's hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hand untying a faded, pale pink silk ribbon tied in a bow around a brass doorknob?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the doorknob dark gold with a vintage engraved pattern on a dark brown, scratched wooden door?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does soft, warm yellow light stream from the side, casting shadows on the hand and ribbon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera fixed in a slightly off-center angle without moving?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023298904299736023 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773298978805542 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023298904299736023, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023298904299736023, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08082854002714157, + 0.08465755730867386, + 0.14141589403152466, + 0.09202694892883301, + 0.02838565595448017, + 0.08273360878229141, + 0.30272161960601807, + 0.09395530819892883, + 0.03472093492746353, + 0.05855390056967735 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 2, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023298904299736023 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a slender, fair-skinned woman's hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hand untying a faded, pale pink silk ribbon tied in a bow around a brass doorknob?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the doorknob dark gold with a vintage engraved pattern on a dark brown, scratched wooden door?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does soft, warm yellow light stream from the side, casting shadows on the hand and ribbon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera fixed in a slightly off-center angle without moving?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07898305356502533 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5789830684661865 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07898305356502533, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07898305356502533, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09297557920217514, + 0.1155724748969078, + 0.10655201971530914, + 0.12754309177398682, + 0.05742013081908226, + 0.030807506293058395, + 0.2898043394088745, + 0.08987023681402206, + 0.0535181388258934, + 0.03593645617365837 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07898305356502533 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_14/index_tensor([4270, 4270])_group_14_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_14/index_tensor([4270, 4270])_group_14_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..f8c24aff14564c05f45345bb9a12a88e33f69606 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_14/index_tensor([4270, 4270])_group_14_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "majestic aerial drone shot slowly pulls back to reveal a boundless, swirling sea of clouds, stained by the golden light of dawn. A massive golden dragon, its slender, sinuous body clad in intricately carved golden armor, gleams with a brilliant metallic sheen in the glow of the rising sun. With a deliberate yet powerful gesture, it gracefully twists and turns above the thick, cotton-like clouds. Its majestic head, long whiskers swaying on the air currents, its piercing amber eyes reveal ancient wisdom and vigilance. The dragon's enormous tail occasionally sweeps gently across the cloud tops, stirring up ripples of mist as if surveying its sacred territory. Thousands of golden rays penetrate the constantly undulating and gathering clouds, rimming the edges of the clouds with a brilliant golden rim and casting a vast, slowly shifting shadow across the sea of clouds below. The whole picture presents a sacred, solemn and epic tranquil atmosphere, with brilliant gold and pure white as the main colors, creating an otherworldly visual spectacle.", + "seed": 32689, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_14/index_4270_seed_32689_dp_28_rank_56_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.027068316971417518, + "vlm_logprob": -0.027068316971417518, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.825, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.027068316971417518, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive golden dragon with slender, sinuous body and intricately carved golden armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the dragon performing a twisting and turning motion above a thick, cotton-like sea of clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature thousands of golden rays penetrating the clouds and rimming their edges with a brilliant golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot an aerial view that slowly pulls back to reveal the boundless scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the dominant colors in the video brilliant gold and pure white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.021139780059456825 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8961398601531982 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.021139780059456825, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.021139780059456825, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13450901210308075, + 0.08002788573503494, + 0.031532298773527145, + 0.014237313531339169, + 0.03309263661503792, + 0.024029484018683434, + 0.6085716485977173, + 0.021882928907871246, + 0.036062173545360565, + 0.016054688021540642 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.021139780059456825 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive golden dragon with slender, sinuous body and intricately carved golden armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the dragon performing a twisting and turning motion above a thick, cotton-like sea of clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature thousands of golden rays penetrating the clouds and rimming their edges with a brilliant golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot an aerial view that slowly pulls back to reveal the boundless scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the dominant colors in the video brilliant gold and pure white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0022038952447474003 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127203941345215 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0022038952447474003, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0022038952447474003, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11393992602825165, + 0.10496851056814194, + 0.06363949179649353, + 0.02588370442390442, + 0.05010741576552391, + 0.05027663707733154, + 0.5147678256034851, + 0.01987101137638092, + 0.03161375969648361, + 0.0249317716807127 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0022038952447474003 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive golden dragon with slender, sinuous body and intricately carved golden armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the dragon performing a twisting and turning motion above a thick, cotton-like sea of clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature thousands of golden rays penetrating the clouds and rimming their edges with a brilliant golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot an aerial view that slowly pulls back to reveal the boundless scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the dominant colors in the video brilliant gold and pure white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011073797941207886 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511073589324951 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011073797941207886, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011073797941207886, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18871496617794037, + 0.12039367109537125, + 0.035959210246801376, + 0.05503746494650841, + 0.18153291940689087, + 0.029746366664767265, + 0.2704436779022217, + 0.0462288074195385, + 0.04022756591439247, + 0.031715359538793564 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011073797941207886 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive golden dragon with slender, sinuous body and intricately carved golden armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the dragon performing a twisting and turning motion above a thick, cotton-like sea of clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature thousands of golden rays penetrating the clouds and rimming their edges with a brilliant golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot an aerial view that slowly pulls back to reveal the boundless scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the dominant colors in the video brilliant gold and pure white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10028940439224243 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3502893447875977 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10028940439224243, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10028940439224243, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10320018231868744, + 0.23104584217071533, + 0.07134171575307846, + 0.11415033042430878, + 0.04075828567147255, + 0.08058423548936844, + 0.16273826360702515, + 0.06888411194086075, + 0.0477491095662117, + 0.07954790443181992 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 6, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10028940439224243 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive golden dragon with slender, sinuous body and intricately carved golden armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the dragon performing a twisting and turning motion above a thick, cotton-like sea of clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature thousands of golden rays penetrating the clouds and rimming their edges with a brilliant golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot an aerial view that slowly pulls back to reveal the boundless scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the dominant colors in the video brilliant gold and pure white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0006347072194330394 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.375634670257568 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0006347072194330394, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0006347072194330394, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1965707242488861, + 0.08734982460737228, + 0.04782630875706673, + 0.020151594653725624, + 0.04792892932891846, + 0.03680633753538132, + 0.40940821170806885, + 0.07681450992822647, + 0.035153139382600784, + 0.04199044033885002 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0006347072194330394 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "majestic aerial drone shot slowly pulls back to reveal a boundless, swirling sea of clouds, stained by the golden light of dawn. A massive golden dragon, its slender, sinuous body clad in intricately carved golden armor, gleams with a brilliant metallic sheen in the glow of the rising sun. With a deliberate yet powerful gesture, it gracefully twists and turns above the thick, cotton-like clouds. Its majestic head, long whiskers swaying on the air currents, its piercing amber eyes reveal ancient wisdom and vigilance. The dragon's enormous tail occasionally sweeps gently across the cloud tops, stirring up ripples of mist as if surveying its sacred territory. Thousands of golden rays penetrate the constantly undulating and gathering clouds, rimming the edges of the clouds with a brilliant golden rim and casting a vast, slowly shifting shadow across the sea of clouds below. The whole picture presents a sacred, solemn and epic tranquil atmosphere, with brilliant gold and pure white as the main colors, creating an otherworldly visual spectacle.", + "seed": 32690, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_14/index_4270_seed_32690_dp_28_rank_56_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.017086366028524935, + "vlm_logprob": -0.017086366028524935, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.85, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.017086366028524935, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive golden dragon with slender, sinuous body and intricately carved golden armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the dragon performing a twisting and turning motion above a thick, cotton-like sea of clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature thousands of golden rays penetrating the clouds and rimming their edges with a brilliant golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot an aerial view that slowly pulls back to reveal the boundless scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the dominant colors in the video brilliant gold and pure white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006444268394261599 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.131444454193115 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006444268394261599, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006444268394261599, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06493981182575226, + 0.1843290776014328, + 0.055773988366127014, + 0.02392507530748844, + 0.046578437089920044, + 0.12419537454843521, + 0.05624059587717056, + 0.09206881374120712, + 0.25052550435066223, + 0.10142329335212708 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006444268394261599 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive golden dragon with slender, sinuous body and intricately carved golden armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the dragon performing a twisting and turning motion above a thick, cotton-like sea of clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature thousands of golden rays penetrating the clouds and rimming their edges with a brilliant golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot an aerial view that slowly pulls back to reveal the boundless scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the dominant colors in the video brilliant gold and pure white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0015185264637693763 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.501518726348877 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0015185264637693763, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0015185264637693763, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07989828288555145, + 0.15822148323059082, + 0.07455769926309586, + 0.07576902955770493, + 0.06212814152240753, + 0.24175859987735748, + 0.07031778991222382, + 0.06870194524526596, + 0.12313004583120346, + 0.04551694914698601 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0015185264637693763 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive golden dragon with slender, sinuous body and intricately carved golden armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the dragon performing a twisting and turning motion above a thick, cotton-like sea of clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature thousands of golden rays penetrating the clouds and rimming their edges with a brilliant golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot an aerial view that slowly pulls back to reveal the boundless scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the dominant colors in the video brilliant gold and pure white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02634189836680889 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513419151306152 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02634189836680889, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02634189836680889, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0731087252497673, + 0.07718656212091446, + 0.034751273691654205, + 0.027835624292492867, + 0.02751673199236393, + 0.5915213227272034, + 0.026770059019327164, + 0.057019054889678955, + 0.0620269700884819, + 0.022263629361987114 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02634189836680889 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive golden dragon with slender, sinuous body and intricately carved golden armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the dragon performing a twisting and turning motion above a thick, cotton-like sea of clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature thousands of golden rays penetrating the clouds and rimming their edges with a brilliant golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot an aerial view that slowly pulls back to reveal the boundless scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the dominant colors in the video brilliant gold and pure white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.048638880252838135 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486388206481934 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.048638880252838135, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.048638880252838135, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06737596541643143, + 0.2005387842655182, + 0.1585322618484497, + 0.07570074498653412, + 0.13741105794906616, + 0.14897967875003815, + 0.0512029193341732, + 0.038477011024951935, + 0.0739329606294632, + 0.04784867540001869 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.048638880252838135 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive golden dragon with slender, sinuous body and intricately carved golden armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the dragon performing a twisting and turning motion above a thick, cotton-like sea of clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature thousands of golden rays penetrating the clouds and rimming their edges with a brilliant golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot an aerial view that slowly pulls back to reveal the boundless scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the dominant colors in the video brilliant gold and pure white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0024882566649466753 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002488136291504 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0024882566649466753, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0024882566649466753, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16474545001983643, + 0.12031301856040955, + 0.08599509298801422, + 0.04894495755434036, + 0.05846060812473297, + 0.19770236313343048, + 0.06558246165513992, + 0.12212210148572922, + 0.045810237526893616, + 0.09032365679740906 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0024882566649466753 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "majestic aerial drone shot slowly pulls back to reveal a boundless, swirling sea of clouds, stained by the golden light of dawn. A massive golden dragon, its slender, sinuous body clad in intricately carved golden armor, gleams with a brilliant metallic sheen in the glow of the rising sun. With a deliberate yet powerful gesture, it gracefully twists and turns above the thick, cotton-like clouds. Its majestic head, long whiskers swaying on the air currents, its piercing amber eyes reveal ancient wisdom and vigilance. The dragon's enormous tail occasionally sweeps gently across the cloud tops, stirring up ripples of mist as if surveying its sacred territory. Thousands of golden rays penetrate the constantly undulating and gathering clouds, rimming the edges of the clouds with a brilliant golden rim and casting a vast, slowly shifting shadow across the sea of clouds below. The whole picture presents a sacred, solemn and epic tranquil atmosphere, with brilliant gold and pure white as the main colors, creating an otherworldly visual spectacle.", + "seed": 32691, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_14/index_4270_seed_32691_dp_29_rank_58_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.01078671591822058, + "vlm_logprob": -0.01078671591822058, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 5.225, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.01078671591822058, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive golden dragon with slender, sinuous body and intricately carved golden armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the dragon performing a twisting and turning motion above a thick, cotton-like sea of clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature thousands of golden rays penetrating the clouds and rimming their edges with a brilliant golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot an aerial view that slowly pulls back to reveal the boundless scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the dominant colors in the video brilliant gold and pure white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0216217003762722 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8966217041015625 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0216217003762722, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0216217003762722, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16119861602783203, + 0.04141002520918846, + 0.18620584905147552, + 0.06644097715616226, + 0.10849381983280182, + 0.15947173535823822, + 0.05125132575631142, + 0.04616977274417877, + 0.07244174182415009, + 0.10691610723733902 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0216217003762722 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive golden dragon with slender, sinuous body and intricately carved golden armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the dragon performing a twisting and turning motion above a thick, cotton-like sea of clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature thousands of golden rays penetrating the clouds and rimming their edges with a brilliant golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot an aerial view that slowly pulls back to reveal the boundless scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the dominant colors in the video brilliant gold and pure white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0013405631761997938 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.626340389251709 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0013405631761997938, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0013405631761997938, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11806019395589828, + 0.04309115558862686, + 0.1204795315861702, + 0.07455623894929886, + 0.07431145757436752, + 0.25164851546287537, + 0.0632464662194252, + 0.07275941222906113, + 0.09439921379089355, + 0.08744778484106064 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0013405631761997938 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive golden dragon with slender, sinuous body and intricately carved golden armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the dragon performing a twisting and turning motion above a thick, cotton-like sea of clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature thousands of golden rays penetrating the clouds and rimming their edges with a brilliant golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot an aerial view that slowly pulls back to reveal the boundless scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the dominant colors in the video brilliant gold and pure white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014193067327141762 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264193058013916 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014193067327141762, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014193067327141762, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16652360558509827, + 0.0817987248301506, + 0.10309336334466934, + 0.06209640949964523, + 0.1400318145751953, + 0.14109280705451965, + 0.08320766687393188, + 0.07814834266901016, + 0.07356336712837219, + 0.07044386863708496 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014193067327141762 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive golden dragon with slender, sinuous body and intricately carved golden armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the dragon performing a twisting and turning motion above a thick, cotton-like sea of clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature thousands of golden rays penetrating the clouds and rimming their edges with a brilliant golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot an aerial view that slowly pulls back to reveal the boundless scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the dominant colors in the video brilliant gold and pure white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01606050878763199 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.1410603523254395 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01606050878763199, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01606050878763199, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17277811467647552, + 0.06844808161258698, + 0.14996539056301117, + 0.0729341134428978, + 0.05239620804786682, + 0.17813760042190552, + 0.07534541189670563, + 0.030103670433163643, + 0.02891029417514801, + 0.17098109424114227 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01606050878763199 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive golden dragon with slender, sinuous body and intricately carved golden armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the dragon performing a twisting and turning motion above a thick, cotton-like sea of clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature thousands of golden rays penetrating the clouds and rimming their edges with a brilliant golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot an aerial view that slowly pulls back to reveal the boundless scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the dominant colors in the video brilliant gold and pure white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0007177399238571525 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.250717639923096 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0007177399238571525, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0007177399238571525, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06118486449122429, + 0.057403095066547394, + 0.059527959674596786, + 0.0584871731698513, + 0.06279413402080536, + 0.07193432748317719, + 0.08046368509531021, + 0.27654188871383667, + 0.19320471584796906, + 0.07845810800790787 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0007177399238571525 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "majestic aerial drone shot slowly pulls back to reveal a boundless, swirling sea of clouds, stained by the golden light of dawn. A massive golden dragon, its slender, sinuous body clad in intricately carved golden armor, gleams with a brilliant metallic sheen in the glow of the rising sun. With a deliberate yet powerful gesture, it gracefully twists and turns above the thick, cotton-like clouds. Its majestic head, long whiskers swaying on the air currents, its piercing amber eyes reveal ancient wisdom and vigilance. The dragon's enormous tail occasionally sweeps gently across the cloud tops, stirring up ripples of mist as if surveying its sacred territory. Thousands of golden rays penetrate the constantly undulating and gathering clouds, rimming the edges of the clouds with a brilliant golden rim and casting a vast, slowly shifting shadow across the sea of clouds below. The whole picture presents a sacred, solemn and epic tranquil atmosphere, with brilliant gold and pure white as the main colors, creating an otherworldly visual spectacle.", + "seed": 32692, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_14/index_4270_seed_32692_dp_29_rank_58_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.012471457326319069, + "vlm_logprob": -0.012471457326319069, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.95, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.012471457326319069, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive golden dragon with slender, sinuous body and intricately carved golden armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the dragon performing a twisting and turning motion above a thick, cotton-like sea of clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature thousands of golden rays penetrating the clouds and rimming their edges with a brilliant golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot an aerial view that slowly pulls back to reveal the boundless scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the dominant colors in the video brilliant gold and pure white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02383984997868538 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7738399505615234 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02383984997868538, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02383984997868538, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1541791409254074, + 0.05348941683769226, + 0.13328920304775238, + 0.11136514693498611, + 0.0452079102396965, + 0.12761233747005463, + 0.02386077307164669, + 0.05310897156596184, + 0.15445572137832642, + 0.14343143999576569 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02383984997868538 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive golden dragon with slender, sinuous body and intricately carved golden armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the dragon performing a twisting and turning motion above a thick, cotton-like sea of clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature thousands of golden rays penetrating the clouds and rimming their edges with a brilliant golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot an aerial view that slowly pulls back to reveal the boundless scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the dominant colors in the video brilliant gold and pure white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0028246049769222736 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877824783325195 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0028246049769222736, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0028246049769222736, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18910281360149384, + 0.06412146240472794, + 0.09159377217292786, + 0.0989162027835846, + 0.06973333656787872, + 0.057544589042663574, + 0.09260041266679764, + 0.08255460858345032, + 0.1619795262813568, + 0.09185334295034409 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0028246049769222736 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive golden dragon with slender, sinuous body and intricately carved golden armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the dragon performing a twisting and turning motion above a thick, cotton-like sea of clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature thousands of golden rays penetrating the clouds and rimming their edges with a brilliant golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot an aerial view that slowly pulls back to reveal the boundless scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the dominant colors in the video brilliant gold and pure white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014194594696164131 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264194488525391 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014194594696164131, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014194594696164131, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16335240006446838, + 0.10861697793006897, + 0.14878465235233307, + 0.12604139745235443, + 0.050989795476198196, + 0.10752851516008377, + 0.03993871435523033, + 0.07137900590896606, + 0.08853360265493393, + 0.09483499079942703 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014194594696164131 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive golden dragon with slender, sinuous body and intricately carved golden armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the dragon performing a twisting and turning motion above a thick, cotton-like sea of clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature thousands of golden rays penetrating the clouds and rimming their edges with a brilliant golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot an aerial view that slowly pulls back to reveal the boundless scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the dominant colors in the video brilliant gold and pure white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02057693526148796 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955769538879395 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02057693526148796, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02057693526148796, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10996246337890625, + 0.05855797603726387, + 0.2722283899784088, + 0.028909701853990555, + 0.06842094659805298, + 0.13532774150371552, + 0.1097833439707756, + 0.1279173046350479, + 0.03542306274175644, + 0.053469158709049225 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02057693526148796 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive golden dragon with slender, sinuous body and intricately carved golden armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the dragon performing a twisting and turning motion above a thick, cotton-like sea of clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature thousands of golden rays penetrating the clouds and rimming their edges with a brilliant golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot an aerial view that slowly pulls back to reveal the boundless scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the dominant colors in the video brilliant gold and pure white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0009213017183355987 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.000921249389648 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0009213017183355987, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0009213017183355987, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15543505549430847, + 0.06976231932640076, + 0.05725393816828728, + 0.0552000068128109, + 0.08106662333011627, + 0.051572032272815704, + 0.24919258058071136, + 0.05531087517738342, + 0.12001220136880875, + 0.10519437491893768 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0009213017183355987 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_15/index_tensor([1701, 1701])_group_15_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_15/index_tensor([1701, 1701])_group_15_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..e110b7931509c367cb7fece4be7d1a1ee6105d43 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_15/index_tensor([1701, 1701])_group_15_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "shaky, low-angle, handheld tracking shot then rapidly moves upward, capturing the swift movements of a man shrouded in darkness. He is clad in a tight, dark tactical suit, the hood pulled low, nearly obscuring half his face, leaving only a glimpse of his taut jawline. Under the cold moonlight, he scales a weathered, ancient city wall. The massive, bluish-gray masonry is covered in moss and cracks from age. His movements are lightning-fast, his tactical-gloved hands grasping the cracks and protrusions of the masonry with precision and force, his feet alternately tapping the vertical wall, his body climbing like a nimble gecko, unhesitatingly. The camera joltes with each of his exertions, creating a powerful sense of presence and tension. Finally, with a sudden pull-up, he turned over silently and jumped onto the wide battlements on the top of the wall. The whole process was completed in deep blue-black and cold silver-gray tones, full of mystery and power.", + "seed": 32660, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_15/index_1701_seed_32660_dp_30_rank_60_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.03388544153422117, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03388544153422117, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.5, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03388544153422117, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a man wearing a tight, dark tactical suit with a hood pulled low?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man scaling a weathered, ancient city wall made of bluish-gray masonry covered in moss and cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man climb using lightning-fast movements with tactical-gloved hands grasping cracks and feet tapping the wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a shaky, low-angle handheld tracking shot and then rapidly move upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the man jumping onto the wide battlements at the top of the wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03425395488739014 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4092540740966797 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03425395488739014, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03425395488739014, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2158440202474594, + 0.08298254013061523, + 0.24905382096767426, + 0.08926278352737427, + 0.12044916301965714, + 0.06685458868741989, + 0.043674618005752563, + 0.03761687129735947, + 0.03959239646792412, + 0.05466923490166664 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03425395488739014 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a man wearing a tight, dark tactical suit with a hood pulled low?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man scaling a weathered, ancient city wall made of bluish-gray masonry covered in moss and cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man climb using lightning-fast movements with tactical-gloved hands grasping cracks and feet tapping the wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a shaky, low-angle handheld tracking shot and then rapidly move upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the man jumping onto the wide battlements at the top of the wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009785539470613003 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.6347856521606445 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009785539470613003, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009785539470613003, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21188794076442719, + 0.035367202013731, + 0.1475236564874649, + 0.08000320941209793, + 0.2266640067100525, + 0.08375590294599533, + 0.09006776660680771, + 0.037400949746370316, + 0.04804878309369087, + 0.03928055614233017 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009785539470613003 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a man wearing a tight, dark tactical suit with a hood pulled low?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man scaling a weathered, ancient city wall made of bluish-gray masonry covered in moss and cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man climb using lightning-fast movements with tactical-gloved hands grasping cracks and feet tapping the wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a shaky, low-angle handheld tracking shot and then rapidly move upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the man jumping onto the wide battlements at the top of the wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0486522801220417 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048652172088623 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0486522801220417, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0486522801220417, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3236466944217682, + 0.09913806617259979, + 0.0791761502623558, + 0.06552930921316147, + 0.14216843247413635, + 0.15148542821407318, + 0.06784185022115707, + 0.0295092836022377, + 0.020555661991238594, + 0.020949140191078186 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0486522801220417 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a man wearing a tight, dark tactical suit with a hood pulled low?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man scaling a weathered, ancient city wall made of bluish-gray masonry covered in moss and cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man climb using lightning-fast movements with tactical-gloved hands grasping cracks and feet tapping the wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a shaky, low-angle handheld tracking shot and then rapidly move upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the man jumping onto the wide battlements at the top of the wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04305289313197136 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168052911758423 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04305289313197136, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04305289313197136, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17062877118587494, + 0.1288069486618042, + 0.11074251681566238, + 0.07839585840702057, + 0.08151322603225708, + 0.08939435333013535, + 0.08425989747047424, + 0.14709478616714478, + 0.057394351810216904, + 0.05176925286650658 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04305289313197136 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a man wearing a tight, dark tactical suit with a hood pulled low?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man scaling a weathered, ancient city wall made of bluish-gray masonry covered in moss and cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man climb using lightning-fast movements with tactical-gloved hands grasping cracks and feet tapping the wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a shaky, low-angle handheld tracking shot and then rapidly move upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the man jumping onto the wide battlements at the top of the wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03368254005908966 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4086825847625732 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03368254005908966, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03368254005908966, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13373899459838867, + 0.052547696977853775, + 0.07574789226055145, + 0.0735875815153122, + 0.07444099336862564, + 0.11658944189548492, + 0.049660343676805496, + 0.07856569439172745, + 0.06596728414297104, + 0.27915412187576294 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03368254005908966 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "shaky, low-angle, handheld tracking shot then rapidly moves upward, capturing the swift movements of a man shrouded in darkness. He is clad in a tight, dark tactical suit, the hood pulled low, nearly obscuring half his face, leaving only a glimpse of his taut jawline. Under the cold moonlight, he scales a weathered, ancient city wall. The massive, bluish-gray masonry is covered in moss and cracks from age. His movements are lightning-fast, his tactical-gloved hands grasping the cracks and protrusions of the masonry with precision and force, his feet alternately tapping the vertical wall, his body climbing like a nimble gecko, unhesitatingly. The camera joltes with each of his exertions, creating a powerful sense of presence and tension. Finally, with a sudden pull-up, he turned over silently and jumped onto the wide battlements on the top of the wall. The whole process was completed in deep blue-black and cold silver-gray tones, full of mystery and power.", + "seed": 32661, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_15/index_1701_seed_32661_dp_30_rank_60_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.11788731794804334, + "vlm_logprob": -0.11788731794804334, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.875, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.11788731794804334, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a man wearing a tight, dark tactical suit with a hood pulled low?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man scaling a weathered, ancient city wall made of bluish-gray masonry covered in moss and cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man climb using lightning-fast movements with tactical-gloved hands grasping cracks and feet tapping the wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a shaky, low-angle handheld tracking shot and then rapidly move upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the man jumping onto the wide battlements at the top of the wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06265623867511749 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8126561641693115 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06265623867511749, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06265623867511749, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25146761536598206, + 0.07249033451080322, + 0.37152019143104553, + 0.033459749072790146, + 0.021196266636252403, + 0.02587328851222992, + 0.06897666305303574, + 0.029775802046060562, + 0.04784277826547623, + 0.07739726454019547 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06265623867511749 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a man wearing a tight, dark tactical suit with a hood pulled low?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man scaling a weathered, ancient city wall made of bluish-gray masonry covered in moss and cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man climb using lightning-fast movements with tactical-gloved hands grasping cracks and feet tapping the wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a shaky, low-angle handheld tracking shot and then rapidly move upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the man jumping onto the wide battlements at the top of the wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008646431379020214 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758646488189697 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008646431379020214, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008646431379020214, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15993282198905945, + 0.03500030189752579, + 0.42903855443000793, + 0.04316147044301033, + 0.02112581953406334, + 0.04530465230345726, + 0.06447920948266983, + 0.028019161894917488, + 0.06409941613674164, + 0.10983863472938538 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008646431379020214 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a man wearing a tight, dark tactical suit with a hood pulled low?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man scaling a weathered, ancient city wall made of bluish-gray masonry covered in moss and cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man climb using lightning-fast movements with tactical-gloved hands grasping cracks and feet tapping the wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a shaky, low-angle handheld tracking shot and then rapidly move upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the man jumping onto the wide battlements at the top of the wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11291860789060593 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2379186153411865 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11291860789060593, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11291860789060593, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.28990939259529114, + 0.0706125870347023, + 0.3335303068161011, + 0.028739767149090767, + 0.02985731139779091, + 0.030994130298495293, + 0.0756697878241539, + 0.0440225675702095, + 0.04893084615468979, + 0.04773319885134697 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11291860789060593 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a man wearing a tight, dark tactical suit with a hood pulled low?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man scaling a weathered, ancient city wall made of bluish-gray masonry covered in moss and cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man climb using lightning-fast movements with tactical-gloved hands grasping cracks and feet tapping the wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a shaky, low-angle handheld tracking shot and then rapidly move upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the man jumping onto the wide battlements at the top of the wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01818414404988289 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018184185028076 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01818414404988289, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01818414404988289, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11256591230630875, + 0.042214903980493546, + 0.2492876797914505, + 0.06742700934410095, + 0.10277973860502243, + 0.24084414541721344, + 0.04166555032134056, + 0.04254121333360672, + 0.051954660564661026, + 0.04871925711631775 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01818414404988289 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a man wearing a tight, dark tactical suit with a hood pulled low?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man scaling a weathered, ancient city wall made of bluish-gray masonry covered in moss and cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man climb using lightning-fast movements with tactical-gloved hands grasping cracks and feet tapping the wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a shaky, low-angle handheld tracking shot and then rapidly move upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the man jumping onto the wide battlements at the top of the wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3870311677455902 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1370311975479126 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3870311677455902, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3870311677455902, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08159459382295609, + 0.053542476147413254, + 0.3626784086227417, + 0.033186331391334534, + 0.03271660581231117, + 0.03129669651389122, + 0.09661377221345901, + 0.04022187739610672, + 0.08155617117881775, + 0.18659308552742004 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3870311677455902 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "shaky, low-angle, handheld tracking shot then rapidly moves upward, capturing the swift movements of a man shrouded in darkness. He is clad in a tight, dark tactical suit, the hood pulled low, nearly obscuring half his face, leaving only a glimpse of his taut jawline. Under the cold moonlight, he scales a weathered, ancient city wall. The massive, bluish-gray masonry is covered in moss and cracks from age. His movements are lightning-fast, his tactical-gloved hands grasping the cracks and protrusions of the masonry with precision and force, his feet alternately tapping the vertical wall, his body climbing like a nimble gecko, unhesitatingly. The camera joltes with each of his exertions, creating a powerful sense of presence and tension. Finally, with a sudden pull-up, he turned over silently and jumped onto the wide battlements on the top of the wall. The whole process was completed in deep blue-black and cold silver-gray tones, full of mystery and power.", + "seed": 32662, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_15/index_1701_seed_32662_dp_31_rank_62_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.023400794621556996, + "vlm_logprob": -0.023400794621556996, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.925, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.023400794621556996, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a man wearing a tight, dark tactical suit with a hood pulled low?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man scaling a weathered, ancient city wall made of bluish-gray masonry covered in moss and cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man climb using lightning-fast movements with tactical-gloved hands grasping cracks and feet tapping the wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a shaky, low-angle handheld tracking shot and then rapidly move upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the man jumping onto the wide battlements at the top of the wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.021076634526252747 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8960766792297363 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.021076634526252747, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.021076634526252747, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19079245626926422, + 0.0522516630589962, + 0.03846621513366699, + 0.033333681523799896, + 0.37008315324783325, + 0.036842890083789825, + 0.0383494608104229, + 0.01640135794878006, + 0.026307178661227226, + 0.1971718966960907 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.021076634526252747 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a man wearing a tight, dark tactical suit with a hood pulled low?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man scaling a weathered, ancient city wall made of bluish-gray masonry covered in moss and cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man climb using lightning-fast movements with tactical-gloved hands grasping cracks and feet tapping the wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a shaky, low-angle handheld tracking shot and then rapidly move upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the man jumping onto the wide battlements at the top of the wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005259012337774038 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255259037017822 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005259012337774038, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005259012337774038, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18640545010566711, + 0.09274230897426605, + 0.0323055274784565, + 0.17324815690517426, + 0.090927854180336, + 0.20395097136497498, + 0.016098415479063988, + 0.06325918436050415, + 0.06332894414663315, + 0.07773320376873016 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005259012337774038 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a man wearing a tight, dark tactical suit with a hood pulled low?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man scaling a weathered, ancient city wall made of bluish-gray masonry covered in moss and cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man climb using lightning-fast movements with tactical-gloved hands grasping cracks and feet tapping the wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a shaky, low-angle handheld tracking shot and then rapidly move upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the man jumping onto the wide battlements at the top of the wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03369925171136856 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4086992740631104 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03369925171136856, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03369925171136856, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2039809674024582, + 0.042827095836400986, + 0.06725308299064636, + 0.027570653706789017, + 0.31461101770401, + 0.10824951529502869, + 0.05874844640493393, + 0.00952190812677145, + 0.01969357766211033, + 0.14754372835159302 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03369925171136856 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a man wearing a tight, dark tactical suit with a hood pulled low?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man scaling a weathered, ancient city wall made of bluish-gray masonry covered in moss and cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man climb using lightning-fast movements with tactical-gloved hands grasping cracks and feet tapping the wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a shaky, low-angle handheld tracking shot and then rapidly move upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the man jumping onto the wide battlements at the top of the wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023283997550606728 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732839584350586 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023283997550606728, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023283997550606728, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21168477833271027, + 0.04960504546761513, + 0.11565020680427551, + 0.024617761373519897, + 0.18303589522838593, + 0.09115350991487503, + 0.064461350440979, + 0.0239883903414011, + 0.017868297174572945, + 0.21793484687805176 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023283997550606728 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a man wearing a tight, dark tactical suit with a hood pulled low?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man scaling a weathered, ancient city wall made of bluish-gray masonry covered in moss and cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man climb using lightning-fast movements with tactical-gloved hands grasping cracks and feet tapping the wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a shaky, low-angle handheld tracking shot and then rapidly move upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the man jumping onto the wide battlements at the top of the wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03368507698178291 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4086849689483643 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03368507698178291, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03368507698178291, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1557822972536087, + 0.04956844821572304, + 0.08614325523376465, + 0.0902596190571785, + 0.17369553446769714, + 0.03974622115492821, + 0.04401390999555588, + 0.06639567762613297, + 0.06438770890235901, + 0.23000730574131012 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03368507698178291 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "shaky, low-angle, handheld tracking shot then rapidly moves upward, capturing the swift movements of a man shrouded in darkness. He is clad in a tight, dark tactical suit, the hood pulled low, nearly obscuring half his face, leaving only a glimpse of his taut jawline. Under the cold moonlight, he scales a weathered, ancient city wall. The massive, bluish-gray masonry is covered in moss and cracks from age. His movements are lightning-fast, his tactical-gloved hands grasping the cracks and protrusions of the masonry with precision and force, his feet alternately tapping the vertical wall, his body climbing like a nimble gecko, unhesitatingly. The camera joltes with each of his exertions, creating a powerful sense of presence and tension. Finally, with a sudden pull-up, he turned over silently and jumped onto the wide battlements on the top of the wall. The whole process was completed in deep blue-black and cold silver-gray tones, full of mystery and power.", + "seed": 32663, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_15/index_1701_seed_32663_dp_31_rank_62_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.04068350866436958, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04068350866436958, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.575, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04068350866436958, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a man wearing a tight, dark tactical suit with a hood pulled low?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man scaling a weathered, ancient city wall made of bluish-gray masonry covered in moss and cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man climb using lightning-fast movements with tactical-gloved hands grasping cracks and feet tapping the wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a shaky, low-angle handheld tracking shot and then rapidly move upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the man jumping onto the wide battlements at the top of the wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.015238530933856964 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.2652387619018555 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.015238530933856964, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.015238530933856964, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09596028178930283, + 0.08214443176984787, + 0.08252134174108505, + 0.019891832023859024, + 0.03814692795276642, + 0.057896703481674194, + 0.21021518111228943, + 0.1229621022939682, + 0.10238625109195709, + 0.1878749579191208 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.015238530933856964 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a man wearing a tight, dark tactical suit with a hood pulled low?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man scaling a weathered, ancient city wall made of bluish-gray masonry covered in moss and cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man climb using lightning-fast movements with tactical-gloved hands grasping cracks and feet tapping the wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a shaky, low-angle handheld tracking shot and then rapidly move upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the man jumping onto the wide battlements at the top of the wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006746135652065277 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006746292114258 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006746135652065277, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006746135652065277, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07642560452222824, + 0.06335703283548355, + 0.09522989392280579, + 0.055303752422332764, + 0.10419140011072159, + 0.08414474129676819, + 0.042377620935440063, + 0.1793716847896576, + 0.15755990147590637, + 0.14203839004039764 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006746135652065277 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a man wearing a tight, dark tactical suit with a hood pulled low?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man scaling a weathered, ancient city wall made of bluish-gray masonry covered in moss and cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man climb using lightning-fast movements with tactical-gloved hands grasping cracks and feet tapping the wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a shaky, low-angle handheld tracking shot and then rapidly move upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the man jumping onto the wide battlements at the top of the wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03809374198317528 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2880938053131104 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03809374198317528, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03809374198317528, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1027742251753807, + 0.11432498693466187, + 0.10853782296180725, + 0.06321019679307938, + 0.029351765289902687, + 0.030907856300473213, + 0.20933520793914795, + 0.16270384192466736, + 0.06260117143392563, + 0.11625292152166367 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03809374198317528 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a man wearing a tight, dark tactical suit with a hood pulled low?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man scaling a weathered, ancient city wall made of bluish-gray masonry covered in moss and cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man climb using lightning-fast movements with tactical-gloved hands grasping cracks and feet tapping the wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a shaky, low-angle handheld tracking shot and then rapidly move upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the man jumping onto the wide battlements at the top of the wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1002945750951767 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.350294589996338 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1002945750951767, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1002945750951767, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07837454974651337, + 0.09992976486682892, + 0.07879319787025452, + 0.046246934682130814, + 0.11401184648275375, + 0.03548640012741089, + 0.20537176728248596, + 0.05305970087647438, + 0.03675854951143265, + 0.25196728110313416 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1002945750951767 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a man wearing a tight, dark tactical suit with a hood pulled low?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man scaling a weathered, ancient city wall made of bluish-gray masonry covered in moss and cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man climb using lightning-fast movements with tactical-gloved hands grasping cracks and feet tapping the wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a shaky, low-angle handheld tracking shot and then rapidly move upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the man jumping onto the wide battlements at the top of the wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0430445596575737 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680445671081543 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0430445596575737, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0430445596575737, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03900916501879692, + 0.05548952892422676, + 0.03473136946558952, + 0.03065340965986252, + 0.012734922580420971, + 0.010000042617321014, + 0.033037930727005005, + 0.09095923602581024, + 0.019833402708172798, + 0.6735509634017944 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0430445596575737 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_2/index_tensor([6705, 6705])_group_2_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_2/index_tensor([6705, 6705])_group_2_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..9c0dabe63c00d9a6d33a15b3b2112db3b0821b54 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_2/index_tensor([6705, 6705])_group_2_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "sweeping, high-angle bird's-eye view slides forward smoothly and deliberately, slowly cruising across a stunningly detailed, glowing 3D map of Mount Everest. Rendered in a stylish, tech-oriented style, the map itself floats within a deep, void-like black, its inner glow the only source of light. The holographic terrain is composed of a fine grid-like structure of brilliant cyan light, its mountainous forms filled with translucent, shifting polygons, giving the peaks and valleys a tangible yet ethereal quality. As the camera moves, the terrain below subtly ripples, its digital faces shimmering as if constantly recalibrating with new information. Luminous rivers of data flow dynamically through this digital landscape; pulsating electric blue lines flow smoothly along established climbing routes along treacherous ridges, while swirling streams of vibrant orange and yellow, representing complex weather patterns, meander through deep valleys and wrap around the highest peaks. The scene's cool color palette, dominated by glowing cyan and deep black, creates a sophisticated, futuristic atmosphere that is both analytically precise and breathtakingly beautiful.", + "seed": 32513, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_2/index_6705_seed_32513_dp_4_rank_8_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.015397422341629862, + "vlm_logprob": -0.015397422341629862, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 5.125, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.015397422341629862, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a high-angle bird's-eye view of a 3D map of Mount Everest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the map rendered with a fine grid-like structure of brilliant cyan light and translucent shifting polygons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do luminous rivers of data flow as pulsating electric blue lines along climbing routes and as swirling orange and yellow streams representing weather patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the terrain ripple and shimmer as the camera moves, with the map floating in a deep black void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slide forward smoothly and deliberately across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05706929415464401 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9320693016052246 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05706929415464401, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05706929415464401, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09386749565601349, + 0.04398772120475769, + 0.02378660999238491, + 0.2783970236778259, + 0.056485481560230255, + 0.18196187913417816, + 0.06878069788217545, + 0.17021356523036957, + 0.03480205312371254, + 0.04771745204925537 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05706929415464401 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a high-angle bird's-eye view of a 3D map of Mount Everest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the map rendered with a fine grid-like structure of brilliant cyan light and translucent shifting polygons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do luminous rivers of data flow as pulsating electric blue lines along climbing routes and as swirling orange and yellow streams representing weather patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the terrain ripple and shimmer as the camera moves, with the map floating in a deep black void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slide forward smoothly and deliberately across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0013519919011741877 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.626351833343506 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0013519919011741877, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0013519919011741877, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14985255897045135, + 0.07071977853775024, + 0.0885179415345192, + 0.07212655991315842, + 0.23466840386390686, + 0.06577331572771072, + 0.07872618734836578, + 0.15203237533569336, + 0.046795159578323364, + 0.04078778252005577 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0013519919011741877 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a high-angle bird's-eye view of a 3D map of Mount Everest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the map rendered with a fine grid-like structure of brilliant cyan light and translucent shifting polygons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do luminous rivers of data flow as pulsating electric blue lines along climbing routes and as swirling orange and yellow streams representing weather patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the terrain ripple and shimmer as the camera moves, with the map floating in a deep black void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slide forward smoothly and deliberately across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004095145035535097 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504095077514648 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004095145035535097, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004095145035535097, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07922127842903137, + 0.07353923469781876, + 0.057095907628536224, + 0.33004051446914673, + 0.14515337347984314, + 0.09182426333427429, + 0.05240950733423233, + 0.07308629155158997, + 0.03850589320063591, + 0.05912372097373009 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004095145035535097 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a high-angle bird's-eye view of a 3D map of Mount Everest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the map rendered with a fine grid-like structure of brilliant cyan light and translucent shifting polygons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do luminous rivers of data flow as pulsating electric blue lines along climbing routes and as swirling orange and yellow streams representing weather patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the terrain ripple and shimmer as the camera moves, with the map floating in a deep black void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slide forward smoothly and deliberately across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.001940036192536354 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.2519402503967285 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.001940036192536354, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.001940036192536354, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12116999924182892, + 0.2970900237560272, + 0.0767071321606636, + 0.07757191359996796, + 0.07048166543245316, + 0.11764843761920929, + 0.05610574409365654, + 0.11562058329582214, + 0.026316916570067406, + 0.041287537664175034 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.001940036192536354 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a high-angle bird's-eye view of a 3D map of Mount Everest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the map rendered with a fine grid-like structure of brilliant cyan light and translucent shifting polygons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do luminous rivers of data flow as pulsating electric blue lines along climbing routes and as swirling orange and yellow streams representing weather patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the terrain ripple and shimmer as the camera moves, with the map floating in a deep black void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slide forward smoothly and deliberately across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012530644424259663 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.38753080368042 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012530644424259663, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012530644424259663, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09235788136720657, + 0.12526088953018188, + 0.050447892397642136, + 0.06046945974230766, + 0.08760039508342743, + 0.32406115531921387, + 0.06688756495714188, + 0.0837407186627388, + 0.02392806112766266, + 0.0852460041642189 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012530644424259663 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "sweeping, high-angle bird's-eye view slides forward smoothly and deliberately, slowly cruising across a stunningly detailed, glowing 3D map of Mount Everest. Rendered in a stylish, tech-oriented style, the map itself floats within a deep, void-like black, its inner glow the only source of light. The holographic terrain is composed of a fine grid-like structure of brilliant cyan light, its mountainous forms filled with translucent, shifting polygons, giving the peaks and valleys a tangible yet ethereal quality. As the camera moves, the terrain below subtly ripples, its digital faces shimmering as if constantly recalibrating with new information. Luminous rivers of data flow dynamically through this digital landscape; pulsating electric blue lines flow smoothly along established climbing routes along treacherous ridges, while swirling streams of vibrant orange and yellow, representing complex weather patterns, meander through deep valleys and wrap around the highest peaks. The scene's cool color palette, dominated by glowing cyan and deep black, creates a sophisticated, futuristic atmosphere that is both analytically precise and breathtakingly beautiful.", + "seed": 32514, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_2/index_6705_seed_32514_dp_4_rank_8_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.018478964734822512, + "vlm_logprob": -0.018478964734822512, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.5, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.018478964734822512, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a high-angle bird's-eye view of a 3D map of Mount Everest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the map rendered with a fine grid-like structure of brilliant cyan light and translucent shifting polygons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do luminous rivers of data flow as pulsating electric blue lines along climbing routes and as swirling orange and yellow streams representing weather patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the terrain ripple and shimmer as the camera moves, with the map floating in a deep black void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slide forward smoothly and deliberately across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06004641577601433 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.935046434402466 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06004641577601433, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06004641577601433, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.32740405201911926, + 0.09912940859794617, + 0.04068470373749733, + 0.14308764040470123, + 0.057686325162649155, + 0.02851206809282303, + 0.07885971665382385, + 0.025820257142186165, + 0.12658460438251495, + 0.0722312405705452 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06004641577601433 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a high-angle bird's-eye view of a 3D map of Mount Everest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the map rendered with a fine grid-like structure of brilliant cyan light and translucent shifting polygons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do luminous rivers of data flow as pulsating electric blue lines along climbing routes and as swirling orange and yellow streams representing weather patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the terrain ripple and shimmer as the camera moves, with the map floating in a deep black void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slide forward smoothly and deliberately across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005278341472148895 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.25527811050415 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005278341472148895, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005278341472148895, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.34668928384780884, + 0.15569840371608734, + 0.10151058435440063, + 0.11943969875574112, + 0.03890922665596008, + 0.07102975249290466, + 0.039824046194553375, + 0.0337577722966671, + 0.0456179678440094, + 0.047523289918899536 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005278341472148895 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a high-angle bird's-eye view of a 3D map of Mount Everest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the map rendered with a fine grid-like structure of brilliant cyan light and translucent shifting polygons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do luminous rivers of data flow as pulsating electric blue lines along climbing routes and as swirling orange and yellow streams representing weather patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the terrain ripple and shimmer as the camera moves, with the map floating in a deep black void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slide forward smoothly and deliberately across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007630605716258287 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882630825042725 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007630605716258287, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007630605716258287, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10977626591920853, + 0.11609552800655365, + 0.06340457499027252, + 0.1175205186009407, + 0.049615804105997086, + 0.06573879718780518, + 0.07396618276834488, + 0.144008070230484, + 0.19592028856277466, + 0.06395388394594193 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007630605716258287 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a high-angle bird's-eye view of a 3D map of Mount Everest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the map rendered with a fine grid-like structure of brilliant cyan light and translucent shifting polygons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do luminous rivers of data flow as pulsating electric blue lines along climbing routes and as swirling orange and yellow streams representing weather patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the terrain ripple and shimmer as the camera moves, with the map floating in a deep black void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slide forward smoothly and deliberately across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005254150368273258 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.25525426864624 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005254150368273258, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005254150368273258, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.29064109921455383, + 0.11809413880109787, + 0.05937297269701958, + 0.07408986985683441, + 0.0820038914680481, + 0.03751972317695618, + 0.06757433712482452, + 0.10004296153783798, + 0.049819640815258026, + 0.12084134668111801 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005254150368273258 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a high-angle bird's-eye view of a 3D map of Mount Everest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the map rendered with a fine grid-like structure of brilliant cyan light and translucent shifting polygons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do luminous rivers of data flow as pulsating electric blue lines along climbing routes and as swirling orange and yellow streams representing weather patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the terrain ripple and shimmer as the camera moves, with the map floating in a deep black void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slide forward smoothly and deliberately across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01418531034141779 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264185428619385 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01418531034141779, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01418531034141779, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15872889757156372, + 0.18673042953014374, + 0.04020926356315613, + 0.09162472188472748, + 0.08119021356105804, + 0.10572818666696548, + 0.08358264714479446, + 0.10819372534751892, + 0.05882255360484123, + 0.08518937230110168 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01418531034141779 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "sweeping, high-angle bird's-eye view slides forward smoothly and deliberately, slowly cruising across a stunningly detailed, glowing 3D map of Mount Everest. Rendered in a stylish, tech-oriented style, the map itself floats within a deep, void-like black, its inner glow the only source of light. The holographic terrain is composed of a fine grid-like structure of brilliant cyan light, its mountainous forms filled with translucent, shifting polygons, giving the peaks and valleys a tangible yet ethereal quality. As the camera moves, the terrain below subtly ripples, its digital faces shimmering as if constantly recalibrating with new information. Luminous rivers of data flow dynamically through this digital landscape; pulsating electric blue lines flow smoothly along established climbing routes along treacherous ridges, while swirling streams of vibrant orange and yellow, representing complex weather patterns, meander through deep valleys and wrap around the highest peaks. The scene's cool color palette, dominated by glowing cyan and deep black, creates a sophisticated, futuristic atmosphere that is both analytically precise and breathtakingly beautiful.", + "seed": 32515, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_2/index_6705_seed_32515_dp_5_rank_10_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.010468363133259117, + "vlm_logprob": -0.010468363133259117, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 5.275, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.010468363133259117, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a high-angle bird's-eye view of a 3D map of Mount Everest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the map rendered with a fine grid-like structure of brilliant cyan light and translucent shifting polygons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do luminous rivers of data flow as pulsating electric blue lines along climbing routes and as swirling orange and yellow streams representing weather patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the terrain ripple and shimmer as the camera moves, with the map floating in a deep black void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slide forward smoothly and deliberately across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03148359805345535 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5314836502075195 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03148359805345535, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03148359805345535, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2786981463432312, + 0.11189459264278412, + 0.07323110103607178, + 0.08887828141450882, + 0.11137400567531586, + 0.05527722090482712, + 0.06574708968400955, + 0.046468719840049744, + 0.07364580035209656, + 0.09478508681058884 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03148359805345535 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a high-angle bird's-eye view of a 3D map of Mount Everest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the map rendered with a fine grid-like structure of brilliant cyan light and translucent shifting polygons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do luminous rivers of data flow as pulsating electric blue lines along climbing routes and as swirling orange and yellow streams representing weather patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the terrain ripple and shimmer as the camera moves, with the map floating in a deep black void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slide forward smoothly and deliberately across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0013461584458127618 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.626346111297607 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0013461584458127618, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0013461584458127618, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2779257893562317, + 0.1239839643239975, + 0.07737516611814499, + 0.12773682177066803, + 0.10228962451219559, + 0.06686996668577194, + 0.05793164297938347, + 0.05385860428214073, + 0.02788836695253849, + 0.08414002507925034 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0013461584458127618 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a high-angle bird's-eye view of a 3D map of Mount Everest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the map rendered with a fine grid-like structure of brilliant cyan light and translucent shifting polygons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do luminous rivers of data flow as pulsating electric blue lines along climbing routes and as swirling orange and yellow streams representing weather patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the terrain ripple and shimmer as the camera moves, with the map floating in a deep black void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slide forward smoothly and deliberately across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003615630092099309 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628615856170654 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003615630092099309, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003615630092099309, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18251949548721313, + 0.06568216532468796, + 0.12408420443534851, + 0.18336686491966248, + 0.1266540139913559, + 0.02708088792860508, + 0.08515474945306778, + 0.12461721897125244, + 0.02816852740943432, + 0.05267181992530823 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003615630092099309 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a high-angle bird's-eye view of a 3D map of Mount Everest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the map rendered with a fine grid-like structure of brilliant cyan light and translucent shifting polygons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do luminous rivers of data flow as pulsating electric blue lines along climbing routes and as swirling orange and yellow streams representing weather patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the terrain ripple and shimmer as the camera moves, with the map floating in a deep black void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slide forward smoothly and deliberately across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0017130000051110983 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.376712799072266 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0017130000051110983, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0017130000051110983, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4175385534763336, + 0.07249680161476135, + 0.07229581475257874, + 0.1384015530347824, + 0.08549244701862335, + 0.023140424862504005, + 0.05246040225028992, + 0.04921304062008858, + 0.0404624342918396, + 0.0484984815120697 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0017130000051110983 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a high-angle bird's-eye view of a 3D map of Mount Everest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the map rendered with a fine grid-like structure of brilliant cyan light and translucent shifting polygons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do luminous rivers of data flow as pulsating electric blue lines along climbing routes and as swirling orange and yellow streams representing weather patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the terrain ripple and shimmer as the camera moves, with the map floating in a deep black void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slide forward smoothly and deliberately across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014183429069817066 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264183521270752 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014183429069817066, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014183429069817066, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2012868970632553, + 0.13210247457027435, + 0.07962236553430557, + 0.09591931104660034, + 0.10708848387002945, + 0.0534370094537735, + 0.06027408316731453, + 0.029937367886304855, + 0.05926204100251198, + 0.1810699850320816 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014183429069817066 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "sweeping, high-angle bird's-eye view slides forward smoothly and deliberately, slowly cruising across a stunningly detailed, glowing 3D map of Mount Everest. Rendered in a stylish, tech-oriented style, the map itself floats within a deep, void-like black, its inner glow the only source of light. The holographic terrain is composed of a fine grid-like structure of brilliant cyan light, its mountainous forms filled with translucent, shifting polygons, giving the peaks and valleys a tangible yet ethereal quality. As the camera moves, the terrain below subtly ripples, its digital faces shimmering as if constantly recalibrating with new information. Luminous rivers of data flow dynamically through this digital landscape; pulsating electric blue lines flow smoothly along established climbing routes along treacherous ridges, while swirling streams of vibrant orange and yellow, representing complex weather patterns, meander through deep valleys and wrap around the highest peaks. The scene's cool color palette, dominated by glowing cyan and deep black, creates a sophisticated, futuristic atmosphere that is both analytically precise and breathtakingly beautiful.", + "seed": 32516, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_2/index_6705_seed_32516_dp_5_rank_10_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.012965118838474154, + "vlm_logprob": -0.012965118838474154, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.925, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.012965118838474154, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a high-angle bird's-eye view of a 3D map of Mount Everest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the map rendered with a fine grid-like structure of brilliant cyan light and translucent shifting polygons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do luminous rivers of data flow as pulsating electric blue lines along climbing routes and as swirling orange and yellow streams representing weather patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the terrain ripple and shimmer as the camera moves, with the map floating in a deep black void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slide forward smoothly and deliberately across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04025920480489731 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2902591228485107 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04025920480489731, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04025920480489731, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1644548624753952, + 0.0599469393491745, + 0.06792791932821274, + 0.20379729568958282, + 0.03742396458983421, + 0.06572625786066055, + 0.05520140007138252, + 0.14974547922611237, + 0.0953020304441452, + 0.10047385096549988 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04025920480489731 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a high-angle bird's-eye view of a 3D map of Mount Everest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the map rendered with a fine grid-like structure of brilliant cyan light and translucent shifting polygons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do luminous rivers of data flow as pulsating electric blue lines along climbing routes and as swirling orange and yellow streams representing weather patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the terrain ripple and shimmer as the camera moves, with the map floating in a deep black void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slide forward smoothly and deliberately across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0015256681945174932 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.50152587890625 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0015256681945174932, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0015256681945174932, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07499121129512787, + 0.08433815091848373, + 0.06005178764462471, + 0.4055106043815613, + 0.051452893763780594, + 0.031143272295594215, + 0.026394518092274666, + 0.07531115412712097, + 0.09434501081705093, + 0.09646135568618774 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0015256681945174932 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a high-angle bird's-eye view of a 3D map of Mount Everest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the map rendered with a fine grid-like structure of brilliant cyan light and translucent shifting polygons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do luminous rivers of data flow as pulsating electric blue lines along climbing routes and as swirling orange and yellow streams representing weather patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the terrain ripple and shimmer as the camera moves, with the map floating in a deep black void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slide forward smoothly and deliberately across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005256166215986013 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255256175994873 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005256166215986013, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005256166215986013, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09950201213359833, + 0.09872718155384064, + 0.07287656515836716, + 0.10276471078395844, + 0.06327461451292038, + 0.11600909382104874, + 0.06243778020143509, + 0.18520870804786682, + 0.12114685028791428, + 0.07805249094963074 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005256166215986013 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a high-angle bird's-eye view of a 3D map of Mount Everest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the map rendered with a fine grid-like structure of brilliant cyan light and translucent shifting polygons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do luminous rivers of data flow as pulsating electric blue lines along climbing routes and as swirling orange and yellow streams representing weather patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the terrain ripple and shimmer as the camera moves, with the map floating in a deep black void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slide forward smoothly and deliberately across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0052535575814545155 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255253791809082 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0052535575814545155, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0052535575814545155, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1602027863264084, + 0.08047181367874146, + 0.09271647781133652, + 0.29495128989219666, + 0.0786803662776947, + 0.037736788392066956, + 0.03392144292593002, + 0.11605815589427948, + 0.05294492468237877, + 0.05231594666838646 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0052535575814545155 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a high-angle bird's-eye view of a 3D map of Mount Everest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the map rendered with a fine grid-like structure of brilliant cyan light and translucent shifting polygons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do luminous rivers of data flow as pulsating electric blue lines along climbing routes and as swirling orange and yellow streams representing weather patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the terrain ripple and shimmer as the camera moves, with the map floating in a deep black void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slide forward smoothly and deliberately across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012530997395515442 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.38753080368042 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012530997395515442, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012530997395515442, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07983028888702393, + 0.08498547971248627, + 0.03828619047999382, + 0.3082498610019684, + 0.1055150106549263, + 0.07224168628454208, + 0.034132760018110275, + 0.1287640929222107, + 0.09074833244085312, + 0.057246286422014236 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 7, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012530997395515442 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_3/index_tensor([4465, 4465])_group_3_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_3/index_tensor([4465, 4465])_group_3_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..bbc4b73b00582968fa7d90af9002a745d2b5a387 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_3/index_tensor([4465, 4465])_group_3_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "violently shaky close-up, captured from a horizontal angle, captures an astronaut jolted awake from a light sleep. Her short, sweat-soaked brown hair clings to her forehead, her eyes wide open in sheer terror, pupils constricted in the dim light. Her body tenses from the violent vibrations of the cabin. Clad in a somewhat bulky white spacesuit, her hands instinctively clutch the metal armrests of her seat, her lips parted as if a silent scream were frozen in her throat. Before her, the once silent, complex dashboard is now dominated by a blinding, blinking red alarm light. This ominous glow dances wildly between the narrow metal walls, casting her pale face and the intricate textures of her spacesuit in a disconcerting, blood-red halo. The remaining unlit screens and buttons on the dashboard are lost in deep shadow. Her eyes were fixed in horror on the madly flashing data and symbols. The entire space creaked and groaned due to the continuous and violent shaking, creating an extremely tense, claustrophobic atmosphere on the verge of being out of control.", + "seed": 33420, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_3/index_4465_seed_33420_dp_6_rank_12_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.12518719024956226, + "vlm_logprob": -0.12518719024956226, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.0, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.12518719024956226, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a violently shaky close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject an astronaut wearing a bulky white spacesuit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the astronaut have short, sweat-soaked brown hair and wide, terrified eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a blinding, blinking red alarm light visible on the dashboard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the astronaut's body tensed and hands clutching metal armrests due to violent shaking?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.47784385085105896 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9778438806533813 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.47784385085105896, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.47784385085105896, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5080360770225525, + 0.10063362121582031, + 0.04342462867498398, + 0.02360411174595356, + 0.01253484282642603, + 0.050633370876312256, + 0.09302949905395508, + 0.0816555991768837, + 0.035106245428323746, + 0.05134205147624016 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.47784385085105896 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a violently shaky close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject an astronaut wearing a bulky white spacesuit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the astronaut have short, sweat-soaked brown hair and wide, terrified eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a blinding, blinking red alarm light visible on the dashboard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the astronaut's body tensed and hands clutching metal armrests due to violent shaking?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011097377166152 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511097431182861 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011097377166152, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011097377166152, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.49413883686065674, + 0.05276481807231903, + 0.030837582424283028, + 0.08483651280403137, + 0.0260840505361557, + 0.09569298475980759, + 0.03074061870574951, + 0.01560115721076727, + 0.034691933542490005, + 0.1346115618944168 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011097377166152 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a violently shaky close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject an astronaut wearing a bulky white spacesuit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the astronaut have short, sweat-soaked brown hair and wide, terrified eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a blinding, blinking red alarm light visible on the dashboard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the astronaut's body tensed and hands clutching metal armrests due to violent shaking?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014210343360900879 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264210224151611 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014210343360900879, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014210343360900879, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12476511299610138, + 0.039296358823776245, + 0.018696602433919907, + 0.016072632744908333, + 0.2109440714120865, + 0.041587114334106445, + 0.022701846435666084, + 0.046577561646699905, + 0.030524631962180138, + 0.44883403182029724 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014210343360900879 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a violently shaky close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject an astronaut wearing a bulky white spacesuit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the astronaut have short, sweat-soaked brown hair and wide, terrified eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a blinding, blinking red alarm light visible on the dashboard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the astronaut's body tensed and hands clutching metal armrests due to violent shaking?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.033712852746248245 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408712863922119 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.033712852746248245, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.033712852746248245, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09254369884729385, + 0.06707389652729034, + 0.01143662165850401, + 0.02658749558031559, + 0.017518680542707443, + 0.08344152569770813, + 0.06481499969959259, + 0.020655600354075432, + 0.12127131968736649, + 0.4946560859680176 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.033712852746248245 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a violently shaky close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject an astronaut wearing a bulky white spacesuit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the astronaut have short, sweat-soaked brown hair and wide, terrified eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a blinding, blinking red alarm light visible on the dashboard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the astronaut's body tensed and hands clutching metal armrests due to violent shaking?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08907152712345123 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.46407151222229 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08907152712345123, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08907152712345123, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4998635947704315, + 0.04579303413629532, + 0.060317736119031906, + 0.03165658563375473, + 0.04520373046398163, + 0.02083096094429493, + 0.030064770951867104, + 0.041919391602277756, + 0.04219004884362221, + 0.1821601837873459 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08907152712345123 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "violently shaky close-up, captured from a horizontal angle, captures an astronaut jolted awake from a light sleep. Her short, sweat-soaked brown hair clings to her forehead, her eyes wide open in sheer terror, pupils constricted in the dim light. Her body tenses from the violent vibrations of the cabin. Clad in a somewhat bulky white spacesuit, her hands instinctively clutch the metal armrests of her seat, her lips parted as if a silent scream were frozen in her throat. Before her, the once silent, complex dashboard is now dominated by a blinding, blinking red alarm light. This ominous glow dances wildly between the narrow metal walls, casting her pale face and the intricate textures of her spacesuit in a disconcerting, blood-red halo. The remaining unlit screens and buttons on the dashboard are lost in deep shadow. Her eyes were fixed in horror on the madly flashing data and symbols. The entire space creaked and groaned due to the continuous and violent shaking, creating an extremely tense, claustrophobic atmosphere on the verge of being out of control.", + "seed": 33421, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_3/index_4465_seed_33421_dp_6_rank_12_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.03858505189418793, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03858505189418793, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.325, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03858505189418793, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a violently shaky close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject an astronaut wearing a bulky white spacesuit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the astronaut have short, sweat-soaked brown hair and wide, terrified eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a blinding, blinking red alarm light visible on the dashboard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the astronaut's body tensed and hands clutching metal armrests due to violent shaking?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05179659277200699 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0517966747283936 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05179659277200699, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05179659277200699, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16852767765522003, + 0.19934527575969696, + 0.07444649189710617, + 0.055318184196949005, + 0.181706964969635, + 0.051915425807237625, + 0.12311018258333206, + 0.04775388166308403, + 0.03922532498836517, + 0.05865060165524483 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05179659277200699 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a violently shaky close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject an astronaut wearing a bulky white spacesuit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the astronaut have short, sweat-soaked brown hair and wide, terrified eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a blinding, blinking red alarm light visible on the dashboard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the astronaut's body tensed and hands clutching metal armrests due to violent shaking?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.054988034069538116 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929988145828247 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.054988034069538116, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.054988034069538116, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12256656587123871, + 0.10407506674528122, + 0.035315465182065964, + 0.028337905183434486, + 0.016411833465099335, + 0.020084550604224205, + 0.04321029409766197, + 0.027100874111056328, + 0.11623961478471756, + 0.4866577386856079 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.054988034069538116 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a violently shaky close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject an astronaut wearing a bulky white spacesuit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the astronaut have short, sweat-soaked brown hair and wide, terrified eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a blinding, blinking red alarm light visible on the dashboard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the astronaut's body tensed and hands clutching metal armrests due to violent shaking?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03813379257917404 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881338596343994 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03813379257917404, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03813379257917404, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1358291357755661, + 0.32913079857826233, + 0.0546332485973835, + 0.031873904168605804, + 0.07150483131408691, + 0.011925961822271347, + 0.11829902231693268, + 0.044886596500873566, + 0.12283945083618164, + 0.07907707989215851 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03813379257917404 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a violently shaky close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject an astronaut wearing a bulky white spacesuit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the astronaut have short, sweat-soaked brown hair and wide, terrified eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a blinding, blinking red alarm light visible on the dashboard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the astronaut's body tensed and hands clutching metal armrests due to violent shaking?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029806073755025864 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529806137084961 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029806073755025864, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029806073755025864, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.027925891801714897, + 0.6559873819351196, + 0.07359513640403748, + 0.008946636691689491, + 0.016707705333828926, + 0.028316393494606018, + 0.012152736075222492, + 0.016984794288873672, + 0.11097465455532074, + 0.04840870574116707 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029806073755025864 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a violently shaky close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject an astronaut wearing a bulky white spacesuit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the astronaut have short, sweat-soaked brown hair and wide, terrified eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a blinding, blinking red alarm light visible on the dashboard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the astronaut's body tensed and hands clutching metal armrests due to violent shaking?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018200766295194626 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018200874328613 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018200766295194626, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018200766295194626, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10174845904111862, + 0.28394815325737, + 0.06148417294025421, + 0.09481076896190643, + 0.0606083981692791, + 0.04507845640182495, + 0.08602946996688843, + 0.023238157853484154, + 0.11455801874399185, + 0.12849600613117218 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018200766295194626 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "violently shaky close-up, captured from a horizontal angle, captures an astronaut jolted awake from a light sleep. Her short, sweat-soaked brown hair clings to her forehead, her eyes wide open in sheer terror, pupils constricted in the dim light. Her body tenses from the violent vibrations of the cabin. Clad in a somewhat bulky white spacesuit, her hands instinctively clutch the metal armrests of her seat, her lips parted as if a silent scream were frozen in her throat. Before her, the once silent, complex dashboard is now dominated by a blinding, blinking red alarm light. This ominous glow dances wildly between the narrow metal walls, casting her pale face and the intricate textures of her spacesuit in a disconcerting, blood-red halo. The remaining unlit screens and buttons on the dashboard are lost in deep shadow. Her eyes were fixed in horror on the madly flashing data and symbols. The entire space creaked and groaned due to the continuous and violent shaking, creating an extremely tense, claustrophobic atmosphere on the verge of being out of control.", + "seed": 33422, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_3/index_4465_seed_33422_dp_7_rank_14_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.20891273878514766, + "vlm_logprob": -0.20891273878514766, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.725, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.20891273878514766, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a violently shaky close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject an astronaut wearing a bulky white spacesuit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the astronaut have short, sweat-soaked brown hair and wide, terrified eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a blinding, blinking red alarm light visible on the dashboard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the astronaut's body tensed and hands clutching metal armrests due to violent shaking?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8312893509864807 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5812893509864807 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.8312893509864807, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.8312893509864807, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1266978532075882, + 0.12497465312480927, + 0.18746429681777954, + 0.20874375104904175, + 0.12318070232868195, + 0.04001057520508766, + 0.03254283592104912, + 0.02646617405116558, + 0.06165008619427681, + 0.06826911121606827 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.8312893509864807 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a violently shaky close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject an astronaut wearing a bulky white spacesuit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the astronaut have short, sweat-soaked brown hair and wide, terrified eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a blinding, blinking red alarm light visible on the dashboard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the astronaut's body tensed and hands clutching metal armrests due to violent shaking?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006762593984603882 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006762504577637 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006762593984603882, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006762593984603882, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06942880898714066, + 0.09214092791080475, + 0.3206331431865692, + 0.08597905933856964, + 0.11152444034814835, + 0.04238453134894371, + 0.0732082724571228, + 0.04117380455136299, + 0.11447005718946457, + 0.04905692860484123 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006762593984603882 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a violently shaky close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject an astronaut wearing a bulky white spacesuit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the astronaut have short, sweat-soaked brown hair and wide, terrified eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a blinding, blinking red alarm light visible on the dashboard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the astronaut's body tensed and hands clutching metal armrests due to violent shaking?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020601341500878334 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895601272583008 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020601341500878334, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020601341500878334, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13027410209178925, + 0.07266263663768768, + 0.2737056314945221, + 0.057125456631183624, + 0.16914524137973785, + 0.04484371468424797, + 0.035695526748895645, + 0.03938424587249756, + 0.10987593978643417, + 0.06728743761777878 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020601341500878334 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a violently shaky close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject an astronaut wearing a bulky white spacesuit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the astronaut have short, sweat-soaked brown hair and wide, terrified eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a blinding, blinking red alarm light visible on the dashboard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the astronaut's body tensed and hands clutching metal armrests due to violent shaking?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04307812824845314 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680781841278076 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04307812824845314, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04307812824845314, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10497769713401794, + 0.03471647575497627, + 0.4905253052711487, + 0.03931043669581413, + 0.043987713754177094, + 0.02682841196656227, + 0.050723280757665634, + 0.05456279218196869, + 0.0788932591676712, + 0.07547460496425629 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04307812824845314 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a violently shaky close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject an astronaut wearing a bulky white spacesuit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the astronaut have short, sweat-soaked brown hair and wide, terrified eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a blinding, blinking red alarm light visible on the dashboard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the astronaut's body tensed and hands clutching metal armrests due to violent shaking?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14283227920532227 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0178322792053223 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14283227920532227, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14283227920532227, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08897163718938828, + 0.2056792676448822, + 0.12423329800367355, + 0.15182888507843018, + 0.08017116039991379, + 0.03868427127599716, + 0.023965058848261833, + 0.042314279824495316, + 0.10367036610841751, + 0.14048179984092712 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14283227920532227 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "violently shaky close-up, captured from a horizontal angle, captures an astronaut jolted awake from a light sleep. Her short, sweat-soaked brown hair clings to her forehead, her eyes wide open in sheer terror, pupils constricted in the dim light. Her body tenses from the violent vibrations of the cabin. Clad in a somewhat bulky white spacesuit, her hands instinctively clutch the metal armrests of her seat, her lips parted as if a silent scream were frozen in her throat. Before her, the once silent, complex dashboard is now dominated by a blinding, blinking red alarm light. This ominous glow dances wildly between the narrow metal walls, casting her pale face and the intricate textures of her spacesuit in a disconcerting, blood-red halo. The remaining unlit screens and buttons on the dashboard are lost in deep shadow. Her eyes were fixed in horror on the madly flashing data and symbols. The entire space creaked and groaned due to the continuous and violent shaking, creating an extremely tense, claustrophobic atmosphere on the verge of being out of control.", + "seed": 33423, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_3/index_4465_seed_33423_dp_7_rank_14_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.11756532117724419, + "vlm_logprob": -0.11756532117724419, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.75, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.11756532117724419, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a violently shaky close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject an astronaut wearing a bulky white spacesuit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the astronaut have short, sweat-soaked brown hair and wide, terrified eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a blinding, blinking red alarm light visible on the dashboard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the astronaut's body tensed and hands clutching metal armrests due to violent shaking?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.38935646414756775 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1393564939498901 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.38935646414756775, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.38935646414756775, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3610982894897461, + 0.14033745229244232, + 0.07738388329744339, + 0.06058061122894287, + 0.15105226635932922, + 0.0667271688580513, + 0.04889035224914551, + 0.03375738114118576, + 0.037585340440273285, + 0.0225872453302145 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.38935646414756775 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a violently shaky close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject an astronaut wearing a bulky white spacesuit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the astronaut have short, sweat-soaked brown hair and wide, terrified eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a blinding, blinking red alarm light visible on the dashboard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the astronaut's body tensed and hands clutching metal armrests due to violent shaking?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01608842797577381 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141088485717773 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01608842797577381, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01608842797577381, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.056470837444067, + 0.25156986713409424, + 0.04882636293768883, + 0.03571311756968498, + 0.0730951800942421, + 0.0973488911986351, + 0.05514724552631378, + 0.22753994166851044, + 0.08956342190504074, + 0.06472514569759369 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 7, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01608842797577381 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a violently shaky close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject an astronaut wearing a bulky white spacesuit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the astronaut have short, sweat-soaked brown hair and wide, terrified eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a blinding, blinking red alarm light visible on the dashboard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the astronaut's body tensed and hands clutching metal armrests due to violent shaking?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04308144003152847 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168081521987915 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04308144003152847, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04308144003152847, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15491586923599243, + 0.17535175383090973, + 0.07150103896856308, + 0.07589263468980789, + 0.08493690937757492, + 0.17653052508831024, + 0.04776297137141228, + 0.05809194967150688, + 0.09432259202003479, + 0.06069379672408104 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04308144003152847 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a violently shaky close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject an astronaut wearing a bulky white spacesuit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the astronaut have short, sweat-soaked brown hair and wide, terrified eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a blinding, blinking red alarm light visible on the dashboard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the astronaut's body tensed and hands clutching metal armrests due to violent shaking?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026343757286667824 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651343822479248 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026343757286667824, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026343757286667824, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13407185673713684, + 0.09223377704620361, + 0.05938059836626053, + 0.14859363436698914, + 0.13164305686950684, + 0.03920850530266762, + 0.052313823252916336, + 0.04496034234762192, + 0.2490762621164322, + 0.048518113791942596 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026343757286667824 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a violently shaky close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject an astronaut wearing a bulky white spacesuit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the astronaut have short, sweat-soaked brown hair and wide, terrified eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a blinding, blinking red alarm light visible on the dashboard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the astronaut's body tensed and hands clutching metal armrests due to violent shaking?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11295651644468307 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2379565238952637 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11295651644468307, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11295651644468307, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2350182682275772, + 0.1637611836194992, + 0.042906373739242554, + 0.08027417957782745, + 0.1037493348121643, + 0.10630939155817032, + 0.06376329809427261, + 0.06679897755384445, + 0.0754837617278099, + 0.061935316771268845 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11295651644468307 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_4/index_tensor([9910, 9910])_group_4_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_4/index_tensor([9910, 9910])_group_4_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..a1b45bb3044fae8dba54f3935836dee109075d1d --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_4/index_tensor([9910, 9910])_group_4_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "dramatic low-angle tracking shot smoothly follows a female architect as she walks with a steady, cautious gait along the narrow, rust-colored surface of steel beams within the cavernous, skeletal frame of an unfinished skyscraper. Her dark brown hair is pulled back into a sleek ponytail, neatly tucked under a plain white hard hat. She projects an image of professional competence in a well-tailored navy blazer paired with a crisp white button-down shirt, slim-fitting dark gray pants, and worn leather work boots. Clutched tightly under her left arm is a thick roll of architectural blueprints. The camera moves parallel to her, maintaining a constant distance, emphasizing her confident poise and the precarious height she commands. The setting is a dizzying geometric grid of steel beams and concrete columns, stretching in every direction and forming stark patterns against the expansive afternoon sky. Far below, the city, a silent tapestry of streets and buildings, grows smaller and more distant. As she moves, the low-angled golden sun casts long, dramatic shadows and creates brilliant flashes of light on the steel beams, bathing the scene in a warm, high-contrast light that evokes awe, focused ambition, and quiet tension.", + "seed": 16339, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_4/index_9910_seed_16339_dp_8_rank_16_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.18920691795647143, + "vlm_logprob": -0.18920691795647143, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.5249999880790712, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.18920691795647143, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a smooth tracking shot parallel to the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a female architect wearing a white hard hat and navy blazer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the character walking on a narrow, rust-colored surface of steel beams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a low-angled golden sun casting long shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.48871639370918274 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1137163639068604 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.48871639370918274, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.48871639370918274, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2652140259742737, + 0.100080706179142, + 0.06498028337955475, + 0.07214965671300888, + 0.0783318281173706, + 0.08826858550310135, + 0.08739050477743149, + 0.13838839530944824, + 0.03184690698981285, + 0.07334908843040466 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.48871639370918274 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a smooth tracking shot parallel to the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a female architect wearing a white hard hat and navy blazer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the character walking on a narrow, rust-colored surface of steel beams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a low-angled golden sun casting long shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.38708335161209106 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1370832920074463 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.38708335161209106, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.7499999403953552, + "token_credit_reward": -0.38708335161209106, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14276614785194397, + 0.05423125997185707, + 0.08326620608568192, + 0.08576667308807373, + 0.1838463395833969, + 0.07060804218053818, + 0.10226356983184814, + 0.06192461773753166, + 0.12787729501724243, + 0.0874498188495636 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.38708335161209106 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a smooth tracking shot parallel to the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a female architect wearing a white hard hat and navy blazer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the character walking on a narrow, rust-colored surface of steel beams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a low-angled golden sun casting long shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026357341557741165 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651357412338257 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026357341557741165, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026357341557741165, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17566412687301636, + 0.14033102989196777, + 0.1034717708826065, + 0.08659698814153671, + 0.14491727948188782, + 0.07324675470590591, + 0.1641235500574112, + 0.026104629039764404, + 0.03177516162395477, + 0.053768761456012726 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026357341557741165 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a smooth tracking shot parallel to the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a female architect wearing a white hard hat and navy blazer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the character walking on a narrow, rust-colored surface of steel beams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a low-angled golden sun casting long shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020588263869285583 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955881595611572 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020588263869285583, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020588263869285583, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14352630078792572, + 0.051810190081596375, + 0.06950191408395767, + 0.09259497374296188, + 0.07288576662540436, + 0.06858019530773163, + 0.3658032715320587, + 0.0425851009786129, + 0.06103575602173805, + 0.03167661279439926 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020588263869285583 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a smooth tracking shot parallel to the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a female architect wearing a white hard hat and navy blazer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the character walking on a narrow, rust-colored surface of steel beams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a low-angled golden sun casting long shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023289239034056664 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773289203643799 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023289239034056664, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023289239034056664, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25166070461273193, + 0.05784592032432556, + 0.04098066687583923, + 0.027318885549902916, + 0.047324128448963165, + 0.04326590895652771, + 0.21024391055107117, + 0.15633080899715424, + 0.08290911465883255, + 0.08212000876665115 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023289239034056664 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dramatic low-angle tracking shot smoothly follows a female architect as she walks with a steady, cautious gait along the narrow, rust-colored surface of steel beams within the cavernous, skeletal frame of an unfinished skyscraper. Her dark brown hair is pulled back into a sleek ponytail, neatly tucked under a plain white hard hat. She projects an image of professional competence in a well-tailored navy blazer paired with a crisp white button-down shirt, slim-fitting dark gray pants, and worn leather work boots. Clutched tightly under her left arm is a thick roll of architectural blueprints. The camera moves parallel to her, maintaining a constant distance, emphasizing her confident poise and the precarious height she commands. The setting is a dizzying geometric grid of steel beams and concrete columns, stretching in every direction and forming stark patterns against the expansive afternoon sky. Far below, the city, a silent tapestry of streets and buildings, grows smaller and more distant. As she moves, the low-angled golden sun casts long, dramatic shadows and creates brilliant flashes of light on the steel beams, bathing the scene in a warm, high-contrast light that evokes awe, focused ambition, and quiet tension.", + "seed": 16340, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_4/index_9910_seed_16340_dp_8_rank_16_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.19091606959700586, + "vlm_logprob": -0.19091606959700586, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.675, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.19091606959700586, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a smooth tracking shot parallel to the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a female architect wearing a white hard hat and navy blazer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the character walking on a narrow, rust-colored surface of steel beams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a low-angled golden sun casting long shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1991317719221115 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.949131727218628 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1991317719221115, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1991317719221115, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1214851662516594, + 0.06738011538982391, + 0.045247673988342285, + 0.043781109154224396, + 0.07695823162794113, + 0.5306555032730103, + 0.021978536620736122, + 0.03843341022729874, + 0.024000011384487152, + 0.030080219730734825 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1991317719221115 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a smooth tracking shot parallel to the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a female architect wearing a white hard hat and navy blazer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the character walking on a narrow, rust-colored surface of steel beams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a low-angled golden sun casting long shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6933691501617432 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6933691501617432 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.6933691501617432, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.6933691501617432, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11460591107606888, + 0.13096295297145844, + 0.2907031178474426, + 0.05104762315750122, + 0.06645406037569046, + 0.10074831545352936, + 0.0458054356276989, + 0.12482239305973053, + 0.03406760096549988, + 0.040782563388347626 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.6933691501617432 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a smooth tracking shot parallel to the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a female architect wearing a white hard hat and navy blazer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the character walking on a narrow, rust-colored surface of steel beams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a low-angled golden sun casting long shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02059772238135338 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955976963043213 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02059772238135338, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02059772238135338, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14376325905323029, + 0.1381681263446808, + 0.08079729229211807, + 0.2679205536842346, + 0.058592379093170166, + 0.08099353313446045, + 0.037166230380535126, + 0.06032741442322731, + 0.08859339356422424, + 0.04367782548069954 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02059772238135338 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a smooth tracking shot parallel to the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a female architect wearing a white hard hat and navy blazer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the character walking on a narrow, rust-colored surface of steel beams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a low-angled golden sun casting long shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018194211646914482 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018194198608398 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018194211646914482, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018194211646914482, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13878782093524933, + 0.033323973417282104, + 0.04256955534219742, + 0.051160458475351334, + 0.039592333137989044, + 0.40215378999710083, + 0.018204566091299057, + 0.12781201303005219, + 0.10088174790143967, + 0.04551374912261963 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018194211646914482 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a smooth tracking shot parallel to the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a female architect wearing a white hard hat and navy blazer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the character walking on a narrow, rust-colored surface of steel beams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a low-angled golden sun casting long shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023287491872906685 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773287534713745 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023287491872906685, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023287491872906685, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10906841605901718, + 0.03160485252737999, + 0.0854576975107193, + 0.04361599683761597, + 0.09912770241498947, + 0.40054598450660706, + 0.11265292018651962, + 0.07314623892307281, + 0.028293851763010025, + 0.01648637093603611 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023287491872906685 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dramatic low-angle tracking shot smoothly follows a female architect as she walks with a steady, cautious gait along the narrow, rust-colored surface of steel beams within the cavernous, skeletal frame of an unfinished skyscraper. Her dark brown hair is pulled back into a sleek ponytail, neatly tucked under a plain white hard hat. She projects an image of professional competence in a well-tailored navy blazer paired with a crisp white button-down shirt, slim-fitting dark gray pants, and worn leather work boots. Clutched tightly under her left arm is a thick roll of architectural blueprints. The camera moves parallel to her, maintaining a constant distance, emphasizing her confident poise and the precarious height she commands. The setting is a dizzying geometric grid of steel beams and concrete columns, stretching in every direction and forming stark patterns against the expansive afternoon sky. Far below, the city, a silent tapestry of streets and buildings, grows smaller and more distant. As she moves, the low-angled golden sun casts long, dramatic shadows and creates brilliant flashes of light on the steel beams, bathing the scene in a warm, high-contrast light that evokes awe, focused ambition, and quiet tension.", + "seed": 16341, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_4/index_9910_seed_16341_dp_9_rank_18_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.13570525730028749, + "vlm_logprob": -0.13570525730028749, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.95, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.13570525730028749, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a smooth tracking shot parallel to the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a female architect wearing a white hard hat and navy blazer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the character walking on a narrow, rust-colored surface of steel beams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a low-angled golden sun casting long shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.13609153032302856 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.386091470718384 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.13609153032302856, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.13609153032302856, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09436429291963577, + 0.13915956020355225, + 0.03395092487335205, + 0.09289980679750443, + 0.06963358074426651, + 0.030101366341114044, + 0.10247544199228287, + 0.2968083322048187, + 0.09369108825922012, + 0.04691557213664055 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.13609153032302856 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a smooth tracking shot parallel to the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a female architect wearing a white hard hat and navy blazer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the character walking on a narrow, rust-colored surface of steel beams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a low-angled golden sun casting long shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.47429364919662476 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9742936491966248 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.47429364919662476, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.47429364919662476, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06143226474523544, + 0.07270115613937378, + 0.05107048898935318, + 0.16525505483150482, + 0.039381206035614014, + 0.041415985673666, + 0.1558205634355545, + 0.25061771273612976, + 0.05697949603199959, + 0.1053260788321495 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 3, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.47429364919662476 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a smooth tracking shot parallel to the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a female architect wearing a white hard hat and navy blazer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the character walking on a narrow, rust-colored surface of steel beams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a low-angled golden sun casting long shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03811256214976311 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881126403808594 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03811256214976311, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03811256214976311, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12456604093313217, + 0.2211051881313324, + 0.08352486044168472, + 0.058397162705659866, + 0.07527807354927063, + 0.0474371463060379, + 0.12063731253147125, + 0.09765604883432388, + 0.0912669226527214, + 0.08013121783733368 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03811256214976311 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a smooth tracking shot parallel to the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a female architect wearing a white hard hat and navy blazer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the character walking on a narrow, rust-colored surface of steel beams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a low-angled golden sun casting long shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006741635967046022 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006741523742676 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006741635967046022, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006741635967046022, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06733692437410355, + 0.07131420820951462, + 0.022315526381134987, + 0.14991605281829834, + 0.04155774787068367, + 0.07214529067277908, + 0.16344639658927917, + 0.15305307507514954, + 0.06612222641706467, + 0.19279250502586365 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006741635967046022 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a smooth tracking shot parallel to the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a female architect wearing a white hard hat and navy blazer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the character walking on a narrow, rust-colored surface of steel beams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a low-angled golden sun casting long shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023286908864974976 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773286819458008 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023286908864974976, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023286908864974976, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12730827927589417, + 0.13038426637649536, + 0.06759757548570633, + 0.08326132595539093, + 0.18436068296432495, + 0.030554726719856262, + 0.1233886107802391, + 0.12976160645484924, + 0.02570091001689434, + 0.09768211841583252 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023286908864974976 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dramatic low-angle tracking shot smoothly follows a female architect as she walks with a steady, cautious gait along the narrow, rust-colored surface of steel beams within the cavernous, skeletal frame of an unfinished skyscraper. Her dark brown hair is pulled back into a sleek ponytail, neatly tucked under a plain white hard hat. She projects an image of professional competence in a well-tailored navy blazer paired with a crisp white button-down shirt, slim-fitting dark gray pants, and worn leather work boots. Clutched tightly under her left arm is a thick roll of architectural blueprints. The camera moves parallel to her, maintaining a constant distance, emphasizing her confident poise and the precarious height she commands. The setting is a dizzying geometric grid of steel beams and concrete columns, stretching in every direction and forming stark patterns against the expansive afternoon sky. Far below, the city, a silent tapestry of streets and buildings, grows smaller and more distant. As she moves, the low-angled golden sun casts long, dramatic shadows and creates brilliant flashes of light on the steel beams, bathing the scene in a warm, high-contrast light that evokes awe, focused ambition, and quiet tension.", + "seed": 16342, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_4/index_9910_seed_16342_dp_9_rank_18_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.18575286772102118, + "vlm_logprob": -0.18575286772102118, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.4, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.18575286772102118, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a smooth tracking shot parallel to the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a female architect wearing a white hard hat and navy blazer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the character walking on a narrow, rust-colored surface of steel beams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a low-angled golden sun casting long shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3691389858722687 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3691389560699463 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3691389858722687, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3691389858722687, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17451225221157074, + 0.11405901610851288, + 0.03982556238770485, + 0.07518330961465836, + 0.042626697570085526, + 0.07730845361948013, + 0.06678131222724915, + 0.04829451069235802, + 0.2963295578956604, + 0.06507935374975204 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3691389858722687 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a smooth tracking shot parallel to the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a female architect wearing a white hard hat and navy blazer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the character walking on a narrow, rust-colored surface of steel beams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a low-angled golden sun casting long shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.428908109664917 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.053908109664917 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.428908109664917, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.428908109664917, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0632510632276535, + 0.42310869693756104, + 0.08052340894937515, + 0.017553074285387993, + 0.04456507787108421, + 0.030930086970329285, + 0.042154546827077866, + 0.10453227162361145, + 0.1678418219089508, + 0.025539975613355637 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.428908109664917 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a smooth tracking shot parallel to the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a female architect wearing a white hard hat and navy blazer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the character walking on a narrow, rust-colored surface of steel beams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a low-angled golden sun casting long shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07900232821702957 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5790023803710938 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07900232821702957, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07900232821702957, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2663132846355438, + 0.2880932092666626, + 0.13954541087150574, + 0.03438277915120125, + 0.07019396126270294, + 0.05130091309547424, + 0.06046351045370102, + 0.02931477501988411, + 0.027858536690473557, + 0.03253353759646416 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07900232821702957 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a smooth tracking shot parallel to the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a female architect wearing a white hard hat and navy blazer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the character walking on a narrow, rust-colored surface of steel beams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a low-angled golden sun casting long shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008648204617202282 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.75864839553833 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008648204617202282, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008648204617202282, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07671019434928894, + 0.7718843817710876, + 0.020625533536076546, + 0.021977722644805908, + 0.00853708852082491, + 0.010414944030344486, + 0.017312616109848022, + 0.012482816353440285, + 0.044349756091833115, + 0.015704991295933723 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008648204617202282 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a smooth tracking shot parallel to the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a female architect wearing a white hard hat and navy blazer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the character walking on a narrow, rust-colored surface of steel beams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a low-angled golden sun casting long shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.043066710233688354 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680667400360107 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.043066710233688354, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.043066710233688354, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2803177833557129, + 0.28974443674087524, + 0.09137415140867233, + 0.04599527642130852, + 0.03600182756781578, + 0.06552375853061676, + 0.06923304498195648, + 0.026579005643725395, + 0.06578041613101959, + 0.02945030853152275 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.043066710233688354 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_5/index_tensor([8585, 8585])_group_5_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_5/index_tensor([8585, 8585])_group_5_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..7c476659187f78ba5e191c39e9a3d89496863973 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_5/index_tensor([8585, 8585])_group_5_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up static shot captures the intricate details of a crisp white cotton dress shirt. A single, soft light source from the side sweeps across the material, highlighting the delicate texture of the weave and creating a dynamic play of light and shadow. As the unseen wearer takes slow, deep breaths, the fabric rhythmically expands upward, the threads momentarily tensing before gently and deliberately retreating into soft, delicate folds as they exhale. This hypnotic, steady movement creates an atmosphere of profound calm and introspection, while the shallow depth of field renders the background a blurred, dark blur, focusing all attention on the quiet, active pulse of the fabric itself.", + "seed": 3418, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_5/index_8585_seed_3418_dp_10_rank_20_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.1728732593357563, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1728732593357563, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.225000023841858, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1728732593357563, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a white cotton dress shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a single soft light source coming from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the fabric rhythmically expand upward and then retreat into folds as if the wearer is breathing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background rendered as a blurred, dark blur with shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static without any camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.024127785116434097 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.024127960205078 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.024127785116434097, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.024127785116434097, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22005198895931244, + 0.23684810101985931, + 0.04921161010861397, + 0.08138976991176605, + 0.07450902462005615, + 0.09018497914075851, + 0.08074168860912323, + 0.03617025166749954, + 0.08621775358915329, + 0.04467478394508362 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.024127785116434097 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a white cotton dress shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a single soft light source coming from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the fabric rhythmically expand upward and then retreat into folds as if the wearer is breathing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background rendered as a blurred, dark blur with shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static without any camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.179961159825325 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8049612045288086 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.179961159825325, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.179961159825325, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4123680591583252, + 0.12944838404655457, + 0.042826373130083084, + 0.04520208388566971, + 0.03333790600299835, + 0.036874379962682724, + 0.043278779834508896, + 0.11241938173770905, + 0.06607447564601898, + 0.07817021012306213 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.179961159825325 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a white cotton dress shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a single soft light source coming from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the fabric rhythmically expand upward and then retreat into folds as if the wearer is breathing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background rendered as a blurred, dark blur with shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static without any camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.043082013726234436 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680819988250732 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.043082013726234436, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.043082013726234436, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.40275365114212036, + 0.06162800267338753, + 0.029173964634537697, + 0.03955516219139099, + 0.04359006509184837, + 0.047666121274232864, + 0.07657518237829208, + 0.13993075489997864, + 0.03621289134025574, + 0.12291422486305237 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.043082013726234436 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a white cotton dress shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a single soft light source coming from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the fabric rhythmically expand upward and then retreat into folds as if the wearer is breathing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background rendered as a blurred, dark blur with shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static without any camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14287248253822327 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0178725719451904 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14287248253822327, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.8750001192092896, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14287248253822327, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.34695249795913696, + 0.29290029406547546, + 0.023883162066340446, + 0.1011132299900055, + 0.03826531395316124, + 0.05297818034887314, + 0.022875642403960228, + 0.09526804834604263, + 0.014727283269166946, + 0.011036363430321217 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14287248253822327 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a white cotton dress shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a single soft light source coming from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the fabric rhythmically expand upward and then retreat into folds as if the wearer is breathing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background rendered as a blurred, dark blur with shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static without any camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4743228554725647 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9743228554725647 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.4743228554725647, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.4743228554725647, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4712471663951874, + 0.12036275863647461, + 0.028121817857027054, + 0.05334967374801636, + 0.022648099809885025, + 0.020312875509262085, + 0.14348548650741577, + 0.04528476670384407, + 0.06123064458370209, + 0.03395673260092735 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.4743228554725647 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up static shot captures the intricate details of a crisp white cotton dress shirt. A single, soft light source from the side sweeps across the material, highlighting the delicate texture of the weave and creating a dynamic play of light and shadow. As the unseen wearer takes slow, deep breaths, the fabric rhythmically expands upward, the threads momentarily tensing before gently and deliberately retreating into soft, delicate folds as they exhale. This hypnotic, steady movement creates an atmosphere of profound calm and introspection, while the shallow depth of field renders the background a blurred, dark blur, focusing all attention on the quiet, active pulse of the fabric itself.", + "seed": 3419, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_5/index_8585_seed_3419_dp_10_rank_20_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.1425217416137457, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1425217416137457, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.675, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1425217416137457, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a white cotton dress shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a single soft light source coming from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the fabric rhythmically expand upward and then retreat into folds as if the wearer is breathing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background rendered as a blurred, dark blur with shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static without any camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.025800563395023346 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.025800704956055 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.025800563395023346, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.025800563395023346, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4184478521347046, + 0.1148022785782814, + 0.03830292075872421, + 0.06827840954065323, + 0.019085882231593132, + 0.02568134479224682, + 0.025451848283410072, + 0.03362829610705376, + 0.0981631949543953, + 0.15815794467926025 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.025800563395023346 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a white cotton dress shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a single soft light source coming from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the fabric rhythmically expand upward and then retreat into folds as if the wearer is breathing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background rendered as a blurred, dark blur with shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static without any camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07007083296775818 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695070743560791 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07007083296775818, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07007083296775818, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.650865375995636, + 0.09184751659631729, + 0.03951207175850868, + 0.02551136165857315, + 0.026564639061689377, + 0.034498780965805054, + 0.023705845698714256, + 0.02449951320886612, + 0.022895177826285362, + 0.06009963899850845 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07007083296775818 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a white cotton dress shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a single soft light source coming from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the fabric rhythmically expand upward and then retreat into folds as if the wearer is breathing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background rendered as a blurred, dark blur with shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static without any camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023303447291254997 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773303508758545 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023303447291254997, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023303447291254997, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08361632376909256, + 0.08670736849308014, + 0.0695817694067955, + 0.02332507260143757, + 0.04463570937514305, + 0.12275655567646027, + 0.03871357440948486, + 0.013266291469335556, + 0.030267823487520218, + 0.4871295094490051 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023303447291254997 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a white cotton dress shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a single soft light source coming from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the fabric rhythmically expand upward and then retreat into folds as if the wearer is breathing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background rendered as a blurred, dark blur with shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static without any camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07005883008241653 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695058822631836 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07005883008241653, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07005883008241653, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.31860801577568054, + 0.17987772822380066, + 0.11394517123699188, + 0.025623982772231102, + 0.10097822546958923, + 0.08236239105463028, + 0.029410608112812042, + 0.020407773554325104, + 0.0360429510474205, + 0.0927431657910347 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07005883008241653 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a white cotton dress shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a single soft light source coming from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the fabric rhythmically expand upward and then retreat into folds as if the wearer is breathing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background rendered as a blurred, dark blur with shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static without any camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5233750343322754 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8983750343322754 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5233750343322754, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5233750343322754, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5461165904998779, + 0.03825993835926056, + 0.08257950097322464, + 0.04374561831355095, + 0.0868162214756012, + 0.10985124856233597, + 0.014328590594232082, + 0.0059271082282066345, + 0.029104789718985558, + 0.04327042028307915 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5233750343322754 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up static shot captures the intricate details of a crisp white cotton dress shirt. A single, soft light source from the side sweeps across the material, highlighting the delicate texture of the weave and creating a dynamic play of light and shadow. As the unseen wearer takes slow, deep breaths, the fabric rhythmically expands upward, the threads momentarily tensing before gently and deliberately retreating into soft, delicate folds as they exhale. This hypnotic, steady movement creates an atmosphere of profound calm and introspection, while the shallow depth of field renders the background a blurred, dark blur, focusing all attention on the quiet, active pulse of the fabric itself.", + "seed": 3420, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_5/index_8585_seed_3420_dp_11_rank_22_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.13824824430048466, + "vlm_logprob": -0.13824824430048466, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.3, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.13824824430048466, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a white cotton dress shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a single soft light source coming from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the fabric rhythmically expand upward and then retreat into folds as if the wearer is breathing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background rendered as a blurred, dark blur with shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static without any camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.025842616334557533 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.9008426666259766 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.025842616334557533, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.025842616334557533, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14139655232429504, + 0.2650257647037506, + 0.033618588000535965, + 0.04043621942400932, + 0.014358704909682274, + 0.012387985363602638, + 0.028800297528505325, + 0.332077294588089, + 0.11142046749591827, + 0.020478110760450363 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.025842616334557533 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a white cotton dress shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a single soft light source coming from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the fabric rhythmically expand upward and then retreat into folds as if the wearer is breathing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background rendered as a blurred, dark blur with shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static without any camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.31351208686828613 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3135120868682861 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.31351208686828613, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.31351208686828613, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1331060826778412, + 0.35485729575157166, + 0.04781735688447952, + 0.04051995277404785, + 0.017939863726496696, + 0.01910625584423542, + 0.02236819826066494, + 0.2069731503725052, + 0.11808032542467117, + 0.03923152759671211 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.31351208686828613 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a white cotton dress shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a single soft light source coming from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the fabric rhythmically expand upward and then retreat into folds as if the wearer is breathing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background rendered as a blurred, dark blur with shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static without any camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14283889532089233 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.017838954925537 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14283889532089233, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14283889532089233, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.02825208380818367, + 0.5651991367340088, + 0.016362903639674187, + 0.0133147481828928, + 0.004980298690497875, + 0.012955131009221077, + 0.010908378288149834, + 0.12281949818134308, + 0.19048309326171875, + 0.03472475707530975 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14283889532089233 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a white cotton dress shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a single soft light source coming from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the fabric rhythmically expand upward and then retreat into folds as if the wearer is breathing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background rendered as a blurred, dark blur with shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static without any camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04868236929178238 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048682451248169 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04868236929178238, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04868236929178238, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11652307212352753, + 0.2586124539375305, + 0.06898666173219681, + 0.042802147567272186, + 0.03855150565505028, + 0.020925385877490044, + 0.02767893671989441, + 0.2977703809738159, + 0.08401785045862198, + 0.04413168877363205 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04868236929178238 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a white cotton dress shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a single soft light source coming from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the fabric rhythmically expand upward and then retreat into folds as if the wearer is breathing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background rendered as a blurred, dark blur with shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static without any camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1603652536869049 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9103652238845825 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1603652536869049, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1603652536869049, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.030226029455661774, + 0.5599172711372375, + 0.025614699348807335, + 0.022473162040114403, + 0.008215207606554031, + 0.011376485228538513, + 0.011041302233934402, + 0.2987805902957916, + 0.019038211554288864, + 0.013317056000232697 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1603652536869049 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up static shot captures the intricate details of a crisp white cotton dress shirt. A single, soft light source from the side sweeps across the material, highlighting the delicate texture of the weave and creating a dynamic play of light and shadow. As the unseen wearer takes slow, deep breaths, the fabric rhythmically expands upward, the threads momentarily tensing before gently and deliberately retreating into soft, delicate folds as they exhale. This hypnotic, steady movement creates an atmosphere of profound calm and introspection, while the shallow depth of field renders the background a blurred, dark blur, focusing all attention on the quiet, active pulse of the fabric itself.", + "seed": 3421, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_5/index_8585_seed_3421_dp_11_rank_22_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.2027292661368847, + "vlm_logprob": -0.2027292661368847, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.375, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.2027292661368847, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a white cotton dress shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a single soft light source coming from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the fabric rhythmically expand upward and then retreat into folds as if the wearer is breathing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background rendered as a blurred, dark blur with shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static without any camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.024899818003177643 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.024899959564209 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.024899818003177643, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.024899818003177643, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08398662507534027, + 0.04541662707924843, + 0.05678100511431694, + 0.03973345458507538, + 0.2849501371383667, + 0.10948998481035233, + 0.1330621838569641, + 0.06177137419581413, + 0.1136004626750946, + 0.07120806723833084 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.024899818003177643 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a white cotton dress shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a single soft light source coming from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the fabric rhythmically expand upward and then retreat into folds as if the wearer is breathing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background rendered as a blurred, dark blur with shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static without any camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07008394598960876 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950838565826416 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07008394598960876, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07008394598960876, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13003110885620117, + 0.26242998242378235, + 0.10200885683298111, + 0.06691684573888779, + 0.04260953888297081, + 0.03615882992744446, + 0.17208148539066315, + 0.06222553551197052, + 0.038051944226026535, + 0.0874858871102333 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07008394598960876 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a white cotton dress shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a single soft light source coming from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the fabric rhythmically expand upward and then retreat into folds as if the wearer is breathing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background rendered as a blurred, dark blur with shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static without any camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.033713776618242264 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4087138175964355 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.033713776618242264, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.033713776618242264, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0640668123960495, + 0.09089432656764984, + 0.03537168353796005, + 0.025420114398002625, + 0.27334338426589966, + 0.2849528193473816, + 0.07611463218927383, + 0.06990709155797958, + 0.06264976412057877, + 0.01727929152548313 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.033713776618242264 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a white cotton dress shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a single soft light source coming from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the fabric rhythmically expand upward and then retreat into folds as if the wearer is breathing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background rendered as a blurred, dark blur with shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static without any camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12709099054336548 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1270909309387207 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12709099054336548, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12709099054336548, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0508929006755352, + 0.029258962720632553, + 0.0621168315410614, + 0.01307877991348505, + 0.6649080514907837, + 0.029070481657981873, + 0.09179671853780746, + 0.025823011994361877, + 0.019854778423905373, + 0.013199503533542156 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12709099054336548 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a white cotton dress shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a single soft light source coming from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the fabric rhythmically expand upward and then retreat into folds as if the wearer is breathing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background rendered as a blurred, dark blur with shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static without any camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7578577995300293 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6328577995300293 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.7578577995300293, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.7578577995300293, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04120178893208504, + 0.07278287410736084, + 0.016536671668291092, + 0.024197762832045555, + 0.732416033744812, + 0.018034419044852257, + 0.018077543005347252, + 0.017831236124038696, + 0.04728095605969429, + 0.011640788987278938 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.7578577995300293 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_6/index_tensor([2232, 2232])_group_6_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_6/index_tensor([2232, 2232])_group_6_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..4398f707e7a044d419ff1ab17130be30a8ae95f4 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_6/index_tensor([2232, 2232])_group_6_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "static medium shot, with a delicate, hand-painted quality, focuses on an ancient chain bridge spanning a bottomless chasm. In the faint, cool, diffuse light of predawn, the thick iron chains are covered in dark brown rust, as if frozen in the wounds of time. The wooden planks beneath are severely rotted, their edges jagged. Cracks intertwined with damp moss reveal dangerous gaps, and a glimpse of the thin morning mist curling below. Countless cold dewdrops carefully condense on the rusted metal and decaying wood, each like a tiny crystal, coalescing into a larger droplet before dangling precariously on the edge, shimmering with a chilling light. The overall image is dominated by a cold palette of rusty browns, the gray of decaying wood, and the off-white of mist. Every detail—from the rust on the chains to the cracks in the planks—is clearly visible, creating an atmosphere of profound loneliness and melancholy, like a delicate painting silently telling a forgotten story.", + "seed": 11694, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_6/index_2232_seed_11694_dp_12_rank_24_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.0747945160139352, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0747945160139352, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.45, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0747945160139352, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a static medium shot of an ancient chain bridge spanning a chasm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the iron chains covered in dark brown rust and the wooden planks severely rotted with jagged edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment illuminated by faint, cool, diffuse light of predawn with morning mist curling below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are cold dewdrops visible condensing on the rusted metal and decaying wood, shimmering with a chilling light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the image have a delicate, hand-painted quality with a cold palette of rusty browns, gray wood, and off-white mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2531558573246002 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5031558275222778 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2531558573246002, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2531558573246002, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1035451889038086, + 0.395706444978714, + 0.01937202736735344, + 0.03492254018783569, + 0.03394204378128052, + 0.06374223530292511, + 0.045557212084531784, + 0.02198941633105278, + 0.1620226502418518, + 0.11920022964477539 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2531558573246002 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a static medium shot of an ancient chain bridge spanning a chasm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the iron chains covered in dark brown rust and the wooden planks severely rotted with jagged edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment illuminated by faint, cool, diffuse light of predawn with morning mist curling below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are cold dewdrops visible condensing on the rusted metal and decaying wood, shimmering with a chilling light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the image have a delicate, hand-painted quality with a cold palette of rusty browns, gray wood, and off-white mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.062051981687545776 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812052011489868 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.062051981687545776, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.062051981687545776, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09233419597148895, + 0.07117701321840286, + 0.04410975053906441, + 0.028545919805765152, + 0.05699634179472923, + 0.030717717483639717, + 0.028282994404435158, + 0.026815984398126602, + 0.34813880920410156, + 0.2728812098503113 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.062051981687545776 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a static medium shot of an ancient chain bridge spanning a chasm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the iron chains covered in dark brown rust and the wooden planks severely rotted with jagged edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment illuminated by faint, cool, diffuse light of predawn with morning mist curling below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are cold dewdrops visible condensing on the rusted metal and decaying wood, shimmering with a chilling light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the image have a delicate, hand-painted quality with a cold palette of rusty browns, gray wood, and off-white mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018181685358285904 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018181800842285 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018181685358285904, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018181685358285904, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15716300904750824, + 0.12252704799175262, + 0.03997983783483505, + 0.07127122581005096, + 0.06869825720787048, + 0.07939177006483078, + 0.0390416644513607, + 0.031535208225250244, + 0.1633419692516327, + 0.22704996168613434 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018181685358285904 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a static medium shot of an ancient chain bridge spanning a chasm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the iron chains covered in dark brown rust and the wooden planks severely rotted with jagged edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment illuminated by faint, cool, diffuse light of predawn with morning mist curling below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are cold dewdrops visible condensing on the rusted metal and decaying wood, shimmering with a chilling light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the image have a delicate, hand-painted quality with a cold palette of rusty browns, gray wood, and off-white mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03809741511940956 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288097381591797 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03809741511940956, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03809741511940956, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06831581890583038, + 0.023864541202783585, + 0.01756899617612362, + 0.049631182104349136, + 0.02313154563307762, + 0.034786056727170944, + 0.03283841907978058, + 0.024674303829669952, + 0.5722593665122986, + 0.15292979776859283 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03809741511940956 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a static medium shot of an ancient chain bridge spanning a chasm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the iron chains covered in dark brown rust and the wooden planks severely rotted with jagged edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment illuminated by faint, cool, diffuse light of predawn with morning mist curling below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are cold dewdrops visible condensing on the rusted metal and decaying wood, shimmering with a chilling light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the image have a delicate, hand-painted quality with a cold palette of rusty browns, gray wood, and off-white mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0024856405798345804 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002485752105713 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0024856405798345804, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0024856405798345804, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09894728660583496, + 0.07954984158277512, + 0.02744305692613125, + 0.05114543437957764, + 0.06997960805892944, + 0.05027385428547859, + 0.03527410328388214, + 0.027606308460235596, + 0.4546598494052887, + 0.10512059181928635 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0024856405798345804 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static medium shot, with a delicate, hand-painted quality, focuses on an ancient chain bridge spanning a bottomless chasm. In the faint, cool, diffuse light of predawn, the thick iron chains are covered in dark brown rust, as if frozen in the wounds of time. The wooden planks beneath are severely rotted, their edges jagged. Cracks intertwined with damp moss reveal dangerous gaps, and a glimpse of the thin morning mist curling below. Countless cold dewdrops carefully condense on the rusted metal and decaying wood, each like a tiny crystal, coalescing into a larger droplet before dangling precariously on the edge, shimmering with a chilling light. The overall image is dominated by a cold palette of rusty browns, the gray of decaying wood, and the off-white of mist. Every detail—from the rust on the chains to the cracks in the planks—is clearly visible, creating an atmosphere of profound loneliness and melancholy, like a delicate painting silently telling a forgotten story.", + "seed": 11695, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_6/index_2232_seed_11695_dp_12_rank_24_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.10192209342494607, + "vlm_logprob": -0.10192209342494607, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.275, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.10192209342494607, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a static medium shot of an ancient chain bridge spanning a chasm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the iron chains covered in dark brown rust and the wooden planks severely rotted with jagged edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment illuminated by faint, cool, diffuse light of predawn with morning mist curling below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are cold dewdrops visible condensing on the rusted metal and decaying wood, shimmering with a chilling light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the image have a delicate, hand-painted quality with a cold palette of rusty browns, gray wood, and off-white mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.35112467408180237 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.22612464427948 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.35112467408180237, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.35112467408180237, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11208585649728775, + 0.28659602999687195, + 0.04624386131763458, + 0.1146964356303215, + 0.017774945124983788, + 0.01663420908153057, + 0.027796154841780663, + 0.09678768366575241, + 0.08162347227334976, + 0.19976140558719635 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.35112467408180237 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a static medium shot of an ancient chain bridge spanning a chasm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the iron chains covered in dark brown rust and the wooden planks severely rotted with jagged edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment illuminated by faint, cool, diffuse light of predawn with morning mist curling below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are cold dewdrops visible condensing on the rusted metal and decaying wood, shimmering with a chilling light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the image have a delicate, hand-painted quality with a cold palette of rusty browns, gray wood, and off-white mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011085116304457188 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511085033416748 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011085116304457188, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011085116304457188, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13237863779067993, + 0.22523200511932373, + 0.09776066243648529, + 0.20126061141490936, + 0.042181555181741714, + 0.028859611600637436, + 0.034965500235557556, + 0.053965795785188675, + 0.04753873124718666, + 0.13585691154003143 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011085116304457188 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a static medium shot of an ancient chain bridge spanning a chasm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the iron chains covered in dark brown rust and the wooden planks severely rotted with jagged edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment illuminated by faint, cool, diffuse light of predawn with morning mist curling below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are cold dewdrops visible condensing on the rusted metal and decaying wood, shimmering with a chilling light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the image have a delicate, hand-painted quality with a cold palette of rusty browns, gray wood, and off-white mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02980804070830345 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298080444335938 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02980804070830345, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02980804070830345, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11506006121635437, + 0.17142491042613983, + 0.24244758486747742, + 0.2626768946647644, + 0.021558688953518867, + 0.015873584896326065, + 0.014785688370466232, + 0.04097392410039902, + 0.0246061310172081, + 0.09059257060289383 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02980804070830345 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a static medium shot of an ancient chain bridge spanning a chasm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the iron chains covered in dark brown rust and the wooden planks severely rotted with jagged edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment illuminated by faint, cool, diffuse light of predawn with morning mist curling below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are cold dewdrops visible condensing on the rusted metal and decaying wood, shimmering with a chilling light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the image have a delicate, hand-painted quality with a cold palette of rusty browns, gray wood, and off-white mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11295662075281143 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2379565238952637 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11295662075281143, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11295662075281143, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09568580985069275, + 0.13270623981952667, + 0.2703199088573456, + 0.22635361552238464, + 0.016993071883916855, + 0.05147423967719078, + 0.03768574818968773, + 0.0630548819899559, + 0.03139301389455795, + 0.07433351874351501 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11295662075281143 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a static medium shot of an ancient chain bridge spanning a chasm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the iron chains covered in dark brown rust and the wooden planks severely rotted with jagged edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment illuminated by faint, cool, diffuse light of predawn with morning mist curling below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are cold dewdrops visible condensing on the rusted metal and decaying wood, shimmering with a chilling light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the image have a delicate, hand-painted quality with a cold palette of rusty browns, gray wood, and off-white mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004636015277355909 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379635810852051 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004636015277355909, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004636015277355909, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1391633301973343, + 0.17807959020137787, + 0.04457418620586395, + 0.16689744591712952, + 0.029680855572223663, + 0.04096727445721626, + 0.037951864302158356, + 0.12481752038002014, + 0.11553432047367096, + 0.12233361601829529 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004636015277355909 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static medium shot, with a delicate, hand-painted quality, focuses on an ancient chain bridge spanning a bottomless chasm. In the faint, cool, diffuse light of predawn, the thick iron chains are covered in dark brown rust, as if frozen in the wounds of time. The wooden planks beneath are severely rotted, their edges jagged. Cracks intertwined with damp moss reveal dangerous gaps, and a glimpse of the thin morning mist curling below. Countless cold dewdrops carefully condense on the rusted metal and decaying wood, each like a tiny crystal, coalescing into a larger droplet before dangling precariously on the edge, shimmering with a chilling light. The overall image is dominated by a cold palette of rusty browns, the gray of decaying wood, and the off-white of mist. Every detail—from the rust on the chains to the cracks in the planks—is clearly visible, creating an atmosphere of profound loneliness and melancholy, like a delicate painting silently telling a forgotten story.", + "seed": 11696, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_6/index_2232_seed_11696_dp_13_rank_26_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.08880527596920729, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08880527596920729, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.05, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08880527596920729, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a static medium shot of an ancient chain bridge spanning a chasm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the iron chains covered in dark brown rust and the wooden planks severely rotted with jagged edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment illuminated by faint, cool, diffuse light of predawn with morning mist curling below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are cold dewdrops visible condensing on the rusted metal and decaying wood, shimmering with a chilling light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the image have a delicate, hand-painted quality with a cold palette of rusty browns, gray wood, and off-white mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.09086183458566666 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4658617973327637 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.09086183458566666, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.09086183458566666, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.27350398898124695, + 0.04256920889019966, + 0.10446090251207352, + 0.07043489813804626, + 0.20071467757225037, + 0.07333285361528397, + 0.03590662032365799, + 0.024763304740190506, + 0.024680325761437416, + 0.14963316917419434 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.09086183458566666 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a static medium shot of an ancient chain bridge spanning a chasm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the iron chains covered in dark brown rust and the wooden planks severely rotted with jagged edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment illuminated by faint, cool, diffuse light of predawn with morning mist curling below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are cold dewdrops visible condensing on the rusted metal and decaying wood, shimmering with a chilling light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the image have a delicate, hand-painted quality with a cold palette of rusty browns, gray wood, and off-white mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02635873481631279 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513588428497314 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02635873481631279, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02635873481631279, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18918193876743317, + 0.12417590618133545, + 0.03286926448345184, + 0.035736680030822754, + 0.08497606962919235, + 0.01671660505235195, + 0.12719063460826874, + 0.08095324039459229, + 0.0755818784236908, + 0.23261785507202148 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02635873481631279 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a static medium shot of an ancient chain bridge spanning a chasm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the iron chains covered in dark brown rust and the wooden planks severely rotted with jagged edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment illuminated by faint, cool, diffuse light of predawn with morning mist curling below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are cold dewdrops visible condensing on the rusted metal and decaying wood, shimmering with a chilling light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the image have a delicate, hand-painted quality with a cold palette of rusty browns, gray wood, and off-white mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07003804296255112 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695038080215454 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07003804296255112, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07003804296255112, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12534929811954498, + 0.019675124436616898, + 0.1407392919063568, + 0.03114566206932068, + 0.13693605363368988, + 0.013855024240911007, + 0.093452088534832, + 0.024089166894555092, + 0.017667874693870544, + 0.39709046483039856 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07003804296255112 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a static medium shot of an ancient chain bridge spanning a chasm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the iron chains covered in dark brown rust and the wooden planks severely rotted with jagged edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment illuminated by faint, cool, diffuse light of predawn with morning mist curling below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are cold dewdrops visible condensing on the rusted metal and decaying wood, shimmering with a chilling light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the image have a delicate, hand-painted quality with a cold palette of rusty browns, gray wood, and off-white mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.25213009119033813 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5021300315856934 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.25213009119033813, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.25213009119033813, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14507026970386505, + 0.032920703291893005, + 0.3293243646621704, + 0.014769117347896099, + 0.15095368027687073, + 0.013549504801630974, + 0.07491496205329895, + 0.029888076707720757, + 0.017637748271226883, + 0.19097156822681427 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.25213009119033813 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a static medium shot of an ancient chain bridge spanning a chasm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the iron chains covered in dark brown rust and the wooden planks severely rotted with jagged edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment illuminated by faint, cool, diffuse light of predawn with morning mist curling below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are cold dewdrops visible condensing on the rusted metal and decaying wood, shimmering with a chilling light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the image have a delicate, hand-painted quality with a cold palette of rusty browns, gray wood, and off-white mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004637676291167736 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379637718200684 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004637676291167736, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004637676291167736, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.36817216873168945, + 0.06064847111701965, + 0.053352776914834976, + 0.0303688645362854, + 0.11283376812934875, + 0.02018878422677517, + 0.19992826879024506, + 0.025045692920684814, + 0.0356709323823452, + 0.09379025548696518 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004637676291167736 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static medium shot, with a delicate, hand-painted quality, focuses on an ancient chain bridge spanning a bottomless chasm. In the faint, cool, diffuse light of predawn, the thick iron chains are covered in dark brown rust, as if frozen in the wounds of time. The wooden planks beneath are severely rotted, their edges jagged. Cracks intertwined with damp moss reveal dangerous gaps, and a glimpse of the thin morning mist curling below. Countless cold dewdrops carefully condense on the rusted metal and decaying wood, each like a tiny crystal, coalescing into a larger droplet before dangling precariously on the edge, shimmering with a chilling light. The overall image is dominated by a cold palette of rusty browns, the gray of decaying wood, and the off-white of mist. Every detail—from the rust on the chains to the cracks in the planks—is clearly visible, creating an atmosphere of profound loneliness and melancholy, like a delicate painting silently telling a forgotten story.", + "seed": 11697, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_6/index_2232_seed_11697_dp_13_rank_26_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.150710894074291, + "vlm_logprob": -0.150710894074291, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.650000011920929, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.150710894074291, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a static medium shot of an ancient chain bridge spanning a chasm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the iron chains covered in dark brown rust and the wooden planks severely rotted with jagged edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment illuminated by faint, cool, diffuse light of predawn with morning mist curling below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are cold dewdrops visible condensing on the rusted metal and decaying wood, shimmering with a chilling light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the image have a delicate, hand-painted quality with a cold palette of rusty browns, gray wood, and off-white mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4302610754966736 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.0552611351013184 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.4302610754966736, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.6250000596046448, + "token_credit_reward": -0.4302610754966736, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5950122475624084, + 0.01942957006394863, + 0.03955121710896492, + 0.19913265109062195, + 0.010562101379036903, + 0.027659643441438675, + 0.020308103412389755, + 0.012846688739955425, + 0.05273216962814331, + 0.02276565134525299 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.4302610754966736 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a static medium shot of an ancient chain bridge spanning a chasm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the iron chains covered in dark brown rust and the wooden planks severely rotted with jagged edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment illuminated by faint, cool, diffuse light of predawn with morning mist curling below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are cold dewdrops visible condensing on the rusted metal and decaying wood, shimmering with a chilling light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the image have a delicate, hand-painted quality with a cold palette of rusty browns, gray wood, and off-white mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.048670221120119095 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486702919006348 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.048670221120119095, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.048670221120119095, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.33251598477363586, + 0.013562489300966263, + 0.03496725112199783, + 0.06757800281047821, + 0.005189672112464905, + 0.36968034505844116, + 0.07853267341852188, + 0.06181098148226738, + 0.03008231706917286, + 0.006080362945795059 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.048670221120119095 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a static medium shot of an ancient chain bridge spanning a chasm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the iron chains covered in dark brown rust and the wooden planks severely rotted with jagged edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment illuminated by faint, cool, diffuse light of predawn with morning mist curling below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are cold dewdrops visible condensing on the rusted metal and decaying wood, shimmering with a chilling light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the image have a delicate, hand-painted quality with a cold palette of rusty browns, gray wood, and off-white mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.043075159192085266 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680750846862793 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.043075159192085266, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.043075159192085266, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5756579041481018, + 0.013050715439021587, + 0.04273238033056259, + 0.058417852967977524, + 0.007295561488717794, + 0.2292657047510147, + 0.018017485737800598, + 0.02499164454638958, + 0.02185240387916565, + 0.008718246594071388 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.043075159192085266 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a static medium shot of an ancient chain bridge spanning a chasm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the iron chains covered in dark brown rust and the wooden planks severely rotted with jagged edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment illuminated by faint, cool, diffuse light of predawn with morning mist curling below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are cold dewdrops visible condensing on the rusted metal and decaying wood, shimmering with a chilling light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the image have a delicate, hand-painted quality with a cold palette of rusty browns, gray wood, and off-white mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22559919953346252 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6005991697311401 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.22559919953346252, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.22559919953346252, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1549386829137802, + 0.04272526502609253, + 0.03599720820784569, + 0.12130078673362732, + 0.011945999227464199, + 0.47731533646583557, + 0.03732771798968315, + 0.04316403716802597, + 0.06335199624300003, + 0.01193290576338768 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.22559919953346252 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a static medium shot of an ancient chain bridge spanning a chasm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the iron chains covered in dark brown rust and the wooden planks severely rotted with jagged edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment illuminated by faint, cool, diffuse light of predawn with morning mist curling below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are cold dewdrops visible condensing on the rusted metal and decaying wood, shimmering with a chilling light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the image have a delicate, hand-painted quality with a cold palette of rusty browns, gray wood, and off-white mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005948815029114485 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130949020385742 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005948815029114485, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005948815029114485, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.7590658068656921, + 0.012325332500040531, + 0.04498424008488655, + 0.024456070736050606, + 0.009631556458771229, + 0.07883026450872421, + 0.024045821279287338, + 0.006566712167114019, + 0.03198720142245293, + 0.008107010275125504 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005948815029114485 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_7/index_tensor([6394, 6394])_group_7_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_7/index_tensor([6394, 6394])_group_7_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..f5a8992ff7cb8135982db3402c8bbd57a8a65328 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_7/index_tensor([6394, 6394])_group_7_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "static, low-angle shot focuses on the iconic vermilion walls of the Forbidden City. Warm afternoon sunlight slants down, casting soft shadows across the towering, majestic facades. A plump pigeon paces along the time-worn, blue-gray stone pavement with a leisurely pace. Its gray-white feathers appear remarkably clean in the sunlight, and its neck gleams with metallic green and purple with each step. With each step, its head rhythmically sways back and forth, its bright, alert orange-red eyes perpetually observing its surroundings. Suddenly, it pauses, briefly surveying its surroundings. With swift and precise movements, it lowers its head and pecks at the barely visible crumbs of food lurking in the cracks between the stone slabs with its dark gray beak. The movement is clean and precise, and it immediately raises its head to resume its leisurely demeanor. The whole scene presents a tranquil and solemn atmosphere. The magnificent historical buildings and the small but vibrant life form a sharp and harmonious contrast, creating a peaceful beauty as if time has stopped.", + "seed": 10720, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_7/index_6394_seed_10720_dp_14_rank_28_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.1003491347655654, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1003491347655654, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.15, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1003491347655654, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a static, low-angle perspective focusing on the vermilion walls of the Forbidden City?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a plump pigeon with clean gray-white feathers and metallic green-purple neck iridescence visible pacing on blue-gray stone pavement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the pigeon exhibit rhythmic head swaying, bright orange-red eyes, and peck at crumbs with a dark gray beak?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm afternoon sunlight casting soft shadows on the facades?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video maintain a static camera position throughout the sequence without panning or zooming?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.23002177476882935 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6050217151641846 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.23002177476882935, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.23002177476882935, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.8214832544326782, + 0.052462778985500336, + 0.0114555973559618, + 0.010080041363835335, + 0.021057341247797012, + 0.022304518148303032, + 0.020688064396381378, + 0.017445959150791168, + 0.01374628022313118, + 0.00927614513784647 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.23002177476882935 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a static, low-angle perspective focusing on the vermilion walls of the Forbidden City?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a plump pigeon with clean gray-white feathers and metallic green-purple neck iridescence visible pacing on blue-gray stone pavement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the pigeon exhibit rhythmic head swaying, bright orange-red eyes, and peck at crumbs with a dark gray beak?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm afternoon sunlight casting soft shadows on the facades?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video maintain a static camera position throughout the sequence without panning or zooming?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004114021547138691 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504114151000977 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004114021547138691, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004114021547138691, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.8353070020675659, + 0.031040221452713013, + 0.011599753983318806, + 0.009868910536170006, + 0.022316480055451393, + 0.03755848482251167, + 0.010836918838322163, + 0.023721681907773018, + 0.011330794543027878, + 0.006419816054403782 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004114021547138691 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a static, low-angle perspective focusing on the vermilion walls of the Forbidden City?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a plump pigeon with clean gray-white feathers and metallic green-purple neck iridescence visible pacing on blue-gray stone pavement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the pigeon exhibit rhythmic head swaying, bright orange-red eyes, and peck at crumbs with a dark gray beak?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm afternoon sunlight casting soft shadows on the facades?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video maintain a static camera position throughout the sequence without panning or zooming?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011080047115683556 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511080265045166 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011080047115683556, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011080047115683556, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.7865742444992065, + 0.02769864909350872, + 0.016179054975509644, + 0.01408684253692627, + 0.029989322647452354, + 0.051656998693943024, + 0.023087194189429283, + 0.021562129259109497, + 0.015520463697612286, + 0.013645125553011894 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011080047115683556 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a static, low-angle perspective focusing on the vermilion walls of the Forbidden City?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a plump pigeon with clean gray-white feathers and metallic green-purple neck iridescence visible pacing on blue-gray stone pavement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the pigeon exhibit rhythmic head swaying, bright orange-red eyes, and peck at crumbs with a dark gray beak?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm afternoon sunlight casting soft shadows on the facades?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video maintain a static camera position throughout the sequence without panning or zooming?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05497167259454727 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929971694946289 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05497167259454727, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05497167259454727, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.9225488305091858, + 0.02685774676501751, + 0.004014942795038223, + 0.008058428764343262, + 0.009256417863070965, + 0.009427479468286037, + 0.0035275951959192753, + 0.007994499988853931, + 0.004647588822990656, + 0.003666435368359089 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05497167259454727 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a static, low-angle perspective focusing on the vermilion walls of the Forbidden City?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a plump pigeon with clean gray-white feathers and metallic green-purple neck iridescence visible pacing on blue-gray stone pavement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the pigeon exhibit rhythmic head swaying, bright orange-red eyes, and peck at crumbs with a dark gray beak?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm afternoon sunlight casting soft shadows on the facades?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video maintain a static camera position throughout the sequence without panning or zooming?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2015581578016281 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7015581130981445 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2015581578016281, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2015581578016281, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5639053583145142, + 0.03702688589692116, + 0.05726495385169983, + 0.04077273979783058, + 0.06893633306026459, + 0.04193546622991562, + 0.05634637922048569, + 0.08271441608667374, + 0.031148571521043777, + 0.019948959350585938 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2015581578016281 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, low-angle shot focuses on the iconic vermilion walls of the Forbidden City. Warm afternoon sunlight slants down, casting soft shadows across the towering, majestic facades. A plump pigeon paces along the time-worn, blue-gray stone pavement with a leisurely pace. Its gray-white feathers appear remarkably clean in the sunlight, and its neck gleams with metallic green and purple with each step. With each step, its head rhythmically sways back and forth, its bright, alert orange-red eyes perpetually observing its surroundings. Suddenly, it pauses, briefly surveying its surroundings. With swift and precise movements, it lowers its head and pecks at the barely visible crumbs of food lurking in the cracks between the stone slabs with its dark gray beak. The movement is clean and precise, and it immediately raises its head to resume its leisurely demeanor. The whole scene presents a tranquil and solemn atmosphere. The magnificent historical buildings and the small but vibrant life form a sharp and harmonious contrast, creating a peaceful beauty as if time has stopped.", + "seed": 10721, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_7/index_6394_seed_10721_dp_14_rank_28_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.16049754992127419, + "vlm_logprob": -0.16049754992127419, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.975, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.16049754992127419, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a static, low-angle perspective focusing on the vermilion walls of the Forbidden City?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a plump pigeon with clean gray-white feathers and metallic green-purple neck iridescence visible pacing on blue-gray stone pavement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the pigeon exhibit rhythmic head swaying, bright orange-red eyes, and peck at crumbs with a dark gray beak?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm afternoon sunlight casting soft shadows on the facades?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video maintain a static camera position throughout the sequence without panning or zooming?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6439810991287231 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7689810991287231 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.6439810991287231, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.6439810991287231, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18743783235549927, + 0.28656914830207825, + 0.03464227542281151, + 0.22717240452766418, + 0.10038388520479202, + 0.041359372437000275, + 0.03927738592028618, + 0.02395402453839779, + 0.02788090519607067, + 0.03132270276546478 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.6439810991287231 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a static, low-angle perspective focusing on the vermilion walls of the Forbidden City?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a plump pigeon with clean gray-white feathers and metallic green-purple neck iridescence visible pacing on blue-gray stone pavement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the pigeon exhibit rhythmic head swaying, bright orange-red eyes, and peck at crumbs with a dark gray beak?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm afternoon sunlight casting soft shadows on the facades?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video maintain a static camera position throughout the sequence without panning or zooming?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007660536095499992 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882660388946533 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007660536095499992, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007660536095499992, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22307856380939484, + 0.04959575831890106, + 0.11789120733737946, + 0.08959969133138657, + 0.34632226824760437, + 0.0365813709795475, + 0.022983569651842117, + 0.018351096659898758, + 0.061266329139471054, + 0.0343300886452198 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007660536095499992 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a static, low-angle perspective focusing on the vermilion walls of the Forbidden City?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a plump pigeon with clean gray-white feathers and metallic green-purple neck iridescence visible pacing on blue-gray stone pavement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the pigeon exhibit rhythmic head swaying, bright orange-red eyes, and peck at crumbs with a dark gray beak?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm afternoon sunlight casting soft shadows on the facades?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video maintain a static camera position throughout the sequence without panning or zooming?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009791677817702293 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634791851043701 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009791677817702293, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009791677817702293, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1236448734998703, + 0.07696721702814102, + 0.14315766096115112, + 0.20562779903411865, + 0.09342076629400253, + 0.12371702492237091, + 0.048196908086538315, + 0.07042896747589111, + 0.046121206134557724, + 0.06871756911277771 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009791677817702293 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a static, low-angle perspective focusing on the vermilion walls of the Forbidden City?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a plump pigeon with clean gray-white feathers and metallic green-purple neck iridescence visible pacing on blue-gray stone pavement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the pigeon exhibit rhythmic head swaying, bright orange-red eyes, and peck at crumbs with a dark gray beak?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm afternoon sunlight casting soft shadows on the facades?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video maintain a static camera position throughout the sequence without panning or zooming?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06207237392663956 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812072277069092 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06207237392663956, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06207237392663956, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.42498016357421875, + 0.143638014793396, + 0.05078822001814842, + 0.22224442660808563, + 0.039838239550590515, + 0.035595159977674484, + 0.01584370993077755, + 0.022237034514546394, + 0.009884454309940338, + 0.03495059162378311 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06207237392663956 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a static, low-angle perspective focusing on the vermilion walls of the Forbidden City?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a plump pigeon with clean gray-white feathers and metallic green-purple neck iridescence visible pacing on blue-gray stone pavement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the pigeon exhibit rhythmic head swaying, bright orange-red eyes, and peck at crumbs with a dark gray beak?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm afternoon sunlight casting soft shadows on the facades?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video maintain a static camera position throughout the sequence without panning or zooming?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07898206263780594 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.57898211479187 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07898206263780594, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07898206263780594, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15258453786373138, + 0.1463068425655365, + 0.038576122373342514, + 0.15936526656150818, + 0.2091660499572754, + 0.10078256577253342, + 0.03362391144037247, + 0.022725190967321396, + 0.02541187033057213, + 0.11145757138729095 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07898206263780594 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, low-angle shot focuses on the iconic vermilion walls of the Forbidden City. Warm afternoon sunlight slants down, casting soft shadows across the towering, majestic facades. A plump pigeon paces along the time-worn, blue-gray stone pavement with a leisurely pace. Its gray-white feathers appear remarkably clean in the sunlight, and its neck gleams with metallic green and purple with each step. With each step, its head rhythmically sways back and forth, its bright, alert orange-red eyes perpetually observing its surroundings. Suddenly, it pauses, briefly surveying its surroundings. With swift and precise movements, it lowers its head and pecks at the barely visible crumbs of food lurking in the cracks between the stone slabs with its dark gray beak. The movement is clean and precise, and it immediately raises its head to resume its leisurely demeanor. The whole scene presents a tranquil and solemn atmosphere. The magnificent historical buildings and the small but vibrant life form a sharp and harmonious contrast, creating a peaceful beauty as if time has stopped.", + "seed": 10722, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_7/index_6394_seed_10722_dp_15_rank_30_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.13992680413648487, + "vlm_logprob": -0.13992680413648487, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.825, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.13992680413648487, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a static, low-angle perspective focusing on the vermilion walls of the Forbidden City?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a plump pigeon with clean gray-white feathers and metallic green-purple neck iridescence visible pacing on blue-gray stone pavement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the pigeon exhibit rhythmic head swaying, bright orange-red eyes, and peck at crumbs with a dark gray beak?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm afternoon sunlight casting soft shadows on the facades?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video maintain a static camera position throughout the sequence without panning or zooming?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20603299140930176 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7060329914093018 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20603299140930176, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20603299140930176, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08653594553470612, + 0.07106071710586548, + 0.09568639099597931, + 0.1367151290178299, + 0.19822295010089874, + 0.03336670249700546, + 0.10521429032087326, + 0.1049278974533081, + 0.11770530045032501, + 0.05056470260024071 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20603299140930176 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a static, low-angle perspective focusing on the vermilion walls of the Forbidden City?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a plump pigeon with clean gray-white feathers and metallic green-purple neck iridescence visible pacing on blue-gray stone pavement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the pigeon exhibit rhythmic head swaying, bright orange-red eyes, and peck at crumbs with a dark gray beak?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm afternoon sunlight casting soft shadows on the facades?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video maintain a static camera position throughout the sequence without panning or zooming?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009805961512029171 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634806156158447 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009805961512029171, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009805961512029171, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1212930828332901, + 0.0606674998998642, + 0.07163118571043015, + 0.14861994981765747, + 0.04841507598757744, + 0.2993766665458679, + 0.1020750030875206, + 0.05362026020884514, + 0.06950321793556213, + 0.024797996506094933 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009805961512029171 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a static, low-angle perspective focusing on the vermilion walls of the Forbidden City?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a plump pigeon with clean gray-white feathers and metallic green-purple neck iridescence visible pacing on blue-gray stone pavement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the pigeon exhibit rhythmic head swaying, bright orange-red eyes, and peck at crumbs with a dark gray beak?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm afternoon sunlight casting soft shadows on the facades?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video maintain a static camera position throughout the sequence without panning or zooming?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007636165712028742 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882636070251465 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007636165712028742, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007636165712028742, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17376084625720978, + 0.11422229558229446, + 0.0594278983771801, + 0.16435427963733673, + 0.11639507114887238, + 0.1212439313530922, + 0.12681981921195984, + 0.03685472533106804, + 0.043599680066108704, + 0.04332149401307106 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007636165712028742 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a static, low-angle perspective focusing on the vermilion walls of the Forbidden City?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a plump pigeon with clean gray-white feathers and metallic green-purple neck iridescence visible pacing on blue-gray stone pavement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the pigeon exhibit rhythmic head swaying, bright orange-red eyes, and peck at crumbs with a dark gray beak?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm afternoon sunlight casting soft shadows on the facades?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video maintain a static camera position throughout the sequence without panning or zooming?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08908013999462128 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4640800952911377 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08908013999462128, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08908013999462128, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2112518846988678, + 0.04171163961291313, + 0.04370947182178497, + 0.10786843299865723, + 0.08056173473596573, + 0.15339705348014832, + 0.10693678259849548, + 0.08009662479162216, + 0.12562379240989685, + 0.04884261637926102 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08908013999462128 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a static, low-angle perspective focusing on the vermilion walls of the Forbidden City?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a plump pigeon with clean gray-white feathers and metallic green-purple neck iridescence visible pacing on blue-gray stone pavement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the pigeon exhibit rhythmic head swaying, bright orange-red eyes, and peck at crumbs with a dark gray beak?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm afternoon sunlight casting soft shadows on the facades?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video maintain a static camera position throughout the sequence without panning or zooming?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.38707876205444336 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1370787620544434 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.38707876205444336, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.38707876205444336, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1501116156578064, + 0.18986114859580994, + 0.09289029240608215, + 0.13934598863124847, + 0.07400436699390411, + 0.0809311792254448, + 0.03078049048781395, + 0.0831332877278328, + 0.06722767651081085, + 0.09171397984027863 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.38707876205444336 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, low-angle shot focuses on the iconic vermilion walls of the Forbidden City. Warm afternoon sunlight slants down, casting soft shadows across the towering, majestic facades. A plump pigeon paces along the time-worn, blue-gray stone pavement with a leisurely pace. Its gray-white feathers appear remarkably clean in the sunlight, and its neck gleams with metallic green and purple with each step. With each step, its head rhythmically sways back and forth, its bright, alert orange-red eyes perpetually observing its surroundings. Suddenly, it pauses, briefly surveying its surroundings. With swift and precise movements, it lowers its head and pecks at the barely visible crumbs of food lurking in the cracks between the stone slabs with its dark gray beak. The movement is clean and precise, and it immediately raises its head to resume its leisurely demeanor. The whole scene presents a tranquil and solemn atmosphere. The magnificent historical buildings and the small but vibrant life form a sharp and harmonious contrast, creating a peaceful beauty as if time has stopped.", + "seed": 10723, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_7/index_6394_seed_10723_dp_15_rank_30_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.0700536900665611, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0700536900665611, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.499999976158142, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0700536900665611, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a static, low-angle perspective focusing on the vermilion walls of the Forbidden City?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a plump pigeon with clean gray-white feathers and metallic green-purple neck iridescence visible pacing on blue-gray stone pavement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the pigeon exhibit rhythmic head swaying, bright orange-red eyes, and peck at crumbs with a dark gray beak?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm afternoon sunlight casting soft shadows on the facades?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video maintain a static camera position throughout the sequence without panning or zooming?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1650097519159317 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9150097370147705 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1650097519159317, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1650097519159317, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23745647072792053, + 0.2367001324892044, + 0.05642778053879738, + 0.09494232386350632, + 0.06204348802566528, + 0.0553758405148983, + 0.03071962296962738, + 0.02393903024494648, + 0.08449172973632812, + 0.11790362000465393 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1650097519159317 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a static, low-angle perspective focusing on the vermilion walls of the Forbidden City?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a plump pigeon with clean gray-white feathers and metallic green-purple neck iridescence visible pacing on blue-gray stone pavement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the pigeon exhibit rhythmic head swaying, bright orange-red eyes, and peck at crumbs with a dark gray beak?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm afternoon sunlight casting soft shadows on the facades?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video maintain a static camera position throughout the sequence without panning or zooming?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036272702272981405 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628627300262451 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036272702272981405, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036272702272981405, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0838559940457344, + 0.33738526701927185, + 0.06764554977416992, + 0.2532341480255127, + 0.05047427490353584, + 0.027590416371822357, + 0.016773752868175507, + 0.035420630127191544, + 0.08271448314189911, + 0.04490552097558975 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036272702272981405 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a static, low-angle perspective focusing on the vermilion walls of the Forbidden City?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a plump pigeon with clean gray-white feathers and metallic green-purple neck iridescence visible pacing on blue-gray stone pavement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the pigeon exhibit rhythmic head swaying, bright orange-red eyes, and peck at crumbs with a dark gray beak?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm afternoon sunlight casting soft shadows on the facades?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video maintain a static camera position throughout the sequence without panning or zooming?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005949170328676701 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130949020385742 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005949170328676701, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005949170328676701, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09202779084444046, + 0.07437723129987717, + 0.06903956085443497, + 0.32443684339523315, + 0.10354554653167725, + 0.04615996032953262, + 0.021905256435275078, + 0.05996738001704216, + 0.14813053607940674, + 0.060409899801015854 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005949170328676701 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a static, low-angle perspective focusing on the vermilion walls of the Forbidden City?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a plump pigeon with clean gray-white feathers and metallic green-purple neck iridescence visible pacing on blue-gray stone pavement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the pigeon exhibit rhythmic head swaying, bright orange-red eyes, and peck at crumbs with a dark gray beak?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm afternoon sunlight casting soft shadows on the facades?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video maintain a static camera position throughout the sequence without panning or zooming?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.048657502979040146 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486574172973633 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.048657502979040146, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.048657502979040146, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13998545706272125, + 0.32830891013145447, + 0.04558844491839409, + 0.1902744621038437, + 0.08547882735729218, + 0.025541357696056366, + 0.02129271999001503, + 0.039402976632118225, + 0.049034636467695236, + 0.07509222626686096 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.048657502979040146 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a static, low-angle perspective focusing on the vermilion walls of the Forbidden City?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a plump pigeon with clean gray-white feathers and metallic green-purple neck iridescence visible pacing on blue-gray stone pavement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the pigeon exhibit rhythmic head swaying, bright orange-red eyes, and peck at crumbs with a dark gray beak?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm afternoon sunlight casting soft shadows on the facades?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video maintain a static camera position throughout the sequence without panning or zooming?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12702475488185883 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1270246505737305 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12702475488185883, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.9999998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12702475488185883, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1209726482629776, + 0.2691901624202728, + 0.03183148056268692, + 0.13302630186080933, + 0.052325695753097534, + 0.038029249757528305, + 0.028461484238505363, + 0.026930490508675575, + 0.20365189015865326, + 0.09558063745498657 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 8, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12702475488185883 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_8/index_tensor([9312, 9312])_group_8_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_8/index_tensor([9312, 9312])_group_8_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..428c056062ab0cc1c476d029e0ef966952b75234 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_8/index_tensor([9312, 9312])_group_8_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up static shot with a pinpoint depth of field is fixed on the translucent tip of a sharp icicle, its surface delicately ridged and imperfect. The ice itself is crystalline yet flawed, filled with tiny trapped air bubbles and internal crack lines that catch and reflect the cold, low-angle winter light, making it glow from within. Against the softly blurred background, the dark, rugged texture of the weathered, damp rock ledge creates a stark, earthy contrast. The central feature is a drop of water, carefully gathered from the thin film of meltwater covering the icicle. Steadily and deliberately expanding, its surface tension holding its shimmering, drooping shape, it acts as a tiny fisheye lens, capturing a distorted, inverted reflection of the scene. Under the unstoppable pull of gravity, the drop stretches, extending its connection to the icicle into a fragile, shimmering thread of water that thins until it finally breaks. The now liberated sphere plummets rapidly, a fleeting silver streak sweeping across the out-of-focus rock face before disappearing from the bottom of the frame, creating an atmosphere of serene concentration on natural, inevitable progression.", + "seed": 6528, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_8/index_9312_seed_6528_dp_16_rank_32_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.010513065499253571, + "vlm_logprob": -0.010513065499253571, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 5.05, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.010513065499253571, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focused on the tip of a sharp icicle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static with a pinpoint depth of field and a blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the icicle surface translucent, ridged, and filled with trapped air bubbles and internal crack lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a water drop gather on the icicle, expand, stretch into a thread, and break under gravity?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the broken water drop plummet rapidly as a silver streak across the out-of-focus rock face before disappearing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03111295774579048 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5311129093170166 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03111295774579048, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03111295774579048, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23290646076202393, + 0.05477777495980263, + 0.019062144681811333, + 0.035454507917165756, + 0.026729093864560127, + 0.1393095850944519, + 0.04613395407795906, + 0.09911762923002243, + 0.198944553732872, + 0.14756426215171814 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03111295774579048 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focused on the tip of a sharp icicle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static with a pinpoint depth of field and a blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the icicle surface translucent, ridged, and filled with trapped air bubbles and internal crack lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a water drop gather on the icicle, expand, stretch into a thread, and break under gravity?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the broken water drop plummet rapidly as a silver streak across the out-of-focus rock face before disappearing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009807024151086807 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634807109832764 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009807024151086807, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009807024151086807, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24074411392211914, + 0.04974235221743584, + 0.03904241323471069, + 0.023283477872610092, + 0.026896366849541664, + 0.04303957149386406, + 0.08961247652769089, + 0.21636678278446198, + 0.16605092585086823, + 0.10522153228521347 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009807024151086807 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focused on the tip of a sharp icicle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static with a pinpoint depth of field and a blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the icicle surface translucent, ridged, and filled with trapped air bubbles and internal crack lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a water drop gather on the icicle, expand, stretch into a thread, and break under gravity?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the broken water drop plummet rapidly as a silver streak across the out-of-focus rock face before disappearing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0017193072708323598 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.3767194747924805 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0017193072708323598, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0017193072708323598, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17492322623729706, + 0.03933262452483177, + 0.030349496752023697, + 0.04138986021280289, + 0.023611392825841904, + 0.0869826152920723, + 0.13151401281356812, + 0.05568734556436539, + 0.34614646434783936, + 0.07006298750638962 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0017193072708323598 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focused on the tip of a sharp icicle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static with a pinpoint depth of field and a blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the icicle surface translucent, ridged, and filled with trapped air bubbles and internal crack lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a water drop gather on the icicle, expand, stretch into a thread, and break under gravity?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the broken water drop plummet rapidly as a silver streak across the out-of-focus rock face before disappearing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003193756565451622 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.7531938552856445 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003193756565451622, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003193756565451622, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0692979171872139, + 0.03884769231081009, + 0.009656595066189766, + 0.018243372440338135, + 0.016902482137084007, + 0.025664085522294044, + 0.04892825707793236, + 0.2338809370994568, + 0.4827112555503845, + 0.05586746335029602 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003193756565451622 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focused on the tip of a sharp icicle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static with a pinpoint depth of field and a blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the icicle surface translucent, ridged, and filled with trapped air bubbles and internal crack lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a water drop gather on the icicle, expand, stretch into a thread, and break under gravity?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the broken water drop plummet rapidly as a silver streak across the out-of-focus rock face before disappearing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0067322817631065845 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.00673246383667 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0067322817631065845, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0067322817631065845, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09714532643556595, + 0.03377711400389671, + 0.018505321815609932, + 0.01789817586541176, + 0.01883847266435623, + 0.01798846200108528, + 0.07042963802814484, + 0.07617519795894623, + 0.32823646068573, + 0.3210058808326721 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0067322817631065845 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up static shot with a pinpoint depth of field is fixed on the translucent tip of a sharp icicle, its surface delicately ridged and imperfect. The ice itself is crystalline yet flawed, filled with tiny trapped air bubbles and internal crack lines that catch and reflect the cold, low-angle winter light, making it glow from within. Against the softly blurred background, the dark, rugged texture of the weathered, damp rock ledge creates a stark, earthy contrast. The central feature is a drop of water, carefully gathered from the thin film of meltwater covering the icicle. Steadily and deliberately expanding, its surface tension holding its shimmering, drooping shape, it acts as a tiny fisheye lens, capturing a distorted, inverted reflection of the scene. Under the unstoppable pull of gravity, the drop stretches, extending its connection to the icicle into a fragile, shimmering thread of water that thins until it finally breaks. The now liberated sphere plummets rapidly, a fleeting silver streak sweeping across the out-of-focus rock face before disappearing from the bottom of the frame, creating an atmosphere of serene concentration on natural, inevitable progression.", + "seed": 6529, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_8/index_9312_seed_6529_dp_16_rank_32_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.14025550633668898, + "vlm_logprob": -0.14025550633668898, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.099999952316284, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.14025550633668898, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focused on the tip of a sharp icicle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static with a pinpoint depth of field and a blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the icicle surface translucent, ridged, and filled with trapped air bubbles and internal crack lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a water drop gather on the icicle, expand, stretch into a thread, and break under gravity?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the broken water drop plummet rapidly as a silver streak across the out-of-focus rock face before disappearing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5797374248504639 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8297374248504639 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5797374248504639, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5797374248504639, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3350759744644165, + 0.2103383094072342, + 0.06308133900165558, + 0.02097783051431179, + 0.09969586879014969, + 0.08736046403646469, + 0.030947834253311157, + 0.028793375939130783, + 0.05132703855633736, + 0.07240194827318192 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5797374248504639 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focused on the tip of a sharp icicle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static with a pinpoint depth of field and a blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the icicle surface translucent, ridged, and filled with trapped air bubbles and internal crack lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a water drop gather on the icicle, expand, stretch into a thread, and break under gravity?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the broken water drop plummet rapidly as a silver streak across the out-of-focus rock face before disappearing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05502921715378761 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9300291538238525 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05502921715378761, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05502921715378761, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24476838111877441, + 0.2416255921125412, + 0.032542649656534195, + 0.029944581910967827, + 0.09143698215484619, + 0.030994871631264687, + 0.04484999179840088, + 0.09862074255943298, + 0.10278277844190598, + 0.08243339508771896 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05502921715378761 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focused on the tip of a sharp icicle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static with a pinpoint depth of field and a blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the icicle surface translucent, ridged, and filled with trapped air bubbles and internal crack lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a water drop gather on the icicle, expand, stretch into a thread, and break under gravity?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the broken water drop plummet rapidly as a silver streak across the out-of-focus rock face before disappearing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005259960889816284 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255259990692139 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005259960889816284, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005259960889816284, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.31411027908325195, + 0.3341768980026245, + 0.03978823497891426, + 0.017595885321497917, + 0.03545869141817093, + 0.04952032119035721, + 0.027674531564116478, + 0.04053011164069176, + 0.04809098690748215, + 0.09305410087108612 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005259960889816284 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focused on the tip of a sharp icicle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static with a pinpoint depth of field and a blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the icicle surface translucent, ridged, and filled with trapped air bubbles and internal crack lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a water drop gather on the icicle, expand, stretch into a thread, and break under gravity?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the broken water drop plummet rapidly as a silver streak across the out-of-focus rock face before disappearing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04306374117732048 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680636405944824 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04306374117732048, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04306374117732048, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.31761935353279114, + 0.12346550822257996, + 0.04281057417392731, + 0.032697755843400955, + 0.065096415579319, + 0.0894048735499382, + 0.04664595052599907, + 0.10732784122228622, + 0.11324217170476913, + 0.061689574271440506 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04306374117732048 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focused on the tip of a sharp icicle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static with a pinpoint depth of field and a blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the icicle surface translucent, ridged, and filled with trapped air bubbles and internal crack lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a water drop gather on the icicle, expand, stretch into a thread, and break under gravity?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the broken water drop plummet rapidly as a silver streak across the out-of-focus rock face before disappearing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018187187612056732 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018187046051025 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018187187612056732, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018187187612056732, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.36961108446121216, + 0.08547983318567276, + 0.08874226361513138, + 0.04180626943707466, + 0.04887058213353157, + 0.07567285746335983, + 0.03102758154273033, + 0.0777217224240303, + 0.10647648572921753, + 0.07459130883216858 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018187187612056732 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up static shot with a pinpoint depth of field is fixed on the translucent tip of a sharp icicle, its surface delicately ridged and imperfect. The ice itself is crystalline yet flawed, filled with tiny trapped air bubbles and internal crack lines that catch and reflect the cold, low-angle winter light, making it glow from within. Against the softly blurred background, the dark, rugged texture of the weathered, damp rock ledge creates a stark, earthy contrast. The central feature is a drop of water, carefully gathered from the thin film of meltwater covering the icicle. Steadily and deliberately expanding, its surface tension holding its shimmering, drooping shape, it acts as a tiny fisheye lens, capturing a distorted, inverted reflection of the scene. Under the unstoppable pull of gravity, the drop stretches, extending its connection to the icicle into a fragile, shimmering thread of water that thins until it finally breaks. The now liberated sphere plummets rapidly, a fleeting silver streak sweeping across the out-of-focus rock face before disappearing from the bottom of the frame, creating an atmosphere of serene concentration on natural, inevitable progression.", + "seed": 6530, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_8/index_9312_seed_6530_dp_17_rank_34_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.059222439443692564, + "vlm_logprob": -0.059222439443692564, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.1, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.059222439443692564, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focused on the tip of a sharp icicle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static with a pinpoint depth of field and a blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the icicle surface translucent, ridged, and filled with trapped air bubbles and internal crack lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a water drop gather on the icicle, expand, stretch into a thread, and break under gravity?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the broken water drop plummet rapidly as a silver streak across the out-of-focus rock face before disappearing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.25303220748901367 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5030322074890137 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.25303220748901367, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.25303220748901367, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17411360144615173, + 0.17284119129180908, + 0.0747389867901802, + 0.05227217078208923, + 0.053117264062166214, + 0.18862810730934143, + 0.007944926619529724, + 0.11136732995510101, + 0.06257562339305878, + 0.10240084677934647 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.25303220748901367 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focused on the tip of a sharp icicle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static with a pinpoint depth of field and a blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the icicle surface translucent, ridged, and filled with trapped air bubbles and internal crack lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a water drop gather on the icicle, expand, stretch into a thread, and break under gravity?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the broken water drop plummet rapidly as a silver streak across the out-of-focus rock face before disappearing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016093002632260323 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141092777252197 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016093002632260323, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016093002632260323, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15252912044525146, + 0.15181390941143036, + 0.10463552176952362, + 0.06298958510160446, + 0.06084389239549637, + 0.11701226979494095, + 0.062172289937734604, + 0.14852865040302277, + 0.06342095136642456, + 0.07605379074811935 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016093002632260323 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focused on the tip of a sharp icicle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static with a pinpoint depth of field and a blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the icicle surface translucent, ridged, and filled with trapped air bubbles and internal crack lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a water drop gather on the icicle, expand, stretch into a thread, and break under gravity?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the broken water drop plummet rapidly as a silver streak across the out-of-focus rock face before disappearing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0017178792040795088 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.376718044281006 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0017178792040795088, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0017178792040795088, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.29504114389419556, + 0.09893481433391571, + 0.049639396369457245, + 0.023607539013028145, + 0.05586717277765274, + 0.07026463747024536, + 0.03612959384918213, + 0.14499925076961517, + 0.05989829823374748, + 0.1656181514263153 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0017178792040795088 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focused on the tip of a sharp icicle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static with a pinpoint depth of field and a blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the icicle surface translucent, ridged, and filled with trapped air bubbles and internal crack lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a water drop gather on the icicle, expand, stretch into a thread, and break under gravity?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the broken water drop plummet rapidly as a silver streak across the out-of-focus rock face before disappearing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011076628230512142 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.5110764503479 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011076628230512142, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011076628230512142, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1129019483923912, + 0.04284272715449333, + 0.06710109859704971, + 0.07827435433864594, + 0.07765685766935349, + 0.10748673975467682, + 0.05893433094024658, + 0.1812412589788437, + 0.18079198896884918, + 0.09276875853538513 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011076628230512142 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focused on the tip of a sharp icicle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static with a pinpoint depth of field and a blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the icicle surface translucent, ridged, and filled with trapped air bubbles and internal crack lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a water drop gather on the icicle, expand, stretch into a thread, and break under gravity?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the broken water drop plummet rapidly as a silver streak across the out-of-focus rock face before disappearing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01419247966259718 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264192581176758 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01419247966259718, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01419247966259718, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1199849471449852, + 0.07062626630067825, + 0.0354824922978878, + 0.06443768739700317, + 0.06190672144293785, + 0.14447730779647827, + 0.029262272641062737, + 0.10531595349311829, + 0.07715190201997757, + 0.2913545072078705 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01419247966259718 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up static shot with a pinpoint depth of field is fixed on the translucent tip of a sharp icicle, its surface delicately ridged and imperfect. The ice itself is crystalline yet flawed, filled with tiny trapped air bubbles and internal crack lines that catch and reflect the cold, low-angle winter light, making it glow from within. Against the softly blurred background, the dark, rugged texture of the weathered, damp rock ledge creates a stark, earthy contrast. The central feature is a drop of water, carefully gathered from the thin film of meltwater covering the icicle. Steadily and deliberately expanding, its surface tension holding its shimmering, drooping shape, it acts as a tiny fisheye lens, capturing a distorted, inverted reflection of the scene. Under the unstoppable pull of gravity, the drop stretches, extending its connection to the icicle into a fragile, shimmering thread of water that thins until it finally breaks. The now liberated sphere plummets rapidly, a fleeting silver streak sweeping across the out-of-focus rock face before disappearing from the bottom of the frame, creating an atmosphere of serene concentration on natural, inevitable progression.", + "seed": 6531, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_8/index_9312_seed_6531_dp_17_rank_34_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.06657879622653126, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06657879622653126, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.875, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06657879622653126, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focused on the tip of a sharp icicle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static with a pinpoint depth of field and a blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the icicle surface translucent, ridged, and filled with trapped air bubbles and internal crack lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a water drop gather on the icicle, expand, stretch into a thread, and break under gravity?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the broken water drop plummet rapidly as a silver streak across the out-of-focus rock face before disappearing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22657355666160583 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6015735864639282 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.22657355666160583, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.22657355666160583, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06580948084592819, + 0.02683902159333229, + 0.04915769398212433, + 0.35941922664642334, + 0.03726164996623993, + 0.02800215780735016, + 0.05922266095876694, + 0.15408992767333984, + 0.1209438145160675, + 0.09925438463687897 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.22657355666160583 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focused on the tip of a sharp icicle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static with a pinpoint depth of field and a blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the icicle surface translucent, ridged, and filled with trapped air bubbles and internal crack lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a water drop gather on the icicle, expand, stretch into a thread, and break under gravity?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the broken water drop plummet rapidly as a silver streak across the out-of-focus rock face before disappearing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08912452310323715 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4641244411468506 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08912452310323715, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08912452310323715, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07089293748140335, + 0.03793187811970711, + 0.0562267005443573, + 0.08474398404359818, + 0.059522077441215515, + 0.05838954821228981, + 0.2596311867237091, + 0.19825379550457, + 0.10594888031482697, + 0.06845898926258087 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08912452310323715 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focused on the tip of a sharp icicle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static with a pinpoint depth of field and a blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the icicle surface translucent, ridged, and filled with trapped air bubbles and internal crack lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a water drop gather on the icicle, expand, stretch into a thread, and break under gravity?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the broken water drop plummet rapidly as a silver streak across the out-of-focus rock face before disappearing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036227568052709103 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628622531890869 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036227568052709103, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036227568052709103, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05344584211707115, + 0.02988247200846672, + 0.09541704505681992, + 0.6365504860877991, + 0.020157381892204285, + 0.017251031473279, + 0.02750629559159279, + 0.041701238602399826, + 0.045556679368019104, + 0.032531581819057465 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036227568052709103 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focused on the tip of a sharp icicle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static with a pinpoint depth of field and a blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the icicle surface translucent, ridged, and filled with trapped air bubbles and internal crack lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a water drop gather on the icicle, expand, stretch into a thread, and break under gravity?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the broken water drop plummet rapidly as a silver streak across the out-of-focus rock face before disappearing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0076280031353235245 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882627964019775 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0076280031353235245, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0076280031353235245, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.019313117489218712, + 0.022519908845424652, + 0.022046256810426712, + 0.5580428838729858, + 0.015163165517151356, + 0.007794350851327181, + 0.02353195659816265, + 0.028184834867715836, + 0.14259248971939087, + 0.16081103682518005 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0076280031353235245 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focused on the tip of a sharp icicle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static with a pinpoint depth of field and a blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the icicle surface translucent, ridged, and filled with trapped air bubbles and internal crack lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a water drop gather on the icicle, expand, stretch into a thread, and break under gravity?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the broken water drop plummet rapidly as a silver streak across the out-of-focus rock face before disappearing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005945141427218914 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130945205688477 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005945141427218914, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005945141427218914, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.014615710824728012, + 0.027902357280254364, + 0.017455795779824257, + 0.589518129825592, + 0.014860899187624454, + 0.009389474987983704, + 0.02234002575278282, + 0.019520064815878868, + 0.11288455128669739, + 0.17151302099227905 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005945141427218914 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_9/index_tensor([1716, 1716])_group_9_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_9/index_tensor([1716, 1716])_group_9_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..321993b246e5f935a6c9253b41beaae76ff77011 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_9/index_tensor([1716, 1716])_group_9_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "An extreme macro close-up, captured in a slow, smooth, tracing motion, slowly slides across a set of grotesque, dust-coated brass gears. These gears are no ordinary industrial artifacts. Their twisted and asymmetrical contours resemble the fossilized bones of some ancient creature, their surfaces coated in a dense layer of gray dust and cobwebs, revealing the silence of time. Sculpted by a single, cold sidelight, the needle-sharp teeth of the gears appear to be shrouded in deep shadow, the cold hardness of the metal forming an eerie contrast with the softness of the dust. Suddenly, as if twirled by an invisible, mysterious force, one of the largest gears begins to tremble ever so slightly, hesitantly. Then, the power is transmitted, and the entire mechanism begins to operate in an eerie yet incredibly graceful rhythm. The gears mesh seamlessly, emitting a nearly inaudible, soft metallic creaking sound, performing a slow, hypnotic mechanical ballet. As they rotate, tiny dust particles are stirred up and float like fireflies in the beams of light, adding a dreamy and unsettling vitality to this moving picture full of Tim Burton's gothic aesthetic, creating an atmosphere that is both exquisite and creepy.", + "seed": 20096, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_9/index_1716_seed_20096_dp_18_rank_36_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.11720416843891143, + "vlm_logprob": -0.11720416843891143, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.35, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.11720416843891143, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro close-up of brass gears?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the gears have twisted, asymmetrical contours resembling fossilized bones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the gears coated in a dense layer of gray dust and cobwebs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single cold sidelight creating deep shadows on the gear teeth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the gears begin to rotate and mesh with tiny dust particles floating in the light beams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10371103882789612 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3537111282348633 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10371103882789612, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10371103882789612, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0693570077419281, + 0.058389365673065186, + 0.07840690016746521, + 0.5244293212890625, + 0.03881222754716873, + 0.0226302333176136, + 0.12716031074523926, + 0.02088983543217182, + 0.04097349941730499, + 0.018951278179883957 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 6, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10371103882789612 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro close-up of brass gears?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the gears have twisted, asymmetrical contours resembling fossilized bones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the gears coated in a dense layer of gray dust and cobwebs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single cold sidelight creating deep shadows on the gear teeth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the gears begin to rotate and mesh with tiny dust particles floating in the light beams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03372207283973694 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408722162246704 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03372207283973694, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03372207283973694, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04255205765366554, + 0.025683356449007988, + 0.08569928258657455, + 0.261060506105423, + 0.021154629066586494, + 0.031621236354112625, + 0.38549408316612244, + 0.09406319260597229, + 0.040689315646886826, + 0.011982321739196777 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 3, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03372207283973694 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro close-up of brass gears?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the gears have twisted, asymmetrical contours resembling fossilized bones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the gears coated in a dense layer of gray dust and cobwebs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single cold sidelight creating deep shadows on the gear teeth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the gears begin to rotate and mesh with tiny dust particles floating in the light beams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04307150840759277 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680715084075928 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04307150840759277, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04307150840759277, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04504338279366493, + 0.02654164470732212, + 0.04807295650243759, + 0.2685384452342987, + 0.019681992009282112, + 0.02903110533952713, + 0.15851835906505585, + 0.325099915266037, + 0.05726923048496246, + 0.02220294438302517 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 3, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04307150840759277 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro close-up of brass gears?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the gears have twisted, asymmetrical contours resembling fossilized bones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the gears coated in a dense layer of gray dust and cobwebs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single cold sidelight creating deep shadows on the gear teeth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the gears begin to rotate and mesh with tiny dust particles floating in the light beams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17988885939121246 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8048888444900513 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17988885939121246, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17988885939121246, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06720949709415436, + 0.032288797199726105, + 0.10074113309383392, + 0.2445167899131775, + 0.06022345647215843, + 0.02846965380012989, + 0.07004106789827347, + 0.3386746644973755, + 0.0384046845138073, + 0.01943032070994377 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17988885939121246 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro close-up of brass gears?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the gears have twisted, asymmetrical contours resembling fossilized bones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the gears coated in a dense layer of gray dust and cobwebs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single cold sidelight creating deep shadows on the gear teeth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the gears begin to rotate and mesh with tiny dust particles floating in the light beams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2256273627281189 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6006274223327637 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2256273627281189, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2256273627281189, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03637343645095825, + 0.06232135370373726, + 0.04936029762029648, + 0.26592278480529785, + 0.06068781390786171, + 0.11063183099031448, + 0.10691110789775848, + 0.1607116013765335, + 0.11653700470924377, + 0.030542803928256035 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2256273627281189 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extreme macro close-up, captured in a slow, smooth, tracing motion, slowly slides across a set of grotesque, dust-coated brass gears. These gears are no ordinary industrial artifacts. Their twisted and asymmetrical contours resemble the fossilized bones of some ancient creature, their surfaces coated in a dense layer of gray dust and cobwebs, revealing the silence of time. Sculpted by a single, cold sidelight, the needle-sharp teeth of the gears appear to be shrouded in deep shadow, the cold hardness of the metal forming an eerie contrast with the softness of the dust. Suddenly, as if twirled by an invisible, mysterious force, one of the largest gears begins to tremble ever so slightly, hesitantly. Then, the power is transmitted, and the entire mechanism begins to operate in an eerie yet incredibly graceful rhythm. The gears mesh seamlessly, emitting a nearly inaudible, soft metallic creaking sound, performing a slow, hypnotic mechanical ballet. As they rotate, tiny dust particles are stirred up and float like fireflies in the beams of light, adding a dreamy and unsettling vitality to this moving picture full of Tim Burton's gothic aesthetic, creating an atmosphere that is both exquisite and creepy.", + "seed": 20097, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_9/index_1716_seed_20097_dp_18_rank_36_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.15861462727189063, + "vlm_logprob": -0.15861462727189063, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.125, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.15861462727189063, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro close-up of brass gears?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the gears have twisted, asymmetrical contours resembling fossilized bones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the gears coated in a dense layer of gray dust and cobwebs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single cold sidelight creating deep shadows on the gear teeth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the gears begin to rotate and mesh with tiny dust particles floating in the light beams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3156868517398834 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.315686821937561 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3156868517398834, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3156868517398834, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04341878741979599, + 0.06481080502271652, + 0.022800976410508156, + 0.05740167200565338, + 0.027463292703032494, + 0.08484744280576706, + 0.48175927996635437, + 0.06213005632162094, + 0.10314835608005524, + 0.05221934616565704 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3156868517398834 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro close-up of brass gears?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the gears have twisted, asymmetrical contours resembling fossilized bones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the gears coated in a dense layer of gray dust and cobwebs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single cold sidelight creating deep shadows on the gear teeth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the gears begin to rotate and mesh with tiny dust particles floating in the light beams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.033742357045412064 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4087424278259277 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.033742357045412064, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.033742357045412064, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23029370605945587, + 0.07447509467601776, + 0.02217349410057068, + 0.028675667941570282, + 0.036432892084121704, + 0.07272344082593918, + 0.36600548028945923, + 0.0332503579556942, + 0.08999010920524597, + 0.04597976803779602 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.033742357045412064 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro close-up of brass gears?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the gears have twisted, asymmetrical contours resembling fossilized bones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the gears coated in a dense layer of gray dust and cobwebs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single cold sidelight creating deep shadows on the gear teeth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the gears begin to rotate and mesh with tiny dust particles floating in the light beams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.038118183612823486 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881181240081787 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.038118183612823486, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.038118183612823486, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1440035104751587, + 0.0966854989528656, + 0.038153864443302155, + 0.1371714323759079, + 0.059730496257543564, + 0.05989883095026016, + 0.1537652164697647, + 0.0528813898563385, + 0.07163301855325699, + 0.18607673048973083 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.038118183612823486 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro close-up of brass gears?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the gears have twisted, asymmetrical contours resembling fossilized bones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the gears coated in a dense layer of gray dust and cobwebs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single cold sidelight creating deep shadows on the gear teeth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the gears begin to rotate and mesh with tiny dust particles floating in the light beams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17990189790725708 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8049018383026123 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17990189790725708, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17990189790725708, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22867825627326965, + 0.05002791807055473, + 0.049257442355155945, + 0.06869172304868698, + 0.045892976224422455, + 0.12869365513324738, + 0.19758054614067078, + 0.048968181014060974, + 0.08503349125385284, + 0.09717577695846558 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17990189790725708 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro close-up of brass gears?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the gears have twisted, asymmetrical contours resembling fossilized bones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the gears coated in a dense layer of gray dust and cobwebs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single cold sidelight creating deep shadows on the gear teeth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the gears begin to rotate and mesh with tiny dust particles floating in the light beams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22562384605407715 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6006238460540771 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.22562384605407715, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.22562384605407715, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09178587049245834, + 0.04970092698931694, + 0.04072923958301544, + 0.06969417631626129, + 0.05725602060556412, + 0.1572691649198532, + 0.1834721863269806, + 0.136825293302536, + 0.08280783146619797, + 0.13045930862426758 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.22562384605407715 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extreme macro close-up, captured in a slow, smooth, tracing motion, slowly slides across a set of grotesque, dust-coated brass gears. These gears are no ordinary industrial artifacts. Their twisted and asymmetrical contours resemble the fossilized bones of some ancient creature, their surfaces coated in a dense layer of gray dust and cobwebs, revealing the silence of time. Sculpted by a single, cold sidelight, the needle-sharp teeth of the gears appear to be shrouded in deep shadow, the cold hardness of the metal forming an eerie contrast with the softness of the dust. Suddenly, as if twirled by an invisible, mysterious force, one of the largest gears begins to tremble ever so slightly, hesitantly. Then, the power is transmitted, and the entire mechanism begins to operate in an eerie yet incredibly graceful rhythm. The gears mesh seamlessly, emitting a nearly inaudible, soft metallic creaking sound, performing a slow, hypnotic mechanical ballet. As they rotate, tiny dust particles are stirred up and float like fireflies in the beams of light, adding a dreamy and unsettling vitality to this moving picture full of Tim Burton's gothic aesthetic, creating an atmosphere that is both exquisite and creepy.", + "seed": 20098, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_9/index_1716_seed_20098_dp_19_rank_38_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.3062192738056183, + "vlm_logprob": -0.3062192738056183, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.65, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.3062192738056183, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro close-up of brass gears?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the gears have twisted, asymmetrical contours resembling fossilized bones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the gears coated in a dense layer of gray dust and cobwebs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single cold sidelight creating deep shadows on the gear teeth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the gears begin to rotate and mesh with tiny dust particles floating in the light beams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.977432906627655 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.47743290662765503 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.977432906627655, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.977432906627655, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09562811255455017, + 0.03836773708462715, + 0.09040752798318863, + 0.11324044317007065, + 0.05553353950381279, + 0.052890073508024216, + 0.0475449413061142, + 0.11420699208974838, + 0.15554876625537872, + 0.2366318255662918 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.977432906627655 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro close-up of brass gears?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the gears have twisted, asymmetrical contours resembling fossilized bones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the gears coated in a dense layer of gray dust and cobwebs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single cold sidelight creating deep shadows on the gear teeth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the gears begin to rotate and mesh with tiny dust particles floating in the light beams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0381450355052948 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288145065307617 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0381450355052948, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0381450355052948, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07068981975317001, + 0.03283665329217911, + 0.20260466635227203, + 0.030096909031271935, + 0.01558658666908741, + 0.032027654349803925, + 0.04744353145360947, + 0.02818240225315094, + 0.11459612846374512, + 0.4259355664253235 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 2, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0381450355052948 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro close-up of brass gears?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the gears have twisted, asymmetrical contours resembling fossilized bones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the gears coated in a dense layer of gray dust and cobwebs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single cold sidelight creating deep shadows on the gear teeth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the gears begin to rotate and mesh with tiny dust particles floating in the light beams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11295268684625626 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.237952709197998 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11295268684625626, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11295268684625626, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04337119683623314, + 0.04405166208744049, + 0.20418263971805573, + 0.05384767800569534, + 0.027598872780799866, + 0.32356059551239014, + 0.11324648559093475, + 0.03876121714711189, + 0.11068659275770187, + 0.040693048387765884 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 2, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11295268684625626 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro close-up of brass gears?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the gears have twisted, asymmetrical contours resembling fossilized bones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the gears coated in a dense layer of gray dust and cobwebs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single cold sidelight creating deep shadows on the gear teeth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the gears begin to rotate and mesh with tiny dust particles floating in the light beams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08905800431966782 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4640579223632812 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08905800431966782, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08905800431966782, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.061558838933706284, + 0.1074601337313652, + 0.06778256595134735, + 0.021650923416018486, + 0.057941701263189316, + 0.42388322949409485, + 0.07550855726003647, + 0.04126259312033653, + 0.09800343215465546, + 0.04494804888963699 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08905800431966782 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro close-up of brass gears?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the gears have twisted, asymmetrical contours resembling fossilized bones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the gears coated in a dense layer of gray dust and cobwebs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single cold sidelight creating deep shadows on the gear teeth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the gears begin to rotate and mesh with tiny dust particles floating in the light beams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.31350773572921753 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3135077953338623 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.31350773572921753, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.31350773572921753, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1020793691277504, + 0.047543320804834366, + 0.030042119324207306, + 0.022000784054398537, + 0.03556385263800621, + 0.3083485960960388, + 0.17479807138442993, + 0.06869637221097946, + 0.1551680713891983, + 0.055759456008672714 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.31350773572921753 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extreme macro close-up, captured in a slow, smooth, tracing motion, slowly slides across a set of grotesque, dust-coated brass gears. These gears are no ordinary industrial artifacts. Their twisted and asymmetrical contours resemble the fossilized bones of some ancient creature, their surfaces coated in a dense layer of gray dust and cobwebs, revealing the silence of time. Sculpted by a single, cold sidelight, the needle-sharp teeth of the gears appear to be shrouded in deep shadow, the cold hardness of the metal forming an eerie contrast with the softness of the dust. Suddenly, as if twirled by an invisible, mysterious force, one of the largest gears begins to tremble ever so slightly, hesitantly. Then, the power is transmitted, and the entire mechanism begins to operate in an eerie yet incredibly graceful rhythm. The gears mesh seamlessly, emitting a nearly inaudible, soft metallic creaking sound, performing a slow, hypnotic mechanical ballet. As they rotate, tiny dust particles are stirred up and float like fireflies in the beams of light, adding a dreamy and unsettling vitality to this moving picture full of Tim Burton's gothic aesthetic, creating an atmosphere that is both exquisite and creepy.", + "seed": 20099, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000143/group_9/index_1716_seed_20099_dp_19_rank_38_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.4756316639482975, + "vlm_logprob": -0.4756316639482975, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.5, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.4756316639482975, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro close-up of brass gears?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the gears have twisted, asymmetrical contours resembling fossilized bones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the gears coated in a dense layer of gray dust and cobwebs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single cold sidelight creating deep shadows on the gear teeth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the gears begin to rotate and mesh with tiny dust particles floating in the light beams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08246990293264389 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.582469940185547 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08246990293264389, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08246990293264389, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16934463381767273, + 0.09240067005157471, + 0.031077420338988304, + 0.016575729474425316, + 0.055017292499542236, + 0.0835321843624115, + 0.14811770617961884, + 0.02938329055905342, + 0.03590422496199608, + 0.338646799325943 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08246990293264389 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro close-up of brass gears?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the gears have twisted, asymmetrical contours resembling fossilized bones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the gears coated in a dense layer of gray dust and cobwebs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single cold sidelight creating deep shadows on the gear teeth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the gears begin to rotate and mesh with tiny dust particles floating in the light beams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04869883507490158 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048698902130127 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04869883507490158, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04869883507490158, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08973613381385803, + 0.3250625729560852, + 0.03042992204427719, + 0.034402213990688324, + 0.039312224835157394, + 0.037114761769771576, + 0.028247421607375145, + 0.048770129680633545, + 0.05736105889081955, + 0.30956345796585083 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04869883507490158 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro close-up of brass gears?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the gears have twisted, asymmetrical contours resembling fossilized bones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the gears coated in a dense layer of gray dust and cobwebs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single cold sidelight creating deep shadows on the gear teeth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the gears begin to rotate and mesh with tiny dust particles floating in the light beams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05498227849602699 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299821853637695 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05498227849602699, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05498227849602699, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07666118443012238, + 0.5719713568687439, + 0.07125518471002579, + 0.01680653728544712, + 0.0308668315410614, + 0.03477790206670761, + 0.03709791973233223, + 0.019426951184868813, + 0.019903631880879402, + 0.12123250216245651 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05498227849602699 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro close-up of brass gears?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the gears have twisted, asymmetrical contours resembling fossilized bones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the gears coated in a dense layer of gray dust and cobwebs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single cold sidelight creating deep shadows on the gear teeth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the gears begin to rotate and mesh with tiny dust particles floating in the light beams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3871135711669922 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1371135711669922 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3871135711669922, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3871135711669922, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19748280942440033, + 0.35271915793418884, + 0.04666521027684212, + 0.056281641125679016, + 0.03227214887738228, + 0.08030153810977936, + 0.037591155618429184, + 0.047624506056308746, + 0.031990792602300644, + 0.1170710101723671 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3871135711669922 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro close-up of brass gears?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the gears have twisted, asymmetrical contours resembling fossilized bones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the gears coated in a dense layer of gray dust and cobwebs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single cold sidelight creating deep shadows on the gear teeth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the gears begin to rotate and mesh with tiny dust particles floating in the light beams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8048937320709229 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17989373207092285 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.8048937320709229, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -1.8048937320709229, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04116245359182358, + 0.3306884467601776, + 0.053721312433481216, + 0.02515692450106144, + 0.05739719048142433, + 0.12063915282487869, + 0.07857953011989594, + 0.11029849946498871, + 0.13304728269577026, + 0.049309179186820984 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.8048937320709229 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_0/index_tensor([4688, 4688])_group_0_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_0/index_tensor([4688, 4688])_group_0_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..1d9c9dc0d0e7d493fb85b5488a9c6b63e3bbf6d4 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_0/index_tensor([4688, 4688])_group_0_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "low-angle shot, close to the ground, hurls itself at breakneck speed toward a heavily modified matte black off-road vehicle, careening across a bumpy dirt road. Its body, caked with dried mud and thick dust, is smeared with the vehicle's massive, blocky all-terrain tires as it rolls over gravel and deep ruts, causing the vehicle to pitch up and down in a violent, rhythmic rhythm, its suspension straining to its limits. Each violent jolt lifts vast swathes of ochre dust from the ground, forming a dense, swirling cloud that nearly engulfs the rear end of the vehicle. The golden evening sun, slanting at a low angle, pierces the dense dust, creating distinct beams in the air that shimmer and illuminate each flying particle, adding a touch of grandeur to the wild scene. As the camera rapidly approaches, the powerful details of the vehicle - such as the sturdy anti-collision bumper on the front and the illuminated round retro headlights - become clearer and clearer, and the whole picture is full of raw, unrestrained energy and a tense and adrenaline-pumping atmosphere.", + "seed": 3903, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_0/index_4688_seed_3903_dp_0_rank_0_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.014268811978399753, + "vlm_logprob": -0.014268811978399753, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.625, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.014268811978399753, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle close to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a heavily modified matte black off-road vehicle visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the vehicle moving at high speed across a bumpy dirt road with gravel and deep ruts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are distinct beams of golden evening sunlight visible piercing through a dense cloud of ochre dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly approach the vehicle, revealing details like the anti-collision bumper and round retro headlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012253599241375923 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.012253761291504 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012253599241375923, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012253599241375923, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.26281365752220154, + 0.14056402444839478, + 0.04300821200013161, + 0.05869900807738304, + 0.05100899562239647, + 0.1489972472190857, + 0.0523625947535038, + 0.03222028538584709, + 0.06621545553207397, + 0.1441105306148529 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012253599241375923 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle close to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a heavily modified matte black off-road vehicle visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the vehicle moving at high speed across a bumpy dirt road with gravel and deep ruts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are distinct beams of golden evening sunlight visible piercing through a dense cloud of ochre dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly approach the vehicle, revealing details like the anti-collision bumper and round retro headlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02330356277525425 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773303508758545 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02330356277525425, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02330356277525425, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18127405643463135, + 0.2583436071872711, + 0.020223552361130714, + 0.05580799654126167, + 0.22868835926055908, + 0.06279871612787247, + 0.04816892370581627, + 0.03111722134053707, + 0.05589279159903526, + 0.05768479406833649 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02330356277525425 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle close to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a heavily modified matte black off-road vehicle visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the vehicle moving at high speed across a bumpy dirt road with gravel and deep ruts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are distinct beams of golden evening sunlight visible piercing through a dense cloud of ochre dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly approach the vehicle, revealing details like the anti-collision bumper and round retro headlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01607270911335945 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141072750091553 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01607270911335945, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01607270911335945, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07265715301036835, + 0.2499726116657257, + 0.028549393638968468, + 0.021119963377714157, + 0.09497443586587906, + 0.09522883594036102, + 0.13600407540798187, + 0.13381128013134003, + 0.1057325154542923, + 0.061949722468853 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01607270911335945 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle close to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a heavily modified matte black off-road vehicle visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the vehicle moving at high speed across a bumpy dirt road with gravel and deep ruts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are distinct beams of golden evening sunlight visible piercing through a dense cloud of ochre dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly approach the vehicle, revealing details like the anti-collision bumper and round retro headlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011079457588493824 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.51107931137085 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011079457588493824, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011079457588493824, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2971207797527313, + 0.04425763338804245, + 0.053051069378852844, + 0.06146661564707756, + 0.031021282076835632, + 0.03313455730676651, + 0.08476226776838303, + 0.05417349189519882, + 0.24932901561260223, + 0.0916832759976387 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011079457588493824 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle close to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a heavily modified matte black off-road vehicle visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the vehicle moving at high speed across a bumpy dirt road with gravel and deep ruts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are distinct beams of golden evening sunlight visible piercing through a dense cloud of ochre dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly approach the vehicle, revealing details like the anti-collision bumper and round retro headlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00863473117351532 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758634567260742 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00863473117351532, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00863473117351532, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11139503866434097, + 0.2447318285703659, + 0.049746789038181305, + 0.0314619354903698, + 0.08480174094438553, + 0.0877426341176033, + 0.09450437128543854, + 0.06287528574466705, + 0.08144892752170563, + 0.15129145979881287 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00863473117351532 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle shot, close to the ground, hurls itself at breakneck speed toward a heavily modified matte black off-road vehicle, careening across a bumpy dirt road. Its body, caked with dried mud and thick dust, is smeared with the vehicle's massive, blocky all-terrain tires as it rolls over gravel and deep ruts, causing the vehicle to pitch up and down in a violent, rhythmic rhythm, its suspension straining to its limits. Each violent jolt lifts vast swathes of ochre dust from the ground, forming a dense, swirling cloud that nearly engulfs the rear end of the vehicle. The golden evening sun, slanting at a low angle, pierces the dense dust, creating distinct beams in the air that shimmer and illuminate each flying particle, adding a touch of grandeur to the wild scene. As the camera rapidly approaches, the powerful details of the vehicle - such as the sturdy anti-collision bumper on the front and the illuminated round retro headlights - become clearer and clearer, and the whole picture is full of raw, unrestrained energy and a tense and adrenaline-pumping atmosphere.", + "seed": 3904, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_0/index_4688_seed_3904_dp_0_rank_0_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.02165394239127636, + "vlm_logprob": -0.02165394239127636, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.125, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.02165394239127636, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle close to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a heavily modified matte black off-road vehicle visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the vehicle moving at high speed across a bumpy dirt road with gravel and deep ruts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are distinct beams of golden evening sunlight visible piercing through a dense cloud of ochre dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly approach the vehicle, revealing details like the anti-collision bumper and round retro headlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.049292828887701035 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.674292802810669 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.049292828887701035, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.049292828887701035, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11172377318143845, + 0.06605955213308334, + 0.03984616696834564, + 0.3812885284423828, + 0.15890224277973175, + 0.04540913179516792, + 0.03908388689160347, + 0.033139750361442566, + 0.04607643559575081, + 0.07847055047750473 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.049292828887701035 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle close to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a heavily modified matte black off-road vehicle visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the vehicle moving at high speed across a bumpy dirt road with gravel and deep ruts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are distinct beams of golden evening sunlight visible piercing through a dense cloud of ochre dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly approach the vehicle, revealing details like the anti-collision bumper and round retro headlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016087841242551804 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141088008880615 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016087841242551804, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016087841242551804, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05333169922232628, + 0.034927792847156525, + 0.04505987465381622, + 0.3234402537345886, + 0.22342783212661743, + 0.024222783744335175, + 0.04217201843857765, + 0.07091441750526428, + 0.07102570682764053, + 0.11147760599851608 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016087841242551804 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle close to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a heavily modified matte black off-road vehicle visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the vehicle moving at high speed across a bumpy dirt road with gravel and deep ruts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are distinct beams of golden evening sunlight visible piercing through a dense cloud of ochre dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly approach the vehicle, revealing details like the anti-collision bumper and round retro headlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008638158440589905 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758638381958008 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008638158440589905, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008638158440589905, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11416584998369217, + 0.05883926898241043, + 0.05686856433749199, + 0.3642154037952423, + 0.04606163501739502, + 0.05026056990027428, + 0.08147094398736954, + 0.06525023281574249, + 0.06978390365839005, + 0.09308366477489471 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008638158440589905 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle close to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a heavily modified matte black off-road vehicle visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the vehicle moving at high speed across a bumpy dirt road with gravel and deep ruts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are distinct beams of golden evening sunlight visible piercing through a dense cloud of ochre dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly approach the vehicle, revealing details like the anti-collision bumper and round retro headlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016073528677225113 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141073703765869 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016073528677225113, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016073528677225113, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10514863580465317, + 0.0219827089458704, + 0.01935482583940029, + 0.1940808892250061, + 0.4371544122695923, + 0.04262562468647957, + 0.10035538673400879, + 0.030166128650307655, + 0.028163636103272438, + 0.020967761054635048 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016073528677225113 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle close to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a heavily modified matte black off-road vehicle visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the vehicle moving at high speed across a bumpy dirt road with gravel and deep ruts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are distinct beams of golden evening sunlight visible piercing through a dense cloud of ochre dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly approach the vehicle, revealing details like the anti-collision bumper and round retro headlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018177354708313942 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018177509307861 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018177354708313942, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018177354708313942, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05440525710582733, + 0.02679646946489811, + 0.043447401374578476, + 0.12122571468353271, + 0.5734154582023621, + 0.03654167428612709, + 0.06296911835670471, + 0.02290704846382141, + 0.02034180425107479, + 0.03795010223984718 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018177354708313942 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle shot, close to the ground, hurls itself at breakneck speed toward a heavily modified matte black off-road vehicle, careening across a bumpy dirt road. Its body, caked with dried mud and thick dust, is smeared with the vehicle's massive, blocky all-terrain tires as it rolls over gravel and deep ruts, causing the vehicle to pitch up and down in a violent, rhythmic rhythm, its suspension straining to its limits. Each violent jolt lifts vast swathes of ochre dust from the ground, forming a dense, swirling cloud that nearly engulfs the rear end of the vehicle. The golden evening sun, slanting at a low angle, pierces the dense dust, creating distinct beams in the air that shimmer and illuminate each flying particle, adding a touch of grandeur to the wild scene. As the camera rapidly approaches, the powerful details of the vehicle - such as the sturdy anti-collision bumper on the front and the illuminated round retro headlights - become clearer and clearer, and the whole picture is full of raw, unrestrained energy and a tense and adrenaline-pumping atmosphere.", + "seed": 3905, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_0/index_4688_seed_3905_dp_1_rank_2_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.011327119916677475, + "vlm_logprob": -0.011327119916677475, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 5.1, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.011327119916677475, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle close to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a heavily modified matte black off-road vehicle visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the vehicle moving at high speed across a bumpy dirt road with gravel and deep ruts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are distinct beams of golden evening sunlight visible piercing through a dense cloud of ochre dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly approach the vehicle, revealing details like the anti-collision bumper and round retro headlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.038716088980436325 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6637160778045654 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.038716088980436325, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.038716088980436325, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09707058221101761, + 0.037454910576343536, + 0.0307560246437788, + 0.06450687348842621, + 0.6139019131660461, + 0.04076480120420456, + 0.021150151267647743, + 0.029213005676865578, + 0.021461179479956627, + 0.04372056946158409 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.038716088980436325 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle close to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a heavily modified matte black off-road vehicle visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the vehicle moving at high speed across a bumpy dirt road with gravel and deep ruts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are distinct beams of golden evening sunlight visible piercing through a dense cloud of ochre dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly approach the vehicle, revealing details like the anti-collision bumper and round retro headlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005965286400169134 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130965232849121 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005965286400169134, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005965286400169134, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07253742963075638, + 0.025651173666119576, + 0.052520282566547394, + 0.23773038387298584, + 0.09408359229564667, + 0.062203649431467056, + 0.053745828568935394, + 0.06866653263568878, + 0.03131725639104843, + 0.3015438914299011 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005965286400169134 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle close to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a heavily modified matte black off-road vehicle visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the vehicle moving at high speed across a bumpy dirt road with gravel and deep ruts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are distinct beams of golden evening sunlight visible piercing through a dense cloud of ochre dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly approach the vehicle, revealing details like the anti-collision bumper and round retro headlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0059472741559147835 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130947113037109 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0059472741559147835, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0059472741559147835, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11553110927343369, + 0.05505826324224472, + 0.04354281350970268, + 0.22197462618350983, + 0.2027672827243805, + 0.09286125749349594, + 0.11817391961812973, + 0.05195295065641403, + 0.057518649846315384, + 0.040619127452373505 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0059472741559147835 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle close to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a heavily modified matte black off-road vehicle visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the vehicle moving at high speed across a bumpy dirt road with gravel and deep ruts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are distinct beams of golden evening sunlight visible piercing through a dense cloud of ochre dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly approach the vehicle, revealing details like the anti-collision bumper and round retro headlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0031928059179335833 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753192901611328 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0031928059179335833, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0031928059179335833, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.056924909353256226, + 0.027885155752301216, + 0.06950169056653976, + 0.49085983633995056, + 0.19613905251026154, + 0.06532914191484451, + 0.017434289678931236, + 0.009561988525092602, + 0.02006341703236103, + 0.04630051925778389 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0031928059179335833 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle close to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a heavily modified matte black off-road vehicle visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the vehicle moving at high speed across a bumpy dirt road with gravel and deep ruts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are distinct beams of golden evening sunlight visible piercing through a dense cloud of ochre dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly approach the vehicle, revealing details like the anti-collision bumper and round retro headlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002814144128933549 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877814292907715 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002814144128933549, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002814144128933549, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06391816586256027, + 0.04338684678077698, + 0.03498972952365875, + 0.14314168691635132, + 0.4403805136680603, + 0.03342008963227272, + 0.0429883636534214, + 0.03306616097688675, + 0.06227549910545349, + 0.10243292152881622 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002814144128933549 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle shot, close to the ground, hurls itself at breakneck speed toward a heavily modified matte black off-road vehicle, careening across a bumpy dirt road. Its body, caked with dried mud and thick dust, is smeared with the vehicle's massive, blocky all-terrain tires as it rolls over gravel and deep ruts, causing the vehicle to pitch up and down in a violent, rhythmic rhythm, its suspension straining to its limits. Each violent jolt lifts vast swathes of ochre dust from the ground, forming a dense, swirling cloud that nearly engulfs the rear end of the vehicle. The golden evening sun, slanting at a low angle, pierces the dense dust, creating distinct beams in the air that shimmer and illuminate each flying particle, adding a touch of grandeur to the wild scene. As the camera rapidly approaches, the powerful details of the vehicle - such as the sturdy anti-collision bumper on the front and the illuminated round retro headlights - become clearer and clearer, and the whole picture is full of raw, unrestrained energy and a tense and adrenaline-pumping atmosphere.", + "seed": 3906, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_0/index_4688_seed_3906_dp_1_rank_2_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.014622381050139665, + "vlm_logprob": -0.014622381050139665, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.7, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.014622381050139665, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle close to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a heavily modified matte black off-road vehicle visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the vehicle moving at high speed across a bumpy dirt road with gravel and deep ruts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are distinct beams of golden evening sunlight visible piercing through a dense cloud of ochre dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly approach the vehicle, revealing details like the anti-collision bumper and round retro headlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018653566017746925 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.518653392791748 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018653566017746925, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018653566017746925, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3104481101036072, + 0.07418400794267654, + 0.1670178771018982, + 0.036118973046541214, + 0.07180999964475632, + 0.09095431119203568, + 0.057090502232313156, + 0.04729633778333664, + 0.07065977901220322, + 0.07442012429237366 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018653566017746925 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle close to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a heavily modified matte black off-road vehicle visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the vehicle moving at high speed across a bumpy dirt road with gravel and deep ruts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are distinct beams of golden evening sunlight visible piercing through a dense cloud of ochre dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly approach the vehicle, revealing details like the anti-collision bumper and round retro headlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.038109004497528076 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288109064102173 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.038109004497528076, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.038109004497528076, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2563741207122803, + 0.12788426876068115, + 0.08148407936096191, + 0.10779650509357452, + 0.05028432980179787, + 0.07487951219081879, + 0.051698777824640274, + 0.09346645325422287, + 0.10643002390861511, + 0.04970187693834305 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.038109004497528076 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle close to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a heavily modified matte black off-road vehicle visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the vehicle moving at high speed across a bumpy dirt road with gravel and deep ruts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are distinct beams of golden evening sunlight visible piercing through a dense cloud of ochre dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly approach the vehicle, revealing details like the anti-collision bumper and round retro headlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004091820679605007 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504091739654541 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004091820679605007, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004091820679605007, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18170928955078125, + 0.0831892266869545, + 0.11987090855836868, + 0.06386063247919083, + 0.1737016886472702, + 0.14545588195323944, + 0.030455753207206726, + 0.03698062151670456, + 0.12841925024986267, + 0.03635673597455025 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004091820679605007 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle close to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a heavily modified matte black off-road vehicle visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the vehicle moving at high speed across a bumpy dirt road with gravel and deep ruts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are distinct beams of golden evening sunlight visible piercing through a dense cloud of ochre dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly approach the vehicle, revealing details like the anti-collision bumper and round retro headlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0046369642950594425 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379636764526367 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0046369642950594425, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0046369642950594425, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.29174408316612244, + 0.3295716941356659, + 0.10135571658611298, + 0.05811724066734314, + 0.04003090411424637, + 0.07004936784505844, + 0.024633074179291725, + 0.01558324322104454, + 0.04247370362281799, + 0.02644096314907074 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0046369642950594425 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle close to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a heavily modified matte black off-road vehicle visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the vehicle moving at high speed across a bumpy dirt road with gravel and deep ruts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are distinct beams of golden evening sunlight visible piercing through a dense cloud of ochre dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly approach the vehicle, revealing details like the anti-collision bumper and round retro headlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007620549760758877 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882620334625244 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007620549760758877, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007620549760758877, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2289942353963852, + 0.10001345723867416, + 0.08966488391160965, + 0.05083780735731125, + 0.053835030645132065, + 0.3716809153556824, + 0.01939980685710907, + 0.017385179176926613, + 0.02565806917846203, + 0.04253063350915909 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007620549760758877 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_1/index_tensor([9665, 9665])_group_1_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_1/index_tensor([9665, 9665])_group_1_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..1f83237e83c90520bcdfb3f892be903f641c9e8b --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_1/index_tensor([9665, 9665])_group_1_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "This low-angle, cinematic tracking shot, characterized by heavy, noticeable film grain that imparts a textured, analog quality, dynamically follows a vintage muscle car as it travels along a winding forest road at dusk. The camera is positioned low to the ground, slightly to the side of the vehicle, emphasizing its speed and the challenging curves of the path. The car, a classic model, boasts a deep cherry red finish that gleams softly in the fading light, its chrome details occasionally gleaming. It races across cracked asphalt, its tires kicking up small stones and dried leaves from the roadside. The surrounding forest is dense and majestic, with tall, dark pine trees forming a shadowy canopy that contrasts sharply with the deep purple and faded orange of the dusk sky. As the car expertly turns another bend, its powerful headlights pierce the dim air, illuminating the road ahead. In the distance, nestled in a small clearing at the end of the road, an isolated two-story wooden house came into view, its weathered wooden structure appearing almost black in the dim light, a warm yellow light flickering through the downstairs windows, creating a potent sense of loneliness and a thick atmosphere of suspense and anticipation.", + "seed": 30953, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_1/index_9665_seed_30953_dp_2_rank_4_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.07773682791739703, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07773682791739703, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.875, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07773682791739703, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a vintage muscle car with a deep cherry red finish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle, slightly to the side of the vehicle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit heavy, noticeable film grain imparting a textured analog quality?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a two-story wooden house visible in the distance with warm yellow light flickering through the downstairs windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the car's headlights pierce the dim air to illuminate the road ahead?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.043531790375709534 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168531894683838 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.043531790375709534, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.043531790375709534, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16152608394622803, + 0.2437928467988968, + 0.09632229804992676, + 0.18896330893039703, + 0.03146892413496971, + 0.1037156879901886, + 0.06828641891479492, + 0.022173939272761345, + 0.03330615162849426, + 0.050444312393665314 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.043531790375709534 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a vintage muscle car with a deep cherry red finish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle, slightly to the side of the vehicle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit heavy, noticeable film grain imparting a textured analog quality?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a two-story wooden house visible in the distance with warm yellow light flickering through the downstairs windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the car's headlights pierce the dim air to illuminate the road ahead?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03810453042387962 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.28810453414917 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03810453042387962, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03810453042387962, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5141177177429199, + 0.11055249720811844, + 0.06490790098905563, + 0.0733385682106018, + 0.028645485639572144, + 0.03961745649576187, + 0.038024529814720154, + 0.04549012705683708, + 0.03061368316411972, + 0.0546921007335186 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03810453042387962 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a vintage muscle car with a deep cherry red finish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle, slightly to the side of the vehicle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit heavy, noticeable film grain imparting a textured analog quality?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a two-story wooden house visible in the distance with warm yellow light flickering through the downstairs windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the car's headlights pierce the dim air to illuminate the road ahead?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014195417053997517 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264195442199707 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014195417053997517, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014195417053997517, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2367708384990692, + 0.17565025389194489, + 0.06579553335905075, + 0.04385461285710335, + 0.041242945939302444, + 0.07206937670707703, + 0.030649930238723755, + 0.027150286361575127, + 0.06660539656877518, + 0.24021084606647491 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014195417053997517 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a vintage muscle car with a deep cherry red finish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle, slightly to the side of the vehicle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit heavy, noticeable film grain imparting a textured analog quality?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a two-story wooden house visible in the distance with warm yellow light flickering through the downstairs windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the car's headlights pierce the dim air to illuminate the road ahead?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11294502019882202 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.237945079803467 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11294502019882202, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11294502019882202, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.639820396900177, + 0.05007300153374672, + 0.02899005264043808, + 0.07083224505186081, + 0.05961018055677414, + 0.02929399162530899, + 0.029689345508813858, + 0.021882282570004463, + 0.03721551597118378, + 0.03259302303195 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11294502019882202 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a vintage muscle car with a deep cherry red finish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle, slightly to the side of the vehicle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit heavy, noticeable film grain imparting a textured analog quality?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a two-story wooden house visible in the distance with warm yellow light flickering through the downstairs windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the car's headlights pierce the dim air to illuminate the road ahead?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17990738153457642 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8049073219299316 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17990738153457642, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17990738153457642, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21825730800628662, + 0.21452009677886963, + 0.053798284381628036, + 0.08028104156255722, + 0.03800247609615326, + 0.06209346652030945, + 0.05672012269496918, + 0.05875406414270401, + 0.08970971405506134, + 0.12786340713500977 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17990738153457642 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "This low-angle, cinematic tracking shot, characterized by heavy, noticeable film grain that imparts a textured, analog quality, dynamically follows a vintage muscle car as it travels along a winding forest road at dusk. The camera is positioned low to the ground, slightly to the side of the vehicle, emphasizing its speed and the challenging curves of the path. The car, a classic model, boasts a deep cherry red finish that gleams softly in the fading light, its chrome details occasionally gleaming. It races across cracked asphalt, its tires kicking up small stones and dried leaves from the roadside. The surrounding forest is dense and majestic, with tall, dark pine trees forming a shadowy canopy that contrasts sharply with the deep purple and faded orange of the dusk sky. As the car expertly turns another bend, its powerful headlights pierce the dim air, illuminating the road ahead. In the distance, nestled in a small clearing at the end of the road, an isolated two-story wooden house came into view, its weathered wooden structure appearing almost black in the dim light, a warm yellow light flickering through the downstairs windows, creating a potent sense of loneliness and a thick atmosphere of suspense and anticipation.", + "seed": 30954, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_1/index_9665_seed_30954_dp_2_rank_4_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.06439867708832026, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06439867708832026, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.175, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06439867708832026, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a vintage muscle car with a deep cherry red finish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle, slightly to the side of the vehicle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit heavy, noticeable film grain imparting a textured analog quality?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a two-story wooden house visible in the distance with warm yellow light flickering through the downstairs windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the car's headlights pierce the dim air to illuminate the road ahead?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.013453063555061817 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.388453006744385 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.013453063555061817, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.013453063555061817, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15346398949623108, + 0.15018831193447113, + 0.05127638950943947, + 0.09655675292015076, + 0.2527937889099121, + 0.05956277623772621, + 0.04288439825177193, + 0.015714524313807487, + 0.07645171135663986, + 0.1011074036359787 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.013453063555061817 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a vintage muscle car with a deep cherry red finish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle, slightly to the side of the vehicle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit heavy, noticeable film grain imparting a textured analog quality?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a two-story wooden house visible in the distance with warm yellow light flickering through the downstairs windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the car's headlights pierce the dim air to illuminate the road ahead?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026351187378168106 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513512134552 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026351187378168106, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026351187378168106, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15028011798858643, + 0.3025466799736023, + 0.051813118159770966, + 0.06521889567375183, + 0.0901145413517952, + 0.08482307195663452, + 0.046149879693984985, + 0.04286402836441994, + 0.0716426819562912, + 0.09454698115587234 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026351187378168106 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a vintage muscle car with a deep cherry red finish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle, slightly to the side of the vehicle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit heavy, noticeable film grain imparting a textured analog quality?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a two-story wooden house visible in the distance with warm yellow light flickering through the downstairs windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the car's headlights pierce the dim air to illuminate the road ahead?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023291219025850296 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732911109924316 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023291219025850296, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023291219025850296, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1461162120103836, + 0.05944763869047165, + 0.02500971592962742, + 0.05609429255127907, + 0.06451599299907684, + 0.44079160690307617, + 0.04502299800515175, + 0.03246457502245903, + 0.07053815573453903, + 0.059998877346515656 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023291219025850296 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a vintage muscle car with a deep cherry red finish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle, slightly to the side of the vehicle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit heavy, noticeable film grain imparting a textured analog quality?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a two-story wooden house visible in the distance with warm yellow light flickering through the downstairs windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the car's headlights pierce the dim air to illuminate the road ahead?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07897908985614777 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.578979015350342 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07897908985614777, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07897908985614777, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12393633276224136, + 0.10231750458478928, + 0.05293984338641167, + 0.06053164228796959, + 0.334964781999588, + 0.13645793497562408, + 0.05279381945729256, + 0.0325779914855957, + 0.06161943078041077, + 0.04186061769723892 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07897908985614777 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a vintage muscle car with a deep cherry red finish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle, slightly to the side of the vehicle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit heavy, noticeable film grain imparting a textured analog quality?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a two-story wooden house visible in the distance with warm yellow light flickering through the downstairs windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the car's headlights pierce the dim air to illuminate the road ahead?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1799188256263733 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8049187660217285 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1799188256263733, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1799188256263733, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1559656709432602, + 0.12454814463853836, + 0.03862157464027405, + 0.05729813873767853, + 0.07177416980266571, + 0.115723617374897, + 0.06420738250017166, + 0.023846320807933807, + 0.0880681499838829, + 0.2599467933177948 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1799188256263733 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "This low-angle, cinematic tracking shot, characterized by heavy, noticeable film grain that imparts a textured, analog quality, dynamically follows a vintage muscle car as it travels along a winding forest road at dusk. The camera is positioned low to the ground, slightly to the side of the vehicle, emphasizing its speed and the challenging curves of the path. The car, a classic model, boasts a deep cherry red finish that gleams softly in the fading light, its chrome details occasionally gleaming. It races across cracked asphalt, its tires kicking up small stones and dried leaves from the roadside. The surrounding forest is dense and majestic, with tall, dark pine trees forming a shadowy canopy that contrasts sharply with the deep purple and faded orange of the dusk sky. As the car expertly turns another bend, its powerful headlights pierce the dim air, illuminating the road ahead. In the distance, nestled in a small clearing at the end of the road, an isolated two-story wooden house came into view, its weathered wooden structure appearing almost black in the dim light, a warm yellow light flickering through the downstairs windows, creating a potent sense of loneliness and a thick atmosphere of suspense and anticipation.", + "seed": 30955, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_1/index_9665_seed_30955_dp_3_rank_6_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.08067817240953445, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08067817240953445, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.625, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08067817240953445, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a vintage muscle car with a deep cherry red finish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle, slightly to the side of the vehicle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit heavy, noticeable film grain imparting a textured analog quality?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a two-story wooden house visible in the distance with warm yellow light flickering through the downstairs windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the car's headlights pierce the dim air to illuminate the road ahead?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0554206483066082 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9304206371307373 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0554206483066082, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0554206483066082, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.01597754657268524, + 0.0105977151542902, + 0.018059194087982178, + 0.022898616269230843, + 0.07181616872549057, + 0.12002388387918472, + 0.520860493183136, + 0.028644345700740814, + 0.029455462470650673, + 0.16166654229164124 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0554206483066082 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a vintage muscle car with a deep cherry red finish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle, slightly to the side of the vehicle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit heavy, noticeable film grain imparting a textured analog quality?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a two-story wooden house visible in the distance with warm yellow light flickering through the downstairs windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the car's headlights pierce the dim air to illuminate the road ahead?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0700293779373169 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950292587280273 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0700293779373169, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0700293779373169, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05614965781569481, + 0.03996236249804497, + 0.026516685262322426, + 0.04190165922045708, + 0.06618724018335342, + 0.2824171781539917, + 0.03220925107598305, + 0.03617287054657936, + 0.0529843270778656, + 0.36549875140190125 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0700293779373169 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a vintage muscle car with a deep cherry red finish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle, slightly to the side of the vehicle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit heavy, noticeable film grain imparting a textured analog quality?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a two-story wooden house visible in the distance with warm yellow light flickering through the downstairs windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the car's headlights pierce the dim air to illuminate the road ahead?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05495418235659599 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299542903900146 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05495418235659599, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05495418235659599, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07287636399269104, + 0.03990231081843376, + 0.07419911026954651, + 0.112078458070755, + 0.03379758074879646, + 0.13993197679519653, + 0.0365455336868763, + 0.02094465307891369, + 0.025914108380675316, + 0.4438098967075348 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05495418235659599 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a vintage muscle car with a deep cherry red finish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle, slightly to the side of the vehicle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit heavy, noticeable film grain imparting a textured analog quality?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a two-story wooden house visible in the distance with warm yellow light flickering through the downstairs windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the car's headlights pierce the dim air to illuminate the road ahead?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04306602478027344 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680660247802734 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04306602478027344, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04306602478027344, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.015312624163925648, + 0.024795034900307655, + 0.03323609381914139, + 0.03388776630163193, + 0.014277162030339241, + 0.025850290432572365, + 0.06631557643413544, + 0.36771532893180847, + 0.03419956937432289, + 0.3844105005264282 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04306602478027344 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a vintage muscle car with a deep cherry red finish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle, slightly to the side of the vehicle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit heavy, noticeable film grain imparting a textured analog quality?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a two-story wooden house visible in the distance with warm yellow light flickering through the downstairs windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the car's headlights pierce the dim air to illuminate the road ahead?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17992062866687775 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8049206733703613 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17992062866687775, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17992062866687775, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12343678623437881, + 0.03537626937031746, + 0.03342193737626076, + 0.0745263546705246, + 0.04839298874139786, + 0.04588725417852402, + 0.06494206190109253, + 0.23274990916252136, + 0.01828679069876671, + 0.3229796290397644 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17992062866687775 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "This low-angle, cinematic tracking shot, characterized by heavy, noticeable film grain that imparts a textured, analog quality, dynamically follows a vintage muscle car as it travels along a winding forest road at dusk. The camera is positioned low to the ground, slightly to the side of the vehicle, emphasizing its speed and the challenging curves of the path. The car, a classic model, boasts a deep cherry red finish that gleams softly in the fading light, its chrome details occasionally gleaming. It races across cracked asphalt, its tires kicking up small stones and dried leaves from the roadside. The surrounding forest is dense and majestic, with tall, dark pine trees forming a shadowy canopy that contrasts sharply with the deep purple and faded orange of the dusk sky. As the car expertly turns another bend, its powerful headlights pierce the dim air, illuminating the road ahead. In the distance, nestled in a small clearing at the end of the road, an isolated two-story wooden house came into view, its weathered wooden structure appearing almost black in the dim light, a warm yellow light flickering through the downstairs windows, creating a potent sense of loneliness and a thick atmosphere of suspense and anticipation.", + "seed": 30956, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_1/index_9665_seed_30956_dp_3_rank_6_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.05088890045881271, + "vlm_logprob": -0.05088890045881271, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.275, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.05088890045881271, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a vintage muscle car with a deep cherry red finish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle, slightly to the side of the vehicle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit heavy, noticeable film grain imparting a textured analog quality?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a two-story wooden house visible in the distance with warm yellow light flickering through the downstairs windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the car's headlights pierce the dim air to illuminate the road ahead?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014911618083715439 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264911651611328 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014911618083715439, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014911618083715439, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2173946052789688, + 0.2226845622062683, + 0.06422468274831772, + 0.09175525605678558, + 0.0705525279045105, + 0.040656089782714844, + 0.06867390125989914, + 0.08123008161783218, + 0.09150823950767517, + 0.051319994032382965 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014911618083715439 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a vintage muscle car with a deep cherry red finish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle, slightly to the side of the vehicle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit heavy, noticeable film grain imparting a textured analog quality?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a two-story wooden house visible in the distance with warm yellow light flickering through the downstairs windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the car's headlights pierce the dim air to illuminate the road ahead?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020592818036675453 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955929279327393 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020592818036675453, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020592818036675453, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2042769491672516, + 0.07249286770820618, + 0.07749463617801666, + 0.10926227271556854, + 0.17790332436561584, + 0.03741108253598213, + 0.06713616847991943, + 0.09194514900445938, + 0.07921111583709717, + 0.08286642283201218 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020592818036675453 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a vintage muscle car with a deep cherry red finish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle, slightly to the side of the vehicle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit heavy, noticeable film grain imparting a textured analog quality?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a two-story wooden house visible in the distance with warm yellow light flickering through the downstairs windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the car's headlights pierce the dim air to illuminate the road ahead?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029806653037667274 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529806613922119 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029806653037667274, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029806653037667274, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1355983167886734, + 0.16220669448375702, + 0.03305291756987572, + 0.2045149952173233, + 0.05999995023012161, + 0.058255426585674286, + 0.1668379306793213, + 0.0373428538441658, + 0.07493844628334045, + 0.0672524943947792 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029806653037667274 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a vintage muscle car with a deep cherry red finish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle, slightly to the side of the vehicle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit heavy, noticeable film grain imparting a textured analog quality?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a two-story wooden house visible in the distance with warm yellow light flickering through the downstairs windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the car's headlights pierce the dim air to illuminate the road ahead?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06205186992883682 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812051773071289 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06205186992883682, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06205186992883682, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.37394586205482483, + 0.07682805508375168, + 0.037802208214998245, + 0.0699491798877716, + 0.11268963664770126, + 0.09303690493106842, + 0.07587572932243347, + 0.07820706814527512, + 0.020960399881005287, + 0.060704901814460754 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06205186992883682 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a vintage muscle car with a deep cherry red finish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle, slightly to the side of the vehicle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit heavy, noticeable film grain imparting a textured analog quality?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a two-story wooden house visible in the distance with warm yellow light flickering through the downstairs windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the car's headlights pierce the dim air to illuminate the road ahead?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12708154320716858 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1270816326141357 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12708154320716858, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12708154320716858, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08791068196296692, + 0.11947513371706009, + 0.05728074163198471, + 0.037290435284376144, + 0.08018932491540909, + 0.04319341108202934, + 0.11274491250514984, + 0.16341926157474518, + 0.12855742871761322, + 0.16993872821331024 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12708154320716858 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_10/index_tensor([5268, 5268])_group_10_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_10/index_tensor([5268, 5268])_group_10_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..bf3e067d2df924ba9fe146cfc4f5e4bbed74ea9c --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_10/index_tensor([5268, 5268])_group_10_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "static, extreme macro shot transports the viewer into a high-tech world, focusing on a microscopic, spider-like robotic bug. Its body, a fusion of matte black carbon fiber and polished chrome, trembles with palpable tension. Six spindly, multi-jointed legs splay, their tiny, pincer-like claws frantically biting into the edges of a bright energy trail emanating from the surface of a vast circuit board. This trail, a pulsating river of cyan light, serves as the scene's primary source of light, casting a harsh, cool afterglow that shimmers across the bug's metallic underbelly. The bug clings desperately to its position, its entire body vibrating as if resisting a powerful electrical current. The surroundings, a vast electronic city of monolithic capacitors and intricate microchips, are cast into a deep, soft blur with an extremely shallow depth of field, rendering the background a beautiful yet indifferent tapestry of glowing bokeh orbs. The atmosphere is one of intense, silent despair, highlighting the tiny machine's lonely struggle against the overwhelming scale of its technological world.", + "seed": 5391, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_10/index_5268_seed_5391_dp_20_rank_40_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.02440919168875553, + "vlm_logprob": -0.02440919168875553, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 5.15, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.02440919168875553, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a microscopic, spider-like robotic bug?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bug's body composed of matte black carbon fiber and polished chrome?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the bug biting into a bright cyan energy trail on a circuit board surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a blurred electronic city of capacitors and microchips with glowing bokeh orbs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro view with an extremely shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005137693602591753 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.755137920379639 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005137693602591753, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005137693602591753, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15142610669136047, + 0.11755732446908951, + 0.06863932311534882, + 0.09202457964420319, + 0.09030061960220337, + 0.0327729806303978, + 0.17183524370193481, + 0.13071657717227936, + 0.08341798931360245, + 0.061309248208999634 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005137693602591753 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a microscopic, spider-like robotic bug?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bug's body composed of matte black carbon fiber and polished chrome?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the bug biting into a bright cyan energy trail on a circuit board surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a blurred electronic city of capacitors and microchips with glowing bokeh orbs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro view with an extremely shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1003112941980362 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.350311279296875 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1003112941980362, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1003112941980362, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11799194663763046, + 0.14321857690811157, + 0.09662812203168869, + 0.16660074889659882, + 0.07919950783252716, + 0.04727445915341377, + 0.16126789152622223, + 0.08272405713796616, + 0.054084666073322296, + 0.05101003497838974 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1003112941980362 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a microscopic, spider-like robotic bug?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bug's body composed of matte black carbon fiber and polished chrome?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the bug biting into a bright cyan energy trail on a circuit board surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a blurred electronic city of capacitors and microchips with glowing bokeh orbs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro view with an extremely shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012545124627649784 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387545108795166 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012545124627649784, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012545124627649784, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10601593554019928, + 0.1911628395318985, + 0.1261388063430786, + 0.0578295923769474, + 0.08668918907642365, + 0.03276316076517105, + 0.04648180678486824, + 0.1927330642938614, + 0.10332434624433517, + 0.0568612702190876 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012545124627649784 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a microscopic, spider-like robotic bug?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bug's body composed of matte black carbon fiber and polished chrome?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the bug biting into a bright cyan energy trail on a circuit board surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a blurred electronic city of capacitors and microchips with glowing bokeh orbs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro view with an extremely shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036139669828116894 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.6286139488220215 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036139669828116894, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036139669828116894, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10897184908390045, + 0.15585099160671234, + 0.09833484143018723, + 0.045636918395757675, + 0.14626473188400269, + 0.023580048233270645, + 0.1423048973083496, + 0.06232728809118271, + 0.1385299265384674, + 0.07819847762584686 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036139669828116894 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a microscopic, spider-like robotic bug?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bug's body composed of matte black carbon fiber and polished chrome?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the bug biting into a bright cyan energy trail on a circuit board surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a blurred electronic city of capacitors and microchips with glowing bokeh orbs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro view with an extremely shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0004378790326882154 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.7504377365112305 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0004378790326882154, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0004378790326882154, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08799806982278824, + 0.08906902372837067, + 0.04631848633289337, + 0.04932267591357231, + 0.060837794095277786, + 0.018957095220685005, + 0.34993839263916016, + 0.1408831924200058, + 0.07286664843559265, + 0.08380866795778275 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0004378790326882154 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, extreme macro shot transports the viewer into a high-tech world, focusing on a microscopic, spider-like robotic bug. Its body, a fusion of matte black carbon fiber and polished chrome, trembles with palpable tension. Six spindly, multi-jointed legs splay, their tiny, pincer-like claws frantically biting into the edges of a bright energy trail emanating from the surface of a vast circuit board. This trail, a pulsating river of cyan light, serves as the scene's primary source of light, casting a harsh, cool afterglow that shimmers across the bug's metallic underbelly. The bug clings desperately to its position, its entire body vibrating as if resisting a powerful electrical current. The surroundings, a vast electronic city of monolithic capacitors and intricate microchips, are cast into a deep, soft blur with an extremely shallow depth of field, rendering the background a beautiful yet indifferent tapestry of glowing bokeh orbs. The atmosphere is one of intense, silent despair, highlighting the tiny machine's lonely struggle against the overwhelming scale of its technological world.", + "seed": 5392, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_10/index_5268_seed_5392_dp_20_rank_40_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.028373576258309184, + "vlm_logprob": -0.028373576258309184, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 5.074999976158142, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.028373576258309184, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a microscopic, spider-like robotic bug?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bug's body composed of matte black carbon fiber and polished chrome?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the bug biting into a bright cyan energy trail on a circuit board surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a blurred electronic city of capacitors and microchips with glowing bokeh orbs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro view with an extremely shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0032059960067272186 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.0032057762146 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0032059960067272186, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0032059960067272186, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13149189949035645, + 0.14942839741706848, + 0.0559130534529686, + 0.10464338213205338, + 0.05778173357248306, + 0.10042163729667664, + 0.15853898227214813, + 0.04838651046156883, + 0.10552515834569931, + 0.08786927163600922 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0032059960067272186 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a microscopic, spider-like robotic bug?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bug's body composed of matte black carbon fiber and polished chrome?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the bug biting into a bright cyan energy trail on a circuit board surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a blurred electronic city of capacitors and microchips with glowing bokeh orbs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro view with an extremely shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1270371377468109 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1270370483398438 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1270371377468109, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.9999998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1270371377468109, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1617659628391266, + 0.22217421233654022, + 0.12046929448843002, + 0.06930765509605408, + 0.09993810206651688, + 0.1125202625989914, + 0.055518463253974915, + 0.05169708654284477, + 0.047696273773908615, + 0.05891270190477371 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1270371377468109 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a microscopic, spider-like robotic bug?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bug's body composed of matte black carbon fiber and polished chrome?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the bug biting into a bright cyan energy trail on a circuit board surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a blurred electronic city of capacitors and microchips with glowing bokeh orbs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro view with an extremely shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00594940735027194 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.1309494972229 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00594940735027194, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00594940735027194, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1424562633037567, + 0.25204330682754517, + 0.13496887683868408, + 0.09164149314165115, + 0.059235114604234695, + 0.062398511916399, + 0.0776585042476654, + 0.04835539311170578, + 0.09346335381269455, + 0.03777913376688957 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00594940735027194 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a microscopic, spider-like robotic bug?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bug's body composed of matte black carbon fiber and polished chrome?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the bug biting into a bright cyan energy trail on a circuit board surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a blurred electronic city of capacitors and microchips with glowing bokeh orbs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro view with an extremely shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004635303281247616 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379635334014893 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004635303281247616, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004635303281247616, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06093607097864151, + 0.07372841238975525, + 0.043097276240587234, + 0.04399459809064865, + 0.04772014915943146, + 0.26868537068367004, + 0.11774412542581558, + 0.020535221323370934, + 0.15618406236171722, + 0.16737478971481323 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004635303281247616 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a microscopic, spider-like robotic bug?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bug's body composed of matte black carbon fiber and polished chrome?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the bug biting into a bright cyan energy trail on a circuit board surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a blurred electronic city of capacitors and microchips with glowing bokeh orbs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro view with an extremely shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0010400369064882398 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.876039981842041 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0010400369064882398, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0010400369064882398, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17759393155574799, + 0.13318070769309998, + 0.08181601017713547, + 0.08731082826852798, + 0.03102792613208294, + 0.12418165057897568, + 0.08044853806495667, + 0.03582453355193138, + 0.10265075415372849, + 0.14596518874168396 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0010400369064882398 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, extreme macro shot transports the viewer into a high-tech world, focusing on a microscopic, spider-like robotic bug. Its body, a fusion of matte black carbon fiber and polished chrome, trembles with palpable tension. Six spindly, multi-jointed legs splay, their tiny, pincer-like claws frantically biting into the edges of a bright energy trail emanating from the surface of a vast circuit board. This trail, a pulsating river of cyan light, serves as the scene's primary source of light, casting a harsh, cool afterglow that shimmers across the bug's metallic underbelly. The bug clings desperately to its position, its entire body vibrating as if resisting a powerful electrical current. The surroundings, a vast electronic city of monolithic capacitors and intricate microchips, are cast into a deep, soft blur with an extremely shallow depth of field, rendering the background a beautiful yet indifferent tapestry of glowing bokeh orbs. The atmosphere is one of intense, silent despair, highlighting the tiny machine's lonely struggle against the overwhelming scale of its technological world.", + "seed": 5393, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_10/index_5268_seed_5393_dp_21_rank_42_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.03625842677429318, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03625842677429318, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.475, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03625842677429318, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a microscopic, spider-like robotic bug?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bug's body composed of matte black carbon fiber and polished chrome?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the bug biting into a bright cyan energy trail on a circuit board surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a blurred electronic city of capacitors and microchips with glowing bokeh orbs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro view with an extremely shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008257061243057251 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.008256912231445 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008257061243057251, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008257061243057251, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16359995305538177, + 0.12583525478839874, + 0.058793745934963226, + 0.07351569086313248, + 0.12612532079219818, + 0.10130053013563156, + 0.11219479143619537, + 0.04655536636710167, + 0.11738404631614685, + 0.07469532638788223 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008257061243057251 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a microscopic, spider-like robotic bug?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bug's body composed of matte black carbon fiber and polished chrome?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the bug biting into a bright cyan energy trail on a circuit board surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a blurred electronic city of capacitors and microchips with glowing bokeh orbs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro view with an extremely shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1129419282078743 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2379419803619385 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1129419282078743, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1129419282078743, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18864457309246063, + 0.049356769770383835, + 0.18677179515361786, + 0.0957806408405304, + 0.08384471386671066, + 0.058151714503765106, + 0.11869411170482635, + 0.1191934198141098, + 0.05137387290596962, + 0.048188403248786926 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1129419282078743 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a microscopic, spider-like robotic bug?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bug's body composed of matte black carbon fiber and polished chrome?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the bug biting into a bright cyan energy trail on a circuit board surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a blurred electronic city of capacitors and microchips with glowing bokeh orbs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro view with an extremely shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05495700612664223 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299569129943848 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05495700612664223, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05495700612664223, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09346168488264084, + 0.05377023667097092, + 0.2707346975803375, + 0.09228444844484329, + 0.04372869059443474, + 0.07228373736143112, + 0.16776001453399658, + 0.04880361258983612, + 0.10769613087177277, + 0.04947669804096222 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05495700612664223 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a microscopic, spider-like robotic bug?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bug's body composed of matte black carbon fiber and polished chrome?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the bug biting into a bright cyan energy trail on a circuit board surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a blurred electronic city of capacitors and microchips with glowing bokeh orbs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro view with an extremely shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004093838855624199 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504093647003174 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004093838855624199, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004093838855624199, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22753217816352844, + 0.0529344417154789, + 0.10605018585920334, + 0.14801058173179626, + 0.0752234011888504, + 0.12203922122716904, + 0.05445706099271774, + 0.026360364630818367, + 0.09860462695360184, + 0.08878792822360992 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004093838855624199 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a microscopic, spider-like robotic bug?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bug's body composed of matte black carbon fiber and polished chrome?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the bug biting into a bright cyan energy trail on a circuit board surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a blurred electronic city of capacitors and microchips with glowing bokeh orbs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro view with an extremely shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0010422994382679462 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.876042366027832 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0010422994382679462, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0010422994382679462, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1934928596019745, + 0.10116541385650635, + 0.05386453494429588, + 0.1854218989610672, + 0.055009614676237106, + 0.07169980555772781, + 0.1264895647764206, + 0.051152683794498444, + 0.0956084206700325, + 0.0660952553153038 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0010422994382679462 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, extreme macro shot transports the viewer into a high-tech world, focusing on a microscopic, spider-like robotic bug. Its body, a fusion of matte black carbon fiber and polished chrome, trembles with palpable tension. Six spindly, multi-jointed legs splay, their tiny, pincer-like claws frantically biting into the edges of a bright energy trail emanating from the surface of a vast circuit board. This trail, a pulsating river of cyan light, serves as the scene's primary source of light, casting a harsh, cool afterglow that shimmers across the bug's metallic underbelly. The bug clings desperately to its position, its entire body vibrating as if resisting a powerful electrical current. The surroundings, a vast electronic city of monolithic capacitors and intricate microchips, are cast into a deep, soft blur with an extremely shallow depth of field, rendering the background a beautiful yet indifferent tapestry of glowing bokeh orbs. The atmosphere is one of intense, silent despair, highlighting the tiny machine's lonely struggle against the overwhelming scale of its technological world.", + "seed": 5394, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_10/index_5268_seed_5394_dp_21_rank_42_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.03095217708032578, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03095217708032578, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.625, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03095217708032578, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a microscopic, spider-like robotic bug?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bug's body composed of matte black carbon fiber and polished chrome?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the bug biting into a bright cyan energy trail on a circuit board surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a blurred electronic city of capacitors and microchips with glowing bokeh orbs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro view with an extremely shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.019699405878782272 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.019699573516846 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.019699405878782272, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.019699405878782272, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08512478321790695, + 0.08350156247615814, + 0.026700850576162338, + 0.11875547468662262, + 0.04715151712298393, + 0.06775867938995361, + 0.022713419049978256, + 0.24944090843200684, + 0.1876475065946579, + 0.1112053170800209 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.019699405878782272 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a microscopic, spider-like robotic bug?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bug's body composed of matte black carbon fiber and polished chrome?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the bug biting into a bright cyan energy trail on a circuit board surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a blurred electronic city of capacitors and microchips with glowing bokeh orbs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro view with an extremely shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11295460164546967 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.237954616546631 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11295460164546967, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11295460164546967, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06384781748056412, + 0.0881032943725586, + 0.04772765189409256, + 0.09133048355579376, + 0.03385353460907936, + 0.048207975924015045, + 0.04770533740520477, + 0.17395278811454773, + 0.19113637506961823, + 0.21413470804691315 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11295460164546967 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a microscopic, spider-like robotic bug?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bug's body composed of matte black carbon fiber and polished chrome?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the bug biting into a bright cyan energy trail on a circuit board surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a blurred electronic city of capacitors and microchips with glowing bokeh orbs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro view with an extremely shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0181954987347126 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018195629119873 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0181954987347126, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0181954987347126, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08411072194576263, + 0.3045691251754761, + 0.042344871908426285, + 0.0771983340382576, + 0.03995385020971298, + 0.04109133407473564, + 0.027258601039648056, + 0.07595979422330856, + 0.08922003954648972, + 0.21829330921173096 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0181954987347126 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a microscopic, spider-like robotic bug?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bug's body composed of matte black carbon fiber and polished chrome?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the bug biting into a bright cyan energy trail on a circuit board surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a blurred electronic city of capacitors and microchips with glowing bokeh orbs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro view with an extremely shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003193043638020754 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753192901611328 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003193043638020754, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003193043638020754, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07553791254758835, + 0.3401906490325928, + 0.018784349784255028, + 0.045787062495946884, + 0.0496804378926754, + 0.03279310464859009, + 0.01791301555931568, + 0.07280109822750092, + 0.2594907581806183, + 0.08702163398265839 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003193043638020754 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a microscopic, spider-like robotic bug?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bug's body composed of matte black carbon fiber and polished chrome?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the bug biting into a bright cyan energy trail on a circuit board surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a blurred electronic city of capacitors and microchips with glowing bokeh orbs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro view with an extremely shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0007183355046436191 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.250718116760254 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0007183355046436191, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0007183355046436191, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09713544696569443, + 0.13220565021038055, + 0.042590461671352386, + 0.05914134159684181, + 0.08930614590644836, + 0.049919720739126205, + 0.01919015869498253, + 0.13500875234603882, + 0.16569773852825165, + 0.20980459451675415 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0007183355046436191 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_11/index_tensor([6241, 6241])_group_11_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_11/index_tensor([6241, 6241])_group_11_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..cf673d995bf77a0f33f3cdc7a20493f7273f3ad5 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_11/index_tensor([6241, 6241])_group_11_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "The scene opens with a static, low-angle shot of a cracked asphalt street corner in a densely populated urban area, simmering in the harsh afternoon sun. The direct, high sun casts sharp shadows across the gravel road, with tiny weeds sprouting from the cracks, while a perfectly clear, cloudless, deep blue sky stretches overhead, creating a stark visual contrast. The camera slowly and deliberately tilts upward, its gaze settling on the primary subject: a classic cast-iron fire hydrant. Its body, coated in layer upon layer of vibrant red paint, is now slightly faded and worn in places, revealing the old coat and the deep rust beneath. Its surface texture feels rough to the touch. The large hexagonal nut and the chain securing the side cover gleam in the intense light, gleaming with a dull metallic sheen. For a moment, the scene remains in a state of intense stillness, until suddenly, with a violent explosion, the side cover bursts apart, flung sideways onto the end of the chain, and spun erratically. From the exposed opening, a powerful, high-pressure horizontal stream of water erupts, a translucent jet that catches the sunlight and atomizes at the edges into a shimmering, fine mist. The gushing water crashes into the scorching street, instantly creating a cloud of steam that quickly floods the cracked asphalt, its flow forming a sprawling, reflective pool that mirrors the deep blue sky above, transforming the stuffy city corner with a sudden, chaotic burst of refreshing energy.", + "seed": 23795, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_11/index_6241_seed_23795_dp_22_rank_44_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.13090958669781685, + "vlm_logprob": -0.13090958669781685, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.2, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.13090958669781685, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at a cracked asphalt street corner in a densely populated urban area under a clear, deep blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera initially positioned at a low angle and does it slowly tilt upward to reveal the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the primary subject a classic cast-iron fire hydrant with a faded red body revealing rust and a dull metallic chain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the side cover of the hydrant burst apart violently, flung sideways, and spin erratically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a high-pressure horizontal stream of water erupt from the hydrant, creating steam and a reflective pool on the asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12789031863212585 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1278903484344482 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12789031863212585, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12789031863212585, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.32613906264305115, + 0.029854031279683113, + 0.033910319209098816, + 0.025838665664196014, + 0.12486110627651215, + 0.05593064799904823, + 0.10923875868320465, + 0.11905021220445633, + 0.10862752050161362, + 0.06654971092939377 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12789031863212585 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at a cracked asphalt street corner in a densely populated urban area under a clear, deep blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera initially positioned at a low angle and does it slowly tilt upward to reveal the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the primary subject a classic cast-iron fire hydrant with a faded red body revealing rust and a dull metallic chain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the side cover of the hydrant burst apart violently, flung sideways, and spin erratically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a high-pressure horizontal stream of water erupt from the hydrant, creating steam and a reflective pool on the asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.038112446665763855 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881124019622803 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.038112446665763855, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.038112446665763855, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.29774051904678345, + 0.04725123941898346, + 0.07170579582452774, + 0.033874016255140305, + 0.09385284036397934, + 0.08082804828882217, + 0.04336787015199661, + 0.23852606117725372, + 0.07183844596147537, + 0.021015135571360588 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.038112446665763855 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at a cracked asphalt street corner in a densely populated urban area under a clear, deep blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera initially positioned at a low angle and does it slowly tilt upward to reveal the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the primary subject a classic cast-iron fire hydrant with a faded red body revealing rust and a dull metallic chain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the side cover of the hydrant burst apart violently, flung sideways, and spin erratically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a high-pressure horizontal stream of water erupt from the hydrant, creating steam and a reflective pool on the asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0031943507492542267 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753194332122803 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0031943507492542267, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0031943507492542267, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2512650191783905, + 0.09175606071949005, + 0.03324810788035393, + 0.04599792882800102, + 0.0793624147772789, + 0.09002518653869629, + 0.023371098563075066, + 0.17303045094013214, + 0.1051233559846878, + 0.10682041198015213 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0031943507492542267 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at a cracked asphalt street corner in a densely populated urban area under a clear, deep blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera initially positioned at a low angle and does it slowly tilt upward to reveal the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the primary subject a classic cast-iron fire hydrant with a faded red body revealing rust and a dull metallic chain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the side cover of the hydrant burst apart violently, flung sideways, and spin erratically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a high-pressure horizontal stream of water erupt from the hydrant, creating steam and a reflective pool on the asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4742770195007324 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9742770195007324 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.4742770195007324, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.4742770195007324, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2600230574607849, + 0.06290991604328156, + 0.037591807544231415, + 0.03736444190144539, + 0.06617440283298492, + 0.24471768736839294, + 0.024107906967401505, + 0.20920637249946594, + 0.027041876688599586, + 0.03086254931986332 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.4742770195007324 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at a cracked asphalt street corner in a densely populated urban area under a clear, deep blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera initially positioned at a low angle and does it slowly tilt upward to reveal the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the primary subject a classic cast-iron fire hydrant with a faded red body revealing rust and a dull metallic chain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the side cover of the hydrant burst apart violently, flung sideways, and spin erratically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a high-pressure horizontal stream of water erupt from the hydrant, creating steam and a reflective pool on the asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011073797941207886 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511073589324951 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011073797941207886, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011073797941207886, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13941501080989838, + 0.07169539481401443, + 0.028621666133403778, + 0.02189306728541851, + 0.09103716164827347, + 0.3501743972301483, + 0.019542081281542778, + 0.12666946649551392, + 0.07663007080554962, + 0.07432163506746292 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011073797941207886 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "The scene opens with a static, low-angle shot of a cracked asphalt street corner in a densely populated urban area, simmering in the harsh afternoon sun. The direct, high sun casts sharp shadows across the gravel road, with tiny weeds sprouting from the cracks, while a perfectly clear, cloudless, deep blue sky stretches overhead, creating a stark visual contrast. The camera slowly and deliberately tilts upward, its gaze settling on the primary subject: a classic cast-iron fire hydrant. Its body, coated in layer upon layer of vibrant red paint, is now slightly faded and worn in places, revealing the old coat and the deep rust beneath. Its surface texture feels rough to the touch. The large hexagonal nut and the chain securing the side cover gleam in the intense light, gleaming with a dull metallic sheen. For a moment, the scene remains in a state of intense stillness, until suddenly, with a violent explosion, the side cover bursts apart, flung sideways onto the end of the chain, and spun erratically. From the exposed opening, a powerful, high-pressure horizontal stream of water erupts, a translucent jet that catches the sunlight and atomizes at the edges into a shimmering, fine mist. The gushing water crashes into the scorching street, instantly creating a cloud of steam that quickly floods the cracked asphalt, its flow forming a sprawling, reflective pool that mirrors the deep blue sky above, transforming the stuffy city corner with a sudden, chaotic burst of refreshing energy.", + "seed": 23796, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_11/index_6241_seed_23796_dp_22_rank_44_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.1737124903127551, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1737124903127551, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.8, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1737124903127551, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at a cracked asphalt street corner in a densely populated urban area under a clear, deep blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera initially positioned at a low angle and does it slowly tilt upward to reveal the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the primary subject a classic cast-iron fire hydrant with a faded red body revealing rust and a dull metallic chain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the side cover of the hydrant burst apart violently, flung sideways, and spin erratically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a high-pressure horizontal stream of water erupt from the hydrant, creating steam and a reflective pool on the asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.694259762763977 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.694259762763977 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.694259762763977, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.694259762763977, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.020335061475634575, + 0.17196941375732422, + 0.006331221200525761, + 0.008809064514935017, + 0.022833077237010002, + 0.02770346775650978, + 0.2651475965976715, + 0.016456112265586853, + 0.045392487198114395, + 0.41502243280410767 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.694259762763977 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at a cracked asphalt street corner in a densely populated urban area under a clear, deep blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera initially positioned at a low angle and does it slowly tilt upward to reveal the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the primary subject a classic cast-iron fire hydrant with a faded red body revealing rust and a dull metallic chain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the side cover of the hydrant burst apart violently, flung sideways, and spin erratically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a high-pressure horizontal stream of water erupt from the hydrant, creating steam and a reflective pool on the asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04868713766336441 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048687219619751 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04868713766336441, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04868713766336441, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3704594075679779, + 0.019158639013767242, + 0.009988507255911827, + 0.013247325085103512, + 0.015527000650763512, + 0.02340349741280079, + 0.21272766590118408, + 0.05730794370174408, + 0.09227193892002106, + 0.18590810894966125 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04868713766336441 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at a cracked asphalt street corner in a densely populated urban area under a clear, deep blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera initially positioned at a low angle and does it slowly tilt upward to reveal the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the primary subject a classic cast-iron fire hydrant with a faded red body revealing rust and a dull metallic chain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the side cover of the hydrant burst apart violently, flung sideways, and spin erratically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a high-pressure horizontal stream of water erupt from the hydrant, creating steam and a reflective pool on the asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014203174039721489 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264203071594238 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014203174039721489, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014203174039721489, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12514592707157135, + 0.19325555860996246, + 0.01833328790962696, + 0.06097429245710373, + 0.0490541085600853, + 0.052309609949588776, + 0.058076292276382446, + 0.04147990047931671, + 0.08630890399217606, + 0.31506219506263733 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014203174039721489 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at a cracked asphalt street corner in a densely populated urban area under a clear, deep blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera initially positioned at a low angle and does it slowly tilt upward to reveal the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the primary subject a classic cast-iron fire hydrant with a faded red body revealing rust and a dull metallic chain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the side cover of the hydrant burst apart violently, flung sideways, and spin erratically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a high-pressure horizontal stream of water erupt from the hydrant, creating steam and a reflective pool on the asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1003359854221344 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3503360748291016 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1003359854221344, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1003359854221344, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12574148178100586, + 0.19164787232875824, + 0.020203610882163048, + 0.012173273600637913, + 0.016531966626644135, + 0.030540943145751953, + 0.19363993406295776, + 0.2669350206851959, + 0.10662098973989487, + 0.03596486896276474 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1003359854221344 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at a cracked asphalt street corner in a densely populated urban area under a clear, deep blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera initially positioned at a low angle and does it slowly tilt upward to reveal the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the primary subject a classic cast-iron fire hydrant with a faded red body revealing rust and a dull metallic chain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the side cover of the hydrant burst apart violently, flung sideways, and spin erratically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a high-pressure horizontal stream of water erupt from the hydrant, creating steam and a reflective pool on the asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01107639167457819 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.5110764503479 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01107639167457819, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01107639167457819, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.043680161237716675, + 0.1275208592414856, + 0.009446695446968079, + 0.008255108259618282, + 0.027419425547122955, + 0.025483263656497, + 0.19281068444252014, + 0.07162047177553177, + 0.06039180979132652, + 0.43337148427963257 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01107639167457819 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "The scene opens with a static, low-angle shot of a cracked asphalt street corner in a densely populated urban area, simmering in the harsh afternoon sun. The direct, high sun casts sharp shadows across the gravel road, with tiny weeds sprouting from the cracks, while a perfectly clear, cloudless, deep blue sky stretches overhead, creating a stark visual contrast. The camera slowly and deliberately tilts upward, its gaze settling on the primary subject: a classic cast-iron fire hydrant. Its body, coated in layer upon layer of vibrant red paint, is now slightly faded and worn in places, revealing the old coat and the deep rust beneath. Its surface texture feels rough to the touch. The large hexagonal nut and the chain securing the side cover gleam in the intense light, gleaming with a dull metallic sheen. For a moment, the scene remains in a state of intense stillness, until suddenly, with a violent explosion, the side cover bursts apart, flung sideways onto the end of the chain, and spun erratically. From the exposed opening, a powerful, high-pressure horizontal stream of water erupts, a translucent jet that catches the sunlight and atomizes at the edges into a shimmering, fine mist. The gushing water crashes into the scorching street, instantly creating a cloud of steam that quickly floods the cracked asphalt, its flow forming a sprawling, reflective pool that mirrors the deep blue sky above, transforming the stuffy city corner with a sudden, chaotic burst of refreshing energy.", + "seed": 23797, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_11/index_6241_seed_23797_dp_23_rank_46_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.03778176316991448, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03778176316991448, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.85, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03778176316991448, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at a cracked asphalt street corner in a densely populated urban area under a clear, deep blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera initially positioned at a low angle and does it slowly tilt upward to reveal the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the primary subject a classic cast-iron fire hydrant with a faded red body revealing rust and a dull metallic chain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the side cover of the hydrant burst apart violently, flung sideways, and spin erratically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a high-pressure horizontal stream of water erupt from the hydrant, creating steam and a reflective pool on the asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07977113127708435 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.579771041870117 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07977113127708435, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07977113127708435, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.049872349947690964, + 0.04363273084163666, + 0.016605552285909653, + 0.023826943710446358, + 0.01915295608341694, + 0.02148248255252838, + 0.15796037018299103, + 0.4395565092563629, + 0.08650558441877365, + 0.14140452444553375 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07977113127708435 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at a cracked asphalt street corner in a densely populated urban area under a clear, deep blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera initially positioned at a low angle and does it slowly tilt upward to reveal the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the primary subject a classic cast-iron fire hydrant with a faded red body revealing rust and a dull metallic chain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the side cover of the hydrant burst apart violently, flung sideways, and spin erratically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a high-pressure horizontal stream of water erupt from the hydrant, creating steam and a reflective pool on the asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04306408390402794 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680641174316406 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04306408390402794, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04306408390402794, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11972532421350479, + 0.037725821137428284, + 0.028583858162164688, + 0.023022903129458427, + 0.027520030736923218, + 0.01427201647311449, + 0.08426200598478317, + 0.4509214460849762, + 0.08200961351394653, + 0.1319570094347 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04306408390402794 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at a cracked asphalt street corner in a densely populated urban area under a clear, deep blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera initially positioned at a low angle and does it slowly tilt upward to reveal the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the primary subject a classic cast-iron fire hydrant with a faded red body revealing rust and a dull metallic chain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the side cover of the hydrant burst apart violently, flung sideways, and spin erratically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a high-pressure horizontal stream of water erupt from the hydrant, creating steam and a reflective pool on the asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002488137688487768 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002488136291504 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002488137688487768, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002488137688487768, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12666387856006622, + 0.08190828561782837, + 0.05528640002012253, + 0.0685066431760788, + 0.024785632267594337, + 0.03192278742790222, + 0.10548856109380722, + 0.20146846771240234, + 0.14666113257408142, + 0.1573082059621811 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002488137688487768 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at a cracked asphalt street corner in a densely populated urban area under a clear, deep blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera initially positioned at a low angle and does it slowly tilt upward to reveal the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the primary subject a classic cast-iron fire hydrant with a faded red body revealing rust and a dull metallic chain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the side cover of the hydrant burst apart violently, flung sideways, and spin erratically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a high-pressure horizontal stream of water erupt from the hydrant, creating steam and a reflective pool on the asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.054952267557382584 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929952383041382 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.054952267557382584, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.054952267557382584, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05983288586139679, + 0.0275493822991848, + 0.028438962996006012, + 0.03434878587722778, + 0.044606320559978485, + 0.03541478142142296, + 0.10734575986862183, + 0.19046029448509216, + 0.3349371552467346, + 0.13706573843955994 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.054952267557382584 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at a cracked asphalt street corner in a densely populated urban area under a clear, deep blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera initially positioned at a low angle and does it slowly tilt upward to reveal the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the primary subject a classic cast-iron fire hydrant with a faded red body revealing rust and a dull metallic chain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the side cover of the hydrant burst apart violently, flung sideways, and spin erratically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a high-pressure horizontal stream of water erupt from the hydrant, creating steam and a reflective pool on the asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008633195422589779 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758633136749268 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008633195422589779, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008633195422589779, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11685533821582794, + 0.02515460178256035, + 0.026190713047981262, + 0.026203548535704613, + 0.01274058036506176, + 0.020094716921448708, + 0.06359750777482986, + 0.4085887670516968, + 0.15466824173927307, + 0.1459060162305832 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008633195422589779 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "The scene opens with a static, low-angle shot of a cracked asphalt street corner in a densely populated urban area, simmering in the harsh afternoon sun. The direct, high sun casts sharp shadows across the gravel road, with tiny weeds sprouting from the cracks, while a perfectly clear, cloudless, deep blue sky stretches overhead, creating a stark visual contrast. The camera slowly and deliberately tilts upward, its gaze settling on the primary subject: a classic cast-iron fire hydrant. Its body, coated in layer upon layer of vibrant red paint, is now slightly faded and worn in places, revealing the old coat and the deep rust beneath. Its surface texture feels rough to the touch. The large hexagonal nut and the chain securing the side cover gleam in the intense light, gleaming with a dull metallic sheen. For a moment, the scene remains in a state of intense stillness, until suddenly, with a violent explosion, the side cover bursts apart, flung sideways onto the end of the chain, and spun erratically. From the exposed opening, a powerful, high-pressure horizontal stream of water erupts, a translucent jet that catches the sunlight and atomizes at the edges into a shimmering, fine mist. The gushing water crashes into the scorching street, instantly creating a cloud of steam that quickly floods the cracked asphalt, its flow forming a sprawling, reflective pool that mirrors the deep blue sky above, transforming the stuffy city corner with a sudden, chaotic burst of refreshing energy.", + "seed": 23798, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_11/index_6241_seed_23798_dp_23_rank_46_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.04388816442806274, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04388816442806274, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.325, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04388816442806274, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at a cracked asphalt street corner in a densely populated urban area under a clear, deep blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera initially positioned at a low angle and does it slowly tilt upward to reveal the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the primary subject a classic cast-iron fire hydrant with a faded red body revealing rust and a dull metallic chain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the side cover of the hydrant burst apart violently, flung sideways, and spin erratically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a high-pressure horizontal stream of water erupt from the hydrant, creating steam and a reflective pool on the asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12758922576904297 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.127589225769043 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12758922576904297, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12758922576904297, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10708382725715637, + 0.03636495769023895, + 0.0314544253051281, + 0.05386299639940262, + 0.16787934303283691, + 0.07738300412893295, + 0.08889993280172348, + 0.3632184565067291, + 0.040918417274951935, + 0.03293463587760925 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12758922576904297 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at a cracked asphalt street corner in a densely populated urban area under a clear, deep blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera initially positioned at a low angle and does it slowly tilt upward to reveal the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the primary subject a classic cast-iron fire hydrant with a faded red body revealing rust and a dull metallic chain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the side cover of the hydrant burst apart violently, flung sideways, and spin erratically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a high-pressure horizontal stream of water erupt from the hydrant, creating steam and a reflective pool on the asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07900222390890121 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5790021419525146 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07900222390890121, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07900222390890121, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23103494942188263, + 0.030406124889850616, + 0.02472570165991783, + 0.0744885578751564, + 0.12460845708847046, + 0.05225526541471481, + 0.19179077446460724, + 0.16208769381046295, + 0.05518991872668266, + 0.0534125417470932 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07900222390890121 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at a cracked asphalt street corner in a densely populated urban area under a clear, deep blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera initially positioned at a low angle and does it slowly tilt upward to reveal the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the primary subject a classic cast-iron fire hydrant with a faded red body revealing rust and a dull metallic chain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the side cover of the hydrant burst apart violently, flung sideways, and spin erratically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a high-pressure horizontal stream of water erupt from the hydrant, creating steam and a reflective pool on the asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002493607811629772 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002493381500244 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002493607811629772, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002493607811629772, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21956866979599, + 0.11191803961992264, + 0.04521339759230614, + 0.032224979251623154, + 0.11776067316532135, + 0.021934309974312782, + 0.04494126886129379, + 0.2707662284374237, + 0.11040221154689789, + 0.0252702459692955 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002493607811629772 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at a cracked asphalt street corner in a densely populated urban area under a clear, deep blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera initially positioned at a low angle and does it slowly tilt upward to reveal the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the primary subject a classic cast-iron fire hydrant with a faded red body revealing rust and a dull metallic chain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the side cover of the hydrant burst apart violently, flung sideways, and spin erratically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a high-pressure horizontal stream of water erupt from the hydrant, creating steam and a reflective pool on the asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008643240667879581 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.75864315032959 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008643240667879581, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008643240667879581, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07859146595001221, + 0.02632749453186989, + 0.017312048003077507, + 0.04234681278467178, + 0.33359435200691223, + 0.035157252103090286, + 0.13885383307933807, + 0.17631590366363525, + 0.12000004202127457, + 0.03150084242224693 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008643240667879581 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at a cracked asphalt street corner in a densely populated urban area under a clear, deep blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera initially positioned at a low angle and does it slowly tilt upward to reveal the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the primary subject a classic cast-iron fire hydrant with a faded red body revealing rust and a dull metallic chain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the side cover of the hydrant burst apart violently, flung sideways, and spin erratically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a high-pressure horizontal stream of water erupt from the hydrant, creating steam and a reflective pool on the asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.001712523982860148 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.376712322235107 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.001712523982860148, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.001712523982860148, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08542649447917938, + 0.03230123966932297, + 0.029959969222545624, + 0.04318315163254738, + 0.06403126567602158, + 0.025278281420469284, + 0.06967272609472275, + 0.1912449151277542, + 0.43071743845939636, + 0.02818448655307293 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.001712523982860148 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_12/index_tensor([8779, 8779])_group_12_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_12/index_tensor([8779, 8779])_group_12_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..92430272c5efcd863a216f01521b99b6e476881d --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_12/index_tensor([8779, 8779])_group_12_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "slowly zooming wide shot begins with a medium close-up of a bride's back, standing alone and quietly on the edge of a cliff, overlooking the turbulent azure sea below. Her long, dark brown hair is meticulously tied into an elegant low bun, strands playfully blew by the sea breeze, caressing her smooth neck. She wears a simple yet elegant ivory satin wedding gown, its fitted bodice emphasizing her slender waist. The most striking feature is her long, pristine white veil, made of the lightest tulle. It cascades down from her bun, unfurling, fluttering, and undulating in the air, carried by the relentless sea breeze like a cloud brought to life, occasionally brushing gently against her bare arms. As the camera steadily and smoothly pulls back, a sweeping panorama unfolds: at the golden hour of sunset, the warm, soft sunlight paints the sky a magnificent canvas of orange, pink, and lavender. The golden light casts a divine halo around the bride's silhouette and shimmers through the translucent veil, creating shimmering specks of light across its surface. The scene's warm and poetic tones create an epic atmosphere of tranquility, romance, and boundless hope and contemplation.", + "seed": 13711, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_12/index_8779_seed_13711_dp_24_rank_48_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.029855918884277344, + "vlm_logprob": -0.029855918884277344, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.95, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.029855918884277344, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a bride wearing an ivory satin wedding gown with a low bun hairstyle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bride standing on the edge of a cliff overlooking a turbulent azure sea?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bride wear a long, pristine white tulle veil that is fluttering and undulating in the breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set during the golden hour of sunset with a sky painted in orange, pink, and lavender?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a medium close-up and smoothly zoom out to reveal a sweeping panorama?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0273609422147274 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7773609161376953 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0273609422147274, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0273609422147274, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12210320681333542, + 0.1144733801484108, + 0.24859535694122314, + 0.054127659648656845, + 0.06103874742984772, + 0.0522429421544075, + 0.05860215425491333, + 0.025199882686138153, + 0.04838607832789421, + 0.21523058414459229 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0273609422147274 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a bride wearing an ivory satin wedding gown with a low bun hairstyle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bride standing on the edge of a cliff overlooking a turbulent azure sea?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bride wear a long, pristine white tulle veil that is fluttering and undulating in the breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set during the golden hour of sunset with a sky painted in orange, pink, and lavender?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a medium close-up and smoothly zoom out to reveal a sweeping panorama?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08902943134307861 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.464029312133789 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08902943134307861, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08902943134307861, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2439606934785843, + 0.052414171397686005, + 0.16988861560821533, + 0.05627784505486488, + 0.12765848636627197, + 0.08763600140810013, + 0.07413481175899506, + 0.026868868619203568, + 0.03373345360159874, + 0.12742701172828674 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08902943134307861 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a bride wearing an ivory satin wedding gown with a low bun hairstyle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bride standing on the edge of a cliff overlooking a turbulent azure sea?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bride wear a long, pristine white tulle veil that is fluttering and undulating in the breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set during the golden hour of sunset with a sky painted in orange, pink, and lavender?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a medium close-up and smoothly zoom out to reveal a sweeping panorama?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011079693213105202 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511079788208008 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011079693213105202, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011079693213105202, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11138341575860977, + 0.06701740622520447, + 0.12495744973421097, + 0.07244382053613663, + 0.16824489831924438, + 0.15741609036922455, + 0.04741378128528595, + 0.03401446342468262, + 0.05479595065116882, + 0.16231268644332886 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011079693213105202 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a bride wearing an ivory satin wedding gown with a low bun hairstyle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bride standing on the edge of a cliff overlooking a turbulent azure sea?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bride wear a long, pristine white tulle veil that is fluttering and undulating in the breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set during the golden hour of sunset with a sky painted in orange, pink, and lavender?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a medium close-up and smoothly zoom out to reveal a sweeping panorama?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007624335587024689 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.88262414932251 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007624335587024689, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007624335587024689, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3408447802066803, + 0.04686698690056801, + 0.055161140859127045, + 0.07979071140289307, + 0.06837831437587738, + 0.0732627585530281, + 0.09601633250713348, + 0.06234843283891678, + 0.08816453814506531, + 0.08916598558425903 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007624335587024689 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a bride wearing an ivory satin wedding gown with a low bun hairstyle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bride standing on the edge of a cliff overlooking a turbulent azure sea?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bride wear a long, pristine white tulle veil that is fluttering and undulating in the breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set during the golden hour of sunset with a sky painted in orange, pink, and lavender?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a medium close-up and smoothly zoom out to reveal a sweeping panorama?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014185192063450813 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264185428619385 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014185192063450813, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014185192063450813, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10031231492757797, + 0.07368931919336319, + 0.10620801895856857, + 0.0855904221534729, + 0.09530700743198395, + 0.06134890764951706, + 0.11734040081501007, + 0.017182523384690285, + 0.0334663912653923, + 0.3095546364784241 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014185192063450813 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slowly zooming wide shot begins with a medium close-up of a bride's back, standing alone and quietly on the edge of a cliff, overlooking the turbulent azure sea below. Her long, dark brown hair is meticulously tied into an elegant low bun, strands playfully blew by the sea breeze, caressing her smooth neck. She wears a simple yet elegant ivory satin wedding gown, its fitted bodice emphasizing her slender waist. The most striking feature is her long, pristine white veil, made of the lightest tulle. It cascades down from her bun, unfurling, fluttering, and undulating in the air, carried by the relentless sea breeze like a cloud brought to life, occasionally brushing gently against her bare arms. As the camera steadily and smoothly pulls back, a sweeping panorama unfolds: at the golden hour of sunset, the warm, soft sunlight paints the sky a magnificent canvas of orange, pink, and lavender. The golden light casts a divine halo around the bride's silhouette and shimmers through the translucent veil, creating shimmering specks of light across its surface. The scene's warm and poetic tones create an epic atmosphere of tranquility, romance, and boundless hope and contemplation.", + "seed": 13712, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_12/index_8779_seed_13712_dp_24_rank_48_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.08049541907384991, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08049541907384991, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.825, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08049541907384991, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a bride wearing an ivory satin wedding gown with a low bun hairstyle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bride standing on the edge of a cliff overlooking a turbulent azure sea?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bride wear a long, pristine white tulle veil that is fluttering and undulating in the breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set during the golden hour of sunset with a sky painted in orange, pink, and lavender?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a medium close-up and smoothly zoom out to reveal a sweeping panorama?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03174543380737305 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.531745433807373 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03174543380737305, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03174543380737305, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1077086478471756, + 0.06408942490816116, + 0.06784181296825409, + 0.04677795246243477, + 0.22175657749176025, + 0.048040784895420074, + 0.06282366812229156, + 0.2406083196401596, + 0.08128544688224792, + 0.05906734615564346 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03174543380737305 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a bride wearing an ivory satin wedding gown with a low bun hairstyle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bride standing on the edge of a cliff overlooking a turbulent azure sea?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bride wear a long, pristine white tulle veil that is fluttering and undulating in the breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set during the golden hour of sunset with a sky painted in orange, pink, and lavender?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a medium close-up and smoothly zoom out to reveal a sweeping panorama?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3486189842224121 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.223618984222412 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3486189842224121, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3486189842224121, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04140212759375572, + 0.01743035577237606, + 0.012734046205878258, + 0.027155118063092232, + 0.03381119295954704, + 0.03183004632592201, + 0.20302093029022217, + 0.29571372270584106, + 0.016180356964468956, + 0.3207221031188965 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3486189842224121 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a bride wearing an ivory satin wedding gown with a low bun hairstyle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bride standing on the edge of a cliff overlooking a turbulent azure sea?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bride wear a long, pristine white tulle veil that is fluttering and undulating in the breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set during the golden hour of sunset with a sky painted in orange, pink, and lavender?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a medium close-up and smoothly zoom out to reveal a sweeping panorama?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00674400432035327 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006743907928467 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00674400432035327, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00674400432035327, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04741768166422844, + 0.023858889937400818, + 0.027763888239860535, + 0.03112635761499405, + 0.132664754986763, + 0.03215496987104416, + 0.10835149139165878, + 0.43054160475730896, + 0.06789376586675644, + 0.09822655469179153 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00674400432035327 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a bride wearing an ivory satin wedding gown with a low bun hairstyle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bride standing on the edge of a cliff overlooking a turbulent azure sea?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bride wear a long, pristine white tulle veil that is fluttering and undulating in the breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set during the golden hour of sunset with a sky painted in orange, pink, and lavender?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a medium close-up and smoothly zoom out to reveal a sweeping panorama?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006735360249876976 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006735324859619 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006735360249876976, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006735360249876976, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04074880853295326, + 0.02144496701657772, + 0.010451636277139187, + 0.02547931671142578, + 0.10972528159618378, + 0.03737340494990349, + 0.38981765508651733, + 0.14388105273246765, + 0.01836741343140602, + 0.20271047949790955 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006735360249876976 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a bride wearing an ivory satin wedding gown with a low bun hairstyle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bride standing on the edge of a cliff overlooking a turbulent azure sea?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bride wear a long, pristine white tulle veil that is fluttering and undulating in the breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set during the golden hour of sunset with a sky painted in orange, pink, and lavender?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a medium close-up and smoothly zoom out to reveal a sweeping panorama?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00863331276923418 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758633136749268 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00863331276923418, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00863331276923418, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07084339112043381, + 0.04062935709953308, + 0.03607285022735596, + 0.05038837343454361, + 0.03357832878828049, + 0.018701376393437386, + 0.16232962906360626, + 0.461569607257843, + 0.0863175094127655, + 0.039569634944200516 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00863331276923418 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slowly zooming wide shot begins with a medium close-up of a bride's back, standing alone and quietly on the edge of a cliff, overlooking the turbulent azure sea below. Her long, dark brown hair is meticulously tied into an elegant low bun, strands playfully blew by the sea breeze, caressing her smooth neck. She wears a simple yet elegant ivory satin wedding gown, its fitted bodice emphasizing her slender waist. The most striking feature is her long, pristine white veil, made of the lightest tulle. It cascades down from her bun, unfurling, fluttering, and undulating in the air, carried by the relentless sea breeze like a cloud brought to life, occasionally brushing gently against her bare arms. As the camera steadily and smoothly pulls back, a sweeping panorama unfolds: at the golden hour of sunset, the warm, soft sunlight paints the sky a magnificent canvas of orange, pink, and lavender. The golden light casts a divine halo around the bride's silhouette and shimmers through the translucent veil, creating shimmering specks of light across its surface. The scene's warm and poetic tones create an epic atmosphere of tranquility, romance, and boundless hope and contemplation.", + "seed": 13713, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_12/index_8779_seed_13713_dp_25_rank_50_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.06111781215295196, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06111781215295196, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.6, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06111781215295196, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a bride wearing an ivory satin wedding gown with a low bun hairstyle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bride standing on the edge of a cliff overlooking a turbulent azure sea?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bride wear a long, pristine white tulle veil that is fluttering and undulating in the breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set during the golden hour of sunset with a sky painted in orange, pink, and lavender?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a medium close-up and smoothly zoom out to reveal a sweeping panorama?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01701929233968258 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.267019271850586 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01701929233968258, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01701929233968258, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09215933829545975, + 0.06626498699188232, + 0.07914499193429947, + 0.18267381191253662, + 0.12868820130825043, + 0.25982096791267395, + 0.07242601364850998, + 0.07539770007133484, + 0.014587300829589367, + 0.02883663773536682 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01701929233968258 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a bride wearing an ivory satin wedding gown with a low bun hairstyle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bride standing on the edge of a cliff overlooking a turbulent azure sea?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bride wear a long, pristine white tulle veil that is fluttering and undulating in the breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set during the golden hour of sunset with a sky painted in orange, pink, and lavender?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a medium close-up and smoothly zoom out to reveal a sweeping panorama?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1798870712518692 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.804887056350708 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1798870712518692, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1798870712518692, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08698433637619019, + 0.06482695788145065, + 0.18159042298793793, + 0.247215136885643, + 0.041660718619823456, + 0.102631114423275, + 0.0589275136590004, + 0.026814928278326988, + 0.03009951300919056, + 0.159249410033226 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1798870712518692 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a bride wearing an ivory satin wedding gown with a low bun hairstyle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bride standing on the edge of a cliff overlooking a turbulent azure sea?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bride wear a long, pristine white tulle veil that is fluttering and undulating in the breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set during the golden hour of sunset with a sky painted in orange, pink, and lavender?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a medium close-up and smoothly zoom out to reveal a sweeping panorama?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003618124406784773 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628618240356445 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003618124406784773, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003618124406784773, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06695964187383652, + 0.08434722572565079, + 0.07011596113443375, + 0.16006892919540405, + 0.14274021983146667, + 0.20940425992012024, + 0.1273321509361267, + 0.0386781208217144, + 0.03263232484459877, + 0.0677211582660675 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003618124406784773 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a bride wearing an ivory satin wedding gown with a low bun hairstyle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bride standing on the edge of a cliff overlooking a turbulent azure sea?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bride wear a long, pristine white tulle veil that is fluttering and undulating in the breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set during the golden hour of sunset with a sky painted in orange, pink, and lavender?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a medium close-up and smoothly zoom out to reveal a sweeping panorama?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01606121100485325 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141061305999756 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01606121100485325, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01606121100485325, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05303476005792618, + 0.07996207475662231, + 0.567382276058197, + 0.06315527111291885, + 0.03197471797466278, + 0.025241922587156296, + 0.03395748883485794, + 0.034378331154584885, + 0.013217879459261894, + 0.0976952388882637 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01606121100485325 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a bride wearing an ivory satin wedding gown with a low bun hairstyle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bride standing on the edge of a cliff overlooking a turbulent azure sea?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bride wear a long, pristine white tulle veil that is fluttering and undulating in the breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set during the golden hour of sunset with a sky painted in orange, pink, and lavender?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a medium close-up and smoothly zoom out to reveal a sweeping panorama?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08900336176156998 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.464003324508667 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08900336176156998, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08900336176156998, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1283249706029892, + 0.17259861528873444, + 0.18200825154781342, + 0.0696936547756195, + 0.0876469835639, + 0.1707833707332611, + 0.08327290415763855, + 0.05488870292901993, + 0.015510300174355507, + 0.035272225737571716 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08900336176156998 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slowly zooming wide shot begins with a medium close-up of a bride's back, standing alone and quietly on the edge of a cliff, overlooking the turbulent azure sea below. Her long, dark brown hair is meticulously tied into an elegant low bun, strands playfully blew by the sea breeze, caressing her smooth neck. She wears a simple yet elegant ivory satin wedding gown, its fitted bodice emphasizing her slender waist. The most striking feature is her long, pristine white veil, made of the lightest tulle. It cascades down from her bun, unfurling, fluttering, and undulating in the air, carried by the relentless sea breeze like a cloud brought to life, occasionally brushing gently against her bare arms. As the camera steadily and smoothly pulls back, a sweeping panorama unfolds: at the golden hour of sunset, the warm, soft sunlight paints the sky a magnificent canvas of orange, pink, and lavender. The golden light casts a divine halo around the bride's silhouette and shimmers through the translucent veil, creating shimmering specks of light across its surface. The scene's warm and poetic tones create an epic atmosphere of tranquility, romance, and boundless hope and contemplation.", + "seed": 13714, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_12/index_8779_seed_13714_dp_25_rank_50_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.055694999359548095, + "vlm_logprob": -0.055694999359548095, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.025, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.055694999359548095, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a bride wearing an ivory satin wedding gown with a low bun hairstyle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bride standing on the edge of a cliff overlooking a turbulent azure sea?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bride wear a long, pristine white tulle veil that is fluttering and undulating in the breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set during the golden hour of sunset with a sky painted in orange, pink, and lavender?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a medium close-up and smoothly zoom out to reveal a sweeping panorama?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02252761647105217 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8975276947021484 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02252761647105217, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02252761647105217, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1726190745830536, + 0.06146353855729103, + 0.03260255977511406, + 0.10202985256910324, + 0.18547797203063965, + 0.05100128427147865, + 0.13876976072788239, + 0.08666713535785675, + 0.10798674821853638, + 0.061382126063108444 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02252761647105217 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a bride wearing an ivory satin wedding gown with a low bun hairstyle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bride standing on the edge of a cliff overlooking a turbulent azure sea?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bride wear a long, pristine white tulle veil that is fluttering and undulating in the breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set during the golden hour of sunset with a sky painted in orange, pink, and lavender?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a medium close-up and smoothly zoom out to reveal a sweeping panorama?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22554640471935272 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6005463600158691 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.22554640471935272, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.22554640471935272, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10072265565395355, + 0.07094366103410721, + 0.03409961611032486, + 0.031179610639810562, + 0.08615528047084808, + 0.06871431320905685, + 0.34847354888916016, + 0.17667299509048462, + 0.036014072597026825, + 0.0470241978764534 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.22554640471935272 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a bride wearing an ivory satin wedding gown with a low bun hairstyle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bride standing on the edge of a cliff overlooking a turbulent azure sea?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bride wear a long, pristine white tulle veil that is fluttering and undulating in the breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set during the golden hour of sunset with a sky painted in orange, pink, and lavender?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a medium close-up and smoothly zoom out to reveal a sweeping panorama?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007637703791260719 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.8826375007629395 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007637703791260719, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007637703791260719, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09300003200769424, + 0.08866093307733536, + 0.041468631476163864, + 0.21465621888637543, + 0.07217910140752792, + 0.0328669399023056, + 0.13398794829845428, + 0.06858264654874802, + 0.13771505653858185, + 0.11688258498907089 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007637703791260719 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a bride wearing an ivory satin wedding gown with a low bun hairstyle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bride standing on the edge of a cliff overlooking a turbulent azure sea?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bride wear a long, pristine white tulle veil that is fluttering and undulating in the breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set during the golden hour of sunset with a sky painted in orange, pink, and lavender?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a medium close-up and smoothly zoom out to reveal a sweeping panorama?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002195212058722973 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127195358276367 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002195212058722973, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002195212058722973, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09727439284324646, + 0.0930400937795639, + 0.03609643504023552, + 0.041168734431266785, + 0.16887052357196808, + 0.10315860062837601, + 0.2542543411254883, + 0.08253931999206543, + 0.08530934154987335, + 0.03828822448849678 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002195212058722973 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a bride wearing an ivory satin wedding gown with a low bun hairstyle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bride standing on the edge of a cliff overlooking a turbulent azure sea?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bride wear a long, pristine white tulle veil that is fluttering and undulating in the breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set during the golden hour of sunset with a sky painted in orange, pink, and lavender?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a medium close-up and smoothly zoom out to reveal a sweeping panorama?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020568059757351875 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955681324005127 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020568059757351875, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020568059757351875, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08167003095149994, + 0.05777514725923538, + 0.05052907392382622, + 0.0534210205078125, + 0.06334918737411499, + 0.06998535990715027, + 0.11048803478479385, + 0.11395943909883499, + 0.3324626684188843, + 0.06636006385087967 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020568059757351875 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_13/index_tensor([3388, 3388])_group_13_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_13/index_tensor([3388, 3388])_group_13_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..711131238996e24db4e6478dda9148aa6db94df0 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_13/index_tensor([3388, 3388])_group_13_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "In a static, low-angle, medium shot shot upward from the foot of a bed, a dim bedroom is captured. Only faint moonlight filters through the gaps in the blinds on one side of the window, casting sharp, pale streaks of light on the walls and furniture. A young woman with long, tousled, dark brown hair suddenly sits up in bed, her movement swift and stiff, as if pulled upward by invisible strings. She wears a light gray cotton T-shirt, slightly damp with cold sweat. Her forehead is beaded with beads of sweat. Her eyes are wide with utter terror, her pupils constricted in the darkness. Her lips part, her chest heaving violently as she breathes in short, hoarse gasps. Each inhale feels like a desperate struggle for air, and her hands subconsciously clutch the tousled white sheets beneath her. The high-contrast, cold-toned image is imbued with a sense of dread and suspense, creating a tense atmosphere of waking from a nightmare, enveloped in loneliness and suffocating fear.", + "seed": 12317, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_13/index_3388_seed_12317_dp_26_rank_52_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.08780186884105205, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08780186884105205, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.325000011920929, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08780186884105205, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle looking upward from the foot of a bed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a dim bedroom with faint moonlight filtering through blinds casting sharp pale streaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a young woman with long, tousled, dark brown hair sitting up in bed with a swift and stiff motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a light gray cotton T-shirt that appears slightly damp with cold sweat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman exhibit signs of terror with wide eyes, constricted pupils, parted lips, and heaving chest while clutching white sheets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3566057085990906 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2316057682037354 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3566057085990906, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.8750000596046448, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3566057085990906, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3541271388530731, + 0.06554675102233887, + 0.047083012759685516, + 0.0816357210278511, + 0.09947088360786438, + 0.11112798750400543, + 0.08053187280893326, + 0.10924287885427475, + 0.030876360833644867, + 0.020357387140393257 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3566057085990906 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle looking upward from the foot of a bed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a dim bedroom with faint moonlight filtering through blinds casting sharp pale streaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a young woman with long, tousled, dark brown hair sitting up in bed with a swift and stiff motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a light gray cotton T-shirt that appears slightly damp with cold sweat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman exhibit signs of terror with wide eyes, constricted pupils, parted lips, and heaving chest while clutching white sheets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018219847232103348 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018219947814941 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018219847232103348, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018219847232103348, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3843773603439331, + 0.05492440611124039, + 0.04321432486176491, + 0.03741056099534035, + 0.08255644142627716, + 0.043669819831848145, + 0.20739802718162537, + 0.056776490062475204, + 0.06486652791500092, + 0.024805985391139984 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018219847232103348 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle looking upward from the foot of a bed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a dim bedroom with faint moonlight filtering through blinds casting sharp pale streaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a young woman with long, tousled, dark brown hair sitting up in bed with a swift and stiff motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a light gray cotton T-shirt that appears slightly damp with cold sweat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman exhibit signs of terror with wide eyes, constricted pupils, parted lips, and heaving chest while clutching white sheets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011086884886026382 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511086940765381 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011086884886026382, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011086884886026382, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16031324863433838, + 0.0812668576836586, + 0.04154433682560921, + 0.06660886108875275, + 0.06647362560033798, + 0.0795043483376503, + 0.0338524654507637, + 0.38947543501853943, + 0.049212224781513214, + 0.03174855560064316 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011086884886026382 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle looking upward from the foot of a bed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a dim bedroom with faint moonlight filtering through blinds casting sharp pale streaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a young woman with long, tousled, dark brown hair sitting up in bed with a swift and stiff motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a light gray cotton T-shirt that appears slightly damp with cold sweat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman exhibit signs of terror with wide eyes, constricted pupils, parted lips, and heaving chest while clutching white sheets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02981220744550228 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298120975494385 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02981220744550228, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02981220744550228, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19862259924411774, + 0.07704683393239975, + 0.0506930872797966, + 0.1513383388519287, + 0.06624166667461395, + 0.10857899487018585, + 0.2076074331998825, + 0.06437849998474121, + 0.04659004136919975, + 0.028902484104037285 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02981220744550228 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle looking upward from the foot of a bed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a dim bedroom with faint moonlight filtering through blinds casting sharp pale streaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a young woman with long, tousled, dark brown hair sitting up in bed with a swift and stiff motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a light gray cotton T-shirt that appears slightly damp with cold sweat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman exhibit signs of terror with wide eyes, constricted pupils, parted lips, and heaving chest while clutching white sheets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02328469604253769 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773284673690796 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02328469604253769, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02328469604253769, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2874473035335541, + 0.03767568618059158, + 0.05442573502659798, + 0.033868927508592606, + 0.05118117853999138, + 0.10472330451011658, + 0.04882645606994629, + 0.2803817391395569, + 0.06890320777893066, + 0.03256649151444435 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02328469604253769 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a static, low-angle, medium shot shot upward from the foot of a bed, a dim bedroom is captured. Only faint moonlight filters through the gaps in the blinds on one side of the window, casting sharp, pale streaks of light on the walls and furniture. A young woman with long, tousled, dark brown hair suddenly sits up in bed, her movement swift and stiff, as if pulled upward by invisible strings. She wears a light gray cotton T-shirt, slightly damp with cold sweat. Her forehead is beaded with beads of sweat. Her eyes are wide with utter terror, her pupils constricted in the darkness. Her lips part, her chest heaving violently as she breathes in short, hoarse gasps. Each inhale feels like a desperate struggle for air, and her hands subconsciously clutch the tousled white sheets beneath her. The high-contrast, cold-toned image is imbued with a sense of dread and suspense, creating a tense atmosphere of waking from a nightmare, enveloped in loneliness and suffocating fear.", + "seed": 12318, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_13/index_3388_seed_12318_dp_26_rank_52_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.03476704526692629, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03476704526692629, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.099999976158142, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03476704526692629, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle looking upward from the foot of a bed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a dim bedroom with faint moonlight filtering through blinds casting sharp pale streaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a young woman with long, tousled, dark brown hair sitting up in bed with a swift and stiff motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a light gray cotton T-shirt that appears slightly damp with cold sweat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman exhibit signs of terror with wide eyes, constricted pupils, parted lips, and heaving chest while clutching white sheets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.13334022462368011 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1333401203155518 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.13334022462368011, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.9999998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -0.13334022462368011, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.6597135663032532, + 0.04949308931827545, + 0.046153608709573746, + 0.043297793716192245, + 0.04382531717419624, + 0.037366338074207306, + 0.037164751440286636, + 0.012694521807134151, + 0.053280919790267944, + 0.017010128125548363 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.13334022462368011 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle looking upward from the foot of a bed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a dim bedroom with faint moonlight filtering through blinds casting sharp pale streaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a young woman with long, tousled, dark brown hair sitting up in bed with a swift and stiff motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a light gray cotton T-shirt that appears slightly damp with cold sweat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman exhibit signs of terror with wide eyes, constricted pupils, parted lips, and heaving chest while clutching white sheets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012573259882628918 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.3875732421875 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012573259882628918, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012573259882628918, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.32937541604042053, + 0.056735873222351074, + 0.041807156056165695, + 0.2009333074092865, + 0.046556636691093445, + 0.06452087312936783, + 0.045755427330732346, + 0.08770480006933212, + 0.06697725504636765, + 0.05963335558772087 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012573259882628918 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle looking upward from the foot of a bed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a dim bedroom with faint moonlight filtering through blinds casting sharp pale streaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a young woman with long, tousled, dark brown hair sitting up in bed with a swift and stiff motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a light gray cotton T-shirt that appears slightly damp with cold sweat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman exhibit signs of terror with wide eyes, constricted pupils, parted lips, and heaving chest while clutching white sheets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006743885576725006 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006743907928467 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006743885576725006, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006743885576725006, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17940019071102142, + 0.08946018666028976, + 0.10265913605690002, + 0.14102205634117126, + 0.13887839019298553, + 0.06360206753015518, + 0.10085377842187881, + 0.04434923827648163, + 0.09495684504508972, + 0.04481803625822067 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006743885576725006 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle looking upward from the foot of a bed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a dim bedroom with faint moonlight filtering through blinds casting sharp pale streaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a young woman with long, tousled, dark brown hair sitting up in bed with a swift and stiff motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a light gray cotton T-shirt that appears slightly damp with cold sweat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman exhibit signs of terror with wide eyes, constricted pupils, parted lips, and heaving chest while clutching white sheets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01254265196621418 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387542724609375 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01254265196621418, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01254265196621418, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22890232503414154, + 0.11022458225488663, + 0.17617957293987274, + 0.09544318914413452, + 0.05497504398226738, + 0.09978213906288147, + 0.0950125902891159, + 0.02816990576684475, + 0.04014429450035095, + 0.07116637378931046 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01254265196621418 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle looking upward from the foot of a bed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a dim bedroom with faint moonlight filtering through blinds casting sharp pale streaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a young woman with long, tousled, dark brown hair sitting up in bed with a swift and stiff motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a light gray cotton T-shirt that appears slightly damp with cold sweat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman exhibit signs of terror with wide eyes, constricted pupils, parted lips, and heaving chest while clutching white sheets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008635204285383224 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.7586350440979 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008635204285383224, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008635204285383224, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18479502201080322, + 0.09456802904605865, + 0.15966415405273438, + 0.09368147701025009, + 0.0451471284031868, + 0.0881308764219284, + 0.0802655816078186, + 0.042818713933229446, + 0.16645710170269012, + 0.04447184130549431 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008635204285383224 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a static, low-angle, medium shot shot upward from the foot of a bed, a dim bedroom is captured. Only faint moonlight filters through the gaps in the blinds on one side of the window, casting sharp, pale streaks of light on the walls and furniture. A young woman with long, tousled, dark brown hair suddenly sits up in bed, her movement swift and stiff, as if pulled upward by invisible strings. She wears a light gray cotton T-shirt, slightly damp with cold sweat. Her forehead is beaded with beads of sweat. Her eyes are wide with utter terror, her pupils constricted in the darkness. Her lips part, her chest heaving violently as she breathes in short, hoarse gasps. Each inhale feels like a desperate struggle for air, and her hands subconsciously clutch the tousled white sheets beneath her. The high-contrast, cold-toned image is imbued with a sense of dread and suspense, creating a tense atmosphere of waking from a nightmare, enveloped in loneliness and suffocating fear.", + "seed": 12319, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_13/index_3388_seed_12319_dp_27_rank_54_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.036192760430276395, + "vlm_logprob": -0.036192760430276395, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.925, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.036192760430276395, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle looking upward from the foot of a bed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a dim bedroom with faint moonlight filtering through blinds casting sharp pale streaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a young woman with long, tousled, dark brown hair sitting up in bed with a swift and stiff motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a light gray cotton T-shirt that appears slightly damp with cold sweat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman exhibit signs of terror with wide eyes, constricted pupils, parted lips, and heaving chest while clutching white sheets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1059064045548439 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3559064865112305 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1059064045548439, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1059064045548439, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11201885342597961, + 0.07777512073516846, + 0.0999099463224411, + 0.06330793350934982, + 0.12148425728082657, + 0.1043868437409401, + 0.14221347868442535, + 0.20002110302448273, + 0.0417172871530056, + 0.03716519847512245 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1059064045548439 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle looking upward from the foot of a bed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a dim bedroom with faint moonlight filtering through blinds casting sharp pale streaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a young woman with long, tousled, dark brown hair sitting up in bed with a swift and stiff motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a light gray cotton T-shirt that appears slightly damp with cold sweat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman exhibit signs of terror with wide eyes, constricted pupils, parted lips, and heaving chest while clutching white sheets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04309263080358505 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168092727661133 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04309263080358505, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04309263080358505, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2985326647758484, + 0.07918880879878998, + 0.09013840556144714, + 0.025702685117721558, + 0.11316940188407898, + 0.04536336287856102, + 0.1528986096382141, + 0.059478987008333206, + 0.07253074645996094, + 0.06299631297588348 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04309263080358505 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle looking upward from the foot of a bed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a dim bedroom with faint moonlight filtering through blinds casting sharp pale streaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a young woman with long, tousled, dark brown hair sitting up in bed with a swift and stiff motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a light gray cotton T-shirt that appears slightly damp with cold sweat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman exhibit signs of terror with wide eyes, constricted pupils, parted lips, and heaving chest while clutching white sheets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00674400432035327 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006743907928467 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00674400432035327, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00674400432035327, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07641120254993439, + 0.05263092741370201, + 0.04835618659853935, + 0.05918833240866661, + 0.10387680679559708, + 0.1896042674779892, + 0.18983194231987, + 0.046971436589956284, + 0.15557891130447388, + 0.07754993438720703 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00674400432035327 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle looking upward from the foot of a bed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a dim bedroom with faint moonlight filtering through blinds casting sharp pale streaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a young woman with long, tousled, dark brown hair sitting up in bed with a swift and stiff motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a light gray cotton T-shirt that appears slightly damp with cold sweat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman exhibit signs of terror with wide eyes, constricted pupils, parted lips, and heaving chest while clutching white sheets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020585577934980392 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895585536956787 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020585577934980392, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020585577934980392, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1508181244134903, + 0.05888054892420769, + 0.08216922730207443, + 0.05588797479867935, + 0.037306465208530426, + 0.060903098434209824, + 0.23245273530483246, + 0.10064241290092468, + 0.1639827936887741, + 0.05695663020014763 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020585577934980392 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle looking upward from the foot of a bed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a dim bedroom with faint moonlight filtering through blinds casting sharp pale streaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a young woman with long, tousled, dark brown hair sitting up in bed with a swift and stiff motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a light gray cotton T-shirt that appears slightly damp with cold sweat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman exhibit signs of terror with wide eyes, constricted pupils, parted lips, and heaving chest while clutching white sheets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004635184537619352 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379635334014893 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004635184537619352, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004635184537619352, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13859260082244873, + 0.05824963375926018, + 0.03371398523449898, + 0.050575803965330124, + 0.06686825305223465, + 0.04505934566259384, + 0.3165551424026489, + 0.1079409047961235, + 0.05948356166481972, + 0.12296080589294434 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004635184537619352 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a static, low-angle, medium shot shot upward from the foot of a bed, a dim bedroom is captured. Only faint moonlight filters through the gaps in the blinds on one side of the window, casting sharp, pale streaks of light on the walls and furniture. A young woman with long, tousled, dark brown hair suddenly sits up in bed, her movement swift and stiff, as if pulled upward by invisible strings. She wears a light gray cotton T-shirt, slightly damp with cold sweat. Her forehead is beaded with beads of sweat. Her eyes are wide with utter terror, her pupils constricted in the darkness. Her lips part, her chest heaving violently as she breathes in short, hoarse gasps. Each inhale feels like a desperate struggle for air, and her hands subconsciously clutch the tousled white sheets beneath her. The high-contrast, cold-toned image is imbued with a sense of dread and suspense, creating a tense atmosphere of waking from a nightmare, enveloped in loneliness and suffocating fear.", + "seed": 12320, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_13/index_3388_seed_12320_dp_27_rank_54_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.018314697593450547, + "vlm_logprob": -0.018314697593450547, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.3, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.018314697593450547, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle looking upward from the foot of a bed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a dim bedroom with faint moonlight filtering through blinds casting sharp pale streaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a young woman with long, tousled, dark brown hair sitting up in bed with a swift and stiff motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a light gray cotton T-shirt that appears slightly damp with cold sweat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman exhibit signs of terror with wide eyes, constricted pupils, parted lips, and heaving chest while clutching white sheets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03887123987078667 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4138712882995605 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03887123987078667, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03887123987078667, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09724868834018707, + 0.4274294972419739, + 0.1047373041510582, + 0.12553513050079346, + 0.04078825190663338, + 0.04137146472930908, + 0.012326096184551716, + 0.013246282935142517, + 0.049721330404281616, + 0.0875958725810051 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03887123987078667 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle looking upward from the foot of a bed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a dim bedroom with faint moonlight filtering through blinds casting sharp pale streaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a young woman with long, tousled, dark brown hair sitting up in bed with a swift and stiff motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a light gray cotton T-shirt that appears slightly damp with cold sweat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman exhibit signs of terror with wide eyes, constricted pupils, parted lips, and heaving chest while clutching white sheets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01820954494178295 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018209457397461 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01820954494178295, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01820954494178295, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18276862800121307, + 0.12345826625823975, + 0.11673830449581146, + 0.033433638513088226, + 0.22961418330669403, + 0.03533057123422623, + 0.03975759446620941, + 0.01574016362428665, + 0.01904420182108879, + 0.20411451160907745 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01820954494178295 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle looking upward from the foot of a bed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a dim bedroom with faint moonlight filtering through blinds casting sharp pale streaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a young woman with long, tousled, dark brown hair sitting up in bed with a swift and stiff motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a light gray cotton T-shirt that appears slightly damp with cold sweat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman exhibit signs of terror with wide eyes, constricted pupils, parted lips, and heaving chest while clutching white sheets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005950947757810354 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130950927734375 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005950947757810354, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005950947757810354, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06396666914224625, + 0.07956904917955399, + 0.06656486541032791, + 0.14911119639873505, + 0.22420468926429749, + 0.05296633020043373, + 0.08385710418224335, + 0.03506908565759659, + 0.05545902997255325, + 0.1892319768667221 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005950947757810354 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle looking upward from the foot of a bed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a dim bedroom with faint moonlight filtering through blinds casting sharp pale streaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a young woman with long, tousled, dark brown hair sitting up in bed with a swift and stiff motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a light gray cotton T-shirt that appears slightly damp with cold sweat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman exhibit signs of terror with wide eyes, constricted pupils, parted lips, and heaving chest while clutching white sheets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023294245824217796 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.77329421043396 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023294245824217796, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023294245824217796, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06015077233314514, + 0.10185310989618301, + 0.10304687917232513, + 0.12142011523246765, + 0.16342656314373016, + 0.10548774898052216, + 0.0531894788146019, + 0.04298727959394455, + 0.055886875838041306, + 0.1925511658191681 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023294245824217796 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle looking upward from the foot of a bed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a dim bedroom with faint moonlight filtering through blinds casting sharp pale streaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a young woman with long, tousled, dark brown hair sitting up in bed with a swift and stiff motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a light gray cotton T-shirt that appears slightly damp with cold sweat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman exhibit signs of terror with wide eyes, constricted pupils, parted lips, and heaving chest while clutching white sheets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0052475095726549625 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255247592926025 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0052475095726549625, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0052475095726549625, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05483979359269142, + 0.1224789246916771, + 0.10469942539930344, + 0.08819685876369476, + 0.323720782995224, + 0.0590648278594017, + 0.05840399116277695, + 0.025801226496696472, + 0.03750542178750038, + 0.12528876960277557 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0052475095726549625 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_14/index_tensor([9538, 9538])_group_14_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_14/index_tensor([9538, 9538])_group_14_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..887308a48d6d90af561561e9c719b7cdefae6b70 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_14/index_tensor([9538, 9538])_group_14_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "An extreme macro close-up, captured from an angle above, slowly and almost imperceptibly advances. In the warm, soft light of golden hour, a narrow-banded swallowtail butterfly, its wings gleaming with a metallic emerald green, gracefully alights upon the cascading, lush petals of an ancient peony. This light, like a stream of golden honey, casts a soft halo around the edges of the peony's delicate, flesh-pink petals and illuminates each drop of translucent morning dew clinging to them with a brilliant glint. The butterfly's signature banded markings on its broad, velvety black wings shift in hues from malachite to emerald. Its six delicate legs firmly grasp the petals, its delicate antennae trembling slightly as it carefully unfolds its spiraling proboscis, poised to penetrate the heart of the flower. The background is extremely blurred, turning into a hazy block of light green and ochre. The whole picture is rendered in warm tones, filled with a tranquil, classical and vital poetic feeling, perfectly reproducing the elegant and ethereal charm of light crimson landscape paintings.", + "seed": 25936, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_14/index_9538_seed_25936_dp_28_rank_56_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.01860297257080674, + "vlm_logprob": -0.01860297257080674, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.65, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.01860297257080674, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a narrow-banded swallowtail butterfly with broad, velvety black wings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the butterfly's wings display metallic emerald green hues and banded markings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the butterfly alighting on the cascading, lush petals of an ancient peony with flesh-pink color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start from an angle above and slowly advance almost imperceptibly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background extremely blurred into a hazy block of light green and ochre?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.025207556784152985 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.77520751953125 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.025207556784152985, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.025207556784152985, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1416013240814209, + 0.08948439359664917, + 0.11933401226997375, + 0.06227745860815048, + 0.0470069944858551, + 0.05879072844982147, + 0.17906121909618378, + 0.10504385828971863, + 0.13179776072502136, + 0.06560223549604416 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.025207556784152985 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a narrow-banded swallowtail butterfly with broad, velvety black wings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the butterfly's wings display metallic emerald green hues and banded markings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the butterfly alighting on the cascading, lush petals of an ancient peony with flesh-pink color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start from an angle above and slowly advance almost imperceptibly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background extremely blurred into a hazy block of light green and ochre?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0025069257244467735 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002506732940674 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0025069257244467735, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0025069257244467735, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10928717255592346, + 0.05098317936062813, + 0.15241187810897827, + 0.043628208339214325, + 0.03428281098604202, + 0.04994957521557808, + 0.13183145225048065, + 0.20370295643806458, + 0.1726590096950531, + 0.051263775676488876 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0025069257244467735 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a narrow-banded swallowtail butterfly with broad, velvety black wings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the butterfly's wings display metallic emerald green hues and banded markings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the butterfly alighting on the cascading, lush petals of an ancient peony with flesh-pink color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start from an angle above and slowly advance almost imperceptibly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background extremely blurred into a hazy block of light green and ochre?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003616461530327797 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.6286163330078125 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003616461530327797, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003616461530327797, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11665206402540207, + 0.09340094774961472, + 0.2897805869579315, + 0.03888312727212906, + 0.03371408209204674, + 0.045800987631082535, + 0.11899036914110184, + 0.14151117205619812, + 0.053354863077402115, + 0.06791181862354279 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003616461530327797 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a narrow-banded swallowtail butterfly with broad, velvety black wings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the butterfly's wings display metallic emerald green hues and banded markings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the butterfly alighting on the cascading, lush petals of an ancient peony with flesh-pink color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start from an angle above and slowly advance almost imperceptibly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background extremely blurred into a hazy block of light green and ochre?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05494820326566696 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929948091506958 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05494820326566696, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05494820326566696, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11139685660600662, + 0.054330866783857346, + 0.2283555418252945, + 0.09412522614002228, + 0.033594150096178055, + 0.07465260475873947, + 0.11110035330057144, + 0.051276836544275284, + 0.04350736737251282, + 0.1976601481437683 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05494820326566696 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a narrow-banded swallowtail butterfly with broad, velvety black wings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the butterfly's wings display metallic emerald green hues and banded markings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the butterfly alighting on the cascading, lush petals of an ancient peony with flesh-pink color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start from an angle above and slowly advance almost imperceptibly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background extremely blurred into a hazy block of light green and ochre?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006735715549439192 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006735801696777 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006735715549439192, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006735715549439192, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2718832194805145, + 0.12788498401641846, + 0.06321503967046738, + 0.08837003260850906, + 0.13697996735572815, + 0.060419946908950806, + 0.06049009785056114, + 0.06780782341957092, + 0.039747271686792374, + 0.08320161700248718 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006735715549439192 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extreme macro close-up, captured from an angle above, slowly and almost imperceptibly advances. In the warm, soft light of golden hour, a narrow-banded swallowtail butterfly, its wings gleaming with a metallic emerald green, gracefully alights upon the cascading, lush petals of an ancient peony. This light, like a stream of golden honey, casts a soft halo around the edges of the peony's delicate, flesh-pink petals and illuminates each drop of translucent morning dew clinging to them with a brilliant glint. The butterfly's signature banded markings on its broad, velvety black wings shift in hues from malachite to emerald. Its six delicate legs firmly grasp the petals, its delicate antennae trembling slightly as it carefully unfolds its spiraling proboscis, poised to penetrate the heart of the flower. The background is extremely blurred, turning into a hazy block of light green and ochre. The whole picture is rendered in warm tones, filled with a tranquil, classical and vital poetic feeling, perfectly reproducing the elegant and ethereal charm of light crimson landscape paintings.", + "seed": 25937, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_14/index_9538_seed_25937_dp_28_rank_56_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.03131190892308951, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03131190892308951, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.85, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03131190892308951, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a narrow-banded swallowtail butterfly with broad, velvety black wings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the butterfly's wings display metallic emerald green hues and banded markings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the butterfly alighting on the cascading, lush petals of an ancient peony with flesh-pink color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start from an angle above and slowly advance almost imperceptibly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background extremely blurred into a hazy block of light green and ochre?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0454898476600647 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.17048978805542 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0454898476600647, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0454898476600647, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14698335528373718, + 0.11792751401662827, + 0.06508079171180725, + 0.1342516541481018, + 0.12941008806228638, + 0.08096430450677872, + 0.13432545959949493, + 0.04708294942975044, + 0.06411149352788925, + 0.07986237853765488 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0454898476600647 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a narrow-banded swallowtail butterfly with broad, velvety black wings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the butterfly's wings display metallic emerald green hues and banded markings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the butterfly alighting on the cascading, lush petals of an ancient peony with flesh-pink color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start from an angle above and slowly advance almost imperceptibly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background extremely blurred into a hazy block of light green and ochre?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01255407091230154 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387554168701172 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01255407091230154, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01255407091230154, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09060528874397278, + 0.04094314947724342, + 0.06491434574127197, + 0.19188043475151062, + 0.1160636767745018, + 0.08139558136463165, + 0.03969626501202583, + 0.03284726291894913, + 0.04980878531932831, + 0.2918452322483063 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01255407091230154 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a narrow-banded swallowtail butterfly with broad, velvety black wings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the butterfly's wings display metallic emerald green hues and banded markings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the butterfly alighting on the cascading, lush petals of an ancient peony with flesh-pink color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start from an angle above and slowly advance almost imperceptibly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background extremely blurred into a hazy block of light green and ochre?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009779401123523712 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634779453277588 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009779401123523712, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009779401123523712, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15649589896202087, + 0.21290627121925354, + 0.05398259684443474, + 0.06077185273170471, + 0.08078613132238388, + 0.09347202628850937, + 0.05040823668241501, + 0.06823831796646118, + 0.12017954885959625, + 0.10275911539793015 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009779401123523712 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a narrow-banded swallowtail butterfly with broad, velvety black wings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the butterfly's wings display metallic emerald green hues and banded markings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the butterfly alighting on the cascading, lush petals of an ancient peony with flesh-pink color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start from an angle above and slowly advance almost imperceptibly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background extremely blurred into a hazy block of light green and ochre?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07895871251821518 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.578958749771118 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07895871251821518, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07895871251821518, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16873367130756378, + 0.13866321742534637, + 0.0513978973031044, + 0.039592012763023376, + 0.09753353893756866, + 0.0540761835873127, + 0.10969636589288712, + 0.03983030095696449, + 0.09525780379772186, + 0.20521901547908783 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07895871251821518 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a narrow-banded swallowtail butterfly with broad, velvety black wings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the butterfly's wings display metallic emerald green hues and banded markings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the butterfly alighting on the cascading, lush petals of an ancient peony with flesh-pink color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start from an angle above and slowly advance almost imperceptibly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background extremely blurred into a hazy block of light green and ochre?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009777512401342392 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634777545928955 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009777512401342392, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009777512401342392, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22159169614315033, + 0.14474734663963318, + 0.07184532284736633, + 0.059867456555366516, + 0.1111091896891594, + 0.0643925741314888, + 0.08341827988624573, + 0.09282129257917404, + 0.08791961520910263, + 0.06228717789053917 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009777512401342392 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extreme macro close-up, captured from an angle above, slowly and almost imperceptibly advances. In the warm, soft light of golden hour, a narrow-banded swallowtail butterfly, its wings gleaming with a metallic emerald green, gracefully alights upon the cascading, lush petals of an ancient peony. This light, like a stream of golden honey, casts a soft halo around the edges of the peony's delicate, flesh-pink petals and illuminates each drop of translucent morning dew clinging to them with a brilliant glint. The butterfly's signature banded markings on its broad, velvety black wings shift in hues from malachite to emerald. Its six delicate legs firmly grasp the petals, its delicate antennae trembling slightly as it carefully unfolds its spiraling proboscis, poised to penetrate the heart of the flower. The background is extremely blurred, turning into a hazy block of light green and ochre. The whole picture is rendered in warm tones, filled with a tranquil, classical and vital poetic feeling, perfectly reproducing the elegant and ethereal charm of light crimson landscape paintings.", + "seed": 25938, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_14/index_9538_seed_25938_dp_29_rank_58_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.03825441529043019, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03825441529043019, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.575, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03825441529043019, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a narrow-banded swallowtail butterfly with broad, velvety black wings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the butterfly's wings display metallic emerald green hues and banded markings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the butterfly alighting on the cascading, lush petals of an ancient peony with flesh-pink color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start from an angle above and slowly advance almost imperceptibly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background extremely blurred into a hazy block of light green and ochre?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12881845235824585 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1288185119628906 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12881845235824585, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12881845235824585, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1531282514333725, + 0.046006154268980026, + 0.029359571635723114, + 0.09638409316539764, + 0.12363852560520172, + 0.05287126451730728, + 0.05792158842086792, + 0.2970568835735321, + 0.1165434941649437, + 0.02709023468196392 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12881845235824585 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a narrow-banded swallowtail butterfly with broad, velvety black wings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the butterfly's wings display metallic emerald green hues and banded markings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the butterfly alighting on the cascading, lush petals of an ancient peony with flesh-pink color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start from an angle above and slowly advance almost imperceptibly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background extremely blurred into a hazy block of light green and ochre?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0022079392801970243 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.1272077560424805 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0022079392801970243, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0022079392801970243, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09486948698759079, + 0.06720460206270218, + 0.032042838633060455, + 0.06611218303442001, + 0.06681416928768158, + 0.1782458871603012, + 0.11077363044023514, + 0.10314540565013885, + 0.1998913288116455, + 0.08090051263570786 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0022079392801970243 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a narrow-banded swallowtail butterfly with broad, velvety black wings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the butterfly's wings display metallic emerald green hues and banded markings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the butterfly alighting on the cascading, lush petals of an ancient peony with flesh-pink color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start from an angle above and slowly advance almost imperceptibly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background extremely blurred into a hazy block of light green and ochre?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0028190179727971554 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877819061279297 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0028190179727971554, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0028190179727971554, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23880460858345032, + 0.08809732645750046, + 0.09491755068302155, + 0.09008178859949112, + 0.05847954377532005, + 0.08918774127960205, + 0.05904402956366539, + 0.10986732691526413, + 0.08043476939201355, + 0.09108532965183258 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0028190179727971554 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a narrow-banded swallowtail butterfly with broad, velvety black wings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the butterfly's wings display metallic emerald green hues and banded markings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the butterfly alighting on the cascading, lush petals of an ancient peony with flesh-pink color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start from an angle above and slowly advance almost imperceptibly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background extremely blurred into a hazy block of light green and ochre?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05494019389152527 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299402236938477 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05494019389152527, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05494019389152527, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1539621651172638, + 0.13732895255088806, + 0.0748581662774086, + 0.11844576150178909, + 0.07942637801170349, + 0.09197916090488434, + 0.10365696251392365, + 0.101741261780262, + 0.05774456262588501, + 0.08085662871599197 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05494019389152527 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a narrow-banded swallowtail butterfly with broad, velvety black wings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the butterfly's wings display metallic emerald green hues and banded markings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the butterfly alighting on the cascading, lush petals of an ancient peony with flesh-pink color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start from an angle above and slowly advance almost imperceptibly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background extremely blurred into a hazy block of light green and ochre?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002486472949385643 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002486705780029 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002486472949385643, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002486472949385643, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1793489307165146, + 0.07695560902357101, + 0.04429613798856735, + 0.04305100068449974, + 0.027854079380631447, + 0.11652342230081558, + 0.2689356207847595, + 0.04195491224527359, + 0.06914399564266205, + 0.1319362372159958 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002486472949385643 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extreme macro close-up, captured from an angle above, slowly and almost imperceptibly advances. In the warm, soft light of golden hour, a narrow-banded swallowtail butterfly, its wings gleaming with a metallic emerald green, gracefully alights upon the cascading, lush petals of an ancient peony. This light, like a stream of golden honey, casts a soft halo around the edges of the peony's delicate, flesh-pink petals and illuminates each drop of translucent morning dew clinging to them with a brilliant glint. The butterfly's signature banded markings on its broad, velvety black wings shift in hues from malachite to emerald. Its six delicate legs firmly grasp the petals, its delicate antennae trembling slightly as it carefully unfolds its spiraling proboscis, poised to penetrate the heart of the flower. The background is extremely blurred, turning into a hazy block of light green and ochre. The whole picture is rendered in warm tones, filled with a tranquil, classical and vital poetic feeling, perfectly reproducing the elegant and ethereal charm of light crimson landscape paintings.", + "seed": 25939, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_14/index_9538_seed_25939_dp_29_rank_58_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.02748167486861348, + "vlm_logprob": -0.02748167486861348, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.05, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.02748167486861348, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a narrow-banded swallowtail butterfly with broad, velvety black wings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the butterfly's wings display metallic emerald green hues and banded markings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the butterfly alighting on the cascading, lush petals of an ancient peony with flesh-pink color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start from an angle above and slowly advance almost imperceptibly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background extremely blurred into a hazy block of light green and ochre?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05623156204819679 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9312314987182617 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05623156204819679, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05623156204819679, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.30519187450408936, + 0.06264130026102066, + 0.09756097197532654, + 0.04259802773594856, + 0.08718070387840271, + 0.11277928203344345, + 0.0903192013502121, + 0.0327545665204525, + 0.13525739312171936, + 0.03371664136648178 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05623156204819679 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a narrow-banded swallowtail butterfly with broad, velvety black wings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the butterfly's wings display metallic emerald green hues and banded markings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the butterfly alighting on the cascading, lush petals of an ancient peony with flesh-pink color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start from an angle above and slowly advance almost imperceptibly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background extremely blurred into a hazy block of light green and ochre?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004103692714124918 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504103660583496 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004103692714124918, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004103692714124918, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12723204493522644, + 0.06028013676404953, + 0.2959638237953186, + 0.012691608630120754, + 0.08350232243537903, + 0.12922367453575134, + 0.1218186467885971, + 0.03354506939649582, + 0.08222020417451859, + 0.053522489964962006 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004103692714124918 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a narrow-banded swallowtail butterfly with broad, velvety black wings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the butterfly's wings display metallic emerald green hues and banded markings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the butterfly alighting on the cascading, lush petals of an ancient peony with flesh-pink color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start from an angle above and slowly advance almost imperceptibly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background extremely blurred into a hazy block of light green and ochre?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01107026170939207 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511070251464844 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01107026170939207, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01107026170939207, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06216459348797798, + 0.09241662919521332, + 0.4861295223236084, + 0.025167351588606834, + 0.04235045611858368, + 0.02462056837975979, + 0.12392076849937439, + 0.04425323009490967, + 0.027756433933973312, + 0.07122048735618591 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01107026170939207 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a narrow-banded swallowtail butterfly with broad, velvety black wings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the butterfly's wings display metallic emerald green hues and banded markings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the butterfly alighting on the cascading, lush petals of an ancient peony with flesh-pink color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start from an angle above and slowly advance almost imperceptibly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background extremely blurred into a hazy block of light green and ochre?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.054933421313762665 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299333095550537 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.054933421313762665, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.054933421313762665, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.061109136790037155, + 0.24829120934009552, + 0.10179688036441803, + 0.022591091692447662, + 0.04627694934606552, + 0.03863047808408737, + 0.09820973128080368, + 0.24261735379695892, + 0.11686857789754868, + 0.023608524352312088 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.054933421313762665 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a narrow-banded swallowtail butterfly with broad, velvety black wings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the butterfly's wings display metallic emerald green hues and banded markings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the butterfly alighting on the cascading, lush petals of an ancient peony with flesh-pink color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start from an angle above and slowly advance almost imperceptibly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background extremely blurred into a hazy block of light green and ochre?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011069436557590961 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511069297790527 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011069436557590961, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011069436557590961, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10991773009300232, + 0.03970883786678314, + 0.4017934799194336, + 0.15825465321540833, + 0.04377998039126396, + 0.03655019775032997, + 0.05863675847649574, + 0.08354606479406357, + 0.020699571818113327, + 0.04711274802684784 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011069436557590961 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_15/index_tensor([382, 382])_group_15_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_15/index_tensor([382, 382])_group_15_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..4063cf02c791178b59d34976fc9ed7b9dec5cea9 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_15/index_tensor([382, 382])_group_15_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "low-angle tracking shot follows an elderly South Asian man with a long, flowing white beard and deep, friendly eyes that hold a quiet wisdom. He wears a simple, loose-fitting off-white cotton tunic, the sleeves showing the gentle wear of time. He walks steadily and deliberately through a narrow, bustling market alley toward the camera. The path is flanked by weathered ochre stone buildings, hung with vibrant, richly colored textiles and tapestries. Market stalls are filled with wares: pyramids of fragrant, colorful spices in woven baskets, gleaming handmade brass pots, and piles of fresh fruit. Brilliant golden afternoon sunlight penetrates sharply through the gaps between the buildings, illuminating the dancing dust in the air and creating a dramatic interplay of bright highlights and deep, cool shadows. He turns his head slightly as he walks, his gaze calmly sweeping across the bustling chaos, creating an atmosphere of contemplative and profound calm amid the market's vibrant energy.", + "seed": 32368, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_15/index_382_seed_32368_dp_30_rank_60_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.06714093093760312, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06714093093760312, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.875, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06714093093760312, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly South Asian man with a long, flowing white beard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a simple, loose-fitting off-white cotton tunic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene take place in a narrow, bustling market alley with weathered ochre stone buildings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are market stalls visible containing pyramids of colorful spices, brass pots, and piles of fresh fruit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle tracking shot that moves toward the camera as the man walks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014425630681216717 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264425754547119 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014425630681216717, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014425630681216717, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.102950319647789, + 0.27888384461402893, + 0.020429177209734917, + 0.12982907891273499, + 0.1432262808084488, + 0.026006121188402176, + 0.14753150939941406, + 0.043560970574617386, + 0.07296384871006012, + 0.03461885824799538 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014425630681216717 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly South Asian man with a long, flowing white beard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a simple, loose-fitting off-white cotton tunic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene take place in a narrow, bustling market alley with weathered ochre stone buildings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are market stalls visible containing pyramids of colorful spices, brass pots, and piles of fresh fruit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle tracking shot that moves toward the camera as the man walks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11291488260030746 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.237914800643921 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11291488260030746, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11291488260030746, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13588865101337433, + 0.24674586951732635, + 0.033355262130498886, + 0.08777923136949539, + 0.060286764055490494, + 0.07854588329792023, + 0.0726647675037384, + 0.05869586020708084, + 0.16064397990703583, + 0.06539373844861984 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11291488260030746 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly South Asian man with a long, flowing white beard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a simple, loose-fitting off-white cotton tunic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene take place in a narrow, bustling market alley with weathered ochre stone buildings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are market stalls visible containing pyramids of colorful spices, brass pots, and piles of fresh fruit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle tracking shot that moves toward the camera as the man walks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0021950930822640657 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127194881439209 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0021950930822640657, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0021950930822640657, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.045826833695173264, + 0.7130275964736938, + 0.019124075770378113, + 0.01527358777821064, + 0.022908413782715797, + 0.024074265733361244, + 0.024776292964816093, + 0.08333181589841843, + 0.011142199859023094, + 0.04051487520337105 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0021950930822640657 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly South Asian man with a long, flowing white beard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a simple, loose-fitting off-white cotton tunic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene take place in a narrow, bustling market alley with weathered ochre stone buildings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are market stalls visible containing pyramids of colorful spices, brass pots, and piles of fresh fruit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle tracking shot that moves toward the camera as the man walks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004639456048607826 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379639625549316 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004639456048607826, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004639456048607826, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04136575013399124, + 0.7827489376068115, + 0.020099349319934845, + 0.010517632588744164, + 0.015217157080769539, + 0.01887921243906021, + 0.00976427923887968, + 0.016119012609124184, + 0.06723784655332565, + 0.01805085688829422 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004639456048607826 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly South Asian man with a long, flowing white beard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a simple, loose-fitting off-white cotton tunic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene take place in a narrow, bustling market alley with weathered ochre stone buildings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are market stalls visible containing pyramids of colorful spices, brass pots, and piles of fresh fruit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle tracking shot that moves toward the camera as the man walks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2015295922756195 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.701529622077942 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2015295922756195, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2015295922756195, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14386294782161713, + 0.22430644929409027, + 0.03234165161848068, + 0.029099488630890846, + 0.08860216289758682, + 0.06269647926092148, + 0.21598277986049652, + 0.12748019397258759, + 0.019467871636152267, + 0.056159891188144684 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2015295922756195 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle tracking shot follows an elderly South Asian man with a long, flowing white beard and deep, friendly eyes that hold a quiet wisdom. He wears a simple, loose-fitting off-white cotton tunic, the sleeves showing the gentle wear of time. He walks steadily and deliberately through a narrow, bustling market alley toward the camera. The path is flanked by weathered ochre stone buildings, hung with vibrant, richly colored textiles and tapestries. Market stalls are filled with wares: pyramids of fragrant, colorful spices in woven baskets, gleaming handmade brass pots, and piles of fresh fruit. Brilliant golden afternoon sunlight penetrates sharply through the gaps between the buildings, illuminating the dancing dust in the air and creating a dramatic interplay of bright highlights and deep, cool shadows. He turns his head slightly as he walks, his gaze calmly sweeping across the bustling chaos, creating an atmosphere of contemplative and profound calm amid the market's vibrant energy.", + "seed": 32369, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_15/index_382_seed_32369_dp_30_rank_60_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.07781529882922769, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07781529882922769, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.825, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07781529882922769, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly South Asian man with a long, flowing white beard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a simple, loose-fitting off-white cotton tunic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene take place in a narrow, bustling market alley with weathered ochre stone buildings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are market stalls visible containing pyramids of colorful spices, brass pots, and piles of fresh fruit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle tracking shot that moves toward the camera as the man walks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018452061340212822 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018452167510986 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018452061340212822, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018452061340212822, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16042748093605042, + 0.022922802716493607, + 0.04008959233760834, + 0.5680316090583801, + 0.05218205228447914, + 0.017199361696839333, + 0.019040288403630257, + 0.0163692869246006, + 0.0211243387311697, + 0.08261319249868393 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018452061340212822 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly South Asian man with a long, flowing white beard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a simple, loose-fitting off-white cotton tunic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene take place in a narrow, bustling market alley with weathered ochre stone buildings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are market stalls visible containing pyramids of colorful spices, brass pots, and piles of fresh fruit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle tracking shot that moves toward the camera as the man walks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11291882395744324 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2379188537597656 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11291882395744324, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11291882395744324, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09845844656229019, + 0.12890933454036713, + 0.04874850809574127, + 0.13011154532432556, + 0.3438139855861664, + 0.027523016557097435, + 0.06293024122714996, + 0.05108720064163208, + 0.0673724040389061, + 0.041045356541872025 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11291882395744324 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly South Asian man with a long, flowing white beard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a simple, loose-fitting off-white cotton tunic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene take place in a narrow, bustling market alley with weathered ochre stone buildings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are market stalls visible containing pyramids of colorful spices, brass pots, and piles of fresh fruit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle tracking shot that moves toward the camera as the man walks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002817115979269147 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877817153930664 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002817115979269147, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002817115979269147, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10379263013601303, + 0.10315672308206558, + 0.18913426995277405, + 0.17570213973522186, + 0.06016368418931961, + 0.15207421779632568, + 0.043201904743909836, + 0.025875519961118698, + 0.032929010689258575, + 0.11396987736225128 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002817115979269147 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly South Asian man with a long, flowing white beard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a simple, loose-fitting off-white cotton tunic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene take place in a narrow, bustling market alley with weathered ochre stone buildings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are market stalls visible containing pyramids of colorful spices, brass pots, and piles of fresh fruit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle tracking shot that moves toward the camera as the man walks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002818423556163907 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877818584442139 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002818423556163907, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002818423556163907, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.043905362486839294, + 0.0315910279750824, + 0.14745695888996124, + 0.14940525591373444, + 0.059067439287900925, + 0.019684405997395515, + 0.15849749743938446, + 0.08072206377983093, + 0.1048528179526329, + 0.20481720566749573 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002818423556163907 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly South Asian man with a long, flowing white beard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a simple, loose-fitting off-white cotton tunic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene take place in a narrow, bustling market alley with weathered ochre stone buildings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are market stalls visible containing pyramids of colorful spices, brass pots, and piles of fresh fruit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle tracking shot that moves toward the camera as the man walks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2520700693130493 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5020700693130493 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2520700693130493, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2520700693130493, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09168784320354462, + 0.05938362702727318, + 0.15131808817386627, + 0.1100090965628624, + 0.12581105530261993, + 0.08038798719644547, + 0.07781066000461578, + 0.06455932557582855, + 0.1724325269460678, + 0.06659982353448868 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2520700693130493 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle tracking shot follows an elderly South Asian man with a long, flowing white beard and deep, friendly eyes that hold a quiet wisdom. He wears a simple, loose-fitting off-white cotton tunic, the sleeves showing the gentle wear of time. He walks steadily and deliberately through a narrow, bustling market alley toward the camera. The path is flanked by weathered ochre stone buildings, hung with vibrant, richly colored textiles and tapestries. Market stalls are filled with wares: pyramids of fragrant, colorful spices in woven baskets, gleaming handmade brass pots, and piles of fresh fruit. Brilliant golden afternoon sunlight penetrates sharply through the gaps between the buildings, illuminating the dancing dust in the air and creating a dramatic interplay of bright highlights and deep, cool shadows. He turns his head slightly as he walks, his gaze calmly sweeping across the bustling chaos, creating an atmosphere of contemplative and profound calm amid the market's vibrant energy.", + "seed": 32370, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_15/index_382_seed_32370_dp_31_rank_62_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.05698512627277523, + "vlm_logprob": -0.05698512627277523, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.15, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.05698512627277523, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly South Asian man with a long, flowing white beard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a simple, loose-fitting off-white cotton tunic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene take place in a narrow, bustling market alley with weathered ochre stone buildings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are market stalls visible containing pyramids of colorful spices, brass pots, and piles of fresh fruit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle tracking shot that moves toward the camera as the man walks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011342566460371017 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511342525482178 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011342566460371017, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011342566460371017, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1850387006998062, + 0.13631419837474823, + 0.048129286617040634, + 0.05840558931231499, + 0.07922820746898651, + 0.08739466220140457, + 0.1827927529811859, + 0.09876637160778046, + 0.0734812542796135, + 0.05044902488589287 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011342566460371017 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly South Asian man with a long, flowing white beard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a simple, loose-fitting off-white cotton tunic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene take place in a narrow, bustling market alley with weathered ochre stone buildings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are market stalls visible containing pyramids of colorful spices, brass pots, and piles of fresh fruit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle tracking shot that moves toward the camera as the man walks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08902692049741745 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.464026927947998 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08902692049741745, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08902692049741745, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14556105434894562, + 0.05012473464012146, + 0.034563157707452774, + 0.11845411360263824, + 0.10521025955677032, + 0.1137687936425209, + 0.11188916862010956, + 0.21587765216827393, + 0.07972520589828491, + 0.02482578717172146 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08902692049741745 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly South Asian man with a long, flowing white beard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a simple, loose-fitting off-white cotton tunic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene take place in a narrow, bustling market alley with weathered ochre stone buildings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are market stalls visible containing pyramids of colorful spices, brass pots, and piles of fresh fruit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle tracking shot that moves toward the camera as the man walks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.001511027687229216 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.501511096954346 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.001511027687229216, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.001511027687229216, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2651880085468292, + 0.07761839032173157, + 0.15259329974651337, + 0.05679134652018547, + 0.04538733512163162, + 0.04629168659448624, + 0.09312457591295242, + 0.1293042004108429, + 0.10336413234472275, + 0.030337018892169 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.001511027687229216 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly South Asian man with a long, flowing white beard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a simple, loose-fitting off-white cotton tunic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene take place in a narrow, bustling market alley with weathered ochre stone buildings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are market stalls visible containing pyramids of colorful spices, brass pots, and piles of fresh fruit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle tracking shot that moves toward the camera as the man walks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0031916177831590176 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.7531914710998535 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0031916177831590176, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0031916177831590176, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13950742781162262, + 0.18927228450775146, + 0.11930002272129059, + 0.06748517602682114, + 0.09949730336666107, + 0.10427885502576828, + 0.1442474126815796, + 0.03465096279978752, + 0.05842221528291702, + 0.04333825781941414 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0031916177831590176 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly South Asian man with a long, flowing white beard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a simple, loose-fitting off-white cotton tunic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene take place in a narrow, bustling market alley with weathered ochre stone buildings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are market stalls visible containing pyramids of colorful spices, brass pots, and piles of fresh fruit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle tracking shot that moves toward the camera as the man walks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17985349893569946 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8048534393310547 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17985349893569946, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17985349893569946, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2158496230840683, + 0.10484037548303604, + 0.04114985093474388, + 0.03877008333802223, + 0.0871301218867302, + 0.05774863064289093, + 0.06673329323530197, + 0.11771737784147263, + 0.22156307101249695, + 0.048497602343559265 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17985349893569946 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle tracking shot follows an elderly South Asian man with a long, flowing white beard and deep, friendly eyes that hold a quiet wisdom. He wears a simple, loose-fitting off-white cotton tunic, the sleeves showing the gentle wear of time. He walks steadily and deliberately through a narrow, bustling market alley toward the camera. The path is flanked by weathered ochre stone buildings, hung with vibrant, richly colored textiles and tapestries. Market stalls are filled with wares: pyramids of fragrant, colorful spices in woven baskets, gleaming handmade brass pots, and piles of fresh fruit. Brilliant golden afternoon sunlight penetrates sharply through the gaps between the buildings, illuminating the dancing dust in the air and creating a dramatic interplay of bright highlights and deep, cool shadows. He turns his head slightly as he walks, his gaze calmly sweeping across the bustling chaos, creating an atmosphere of contemplative and profound calm amid the market's vibrant energy.", + "seed": 32371, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_15/index_382_seed_32371_dp_31_rank_62_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.04320121093187481, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04320121093187481, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.425, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04320121093187481, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly South Asian man with a long, flowing white beard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a simple, loose-fitting off-white cotton tunic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene take place in a narrow, bustling market alley with weathered ochre stone buildings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are market stalls visible containing pyramids of colorful spices, brass pots, and piles of fresh fruit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle tracking shot that moves toward the camera as the man walks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0061097280122339725 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.131109714508057 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0061097280122339725, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0061097280122339725, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3011052906513214, + 0.07104387879371643, + 0.23149476945400238, + 0.0393311083316803, + 0.04918460547924042, + 0.03668098524212837, + 0.14859136939048767, + 0.038394615054130554, + 0.03905973210930824, + 0.045113664120435715 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0061097280122339725 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly South Asian man with a long, flowing white beard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a simple, loose-fitting off-white cotton tunic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene take place in a narrow, bustling market alley with weathered ochre stone buildings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are market stalls visible containing pyramids of colorful spices, brass pots, and piles of fresh fruit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle tracking shot that moves toward the camera as the man walks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07896608859300613 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5789661407470703 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07896608859300613, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07896608859300613, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17026391625404358, + 0.10504807531833649, + 0.17849135398864746, + 0.08338600397109985, + 0.052438363432884216, + 0.031244896352291107, + 0.2130485475063324, + 0.06333895772695541, + 0.05422055721282959, + 0.04851929470896721 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07896608859300613 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly South Asian man with a long, flowing white beard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a simple, loose-fitting off-white cotton tunic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene take place in a narrow, bustling market alley with weathered ochre stone buildings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are market stalls visible containing pyramids of colorful spices, brass pots, and piles of fresh fruit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle tracking shot that moves toward the camera as the man walks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002195806708186865 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127195835113525 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002195806708186865, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002195806708186865, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3567253351211548, + 0.04100162908434868, + 0.045271456241607666, + 0.10215936601161957, + 0.03536819666624069, + 0.015671513974666595, + 0.2249428927898407, + 0.09304655343294144, + 0.04661250859498978, + 0.0392005480825901 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002195806708186865 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly South Asian man with a long, flowing white beard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a simple, loose-fitting off-white cotton tunic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene take place in a narrow, bustling market alley with weathered ochre stone buildings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are market stalls visible containing pyramids of colorful spices, brass pots, and piles of fresh fruit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle tracking shot that moves toward the camera as the man walks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0017133570509031415 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.376713275909424 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0017133570509031415, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0017133570509031415, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09170810878276825, + 0.05727198347449303, + 0.0683831050992012, + 0.05281444266438484, + 0.048470355570316315, + 0.13225887715816498, + 0.27569371461868286, + 0.17776091396808624, + 0.04011660814285278, + 0.05552190542221069 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0017133570509031415 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly South Asian man with a long, flowing white beard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a simple, loose-fitting off-white cotton tunic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene take place in a narrow, bustling market alley with weathered ochre stone buildings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are market stalls visible containing pyramids of colorful spices, brass pots, and piles of fresh fruit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle tracking shot that moves toward the camera as the man walks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12702107429504395 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.127021074295044 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12702107429504395, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12702107429504395, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1002347320318222, + 0.07241683453321457, + 0.08815602958202362, + 0.2580520808696747, + 0.08831992000341415, + 0.092232346534729, + 0.16689826548099518, + 0.06992194801568985, + 0.03576693311333656, + 0.02800091542303562 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12702107429504395 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_2/index_tensor([1277, 1277])_group_2_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_2/index_tensor([1277, 1277])_group_2_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..04e3598cab621b35c30dbe5bcb9edb3eeee84495 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_2/index_tensor([1277, 1277])_group_2_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "In a scene steeped in retro pixel art, a relentlessly forward-moving camera transports us into a black hole structure composed of luminous concentric rings, suspended in a pure black digital void. This once orderly pattern begins to distort and stretch violently. Its key rings, representing the event horizon, and the singular pixel at its center, flicker, jump, and misalign in unpredictable patterns, like a corrupted data stream. Once-smooth pixel lines are ripped into irregular blocks, leaving fleeting, miscolored afterimages on the screen. As the camera steadily and unhesitatingly descends into the center of this chaos, the image transforms into a digital vortex of shattered cyan and magenta lines and distorted blocks of color. The ring structure completely disintegrates, as if sucked into the singularity by an invisible force, creating a deeply unsettling and psychedelic feeling of system collapse and data disintegration.", + "seed": 22398, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_2/index_1277_seed_22398_dp_4_rank_8_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.6897355392575264, + "vlm_logprob": -0.6897355392575264, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.400000023841858, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.6897355392575264, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.6, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style of the video retro pixel art?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a pure black digital void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central structure a black hole composed of luminous concentric rings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move steadily and unhesitatingly forward into the center of the structure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the rings and center pixel flicker, jump, and misalign in unpredictable patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.018784761428833 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14378485083580017 + ], + "logprob_reward": -2.018784761428833, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.8749998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -2.018784761428833, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15024100244045258, + 0.0670844167470932, + 0.3038584291934967, + 0.058815233409404755, + 0.03753691911697388, + 0.025554677471518517, + 0.10936405509710312, + 0.10451794415712357, + 0.041445229202508926, + 0.10158205777406693 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -2.018784761428833 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style of the video retro pixel art?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a pure black digital void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central structure a black hole composed of luminous concentric rings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move steadily and unhesitatingly forward into the center of the structure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the rings and center pixel flicker, jump, and misalign in unpredictable patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3134183883666992 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.31341832876205444 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.3134183883666992, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -1.3134183883666992, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17339955270290375, + 0.08162099123001099, + 0.14117099344730377, + 0.025185124948620796, + 0.08100966364145279, + 0.014243612065911293, + 0.06533826142549515, + 0.054172974079847336, + 0.31529101729393005, + 0.048567891120910645 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.3134183883666992 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style of the video retro pixel art?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a pure black digital void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central structure a black hole composed of luminous concentric rings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move steadily and unhesitatingly forward into the center of the structure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the rings and center pixel flicker, jump, and misalign in unpredictable patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02332860231399536 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7733285427093506 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02332860231399536, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02332860231399536, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1658986657857895, + 0.09399854391813278, + 0.03715060278773308, + 0.029657401144504547, + 0.05185484513640404, + 0.020673535764217377, + 0.11400464177131653, + 0.07587120682001114, + 0.3081585168838501, + 0.10273201763629913 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02332860231399536 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style of the video retro pixel art?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a pure black digital void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central structure a black hole composed of luminous concentric rings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move steadily and unhesitatingly forward into the center of the structure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the rings and center pixel flicker, jump, and misalign in unpredictable patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03813229873776436 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881321907043457 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03813229873776436, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03813229873776436, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13725760579109192, + 0.15656542778015137, + 0.09818678349256516, + 0.05232475325465202, + 0.10316704958677292, + 0.035098474472761154, + 0.10202203691005707, + 0.0725402757525444, + 0.09732452780008316, + 0.14551308751106262 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03813229873776436 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style of the video retro pixel art?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a pure black digital void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central structure a black hole composed of luminous concentric rings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move steadily and unhesitatingly forward into the center of the structure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the rings and center pixel flicker, jump, and misalign in unpredictable patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05501364544034004 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.930013656616211 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05501364544034004, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05501364544034004, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0965820699930191, + 0.043366823345422745, + 0.05911192670464516, + 0.05486222356557846, + 0.05724251642823219, + 0.03905823826789856, + 0.14766846597194672, + 0.18091236054897308, + 0.16687802970409393, + 0.15431731939315796 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05501364544034004 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a scene steeped in retro pixel art, a relentlessly forward-moving camera transports us into a black hole structure composed of luminous concentric rings, suspended in a pure black digital void. This once orderly pattern begins to distort and stretch violently. Its key rings, representing the event horizon, and the singular pixel at its center, flicker, jump, and misalign in unpredictable patterns, like a corrupted data stream. Once-smooth pixel lines are ripped into irregular blocks, leaving fleeting, miscolored afterimages on the screen. As the camera steadily and unhesitatingly descends into the center of this chaos, the image transforms into a digital vortex of shattered cyan and magenta lines and distorted blocks of color. The ring structure completely disintegrates, as if sucked into the singularity by an invisible force, creating a deeply unsettling and psychedelic feeling of system collapse and data disintegration.", + "seed": 22399, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_2/index_1277_seed_22399_dp_4_rank_8_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.2822646054439247, + "vlm_logprob": -0.2822646054439247, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.55, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.2822646054439247, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style of the video retro pixel art?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a pure black digital void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central structure a black hole composed of luminous concentric rings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move steadily and unhesitatingly forward into the center of the structure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the rings and center pixel flicker, jump, and misalign in unpredictable patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5295422077178955 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9045422077178955 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5295422077178955, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5295422077178955, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21364592015743256, + 0.064756378531456, + 0.06794046610593796, + 0.030518174171447754, + 0.02437678538262844, + 0.12426285445690155, + 0.06489916145801544, + 0.20779089629650116, + 0.03926213085651398, + 0.16254720091819763 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5295422077178955 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style of the video retro pixel art?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a pure black digital void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central structure a black hole composed of luminous concentric rings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move steadily and unhesitatingly forward into the center of the structure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the rings and center pixel flicker, jump, and misalign in unpredictable patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8260984420776367 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5760984420776367 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.8260984420776367, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.8260984420776367, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07112353295087814, + 0.15633036196231842, + 0.035760533064603806, + 0.02681574784219265, + 0.039940278977155685, + 0.17274141311645508, + 0.0340886116027832, + 0.2774135172367096, + 0.03747320547699928, + 0.1483127921819687 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.8260984420776367 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style of the video retro pixel art?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a pure black digital void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central structure a black hole composed of luminous concentric rings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move steadily and unhesitatingly forward into the center of the structure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the rings and center pixel flicker, jump, and misalign in unpredictable patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005266483407467604 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.2552666664123535 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005266483407467604, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005266483407467604, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06995873898267746, + 0.1586446464061737, + 0.02828599512577057, + 0.03497529774904251, + 0.02443145215511322, + 0.3101194202899933, + 0.07248497754335403, + 0.1733943521976471, + 0.014877095818519592, + 0.11282804608345032 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005266483407467604 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style of the video retro pixel art?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a pure black digital void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central structure a black hole composed of luminous concentric rings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move steadily and unhesitatingly forward into the center of the structure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the rings and center pixel flicker, jump, and misalign in unpredictable patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020592233166098595 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895592212677002 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020592233166098595, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020592233166098595, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07030340284109116, + 0.1187928318977356, + 0.22117117047309875, + 0.024980328977108, + 0.05849913880228996, + 0.2683566212654114, + 0.06595851480960846, + 0.09064965695142746, + 0.020592322573065758, + 0.06069596856832504 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020592233166098595 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style of the video retro pixel art?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a pure black digital void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central structure a black hole composed of luminous concentric rings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move steadily and unhesitatingly forward into the center of the structure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the rings and center pixel flicker, jump, and misalign in unpredictable patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029823660850524902 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298237800598145 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029823660850524902, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029823660850524902, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12624554336071014, + 0.06087202578783035, + 0.2518453001976013, + 0.07235259562730789, + 0.050180066376924515, + 0.23740659654140472, + 0.08301178365945816, + 0.03891560807824135, + 0.017774546518921852, + 0.06139591708779335 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029823660850524902 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a scene steeped in retro pixel art, a relentlessly forward-moving camera transports us into a black hole structure composed of luminous concentric rings, suspended in a pure black digital void. This once orderly pattern begins to distort and stretch violently. Its key rings, representing the event horizon, and the singular pixel at its center, flicker, jump, and misalign in unpredictable patterns, like a corrupted data stream. Once-smooth pixel lines are ripped into irregular blocks, leaving fleeting, miscolored afterimages on the screen. As the camera steadily and unhesitatingly descends into the center of this chaos, the image transforms into a digital vortex of shattered cyan and magenta lines and distorted blocks of color. The ring structure completely disintegrates, as if sucked into the singularity by an invisible force, creating a deeply unsettling and psychedelic feeling of system collapse and data disintegration.", + "seed": 22400, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_2/index_1277_seed_22400_dp_5_rank_10_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.7729780491441488, + "vlm_logprob": -0.7729780491441488, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.325, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.7729780491441488, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.6, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style of the video retro pixel art?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a pure black digital void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central structure a black hole composed of luminous concentric rings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move steadily and unhesitatingly forward into the center of the structure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the rings and center pixel flicker, jump, and misalign in unpredictable patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3509395122528076 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10093943029642105 + ], + "logprob_reward": -2.3509395122528076, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -2.3509395122528076, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3841560184955597, + 0.06960499286651611, + 0.018268205225467682, + 0.05682293325662613, + 0.08760357648134232, + 0.06447704136371613, + 0.05465872213244438, + 0.08478312939405441, + 0.05503741651773453, + 0.12458792328834534 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -2.3509395122528076 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style of the video retro pixel art?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a pure black digital void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central structure a black hole composed of luminous concentric rings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move steadily and unhesitatingly forward into the center of the structure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the rings and center pixel flicker, jump, and misalign in unpredictable patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4063035249710083 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2813035249710083 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.4063035249710083, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -1.4063035249710083, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.38520845770835876, + 0.12236115336418152, + 0.018582256510853767, + 0.05021670088171959, + 0.25156494975090027, + 0.031296756118535995, + 0.02177218161523342, + 0.048600222915410995, + 0.02259192056953907, + 0.047805462032556534 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.4063035249710083 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style of the video retro pixel art?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a pure black digital void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central structure a black hole composed of luminous concentric rings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move steadily and unhesitatingly forward into the center of the structure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the rings and center pixel flicker, jump, and misalign in unpredictable patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02639020048081875 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651390314102173 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02639020048081875, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02639020048081875, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17640367150306702, + 0.14574196934700012, + 0.02449979819357395, + 0.03192679211497307, + 0.3636046051979065, + 0.026032283902168274, + 0.028227180242538452, + 0.08520374447107315, + 0.06141127273440361, + 0.05694867670536041 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02639020048081875 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style of the video retro pixel art?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a pure black digital void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central structure a black hole composed of luminous concentric rings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move steadily and unhesitatingly forward into the center of the structure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the rings and center pixel flicker, jump, and misalign in unpredictable patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03813069313764572 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288130760192871 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03813069313764572, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03813069313764572, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.516146183013916, + 0.06244714930653572, + 0.042036108672618866, + 0.04030760005116463, + 0.15601900219917297, + 0.02840578556060791, + 0.0319177582859993, + 0.05020838975906372, + 0.022289440035820007, + 0.05022258684039116 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03813069313764572 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style of the video retro pixel art?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a pure black digital void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central structure a black hole composed of luminous concentric rings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move steadily and unhesitatingly forward into the center of the structure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the rings and center pixel flicker, jump, and misalign in unpredictable patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.043126314878463745 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168126344680786 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.043126314878463745, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.043126314878463745, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23763103783130646, + 0.06074882671236992, + 0.030278122052550316, + 0.06897320598363876, + 0.19754911959171295, + 0.03414677083492279, + 0.05442783236503601, + 0.1656782031059265, + 0.07980750501155853, + 0.0707593709230423 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.043126314878463745 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a scene steeped in retro pixel art, a relentlessly forward-moving camera transports us into a black hole structure composed of luminous concentric rings, suspended in a pure black digital void. This once orderly pattern begins to distort and stretch violently. Its key rings, representing the event horizon, and the singular pixel at its center, flicker, jump, and misalign in unpredictable patterns, like a corrupted data stream. Once-smooth pixel lines are ripped into irregular blocks, leaving fleeting, miscolored afterimages on the screen. As the camera steadily and unhesitatingly descends into the center of this chaos, the image transforms into a digital vortex of shattered cyan and magenta lines and distorted blocks of color. The ring structure completely disintegrates, as if sucked into the singularity by an invisible force, creating a deeply unsettling and psychedelic feeling of system collapse and data disintegration.", + "seed": 22401, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_2/index_1277_seed_22401_dp_5_rank_10_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.498356310185045, + "vlm_logprob": -0.498356310185045, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.774999988079071, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.498356310185045, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.6, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style of the video retro pixel art?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a pure black digital void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central structure a black hole composed of luminous concentric rings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move steadily and unhesitatingly forward into the center of the structure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the rings and center pixel flicker, jump, and misalign in unpredictable patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1418180465698242 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.39181798696517944 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.1418180465698242, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.7500000596046448, + "token_credit_reward": -1.1418180465698242, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16726885735988617, + 0.06648563593626022, + 0.07283247262239456, + 0.023610860109329224, + 0.47909635305404663, + 0.01787249557673931, + 0.02776576578617096, + 0.023670580238103867, + 0.05149438977241516, + 0.06990267336368561 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.1418180465698242 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style of the video retro pixel art?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a pure black digital void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central structure a black hole composed of luminous concentric rings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move steadily and unhesitatingly forward into the center of the structure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the rings and center pixel flicker, jump, and misalign in unpredictable patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2235811948776245 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3485811948776245 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.2235811948776245, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -1.2235811948776245, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15401160717010498, + 0.1419648975133896, + 0.11953103542327881, + 0.05591254681348801, + 0.227888822555542, + 0.04403560236096382, + 0.06869541108608246, + 0.02374495193362236, + 0.07536550611257553, + 0.08884963393211365 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.2235811948776245 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style of the video retro pixel art?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a pure black digital void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central structure a black hole composed of luminous concentric rings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move steadily and unhesitatingly forward into the center of the structure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the rings and center pixel flicker, jump, and misalign in unpredictable patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007649179082363844 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882648944854736 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007649179082363844, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007649179082363844, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09758450090885162, + 0.11348951607942581, + 0.0361018106341362, + 0.02744939550757408, + 0.5284507274627686, + 0.019253764301538467, + 0.027868498116731644, + 0.06355654448270798, + 0.027055896818637848, + 0.05918937176465988 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007649179082363844 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style of the video retro pixel art?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a pure black digital void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central structure a black hole composed of luminous concentric rings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move steadily and unhesitatingly forward into the center of the structure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the rings and center pixel flicker, jump, and misalign in unpredictable patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07004326581954956 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950433254241943 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07004326581954956, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07004326581954956, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08376732468605042, + 0.05447022244334221, + 0.017970364540815353, + 0.027037659659981728, + 0.500756025314331, + 0.02218100242316723, + 0.04070848226547241, + 0.028997421264648438, + 0.053674690425395966, + 0.1704368144273758 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07004326581954956 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style of the video retro pixel art?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a pure black digital void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central structure a black hole composed of luminous concentric rings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move steadily and unhesitatingly forward into the center of the structure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the rings and center pixel flicker, jump, and misalign in unpredictable patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.048689864575862885 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048689842224121 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.048689864575862885, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.048689864575862885, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06644102185964584, + 0.047632619738578796, + 0.04226271063089371, + 0.03805696964263916, + 0.3340233862400055, + 0.039650410413742065, + 0.04269900918006897, + 0.1312950849533081, + 0.1236875131726265, + 0.13425131142139435 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.048689864575862885 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_3/index_tensor([8283, 8283])_group_3_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_3/index_tensor([8283, 8283])_group_3_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..85ab4dbc5f122ebd027e10d4076eaa5c09b0a1eb --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_3/index_tensor([8283, 8283])_group_3_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "close-up, static shot from directly above focuses on a flat sheet of warm-yellow talisman paper with a rough, fibrous texture, set against a pure, shadowless white background. A slender, bony hand steadily enters the frame, gripping a dark bamboo-handled brush in a traditional yet elegant pose. The tip is saturated with a thick, vibrant cinnabar. With a gentle twist of the wrist, the tip of the brush moves across the paper with a swift and decisive rhythm, flowing like water, inking an ancient and complex spell in one continuous motion. The camera captures the moment the cinnabar ink leaves the tip, leaving a wet, glossy trail on the paper. The bright red liquid subtly seeps into the paper's fibers, forming lines imbued with a mysterious power. The composition is remarkably minimalist, and the strong color contrast (white, yellow, and red) creates a powerful visual impact. The bright, even light eliminates all distractions, focusing the viewer's attention entirely on this ritualistic and focused act of writing, creating a sacred and tense atmosphere.", + "seed": 24357, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_3/index_8283_seed_24357_dp_6_rank_12_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.4230738657526672, + "vlm_logprob": -0.4230738657526672, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.925, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.4230738657526672, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up, static view from directly above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a flat sheet of warm-yellow talisman paper with a rough, fibrous texture visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a slender, bony hand enter the frame gripping a dark bamboo-handled brush?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the brush tip move across the paper in a swift, continuous motion leaving a wet, glossy red trail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a pure, shadowless white surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.045567870140075684 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2955679893493652 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.045567870140075684, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.045567870140075684, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14725950360298157, + 0.2134452611207962, + 0.16247473657131195, + 0.11027516424655914, + 0.06743185222148895, + 0.04568230360746384, + 0.13156254589557648, + 0.04891171306371689, + 0.03818714991211891, + 0.03476976603269577 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.045567870140075684 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up, static view from directly above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a flat sheet of warm-yellow talisman paper with a rough, fibrous texture visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a slender, bony hand enter the frame gripping a dark bamboo-handled brush?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the brush tip move across the paper in a swift, continuous motion leaving a wet, glossy red trail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a pure, shadowless white surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005276799667626619 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255276679992676 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005276799667626619, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005276799667626619, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19755908846855164, + 0.17684780061244965, + 0.22422954440116882, + 0.036501962691545486, + 0.057748425751924515, + 0.13733656704425812, + 0.05248555541038513, + 0.04421340301632881, + 0.03493538871407509, + 0.03814229369163513 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005276799667626619 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up, static view from directly above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a flat sheet of warm-yellow talisman paper with a rough, fibrous texture visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a slender, bony hand enter the frame gripping a dark bamboo-handled brush?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the brush tip move across the paper in a swift, continuous motion leaving a wet, glossy red trail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a pure, shadowless white surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03810946270823479 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288109540939331 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03810946270823479, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03810946270823479, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10679267346858978, + 0.2652719020843506, + 0.31480541825294495, + 0.02920582890510559, + 0.09461873769760132, + 0.059636570513248444, + 0.039686527103185654, + 0.02211364172399044, + 0.03886466845870018, + 0.029004007577896118 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03810946270823479 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up, static view from directly above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a flat sheet of warm-yellow talisman paper with a rough, fibrous texture visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a slender, bony hand enter the frame gripping a dark bamboo-handled brush?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the brush tip move across the paper in a swift, continuous motion leaving a wet, glossy red trail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a pure, shadowless white surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008643713779747486 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758643627166748 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008643713779747486, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008643713779747486, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11584974825382233, + 0.09008801728487015, + 0.18004125356674194, + 0.0322299525141716, + 0.08348781615495682, + 0.07996115833520889, + 0.17904062569141388, + 0.0798596665263176, + 0.06992513686418533, + 0.08951661735773087 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008643713779747486 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up, static view from directly above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a flat sheet of warm-yellow talisman paper with a rough, fibrous texture visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a slender, bony hand enter the frame gripping a dark bamboo-handled brush?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the brush tip move across the paper in a swift, continuous motion leaving a wet, glossy red trail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a pure, shadowless white surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0177714824676514 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14277151226997375 + ], + "logprob_reward": -2.0177714824676514, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -2.0177714824676514, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.29885682463645935, + 0.05620932579040527, + 0.26802128553390503, + 0.02408445253968239, + 0.11672352999448776, + 0.15459173917770386, + 0.03164101764559746, + 0.024451153352856636, + 0.01414068415760994, + 0.011279971338808537 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -2.0177714824676514 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up, static shot from directly above focuses on a flat sheet of warm-yellow talisman paper with a rough, fibrous texture, set against a pure, shadowless white background. A slender, bony hand steadily enters the frame, gripping a dark bamboo-handled brush in a traditional yet elegant pose. The tip is saturated with a thick, vibrant cinnabar. With a gentle twist of the wrist, the tip of the brush moves across the paper with a swift and decisive rhythm, flowing like water, inking an ancient and complex spell in one continuous motion. The camera captures the moment the cinnabar ink leaves the tip, leaving a wet, glossy trail on the paper. The bright red liquid subtly seeps into the paper's fibers, forming lines imbued with a mysterious power. The composition is remarkably minimalist, and the strong color contrast (white, yellow, and red) creates a powerful visual impact. The bright, even light eliminates all distractions, focusing the viewer's attention entirely on this ritualistic and focused act of writing, creating a sacred and tense atmosphere.", + "seed": 24358, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_3/index_8283_seed_24358_dp_6_rank_12_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.24702509688213467, + "vlm_logprob": -0.24702509688213467, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.15, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.24702509688213467, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up, static view from directly above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a flat sheet of warm-yellow talisman paper with a rough, fibrous texture visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a slender, bony hand enter the frame gripping a dark bamboo-handled brush?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the brush tip move across the paper in a swift, continuous motion leaving a wet, glossy red trail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a pure, shadowless white surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02679230459034443 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.026792526245117 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02679230459034443, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02679230459034443, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16357167065143585, + 0.18119649589061737, + 0.048654187470674515, + 0.07788416743278503, + 0.12072394043207169, + 0.08036641031503677, + 0.1265682578086853, + 0.06827285885810852, + 0.05004644766449928, + 0.08271555602550507 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02679230459034443 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up, static view from directly above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a flat sheet of warm-yellow talisman paper with a rough, fibrous texture visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a slender, bony hand enter the frame gripping a dark bamboo-handled brush?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the brush tip move across the paper in a swift, continuous motion leaving a wet, glossy red trail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a pure, shadowless white surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00766361178830266 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882663726806641 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00766361178830266, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00766361178830266, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04824480786919594, + 0.4808186888694763, + 0.028053687885403633, + 0.024825433269143105, + 0.03770008310675621, + 0.01841428503394127, + 0.03169044479727745, + 0.26417556405067444, + 0.028872810304164886, + 0.03720417246222496 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00766361178830266 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up, static view from directly above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a flat sheet of warm-yellow talisman paper with a rough, fibrous texture visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a slender, bony hand enter the frame gripping a dark bamboo-handled brush?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the brush tip move across the paper in a swift, continuous motion leaving a wet, glossy red trail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a pure, shadowless white surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.054987017065286636 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299869537353516 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.054987017065286636, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.054987017065286636, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09485407918691635, + 0.3022615909576416, + 0.06143740937113762, + 0.05691760405898094, + 0.15456219017505646, + 0.03475441411137581, + 0.042324814945459366, + 0.11670257151126862, + 0.04116286709904671, + 0.09502246975898743 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 4, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.054987017065286636 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up, static view from directly above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a flat sheet of warm-yellow talisman paper with a rough, fibrous texture visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a slender, bony hand enter the frame gripping a dark bamboo-handled brush?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the brush tip move across the paper in a swift, continuous motion leaving a wet, glossy red trail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a pure, shadowless white surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008642531931400299 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758642673492432 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008642531931400299, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008642531931400299, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05199837312102318, + 0.14766010642051697, + 0.07654307037591934, + 0.04136881232261658, + 0.06812892854213715, + 0.22489912807941437, + 0.1739877462387085, + 0.11834435164928436, + 0.05180833861231804, + 0.04526109993457794 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008642531931400299 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up, static view from directly above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a flat sheet of warm-yellow talisman paper with a rough, fibrous texture visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a slender, bony hand enter the frame gripping a dark bamboo-handled brush?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the brush tip move across the paper in a swift, continuous motion leaving a wet, glossy red trail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a pure, shadowless white surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1370400190353394 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.38704004883766174 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.1370400190353394, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -1.1370400190353394, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1964627057313919, + 0.25975844264030457, + 0.056250691413879395, + 0.04564124718308449, + 0.06654857099056244, + 0.08721494674682617, + 0.028774932026863098, + 0.15312835574150085, + 0.03616437315940857, + 0.07005570083856583 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.1370400190353394 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up, static shot from directly above focuses on a flat sheet of warm-yellow talisman paper with a rough, fibrous texture, set against a pure, shadowless white background. A slender, bony hand steadily enters the frame, gripping a dark bamboo-handled brush in a traditional yet elegant pose. The tip is saturated with a thick, vibrant cinnabar. With a gentle twist of the wrist, the tip of the brush moves across the paper with a swift and decisive rhythm, flowing like water, inking an ancient and complex spell in one continuous motion. The camera captures the moment the cinnabar ink leaves the tip, leaving a wet, glossy trail on the paper. The bright red liquid subtly seeps into the paper's fibers, forming lines imbued with a mysterious power. The composition is remarkably minimalist, and the strong color contrast (white, yellow, and red) creates a powerful visual impact. The bright, even light eliminates all distractions, focusing the viewer's attention entirely on this ritualistic and focused act of writing, creating a sacred and tense atmosphere.", + "seed": 24359, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_3/index_8283_seed_24359_dp_7_rank_14_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.37418789491057397, + "vlm_logprob": -0.37418789491057397, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.275, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.37418789491057397, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up, static view from directly above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a flat sheet of warm-yellow talisman paper with a rough, fibrous texture visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a slender, bony hand enter the frame gripping a dark bamboo-handled brush?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the brush tip move across the paper in a swift, continuous motion leaving a wet, glossy red trail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a pure, shadowless white surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.022264869883656502 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.0222649574279785 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.022264869883656502, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.022264869883656502, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11686618626117706, + 0.12307977676391602, + 0.08934049308300018, + 0.06925326585769653, + 0.09026376903057098, + 0.16318653523921967, + 0.16494740545749664, + 0.04502204805612564, + 0.055729061365127563, + 0.08231145888566971 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.022264869883656502 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up, static view from directly above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a flat sheet of warm-yellow talisman paper with a rough, fibrous texture visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a slender, bony hand enter the frame gripping a dark bamboo-handled brush?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the brush tip move across the paper in a swift, continuous motion leaving a wet, glossy red trail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a pure, shadowless white surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004124349914491177 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504124164581299 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004124349914491177, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004124349914491177, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15356241166591644, + 0.042484890669584274, + 0.04739648848772049, + 0.0639682412147522, + 0.2136000692844391, + 0.12300241738557816, + 0.23376457393169403, + 0.015526006929576397, + 0.05463732033967972, + 0.05205758661031723 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004124349914491177 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up, static view from directly above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a flat sheet of warm-yellow talisman paper with a rough, fibrous texture visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a slender, bony hand enter the frame gripping a dark bamboo-handled brush?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the brush tip move across the paper in a swift, continuous motion leaving a wet, glossy red trail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a pure, shadowless white surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03373025730252266 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4087302684783936 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03373025730252266, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03373025730252266, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08298885822296143, + 0.2036164253950119, + 0.0766642689704895, + 0.03784976527094841, + 0.09483765065670013, + 0.19760753214359283, + 0.08704140037298203, + 0.10967887192964554, + 0.07790812104940414, + 0.03180712088942528 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03373025730252266 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up, static view from directly above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a flat sheet of warm-yellow talisman paper with a rough, fibrous texture visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a slender, bony hand enter the frame gripping a dark bamboo-handled brush?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the brush tip move across the paper in a swift, continuous motion leaving a wet, glossy red trail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a pure, shadowless white surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005952014587819576 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130951881408691 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005952014587819576, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005952014587819576, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06128976121544838, + 0.1469239443540573, + 0.10121165961027145, + 0.1125919371843338, + 0.06761355698108673, + 0.06909345835447311, + 0.23817230761051178, + 0.07041758298873901, + 0.07319375872612, + 0.05949200689792633 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005952014587819576 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up, static view from directly above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a flat sheet of warm-yellow talisman paper with a rough, fibrous texture visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a slender, bony hand enter the frame gripping a dark bamboo-handled brush?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the brush tip move across the paper in a swift, continuous motion leaving a wet, glossy red trail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a pure, shadowless white surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8048679828643799 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1798679381608963 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.8048679828643799, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -1.8048679828643799, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.056204576045274734, + 0.05504487454891205, + 0.04716375097632408, + 0.06415816396474838, + 0.24828475713729858, + 0.27142322063446045, + 0.16301153600215912, + 0.020866746082901955, + 0.014577750116586685, + 0.059264637529850006 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.8048679828643799 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up, static shot from directly above focuses on a flat sheet of warm-yellow talisman paper with a rough, fibrous texture, set against a pure, shadowless white background. A slender, bony hand steadily enters the frame, gripping a dark bamboo-handled brush in a traditional yet elegant pose. The tip is saturated with a thick, vibrant cinnabar. With a gentle twist of the wrist, the tip of the brush moves across the paper with a swift and decisive rhythm, flowing like water, inking an ancient and complex spell in one continuous motion. The camera captures the moment the cinnabar ink leaves the tip, leaving a wet, glossy trail on the paper. The bright red liquid subtly seeps into the paper's fibers, forming lines imbued with a mysterious power. The composition is remarkably minimalist, and the strong color contrast (white, yellow, and red) creates a powerful visual impact. The bright, even light eliminates all distractions, focusing the viewer's attention entirely on this ritualistic and focused act of writing, creating a sacred and tense atmosphere.", + "seed": 24360, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_3/index_8283_seed_24360_dp_7_rank_14_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.5495133028831333, + "vlm_logprob": -0.5495133028831333, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.7, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.5495133028831333, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up, static view from directly above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a flat sheet of warm-yellow talisman paper with a rough, fibrous texture visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a slender, bony hand enter the frame gripping a dark bamboo-handled brush?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the brush tip move across the paper in a swift, continuous motion leaving a wet, glossy red trail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a pure, shadowless white surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020136572420597076 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.14513635635376 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020136572420597076, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020136572420597076, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14220061898231506, + 0.08162753283977509, + 0.09431013464927673, + 0.12454482913017273, + 0.1117938905954361, + 0.09165409207344055, + 0.07987336069345474, + 0.08988945931196213, + 0.077591672539711, + 0.1065143570303917 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020136572420597076 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up, static view from directly above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a flat sheet of warm-yellow talisman paper with a rough, fibrous texture visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a slender, bony hand enter the frame gripping a dark bamboo-handled brush?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the brush tip move across the paper in a swift, continuous motion leaving a wet, glossy red trail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a pure, shadowless white surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007654975634068251 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882655143737793 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007654975634068251, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007654975634068251, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25663939118385315, + 0.08351574093103409, + 0.04421079531311989, + 0.1077033206820488, + 0.0711987093091011, + 0.11184073984622955, + 0.08414756506681442, + 0.036653753370046616, + 0.040561430156230927, + 0.16352854669094086 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007654975634068251 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up, static view from directly above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a flat sheet of warm-yellow talisman paper with a rough, fibrous texture visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a slender, bony hand enter the frame gripping a dark bamboo-handled brush?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the brush tip move across the paper in a swift, continuous motion leaving a wet, glossy red trail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a pure, shadowless white surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2521461248397827 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5021461248397827 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2521461248397827, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2521461248397827, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10609728842973709, + 0.049160972237586975, + 0.0415864922106266, + 0.26844432950019836, + 0.08075332641601562, + 0.05187400430440903, + 0.08205096423625946, + 0.2036571353673935, + 0.05709831416606903, + 0.05927717685699463 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2521461248397827 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up, static view from directly above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a flat sheet of warm-yellow talisman paper with a rough, fibrous texture visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a slender, bony hand enter the frame gripping a dark bamboo-handled brush?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the brush tip move across the paper in a swift, continuous motion leaving a wet, glossy red trail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a pure, shadowless white surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036176491994410753 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628617763519287 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036176491994410753, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036176491994410753, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10402674227952957, + 0.05742029845714569, + 0.06192615628242493, + 0.1248306930065155, + 0.15890012681484222, + 0.1066400334239006, + 0.14449350535869598, + 0.0794927328824997, + 0.10720834881067276, + 0.055061377584934235 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036176491994410753 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up, static view from directly above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a flat sheet of warm-yellow talisman paper with a rough, fibrous texture visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a slender, bony hand enter the frame gripping a dark bamboo-handled brush?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the brush tip move across the paper in a swift, continuous motion leaving a wet, glossy red trail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a pure, shadowless white surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4640111923217773 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08901111036539078 + ], + "logprob_reward": -2.4640111923217773, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -2.4640111923217773, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.26758912205696106, + 0.05778878554701805, + 0.06433473527431488, + 0.1707102209329605, + 0.20584383606910706, + 0.09445104002952576, + 0.04689985513687134, + 0.042448826134204865, + 0.016090260818600655, + 0.03384339436888695 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -2.4640111923217773 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_4/index_tensor([4818, 4818])_group_4_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_4/index_tensor([4818, 4818])_group_4_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..2dbe05b361730062b7fdf1301c5805468c15da5c --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_4/index_tensor([4818, 4818])_group_4_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "The film begins with a fluid, 360-degree panning shot, revealing a fairyland shrouded in dense, flowing mist. Like living white silk, these clouds drift slowly between the looming mountains. At the center of the frame, countless tiny energy points, shimmering with a soft bluish-white glow, like sentient fireflies, begin to be drawn by an invisible force. They converge from all directions, spiraling through the air in elegant spirals, accelerating and converging, ultimately forming a futuristic lotus emblem in the very center of the frame. Translucent, metallic-hued geometric lines form the delicate contours of the petals, which are filled with a shimmering crystal material. At its center lies a core of pure, pulsing energy. The moment the emblem took shape, it erupted with an intense yet subtle, holy light. This cool cyan and silver radiance instantly pierced the dense fog, illuminating the surrounding classical Chinese pavilions and towers suspended above the sea of clouds. The jade-like walls and glazed tile roofs of these buildings revealed their delicate textures in the light, while their eaves and corners cast dynamic light and shadow that shifted with the camera's movement. The entire process, dominated by a palette of deep indigo and mysterious purple, created an atmosphere of sacredness, solemnity, tranquility, and power. As the camera completed its full circular path, it fully showcased the spectacular fusion of ancient imagery and futuristic technology.", + "seed": 33452, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_4/index_4818_seed_33452_dp_8_rank_16_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.08573800893500447, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08573800893500447, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.25, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08573800893500447, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a fluid 360-degree panning shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are translucent metallic-hued geometric lines forming a futuristic lotus emblem in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lotus emblem filled with a shimmering crystal material and a core of pure pulsing energy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do classical Chinese pavilions and towers with jade-like walls and glazed tile roofs appear suspended above the sea of clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a palette dominated by deep indigo and mysterious purple with a cool cyan and silver radiance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3501530885696411 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2251530885696411 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3501530885696411, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3501530885696411, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14984674751758575, + 0.07018240541219711, + 0.17550264298915863, + 0.09657647460699081, + 0.16493472456932068, + 0.11533385515213013, + 0.0651056244969368, + 0.03213797137141228, + 0.06030984967947006, + 0.07006967067718506 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3501530885696411 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a fluid 360-degree panning shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are translucent metallic-hued geometric lines forming a futuristic lotus emblem in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lotus emblem filled with a shimmering crystal material and a core of pure pulsing energy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do classical Chinese pavilions and towers with jade-like walls and glazed tile roofs appear suspended above the sea of clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a palette dominated by deep indigo and mysterious purple with a cool cyan and silver radiance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036266762763261795 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628626823425293 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036266762763261795, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036266762763261795, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09754662960767746, + 0.06850219517946243, + 0.12448272854089737, + 0.130868062376976, + 0.08795124292373657, + 0.2168642282485962, + 0.04647831991314888, + 0.01747991517186165, + 0.18397217988967896, + 0.025854453444480896 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 8, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036266762763261795 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a fluid 360-degree panning shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are translucent metallic-hued geometric lines forming a futuristic lotus emblem in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lotus emblem filled with a shimmering crystal material and a core of pure pulsing energy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do classical Chinese pavilions and towers with jade-like walls and glazed tile roofs appear suspended above the sea of clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a palette dominated by deep indigo and mysterious purple with a cool cyan and silver radiance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00319268717430532 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753192901611328 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00319268717430532, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00319268717430532, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1113724410533905, + 0.11096848547458649, + 0.0878826379776001, + 0.08626162260770798, + 0.12489666789770126, + 0.20430482923984528, + 0.06081821769475937, + 0.02611031010746956, + 0.1525263786315918, + 0.03485839068889618 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00319268717430532 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a fluid 360-degree panning shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are translucent metallic-hued geometric lines forming a futuristic lotus emblem in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lotus emblem filled with a shimmering crystal material and a core of pure pulsing energy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do classical Chinese pavilions and towers with jade-like walls and glazed tile roofs appear suspended above the sea of clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a palette dominated by deep indigo and mysterious purple with a cool cyan and silver radiance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07000625878572464 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950063705444336 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07000625878572464, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07000625878572464, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06236826628446579, + 0.20800869166851044, + 0.03490225970745087, + 0.13229793310165405, + 0.06002958491444588, + 0.4095597267150879, + 0.022274071350693703, + 0.0076009430922567844, + 0.04243705794215202, + 0.02052146941423416 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07000625878572464 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a fluid 360-degree panning shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are translucent metallic-hued geometric lines forming a futuristic lotus emblem in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lotus emblem filled with a shimmering crystal material and a core of pure pulsing energy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do classical Chinese pavilions and towers with jade-like walls and glazed tile roofs appear suspended above the sea of clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a palette dominated by deep indigo and mysterious purple with a cool cyan and silver radiance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0017113338690251112 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.376711368560791 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0017113338690251112, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0017113338690251112, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1569988876581192, + 0.09221278876066208, + 0.07356622070074081, + 0.0720311626791954, + 0.061080969870090485, + 0.3213694989681244, + 0.056356754153966904, + 0.025386938825249672, + 0.09615793824195862, + 0.044838812202215195 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0017113338690251112 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "The film begins with a fluid, 360-degree panning shot, revealing a fairyland shrouded in dense, flowing mist. Like living white silk, these clouds drift slowly between the looming mountains. At the center of the frame, countless tiny energy points, shimmering with a soft bluish-white glow, like sentient fireflies, begin to be drawn by an invisible force. They converge from all directions, spiraling through the air in elegant spirals, accelerating and converging, ultimately forming a futuristic lotus emblem in the very center of the frame. Translucent, metallic-hued geometric lines form the delicate contours of the petals, which are filled with a shimmering crystal material. At its center lies a core of pure, pulsing energy. The moment the emblem took shape, it erupted with an intense yet subtle, holy light. This cool cyan and silver radiance instantly pierced the dense fog, illuminating the surrounding classical Chinese pavilions and towers suspended above the sea of clouds. The jade-like walls and glazed tile roofs of these buildings revealed their delicate textures in the light, while their eaves and corners cast dynamic light and shadow that shifted with the camera's movement. The entire process, dominated by a palette of deep indigo and mysterious purple, created an atmosphere of sacredness, solemnity, tranquility, and power. As the camera completed its full circular path, it fully showcased the spectacular fusion of ancient imagery and futuristic technology.", + "seed": 33453, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_4/index_4818_seed_33453_dp_8_rank_16_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.02547225058078766, + "vlm_logprob": -0.02547225058078766, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.5, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.02547225058078766, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a fluid 360-degree panning shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are translucent metallic-hued geometric lines forming a futuristic lotus emblem in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lotus emblem filled with a shimmering crystal material and a core of pure pulsing energy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do classical Chinese pavilions and towers with jade-like walls and glazed tile roofs appear suspended above the sea of clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a palette dominated by deep indigo and mysterious purple with a cool cyan and silver radiance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08944157510995865 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4644415378570557 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08944157510995865, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08944157510995865, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1090291291475296, + 0.05992881581187248, + 0.4389571249485016, + 0.03918267413973808, + 0.10831142216920853, + 0.05421770364046097, + 0.05064366012811661, + 0.02407691441476345, + 0.06523206830024719, + 0.05042046681046486 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08944157510995865 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a fluid 360-degree panning shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are translucent metallic-hued geometric lines forming a futuristic lotus emblem in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lotus emblem filled with a shimmering crystal material and a core of pure pulsing energy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do classical Chinese pavilions and towers with jade-like walls and glazed tile roofs appear suspended above the sea of clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a palette dominated by deep indigo and mysterious purple with a cool cyan and silver radiance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005958057940006256 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130958080291748 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005958057940006256, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005958057940006256, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.040828872472047806, + 0.023052841424942017, + 0.6637721657752991, + 0.011993794701993465, + 0.05225815996527672, + 0.018147051334381104, + 0.02273012511432171, + 0.03370469808578491, + 0.06550208479166031, + 0.06801026314496994 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005958057940006256 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a fluid 360-degree panning shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are translucent metallic-hued geometric lines forming a futuristic lotus emblem in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lotus emblem filled with a shimmering crystal material and a core of pure pulsing energy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do classical Chinese pavilions and towers with jade-like walls and glazed tile roofs appear suspended above the sea of clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a palette dominated by deep indigo and mysterious purple with a cool cyan and silver radiance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0067379651591181755 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006738185882568 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0067379651591181755, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0067379651591181755, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08684131503105164, + 0.030034217983484268, + 0.1960889846086502, + 0.036015771329402924, + 0.08675919473171234, + 0.17890873551368713, + 0.07157399505376816, + 0.06840301305055618, + 0.1636279821395874, + 0.08174676448106766 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 5, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0067379651591181755 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a fluid 360-degree panning shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are translucent metallic-hued geometric lines forming a futuristic lotus emblem in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lotus emblem filled with a shimmering crystal material and a core of pure pulsing energy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do classical Chinese pavilions and towers with jade-like walls and glazed tile roofs appear suspended above the sea of clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a palette dominated by deep indigo and mysterious purple with a cool cyan and silver radiance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023285046219825745 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773285150527954 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023285046219825745, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023285046219825745, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14548951387405396, + 0.15442940592765808, + 0.19179971516132355, + 0.053854696452617645, + 0.20052459836006165, + 0.03571143373847008, + 0.06278423964977264, + 0.054711658507585526, + 0.0482788048684597, + 0.05241589620709419 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023285046219825745 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a fluid 360-degree panning shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are translucent metallic-hued geometric lines forming a futuristic lotus emblem in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lotus emblem filled with a shimmering crystal material and a core of pure pulsing energy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do classical Chinese pavilions and towers with jade-like walls and glazed tile roofs appear suspended above the sea of clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a palette dominated by deep indigo and mysterious purple with a cool cyan and silver radiance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0019386084750294685 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.251938819885254 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0019386084750294685, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0019386084750294685, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.02932911366224289, + 0.01691693626344204, + 0.8656283617019653, + 0.009462260641157627, + 0.010566771030426025, + 0.026977593079209328, + 0.003645631019026041, + 0.0064648836851119995, + 0.018899474292993546, + 0.01210903748869896 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0019386084750294685 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "The film begins with a fluid, 360-degree panning shot, revealing a fairyland shrouded in dense, flowing mist. Like living white silk, these clouds drift slowly between the looming mountains. At the center of the frame, countless tiny energy points, shimmering with a soft bluish-white glow, like sentient fireflies, begin to be drawn by an invisible force. They converge from all directions, spiraling through the air in elegant spirals, accelerating and converging, ultimately forming a futuristic lotus emblem in the very center of the frame. Translucent, metallic-hued geometric lines form the delicate contours of the petals, which are filled with a shimmering crystal material. At its center lies a core of pure, pulsing energy. The moment the emblem took shape, it erupted with an intense yet subtle, holy light. This cool cyan and silver radiance instantly pierced the dense fog, illuminating the surrounding classical Chinese pavilions and towers suspended above the sea of clouds. The jade-like walls and glazed tile roofs of these buildings revealed their delicate textures in the light, while their eaves and corners cast dynamic light and shadow that shifted with the camera's movement. The entire process, dominated by a palette of deep indigo and mysterious purple, created an atmosphere of sacredness, solemnity, tranquility, and power. As the camera completed its full circular path, it fully showcased the spectacular fusion of ancient imagery and futuristic technology.", + "seed": 33454, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_4/index_4818_seed_33454_dp_9_rank_18_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.07178163537755608, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07178163537755608, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.9749999761581423, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07178163537755608, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a fluid 360-degree panning shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are translucent metallic-hued geometric lines forming a futuristic lotus emblem in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lotus emblem filled with a shimmering crystal material and a core of pure pulsing energy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do classical Chinese pavilions and towers with jade-like walls and glazed tile roofs appear suspended above the sea of clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a palette dominated by deep indigo and mysterious purple with a cool cyan and silver radiance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1434258073568344 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.018425703048706 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1434258073568344, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.8749998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1434258073568344, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04795829951763153, + 0.06601636856794357, + 0.3970603942871094, + 0.06311547756195068, + 0.05933823436498642, + 0.05934876203536987, + 0.14229023456573486, + 0.07630901038646698, + 0.07319611310958862, + 0.015367048792541027 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1434258073568344 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a fluid 360-degree panning shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are translucent metallic-hued geometric lines forming a futuristic lotus emblem in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lotus emblem filled with a shimmering crystal material and a core of pure pulsing energy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do classical Chinese pavilions and towers with jade-like walls and glazed tile roofs appear suspended above the sea of clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a palette dominated by deep indigo and mysterious purple with a cool cyan and silver radiance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004105235915631056 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504105091094971 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004105235915631056, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004105235915631056, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05431939661502838, + 0.050425633788108826, + 0.47048693895339966, + 0.049241501837968826, + 0.03615497052669525, + 0.02633659355342388, + 0.11754229664802551, + 0.08764532208442688, + 0.061305202543735504, + 0.04654206335544586 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004105235915631056 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a fluid 360-degree panning shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are translucent metallic-hued geometric lines forming a futuristic lotus emblem in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lotus emblem filled with a shimmering crystal material and a core of pure pulsing energy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do classical Chinese pavilions and towers with jade-like walls and glazed tile roofs appear suspended above the sea of clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a palette dominated by deep indigo and mysterious purple with a cool cyan and silver radiance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00763084227219224 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882630825042725 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00763084227219224, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00763084227219224, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1367816925048828, + 0.11830081045627594, + 0.06166607886552811, + 0.04093058034777641, + 0.05764424428343773, + 0.03667145222425461, + 0.31891366839408875, + 0.08581482619047165, + 0.09395147860050201, + 0.04932517558336258 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00763084227219224 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a fluid 360-degree panning shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are translucent metallic-hued geometric lines forming a futuristic lotus emblem in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lotus emblem filled with a shimmering crystal material and a core of pure pulsing energy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do classical Chinese pavilions and towers with jade-like walls and glazed tile roofs appear suspended above the sea of clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a palette dominated by deep indigo and mysterious purple with a cool cyan and silver radiance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20155084133148193 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.701550841331482 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20155084133148193, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20155084133148193, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03629252314567566, + 0.03707475960254669, + 0.5539047122001648, + 0.030620381236076355, + 0.022652965039014816, + 0.03705223649740219, + 0.16917282342910767, + 0.06690159440040588, + 0.03427635505795479, + 0.012051645666360855 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20155084133148193 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a fluid 360-degree panning shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are translucent metallic-hued geometric lines forming a futuristic lotus emblem in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lotus emblem filled with a shimmering crystal material and a core of pure pulsing energy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do classical Chinese pavilions and towers with jade-like walls and glazed tile roofs appear suspended above the sea of clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a palette dominated by deep indigo and mysterious purple with a cool cyan and silver radiance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002195450011640787 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127195358276367 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002195450011640787, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002195450011640787, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1277560144662857, + 0.1498686969280243, + 0.34444475173950195, + 0.05336877331137657, + 0.06878764927387238, + 0.029761413112282753, + 0.08282364159822464, + 0.04970736801624298, + 0.04354708641767502, + 0.04993458837270737 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002195450011640787 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "The film begins with a fluid, 360-degree panning shot, revealing a fairyland shrouded in dense, flowing mist. Like living white silk, these clouds drift slowly between the looming mountains. At the center of the frame, countless tiny energy points, shimmering with a soft bluish-white glow, like sentient fireflies, begin to be drawn by an invisible force. They converge from all directions, spiraling through the air in elegant spirals, accelerating and converging, ultimately forming a futuristic lotus emblem in the very center of the frame. Translucent, metallic-hued geometric lines form the delicate contours of the petals, which are filled with a shimmering crystal material. At its center lies a core of pure, pulsing energy. The moment the emblem took shape, it erupted with an intense yet subtle, holy light. This cool cyan and silver radiance instantly pierced the dense fog, illuminating the surrounding classical Chinese pavilions and towers suspended above the sea of clouds. The jade-like walls and glazed tile roofs of these buildings revealed their delicate textures in the light, while their eaves and corners cast dynamic light and shadow that shifted with the camera's movement. The entire process, dominated by a palette of deep indigo and mysterious purple, created an atmosphere of sacredness, solemnity, tranquility, and power. As the camera completed its full circular path, it fully showcased the spectacular fusion of ancient imagery and futuristic technology.", + "seed": 33455, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_4/index_4818_seed_33455_dp_9_rank_18_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.030532246688380837, + "vlm_logprob": -0.030532246688380837, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.35, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.030532246688380837, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a fluid 360-degree panning shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are translucent metallic-hued geometric lines forming a futuristic lotus emblem in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lotus emblem filled with a shimmering crystal material and a core of pure pulsing energy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do classical Chinese pavilions and towers with jade-like walls and glazed tile roofs appear suspended above the sea of clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a palette dominated by deep indigo and mysterious purple with a cool cyan and silver radiance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10097574442625046 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.350975751876831 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10097574442625046, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10097574442625046, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.30124548077583313, + 0.0631977766752243, + 0.06855426728725433, + 0.14931191504001617, + 0.07282214611768723, + 0.0531584694981575, + 0.07757383584976196, + 0.058911554515361786, + 0.09671681374311447, + 0.05850766971707344 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10097574442625046 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a fluid 360-degree panning shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are translucent metallic-hued geometric lines forming a futuristic lotus emblem in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lotus emblem filled with a shimmering crystal material and a core of pure pulsing energy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do classical Chinese pavilions and towers with jade-like walls and glazed tile roofs appear suspended above the sea of clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a palette dominated by deep indigo and mysterious purple with a cool cyan and silver radiance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0041038114577531815 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504103660583496 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0041038114577531815, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0041038114577531815, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05328494682908058, + 0.03946354240179062, + 0.218192920088768, + 0.050225287675857544, + 0.023205429315567017, + 0.04075973480939865, + 0.0634804368019104, + 0.04898640885949135, + 0.08969998359680176, + 0.3727012872695923 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 2, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0041038114577531815 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a fluid 360-degree panning shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are translucent metallic-hued geometric lines forming a futuristic lotus emblem in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lotus emblem filled with a shimmering crystal material and a core of pure pulsing energy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do classical Chinese pavilions and towers with jade-like walls and glazed tile roofs appear suspended above the sea of clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a palette dominated by deep indigo and mysterious purple with a cool cyan and silver radiance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016073880717158318 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141073703765869 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016073880717158318, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016073880717158318, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.021374668926000595, + 0.012523404322564602, + 0.31532227993011475, + 0.011977867223322392, + 0.0045028021559119225, + 0.01404805388301611, + 0.011237859725952148, + 0.021719446405768394, + 0.0529043972492218, + 0.5343892574310303 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 2, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016073880717158318 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a fluid 360-degree panning shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are translucent metallic-hued geometric lines forming a futuristic lotus emblem in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lotus emblem filled with a shimmering crystal material and a core of pure pulsing energy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do classical Chinese pavilions and towers with jade-like walls and glazed tile roofs appear suspended above the sea of clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a palette dominated by deep indigo and mysterious purple with a cool cyan and silver radiance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029796700924634933 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529796600341797 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029796700924634933, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029796700924634933, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13770036399364471, + 0.09046348929405212, + 0.06441051512956619, + 0.10364002734422684, + 0.03720930591225624, + 0.23559701442718506, + 0.07853350788354874, + 0.03845570981502533, + 0.09811539947986603, + 0.11587464809417725 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029796700924634933 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a fluid 360-degree panning shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are translucent metallic-hued geometric lines forming a futuristic lotus emblem in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lotus emblem filled with a shimmering crystal material and a core of pure pulsing energy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do classical Chinese pavilions and towers with jade-like walls and glazed tile roofs appear suspended above the sea of clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a palette dominated by deep indigo and mysterious purple with a cool cyan and silver radiance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.001711095916107297 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.376710891723633 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.001711095916107297, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.001711095916107297, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17662666738033295, + 0.02246726304292679, + 0.11929000914096832, + 0.026753850281238556, + 0.013723905198276043, + 0.06319092959165573, + 0.03853986784815788, + 0.0555257648229599, + 0.03786613792181015, + 0.4460156261920929 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.001711095916107297 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_5/index_tensor([6576, 6576])_group_5_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_5/index_tensor([6576, 6576])_group_5_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..541f3fb54418d90ba7fb84c12f283ecfc90c9704 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_5/index_tensor([6576, 6576])_group_5_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "close-up shot from a high angle, the camera remains stationary, focused on a dusty, dark-stained wooden workbench. A beam of warm, bright afternoon sunlight streams through a high window just outside the frame, striking the lens directly, creating a vibrant, iridescent lens flare that adds a dreamlike quality to the image. Illuminated by the band of light, a hand, marked by age, its knuckles delicately calloused, moves with delicate yet deliberate movements, using the side of its palm to gently push aside the scattered golden, curly shavings and fine sawdust. With the steady movement of the hand, countless tiny dust particles are stirred up, shimmering in the beam of light, seemingly dancing in the air. This creates an atmosphere of profound tranquility, nostalgia, and concentration, the scene bathed in warm, soft tones.", + "seed": 7143, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_5/index_6576_seed_7143_dp_10_rank_20_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.3252068522619084, + "vlm_logprob": -0.3252068522619084, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.025, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.3252068522619084, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a high angle looking down at a dusty, dark-stained wooden workbench?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera stationary throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a beam of warm, bright sunlight streaming through a window and striking the lens to create a vibrant, iridescent lens flare?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is an aged hand with calloused knuckles visible, moving to push aside golden curly shavings and sawdust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are tiny dust particles visible shimmering and dancing in the beam of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029128486290574074 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.9041285514831543 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029128486290574074, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029128486290574074, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1203589215874672, + 0.21202152967453003, + 0.04871712997555733, + 0.054416242986917496, + 0.04932062700390816, + 0.046798694878816605, + 0.30111733078956604, + 0.031672485172748566, + 0.0922900140285492, + 0.04328704625368118 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029128486290574074 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a high angle looking down at a dusty, dark-stained wooden workbench?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera stationary throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a beam of warm, bright sunlight streaming through a window and striking the lens to create a vibrant, iridescent lens flare?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is an aged hand with calloused knuckles visible, moving to push aside golden curly shavings and sawdust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are tiny dust particles visible shimmering and dancing in the beam of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5020822286605835 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2520821988582611 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.5020822286605835, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -1.5020822286605835, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05868953838944435, + 0.05313752591609955, + 0.03238799795508385, + 0.01672842539846897, + 0.07805339992046356, + 0.03657006099820137, + 0.5184130668640137, + 0.0578523725271225, + 0.02387366071343422, + 0.12429392337799072 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.5020822286605835 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a high angle looking down at a dusty, dark-stained wooden workbench?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera stationary throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a beam of warm, bright sunlight streaming through a window and striking the lens to create a vibrant, iridescent lens flare?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is an aged hand with calloused knuckles visible, moving to push aside golden curly shavings and sawdust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are tiny dust particles visible shimmering and dancing in the beam of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0017303746426478028 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.376730442047119 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0017303746426478028, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0017303746426478028, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05492016673088074, + 0.13604900240898132, + 0.050951529294252396, + 0.02161066047847271, + 0.1233399361371994, + 0.07661993056535721, + 0.3797619044780731, + 0.06262773275375366, + 0.06486576050519943, + 0.029253307729959488 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0017303746426478028 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a high angle looking down at a dusty, dark-stained wooden workbench?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera stationary throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a beam of warm, bright sunlight streaming through a window and striking the lens to create a vibrant, iridescent lens flare?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is an aged hand with calloused knuckles visible, moving to push aside golden curly shavings and sawdust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are tiny dust particles visible shimmering and dancing in the beam of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05498611554503441 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929986000061035 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05498611554503441, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05498611554503441, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09930703788995743, + 0.09776420146226883, + 0.09572460502386093, + 0.047713179141283035, + 0.03836914524435997, + 0.09914723038673401, + 0.4100578725337982, + 0.026579415425658226, + 0.0625697672367096, + 0.02276754193007946 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05498611554503441 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a high angle looking down at a dusty, dark-stained wooden workbench?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera stationary throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a beam of warm, bright sunlight streaming through a window and striking the lens to create a vibrant, iridescent lens flare?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is an aged hand with calloused knuckles visible, moving to push aside golden curly shavings and sawdust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are tiny dust particles visible shimmering and dancing in the beam of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03810705617070198 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.28810715675354 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03810705617070198, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03810705617070198, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10366755723953247, + 0.07567532360553741, + 0.04398580640554428, + 0.0326668880879879, + 0.11534396559000015, + 0.05154898017644882, + 0.35980018973350525, + 0.09767904877662659, + 0.07409295439720154, + 0.045539285987615585 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03810705617070198 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up shot from a high angle, the camera remains stationary, focused on a dusty, dark-stained wooden workbench. A beam of warm, bright afternoon sunlight streams through a high window just outside the frame, striking the lens directly, creating a vibrant, iridescent lens flare that adds a dreamlike quality to the image. Illuminated by the band of light, a hand, marked by age, its knuckles delicately calloused, moves with delicate yet deliberate movements, using the side of its palm to gently push aside the scattered golden, curly shavings and fine sawdust. With the steady movement of the hand, countless tiny dust particles are stirred up, shimmering in the beam of light, seemingly dancing in the air. This creates an atmosphere of profound tranquility, nostalgia, and concentration, the scene bathed in warm, soft tones.", + "seed": 7144, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_5/index_6576_seed_7144_dp_10_rank_20_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.30042898778337984, + "vlm_logprob": -0.30042898778337984, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.25, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.30042898778337984, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a high angle looking down at a dusty, dark-stained wooden workbench?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera stationary throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a beam of warm, bright sunlight streaming through a window and striking the lens to create a vibrant, iridescent lens flare?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is an aged hand with calloused knuckles visible, moving to push aside golden curly shavings and sawdust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are tiny dust particles visible shimmering and dancing in the beam of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.042206306010484695 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.667206287384033 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.042206306010484695, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.042206306010484695, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2517661154270172, + 0.06597242504358292, + 0.030674748122692108, + 0.07705113291740417, + 0.037261251360177994, + 0.04496971517801285, + 0.06946765631437302, + 0.20526620745658875, + 0.028684895485639572, + 0.1888858824968338 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.042206306010484695 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a high angle looking down at a dusty, dark-stained wooden workbench?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera stationary throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a beam of warm, bright sunlight streaming through a window and striking the lens to create a vibrant, iridescent lens flare?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is an aged hand with calloused knuckles visible, moving to push aside golden curly shavings and sawdust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are tiny dust particles visible shimmering and dancing in the beam of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.406317114830017 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2813171148300171 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.406317114830017, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -1.406317114830017, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06842994689941406, + 0.19223323464393616, + 0.10508214682340622, + 0.044704653322696686, + 0.07027392089366913, + 0.13093963265419006, + 0.04253862053155899, + 0.18985462188720703, + 0.04641305282711983, + 0.10953020304441452 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 7, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.406317114830017 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a high angle looking down at a dusty, dark-stained wooden workbench?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera stationary throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a beam of warm, bright sunlight streaming through a window and striking the lens to create a vibrant, iridescent lens flare?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is an aged hand with calloused knuckles visible, moving to push aside golden curly shavings and sawdust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are tiny dust particles visible shimmering and dancing in the beam of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0017287085065618157 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.376728534698486 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0017287085065618157, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0017287085065618157, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17005790770053864, + 0.22267156839370728, + 0.07647893577814102, + 0.05660576373338699, + 0.11763463914394379, + 0.07618619501590729, + 0.020506972447037697, + 0.08641615509986877, + 0.020663054659962654, + 0.15277881920337677 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0017287085065618157 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a high angle looking down at a dusty, dark-stained wooden workbench?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera stationary throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a beam of warm, bright sunlight streaming through a window and striking the lens to create a vibrant, iridescent lens flare?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is an aged hand with calloused knuckles visible, moving to push aside golden curly shavings and sawdust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are tiny dust particles visible shimmering and dancing in the beam of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018196668475866318 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.0181965827941895 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018196668475866318, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018196668475866318, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.052342597395181656, + 0.13129425048828125, + 0.13274191319942474, + 0.29752054810523987, + 0.17214295268058777, + 0.0833234116435051, + 0.013337904587388039, + 0.07317514717578888, + 0.0243291687220335, + 0.019792139530181885 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018196668475866318 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a high angle looking down at a dusty, dark-stained wooden workbench?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera stationary throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a beam of warm, bright sunlight streaming through a window and striking the lens to create a vibrant, iridescent lens flare?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is an aged hand with calloused knuckles visible, moving to push aside golden curly shavings and sawdust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are tiny dust particles visible shimmering and dancing in the beam of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.033696141093969345 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408696174621582 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.033696141093969345, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.033696141093969345, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07983436435461044, + 0.07166930288076401, + 0.07594800740480423, + 0.24776186048984528, + 0.1558298021554947, + 0.050715766847133636, + 0.04046915844082832, + 0.13289128243923187, + 0.02872219868004322, + 0.11615832149982452 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.033696141093969345 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up shot from a high angle, the camera remains stationary, focused on a dusty, dark-stained wooden workbench. A beam of warm, bright afternoon sunlight streams through a high window just outside the frame, striking the lens directly, creating a vibrant, iridescent lens flare that adds a dreamlike quality to the image. Illuminated by the band of light, a hand, marked by age, its knuckles delicately calloused, moves with delicate yet deliberate movements, using the side of its palm to gently push aside the scattered golden, curly shavings and fine sawdust. With the steady movement of the hand, countless tiny dust particles are stirred up, shimmering in the beam of light, seemingly dancing in the air. This creates an atmosphere of profound tranquility, nostalgia, and concentration, the scene bathed in warm, soft tones.", + "seed": 7145, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_5/index_6576_seed_7145_dp_11_rank_22_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.33654055995866655, + "vlm_logprob": -0.33654055995866655, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.25, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.33654055995866655, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a high angle looking down at a dusty, dark-stained wooden workbench?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera stationary throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a beam of warm, bright sunlight streaming through a window and striking the lens to create a vibrant, iridescent lens flare?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is an aged hand with calloused knuckles visible, moving to push aside golden curly shavings and sawdust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are tiny dust particles visible shimmering and dancing in the beam of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020140428096055984 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.395140647888184 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020140428096055984, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020140428096055984, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11289695650339127, + 0.24154791235923767, + 0.03777465224266052, + 0.12396156042814255, + 0.052851542830467224, + 0.04200587049126625, + 0.04555926099419594, + 0.03725379705429077, + 0.16369694471359253, + 0.1424514800310135 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020140428096055984 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a high angle looking down at a dusty, dark-stained wooden workbench?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera stationary throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a beam of warm, bright sunlight streaming through a window and striking the lens to create a vibrant, iridescent lens flare?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is an aged hand with calloused knuckles visible, moving to push aside golden curly shavings and sawdust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are tiny dust particles visible shimmering and dancing in the beam of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.600542426109314 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22554241120815277 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.600542426109314, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -1.600542426109314, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08849383890628815, + 0.3795081377029419, + 0.06686660647392273, + 0.06657685339450836, + 0.050546132028102875, + 0.04189388081431389, + 0.04915947467088699, + 0.035474617034196854, + 0.03583650290966034, + 0.18564395606517792 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.600542426109314 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a high angle looking down at a dusty, dark-stained wooden workbench?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera stationary throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a beam of warm, bright sunlight streaming through a window and striking the lens to create a vibrant, iridescent lens flare?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is an aged hand with calloused knuckles visible, moving to push aside golden curly shavings and sawdust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are tiny dust particles visible shimmering and dancing in the beam of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0019584777764976025 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.25195837020874 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0019584777764976025, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0019584777764976025, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15125755965709686, + 0.19870996475219727, + 0.09084560722112656, + 0.06819076836109161, + 0.08501382172107697, + 0.035246655344963074, + 0.0318121463060379, + 0.0591878779232502, + 0.05795969441533089, + 0.2217758595943451 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0019584777764976025 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a high angle looking down at a dusty, dark-stained wooden workbench?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera stationary throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a beam of warm, bright sunlight streaming through a window and striking the lens to create a vibrant, iridescent lens flare?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is an aged hand with calloused knuckles visible, moving to push aside golden curly shavings and sawdust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are tiny dust particles visible shimmering and dancing in the beam of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026361869648098946 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513619422912598 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026361869648098946, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026361869648098946, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1510976254940033, + 0.03201942890882492, + 0.12701238691806793, + 0.1094491109251976, + 0.11461561173200607, + 0.08681295067071915, + 0.04669281467795372, + 0.046632472425699234, + 0.05426628515124321, + 0.23140136897563934 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026361869648098946 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a high angle looking down at a dusty, dark-stained wooden workbench?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera stationary throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a beam of warm, bright sunlight streaming through a window and striking the lens to create a vibrant, iridescent lens flare?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is an aged hand with calloused knuckles visible, moving to push aside golden curly shavings and sawdust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are tiny dust particles visible shimmering and dancing in the beam of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03369959816336632 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4086995124816895 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03369959816336632, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03369959816336632, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10906132310628891, + 0.24773208796977997, + 0.034055884927511215, + 0.13450798392295837, + 0.04046127572655678, + 0.06127597391605377, + 0.08121590316295624, + 0.04612749069929123, + 0.04498503729701042, + 0.20057709515094757 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03369959816336632 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up shot from a high angle, the camera remains stationary, focused on a dusty, dark-stained wooden workbench. A beam of warm, bright afternoon sunlight streams through a high window just outside the frame, striking the lens directly, creating a vibrant, iridescent lens flare that adds a dreamlike quality to the image. Illuminated by the band of light, a hand, marked by age, its knuckles delicately calloused, moves with delicate yet deliberate movements, using the side of its palm to gently push aside the scattered golden, curly shavings and fine sawdust. With the steady movement of the hand, countless tiny dust particles are stirred up, shimmering in the beam of light, seemingly dancing in the air. This creates an atmosphere of profound tranquility, nostalgia, and concentration, the scene bathed in warm, soft tones.", + "seed": 7146, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_5/index_6576_seed_7146_dp_11_rank_22_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.32370955920778216, + "vlm_logprob": -0.32370955920778216, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.975, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.32370955920778216, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a high angle looking down at a dusty, dark-stained wooden workbench?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera stationary throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a beam of warm, bright sunlight streaming through a window and striking the lens to create a vibrant, iridescent lens flare?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is an aged hand with calloused knuckles visible, moving to push aside golden curly shavings and sawdust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are tiny dust particles visible shimmering and dancing in the beam of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04602586850523949 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4210257530212402 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04602586850523949, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04602586850523949, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21532858908176422, + 0.02846587635576725, + 0.2914605438709259, + 0.07568192481994629, + 0.1070232167840004, + 0.049613405019044876, + 0.05532139912247658, + 0.02673022635281086, + 0.04720074310898781, + 0.1031741052865982 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04602586850523949 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a high angle looking down at a dusty, dark-stained wooden workbench?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera stationary throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a beam of warm, bright sunlight streaming through a window and striking the lens to create a vibrant, iridescent lens flare?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is an aged hand with calloused knuckles visible, moving to push aside golden curly shavings and sawdust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are tiny dust particles visible shimmering and dancing in the beam of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5020856857299805 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2520856261253357 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.5020856857299805, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -1.5020856857299805, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3931078314781189, + 0.05424739420413971, + 0.16963347792625427, + 0.1276489794254303, + 0.05070075765252113, + 0.016200317069888115, + 0.025828514248132706, + 0.032696615904569626, + 0.08015786111354828, + 0.04977827146649361 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.5020856857299805 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a high angle looking down at a dusty, dark-stained wooden workbench?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera stationary throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a beam of warm, bright sunlight streaming through a window and striking the lens to create a vibrant, iridescent lens flare?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is an aged hand with calloused knuckles visible, moving to push aside golden curly shavings and sawdust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are tiny dust particles visible shimmering and dancing in the beam of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0025137036573141813 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002513885498047 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0025137036573141813, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0025137036573141813, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3752516508102417, + 0.04631368815898895, + 0.1835896372795105, + 0.12499487400054932, + 0.07391372323036194, + 0.01486525870859623, + 0.015905052423477173, + 0.059875793755054474, + 0.04074219986796379, + 0.0645480826497078 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0025137036573141813 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a high angle looking down at a dusty, dark-stained wooden workbench?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera stationary throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a beam of warm, bright sunlight streaming through a window and striking the lens to create a vibrant, iridescent lens flare?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is an aged hand with calloused knuckles visible, moving to push aside golden curly shavings and sawdust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are tiny dust particles visible shimmering and dancing in the beam of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029820075258612633 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529819965362549 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029820075258612633, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029820075258612633, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.31891030073165894, + 0.17028425633907318, + 0.09133739769458771, + 0.12264081090688705, + 0.03742702677845955, + 0.04467074200510979, + 0.015361735597252846, + 0.044424351304769516, + 0.030368786305189133, + 0.12457459419965744 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029820075258612633 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a high angle looking down at a dusty, dark-stained wooden workbench?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera stationary throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a beam of warm, bright sunlight streaming through a window and striking the lens to create a vibrant, iridescent lens flare?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is an aged hand with calloused knuckles visible, moving to push aside golden curly shavings and sawdust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are tiny dust particles visible shimmering and dancing in the beam of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03810246288776398 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288102388381958 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03810246288776398, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03810246288776398, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12166914343833923, + 0.07223407924175262, + 0.30504605174064636, + 0.07773629575967789, + 0.15234880149364471, + 0.021788164973258972, + 0.06975303590297699, + 0.049567606300115585, + 0.05130176991224289, + 0.07855504751205444 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03810246288776398 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_6/index_tensor([2435, 2435])_group_6_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_6/index_tensor([2435, 2435])_group_6_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..0e5db247161a5a9baa707df573df4a4a8b5abb0b --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_6/index_tensor([2435, 2435])_group_6_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "low-angle shot, the camera tilted steadily upward, closely following a sturdy figure. He was a man with defined back and arms, tackling a nearly vertical, rough, dark gray and ochre granite face with his bare hands. He wore a tight, quick-drying black T-shirt and durable khaki climbing shorts, with a chalk bag of white magnesium chalk strapped to his waist. The bright afternoon sun streamed in from the side, casting sharp shadows on his tanned skin. Beads of sweat glistened on his forehead. His face was intensely focused, his lips pursed. He carefully extended his calloused right hand, his fingers precisely gripping a tiny rock protrusion. With steady, powerful force, he pulled himself upward, while his other hand and foot searched for a new foothold on the rock face. The camera is synchronized with his climbing movements, slowly revealing the bottomless canyon below him and the clear blue sky above his head, creating a magnificent atmosphere of extreme tension, high concentration, and the confrontation between human power and the majesty of nature.", + "seed": 18926, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_6/index_2435_seed_18926_dp_12_rank_24_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.04704507365822792, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04704507365822792, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.275, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04704507365822792, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low angle with the camera tilted upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the climber wearing a tight black T-shirt and durable khaki climbing shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a white chalk bag strapped to the climber's waist visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the rock face rough, dark gray and ochre in color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly reveal the bottomless canyon below and the clear blue sky above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11782711744308472 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2428271770477295 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11782711744308472, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11782711744308472, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25524553656578064, + 0.045086923986673355, + 0.0808216780424118, + 0.2586396038532257, + 0.03715841844677925, + 0.04863300174474716, + 0.05740070715546608, + 0.029208699241280556, + 0.15618598461151123, + 0.03161943331360817 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11782711744308472 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low angle with the camera tilted upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the climber wearing a tight black T-shirt and durable khaki climbing shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a white chalk bag strapped to the climber's waist visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the rock face rough, dark gray and ochre in color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly reveal the bottomless canyon below and the clear blue sky above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02635931596159935 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513593196868896 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02635931596159935, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02635931596159935, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.43974414467811584, + 0.0453660823404789, + 0.039801694452762604, + 0.027573954313993454, + 0.01892547309398651, + 0.034169428050518036, + 0.07008274644613266, + 0.12454923242330551, + 0.1589679718017578, + 0.04081932455301285 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02635931596159935 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low angle with the camera tilted upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the climber wearing a tight black T-shirt and durable khaki climbing shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a white chalk bag strapped to the climber's waist visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the rock face rough, dark gray and ochre in color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly reveal the bottomless canyon below and the clear blue sky above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04305346682667732 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168053388595581 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04305346682667732, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04305346682667732, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4082593619823456, + 0.05837896838784218, + 0.02632170543074608, + 0.17747895419597626, + 0.0194863211363554, + 0.05526198819279671, + 0.051814690232276917, + 0.04907814413309097, + 0.10820112377405167, + 0.04571869224309921 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04305346682667732 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low angle with the camera tilted upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the climber wearing a tight black T-shirt and durable khaki climbing shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a white chalk bag strapped to the climber's waist visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the rock face rough, dark gray and ochre in color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly reveal the bottomless canyon below and the clear blue sky above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018183674663305283 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018183708190918 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018183674663305283, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018183674663305283, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.27224600315093994, + 0.027786409482359886, + 0.04597204923629761, + 0.17173224687576294, + 0.04753316938877106, + 0.08293978124856949, + 0.04580554738640785, + 0.03254857659339905, + 0.138833150267601, + 0.13460306823253632 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018183674663305283 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low angle with the camera tilted upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the climber wearing a tight black T-shirt and durable khaki climbing shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a white chalk bag strapped to the climber's waist visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the rock face rough, dark gray and ochre in color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly reveal the bottomless canyon below and the clear blue sky above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02980179339647293 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529801845550537 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02980179339647293, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02980179339647293, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15938028693199158, + 0.029345612972974777, + 0.037814658135175705, + 0.06288539618253708, + 0.07006034255027771, + 0.03203193470835686, + 0.0457632802426815, + 0.06847844272851944, + 0.4184721112251282, + 0.07576800882816315 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02980179339647293 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle shot, the camera tilted steadily upward, closely following a sturdy figure. He was a man with defined back and arms, tackling a nearly vertical, rough, dark gray and ochre granite face with his bare hands. He wore a tight, quick-drying black T-shirt and durable khaki climbing shorts, with a chalk bag of white magnesium chalk strapped to his waist. The bright afternoon sun streamed in from the side, casting sharp shadows on his tanned skin. Beads of sweat glistened on his forehead. His face was intensely focused, his lips pursed. He carefully extended his calloused right hand, his fingers precisely gripping a tiny rock protrusion. With steady, powerful force, he pulled himself upward, while his other hand and foot searched for a new foothold on the rock face. The camera is synchronized with his climbing movements, slowly revealing the bottomless canyon below him and the clear blue sky above his head, creating a magnificent atmosphere of extreme tension, high concentration, and the confrontation between human power and the majesty of nature.", + "seed": 18927, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_6/index_2435_seed_18927_dp_12_rank_24_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.06180679127573967, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06180679127573967, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.049999976158142, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06180679127573967, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low angle with the camera tilted upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the climber wearing a tight black T-shirt and durable khaki climbing shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a white chalk bag strapped to the climber's waist visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the rock face rough, dark gray and ochre in color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly reveal the bottomless canyon below and the clear blue sky above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14886362850666046 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0238635540008545 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14886362850666046, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.8749998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14886362850666046, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08723904937505722, + 0.20557944476604462, + 0.0743156224489212, + 0.20322446525096893, + 0.042946167290210724, + 0.025442048907279968, + 0.06812598556280136, + 0.021362563595175743, + 0.039713069796562195, + 0.23205158114433289 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14886362850666046 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low angle with the camera tilted upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the climber wearing a tight black T-shirt and durable khaki climbing shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a white chalk bag strapped to the climber's waist visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the rock face rough, dark gray and ochre in color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly reveal the bottomless canyon below and the clear blue sky above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023307407274842262 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7733073234558105 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023307407274842262, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023307407274842262, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.022050535306334496, + 0.046385470777750015, + 0.12250704318284988, + 0.5447622537612915, + 0.026632357388734818, + 0.012495107017457485, + 0.17106746137142181, + 0.030614415183663368, + 0.006608924362808466, + 0.016876427456736565 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 6, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023307407274842262 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low angle with the camera tilted upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the climber wearing a tight black T-shirt and durable khaki climbing shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a white chalk bag strapped to the climber's waist visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the rock face rough, dark gray and ochre in color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly reveal the bottomless canyon below and the clear blue sky above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04864932969212532 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048649311065674 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04864932969212532, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04864932969212532, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09648802131414413, + 0.16551640629768372, + 0.154209166765213, + 0.14948445558547974, + 0.04316375032067299, + 0.05308061093091965, + 0.14185301959514618, + 0.05905449390411377, + 0.04844723641872406, + 0.08870280534029007 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04864932969212532 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low angle with the camera tilted upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the climber wearing a tight black T-shirt and durable khaki climbing shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a white chalk bag strapped to the climber's waist visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the rock face rough, dark gray and ochre in color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly reveal the bottomless canyon below and the clear blue sky above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018181217834353447 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018181324005127 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018181217834353447, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018181217834353447, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06989194452762604, + 0.07252279669046402, + 0.08054967224597931, + 0.41966867446899414, + 0.023428605869412422, + 0.05369389429688454, + 0.12793412804603577, + 0.049210838973522186, + 0.013760770671069622, + 0.08933870494365692 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018181217834353447 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low angle with the camera tilted upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the climber wearing a tight black T-shirt and durable khaki climbing shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a white chalk bag strapped to the climber's waist visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the rock face rough, dark gray and ochre in color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly reveal the bottomless canyon below and the clear blue sky above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07003237307071686 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950323581695557 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07003237307071686, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07003237307071686, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13685986399650574, + 0.06464884430170059, + 0.05252541974186897, + 0.07200925797224045, + 0.028494296595454216, + 0.04179225489497185, + 0.2266698181629181, + 0.03521006181836128, + 0.05868843197822571, + 0.28310176730155945 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07003237307071686 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle shot, the camera tilted steadily upward, closely following a sturdy figure. He was a man with defined back and arms, tackling a nearly vertical, rough, dark gray and ochre granite face with his bare hands. He wore a tight, quick-drying black T-shirt and durable khaki climbing shorts, with a chalk bag of white magnesium chalk strapped to his waist. The bright afternoon sun streamed in from the side, casting sharp shadows on his tanned skin. Beads of sweat glistened on his forehead. His face was intensely focused, his lips pursed. He carefully extended his calloused right hand, his fingers precisely gripping a tiny rock protrusion. With steady, powerful force, he pulled himself upward, while his other hand and foot searched for a new foothold on the rock face. The camera is synchronized with his climbing movements, slowly revealing the bottomless canyon below him and the clear blue sky above his head, creating a magnificent atmosphere of extreme tension, high concentration, and the confrontation between human power and the majesty of nature.", + "seed": 18928, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_6/index_2435_seed_18928_dp_13_rank_26_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.06326566822826862, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06326566822826862, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.0250000238418577, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06326566822826862, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low angle with the camera tilted upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the climber wearing a tight black T-shirt and durable khaki climbing shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a white chalk bag strapped to the climber's waist visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the rock face rough, dark gray and ochre in color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly reveal the bottomless canyon below and the clear blue sky above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14700429141521454 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0220043659210205 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14700429141521454, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.8750001192092896, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14700429141521454, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.44060268998146057, + 0.10888863354921341, + 0.16039106249809265, + 0.014390339143574238, + 0.040353864431381226, + 0.022488461807370186, + 0.04719056561589241, + 0.06218968704342842, + 0.05607576295733452, + 0.04742883890867233 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14700429141521454 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low angle with the camera tilted upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the climber wearing a tight black T-shirt and durable khaki climbing shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a white chalk bag strapped to the climber's waist visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the rock face rough, dark gray and ochre in color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly reveal the bottomless canyon below and the clear blue sky above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03810935094952583 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288109302520752 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03810935094952583, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03810935094952583, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08623453229665756, + 0.24873237311840057, + 0.20560933649539948, + 0.032140184193849564, + 0.07419437170028687, + 0.025190653279423714, + 0.08464452624320984, + 0.03048899956047535, + 0.16210807859897614, + 0.05065694451332092 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03810935094952583 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low angle with the camera tilted upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the climber wearing a tight black T-shirt and durable khaki climbing shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a white chalk bag strapped to the climber's waist visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the rock face rough, dark gray and ochre in color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly reveal the bottomless canyon below and the clear blue sky above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07002115249633789 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695021152496338 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07002115249633789, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07002115249633789, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12622688710689545, + 0.19875673949718475, + 0.16092923283576965, + 0.05999884381890297, + 0.04569169878959656, + 0.03075035661458969, + 0.03934116289019585, + 0.04578731209039688, + 0.20032232999801636, + 0.09219542890787125 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07002115249633789 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low angle with the camera tilted upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the climber wearing a tight black T-shirt and durable khaki climbing shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a white chalk bag strapped to the climber's waist visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the rock face rough, dark gray and ochre in color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly reveal the bottomless canyon below and the clear blue sky above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012535588815808296 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387535572052002 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012535588815808296, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012535588815808296, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10410303622484207, + 0.12400374561548233, + 0.19651389122009277, + 0.0565817691385746, + 0.13174201548099518, + 0.023602748289704323, + 0.04455992951989174, + 0.041655533015728, + 0.23472845554351807, + 0.04250893369317055 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012535588815808296 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low angle with the camera tilted upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the climber wearing a tight black T-shirt and durable khaki climbing shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a white chalk bag strapped to the climber's waist visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the rock face rough, dark gray and ochre in color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly reveal the bottomless canyon below and the clear blue sky above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04865795746445656 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486578941345215 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04865795746445656, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04865795746445656, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3172910809516907, + 0.06911931931972504, + 0.050748445093631744, + 0.029527697712183, + 0.10232211649417877, + 0.03657805547118187, + 0.11501308530569077, + 0.17345185577869415, + 0.0666535347700119, + 0.039294835180044174 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04865795746445656 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle shot, the camera tilted steadily upward, closely following a sturdy figure. He was a man with defined back and arms, tackling a nearly vertical, rough, dark gray and ochre granite face with his bare hands. He wore a tight, quick-drying black T-shirt and durable khaki climbing shorts, with a chalk bag of white magnesium chalk strapped to his waist. The bright afternoon sun streamed in from the side, casting sharp shadows on his tanned skin. Beads of sweat glistened on his forehead. His face was intensely focused, his lips pursed. He carefully extended his calloused right hand, his fingers precisely gripping a tiny rock protrusion. With steady, powerful force, he pulled himself upward, while his other hand and foot searched for a new foothold on the rock face. The camera is synchronized with his climbing movements, slowly revealing the bottomless canyon below him and the clear blue sky above his head, creating a magnificent atmosphere of extreme tension, high concentration, and the confrontation between human power and the majesty of nature.", + "seed": 18929, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_6/index_2435_seed_18929_dp_13_rank_26_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.07372774295508862, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07372774295508862, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.7, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07372774295508862, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low angle with the camera tilted upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the climber wearing a tight black T-shirt and durable khaki climbing shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a white chalk bag strapped to the climber's waist visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the rock face rough, dark gray and ochre in color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly reveal the bottomless canyon below and the clear blue sky above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11627551913261414 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2412755489349365 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11627551913261414, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11627551913261414, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2913551330566406, + 0.03555746749043465, + 0.08439093828201294, + 0.14594855904579163, + 0.039829693734645844, + 0.13907834887504578, + 0.025655411183834076, + 0.09445967525243759, + 0.09747175127267838, + 0.04625299572944641 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11627551913261414 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low angle with the camera tilted upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the climber wearing a tight black T-shirt and durable khaki climbing shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a white chalk bag strapped to the climber's waist visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the rock face rough, dark gray and ochre in color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly reveal the bottomless canyon below and the clear blue sky above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07002659887075424 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950266361236572 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07002659887075424, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07002659887075424, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21680094301700592, + 0.03953590244054794, + 0.06669224798679352, + 0.2203717976808548, + 0.081589475274086, + 0.127595454454422, + 0.12035061419010162, + 0.05045180767774582, + 0.05104164034128189, + 0.025570126250386238 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07002659887075424 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low angle with the camera tilted upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the climber wearing a tight black T-shirt and durable khaki climbing shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a white chalk bag strapped to the climber's waist visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the rock face rough, dark gray and ochre in color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly reveal the bottomless canyon below and the clear blue sky above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07000803202390671 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950080394744873 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07000803202390671, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07000803202390671, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25801268219947815, + 0.04749392718076706, + 0.0645611360669136, + 0.03369944170117378, + 0.130606010556221, + 0.1843913048505783, + 0.08722835034132004, + 0.1084163635969162, + 0.030786488205194473, + 0.05480432137846947 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07000803202390671 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low angle with the camera tilted upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the climber wearing a tight black T-shirt and durable khaki climbing shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a white chalk bag strapped to the climber's waist visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the rock face rough, dark gray and ochre in color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly reveal the bottomless canyon below and the clear blue sky above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02328539453446865 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773285388946533 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02328539453446865, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02328539453446865, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5733298063278198, + 0.0123677346855402, + 0.02350483275949955, + 0.13782790303230286, + 0.08230715245008469, + 0.05014977231621742, + 0.014473306946456432, + 0.04308415204286575, + 0.03096151165664196, + 0.0319937989115715 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02328539453446865 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low angle with the camera tilted upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the climber wearing a tight black T-shirt and durable khaki climbing shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a white chalk bag strapped to the climber's waist visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the rock face rough, dark gray and ochre in color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly reveal the bottomless canyon below and the clear blue sky above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08904317021369934 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.464043140411377 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08904317021369934, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08904317021369934, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10171416401863098, + 0.03355757147073746, + 0.034681398421525955, + 0.3775496482849121, + 0.05232686176896095, + 0.1319964975118637, + 0.03189866617321968, + 0.1839917004108429, + 0.023045223206281662, + 0.029238292947411537 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 7, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08904317021369934 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_7/index_tensor([9979, 9979])_group_7_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_7/index_tensor([9979, 9979])_group_7_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..448a4f4013d6470c6a07f56cfbbc1a7331093818 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_7/index_tensor([9979, 9979])_group_7_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "360-degree slow-motion doll gracefully rotates around a large, round, dark wooden table, polished to a soft patina by generations of use, situated in the center of a house dating back to the early Ming Dynasty. The entire scene is bathed in the soft, romantic glow of red and yellow paper lanterns hanging from the ceiling beams, casting a warm golden light and creating gently dancing shadows. A multi-generational family gathers around the table, engrossed in the shared ritual of making dumplings. An elderly grandmother, her silver hair tied in an elegant bun and her face lined with wrinkles, demonstrates her pleating technique with nimble, practiced fingers. Beside her, a young mother dressed in a simple silk aoqun in a pastel green, her dark hair held up with a jade hairpin, smiles warmly as she assists her young daughter, her bright, curious eyes focused on the task. A father and grandfather, dressed in simple linen tunics, work quietly and intently, their larger hands moving with surprising gentleness. Their hands, smeared with white flour, moved in beautiful, near-perfect unisons, deftly scooping ground pork and chives onto thin, round wrappers, moistening the edges and pleating them into perfect crescents before lovingly placing them on bamboo plates. A gentle, contented smile graced each face, reflecting the light of the lanterns, creating an atmosphere of profound peace, familial affection, and a tranquil, joyful tradition. In the background, a carved wooden screen and hanging calligraphy scrolls added a touch of period authenticity, completing this intimate portrait of familial harmony.", + "seed": 534, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_7/index_9979_seed_534_dp_14_rank_28_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.2847747979685664, + "vlm_logprob": -0.2847747979685664, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.7, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.2847747979685664, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a 360-degree slow-motion shot of a doll rotating around a large, round, dark wooden table visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a house dating back to the early Ming Dynasty with red and yellow paper lanterns hanging from the ceiling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a multi-generational family gathered around the table making dumplings, including an elderly grandmother with silver hair in a bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the family members wearing period-appropriate clothing such as a pastel green silk aoqun for the mother and linen tunics for the father and grandfather?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the hands of the family members shown smeared with white flour while filling and pleating dumpling wrappers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3161449134349823 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3161449432373047 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3161449134349823, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3161449134349823, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09584654122591019, + 0.05118845775723457, + 0.07434633374214172, + 0.09538467228412628, + 0.08770240843296051, + 0.0732102170586586, + 0.0605878010392189, + 0.1396121084690094, + 0.24034695327281952, + 0.08177449554204941 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3161449134349823 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a 360-degree slow-motion shot of a doll rotating around a large, round, dark wooden table visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a house dating back to the early Ming Dynasty with red and yellow paper lanterns hanging from the ceiling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a multi-generational family gathered around the table making dumplings, including an elderly grandmother with silver hair in a bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the family members wearing period-appropriate clothing such as a pastel green silk aoqun for the mother and linen tunics for the father and grandfather?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the hands of the family members shown smeared with white flour while filling and pleating dumpling wrappers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.053909182548523 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.42890918254852295 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.053909182548523, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.625, + "token_credit_reward": -1.053909182548523, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15983806550502777, + 0.04016583785414696, + 0.04252815246582031, + 0.04795907437801361, + 0.2591390907764435, + 0.20940224826335907, + 0.07045099884271622, + 0.03959633409976959, + 0.05152082443237305, + 0.07939941436052322 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.053909182548523 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a 360-degree slow-motion shot of a doll rotating around a large, round, dark wooden table visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a house dating back to the early Ming Dynasty with red and yellow paper lanterns hanging from the ceiling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a multi-generational family gathered around the table making dumplings, including an elderly grandmother with silver hair in a bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the family members wearing period-appropriate clothing such as a pastel green silk aoqun for the mother and linen tunics for the father and grandfather?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the hands of the family members shown smeared with white flour while filling and pleating dumpling wrappers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03809615224599838 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2880961894989014 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03809615224599838, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03809615224599838, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1557607203722, + 0.0900801420211792, + 0.07014426589012146, + 0.17811019718647003, + 0.07428083568811417, + 0.046657465398311615, + 0.0729580819606781, + 0.08245237171649933, + 0.1357431709766388, + 0.0938127189874649 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03809615224599838 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a 360-degree slow-motion shot of a doll rotating around a large, round, dark wooden table visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a house dating back to the early Ming Dynasty with red and yellow paper lanterns hanging from the ceiling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a multi-generational family gathered around the table making dumplings, including an elderly grandmother with silver hair in a bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the family members wearing period-appropriate clothing such as a pastel green silk aoqun for the mother and linen tunics for the father and grandfather?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the hands of the family members shown smeared with white flour while filling and pleating dumpling wrappers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011085234582424164 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511085033416748 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011085234582424164, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011085234582424164, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14527472853660583, + 0.06074679642915726, + 0.07817751169204712, + 0.0754086822271347, + 0.14774465560913086, + 0.10884616523981094, + 0.06151515245437622, + 0.04973623901605606, + 0.09986838698387146, + 0.17268164455890656 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011085234582424164 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a 360-degree slow-motion shot of a doll rotating around a large, round, dark wooden table visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a house dating back to the early Ming Dynasty with red and yellow paper lanterns hanging from the ceiling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a multi-generational family gathered around the table making dumplings, including an elderly grandmother with silver hair in a bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the family members wearing period-appropriate clothing such as a pastel green silk aoqun for the mother and linen tunics for the father and grandfather?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the hands of the family members shown smeared with white flour while filling and pleating dumpling wrappers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004638507030904293 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379638671875 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004638507030904293, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004638507030904293, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18245360255241394, + 0.16778971254825592, + 0.0829416885972023, + 0.09988681972026825, + 0.13224108517169952, + 0.09209516644477844, + 0.049947332590818405, + 0.049445804208517075, + 0.0697360634803772, + 0.07346271723508835 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004638507030904293 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "360-degree slow-motion doll gracefully rotates around a large, round, dark wooden table, polished to a soft patina by generations of use, situated in the center of a house dating back to the early Ming Dynasty. The entire scene is bathed in the soft, romantic glow of red and yellow paper lanterns hanging from the ceiling beams, casting a warm golden light and creating gently dancing shadows. A multi-generational family gathers around the table, engrossed in the shared ritual of making dumplings. An elderly grandmother, her silver hair tied in an elegant bun and her face lined with wrinkles, demonstrates her pleating technique with nimble, practiced fingers. Beside her, a young mother dressed in a simple silk aoqun in a pastel green, her dark hair held up with a jade hairpin, smiles warmly as she assists her young daughter, her bright, curious eyes focused on the task. A father and grandfather, dressed in simple linen tunics, work quietly and intently, their larger hands moving with surprising gentleness. Their hands, smeared with white flour, moved in beautiful, near-perfect unisons, deftly scooping ground pork and chives onto thin, round wrappers, moistening the edges and pleating them into perfect crescents before lovingly placing them on bamboo plates. A gentle, contented smile graced each face, reflecting the light of the lanterns, creating an atmosphere of profound peace, familial affection, and a tranquil, joyful tradition. In the background, a carved wooden screen and hanging calligraphy scrolls added a touch of period authenticity, completing this intimate portrait of familial harmony.", + "seed": 535, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_7/index_9979_seed_535_dp_14_rank_28_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.2908020346425474, + "vlm_logprob": -0.2908020346425474, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.275, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.2908020346425474, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a 360-degree slow-motion shot of a doll rotating around a large, round, dark wooden table visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a house dating back to the early Ming Dynasty with red and yellow paper lanterns hanging from the ceiling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a multi-generational family gathered around the table making dumplings, including an elderly grandmother with silver hair in a bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the family members wearing period-appropriate clothing such as a pastel green silk aoqun for the mother and linen tunics for the father and grandfather?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the hands of the family members shown smeared with white flour while filling and pleating dumpling wrappers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.760578453540802 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.635578453540802 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.760578453540802, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.760578453540802, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07636702060699463, + 0.18364542722702026, + 0.12500537931919098, + 0.07862138003110886, + 0.059734128415584564, + 0.0687449648976326, + 0.19793294370174408, + 0.08488333225250244, + 0.07253755629062653, + 0.05252782255411148 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.760578453540802 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a 360-degree slow-motion shot of a doll rotating around a large, round, dark wooden table visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a house dating back to the early Ming Dynasty with red and yellow paper lanterns hanging from the ceiling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a multi-generational family gathered around the table making dumplings, including an elderly grandmother with silver hair in a bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the family members wearing period-appropriate clothing such as a pastel green silk aoqun for the mother and linen tunics for the father and grandfather?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the hands of the family members shown smeared with white flour while filling and pleating dumpling wrappers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5762289762496948 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8262289762496948 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5762289762496948, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5762289762496948, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09652414917945862, + 0.11975658684968948, + 0.09495703130960464, + 0.059703875333070755, + 0.05348896607756615, + 0.2892264127731323, + 0.06190815940499306, + 0.04758594557642937, + 0.06172439828515053, + 0.11512449383735657 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5762289762496948 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a 360-degree slow-motion shot of a doll rotating around a large, round, dark wooden table visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a house dating back to the early Ming Dynasty with red and yellow paper lanterns hanging from the ceiling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a multi-generational family gathered around the table making dumplings, including an elderly grandmother with silver hair in a bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the family members wearing period-appropriate clothing such as a pastel green silk aoqun for the mother and linen tunics for the father and grandfather?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the hands of the family members shown smeared with white flour while filling and pleating dumpling wrappers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07001548260450363 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950154304504395 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07001548260450363, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07001548260450363, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04710693657398224, + 0.33025720715522766, + 0.06142386794090271, + 0.02731490321457386, + 0.0384373776614666, + 0.07377401739358902, + 0.0638054609298706, + 0.23502716422080994, + 0.047107111662626266, + 0.07574598491191864 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07001548260450363 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a 360-degree slow-motion shot of a doll rotating around a large, round, dark wooden table visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a house dating back to the early Ming Dynasty with red and yellow paper lanterns hanging from the ceiling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a multi-generational family gathered around the table making dumplings, including an elderly grandmother with silver hair in a bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the family members wearing period-appropriate clothing such as a pastel green silk aoqun for the mother and linen tunics for the father and grandfather?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the hands of the family members shown smeared with white flour while filling and pleating dumpling wrappers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04308463633060455 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680846214294434 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04308463633060455, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04308463633060455, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10315386205911636, + 0.16116343438625336, + 0.06752604991197586, + 0.05868609994649887, + 0.06598033010959625, + 0.08306057006120682, + 0.23744602501392365, + 0.05394657328724861, + 0.08707565069198608, + 0.08196141570806503 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04308463633060455 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a 360-degree slow-motion shot of a doll rotating around a large, round, dark wooden table visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a house dating back to the early Ming Dynasty with red and yellow paper lanterns hanging from the ceiling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a multi-generational family gathered around the table making dumplings, including an elderly grandmother with silver hair in a bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the family members wearing period-appropriate clothing such as a pastel green silk aoqun for the mother and linen tunics for the father and grandfather?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the hands of the family members shown smeared with white flour while filling and pleating dumpling wrappers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004102624487131834 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.50410270690918 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004102624487131834, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004102624487131834, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16081830859184265, + 0.07048209756612778, + 0.07835178822278976, + 0.06213150545954704, + 0.06131347641348839, + 0.06142199784517288, + 0.10012568533420563, + 0.11843520402908325, + 0.1920648217201233, + 0.09485505521297455 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004102624487131834 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "360-degree slow-motion doll gracefully rotates around a large, round, dark wooden table, polished to a soft patina by generations of use, situated in the center of a house dating back to the early Ming Dynasty. The entire scene is bathed in the soft, romantic glow of red and yellow paper lanterns hanging from the ceiling beams, casting a warm golden light and creating gently dancing shadows. A multi-generational family gathers around the table, engrossed in the shared ritual of making dumplings. An elderly grandmother, her silver hair tied in an elegant bun and her face lined with wrinkles, demonstrates her pleating technique with nimble, practiced fingers. Beside her, a young mother dressed in a simple silk aoqun in a pastel green, her dark hair held up with a jade hairpin, smiles warmly as she assists her young daughter, her bright, curious eyes focused on the task. A father and grandfather, dressed in simple linen tunics, work quietly and intently, their larger hands moving with surprising gentleness. Their hands, smeared with white flour, moved in beautiful, near-perfect unisons, deftly scooping ground pork and chives onto thin, round wrappers, moistening the edges and pleating them into perfect crescents before lovingly placing them on bamboo plates. A gentle, contented smile graced each face, reflecting the light of the lanterns, creating an atmosphere of profound peace, familial affection, and a tranquil, joyful tradition. In the background, a carved wooden screen and hanging calligraphy scrolls added a touch of period authenticity, completing this intimate portrait of familial harmony.", + "seed": 536, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_7/index_9979_seed_536_dp_15_rank_30_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.2959961585700512, + "vlm_logprob": -0.2959961585700512, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.8, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.2959961585700512, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a 360-degree slow-motion shot of a doll rotating around a large, round, dark wooden table visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a house dating back to the early Ming Dynasty with red and yellow paper lanterns hanging from the ceiling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a multi-generational family gathered around the table making dumplings, including an elderly grandmother with silver hair in a bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the family members wearing period-appropriate clothing such as a pastel green silk aoqun for the mother and linen tunics for the father and grandfather?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the hands of the family members shown smeared with white flour while filling and pleating dumpling wrappers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.38933253288269043 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1393325328826904 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.38933253288269043, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.38933253288269043, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2732904851436615, + 0.05234319344162941, + 0.058592408895492554, + 0.2528797686100006, + 0.080843985080719, + 0.08495625853538513, + 0.08017750084400177, + 0.03357895091176033, + 0.01571829617023468, + 0.06761915981769562 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.38933253288269043 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a 360-degree slow-motion shot of a doll rotating around a large, round, dark wooden table visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a house dating back to the early Ming Dynasty with red and yellow paper lanterns hanging from the ceiling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a multi-generational family gathered around the table making dumplings, including an elderly grandmother with silver hair in a bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the family members wearing period-appropriate clothing such as a pastel green silk aoqun for the mother and linen tunics for the father and grandfather?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the hands of the family members shown smeared with white flour while filling and pleating dumpling wrappers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.0538969039916992 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4288969337940216 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.0538969039916992, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.625, + "token_credit_reward": -1.0538969039916992, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1531904935836792, + 0.0648481473326683, + 0.1268623322248459, + 0.3539021611213684, + 0.03934154659509659, + 0.09740015864372253, + 0.04114909470081329, + 0.04255228117108345, + 0.0391012579202652, + 0.04165257513523102 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.0538969039916992 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a 360-degree slow-motion shot of a doll rotating around a large, round, dark wooden table visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a house dating back to the early Ming Dynasty with red and yellow paper lanterns hanging from the ceiling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a multi-generational family gathered around the table making dumplings, including an elderly grandmother with silver hair in a bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the family members wearing period-appropriate clothing such as a pastel green silk aoqun for the mother and linen tunics for the father and grandfather?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the hands of the family members shown smeared with white flour while filling and pleating dumpling wrappers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012539827264845371 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387539863586426 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012539827264845371, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012539827264845371, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15944230556488037, + 0.04878397658467293, + 0.07728530466556549, + 0.3450387418270111, + 0.0455942265689373, + 0.10405556112527847, + 0.0678500235080719, + 0.08197441697120667, + 0.03587371110916138, + 0.034101780503988266 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012539827264845371 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a 360-degree slow-motion shot of a doll rotating around a large, round, dark wooden table visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a house dating back to the early Ming Dynasty with red and yellow paper lanterns hanging from the ceiling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a multi-generational family gathered around the table making dumplings, including an elderly grandmother with silver hair in a bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the family members wearing period-appropriate clothing such as a pastel green silk aoqun for the mother and linen tunics for the father and grandfather?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the hands of the family members shown smeared with white flour while filling and pleating dumpling wrappers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02059328556060791 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955931663513184 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02059328556060791, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02059328556060791, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21429967880249023, + 0.033978428691625595, + 0.08453042805194855, + 0.24409565329551697, + 0.06845222413539886, + 0.0864420160651207, + 0.06274062395095825, + 0.050668273121118546, + 0.06124338135123253, + 0.09354931116104126 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02059328556060791 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a 360-degree slow-motion shot of a doll rotating around a large, round, dark wooden table visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a house dating back to the early Ming Dynasty with red and yellow paper lanterns hanging from the ceiling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a multi-generational family gathered around the table making dumplings, including an elderly grandmother with silver hair in a bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the family members wearing period-appropriate clothing such as a pastel green silk aoqun for the mother and linen tunics for the father and grandfather?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the hands of the family members shown smeared with white flour while filling and pleating dumpling wrappers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036182431504130363 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628618240356445 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036182431504130363, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036182431504130363, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1906282603740692, + 0.08271773904561996, + 0.2529795467853546, + 0.09498302638530731, + 0.05658533051609993, + 0.059855662286281586, + 0.03528932109475136, + 0.074933260679245, + 0.08152012526988983, + 0.0705077201128006 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036182431504130363 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "360-degree slow-motion doll gracefully rotates around a large, round, dark wooden table, polished to a soft patina by generations of use, situated in the center of a house dating back to the early Ming Dynasty. The entire scene is bathed in the soft, romantic glow of red and yellow paper lanterns hanging from the ceiling beams, casting a warm golden light and creating gently dancing shadows. A multi-generational family gathers around the table, engrossed in the shared ritual of making dumplings. An elderly grandmother, her silver hair tied in an elegant bun and her face lined with wrinkles, demonstrates her pleating technique with nimble, practiced fingers. Beside her, a young mother dressed in a simple silk aoqun in a pastel green, her dark hair held up with a jade hairpin, smiles warmly as she assists her young daughter, her bright, curious eyes focused on the task. A father and grandfather, dressed in simple linen tunics, work quietly and intently, their larger hands moving with surprising gentleness. Their hands, smeared with white flour, moved in beautiful, near-perfect unisons, deftly scooping ground pork and chives onto thin, round wrappers, moistening the edges and pleating them into perfect crescents before lovingly placing them on bamboo plates. A gentle, contented smile graced each face, reflecting the light of the lanterns, creating an atmosphere of profound peace, familial affection, and a tranquil, joyful tradition. In the background, a carved wooden screen and hanging calligraphy scrolls added a touch of period authenticity, completing this intimate portrait of familial harmony.", + "seed": 537, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_7/index_9979_seed_537_dp_15_rank_30_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.34263101425021886, + "vlm_logprob": -0.34263101425021886, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.7, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.34263101425021886, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.6, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a 360-degree slow-motion shot of a doll rotating around a large, round, dark wooden table visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a house dating back to the early Ming Dynasty with red and yellow paper lanterns hanging from the ceiling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a multi-generational family gathered around the table making dumplings, including an elderly grandmother with silver hair in a bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the family members wearing period-appropriate clothing such as a pastel green silk aoqun for the mother and linen tunics for the father and grandfather?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the hands of the family members shown smeared with white flour while filling and pleating dumpling wrappers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7002311944961548 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7002311944961548 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.7002311944961548, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.7002311944961548, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16002650558948517, + 0.06292760372161865, + 0.02783743105828762, + 0.04661283269524574, + 0.11669550091028214, + 0.17163366079330444, + 0.0771573856472969, + 0.02354760654270649, + 0.19163909554481506, + 0.12192234396934509 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.7002311944961548 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a 360-degree slow-motion shot of a doll rotating around a large, round, dark wooden table visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a house dating back to the early Ming Dynasty with red and yellow paper lanterns hanging from the ceiling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a multi-generational family gathered around the table making dumplings, including an elderly grandmother with silver hair in a bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the family members wearing period-appropriate clothing such as a pastel green silk aoqun for the mother and linen tunics for the father and grandfather?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the hands of the family members shown smeared with white flour while filling and pleating dumpling wrappers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9742934107780457 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.47429341077804565 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.9742934107780457, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.9742934107780457, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14480425417423248, + 0.04255708307027817, + 0.03780553117394447, + 0.059719279408454895, + 0.37825945019721985, + 0.08740237355232239, + 0.03606119379401207, + 0.0297772865742445, + 0.06506360322237015, + 0.1185498908162117 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.9742934107780457 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a 360-degree slow-motion shot of a doll rotating around a large, round, dark wooden table visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a house dating back to the early Ming Dynasty with red and yellow paper lanterns hanging from the ceiling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a multi-generational family gathered around the table making dumplings, including an elderly grandmother with silver hair in a bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the family members wearing period-appropriate clothing such as a pastel green silk aoqun for the mother and linen tunics for the father and grandfather?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the hands of the family members shown smeared with white flour while filling and pleating dumpling wrappers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008643240667879581 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.75864315032959 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008643240667879581, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008643240667879581, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11892852932214737, + 0.054143257439136505, + 0.07013007998466492, + 0.11113147437572479, + 0.1542966365814209, + 0.14245742559432983, + 0.05957210808992386, + 0.055237770080566406, + 0.12597322463989258, + 0.10812953114509583 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008643240667879581 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a 360-degree slow-motion shot of a doll rotating around a large, round, dark wooden table visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a house dating back to the early Ming Dynasty with red and yellow paper lanterns hanging from the ceiling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a multi-generational family gathered around the table making dumplings, including an elderly grandmother with silver hair in a bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the family members wearing period-appropriate clothing such as a pastel green silk aoqun for the mother and linen tunics for the father and grandfather?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the hands of the family members shown smeared with white flour while filling and pleating dumpling wrappers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0263676755130291 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651367664337158 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0263676755130291, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0263676755130291, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23230966925621033, + 0.04634925350546837, + 0.0437077172100544, + 0.04775950312614441, + 0.08695966005325317, + 0.06505663692951202, + 0.09009339660406113, + 0.06246909499168396, + 0.10215050727128983, + 0.2231445610523224 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0263676755130291 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a 360-degree slow-motion shot of a doll rotating around a large, round, dark wooden table visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a house dating back to the early Ming Dynasty with red and yellow paper lanterns hanging from the ceiling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a multi-generational family gathered around the table making dumplings, including an elderly grandmother with silver hair in a bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the family members wearing period-appropriate clothing such as a pastel green silk aoqun for the mother and linen tunics for the father and grandfather?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the hands of the family members shown smeared with white flour while filling and pleating dumpling wrappers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003619549795985222 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.62861967086792 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003619549795985222, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003619549795985222, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16804614663124084, + 0.05837173014879227, + 0.041680943220853806, + 0.03568422049283981, + 0.19071047008037567, + 0.14417044818401337, + 0.09988723695278168, + 0.05333125963807106, + 0.09180416166782379, + 0.11631333082914352 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003619549795985222 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_8/index_tensor([175, 175])_group_8_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_8/index_tensor([175, 175])_group_8_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..15ffd2f2d1d2756b150f167a523858436d19411b --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_8/index_tensor([175, 175])_group_8_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "An epic, ultra-long, static shot, captured from a distant, eye-level perspective, captures the majestic spectacle of Chongqing's futuristic skyscrapers rising resolutely through a sea of swirling clouds. The entire city skyline is rendered in a bold, flat, blocky vector art style. Building outlines are simplified into clean, geometric shapes, their surfaces a pure palette of deep blue, cool gray, and bright cyan, devoid of texture or gradient. Towering spires decisively pierce the cloud cover. Below, dense, stylized clouds, like layers of smooth white and light gray, overlap with streamlined edges, forming a dynamic ocean that completely obscures the famous confluence of the two rivers, creating a surreal illusion of the city suspended in the sky. The image's clean composition and even, diffuse lighting, devoid of defined light sources or shadows, further emphasize the purity of form and color. The resulting visual spectacle is serene, majestic, and highly designed, imbued with a simple yet spectacular futuristic spirit.", + "seed": 5063, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_8/index_175_seed_5063_dp_16_rank_32_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.12190949113573879, + "vlm_logprob": -0.12190949113573879, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.625, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.12190949113573879, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a city skyline featuring futuristic skyscrapers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a bold, flat, blocky vector art style with clean geometric shapes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the building surfaces rendered in deep blue, cool gray, and bright cyan without texture or gradient?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lower portion of the scene filled with dense, stylized white and light gray clouds obscuring the rivers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static, distant, and at eye-level perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036320213694125414 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.878632068634033 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036320213694125414, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036320213694125414, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18238644301891327, + 0.26191407442092896, + 0.03166060894727707, + 0.06863047182559967, + 0.19939973950386047, + 0.037108711898326874, + 0.07455700635910034, + 0.050086669623851776, + 0.04444846883416176, + 0.04980775713920593 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036320213694125414 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a city skyline featuring futuristic skyscrapers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a bold, flat, blocky vector art style with clean geometric shapes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the building surfaces rendered in deep blue, cool gray, and bright cyan without texture or gradient?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lower portion of the scene filled with dense, stylized white and light gray clouds obscuring the rivers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static, distant, and at eye-level perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0013427060330286622 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.6263427734375 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0013427060330286622, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0013427060330286622, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1262912154197693, + 0.15535075962543488, + 0.08125646412372589, + 0.05085903778672218, + 0.31478995084762573, + 0.11862626671791077, + 0.03764745593070984, + 0.053667277097702026, + 0.029306162148714066, + 0.03220544010400772 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0013427060330286622 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a city skyline featuring futuristic skyscrapers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a bold, flat, blocky vector art style with clean geometric shapes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the building surfaces rendered in deep blue, cool gray, and bright cyan without texture or gradient?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lower portion of the scene filled with dense, stylized white and light gray clouds obscuring the rivers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static, distant, and at eye-level perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04865625500679016 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486562252044678 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04865625500679016, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04865625500679016, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1235002800822258, + 0.17432533204555511, + 0.094215027987957, + 0.06694486737251282, + 0.23909685015678406, + 0.09607049077749252, + 0.09340520948171616, + 0.04840296879410744, + 0.028633257374167442, + 0.03540566563606262 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04865625500679016 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a city skyline featuring futuristic skyscrapers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a bold, flat, blocky vector art style with clean geometric shapes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the building surfaces rendered in deep blue, cool gray, and bright cyan without texture or gradient?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lower portion of the scene filled with dense, stylized white and light gray clouds obscuring the rivers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static, distant, and at eye-level perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12703220546245575 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1270322799682617 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12703220546245575, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12703220546245575, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23614703118801117, + 0.17949266731739044, + 0.05542144179344177, + 0.05361473932862282, + 0.16502876579761505, + 0.08438139408826828, + 0.06355099380016327, + 0.09982062876224518, + 0.020136363804340363, + 0.04240594059228897 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12703220546245575 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a city skyline featuring futuristic skyscrapers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a bold, flat, blocky vector art style with clean geometric shapes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the building surfaces rendered in deep blue, cool gray, and bright cyan without texture or gradient?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lower portion of the scene filled with dense, stylized white and light gray clouds obscuring the rivers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static, distant, and at eye-level perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.42888426780700684 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.0538842678070068 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.42888426780700684, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.42888426780700684, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11705151945352554, + 0.21664495766162872, + 0.07221771031618118, + 0.13610759377479553, + 0.06342674791812897, + 0.056947238743305206, + 0.19312357902526855, + 0.045099034905433655, + 0.06741389632225037, + 0.03196768835186958 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 6, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.42888426780700684 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An epic, ultra-long, static shot, captured from a distant, eye-level perspective, captures the majestic spectacle of Chongqing's futuristic skyscrapers rising resolutely through a sea of swirling clouds. The entire city skyline is rendered in a bold, flat, blocky vector art style. Building outlines are simplified into clean, geometric shapes, their surfaces a pure palette of deep blue, cool gray, and bright cyan, devoid of texture or gradient. Towering spires decisively pierce the cloud cover. Below, dense, stylized clouds, like layers of smooth white and light gray, overlap with streamlined edges, forming a dynamic ocean that completely obscures the famous confluence of the two rivers, creating a surreal illusion of the city suspended in the sky. The image's clean composition and even, diffuse lighting, devoid of defined light sources or shadows, further emphasize the purity of form and color. The resulting visual spectacle is serene, majestic, and highly designed, imbued with a simple yet spectacular futuristic spirit.", + "seed": 5064, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_8/index_175_seed_5064_dp_16_rank_32_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.2111281394958496, + "vlm_logprob": -0.2111281394958496, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.899999988079071, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.2111281394958496, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a city skyline featuring futuristic skyscrapers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a bold, flat, blocky vector art style with clean geometric shapes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the building surfaces rendered in deep blue, cool gray, and bright cyan without texture or gradient?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lower portion of the scene filled with dense, stylized white and light gray clouds obscuring the rivers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static, distant, and at eye-level perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14325259625911713 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0182526111602783 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14325259625911713, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14325259625911713, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.176954448223114, + 0.12177976965904236, + 0.045229099690914154, + 0.06974577158689499, + 0.05880160629749298, + 0.13500726222991943, + 0.2730361223220825, + 0.05101444572210312, + 0.046560533344745636, + 0.02187100052833557 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14325259625911713 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a city skyline featuring futuristic skyscrapers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a bold, flat, blocky vector art style with clean geometric shapes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the building surfaces rendered in deep blue, cool gray, and bright cyan without texture or gradient?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lower portion of the scene filled with dense, stylized white and light gray clouds obscuring the rivers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static, distant, and at eye-level perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026360243558883667 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651360273361206 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026360243558883667, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026360243558883667, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2098613977432251, + 0.17167845368385315, + 0.051435403525829315, + 0.17081597447395325, + 0.040943387895822525, + 0.07054148614406586, + 0.11663718521595001, + 0.11126939207315445, + 0.028059735894203186, + 0.02875753864645958 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026360243558883667 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a city skyline featuring futuristic skyscrapers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a bold, flat, blocky vector art style with clean geometric shapes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the building surfaces rendered in deep blue, cool gray, and bright cyan without texture or gradient?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lower portion of the scene filled with dense, stylized white and light gray clouds obscuring the rivers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static, distant, and at eye-level perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3870842456817627 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1370842456817627 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3870842456817627, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3870842456817627, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13540911674499512, + 0.11172406375408173, + 0.07378649711608887, + 0.1349528580904007, + 0.06969524919986725, + 0.16262724995613098, + 0.09612464159727097, + 0.126336008310318, + 0.04555515944957733, + 0.04378918558359146 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3870842456817627 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a city skyline featuring futuristic skyscrapers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a bold, flat, blocky vector art style with clean geometric shapes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the building surfaces rendered in deep blue, cool gray, and bright cyan without texture or gradient?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lower portion of the scene filled with dense, stylized white and light gray clouds obscuring the rivers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static, distant, and at eye-level perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0700213760137558 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695021390914917 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0700213760137558, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0700213760137558, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10449770838022232, + 0.08896493166685104, + 0.04005784913897514, + 0.10273588448762894, + 0.1018512174487114, + 0.1534600853919983, + 0.18182525038719177, + 0.1150171160697937, + 0.06689766049385071, + 0.04469234496355057 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0700213760137558 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a city skyline featuring futuristic skyscrapers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a bold, flat, blocky vector art style with clean geometric shapes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the building surfaces rendered in deep blue, cool gray, and bright cyan without texture or gradient?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lower portion of the scene filled with dense, stylized white and light gray clouds obscuring the rivers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static, distant, and at eye-level perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.42892223596572876 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.053922176361084 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.42892223596572876, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.6249999403953552, + "token_credit_reward": -0.42892223596572876, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20652391016483307, + 0.16921772062778473, + 0.06629370152950287, + 0.11103473603725433, + 0.08925934880971909, + 0.06216290220618248, + 0.06946752220392227, + 0.07218421995639801, + 0.07117211073637009, + 0.08268377184867859 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.42892223596572876 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An epic, ultra-long, static shot, captured from a distant, eye-level perspective, captures the majestic spectacle of Chongqing's futuristic skyscrapers rising resolutely through a sea of swirling clouds. The entire city skyline is rendered in a bold, flat, blocky vector art style. Building outlines are simplified into clean, geometric shapes, their surfaces a pure palette of deep blue, cool gray, and bright cyan, devoid of texture or gradient. Towering spires decisively pierce the cloud cover. Below, dense, stylized clouds, like layers of smooth white and light gray, overlap with streamlined edges, forming a dynamic ocean that completely obscures the famous confluence of the two rivers, creating a surreal illusion of the city suspended in the sky. The image's clean composition and even, diffuse lighting, devoid of defined light sources or shadows, further emphasize the purity of form and color. The resulting visual spectacle is serene, majestic, and highly designed, imbued with a simple yet spectacular futuristic spirit.", + "seed": 5065, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_8/index_175_seed_5065_dp_17_rank_34_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.09476890831720083, + "vlm_logprob": -0.09476890831720083, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.15, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.09476890831720083, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a city skyline featuring futuristic skyscrapers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a bold, flat, blocky vector art style with clean geometric shapes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the building surfaces rendered in deep blue, cool gray, and bright cyan without texture or gradient?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lower portion of the scene filled with dense, stylized white and light gray clouds obscuring the rivers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static, distant, and at eye-level perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02097403071820736 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8959739208221436 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02097403071820736, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02097403071820736, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21460697054862976, + 0.09555313736200333, + 0.12048971652984619, + 0.06079765781760216, + 0.05639679729938507, + 0.17700619995594025, + 0.08334504812955856, + 0.0655805841088295, + 0.10876762866973877, + 0.017456304281949997 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02097403071820736 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a city skyline featuring futuristic skyscrapers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a bold, flat, blocky vector art style with clean geometric shapes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the building surfaces rendered in deep blue, cool gray, and bright cyan without texture or gradient?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lower portion of the scene filled with dense, stylized white and light gray clouds obscuring the rivers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static, distant, and at eye-level perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.001948483637534082 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.251948356628418 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.001948483637534082, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.001948483637534082, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18551133573055267, + 0.049648549407720566, + 0.15762344002723694, + 0.046051498502492905, + 0.24121904373168945, + 0.03949734941124916, + 0.029412878677248955, + 0.09475434571504593, + 0.037669215351343155, + 0.11861233413219452 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.001948483637534082 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a city skyline featuring futuristic skyscrapers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a bold, flat, blocky vector art style with clean geometric shapes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the building surfaces rendered in deep blue, cool gray, and bright cyan without texture or gradient?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lower portion of the scene filled with dense, stylized white and light gray clouds obscuring the rivers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static, distant, and at eye-level perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08903804421424866 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.464038133621216 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08903804421424866, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08903804421424866, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2007197141647339, + 0.1366148591041565, + 0.13625460863113403, + 0.10075827687978745, + 0.11675860732793808, + 0.13599492609500885, + 0.021693887189030647, + 0.08324258029460907, + 0.030307773500680923, + 0.037654779851436615 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08903804421424866 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a city skyline featuring futuristic skyscrapers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a bold, flat, blocky vector art style with clean geometric shapes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the building surfaces rendered in deep blue, cool gray, and bright cyan without texture or gradient?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lower portion of the scene filled with dense, stylized white and light gray clouds obscuring the rivers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static, distant, and at eye-level perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16034424304962158 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9103442430496216 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16034424304962158, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16034424304962158, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1391301453113556, + 0.17374391853809357, + 0.057893529534339905, + 0.04620647802948952, + 0.29888659715652466, + 0.07688390463590622, + 0.03530703857541084, + 0.08197033405303955, + 0.024656757712364197, + 0.06532128155231476 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16034424304962158 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a city skyline featuring futuristic skyscrapers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a bold, flat, blocky vector art style with clean geometric shapes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the building surfaces rendered in deep blue, cool gray, and bright cyan without texture or gradient?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lower portion of the scene filled with dense, stylized white and light gray clouds obscuring the rivers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static, distant, and at eye-level perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20153973996639252 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7015397548675537 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20153973996639252, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20153973996639252, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07141661643981934, + 0.06740884482860565, + 0.030316701158881187, + 0.06371094286441803, + 0.3099985718727112, + 0.02583743818104267, + 0.03194519504904747, + 0.14995445311069489, + 0.05985584110021591, + 0.18955540657043457 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20153973996639252 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An epic, ultra-long, static shot, captured from a distant, eye-level perspective, captures the majestic spectacle of Chongqing's futuristic skyscrapers rising resolutely through a sea of swirling clouds. The entire city skyline is rendered in a bold, flat, blocky vector art style. Building outlines are simplified into clean, geometric shapes, their surfaces a pure palette of deep blue, cool gray, and bright cyan, devoid of texture or gradient. Towering spires decisively pierce the cloud cover. Below, dense, stylized clouds, like layers of smooth white and light gray, overlap with streamlined edges, forming a dynamic ocean that completely obscures the famous confluence of the two rivers, creating a surreal illusion of the city suspended in the sky. The image's clean composition and even, diffuse lighting, devoid of defined light sources or shadows, further emphasize the purity of form and color. The resulting visual spectacle is serene, majestic, and highly designed, imbued with a simple yet spectacular futuristic spirit.", + "seed": 5066, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_8/index_175_seed_5066_dp_17_rank_34_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.1647764017805457, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1647764017805457, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.025, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1647764017805457, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a city skyline featuring futuristic skyscrapers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a bold, flat, blocky vector art style with clean geometric shapes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the building surfaces rendered in deep blue, cool gray, and bright cyan without texture or gradient?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lower portion of the scene filled with dense, stylized white and light gray clouds obscuring the rivers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static, distant, and at eye-level perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004250421188771725 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.629250526428223 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004250421188771725, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004250421188771725, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16247141361236572, + 0.04704204201698303, + 0.0654478669166565, + 0.062180135399103165, + 0.02887299656867981, + 0.04079470410943031, + 0.028580613434314728, + 0.0665864571928978, + 0.3964078724384308, + 0.10161585360765457 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004250421188771725 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a city skyline featuring futuristic skyscrapers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a bold, flat, blocky vector art style with clean geometric shapes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the building surfaces rendered in deep blue, cool gray, and bright cyan without texture or gradient?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lower portion of the scene filled with dense, stylized white and light gray clouds obscuring the rivers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static, distant, and at eye-level perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008650686591863632 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758650779724121 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008650686591863632, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008650686591863632, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04276134818792343, + 0.07248522341251373, + 0.05131953954696655, + 0.15761874616146088, + 0.02192513830959797, + 0.022404111921787262, + 0.03762565553188324, + 0.022681521251797676, + 0.5321269035339355, + 0.03905174136161804 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008650686591863632 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a city skyline featuring futuristic skyscrapers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a bold, flat, blocky vector art style with clean geometric shapes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the building surfaces rendered in deep blue, cool gray, and bright cyan without texture or gradient?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lower portion of the scene filled with dense, stylized white and light gray clouds obscuring the rivers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static, distant, and at eye-level perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17988358438014984 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.804883599281311 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17988358438014984, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17988358438014984, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.030815578997135162, + 0.032356467097997665, + 0.19105933606624603, + 0.15507401525974274, + 0.04109766706824303, + 0.01865692250430584, + 0.03114577941596508, + 0.0180406142026186, + 0.46492382884025574, + 0.016829706728458405 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17988358438014984 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a city skyline featuring futuristic skyscrapers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a bold, flat, blocky vector art style with clean geometric shapes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the building surfaces rendered in deep blue, cool gray, and bright cyan without texture or gradient?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lower portion of the scene filled with dense, stylized white and light gray clouds obscuring the rivers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static, distant, and at eye-level perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.054941773414611816 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299416542053223 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.054941773414611816, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.054941773414611816, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1263238489627838, + 0.06667149066925049, + 0.24542783200740814, + 0.05332759767770767, + 0.01424368005245924, + 0.039615292102098465, + 0.039481885731220245, + 0.2048671841621399, + 0.08016394823789597, + 0.12987729907035828 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.054941773414611816 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a city skyline featuring futuristic skyscrapers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a bold, flat, blocky vector art style with clean geometric shapes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the building surfaces rendered in deep blue, cool gray, and bright cyan without texture or gradient?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lower portion of the scene filled with dense, stylized white and light gray clouds obscuring the rivers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static, distant, and at eye-level perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5761555433273315 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8261555433273315 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5761555433273315, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5761555433273315, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05557839199900627, + 0.07575935870409012, + 0.22443990409374237, + 0.13548411428928375, + 0.04226647689938545, + 0.0635240450501442, + 0.16135716438293457, + 0.04330061748623848, + 0.16983532905578613, + 0.028454605489969254 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5761555433273315 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_9/index_tensor([9990, 9990])_group_9_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_9/index_tensor([9990, 9990])_group_9_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..339c7a95de346538cbfffac4fffc2b6d96c67561 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_9/index_tensor([9990, 9990])_group_9_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "close-up shot from the ground, shot upward, locks the viewer's gaze firmly into the heart of a bustling Chinese lumber mill in the 1950s. In the center of the frame, an old-fashioned circular saw, constructed of heavy cast iron and stained with oil and the scratches of time, churns at full speed. Its massive, razor-sharp circular blade blurs into a disc gleaming with a menacing silver gleam at its hyperspeed. A thick, rough-grained pine board is steadily pushed against the saw blade, and the moment they make contact, the blade violently slices into the wood, sending a shower of wood chips flying through the air. A dim, dust-laden shaft of light slants down from a high window in the workshop, illuminating the area and casting a dense, violent cascade of wood chips toward and around the camera like vibrant golden snowflakes, a scene imbued with a chaotic and spectacular dynamic beauty. The scene, shrouded in a warm palette of the deep brown of the wood, the dull gray of the machinery, and the bright yellow of the flying chips, creates an atmosphere of intense, focused intensity, both jarring and raw, industrial power.", + "seed": 15762, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_9/index_9990_seed_15762_dp_18_rank_36_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.2594342611730099, + "vlm_logprob": -0.2594342611730099, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.525000011920929, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.2594342611730099, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at ground level looking upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an old-fashioned circular saw made of heavy cast iron visible in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a thick, rough-grained pine board being pushed against the saw blade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are wood chips flying through the air in a shower or cascade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a dim, dust-laden shaft of light slanting down from a high window visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1491022109985352 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.39910227060317993 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.1491022109985352, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.7499999403953552, + "token_credit_reward": -1.1491022109985352, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09765572100877762, + 0.050330810248851776, + 0.06066954508423805, + 0.09169988334178925, + 0.362150102853775, + 0.05445164442062378, + 0.07847204804420471, + 0.07220534980297089, + 0.09936144202947617, + 0.03300341218709946 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.1491022109985352 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at ground level looking upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an old-fashioned circular saw made of heavy cast iron visible in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a thick, rough-grained pine board being pushed against the saw blade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are wood chips flying through the air in a shower or cascade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a dim, dust-laden shaft of light slanting down from a high window visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03814342990517616 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881433963775635 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03814342990517616, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03814342990517616, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06082677096128464, + 0.09556125849485397, + 0.35391998291015625, + 0.08842507004737854, + 0.17486277222633362, + 0.036703046411275864, + 0.027764787897467613, + 0.06507303565740585, + 0.0658196285367012, + 0.031043604016304016 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03814342990517616 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at ground level looking upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an old-fashioned circular saw made of heavy cast iron visible in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a thick, rough-grained pine board being pushed against the saw blade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are wood chips flying through the air in a shower or cascade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a dim, dust-laden shaft of light slanting down from a high window visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04307401925325394 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168074131011963 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04307401925325394, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04307401925325394, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05452817305922508, + 0.021272581070661545, + 0.06574273854494095, + 0.059300996363162994, + 0.49240541458129883, + 0.05165974795818329, + 0.01775551401078701, + 0.04372255876660347, + 0.16538162529468536, + 0.02823059633374214 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04307401925325394 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at ground level looking upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an old-fashioned circular saw made of heavy cast iron visible in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a thick, rough-grained pine board being pushed against the saw blade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are wood chips flying through the air in a shower or cascade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a dim, dust-laden shaft of light slanting down from a high window visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018195733428001404 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018195629119873 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018195733428001404, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018195733428001404, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07517185062170029, + 0.02322857268154621, + 0.03552386909723282, + 0.029851695522665977, + 0.11314783245325089, + 0.03763732314109802, + 0.015101300552487373, + 0.04684693366289139, + 0.5627607107162476, + 0.06072995066642761 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018195733428001404 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at ground level looking upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an old-fashioned circular saw made of heavy cast iron visible in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a thick, rough-grained pine board being pushed against the saw blade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are wood chips flying through the air in a shower or cascade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a dim, dust-laden shaft of light slanting down from a high window visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0486559122800827 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486559867858887 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0486559122800827, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0486559122800827, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04715411365032196, + 0.03267168253660202, + 0.04453366994857788, + 0.08192112296819687, + 0.2016218602657318, + 0.05717962980270386, + 0.16510340571403503, + 0.06808937340974808, + 0.09362421184778214, + 0.20810090005397797 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0486559122800827 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up shot from the ground, shot upward, locks the viewer's gaze firmly into the heart of a bustling Chinese lumber mill in the 1950s. In the center of the frame, an old-fashioned circular saw, constructed of heavy cast iron and stained with oil and the scratches of time, churns at full speed. Its massive, razor-sharp circular blade blurs into a disc gleaming with a menacing silver gleam at its hyperspeed. A thick, rough-grained pine board is steadily pushed against the saw blade, and the moment they make contact, the blade violently slices into the wood, sending a shower of wood chips flying through the air. A dim, dust-laden shaft of light slants down from a high window in the workshop, illuminating the area and casting a dense, violent cascade of wood chips toward and around the camera like vibrant golden snowflakes, a scene imbued with a chaotic and spectacular dynamic beauty. The scene, shrouded in a warm palette of the deep brown of the wood, the dull gray of the machinery, and the bright yellow of the flying chips, creates an atmosphere of intense, focused intensity, both jarring and raw, industrial power.", + "seed": 15763, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_9/index_9990_seed_15763_dp_18_rank_36_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.2088734157383442, + "vlm_logprob": -0.2088734157383442, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.625, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.2088734157383442, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at ground level looking upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an old-fashioned circular saw made of heavy cast iron visible in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a thick, rough-grained pine board being pushed against the saw blade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are wood chips flying through the air in a shower or cascade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a dim, dust-laden shaft of light slanting down from a high window visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8605595231056213 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6105595231056213 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.8605595231056213, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.8605595231056213, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3041354715824127, + 0.06637797504663467, + 0.05041712895035744, + 0.03827442601323128, + 0.1748189479112625, + 0.05124478414654732, + 0.15255165100097656, + 0.0724864974617958, + 0.028836369514465332, + 0.06085669621825218 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.8605595231056213 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at ground level looking upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an old-fashioned circular saw made of heavy cast iron visible in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a thick, rough-grained pine board being pushed against the saw blade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are wood chips flying through the air in a shower or cascade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a dim, dust-laden shaft of light slanting down from a high window visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.048704396933317184 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0487043857574463 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.048704396933317184, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.048704396933317184, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10235560685396194, + 0.5708873271942139, + 0.04545430839061737, + 0.04405899718403816, + 0.023874470964074135, + 0.01934586837887764, + 0.062460340559482574, + 0.04610949382185936, + 0.029742253944277763, + 0.05571138486266136 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.048704396933317184 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at ground level looking upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an old-fashioned circular saw made of heavy cast iron visible in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a thick, rough-grained pine board being pushed against the saw blade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are wood chips flying through the air in a shower or cascade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a dim, dust-laden shaft of light slanting down from a high window visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02059001475572586 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.89559006690979 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02059001475572586, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02059001475572586, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.40467339754104614, + 0.05010543763637543, + 0.03137243911623955, + 0.031857408583164215, + 0.11530172824859619, + 0.05232701823115349, + 0.04438914358615875, + 0.048488110303878784, + 0.09265147894620895, + 0.1288338154554367 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02059001475572586 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at ground level looking upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an old-fashioned circular saw made of heavy cast iron visible in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a thick, rough-grained pine board being pushed against the saw blade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are wood chips flying through the air in a shower or cascade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a dim, dust-laden shaft of light slanting down from a high window visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01420411467552185 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264204025268555 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01420411467552185, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01420411467552185, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14540478587150574, + 0.04655889421701431, + 0.019077125936746597, + 0.12523867189884186, + 0.36300209164619446, + 0.04319579526782036, + 0.05826625972986221, + 0.03683546185493469, + 0.08526961505413055, + 0.07715141028165817 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01420411467552185 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at ground level looking upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an old-fashioned circular saw made of heavy cast iron visible in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a thick, rough-grained pine board being pushed against the saw blade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are wood chips flying through the air in a shower or cascade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a dim, dust-laden shaft of light slanting down from a high window visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10030902922153473 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.350309133529663 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10030902922153473, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10030902922153473, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19856782257556915, + 0.10727132111787796, + 0.10418852418661118, + 0.05863730609416962, + 0.16574661433696747, + 0.14629840850830078, + 0.04876892268657684, + 0.0624510832130909, + 0.03142032027244568, + 0.07664965838193893 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10030902922153473 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up shot from the ground, shot upward, locks the viewer's gaze firmly into the heart of a bustling Chinese lumber mill in the 1950s. In the center of the frame, an old-fashioned circular saw, constructed of heavy cast iron and stained with oil and the scratches of time, churns at full speed. Its massive, razor-sharp circular blade blurs into a disc gleaming with a menacing silver gleam at its hyperspeed. A thick, rough-grained pine board is steadily pushed against the saw blade, and the moment they make contact, the blade violently slices into the wood, sending a shower of wood chips flying through the air. A dim, dust-laden shaft of light slants down from a high window in the workshop, illuminating the area and casting a dense, violent cascade of wood chips toward and around the camera like vibrant golden snowflakes, a scene imbued with a chaotic and spectacular dynamic beauty. The scene, shrouded in a warm palette of the deep brown of the wood, the dull gray of the machinery, and the bright yellow of the flying chips, creates an atmosphere of intense, focused intensity, both jarring and raw, industrial power.", + "seed": 15764, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_9/index_9990_seed_15764_dp_19_rank_38_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.2712990216910839, + "vlm_logprob": -0.2712990216910839, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.875, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.2712990216910839, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at ground level looking upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an old-fashioned circular saw made of heavy cast iron visible in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a thick, rough-grained pine board being pushed against the saw blade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are wood chips flying through the air in a shower or cascade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a dim, dust-laden shaft of light slanting down from a high window visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2341666221618652 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3591666519641876 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.2341666221618652, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -1.2341666221618652, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09265680611133575, + 0.1836632788181305, + 0.05502057820558548, + 0.11102067679166794, + 0.061898451298475266, + 0.09805668890476227, + 0.0407412014901638, + 0.06845515221357346, + 0.17279097437858582, + 0.11569616943597794 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.2341666221618652 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at ground level looking upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an old-fashioned circular saw made of heavy cast iron visible in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a thick, rough-grained pine board being pushed against the saw blade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are wood chips flying through the air in a shower or cascade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a dim, dust-laden shaft of light slanting down from a high window visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.054976072162389755 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929975986480713 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.054976072162389755, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.054976072162389755, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05358691141009331, + 0.410264790058136, + 0.07060170918703079, + 0.09137734025716782, + 0.06199977919459343, + 0.11788610368967056, + 0.028974132612347603, + 0.03510533645749092, + 0.05061425641179085, + 0.07958965003490448 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.054976072162389755 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at ground level looking upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an old-fashioned circular saw made of heavy cast iron visible in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a thick, rough-grained pine board being pushed against the saw blade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are wood chips flying through the air in a shower or cascade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a dim, dust-laden shaft of light slanting down from a high window visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011076509952545166 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.5110764503479 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011076509952545166, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011076509952545166, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.060917794704437256, + 0.1544715315103531, + 0.19694934785366058, + 0.2163684368133545, + 0.05576806142926216, + 0.11631859838962555, + 0.029450420290231705, + 0.03717369958758354, + 0.042741186916828156, + 0.0898408591747284 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011076509952545166 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at ground level looking upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an old-fashioned circular saw made of heavy cast iron visible in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a thick, rough-grained pine board being pushed against the saw blade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are wood chips flying through the air in a shower or cascade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a dim, dust-laden shaft of light slanting down from a high window visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007629185914993286 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.88262939453125 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007629185914993286, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007629185914993286, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05736502632498741, + 0.08964807540178299, + 0.08160897344350815, + 0.027135035023093224, + 0.080494724214077, + 0.07244696468114853, + 0.03613096475601196, + 0.06715109199285507, + 0.3868553340435028, + 0.10116380453109741 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007629185914993286 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at ground level looking upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an old-fashioned circular saw made of heavy cast iron visible in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a thick, rough-grained pine board being pushed against the saw blade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are wood chips flying through the air in a shower or cascade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a dim, dust-laden shaft of light slanting down from a high window visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0486467182636261 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486466884613037 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0486467182636261, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0486467182636261, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06214655935764313, + 0.1520862877368927, + 0.16480234265327454, + 0.07687882333993912, + 0.24634189903736115, + 0.06776183098554611, + 0.01962088979780674, + 0.03731406107544899, + 0.12065960466861725, + 0.05238766968250275 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0486467182636261 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up shot from the ground, shot upward, locks the viewer's gaze firmly into the heart of a bustling Chinese lumber mill in the 1950s. In the center of the frame, an old-fashioned circular saw, constructed of heavy cast iron and stained with oil and the scratches of time, churns at full speed. Its massive, razor-sharp circular blade blurs into a disc gleaming with a menacing silver gleam at its hyperspeed. A thick, rough-grained pine board is steadily pushed against the saw blade, and the moment they make contact, the blade violently slices into the wood, sending a shower of wood chips flying through the air. A dim, dust-laden shaft of light slants down from a high window in the workshop, illuminating the area and casting a dense, violent cascade of wood chips toward and around the camera like vibrant golden snowflakes, a scene imbued with a chaotic and spectacular dynamic beauty. The scene, shrouded in a warm palette of the deep brown of the wood, the dull gray of the machinery, and the bright yellow of the flying chips, creates an atmosphere of intense, focused intensity, both jarring and raw, industrial power.", + "seed": 15765, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000149/group_9/index_9990_seed_15765_dp_19_rank_38_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.30589780360460284, + "vlm_logprob": -0.30589780360460284, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.075, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.30589780360460284, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at ground level looking upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an old-fashioned circular saw made of heavy cast iron visible in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a thick, rough-grained pine board being pushed against the saw blade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are wood chips flying through the air in a shower or cascade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a dim, dust-laden shaft of light slanting down from a high window visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.25490403175354 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.37990403175354004 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.25490403175354, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -1.25490403175354, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5250753164291382, + 0.04542826488614082, + 0.03024391643702984, + 0.038934141397476196, + 0.04782961681485176, + 0.04072117805480957, + 0.033917032182216644, + 0.011144790798425674, + 0.0843171626329422, + 0.14238859713077545 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.25490403175354 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at ground level looking upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an old-fashioned circular saw made of heavy cast iron visible in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a thick, rough-grained pine board being pushed against the saw blade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are wood chips flying through the air in a shower or cascade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a dim, dust-laden shaft of light slanting down from a high window visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03373613581061363 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408736228942871 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03373613581061363, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03373613581061363, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4321596324443817, + 0.12893977761268616, + 0.12246245890855789, + 0.04108657315373421, + 0.05783253163099289, + 0.03439920023083687, + 0.07533411681652069, + 0.023487213999032974, + 0.04765408858656883, + 0.036644428968429565 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03373613581061363 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at ground level looking upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an old-fashioned circular saw made of heavy cast iron visible in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a thick, rough-grained pine board being pushed against the saw blade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are wood chips flying through the air in a shower or cascade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a dim, dust-laden shaft of light slanting down from a high window visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04306533932685852 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168065309524536 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04306533932685852, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04306533932685852, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.7148950099945068, + 0.019693782553076744, + 0.013099076226353645, + 0.02193000540137291, + 0.07277454435825348, + 0.022427616640925407, + 0.015195459127426147, + 0.007004288490861654, + 0.04613406956195831, + 0.06684613972902298 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04306533932685852 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at ground level looking upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an old-fashioned circular saw made of heavy cast iron visible in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a thick, rough-grained pine board being pushed against the saw blade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are wood chips flying through the air in a shower or cascade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a dim, dust-laden shaft of light slanting down from a high window visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.054968174546957016 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299681186676025 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.054968174546957016, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.054968174546957016, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4391992688179016, + 0.019730694591999054, + 0.03556305915117264, + 0.014814171008765697, + 0.03121046908199787, + 0.028111359104514122, + 0.023728888481855392, + 0.016672056168317795, + 0.1681082844734192, + 0.22286175191402435 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.054968174546957016 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at ground level looking upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an old-fashioned circular saw made of heavy cast iron visible in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a thick, rough-grained pine board being pushed against the saw blade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are wood chips flying through the air in a shower or cascade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a dim, dust-laden shaft of light slanting down from a high window visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14281533658504486 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.017815351486206 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14281533658504486, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14281533658504486, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.713162362575531, + 0.027995022013783455, + 0.05768352001905441, + 0.04100845754146576, + 0.02133515290915966, + 0.008879238739609718, + 0.010779749602079391, + 0.009136178530752659, + 0.025653833523392677, + 0.0843665674328804 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14281533658504486 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_0/index_tensor([3190, 3190])_group_0_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_0/index_tensor([3190, 3190])_group_0_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..683cef4c6b57a965c79042ebb6d723e62594052d --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_0/index_tensor([3190, 3190])_group_0_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "Inspired by traditional Japanese aesthetics, a low-angle, full-shot shot slowly pans forward, focusing on a lone figure standing defiantly amidst a catastrophic urban flood. The figure is adorned with the ornate Sacra Umbra Armor, a masterpiece of darkly painted metal plates intricately connected by deep blue silk thread. The helmet, a formidable kabuto, features a menacing, full-face man-yorai mask that conceals all features, its metallic scowl fixed against the floodwaters. Rain pours down like a thick downpour, flowing over the armor's polished, obsidian-like surface, beading like tiny gems before cascading into the churning waters below. The figure stands waist-deep in raging, murky water, which swirls powerfully around their legs. In the background, the submerged cityscape is a chaotic mix of modern high-rises and traditional buildings, their lower halves engulfed by the floodwaters. The entire scene is lit almost entirely from below by the lights of underwater buildings and neon signs, which flicker ominously beneath the turbulent surface, casting a ghostly, refracted glow of electric blues and garish reds. This otherworldly underwater light creates deep, dramatic shadows that stretch and twist across the rising waters, painting a scene of somber, apocalyptic grandeur, while the figure remains completely motionless, a stoic fortress of shadow and steel against the raging storm.", + "seed": 19671, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_0/index_3190_seed_19671_dp_0_rank_0_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.21168134231120347, + "vlm_logprob": -0.21168134231120347, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.475, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.21168134231120347, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle full-shot that slowly pans forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure wearing darkly painted metal armor plates connected by deep blue silk thread?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the figure wear a kabuto helmet with a full-face man-yorai mask that conceals all facial features?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit primarily from below by underwater building lights and neon signs casting electric blue and red glows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the figure standing completely motionless in waist-deep, churning, murky floodwater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.18869444727897644 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8136944770812988 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.18869444727897644, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.18869444727897644, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12655091285705566, + 0.04362158477306366, + 0.16001620888710022, + 0.056590646505355835, + 0.04720405489206314, + 0.2480321228504181, + 0.05821800231933594, + 0.05609246715903282, + 0.10651370882987976, + 0.09716030955314636 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.18869444727897644 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle full-shot that slowly pans forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure wearing darkly painted metal armor plates connected by deep blue silk thread?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the figure wear a kabuto helmet with a full-face man-yorai mask that conceals all facial features?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit primarily from below by underwater building lights and neon signs casting electric blue and red glows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the figure standing completely motionless in waist-deep, churning, murky floodwater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06207237392663956 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812072277069092 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06207237392663956, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06207237392663956, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18720237910747528, + 0.08994245529174805, + 0.06535607576370239, + 0.08704200387001038, + 0.1519969403743744, + 0.12377715855836868, + 0.03929270803928375, + 0.08641032874584198, + 0.08549389988183975, + 0.08348611742258072 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06207237392663956 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle full-shot that slowly pans forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure wearing darkly painted metal armor plates connected by deep blue silk thread?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the figure wear a kabuto helmet with a full-face man-yorai mask that conceals all facial features?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit primarily from below by underwater building lights and neon signs casting electric blue and red glows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the figure standing completely motionless in waist-deep, churning, murky floodwater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.043065112084150314 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168065071105957 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.043065112084150314, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.043065112084150314, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.26824134588241577, + 0.05373981222510338, + 0.09039608389139175, + 0.1376076191663742, + 0.10111481696367264, + 0.10333185642957687, + 0.03585894778370857, + 0.11131131649017334, + 0.05033700540661812, + 0.04806118831038475 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.043065112084150314 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle full-shot that slowly pans forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure wearing darkly painted metal armor plates connected by deep blue silk thread?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the figure wear a kabuto helmet with a full-face man-yorai mask that conceals all facial features?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit primarily from below by underwater building lights and neon signs casting electric blue and red glows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the figure standing completely motionless in waist-deep, churning, murky floodwater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006738794036209583 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006738662719727 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006738794036209583, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006738794036209583, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1387709081172943, + 0.2962874472141266, + 0.15739373862743378, + 0.09204329550266266, + 0.03504377231001854, + 0.0276949480175972, + 0.04346443712711334, + 0.09571575373411179, + 0.056197769939899445, + 0.057387907058000565 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006738794036209583 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle full-shot that slowly pans forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure wearing darkly painted metal armor plates connected by deep blue silk thread?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the figure wear a kabuto helmet with a full-face man-yorai mask that conceals all facial features?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit primarily from below by underwater building lights and neon signs casting electric blue and red glows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the figure standing completely motionless in waist-deep, churning, murky floodwater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7578359842300415 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6328359842300415 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.7578359842300415, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.7578359842300415, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.135365292429924, + 0.12068124860525131, + 0.0763462707400322, + 0.11406616121530533, + 0.07939731329679489, + 0.1568465232849121, + 0.046137310564517975, + 0.12801428139209747, + 0.08248194307088852, + 0.060663580894470215 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.7578359842300415 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "Inspired by traditional Japanese aesthetics, a low-angle, full-shot shot slowly pans forward, focusing on a lone figure standing defiantly amidst a catastrophic urban flood. The figure is adorned with the ornate Sacra Umbra Armor, a masterpiece of darkly painted metal plates intricately connected by deep blue silk thread. The helmet, a formidable kabuto, features a menacing, full-face man-yorai mask that conceals all features, its metallic scowl fixed against the floodwaters. Rain pours down like a thick downpour, flowing over the armor's polished, obsidian-like surface, beading like tiny gems before cascading into the churning waters below. The figure stands waist-deep in raging, murky water, which swirls powerfully around their legs. In the background, the submerged cityscape is a chaotic mix of modern high-rises and traditional buildings, their lower halves engulfed by the floodwaters. The entire scene is lit almost entirely from below by the lights of underwater buildings and neon signs, which flicker ominously beneath the turbulent surface, casting a ghostly, refracted glow of electric blues and garish reds. This otherworldly underwater light creates deep, dramatic shadows that stretch and twist across the rising waters, painting a scene of somber, apocalyptic grandeur, while the figure remains completely motionless, a stoic fortress of shadow and steel against the raging storm.", + "seed": 19672, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_0/index_3190_seed_19672_dp_0_rank_0_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.2688258634880185, + "vlm_logprob": -0.2688258634880185, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.325, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.2688258634880185, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle full-shot that slowly pans forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure wearing darkly painted metal armor plates connected by deep blue silk thread?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the figure wear a kabuto helmet with a full-face man-yorai mask that conceals all facial features?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit primarily from below by underwater building lights and neon signs casting electric blue and red glows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the figure standing completely motionless in waist-deep, churning, murky floodwater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2594098150730133 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.509409785270691 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2594098150730133, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2594098150730133, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1467423141002655, + 0.055567849427461624, + 0.09697035700082779, + 0.05735236406326294, + 0.15512773394584656, + 0.03574036806821823, + 0.07413674890995026, + 0.2852272689342499, + 0.04565078020095825, + 0.04748423770070076 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2594098150730133 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle full-shot that slowly pans forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure wearing darkly painted metal armor plates connected by deep blue silk thread?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the figure wear a kabuto helmet with a full-face man-yorai mask that conceals all facial features?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit primarily from below by underwater building lights and neon signs casting electric blue and red glows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the figure standing completely motionless in waist-deep, churning, murky floodwater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.054994914680719376 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929994821548462 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.054994914680719376, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.054994914680719376, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12192945182323456, + 0.02935730665922165, + 0.03701428696513176, + 0.028242740780115128, + 0.15741604566574097, + 0.019003305584192276, + 0.02023315615952015, + 0.5104304552078247, + 0.029322518035769463, + 0.04705072566866875 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.054994914680719376 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle full-shot that slowly pans forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure wearing darkly painted metal armor plates connected by deep blue silk thread?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the figure wear a kabuto helmet with a full-face man-yorai mask that conceals all facial features?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit primarily from below by underwater building lights and neon signs casting electric blue and red glows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the figure standing completely motionless in waist-deep, churning, murky floodwater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04866760969161987 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486676692962646 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04866760969161987, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04866760969161987, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08962685614824295, + 0.03581980615854263, + 0.039566539227962494, + 0.025560177862644196, + 0.11814377456903458, + 0.06906606256961823, + 0.04794774204492569, + 0.40236493945121765, + 0.03898652270436287, + 0.1329176276922226 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04866760969161987 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle full-shot that slowly pans forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure wearing darkly painted metal armor plates connected by deep blue silk thread?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the figure wear a kabuto helmet with a full-face man-yorai mask that conceals all facial features?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit primarily from below by underwater building lights and neon signs casting electric blue and red glows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the figure standing completely motionless in waist-deep, churning, murky floodwater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006742109544575214 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006742000579834 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006742109544575214, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006742109544575214, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07404719293117523, + 0.026442846283316612, + 0.22099463641643524, + 0.06372611224651337, + 0.14044782519340515, + 0.025400251150131226, + 0.13048775494098663, + 0.21252062916755676, + 0.042612385004758835, + 0.06332040578126907 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 7, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006742109544575214 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle full-shot that slowly pans forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure wearing darkly painted metal armor plates connected by deep blue silk thread?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the figure wear a kabuto helmet with a full-face man-yorai mask that conceals all facial features?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit primarily from below by underwater building lights and neon signs casting electric blue and red glows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the figure standing completely motionless in waist-deep, churning, murky floodwater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9743148684501648 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4743148684501648 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.9743148684501648, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.9743148684501648, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05851104483008385, + 0.040861207991838455, + 0.1003529354929924, + 0.05475691705942154, + 0.05384800210595131, + 0.10629355907440186, + 0.15053878724575043, + 0.32974594831466675, + 0.06936472654342651, + 0.03572685644030571 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.9743148684501648 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "Inspired by traditional Japanese aesthetics, a low-angle, full-shot shot slowly pans forward, focusing on a lone figure standing defiantly amidst a catastrophic urban flood. The figure is adorned with the ornate Sacra Umbra Armor, a masterpiece of darkly painted metal plates intricately connected by deep blue silk thread. The helmet, a formidable kabuto, features a menacing, full-face man-yorai mask that conceals all features, its metallic scowl fixed against the floodwaters. Rain pours down like a thick downpour, flowing over the armor's polished, obsidian-like surface, beading like tiny gems before cascading into the churning waters below. The figure stands waist-deep in raging, murky water, which swirls powerfully around their legs. In the background, the submerged cityscape is a chaotic mix of modern high-rises and traditional buildings, their lower halves engulfed by the floodwaters. The entire scene is lit almost entirely from below by the lights of underwater buildings and neon signs, which flicker ominously beneath the turbulent surface, casting a ghostly, refracted glow of electric blues and garish reds. This otherworldly underwater light creates deep, dramatic shadows that stretch and twist across the rising waters, painting a scene of somber, apocalyptic grandeur, while the figure remains completely motionless, a stoic fortress of shadow and steel against the raging storm.", + "seed": 19673, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_0/index_3190_seed_19673_dp_1_rank_2_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.22054606527090073, + "vlm_logprob": -0.22054606527090073, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.8, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.22054606527090073, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle full-shot that slowly pans forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure wearing darkly painted metal armor plates connected by deep blue silk thread?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the figure wear a kabuto helmet with a full-face man-yorai mask that conceals all facial features?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit primarily from below by underwater building lights and neon signs casting electric blue and red glows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the figure standing completely motionless in waist-deep, churning, murky floodwater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.13083875179290771 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1308388710021973 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.13083875179290771, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.13083875179290771, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18932130932807922, + 0.04590090364217758, + 0.07648604363203049, + 0.10572035610675812, + 0.0641026422381401, + 0.044972535222768784, + 0.0638674944639206, + 0.3039565682411194, + 0.07103892415761948, + 0.03463318571448326 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.13083875179290771 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle full-shot that slowly pans forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure wearing darkly painted metal armor plates connected by deep blue silk thread?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the figure wear a kabuto helmet with a full-face man-yorai mask that conceals all facial features?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit primarily from below by underwater building lights and neon signs casting electric blue and red glows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the figure standing completely motionless in waist-deep, churning, murky floodwater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10035582631826401 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.350355863571167 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10035582631826401, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10035582631826401, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10981294512748718, + 0.0475597158074379, + 0.06971634179353714, + 0.05114555358886719, + 0.16841593384742737, + 0.03746276721358299, + 0.053582482039928436, + 0.2454880177974701, + 0.14669939875602722, + 0.07011682540178299 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 4, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10035582631826401 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle full-shot that slowly pans forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure wearing darkly painted metal armor plates connected by deep blue silk thread?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the figure wear a kabuto helmet with a full-face man-yorai mask that conceals all facial features?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit primarily from below by underwater building lights and neon signs casting electric blue and red glows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the figure standing completely motionless in waist-deep, churning, murky floodwater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08906170725822449 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.464061737060547 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08906170725822449, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08906170725822449, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12191727757453918, + 0.1074867770075798, + 0.07568684965372086, + 0.061776746064424515, + 0.2924489378929138, + 0.04730187729001045, + 0.07812406122684479, + 0.1032760962843895, + 0.06563231348991394, + 0.04634910449385643 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08906170725822449 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle full-shot that slowly pans forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure wearing darkly painted metal armor plates connected by deep blue silk thread?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the figure wear a kabuto helmet with a full-face man-yorai mask that conceals all facial features?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit primarily from below by underwater building lights and neon signs casting electric blue and red glows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the figure standing completely motionless in waist-deep, churning, murky floodwater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0890684723854065 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4640684127807617 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0890684723854065, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0890684723854065, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06872483342885971, + 0.02284826524555683, + 0.050090234726667404, + 0.06339295208454132, + 0.32508549094200134, + 0.05721968784928322, + 0.056270062923431396, + 0.25905123353004456, + 0.06047902628779411, + 0.03683825209736824 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0890684723854065 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle full-shot that slowly pans forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure wearing darkly painted metal armor plates connected by deep blue silk thread?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the figure wear a kabuto helmet with a full-face man-yorai mask that conceals all facial features?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit primarily from below by underwater building lights and neon signs casting electric blue and red glows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the figure standing completely motionless in waist-deep, churning, murky floodwater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6934055685997009 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6934055685997009 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.6934055685997009, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.6934055685997009, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09013532847166061, + 0.04592226818203926, + 0.07688077539205551, + 0.034779299050569534, + 0.17847271263599396, + 0.03807239606976509, + 0.04475626349449158, + 0.167341411113739, + 0.2836819589138031, + 0.039957549422979355 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 4, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.6934055685997009 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "Inspired by traditional Japanese aesthetics, a low-angle, full-shot shot slowly pans forward, focusing on a lone figure standing defiantly amidst a catastrophic urban flood. The figure is adorned with the ornate Sacra Umbra Armor, a masterpiece of darkly painted metal plates intricately connected by deep blue silk thread. The helmet, a formidable kabuto, features a menacing, full-face man-yorai mask that conceals all features, its metallic scowl fixed against the floodwaters. Rain pours down like a thick downpour, flowing over the armor's polished, obsidian-like surface, beading like tiny gems before cascading into the churning waters below. The figure stands waist-deep in raging, murky water, which swirls powerfully around their legs. In the background, the submerged cityscape is a chaotic mix of modern high-rises and traditional buildings, their lower halves engulfed by the floodwaters. The entire scene is lit almost entirely from below by the lights of underwater buildings and neon signs, which flicker ominously beneath the turbulent surface, casting a ghostly, refracted glow of electric blues and garish reds. This otherworldly underwater light creates deep, dramatic shadows that stretch and twist across the rising waters, painting a scene of somber, apocalyptic grandeur, while the figure remains completely motionless, a stoic fortress of shadow and steel against the raging storm.", + "seed": 19674, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_0/index_3190_seed_19674_dp_1_rank_2_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.18371942974627017, + "vlm_logprob": -0.18371942974627017, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.65, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.18371942974627017, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle full-shot that slowly pans forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure wearing darkly painted metal armor plates connected by deep blue silk thread?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the figure wear a kabuto helmet with a full-face man-yorai mask that conceals all facial features?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit primarily from below by underwater building lights and neon signs casting electric blue and red glows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the figure standing completely motionless in waist-deep, churning, murky floodwater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11858019977807999 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2435801029205322 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11858019977807999, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11858019977807999, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08831159770488739, + 0.20847952365875244, + 0.19662795960903168, + 0.09434824436903, + 0.1529383659362793, + 0.010296689346432686, + 0.02535545825958252, + 0.022260773926973343, + 0.18389244377613068, + 0.01748899184167385 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11858019977807999 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle full-shot that slowly pans forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure wearing darkly painted metal armor plates connected by deep blue silk thread?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the figure wear a kabuto helmet with a full-face man-yorai mask that conceals all facial features?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit primarily from below by underwater building lights and neon signs casting electric blue and red glows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the figure standing completely motionless in waist-deep, churning, murky floodwater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07005971670150757 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950597763061523 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07005971670150757, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07005971670150757, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09856659919023514, + 0.5721167325973511, + 0.0438978374004364, + 0.048091061413288116, + 0.04130619764328003, + 0.018847450613975525, + 0.031546611338853836, + 0.05490516498684883, + 0.02650398574769497, + 0.0642184242606163 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07005971670150757 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle full-shot that slowly pans forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure wearing darkly painted metal armor plates connected by deep blue silk thread?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the figure wear a kabuto helmet with a full-face man-yorai mask that conceals all facial features?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit primarily from below by underwater building lights and neon signs casting electric blue and red glows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the figure standing completely motionless in waist-deep, churning, murky floodwater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029813941568136215 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298140048980713 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029813941568136215, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029813941568136215, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10501330345869064, + 0.26353976130485535, + 0.23153197765350342, + 0.04835838824510574, + 0.03452661633491516, + 0.04235432669520378, + 0.04794323816895485, + 0.0276959128677845, + 0.15384192764759064, + 0.04519455507397652 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029813941568136215 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle full-shot that slowly pans forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure wearing darkly painted metal armor plates connected by deep blue silk thread?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the figure wear a kabuto helmet with a full-face man-yorai mask that conceals all facial features?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit primarily from below by underwater building lights and neon signs casting electric blue and red glows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the figure standing completely motionless in waist-deep, churning, murky floodwater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006738675758242607 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006738662719727 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006738675758242607, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006738675758242607, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1632729023694992, + 0.22564934194087982, + 0.04939514398574829, + 0.13737930357456207, + 0.08430974185466766, + 0.01972357928752899, + 0.06255713105201721, + 0.09733135998249054, + 0.13363811373710632, + 0.02674337476491928 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006738675758242607 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle full-shot that slowly pans forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure wearing darkly painted metal armor plates connected by deep blue silk thread?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the figure wear a kabuto helmet with a full-face man-yorai mask that conceals all facial features?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit primarily from below by underwater building lights and neon signs casting electric blue and red glows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the figure standing completely motionless in waist-deep, churning, murky floodwater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6934046149253845 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6934046149253845 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.6934046149253845, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.6934046149253845, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07740732282400131, + 0.21980516612529755, + 0.0735737755894661, + 0.07209093868732452, + 0.10027403384447098, + 0.029782475903630257, + 0.04820804297924042, + 0.08605386316776276, + 0.27146193385124207, + 0.021342456340789795 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.6934046149253845 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_1/index_tensor([7552, 7552])_group_1_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_1/index_tensor([7552, 7552])_group_1_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..4f9192c6fdbf5bc06731af8db9bc743fc5c917b5 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_1/index_tensor([7552, 7552])_group_1_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "In an elegantly decorated Chinese restaurant, a static, eye-level wide-angle shot captures a dynamic social scene, unfolding around a large round table. The warm light from ornate overhead lanterns casts a soft glow over the gathering. To the right, a woman in a crisp white silk blouse engages in conversation, smiles slightly, turns her head, and elegantly smooths back her tousled black hair. Next to her, a woman in a vibrant red dress holds a lit cigarette between her fingers, a wisp of smoke curling toward the ceiling. She leans over and gives a gentle, encouraging pat on the arm of a man in a simple black sweater. Across the table, a man in a forest green jacket deliberately bends down, his upper body disappearing from the frame. He searches the floor for something before slowly returning to his seat. On the far left, a woman with hair in a neat bun, absorbed in her meal, steadily picks up dark wooden chopsticks and reaches forward to select a piece of food from the steaming plate in the center. Meanwhile, a woman in a black turtleneck quietly raises a clear glass to her lips to take a sip of water, then subtly shifts her weight to lean forward across the table, her posture signaling growing interest in the conversation, all contributing to a rich, layered, and naturally casual, friendly dinner atmosphere.", + "seed": 18204, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_1/index_7552_seed_18204_dp_2_rank_4_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.42728527188301085, + "vlm_logprob": -0.42728527188301085, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.175, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.42728527188301085, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an elegantly decorated Chinese restaurant with a large round table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static, eye-level, and wide-angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a woman in a crisp white silk blouse visible who smooths back her tousled black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a woman in a vibrant red dress holding a lit cigarette with smoke curling upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a man in a forest green jacket visible bending down to search the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5043916702270508 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.25439172983169556 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.5043916702270508, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -1.5043916702270508, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3958698511123657, + 0.10225753486156464, + 0.09450696408748627, + 0.11944787204265594, + 0.03552089259028435, + 0.04451620951294899, + 0.043444059789180756, + 0.05982710421085358, + 0.04569844529032707, + 0.05891106650233269 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.5043916702270508 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an elegantly decorated Chinese restaurant with a large round table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static, eye-level, and wide-angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a woman in a crisp white silk blouse visible who smooths back her tousled black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a woman in a vibrant red dress holding a lit cigarette with smoke curling upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a man in a forest green jacket visible bending down to search the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1271640658378601 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.127164125442505 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1271640658378601, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1271640658378601, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2503516674041748, + 0.050378404557704926, + 0.0427234061062336, + 0.08236869424581528, + 0.027968760579824448, + 0.04532254859805107, + 0.08056715130805969, + 0.09289137274026871, + 0.1703030914068222, + 0.15712495148181915 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1271640658378601 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an elegantly decorated Chinese restaurant with a large round table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static, eye-level, and wide-angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a woman in a crisp white silk blouse visible who smooths back her tousled black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a woman in a vibrant red dress holding a lit cigarette with smoke curling upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a man in a forest green jacket visible bending down to search the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20162178575992584 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7016217708587646 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20162178575992584, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20162178575992584, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4588451087474823, + 0.14034149050712585, + 0.07621701806783676, + 0.030072569847106934, + 0.03586496040225029, + 0.024050159379839897, + 0.030767114832997322, + 0.07202431559562683, + 0.04508516192436218, + 0.08673202991485596 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20162178575992584 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an elegantly decorated Chinese restaurant with a large round table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static, eye-level, and wide-angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a woman in a crisp white silk blouse visible who smooths back her tousled black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a woman in a vibrant red dress holding a lit cigarette with smoke curling upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a man in a forest green jacket visible bending down to search the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1604273021221161 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9104273319244385 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1604273021221161, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1604273021221161, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.33357784152030945, + 0.07716111093759537, + 0.06436680257320404, + 0.0802922323346138, + 0.043958429247140884, + 0.036956652998924255, + 0.0751023143529892, + 0.12599922716617584, + 0.07592175155878067, + 0.08666356652975082 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1604273021221161 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an elegantly decorated Chinese restaurant with a large round table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static, eye-level, and wide-angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a woman in a crisp white silk blouse visible who smooths back her tousled black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a woman in a vibrant red dress holding a lit cigarette with smoke curling upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a man in a forest green jacket visible bending down to search the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1428215354681015 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0178215503692627 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1428215354681015, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1428215354681015, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13430562615394592, + 0.049611181020736694, + 0.04015202820301056, + 0.04312960430979729, + 0.02354411780834198, + 0.02656794711947441, + 0.05379420146346092, + 0.10897278040647507, + 0.07760105282068253, + 0.4423214793205261 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1428215354681015 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In an elegantly decorated Chinese restaurant, a static, eye-level wide-angle shot captures a dynamic social scene, unfolding around a large round table. The warm light from ornate overhead lanterns casts a soft glow over the gathering. To the right, a woman in a crisp white silk blouse engages in conversation, smiles slightly, turns her head, and elegantly smooths back her tousled black hair. Next to her, a woman in a vibrant red dress holds a lit cigarette between her fingers, a wisp of smoke curling toward the ceiling. She leans over and gives a gentle, encouraging pat on the arm of a man in a simple black sweater. Across the table, a man in a forest green jacket deliberately bends down, his upper body disappearing from the frame. He searches the floor for something before slowly returning to his seat. On the far left, a woman with hair in a neat bun, absorbed in her meal, steadily picks up dark wooden chopsticks and reaches forward to select a piece of food from the steaming plate in the center. Meanwhile, a woman in a black turtleneck quietly raises a clear glass to her lips to take a sip of water, then subtly shifts her weight to lean forward across the table, her posture signaling growing interest in the conversation, all contributing to a rich, layered, and naturally casual, friendly dinner atmosphere.", + "seed": 18205, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_1/index_7552_seed_18205_dp_2_rank_4_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.19168269224464893, + "vlm_logprob": -0.19168269224464893, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.675, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.19168269224464893, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an elegantly decorated Chinese restaurant with a large round table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static, eye-level, and wide-angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a woman in a crisp white silk blouse visible who smooths back her tousled black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a woman in a vibrant red dress holding a lit cigarette with smoke curling upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a man in a forest green jacket visible bending down to search the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.013708963990211487 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.38870906829834 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.013708963990211487, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.013708963990211487, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14209164679050446, + 0.13527868688106537, + 0.07657971233129501, + 0.06489076465368271, + 0.1305774748325348, + 0.09228993952274323, + 0.07237980514764786, + 0.0975528135895729, + 0.14254839718341827, + 0.0458107627928257 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.013708963990211487 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an elegantly decorated Chinese restaurant with a large round table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static, eye-level, and wide-angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a woman in a crisp white silk blouse visible who smooths back her tousled black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a woman in a vibrant red dress holding a lit cigarette with smoke curling upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a man in a forest green jacket visible bending down to search the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6933746337890625 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6933746337890625 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.6933746337890625, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.6933746337890625, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09450563043355942, + 0.04291066527366638, + 0.05951782315969467, + 0.06617039442062378, + 0.34428632259368896, + 0.06460613757371902, + 0.07926389575004578, + 0.12661311030387878, + 0.05760853737592697, + 0.06451740115880966 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.6933746337890625 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an elegantly decorated Chinese restaurant with a large round table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static, eye-level, and wide-angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a woman in a crisp white silk blouse visible who smooths back her tousled black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a woman in a vibrant red dress holding a lit cigarette with smoke curling upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a man in a forest green jacket visible bending down to search the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03370501473546028 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408704996109009 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03370501473546028, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03370501473546028, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18152019381523132, + 0.06697683781385422, + 0.18040290474891663, + 0.0609513595700264, + 0.0516682006418705, + 0.14413891732692719, + 0.13245345652103424, + 0.05200788006186485, + 0.0803862065076828, + 0.04949402064085007 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03370501473546028 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an elegantly decorated Chinese restaurant with a large round table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static, eye-level, and wide-angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a woman in a crisp white silk blouse visible who smooths back her tousled black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a woman in a vibrant red dress holding a lit cigarette with smoke curling upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a man in a forest green jacket visible bending down to search the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016078105196356773 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141077995300293 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016078105196356773, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016078105196356773, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20128601789474487, + 0.16595616936683655, + 0.19332297146320343, + 0.040478795766830444, + 0.05752655863761902, + 0.07166734337806702, + 0.12021545320749283, + 0.04795684292912483, + 0.05512954294681549, + 0.04646028205752373 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016078105196356773 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an elegantly decorated Chinese restaurant with a large round table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static, eye-level, and wide-angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a woman in a crisp white silk blouse visible who smooths back her tousled black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a woman in a vibrant red dress holding a lit cigarette with smoke curling upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a man in a forest green jacket visible bending down to search the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20154674351215363 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7015467882156372 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20154674351215363, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20154674351215363, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0637206956744194, + 0.04924657195806503, + 0.0673181414604187, + 0.0652211382985115, + 0.1754683405160904, + 0.04292767867445946, + 0.18665531277656555, + 0.19343920052051544, + 0.06651236116886139, + 0.08949057012796402 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20154674351215363 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In an elegantly decorated Chinese restaurant, a static, eye-level wide-angle shot captures a dynamic social scene, unfolding around a large round table. The warm light from ornate overhead lanterns casts a soft glow over the gathering. To the right, a woman in a crisp white silk blouse engages in conversation, smiles slightly, turns her head, and elegantly smooths back her tousled black hair. Next to her, a woman in a vibrant red dress holds a lit cigarette between her fingers, a wisp of smoke curling toward the ceiling. She leans over and gives a gentle, encouraging pat on the arm of a man in a simple black sweater. Across the table, a man in a forest green jacket deliberately bends down, his upper body disappearing from the frame. He searches the floor for something before slowly returning to his seat. On the far left, a woman with hair in a neat bun, absorbed in her meal, steadily picks up dark wooden chopsticks and reaches forward to select a piece of food from the steaming plate in the center. Meanwhile, a woman in a black turtleneck quietly raises a clear glass to her lips to take a sip of water, then subtly shifts her weight to lean forward across the table, her posture signaling growing interest in the conversation, all contributing to a rich, layered, and naturally casual, friendly dinner atmosphere.", + "seed": 18206, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_1/index_7552_seed_18206_dp_3_rank_6_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.16919455397874117, + "vlm_logprob": -0.16919455397874117, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.65, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.16919455397874117, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an elegantly decorated Chinese restaurant with a large round table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static, eye-level, and wide-angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a woman in a crisp white silk blouse visible who smooths back her tousled black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a woman in a vibrant red dress holding a lit cigarette with smoke curling upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a man in a forest green jacket visible bending down to search the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014248657040297985 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.389248847961426 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014248657040297985, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014248657040297985, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08620908856391907, + 0.08720040321350098, + 0.042648859322071075, + 0.10472001880407333, + 0.08106854557991028, + 0.16562987864017487, + 0.1413373351097107, + 0.12554486095905304, + 0.08485706895589828, + 0.0807839035987854 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014248657040297985 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an elegantly decorated Chinese restaurant with a large round table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static, eye-level, and wide-angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a woman in a crisp white silk blouse visible who smooths back her tousled black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a woman in a vibrant red dress holding a lit cigarette with smoke curling upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a man in a forest green jacket visible bending down to search the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5233353972434998 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8983353972434998 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5233353972434998, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5233353972434998, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.033544231206178665, + 0.06917557120323181, + 0.05073971301317215, + 0.030714333057403564, + 0.026027001440525055, + 0.08295364677906036, + 0.40091633796691895, + 0.05870606005191803, + 0.06240168213844299, + 0.18482139706611633 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5233353972434998 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an elegantly decorated Chinese restaurant with a large round table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static, eye-level, and wide-angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a woman in a crisp white silk blouse visible who smooths back her tousled black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a woman in a vibrant red dress holding a lit cigarette with smoke curling upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a man in a forest green jacket visible bending down to search the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.038104183971881866 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288104295730591 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.038104183971881866, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.038104183971881866, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14048099517822266, + 0.06022707372903824, + 0.03411925211548805, + 0.08674813061952591, + 0.06110551580786705, + 0.060278650373220444, + 0.3479582667350769, + 0.07875952124595642, + 0.03523572161793709, + 0.09508688747882843 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.038104183971881866 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an elegantly decorated Chinese restaurant with a large round table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static, eye-level, and wide-angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a woman in a crisp white silk blouse visible who smooths back her tousled black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a woman in a vibrant red dress holding a lit cigarette with smoke curling upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a man in a forest green jacket visible bending down to search the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018199829384684563 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018199920654297 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018199829384684563, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018199829384684563, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10369033366441727, + 0.06859263777732849, + 0.038449324667453766, + 0.058519985526800156, + 0.03207319229841232, + 0.031137840822339058, + 0.07909239083528519, + 0.173866868019104, + 0.35733067989349365, + 0.057246726006269455 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018199829384684563 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an elegantly decorated Chinese restaurant with a large round table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static, eye-level, and wide-angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a woman in a crisp white silk blouse visible who smooths back her tousled black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a woman in a vibrant red dress holding a lit cigarette with smoke curling upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a man in a forest green jacket visible bending down to search the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2520847022533417 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.502084732055664 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2520847022533417, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2520847022533417, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13129368424415588, + 0.06962621957063675, + 0.04560292512178421, + 0.04031999036669731, + 0.1397160440683365, + 0.05799940600991249, + 0.13804227113723755, + 0.08809927850961685, + 0.2388448417186737, + 0.050455253571271896 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2520847022533417 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In an elegantly decorated Chinese restaurant, a static, eye-level wide-angle shot captures a dynamic social scene, unfolding around a large round table. The warm light from ornate overhead lanterns casts a soft glow over the gathering. To the right, a woman in a crisp white silk blouse engages in conversation, smiles slightly, turns her head, and elegantly smooths back her tousled black hair. Next to her, a woman in a vibrant red dress holds a lit cigarette between her fingers, a wisp of smoke curling toward the ceiling. She leans over and gives a gentle, encouraging pat on the arm of a man in a simple black sweater. Across the table, a man in a forest green jacket deliberately bends down, his upper body disappearing from the frame. He searches the floor for something before slowly returning to his seat. On the far left, a woman with hair in a neat bun, absorbed in her meal, steadily picks up dark wooden chopsticks and reaches forward to select a piece of food from the steaming plate in the center. Meanwhile, a woman in a black turtleneck quietly raises a clear glass to her lips to take a sip of water, then subtly shifts her weight to lean forward across the table, her posture signaling growing interest in the conversation, all contributing to a rich, layered, and naturally casual, friendly dinner atmosphere.", + "seed": 18207, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_1/index_7552_seed_18207_dp_3_rank_6_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.1425342619419098, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1425342619419098, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.325, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1425342619419098, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an elegantly decorated Chinese restaurant with a large round table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static, eye-level, and wide-angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a woman in a crisp white silk blouse visible who smooths back her tousled black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a woman in a vibrant red dress holding a lit cigarette with smoke curling upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a man in a forest green jacket visible bending down to search the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03497263044118881 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.534972667694092 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03497263044118881, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03497263044118881, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2618490159511566, + 0.15837743878364563, + 0.037989597767591476, + 0.06287719309329987, + 0.06847205013036728, + 0.13322006165981293, + 0.10847201943397522, + 0.04250764846801758, + 0.029950926080346107, + 0.09628406167030334 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03497263044118881 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an elegantly decorated Chinese restaurant with a large round table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static, eye-level, and wide-angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a woman in a crisp white silk blouse visible who smooths back her tousled black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a woman in a vibrant red dress holding a lit cigarette with smoke curling upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a man in a forest green jacket visible bending down to search the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17992660403251648 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8049266338348389 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17992660403251648, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17992660403251648, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08098354935646057, + 0.07169879227876663, + 0.10485143214464188, + 0.0934019386768341, + 0.26766976714134216, + 0.14600640535354614, + 0.09216836094856262, + 0.036150045692920685, + 0.06431365758180618, + 0.04275600239634514 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17992660403251648 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an elegantly decorated Chinese restaurant with a large round table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static, eye-level, and wide-angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a woman in a crisp white silk blouse visible who smooths back her tousled black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a woman in a vibrant red dress holding a lit cigarette with smoke curling upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a man in a forest green jacket visible bending down to search the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.062055230140686035 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120551109313965 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.062055230140686035, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.062055230140686035, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19237910211086273, + 0.06916305422782898, + 0.07847399264574051, + 0.11259783059358597, + 0.27982500195503235, + 0.11869305372238159, + 0.033312320709228516, + 0.037661850452423096, + 0.03023177571594715, + 0.04766201227903366 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.062055230140686035 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an elegantly decorated Chinese restaurant with a large round table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static, eye-level, and wide-angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a woman in a crisp white silk blouse visible who smooths back her tousled black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a woman in a vibrant red dress holding a lit cigarette with smoke curling upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a man in a forest green jacket visible bending down to search the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04867339879274368 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048673391342163 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04867339879274368, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04867339879274368, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2158200740814209, + 0.13209953904151917, + 0.05362628772854805, + 0.04507165402173996, + 0.30896252393722534, + 0.09590043127536774, + 0.04946640878915787, + 0.027074133977293968, + 0.022732490673661232, + 0.04924635589122772 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04867339879274368 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an elegantly decorated Chinese restaurant with a large round table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static, eye-level, and wide-angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a woman in a crisp white silk blouse visible who smooths back her tousled black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a woman in a vibrant red dress holding a lit cigarette with smoke curling upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a man in a forest green jacket visible bending down to search the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.38704344630241394 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1370434761047363 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.38704344630241394, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.38704344630241394, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.35123005509376526, + 0.06775831431150436, + 0.04965381324291229, + 0.0712755024433136, + 0.07831250876188278, + 0.06216495484113693, + 0.05165106803178787, + 0.04614130035042763, + 0.0907769501209259, + 0.13103558123111725 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.38704344630241394 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_10/index_tensor([5617, 5617])_group_10_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_10/index_tensor([5617, 5617])_group_10_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..5af86379cf03fa1029dcc0fe45d81cc6e9bbe7f9 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_10/index_tensor([5617, 5617])_group_10_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "An extremely close-up, static shot focuses with razor-sharp clarity on the angled tip of a sterile, stainless-steel hypodermic needle. The polished metal gleams in bright, direct light, revealing microscopic striations from its manufacturing process. Suddenly, a clear, viscous liquid powerfully erupts from the narrow gap in a swift and decisive eruption. The syrupy liquid catches the light, shimmering and forming a perfect arc against the cool, softly blurred, sterile blue-white background. The initial, cohesive spray of liquid lingers in the air for a moment before gracefully breaking into shimmering, individual droplets that follow the same trajectory. The entire scene is illuminated by cool, high-key lighting, creating sharp, mirror-like highlights on the needle and making each droplet shimmer, creating an atmosphere of intense focus, clinical precision, and controlled force.", + "seed": 225, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_10/index_5617_seed_225_dp_20_rank_40_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.43945272646378725, + "vlm_logprob": -0.43945272646378725, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.35, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.43945272646378725, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extremely close-up view of a sterile, stainless-steel hypodermic needle tip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a clear, viscous liquid erupt powerfully from the needle gap in a swift motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a cool, softly blurred, sterile blue-white environment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the liquid form a perfect arc before breaking into individual shimmering droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011727673932909966 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.636727809906006 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011727673932909966, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011727673932909966, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13796550035476685, + 0.04658076912164688, + 0.038781337440013885, + 0.08225483447313309, + 0.12677699327468872, + 0.1500469148159027, + 0.16554343700408936, + 0.17730753123760223, + 0.0395011380314827, + 0.03524149954319 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011727673932909966 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extremely close-up view of a sterile, stainless-steel hypodermic needle tip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a clear, viscous liquid erupt powerfully from the needle gap in a swift motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a cool, softly blurred, sterile blue-white environment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the liquid form a perfect arc before breaking into individual shimmering droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1270391941070557 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12703923881053925 + ], + "logprob_reward": -2.1270391941070557, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -2.1270391941070557, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14505156874656677, + 0.03325433284044266, + 0.035413749516010284, + 0.11190886795520782, + 0.12322835624217987, + 0.10807644575834274, + 0.1599651426076889, + 0.05393263325095177, + 0.08769313246011734, + 0.14147573709487915 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -2.1270391941070557 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extremely close-up view of a sterile, stainless-steel hypodermic needle tip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a clear, viscous liquid erupt powerfully from the needle gap in a swift motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a cool, softly blurred, sterile blue-white environment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the liquid form a perfect arc before breaking into individual shimmering droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014225739054381847 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264225959777832 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014225739054381847, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014225739054381847, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05322698876261711, + 0.04072938859462738, + 0.02612466551363468, + 0.03150153532624245, + 0.10768052190542221, + 0.39962002635002136, + 0.06984250247478485, + 0.20133526623249054, + 0.043947696685791016, + 0.025991393253207207 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 7, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014225739054381847 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extremely close-up view of a sterile, stainless-steel hypodermic needle tip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a clear, viscous liquid erupt powerfully from the needle gap in a swift motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a cool, softly blurred, sterile blue-white environment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the liquid form a perfect arc before breaking into individual shimmering droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0011837625643238425 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.751183986663818 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0011837625643238425, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0011837625643238425, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0850098580121994, + 0.057134903967380524, + 0.14284391701221466, + 0.05955688655376434, + 0.07841528952121735, + 0.08678125590085983, + 0.14359702169895172, + 0.1673399806022644, + 0.10872124135494232, + 0.07059964537620544 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0011837625643238425 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extremely close-up view of a sterile, stainless-steel hypodermic needle tip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a clear, viscous liquid erupt powerfully from the needle gap in a swift motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a cool, softly blurred, sterile blue-white environment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the liquid form a perfect arc before breaking into individual shimmering droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04308726266026497 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680872440338135 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04308726266026497, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04308726266026497, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.060562606900930405, + 0.03226044028997421, + 0.044381044805049896, + 0.030820317566394806, + 0.09884049743413925, + 0.20030809938907623, + 0.28387314081192017, + 0.17575901746749878, + 0.034770719707012177, + 0.038424137979745865 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04308726266026497 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extremely close-up, static shot focuses with razor-sharp clarity on the angled tip of a sterile, stainless-steel hypodermic needle. The polished metal gleams in bright, direct light, revealing microscopic striations from its manufacturing process. Suddenly, a clear, viscous liquid powerfully erupts from the narrow gap in a swift and decisive eruption. The syrupy liquid catches the light, shimmering and forming a perfect arc against the cool, softly blurred, sterile blue-white background. The initial, cohesive spray of liquid lingers in the air for a moment before gracefully breaking into shimmering, individual droplets that follow the same trajectory. The entire scene is illuminated by cool, high-key lighting, creating sharp, mirror-like highlights on the needle and making each droplet shimmer, creating an atmosphere of intense focus, clinical precision, and controlled force.", + "seed": 226, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_10/index_5617_seed_226_dp_20_rank_40_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.3156466740765609, + "vlm_logprob": -0.3156466740765609, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.625, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.3156466740765609, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extremely close-up view of a sterile, stainless-steel hypodermic needle tip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a clear, viscous liquid erupt powerfully from the needle gap in a swift motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a cool, softly blurred, sterile blue-white environment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the liquid form a perfect arc before breaking into individual shimmering droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008148993365466595 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.133149147033691 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008148993365466595, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008148993365466595, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21072056889533997, + 0.11966703087091446, + 0.18409007787704468, + 0.16240638494491577, + 0.06445331871509552, + 0.029503729194402695, + 0.11955897510051727, + 0.016319992020726204, + 0.06323748081922531, + 0.030042340978980064 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008148993365466595 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extremely close-up view of a sterile, stainless-steel hypodermic needle tip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a clear, viscous liquid erupt powerfully from the needle gap in a swift motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a cool, softly blurred, sterile blue-white environment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the liquid form a perfect arc before breaking into individual shimmering droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5020968914031982 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.25209692120552063 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.5020968914031982, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -1.5020968914031982, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12774929404258728, + 0.05817762762308121, + 0.19570182263851166, + 0.193751722574234, + 0.06357808411121368, + 0.0640464723110199, + 0.12344951182603836, + 0.03335634246468544, + 0.03528853505849838, + 0.10490061342716217 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.5020968914031982 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extremely close-up view of a sterile, stainless-steel hypodermic needle tip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a clear, viscous liquid erupt powerfully from the needle gap in a swift motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a cool, softly blurred, sterile blue-white environment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the liquid form a perfect arc before breaking into individual shimmering droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03372299671173096 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4087228775024414 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03372299671173096, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03372299671173096, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17849905788898468, + 0.1775309294462204, + 0.16039133071899414, + 0.22754384577274323, + 0.059485964477062225, + 0.05205570533871651, + 0.06914261728525162, + 0.015676673501729965, + 0.01777425967156887, + 0.04189956933259964 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03372299671173096 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extremely close-up view of a sterile, stainless-steel hypodermic needle tip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a clear, viscous liquid erupt powerfully from the needle gap in a swift motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a cool, softly blurred, sterile blue-white environment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the liquid form a perfect arc before breaking into individual shimmering droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0005613181856460869 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.500561237335205 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0005613181856460869, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0005613181856460869, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12265986949205399, + 0.20561261475086212, + 0.12040743976831436, + 0.14318008720874786, + 0.08558270335197449, + 0.0683244988322258, + 0.10432118922472, + 0.0670822337269783, + 0.02129104919731617, + 0.06153840571641922 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0005613181856460869 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extremely close-up view of a sterile, stainless-steel hypodermic needle tip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a clear, viscous liquid erupt powerfully from the needle gap in a swift motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a cool, softly blurred, sterile blue-white environment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the liquid form a perfect arc before breaking into individual shimmering droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03370317071676254 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408703088760376 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03370317071676254, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03370317071676254, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19087259471416473, + 0.08843942731618881, + 0.1374601572751999, + 0.26840940117836, + 0.028334813192486763, + 0.12384673207998276, + 0.07014473527669907, + 0.03247987851500511, + 0.039625383913517, + 0.02038697339594364 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03370317071676254 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extremely close-up, static shot focuses with razor-sharp clarity on the angled tip of a sterile, stainless-steel hypodermic needle. The polished metal gleams in bright, direct light, revealing microscopic striations from its manufacturing process. Suddenly, a clear, viscous liquid powerfully erupts from the narrow gap in a swift and decisive eruption. The syrupy liquid catches the light, shimmering and forming a perfect arc against the cool, softly blurred, sterile blue-white background. The initial, cohesive spray of liquid lingers in the air for a moment before gracefully breaking into shimmering, individual droplets that follow the same trajectory. The entire scene is illuminated by cool, high-key lighting, creating sharp, mirror-like highlights on the needle and making each droplet shimmer, creating an atmosphere of intense focus, clinical precision, and controlled force.", + "seed": 227, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_10/index_5617_seed_227_dp_21_rank_42_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.24245297480374575, + "vlm_logprob": -0.24245297480374575, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.55, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.24245297480374575, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extremely close-up view of a sterile, stainless-steel hypodermic needle tip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a clear, viscous liquid erupt powerfully from the needle gap in a swift motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a cool, softly blurred, sterile blue-white environment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the liquid form a perfect arc before breaking into individual shimmering droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.050341926515102386 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.050341844558716 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.050341926515102386, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.050341926515102386, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.349830687046051, + 0.2188272774219513, + 0.06583713740110397, + 0.07535959035158157, + 0.06222505867481232, + 0.05715144798159599, + 0.035953156650066376, + 0.054520342499017715, + 0.04187418892979622, + 0.03842110559344292 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.050341926515102386 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extremely close-up view of a sterile, stainless-steel hypodermic needle tip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a clear, viscous liquid erupt powerfully from the needle gap in a swift motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a cool, softly blurred, sterile blue-white environment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the liquid form a perfect arc before breaking into individual shimmering droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7578803896903992 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6328803896903992 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.7578803896903992, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.7578803896903992, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15873576700687408, + 0.2697128653526306, + 0.1342814713716507, + 0.10298258066177368, + 0.04588614031672478, + 0.09692340344190598, + 0.074741430580616, + 0.02900662086904049, + 0.027172965928912163, + 0.06055672839283943 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.7578803896903992 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extremely close-up view of a sterile, stainless-steel hypodermic needle tip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a clear, viscous liquid erupt powerfully from the needle gap in a swift motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a cool, softly blurred, sterile blue-white environment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the liquid form a perfect arc before breaking into individual shimmering droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.31347426772117615 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3134742975234985 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.31347426772117615, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.31347426772117615, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.36507079005241394, + 0.16162577271461487, + 0.05714873597025871, + 0.06625090539455414, + 0.10838168114423752, + 0.05524042993783951, + 0.05364370718598366, + 0.04354088753461838, + 0.04405410215258598, + 0.045043013989925385 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.31347426772117615 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extremely close-up view of a sterile, stainless-steel hypodermic needle tip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a clear, viscous liquid erupt powerfully from the needle gap in a swift motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a cool, softly blurred, sterile blue-white environment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the liquid form a perfect arc before breaking into individual shimmering droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0015138844028115273 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.501513957977295 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0015138844028115273, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0015138844028115273, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2356797158718109, + 0.23415957391262054, + 0.1005987748503685, + 0.06305316090583801, + 0.12190365046262741, + 0.03824003040790558, + 0.020844552665948868, + 0.026032868772745132, + 0.05925140529870987, + 0.10023631155490875 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0015138844028115273 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extremely close-up view of a sterile, stainless-steel hypodermic needle tip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a clear, viscous liquid erupt powerfully from the needle gap in a swift motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a cool, softly blurred, sterile blue-white environment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the liquid form a perfect arc before breaking into individual shimmering droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0890544056892395 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4640543460845947 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0890544056892395, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0890544056892395, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3246348798274994, + 0.15060268342494965, + 0.12732133269309998, + 0.10535366833209991, + 0.04784320667386055, + 0.03968987613916397, + 0.04644591733813286, + 0.03166932612657547, + 0.06946180015802383, + 0.05697724595665932 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0890544056892395 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extremely close-up, static shot focuses with razor-sharp clarity on the angled tip of a sterile, stainless-steel hypodermic needle. The polished metal gleams in bright, direct light, revealing microscopic striations from its manufacturing process. Suddenly, a clear, viscous liquid powerfully erupts from the narrow gap in a swift and decisive eruption. The syrupy liquid catches the light, shimmering and forming a perfect arc against the cool, softly blurred, sterile blue-white background. The initial, cohesive spray of liquid lingers in the air for a moment before gracefully breaking into shimmering, individual droplets that follow the same trajectory. The entire scene is illuminated by cool, high-key lighting, creating sharp, mirror-like highlights on the needle and making each droplet shimmer, creating an atmosphere of intense focus, clinical precision, and controlled force.", + "seed": 228, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_10/index_5617_seed_228_dp_21_rank_42_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.33338707983493804, + "vlm_logprob": -0.33338707983493804, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.975, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.33338707983493804, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extremely close-up view of a sterile, stainless-steel hypodermic needle tip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a clear, viscous liquid erupt powerfully from the needle gap in a swift motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a cool, softly blurred, sterile blue-white environment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the liquid form a perfect arc before breaking into individual shimmering droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0924762710928917 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4674763679504395 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0924762710928917, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0924762710928917, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.012836441397666931, + 0.035838305950164795, + 0.012553186155855656, + 0.03863757103681564, + 0.00467546796426177, + 0.003194093005731702, + 0.028416531160473824, + 0.6867442727088928, + 0.04545775055885315, + 0.13164645433425903 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0924762710928917 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extremely close-up view of a sterile, stainless-steel hypodermic needle tip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a clear, viscous liquid erupt powerfully from the needle gap in a swift motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a cool, softly blurred, sterile blue-white environment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the liquid form a perfect arc before breaking into individual shimmering droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4063202142715454 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.281320184469223 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.4063202142715454, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -1.4063202142715454, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0059354123659431934, + 0.02769101783633232, + 0.01772288791835308, + 0.004423826467245817, + 0.004638135898858309, + 0.0036723115481436253, + 0.016444753855466843, + 0.5586699843406677, + 0.03610342741012573, + 0.324698269367218 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.4063202142715454 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extremely close-up view of a sterile, stainless-steel hypodermic needle tip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a clear, viscous liquid erupt powerfully from the needle gap in a swift motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a cool, softly blurred, sterile blue-white environment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the liquid form a perfect arc before breaking into individual shimmering droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.054996270686388016 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299962520599365 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.054996270686388016, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.054996270686388016, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.005975394044071436, + 0.00870948750525713, + 0.00839767325669527, + 0.017501557245850563, + 0.003007835242897272, + 0.007364917080849409, + 0.045074574649333954, + 0.06342975795269012, + 0.01145800482481718, + 0.8290808200836182 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.054996270686388016 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extremely close-up view of a sterile, stainless-steel hypodermic needle tip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a clear, viscous liquid erupt powerfully from the needle gap in a swift motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a cool, softly blurred, sterile blue-white environment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the liquid form a perfect arc before breaking into individual shimmering droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07005971670150757 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950597763061523 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07005971670150757, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07005971670150757, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.020784299820661545, + 0.01590684801340103, + 0.028620436787605286, + 0.020182613283395767, + 0.009721926413476467, + 0.005446602590382099, + 0.013451595790684223, + 0.5697532892227173, + 0.014116497710347176, + 0.30201590061187744 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07005971670150757 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extremely close-up view of a sterile, stainless-steel hypodermic needle tip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a clear, viscous liquid erupt powerfully from the needle gap in a swift motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a cool, softly blurred, sterile blue-white environment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the liquid form a perfect arc before breaking into individual shimmering droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04308292642235756 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680829524993896 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04308292642235756, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04308292642235756, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.00464659882709384, + 0.010058012790977955, + 0.0061661358922719955, + 0.006173437461256981, + 0.0018454723758623004, + 0.00318342843092978, + 0.013026830740272999, + 0.05639827251434326, + 0.008469334803521633, + 0.8900324106216431 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04308292642235756 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_11/index_tensor([2992, 2992])_group_11_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_11/index_tensor([2992, 2992])_group_11_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..b20547cf1934e5e5afc5c9ba4d983592fbb56964 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_11/index_tensor([2992, 2992])_group_11_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "steady, low-angle, static wide shot captures the towering silhouettes of a modern city. These sharp, geometric skyscrapers stand silently in pure black in the lower half of the frame. A strong desaturated color grading is employed throughout, creating a calm yet striking black-and-white quality. The sky is a deep, almost black canvas. Amidst this silent grandeur, a total lunar eclipse unfolds: Earth's umbra, like an invisible curtain, steadily and relentlessly engulfs the moon's luminous silver disk. As the last shimmer of silver light is swallowed by darkness, the moon, far from disappearing, glows a deep, saturated, blood-red. In this almost entirely monochrome world, the crimson moon provides the sole, breathtaking source of color, its ominous and majestic halo standing out against the stark black-and-white contrast. The entire dynamic unfolds silently, creating an apocalyptic, awe-inspiring stillness and visual tension.", + "seed": 7555, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_11/index_2992_seed_7555_dp_22_rank_44_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.1123276336118579, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1123276336118579, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.925, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1123276336118579, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static wide shot with a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are sharp, geometric skyscrapers visible as silhouettes in the lower half of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered with a desaturated, black-and-white color grading?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the moon glow a deep, saturated blood-red color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky depicted as a deep, almost black canvas?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.18669049441814423 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8116904497146606 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.18669049441814423, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.18669049441814423, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.47020915150642395, + 0.03924834728240967, + 0.2658286690711975, + 0.07911865413188934, + 0.05001481994986534, + 0.015564631670713425, + 0.023095939308404922, + 0.02587014250457287, + 0.007439866196364164, + 0.023609798401594162 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.18669049441814423 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static wide shot with a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are sharp, geometric skyscrapers visible as silhouettes in the lower half of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered with a desaturated, black-and-white color grading?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the moon glow a deep, saturated blood-red color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky depicted as a deep, almost black canvas?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0086548225954175 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758654594421387 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0086548225954175, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0086548225954175, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.676114559173584, + 0.030779659748077393, + 0.0646883100271225, + 0.0840803012251854, + 0.028615718707442284, + 0.022555433213710785, + 0.020405586808919907, + 0.02372068539261818, + 0.01317109726369381, + 0.03586875647306442 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0086548225954175 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static wide shot with a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are sharp, geometric skyscrapers visible as silhouettes in the lower half of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered with a desaturated, black-and-white color grading?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the moon glow a deep, saturated blood-red color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky depicted as a deep, almost black canvas?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3135640025138855 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3135640621185303 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3135640025138855, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3135640025138855, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3511582314968109, + 0.0523143969476223, + 0.19989129900932312, + 0.07338063418865204, + 0.10484950989484787, + 0.029411345720291138, + 0.0507972352206707, + 0.06558553129434586, + 0.04014391079545021, + 0.03246790170669556 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3135640025138855 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static wide shot with a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are sharp, geometric skyscrapers visible as silhouettes in the lower half of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered with a desaturated, black-and-white color grading?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the moon glow a deep, saturated blood-red color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky depicted as a deep, almost black canvas?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02638462744653225 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513845920562744 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02638462744653225, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02638462744653225, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.539417028427124, + 0.08424022793769836, + 0.08540231734514236, + 0.04842672124505043, + 0.03731834143400192, + 0.019654249772429466, + 0.03265591710805893, + 0.048187028616666794, + 0.060013752430677414, + 0.04468443617224693 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02638462744653225 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static wide shot with a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are sharp, geometric skyscrapers visible as silhouettes in the lower half of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered with a desaturated, black-and-white color grading?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the moon glow a deep, saturated blood-red color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky depicted as a deep, almost black canvas?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026344221085309982 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513442993164062 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026344221085309982, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026344221085309982, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.606779932975769, + 0.027194708585739136, + 0.26467272639274597, + 0.022556645795702934, + 0.023197675123810768, + 0.011139577254652977, + 0.009574071504175663, + 0.007042279466986656, + 0.00799692515283823, + 0.01984553225338459 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026344221085309982 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "steady, low-angle, static wide shot captures the towering silhouettes of a modern city. These sharp, geometric skyscrapers stand silently in pure black in the lower half of the frame. A strong desaturated color grading is employed throughout, creating a calm yet striking black-and-white quality. The sky is a deep, almost black canvas. Amidst this silent grandeur, a total lunar eclipse unfolds: Earth's umbra, like an invisible curtain, steadily and relentlessly engulfs the moon's luminous silver disk. As the last shimmer of silver light is swallowed by darkness, the moon, far from disappearing, glows a deep, saturated, blood-red. In this almost entirely monochrome world, the crimson moon provides the sole, breathtaking source of color, its ominous and majestic halo standing out against the stark black-and-white contrast. The entire dynamic unfolds silently, creating an apocalyptic, awe-inspiring stillness and visual tension.", + "seed": 7556, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_11/index_2992_seed_7556_dp_22_rank_44_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.027157705556601287, + "vlm_logprob": -0.027157705556601287, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.975, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.027157705556601287, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static wide shot with a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are sharp, geometric skyscrapers visible as silhouettes in the lower half of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered with a desaturated, black-and-white color grading?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the moon glow a deep, saturated blood-red color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky depicted as a deep, almost black canvas?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07305797934532166 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6980578899383545 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07305797934532166, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07305797934532166, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04746955260634422, + 0.689159631729126, + 0.13191038370132446, + 0.03619597852230072, + 0.03200802952051163, + 0.02639690972864628, + 0.008974160067737103, + 0.008617888204753399, + 0.01159363891929388, + 0.007673945743590593 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07305797934532166 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static wide shot with a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are sharp, geometric skyscrapers visible as silhouettes in the lower half of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered with a desaturated, black-and-white color grading?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the moon glow a deep, saturated blood-red color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky depicted as a deep, almost black canvas?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014209873043000698 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264209747314453 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014209873043000698, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014209873043000698, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07338562607765198, + 0.4022088646888733, + 0.15947063267230988, + 0.12468375265598297, + 0.043780457228422165, + 0.02421659417450428, + 0.01617739163339138, + 0.03350852057337761, + 0.07335229963064194, + 0.0492158979177475 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014209873043000698 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static wide shot with a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are sharp, geometric skyscrapers visible as silhouettes in the lower half of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered with a desaturated, black-and-white color grading?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the moon glow a deep, saturated blood-red color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky depicted as a deep, almost black canvas?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0233097355812788 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7733097076416016 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0233097355812788, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0233097355812788, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08821096271276474, + 0.1660947948694229, + 0.37875792384147644, + 0.026528138667345047, + 0.05830514430999756, + 0.03440171480178833, + 0.02387363649904728, + 0.031102901324629784, + 0.024541344493627548, + 0.16818341612815857 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0233097355812788 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static wide shot with a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are sharp, geometric skyscrapers visible as silhouettes in the lower half of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered with a desaturated, black-and-white color grading?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the moon glow a deep, saturated blood-red color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky depicted as a deep, almost black canvas?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004641829524189234 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379642009735107 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004641829524189234, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004641829524189234, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11115267127752304, + 0.29661276936531067, + 0.16525384783744812, + 0.08041728287935257, + 0.06633250415325165, + 0.02371656522154808, + 0.03429684042930603, + 0.06051125377416611, + 0.07526592910289764, + 0.08644041419029236 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004641829524189234 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static wide shot with a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are sharp, geometric skyscrapers visible as silhouettes in the lower half of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered with a desaturated, black-and-white color grading?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the moon glow a deep, saturated blood-red color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky depicted as a deep, almost black canvas?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02056911028921604 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895569086074829 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02056911028921604, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02056911028921604, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07759897410869598, + 0.3482120633125305, + 0.30884549021720886, + 0.03663003072142601, + 0.04606933891773224, + 0.10542021691799164, + 0.007232331670820713, + 0.015916679054498672, + 0.013208321295678616, + 0.04086661338806152 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02056911028921604 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "steady, low-angle, static wide shot captures the towering silhouettes of a modern city. These sharp, geometric skyscrapers stand silently in pure black in the lower half of the frame. A strong desaturated color grading is employed throughout, creating a calm yet striking black-and-white quality. The sky is a deep, almost black canvas. Amidst this silent grandeur, a total lunar eclipse unfolds: Earth's umbra, like an invisible curtain, steadily and relentlessly engulfs the moon's luminous silver disk. As the last shimmer of silver light is swallowed by darkness, the moon, far from disappearing, glows a deep, saturated, blood-red. In this almost entirely monochrome world, the crimson moon provides the sole, breathtaking source of color, its ominous and majestic halo standing out against the stark black-and-white contrast. The entire dynamic unfolds silently, creating an apocalyptic, awe-inspiring stillness and visual tension.", + "seed": 7557, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_11/index_2992_seed_7557_dp_23_rank_46_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.0453023012727499, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0453023012727499, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.575, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0453023012727499, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static wide shot with a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are sharp, geometric skyscrapers visible as silhouettes in the lower half of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered with a desaturated, black-and-white color grading?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the moon glow a deep, saturated blood-red color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky depicted as a deep, almost black canvas?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1345205157995224 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2595205307006836 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1345205157995224, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1345205157995224, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06828900426626205, + 0.04383840784430504, + 0.023945987224578857, + 0.23023049533367157, + 0.22495034337043762, + 0.3717065453529358, + 0.009372248314321041, + 0.008575810119509697, + 0.007096376270055771, + 0.011994758620858192 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1345205157995224 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static wide shot with a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are sharp, geometric skyscrapers visible as silhouettes in the lower half of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered with a desaturated, black-and-white color grading?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the moon glow a deep, saturated blood-red color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky depicted as a deep, almost black canvas?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029836736619472504 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529836654663086 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029836736619472504, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029836736619472504, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2725885510444641, + 0.0437750518321991, + 0.048578228801488876, + 0.14758974313735962, + 0.2516683042049408, + 0.148079514503479, + 0.017469653859734535, + 0.02452634461224079, + 0.025037987157702446, + 0.02068656124174595 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029836736619472504 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static wide shot with a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are sharp, geometric skyscrapers visible as silhouettes in the lower half of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered with a desaturated, black-and-white color grading?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the moon glow a deep, saturated blood-red color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky depicted as a deep, almost black canvas?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02637499012053013 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513750553131104 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02637499012053013, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02637499012053013, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4540310204029083, + 0.21121592819690704, + 0.05806535854935646, + 0.04128880053758621, + 0.0703926607966423, + 0.024363428354263306, + 0.02337653562426567, + 0.023486969992518425, + 0.04137629643082619, + 0.05240306258201599 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02637499012053013 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static wide shot with a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are sharp, geometric skyscrapers visible as silhouettes in the lower half of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered with a desaturated, black-and-white color grading?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the moon glow a deep, saturated blood-red color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky depicted as a deep, almost black canvas?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029832107946276665 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529832124710083 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029832107946276665, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029832107946276665, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20135414600372314, + 0.04502645507454872, + 0.2556292712688446, + 0.03118952363729477, + 0.08646783977746964, + 0.020733490586280823, + 0.01096898503601551, + 0.0432962104678154, + 0.1611708402633667, + 0.14416320621967316 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029832107946276665 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static wide shot with a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are sharp, geometric skyscrapers visible as silhouettes in the lower half of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered with a desaturated, black-and-white color grading?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the moon glow a deep, saturated blood-red color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky depicted as a deep, almost black canvas?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005947155877947807 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130947113037109 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005947155877947807, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005947155877947807, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3575817942619324, + 0.23888516426086426, + 0.06904885917901993, + 0.07097713649272919, + 0.13298380374908447, + 0.041786838322877884, + 0.009249814786016941, + 0.01277829334139824, + 0.02770429290831089, + 0.03900397941470146 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005947155877947807 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "steady, low-angle, static wide shot captures the towering silhouettes of a modern city. These sharp, geometric skyscrapers stand silently in pure black in the lower half of the frame. A strong desaturated color grading is employed throughout, creating a calm yet striking black-and-white quality. The sky is a deep, almost black canvas. Amidst this silent grandeur, a total lunar eclipse unfolds: Earth's umbra, like an invisible curtain, steadily and relentlessly engulfs the moon's luminous silver disk. As the last shimmer of silver light is swallowed by darkness, the moon, far from disappearing, glows a deep, saturated, blood-red. In this almost entirely monochrome world, the crimson moon provides the sole, breathtaking source of color, its ominous and majestic halo standing out against the stark black-and-white contrast. The entire dynamic unfolds silently, creating an apocalyptic, awe-inspiring stillness and visual tension.", + "seed": 7558, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_11/index_2992_seed_7558_dp_23_rank_46_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.037798077519983056, + "vlm_logprob": -0.037798077519983056, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.825, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.037798077519983056, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static wide shot with a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are sharp, geometric skyscrapers visible as silhouettes in the lower half of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered with a desaturated, black-and-white color grading?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the moon glow a deep, saturated blood-red color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky depicted as a deep, almost black canvas?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06647102534770966 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8164710998535156 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06647102534770966, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06647102534770966, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15146778523921967, + 0.06002049520611763, + 0.01869776099920273, + 0.042591679841279984, + 0.18600958585739136, + 0.22529691457748413, + 0.1338852494955063, + 0.04536288604140282, + 0.10706982761621475, + 0.029597871005535126 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06647102534770966 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static wide shot with a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are sharp, geometric skyscrapers visible as silhouettes in the lower half of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered with a desaturated, black-and-white color grading?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the moon glow a deep, saturated blood-red color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky depicted as a deep, almost black canvas?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01820170320570469 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.01820182800293 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01820170320570469, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01820170320570469, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1855688989162445, + 0.10913549363613129, + 0.024767251685261726, + 0.05792989954352379, + 0.04865223541855812, + 0.11660583317279816, + 0.1475551873445511, + 0.051639389246702194, + 0.2300175279378891, + 0.028128309175372124 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01820170320570469 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static wide shot with a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are sharp, geometric skyscrapers visible as silhouettes in the lower half of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered with a desaturated, black-and-white color grading?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the moon glow a deep, saturated blood-red color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky depicted as a deep, almost black canvas?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0891508013010025 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.464150905609131 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0891508013010025, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0891508013010025, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07119666785001755, + 0.06421410292387009, + 0.022154556587338448, + 0.03444354236125946, + 0.08379856497049332, + 0.19881194829940796, + 0.19849948585033417, + 0.06151924654841423, + 0.2171972095966339, + 0.0481647290289402 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0891508013010025 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static wide shot with a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are sharp, geometric skyscrapers visible as silhouettes in the lower half of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered with a desaturated, black-and-white color grading?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the moon glow a deep, saturated blood-red color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky depicted as a deep, almost black canvas?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0041004871018230915 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504100322723389 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0041004871018230915, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0041004871018230915, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13000713288784027, + 0.10293904691934586, + 0.025022435933351517, + 0.03708978369832039, + 0.07121685147285461, + 0.17075511813163757, + 0.08072957396507263, + 0.11659156531095505, + 0.17715086042881012, + 0.08849763870239258 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0041004871018230915 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static wide shot with a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are sharp, geometric skyscrapers visible as silhouettes in the lower half of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered with a desaturated, black-and-white color grading?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the moon glow a deep, saturated blood-red color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky depicted as a deep, almost black canvas?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011066370643675327 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511066436767578 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011066370643675327, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011066370643675327, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1255996972322464, + 0.07930358499288559, + 0.027965271845459938, + 0.029069460928440094, + 0.12132633477449417, + 0.08670102804899216, + 0.32185542583465576, + 0.06339694559574127, + 0.07475661486387253, + 0.07002568244934082 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011066370643675327 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_12/index_tensor([6274, 6274])_group_12_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_12/index_tensor([6274, 6274])_group_12_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..b24ed7e5cd2cc26fd261f846e12f989cb205c302 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_12/index_tensor([6274, 6274])_group_12_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "In one uninterrupted shot, the camera, at eye level, performs a slow, graceful 360-degree orbit around a serene, white-bearded sage seated in perfect lotus pose beneath a majestic, stylized tree. The sage, his long, flowing white beard resting on his chest, his eyes gently closed, lost in deep meditation, maintaining absolute stillness. His body is clad in a simple off-white silk robe. The tree above him is a fantastical creation, with a gnarled, pearly trunk gracefully winding toward a crown of crystal leaves that shimmer with a soft inner glow. The background is a dreamy, soft-focus, pastel-colored cloudscape. As the camera glides, a point of light appears on the glowing mossy ground next to the sage, sprouting a new life cycle – a magical plant majestically accelerating its life cycle. The stem spirals upward, unfurling its leaves to reveal an intricate, bioluminescent, whimsical pattern. The flowers then blossom into a vibrant spectacle of unfolding fractals and incredible colors, releasing soft pulses of light. Simultaneously, these same intricate patterns begin to flow and echo across the surface of the saint's robes and ripple across the dreamlike background, visually weaving the saint, the plants, and the universe into a single, interconnected tapestry of quiet magic and unfolding wonder.", + "seed": 20847, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_12/index_6274_seed_20847_dp_24_rank_48_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.03458128706552088, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03458128706552088, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.725, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03458128706552088, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a white-bearded sage seated in a lotus pose visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sage wearing a simple off-white silk robe?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a fantastical tree with a pearly trunk and crystal leaves glowing above the sage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, graceful 360-degree orbit around the sage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a magical plant sprout from the ground and bloom with bioluminescent fractal patterns that ripple onto the sage's robes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008943026885390282 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.7589430809021 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008943026885390282, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008943026885390282, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06896426528692245, + 0.08631238341331482, + 0.0660276710987091, + 0.09929829835891724, + 0.041672397404909134, + 0.05714327096939087, + 0.25003504753112793, + 0.17616009712219238, + 0.11234685033559799, + 0.04203972592949867 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008943026885390282 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a white-bearded sage seated in a lotus pose visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sage wearing a simple off-white silk robe?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a fantastical tree with a pearly trunk and crystal leaves glowing above the sage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, graceful 360-degree orbit around the sage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a magical plant sprout from the ground and bloom with bioluminescent fractal patterns that ripple onto the sage's robes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14276407659053802 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.017764091491699 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14276407659053802, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14276407659053802, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.6440396308898926, + 0.03276977315545082, + 0.040613528341054916, + 0.01854703575372696, + 0.05097762495279312, + 0.023088917136192322, + 0.04840211942791939, + 0.044282883405685425, + 0.06970949470996857, + 0.027569003403186798 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14276407659053802 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a white-bearded sage seated in a lotus pose visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sage wearing a simple off-white silk robe?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a fantastical tree with a pearly trunk and crystal leaves glowing above the sage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, graceful 360-degree orbit around the sage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a magical plant sprout from the ground and bloom with bioluminescent fractal patterns that ripple onto the sage's robes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0015140033792704344 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.501513957977295 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0015140033792704344, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0015140033792704344, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4624955654144287, + 0.09729121625423431, + 0.1247294619679451, + 0.0384167842566967, + 0.060850609093904495, + 0.022663481533527374, + 0.09059228003025055, + 0.04818092659115791, + 0.03037463128566742, + 0.02440500259399414 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0015140033792704344 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a white-bearded sage seated in a lotus pose visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sage wearing a simple off-white silk robe?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a fantastical tree with a pearly trunk and crystal leaves glowing above the sage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, graceful 360-degree orbit around the sage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a magical plant sprout from the ground and bloom with bioluminescent fractal patterns that ripple onto the sage's robes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018174896016716957 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.01817512512207 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018174896016716957, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018174896016716957, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16839119791984558, + 0.12186897546052933, + 0.0470254123210907, + 0.07741528004407883, + 0.07127940654754639, + 0.018683265894651413, + 0.2668674886226654, + 0.037599097937345505, + 0.10140163451433182, + 0.08946827054023743 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018174896016716957 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a white-bearded sage seated in a lotus pose visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sage wearing a simple off-white silk robe?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a fantastical tree with a pearly trunk and crystal leaves glowing above the sage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, graceful 360-degree orbit around the sage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a magical plant sprout from the ground and bloom with bioluminescent fractal patterns that ripple onto the sage's robes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.001510432455688715 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.5015106201171875 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.001510432455688715, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.001510432455688715, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2394505888223648, + 0.06883981823921204, + 0.08301617950201035, + 0.05679039657115936, + 0.07026372104883194, + 0.04293494671583176, + 0.2567065358161926, + 0.06896606832742691, + 0.03644786775112152, + 0.0765838772058487 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.001510432455688715 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In one uninterrupted shot, the camera, at eye level, performs a slow, graceful 360-degree orbit around a serene, white-bearded sage seated in perfect lotus pose beneath a majestic, stylized tree. The sage, his long, flowing white beard resting on his chest, his eyes gently closed, lost in deep meditation, maintaining absolute stillness. His body is clad in a simple off-white silk robe. The tree above him is a fantastical creation, with a gnarled, pearly trunk gracefully winding toward a crown of crystal leaves that shimmer with a soft inner glow. The background is a dreamy, soft-focus, pastel-colored cloudscape. As the camera glides, a point of light appears on the glowing mossy ground next to the sage, sprouting a new life cycle – a magical plant majestically accelerating its life cycle. The stem spirals upward, unfurling its leaves to reveal an intricate, bioluminescent, whimsical pattern. The flowers then blossom into a vibrant spectacle of unfolding fractals and incredible colors, releasing soft pulses of light. Simultaneously, these same intricate patterns begin to flow and echo across the surface of the saint's robes and ripple across the dreamlike background, visually weaving the saint, the plants, and the universe into a single, interconnected tapestry of quiet magic and unfolding wonder.", + "seed": 20848, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_12/index_6274_seed_20848_dp_24_rank_48_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.025287280883640052, + "vlm_logprob": -0.025287280883640052, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.3, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.025287280883640052, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a white-bearded sage seated in a lotus pose visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sage wearing a simple off-white silk robe?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a fantastical tree with a pearly trunk and crystal leaves glowing above the sage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, graceful 360-degree orbit around the sage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a magical plant sprout from the ground and bloom with bioluminescent fractal patterns that ripple onto the sage's robes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023593515157699585 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7735934257507324 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023593515157699585, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023593515157699585, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5009970664978027, + 0.0622609443962574, + 0.09114798903465271, + 0.03953222185373306, + 0.0408608578145504, + 0.026151716709136963, + 0.03570445999503136, + 0.03099813498556614, + 0.13041642308235168, + 0.04193023592233658 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023593515157699585 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a white-bearded sage seated in a lotus pose visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sage wearing a simple off-white silk robe?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a fantastical tree with a pearly trunk and crystal leaves glowing above the sage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, graceful 360-degree orbit around the sage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a magical plant sprout from the ground and bloom with bioluminescent fractal patterns that ripple onto the sage's robes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07895463705062866 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5789546966552734 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07895463705062866, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07895463705062866, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.40472662448883057, + 0.05921557545661926, + 0.05251414328813553, + 0.12248601019382477, + 0.06215079501271248, + 0.02656552381813526, + 0.04179492965340614, + 0.0617925301194191, + 0.1099381148815155, + 0.05881572142243385 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07895463705062866 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a white-bearded sage seated in a lotus pose visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sage wearing a simple off-white silk robe?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a fantastical tree with a pearly trunk and crystal leaves glowing above the sage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, graceful 360-degree orbit around the sage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a magical plant sprout from the ground and bloom with bioluminescent fractal patterns that ripple onto the sage's robes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003193756565451622 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.7531938552856445 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003193756565451622, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003193756565451622, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.48581984639167786, + 0.09816651791334152, + 0.05600455030798912, + 0.024005696177482605, + 0.057785551995038986, + 0.04682968929409981, + 0.07909870147705078, + 0.04952521622180939, + 0.048591144382953644, + 0.05417311564087868 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003193756565451622 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a white-bearded sage seated in a lotus pose visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sage wearing a simple off-white silk robe?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a fantastical tree with a pearly trunk and crystal leaves glowing above the sage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, graceful 360-degree orbit around the sage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a magical plant sprout from the ground and bloom with bioluminescent fractal patterns that ripple onto the sage's robes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01606132835149765 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141061305999756 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01606132835149765, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01606132835149765, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4840497672557831, + 0.04390527307987213, + 0.05801417678594589, + 0.050888657569885254, + 0.042866721749305725, + 0.06701914221048355, + 0.09591779112815857, + 0.05446098744869232, + 0.07029566168785095, + 0.03258184716105461 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01606132835149765 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a white-bearded sage seated in a lotus pose visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sage wearing a simple off-white silk robe?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a fantastical tree with a pearly trunk and crystal leaves glowing above the sage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, graceful 360-degree orbit around the sage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a magical plant sprout from the ground and bloom with bioluminescent fractal patterns that ripple onto the sage's robes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004633167292922735 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379632949829102 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004633167292922735, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004633167292922735, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23524309694766998, + 0.06872351467609406, + 0.04846179857850075, + 0.02676793560385704, + 0.086674764752388, + 0.15277695655822754, + 0.15641999244689941, + 0.12985549867153168, + 0.054432712495326996, + 0.040643706917762756 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004633167292922735 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In one uninterrupted shot, the camera, at eye level, performs a slow, graceful 360-degree orbit around a serene, white-bearded sage seated in perfect lotus pose beneath a majestic, stylized tree. The sage, his long, flowing white beard resting on his chest, his eyes gently closed, lost in deep meditation, maintaining absolute stillness. His body is clad in a simple off-white silk robe. The tree above him is a fantastical creation, with a gnarled, pearly trunk gracefully winding toward a crown of crystal leaves that shimmer with a soft inner glow. The background is a dreamy, soft-focus, pastel-colored cloudscape. As the camera glides, a point of light appears on the glowing mossy ground next to the sage, sprouting a new life cycle – a magical plant majestically accelerating its life cycle. The stem spirals upward, unfurling its leaves to reveal an intricate, bioluminescent, whimsical pattern. The flowers then blossom into a vibrant spectacle of unfolding fractals and incredible colors, releasing soft pulses of light. Simultaneously, these same intricate patterns begin to flow and echo across the surface of the saint's robes and ripple across the dreamlike background, visually weaving the saint, the plants, and the universe into a single, interconnected tapestry of quiet magic and unfolding wonder.", + "seed": 20849, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_12/index_6274_seed_20849_dp_25_rank_50_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.023362133372575044, + "vlm_logprob": -0.023362133372575044, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.025, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.023362133372575044, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a white-bearded sage seated in a lotus pose visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sage wearing a simple off-white silk robe?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a fantastical tree with a pearly trunk and crystal leaves glowing above the sage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, graceful 360-degree orbit around the sage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a magical plant sprout from the ground and bloom with bioluminescent fractal patterns that ripple onto the sage's robes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02344983071088791 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7734498977661133 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02344983071088791, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02344983071088791, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18193122744560242, + 0.0617009773850441, + 0.11549236625432968, + 0.06173647940158844, + 0.05442489683628082, + 0.08793313801288605, + 0.07807943224906921, + 0.13394184410572052, + 0.11416541785001755, + 0.1105942502617836 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02344983071088791 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a white-bearded sage seated in a lotus pose visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sage wearing a simple off-white silk robe?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a fantastical tree with a pearly trunk and crystal leaves glowing above the sage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, graceful 360-degree orbit around the sage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a magical plant sprout from the ground and bloom with bioluminescent fractal patterns that ripple onto the sage's robes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0430484414100647 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.16804838180542 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0430484414100647, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0430484414100647, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2752951681613922, + 0.05181245505809784, + 0.07372167706489563, + 0.06489928066730499, + 0.06371887773275375, + 0.04675093665719032, + 0.10475798696279526, + 0.055143803358078, + 0.12943591177463531, + 0.1344638615846634 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0430484414100647 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a white-bearded sage seated in a lotus pose visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sage wearing a simple off-white silk robe?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a fantastical tree with a pearly trunk and crystal leaves glowing above the sage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, graceful 360-degree orbit around the sage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a magical plant sprout from the ground and bloom with bioluminescent fractal patterns that ripple onto the sage's robes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004095145035535097 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504095077514648 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004095145035535097, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004095145035535097, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2571004033088684, + 0.0718938410282135, + 0.24967464804649353, + 0.08588683605194092, + 0.09593421965837479, + 0.04599066451191902, + 0.032716408371925354, + 0.04039321094751358, + 0.05912971496582031, + 0.0612800270318985 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004095145035535097 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a white-bearded sage seated in a lotus pose visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sage wearing a simple off-white silk robe?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a fantastical tree with a pearly trunk and crystal leaves glowing above the sage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, graceful 360-degree orbit around the sage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a magical plant sprout from the ground and bloom with bioluminescent fractal patterns that ripple onto the sage's robes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.033685192465782166 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4086852073669434 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.033685192465782166, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.033685192465782166, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3990333378314972, + 0.060969408601522446, + 0.06544695794582367, + 0.08217895030975342, + 0.05782567709684372, + 0.03389570116996765, + 0.04242877662181854, + 0.12491808831691742, + 0.06056073307991028, + 0.07274232059717178 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.033685192465782166 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a white-bearded sage seated in a lotus pose visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sage wearing a simple off-white silk robe?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a fantastical tree with a pearly trunk and crystal leaves glowing above the sage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, graceful 360-degree orbit around the sage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a magical plant sprout from the ground and bloom with bioluminescent fractal patterns that ripple onto the sage's robes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012532057240605354 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.3875322341918945 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012532057240605354, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012532057240605354, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2758130431175232, + 0.06614713370800018, + 0.17561446130275726, + 0.12646475434303284, + 0.060720257461071014, + 0.06436388194561005, + 0.04086367040872574, + 0.04524363949894905, + 0.05805595964193344, + 0.08671315014362335 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012532057240605354 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In one uninterrupted shot, the camera, at eye level, performs a slow, graceful 360-degree orbit around a serene, white-bearded sage seated in perfect lotus pose beneath a majestic, stylized tree. The sage, his long, flowing white beard resting on his chest, his eyes gently closed, lost in deep meditation, maintaining absolute stillness. His body is clad in a simple off-white silk robe. The tree above him is a fantastical creation, with a gnarled, pearly trunk gracefully winding toward a crown of crystal leaves that shimmer with a soft inner glow. The background is a dreamy, soft-focus, pastel-colored cloudscape. As the camera glides, a point of light appears on the glowing mossy ground next to the sage, sprouting a new life cycle – a magical plant majestically accelerating its life cycle. The stem spirals upward, unfurling its leaves to reveal an intricate, bioluminescent, whimsical pattern. The flowers then blossom into a vibrant spectacle of unfolding fractals and incredible colors, releasing soft pulses of light. Simultaneously, these same intricate patterns begin to flow and echo across the surface of the saint's robes and ripple across the dreamlike background, visually weaving the saint, the plants, and the universe into a single, interconnected tapestry of quiet magic and unfolding wonder.", + "seed": 20850, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_12/index_6274_seed_20850_dp_25_rank_50_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.025828035175800325, + "vlm_logprob": -0.025828035175800325, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.475, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.025828035175800325, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a white-bearded sage seated in a lotus pose visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sage wearing a simple off-white silk robe?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a fantastical tree with a pearly trunk and crystal leaves glowing above the sage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, graceful 360-degree orbit around the sage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a magical plant sprout from the ground and bloom with bioluminescent fractal patterns that ripple onto the sage's robes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006063873879611492 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.131063938140869 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006063873879611492, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006063873879611492, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19678324460983276, + 0.1414787769317627, + 0.06531935185194016, + 0.048874616622924805, + 0.07054344564676285, + 0.29770055413246155, + 0.07064813375473022, + 0.03106280043721199, + 0.029124058783054352, + 0.048464998602867126 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006063873879611492 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a white-bearded sage seated in a lotus pose visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sage wearing a simple off-white silk robe?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a fantastical tree with a pearly trunk and crystal leaves glowing above the sage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, graceful 360-degree orbit around the sage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a magical plant sprout from the ground and bloom with bioluminescent fractal patterns that ripple onto the sage's robes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08900674432516098 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4640066623687744 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08900674432516098, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08900674432516098, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1841035634279251, + 0.1550006866455078, + 0.0883975625038147, + 0.10437997430562973, + 0.09601487219333649, + 0.1880885809659958, + 0.03717677295207977, + 0.04229620844125748, + 0.03604372590780258, + 0.06849806010723114 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08900674432516098 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a white-bearded sage seated in a lotus pose visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sage wearing a simple off-white silk robe?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a fantastical tree with a pearly trunk and crystal leaves glowing above the sage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, graceful 360-degree orbit around the sage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a magical plant sprout from the ground and bloom with bioluminescent fractal patterns that ripple onto the sage's robes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002488494385033846 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002488613128662 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002488494385033846, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002488494385033846, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1876813769340515, + 0.27236756682395935, + 0.1210145652294159, + 0.03359641879796982, + 0.0669664591550827, + 0.028231250122189522, + 0.05253075435757637, + 0.1367143988609314, + 0.026463713496923447, + 0.07443347573280334 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002488494385033846 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a white-bearded sage seated in a lotus pose visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sage wearing a simple off-white silk robe?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a fantastical tree with a pearly trunk and crystal leaves glowing above the sage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, graceful 360-degree orbit around the sage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a magical plant sprout from the ground and bloom with bioluminescent fractal patterns that ripple onto the sage's robes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02633284218609333 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513328552246094 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02633284218609333, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02633284218609333, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.26055917143821716, + 0.12660256028175354, + 0.08189272880554199, + 0.044966552406549454, + 0.08463998883962631, + 0.10810256749391556, + 0.04242270067334175, + 0.15391500294208527, + 0.04124131053686142, + 0.05565737932920456 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02633284218609333 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a white-bearded sage seated in a lotus pose visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sage wearing a simple off-white silk robe?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a fantastical tree with a pearly trunk and crystal leaves glowing above the sage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, graceful 360-degree orbit around the sage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a magical plant sprout from the ground and bloom with bioluminescent fractal patterns that ripple onto the sage's robes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005248221103101969 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255248069763184 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005248221103101969, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005248221103101969, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06942806392908096, + 0.06419622898101807, + 0.11118096113204956, + 0.05916774272918701, + 0.05750325322151184, + 0.06520586460828781, + 0.09476957470178604, + 0.29199403524398804, + 0.04140855371952057, + 0.1451457142829895 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005248221103101969 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_13/index_tensor([9568, 9568])_group_13_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_13/index_tensor([9568, 9568])_group_13_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..3bd4937949b65b7131b892c0c44883658f587a8e --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_13/index_tensor([9568, 9568])_group_13_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "wide-angle shot, shot from a slightly upward angle, the camera slowly panning forward, accompanied by a gentle, irregular sway simulated by wind, captures the breathtaking spectacle of an ancient chain bridge swaying violently over a bottomless chasm. The sky is shrouded in thick, swirling clouds, as dark as ink. Pale, forked lightning occasionally rips through the canopy, each flash momentarily illuminating the bridge's thick chains, coated in dark brown grains of rust, and its slippery, dark wood, soaked by the torrential rain and reflecting a cold, high-gloss light. Under the raging wind, the entire bridge groans under the weight, emitting a harsh sound of metal rubbing and wood squeezing. It twists and throbs in agony like a dying python, and through the gaps in the planks, one can glimpse the endless darkness below, swallowed by the thick fog. This scene was built with the extremely high standards of the UE engine, presenting a film-like texture. Whether it is the traces of rain flowing on the iron chain or the wet texture of the wooden board, it has achieved a realistic level of detail. At the same time, a layer of subtle film grain is covered on the picture, which not only enhances the visual depth, but also creates a tense, epic and doomsday atmosphere of despair.", + "seed": 2885, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_13/index_9568_seed_2885_dp_26_rank_52_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.15005797259509562, + "vlm_logprob": -0.15005797259509562, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.25, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.15005797259509562, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an ancient chain bridge spanning a deep chasm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bridge swaying violently due to strong wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a sky with thick, dark, swirling clouds and occasional pale forked lightning?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a slightly upward angle and slowly panning forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the bridge chains coated in dark brown rust and the wooden planks wet with a high-gloss reflection?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05547816678881645 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.930478096008301 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05547816678881645, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05547816678881645, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13658475875854492, + 0.1788952350616455, + 0.028651556000113487, + 0.06132242828607559, + 0.06284234672784805, + 0.16478590667247772, + 0.04376896843314171, + 0.21891623735427856, + 0.07460582256317139, + 0.02962673082947731 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05547816678881645 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an ancient chain bridge spanning a deep chasm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bridge swaying violently due to strong wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a sky with thick, dark, swirling clouds and occasional pale forked lightning?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a slightly upward angle and slowly panning forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the bridge chains coated in dark brown rust and the wooden planks wet with a high-gloss reflection?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6328231692314148 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7578231692314148 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.6328231692314148, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.6328231692314148, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.36105018854141235, + 0.22930054366588593, + 0.11433867365121841, + 0.08204919099807739, + 0.022708136588335037, + 0.06705602258443832, + 0.019951829686760902, + 0.031639404594898224, + 0.037907153367996216, + 0.03399890288710594 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.6328231692314148 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an ancient chain bridge spanning a deep chasm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bridge swaying violently due to strong wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a sky with thick, dark, swirling clouds and occasional pale forked lightning?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a slightly upward angle and slowly panning forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the bridge chains coated in dark brown rust and the wooden planks wet with a high-gloss reflection?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.001939084380865097 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.251939296722412 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.001939084380865097, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.001939084380865097, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18649336695671082, + 0.1188533678650856, + 0.07063525915145874, + 0.048088666051626205, + 0.03272904455661774, + 0.05313269793987274, + 0.04908880218863487, + 0.3714675307273865, + 0.04566923528909683, + 0.023842038586735725 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.001939084380865097 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an ancient chain bridge spanning a deep chasm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bridge swaying violently due to strong wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a sky with thick, dark, swirling clouds and occasional pale forked lightning?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a slightly upward angle and slowly panning forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the bridge chains coated in dark brown rust and the wooden planks wet with a high-gloss reflection?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026340970769524574 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651340961456299 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026340970769524574, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026340970769524574, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04794546961784363, + 0.2184406965970993, + 0.051379017531871796, + 0.023430533707141876, + 0.04885568097233772, + 0.06098104268312454, + 0.034553688019514084, + 0.41946783661842346, + 0.05834300443530083, + 0.03660305216908455 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026340970769524574 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an ancient chain bridge spanning a deep chasm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bridge swaying violently due to strong wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a sky with thick, dark, swirling clouds and occasional pale forked lightning?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a slightly upward angle and slowly panning forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the bridge chains coated in dark brown rust and the wooden planks wet with a high-gloss reflection?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.033708471804857254 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4087085723876953 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.033708471804857254, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.033708471804857254, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07852018624544144, + 0.1202104240655899, + 0.06389690935611725, + 0.042526260018348694, + 0.045060448348522186, + 0.05930560082197189, + 0.0335693433880806, + 0.4748336374759674, + 0.05502082780003548, + 0.027056338265538216 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.033708471804857254 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "wide-angle shot, shot from a slightly upward angle, the camera slowly panning forward, accompanied by a gentle, irregular sway simulated by wind, captures the breathtaking spectacle of an ancient chain bridge swaying violently over a bottomless chasm. The sky is shrouded in thick, swirling clouds, as dark as ink. Pale, forked lightning occasionally rips through the canopy, each flash momentarily illuminating the bridge's thick chains, coated in dark brown grains of rust, and its slippery, dark wood, soaked by the torrential rain and reflecting a cold, high-gloss light. Under the raging wind, the entire bridge groans under the weight, emitting a harsh sound of metal rubbing and wood squeezing. It twists and throbs in agony like a dying python, and through the gaps in the planks, one can glimpse the endless darkness below, swallowed by the thick fog. This scene was built with the extremely high standards of the UE engine, presenting a film-like texture. Whether it is the traces of rain flowing on the iron chain or the wet texture of the wooden board, it has achieved a realistic level of detail. At the same time, a layer of subtle film grain is covered on the picture, which not only enhances the visual depth, but also creates a tense, epic and doomsday atmosphere of despair.", + "seed": 2886, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_13/index_9568_seed_2886_dp_26_rank_52_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.09524725563824177, + "vlm_logprob": -0.09524725563824177, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.675, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.09524725563824177, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an ancient chain bridge spanning a deep chasm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bridge swaying violently due to strong wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a sky with thick, dark, swirling clouds and occasional pale forked lightning?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a slightly upward angle and slowly panning forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the bridge chains coated in dark brown rust and the wooden planks wet with a high-gloss reflection?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05525822937488556 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.930258274078369 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05525822937488556, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05525822937488556, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.01692081242799759, + 0.005284113343805075, + 0.00657085282728076, + 0.014489400200545788, + 0.005256392993032932, + 0.0028103257063776255, + 0.008914472535252571, + 0.004525391850620508, + 0.021286707371473312, + 0.913941502571106 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05525822937488556 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an ancient chain bridge spanning a deep chasm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bridge swaying violently due to strong wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a sky with thick, dark, swirling clouds and occasional pale forked lightning?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a slightly upward angle and slowly panning forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the bridge chains coated in dark brown rust and the wooden planks wet with a high-gloss reflection?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3870871067047119 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.137087106704712 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3870871067047119, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3870871067047119, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.059134602546691895, + 0.02644474431872368, + 0.042534999549388885, + 0.03158101439476013, + 0.011772741563618183, + 0.014538301154971123, + 0.010319079272449017, + 0.011178928427398205, + 0.0599682442843914, + 0.7325272560119629 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3870871067047119 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an ancient chain bridge spanning a deep chasm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bridge swaying violently due to strong wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a sky with thick, dark, swirling clouds and occasional pale forked lightning?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a slightly upward angle and slowly panning forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the bridge chains coated in dark brown rust and the wooden planks wet with a high-gloss reflection?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00151078961789608 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.5015106201171875 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00151078961789608, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00151078961789608, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06261591613292694, + 0.051383763551712036, + 0.050089623779058456, + 0.038810186088085175, + 0.023542290553450584, + 0.013272522017359734, + 0.03782688081264496, + 0.025688018649816513, + 0.04032159969210625, + 0.6564491987228394 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00151078961789608 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an ancient chain bridge spanning a deep chasm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bridge swaying violently due to strong wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a sky with thick, dark, swirling clouds and occasional pale forked lightning?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a slightly upward angle and slowly panning forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the bridge chains coated in dark brown rust and the wooden planks wet with a high-gloss reflection?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018183089792728424 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.01818323135376 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018183089792728424, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018183089792728424, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.015731625258922577, + 0.006953964475542307, + 0.009416905231773853, + 0.014239685609936714, + 0.006602894980460405, + 0.0047852275893092155, + 0.013046509586274624, + 0.027608780190348625, + 0.049555134028196335, + 0.8520591855049133 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018183089792728424 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an ancient chain bridge spanning a deep chasm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bridge swaying violently due to strong wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a sky with thick, dark, swirling clouds and occasional pale forked lightning?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a slightly upward angle and slowly panning forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the bridge chains coated in dark brown rust and the wooden planks wet with a high-gloss reflection?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014197062700986862 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264196872711182 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014197062700986862, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014197062700986862, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18037967383861542, + 0.07497227191925049, + 0.034543830901384354, + 0.03985585272312164, + 0.03929879888892174, + 0.026104720309376717, + 0.0426686629652977, + 0.039763011038303375, + 0.10046212375164032, + 0.421951025724411 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014197062700986862 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "wide-angle shot, shot from a slightly upward angle, the camera slowly panning forward, accompanied by a gentle, irregular sway simulated by wind, captures the breathtaking spectacle of an ancient chain bridge swaying violently over a bottomless chasm. The sky is shrouded in thick, swirling clouds, as dark as ink. Pale, forked lightning occasionally rips through the canopy, each flash momentarily illuminating the bridge's thick chains, coated in dark brown grains of rust, and its slippery, dark wood, soaked by the torrential rain and reflecting a cold, high-gloss light. Under the raging wind, the entire bridge groans under the weight, emitting a harsh sound of metal rubbing and wood squeezing. It twists and throbs in agony like a dying python, and through the gaps in the planks, one can glimpse the endless darkness below, swallowed by the thick fog. This scene was built with the extremely high standards of the UE engine, presenting a film-like texture. Whether it is the traces of rain flowing on the iron chain or the wet texture of the wooden board, it has achieved a realistic level of detail. At the same time, a layer of subtle film grain is covered on the picture, which not only enhances the visual depth, but also creates a tense, epic and doomsday atmosphere of despair.", + "seed": 2887, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_13/index_9568_seed_2887_dp_27_rank_54_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.1494224055670202, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1494224055670202, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.3, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1494224055670202, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an ancient chain bridge spanning a deep chasm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bridge swaying violently due to strong wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a sky with thick, dark, swirling clouds and occasional pale forked lightning?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a slightly upward angle and slowly panning forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the bridge chains coated in dark brown rust and the wooden planks wet with a high-gloss reflection?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06271703541278839 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8127169609069824 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06271703541278839, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06271703541278839, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15148375928401947, + 0.16240528225898743, + 0.08462046086788177, + 0.08126062154769897, + 0.11527838557958603, + 0.17083439230918884, + 0.08783785998821259, + 0.038900479674339294, + 0.0175959300249815, + 0.08978284150362015 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06271703541278839 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an ancient chain bridge spanning a deep chasm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bridge swaying violently due to strong wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a sky with thick, dark, swirling clouds and occasional pale forked lightning?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a slightly upward angle and slowly panning forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the bridge chains coated in dark brown rust and the wooden planks wet with a high-gloss reflection?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6328133940696716 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7578133940696716 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.6328133940696716, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.6328133940696716, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09642627090215683, + 0.08281657844781876, + 0.07190944254398346, + 0.30035629868507385, + 0.011805699206888676, + 0.19991937279701233, + 0.1634184569120407, + 0.028710465878248215, + 0.016077585518360138, + 0.028559796512126923 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.6328133940696716 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an ancient chain bridge spanning a deep chasm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bridge swaying violently due to strong wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a sky with thick, dark, swirling clouds and occasional pale forked lightning?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a slightly upward angle and slowly panning forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the bridge chains coated in dark brown rust and the wooden planks wet with a high-gloss reflection?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0019393223337829113 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.251939296722412 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0019393223337829113, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0019393223337829113, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13541866838932037, + 0.05932779610157013, + 0.05339758098125458, + 0.26612532138824463, + 0.08895350992679596, + 0.07442211359739304, + 0.19362381100654602, + 0.037655096501111984, + 0.04647593945264816, + 0.04460013657808304 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0019393223337829113 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an ancient chain bridge spanning a deep chasm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bridge swaying violently due to strong wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a sky with thick, dark, swirling clouds and occasional pale forked lightning?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a slightly upward angle and slowly panning forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the bridge chains coated in dark brown rust and the wooden planks wet with a high-gloss reflection?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023286443203687668 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732863426208496 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023286443203687668, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023286443203687668, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08057834208011627, + 0.20149806141853333, + 0.06725168973207474, + 0.13220913708209991, + 0.06104235723614693, + 0.2951492667198181, + 0.06319382786750793, + 0.016955234110355377, + 0.05220336094498634, + 0.029918748885393143 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023286443203687668 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an ancient chain bridge spanning a deep chasm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bridge swaying violently due to strong wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a sky with thick, dark, swirling clouds and occasional pale forked lightning?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a slightly upward angle and slowly panning forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the bridge chains coated in dark brown rust and the wooden planks wet with a high-gloss reflection?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026355832815170288 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651355743408203 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026355832815170288, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026355832815170288, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10873531550168991, + 0.06864586472511292, + 0.05706886947154999, + 0.15830408036708832, + 0.11400055885314941, + 0.1440490037202835, + 0.1754949688911438, + 0.059495698660612106, + 0.018313545733690262, + 0.09589214622974396 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026355832815170288 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "wide-angle shot, shot from a slightly upward angle, the camera slowly panning forward, accompanied by a gentle, irregular sway simulated by wind, captures the breathtaking spectacle of an ancient chain bridge swaying violently over a bottomless chasm. The sky is shrouded in thick, swirling clouds, as dark as ink. Pale, forked lightning occasionally rips through the canopy, each flash momentarily illuminating the bridge's thick chains, coated in dark brown grains of rust, and its slippery, dark wood, soaked by the torrential rain and reflecting a cold, high-gloss light. Under the raging wind, the entire bridge groans under the weight, emitting a harsh sound of metal rubbing and wood squeezing. It twists and throbs in agony like a dying python, and through the gaps in the planks, one can glimpse the endless darkness below, swallowed by the thick fog. This scene was built with the extremely high standards of the UE engine, presenting a film-like texture. Whether it is the traces of rain flowing on the iron chain or the wet texture of the wooden board, it has achieved a realistic level of detail. At the same time, a layer of subtle film grain is covered on the picture, which not only enhances the visual depth, but also creates a tense, epic and doomsday atmosphere of despair.", + "seed": 2888, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_13/index_9568_seed_2888_dp_27_rank_54_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.08283442216925323, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08283442216925323, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.725, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08283442216925323, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an ancient chain bridge spanning a deep chasm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bridge swaying violently due to strong wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a sky with thick, dark, swirling clouds and occasional pale forked lightning?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a slightly upward angle and slowly panning forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the bridge chains coated in dark brown rust and the wooden planks wet with a high-gloss reflection?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02667972259223461 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651679754257202 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02667972259223461, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02667972259223461, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.49118220806121826, + 0.06400972604751587, + 0.0548846572637558, + 0.027051366865634918, + 0.05611002817749977, + 0.0366787314414978, + 0.02372889034450054, + 0.022600557655096054, + 0.0677851215004921, + 0.15596863627433777 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02667972259223461 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an ancient chain bridge spanning a deep chasm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bridge swaying violently due to strong wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a sky with thick, dark, swirling clouds and occasional pale forked lightning?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a slightly upward angle and slowly panning forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the bridge chains coated in dark brown rust and the wooden planks wet with a high-gloss reflection?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.34864354133605957 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2236435413360596 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.34864354133605957, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.34864354133605957, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09953003376722336, + 0.10170765221118927, + 0.05984262377023697, + 0.030316956341266632, + 0.13507723808288574, + 0.032739557325839996, + 0.05149451643228531, + 0.1535637527704239, + 0.22497686743736267, + 0.11075079441070557 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.34864354133605957 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an ancient chain bridge spanning a deep chasm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bridge swaying violently due to strong wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a sky with thick, dark, swirling clouds and occasional pale forked lightning?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a slightly upward angle and slowly panning forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the bridge chains coated in dark brown rust and the wooden planks wet with a high-gloss reflection?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0021956877317279577 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127195835113525 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0021956877317279577, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0021956877317279577, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4915568232536316, + 0.06184108555316925, + 0.05020523816347122, + 0.030775347724556923, + 0.07277184724807739, + 0.044828884303569794, + 0.08915925025939941, + 0.07395119965076447, + 0.02454160898923874, + 0.06036876142024994 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0021956877317279577 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an ancient chain bridge spanning a deep chasm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bridge swaying violently due to strong wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a sky with thick, dark, swirling clouds and occasional pale forked lightning?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a slightly upward angle and slowly panning forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the bridge chains coated in dark brown rust and the wooden planks wet with a high-gloss reflection?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020577870309352875 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895577907562256 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020577870309352875, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020577870309352875, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2941877841949463, + 0.1378944367170334, + 0.09863251447677612, + 0.07256410270929337, + 0.05479997768998146, + 0.10443191975355148, + 0.032836273312568665, + 0.02694806456565857, + 0.10209135711193085, + 0.0756135806441307 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020577870309352875 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an ancient chain bridge spanning a deep chasm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bridge swaying violently due to strong wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a sky with thick, dark, swirling clouds and occasional pale forked lightning?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a slightly upward angle and slowly panning forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the bridge chains coated in dark brown rust and the wooden planks wet with a high-gloss reflection?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016075288876891136 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141075134277344 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016075288876891136, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016075288876891136, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4275997281074524, + 0.0600561648607254, + 0.06794009357690811, + 0.0331876203417778, + 0.08332868665456772, + 0.13152572512626648, + 0.018052637577056885, + 0.04442106932401657, + 0.062144048511981964, + 0.07174424082040787 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016075288876891136 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_14/index_tensor([161, 161])_group_14_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_14/index_tensor([161, 161])_group_14_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..5bcf11a8ec4b8fc4329a1766b5e67d8df1ba8a8f --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_14/index_tensor([161, 161])_group_14_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "low-angle, static shot depicts the rear of a pearlescent white, wedge-shaped supercar, parked on a rain-slicked city street at night. Its low-slung chassis is all sharp angles and aggressive lines, culminating in a mesmerizing array of vibrant, glowing crimson hexagonal taillights, brimming with potential energy. The surrounding architecture is a symphony of towering Art Deco skyscrapers, their facades adorned with intricate gilded geometric patterns and bold vertical chrome lines, gleaming in the city lights, their reflections shimmering on the dark, wet asphalt. Suddenly, the taillights flash violently, and the supercar launches forward with explosive and decisive acceleration, its wide rear tires viciously cutting through standing water and sending a dramatic plume of spray into the air. As the car speeds down the street, transforming into a streak of white light, the camera smoothly and swiftly pulls up, rising vertically to reveal a breathtaking, sprawling metropolis stretching to the horizon, a vast network of illuminated streets and monumental buildings creating a powerful and awe-inspiring sense of scale and speed.", + "seed": 14033, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_14/index_161_seed_14033_dp_28_rank_56_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.07183196060359479, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07183196060359479, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.95, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07183196060359479, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a pearlescent white, wedge-shaped supercar with sharp angles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the taillights vibrant, glowing crimson hexagons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a rain-slicked city street at night with Art Deco skyscrapers featuring gilded geometric patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the car launch forward with explosive acceleration, cutting through standing water and creating a plume of spray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly pull up vertically to reveal a sprawling metropolis stretching to the horizon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20217442512512207 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.702174425125122 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20217442512512207, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20217442512512207, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20367543399333954, + 0.0647444948554039, + 0.03885477036237717, + 0.11342543363571167, + 0.02101733349263668, + 0.2314048856496811, + 0.054706741124391556, + 0.049718283116817474, + 0.08761337399482727, + 0.1348392218351364 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20217442512512207 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a pearlescent white, wedge-shaped supercar with sharp angles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the taillights vibrant, glowing crimson hexagons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a rain-slicked city street at night with Art Deco skyscrapers featuring gilded geometric patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the car launch forward with explosive acceleration, cutting through standing water and creating a plume of spray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly pull up vertically to reveal a sprawling metropolis stretching to the horizon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0620647557079792 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120646476745605 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0620647557079792, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0620647557079792, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12878866493701935, + 0.05094419792294502, + 0.03069296106696129, + 0.2854824364185333, + 0.0664534643292427, + 0.14805465936660767, + 0.12326813489198685, + 0.055482640862464905, + 0.06865756213665009, + 0.042175304144620895 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0620647557079792 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a pearlescent white, wedge-shaped supercar with sharp angles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the taillights vibrant, glowing crimson hexagons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a rain-slicked city street at night with Art Deco skyscrapers featuring gilded geometric patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the car launch forward with explosive acceleration, cutting through standing water and creating a plume of spray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly pull up vertically to reveal a sprawling metropolis stretching to the horizon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018181568011641502 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018181800842285 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018181568011641502, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018181568011641502, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16974493861198425, + 0.027859751135110855, + 0.047731440514326096, + 0.18792317807674408, + 0.07323551923036575, + 0.08127694576978683, + 0.07046005129814148, + 0.08445274084806442, + 0.18210740387439728, + 0.07520812004804611 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018181568011641502 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a pearlescent white, wedge-shaped supercar with sharp angles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the taillights vibrant, glowing crimson hexagons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a rain-slicked city street at night with Art Deco skyscrapers featuring gilded geometric patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the car launch forward with explosive acceleration, cutting through standing water and creating a plume of spray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly pull up vertically to reveal a sprawling metropolis stretching to the horizon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.033691298216581345 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.40869140625 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.033691298216581345, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.033691298216581345, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06489214301109314, + 0.03185150399804115, + 0.025646859779953957, + 0.20344765484333038, + 0.07100744545459747, + 0.073929563164711, + 0.15609082579612732, + 0.07991356402635574, + 0.20887823402881622, + 0.0843421220779419 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 3, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.033691298216581345 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a pearlescent white, wedge-shaped supercar with sharp angles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the taillights vibrant, glowing crimson hexagons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a rain-slicked city street at night with Art Deco skyscrapers featuring gilded geometric patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the car launch forward with explosive acceleration, cutting through standing water and creating a plume of spray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly pull up vertically to reveal a sprawling metropolis stretching to the horizon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04304775595664978 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680476665496826 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04304775595664978, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04304775595664978, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05914459750056267, + 0.021641001105308533, + 0.03436671942472458, + 0.5250744223594666, + 0.0195680670440197, + 0.04864589124917984, + 0.03593628481030464, + 0.04516215994954109, + 0.16136406362056732, + 0.04909680411219597 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04304775595664978 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, static shot depicts the rear of a pearlescent white, wedge-shaped supercar, parked on a rain-slicked city street at night. Its low-slung chassis is all sharp angles and aggressive lines, culminating in a mesmerizing array of vibrant, glowing crimson hexagonal taillights, brimming with potential energy. The surrounding architecture is a symphony of towering Art Deco skyscrapers, their facades adorned with intricate gilded geometric patterns and bold vertical chrome lines, gleaming in the city lights, their reflections shimmering on the dark, wet asphalt. Suddenly, the taillights flash violently, and the supercar launches forward with explosive and decisive acceleration, its wide rear tires viciously cutting through standing water and sending a dramatic plume of spray into the air. As the car speeds down the street, transforming into a streak of white light, the camera smoothly and swiftly pulls up, rising vertically to reveal a breathtaking, sprawling metropolis stretching to the horizon, a vast network of illuminated streets and monumental buildings creating a powerful and awe-inspiring sense of scale and speed.", + "seed": 14034, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_14/index_161_seed_14034_dp_28_rank_56_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.03913355506956577, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03913355506956577, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.4, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03913355506956577, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a pearlescent white, wedge-shaped supercar with sharp angles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the taillights vibrant, glowing crimson hexagons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a rain-slicked city street at night with Art Deco skyscrapers featuring gilded geometric patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the car launch forward with explosive acceleration, cutting through standing water and creating a plume of spray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly pull up vertically to reveal a sprawling metropolis stretching to the horizon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.043849822133779526 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1688497066497803 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.043849822133779526, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.043849822133779526, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21427078545093536, + 0.19504810869693756, + 0.057630155235528946, + 0.12161026895046234, + 0.03281733766198158, + 0.05118122324347496, + 0.03177107125520706, + 0.16626796126365662, + 0.06710170954465866, + 0.062301311641931534 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.043849822133779526 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a pearlescent white, wedge-shaped supercar with sharp angles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the taillights vibrant, glowing crimson hexagons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a rain-slicked city street at night with Art Deco skyscrapers featuring gilded geometric patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the car launch forward with explosive acceleration, cutting through standing water and creating a plume of spray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly pull up vertically to reveal a sprawling metropolis stretching to the horizon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03810005635023117 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288100004196167 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03810005635023117, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03810005635023117, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2857573628425598, + 0.056629765778779984, + 0.09183189272880554, + 0.06909860670566559, + 0.06263237446546555, + 0.06332278996706009, + 0.11547908186912537, + 0.11931172758340836, + 0.0649862140417099, + 0.07095024734735489 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03810005635023117 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a pearlescent white, wedge-shaped supercar with sharp angles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the taillights vibrant, glowing crimson hexagons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a rain-slicked city street at night with Art Deco skyscrapers featuring gilded geometric patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the car launch forward with explosive acceleration, cutting through standing water and creating a plume of spray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly pull up vertically to reveal a sprawling metropolis stretching to the horizon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014191068708896637 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264191150665283 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014191068708896637, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014191068708896637, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4068072438240051, + 0.02610236220061779, + 0.03771878406405449, + 0.06789534538984299, + 0.0749880000948906, + 0.08747844398021698, + 0.03505262732505798, + 0.07408563047647476, + 0.06503371894359589, + 0.12483785301446915 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014191068708896637 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a pearlescent white, wedge-shaped supercar with sharp angles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the taillights vibrant, glowing crimson hexagons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a rain-slicked city street at night with Art Deco skyscrapers featuring gilded geometric patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the car launch forward with explosive acceleration, cutting through standing water and creating a plume of spray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly pull up vertically to reveal a sprawling metropolis stretching to the horizon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020571095868945122 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895570993423462 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020571095868945122, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020571095868945122, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08769223839044571, + 0.0823594331741333, + 0.023783883079886436, + 0.02413487806916237, + 0.06691481918096542, + 0.14852549135684967, + 0.16708165407180786, + 0.17753711342811584, + 0.10240425914525986, + 0.11956622451543808 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020571095868945122 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a pearlescent white, wedge-shaped supercar with sharp angles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the taillights vibrant, glowing crimson hexagons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a rain-slicked city street at night with Art Deco skyscrapers featuring gilded geometric patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the car launch forward with explosive acceleration, cutting through standing water and creating a plume of spray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly pull up vertically to reveal a sprawling metropolis stretching to the horizon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07895573228597641 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.57895565032959 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07895573228597641, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07895573228597641, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20580394566059113, + 0.08867047727108002, + 0.04492732509970665, + 0.05902090668678284, + 0.11872198432683945, + 0.1601874679327011, + 0.11055438965559006, + 0.0882185623049736, + 0.04774601757526398, + 0.0761488527059555 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07895573228597641 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, static shot depicts the rear of a pearlescent white, wedge-shaped supercar, parked on a rain-slicked city street at night. Its low-slung chassis is all sharp angles and aggressive lines, culminating in a mesmerizing array of vibrant, glowing crimson hexagonal taillights, brimming with potential energy. The surrounding architecture is a symphony of towering Art Deco skyscrapers, their facades adorned with intricate gilded geometric patterns and bold vertical chrome lines, gleaming in the city lights, their reflections shimmering on the dark, wet asphalt. Suddenly, the taillights flash violently, and the supercar launches forward with explosive and decisive acceleration, its wide rear tires viciously cutting through standing water and sending a dramatic plume of spray into the air. As the car speeds down the street, transforming into a streak of white light, the camera smoothly and swiftly pulls up, rising vertically to reveal a breathtaking, sprawling metropolis stretching to the horizon, a vast network of illuminated streets and monumental buildings creating a powerful and awe-inspiring sense of scale and speed.", + "seed": 14035, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_14/index_161_seed_14035_dp_29_rank_58_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.10899387188255787, + "vlm_logprob": -0.10899387188255787, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.8, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.10899387188255787, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a pearlescent white, wedge-shaped supercar with sharp angles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the taillights vibrant, glowing crimson hexagons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a rain-slicked city street at night with Art Deco skyscrapers featuring gilded geometric patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the car launch forward with explosive acceleration, cutting through standing water and creating a plume of spray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly pull up vertically to reveal a sprawling metropolis stretching to the horizon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03485186770558357 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4098517894744873 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03485186770558357, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03485186770558357, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19783654808998108, + 0.13087795674800873, + 0.07275938242673874, + 0.044446785002946854, + 0.21333906054496765, + 0.04553457349538803, + 0.05568014457821846, + 0.04254758358001709, + 0.12049885839223862, + 0.07647904753684998 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03485186770558357 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a pearlescent white, wedge-shaped supercar with sharp angles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the taillights vibrant, glowing crimson hexagons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a rain-slicked city street at night with Art Deco skyscrapers featuring gilded geometric patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the car launch forward with explosive acceleration, cutting through standing water and creating a plume of spray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly pull up vertically to reveal a sprawling metropolis stretching to the horizon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07002237439155579 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950223445892334 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07002237439155579, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07002237439155579, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11855161935091019, + 0.22662052512168884, + 0.037114132195711136, + 0.05362771451473236, + 0.2219390571117401, + 0.03314386308193207, + 0.07429980486631393, + 0.04319059103727341, + 0.13297541439533234, + 0.058537326753139496 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 4, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07002237439155579 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a pearlescent white, wedge-shaped supercar with sharp angles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the taillights vibrant, glowing crimson hexagons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a rain-slicked city street at night with Art Deco skyscrapers featuring gilded geometric patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the car launch forward with explosive acceleration, cutting through standing water and creating a plume of spray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly pull up vertically to reveal a sprawling metropolis stretching to the horizon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023280736058950424 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773280620574951 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023280736058950424, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023280736058950424, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12995821237564087, + 0.13917388021945953, + 0.11249314993619919, + 0.08925163000822067, + 0.22596195340156555, + 0.028960498049855232, + 0.041406381875276566, + 0.05851919203996658, + 0.0822489783167839, + 0.09202613681554794 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023280736058950424 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a pearlescent white, wedge-shaped supercar with sharp angles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the taillights vibrant, glowing crimson hexagons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a rain-slicked city street at night with Art Deco skyscrapers featuring gilded geometric patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the car launch forward with explosive acceleration, cutting through standing water and creating a plume of spray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly pull up vertically to reveal a sprawling metropolis stretching to the horizon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02979334630072117 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5297932624816895 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02979334630072117, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02979334630072117, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09299159795045853, + 0.08845038712024689, + 0.04819868132472038, + 0.07079719752073288, + 0.060711003839969635, + 0.026203542947769165, + 0.0660744234919548, + 0.09844252467155457, + 0.31745418906211853, + 0.1306764781475067 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02979334630072117 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a pearlescent white, wedge-shaped supercar with sharp angles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the taillights vibrant, glowing crimson hexagons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a rain-slicked city street at night with Art Deco skyscrapers featuring gilded geometric patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the car launch forward with explosive acceleration, cutting through standing water and creating a plume of spray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly pull up vertically to reveal a sprawling metropolis stretching to the horizon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3870210349559784 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1370210647583008 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3870210349559784, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3870210349559784, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03210248053073883, + 0.04627396911382675, + 0.03992766886949539, + 0.04608194902539253, + 0.1818469613790512, + 0.09636760503053665, + 0.17604494094848633, + 0.06110679730772972, + 0.15887963771820068, + 0.1613679677248001 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3870210349559784 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, static shot depicts the rear of a pearlescent white, wedge-shaped supercar, parked on a rain-slicked city street at night. Its low-slung chassis is all sharp angles and aggressive lines, culminating in a mesmerizing array of vibrant, glowing crimson hexagonal taillights, brimming with potential energy. The surrounding architecture is a symphony of towering Art Deco skyscrapers, their facades adorned with intricate gilded geometric patterns and bold vertical chrome lines, gleaming in the city lights, their reflections shimmering on the dark, wet asphalt. Suddenly, the taillights flash violently, and the supercar launches forward with explosive and decisive acceleration, its wide rear tires viciously cutting through standing water and sending a dramatic plume of spray into the air. As the car speeds down the street, transforming into a streak of white light, the camera smoothly and swiftly pulls up, rising vertically to reveal a breathtaking, sprawling metropolis stretching to the horizon, a vast network of illuminated streets and monumental buildings creating a powerful and awe-inspiring sense of scale and speed.", + "seed": 14036, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_14/index_161_seed_14036_dp_29_rank_58_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.052480054274201396, + "vlm_logprob": -0.052480054274201396, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.125, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.052480054274201396, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a pearlescent white, wedge-shaped supercar with sharp angles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the taillights vibrant, glowing crimson hexagons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a rain-slicked city street at night with Art Deco skyscrapers featuring gilded geometric patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the car launch forward with explosive acceleration, cutting through standing water and creating a plume of spray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly pull up vertically to reveal a sprawling metropolis stretching to the horizon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06283291429281235 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812832832336426 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06283291429281235, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06283291429281235, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13318906724452972, + 0.0648387148976326, + 0.059642866253852844, + 0.06492894887924194, + 0.17880912125110626, + 0.04796507582068443, + 0.034054748713970184, + 0.22807197272777557, + 0.0722447857260704, + 0.11625466495752335 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06283291429281235 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a pearlescent white, wedge-shaped supercar with sharp angles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the taillights vibrant, glowing crimson hexagons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a rain-slicked city street at night with Art Deco skyscrapers featuring gilded geometric patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the car launch forward with explosive acceleration, cutting through standing water and creating a plume of spray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly pull up vertically to reveal a sprawling metropolis stretching to the horizon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07002859562635422 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.69502854347229 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07002859562635422, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07002859562635422, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3368217647075653, + 0.044824786484241486, + 0.06906736642122269, + 0.0514768622815609, + 0.06808354705572128, + 0.03188176453113556, + 0.025344930589199066, + 0.16445891559123993, + 0.07438934594392776, + 0.1336507499217987 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07002859562635422 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a pearlescent white, wedge-shaped supercar with sharp angles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the taillights vibrant, glowing crimson hexagons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a rain-slicked city street at night with Art Deco skyscrapers featuring gilded geometric patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the car launch forward with explosive acceleration, cutting through standing water and creating a plume of spray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly pull up vertically to reveal a sprawling metropolis stretching to the horizon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014189541339874268 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264189720153809 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014189541339874268, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014189541339874268, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14388376474380493, + 0.2458629459142685, + 0.06680943816900253, + 0.08992991596460342, + 0.11353705823421478, + 0.04453247785568237, + 0.031195897608995438, + 0.06971196085214615, + 0.06716039031744003, + 0.12737615406513214 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014189541339874268 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a pearlescent white, wedge-shaped supercar with sharp angles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the taillights vibrant, glowing crimson hexagons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a rain-slicked city street at night with Art Deco skyscrapers featuring gilded geometric patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the car launch forward with explosive acceleration, cutting through standing water and creating a plume of spray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly pull up vertically to reveal a sprawling metropolis stretching to the horizon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026337021961808205 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651336908340454 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026337021961808205, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026337021961808205, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1068011149764061, + 0.1759924441576004, + 0.06420360505580902, + 0.13410313427448273, + 0.22356387972831726, + 0.06196589395403862, + 0.02855275198817253, + 0.04305132478475571, + 0.035757411271333694, + 0.12600843608379364 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026337021961808205 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a pearlescent white, wedge-shaped supercar with sharp angles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the taillights vibrant, glowing crimson hexagons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a rain-slicked city street at night with Art Deco skyscrapers featuring gilded geometric patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the car launch forward with explosive acceleration, cutting through standing water and creating a plume of spray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly pull up vertically to reveal a sprawling metropolis stretching to the horizon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08901219815015793 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4640121459960938 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08901219815015793, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08901219815015793, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11478646844625473, + 0.06969217956066132, + 0.057130564004182816, + 0.07875774800777435, + 0.0934969037771225, + 0.09273334592580795, + 0.04178273305296898, + 0.061165522783994675, + 0.06697342544794083, + 0.32348114252090454 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08901219815015793 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_15/index_tensor([923, 923])_group_15_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_15/index_tensor([923, 923])_group_15_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..6210891f80ecb4663503058eb05785472ed39d6d --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_15/index_tensor([923, 923])_group_15_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "wide-angle shot, as if filmed from a deep-sea submersible, captures a giant octopus as it emerges from the inky abyss. The creature floats majestically and deliberately in the murky waters, its body a marvel of ethereal biology. Its translucent, membranous flesh, shades of deep indigo and ghostly white, undulates with a hypnotic slowness, truly resembling a wisp of smoke in zero gravity. A cool internal bioluminescence pulses rhythmically from within its cloak and along the delicate webs between its arms, casting a soft, ever-shifting glow that illuminates the intricate patterns on its skin. Its enormous, intelligent silver eyes gaze forward into the void, while its tentacles trail behind with languid grace. The only light in the devastating darkness comes from the octopus itself, capturing countless grains of marine snow that drift across the camera like a slow-motion blizzard, creating an atmosphere of mystery and awe, witnessing a primordial, otherworldly being in its profoundly silent realm.", + "seed": 21207, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_15/index_923_seed_21207_dp_30_rank_60_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.12875674962997435, + "vlm_logprob": -0.12875674962997435, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.15, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.12875674962997435, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a wide-angle view from a deep-sea submersible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a giant octopus with translucent, membranous flesh in shades of deep indigo and ghostly white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the octopus exhibit cool internal bioluminescence pulsing from its body and arms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are enormous silver eyes visible on the octopus gazing forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a dark deep-sea setting with marine snow drifting across the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5275202989578247 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9025202989578247 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5275202989578247, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5275202989578247, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13834068179130554, + 0.03415878862142563, + 0.06707008183002472, + 0.11195602267980576, + 0.11496485769748688, + 0.0956999659538269, + 0.04829064756631851, + 0.270622193813324, + 0.0858815610408783, + 0.03301527351140976 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5275202989578247 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a wide-angle view from a deep-sea submersible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a giant octopus with translucent, membranous flesh in shades of deep indigo and ghostly white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the octopus exhibit cool internal bioluminescence pulsing from its body and arms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are enormous silver eyes visible on the octopus gazing forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a dark deep-sea setting with marine snow drifting across the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004113784059882164 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504113674163818 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004113784059882164, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004113784059882164, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09085221588611603, + 0.06275374442338943, + 0.04776381701231003, + 0.2965238094329834, + 0.0641687661409378, + 0.08044428378343582, + 0.043238360434770584, + 0.14447881281375885, + 0.1293952465057373, + 0.040380991995334625 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004113784059882164 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a wide-angle view from a deep-sea submersible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a giant octopus with translucent, membranous flesh in shades of deep indigo and ghostly white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the octopus exhibit cool internal bioluminescence pulsing from its body and arms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are enormous silver eyes visible on the octopus gazing forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a dark deep-sea setting with marine snow drifting across the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02980688400566578 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298068523406982 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02980688400566578, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02980688400566578, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2135682851076126, + 0.0467006154358387, + 0.07042040675878525, + 0.3186716139316559, + 0.06332354992628098, + 0.07131435722112656, + 0.025057053193449974, + 0.10213680565357208, + 0.06541212648153305, + 0.02339516207575798 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02980688400566578 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a wide-angle view from a deep-sea submersible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a giant octopus with translucent, membranous flesh in shades of deep indigo and ghostly white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the octopus exhibit cool internal bioluminescence pulsing from its body and arms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are enormous silver eyes visible on the octopus gazing forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a dark deep-sea setting with marine snow drifting across the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04865194112062454 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048651933670044 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04865194112062454, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04865194112062454, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06090415269136429, + 0.06434261053800583, + 0.13082575798034668, + 0.0993206724524498, + 0.061580199748277664, + 0.0919836089015007, + 0.041425541043281555, + 0.3782491981983185, + 0.047390200197696686, + 0.023978080600500107 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04865194112062454 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a wide-angle view from a deep-sea submersible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a giant octopus with translucent, membranous flesh in shades of deep indigo and ghostly white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the octopus exhibit cool internal bioluminescence pulsing from its body and arms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are enormous silver eyes visible on the octopus gazing forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a dark deep-sea setting with marine snow drifting across the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.033690840005874634 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408690929412842 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.033690840005874634, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.033690840005874634, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08425453305244446, + 0.046424154192209244, + 0.05400703474879265, + 0.10422000288963318, + 0.04352780058979988, + 0.14180389046669006, + 0.037202827632427216, + 0.33398857712745667, + 0.11664339154958725, + 0.0379277765750885 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 5, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.033690840005874634 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "wide-angle shot, as if filmed from a deep-sea submersible, captures a giant octopus as it emerges from the inky abyss. The creature floats majestically and deliberately in the murky waters, its body a marvel of ethereal biology. Its translucent, membranous flesh, shades of deep indigo and ghostly white, undulates with a hypnotic slowness, truly resembling a wisp of smoke in zero gravity. A cool internal bioluminescence pulses rhythmically from within its cloak and along the delicate webs between its arms, casting a soft, ever-shifting glow that illuminates the intricate patterns on its skin. Its enormous, intelligent silver eyes gaze forward into the void, while its tentacles trail behind with languid grace. The only light in the devastating darkness comes from the octopus itself, capturing countless grains of marine snow that drift across the camera like a slow-motion blizzard, creating an atmosphere of mystery and awe, witnessing a primordial, otherworldly being in its profoundly silent realm.", + "seed": 21208, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_15/index_923_seed_21208_dp_30_rank_60_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.13814040794968604, + "vlm_logprob": -0.13814040794968604, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.500000011920929, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.13814040794968604, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a wide-angle view from a deep-sea submersible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a giant octopus with translucent, membranous flesh in shades of deep indigo and ghostly white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the octopus exhibit cool internal bioluminescence pulsing from its body and arms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are enormous silver eyes visible on the octopus gazing forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a dark deep-sea setting with marine snow drifting across the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4487914443016052 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.07379150390625 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.4487914443016052, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.6250000596046448, + "token_credit_reward": -0.4487914443016052, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.32525140047073364, + 0.09725599735975266, + 0.04317460209131241, + 0.08301621675491333, + 0.07131430506706238, + 0.02819722518324852, + 0.05284825339913368, + 0.06860443204641342, + 0.04257495701313019, + 0.18776263296604156 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.4487914443016052 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a wide-angle view from a deep-sea submersible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a giant octopus with translucent, membranous flesh in shades of deep indigo and ghostly white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the octopus exhibit cool internal bioluminescence pulsing from its body and arms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are enormous silver eyes visible on the octopus gazing forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a dark deep-sea setting with marine snow drifting across the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018224645406007767 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018224716186523 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018224645406007767, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018224645406007767, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.33764785528182983, + 0.056531015783548355, + 0.033204905688762665, + 0.038353901356458664, + 0.01994711346924305, + 0.011891249567270279, + 0.010397125966846943, + 0.03700842335820198, + 0.0429387241601944, + 0.4120796024799347 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018224645406007767 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a wide-angle view from a deep-sea submersible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a giant octopus with translucent, membranous flesh in shades of deep indigo and ghostly white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the octopus exhibit cool internal bioluminescence pulsing from its body and arms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are enormous silver eyes visible on the octopus gazing forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a dark deep-sea setting with marine snow drifting across the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11297174543142319 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.237971782684326 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11297174543142319, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11297174543142319, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24522832036018372, + 0.06822232902050018, + 0.11973316967487335, + 0.04453599080443382, + 0.051149267703294754, + 0.06731462478637695, + 0.04577205330133438, + 0.14488644897937775, + 0.0856524184346199, + 0.1275053769350052 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11297174543142319 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a wide-angle view from a deep-sea submersible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a giant octopus with translucent, membranous flesh in shades of deep indigo and ghostly white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the octopus exhibit cool internal bioluminescence pulsing from its body and arms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are enormous silver eyes visible on the octopus gazing forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a dark deep-sea setting with marine snow drifting across the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.048666927963495255 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486669540405273 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.048666927963495255, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.048666927963495255, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24545104801654816, + 0.03309210017323494, + 0.1542566418647766, + 0.10807989537715912, + 0.1658172458410263, + 0.02911900356411934, + 0.02416035532951355, + 0.07574743032455444, + 0.041215721517801285, + 0.12306061387062073 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.048666927963495255 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a wide-angle view from a deep-sea submersible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a giant octopus with translucent, membranous flesh in shades of deep indigo and ghostly white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the octopus exhibit cool internal bioluminescence pulsing from its body and arms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are enormous silver eyes visible on the octopus gazing forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a dark deep-sea setting with marine snow drifting across the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06204727664589882 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812047243118286 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06204727664589882, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06204727664589882, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4061026871204376, + 0.07742033898830414, + 0.08109916001558304, + 0.06526102125644684, + 0.07971164584159851, + 0.0455806739628315, + 0.05314632132649422, + 0.08081921935081482, + 0.028193054720759392, + 0.08266588300466537 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06204727664589882 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "wide-angle shot, as if filmed from a deep-sea submersible, captures a giant octopus as it emerges from the inky abyss. The creature floats majestically and deliberately in the murky waters, its body a marvel of ethereal biology. Its translucent, membranous flesh, shades of deep indigo and ghostly white, undulates with a hypnotic slowness, truly resembling a wisp of smoke in zero gravity. A cool internal bioluminescence pulses rhythmically from within its cloak and along the delicate webs between its arms, casting a soft, ever-shifting glow that illuminates the intricate patterns on its skin. Its enormous, intelligent silver eyes gaze forward into the void, while its tentacles trail behind with languid grace. The only light in the devastating darkness comes from the octopus itself, capturing countless grains of marine snow that drift across the camera like a slow-motion blizzard, creating an atmosphere of mystery and awe, witnessing a primordial, otherworldly being in its profoundly silent realm.", + "seed": 21209, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_15/index_923_seed_21209_dp_31_rank_62_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.09093205416575074, + "vlm_logprob": -0.09093205416575074, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.725, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.09093205416575074, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a wide-angle view from a deep-sea submersible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a giant octopus with translucent, membranous flesh in shades of deep indigo and ghostly white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the octopus exhibit cool internal bioluminescence pulsing from its body and arms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are enormous silver eyes visible on the octopus gazing forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a dark deep-sea setting with marine snow drifting across the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.39114344120025635 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1411434412002563 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.39114344120025635, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.39114344120025635, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.511003315448761, + 0.038825623691082, + 0.019665788859128952, + 0.04859453812241554, + 0.04987599328160286, + 0.02648538537323475, + 0.041053127497434616, + 0.14500553905963898, + 0.10378153622150421, + 0.015709174796938896 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.39114344120025635 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a wide-angle view from a deep-sea submersible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a giant octopus with translucent, membranous flesh in shades of deep indigo and ghostly white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the octopus exhibit cool internal bioluminescence pulsing from its body and arms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are enormous silver eyes visible on the octopus gazing forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a dark deep-sea setting with marine snow drifting across the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005970263388007879 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130970478057861 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005970263388007879, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005970263388007879, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.6362650394439697, + 0.04220563918352127, + 0.033779989928007126, + 0.07352815568447113, + 0.02008184790611267, + 0.030767368152737617, + 0.04773480072617531, + 0.07333394885063171, + 0.023519044741988182, + 0.01878417283296585 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005970263388007879 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a wide-angle view from a deep-sea submersible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a giant octopus with translucent, membranous flesh in shades of deep indigo and ghostly white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the octopus exhibit cool internal bioluminescence pulsing from its body and arms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are enormous silver eyes visible on the octopus gazing forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a dark deep-sea setting with marine snow drifting across the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01420364435762167 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.2642035484313965 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01420364435762167, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01420364435762167, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.6212873458862305, + 0.08486722409725189, + 0.05509895831346512, + 0.055095124989748, + 0.04130345210433006, + 0.01865139976143837, + 0.04462921619415283, + 0.03192512318491936, + 0.02578490599989891, + 0.02135726809501648 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01420364435762167 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a wide-angle view from a deep-sea submersible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a giant octopus with translucent, membranous flesh in shades of deep indigo and ghostly white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the octopus exhibit cool internal bioluminescence pulsing from its body and arms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are enormous silver eyes visible on the octopus gazing forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a dark deep-sea setting with marine snow drifting across the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03809351474046707 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2880935668945312 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03809351474046707, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03809351474046707, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.43639257550239563, + 0.08080828189849854, + 0.020254911854863167, + 0.022779569029808044, + 0.045111283659935, + 0.025535346940159798, + 0.1563381850719452, + 0.12338355928659439, + 0.0761839970946312, + 0.013212254270911217 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03809351474046707 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a wide-angle view from a deep-sea submersible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a giant octopus with translucent, membranous flesh in shades of deep indigo and ghostly white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the octopus exhibit cool internal bioluminescence pulsing from its body and arms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are enormous silver eyes visible on the octopus gazing forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a dark deep-sea setting with marine snow drifting across the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005249407142400742 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255249500274658 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005249407142400742, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005249407142400742, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.9192128777503967, + 0.008183220401406288, + 0.002749460516497493, + 0.007171982899308205, + 0.005460203625261784, + 0.002661667298525572, + 0.02963433787226677, + 0.016602691262960434, + 0.0033274036832153797, + 0.004996167961508036 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005249407142400742 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "wide-angle shot, as if filmed from a deep-sea submersible, captures a giant octopus as it emerges from the inky abyss. The creature floats majestically and deliberately in the murky waters, its body a marvel of ethereal biology. Its translucent, membranous flesh, shades of deep indigo and ghostly white, undulates with a hypnotic slowness, truly resembling a wisp of smoke in zero gravity. A cool internal bioluminescence pulses rhythmically from within its cloak and along the delicate webs between its arms, casting a soft, ever-shifting glow that illuminates the intricate patterns on its skin. Its enormous, intelligent silver eyes gaze forward into the void, while its tentacles trail behind with languid grace. The only light in the devastating darkness comes from the octopus itself, capturing countless grains of marine snow that drift across the camera like a slow-motion blizzard, creating an atmosphere of mystery and awe, witnessing a primordial, otherworldly being in its profoundly silent realm.", + "seed": 21210, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_15/index_923_seed_21210_dp_31_rank_62_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.3297682709991932, + "vlm_logprob": -0.3297682709991932, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.65, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.3297682709991932, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a wide-angle view from a deep-sea submersible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a giant octopus with translucent, membranous flesh in shades of deep indigo and ghostly white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the octopus exhibit cool internal bioluminescence pulsing from its body and arms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are enormous silver eyes visible on the octopus gazing forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a dark deep-sea setting with marine snow drifting across the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2275358438491821 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.35253581404685974 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.2275358438491821, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -1.2275358438491821, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15447282791137695, + 0.056555163115262985, + 0.25383126735687256, + 0.16110390424728394, + 0.05119284242391586, + 0.04476337507367134, + 0.052939657121896744, + 0.13118575513362885, + 0.0595916323363781, + 0.03436356037855148 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.2275358438491821 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a wide-angle view from a deep-sea submersible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a giant octopus with translucent, membranous flesh in shades of deep indigo and ghostly white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the octopus exhibit cool internal bioluminescence pulsing from its body and arms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are enormous silver eyes visible on the octopus gazing forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a dark deep-sea setting with marine snow drifting across the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07901719957590103 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.579017162322998 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07901719957590103, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07901719957590103, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09175711125135422, + 0.05608508363366127, + 0.24835588037967682, + 0.08979811519384384, + 0.043391354382038116, + 0.08242848515510559, + 0.09943832457065582, + 0.21896260976791382, + 0.019785141572356224, + 0.049997877329587936 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07901719957590103 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a wide-angle view from a deep-sea submersible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a giant octopus with translucent, membranous flesh in shades of deep indigo and ghostly white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the octopus exhibit cool internal bioluminescence pulsing from its body and arms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are enormous silver eyes visible on the octopus gazing forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a dark deep-sea setting with marine snow drifting across the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10033933073282242 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.350339412689209 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10033933073282242, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10033933073282242, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0882817804813385, + 0.059289172291755676, + 0.20284391939640045, + 0.07362791895866394, + 0.03330698609352112, + 0.09603176265954971, + 0.21431969106197357, + 0.1554659903049469, + 0.01581122726202011, + 0.061021603643894196 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 2, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10033933073282242 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a wide-angle view from a deep-sea submersible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a giant octopus with translucent, membranous flesh in shades of deep indigo and ghostly white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the octopus exhibit cool internal bioluminescence pulsing from its body and arms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are enormous silver eyes visible on the octopus gazing forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a dark deep-sea setting with marine snow drifting across the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06204727664589882 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812047243118286 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06204727664589882, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06204727664589882, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1033124327659607, + 0.08695796877145767, + 0.32167354226112366, + 0.09651467204093933, + 0.028407886624336243, + 0.09392714500427246, + 0.07898715883493423, + 0.09044574946165085, + 0.034951306879520416, + 0.06482216715812683 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06204727664589882 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a wide-angle view from a deep-sea submersible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a giant octopus with translucent, membranous flesh in shades of deep indigo and ghostly white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the octopus exhibit cool internal bioluminescence pulsing from its body and arms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are enormous silver eyes visible on the octopus gazing forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a dark deep-sea setting with marine snow drifting across the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17990170419216156 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8049017190933228 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17990170419216156, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17990170419216156, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17652925848960876, + 0.04866631701588631, + 0.215170755982399, + 0.10862401127815247, + 0.0662069246172905, + 0.04602089896798134, + 0.1169220432639122, + 0.1406814157962799, + 0.036071911454200745, + 0.045106492936611176 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17990170419216156 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_2/index_tensor([3382, 3382])_group_2_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_2/index_tensor([3382, 3382])_group_2_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..064b4004eb4db7b60d97a8b43cd7276426246d3c --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_2/index_tensor([3382, 3382])_group_2_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "low-angle, tracking shot, close to the ground, captures a discarded white paper takeout container, like a lone boat, drifting steadily in the current that gathers along the curb of a rainy city street. The waterlogged container, its edges softened and its bottom partially submerged in the murky water, maintains its buoyancy thanks to its ingenious folding structure. Propelled by a gentle, steady current, it sails forward steadily and calmly, occasionally giving a gentle spin when encountering small obstacles like fallen leaves. The wet asphalt, like a black mirror, shimmers with the warm yellow glow of distant streetlights and the blue and red reflections of neon store signs. These shimmering shadows are stretched and distorted by the flowing water, paving a dazzling path for this miniature voyage. The entire scene evokes the unique tranquility and poetry of a rainy night, transforming an ordinary discarded object into an unexpected and beautiful visual spectacle.", + "seed": 5764, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_2/index_3382_seed_5764_dp_4_rank_8_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.009692895552143454, + "vlm_logprob": -0.009692895552143454, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.975, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.009692895552143454, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle close to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a discarded white paper takeout container?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the container drifting in murky water along the curb of a rainy city street?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the container move steadily forward and occasionally spin when encountering obstacles like fallen leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the wet asphalt reflect warm yellow streetlights and blue/red neon store signs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02390643022954464 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.273906230926514 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02390643022954464, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02390643022954464, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21194620430469513, + 0.1777128130197525, + 0.10750464349985123, + 0.01888776198029518, + 0.07557877153158188, + 0.17860594391822815, + 0.07413646578788757, + 0.05560123920440674, + 0.03808547928929329, + 0.06194064021110535 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02390643022954464 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle close to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a discarded white paper takeout container?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the container drifting in murky water along the curb of a rainy city street?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the container move steadily forward and occasionally spin when encountering obstacles like fallen leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the wet asphalt reflect warm yellow streetlights and blue/red neon store signs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008658604696393013 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758658409118652 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008658604696393013, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008658604696393013, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.058632075786590576, + 0.07300056517124176, + 0.041178472340106964, + 0.018878161907196045, + 0.060946960002183914, + 0.32360875606536865, + 0.22056631743907928, + 0.08683706074953079, + 0.08476158231496811, + 0.031590089201927185 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008658604696393013 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle close to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a discarded white paper takeout container?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the container drifting in murky water along the curb of a rainy city street?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the container move steadily forward and occasionally spin when encountering obstacles like fallen leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the wet asphalt reflect warm yellow streetlights and blue/red neon store signs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004644202534109354 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379644393920898 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004644202534109354, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004644202534109354, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12062794715166092, + 0.05067569762468338, + 0.15208202600479126, + 0.016893528401851654, + 0.145392045378685, + 0.34129729866981506, + 0.08259446173906326, + 0.03376903384923935, + 0.023514222353696823, + 0.033153750002384186 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004644202534109354 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle close to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a discarded white paper takeout container?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the container drifting in murky water along the curb of a rainy city street?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the container move steadily forward and occasionally spin when encountering obstacles like fallen leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the wet asphalt reflect warm yellow streetlights and blue/red neon store signs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007636165712028742 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882636070251465 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007636165712028742, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007636165712028742, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.040162019431591034, + 0.03734405338764191, + 0.04392418637871742, + 0.054738424718379974, + 0.048829156905412674, + 0.5626589059829712, + 0.0486886240541935, + 0.03339969739317894, + 0.083567313849926, + 0.04668756574392319 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 8, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007636165712028742 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle close to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a discarded white paper takeout container?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the container drifting in murky water along the curb of a rainy city street?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the container move steadily forward and occasionally spin when encountering obstacles like fallen leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the wet asphalt reflect warm yellow streetlights and blue/red neon store signs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036190745886415243 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628619194030762 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036190745886415243, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036190745886415243, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2118542343378067, + 0.023744339123368263, + 0.02096186950802803, + 0.10607105493545532, + 0.08240502327680588, + 0.08357180655002594, + 0.3495521545410156, + 0.02869274467229843, + 0.03643564134836197, + 0.056711141020059586 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036190745886415243 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, tracking shot, close to the ground, captures a discarded white paper takeout container, like a lone boat, drifting steadily in the current that gathers along the curb of a rainy city street. The waterlogged container, its edges softened and its bottom partially submerged in the murky water, maintains its buoyancy thanks to its ingenious folding structure. Propelled by a gentle, steady current, it sails forward steadily and calmly, occasionally giving a gentle spin when encountering small obstacles like fallen leaves. The wet asphalt, like a black mirror, shimmers with the warm yellow glow of distant streetlights and the blue and red reflections of neon store signs. These shimmering shadows are stretched and distorted by the flowing water, paving a dazzling path for this miniature voyage. The entire scene evokes the unique tranquility and poetry of a rainy night, transforming an ordinary discarded object into an unexpected and beautiful visual spectacle.", + "seed": 5765, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_2/index_3382_seed_5765_dp_4_rank_8_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.02253848947584629, + "vlm_logprob": -0.02253848947584629, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.225, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.02253848947584629, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle close to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a discarded white paper takeout container?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the container drifting in murky water along the curb of a rainy city street?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the container move steadily forward and occasionally spin when encountering obstacles like fallen leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the wet asphalt reflect warm yellow streetlights and blue/red neon store signs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06439685076475143 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.939396858215332 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06439685076475143, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06439685076475143, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.056048907339572906, + 0.17026494443416595, + 0.1304064393043518, + 0.026455191895365715, + 0.13673479855060577, + 0.20985202491283417, + 0.20831246674060822, + 0.022909030318260193, + 0.023658903315663338, + 0.015357318334281445 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06439685076475143 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle close to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a discarded white paper takeout container?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the container drifting in murky water along the curb of a rainy city street?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the container move steadily forward and occasionally spin when encountering obstacles like fallen leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the wet asphalt reflect warm yellow streetlights and blue/red neon store signs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011092307977378368 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511092185974121 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011092307977378368, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011092307977378368, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20108705759048462, + 0.11569170653820038, + 0.11888166517019272, + 0.08363636583089828, + 0.0658276379108429, + 0.09921582788228989, + 0.14570443332195282, + 0.06042278930544853, + 0.039713162928819656, + 0.06981933861970901 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011092307977378368 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle close to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a discarded white paper takeout container?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the container drifting in murky water along the curb of a rainy city street?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the container move steadily forward and occasionally spin when encountering obstacles like fallen leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the wet asphalt reflect warm yellow streetlights and blue/red neon store signs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02329809032380581 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732980251312256 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02329809032380581, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02329809032380581, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06438373029232025, + 0.45536237955093384, + 0.05402101203799248, + 0.02783038280904293, + 0.10973987728357315, + 0.16490207612514496, + 0.07610853761434555, + 0.012010912410914898, + 0.015152049250900745, + 0.020489027723670006 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02329809032380581 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle close to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a discarded white paper takeout container?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the container drifting in murky water along the curb of a rainy city street?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the container move steadily forward and occasionally spin when encountering obstacles like fallen leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the wet asphalt reflect warm yellow streetlights and blue/red neon store signs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008648913353681564 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758648872375488 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008648913353681564, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008648913353681564, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13164719939231873, + 0.28369805216789246, + 0.043946363031864166, + 0.05394100770354271, + 0.05750082805752754, + 0.2545657753944397, + 0.06911852955818176, + 0.034906938672065735, + 0.02492360770702362, + 0.04575167968869209 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008648913353681564 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle close to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a discarded white paper takeout container?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the container drifting in murky water along the curb of a rainy city street?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the container move steadily forward and occasionally spin when encountering obstacles like fallen leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the wet asphalt reflect warm yellow streetlights and blue/red neon store signs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005256284959614277 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255256175994873 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005256284959614277, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005256284959614277, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16574019193649292, + 0.12476813793182373, + 0.03787543997168541, + 0.09757165610790253, + 0.08979175984859467, + 0.07889319956302643, + 0.1416141390800476, + 0.03716345876455307, + 0.058729249984025955, + 0.16785278916358948 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005256284959614277 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, tracking shot, close to the ground, captures a discarded white paper takeout container, like a lone boat, drifting steadily in the current that gathers along the curb of a rainy city street. The waterlogged container, its edges softened and its bottom partially submerged in the murky water, maintains its buoyancy thanks to its ingenious folding structure. Propelled by a gentle, steady current, it sails forward steadily and calmly, occasionally giving a gentle spin when encountering small obstacles like fallen leaves. The wet asphalt, like a black mirror, shimmers with the warm yellow glow of distant streetlights and the blue and red reflections of neon store signs. These shimmering shadows are stretched and distorted by the flowing water, paving a dazzling path for this miniature voyage. The entire scene evokes the unique tranquility and poetry of a rainy night, transforming an ordinary discarded object into an unexpected and beautiful visual spectacle.", + "seed": 5766, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_2/index_3382_seed_5766_dp_5_rank_10_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.02772488505579531, + "vlm_logprob": -0.02772488505579531, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.275, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.02772488505579531, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle close to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a discarded white paper takeout container?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the container drifting in murky water along the curb of a rainy city street?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the container move steadily forward and occasionally spin when encountering obstacles like fallen leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the wet asphalt reflect warm yellow streetlights and blue/red neon store signs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08956343680620193 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5895633697509766 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08956343680620193, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08956343680620193, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16402599215507507, + 0.15692348778247833, + 0.0849999487400055, + 0.12858544290065765, + 0.08044915646314621, + 0.025090329349040985, + 0.05385668948292732, + 0.040906284004449844, + 0.09292230010032654, + 0.17224039137363434 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08956343680620193 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle close to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a discarded white paper takeout container?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the container drifting in murky water along the curb of a rainy city street?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the container move steadily forward and occasionally spin when encountering obstacles like fallen leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the wet asphalt reflect warm yellow streetlights and blue/red neon store signs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02638625167310238 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651386260986328 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02638625167310238, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02638625167310238, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22040580213069916, + 0.06671065837144852, + 0.03985682502388954, + 0.031208112835884094, + 0.040591347962617874, + 0.023459771648049355, + 0.11197294294834137, + 0.2071189135313034, + 0.21839293837547302, + 0.04028268903493881 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02638625167310238 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle close to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a discarded white paper takeout container?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the container drifting in murky water along the curb of a rainy city street?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the container move steadily forward and occasionally spin when encountering obstacles like fallen leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the wet asphalt reflect warm yellow streetlights and blue/red neon store signs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005264941602945328 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255264759063721 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005264941602945328, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005264941602945328, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.31751951575279236, + 0.32439157366752625, + 0.07654618471860886, + 0.0203569196164608, + 0.024419378489255905, + 0.013187307864427567, + 0.017439235001802444, + 0.10671025514602661, + 0.04587492719292641, + 0.05355466902256012 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005264941602945328 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle close to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a discarded white paper takeout container?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the container drifting in murky water along the curb of a rainy city street?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the container move steadily forward and occasionally spin when encountering obstacles like fallen leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the wet asphalt reflect warm yellow streetlights and blue/red neon store signs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014211166650056839 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264211177825928 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014211166650056839, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014211166650056839, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24822434782981873, + 0.05822105333209038, + 0.21261270344257355, + 0.04395391047000885, + 0.07697171717882156, + 0.03685088828206062, + 0.019485801458358765, + 0.16973476111888885, + 0.03780999407172203, + 0.0961347296833992 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014211166650056839 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle close to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a discarded white paper takeout container?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the container drifting in murky water along the curb of a rainy city street?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the container move steadily forward and occasionally spin when encountering obstacles like fallen leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the wet asphalt reflect warm yellow streetlights and blue/red neon store signs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0031986285466700792 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753198623657227 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0031986285466700792, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0031986285466700792, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2030729055404663, + 0.16248874366283417, + 0.034982744604349136, + 0.08579143136739731, + 0.1255471259355545, + 0.05303221940994263, + 0.03311712294816971, + 0.049395281821489334, + 0.1631406992673874, + 0.08943170309066772 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0031986285466700792 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, tracking shot, close to the ground, captures a discarded white paper takeout container, like a lone boat, drifting steadily in the current that gathers along the curb of a rainy city street. The waterlogged container, its edges softened and its bottom partially submerged in the murky water, maintains its buoyancy thanks to its ingenious folding structure. Propelled by a gentle, steady current, it sails forward steadily and calmly, occasionally giving a gentle spin when encountering small obstacles like fallen leaves. The wet asphalt, like a black mirror, shimmers with the warm yellow glow of distant streetlights and the blue and red reflections of neon store signs. These shimmering shadows are stretched and distorted by the flowing water, paving a dazzling path for this miniature voyage. The entire scene evokes the unique tranquility and poetry of a rainy night, transforming an ordinary discarded object into an unexpected and beautiful visual spectacle.", + "seed": 5767, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_2/index_3382_seed_5767_dp_5_rank_10_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.009460205957293511, + "vlm_logprob": -0.009460205957293511, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.85, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.009460205957293511, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle close to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a discarded white paper takeout container?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the container drifting in murky water along the curb of a rainy city street?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the container move steadily forward and occasionally spin when encountering obstacles like fallen leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the wet asphalt reflect warm yellow streetlights and blue/red neon store signs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.019403763115406036 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.26940393447876 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.019403763115406036, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.019403763115406036, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2780677080154419, + 0.0906727984547615, + 0.12647566199302673, + 0.14711859822273254, + 0.031840790063142776, + 0.029461756348609924, + 0.044579047709703445, + 0.050479475408792496, + 0.06952783465385437, + 0.13177631795406342 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.019403763115406036 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle close to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a discarded white paper takeout container?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the container drifting in murky water along the curb of a rainy city street?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the container move steadily forward and occasionally spin when encountering obstacles like fallen leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the wet asphalt reflect warm yellow streetlights and blue/red neon store signs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00596398301422596 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.1309638023376465 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00596398301422596, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00596398301422596, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2323061227798462, + 0.19859939813613892, + 0.04677572846412659, + 0.04921632260084152, + 0.07429394125938416, + 0.08766273409128189, + 0.0322231687605381, + 0.033537257462739944, + 0.0270455963909626, + 0.2183397263288498 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00596398301422596 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle close to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a discarded white paper takeout container?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the container drifting in murky water along the curb of a rainy city street?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the container move steadily forward and occasionally spin when encountering obstacles like fallen leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the wet asphalt reflect warm yellow streetlights and blue/red neon store signs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0046443212777376175 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379644393920898 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0046443212777376175, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0046443212777376175, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09090296924114227, + 0.13605687022209167, + 0.10918751358985901, + 0.06738383322954178, + 0.09664120525121689, + 0.2665341794490814, + 0.03895394131541252, + 0.060965314507484436, + 0.07787306606769562, + 0.055501073598861694 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0046443212777376175 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle close to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a discarded white paper takeout container?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the container drifting in murky water along the curb of a rainy city street?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the container move steadily forward and occasionally spin when encountering obstacles like fallen leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the wet asphalt reflect warm yellow streetlights and blue/red neon store signs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008646076545119286 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758646011352539 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008646076545119286, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008646076545119286, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21917349100112915, + 0.2553124725818634, + 0.09746173769235611, + 0.055842578411102295, + 0.037528812885284424, + 0.07677443325519562, + 0.0428043007850647, + 0.02739115245640278, + 0.04803044721484184, + 0.1396806538105011 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008646076545119286 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle close to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a discarded white paper takeout container?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the container drifting in murky water along the curb of a rainy city street?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the container move steadily forward and occasionally spin when encountering obstacles like fallen leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the wet asphalt reflect warm yellow streetlights and blue/red neon store signs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008642885833978653 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758642673492432 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008642885833978653, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008642885833978653, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25080373883247375, + 0.16068287193775177, + 0.10923413187265396, + 0.05824663117527962, + 0.04768985137343407, + 0.08926617354154587, + 0.08113060146570206, + 0.05268765985965729, + 0.05139002576470375, + 0.09886831790208817 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008642885833978653 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_3/index_tensor([1838, 1838])_group_3_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_3/index_tensor([1838, 1838])_group_3_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..76757fd82353962a44b1c699f1665ce00c47e9fc --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_3/index_tensor([1838, 1838])_group_3_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "strikingly composed long shot, captured with a telephoto lens, holds the camera still, its focus fixed on a mournful aristocratic woman. She stands alone at the edge of a rugged, barren black volcanic cliff, clad in an intricately patterned silk kimono, embroidered with chrysanthemums and cranes in silver thread, symbols of both nobility and the transience of life. Behind her, the boundless, surging sea of white foam tumbles, its waves crashing again and again with thunderous force against the sharp, dark rocks at the cliff's base, sending a cascade of spray skyward. A harsh, low-angled light, like a stage spotlight, slices her profile from the side, casting deep, sharp shadows across her pale, delicate face, accentuating the sorrowful frown between her brows and the hollowness of her eyes. Wisps of wind-blown black hair brush against her cheeks, while the wide sleeves of her kimono rustle in the sharp, gusty wind. The entire scene presents the ultimate 1940s black-and-white film style. The strong dramatic contrast of light and shadow highlights the loneliness and despair of the characters. The picture has obvious graininess and silver salt texture, creating a grand, tragic and fatalistic visual atmosphere.", + "seed": 19272, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_3/index_1838_seed_19272_dp_6_rank_12_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.08574698958545923, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08574698958545923, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.95, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08574698958545923, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a long shot featuring a mournful aristocratic woman standing alone at the edge of a rugged, barren black volcanic cliff?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing an intricately patterned silk kimono embroidered with chrysanthemums and cranes in silver thread?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a boundless sea of white foam crashing against dark rocks with spray rising into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting harsh and low-angled, creating strong dramatic contrast with deep shadows on the woman's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a 1940s black-and-white film style with obvious graininess and silver salt texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01889995113015175 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018899917602539 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01889995113015175, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01889995113015175, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3531498312950134, + 0.05508321523666382, + 0.1318148970603943, + 0.050737593322992325, + 0.03647225350141525, + 0.03200451284646988, + 0.03212814778089523, + 0.05099077895283699, + 0.03029053285717964, + 0.22732822597026825 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01889995113015175 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a long shot featuring a mournful aristocratic woman standing alone at the edge of a rugged, barren black volcanic cliff?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing an intricately patterned silk kimono embroidered with chrysanthemums and cranes in silver thread?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a boundless sea of white foam crashing against dark rocks with spray rising into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting harsh and low-angled, creating strong dramatic contrast with deep shadows on the woman's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a 1940s black-and-white film style with obvious graininess and silver salt texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.38724735379219055 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1372473239898682 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.38724735379219055, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.38724735379219055, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3803216814994812, + 0.13310247659683228, + 0.07673034071922302, + 0.06529217213392258, + 0.024390408769249916, + 0.033362723886966705, + 0.031308531761169434, + 0.02272784896194935, + 0.030034862458705902, + 0.20272895693778992 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.38724735379219055 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a long shot featuring a mournful aristocratic woman standing alone at the edge of a rugged, barren black volcanic cliff?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing an intricately patterned silk kimono embroidered with chrysanthemums and cranes in silver thread?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a boundless sea of white foam crashing against dark rocks with spray rising into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting harsh and low-angled, creating strong dramatic contrast with deep shadows on the woman's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a 1940s black-and-white film style with obvious graininess and silver salt texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004093126393854618 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504093170166016 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004093126393854618, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004093126393854618, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11430741846561432, + 0.0695117712020874, + 0.07877997308969498, + 0.05196979269385338, + 0.05447777733206749, + 0.0657825767993927, + 0.028680551797151566, + 0.059881165623664856, + 0.029320375993847847, + 0.4472885727882385 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004093126393854618 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a long shot featuring a mournful aristocratic woman standing alone at the edge of a rugged, barren black volcanic cliff?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing an intricately patterned silk kimono embroidered with chrysanthemums and cranes in silver thread?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a boundless sea of white foam crashing against dark rocks with spray rising into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting harsh and low-angled, creating strong dramatic contrast with deep shadows on the woman's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a 1940s black-and-white film style with obvious graininess and silver salt texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012547360733151436 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387547492980957 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012547360733151436, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012547360733151436, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10316925495862961, + 0.05110066756606102, + 0.03829258680343628, + 0.07239242643117905, + 0.013545830734074116, + 0.05037294328212738, + 0.039627160876989365, + 0.04971257224678993, + 0.0138746602460742, + 0.5679119229316711 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012547360733151436 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a long shot featuring a mournful aristocratic woman standing alone at the edge of a rugged, barren black volcanic cliff?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing an intricately patterned silk kimono embroidered with chrysanthemums and cranes in silver thread?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a boundless sea of white foam crashing against dark rocks with spray rising into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting harsh and low-angled, creating strong dramatic contrast with deep shadows on the woman's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a 1940s black-and-white film style with obvious graininess and silver salt texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005947155877947807 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130947113037109 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005947155877947807, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005947155877947807, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18726299703121185, + 0.08337650448083878, + 0.01586010865867138, + 0.11770553886890411, + 0.012485172599554062, + 0.048420801758766174, + 0.03889397531747818, + 0.13233576714992523, + 0.013780180364847183, + 0.3498789370059967 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005947155877947807 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "strikingly composed long shot, captured with a telephoto lens, holds the camera still, its focus fixed on a mournful aristocratic woman. She stands alone at the edge of a rugged, barren black volcanic cliff, clad in an intricately patterned silk kimono, embroidered with chrysanthemums and cranes in silver thread, symbols of both nobility and the transience of life. Behind her, the boundless, surging sea of white foam tumbles, its waves crashing again and again with thunderous force against the sharp, dark rocks at the cliff's base, sending a cascade of spray skyward. A harsh, low-angled light, like a stage spotlight, slices her profile from the side, casting deep, sharp shadows across her pale, delicate face, accentuating the sorrowful frown between her brows and the hollowness of her eyes. Wisps of wind-blown black hair brush against her cheeks, while the wide sleeves of her kimono rustle in the sharp, gusty wind. The entire scene presents the ultimate 1940s black-and-white film style. The strong dramatic contrast of light and shadow highlights the loneliness and despair of the characters. The picture has obvious graininess and silver salt texture, creating a grand, tragic and fatalistic visual atmosphere.", + "seed": 19273, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_3/index_1838_seed_19273_dp_6_rank_12_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.12096356227993965, + "vlm_logprob": -0.12096356227993965, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.5, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.12096356227993965, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a long shot featuring a mournful aristocratic woman standing alone at the edge of a rugged, barren black volcanic cliff?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing an intricately patterned silk kimono embroidered with chrysanthemums and cranes in silver thread?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a boundless sea of white foam crashing against dark rocks with spray rising into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting harsh and low-angled, creating strong dramatic contrast with deep shadows on the woman's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a 1940s black-and-white film style with obvious graininess and silver salt texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03295659273862839 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.532956600189209 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03295659273862839, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03295659273862839, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21040166914463043, + 0.08699323982000351, + 0.12497872114181519, + 0.10712403059005737, + 0.051497068256139755, + 0.06046030670404434, + 0.047585539519786835, + 0.10176152735948563, + 0.17295140027999878, + 0.036246441304683685 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03295659273862839 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a long shot featuring a mournful aristocratic woman standing alone at the edge of a rugged, barren black volcanic cliff?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing an intricately patterned silk kimono embroidered with chrysanthemums and cranes in silver thread?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a boundless sea of white foam crashing against dark rocks with spray rising into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting harsh and low-angled, creating strong dramatic contrast with deep shadows on the woman's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a 1940s black-and-white film style with obvious graininess and silver salt texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5234891176223755 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8984891176223755 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5234891176223755, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5234891176223755, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20696531236171722, + 0.09164372086524963, + 0.13347993791103363, + 0.05222402513027191, + 0.0912233218550682, + 0.05337389558553696, + 0.0340442955493927, + 0.1921842098236084, + 0.09934119135141373, + 0.04552008956670761 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5234891176223755 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a long shot featuring a mournful aristocratic woman standing alone at the edge of a rugged, barren black volcanic cliff?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing an intricately patterned silk kimono embroidered with chrysanthemums and cranes in silver thread?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a boundless sea of white foam crashing against dark rocks with spray rising into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting harsh and low-angled, creating strong dramatic contrast with deep shadows on the woman's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a 1940s black-and-white film style with obvious graininess and silver salt texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00248873233795166 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002488613128662 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00248873233795166, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00248873233795166, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1717236191034317, + 0.10917188227176666, + 0.13416710495948792, + 0.05627811700105667, + 0.10051523149013519, + 0.0525452122092247, + 0.03486303985118866, + 0.15076112747192383, + 0.15308131277561188, + 0.036893364042043686 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00248873233795166 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a long shot featuring a mournful aristocratic woman standing alone at the edge of a rugged, barren black volcanic cliff?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing an intricately patterned silk kimono embroidered with chrysanthemums and cranes in silver thread?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a boundless sea of white foam crashing against dark rocks with spray rising into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting harsh and low-angled, creating strong dramatic contrast with deep shadows on the woman's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a 1940s black-and-white film style with obvious graininess and silver salt texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02981371060013771 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529813766479492 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02981371060013771, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02981371060013771, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20774975419044495, + 0.07893902063369751, + 0.14014531672000885, + 0.20812347531318665, + 0.06330295652151108, + 0.04441801831126213, + 0.0263996459543705, + 0.1031193733215332, + 0.04769584909081459, + 0.08010660856962204 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02981371060013771 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a long shot featuring a mournful aristocratic woman standing alone at the edge of a rugged, barren black volcanic cliff?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing an intricately patterned silk kimono embroidered with chrysanthemums and cranes in silver thread?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a boundless sea of white foam crashing against dark rocks with spray rising into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting harsh and low-angled, creating strong dramatic contrast with deep shadows on the woman's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a 1940s black-and-white film style with obvious graininess and silver salt texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01606965810060501 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.1410698890686035 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01606965810060501, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01606965810060501, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18196389079093933, + 0.05869191512465477, + 0.0649387314915657, + 0.049191609025001526, + 0.07493426650762558, + 0.028856027871370316, + 0.029021283611655235, + 0.3735765814781189, + 0.07723592966794968, + 0.06158969923853874 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01606965810060501 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "strikingly composed long shot, captured with a telephoto lens, holds the camera still, its focus fixed on a mournful aristocratic woman. She stands alone at the edge of a rugged, barren black volcanic cliff, clad in an intricately patterned silk kimono, embroidered with chrysanthemums and cranes in silver thread, symbols of both nobility and the transience of life. Behind her, the boundless, surging sea of white foam tumbles, its waves crashing again and again with thunderous force against the sharp, dark rocks at the cliff's base, sending a cascade of spray skyward. A harsh, low-angled light, like a stage spotlight, slices her profile from the side, casting deep, sharp shadows across her pale, delicate face, accentuating the sorrowful frown between her brows and the hollowness of her eyes. Wisps of wind-blown black hair brush against her cheeks, while the wide sleeves of her kimono rustle in the sharp, gusty wind. The entire scene presents the ultimate 1940s black-and-white film style. The strong dramatic contrast of light and shadow highlights the loneliness and despair of the characters. The picture has obvious graininess and silver salt texture, creating a grand, tragic and fatalistic visual atmosphere.", + "seed": 19274, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_3/index_1838_seed_19274_dp_7_rank_14_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.1905328243970871, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1905328243970871, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.525, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1905328243970871, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a long shot featuring a mournful aristocratic woman standing alone at the edge of a rugged, barren black volcanic cliff?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing an intricately patterned silk kimono embroidered with chrysanthemums and cranes in silver thread?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a boundless sea of white foam crashing against dark rocks with spray rising into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting harsh and low-angled, creating strong dramatic contrast with deep shadows on the woman's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a 1940s black-and-white film style with obvious graininess and silver salt texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.027255268767476082 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6522552967071533 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.027255268767476082, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.027255268767476082, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22955875098705292, + 0.0628340020775795, + 0.0706939771771431, + 0.390967458486557, + 0.029867935925722122, + 0.05509607866406441, + 0.04399818927049637, + 0.02904743328690529, + 0.02974442020058632, + 0.05819174274802208 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.027255268767476082 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a long shot featuring a mournful aristocratic woman standing alone at the edge of a rugged, barren black volcanic cliff?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing an intricately patterned silk kimono embroidered with chrysanthemums and cranes in silver thread?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a boundless sea of white foam crashing against dark rocks with spray rising into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting harsh and low-angled, creating strong dramatic contrast with deep shadows on the woman's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a 1940s black-and-white film style with obvious graininess and silver salt texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8984389901161194 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5234389901161194 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.8984389901161194, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.8984389901161194, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1574324667453766, + 0.05125899985432625, + 0.08646060526371002, + 0.47941839694976807, + 0.05757589265704155, + 0.06687031686306, + 0.0257059708237648, + 0.02128966897726059, + 0.018511313945055008, + 0.03547633811831474 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.8984389901161194 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a long shot featuring a mournful aristocratic woman standing alone at the edge of a rugged, barren black volcanic cliff?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing an intricately patterned silk kimono embroidered with chrysanthemums and cranes in silver thread?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a boundless sea of white foam crashing against dark rocks with spray rising into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting harsh and low-angled, creating strong dramatic contrast with deep shadows on the woman's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a 1940s black-and-white film style with obvious graininess and silver salt texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004637913778424263 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379637718200684 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004637913778424263, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004637913778424263, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17532403767108917, + 0.1369783878326416, + 0.04164525121450424, + 0.44096678495407104, + 0.0454549677670002, + 0.03334289789199829, + 0.019242731854319572, + 0.04549543932080269, + 0.024335630238056183, + 0.037213850766420364 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004637913778424263 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a long shot featuring a mournful aristocratic woman standing alone at the edge of a rugged, barren black volcanic cliff?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing an intricately patterned silk kimono embroidered with chrysanthemums and cranes in silver thread?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a boundless sea of white foam crashing against dark rocks with spray rising into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting harsh and low-angled, creating strong dramatic contrast with deep shadows on the woman's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a 1940s black-and-white film style with obvious graininess and silver salt texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01254983339458704 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387549877166748 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01254983339458704, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01254983339458704, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2227802872657776, + 0.06037696450948715, + 0.04327608272433281, + 0.2536785304546356, + 0.13465498387813568, + 0.061092402786016464, + 0.10166151076555252, + 0.045607928186655045, + 0.03153587877750397, + 0.045335497707128525 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01254983339458704 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a long shot featuring a mournful aristocratic woman standing alone at the edge of a rugged, barren black volcanic cliff?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing an intricately patterned silk kimono embroidered with chrysanthemums and cranes in silver thread?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a boundless sea of white foam crashing against dark rocks with spray rising into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting harsh and low-angled, creating strong dramatic contrast with deep shadows on the woman's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a 1940s black-and-white film style with obvious graininess and silver salt texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009782115928828716 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634782314300537 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009782115928828716, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009782115928828716, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03301500529050827, + 0.014961957931518555, + 0.013370256870985031, + 0.8784899115562439, + 0.014197703450918198, + 0.01716846600174904, + 0.005501913372427225, + 0.006026459392160177, + 0.00424524862319231, + 0.013023081235587597 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009782115928828716 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "strikingly composed long shot, captured with a telephoto lens, holds the camera still, its focus fixed on a mournful aristocratic woman. She stands alone at the edge of a rugged, barren black volcanic cliff, clad in an intricately patterned silk kimono, embroidered with chrysanthemums and cranes in silver thread, symbols of both nobility and the transience of life. Behind her, the boundless, surging sea of white foam tumbles, its waves crashing again and again with thunderous force against the sharp, dark rocks at the cliff's base, sending a cascade of spray skyward. A harsh, low-angled light, like a stage spotlight, slices her profile from the side, casting deep, sharp shadows across her pale, delicate face, accentuating the sorrowful frown between her brows and the hollowness of her eyes. Wisps of wind-blown black hair brush against her cheeks, while the wide sleeves of her kimono rustle in the sharp, gusty wind. The entire scene presents the ultimate 1940s black-and-white film style. The strong dramatic contrast of light and shadow highlights the loneliness and despair of the characters. The picture has obvious graininess and silver salt texture, creating a grand, tragic and fatalistic visual atmosphere.", + "seed": 19275, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_3/index_1838_seed_19275_dp_7_rank_14_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.0748879915336147, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0748879915336147, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.95, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0748879915336147, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a long shot featuring a mournful aristocratic woman standing alone at the edge of a rugged, barren black volcanic cliff?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing an intricately patterned silk kimono embroidered with chrysanthemums and cranes in silver thread?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a boundless sea of white foam crashing against dark rocks with spray rising into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting harsh and low-angled, creating strong dramatic contrast with deep shadows on the woman's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a 1940s black-and-white film style with obvious graininess and silver salt texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03225516900420189 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.532255172729492 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03225516900420189, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03225516900420189, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2558557391166687, + 0.13908670842647552, + 0.1467193365097046, + 0.0496089830994606, + 0.036306314170360565, + 0.06630732864141464, + 0.14788785576820374, + 0.04580865800380707, + 0.04053698107600212, + 0.07188211381435394 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03225516900420189 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a long shot featuring a mournful aristocratic woman standing alone at the edge of a rugged, barren black volcanic cliff?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing an intricately patterned silk kimono embroidered with chrysanthemums and cranes in silver thread?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a boundless sea of white foam crashing against dark rocks with spray rising into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting harsh and low-angled, creating strong dramatic contrast with deep shadows on the woman's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a 1940s black-and-white film style with obvious graininess and silver salt texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.31369173526763916 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3136917352676392 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.31369173526763916, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.31369173526763916, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18799011409282684, + 0.3121155798435211, + 0.05580833926796913, + 0.056863926351070404, + 0.10400061309337616, + 0.07882729917764664, + 0.09887915849685669, + 0.03334929794073105, + 0.019276734441518784, + 0.052888963371515274 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.31369173526763916 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a long shot featuring a mournful aristocratic woman standing alone at the edge of a rugged, barren black volcanic cliff?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing an intricately patterned silk kimono embroidered with chrysanthemums and cranes in silver thread?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a boundless sea of white foam crashing against dark rocks with spray rising into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting harsh and low-angled, creating strong dramatic contrast with deep shadows on the woman's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a 1940s black-and-white film style with obvious graininess and silver salt texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0019421778852120042 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.251942157745361 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0019421778852120042, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0019421778852120042, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.192744642496109, + 0.10218223184347153, + 0.26083996891975403, + 0.0723126158118248, + 0.02790539152920246, + 0.06836620718240738, + 0.17412446439266205, + 0.04275104030966759, + 0.027172859758138657, + 0.03160050883889198 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0019421778852120042 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a long shot featuring a mournful aristocratic woman standing alone at the edge of a rugged, barren black volcanic cliff?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing an intricately patterned silk kimono embroidered with chrysanthemums and cranes in silver thread?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a boundless sea of white foam crashing against dark rocks with spray rising into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting harsh and low-angled, creating strong dramatic contrast with deep shadows on the woman's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a 1940s black-and-white film style with obvious graininess and silver salt texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020600875839591026 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8956007957458496 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020600875839591026, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020600875839591026, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.44428399205207825, + 0.08147122710943222, + 0.10884422063827515, + 0.06876487284898758, + 0.06874068826436996, + 0.06565496325492859, + 0.073524110019207, + 0.028081335127353668, + 0.022696131840348244, + 0.037938427180051804 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020600875839591026 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a long shot featuring a mournful aristocratic woman standing alone at the edge of a rugged, barren black volcanic cliff?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing an intricately patterned silk kimono embroidered with chrysanthemums and cranes in silver thread?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a boundless sea of white foam crashing against dark rocks with spray rising into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting harsh and low-angled, creating strong dramatic contrast with deep shadows on the woman's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a 1940s black-and-white film style with obvious graininess and silver salt texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005949999671429396 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130949974060059 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005949999671429396, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005949999671429396, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.41230952739715576, + 0.12550978362560272, + 0.1428808569908142, + 0.07405312359333038, + 0.07771299034357071, + 0.06252206861972809, + 0.0408247634768486, + 0.02176303043961525, + 0.017689574509859085, + 0.024734316393733025 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005949999671429396 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_4/index_tensor([3970, 3970])_group_4_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_4/index_tensor([3970, 3970])_group_4_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..a1760e2414775c1155305d0d41e306b0dc30ddbd --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_4/index_tensor([3970, 3970])_group_4_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "cinematic, close-up shot, rendered with the signature high dynamic range and sharp image quality of Sony cameras, begins with a massive basketball player. Clad in a tight, sleeveless black athletic tank top, he's bathed in dramatic, high-contrast studio lighting. Sweat shimmers on his tanned skin, highlighting every muscle bulging with energy. With his focus completely focused, his eyes fixed forward, he swung a heavy, cloth-wrapped gong mallet with unstoppable force, striking a massive, ancient bronze gong suspended from a dark wooden frame. At the moment of impact, the camera's focus remains fixed on his forearm, which tenses and bulges with veins from the immense force. Then, in a swift and smooth rack focus, the focus shifts from his arm to the struck gong surface. Under strong sidelight, the gong's surface vibrates violently, creating visible concentric ripples that spread like water waves. Its highly polished surface reflects a dazzling specular highlight, causing the camera to produce a brief and dazzling halo, and the entire screen to instantly flash in a dazzling white light, creating an ultimate sense of impact in which power and sound are visualized, and a grand atmosphere like a commercial blockbuster.", + "seed": 27340, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_4/index_3970_seed_27340_dp_8_rank_16_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.05569048011675477, + "vlm_logprob": -0.05569048011675477, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.5, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.05569048011675477, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive basketball player wearing a tight, sleeveless black athletic tank top?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the player swing a heavy, cloth-wrapped mallet to strike a massive, ancient bronze gong suspended from a dark wooden frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera initially focus on the player's forearm, showing it tensing and bulging with veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a swift and smooth rack focus to shift attention from the arm to the gong surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the gong surface show visible concentric ripples spreading like water waves after being struck?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.160612091422081 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9106121063232422 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.160612091422081, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.160612091422081, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2150791436433792, + 0.07200252264738083, + 0.17055444419384003, + 0.03228703886270523, + 0.037333253771066666, + 0.2482784539461136, + 0.029264219105243683, + 0.061714205890893936, + 0.09685096144676208, + 0.03663577511906624 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.160612091422081 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive basketball player wearing a tight, sleeveless black athletic tank top?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the player swing a heavy, cloth-wrapped mallet to strike a massive, ancient bronze gong suspended from a dark wooden frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera initially focus on the player's forearm, showing it tensing and bulging with veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a swift and smooth rack focus to shift attention from the arm to the gong surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the gong surface show visible concentric ripples spreading like water waves after being struck?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016088780015707016 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141088962554932 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016088780015707016, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016088780015707016, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12704230844974518, + 0.08309084177017212, + 0.060801777988672256, + 0.04233493283390999, + 0.06856236606836319, + 0.32552480697631836, + 0.08147266507148743, + 0.08219625800848007, + 0.07547352463006973, + 0.05350054055452347 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016088780015707016 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive basketball player wearing a tight, sleeveless black athletic tank top?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the player swing a heavy, cloth-wrapped mallet to strike a massive, ancient bronze gong suspended from a dark wooden frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera initially focus on the player's forearm, showing it tensing and bulging with veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a swift and smooth rack focus to shift attention from the arm to the gong surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the gong surface show visible concentric ripples spreading like water waves after being struck?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01606649160385132 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141066551208496 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01606649160385132, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01606649160385132, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23973269760608673, + 0.11911498755216599, + 0.0994931012392044, + 0.0330757200717926, + 0.030765797942876816, + 0.07497838139533997, + 0.053445685654878616, + 0.16596803069114685, + 0.16119512915611267, + 0.022230442613363266 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01606649160385132 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive basketball player wearing a tight, sleeveless black athletic tank top?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the player swing a heavy, cloth-wrapped mallet to strike a massive, ancient bronze gong suspended from a dark wooden frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera initially focus on the player's forearm, showing it tensing and bulging with veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a swift and smooth rack focus to shift attention from the arm to the gong surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the gong surface show visible concentric ripples spreading like water waves after being struck?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006730624008923769 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006730556488037 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006730624008923769, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006730624008923769, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10906405746936798, + 0.09623534232378006, + 0.02644026279449463, + 0.03823913633823395, + 0.06147488206624985, + 0.14112588763237, + 0.09716038405895233, + 0.19037368893623352, + 0.19480262696743011, + 0.0450836606323719 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006730624008923769 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive basketball player wearing a tight, sleeveless black athletic tank top?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the player swing a heavy, cloth-wrapped mallet to strike a massive, ancient bronze gong suspended from a dark wooden frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera initially focus on the player's forearm, showing it tensing and bulging with veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a swift and smooth rack focus to shift attention from the arm to the gong surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the gong surface show visible concentric ripples spreading like water waves after being struck?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07895441353321075 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5789544582366943 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07895441353321075, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07895441353321075, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.050214800983667374, + 0.1032220721244812, + 0.052825313061475754, + 0.02553286962211132, + 0.04587702080607414, + 0.28460001945495605, + 0.08305850625038147, + 0.1141904965043068, + 0.13439024984836578, + 0.10608865320682526 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07895441353321075 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "cinematic, close-up shot, rendered with the signature high dynamic range and sharp image quality of Sony cameras, begins with a massive basketball player. Clad in a tight, sleeveless black athletic tank top, he's bathed in dramatic, high-contrast studio lighting. Sweat shimmers on his tanned skin, highlighting every muscle bulging with energy. With his focus completely focused, his eyes fixed forward, he swung a heavy, cloth-wrapped gong mallet with unstoppable force, striking a massive, ancient bronze gong suspended from a dark wooden frame. At the moment of impact, the camera's focus remains fixed on his forearm, which tenses and bulges with veins from the immense force. Then, in a swift and smooth rack focus, the focus shifts from his arm to the struck gong surface. Under strong sidelight, the gong's surface vibrates violently, creating visible concentric ripples that spread like water waves. Its highly polished surface reflects a dazzling specular highlight, causing the camera to produce a brief and dazzling halo, and the entire screen to instantly flash in a dazzling white light, creating an ultimate sense of impact in which power and sound are visualized, and a grand atmosphere like a commercial blockbuster.", + "seed": 27341, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_4/index_3970_seed_27341_dp_8_rank_16_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.04968601241707802, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04968601241707802, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.825, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04968601241707802, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive basketball player wearing a tight, sleeveless black athletic tank top?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the player swing a heavy, cloth-wrapped mallet to strike a massive, ancient bronze gong suspended from a dark wooden frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera initially focus on the player's forearm, showing it tensing and bulging with veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a swift and smooth rack focus to shift attention from the arm to the gong surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the gong surface show visible concentric ripples spreading like water waves after being struck?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1433427631855011 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0183427333831787 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1433427631855011, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1433427631855011, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10682261735200882, + 0.4621374011039734, + 0.04599413648247719, + 0.031475652009248734, + 0.033328935503959656, + 0.03874107822775841, + 0.158139169216156, + 0.022230364382267, + 0.040805354714393616, + 0.06032535061240196 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1433427631855011 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive basketball player wearing a tight, sleeveless black athletic tank top?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the player swing a heavy, cloth-wrapped mallet to strike a massive, ancient bronze gong suspended from a dark wooden frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera initially focus on the player's forearm, showing it tensing and bulging with veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a swift and smooth rack focus to shift attention from the arm to the gong surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the gong surface show visible concentric ripples spreading like water waves after being struck?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016101330518722534 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141101360321045 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016101330518722534, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016101330518722534, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07803424447774887, + 0.3810359835624695, + 0.04537373408675194, + 0.025937283411622047, + 0.076573945581913, + 0.05468015745282173, + 0.07057496905326843, + 0.0640605166554451, + 0.05758512020111084, + 0.1461440771818161 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016101330518722534 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive basketball player wearing a tight, sleeveless black athletic tank top?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the player swing a heavy, cloth-wrapped mallet to strike a massive, ancient bronze gong suspended from a dark wooden frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera initially focus on the player's forearm, showing it tensing and bulging with veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a swift and smooth rack focus to shift attention from the arm to the gong surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the gong surface show visible concentric ripples spreading like water waves after being struck?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004091701935976744 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504091739654541 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004091701935976744, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004091701935976744, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1302817314863205, + 0.4264485239982605, + 0.08314760774374008, + 0.06816994398832321, + 0.09420321136713028, + 0.03390032425522804, + 0.04920566827058792, + 0.02757442556321621, + 0.03938877955079079, + 0.047679852694272995 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004091701935976744 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive basketball player wearing a tight, sleeveless black athletic tank top?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the player swing a heavy, cloth-wrapped mallet to strike a massive, ancient bronze gong suspended from a dark wooden frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera initially focus on the player's forearm, showing it tensing and bulging with veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a swift and smooth rack focus to shift attention from the arm to the gong surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the gong surface show visible concentric ripples spreading like water waves after being struck?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005943600554019213 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130943775177002 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005943600554019213, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005943600554019213, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11490200459957123, + 0.203667551279068, + 0.05708874762058258, + 0.15627436339855194, + 0.08781665563583374, + 0.04576781392097473, + 0.058924783021211624, + 0.05263649299740791, + 0.10758225619792938, + 0.11533931642770767 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005943600554019213 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive basketball player wearing a tight, sleeveless black athletic tank top?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the player swing a heavy, cloth-wrapped mallet to strike a massive, ancient bronze gong suspended from a dark wooden frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera initially focus on the player's forearm, showing it tensing and bulging with veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a swift and smooth rack focus to shift attention from the arm to the gong surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the gong surface show visible concentric ripples spreading like water waves after being struck?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0789506658911705 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5789506435394287 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0789506658911705, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0789506658911705, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06248404085636139, + 0.18354056775569916, + 0.03418275713920593, + 0.06073965132236481, + 0.06653370708227158, + 0.06857006996870041, + 0.09597306698560715, + 0.10853997617959976, + 0.0867387130856514, + 0.2326975017786026 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0789506658911705 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "cinematic, close-up shot, rendered with the signature high dynamic range and sharp image quality of Sony cameras, begins with a massive basketball player. Clad in a tight, sleeveless black athletic tank top, he's bathed in dramatic, high-contrast studio lighting. Sweat shimmers on his tanned skin, highlighting every muscle bulging with energy. With his focus completely focused, his eyes fixed forward, he swung a heavy, cloth-wrapped gong mallet with unstoppable force, striking a massive, ancient bronze gong suspended from a dark wooden frame. At the moment of impact, the camera's focus remains fixed on his forearm, which tenses and bulges with veins from the immense force. Then, in a swift and smooth rack focus, the focus shifts from his arm to the struck gong surface. Under strong sidelight, the gong's surface vibrates violently, creating visible concentric ripples that spread like water waves. Its highly polished surface reflects a dazzling specular highlight, causing the camera to produce a brief and dazzling halo, and the entire screen to instantly flash in a dazzling white light, creating an ultimate sense of impact in which power and sound are visualized, and a grand atmosphere like a commercial blockbuster.", + "seed": 27342, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_4/index_3970_seed_27342_dp_9_rank_18_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.04338973490521312, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04338973490521312, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.825000023841858, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04338973490521312, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive basketball player wearing a tight, sleeveless black athletic tank top?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the player swing a heavy, cloth-wrapped mallet to strike a massive, ancient bronze gong suspended from a dark wooden frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera initially focus on the player's forearm, showing it tensing and bulging with veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a swift and smooth rack focus to shift attention from the arm to the gong surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the gong surface show visible concentric ripples spreading like water waves after being struck?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04335258901119232 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1683526039123535 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04335258901119232, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04335258901119232, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09239469468593597, + 0.04250099137425423, + 0.063241146504879, + 0.07971381396055222, + 0.058562856167554855, + 0.16968581080436707, + 0.19294622540473938, + 0.03895170986652374, + 0.05952400341629982, + 0.20247872173786163 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04335258901119232 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive basketball player wearing a tight, sleeveless black athletic tank top?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the player swing a heavy, cloth-wrapped mallet to strike a massive, ancient bronze gong suspended from a dark wooden frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera initially focus on the player's forearm, showing it tensing and bulging with veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a swift and smooth rack focus to shift attention from the arm to the gong surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the gong surface show visible concentric ripples spreading like water waves after being struck?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014209403656423092 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264209270477295 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014209403656423092, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014209403656423092, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04169527813792229, + 0.017204031348228455, + 0.02090647630393505, + 0.02043968066573143, + 0.07539676129817963, + 0.05198557674884796, + 0.22058327496051788, + 0.058224085718393326, + 0.13908149302005768, + 0.35448333621025085 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014209403656423092 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive basketball player wearing a tight, sleeveless black athletic tank top?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the player swing a heavy, cloth-wrapped mallet to strike a massive, ancient bronze gong suspended from a dark wooden frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera initially focus on the player's forearm, showing it tensing and bulging with veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a swift and smooth rack focus to shift attention from the arm to the gong surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the gong surface show visible concentric ripples spreading like water waves after being struck?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012532292865216732 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.3875322341918945 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012532292865216732, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012532292865216732, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06959804892539978, + 0.028419099748134613, + 0.05418279021978378, + 0.03913765028119087, + 0.0842563658952713, + 0.17779265344142914, + 0.24182236194610596, + 0.04547300189733505, + 0.07383336871862411, + 0.18548472225666046 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012532292865216732 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive basketball player wearing a tight, sleeveless black athletic tank top?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the player swing a heavy, cloth-wrapped mallet to strike a massive, ancient bronze gong suspended from a dark wooden frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera initially focus on the player's forearm, showing it tensing and bulging with veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a swift and smooth rack focus to shift attention from the arm to the gong surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the gong surface show visible concentric ripples spreading like water waves after being struck?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004088971298187971 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504088878631592 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004088971298187971, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004088971298187971, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08396316319704056, + 0.016518842428922653, + 0.024222688749432564, + 0.036831725388765335, + 0.057161226868629456, + 0.10186634212732315, + 0.167145237326622, + 0.04592393711209297, + 0.18013213574886322, + 0.28623470664024353 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004088971298187971 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive basketball player wearing a tight, sleeveless black athletic tank top?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the player swing a heavy, cloth-wrapped mallet to strike a massive, ancient bronze gong suspended from a dark wooden frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera initially focus on the player's forearm, showing it tensing and bulging with veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a swift and smooth rack focus to shift attention from the arm to the gong surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the gong surface show visible concentric ripples spreading like water waves after being struck?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14276541769504547 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.017765522003174 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14276541769504547, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.8750001192092896, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14276541769504547, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07523100078105927, + 0.016675764694809914, + 0.015484045259654522, + 0.02934836596250534, + 0.05036015063524246, + 0.06016483157873154, + 0.05017301067709923, + 0.043750546872615814, + 0.09413650631904602, + 0.5646758675575256 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14276541769504547 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "cinematic, close-up shot, rendered with the signature high dynamic range and sharp image quality of Sony cameras, begins with a massive basketball player. Clad in a tight, sleeveless black athletic tank top, he's bathed in dramatic, high-contrast studio lighting. Sweat shimmers on his tanned skin, highlighting every muscle bulging with energy. With his focus completely focused, his eyes fixed forward, he swung a heavy, cloth-wrapped gong mallet with unstoppable force, striking a massive, ancient bronze gong suspended from a dark wooden frame. At the moment of impact, the camera's focus remains fixed on his forearm, which tenses and bulges with veins from the immense force. Then, in a swift and smooth rack focus, the focus shifts from his arm to the struck gong surface. Under strong sidelight, the gong's surface vibrates violently, creating visible concentric ripples that spread like water waves. Its highly polished surface reflects a dazzling specular highlight, causing the camera to produce a brief and dazzling halo, and the entire screen to instantly flash in a dazzling white light, creating an ultimate sense of impact in which power and sound are visualized, and a grand atmosphere like a commercial blockbuster.", + "seed": 27343, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_4/index_3970_seed_27343_dp_9_rank_18_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.053705024905502795, + "vlm_logprob": -0.053705024905502795, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.275, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.053705024905502795, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive basketball player wearing a tight, sleeveless black athletic tank top?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the player swing a heavy, cloth-wrapped mallet to strike a massive, ancient bronze gong suspended from a dark wooden frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera initially focus on the player's forearm, showing it tensing and bulging with veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a swift and smooth rack focus to shift attention from the arm to the gong surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the gong surface show visible concentric ripples spreading like water waves after being struck?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11341308802366257 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.238413095474243 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11341308802366257, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11341308802366257, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11343273520469666, + 0.07388380169868469, + 0.05035233125090599, + 0.11172722280025482, + 0.15329314768314362, + 0.05507601052522659, + 0.08400823175907135, + 0.09973908215761185, + 0.14901728928089142, + 0.10947023332118988 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11341308802366257 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive basketball player wearing a tight, sleeveless black athletic tank top?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the player swing a heavy, cloth-wrapped mallet to strike a massive, ancient bronze gong suspended from a dark wooden frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera initially focus on the player's forearm, showing it tensing and bulging with veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a swift and smooth rack focus to shift attention from the arm to the gong surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the gong surface show visible concentric ripples spreading like water waves after being struck?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03813425078988075 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881343364715576 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03813425078988075, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03813425078988075, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1267547905445099, + 0.05444621294736862, + 0.06382656842470169, + 0.07589016854763031, + 0.12567080557346344, + 0.045257993042469025, + 0.1275503933429718, + 0.059055544435977936, + 0.17625781893730164, + 0.14528967440128326 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03813425078988075 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive basketball player wearing a tight, sleeveless black athletic tank top?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the player swing a heavy, cloth-wrapped mallet to strike a massive, ancient bronze gong suspended from a dark wooden frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera initially focus on the player's forearm, showing it tensing and bulging with veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a swift and smooth rack focus to shift attention from the arm to the gong surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the gong surface show visible concentric ripples spreading like water waves after being struck?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01818835735321045 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.0181884765625 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01818835735321045, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01818835735321045, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13338682055473328, + 0.05577021837234497, + 0.09920826554298401, + 0.211818128824234, + 0.05051218345761299, + 0.07472892105579376, + 0.09456995129585266, + 0.05144338309764862, + 0.08677367120981216, + 0.14178845286369324 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01818835735321045 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive basketball player wearing a tight, sleeveless black athletic tank top?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the player swing a heavy, cloth-wrapped mallet to strike a massive, ancient bronze gong suspended from a dark wooden frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera initially focus on the player's forearm, showing it tensing and bulging with veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a swift and smooth rack focus to shift attention from the arm to the gong surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the gong surface show visible concentric ripples spreading like water waves after being struck?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009778101928532124 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634778022766113 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009778101928532124, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009778101928532124, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.045994870364665985, + 0.04133499786257744, + 0.060160595923662186, + 0.11489702761173248, + 0.09570514410734177, + 0.11207374930381775, + 0.09748940914869308, + 0.11635548621416092, + 0.13134190440177917, + 0.18464678525924683 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009778101928532124 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive basketball player wearing a tight, sleeveless black athletic tank top?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the player swing a heavy, cloth-wrapped mallet to strike a massive, ancient bronze gong suspended from a dark wooden frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera initially focus on the player's forearm, showing it tensing and bulging with veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a swift and smooth rack focus to shift attention from the arm to the gong surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the gong surface show visible concentric ripples spreading like water waves after being struck?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08901132643222809 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4640114307403564 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08901132643222809, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08901132643222809, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06588883697986603, + 0.0518856905400753, + 0.04142298921942711, + 0.05531146377325058, + 0.06540058553218842, + 0.12686507403850555, + 0.042477745562791824, + 0.11335235834121704, + 0.14950184524059296, + 0.28789347410202026 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08901132643222809 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_5/index_tensor([3893, 3893])_group_5_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_5/index_tensor([3893, 3893])_group_5_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..1d834657af693df29dc442f318398d11adca794b --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_5/index_tensor([3893, 3893])_group_5_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "subsequent low-angle, dynamic tracking shot captures a sleek, matte-black sports motorcycle speeding down a rain-soaked, neon-lit city street at midnight. A rider, clad in a tight black leather jersey and a full-face helmet, leans forward, pressed against the motorcycle's body. The dark visor reflects the shimmering light of the massive, multicolored billboards adorning the tall buildings. The damp asphalt acts like a black mirror, reflecting intensely saturated cyan, magenta, and blue hues. A thin layer of airborne vapor creates a hazy, layered light. As the rider decisively lowers the motorcycle around a sharp turn, the metal side of the motorcycle rubs violently against the rough pavement, sending a trail of dazzling orange-red sparks flying. These sparks are like short-lived flames, hissing through the night, not only illuminating the splashes of the high-speed rotating wheels, but also leaving a fiery trail on the slippery ground. The whole scene is full of speed and power, creating a cyberpunk, adrenaline-pumping atmosphere of tension.", + "seed": 17506, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_5/index_3893_seed_17506_dp_10_rank_20_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.050574053451418875, + "vlm_logprob": -0.050574053451418875, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.475, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.050574053451418875, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a sleek, matte-black sports motorcycle visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a rain-soaked, neon-lit city street at midnight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the rider wear a tight black leather jersey and a full-face helmet with a dark visor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are orange-red sparks flying from the motorcycle rubbing against the pavement during a sharp turn?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle while tracking the motorcycle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10057792067527771 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3505778312683105 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10057792067527771, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10057792067527771, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03647102043032646, + 0.04353706166148186, + 0.016611488536000252, + 0.0358382947742939, + 0.722761869430542, + 0.01806419901549816, + 0.01316793728619814, + 0.019000932574272156, + 0.06770370155572891, + 0.026843523606657982 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10057792067527771 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a sleek, matte-black sports motorcycle visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a rain-soaked, neon-lit city street at midnight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the rider wear a tight black leather jersey and a full-face helmet with a dark visor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are orange-red sparks flying from the motorcycle rubbing against the pavement during a sharp turn?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle while tracking the motorcycle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08906116336584091 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4640612602233887 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08906116336584091, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08906116336584091, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10736097395420074, + 0.04041813313961029, + 0.058171652257442474, + 0.06481216102838516, + 0.1427847146987915, + 0.04239143431186676, + 0.06839513778686523, + 0.016735687851905823, + 0.31541186571121216, + 0.14351823925971985 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08906116336584091 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a sleek, matte-black sports motorcycle visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a rain-soaked, neon-lit city street at midnight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the rider wear a tight black leather jersey and a full-face helmet with a dark visor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are orange-red sparks flying from the motorcycle rubbing against the pavement during a sharp turn?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle while tracking the motorcycle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016070948913693428 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.14107084274292 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016070948913693428, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016070948913693428, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04524347931146622, + 0.07777676731348038, + 0.01883167400956154, + 0.012723850086331367, + 0.6556434631347656, + 0.026528114452958107, + 0.024693923071026802, + 0.022135509178042412, + 0.07459867000579834, + 0.0418245755136013 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016070948913693428 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a sleek, matte-black sports motorcycle visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a rain-soaked, neon-lit city street at midnight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the rider wear a tight black leather jersey and a full-face helmet with a dark visor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are orange-red sparks flying from the motorcycle rubbing against the pavement during a sharp turn?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle while tracking the motorcycle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04306865110993385 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680686473846436 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04306865110993385, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04306865110993385, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07281269878149033, + 0.05442781001329422, + 0.05067963898181915, + 0.1454322189092636, + 0.11103091388940811, + 0.09920364618301392, + 0.04831739142537117, + 0.026427553966641426, + 0.17060302197933197, + 0.22106510400772095 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04306865110993385 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a sleek, matte-black sports motorcycle visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a rain-soaked, neon-lit city street at midnight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the rider wear a tight black leather jersey and a full-face helmet with a dark visor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are orange-red sparks flying from the motorcycle rubbing against the pavement during a sharp turn?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle while tracking the motorcycle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00409158319234848 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504091739654541 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00409158319234848, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00409158319234848, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1596670001745224, + 0.045480165630578995, + 0.046917881816625595, + 0.17965900897979736, + 0.06768873333930969, + 0.0727163776755333, + 0.06058450788259506, + 0.03853437304496765, + 0.17931464314460754, + 0.14943736791610718 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00409158319234848 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "subsequent low-angle, dynamic tracking shot captures a sleek, matte-black sports motorcycle speeding down a rain-soaked, neon-lit city street at midnight. A rider, clad in a tight black leather jersey and a full-face helmet, leans forward, pressed against the motorcycle's body. The dark visor reflects the shimmering light of the massive, multicolored billboards adorning the tall buildings. The damp asphalt acts like a black mirror, reflecting intensely saturated cyan, magenta, and blue hues. A thin layer of airborne vapor creates a hazy, layered light. As the rider decisively lowers the motorcycle around a sharp turn, the metal side of the motorcycle rubs violently against the rough pavement, sending a trail of dazzling orange-red sparks flying. These sparks are like short-lived flames, hissing through the night, not only illuminating the splashes of the high-speed rotating wheels, but also leaving a fiery trail on the slippery ground. The whole scene is full of speed and power, creating a cyberpunk, adrenaline-pumping atmosphere of tension.", + "seed": 17507, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_5/index_3893_seed_17507_dp_10_rank_20_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.08872139072045684, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08872139072045684, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.3, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08872139072045684, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a sleek, matte-black sports motorcycle visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a rain-soaked, neon-lit city street at midnight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the rider wear a tight black leather jersey and a full-face helmet with a dark visor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are orange-red sparks flying from the motorcycle rubbing against the pavement during a sharp turn?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle while tracking the motorcycle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08915625512599945 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.464156150817871 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08915625512599945, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08915625512599945, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23964817821979523, + 0.08062539249658585, + 0.09669270366430283, + 0.15393424034118652, + 0.051320385187864304, + 0.10375823825597763, + 0.03053128905594349, + 0.1297644078731537, + 0.0564638152718544, + 0.057261426001787186 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08915625512599945 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a sleek, matte-black sports motorcycle visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a rain-soaked, neon-lit city street at midnight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the rider wear a tight black leather jersey and a full-face helmet with a dark visor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are orange-red sparks flying from the motorcycle rubbing against the pavement during a sharp turn?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle while tracking the motorcycle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3134584128856659 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3134584426879883 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3134584128856659, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3134584128856659, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19424794614315033, + 0.08494313061237335, + 0.06838793307542801, + 0.07809042930603027, + 0.0371149517595768, + 0.21493390202522278, + 0.041441336274147034, + 0.0335337333381176, + 0.12124475091695786, + 0.12606194615364075 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3134584128856659 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a sleek, matte-black sports motorcycle visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a rain-soaked, neon-lit city street at midnight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the rider wear a tight black leather jersey and a full-face helmet with a dark visor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are orange-red sparks flying from the motorcycle rubbing against the pavement during a sharp turn?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle while tracking the motorcycle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016072941944003105 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141072750091553 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016072941944003105, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016072941944003105, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21839818358421326, + 0.1955811083316803, + 0.0698389932513237, + 0.03534599393606186, + 0.0385301299393177, + 0.06265340000391006, + 0.0483335480093956, + 0.13048888742923737, + 0.0711379200220108, + 0.12969183921813965 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016072941944003105 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a sleek, matte-black sports motorcycle visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a rain-soaked, neon-lit city street at midnight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the rider wear a tight black leather jersey and a full-face helmet with a dark visor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are orange-red sparks flying from the motorcycle rubbing against the pavement during a sharp turn?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle while tracking the motorcycle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01818777248263359 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018187999725342 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01818777248263359, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01818777248263359, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.058802515268325806, + 0.08079351484775543, + 0.07748397439718246, + 0.10611170530319214, + 0.03601670265197754, + 0.12052999436855316, + 0.046131331473588943, + 0.10551593452692032, + 0.2032269537448883, + 0.1653873473405838 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01818777248263359 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a sleek, matte-black sports motorcycle visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a rain-soaked, neon-lit city street at midnight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the rider wear a tight black leather jersey and a full-face helmet with a dark visor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are orange-red sparks flying from the motorcycle rubbing against the pavement during a sharp turn?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle while tracking the motorcycle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006731571163982153 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.0067315101623535 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006731571163982153, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006731571163982153, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20345652103424072, + 0.0677759200334549, + 0.08341048657894135, + 0.10916537791490555, + 0.02921714074909687, + 0.17422249913215637, + 0.09830199927091599, + 0.0529097244143486, + 0.09770569950342178, + 0.0838346779346466 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006731571163982153 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "subsequent low-angle, dynamic tracking shot captures a sleek, matte-black sports motorcycle speeding down a rain-soaked, neon-lit city street at midnight. A rider, clad in a tight black leather jersey and a full-face helmet, leans forward, pressed against the motorcycle's body. The dark visor reflects the shimmering light of the massive, multicolored billboards adorning the tall buildings. The damp asphalt acts like a black mirror, reflecting intensely saturated cyan, magenta, and blue hues. A thin layer of airborne vapor creates a hazy, layered light. As the rider decisively lowers the motorcycle around a sharp turn, the metal side of the motorcycle rubs violently against the rough pavement, sending a trail of dazzling orange-red sparks flying. These sparks are like short-lived flames, hissing through the night, not only illuminating the splashes of the high-speed rotating wheels, but also leaving a fiery trail on the slippery ground. The whole scene is full of speed and power, creating a cyberpunk, adrenaline-pumping atmosphere of tension.", + "seed": 17508, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_5/index_3893_seed_17508_dp_11_rank_22_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.022824848350137473, + "vlm_logprob": -0.022824848350137473, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.1, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.022824848350137473, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a sleek, matte-black sports motorcycle visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a rain-soaked, neon-lit city street at midnight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the rider wear a tight black leather jersey and a full-face helmet with a dark visor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are orange-red sparks flying from the motorcycle rubbing against the pavement during a sharp turn?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle while tracking the motorcycle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018395885825157166 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018395900726318 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018395885825157166, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018395885825157166, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15470491349697113, + 0.03912493586540222, + 0.11756180226802826, + 0.07823161780834198, + 0.1512094885110855, + 0.14543499052524567, + 0.0662209540605545, + 0.07222659885883331, + 0.02429843321442604, + 0.15098629891872406 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018395885825157166 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a sleek, matte-black sports motorcycle visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a rain-soaked, neon-lit city street at midnight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the rider wear a tight black leather jersey and a full-face helmet with a dark visor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are orange-red sparks flying from the motorcycle rubbing against the pavement during a sharp turn?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle while tracking the motorcycle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.054962195456027985 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929962158203125 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.054962195456027985, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.054962195456027985, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2719708979129791, + 0.11450839042663574, + 0.07537463307380676, + 0.06114643067121506, + 0.052974097430706024, + 0.04495799541473389, + 0.06051607057452202, + 0.029095517471432686, + 0.030621925368905067, + 0.25883403420448303 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.054962195456027985 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a sleek, matte-black sports motorcycle visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a rain-soaked, neon-lit city street at midnight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the rider wear a tight black leather jersey and a full-face helmet with a dark visor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are orange-red sparks flying from the motorcycle rubbing against the pavement during a sharp turn?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle while tracking the motorcycle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009785185568034649 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634785175323486 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009785185568034649, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009785185568034649, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10702703148126602, + 0.08144872635602951, + 0.11597859859466553, + 0.11468781530857086, + 0.07800070941448212, + 0.1684478372335434, + 0.041476644575595856, + 0.051152605563402176, + 0.030216034501791, + 0.21156395971775055 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 5, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009785185568034649 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a sleek, matte-black sports motorcycle visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a rain-soaked, neon-lit city street at midnight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the rider wear a tight black leather jersey and a full-face helmet with a dark visor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are orange-red sparks flying from the motorcycle rubbing against the pavement during a sharp turn?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle while tracking the motorcycle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026348400861024857 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651348352432251 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026348400861024857, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026348400861024857, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20719388127326965, + 0.10439694672822952, + 0.09429068118333817, + 0.16598716378211975, + 0.0795077383518219, + 0.036170728504657745, + 0.06160362437367439, + 0.05009724199771881, + 0.038762398064136505, + 0.16198955476284027 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026348400861024857 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a sleek, matte-black sports motorcycle visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a rain-soaked, neon-lit city street at midnight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the rider wear a tight black leather jersey and a full-face helmet with a dark visor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are orange-red sparks flying from the motorcycle rubbing against the pavement during a sharp turn?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle while tracking the motorcycle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004632574040442705 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379632472991943 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004632574040442705, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004632574040442705, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15236534178256989, + 0.06104204058647156, + 0.07737331092357635, + 0.13499726355075836, + 0.1129131019115448, + 0.06448272615671158, + 0.11039560288190842, + 0.07091528922319412, + 0.14204862713813782, + 0.07346675544977188 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004632574040442705 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "subsequent low-angle, dynamic tracking shot captures a sleek, matte-black sports motorcycle speeding down a rain-soaked, neon-lit city street at midnight. A rider, clad in a tight black leather jersey and a full-face helmet, leans forward, pressed against the motorcycle's body. The dark visor reflects the shimmering light of the massive, multicolored billboards adorning the tall buildings. The damp asphalt acts like a black mirror, reflecting intensely saturated cyan, magenta, and blue hues. A thin layer of airborne vapor creates a hazy, layered light. As the rider decisively lowers the motorcycle around a sharp turn, the metal side of the motorcycle rubs violently against the rough pavement, sending a trail of dazzling orange-red sparks flying. These sparks are like short-lived flames, hissing through the night, not only illuminating the splashes of the high-speed rotating wheels, but also leaving a fiery trail on the slippery ground. The whole scene is full of speed and power, creating a cyberpunk, adrenaline-pumping atmosphere of tension.", + "seed": 17509, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_5/index_3893_seed_17509_dp_11_rank_22_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.04726521298289299, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04726521298289299, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.7, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04726521298289299, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a sleek, matte-black sports motorcycle visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a rain-soaked, neon-lit city street at midnight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the rider wear a tight black leather jersey and a full-face helmet with a dark visor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are orange-red sparks flying from the motorcycle rubbing against the pavement during a sharp turn?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle while tracking the motorcycle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014437145553529263 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264437198638916 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014437145553529263, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014437145553529263, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20751483738422394, + 0.11699708551168442, + 0.07856573909521103, + 0.09715370833873749, + 0.055195629596710205, + 0.09408306330442429, + 0.12229575961828232, + 0.0319400355219841, + 0.14397720992565155, + 0.05227697268128395 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014437145553529263 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a sleek, matte-black sports motorcycle visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a rain-soaked, neon-lit city street at midnight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the rider wear a tight black leather jersey and a full-face helmet with a dark visor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are orange-red sparks flying from the motorcycle rubbing against the pavement during a sharp turn?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle while tracking the motorcycle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.062057022005319595 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120570182800293 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.062057022005319595, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.062057022005319595, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3928912281990051, + 0.10924641788005829, + 0.0968729555606842, + 0.029873033985495567, + 0.030441194772720337, + 0.0973525419831276, + 0.07726316154003143, + 0.03575579822063446, + 0.07723204791545868, + 0.05307159945368767 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.062057022005319595 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a sleek, matte-black sports motorcycle visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a rain-soaked, neon-lit city street at midnight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the rider wear a tight black leather jersey and a full-face helmet with a dark visor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are orange-red sparks flying from the motorcycle rubbing against the pavement during a sharp turn?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle while tracking the motorcycle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011078632436692715 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511078834533691 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011078632436692715, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011078632436692715, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1687968224287033, + 0.07011034339666367, + 0.11362668126821518, + 0.2694184482097626, + 0.037775252014398575, + 0.12588569521903992, + 0.05307213217020035, + 0.04049626365303993, + 0.06223675608634949, + 0.0585816316306591 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011078632436692715 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a sleek, matte-black sports motorcycle visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a rain-soaked, neon-lit city street at midnight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the rider wear a tight black leather jersey and a full-face helmet with a dark visor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are orange-red sparks flying from the motorcycle rubbing against the pavement during a sharp turn?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle while tracking the motorcycle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1428080052137375 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.017807960510254 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1428080052137375, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1428080052137375, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3913459777832031, + 0.055415909737348557, + 0.07527845352888107, + 0.05019264668226242, + 0.05002357438206673, + 0.12458502501249313, + 0.054079119116067886, + 0.03962516412138939, + 0.11986105889081955, + 0.03959301859140396 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1428080052137375 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a sleek, matte-black sports motorcycle visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a rain-soaked, neon-lit city street at midnight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the rider wear a tight black leather jersey and a full-face helmet with a dark visor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are orange-red sparks flying from the motorcycle rubbing against the pavement during a sharp turn?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle while tracking the motorcycle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00594525970518589 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130945205688477 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00594525970518589, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00594525970518589, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19422698020935059, + 0.07643906772136688, + 0.23294159770011902, + 0.08409027755260468, + 0.04658593609929085, + 0.09022987633943558, + 0.03442281112074852, + 0.05436839535832405, + 0.11852743476629257, + 0.06816764920949936 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00594525970518589 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_6/index_tensor([5656, 5656])_group_6_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_6/index_tensor([5656, 5656])_group_6_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..c8e34b3d31eecbe0a3a5a75c2b8979b27a0a2424 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_6/index_tensor([5656, 5656])_group_6_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "shot begins from an overhead angle, then gradually tilts upward and zooms out as the subject ascends, revealing a scene imbued with the riches of Eastern mythology. At the center of the frame, a majestic Chinese dragon, constructed entirely of clay, bears the subtle fingerprints and tool marks of hand-molding. Each scale appears individually molded and affixed, its edges slightly roughened, lending it a unique earthy texture. The dragon's head is majestic, its horns and flowing whiskers formed from golden clay, while its eyes, two smooth black glass beads, stand out against the matte clay skin. It soars slowly through the mist-shrouded mountains. Its movements are not fluid but rather rhythmic, with subtle pauses, each frame ascending, creating a unique frame-by-frame animation effect. Its serpentine body rises and falls rhythmically, its four claws making subtle strokes in the air. The backdrop is a rolling, inky-green mountain range, its peaks enveloped and obscured by a thick, cotton-like cloud, also sculpted from white clay. A few ancient, sturdy pines dot the landscape, evoking the texture of clay sculptures. Soft, diffused light evenly illuminates the scene, highlighting the matte texture of the clay, devoid of harsh reflections. The overall palette is simple and elegant, creating an artistic atmosphere of tranquility, solemnity, and the warmth of craftsmanship.", + "seed": 17853, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_6/index_5656_seed_17853_dp_12_rank_24_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.026433277735486628, + "vlm_logprob": -0.026433277735486628, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.375, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.026433277735486628, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Chinese dragon constructed entirely of clay?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the dragon's body exhibit visible hand-molding marks, roughened edges, and individually molded scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the dragon's horns and whiskers made of golden clay while its eyes are smooth black glass beads?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a rolling, inky-green mountain range with white clay clouds and clay-textured pine trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start from an overhead angle, then tilt upward and zoom out as the dragon ascends?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.09044613689184189 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4654462337493896 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.09044613689184189, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.09044613689184189, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08176251500844955, + 0.24040572345256805, + 0.08211331814527512, + 0.05252167582511902, + 0.03196612745523453, + 0.13074049353599548, + 0.09515257924795151, + 0.09001529961824417, + 0.06815000623464584, + 0.12717226147651672 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.09044613689184189 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Chinese dragon constructed entirely of clay?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the dragon's body exhibit visible hand-molding marks, roughened edges, and individually molded scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the dragon's horns and whiskers made of golden clay while its eyes are smooth black glass beads?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a rolling, inky-green mountain range with white clay clouds and clay-textured pine trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start from an overhead angle, then tilt upward and zoom out as the dragon ascends?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005266245920211077 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255266189575195 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005266245920211077, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005266245920211077, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1136792004108429, + 0.1443759799003601, + 0.02165103331208229, + 0.04473565146327019, + 0.03312774375081062, + 0.1254417896270752, + 0.10927420854568481, + 0.1520853489637375, + 0.07073262333869934, + 0.18489645421504974 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005266245920211077 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Chinese dragon constructed entirely of clay?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the dragon's body exhibit visible hand-molding marks, roughened edges, and individually molded scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the dragon's horns and whiskers made of golden clay while its eyes are smooth black glass beads?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a rolling, inky-green mountain range with white clay clouds and clay-textured pine trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start from an overhead angle, then tilt upward and zoom out as the dragon ascends?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01820380985736847 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.0182037353515625 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01820380985736847, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01820380985736847, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11579284816980362, + 0.0775059163570404, + 0.028921306133270264, + 0.0953810065984726, + 0.042660728096961975, + 0.168237566947937, + 0.16066893935203552, + 0.10188958048820496, + 0.06775422394275665, + 0.14118781685829163 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01820380985736847 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Chinese dragon constructed entirely of clay?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the dragon's body exhibit visible hand-molding marks, roughened edges, and individually molded scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the dragon's horns and whiskers made of golden clay while its eyes are smooth black glass beads?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a rolling, inky-green mountain range with white clay clouds and clay-textured pine trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start from an overhead angle, then tilt upward and zoom out as the dragon ascends?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0021944984328001738 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127194404602051 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0021944984328001738, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0021944984328001738, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12790779769420624, + 0.06372377276420593, + 0.09488445520401001, + 0.10654337704181671, + 0.0902538001537323, + 0.09676091372966766, + 0.06956981122493744, + 0.2274789661169052, + 0.041516825556755066, + 0.0813603401184082 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0021944984328001738 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Chinese dragon constructed entirely of clay?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the dragon's body exhibit visible hand-molding marks, roughened edges, and individually molded scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the dragon's horns and whiskers made of golden clay while its eyes are smooth black glass beads?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a rolling, inky-green mountain range with white clay clouds and clay-textured pine trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start from an overhead angle, then tilt upward and zoom out as the dragon ascends?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016055697575211525 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141055583953857 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016055697575211525, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016055697575211525, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22378909587860107, + 0.11627355962991714, + 0.06485144048929214, + 0.1373566836118698, + 0.06509228050708771, + 0.0952848494052887, + 0.09296590089797974, + 0.08979972451925278, + 0.06678398698568344, + 0.04780249297618866 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016055697575211525 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "shot begins from an overhead angle, then gradually tilts upward and zooms out as the subject ascends, revealing a scene imbued with the riches of Eastern mythology. At the center of the frame, a majestic Chinese dragon, constructed entirely of clay, bears the subtle fingerprints and tool marks of hand-molding. Each scale appears individually molded and affixed, its edges slightly roughened, lending it a unique earthy texture. The dragon's head is majestic, its horns and flowing whiskers formed from golden clay, while its eyes, two smooth black glass beads, stand out against the matte clay skin. It soars slowly through the mist-shrouded mountains. Its movements are not fluid but rather rhythmic, with subtle pauses, each frame ascending, creating a unique frame-by-frame animation effect. Its serpentine body rises and falls rhythmically, its four claws making subtle strokes in the air. The backdrop is a rolling, inky-green mountain range, its peaks enveloped and obscured by a thick, cotton-like cloud, also sculpted from white clay. A few ancient, sturdy pines dot the landscape, evoking the texture of clay sculptures. Soft, diffused light evenly illuminates the scene, highlighting the matte texture of the clay, devoid of harsh reflections. The overall palette is simple and elegant, creating an artistic atmosphere of tranquility, solemnity, and the warmth of craftsmanship.", + "seed": 17854, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_6/index_5656_seed_17854_dp_12_rank_24_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.03718955209478736, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03718955209478736, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.0, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03718955209478736, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Chinese dragon constructed entirely of clay?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the dragon's body exhibit visible hand-molding marks, roughened edges, and individually molded scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the dragon's horns and whiskers made of golden clay while its eyes are smooth black glass beads?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a rolling, inky-green mountain range with white clay clouds and clay-textured pine trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start from an overhead angle, then tilt upward and zoom out as the dragon ascends?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07211054116487503 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.697110652923584 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07211054116487503, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07211054116487503, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10353134572505951, + 0.08166789263486862, + 0.05578301101922989, + 0.018360968679189682, + 0.0437975712120533, + 0.04889310896396637, + 0.16335901618003845, + 0.33141639828681946, + 0.11823819577693939, + 0.03495246544480324 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07211054116487503 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Chinese dragon constructed entirely of clay?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the dragon's body exhibit visible hand-molding marks, roughened edges, and individually molded scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the dragon's horns and whiskers made of golden clay while its eyes are smooth black glass beads?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a rolling, inky-green mountain range with white clay clouds and clay-textured pine trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start from an overhead angle, then tilt upward and zoom out as the dragon ascends?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004112715367227793 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504112720489502 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004112715367227793, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004112715367227793, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07688365876674652, + 0.27427658438682556, + 0.059068117290735245, + 0.031857047230005264, + 0.0697568878531456, + 0.05602670833468437, + 0.051394835114479065, + 0.30789873003959656, + 0.03431909903883934, + 0.03851831704378128 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004112715367227793 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Chinese dragon constructed entirely of clay?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the dragon's body exhibit visible hand-molding marks, roughened edges, and individually molded scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the dragon's horns and whiskers made of golden clay while its eyes are smooth black glass beads?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a rolling, inky-green mountain range with white clay clouds and clay-textured pine trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start from an overhead angle, then tilt upward and zoom out as the dragon ascends?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016084088012576103 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.14108419418335 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016084088012576103, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016084088012576103, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.02716778963804245, + 0.21153518557548523, + 0.045729175209999084, + 0.022884313017129898, + 0.01622783951461315, + 0.027217863127589226, + 0.08085960894823074, + 0.25569459795951843, + 0.06681150943040848, + 0.2458721548318863 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016084088012576103 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Chinese dragon constructed entirely of clay?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the dragon's body exhibit visible hand-molding marks, roughened edges, and individually molded scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the dragon's horns and whiskers made of golden clay while its eyes are smooth black glass beads?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a rolling, inky-green mountain range with white clay clouds and clay-textured pine trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start from an overhead angle, then tilt upward and zoom out as the dragon ascends?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004635303281247616 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379635334014893 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004635303281247616, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004635303281247616, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07852518558502197, + 0.03816989064216614, + 0.05512320622801781, + 0.03080977126955986, + 0.025851324200630188, + 0.054788388311862946, + 0.32795897126197815, + 0.2047988474369049, + 0.034901995211839676, + 0.14907240867614746 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004635303281247616 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Chinese dragon constructed entirely of clay?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the dragon's body exhibit visible hand-molding marks, roughened edges, and individually molded scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the dragon's horns and whiskers made of golden clay while its eyes are smooth black glass beads?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a rolling, inky-green mountain range with white clay clouds and clay-textured pine trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start from an overhead angle, then tilt upward and zoom out as the dragon ascends?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08900511264801025 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4640049934387207 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08900511264801025, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08900511264801025, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08383660763502121, + 0.2304091900587082, + 0.11022164672613144, + 0.03216321021318436, + 0.014338688924908638, + 0.03981592506170273, + 0.16390156745910645, + 0.2715030014514923, + 0.015420581214129925, + 0.038389578461647034 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08900511264801025 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "shot begins from an overhead angle, then gradually tilts upward and zooms out as the subject ascends, revealing a scene imbued with the riches of Eastern mythology. At the center of the frame, a majestic Chinese dragon, constructed entirely of clay, bears the subtle fingerprints and tool marks of hand-molding. Each scale appears individually molded and affixed, its edges slightly roughened, lending it a unique earthy texture. The dragon's head is majestic, its horns and flowing whiskers formed from golden clay, while its eyes, two smooth black glass beads, stand out against the matte clay skin. It soars slowly through the mist-shrouded mountains. Its movements are not fluid but rather rhythmic, with subtle pauses, each frame ascending, creating a unique frame-by-frame animation effect. Its serpentine body rises and falls rhythmically, its four claws making subtle strokes in the air. The backdrop is a rolling, inky-green mountain range, its peaks enveloped and obscured by a thick, cotton-like cloud, also sculpted from white clay. A few ancient, sturdy pines dot the landscape, evoking the texture of clay sculptures. Soft, diffused light evenly illuminates the scene, highlighting the matte texture of the clay, devoid of harsh reflections. The overall palette is simple and elegant, creating an artistic atmosphere of tranquility, solemnity, and the warmth of craftsmanship.", + "seed": 17855, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_6/index_5656_seed_17855_dp_13_rank_26_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.03846104573458433, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03846104573458433, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.1749999761581424, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03846104573458433, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Chinese dragon constructed entirely of clay?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the dragon's body exhibit visible hand-molding marks, roughened edges, and individually molded scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the dragon's horns and whiskers made of golden clay while its eyes are smooth black glass beads?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a rolling, inky-green mountain range with white clay clouds and clay-textured pine trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start from an overhead angle, then tilt upward and zoom out as the dragon ascends?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14399752020835876 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0189974308013916 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14399752020835876, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.8749998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14399752020835876, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10068229585886002, + 0.062386322766542435, + 0.11592015624046326, + 0.13427764177322388, + 0.03744800388813019, + 0.12354253977537155, + 0.03557118400931358, + 0.10406321287155151, + 0.11768771708011627, + 0.16842088103294373 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14399752020835876 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Chinese dragon constructed entirely of clay?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the dragon's body exhibit visible hand-molding marks, roughened edges, and individually molded scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the dragon's horns and whiskers made of golden clay while its eyes are smooth black glass beads?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a rolling, inky-green mountain range with white clay clouds and clay-textured pine trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start from an overhead angle, then tilt upward and zoom out as the dragon ascends?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006754186935722828 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006754398345947 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006754186935722828, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006754186935722828, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15314649045467377, + 0.06187870725989342, + 0.10944095253944397, + 0.07170750200748444, + 0.09979401528835297, + 0.07992907613515854, + 0.042161718010902405, + 0.05052900314331055, + 0.09954662621021271, + 0.23186591267585754 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006754186935722828 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Chinese dragon constructed entirely of clay?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the dragon's body exhibit visible hand-molding marks, roughened edges, and individually molded scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the dragon's horns and whiskers made of golden clay while its eyes are smooth black glass beads?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a rolling, inky-green mountain range with white clay clouds and clay-textured pine trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start from an overhead angle, then tilt upward and zoom out as the dragon ascends?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016086667776107788 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141086578369141 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016086667776107788, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016086667776107788, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10754289478063583, + 0.13908293843269348, + 0.1202073022723198, + 0.07307188212871552, + 0.12124112993478775, + 0.08283385634422302, + 0.05133132264018059, + 0.08264227956533432, + 0.09923430532217026, + 0.12281210720539093 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016086667776107788 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Chinese dragon constructed entirely of clay?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the dragon's body exhibit visible hand-molding marks, roughened edges, and individually molded scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the dragon's horns and whiskers made of golden clay while its eyes are smooth black glass beads?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a rolling, inky-green mountain range with white clay clouds and clay-textured pine trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start from an overhead angle, then tilt upward and zoom out as the dragon ascends?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0021947361528873444 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127194881439209 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0021947361528873444, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0021947361528873444, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1546364575624466, + 0.11999539285898209, + 0.06601537764072418, + 0.07045672088861465, + 0.13222472369670868, + 0.09066477417945862, + 0.046023208647966385, + 0.0490809790790081, + 0.10870424658060074, + 0.16219812631607056 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0021947361528873444 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Chinese dragon constructed entirely of clay?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the dragon's body exhibit visible hand-molding marks, roughened edges, and individually molded scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the dragon's horns and whiskers made of golden clay while its eyes are smooth black glass beads?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a rolling, inky-green mountain range with white clay clouds and clay-textured pine trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start from an overhead angle, then tilt upward and zoom out as the dragon ascends?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023272117599844933 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732720375061035 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023272117599844933, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023272117599844933, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.30869632959365845, + 0.11828823387622833, + 0.06370014697313309, + 0.05565445497632027, + 0.0923910066485405, + 0.05669664591550827, + 0.07064387947320938, + 0.06384558230638504, + 0.07405421137809753, + 0.09602954238653183 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023272117599844933 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "shot begins from an overhead angle, then gradually tilts upward and zooms out as the subject ascends, revealing a scene imbued with the riches of Eastern mythology. At the center of the frame, a majestic Chinese dragon, constructed entirely of clay, bears the subtle fingerprints and tool marks of hand-molding. Each scale appears individually molded and affixed, its edges slightly roughened, lending it a unique earthy texture. The dragon's head is majestic, its horns and flowing whiskers formed from golden clay, while its eyes, two smooth black glass beads, stand out against the matte clay skin. It soars slowly through the mist-shrouded mountains. Its movements are not fluid but rather rhythmic, with subtle pauses, each frame ascending, creating a unique frame-by-frame animation effect. Its serpentine body rises and falls rhythmically, its four claws making subtle strokes in the air. The backdrop is a rolling, inky-green mountain range, its peaks enveloped and obscured by a thick, cotton-like cloud, also sculpted from white clay. A few ancient, sturdy pines dot the landscape, evoking the texture of clay sculptures. Soft, diffused light evenly illuminates the scene, highlighting the matte texture of the clay, devoid of harsh reflections. The overall palette is simple and elegant, creating an artistic atmosphere of tranquility, solemnity, and the warmth of craftsmanship.", + "seed": 17856, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_6/index_5656_seed_17856_dp_13_rank_26_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.022347215702757238, + "vlm_logprob": -0.022347215702757238, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.725, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.022347215702757238, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Chinese dragon constructed entirely of clay?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the dragon's body exhibit visible hand-molding marks, roughened edges, and individually molded scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the dragon's horns and whiskers made of golden clay while its eyes are smooth black glass beads?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a rolling, inky-green mountain range with white clay clouds and clay-textured pine trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start from an overhead angle, then tilt upward and zoom out as the dragon ascends?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08042088150978088 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.580420970916748 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08042088150978088, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08042088150978088, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.020109595730900764, + 0.005951670929789543, + 0.004549666307866573, + 0.01249669399112463, + 0.004500376991927624, + 0.902558445930481, + 0.012621354311704636, + 0.010420523583889008, + 0.018054375424981117, + 0.008737251162528992 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08042088150978088 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Chinese dragon constructed entirely of clay?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the dragon's body exhibit visible hand-molding marks, roughened edges, and individually molded scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the dragon's horns and whiskers made of golden clay while its eyes are smooth black glass beads?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a rolling, inky-green mountain range with white clay clouds and clay-textured pine trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start from an overhead angle, then tilt upward and zoom out as the dragon ascends?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002833758248016238 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877833843231201 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002833758248016238, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002833758248016238, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.014689730480313301, + 0.003510218346491456, + 0.005168452393263578, + 0.04642880707979202, + 0.022439582273364067, + 0.8752879500389099, + 0.006850796286016703, + 0.004385318141430616, + 0.01746118627488613, + 0.0037780290003865957 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002833758248016238 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Chinese dragon constructed entirely of clay?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the dragon's body exhibit visible hand-molding marks, roughened edges, and individually molded scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the dragon's horns and whiskers made of golden clay while its eyes are smooth black glass beads?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a rolling, inky-green mountain range with white clay clouds and clay-textured pine trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start from an overhead angle, then tilt upward and zoom out as the dragon ascends?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020599940791726112 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895599842071533 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020599940791726112, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020599940791726112, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.016177689656615257, + 0.007709787227213383, + 0.01492059975862503, + 0.05541364476084709, + 0.02477836050093174, + 0.8131487965583801, + 0.010429484769701958, + 0.026062361896038055, + 0.025355830788612366, + 0.006003379821777344 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 3, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020599940791726112 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Chinese dragon constructed entirely of clay?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the dragon's body exhibit visible hand-molding marks, roughened edges, and individually molded scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the dragon's horns and whiskers made of golden clay while its eyes are smooth black glass beads?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a rolling, inky-green mountain range with white clay clouds and clay-textured pine trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start from an overhead angle, then tilt upward and zoom out as the dragon ascends?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0019386084750294685 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.251938819885254 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0019386084750294685, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0019386084750294685, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04576805979013443, + 0.021728085353970528, + 0.02406008541584015, + 0.05435286834836006, + 0.04014015942811966, + 0.4777058959007263, + 0.03245797008275986, + 0.06527405977249146, + 0.20935438573360443, + 0.02915845438838005 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0019386084750294685 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Chinese dragon constructed entirely of clay?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the dragon's body exhibit visible hand-molding marks, roughened edges, and individually molded scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the dragon's horns and whiskers made of golden clay while its eyes are smooth black glass beads?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a rolling, inky-green mountain range with white clay clouds and clay-textured pine trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start from an overhead angle, then tilt upward and zoom out as the dragon ascends?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005942889489233494 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.1309428215026855 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005942889489233494, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005942889489233494, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.018048198893666267, + 0.009888400323688984, + 0.01089155487716198, + 0.09612920880317688, + 0.05135040357708931, + 0.7723209857940674, + 0.013971423730254173, + 0.011821113526821136, + 0.00968859251588583, + 0.00589012959972024 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005942889489233494 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_7/index_tensor([5912, 5912])_group_7_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_7/index_tensor([5912, 5912])_group_7_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..7899f73d1706ad681004aa70caf5ded89cd099d2 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_7/index_tensor([5912, 5912])_group_7_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "low-angle, static, extreme close-up, rendered in HR Giger's signature dark, surreal style, captures a biomechanical pangolin as it slowly unfurls from a defensive ball. The creature's form is a nightmarish fusion of polished chrome and dark, damp chitin, the tight framing focused on the terrifyingly complex movements of its interlocking plates. With deliberate mechanical slowness, the chrome scales, reflecting a distorted, cold light, begin to separate from the smooth, oily chitin plates, revealing the gleaming, muscular flesh beneath. This underlying tissue is a grotesque tapestry of translucent muscle fibers interwoven with black, pulsating conduits and thin metallic wiring, all slick with a viscous fluid. The scene is illuminated by a harsh keylight from above, carving the creature out of the oppressive, ambiguous darkness and creating a stark interplay of metallic shimmer and deep, cavernous shadows. The color palette is a cool, desaturated monochrome of gunmetal and obsidian, emphasizing the alien textures and creating a claustrophobic, deeply unsettling atmosphere of biomechanical horror.", + "seed": 4947, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_7/index_5912_seed_4947_dp_14_rank_28_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.1474272958934307, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1474272958934307, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.575, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1474272958934307, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a biomechanical pangolin composed of polished chrome and dark chitin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the pangolin shown slowly unfurling from a defensive ball?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the creature reveal translucent muscle fibers, black pulsating conduits, and metallic wiring beneath its plates?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a harsh keylight from above creating stark metallic shimmer and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color palette a cool, desaturated monochrome of gunmetal and obsidian?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08243565261363983 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5824356079101562 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08243565261363983, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08243565261363983, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.37860891222953796, + 0.07675985991954803, + 0.03317398205399513, + 0.03116610087454319, + 0.08302891999483109, + 0.0362144336104393, + 0.05386299267411232, + 0.12136445194482803, + 0.08720870316028595, + 0.09861168265342712 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08243565261363983 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a biomechanical pangolin composed of polished chrome and dark chitin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the pangolin shown slowly unfurling from a defensive ball?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the creature reveal translucent muscle fibers, black pulsating conduits, and metallic wiring beneath its plates?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a harsh keylight from above creating stark metallic shimmer and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color palette a cool, desaturated monochrome of gunmetal and obsidian?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.25213491916656494 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.502134919166565 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.25213491916656494, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.25213491916656494, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5479694604873657, + 0.04324694350361824, + 0.08568285405635834, + 0.027947232127189636, + 0.02025728113949299, + 0.02408156730234623, + 0.06596297770738602, + 0.09964577108621597, + 0.061599552631378174, + 0.0236063115298748 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.25213491916656494 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a biomechanical pangolin composed of polished chrome and dark chitin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the pangolin shown slowly unfurling from a defensive ball?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the creature reveal translucent muscle fibers, black pulsating conduits, and metallic wiring beneath its plates?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a harsh keylight from above creating stark metallic shimmer and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color palette a cool, desaturated monochrome of gunmetal and obsidian?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0052642300724983215 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.2552642822265625 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0052642300724983215, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0052642300724983215, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21043981611728668, + 0.10127914696931839, + 0.04974113777279854, + 0.017503509297966957, + 0.01404228899627924, + 0.028118610382080078, + 0.04235487058758736, + 0.25105273723602295, + 0.12605701386928558, + 0.15941084921360016 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0052642300724983215 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a biomechanical pangolin composed of polished chrome and dark chitin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the pangolin shown slowly unfurling from a defensive ball?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the creature reveal translucent muscle fibers, black pulsating conduits, and metallic wiring beneath its plates?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a harsh keylight from above creating stark metallic shimmer and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color palette a cool, desaturated monochrome of gunmetal and obsidian?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04865739122033119 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486574172973633 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04865739122033119, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04865739122033119, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22365789115428925, + 0.05445757135748863, + 0.041604168713092804, + 0.020567789673805237, + 0.054814983159303665, + 0.044145409017801285, + 0.01577608659863472, + 0.13196077942848206, + 0.14797274768352509, + 0.26504257321357727 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04865739122033119 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a biomechanical pangolin composed of polished chrome and dark chitin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the pangolin shown slowly unfurling from a defensive ball?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the creature reveal translucent muscle fibers, black pulsating conduits, and metallic wiring beneath its plates?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a harsh keylight from above creating stark metallic shimmer and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color palette a cool, desaturated monochrome of gunmetal and obsidian?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.34864428639411926 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2236442565917969 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.34864428639411926, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.34864428639411926, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18784476816654205, + 0.07806926965713501, + 0.011027159169316292, + 0.016965357586741447, + 0.016116082668304443, + 0.02266836352646351, + 0.02304336428642273, + 0.3098236620426178, + 0.29844993352890015, + 0.03599207475781441 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.34864428639411926 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, static, extreme close-up, rendered in HR Giger's signature dark, surreal style, captures a biomechanical pangolin as it slowly unfurls from a defensive ball. The creature's form is a nightmarish fusion of polished chrome and dark, damp chitin, the tight framing focused on the terrifyingly complex movements of its interlocking plates. With deliberate mechanical slowness, the chrome scales, reflecting a distorted, cold light, begin to separate from the smooth, oily chitin plates, revealing the gleaming, muscular flesh beneath. This underlying tissue is a grotesque tapestry of translucent muscle fibers interwoven with black, pulsating conduits and thin metallic wiring, all slick with a viscous fluid. The scene is illuminated by a harsh keylight from above, carving the creature out of the oppressive, ambiguous darkness and creating a stark interplay of metallic shimmer and deep, cavernous shadows. The color palette is a cool, desaturated monochrome of gunmetal and obsidian, emphasizing the alien textures and creating a claustrophobic, deeply unsettling atmosphere of biomechanical horror.", + "seed": 4948, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_7/index_5912_seed_4948_dp_14_rank_28_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.03510065884329379, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03510065884329379, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.675, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03510065884329379, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a biomechanical pangolin composed of polished chrome and dark chitin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the pangolin shown slowly unfurling from a defensive ball?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the creature reveal translucent muscle fibers, black pulsating conduits, and metallic wiring beneath its plates?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a harsh keylight from above creating stark metallic shimmer and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color palette a cool, desaturated monochrome of gunmetal and obsidian?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.028257273137569427 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.653257369995117 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.028257273137569427, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.028257273137569427, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11020607501268387, + 0.20689766108989716, + 0.04093443974852562, + 0.05014728009700775, + 0.09559027850627899, + 0.10077985376119614, + 0.16239334642887115, + 0.03305230289697647, + 0.11626877635717392, + 0.08373001217842102 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.028257273137569427 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a biomechanical pangolin composed of polished chrome and dark chitin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the pangolin shown slowly unfurling from a defensive ball?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the creature reveal translucent muscle fibers, black pulsating conduits, and metallic wiring beneath its plates?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a harsh keylight from above creating stark metallic shimmer and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color palette a cool, desaturated monochrome of gunmetal and obsidian?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05497268959879875 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299726486206055 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05497268959879875, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05497268959879875, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07578377425670624, + 0.18935561180114746, + 0.0357113741338253, + 0.02404162473976612, + 0.05895767733454704, + 0.07814488559961319, + 0.14332932233810425, + 0.08710398524999619, + 0.17599603533744812, + 0.13157562911510468 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05497268959879875 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a biomechanical pangolin composed of polished chrome and dark chitin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the pangolin shown slowly unfurling from a defensive ball?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the creature reveal translucent muscle fibers, black pulsating conduits, and metallic wiring beneath its plates?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a harsh keylight from above creating stark metallic shimmer and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color palette a cool, desaturated monochrome of gunmetal and obsidian?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036253698635846376 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628625392913818 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036253698635846376, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036253698635846376, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04898205026984215, + 0.39855432510375977, + 0.0334039069712162, + 0.03270379453897476, + 0.06037026271224022, + 0.05970611050724983, + 0.07162846624851227, + 0.03432166203856468, + 0.0914175733923912, + 0.16891178488731384 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036253698635846376 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a biomechanical pangolin composed of polished chrome and dark chitin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the pangolin shown slowly unfurling from a defensive ball?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the creature reveal translucent muscle fibers, black pulsating conduits, and metallic wiring beneath its plates?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a harsh keylight from above creating stark metallic shimmer and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color palette a cool, desaturated monochrome of gunmetal and obsidian?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03369637206196785 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408696413040161 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03369637206196785, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03369637206196785, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14101815223693848, + 0.2628081440925598, + 0.043925389647483826, + 0.031867727637290955, + 0.12194640189409256, + 0.03808300197124481, + 0.07558704167604446, + 0.043604519218206406, + 0.09205526858568192, + 0.14910443127155304 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03369637206196785 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a biomechanical pangolin composed of polished chrome and dark chitin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the pangolin shown slowly unfurling from a defensive ball?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the creature reveal translucent muscle fibers, black pulsating conduits, and metallic wiring beneath its plates?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a harsh keylight from above creating stark metallic shimmer and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color palette a cool, desaturated monochrome of gunmetal and obsidian?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.054951589554548264 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299516677856445 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.054951589554548264, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.054951589554548264, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08911150693893433, + 0.06275147199630737, + 0.038580913096666336, + 0.06529904901981354, + 0.08547414839267731, + 0.03133029118180275, + 0.063498355448246, + 0.04301121458411217, + 0.2860262989997864, + 0.23491674661636353 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.054951589554548264 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, static, extreme close-up, rendered in HR Giger's signature dark, surreal style, captures a biomechanical pangolin as it slowly unfurls from a defensive ball. The creature's form is a nightmarish fusion of polished chrome and dark, damp chitin, the tight framing focused on the terrifyingly complex movements of its interlocking plates. With deliberate mechanical slowness, the chrome scales, reflecting a distorted, cold light, begin to separate from the smooth, oily chitin plates, revealing the gleaming, muscular flesh beneath. This underlying tissue is a grotesque tapestry of translucent muscle fibers interwoven with black, pulsating conduits and thin metallic wiring, all slick with a viscous fluid. The scene is illuminated by a harsh keylight from above, carving the creature out of the oppressive, ambiguous darkness and creating a stark interplay of metallic shimmer and deep, cavernous shadows. The color palette is a cool, desaturated monochrome of gunmetal and obsidian, emphasizing the alien textures and creating a claustrophobic, deeply unsettling atmosphere of biomechanical horror.", + "seed": 4949, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_7/index_5912_seed_4949_dp_15_rank_30_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.15585846127942204, + "vlm_logprob": -0.15585846127942204, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.7, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.15585846127942204, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a biomechanical pangolin composed of polished chrome and dark chitin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the pangolin shown slowly unfurling from a defensive ball?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the creature reveal translucent muscle fibers, black pulsating conduits, and metallic wiring beneath its plates?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a harsh keylight from above creating stark metallic shimmer and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color palette a cool, desaturated monochrome of gunmetal and obsidian?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08469230681657791 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5846922397613525 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08469230681657791, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08469230681657791, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10451049357652664, + 0.09435195475816727, + 0.07269763946533203, + 0.14588995277881622, + 0.030987992882728577, + 0.032910142093896866, + 0.06205228343605995, + 0.10017137229442596, + 0.20550519227981567, + 0.1509229689836502 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08469230681657791 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a biomechanical pangolin composed of polished chrome and dark chitin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the pangolin shown slowly unfurling from a defensive ball?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the creature reveal translucent muscle fibers, black pulsating conduits, and metallic wiring beneath its plates?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a harsh keylight from above creating stark metallic shimmer and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color palette a cool, desaturated monochrome of gunmetal and obsidian?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08905593305826187 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4640560150146484 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08905593305826187, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08905593305826187, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09164351969957352, + 0.08543653786182404, + 0.08026973903179169, + 0.09349563717842102, + 0.04134438559412956, + 0.08975540846586227, + 0.14085054397583008, + 0.054323356598615646, + 0.23775073885917664, + 0.08513015508651733 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08905593305826187 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a biomechanical pangolin composed of polished chrome and dark chitin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the pangolin shown slowly unfurling from a defensive ball?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the creature reveal translucent muscle fibers, black pulsating conduits, and metallic wiring beneath its plates?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a harsh keylight from above creating stark metallic shimmer and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color palette a cool, desaturated monochrome of gunmetal and obsidian?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0032029063440859318 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.75320291519165 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0032029063440859318, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0032029063440859318, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.060134273022413254, + 0.04718908667564392, + 0.030900871381163597, + 0.02364654280245304, + 0.027824675664305687, + 0.04764191806316376, + 0.038886863738298416, + 0.16076232492923737, + 0.4612002372741699, + 0.10181315988302231 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0032029063440859318 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a biomechanical pangolin composed of polished chrome and dark chitin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the pangolin shown slowly unfurling from a defensive ball?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the creature reveal translucent muscle fibers, black pulsating conduits, and metallic wiring beneath its plates?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a harsh keylight from above creating stark metallic shimmer and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color palette a cool, desaturated monochrome of gunmetal and obsidian?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07898591458797455 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5789859294891357 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07898591458797455, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07898591458797455, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10696132481098175, + 0.03063761442899704, + 0.07881505787372589, + 0.08175064623355865, + 0.06310944259166718, + 0.05568794161081314, + 0.03866183012723923, + 0.030695905908942223, + 0.3741630017757416, + 0.13951724767684937 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07898591458797455 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a biomechanical pangolin composed of polished chrome and dark chitin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the pangolin shown slowly unfurling from a defensive ball?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the creature reveal translucent muscle fibers, black pulsating conduits, and metallic wiring beneath its plates?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a harsh keylight from above creating stark metallic shimmer and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color palette a cool, desaturated monochrome of gunmetal and obsidian?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.52335524559021 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.89835524559021 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.52335524559021, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.52335524559021, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03309217095375061, + 0.01681145839393139, + 0.020426588132977486, + 0.013820860534906387, + 0.01944095641374588, + 0.025396764278411865, + 0.031174033880233765, + 0.019230589270591736, + 0.5907464027404785, + 0.22986015677452087 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.52335524559021 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, static, extreme close-up, rendered in HR Giger's signature dark, surreal style, captures a biomechanical pangolin as it slowly unfurls from a defensive ball. The creature's form is a nightmarish fusion of polished chrome and dark, damp chitin, the tight framing focused on the terrifyingly complex movements of its interlocking plates. With deliberate mechanical slowness, the chrome scales, reflecting a distorted, cold light, begin to separate from the smooth, oily chitin plates, revealing the gleaming, muscular flesh beneath. This underlying tissue is a grotesque tapestry of translucent muscle fibers interwoven with black, pulsating conduits and thin metallic wiring, all slick with a viscous fluid. The scene is illuminated by a harsh keylight from above, carving the creature out of the oppressive, ambiguous darkness and creating a stark interplay of metallic shimmer and deep, cavernous shadows. The color palette is a cool, desaturated monochrome of gunmetal and obsidian, emphasizing the alien textures and creating a claustrophobic, deeply unsettling atmosphere of biomechanical horror.", + "seed": 4950, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_7/index_5912_seed_4950_dp_15_rank_30_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.053176664654165505, + "vlm_logprob": -0.053176664654165505, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.325, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.053176664654165505, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a biomechanical pangolin composed of polished chrome and dark chitin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the pangolin shown slowly unfurling from a defensive ball?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the creature reveal translucent muscle fibers, black pulsating conduits, and metallic wiring beneath its plates?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a harsh keylight from above creating stark metallic shimmer and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color palette a cool, desaturated monochrome of gunmetal and obsidian?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.031286973506212234 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5312869548797607 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.031286973506212234, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.031286973506212234, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.32141053676605225, + 0.13814933598041534, + 0.07038762420415878, + 0.019334441050887108, + 0.0850745290517807, + 0.0695280209183693, + 0.076045922935009, + 0.0347730852663517, + 0.05416392162442207, + 0.1311325877904892 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.031286973506212234 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a biomechanical pangolin composed of polished chrome and dark chitin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the pangolin shown slowly unfurling from a defensive ball?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the creature reveal translucent muscle fibers, black pulsating conduits, and metallic wiring beneath its plates?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a harsh keylight from above creating stark metallic shimmer and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color palette a cool, desaturated monochrome of gunmetal and obsidian?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05498340725898743 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929983377456665 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05498340725898743, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05498340725898743, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17806343734264374, + 0.0932752713561058, + 0.31078100204467773, + 0.04311887547373772, + 0.04182349145412445, + 0.11339501291513443, + 0.059750527143478394, + 0.08115022629499435, + 0.052628155797719955, + 0.026014059782028198 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05498340725898743 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a biomechanical pangolin composed of polished chrome and dark chitin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the pangolin shown slowly unfurling from a defensive ball?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the creature reveal translucent muscle fibers, black pulsating conduits, and metallic wiring beneath its plates?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a harsh keylight from above creating stark metallic shimmer and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color palette a cool, desaturated monochrome of gunmetal and obsidian?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004645389039069414 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379645347595215 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004645389039069414, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004645389039069414, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1319173276424408, + 0.07898993790149689, + 0.11513598263263702, + 0.02403976209461689, + 0.028581425547599792, + 0.0815051943063736, + 0.27074480056762695, + 0.09180007874965668, + 0.12148071080446243, + 0.055804844945669174 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004645389039069414 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a biomechanical pangolin composed of polished chrome and dark chitin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the pangolin shown slowly unfurling from a defensive ball?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the creature reveal translucent muscle fibers, black pulsating conduits, and metallic wiring beneath its plates?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a harsh keylight from above creating stark metallic shimmer and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color palette a cool, desaturated monochrome of gunmetal and obsidian?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06204436346888542 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812044382095337 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06204436346888542, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06204436346888542, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.6104922890663147, + 0.03606577217578888, + 0.05699257180094719, + 0.03414030000567436, + 0.04474774748086929, + 0.04138158634305, + 0.06640951335430145, + 0.029405605047941208, + 0.023602336645126343, + 0.05676236003637314 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06204436346888542 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a biomechanical pangolin composed of polished chrome and dark chitin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the pangolin shown slowly unfurling from a defensive ball?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the creature reveal translucent muscle fibers, black pulsating conduits, and metallic wiring beneath its plates?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a harsh keylight from above creating stark metallic shimmer and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color palette a cool, desaturated monochrome of gunmetal and obsidian?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11292318999767303 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2379231452941895 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11292318999767303, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11292318999767303, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3082510828971863, + 0.06852944195270538, + 0.044110581278800964, + 0.05749022588133812, + 0.026985622942447662, + 0.14308029413223267, + 0.1111232116818428, + 0.0565631203353405, + 0.07837113738059998, + 0.10549528896808624 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11292318999767303 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_8/index_tensor([7245, 7245])_group_8_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_8/index_tensor([7245, 7245])_group_8_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..8dd5ddf67162841b189e6f774a5257b8dba5e967 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_8/index_tensor([7245, 7245])_group_8_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "close-up, static shot focuses precisely on a pair of hands with vibrant skin and distinct knuckles, carefully cradling a square, layered French mille-feuille pastry. The pastry is evenly coated with a thick, delicate layer of snow-white icing. Warm afternoon sunlight streams through the window on the left, casting soft golden outlines on the pastry and the backs of the hands. In the background, a wooden kitchen counter and a partially blurred white tiled wall are softly blurred. As another pair of equally warm hands slowly reaches in from the right, ready to gently receive this sweet gift, the gentle touch and exchange of hands slightly disturbs the top layer of powdered sugar on the pastry. At this moment, the scene enters an extreme slow motion effect, with countless tiny particles of powdered sugar rising up and dancing like shimmering stardust in the golden light penetrating the kitchen, each particle clearly visible before slowly dispersing. The main colors of the entire picture are warm beige and wood color, with soft light and shadow, full of tranquility, healing comfort, creating a pure and warm atmosphere.", + "seed": 13534, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_8/index_7245_seed_13534_dp_16_rank_32_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.15123252645134927, + "vlm_logprob": -0.15123252645134927, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.65, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.15123252645134927, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focusing on a pair of hands with vibrant skin and distinct knuckles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a square, layered French mille-feuille pastry coated with thick snow-white icing visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include warm afternoon sunlight streaming from the left, casting golden outlines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do two pairs of hands exchange the pastry, causing powdered sugar particles to rise in extreme slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static throughout the scene with a blurred background of a wooden counter and white tiled wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.524135172367096 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.899135172367096 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.524135172367096, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.524135172367096, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4824916124343872, + 0.021144211292266846, + 0.0593830868601799, + 0.014576761983335018, + 0.018368367105722427, + 0.01190423034131527, + 0.019721701741218567, + 0.02532614953815937, + 0.29903432726860046, + 0.04804961755871773 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.524135172367096 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focusing on a pair of hands with vibrant skin and distinct knuckles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a square, layered French mille-feuille pastry coated with thick snow-white icing visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include warm afternoon sunlight streaming from the left, casting golden outlines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do two pairs of hands exchange the pastry, causing powdered sugar particles to rise in extreme slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static throughout the scene with a blurred background of a wooden counter and white tiled wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01608596369624138 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141086101531982 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01608596369624138, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01608596369624138, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.7386497855186462, + 0.035600580275058746, + 0.041034553200006485, + 0.014446808956563473, + 0.031049011275172234, + 0.028827155008912086, + 0.032724201679229736, + 0.019484808668494225, + 0.02901090495288372, + 0.029172195121645927 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01608596369624138 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focusing on a pair of hands with vibrant skin and distinct knuckles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a square, layered French mille-feuille pastry coated with thick snow-white icing visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include warm afternoon sunlight streaming from the left, casting golden outlines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do two pairs of hands exchange the pastry, causing powdered sugar particles to rise in extreme slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static throughout the scene with a blurred background of a wooden counter and white tiled wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01819046586751938 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018190383911133 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01819046586751938, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01819046586751938, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14724233746528625, + 0.03772728890180588, + 0.03074009343981743, + 0.021751081570982933, + 0.0332852341234684, + 0.017860813066363335, + 0.3544427156448364, + 0.05721862614154816, + 0.26890069246292114, + 0.03083110973238945 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01819046586751938 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focusing on a pair of hands with vibrant skin and distinct knuckles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a square, layered French mille-feuille pastry coated with thick snow-white icing visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include warm afternoon sunlight streaming from the left, casting golden outlines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do two pairs of hands exchange the pastry, causing powdered sugar particles to rise in extreme slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static throughout the scene with a blurred background of a wooden counter and white tiled wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14280034601688385 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0178003311157227 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14280034601688385, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14280034601688385, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.609806478023529, + 0.008050916716456413, + 0.04925018548965454, + 0.012961752712726593, + 0.035119134932756424, + 0.037651292979717255, + 0.03274931013584137, + 0.020533135160803795, + 0.1299363523721695, + 0.06394156068563461 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14280034601688385 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focusing on a pair of hands with vibrant skin and distinct knuckles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a square, layered French mille-feuille pastry coated with thick snow-white icing visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include warm afternoon sunlight streaming from the left, casting golden outlines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do two pairs of hands exchange the pastry, causing powdered sugar particles to rise in extreme slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static throughout the scene with a blurred background of a wooden counter and white tiled wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05495068430900574 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929950714111328 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05495068430900574, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05495068430900574, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19865670800209045, + 0.03701092302799225, + 0.04920858144760132, + 0.04373365640640259, + 0.05065682530403137, + 0.12483655661344528, + 0.09570968896150589, + 0.040888380259275436, + 0.3201150894165039, + 0.039183590561151505 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05495068430900574 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up, static shot focuses precisely on a pair of hands with vibrant skin and distinct knuckles, carefully cradling a square, layered French mille-feuille pastry. The pastry is evenly coated with a thick, delicate layer of snow-white icing. Warm afternoon sunlight streams through the window on the left, casting soft golden outlines on the pastry and the backs of the hands. In the background, a wooden kitchen counter and a partially blurred white tiled wall are softly blurred. As another pair of equally warm hands slowly reaches in from the right, ready to gently receive this sweet gift, the gentle touch and exchange of hands slightly disturbs the top layer of powdered sugar on the pastry. At this moment, the scene enters an extreme slow motion effect, with countless tiny particles of powdered sugar rising up and dancing like shimmering stardust in the golden light penetrating the kitchen, each particle clearly visible before slowly dispersing. The main colors of the entire picture are warm beige and wood color, with soft light and shadow, full of tranquility, healing comfort, creating a pure and warm atmosphere.", + "seed": 13535, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_8/index_7245_seed_13535_dp_16_rank_32_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.03936619684100151, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03936619684100151, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.5, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03936619684100151, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focusing on a pair of hands with vibrant skin and distinct knuckles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a square, layered French mille-feuille pastry coated with thick snow-white icing visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include warm afternoon sunlight streaming from the left, casting golden outlines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do two pairs of hands exchange the pastry, causing powdered sugar particles to rise in extreme slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static throughout the scene with a blurred background of a wooden counter and white tiled wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.057115230709314346 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.932115316390991 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.057115230709314346, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.057115230709314346, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17413556575775146, + 0.011088289320468903, + 0.013420140370726585, + 0.046366993337869644, + 0.012773208320140839, + 0.08188754320144653, + 0.01921255886554718, + 0.040306076407432556, + 0.16072455048561096, + 0.4400850832462311 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.057115230709314346 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focusing on a pair of hands with vibrant skin and distinct knuckles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a square, layered French mille-feuille pastry coated with thick snow-white icing visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include warm afternoon sunlight streaming from the left, casting golden outlines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do two pairs of hands exchange the pastry, causing powdered sugar particles to rise in extreme slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static throughout the scene with a blurred background of a wooden counter and white tiled wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0076469313353300095 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.8826470375061035 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0076469313353300095, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0076469313353300095, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.037591610103845596, + 0.030123673379421234, + 0.015885276719927788, + 0.1125086322426796, + 0.009776661172509193, + 0.04071160405874252, + 0.015782909467816353, + 0.03918280079960823, + 0.042785145342350006, + 0.6556516289710999 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 3, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0076469313353300095 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focusing on a pair of hands with vibrant skin and distinct knuckles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a square, layered French mille-feuille pastry coated with thick snow-white icing visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include warm afternoon sunlight streaming from the left, casting golden outlines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do two pairs of hands exchange the pastry, causing powdered sugar particles to rise in extreme slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static throughout the scene with a blurred background of a wooden counter and white tiled wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02329145185649395 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732913494110107 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02329145185649395, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02329145185649395, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1055292934179306, + 0.14068534970283508, + 0.030724937096238136, + 0.025240151211619377, + 0.10295191407203674, + 0.11933623254299164, + 0.02602730132639408, + 0.04469461366534233, + 0.12788483500480652, + 0.27692538499832153 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02329145185649395 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focusing on a pair of hands with vibrant skin and distinct knuckles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a square, layered French mille-feuille pastry coated with thick snow-white icing visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include warm afternoon sunlight streaming from the left, casting golden outlines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do two pairs of hands exchange the pastry, causing powdered sugar particles to rise in extreme slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static throughout the scene with a blurred background of a wooden counter and white tiled wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02980433776974678 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529804229736328 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02980433776974678, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02980433776974678, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12200117856264114, + 0.017722249031066895, + 0.02580167166888714, + 0.04754326865077019, + 0.02026490308344364, + 0.04657641798257828, + 0.02542577125132084, + 0.14763349294662476, + 0.1254311501979828, + 0.4215998649597168 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02980433776974678 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focusing on a pair of hands with vibrant skin and distinct knuckles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a square, layered French mille-feuille pastry coated with thick snow-white icing visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include warm afternoon sunlight streaming from the left, casting golden outlines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do two pairs of hands exchange the pastry, causing powdered sugar particles to rise in extreme slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static throughout the scene with a blurred background of a wooden counter and white tiled wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07897303253412247 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5789730548858643 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07897303253412247, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07897303253412247, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0897979885339737, + 0.03615270555019379, + 0.03554178401827812, + 0.046379830688238144, + 0.019373606890439987, + 0.08209951221942902, + 0.03565025329589844, + 0.2241068035364151, + 0.11487899720668793, + 0.3160184919834137 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07897303253412247 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up, static shot focuses precisely on a pair of hands with vibrant skin and distinct knuckles, carefully cradling a square, layered French mille-feuille pastry. The pastry is evenly coated with a thick, delicate layer of snow-white icing. Warm afternoon sunlight streams through the window on the left, casting soft golden outlines on the pastry and the backs of the hands. In the background, a wooden kitchen counter and a partially blurred white tiled wall are softly blurred. As another pair of equally warm hands slowly reaches in from the right, ready to gently receive this sweet gift, the gentle touch and exchange of hands slightly disturbs the top layer of powdered sugar on the pastry. At this moment, the scene enters an extreme slow motion effect, with countless tiny particles of powdered sugar rising up and dancing like shimmering stardust in the golden light penetrating the kitchen, each particle clearly visible before slowly dispersing. The main colors of the entire picture are warm beige and wood color, with soft light and shadow, full of tranquility, healing comfort, creating a pure and warm atmosphere.", + "seed": 13536, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_8/index_7245_seed_13536_dp_17_rank_34_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.09266892420127988, + "vlm_logprob": -0.09266892420127988, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.35, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.09266892420127988, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focusing on a pair of hands with vibrant skin and distinct knuckles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a square, layered French mille-feuille pastry coated with thick snow-white icing visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include warm afternoon sunlight streaming from the left, casting golden outlines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do two pairs of hands exchange the pastry, causing powdered sugar particles to rise in extreme slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static throughout the scene with a blurred background of a wooden counter and white tiled wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.31426605582237244 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3142660856246948 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.31426605582237244, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.31426605582237244, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.051096200942993164, + 0.022725176066160202, + 0.03491602838039398, + 0.1250571608543396, + 0.03103441186249256, + 0.3427460491657257, + 0.09871666133403778, + 0.028234105557203293, + 0.05891511216759682, + 0.20655909180641174 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.31426605582237244 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focusing on a pair of hands with vibrant skin and distinct knuckles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a square, layered French mille-feuille pastry coated with thick snow-white icing visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include warm afternoon sunlight streaming from the left, casting golden outlines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do two pairs of hands exchange the pastry, causing powdered sugar particles to rise in extreme slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static throughout the scene with a blurred background of a wooden counter and white tiled wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006749805994331837 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006749629974365 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006749805994331837, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006749805994331837, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16020995378494263, + 0.1139073520898819, + 0.027925288304686546, + 0.0787687823176384, + 0.02636871486902237, + 0.06883969902992249, + 0.07731088250875473, + 0.04814392328262329, + 0.05507265776395798, + 0.3434527516365051 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006749805994331837 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focusing on a pair of hands with vibrant skin and distinct knuckles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a square, layered French mille-feuille pastry coated with thick snow-white icing visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include warm afternoon sunlight streaming from the left, casting golden outlines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do two pairs of hands exchange the pastry, causing powdered sugar particles to rise in extreme slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static throughout the scene with a blurred background of a wooden counter and white tiled wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0046372017823159695 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379637241363525 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0046372017823159695, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0046372017823159695, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03673883154988289, + 0.015571479685604572, + 0.0883897989988327, + 0.1264411360025406, + 0.2032160758972168, + 0.18651250004768372, + 0.05667765438556671, + 0.029352206736803055, + 0.05028752610087395, + 0.2068127989768982 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0046372017823159695 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focusing on a pair of hands with vibrant skin and distinct knuckles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a square, layered French mille-feuille pastry coated with thick snow-white icing visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include warm afternoon sunlight streaming from the left, casting golden outlines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do two pairs of hands exchange the pastry, causing powdered sugar particles to rise in extreme slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static throughout the scene with a blurred background of a wooden counter and white tiled wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04865580052137375 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486557483673096 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04865580052137375, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04865580052137375, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.057047028094530106, + 0.01950715482234955, + 0.02586227096617222, + 0.02237245999276638, + 0.19788923859596252, + 0.07470692694187164, + 0.09686505049467087, + 0.062759630382061, + 0.07199889421463013, + 0.3709912598133087 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04865580052137375 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focusing on a pair of hands with vibrant skin and distinct knuckles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a square, layered French mille-feuille pastry coated with thick snow-white icing visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include warm afternoon sunlight streaming from the left, casting golden outlines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do two pairs of hands exchange the pastry, causing powdered sugar particles to rise in extreme slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static throughout the scene with a blurred background of a wooden counter and white tiled wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0890357568860054 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.464035749435425 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0890357568860054, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0890357568860054, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04625244066119194, + 0.02610507234930992, + 0.023515300825238228, + 0.0279656033962965, + 0.1460956335067749, + 0.04367669299244881, + 0.222683846950531, + 0.04670548439025879, + 0.12989871203899384, + 0.2871011793613434 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0890357568860054 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up, static shot focuses precisely on a pair of hands with vibrant skin and distinct knuckles, carefully cradling a square, layered French mille-feuille pastry. The pastry is evenly coated with a thick, delicate layer of snow-white icing. Warm afternoon sunlight streams through the window on the left, casting soft golden outlines on the pastry and the backs of the hands. In the background, a wooden kitchen counter and a partially blurred white tiled wall are softly blurred. As another pair of equally warm hands slowly reaches in from the right, ready to gently receive this sweet gift, the gentle touch and exchange of hands slightly disturbs the top layer of powdered sugar on the pastry. At this moment, the scene enters an extreme slow motion effect, with countless tiny particles of powdered sugar rising up and dancing like shimmering stardust in the golden light penetrating the kitchen, each particle clearly visible before slowly dispersing. The main colors of the entire picture are warm beige and wood color, with soft light and shadow, full of tranquility, healing comfort, creating a pure and warm atmosphere.", + "seed": 13537, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_8/index_7245_seed_13537_dp_17_rank_34_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.2975830117240548, + "vlm_logprob": -0.2975830117240548, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.675, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.2975830117240548, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focusing on a pair of hands with vibrant skin and distinct knuckles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a square, layered French mille-feuille pastry coated with thick snow-white icing visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include warm afternoon sunlight streaming from the left, casting golden outlines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do two pairs of hands exchange the pastry, causing powdered sugar particles to rise in extreme slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static throughout the scene with a blurred background of a wooden counter and white tiled wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3139259815216064 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.31392601132392883 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.3139259815216064, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -1.3139259815216064, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2674240469932556, + 0.03464808687567711, + 0.09682711213827133, + 0.02128690481185913, + 0.03955426439642906, + 0.16591277718544006, + 0.20583072304725647, + 0.07454172521829605, + 0.031449269503355026, + 0.06252509355545044 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.3139259815216064 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focusing on a pair of hands with vibrant skin and distinct knuckles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a square, layered French mille-feuille pastry coated with thick snow-white icing visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include warm afternoon sunlight streaming from the left, casting golden outlines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do two pairs of hands exchange the pastry, causing powdered sugar particles to rise in extreme slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static throughout the scene with a blurred background of a wooden counter and white tiled wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006757502444088459 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006757736206055 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006757502444088459, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006757502444088459, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17135369777679443, + 0.024321652948856354, + 0.15260355174541473, + 0.022147566080093384, + 0.06644229590892792, + 0.29720035195350647, + 0.13582193851470947, + 0.06724095344543457, + 0.029586639255285263, + 0.033281359821558 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006757502444088459 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focusing on a pair of hands with vibrant skin and distinct knuckles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a square, layered French mille-feuille pastry coated with thick snow-white icing visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include warm afternoon sunlight streaming from the left, casting golden outlines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do two pairs of hands exchange the pastry, causing powdered sugar particles to rise in extreme slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static throughout the scene with a blurred background of a wooden counter and white tiled wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020589664578437805 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895589590072632 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020589664578437805, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020589664578437805, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12635265290737152, + 0.02387070469558239, + 0.3858974575996399, + 0.04337554797530174, + 0.0672416165471077, + 0.15538084506988525, + 0.06783595681190491, + 0.06430727243423462, + 0.034721460193395615, + 0.03101649321615696 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020589664578437805 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focusing on a pair of hands with vibrant skin and distinct knuckles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a square, layered French mille-feuille pastry coated with thick snow-white icing visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include warm afternoon sunlight streaming from the left, casting golden outlines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do two pairs of hands exchange the pastry, causing powdered sugar particles to rise in extreme slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static throughout the scene with a blurred background of a wooden counter and white tiled wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11294565349817276 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.237945556640625 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11294565349817276, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11294565349817276, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10251235216856003, + 0.04825760796666145, + 0.2100840061903, + 0.035115230828523636, + 0.05420393496751785, + 0.06806677579879761, + 0.08000049740076065, + 0.1622951775789261, + 0.10068570822477341, + 0.1387787163257599 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11294565349817276 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focusing on a pair of hands with vibrant skin and distinct knuckles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a square, layered French mille-feuille pastry coated with thick snow-white icing visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include warm afternoon sunlight streaming from the left, casting golden outlines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do two pairs of hands exchange the pastry, causing powdered sugar particles to rise in extreme slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static throughout the scene with a blurred background of a wooden counter and white tiled wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0336962565779686 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408696174621582 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0336962565779686, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0336962565779686, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12185769528150558, + 0.02917870320379734, + 0.021788375452160835, + 0.09841816127300262, + 0.049949321895837784, + 0.36067232489585876, + 0.06691427528858185, + 0.11242277920246124, + 0.07624263316392899, + 0.06255577504634857 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0336962565779686 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_9/index_tensor([7040, 7040])_group_9_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_9/index_tensor([7040, 7040])_group_9_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..039c28bd93cc8b6de4cd1842d4387b8e3ce10200 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_9/index_tensor([7040, 7040])_group_9_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "wide, eye-level tracking shot follows a lone traveler as they glide smoothly through a vast, modern airport terminal bathed in the golden glow of the afternoon sun. Light streams through vast floor-to-ceiling windows, casting long, dramatic shadows across the highly polished concrete floor and creating cinematic lens flares as the camera moves. The traveler, a quiet figure with medium-length dark brown hair, wears a practical olive green canvas jacket paired with a simple white T-shirt and dark denim jeans for a long journey. They walk with a steady, deliberate pace, one hand firmly grasping the extended handle of a sleek, dark gray hardshell rolling suitcase, its wheels gliding almost silently across the floor. In the background, the vast expanse of the concourse stretches outward, its high, vaulted ceiling supported by minimalist steel beams, while other passengers become blurred, anonymous figures in the distance. Through the expansive glass, the silhouettes of airplanes are visible on the sun-drenched tarmac, imbuing the scene with a hopeful and contemplative atmosphere, capturing a moment of transition and the purposeful beginning of an important journey to a distant gate.", + "seed": 29000, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_9/index_7040_seed_29000_dp_18_rank_36_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.012020285194739699, + "vlm_logprob": -0.012020285194739699, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.625, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.012020285194739699, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast, modern airport terminal with high vaulted ceilings and steel beams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by golden afternoon sun streaming through floor-to-ceiling windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the traveler wearing an olive green canvas jacket, a white T-shirt, and dark denim jeans?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the traveler pulling a sleek, dark gray hardshell rolling suitcase with one hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a wide, eye-level tracking shot moving smoothly alongside the traveler?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003114256775006652 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.128114223480225 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003114256775006652, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003114256775006652, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3101213574409485, + 0.12141212821006775, + 0.1267554759979248, + 0.08323025703430176, + 0.05258864909410477, + 0.08787339180707932, + 0.041884567588567734, + 0.03753253445029259, + 0.0696597769856453, + 0.06894189864397049 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003114256775006652 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast, modern airport terminal with high vaulted ceilings and steel beams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by golden afternoon sun streaming through floor-to-ceiling windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the traveler wearing an olive green canvas jacket, a white T-shirt, and dark denim jeans?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the traveler pulling a sleek, dark gray hardshell rolling suitcase with one hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a wide, eye-level tracking shot moving smoothly alongside the traveler?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014208345673978329 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.2642083168029785 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014208345673978329, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014208345673978329, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22150661051273346, + 0.11812054365873337, + 0.23344361782073975, + 0.10718316584825516, + 0.07113124430179596, + 0.04278165474534035, + 0.049605246633291245, + 0.04550229012966156, + 0.0428490974009037, + 0.06787646561861038 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014208345673978329 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast, modern airport terminal with high vaulted ceilings and steel beams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by golden afternoon sun streaming through floor-to-ceiling windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the traveler wearing an olive green canvas jacket, a white T-shirt, and dark denim jeans?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the traveler pulling a sleek, dark gray hardshell rolling suitcase with one hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a wide, eye-level tracking shot moving smoothly alongside the traveler?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014190363697707653 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264190196990967 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014190363697707653, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014190363697707653, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14801493287086487, + 0.12551964819431305, + 0.046493347734212875, + 0.046637680381536484, + 0.10338517278432846, + 0.23752567172050476, + 0.0677211806178093, + 0.05551692470908165, + 0.10066110640764236, + 0.0685243010520935 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014190363697707653 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast, modern airport terminal with high vaulted ceilings and steel beams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by golden afternoon sun streaming through floor-to-ceiling windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the traveler wearing an olive green canvas jacket, a white T-shirt, and dark denim jeans?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the traveler pulling a sleek, dark gray hardshell rolling suitcase with one hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a wide, eye-level tracking shot moving smoothly alongside the traveler?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012532410211861134 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.3875322341918945 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012532410211861134, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012532410211861134, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.061705488711595535, + 0.08400548994541168, + 0.07343422621488571, + 0.057444844394922256, + 0.06364216655492783, + 0.05460292100906372, + 0.06337373703718185, + 0.08364243060350418, + 0.2598937153816223, + 0.1982550024986267 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012532410211861134 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast, modern airport terminal with high vaulted ceilings and steel beams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by golden afternoon sun streaming through floor-to-ceiling windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the traveler wearing an olive green canvas jacket, a white T-shirt, and dark denim jeans?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the traveler pulling a sleek, dark gray hardshell rolling suitcase with one hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a wide, eye-level tracking shot moving smoothly alongside the traveler?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01605604961514473 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141056060791016 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01605604961514473, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01605604961514473, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.31035730242729187, + 0.12850713729858398, + 0.04217942804098129, + 0.0606934130191803, + 0.08336823433637619, + 0.11800877749919891, + 0.11501961201429367, + 0.01808069460093975, + 0.07548417150974274, + 0.04830126836895943 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01605604961514473 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "wide, eye-level tracking shot follows a lone traveler as they glide smoothly through a vast, modern airport terminal bathed in the golden glow of the afternoon sun. Light streams through vast floor-to-ceiling windows, casting long, dramatic shadows across the highly polished concrete floor and creating cinematic lens flares as the camera moves. The traveler, a quiet figure with medium-length dark brown hair, wears a practical olive green canvas jacket paired with a simple white T-shirt and dark denim jeans for a long journey. They walk with a steady, deliberate pace, one hand firmly grasping the extended handle of a sleek, dark gray hardshell rolling suitcase, its wheels gliding almost silently across the floor. In the background, the vast expanse of the concourse stretches outward, its high, vaulted ceiling supported by minimalist steel beams, while other passengers become blurred, anonymous figures in the distance. Through the expansive glass, the silhouettes of airplanes are visible on the sun-drenched tarmac, imbuing the scene with a hopeful and contemplative atmosphere, capturing a moment of transition and the purposeful beginning of an important journey to a distant gate.", + "seed": 29001, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_9/index_7040_seed_29001_dp_18_rank_36_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.010016285721212626, + "vlm_logprob": -0.010016285721212626, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 5.05, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.010016285721212626, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast, modern airport terminal with high vaulted ceilings and steel beams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by golden afternoon sun streaming through floor-to-ceiling windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the traveler wearing an olive green canvas jacket, a white T-shirt, and dark denim jeans?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the traveler pulling a sleek, dark gray hardshell rolling suitcase with one hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a wide, eye-level tracking shot moving smoothly alongside the traveler?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0014413930475711823 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.376441478729248 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0014413930475711823, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0014413930475711823, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19725430011749268, + 0.044386330991983414, + 0.09746462106704712, + 0.09064484387636185, + 0.14867261052131653, + 0.07618671655654907, + 0.03623230382800102, + 0.18553346395492554, + 0.021052617579698563, + 0.1025722324848175 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0014413930475711823 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast, modern airport terminal with high vaulted ceilings and steel beams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by golden afternoon sun streaming through floor-to-ceiling windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the traveler wearing an olive green canvas jacket, a white T-shirt, and dark denim jeans?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the traveler pulling a sleek, dark gray hardshell rolling suitcase with one hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a wide, eye-level tracking shot moving smoothly alongside the traveler?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006741635967046022 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006741523742676 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006741635967046022, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006741635967046022, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2693791687488556, + 0.07266286015510559, + 0.06300060451030731, + 0.10183535516262054, + 0.0386698916554451, + 0.034039828926324844, + 0.03608238697052002, + 0.05438331514596939, + 0.10738226771354675, + 0.22256436944007874 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006741635967046022 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast, modern airport terminal with high vaulted ceilings and steel beams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by golden afternoon sun streaming through floor-to-ceiling windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the traveler wearing an olive green canvas jacket, a white T-shirt, and dark denim jeans?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the traveler pulling a sleek, dark gray hardshell rolling suitcase with one hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a wide, eye-level tracking shot moving smoothly alongside the traveler?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016065435484051704 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.14106559753418 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016065435484051704, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016065435484051704, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1924285590648651, + 0.03958781063556671, + 0.10695209354162216, + 0.08714654296636581, + 0.06678666919469833, + 0.0682615265250206, + 0.05234554782509804, + 0.19437815248966217, + 0.10149069130420685, + 0.09062241017818451 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016065435484051704 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast, modern airport terminal with high vaulted ceilings and steel beams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by golden afternoon sun streaming through floor-to-ceiling windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the traveler wearing an olive green canvas jacket, a white T-shirt, and dark denim jeans?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the traveler pulling a sleek, dark gray hardshell rolling suitcase with one hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a wide, eye-level tracking shot moving smoothly alongside the traveler?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009775623679161072 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634775638580322 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009775623679161072, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009775623679161072, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1648160219192505, + 0.07292643934488297, + 0.10176091641187668, + 0.181247279047966, + 0.08125235140323639, + 0.0570707805454731, + 0.05003391578793526, + 0.08718577772378922, + 0.047967374324798584, + 0.1557391732931137 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009775623679161072 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast, modern airport terminal with high vaulted ceilings and steel beams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by golden afternoon sun streaming through floor-to-ceiling windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the traveler wearing an olive green canvas jacket, a white T-shirt, and dark denim jeans?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the traveler pulling a sleek, dark gray hardshell rolling suitcase with one hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a wide, eye-level tracking shot moving smoothly alongside the traveler?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016057340428233147 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.14105749130249 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016057340428233147, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016057340428233147, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18913410604000092, + 0.10449758172035217, + 0.07218609750270844, + 0.23628224432468414, + 0.0448714904487133, + 0.12347649782896042, + 0.06027720496058464, + 0.08645229786634445, + 0.03054521046578884, + 0.05227719247341156 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016057340428233147 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "wide, eye-level tracking shot follows a lone traveler as they glide smoothly through a vast, modern airport terminal bathed in the golden glow of the afternoon sun. Light streams through vast floor-to-ceiling windows, casting long, dramatic shadows across the highly polished concrete floor and creating cinematic lens flares as the camera moves. The traveler, a quiet figure with medium-length dark brown hair, wears a practical olive green canvas jacket paired with a simple white T-shirt and dark denim jeans for a long journey. They walk with a steady, deliberate pace, one hand firmly grasping the extended handle of a sleek, dark gray hardshell rolling suitcase, its wheels gliding almost silently across the floor. In the background, the vast expanse of the concourse stretches outward, its high, vaulted ceiling supported by minimalist steel beams, while other passengers become blurred, anonymous figures in the distance. Through the expansive glass, the silhouettes of airplanes are visible on the sun-drenched tarmac, imbuing the scene with a hopeful and contemplative atmosphere, capturing a moment of transition and the purposeful beginning of an important journey to a distant gate.", + "seed": 29002, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_9/index_7040_seed_29002_dp_19_rank_38_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.011572922114282846, + "vlm_logprob": -0.011572922114282846, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.525, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.011572922114282846, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast, modern airport terminal with high vaulted ceilings and steel beams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by golden afternoon sun streaming through floor-to-ceiling windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the traveler wearing an olive green canvas jacket, a white T-shirt, and dark denim jeans?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the traveler pulling a sleek, dark gray hardshell rolling suitcase with one hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a wide, eye-level tracking shot moving smoothly alongside the traveler?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007450532168149948 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.007450580596924 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007450532168149948, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007450532168149948, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1485370695590973, + 0.06101778894662857, + 0.062252018600702286, + 0.09092556685209274, + 0.044517964124679565, + 0.04893874004483223, + 0.19546380639076233, + 0.043672770261764526, + 0.2287941575050354, + 0.07588013261556625 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007450532168149948 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast, modern airport terminal with high vaulted ceilings and steel beams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by golden afternoon sun streaming through floor-to-ceiling windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the traveler wearing an olive green canvas jacket, a white T-shirt, and dark denim jeans?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the traveler pulling a sleek, dark gray hardshell rolling suitcase with one hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a wide, eye-level tracking shot moving smoothly alongside the traveler?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007639241870492697 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882639408111572 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007639241870492697, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007639241870492697, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19769731163978577, + 0.363566130399704, + 0.03828096762299538, + 0.1009674072265625, + 0.02795703336596489, + 0.030115175992250443, + 0.036304738372564316, + 0.08478470146656036, + 0.04455573484301567, + 0.07577069848775864 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007639241870492697 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast, modern airport terminal with high vaulted ceilings and steel beams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by golden afternoon sun streaming through floor-to-ceiling windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the traveler wearing an olive green canvas jacket, a white T-shirt, and dark denim jeans?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the traveler pulling a sleek, dark gray hardshell rolling suitcase with one hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a wide, eye-level tracking shot moving smoothly alongside the traveler?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01253464724868536 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.3875346183776855 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01253464724868536, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01253464724868536, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14052720367908478, + 0.2119063138961792, + 0.08509188890457153, + 0.05763433501124382, + 0.053415894508361816, + 0.08795185387134552, + 0.06067565456032753, + 0.05028579756617546, + 0.05229610949754715, + 0.2002149075269699 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01253464724868536 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast, modern airport terminal with high vaulted ceilings and steel beams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by golden afternoon sun streaming through floor-to-ceiling windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the traveler wearing an olive green canvas jacket, a white T-shirt, and dark denim jeans?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the traveler pulling a sleek, dark gray hardshell rolling suitcase with one hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a wide, eye-level tracking shot moving smoothly alongside the traveler?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014185898005962372 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264185905456543 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014185898005962372, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014185898005962372, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.058112308382987976, + 0.5453630685806274, + 0.013958591967821121, + 0.023303091526031494, + 0.02465410903096199, + 0.04474015533924103, + 0.1444498747587204, + 0.03589101880788803, + 0.03305662050843239, + 0.07647116482257843 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014185898005962372 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast, modern airport terminal with high vaulted ceilings and steel beams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by golden afternoon sun streaming through floor-to-ceiling windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the traveler wearing an olive green canvas jacket, a white T-shirt, and dark denim jeans?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the traveler pulling a sleek, dark gray hardshell rolling suitcase with one hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a wide, eye-level tracking shot moving smoothly alongside the traveler?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016054291278123856 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141054153442383 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016054291278123856, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016054291278123856, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06461232900619507, + 0.5880482792854309, + 0.04529601335525513, + 0.03248048201203346, + 0.02801896631717682, + 0.018665295094251633, + 0.03580458462238312, + 0.06406503170728683, + 0.09530353546142578, + 0.027705514803528786 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016054291278123856 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "wide, eye-level tracking shot follows a lone traveler as they glide smoothly through a vast, modern airport terminal bathed in the golden glow of the afternoon sun. Light streams through vast floor-to-ceiling windows, casting long, dramatic shadows across the highly polished concrete floor and creating cinematic lens flares as the camera moves. The traveler, a quiet figure with medium-length dark brown hair, wears a practical olive green canvas jacket paired with a simple white T-shirt and dark denim jeans for a long journey. They walk with a steady, deliberate pace, one hand firmly grasping the extended handle of a sleek, dark gray hardshell rolling suitcase, its wheels gliding almost silently across the floor. In the background, the vast expanse of the concourse stretches outward, its high, vaulted ceiling supported by minimalist steel beams, while other passengers become blurred, anonymous figures in the distance. Through the expansive glass, the silhouettes of airplanes are visible on the sun-drenched tarmac, imbuing the scene with a hopeful and contemplative atmosphere, capturing a moment of transition and the purposeful beginning of an important journey to a distant gate.", + "seed": 29003, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000162/group_9/index_7040_seed_29003_dp_19_rank_38_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.013754513673484325, + "vlm_logprob": -0.013754513673484325, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.525, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.013754513673484325, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast, modern airport terminal with high vaulted ceilings and steel beams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by golden afternoon sun streaming through floor-to-ceiling windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the traveler wearing an olive green canvas jacket, a white T-shirt, and dark denim jeans?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the traveler pulling a sleek, dark gray hardshell rolling suitcase with one hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a wide, eye-level tracking shot moving smoothly alongside the traveler?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003998737782239914 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.003998756408691 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003998737782239914, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003998737782239914, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15353335440158844, + 0.1322067826986313, + 0.10353702306747437, + 0.07335060089826584, + 0.06942864507436752, + 0.12834680080413818, + 0.10657072067260742, + 0.04840083792805672, + 0.10321623831987381, + 0.08140896260738373 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003998737782239914 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast, modern airport terminal with high vaulted ceilings and steel beams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by golden afternoon sun streaming through floor-to-ceiling windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the traveler wearing an olive green canvas jacket, a white T-shirt, and dark denim jeans?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the traveler pulling a sleek, dark gray hardshell rolling suitcase with one hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a wide, eye-level tracking shot moving smoothly alongside the traveler?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012553836219012737 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387553691864014 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012553836219012737, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012553836219012737, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07430965453386307, + 0.17056545615196228, + 0.02563345991075039, + 0.057304855436086655, + 0.05061893165111542, + 0.09119290113449097, + 0.39484351873397827, + 0.02230110950767994, + 0.06256862729787827, + 0.05066148191690445 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012553836219012737 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast, modern airport terminal with high vaulted ceilings and steel beams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by golden afternoon sun streaming through floor-to-ceiling windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the traveler wearing an olive green canvas jacket, a white T-shirt, and dark denim jeans?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the traveler pulling a sleek, dark gray hardshell rolling suitcase with one hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a wide, eye-level tracking shot moving smoothly alongside the traveler?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020579621195793152 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955795764923096 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020579621195793152, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020579621195793152, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09690218418836594, + 0.15836933255195618, + 0.073175348341465, + 0.03761876001954079, + 0.09516870975494385, + 0.16005359590053558, + 0.13196875154972076, + 0.06763197481632233, + 0.14255297183990479, + 0.03655846416950226 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020579621195793152 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast, modern airport terminal with high vaulted ceilings and steel beams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by golden afternoon sun streaming through floor-to-ceiling windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the traveler wearing an olive green canvas jacket, a white T-shirt, and dark denim jeans?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the traveler pulling a sleek, dark gray hardshell rolling suitcase with one hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a wide, eye-level tracking shot moving smoothly alongside the traveler?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020575417205691338 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895575523376465 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020575417205691338, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020575417205691338, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07910281419754028, + 0.09101829677820206, + 0.045305442065000534, + 0.02817821502685547, + 0.1639270931482315, + 0.056803759187459946, + 0.059500984847545624, + 0.03959863260388374, + 0.40036630630493164, + 0.036198437213897705 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020575417205691338 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast, modern airport terminal with high vaulted ceilings and steel beams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by golden afternoon sun streaming through floor-to-ceiling windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the traveler wearing an olive green canvas jacket, a white T-shirt, and dark denim jeans?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the traveler pulling a sleek, dark gray hardshell rolling suitcase with one hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a wide, eye-level tracking shot moving smoothly alongside the traveler?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011064955964684486 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.5110650062561035 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011064955964684486, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011064955964684486, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14251860976219177, + 0.14729925990104675, + 0.07086480408906937, + 0.0277642160654068, + 0.11363757401704788, + 0.10311832278966904, + 0.06210515648126602, + 0.1687236726284027, + 0.08421473950147629, + 0.07975367456674576 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011064955964684486 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_0/index_tensor([6348, 6348])_group_0_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_0/index_tensor([6348, 6348])_group_0_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..938c292dc3ebf6b83bc6758a494ff46e2be0228a --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_0/index_tensor([6348, 6348])_group_0_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "striking low-angle close-up captures a massive white tiger at the very center of the frame, its massive bulk practically filling the entire frame. The beast's thick, snow-white fur is marked with distinct inky black stripes, and its icy blue eyes gleam with a fierce glint, fixed intently on the camera. Its maw, gaping, reveals its dagger-sharp canines, its barbed pink tongue curling with intensity as it unleashes a heartfelt, ear-piercing roar. Its bristly whiskers tremble with fury as it roars, its powerful sonic waves seemingly shaking the very air. The hot breath from its throat condenses into a white mist in the cool air. The background is the gloomy jungle. A few faint rays of light penetrate the dense canopy, sculpting the tiger's muscular shoulders and reflecting off its wet teeth. The entire picture is full of primitive power. The low-angle upward perspective greatly enhances its size and majesty, creating a suffocating, wild and threatening sense of oppression.", + "seed": 27062, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_0/index_6348_seed_27062_dp_0_rank_0_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.05021203383803367, + "vlm_logprob": -0.05021203383803367, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.45, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.05021203383803367, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive white tiger with inky black stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger's mouth open, revealing sharp canines and a pink tongue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger unleashing a roar with visible hot breath condensing into white mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a gloomy jungle with faint rays of light penetrating the canopy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle close-up where the tiger fills the entire frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.010710729286074638 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.635710716247559 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.010710729286074638, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.010710729286074638, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2485615313053131, + 0.08387632668018341, + 0.045430395752191544, + 0.05869748443365097, + 0.09709908068180084, + 0.1583189219236374, + 0.1258377879858017, + 0.05275263637304306, + 0.0575718991458416, + 0.07185401022434235 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.010710729286074638 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive white tiger with inky black stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger's mouth open, revealing sharp canines and a pink tongue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger unleashing a roar with visible hot breath condensing into white mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a gloomy jungle with faint rays of light penetrating the canopy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle close-up where the tiger fills the entire frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016090303659439087 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141090393066406 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016090303659439087, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016090303659439087, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11169374734163284, + 0.03177206963300705, + 0.08499367535114288, + 0.048274073749780655, + 0.06984677910804749, + 0.1890777349472046, + 0.14938783645629883, + 0.12302516400814056, + 0.13021773099899292, + 0.06171124428510666 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016090303659439087 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive white tiger with inky black stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger's mouth open, revealing sharp canines and a pink tongue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger unleashing a roar with visible hot breath condensing into white mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a gloomy jungle with faint rays of light penetrating the canopy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle close-up where the tiger fills the entire frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1270749270915985 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.127074956893921 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1270749270915985, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1270749270915985, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14952388405799866, + 0.0256497822701931, + 0.09823045134544373, + 0.17229729890823364, + 0.08096536993980408, + 0.04327165335416794, + 0.03145439550280571, + 0.07565895467996597, + 0.12409471720457077, + 0.1988534927368164 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1270749270915985 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive white tiger with inky black stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger's mouth open, revealing sharp canines and a pink tongue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger unleashing a roar with visible hot breath condensing into white mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a gloomy jungle with faint rays of light penetrating the canopy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle close-up where the tiger fills the entire frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0790029913187027 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.579003095626831 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0790029913187027, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0790029913187027, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06126612797379494, + 0.06037512794137001, + 0.10061170160770416, + 0.041120417416095734, + 0.03742925822734833, + 0.03959120064973831, + 0.1600135862827301, + 0.026120852679014206, + 0.42296597361564636, + 0.050505731254816055 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0790029913187027 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive white tiger with inky black stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger's mouth open, revealing sharp canines and a pink tongue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger unleashing a roar with visible hot breath condensing into white mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a gloomy jungle with faint rays of light penetrating the canopy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle close-up where the tiger fills the entire frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018181217834353447 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018181324005127 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018181217834353447, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018181217834353447, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10765211284160614, + 0.0697295293211937, + 0.045151740312576294, + 0.08321646600961685, + 0.0992470532655716, + 0.12419361621141434, + 0.04603457823395729, + 0.0812130719423294, + 0.06065675988793373, + 0.28290507197380066 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018181217834353447 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "striking low-angle close-up captures a massive white tiger at the very center of the frame, its massive bulk practically filling the entire frame. The beast's thick, snow-white fur is marked with distinct inky black stripes, and its icy blue eyes gleam with a fierce glint, fixed intently on the camera. Its maw, gaping, reveals its dagger-sharp canines, its barbed pink tongue curling with intensity as it unleashes a heartfelt, ear-piercing roar. Its bristly whiskers tremble with fury as it roars, its powerful sonic waves seemingly shaking the very air. The hot breath from its throat condenses into a white mist in the cool air. The background is the gloomy jungle. A few faint rays of light penetrate the dense canopy, sculpting the tiger's muscular shoulders and reflecting off its wet teeth. The entire picture is full of primitive power. The low-angle upward perspective greatly enhances its size and majesty, creating a suffocating, wild and threatening sense of oppression.", + "seed": 27063, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_0/index_6348_seed_27063_dp_0_rank_0_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.0789523296058178, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0789523296058178, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.85, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0789523296058178, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive white tiger with inky black stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger's mouth open, revealing sharp canines and a pink tongue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger unleashing a roar with visible hot breath condensing into white mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a gloomy jungle with faint rays of light penetrating the canopy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle close-up where the tiger fills the entire frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03852810710668564 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2885282039642334 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03852810710668564, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03852810710668564, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14067915081977844, + 0.09639550745487213, + 0.13404801487922668, + 0.08074302226305008, + 0.05993998050689697, + 0.200100377202034, + 0.04237018898129463, + 0.1698271632194519, + 0.05992370471358299, + 0.01597290299832821 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03852810710668564 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive white tiger with inky black stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger's mouth open, revealing sharp canines and a pink tongue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger unleashing a roar with visible hot breath condensing into white mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a gloomy jungle with faint rays of light penetrating the canopy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle close-up where the tiger fills the entire frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020613837987184525 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8956139087677 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020613837987184525, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020613837987184525, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05403738096356392, + 0.05023335665464401, + 0.06970500946044922, + 0.13595908880233765, + 0.07152260839939117, + 0.11702229082584381, + 0.061066269874572754, + 0.12960389256477356, + 0.27327337861061096, + 0.03757677227258682 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 3, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020613837987184525 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive white tiger with inky black stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger's mouth open, revealing sharp canines and a pink tongue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger unleashing a roar with visible hot breath condensing into white mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a gloomy jungle with faint rays of light penetrating the canopy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle close-up where the tiger fills the entire frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2016063928604126 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7016063928604126 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2016063928604126, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2016063928604126, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.053006045520305634, + 0.02556426450610161, + 0.03270454704761505, + 0.04936705902218819, + 0.018328970298171043, + 0.0509270504117012, + 0.027917932718992233, + 0.32598578929901123, + 0.3948371410369873, + 0.021361233666539192 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2016063928604126 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive white tiger with inky black stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger's mouth open, revealing sharp canines and a pink tongue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger unleashing a roar with visible hot breath condensing into white mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a gloomy jungle with faint rays of light penetrating the canopy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle close-up where the tiger fills the entire frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10031797736883163 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.35031795501709 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10031797736883163, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10031797736883163, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05292056128382683, + 0.08692149817943573, + 0.03355396166443825, + 0.036006636917591095, + 0.021890291944146156, + 0.19003760814666748, + 0.042871829122304916, + 0.2797337472438812, + 0.1971607357263565, + 0.05890313535928726 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10031797736883163 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive white tiger with inky black stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger's mouth open, revealing sharp canines and a pink tongue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger unleashing a roar with visible hot breath condensing into white mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a gloomy jungle with faint rays of light penetrating the canopy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle close-up where the tiger fills the entire frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03369533270597458 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4086952209472656 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03369533270597458, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03369533270597458, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.038755543529987335, + 0.09191925078630447, + 0.06576918810606003, + 0.048658352345228195, + 0.05645329877734184, + 0.2757634222507477, + 0.036879461258649826, + 0.2574683725833893, + 0.07552928477525711, + 0.05280391499400139 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03369533270597458 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "striking low-angle close-up captures a massive white tiger at the very center of the frame, its massive bulk practically filling the entire frame. The beast's thick, snow-white fur is marked with distinct inky black stripes, and its icy blue eyes gleam with a fierce glint, fixed intently on the camera. Its maw, gaping, reveals its dagger-sharp canines, its barbed pink tongue curling with intensity as it unleashes a heartfelt, ear-piercing roar. Its bristly whiskers tremble with fury as it roars, its powerful sonic waves seemingly shaking the very air. The hot breath from its throat condenses into a white mist in the cool air. The background is the gloomy jungle. A few faint rays of light penetrate the dense canopy, sculpting the tiger's muscular shoulders and reflecting off its wet teeth. The entire picture is full of primitive power. The low-angle upward perspective greatly enhances its size and majesty, creating a suffocating, wild and threatening sense of oppression.", + "seed": 27064, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_0/index_6348_seed_27064_dp_1_rank_2_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.03378692306578159, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03378692306578159, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.8, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03378692306578159, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive white tiger with inky black stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger's mouth open, revealing sharp canines and a pink tongue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger unleashing a roar with visible hot breath condensing into white mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a gloomy jungle with faint rays of light penetrating the canopy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle close-up where the tiger fills the entire frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02409985661506653 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.774099826812744 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02409985661506653, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02409985661506653, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1021527573466301, + 0.19709371030330658, + 0.06902649253606796, + 0.05517148971557617, + 0.06793197244405746, + 0.08385089039802551, + 0.1366991400718689, + 0.04676365479826927, + 0.14257670938968658, + 0.09873321652412415 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02409985661506653 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive white tiger with inky black stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger's mouth open, revealing sharp canines and a pink tongue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger unleashing a roar with visible hot breath condensing into white mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a gloomy jungle with faint rays of light penetrating the canopy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle close-up where the tiger fills the entire frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012556307949125767 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387556076049805 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012556307949125767, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012556307949125767, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06487864255905151, + 0.12776395678520203, + 0.060508765280246735, + 0.12245449423789978, + 0.08226185292005539, + 0.056851524859666824, + 0.12469997256994247, + 0.032260507345199585, + 0.18040664494037628, + 0.14791367948055267 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012556307949125767 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive white tiger with inky black stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger's mouth open, revealing sharp canines and a pink tongue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger unleashing a roar with visible hot breath condensing into white mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a gloomy jungle with faint rays of light penetrating the canopy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle close-up where the tiger fills the entire frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07899098843336105 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.578990936279297 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07899098843336105, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07899098843336105, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.058686237782239914, + 0.08607232570648193, + 0.11374814808368683, + 0.10289230197668076, + 0.0755077674984932, + 0.0533737912774086, + 0.18254771828651428, + 0.17997248470783234, + 0.08195318281650543, + 0.06524603068828583 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07899098843336105 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive white tiger with inky black stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger's mouth open, revealing sharp canines and a pink tongue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger unleashing a roar with visible hot breath condensing into white mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a gloomy jungle with faint rays of light penetrating the canopy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle close-up where the tiger fills the entire frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.048655007034540176 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486550331115723 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.048655007034540176, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.048655007034540176, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04504379630088806, + 0.04712075740098953, + 0.10311397910118103, + 0.12881147861480713, + 0.2177055925130844, + 0.14797250926494598, + 0.05868149548768997, + 0.06851150095462799, + 0.16125717759132385, + 0.02178165130317211 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.048655007034540176 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive white tiger with inky black stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger's mouth open, revealing sharp canines and a pink tongue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger unleashing a roar with visible hot breath condensing into white mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a gloomy jungle with faint rays of light penetrating the canopy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle close-up where the tiger fills the entire frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004632455296814442 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379632472991943 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004632455296814442, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004632455296814442, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10163756459951401, + 0.047041140496730804, + 0.07561581581830978, + 0.060226067900657654, + 0.1519836187362671, + 0.09886819869279861, + 0.16552361845970154, + 0.07092085480690002, + 0.1551133096218109, + 0.07306978851556778 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004632455296814442 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "striking low-angle close-up captures a massive white tiger at the very center of the frame, its massive bulk practically filling the entire frame. The beast's thick, snow-white fur is marked with distinct inky black stripes, and its icy blue eyes gleam with a fierce glint, fixed intently on the camera. Its maw, gaping, reveals its dagger-sharp canines, its barbed pink tongue curling with intensity as it unleashes a heartfelt, ear-piercing roar. Its bristly whiskers tremble with fury as it roars, its powerful sonic waves seemingly shaking the very air. The hot breath from its throat condenses into a white mist in the cool air. The background is the gloomy jungle. A few faint rays of light penetrate the dense canopy, sculpting the tiger's muscular shoulders and reflecting off its wet teeth. The entire picture is full of primitive power. The low-angle upward perspective greatly enhances its size and majesty, creating a suffocating, wild and threatening sense of oppression.", + "seed": 27065, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_0/index_6348_seed_27065_dp_1_rank_2_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.027981389500200748, + "vlm_logprob": -0.027981389500200748, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.925, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.027981389500200748, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive white tiger with inky black stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger's mouth open, revealing sharp canines and a pink tongue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger unleashing a roar with visible hot breath condensing into white mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a gloomy jungle with faint rays of light penetrating the canopy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle close-up where the tiger fills the entire frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018905097618699074 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018905162811279 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018905097618699074, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018905097618699074, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21991752088069916, + 0.08614927530288696, + 0.05851941555738449, + 0.14847956597805023, + 0.07587185502052307, + 0.14915136992931366, + 0.0787578895688057, + 0.06633619219064713, + 0.06780709326267242, + 0.049009762704372406 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018905097618699074 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive white tiger with inky black stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger's mouth open, revealing sharp canines and a pink tongue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger unleashing a roar with visible hot breath condensing into white mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a gloomy jungle with faint rays of light penetrating the canopy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle close-up where the tiger fills the entire frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01109867449849844 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511098861694336 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01109867449849844, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01109867449849844, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12281253933906555, + 0.1253461092710495, + 0.1840682476758957, + 0.10592412203550339, + 0.23051373660564423, + 0.053535327315330505, + 0.05082089453935623, + 0.04572653770446777, + 0.056579139083623886, + 0.024673422798514366 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01109867449849844 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive white tiger with inky black stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger's mouth open, revealing sharp canines and a pink tongue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger unleashing a roar with visible hot breath condensing into white mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a gloomy jungle with faint rays of light penetrating the canopy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle close-up where the tiger fills the entire frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07899285852909088 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5789928436279297 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07899285852909088, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07899285852909088, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23951226472854614, + 0.11855778843164444, + 0.11438167840242386, + 0.14693376421928406, + 0.09593610465526581, + 0.03324006497859955, + 0.03862593695521355, + 0.04577320069074631, + 0.11343362927436829, + 0.053605612367391586 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07899285852909088 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive white tiger with inky black stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger's mouth open, revealing sharp canines and a pink tongue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger unleashing a roar with visible hot breath condensing into white mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a gloomy jungle with faint rays of light penetrating the canopy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle close-up where the tiger fills the entire frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023285744711756706 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732856273651123 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023285744711756706, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023285744711756706, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2096569836139679, + 0.0713050588965416, + 0.08476518839597702, + 0.09246817231178284, + 0.07504463940858841, + 0.02939486689865589, + 0.1842784732580185, + 0.06356106698513031, + 0.13512855768203735, + 0.05439698323607445 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023285744711756706 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive white tiger with inky black stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger's mouth open, revealing sharp canines and a pink tongue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger unleashing a roar with visible hot breath condensing into white mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a gloomy jungle with faint rays of light penetrating the canopy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle close-up where the tiger fills the entire frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007624572142958641 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882624626159668 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007624572142958641, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007624572142958641, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.42361605167388916, + 0.09253007918596268, + 0.04200645908713341, + 0.12048357725143433, + 0.04037449136376381, + 0.04738644137978554, + 0.07468997687101364, + 0.07412173599004745, + 0.037240732461214066, + 0.04755045473575592 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007624572142958641 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_1/index_tensor([8012, 8012])_group_1_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_1/index_tensor([8012, 8012])_group_1_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..21fb1742fc92ce1b80290dae702fa0fd1272d8d1 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_1/index_tensor([8012, 8012])_group_1_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "wide, long shot captured from underwater, the camera slowly pans to the right, following a massive humpback whale as it cruises through the boundless deep blue ocean. Brilliant beams of sunlight penetrate the shimmering surface, piercing the clear waters vertically, casting a shifting, dancing pattern of light and shadow across the whale's deep, blue-black skin, which flows with its movements. Its massive, streamlined form, its skin covered in white scratches and barnacles from age, dominates the frame, its massive pectoral fins gracefully extended like wings. With an almost meditative composure, it propels its body slowly and steadily forward through the powerful, steady up-and-down movements of its enormous tail fin, surrounded by countless tiny plankton shimmering in the beams of light. The dominant colors of the scene are deep ocean blue and brilliant sunlight white, interweaving light and shadow to create a majestic, tranquil, and vibrant atmosphere filled with a profound awe for the wonders of nature.", + "seed": 18045, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_1/index_8012_seed_18045_dp_2_rank_4_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.04675038503482938, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04675038503482938, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.825, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04675038503482938, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set underwater in a deep blue ocean?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive humpback whale visible as the main subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the whale's skin show white scratches and barnacles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are vertical beams of sunlight penetrating the water surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan to the right following the whale?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004474034067243338 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.87947416305542 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004474034067243338, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004474034067243338, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2580360174179077, + 0.17681291699409485, + 0.053833480924367905, + 0.03515156731009483, + 0.05190148577094078, + 0.03524358943104744, + 0.06708573549985886, + 0.04198019206523895, + 0.2130051702260971, + 0.06694984436035156 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004474034067243338 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set underwater in a deep blue ocean?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive humpback whale visible as the main subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the whale's skin show white scratches and barnacles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are vertical beams of sunlight penetrating the water surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan to the right following the whale?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00319446949288249 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753194332122803 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00319446949288249, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00319446949288249, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17021122574806213, + 0.09176460653543472, + 0.09161573648452759, + 0.09637824445962906, + 0.11333145946264267, + 0.04135230556130409, + 0.08127035945653915, + 0.17256759107112885, + 0.056945908814668655, + 0.08456255495548248 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00319446949288249 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set underwater in a deep blue ocean?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive humpback whale visible as the main subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the whale's skin show white scratches and barnacles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are vertical beams of sunlight penetrating the water surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan to the right following the whale?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.043053124099969864 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168053150177002 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.043053124099969864, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.043053124099969864, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1309330314397812, + 0.09334708750247955, + 0.06704815477132797, + 0.10311930626630783, + 0.08420998603105545, + 0.03249521926045418, + 0.08412499725818634, + 0.08736498653888702, + 0.08423380553722382, + 0.23312336206436157 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.043053124099969864 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set underwater in a deep blue ocean?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive humpback whale visible as the main subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the whale's skin show white scratches and barnacles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are vertical beams of sunlight penetrating the water surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan to the right following the whale?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003189241047948599 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.7531890869140625 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003189241047948599, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003189241047948599, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2846142053604126, + 0.1785655915737152, + 0.04263569414615631, + 0.09523837268352509, + 0.05841273441910744, + 0.03272635489702225, + 0.06331255286931992, + 0.04035412147641182, + 0.0954911932349205, + 0.10864920914173126 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003189241047948599 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set underwater in a deep blue ocean?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive humpback whale visible as the main subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the whale's skin show white scratches and barnacles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are vertical beams of sunlight penetrating the water surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan to the right following the whale?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1798410564661026 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8048410415649414 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1798410564661026, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1798410564661026, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06060074269771576, + 0.09595087915658951, + 0.019716450944542885, + 0.06662964075803757, + 0.0475475899875164, + 0.061655256897211075, + 0.08785949647426605, + 0.31388697028160095, + 0.03337644413113594, + 0.21277658641338348 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1798410564661026 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "wide, long shot captured from underwater, the camera slowly pans to the right, following a massive humpback whale as it cruises through the boundless deep blue ocean. Brilliant beams of sunlight penetrate the shimmering surface, piercing the clear waters vertically, casting a shifting, dancing pattern of light and shadow across the whale's deep, blue-black skin, which flows with its movements. Its massive, streamlined form, its skin covered in white scratches and barnacles from age, dominates the frame, its massive pectoral fins gracefully extended like wings. With an almost meditative composure, it propels its body slowly and steadily forward through the powerful, steady up-and-down movements of its enormous tail fin, surrounded by countless tiny plankton shimmering in the beams of light. The dominant colors of the scene are deep ocean blue and brilliant sunlight white, interweaving light and shadow to create a majestic, tranquil, and vibrant atmosphere filled with a profound awe for the wonders of nature.", + "seed": 18046, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_1/index_8012_seed_18046_dp_2_rank_4_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.08518934790045023, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08518934790045023, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.9, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08518934790045023, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set underwater in a deep blue ocean?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive humpback whale visible as the main subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the whale's skin show white scratches and barnacles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are vertical beams of sunlight penetrating the water surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan to the right following the whale?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0033098459243774414 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.628309726715088 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0033098459243774414, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0033098459243774414, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19842472672462463, + 0.08650615811347961, + 0.18740476667881012, + 0.08029373735189438, + 0.09040510654449463, + 0.09127647429704666, + 0.07443302124738693, + 0.08141268789768219, + 0.07701785117387772, + 0.03282547369599342 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0033098459243774414 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set underwater in a deep blue ocean?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive humpback whale visible as the main subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the whale's skin show white scratches and barnacles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are vertical beams of sunlight penetrating the water surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan to the right following the whale?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016067780554294586 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141067981719971 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016067780554294586, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016067780554294586, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07785502076148987, + 0.1197190061211586, + 0.10948771983385086, + 0.07593580335378647, + 0.11557850986719131, + 0.08290547132492065, + 0.09243875741958618, + 0.16728462278842926, + 0.11065556108951569, + 0.04813958331942558 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016067780554294586 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set underwater in a deep blue ocean?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive humpback whale visible as the main subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the whale's skin show white scratches and barnacles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are vertical beams of sunlight penetrating the water surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan to the right following the whale?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07897821068763733 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5789783000946045 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07897821068763733, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07897821068763733, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12140193581581116, + 0.10183755308389664, + 0.06942381709814072, + 0.10244598984718323, + 0.11926574259996414, + 0.09419954568147659, + 0.15729625523090363, + 0.11586657166481018, + 0.07610956579446793, + 0.04215295985341072 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07897821068763733 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set underwater in a deep blue ocean?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive humpback whale visible as the main subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the whale's skin show white scratches and barnacles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are vertical beams of sunlight penetrating the water surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan to the right following the whale?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014190246351063251 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264190196990967 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014190246351063251, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014190246351063251, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20657271146774292, + 0.029377346858382225, + 0.09777268022298813, + 0.34712710976600647, + 0.03655385226011276, + 0.0731070339679718, + 0.05688691511750221, + 0.04086640104651451, + 0.05697073042392731, + 0.054765257984399796 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014190246351063251 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set underwater in a deep blue ocean?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive humpback whale visible as the main subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the whale's skin show white scratches and barnacles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are vertical beams of sunlight penetrating the water surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan to the right following the whale?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.31340065598487854 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3134006261825562 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.31340065598487854, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.31340065598487854, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08642486482858658, + 0.07127997279167175, + 0.055807918310165405, + 0.07840481400489807, + 0.05278029292821884, + 0.3652660846710205, + 0.12209824472665787, + 0.030303116887807846, + 0.05243467539548874, + 0.08520004153251648 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.31340065598487854 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "wide, long shot captured from underwater, the camera slowly pans to the right, following a massive humpback whale as it cruises through the boundless deep blue ocean. Brilliant beams of sunlight penetrate the shimmering surface, piercing the clear waters vertically, casting a shifting, dancing pattern of light and shadow across the whale's deep, blue-black skin, which flows with its movements. Its massive, streamlined form, its skin covered in white scratches and barnacles from age, dominates the frame, its massive pectoral fins gracefully extended like wings. With an almost meditative composure, it propels its body slowly and steadily forward through the powerful, steady up-and-down movements of its enormous tail fin, surrounded by countless tiny plankton shimmering in the beams of light. The dominant colors of the scene are deep ocean blue and brilliant sunlight white, interweaving light and shadow to create a majestic, tranquil, and vibrant atmosphere filled with a profound awe for the wonders of nature.", + "seed": 18047, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_1/index_8012_seed_18047_dp_3_rank_6_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.05129251175094396, + "vlm_logprob": -0.05129251175094396, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.575, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.05129251175094396, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set underwater in a deep blue ocean?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive humpback whale visible as the main subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the whale's skin show white scratches and barnacles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are vertical beams of sunlight penetrating the water surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan to the right following the whale?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004002655856311321 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.129002571105957 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004002655856311321, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004002655856311321, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10257180035114288, + 0.03420456498861313, + 0.04997113719582558, + 0.10924975574016571, + 0.1444886177778244, + 0.04221907630562782, + 0.1863216906785965, + 0.0851537361741066, + 0.14204736053943634, + 0.10377226024866104 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 4, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004002655856311321 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set underwater in a deep blue ocean?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive humpback whale visible as the main subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the whale's skin show white scratches and barnacles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are vertical beams of sunlight penetrating the water surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan to the right following the whale?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0011843579122796655 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.751184463500977 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0011843579122796655, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0011843579122796655, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09432177245616913, + 0.05536828935146332, + 0.05614091455936432, + 0.025772670283913612, + 0.4805245101451874, + 0.033214129507541656, + 0.06688394397497177, + 0.03180801868438721, + 0.045409224927425385, + 0.11055649071931839 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0011843579122796655 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set underwater in a deep blue ocean?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive humpback whale visible as the main subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the whale's skin show white scratches and barnacles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are vertical beams of sunlight penetrating the water surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan to the right following the whale?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03369786962866783 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4086978435516357 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03369786962866783, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03369786962866783, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.044839564710855484, + 0.04293275624513626, + 0.05521618202328682, + 0.05892759934067726, + 0.38569262623786926, + 0.1577107310295105, + 0.09784726798534393, + 0.05978101119399071, + 0.06378837674856186, + 0.03326386958360672 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03369786962866783 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set underwater in a deep blue ocean?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive humpback whale visible as the main subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the whale's skin show white scratches and barnacles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are vertical beams of sunlight penetrating the water surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan to the right following the whale?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01606590487062931 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141066074371338 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01606590487062931, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01606590487062931, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.031481530517339706, + 0.036663684993982315, + 0.15813514590263367, + 0.06975651532411575, + 0.12873782217502594, + 0.019736938178539276, + 0.27843737602233887, + 0.040311556309461594, + 0.1582554280757904, + 0.07848396897315979 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01606590487062931 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set underwater in a deep blue ocean?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive humpback whale visible as the main subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the whale's skin show white scratches and barnacles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are vertical beams of sunlight penetrating the water surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan to the right following the whale?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20151177048683167 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7015117406845093 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20151177048683167, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20151177048683167, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.024817530065774918, + 0.01202569343149662, + 0.054649513214826584, + 0.027965962886810303, + 0.10816704481840134, + 0.04260522127151489, + 0.5216617584228516, + 0.04002336785197258, + 0.14528942108154297, + 0.022794542834162712 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20151177048683167 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "wide, long shot captured from underwater, the camera slowly pans to the right, following a massive humpback whale as it cruises through the boundless deep blue ocean. Brilliant beams of sunlight penetrate the shimmering surface, piercing the clear waters vertically, casting a shifting, dancing pattern of light and shadow across the whale's deep, blue-black skin, which flows with its movements. Its massive, streamlined form, its skin covered in white scratches and barnacles from age, dominates the frame, its massive pectoral fins gracefully extended like wings. With an almost meditative composure, it propels its body slowly and steadily forward through the powerful, steady up-and-down movements of its enormous tail fin, surrounded by countless tiny plankton shimmering in the beams of light. The dominant colors of the scene are deep ocean blue and brilliant sunlight white, interweaving light and shadow to create a majestic, tranquil, and vibrant atmosphere filled with a profound awe for the wonders of nature.", + "seed": 18048, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_1/index_8012_seed_18048_dp_3_rank_6_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.05735650649294257, + "vlm_logprob": -0.05735650649294257, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.9, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.05735650649294257, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set underwater in a deep blue ocean?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive humpback whale visible as the main subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the whale's skin show white scratches and barnacles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are vertical beams of sunlight penetrating the water surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan to the right following the whale?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005558510776609182 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.255558490753174 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005558510776609182, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005558510776609182, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1730050891637802, + 0.15024837851524353, + 0.06736014038324356, + 0.027552684769034386, + 0.052180107682943344, + 0.034088149666786194, + 0.1646401733160019, + 0.14080363512039185, + 0.06477771699428558, + 0.1253439038991928 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005558510776609182 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set underwater in a deep blue ocean?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive humpback whale visible as the main subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the whale's skin show white scratches and barnacles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are vertical beams of sunlight penetrating the water surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan to the right following the whale?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00864654965698719 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758646488189697 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00864654965698719, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00864654965698719, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09053173661231995, + 0.029815783724188805, + 0.06299886852502823, + 0.013407813385128975, + 0.05978881195187569, + 0.06775639951229095, + 0.15496082603931427, + 0.2073335498571396, + 0.180147185921669, + 0.13325902819633484 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00864654965698719 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set underwater in a deep blue ocean?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive humpback whale visible as the main subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the whale's skin show white scratches and barnacles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are vertical beams of sunlight penetrating the water surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan to the right following the whale?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05497325211763382 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299733638763428 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05497325211763382, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05497325211763382, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06643195450305939, + 0.06938645988702774, + 0.06125476956367493, + 0.019566627219319344, + 0.05118987709283829, + 0.09372444450855255, + 0.1352008581161499, + 0.30978691577911377, + 0.06339871138334274, + 0.13005945086479187 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05497325211763382 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set underwater in a deep blue ocean?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive humpback whale visible as the main subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the whale's skin show white scratches and barnacles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are vertical beams of sunlight penetrating the water surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan to the right following the whale?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01606731116771698 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.1410675048828125 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01606731116771698, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01606731116771698, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.47681325674057007, + 0.05583738163113594, + 0.14124494791030884, + 0.011745218187570572, + 0.041499216109514236, + 0.0529075488448143, + 0.05243959277868271, + 0.10807128250598907, + 0.014616168104112148, + 0.04482537880539894 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01606731116771698 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set underwater in a deep blue ocean?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive humpback whale visible as the main subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the whale's skin show white scratches and barnacles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are vertical beams of sunlight penetrating the water surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan to the right following the whale?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20153690874576569 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7015368938446045 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20153690874576569, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20153690874576569, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0668170377612114, + 0.034043747931718826, + 0.05762846767902374, + 0.03808537870645523, + 0.029292168095707893, + 0.12216131389141083, + 0.22970162332057953, + 0.1918218731880188, + 0.09599395096302032, + 0.13445442914962769 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20153690874576569 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_10/index_tensor([8887, 8887])_group_10_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_10/index_tensor([8887, 8887])_group_10_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..2fc64aaa31844659e8b94212a4d17bfdf40b31b6 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_10/index_tensor([8887, 8887])_group_10_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "medium, close-up, static shot, captured from a slight overhead angle, focuses on a gentle Asian mother, comfortably seated in a vintage wooden armchair. Soft afternoon sunlight slants through a large window, casting a warm golden hue on her long, dark brown hair, pulled into a low bun, and the off-white, turtleneck cashmere sweater she wears. Her face holds a serene, focused expression, her eyes slightly downcast, her gaze completely focused on the work in her hands. Her hands move steadily and deliberately, two smooth bamboo knitting needles twirling between her deft fingers. One needle expertly picks up lavender yarn and delicately threads it through the loop of the other. A half-finished sweater drapes across her legs, its intricate, twisted pattern clearly visible in the light, each fluffy fiber seeming palpable, a vivid, textured expression. Beside her, a wicker basket filled with colorful balls of yarn rests on the ground. The bookshelves and greenery in the background are softly blurred by the shallow depth of field. The entire scene is warm and harmonious, imbued with the warmth of home and the tranquility of time brought by handmade crafts.", + "seed": 8252, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_10/index_8887_seed_8252_dp_20_rank_40_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.028139535151422024, + "vlm_logprob": -0.028139535151422024, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.849999952316284, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.028139535151422024, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up of an Asian mother seated in a vintage wooden armchair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera captured from a slight overhead angle in a static position?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing an off-white turtleneck cashmere sweater with her dark brown hair pulled into a low bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are two smooth bamboo knitting needles visible twirling between her fingers while she threads lavender yarn?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a half-finished sweater with an intricate twisted pattern draped across her legs next to a wicker basket of colorful yarn balls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016405222937464714 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.14140510559082 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016405222937464714, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016405222937464714, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3806053102016449, + 0.07759509235620499, + 0.04969850555062294, + 0.03244612738490105, + 0.06867323070764542, + 0.01719043217599392, + 0.15893729031085968, + 0.017030727118253708, + 0.052676863968372345, + 0.145146444439888 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016405222937464714 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up of an Asian mother seated in a vintage wooden armchair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera captured from a slight overhead angle in a static position?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing an off-white turtleneck cashmere sweater with her dark brown hair pulled into a low bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are two smooth bamboo knitting needles visible twirling between her fingers while she threads lavender yarn?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a half-finished sweater with an intricate twisted pattern draped across her legs next to a wicker basket of colorful yarn balls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07897093892097473 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5789709091186523 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07897093892097473, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07897093892097473, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.48134928941726685, + 0.06465794146060944, + 0.05401178076863289, + 0.053673308342695236, + 0.027919907122850418, + 0.022387707605957985, + 0.1034381166100502, + 0.025853045284748077, + 0.08185048401355743, + 0.08485843986272812 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07897093892097473 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up of an Asian mother seated in a vintage wooden armchair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera captured from a slight overhead angle in a static position?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing an off-white turtleneck cashmere sweater with her dark brown hair pulled into a low bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are two smooth bamboo knitting needles visible twirling between her fingers while she threads lavender yarn?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a half-finished sweater with an intricate twisted pattern draped across her legs next to a wicker basket of colorful yarn balls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011074270121753216 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511074066162109 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011074270121753216, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011074270121753216, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.43172359466552734, + 0.0641043409705162, + 0.05521383509039879, + 0.02754458785057068, + 0.026295851916074753, + 0.01307668723165989, + 0.10520283877849579, + 0.01884358376264572, + 0.025931555777788162, + 0.2320631742477417 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011074270121753216 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up of an Asian mother seated in a vintage wooden armchair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera captured from a slight overhead angle in a static position?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing an off-white turtleneck cashmere sweater with her dark brown hair pulled into a low bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are two smooth bamboo knitting needles visible twirling between her fingers while she threads lavender yarn?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a half-finished sweater with an intricate twisted pattern draped across her legs next to a wicker basket of colorful yarn balls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016068601980805397 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141068458557129 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016068601980805397, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016068601980805397, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.6611904501914978, + 0.01794007420539856, + 0.05821617320179939, + 0.02008969895541668, + 0.02728353999555111, + 0.019540440291166306, + 0.12492591142654419, + 0.009618881158530712, + 0.036378901451826096, + 0.024815918877720833 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016068601980805397 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up of an Asian mother seated in a vintage wooden armchair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera captured from a slight overhead angle in a static position?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing an off-white turtleneck cashmere sweater with her dark brown hair pulled into a low bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are two smooth bamboo knitting needles visible twirling between her fingers while she threads lavender yarn?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a half-finished sweater with an intricate twisted pattern draped across her legs next to a wicker basket of colorful yarn balls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01817864179611206 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018178462982178 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01817864179611206, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01817864179611206, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.6619353294372559, + 0.06221016123890877, + 0.0314919650554657, + 0.02975708805024624, + 0.028368506580591202, + 0.030933767557144165, + 0.015163976699113846, + 0.02346324548125267, + 0.08163723349571228, + 0.035038772970438004 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01817864179611206 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "medium, close-up, static shot, captured from a slight overhead angle, focuses on a gentle Asian mother, comfortably seated in a vintage wooden armchair. Soft afternoon sunlight slants through a large window, casting a warm golden hue on her long, dark brown hair, pulled into a low bun, and the off-white, turtleneck cashmere sweater she wears. Her face holds a serene, focused expression, her eyes slightly downcast, her gaze completely focused on the work in her hands. Her hands move steadily and deliberately, two smooth bamboo knitting needles twirling between her deft fingers. One needle expertly picks up lavender yarn and delicately threads it through the loop of the other. A half-finished sweater drapes across her legs, its intricate, twisted pattern clearly visible in the light, each fluffy fiber seeming palpable, a vivid, textured expression. Beside her, a wicker basket filled with colorful balls of yarn rests on the ground. The bookshelves and greenery in the background are softly blurred by the shallow depth of field. The entire scene is warm and harmonious, imbued with the warmth of home and the tranquility of time brought by handmade crafts.", + "seed": 8253, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_10/index_8887_seed_8253_dp_20_rank_40_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.03098156936466694, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03098156936466694, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.825, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03098156936466694, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up of an Asian mother seated in a vintage wooden armchair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera captured from a slight overhead angle in a static position?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing an off-white turtleneck cashmere sweater with her dark brown hair pulled into a low bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are two smooth bamboo knitting needles visible twirling between her fingers while she threads lavender yarn?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a half-finished sweater with an intricate twisted pattern draped across her legs next to a wicker basket of colorful yarn balls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0129257682710886 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387925624847412 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0129257682710886, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0129257682710886, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15237604081630707, + 0.38933974504470825, + 0.036428891122341156, + 0.07236086577177048, + 0.04968370124697685, + 0.06298401951789856, + 0.092648446559906, + 0.03510379418730736, + 0.04933617636561394, + 0.05973832681775093 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0129257682710886 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up of an Asian mother seated in a vintage wooden armchair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera captured from a slight overhead angle in a static position?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing an off-white turtleneck cashmere sweater with her dark brown hair pulled into a low bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are two smooth bamboo knitting needles visible twirling between her fingers while she threads lavender yarn?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a half-finished sweater with an intricate twisted pattern draped across her legs next to a wicker basket of colorful yarn balls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07897412776947021 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5789742469787598 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07897412776947021, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07897412776947021, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12071959674358368, + 0.4127369523048401, + 0.06565560400485992, + 0.06150979548692703, + 0.039222829043865204, + 0.0438447929918766, + 0.1286228597164154, + 0.043870288878679276, + 0.055850304663181305, + 0.027966951951384544 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07897412776947021 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up of an Asian mother seated in a vintage wooden armchair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera captured from a slight overhead angle in a static position?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing an off-white turtleneck cashmere sweater with her dark brown hair pulled into a low bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are two smooth bamboo knitting needles visible twirling between her fingers while she threads lavender yarn?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a half-finished sweater with an intricate twisted pattern draped across her legs next to a wicker basket of colorful yarn balls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006735123693943024 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006735324859619 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006735123693943024, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006735123693943024, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14308008551597595, + 0.24031932651996613, + 0.05546491965651512, + 0.06295671314001083, + 0.05223753675818443, + 0.04545065388083458, + 0.21846728026866913, + 0.06495191156864166, + 0.07369082421064377, + 0.043380752205848694 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006735123693943024 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up of an Asian mother seated in a vintage wooden armchair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera captured from a slight overhead angle in a static position?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing an off-white turtleneck cashmere sweater with her dark brown hair pulled into a low bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are two smooth bamboo knitting needles visible twirling between her fingers while she threads lavender yarn?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a half-finished sweater with an intricate twisted pattern draped across her legs next to a wicker basket of colorful yarn balls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018183674663305283 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018183708190918 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018183674663305283, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018183674663305283, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12197870761156082, + 0.2645142078399658, + 0.042604848742485046, + 0.08216547966003418, + 0.030931895598769188, + 0.035268448293209076, + 0.289401113986969, + 0.029830632731318474, + 0.06748205423355103, + 0.035822633653879166 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018183674663305283 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up of an Asian mother seated in a vintage wooden armchair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera captured from a slight overhead angle in a static position?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing an off-white turtleneck cashmere sweater with her dark brown hair pulled into a low bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are two smooth bamboo knitting needles visible twirling between her fingers while she threads lavender yarn?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a half-finished sweater with an intricate twisted pattern draped across her legs next to a wicker basket of colorful yarn balls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03808915242552757 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2880890369415283 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03808915242552757, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03808915242552757, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09718386083841324, + 0.23606857657432556, + 0.08202224224805832, + 0.09038709104061127, + 0.03914489597082138, + 0.047130655497312546, + 0.24818813800811768, + 0.05321963131427765, + 0.06642939895391464, + 0.040225524455308914 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03808915242552757 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "medium, close-up, static shot, captured from a slight overhead angle, focuses on a gentle Asian mother, comfortably seated in a vintage wooden armchair. Soft afternoon sunlight slants through a large window, casting a warm golden hue on her long, dark brown hair, pulled into a low bun, and the off-white, turtleneck cashmere sweater she wears. Her face holds a serene, focused expression, her eyes slightly downcast, her gaze completely focused on the work in her hands. Her hands move steadily and deliberately, two smooth bamboo knitting needles twirling between her deft fingers. One needle expertly picks up lavender yarn and delicately threads it through the loop of the other. A half-finished sweater drapes across her legs, its intricate, twisted pattern clearly visible in the light, each fluffy fiber seeming palpable, a vivid, textured expression. Beside her, a wicker basket filled with colorful balls of yarn rests on the ground. The bookshelves and greenery in the background are softly blurred by the shallow depth of field. The entire scene is warm and harmonious, imbued with the warmth of home and the tranquility of time brought by handmade crafts.", + "seed": 8254, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_10/index_8887_seed_8254_dp_21_rank_42_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.03671542257070541, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03671542257070541, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.65, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03671542257070541, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up of an Asian mother seated in a vintage wooden armchair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera captured from a slight overhead angle in a static position?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing an off-white turtleneck cashmere sweater with her dark brown hair pulled into a low bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are two smooth bamboo knitting needles visible twirling between her fingers while she threads lavender yarn?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a half-finished sweater with an intricate twisted pattern draped across her legs next to a wicker basket of colorful yarn balls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012878225184977055 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.38787841796875 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012878225184977055, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012878225184977055, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07678478956222534, + 0.039082009345293045, + 0.2929372489452362, + 0.04338822513818741, + 0.06992443650960922, + 0.08631736040115356, + 0.19381988048553467, + 0.1772729605436325, + 0.01084353681653738, + 0.009629559703171253 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012878225184977055 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up of an Asian mother seated in a vintage wooden armchair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera captured from a slight overhead angle in a static position?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing an off-white turtleneck cashmere sweater with her dark brown hair pulled into a low bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are two smooth bamboo knitting needles visible twirling between her fingers while she threads lavender yarn?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a half-finished sweater with an intricate twisted pattern draped across her legs next to a wicker basket of colorful yarn balls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08902212232351303 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.464022159576416 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08902212232351303, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08902212232351303, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17945246398448944, + 0.11977168172597885, + 0.14158029854297638, + 0.06966086477041245, + 0.06252002716064453, + 0.06491999328136444, + 0.1386907994747162, + 0.13832901418209076, + 0.0637749657034874, + 0.02129988558590412 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08902212232351303 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up of an Asian mother seated in a vintage wooden armchair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera captured from a slight overhead angle in a static position?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing an off-white turtleneck cashmere sweater with her dark brown hair pulled into a low bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are two smooth bamboo knitting needles visible twirling between her fingers while she threads lavender yarn?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a half-finished sweater with an intricate twisted pattern draped across her legs next to a wicker basket of colorful yarn balls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012537590228021145 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387537479400635 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012537590228021145, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012537590228021145, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07672561705112457, + 0.028506221249699593, + 0.4860895574092865, + 0.03614487871527672, + 0.05335203930735588, + 0.0702989473938942, + 0.08950062841176987, + 0.13725870847702026, + 0.012190313078463078, + 0.00993312243372202 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012537590228021145 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up of an Asian mother seated in a vintage wooden armchair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera captured from a slight overhead angle in a static position?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing an off-white turtleneck cashmere sweater with her dark brown hair pulled into a low bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are two smooth bamboo knitting needles visible twirling between her fingers while she threads lavender yarn?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a half-finished sweater with an intricate twisted pattern draped across her legs next to a wicker basket of colorful yarn balls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014194242656230927 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264194011688232 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014194242656230927, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014194242656230927, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14620797336101532, + 0.06968256831169128, + 0.06235333904623985, + 0.08585421741008759, + 0.07149215787649155, + 0.09092266857624054, + 0.19385279715061188, + 0.17595292627811432, + 0.07164116203784943, + 0.03204013779759407 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014194242656230927 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up of an Asian mother seated in a vintage wooden armchair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera captured from a slight overhead angle in a static position?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing an off-white turtleneck cashmere sweater with her dark brown hair pulled into a low bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are two smooth bamboo knitting needles visible twirling between her fingers while she threads lavender yarn?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a half-finished sweater with an intricate twisted pattern draped across her legs next to a wicker basket of colorful yarn balls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05494493246078491 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299449920654297 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05494493246078491, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05494493246078491, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1479087769985199, + 0.07875259220600128, + 0.14729434251785278, + 0.05878628417849541, + 0.056960221379995346, + 0.11403853446245193, + 0.12261262536048889, + 0.18607346713542938, + 0.059012461453676224, + 0.028560742735862732 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05494493246078491 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "medium, close-up, static shot, captured from a slight overhead angle, focuses on a gentle Asian mother, comfortably seated in a vintage wooden armchair. Soft afternoon sunlight slants through a large window, casting a warm golden hue on her long, dark brown hair, pulled into a low bun, and the off-white, turtleneck cashmere sweater she wears. Her face holds a serene, focused expression, her eyes slightly downcast, her gaze completely focused on the work in her hands. Her hands move steadily and deliberately, two smooth bamboo knitting needles twirling between her deft fingers. One needle expertly picks up lavender yarn and delicately threads it through the loop of the other. A half-finished sweater drapes across her legs, its intricate, twisted pattern clearly visible in the light, each fluffy fiber seeming palpable, a vivid, textured expression. Beside her, a wicker basket filled with colorful balls of yarn rests on the ground. The bookshelves and greenery in the background are softly blurred by the shallow depth of field. The entire scene is warm and harmonious, imbued with the warmth of home and the tranquility of time brought by handmade crafts.", + "seed": 8255, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_10/index_8887_seed_8255_dp_21_rank_42_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.02403122466057539, + "vlm_logprob": -0.02403122466057539, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.825, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.02403122466057539, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up of an Asian mother seated in a vintage wooden armchair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera captured from a slight overhead angle in a static position?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing an off-white turtleneck cashmere sweater with her dark brown hair pulled into a low bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are two smooth bamboo knitting needles visible twirling between her fingers while she threads lavender yarn?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a half-finished sweater with an intricate twisted pattern draped across her legs next to a wicker basket of colorful yarn balls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018909426406025887 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018909454345703 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018909426406025887, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018909426406025887, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.46543627977371216, + 0.08974149078130722, + 0.20179462432861328, + 0.03433048725128174, + 0.03503911942243576, + 0.03724424168467522, + 0.025742849335074425, + 0.019125182181596756, + 0.04189829155802727, + 0.049647361040115356 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018909426406025887 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up of an Asian mother seated in a vintage wooden armchair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera captured from a slight overhead angle in a static position?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing an off-white turtleneck cashmere sweater with her dark brown hair pulled into a low bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are two smooth bamboo knitting needles visible twirling between her fingers while she threads lavender yarn?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a half-finished sweater with an intricate twisted pattern draped across her legs next to a wicker basket of colorful yarn balls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04306123033165932 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680612564086914 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04306123033165932, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04306123033165932, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.37165728211402893, + 0.15595237910747528, + 0.08106248080730438, + 0.05759943276643753, + 0.05250386893749237, + 0.06826786696910858, + 0.03820020332932472, + 0.06027354672551155, + 0.0593896210193634, + 0.05509330332279205 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04306123033165932 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up of an Asian mother seated in a vintage wooden armchair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera captured from a slight overhead angle in a static position?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing an off-white turtleneck cashmere sweater with her dark brown hair pulled into a low bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are two smooth bamboo knitting needles visible twirling between her fingers while she threads lavender yarn?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a half-finished sweater with an intricate twisted pattern draped across her legs next to a wicker basket of colorful yarn balls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014198473654687405 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264198303222656 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014198473654687405, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014198473654687405, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2557747960090637, + 0.12178574502468109, + 0.2708147466182709, + 0.05762723460793495, + 0.09062517434358597, + 0.05513574928045273, + 0.03162897378206253, + 0.025531580671668053, + 0.051333751529455185, + 0.03974229469895363 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014198473654687405 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up of an Asian mother seated in a vintage wooden armchair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera captured from a slight overhead angle in a static position?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing an off-white turtleneck cashmere sweater with her dark brown hair pulled into a low bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are two smooth bamboo knitting needles visible twirling between her fingers while she threads lavender yarn?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a half-finished sweater with an intricate twisted pattern draped across her legs next to a wicker basket of colorful yarn balls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014193184673786163 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264193058013916 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014193184673786163, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014193184673786163, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3907715976238251, + 0.09816576540470123, + 0.11409621685743332, + 0.05087093263864517, + 0.05749833956360817, + 0.047504913061857224, + 0.04231962934136391, + 0.05122067779302597, + 0.10030066221952438, + 0.047251198440790176 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014193184673786163 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up of an Asian mother seated in a vintage wooden armchair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera captured from a slight overhead angle in a static position?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing an off-white turtleneck cashmere sweater with her dark brown hair pulled into a low bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are two smooth bamboo knitting needles visible twirling between her fingers while she threads lavender yarn?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a half-finished sweater with an intricate twisted pattern draped across her legs next to a wicker basket of colorful yarn balls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029793808236718178 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5297937393188477 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029793808236718178, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029793808236718178, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2879456877708435, + 0.10002022236585617, + 0.09298214316368103, + 0.04095781594514847, + 0.0718228816986084, + 0.03323981910943985, + 0.07855670154094696, + 0.02132924646139145, + 0.21719153225421906, + 0.055953968316316605 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029793808236718178 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_11/index_tensor([1852, 1852])_group_11_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_11/index_tensor([1852, 1852])_group_11_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..7532723de244d4e8a6750ec0acff171ea6cc59b8 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_11/index_tensor([1852, 1852])_group_11_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "The scene begins with a high-angle, long shot, slowly and deliberately zooming in, capturing a winding, dark gray paved mountain road through a dense forest ablaze with fiery reds and brilliant golds of autumn leaves. The low, golden rays of the dawn sun shimmer across the distant ridges, casting long, dramatic shadows and bathing the crisp air in a warm, ethereal glow. At the center of this vast, serene landscape lies the solitary figure of a petite, young Southeast Asian man with short, unkempt black hair, dressed simply in a gray sweatshirt and dark blue jeans. As the camera zooms in, his concentrated expression becomes clear, tinged with a hint of nervous worry. He rides on a worn skateboard with bright orange wheels, rolling forward at a slow, hesitant pace. His body stiffens and sways, his center of gravity shifting precariously. In an effort to maintain stability, he awkwardly flings his arms to the sides in an uncoordinated circle, his hands outstretched as if trying to grasp at the air itself. The entire scene is a tense and poignant ballet of effort, contrasting the men’s awkward, determined struggle with the quiet, breathtaking beauty of a golden autumn morning.", + "seed": 5755, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_11/index_1852_seed_5755_dp_22_rank_44_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.0746200941503048, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0746200941503048, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.725, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0746200941503048, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a winding, dark gray paved mountain road through a dense forest with autumn leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by low golden dawn sun rays casting long shadows and a warm glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a petite young Southeast Asian man with short black hair wearing a gray sweatshirt and dark blue jeans?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the man riding a worn skateboard with bright orange wheels at a slow, hesitant pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a high-angle long shot and slowly zoom in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.031956747174263 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.531956672668457 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.031956747174263, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.031956747174263, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14441370964050293, + 0.026981493458151817, + 0.02580953761935234, + 0.08065008372068405, + 0.055914316326379776, + 0.5086958408355713, + 0.0398845300078392, + 0.04999392852187157, + 0.024566946551203728, + 0.043089624494314194 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.031956747174263 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a winding, dark gray paved mountain road through a dense forest with autumn leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by low golden dawn sun rays casting long shadows and a warm glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a petite young Southeast Asian man with short black hair wearing a gray sweatshirt and dark blue jeans?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the man riding a worn skateboard with bright orange wheels at a slow, hesitant pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a high-angle long shot and slowly zoom in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10033145546913147 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3503315448760986 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10033145546913147, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10033145546913147, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15693549811840057, + 0.05551416426897049, + 0.04025568813085556, + 0.04597272723913193, + 0.03373832255601883, + 0.41542762517929077, + 0.13530263304710388, + 0.027149271219968796, + 0.025486046448349953, + 0.06421814858913422 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10033145546913147 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a winding, dark gray paved mountain road through a dense forest with autumn leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by low golden dawn sun rays casting long shadows and a warm glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a petite young Southeast Asian man with short black hair wearing a gray sweatshirt and dark blue jeans?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the man riding a worn skateboard with bright orange wheels at a slow, hesitant pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a high-angle long shot and slowly zoom in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14281150698661804 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0178115367889404 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14281150698661804, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14281150698661804, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07012191414833069, + 0.03652020916342735, + 0.06141362339258194, + 0.11048328876495361, + 0.030191997066140175, + 0.07268965244293213, + 0.2657429873943329, + 0.15711455047130585, + 0.07871145755052567, + 0.11701033264398575 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14281150698661804 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a winding, dark gray paved mountain road through a dense forest with autumn leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by low golden dawn sun rays casting long shadows and a warm glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a petite young Southeast Asian man with short black hair wearing a gray sweatshirt and dark blue jeans?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the man riding a worn skateboard with bright orange wheels at a slow, hesitant pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a high-angle long shot and slowly zoom in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.043062712997198105 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168062686920166 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.043062712997198105, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.043062712997198105, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03765184059739113, + 0.014713789336383343, + 0.024706540629267693, + 0.024652229622006416, + 0.05795041471719742, + 0.6467162370681763, + 0.03471764549612999, + 0.04967997595667839, + 0.057118434458971024, + 0.052092913538217545 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.043062712997198105 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a winding, dark gray paved mountain road through a dense forest with autumn leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by low golden dawn sun rays casting long shadows and a warm glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a petite young Southeast Asian man with short black hair wearing a gray sweatshirt and dark blue jeans?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the man riding a worn skateboard with bright orange wheels at a slow, hesitant pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a high-angle long shot and slowly zoom in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.054938048124313354 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299380779266357 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.054938048124313354, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.054938048124313354, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22061793506145477, + 0.02697615884244442, + 0.06057227402925491, + 0.09786009043455124, + 0.06360822170972824, + 0.17624424397945404, + 0.09514228999614716, + 0.07002423703670502, + 0.10406537353992462, + 0.0848892331123352 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.054938048124313354 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "The scene begins with a high-angle, long shot, slowly and deliberately zooming in, capturing a winding, dark gray paved mountain road through a dense forest ablaze with fiery reds and brilliant golds of autumn leaves. The low, golden rays of the dawn sun shimmer across the distant ridges, casting long, dramatic shadows and bathing the crisp air in a warm, ethereal glow. At the center of this vast, serene landscape lies the solitary figure of a petite, young Southeast Asian man with short, unkempt black hair, dressed simply in a gray sweatshirt and dark blue jeans. As the camera zooms in, his concentrated expression becomes clear, tinged with a hint of nervous worry. He rides on a worn skateboard with bright orange wheels, rolling forward at a slow, hesitant pace. His body stiffens and sways, his center of gravity shifting precariously. In an effort to maintain stability, he awkwardly flings his arms to the sides in an uncoordinated circle, his hands outstretched as if trying to grasp at the air itself. The entire scene is a tense and poignant ballet of effort, contrasting the men’s awkward, determined struggle with the quiet, breathtaking beauty of a golden autumn morning.", + "seed": 5756, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_11/index_1852_seed_5756_dp_22_rank_44_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.10485990159213543, + "vlm_logprob": -0.10485990159213543, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.725, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.10485990159213543, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a winding, dark gray paved mountain road through a dense forest with autumn leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by low golden dawn sun rays casting long shadows and a warm glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a petite young Southeast Asian man with short black hair wearing a gray sweatshirt and dark blue jeans?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the man riding a worn skateboard with bright orange wheels at a slow, hesitant pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a high-angle long shot and slowly zoom in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0219035092741251 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8969035148620605 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0219035092741251, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0219035092741251, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12378691881895065, + 0.08220872282981873, + 0.07674511522054672, + 0.025714822113513947, + 0.36835601925849915, + 0.02886933647096157, + 0.20691028237342834, + 0.03989286348223686, + 0.023312179371714592, + 0.024203721433877945 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0219035092741251 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a winding, dark gray paved mountain road through a dense forest with autumn leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by low golden dawn sun rays casting long shadows and a warm glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a petite young Southeast Asian man with short black hair wearing a gray sweatshirt and dark blue jeans?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the man riding a worn skateboard with bright orange wheels at a slow, hesitant pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a high-angle long shot and slowly zoom in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06206318736076355 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812063217163086 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06206318736076355, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06206318736076355, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17300103604793549, + 0.12490344792604446, + 0.08364539593458176, + 0.04757653921842575, + 0.24320165812969208, + 0.07776818424463272, + 0.13908028602600098, + 0.02784399688243866, + 0.034199927002191544, + 0.04877954721450806 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06206318736076355 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a winding, dark gray paved mountain road through a dense forest with autumn leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by low golden dawn sun rays casting long shadows and a warm glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a petite young Southeast Asian man with short black hair wearing a gray sweatshirt and dark blue jeans?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the man riding a worn skateboard with bright orange wheels at a slow, hesitant pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a high-angle long shot and slowly zoom in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3486327826976776 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2236328125 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3486327826976776, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3486327826976776, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11514774709939957, + 0.09355901181697845, + 0.12081512808799744, + 0.02616107650101185, + 0.1217799261212349, + 0.06286538392305374, + 0.15625889599323273, + 0.14963766932487488, + 0.08619969338178635, + 0.06757546216249466 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3486327826976776 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a winding, dark gray paved mountain road through a dense forest with autumn leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by low golden dawn sun rays casting long shadows and a warm glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a petite young Southeast Asian man with short black hair wearing a gray sweatshirt and dark blue jeans?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the man riding a worn skateboard with bright orange wheels at a slow, hesitant pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a high-angle long shot and slowly zoom in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04865409806370735 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048654079437256 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04865409806370735, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04865409806370735, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.029565544798970222, + 0.02436988800764084, + 0.08581957221031189, + 0.022195512428879738, + 0.5049422383308411, + 0.029601050540804863, + 0.1411840319633484, + 0.052877847105264664, + 0.05634463578462601, + 0.05309969186782837 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04865409806370735 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a winding, dark gray paved mountain road through a dense forest with autumn leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by low golden dawn sun rays casting long shadows and a warm glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a petite young Southeast Asian man with short black hair wearing a gray sweatshirt and dark blue jeans?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the man riding a worn skateboard with bright orange wheels at a slow, hesitant pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a high-angle long shot and slowly zoom in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.043045930564403534 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168045997619629 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.043045930564403534, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.043045930564403534, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18704336881637573, + 0.09896967560052872, + 0.17733587324619293, + 0.08220189064741135, + 0.11929904669523239, + 0.06367433816194534, + 0.13070406019687653, + 0.036843329668045044, + 0.03583429008722305, + 0.06809414178133011 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.043045930564403534 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "The scene begins with a high-angle, long shot, slowly and deliberately zooming in, capturing a winding, dark gray paved mountain road through a dense forest ablaze with fiery reds and brilliant golds of autumn leaves. The low, golden rays of the dawn sun shimmer across the distant ridges, casting long, dramatic shadows and bathing the crisp air in a warm, ethereal glow. At the center of this vast, serene landscape lies the solitary figure of a petite, young Southeast Asian man with short, unkempt black hair, dressed simply in a gray sweatshirt and dark blue jeans. As the camera zooms in, his concentrated expression becomes clear, tinged with a hint of nervous worry. He rides on a worn skateboard with bright orange wheels, rolling forward at a slow, hesitant pace. His body stiffens and sways, his center of gravity shifting precariously. In an effort to maintain stability, he awkwardly flings his arms to the sides in an uncoordinated circle, his hands outstretched as if trying to grasp at the air itself. The entire scene is a tense and poignant ballet of effort, contrasting the men’s awkward, determined struggle with the quiet, breathtaking beauty of a golden autumn morning.", + "seed": 5757, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_11/index_1852_seed_5757_dp_23_rank_46_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.06514956932514906, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06514956932514906, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.125, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06514956932514906, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a winding, dark gray paved mountain road through a dense forest with autumn leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by low golden dawn sun rays casting long shadows and a warm glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a petite young Southeast Asian man with short black hair wearing a gray sweatshirt and dark blue jeans?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the man riding a worn skateboard with bright orange wheels at a slow, hesitant pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a high-angle long shot and slowly zoom in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01445982325822115 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.389459609985352 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01445982325822115, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01445982325822115, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08733123540878296, + 0.06041335314512253, + 0.047221969813108444, + 0.06712428480386734, + 0.1928129494190216, + 0.23911534249782562, + 0.03400348871946335, + 0.06000842899084091, + 0.07653720676898956, + 0.13543175160884857 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01445982325822115 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a winding, dark gray paved mountain road through a dense forest with autumn leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by low golden dawn sun rays casting long shadows and a warm glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a petite young Southeast Asian man with short black hair wearing a gray sweatshirt and dark blue jeans?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the man riding a worn skateboard with bright orange wheels at a slow, hesitant pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a high-angle long shot and slowly zoom in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02329995296895504 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732999324798584 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02329995296895504, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02329995296895504, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.014427308924496174, + 0.014795484021306038, + 0.10714050382375717, + 0.020831158384680748, + 0.016650686040520668, + 0.04472446069121361, + 0.03884255886077881, + 0.026597877964377403, + 0.018802527338266373, + 0.6971874833106995 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02329995296895504 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a winding, dark gray paved mountain road through a dense forest with autumn leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by low golden dawn sun rays casting long shadows and a warm glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a petite young Southeast Asian man with short black hair wearing a gray sweatshirt and dark blue jeans?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the man riding a worn skateboard with bright orange wheels at a slow, hesitant pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a high-angle long shot and slowly zoom in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17989204823970795 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8048920631408691 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17989204823970795, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17989204823970795, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.038189373910427094, + 0.03405933454632759, + 0.18352380394935608, + 0.04585828259587288, + 0.2322276085615158, + 0.19604578614234924, + 0.016492893919348717, + 0.12204740941524506, + 0.02905704639852047, + 0.10249844938516617 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17989204823970795 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a winding, dark gray paved mountain road through a dense forest with autumn leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by low golden dawn sun rays casting long shadows and a warm glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a petite young Southeast Asian man with short black hair wearing a gray sweatshirt and dark blue jeans?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the man riding a worn skateboard with bright orange wheels at a slow, hesitant pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a high-angle long shot and slowly zoom in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03810166195034981 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881016731262207 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03810166195034981, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03810166195034981, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03212311863899231, + 0.054832782596349716, + 0.09476130455732346, + 0.03041725791990757, + 0.05980265885591507, + 0.35707804560661316, + 0.024369774386286736, + 0.08794127404689789, + 0.053629469126462936, + 0.20504429936408997 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03810166195034981 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a winding, dark gray paved mountain road through a dense forest with autumn leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by low golden dawn sun rays casting long shadows and a warm glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a petite young Southeast Asian man with short black hair wearing a gray sweatshirt and dark blue jeans?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the man riding a worn skateboard with bright orange wheels at a slow, hesitant pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a high-angle long shot and slowly zoom in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06999436020851135 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6949944496154785 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06999436020851135, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06999436020851135, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06910046935081482, + 0.043603647500276566, + 0.11040806770324707, + 0.06609777361154556, + 0.04004133120179176, + 0.03886456415057182, + 0.07157375663518906, + 0.3023914694786072, + 0.07464978098869324, + 0.18326912820339203 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06999436020851135 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "The scene begins with a high-angle, long shot, slowly and deliberately zooming in, capturing a winding, dark gray paved mountain road through a dense forest ablaze with fiery reds and brilliant golds of autumn leaves. The low, golden rays of the dawn sun shimmer across the distant ridges, casting long, dramatic shadows and bathing the crisp air in a warm, ethereal glow. At the center of this vast, serene landscape lies the solitary figure of a petite, young Southeast Asian man with short, unkempt black hair, dressed simply in a gray sweatshirt and dark blue jeans. As the camera zooms in, his concentrated expression becomes clear, tinged with a hint of nervous worry. He rides on a worn skateboard with bright orange wheels, rolling forward at a slow, hesitant pace. His body stiffens and sways, his center of gravity shifting precariously. In an effort to maintain stability, he awkwardly flings his arms to the sides in an uncoordinated circle, his hands outstretched as if trying to grasp at the air itself. The entire scene is a tense and poignant ballet of effort, contrasting the men’s awkward, determined struggle with the quiet, breathtaking beauty of a golden autumn morning.", + "seed": 5758, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_11/index_1852_seed_5758_dp_23_rank_46_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.10893742982298135, + "vlm_logprob": -0.10893742982298135, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.925, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.10893742982298135, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a winding, dark gray paved mountain road through a dense forest with autumn leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by low golden dawn sun rays casting long shadows and a warm glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a petite young Southeast Asian man with short black hair wearing a gray sweatshirt and dark blue jeans?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the man riding a worn skateboard with bright orange wheels at a slow, hesitant pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a high-angle long shot and slowly zoom in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020106662064790726 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.020106792449951 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020106662064790726, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020106662064790726, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12578950822353363, + 0.06656274199485779, + 0.028669709339737892, + 0.03661596402525902, + 0.06828226894140244, + 0.5005272030830383, + 0.04241862893104553, + 0.07576817274093628, + 0.03318846970796585, + 0.022177299484610558 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020106662064790726 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a winding, dark gray paved mountain road through a dense forest with autumn leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by low golden dawn sun rays casting long shadows and a warm glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a petite young Southeast Asian man with short black hair wearing a gray sweatshirt and dark blue jeans?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the man riding a worn skateboard with bright orange wheels at a slow, hesitant pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a high-angle long shot and slowly zoom in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012552776373922825 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387552738189697 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012552776373922825, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012552776373922825, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.26906201243400574, + 0.23440061509609222, + 0.0949040874838829, + 0.038510456681251526, + 0.07135886698961258, + 0.12254609912633896, + 0.04239961504936218, + 0.05424118787050247, + 0.03479970991611481, + 0.0377773679792881 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012552776373922825 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a winding, dark gray paved mountain road through a dense forest with autumn leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by low golden dawn sun rays casting long shadows and a warm glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a petite young Southeast Asian man with short black hair wearing a gray sweatshirt and dark blue jeans?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the man riding a worn skateboard with bright orange wheels at a slow, hesitant pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a high-angle long shot and slowly zoom in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3870685398578644 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.137068510055542 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3870685398578644, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3870685398578644, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05240800604224205, + 0.018658287823200226, + 0.03568356856703758, + 0.025505974888801575, + 0.027721555903553963, + 0.7186156511306763, + 0.021801726892590523, + 0.060184743255376816, + 0.02480149455368519, + 0.014618979766964912 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3870685398578644 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a winding, dark gray paved mountain road through a dense forest with autumn leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by low golden dawn sun rays casting long shadows and a warm glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a petite young Southeast Asian man with short black hair wearing a gray sweatshirt and dark blue jeans?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the man riding a worn skateboard with bright orange wheels at a slow, hesitant pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a high-angle long shot and slowly zoom in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.070022813975811 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950228214263916 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.070022813975811, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.070022813975811, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0617382638156414, + 0.05897827818989754, + 0.0671876072883606, + 0.07533425092697144, + 0.16311153769493103, + 0.4471500813961029, + 0.026638587936758995, + 0.0438430979847908, + 0.030710075050592422, + 0.025308240205049515 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.070022813975811 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a winding, dark gray paved mountain road through a dense forest with autumn leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by low golden dawn sun rays casting long shadows and a warm glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a petite young Southeast Asian man with short black hair wearing a gray sweatshirt and dark blue jeans?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the man riding a worn skateboard with bright orange wheels at a slow, hesitant pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a high-angle long shot and slowly zoom in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05493635684251785 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929936408996582 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05493635684251785, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05493635684251785, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1123894527554512, + 0.042426761239767075, + 0.09629708528518677, + 0.0350269116461277, + 0.12479197233915329, + 0.31571707129478455, + 0.0631428211927414, + 0.1349368393421173, + 0.04934191703796387, + 0.025929156690835953 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 7, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05493635684251785 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_12/index_tensor([5920, 5920])_group_12_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_12/index_tensor([5920, 5920])_group_12_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..07712ba70aa6bd2b258189ab952fd736e9a71757 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_12/index_tensor([5920, 5920])_group_12_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "dynamic, low-angle, handheld shot closely follows two Asian men engaged in a fierce exchange, the camera panning with their movements to create an immersive sense of chaos. The man in the foreground, with short, sweat-soaked black hair plastered to his scalp, is shirtless, revealing a chiseled, taut back and shoulders, each muscle trembling with exertion. The other man, facing the camera, has slightly longer, tangled black hair, with a few wet strands clinging to his forehead and cheeks. He wears a thoroughly soaked gray cotton T-shirt, tightly clung to his chest and abdomen, emphasizing his muscular physique. In a swift, turning, blocking motion, beads of sweat flung from their arms, hair, and cheeks. Under the harsh, single, cold light source from above, these splattering beads of sweat are momentarily illuminated, like countless tiny, shimmering crystals, drawing fleeting, bright arcs against the dim, rough concrete basement backdrop behind them. The entire scene is painted in a cool tone, dominated by the gray of concrete and the natural tones of the skin. The contrast between light and shadow is extremely strong, creating a primitive, tense and powerful fighting atmosphere.", + "seed": 26292, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_12/index_5920_seed_26292_dp_24_rank_48_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.10966487377882003, + "vlm_logprob": -0.10966487377882003, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.425, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.10966487377882003, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two Asian men visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man in the foreground shirtless with short, sweat-soaked black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the other man wearing a thoroughly soaked gray cotton T-shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dim, rough concrete basement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a dynamic, low-angle, handheld camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0559929683804512 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.93099308013916 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0559929683804512, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0559929683804512, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2869037091732025, + 0.06596043705940247, + 0.0640408843755722, + 0.04140784591436386, + 0.09711024165153503, + 0.03289391100406647, + 0.04834164306521416, + 0.10936123132705688, + 0.18390010297298431, + 0.07007992267608643 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0559929683804512 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two Asian men visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man in the foreground shirtless with short, sweat-soaked black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the other man wearing a thoroughly soaked gray cotton T-shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dim, rough concrete basement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a dynamic, low-angle, handheld camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11294203251600266 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2379419803619385 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11294203251600266, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11294203251600266, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1352057307958603, + 0.0995088517665863, + 0.16759788990020752, + 0.02717648632824421, + 0.03272171691060066, + 0.22532109916210175, + 0.05250760167837143, + 0.04923185706138611, + 0.0364748053252697, + 0.174253910779953 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11294203251600266 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two Asian men visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man in the foreground shirtless with short, sweat-soaked black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the other man wearing a thoroughly soaked gray cotton T-shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dim, rough concrete basement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a dynamic, low-angle, handheld camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.043076418340206146 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168076515197754 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.043076418340206146, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.043076418340206146, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22706866264343262, + 0.08462810516357422, + 0.09352033585309982, + 0.06356434524059296, + 0.13709689676761627, + 0.0679546594619751, + 0.04477770999073982, + 0.0771179124712944, + 0.08355547487735748, + 0.12071585655212402 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.043076418340206146 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two Asian men visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man in the foreground shirtless with short, sweat-soaked black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the other man wearing a thoroughly soaked gray cotton T-shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dim, rough concrete basement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a dynamic, low-angle, handheld camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2813664376735687 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4063664674758911 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2813664376735687, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2813664376735687, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4232771694660187, + 0.0717342272400856, + 0.04404734447598457, + 0.022189872339367867, + 0.18908517062664032, + 0.025968071073293686, + 0.01986023597419262, + 0.03173910453915596, + 0.1154865175485611, + 0.0566122867166996 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2813664376735687 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two Asian men visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man in the foreground shirtless with short, sweat-soaked black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the other man wearing a thoroughly soaked gray cotton T-shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dim, rough concrete basement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a dynamic, low-angle, handheld camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05494651198387146 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299464225769043 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05494651198387146, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05494651198387146, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.36975598335266113, + 0.07175509631633759, + 0.06251557171344757, + 0.08863624930381775, + 0.08807243406772614, + 0.07005783915519714, + 0.06979584693908691, + 0.04936622455716133, + 0.053594328463077545, + 0.0764504224061966 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05494651198387146 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dynamic, low-angle, handheld shot closely follows two Asian men engaged in a fierce exchange, the camera panning with their movements to create an immersive sense of chaos. The man in the foreground, with short, sweat-soaked black hair plastered to his scalp, is shirtless, revealing a chiseled, taut back and shoulders, each muscle trembling with exertion. The other man, facing the camera, has slightly longer, tangled black hair, with a few wet strands clinging to his forehead and cheeks. He wears a thoroughly soaked gray cotton T-shirt, tightly clung to his chest and abdomen, emphasizing his muscular physique. In a swift, turning, blocking motion, beads of sweat flung from their arms, hair, and cheeks. Under the harsh, single, cold light source from above, these splattering beads of sweat are momentarily illuminated, like countless tiny, shimmering crystals, drawing fleeting, bright arcs against the dim, rough concrete basement backdrop behind them. The entire scene is painted in a cool tone, dominated by the gray of concrete and the natural tones of the skin. The contrast between light and shadow is extremely strong, creating a primitive, tense and powerful fighting atmosphere.", + "seed": 26293, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_12/index_5920_seed_26293_dp_24_rank_48_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.06782309077680111, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06782309077680111, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.925, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06782309077680111, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two Asian men visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man in the foreground shirtless with short, sweat-soaked black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the other man wearing a thoroughly soaked gray cotton T-shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dim, rough concrete basement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a dynamic, low-angle, handheld camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07092981785535812 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695929765701294 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07092981785535812, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07092981785535812, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2734100818634033, + 0.05295468866825104, + 0.11298035085201263, + 0.1449182629585266, + 0.10136183351278305, + 0.06918379664421082, + 0.07155445963144302, + 0.07786311209201813, + 0.05737041309475899, + 0.038403041660785675 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07092981785535812 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two Asian men visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man in the foreground shirtless with short, sweat-soaked black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the other man wearing a thoroughly soaked gray cotton T-shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dim, rough concrete basement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a dynamic, low-angle, handheld camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04307698830962181 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168076992034912 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04307698830962181, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04307698830962181, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2196967899799347, + 0.0649927407503128, + 0.08427992463111877, + 0.09098131209611893, + 0.29547855257987976, + 0.0231504924595356, + 0.03388049080967903, + 0.0742294192314148, + 0.03907310217618942, + 0.07423713803291321 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04307698830962181 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two Asian men visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man in the foreground shirtless with short, sweat-soaked black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the other man wearing a thoroughly soaked gray cotton T-shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dim, rough concrete basement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a dynamic, low-angle, handheld camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.048672378063201904 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486724376678467 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.048672378063201904, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.048672378063201904, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16940249502658844, + 0.07552683353424072, + 0.1260392814874649, + 0.12457465380430222, + 0.18543997406959534, + 0.06734587252140045, + 0.05166798084974289, + 0.09586509317159653, + 0.0543828047811985, + 0.04975508153438568 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.048672378063201904 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two Asian men visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man in the foreground shirtless with short, sweat-soaked black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the other man wearing a thoroughly soaked gray cotton T-shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dim, rough concrete basement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a dynamic, low-angle, handheld camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16036860644817352 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.91036856174469 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16036860644817352, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16036860644817352, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07714641094207764, + 0.13651838898658752, + 0.17985379695892334, + 0.13435424864292145, + 0.13142892718315125, + 0.17636214196681976, + 0.03432222455739975, + 0.03452789783477783, + 0.05852918326854706, + 0.0369567833840847 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16036860644817352 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two Asian men visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man in the foreground shirtless with short, sweat-soaked black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the other man wearing a thoroughly soaked gray cotton T-shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dim, rough concrete basement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a dynamic, low-angle, handheld camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016067663207650185 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.1410675048828125 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016067663207650185, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016067663207650185, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20858585834503174, + 0.07951343804597855, + 0.10553530603647232, + 0.09826438128948212, + 0.16156691312789917, + 0.031411442905664444, + 0.05705443397164345, + 0.07401919364929199, + 0.13545167446136475, + 0.04859739542007446 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016067663207650185 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dynamic, low-angle, handheld shot closely follows two Asian men engaged in a fierce exchange, the camera panning with their movements to create an immersive sense of chaos. The man in the foreground, with short, sweat-soaked black hair plastered to his scalp, is shirtless, revealing a chiseled, taut back and shoulders, each muscle trembling with exertion. The other man, facing the camera, has slightly longer, tangled black hair, with a few wet strands clinging to his forehead and cheeks. He wears a thoroughly soaked gray cotton T-shirt, tightly clung to his chest and abdomen, emphasizing his muscular physique. In a swift, turning, blocking motion, beads of sweat flung from their arms, hair, and cheeks. Under the harsh, single, cold light source from above, these splattering beads of sweat are momentarily illuminated, like countless tiny, shimmering crystals, drawing fleeting, bright arcs against the dim, rough concrete basement backdrop behind them. The entire scene is painted in a cool tone, dominated by the gray of concrete and the natural tones of the skin. The contrast between light and shadow is extremely strong, creating a primitive, tense and powerful fighting atmosphere.", + "seed": 26294, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_12/index_5920_seed_26294_dp_25_rank_50_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.19330539479851722, + "vlm_logprob": -0.19330539479851722, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.375, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.19330539479851722, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two Asian men visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man in the foreground shirtless with short, sweat-soaked black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the other man wearing a thoroughly soaked gray cotton T-shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dim, rough concrete basement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a dynamic, low-angle, handheld camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14355851709842682 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0185585021972656 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14355851709842682, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14355851709842682, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18950387835502625, + 0.11483904719352722, + 0.08351338654756546, + 0.15751704573631287, + 0.08122578263282776, + 0.07960671931505203, + 0.10641846805810928, + 0.034779131412506104, + 0.040528882294893265, + 0.11206766963005066 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14355851709842682 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two Asian men visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man in the foreground shirtless with short, sweat-soaked black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the other man wearing a thoroughly soaked gray cotton T-shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dim, rough concrete basement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a dynamic, low-angle, handheld camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012559957802295685 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.38755989074707 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012559957802295685, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012559957802295685, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18606770038604736, + 0.26237767934799194, + 0.0562768392264843, + 0.11977886408567429, + 0.06211482360959053, + 0.03777408227324486, + 0.05971207469701767, + 0.022812167182564735, + 0.04879341647028923, + 0.14429232478141785 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012559957802295685 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two Asian men visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man in the foreground shirtless with short, sweat-soaked black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the other man wearing a thoroughly soaked gray cotton T-shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dim, rough concrete basement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a dynamic, low-angle, handheld camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06206654757261276 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120665550231934 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06206654757261276, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06206654757261276, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13661442697048187, + 0.3545466661453247, + 0.06518562138080597, + 0.0590493343770504, + 0.09139000624418259, + 0.057216085493564606, + 0.04133208841085434, + 0.025495411828160286, + 0.10443272441625595, + 0.06473766267299652 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06206654757261276 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two Asian men visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man in the foreground shirtless with short, sweat-soaked black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the other man wearing a thoroughly soaked gray cotton T-shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dim, rough concrete basement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a dynamic, low-angle, handheld camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6933839321136475 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6933839321136475 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.6933839321136475, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.6933839321136475, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1511612832546234, + 0.06728863716125488, + 0.09872332215309143, + 0.18324418365955353, + 0.04625581204891205, + 0.1491542011499405, + 0.10010553896427155, + 0.0555403009057045, + 0.02646823227405548, + 0.12205850332975388 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.6933839321136475 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two Asian men visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man in the foreground shirtless with short, sweat-soaked black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the other man wearing a thoroughly soaked gray cotton T-shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dim, rough concrete basement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a dynamic, low-angle, handheld camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05495801940560341 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299581050872803 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05495801940560341, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05495801940560341, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1173408105969429, + 0.06812339276075363, + 0.0840185284614563, + 0.13338764011859894, + 0.07118120044469833, + 0.11535362154245377, + 0.08027227222919464, + 0.04487956315279007, + 0.05747603252530098, + 0.2279670089483261 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05495801940560341 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dynamic, low-angle, handheld shot closely follows two Asian men engaged in a fierce exchange, the camera panning with their movements to create an immersive sense of chaos. The man in the foreground, with short, sweat-soaked black hair plastered to his scalp, is shirtless, revealing a chiseled, taut back and shoulders, each muscle trembling with exertion. The other man, facing the camera, has slightly longer, tangled black hair, with a few wet strands clinging to his forehead and cheeks. He wears a thoroughly soaked gray cotton T-shirt, tightly clung to his chest and abdomen, emphasizing his muscular physique. In a swift, turning, blocking motion, beads of sweat flung from their arms, hair, and cheeks. Under the harsh, single, cold light source from above, these splattering beads of sweat are momentarily illuminated, like countless tiny, shimmering crystals, drawing fleeting, bright arcs against the dim, rough concrete basement backdrop behind them. The entire scene is painted in a cool tone, dominated by the gray of concrete and the natural tones of the skin. The contrast between light and shadow is extremely strong, creating a primitive, tense and powerful fighting atmosphere.", + "seed": 26295, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_12/index_5920_seed_26295_dp_25_rank_50_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.07870985195040703, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07870985195040703, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.025, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07870985195040703, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two Asian men visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man in the foreground shirtless with short, sweat-soaked black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the other man wearing a thoroughly soaked gray cotton T-shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dim, rough concrete basement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a dynamic, low-angle, handheld camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04920703545212746 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0492069721221924 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04920703545212746, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04920703545212746, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.197573721408844, + 0.05175982415676117, + 0.09565774351358414, + 0.27726686000823975, + 0.05851896107196808, + 0.05033915117383003, + 0.11602280288934708, + 0.06861812621355057, + 0.05541136488318443, + 0.028831474483013153 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04920703545212746 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two Asian men visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man in the foreground shirtless with short, sweat-soaked black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the other man wearing a thoroughly soaked gray cotton T-shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dim, rough concrete basement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a dynamic, low-angle, handheld camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011087238788604736 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511087417602539 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011087238788604736, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011087238788604736, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.44279754161834717, + 0.04164266958832741, + 0.049583058804273605, + 0.20860566198825836, + 0.04095885530114174, + 0.021202100440859795, + 0.05158461630344391, + 0.07171402871608734, + 0.038926415145397186, + 0.032985057681798935 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011087238788604736 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two Asian men visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man in the foreground shirtless with short, sweat-soaked black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the other man wearing a thoroughly soaked gray cotton T-shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dim, rough concrete basement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a dynamic, low-angle, handheld camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04306408390402794 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680641174316406 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04306408390402794, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04306408390402794, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21701247990131378, + 0.18494322896003723, + 0.04906892403960228, + 0.15500222146511078, + 0.08850106596946716, + 0.03952627256512642, + 0.11963360756635666, + 0.041572634130716324, + 0.042416661977767944, + 0.06232292577624321 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04306408390402794 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two Asian men visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man in the foreground shirtless with short, sweat-soaked black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the other man wearing a thoroughly soaked gray cotton T-shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dim, rough concrete basement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a dynamic, low-angle, handheld camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.25210174918174744 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5021017789840698 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.25210174918174744, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.25210174918174744, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2848193049430847, + 0.0323580801486969, + 0.017416872084140778, + 0.5360693335533142, + 0.015604324638843536, + 0.023607058450579643, + 0.0491541363298893, + 0.016125861555337906, + 0.006403286941349506, + 0.018441731110215187 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.25210174918174744 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two Asian men visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man in the foreground shirtless with short, sweat-soaked black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the other man wearing a thoroughly soaked gray cotton T-shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dim, rough concrete basement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a dynamic, low-angle, handheld camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03808915242552757 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2880890369415283 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03808915242552757, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03808915242552757, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1591915637254715, + 0.029697660356760025, + 0.043032046407461166, + 0.2458396852016449, + 0.14718739688396454, + 0.04569084569811821, + 0.17545777559280396, + 0.05826511234045029, + 0.0343109555542469, + 0.061326976865530014 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03808915242552757 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_13/index_tensor([8294, 8294])_group_13_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_13/index_tensor([8294, 8294])_group_13_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..85dc5ed807d8b8840f846cbba0c3bc9e691a1714 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_13/index_tensor([8294, 8294])_group_13_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "cinematic camera, shot from the side, smoothly pans, following an athletic young woman with warm olive skin as she rides a mountain bike at a moderate pace. Her dark brown hair, held in a high, tight ponytail, bounces with her movements. A bright, genuinely happy expression illuminates her face, her eyes crinkling at the corners as she smiles widely. She wears a vibrant, puffy winter coat with a glossy geometric pattern of turquoise, fuchsia, and yellow, and a sleek black tech backpack strapped to her back. Her legs, clad in dark athletic leggings, push the pedals with a steady, powerful rhythm, advancing along a narrow country road covered in a layer of crisp white snow that crunches softly beneath the knobby tires. On either side, sparse birch and pine forests are silhouetted against the twilight. The scene is bathed in the cool, ethereal light of dusk, the last rosy glow of sunset on the horizon casting long, soft blue shadows across the landscape, creating an atmosphere of quiet excitement and tranquil solitude.", + "seed": 4230, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_13/index_8294_seed_4230_dp_26_rank_52_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.03287387611344457, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03287387611344457, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.9, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03287387611344457, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an athletic young woman with warm olive skin riding a mountain bike?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a vibrant puffy winter coat with a glossy geometric pattern of turquoise, fuchsia, and yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman riding on a narrow country road covered in a layer of crisp white snow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of sparse birch and pine forests silhouetted against a twilight sky with a rosy sunset glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly pan from the side to follow the woman's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08395282179117203 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5839529037475586 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08395282179117203, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08395282179117203, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23529240489006042, + 0.13287223875522614, + 0.08725953847169876, + 0.04799788072705269, + 0.041424524039030075, + 0.11365097761154175, + 0.06015528365969658, + 0.11886346340179443, + 0.03288460895419121, + 0.12959909439086914 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08395282179117203 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an athletic young woman with warm olive skin riding a mountain bike?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a vibrant puffy winter coat with a glossy geometric pattern of turquoise, fuchsia, and yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman riding on a narrow country road covered in a layer of crisp white snow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of sparse birch and pine forests silhouetted against a twilight sky with a rosy sunset glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly pan from the side to follow the woman's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016089366748929024 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.14108943939209 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016089366748929024, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016089366748929024, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22565442323684692, + 0.15700605511665344, + 0.07001395523548126, + 0.0588444247841835, + 0.06436777114868164, + 0.13289184868335724, + 0.09442126750946045, + 0.08382510393857956, + 0.03216956928372383, + 0.08080561459064484 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016089366748929024 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an athletic young woman with warm olive skin riding a mountain bike?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a vibrant puffy winter coat with a glossy geometric pattern of turquoise, fuchsia, and yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman riding on a narrow country road covered in a layer of crisp white snow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of sparse birch and pine forests silhouetted against a twilight sky with a rosy sunset glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly pan from the side to follow the woman's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011070497334003448 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511070728302002 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011070497334003448, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011070497334003448, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18632005155086517, + 0.08295028656721115, + 0.08618735522031784, + 0.053825367242097855, + 0.14042790234088898, + 0.1319383978843689, + 0.18025803565979004, + 0.03269100561738014, + 0.056998979300260544, + 0.048402633517980576 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011070497334003448 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an athletic young woman with warm olive skin riding a mountain bike?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a vibrant puffy winter coat with a glossy geometric pattern of turquoise, fuchsia, and yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman riding on a narrow country road covered in a layer of crisp white snow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of sparse birch and pine forests silhouetted against a twilight sky with a rosy sunset glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly pan from the side to follow the woman's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004632574040442705 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379632472991943 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004632574040442705, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004632574040442705, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.35329246520996094, + 0.11727656424045563, + 0.07110271602869034, + 0.05403779447078705, + 0.06574290990829468, + 0.07177520543336868, + 0.06267672777175903, + 0.10034579783678055, + 0.05343800410628319, + 0.0503118522465229 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004632574040442705 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an athletic young woman with warm olive skin riding a mountain bike?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a vibrant puffy winter coat with a glossy geometric pattern of turquoise, fuchsia, and yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman riding on a narrow country road covered in a layer of crisp white snow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of sparse birch and pine forests silhouetted against a twilight sky with a rosy sunset glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly pan from the side to follow the woman's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04862412065267563 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048624038696289 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04862412065267563, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04862412065267563, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11500273644924164, + 0.11407829821109772, + 0.12362170219421387, + 0.07418181747198105, + 0.06998574733734131, + 0.08629902452230453, + 0.0393153540790081, + 0.2545296549797058, + 0.07209844142198563, + 0.050887271761894226 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04862412065267563 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "cinematic camera, shot from the side, smoothly pans, following an athletic young woman with warm olive skin as she rides a mountain bike at a moderate pace. Her dark brown hair, held in a high, tight ponytail, bounces with her movements. A bright, genuinely happy expression illuminates her face, her eyes crinkling at the corners as she smiles widely. She wears a vibrant, puffy winter coat with a glossy geometric pattern of turquoise, fuchsia, and yellow, and a sleek black tech backpack strapped to her back. Her legs, clad in dark athletic leggings, push the pedals with a steady, powerful rhythm, advancing along a narrow country road covered in a layer of crisp white snow that crunches softly beneath the knobby tires. On either side, sparse birch and pine forests are silhouetted against the twilight. The scene is bathed in the cool, ethereal light of dusk, the last rosy glow of sunset on the horizon casting long, soft blue shadows across the landscape, creating an atmosphere of quiet excitement and tranquil solitude.", + "seed": 4231, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_13/index_8294_seed_4231_dp_26_rank_52_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.06263511683791875, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06263511683791875, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.5, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06263511683791875, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an athletic young woman with warm olive skin riding a mountain bike?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a vibrant puffy winter coat with a glossy geometric pattern of turquoise, fuchsia, and yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman riding on a narrow country road covered in a layer of crisp white snow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of sparse birch and pine forests silhouetted against a twilight sky with a rosy sunset glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly pan from the side to follow the woman's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.208128422498703 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7081284523010254 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.208128422498703, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.208128422498703, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13831250369548798, + 0.09804211556911469, + 0.08713748306035995, + 0.11930584907531738, + 0.2316598892211914, + 0.03786090761423111, + 0.07110969722270966, + 0.03425050899386406, + 0.08062493801116943, + 0.10169609636068344 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.208128422498703 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an athletic young woman with warm olive skin riding a mountain bike?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a vibrant puffy winter coat with a glossy geometric pattern of turquoise, fuchsia, and yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman riding on a narrow country road covered in a layer of crisp white snow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of sparse birch and pine forests silhouetted against a twilight sky with a rosy sunset glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly pan from the side to follow the woman's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014216690324246883 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264216899871826 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014216690324246883, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014216690324246883, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09058287739753723, + 0.11411771178245544, + 0.3880847692489624, + 0.12172006815671921, + 0.12429880350828171, + 0.02684837393462658, + 0.03934387117624283, + 0.026125984266400337, + 0.02511935494840145, + 0.04375817999243736 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014216690324246883 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an athletic young woman with warm olive skin riding a mountain bike?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a vibrant puffy winter coat with a glossy geometric pattern of turquoise, fuchsia, and yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman riding on a narrow country road covered in a layer of crisp white snow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of sparse birch and pine forests silhouetted against a twilight sky with a rosy sunset glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly pan from the side to follow the woman's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011069318279623985 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511069297790527 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011069318279623985, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011069318279623985, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2581283152103424, + 0.0462505929172039, + 0.12385225296020508, + 0.2220078706741333, + 0.13787700235843658, + 0.06146853417158127, + 0.05301442742347717, + 0.03845933824777603, + 0.025948304682970047, + 0.032993391156196594 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011069318279623985 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an athletic young woman with warm olive skin riding a mountain bike?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a vibrant puffy winter coat with a glossy geometric pattern of turquoise, fuchsia, and yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman riding on a narrow country road covered in a layer of crisp white snow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of sparse birch and pine forests silhouetted against a twilight sky with a rosy sunset glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly pan from the side to follow the woman's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009776568040251732 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634776592254639 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009776568040251732, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009776568040251732, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18732525408267975, + 0.046623263508081436, + 0.2838369607925415, + 0.1777811497449875, + 0.08967859297990799, + 0.048264652490615845, + 0.033336393535137177, + 0.05079761520028114, + 0.04702985659241676, + 0.03532624989748001 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009776568040251732 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an athletic young woman with warm olive skin riding a mountain bike?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a vibrant puffy winter coat with a glossy geometric pattern of turquoise, fuchsia, and yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman riding on a narrow country road covered in a layer of crisp white snow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of sparse birch and pine forests silhouetted against a twilight sky with a rosy sunset glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly pan from the side to follow the woman's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06998458504676819 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6949846744537354 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06998458504676819, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06998458504676819, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11135774105787277, + 0.08081292361021042, + 0.333248496055603, + 0.10353503376245499, + 0.1686311513185501, + 0.05444786697626114, + 0.042753253132104874, + 0.035721588879823685, + 0.021265525370836258, + 0.04822641238570213 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06998458504676819 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "cinematic camera, shot from the side, smoothly pans, following an athletic young woman with warm olive skin as she rides a mountain bike at a moderate pace. Her dark brown hair, held in a high, tight ponytail, bounces with her movements. A bright, genuinely happy expression illuminates her face, her eyes crinkling at the corners as she smiles widely. She wears a vibrant, puffy winter coat with a glossy geometric pattern of turquoise, fuchsia, and yellow, and a sleek black tech backpack strapped to her back. Her legs, clad in dark athletic leggings, push the pedals with a steady, powerful rhythm, advancing along a narrow country road covered in a layer of crisp white snow that crunches softly beneath the knobby tires. On either side, sparse birch and pine forests are silhouetted against the twilight. The scene is bathed in the cool, ethereal light of dusk, the last rosy glow of sunset on the horizon casting long, soft blue shadows across the landscape, creating an atmosphere of quiet excitement and tranquil solitude.", + "seed": 4232, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_13/index_8294_seed_4232_dp_27_rank_54_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.05044855363667011, + "vlm_logprob": -0.05044855363667011, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.475, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.05044855363667011, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an athletic young woman with warm olive skin riding a mountain bike?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a vibrant puffy winter coat with a glossy geometric pattern of turquoise, fuchsia, and yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman riding on a narrow country road covered in a layer of crisp white snow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of sparse birch and pine forests silhouetted against a twilight sky with a rosy sunset glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly pan from the side to follow the woman's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16506735980510712 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9150673151016235 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16506735980510712, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16506735980510712, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16813918948173523, + 0.04954048618674278, + 0.07003713399171829, + 0.06273587048053741, + 0.5264685153961182, + 0.02603640966117382, + 0.021532058715820312, + 0.01213487982749939, + 0.013725688681006432, + 0.04964979737997055 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16506735980510712 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an athletic young woman with warm olive skin riding a mountain bike?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a vibrant puffy winter coat with a glossy geometric pattern of turquoise, fuchsia, and yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman riding on a narrow country road covered in a layer of crisp white snow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of sparse birch and pine forests silhouetted against a twilight sky with a rosy sunset glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly pan from the side to follow the woman's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016089484095573425 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.14108943939209 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016089484095573425, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016089484095573425, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.31600815057754517, + 0.08180329948663712, + 0.07054856419563293, + 0.06091941520571709, + 0.23520225286483765, + 0.05498141050338745, + 0.03350817412137985, + 0.01997373066842556, + 0.049066439270973206, + 0.07798855751752853 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016089484095573425 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an athletic young woman with warm olive skin riding a mountain bike?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a vibrant puffy winter coat with a glossy geometric pattern of turquoise, fuchsia, and yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman riding on a narrow country road covered in a layer of crisp white snow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of sparse birch and pine forests silhouetted against a twilight sky with a rosy sunset glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly pan from the side to follow the woman's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02633899636566639 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651339054107666 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02633899636566639, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02633899636566639, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1360650509595871, + 0.09962038695812225, + 0.12091919779777527, + 0.05695302039384842, + 0.29992014169692993, + 0.055203620344400406, + 0.07152223587036133, + 0.01484172884374857, + 0.020877758041024208, + 0.12407677620649338 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02633899636566639 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an athletic young woman with warm olive skin riding a mountain bike?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a vibrant puffy winter coat with a glossy geometric pattern of turquoise, fuchsia, and yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman riding on a narrow country road covered in a layer of crisp white snow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of sparse birch and pine forests silhouetted against a twilight sky with a rosy sunset glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly pan from the side to follow the woman's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011070497334003448 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511070728302002 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011070497334003448, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011070497334003448, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1651291698217392, + 0.13519415259361267, + 0.10290473699569702, + 0.02333134226500988, + 0.3587389290332794, + 0.062782883644104, + 0.04419318214058876, + 0.023301206529140472, + 0.018207114189863205, + 0.06621728092432022 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011070497334003448 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an athletic young woman with warm olive skin riding a mountain bike?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a vibrant puffy winter coat with a glossy geometric pattern of turquoise, fuchsia, and yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman riding on a narrow country road covered in a layer of crisp white snow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of sparse birch and pine forests silhouetted against a twilight sky with a rosy sunset glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly pan from the side to follow the woman's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03367643058300018 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4086763858795166 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03367643058300018, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03367643058300018, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24544040858745575, + 0.11089843511581421, + 0.093153215944767, + 0.11784222722053528, + 0.07405207306146622, + 0.10853857547044754, + 0.0463404655456543, + 0.03372972458600998, + 0.06585047394037247, + 0.10415435582399368 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03367643058300018 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "cinematic camera, shot from the side, smoothly pans, following an athletic young woman with warm olive skin as she rides a mountain bike at a moderate pace. Her dark brown hair, held in a high, tight ponytail, bounces with her movements. A bright, genuinely happy expression illuminates her face, her eyes crinkling at the corners as she smiles widely. She wears a vibrant, puffy winter coat with a glossy geometric pattern of turquoise, fuchsia, and yellow, and a sleek black tech backpack strapped to her back. Her legs, clad in dark athletic leggings, push the pedals with a steady, powerful rhythm, advancing along a narrow country road covered in a layer of crisp white snow that crunches softly beneath the knobby tires. On either side, sparse birch and pine forests are silhouetted against the twilight. The scene is bathed in the cool, ethereal light of dusk, the last rosy glow of sunset on the horizon casting long, soft blue shadows across the landscape, creating an atmosphere of quiet excitement and tranquil solitude.", + "seed": 4233, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_13/index_8294_seed_4233_dp_27_rank_54_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.018103044107556344, + "vlm_logprob": -0.018103044107556344, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.375, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.018103044107556344, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an athletic young woman with warm olive skin riding a mountain bike?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a vibrant puffy winter coat with a glossy geometric pattern of turquoise, fuchsia, and yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman riding on a narrow country road covered in a layer of crisp white snow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of sparse birch and pine forests silhouetted against a twilight sky with a rosy sunset glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly pan from the side to follow the woman's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04052264988422394 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.290522575378418 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04052264988422394, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04052264988422394, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.031065665185451508, + 0.9210971593856812, + 0.0057409158907830715, + 0.007746613118797541, + 0.004745095502585173, + 0.007847811095416546, + 0.004162031691521406, + 0.0037378326524049044, + 0.0046630860306322575, + 0.009193831123411655 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04052264988422394 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an athletic young woman with warm olive skin riding a mountain bike?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a vibrant puffy winter coat with a glossy geometric pattern of turquoise, fuchsia, and yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman riding on a narrow country road covered in a layer of crisp white snow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of sparse birch and pine forests silhouetted against a twilight sky with a rosy sunset glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly pan from the side to follow the woman's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01108440849930048 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.51108455657959 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01108440849930048, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01108440849930048, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.035817742347717285, + 0.8432220220565796, + 0.009195277467370033, + 0.009577390737831593, + 0.017365967854857445, + 0.02706267312169075, + 0.0064915926195681095, + 0.008514737710356712, + 0.012655215337872505, + 0.03009740449488163 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01108440849930048 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an athletic young woman with warm olive skin riding a mountain bike?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a vibrant puffy winter coat with a glossy geometric pattern of turquoise, fuchsia, and yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman riding on a narrow country road covered in a layer of crisp white snow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of sparse birch and pine forests silhouetted against a twilight sky with a rosy sunset glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly pan from the side to follow the woman's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009772907942533493 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634772777557373 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009772907942533493, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009772907942533493, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.011072483845055103, + 0.9299229979515076, + 0.005633808206766844, + 0.0029475283809006214, + 0.004393582697957754, + 0.007441050373017788, + 0.0013559787767007947, + 0.004419996868818998, + 0.01711546629667282, + 0.015697192400693893 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009772907942533493 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an athletic young woman with warm olive skin riding a mountain bike?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a vibrant puffy winter coat with a glossy geometric pattern of turquoise, fuchsia, and yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman riding on a narrow country road covered in a layer of crisp white snow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of sparse birch and pine forests silhouetted against a twilight sky with a rosy sunset glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly pan from the side to follow the woman's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0028139064088463783 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877813816070557 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0028139064088463783, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0028139064088463783, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08219258487224579, + 0.6518412828445435, + 0.03415951132774353, + 0.011333632282912731, + 0.022534873336553574, + 0.03235037252306938, + 0.04662860929965973, + 0.04717158153653145, + 0.05215214192867279, + 0.01963534578680992 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0028139064088463783 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an athletic young woman with warm olive skin riding a mountain bike?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a vibrant puffy winter coat with a glossy geometric pattern of turquoise, fuchsia, and yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman riding on a narrow country road covered in a layer of crisp white snow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of sparse birch and pine forests silhouetted against a twilight sky with a rosy sunset glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly pan from the side to follow the woman's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026321347802877426 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513214111328125 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026321347802877426, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026321347802877426, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05635809898376465, + 0.8076627850532532, + 0.017889738082885742, + 0.035956986248493195, + 0.017193352803587914, + 0.011048813350498676, + 0.011089950799942017, + 0.011077026836574078, + 0.01569673791527748, + 0.016026536002755165 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026321347802877426 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_14/index_tensor([1677, 1677])_group_14_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_14/index_tensor([1677, 1677])_group_14_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..ff782c64ef8a0625340bfc00e726179ce0849ebf --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_14/index_tensor([1677, 1677])_group_14_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "sweeping aerial shot slowly pans right, following a majestic Chinese dragon as it soars through mountains etched with the rich aesthetic of an ink wash painting. The dragon boasts a slender, sinuous body, covered in pearly, turquoise scales, each one sharply defined. A fiery crimson mane stretches from head to tail, striking against the austere backdrop. Its head is majestic, its antlers protruding, its amber eyes gleaming with wisdom and majesty, its long whiskers flowing gracefully in the air. It rises and falls in a powerful and rhythmic manner, its powerful claws folding and unfurling as its body stretches. Its massive tail traces a graceful arc behind it, its every movement seemingly stirring the air currents between heaven and earth, causing the surrounding clouds to swirl and disperse. The background is a continuous expanse of towering peaks, rendered in varying shades of ink. Nearby peaks are sharply defined, their ink rich, with a few ancient pines dotting the cliffs. Distant peaks gradually fade into a hazy mist of ethereal light ink and vast expanses of white. The dragon's form occasionally appears and disappears within the clouds, creating a profound sense of space. The dominant tones of the painting are classic black, white, and gray. The light, rather than originating from a single source, seems to permeate the rice paper itself, creating an even and soft radiance. The green of the dragon's body and the crimson of its mane, the only bright colors in the image, are subtly saturated yet profoundly charged, creating a visual epic that is both sacred and majestic, yet imbued with the tranquility and power of Eastern philosophy.", + "seed": 12895, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_14/index_1677_seed_12895_dp_28_rank_56_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.047447682823985815, + "vlm_logprob": -0.047447682823985815, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.25, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.047447682823985815, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Chinese dragon with a slender, sinuous body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the dragon's scales pearly and turquoise, and is its mane fiery crimson?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the dragon exhibit specific features including antlers, amber eyes, and long whiskers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style an ink wash painting with black, white, and gray tones, featuring mountains and ancient pines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a sweeping aerial shot that slowly pans right following the dragon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005817624274641275 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.380817413330078 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005817624274641275, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005817624274641275, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21462282538414001, + 0.06491868197917938, + 0.043081264942884445, + 0.03459283336997032, + 0.03665109723806381, + 0.0856785997748375, + 0.2840449810028076, + 0.14559406042099, + 0.04396616667509079, + 0.046849481761455536 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005817624274641275 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Chinese dragon with a slender, sinuous body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the dragon's scales pearly and turquoise, and is its mane fiery crimson?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the dragon exhibit specific features including antlers, amber eyes, and long whiskers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style an ink wash painting with black, white, and gray tones, featuring mountains and ancient pines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a sweeping aerial shot that slowly pans right following the dragon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007639123592525721 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882638931274414 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007639123592525721, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007639123592525721, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1949312537908554, + 0.08902333676815033, + 0.07308731973171234, + 0.031294699758291245, + 0.10652314871549606, + 0.08452022075653076, + 0.20406337082386017, + 0.12279142439365387, + 0.02995467558503151, + 0.06381059437990189 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007639123592525721 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Chinese dragon with a slender, sinuous body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the dragon's scales pearly and turquoise, and is its mane fiery crimson?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the dragon exhibit specific features including antlers, amber eyes, and long whiskers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style an ink wash painting with black, white, and gray tones, featuring mountains and ancient pines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a sweeping aerial shot that slowly pans right following the dragon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018195264041423798 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018195152282715 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018195264041423798, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018195264041423798, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22618523240089417, + 0.08443503826856613, + 0.07716094702482224, + 0.038193732500076294, + 0.10407264530658722, + 0.0792289599776268, + 0.12943224608898163, + 0.16180260479450226, + 0.05131441727280617, + 0.04817415401339531 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018195264041423798 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Chinese dragon with a slender, sinuous body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the dragon's scales pearly and turquoise, and is its mane fiery crimson?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the dragon exhibit specific features including antlers, amber eyes, and long whiskers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style an ink wash painting with black, white, and gray tones, featuring mountains and ancient pines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a sweeping aerial shot that slowly pans right following the dragon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004090039525181055 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504089832305908 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004090039525181055, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004090039525181055, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1958458125591278, + 0.18743889033794403, + 0.04332387447357178, + 0.03476472198963165, + 0.06022324040532112, + 0.25196385383605957, + 0.10396110266447067, + 0.03513752296566963, + 0.03819265589118004, + 0.0491483174264431 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004090039525181055 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Chinese dragon with a slender, sinuous body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the dragon's scales pearly and turquoise, and is its mane fiery crimson?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the dragon exhibit specific features including antlers, amber eyes, and long whiskers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style an ink wash painting with black, white, and gray tones, featuring mountains and ancient pines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a sweeping aerial shot that slowly pans right following the dragon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20149636268615723 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7014963626861572 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20149636268615723, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20149636268615723, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09766530990600586, + 0.03452526777982712, + 0.02418430894613266, + 0.0915454775094986, + 0.11462564766407013, + 0.061703115701675415, + 0.14044128358364105, + 0.1567220389842987, + 0.22615733742713928, + 0.05243014544248581 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20149636268615723 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "sweeping aerial shot slowly pans right, following a majestic Chinese dragon as it soars through mountains etched with the rich aesthetic of an ink wash painting. The dragon boasts a slender, sinuous body, covered in pearly, turquoise scales, each one sharply defined. A fiery crimson mane stretches from head to tail, striking against the austere backdrop. Its head is majestic, its antlers protruding, its amber eyes gleaming with wisdom and majesty, its long whiskers flowing gracefully in the air. It rises and falls in a powerful and rhythmic manner, its powerful claws folding and unfurling as its body stretches. Its massive tail traces a graceful arc behind it, its every movement seemingly stirring the air currents between heaven and earth, causing the surrounding clouds to swirl and disperse. The background is a continuous expanse of towering peaks, rendered in varying shades of ink. Nearby peaks are sharply defined, their ink rich, with a few ancient pines dotting the cliffs. Distant peaks gradually fade into a hazy mist of ethereal light ink and vast expanses of white. The dragon's form occasionally appears and disappears within the clouds, creating a profound sense of space. The dominant tones of the painting are classic black, white, and gray. The light, rather than originating from a single source, seems to permeate the rice paper itself, creating an even and soft radiance. The green of the dragon's body and the crimson of its mane, the only bright colors in the image, are subtly saturated yet profoundly charged, creating a visual epic that is both sacred and majestic, yet imbued with the tranquility and power of Eastern philosophy.", + "seed": 12896, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_14/index_1677_seed_12896_dp_28_rank_56_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.02794757247902453, + "vlm_logprob": -0.02794757247902453, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.025, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.02794757247902453, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Chinese dragon with a slender, sinuous body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the dragon's scales pearly and turquoise, and is its mane fiery crimson?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the dragon exhibit specific features including antlers, amber eyes, and long whiskers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style an ink wash painting with black, white, and gray tones, featuring mountains and ancient pines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a sweeping aerial shot that slowly pans right following the dragon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026980996131896973 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6519808769226074 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026980996131896973, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026980996131896973, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13822920620441437, + 0.08698102086782455, + 0.09580020606517792, + 0.0681455209851265, + 0.21456573903560638, + 0.033574726432561874, + 0.1240086629986763, + 0.10060782730579376, + 0.08116471022367477, + 0.056922417134046555 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026980996131896973 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Chinese dragon with a slender, sinuous body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the dragon's scales pearly and turquoise, and is its mane fiery crimson?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the dragon exhibit specific features including antlers, amber eyes, and long whiskers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style an ink wash painting with black, white, and gray tones, featuring mountains and ancient pines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a sweeping aerial shot that slowly pans right following the dragon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03812151402235031 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288121461868286 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03812151402235031, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03812151402235031, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14909058809280396, + 0.1028892993927002, + 0.08963354676961899, + 0.07675657421350479, + 0.15031591057777405, + 0.07916652411222458, + 0.11634314060211182, + 0.12505239248275757, + 0.06410252302885056, + 0.046649545431137085 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03812151402235031 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Chinese dragon with a slender, sinuous body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the dragon's scales pearly and turquoise, and is its mane fiery crimson?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the dragon exhibit specific features including antlers, amber eyes, and long whiskers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style an ink wash painting with black, white, and gray tones, featuring mountains and ancient pines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a sweeping aerial shot that slowly pans right following the dragon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009795455262064934 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634795665740967 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009795455262064934, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009795455262064934, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18596850335597992, + 0.07626054435968399, + 0.1261511892080307, + 0.049078743904829025, + 0.09102551639080048, + 0.056458331644535065, + 0.07314992696046829, + 0.1064840778708458, + 0.1683475524187088, + 0.06707557290792465 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009795455262064934 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Chinese dragon with a slender, sinuous body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the dragon's scales pearly and turquoise, and is its mane fiery crimson?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the dragon exhibit specific features including antlers, amber eyes, and long whiskers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style an ink wash painting with black, white, and gray tones, featuring mountains and ancient pines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a sweeping aerial shot that slowly pans right following the dragon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0028178293723613024 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877817630767822 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0028178293723613024, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0028178293723613024, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15571221709251404, + 0.08048957586288452, + 0.08106261491775513, + 0.040538229048252106, + 0.10258464515209198, + 0.1054961234331131, + 0.06443047523498535, + 0.13236120343208313, + 0.1323791891336441, + 0.10494576394557953 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0028178293723613024 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Chinese dragon with a slender, sinuous body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the dragon's scales pearly and turquoise, and is its mane fiery crimson?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the dragon exhibit specific features including antlers, amber eyes, and long whiskers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style an ink wash painting with black, white, and gray tones, featuring mountains and ancient pines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a sweeping aerial shot that slowly pans right following the dragon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06202206760644913 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120219707489014 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06202206760644913, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06202206760644913, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19756712019443512, + 0.08113952726125717, + 0.1484198272228241, + 0.11768174171447754, + 0.04558585584163666, + 0.051886580884456635, + 0.048551928251981735, + 0.09744774550199509, + 0.11974982172250748, + 0.09196984767913818 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06202206760644913 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "sweeping aerial shot slowly pans right, following a majestic Chinese dragon as it soars through mountains etched with the rich aesthetic of an ink wash painting. The dragon boasts a slender, sinuous body, covered in pearly, turquoise scales, each one sharply defined. A fiery crimson mane stretches from head to tail, striking against the austere backdrop. Its head is majestic, its antlers protruding, its amber eyes gleaming with wisdom and majesty, its long whiskers flowing gracefully in the air. It rises and falls in a powerful and rhythmic manner, its powerful claws folding and unfurling as its body stretches. Its massive tail traces a graceful arc behind it, its every movement seemingly stirring the air currents between heaven and earth, causing the surrounding clouds to swirl and disperse. The background is a continuous expanse of towering peaks, rendered in varying shades of ink. Nearby peaks are sharply defined, their ink rich, with a few ancient pines dotting the cliffs. Distant peaks gradually fade into a hazy mist of ethereal light ink and vast expanses of white. The dragon's form occasionally appears and disappears within the clouds, creating a profound sense of space. The dominant tones of the painting are classic black, white, and gray. The light, rather than originating from a single source, seems to permeate the rice paper itself, creating an even and soft radiance. The green of the dragon's body and the crimson of its mane, the only bright colors in the image, are subtly saturated yet profoundly charged, creating a visual epic that is both sacred and majestic, yet imbued with the tranquility and power of Eastern philosophy.", + "seed": 12897, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_14/index_1677_seed_12897_dp_29_rank_58_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.028467719280160963, + "vlm_logprob": -0.028467719280160963, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.65, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.028467719280160963, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Chinese dragon with a slender, sinuous body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the dragon's scales pearly and turquoise, and is its mane fiery crimson?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the dragon exhibit specific features including antlers, amber eyes, and long whiskers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style an ink wash painting with black, white, and gray tones, featuring mountains and ancient pines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a sweeping aerial shot that slowly pans right following the dragon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005553887225687504 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255553722381592 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005553887225687504, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005553887225687504, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11399944871664047, + 0.05577975884079933, + 0.05780087411403656, + 0.05394977331161499, + 0.19324907660484314, + 0.22165369987487793, + 0.08594059944152832, + 0.06124250218272209, + 0.07071186602115631, + 0.08567237854003906 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005553887225687504 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Chinese dragon with a slender, sinuous body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the dragon's scales pearly and turquoise, and is its mane fiery crimson?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the dragon exhibit specific features including antlers, amber eyes, and long whiskers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style an ink wash painting with black, white, and gray tones, featuring mountains and ancient pines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a sweeping aerial shot that slowly pans right following the dragon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008648676797747612 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758648872375488 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008648676797747612, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008648676797747612, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12200159579515457, + 0.06801605969667435, + 0.10247040539979935, + 0.06289566308259964, + 0.10944338142871857, + 0.1360670030117035, + 0.22184497117996216, + 0.08675236999988556, + 0.043830372393131256, + 0.046678245067596436 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008648676797747612 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Chinese dragon with a slender, sinuous body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the dragon's scales pearly and turquoise, and is its mane fiery crimson?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the dragon exhibit specific features including antlers, amber eyes, and long whiskers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style an ink wash painting with black, white, and gray tones, featuring mountains and ancient pines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a sweeping aerial shot that slowly pans right following the dragon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014206347987055779 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264206409454346 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014206347987055779, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014206347987055779, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1018841341137886, + 0.0485951192677021, + 0.04429223760962486, + 0.09737315773963928, + 0.21931692957878113, + 0.21071478724479675, + 0.09464608877897263, + 0.03742113336920738, + 0.06634053587913513, + 0.07941590249538422 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014206347987055779 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Chinese dragon with a slender, sinuous body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the dragon's scales pearly and turquoise, and is its mane fiery crimson?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the dragon exhibit specific features including antlers, amber eyes, and long whiskers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style an ink wash painting with black, white, and gray tones, featuring mountains and ancient pines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a sweeping aerial shot that slowly pans right following the dragon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0010400369064882398 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.876039981842041 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0010400369064882398, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0010400369064882398, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14605499804019928, + 0.06015690788626671, + 0.05403033271431923, + 0.028669556602835655, + 0.21136029064655304, + 0.1849808394908905, + 0.0748962014913559, + 0.06832626461982727, + 0.09306870400905609, + 0.07845590263605118 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0010400369064882398 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Chinese dragon with a slender, sinuous body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the dragon's scales pearly and turquoise, and is its mane fiery crimson?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the dragon exhibit specific features including antlers, amber eyes, and long whiskers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style an ink wash painting with black, white, and gray tones, featuring mountains and ancient pines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a sweeping aerial shot that slowly pans right following the dragon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11288964748382568 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2378897666931152 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11288964748382568, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11288964748382568, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10333780944347382, + 0.056320253759622574, + 0.045753855258226395, + 0.13000035285949707, + 0.1576147973537445, + 0.18356551229953766, + 0.15140537917613983, + 0.04791431501507759, + 0.054301369935274124, + 0.06978630274534225 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11288964748382568 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "sweeping aerial shot slowly pans right, following a majestic Chinese dragon as it soars through mountains etched with the rich aesthetic of an ink wash painting. The dragon boasts a slender, sinuous body, covered in pearly, turquoise scales, each one sharply defined. A fiery crimson mane stretches from head to tail, striking against the austere backdrop. Its head is majestic, its antlers protruding, its amber eyes gleaming with wisdom and majesty, its long whiskers flowing gracefully in the air. It rises and falls in a powerful and rhythmic manner, its powerful claws folding and unfurling as its body stretches. Its massive tail traces a graceful arc behind it, its every movement seemingly stirring the air currents between heaven and earth, causing the surrounding clouds to swirl and disperse. The background is a continuous expanse of towering peaks, rendered in varying shades of ink. Nearby peaks are sharply defined, their ink rich, with a few ancient pines dotting the cliffs. Distant peaks gradually fade into a hazy mist of ethereal light ink and vast expanses of white. The dragon's form occasionally appears and disappears within the clouds, creating a profound sense of space. The dominant tones of the painting are classic black, white, and gray. The light, rather than originating from a single source, seems to permeate the rice paper itself, creating an even and soft radiance. The green of the dragon's body and the crimson of its mane, the only bright colors in the image, are subtly saturated yet profoundly charged, creating a visual epic that is both sacred and majestic, yet imbued with the tranquility and power of Eastern philosophy.", + "seed": 12898, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_14/index_1677_seed_12898_dp_29_rank_58_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.018059385241940618, + "vlm_logprob": -0.018059385241940618, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.7, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.018059385241940618, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Chinese dragon with a slender, sinuous body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the dragon's scales pearly and turquoise, and is its mane fiery crimson?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the dragon exhibit specific features including antlers, amber eyes, and long whiskers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style an ink wash painting with black, white, and gray tones, featuring mountains and ancient pines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a sweeping aerial shot that slowly pans right following the dragon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00331234117038548 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.878312110900879 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00331234117038548, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00331234117038548, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.059106793254613876, + 0.061022691428661346, + 0.05636901408433914, + 0.07171742618083954, + 0.1085369810461998, + 0.04321223497390747, + 0.11469237506389618, + 0.3229736387729645, + 0.04838956519961357, + 0.113979272544384 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00331234117038548 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Chinese dragon with a slender, sinuous body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the dragon's scales pearly and turquoise, and is its mane fiery crimson?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the dragon exhibit specific features including antlers, amber eyes, and long whiskers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style an ink wash painting with black, white, and gray tones, featuring mountains and ancient pines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a sweeping aerial shot that slowly pans right following the dragon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011082522571086884 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511082649230957 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011082522571086884, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011082522571086884, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.037050679326057434, + 0.05810939893126488, + 0.08438798040151596, + 0.06396893411874771, + 0.10981672257184982, + 0.06616441160440445, + 0.05832787975668907, + 0.17872078716754913, + 0.04032229259610176, + 0.30313095450401306 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011082522571086884 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Chinese dragon with a slender, sinuous body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the dragon's scales pearly and turquoise, and is its mane fiery crimson?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the dragon exhibit specific features including antlers, amber eyes, and long whiskers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style an ink wash painting with black, white, and gray tones, featuring mountains and ancient pines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a sweeping aerial shot that slowly pans right following the dragon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01107827853411436 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511078357696533 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01107827853411436, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01107827853411436, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08223021775484085, + 0.06253324449062347, + 0.07580842822790146, + 0.04313795268535614, + 0.0598728321492672, + 0.07374881207942963, + 0.08235694468021393, + 0.3584881126880646, + 0.033333294093608856, + 0.12849022448062897 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01107827853411436 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Chinese dragon with a slender, sinuous body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the dragon's scales pearly and turquoise, and is its mane fiery crimson?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the dragon exhibit specific features including antlers, amber eyes, and long whiskers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style an ink wash painting with black, white, and gray tones, featuring mountains and ancient pines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a sweeping aerial shot that slowly pans right following the dragon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002814263105392456 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877814292907715 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002814263105392456, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002814263105392456, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.019245823845267296, + 0.029177747666835785, + 0.019550563767552376, + 0.03515729308128357, + 0.03217814117670059, + 0.07233548909425735, + 0.04432471841573715, + 0.4709568917751312, + 0.03819781169295311, + 0.23887547850608826 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002814263105392456 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Chinese dragon with a slender, sinuous body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the dragon's scales pearly and turquoise, and is its mane fiery crimson?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the dragon exhibit specific features including antlers, amber eyes, and long whiskers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style an ink wash painting with black, white, and gray tones, featuring mountains and ancient pines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a sweeping aerial shot that slowly pans right following the dragon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06200952082872391 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812009572982788 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06200952082872391, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06200952082872391, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0834963247179985, + 0.06264152377843857, + 0.034456584602594376, + 0.047934580594301224, + 0.03384681046009064, + 0.050244785845279694, + 0.10041021555662155, + 0.10574971139431, + 0.13318315148353577, + 0.34803634881973267 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06200952082872391 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_15/index_tensor([5480, 5480])_group_15_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_15/index_tensor([5480, 5480])_group_15_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..666ad26ce652cc1452d3fa34851fff7386a7f96d --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_15/index_tensor([5480, 5480])_group_15_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "An extreme macro, low-angle shot, captured in dramatic, high-speed slow motion, unfolds with a slow, almost imperceptible progression into a monumental conflict. Two black garden ants, their exoskeletons gleaming with an obsidian sheen, engage in a fierce struggle across the vast, polished surface of a black mahogany table. The wood grain beneath them appears like a richly textured, undulating landscape. At the center of their battle is a single, large sugar crystal, a translucent, faceted monolith that refracts light like a precious gem. One ant clings tenaciously to the crystal with its jaws, while the other ant pounces, its own jaws breaking in a desperate attempt to seize the prize. Their spindly legs fumble for purchase against the smooth, reflective wood, their antennae twitching erratically in a flurry of attacks and exchanges. A single, warm light source from above casts long, dramatic shadows, exaggerating their movements and transforming this minor skirmish into an epic duel. The shallow depth of field blurs the distant background into a soft, blurred bokeh, ensuring all focus remains on the raw, silent violence of the scene, creating an atmosphere of intense, microscopic tension.", + "seed": 14260, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_15/index_5480_seed_14260_dp_30_rank_60_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.05016339239664376, + "vlm_logprob": -0.05016339239664376, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.9, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.05016339239664376, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two black garden ants visible engaging in a struggle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a single large translucent sugar crystal present at the center of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a polished black mahogany table with visible wood grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a low angle with a shallow depth of field creating a blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the motion captured in high-speed slow motion with a slow progression?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04928794875741005 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.049288034439087 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04928794875741005, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04928794875741005, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10781911760568619, + 0.13319705426692963, + 0.09205019474029541, + 0.17317277193069458, + 0.10515458881855011, + 0.08121383190155029, + 0.07953154295682907, + 0.022663703188300133, + 0.0380212776362896, + 0.16717594861984253 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04928794875741005 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two black garden ants visible engaging in a struggle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a single large translucent sugar crystal present at the center of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a polished black mahogany table with visible wood grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a low angle with a shallow depth of field creating a blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the motion captured in high-speed slow motion with a slow progression?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.033706169575452805 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4087061882019043 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.033706169575452805, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.033706169575452805, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14342179894447327, + 0.12735530734062195, + 0.040168583393096924, + 0.09828174859285355, + 0.20277395844459534, + 0.10021840035915375, + 0.10181067883968353, + 0.03412384167313576, + 0.056134432554244995, + 0.09571129083633423 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.033706169575452805 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two black garden ants visible engaging in a struggle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a single large translucent sugar crystal present at the center of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a polished black mahogany table with visible wood grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a low angle with a shallow depth of field creating a blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the motion captured in high-speed slow motion with a slow progression?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16037501394748688 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9103749990463257 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16037501394748688, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16037501394748688, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13429687917232513, + 0.1605914682149887, + 0.05030117556452751, + 0.06867439299821854, + 0.08230267465114594, + 0.2406293898820877, + 0.1380409300327301, + 0.021187175065279007, + 0.030049707740545273, + 0.07392615079879761 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16037501394748688 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two black garden ants visible engaging in a struggle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a single large translucent sugar crystal present at the center of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a polished black mahogany table with visible wood grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a low angle with a shallow depth of field creating a blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the motion captured in high-speed slow motion with a slow progression?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002198066795244813 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127198219299316 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002198066795244813, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002198066795244813, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11274435371160507, + 0.23283438384532928, + 0.027738917618989944, + 0.039463091641664505, + 0.04978686943650246, + 0.16684482991695404, + 0.08457565307617188, + 0.040465742349624634, + 0.025738045573234558, + 0.21980811655521393 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002198066795244813 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two black garden ants visible engaging in a struggle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a single large translucent sugar crystal present at the center of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a polished black mahogany table with visible wood grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a low angle with a shallow depth of field creating a blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the motion captured in high-speed slow motion with a slow progression?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005249762907624245 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255249977111816 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005249762907624245, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005249762907624245, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1805674135684967, + 0.13791927695274353, + 0.04636544734239578, + 0.0826411172747612, + 0.09970296174287796, + 0.16439545154571533, + 0.09871159493923187, + 0.0576559454202652, + 0.0690496638417244, + 0.06299106776714325 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005249762907624245 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extreme macro, low-angle shot, captured in dramatic, high-speed slow motion, unfolds with a slow, almost imperceptible progression into a monumental conflict. Two black garden ants, their exoskeletons gleaming with an obsidian sheen, engage in a fierce struggle across the vast, polished surface of a black mahogany table. The wood grain beneath them appears like a richly textured, undulating landscape. At the center of their battle is a single, large sugar crystal, a translucent, faceted monolith that refracts light like a precious gem. One ant clings tenaciously to the crystal with its jaws, while the other ant pounces, its own jaws breaking in a desperate attempt to seize the prize. Their spindly legs fumble for purchase against the smooth, reflective wood, their antennae twitching erratically in a flurry of attacks and exchanges. A single, warm light source from above casts long, dramatic shadows, exaggerating their movements and transforming this minor skirmish into an epic duel. The shallow depth of field blurs the distant background into a soft, blurred bokeh, ensuring all focus remains on the raw, silent violence of the scene, creating an atmosphere of intense, microscopic tension.", + "seed": 14261, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_15/index_5480_seed_14261_dp_30_rank_60_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.07475508451461792, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07475508451461792, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.3, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07475508451461792, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two black garden ants visible engaging in a struggle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a single large translucent sugar crystal present at the center of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a polished black mahogany table with visible wood grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a low angle with a shallow depth of field creating a blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the motion captured in high-speed slow motion with a slow progression?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14388954639434814 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0188894271850586 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14388954639434814, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.8749998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14388954639434814, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23705928027629852, + 0.0541188046336174, + 0.032403383404016495, + 0.03458190709352493, + 0.022509032860398293, + 0.2689252197742462, + 0.03629044443368912, + 0.07484336197376251, + 0.06364410370588303, + 0.17562448978424072 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14388954639434814 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two black garden ants visible engaging in a struggle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a single large translucent sugar crystal present at the center of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a polished black mahogany table with visible wood grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a low angle with a shallow depth of field creating a blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the motion captured in high-speed slow motion with a slow progression?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07003815472126007 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695038080215454 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07003815472126007, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07003815472126007, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11315516382455826, + 0.07763227075338364, + 0.07174205034971237, + 0.04893897846341133, + 0.03680714592337608, + 0.11719383299350739, + 0.09269002079963684, + 0.16832363605499268, + 0.14243318140506744, + 0.1310836672782898 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07003815472126007 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two black garden ants visible engaging in a struggle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a single large translucent sugar crystal present at the center of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a polished black mahogany table with visible wood grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a low angle with a shallow depth of field creating a blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the motion captured in high-speed slow motion with a slow progression?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1428329050540924 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0178329944610596 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1428329050540924, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.8750001192092896, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1428329050540924, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12104281038045883, + 0.07472068071365356, + 0.049438200891017914, + 0.025737140327692032, + 0.07574495673179626, + 0.0658021792769432, + 0.05942830443382263, + 0.11568038910627365, + 0.3603394329547882, + 0.052065834403038025 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1428329050540924 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two black garden ants visible engaging in a struggle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a single large translucent sugar crystal present at the center of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a polished black mahogany table with visible wood grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a low angle with a shallow depth of field creating a blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the motion captured in high-speed slow motion with a slow progression?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002821514382958412 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877821445465088 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002821514382958412, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002821514382958412, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14135612547397614, + 0.03313975781202316, + 0.08589212596416473, + 0.03935094550251961, + 0.03372207283973694, + 0.3458671271800995, + 0.0547107495367527, + 0.13591425120830536, + 0.04963071271777153, + 0.08041612058877945 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002821514382958412 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two black garden ants visible engaging in a struggle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a single large translucent sugar crystal present at the center of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a polished black mahogany table with visible wood grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a low angle with a shallow depth of field creating a blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the motion captured in high-speed slow motion with a slow progression?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014193302020430565 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264193534851074 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014193302020430565, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014193302020430565, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11798378825187683, + 0.038214653730392456, + 0.05827648192644119, + 0.0455799400806427, + 0.03194643184542656, + 0.33112087845802307, + 0.061445895582437515, + 0.0768454298377037, + 0.05037187784910202, + 0.18821461498737335 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014193302020430565 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extreme macro, low-angle shot, captured in dramatic, high-speed slow motion, unfolds with a slow, almost imperceptible progression into a monumental conflict. Two black garden ants, their exoskeletons gleaming with an obsidian sheen, engage in a fierce struggle across the vast, polished surface of a black mahogany table. The wood grain beneath them appears like a richly textured, undulating landscape. At the center of their battle is a single, large sugar crystal, a translucent, faceted monolith that refracts light like a precious gem. One ant clings tenaciously to the crystal with its jaws, while the other ant pounces, its own jaws breaking in a desperate attempt to seize the prize. Their spindly legs fumble for purchase against the smooth, reflective wood, their antennae twitching erratically in a flurry of attacks and exchanges. A single, warm light source from above casts long, dramatic shadows, exaggerating their movements and transforming this minor skirmish into an epic duel. The shallow depth of field blurs the distant background into a soft, blurred bokeh, ensuring all focus remains on the raw, silent violence of the scene, creating an atmosphere of intense, microscopic tension.", + "seed": 14262, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_15/index_5480_seed_14262_dp_31_rank_62_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.4986504063010216, + "vlm_logprob": -0.4986504063010216, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.425, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.4986504063010216, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two black garden ants visible engaging in a struggle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a single large translucent sugar crystal present at the center of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a polished black mahogany table with visible wood grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a low angle with a shallow depth of field creating a blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the motion captured in high-speed slow motion with a slow progression?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07050574570894241 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6955058574676514 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07050574570894241, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07050574570894241, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12252683192491531, + 0.07169941812753677, + 0.08604361861944199, + 0.12593266367912292, + 0.044800110161304474, + 0.0744125247001648, + 0.04753054305911064, + 0.193864643573761, + 0.18742020428180695, + 0.045769479125738144 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07050574570894241 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two black garden ants visible engaging in a struggle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a single large translucent sugar crystal present at the center of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a polished black mahogany table with visible wood grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a low angle with a shallow depth of field creating a blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the motion captured in high-speed slow motion with a slow progression?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04308052733540535 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680805683135986 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04308052733540535, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04308052733540535, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20410598814487457, + 0.12083090841770172, + 0.07538089156150818, + 0.12062012404203415, + 0.07813224196434021, + 0.1154492050409317, + 0.055900938808918, + 0.11669491231441498, + 0.08362559974193573, + 0.029259147122502327 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04308052733540535 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two black garden ants visible engaging in a struggle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a single large translucent sugar crystal present at the center of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a polished black mahogany table with visible wood grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a low angle with a shallow depth of field creating a blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the motion captured in high-speed slow motion with a slow progression?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3503918647766113 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1003919467329979 + ], + "logprob_reward": -2.3503918647766113, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -2.3503918647766113, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14949333667755127, + 0.08875980973243713, + 0.09769488871097565, + 0.061424653977155685, + 0.2364332526922226, + 0.1742851883172989, + 0.026195507496595383, + 0.014303124509751797, + 0.13594859838485718, + 0.015461680479347706 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -2.3503918647766113 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two black garden ants visible engaging in a struggle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a single large translucent sugar crystal present at the center of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a polished black mahogany table with visible wood grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a low angle with a shallow depth of field creating a blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the motion captured in high-speed slow motion with a slow progression?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008672667667269707 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758672714233398 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008672667667269707, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008672667667269707, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1504616141319275, + 0.0941714346408844, + 0.11354607343673706, + 0.06757484376430511, + 0.18439523875713348, + 0.18282842636108398, + 0.03734472766518593, + 0.02033388614654541, + 0.11869959533214569, + 0.03064422681927681 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008672667667269707 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two black garden ants visible engaging in a struggle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a single large translucent sugar crystal present at the center of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a polished black mahogany table with visible wood grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a low angle with a shallow depth of field creating a blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the motion captured in high-speed slow motion with a slow progression?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02060122601687908 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895601272583008 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02060122601687908, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02060122601687908, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10165530443191528, + 0.08331046253442764, + 0.11681583523750305, + 0.07604414224624634, + 0.16105028986930847, + 0.15710483491420746, + 0.0523713082075119, + 0.044161487370729446, + 0.1834619641304016, + 0.02402440272271633 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02060122601687908 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extreme macro, low-angle shot, captured in dramatic, high-speed slow motion, unfolds with a slow, almost imperceptible progression into a monumental conflict. Two black garden ants, their exoskeletons gleaming with an obsidian sheen, engage in a fierce struggle across the vast, polished surface of a black mahogany table. The wood grain beneath them appears like a richly textured, undulating landscape. At the center of their battle is a single, large sugar crystal, a translucent, faceted monolith that refracts light like a precious gem. One ant clings tenaciously to the crystal with its jaws, while the other ant pounces, its own jaws breaking in a desperate attempt to seize the prize. Their spindly legs fumble for purchase against the smooth, reflective wood, their antennae twitching erratically in a flurry of attacks and exchanges. A single, warm light source from above casts long, dramatic shadows, exaggerating their movements and transforming this minor skirmish into an epic duel. The shallow depth of field blurs the distant background into a soft, blurred bokeh, ensuring all focus remains on the raw, silent violence of the scene, creating an atmosphere of intense, microscopic tension.", + "seed": 14263, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_15/index_5480_seed_14263_dp_31_rank_62_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.07782016675919294, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07782016675919294, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.55, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07782016675919294, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two black garden ants visible engaging in a struggle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a single large translucent sugar crystal present at the center of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a polished black mahogany table with visible wood grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a low angle with a shallow depth of field creating a blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the motion captured in high-speed slow motion with a slow progression?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026990164071321487 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6519901752471924 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026990164071321487, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026990164071321487, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18210327625274658, + 0.11647354066371918, + 0.17014645040035248, + 0.09687969833612442, + 0.14157579839229584, + 0.039370037615299225, + 0.028385886922478676, + 0.08975493907928467, + 0.07905263453722, + 0.0562576949596405 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026990164071321487 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two black garden ants visible engaging in a struggle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a single large translucent sugar crystal present at the center of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a polished black mahogany table with visible wood grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a low angle with a shallow depth of field creating a blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the motion captured in high-speed slow motion with a slow progression?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02981058694422245 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529810667037964 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02981058694422245, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02981058694422245, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21079443395137787, + 0.21013498306274414, + 0.08749114722013474, + 0.13159003853797913, + 0.08796253800392151, + 0.05427290126681328, + 0.028286797925829887, + 0.07636209577322006, + 0.07156660407781601, + 0.04153845086693764 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02981058694422245 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two black garden ants visible engaging in a struggle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a single large translucent sugar crystal present at the center of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a polished black mahogany table with visible wood grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a low angle with a shallow depth of field creating a blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the motion captured in high-speed slow motion with a slow progression?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.31346625089645386 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3134663105010986 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.31346625089645386, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.31346625089645386, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06574749201536179, + 0.45260441303253174, + 0.07267897576093674, + 0.09613694250583649, + 0.09706850349903107, + 0.036761119961738586, + 0.023209312930703163, + 0.03619080036878586, + 0.05631400644779205, + 0.06328844279050827 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.31346625089645386 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two black garden ants visible engaging in a struggle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a single large translucent sugar crystal present at the center of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a polished black mahogany table with visible wood grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a low angle with a shallow depth of field creating a blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the motion captured in high-speed slow motion with a slow progression?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00464111752808094 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379641056060791 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00464111752808094, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00464111752808094, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10364653915166855, + 0.545418381690979, + 0.04471167176961899, + 0.10495113581418991, + 0.046551886945962906, + 0.018649697303771973, + 0.02124384604394436, + 0.030778203159570694, + 0.054071009159088135, + 0.029977641999721527 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00464111752808094 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two black garden ants visible engaging in a struggle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a single large translucent sugar crystal present at the center of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a polished black mahogany table with visible wood grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a low angle with a shallow depth of field creating a blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the motion captured in high-speed slow motion with a slow progression?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014192714355885983 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264192581176758 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014192714355885983, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014192714355885983, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22289793193340302, + 0.17100141942501068, + 0.207720547914505, + 0.08367451280355453, + 0.06030023470520973, + 0.04556522145867348, + 0.022095827385783195, + 0.054045092314481735, + 0.06373234838247299, + 0.06896684318780899 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014192714355885983 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_2/index_tensor([4575, 4575])_group_2_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_2/index_tensor([4575, 4575])_group_2_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..449f61be751a3bab9740c84987bcbf20fd1b51b3 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_2/index_tensor([4575, 4575])_group_2_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "low-angle, fixed-mounted projection shot from the hood of a rally-ready Ford RS200 captures a visceral and chaotic perspective, the world shaking and vibrating violently with every brutal movement of the machine. The car executes an aggressive, high-speed drift, sliding sideways across a narrow, sun-drenched dirt track lined with blurry green foliage. As the vehicle hangs on the edge of control, the camera jarringly captures rapid countersteering adjustments, unleashing a torrent of thick ochre dust and fine gravel from the rear wheels. This dense cloud rolls forward, streaking across the lens in thick, grainy waves, temporarily obscuring the view and creating a raw and intense display of power. Harsh sunlight penetrates the dust, illuminating the chaos and casting sharp, fleeting shadows across the rutted track, creating a gritty, high-contrast atmosphere that is both breathtaking and immersive.", + "seed": 33079, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_2/index_4575_seed_33079_dp_4_rank_8_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.08603291542967781, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08603291542967781, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.7, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08603291542967781, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Ford RS200 rally car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle from the hood of the car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the car performing a high-speed drift on a dirt track?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a thick cloud of ochre dust and gravel visible rolling forward from the rear wheels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by harsh sunlight creating high contrast and sharp shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10417808592319489 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3541781902313232 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10417808592319489, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10417808592319489, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.176999032497406, + 0.1251288205385208, + 0.11787017434835434, + 0.12704557180404663, + 0.09616301208734512, + 0.07722201943397522, + 0.08257583528757095, + 0.08469526469707489, + 0.03666890785098076, + 0.07563138008117676 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10417808592319489 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Ford RS200 rally car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle from the hood of the car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the car performing a high-speed drift on a dirt track?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a thick cloud of ochre dust and gravel visible rolling forward from the rear wheels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by harsh sunlight creating high contrast and sharp shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2813659906387329 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.406365990638733 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2813659906387329, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2813659906387329, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11166469007730484, + 0.08550003916025162, + 0.026502514258027077, + 0.13518399000167847, + 0.116631418466568, + 0.07899636775255203, + 0.24196673929691315, + 0.0724795013666153, + 0.04617087543010712, + 0.08490390330553055 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2813659906387329 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Ford RS200 rally car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle from the hood of the car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the car performing a high-speed drift on a dirt track?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a thick cloud of ochre dust and gravel visible rolling forward from the rear wheels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by harsh sunlight creating high contrast and sharp shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014197885990142822 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264197826385498 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014197885990142822, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014197885990142822, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10428154468536377, + 0.1872728317975998, + 0.05645950511097908, + 0.13505324721336365, + 0.1242222934961319, + 0.08345528692007065, + 0.14238469302654266, + 0.05651848763227463, + 0.0424729660153389, + 0.06787914782762527 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 6, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014197885990142822 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Ford RS200 rally car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle from the hood of the car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the car performing a high-speed drift on a dirt track?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a thick cloud of ochre dust and gravel visible rolling forward from the rear wheels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by harsh sunlight creating high contrast and sharp shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0006347072194330394 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.375634670257568 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0006347072194330394, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0006347072194330394, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11699308454990387, + 0.09981734305620193, + 0.05443047732114792, + 0.0433066301047802, + 0.07697224617004395, + 0.1293499767780304, + 0.1788215935230255, + 0.1018962636590004, + 0.06007974594831467, + 0.13833263516426086 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0006347072194330394 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Ford RS200 rally car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle from the hood of the car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the car performing a high-speed drift on a dirt track?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a thick cloud of ochre dust and gravel visible rolling forward from the rear wheels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by harsh sunlight creating high contrast and sharp shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029787907376885414 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529788017272949 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029787907376885414, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029787907376885414, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22052131593227386, + 0.07905899733304977, + 0.05324236676096916, + 0.05551915243268013, + 0.11368187516927719, + 0.026774609461426735, + 0.06197913736104965, + 0.07135162502527237, + 0.09121773391962051, + 0.22665314376354218 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029787907376885414 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, fixed-mounted projection shot from the hood of a rally-ready Ford RS200 captures a visceral and chaotic perspective, the world shaking and vibrating violently with every brutal movement of the machine. The car executes an aggressive, high-speed drift, sliding sideways across a narrow, sun-drenched dirt track lined with blurry green foliage. As the vehicle hangs on the edge of control, the camera jarringly captures rapid countersteering adjustments, unleashing a torrent of thick ochre dust and fine gravel from the rear wheels. This dense cloud rolls forward, streaking across the lens in thick, grainy waves, temporarily obscuring the view and creating a raw and intense display of power. Harsh sunlight penetrates the dust, illuminating the chaos and casting sharp, fleeting shadows across the rutted track, creating a gritty, high-contrast atmosphere that is both breathtaking and immersive.", + "seed": 33080, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_2/index_4575_seed_33080_dp_4_rank_8_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.07335565928369761, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07335565928369761, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.075, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07335565928369761, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Ford RS200 rally car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle from the hood of the car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the car performing a high-speed drift on a dirt track?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a thick cloud of ochre dust and gravel visible rolling forward from the rear wheels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by harsh sunlight creating high contrast and sharp shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16710446774959564 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9171044826507568 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16710446774959564, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16710446774959564, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.28068962693214417, + 0.11448725312948227, + 0.09041503816843033, + 0.09802544116973877, + 0.0362514927983284, + 0.061413828283548355, + 0.060761481523513794, + 0.10885223746299744, + 0.06687270104885101, + 0.08223087340593338 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16710446774959564 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Ford RS200 rally car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle from the hood of the car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the car performing a high-speed drift on a dirt track?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a thick cloud of ochre dust and gravel visible rolling forward from the rear wheels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by harsh sunlight creating high contrast and sharp shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17991097271442413 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8049110174179077 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17991097271442413, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17991097271442413, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13119281828403473, + 0.15248757600784302, + 0.1351359486579895, + 0.07960999011993408, + 0.02411256544291973, + 0.13625235855579376, + 0.12047912925481796, + 0.09128570556640625, + 0.0711069405078888, + 0.0583370141685009 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 5, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17991097271442413 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Ford RS200 rally car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle from the hood of the car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the car performing a high-speed drift on a dirt track?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a thick cloud of ochre dust and gravel visible rolling forward from the rear wheels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by harsh sunlight creating high contrast and sharp shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006738083902746439 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006738185882568 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006738083902746439, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006738083902746439, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18642950057983398, + 0.11388156563043594, + 0.12399330735206604, + 0.13538089394569397, + 0.06672759354114532, + 0.12386630475521088, + 0.09994823485612869, + 0.058693982660770416, + 0.04763876646757126, + 0.04343990981578827 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006738083902746439 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Ford RS200 rally car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle from the hood of the car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the car performing a high-speed drift on a dirt track?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a thick cloud of ochre dust and gravel visible rolling forward from the rear wheels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by harsh sunlight creating high contrast and sharp shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0004948345012962818 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.625494956970215 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0004948345012962818, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0004948345012962818, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15261311829090118, + 0.059827376157045364, + 0.06188812106847763, + 0.15487027168273926, + 0.06390330940485, + 0.12314341217279434, + 0.07720224559307098, + 0.08297634869813919, + 0.15454228222370148, + 0.0690334290266037 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0004948345012962818 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Ford RS200 rally car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle from the hood of the car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the car performing a high-speed drift on a dirt track?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a thick cloud of ochre dust and gravel visible rolling forward from the rear wheels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by harsh sunlight creating high contrast and sharp shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01252993755042553 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.3875298500061035 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01252993755042553, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01252993755042553, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07129070162773132, + 0.10112514346837997, + 0.19644859433174133, + 0.1996389627456665, + 0.06016111001372337, + 0.06537532061338425, + 0.13532514870166779, + 0.08065276592969894, + 0.05667262151837349, + 0.033309586346149445 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01252993755042553 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, fixed-mounted projection shot from the hood of a rally-ready Ford RS200 captures a visceral and chaotic perspective, the world shaking and vibrating violently with every brutal movement of the machine. The car executes an aggressive, high-speed drift, sliding sideways across a narrow, sun-drenched dirt track lined with blurry green foliage. As the vehicle hangs on the edge of control, the camera jarringly captures rapid countersteering adjustments, unleashing a torrent of thick ochre dust and fine gravel from the rear wheels. This dense cloud rolls forward, streaking across the lens in thick, grainy waves, temporarily obscuring the view and creating a raw and intense display of power. Harsh sunlight penetrates the dust, illuminating the chaos and casting sharp, fleeting shadows across the rutted track, creating a gritty, high-contrast atmosphere that is both breathtaking and immersive.", + "seed": 33081, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_2/index_4575_seed_33081_dp_5_rank_10_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.059124306828016414, + "vlm_logprob": -0.059124306828016414, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.9749999761581423, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.059124306828016414, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Ford RS200 rally car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle from the hood of the car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the car performing a high-speed drift on a dirt track?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a thick cloud of ochre dust and gravel visible rolling forward from the rear wheels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by harsh sunlight creating high contrast and sharp shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14480696618556976 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0198068618774414 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14480696618556976, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.8749998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14480696618556976, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20616881549358368, + 0.10878618061542511, + 0.04025297984480858, + 0.08808164298534393, + 0.17491331696510315, + 0.09252887964248657, + 0.0523233525454998, + 0.08100058883428574, + 0.05007321015000343, + 0.10587102174758911 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14480696618556976 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Ford RS200 rally car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle from the hood of the car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the car performing a high-speed drift on a dirt track?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a thick cloud of ochre dust and gravel visible rolling forward from the rear wheels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by harsh sunlight creating high contrast and sharp shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11296971887350082 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2379696369171143 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11296971887350082, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11296971887350082, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.039222680032253265, + 0.036551255732774734, + 0.03377462178468704, + 0.08714058250188828, + 0.024189911782741547, + 0.10108083486557007, + 0.03816327452659607, + 0.5729934573173523, + 0.02851738967001438, + 0.038366030901670456 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11296971887350082 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Ford RS200 rally car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle from the hood of the car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the car performing a high-speed drift on a dirt track?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a thick cloud of ochre dust and gravel visible rolling forward from the rear wheels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by harsh sunlight creating high contrast and sharp shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01107332669198513 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511073112487793 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01107332669198513, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01107332669198513, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11375100910663605, + 0.2474004328250885, + 0.07538586109876633, + 0.12460097670555115, + 0.020522838458418846, + 0.17588432133197784, + 0.08369269222021103, + 0.04567403346300125, + 0.035436972975730896, + 0.07765081524848938 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01107332669198513 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Ford RS200 rally car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle from the hood of the car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the car performing a high-speed drift on a dirt track?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a thick cloud of ochre dust and gravel visible rolling forward from the rear wheels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by harsh sunlight creating high contrast and sharp shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0004374024283606559 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.750437259674072 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0004374024283606559, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0004374024283606559, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05514327436685562, + 0.190328910946846, + 0.0702873021364212, + 0.19711367785930634, + 0.04916759207844734, + 0.11971201002597809, + 0.145403191447258, + 0.08344820141792297, + 0.03516032174229622, + 0.05423547700047493 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0004374024283606559 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Ford RS200 rally car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle from the hood of the car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the car performing a high-speed drift on a dirt track?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a thick cloud of ochre dust and gravel visible rolling forward from the rear wheels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by harsh sunlight creating high contrast and sharp shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026334119960665703 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651334047317505 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026334119960665703, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026334119960665703, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06151159852743149, + 0.05572914704680443, + 0.032389380037784576, + 0.08099787682294846, + 0.031691234558820724, + 0.2527523636817932, + 0.16524982452392578, + 0.13914847373962402, + 0.02726367674767971, + 0.15326640009880066 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026334119960665703 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, fixed-mounted projection shot from the hood of a rally-ready Ford RS200 captures a visceral and chaotic perspective, the world shaking and vibrating violently with every brutal movement of the machine. The car executes an aggressive, high-speed drift, sliding sideways across a narrow, sun-drenched dirt track lined with blurry green foliage. As the vehicle hangs on the edge of control, the camera jarringly captures rapid countersteering adjustments, unleashing a torrent of thick ochre dust and fine gravel from the rear wheels. This dense cloud rolls forward, streaking across the lens in thick, grainy waves, temporarily obscuring the view and creating a raw and intense display of power. Harsh sunlight penetrates the dust, illuminating the chaos and casting sharp, fleeting shadows across the rutted track, creating a gritty, high-contrast atmosphere that is both breathtaking and immersive.", + "seed": 33082, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_2/index_4575_seed_33082_dp_5_rank_10_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.06768497413722799, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06768497413722799, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.9, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06768497413722799, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Ford RS200 rally car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle from the hood of the car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the car performing a high-speed drift on a dirt track?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a thick cloud of ochre dust and gravel visible rolling forward from the rear wheels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by harsh sunlight creating high contrast and sharp shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06553518772125244 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.815535068511963 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06553518772125244, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06553518772125244, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2962579131126404, + 0.10875032097101212, + 0.11526278406381607, + 0.06047925353050232, + 0.03299549221992493, + 0.06971819698810577, + 0.1006862223148346, + 0.04164547100663185, + 0.056290701031684875, + 0.117913618683815 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06553518772125244 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Ford RS200 rally car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle from the hood of the car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the car performing a high-speed drift on a dirt track?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a thick cloud of ochre dust and gravel visible rolling forward from the rear wheels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by harsh sunlight creating high contrast and sharp shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22559121251106262 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6005911827087402 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.22559121251106262, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.22559121251106262, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15881045162677765, + 0.10187240689992905, + 0.2194356620311737, + 0.0404987707734108, + 0.07918241620063782, + 0.11682320386171341, + 0.07541954517364502, + 0.035049404948949814, + 0.10263670235872269, + 0.07027142494916916 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.22559121251106262 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Ford RS200 rally car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle from the hood of the car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the car performing a high-speed drift on a dirt track?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a thick cloud of ochre dust and gravel visible rolling forward from the rear wheels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by harsh sunlight creating high contrast and sharp shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026339925825595856 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513400077819824 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026339925825595856, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026339925825595856, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1268797516822815, + 0.2890615463256836, + 0.26472145318984985, + 0.06786864250898361, + 0.03435349836945534, + 0.016056926921010017, + 0.023044487461447716, + 0.02969387173652649, + 0.07278342545032501, + 0.07553635537624359 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026339925825595856 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Ford RS200 rally car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle from the hood of the car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the car performing a high-speed drift on a dirt track?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a thick cloud of ochre dust and gravel visible rolling forward from the rear wheels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by harsh sunlight creating high contrast and sharp shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0003861635341309011 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.8753862380981445 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0003861635341309011, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0003861635341309011, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19228976964950562, + 0.16599923372268677, + 0.1572304517030716, + 0.0819324478507042, + 0.07663469761610031, + 0.1076231524348259, + 0.07228036224842072, + 0.025104470551013947, + 0.05942172557115555, + 0.06148361787199974 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0003861635341309011 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Ford RS200 rally car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle from the hood of the car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the car performing a high-speed drift on a dirt track?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a thick cloud of ochre dust and gravel visible rolling forward from the rear wheels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by harsh sunlight creating high contrast and sharp shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02057238109409809 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955724239349365 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02057238109409809, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02057238109409809, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4493870139122009, + 0.1382962018251419, + 0.05485822260379791, + 0.04081227630376816, + 0.05217878147959709, + 0.06192387267947197, + 0.03449321910738945, + 0.05938280001282692, + 0.06054456904530525, + 0.0481230728328228 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02057238109409809 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_3/index_tensor([5004, 5004])_group_3_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_3/index_tensor([5004, 5004])_group_3_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..4c07a6f06b500ea0876a8fba9bd5c99d77d0c446 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_3/index_tensor([5004, 5004])_group_3_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "close-up, slow-motion shot, shot from an extremely low angle, focuses on a massive king crab lurking in the clear yet murky shallows. A powerful overhead light penetrates the water, precisely illuminating its deep, vibrant crimson carapace, studded with terrifyingly sharp spines that gleam with a wet, hard sheen in the light. In an instant, its curled body erupts, its long, spiky legs violently extending outward with astonishing speed and force, tearing the previously calm surface apart. In the extreme slow motion, we can clearly see that each swing of the crab's legs unleashes an explosive, circular spray of countless crystalline droplets and white foam. Each droplet, illuminated by the overhead light, gleams like diamonds, briefly suspended in mid-air. The entire image is awash in high-contrast light and shadow, the crab's red body contrasting sharply against the dark background, creating a powerful atmosphere imbued with primal power and dramatic tension.", + "seed": 32912, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_3/index_5004_seed_32912_dp_6_rank_12_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.14907702356576918, + "vlm_logprob": -0.14907702356576918, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.3, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.14907702356576918, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a massive king crab?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at an extremely low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the crab's carapace deep crimson and studded with sharp spines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the crab erupt with its legs extending outward violently?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot in slow motion showing droplets suspended in mid-air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07313720881938934 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6981372833251953 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07313720881938934, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07313720881938934, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2976919114589691, + 0.06279853731393814, + 0.03857611492276192, + 0.03170312941074371, + 0.01896795444190502, + 0.08410724997520447, + 0.08913011103868484, + 0.12591834366321564, + 0.0737610012292862, + 0.1773456186056137 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07313720881938934 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a massive king crab?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at an extremely low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the crab's carapace deep crimson and studded with sharp spines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the crab erupt with its legs extending outward violently?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot in slow motion showing droplets suspended in mid-air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.47437596321105957 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9743759632110596 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.47437596321105957, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.47437596321105957, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.29927507042884827, + 0.06232909485697746, + 0.08543316274881363, + 0.04099823907017708, + 0.03663988411426544, + 0.09225025773048401, + 0.05228715389966965, + 0.10241582244634628, + 0.07905711978673935, + 0.14931423962116241 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.47437596321105957 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a massive king crab?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at an extremely low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the crab's carapace deep crimson and studded with sharp spines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the crab erupt with its legs extending outward violently?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot in slow motion showing droplets suspended in mid-air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07901037484407425 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.579010486602783 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07901037484407425, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07901037484407425, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1498197466135025, + 0.08366979658603668, + 0.05301257595419884, + 0.02837895043194294, + 0.04374011978507042, + 0.10799047350883484, + 0.050736505538225174, + 0.0576322115957737, + 0.07500399649143219, + 0.35001564025878906 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07901037484407425 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a massive king crab?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at an extremely low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the crab's carapace deep crimson and studded with sharp spines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the crab erupt with its legs extending outward violently?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot in slow motion showing droplets suspended in mid-air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029817529022693634 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529817581176758 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029817529022693634, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029817529022693634, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24422164261341095, + 0.17149753868579865, + 0.08255860209465027, + 0.08104361593723297, + 0.024472270160913467, + 0.07942084223031998, + 0.07346931099891663, + 0.048854902386665344, + 0.08170448243618011, + 0.11275680363178253 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029817529022693634 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a massive king crab?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at an extremely low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the crab's carapace deep crimson and studded with sharp spines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the crab erupt with its legs extending outward violently?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot in slow motion showing droplets suspended in mid-air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08904404193162918 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4640440940856934 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08904404193162918, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08904404193162918, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21552863717079163, + 0.11074188351631165, + 0.13252516090869904, + 0.05368608608841896, + 0.06048986315727234, + 0.07749705016613007, + 0.06580843031406403, + 0.13592787086963654, + 0.03852059692144394, + 0.1092744693160057 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08904404193162918 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up, slow-motion shot, shot from an extremely low angle, focuses on a massive king crab lurking in the clear yet murky shallows. A powerful overhead light penetrates the water, precisely illuminating its deep, vibrant crimson carapace, studded with terrifyingly sharp spines that gleam with a wet, hard sheen in the light. In an instant, its curled body erupts, its long, spiky legs violently extending outward with astonishing speed and force, tearing the previously calm surface apart. In the extreme slow motion, we can clearly see that each swing of the crab's legs unleashes an explosive, circular spray of countless crystalline droplets and white foam. Each droplet, illuminated by the overhead light, gleams like diamonds, briefly suspended in mid-air. The entire image is awash in high-contrast light and shadow, the crab's red body contrasting sharply against the dark background, creating a powerful atmosphere imbued with primal power and dramatic tension.", + "seed": 32913, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_3/index_5004_seed_32913_dp_6_rank_12_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.09362471513450146, + "vlm_logprob": -0.09362471513450146, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.85, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.09362471513450146, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a massive king crab?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at an extremely low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the crab's carapace deep crimson and studded with sharp spines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the crab erupt with its legs extending outward violently?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot in slow motion showing droplets suspended in mid-air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.046599265187978745 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1715991497039795 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.046599265187978745, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.046599265187978745, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17126190662384033, + 0.0860939472913742, + 0.129787877202034, + 0.09864599257707596, + 0.0743355005979538, + 0.04452355206012726, + 0.14795169234275818, + 0.13077357411384583, + 0.04131174087524414, + 0.07531425356864929 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.046599265187978745 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a massive king crab?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at an extremely low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the crab's carapace deep crimson and studded with sharp spines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the crab erupt with its legs extending outward violently?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot in slow motion showing droplets suspended in mid-air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3134748041629791 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3134747743606567 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3134748041629791, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3134748041629791, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13607895374298096, + 0.20663109421730042, + 0.19626368582248688, + 0.05742080509662628, + 0.06252443045377731, + 0.05380116403102875, + 0.02928696759045124, + 0.1097320094704628, + 0.08631931245326996, + 0.06194159388542175 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3134748041629791 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a massive king crab?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at an extremely low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the crab's carapace deep crimson and studded with sharp spines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the crab erupt with its legs extending outward violently?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot in slow motion showing droplets suspended in mid-air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.054963547736406326 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299635887145996 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.054963547736406326, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.054963547736406326, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09936155378818512, + 0.05879300832748413, + 0.21365244686603546, + 0.09344058483839035, + 0.0846603512763977, + 0.04225938394665718, + 0.18533584475517273, + 0.06936871260404587, + 0.026071563363075256, + 0.1270565539598465 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.054963547736406326 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a massive king crab?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at an extremely low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the crab's carapace deep crimson and studded with sharp spines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the crab erupt with its legs extending outward violently?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot in slow motion showing droplets suspended in mid-air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023292265832424164 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773292303085327 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023292265832424164, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023292265832424164, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09761911630630493, + 0.14694508910179138, + 0.11183567345142365, + 0.051200587302446365, + 0.04128240793943405, + 0.06539665162563324, + 0.11230701208114624, + 0.2828516960144043, + 0.032930128276348114, + 0.05763160437345505 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023292265832424164 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a massive king crab?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at an extremely low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the crab's carapace deep crimson and studded with sharp spines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the crab erupt with its legs extending outward violently?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot in slow motion showing droplets suspended in mid-air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029793692752718925 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5297937393188477 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029793692752718925, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029793692752718925, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10217563062906265, + 0.1335889995098114, + 0.16411486268043518, + 0.10114496201276779, + 0.05103708431124687, + 0.03487013280391693, + 0.1971123367547989, + 0.11633516848087311, + 0.025885822251439095, + 0.07373493909835815 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029793692752718925 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up, slow-motion shot, shot from an extremely low angle, focuses on a massive king crab lurking in the clear yet murky shallows. A powerful overhead light penetrates the water, precisely illuminating its deep, vibrant crimson carapace, studded with terrifyingly sharp spines that gleam with a wet, hard sheen in the light. In an instant, its curled body erupts, its long, spiky legs violently extending outward with astonishing speed and force, tearing the previously calm surface apart. In the extreme slow motion, we can clearly see that each swing of the crab's legs unleashes an explosive, circular spray of countless crystalline droplets and white foam. Each droplet, illuminated by the overhead light, gleams like diamonds, briefly suspended in mid-air. The entire image is awash in high-contrast light and shadow, the crab's red body contrasting sharply against the dark background, creating a powerful atmosphere imbued with primal power and dramatic tension.", + "seed": 32914, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_3/index_5004_seed_32914_dp_7_rank_14_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.20340878367424012, + "vlm_logprob": -0.20340878367424012, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.925, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.20340878367424012, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a massive king crab?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at an extremely low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the crab's carapace deep crimson and studded with sharp spines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the crab erupt with its legs extending outward violently?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot in slow motion showing droplets suspended in mid-air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16290587186813354 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9129059314727783 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16290587186813354, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16290587186813354, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4644010663032532, + 0.034572675824165344, + 0.07840463519096375, + 0.022929247468709946, + 0.05401500687003136, + 0.12813997268676758, + 0.03060433827340603, + 0.03398847207427025, + 0.11283687502145767, + 0.04010767489671707 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16290587186813354 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a massive king crab?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at an extremely low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the crab's carapace deep crimson and studded with sharp spines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the crab erupt with its legs extending outward violently?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot in slow motion showing droplets suspended in mid-air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5761874318122864 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8261874318122864 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5761874318122864, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5761874318122864, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2758810520172119, + 0.06755661964416504, + 0.07037599384784698, + 0.04285818710923195, + 0.03526073321700096, + 0.11132203042507172, + 0.0878743901848793, + 0.14760123193264008, + 0.09014267474412918, + 0.07112710177898407 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5761874318122864 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a massive king crab?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at an extremely low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the crab's carapace deep crimson and studded with sharp spines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the crab erupt with its legs extending outward violently?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot in slow motion showing droplets suspended in mid-air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17991206049919128 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8049120903015137 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17991206049919128, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17991206049919128, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2659247815608978, + 0.04635394364595413, + 0.08446335047483444, + 0.017766961827874184, + 0.029969291761517525, + 0.25368598103523254, + 0.01690668612718582, + 0.2331836074590683, + 0.026067594066262245, + 0.02567788027226925 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17991206049919128 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a massive king crab?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at an extremely low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the crab's carapace deep crimson and studded with sharp spines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the crab erupt with its legs extending outward violently?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot in slow motion showing droplets suspended in mid-air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04308098554611206 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168081045150757 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04308098554611206, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04308098554611206, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19017264246940613, + 0.08818680793046951, + 0.12182912975549698, + 0.05359398573637009, + 0.03287067636847496, + 0.18644648790359497, + 0.020555095747113228, + 0.20306019484996796, + 0.07203967124223709, + 0.031245270743966103 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04308098554611206 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a massive king crab?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at an extremely low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the crab's carapace deep crimson and studded with sharp spines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the crab erupt with its legs extending outward violently?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot in slow motion showing droplets suspended in mid-air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.054957568645477295 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929957628250122 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.054957568645477295, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.054957568645477295, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.6956978440284729, + 0.021865103393793106, + 0.023427199572324753, + 0.015927918255329132, + 0.0357346311211586, + 0.05313761159777641, + 0.011341258883476257, + 0.10511990636587143, + 0.019557761028409004, + 0.018190765753388405 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.054957568645477295 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up, slow-motion shot, shot from an extremely low angle, focuses on a massive king crab lurking in the clear yet murky shallows. A powerful overhead light penetrates the water, precisely illuminating its deep, vibrant crimson carapace, studded with terrifyingly sharp spines that gleam with a wet, hard sheen in the light. In an instant, its curled body erupts, its long, spiky legs violently extending outward with astonishing speed and force, tearing the previously calm surface apart. In the extreme slow motion, we can clearly see that each swing of the crab's legs unleashes an explosive, circular spray of countless crystalline droplets and white foam. Each droplet, illuminated by the overhead light, gleams like diamonds, briefly suspended in mid-air. The entire image is awash in high-contrast light and shadow, the crab's red body contrasting sharply against the dark background, creating a powerful atmosphere imbued with primal power and dramatic tension.", + "seed": 32915, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_3/index_5004_seed_32915_dp_7_rank_14_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.2130970187485218, + "vlm_logprob": -0.2130970187485218, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.225, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.2130970187485218, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a massive king crab?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at an extremely low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the crab's carapace deep crimson and studded with sharp spines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the crab erupt with its legs extending outward violently?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot in slow motion showing droplets suspended in mid-air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0824444368481636 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.582444429397583 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0824444368481636, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0824444368481636, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25036710500717163, + 0.0334378220140934, + 0.055395182222127914, + 0.22563472390174866, + 0.1385153830051422, + 0.1292489916086197, + 0.04455199092626572, + 0.014487088657915592, + 0.032988738268613815, + 0.07537289708852768 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0824444368481636 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a massive king crab?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at an extremely low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the crab's carapace deep crimson and studded with sharp spines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the crab erupt with its legs extending outward violently?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot in slow motion showing droplets suspended in mid-air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8262178301811218 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5762178301811218 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.8262178301811218, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.8262178301811218, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11681050807237625, + 0.09541581571102142, + 0.056779202073812485, + 0.08233869075775146, + 0.08526362478733063, + 0.17647039890289307, + 0.05029230937361717, + 0.16423417627811432, + 0.073295459151268, + 0.09909985959529877 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.8262178301811218 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a massive king crab?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at an extremely low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the crab's carapace deep crimson and studded with sharp spines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the crab erupt with its legs extending outward violently?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot in slow motion showing droplets suspended in mid-air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.048675671219825745 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048675775527954 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.048675671219825745, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.048675671219825745, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2724466323852539, + 0.0639386996626854, + 0.047184377908706665, + 0.09457181394100189, + 0.17119300365447998, + 0.19286368787288666, + 0.0478721559047699, + 0.05072576180100441, + 0.030269918963313103, + 0.02893398143351078 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.048675671219825745 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a massive king crab?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at an extremely low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the crab's carapace deep crimson and studded with sharp spines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the crab erupt with its legs extending outward violently?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot in slow motion showing droplets suspended in mid-air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07003837823867798 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695038318634033 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07003837823867798, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07003837823867798, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11146534979343414, + 0.09611450135707855, + 0.04901948943734169, + 0.0781383365392685, + 0.09568086266517639, + 0.36194685101509094, + 0.03493393212556839, + 0.08049406111240387, + 0.04929068684577942, + 0.04291593283414841 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07003837823867798 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a massive king crab?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at an extremely low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the crab's carapace deep crimson and studded with sharp spines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the crab erupt with its legs extending outward violently?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot in slow motion showing droplets suspended in mid-air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03810877725481987 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881088256835938 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03810877725481987, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03810877725481987, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13434603810310364, + 0.040902458131313324, + 0.0357511043548584, + 0.14033940434455872, + 0.12065906077623367, + 0.09328669309616089, + 0.05210011079907417, + 0.11154601722955704, + 0.13085748255252838, + 0.1402115821838379 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03810877725481987 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_4/index_tensor([7287, 7287])_group_4_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_4/index_tensor([7287, 7287])_group_4_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..6c29bcaab2de8cf302f207aec3ff89402561c240 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_4/index_tensor([7287, 7287])_group_4_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "medium close-up shot in super slow motion begins at eye level, following the accidental fall of a minimalist, matte-white ceramic pot from a sun-drenched, white wooden windowsill. The camera then smoothly tilts downward, poetically tracking its descent. The delicate succulent is a plump, rosette-shaped cluster of Echeveria, its leaves graduating from a vibrant green in the center to pale pink and lavender at the edges, coated in a delicate white frosting. As the pot gently tumbles through the air, bright, warm afternoon sunlight filters through from behind, casting a dazzling golden halo around the pot and the plant, making the translucent leaf edges appear to glow from within. Then, a handful of dark, nutrient-rich soil gracefully gushes from the pot's lip, forming a slowly expanding, balletic, nebula in the air. Countless tiny particles of soil and white perlite shimmer in the light like floating dust. The entire picture is shrouded in a tranquil and focused atmosphere. The background is the slightly overexposed and blurred outdoor greenery seen through the clean window. The warm light and shadow are intertwined with the dynamic elements suspended in the air, transforming an unexpected moment into a dynamic painting full of harmony and broken beauty, and with a strong sense of life aesthetics.", + "seed": 6406, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_4/index_7287_seed_6406_dp_8_rank_16_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.07550067361444235, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07550067361444235, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.7, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07550067361444235, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up of a minimalist, matte-white ceramic pot falling from a white wooden windowsill?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video show a succulent plant with rosette-shaped Echeveria leaves that are green in the center and pale pink/lavender at the edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the camera movement a smooth tilt downward tracking the pot's descent in super slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature bright, warm afternoon sunlight creating a golden halo and glowing translucent edges on the pot and plant?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do dark soil and white perlite particles gush from the pot and shimmer like floating dust in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3149911165237427 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3149911165237427 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3149911165237427, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3149911165237427, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.615440845489502, + 0.12073741108179092, + 0.020295733585953712, + 0.0689353421330452, + 0.011291197501122952, + 0.010472617112100124, + 0.017974240705370903, + 0.011673567816615105, + 0.10309742391109467, + 0.020081697031855583 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3149911165237427 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up of a minimalist, matte-white ceramic pot falling from a white wooden windowsill?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video show a succulent plant with rosette-shaped Echeveria leaves that are green in the center and pale pink/lavender at the edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the camera movement a smooth tilt downward tracking the pot's descent in super slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature bright, warm afternoon sunlight creating a golden halo and glowing translucent edges on the pot and plant?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do dark soil and white perlite particles gush from the pot and shimmer like floating dust in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007647049613296986 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.8826470375061035 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007647049613296986, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007647049613296986, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.7811697125434875, + 0.09069916605949402, + 0.022217584773898125, + 0.018731921911239624, + 0.011389180086553097, + 0.010532557033002377, + 0.014820071868598461, + 0.0075684781186282635, + 0.02270202338695526, + 0.020169289782643318 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007647049613296986 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up of a minimalist, matte-white ceramic pot falling from a white wooden windowsill?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video show a succulent plant with rosette-shaped Echeveria leaves that are green in the center and pale pink/lavender at the edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the camera movement a smooth tilt downward tracking the pot's descent in super slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature bright, warm afternoon sunlight creating a golden halo and glowing translucent edges on the pot and plant?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do dark soil and white perlite particles gush from the pot and shimmer like floating dust in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026338066905736923 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513381004333496 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026338066905736923, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026338066905736923, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.41044679284095764, + 0.12782591581344604, + 0.04792890325188637, + 0.050885412842035294, + 0.03116779401898384, + 0.020203350111842155, + 0.02536851540207863, + 0.01917761005461216, + 0.2209913730621338, + 0.04600434750318527 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026338066905736923 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up of a minimalist, matte-white ceramic pot falling from a white wooden windowsill?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video show a succulent plant with rosette-shaped Echeveria leaves that are green in the center and pale pink/lavender at the edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the camera movement a smooth tilt downward tracking the pot's descent in super slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature bright, warm afternoon sunlight creating a golden halo and glowing translucent edges on the pot and plant?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do dark soil and white perlite particles gush from the pot and shimmer like floating dust in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005250474438071251 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255250453948975 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005250474438071251, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005250474438071251, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.7320380806922913, + 0.09268885850906372, + 0.038885075598955154, + 0.03819131478667259, + 0.008209151215851307, + 0.0061333198100328445, + 0.012733081355690956, + 0.014194837771356106, + 0.03911144286394119, + 0.017814861610531807 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005250474438071251 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up of a minimalist, matte-white ceramic pot falling from a white wooden windowsill?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video show a succulent plant with rosette-shaped Echeveria leaves that are green in the center and pale pink/lavender at the edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the camera movement a smooth tilt downward tracking the pot's descent in super slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature bright, warm afternoon sunlight creating a golden halo and glowing translucent edges on the pot and plant?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do dark soil and white perlite particles gush from the pot and shimmer like floating dust in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023276660591363907 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732765674591064 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023276660591363907, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023276660591363907, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.36385247111320496, + 0.1838996261358261, + 0.03908254951238632, + 0.08862492442131042, + 0.07988382130861282, + 0.029579371213912964, + 0.06455029547214508, + 0.015759972855448723, + 0.07616046071052551, + 0.05860646814107895 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023276660591363907 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "medium close-up shot in super slow motion begins at eye level, following the accidental fall of a minimalist, matte-white ceramic pot from a sun-drenched, white wooden windowsill. The camera then smoothly tilts downward, poetically tracking its descent. The delicate succulent is a plump, rosette-shaped cluster of Echeveria, its leaves graduating from a vibrant green in the center to pale pink and lavender at the edges, coated in a delicate white frosting. As the pot gently tumbles through the air, bright, warm afternoon sunlight filters through from behind, casting a dazzling golden halo around the pot and the plant, making the translucent leaf edges appear to glow from within. Then, a handful of dark, nutrient-rich soil gracefully gushes from the pot's lip, forming a slowly expanding, balletic, nebula in the air. Countless tiny particles of soil and white perlite shimmer in the light like floating dust. The entire picture is shrouded in a tranquil and focused atmosphere. The background is the slightly overexposed and blurred outdoor greenery seen through the clean window. The warm light and shadow are intertwined with the dynamic elements suspended in the air, transforming an unexpected moment into a dynamic painting full of harmony and broken beauty, and with a strong sense of life aesthetics.", + "seed": 6407, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_4/index_7287_seed_6407_dp_8_rank_16_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.013174032140523196, + "vlm_logprob": -0.013174032140523196, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.55, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.013174032140523196, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up of a minimalist, matte-white ceramic pot falling from a white wooden windowsill?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video show a succulent plant with rosette-shaped Echeveria leaves that are green in the center and pale pink/lavender at the edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the camera movement a smooth tilt downward tracking the pot's descent in super slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature bright, warm afternoon sunlight creating a golden halo and glowing translucent edges on the pot and plant?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do dark soil and white perlite particles gush from the pot and shimmer like floating dust in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03112647868692875 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5311264991760254 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03112647868692875, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03112647868692875, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10583757609128952, + 0.06895984709262848, + 0.04822615161538124, + 0.07962381839752197, + 0.11918764561414719, + 0.08337945491075516, + 0.13134461641311646, + 0.22806619107723236, + 0.09319121390581131, + 0.04218355193734169 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03112647868692875 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up of a minimalist, matte-white ceramic pot falling from a white wooden windowsill?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video show a succulent plant with rosette-shaped Echeveria leaves that are green in the center and pale pink/lavender at the edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the camera movement a smooth tilt downward tracking the pot's descent in super slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature bright, warm afternoon sunlight creating a golden halo and glowing translucent edges on the pot and plant?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do dark soil and white perlite particles gush from the pot and shimmer like floating dust in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009804781526327133 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634804725646973 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009804781526327133, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009804781526327133, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25503990054130554, + 0.1437183916568756, + 0.06678861379623413, + 0.06639241427183151, + 0.03993364796042442, + 0.09172341227531433, + 0.14285621047019958, + 0.08904433250427246, + 0.04755458980798721, + 0.056948479264974594 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009804781526327133 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up of a minimalist, matte-white ceramic pot falling from a white wooden windowsill?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video show a succulent plant with rosette-shaped Echeveria leaves that are green in the center and pale pink/lavender at the edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the camera movement a smooth tilt downward tracking the pot's descent in super slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature bright, warm afternoon sunlight creating a golden halo and glowing translucent edges on the pot and plant?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do dark soil and white perlite particles gush from the pot and shimmer like floating dust in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00977680366486311 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634776592254639 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00977680366486311, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00977680366486311, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11770747601985931, + 0.08832535147666931, + 0.0601629801094532, + 0.21874669194221497, + 0.06185518577694893, + 0.07492131739854813, + 0.13910996913909912, + 0.13562384247779846, + 0.06716536730527878, + 0.03638182207942009 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00977680366486311 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up of a minimalist, matte-white ceramic pot falling from a white wooden windowsill?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video show a succulent plant with rosette-shaped Echeveria leaves that are green in the center and pale pink/lavender at the edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the camera movement a smooth tilt downward tracking the pot's descent in super slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature bright, warm afternoon sunlight creating a golden halo and glowing translucent edges on the pot and plant?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do dark soil and white perlite particles gush from the pot and shimmer like floating dust in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004093957599252462 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504094123840332 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004093957599252462, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004093957599252462, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22373877465724945, + 0.041829440742731094, + 0.0358513742685318, + 0.08386685699224472, + 0.06042052432894707, + 0.09544385224580765, + 0.13484667241573334, + 0.05812213569879532, + 0.14497895538806915, + 0.1209014281630516 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004093957599252462 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up of a minimalist, matte-white ceramic pot falling from a white wooden windowsill?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video show a succulent plant with rosette-shaped Echeveria leaves that are green in the center and pale pink/lavender at the edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the camera movement a smooth tilt downward tracking the pot's descent in super slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature bright, warm afternoon sunlight creating a golden halo and glowing translucent edges on the pot and plant?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do dark soil and white perlite particles gush from the pot and shimmer like floating dust in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011068139225244522 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511068344116211 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011068139225244522, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011068139225244522, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09304304420948029, + 0.08225655555725098, + 0.03625185415148735, + 0.05302935466170311, + 0.07262590527534485, + 0.09646952152252197, + 0.23516452312469482, + 0.2126520872116089, + 0.06037738546729088, + 0.05812973529100418 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011068139225244522 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "medium close-up shot in super slow motion begins at eye level, following the accidental fall of a minimalist, matte-white ceramic pot from a sun-drenched, white wooden windowsill. The camera then smoothly tilts downward, poetically tracking its descent. The delicate succulent is a plump, rosette-shaped cluster of Echeveria, its leaves graduating from a vibrant green in the center to pale pink and lavender at the edges, coated in a delicate white frosting. As the pot gently tumbles through the air, bright, warm afternoon sunlight filters through from behind, casting a dazzling golden halo around the pot and the plant, making the translucent leaf edges appear to glow from within. Then, a handful of dark, nutrient-rich soil gracefully gushes from the pot's lip, forming a slowly expanding, balletic, nebula in the air. Countless tiny particles of soil and white perlite shimmer in the light like floating dust. The entire picture is shrouded in a tranquil and focused atmosphere. The background is the slightly overexposed and blurred outdoor greenery seen through the clean window. The warm light and shadow are intertwined with the dynamic elements suspended in the air, transforming an unexpected moment into a dynamic painting full of harmony and broken beauty, and with a strong sense of life aesthetics.", + "seed": 6408, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_4/index_7287_seed_6408_dp_9_rank_18_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.039330655429512265, + "vlm_logprob": -0.039330655429512265, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.275, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.039330655429512265, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up of a minimalist, matte-white ceramic pot falling from a white wooden windowsill?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video show a succulent plant with rosette-shaped Echeveria leaves that are green in the center and pale pink/lavender at the edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the camera movement a smooth tilt downward tracking the pot's descent in super slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature bright, warm afternoon sunlight creating a golden halo and glowing translucent edges on the pot and plant?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do dark soil and white perlite particles gush from the pot and shimmer like floating dust in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1445946842432022 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.019594669342041 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1445946842432022, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1445946842432022, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07454156875610352, + 0.29942581057548523, + 0.1573510617017746, + 0.08788293600082397, + 0.09458651393651962, + 0.04953278601169586, + 0.021862082183361053, + 0.061685457825660706, + 0.11115622520446777, + 0.041975539177656174 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1445946842432022 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up of a minimalist, matte-white ceramic pot falling from a white wooden windowsill?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video show a succulent plant with rosette-shaped Echeveria leaves that are green in the center and pale pink/lavender at the edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the camera movement a smooth tilt downward tracking the pot's descent in super slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature bright, warm afternoon sunlight creating a golden halo and glowing translucent edges on the pot and plant?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do dark soil and white perlite particles gush from the pot and shimmer like floating dust in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0032088477164506912 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753208637237549 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0032088477164506912, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0032088477164506912, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15011855959892273, + 0.10449476540088654, + 0.21924307942390442, + 0.07935435324907303, + 0.11403395980596542, + 0.048719778656959534, + 0.02773354947566986, + 0.06143935024738312, + 0.13440178334712982, + 0.060460809618234634 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0032088477164506912 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up of a minimalist, matte-white ceramic pot falling from a white wooden windowsill?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video show a succulent plant with rosette-shaped Echeveria leaves that are green in the center and pale pink/lavender at the edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the camera movement a smooth tilt downward tracking the pot's descent in super slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature bright, warm afternoon sunlight creating a golden halo and glowing translucent edges on the pot and plant?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do dark soil and white perlite particles gush from the pot and shimmer like floating dust in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026341086253523827 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651341199874878 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026341086253523827, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026341086253523827, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.097989022731781, + 0.11231885105371475, + 0.17047907412052155, + 0.07241661101579666, + 0.1768588125705719, + 0.04962471127510071, + 0.03207015618681908, + 0.12484312802553177, + 0.14291051030158997, + 0.020489143207669258 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 2, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026341086253523827 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up of a minimalist, matte-white ceramic pot falling from a white wooden windowsill?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video show a succulent plant with rosette-shaped Echeveria leaves that are green in the center and pale pink/lavender at the edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the camera movement a smooth tilt downward tracking the pot's descent in super slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature bright, warm afternoon sunlight creating a golden halo and glowing translucent edges on the pot and plant?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do dark soil and white perlite particles gush from the pot and shimmer like floating dust in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0019388464279472828 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.251938819885254 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0019388464279472828, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0019388464279472828, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12506385147571564, + 0.17230208218097687, + 0.1857708990573883, + 0.06671507656574249, + 0.09091860055923462, + 0.09186669439077377, + 0.07286637276411057, + 0.1115143895149231, + 0.05593165010213852, + 0.02705037221312523 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0019388464279472828 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up of a minimalist, matte-white ceramic pot falling from a white wooden windowsill?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video show a succulent plant with rosette-shaped Echeveria leaves that are green in the center and pale pink/lavender at the edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the camera movement a smooth tilt downward tracking the pot's descent in super slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature bright, warm afternoon sunlight creating a golden halo and glowing translucent edges on the pot and plant?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do dark soil and white perlite particles gush from the pot and shimmer like floating dust in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0205698125064373 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955698013305664 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0205698125064373, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0205698125064373, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09402264654636383, + 0.08062426000833511, + 0.17652516067028046, + 0.06231304630637169, + 0.17342020571231842, + 0.07708761841058731, + 0.0661882534623146, + 0.050060346722602844, + 0.10799141228199005, + 0.11176709830760956 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0205698125064373 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "medium close-up shot in super slow motion begins at eye level, following the accidental fall of a minimalist, matte-white ceramic pot from a sun-drenched, white wooden windowsill. The camera then smoothly tilts downward, poetically tracking its descent. The delicate succulent is a plump, rosette-shaped cluster of Echeveria, its leaves graduating from a vibrant green in the center to pale pink and lavender at the edges, coated in a delicate white frosting. As the pot gently tumbles through the air, bright, warm afternoon sunlight filters through from behind, casting a dazzling golden halo around the pot and the plant, making the translucent leaf edges appear to glow from within. Then, a handful of dark, nutrient-rich soil gracefully gushes from the pot's lip, forming a slowly expanding, balletic, nebula in the air. Countless tiny particles of soil and white perlite shimmer in the light like floating dust. The entire picture is shrouded in a tranquil and focused atmosphere. The background is the slightly overexposed and blurred outdoor greenery seen through the clean window. The warm light and shadow are intertwined with the dynamic elements suspended in the air, transforming an unexpected moment into a dynamic painting full of harmony and broken beauty, and with a strong sense of life aesthetics.", + "seed": 6409, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_4/index_7287_seed_6409_dp_9_rank_18_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.10700378119945526, + "vlm_logprob": -0.10700378119945526, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.55, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.10700378119945526, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up of a minimalist, matte-white ceramic pot falling from a white wooden windowsill?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video show a succulent plant with rosette-shaped Echeveria leaves that are green in the center and pale pink/lavender at the edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the camera movement a smooth tilt downward tracking the pot's descent in super slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature bright, warm afternoon sunlight creating a golden halo and glowing translucent edges on the pot and plant?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do dark soil and white perlite particles gush from the pot and shimmer like floating dust in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.47478240728378296 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.974782407283783 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.47478240728378296, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.47478240728378296, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23545856773853302, + 0.07916755229234695, + 0.04886693134903908, + 0.12650005519390106, + 0.029812347143888474, + 0.055476583540439606, + 0.1419389694929123, + 0.17497465014457703, + 0.05718124657869339, + 0.050623126327991486 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.47478240728378296 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up of a minimalist, matte-white ceramic pot falling from a white wooden windowsill?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video show a succulent plant with rosette-shaped Echeveria leaves that are green in the center and pale pink/lavender at the edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the camera movement a smooth tilt downward tracking the pot's descent in super slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature bright, warm afternoon sunlight creating a golden halo and glowing translucent edges on the pot and plant?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do dark soil and white perlite particles gush from the pot and shimmer like floating dust in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016094528138637543 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.14109468460083 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016094528138637543, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016094528138637543, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08696461468935013, + 0.11619500815868378, + 0.15245722234249115, + 0.13141673803329468, + 0.1125146895647049, + 0.07646801322698593, + 0.14431603252887726, + 0.07427609711885452, + 0.06604941934347153, + 0.039342090487480164 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 6, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016094528138637543 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up of a minimalist, matte-white ceramic pot falling from a white wooden windowsill?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video show a succulent plant with rosette-shaped Echeveria leaves that are green in the center and pale pink/lavender at the edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the camera movement a smooth tilt downward tracking the pot's descent in super slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature bright, warm afternoon sunlight creating a golden halo and glowing translucent edges on the pot and plant?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do dark soil and white perlite particles gush from the pot and shimmer like floating dust in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026342015713453293 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513419151306152 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026342015713453293, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026342015713453293, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04622667655348778, + 0.036531440913677216, + 0.03307555615901947, + 0.5177839398384094, + 0.09293676167726517, + 0.07218996435403824, + 0.07728487253189087, + 0.07069146633148193, + 0.030968433246016502, + 0.02231089398264885 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026342015713453293 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up of a minimalist, matte-white ceramic pot falling from a white wooden windowsill?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video show a succulent plant with rosette-shaped Echeveria leaves that are green in the center and pale pink/lavender at the edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the camera movement a smooth tilt downward tracking the pot's descent in super slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature bright, warm afternoon sunlight creating a golden halo and glowing translucent edges on the pot and plant?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do dark soil and white perlite particles gush from the pot and shimmer like floating dust in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006733584217727184 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006733417510986 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006733584217727184, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006733584217727184, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1603643298149109, + 0.04801793396472931, + 0.05110476166009903, + 0.31592467427253723, + 0.07525337487459183, + 0.07425277680158615, + 0.09717350453138351, + 0.10956185311079025, + 0.03645602986216545, + 0.031890712678432465 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006733584217727184 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up of a minimalist, matte-white ceramic pot falling from a white wooden windowsill?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video show a succulent plant with rosette-shaped Echeveria leaves that are green in the center and pale pink/lavender at the edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the camera movement a smooth tilt downward tracking the pot's descent in super slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature bright, warm afternoon sunlight creating a golden halo and glowing translucent edges on the pot and plant?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do dark soil and white perlite particles gush from the pot and shimmer like floating dust in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011066370643675327 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511066436767578 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011066370643675327, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011066370643675327, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07092162221670151, + 0.03955751657485962, + 0.042487647384405136, + 0.11919901520013809, + 0.05063299834728241, + 0.07094606757164001, + 0.03621979430317879, + 0.5117243528366089, + 0.029382549226284027, + 0.028928451240062714 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011066370643675327 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_5/index_tensor([3582, 3582])_group_5_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_5/index_tensor([3582, 3582])_group_5_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..8a3aa894e8c8129fd1d4efbb194fab60a45d3767 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_5/index_tensor([3582, 3582])_group_5_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "slow, low-angle tracking shot glides across the dark forest floor, rendered in a rich, painterly 3D cartoon style reminiscent of the \"Two Cities\" series. Unusual tendrils of a magical fire, a vibrant blend of fuchsia, violet, and fiery orange, creep across the damp soil and gnarled tree roots with serpentine grace. The fire doesn't rage; it cautiously licks the dense green stems of a lush, succulent plant, its heat causing the air to shimmer. Large, velvety, deep purple bell-shaped flowers hang heavily, glowing intensely in the inferno's unnatural light, illuminating their delicate petal textures and casting dynamic, flickering highlights against the deep shadows of the surrounding woods. Every detail, from the subtle fuzz on the plant stems to the individual, crackling embers that drift upward like malevolent fireflies, is rendered in crisp, vibrant ultra-high definition, creating a menacing and alluring atmosphere.", + "seed": 27115, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_5/index_3582_seed_27115_dp_10_rank_20_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.025121960951946676, + "vlm_logprob": -0.025121960951946676, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.45, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.025121960951946676, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a slow, low-angle tracking shot across the forest floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a rich, painterly 3D cartoon reminiscent of the 'Two Cities' series?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are tendrils of magical fire blending fuchsia, violet, and fiery orange visible creeping across the soil and roots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are large, velvety, deep purple bell-shaped flowers hanging heavily and glowing intensely in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are individual crackling embers drifting upward like malevolent fireflies visible in the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03615700826048851 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4111568927764893 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03615700826048851, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03615700826048851, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1207566112279892, + 0.10783539712429047, + 0.09913056343793869, + 0.09866692870855331, + 0.17445333302021027, + 0.07646903395652771, + 0.07202480733394623, + 0.03361477702856064, + 0.1778677999973297, + 0.03918073698878288 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03615700826048851 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a slow, low-angle tracking shot across the forest floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a rich, painterly 3D cartoon reminiscent of the 'Two Cities' series?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are tendrils of magical fire blending fuchsia, violet, and fiery orange visible creeping across the soil and roots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are large, velvety, deep purple bell-shaped flowers hanging heavily and glowing intensely in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are individual crackling embers drifting upward like malevolent fireflies visible in the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023292848840355873 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732927799224854 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023292848840355873, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023292848840355873, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12785759568214417, + 0.10808557271957397, + 0.148957297205925, + 0.08879803121089935, + 0.19506269693374634, + 0.03731565549969673, + 0.060893259942531586, + 0.03654685616493225, + 0.14459146559238434, + 0.05189158022403717 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 2, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023292848840355873 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a slow, low-angle tracking shot across the forest floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a rich, painterly 3D cartoon reminiscent of the 'Two Cities' series?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are tendrils of magical fire blending fuchsia, violet, and fiery orange visible creeping across the soil and roots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are large, velvety, deep purple bell-shaped flowers hanging heavily and glowing intensely in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are individual crackling embers drifting upward like malevolent fireflies visible in the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0019443194614723325 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.251944541931152 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0019443194614723325, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0019443194614723325, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10899524390697479, + 0.09875880926847458, + 0.15691009163856506, + 0.22642534971237183, + 0.1493506133556366, + 0.04202389717102051, + 0.03840123862028122, + 0.023708710446953773, + 0.10512207448482513, + 0.050303954631090164 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0019443194614723325 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a slow, low-angle tracking shot across the forest floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a rich, painterly 3D cartoon reminiscent of the 'Two Cities' series?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are tendrils of magical fire blending fuchsia, violet, and fiery orange visible creeping across the soil and roots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are large, velvety, deep purple bell-shaped flowers hanging heavily and glowing intensely in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are individual crackling embers drifting upward like malevolent fireflies visible in the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0021956877317279577 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127195835113525 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0021956877317279577, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0021956877317279577, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14557000994682312, + 0.11487573385238647, + 0.06528794765472412, + 0.15316560864448547, + 0.08620333671569824, + 0.03540458157658577, + 0.14001259207725525, + 0.05228772386908531, + 0.0886671245098114, + 0.11852531135082245 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0021956877317279577 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a slow, low-angle tracking shot across the forest floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a rich, painterly 3D cartoon reminiscent of the 'Two Cities' series?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are tendrils of magical fire blending fuchsia, violet, and fiery orange visible creeping across the soil and roots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are large, velvety, deep purple bell-shaped flowers hanging heavily and glowing intensely in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are individual crackling embers drifting upward like malevolent fireflies visible in the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.062019940465688705 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120198249816895 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.062019940465688705, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.062019940465688705, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16171710193157196, + 0.08333317935466766, + 0.10634725540876389, + 0.07949863374233246, + 0.2669880986213684, + 0.025922108441591263, + 0.05897149816155434, + 0.034858159720897675, + 0.0420830138027668, + 0.14028093218803406 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.062019940465688705 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow, low-angle tracking shot glides across the dark forest floor, rendered in a rich, painterly 3D cartoon style reminiscent of the \"Two Cities\" series. Unusual tendrils of a magical fire, a vibrant blend of fuchsia, violet, and fiery orange, creep across the damp soil and gnarled tree roots with serpentine grace. The fire doesn't rage; it cautiously licks the dense green stems of a lush, succulent plant, its heat causing the air to shimmer. Large, velvety, deep purple bell-shaped flowers hang heavily, glowing intensely in the inferno's unnatural light, illuminating their delicate petal textures and casting dynamic, flickering highlights against the deep shadows of the surrounding woods. Every detail, from the subtle fuzz on the plant stems to the individual, crackling embers that drift upward like malevolent fireflies, is rendered in crisp, vibrant ultra-high definition, creating a menacing and alluring atmosphere.", + "seed": 27116, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_5/index_3582_seed_27116_dp_10_rank_20_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.016786868311464788, + "vlm_logprob": -0.016786868311464788, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.525, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.016786868311464788, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a slow, low-angle tracking shot across the forest floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a rich, painterly 3D cartoon reminiscent of the 'Two Cities' series?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are tendrils of magical fire blending fuchsia, violet, and fiery orange visible creeping across the soil and roots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are large, velvety, deep purple bell-shaped flowers hanging heavily and glowing intensely in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are individual crackling embers drifting upward like malevolent fireflies visible in the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01826350763440132 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.143263339996338 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01826350763440132, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01826350763440132, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15290367603302002, + 0.10903223603963852, + 0.04384496062994003, + 0.07135472446680069, + 0.1669401079416275, + 0.1422363817691803, + 0.08324914425611496, + 0.10905405879020691, + 0.08244305849075317, + 0.03894156962633133 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01826350763440132 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a slow, low-angle tracking shot across the forest floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a rich, painterly 3D cartoon reminiscent of the 'Two Cities' series?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are tendrils of magical fire blending fuchsia, violet, and fiery orange visible creeping across the soil and roots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are large, velvety, deep purple bell-shaped flowers hanging heavily and glowing intensely in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are individual crackling embers drifting upward like malevolent fireflies visible in the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01419964898377657 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264199733734131 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01419964898377657, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01419964898377657, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11092066764831543, + 0.1386689692735672, + 0.08884263783693314, + 0.059915848076343536, + 0.15838640928268433, + 0.22507047653198242, + 0.06916403025388718, + 0.04314364865422249, + 0.041508644819259644, + 0.06437867134809494 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01419964898377657 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a slow, low-angle tracking shot across the forest floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a rich, painterly 3D cartoon reminiscent of the 'Two Cities' series?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are tendrils of magical fire blending fuchsia, violet, and fiery orange visible creeping across the soil and roots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are large, velvety, deep purple bell-shaped flowers hanging heavily and glowing intensely in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are individual crackling embers drifting upward like malevolent fireflies visible in the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00248968368396163 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.0024895668029785 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00248968368396163, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00248968368396163, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14772051572799683, + 0.2091207653284073, + 0.11018642783164978, + 0.06016011908650398, + 0.09813401103019714, + 0.1784645915031433, + 0.03118785098195076, + 0.051756277680397034, + 0.04905040189623833, + 0.06421910971403122 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00248968368396163 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a slow, low-angle tracking shot across the forest floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a rich, painterly 3D cartoon reminiscent of the 'Two Cities' series?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are tendrils of magical fire blending fuchsia, violet, and fiery orange visible creeping across the soil and roots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are large, velvety, deep purple bell-shaped flowers hanging heavily and glowing intensely in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are individual crackling embers drifting upward like malevolent fireflies visible in the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005942652467638254 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.1309428215026855 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005942652467638254, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005942652467638254, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0751989409327507, + 0.08855614066123962, + 0.10054433345794678, + 0.32970550656318665, + 0.045417413115501404, + 0.14367929100990295, + 0.0473930686712265, + 0.057620465755462646, + 0.05668531358242035, + 0.0551995113492012 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 5, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005942652467638254 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a slow, low-angle tracking shot across the forest floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a rich, painterly 3D cartoon reminiscent of the 'Two Cities' series?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are tendrils of magical fire blending fuchsia, violet, and fiery orange visible creeping across the soil and roots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are large, velvety, deep purple bell-shaped flowers hanging heavily and glowing intensely in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are individual crackling embers drifting upward like malevolent fireflies visible in the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04303884878754616 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168038845062256 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04303884878754616, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04303884878754616, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.30203577876091003, + 0.08874417096376419, + 0.060325853526592255, + 0.08909386396408081, + 0.11074993759393692, + 0.13671262562274933, + 0.021517129614949226, + 0.0374990738928318, + 0.045944955199956894, + 0.1073765754699707 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04303884878754616 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow, low-angle tracking shot glides across the dark forest floor, rendered in a rich, painterly 3D cartoon style reminiscent of the \"Two Cities\" series. Unusual tendrils of a magical fire, a vibrant blend of fuchsia, violet, and fiery orange, creep across the damp soil and gnarled tree roots with serpentine grace. The fire doesn't rage; it cautiously licks the dense green stems of a lush, succulent plant, its heat causing the air to shimmer. Large, velvety, deep purple bell-shaped flowers hang heavily, glowing intensely in the inferno's unnatural light, illuminating their delicate petal textures and casting dynamic, flickering highlights against the deep shadows of the surrounding woods. Every detail, from the subtle fuzz on the plant stems to the individual, crackling embers that drift upward like malevolent fireflies, is rendered in crisp, vibrant ultra-high definition, creating a menacing and alluring atmosphere.", + "seed": 27117, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_5/index_3582_seed_27117_dp_11_rank_22_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.06810054806992412, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06810054806992412, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.525, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06810054806992412, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a slow, low-angle tracking shot across the forest floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a rich, painterly 3D cartoon reminiscent of the 'Two Cities' series?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are tendrils of magical fire blending fuchsia, violet, and fiery orange visible creeping across the soil and roots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are large, velvety, deep purple bell-shaped flowers hanging heavily and glowing intensely in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are individual crackling embers drifting upward like malevolent fireflies visible in the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.18169505894184113 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8066951036453247 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.18169505894184113, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.18169505894184113, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.26433831453323364, + 0.06101665645837784, + 0.06696286052465439, + 0.10688161104917526, + 0.09946528822183609, + 0.1746693104505539, + 0.13741232454776764, + 0.013630821369588375, + 0.04575717821717262, + 0.029865657910704613 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.18169505894184113 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a slow, low-angle tracking shot across the forest floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a rich, painterly 3D cartoon reminiscent of the 'Two Cities' series?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are tendrils of magical fire blending fuchsia, violet, and fiery orange visible creeping across the soil and roots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are large, velvety, deep purple bell-shaped flowers hanging heavily and glowing intensely in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are individual crackling embers drifting upward like malevolent fireflies visible in the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01819690316915512 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018197059631348 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01819690316915512, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01819690316915512, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19679711759090424, + 0.07970494031906128, + 0.08718784898519516, + 0.08203296363353729, + 0.14184348285198212, + 0.20455467700958252, + 0.06036502495408058, + 0.05086754262447357, + 0.05112437531352043, + 0.04552203789353371 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01819690316915512 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a slow, low-angle tracking shot across the forest floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a rich, painterly 3D cartoon reminiscent of the 'Two Cities' series?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are tendrils of magical fire blending fuchsia, violet, and fiery orange visible creeping across the soil and roots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are large, velvety, deep purple bell-shaped flowers hanging heavily and glowing intensely in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are individual crackling embers drifting upward like malevolent fireflies visible in the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007634272798895836 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882634162902832 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007634272798895836, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007634272798895836, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09761389344930649, + 0.1177324652671814, + 0.15065975487232208, + 0.1770339012145996, + 0.1201958954334259, + 0.09261168539524078, + 0.06356330960988998, + 0.07656582444906235, + 0.03925419971346855, + 0.06476902961730957 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007634272798895836 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a slow, low-angle tracking shot across the forest floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a rich, painterly 3D cartoon reminiscent of the 'Two Cities' series?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are tendrils of magical fire blending fuchsia, violet, and fiery orange visible creeping across the soil and roots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are large, velvety, deep purple bell-shaped flowers hanging heavily and glowing intensely in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are individual crackling embers drifting upward like malevolent fireflies visible in the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005948815029114485 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130949020385742 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005948815029114485, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005948815029114485, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.36749404668807983, + 0.06568431854248047, + 0.03514230623841286, + 0.05674542114138603, + 0.23403388261795044, + 0.058132536709308624, + 0.11985789984464645, + 0.020902903750538826, + 0.024418896064162254, + 0.01758783683180809 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005948815029114485 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a slow, low-angle tracking shot across the forest floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a rich, painterly 3D cartoon reminiscent of the 'Two Cities' series?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are tendrils of magical fire blending fuchsia, violet, and fiery orange visible creeping across the soil and roots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are large, velvety, deep purple bell-shaped flowers hanging heavily and glowing intensely in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are individual crackling embers drifting upward like malevolent fireflies visible in the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.127027690410614 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.127027750015259 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.127027690410614, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.127027690410614, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18954049050807953, + 0.05920347943902016, + 0.09102222323417664, + 0.09451685845851898, + 0.13701635599136353, + 0.0672064945101738, + 0.17478451132774353, + 0.05807476118206978, + 0.08250049501657486, + 0.04613432660698891 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.127027690410614 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow, low-angle tracking shot glides across the dark forest floor, rendered in a rich, painterly 3D cartoon style reminiscent of the \"Two Cities\" series. Unusual tendrils of a magical fire, a vibrant blend of fuchsia, violet, and fiery orange, creep across the damp soil and gnarled tree roots with serpentine grace. The fire doesn't rage; it cautiously licks the dense green stems of a lush, succulent plant, its heat causing the air to shimmer. Large, velvety, deep purple bell-shaped flowers hang heavily, glowing intensely in the inferno's unnatural light, illuminating their delicate petal textures and casting dynamic, flickering highlights against the deep shadows of the surrounding woods. Every detail, from the subtle fuzz on the plant stems to the individual, crackling embers that drift upward like malevolent fireflies, is rendered in crisp, vibrant ultra-high definition, creating a menacing and alluring atmosphere.", + "seed": 27118, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_5/index_3582_seed_27118_dp_11_rank_22_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.1045297073200345, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1045297073200345, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.375, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1045297073200345, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a slow, low-angle tracking shot across the forest floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a rich, painterly 3D cartoon reminiscent of the 'Two Cities' series?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are tendrils of magical fire blending fuchsia, violet, and fiery orange visible creeping across the soil and roots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are large, velvety, deep purple bell-shaped flowers hanging heavily and glowing intensely in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are individual crackling embers drifting upward like malevolent fireflies visible in the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.43109026551246643 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.056090235710144 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.43109026551246643, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.43109026551246643, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10160648822784424, + 0.0945034772157669, + 0.03860493004322052, + 0.04576806351542473, + 0.14668500423431396, + 0.030594060197472572, + 0.21879994869232178, + 0.13866505026817322, + 0.09831974655389786, + 0.08645325154066086 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 4, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.43109026551246643 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a slow, low-angle tracking shot across the forest floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a rich, painterly 3D cartoon reminiscent of the 'Two Cities' series?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are tendrils of magical fire blending fuchsia, violet, and fiery orange visible creeping across the soil and roots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are large, velvety, deep purple bell-shaped flowers hanging heavily and glowing intensely in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are individual crackling embers drifting upward like malevolent fireflies visible in the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018196552991867065 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.0181965827941895 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018196552991867065, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018196552991867065, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12952382862567902, + 0.25310400128364563, + 0.18723510205745697, + 0.03573627024888992, + 0.05771368369460106, + 0.030469508841633797, + 0.07057526707649231, + 0.04031688719987869, + 0.04187310114502907, + 0.15345238149166107 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018196552991867065 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a slow, low-angle tracking shot across the forest floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a rich, painterly 3D cartoon reminiscent of the 'Two Cities' series?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are tendrils of magical fire blending fuchsia, violet, and fiery orange visible creeping across the soil and roots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are large, velvety, deep purple bell-shaped flowers hanging heavily and glowing intensely in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are individual crackling embers drifting upward like malevolent fireflies visible in the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009788726456463337 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634788513183594 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009788726456463337, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009788726456463337, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11121302098035812, + 0.07061880081892014, + 0.07935739308595657, + 0.03134344890713692, + 0.25663721561431885, + 0.04737092927098274, + 0.07512255012989044, + 0.06964529305696487, + 0.10437239706516266, + 0.15431895852088928 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009788726456463337 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a slow, low-angle tracking shot across the forest floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a rich, painterly 3D cartoon reminiscent of the 'Two Cities' series?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are tendrils of magical fire blending fuchsia, violet, and fiery orange visible creeping across the soil and roots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are large, velvety, deep purple bell-shaped flowers hanging heavily and glowing intensely in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are individual crackling embers drifting upward like malevolent fireflies visible in the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008634377270936966 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758634567260742 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008634377270936966, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008634377270936966, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14215344190597534, + 0.08838482201099396, + 0.060463640838861465, + 0.059445880353450775, + 0.09130030870437622, + 0.025341514497995377, + 0.09421111643314362, + 0.14497508108615875, + 0.026370804756879807, + 0.2673534154891968 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008634377270936966 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a slow, low-angle tracking shot across the forest floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a rich, painterly 3D cartoon reminiscent of the 'Two Cities' series?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are tendrils of magical fire blending fuchsia, violet, and fiery orange visible creeping across the soil and roots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are large, velvety, deep purple bell-shaped flowers hanging heavily and glowing intensely in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are individual crackling embers drifting upward like malevolent fireflies visible in the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05493861436843872 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929938554763794 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05493861436843872, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05493861436843872, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08643306791782379, + 0.10239283740520477, + 0.04845895618200302, + 0.04159219190478325, + 0.07496634125709534, + 0.050653230398893356, + 0.2618447542190552, + 0.19560708105564117, + 0.07962077111005783, + 0.0584307536482811 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05493861436843872 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_6/index_tensor([2521, 2521])_group_6_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_6/index_tensor([2521, 2521])_group_6_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..eb75e586bec8b81d374e184af44a44ffa884252a --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_6/index_tensor([2521, 2521])_group_6_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "static medium close-up depicts a red pen tumbling and spinning in a desolate void. The entire scene is filmed at a high frame rate, transforming the chaotic action into a slow, mesmerizing ballet. The pen, a retractable ballpoint made of polished crimson plastic, rotates gracefully. Demonic cinematic lighting, derived from a single, hard, off-camera light source, carves the object out of infinite blackness, casting long, sharp shadows across its own form and creating stark, bright highlights on its gleaming metal clip and tip. Every minute rotation and reflection is rendered in perfect, crystal-clear detail, capturing the hypnotic glow of the polished plastic and gleaming metal, creating an atmosphere both elegant and deeply unsettling as the pen turns relentlessly in the silent abyss.", + "seed": 30426, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_6/index_2521_seed_30426_dp_12_rank_24_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.10338397808372975, + "vlm_logprob": -0.10338397808372975, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.8, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.10338397808372975, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a red retractable ballpoint pen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the pen made of polished crimson plastic with a gleaming metal clip and tip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pen tumbling and spinning in a desolate void with infinite blackness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single hard off-camera light source creating long sharp shadows and bright highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot as a static medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04420744627714157 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1692073345184326 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04420744627714157, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04420744627714157, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2219986617565155, + 0.0678037777543068, + 0.15658152103424072, + 0.05765392258763313, + 0.12367727607488632, + 0.056054629385471344, + 0.11207607388496399, + 0.04587378725409508, + 0.12195052206516266, + 0.036329831928014755 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04420744627714157 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a red retractable ballpoint pen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the pen made of polished crimson plastic with a gleaming metal clip and tip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pen tumbling and spinning in a desolate void with infinite blackness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single hard off-camera light source creating long sharp shadows and bright highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot as a static medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.054973140358924866 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299731254577637 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.054973140358924866, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.054973140358924866, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.33758240938186646, + 0.06740264594554901, + 0.14024418592453003, + 0.05229920521378517, + 0.06199304759502411, + 0.04308996722102165, + 0.0869322270154953, + 0.047285012900829315, + 0.10404102504253387, + 0.0591302327811718 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.054973140358924866 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a red retractable ballpoint pen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the pen made of polished crimson plastic with a gleaming metal clip and tip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pen tumbling and spinning in a desolate void with infinite blackness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single hard off-camera light source creating long sharp shadows and bright highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot as a static medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.34861719608306885 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2236171960830688 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.34861719608306885, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.34861719608306885, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3420705795288086, + 0.15715281665325165, + 0.24450717866420746, + 0.06506658345460892, + 0.04459000751376152, + 0.01477616187185049, + 0.02165750041604042, + 0.02181321382522583, + 0.05011233314871788, + 0.03825366497039795 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.34861719608306885 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a red retractable ballpoint pen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the pen made of polished crimson plastic with a gleaming metal clip and tip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pen tumbling and spinning in a desolate void with infinite blackness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single hard off-camera light source creating long sharp shadows and bright highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot as a static medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014190716668963432 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264190673828125 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014190716668963432, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014190716668963432, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.29054757952690125, + 0.09113268554210663, + 0.17556007206439972, + 0.063166543841362, + 0.05837825685739517, + 0.02225254289805889, + 0.04441329836845398, + 0.037099216133356094, + 0.18746083974838257, + 0.029989002272486687 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014190716668963432 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a red retractable ballpoint pen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the pen made of polished crimson plastic with a gleaming metal clip and tip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pen tumbling and spinning in a desolate void with infinite blackness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single hard off-camera light source creating long sharp shadows and bright highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot as a static medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05493139103055 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929931402206421 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05493139103055, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05493139103055, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1758577525615692, + 0.12219738960266113, + 0.08051621913909912, + 0.04698171466588974, + 0.02805251069366932, + 0.04140092432498932, + 0.09058377891778946, + 0.11882830411195755, + 0.2674054205417633, + 0.02817598730325699 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05493139103055 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static medium close-up depicts a red pen tumbling and spinning in a desolate void. The entire scene is filmed at a high frame rate, transforming the chaotic action into a slow, mesmerizing ballet. The pen, a retractable ballpoint made of polished crimson plastic, rotates gracefully. Demonic cinematic lighting, derived from a single, hard, off-camera light source, carves the object out of infinite blackness, casting long, sharp shadows across its own form and creating stark, bright highlights on its gleaming metal clip and tip. Every minute rotation and reflection is rendered in perfect, crystal-clear detail, capturing the hypnotic glow of the polished plastic and gleaming metal, creating an atmosphere both elegant and deeply unsettling as the pen turns relentlessly in the silent abyss.", + "seed": 30427, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_6/index_2521_seed_30427_dp_12_rank_24_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.03382613640278578, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03382613640278578, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.675, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03382613640278578, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a red retractable ballpoint pen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the pen made of polished crimson plastic with a gleaming metal clip and tip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pen tumbling and spinning in a desolate void with infinite blackness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single hard off-camera light source creating long sharp shadows and bright highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot as a static medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.024788301438093185 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7747883796691895 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.024788301438093185, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.024788301438093185, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0909595862030983, + 0.016198057681322098, + 0.033834539353847504, + 0.3738943338394165, + 0.12117714434862137, + 0.12013176828622818, + 0.015301343984901905, + 0.13344644010066986, + 0.08018761873245239, + 0.014869212172925472 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 7, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.024788301438093185 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a red retractable ballpoint pen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the pen made of polished crimson plastic with a gleaming metal clip and tip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pen tumbling and spinning in a desolate void with infinite blackness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single hard off-camera light source creating long sharp shadows and bright highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot as a static medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029822388663887978 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.52982234954834 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029822388663887978, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029822388663887978, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0611165426671505, + 0.039445910602808, + 0.028986699879169464, + 0.2441222220659256, + 0.10055931657552719, + 0.19232319295406342, + 0.066680908203125, + 0.04970789700746536, + 0.18743275105953217, + 0.02962457202374935 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 5, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029822388663887978 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a red retractable ballpoint pen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the pen made of polished crimson plastic with a gleaming metal clip and tip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pen tumbling and spinning in a desolate void with infinite blackness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single hard off-camera light source creating long sharp shadows and bright highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot as a static medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05495666712522507 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299566745758057 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05495666712522507, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05495666712522507, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04061849042773247, + 0.021752912551164627, + 0.029334023594856262, + 0.18376651406288147, + 0.07147134840488434, + 0.34966352581977844, + 0.0051294611766934395, + 0.04036230966448784, + 0.09766299277544022, + 0.16023842990398407 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05495666712522507 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a red retractable ballpoint pen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the pen made of polished crimson plastic with a gleaming metal clip and tip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pen tumbling and spinning in a desolate void with infinite blackness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single hard off-camera light source creating long sharp shadows and bright highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot as a static medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004633286036550999 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.37963342666626 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004633286036550999, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004633286036550999, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13809834420681, + 0.04990652948617935, + 0.018820764496922493, + 0.13620974123477936, + 0.12691232562065125, + 0.2660101354122162, + 0.02611781284213066, + 0.03461730480194092, + 0.06883936375379562, + 0.13446766138076782 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004633286036550999 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a red retractable ballpoint pen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the pen made of polished crimson plastic with a gleaming metal clip and tip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pen tumbling and spinning in a desolate void with infinite blackness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single hard off-camera light source creating long sharp shadows and bright highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot as a static medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05493003875017166 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299299716949463 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05493003875017166, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05493003875017166, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21639689803123474, + 0.014068320393562317, + 0.029212594032287598, + 0.10313177853822708, + 0.1407061368227005, + 0.10169786214828491, + 0.15485809743404388, + 0.03832912817597389, + 0.09011363238096237, + 0.11148560047149658 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05493003875017166 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static medium close-up depicts a red pen tumbling and spinning in a desolate void. The entire scene is filmed at a high frame rate, transforming the chaotic action into a slow, mesmerizing ballet. The pen, a retractable ballpoint made of polished crimson plastic, rotates gracefully. Demonic cinematic lighting, derived from a single, hard, off-camera light source, carves the object out of infinite blackness, casting long, sharp shadows across its own form and creating stark, bright highlights on its gleaming metal clip and tip. Every minute rotation and reflection is rendered in perfect, crystal-clear detail, capturing the hypnotic glow of the polished plastic and gleaming metal, creating an atmosphere both elegant and deeply unsettling as the pen turns relentlessly in the silent abyss.", + "seed": 30428, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_6/index_2521_seed_30428_dp_13_rank_26_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.06782322842627764, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06782322842627764, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.175, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06782322842627764, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a red retractable ballpoint pen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the pen made of polished crimson plastic with a gleaming metal clip and tip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pen tumbling and spinning in a desolate void with infinite blackness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single hard off-camera light source creating long sharp shadows and bright highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot as a static medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01669917441904545 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141699314117432 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01669917441904545, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01669917441904545, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0452735461294651, + 0.07756301015615463, + 0.022190529853105545, + 0.2164883315563202, + 0.16307486593723297, + 0.0459822341799736, + 0.04115463048219681, + 0.3224404752254486, + 0.02255685068666935, + 0.04327554255723953 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01669917441904545 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a red retractable ballpoint pen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the pen made of polished crimson plastic with a gleaming metal clip and tip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pen tumbling and spinning in a desolate void with infinite blackness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single hard off-camera light source creating long sharp shadows and bright highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot as a static medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05496862530708313 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299685955047607 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05496862530708313, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05496862530708313, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03269399702548981, + 0.09989963471889496, + 0.017621077597141266, + 0.14230361580848694, + 0.17084461450576782, + 0.33300715684890747, + 0.04201075807213783, + 0.11269118636846542, + 0.012267809361219406, + 0.036660175770521164 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05496862530708313 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a red retractable ballpoint pen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the pen made of polished crimson plastic with a gleaming metal clip and tip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pen tumbling and spinning in a desolate void with infinite blackness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single hard off-camera light source creating long sharp shadows and bright highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot as a static medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1798657476902008 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8048657178878784 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1798657476902008, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1798657476902008, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.02375715970993042, + 0.2501504421234131, + 0.02082456648349762, + 0.19056682288646698, + 0.27722832560539246, + 0.056935492902994156, + 0.0069746896624565125, + 0.10630030930042267, + 0.006306479685008526, + 0.06095577031373978 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1798657476902008 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a red retractable ballpoint pen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the pen made of polished crimson plastic with a gleaming metal clip and tip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pen tumbling and spinning in a desolate void with infinite blackness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single hard off-camera light source creating long sharp shadows and bright highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot as a static medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008634022437036037 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758634090423584 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008634022437036037, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008634022437036037, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.025657175108790398, + 0.21860571205615997, + 0.034038275480270386, + 0.1978299915790558, + 0.3491516709327698, + 0.05492941290140152, + 0.011026032269001007, + 0.04792069271206856, + 0.007787473499774933, + 0.053053565323352814 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008634022437036037 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a red retractable ballpoint pen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the pen made of polished crimson plastic with a gleaming metal clip and tip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pen tumbling and spinning in a desolate void with infinite blackness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single hard off-camera light source creating long sharp shadows and bright highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot as a static medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07894857227802277 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.578948497772217 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07894857227802277, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07894857227802277, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03425920754671097, + 0.08848276734352112, + 0.06061812862753868, + 0.20253624022006989, + 0.13209718465805054, + 0.043090227991342545, + 0.019575027748942375, + 0.3828980624675751, + 0.01059163361787796, + 0.02585146389901638 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07894857227802277 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static medium close-up depicts a red pen tumbling and spinning in a desolate void. The entire scene is filmed at a high frame rate, transforming the chaotic action into a slow, mesmerizing ballet. The pen, a retractable ballpoint made of polished crimson plastic, rotates gracefully. Demonic cinematic lighting, derived from a single, hard, off-camera light source, carves the object out of infinite blackness, casting long, sharp shadows across its own form and creating stark, bright highlights on its gleaming metal clip and tip. Every minute rotation and reflection is rendered in perfect, crystal-clear detail, capturing the hypnotic glow of the polished plastic and gleaming metal, creating an atmosphere both elegant and deeply unsettling as the pen turns relentlessly in the silent abyss.", + "seed": 30429, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_6/index_2521_seed_30429_dp_13_rank_26_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.07437074249610305, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07437074249610305, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.2, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07437074249610305, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a red retractable ballpoint pen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the pen made of polished crimson plastic with a gleaming metal clip and tip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pen tumbling and spinning in a desolate void with infinite blackness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single hard off-camera light source creating long sharp shadows and bright highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot as a static medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.027664562687277794 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6526646614074707 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.027664562687277794, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.027664562687277794, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08689336478710175, + 0.061482153832912445, + 0.33774706721305847, + 0.026348944753408432, + 0.03509674593806267, + 0.05915422737598419, + 0.01765451394021511, + 0.046371739357709885, + 0.22854213416576385, + 0.10070905089378357 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.027664562687277794 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a red retractable ballpoint pen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the pen made of polished crimson plastic with a gleaming metal clip and tip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pen tumbling and spinning in a desolate void with infinite blackness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single hard off-camera light source creating long sharp shadows and bright highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot as a static medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03372207283973694 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408722162246704 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03372207283973694, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03372207283973694, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12459556013345718, + 0.045108966529369354, + 0.11242931336164474, + 0.04350127652287483, + 0.03366418927907944, + 0.0707840621471405, + 0.02299010194838047, + 0.029711458832025528, + 0.31822457909584045, + 0.1989903748035431 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03372207283973694 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a red retractable ballpoint pen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the pen made of polished crimson plastic with a gleaming metal clip and tip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pen tumbling and spinning in a desolate void with infinite blackness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single hard off-camera light source creating long sharp shadows and bright highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot as a static medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.225570946931839 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6005709171295166 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.225570946931839, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.225570946931839, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12998105585575104, + 0.03259905427694321, + 0.05162537470459938, + 0.02330990508198738, + 0.033240508288145065, + 0.07783989608287811, + 0.013720763847231865, + 0.010426378808915615, + 0.27371296286582947, + 0.353544145822525 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.225570946931839 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a red retractable ballpoint pen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the pen made of polished crimson plastic with a gleaming metal clip and tip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pen tumbling and spinning in a desolate void with infinite blackness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single hard off-camera light source creating long sharp shadows and bright highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot as a static medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0059434822760522366 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130943298339844 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0059434822760522366, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0059434822760522366, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11169373244047165, + 0.02259567379951477, + 0.23402199149131775, + 0.023004300892353058, + 0.043967559933662415, + 0.05719109624624252, + 0.012448602356016636, + 0.01598178781569004, + 0.22171688079833984, + 0.25737839937210083 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 2, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0059434822760522366 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a red retractable ballpoint pen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the pen made of polished crimson plastic with a gleaming metal clip and tip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pen tumbling and spinning in a desolate void with infinite blackness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single hard off-camera light source creating long sharp shadows and bright highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot as a static medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07895264774560928 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5789525508880615 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07895264774560928, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07895264774560928, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2179044932126999, + 0.09754965454339981, + 0.05007303133606911, + 0.04502465948462486, + 0.03651893883943558, + 0.05611487105488777, + 0.06869874149560928, + 0.07565366476774216, + 0.15045718848705292, + 0.2020048350095749 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07895264774560928 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_7/index_tensor([35, 35])_group_7_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_7/index_tensor([35, 35])_group_7_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..078e47fb2707f149bd18480bd0053d2e99d18274 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_7/index_tensor([35, 35])_group_7_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "highly dynamic first-person perspective shot places the viewer directly in the cockpit of a high-tech, specialized polar transport vehicle. The camera, with its wide-angle perspective, moves forward steadily and smoothly, as if supported by a top-tier gyroscopic stabilizer, imbued with the high-definition quality of an Olympic-level broadcast. At the bottom of the frame, the vehicle's massive tracks, constructed from black composite materials with metal hinges, dominate the field of view, their deep V-shaped patterns leaving a distinct imprint on the ground. As the vehicle moves forward with steady yet powerful force, the tracks cut deeply into the boundless, pure white snowfield, powerfully stirring and sweeping back vast clouds of shimmering snow and fine ice crystals. In the clear, cold polar sunlight, these flying snow particles refract like diamonds. As the vehicle reaches the edge of a magnificent glacier, its deep, crystalline blue ice looming below the cliffs, the vehicle executes an impeccable U-turn: the camera pans along with the vehicle in a grand, silky arc, one track slowing while the other powerfully propels it forward, carving a perfect semicircle across the vast snowy landscape with a display of absolute control. The entire sequence is imbued with unparalleled dynamic cinematography, seamlessly blending the power and precision of the machinery with the grandeur and harshness of the polar environment, creating a thrilling, epic atmosphere of exploration and conquest.", + "seed": 19315, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_7/index_35_seed_19315_dp_14_rank_28_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.03943862160667777, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03943862160667777, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.5, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03943862160667777, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective inside the cockpit of a vehicle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the vehicle's massive black composite tracks with metal hinges visible at the bottom of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the vehicle move forward steadily, cutting deep into a pure white snowfield and stirring clouds of snow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the vehicle execute a U-turn at the edge of a glacier with deep crystalline blue ice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan in a silky arc along with the vehicle during the U-turn?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0829499363899231 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5829498767852783 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0829499363899231, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0829499363899231, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1612643599510193, + 0.05588632822036743, + 0.14889267086982727, + 0.09253975003957748, + 0.12166395783424377, + 0.08506567031145096, + 0.15268900990486145, + 0.0634341612458229, + 0.09453438222408295, + 0.02402970753610134 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0829499363899231 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective inside the cockpit of a vehicle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the vehicle's massive black composite tracks with metal hinges visible at the bottom of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the vehicle move forward steadily, cutting deep into a pure white snowfield and stirring clouds of snow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the vehicle execute a U-turn at the edge of a glacier with deep crystalline blue ice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan in a silky arc along with the vehicle during the U-turn?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.038116004317998886 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288115978240967 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.038116004317998886, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.038116004317998886, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11371766030788422, + 0.13999685645103455, + 0.2069108933210373, + 0.16105669736862183, + 0.09398777037858963, + 0.05024084821343422, + 0.06747383624315262, + 0.05862779915332794, + 0.04298722371459007, + 0.06500045955181122 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.038116004317998886 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective inside the cockpit of a vehicle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the vehicle's massive black composite tracks with metal hinges visible at the bottom of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the vehicle move forward steadily, cutting deep into a pure white snowfield and stirring clouds of snow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the vehicle execute a U-turn at the edge of a glacier with deep crystalline blue ice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan in a silky arc along with the vehicle during the U-turn?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04304547235369682 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680455207824707 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04304547235369682, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04304547235369682, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10764770209789276, + 0.0760955661535263, + 0.16305291652679443, + 0.0490163154900074, + 0.2962530851364136, + 0.05580788478255272, + 0.08407845348119736, + 0.07705065608024597, + 0.0570179745554924, + 0.033979449421167374 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04304547235369682 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective inside the cockpit of a vehicle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the vehicle's massive black composite tracks with metal hinges visible at the bottom of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the vehicle move forward steadily, cutting deep into a pure white snowfield and stirring clouds of snow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the vehicle execute a U-turn at the edge of a glacier with deep crystalline blue ice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan in a silky arc along with the vehicle during the U-turn?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02634515054523945 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513452529907227 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02634515054523945, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02634515054523945, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07834317535161972, + 0.06400976330041885, + 0.1353798508644104, + 0.15659016370773315, + 0.22866587340831757, + 0.049582887440919876, + 0.11412326246500015, + 0.050602447241544724, + 0.062088493257761, + 0.06061409413814545 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02634515054523945 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective inside the cockpit of a vehicle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the vehicle's massive black composite tracks with metal hinges visible at the bottom of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the vehicle move forward steadily, cutting deep into a pure white snowfield and stirring clouds of snow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the vehicle execute a U-turn at the edge of a glacier with deep crystalline blue ice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan in a silky arc along with the vehicle during the U-turn?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0067365444265306 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006736755371094 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0067365444265306, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0067365444265306, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10254092514514923, + 0.05719491466879845, + 0.21966315805912018, + 0.1826721578836441, + 0.0708325058221817, + 0.0720280259847641, + 0.11820046603679657, + 0.040651530027389526, + 0.0702052190899849, + 0.06601110100746155 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0067365444265306 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "highly dynamic first-person perspective shot places the viewer directly in the cockpit of a high-tech, specialized polar transport vehicle. The camera, with its wide-angle perspective, moves forward steadily and smoothly, as if supported by a top-tier gyroscopic stabilizer, imbued with the high-definition quality of an Olympic-level broadcast. At the bottom of the frame, the vehicle's massive tracks, constructed from black composite materials with metal hinges, dominate the field of view, their deep V-shaped patterns leaving a distinct imprint on the ground. As the vehicle moves forward with steady yet powerful force, the tracks cut deeply into the boundless, pure white snowfield, powerfully stirring and sweeping back vast clouds of shimmering snow and fine ice crystals. In the clear, cold polar sunlight, these flying snow particles refract like diamonds. As the vehicle reaches the edge of a magnificent glacier, its deep, crystalline blue ice looming below the cliffs, the vehicle executes an impeccable U-turn: the camera pans along with the vehicle in a grand, silky arc, one track slowing while the other powerfully propels it forward, carving a perfect semicircle across the vast snowy landscape with a display of absolute control. The entire sequence is imbued with unparalleled dynamic cinematography, seamlessly blending the power and precision of the machinery with the grandeur and harshness of the polar environment, creating a thrilling, epic atmosphere of exploration and conquest.", + "seed": 19316, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_7/index_35_seed_19316_dp_14_rank_28_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.0625702751800418, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0625702751800418, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.525, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0625702751800418, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective inside the cockpit of a vehicle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the vehicle's massive black composite tracks with metal hinges visible at the bottom of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the vehicle move forward steadily, cutting deep into a pure white snowfield and stirring clouds of snow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the vehicle execute a U-turn at the edge of a glacier with deep crystalline blue ice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan in a silky arc along with the vehicle during the U-turn?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.18888631463050842 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.813886284828186 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.18888631463050842, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.18888631463050842, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11061941832304001, + 0.026747627183794975, + 0.007061045616865158, + 0.042090024799108505, + 0.01989930495619774, + 0.413530170917511, + 0.06707915663719177, + 0.040143873542547226, + 0.1318870633840561, + 0.14094232022762299 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.18888631463050842 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective inside the cockpit of a vehicle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the vehicle's massive black composite tracks with metal hinges visible at the bottom of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the vehicle move forward steadily, cutting deep into a pure white snowfield and stirring clouds of snow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the vehicle execute a U-turn at the edge of a glacier with deep crystalline blue ice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan in a silky arc along with the vehicle during the U-turn?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0041169896721839905 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504117012023926 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0041169896721839905, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0041169896721839905, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.29854944348335266, + 0.05578894913196564, + 0.028655465692281723, + 0.02467331290245056, + 0.020329028367996216, + 0.22081662714481354, + 0.07928679883480072, + 0.0194737296551466, + 0.041621945798397064, + 0.21080471575260162 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0041169896721839905 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective inside the cockpit of a vehicle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the vehicle's massive black composite tracks with metal hinges visible at the bottom of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the vehicle move forward steadily, cutting deep into a pure white snowfield and stirring clouds of snow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the vehicle execute a U-turn at the edge of a glacier with deep crystalline blue ice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan in a silky arc along with the vehicle during the U-turn?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029794966802001 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529794931411743 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029794966802001, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029794966802001, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16837909817695618, + 0.03226857632398605, + 0.02131197415292263, + 0.05443236976861954, + 0.024737253785133362, + 0.2573752701282501, + 0.21339178085327148, + 0.08723272383213043, + 0.043949831277132034, + 0.09692109376192093 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029794966802001 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective inside the cockpit of a vehicle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the vehicle's massive black composite tracks with metal hinges visible at the bottom of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the vehicle move forward steadily, cutting deep into a pure white snowfield and stirring clouds of snow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the vehicle execute a U-turn at the edge of a glacier with deep crystalline blue ice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan in a silky arc along with the vehicle during the U-turn?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07897600531578064 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5789759159088135 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07897600531578064, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07897600531578064, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10412505269050598, + 0.02977626398205757, + 0.014623287133872509, + 0.16963593661785126, + 0.038035549223423004, + 0.30802297592163086, + 0.024595296010375023, + 0.044278863817453384, + 0.07994750142097473, + 0.18695931136608124 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07897600531578064 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective inside the cockpit of a vehicle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the vehicle's massive black composite tracks with metal hinges visible at the bottom of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the vehicle move forward steadily, cutting deep into a pure white snowfield and stirring clouds of snow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the vehicle execute a U-turn at the edge of a glacier with deep crystalline blue ice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan in a silky arc along with the vehicle during the U-turn?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011077099479734898 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511076927185059 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011077099479734898, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011077099479734898, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1753319948911667, + 0.03825322911143303, + 0.02414972521364689, + 0.0697723850607872, + 0.031431831419467926, + 0.18231500685214996, + 0.13498906791210175, + 0.03423662483692169, + 0.14124895632266998, + 0.16827121376991272 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011077099479734898 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "highly dynamic first-person perspective shot places the viewer directly in the cockpit of a high-tech, specialized polar transport vehicle. The camera, with its wide-angle perspective, moves forward steadily and smoothly, as if supported by a top-tier gyroscopic stabilizer, imbued with the high-definition quality of an Olympic-level broadcast. At the bottom of the frame, the vehicle's massive tracks, constructed from black composite materials with metal hinges, dominate the field of view, their deep V-shaped patterns leaving a distinct imprint on the ground. As the vehicle moves forward with steady yet powerful force, the tracks cut deeply into the boundless, pure white snowfield, powerfully stirring and sweeping back vast clouds of shimmering snow and fine ice crystals. In the clear, cold polar sunlight, these flying snow particles refract like diamonds. As the vehicle reaches the edge of a magnificent glacier, its deep, crystalline blue ice looming below the cliffs, the vehicle executes an impeccable U-turn: the camera pans along with the vehicle in a grand, silky arc, one track slowing while the other powerfully propels it forward, carving a perfect semicircle across the vast snowy landscape with a display of absolute control. The entire sequence is imbued with unparalleled dynamic cinematography, seamlessly blending the power and precision of the machinery with the grandeur and harshness of the polar environment, creating a thrilling, epic atmosphere of exploration and conquest.", + "seed": 19317, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_7/index_35_seed_19317_dp_15_rank_30_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.18791374564170837, + "vlm_logprob": -0.18791374564170837, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.85, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.18791374564170837, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective inside the cockpit of a vehicle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the vehicle's massive black composite tracks with metal hinges visible at the bottom of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the vehicle move forward steadily, cutting deep into a pure white snowfield and stirring clouds of snow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the vehicle execute a U-turn at the edge of a glacier with deep crystalline blue ice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan in a silky arc along with the vehicle during the U-turn?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3239116966724396 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3239116668701172 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3239116966724396, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3239116966724396, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3479660153388977, + 0.06770424544811249, + 0.06053129956126213, + 0.03866780921816826, + 0.022646605968475342, + 0.053986240178346634, + 0.23034662008285522, + 0.06923458725214005, + 0.05836723372340202, + 0.05054928734898567 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3239116966724396 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective inside the cockpit of a vehicle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the vehicle's massive black composite tracks with metal hinges visible at the bottom of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the vehicle move forward steadily, cutting deep into a pure white snowfield and stirring clouds of snow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the vehicle execute a U-turn at the edge of a glacier with deep crystalline blue ice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan in a silky arc along with the vehicle during the U-turn?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014223741367459297 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264223575592041 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014223741367459297, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014223741367459297, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3530496060848236, + 0.09733971208333969, + 0.05066683888435364, + 0.046633340418338776, + 0.08009713143110275, + 0.06403601914644241, + 0.0911528617143631, + 0.13721269369125366, + 0.051422879099845886, + 0.028388988226652145 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014223741367459297 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective inside the cockpit of a vehicle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the vehicle's massive black composite tracks with metal hinges visible at the bottom of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the vehicle move forward steadily, cutting deep into a pure white snowfield and stirring clouds of snow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the vehicle execute a U-turn at the edge of a glacier with deep crystalline blue ice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan in a silky arc along with the vehicle during the U-turn?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014193302020430565 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264193534851074 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014193302020430565, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014193302020430565, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.37349361181259155, + 0.08932814747095108, + 0.05330909043550491, + 0.045255593955516815, + 0.04699490964412689, + 0.07089436799287796, + 0.067022405564785, + 0.041711386293172836, + 0.0802840068936348, + 0.13170641660690308 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014193302020430565 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective inside the cockpit of a vehicle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the vehicle's massive black composite tracks with metal hinges visible at the bottom of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the vehicle move forward steadily, cutting deep into a pure white snowfield and stirring clouds of snow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the vehicle execute a U-turn at the edge of a glacier with deep crystalline blue ice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan in a silky arc along with the vehicle during the U-turn?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5761587619781494 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8261587619781494 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5761587619781494, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5761587619781494, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.29875534772872925, + 0.07136761397123337, + 0.034199558198451996, + 0.02003319375216961, + 0.029907457530498505, + 0.027818158268928528, + 0.061504069715738297, + 0.35600176453590393, + 0.06202518194913864, + 0.038387659937143326 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5761587619781494 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective inside the cockpit of a vehicle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the vehicle's massive black composite tracks with metal hinges visible at the bottom of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the vehicle move forward steadily, cutting deep into a pure white snowfield and stirring clouds of snow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the vehicle execute a U-turn at the edge of a glacier with deep crystalline blue ice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan in a silky arc along with the vehicle during the U-turn?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011081226170063019 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511081218719482 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011081226170063019, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011081226170063019, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.29573673009872437, + 0.08695600926876068, + 0.03769967705011368, + 0.02940724417567253, + 0.06291060149669647, + 0.07501288503408432, + 0.15540911257266998, + 0.09799577295780182, + 0.11977215856313705, + 0.03909981995820999 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011081226170063019 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "highly dynamic first-person perspective shot places the viewer directly in the cockpit of a high-tech, specialized polar transport vehicle. The camera, with its wide-angle perspective, moves forward steadily and smoothly, as if supported by a top-tier gyroscopic stabilizer, imbued with the high-definition quality of an Olympic-level broadcast. At the bottom of the frame, the vehicle's massive tracks, constructed from black composite materials with metal hinges, dominate the field of view, their deep V-shaped patterns leaving a distinct imprint on the ground. As the vehicle moves forward with steady yet powerful force, the tracks cut deeply into the boundless, pure white snowfield, powerfully stirring and sweeping back vast clouds of shimmering snow and fine ice crystals. In the clear, cold polar sunlight, these flying snow particles refract like diamonds. As the vehicle reaches the edge of a magnificent glacier, its deep, crystalline blue ice looming below the cliffs, the vehicle executes an impeccable U-turn: the camera pans along with the vehicle in a grand, silky arc, one track slowing while the other powerfully propels it forward, carving a perfect semicircle across the vast snowy landscape with a display of absolute control. The entire sequence is imbued with unparalleled dynamic cinematography, seamlessly blending the power and precision of the machinery with the grandeur and harshness of the polar environment, creating a thrilling, epic atmosphere of exploration and conquest.", + "seed": 19318, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_7/index_35_seed_19318_dp_15_rank_30_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.04896891573444009, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04896891573444009, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.5, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04896891573444009, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective inside the cockpit of a vehicle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the vehicle's massive black composite tracks with metal hinges visible at the bottom of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the vehicle move forward steadily, cutting deep into a pure white snowfield and stirring clouds of snow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the vehicle execute a U-turn at the edge of a glacier with deep crystalline blue ice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan in a silky arc along with the vehicle during the U-turn?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14707663655281067 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0220766067504883 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14707663655281067, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14707663655281067, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06552679091691971, + 0.04544489085674286, + 0.21533051133155823, + 0.06766636669635773, + 0.04816225543618202, + 0.04052494093775749, + 0.04074268415570259, + 0.21497051417827606, + 0.1922958493232727, + 0.0693352147936821 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14707663655281067 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective inside the cockpit of a vehicle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the vehicle's massive black composite tracks with metal hinges visible at the bottom of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the vehicle move forward steadily, cutting deep into a pure white snowfield and stirring clouds of snow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the vehicle execute a U-turn at the edge of a glacier with deep crystalline blue ice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan in a silky arc along with the vehicle during the U-turn?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023301351815462112 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773301362991333 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023301351815462112, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023301351815462112, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16189536452293396, + 0.026293843984603882, + 0.12776951491832733, + 0.024525491520762444, + 0.05077517777681351, + 0.03206491097807884, + 0.025739148259162903, + 0.04039529338479042, + 0.43236199021339417, + 0.078179270029068 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023301351815462112 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective inside the cockpit of a vehicle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the vehicle's massive black composite tracks with metal hinges visible at the bottom of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the vehicle move forward steadily, cutting deep into a pure white snowfield and stirring clouds of snow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the vehicle execute a U-turn at the edge of a glacier with deep crystalline blue ice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan in a silky arc along with the vehicle during the U-turn?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01818273961544037 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018182754516602 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01818273961544037, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01818273961544037, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2207309603691101, + 0.044818781316280365, + 0.21046020090579987, + 0.08906050771474838, + 0.05398532375693321, + 0.04756386578083038, + 0.03899310901761055, + 0.09484407305717468, + 0.13731200993061066, + 0.062231145799160004 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01818273961544037 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective inside the cockpit of a vehicle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the vehicle's massive black composite tracks with metal hinges visible at the bottom of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the vehicle move forward steadily, cutting deep into a pure white snowfield and stirring clouds of snow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the vehicle execute a U-turn at the edge of a glacier with deep crystalline blue ice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan in a silky arc along with the vehicle during the U-turn?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04865182563662529 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048651933670044 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04865182563662529, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04865182563662529, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15321719646453857, + 0.08741311728954315, + 0.11516516655683517, + 0.0820399597287178, + 0.046253081411123276, + 0.058424074202775955, + 0.048278093338012695, + 0.12554089725017548, + 0.12573249638080597, + 0.15793590247631073 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04865182563662529 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective inside the cockpit of a vehicle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the vehicle's massive black composite tracks with metal hinges visible at the bottom of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the vehicle move forward steadily, cutting deep into a pure white snowfield and stirring clouds of snow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the vehicle execute a U-turn at the edge of a glacier with deep crystalline blue ice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan in a silky arc along with the vehicle during the U-turn?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007632025051862001 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882632255554199 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007632025051862001, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007632025051862001, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2370758056640625, + 0.09646198898553848, + 0.12457412481307983, + 0.132978618144989, + 0.02937166579067707, + 0.1213138997554779, + 0.03982406482100487, + 0.10399629175662994, + 0.054261188954114914, + 0.06014236807823181 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007632025051862001 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_8/index_tensor([2566, 2566])_group_8_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_8/index_tensor([2566, 2566])_group_8_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..aaac4ac31661e08b886b30a28bf522b9358c57df --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_8/index_tensor([2566, 2566])_group_8_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "dynamic tracking shot, filmed from a low angle, follows an ornate carriage as it speeds along a dry, dirt country road. The carriage, with its crimson lacquer and intricately carved gold trim, gleams luxuriously in the evening sun. Four powerful, glossy, dark brown horses gallop with gusto, their muscles straining, the brass fittings of their leather harnesses swaying with their movements. The driver, dressed in a dark uniform and a top hat, maintains a focused and resolute expression as he grips the reins, his body swaying with the carriage's violent jolting. Massive wooden wheels, rimmed with iron hoops, spin at high speed, rolling over the ground, flinging loose dirt and gravel backward and raising a thick, tawny cloud of dust. This cloud, pierced by golden sunlight and shimmering with halos at the edges, trails behind the carriage like a magnificent tail, nearly engulfing the green hills and winding road in the distance. The whole picture presents a tense atmosphere full of dramatic tension, speed and retro luxury in the warm light and shadow.", + "seed": 30625, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_8/index_2566_seed_30625_dp_16_rank_32_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.03934123674407601, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03934123674407601, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.824999952316284, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03934123674407601, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an ornate carriage with crimson lacquer and gold trim?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are four dark brown horses galloping in front of the carriage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a driver wearing a dark uniform and top hat visible holding the reins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a dry dirt country road with green hills in the distance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot filmed from a low angle with a dynamic tracking motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03424312546849251 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.409243106842041 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03424312546849251, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03424312546849251, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06520705670118332, + 0.019909527152776718, + 0.07360033690929413, + 0.4712855815887451, + 0.06320864707231522, + 0.033264242112636566, + 0.07858828455209732, + 0.03225347399711609, + 0.08569152653217316, + 0.07699129730463028 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03424312546849251 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an ornate carriage with crimson lacquer and gold trim?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are four dark brown horses galloping in front of the carriage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a driver wearing a dark uniform and top hat visible holding the reins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a dry dirt country road with green hills in the distance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot filmed from a low angle with a dynamic tracking motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12710264325141907 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1271026134490967 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12710264325141907, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12710264325141907, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06725016981363297, + 0.035284049808979034, + 0.060066234320402145, + 0.27083900570869446, + 0.08276703208684921, + 0.03873966634273529, + 0.053492628037929535, + 0.03628229349851608, + 0.2615935504436493, + 0.09368535876274109 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12710264325141907 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an ornate carriage with crimson lacquer and gold trim?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are four dark brown horses galloping in front of the carriage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a driver wearing a dark uniform and top hat visible holding the reins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a dry dirt country road with green hills in the distance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot filmed from a low angle with a dynamic tracking motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018189646303653717 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018189430236816 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018189646303653717, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018189646303653717, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1884436160326004, + 0.0397602804005146, + 0.043986976146698, + 0.19149528443813324, + 0.05837375298142433, + 0.06319189071655273, + 0.11048167198896408, + 0.03730403631925583, + 0.1929638683795929, + 0.0739985927939415 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018189646303653717 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an ornate carriage with crimson lacquer and gold trim?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are four dark brown horses galloping in front of the carriage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a driver wearing a dark uniform and top hat visible holding the reins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a dry dirt country road with green hills in the distance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot filmed from a low angle with a dynamic tracking motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004634591285139322 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379634380340576 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004634591285139322, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004634591285139322, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12631557881832123, + 0.037863027304410934, + 0.020170850679278374, + 0.2790682911872864, + 0.11442328244447708, + 0.06212308630347252, + 0.03111531026661396, + 0.015889840200543404, + 0.03675316646695137, + 0.2762775719165802 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004634591285139322 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an ornate carriage with crimson lacquer and gold trim?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are four dark brown horses galloping in front of the carriage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a driver wearing a dark uniform and top hat visible holding the reins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a dry dirt country road with green hills in the distance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot filmed from a low angle with a dynamic tracking motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012536177411675453 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.38753604888916 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012536177411675453, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012536177411675453, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03808027133345604, + 0.02486966736614704, + 0.027088569477200508, + 0.5530162453651428, + 0.08599770814180374, + 0.02885955199599266, + 0.0471949502825737, + 0.023286068812012672, + 0.06949647516012192, + 0.10211049020290375 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012536177411675453 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dynamic tracking shot, filmed from a low angle, follows an ornate carriage as it speeds along a dry, dirt country road. The carriage, with its crimson lacquer and intricately carved gold trim, gleams luxuriously in the evening sun. Four powerful, glossy, dark brown horses gallop with gusto, their muscles straining, the brass fittings of their leather harnesses swaying with their movements. The driver, dressed in a dark uniform and a top hat, maintains a focused and resolute expression as he grips the reins, his body swaying with the carriage's violent jolting. Massive wooden wheels, rimmed with iron hoops, spin at high speed, rolling over the ground, flinging loose dirt and gravel backward and raising a thick, tawny cloud of dust. This cloud, pierced by golden sunlight and shimmering with halos at the edges, trails behind the carriage like a magnificent tail, nearly engulfing the green hills and winding road in the distance. The whole picture presents a tense atmosphere full of dramatic tension, speed and retro luxury in the warm light and shadow.", + "seed": 30626, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_8/index_2566_seed_30626_dp_16_rank_32_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.06035699993371964, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06035699993371964, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.449999952316284, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06035699993371964, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an ornate carriage with crimson lacquer and gold trim?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are four dark brown horses galloping in front of the carriage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a driver wearing a dark uniform and top hat visible holding the reins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a dry dirt country road with green hills in the distance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot filmed from a low angle with a dynamic tracking motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018621506169438362 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018621444702148 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018621506169438362, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018621506169438362, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10962659120559692, + 0.0755978524684906, + 0.11067444831132889, + 0.07212121039628983, + 0.05646390840411186, + 0.21704375743865967, + 0.05190611258149147, + 0.08154632151126862, + 0.12116943299770355, + 0.10385031253099442 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018621506169438362 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an ornate carriage with crimson lacquer and gold trim?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are four dark brown horses galloping in front of the carriage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a driver wearing a dark uniform and top hat visible holding the reins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a dry dirt country road with green hills in the distance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot filmed from a low angle with a dynamic tracking motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.225610613822937 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.600610613822937 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.225610613822937, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.225610613822937, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21002312004566193, + 0.12740084528923035, + 0.04791688174009323, + 0.05763332173228264, + 0.03912922739982605, + 0.19104325771331787, + 0.033931244164705276, + 0.136383518576622, + 0.07189679145812988, + 0.08464181423187256 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.225610613822937 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an ornate carriage with crimson lacquer and gold trim?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are four dark brown horses galloping in front of the carriage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a driver wearing a dark uniform and top hat visible holding the reins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a dry dirt country road with green hills in the distance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot filmed from a low angle with a dynamic tracking motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018194327130913734 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018194198608398 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018194327130913734, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018194327130913734, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14492063224315643, + 0.20677486062049866, + 0.11114635318517685, + 0.08591694384813309, + 0.048394374549388885, + 0.13482165336608887, + 0.05193856731057167, + 0.09695760905742645, + 0.06094961240887642, + 0.05817941948771477 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018194327130913734 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an ornate carriage with crimson lacquer and gold trim?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are four dark brown horses galloping in front of the carriage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a driver wearing a dark uniform and top hat visible holding the reins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a dry dirt country road with green hills in the distance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot filmed from a low angle with a dynamic tracking motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01607036218047142 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141070365905762 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01607036218047142, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01607036218047142, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20276214182376862, + 0.057873982936143875, + 0.09147626906633377, + 0.055653247982263565, + 0.03233744576573372, + 0.11812075972557068, + 0.050296735018491745, + 0.06925877928733826, + 0.16133619844913483, + 0.16088441014289856 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01607036218047142 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an ornate carriage with crimson lacquer and gold trim?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are four dark brown horses galloping in front of the carriage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a driver wearing a dark uniform and top hat visible holding the reins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a dry dirt country road with green hills in the distance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot filmed from a low angle with a dynamic tracking motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023288190364837646 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732882499694824 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023288190364837646, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023288190364837646, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10788723826408386, + 0.06076043099164963, + 0.0939699336886406, + 0.049211617559194565, + 0.03371020779013634, + 0.09232766926288605, + 0.08080827444791794, + 0.1350039839744568, + 0.12811565399169922, + 0.218205064535141 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023288190364837646 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dynamic tracking shot, filmed from a low angle, follows an ornate carriage as it speeds along a dry, dirt country road. The carriage, with its crimson lacquer and intricately carved gold trim, gleams luxuriously in the evening sun. Four powerful, glossy, dark brown horses gallop with gusto, their muscles straining, the brass fittings of their leather harnesses swaying with their movements. The driver, dressed in a dark uniform and a top hat, maintains a focused and resolute expression as he grips the reins, his body swaying with the carriage's violent jolting. Massive wooden wheels, rimmed with iron hoops, spin at high speed, rolling over the ground, flinging loose dirt and gravel backward and raising a thick, tawny cloud of dust. This cloud, pierced by golden sunlight and shimmering with halos at the edges, trails behind the carriage like a magnificent tail, nearly engulfing the green hills and winding road in the distance. The whole picture presents a tense atmosphere full of dramatic tension, speed and retro luxury in the warm light and shadow.", + "seed": 30627, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_8/index_2566_seed_30627_dp_17_rank_34_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.027325637452304364, + "vlm_logprob": -0.027325637452304364, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.85, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.027325637452304364, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an ornate carriage with crimson lacquer and gold trim?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are four dark brown horses galloping in front of the carriage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a driver wearing a dark uniform and top hat visible holding the reins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a dry dirt country road with green hills in the distance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot filmed from a low angle with a dynamic tracking motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.021129975095391273 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.896130084991455 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.021129975095391273, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.021129975095391273, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.26803815364837646, + 0.04951048642396927, + 0.0427418127655983, + 0.09515092521905899, + 0.13904578983783722, + 0.04700693115592003, + 0.0522494837641716, + 0.04246193543076515, + 0.19079335033893585, + 0.07300107926130295 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.021129975095391273 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an ornate carriage with crimson lacquer and gold trim?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are four dark brown horses galloping in front of the carriage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a driver wearing a dark uniform and top hat visible holding the reins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a dry dirt country road with green hills in the distance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot filmed from a low angle with a dynamic tracking motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06208738684654236 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812087297439575 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06208738684654236, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06208738684654236, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2322968989610672, + 0.06418721377849579, + 0.09904780983924866, + 0.042903076857328415, + 0.21048785746097565, + 0.06795670837163925, + 0.1172068864107132, + 0.03222311660647392, + 0.09921518713235855, + 0.03447520732879639 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06208738684654236 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an ornate carriage with crimson lacquer and gold trim?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are four dark brown horses galloping in front of the carriage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a driver wearing a dark uniform and top hat visible holding the reins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a dry dirt country road with green hills in the distance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot filmed from a low angle with a dynamic tracking motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011079810559749603 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511079788208008 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011079810559749603, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011079810559749603, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2563343942165375, + 0.059733059257268906, + 0.04868378862738609, + 0.09683538228273392, + 0.09195359796285629, + 0.13322927057743073, + 0.09163559973239899, + 0.09211420267820358, + 0.09129910916090012, + 0.03818153589963913 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011079810559749603 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an ornate carriage with crimson lacquer and gold trim?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are four dark brown horses galloping in front of the carriage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a driver wearing a dark uniform and top hat visible holding the reins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a dry dirt country road with green hills in the distance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot filmed from a low angle with a dynamic tracking motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008635913021862507 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758635997772217 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008635913021862507, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008635913021862507, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.7263464331626892, + 0.042752522975206375, + 0.037054240703582764, + 0.012571296654641628, + 0.026029644533991814, + 0.030752157792448997, + 0.03924570232629776, + 0.017685191705822945, + 0.045021843165159225, + 0.022540943697094917 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008635913021862507 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an ornate carriage with crimson lacquer and gold trim?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are four dark brown horses galloping in front of the carriage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a driver wearing a dark uniform and top hat visible holding the reins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a dry dirt country road with green hills in the distance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot filmed from a low angle with a dynamic tracking motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.033695101737976074 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4086952209472656 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.033695101737976074, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.033695101737976074, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2152782380580902, + 0.08430670201778412, + 0.10612909495830536, + 0.06946247071027756, + 0.06531108915805817, + 0.05211874842643738, + 0.16623400151729584, + 0.03422845900058746, + 0.1476401537656784, + 0.059291038662195206 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.033695101737976074 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dynamic tracking shot, filmed from a low angle, follows an ornate carriage as it speeds along a dry, dirt country road. The carriage, with its crimson lacquer and intricately carved gold trim, gleams luxuriously in the evening sun. Four powerful, glossy, dark brown horses gallop with gusto, their muscles straining, the brass fittings of their leather harnesses swaying with their movements. The driver, dressed in a dark uniform and a top hat, maintains a focused and resolute expression as he grips the reins, his body swaying with the carriage's violent jolting. Massive wooden wheels, rimmed with iron hoops, spin at high speed, rolling over the ground, flinging loose dirt and gravel backward and raising a thick, tawny cloud of dust. This cloud, pierced by golden sunlight and shimmering with halos at the edges, trails behind the carriage like a magnificent tail, nearly engulfing the green hills and winding road in the distance. The whole picture presents a tense atmosphere full of dramatic tension, speed and retro luxury in the warm light and shadow.", + "seed": 30628, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_8/index_2566_seed_30628_dp_17_rank_34_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.03192656366154552, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03192656366154552, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.8, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03192656366154552, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an ornate carriage with crimson lacquer and gold trim?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are four dark brown horses galloping in front of the carriage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a driver wearing a dark uniform and top hat visible holding the reins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a dry dirt country road with green hills in the distance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot filmed from a low angle with a dynamic tracking motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011370617896318436 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511370658874512 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011370617896318436, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011370617896318436, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2838774621486664, + 0.07767625153064728, + 0.08169632405042648, + 0.1275777518749237, + 0.1573438048362732, + 0.04927126318216324, + 0.04374069720506668, + 0.026434922590851784, + 0.04614051431417465, + 0.10624098777770996 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011370617896318436 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an ornate carriage with crimson lacquer and gold trim?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are four dark brown horses galloping in front of the carriage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a driver wearing a dark uniform and top hat visible holding the reins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a dry dirt country road with green hills in the distance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot filmed from a low angle with a dynamic tracking motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05498306825757027 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929983139038086 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05498306825757027, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05498306825757027, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23296158015727997, + 0.2741299271583557, + 0.06888710707426071, + 0.09169593453407288, + 0.06389287859201431, + 0.029386872425675392, + 0.05605076625943184, + 0.07086697965860367, + 0.032997678965330124, + 0.07913025468587875 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05498306825757027 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an ornate carriage with crimson lacquer and gold trim?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are four dark brown horses galloping in front of the carriage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a driver wearing a dark uniform and top hat visible holding the reins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a dry dirt country road with green hills in the distance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot filmed from a low angle with a dynamic tracking motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03369786962866783 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4086978435516357 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03369786962866783, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03369786962866783, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1462150514125824, + 0.1357884556055069, + 0.064518041908741, + 0.07649398595094681, + 0.05631830543279648, + 0.025715868920087814, + 0.042977649718523026, + 0.05108119547367096, + 0.05276118963956833, + 0.34813031554222107 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03369786962866783 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an ornate carriage with crimson lacquer and gold trim?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are four dark brown horses galloping in front of the carriage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a driver wearing a dark uniform and top hat visible holding the reins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a dry dirt country road with green hills in the distance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot filmed from a low angle with a dynamic tracking motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0046355403028428555 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379635334014893 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0046355403028428555, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0046355403028428555, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15552638471126556, + 0.027511127293109894, + 0.060413479804992676, + 0.09711169451475143, + 0.13462495803833008, + 0.2393423169851303, + 0.019521564245224, + 0.08441366255283356, + 0.04178392514586449, + 0.1397509127855301 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0046355403028428555 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an ornate carriage with crimson lacquer and gold trim?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are four dark brown horses galloping in front of the carriage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a driver wearing a dark uniform and top hat visible holding the reins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a dry dirt country road with green hills in the distance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot filmed from a low angle with a dynamic tracking motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.054945722222328186 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929945707321167 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.054945722222328186, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.054945722222328186, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09077427536249161, + 0.042319584637880325, + 0.07382618635892868, + 0.16036023199558258, + 0.14886684715747833, + 0.03406878560781479, + 0.05588292330503464, + 0.021096643060445786, + 0.19663792848587036, + 0.17616648972034454 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.054945722222328186 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_9/index_tensor([5068, 5068])_group_9_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_9/index_tensor([5068, 5068])_group_9_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..7ab6e876dd3612b8fcadcb95246d02d537634bc2 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_9/index_tensor([5068, 5068])_group_9_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "continuous, fluid close-up glides smoothly, closely following the precise, coordinated hand movements of two scientists as they work together on a complex holographic interface. The primary focus is on one of the scientists, her dark hair neatly tied in a bun, her face a look of intense concentration. She wears a wrinkle-free, pure white, high-tech lab coat, a dark gray turtleneck peeking out from beneath. Her fingers, and those of her collaborator beside her, dance gracefully in the air, pinching and zooming, sliding and rotating, collectively manipulating a luminous three-dimensional projection suspended between them, composed of countless translucent data streams and swirling molecular models. The holographic interface serves as the scene's primary light source, casting an ethereal, cool hue of cyan and electric blue onto their focused faces and hands, highlighting the subtle textures of their skin and the pristine texture of their lab coats. Against the softly out-of-focus background, the futuristic, sterile laboratory, with its polished white composite surfaces and minimalist design, looms, bathed in shadowless clinical white light from overhead LED panels. The cool color temperature of the entire scene creates an atmosphere of intense, quiet concentration and cutting-edge technological precision, where every gesture is carefully considered and part of seamless collaboration.", + "seed": 8587, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_9/index_5068_seed_8587_dp_18_rank_36_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.04165791599079967, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04165791599079967, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.55, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04165791599079967, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focusing on two scientists' hands and faces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is one of the scientists a woman with dark hair tied in a bun wearing a pure white lab coat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the scientists' hands performing coordinated gestures like pinching, zooming, and rotating to manipulate a holographic interface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the holographic interface composed of translucent data streams and molecular models emitting cyan and electric blue light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a sterile laboratory with polished white surfaces and overhead LED panels that are softly out of focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04568552225828171 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2956855297088623 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04568552225828171, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04568552225828171, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05906124413013458, + 0.030929304659366608, + 0.5591365694999695, + 0.01785927824676037, + 0.021737581118941307, + 0.030989350751042366, + 0.03559276461601257, + 0.01571084000170231, + 0.2135619819164276, + 0.015421072952449322 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04568552225828171 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focusing on two scientists' hands and faces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is one of the scientists a woman with dark hair tied in a bun wearing a pure white lab coat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the scientists' hands performing coordinated gestures like pinching, zooming, and rotating to manipulate a holographic interface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the holographic interface composed of translucent data streams and molecular models emitting cyan and electric blue light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a sterile laboratory with polished white surfaces and overhead LED panels that are softly out of focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.062105871737003326 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812105894088745 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.062105871737003326, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.062105871737003326, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18401262164115906, + 0.09058868139982224, + 0.22939740121364594, + 0.023345550522208214, + 0.01302334200590849, + 0.03907041624188423, + 0.09332945197820663, + 0.06723186373710632, + 0.20665302872657776, + 0.053347647190093994 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.062105871737003326 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focusing on two scientists' hands and faces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is one of the scientists a woman with dark hair tied in a bun wearing a pure white lab coat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the scientists' hands performing coordinated gestures like pinching, zooming, and rotating to manipulate a holographic interface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the holographic interface composed of translucent data streams and molecular models emitting cyan and electric blue light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a sterile laboratory with polished white surfaces and overhead LED panels that are softly out of focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0263650044798851 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651365041732788 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0263650044798851, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0263650044798851, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.040334828197956085, + 0.008988630026578903, + 0.7044910192489624, + 0.02834158018231392, + 0.015655219554901123, + 0.027977416291832924, + 0.02895360440015793, + 0.02572385035455227, + 0.07218976318836212, + 0.047344136983156204 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0263650044798851 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focusing on two scientists' hands and faces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is one of the scientists a woman with dark hair tied in a bun wearing a pure white lab coat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the scientists' hands performing coordinated gestures like pinching, zooming, and rotating to manipulate a holographic interface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the holographic interface composed of translucent data streams and molecular models emitting cyan and electric blue light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a sterile laboratory with polished white surfaces and overhead LED panels that are softly out of focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0040984689258039 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504098415374756 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0040984689258039, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0040984689258039, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0698174312710762, + 0.035749372094869614, + 0.23481455445289612, + 0.03612726926803589, + 0.11783747375011444, + 0.03358815982937813, + 0.08388205617666245, + 0.0669994130730629, + 0.09007362276315689, + 0.231110617518425 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0040984689258039 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focusing on two scientists' hands and faces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is one of the scientists a woman with dark hair tied in a bun wearing a pure white lab coat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the scientists' hands performing coordinated gestures like pinching, zooming, and rotating to manipulate a holographic interface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the holographic interface composed of translucent data streams and molecular models emitting cyan and electric blue light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a sterile laboratory with polished white surfaces and overhead LED panels that are softly out of focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07003471255302429 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950347423553467 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07003471255302429, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07003471255302429, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.053041789680719376, + 0.03818490728735924, + 0.44377636909484863, + 0.04910343512892723, + 0.09299812465906143, + 0.016246186569333076, + 0.05843665078282356, + 0.06632297486066818, + 0.07160259038209915, + 0.11028694361448288 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07003471255302429 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "continuous, fluid close-up glides smoothly, closely following the precise, coordinated hand movements of two scientists as they work together on a complex holographic interface. The primary focus is on one of the scientists, her dark hair neatly tied in a bun, her face a look of intense concentration. She wears a wrinkle-free, pure white, high-tech lab coat, a dark gray turtleneck peeking out from beneath. Her fingers, and those of her collaborator beside her, dance gracefully in the air, pinching and zooming, sliding and rotating, collectively manipulating a luminous three-dimensional projection suspended between them, composed of countless translucent data streams and swirling molecular models. The holographic interface serves as the scene's primary light source, casting an ethereal, cool hue of cyan and electric blue onto their focused faces and hands, highlighting the subtle textures of their skin and the pristine texture of their lab coats. Against the softly out-of-focus background, the futuristic, sterile laboratory, with its polished white composite surfaces and minimalist design, looms, bathed in shadowless clinical white light from overhead LED panels. The cool color temperature of the entire scene creates an atmosphere of intense, quiet concentration and cutting-edge technological precision, where every gesture is carefully considered and part of seamless collaboration.", + "seed": 8588, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_9/index_5068_seed_8588_dp_18_rank_36_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.08231685669161379, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08231685669161379, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.125, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08231685669161379, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focusing on two scientists' hands and faces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is one of the scientists a woman with dark hair tied in a bun wearing a pure white lab coat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the scientists' hands performing coordinated gestures like pinching, zooming, and rotating to manipulate a holographic interface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the holographic interface composed of translucent data streams and molecular models emitting cyan and electric blue light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a sterile laboratory with polished white surfaces and overhead LED panels that are softly out of focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16848747432231903 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9184874296188354 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16848747432231903, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16848747432231903, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1582147777080536, + 0.09129473567008972, + 0.051900047808885574, + 0.1804288774728775, + 0.10614641010761261, + 0.051141176372766495, + 0.1416553258895874, + 0.06618933379650116, + 0.05122755840420723, + 0.10180172324180603 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16848747432231903 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focusing on two scientists' hands and faces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is one of the scientists a woman with dark hair tied in a bun wearing a pure white lab coat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the scientists' hands performing coordinated gestures like pinching, zooming, and rotating to manipulate a holographic interface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the holographic interface composed of translucent data streams and molecular models emitting cyan and electric blue light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a sterile laboratory with polished white surfaces and overhead LED panels that are softly out of focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0790138989686966 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5790138244628906 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0790138989686966, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0790138989686966, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11192913353443146, + 0.0650455579161644, + 0.02568328194320202, + 0.13870178163051605, + 0.15287281572818756, + 0.0613800473511219, + 0.17786405980587006, + 0.10661675035953522, + 0.11022266745567322, + 0.04968397319316864 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0790138989686966 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focusing on two scientists' hands and faces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is one of the scientists a woman with dark hair tied in a bun wearing a pure white lab coat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the scientists' hands performing coordinated gestures like pinching, zooming, and rotating to manipulate a holographic interface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the holographic interface composed of translucent data streams and molecular models emitting cyan and electric blue light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a sterile laboratory with polished white surfaces and overhead LED panels that are softly out of focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1003282219171524 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.350328207015991 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1003282219171524, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1003282219171524, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.553907573223114, + 0.07685317099094391, + 0.05108289048075676, + 0.12386735528707504, + 0.018718108534812927, + 0.01705889403820038, + 0.026552703231573105, + 0.019592519849538803, + 0.017827071249485016, + 0.09453977644443512 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1003282219171524 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focusing on two scientists' hands and faces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is one of the scientists a woman with dark hair tied in a bun wearing a pure white lab coat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the scientists' hands performing coordinated gestures like pinching, zooming, and rotating to manipulate a holographic interface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the holographic interface composed of translucent data streams and molecular models emitting cyan and electric blue light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a sterile laboratory with polished white surfaces and overhead LED panels that are softly out of focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0017132379580289125 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.376713275909424 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0017132379580289125, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0017132379580289125, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.329399436712265, + 0.05035547912120819, + 0.03956824913620949, + 0.11649559438228607, + 0.08334634453058243, + 0.04702063649892807, + 0.038511477410793304, + 0.0769081637263298, + 0.06897042691707611, + 0.149424210190773 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0017132379580289125 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focusing on two scientists' hands and faces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is one of the scientists a woman with dark hair tied in a bun wearing a pure white lab coat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the scientists' hands performing coordinated gestures like pinching, zooming, and rotating to manipulate a holographic interface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the holographic interface composed of translucent data streams and molecular models emitting cyan and electric blue light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a sterile laboratory with polished white surfaces and overhead LED panels that are softly out of focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.062041450291872025 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120415210723877 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.062041450291872025, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.062041450291872025, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2386767417192459, + 0.06993824988603592, + 0.058419324457645416, + 0.13611359894275665, + 0.20727454125881195, + 0.09325524419546127, + 0.03482606261968613, + 0.036733996123075485, + 0.10537684708833694, + 0.01938539557158947 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.062041450291872025 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "continuous, fluid close-up glides smoothly, closely following the precise, coordinated hand movements of two scientists as they work together on a complex holographic interface. The primary focus is on one of the scientists, her dark hair neatly tied in a bun, her face a look of intense concentration. She wears a wrinkle-free, pure white, high-tech lab coat, a dark gray turtleneck peeking out from beneath. Her fingers, and those of her collaborator beside her, dance gracefully in the air, pinching and zooming, sliding and rotating, collectively manipulating a luminous three-dimensional projection suspended between them, composed of countless translucent data streams and swirling molecular models. The holographic interface serves as the scene's primary light source, casting an ethereal, cool hue of cyan and electric blue onto their focused faces and hands, highlighting the subtle textures of their skin and the pristine texture of their lab coats. Against the softly out-of-focus background, the futuristic, sterile laboratory, with its polished white composite surfaces and minimalist design, looms, bathed in shadowless clinical white light from overhead LED panels. The cool color temperature of the entire scene creates an atmosphere of intense, quiet concentration and cutting-edge technological precision, where every gesture is carefully considered and part of seamless collaboration.", + "seed": 8589, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_9/index_5068_seed_8589_dp_19_rank_38_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.04885871247388422, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04885871247388422, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.65, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04885871247388422, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focusing on two scientists' hands and faces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is one of the scientists a woman with dark hair tied in a bun wearing a pure white lab coat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the scientists' hands performing coordinated gestures like pinching, zooming, and rotating to manipulate a holographic interface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the holographic interface composed of translucent data streams and molecular models emitting cyan and electric blue light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a sterile laboratory with polished white surfaces and overhead LED panels that are softly out of focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.027905840426683426 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7779059410095215 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.027905840426683426, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.027905840426683426, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2384546995162964, + 0.053037937730550766, + 0.053825829178094864, + 0.12112266570329666, + 0.019616873934864998, + 0.06942575424909592, + 0.03340619429945946, + 0.023232650011777878, + 0.3466476798057556, + 0.041229695081710815 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.027905840426683426 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focusing on two scientists' hands and faces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is one of the scientists a woman with dark hair tied in a bun wearing a pure white lab coat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the scientists' hands performing coordinated gestures like pinching, zooming, and rotating to manipulate a holographic interface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the holographic interface composed of translucent data streams and molecular models emitting cyan and electric blue light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a sterile laboratory with polished white surfaces and overhead LED panels that are softly out of focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07005293667316437 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950528621673584 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07005293667316437, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07005293667316437, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13871492445468903, + 0.16623687744140625, + 0.10862655192613602, + 0.056007303297519684, + 0.02193770743906498, + 0.026514645665884018, + 0.06558269262313843, + 0.043644167482852936, + 0.27319759130477905, + 0.09953753650188446 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07005293667316437 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focusing on two scientists' hands and faces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is one of the scientists a woman with dark hair tied in a bun wearing a pure white lab coat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the scientists' hands performing coordinated gestures like pinching, zooming, and rotating to manipulate a holographic interface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the holographic interface composed of translucent data streams and molecular models emitting cyan and electric blue light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a sterile laboratory with polished white surfaces and overhead LED panels that are softly out of focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016084790229797363 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141084671020508 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016084790229797363, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016084790229797363, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.35636141896247864, + 0.05350859835743904, + 0.08973981440067291, + 0.05599033832550049, + 0.02437388338148594, + 0.033773694187402725, + 0.05259699001908302, + 0.03174804151058197, + 0.24060595035552979, + 0.06130126491189003 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016084790229797363 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focusing on two scientists' hands and faces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is one of the scientists a woman with dark hair tied in a bun wearing a pure white lab coat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the scientists' hands performing coordinated gestures like pinching, zooming, and rotating to manipulate a holographic interface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the holographic interface composed of translucent data streams and molecular models emitting cyan and electric blue light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a sterile laboratory with polished white surfaces and overhead LED panels that are softly out of focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0031945884693413973 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753194808959961 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0031945884693413973, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0031945884693413973, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3040798008441925, + 0.06095435097813606, + 0.33523041009902954, + 0.07807768881320953, + 0.06292245537042618, + 0.0316367968916893, + 0.033512428402900696, + 0.025278309360146523, + 0.022378206253051758, + 0.04592955857515335 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0031945884693413973 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focusing on two scientists' hands and faces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is one of the scientists a woman with dark hair tied in a bun wearing a pure white lab coat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the scientists' hands performing coordinated gestures like pinching, zooming, and rotating to manipulate a holographic interface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the holographic interface composed of translucent data streams and molecular models emitting cyan and electric blue light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a sterile laboratory with polished white surfaces and overhead LED panels that are softly out of focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12705540657043457 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1270554065704346 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12705540657043457, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12705540657043457, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4517207443714142, + 0.07483126223087311, + 0.06502722948789597, + 0.04329295456409454, + 0.04975905269384384, + 0.018192755058407784, + 0.039711982011795044, + 0.06914164125919342, + 0.09576112776994705, + 0.09256130456924438 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12705540657043457 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "continuous, fluid close-up glides smoothly, closely following the precise, coordinated hand movements of two scientists as they work together on a complex holographic interface. The primary focus is on one of the scientists, her dark hair neatly tied in a bun, her face a look of intense concentration. She wears a wrinkle-free, pure white, high-tech lab coat, a dark gray turtleneck peeking out from beneath. Her fingers, and those of her collaborator beside her, dance gracefully in the air, pinching and zooming, sliding and rotating, collectively manipulating a luminous three-dimensional projection suspended between them, composed of countless translucent data streams and swirling molecular models. The holographic interface serves as the scene's primary light source, casting an ethereal, cool hue of cyan and electric blue onto their focused faces and hands, highlighting the subtle textures of their skin and the pristine texture of their lab coats. Against the softly out-of-focus background, the futuristic, sterile laboratory, with its polished white composite surfaces and minimalist design, looms, bathed in shadowless clinical white light from overhead LED panels. The cool color temperature of the entire scene creates an atmosphere of intense, quiet concentration and cutting-edge technological precision, where every gesture is carefully considered and part of seamless collaboration.", + "seed": 8590, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000168/group_9/index_5068_seed_8590_dp_19_rank_38_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.022969855763949453, + "vlm_logprob": -0.022969855763949453, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.374999952316284, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.022969855763949453, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focusing on two scientists' hands and faces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is one of the scientists a woman with dark hair tied in a bun wearing a pure white lab coat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the scientists' hands performing coordinated gestures like pinching, zooming, and rotating to manipulate a holographic interface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the holographic interface composed of translucent data streams and molecular models emitting cyan and electric blue light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a sterile laboratory with polished white surfaces and overhead LED panels that are softly out of focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.024131275713443756 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.0241312980651855 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.024131275713443756, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.024131275713443756, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1091923639178276, + 0.07021019607782364, + 0.059671055525541306, + 0.0674528107047081, + 0.09376109391450882, + 0.052903737872838974, + 0.06047030910849571, + 0.08331773430109024, + 0.07666906714439392, + 0.32635167241096497 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.024131275713443756 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focusing on two scientists' hands and faces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is one of the scientists a woman with dark hair tied in a bun wearing a pure white lab coat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the scientists' hands performing coordinated gestures like pinching, zooming, and rotating to manipulate a holographic interface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the holographic interface composed of translucent data streams and molecular models emitting cyan and electric blue light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a sterile laboratory with polished white surfaces and overhead LED panels that are softly out of focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0337202288210392 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4087202548980713 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0337202288210392, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0337202288210392, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2528228759765625, + 0.13109728693962097, + 0.03055325336754322, + 0.059985820204019547, + 0.08315341174602509, + 0.03943551704287529, + 0.21515336632728577, + 0.08572333306074142, + 0.03549656644463539, + 0.06657864153385162 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0337202288210392 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focusing on two scientists' hands and faces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is one of the scientists a woman with dark hair tied in a bun wearing a pure white lab coat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the scientists' hands performing coordinated gestures like pinching, zooming, and rotating to manipulate a holographic interface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the holographic interface composed of translucent data streams and molecular models emitting cyan and electric blue light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a sterile laboratory with polished white surfaces and overhead LED panels that are softly out of focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018190113827586174 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018189907073975 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018190113827586174, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018190113827586174, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10021145641803741, + 0.056405454874038696, + 0.08149799704551697, + 0.05790102854371071, + 0.09483570605516434, + 0.24405890703201294, + 0.06276693195104599, + 0.10359592735767365, + 0.08435769379138947, + 0.11436887830495834 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018190113827586174 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focusing on two scientists' hands and faces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is one of the scientists a woman with dark hair tied in a bun wearing a pure white lab coat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the scientists' hands performing coordinated gestures like pinching, zooming, and rotating to manipulate a holographic interface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the holographic interface composed of translucent data streams and molecular models emitting cyan and electric blue light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a sterile laboratory with polished white surfaces and overhead LED panels that are softly out of focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0007167869480326772 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.250716686248779 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0007167869480326772, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0007167869480326772, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17832070589065552, + 0.14652372896671295, + 0.08131088316440582, + 0.06272336095571518, + 0.04108964651823044, + 0.061341870576143265, + 0.18327195942401886, + 0.09901858121156693, + 0.05539174750447273, + 0.0910075455904007 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0007167869480326772 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focusing on two scientists' hands and faces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is one of the scientists a woman with dark hair tied in a bun wearing a pure white lab coat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the scientists' hands performing coordinated gestures like pinching, zooming, and rotating to manipulate a holographic interface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the holographic interface composed of translucent data streams and molecular models emitting cyan and electric blue light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a sterile laboratory with polished white surfaces and overhead LED panels that are softly out of focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03809087350964546 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288090944290161 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03809087350964546, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03809087350964546, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11388750374317169, + 0.052030257880687714, + 0.07296516746282578, + 0.05427169054746628, + 0.13528379797935486, + 0.12217503786087036, + 0.30613332986831665, + 0.04543089121580124, + 0.04118823632597923, + 0.056634124368429184 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03809087350964546 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_0/index_tensor([829, 829])_group_0_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_0/index_tensor([829, 829])_group_0_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..e214b988fe3cb16ea05afa4656afe0ea54dca954 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_0/index_tensor([829, 829])_group_0_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "slow, horizontal, medium shot draws the viewer's attention to an elderly master, nestled amidst a tranquil bamboo forest shrouded in morning mist. His hair, pulled high in a bun, is as white as snow. His face, though marked by the scars of time, exudes a profound tranquility and concentration. He wears a flowing, pure white silk robe, the fabric smooth and soft, shimmering with a faint pearlescent sheen in the humid air. With excruciatingly slow movements, he practices Tai Chi, his arms rising with unhurried deliberation, his hands seemingly stirring invisible energy, drawing perfect, continuous arcs in the air. Each movement is imbued with an inner sense of power, transmitted from his stable physique to his fingertips, causing the wide silk sleeves to rise and fall gracefully like ripples of water. Following the trajectory of his hands, countless ethereal, shimmering golden particles emerge from the air. Shot in slow motion, these particles appear like awakened spirits, entwining his arms and trailing streams of radiant light, slowly dispersing through the damp, cool air. Under the soft diffuse skylight, the entire picture presents a cold tranquility. Only the flowing light and shadow particles bring a touch of extraordinary warmth, perfectly creating a profound artistic conception between reality and fantasy, where the real and the virtual coexist.", + "seed": 21057, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_0/index_829_seed_21057_dp_0_rank_0_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.05034898445010185, + "vlm_logprob": -0.05034898445010185, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.125, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.05034898445010185, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly master with white hair tied in a bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the master wearing a flowing pure white silk robe with a pearlescent sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a tranquil bamboo forest shrouded in morning mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are ethereal shimmering golden particles visible emerging from the air and trailing the master's arms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot with slow, horizontal camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05084317922592163 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0508432388305664 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05084317922592163, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05084317922592163, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2331380397081375, + 0.1031145453453064, + 0.14539869129657745, + 0.07756135612726212, + 0.04282154142856598, + 0.060585301369428635, + 0.08165229856967926, + 0.02133856527507305, + 0.07853589951992035, + 0.1558537483215332 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05084317922592163 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly master with white hair tied in a bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the master wearing a flowing pure white silk robe with a pearlescent sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a tranquil bamboo forest shrouded in morning mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are ethereal shimmering golden particles visible emerging from the air and trailing the master's arms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot with slow, horizontal camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01609358936548233 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141093730926514 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01609358936548233, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01609358936548233, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15331332385540009, + 0.09365161508321762, + 0.13465192914009094, + 0.0976531058549881, + 0.17088069021701813, + 0.048314787447452545, + 0.06180787459015846, + 0.041805341839790344, + 0.05392340570688248, + 0.1439979076385498 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01609358936548233 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly master with white hair tied in a bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the master wearing a flowing pure white silk robe with a pearlescent sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a tranquil bamboo forest shrouded in morning mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are ethereal shimmering golden particles visible emerging from the air and trailing the master's arms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot with slow, horizontal camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08906596153974533 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4640660285949707 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08906596153974533, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08906596153974533, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.39649954438209534, + 0.13006244599819183, + 0.064945749938488, + 0.06764394044876099, + 0.05406523123383522, + 0.02943110652267933, + 0.12909339368343353, + 0.053805604577064514, + 0.029433773830533028, + 0.045019250363111496 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08906596153974533 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly master with white hair tied in a bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the master wearing a flowing pure white silk robe with a pearlescent sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a tranquil bamboo forest shrouded in morning mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are ethereal shimmering golden particles visible emerging from the air and trailing the master's arms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot with slow, horizontal camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0337083600461483 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408708333969116 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0337083600461483, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0337083600461483, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0808241069316864, + 0.09189871698617935, + 0.09825590252876282, + 0.06403764337301254, + 0.0779680386185646, + 0.0920642837882042, + 0.10869015008211136, + 0.041792552918195724, + 0.02741868980228901, + 0.31704992055892944 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0337083600461483 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly master with white hair tied in a bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the master wearing a flowing pure white silk robe with a pearlescent sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a tranquil bamboo forest shrouded in morning mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are ethereal shimmering golden particles visible emerging from the air and trailing the master's arms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot with slow, horizontal camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06203383207321167 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120338916778564 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06203383207321167, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06203383207321167, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19037318229675293, + 0.08168846368789673, + 0.03558991849422455, + 0.03552531078457832, + 0.04719690605998039, + 0.05750180780887604, + 0.12986494600772858, + 0.0198539849370718, + 0.024668525904417038, + 0.3777369558811188 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06203383207321167 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow, horizontal, medium shot draws the viewer's attention to an elderly master, nestled amidst a tranquil bamboo forest shrouded in morning mist. His hair, pulled high in a bun, is as white as snow. His face, though marked by the scars of time, exudes a profound tranquility and concentration. He wears a flowing, pure white silk robe, the fabric smooth and soft, shimmering with a faint pearlescent sheen in the humid air. With excruciatingly slow movements, he practices Tai Chi, his arms rising with unhurried deliberation, his hands seemingly stirring invisible energy, drawing perfect, continuous arcs in the air. Each movement is imbued with an inner sense of power, transmitted from his stable physique to his fingertips, causing the wide silk sleeves to rise and fall gracefully like ripples of water. Following the trajectory of his hands, countless ethereal, shimmering golden particles emerge from the air. Shot in slow motion, these particles appear like awakened spirits, entwining his arms and trailing streams of radiant light, slowly dispersing through the damp, cool air. Under the soft diffuse skylight, the entire picture presents a cold tranquility. Only the flowing light and shadow particles bring a touch of extraordinary warmth, perfectly creating a profound artistic conception between reality and fantasy, where the real and the virtual coexist.", + "seed": 21058, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_0/index_829_seed_21058_dp_0_rank_0_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.026967935729771852, + "vlm_logprob": -0.026967935729771852, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.875, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.026967935729771852, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly master with white hair tied in a bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the master wearing a flowing pure white silk robe with a pearlescent sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a tranquil bamboo forest shrouded in morning mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are ethereal shimmering golden particles visible emerging from the air and trailing the master's arms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot with slow, horizontal camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.013368493877351284 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.388368606567383 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.013368493877351284, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.013368493877351284, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.043381333351135254, + 0.09714771807193756, + 0.7274055480957031, + 0.026077330112457275, + 0.024195004254579544, + 0.025806421414017677, + 0.02006746083498001, + 0.008296728134155273, + 0.01530193816870451, + 0.012320495210587978 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.013368493877351284 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly master with white hair tied in a bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the master wearing a flowing pure white silk robe with a pearlescent sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a tranquil bamboo forest shrouded in morning mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are ethereal shimmering golden particles visible emerging from the air and trailing the master's arms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot with slow, horizontal camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006748385261744261 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006748199462891 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006748385261744261, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006748385261744261, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15124903619289398, + 0.0909162238240242, + 0.4650445580482483, + 0.04617868736386299, + 0.040152959525585175, + 0.04334849491715431, + 0.02767176367342472, + 0.08164966106414795, + 0.018467804417014122, + 0.035320840775966644 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006748385261744261 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly master with white hair tied in a bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the master wearing a flowing pure white silk robe with a pearlescent sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a tranquil bamboo forest shrouded in morning mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are ethereal shimmering golden particles visible emerging from the air and trailing the master's arms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot with slow, horizontal camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02634584717452526 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651345729827881 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02634584717452526, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02634584717452526, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03337875008583069, + 0.15178176760673523, + 0.7394102215766907, + 0.008316893130540848, + 0.020229121670126915, + 0.006925659254193306, + 0.011859129182994366, + 0.008137993514537811, + 0.010354621335864067, + 0.009605818428099155 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02634584717452526 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly master with white hair tied in a bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the master wearing a flowing pure white silk robe with a pearlescent sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a tranquil bamboo forest shrouded in morning mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are ethereal shimmering golden particles visible emerging from the air and trailing the master's arms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot with slow, horizontal camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026347937062382698 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513478755950928 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026347937062382698, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026347937062382698, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03072797879576683, + 0.05978938937187195, + 0.8366395235061646, + 0.01209755428135395, + 0.006442703306674957, + 0.011030147783458233, + 0.017639171332120895, + 0.006869629956781864, + 0.008104164153337479, + 0.010659699328243732 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026347937062382698 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly master with white hair tied in a bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the master wearing a flowing pure white silk robe with a pearlescent sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a tranquil bamboo forest shrouded in morning mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are ethereal shimmering golden particles visible emerging from the air and trailing the master's arms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot with slow, horizontal camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06202901527285576 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120291233062744 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06202901527285576, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06202901527285576, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.079566590487957, + 0.28907129168510437, + 0.3244805335998535, + 0.043688733130693436, + 0.04421613737940788, + 0.03465026244521141, + 0.05560968816280365, + 0.03404228761792183, + 0.06403663754463196, + 0.03063790313899517 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06202901527285576 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow, horizontal, medium shot draws the viewer's attention to an elderly master, nestled amidst a tranquil bamboo forest shrouded in morning mist. His hair, pulled high in a bun, is as white as snow. His face, though marked by the scars of time, exudes a profound tranquility and concentration. He wears a flowing, pure white silk robe, the fabric smooth and soft, shimmering with a faint pearlescent sheen in the humid air. With excruciatingly slow movements, he practices Tai Chi, his arms rising with unhurried deliberation, his hands seemingly stirring invisible energy, drawing perfect, continuous arcs in the air. Each movement is imbued with an inner sense of power, transmitted from his stable physique to his fingertips, causing the wide silk sleeves to rise and fall gracefully like ripples of water. Following the trajectory of his hands, countless ethereal, shimmering golden particles emerge from the air. Shot in slow motion, these particles appear like awakened spirits, entwining his arms and trailing streams of radiant light, slowly dispersing through the damp, cool air. Under the soft diffuse skylight, the entire picture presents a cold tranquility. Only the flowing light and shadow particles bring a touch of extraordinary warmth, perfectly creating a profound artistic conception between reality and fantasy, where the real and the virtual coexist.", + "seed": 21059, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_0/index_829_seed_21059_dp_1_rank_2_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.042832001484930514, + "vlm_logprob": -0.042832001484930514, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.674999952316284, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.042832001484930514, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly master with white hair tied in a bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the master wearing a flowing pure white silk robe with a pearlescent sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a tranquil bamboo forest shrouded in morning mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are ethereal shimmering golden particles visible emerging from the air and trailing the master's arms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot with slow, horizontal camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.019537625834345818 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.019537448883057 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.019537625834345818, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.019537625834345818, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5381718873977661, + 0.14898650348186493, + 0.0395347885787487, + 0.041693951934576035, + 0.06861277669668198, + 0.03431513532996178, + 0.0376930832862854, + 0.05114032328128815, + 0.027208590880036354, + 0.012642867863178253 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.019537625834345818 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly master with white hair tied in a bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the master wearing a flowing pure white silk robe with a pearlescent sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a tranquil bamboo forest shrouded in morning mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are ethereal shimmering golden particles visible emerging from the air and trailing the master's arms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot with slow, horizontal camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004104523919522762 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.5041046142578125 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004104523919522762, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004104523919522762, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.629386842250824, + 0.10799367725849152, + 0.02445637620985508, + 0.059929363429546356, + 0.04169788956642151, + 0.027677176520228386, + 0.031132426112890244, + 0.027454981580376625, + 0.023029999807476997, + 0.02724137343466282 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004104523919522762 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly master with white hair tied in a bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the master wearing a flowing pure white silk robe with a pearlescent sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a tranquil bamboo forest shrouded in morning mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are ethereal shimmering golden particles visible emerging from the air and trailing the master's arms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot with slow, horizontal camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029804106801748276 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529803991317749 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029804106801748276, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029804106801748276, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16655801236629486, + 0.24054282903671265, + 0.07349971681833267, + 0.19930629432201385, + 0.08240263164043427, + 0.04036694020032883, + 0.05642175301909447, + 0.041239600628614426, + 0.035194091498851776, + 0.0644681379199028 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029804106801748276 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly master with white hair tied in a bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the master wearing a flowing pure white silk robe with a pearlescent sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a tranquil bamboo forest shrouded in morning mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are ethereal shimmering golden particles visible emerging from the air and trailing the master's arms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot with slow, horizontal camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03370201960206032 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4087021350860596 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03370201960206032, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03370201960206032, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3676951825618744, + 0.10341916233301163, + 0.08235298097133636, + 0.09073348343372345, + 0.09425254166126251, + 0.060357578098773956, + 0.07368495315313339, + 0.033062610775232315, + 0.05199289694428444, + 0.042448606342077255 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03370201960206032 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly master with white hair tied in a bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the master wearing a flowing pure white silk robe with a pearlescent sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a tranquil bamboo forest shrouded in morning mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are ethereal shimmering golden particles visible emerging from the air and trailing the master's arms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot with slow, horizontal camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1270117312669754 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.127011775970459 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1270117312669754, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1270117312669754, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1227700263261795, + 0.15819932520389557, + 0.08528521656990051, + 0.14766554534435272, + 0.11205337196588516, + 0.07437456399202347, + 0.12626130878925323, + 0.03709422051906586, + 0.051351163536310196, + 0.0849452093243599 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 3, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1270117312669754 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow, horizontal, medium shot draws the viewer's attention to an elderly master, nestled amidst a tranquil bamboo forest shrouded in morning mist. His hair, pulled high in a bun, is as white as snow. His face, though marked by the scars of time, exudes a profound tranquility and concentration. He wears a flowing, pure white silk robe, the fabric smooth and soft, shimmering with a faint pearlescent sheen in the humid air. With excruciatingly slow movements, he practices Tai Chi, his arms rising with unhurried deliberation, his hands seemingly stirring invisible energy, drawing perfect, continuous arcs in the air. Each movement is imbued with an inner sense of power, transmitted from his stable physique to his fingertips, causing the wide silk sleeves to rise and fall gracefully like ripples of water. Following the trajectory of his hands, countless ethereal, shimmering golden particles emerge from the air. Shot in slow motion, these particles appear like awakened spirits, entwining his arms and trailing streams of radiant light, slowly dispersing through the damp, cool air. Under the soft diffuse skylight, the entire picture presents a cold tranquility. Only the flowing light and shadow particles bring a touch of extraordinary warmth, perfectly creating a profound artistic conception between reality and fantasy, where the real and the virtual coexist.", + "seed": 21060, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_0/index_829_seed_21060_dp_1_rank_2_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.043923101387917995, + "vlm_logprob": -0.043923101387917995, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.25, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.043923101387917995, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly master with white hair tied in a bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the master wearing a flowing pure white silk robe with a pearlescent sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a tranquil bamboo forest shrouded in morning mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are ethereal shimmering golden particles visible emerging from the air and trailing the master's arms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot with slow, horizontal camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03523056209087372 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4102306365966797 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03523056209087372, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03523056209087372, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2311549186706543, + 0.06412430852651596, + 0.06700460612773895, + 0.0346352644264698, + 0.0954480990767479, + 0.04023190587759018, + 0.041479237377643585, + 0.13745981454849243, + 0.056090328842401505, + 0.2323715090751648 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03523056209087372 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly master with white hair tied in a bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the master wearing a flowing pure white silk robe with a pearlescent sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a tranquil bamboo forest shrouded in morning mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are ethereal shimmering golden particles visible emerging from the air and trailing the master's arms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot with slow, horizontal camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01421563234180212 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264215469360352 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01421563234180212, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01421563234180212, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25940969586372375, + 0.09757614135742188, + 0.08356884121894836, + 0.04049200564622879, + 0.1161094531416893, + 0.058142226189374924, + 0.06499609351158142, + 0.1562701314687729, + 0.06400996446609497, + 0.059425417333841324 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01421563234180212 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly master with white hair tied in a bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the master wearing a flowing pure white silk robe with a pearlescent sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a tranquil bamboo forest shrouded in morning mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are ethereal shimmering golden particles visible emerging from the air and trailing the master's arms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot with slow, horizontal camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06205747276544571 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120574951171875 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06205747276544571, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06205747276544571, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25561296939849854, + 0.04991459473967552, + 0.13600413501262665, + 0.0340571403503418, + 0.08757824450731277, + 0.05139843001961708, + 0.11564366519451141, + 0.13793392479419708, + 0.07382088899612427, + 0.058036018162965775 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06205747276544571 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly master with white hair tied in a bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the master wearing a flowing pure white silk robe with a pearlescent sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a tranquil bamboo forest shrouded in morning mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are ethereal shimmering golden particles visible emerging from the air and trailing the master's arms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot with slow, horizontal camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03810625150799751 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881062030792236 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03810625150799751, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03810625150799751, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25317060947418213, + 0.13845312595367432, + 0.05504711717367172, + 0.037148505449295044, + 0.04788251966238022, + 0.036640483886003494, + 0.042911775410175323, + 0.17337802052497864, + 0.09437792748212814, + 0.12098987400531769 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03810625150799751 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly master with white hair tied in a bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the master wearing a flowing pure white silk robe with a pearlescent sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a tranquil bamboo forest shrouded in morning mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are ethereal shimmering golden particles visible emerging from the air and trailing the master's arms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot with slow, horizontal camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07000558823347092 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950056552886963 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07000558823347092, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07000558823347092, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14647041261196136, + 0.042021941393613815, + 0.031716033816337585, + 0.05215580761432648, + 0.028243238106369972, + 0.020271504297852516, + 0.0390179269015789, + 0.08849858492612839, + 0.1491447240114212, + 0.4024598300457001 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07000558823347092 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_1/index_tensor([416, 416])_group_1_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_1/index_tensor([416, 416])_group_1_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..4c9c6aa6444bcd0ce623d21f5e1b5cd373ae849e --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_1/index_tensor([416, 416])_group_1_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "From a majestic high-angle bird's-eye view, the camera slowly sweeps to the right, revealing a vast and serene desert landscape beneath a brilliant blue sky. A few fluffy white cumulus clouds drift lazily across the frame, casting vast, slow-moving shadows on the world below. The scene is bathed in bright, unfiltered midday sunlight, which sculpts the undulating waves of light-brown sand, creating sharp, defined ridges and deep shadows that emphasize their texture. These dunes stretch endlessly toward the horizon, their warm ochre hues contrasting sharply with the small, springy green shrubs sparsely scattered across the terrain. In the distance, a hazy mountain range rises, its weathered peaks a blend of soft reds and browns, blending seamlessly with the shimmering air at the edge of the world. The camera's deliberate, expansive movements enhance the scale of the vista, evoking a powerful atmosphere of tranquil solitude and majestic, untouched nature.", + "seed": 11686, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_1/index_416_seed_11686_dp_2_rank_4_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.1583901499689091, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1583901499689091, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.2, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1583901499689091, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a high-angle bird's-eye view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly sweep to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a desert landscape with light-brown sand dunes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are fluffy white cumulus clouds visible drifting across a brilliant blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in bright midday sunlight creating sharp shadows on the dunes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5797545909881592 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8297545909881592 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5797545909881592, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5797545909881592, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1439855396747589, + 0.13126933574676514, + 0.1142367273569107, + 0.034668684005737305, + 0.05024810880422592, + 0.08127246052026749, + 0.1017426997423172, + 0.04560678452253342, + 0.24835458397865295, + 0.04861500486731529 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5797545909881592 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a high-angle bird's-eye view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly sweep to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a desert landscape with light-brown sand dunes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are fluffy white cumulus clouds visible drifting across a brilliant blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in bright midday sunlight creating sharp shadows on the dunes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2015506476163864 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7015506029129028 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2015506476163864, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2015506476163864, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.012098184786736965, + 0.015625230967998505, + 0.023304838687181473, + 0.013153078965842724, + 0.011644641868770123, + 0.005434740334749222, + 0.04309247061610222, + 0.02384256199002266, + 0.7224608659744263, + 0.12934337556362152 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2015506476163864 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a high-angle bird's-eye view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly sweep to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a desert landscape with light-brown sand dunes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are fluffy white cumulus clouds visible drifting across a brilliant blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in bright midday sunlight creating sharp shadows on the dunes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.000302030734019354 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -8.1253023147583 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.000302030734019354, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 8.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.000302030734019354, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12983398139476776, + 0.05081421881914139, + 0.15680156648159027, + 0.029980113729834557, + 0.09080492705106735, + 0.022222429513931274, + 0.028798287734389305, + 0.025298194959759712, + 0.3842986524105072, + 0.08114766329526901 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.000302030734019354 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a high-angle bird's-eye view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly sweep to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a desert landscape with light-brown sand dunes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are fluffy white cumulus clouds visible drifting across a brilliant blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in bright midday sunlight creating sharp shadows on the dunes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0017135950038209558 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.376713752746582 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0017135950038209558, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0017135950038209558, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06349600851535797, + 0.14520762860774994, + 0.10617649555206299, + 0.030966568738222122, + 0.027664871886372566, + 0.029262322932481766, + 0.021636642515659332, + 0.02222052961587906, + 0.4858933389186859, + 0.06747563928365707 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0017135950038209558 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a high-angle bird's-eye view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly sweep to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a desert landscape with light-brown sand dunes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are fluffy white cumulus clouds visible drifting across a brilliant blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in bright midday sunlight creating sharp shadows on the dunes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008629885502159595 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.75862979888916 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008629885502159595, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008629885502159595, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12051678448915482, + 0.06186079978942871, + 0.12394766509532928, + 0.033033572137355804, + 0.09998401999473572, + 0.07574271410703659, + 0.04598128795623779, + 0.06148785725235939, + 0.23695193231105804, + 0.14049342274665833 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008629885502159595 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "From a majestic high-angle bird's-eye view, the camera slowly sweeps to the right, revealing a vast and serene desert landscape beneath a brilliant blue sky. A few fluffy white cumulus clouds drift lazily across the frame, casting vast, slow-moving shadows on the world below. The scene is bathed in bright, unfiltered midday sunlight, which sculpts the undulating waves of light-brown sand, creating sharp, defined ridges and deep shadows that emphasize their texture. These dunes stretch endlessly toward the horizon, their warm ochre hues contrasting sharply with the small, springy green shrubs sparsely scattered across the terrain. In the distance, a hazy mountain range rises, its weathered peaks a blend of soft reds and browns, blending seamlessly with the shimmering air at the edge of the world. The camera's deliberate, expansive movements enhance the scale of the vista, evoking a powerful atmosphere of tranquil solitude and majestic, untouched nature.", + "seed": 11687, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_1/index_416_seed_11687_dp_2_rank_4_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.19137059358181432, + "vlm_logprob": -0.19137059358181432, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.024999904632568, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.19137059358181432, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a high-angle bird's-eye view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly sweep to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a desert landscape with light-brown sand dunes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are fluffy white cumulus clouds visible drifting across a brilliant blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in bright midday sunlight creating sharp shadows on the dunes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8282191157341003 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5782191157341003 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.8282191157341003, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.8282191157341003, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07511270046234131, + 0.038045600056648254, + 0.020157696679234505, + 0.027113722637295723, + 0.07565471529960632, + 0.1329137235879898, + 0.10911761969327927, + 0.06023687124252319, + 0.07366165518760681, + 0.3879856467247009 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.8282191157341003 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a high-angle bird's-eye view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly sweep to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a desert landscape with light-brown sand dunes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are fluffy white cumulus clouds visible drifting across a brilliant blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in bright midday sunlight creating sharp shadows on the dunes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11294448375701904 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2379446029663086 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11294448375701904, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11294448375701904, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03274768963456154, + 0.016701962798833847, + 0.01611039787530899, + 0.011011539958417416, + 0.10340581089258194, + 0.14193813502788544, + 0.14378128945827484, + 0.036712002009153366, + 0.01716829463839531, + 0.48042285442352295 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11294448375701904 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a high-angle bird's-eye view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly sweep to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a desert landscape with light-brown sand dunes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are fluffy white cumulus clouds visible drifting across a brilliant blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in bright midday sunlight creating sharp shadows on the dunes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00034171465085819364 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -8.000341415405273 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00034171465085819364, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.999999523162842, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00034171465085819364, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12322443723678589, + 0.04024103283882141, + 0.023067623376846313, + 0.07241267710924149, + 0.10318099707365036, + 0.04806240648031235, + 0.05088302120566368, + 0.041758108884096146, + 0.04279685765504837, + 0.45437291264533997 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00034171465085819364 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a high-angle bird's-eye view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly sweep to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a desert landscape with light-brown sand dunes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are fluffy white cumulus clouds visible drifting across a brilliant blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in bright midday sunlight creating sharp shadows on the dunes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0028183048125356436 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.8778181076049805 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0028183048125356436, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0028183048125356436, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09503336250782013, + 0.053299788385629654, + 0.02742447517812252, + 0.01876886747777462, + 0.05592922121286392, + 0.029453566297888756, + 0.045292068272829056, + 0.05001092702150345, + 0.05820649117231369, + 0.5665812492370605 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0028183048125356436 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a high-angle bird's-eye view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly sweep to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a desert landscape with light-brown sand dunes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are fluffy white cumulus clouds visible drifting across a brilliant blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in bright midday sunlight creating sharp shadows on the dunes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012529348954558372 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387529373168945 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012529348954558372, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012529348954558372, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0898771584033966, + 0.020110024139285088, + 0.04145564138889313, + 0.04774589464068413, + 0.139008566737175, + 0.04900258034467697, + 0.07651948928833008, + 0.04601116105914116, + 0.047454189509153366, + 0.44281524419784546 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012529348954558372 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "From a majestic high-angle bird's-eye view, the camera slowly sweeps to the right, revealing a vast and serene desert landscape beneath a brilliant blue sky. A few fluffy white cumulus clouds drift lazily across the frame, casting vast, slow-moving shadows on the world below. The scene is bathed in bright, unfiltered midday sunlight, which sculpts the undulating waves of light-brown sand, creating sharp, defined ridges and deep shadows that emphasize their texture. These dunes stretch endlessly toward the horizon, their warm ochre hues contrasting sharply with the small, springy green shrubs sparsely scattered across the terrain. In the distance, a hazy mountain range rises, its weathered peaks a blend of soft reds and browns, blending seamlessly with the shimmering air at the edge of the world. The camera's deliberate, expansive movements enhance the scale of the vista, evoking a powerful atmosphere of tranquil solitude and majestic, untouched nature.", + "seed": 11688, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_1/index_416_seed_11688_dp_3_rank_6_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.15016201599501072, + "vlm_logprob": -0.15016201599501072, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.9, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.15016201599501072, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a high-angle bird's-eye view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly sweep to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a desert landscape with light-brown sand dunes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are fluffy white cumulus clouds visible drifting across a brilliant blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in bright midday sunlight creating sharp shadows on the dunes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5786066055297852 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8286066055297852 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5786066055297852, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5786066055297852, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1209205910563469, + 0.056307870894670486, + 0.07878273725509644, + 0.2922282814979553, + 0.061562806367874146, + 0.08853410184383392, + 0.13184784352779388, + 0.0599091611802578, + 0.0514804981648922, + 0.058426134288311005 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5786066055297852 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a high-angle bird's-eye view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly sweep to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a desert landscape with light-brown sand dunes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are fluffy white cumulus clouds visible drifting across a brilliant blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in bright midday sunlight creating sharp shadows on the dunes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1603490114212036 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9103490114212036 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1603490114212036, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1603490114212036, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07035021483898163, + 0.08929833769798279, + 0.051318682730197906, + 0.11046440899372101, + 0.10247809439897537, + 0.07368078827857971, + 0.33848315477371216, + 0.036764755845069885, + 0.04204494133591652, + 0.08511654287576675 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1603490114212036 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a high-angle bird's-eye view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly sweep to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a desert landscape with light-brown sand dunes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are fluffy white cumulus clouds visible drifting across a brilliant blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in bright midday sunlight creating sharp shadows on the dunes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0010417040903121233 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.876041889190674 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0010417040903121233, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0010417040903121233, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15851527452468872, + 0.05161132663488388, + 0.0383911207318306, + 0.2308298945426941, + 0.10367482155561447, + 0.12966176867485046, + 0.07607702910900116, + 0.06793788820505142, + 0.024875786155462265, + 0.11842508614063263 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0010417040903121233 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a high-angle bird's-eye view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly sweep to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a desert landscape with light-brown sand dunes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are fluffy white cumulus clouds visible drifting across a brilliant blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in bright midday sunlight creating sharp shadows on the dunes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0031916177831590176 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.7531914710998535 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0031916177831590176, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0031916177831590176, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20040154457092285, + 0.07881622761487961, + 0.09091614186763763, + 0.07772001624107361, + 0.04274444282054901, + 0.06858121603727341, + 0.24985292553901672, + 0.05832185223698616, + 0.049385327845811844, + 0.08326023817062378 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0031916177831590176 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a high-angle bird's-eye view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly sweep to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a desert landscape with light-brown sand dunes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are fluffy white cumulus clouds visible drifting across a brilliant blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in bright midday sunlight creating sharp shadows on the dunes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007621141150593758 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.8826212882995605 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007621141150593758, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007621141150593758, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1448587328195572, + 0.04809606075286865, + 0.16578654944896698, + 0.09012014418840408, + 0.051987193524837494, + 0.10804110020399094, + 0.21924662590026855, + 0.04884444549679756, + 0.05974092334508896, + 0.0632781833410263 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007621141150593758 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "From a majestic high-angle bird's-eye view, the camera slowly sweeps to the right, revealing a vast and serene desert landscape beneath a brilliant blue sky. A few fluffy white cumulus clouds drift lazily across the frame, casting vast, slow-moving shadows on the world below. The scene is bathed in bright, unfiltered midday sunlight, which sculpts the undulating waves of light-brown sand, creating sharp, defined ridges and deep shadows that emphasize their texture. These dunes stretch endlessly toward the horizon, their warm ochre hues contrasting sharply with the small, springy green shrubs sparsely scattered across the terrain. In the distance, a hazy mountain range rises, its weathered peaks a blend of soft reds and browns, blending seamlessly with the shimmering air at the edge of the world. The camera's deliberate, expansive movements enhance the scale of the vista, evoking a powerful atmosphere of tranquil solitude and majestic, untouched nature.", + "seed": 11689, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_1/index_416_seed_11689_dp_3_rank_6_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.15600885150488467, + "vlm_logprob": -0.15600885150488467, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.15, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.15600885150488467, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a high-angle bird's-eye view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly sweep to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a desert landscape with light-brown sand dunes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are fluffy white cumulus clouds visible drifting across a brilliant blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in bright midday sunlight creating sharp shadows on the dunes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6962540745735168 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6962540745735168 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.6962540745735168, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.6962540745735168, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1143350899219513, + 0.07622019201517105, + 0.04341833293437958, + 0.06562748551368713, + 0.09008404612541199, + 0.07163366675376892, + 0.05288992077112198, + 0.2751469314098358, + 0.11905793845653534, + 0.0915864109992981 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.6962540745735168 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a high-angle bird's-eye view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly sweep to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a desert landscape with light-brown sand dunes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are fluffy white cumulus clouds visible drifting across a brilliant blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in bright midday sunlight creating sharp shadows on the dunes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0700172632932663 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950173377990723 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0700172632932663, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0700172632932663, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1909131407737732, + 0.045525211840867996, + 0.02873232215642929, + 0.1644112765789032, + 0.07838048040866852, + 0.03772831708192825, + 0.054505620151758194, + 0.1700616031885147, + 0.08184261620044708, + 0.14789938926696777 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0700172632932663 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a high-angle bird's-eye view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly sweep to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a desert landscape with light-brown sand dunes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are fluffy white cumulus clouds visible drifting across a brilliant blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in bright midday sunlight creating sharp shadows on the dunes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00038628268521279097 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.8753862380981445 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00038628268521279097, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00038628268521279097, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17781232297420502, + 0.06529486179351807, + 0.029666757211089134, + 0.056008998304605484, + 0.08614770323038101, + 0.08101414889097214, + 0.026865718886256218, + 0.07756862044334412, + 0.06421303004026413, + 0.33540791273117065 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00038628268521279097 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a high-angle bird's-eye view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly sweep to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a desert landscape with light-brown sand dunes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are fluffy white cumulus clouds visible drifting across a brilliant blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in bright midday sunlight creating sharp shadows on the dunes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003613610751926899 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628613471984863 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003613610751926899, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003613610751926899, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2068469226360321, + 0.16652238368988037, + 0.09023375064134598, + 0.020289791747927666, + 0.08448901027441025, + 0.041554369032382965, + 0.03387914225459099, + 0.20729570090770721, + 0.05636611208319664, + 0.09252278506755829 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003613610751926899 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a high-angle bird's-eye view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly sweep to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a desert landscape with light-brown sand dunes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are fluffy white cumulus clouds visible drifting across a brilliant blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in bright midday sunlight creating sharp shadows on the dunes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00977302622050047 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634773254394531 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00977302622050047, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00977302622050047, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17915256321430206, + 0.04587863013148308, + 0.030442262068390846, + 0.04421967267990112, + 0.04478437453508377, + 0.05992945656180382, + 0.051601994782686234, + 0.20199261605739594, + 0.15835517644882202, + 0.18364323675632477 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00977302622050047 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_10/index_tensor([9611, 9611])_group_10_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_10/index_tensor([9611, 9611])_group_10_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..d079cfac6e461ef11f91db5acec7312c587f819b --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_10/index_tensor([9611, 9611])_group_10_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "static, medium shot establishes the abyssal darkness of murky, green waters, teeming with suspended particulate matter. A harsh beam of light cuts diagonally through the darkness from an unseen source above, illuminating a large, predatory barracuda circling ominously, its form defined by deep, high-contrast shadows of a criminal aesthetic. The harsh light captures the iridescent, olive-green sheen of its scales along its back, while its underbelly is engulfed in impenetrable black. With a slow, deliberate rhythm, the fish executes a powerful shimmy with its tail fin, a controlled muscle contraction that stirs up a small cloud of fine powder from the invisible floor. The particles momentarily catch the light before dispersing into the otherwise still water. The camera then begins a tight, relentless advance, gliding smoothly across the fish's menacing, half-open jaw, light glints off rows of sharp, needle-like teeth, culminating in an extreme close-up of its cold, glassy eye—a perfect, unblinking black orb reflecting the singular light source, suffusing the frame with pure, focused predatory intent.", + "seed": 22466, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_10/index_9611_seed_22466_dp_20_rank_40_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.060066177137196065, + "vlm_logprob": -0.060066177137196065, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.65, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.060066177137196065, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in murky, green water with suspended particulate matter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a large barracuda visible with an olive-green sheen on its back and a black underbelly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the barracuda execute a slow, deliberate shimmy with its tail fin that stirs up a cloud of fine powder?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shown advancing in a tight, smooth motion from a medium shot to an extreme close-up of the fish's eye?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the fish's eye depicted as a cold, glassy black orb reflecting a singular light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008274204097688198 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.383274078369141 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008274204097688198, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008274204097688198, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17448759078979492, + 0.08924940228462219, + 0.20448854565620422, + 0.08341129124164581, + 0.09003389626741409, + 0.03193691000342369, + 0.036083564162254333, + 0.045207712799310684, + 0.09409832954406738, + 0.1510026901960373 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008274204097688198 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in murky, green water with suspended particulate matter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a large barracuda visible with an olive-green sheen on its back and a black underbelly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the barracuda execute a slow, deliberate shimmy with its tail fin that stirs up a cloud of fine powder?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shown advancing in a tight, smooth motion from a medium shot to an extreme close-up of the fish's eye?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the fish's eye depicted as a cold, glassy black orb reflecting a singular light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020590949803590775 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955910205841064 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020590949803590775, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020590949803590775, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15827062726020813, + 0.13455507159233093, + 0.10355237126350403, + 0.09033127129077911, + 0.03032180853188038, + 0.06888872385025024, + 0.06065956503152847, + 0.09672383964061737, + 0.11148124188184738, + 0.1452154964208603 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020590949803590775 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in murky, green water with suspended particulate matter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a large barracuda visible with an olive-green sheen on its back and a black underbelly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the barracuda execute a slow, deliberate shimmy with its tail fin that stirs up a cloud of fine powder?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shown advancing in a tight, smooth motion from a medium shot to an extreme close-up of the fish's eye?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the fish's eye depicted as a cold, glassy black orb reflecting a singular light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22559930384159088 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6005992889404297 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.22559930384159088, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.22559930384159088, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12627367675304413, + 0.06253153085708618, + 0.1728084683418274, + 0.034984856843948364, + 0.02286454290151596, + 0.058480676263570786, + 0.03142504766583443, + 0.07683910429477692, + 0.13150134682655334, + 0.2822907567024231 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 2, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.22559930384159088 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in murky, green water with suspended particulate matter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a large barracuda visible with an olive-green sheen on its back and a black underbelly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the barracuda execute a slow, deliberate shimmy with its tail fin that stirs up a cloud of fine powder?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shown advancing in a tight, smooth motion from a medium shot to an extreme close-up of the fish's eye?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the fish's eye depicted as a cold, glassy black orb reflecting a singular light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016066139563918114 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141066074371338 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016066139563918114, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016066139563918114, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05447001755237579, + 0.04355777055025101, + 0.11901196092367172, + 0.03186807408928871, + 0.030406465753912926, + 0.027663227170705795, + 0.06248236075043678, + 0.05005194619297981, + 0.09847688674926758, + 0.4820112884044647 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 2, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016066139563918114 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in murky, green water with suspended particulate matter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a large barracuda visible with an olive-green sheen on its back and a black underbelly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the barracuda execute a slow, deliberate shimmy with its tail fin that stirs up a cloud of fine powder?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shown advancing in a tight, smooth motion from a medium shot to an extreme close-up of the fish's eye?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the fish's eye depicted as a cold, glassy black orb reflecting a singular light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029800288379192352 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298001766204834 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029800288379192352, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029800288379192352, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09997730702161789, + 0.05277585983276367, + 0.05104139819741249, + 0.039972539991140366, + 0.0228774081915617, + 0.022377679124474525, + 0.052186254411935806, + 0.07728429138660431, + 0.11042925715446472, + 0.47107797861099243 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029800288379192352 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, medium shot establishes the abyssal darkness of murky, green waters, teeming with suspended particulate matter. A harsh beam of light cuts diagonally through the darkness from an unseen source above, illuminating a large, predatory barracuda circling ominously, its form defined by deep, high-contrast shadows of a criminal aesthetic. The harsh light captures the iridescent, olive-green sheen of its scales along its back, while its underbelly is engulfed in impenetrable black. With a slow, deliberate rhythm, the fish executes a powerful shimmy with its tail fin, a controlled muscle contraction that stirs up a small cloud of fine powder from the invisible floor. The particles momentarily catch the light before dispersing into the otherwise still water. The camera then begins a tight, relentless advance, gliding smoothly across the fish's menacing, half-open jaw, light glints off rows of sharp, needle-like teeth, culminating in an extreme close-up of its cold, glassy eye—a perfect, unblinking black orb reflecting the singular light source, suffusing the frame with pure, focused predatory intent.", + "seed": 22467, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_10/index_9611_seed_22467_dp_20_rank_40_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.04408511854708195, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04408511854708195, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.925, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04408511854708195, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in murky, green water with suspended particulate matter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a large barracuda visible with an olive-green sheen on its back and a black underbelly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the barracuda execute a slow, deliberate shimmy with its tail fin that stirs up a cloud of fine powder?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shown advancing in a tight, smooth motion from a medium shot to an extreme close-up of the fish's eye?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the fish's eye depicted as a cold, glassy black orb reflecting a singular light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006370356772094965 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.381370544433594 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006370356772094965, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006370356772094965, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08289498090744019, + 0.028157014399766922, + 0.106380894780159, + 0.02821202203631401, + 0.04894355311989784, + 0.05043461173772812, + 0.05622971057891846, + 0.03443634510040283, + 0.07856270670890808, + 0.48574814200401306 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006370356772094965 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in murky, green water with suspended particulate matter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a large barracuda visible with an olive-green sheen on its back and a black underbelly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the barracuda execute a slow, deliberate shimmy with its tail fin that stirs up a cloud of fine powder?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shown advancing in a tight, smooth motion from a medium shot to an extreme close-up of the fish's eye?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the fish's eye depicted as a cold, glassy black orb reflecting a singular light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020595386624336243 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955953121185303 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020595386624336243, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020595386624336243, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05684155598282814, + 0.022698648273944855, + 0.023557137697935104, + 0.0569058358669281, + 0.1325715035200119, + 0.06326521188020706, + 0.04891436547040939, + 0.029214700683951378, + 0.016696613281965256, + 0.5493344068527222 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020595386624336243 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in murky, green water with suspended particulate matter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a large barracuda visible with an olive-green sheen on its back and a black underbelly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the barracuda execute a slow, deliberate shimmy with its tail fin that stirs up a cloud of fine powder?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shown advancing in a tight, smooth motion from a medium shot to an extreme close-up of the fish's eye?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the fish's eye depicted as a cold, glassy black orb reflecting a singular light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1603829264640808 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9103829860687256 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1603829264640808, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1603829264640808, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03948863223195076, + 0.01372948195785284, + 0.02633507363498211, + 0.05814433470368385, + 0.027956658974289894, + 0.016468344256281853, + 0.021773217245936394, + 0.031036242842674255, + 0.140334814786911, + 0.6247332096099854 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1603829264640808 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in murky, green water with suspended particulate matter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a large barracuda visible with an olive-green sheen on its back and a black underbelly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the barracuda execute a slow, deliberate shimmy with its tail fin that stirs up a cloud of fine powder?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shown advancing in a tight, smooth motion from a medium shot to an extreme close-up of the fish's eye?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the fish's eye depicted as a cold, glassy black orb reflecting a singular light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006735952105373144 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006735801696777 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006735952105373144, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006735952105373144, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.021812578663229942, + 0.005833103787153959, + 0.007818055339157581, + 0.008889922872185707, + 0.031547967344522476, + 0.10913150012493134, + 0.013783863745629787, + 0.0134971234947443, + 0.01447991095483303, + 0.7732059359550476 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006735952105373144 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in murky, green water with suspended particulate matter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a large barracuda visible with an olive-green sheen on its back and a black underbelly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the barracuda execute a slow, deliberate shimmy with its tail fin that stirs up a cloud of fine powder?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shown advancing in a tight, smooth motion from a medium shot to an extreme close-up of the fish's eye?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the fish's eye depicted as a cold, glassy black orb reflecting a singular light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026340970769524574 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651340961456299 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026340970769524574, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026340970769524574, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.050879012793302536, + 0.01773105561733246, + 0.036944396793842316, + 0.026130933314561844, + 0.03129320219159126, + 0.06424810737371445, + 0.01991729624569416, + 0.026278482750058174, + 0.07415495067834854, + 0.6524226069450378 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026340970769524574 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, medium shot establishes the abyssal darkness of murky, green waters, teeming with suspended particulate matter. A harsh beam of light cuts diagonally through the darkness from an unseen source above, illuminating a large, predatory barracuda circling ominously, its form defined by deep, high-contrast shadows of a criminal aesthetic. The harsh light captures the iridescent, olive-green sheen of its scales along its back, while its underbelly is engulfed in impenetrable black. With a slow, deliberate rhythm, the fish executes a powerful shimmy with its tail fin, a controlled muscle contraction that stirs up a small cloud of fine powder from the invisible floor. The particles momentarily catch the light before dispersing into the otherwise still water. The camera then begins a tight, relentless advance, gliding smoothly across the fish's menacing, half-open jaw, light glints off rows of sharp, needle-like teeth, culminating in an extreme close-up of its cold, glassy eye—a perfect, unblinking black orb reflecting the singular light source, suffusing the frame with pure, focused predatory intent.", + "seed": 22468, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_10/index_9611_seed_22468_dp_21_rank_42_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.11030688555911183, + "vlm_logprob": -0.11030688555911183, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.4, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.11030688555911183, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in murky, green water with suspended particulate matter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a large barracuda visible with an olive-green sheen on its back and a black underbelly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the barracuda execute a slow, deliberate shimmy with its tail fin that stirs up a cloud of fine powder?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shown advancing in a tight, smooth motion from a medium shot to an extreme close-up of the fish's eye?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the fish's eye depicted as a cold, glassy black orb reflecting a singular light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.015141783282160759 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.26514196395874 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.015141783282160759, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.015141783282160759, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13469603657722473, + 0.0897531658411026, + 0.09095614403486252, + 0.058811936527490616, + 0.09924252331256866, + 0.05047187954187393, + 0.2807709276676178, + 0.06102905422449112, + 0.07686013728380203, + 0.05740821734070778 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.015141783282160759 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in murky, green water with suspended particulate matter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a large barracuda visible with an olive-green sheen on its back and a black underbelly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the barracuda execute a slow, deliberate shimmy with its tail fin that stirs up a cloud of fine powder?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shown advancing in a tight, smooth motion from a medium shot to an extreme close-up of the fish's eye?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the fish's eye depicted as a cold, glassy black orb reflecting a singular light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029817529022693634 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529817581176758 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029817529022693634, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029817529022693634, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2601315975189209, + 0.12693844735622406, + 0.09367763996124268, + 0.08207520097494125, + 0.06185010075569153, + 0.0590011402964592, + 0.03627932816743851, + 0.0748911201953888, + 0.16837464272975922, + 0.03678078576922417 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029817529022693634 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in murky, green water with suspended particulate matter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a large barracuda visible with an olive-green sheen on its back and a black underbelly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the barracuda execute a slow, deliberate shimmy with its tail fin that stirs up a cloud of fine powder?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shown advancing in a tight, smooth motion from a medium shot to an extreme close-up of the fish's eye?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the fish's eye depicted as a cold, glassy black orb reflecting a singular light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.474279522895813 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.974279522895813 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.474279522895813, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.474279522895813, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10521098226308823, + 0.04766971245408058, + 0.19681032001972198, + 0.03855922818183899, + 0.0559416264295578, + 0.04247095063328743, + 0.04449785128235817, + 0.06258115917444229, + 0.3582824468612671, + 0.04797569662332535 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.474279522895813 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in murky, green water with suspended particulate matter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a large barracuda visible with an olive-green sheen on its back and a black underbelly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the barracuda execute a slow, deliberate shimmy with its tail fin that stirs up a cloud of fine powder?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shown advancing in a tight, smooth motion from a medium shot to an extreme close-up of the fish's eye?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the fish's eye depicted as a cold, glassy black orb reflecting a singular light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005948933307081461 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130949020385742 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005948933307081461, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005948933307081461, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11173811554908752, + 0.047305867075920105, + 0.03555084764957428, + 0.07682780176401138, + 0.04914163053035736, + 0.037679366767406464, + 0.19375500082969666, + 0.2014017254114151, + 0.17516149580478668, + 0.07143818587064743 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005948933307081461 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in murky, green water with suspended particulate matter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a large barracuda visible with an olive-green sheen on its back and a black underbelly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the barracuda execute a slow, deliberate shimmy with its tail fin that stirs up a cloud of fine powder?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shown advancing in a tight, smooth motion from a medium shot to an extreme close-up of the fish's eye?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the fish's eye depicted as a cold, glassy black orb reflecting a singular light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026346659287810326 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513466835021973 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026346659287810326, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026346659287810326, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13387279212474823, + 0.03395666927099228, + 0.05737728253006935, + 0.06388429552316666, + 0.03615440055727959, + 0.029748236760497093, + 0.2970387935638428, + 0.12888528406620026, + 0.20207424461841583, + 0.017008010298013687 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026346659287810326 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, medium shot establishes the abyssal darkness of murky, green waters, teeming with suspended particulate matter. A harsh beam of light cuts diagonally through the darkness from an unseen source above, illuminating a large, predatory barracuda circling ominously, its form defined by deep, high-contrast shadows of a criminal aesthetic. The harsh light captures the iridescent, olive-green sheen of its scales along its back, while its underbelly is engulfed in impenetrable black. With a slow, deliberate rhythm, the fish executes a powerful shimmy with its tail fin, a controlled muscle contraction that stirs up a small cloud of fine powder from the invisible floor. The particles momentarily catch the light before dispersing into the otherwise still water. The camera then begins a tight, relentless advance, gliding smoothly across the fish's menacing, half-open jaw, light glints off rows of sharp, needle-like teeth, culminating in an extreme close-up of its cold, glassy eye—a perfect, unblinking black orb reflecting the singular light source, suffusing the frame with pure, focused predatory intent.", + "seed": 22469, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_10/index_9611_seed_22469_dp_21_rank_42_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.0660684890113771, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0660684890113771, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.849999952316284, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0660684890113771, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in murky, green water with suspended particulate matter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a large barracuda visible with an olive-green sheen on its back and a black underbelly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the barracuda execute a slow, deliberate shimmy with its tail fin that stirs up a cloud of fine powder?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shown advancing in a tight, smooth motion from a medium shot to an extreme close-up of the fish's eye?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the fish's eye depicted as a cold, glassy black orb reflecting a singular light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008952242322266102 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.0089521408081055 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008952242322266102, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008952242322266102, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03527107462286949, + 0.037297070026397705, + 0.022707484662532806, + 0.0641927719116211, + 0.01149218063801527, + 0.037664592266082764, + 0.6487816572189331, + 0.04735381528735161, + 0.07617143541574478, + 0.01906796544790268 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008952242322266102 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in murky, green water with suspended particulate matter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a large barracuda visible with an olive-green sheen on its back and a black underbelly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the barracuda execute a slow, deliberate shimmy with its tail fin that stirs up a cloud of fine powder?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shown advancing in a tight, smooth motion from a medium shot to an extreme close-up of the fish's eye?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the fish's eye depicted as a cold, glassy black orb reflecting a singular light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018202990293502808 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018202781677246 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018202990293502808, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018202990293502808, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08660672605037689, + 0.020787987858057022, + 0.021843036636710167, + 0.1604270190000534, + 0.026164745911955833, + 0.04749397933483124, + 0.41846734285354614, + 0.0329398550093174, + 0.08975305408239365, + 0.09551628679037094 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018202990293502808 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in murky, green water with suspended particulate matter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a large barracuda visible with an olive-green sheen on its back and a black underbelly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the barracuda execute a slow, deliberate shimmy with its tail fin that stirs up a cloud of fine powder?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shown advancing in a tight, smooth motion from a medium shot to an extreme close-up of the fish's eye?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the fish's eye depicted as a cold, glassy black orb reflecting a singular light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2813646197319031 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4063646793365479 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2813646197319031, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2813646197319031, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0572206936776638, + 0.04499082639813423, + 0.03280515596270561, + 0.15331658720970154, + 0.05685097724199295, + 0.1334075927734375, + 0.33729878067970276, + 0.03274637833237648, + 0.13034147024154663, + 0.02102147974073887 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2813646197319031 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in murky, green water with suspended particulate matter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a large barracuda visible with an olive-green sheen on its back and a black underbelly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the barracuda execute a slow, deliberate shimmy with its tail fin that stirs up a cloud of fine powder?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shown advancing in a tight, smooth motion from a medium shot to an extreme close-up of the fish's eye?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the fish's eye depicted as a cold, glassy black orb reflecting a singular light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00762729300186038 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882627487182617 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00762729300186038, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00762729300186038, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.047809481620788574, + 0.030047234147787094, + 0.03456903249025345, + 0.18084099888801575, + 0.026467833667993546, + 0.06015614792704582, + 0.22885838150978088, + 0.026086704805493355, + 0.2908880412578583, + 0.0742761641740799 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00762729300186038 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in murky, green water with suspended particulate matter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a large barracuda visible with an olive-green sheen on its back and a black underbelly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the barracuda execute a slow, deliberate shimmy with its tail fin that stirs up a cloud of fine powder?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shown advancing in a tight, smooth motion from a medium shot to an extreme close-up of the fish's eye?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the fish's eye depicted as a cold, glassy black orb reflecting a singular light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014195299707353115 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264195442199707 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014195299707353115, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014195299707353115, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06038773059844971, + 0.02129313349723816, + 0.013125966303050518, + 0.08075368404388428, + 0.041388411074876785, + 0.02508409135043621, + 0.4431689977645874, + 0.03291670233011246, + 0.10297580063343048, + 0.17890553176403046 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014195299707353115 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_11/index_tensor([8884, 8884])_group_11_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_11/index_tensor([8884, 8884])_group_11_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..15031b5be1cd9a384bb592d7b7154ef15401313c --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_11/index_tensor([8884, 8884])_group_11_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "dramatic, high-angle, sweeping drone view dynamically orbits the legendary Nissan Skyline GT-R R34, its iconic Bayside Blue Metallic paint gleaming in the glare of the setting sun as it violently spins out of control on a treacherous mountain pass. Rendered in a high-energy anime art style, the entire scene is defined by bold glass-shadow outlines, exaggerated motion blur, and dynamic speed lines spanning the frame. The car loses all traction and slides sideways with uncontrollable momentum, tires hissing and billowing thick white smoke. A cloud of brilliant, stylized orange and white sparks erupts into the air as its side ruthlessly scrapes against the worn steel guardrail. The impact causes the front bumper to crack and shatter, sending jagged fragments flying, while the undercarriage groans and visibly buckles. The camera swoops down, closely following the vehicle as its tires dig into the curb, sending it into a catastrophic roll. In a chaotic ballet of destruction, the car flips over and the detached parts of its bodywork – shattered headlights, crumpled hoods, shards of glass – are ejected with explosive force, creating a series of fragments rendered as vibrant particle effects that simultaneously emphasize both the raw speed and the beautiful, utterly devastated machine against the backdrop of a rugged mountain range.", + "seed": 8463, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_11/index_8884_seed_8463_dp_22_rank_44_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.06236290838569403, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06236290838569403, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.15, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06236290838569403, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Nissan Skyline GT-R R34 with Bayside Blue Metallic paint?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a high-energy anime art style with bold glass-shadow outlines and exaggerated motion blur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the car violently spinning out of control on a treacherous mountain pass with thick white smoke from tires?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the car scrape against a steel guardrail, causing the front bumper to crack and shatter with jagged fragments flying?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a high-angle sweeping drone view that swoops down to follow the car as it flips over?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11849337816238403 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2434933185577393 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11849337816238403, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11849337816238403, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20634618401527405, + 0.057647187262773514, + 0.12253521382808685, + 0.10816236585378647, + 0.0935116708278656, + 0.05422865226864815, + 0.24501851201057434, + 0.048287905752658844, + 0.014829243533313274, + 0.049433037638664246 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11849337816238403 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Nissan Skyline GT-R R34 with Bayside Blue Metallic paint?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a high-energy anime art style with bold glass-shadow outlines and exaggerated motion blur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the car violently spinning out of control on a treacherous mountain pass with thick white smoke from tires?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the car scrape against a steel guardrail, causing the front bumper to crack and shatter with jagged fragments flying?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a high-angle sweeping drone view that swoops down to follow the car as it flips over?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004652864299714565 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379652976989746 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004652864299714565, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004652864299714565, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22372668981552124, + 0.08344339579343796, + 0.2245977222919464, + 0.04339732602238655, + 0.08297479897737503, + 0.02614223212003708, + 0.1280192732810974, + 0.05863150209188461, + 0.02148447558283806, + 0.10758256912231445 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004652864299714565 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Nissan Skyline GT-R R34 with Bayside Blue Metallic paint?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a high-energy anime art style with bold glass-shadow outlines and exaggerated motion blur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the car violently spinning out of control on a treacherous mountain pass with thick white smoke from tires?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the car scrape against a steel guardrail, causing the front bumper to crack and shatter with jagged fragments flying?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a high-angle sweeping drone view that swoops down to follow the car as it flips over?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0700078159570694 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695007801055908 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0700078159570694, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0700078159570694, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13330119848251343, + 0.062207289040088654, + 0.33466237783432007, + 0.2289939522743225, + 0.056407131254673004, + 0.023120956495404243, + 0.031591128557920456, + 0.028175193816423416, + 0.008763621561229229, + 0.09277709573507309 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0700078159570694 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Nissan Skyline GT-R R34 with Bayside Blue Metallic paint?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a high-energy anime art style with bold glass-shadow outlines and exaggerated motion blur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the car violently spinning out of control on a treacherous mountain pass with thick white smoke from tires?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the car scrape against a steel guardrail, causing the front bumper to crack and shatter with jagged fragments flying?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a high-angle sweeping drone view that swoops down to follow the car as it flips over?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04866022989153862 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486602783203125 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04866022989153862, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04866022989153862, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19037961959838867, + 0.10242827981710434, + 0.08714913576841354, + 0.03841831907629967, + 0.06335790455341339, + 0.03406249359250069, + 0.13655708730220795, + 0.23198367655277252, + 0.021177126094698906, + 0.09448634088039398 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04866022989153862 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Nissan Skyline GT-R R34 with Bayside Blue Metallic paint?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a high-energy anime art style with bold glass-shadow outlines and exaggerated motion blur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the car violently spinning out of control on a treacherous mountain pass with thick white smoke from tires?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the car scrape against a steel guardrail, causing the front bumper to crack and shatter with jagged fragments flying?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a high-angle sweeping drone view that swoops down to follow the car as it flips over?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07000025361776352 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695000171661377 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07000025361776352, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07000025361776352, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12507067620754242, + 0.049074918031692505, + 0.23400531709194183, + 0.18017300963401794, + 0.09130794554948807, + 0.033209528774023056, + 0.1473054736852646, + 0.04514503479003906, + 0.032147087156772614, + 0.06256098300218582 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07000025361776352 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dramatic, high-angle, sweeping drone view dynamically orbits the legendary Nissan Skyline GT-R R34, its iconic Bayside Blue Metallic paint gleaming in the glare of the setting sun as it violently spins out of control on a treacherous mountain pass. Rendered in a high-energy anime art style, the entire scene is defined by bold glass-shadow outlines, exaggerated motion blur, and dynamic speed lines spanning the frame. The car loses all traction and slides sideways with uncontrollable momentum, tires hissing and billowing thick white smoke. A cloud of brilliant, stylized orange and white sparks erupts into the air as its side ruthlessly scrapes against the worn steel guardrail. The impact causes the front bumper to crack and shatter, sending jagged fragments flying, while the undercarriage groans and visibly buckles. The camera swoops down, closely following the vehicle as its tires dig into the curb, sending it into a catastrophic roll. In a chaotic ballet of destruction, the car flips over and the detached parts of its bodywork – shattered headlights, crumpled hoods, shards of glass – are ejected with explosive force, creating a series of fragments rendered as vibrant particle effects that simultaneously emphasize both the raw speed and the beautiful, utterly devastated machine against the backdrop of a rugged mountain range.", + "seed": 8464, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_11/index_8884_seed_8464_dp_22_rank_44_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.21793480664491655, + "vlm_logprob": -0.21793480664491655, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.125, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.21793480664491655, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Nissan Skyline GT-R R34 with Bayside Blue Metallic paint?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a high-energy anime art style with bold glass-shadow outlines and exaggerated motion blur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the car violently spinning out of control on a treacherous mountain pass with thick white smoke from tires?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the car scrape against a steel guardrail, causing the front bumper to crack and shatter with jagged fragments flying?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a high-angle sweeping drone view that swoops down to follow the car as it flips over?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20518240332603455 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.705182433128357 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20518240332603455, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20518240332603455, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0815022736787796, + 0.07790526002645493, + 0.07018942385911942, + 0.23659159243106842, + 0.029637880623340607, + 0.08033620566129684, + 0.02441931888461113, + 0.3491474986076355, + 0.01856309361755848, + 0.03170739486813545 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20518240332603455 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Nissan Skyline GT-R R34 with Bayside Blue Metallic paint?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a high-energy anime art style with bold glass-shadow outlines and exaggerated motion blur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the car violently spinning out of control on a treacherous mountain pass with thick white smoke from tires?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the car scrape against a steel guardrail, causing the front bumper to crack and shatter with jagged fragments flying?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a high-angle sweeping drone view that swoops down to follow the car as it flips over?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009796753525733948 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634796619415283 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009796753525733948, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009796753525733948, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15752281248569489, + 0.15952588617801666, + 0.05783264338970184, + 0.11650041490793228, + 0.07721730321645737, + 0.06318788230419159, + 0.0525408573448658, + 0.11593740433454514, + 0.1400219202041626, + 0.05971282348036766 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009796753525733948 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Nissan Skyline GT-R R34 with Bayside Blue Metallic paint?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a high-energy anime art style with bold glass-shadow outlines and exaggerated motion blur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the car violently spinning out of control on a treacherous mountain pass with thick white smoke from tires?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the car scrape against a steel guardrail, causing the front bumper to crack and shatter with jagged fragments flying?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a high-angle sweeping drone view that swoops down to follow the car as it flips over?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.632771909236908 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.757771909236908 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.632771909236908, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.632771909236908, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09824304282665253, + 0.06871090084314346, + 0.0521673820912838, + 0.07851728796958923, + 0.033354878425598145, + 0.042620159685611725, + 0.019114570692181587, + 0.5416115522384644, + 0.014391087926924229, + 0.051269154995679855 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.632771909236908 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Nissan Skyline GT-R R34 with Bayside Blue Metallic paint?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a high-energy anime art style with bold glass-shadow outlines and exaggerated motion blur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the car violently spinning out of control on a treacherous mountain pass with thick white smoke from tires?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the car scrape against a steel guardrail, causing the front bumper to crack and shatter with jagged fragments flying?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a high-angle sweeping drone view that swoops down to follow the car as it flips over?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17989832162857056 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8048982620239258 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17989832162857056, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17989832162857056, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1367303729057312, + 0.06850587576627731, + 0.04635253921151161, + 0.08673559874296188, + 0.05371365696191788, + 0.08742862194776535, + 0.022167567163705826, + 0.3270460367202759, + 0.04378611966967583, + 0.12753362953662872 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17989832162857056 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Nissan Skyline GT-R R34 with Bayside Blue Metallic paint?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a high-energy anime art style with bold glass-shadow outlines and exaggerated motion blur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the car violently spinning out of control on a treacherous mountain pass with thick white smoke from tires?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the car scrape against a steel guardrail, causing the front bumper to crack and shatter with jagged fragments flying?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a high-angle sweeping drone view that swoops down to follow the car as it flips over?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06202464550733566 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120245933532715 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06202464550733566, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06202464550733566, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14815491437911987, + 0.14432580769062042, + 0.0731506273150444, + 0.06660538911819458, + 0.09529177844524384, + 0.08821500092744827, + 0.0768023356795311, + 0.17768335342407227, + 0.04488280415534973, + 0.08488798886537552 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06202464550733566 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dramatic, high-angle, sweeping drone view dynamically orbits the legendary Nissan Skyline GT-R R34, its iconic Bayside Blue Metallic paint gleaming in the glare of the setting sun as it violently spins out of control on a treacherous mountain pass. Rendered in a high-energy anime art style, the entire scene is defined by bold glass-shadow outlines, exaggerated motion blur, and dynamic speed lines spanning the frame. The car loses all traction and slides sideways with uncontrollable momentum, tires hissing and billowing thick white smoke. A cloud of brilliant, stylized orange and white sparks erupts into the air as its side ruthlessly scrapes against the worn steel guardrail. The impact causes the front bumper to crack and shatter, sending jagged fragments flying, while the undercarriage groans and visibly buckles. The camera swoops down, closely following the vehicle as its tires dig into the curb, sending it into a catastrophic roll. In a chaotic ballet of destruction, the car flips over and the detached parts of its bodywork – shattered headlights, crumpled hoods, shards of glass – are ejected with explosive force, creating a series of fragments rendered as vibrant particle effects that simultaneously emphasize both the raw speed and the beautiful, utterly devastated machine against the backdrop of a rugged mountain range.", + "seed": 8465, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_11/index_8884_seed_8465_dp_23_rank_46_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.20816817246377467, + "vlm_logprob": -0.20816817246377467, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.05, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.20816817246377467, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Nissan Skyline GT-R R34 with Bayside Blue Metallic paint?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a high-energy anime art style with bold glass-shadow outlines and exaggerated motion blur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the car violently spinning out of control on a treacherous mountain pass with thick white smoke from tires?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the car scrape against a steel guardrail, causing the front bumper to crack and shatter with jagged fragments flying?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a high-angle sweeping drone view that swoops down to follow the car as it flips over?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16368244588375092 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.913682460784912 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16368244588375092, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16368244588375092, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13715951144695282, + 0.03546512499451637, + 0.04694021865725517, + 0.038383059203624725, + 0.052873630076646805, + 0.0385965034365654, + 0.0522775836288929, + 0.23605667054653168, + 0.2325478047132492, + 0.12969988584518433 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16368244588375092 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Nissan Skyline GT-R R34 with Bayside Blue Metallic paint?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a high-energy anime art style with bold glass-shadow outlines and exaggerated motion blur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the car violently spinning out of control on a treacherous mountain pass with thick white smoke from tires?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the car scrape against a steel guardrail, causing the front bumper to crack and shatter with jagged fragments flying?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a high-angle sweeping drone view that swoops down to follow the car as it flips over?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00865045003592968 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758650302886963 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00865045003592968, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00865045003592968, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11227656155824661, + 0.04775194823741913, + 0.04765833541750908, + 0.04095570370554924, + 0.031760960817337036, + 0.03444969654083252, + 0.10609583556652069, + 0.2183838188648224, + 0.3036557137966156, + 0.057011354714632034 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00865045003592968 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Nissan Skyline GT-R R34 with Bayside Blue Metallic paint?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a high-energy anime art style with bold glass-shadow outlines and exaggerated motion blur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the car violently spinning out of control on a treacherous mountain pass with thick white smoke from tires?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the car scrape against a steel guardrail, causing the front bumper to crack and shatter with jagged fragments flying?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a high-angle sweeping drone view that swoops down to follow the car as it flips over?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2813061475753784 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4063061475753784 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2813061475753784, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2813061475753784, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1877015084028244, + 0.07290084660053253, + 0.0586356595158577, + 0.057571105659008026, + 0.05906592682003975, + 0.07085900753736496, + 0.09717671573162079, + 0.11118752509355545, + 0.04581567272543907, + 0.23908604681491852 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2813061475753784 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Nissan Skyline GT-R R34 with Bayside Blue Metallic paint?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a high-energy anime art style with bold glass-shadow outlines and exaggerated motion blur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the car violently spinning out of control on a treacherous mountain pass with thick white smoke from tires?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the car scrape against a steel guardrail, causing the front bumper to crack and shatter with jagged fragments flying?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a high-angle sweeping drone view that swoops down to follow the car as it flips over?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11294512450695038 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.237945079803467 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11294512450695038, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11294512450695038, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.043095096945762634, + 0.023185931146144867, + 0.027996761724352837, + 0.05574733391404152, + 0.10812057554721832, + 0.0871175155043602, + 0.17526142299175262, + 0.2542455494403839, + 0.16049624979496002, + 0.06473354995250702 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11294512450695038 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Nissan Skyline GT-R R34 with Bayside Blue Metallic paint?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a high-energy anime art style with bold glass-shadow outlines and exaggerated motion blur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the car violently spinning out of control on a treacherous mountain pass with thick white smoke from tires?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the car scrape against a steel guardrail, causing the front bumper to crack and shatter with jagged fragments flying?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a high-angle sweeping drone view that swoops down to follow the car as it flips over?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.474256694316864 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.974256694316864 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.474256694316864, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.474256694316864, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1588805913925171, + 0.0938999280333519, + 0.036750953644514084, + 0.0721561536192894, + 0.09230075776576996, + 0.026881232857704163, + 0.04826275259256363, + 0.10264862328767776, + 0.18407626450061798, + 0.18414270877838135 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.474256694316864 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dramatic, high-angle, sweeping drone view dynamically orbits the legendary Nissan Skyline GT-R R34, its iconic Bayside Blue Metallic paint gleaming in the glare of the setting sun as it violently spins out of control on a treacherous mountain pass. Rendered in a high-energy anime art style, the entire scene is defined by bold glass-shadow outlines, exaggerated motion blur, and dynamic speed lines spanning the frame. The car loses all traction and slides sideways with uncontrollable momentum, tires hissing and billowing thick white smoke. A cloud of brilliant, stylized orange and white sparks erupts into the air as its side ruthlessly scrapes against the worn steel guardrail. The impact causes the front bumper to crack and shatter, sending jagged fragments flying, while the undercarriage groans and visibly buckles. The camera swoops down, closely following the vehicle as its tires dig into the curb, sending it into a catastrophic roll. In a chaotic ballet of destruction, the car flips over and the detached parts of its bodywork – shattered headlights, crumpled hoods, shards of glass – are ejected with explosive force, creating a series of fragments rendered as vibrant particle effects that simultaneously emphasize both the raw speed and the beautiful, utterly devastated machine against the backdrop of a rugged mountain range.", + "seed": 8466, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_11/index_8884_seed_8466_dp_23_rank_46_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.08201817497611046, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08201817497611046, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.749999976158142, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08201817497611046, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Nissan Skyline GT-R R34 with Bayside Blue Metallic paint?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a high-energy anime art style with bold glass-shadow outlines and exaggerated motion blur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the car violently spinning out of control on a treacherous mountain pass with thick white smoke from tires?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the car scrape against a steel guardrail, causing the front bumper to crack and shatter with jagged fragments flying?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a high-angle sweeping drone view that swoops down to follow the car as it flips over?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10296903550624847 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.35296893119812 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10296903550624847, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10296903550624847, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08418715000152588, + 0.07787194103002548, + 0.12504348158836365, + 0.04648386687040329, + 0.03593594580888748, + 0.17208413779735565, + 0.11496435850858688, + 0.08438587188720703, + 0.21498866379261017, + 0.0440545491874218 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 5, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10296903550624847 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Nissan Skyline GT-R R34 with Bayside Blue Metallic paint?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a high-energy anime art style with bold glass-shadow outlines and exaggerated motion blur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the car violently spinning out of control on a treacherous mountain pass with thick white smoke from tires?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the car scrape against a steel guardrail, causing the front bumper to crack and shatter with jagged fragments flying?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a high-angle sweeping drone view that swoops down to follow the car as it flips over?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009792622178792953 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634792804718018 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009792622178792953, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009792622178792953, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07704547792673111, + 0.03520877659320831, + 0.04603053629398346, + 0.07060167193412781, + 0.0177906583994627, + 0.04868127405643463, + 0.08747857064008713, + 0.02797629125416279, + 0.5645462274551392, + 0.02464056760072708 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009792622178792953 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Nissan Skyline GT-R R34 with Bayside Blue Metallic paint?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a high-energy anime art style with bold glass-shadow outlines and exaggerated motion blur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the car violently spinning out of control on a treacherous mountain pass with thick white smoke from tires?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the car scrape against a steel guardrail, causing the front bumper to crack and shatter with jagged fragments flying?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a high-angle sweeping drone view that swoops down to follow the car as it flips over?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07000314444303513 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695003032684326 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07000314444303513, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07000314444303513, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1383177936077118, + 0.07298554480075836, + 0.12301956117153168, + 0.2433776706457138, + 0.06961927562952042, + 0.13087789714336395, + 0.07348769903182983, + 0.037039171904325485, + 0.06701841205358505, + 0.04425698146224022 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07000314444303513 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Nissan Skyline GT-R R34 with Bayside Blue Metallic paint?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a high-energy anime art style with bold glass-shadow outlines and exaggerated motion blur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the car violently spinning out of control on a treacherous mountain pass with thick white smoke from tires?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the car scrape against a steel guardrail, causing the front bumper to crack and shatter with jagged fragments flying?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a high-angle sweeping drone view that swoops down to follow the car as it flips over?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10031560808420181 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.350315570831299 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10031560808420181, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10031560808420181, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0779646709561348, + 0.2540915906429291, + 0.04449104890227318, + 0.08128158748149872, + 0.026504140347242355, + 0.11569374054670334, + 0.16854850947856903, + 0.03316444903612137, + 0.15041770040988922, + 0.04784255102276802 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10031560808420181 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Nissan Skyline GT-R R34 with Bayside Blue Metallic paint?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a high-energy anime art style with bold glass-shadow outlines and exaggerated motion blur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the car violently spinning out of control on a treacherous mountain pass with thick white smoke from tires?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the car scrape against a steel guardrail, causing the front bumper to crack and shatter with jagged fragments flying?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a high-angle sweeping drone view that swoops down to follow the car as it flips over?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12701046466827393 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1270103454589844 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12701046466827393, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.9999998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12701046466827393, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07376430183649063, + 0.35840800404548645, + 0.06273601949214935, + 0.0747327134013176, + 0.05851628631353378, + 0.18018542230129242, + 0.07157905399799347, + 0.04296454042196274, + 0.05361070856451988, + 0.02350297011435032 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12701046466827393 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_12/index_tensor([5494, 5494])_group_12_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_12/index_tensor([5494, 5494])_group_12_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..048f7fd9c7902119e3b0a700197f128f1730c42f --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_12/index_tensor([5494, 5494])_group_12_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "dynamic, low-angle, side-on tracking shot follows a knight as he gallops through an elegant courtyard. The knight is handsome, with sharp eyebrows and sparkling eyes. His long, jet-black hair is tied high with a simple cloth belt, a few strands of hair brushing against his resolute features in the wind. He wears a flowing, pure white silk robe, bound at the waist by a wide, dark brown leather belt. From one side hangs a simple, ancient longsword, its scabbard intricately carved with cloud patterns. His robe and sleeves rustle in the wind whipped up by the horse's gallop. His steed, jet-black, with defined muscles and a glossy coat that reflects the light like satin, treads with vigor and swiftness, its hooves flying, steadily treading across the courtyard's bluestone pavement. The backdrop is a vermilion wooden corridor with carved window panes. Clumps of lush green bamboo sway gently in the wind, and a moon gate in the distance outlines another courtyard. At dusk, soft golden sunlight slants through the courtyard, gilding the entire scene with a warm and nostalgic glow. Casting elongated, dynamic shadows of the knight and his steed on the bluestone pavement, the entire scene is imbued with classical poetry and the unrestrained spirit of the chivalrous warrior, creating a profound atmosphere of tranquility and inner strength.", + "seed": 7710, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_12/index_5494_seed_7710_dp_24_rank_48_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.0965353786945343, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0965353786945343, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.525, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0965353786945343, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle, side-on tracking shot following the knight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the knight wearing a flowing, pure white silk robe bound by a wide, dark brown leather belt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the knight's steed jet-black with a glossy coat reflecting light like satin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vermilion wooden corridor with carved window panes and lush green bamboo?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by soft golden sunlight at dusk, casting elongated shadows on the bluestone pavement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06391196697950363 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8139119148254395 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06391196697950363, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06391196697950363, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10898691415786743, + 0.23409241437911987, + 0.28285181522369385, + 0.026672497391700745, + 0.03555413708090782, + 0.04488949477672577, + 0.040401097387075424, + 0.07840009033679962, + 0.04398341849446297, + 0.1041681095957756 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06391196697950363 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle, side-on tracking shot following the knight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the knight wearing a flowing, pure white silk robe bound by a wide, dark brown leather belt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the knight's steed jet-black with a glossy coat reflecting light like satin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vermilion wooden corridor with carved window panes and lush green bamboo?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by soft golden sunlight at dusk, casting elongated shadows on the bluestone pavement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16037815809249878 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9103782176971436 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16037815809249878, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16037815809249878, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07865782827138901, + 0.1817467361688614, + 0.04021072760224342, + 0.1947634518146515, + 0.03340494632720947, + 0.2866061329841614, + 0.05584802106022835, + 0.049977321177721024, + 0.039289239794015884, + 0.03949560970067978 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16037815809249878 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle, side-on tracking shot following the knight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the knight wearing a flowing, pure white silk robe bound by a wide, dark brown leather belt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the knight's steed jet-black with a glossy coat reflecting light like satin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vermilion wooden corridor with carved window panes and lush green bamboo?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by soft golden sunlight at dusk, casting elongated shadows on the bluestone pavement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04866352304816246 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.04866361618042 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04866352304816246, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04866352304816246, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14368405938148499, + 0.4169493019580841, + 0.1507018804550171, + 0.05913858860731125, + 0.03537343442440033, + 0.043020106852054596, + 0.035302624106407166, + 0.038791149854660034, + 0.05538355931639671, + 0.021655328571796417 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04866352304816246 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle, side-on tracking shot following the knight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the knight wearing a flowing, pure white silk robe bound by a wide, dark brown leather belt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the knight's steed jet-black with a glossy coat reflecting light like satin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vermilion wooden corridor with carved window panes and lush green bamboo?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by soft golden sunlight at dusk, casting elongated shadows on the bluestone pavement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029805611819028854 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298056602478027 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029805611819028854, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029805611819028854, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06007785350084305, + 0.29386085271835327, + 0.23033054172992706, + 0.033676356077194214, + 0.023077992722392082, + 0.08433862030506134, + 0.1286451518535614, + 0.08379054069519043, + 0.03553435578942299, + 0.026667719706892967 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029805611819028854 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle, side-on tracking shot following the knight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the knight wearing a flowing, pure white silk robe bound by a wide, dark brown leather belt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the knight's steed jet-black with a glossy coat reflecting light like satin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vermilion wooden corridor with carved window panes and lush green bamboo?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by soft golden sunlight at dusk, casting elongated shadows on the bluestone pavement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17991763353347778 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.804917573928833 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17991763353347778, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17991763353347778, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0705922469496727, + 0.24325786530971527, + 0.1625944823026657, + 0.08301135897636414, + 0.02370520867407322, + 0.054100751876831055, + 0.15891017019748688, + 0.056456007063388824, + 0.05331071838736534, + 0.09406115859746933 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17991763353347778 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dynamic, low-angle, side-on tracking shot follows a knight as he gallops through an elegant courtyard. The knight is handsome, with sharp eyebrows and sparkling eyes. His long, jet-black hair is tied high with a simple cloth belt, a few strands of hair brushing against his resolute features in the wind. He wears a flowing, pure white silk robe, bound at the waist by a wide, dark brown leather belt. From one side hangs a simple, ancient longsword, its scabbard intricately carved with cloud patterns. His robe and sleeves rustle in the wind whipped up by the horse's gallop. His steed, jet-black, with defined muscles and a glossy coat that reflects the light like satin, treads with vigor and swiftness, its hooves flying, steadily treading across the courtyard's bluestone pavement. The backdrop is a vermilion wooden corridor with carved window panes. Clumps of lush green bamboo sway gently in the wind, and a moon gate in the distance outlines another courtyard. At dusk, soft golden sunlight slants through the courtyard, gilding the entire scene with a warm and nostalgic glow. Casting elongated, dynamic shadows of the knight and his steed on the bluestone pavement, the entire scene is imbued with classical poetry and the unrestrained spirit of the chivalrous warrior, creating a profound atmosphere of tranquility and inner strength.", + "seed": 7711, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_12/index_5494_seed_7711_dp_24_rank_48_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.06922720335423946, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06922720335423946, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.775, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06922720335423946, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle, side-on tracking shot following the knight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the knight wearing a flowing, pure white silk robe bound by a wide, dark brown leather belt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the knight's steed jet-black with a glossy coat reflecting light like satin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vermilion wooden corridor with carved window panes and lush green bamboo?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by soft golden sunlight at dusk, casting elongated shadows on the bluestone pavement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0402589775621891 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2902588844299316 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0402589775621891, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0402589775621891, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14255784451961517, + 0.10635120421648026, + 0.09607183933258057, + 0.05305660516023636, + 0.036279719322919846, + 0.047880858182907104, + 0.0760568380355835, + 0.1805175393819809, + 0.18693915009498596, + 0.07428834587335587 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0402589775621891 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle, side-on tracking shot following the knight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the knight wearing a flowing, pure white silk robe bound by a wide, dark brown leather belt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the knight's steed jet-black with a glossy coat reflecting light like satin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vermilion wooden corridor with carved window panes and lush green bamboo?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by soft golden sunlight at dusk, casting elongated shadows on the bluestone pavement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0700334906578064 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695033550262451 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0700334906578064, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0700334906578064, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0988987535238266, + 0.4252023994922638, + 0.04969232529401779, + 0.028728164732456207, + 0.03425876051187515, + 0.03825709968805313, + 0.12072384357452393, + 0.05213426053524017, + 0.07646501064300537, + 0.07563944160938263 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0700334906578064 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle, side-on tracking shot following the knight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the knight wearing a flowing, pure white silk robe bound by a wide, dark brown leather belt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the knight's steed jet-black with a glossy coat reflecting light like satin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vermilion wooden corridor with carved window panes and lush green bamboo?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by soft golden sunlight at dusk, casting elongated shadows on the bluestone pavement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07898613810539246 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.578986167907715 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07898613810539246, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07898613810539246, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2468390017747879, + 0.1485903114080429, + 0.07214772701263428, + 0.06141674891114235, + 0.08321879059076309, + 0.06334257870912552, + 0.07339934259653091, + 0.12375625222921371, + 0.0907464548945427, + 0.036542851477861404 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07898613810539246 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle, side-on tracking shot following the knight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the knight wearing a flowing, pure white silk robe bound by a wide, dark brown leather belt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the knight's steed jet-black with a glossy coat reflecting light like satin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vermilion wooden corridor with carved window panes and lush green bamboo?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by soft golden sunlight at dusk, casting elongated shadows on the bluestone pavement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029805148020386696 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298051834106445 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029805148020386696, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029805148020386696, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11743562668561935, + 0.12026962637901306, + 0.03324237838387489, + 0.02989254705607891, + 0.018412278965115547, + 0.05499252676963806, + 0.04700560122728348, + 0.062268584966659546, + 0.4626355469226837, + 0.05384530872106552 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029805148020386696 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle, side-on tracking shot following the knight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the knight wearing a flowing, pure white silk robe bound by a wide, dark brown leather belt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the knight's steed jet-black with a glossy coat reflecting light like satin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vermilion wooden corridor with carved window panes and lush green bamboo?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by soft golden sunlight at dusk, casting elongated shadows on the bluestone pavement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12705226242542267 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1270523071289062 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12705226242542267, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12705226242542267, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11801101267337799, + 0.10987313836812973, + 0.031183388084173203, + 0.051756422966718674, + 0.11359137296676636, + 0.08313850313425064, + 0.102547287940979, + 0.22036470472812653, + 0.062194135040044785, + 0.1073400154709816 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12705226242542267 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dynamic, low-angle, side-on tracking shot follows a knight as he gallops through an elegant courtyard. The knight is handsome, with sharp eyebrows and sparkling eyes. His long, jet-black hair is tied high with a simple cloth belt, a few strands of hair brushing against his resolute features in the wind. He wears a flowing, pure white silk robe, bound at the waist by a wide, dark brown leather belt. From one side hangs a simple, ancient longsword, its scabbard intricately carved with cloud patterns. His robe and sleeves rustle in the wind whipped up by the horse's gallop. His steed, jet-black, with defined muscles and a glossy coat that reflects the light like satin, treads with vigor and swiftness, its hooves flying, steadily treading across the courtyard's bluestone pavement. The backdrop is a vermilion wooden corridor with carved window panes. Clumps of lush green bamboo sway gently in the wind, and a moon gate in the distance outlines another courtyard. At dusk, soft golden sunlight slants through the courtyard, gilding the entire scene with a warm and nostalgic glow. Casting elongated, dynamic shadows of the knight and his steed on the bluestone pavement, the entire scene is imbued with classical poetry and the unrestrained spirit of the chivalrous warrior, creating a profound atmosphere of tranquility and inner strength.", + "seed": 7712, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_12/index_5494_seed_7712_dp_25_rank_50_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.05641730353236198, + "vlm_logprob": -0.05641730353236198, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.875, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.05641730353236198, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle, side-on tracking shot following the knight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the knight wearing a flowing, pure white silk robe bound by a wide, dark brown leather belt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the knight's steed jet-black with a glossy coat reflecting light like satin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vermilion wooden corridor with carved window panes and lush green bamboo?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by soft golden sunlight at dusk, casting elongated shadows on the bluestone pavement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05031166225671768 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.05031156539917 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05031166225671768, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05031166225671768, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08822022378444672, + 0.06091833487153053, + 0.21619974076747894, + 0.1226264163851738, + 0.024042129516601562, + 0.043015073984861374, + 0.026336628943681717, + 0.3465445935726166, + 0.02411464974284172, + 0.04798218607902527 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05031166225671768 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle, side-on tracking shot following the knight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the knight wearing a flowing, pure white silk robe bound by a wide, dark brown leather belt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the knight's steed jet-black with a glossy coat reflecting light like satin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vermilion wooden corridor with carved window panes and lush green bamboo?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by soft golden sunlight at dusk, casting elongated shadows on the bluestone pavement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07003670930862427 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950366497039795 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07003670930862427, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07003670930862427, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14399506151676178, + 0.0414145328104496, + 0.02748134918510914, + 0.12914827466011047, + 0.10270342975854874, + 0.10276447236537933, + 0.05131200700998306, + 0.31531521677970886, + 0.031098905950784683, + 0.05476684868335724 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07003670930862427 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle, side-on tracking shot following the knight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the knight wearing a flowing, pure white silk robe bound by a wide, dark brown leather belt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the knight's steed jet-black with a glossy coat reflecting light like satin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vermilion wooden corridor with carved window panes and lush green bamboo?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by soft golden sunlight at dusk, casting elongated shadows on the bluestone pavement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.048657048493623734 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048656940460205 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.048657048493623734, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.048657048493623734, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09596972912549973, + 0.025793015956878662, + 0.027418728917837143, + 0.052538130432367325, + 0.026430321857333183, + 0.034323252737522125, + 0.038888223469257355, + 0.4653814435005188, + 0.10052168369293213, + 0.1327354609966278 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.048657048493623734 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle, side-on tracking shot following the knight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the knight wearing a flowing, pure white silk robe bound by a wide, dark brown leather belt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the knight's steed jet-black with a glossy coat reflecting light like satin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vermilion wooden corridor with carved window panes and lush green bamboo?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by soft golden sunlight at dusk, casting elongated shadows on the bluestone pavement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07002637535333633 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695026397705078 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07002637535333633, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07002637535333633, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.02256108820438385, + 0.023520205169916153, + 0.010074025951325893, + 0.01538566593080759, + 0.006591394543647766, + 0.008256666362285614, + 0.009085295721888542, + 0.8676686882972717, + 0.008612346835434437, + 0.02824460342526436 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07002637535333633 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle, side-on tracking shot following the knight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the knight wearing a flowing, pure white silk robe bound by a wide, dark brown leather belt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the knight's steed jet-black with a glossy coat reflecting light like satin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vermilion wooden corridor with carved window panes and lush green bamboo?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by soft golden sunlight at dusk, casting elongated shadows on the bluestone pavement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.043054722249507904 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680548191070557 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.043054722249507904, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.043054722249507904, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13811327517032623, + 0.027208557352423668, + 0.016660571098327637, + 0.027045058086514473, + 0.02086668834090233, + 0.024640316143631935, + 0.01735622063279152, + 0.6780663132667542, + 0.02843085117638111, + 0.021612199023365974 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.043054722249507904 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dynamic, low-angle, side-on tracking shot follows a knight as he gallops through an elegant courtyard. The knight is handsome, with sharp eyebrows and sparkling eyes. His long, jet-black hair is tied high with a simple cloth belt, a few strands of hair brushing against his resolute features in the wind. He wears a flowing, pure white silk robe, bound at the waist by a wide, dark brown leather belt. From one side hangs a simple, ancient longsword, its scabbard intricately carved with cloud patterns. His robe and sleeves rustle in the wind whipped up by the horse's gallop. His steed, jet-black, with defined muscles and a glossy coat that reflects the light like satin, treads with vigor and swiftness, its hooves flying, steadily treading across the courtyard's bluestone pavement. The backdrop is a vermilion wooden corridor with carved window panes. Clumps of lush green bamboo sway gently in the wind, and a moon gate in the distance outlines another courtyard. At dusk, soft golden sunlight slants through the courtyard, gilding the entire scene with a warm and nostalgic glow. Casting elongated, dynamic shadows of the knight and his steed on the bluestone pavement, the entire scene is imbued with classical poetry and the unrestrained spirit of the chivalrous warrior, creating a profound atmosphere of tranquility and inner strength.", + "seed": 7713, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_12/index_5494_seed_7713_dp_25_rank_50_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.12809550240635872, + "vlm_logprob": -0.12809550240635872, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.3999999523162843, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.12809550240635872, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle, side-on tracking shot following the knight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the knight wearing a flowing, pure white silk robe bound by a wide, dark brown leather belt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the knight's steed jet-black with a glossy coat reflecting light like satin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vermilion wooden corridor with carved window panes and lush green bamboo?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by soft golden sunlight at dusk, casting elongated shadows on the bluestone pavement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.050313133746385574 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0503132343292236 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.050313133746385574, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.050313133746385574, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1298675835132599, + 0.05153154209256172, + 0.04448477178812027, + 0.3473303020000458, + 0.04855205863714218, + 0.04548210650682449, + 0.10929718613624573, + 0.05566135793924332, + 0.06653168797492981, + 0.1012614369392395 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.050313133746385574 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle, side-on tracking shot following the knight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the knight wearing a flowing, pure white silk robe bound by a wide, dark brown leather belt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the knight's steed jet-black with a glossy coat reflecting light like satin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vermilion wooden corridor with carved window panes and lush green bamboo?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by soft golden sunlight at dusk, casting elongated shadows on the bluestone pavement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.28134122490882874 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4063411951065063 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.28134122490882874, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.28134122490882874, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09735608845949173, + 0.05178943648934364, + 0.14783690869808197, + 0.18772034347057343, + 0.04884154722094536, + 0.0384783111512661, + 0.0442817248404026, + 0.10314277559518814, + 0.11425627022981644, + 0.1662965565919876 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.28134122490882874 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle, side-on tracking shot following the knight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the knight wearing a flowing, pure white silk robe bound by a wide, dark brown leather belt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the knight's steed jet-black with a glossy coat reflecting light like satin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vermilion wooden corridor with carved window panes and lush green bamboo?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by soft golden sunlight at dusk, casting elongated shadows on the bluestone pavement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08905243873596191 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.464052438735962 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08905243873596191, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08905243873596191, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16481074690818787, + 0.19063958525657654, + 0.07768949866294861, + 0.2471727877855301, + 0.023885199800133705, + 0.021973947063088417, + 0.056146830320358276, + 0.05013526231050491, + 0.0900118350982666, + 0.0775342658162117 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08905243873596191 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle, side-on tracking shot following the knight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the knight wearing a flowing, pure white silk robe bound by a wide, dark brown leather belt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the knight's steed jet-black with a glossy coat reflecting light like satin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vermilion wooden corridor with carved window panes and lush green bamboo?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by soft golden sunlight at dusk, casting elongated shadows on the bluestone pavement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01818917691707611 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018188953399658 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01818917691707611, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01818917691707611, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0613541379570961, + 0.02273375727236271, + 0.09975451231002808, + 0.15398748219013214, + 0.0229167677462101, + 0.03486720845103264, + 0.033157870173454285, + 0.03715914115309715, + 0.12252731621265411, + 0.41154181957244873 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 3, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01818917691707611 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle, side-on tracking shot following the knight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the knight wearing a flowing, pure white silk robe bound by a wide, dark brown leather belt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the knight's steed jet-black with a glossy coat reflecting light like satin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vermilion wooden corridor with carved window panes and lush green bamboo?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by soft golden sunlight at dusk, casting elongated shadows on the bluestone pavement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20158153772354126 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7015814781188965 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20158153772354126, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20158153772354126, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06575743854045868, + 0.0948423519730568, + 0.07250051200389862, + 0.3906232714653015, + 0.02906366065144539, + 0.01881333254277706, + 0.07670063525438309, + 0.08003468066453934, + 0.07430535554885864, + 0.0973588302731514 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20158153772354126 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_13/index_tensor([8021, 8021])_group_13_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_13/index_tensor([8021, 8021])_group_13_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..e530a89f3060d21035b2b1adf3c3ebfc32937ddf --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_13/index_tensor([8021, 8021])_group_13_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "wide-angle shot, tilted slowly downward from a high angle, initially captures a deep, moonless night sky, its velvety indigo blue dotted with distant, motionless stars. Then, countless luminous stars begin to fall from the sky like a dense, tranquil shower, each trailing a faint, shimmering silver trail as they gracefully streak through the darkness like a soft comet. As the camera continues to pan downward, a vast, tranquil lake reveals itself below, its surface as smooth as obsidian, perfectly reflecting the cosmic wonders unfolding above. As the first meteor gently touches the water, it doesn't splash, but silently dissipates, instantly stirring up a dreamy ripple of pure light. The ripples, emitting a cool, blue-white phosphorescence, spread outward steadily and deliberately. Then, thousands of stars continuously fell into the lake, each creating its own ripple of light. These ripples intertwined and overlapped, forming a complex, ever-changing, dynamic tapestry of light across the surface. The entire scene was illuminated by the ethereal glow of these falling stars and ripples, creating an atmosphere of profound tranquility, otherworldly beauty, and magic.", + "seed": 6129, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_13/index_8021_seed_6129_dp_26_rank_52_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.009140031156130135, + "vlm_logprob": -0.009140031156130135, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 5.425, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.009140031156130135, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a wide-angle view of a deep, moonless night sky with distant stars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do countless luminous stars fall from the sky leaving faint, shimmering silver trails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt slowly downward from a high angle to reveal a vast lake below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the falling stars create ripples of cool, blue-white phosphorescence on the obsidian-like lake surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the ripples intertwine and overlap to form a complex, dynamic tapestry of light across the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03397214785218239 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4089722633361816 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03397214785218239, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03397214785218239, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.8321135640144348, + 0.05552973225712776, + 0.02168898470699787, + 0.014853323809802532, + 0.029194815084338188, + 0.0074494522996246815, + 0.013258852064609528, + 0.010869682766497135, + 0.008555243723094463, + 0.006486320402473211 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03397214785218239 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a wide-angle view of a deep, moonless night sky with distant stars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do countless luminous stars fall from the sky leaving faint, shimmering silver trails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt slowly downward from a high angle to reveal a vast lake below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the falling stars create ripples of cool, blue-white phosphorescence on the obsidian-like lake surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the ripples intertwine and overlap to form a complex, dynamic tapestry of light across the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036281016655266285 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628628253936768 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036281016655266285, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036281016655266285, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.34846264123916626, + 0.4096192419528961, + 0.0888899490237236, + 0.019814390689134598, + 0.053637586534023285, + 0.014978351071476936, + 0.020297547802329063, + 0.016568919643759727, + 0.01962420530617237, + 0.008107151836156845 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036281016655266285 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a wide-angle view of a deep, moonless night sky with distant stars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do countless luminous stars fall from the sky leaving faint, shimmering silver trails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt slowly downward from a high angle to reveal a vast lake below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the falling stars create ripples of cool, blue-white phosphorescence on the obsidian-like lake surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the ripples intertwine and overlap to form a complex, dynamic tapestry of light across the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004644795786589384 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379644870758057 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004644795786589384, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004644795786589384, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1895856261253357, + 0.5607616305351257, + 0.051738984882831573, + 0.03285876289010048, + 0.054735928773880005, + 0.01123737171292305, + 0.029775729402899742, + 0.04218176752328873, + 0.01871398277580738, + 0.008410165086388588 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004644795786589384 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a wide-angle view of a deep, moonless night sky with distant stars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do countless luminous stars fall from the sky leaving faint, shimmering silver trails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt slowly downward from a high angle to reveal a vast lake below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the falling stars create ripples of cool, blue-white phosphorescence on the obsidian-like lake surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the ripples intertwine and overlap to form a complex, dynamic tapestry of light across the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0019412260735407472 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.251941204071045 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0019412260735407472, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0019412260735407472, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23376868665218353, + 0.46953287720680237, + 0.03423380106687546, + 0.024894757196307182, + 0.08637260645627975, + 0.0260592270642519, + 0.059328604489564896, + 0.028160231187939644, + 0.019335603341460228, + 0.018313594162464142 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0019412260735407472 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a wide-angle view of a deep, moonless night sky with distant stars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do countless luminous stars fall from the sky leaving faint, shimmering silver trails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt slowly downward from a high angle to reveal a vast lake below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the falling stars create ripples of cool, blue-white phosphorescence on the obsidian-like lake surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the ripples intertwine and overlap to form a complex, dynamic tapestry of light across the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0015138844028115273 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.501513957977295 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0015138844028115273, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0015138844028115273, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3036203682422638, + 0.3270512521266937, + 0.028755569830536842, + 0.03704395517706871, + 0.04750007390975952, + 0.01569243334233761, + 0.04030993580818176, + 0.10051950067281723, + 0.046595726162195206, + 0.052911195904016495 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0015138844028115273 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "wide-angle shot, tilted slowly downward from a high angle, initially captures a deep, moonless night sky, its velvety indigo blue dotted with distant, motionless stars. Then, countless luminous stars begin to fall from the sky like a dense, tranquil shower, each trailing a faint, shimmering silver trail as they gracefully streak through the darkness like a soft comet. As the camera continues to pan downward, a vast, tranquil lake reveals itself below, its surface as smooth as obsidian, perfectly reflecting the cosmic wonders unfolding above. As the first meteor gently touches the water, it doesn't splash, but silently dissipates, instantly stirring up a dreamy ripple of pure light. The ripples, emitting a cool, blue-white phosphorescence, spread outward steadily and deliberately. Then, thousands of stars continuously fell into the lake, each creating its own ripple of light. These ripples intertwined and overlapped, forming a complex, ever-changing, dynamic tapestry of light across the surface. The entire scene was illuminated by the ethereal glow of these falling stars and ripples, creating an atmosphere of profound tranquility, otherworldly beauty, and magic.", + "seed": 6130, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_13/index_8021_seed_6130_dp_26_rank_52_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.006458488339558244, + "vlm_logprob": -0.006458488339558244, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 5.35, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.006458488339558244, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a wide-angle view of a deep, moonless night sky with distant stars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do countless luminous stars fall from the sky leaving faint, shimmering silver trails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt slowly downward from a high angle to reveal a vast lake below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the falling stars create ripples of cool, blue-white phosphorescence on the obsidian-like lake surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the ripples intertwine and overlap to form a complex, dynamic tapestry of light across the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01623774692416191 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141237735748291 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01623774692416191, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01623774692416191, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11834583431482315, + 0.14685982465744019, + 0.029442789033055305, + 0.07245165854692459, + 0.4570082724094391, + 0.05574199557304382, + 0.03378981724381447, + 0.047871463000774384, + 0.010532313957810402, + 0.02795593813061714 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01623774692416191 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a wide-angle view of a deep, moonless night sky with distant stars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do countless luminous stars fall from the sky leaving faint, shimmering silver trails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt slowly downward from a high angle to reveal a vast lake below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the falling stars create ripples of cool, blue-white phosphorescence on the obsidian-like lake surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the ripples intertwine and overlap to form a complex, dynamic tapestry of light across the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005960309412330389 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130960464477539 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005960309412330389, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005960309412330389, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07344353199005127, + 0.2880953550338745, + 0.04148656874895096, + 0.32238805294036865, + 0.17006045579910278, + 0.015031801536679268, + 0.018588049337267876, + 0.022281233221292496, + 0.012676610611379147, + 0.035948362201452255 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005960309412330389 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a wide-angle view of a deep, moonless night sky with distant stars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do countless luminous stars fall from the sky leaving faint, shimmering silver trails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt slowly downward from a high angle to reveal a vast lake below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the falling stars create ripples of cool, blue-white phosphorescence on the obsidian-like lake surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the ripples intertwine and overlap to form a complex, dynamic tapestry of light across the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005955806467682123 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130955696105957 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005955806467682123, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005955806467682123, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06635840237140656, + 0.10302320122718811, + 0.024302750825881958, + 0.21387459337711334, + 0.45861509442329407, + 0.06821336597204208, + 0.027783788740634918, + 0.020292727276682854, + 0.00853086356073618, + 0.009005185216665268 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005955806467682123 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a wide-angle view of a deep, moonless night sky with distant stars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do countless luminous stars fall from the sky leaving faint, shimmering silver trails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt slowly downward from a high angle to reveal a vast lake below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the falling stars create ripples of cool, blue-white phosphorescence on the obsidian-like lake surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the ripples intertwine and overlap to form a complex, dynamic tapestry of light across the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0019406310748308897 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.251940727233887 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0019406310748308897, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0019406310748308897, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.050603654235601425, + 0.17957153916358948, + 0.01552352774888277, + 0.25017526745796204, + 0.37825798988342285, + 0.025454068556427956, + 0.029645634815096855, + 0.03551052510738373, + 0.010187089443206787, + 0.025070736184716225 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0019406310748308897 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a wide-angle view of a deep, moonless night sky with distant stars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do countless luminous stars fall from the sky leaving faint, shimmering silver trails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt slowly downward from a high angle to reveal a vast lake below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the falling stars create ripples of cool, blue-white phosphorescence on the obsidian-like lake surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the ripples intertwine and overlap to form a complex, dynamic tapestry of light across the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002197947818785906 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127197742462158 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002197947818785906, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002197947818785906, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0247633196413517, + 0.19690445065498352, + 0.017553046345710754, + 0.18098308145999908, + 0.38466230034828186, + 0.04333635792136192, + 0.048647742718458176, + 0.03147321939468384, + 0.0317750945687294, + 0.03990142047405243 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002197947818785906 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "wide-angle shot, tilted slowly downward from a high angle, initially captures a deep, moonless night sky, its velvety indigo blue dotted with distant, motionless stars. Then, countless luminous stars begin to fall from the sky like a dense, tranquil shower, each trailing a faint, shimmering silver trail as they gracefully streak through the darkness like a soft comet. As the camera continues to pan downward, a vast, tranquil lake reveals itself below, its surface as smooth as obsidian, perfectly reflecting the cosmic wonders unfolding above. As the first meteor gently touches the water, it doesn't splash, but silently dissipates, instantly stirring up a dreamy ripple of pure light. The ripples, emitting a cool, blue-white phosphorescence, spread outward steadily and deliberately. Then, thousands of stars continuously fell into the lake, each creating its own ripple of light. These ripples intertwined and overlapped, forming a complex, ever-changing, dynamic tapestry of light across the surface. The entire scene was illuminated by the ethereal glow of these falling stars and ripples, creating an atmosphere of profound tranquility, otherworldly beauty, and magic.", + "seed": 6131, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_13/index_8021_seed_6131_dp_27_rank_54_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.014271761383861303, + "vlm_logprob": -0.014271761383861303, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 5.175, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.014271761383861303, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a wide-angle view of a deep, moonless night sky with distant stars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do countless luminous stars fall from the sky leaving faint, shimmering silver trails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt slowly downward from a high angle to reveal a vast lake below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the falling stars create ripples of cool, blue-white phosphorescence on the obsidian-like lake surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the ripples intertwine and overlap to form a complex, dynamic tapestry of light across the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.055184680968523026 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9301846027374268 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.055184680968523026, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.055184680968523026, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.7212305068969727, + 0.008034944534301758, + 0.023623613640666008, + 0.10274367034435272, + 0.012246234342455864, + 0.008783136494457722, + 0.04239450395107269, + 0.003325164783746004, + 0.04427986592054367, + 0.03333832323551178 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.055184680968523026 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a wide-angle view of a deep, moonless night sky with distant stars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do countless luminous stars fall from the sky leaving faint, shimmering silver trails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt slowly downward from a high angle to reveal a vast lake below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the falling stars create ripples of cool, blue-white phosphorescence on the obsidian-like lake surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the ripples intertwine and overlap to form a complex, dynamic tapestry of light across the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00410571089014411 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504105567932129 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00410571089014411, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00410571089014411, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.39011627435684204, + 0.07115794718265533, + 0.10566667467355728, + 0.0847487673163414, + 0.041357334703207016, + 0.017203688621520996, + 0.18037430942058563, + 0.020177900791168213, + 0.03765000402927399, + 0.05154713615775108 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00410571089014411 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a wide-angle view of a deep, moonless night sky with distant stars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do countless luminous stars fall from the sky leaving faint, shimmering silver trails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt slowly downward from a high angle to reveal a vast lake below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the falling stars create ripples of cool, blue-white phosphorescence on the obsidian-like lake surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the ripples intertwine and overlap to form a complex, dynamic tapestry of light across the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00864217709749937 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758642196655273 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00864217709749937, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00864217709749937, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5782173871994019, + 0.026863109320402145, + 0.049971166998147964, + 0.14170622825622559, + 0.0208026971668005, + 0.017642229795455933, + 0.06502804905176163, + 0.011675906367599964, + 0.06385545432567596, + 0.02423779107630253 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00864217709749937 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a wide-angle view of a deep, moonless night sky with distant stars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do countless luminous stars fall from the sky leaving faint, shimmering silver trails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt slowly downward from a high angle to reveal a vast lake below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the falling stars create ripples of cool, blue-white phosphorescence on the obsidian-like lake surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the ripples intertwine and overlap to form a complex, dynamic tapestry of light across the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.001712523982860148 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.376712322235107 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.001712523982860148, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.001712523982860148, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3020152449607849, + 0.05628616735339165, + 0.04844139888882637, + 0.135559543967247, + 0.04844873026013374, + 0.022307541221380234, + 0.13512049615383148, + 0.04162503778934479, + 0.11248130351305008, + 0.09771453589200974 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.001712523982860148 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a wide-angle view of a deep, moonless night sky with distant stars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do countless luminous stars fall from the sky leaving faint, shimmering silver trails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt slowly downward from a high angle to reveal a vast lake below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the falling stars create ripples of cool, blue-white phosphorescence on the obsidian-like lake surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the ripples intertwine and overlap to form a complex, dynamic tapestry of light across the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0017137139802798629 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.376713752746582 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0017137139802798629, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0017137139802798629, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5033378601074219, + 0.02818676456809044, + 0.08825741708278656, + 0.05419047176837921, + 0.023582033812999725, + 0.016087686643004417, + 0.031292304396629333, + 0.04650488495826721, + 0.05804726481437683, + 0.15051330626010895 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0017137139802798629 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "wide-angle shot, tilted slowly downward from a high angle, initially captures a deep, moonless night sky, its velvety indigo blue dotted with distant, motionless stars. Then, countless luminous stars begin to fall from the sky like a dense, tranquil shower, each trailing a faint, shimmering silver trail as they gracefully streak through the darkness like a soft comet. As the camera continues to pan downward, a vast, tranquil lake reveals itself below, its surface as smooth as obsidian, perfectly reflecting the cosmic wonders unfolding above. As the first meteor gently touches the water, it doesn't splash, but silently dissipates, instantly stirring up a dreamy ripple of pure light. The ripples, emitting a cool, blue-white phosphorescence, spread outward steadily and deliberately. Then, thousands of stars continuously fell into the lake, each creating its own ripple of light. These ripples intertwined and overlapped, forming a complex, ever-changing, dynamic tapestry of light across the surface. The entire scene was illuminated by the ethereal glow of these falling stars and ripples, creating an atmosphere of profound tranquility, otherworldly beauty, and magic.", + "seed": 6132, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_13/index_8021_seed_6132_dp_27_rank_54_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.010851810686290264, + "vlm_logprob": -0.010851810686290264, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.825, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.010851810686290264, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a wide-angle view of a deep, moonless night sky with distant stars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do countless luminous stars fall from the sky leaving faint, shimmering silver trails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt slowly downward from a high angle to reveal a vast lake below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the falling stars create ripples of cool, blue-white phosphorescence on the obsidian-like lake surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the ripples intertwine and overlap to form a complex, dynamic tapestry of light across the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029988067224621773 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5299880504608154 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029988067224621773, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029988067224621773, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.30085116624832153, + 0.21801789104938507, + 0.1501608043909073, + 0.05650739744305611, + 0.028962574899196625, + 0.040587712079286575, + 0.049735695123672485, + 0.018695341423153877, + 0.05487622693181038, + 0.0816052109003067 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029988067224621773 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a wide-angle view of a deep, moonless night sky with distant stars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do countless luminous stars fall from the sky leaving faint, shimmering silver trails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt slowly downward from a high angle to reveal a vast lake below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the falling stars create ripples of cool, blue-white phosphorescence on the obsidian-like lake surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the ripples intertwine and overlap to form a complex, dynamic tapestry of light across the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008653995580971241 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.7586541175842285 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008653995580971241, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008653995580971241, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12546449899673462, + 0.22744157910346985, + 0.21826156973838806, + 0.07299217581748962, + 0.033405330032110214, + 0.06354310363531113, + 0.04873954877257347, + 0.054358866065740585, + 0.06427890807390213, + 0.09151449799537659 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008653995580971241 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a wide-angle view of a deep, moonless night sky with distant stars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do countless luminous stars fall from the sky leaving faint, shimmering silver trails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt slowly downward from a high angle to reveal a vast lake below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the falling stars create ripples of cool, blue-white phosphorescence on the obsidian-like lake surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the ripples intertwine and overlap to form a complex, dynamic tapestry of light across the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00674400432035327 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006743907928467 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00674400432035327, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00674400432035327, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.164899080991745, + 0.09314627200365067, + 0.05069519579410553, + 0.14746281504631042, + 0.03969402611255646, + 0.11683237552642822, + 0.2145894467830658, + 0.040956687182188034, + 0.05967791751027107, + 0.07204615324735641 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00674400432035327 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a wide-angle view of a deep, moonless night sky with distant stars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do countless luminous stars fall from the sky leaving faint, shimmering silver trails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt slowly downward from a high angle to reveal a vast lake below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the falling stars create ripples of cool, blue-white phosphorescence on the obsidian-like lake surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the ripples intertwine and overlap to form a complex, dynamic tapestry of light across the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005254743155092001 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255254745483398 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005254743155092001, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005254743155092001, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0869915708899498, + 0.10924368351697922, + 0.07249714434146881, + 0.03345641493797302, + 0.02090551145374775, + 0.10975440591573715, + 0.08944637328386307, + 0.1442062258720398, + 0.07862735539674759, + 0.25487130880355835 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005254743155092001 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a wide-angle view of a deep, moonless night sky with distant stars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do countless luminous stars fall from the sky leaving faint, shimmering silver trails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt slowly downward from a high angle to reveal a vast lake below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the falling stars create ripples of cool, blue-white phosphorescence on the obsidian-like lake surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the ripples intertwine and overlap to form a complex, dynamic tapestry of light across the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036182431504130363 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628618240356445 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036182431504130363, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036182431504130363, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.053159359842538834, + 0.07120552659034729, + 0.03161407634615898, + 0.021970927715301514, + 0.02990902215242386, + 0.06232333183288574, + 0.24203525483608246, + 0.08188275247812271, + 0.0894944816827774, + 0.3164052963256836 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036182431504130363 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_14/index_tensor([5019, 5019])_group_14_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_14/index_tensor([5019, 5019])_group_14_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..cf9a8e645cfbfec0d88ec36d35fda23db30d4156 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_14/index_tensor([5019, 5019])_group_14_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "static, low-angle shot captures the scene inside a dimly lit warehouse, focusing on a tall, precarious stack of assorted cardboard boxes on the dusty concrete floor. The boxes vary in size and condition, showing signs of wear, with wrinkled corners and peeling packing tape, creating a featureless mass. From the left side of the frame, a long, weathered wooden pencil—its surface a tapestry of faded gray veins, dark water stains, and tattered edges—hurls itself swiftly and decisively at the stack. It strikes the mid-height of the stack with a violent force. In a flash of kinetic energy, the corrugated cardboard of the central box visibly wrinkles and dents as a cloud of dust erupts under the harsh overhead lighting. The entire stack collapses instantly; the lower boxes flare outward, while the upper ones tilt forward, then cascade down in a chaotic, dramatic fashion, the individual boxes tumbling and flattening as they scatter across the floor. The sudden destruction creates a tense and impactful atmosphere.", + "seed": 33167, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_14/index_5019_seed_33167_dp_28_rank_56_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.08157840957865119, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08157840957865119, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.025, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08157840957865119, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set inside a dimly lit warehouse with a dusty concrete floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle capturing a tall stack of assorted cardboard boxes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a long, weathered wooden pencil with faded gray veins and dark water stains visible hurling from the left side of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the central box visibly wrinkle and dent upon impact, causing a cloud of dust to erupt under harsh overhead lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the entire stack of boxes collapse instantly, with lower boxes flaring outward and upper ones cascading down chaotically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03440174087882042 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4094016551971436 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03440174087882042, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03440174087882042, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16750551760196686, + 0.5989595651626587, + 0.043754320591688156, + 0.030866259709000587, + 0.011789894662797451, + 0.02391519770026207, + 0.02813834138214588, + 0.036552030593156815, + 0.015589667484164238, + 0.042929213494062424 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03440174087882042 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set inside a dimly lit warehouse with a dusty concrete floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle capturing a tall stack of assorted cardboard boxes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a long, weathered wooden pencil with faded gray veins and dark water stains visible hurling from the left side of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the central box visibly wrinkle and dent upon impact, causing a cloud of dust to erupt under harsh overhead lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the entire stack of boxes collapse instantly, with lower boxes flaring outward and upper ones cascading down chaotically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00676212040707469 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.0067620277404785 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00676212040707469, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00676212040707469, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23405703902244568, + 0.20927481353282928, + 0.08037680387496948, + 0.13760562241077423, + 0.027518322691321373, + 0.06898196786642075, + 0.060544248670339584, + 0.055649012327194214, + 0.02807197906076908, + 0.09792013466358185 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00676212040707469 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set inside a dimly lit warehouse with a dusty concrete floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle capturing a tall stack of assorted cardboard boxes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a long, weathered wooden pencil with faded gray veins and dark water stains visible hurling from the left side of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the central box visibly wrinkle and dent upon impact, causing a cloud of dust to erupt under harsh overhead lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the entire stack of boxes collapse instantly, with lower boxes flaring outward and upper ones cascading down chaotically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12707209587097168 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1270720958709717 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12707209587097168, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12707209587097168, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06918308138847351, + 0.22842323780059814, + 0.0477183498442173, + 0.26546093821525574, + 0.04975702613592148, + 0.06979966163635254, + 0.05414200201630592, + 0.07738755643367767, + 0.07498063147068024, + 0.06314755976200104 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12707209587097168 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set inside a dimly lit warehouse with a dusty concrete floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle capturing a tall stack of assorted cardboard boxes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a long, weathered wooden pencil with faded gray veins and dark water stains visible hurling from the left side of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the central box visibly wrinkle and dent upon impact, causing a cloud of dust to erupt under harsh overhead lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the entire stack of boxes collapse instantly, with lower boxes flaring outward and upper ones cascading down chaotically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.038106709718704224 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288106679916382 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.038106709718704224, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.038106709718704224, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07725337147712708, + 0.16524025797843933, + 0.12404672056436539, + 0.15565814077854156, + 0.03420654684305191, + 0.05724414065480232, + 0.05487290024757385, + 0.09143524616956711, + 0.12443649023771286, + 0.11560626327991486 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 3, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.038106709718704224 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set inside a dimly lit warehouse with a dusty concrete floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle capturing a tall stack of assorted cardboard boxes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a long, weathered wooden pencil with faded gray veins and dark water stains visible hurling from the left side of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the central box visibly wrinkle and dent upon impact, causing a cloud of dust to erupt under harsh overhead lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the entire stack of boxes collapse instantly, with lower boxes flaring outward and upper ones cascading down chaotically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20154938101768494 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7015494108200073 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20154938101768494, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20154938101768494, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07172417640686035, + 0.3803337514400482, + 0.12269176542758942, + 0.06874118745326996, + 0.03645345941185951, + 0.049010466784238815, + 0.03403104096651077, + 0.05821503326296806, + 0.12044686824083328, + 0.058352284133434296 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20154938101768494 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, low-angle shot captures the scene inside a dimly lit warehouse, focusing on a tall, precarious stack of assorted cardboard boxes on the dusty concrete floor. The boxes vary in size and condition, showing signs of wear, with wrinkled corners and peeling packing tape, creating a featureless mass. From the left side of the frame, a long, weathered wooden pencil—its surface a tapestry of faded gray veins, dark water stains, and tattered edges—hurls itself swiftly and decisively at the stack. It strikes the mid-height of the stack with a violent force. In a flash of kinetic energy, the corrugated cardboard of the central box visibly wrinkles and dents as a cloud of dust erupts under the harsh overhead lighting. The entire stack collapses instantly; the lower boxes flare outward, while the upper ones tilt forward, then cascade down in a chaotic, dramatic fashion, the individual boxes tumbling and flattening as they scatter across the floor. The sudden destruction creates a tense and impactful atmosphere.", + "seed": 33168, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_14/index_5019_seed_33168_dp_28_rank_56_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.2677121482789516, + "vlm_logprob": -0.2677121482789516, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.725, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.2677121482789516, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set inside a dimly lit warehouse with a dusty concrete floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle capturing a tall stack of assorted cardboard boxes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a long, weathered wooden pencil with faded gray veins and dark water stains visible hurling from the left side of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the central box visibly wrinkle and dent upon impact, causing a cloud of dust to erupt under harsh overhead lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the entire stack of boxes collapse instantly, with lower boxes flaring outward and upper ones cascading down chaotically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5769385099411011 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8269385099411011 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5769385099411011, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5769385099411011, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3090684413909912, + 0.12633639574050903, + 0.027284864336252213, + 0.07897550612688065, + 0.037774231284856796, + 0.03437625244259834, + 0.04502244293689728, + 0.058598700910806656, + 0.14386726915836334, + 0.13869589567184448 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5769385099411011 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set inside a dimly lit warehouse with a dusty concrete floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle capturing a tall stack of assorted cardboard boxes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a long, weathered wooden pencil with faded gray veins and dark water stains visible hurling from the left side of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the central box visibly wrinkle and dent upon impact, causing a cloud of dust to erupt under harsh overhead lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the entire stack of boxes collapse instantly, with lower boxes flaring outward and upper ones cascading down chaotically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012566667050123215 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387566566467285 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012566667050123215, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012566667050123215, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.31421175599098206, + 0.06687343120574951, + 0.03883308172225952, + 0.116349957883358, + 0.02487519569694996, + 0.08588676899671555, + 0.10276078432798386, + 0.10355979949235916, + 0.09450240433216095, + 0.05214682221412659 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012566667050123215 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set inside a dimly lit warehouse with a dusty concrete floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle capturing a tall stack of assorted cardboard boxes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a long, weathered wooden pencil with faded gray veins and dark water stains visible hurling from the left side of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the central box visibly wrinkle and dent upon impact, causing a cloud of dust to erupt under harsh overhead lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the entire stack of boxes collapse instantly, with lower boxes flaring outward and upper ones cascading down chaotically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16040882468223572 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.910408854484558 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16040882468223572, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16040882468223572, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06197855621576309, + 0.08706368505954742, + 0.03939787670969963, + 0.1365514099597931, + 0.04884231090545654, + 0.1167612299323082, + 0.26550498604774475, + 0.07018527388572693, + 0.12403377890586853, + 0.049680907279253006 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 3, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16040882468223572 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set inside a dimly lit warehouse with a dusty concrete floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle capturing a tall stack of assorted cardboard boxes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a long, weathered wooden pencil with faded gray veins and dark water stains visible hurling from the left side of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the central box visibly wrinkle and dent upon impact, causing a cloud of dust to erupt under harsh overhead lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the entire stack of boxes collapse instantly, with lower boxes flaring outward and upper ones cascading down chaotically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20157891511917114 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7015788555145264 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20157891511917114, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20157891511917114, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09035858511924744, + 0.015381768345832825, + 0.01160611305385828, + 0.01672193966805935, + 0.046328071504831314, + 0.09303338825702667, + 0.28847959637641907, + 0.07056264579296112, + 0.3074035346508026, + 0.060124386101961136 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20157891511917114 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set inside a dimly lit warehouse with a dusty concrete floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle capturing a tall stack of assorted cardboard boxes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a long, weathered wooden pencil with faded gray veins and dark water stains visible hurling from the left side of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the central box visibly wrinkle and dent upon impact, causing a cloud of dust to erupt under harsh overhead lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the entire stack of boxes collapse instantly, with lower boxes flaring outward and upper ones cascading down chaotically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3870678246021271 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1370677947998047 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3870678246021271, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3870678246021271, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11555264890193939, + 0.04827864468097687, + 0.027304716408252716, + 0.10671444982290268, + 0.0591391883790493, + 0.07740054279565811, + 0.20480573177337646, + 0.07965146750211716, + 0.14875799417495728, + 0.13239455223083496 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3870678246021271 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, low-angle shot captures the scene inside a dimly lit warehouse, focusing on a tall, precarious stack of assorted cardboard boxes on the dusty concrete floor. The boxes vary in size and condition, showing signs of wear, with wrinkled corners and peeling packing tape, creating a featureless mass. From the left side of the frame, a long, weathered wooden pencil—its surface a tapestry of faded gray veins, dark water stains, and tattered edges—hurls itself swiftly and decisively at the stack. It strikes the mid-height of the stack with a violent force. In a flash of kinetic energy, the corrugated cardboard of the central box visibly wrinkles and dents as a cloud of dust erupts under the harsh overhead lighting. The entire stack collapses instantly; the lower boxes flare outward, while the upper ones tilt forward, then cascade down in a chaotic, dramatic fashion, the individual boxes tumbling and flattening as they scatter across the floor. The sudden destruction creates a tense and impactful atmosphere.", + "seed": 33169, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_14/index_5019_seed_33169_dp_29_rank_58_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.10215025544166564, + "vlm_logprob": -0.10215025544166564, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.824999952316284, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.10215025544166564, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set inside a dimly lit warehouse with a dusty concrete floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle capturing a tall stack of assorted cardboard boxes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a long, weathered wooden pencil with faded gray veins and dark water stains visible hurling from the left side of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the central box visibly wrinkle and dent upon impact, causing a cloud of dust to erupt under harsh overhead lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the entire stack of boxes collapse instantly, with lower boxes flaring outward and upper ones cascading down chaotically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10096248984336853 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3509624004364014 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10096248984336853, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10096248984336853, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3769559860229492, + 0.08538277447223663, + 0.07394645363092422, + 0.09017525613307953, + 0.05891623720526695, + 0.018326057121157646, + 0.008667128160595894, + 0.0790996178984642, + 0.1037067398428917, + 0.10482372343540192 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10096248984336853 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set inside a dimly lit warehouse with a dusty concrete floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle capturing a tall stack of assorted cardboard boxes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a long, weathered wooden pencil with faded gray veins and dark water stains visible hurling from the left side of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the central box visibly wrinkle and dent upon impact, causing a cloud of dust to erupt under harsh overhead lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the entire stack of boxes collapse instantly, with lower boxes flaring outward and upper ones cascading down chaotically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018220080062747 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018219947814941 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018220080062747, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018220080062747, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16099298000335693, + 0.1753789633512497, + 0.05584214627742767, + 0.10498034954071045, + 0.07468530535697937, + 0.01971607655286789, + 0.07010075449943542, + 0.06353628635406494, + 0.1829056590795517, + 0.09186147153377533 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018220080062747 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set inside a dimly lit warehouse with a dusty concrete floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle capturing a tall stack of assorted cardboard boxes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a long, weathered wooden pencil with faded gray veins and dark water stains visible hurling from the left side of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the central box visibly wrinkle and dent upon impact, causing a cloud of dust to erupt under harsh overhead lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the entire stack of boxes collapse instantly, with lower boxes flaring outward and upper ones cascading down chaotically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06205904111266136 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812058925628662 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06205904111266136, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06205904111266136, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18081213533878326, + 0.08155962824821472, + 0.03726234287023544, + 0.04783983156085014, + 0.057741928845644, + 0.01926005631685257, + 0.07712667435407639, + 0.23814328014850616, + 0.09650825709104538, + 0.16374589502811432 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06205904111266136 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set inside a dimly lit warehouse with a dusty concrete floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle capturing a tall stack of assorted cardboard boxes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a long, weathered wooden pencil with faded gray veins and dark water stains visible hurling from the left side of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the central box visibly wrinkle and dent upon impact, causing a cloud of dust to erupt under harsh overhead lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the entire stack of boxes collapse instantly, with lower boxes flaring outward and upper ones cascading down chaotically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016074350103735924 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141074180603027 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016074350103735924, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016074350103735924, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13610194623470306, + 0.04101382941007614, + 0.018995162099599838, + 0.046668387949466705, + 0.05788908898830414, + 0.036375124007463455, + 0.05510440841317177, + 0.3460579514503479, + 0.10027974098920822, + 0.16151438653469086 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016074350103735924 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set inside a dimly lit warehouse with a dusty concrete floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle capturing a tall stack of assorted cardboard boxes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a long, weathered wooden pencil with faded gray veins and dark water stains visible hurling from the left side of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the central box visibly wrinkle and dent upon impact, causing a cloud of dust to erupt under harsh overhead lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the entire stack of boxes collapse instantly, with lower boxes flaring outward and upper ones cascading down chaotically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.31343531608581543 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3134353160858154 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.31343531608581543, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.31343531608581543, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08753392100334167, + 0.08359412103891373, + 0.04642442986369133, + 0.07530635595321655, + 0.04561425745487213, + 0.032851576805114746, + 0.07882482558488846, + 0.11861315369606018, + 0.17284202575683594, + 0.25839531421661377 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.31343531608581543 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, low-angle shot captures the scene inside a dimly lit warehouse, focusing on a tall, precarious stack of assorted cardboard boxes on the dusty concrete floor. The boxes vary in size and condition, showing signs of wear, with wrinkled corners and peeling packing tape, creating a featureless mass. From the left side of the frame, a long, weathered wooden pencil—its surface a tapestry of faded gray veins, dark water stains, and tattered edges—hurls itself swiftly and decisively at the stack. It strikes the mid-height of the stack with a violent force. In a flash of kinetic energy, the corrugated cardboard of the central box visibly wrinkles and dents as a cloud of dust erupts under the harsh overhead lighting. The entire stack collapses instantly; the lower boxes flare outward, while the upper ones tilt forward, then cascade down in a chaotic, dramatic fashion, the individual boxes tumbling and flattening as they scatter across the floor. The sudden destruction creates a tense and impactful atmosphere.", + "seed": 33170, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_14/index_5019_seed_33170_dp_29_rank_58_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.03303004647605121, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03303004647605121, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.075, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03303004647605121, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set inside a dimly lit warehouse with a dusty concrete floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle capturing a tall stack of assorted cardboard boxes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a long, weathered wooden pencil with faded gray veins and dark water stains visible hurling from the left side of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the central box visibly wrinkle and dent upon impact, causing a cloud of dust to erupt under harsh overhead lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the entire stack of boxes collapse instantly, with lower boxes flaring outward and upper ones cascading down chaotically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012257014401257038 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.637257099151611 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012257014401257038, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012257014401257038, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22137108445167542, + 0.045345503836870193, + 0.047709494829177856, + 0.05932744964957237, + 0.13531993329524994, + 0.08179257810115814, + 0.028406530618667603, + 0.09386559575796127, + 0.07631322741508484, + 0.2105485498905182 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012257014401257038 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set inside a dimly lit warehouse with a dusty concrete floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle capturing a tall stack of assorted cardboard boxes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a long, weathered wooden pencil with faded gray veins and dark water stains visible hurling from the left side of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the central box visibly wrinkle and dent upon impact, causing a cloud of dust to erupt under harsh overhead lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the entire stack of boxes collapse instantly, with lower boxes flaring outward and upper ones cascading down chaotically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0032144326251000166 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753214359283447 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0032144326251000166, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0032144326251000166, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24214841425418854, + 0.03476719558238983, + 0.05015147477388382, + 0.07139326632022858, + 0.3001682460308075, + 0.06507637351751328, + 0.030912399291992188, + 0.07731276750564575, + 0.07719734311103821, + 0.05087242275476456 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0032144326251000166 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set inside a dimly lit warehouse with a dusty concrete floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle capturing a tall stack of assorted cardboard boxes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a long, weathered wooden pencil with faded gray veins and dark water stains visible hurling from the left side of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the central box visibly wrinkle and dent upon impact, causing a cloud of dust to erupt under harsh overhead lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the entire stack of boxes collapse instantly, with lower boxes flaring outward and upper ones cascading down chaotically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07899946719408035 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5789995193481445 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07899946719408035, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07899946719408035, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1623968482017517, + 0.032338254153728485, + 0.02103988081216812, + 0.09967967122793198, + 0.2639758884906769, + 0.13130386173725128, + 0.0778849869966507, + 0.09933558106422424, + 0.051604270935058594, + 0.060440775007009506 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07899946719408035 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set inside a dimly lit warehouse with a dusty concrete floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle capturing a tall stack of assorted cardboard boxes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a long, weathered wooden pencil with faded gray veins and dark water stains visible hurling from the left side of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the central box visibly wrinkle and dent upon impact, causing a cloud of dust to erupt under harsh overhead lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the entire stack of boxes collapse instantly, with lower boxes flaring outward and upper ones cascading down chaotically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008647613227367401 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758647441864014 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008647613227367401, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008647613227367401, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24590571224689484, + 0.026288677006959915, + 0.02966921217739582, + 0.07582274824380875, + 0.13601136207580566, + 0.14422127604484558, + 0.09753845632076263, + 0.035945214331150055, + 0.026032105088233948, + 0.18256522715091705 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008647613227367401 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set inside a dimly lit warehouse with a dusty concrete floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle capturing a tall stack of assorted cardboard boxes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a long, weathered wooden pencil with faded gray veins and dark water stains visible hurling from the left side of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the central box visibly wrinkle and dent upon impact, causing a cloud of dust to erupt under harsh overhead lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the entire stack of boxes collapse instantly, with lower boxes flaring outward and upper ones cascading down chaotically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06203170493245125 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120317459106445 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06203170493245125, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06203170493245125, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.049072518944740295, + 0.03385479748249054, + 0.017053108662366867, + 0.07687363028526306, + 0.18319708108901978, + 0.28913211822509766, + 0.16585305333137512, + 0.042126864194869995, + 0.03150138258934021, + 0.11133544892072678 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06203170493245125 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_15/index_tensor([9952, 9952])_group_15_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_15/index_tensor([9952, 9952])_group_15_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..bd04ddafaf651021e9787738710ea86bc2105fb4 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_15/index_tensor([9952, 9952])_group_15_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "sweeping shot, shot from above, employing a humanistic style, first focuses sharply on a young female tourist in the foreground. She wears an off-white turtleneck sweater, her long hair gently ruffled by the riverside breeze. Her eyes widen slightly in wonder, her lips parted, and the glittering lights of the city reflected on her face, a look of pure fascination. Behind her, the majestic Oriental Pearl Tower blurs into a soft, shimmering swirl of pink and blue light, blending with the equally out-of-focus lights of the ferries traversing the deep blue Huangpu River to create a dreamlike backdrop. The camera then executes a swift and smooth focus switch, accompanied by a subtle, warm screen flicker, as if capturing a momentary emotional aura. The viewer's attention is quickly drawn from the foreground figure to the distant vista; the focus falls decisively on the distant Oriental Pearl Tower's spire. Its iconic spherical structure and steel antennae piercing the twilight sky become incredibly sharp, and the tower's shimmering lights are clearly visible. At this moment, the silhouettes of tourists in the foreground fade into blur, while in the background, a steady stream of illuminated ferries and sightseeing boats glide across the Huangpu River, casting long, shimmering shadows on the dark water. The interweaving of cool and warm tones at dusk, and the rapid shift in focus between grand architecture and delicate emotions, create a poetic sense of immersion, akin to being in a bustling city, transfixed by the fleeting grandeur and beauty.", + "seed": 29614, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_15/index_9952_seed_29614_dp_30_rank_60_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.14404132217168808, + "vlm_logprob": -0.14404132217168808, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.625, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.14404132217168808, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from an elevated angle looking down on the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a young female tourist wearing an off-white turtleneck sweater visible in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a sharp focus on the tourist before shifting focus to the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the Oriental Pearl Tower visible in the background with its spherical structure and steel antennae?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show illuminated ferries and sightseeing boats gliding across the Huangpu River?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6492252349853516 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7742252349853516 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.6492252349853516, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.6492252349853516, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20153748989105225, + 0.08910250663757324, + 0.06329082697629929, + 0.04720491170883179, + 0.07232432812452316, + 0.18358948826789856, + 0.03709759935736656, + 0.11001668870449066, + 0.1074838936328888, + 0.08835221827030182 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.6492252349853516 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from an elevated angle looking down on the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a young female tourist wearing an off-white turtleneck sweater visible in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a sharp focus on the tourist before shifting focus to the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the Oriental Pearl Tower visible in the background with its spherical structure and steel antennae?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show illuminated ferries and sightseeing boats gliding across the Huangpu River?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011095608584582806 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.5110955238342285 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011095608584582806, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011095608584582806, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3185640573501587, + 0.10841996967792511, + 0.14121124148368835, + 0.049959469586610794, + 0.07911000400781631, + 0.0703909620642662, + 0.04016869515180588, + 0.0891508087515831, + 0.050230078399181366, + 0.05279461666941643 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011095608584582806 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from an elevated angle looking down on the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a young female tourist wearing an off-white turtleneck sweater visible in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a sharp focus on the tourist before shifting focus to the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the Oriental Pearl Tower visible in the background with its spherical structure and steel antennae?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show illuminated ferries and sightseeing boats gliding across the Huangpu River?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007635574322193861 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882635593414307 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007635574322193861, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007635574322193861, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12041324377059937, + 0.19332703948020935, + 0.21262364089488983, + 0.02634776569902897, + 0.10516545921564102, + 0.0866205021739006, + 0.05091862753033638, + 0.047138649970293045, + 0.11775580048561096, + 0.03968929126858711 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007635574322193861 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from an elevated angle looking down on the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a young female tourist wearing an off-white turtleneck sweater visible in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a sharp focus on the tourist before shifting focus to the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the Oriental Pearl Tower visible in the background with its spherical structure and steel antennae?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show illuminated ferries and sightseeing boats gliding across the Huangpu River?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003615511115640402 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628615379333496 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003615511115640402, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003615511115640402, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03922049328684807, + 0.02275209315121174, + 0.07912667095661163, + 0.016858622431755066, + 0.03162944316864014, + 0.058808907866477966, + 0.09670480340719223, + 0.1271997094154358, + 0.3656602203845978, + 0.16203898191452026 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003615511115640402 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from an elevated angle looking down on the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a young female tourist wearing an off-white turtleneck sweater visible in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a sharp focus on the tourist before shifting focus to the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the Oriental Pearl Tower visible in the background with its spherical structure and steel antennae?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show illuminated ferries and sightseeing boats gliding across the Huangpu River?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04863468185067177 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486347675323486 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04863468185067177, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04863468185067177, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0968189537525177, + 0.12409865111112595, + 0.10334514826536179, + 0.022057849913835526, + 0.07459008693695068, + 0.13495774567127228, + 0.08655117452144623, + 0.06852342933416367, + 0.07304313033819199, + 0.2160138487815857 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04863468185067177 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "sweeping shot, shot from above, employing a humanistic style, first focuses sharply on a young female tourist in the foreground. She wears an off-white turtleneck sweater, her long hair gently ruffled by the riverside breeze. Her eyes widen slightly in wonder, her lips parted, and the glittering lights of the city reflected on her face, a look of pure fascination. Behind her, the majestic Oriental Pearl Tower blurs into a soft, shimmering swirl of pink and blue light, blending with the equally out-of-focus lights of the ferries traversing the deep blue Huangpu River to create a dreamlike backdrop. The camera then executes a swift and smooth focus switch, accompanied by a subtle, warm screen flicker, as if capturing a momentary emotional aura. The viewer's attention is quickly drawn from the foreground figure to the distant vista; the focus falls decisively on the distant Oriental Pearl Tower's spire. Its iconic spherical structure and steel antennae piercing the twilight sky become incredibly sharp, and the tower's shimmering lights are clearly visible. At this moment, the silhouettes of tourists in the foreground fade into blur, while in the background, a steady stream of illuminated ferries and sightseeing boats glide across the Huangpu River, casting long, shimmering shadows on the dark water. The interweaving of cool and warm tones at dusk, and the rapid shift in focus between grand architecture and delicate emotions, create a poetic sense of immersion, akin to being in a bustling city, transfixed by the fleeting grandeur and beauty.", + "seed": 29615, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_15/index_9952_seed_29615_dp_30_rank_60_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.39497037790715694, + "vlm_logprob": -0.39497037790715694, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.15, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.39497037790715694, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from an elevated angle looking down on the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a young female tourist wearing an off-white turtleneck sweater visible in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a sharp focus on the tourist before shifting focus to the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the Oriental Pearl Tower visible in the background with its spherical structure and steel antennae?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show illuminated ferries and sightseeing boats gliding across the Huangpu River?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7149807214736938 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.21498073637485504 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.7149807214736938, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -1.7149807214736938, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07965996861457825, + 0.15398280322551727, + 0.17528299987316132, + 0.0333758145570755, + 0.10548259317874908, + 0.07894884794950485, + 0.057395774871110916, + 0.057992152869701385, + 0.04780355468392372, + 0.2100755125284195 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.7149807214736938 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from an elevated angle looking down on the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a young female tourist wearing an off-white turtleneck sweater visible in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a sharp focus on the tourist before shifting focus to the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the Oriental Pearl Tower visible in the background with its spherical structure and steel antennae?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show illuminated ferries and sightseeing boats gliding across the Huangpu River?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026392405852675438 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513924598693848 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026392405852675438, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026392405852675438, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13591516017913818, + 0.22478021681308746, + 0.07067243754863739, + 0.050310153514146805, + 0.04874080792069435, + 0.06112879514694214, + 0.23740802705287933, + 0.05886967107653618, + 0.06166796386241913, + 0.050506725907325745 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026392405852675438 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from an elevated angle looking down on the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a young female tourist wearing an off-white turtleneck sweater visible in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a sharp focus on the tourist before shifting focus to the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the Oriental Pearl Tower visible in the background with its spherical structure and steel antennae?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show illuminated ferries and sightseeing boats gliding across the Huangpu River?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05496241897344589 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929962396621704 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05496241897344589, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05496241897344589, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11201067268848419, + 0.08227372169494629, + 0.2583063542842865, + 0.02855292148888111, + 0.06087159737944603, + 0.09387621283531189, + 0.10159989446401596, + 0.12981371581554413, + 0.07941611856222153, + 0.053278848528862 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05496241897344589 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from an elevated angle looking down on the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a young female tourist wearing an off-white turtleneck sweater visible in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a sharp focus on the tourist before shifting focus to the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the Oriental Pearl Tower visible in the background with its spherical structure and steel antennae?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show illuminated ferries and sightseeing boats gliding across the Huangpu River?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01818835735321045 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.0181884765625 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01818835735321045, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01818835735321045, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.046681731939315796, + 0.15855975449085236, + 0.09062183648347855, + 0.022869059816002846, + 0.09086890518665314, + 0.07961083948612213, + 0.09135246276855469, + 0.07097814232110977, + 0.12425553798675537, + 0.2242017537355423 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01818835735321045 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from an elevated angle looking down on the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a young female tourist wearing an off-white turtleneck sweater visible in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a sharp focus on the tourist before shifting focus to the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the Oriental Pearl Tower visible in the background with its spherical structure and steel antennae?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show illuminated ferries and sightseeing boats gliding across the Huangpu River?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1603279858827591 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9103280305862427 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1603279858827591, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1603279858827591, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05961094796657562, + 0.07116276770830154, + 0.06899603456258774, + 0.028597209602594376, + 0.0713014155626297, + 0.07579255849123001, + 0.23118014633655548, + 0.08932417631149292, + 0.08551696687936783, + 0.21851776540279388 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1603279858827591 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "sweeping shot, shot from above, employing a humanistic style, first focuses sharply on a young female tourist in the foreground. She wears an off-white turtleneck sweater, her long hair gently ruffled by the riverside breeze. Her eyes widen slightly in wonder, her lips parted, and the glittering lights of the city reflected on her face, a look of pure fascination. Behind her, the majestic Oriental Pearl Tower blurs into a soft, shimmering swirl of pink and blue light, blending with the equally out-of-focus lights of the ferries traversing the deep blue Huangpu River to create a dreamlike backdrop. The camera then executes a swift and smooth focus switch, accompanied by a subtle, warm screen flicker, as if capturing a momentary emotional aura. The viewer's attention is quickly drawn from the foreground figure to the distant vista; the focus falls decisively on the distant Oriental Pearl Tower's spire. Its iconic spherical structure and steel antennae piercing the twilight sky become incredibly sharp, and the tower's shimmering lights are clearly visible. At this moment, the silhouettes of tourists in the foreground fade into blur, while in the background, a steady stream of illuminated ferries and sightseeing boats glide across the Huangpu River, casting long, shimmering shadows on the dark water. The interweaving of cool and warm tones at dusk, and the rapid shift in focus between grand architecture and delicate emotions, create a poetic sense of immersion, akin to being in a bustling city, transfixed by the fleeting grandeur and beauty.", + "seed": 29616, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_15/index_9952_seed_29616_dp_31_rank_62_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.2700704778544605, + "vlm_logprob": -0.2700704778544605, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.85, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.2700704778544605, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from an elevated angle looking down on the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a young female tourist wearing an off-white turtleneck sweater visible in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a sharp focus on the tourist before shifting focus to the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the Oriental Pearl Tower visible in the background with its spherical structure and steel antennae?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show illuminated ferries and sightseeing boats gliding across the Huangpu River?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.233688473701477 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.35868850350379944 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.233688473701477, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -1.233688473701477, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23729883134365082, + 0.3037121295928955, + 0.03212567791342735, + 0.046135324984788895, + 0.03727150335907936, + 0.08878463506698608, + 0.0693449079990387, + 0.0806960016489029, + 0.0551125593483448, + 0.049518439918756485 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.233688473701477 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from an elevated angle looking down on the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a young female tourist wearing an off-white turtleneck sweater visible in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a sharp focus on the tourist before shifting focus to the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the Oriental Pearl Tower visible in the background with its spherical structure and steel antennae?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show illuminated ferries and sightseeing boats gliding across the Huangpu River?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04868645966053009 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486865043640137 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04868645966053009, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04868645966053009, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22457341849803925, + 0.5215335488319397, + 0.0416279062628746, + 0.030576642602682114, + 0.03188130632042885, + 0.03274412080645561, + 0.01719672419130802, + 0.053813718259334564, + 0.028103308752179146, + 0.017949238419532776 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04868645966053009 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from an elevated angle looking down on the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a young female tourist wearing an off-white turtleneck sweater visible in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a sharp focus on the tourist before shifting focus to the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the Oriental Pearl Tower visible in the background with its spherical structure and steel antennae?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show illuminated ferries and sightseeing boats gliding across the Huangpu River?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018190348520874977 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018190383911133 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018190348520874977, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018190348520874977, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.30475887656211853, + 0.14393578469753265, + 0.061154019087553024, + 0.06301340460777283, + 0.06261573731899261, + 0.08303659409284592, + 0.04216361045837402, + 0.0989232137799263, + 0.09863395988941193, + 0.041764844208955765 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018190348520874977 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from an elevated angle looking down on the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a young female tourist wearing an off-white turtleneck sweater visible in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a sharp focus on the tourist before shifting focus to the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the Oriental Pearl Tower visible in the background with its spherical structure and steel antennae?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show illuminated ferries and sightseeing boats gliding across the Huangpu River?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0067384387366473675 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006738662719727 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0067384387366473675, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0067384387366473675, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1794532686471939, + 0.2997003197669983, + 0.03635171800851822, + 0.02453436516225338, + 0.030597703531384468, + 0.05059294030070305, + 0.06146940588951111, + 0.09647181630134583, + 0.05345766991376877, + 0.16737082600593567 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0067384387366473675 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from an elevated angle looking down on the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a young female tourist wearing an off-white turtleneck sweater visible in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a sharp focus on the tourist before shifting focus to the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the Oriental Pearl Tower visible in the background with its spherical structure and steel antennae?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show illuminated ferries and sightseeing boats gliding across the Huangpu River?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0430486686527729 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168048620223999 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0430486686527729, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0430486686527729, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07562185078859329, + 0.15444226562976837, + 0.020170599222183228, + 0.07070036977529526, + 0.03422197699546814, + 0.06860622763633728, + 0.047986287623643875, + 0.4029759466648102, + 0.045192573219537735, + 0.08008197695016861 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0430486686527729 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "sweeping shot, shot from above, employing a humanistic style, first focuses sharply on a young female tourist in the foreground. She wears an off-white turtleneck sweater, her long hair gently ruffled by the riverside breeze. Her eyes widen slightly in wonder, her lips parted, and the glittering lights of the city reflected on her face, a look of pure fascination. Behind her, the majestic Oriental Pearl Tower blurs into a soft, shimmering swirl of pink and blue light, blending with the equally out-of-focus lights of the ferries traversing the deep blue Huangpu River to create a dreamlike backdrop. The camera then executes a swift and smooth focus switch, accompanied by a subtle, warm screen flicker, as if capturing a momentary emotional aura. The viewer's attention is quickly drawn from the foreground figure to the distant vista; the focus falls decisively on the distant Oriental Pearl Tower's spire. Its iconic spherical structure and steel antennae piercing the twilight sky become incredibly sharp, and the tower's shimmering lights are clearly visible. At this moment, the silhouettes of tourists in the foreground fade into blur, while in the background, a steady stream of illuminated ferries and sightseeing boats glide across the Huangpu River, casting long, shimmering shadows on the dark water. The interweaving of cool and warm tones at dusk, and the rapid shift in focus between grand architecture and delicate emotions, create a poetic sense of immersion, akin to being in a bustling city, transfixed by the fleeting grandeur and beauty.", + "seed": 29617, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_15/index_9952_seed_29617_dp_31_rank_62_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.5143925523385405, + "vlm_logprob": -0.5143925523385405, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.2, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.5143925523385405, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from an elevated angle looking down on the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a young female tourist wearing an off-white turtleneck sweater visible in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a sharp focus on the tourist before shifting focus to the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the Oriental Pearl Tower visible in the background with its spherical structure and steel antennae?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show illuminated ferries and sightseeing boats gliding across the Huangpu River?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2458558082580566 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12085571140050888 + ], + "logprob_reward": -2.2458558082580566, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -2.2458558082580566, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2588734030723572, + 0.10005646198987961, + 0.07445085793733597, + 0.06443708389997482, + 0.05969390645623207, + 0.048118360340595245, + 0.06139496713876724, + 0.07628250122070312, + 0.14719155430793762, + 0.10950092226266861 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -2.2458558082580566 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from an elevated angle looking down on the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a young female tourist wearing an off-white turtleneck sweater visible in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a sharp focus on the tourist before shifting focus to the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the Oriental Pearl Tower visible in the background with its spherical structure and steel antennae?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show illuminated ferries and sightseeing boats gliding across the Huangpu River?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02640273980796337 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651402711868286 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02640273980796337, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02640273980796337, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16945423185825348, + 0.1046244278550148, + 0.08130871504545212, + 0.0743650272488594, + 0.09840869158506393, + 0.05164594203233719, + 0.049908597022295, + 0.07819510251283646, + 0.14261725544929504, + 0.14947202801704407 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02640273980796337 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from an elevated angle looking down on the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a young female tourist wearing an off-white turtleneck sweater visible in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a sharp focus on the tourist before shifting focus to the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the Oriental Pearl Tower visible in the background with its spherical structure and steel antennae?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show illuminated ferries and sightseeing boats gliding across the Huangpu River?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2255919724702835 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.600592017173767 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2255919724702835, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2255919724702835, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1359441727399826, + 0.08683265745639801, + 0.09510234743356705, + 0.1073153093457222, + 0.12436746805906296, + 0.14070989191532135, + 0.06854107230901718, + 0.04030383378267288, + 0.09577702730894089, + 0.1051061823964119 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2255919724702835 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from an elevated angle looking down on the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a young female tourist wearing an off-white turtleneck sweater visible in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a sharp focus on the tourist before shifting focus to the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the Oriental Pearl Tower visible in the background with its spherical structure and steel antennae?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show illuminated ferries and sightseeing boats gliding across the Huangpu River?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004099537618458271 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504099369049072 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004099537618458271, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004099537618458271, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14689402282238007, + 0.09487823396921158, + 0.10142658650875092, + 0.13009808957576752, + 0.13602188229560852, + 0.06326772272586823, + 0.08577222377061844, + 0.052843861281871796, + 0.058519814163446426, + 0.1302775740623474 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004099537618458271 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from an elevated angle looking down on the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a young female tourist wearing an off-white turtleneck sweater visible in the foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a sharp focus on the tourist before shifting focus to the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the Oriental Pearl Tower visible in the background with its spherical structure and steel antennae?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show illuminated ferries and sightseeing boats gliding across the Huangpu River?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07001270353794098 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950128078460693 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07001270353794098, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07001270353794098, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1606857180595398, + 0.09566926211118698, + 0.06618940085172653, + 0.08314035832881927, + 0.22810062766075134, + 0.1211622953414917, + 0.08070774376392365, + 0.04310615360736847, + 0.06470941752195358, + 0.05652909353375435 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07001270353794098 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_2/index_tensor([9738, 9738])_group_2_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_2/index_tensor([9738, 9738])_group_2_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..54206a390834822e4dd9766ff45e54389d9735ae --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_2/index_tensor([9738, 9738])_group_2_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "cinematic macro shot, static and held at intimate eye level, focuses with razor-sharp clarity on the delicate, vibrant green stems of a young vine. The slender stems, almost translucent and covered in a dense layer of fine hairs, emerge from the dark, moist soil of a weathered clay pot. An unseen breeze causes the stems to sway slowly and gracefully, their movements subtle and deliberate. A curled, curious tendril at the tip of one stem leans toward the stem next to it, making soft, brief contact with the stem of another. They gently nudge and brush against each other, their delicate interaction appearing like a silent, choreographed conversation. The scene is bathed in a soft, warm late afternoon glow from a nearby window, backlighting the fine hairs on the stems and creating a beautiful bokeh effect against the out-of-focus background. This interplay of light, shadow, and slow motion creates an atmosphere of tranquility, contemplation, and deep calm, capturing a quiet moment of natural beauty.", + "seed": 1261, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_2/index_9738_seed_1261_dp_4_rank_8_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.014625467685982585, + "vlm_logprob": -0.014625467685982585, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.8, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.014625467685982585, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a cinematic macro view focusing on the delicate, vibrant green stems of a young vine?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the stems slender, almost translucent, and covered in a dense layer of fine hairs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the stems emerge from dark, moist soil inside a weathered clay pot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a curled tendril at the tip of one stem lean toward and gently brush against the stem of another?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene backlit by a soft, warm late afternoon glow creating a bokeh effect against the out-of-focus background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002978414995595813 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.252978324890137 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002978414995595813, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002978414995595813, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2043519914150238, + 0.11924892663955688, + 0.08075785636901855, + 0.06684622168540955, + 0.036508649587631226, + 0.22482554614543915, + 0.05061252415180206, + 0.044891588389873505, + 0.11407539248466492, + 0.05788132920861244 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002978414995595813 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a cinematic macro view focusing on the delicate, vibrant green stems of a young vine?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the stems slender, almost translucent, and covered in a dense layer of fine hairs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the stems emerge from dark, moist soil inside a weathered clay pot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a curled tendril at the tip of one stem lean toward and gently brush against the stem of another?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene backlit by a soft, warm late afternoon glow creating a bokeh effect against the out-of-focus background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.038115546107292175 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881155014038086 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.038115546107292175, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.038115546107292175, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18491066992282867, + 0.07137404382228851, + 0.059105437248945236, + 0.07822901010513306, + 0.05802211910486221, + 0.3583863079547882, + 0.030198991298675537, + 0.02779626101255417, + 0.08434267342090607, + 0.04763449355959892 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.038115546107292175 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a cinematic macro view focusing on the delicate, vibrant green stems of a young vine?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the stems slender, almost translucent, and covered in a dense layer of fine hairs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the stems emerge from dark, moist soil inside a weathered clay pot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a curled tendril at the tip of one stem lean toward and gently brush against the stem of another?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene backlit by a soft, warm late afternoon glow creating a bokeh effect against the out-of-focus background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0028194934129714966 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877819538116455 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0028194934129714966, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0028194934129714966, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.28221747279167175, + 0.2030043601989746, + 0.07939181476831436, + 0.07210996747016907, + 0.08002456277608871, + 0.06053783744573593, + 0.058837294578552246, + 0.05671784281730652, + 0.034952111542224884, + 0.0722067579627037 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0028194934129714966 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a cinematic macro view focusing on the delicate, vibrant green stems of a young vine?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the stems slender, almost translucent, and covered in a dense layer of fine hairs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the stems emerge from dark, moist soil inside a weathered clay pot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a curled tendril at the tip of one stem lean toward and gently brush against the stem of another?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene backlit by a soft, warm late afternoon glow creating a bokeh effect against the out-of-focus background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020579271018505096 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955793380737305 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020579271018505096, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020579271018505096, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08271215111017227, + 0.04471520334482193, + 0.028383081778883934, + 0.04252425953745842, + 0.1280468851327896, + 0.33774298429489136, + 0.16598676145076752, + 0.09321626275777817, + 0.052322447299957275, + 0.02434997446835041 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020579271018505096 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a cinematic macro view focusing on the delicate, vibrant green stems of a young vine?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the stems slender, almost translucent, and covered in a dense layer of fine hairs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the stems emerge from dark, moist soil inside a weathered clay pot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a curled tendril at the tip of one stem lean toward and gently brush against the stem of another?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene backlit by a soft, warm late afternoon glow creating a bokeh effect against the out-of-focus background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008634612895548344 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758634567260742 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008634612895548344, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008634612895548344, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3038146197795868, + 0.18337851762771606, + 0.09217245876789093, + 0.08454515039920807, + 0.05956191197037697, + 0.08117794990539551, + 0.053064290434122086, + 0.047537192702293396, + 0.04084743559360504, + 0.05390044301748276 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008634612895548344 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "cinematic macro shot, static and held at intimate eye level, focuses with razor-sharp clarity on the delicate, vibrant green stems of a young vine. The slender stems, almost translucent and covered in a dense layer of fine hairs, emerge from the dark, moist soil of a weathered clay pot. An unseen breeze causes the stems to sway slowly and gracefully, their movements subtle and deliberate. A curled, curious tendril at the tip of one stem leans toward the stem next to it, making soft, brief contact with the stem of another. They gently nudge and brush against each other, their delicate interaction appearing like a silent, choreographed conversation. The scene is bathed in a soft, warm late afternoon glow from a nearby window, backlighting the fine hairs on the stems and creating a beautiful bokeh effect against the out-of-focus background. This interplay of light, shadow, and slow motion creates an atmosphere of tranquility, contemplation, and deep calm, capturing a quiet moment of natural beauty.", + "seed": 1262, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_2/index_9738_seed_1262_dp_4_rank_8_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.030040310975164176, + "vlm_logprob": -0.030040310975164176, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.95, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.030040310975164176, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a cinematic macro view focusing on the delicate, vibrant green stems of a young vine?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the stems slender, almost translucent, and covered in a dense layer of fine hairs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the stems emerge from dark, moist soil inside a weathered clay pot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a curled tendril at the tip of one stem lean toward and gently brush against the stem of another?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene backlit by a soft, warm late afternoon glow creating a bokeh effect against the out-of-focus background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.015908462926745415 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.265908241271973 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.015908462926745415, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.015908462926745415, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22954010963439941, + 0.30199161171913147, + 0.017685992643237114, + 0.020250586792826653, + 0.009895974770188332, + 0.017570126801729202, + 0.03414583206176758, + 0.18232694268226624, + 0.13549712300300598, + 0.05109572038054466 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.015908462926745415 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a cinematic macro view focusing on the delicate, vibrant green stems of a young vine?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the stems slender, almost translucent, and covered in a dense layer of fine hairs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the stems emerge from dark, moist soil inside a weathered clay pot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a curled tendril at the tip of one stem lean toward and gently brush against the stem of another?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene backlit by a soft, warm late afternoon glow creating a bokeh effect against the out-of-focus background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0790116935968399 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5790116786956787 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0790116935968399, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0790116935968399, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2139996737241745, + 0.08030463010072708, + 0.02409377694129944, + 0.01136152446269989, + 0.01041877269744873, + 0.01373498234897852, + 0.039080314338207245, + 0.23352758586406708, + 0.29861611127853394, + 0.07486260682344437 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0790116935968399 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a cinematic macro view focusing on the delicate, vibrant green stems of a young vine?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the stems slender, almost translucent, and covered in a dense layer of fine hairs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the stems emerge from dark, moist soil inside a weathered clay pot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a curled tendril at the tip of one stem lean toward and gently brush against the stem of another?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene backlit by a soft, warm late afternoon glow creating a bokeh effect against the out-of-focus background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004641236271709204 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379641056060791 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004641236271709204, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004641236271709204, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1347336322069168, + 0.5424013137817383, + 0.04061102494597435, + 0.01131814531981945, + 0.007747255731374025, + 0.007120396476238966, + 0.023892946541309357, + 0.1454107016324997, + 0.03916669264435768, + 0.04759788513183594 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004641236271709204 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a cinematic macro view focusing on the delicate, vibrant green stems of a young vine?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the stems slender, almost translucent, and covered in a dense layer of fine hairs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the stems emerge from dark, moist soil inside a weathered clay pot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a curled tendril at the tip of one stem lean toward and gently brush against the stem of another?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene backlit by a soft, warm late afternoon glow creating a bokeh effect against the out-of-focus background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.038102924823760986 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288102865219116 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.038102924823760986, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.038102924823760986, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09061834961175919, + 0.30531319975852966, + 0.07100005447864532, + 0.08663550764322281, + 0.013871622271835804, + 0.012628840282559395, + 0.048773135989904404, + 0.18824104964733124, + 0.14108246564865112, + 0.0418357327580452 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.038102924823760986 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a cinematic macro view focusing on the delicate, vibrant green stems of a young vine?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the stems slender, almost translucent, and covered in a dense layer of fine hairs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the stems emerge from dark, moist soil inside a weathered clay pot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a curled tendril at the tip of one stem lean toward and gently brush against the stem of another?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene backlit by a soft, warm late afternoon glow creating a bokeh effect against the out-of-focus background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012537237256765366 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387537002563477 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012537237256765366, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012537237256765366, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08588678389787674, + 0.5418686270713806, + 0.02150842547416687, + 0.019535688683390617, + 0.00674812588840723, + 0.00965152122080326, + 0.04736218973994255, + 0.09538175910711288, + 0.133153036236763, + 0.03890387341380119 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012537237256765366 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "cinematic macro shot, static and held at intimate eye level, focuses with razor-sharp clarity on the delicate, vibrant green stems of a young vine. The slender stems, almost translucent and covered in a dense layer of fine hairs, emerge from the dark, moist soil of a weathered clay pot. An unseen breeze causes the stems to sway slowly and gracefully, their movements subtle and deliberate. A curled, curious tendril at the tip of one stem leans toward the stem next to it, making soft, brief contact with the stem of another. They gently nudge and brush against each other, their delicate interaction appearing like a silent, choreographed conversation. The scene is bathed in a soft, warm late afternoon glow from a nearby window, backlighting the fine hairs on the stems and creating a beautiful bokeh effect against the out-of-focus background. This interplay of light, shadow, and slow motion creates an atmosphere of tranquility, contemplation, and deep calm, capturing a quiet moment of natural beauty.", + "seed": 1263, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_2/index_9738_seed_1263_dp_5_rank_10_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.018677728576585652, + "vlm_logprob": -0.018677728576585652, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.45, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.018677728576585652, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a cinematic macro view focusing on the delicate, vibrant green stems of a young vine?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the stems slender, almost translucent, and covered in a dense layer of fine hairs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the stems emerge from dark, moist soil inside a weathered clay pot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a curled tendril at the tip of one stem lean toward and gently brush against the stem of another?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene backlit by a soft, warm late afternoon glow creating a bokeh effect against the out-of-focus background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00606138538569212 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.256061553955078 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00606138538569212, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00606138538569212, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2846909761428833, + 0.04704888164997101, + 0.08925608545541763, + 0.04007895663380623, + 0.12524405121803284, + 0.04779389873147011, + 0.0968012735247612, + 0.07509221136569977, + 0.06152410805225372, + 0.13246957957744598 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00606138538569212 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a cinematic macro view focusing on the delicate, vibrant green stems of a young vine?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the stems slender, almost translucent, and covered in a dense layer of fine hairs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the stems emerge from dark, moist soil inside a weathered clay pot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a curled tendril at the tip of one stem lean toward and gently brush against the stem of another?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene backlit by a soft, warm late afternoon glow creating a bokeh effect against the out-of-focus background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04868793487548828 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486879348754883 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04868793487548828, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04868793487548828, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2084950953722, + 0.13573774695396423, + 0.12332671880722046, + 0.03956497460603714, + 0.07281744480133057, + 0.04006020724773407, + 0.13378757238388062, + 0.03169015422463417, + 0.04371483251452446, + 0.1708052158355713 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04868793487548828 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a cinematic macro view focusing on the delicate, vibrant green stems of a young vine?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the stems slender, almost translucent, and covered in a dense layer of fine hairs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the stems emerge from dark, moist soil inside a weathered clay pot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a curled tendril at the tip of one stem lean toward and gently brush against the stem of another?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene backlit by a soft, warm late afternoon glow creating a bokeh effect against the out-of-focus background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0028199690859764814 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877820014953613 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0028199690859764814, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0028199690859764814, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1884656548500061, + 0.1315324902534485, + 0.1495879739522934, + 0.05149534344673157, + 0.1408548504114151, + 0.056523650884628296, + 0.07088790088891983, + 0.0644497275352478, + 0.0665423646569252, + 0.07966002821922302 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0028199690859764814 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a cinematic macro view focusing on the delicate, vibrant green stems of a young vine?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the stems slender, almost translucent, and covered in a dense layer of fine hairs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the stems emerge from dark, moist soil inside a weathered clay pot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a curled tendril at the tip of one stem lean toward and gently brush against the stem of another?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene backlit by a soft, warm late afternoon glow creating a bokeh effect against the out-of-focus background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023283882066607475 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732839584350586 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023283882066607475, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023283882066607475, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18810990452766418, + 0.07593335211277008, + 0.07204598188400269, + 0.07072228938341141, + 0.08343174308538437, + 0.038401611149311066, + 0.22339807450771332, + 0.0445314384996891, + 0.12987728416919708, + 0.0735483467578888 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023283882066607475 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a cinematic macro view focusing on the delicate, vibrant green stems of a young vine?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the stems slender, almost translucent, and covered in a dense layer of fine hairs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the stems emerge from dark, moist soil inside a weathered clay pot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a curled tendril at the tip of one stem lean toward and gently brush against the stem of another?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene backlit by a soft, warm late afternoon glow creating a bokeh effect against the out-of-focus background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012535471469163895 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387535572052002 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012535471469163895, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012535471469163895, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.443716436624527, + 0.07079486548900604, + 0.052631281316280365, + 0.0532253198325634, + 0.07548341900110245, + 0.02828945405781269, + 0.12606137990951538, + 0.05598386749625206, + 0.04052489995956421, + 0.05328909307718277 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012535471469163895 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "cinematic macro shot, static and held at intimate eye level, focuses with razor-sharp clarity on the delicate, vibrant green stems of a young vine. The slender stems, almost translucent and covered in a dense layer of fine hairs, emerge from the dark, moist soil of a weathered clay pot. An unseen breeze causes the stems to sway slowly and gracefully, their movements subtle and deliberate. A curled, curious tendril at the tip of one stem leans toward the stem next to it, making soft, brief contact with the stem of another. They gently nudge and brush against each other, their delicate interaction appearing like a silent, choreographed conversation. The scene is bathed in a soft, warm late afternoon glow from a nearby window, backlighting the fine hairs on the stems and creating a beautiful bokeh effect against the out-of-focus background. This interplay of light, shadow, and slow motion creates an atmosphere of tranquility, contemplation, and deep calm, capturing a quiet moment of natural beauty.", + "seed": 1264, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_2/index_9738_seed_1264_dp_5_rank_10_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.029864274617284536, + "vlm_logprob": -0.029864274617284536, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.075, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.029864274617284536, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a cinematic macro view focusing on the delicate, vibrant green stems of a young vine?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the stems slender, almost translucent, and covered in a dense layer of fine hairs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the stems emerge from dark, moist soil inside a weathered clay pot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a curled tendril at the tip of one stem lean toward and gently brush against the stem of another?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene backlit by a soft, warm late afternoon glow creating a bokeh effect against the out-of-focus background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005684282630681992 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.7556843757629395 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005684282630681992, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005684282630681992, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15149520337581635, + 0.03961026668548584, + 0.05238045006990433, + 0.030561504885554314, + 0.18490596115589142, + 0.06654084473848343, + 0.06360884010791779, + 0.16166408360004425, + 0.10780707001686096, + 0.1414257287979126 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005684282630681992 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a cinematic macro view focusing on the delicate, vibrant green stems of a young vine?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the stems slender, almost translucent, and covered in a dense layer of fine hairs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the stems emerge from dark, moist soil inside a weathered clay pot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a curled tendril at the tip of one stem lean toward and gently brush against the stem of another?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene backlit by a soft, warm late afternoon glow creating a bokeh effect against the out-of-focus background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07004838436841965 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950483322143555 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07004838436841965, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07004838436841965, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1582845151424408, + 0.07783765345811844, + 0.08825893700122833, + 0.03622937202453613, + 0.13238029181957245, + 0.10955558717250824, + 0.08437968045473099, + 0.09163503348827362, + 0.0880194753408432, + 0.1334194839000702 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07004838436841965 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a cinematic macro view focusing on the delicate, vibrant green stems of a young vine?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the stems slender, almost translucent, and covered in a dense layer of fine hairs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the stems emerge from dark, moist soil inside a weathered clay pot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a curled tendril at the tip of one stem lean toward and gently brush against the stem of another?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene backlit by a soft, warm late afternoon glow creating a bokeh effect against the out-of-focus background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04866158962249756 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048661708831787 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04866158962249756, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04866158962249756, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20474715530872345, + 0.06637577712535858, + 0.050491634756326675, + 0.05517444387078285, + 0.1455010324716568, + 0.20232923328876495, + 0.08130739629268646, + 0.09757688641548157, + 0.030394595116376877, + 0.06610187888145447 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04866158962249756 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a cinematic macro view focusing on the delicate, vibrant green stems of a young vine?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the stems slender, almost translucent, and covered in a dense layer of fine hairs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the stems emerge from dark, moist soil inside a weathered clay pot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a curled tendril at the tip of one stem lean toward and gently brush against the stem of another?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene backlit by a soft, warm late afternoon glow creating a bokeh effect against the out-of-focus background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018191400915384293 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018191337585449 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018191400915384293, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018191400915384293, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07435352355241776, + 0.03167490288615227, + 0.030203120782971382, + 0.021240944042801857, + 0.047128189355134964, + 0.0998736321926117, + 0.05987772345542908, + 0.3580123782157898, + 0.1902371495962143, + 0.08739842474460602 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018191400915384293 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a cinematic macro view focusing on the delicate, vibrant green stems of a young vine?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the stems slender, almost translucent, and covered in a dense layer of fine hairs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the stems emerge from dark, moist soil inside a weathered clay pot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a curled tendril at the tip of one stem lean toward and gently brush against the stem of another?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene backlit by a soft, warm late afternoon glow creating a bokeh effect against the out-of-focus background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006735715549439192 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006735801696777 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006735715549439192, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006735715549439192, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05985347926616669, + 0.017438730224967003, + 0.023725837469100952, + 0.00988756213337183, + 0.05727655068039894, + 0.022605838254094124, + 0.1805322915315628, + 0.07866902649402618, + 0.040331508964300156, + 0.5096791982650757 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006735715549439192 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_3/index_tensor([9931, 9931])_group_3_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_3/index_tensor([9931, 9931])_group_3_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..e6e069f221c4e0e41ecbdab89bd7e18e47749e85 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_3/index_tensor([9931, 9931])_group_3_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "low, tracking shot hurtles forward along the centerline of a railway track at a dizzying pace. Under the bright, intense midday sun, the two parallel rails reflect a continuous, dazzling, and fleeting flash of light, their cold metallic texture contrasting sharply with the dark, weathered, and cracked wooden sleepers beneath. The camera's extreme closeness to the ground renders the rough texture and irregular shapes of each angular, gray ballast stone strikingly clear, as if frozen in time at high speed. Together with the rapidly passing sleepers, they create a powerful visual impact. The green vegetation and weeds on either side of the track are stretched into blurred, dynamic lines at the edges of the field of view, further intensifying the sense of unparalleled speed in the center of the frame. The entire scene is filled with high-contrast light and shadow and a mechanical, relentless kinetic energy, creating an intense and exhilarating immersive experience.", + "seed": 24863, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_3/index_9931_seed_24863_dp_6_rank_12_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.1883630182594061, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1883630182594061, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.75, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1883630182594061, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle tracking shot moving forward along the centerline of a railway track?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the parallel rails reflecting a continuous, dazzling flash of light under bright midday sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are dark, weathered, and cracked wooden sleepers visible beneath the rails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are angular, gray ballast stones visible with rough texture and irregular shapes due to the extreme closeness to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the green vegetation and weeds on either side of the track stretched into blurred, dynamic lines at the edges of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0201216172426939 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.2701215744018555 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0201216172426939, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0201216172426939, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21165794134140015, + 0.06843961775302887, + 0.07372237741947174, + 0.04134245216846466, + 0.127982035279274, + 0.06107570603489876, + 0.18572711944580078, + 0.1419992446899414, + 0.05429931730031967, + 0.03375425562262535 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0201216172426939 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle tracking shot moving forward along the centerline of a railway track?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the parallel rails reflecting a continuous, dazzling flash of light under bright midday sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are dark, weathered, and cracked wooden sleepers visible beneath the rails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are angular, gray ballast stones visible with rough texture and irregular shapes due to the extreme closeness to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the green vegetation and weeds on either side of the track stretched into blurred, dynamic lines at the edges of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8983019590377808 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5233019590377808 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.8983019590377808, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.8983019590377808, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.068215511739254, + 0.0411762036383152, + 0.02301095612347126, + 0.025562738999724388, + 0.02969573251903057, + 0.1089053601026535, + 0.06532074511051178, + 0.4837324917316437, + 0.03787298500537872, + 0.11650728434324265 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.8983019590377808 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle tracking shot moving forward along the centerline of a railway track?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the parallel rails reflecting a continuous, dazzling flash of light under bright midday sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are dark, weathered, and cracked wooden sleepers visible beneath the rails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are angular, gray ballast stones visible with rough texture and irregular shapes due to the extreme closeness to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the green vegetation and weeds on either side of the track stretched into blurred, dynamic lines at the edges of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004103930201381445 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504104137420654 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004103930201381445, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004103930201381445, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11172112077474594, + 0.047424402087926865, + 0.13219612836837769, + 0.04939443618059158, + 0.0690615326166153, + 0.04355078935623169, + 0.10756570100784302, + 0.24936677515506744, + 0.06483535468578339, + 0.1248837411403656 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 2, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004103930201381445 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle tracking shot moving forward along the centerline of a railway track?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the parallel rails reflecting a continuous, dazzling flash of light under bright midday sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are dark, weathered, and cracked wooden sleepers visible beneath the rails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are angular, gray ballast stones visible with rough texture and irregular shapes due to the extreme closeness to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the green vegetation and weeds on either side of the track stretched into blurred, dynamic lines at the edges of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006741635967046022 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006741523742676 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006741635967046022, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006741635967046022, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07079755514860153, + 0.0509655624628067, + 0.0669618621468544, + 0.07052701711654663, + 0.04288829118013382, + 0.09002113342285156, + 0.1673368364572525, + 0.17208532989025116, + 0.1161758154630661, + 0.15224061906337738 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006741635967046022 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle tracking shot moving forward along the centerline of a railway track?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the parallel rails reflecting a continuous, dazzling flash of light under bright midday sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are dark, weathered, and cracked wooden sleepers visible beneath the rails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are angular, gray ballast stones visible with rough texture and irregular shapes due to the extreme closeness to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the green vegetation and weeds on either side of the track stretched into blurred, dynamic lines at the edges of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012545948848128319 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387546062469482 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012545948848128319, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012545948848128319, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0733904018998146, + 0.056294068694114685, + 0.02574826031923294, + 0.06345560401678085, + 0.06671779602766037, + 0.13438016176223755, + 0.10150554776191711, + 0.2923336625099182, + 0.028474774211645126, + 0.15769973397254944 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012545948848128319 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low, tracking shot hurtles forward along the centerline of a railway track at a dizzying pace. Under the bright, intense midday sun, the two parallel rails reflect a continuous, dazzling, and fleeting flash of light, their cold metallic texture contrasting sharply with the dark, weathered, and cracked wooden sleepers beneath. The camera's extreme closeness to the ground renders the rough texture and irregular shapes of each angular, gray ballast stone strikingly clear, as if frozen in time at high speed. Together with the rapidly passing sleepers, they create a powerful visual impact. The green vegetation and weeds on either side of the track are stretched into blurred, dynamic lines at the edges of the field of view, further intensifying the sense of unparalleled speed in the center of the frame. The entire scene is filled with high-contrast light and shadow and a mechanical, relentless kinetic energy, creating an intense and exhilarating immersive experience.", + "seed": 24864, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_3/index_9931_seed_24864_dp_6_rank_12_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.23008852861821652, + "vlm_logprob": -0.23008852861821652, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.95, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.23008852861821652, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle tracking shot moving forward along the centerline of a railway track?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the parallel rails reflecting a continuous, dazzling flash of light under bright midday sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are dark, weathered, and cracked wooden sleepers visible beneath the rails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are angular, gray ballast stones visible with rough texture and irregular shapes due to the extreme closeness to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the green vegetation and weeds on either side of the track stretched into blurred, dynamic lines at the edges of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03828169032931328 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4132816791534424 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03828169032931328, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03828169032931328, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10029499232769012, + 0.029387112706899643, + 0.05693858861923218, + 0.09121157974004745, + 0.1022915467619896, + 0.08651673793792725, + 0.041115883737802505, + 0.08449850976467133, + 0.17253918945789337, + 0.23520582914352417 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03828169032931328 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle tracking shot moving forward along the centerline of a railway track?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the parallel rails reflecting a continuous, dazzling flash of light under bright midday sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are dark, weathered, and cracked wooden sleepers visible beneath the rails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are angular, gray ballast stones visible with rough texture and irregular shapes due to the extreme closeness to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the green vegetation and weeds on either side of the track stretched into blurred, dynamic lines at the edges of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.0539013147354126 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.428901344537735 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.0539013147354126, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.625, + "token_credit_reward": -1.0539013147354126, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10176895558834076, + 0.03256269916892052, + 0.060329191386699677, + 0.1802223026752472, + 0.08591301739215851, + 0.06441611796617508, + 0.023725716397166252, + 0.03893303498625755, + 0.3060145378112793, + 0.10611438751220703 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.0539013147354126 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle tracking shot moving forward along the centerline of a railway track?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the parallel rails reflecting a continuous, dazzling flash of light under bright midday sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are dark, weathered, and cracked wooden sleepers visible beneath the rails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are angular, gray ballast stones visible with rough texture and irregular shapes due to the extreme closeness to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the green vegetation and weeds on either side of the track stretched into blurred, dynamic lines at the edges of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029830489307641983 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298304557800293 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029830489307641983, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029830489307641983, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.051685549318790436, + 0.13082855939865112, + 0.0764981284737587, + 0.15972840785980225, + 0.2333463877439499, + 0.11033667623996735, + 0.07453455775976181, + 0.06286729127168655, + 0.07709279656410217, + 0.02308163233101368 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029830489307641983 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle tracking shot moving forward along the centerline of a railway track?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the parallel rails reflecting a continuous, dazzling flash of light under bright midday sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are dark, weathered, and cracked wooden sleepers visible beneath the rails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are angular, gray ballast stones visible with rough texture and irregular shapes due to the extreme closeness to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the green vegetation and weeds on either side of the track stretched into blurred, dynamic lines at the edges of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014216925017535686 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264216899871826 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014216925017535686, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014216925017535686, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04100045934319496, + 0.05954299867153168, + 0.06225445121526718, + 0.10107812285423279, + 0.12076897919178009, + 0.047975990921258926, + 0.019589748233556747, + 0.11897320300340652, + 0.3137859106063843, + 0.11503017693758011 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 4, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014216925017535686 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle tracking shot moving forward along the centerline of a railway track?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the parallel rails reflecting a continuous, dazzling flash of light under bright midday sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are dark, weathered, and cracked wooden sleepers visible beneath the rails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are angular, gray ballast stones visible with rough texture and irregular shapes due to the extreme closeness to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the green vegetation and weeds on either side of the track stretched into blurred, dynamic lines at the edges of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014212223701179028 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264212131500244 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014212223701179028, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014212223701179028, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2689403295516968, + 0.04033958539366722, + 0.06656411290168762, + 0.12529343366622925, + 0.08735670149326324, + 0.13668277859687805, + 0.0441528744995594, + 0.025908952578902245, + 0.15787343680858612, + 0.046887703239917755 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014212223701179028 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low, tracking shot hurtles forward along the centerline of a railway track at a dizzying pace. Under the bright, intense midday sun, the two parallel rails reflect a continuous, dazzling, and fleeting flash of light, their cold metallic texture contrasting sharply with the dark, weathered, and cracked wooden sleepers beneath. The camera's extreme closeness to the ground renders the rough texture and irregular shapes of each angular, gray ballast stone strikingly clear, as if frozen in time at high speed. Together with the rapidly passing sleepers, they create a powerful visual impact. The green vegetation and weeds on either side of the track are stretched into blurred, dynamic lines at the edges of the field of view, further intensifying the sense of unparalleled speed in the center of the frame. The entire scene is filled with high-contrast light and shadow and a mechanical, relentless kinetic energy, creating an intense and exhilarating immersive experience.", + "seed": 24865, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_3/index_9931_seed_24865_dp_7_rank_14_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.34907381031662227, + "vlm_logprob": -0.34907381031662227, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.425, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.34907381031662227, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle tracking shot moving forward along the centerline of a railway track?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the parallel rails reflecting a continuous, dazzling flash of light under bright midday sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are dark, weathered, and cracked wooden sleepers visible beneath the rails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are angular, gray ballast stones visible with rough texture and irregular shapes due to the extreme closeness to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the green vegetation and weeds on either side of the track stretched into blurred, dynamic lines at the edges of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007191959768533707 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.257192134857178 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007191959768533707, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007191959768533707, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10380672663450241, + 0.09297870844602585, + 0.11068779975175858, + 0.1172124445438385, + 0.04862360283732414, + 0.15315935015678406, + 0.13132460415363312, + 0.17349885404109955, + 0.023425225168466568, + 0.04528265818953514 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007191959768533707 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle tracking shot moving forward along the centerline of a railway track?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the parallel rails reflecting a continuous, dazzling flash of light under bright midday sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are dark, weathered, and cracked wooden sleepers visible beneath the rails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are angular, gray ballast stones visible with rough texture and irregular shapes due to the extreme closeness to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the green vegetation and weeds on either side of the track stretched into blurred, dynamic lines at the edges of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7015376091003418 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2015375941991806 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.7015376091003418, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -1.7015376091003418, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1440771073102951, + 0.2461058348417282, + 0.11320261657238007, + 0.23726850748062134, + 0.05315389484167099, + 0.03611576929688454, + 0.024309322237968445, + 0.02607610449194908, + 0.043280430138111115, + 0.0764104500412941 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.7015376091003418 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle tracking shot moving forward along the centerline of a railway track?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the parallel rails reflecting a continuous, dazzling flash of light under bright midday sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are dark, weathered, and cracked wooden sleepers visible beneath the rails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are angular, gray ballast stones visible with rough texture and irregular shapes due to the extreme closeness to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the green vegetation and weeds on either side of the track stretched into blurred, dynamic lines at the edges of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009797580540180206 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.6347975730896 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009797580540180206, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009797580540180206, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08809442073106766, + 0.07120702415704727, + 0.13230539858341217, + 0.2701856791973114, + 0.03254813328385353, + 0.2173091024160385, + 0.035305894911289215, + 0.0745789110660553, + 0.03122001886367798, + 0.04724539443850517 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 5, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009797580540180206 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle tracking shot moving forward along the centerline of a railway track?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the parallel rails reflecting a continuous, dazzling flash of light under bright midday sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are dark, weathered, and cracked wooden sleepers visible beneath the rails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are angular, gray ballast stones visible with rough texture and irregular shapes due to the extreme closeness to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the green vegetation and weeds on either side of the track stretched into blurred, dynamic lines at the edges of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018198424950242043 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018198490142822 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018198424950242043, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018198424950242043, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14895842969417572, + 0.06156281381845474, + 0.13760164380073547, + 0.25725898146629333, + 0.02968607284128666, + 0.049147654324769974, + 0.08600827306509018, + 0.13031572103500366, + 0.03800433501601219, + 0.061456117779016495 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018198424950242043 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle tracking shot moving forward along the centerline of a railway track?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the parallel rails reflecting a continuous, dazzling flash of light under bright midday sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are dark, weathered, and cracked wooden sleepers visible beneath the rails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are angular, gray ballast stones visible with rough texture and irregular shapes due to the extreme closeness to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the green vegetation and weeds on either side of the track stretched into blurred, dynamic lines at the edges of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008643477223813534 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758643627166748 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008643477223813534, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008643477223813534, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25676363706588745, + 0.1907472163438797, + 0.09517526626586914, + 0.04512988403439522, + 0.07598207890987396, + 0.08678223192691803, + 0.049374260008335114, + 0.08136919140815735, + 0.028485460206866264, + 0.09019080549478531 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008643477223813534 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low, tracking shot hurtles forward along the centerline of a railway track at a dizzying pace. Under the bright, intense midday sun, the two parallel rails reflect a continuous, dazzling, and fleeting flash of light, their cold metallic texture contrasting sharply with the dark, weathered, and cracked wooden sleepers beneath. The camera's extreme closeness to the ground renders the rough texture and irregular shapes of each angular, gray ballast stone strikingly clear, as if frozen in time at high speed. Together with the rapidly passing sleepers, they create a powerful visual impact. The green vegetation and weeds on either side of the track are stretched into blurred, dynamic lines at the edges of the field of view, further intensifying the sense of unparalleled speed in the center of the frame. The entire scene is filled with high-contrast light and shadow and a mechanical, relentless kinetic energy, creating an intense and exhilarating immersive experience.", + "seed": 24866, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_3/index_9931_seed_24866_dp_7_rank_14_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.06034782035276294, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06034782035276294, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.925, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06034782035276294, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle tracking shot moving forward along the centerline of a railway track?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the parallel rails reflecting a continuous, dazzling flash of light under bright midday sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are dark, weathered, and cracked wooden sleepers visible beneath the rails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are angular, gray ballast stones visible with rough texture and irregular shapes due to the extreme closeness to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the green vegetation and weeds on either side of the track stretched into blurred, dynamic lines at the edges of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020130613818764687 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.020130634307861 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020130613818764687, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020130613818764687, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13880811631679535, + 0.06248282268643379, + 0.06665486097335815, + 0.03547751158475876, + 0.036098502576351166, + 0.04010229930281639, + 0.15557552874088287, + 0.09778982400894165, + 0.15529027581214905, + 0.21172025799751282 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020130613818764687 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle tracking shot moving forward along the centerline of a railway track?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the parallel rails reflecting a continuous, dazzling flash of light under bright midday sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are dark, weathered, and cracked wooden sleepers visible beneath the rails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are angular, gray ballast stones visible with rough texture and irregular shapes due to the extreme closeness to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the green vegetation and weeds on either side of the track stretched into blurred, dynamic lines at the edges of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2521238923072815 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5021238327026367 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2521238923072815, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2521238923072815, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10376354306936264, + 0.06576226651668549, + 0.03650931641459465, + 0.022579655051231384, + 0.015243553556501865, + 0.19761431217193604, + 0.06636960804462433, + 0.07762930542230606, + 0.2479267567396164, + 0.16660170257091522 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2521238923072815 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle tracking shot moving forward along the centerline of a railway track?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the parallel rails reflecting a continuous, dazzling flash of light under bright midday sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are dark, weathered, and cracked wooden sleepers visible beneath the rails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are angular, gray ballast stones visible with rough texture and irregular shapes due to the extreme closeness to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the green vegetation and weeds on either side of the track stretched into blurred, dynamic lines at the edges of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016078924760222435 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141078948974609 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016078924760222435, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016078924760222435, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1422213762998581, + 0.08382228016853333, + 0.04894397407770157, + 0.12015429884195328, + 0.02359234355390072, + 0.01387112494558096, + 0.02275245450437069, + 0.2460012584924698, + 0.06673604249954224, + 0.23190489411354065 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016078924760222435 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle tracking shot moving forward along the centerline of a railway track?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the parallel rails reflecting a continuous, dazzling flash of light under bright midday sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are dark, weathered, and cracked wooden sleepers visible beneath the rails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are angular, gray ballast stones visible with rough texture and irregular shapes due to the extreme closeness to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the green vegetation and weeds on either side of the track stretched into blurred, dynamic lines at the edges of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0097875464707613 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634787559509277 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0097875464707613, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0097875464707613, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06578745692968369, + 0.0500657893717289, + 0.056968141347169876, + 0.02306125871837139, + 0.030523495748639107, + 0.01708531752228737, + 0.02972502075135708, + 0.023667722940444946, + 0.1185024082660675, + 0.5846133828163147 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0097875464707613 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle tracking shot moving forward along the centerline of a railway track?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the parallel rails reflecting a continuous, dazzling flash of light under bright midday sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are dark, weathered, and cracked wooden sleepers visible beneath the rails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are angular, gray ballast stones visible with rough texture and irregular shapes due to the extreme closeness to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the green vegetation and weeds on either side of the track stretched into blurred, dynamic lines at the edges of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003618124406784773 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628618240356445 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003618124406784773, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003618124406784773, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1091444343328476, + 0.06473028659820557, + 0.04388654604554176, + 0.02744448557496071, + 0.02721744030714035, + 0.0282133836299181, + 0.07708533108234406, + 0.1198858767747879, + 0.1910349726676941, + 0.3113572299480438 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003618124406784773 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_4/index_tensor([9592, 9592])_group_4_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_4/index_tensor([9592, 9592])_group_4_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..634ea44bd47a08beecddb8a8bc6dee0c90d2bbfd --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_4/index_tensor([9592, 9592])_group_4_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "static, slightly high-angled, medium close-up captures a neatly arranged, vertical stack of nested, clear glass bowls, placed next to a dark albizzia wood serving tray on a polished tabletop. The scene is bathed in the warm, soft glow of a realistic living room light, casting soft, shimmering highlights on the polished, curved glass surface and creating gentle shadows on the matte finish of the serving tray. A pair of hands enters the frame, one steadily supporting the stack while the other carefully grasps the rim of the topmost bowl. With graceful precision, the fingers lift the bowl, silently separating it from the others. The hand moves smoothly across the frame, the clear bowl catching and refracting the ambient light before deliberately placing it on the wooden tray with a soft, satisfying clink. This dynamic movement repeats in an orderly sequence until the final state shows all bowls separated from their stack and neatly and elegantly arranged in a row on the tray, ready for serving and creating a calm, focused atmosphere of preparation.", + "seed": 26659, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_4/index_9592_seed_26659_dp_8_rank_16_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.08521295208483934, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08521295208483934, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.525, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08521295208483934, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, slightly high-angled medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a living room with warm, soft lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are clear glass bowls stacked vertically on a dark albizzia wood serving tray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do hands enter the frame to lift the top bowl and place it on the tray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the bowls being separated and arranged in a neat row on the tray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012715808115899563 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.512715816497803 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012715808115899563, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012715808115899563, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.016046391800045967, + 0.001740113366395235, + 0.959231436252594, + 0.0033209470566362143, + 0.0014607412740588188, + 0.00527697941288352, + 0.0017756863962858915, + 0.004411780275404453, + 0.002412473550066352, + 0.004323443863540888 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012715808115899563 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, slightly high-angled medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a living room with warm, soft lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are clear glass bowls stacked vertically on a dark albizzia wood serving tray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do hands enter the frame to lift the top bowl and place it on the tray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the bowls being separated and arranged in a neat row on the tray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0550650954246521 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.930065155029297 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0550650954246521, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0550650954246521, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.047934625297784805, + 0.01894652657210827, + 0.8671066761016846, + 0.0069427937269210815, + 0.0037617601919919252, + 0.027636820450425148, + 0.004159078933298588, + 0.008614281192421913, + 0.007685121614485979, + 0.00721236364915967 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0550650954246521 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, slightly high-angled medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a living room with warm, soft lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are clear glass bowls stacked vertically on a dark albizzia wood serving tray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do hands enter the frame to lift the top bowl and place it on the tray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the bowls being separated and arranged in a neat row on the tray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006746964529156685 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006746768951416 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006746964529156685, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006746964529156685, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11606772243976593, + 0.018746040761470795, + 0.557136595249176, + 0.03942137956619263, + 0.0160905160009861, + 0.1512637883424759, + 0.015145167708396912, + 0.04685019701719284, + 0.01805878058075905, + 0.021219829097390175 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006746964529156685 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, slightly high-angled medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a living room with warm, soft lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are clear glass bowls stacked vertically on a dark albizzia wood serving tray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do hands enter the frame to lift the top bowl and place it on the tray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the bowls being separated and arranged in a neat row on the tray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03810235112905502 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288102388381958 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03810235112905502, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03810235112905502, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.029455292969942093, + 0.004620779305696487, + 0.9121158719062805, + 0.004516232758760452, + 0.0026451367884874344, + 0.02668865956366062, + 0.0032736945431679487, + 0.00924240704625845, + 0.003227737033739686, + 0.004214170854538679 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03810235112905502 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, slightly high-angled medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a living room with warm, soft lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are clear glass bowls stacked vertically on a dark albizzia wood serving tray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do hands enter the frame to lift the top bowl and place it on the tray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the bowls being separated and arranged in a neat row on the tray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.31343454122543335 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3134346008300781 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.31343454122543335, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.31343454122543335, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.004313461948186159, + 0.001584098907187581, + 0.9531551003456116, + 0.002647585468366742, + 0.001991197932511568, + 0.02174808271229267, + 0.001948345685377717, + 0.007288268767297268, + 0.0027844205033034086, + 0.002539389068260789 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.31343454122543335 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, slightly high-angled, medium close-up captures a neatly arranged, vertical stack of nested, clear glass bowls, placed next to a dark albizzia wood serving tray on a polished tabletop. The scene is bathed in the warm, soft glow of a realistic living room light, casting soft, shimmering highlights on the polished, curved glass surface and creating gentle shadows on the matte finish of the serving tray. A pair of hands enters the frame, one steadily supporting the stack while the other carefully grasps the rim of the topmost bowl. With graceful precision, the fingers lift the bowl, silently separating it from the others. The hand moves smoothly across the frame, the clear bowl catching and refracting the ambient light before deliberately placing it on the wooden tray with a soft, satisfying clink. This dynamic movement repeats in an orderly sequence until the final state shows all bowls separated from their stack and neatly and elegantly arranged in a row on the tray, ready for serving and creating a calm, focused atmosphere of preparation.", + "seed": 26660, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_4/index_9592_seed_26660_dp_8_rank_16_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.02464379584416747, + "vlm_logprob": -0.02464379584416747, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.275, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.02464379584416747, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, slightly high-angled medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a living room with warm, soft lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are clear glass bowls stacked vertically on a dark albizzia wood serving tray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do hands enter the frame to lift the top bowl and place it on the tray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the bowls being separated and arranged in a neat row on the tray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011183200404047966 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.261183261871338 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011183200404047966, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011183200404047966, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13709217309951782, + 0.11252918094396591, + 0.11679872870445251, + 0.04383992776274681, + 0.1200781911611557, + 0.07903196662664413, + 0.04651401564478874, + 0.09913552552461624, + 0.1457263082265854, + 0.09925398975610733 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011183200404047966 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, slightly high-angled medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a living room with warm, soft lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are clear glass bowls stacked vertically on a dark albizzia wood serving tray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do hands enter the frame to lift the top bowl and place it on the tray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the bowls being separated and arranged in a neat row on the tray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05504490062594414 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9300448894500732 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05504490062594414, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05504490062594414, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.231891930103302, + 0.11841180920600891, + 0.07359691709280014, + 0.04615730792284012, + 0.08429128676652908, + 0.07616204023361206, + 0.08290454000234604, + 0.16022181510925293, + 0.053732480853796005, + 0.0726298838853836 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05504490062594414 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, slightly high-angled medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a living room with warm, soft lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are clear glass bowls stacked vertically on a dark albizzia wood serving tray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do hands enter the frame to lift the top bowl and place it on the tray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the bowls being separated and arranged in a neat row on the tray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002830191981047392 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.8778300285339355 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002830191981047392, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002830191981047392, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1331479251384735, + 0.11357782036066055, + 0.269480437040329, + 0.1307222545146942, + 0.0718432292342186, + 0.03728128597140312, + 0.0655720978975296, + 0.07948841154575348, + 0.043332602828741074, + 0.05555390194058418 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002830191981047392 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, slightly high-angled medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a living room with warm, soft lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are clear glass bowls stacked vertically on a dark albizzia wood serving tray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do hands enter the frame to lift the top bowl and place it on the tray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the bowls being separated and arranged in a neat row on the tray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016076697036623955 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141076564788818 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016076697036623955, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016076697036623955, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05488692224025726, + 0.09371701627969742, + 0.07308157533407211, + 0.02435557171702385, + 0.0440535768866539, + 0.030852578580379486, + 0.03217663988471031, + 0.07485132664442062, + 0.5278546214103699, + 0.04417009651660919 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016076697036623955 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, slightly high-angled medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a living room with warm, soft lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are clear glass bowls stacked vertically on a dark albizzia wood serving tray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do hands enter the frame to lift the top bowl and place it on the tray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the bowls being separated and arranged in a neat row on the tray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.038083989173173904 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288084030151367 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.038083989173173904, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.038083989173173904, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12341494858264923, + 0.14208173751831055, + 0.10532853752374649, + 0.1740577667951584, + 0.06891720741987228, + 0.048024654388427734, + 0.025379331782460213, + 0.049343209713697433, + 0.1390470266342163, + 0.12440558522939682 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.038083989173173904 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, slightly high-angled, medium close-up captures a neatly arranged, vertical stack of nested, clear glass bowls, placed next to a dark albizzia wood serving tray on a polished tabletop. The scene is bathed in the warm, soft glow of a realistic living room light, casting soft, shimmering highlights on the polished, curved glass surface and creating gentle shadows on the matte finish of the serving tray. A pair of hands enters the frame, one steadily supporting the stack while the other carefully grasps the rim of the topmost bowl. With graceful precision, the fingers lift the bowl, silently separating it from the others. The hand moves smoothly across the frame, the clear bowl catching and refracting the ambient light before deliberately placing it on the wooden tray with a soft, satisfying clink. This dynamic movement repeats in an orderly sequence until the final state shows all bowls separated from their stack and neatly and elegantly arranged in a row on the tray, ready for serving and creating a calm, focused atmosphere of preparation.", + "seed": 26661, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_4/index_9592_seed_26661_dp_9_rank_18_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.02475280882790685, + "vlm_logprob": -0.02475280882790685, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.25, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.02475280882790685, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, slightly high-angled medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a living room with warm, soft lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are clear glass bowls stacked vertically on a dark albizzia wood serving tray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do hands enter the frame to lift the top bowl and place it on the tray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the bowls being separated and arranged in a neat row on the tray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.017780669033527374 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.017780780792236 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.017780669033527374, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.017780669033527374, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09034597873687744, + 0.11935919523239136, + 0.05186545103788376, + 0.08286211639642715, + 0.08558543026447296, + 0.10527394711971283, + 0.15522567927837372, + 0.1256793886423111, + 0.0980045273900032, + 0.08579832315444946 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.017780669033527374 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, slightly high-angled medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a living room with warm, soft lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are clear glass bowls stacked vertically on a dark albizzia wood serving tray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do hands enter the frame to lift the top bowl and place it on the tray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the bowls being separated and arranged in a neat row on the tray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07013940066099167 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6951394081115723 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07013940066099167, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07013940066099167, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16096529364585876, + 0.0644436776638031, + 0.03547293320298195, + 0.12064400315284729, + 0.10365897417068481, + 0.08729906380176544, + 0.04891326650977135, + 0.1265755593776703, + 0.1261155903339386, + 0.12591156363487244 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07013940066099167 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, slightly high-angled medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a living room with warm, soft lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are clear glass bowls stacked vertically on a dark albizzia wood serving tray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do hands enter the frame to lift the top bowl and place it on the tray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the bowls being separated and arranged in a neat row on the tray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007638768292963505 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882638931274414 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007638768292963505, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007638768292963505, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24404719471931458, + 0.03688346967101097, + 0.08506284654140472, + 0.08805347234010696, + 0.07852984964847565, + 0.03943571075797081, + 0.04941301792860031, + 0.1740056723356247, + 0.08692547678947449, + 0.11764327436685562 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007638768292963505 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, slightly high-angled medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a living room with warm, soft lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are clear glass bowls stacked vertically on a dark albizzia wood serving tray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do hands enter the frame to lift the top bowl and place it on the tray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the bowls being separated and arranged in a neat row on the tray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007630723994225264 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882630825042725 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007630723994225264, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007630723994225264, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1543159931898117, + 0.06365695595741272, + 0.04627566412091255, + 0.05303818732500076, + 0.08822119981050491, + 0.15858574211597443, + 0.15109433233737946, + 0.15583151578903198, + 0.09140310436487198, + 0.03757728636264801 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007630723994225264 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, slightly high-angled medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a living room with warm, soft lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are clear glass bowls stacked vertically on a dark albizzia wood serving tray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do hands enter the frame to lift the top bowl and place it on the tray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the bowls being separated and arranged in a neat row on the tray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020574482157826424 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955745697021484 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020574482157826424, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020574482157826424, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0656227096915245, + 0.062062449753284454, + 0.05924912169575691, + 0.07073918730020523, + 0.13116750121116638, + 0.08308028429746628, + 0.04842625558376312, + 0.20273643732070923, + 0.22326256334781647, + 0.05365355685353279 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020574482157826424 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, slightly high-angled, medium close-up captures a neatly arranged, vertical stack of nested, clear glass bowls, placed next to a dark albizzia wood serving tray on a polished tabletop. The scene is bathed in the warm, soft glow of a realistic living room light, casting soft, shimmering highlights on the polished, curved glass surface and creating gentle shadows on the matte finish of the serving tray. A pair of hands enters the frame, one steadily supporting the stack while the other carefully grasps the rim of the topmost bowl. With graceful precision, the fingers lift the bowl, silently separating it from the others. The hand moves smoothly across the frame, the clear bowl catching and refracting the ambient light before deliberately placing it on the wooden tray with a soft, satisfying clink. This dynamic movement repeats in an orderly sequence until the final state shows all bowls separated from their stack and neatly and elegantly arranged in a row on the tray, ready for serving and creating a calm, focused atmosphere of preparation.", + "seed": 26662, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_4/index_9592_seed_26662_dp_9_rank_18_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.0439198057167232, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0439198057167232, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.75, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0439198057167232, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, slightly high-angled medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a living room with warm, soft lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are clear glass bowls stacked vertically on a dark albizzia wood serving tray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do hands enter the frame to lift the top bowl and place it on the tray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the bowls being separated and arranged in a neat row on the tray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011978480033576488 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.261978626251221 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011978480033576488, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011978480033576488, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1524592787027359, + 0.10895369946956635, + 0.045263562351465225, + 0.026274628937244415, + 0.060660120099782944, + 0.071562260389328, + 0.13762135803699493, + 0.07190582156181335, + 0.16566969454288483, + 0.15962962806224823 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011978480033576488 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, slightly high-angled medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a living room with warm, soft lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are clear glass bowls stacked vertically on a dark albizzia wood serving tray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do hands enter the frame to lift the top bowl and place it on the tray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the bowls being separated and arranged in a neat row on the tray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.055027298629283905 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9300272464752197 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.055027298629283905, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.055027298629283905, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12891767919063568, + 0.08888960629701614, + 0.03372073546051979, + 0.05844524875283241, + 0.02025182731449604, + 0.052755217999219894, + 0.09796851873397827, + 0.0453004390001297, + 0.34173136949539185, + 0.13201938569545746 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.055027298629283905 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, slightly high-angled medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a living room with warm, soft lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are clear glass bowls stacked vertically on a dark albizzia wood serving tray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do hands enter the frame to lift the top bowl and place it on the tray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the bowls being separated and arranged in a neat row on the tray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005962679628282785 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.13096284866333 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005962679628282785, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005962679628282785, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09216353297233582, + 0.08394169062376022, + 0.06294786185026169, + 0.09591281414031982, + 0.031889963895082474, + 0.12306950241327286, + 0.12949810922145844, + 0.11100460588932037, + 0.09585379809141159, + 0.17371821403503418 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005962679628282785 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, slightly high-angled medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a living room with warm, soft lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are clear glass bowls stacked vertically on a dark albizzia wood serving tray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do hands enter the frame to lift the top bowl and place it on the tray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the bowls being separated and arranged in a neat row on the tray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.033709511160850525 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4087095260620117 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.033709511160850525, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.033709511160850525, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08112192153930664, + 0.07227186113595963, + 0.06879033893346786, + 0.07397104799747467, + 0.022844700142741203, + 0.07322075217962265, + 0.14792239665985107, + 0.1477096676826477, + 0.11345052719116211, + 0.1986967921257019 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.033709511160850525 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, slightly high-angled medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a living room with warm, soft lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are clear glass bowls stacked vertically on a dark albizzia wood serving tray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do hands enter the frame to lift the top bowl and place it on the tray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the bowls being separated and arranged in a neat row on the tray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11292105913162231 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2379209995269775 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11292105913162231, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11292105913162231, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.055591482669115067, + 0.1402779221534729, + 0.030810773372650146, + 0.0662987232208252, + 0.04902719706296921, + 0.11601287126541138, + 0.09531794488430023, + 0.10490518808364868, + 0.1090627908706665, + 0.23269511759281158 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11292105913162231 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_5/index_tensor([2679, 2679])_group_5_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_5/index_tensor([2679, 2679])_group_5_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..f0a5def4daf72b9391086d7db6a4f28d360acf96 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_5/index_tensor([2679, 2679])_group_5_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "precisely synchronized four-screen composition, with cinematic high-definition quality, freezes the pinnacle moments of four Olympic sports in a single instant. In the upper left quadrant, a sideways, medium-shot slow-motion shot captures a female diver, her raven hair tightly tied back, her body curled in a perfect tuck position, silently plunging into the deep blue waters of the Olympic pool. A cloud of white bubbles explodes beneath her, almost without a splash. Simultaneously, in the upper right quadrant, a powerful overhead shot focuses on a muscular gymnast, who leaps powerfully from the apparatus, his body tensed in the air, executing a complex spin. His face is etched with intense concentration, his background ablaze with lights and a cheering crowd blurred into a swirl of color. In the lower left quadrant, a high-speed side-on medium shot freezes a female sprinter with blonde hair in a ponytail. She bursts from the starting line with explosive force, her powerful leg muscles contracting instantly, propelling her body forward. The bright red track stretches out behind her, her expression one of pure, reckless determination. Finally, in the lower right quadrant, an extreme close-up focuses on the face of an archer, his eyes narrowed, a bead of sweat on his temple. The moment his fingers release the bowstring, the arrow scatters in a swift, shadowy flash. All four scenes are illuminated by bright stadium lighting, yet their individual tones—the azure blue of the water, the vibrant colors of the gymnastics uniforms, the fiery red of the track, the emerald green of the grass—combine to create a visually rich image, seamlessly blending the shared intensity of the athletes' faces with the synchronized excitement of a global audience into an epic canvas of power and glory.", + "seed": 3181, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_5/index_2679_seed_3181_dp_10_rank_20_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.03637484535574913, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03637484535574913, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.5249999523162843, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03637484535574913, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video composed of a four-screen layout with scenes in the upper left, upper right, lower left, and lower right quadrants?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the upper left quadrant show a female diver with raven hair in a tuck position plunging into blue water with white bubbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the upper right quadrant show a muscular male gymnast performing a complex spin with a blurred crowd and lights in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lower left quadrant show a female sprinter with blonde hair in a ponytail bursting from a bright red track?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the lower right quadrant show an extreme close-up of a male archer releasing an arrow with a shadowy flash?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01277630589902401 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.3877763748168945 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01277630589902401, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01277630589902401, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16860681772232056, + 0.06581919640302658, + 0.20390835404396057, + 0.0542793907225132, + 0.12676872313022614, + 0.10719862580299377, + 0.08801223337650299, + 0.08165790885686874, + 0.05453554913401604, + 0.049213290214538574 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01277630589902401 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video composed of a four-screen layout with scenes in the upper left, upper right, lower left, and lower right quadrants?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the upper left quadrant show a female diver with raven hair in a tuck position plunging into blue water with white bubbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the upper right quadrant show a muscular male gymnast performing a complex spin with a blurred crowd and lights in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lower left quadrant show a female sprinter with blonde hair in a ponytail bursting from a bright red track?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the lower right quadrant show an extreme close-up of a male archer releasing an arrow with a shadowy flash?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01819819025695324 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018198013305664 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01819819025695324, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01819819025695324, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1811942309141159, + 0.06799384206533432, + 0.053836509585380554, + 0.10877851396799088, + 0.090823233127594, + 0.07674319297075272, + 0.18151745200157166, + 0.08526167273521423, + 0.08812298625707626, + 0.06572834402322769 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01819819025695324 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video composed of a four-screen layout with scenes in the upper left, upper right, lower left, and lower right quadrants?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the upper left quadrant show a female diver with raven hair in a tuck position plunging into blue water with white bubbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the upper right quadrant show a muscular male gymnast performing a complex spin with a blurred crowd and lights in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lower left quadrant show a female sprinter with blonde hair in a ponytail bursting from a bright red track?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the lower right quadrant show an extreme close-up of a male archer releasing an arrow with a shadowy flash?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02328411489725113 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732841968536377 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02328411489725113, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02328411489725113, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20171085000038147, + 0.10380616784095764, + 0.09933261573314667, + 0.0354202538728714, + 0.12307009100914001, + 0.07935759425163269, + 0.07009858638048172, + 0.10129296034574509, + 0.09897816926240921, + 0.0869327113032341 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02328411489725113 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video composed of a four-screen layout with scenes in the upper left, upper right, lower left, and lower right quadrants?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the upper left quadrant show a female diver with raven hair in a tuck position plunging into blue water with white bubbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the upper right quadrant show a muscular male gymnast performing a complex spin with a blurred crowd and lights in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lower left quadrant show a female sprinter with blonde hair in a ponytail bursting from a bright red track?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the lower right quadrant show an extreme close-up of a male archer releasing an arrow with a shadowy flash?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04864490032196045 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.04864501953125 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04864490032196045, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04864490032196045, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09783229231834412, + 0.027284780517220497, + 0.26731011271476746, + 0.046985261142253876, + 0.06967835873365402, + 0.07242712378501892, + 0.1801302433013916, + 0.1024361401796341, + 0.10207878798246384, + 0.033836930990219116 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04864490032196045 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video composed of a four-screen layout with scenes in the upper left, upper right, lower left, and lower right quadrants?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the upper left quadrant show a female diver with raven hair in a tuck position plunging into blue water with white bubbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the upper right quadrant show a muscular male gymnast performing a complex spin with a blurred crowd and lights in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lower left quadrant show a female sprinter with blonde hair in a ponytail bursting from a bright red track?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the lower right quadrant show an extreme close-up of a male archer releasing an arrow with a shadowy flash?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07897071540355682 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5789706707000732 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07897071540355682, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07897071540355682, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1555347889661789, + 0.025986861437559128, + 0.07322734594345093, + 0.030028624460101128, + 0.15611600875854492, + 0.09504196047782898, + 0.13039833307266235, + 0.09554462134838104, + 0.05333814024925232, + 0.18478335440158844 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07897071540355682 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "precisely synchronized four-screen composition, with cinematic high-definition quality, freezes the pinnacle moments of four Olympic sports in a single instant. In the upper left quadrant, a sideways, medium-shot slow-motion shot captures a female diver, her raven hair tightly tied back, her body curled in a perfect tuck position, silently plunging into the deep blue waters of the Olympic pool. A cloud of white bubbles explodes beneath her, almost without a splash. Simultaneously, in the upper right quadrant, a powerful overhead shot focuses on a muscular gymnast, who leaps powerfully from the apparatus, his body tensed in the air, executing a complex spin. His face is etched with intense concentration, his background ablaze with lights and a cheering crowd blurred into a swirl of color. In the lower left quadrant, a high-speed side-on medium shot freezes a female sprinter with blonde hair in a ponytail. She bursts from the starting line with explosive force, her powerful leg muscles contracting instantly, propelling her body forward. The bright red track stretches out behind her, her expression one of pure, reckless determination. Finally, in the lower right quadrant, an extreme close-up focuses on the face of an archer, his eyes narrowed, a bead of sweat on his temple. The moment his fingers release the bowstring, the arrow scatters in a swift, shadowy flash. All four scenes are illuminated by bright stadium lighting, yet their individual tones—the azure blue of the water, the vibrant colors of the gymnastics uniforms, the fiery red of the track, the emerald green of the grass—combine to create a visually rich image, seamlessly blending the shared intensity of the athletes' faces with the synchronized excitement of a global audience into an epic canvas of power and glory.", + "seed": 3182, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_5/index_2679_seed_3182_dp_10_rank_20_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.036874737590551376, + "vlm_logprob": -0.036874737590551376, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.55, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.036874737590551376, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video composed of a four-screen layout with scenes in the upper left, upper right, lower left, and lower right quadrants?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the upper left quadrant show a female diver with raven hair in a tuck position plunging into blue water with white bubbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the upper right quadrant show a muscular male gymnast performing a complex spin with a blurred crowd and lights in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lower left quadrant show a female sprinter with blonde hair in a ponytail bursting from a bright red track?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the lower right quadrant show an extreme close-up of a male archer releasing an arrow with a shadowy flash?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009999774396419525 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634999752044678 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009999774396419525, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009999774396419525, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1884722262620926, + 0.07477223128080368, + 0.016897760331630707, + 0.03914196789264679, + 0.07619466632604599, + 0.2926674783229828, + 0.08583288639783859, + 0.07296434789896011, + 0.052912671118974686, + 0.10014376044273376 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009999774396419525 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video composed of a four-screen layout with scenes in the upper left, upper right, lower left, and lower right quadrants?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the upper left quadrant show a female diver with raven hair in a tuck position plunging into blue water with white bubbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the upper right quadrant show a muscular male gymnast performing a complex spin with a blurred crowd and lights in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lower left quadrant show a female sprinter with blonde hair in a ponytail bursting from a bright red track?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the lower right quadrant show an extreme close-up of a male archer releasing an arrow with a shadowy flash?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03812839835882187 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.28812837600708 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03812839835882187, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03812839835882187, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2572145164012909, + 0.05538346245884895, + 0.08760026842355728, + 0.06416375935077667, + 0.046489130705595016, + 0.18187114596366882, + 0.047161273658275604, + 0.05003836750984192, + 0.04370814189314842, + 0.16636991500854492 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03812839835882187 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video composed of a four-screen layout with scenes in the upper left, upper right, lower left, and lower right quadrants?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the upper left quadrant show a female diver with raven hair in a tuck position plunging into blue water with white bubbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the upper right quadrant show a muscular male gymnast performing a complex spin with a blurred crowd and lights in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lower left quadrant show a female sprinter with blonde hair in a ponytail bursting from a bright red track?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the lower right quadrant show an extreme close-up of a male archer releasing an arrow with a shadowy flash?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07898878306150436 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.578988790512085 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07898878306150436, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07898878306150436, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18305189907550812, + 0.09195868670940399, + 0.08016876876354218, + 0.05124300345778465, + 0.030243027955293655, + 0.11689116060733795, + 0.09464345872402191, + 0.09010015428066254, + 0.05231708660721779, + 0.20938275754451752 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07898878306150436 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video composed of a four-screen layout with scenes in the upper left, upper right, lower left, and lower right quadrants?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the upper left quadrant show a female diver with raven hair in a tuck position plunging into blue water with white bubbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the upper right quadrant show a muscular male gymnast performing a complex spin with a blurred crowd and lights in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lower left quadrant show a female sprinter with blonde hair in a ponytail bursting from a bright red track?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the lower right quadrant show an extreme close-up of a male archer releasing an arrow with a shadowy flash?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.043058376759290695 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168058395385742 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.043058376759290695, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.043058376759290695, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23527425527572632, + 0.04970668628811836, + 0.024429896846413612, + 0.030235081911087036, + 0.04145628958940506, + 0.035948917269706726, + 0.0434386283159256, + 0.05546339973807335, + 0.050296563655138016, + 0.4337502419948578 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.043058376759290695 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video composed of a four-screen layout with scenes in the upper left, upper right, lower left, and lower right quadrants?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the upper left quadrant show a female diver with raven hair in a tuck position plunging into blue water with white bubbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the upper right quadrant show a muscular male gymnast performing a complex spin with a blurred crowd and lights in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lower left quadrant show a female sprinter with blonde hair in a ponytail bursting from a bright red track?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the lower right quadrant show an extreme close-up of a male archer releasing an arrow with a shadowy flash?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014198355376720428 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264198303222656 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014198355376720428, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014198355376720428, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08889107406139374, + 0.07312726229429245, + 0.10251201689243317, + 0.08662331849336624, + 0.026323409751057625, + 0.03652144595980644, + 0.12387681752443314, + 0.14413931965827942, + 0.05732009932398796, + 0.2606651782989502 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014198355376720428 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "precisely synchronized four-screen composition, with cinematic high-definition quality, freezes the pinnacle moments of four Olympic sports in a single instant. In the upper left quadrant, a sideways, medium-shot slow-motion shot captures a female diver, her raven hair tightly tied back, her body curled in a perfect tuck position, silently plunging into the deep blue waters of the Olympic pool. A cloud of white bubbles explodes beneath her, almost without a splash. Simultaneously, in the upper right quadrant, a powerful overhead shot focuses on a muscular gymnast, who leaps powerfully from the apparatus, his body tensed in the air, executing a complex spin. His face is etched with intense concentration, his background ablaze with lights and a cheering crowd blurred into a swirl of color. In the lower left quadrant, a high-speed side-on medium shot freezes a female sprinter with blonde hair in a ponytail. She bursts from the starting line with explosive force, her powerful leg muscles contracting instantly, propelling her body forward. The bright red track stretches out behind her, her expression one of pure, reckless determination. Finally, in the lower right quadrant, an extreme close-up focuses on the face of an archer, his eyes narrowed, a bead of sweat on his temple. The moment his fingers release the bowstring, the arrow scatters in a swift, shadowy flash. All four scenes are illuminated by bright stadium lighting, yet their individual tones—the azure blue of the water, the vibrant colors of the gymnastics uniforms, the fiery red of the track, the emerald green of the grass—combine to create a visually rich image, seamlessly blending the shared intensity of the athletes' faces with the synchronized excitement of a global audience into an epic canvas of power and glory.", + "seed": 3183, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_5/index_2679_seed_3183_dp_11_rank_22_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.0275976138189435, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0275976138189435, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.9, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0275976138189435, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video composed of a four-screen layout with scenes in the upper left, upper right, lower left, and lower right quadrants?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the upper left quadrant show a female diver with raven hair in a tuck position plunging into blue water with white bubbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the upper right quadrant show a muscular male gymnast performing a complex spin with a blurred crowd and lights in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lower left quadrant show a female sprinter with blonde hair in a ponytail bursting from a bright red track?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the lower right quadrant show an extreme close-up of a male archer releasing an arrow with a shadowy flash?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0029463237151503563 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877946376800537 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0029463237151503563, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0029463237151503563, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18161654472351074, + 0.0934276431798935, + 0.15891101956367493, + 0.23286211490631104, + 0.0381779707968235, + 0.03435477986931801, + 0.0583210214972496, + 0.08423517644405365, + 0.052289996296167374, + 0.06580375134944916 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0029463237151503563 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video composed of a four-screen layout with scenes in the upper left, upper right, lower left, and lower right quadrants?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the upper left quadrant show a female diver with raven hair in a tuck position plunging into blue water with white bubbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the upper right quadrant show a muscular male gymnast performing a complex spin with a blurred crowd and lights in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lower left quadrant show a female sprinter with blonde hair in a ponytail bursting from a bright red track?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the lower right quadrant show an extreme close-up of a male archer releasing an arrow with a shadowy flash?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026359546929597855 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513595581054688 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026359546929597855, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026359546929597855, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3130994141101837, + 0.13499212265014648, + 0.1050717830657959, + 0.12676557898521423, + 0.04386759549379349, + 0.07051632553339005, + 0.05851516127586365, + 0.05001985654234886, + 0.05658411234617233, + 0.04056800901889801 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026359546929597855 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video composed of a four-screen layout with scenes in the upper left, upper right, lower left, and lower right quadrants?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the upper left quadrant show a female diver with raven hair in a tuck position plunging into blue water with white bubbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the upper right quadrant show a muscular male gymnast performing a complex spin with a blurred crowd and lights in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lower left quadrant show a female sprinter with blonde hair in a ponytail bursting from a bright red track?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the lower right quadrant show an extreme close-up of a male archer releasing an arrow with a shadowy flash?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02634306065738201 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513431072235107 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02634306065738201, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02634306065738201, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2841189503669739, + 0.08931808173656464, + 0.17570282518863678, + 0.03362356498837471, + 0.0367753766477108, + 0.07773440331220627, + 0.04721008986234665, + 0.08107572793960571, + 0.12421848624944687, + 0.05022247135639191 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02634306065738201 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video composed of a four-screen layout with scenes in the upper left, upper right, lower left, and lower right quadrants?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the upper left quadrant show a female diver with raven hair in a tuck position plunging into blue water with white bubbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the upper right quadrant show a muscular male gymnast performing a complex spin with a blurred crowd and lights in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lower left quadrant show a female sprinter with blonde hair in a ponytail bursting from a bright red track?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the lower right quadrant show an extreme close-up of a male archer releasing an arrow with a shadowy flash?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03369026258587837 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4086902141571045 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03369026258587837, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03369026258587837, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13487254083156586, + 0.07112763077020645, + 0.15742819011211395, + 0.08555509150028229, + 0.04093234986066818, + 0.10167569667100906, + 0.11716204881668091, + 0.08042343705892563, + 0.1474558264017105, + 0.06336709856987 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03369026258587837 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video composed of a four-screen layout with scenes in the upper left, upper right, lower left, and lower right quadrants?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the upper left quadrant show a female diver with raven hair in a tuck position plunging into blue water with white bubbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the upper right quadrant show a muscular male gymnast performing a complex spin with a blurred crowd and lights in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lower left quadrant show a female sprinter with blonde hair in a ponytail bursting from a bright red track?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the lower right quadrant show an extreme close-up of a male archer releasing an arrow with a shadowy flash?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04864887520670891 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486488342285156 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04864887520670891, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04864887520670891, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11734198778867722, + 0.12403924018144608, + 0.09952009469270706, + 0.1259034126996994, + 0.049543533474206924, + 0.05255147069692612, + 0.12085609138011932, + 0.09615303575992584, + 0.10493507981300354, + 0.109156034886837 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04864887520670891 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "precisely synchronized four-screen composition, with cinematic high-definition quality, freezes the pinnacle moments of four Olympic sports in a single instant. In the upper left quadrant, a sideways, medium-shot slow-motion shot captures a female diver, her raven hair tightly tied back, her body curled in a perfect tuck position, silently plunging into the deep blue waters of the Olympic pool. A cloud of white bubbles explodes beneath her, almost without a splash. Simultaneously, in the upper right quadrant, a powerful overhead shot focuses on a muscular gymnast, who leaps powerfully from the apparatus, his body tensed in the air, executing a complex spin. His face is etched with intense concentration, his background ablaze with lights and a cheering crowd blurred into a swirl of color. In the lower left quadrant, a high-speed side-on medium shot freezes a female sprinter with blonde hair in a ponytail. She bursts from the starting line with explosive force, her powerful leg muscles contracting instantly, propelling her body forward. The bright red track stretches out behind her, her expression one of pure, reckless determination. Finally, in the lower right quadrant, an extreme close-up focuses on the face of an archer, his eyes narrowed, a bead of sweat on his temple. The moment his fingers release the bowstring, the arrow scatters in a swift, shadowy flash. All four scenes are illuminated by bright stadium lighting, yet their individual tones—the azure blue of the water, the vibrant colors of the gymnastics uniforms, the fiery red of the track, the emerald green of the grass—combine to create a visually rich image, seamlessly blending the shared intensity of the athletes' faces with the synchronized excitement of a global audience into an epic canvas of power and glory.", + "seed": 3184, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_5/index_2679_seed_3184_dp_11_rank_22_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.012696927646175027, + "vlm_logprob": -0.012696927646175027, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.575, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.012696927646175027, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video composed of a four-screen layout with scenes in the upper left, upper right, lower left, and lower right quadrants?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the upper left quadrant show a female diver with raven hair in a tuck position plunging into blue water with white bubbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the upper right quadrant show a muscular male gymnast performing a complex spin with a blurred crowd and lights in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lower left quadrant show a female sprinter with blonde hair in a ponytail bursting from a bright red track?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the lower right quadrant show an extreme close-up of a male archer releasing an arrow with a shadowy flash?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0033789940644055605 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753378868103027 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0033789940644055605, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0033789940644055605, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14229734241962433, + 0.07185298949480057, + 0.03367217630147934, + 0.08931754529476166, + 0.06491044163703918, + 0.05148307979106903, + 0.06246121600270271, + 0.07206464558839798, + 0.07130134105682373, + 0.34063920378685 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0033789940644055605 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video composed of a four-screen layout with scenes in the upper left, upper right, lower left, and lower right quadrants?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the upper left quadrant show a female diver with raven hair in a tuck position plunging into blue water with white bubbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the upper right quadrant show a muscular male gymnast performing a complex spin with a blurred crowd and lights in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lower left quadrant show a female sprinter with blonde hair in a ponytail bursting from a bright red track?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the lower right quadrant show an extreme close-up of a male archer releasing an arrow with a shadowy flash?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009797343984246254 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.6347975730896 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009797343984246254, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009797343984246254, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18018940091133118, + 0.11618862301111221, + 0.0881538987159729, + 0.06547681242227554, + 0.0493629015982151, + 0.050875503569841385, + 0.14911454916000366, + 0.06987792253494263, + 0.13802792131900787, + 0.09273254871368408 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009797343984246254 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video composed of a four-screen layout with scenes in the upper left, upper right, lower left, and lower right quadrants?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the upper left quadrant show a female diver with raven hair in a tuck position plunging into blue water with white bubbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the upper right quadrant show a muscular male gymnast performing a complex spin with a blurred crowd and lights in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lower left quadrant show a female sprinter with blonde hair in a ponytail bursting from a bright red track?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the lower right quadrant show an extreme close-up of a male archer releasing an arrow with a shadowy flash?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00977916456758976 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.63477897644043 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00977916456758976, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00977916456758976, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2016955465078354, + 0.0780545175075531, + 0.13741274178028107, + 0.05992073565721512, + 0.07093122601509094, + 0.09704527258872986, + 0.05515611544251442, + 0.0628226101398468, + 0.12299755960702896, + 0.11396365612745285 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00977916456758976 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video composed of a four-screen layout with scenes in the upper left, upper right, lower left, and lower right quadrants?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the upper left quadrant show a female diver with raven hair in a tuck position plunging into blue water with white bubbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the upper right quadrant show a muscular male gymnast performing a complex spin with a blurred crowd and lights in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lower left quadrant show a female sprinter with blonde hair in a ponytail bursting from a bright red track?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the lower right quadrant show an extreme close-up of a male archer releasing an arrow with a shadowy flash?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026338184252381325 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513381004333496 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026338184252381325, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026338184252381325, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.085905522108078, + 0.049756329506635666, + 0.06689600646495819, + 0.06406804174184799, + 0.07285383343696594, + 0.15955863893032074, + 0.12169556319713593, + 0.1911807805299759, + 0.0827493667602539, + 0.10533596575260162 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026338184252381325 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video composed of a four-screen layout with scenes in the upper left, upper right, lower left, and lower right quadrants?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the upper left quadrant show a female diver with raven hair in a tuck position plunging into blue water with white bubbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the upper right quadrant show a muscular male gymnast performing a complex spin with a blurred crowd and lights in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lower left quadrant show a female sprinter with blonde hair in a ponytail bursting from a bright red track?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the lower right quadrant show an extreme close-up of a male archer releasing an arrow with a shadowy flash?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014190951362252235 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264191150665283 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014190951362252235, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014190951362252235, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08499239385128021, + 0.026470324024558067, + 0.06808606535196304, + 0.03617722913622856, + 0.08095964044332504, + 0.03208635374903679, + 0.07359705865383148, + 0.07627391815185547, + 0.1372472494840622, + 0.3841097950935364 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014190951362252235 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_6/index_tensor([1951, 1951])_group_6_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_6/index_tensor([1951, 1951])_group_6_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..c420e38f7eb68906dbf6a0c3fd100adfa0319006 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_6/index_tensor([1951, 1951])_group_6_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "slow, subtle, close-up shot, moving forward, resembles examining a breathtaking, faded, vintage painting. At the center of the frame stands a young man with the handsome features of a classical sculpture, his short, slightly tousled silver-white hair cascading across his smooth forehead. His expression is serene and slightly melancholic, his eyes downcast, as if lost in an undisturbed dream. Most striking is his skin: smooth and pale, yet under the light, it takes on a strange, snake-scale sheen. A faint iridescent pattern shifts with the subtle undulations of his body, imbuing him with an inhuman, uncanny beauty. Deep green, almost black, vines organically climb and grow from the shadows of his body at an almost imperceptible pace. Delicate tendrils gently explore and coil around his neck, collarbone, and arms, as if engaged in a silent, intimate symbiosis. The entire scene is illuminated by a single, soft light source from the upper left, creating a strong contrast between light and dark and a texture reminiscent of a classical painting. The background, a deep, mottled dark hue, further emphasizes the subject's silhouette. The overall tones of the painting are extremely desaturated, almost monochrome, retaining only faint hints of color in the deep green of the vines and the iridescent sheen of the skin. This creates an atmosphere of tranquility, melancholy, and mysterious beauty, like a surreal allegory frozen in time about the symbiosis between nature and the human body.", + "seed": 24470, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_6/index_1951_seed_24470_dp_12_rank_24_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.013159866584464908, + "vlm_logprob": -0.013159866584464908, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.875, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.013159866584464908, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a young man with short, slightly tousled silver-white hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the man's skin appear smooth and pale with a visible snake-scale sheen and faint iridescent patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are deep green, almost black vines visible climbing from the shadows and coiling around the man's neck, collarbone, and arms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a single soft light source from the upper left creating strong contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color palette extremely desaturated and almost monochrome, retaining only faint hints of green and iridescence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0055986978113651276 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255598545074463 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0055986978113651276, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0055986978113651276, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.7171645760536194, + 0.05266844481229782, + 0.01703278161585331, + 0.010694284923374653, + 0.014749720692634583, + 0.03378942608833313, + 0.030375121161341667, + 0.044356316328048706, + 0.0418059378862381, + 0.03736336529254913 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0055986978113651276 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a young man with short, slightly tousled silver-white hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the man's skin appear smooth and pale with a visible snake-scale sheen and faint iridescent patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are deep green, almost black vines visible climbing from the shadows and coiling around the man's neck, collarbone, and arms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a single soft light source from the upper left creating strong contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color palette extremely desaturated and almost monochrome, retaining only faint hints of green and iridescence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004102624487131834 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.50410270690918 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004102624487131834, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004102624487131834, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.7719943523406982, + 0.03321941941976547, + 0.012897549197077751, + 0.011412778869271278, + 0.02874891273677349, + 0.01608949340879917, + 0.01618202030658722, + 0.05297291651368141, + 0.032271187752485275, + 0.024211354553699493 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004102624487131834 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a young man with short, slightly tousled silver-white hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the man's skin appear smooth and pale with a visible snake-scale sheen and faint iridescent patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are deep green, almost black vines visible climbing from the shadows and coiling around the man's neck, collarbone, and arms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a single soft light source from the upper left creating strong contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color palette extremely desaturated and almost monochrome, retaining only faint hints of green and iridescence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00193896540440619 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.251938819885254 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00193896540440619, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00193896540440619, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.7048677802085876, + 0.033355001360177994, + 0.029052115976810455, + 0.014286338351666927, + 0.01846022717654705, + 0.020945120602846146, + 0.012623201124370098, + 0.041488777846097946, + 0.0435890331864357, + 0.08133235573768616 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00193896540440619 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a young man with short, slightly tousled silver-white hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the man's skin appear smooth and pale with a visible snake-scale sheen and faint iridescent patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are deep green, almost black vines visible climbing from the shadows and coiling around the man's neck, collarbone, and arms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a single soft light source from the upper left creating strong contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color palette extremely desaturated and almost monochrome, retaining only faint hints of green and iridescence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016064614057540894 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141064643859863 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016064614057540894, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016064614057540894, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.9129010438919067, + 0.017716601490974426, + 0.00741242989897728, + 0.01146559976041317, + 0.007019299082458019, + 0.005096054635941982, + 0.003985156305134296, + 0.015522223897278309, + 0.007906027138233185, + 0.010975551791489124 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016064614057540894 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a young man with short, slightly tousled silver-white hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the man's skin appear smooth and pale with a visible snake-scale sheen and faint iridescent patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are deep green, almost black vines visible climbing from the shadows and coiling around the man's neck, collarbone, and arms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a single soft light source from the upper left creating strong contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color palette extremely desaturated and almost monochrome, retaining only faint hints of green and iridescence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03809443116188049 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2880945205688477 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03809443116188049, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03809443116188049, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.6256024837493896, + 0.07625026255846024, + 0.008983506821095943, + 0.006567050702869892, + 0.01713365502655506, + 0.010189930908381939, + 0.03679046407341957, + 0.12504525482654572, + 0.018381396308541298, + 0.07505598664283752 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03809443116188049 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow, subtle, close-up shot, moving forward, resembles examining a breathtaking, faded, vintage painting. At the center of the frame stands a young man with the handsome features of a classical sculpture, his short, slightly tousled silver-white hair cascading across his smooth forehead. His expression is serene and slightly melancholic, his eyes downcast, as if lost in an undisturbed dream. Most striking is his skin: smooth and pale, yet under the light, it takes on a strange, snake-scale sheen. A faint iridescent pattern shifts with the subtle undulations of his body, imbuing him with an inhuman, uncanny beauty. Deep green, almost black, vines organically climb and grow from the shadows of his body at an almost imperceptible pace. Delicate tendrils gently explore and coil around his neck, collarbone, and arms, as if engaged in a silent, intimate symbiosis. The entire scene is illuminated by a single, soft light source from the upper left, creating a strong contrast between light and dark and a texture reminiscent of a classical painting. The background, a deep, mottled dark hue, further emphasizes the subject's silhouette. The overall tones of the painting are extremely desaturated, almost monochrome, retaining only faint hints of color in the deep green of the vines and the iridescent sheen of the skin. This creates an atmosphere of tranquility, melancholy, and mysterious beauty, like a surreal allegory frozen in time about the symbiosis between nature and the human body.", + "seed": 24471, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_6/index_1951_seed_24471_dp_12_rank_24_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.023364818096160887, + "vlm_logprob": -0.023364818096160887, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.45, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.023364818096160887, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a young man with short, slightly tousled silver-white hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the man's skin appear smooth and pale with a visible snake-scale sheen and faint iridescent patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are deep green, almost black vines visible climbing from the shadows and coiling around the man's neck, collarbone, and arms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a single soft light source from the upper left creating strong contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color palette extremely desaturated and almost monochrome, retaining only faint hints of green and iridescence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011519819498062134 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511519908905029 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011519819498062134, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011519819498062134, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03835306689143181, + 0.12010882049798965, + 0.018200621008872986, + 0.04905874282121658, + 0.2991829514503479, + 0.05611201375722885, + 0.10482659935951233, + 0.19270473718643188, + 0.08775471150875092, + 0.03369775041937828 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011519819498062134 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a young man with short, slightly tousled silver-white hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the man's skin appear smooth and pale with a visible snake-scale sheen and faint iridescent patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are deep green, almost black vines visible climbing from the shadows and coiling around the man's neck, collarbone, and arms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a single soft light source from the upper left creating strong contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color palette extremely desaturated and almost monochrome, retaining only faint hints of green and iridescence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005955214146524668 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130955219268799 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005955214146524668, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005955214146524668, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.021096719428896904, + 0.09628613293170929, + 0.025133097544312477, + 0.05293375626206398, + 0.05437948554754257, + 0.08839356899261475, + 0.1925504356622696, + 0.3064866364002228, + 0.12867534160614014, + 0.034064777195453644 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005955214146524668 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a young man with short, slightly tousled silver-white hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the man's skin appear smooth and pale with a visible snake-scale sheen and faint iridescent patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are deep green, almost black vines visible climbing from the shadows and coiling around the man's neck, collarbone, and arms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a single soft light source from the upper left creating strong contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color palette extremely desaturated and almost monochrome, retaining only faint hints of green and iridescence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0021949741058051586 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127194881439209 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0021949741058051586, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0021949741058051586, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.050216637551784515, + 0.05937992408871651, + 0.05199262127280235, + 0.04119376838207245, + 0.12106002867221832, + 0.12434452772140503, + 0.1582738608121872, + 0.25999823212623596, + 0.07571452856063843, + 0.05782592296600342 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0021949741058051586 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a young man with short, slightly tousled silver-white hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the man's skin appear smooth and pale with a visible snake-scale sheen and faint iridescent patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are deep green, almost black vines visible climbing from the shadows and coiling around the man's neck, collarbone, and arms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a single soft light source from the upper left creating strong contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color palette extremely desaturated and almost monochrome, retaining only faint hints of green and iridescence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01818215288221836 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018182277679443 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01818215288221836, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01818215288221836, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05811627209186554, + 0.12284184247255325, + 0.12409386783838272, + 0.05062609165906906, + 0.06110860034823418, + 0.04956936463713646, + 0.10991054028272629, + 0.2516815960407257, + 0.050342343747615814, + 0.121709443628788 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01818215288221836 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a young man with short, slightly tousled silver-white hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the man's skin appear smooth and pale with a visible snake-scale sheen and faint iridescent patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are deep green, almost black vines visible climbing from the shadows and coiling around the man's neck, collarbone, and arms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a single soft light source from the upper left creating strong contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color palette extremely desaturated and almost monochrome, retaining only faint hints of green and iridescence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07897192984819412 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5789718627929688 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07897192984819412, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07897192984819412, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.044995423406362534, + 0.08156049251556396, + 0.058203648775815964, + 0.04352555051445961, + 0.059609297662973404, + 0.09431702643632889, + 0.2010624259710312, + 0.3356751799583435, + 0.035717595368623734, + 0.04533335939049721 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07897192984819412 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow, subtle, close-up shot, moving forward, resembles examining a breathtaking, faded, vintage painting. At the center of the frame stands a young man with the handsome features of a classical sculpture, his short, slightly tousled silver-white hair cascading across his smooth forehead. His expression is serene and slightly melancholic, his eyes downcast, as if lost in an undisturbed dream. Most striking is his skin: smooth and pale, yet under the light, it takes on a strange, snake-scale sheen. A faint iridescent pattern shifts with the subtle undulations of his body, imbuing him with an inhuman, uncanny beauty. Deep green, almost black, vines organically climb and grow from the shadows of his body at an almost imperceptible pace. Delicate tendrils gently explore and coil around his neck, collarbone, and arms, as if engaged in a silent, intimate symbiosis. The entire scene is illuminated by a single, soft light source from the upper left, creating a strong contrast between light and dark and a texture reminiscent of a classical painting. The background, a deep, mottled dark hue, further emphasizes the subject's silhouette. The overall tones of the painting are extremely desaturated, almost monochrome, retaining only faint hints of color in the deep green of the vines and the iridescent sheen of the skin. This creates an atmosphere of tranquility, melancholy, and mysterious beauty, like a surreal allegory frozen in time about the symbiosis between nature and the human body.", + "seed": 24472, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_6/index_1951_seed_24472_dp_13_rank_26_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.02616839543916285, + "vlm_logprob": -0.02616839543916285, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.125, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.02616839543916285, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a young man with short, slightly tousled silver-white hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the man's skin appear smooth and pale with a visible snake-scale sheen and faint iridescent patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are deep green, almost black vines visible climbing from the shadows and coiling around the man's neck, collarbone, and arms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a single soft light source from the upper left creating strong contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color palette extremely desaturated and almost monochrome, retaining only faint hints of green and iridescence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012883991934359074 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387884140014648 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012883991934359074, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012883991934359074, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11164959520101547, + 0.0682690218091011, + 0.16903989017009735, + 0.17035064101219177, + 0.10835365206003189, + 0.036729101091623306, + 0.09692790359258652, + 0.042361222207546234, + 0.04084356501698494, + 0.1554754078388214 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012883991934359074 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a young man with short, slightly tousled silver-white hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the man's skin appear smooth and pale with a visible snake-scale sheen and faint iridescent patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are deep green, almost black vines visible climbing from the shadows and coiling around the man's neck, collarbone, and arms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a single soft light source from the upper left creating strong contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color palette extremely desaturated and almost monochrome, retaining only faint hints of green and iridescence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011082404293119907 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511082172393799 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011082404293119907, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011082404293119907, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1459788978099823, + 0.07180988788604736, + 0.12305542081594467, + 0.222610205411911, + 0.10086210072040558, + 0.05228613689541817, + 0.04092419520020485, + 0.06928443163633347, + 0.03847157210111618, + 0.13471710681915283 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011082404293119907 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a young man with short, slightly tousled silver-white hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the man's skin appear smooth and pale with a visible snake-scale sheen and faint iridescent patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are deep green, almost black vines visible climbing from the shadows and coiling around the man's neck, collarbone, and arms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a single soft light source from the upper left creating strong contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color palette extremely desaturated and almost monochrome, retaining only faint hints of green and iridescence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0031881716568022966 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753188133239746 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0031881716568022966, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0031881716568022966, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08283522725105286, + 0.04471767321228981, + 0.12349903583526611, + 0.19639112055301666, + 0.1776086539030075, + 0.07753811031579971, + 0.2009756714105606, + 0.029849734157323837, + 0.02048899047076702, + 0.04609574377536774 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0031881716568022966 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a young man with short, slightly tousled silver-white hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the man's skin appear smooth and pale with a visible snake-scale sheen and faint iridescent patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are deep green, almost black vines visible climbing from the shadows and coiling around the man's neck, collarbone, and arms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a single soft light source from the upper left creating strong contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color palette extremely desaturated and almost monochrome, retaining only faint hints of green and iridescence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03368726745247841 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4086873531341553 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03368726745247841, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03368726745247841, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16180863976478577, + 0.06548268347978592, + 0.05945843085646629, + 0.19442877173423767, + 0.10376188158988953, + 0.0523219108581543, + 0.18434442579746246, + 0.030482487753033638, + 0.03577534854412079, + 0.11213534325361252 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03368726745247841 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a young man with short, slightly tousled silver-white hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the man's skin appear smooth and pale with a visible snake-scale sheen and faint iridescent patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are deep green, almost black vines visible climbing from the shadows and coiling around the man's neck, collarbone, and arms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a single soft light source from the upper left creating strong contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color palette extremely desaturated and almost monochrome, retaining only faint hints of green and iridescence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07000014185905457 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695000171661377 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07000014185905457, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07000014185905457, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21588020026683807, + 0.0706794336438179, + 0.057778358459472656, + 0.20572903752326965, + 0.10628999024629593, + 0.05417490750551224, + 0.13589365780353546, + 0.04432791844010353, + 0.03914709761738777, + 0.07009942084550858 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07000014185905457 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow, subtle, close-up shot, moving forward, resembles examining a breathtaking, faded, vintage painting. At the center of the frame stands a young man with the handsome features of a classical sculpture, his short, slightly tousled silver-white hair cascading across his smooth forehead. His expression is serene and slightly melancholic, his eyes downcast, as if lost in an undisturbed dream. Most striking is his skin: smooth and pale, yet under the light, it takes on a strange, snake-scale sheen. A faint iridescent pattern shifts with the subtle undulations of his body, imbuing him with an inhuman, uncanny beauty. Deep green, almost black, vines organically climb and grow from the shadows of his body at an almost imperceptible pace. Delicate tendrils gently explore and coil around his neck, collarbone, and arms, as if engaged in a silent, intimate symbiosis. The entire scene is illuminated by a single, soft light source from the upper left, creating a strong contrast between light and dark and a texture reminiscent of a classical painting. The background, a deep, mottled dark hue, further emphasizes the subject's silhouette. The overall tones of the painting are extremely desaturated, almost monochrome, retaining only faint hints of color in the deep green of the vines and the iridescent sheen of the skin. This creates an atmosphere of tranquility, melancholy, and mysterious beauty, like a surreal allegory frozen in time about the symbiosis between nature and the human body.", + "seed": 24473, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_6/index_1951_seed_24473_dp_13_rank_26_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.0192403681576252, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0192403681576252, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.525, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0192403681576252, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a young man with short, slightly tousled silver-white hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the man's skin appear smooth and pale with a visible snake-scale sheen and faint iridescent patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are deep green, almost black vines visible climbing from the shadows and coiling around the man's neck, collarbone, and arms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a single soft light source from the upper left creating strong contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color palette extremely desaturated and almost monochrome, retaining only faint hints of green and iridescence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01146690547466278 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511466979980469 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01146690547466278, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01146690547466278, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09060247987508774, + 0.0721723660826683, + 0.07189290225505829, + 0.04879509657621384, + 0.10811509191989899, + 0.09136765450239182, + 0.034334082156419754, + 0.11537282168865204, + 0.21485008299350739, + 0.15249744057655334 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01146690547466278 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a young man with short, slightly tousled silver-white hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the man's skin appear smooth and pale with a visible snake-scale sheen and faint iridescent patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are deep green, almost black vines visible climbing from the shadows and coiling around the man's neck, collarbone, and arms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a single soft light source from the upper left creating strong contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color palette extremely desaturated and almost monochrome, retaining only faint hints of green and iridescence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0041025057435035706 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.50410270690918 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0041025057435035706, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0041025057435035706, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13169212639331818, + 0.1780168116092682, + 0.0943027213215828, + 0.14921949803829193, + 0.043055787682533264, + 0.05203647539019585, + 0.07729747146368027, + 0.11944853514432907, + 0.05445260927081108, + 0.10047802329063416 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0041025057435035706 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a young man with short, slightly tousled silver-white hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the man's skin appear smooth and pale with a visible snake-scale sheen and faint iridescent patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are deep green, almost black vines visible climbing from the shadows and coiling around the man's neck, collarbone, and arms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a single soft light source from the upper left creating strong contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color palette extremely desaturated and almost monochrome, retaining only faint hints of green and iridescence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0021947361528873444 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127194881439209 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0021947361528873444, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0021947361528873444, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14283476769924164, + 0.08685111999511719, + 0.07924953103065491, + 0.13760213553905487, + 0.12825699150562286, + 0.0385715551674366, + 0.0469503290951252, + 0.14604069292545319, + 0.06350193917751312, + 0.13014085590839386 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0021947361528873444 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a young man with short, slightly tousled silver-white hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the man's skin appear smooth and pale with a visible snake-scale sheen and faint iridescent patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are deep green, almost black vines visible climbing from the shadows and coiling around the man's neck, collarbone, and arms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a single soft light source from the upper left creating strong contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color palette extremely desaturated and almost monochrome, retaining only faint hints of green and iridescence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02979404106736183 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5297939777374268 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02979404106736183, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02979404106736183, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08145280182361603, + 0.06456036865711212, + 0.12080368399620056, + 0.13237059116363525, + 0.43347781896591187, + 0.02731269970536232, + 0.017423270270228386, + 0.04116704314947128, + 0.03018433414399624, + 0.051247455179691315 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02979404106736183 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a young man with short, slightly tousled silver-white hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the man's skin appear smooth and pale with a visible snake-scale sheen and faint iridescent patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are deep green, almost black vines visible climbing from the shadows and coiling around the man's neck, collarbone, and arms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a single soft light source from the upper left creating strong contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color palette extremely desaturated and almost monochrome, retaining only faint hints of green and iridescence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.048643652349710464 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486435890197754 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.048643652349710464, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.048643652349710464, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10476591438055038, + 0.10298249870538712, + 0.2402999848127365, + 0.07455512881278992, + 0.07057322561740875, + 0.06082620844244957, + 0.04903480038046837, + 0.1874411702156067, + 0.03595464304089546, + 0.07356637716293335 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.048643652349710464 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_7/index_tensor([1110, 1110])_group_7_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_7/index_tensor([1110, 1110])_group_7_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..722d554865e4ca7d2deeecc6d6246161da866b9e --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_7/index_tensor([1110, 1110])_group_7_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "cinematically fluid tracking shot glides forward through the heart of a vast, Giger-esque abyss, its walls a nightmarish fusion of ribbed biomechanical structures and weeping fossilized bones. The camera follows a massive horror reminiscent of a deep-sea siphonophore, a serpentine chain of pulsating, translucent coral polyps emitting a sickly, cold blue-green bioluminescence. These fleshy sacs unnaturally fuse with fragments of blackened, oily metal and jagged, ivory-like bony protrusions to form a grotesque external spine. The entire organism floats in the suffocating darkness with a slow, sinuous grace. Suddenly, its monstrous body contracts, and from its segments, it extends impossibly thin, tentacle-like tentacles, crackling with faint bursts of electrical energy. These whips strike fiercely and decisively at a point off-screen, signifying a swift and brutal attack on an unseen victim. The only source of light remains the creature's own rhythmic, hypnotic glow, casting long, dancing shadows across the abyssal monstrosity and creating an atmosphere of profound cosmic dread and claustrophobia.", + "seed": 17881, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_7/index_1110_seed_17881_dp_14_rank_28_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.01879488826962188, + "vlm_logprob": -0.01879488826962188, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 5.2, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.01879488826962188, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast abyss featuring ribbed biomechanical structures and weeping fossilized bones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive, serpentine creature resembling a deep-sea siphonophore with translucent, pulsating coral polyps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the creature emit a sickly, cold blue-green bioluminescence and feature fleshy sacs fused with blackened metal and ivory-like bone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the creature extend thin, tentacle-like appendages crackling with electrical energy to strike off-screen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit only by the creature's rhythmic glow, casting long, dancing shadows in a dark environment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006075248587876558 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.256075382232666 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006075248587876558, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006075248587876558, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.7707686424255371, + 0.020758988335728645, + 0.026891041547060013, + 0.02872806042432785, + 0.022723451256752014, + 0.028223443776369095, + 0.01605433039367199, + 0.03350503742694855, + 0.03143047168850899, + 0.02091657742857933 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006075248587876558 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast abyss featuring ribbed biomechanical structures and weeping fossilized bones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive, serpentine creature resembling a deep-sea siphonophore with translucent, pulsating coral polyps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the creature emit a sickly, cold blue-green bioluminescence and feature fleshy sacs fused with blackened metal and ivory-like bone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the creature extend thin, tentacle-like appendages crackling with electrical energy to strike off-screen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit only by the creature's rhythmic glow, casting long, dancing shadows in a dark environment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0040968069806694984 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504096984863281 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0040968069806694984, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0040968069806694984, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5626667141914368, + 0.05632035806775093, + 0.10684879869222641, + 0.05573654547333717, + 0.026629293337464333, + 0.025337792932987213, + 0.038015034049749374, + 0.06432466953992844, + 0.03217735141515732, + 0.0319434329867363 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0040968069806694984 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast abyss featuring ribbed biomechanical structures and weeping fossilized bones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive, serpentine creature resembling a deep-sea siphonophore with translucent, pulsating coral polyps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the creature emit a sickly, cold blue-green bioluminescence and feature fleshy sacs fused with blackened metal and ivory-like bone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the creature extend thin, tentacle-like appendages crackling with electrical energy to strike off-screen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit only by the creature's rhythmic glow, casting long, dancing shadows in a dark environment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0007194076315499842 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.2507195472717285 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0007194076315499842, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0007194076315499842, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.8345256447792053, + 0.011803136207163334, + 0.02334008552134037, + 0.028930287808179855, + 0.009265104308724403, + 0.010451973415911198, + 0.012936132960021496, + 0.031360793858766556, + 0.019717704504728317, + 0.01766921952366829 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0007194076315499842 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast abyss featuring ribbed biomechanical structures and weeping fossilized bones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive, serpentine creature resembling a deep-sea siphonophore with translucent, pulsating coral polyps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the creature emit a sickly, cold blue-green bioluminescence and feature fleshy sacs fused with blackened metal and ivory-like bone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the creature extend thin, tentacle-like appendages crackling with electrical energy to strike off-screen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit only by the creature's rhythmic glow, casting long, dancing shadows in a dark environment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07898878306150436 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.578988790512085 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07898878306150436, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07898878306150436, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.32590430974960327, + 0.09390360116958618, + 0.05729321017861366, + 0.04241667687892914, + 0.04433049261569977, + 0.025017505511641502, + 0.10456358641386032, + 0.2299264520406723, + 0.05568821355700493, + 0.02095595933496952 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07898878306150436 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast abyss featuring ribbed biomechanical structures and weeping fossilized bones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive, serpentine creature resembling a deep-sea siphonophore with translucent, pulsating coral polyps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the creature emit a sickly, cold blue-green bioluminescence and feature fleshy sacs fused with blackened metal and ivory-like bone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the creature extend thin, tentacle-like appendages crackling with electrical energy to strike off-screen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit only by the creature's rhythmic glow, casting long, dancing shadows in a dark environment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004094195086508989 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504094123840332 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004094195086508989, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004094195086508989, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.7816027402877808, + 0.04735419526696205, + 0.03172256797552109, + 0.021266750991344452, + 0.012900215573608875, + 0.013056240044534206, + 0.024577997624874115, + 0.03375988081097603, + 0.02026447094976902, + 0.013494853861629963 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004094195086508989 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "cinematically fluid tracking shot glides forward through the heart of a vast, Giger-esque abyss, its walls a nightmarish fusion of ribbed biomechanical structures and weeping fossilized bones. The camera follows a massive horror reminiscent of a deep-sea siphonophore, a serpentine chain of pulsating, translucent coral polyps emitting a sickly, cold blue-green bioluminescence. These fleshy sacs unnaturally fuse with fragments of blackened, oily metal and jagged, ivory-like bony protrusions to form a grotesque external spine. The entire organism floats in the suffocating darkness with a slow, sinuous grace. Suddenly, its monstrous body contracts, and from its segments, it extends impossibly thin, tentacle-like tentacles, crackling with faint bursts of electrical energy. These whips strike fiercely and decisively at a point off-screen, signifying a swift and brutal attack on an unseen victim. The only source of light remains the creature's own rhythmic, hypnotic glow, casting long, dancing shadows across the abyssal monstrosity and creating an atmosphere of profound cosmic dread and claustrophobia.", + "seed": 17882, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_7/index_1110_seed_17882_dp_14_rank_28_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.019372335390653462, + "vlm_logprob": -0.019372335390653462, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 5.125, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.019372335390653462, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast abyss featuring ribbed biomechanical structures and weeping fossilized bones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive, serpentine creature resembling a deep-sea siphonophore with translucent, pulsating coral polyps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the creature emit a sickly, cold blue-green bioluminescence and feature fleshy sacs fused with blackened metal and ivory-like bone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the creature extend thin, tentacle-like appendages crackling with electrical energy to strike off-screen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit only by the creature's rhythmic glow, casting long, dancing shadows in a dark environment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00790290255099535 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.132903099060059 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00790290255099535, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00790290255099535, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19597387313842773, + 0.07621921598911285, + 0.14651338756084442, + 0.0977388396859169, + 0.06268700212240219, + 0.10906977951526642, + 0.1454753279685974, + 0.04303832724690437, + 0.08319395035505295, + 0.040090300142765045 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00790290255099535 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast abyss featuring ribbed biomechanical structures and weeping fossilized bones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive, serpentine creature resembling a deep-sea siphonophore with translucent, pulsating coral polyps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the creature emit a sickly, cold blue-green bioluminescence and feature fleshy sacs fused with blackened metal and ivory-like bone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the creature extend thin, tentacle-like appendages crackling with electrical energy to strike off-screen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit only by the creature's rhythmic glow, casting long, dancing shadows in a dark environment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003195182653144002 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753195285797119 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003195182653144002, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003195182653144002, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21067912876605988, + 0.148783341050148, + 0.09885184466838837, + 0.06573695689439774, + 0.06080993637442589, + 0.16473586857318878, + 0.10725735127925873, + 0.040989432483911514, + 0.07541538029909134, + 0.026740729808807373 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003195182653144002 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast abyss featuring ribbed biomechanical structures and weeping fossilized bones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive, serpentine creature resembling a deep-sea siphonophore with translucent, pulsating coral polyps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the creature emit a sickly, cold blue-green bioluminescence and feature fleshy sacs fused with blackened metal and ivory-like bone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the creature extend thin, tentacle-like appendages crackling with electrical energy to strike off-screen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit only by the creature's rhythmic glow, casting long, dancing shadows in a dark environment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0008154166280291975 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.125815391540527 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0008154166280291975, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0008154166280291975, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17327924072742462, + 0.13824060559272766, + 0.08726906776428223, + 0.06105874478816986, + 0.09222181886434555, + 0.17792779207229614, + 0.09775976836681366, + 0.0344155915081501, + 0.1049879863858223, + 0.0328393280506134 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0008154166280291975 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast abyss featuring ribbed biomechanical structures and weeping fossilized bones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive, serpentine creature resembling a deep-sea siphonophore with translucent, pulsating coral polyps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the creature emit a sickly, cold blue-green bioluminescence and feature fleshy sacs fused with blackened metal and ivory-like bone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the creature extend thin, tentacle-like appendages crackling with electrical energy to strike off-screen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit only by the creature's rhythmic glow, casting long, dancing shadows in a dark environment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07899770140647888 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5789976119995117 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07899770140647888, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07899770140647888, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07207728922367096, + 0.048260755836963654, + 0.04063783213496208, + 0.05273417755961418, + 0.04807203263044357, + 0.5691800117492676, + 0.04476945474743843, + 0.020631469786167145, + 0.07607509940862656, + 0.02756197564303875 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07899770140647888 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast abyss featuring ribbed biomechanical structures and weeping fossilized bones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive, serpentine creature resembling a deep-sea siphonophore with translucent, pulsating coral polyps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the creature emit a sickly, cold blue-green bioluminescence and feature fleshy sacs fused with blackened metal and ivory-like bone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the creature extend thin, tentacle-like appendages crackling with electrical energy to strike off-screen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit only by the creature's rhythmic glow, casting long, dancing shadows in a dark environment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005950473714619875 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130950450897217 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005950473714619875, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005950473714619875, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2571554183959961, + 0.12706924974918365, + 0.13036218285560608, + 0.05543946102261543, + 0.05093032494187355, + 0.12961037456989288, + 0.05364042520523071, + 0.029169177636504173, + 0.12004616856575012, + 0.04657718539237976 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005950473714619875 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "cinematically fluid tracking shot glides forward through the heart of a vast, Giger-esque abyss, its walls a nightmarish fusion of ribbed biomechanical structures and weeping fossilized bones. The camera follows a massive horror reminiscent of a deep-sea siphonophore, a serpentine chain of pulsating, translucent coral polyps emitting a sickly, cold blue-green bioluminescence. These fleshy sacs unnaturally fuse with fragments of blackened, oily metal and jagged, ivory-like bony protrusions to form a grotesque external spine. The entire organism floats in the suffocating darkness with a slow, sinuous grace. Suddenly, its monstrous body contracts, and from its segments, it extends impossibly thin, tentacle-like tentacles, crackling with faint bursts of electrical energy. These whips strike fiercely and decisively at a point off-screen, signifying a swift and brutal attack on an unseen victim. The only source of light remains the creature's own rhythmic, hypnotic glow, casting long, dancing shadows across the abyssal monstrosity and creating an atmosphere of profound cosmic dread and claustrophobia.", + "seed": 17883, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_7/index_1110_seed_17883_dp_15_rank_30_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.04436458589043468, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04436458589043468, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.775, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04436458589043468, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast abyss featuring ribbed biomechanical structures and weeping fossilized bones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive, serpentine creature resembling a deep-sea siphonophore with translucent, pulsating coral polyps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the creature emit a sickly, cold blue-green bioluminescence and feature fleshy sacs fused with blackened metal and ivory-like bone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the creature extend thin, tentacle-like appendages crackling with electrical energy to strike off-screen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit only by the creature's rhythmic glow, casting long, dancing shadows in a dark environment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.010430112481117249 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.635430335998535 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.010430112481117249, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.010430112481117249, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08571384102106094, + 0.4988780915737152, + 0.09630084037780762, + 0.0629868432879448, + 0.10676614195108414, + 0.02482985146343708, + 0.016086727380752563, + 0.015942521393299103, + 0.04408177360892296, + 0.04841335862874985 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.010430112481117249 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast abyss featuring ribbed biomechanical structures and weeping fossilized bones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive, serpentine creature resembling a deep-sea siphonophore with translucent, pulsating coral polyps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the creature emit a sickly, cold blue-green bioluminescence and feature fleshy sacs fused with blackened metal and ivory-like bone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the creature extend thin, tentacle-like appendages crackling with electrical energy to strike off-screen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit only by the creature's rhythmic glow, casting long, dancing shadows in a dark environment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00464111752808094 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379641056060791 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00464111752808094, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00464111752808094, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.048367954790592194, + 0.33025434613227844, + 0.0670710876584053, + 0.04877680540084839, + 0.08463197201490402, + 0.05321687087416649, + 0.02424507960677147, + 0.032721955329179764, + 0.25527524948120117, + 0.05543871223926544 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00464111752808094 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast abyss featuring ribbed biomechanical structures and weeping fossilized bones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive, serpentine creature resembling a deep-sea siphonophore with translucent, pulsating coral polyps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the creature emit a sickly, cold blue-green bioluminescence and feature fleshy sacs fused with blackened metal and ivory-like bone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the creature extend thin, tentacle-like appendages crackling with electrical energy to strike off-screen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit only by the creature's rhythmic glow, casting long, dancing shadows in a dark environment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0010446811793372035 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.876044750213623 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0010446811793372035, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0010446811793372035, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.02356048673391342, + 0.5142784118652344, + 0.028582211583852768, + 0.023201843723654747, + 0.057764191180467606, + 0.008777891285717487, + 0.009637118317186832, + 0.01328896265476942, + 0.3006727397441864, + 0.02023608796298504 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0010446811793372035 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast abyss featuring ribbed biomechanical structures and weeping fossilized bones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive, serpentine creature resembling a deep-sea siphonophore with translucent, pulsating coral polyps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the creature emit a sickly, cold blue-green bioluminescence and feature fleshy sacs fused with blackened metal and ivory-like bone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the creature extend thin, tentacle-like appendages crackling with electrical energy to strike off-screen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit only by the creature's rhythmic glow, casting long, dancing shadows in a dark environment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20161116123199463 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7016111612319946 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20161116123199463, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20161116123199463, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07731954008340836, + 0.18319807946681976, + 0.02371106669306755, + 0.06204376742243767, + 0.050269514322280884, + 0.015607944689691067, + 0.01164346095174551, + 0.03282328322529793, + 0.48022231459617615, + 0.06316103786230087 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20161116123199463 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast abyss featuring ribbed biomechanical structures and weeping fossilized bones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive, serpentine creature resembling a deep-sea siphonophore with translucent, pulsating coral polyps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the creature emit a sickly, cold blue-green bioluminescence and feature fleshy sacs fused with blackened metal and ivory-like bone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the creature extend thin, tentacle-like appendages crackling with electrical energy to strike off-screen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit only by the creature's rhythmic glow, casting long, dancing shadows in a dark environment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004095857031643391 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504096031188965 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004095857031643391, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004095857031643391, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0736188217997551, + 0.16086643934249878, + 0.023763101547956467, + 0.1635936051607132, + 0.058615658432245255, + 0.021899811923503876, + 0.015007402747869492, + 0.03018888831138611, + 0.3771025836467743, + 0.07534367591142654 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004095857031643391 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "cinematically fluid tracking shot glides forward through the heart of a vast, Giger-esque abyss, its walls a nightmarish fusion of ribbed biomechanical structures and weeping fossilized bones. The camera follows a massive horror reminiscent of a deep-sea siphonophore, a serpentine chain of pulsating, translucent coral polyps emitting a sickly, cold blue-green bioluminescence. These fleshy sacs unnaturally fuse with fragments of blackened, oily metal and jagged, ivory-like bony protrusions to form a grotesque external spine. The entire organism floats in the suffocating darkness with a slow, sinuous grace. Suddenly, its monstrous body contracts, and from its segments, it extends impossibly thin, tentacle-like tentacles, crackling with faint bursts of electrical energy. These whips strike fiercely and decisively at a point off-screen, signifying a swift and brutal attack on an unseen victim. The only source of light remains the creature's own rhythmic, hypnotic glow, casting long, dancing shadows across the abyssal monstrosity and creating an atmosphere of profound cosmic dread and claustrophobia.", + "seed": 17884, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_7/index_1110_seed_17884_dp_15_rank_30_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.0287791837239638, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0287791837239638, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.975, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0287791837239638, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast abyss featuring ribbed biomechanical structures and weeping fossilized bones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive, serpentine creature resembling a deep-sea siphonophore with translucent, pulsating coral polyps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the creature emit a sickly, cold blue-green bioluminescence and feature fleshy sacs fused with blackened metal and ivory-like bone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the creature extend thin, tentacle-like appendages crackling with electrical energy to strike off-screen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit only by the creature's rhythmic glow, casting long, dancing shadows in a dark environment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006775973830372095 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.256775856018066 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006775973830372095, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006775973830372095, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2346215546131134, + 0.08586333692073822, + 0.1284695416688919, + 0.07814642786979675, + 0.13519276678562164, + 0.06160089746117592, + 0.0525679774582386, + 0.11592117697000504, + 0.05884970724582672, + 0.048766594380140305 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006775973830372095 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast abyss featuring ribbed biomechanical structures and weeping fossilized bones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive, serpentine creature resembling a deep-sea siphonophore with translucent, pulsating coral polyps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the creature emit a sickly, cold blue-green bioluminescence and feature fleshy sacs fused with blackened metal and ivory-like bone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the creature extend thin, tentacle-like appendages crackling with electrical energy to strike off-screen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit only by the creature's rhythmic glow, casting long, dancing shadows in a dark environment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005257115233689547 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.2552571296691895 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005257115233689547, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005257115233689547, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2768551707267761, + 0.14154556393623352, + 0.09532535821199417, + 0.11099942028522491, + 0.06294584274291992, + 0.04204360395669937, + 0.046869851648807526, + 0.10594631731510162, + 0.0622866116464138, + 0.05518224462866783 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005257115233689547 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast abyss featuring ribbed biomechanical structures and weeping fossilized bones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive, serpentine creature resembling a deep-sea siphonophore with translucent, pulsating coral polyps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the creature emit a sickly, cold blue-green bioluminescence and feature fleshy sacs fused with blackened metal and ivory-like bone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the creature extend thin, tentacle-like appendages crackling with electrical energy to strike off-screen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit only by the creature's rhythmic glow, casting long, dancing shadows in a dark environment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0011825718684121966 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.751182556152344 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0011825718684121966, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0011825718684121966, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3089422583580017, + 0.13628017902374268, + 0.10497736185789108, + 0.0593208372592926, + 0.07674536108970642, + 0.06049409136176109, + 0.04827383905649185, + 0.038906484842300415, + 0.07684478908777237, + 0.08921478688716888 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0011825718684121966 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast abyss featuring ribbed biomechanical structures and weeping fossilized bones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive, serpentine creature resembling a deep-sea siphonophore with translucent, pulsating coral polyps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the creature emit a sickly, cold blue-green bioluminescence and feature fleshy sacs fused with blackened metal and ivory-like bone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the creature extend thin, tentacle-like appendages crackling with electrical energy to strike off-screen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit only by the creature's rhythmic glow, casting long, dancing shadows in a dark environment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12706391513347626 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1270639896392822 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12706391513347626, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12706391513347626, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1760724037885666, + 0.20831096172332764, + 0.16955611109733582, + 0.1571696251630783, + 0.06224702671170235, + 0.04315692186355591, + 0.05853680893778801, + 0.03717196732759476, + 0.051919613033533096, + 0.03585848957300186 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12706391513347626 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast abyss featuring ribbed biomechanical structures and weeping fossilized bones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive, serpentine creature resembling a deep-sea siphonophore with translucent, pulsating coral polyps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the creature emit a sickly, cold blue-green bioluminescence and feature fleshy sacs fused with blackened metal and ivory-like bone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the creature extend thin, tentacle-like appendages crackling with electrical energy to strike off-screen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit only by the creature's rhythmic glow, casting long, dancing shadows in a dark environment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00361634255386889 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.6286163330078125 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00361634255386889, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00361634255386889, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2612031400203705, + 0.17828696966171265, + 0.08251123875379562, + 0.06223412603139877, + 0.10040056705474854, + 0.07680117338895798, + 0.05401065573096275, + 0.04765065759420395, + 0.0837348997592926, + 0.05316649377346039 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00361634255386889 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_8/index_tensor([3579, 3579])_group_8_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_8/index_tensor([3579, 3579])_group_8_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..c922a693b78e96ad0c9cc7cd29997e40544a1b0f --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_8/index_tensor([3579, 3579])_group_8_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "This extreme close-up, shot from a slightly elevated frontal angle, initially captures the delicate movements of a slender teenage African-American girl planting a seedling. Her face, intensely focused, is in focus, as is thin, black-framed glasses. Neat rows of corn emerge from beneath the soft fabric of her heather-gray cotton hoodie. Her slender hands, stained with black soil, move swiftly but clumsily, grasping a tiny, vibrant green sprout with three delicate leaves and a fragile root ball. In a heartbreaking moment, her fingers fumble, and the tiny plant nearly drops, before she quickly readjusts her grip. Then, refocusing, she steadily and deliberately lowers the seedling into a pre-dug hole in the fertile, dark soil. As she successfully completes the placement, the camera begins a slow, steady zoom out, gradually revealing more of her kneeling figure on the garden plot. A gentle breeze sweeps across the scene, causing the tiny leaves of the seedlings to rustle subtly, bathed in the soft, warm afternoon sun, creating an atmosphere of tranquility and hope.", + "seed": 16555, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_8/index_3579_seed_16555_dp_16_rank_32_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.11583561338484287, + "vlm_logprob": -0.11583561338484287, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.55, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.11583561338484287, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a slender teenage African-American girl wearing thin, black-framed glasses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the girl's hands stained with black soil while she handles a tiny, vibrant green sprout with three leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the girl fumbling with the plant before successfully placing it into a pre-dug hole in dark soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin a slow, steady zoom out to reveal more of the girl kneeling on the garden plot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in soft, warm afternoon sun with a gentle breeze causing the seedling leaves to rustle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5247222781181335 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8997222781181335 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5247222781181335, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5247222781181335, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11671876162290573, + 0.14880654215812683, + 0.08783844858407974, + 0.02828880213201046, + 0.04099566116929054, + 0.0195733942091465, + 0.052443213760852814, + 0.42643508315086365, + 0.02827417477965355, + 0.05062589421868324 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5247222781181335 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a slender teenage African-American girl wearing thin, black-framed glasses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the girl's hands stained with black soil while she handles a tiny, vibrant green sprout with three leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the girl fumbling with the plant before successfully placing it into a pre-dug hole in dark soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin a slow, steady zoom out to reveal more of the girl kneeling on the garden plot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in soft, warm afternoon sun with a gentle breeze causing the seedling leaves to rustle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016096286475658417 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141096115112305 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016096286475658417, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016096286475658417, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05281487852334976, + 0.12494008988142014, + 0.02681943215429783, + 0.015733972191810608, + 0.02742103300988674, + 0.007819410413503647, + 0.03544853627681732, + 0.6049706935882568, + 0.028184887021780014, + 0.07584705203771591 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016096286475658417 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a slender teenage African-American girl wearing thin, black-framed glasses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the girl's hands stained with black soil while she handles a tiny, vibrant green sprout with three leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the girl fumbling with the plant before successfully placing it into a pre-dug hole in dark soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin a slow, steady zoom out to reveal more of the girl kneeling on the garden plot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in soft, warm afternoon sun with a gentle breeze causing the seedling leaves to rustle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018186133354902267 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018186092376709 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018186133354902267, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018186133354902267, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0734965056180954, + 0.05778399482369423, + 0.04943305253982544, + 0.019401835277676582, + 0.02679603546857834, + 0.011896242387592793, + 0.019186625257134438, + 0.623475193977356, + 0.06065145507454872, + 0.057879041880369186 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018186133354902267 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a slender teenage African-American girl wearing thin, black-framed glasses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the girl's hands stained with black soil while she handles a tiny, vibrant green sprout with three leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the girl fumbling with the plant before successfully placing it into a pre-dug hole in dark soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin a slow, steady zoom out to reveal more of the girl kneeling on the garden plot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in soft, warm afternoon sun with a gentle breeze causing the seedling leaves to rustle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007629185914993286 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.88262939453125 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007629185914993286, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007629185914993286, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04549292102456093, + 0.041675254702568054, + 0.030828818678855896, + 0.022899435833096504, + 0.03859831765294075, + 0.01394101232290268, + 0.050825368613004684, + 0.579232394695282, + 0.05583807826042175, + 0.12066850811243057 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007629185914993286 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a slender teenage African-American girl wearing thin, black-framed glasses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the girl's hands stained with black soil while she handles a tiny, vibrant green sprout with three leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the girl fumbling with the plant before successfully placing it into a pre-dug hole in dark soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin a slow, steady zoom out to reveal more of the girl kneeling on the garden plot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in soft, warm afternoon sun with a gentle breeze causing the seedling leaves to rustle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012544183060526848 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.38754415512085 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012544183060526848, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012544183060526848, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04788060858845711, + 0.05907624214887619, + 0.03660532087087631, + 0.009993139654397964, + 0.018145639449357986, + 0.00767471082508564, + 0.019527049735188484, + 0.6828248500823975, + 0.04940593242645264, + 0.06886651366949081 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012544183060526848 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "This extreme close-up, shot from a slightly elevated frontal angle, initially captures the delicate movements of a slender teenage African-American girl planting a seedling. Her face, intensely focused, is in focus, as is thin, black-framed glasses. Neat rows of corn emerge from beneath the soft fabric of her heather-gray cotton hoodie. Her slender hands, stained with black soil, move swiftly but clumsily, grasping a tiny, vibrant green sprout with three delicate leaves and a fragile root ball. In a heartbreaking moment, her fingers fumble, and the tiny plant nearly drops, before she quickly readjusts her grip. Then, refocusing, she steadily and deliberately lowers the seedling into a pre-dug hole in the fertile, dark soil. As she successfully completes the placement, the camera begins a slow, steady zoom out, gradually revealing more of her kneeling figure on the garden plot. A gentle breeze sweeps across the scene, causing the tiny leaves of the seedlings to rustle subtly, bathed in the soft, warm afternoon sun, creating an atmosphere of tranquility and hope.", + "seed": 16556, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_8/index_3579_seed_16556_dp_16_rank_32_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.06845097746700049, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06845097746700049, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.225, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06845097746700049, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a slender teenage African-American girl wearing thin, black-framed glasses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the girl's hands stained with black soil while she handles a tiny, vibrant green sprout with three leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the girl fumbling with the plant before successfully placing it into a pre-dug hole in dark soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin a slow, steady zoom out to reveal more of the girl kneeling on the garden plot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in soft, warm afternoon sun with a gentle breeze causing the seedling leaves to rustle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22605355083942413 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6010535955429077 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.22605355083942413, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.22605355083942413, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1416715681552887, + 0.027771584689617157, + 0.08974555134773254, + 0.06148828938603401, + 0.04119080677628517, + 0.03017369844019413, + 0.21829527616500854, + 0.03972474858164787, + 0.10608267039060593, + 0.2438557893037796 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.22605355083942413 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a slender teenage African-American girl wearing thin, black-framed glasses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the girl's hands stained with black soil while she handles a tiny, vibrant green sprout with three leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the girl fumbling with the plant before successfully placing it into a pre-dug hole in dark soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin a slow, steady zoom out to reveal more of the girl kneeling on the garden plot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in soft, warm afternoon sun with a gentle breeze causing the seedling leaves to rustle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008656713180243969 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.7586565017700195 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008656713180243969, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008656713180243969, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.027693217620253563, + 0.03577541559934616, + 0.02073890157043934, + 0.04112553223967552, + 0.02836735174059868, + 0.04661465436220169, + 0.23002789914608002, + 0.027487901970744133, + 0.10926523804664612, + 0.43290388584136963 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008656713180243969 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a slender teenage African-American girl wearing thin, black-framed glasses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the girl's hands stained with black soil while she handles a tiny, vibrant green sprout with three leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the girl fumbling with the plant before successfully placing it into a pre-dug hole in dark soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin a slow, steady zoom out to reveal more of the girl kneeling on the garden plot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in soft, warm afternoon sun with a gentle breeze causing the seedling leaves to rustle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026348400861024857 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651348352432251 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026348400861024857, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026348400861024857, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05446929484605789, + 0.023957105353474617, + 0.03607560694217682, + 0.07550870627164841, + 0.021124836057424545, + 0.06924890726804733, + 0.1766599416732788, + 0.04410563036799431, + 0.10197634994983673, + 0.3968735635280609 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026348400861024857 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a slender teenage African-American girl wearing thin, black-framed glasses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the girl's hands stained with black soil while she handles a tiny, vibrant green sprout with three leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the girl fumbling with the plant before successfully placing it into a pre-dug hole in dark soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin a slow, steady zoom out to reveal more of the girl kneeling on the garden plot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in soft, warm afternoon sun with a gentle breeze causing the seedling leaves to rustle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.038099367171525955 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2880992889404297 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.038099367171525955, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.038099367171525955, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07886731624603271, + 0.04655446112155914, + 0.03927972540259361, + 0.04655865952372551, + 0.04508937522768974, + 0.1117313951253891, + 0.17081141471862793, + 0.06308300793170929, + 0.14799760282039642, + 0.25002703070640564 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.038099367171525955 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a slender teenage African-American girl wearing thin, black-framed glasses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the girl's hands stained with black soil while she handles a tiny, vibrant green sprout with three leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the girl fumbling with the plant before successfully placing it into a pre-dug hole in dark soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin a slow, steady zoom out to reveal more of the girl kneeling on the garden plot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in soft, warm afternoon sun with a gentle breeze causing the seedling leaves to rustle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04309685528278351 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680967807769775 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04309685528278351, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04309685528278351, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11391890794038773, + 0.040944475680589676, + 0.04259549453854561, + 0.015697676688432693, + 0.01868543215095997, + 0.034343596547842026, + 0.431751012802124, + 0.13213558495044708, + 0.05623793601989746, + 0.11368989944458008 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04309685528278351 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "This extreme close-up, shot from a slightly elevated frontal angle, initially captures the delicate movements of a slender teenage African-American girl planting a seedling. Her face, intensely focused, is in focus, as is thin, black-framed glasses. Neat rows of corn emerge from beneath the soft fabric of her heather-gray cotton hoodie. Her slender hands, stained with black soil, move swiftly but clumsily, grasping a tiny, vibrant green sprout with three delicate leaves and a fragile root ball. In a heartbreaking moment, her fingers fumble, and the tiny plant nearly drops, before she quickly readjusts her grip. Then, refocusing, she steadily and deliberately lowers the seedling into a pre-dug hole in the fertile, dark soil. As she successfully completes the placement, the camera begins a slow, steady zoom out, gradually revealing more of her kneeling figure on the garden plot. A gentle breeze sweeps across the scene, causing the tiny leaves of the seedlings to rustle subtly, bathed in the soft, warm afternoon sun, creating an atmosphere of tranquility and hope.", + "seed": 16557, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_8/index_3579_seed_16557_dp_17_rank_34_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.31859082356095314, + "vlm_logprob": -0.31859082356095314, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.8, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.31859082356095314, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a slender teenage African-American girl wearing thin, black-framed glasses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the girl's hands stained with black soil while she handles a tiny, vibrant green sprout with three leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the girl fumbling with the plant before successfully placing it into a pre-dug hole in dark soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin a slow, steady zoom out to reveal more of the girl kneeling on the garden plot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in soft, warm afternoon sun with a gentle breeze causing the seedling leaves to rustle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5026726722717285 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2526727318763733 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.5026726722717285, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -1.5026726722717285, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06561855971813202, + 0.17550477385520935, + 0.022217603400349617, + 0.0382622592151165, + 0.1894311159849167, + 0.03256940841674805, + 0.2788131833076477, + 0.015777630731463432, + 0.14284662902355194, + 0.038958944380283356 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.5026726722717285 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a slender teenage African-American girl wearing thin, black-framed glasses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the girl's hands stained with black soil while she handles a tiny, vibrant green sprout with three leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the girl fumbling with the plant before successfully placing it into a pre-dug hole in dark soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin a slow, steady zoom out to reveal more of the girl kneeling on the garden plot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in soft, warm afternoon sun with a gentle breeze causing the seedling leaves to rustle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023347236216068268 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7733471393585205 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023347236216068268, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023347236216068268, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04278090223670006, + 0.023344697430729866, + 0.027567069977521896, + 0.05069949850440025, + 0.1623128354549408, + 0.1023486778140068, + 0.2819851040840149, + 0.013384291902184486, + 0.2674016058444977, + 0.028175294399261475 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023347236216068268 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a slender teenage African-American girl wearing thin, black-framed glasses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the girl's hands stained with black soil while she handles a tiny, vibrant green sprout with three leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the girl fumbling with the plant before successfully placing it into a pre-dug hole in dark soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin a slow, steady zoom out to reveal more of the girl kneeling on the garden plot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in soft, warm afternoon sun with a gentle breeze causing the seedling leaves to rustle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014201529324054718 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264201641082764 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014201529324054718, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014201529324054718, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04379976913332939, + 0.06097954511642456, + 0.04747386276721954, + 0.03698022663593292, + 0.530897319316864, + 0.022013749927282333, + 0.01847778633236885, + 0.03126506879925728, + 0.16149672865867615, + 0.04661589860916138 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014201529324054718 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a slender teenage African-American girl wearing thin, black-framed glasses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the girl's hands stained with black soil while she handles a tiny, vibrant green sprout with three leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the girl fumbling with the plant before successfully placing it into a pre-dug hole in dark soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin a slow, steady zoom out to reveal more of the girl kneeling on the garden plot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in soft, warm afternoon sun with a gentle breeze causing the seedling leaves to rustle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026352928951382637 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651352882385254 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026352928951382637, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026352928951382637, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03469030559062958, + 0.14065730571746826, + 0.01566532626748085, + 0.03413156047463417, + 0.4884202182292938, + 0.05860235542058945, + 0.08108502626419067, + 0.014307934790849686, + 0.06151396036148071, + 0.0709259882569313 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026352928951382637 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a slender teenage African-American girl wearing thin, black-framed glasses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the girl's hands stained with black soil while she handles a tiny, vibrant green sprout with three leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the girl fumbling with the plant before successfully placing it into a pre-dug hole in dark soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin a slow, steady zoom out to reveal more of the girl kneeling on the garden plot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in soft, warm afternoon sun with a gentle breeze causing the seedling leaves to rustle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026379751041531563 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513798236846924 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026379751041531563, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026379751041531563, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.058618273586034775, + 0.29571688175201416, + 0.027123644948005676, + 0.047531820833683014, + 0.07318924367427826, + 0.041956864297389984, + 0.07498928159475327, + 0.05379331111907959, + 0.22944635152816772, + 0.09763437509536743 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026379751041531563 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "This extreme close-up, shot from a slightly elevated frontal angle, initially captures the delicate movements of a slender teenage African-American girl planting a seedling. Her face, intensely focused, is in focus, as is thin, black-framed glasses. Neat rows of corn emerge from beneath the soft fabric of her heather-gray cotton hoodie. Her slender hands, stained with black soil, move swiftly but clumsily, grasping a tiny, vibrant green sprout with three delicate leaves and a fragile root ball. In a heartbreaking moment, her fingers fumble, and the tiny plant nearly drops, before she quickly readjusts her grip. Then, refocusing, she steadily and deliberately lowers the seedling into a pre-dug hole in the fertile, dark soil. As she successfully completes the placement, the camera begins a slow, steady zoom out, gradually revealing more of her kneeling figure on the garden plot. A gentle breeze sweeps across the scene, causing the tiny leaves of the seedlings to rustle subtly, bathed in the soft, warm afternoon sun, creating an atmosphere of tranquility and hope.", + "seed": 16558, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_8/index_3579_seed_16558_dp_17_rank_34_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.5396898865699769, + "vlm_logprob": -0.5396898865699769, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.825, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.5396898865699769, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a slender teenage African-American girl wearing thin, black-framed glasses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the girl's hands stained with black soil while she handles a tiny, vibrant green sprout with three leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the girl fumbling with the plant before successfully placing it into a pre-dug hole in dark soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin a slow, steady zoom out to reveal more of the girl kneeling on the garden plot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in soft, warm afternoon sun with a gentle breeze causing the seedling leaves to rustle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.464402198791504 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0894022211432457 + ], + "logprob_reward": -2.464402198791504, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -2.464402198791504, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17789921164512634, + 0.19468829035758972, + 0.0356491394340992, + 0.08415848016738892, + 0.06773380935192108, + 0.026279423385858536, + 0.11254902929067612, + 0.1724940538406372, + 0.0322381854057312, + 0.09631048142910004 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -2.464402198791504 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a slender teenage African-American girl wearing thin, black-framed glasses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the girl's hands stained with black soil while she handles a tiny, vibrant green sprout with three leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the girl fumbling with the plant before successfully placing it into a pre-dug hole in dark soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin a slow, steady zoom out to reveal more of the girl kneeling on the garden plot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in soft, warm afternoon sun with a gentle breeze causing the seedling leaves to rustle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07016674429178238 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695166826248169 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07016674429178238, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07016674429178238, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14344993233680725, + 0.19191278517246246, + 0.025212401524186134, + 0.07732903212308884, + 0.04515313729643822, + 0.03158589452505112, + 0.0909150019288063, + 0.10145984590053558, + 0.2048894762992859, + 0.08809248358011246 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07016674429178238 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a slender teenage African-American girl wearing thin, black-framed glasses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the girl's hands stained with black soil while she handles a tiny, vibrant green sprout with three leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the girl fumbling with the plant before successfully placing it into a pre-dug hole in dark soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin a slow, steady zoom out to reveal more of the girl kneeling on the garden plot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in soft, warm afternoon sun with a gentle breeze causing the seedling leaves to rustle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07902248948812485 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5790224075317383 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07902248948812485, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07902248948812485, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10353299975395203, + 0.12826256453990936, + 0.0329810306429863, + 0.0702165737748146, + 0.1140640527009964, + 0.054398588836193085, + 0.06972713023424149, + 0.2003943920135498, + 0.12610499560832977, + 0.10031762719154358 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07902248948812485 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a slender teenage African-American girl wearing thin, black-framed glasses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the girl's hands stained with black soil while she handles a tiny, vibrant green sprout with three leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the girl fumbling with the plant before successfully placing it into a pre-dug hole in dark soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin a slow, steady zoom out to reveal more of the girl kneeling on the garden plot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in soft, warm afternoon sun with a gentle breeze causing the seedling leaves to rustle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029825512319803238 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529825448989868 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029825512319803238, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029825512319803238, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20002692937850952, + 0.06817934662103653, + 0.01924644596874714, + 0.10698679089546204, + 0.04404263198375702, + 0.03401578217744827, + 0.056939560920000076, + 0.12095391005277634, + 0.20471230149269104, + 0.14489629864692688 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029825512319803238 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a slender teenage African-American girl wearing thin, black-framed glasses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the girl's hands stained with black soil while she handles a tiny, vibrant green sprout with three leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the girl fumbling with the plant before successfully placing it into a pre-dug hole in dark soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin a slow, steady zoom out to reveal more of the girl kneeling on the garden plot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in soft, warm afternoon sun with a gentle breeze causing the seedling leaves to rustle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05503248795866966 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.93003249168396 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05503248795866966, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05503248795866966, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.222398579120636, + 0.15718673169612885, + 0.0453067310154438, + 0.13019536435604095, + 0.034511156380176544, + 0.04955005645751953, + 0.0376480296254158, + 0.11032135039567947, + 0.15297360718250275, + 0.05990837886929512 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05503248795866966 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_9/index_tensor([9833, 9833])_group_9_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_9/index_tensor([9833, 9833])_group_9_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..51ae6d9fd6d1454d41206d7b6360ddde4534d732 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_9/index_tensor([9833, 9833])_group_9_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "In a gritty, industrial cinematography style, a low-angle close-up begins, slowly and deliberately panning to the right, tracking a large, black bull shark feeding in the murky waters. The creature's skin is a deep, oily black, reflecting harsh, filtered light with a sleek sheen. Its broad, flat head, adorned with long, sensitive barbs, methodically drags along the silty bottom. It navigates a desolate underwater landscape, surrounded by massive, rust-colored industrial pipes, their surfaces heavily corroded and grime-covered, fading into the darkness. The water itself is a cloudy, green-brown soup, its surface punctuated by a shimmering sheen of metallic pollutants that catch the light like an oil slick, while suspended particles drift lazily through the water column. With deliberate, forceful undulations of its body, the bull shark steadily advances, its head occasionally thrusting into the soft sediment in search of food, creating a grim and bleak portrait of survival in a polluted, man-made environment.", + "seed": 24453, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_9/index_9833_seed_24453_dp_18_rank_36_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.2101217806339264, + "vlm_logprob": -0.2101217806339264, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.575, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.2101217806339264, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large black bull shark with a deep oily black skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shark's head broad, flat, and adorned with long sensitive barbs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the shark methodically dragging its head along a silty bottom while advancing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a murky underwater landscape with massive rust-colored corroded industrial pipes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle close-up and slowly pan to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4291655123233795 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.0541654825210571 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.4291655123233795, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.4291655123233795, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.066623754799366, + 0.03399618715047836, + 0.045053303241729736, + 0.4590400457382202, + 0.09241988509893417, + 0.046837709844112396, + 0.04041602462530136, + 0.10051637142896652, + 0.06377625465393066, + 0.05132048577070236 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 7, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.4291655123233795 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large black bull shark with a deep oily black skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shark's head broad, flat, and adorned with long sensitive barbs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the shark methodically dragging its head along a silty bottom while advancing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a murky underwater landscape with massive rust-colored corroded industrial pipes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle close-up and slowly pan to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17990976572036743 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8049097061157227 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17990976572036743, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17990976572036743, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0694974735379219, + 0.038596756756305695, + 0.09501666575670242, + 0.3778753876686096, + 0.12241891771554947, + 0.03978521004319191, + 0.029211826622486115, + 0.10225380957126617, + 0.029061321169137955, + 0.09628267586231232 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17990976572036743 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large black bull shark with a deep oily black skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shark's head broad, flat, and adorned with long sensitive barbs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the shark methodically dragging its head along a silty bottom while advancing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a murky underwater landscape with massive rust-colored corroded industrial pipes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle close-up and slowly pan to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11293575167655945 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.237935781478882 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11293575167655945, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11293575167655945, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07115383446216583, + 0.06141794100403786, + 0.10452631860971451, + 0.25610780715942383, + 0.17468029260635376, + 0.14121778309345245, + 0.02918391488492489, + 0.07045435160398483, + 0.028718212619423866, + 0.06253951787948608 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11293575167655945 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large black bull shark with a deep oily black skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shark's head broad, flat, and adorned with long sensitive barbs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the shark methodically dragging its head along a silty bottom while advancing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a murky underwater landscape with massive rust-colored corroded industrial pipes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle close-up and slowly pan to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12705278396606445 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1270527839660645 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12705278396606445, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12705278396606445, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.074122853577137, + 0.10488639026880264, + 0.06057018041610718, + 0.3163931965827942, + 0.2105257362127304, + 0.05352212116122246, + 0.018262211233377457, + 0.02488536573946476, + 0.028140513226389885, + 0.10869143903255463 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12705278396606445 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large black bull shark with a deep oily black skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shark's head broad, flat, and adorned with long sensitive barbs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the shark methodically dragging its head along a silty bottom while advancing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a murky underwater landscape with massive rust-colored corroded industrial pipes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle close-up and slowly pan to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2015450894832611 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7015451192855835 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2015450894832611, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2015450894832611, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11873891204595566, + 0.07001440227031708, + 0.04733528569340706, + 0.0520942322909832, + 0.10145726054906845, + 0.1755574643611908, + 0.04369385167956352, + 0.05285640060901642, + 0.06210845336318016, + 0.2761436998844147 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2015450894832611 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a gritty, industrial cinematography style, a low-angle close-up begins, slowly and deliberately panning to the right, tracking a large, black bull shark feeding in the murky waters. The creature's skin is a deep, oily black, reflecting harsh, filtered light with a sleek sheen. Its broad, flat head, adorned with long, sensitive barbs, methodically drags along the silty bottom. It navigates a desolate underwater landscape, surrounded by massive, rust-colored industrial pipes, their surfaces heavily corroded and grime-covered, fading into the darkness. The water itself is a cloudy, green-brown soup, its surface punctuated by a shimmering sheen of metallic pollutants that catch the light like an oil slick, while suspended particles drift lazily through the water column. With deliberate, forceful undulations of its body, the bull shark steadily advances, its head occasionally thrusting into the soft sediment in search of food, creating a grim and bleak portrait of survival in a polluted, man-made environment.", + "seed": 24454, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_9/index_9833_seed_24454_dp_18_rank_36_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.14458234179764987, + "vlm_logprob": -0.14458234179764987, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.6249999940395354, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.14458234179764987, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large black bull shark with a deep oily black skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shark's head broad, flat, and adorned with long sensitive barbs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the shark methodically dragging its head along a silty bottom while advancing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a murky underwater landscape with massive rust-colored corroded industrial pipes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle close-up and slowly pan to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4745399057865143 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9745398759841919 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.4745399057865143, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.4999999701976776, + "token_credit_reward": -0.4745399057865143, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05002540349960327, + 0.0829121544957161, + 0.10486657917499542, + 0.26288577914237976, + 0.07379227131605148, + 0.12212388217449188, + 0.074554942548275, + 0.04784490913152695, + 0.0962771624326706, + 0.08471695333719254 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 5, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.4745399057865143 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large black bull shark with a deep oily black skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shark's head broad, flat, and adorned with long sensitive barbs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the shark methodically dragging its head along a silty bottom while advancing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a murky underwater landscape with massive rust-colored corroded industrial pipes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle close-up and slowly pan to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0790080577135086 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.579008102416992 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0790080577135086, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0790080577135086, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.025442281737923622, + 0.03172846511006355, + 0.15513679385185242, + 0.6264968514442444, + 0.016938522458076477, + 0.039016734808683395, + 0.022145960479974747, + 0.008120635524392128, + 0.032306939363479614, + 0.04266681894659996 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0790080577135086 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large black bull shark with a deep oily black skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shark's head broad, flat, and adorned with long sensitive barbs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the shark methodically dragging its head along a silty bottom while advancing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a murky underwater landscape with massive rust-colored corroded industrial pipes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle close-up and slowly pan to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03370029106736183 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4087002277374268 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03370029106736183, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03370029106736183, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04429181292653084, + 0.05292503908276558, + 0.1758241504430771, + 0.4411395788192749, + 0.056371480226516724, + 0.06796728819608688, + 0.03244689851999283, + 0.022268172353506088, + 0.0571884885430336, + 0.04957714304327965 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03370029106736183 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large black bull shark with a deep oily black skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shark's head broad, flat, and adorned with long sensitive barbs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the shark methodically dragging its head along a silty bottom while advancing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a murky underwater landscape with massive rust-colored corroded industrial pipes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle close-up and slowly pan to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008639340288937092 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758639335632324 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008639340288937092, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008639340288937092, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.049507495015859604, + 0.07664182037115097, + 0.05382489040493965, + 0.5216853022575378, + 0.03939802572131157, + 0.06226266175508499, + 0.023968452587723732, + 0.03125263750553131, + 0.065196193754673, + 0.07626254856586456 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008639340288937092 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large black bull shark with a deep oily black skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shark's head broad, flat, and adorned with long sensitive barbs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the shark methodically dragging its head along a silty bottom while advancing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a murky underwater landscape with massive rust-colored corroded industrial pipes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle close-up and slowly pan to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1270241141319275 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1270241737365723 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1270241141319275, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1270241141319275, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.020011192187666893, + 0.03521689400076866, + 0.026526307687163353, + 0.6857621669769287, + 0.040266312658786774, + 0.08704778552055359, + 0.055292610079050064, + 0.01584460213780403, + 0.02176753059029579, + 0.012264595367014408 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1270241141319275 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a gritty, industrial cinematography style, a low-angle close-up begins, slowly and deliberately panning to the right, tracking a large, black bull shark feeding in the murky waters. The creature's skin is a deep, oily black, reflecting harsh, filtered light with a sleek sheen. Its broad, flat head, adorned with long, sensitive barbs, methodically drags along the silty bottom. It navigates a desolate underwater landscape, surrounded by massive, rust-colored industrial pipes, their surfaces heavily corroded and grime-covered, fading into the darkness. The water itself is a cloudy, green-brown soup, its surface punctuated by a shimmering sheen of metallic pollutants that catch the light like an oil slick, while suspended particles drift lazily through the water column. With deliberate, forceful undulations of its body, the bull shark steadily advances, its head occasionally thrusting into the soft sediment in search of food, creating a grim and bleak portrait of survival in a polluted, man-made environment.", + "seed": 24455, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_9/index_9833_seed_24455_dp_19_rank_38_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.17969861440360546, + "vlm_logprob": -0.17969861440360546, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.325, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.17969861440360546, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large black bull shark with a deep oily black skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shark's head broad, flat, and adorned with long sensitive barbs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the shark methodically dragging its head along a silty bottom while advancing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a murky underwater landscape with massive rust-colored corroded industrial pipes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle close-up and slowly pan to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6328656673431396 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7578656673431396 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.6328656673431396, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.6328656673431396, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08807315677404404, + 0.22541970014572144, + 0.09999661147594452, + 0.06950802356004715, + 0.028795981779694557, + 0.016276460140943527, + 0.0401528924703598, + 0.1624380499124527, + 0.23043495416641235, + 0.03890413045883179 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.6328656673431396 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large black bull shark with a deep oily black skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shark's head broad, flat, and adorned with long sensitive barbs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the shark methodically dragging its head along a silty bottom while advancing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a murky underwater landscape with massive rust-colored corroded industrial pipes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle close-up and slowly pan to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11297110468149185 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.237971067428589 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11297110468149185, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11297110468149185, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11499514430761337, + 0.07708855718374252, + 0.1285330206155777, + 0.04024268314242363, + 0.02741432376205921, + 0.05945538729429245, + 0.03360404074192047, + 0.1586339920759201, + 0.27841195464134216, + 0.0816209688782692 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11297110468149185 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large black bull shark with a deep oily black skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shark's head broad, flat, and adorned with long sensitive barbs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the shark methodically dragging its head along a silty bottom while advancing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a murky underwater landscape with massive rust-colored corroded industrial pipes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle close-up and slowly pan to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.043064314872026443 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680643558502197 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.043064314872026443, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.043064314872026443, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21109069883823395, + 0.1616993546485901, + 0.03961392492055893, + 0.0847964882850647, + 0.0279689971357584, + 0.040150195360183716, + 0.03397683799266815, + 0.064442940056324, + 0.3090026378631592, + 0.027257977053523064 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.043064314872026443 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large black bull shark with a deep oily black skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shark's head broad, flat, and adorned with long sensitive barbs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the shark methodically dragging its head along a silty bottom while advancing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a murky underwater landscape with massive rust-colored corroded industrial pipes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle close-up and slowly pan to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02058207429945469 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955819606781006 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02058207429945469, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02058207429945469, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09563983976840973, + 0.09953232854604721, + 0.14649276435375214, + 0.13539718091487885, + 0.03394177928566933, + 0.11195284128189087, + 0.026340162381529808, + 0.06962919235229492, + 0.24292875826358795, + 0.03814515843987465 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02058207429945469 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large black bull shark with a deep oily black skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shark's head broad, flat, and adorned with long sensitive barbs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the shark methodically dragging its head along a silty bottom while advancing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a murky underwater landscape with massive rust-colored corroded industrial pipes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle close-up and slowly pan to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08900991082191467 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.464010000228882 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08900991082191467, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08900991082191467, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19418437778949738, + 0.11607131361961365, + 0.09928905218839645, + 0.04685060307383537, + 0.07118653506040573, + 0.16155625879764557, + 0.13739854097366333, + 0.03132506087422371, + 0.09432335197925568, + 0.047814853489398956 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08900991082191467 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a gritty, industrial cinematography style, a low-angle close-up begins, slowly and deliberately panning to the right, tracking a large, black bull shark feeding in the murky waters. The creature's skin is a deep, oily black, reflecting harsh, filtered light with a sleek sheen. Its broad, flat head, adorned with long, sensitive barbs, methodically drags along the silty bottom. It navigates a desolate underwater landscape, surrounded by massive, rust-colored industrial pipes, their surfaces heavily corroded and grime-covered, fading into the darkness. The water itself is a cloudy, green-brown soup, its surface punctuated by a shimmering sheen of metallic pollutants that catch the light like an oil slick, while suspended particles drift lazily through the water column. With deliberate, forceful undulations of its body, the bull shark steadily advances, its head occasionally thrusting into the soft sediment in search of food, creating a grim and bleak portrait of survival in a polluted, man-made environment.", + "seed": 24456, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000186/group_9/index_9833_seed_24456_dp_19_rank_38_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.1689674887806177, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1689674887806177, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.2, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1689674887806177, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large black bull shark with a deep oily black skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shark's head broad, flat, and adorned with long sensitive barbs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the shark methodically dragging its head along a silty bottom while advancing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a murky underwater landscape with massive rust-colored corroded industrial pipes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle close-up and slowly pan to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5235339403152466 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8985339403152466 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5235339403152466, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5235339403152466, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04975353926420212, + 0.01646636798977852, + 0.08153708279132843, + 0.03256862238049507, + 0.046055905520915985, + 0.0290907621383667, + 0.24066726863384247, + 0.1458451747894287, + 0.12850525975227356, + 0.22951000928878784 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5235339403152466 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large black bull shark with a deep oily black skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shark's head broad, flat, and adorned with long sensitive barbs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the shark methodically dragging its head along a silty bottom while advancing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a murky underwater landscape with massive rust-colored corroded industrial pipes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle close-up and slowly pan to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11296556890010834 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2379655838012695 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11296556890010834, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11296556890010834, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.043850820511579514, + 0.030930450186133385, + 0.13978031277656555, + 0.048684000968933105, + 0.05555499717593193, + 0.04687214270234108, + 0.11728990077972412, + 0.16160176694393158, + 0.05138289928436279, + 0.3040527105331421 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11296556890010834 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large black bull shark with a deep oily black skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shark's head broad, flat, and adorned with long sensitive barbs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the shark methodically dragging its head along a silty bottom while advancing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a murky underwater landscape with massive rust-colored corroded industrial pipes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle close-up and slowly pan to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05495835840702057 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299583435058594 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05495835840702057, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05495835840702057, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07734082639217377, + 0.046237897127866745, + 0.046760860830545425, + 0.06350671499967575, + 0.06519590318202972, + 0.02882426604628563, + 0.12097484618425369, + 0.2424827367067337, + 0.11967295408248901, + 0.18900299072265625 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05495835840702057 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large black bull shark with a deep oily black skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shark's head broad, flat, and adorned with long sensitive barbs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the shark methodically dragging its head along a silty bottom while advancing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a murky underwater landscape with massive rust-colored corroded industrial pipes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle close-up and slowly pan to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026354091241955757 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513540744781494 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026354091241955757, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026354091241955757, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07465022802352905, + 0.061243414878845215, + 0.10655470192432404, + 0.06441563367843628, + 0.08118408918380737, + 0.024555010721087456, + 0.09487366676330566, + 0.12528884410858154, + 0.09280901402235031, + 0.2744253873825073 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026354091241955757 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large black bull shark with a deep oily black skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shark's head broad, flat, and adorned with long sensitive barbs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the shark methodically dragging its head along a silty bottom while advancing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a murky underwater landscape with massive rust-colored corroded industrial pipes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle close-up and slowly pan to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12702548503875732 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.127025604248047 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12702548503875732, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12702548503875732, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05539049953222275, + 0.041443392634391785, + 0.052503131330013275, + 0.026951277628540993, + 0.10831024497747421, + 0.04107387363910675, + 0.20730642974376678, + 0.12067218869924545, + 0.05928299203515053, + 0.2870660126209259 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12702548503875732 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_0/index_tensor([1131, 1131])_group_0_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_0/index_tensor([1131, 1131])_group_0_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..6be9cb6e1da7e4551ad0ec4f1384856595c9196b --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_0/index_tensor([1131, 1131])_group_0_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "static, extreme close-up captures a stack of three perfectly round, fluffy pancakes on a clean white ceramic plate, their surface a beautiful golden-brown with a porous, spongy texture. Warm, soft morning sunlight, streaming from an off-camera source, backlights a thick, viscous stream of golden-amber syrup as it deliberately seeps down the side of the stack. The light creates bright, shimmering highlights on the syrup's smooth surface, revealing tiny bubbles trapped within its translucent depths. The syrup's movement is almost imperceptibly slow as it solidifies, thickening at the edges as it pools at the bottom of the pancakes, creating a sense of decadent tranquility. The shallow depth of field renders the background into a soft, fuzzy blur, enhancing the scene's tranquil, appetizing, and comforting atmosphere, which is preserved for a final moment before gently and smoothly fading to black.", + "seed": 17444, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_0/index_1131_seed_17444_dp_0_rank_0_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.05331863397732377, + "vlm_logprob": -0.05331863397732377, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.975, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.05331863397732377, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static extreme close-up of a stack of three perfectly round, fluffy pancakes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the pancakes on a clean white ceramic plate with a golden-brown, porous, and spongy surface texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a thick, viscous stream of golden-amber syrup seen seeping down the side of the pancake stack?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature warm, soft morning sunlight backlighting the syrup to create bright highlights and visible tiny bubbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background rendered as a soft, fuzzy blur due to a shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22639648616313934 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6013964414596558 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.22639648616313934, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.22639648616313934, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12339349836111069, + 0.023436404764652252, + 0.10075893998146057, + 0.09917569160461426, + 0.04428436607122421, + 0.05257595330476761, + 0.07085912674665451, + 0.033207084983587265, + 0.3595716059207916, + 0.09273736923933029 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.22639648616313934 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static extreme close-up of a stack of three perfectly round, fluffy pancakes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the pancakes on a clean white ceramic plate with a golden-brown, porous, and spongy surface texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a thick, viscous stream of golden-amber syrup seen seeping down the side of the pancake stack?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature warm, soft morning sunlight backlighting the syrup to create bright highlights and visible tiny bubbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background rendered as a soft, fuzzy blur due to a shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009823078289628029 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634822845458984 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009823078289628029, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009823078289628029, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04268130287528038, + 0.017705952748656273, + 0.13840171694755554, + 0.4748898148536682, + 0.041617266833782196, + 0.04142387956380844, + 0.045842599123716354, + 0.0316506065428257, + 0.12715819478034973, + 0.03862860053777695 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009823078289628029 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static extreme close-up of a stack of three perfectly round, fluffy pancakes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the pancakes on a clean white ceramic plate with a golden-brown, porous, and spongy surface texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a thick, viscous stream of golden-amber syrup seen seeping down the side of the pancake stack?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature warm, soft morning sunlight backlighting the syrup to create bright highlights and visible tiny bubbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background rendered as a soft, fuzzy blur due to a shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01255748514086008 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387557506561279 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01255748514086008, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01255748514086008, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12925384938716888, + 0.07854285091161728, + 0.22244244813919067, + 0.10012193024158478, + 0.01003555953502655, + 0.04458995535969734, + 0.036179933696985245, + 0.051024023443460464, + 0.29713690280914307, + 0.03067256510257721 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01255748514086008 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static extreme close-up of a stack of three perfectly round, fluffy pancakes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the pancakes on a clean white ceramic plate with a golden-brown, porous, and spongy surface texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a thick, viscous stream of golden-amber syrup seen seeping down the side of the pancake stack?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature warm, soft morning sunlight backlighting the syrup to create bright highlights and visible tiny bubbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background rendered as a soft, fuzzy blur due to a shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011079339310526848 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.51107931137085 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011079339310526848, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011079339310526848, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04462810233235359, + 0.0413447767496109, + 0.058163516223430634, + 0.301906019449234, + 0.03655160963535309, + 0.04126793518662453, + 0.03402743488550186, + 0.056548573076725006, + 0.33911094069480896, + 0.046451035887002945 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011079339310526848 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static extreme close-up of a stack of three perfectly round, fluffy pancakes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the pancakes on a clean white ceramic plate with a golden-brown, porous, and spongy surface texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a thick, viscous stream of golden-amber syrup seen seeping down the side of the pancake stack?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature warm, soft morning sunlight backlighting the syrup to create bright highlights and visible tiny bubbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background rendered as a soft, fuzzy blur due to a shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006736780982464552 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006736755371094 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006736780982464552, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006736780982464552, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.02556869573891163, + 0.016047243028879166, + 0.03827319294214249, + 0.46712735295295715, + 0.023231731727719307, + 0.07189973443746567, + 0.08867082744836807, + 0.031015219166874886, + 0.19695767760276794, + 0.04120831936597824 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006736780982464552 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, extreme close-up captures a stack of three perfectly round, fluffy pancakes on a clean white ceramic plate, their surface a beautiful golden-brown with a porous, spongy texture. Warm, soft morning sunlight, streaming from an off-camera source, backlights a thick, viscous stream of golden-amber syrup as it deliberately seeps down the side of the stack. The light creates bright, shimmering highlights on the syrup's smooth surface, revealing tiny bubbles trapped within its translucent depths. The syrup's movement is almost imperceptibly slow as it solidifies, thickening at the edges as it pools at the bottom of the pancakes, creating a sense of decadent tranquility. The shallow depth of field renders the background into a soft, fuzzy blur, enhancing the scene's tranquil, appetizing, and comforting atmosphere, which is preserved for a final moment before gently and smoothly fading to black.", + "seed": 17445, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_0/index_1131_seed_17445_dp_0_rank_0_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.07734696287661791, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07734696287661791, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.675, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07734696287661791, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static extreme close-up of a stack of three perfectly round, fluffy pancakes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the pancakes on a clean white ceramic plate with a golden-brown, porous, and spongy surface texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a thick, viscous stream of golden-amber syrup seen seeping down the side of the pancake stack?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature warm, soft morning sunlight backlighting the syrup to create bright highlights and visible tiny bubbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background rendered as a soft, fuzzy blur due to a shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.31433719396591187 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3143372535705566 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.31433719396591187, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.31433719396591187, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04595750570297241, + 0.08741597086191177, + 0.10604876279830933, + 0.05958355590701103, + 0.06727520376443863, + 0.11009839177131653, + 0.10010802745819092, + 0.11750949919223785, + 0.19130589067935944, + 0.11469713598489761 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.31433719396591187 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static extreme close-up of a stack of three perfectly round, fluffy pancakes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the pancakes on a clean white ceramic plate with a golden-brown, porous, and spongy surface texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a thick, viscous stream of golden-amber syrup seen seeping down the side of the pancake stack?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature warm, soft morning sunlight backlighting the syrup to create bright highlights and visible tiny bubbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background rendered as a soft, fuzzy blur due to a shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.043185342103242874 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168185234069824 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.043185342103242874, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.043185342103242874, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.045697618275880814, + 0.10740884393453598, + 0.035402193665504456, + 0.08530348539352417, + 0.023846987634897232, + 0.09617304056882858, + 0.05601583793759346, + 0.080546073615551, + 0.39410579204559326, + 0.07550008594989777 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.043185342103242874 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static extreme close-up of a stack of three perfectly round, fluffy pancakes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the pancakes on a clean white ceramic plate with a golden-brown, porous, and spongy surface texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a thick, viscous stream of golden-amber syrup seen seeping down the side of the pancake stack?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature warm, soft morning sunlight backlighting the syrup to create bright highlights and visible tiny bubbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background rendered as a soft, fuzzy blur due to a shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012562429532408714 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387562274932861 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012562429532408714, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012562429532408714, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.030755555257201195, + 0.024613339453935623, + 0.02891351282596588, + 0.026384739205241203, + 0.042138099670410156, + 0.5545090436935425, + 0.026728380471467972, + 0.02874290943145752, + 0.1891714334487915, + 0.04804302752017975 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012562429532408714 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static extreme close-up of a stack of three perfectly round, fluffy pancakes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the pancakes on a clean white ceramic plate with a golden-brown, porous, and spongy surface texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a thick, viscous stream of golden-amber syrup seen seeping down the side of the pancake stack?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature warm, soft morning sunlight backlighting the syrup to create bright highlights and visible tiny bubbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background rendered as a soft, fuzzy blur due to a shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01254948042333126 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.38754940032959 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01254948042333126, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01254948042333126, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06981909275054932, + 0.0778241753578186, + 0.03820326551795006, + 0.07408743351697922, + 0.052382323890924454, + 0.1116524189710617, + 0.055663205683231354, + 0.06840541958808899, + 0.4131775498390198, + 0.0387851819396019 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01254948042333126 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static extreme close-up of a stack of three perfectly round, fluffy pancakes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the pancakes on a clean white ceramic plate with a golden-brown, porous, and spongy surface texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a thick, viscous stream of golden-amber syrup seen seeping down the side of the pancake stack?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature warm, soft morning sunlight backlighting the syrup to create bright highlights and visible tiny bubbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background rendered as a soft, fuzzy blur due to a shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004100368358194828 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504100322723389 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004100368358194828, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004100368358194828, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05262312293052673, + 0.04395334795117378, + 0.16191455721855164, + 0.12474225461483002, + 0.12500737607479095, + 0.13564801216125488, + 0.17472489178180695, + 0.04208006337285042, + 0.0917482003569603, + 0.04755827412009239 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004100368358194828 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, extreme close-up captures a stack of three perfectly round, fluffy pancakes on a clean white ceramic plate, their surface a beautiful golden-brown with a porous, spongy texture. Warm, soft morning sunlight, streaming from an off-camera source, backlights a thick, viscous stream of golden-amber syrup as it deliberately seeps down the side of the stack. The light creates bright, shimmering highlights on the syrup's smooth surface, revealing tiny bubbles trapped within its translucent depths. The syrup's movement is almost imperceptibly slow as it solidifies, thickening at the edges as it pools at the bottom of the pancakes, creating a sense of decadent tranquility. The shallow depth of field renders the background into a soft, fuzzy blur, enhancing the scene's tranquil, appetizing, and comforting atmosphere, which is preserved for a final moment before gently and smoothly fading to black.", + "seed": 17446, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_0/index_1131_seed_17446_dp_1_rank_2_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.0588480758946389, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0588480758946389, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.95, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0588480758946389, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static extreme close-up of a stack of three perfectly round, fluffy pancakes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the pancakes on a clean white ceramic plate with a golden-brown, porous, and spongy surface texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a thick, viscous stream of golden-amber syrup seen seeping down the side of the pancake stack?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature warm, soft morning sunlight backlighting the syrup to create bright highlights and visible tiny bubbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background rendered as a soft, fuzzy blur due to a shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22617773711681366 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.60117769241333 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.22617773711681366, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.22617773711681366, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25710755586624146, + 0.030724575743079185, + 0.04633811488747597, + 0.12062987685203552, + 0.1579558253288269, + 0.1194695234298706, + 0.07719289511442184, + 0.06138109043240547, + 0.05784638971090317, + 0.0713542029261589 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.22617773711681366 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static extreme close-up of a stack of three perfectly round, fluffy pancakes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the pancakes on a clean white ceramic plate with a golden-brown, porous, and spongy surface texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a thick, viscous stream of golden-amber syrup seen seeping down the side of the pancake stack?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature warm, soft morning sunlight backlighting the syrup to create bright highlights and visible tiny bubbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background rendered as a soft, fuzzy blur due to a shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009819891303777695 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634819984436035 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009819891303777695, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009819891303777695, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15461060404777527, + 0.0500226654112339, + 0.04393785446882248, + 0.029634106904268265, + 0.0581708699464798, + 0.14542479813098907, + 0.11726135015487671, + 0.12791436910629272, + 0.08790267258882523, + 0.18512070178985596 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009819891303777695 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static extreme close-up of a stack of three perfectly round, fluffy pancakes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the pancakes on a clean white ceramic plate with a golden-brown, porous, and spongy surface texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a thick, viscous stream of golden-amber syrup seen seeping down the side of the pancake stack?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature warm, soft morning sunlight backlighting the syrup to create bright highlights and visible tiny bubbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background rendered as a soft, fuzzy blur due to a shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0486777164041996 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048677682876587 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0486777164041996, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0486777164041996, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16190405189990997, + 0.0438741073012352, + 0.05615689232945442, + 0.17378279566764832, + 0.3063502609729767, + 0.07233916223049164, + 0.0481104850769043, + 0.05197980999946594, + 0.0663752555847168, + 0.019127095118165016 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0486777164041996 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static extreme close-up of a stack of three perfectly round, fluffy pancakes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the pancakes on a clean white ceramic plate with a golden-brown, porous, and spongy surface texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a thick, viscous stream of golden-amber syrup seen seeping down the side of the pancake stack?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature warm, soft morning sunlight backlighting the syrup to create bright highlights and visible tiny bubbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background rendered as a soft, fuzzy blur due to a shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005950592458248138 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130950450897217 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005950592458248138, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005950592458248138, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16619278490543365, + 0.08031158149242401, + 0.04306187480688095, + 0.11580882966518402, + 0.0632157176733017, + 0.2856466472148895, + 0.08528322726488113, + 0.04331054538488388, + 0.06353878974914551, + 0.05362999066710472 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005950592458248138 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static extreme close-up of a stack of three perfectly round, fluffy pancakes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the pancakes on a clean white ceramic plate with a golden-brown, porous, and spongy surface texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a thick, viscous stream of golden-amber syrup seen seeping down the side of the pancake stack?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature warm, soft morning sunlight backlighting the syrup to create bright highlights and visible tiny bubbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background rendered as a soft, fuzzy blur due to a shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003614442190155387 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.62861442565918 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003614442190155387, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003614442190155387, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25102514028549194, + 0.09853240102529526, + 0.07608742266893387, + 0.10799253731966019, + 0.0701657086610794, + 0.0491253025829792, + 0.10552000999450684, + 0.06445778906345367, + 0.11479338258504868, + 0.062300343066453934 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003614442190155387 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, extreme close-up captures a stack of three perfectly round, fluffy pancakes on a clean white ceramic plate, their surface a beautiful golden-brown with a porous, spongy texture. Warm, soft morning sunlight, streaming from an off-camera source, backlights a thick, viscous stream of golden-amber syrup as it deliberately seeps down the side of the stack. The light creates bright, shimmering highlights on the syrup's smooth surface, revealing tiny bubbles trapped within its translucent depths. The syrup's movement is almost imperceptibly slow as it solidifies, thickening at the edges as it pools at the bottom of the pancakes, creating a sense of decadent tranquility. The shallow depth of field renders the background into a soft, fuzzy blur, enhancing the scene's tranquil, appetizing, and comforting atmosphere, which is preserved for a final moment before gently and smoothly fading to black.", + "seed": 17447, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_0/index_1131_seed_17447_dp_1_rank_2_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.22752661537379026, + "vlm_logprob": -0.22752661537379026, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.099999988079071, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.22752661537379026, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static extreme close-up of a stack of three perfectly round, fluffy pancakes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the pancakes on a clean white ceramic plate with a golden-brown, porous, and spongy surface texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a thick, viscous stream of golden-amber syrup seen seeping down the side of the pancake stack?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature warm, soft morning sunlight backlighting the syrup to create bright highlights and visible tiny bubbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background rendered as a soft, fuzzy blur due to a shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.0544073581695557 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4294072985649109 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.0544073581695557, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.6250000596046448, + "token_credit_reward": -1.0544073581695557, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14845432341098785, + 0.4463416635990143, + 0.08950383216142654, + 0.03372989594936371, + 0.04269111901521683, + 0.1178530901670456, + 0.07907348871231079, + 0.014633124694228172, + 0.015059704892337322, + 0.012659817934036255 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.0544073581695557 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static extreme close-up of a stack of three perfectly round, fluffy pancakes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the pancakes on a clean white ceramic plate with a golden-brown, porous, and spongy surface texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a thick, viscous stream of golden-amber syrup seen seeping down the side of the pancake stack?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature warm, soft morning sunlight backlighting the syrup to create bright highlights and visible tiny bubbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background rendered as a soft, fuzzy blur due to a shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016138985753059387 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141139030456543 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016138985753059387, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016138985753059387, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0784187838435173, + 0.6302151679992676, + 0.025550680235028267, + 0.07093316316604614, + 0.010945781134068966, + 0.08282056450843811, + 0.07823893427848816, + 0.008842146955430508, + 0.0071209329180419445, + 0.006913871504366398 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016138985753059387 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static extreme close-up of a stack of three perfectly round, fluffy pancakes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the pancakes on a clean white ceramic plate with a golden-brown, porous, and spongy surface texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a thick, viscous stream of golden-amber syrup seen seeping down the side of the pancake stack?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature warm, soft morning sunlight backlighting the syrup to create bright highlights and visible tiny bubbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background rendered as a soft, fuzzy blur due to a shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04309308901429176 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168093204498291 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04309308901429176, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04309308901429176, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1253984272480011, + 0.5778592228889465, + 0.08039206266403198, + 0.022062748670578003, + 0.013966626487672329, + 0.05754907429218292, + 0.09204431623220444, + 0.00918340403586626, + 0.009135001339018345, + 0.012409165501594543 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04309308901429176 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static extreme close-up of a stack of three perfectly round, fluffy pancakes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the pancakes on a clean white ceramic plate with a golden-brown, porous, and spongy surface texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a thick, viscous stream of golden-amber syrup seen seeping down the side of the pancake stack?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature warm, soft morning sunlight backlighting the syrup to create bright highlights and visible tiny bubbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background rendered as a soft, fuzzy blur due to a shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014209285378456116 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264209270477295 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014209285378456116, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014209285378456116, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17397719621658325, + 0.1765843629837036, + 0.11761793494224548, + 0.04715569317340851, + 0.056787312030792236, + 0.20924736559391022, + 0.15472106635570526, + 0.03174721077084541, + 0.011377865448594093, + 0.02078397199511528 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014209285378456116 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static extreme close-up of a stack of three perfectly round, fluffy pancakes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the pancakes on a clean white ceramic plate with a golden-brown, porous, and spongy surface texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a thick, viscous stream of golden-amber syrup seen seeping down the side of the pancake stack?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature warm, soft morning sunlight backlighting the syrup to create bright highlights and visible tiny bubbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background rendered as a soft, fuzzy blur due to a shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00978435855358839 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.63478422164917 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00978435855358839, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00978435855358839, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07095129787921906, + 0.6775316596031189, + 0.09854248911142349, + 0.016977954655885696, + 0.01274797786027193, + 0.05859334021806717, + 0.04140767455101013, + 0.012008452787995338, + 0.004067493602633476, + 0.007171586621552706 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00978435855358839 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_1/index_tensor([7262, 7262])_group_1_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_1/index_tensor([7262, 7262])_group_1_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..6f8ec3bf7b91463f0266e6002aa14210c370e4d2 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_1/index_tensor([7262, 7262])_group_1_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "In a compelling close-up shot from a very low angle, a massive white tiger dominates the frame, its thick, pristine white fur streaked with jet-black stripes, each individual hair clearly visible in the dim light. Facing the camera, its maw stretched wide, revealing dagger-sharp canines and moist, pink gums, it roars in a silent yet powerful roar. Its muzzle wrinkles with intense fury, its neck muscles flexing with a forceful intensity. The beast's eyes are not of the ordinary; instead, they burn with an unearthly, intense, icy-blue light, emanating from deep within its sockets and casting eerie, cold reflections across its facial fur. At this moment, a dazzling, horizontally elongated anamorphic lens flare sweeps across the frame, briefly obscuring a portion of its ferocious features and casting shifting shadows and light across the beast's muzzle and white mane. The entire scene is shrouded in a primal, awe-inspired atmosphere of terror, filled with cinematic tension.", + "seed": 25711, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_1/index_7262_seed_25711_dp_2_rank_4_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.0672299618832767, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0672299618832767, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.175, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0672299618832767, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a very low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a massive white tiger with jet-black stripes and visible individual hairs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the tiger's eyes glowing with an intense icy-blue light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a horizontally elongated anamorphic lens flare sweeping across the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger facing the camera with its mouth wide open in a roaring pose?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08598030358552933 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0859804153442383 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08598030358552933, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08598030358552933, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.02249879762530327, + 0.9037278890609741, + 0.01662643626332283, + 0.010466757230460644, + 0.00838190596550703, + 0.008209867402911186, + 0.0052686892449855804, + 0.007814315147697926, + 0.01251168642193079, + 0.004493619315326214 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08598030358552933 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a very low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a massive white tiger with jet-black stripes and visible individual hairs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the tiger's eyes glowing with an intense icy-blue light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a horizontally elongated anamorphic lens flare sweeping across the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger facing the camera with its mouth wide open in a roaring pose?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007658643182367086 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.8826584815979 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007658643182367086, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007658643182367086, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.027939319610595703, + 0.5920213460922241, + 0.030028225854039192, + 0.026585862040519714, + 0.02962825447320938, + 0.16124603152275085, + 0.00978662259876728, + 0.026372868567705154, + 0.052970997989177704, + 0.04342050105333328 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 5, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007658643182367086 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a very low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a massive white tiger with jet-black stripes and visible individual hairs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the tiger's eyes glowing with an intense icy-blue light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a horizontally elongated anamorphic lens flare sweeping across the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger facing the camera with its mouth wide open in a roaring pose?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08905178308486938 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4640517234802246 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08905178308486938, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08905178308486938, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.012657726183533669, + 0.8975434303283691, + 0.006454928312450647, + 0.019135290756821632, + 0.011893841437995434, + 0.008919552899897099, + 0.011771920137107372, + 0.005642255302518606, + 0.010780169628560543, + 0.01520087942481041 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08905178308486938 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a very low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a massive white tiger with jet-black stripes and visible individual hairs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the tiger's eyes glowing with an intense icy-blue light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a horizontally elongated anamorphic lens flare sweeping across the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger facing the camera with its mouth wide open in a roaring pose?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026356644928455353 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513566970825195 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026356644928455353, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026356644928455353, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06258342415094376, + 0.5286381244659424, + 0.027672527357935905, + 0.014359221793711185, + 0.01168094016611576, + 0.025141147896647453, + 0.027111105620861053, + 0.0412818007171154, + 0.03661021217703819, + 0.22492142021656036 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026356644928455353 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a very low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a massive white tiger with jet-black stripes and visible individual hairs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the tiger's eyes glowing with an intense icy-blue light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a horizontally elongated anamorphic lens flare sweeping across the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger facing the camera with its mouth wide open in a roaring pose?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12710243463516235 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1271023750305176 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12710243463516235, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12710243463516235, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.01970795914530754, + 0.8722209930419922, + 0.025616807863116264, + 0.014354772865772247, + 0.02298724837601185, + 0.00749176973477006, + 0.005091684404760599, + 0.004945285152643919, + 0.022878602147102356, + 0.004704856779426336 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12710243463516235 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a compelling close-up shot from a very low angle, a massive white tiger dominates the frame, its thick, pristine white fur streaked with jet-black stripes, each individual hair clearly visible in the dim light. Facing the camera, its maw stretched wide, revealing dagger-sharp canines and moist, pink gums, it roars in a silent yet powerful roar. Its muzzle wrinkles with intense fury, its neck muscles flexing with a forceful intensity. The beast's eyes are not of the ordinary; instead, they burn with an unearthly, intense, icy-blue light, emanating from deep within its sockets and casting eerie, cold reflections across its facial fur. At this moment, a dazzling, horizontally elongated anamorphic lens flare sweeps across the frame, briefly obscuring a portion of its ferocious features and casting shifting shadows and light across the beast's muzzle and white mane. The entire scene is shrouded in a primal, awe-inspired atmosphere of terror, filled with cinematic tension.", + "seed": 25712, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_1/index_7262_seed_25712_dp_2_rank_4_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.052925271540880205, + "vlm_logprob": -0.052925271540880205, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.225, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.052925271540880205, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a very low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a massive white tiger with jet-black stripes and visible individual hairs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the tiger's eyes glowing with an intense icy-blue light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a horizontally elongated anamorphic lens flare sweeping across the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger facing the camera with its mouth wide open in a roaring pose?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07770222425460815 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.827702283859253 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07770222425460815, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07770222425460815, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07601360231637955, + 0.06666726619005203, + 0.02614138089120388, + 0.05218058452010155, + 0.11014232784509659, + 0.055483441799879074, + 0.0979316234588623, + 0.07167021185159683, + 0.367843359708786, + 0.07592625170946121 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07770222425460815 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a very low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a massive white tiger with jet-black stripes and visible individual hairs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the tiger's eyes glowing with an intense icy-blue light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a horizontally elongated anamorphic lens flare sweeping across the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger facing the camera with its mouth wide open in a roaring pose?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009819064289331436 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634819030761719 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009819064289331436, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009819064289331436, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12978701293468475, + 0.12156699597835541, + 0.09487684816122055, + 0.15950486063957214, + 0.030510535463690758, + 0.024690620601177216, + 0.32523348927497864, + 0.014659981243312359, + 0.07180540263652802, + 0.027364253997802734 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009819064289331436 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a very low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a massive white tiger with jet-black stripes and visible individual hairs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the tiger's eyes glowing with an intense icy-blue light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a horizontally elongated anamorphic lens flare sweeping across the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger facing the camera with its mouth wide open in a roaring pose?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10032854229211807 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3503284454345703 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10032854229211807, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10032854229211807, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.040080804377794266, + 0.20708395540714264, + 0.06295614689588547, + 0.03177729249000549, + 0.07626590877771378, + 0.05084866285324097, + 0.20508511364459991, + 0.018090367317199707, + 0.1680343896150589, + 0.13977737724781036 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10032854229211807 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a very low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a massive white tiger with jet-black stripes and visible individual hairs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the tiger's eyes glowing with an intense icy-blue light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a horizontally elongated anamorphic lens flare sweeping across the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger facing the camera with its mouth wide open in a roaring pose?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04307105019688606 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680710315704346 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04307105019688606, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04307105019688606, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.024343978613615036, + 0.0371294729411602, + 0.025508977472782135, + 0.031181814149022102, + 0.04819037765264511, + 0.08440900593996048, + 0.03784159943461418, + 0.026910673826932907, + 0.667698860168457, + 0.01678522303700447 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04307105019688606 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a very low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a massive white tiger with jet-black stripes and visible individual hairs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the tiger's eyes glowing with an intense icy-blue light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a horizontally elongated anamorphic lens flare sweeping across the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger facing the camera with its mouth wide open in a roaring pose?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03370547667145729 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408705472946167 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03370547667145729, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03370547667145729, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06501691788434982, + 0.34720927476882935, + 0.08553270250558853, + 0.02765987440943718, + 0.0324309878051281, + 0.08399878442287445, + 0.04189569503068924, + 0.020212925970554352, + 0.24024900794029236, + 0.05579374358057976 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03370547667145729 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a compelling close-up shot from a very low angle, a massive white tiger dominates the frame, its thick, pristine white fur streaked with jet-black stripes, each individual hair clearly visible in the dim light. Facing the camera, its maw stretched wide, revealing dagger-sharp canines and moist, pink gums, it roars in a silent yet powerful roar. Its muzzle wrinkles with intense fury, its neck muscles flexing with a forceful intensity. The beast's eyes are not of the ordinary; instead, they burn with an unearthly, intense, icy-blue light, emanating from deep within its sockets and casting eerie, cold reflections across its facial fur. At this moment, a dazzling, horizontally elongated anamorphic lens flare sweeps across the frame, briefly obscuring a portion of its ferocious features and casting shifting shadows and light across the beast's muzzle and white mane. The entire scene is shrouded in a primal, awe-inspired atmosphere of terror, filled with cinematic tension.", + "seed": 25713, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_1/index_7262_seed_25713_dp_3_rank_6_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.0662841446697712, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0662841446697712, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.85, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0662841446697712, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a very low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a massive white tiger with jet-black stripes and visible individual hairs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the tiger's eyes glowing with an intense icy-blue light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a horizontally elongated anamorphic lens flare sweeping across the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger facing the camera with its mouth wide open in a roaring pose?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07289418578147888 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8228940963745117 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07289418578147888, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07289418578147888, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13284295797348022, + 0.20070865750312805, + 0.08332344889640808, + 0.06654322147369385, + 0.07214601337909698, + 0.14529536664485931, + 0.02695869840681553, + 0.02452668733894825, + 0.06280683726072311, + 0.18484805524349213 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07289418578147888 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a very low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a massive white tiger with jet-black stripes and visible individual hairs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the tiger's eyes glowing with an intense icy-blue light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a horizontally elongated anamorphic lens flare sweeping across the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger facing the camera with its mouth wide open in a roaring pose?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02060776576399803 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8956077098846436 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02060776576399803, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02060776576399803, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0974234789609909, + 0.4890036880970001, + 0.026568284258246422, + 0.04688448831439018, + 0.05974370986223221, + 0.02850925922393799, + 0.039024144411087036, + 0.10484682768583298, + 0.04894567281007767, + 0.059050463140010834 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02060776576399803 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a very low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a massive white tiger with jet-black stripes and visible individual hairs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the tiger's eyes glowing with an intense icy-blue light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a horizontally elongated anamorphic lens flare sweeping across the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger facing the camera with its mouth wide open in a roaring pose?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11294341832399368 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.237943410873413 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11294341832399368, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11294341832399368, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17685894668102264, + 0.09134696424007416, + 0.10843020677566528, + 0.11091173440217972, + 0.1336740106344223, + 0.09802012890577316, + 0.06710749864578247, + 0.059271086007356644, + 0.08422809094190598, + 0.07015132904052734 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11294341832399368 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a very low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a massive white tiger with jet-black stripes and visible individual hairs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the tiger's eyes glowing with an intense icy-blue light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a horizontally elongated anamorphic lens flare sweeping across the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger facing the camera with its mouth wide open in a roaring pose?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05495531111955643 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929955244064331 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05495531111955643, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05495531111955643, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13879701495170593, + 0.052239228039979935, + 0.22065289318561554, + 0.21839211881160736, + 0.0744287371635437, + 0.05981041118502617, + 0.030636074021458626, + 0.014428832568228245, + 0.13746319711208344, + 0.05315147340297699 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05495531111955643 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a very low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a massive white tiger with jet-black stripes and visible individual hairs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the tiger's eyes glowing with an intense icy-blue light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a horizontally elongated anamorphic lens flare sweeping across the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger facing the camera with its mouth wide open in a roaring pose?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07002004235982895 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950199604034424 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07002004235982895, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07002004235982895, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17865848541259766, + 0.1500317007303238, + 0.09205374866724014, + 0.07704828679561615, + 0.04620501026511192, + 0.040598563849925995, + 0.08220601826906204, + 0.04720782861113548, + 0.23715615272521973, + 0.0488341823220253 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07002004235982895 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a compelling close-up shot from a very low angle, a massive white tiger dominates the frame, its thick, pristine white fur streaked with jet-black stripes, each individual hair clearly visible in the dim light. Facing the camera, its maw stretched wide, revealing dagger-sharp canines and moist, pink gums, it roars in a silent yet powerful roar. Its muzzle wrinkles with intense fury, its neck muscles flexing with a forceful intensity. The beast's eyes are not of the ordinary; instead, they burn with an unearthly, intense, icy-blue light, emanating from deep within its sockets and casting eerie, cold reflections across its facial fur. At this moment, a dazzling, horizontally elongated anamorphic lens flare sweeps across the frame, briefly obscuring a portion of its ferocious features and casting shifting shadows and light across the beast's muzzle and white mane. The entire scene is shrouded in a primal, awe-inspired atmosphere of terror, filled with cinematic tension.", + "seed": 25714, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_1/index_7262_seed_25714_dp_3_rank_6_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.06434604357928038, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06434604357928038, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.975, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06434604357928038, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a very low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a massive white tiger with jet-black stripes and visible individual hairs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the tiger's eyes glowing with an intense icy-blue light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a horizontally elongated anamorphic lens flare sweeping across the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger facing the camera with its mouth wide open in a roaring pose?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.09648556262254715 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5964856147766113 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.09648556262254715, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.09648556262254715, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05584030970931053, + 0.12288355827331543, + 0.04938613623380661, + 0.15328994393348694, + 0.41774991154670715, + 0.07769974321126938, + 0.0376012958586216, + 0.027441030368208885, + 0.02891240455210209, + 0.02919568493962288 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.09648556262254715 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a very low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a massive white tiger with jet-black stripes and visible individual hairs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the tiger's eyes glowing with an intense icy-blue light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a horizontally elongated anamorphic lens flare sweeping across the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger facing the camera with its mouth wide open in a roaring pose?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.054994240403175354 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299943447113037 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.054994240403175354, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.054994240403175354, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07022307813167572, + 0.05903739854693413, + 0.07655222713947296, + 0.09178950637578964, + 0.33280783891677856, + 0.07526811212301254, + 0.07150933891534805, + 0.026945406571030617, + 0.03778209909796715, + 0.15808500349521637 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.054994240403175354 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a very low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a massive white tiger with jet-black stripes and visible individual hairs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the tiger's eyes glowing with an intense icy-blue light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a horizontally elongated anamorphic lens flare sweeping across the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger facing the camera with its mouth wide open in a roaring pose?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04309605807065964 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680960655212402 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04309605807065964, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04309605807065964, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18203972280025482, + 0.16287347674369812, + 0.11183755844831467, + 0.05499187484383583, + 0.21073469519615173, + 0.08479461818933487, + 0.02554692141711712, + 0.051382504403591156, + 0.03985913097858429, + 0.07593941688537598 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04309605807065964 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a very low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a massive white tiger with jet-black stripes and visible individual hairs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the tiger's eyes glowing with an intense icy-blue light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a horizontally elongated anamorphic lens flare sweeping across the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger facing the camera with its mouth wide open in a roaring pose?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014209873043000698 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264209747314453 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014209873043000698, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014209873043000698, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04938666522502899, + 0.07757267355918884, + 0.026748552918434143, + 0.0802314281463623, + 0.30007079243659973, + 0.12321754544973373, + 0.0679924413561821, + 0.12965962290763855, + 0.07804974913597107, + 0.06707049161195755 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 7, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014209873043000698 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a very low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a massive white tiger with jet-black stripes and visible individual hairs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the tiger's eyes glowing with an intense icy-blue light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a horizontally elongated anamorphic lens flare sweeping across the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger facing the camera with its mouth wide open in a roaring pose?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11294448375701904 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2379446029663086 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11294448375701904, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11294448375701904, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11519938707351685, + 0.1687765121459961, + 0.04371959716081619, + 0.1060144379734993, + 0.4795878529548645, + 0.01649440824985504, + 0.014322865754365921, + 0.00845870841294527, + 0.019215837121009827, + 0.028210485354065895 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11294448375701904 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_10/index_tensor([7598, 7598])_group_10_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_10/index_tensor([7598, 7598])_group_10_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..1a8c8a071f49fcc9e588bd7728b9c10fbe443500 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_10/index_tensor([7598, 7598])_group_10_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "slow, steady forward motion leads the viewer through a vast, futuristic greenhouse. Beneath a soaring, curved glass dome, a matte silver, intricate metal framework crisscrosses. LED grow lights suspended from the ceiling, emitting a natural spectrum, cast a warm, soft glow. The light penetrates the fine mist emanating from the automated sprinkler arms that glide silently on ceiling tracks, forming dreamy beams of light that shroud the entire space in a veil-like haze. As the camera pans, focus gradually deepens, revealing rows of neatly arranged, modular white culture trays, housing countless fresh, tender seedlings thriving. Their emerald leaves are adorned with tiny, crystal-clear water droplets condensed from the sprinkler system, shimmering with life in the light. The image's clean, bright color palette, dominated by the emerald green of the plants and the pure white of the surroundings, punctuated by touches of technological silver, creates an atmosphere of tranquility, cleanliness, and vibrant vitality, perfectly embodying the refined quality and hope for the future of technological agriculture pursued in high-end commercials.", + "seed": 16101, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_10/index_7598_seed_16101_dp_20_rank_40_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.014959611278027297, + "vlm_logprob": -0.014959611278027297, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.7, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.014959611278027297, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set inside a vast futuristic greenhouse with a soaring curved glass dome?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a matte silver intricate metal framework crisscrossing beneath the dome?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are rows of modular white culture trays containing fresh seedlings with emerald leaves visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the space filled with a fine mist from sprinkler arms creating a veil-like haze with warm soft LED lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan while the focus gradually deepens to reveal the details of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0049335649237036705 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.3799333572387695 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0049335649237036705, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0049335649237036705, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18848088383674622, + 0.10073072463274002, + 0.050923023372888565, + 0.07247546315193176, + 0.05674370750784874, + 0.0418950654566288, + 0.19939027726650238, + 0.10473322123289108, + 0.048758577555418015, + 0.1358690857887268 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0049335649237036705 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set inside a vast futuristic greenhouse with a soaring curved glass dome?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a matte silver intricate metal framework crisscrossing beneath the dome?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are rows of modular white culture trays containing fresh seedlings with emerald leaves visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the space filled with a fine mist from sprinkler arms creating a veil-like haze with warm soft LED lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan while the focus gradually deepens to reveal the details of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014203056693077087 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264203071594238 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014203056693077087, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014203056693077087, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14554257690906525, + 0.11503452062606812, + 0.03233933821320534, + 0.04309191554784775, + 0.037290215492248535, + 0.027668863534927368, + 0.17143365740776062, + 0.061555907130241394, + 0.0657595619559288, + 0.30028340220451355 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014203056693077087 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set inside a vast futuristic greenhouse with a soaring curved glass dome?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a matte silver intricate metal framework crisscrossing beneath the dome?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are rows of modular white culture trays containing fresh seedlings with emerald leaves visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the space filled with a fine mist from sprinkler arms creating a veil-like haze with warm soft LED lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan while the focus gradually deepens to reveal the details of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.001512932125478983 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.5015130043029785 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.001512932125478983, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.001512932125478983, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.018362373113632202, + 0.06438878923654556, + 0.021373029798269272, + 0.017181899398565292, + 0.038395579904317856, + 0.01817571371793747, + 0.19521678984165192, + 0.040530867874622345, + 0.04978802800178528, + 0.5365869998931885 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.001512932125478983 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set inside a vast futuristic greenhouse with a soaring curved glass dome?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a matte silver intricate metal framework crisscrossing beneath the dome?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are rows of modular white culture trays containing fresh seedlings with emerald leaves visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the space filled with a fine mist from sprinkler arms creating a veil-like haze with warm soft LED lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan while the focus gradually deepens to reveal the details of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016065318137407303 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.1410651206970215 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016065318137407303, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016065318137407303, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06996212899684906, + 0.03685195371508598, + 0.04816462844610214, + 0.03746064007282257, + 0.03094414435327053, + 0.037956565618515015, + 0.27155569195747375, + 0.07127507030963898, + 0.11882076412439346, + 0.27700838446617126 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016065318137407303 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set inside a vast futuristic greenhouse with a soaring curved glass dome?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a matte silver intricate metal framework crisscrossing beneath the dome?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are rows of modular white culture trays containing fresh seedlings with emerald leaves visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the space filled with a fine mist from sprinkler arms creating a veil-like haze with warm soft LED lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan while the focus gradually deepens to reveal the details of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03808318451046944 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288083076477051 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03808318451046944, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03808318451046944, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1819838285446167, + 0.15242113173007965, + 0.034205928444862366, + 0.04970408231019974, + 0.03316314518451691, + 0.028474925085902214, + 0.180756077170372, + 0.1251557469367981, + 0.1463620960712433, + 0.06777302175760269 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03808318451046944 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow, steady forward motion leads the viewer through a vast, futuristic greenhouse. Beneath a soaring, curved glass dome, a matte silver, intricate metal framework crisscrosses. LED grow lights suspended from the ceiling, emitting a natural spectrum, cast a warm, soft glow. The light penetrates the fine mist emanating from the automated sprinkler arms that glide silently on ceiling tracks, forming dreamy beams of light that shroud the entire space in a veil-like haze. As the camera pans, focus gradually deepens, revealing rows of neatly arranged, modular white culture trays, housing countless fresh, tender seedlings thriving. Their emerald leaves are adorned with tiny, crystal-clear water droplets condensed from the sprinkler system, shimmering with life in the light. The image's clean, bright color palette, dominated by the emerald green of the plants and the pure white of the surroundings, punctuated by touches of technological silver, creates an atmosphere of tranquility, cleanliness, and vibrant vitality, perfectly embodying the refined quality and hope for the future of technological agriculture pursued in high-end commercials.", + "seed": 16102, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_10/index_7598_seed_16102_dp_20_rank_40_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.022880010772496462, + "vlm_logprob": -0.022880010772496462, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.5, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.022880010772496462, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set inside a vast futuristic greenhouse with a soaring curved glass dome?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a matte silver intricate metal framework crisscrossing beneath the dome?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are rows of modular white culture trays containing fresh seedlings with emerald leaves visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the space filled with a fine mist from sprinkler arms creating a veil-like haze with warm soft LED lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan while the focus gradually deepens to reveal the details of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0033946766052395105 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753394603729248 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0033946766052395105, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0033946766052395105, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25265181064605713, + 0.06716088950634003, + 0.05174005776643753, + 0.04072779044508934, + 0.23656174540519714, + 0.04356086999177933, + 0.03509083390235901, + 0.0622335821390152, + 0.10418280959129333, + 0.10608955472707748 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0033946766052395105 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set inside a vast futuristic greenhouse with a soaring curved glass dome?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a matte silver intricate metal framework crisscrossing beneath the dome?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are rows of modular white culture trays containing fresh seedlings with emerald leaves visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the space filled with a fine mist from sprinkler arms creating a veil-like haze with warm soft LED lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan while the focus gradually deepens to reveal the details of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011079810559749603 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511079788208008 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011079810559749603, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011079810559749603, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1807156354188919, + 0.15001806616783142, + 0.09032499045133591, + 0.06264163553714752, + 0.13315868377685547, + 0.07437267899513245, + 0.034869272261857986, + 0.029474113136529922, + 0.16108207404613495, + 0.08334293961524963 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011079810559749603 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set inside a vast futuristic greenhouse with a soaring curved glass dome?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a matte silver intricate metal framework crisscrossing beneath the dome?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are rows of modular white culture trays containing fresh seedlings with emerald leaves visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the space filled with a fine mist from sprinkler arms creating a veil-like haze with warm soft LED lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan while the focus gradually deepens to reveal the details of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00193896540440619 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.251938819885254 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00193896540440619, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00193896540440619, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.45515257120132446, + 0.08831554651260376, + 0.07934312522411346, + 0.031512871384620667, + 0.06482622772455215, + 0.05852122977375984, + 0.033013466745615005, + 0.04426832124590874, + 0.026065196841955185, + 0.11898142844438553 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00193896540440619 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set inside a vast futuristic greenhouse with a soaring curved glass dome?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a matte silver intricate metal framework crisscrossing beneath the dome?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are rows of modular white culture trays containing fresh seedlings with emerald leaves visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the space filled with a fine mist from sprinkler arms creating a veil-like haze with warm soft LED lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan while the focus gradually deepens to reveal the details of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04305814579129219 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168058156967163 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04305814579129219, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04305814579129219, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5532349348068237, + 0.030835753306746483, + 0.10854701697826385, + 0.03613395616412163, + 0.03950820863246918, + 0.060150060802698135, + 0.05125431716442108, + 0.05725795403122902, + 0.033019598573446274, + 0.030058173462748528 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04305814579129219 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set inside a vast futuristic greenhouse with a soaring curved glass dome?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a matte silver intricate metal framework crisscrossing beneath the dome?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are rows of modular white culture trays containing fresh seedlings with emerald leaves visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the space filled with a fine mist from sprinkler arms creating a veil-like haze with warm soft LED lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan while the focus gradually deepens to reveal the details of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.054928455501794815 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299285411834717 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.054928455501794815, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.054928455501794815, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25512078404426575, + 0.10923056304454803, + 0.07972031086683273, + 0.05431569367647171, + 0.05541018769145012, + 0.05858674272894859, + 0.05006684735417366, + 0.06092965975403786, + 0.06794407963752747, + 0.2086750864982605 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.054928455501794815 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow, steady forward motion leads the viewer through a vast, futuristic greenhouse. Beneath a soaring, curved glass dome, a matte silver, intricate metal framework crisscrosses. LED grow lights suspended from the ceiling, emitting a natural spectrum, cast a warm, soft glow. The light penetrates the fine mist emanating from the automated sprinkler arms that glide silently on ceiling tracks, forming dreamy beams of light that shroud the entire space in a veil-like haze. As the camera pans, focus gradually deepens, revealing rows of neatly arranged, modular white culture trays, housing countless fresh, tender seedlings thriving. Their emerald leaves are adorned with tiny, crystal-clear water droplets condensed from the sprinkler system, shimmering with life in the light. The image's clean, bright color palette, dominated by the emerald green of the plants and the pure white of the surroundings, punctuated by touches of technological silver, creates an atmosphere of tranquility, cleanliness, and vibrant vitality, perfectly embodying the refined quality and hope for the future of technological agriculture pursued in high-end commercials.", + "seed": 16103, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_10/index_7598_seed_16103_dp_21_rank_42_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.025129394908435642, + "vlm_logprob": -0.025129394908435642, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.35, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.025129394908435642, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set inside a vast futuristic greenhouse with a soaring curved glass dome?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a matte silver intricate metal framework crisscrossing beneath the dome?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are rows of modular white culture trays containing fresh seedlings with emerald leaves visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the space filled with a fine mist from sprinkler arms creating a veil-like haze with warm soft LED lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan while the focus gradually deepens to reveal the details of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00490189203992486 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504901885986328 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00490189203992486, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00490189203992486, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13573896884918213, + 0.08692814409732819, + 0.060835279524326324, + 0.27267688512802124, + 0.04394542798399925, + 0.029621178284287453, + 0.03594664856791496, + 0.04316070303320885, + 0.1991790384054184, + 0.09196770936250687 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00490189203992486 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set inside a vast futuristic greenhouse with a soaring curved glass dome?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a matte silver intricate metal framework crisscrossing beneath the dome?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are rows of modular white culture trays containing fresh seedlings with emerald leaves visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the space filled with a fine mist from sprinkler arms creating a veil-like haze with warm soft LED lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan while the focus gradually deepens to reveal the details of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023294828832149506 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732949256896973 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023294828832149506, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023294828832149506, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12076185643672943, + 0.07960885018110275, + 0.07134014368057251, + 0.504306972026825, + 0.029220275580883026, + 0.017828309908509254, + 0.01851654425263405, + 0.0341668464243412, + 0.09128691256046295, + 0.0329633504152298 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023294828832149506 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set inside a vast futuristic greenhouse with a soaring curved glass dome?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a matte silver intricate metal framework crisscrossing beneath the dome?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are rows of modular white culture trays containing fresh seedlings with emerald leaves visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the space filled with a fine mist from sprinkler arms creating a veil-like haze with warm soft LED lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan while the focus gradually deepens to reveal the details of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0017144280718639493 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.37671422958374 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0017144280718639493, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0017144280718639493, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06182872876524925, + 0.032534800469875336, + 0.037976544350385666, + 0.4874301552772522, + 0.018698077648878098, + 0.026134232059121132, + 0.024286450818181038, + 0.03173195570707321, + 0.21688997745513916, + 0.062489110976457596 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0017144280718639493 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set inside a vast futuristic greenhouse with a soaring curved glass dome?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a matte silver intricate metal framework crisscrossing beneath the dome?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are rows of modular white culture trays containing fresh seedlings with emerald leaves visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the space filled with a fine mist from sprinkler arms creating a veil-like haze with warm soft LED lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan while the focus gradually deepens to reveal the details of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.062050748616456985 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120508193969727 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.062050748616456985, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.062050748616456985, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13871051371097565, + 0.0802302211523056, + 0.05626232549548149, + 0.2992478311061859, + 0.054678432643413544, + 0.05139133334159851, + 0.029415015131235123, + 0.09591633081436157, + 0.058591462671756744, + 0.13555648922920227 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.062050748616456985 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set inside a vast futuristic greenhouse with a soaring curved glass dome?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a matte silver intricate metal framework crisscrossing beneath the dome?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are rows of modular white culture trays containing fresh seedlings with emerald leaves visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the space filled with a fine mist from sprinkler arms creating a veil-like haze with warm soft LED lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan while the focus gradually deepens to reveal the details of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03368507698178291 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4086849689483643 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03368507698178291, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03368507698178291, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09414546191692352, + 0.0904894769191742, + 0.02420123480260372, + 0.06409095972776413, + 0.08887913078069687, + 0.019481871277093887, + 0.047475945204496384, + 0.045460294932127, + 0.4286477267742157, + 0.09712788462638855 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03368507698178291 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow, steady forward motion leads the viewer through a vast, futuristic greenhouse. Beneath a soaring, curved glass dome, a matte silver, intricate metal framework crisscrosses. LED grow lights suspended from the ceiling, emitting a natural spectrum, cast a warm, soft glow. The light penetrates the fine mist emanating from the automated sprinkler arms that glide silently on ceiling tracks, forming dreamy beams of light that shroud the entire space in a veil-like haze. As the camera pans, focus gradually deepens, revealing rows of neatly arranged, modular white culture trays, housing countless fresh, tender seedlings thriving. Their emerald leaves are adorned with tiny, crystal-clear water droplets condensed from the sprinkler system, shimmering with life in the light. The image's clean, bright color palette, dominated by the emerald green of the plants and the pure white of the surroundings, punctuated by touches of technological silver, creates an atmosphere of tranquility, cleanliness, and vibrant vitality, perfectly embodying the refined quality and hope for the future of technological agriculture pursued in high-end commercials.", + "seed": 16104, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_10/index_7598_seed_16104_dp_21_rank_42_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.021897300728596747, + "vlm_logprob": -0.021897300728596747, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.625, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.021897300728596747, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set inside a vast futuristic greenhouse with a soaring curved glass dome?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a matte silver intricate metal framework crisscrossing beneath the dome?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are rows of modular white culture trays containing fresh seedlings with emerald leaves visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the space filled with a fine mist from sprinkler arms creating a veil-like haze with warm soft LED lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan while the focus gradually deepens to reveal the details of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002200683578848839 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.252200603485107 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002200683578848839, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002200683578848839, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06926608085632324, + 0.034514423459768295, + 0.02662232518196106, + 0.04512573778629303, + 0.30647870898246765, + 0.016488267108798027, + 0.0318852961063385, + 0.02466343343257904, + 0.047578632831573486, + 0.3973771631717682 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002200683578848839 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set inside a vast futuristic greenhouse with a soaring curved glass dome?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a matte silver intricate metal framework crisscrossing beneath the dome?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are rows of modular white culture trays containing fresh seedlings with emerald leaves visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the space filled with a fine mist from sprinkler arms creating a veil-like haze with warm soft LED lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan while the focus gradually deepens to reveal the details of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012543711811304092 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387543678283691 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012543711811304092, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012543711811304092, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09349284321069717, + 0.05492110550403595, + 0.08253933489322662, + 0.07944705337285995, + 0.21735350787639618, + 0.19499242305755615, + 0.043657805770635605, + 0.01795601285994053, + 0.05247744545340538, + 0.163162499666214 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012543711811304092 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set inside a vast futuristic greenhouse with a soaring curved glass dome?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a matte silver intricate metal framework crisscrossing beneath the dome?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are rows of modular white culture trays containing fresh seedlings with emerald leaves visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the space filled with a fine mist from sprinkler arms creating a veil-like haze with warm soft LED lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan while the focus gradually deepens to reveal the details of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0017127619357779622 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.376712799072266 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0017127619357779622, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0017127619357779622, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10150379687547684, + 0.06667426228523254, + 0.02865980565547943, + 0.038229890167713165, + 0.050755392760038376, + 0.05754781886935234, + 0.00812065601348877, + 0.013665618374943733, + 0.05803019180893898, + 0.5768125057220459 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0017127619357779622 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set inside a vast futuristic greenhouse with a soaring curved glass dome?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a matte silver intricate metal framework crisscrossing beneath the dome?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are rows of modular white culture trays containing fresh seedlings with emerald leaves visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the space filled with a fine mist from sprinkler arms creating a veil-like haze with warm soft LED lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan while the focus gradually deepens to reveal the details of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.038095809519290924 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288095712661743 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.038095809519290924, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.038095809519290924, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12393886595964432, + 0.06243155896663666, + 0.026858827099204063, + 0.06902837008237839, + 0.1900908201932907, + 0.02663612551987171, + 0.014680723659694195, + 0.011913178488612175, + 0.016860883682966232, + 0.4575607478618622 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.038095809519290924 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set inside a vast futuristic greenhouse with a soaring curved glass dome?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a matte silver intricate metal framework crisscrossing beneath the dome?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are rows of modular white culture trays containing fresh seedlings with emerald leaves visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the space filled with a fine mist from sprinkler arms creating a veil-like haze with warm soft LED lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan while the focus gradually deepens to reveal the details of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05493353679776192 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929933547973633 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05493353679776192, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05493353679776192, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05881352722644806, + 0.07925720512866974, + 0.06091858819127083, + 0.04167577251791954, + 0.24969466030597687, + 0.05145133659243584, + 0.10296716541051865, + 0.07014613598585129, + 0.061465803533792496, + 0.22360976040363312 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05493353679776192 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_11/index_tensor([6719, 6719])_group_11_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_11/index_tensor([6719, 6719])_group_11_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..cc6b7e7c79b294abd6626ecbef385ddd4501b84e --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_11/index_tensor([6719, 6719])_group_11_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "static, extreme close-up shot from a slightly high angle, rendered with stunning realism, captures a moment of tranquil ritual. A minimalist off-white ceramic cup with a smooth, matte glaze rests on a soft, blurred wooden surface, filled with crystal-clear hot water, from which a faint wisp of steam gently rises. A delicate rattan-mesh tea bag, its translucent weave revealing the dark, curled tea leaves within, is released into the frame and meets the water's surface. As the water rapidly saturates the fine mesh, the camera carefully follows, causing the bag to become heavy and begin a steady, deliberate descent. As the bag sinks, a gorgeous amber plume begins to unfurl from the bag, forming an elegant, slow-moving vortex in the water, with occasional tiny bubbles escaping the mesh. The tea bag finally settles gently to the bottom of the cup. As the brew continues to deepen, the white string and plain paper label attached to the bag dangle from the rim. Under the soft, directional light, the clear water turns a warm, luminous gold, evoking an atmosphere of profound tranquility and concentration.", + "seed": 10592, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_11/index_6719_seed_10592_dp_22_rank_44_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.04015465881675482, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04015465881675482, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.15, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04015465881675482, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a minimalist off-white ceramic cup with a smooth matte glaze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does a delicate rattan-mesh tea bag with visible dark curled leaves enter the frame and sink to the bottom of the cup?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does an amber plume unfurl from the tea bag forming a slow-moving vortex with tiny bubbles escaping the mesh?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the white string and plain paper label dangle from the rim of the cup as the water turns a warm luminous gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle slightly high and does it follow the tea bag's descent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16212746500968933 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9121274948120117 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16212746500968933, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16212746500968933, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.119957834482193, + 0.03513103723526001, + 0.09361029416322708, + 0.11603586375713348, + 0.07477182149887085, + 0.06081629544496536, + 0.0740506574511528, + 0.08160515874624252, + 0.2680383324623108, + 0.07598260045051575 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16212746500968933 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a minimalist off-white ceramic cup with a smooth matte glaze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does a delicate rattan-mesh tea bag with visible dark curled leaves enter the frame and sink to the bottom of the cup?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does an amber plume unfurl from the tea bag forming a slow-moving vortex with tiny bubbles escaping the mesh?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the white string and plain paper label dangle from the rim of the cup as the water turns a warm luminous gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle slightly high and does it follow the tea bag's descent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009811509400606155 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.6348114013671875 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009811509400606155, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009811509400606155, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.191162109375, + 0.09775460511445999, + 0.2744845151901245, + 0.11025341600179672, + 0.06342139095067978, + 0.05906437337398529, + 0.06411198526620865, + 0.05501333251595497, + 0.06223167106509209, + 0.022502616047859192 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009811509400606155 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a minimalist off-white ceramic cup with a smooth matte glaze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does a delicate rattan-mesh tea bag with visible dark curled leaves enter the frame and sink to the bottom of the cup?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does an amber plume unfurl from the tea bag forming a slow-moving vortex with tiny bubbles escaping the mesh?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the white string and plain paper label dangle from the rim of the cup as the water turns a warm luminous gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle slightly high and does it follow the tea bag's descent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004105829633772373 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504106044769287 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004105829633772373, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004105829633772373, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12218013405799866, + 0.056979916989803314, + 0.32928964495658875, + 0.06390313804149628, + 0.06478873640298843, + 0.04420210048556328, + 0.030856583267450333, + 0.09789057075977325, + 0.13100039958953857, + 0.05890875682234764 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004105829633772373 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a minimalist off-white ceramic cup with a smooth matte glaze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does a delicate rattan-mesh tea bag with visible dark curled leaves enter the frame and sink to the bottom of the cup?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does an amber plume unfurl from the tea bag forming a slow-moving vortex with tiny bubbles escaping the mesh?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the white string and plain paper label dangle from the rim of the cup as the water turns a warm luminous gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle slightly high and does it follow the tea bag's descent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008657541126012802 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758657455444336 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008657541126012802, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008657541126012802, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08682799339294434, + 0.06329140812158585, + 0.17902623116970062, + 0.09107193350791931, + 0.09131353348493576, + 0.05468371883034706, + 0.1838618367910385, + 0.10998967289924622, + 0.06948085129261017, + 0.07045277953147888 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 2, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008657541126012802 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a minimalist off-white ceramic cup with a smooth matte glaze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does a delicate rattan-mesh tea bag with visible dark curled leaves enter the frame and sink to the bottom of the cup?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does an amber plume unfurl from the tea bag forming a slow-moving vortex with tiny bubbles escaping the mesh?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the white string and plain paper label dangle from the rim of the cup as the water turns a warm luminous gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle slightly high and does it follow the tea bag's descent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016070948913693428 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.14107084274292 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016070948913693428, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016070948913693428, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19797125458717346, + 0.11118648201227188, + 0.12167210876941681, + 0.06800032407045364, + 0.059694115072488785, + 0.03588680922985077, + 0.061610788106918335, + 0.055499833077192307, + 0.23647363483905792, + 0.05200463533401489 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016070948913693428 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, extreme close-up shot from a slightly high angle, rendered with stunning realism, captures a moment of tranquil ritual. A minimalist off-white ceramic cup with a smooth, matte glaze rests on a soft, blurred wooden surface, filled with crystal-clear hot water, from which a faint wisp of steam gently rises. A delicate rattan-mesh tea bag, its translucent weave revealing the dark, curled tea leaves within, is released into the frame and meets the water's surface. As the water rapidly saturates the fine mesh, the camera carefully follows, causing the bag to become heavy and begin a steady, deliberate descent. As the bag sinks, a gorgeous amber plume begins to unfurl from the bag, forming an elegant, slow-moving vortex in the water, with occasional tiny bubbles escaping the mesh. The tea bag finally settles gently to the bottom of the cup. As the brew continues to deepen, the white string and plain paper label attached to the bag dangle from the rim. Under the soft, directional light, the clear water turns a warm, luminous gold, evoking an atmosphere of profound tranquility and concentration.", + "seed": 10593, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_11/index_6719_seed_10593_dp_22_rank_44_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.06259375903755426, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06259375903755426, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.45, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06259375903755426, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a minimalist off-white ceramic cup with a smooth matte glaze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does a delicate rattan-mesh tea bag with visible dark curled leaves enter the frame and sink to the bottom of the cup?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does an amber plume unfurl from the tea bag forming a slow-moving vortex with tiny bubbles escaping the mesh?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the white string and plain paper label dangle from the rim of the cup as the water turns a warm luminous gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle slightly high and does it follow the tea bag's descent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2274916172027588 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6024916172027588 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2274916172027588, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2274916172027588, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06711658835411072, + 0.7259799242019653, + 0.03135346248745918, + 0.02139851823449135, + 0.06351308524608612, + 0.05424557998776436, + 0.010013677179813385, + 0.012393217533826828, + 0.005060750991106033, + 0.008925140835344791 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2274916172027588 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a minimalist off-white ceramic cup with a smooth matte glaze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does a delicate rattan-mesh tea bag with visible dark curled leaves enter the frame and sink to the bottom of the cup?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does an amber plume unfurl from the tea bag forming a slow-moving vortex with tiny bubbles escaping the mesh?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the white string and plain paper label dangle from the rim of the cup as the water turns a warm luminous gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle slightly high and does it follow the tea bag's descent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009816939942538738 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634817123413086 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009816939942538738, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009816939942538738, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05656726285815239, + 0.26566433906555176, + 0.07583305239677429, + 0.23557671904563904, + 0.04016215726733208, + 0.1402234435081482, + 0.10210733115673065, + 0.02540421299636364, + 0.025044837966561317, + 0.03341669589281082 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009816939942538738 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a minimalist off-white ceramic cup with a smooth matte glaze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does a delicate rattan-mesh tea bag with visible dark curled leaves enter the frame and sink to the bottom of the cup?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does an amber plume unfurl from the tea bag forming a slow-moving vortex with tiny bubbles escaping the mesh?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the white string and plain paper label dangle from the rim of the cup as the water turns a warm luminous gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle slightly high and does it follow the tea bag's descent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03813884034752846 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881388664245605 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03813884034752846, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03813884034752846, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11149004101753235, + 0.3804391920566559, + 0.03428536280989647, + 0.09312612563371658, + 0.052603237330913544, + 0.076363205909729, + 0.12767577171325684, + 0.03929908573627472, + 0.01832151599228382, + 0.06639648228883743 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03813884034752846 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a minimalist off-white ceramic cup with a smooth matte glaze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does a delicate rattan-mesh tea bag with visible dark curled leaves enter the frame and sink to the bottom of the cup?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does an amber plume unfurl from the tea bag forming a slow-moving vortex with tiny bubbles escaping the mesh?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the white string and plain paper label dangle from the rim of the cup as the water turns a warm luminous gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle slightly high and does it follow the tea bag's descent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023319868370890617 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773319959640503 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023319868370890617, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023319868370890617, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0641305074095726, + 0.5368297696113586, + 0.04774925485253334, + 0.06690395623445511, + 0.048699092119932175, + 0.09797980636358261, + 0.0618450902402401, + 0.02952837571501732, + 0.01888471655547619, + 0.027449484914541245 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023319868370890617 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a minimalist off-white ceramic cup with a smooth matte glaze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does a delicate rattan-mesh tea bag with visible dark curled leaves enter the frame and sink to the bottom of the cup?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does an amber plume unfurl from the tea bag forming a slow-moving vortex with tiny bubbles escaping the mesh?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the white string and plain paper label dangle from the rim of the cup as the water turns a warm luminous gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle slightly high and does it follow the tea bag's descent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014201529324054718 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264201641082764 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014201529324054718, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014201529324054718, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06417127698659897, + 0.5407111048698425, + 0.03443126380443573, + 0.09425366669893265, + 0.05914640426635742, + 0.09119526296854019, + 0.03885086253285408, + 0.036143407225608826, + 0.02072342112660408, + 0.02037332020699978 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014201529324054718 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, extreme close-up shot from a slightly high angle, rendered with stunning realism, captures a moment of tranquil ritual. A minimalist off-white ceramic cup with a smooth, matte glaze rests on a soft, blurred wooden surface, filled with crystal-clear hot water, from which a faint wisp of steam gently rises. A delicate rattan-mesh tea bag, its translucent weave revealing the dark, curled tea leaves within, is released into the frame and meets the water's surface. As the water rapidly saturates the fine mesh, the camera carefully follows, causing the bag to become heavy and begin a steady, deliberate descent. As the bag sinks, a gorgeous amber plume begins to unfurl from the bag, forming an elegant, slow-moving vortex in the water, with occasional tiny bubbles escaping the mesh. The tea bag finally settles gently to the bottom of the cup. As the brew continues to deepen, the white string and plain paper label attached to the bag dangle from the rim. Under the soft, directional light, the clear water turns a warm, luminous gold, evoking an atmosphere of profound tranquility and concentration.", + "seed": 10594, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_11/index_6719_seed_10594_dp_23_rank_46_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.02279755207709968, + "vlm_logprob": -0.02279755207709968, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.424999952316284, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.02279755207709968, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a minimalist off-white ceramic cup with a smooth matte glaze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does a delicate rattan-mesh tea bag with visible dark curled leaves enter the frame and sink to the bottom of the cup?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does an amber plume unfurl from the tea bag forming a slow-moving vortex with tiny bubbles escaping the mesh?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the white string and plain paper label dangle from the rim of the cup as the water turns a warm luminous gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle slightly high and does it follow the tea bag's descent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.072754867374897 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6977548599243164 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.072754867374897, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.072754867374897, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2397684007883072, + 0.0716153234243393, + 0.0778937041759491, + 0.10999449342489243, + 0.10643111914396286, + 0.13699807226657867, + 0.06622576713562012, + 0.04452933743596077, + 0.07380669564008713, + 0.07273706793785095 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.072754867374897 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a minimalist off-white ceramic cup with a smooth matte glaze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does a delicate rattan-mesh tea bag with visible dark curled leaves enter the frame and sink to the bottom of the cup?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does an amber plume unfurl from the tea bag forming a slow-moving vortex with tiny bubbles escaping the mesh?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the white string and plain paper label dangle from the rim of the cup as the water turns a warm luminous gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle slightly high and does it follow the tea bag's descent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016108838841319084 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141108989715576 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016108838841319084, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016108838841319084, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1513109803199768, + 0.12538544833660126, + 0.0808212086558342, + 0.046552129089832306, + 0.12731905281543732, + 0.10532552003860474, + 0.04251862317323685, + 0.019385162740945816, + 0.2386113852262497, + 0.06277056038379669 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016108838841319084 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a minimalist off-white ceramic cup with a smooth matte glaze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does a delicate rattan-mesh tea bag with visible dark curled leaves enter the frame and sink to the bottom of the cup?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does an amber plume unfurl from the tea bag forming a slow-moving vortex with tiny bubbles escaping the mesh?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the white string and plain paper label dangle from the rim of the cup as the water turns a warm luminous gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle slightly high and does it follow the tea bag's descent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004107017070055008 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.5041069984436035 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004107017070055008, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004107017070055008, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08487280458211899, + 0.08327421545982361, + 0.19768546521663666, + 0.04619664326310158, + 0.2496262639760971, + 0.0620444230735302, + 0.03231974318623543, + 0.030856531113386154, + 0.05776737630367279, + 0.15535658597946167 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 2, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004107017070055008 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a minimalist off-white ceramic cup with a smooth matte glaze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does a delicate rattan-mesh tea bag with visible dark curled leaves enter the frame and sink to the bottom of the cup?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does an amber plume unfurl from the tea bag forming a slow-moving vortex with tiny bubbles escaping the mesh?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the white string and plain paper label dangle from the rim of the cup as the water turns a warm luminous gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle slightly high and does it follow the tea bag's descent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0028307863976806402 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877830982208252 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0028307863976806402, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0028307863976806402, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18857690691947937, + 0.11549339443445206, + 0.11472605913877487, + 0.04609624296426773, + 0.03977828845381737, + 0.10370305180549622, + 0.031853530555963516, + 0.10031559318304062, + 0.1415800005197525, + 0.11787695437669754 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0028307863976806402 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a minimalist off-white ceramic cup with a smooth matte glaze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does a delicate rattan-mesh tea bag with visible dark curled leaves enter the frame and sink to the bottom of the cup?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does an amber plume unfurl from the tea bag forming a slow-moving vortex with tiny bubbles escaping the mesh?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the white string and plain paper label dangle from the rim of the cup as the water turns a warm luminous gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle slightly high and does it follow the tea bag's descent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01818625070154667 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018186092376709 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01818625070154667, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01818625070154667, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14998336136341095, + 0.03799590840935707, + 0.11368995159864426, + 0.09066127240657806, + 0.16676458716392517, + 0.06238575279712677, + 0.06363145262002945, + 0.0655800849199295, + 0.10302719473838806, + 0.14628037810325623 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01818625070154667 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, extreme close-up shot from a slightly high angle, rendered with stunning realism, captures a moment of tranquil ritual. A minimalist off-white ceramic cup with a smooth, matte glaze rests on a soft, blurred wooden surface, filled with crystal-clear hot water, from which a faint wisp of steam gently rises. A delicate rattan-mesh tea bag, its translucent weave revealing the dark, curled tea leaves within, is released into the frame and meets the water's surface. As the water rapidly saturates the fine mesh, the camera carefully follows, causing the bag to become heavy and begin a steady, deliberate descent. As the bag sinks, a gorgeous amber plume begins to unfurl from the bag, forming an elegant, slow-moving vortex in the water, with occasional tiny bubbles escaping the mesh. The tea bag finally settles gently to the bottom of the cup. As the brew continues to deepen, the white string and plain paper label attached to the bag dangle from the rim. Under the soft, directional light, the clear water turns a warm, luminous gold, evoking an atmosphere of profound tranquility and concentration.", + "seed": 10595, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_11/index_6719_seed_10595_dp_23_rank_46_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.030775158386677503, + "vlm_logprob": -0.030775158386677503, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.05, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.030775158386677503, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a minimalist off-white ceramic cup with a smooth matte glaze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does a delicate rattan-mesh tea bag with visible dark curled leaves enter the frame and sink to the bottom of the cup?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does an amber plume unfurl from the tea bag forming a slow-moving vortex with tiny bubbles escaping the mesh?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the white string and plain paper label dangle from the rim of the cup as the water turns a warm luminous gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle slightly high and does it follow the tea bag's descent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10214360803365707 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3521435260772705 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10214360803365707, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10214360803365707, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17958375811576843, + 0.07815026491880417, + 0.05145905911922455, + 0.07274190336465836, + 0.1796342432498932, + 0.1590021848678589, + 0.0496976301074028, + 0.10106813907623291, + 0.07189905643463135, + 0.056763842701911926 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10214360803365707 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a minimalist off-white ceramic cup with a smooth matte glaze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does a delicate rattan-mesh tea bag with visible dark curled leaves enter the frame and sink to the bottom of the cup?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does an amber plume unfurl from the tea bag forming a slow-moving vortex with tiny bubbles escaping the mesh?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the white string and plain paper label dangle from the rim of the cup as the water turns a warm luminous gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle slightly high and does it follow the tea bag's descent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01823330856859684 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018233299255371 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01823330856859684, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01823330856859684, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2134978473186493, + 0.12940038740634918, + 0.1373494565486908, + 0.0629485696554184, + 0.10257229954004288, + 0.11926079541444778, + 0.06568297743797302, + 0.06459367275238037, + 0.05388728156685829, + 0.0508066788315773 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01823330856859684 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a minimalist off-white ceramic cup with a smooth matte glaze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does a delicate rattan-mesh tea bag with visible dark curled leaves enter the frame and sink to the bottom of the cup?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does an amber plume unfurl from the tea bag forming a slow-moving vortex with tiny bubbles escaping the mesh?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the white string and plain paper label dangle from the rim of the cup as the water turns a warm luminous gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle slightly high and does it follow the tea bag's descent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005265890154987574 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255265712738037 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005265890154987574, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005265890154987574, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08858883380889893, + 0.12428060919046402, + 0.18806420266628265, + 0.03228563442826271, + 0.03961747884750366, + 0.0642010048031807, + 0.04669353738427162, + 0.03449589014053345, + 0.06981972604990005, + 0.31195300817489624 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005265890154987574 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a minimalist off-white ceramic cup with a smooth matte glaze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does a delicate rattan-mesh tea bag with visible dark curled leaves enter the frame and sink to the bottom of the cup?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does an amber plume unfurl from the tea bag forming a slow-moving vortex with tiny bubbles escaping the mesh?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the white string and plain paper label dangle from the rim of the cup as the water turns a warm luminous gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle slightly high and does it follow the tea bag's descent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007647759281098843 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.88264799118042 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007647759281098843, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007647759281098843, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15643537044525146, + 0.024299288168549538, + 0.06683085113763809, + 0.08673521876335144, + 0.08389896899461746, + 0.06972227245569229, + 0.03716251999139786, + 0.03426096960902214, + 0.05584604665637016, + 0.3848084807395935 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007647759281098843 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a minimalist off-white ceramic cup with a smooth matte glaze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does a delicate rattan-mesh tea bag with visible dark curled leaves enter the frame and sink to the bottom of the cup?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does an amber plume unfurl from the tea bag forming a slow-moving vortex with tiny bubbles escaping the mesh?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the white string and plain paper label dangle from the rim of the cup as the water turns a warm luminous gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle slightly high and does it follow the tea bag's descent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020585225895047188 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895585298538208 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020585225895047188, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020585225895047188, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1417456418275833, + 0.06282930821180344, + 0.15973877906799316, + 0.09147118777036667, + 0.22282737493515015, + 0.05094827339053154, + 0.05021445453166962, + 0.06441526859998703, + 0.08586548268795013, + 0.06994426995515823 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020585225895047188 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_12/index_tensor([7526, 7526])_group_12_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_12/index_tensor([7526, 7526])_group_12_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..a8783f1c1a1d6ac698cb1bbe084c83e06ef3c1ac --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_12/index_tensor([7526, 7526])_group_12_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "low-angle shot, beginning from the ground, slowly and steadily tilts upward, eventually transitioning to a distant drone-like perspective. This shot captures a massive, flattened, lens-shaped alien spacecraft rising vertically in absolute silence, seemingly against the force of gravity. Its smooth, obsidian-black organic metal hull lacks any visible seams, windows, or thrusters. Its massive curves reflect flowing, cold white highlights in the cool moonlight, creating a scene both elegant and oppressive. As the spacecraft ascends, only wisps of mist gently stirred by an invisible force in the vast wheat fields below. Without the roar of engines or the rumbling of air, this creates a sense of technological sophistication beyond the laws of physics. As the camera zooms out and shifts to a bird's-eye view, the image reveals the spacecraft's departure: on the ground where it had just landed, a vast, complex geometric pattern of perfectly flattened wheat stalks—a crop circle—is clearly visible in the moonlight. The entire scene, shrouded in a cold blue-black hue, exudes a solemn, serene, and otherworldly mystery.", + "seed": 29815, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_12/index_7526_seed_29815_dp_24_rank_48_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.043319277465343475, + "vlm_logprob": -0.043319277465343475, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.45, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.043319277465343475, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive, flattened, lens-shaped alien spacecraft?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the spacecraft's hull smooth, obsidian-black, and lacking visible seams, windows, or thrusters?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene take place in vast wheat fields under cool moonlight with a cold blue-black hue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle shot from the ground and slowly tilt upward to a distant drone-like perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a complex geometric pattern of flattened wheat stalks (a crop circle) visible on the ground after the spacecraft departs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03036872297525406 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5303688049316406 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03036872297525406, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03036872297525406, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12753036618232727, + 0.03799116238951683, + 0.11413700878620148, + 0.019684290513396263, + 0.04195340722799301, + 0.038257353007793427, + 0.053338732570409775, + 0.2715493142604828, + 0.12226081639528275, + 0.17329759895801544 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03036872297525406 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive, flattened, lens-shaped alien spacecraft?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the spacecraft's hull smooth, obsidian-black, and lacking visible seams, windows, or thrusters?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene take place in vast wheat fields under cool moonlight with a cold blue-black hue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle shot from the ground and slowly tilt upward to a distant drone-like perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a complex geometric pattern of flattened wheat stalks (a crop circle) visible on the ground after the spacecraft departs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020605195313692093 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8956050872802734 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020605195313692093, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020605195313692093, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19524206221103668, + 0.05844240263104439, + 0.09258899092674255, + 0.03365553542971611, + 0.05547372251749039, + 0.22005510330200195, + 0.06493259966373444, + 0.10759030282497406, + 0.06013920530676842, + 0.11188004165887833 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020605195313692093 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive, flattened, lens-shaped alien spacecraft?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the spacecraft's hull smooth, obsidian-black, and lacking visible seams, windows, or thrusters?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene take place in vast wheat fields under cool moonlight with a cold blue-black hue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle shot from the ground and slowly tilt upward to a distant drone-like perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a complex geometric pattern of flattened wheat stalks (a crop circle) visible on the ground after the spacecraft departs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07900331914424896 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.57900333404541 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07900331914424896, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07900331914424896, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14314815402030945, + 0.08080178499221802, + 0.17959465086460114, + 0.03217329829931259, + 0.07150235027074814, + 0.01773117296397686, + 0.04972337931394577, + 0.2205810844898224, + 0.06469926983118057, + 0.14004479348659515 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07900331914424896 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive, flattened, lens-shaped alien spacecraft?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the spacecraft's hull smooth, obsidian-black, and lacking visible seams, windows, or thrusters?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene take place in vast wheat fields under cool moonlight with a cold blue-black hue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle shot from the ground and slowly tilt upward to a distant drone-like perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a complex geometric pattern of flattened wheat stalks (a crop circle) visible on the ground after the spacecraft departs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07898558676242828 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5789856910705566 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07898558676242828, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07898558676242828, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19831722974777222, + 0.024967579171061516, + 0.13265132904052734, + 0.030766207724809647, + 0.030778931453824043, + 0.3067733347415924, + 0.03428223356604576, + 0.0882520005106926, + 0.10068102926015854, + 0.05253012478351593 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07898558676242828 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive, flattened, lens-shaped alien spacecraft?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the spacecraft's hull smooth, obsidian-black, and lacking visible seams, windows, or thrusters?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene take place in vast wheat fields under cool moonlight with a cold blue-black hue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle shot from the ground and slowly tilt upward to a distant drone-like perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a complex geometric pattern of flattened wheat stalks (a crop circle) visible on the ground after the spacecraft departs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007633563131093979 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882633686065674 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007633563131093979, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007633563131093979, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.040609199553728104, + 0.04202553629875183, + 0.1282370388507843, + 0.01686471328139305, + 0.023927941918373108, + 0.08448687940835953, + 0.04693656414747238, + 0.31442394852638245, + 0.11203989386558533, + 0.19044829905033112 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007633563131093979 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle shot, beginning from the ground, slowly and steadily tilts upward, eventually transitioning to a distant drone-like perspective. This shot captures a massive, flattened, lens-shaped alien spacecraft rising vertically in absolute silence, seemingly against the force of gravity. Its smooth, obsidian-black organic metal hull lacks any visible seams, windows, or thrusters. Its massive curves reflect flowing, cold white highlights in the cool moonlight, creating a scene both elegant and oppressive. As the spacecraft ascends, only wisps of mist gently stirred by an invisible force in the vast wheat fields below. Without the roar of engines or the rumbling of air, this creates a sense of technological sophistication beyond the laws of physics. As the camera zooms out and shifts to a bird's-eye view, the image reveals the spacecraft's departure: on the ground where it had just landed, a vast, complex geometric pattern of perfectly flattened wheat stalks—a crop circle—is clearly visible in the moonlight. The entire scene, shrouded in a cold blue-black hue, exudes a solemn, serene, and otherworldly mystery.", + "seed": 29816, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_12/index_7526_seed_29816_dp_24_rank_48_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.03833118863403797, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03833118863403797, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.7, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03833118863403797, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive, flattened, lens-shaped alien spacecraft?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the spacecraft's hull smooth, obsidian-black, and lacking visible seams, windows, or thrusters?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene take place in vast wheat fields under cool moonlight with a cold blue-black hue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle shot from the ground and slowly tilt upward to a distant drone-like perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a complex geometric pattern of flattened wheat stalks (a crop circle) visible on the ground after the spacecraft departs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005977965891361237 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255978107452393 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005977965891361237, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005977965891361237, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2747606039047241, + 0.10166133940219879, + 0.09196595102548599, + 0.08198275417089462, + 0.08212345838546753, + 0.08520292490720749, + 0.11067202687263489, + 0.0787646546959877, + 0.05531496927142143, + 0.03755133971571922 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005977965891361237 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive, flattened, lens-shaped alien spacecraft?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the spacecraft's hull smooth, obsidian-black, and lacking visible seams, windows, or thrusters?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene take place in vast wheat fields under cool moonlight with a cold blue-black hue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle shot from the ground and slowly tilt upward to a distant drone-like perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a complex geometric pattern of flattened wheat stalks (a crop circle) visible on the ground after the spacecraft departs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.043085552752017975 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680855751037598 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.043085552752017975, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.043085552752017975, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3208678066730499, + 0.22481326758861542, + 0.06070753186941147, + 0.05347694829106331, + 0.06486430764198303, + 0.12436480075120926, + 0.06396832317113876, + 0.048146072775125504, + 0.017193172127008438, + 0.021597690880298615 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.043085552752017975 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive, flattened, lens-shaped alien spacecraft?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the spacecraft's hull smooth, obsidian-black, and lacking visible seams, windows, or thrusters?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene take place in vast wheat fields under cool moonlight with a cold blue-black hue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle shot from the ground and slowly tilt upward to a distant drone-like perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a complex geometric pattern of flattened wheat stalks (a crop circle) visible on the ground after the spacecraft departs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008647022768855095 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.7586469650268555 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008647022768855095, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008647022768855095, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15366101264953613, + 0.11122524738311768, + 0.1480311155319214, + 0.10219712555408478, + 0.13902360200881958, + 0.09466082602739334, + 0.10435108840465546, + 0.0793972760438919, + 0.03738871589303017, + 0.030063942074775696 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008647022768855095 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive, flattened, lens-shaped alien spacecraft?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the spacecraft's hull smooth, obsidian-black, and lacking visible seams, windows, or thrusters?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene take place in vast wheat fields under cool moonlight with a cold blue-black hue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle shot from the ground and slowly tilt upward to a distant drone-like perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a complex geometric pattern of flattened wheat stalks (a crop circle) visible on the ground after the spacecraft departs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0789860263466835 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5789859294891357 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0789860263466835, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0789860263466835, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15834610164165497, + 0.15280762314796448, + 0.03699112311005592, + 0.05023106560111046, + 0.03797463700175285, + 0.39290377497673035, + 0.07368330657482147, + 0.05225517973303795, + 0.021983178332448006, + 0.022824015468358994 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0789860263466835 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive, flattened, lens-shaped alien spacecraft?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the spacecraft's hull smooth, obsidian-black, and lacking visible seams, windows, or thrusters?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene take place in vast wheat fields under cool moonlight with a cold blue-black hue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle shot from the ground and slowly tilt upward to a distant drone-like perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a complex geometric pattern of flattened wheat stalks (a crop circle) visible on the ground after the spacecraft departs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05495937541127205 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929959297180176 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05495937541127205, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05495937541127205, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1864871084690094, + 0.10445564240217209, + 0.09798230975866318, + 0.06325754523277283, + 0.06561194360256195, + 0.2023993879556656, + 0.07354363799095154, + 0.10443045943975449, + 0.04219857603311539, + 0.059633467346429825 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05495937541127205 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle shot, beginning from the ground, slowly and steadily tilts upward, eventually transitioning to a distant drone-like perspective. This shot captures a massive, flattened, lens-shaped alien spacecraft rising vertically in absolute silence, seemingly against the force of gravity. Its smooth, obsidian-black organic metal hull lacks any visible seams, windows, or thrusters. Its massive curves reflect flowing, cold white highlights in the cool moonlight, creating a scene both elegant and oppressive. As the spacecraft ascends, only wisps of mist gently stirred by an invisible force in the vast wheat fields below. Without the roar of engines or the rumbling of air, this creates a sense of technological sophistication beyond the laws of physics. As the camera zooms out and shifts to a bird's-eye view, the image reveals the spacecraft's departure: on the ground where it had just landed, a vast, complex geometric pattern of perfectly flattened wheat stalks—a crop circle—is clearly visible in the moonlight. The entire scene, shrouded in a cold blue-black hue, exudes a solemn, serene, and otherworldly mystery.", + "seed": 29817, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_12/index_7526_seed_29817_dp_25_rank_50_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.10232764058746398, + "vlm_logprob": -0.10232764058746398, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.7, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.10232764058746398, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive, flattened, lens-shaped alien spacecraft?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the spacecraft's hull smooth, obsidian-black, and lacking visible seams, windows, or thrusters?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene take place in vast wheat fields under cool moonlight with a cold blue-black hue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle shot from the ground and slowly tilt upward to a distant drone-like perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a complex geometric pattern of flattened wheat stalks (a crop circle) visible on the ground after the spacecraft departs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0030176362488418818 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.128017425537109 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0030176362488418818, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0030176362488418818, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2500985562801361, + 0.07138551771640778, + 0.07312262058258057, + 0.05387960001826286, + 0.06940148770809174, + 0.04882299527525902, + 0.0629989430308342, + 0.17851978540420532, + 0.10420974344015121, + 0.0875607579946518 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0030176362488418818 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive, flattened, lens-shaped alien spacecraft?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the spacecraft's hull smooth, obsidian-black, and lacking visible seams, windows, or thrusters?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene take place in vast wheat fields under cool moonlight with a cold blue-black hue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle shot from the ground and slowly tilt upward to a distant drone-like perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a complex geometric pattern of flattened wheat stalks (a crop circle) visible on the ground after the spacecraft departs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007651781663298607 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.8826518058776855 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007651781663298607, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007651781663298607, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24665896594524384, + 0.03907957673072815, + 0.058317478746175766, + 0.03944071754813194, + 0.074116051197052, + 0.025335311889648438, + 0.029477909207344055, + 0.13688138127326965, + 0.0635451003909111, + 0.28714752197265625 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007651781663298607 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive, flattened, lens-shaped alien spacecraft?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the spacecraft's hull smooth, obsidian-black, and lacking visible seams, windows, or thrusters?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene take place in vast wheat fields under cool moonlight with a cold blue-black hue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle shot from the ground and slowly tilt upward to a distant drone-like perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a complex geometric pattern of flattened wheat stalks (a crop circle) visible on the ground after the spacecraft departs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007636875845491886 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882637023925781 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007636875845491886, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007636875845491886, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.590495228767395, + 0.06860633194446564, + 0.024452731013298035, + 0.0865338072180748, + 0.035405635833740234, + 0.03218698129057884, + 0.015312399715185165, + 0.06316012144088745, + 0.0570775605738163, + 0.026769235730171204 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007636875845491886 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive, flattened, lens-shaped alien spacecraft?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the spacecraft's hull smooth, obsidian-black, and lacking visible seams, windows, or thrusters?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene take place in vast wheat fields under cool moonlight with a cold blue-black hue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle shot from the ground and slowly tilt upward to a distant drone-like perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a complex geometric pattern of flattened wheat stalks (a crop circle) visible on the ground after the spacecraft departs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.31343409419059753 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.31343412399292 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.31343409419059753, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.31343409419059753, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.30380845069885254, + 0.07095467299222946, + 0.05064799264073372, + 0.03480171784758568, + 0.045893579721450806, + 0.03707275539636612, + 0.04025609791278839, + 0.1921088546514511, + 0.021637916564941406, + 0.20281794667243958 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.31343409419059753 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive, flattened, lens-shaped alien spacecraft?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the spacecraft's hull smooth, obsidian-black, and lacking visible seams, windows, or thrusters?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene take place in vast wheat fields under cool moonlight with a cold blue-black hue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle shot from the ground and slowly tilt upward to a distant drone-like perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a complex geometric pattern of flattened wheat stalks (a crop circle) visible on the ground after the spacecraft departs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17989781498908997 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8048977851867676 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17989781498908997, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17989781498908997, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1580296903848648, + 0.0767258033156395, + 0.059533875435590744, + 0.03463476151227951, + 0.04376193881034851, + 0.05241342633962631, + 0.033149201422929764, + 0.09592510014772415, + 0.18974308669567108, + 0.25608304142951965 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17989781498908997 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle shot, beginning from the ground, slowly and steadily tilts upward, eventually transitioning to a distant drone-like perspective. This shot captures a massive, flattened, lens-shaped alien spacecraft rising vertically in absolute silence, seemingly against the force of gravity. Its smooth, obsidian-black organic metal hull lacks any visible seams, windows, or thrusters. Its massive curves reflect flowing, cold white highlights in the cool moonlight, creating a scene both elegant and oppressive. As the spacecraft ascends, only wisps of mist gently stirred by an invisible force in the vast wheat fields below. Without the roar of engines or the rumbling of air, this creates a sense of technological sophistication beyond the laws of physics. As the camera zooms out and shifts to a bird's-eye view, the image reveals the spacecraft's departure: on the ground where it had just landed, a vast, complex geometric pattern of perfectly flattened wheat stalks—a crop circle—is clearly visible in the moonlight. The entire scene, shrouded in a cold blue-black hue, exudes a solemn, serene, and otherworldly mystery.", + "seed": 29818, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_12/index_7526_seed_29818_dp_25_rank_50_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.02942124679684639, + "vlm_logprob": -0.02942124679684639, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.024999952316284, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.02942124679684639, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive, flattened, lens-shaped alien spacecraft?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the spacecraft's hull smooth, obsidian-black, and lacking visible seams, windows, or thrusters?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene take place in vast wheat fields under cool moonlight with a cold blue-black hue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle shot from the ground and slowly tilt upward to a distant drone-like perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a complex geometric pattern of flattened wheat stalks (a crop circle) visible on the ground after the spacecraft departs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00508100213482976 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.3800811767578125 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00508100213482976, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00508100213482976, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.251565158367157, + 0.21397416293621063, + 0.0939069613814354, + 0.06932445615530014, + 0.06198809668421745, + 0.1270371824502945, + 0.024766473099589348, + 0.04694418981671333, + 0.03745665401220322, + 0.07303668558597565 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00508100213482976 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive, flattened, lens-shaped alien spacecraft?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the spacecraft's hull smooth, obsidian-black, and lacking visible seams, windows, or thrusters?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene take place in vast wheat fields under cool moonlight with a cold blue-black hue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle shot from the ground and slowly tilt upward to a distant drone-like perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a complex geometric pattern of flattened wheat stalks (a crop circle) visible on the ground after the spacecraft departs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018206268548965454 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.0182061195373535 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018206268548965454, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018206268548965454, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4704112410545349, + 0.05670822039246559, + 0.07970006763935089, + 0.06201408803462982, + 0.09936758130788803, + 0.1066657081246376, + 0.027891352772712708, + 0.018390994518995285, + 0.03330741077661514, + 0.045543331652879715 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018206268548965454 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive, flattened, lens-shaped alien spacecraft?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the spacecraft's hull smooth, obsidian-black, and lacking visible seams, windows, or thrusters?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene take place in vast wheat fields under cool moonlight with a cold blue-black hue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle shot from the ground and slowly tilt upward to a distant drone-like perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a complex geometric pattern of flattened wheat stalks (a crop circle) visible on the ground after the spacecraft departs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03810866177082062 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881085872650146 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03810866177082062, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03810866177082062, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16503609716892242, + 0.33274155855178833, + 0.13510389626026154, + 0.07947328686714172, + 0.09762956202030182, + 0.06596358120441437, + 0.035121072083711624, + 0.05865637585520744, + 0.01852455735206604, + 0.011749970726668835 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03810866177082062 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive, flattened, lens-shaped alien spacecraft?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the spacecraft's hull smooth, obsidian-black, and lacking visible seams, windows, or thrusters?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene take place in vast wheat fields under cool moonlight with a cold blue-black hue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle shot from the ground and slowly tilt upward to a distant drone-like perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a complex geometric pattern of flattened wheat stalks (a crop circle) visible on the ground after the spacecraft departs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07896961271762848 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.578969717025757 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07896961271762848, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07896961271762848, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.39313578605651855, + 0.37883248925209045, + 0.06969243288040161, + 0.01712520234286785, + 0.012760361656546593, + 0.020174173638224602, + 0.023419193923473358, + 0.018331339582800865, + 0.049264054745435715, + 0.017265036702156067 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07896961271762848 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive, flattened, lens-shaped alien spacecraft?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the spacecraft's hull smooth, obsidian-black, and lacking visible seams, windows, or thrusters?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene take place in vast wheat fields under cool moonlight with a cold blue-black hue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle shot from the ground and slowly tilt upward to a distant drone-like perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a complex geometric pattern of flattened wheat stalks (a crop circle) visible on the ground after the spacecraft departs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0067406888119876385 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006740570068359 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0067406888119876385, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0067406888119876385, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24125279486179352, + 0.2432667762041092, + 0.04896226525306702, + 0.0226291511207819, + 0.024242525920271873, + 0.1877276450395584, + 0.027681227773427963, + 0.07687816768884659, + 0.03627479821443558, + 0.09108461439609528 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0067406888119876385 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_13/index_tensor([8735, 8735])_group_13_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_13/index_tensor([8735, 8735])_group_13_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..ba2c14bad903d46418674a36cde8090f1463efc8 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_13/index_tensor([8735, 8735])_group_13_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up, static macro shot plunges the viewer into a murky aquatic environment, where a mesmerizing natural event unfolds. As translucent mineral grains rapidly crystallize, the camera remains perfectly still, capturing the entire hardening process with breathtaking clarity. Sharp, geometric structures explosively branch outward from a single nucleation point, their branch-like, splinter-like arms swiftly and decisively crossing the frame. These glassy structures precisely interlock, their faceted edges colliding and merging to form a complex, rigid grid that steadily consumes the fluid space. The scene is dramatically illuminated by a single, intense light source, creating a black-and-white contrast of deep, inky shadows and brilliant, specular highlights that shimmer with each newly formed edge and surface. The palette, rendered in stark, desaturated color gradations, reduced to a cool spectrum of white, gray, and black, reveals every intricate detail of the hardening process and enhances the pristine structural beauty. The atmosphere is tense and hypnotic, utterly focused on the beautiful violence of creation, where sharp, interlocking crystals conquer the void.", + "seed": 13898, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_13/index_8735_seed_13898_dp_26_rank_52_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.6060126606374979, + "vlm_logprob": -0.6060126606374979, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.800000011920929, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.6060126606374979, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.6, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro view of translucent mineral grains crystallizing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment depicted as a murky aquatic setting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perfectly still throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a single intense light source creating high contrast between deep shadows and brilliant specular highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color palette strictly limited to a cool spectrum of white, gray, and black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08112175762653351 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5811216831207275 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08112175762653351, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08112175762653351, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04234204441308975, + 0.036951273679733276, + 0.09957294911146164, + 0.03499341756105423, + 0.2726622521877289, + 0.2585371732711792, + 0.03744203597307205, + 0.028485620394349098, + 0.09248406440019608, + 0.09652921557426453 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08112175762653351 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro view of translucent mineral grains crystallizing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment depicted as a murky aquatic setting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perfectly still throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a single intense light source creating high contrast between deep shadows and brilliant specular highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color palette strictly limited to a cool spectrum of white, gray, and black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7015888690948486 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20158885419368744 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.7015888690948486, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -1.7015888690948486, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09428933262825012, + 0.06198926642537117, + 0.14160509407520294, + 0.059850819408893585, + 0.18330809473991394, + 0.04357238486409187, + 0.07010449469089508, + 0.027259185910224915, + 0.05487232655286789, + 0.26314905285835266 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.7015888690948486 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro view of translucent mineral grains crystallizing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment depicted as a murky aquatic setting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perfectly still throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a single intense light source creating high contrast between deep shadows and brilliant specular highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color palette strictly limited to a cool spectrum of white, gray, and black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.223681926727295 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3486819863319397 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.223681926727295, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.8749999403953552, + "token_credit_reward": -1.223681926727295, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.046753715723752975, + 0.10683825612068176, + 0.15010936558246613, + 0.05967191606760025, + 0.13214561343193054, + 0.24234481155872345, + 0.033364180475473404, + 0.021022194996476173, + 0.03561890497803688, + 0.17213107645511627 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.223681926727295 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro view of translucent mineral grains crystallizing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment depicted as a murky aquatic setting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perfectly still throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a single intense light source creating high contrast between deep shadows and brilliant specular highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color palette strictly limited to a cool spectrum of white, gray, and black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01257679145783186 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387576580047607 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01257679145783186, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01257679145783186, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0734638199210167, + 0.11198799312114716, + 0.24152331054210663, + 0.04725994914770126, + 0.15172965824604034, + 0.03412532061338425, + 0.02300393208861351, + 0.02901305817067623, + 0.029060907661914825, + 0.25883209705352783 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01257679145783186 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro view of translucent mineral grains crystallizing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment depicted as a murky aquatic setting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perfectly still throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a single intense light source creating high contrast between deep shadows and brilliant specular highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color palette strictly limited to a cool spectrum of white, gray, and black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011093958280980587 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511094093322754 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011093958280980587, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011093958280980587, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0896807461977005, + 0.07545488327741623, + 0.2625572681427002, + 0.019726630300283432, + 0.04738551750779152, + 0.1903173327445984, + 0.02076403796672821, + 0.02077513188123703, + 0.022218916565179825, + 0.25111958384513855 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011093958280980587 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up, static macro shot plunges the viewer into a murky aquatic environment, where a mesmerizing natural event unfolds. As translucent mineral grains rapidly crystallize, the camera remains perfectly still, capturing the entire hardening process with breathtaking clarity. Sharp, geometric structures explosively branch outward from a single nucleation point, their branch-like, splinter-like arms swiftly and decisively crossing the frame. These glassy structures precisely interlock, their faceted edges colliding and merging to form a complex, rigid grid that steadily consumes the fluid space. The scene is dramatically illuminated by a single, intense light source, creating a black-and-white contrast of deep, inky shadows and brilliant, specular highlights that shimmer with each newly formed edge and surface. The palette, rendered in stark, desaturated color gradations, reduced to a cool spectrum of white, gray, and black, reveals every intricate detail of the hardening process and enhances the pristine structural beauty. The atmosphere is tense and hypnotic, utterly focused on the beautiful violence of creation, where sharp, interlocking crystals conquer the void.", + "seed": 13899, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_13/index_8735_seed_13899_dp_26_rank_52_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.6645643144845963, + "vlm_logprob": -0.6645643144845963, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.725000023841858, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.6645643144845963, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.6, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro view of translucent mineral grains crystallizing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment depicted as a murky aquatic setting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perfectly still throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a single intense light source creating high contrast between deep shadows and brilliant specular highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color palette strictly limited to a cool spectrum of white, gray, and black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05055717006325722 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0505571365356445 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05055717006325722, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05055717006325722, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.054060932248830795, + 0.04826455935835838, + 0.02838975004851818, + 0.04779764264822006, + 0.1356671154499054, + 0.08233784139156342, + 0.05325838550925255, + 0.04560582712292671, + 0.30742231011390686, + 0.1971956193447113 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05055717006325722 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro view of translucent mineral grains crystallizing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment depicted as a murky aquatic setting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perfectly still throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a single intense light source creating high contrast between deep shadows and brilliant specular highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color palette strictly limited to a cool spectrum of white, gray, and black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0177836418151855 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14278371632099152 + ], + "logprob_reward": -2.0177836418151855, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.8749998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -2.0177836418151855, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07377395778894424, + 0.057335708290338516, + 0.040701236575841904, + 0.18288521468639374, + 0.058056995272636414, + 0.027880778536200523, + 0.018925022333860397, + 0.037474967539310455, + 0.14820866286754608, + 0.3547573983669281 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 3, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -2.0177836418151855 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro view of translucent mineral grains crystallizing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment depicted as a murky aquatic setting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perfectly still throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a single intense light source creating high contrast between deep shadows and brilliant specular highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color palette strictly limited to a cool spectrum of white, gray, and black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2236993312835693 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.34869930148124695 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.2236993312835693, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -1.2236993312835693, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06569833308458328, + 0.06599432975053787, + 0.06758298724889755, + 0.17756809294223785, + 0.09842243790626526, + 0.05753708630800247, + 0.15035571157932281, + 0.04116888344287872, + 0.08811116218566895, + 0.18756093084812164 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 3, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.2236993312835693 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro view of translucent mineral grains crystallizing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment depicted as a murky aquatic setting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perfectly still throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a single intense light source creating high contrast between deep shadows and brilliant specular highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color palette strictly limited to a cool spectrum of white, gray, and black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018223825842142105 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018223762512207 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018223825842142105, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018223825842142105, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2744128406047821, + 0.02963479794561863, + 0.045772355049848557, + 0.1098586916923523, + 0.018731914460659027, + 0.05837933346629143, + 0.07066197693347931, + 0.03412923961877823, + 0.08987760543823242, + 0.268541157245636 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018223825842142105 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro view of translucent mineral grains crystallizing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment depicted as a murky aquatic setting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perfectly still throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a single intense light source creating high contrast between deep shadows and brilliant specular highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color palette strictly limited to a cool spectrum of white, gray, and black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012557603418827057 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387557506561279 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012557603418827057, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012557603418827057, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10924060642719269, + 0.07495613396167755, + 0.03658869117498398, + 0.11175351589918137, + 0.01938970759510994, + 0.06068560108542442, + 0.046173371374607086, + 0.14159151911735535, + 0.13300134241580963, + 0.2666195034980774 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012557603418827057 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up, static macro shot plunges the viewer into a murky aquatic environment, where a mesmerizing natural event unfolds. As translucent mineral grains rapidly crystallize, the camera remains perfectly still, capturing the entire hardening process with breathtaking clarity. Sharp, geometric structures explosively branch outward from a single nucleation point, their branch-like, splinter-like arms swiftly and decisively crossing the frame. These glassy structures precisely interlock, their faceted edges colliding and merging to form a complex, rigid grid that steadily consumes the fluid space. The scene is dramatically illuminated by a single, intense light source, creating a black-and-white contrast of deep, inky shadows and brilliant, specular highlights that shimmer with each newly formed edge and surface. The palette, rendered in stark, desaturated color gradations, reduced to a cool spectrum of white, gray, and black, reveals every intricate detail of the hardening process and enhances the pristine structural beauty. The atmosphere is tense and hypnotic, utterly focused on the beautiful violence of creation, where sharp, interlocking crystals conquer the void.", + "seed": 13900, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_13/index_8735_seed_13900_dp_27_rank_54_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.6615905195474625, + "vlm_logprob": -0.6615905195474625, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.55, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.6615905195474625, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.6, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro view of translucent mineral grains crystallizing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment depicted as a murky aquatic setting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perfectly still throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a single intense light source creating high contrast between deep shadows and brilliant specular highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color palette strictly limited to a cool spectrum of white, gray, and black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.09048784524202347 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4654879570007324 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.09048784524202347, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.09048784524202347, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06507617980241776, + 0.1436544954776764, + 0.02112969197332859, + 0.06742645800113678, + 0.0873401090502739, + 0.07690007984638214, + 0.07482217252254486, + 0.08658131211996078, + 0.027172928676009178, + 0.349896639585495 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.09048784524202347 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro view of translucent mineral grains crystallizing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment depicted as a murky aquatic setting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perfectly still throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a single intense light source creating high contrast between deep shadows and brilliant specular highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color palette strictly limited to a cool spectrum of white, gray, and black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1270415782928467 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1270415484905243 + ], + "logprob_reward": -2.1270415782928467, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -2.1270415782928467, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10612597316503525, + 0.05751866474747658, + 0.03639594092965126, + 0.07927564531564713, + 0.07694143801927567, + 0.1515718251466751, + 0.06216718256473541, + 0.1016649678349495, + 0.05457932874560356, + 0.2737590968608856 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -2.1270415782928467 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro view of translucent mineral grains crystallizing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment depicted as a murky aquatic setting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perfectly still throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a single intense light source creating high contrast between deep shadows and brilliant specular highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color palette strictly limited to a cool spectrum of white, gray, and black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.0539851188659668 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4289851188659668 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.0539851188659668, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.625, + "token_credit_reward": -1.0539851188659668, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0668397843837738, + 0.055786021053791046, + 0.09505973011255264, + 0.2281814068555832, + 0.2524571418762207, + 0.10492803901433945, + 0.03691762685775757, + 0.046563662588596344, + 0.02175021730363369, + 0.09151637554168701 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.0539851188659668 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro view of translucent mineral grains crystallizing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment depicted as a murky aquatic setting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perfectly still throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a single intense light source creating high contrast between deep shadows and brilliant specular highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color palette strictly limited to a cool spectrum of white, gray, and black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01822710409760475 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.0182271003723145 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01822710409760475, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01822710409760475, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2167881429195404, + 0.17017489671707153, + 0.048653632402420044, + 0.06630239635705948, + 0.17173567414283752, + 0.05039675533771515, + 0.08457529544830322, + 0.08491263538599014, + 0.03555304557085037, + 0.07090749591588974 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01822710409760475 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro view of translucent mineral grains crystallizing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment depicted as a murky aquatic setting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perfectly still throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a single intense light source creating high contrast between deep shadows and brilliant specular highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color palette strictly limited to a cool spectrum of white, gray, and black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01821095123887062 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.0182108879089355 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01821095123887062, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01821095123887062, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09528863430023193, + 0.06518403440713882, + 0.0292738638818264, + 0.06380265951156616, + 0.20420874655246735, + 0.2038894146680832, + 0.02493678592145443, + 0.06849709898233414, + 0.05487719550728798, + 0.19004160165786743 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01821095123887062 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up, static macro shot plunges the viewer into a murky aquatic environment, where a mesmerizing natural event unfolds. As translucent mineral grains rapidly crystallize, the camera remains perfectly still, capturing the entire hardening process with breathtaking clarity. Sharp, geometric structures explosively branch outward from a single nucleation point, their branch-like, splinter-like arms swiftly and decisively crossing the frame. These glassy structures precisely interlock, their faceted edges colliding and merging to form a complex, rigid grid that steadily consumes the fluid space. The scene is dramatically illuminated by a single, intense light source, creating a black-and-white contrast of deep, inky shadows and brilliant, specular highlights that shimmer with each newly formed edge and surface. The palette, rendered in stark, desaturated color gradations, reduced to a cool spectrum of white, gray, and black, reveals every intricate detail of the hardening process and enhances the pristine structural beauty. The atmosphere is tense and hypnotic, utterly focused on the beautiful violence of creation, where sharp, interlocking crystals conquer the void.", + "seed": 13901, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_13/index_8735_seed_13901_dp_27_rank_54_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.6844683695584536, + "vlm_logprob": -0.6844683695584536, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.775000023841858, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.6844683695584536, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.6, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro view of translucent mineral grains crystallizing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment depicted as a murky aquatic setting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perfectly still throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a single intense light source creating high contrast between deep shadows and brilliant specular highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color palette strictly limited to a cool spectrum of white, gray, and black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04438740760087967 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1693873405456543 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04438740760087967, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04438740760087967, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11915460228919983, + 0.0437939427793026, + 0.0872437059879303, + 0.17445513606071472, + 0.16971847414970398, + 0.0860447958111763, + 0.08570562303066254, + 0.039512861520051956, + 0.09496726840734482, + 0.09940357506275177 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04438740760087967 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro view of translucent mineral grains crystallizing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment depicted as a murky aquatic setting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perfectly still throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a single intense light source creating high contrast between deep shadows and brilliant specular highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color palette strictly limited to a cool spectrum of white, gray, and black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1270337104797363 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1270337849855423 + ], + "logprob_reward": -2.1270337104797363, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.9999998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -2.1270337104797363, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22932708263397217, + 0.035220175981521606, + 0.1295621395111084, + 0.15897829830646515, + 0.13825498521327972, + 0.04304102808237076, + 0.03595566377043724, + 0.03609059378504753, + 0.05427392199635506, + 0.13929609954357147 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -2.1270337104797363 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro view of translucent mineral grains crystallizing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment depicted as a murky aquatic setting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perfectly still throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a single intense light source creating high contrast between deep shadows and brilliant specular highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color palette strictly limited to a cool spectrum of white, gray, and black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2237011194229126 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.348701149225235 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.2237011194229126, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -1.2237011194229126, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1893124133348465, + 0.03416381776332855, + 0.06990494579076767, + 0.16271640360355377, + 0.14314310252666473, + 0.07818876206874847, + 0.17693887650966644, + 0.02942340075969696, + 0.045893121510744095, + 0.07031513750553131 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.2237011194229126 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro view of translucent mineral grains crystallizing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment depicted as a murky aquatic setting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perfectly still throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a single intense light source creating high contrast between deep shadows and brilliant specular highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color palette strictly limited to a cool spectrum of white, gray, and black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016117870807647705 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141118049621582 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016117870807647705, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016117870807647705, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11819417774677277, + 0.06716356426477432, + 0.058222923427820206, + 0.06322482228279114, + 0.17667874693870544, + 0.12429604679346085, + 0.16340577602386475, + 0.03677242249250412, + 0.052317287772893906, + 0.13972415030002594 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016117870807647705 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro view of translucent mineral grains crystallizing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment depicted as a murky aquatic setting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perfectly still throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a single intense light source creating high contrast between deep shadows and brilliant specular highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color palette strictly limited to a cool spectrum of white, gray, and black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0111017394810915 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511101722717285 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0111017394810915, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0111017394810915, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21923190355300903, + 0.08938992768526077, + 0.10266964137554169, + 0.06055111810564995, + 0.07143904268741608, + 0.0835026204586029, + 0.10963501781225204, + 0.03931095451116562, + 0.051779333502054214, + 0.17249037325382233 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0111017394810915 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_14/index_tensor([3045, 3045])_group_14_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_14/index_tensor([3045, 3045])_group_14_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..5bf7c75a5e46fb38cc382445e70a173878dd1de8 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_14/index_tensor([3045, 3045])_group_14_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "still close-up, captured from a level eye level, captures a moment of pure, suppressed grief on a young boy, perhaps five or six. His short, messy dark brown hair is slightly damp with sweat, strands clinging to his forehead. His cheeks are smeared with a mixture of dirt and dust from play. His eyes are tightly closed, his long lashes clinging to his tears, his lids trembling slightly with the effort of endurance. Crystal-clear, large tears silently flow from the corners of his closed eyes, slowly sliding down his dusty cheeks, leaving two distinct, wet streaks that gleam and shimmer in the soft afternoon sunlight. His lips are pursed, his lower lip trembling uncontrollably, as if he is exerting all his strength to suppress his sobs. The blurred background, with its out-of-focus greenery and dappled light, suggests a warm outdoor setting, but this tranquil backdrop only serves to accentuate his loneliness and profound grief. The entire image is imbued with a heartbreaking tranquility and vulnerability.", + "seed": 23469, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_14/index_3045_seed_23469_dp_28_rank_56_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.019842396723106503, + "vlm_logprob": -0.019842396723106503, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.375, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.019842396723106503, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a young boy, approximately five or six years old, with short, messy dark brown hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the boy's cheeks smeared with dirt and dust, and is his hair slightly damp with sweat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the boy's eyes tightly closed with long lashes clinging to tears, and are large tears visibly flowing down his cheeks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the boy's lower lip trembling uncontrollably while his lips are pursed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred with out-of-focus greenery and dappled light, suggesting a warm outdoor setting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03830830752849579 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2883083820343018 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03830830752849579, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03830830752849579, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08577115088701248, + 0.0932002142071724, + 0.04164717718958855, + 0.03576001897454262, + 0.1482485830783844, + 0.12392881512641907, + 0.15325826406478882, + 0.12365101277828217, + 0.04638795182108879, + 0.1481468230485916 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03830830752849579 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a young boy, approximately five or six years old, with short, messy dark brown hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the boy's cheeks smeared with dirt and dust, and is his hair slightly damp with sweat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the boy's eyes tightly closed with long lashes clinging to tears, and are large tears visibly flowing down his cheeks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the boy's lower lip trembling uncontrollably while his lips are pursed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred with out-of-focus greenery and dappled light, suggesting a warm outdoor setting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009795219637453556 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634795188903809 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009795219637453556, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009795219637453556, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1440388709306717, + 0.21672597527503967, + 0.2475328892469406, + 0.01780044659972191, + 0.034635480493307114, + 0.04189720004796982, + 0.1203116625547409, + 0.0635661631822586, + 0.045589614659547806, + 0.06790169328451157 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009795219637453556 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a young boy, approximately five or six years old, with short, messy dark brown hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the boy's cheeks smeared with dirt and dust, and is his hair slightly damp with sweat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the boy's eyes tightly closed with long lashes clinging to tears, and are large tears visibly flowing down his cheeks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the boy's lower lip trembling uncontrollably while his lips are pursed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred with out-of-focus greenery and dappled light, suggesting a warm outdoor setting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011082993820309639 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511083126068115 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011082993820309639, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011082993820309639, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1625213623046875, + 0.07828323543071747, + 0.07852411270141602, + 0.03088575415313244, + 0.04586398974061012, + 0.03694547340273857, + 0.2135179340839386, + 0.12810972332954407, + 0.13381877541542053, + 0.09152966737747192 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011082993820309639 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a young boy, approximately five or six years old, with short, messy dark brown hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the boy's cheeks smeared with dirt and dust, and is his hair slightly damp with sweat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the boy's eyes tightly closed with long lashes clinging to tears, and are large tears visibly flowing down his cheeks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the boy's lower lip trembling uncontrollably while his lips are pursed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred with out-of-focus greenery and dappled light, suggesting a warm outdoor setting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03808697313070297 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2880868911743164 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03808697313070297, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03808697313070297, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14869555830955505, + 0.05483176186680794, + 0.12027619034051895, + 0.021920256316661835, + 0.04785384237766266, + 0.12307561933994293, + 0.10326050966978073, + 0.18176451325416565, + 0.12184552848339081, + 0.07647627592086792 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03808697313070297 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a young boy, approximately five or six years old, with short, messy dark brown hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the boy's cheeks smeared with dirt and dust, and is his hair slightly damp with sweat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the boy's eyes tightly closed with long lashes clinging to tears, and are large tears visibly flowing down his cheeks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the boy's lower lip trembling uncontrollably while his lips are pursed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred with out-of-focus greenery and dappled light, suggesting a warm outdoor setting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0019384894985705614 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.251938343048096 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0019384894985705614, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0019384894985705614, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04658402502536774, + 0.6116781234741211, + 0.05229724198579788, + 0.02735511213541031, + 0.024298399686813354, + 0.02934957668185234, + 0.12432996928691864, + 0.03494197130203247, + 0.013120099902153015, + 0.03604545071721077 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 6, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0019384894985705614 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "still close-up, captured from a level eye level, captures a moment of pure, suppressed grief on a young boy, perhaps five or six. His short, messy dark brown hair is slightly damp with sweat, strands clinging to his forehead. His cheeks are smeared with a mixture of dirt and dust from play. His eyes are tightly closed, his long lashes clinging to his tears, his lids trembling slightly with the effort of endurance. Crystal-clear, large tears silently flow from the corners of his closed eyes, slowly sliding down his dusty cheeks, leaving two distinct, wet streaks that gleam and shimmer in the soft afternoon sunlight. His lips are pursed, his lower lip trembling uncontrollably, as if he is exerting all his strength to suppress his sobs. The blurred background, with its out-of-focus greenery and dappled light, suggests a warm outdoor setting, but this tranquil backdrop only serves to accentuate his loneliness and profound grief. The entire image is imbued with a heartbreaking tranquility and vulnerability.", + "seed": 23470, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_14/index_3045_seed_23470_dp_28_rank_56_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.03379807346500456, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03379807346500456, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.925, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03379807346500456, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a young boy, approximately five or six years old, with short, messy dark brown hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the boy's cheeks smeared with dirt and dust, and is his hair slightly damp with sweat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the boy's eyes tightly closed with long lashes clinging to tears, and are large tears visibly flowing down his cheeks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the boy's lower lip trembling uncontrollably while his lips are pursed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred with out-of-focus greenery and dappled light, suggesting a warm outdoor setting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07046819478273392 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6954681873321533 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07046819478273392, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07046819478273392, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1780996471643448, + 0.19510765373706818, + 0.1073899045586586, + 0.035028550773859024, + 0.07877147197723389, + 0.08197386562824249, + 0.07411707192659378, + 0.11055392771959305, + 0.05472179874777794, + 0.08423615992069244 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07046819478273392 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a young boy, approximately five or six years old, with short, messy dark brown hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the boy's cheeks smeared with dirt and dust, and is his hair slightly damp with sweat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the boy's eyes tightly closed with long lashes clinging to tears, and are large tears visibly flowing down his cheeks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the boy's lower lip trembling uncontrollably while his lips are pursed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred with out-of-focus greenery and dappled light, suggesting a warm outdoor setting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018204277381300926 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018204212188721 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018204277381300926, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018204277381300926, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09040588140487671, + 0.1361459344625473, + 0.08135697990655899, + 0.048645418137311935, + 0.09218021482229233, + 0.2406335473060608, + 0.023528028279542923, + 0.09872617572546005, + 0.0895705446600914, + 0.09880728274583817 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018204277381300926 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a young boy, approximately five or six years old, with short, messy dark brown hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the boy's cheeks smeared with dirt and dust, and is his hair slightly damp with sweat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the boy's eyes tightly closed with long lashes clinging to tears, and are large tears visibly flowing down his cheeks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the boy's lower lip trembling uncontrollably while his lips are pursed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred with out-of-focus greenery and dappled light, suggesting a warm outdoor setting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0160837359726429 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141083717346191 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0160837359726429, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0160837359726429, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09304629266262054, + 0.05282619595527649, + 0.07071889936923981, + 0.03478798642754555, + 0.02228887751698494, + 0.13842788338661194, + 0.03491679206490517, + 0.1278592348098755, + 0.0531773567199707, + 0.37195053696632385 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0160837359726429 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a young boy, approximately five or six years old, with short, messy dark brown hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the boy's cheeks smeared with dirt and dust, and is his hair slightly damp with sweat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the boy's eyes tightly closed with long lashes clinging to tears, and are large tears visibly flowing down his cheeks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the boy's lower lip trembling uncontrollably while his lips are pursed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred with out-of-focus greenery and dappled light, suggesting a warm outdoor setting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.062035735696554184 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120357990264893 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.062035735696554184, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.062035735696554184, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09671513736248016, + 0.07318364828824997, + 0.12389252334833145, + 0.024493079632520676, + 0.028511350974440575, + 0.05851732939481735, + 0.020251786336302757, + 0.044039152562618256, + 0.07853782922029495, + 0.45185816287994385 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.062035735696554184 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a young boy, approximately five or six years old, with short, messy dark brown hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the boy's cheeks smeared with dirt and dust, and is his hair slightly damp with sweat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the boy's eyes tightly closed with long lashes clinging to tears, and are large tears visibly flowing down his cheeks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the boy's lower lip trembling uncontrollably while his lips are pursed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred with out-of-focus greenery and dappled light, suggesting a warm outdoor setting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0021984234917908907 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127198219299316 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0021984234917908907, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0021984234917908907, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.151381716132164, + 0.13674472272396088, + 0.3189677894115448, + 0.021221645176410675, + 0.021640868857502937, + 0.08049989491701126, + 0.02926679141819477, + 0.07277730107307434, + 0.030181152746081352, + 0.13731814920902252 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0021984234917908907 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "still close-up, captured from a level eye level, captures a moment of pure, suppressed grief on a young boy, perhaps five or six. His short, messy dark brown hair is slightly damp with sweat, strands clinging to his forehead. His cheeks are smeared with a mixture of dirt and dust from play. His eyes are tightly closed, his long lashes clinging to his tears, his lids trembling slightly with the effort of endurance. Crystal-clear, large tears silently flow from the corners of his closed eyes, slowly sliding down his dusty cheeks, leaving two distinct, wet streaks that gleam and shimmer in the soft afternoon sunlight. His lips are pursed, his lower lip trembling uncontrollably, as if he is exerting all his strength to suppress his sobs. The blurred background, with its out-of-focus greenery and dappled light, suggests a warm outdoor setting, but this tranquil backdrop only serves to accentuate his loneliness and profound grief. The entire image is imbued with a heartbreaking tranquility and vulnerability.", + "seed": 23471, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_14/index_3045_seed_23471_dp_29_rank_58_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.04181677128653973, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04181677128653973, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.325, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04181677128653973, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a young boy, approximately five or six years old, with short, messy dark brown hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the boy's cheeks smeared with dirt and dust, and is his hair slightly damp with sweat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the boy's eyes tightly closed with long lashes clinging to tears, and are large tears visibly flowing down his cheeks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the boy's lower lip trembling uncontrollably while his lips are pursed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred with out-of-focus greenery and dappled light, suggesting a warm outdoor setting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007877946831285954 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882877826690674 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007877946831285954, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007877946831285954, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3894265592098236, + 0.021688196808099747, + 0.05644746124744415, + 0.07818716764450073, + 0.053421758115291595, + 0.3675779700279236, + 0.005187714472413063, + 0.006742720492184162, + 0.00841568224132061, + 0.012904814444482327 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007877946831285954 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a young boy, approximately five or six years old, with short, messy dark brown hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the boy's cheeks smeared with dirt and dust, and is his hair slightly damp with sweat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the boy's eyes tightly closed with long lashes clinging to tears, and are large tears visibly flowing down his cheeks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the boy's lower lip trembling uncontrollably while his lips are pursed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred with out-of-focus greenery and dappled light, suggesting a warm outdoor setting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008654467761516571 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758654594421387 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008654467761516571, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008654467761516571, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20756526291370392, + 0.03187023103237152, + 0.030220378190279007, + 0.17018944025039673, + 0.016506973654031754, + 0.431779682636261, + 0.02350652404129505, + 0.014001824893057346, + 0.02595682628452778, + 0.04840286076068878 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008654467761516571 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a young boy, approximately five or six years old, with short, messy dark brown hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the boy's cheeks smeared with dirt and dust, and is his hair slightly damp with sweat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the boy's eyes tightly closed with long lashes clinging to tears, and are large tears visibly flowing down his cheeks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the boy's lower lip trembling uncontrollably while his lips are pursed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred with out-of-focus greenery and dappled light, suggesting a warm outdoor setting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11295183002948761 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2379517555236816 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11295183002948761, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11295183002948761, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07711616903543472, + 0.03580848500132561, + 0.03954535350203514, + 0.21826037764549255, + 0.12584605813026428, + 0.3796024024486542, + 0.0384213887155056, + 0.018551476299762726, + 0.02511417493224144, + 0.041734110563993454 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11295183002948761 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a young boy, approximately five or six years old, with short, messy dark brown hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the boy's cheeks smeared with dirt and dust, and is his hair slightly damp with sweat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the boy's eyes tightly closed with long lashes clinging to tears, and are large tears visibly flowing down his cheeks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the boy's lower lip trembling uncontrollably while his lips are pursed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred with out-of-focus greenery and dappled light, suggesting a warm outdoor setting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07896597683429718 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.578965902328491 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07896597683429718, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07896597683429718, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.49847733974456787, + 0.02507978491485119, + 0.009227769449353218, + 0.11786593496799469, + 0.010408236645162106, + 0.2967977225780487, + 0.009517972357571125, + 0.007809802424162626, + 0.016737043857574463, + 0.00807839073240757 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07896597683429718 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a young boy, approximately five or six years old, with short, messy dark brown hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the boy's cheeks smeared with dirt and dust, and is his hair slightly damp with sweat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the boy's eyes tightly closed with long lashes clinging to tears, and are large tears visibly flowing down his cheeks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the boy's lower lip trembling uncontrollably while his lips are pursed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred with out-of-focus greenery and dappled light, suggesting a warm outdoor setting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0006336349761113524 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.375633716583252 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0006336349761113524, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0006336349761113524, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5130658745765686, + 0.04051186516880989, + 0.028650423511862755, + 0.020536720752716064, + 0.012885854579508305, + 0.3366248607635498, + 0.009923254139721394, + 0.0132816256955266, + 0.006741771474480629, + 0.017777781933546066 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0006336349761113524 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "still close-up, captured from a level eye level, captures a moment of pure, suppressed grief on a young boy, perhaps five or six. His short, messy dark brown hair is slightly damp with sweat, strands clinging to his forehead. His cheeks are smeared with a mixture of dirt and dust from play. His eyes are tightly closed, his long lashes clinging to his tears, his lids trembling slightly with the effort of endurance. Crystal-clear, large tears silently flow from the corners of his closed eyes, slowly sliding down his dusty cheeks, leaving two distinct, wet streaks that gleam and shimmer in the soft afternoon sunlight. His lips are pursed, his lower lip trembling uncontrollably, as if he is exerting all his strength to suppress his sobs. The blurred background, with its out-of-focus greenery and dappled light, suggests a warm outdoor setting, but this tranquil backdrop only serves to accentuate his loneliness and profound grief. The entire image is imbued with a heartbreaking tranquility and vulnerability.", + "seed": 23472, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_14/index_3045_seed_23472_dp_29_rank_58_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.04096350711770356, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04096350711770356, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.875, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04096350711770356, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a young boy, approximately five or six years old, with short, messy dark brown hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the boy's cheeks smeared with dirt and dust, and is his hair slightly damp with sweat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the boy's eyes tightly closed with long lashes clinging to tears, and are large tears visibly flowing down his cheeks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the boy's lower lip trembling uncontrollably while his lips are pursed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred with out-of-focus greenery and dappled light, suggesting a warm outdoor setting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04337838664650917 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1683783531188965 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04337838664650917, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04337838664650917, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22866125404834747, + 0.10401860624551773, + 0.07834442704916, + 0.030247483402490616, + 0.05940781533718109, + 0.10428618639707565, + 0.2765653729438782, + 0.05389640852808952, + 0.032600488513708115, + 0.03197188675403595 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04337838664650917 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a young boy, approximately five or six years old, with short, messy dark brown hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the boy's cheeks smeared with dirt and dust, and is his hair slightly damp with sweat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the boy's eyes tightly closed with long lashes clinging to tears, and are large tears visibly flowing down his cheeks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the boy's lower lip trembling uncontrollably while his lips are pursed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred with out-of-focus greenery and dappled light, suggesting a warm outdoor setting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01109160017222166 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511091709136963 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01109160017222166, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01109160017222166, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14226973056793213, + 0.16337443888187408, + 0.13141381740570068, + 0.05413753166794777, + 0.055477309972047806, + 0.028674429282546043, + 0.1629638671875, + 0.17389445006847382, + 0.06212015450000763, + 0.02567427046597004 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01109160017222166 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a young boy, approximately five or six years old, with short, messy dark brown hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the boy's cheeks smeared with dirt and dust, and is his hair slightly damp with sweat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the boy's eyes tightly closed with long lashes clinging to tears, and are large tears visibly flowing down his cheeks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the boy's lower lip trembling uncontrollably while his lips are pursed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred with out-of-focus greenery and dappled light, suggesting a warm outdoor setting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07004938274621964 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695049285888672 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07004938274621964, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07004938274621964, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16291853785514832, + 0.25688478350639343, + 0.06712797284126282, + 0.04977782815694809, + 0.07991506904363632, + 0.02280103974044323, + 0.2061454951763153, + 0.09329594671726227, + 0.028646117076277733, + 0.032487183809280396 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07004938274621964 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a young boy, approximately five or six years old, with short, messy dark brown hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the boy's cheeks smeared with dirt and dust, and is his hair slightly damp with sweat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the boy's eyes tightly closed with long lashes clinging to tears, and are large tears visibly flowing down his cheeks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the boy's lower lip trembling uncontrollably while his lips are pursed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred with out-of-focus greenery and dappled light, suggesting a warm outdoor setting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07896355539560318 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5789635181427 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07896355539560318, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07896355539560318, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18377576768398285, + 0.09611253440380096, + 0.21746596693992615, + 0.05591769888997078, + 0.05565967410802841, + 0.02512834221124649, + 0.08783718943595886, + 0.176533505320549, + 0.055100880563259125, + 0.04646842181682587 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07896355539560318 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a young boy, approximately five or six years old, with short, messy dark brown hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the boy's cheeks smeared with dirt and dust, and is his hair slightly damp with sweat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the boy's eyes tightly closed with long lashes clinging to tears, and are large tears visibly flowing down his cheeks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the boy's lower lip trembling uncontrollably while his lips are pursed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred with out-of-focus greenery and dappled light, suggesting a warm outdoor setting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.001334610627964139 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.6263346672058105 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.001334610627964139, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.001334610627964139, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2311997264623642, + 0.19450895488262177, + 0.10125124454498291, + 0.05604852735996246, + 0.06854038685560226, + 0.07605623453855515, + 0.06280728429555893, + 0.08057990670204163, + 0.08788048475980759, + 0.0411272756755352 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.001334610627964139 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_15/index_tensor([964, 964])_group_15_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_15/index_tensor([964, 964])_group_15_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..25241a0def6c37aac80bf580f542b36ddbf76db9 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_15/index_tensor([964, 964])_group_15_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "shaky, handheld medium shot captures a raw, tense moment in the humid, sun-drenched swamp. A rugged man in his 30s, with sun-bleached brown hair, sweat on his forehead, and dressed in a practical khaki, short-sleeved utility shirt, teeters on the muddy ground. He clings to a struggling young crocodile with both hands, its dark green scales gleaming in the harsh, dappled sunlight filtering through the dense mangrove canopy. As he struggles to maintain his balance, the man quickly turns his head to look directly into the camera, his expression a mixture of concentration and physical tension. He begins to speak as his body continues to sway in his effort to control the reptile, creating a visceral, perilous atmosphere of fieldwork.", + "seed": 33, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_15/index_964_seed_33_dp_30_rank_60_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.36351716946810486, + "vlm_logprob": -0.36351716946810486, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.325, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.36351716946810486, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot shaky and handheld?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a humid, sun-drenched swamp with dense mangrove canopy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a rugged man in his 30s with sun-bleached brown hair and a khaki short-sleeved utility shirt visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the man clinging to a struggling young crocodile with dark green scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the man turn his head to look directly into the camera while speaking?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5149074792861938 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.26490747928619385 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.5149074792861938, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -1.5149074792861938, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08672437071800232, + 0.2758334279060364, + 0.06379858404397964, + 0.07388138025999069, + 0.03178803622722626, + 0.09061272442340851, + 0.08584179729223251, + 0.1505770981311798, + 0.08711924403905869, + 0.0538233183324337 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 7, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.5149074792861938 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot shaky and handheld?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a humid, sun-drenched swamp with dense mangrove canopy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a rugged man in his 30s with sun-bleached brown hair and a khaki short-sleeved utility shirt visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the man clinging to a struggling young crocodile with dark green scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the man turn his head to look directly into the camera while speaking?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1004244014620781 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.350424289703369 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1004244014620781, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1004244014620781, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07854560017585754, + 0.10336330533027649, + 0.060386065393686295, + 0.09730381518602371, + 0.02167901024222374, + 0.0338628888130188, + 0.0623813234269619, + 0.23472531139850616, + 0.1575578898191452, + 0.15019473433494568 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1004244014620781 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot shaky and handheld?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a humid, sun-drenched swamp with dense mangrove canopy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a rugged man in his 30s with sun-bleached brown hair and a khaki short-sleeved utility shirt visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the man clinging to a struggling young crocodile with dark green scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the man turn his head to look directly into the camera while speaking?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012552540749311447 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387552738189697 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012552540749311447, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012552540749311447, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.015752529725432396, + 0.06187746301293373, + 0.0187411867082119, + 0.03213859349489212, + 0.0250550489872694, + 0.04687362536787987, + 0.021605195477604866, + 0.6386421322822571, + 0.06547081470489502, + 0.07384346425533295 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012552540749311447 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot shaky and handheld?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a humid, sun-drenched swamp with dense mangrove canopy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a rugged man in his 30s with sun-bleached brown hair and a khaki short-sleeved utility shirt visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the man clinging to a struggling young crocodile with dark green scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the man turn his head to look directly into the camera while speaking?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00978896301239729 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634788990020752 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00978896301239729, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00978896301239729, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0840223953127861, + 0.12570084631443024, + 0.04422583058476448, + 0.1552722007036209, + 0.07769692689180374, + 0.14946778118610382, + 0.04796859249472618, + 0.12330138683319092, + 0.06705030798912048, + 0.12529371678829193 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00978896301239729 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot shaky and handheld?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a humid, sun-drenched swamp with dense mangrove canopy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a rugged man in his 30s with sun-bleached brown hair and a khaki short-sleeved utility shirt visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the man clinging to a struggling young crocodile with dark green scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the man turn his head to look directly into the camera while speaking?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17991246283054352 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8049124479293823 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17991246283054352, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17991246283054352, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04658528417348862, + 0.06955626606941223, + 0.038020193576812744, + 0.039627108722925186, + 0.024734241887927055, + 0.05496133863925934, + 0.03187963739037514, + 0.4620751440525055, + 0.0668007954955101, + 0.16576001048088074 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17991246283054352 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "shaky, handheld medium shot captures a raw, tense moment in the humid, sun-drenched swamp. A rugged man in his 30s, with sun-bleached brown hair, sweat on his forehead, and dressed in a practical khaki, short-sleeved utility shirt, teeters on the muddy ground. He clings to a struggling young crocodile with both hands, its dark green scales gleaming in the harsh, dappled sunlight filtering through the dense mangrove canopy. As he struggles to maintain his balance, the man quickly turns his head to look directly into the camera, his expression a mixture of concentration and physical tension. He begins to speak as his body continues to sway in his effort to control the reptile, creating a visceral, perilous atmosphere of fieldwork.", + "seed": 34, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_15/index_964_seed_34_dp_30_rank_60_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.3258123151026666, + "vlm_logprob": -0.3258123151026666, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.6, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.3258123151026666, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot shaky and handheld?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a humid, sun-drenched swamp with dense mangrove canopy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a rugged man in his 30s with sun-bleached brown hair and a khaki short-sleeved utility shirt visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the man clinging to a struggling young crocodile with dark green scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the man turn his head to look directly into the camera while speaking?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3261234760284424 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.32612350583076477 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.3261234760284424, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -1.3261234760284424, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.040061093866825104, + 0.017719624564051628, + 0.0485348179936409, + 0.05946553498506546, + 0.05234668031334877, + 0.05170317366719246, + 0.6271769404411316, + 0.02577551081776619, + 0.026152748614549637, + 0.05106385052204132 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.3261234760284424 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot shaky and handheld?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a humid, sun-drenched swamp with dense mangrove canopy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a rugged man in his 30s with sun-bleached brown hair and a khaki short-sleeved utility shirt visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the man clinging to a struggling young crocodile with dark green scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the man turn his head to look directly into the camera while speaking?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029886256903409958 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529886245727539 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029886256903409958, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029886256903409958, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07951761782169342, + 0.028644083067774773, + 0.03354780375957489, + 0.08429376780986786, + 0.05703055113554001, + 0.10081356763839722, + 0.34497448801994324, + 0.0442594476044178, + 0.14476770162582397, + 0.08215097337961197 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029886256903409958 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot shaky and handheld?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a humid, sun-drenched swamp with dense mangrove canopy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a rugged man in his 30s with sun-bleached brown hair and a khaki short-sleeved utility shirt visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the man clinging to a struggling young crocodile with dark green scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the man turn his head to look directly into the camera while speaking?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006744833197444677 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006744861602783 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006744833197444677, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006744833197444677, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05656186863780022, + 0.04421437159180641, + 0.018047736957669258, + 0.02768978290259838, + 0.03138197958469391, + 0.018930066376924515, + 0.6661236882209778, + 0.03896605968475342, + 0.03136414289474487, + 0.06672029942274094 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006744833197444677 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot shaky and handheld?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a humid, sun-drenched swamp with dense mangrove canopy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a rugged man in his 30s with sun-bleached brown hair and a khaki short-sleeved utility shirt visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the man clinging to a struggling young crocodile with dark green scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the man turn his head to look directly into the camera while speaking?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014199061319231987 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264199256896973 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014199061319231987, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014199061319231987, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03602020815014839, + 0.0806928426027298, + 0.03388459235429764, + 0.026179999113082886, + 0.06130638346076012, + 0.041740138083696365, + 0.6450682282447815, + 0.02272534929215908, + 0.03401836380362511, + 0.018363939598202705 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014199061319231987 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot shaky and handheld?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a humid, sun-drenched swamp with dense mangrove canopy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a rugged man in his 30s with sun-bleached brown hair and a khaki short-sleeved utility shirt visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the man clinging to a struggling young crocodile with dark green scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the man turn his head to look directly into the camera while speaking?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2521079480648041 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5021079778671265 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2521079480648041, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2521079480648041, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03338121995329857, + 0.014842693693935871, + 0.016754938289523125, + 0.017180059105157852, + 0.009833136573433876, + 0.020597850903868675, + 0.6720852851867676, + 0.03748374059796333, + 0.10645070672035217, + 0.07139033824205399 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2521079480648041 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "shaky, handheld medium shot captures a raw, tense moment in the humid, sun-drenched swamp. A rugged man in his 30s, with sun-bleached brown hair, sweat on his forehead, and dressed in a practical khaki, short-sleeved utility shirt, teeters on the muddy ground. He clings to a struggling young crocodile with both hands, its dark green scales gleaming in the harsh, dappled sunlight filtering through the dense mangrove canopy. As he struggles to maintain his balance, the man quickly turns his head to look directly into the camera, his expression a mixture of concentration and physical tension. He begins to speak as his body continues to sway in his effort to control the reptile, creating a visceral, perilous atmosphere of fieldwork.", + "seed": 35, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_15/index_964_seed_35_dp_31_rank_62_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.3239619769155979, + "vlm_logprob": -0.3239619769155979, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.55, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.3239619769155979, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot shaky and handheld?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a humid, sun-drenched swamp with dense mangrove canopy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a rugged man in his 30s with sun-bleached brown hair and a khaki short-sleeved utility shirt visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the man clinging to a struggling young crocodile with dark green scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the man turn his head to look directly into the camera while speaking?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.415336012840271 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.290336012840271 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.415336012840271, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -1.415336012840271, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12585222721099854, + 0.12276148051023483, + 0.11398819088935852, + 0.18113455176353455, + 0.06154927238821983, + 0.09076795727014542, + 0.07220041751861572, + 0.06326649338006973, + 0.07179456949234009, + 0.09668484330177307 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.415336012840271 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot shaky and handheld?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a humid, sun-drenched swamp with dense mangrove canopy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a rugged man in his 30s with sun-bleached brown hair and a khaki short-sleeved utility shirt visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the man clinging to a struggling young crocodile with dark green scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the man turn his head to look directly into the camera while speaking?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.055061597377061844 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9300615787506104 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.055061597377061844, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.055061597377061844, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11005084961652756, + 0.13569311797618866, + 0.14839129149913788, + 0.10955646634101868, + 0.0701628252863884, + 0.13148024678230286, + 0.16197678446769714, + 0.06512241065502167, + 0.02800934761762619, + 0.039556656032800674 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.055061597377061844 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot shaky and handheld?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a humid, sun-drenched swamp with dense mangrove canopy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a rugged man in his 30s with sun-bleached brown hair and a khaki short-sleeved utility shirt visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the man clinging to a struggling young crocodile with dark green scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the man turn his head to look directly into the camera while speaking?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009793094359338284 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634793281555176 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009793094359338284, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009793094359338284, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12156038731336594, + 0.09476437419652939, + 0.214679554104805, + 0.058692511171102524, + 0.07247648388147354, + 0.05350809171795845, + 0.09236812591552734, + 0.06883686035871506, + 0.09101050347089767, + 0.1321031153202057 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009793094359338284 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot shaky and handheld?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a humid, sun-drenched swamp with dense mangrove canopy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a rugged man in his 30s with sun-bleached brown hair and a khaki short-sleeved utility shirt visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the man clinging to a struggling young crocodile with dark green scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the man turn his head to look directly into the camera while speaking?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012545713223516941 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387545585632324 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012545713223516941, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012545713223516941, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11743886768817902, + 0.15679720044136047, + 0.16055220365524292, + 0.09269903600215912, + 0.053964611142873764, + 0.08535025268793106, + 0.08659372478723526, + 0.06366855651140213, + 0.09839698672294617, + 0.08453856408596039 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012545713223516941 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot shaky and handheld?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a humid, sun-drenched swamp with dense mangrove canopy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a rugged man in his 30s with sun-bleached brown hair and a khaki short-sleeved utility shirt visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the man clinging to a struggling young crocodile with dark green scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the man turn his head to look directly into the camera while speaking?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1270734667778015 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1270735263824463 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1270734667778015, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1270734667778015, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09283877909183502, + 0.11048197001218796, + 0.13339711725711823, + 0.04443991929292679, + 0.032176267355680466, + 0.045982684940099716, + 0.10283215343952179, + 0.1050674095749855, + 0.19151559472084045, + 0.14126808941364288 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1270734667778015 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "shaky, handheld medium shot captures a raw, tense moment in the humid, sun-drenched swamp. A rugged man in his 30s, with sun-bleached brown hair, sweat on his forehead, and dressed in a practical khaki, short-sleeved utility shirt, teeters on the muddy ground. He clings to a struggling young crocodile with both hands, its dark green scales gleaming in the harsh, dappled sunlight filtering through the dense mangrove canopy. As he struggles to maintain his balance, the man quickly turns his head to look directly into the camera, his expression a mixture of concentration and physical tension. He begins to speak as his body continues to sway in his effort to control the reptile, creating a visceral, perilous atmosphere of fieldwork.", + "seed": 36, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_15/index_964_seed_36_dp_31_rank_62_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.3721397165209055, + "vlm_logprob": -0.3721397165209055, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.6, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.3721397165209055, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot shaky and handheld?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a humid, sun-drenched swamp with dense mangrove canopy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a rugged man in his 30s with sun-bleached brown hair and a khaki short-sleeved utility shirt visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the man clinging to a struggling young crocodile with dark green scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the man turn his head to look directly into the camera while speaking?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.616615653038025 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2416156530380249 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.616615653038025, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -1.616615653038025, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10889887809753418, + 0.04930867254734039, + 0.09672126173973083, + 0.04618813097476959, + 0.053118374198675156, + 0.0504475012421608, + 0.06284909695386887, + 0.10691484808921814, + 0.12077496945858002, + 0.30477818846702576 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.616615653038025 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot shaky and handheld?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a humid, sun-drenched swamp with dense mangrove canopy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a rugged man in his 30s with sun-bleached brown hair and a khaki short-sleeved utility shirt visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the man clinging to a struggling young crocodile with dark green scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the man turn his head to look directly into the camera while speaking?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04877183958888054 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048771858215332 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04877183958888054, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04877183958888054, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19161677360534668, + 0.07416252046823502, + 0.15691369771957397, + 0.03229990229010582, + 0.021737156435847282, + 0.05122748762369156, + 0.058553099632263184, + 0.20557866990566254, + 0.06726749986410141, + 0.14064320921897888 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04877183958888054 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot shaky and handheld?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a humid, sun-drenched swamp with dense mangrove canopy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a rugged man in his 30s with sun-bleached brown hair and a khaki short-sleeved utility shirt visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the man clinging to a struggling young crocodile with dark green scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the man turn his head to look directly into the camera while speaking?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006750516593456268 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006750583648682 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006750516593456268, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006750516593456268, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09374728053808212, + 0.045218273997306824, + 0.08929424732923508, + 0.057906173169612885, + 0.03145647794008255, + 0.054722532629966736, + 0.15037904679775238, + 0.18185634911060333, + 0.16275867819786072, + 0.13266098499298096 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006750516593456268 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot shaky and handheld?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a humid, sun-drenched swamp with dense mangrove canopy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a rugged man in his 30s with sun-bleached brown hair and a khaki short-sleeved utility shirt visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the man clinging to a struggling young crocodile with dark green scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the man turn his head to look directly into the camera while speaking?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008647022768855095 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.7586469650268555 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008647022768855095, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008647022768855095, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13167613744735718, + 0.05371791869401932, + 0.07568959891796112, + 0.17124272882938385, + 0.07173274457454681, + 0.16233506798744202, + 0.11814239621162415, + 0.09800650924444199, + 0.084217868745327, + 0.03323899209499359 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008647022768855095 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot shaky and handheld?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a humid, sun-drenched swamp with dense mangrove canopy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a rugged man in his 30s with sun-bleached brown hair and a khaki short-sleeved utility shirt visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the man clinging to a struggling young crocodile with dark green scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the man turn his head to look directly into the camera while speaking?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17991355061531067 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8049135208129883 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17991355061531067, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17991355061531067, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07731463015079498, + 0.03454309701919556, + 0.08092240989208221, + 0.04596562683582306, + 0.022600818425416946, + 0.06440134346485138, + 0.03521602228283882, + 0.22626735270023346, + 0.2966712713241577, + 0.11609737575054169 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17991355061531067 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_2/index_tensor([4314, 4314])_group_2_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_2/index_tensor([4314, 4314])_group_2_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..5a830f7a3edba7aedfb764fb0b39a640051806c8 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_2/index_tensor([4314, 4314])_group_2_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "In a striking, high-contrast graphic novel style defined by bold, decisive ink lines, the scene opens as the camera slowly performs a dolly left, tracking the subjects' descent. A medium-wide shot captures the stark, black silhouettes of a newlywed couple, their forms sharply defined against a vibrantly colored background. The groom embraces the bride, clearly defined by the sharp outlines of his suit jacket and shoulders, while the bride's flowing wedding dress and delicate veil gently flowing upward create a vibrant, elegant silhouette against the light. They are set against a vibrant, abstract sunset, which, rather than being static, plummets downward in a continuous, rapid cascade of color; swirls of fiery orange, deep burgundy, and electric yellow blend and streak vertically across the frame. The constant downward motion of the background creates a powerful and surreal illusion, as if the couple themselves are falling from an endless, painted sky, while their embracing silhouettes remain a point of tranquility, a stark anchor amidst the beautiful chaos, evoking an atmosphere of drama and deep romance.", + "seed": 5519, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_2/index_4314_seed_5519_dp_4_rank_8_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.3827570898458362, + "vlm_logprob": -0.3827570898458362, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.175000011920929, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.3827570898458362, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.6, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a high-contrast graphic novel style with bold, decisive ink lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow dolly left movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the subjects depicted as black silhouettes of a groom in a suit and a bride in a flowing dress with a veil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vibrant abstract sunset with swirling colors of fiery orange, deep burgundy, and electric yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background move in a continuous, rapid downward cascade while the couple's silhouettes remain relatively static?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7597063779830933 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6347063779830933 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.7597063779830933, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.7597063779830933, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13628005981445312, + 0.04328092932701111, + 0.0948210284113884, + 0.020685169845819473, + 0.042604561895132065, + 0.07925435900688171, + 0.13321183621883392, + 0.015865206718444824, + 0.03795326128602028, + 0.3960435688495636 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.7597063779830933 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a high-contrast graphic novel style with bold, decisive ink lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow dolly left movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the subjects depicted as black silhouettes of a groom in a suit and a bride in a flowing dress with a veil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vibrant abstract sunset with swirling colors of fiery orange, deep burgundy, and electric yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background move in a continuous, rapid downward cascade while the couple's silhouettes remain relatively static?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.0538887977600098 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.42888885736465454 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.0538887977600098, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.6249999403953552, + "token_credit_reward": -1.0538887977600098, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.043915946036577225, + 0.03138246014714241, + 0.02990870364010334, + 0.03353673964738846, + 0.019739216193556786, + 0.06992630660533905, + 0.05844862386584282, + 0.0318627804517746, + 0.025366032496094704, + 0.6559131741523743 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.0538887977600098 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a high-contrast graphic novel style with bold, decisive ink lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow dolly left movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the subjects depicted as black silhouettes of a groom in a suit and a bride in a flowing dress with a veil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vibrant abstract sunset with swirling colors of fiery orange, deep burgundy, and electric yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background move in a continuous, rapid downward cascade while the couple's silhouettes remain relatively static?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012549244798719883 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.38754940032959 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012549244798719883, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012549244798719883, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14652322232723236, + 0.04855310544371605, + 0.09670323878526688, + 0.03914458677172661, + 0.14143700897693634, + 0.20918533205986023, + 0.04815362021327019, + 0.09524932503700256, + 0.12373557686805725, + 0.05131497606635094 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012549244798719883 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a high-contrast graphic novel style with bold, decisive ink lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow dolly left movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the subjects depicted as black silhouettes of a groom in a suit and a bride in a flowing dress with a veil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vibrant abstract sunset with swirling colors of fiery orange, deep burgundy, and electric yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background move in a continuous, rapid downward cascade while the couple's silhouettes remain relatively static?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008644422516226768 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.7586445808410645 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008644422516226768, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008644422516226768, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3729020059108734, + 0.05832749232649803, + 0.1308499127626419, + 0.07702232152223587, + 0.04762040078639984, + 0.10139123350381851, + 0.08017531037330627, + 0.02730080857872963, + 0.039535656571388245, + 0.0648748055100441 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008644422516226768 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a high-contrast graphic novel style with bold, decisive ink lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow dolly left movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the subjects depicted as black silhouettes of a groom in a suit and a bride in a flowing dress with a veil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vibrant abstract sunset with swirling colors of fiery orange, deep burgundy, and electric yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background move in a continuous, rapid downward cascade while the couple's silhouettes remain relatively static?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07899660617113113 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5789966583251953 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07899660617113113, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07899660617113113, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11558288335800171, + 0.03488468378782272, + 0.08622119575738907, + 0.058509692549705505, + 0.03704504668712616, + 0.06596536189317703, + 0.03877977654337883, + 0.02691536955535412, + 0.04529133439064026, + 0.4908045828342438 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07899660617113113 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a striking, high-contrast graphic novel style defined by bold, decisive ink lines, the scene opens as the camera slowly performs a dolly left, tracking the subjects' descent. A medium-wide shot captures the stark, black silhouettes of a newlywed couple, their forms sharply defined against a vibrantly colored background. The groom embraces the bride, clearly defined by the sharp outlines of his suit jacket and shoulders, while the bride's flowing wedding dress and delicate veil gently flowing upward create a vibrant, elegant silhouette against the light. They are set against a vibrant, abstract sunset, which, rather than being static, plummets downward in a continuous, rapid cascade of color; swirls of fiery orange, deep burgundy, and electric yellow blend and streak vertically across the frame. The constant downward motion of the background creates a powerful and surreal illusion, as if the couple themselves are falling from an endless, painted sky, while their embracing silhouettes remain a point of tranquility, a stark anchor amidst the beautiful chaos, evoking an atmosphere of drama and deep romance.", + "seed": 5520, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_2/index_4314_seed_5520_dp_4_rank_8_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.4381066281814128, + "vlm_logprob": -0.4381066281814128, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.649999976158142, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.4381066281814128, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a high-contrast graphic novel style with bold, decisive ink lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow dolly left movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the subjects depicted as black silhouettes of a groom in a suit and a bride in a flowing dress with a veil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vibrant abstract sunset with swirling colors of fiery orange, deep burgundy, and electric yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background move in a continuous, rapid downward cascade while the couple's silhouettes remain relatively static?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14537963271141052 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0203795433044434 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14537963271141052, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.8749998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14537963271141052, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07386495172977448, + 0.04925668612122536, + 0.04597744345664978, + 0.018382851034402847, + 0.6809864044189453, + 0.037775248289108276, + 0.021121330559253693, + 0.013257214799523354, + 0.01892191916704178, + 0.04045603796839714 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14537963271141052 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a high-contrast graphic novel style with bold, decisive ink lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow dolly left movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the subjects depicted as black silhouettes of a groom in a suit and a bride in a flowing dress with a veil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vibrant abstract sunset with swirling colors of fiery orange, deep burgundy, and electric yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background move in a continuous, rapid downward cascade while the couple's silhouettes remain relatively static?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9103362560272217 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16033631563186646 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.9103362560272217, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -1.9103362560272217, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03617361932992935, + 0.02068658545613289, + 0.02831423282623291, + 0.013239114545285702, + 0.7233353853225708, + 0.06007910147309303, + 0.02123698778450489, + 0.021359968930482864, + 0.022025316953659058, + 0.0535496287047863 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.9103362560272217 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a high-contrast graphic novel style with bold, decisive ink lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow dolly left movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the subjects depicted as black silhouettes of a groom in a suit and a bride in a flowing dress with a veil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vibrant abstract sunset with swirling colors of fiery orange, deep burgundy, and electric yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background move in a continuous, rapid downward cascade while the couple's silhouettes remain relatively static?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00362905184738338 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628629207611084 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00362905184738338, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00362905184738338, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1909075230360031, + 0.1493467539548874, + 0.09563522040843964, + 0.04393085092306137, + 0.21957601606845856, + 0.0628209337592125, + 0.09810798615217209, + 0.028729109093546867, + 0.041876163333654404, + 0.06906946748495102 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00362905184738338 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a high-contrast graphic novel style with bold, decisive ink lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow dolly left movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the subjects depicted as black silhouettes of a groom in a suit and a bride in a flowing dress with a veil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vibrant abstract sunset with swirling colors of fiery orange, deep burgundy, and electric yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background move in a continuous, rapid downward cascade while the couple's silhouettes remain relatively static?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004103930201381445 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504104137420654 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004103930201381445, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004103930201381445, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13252118229866028, + 0.12819744646549225, + 0.13690902292728424, + 0.029243068769574165, + 0.21041397750377655, + 0.05708315968513489, + 0.06983090937137604, + 0.06706268340349197, + 0.027948610484600067, + 0.1407899409532547 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004103930201381445 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a high-contrast graphic novel style with bold, decisive ink lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow dolly left movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the subjects depicted as black silhouettes of a groom in a suit and a bride in a flowing dress with a veil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vibrant abstract sunset with swirling colors of fiery orange, deep burgundy, and electric yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background move in a continuous, rapid downward cascade while the couple's silhouettes remain relatively static?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12708427011966705 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.127084255218506 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12708427011966705, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12708427011966705, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09035900235176086, + 0.05430196598172188, + 0.19550420343875885, + 0.037474583834409714, + 0.23292852938175201, + 0.15203975141048431, + 0.021189678460359573, + 0.03356634080410004, + 0.01641366071999073, + 0.1662222445011139 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 2, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12708427011966705 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a striking, high-contrast graphic novel style defined by bold, decisive ink lines, the scene opens as the camera slowly performs a dolly left, tracking the subjects' descent. A medium-wide shot captures the stark, black silhouettes of a newlywed couple, their forms sharply defined against a vibrantly colored background. The groom embraces the bride, clearly defined by the sharp outlines of his suit jacket and shoulders, while the bride's flowing wedding dress and delicate veil gently flowing upward create a vibrant, elegant silhouette against the light. They are set against a vibrant, abstract sunset, which, rather than being static, plummets downward in a continuous, rapid cascade of color; swirls of fiery orange, deep burgundy, and electric yellow blend and streak vertically across the frame. The constant downward motion of the background creates a powerful and surreal illusion, as if the couple themselves are falling from an endless, painted sky, while their embracing silhouettes remain a point of tranquility, a stark anchor amidst the beautiful chaos, evoking an atmosphere of drama and deep romance.", + "seed": 5521, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_2/index_4314_seed_5521_dp_5_rank_10_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.44623233284801245, + "vlm_logprob": -0.44623233284801245, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.375000023841858, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.44623233284801245, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a high-contrast graphic novel style with bold, decisive ink lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow dolly left movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the subjects depicted as black silhouettes of a groom in a suit and a bride in a flowing dress with a veil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vibrant abstract sunset with swirling colors of fiery orange, deep burgundy, and electric yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background move in a continuous, rapid downward cascade while the couple's silhouettes remain relatively static?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5780075788497925 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8280075788497925 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5780075788497925, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5780075788497925, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09026415646076202, + 0.045514125376939774, + 0.026221565902233124, + 0.01439500879496336, + 0.43648090958595276, + 0.16295309364795685, + 0.07907227426767349, + 0.028097620233893394, + 0.08429773896932602, + 0.032703500241041183 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5780075788497925 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a high-contrast graphic novel style with bold, decisive ink lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow dolly left movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the subjects depicted as black silhouettes of a groom in a suit and a bride in a flowing dress with a veil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vibrant abstract sunset with swirling colors of fiery orange, deep burgundy, and electric yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background move in a continuous, rapid downward cascade while the couple's silhouettes remain relatively static?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5020649433135986 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.252064973115921 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.5020649433135986, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -1.5020649433135986, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0573551207780838, + 0.029304979369044304, + 0.05059269443154335, + 0.023511389270424843, + 0.503601610660553, + 0.20756009221076965, + 0.04300695285201073, + 0.030271369963884354, + 0.04023008421063423, + 0.014565723948180676 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.5020649433135986 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a high-contrast graphic novel style with bold, decisive ink lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow dolly left movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the subjects depicted as black silhouettes of a groom in a suit and a bride in a flowing dress with a veil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vibrant abstract sunset with swirling colors of fiery orange, deep burgundy, and electric yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background move in a continuous, rapid downward cascade while the couple's silhouettes remain relatively static?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036264387890696526 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628626346588135 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036264387890696526, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036264387890696526, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0904727429151535, + 0.044812705367803574, + 0.03703170269727707, + 0.019742842763662338, + 0.4437820613384247, + 0.20816631615161896, + 0.0708305761218071, + 0.02290043793618679, + 0.04158225283026695, + 0.02067835070192814 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036264387890696526 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a high-contrast graphic novel style with bold, decisive ink lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow dolly left movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the subjects depicted as black silhouettes of a groom in a suit and a bride in a flowing dress with a veil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vibrant abstract sunset with swirling colors of fiery orange, deep burgundy, and electric yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background move in a continuous, rapid downward cascade while the couple's silhouettes remain relatively static?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004643134772777557 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379642963409424 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004643134772777557, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004643134772777557, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07910803705453873, + 0.0450967475771904, + 0.02296125888824463, + 0.022649046033620834, + 0.6032510995864868, + 0.09488335996866226, + 0.044089287519454956, + 0.0289964247494936, + 0.032417669892311096, + 0.026547005400061607 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004643134772777557 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a high-contrast graphic novel style with bold, decisive ink lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow dolly left movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the subjects depicted as black silhouettes of a groom in a suit and a bride in a flowing dress with a veil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vibrant abstract sunset with swirling colors of fiery orange, deep burgundy, and electric yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background move in a continuous, rapid downward cascade while the couple's silhouettes remain relatively static?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1428195685148239 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.01781964302063 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1428195685148239, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.8750001192092896, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1428195685148239, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08632724732160568, + 0.04578106477856636, + 0.13191194832324982, + 0.051546573638916016, + 0.15229012072086334, + 0.1484939604997635, + 0.17618541419506073, + 0.08256572484970093, + 0.10725515335798264, + 0.01764277182519436 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1428195685148239 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a striking, high-contrast graphic novel style defined by bold, decisive ink lines, the scene opens as the camera slowly performs a dolly left, tracking the subjects' descent. A medium-wide shot captures the stark, black silhouettes of a newlywed couple, their forms sharply defined against a vibrantly colored background. The groom embraces the bride, clearly defined by the sharp outlines of his suit jacket and shoulders, while the bride's flowing wedding dress and delicate veil gently flowing upward create a vibrant, elegant silhouette against the light. They are set against a vibrant, abstract sunset, which, rather than being static, plummets downward in a continuous, rapid cascade of color; swirls of fiery orange, deep burgundy, and electric yellow blend and streak vertically across the frame. The constant downward motion of the background creates a powerful and surreal illusion, as if the couple themselves are falling from an endless, painted sky, while their embracing silhouettes remain a point of tranquility, a stark anchor amidst the beautiful chaos, evoking an atmosphere of drama and deep romance.", + "seed": 5522, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_2/index_4314_seed_5522_dp_5_rank_10_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.20591852073557676, + "vlm_logprob": -0.20591852073557676, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.25, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.20591852073557676, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a high-contrast graphic novel style with bold, decisive ink lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow dolly left movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the subjects depicted as black silhouettes of a groom in a suit and a bride in a flowing dress with a veil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vibrant abstract sunset with swirling colors of fiery orange, deep burgundy, and electric yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background move in a continuous, rapid downward cascade while the couple's silhouettes remain relatively static?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.036149077117443085 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.411149024963379 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.036149077117443085, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.036149077117443085, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0787525624036789, + 0.03561702370643616, + 0.08438816666603088, + 0.04988234490156174, + 0.07689182460308075, + 0.03728528320789337, + 0.06241836026310921, + 0.1632702350616455, + 0.3533382713794708, + 0.05815592780709267 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.036149077117443085 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a high-contrast graphic novel style with bold, decisive ink lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow dolly left movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the subjects depicted as black silhouettes of a groom in a suit and a bride in a flowing dress with a veil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vibrant abstract sunset with swirling colors of fiery orange, deep burgundy, and electric yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background move in a continuous, rapid downward cascade while the couple's silhouettes remain relatively static?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8261547684669495 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5761547684669495 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.8261547684669495, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.8261547684669495, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04903678223490715, + 0.022893007844686508, + 0.07927817851305008, + 0.05513413995504379, + 0.059718407690525055, + 0.10584868490695953, + 0.20007899403572083, + 0.1529688537120819, + 0.171765998005867, + 0.10327690094709396 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.8261547684669495 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a high-contrast graphic novel style with bold, decisive ink lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow dolly left movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the subjects depicted as black silhouettes of a groom in a suit and a bride in a flowing dress with a veil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vibrant abstract sunset with swirling colors of fiery orange, deep burgundy, and electric yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background move in a continuous, rapid downward cascade while the couple's silhouettes remain relatively static?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0028234163764864206 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877823352813721 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0028234163764864206, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0028234163764864206, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11985117197036743, + 0.06679525971412659, + 0.057250745594501495, + 0.12248630821704865, + 0.213510662317276, + 0.12405990064144135, + 0.09045390039682388, + 0.07695614546537399, + 0.07008694112300873, + 0.05854899436235428 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0028234163764864206 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a high-contrast graphic novel style with bold, decisive ink lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow dolly left movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the subjects depicted as black silhouettes of a groom in a suit and a bride in a flowing dress with a veil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vibrant abstract sunset with swirling colors of fiery orange, deep burgundy, and electric yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background move in a continuous, rapid downward cascade while the couple's silhouettes remain relatively static?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004099775105714798 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.5040998458862305 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004099775105714798, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004099775105714798, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16198056936264038, + 0.06986542791128159, + 0.120259590446949, + 0.18643134832382202, + 0.06191413849592209, + 0.047238752245903015, + 0.046786118298769, + 0.18126463890075684, + 0.0575273260474205, + 0.06673204898834229 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004099775105714798 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a high-contrast graphic novel style with bold, decisive ink lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow dolly left movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the subjects depicted as black silhouettes of a groom in a suit and a bride in a flowing dress with a veil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vibrant abstract sunset with swirling colors of fiery orange, deep burgundy, and electric yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background move in a continuous, rapid downward cascade while the couple's silhouettes remain relatively static?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16036556661128998 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9103655815124512 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16036556661128998, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16036556661128998, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07047369331121445, + 0.054013971239328384, + 0.08465822041034698, + 0.04451429843902588, + 0.071529321372509, + 0.12859265506267548, + 0.18425065279006958, + 0.13236577808856964, + 0.14758369326591492, + 0.08201765269041061 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16036556661128998 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_3/index_tensor([9747, 9747])_group_3_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_3/index_tensor([9747, 9747])_group_3_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..6f1a3859866226a5b9ff0f4e799a0b7da56e1d37 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_3/index_tensor([9747, 9747])_group_3_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "slow-motion tracking shot, shot from a low angle, follows a lone figure as he struggles to climb the steep steps of the majestic Great Wall. Beneath his feet are massive, weathered, blue-gray stone steps, each uneven, its edges smoothed by age. Tufts of withered weeds stubbornly grow between the cracks in the stone. The steps stretch endlessly upward, disappearing into view. The figure, dressed in a dark windbreaker and trousers, leans forward, his weight low, each step heavy and determined. His breath condenses into a faint white mist in the cool air, and he occasionally clings to the mottled parapets beside him for balance. In the background, the Great Wall winds like a giant dragon, coiling across the vast, rolling hills. It's dusk, and the golden, setting sun elongates his figure and the ancient wall, casting its shadow across the rough masonry, highlighting every crack and weathered texture. The main colors of the entire picture are warm ochre and cool gray-blue. The strong contrast between light and dark and the characters' tenacious climbing posture together create an epic atmosphere that is solemn, lonely and full of historical weight.", + "seed": 21330, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_3/index_9747_seed_21330_dp_6_rank_12_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.09465221101418138, + "vlm_logprob": -0.09465221101418138, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.449999988079071, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.09465221101418138, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a slow-motion tracking shot following a lone figure climbing steep steps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low, looking up at the figure and the steps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the steps massive, weathered, and blue-gray in color with visible cracks and weeds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing a dark windbreaker and trousers while leaning forward with a determined posture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at dusk with warm ochre and cool gray-blue lighting casting long shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3881092667579651 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1381092071533203 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3881092667579651, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.7499999403953552, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3881092667579651, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09986269474029541, + 0.12934911251068115, + 0.11837399005889893, + 0.0768851786851883, + 0.30825620889663696, + 0.031932663172483444, + 0.048171594738960266, + 0.04972539097070694, + 0.04434020817279816, + 0.09310296177864075 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3881092667579651 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a slow-motion tracking shot following a lone figure climbing steep steps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low, looking up at the figure and the steps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the steps massive, weathered, and blue-gray in color with visible cracks and weeds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing a dark windbreaker and trousers while leaning forward with a determined posture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at dusk with warm ochre and cool gray-blue lighting casting long shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04307858645915985 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168078660964966 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04307858645915985, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04307858645915985, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1327417939901352, + 0.09389010816812515, + 0.09707789868116379, + 0.08350531756877899, + 0.04611384868621826, + 0.039531439542770386, + 0.07571819424629211, + 0.0561944842338562, + 0.1026599183678627, + 0.2725670039653778 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04307858645915985 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a slow-motion tracking shot following a lone figure climbing steep steps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low, looking up at the figure and the steps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the steps massive, weathered, and blue-gray in color with visible cracks and weeds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing a dark windbreaker and trousers while leaning forward with a determined posture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at dusk with warm ochre and cool gray-blue lighting casting long shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005948815029114485 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130949020385742 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005948815029114485, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005948815029114485, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14740388095378876, + 0.08809807151556015, + 0.1264079213142395, + 0.0546240471303463, + 0.21305963397026062, + 0.04312175512313843, + 0.13041333854198456, + 0.07651396095752716, + 0.05808241292834282, + 0.06227501481771469 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005948815029114485 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a slow-motion tracking shot following a lone figure climbing steep steps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low, looking up at the figure and the steps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the steps massive, weathered, and blue-gray in color with visible cracks and weeds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing a dark windbreaker and trousers while leaning forward with a determined posture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at dusk with warm ochre and cool gray-blue lighting casting long shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026347937062382698 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513478755950928 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026347937062382698, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026347937062382698, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16697958111763, + 0.23563440144062042, + 0.19093984365463257, + 0.049253109842538834, + 0.08527829498052597, + 0.06276539713144302, + 0.06639207154512405, + 0.05068013817071915, + 0.05119185522198677, + 0.04088527709245682 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026347937062382698 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a slow-motion tracking shot following a lone figure climbing steep steps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low, looking up at the figure and the steps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the steps massive, weathered, and blue-gray in color with visible cracks and weeds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing a dark windbreaker and trousers while leaning forward with a determined posture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at dusk with warm ochre and cool gray-blue lighting casting long shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009776449762284756 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634776592254639 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009776449762284756, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009776449762284756, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08825171738862991, + 0.06635969877243042, + 0.014075740240514278, + 0.030809443444013596, + 0.07091719657182693, + 0.038965724408626556, + 0.1626305729150772, + 0.25795871019363403, + 0.22680844366550446, + 0.04322277009487152 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009776449762284756 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow-motion tracking shot, shot from a low angle, follows a lone figure as he struggles to climb the steep steps of the majestic Great Wall. Beneath his feet are massive, weathered, blue-gray stone steps, each uneven, its edges smoothed by age. Tufts of withered weeds stubbornly grow between the cracks in the stone. The steps stretch endlessly upward, disappearing into view. The figure, dressed in a dark windbreaker and trousers, leans forward, his weight low, each step heavy and determined. His breath condenses into a faint white mist in the cool air, and he occasionally clings to the mottled parapets beside him for balance. In the background, the Great Wall winds like a giant dragon, coiling across the vast, rolling hills. It's dusk, and the golden, setting sun elongates his figure and the ancient wall, casting its shadow across the rough masonry, highlighting every crack and weathered texture. The main colors of the entire picture are warm ochre and cool gray-blue. The strong contrast between light and dark and the characters' tenacious climbing posture together create an epic atmosphere that is solemn, lonely and full of historical weight.", + "seed": 21331, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_3/index_9747_seed_21331_dp_6_rank_12_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.04303312250413001, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04303312250413001, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.025, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04303312250413001, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a slow-motion tracking shot following a lone figure climbing steep steps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low, looking up at the figure and the steps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the steps massive, weathered, and blue-gray in color with visible cracks and weeds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing a dark windbreaker and trousers while leaning forward with a determined posture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at dusk with warm ochre and cool gray-blue lighting casting long shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16128738224506378 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9112874269485474 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16128738224506378, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16128738224506378, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2178667038679123, + 0.134189173579216, + 0.19610226154327393, + 0.040957529097795486, + 0.06686364859342575, + 0.04242802411317825, + 0.0889526829123497, + 0.07661430537700653, + 0.07203157991170883, + 0.06399407982826233 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16128738224506378 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a slow-motion tracking shot following a lone figure climbing steep steps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low, looking up at the figure and the steps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the steps massive, weathered, and blue-gray in color with visible cracks and weeds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing a dark windbreaker and trousers while leaning forward with a determined posture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at dusk with warm ochre and cool gray-blue lighting casting long shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026359431445598602 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513593196868896 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026359431445598602, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026359431445598602, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24571505188941956, + 0.15985484421253204, + 0.20951685309410095, + 0.032548923045396805, + 0.049799978733062744, + 0.040087342262268066, + 0.047854553908109665, + 0.04737035930156708, + 0.086493581533432, + 0.08075853437185287 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026359431445598602 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a slow-motion tracking shot following a lone figure climbing steep steps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low, looking up at the figure and the steps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the steps massive, weathered, and blue-gray in color with visible cracks and weeds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing a dark windbreaker and trousers while leaning forward with a determined posture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at dusk with warm ochre and cool gray-blue lighting casting long shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002817115979269147 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877817153930664 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002817115979269147, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002817115979269147, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2305634766817093, + 0.22671398520469666, + 0.13000303506851196, + 0.03235837444663048, + 0.04355474188923836, + 0.05973941460251808, + 0.0647323951125145, + 0.05033610761165619, + 0.05684899166226387, + 0.10514955967664719 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002817115979269147 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a slow-motion tracking shot following a lone figure climbing steep steps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low, looking up at the figure and the steps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the steps massive, weathered, and blue-gray in color with visible cracks and weeds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing a dark windbreaker and trousers while leaning forward with a determined posture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at dusk with warm ochre and cool gray-blue lighting casting long shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01606801524758339 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141067981719971 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01606801524758339, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01606801524758339, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.28349724411964417, + 0.13253457844257355, + 0.12675054371356964, + 0.06530792266130447, + 0.08495589345693588, + 0.056508224457502365, + 0.04514892026782036, + 0.07200111448764801, + 0.06470674276351929, + 0.06858877837657928 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01606801524758339 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a slow-motion tracking shot following a lone figure climbing steep steps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low, looking up at the figure and the steps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the steps massive, weathered, and blue-gray in color with visible cracks and weeds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing a dark windbreaker and trousers while leaning forward with a determined posture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at dusk with warm ochre and cool gray-blue lighting casting long shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008633667603135109 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758633613586426 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008633667603135109, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008633667603135109, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13140413165092468, + 0.1001601591706276, + 0.04693872481584549, + 0.025327743962407112, + 0.03251814469695091, + 0.020415516570210457, + 0.053513262420892715, + 0.06527427583932877, + 0.46167099475860596, + 0.0627770870923996 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008633667603135109 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow-motion tracking shot, shot from a low angle, follows a lone figure as he struggles to climb the steep steps of the majestic Great Wall. Beneath his feet are massive, weathered, blue-gray stone steps, each uneven, its edges smoothed by age. Tufts of withered weeds stubbornly grow between the cracks in the stone. The steps stretch endlessly upward, disappearing into view. The figure, dressed in a dark windbreaker and trousers, leans forward, his weight low, each step heavy and determined. His breath condenses into a faint white mist in the cool air, and he occasionally clings to the mottled parapets beside him for balance. In the background, the Great Wall winds like a giant dragon, coiling across the vast, rolling hills. It's dusk, and the golden, setting sun elongates his figure and the ancient wall, casting its shadow across the rough masonry, highlighting every crack and weathered texture. The main colors of the entire picture are warm ochre and cool gray-blue. The strong contrast between light and dark and the characters' tenacious climbing posture together create an epic atmosphere that is solemn, lonely and full of historical weight.", + "seed": 21332, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_3/index_9747_seed_21332_dp_7_rank_14_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.019410331826657058, + "vlm_logprob": -0.019410331826657058, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.3, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.019410331826657058, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a slow-motion tracking shot following a lone figure climbing steep steps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low, looking up at the figure and the steps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the steps massive, weathered, and blue-gray in color with visible cracks and weeds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing a dark windbreaker and trousers while leaning forward with a determined posture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at dusk with warm ochre and cool gray-blue lighting casting long shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04966745525598526 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0496673583984375 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04966745525598526, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04966745525598526, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11777939647436142, + 0.27985092997550964, + 0.051257453858852386, + 0.08260327577590942, + 0.09084217250347137, + 0.18881380558013916, + 0.02530575916171074, + 0.054549798369407654, + 0.033615320920944214, + 0.07538216561079025 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04966745525598526 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a slow-motion tracking shot following a lone figure climbing steep steps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low, looking up at the figure and the steps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the steps massive, weathered, and blue-gray in color with visible cracks and weeds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing a dark windbreaker and trousers while leaning forward with a determined posture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at dusk with warm ochre and cool gray-blue lighting casting long shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012551010586321354 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.3875508308410645 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012551010586321354, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012551010586321354, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13488632440567017, + 0.28892526030540466, + 0.0767410397529602, + 0.0847432091832161, + 0.06003042310476303, + 0.06467889994382858, + 0.030915305018424988, + 0.11670393496751785, + 0.05685554817318916, + 0.08552004396915436 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012551010586321354 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a slow-motion tracking shot following a lone figure climbing steep steps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low, looking up at the figure and the steps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the steps massive, weathered, and blue-gray in color with visible cracks and weeds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing a dark windbreaker and trousers while leaning forward with a determined posture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at dusk with warm ochre and cool gray-blue lighting casting long shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00319126108661294 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.7531914710998535 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00319126108661294, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00319126108661294, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11639389395713806, + 0.12054736167192459, + 0.1651216745376587, + 0.09104601293802261, + 0.04909725487232208, + 0.0924215242266655, + 0.05308359116315842, + 0.10272720456123352, + 0.09805169701576233, + 0.11150966584682465 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00319126108661294 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a slow-motion tracking shot following a lone figure climbing steep steps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low, looking up at the figure and the steps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the steps massive, weathered, and blue-gray in color with visible cracks and weeds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing a dark windbreaker and trousers while leaning forward with a determined posture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at dusk with warm ochre and cool gray-blue lighting casting long shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011069318279623985 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511069297790527 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011069318279623985, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011069318279623985, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0694567933678627, + 0.07863219082355499, + 0.05515506491065025, + 0.04473868012428284, + 0.06269896775484085, + 0.5505144596099854, + 0.013569716364145279, + 0.07845152914524078, + 0.015294412150979042, + 0.03148812800645828 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011069318279623985 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a slow-motion tracking shot following a lone figure climbing steep steps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low, looking up at the figure and the steps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the steps massive, weathered, and blue-gray in color with visible cracks and weeds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing a dark windbreaker and trousers while leaning forward with a determined posture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at dusk with warm ochre and cool gray-blue lighting casting long shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020572613924741745 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955726623535156 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020572613924741745, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020572613924741745, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1626351773738861, + 0.29725754261016846, + 0.09880641102790833, + 0.08134204894304276, + 0.03445694223046303, + 0.1334509402513504, + 0.01920063979923725, + 0.09697423130273819, + 0.049592144787311554, + 0.02628389373421669 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020572613924741745 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow-motion tracking shot, shot from a low angle, follows a lone figure as he struggles to climb the steep steps of the majestic Great Wall. Beneath his feet are massive, weathered, blue-gray stone steps, each uneven, its edges smoothed by age. Tufts of withered weeds stubbornly grow between the cracks in the stone. The steps stretch endlessly upward, disappearing into view. The figure, dressed in a dark windbreaker and trousers, leans forward, his weight low, each step heavy and determined. His breath condenses into a faint white mist in the cool air, and he occasionally clings to the mottled parapets beside him for balance. In the background, the Great Wall winds like a giant dragon, coiling across the vast, rolling hills. It's dusk, and the golden, setting sun elongates his figure and the ancient wall, casting its shadow across the rough masonry, highlighting every crack and weathered texture. The main colors of the entire picture are warm ochre and cool gray-blue. The strong contrast between light and dark and the characters' tenacious climbing posture together create an epic atmosphere that is solemn, lonely and full of historical weight.", + "seed": 21333, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_3/index_9747_seed_21333_dp_7_rank_14_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.03235147288069129, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03235147288069129, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.925, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03235147288069129, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a slow-motion tracking shot following a lone figure climbing steep steps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low, looking up at the figure and the steps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the steps massive, weathered, and blue-gray in color with visible cracks and weeds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing a dark windbreaker and trousers while leaning forward with a determined posture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at dusk with warm ochre and cool gray-blue lighting casting long shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10155726224184036 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3515572547912598 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10155726224184036, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10155726224184036, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23199592530727386, + 0.1267692595720291, + 0.021330926567316055, + 0.2305193394422531, + 0.10540930181741714, + 0.06146697327494621, + 0.03527896851301193, + 0.04417058452963829, + 0.09044323861598969, + 0.0526154488325119 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10155726224184036 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a slow-motion tracking shot following a lone figure climbing steep steps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low, looking up at the figure and the steps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the steps massive, weathered, and blue-gray in color with visible cracks and weeds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing a dark windbreaker and trousers while leaning forward with a determined posture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at dusk with warm ochre and cool gray-blue lighting casting long shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023303447291254997 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773303508758545 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023303447291254997, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023303447291254997, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24185432493686676, + 0.18328213691711426, + 0.029010096564888954, + 0.0647215023636818, + 0.06184858828783035, + 0.038573525846004486, + 0.053744737058877945, + 0.05289920046925545, + 0.10464770346879959, + 0.16941821575164795 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023303447291254997 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a slow-motion tracking shot following a lone figure climbing steep steps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low, looking up at the figure and the steps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the steps massive, weathered, and blue-gray in color with visible cracks and weeds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing a dark windbreaker and trousers while leaning forward with a determined posture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at dusk with warm ochre and cool gray-blue lighting casting long shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0052507114596664906 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255250930786133 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0052507114596664906, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0052507114596664906, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12694820761680603, + 0.1117074266076088, + 0.17719757556915283, + 0.08307647705078125, + 0.09566976875066757, + 0.052190784364938736, + 0.05718047171831131, + 0.1248674988746643, + 0.08966904133558273, + 0.08149274438619614 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0052507114596664906 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a slow-motion tracking shot following a lone figure climbing steep steps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low, looking up at the figure and the steps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the steps massive, weathered, and blue-gray in color with visible cracks and weeds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing a dark windbreaker and trousers while leaning forward with a determined posture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at dusk with warm ochre and cool gray-blue lighting casting long shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011073444969952106 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511073589324951 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011073444969952106, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011073444969952106, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15417377650737762, + 0.10826808959245682, + 0.0563405342400074, + 0.4424000084400177, + 0.04071181267499924, + 0.03585408627986908, + 0.037933748215436935, + 0.02470438741147518, + 0.05626097694039345, + 0.043352603912353516 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011073444969952106 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a slow-motion tracking shot following a lone figure climbing steep steps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low, looking up at the figure and the steps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the steps massive, weathered, and blue-gray in color with visible cracks and weeds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing a dark windbreaker and trousers while leaning forward with a determined posture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at dusk with warm ochre and cool gray-blue lighting casting long shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020572498440742493 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955724239349365 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020572498440742493, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020572498440742493, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11374815553426743, + 0.050417639315128326, + 0.05959375575184822, + 0.052775200456380844, + 0.08242207020521164, + 0.06577233970165253, + 0.3211544454097748, + 0.14267590641975403, + 0.0608365498483181, + 0.05060397461056709 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020572498440742493 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_4/index_tensor([8339, 8339])_group_4_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_4/index_tensor([8339, 8339])_group_4_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..2d24006e01054d798fe239be0b5073c027d5e097 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_4/index_tensor([8339, 8339])_group_4_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "The camera executes a slow crane drop, descending from a high-angle perspective, immersing the viewer in a scene rendered entirely in the distinctive PS1 graphical style. Below, a low-polygon 3D model of the Yangtze River Dam is displayed, its iconic structure simplified to sharp, non-jaggy geometry and distinct polygonal edges. Its massive concrete surface is clad in a distinctly pixelated, repetitive gray texture that stretches and distorts across a flat, shaded plane. The entire massive model tilts and tumbles violently, rocking back and forth as if struck by a massive, unseen earthquake. This violent, rigid movement causes the water within its submersible—a single, solid plane of cyan geometric mesh—to slosh unrealistically, tilting as a whole and creating sharp, angular wave crests that jar through the dam's polygonal geometry without any hint of fluid dynamics. The surrounding landscape is composed of jagged, low-lying mountains with muddy, low-resolution green and brown textures. The entire chaotic scene is illuminated by the characteristic sharp, uniform digital light of early 3D engines, which casts no soft shadows but instead creates a surreal, unsettling, and strangely nostalgic atmosphere of digital disaster.", + "seed": 2890, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_4/index_8339_seed_2890_dp_8_rank_16_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.08393628592602909, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08393628592602909, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.9, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08393628592602909, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a distinctive PS1 graphical style with low-polygon geometry?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a low-polygon 3D model of the Yangtze River Dam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the dam model tilt and tumble violently as if struck by an earthquake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the water inside the dam represented as a single solid plane of cyan geometric mesh sloshing unrealistically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow crane drop from a high-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0038784535136073828 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.253878593444824 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0038784535136073828, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0038784535136073828, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11608394980430603, + 0.3411649167537689, + 0.24746572971343994, + 0.03360737860202789, + 0.012712209485471249, + 0.021300621330738068, + 0.049832578748464584, + 0.08104640245437622, + 0.04776373133063316, + 0.049022477120161057 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0038784535136073828 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a distinctive PS1 graphical style with low-polygon geometry?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a low-polygon 3D model of the Yangtze River Dam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the dam model tilt and tumble violently as if struck by an earthquake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the water inside the dam represented as a single solid plane of cyan geometric mesh sloshing unrealistically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow crane drop from a high-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02059001475572586 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.89559006690979 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02059001475572586, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02059001475572586, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.29209649562835693, + 0.2959142327308655, + 0.15165330469608307, + 0.08134397119283676, + 0.02295774221420288, + 0.023763112723827362, + 0.0189433041960001, + 0.049670882523059845, + 0.025580840185284615, + 0.03807612136006355 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02059001475572586 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a distinctive PS1 graphical style with low-polygon geometry?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a low-polygon 3D model of the Yangtze River Dam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the dam model tilt and tumble violently as if struck by an earthquake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the water inside the dam represented as a single solid plane of cyan geometric mesh sloshing unrealistically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow crane drop from a high-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0789726972579956 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.578972816467285 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0789726972579956, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0789726972579956, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05197794362902641, + 0.38304340839385986, + 0.352512389421463, + 0.01352817751467228, + 0.014178556390106678, + 0.012939459644258022, + 0.03578786551952362, + 0.10238193720579147, + 0.01478257030248642, + 0.0188677329570055 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0789726972579956 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a distinctive PS1 graphical style with low-polygon geometry?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a low-polygon 3D model of the Yangtze River Dam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the dam model tilt and tumble violently as if struck by an earthquake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the water inside the dam represented as a single solid plane of cyan geometric mesh sloshing unrealistically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow crane drop from a high-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002820206806063652 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877820014953613 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002820206806063652, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002820206806063652, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.061815954744815826, + 0.4072164297103882, + 0.1458374708890915, + 0.013350634835660458, + 0.00802025105804205, + 0.008186081424355507, + 0.06271734833717346, + 0.2597716152667999, + 0.01146174781024456, + 0.021622462198138237 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 7, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002820206806063652 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a distinctive PS1 graphical style with low-polygon geometry?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a low-polygon 3D model of the Yangtze River Dam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the dam model tilt and tumble violently as if struck by an earthquake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the water inside the dam represented as a single solid plane of cyan geometric mesh sloshing unrealistically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow crane drop from a high-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.31342005729675293 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.313420057296753 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.31342005729675293, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.31342005729675293, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03497898578643799, + 0.15939804911613464, + 0.6160651445388794, + 0.017827674746513367, + 0.010039661079645157, + 0.008469966240227222, + 0.04656227305531502, + 0.0403389036655426, + 0.038163717836141586, + 0.028155667707324028 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.31342005729675293 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "The camera executes a slow crane drop, descending from a high-angle perspective, immersing the viewer in a scene rendered entirely in the distinctive PS1 graphical style. Below, a low-polygon 3D model of the Yangtze River Dam is displayed, its iconic structure simplified to sharp, non-jaggy geometry and distinct polygonal edges. Its massive concrete surface is clad in a distinctly pixelated, repetitive gray texture that stretches and distorts across a flat, shaded plane. The entire massive model tilts and tumbles violently, rocking back and forth as if struck by a massive, unseen earthquake. This violent, rigid movement causes the water within its submersible—a single, solid plane of cyan geometric mesh—to slosh unrealistically, tilting as a whole and creating sharp, angular wave crests that jar through the dam's polygonal geometry without any hint of fluid dynamics. The surrounding landscape is composed of jagged, low-lying mountains with muddy, low-resolution green and brown textures. The entire chaotic scene is illuminated by the characteristic sharp, uniform digital light of early 3D engines, which casts no soft shadows but instead creates a surreal, unsettling, and strangely nostalgic atmosphere of digital disaster.", + "seed": 2891, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_4/index_8339_seed_2891_dp_8_rank_16_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.1052208753535524, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1052208753535524, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.425000011920929, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1052208753535524, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a distinctive PS1 graphical style with low-polygon geometry?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a low-polygon 3D model of the Yangtze River Dam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the dam model tilt and tumble violently as if struck by an earthquake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the water inside the dam represented as a single solid plane of cyan geometric mesh sloshing unrealistically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow crane drop from a high-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.015368256717920303 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.265368461608887 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.015368256717920303, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.015368256717920303, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.26578450202941895, + 0.10507024824619293, + 0.1498725563287735, + 0.16370727121829987, + 0.1138177216053009, + 0.07739745080471039, + 0.040896497666835785, + 0.015436988323926926, + 0.027100292965769768, + 0.040916480123996735 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.015368256717920303 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a distinctive PS1 graphical style with low-polygon geometry?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a low-polygon 3D model of the Yangtze River Dam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the dam model tilt and tumble violently as if struck by an earthquake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the water inside the dam represented as a single solid plane of cyan geometric mesh sloshing unrealistically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow crane drop from a high-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.033723458647727966 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4087233543395996 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.033723458647727966, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.033723458647727966, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1975211501121521, + 0.13154879212379456, + 0.3680887520313263, + 0.06429139524698257, + 0.052027832716703415, + 0.07470356673002243, + 0.037234093993902206, + 0.02298734150826931, + 0.015902644023299217, + 0.035694386810064316 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.033723458647727966 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a distinctive PS1 graphical style with low-polygon geometry?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a low-polygon 3D model of the Yangtze River Dam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the dam model tilt and tumble violently as if struck by an earthquake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the water inside the dam represented as a single solid plane of cyan geometric mesh sloshing unrealistically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow crane drop from a high-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12703672051429749 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1270368099212646 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12703672051429749, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12703672051429749, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11948162317276001, + 0.20877307653427124, + 0.22892802953720093, + 0.0633721649646759, + 0.06480488926172256, + 0.07670719176530838, + 0.04217316955327988, + 0.06505633890628815, + 0.09112676233053207, + 0.03957675024867058 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12703672051429749 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a distinctive PS1 graphical style with low-polygon geometry?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a low-polygon 3D model of the Yangtze River Dam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the dam model tilt and tumble violently as if struck by an earthquake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the water inside the dam represented as a single solid plane of cyan geometric mesh sloshing unrealistically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow crane drop from a high-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0013388964580371976 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.626338958740234 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0013388964580371976, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0013388964580371976, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19738700985908508, + 0.1741141825914383, + 0.3047504425048828, + 0.14203405380249023, + 0.050462380051612854, + 0.038068097084760666, + 0.045380499213933945, + 0.017122194170951843, + 0.015220202505588531, + 0.015460954047739506 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0013388964580371976 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a distinctive PS1 graphical style with low-polygon geometry?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a low-polygon 3D model of the Yangtze River Dam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the dam model tilt and tumble violently as if struck by an earthquake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the water inside the dam represented as a single solid plane of cyan geometric mesh sloshing unrealistically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow crane drop from a high-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.34863704442977905 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2236371040344238 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.34863704442977905, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.8750000596046448, + "token_credit_reward": -0.34863704442977905, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2087153047323227, + 0.18750163912773132, + 0.1469472348690033, + 0.08418017625808716, + 0.13665401935577393, + 0.08247440308332443, + 0.03134813532233238, + 0.03236810490489006, + 0.03247000649571419, + 0.05734090507030487 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.34863704442977905 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "The camera executes a slow crane drop, descending from a high-angle perspective, immersing the viewer in a scene rendered entirely in the distinctive PS1 graphical style. Below, a low-polygon 3D model of the Yangtze River Dam is displayed, its iconic structure simplified to sharp, non-jaggy geometry and distinct polygonal edges. Its massive concrete surface is clad in a distinctly pixelated, repetitive gray texture that stretches and distorts across a flat, shaded plane. The entire massive model tilts and tumbles violently, rocking back and forth as if struck by a massive, unseen earthquake. This violent, rigid movement causes the water within its submersible—a single, solid plane of cyan geometric mesh—to slosh unrealistically, tilting as a whole and creating sharp, angular wave crests that jar through the dam's polygonal geometry without any hint of fluid dynamics. The surrounding landscape is composed of jagged, low-lying mountains with muddy, low-resolution green and brown textures. The entire chaotic scene is illuminated by the characteristic sharp, uniform digital light of early 3D engines, which casts no soft shadows but instead creates a surreal, unsettling, and strangely nostalgic atmosphere of digital disaster.", + "seed": 2892, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_4/index_8339_seed_2892_dp_9_rank_18_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.07791527539957314, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07791527539957314, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.75, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07791527539957314, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a distinctive PS1 graphical style with low-polygon geometry?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a low-polygon 3D model of the Yangtze River Dam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the dam model tilt and tumble violently as if struck by an earthquake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the water inside the dam represented as a single solid plane of cyan geometric mesh sloshing unrealistically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow crane drop from a high-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00495005352422595 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.629950046539307 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00495005352422595, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00495005352422595, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5602021217346191, + 0.05606299638748169, + 0.0920458734035492, + 0.01852872595191002, + 0.020593581721186638, + 0.09343481808900833, + 0.016483286395668983, + 0.022866787388920784, + 0.07511207461357117, + 0.044669754803180695 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00495005352422595 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a distinctive PS1 graphical style with low-polygon geometry?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a low-polygon 3D model of the Yangtze River Dam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the dam model tilt and tumble violently as if struck by an earthquake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the water inside the dam represented as a single solid plane of cyan geometric mesh sloshing unrealistically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow crane drop from a high-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04307664558291435 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168076753616333 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04307664558291435, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04307664558291435, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1820325255393982, + 0.11719608306884766, + 0.2858908474445343, + 0.08222512900829315, + 0.031730834394693375, + 0.047384630888700485, + 0.017470628023147583, + 0.014911903999745846, + 0.1980276256799698, + 0.023129763081669807 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04307664558291435 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a distinctive PS1 graphical style with low-polygon geometry?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a low-polygon 3D model of the Yangtze River Dam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the dam model tilt and tumble violently as if struck by an earthquake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the water inside the dam represented as a single solid plane of cyan geometric mesh sloshing unrealistically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow crane drop from a high-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17987193167209625 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.804871916770935 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17987193167209625, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17987193167209625, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18989969789981842, + 0.06437517702579498, + 0.14759141206741333, + 0.05082884803414345, + 0.040236037224531174, + 0.24534030258655548, + 0.024949202314019203, + 0.018251195549964905, + 0.08884332329034805, + 0.12968488037586212 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17987193167209625 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a distinctive PS1 graphical style with low-polygon geometry?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a low-polygon 3D model of the Yangtze River Dam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the dam model tilt and tumble violently as if struck by an earthquake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the water inside the dam represented as a single solid plane of cyan geometric mesh sloshing unrealistically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow crane drop from a high-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0013381821336224675 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.626338005065918 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0013381821336224675, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0013381821336224675, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10797876119613647, + 0.12004893273115158, + 0.07737930864095688, + 0.042295053601264954, + 0.0680137425661087, + 0.22767072916030884, + 0.03692465275526047, + 0.018279941752552986, + 0.217060849070549, + 0.08434801548719406 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0013381821336224675 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a distinctive PS1 graphical style with low-polygon geometry?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a low-polygon 3D model of the Yangtze River Dam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the dam model tilt and tumble violently as if struck by an earthquake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the water inside the dam represented as a single solid plane of cyan geometric mesh sloshing unrealistically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow crane drop from a high-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1603395640850067 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.910339593887329 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1603395640850067, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1603395640850067, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3176451325416565, + 0.21525132656097412, + 0.13193991780281067, + 0.029946936294436455, + 0.028795713558793068, + 0.09158280491828918, + 0.02181696891784668, + 0.020809052512049675, + 0.11832384765148163, + 0.023888306692242622 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1603395640850067 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "The camera executes a slow crane drop, descending from a high-angle perspective, immersing the viewer in a scene rendered entirely in the distinctive PS1 graphical style. Below, a low-polygon 3D model of the Yangtze River Dam is displayed, its iconic structure simplified to sharp, non-jaggy geometry and distinct polygonal edges. Its massive concrete surface is clad in a distinctly pixelated, repetitive gray texture that stretches and distorts across a flat, shaded plane. The entire massive model tilts and tumbles violently, rocking back and forth as if struck by a massive, unseen earthquake. This violent, rigid movement causes the water within its submersible—a single, solid plane of cyan geometric mesh—to slosh unrealistically, tilting as a whole and creating sharp, angular wave crests that jar through the dam's polygonal geometry without any hint of fluid dynamics. The surrounding landscape is composed of jagged, low-lying mountains with muddy, low-resolution green and brown textures. The entire chaotic scene is illuminated by the characteristic sharp, uniform digital light of early 3D engines, which casts no soft shadows but instead creates a surreal, unsettling, and strangely nostalgic atmosphere of digital disaster.", + "seed": 2893, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_4/index_8339_seed_2893_dp_9_rank_18_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.18157690465450288, + "vlm_logprob": -0.18157690465450288, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.6, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.18157690465450288, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a distinctive PS1 graphical style with low-polygon geometry?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a low-polygon 3D model of the Yangtze River Dam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the dam model tilt and tumble violently as if struck by an earthquake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the water inside the dam represented as a single solid plane of cyan geometric mesh sloshing unrealistically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow crane drop from a high-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011288229376077652 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.636288166046143 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011288229376077652, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011288229376077652, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3079386055469513, + 0.04461950436234474, + 0.1931772530078888, + 0.12609034776687622, + 0.03061225451529026, + 0.027309389784932137, + 0.04714212194085121, + 0.03167438879609108, + 0.06729554384946823, + 0.12414061278104782 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011288229376077652 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a distinctive PS1 graphical style with low-polygon geometry?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a low-polygon 3D model of the Yangtze River Dam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the dam model tilt and tumble violently as if struck by an earthquake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the water inside the dam represented as a single solid plane of cyan geometric mesh sloshing unrealistically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow crane drop from a high-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026361636817455292 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513617038726807 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026361636817455292, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026361636817455292, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24721592664718628, + 0.11558360606431961, + 0.11970993131399155, + 0.042925041168928146, + 0.0319293849170208, + 0.042605310678482056, + 0.04305875301361084, + 0.04851387068629265, + 0.07313230633735657, + 0.23532584309577942 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026361636817455292 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a distinctive PS1 graphical style with low-polygon geometry?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a low-polygon 3D model of the Yangtze River Dam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the dam model tilt and tumble violently as if struck by an earthquake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the water inside the dam represented as a single solid plane of cyan geometric mesh sloshing unrealistically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow crane drop from a high-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0430566631257534 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680567264556885 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0430566631257534, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0430566631257534, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14362460374832153, + 0.05149654671549797, + 0.21352830529212952, + 0.1031457781791687, + 0.04786546900868416, + 0.02454787865281105, + 0.046562206000089645, + 0.04478708654642105, + 0.132522851228714, + 0.19191929697990417 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0430566631257534 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a distinctive PS1 graphical style with low-polygon geometry?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a low-polygon 3D model of the Yangtze River Dam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the dam model tilt and tumble violently as if struck by an earthquake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the water inside the dam represented as a single solid plane of cyan geometric mesh sloshing unrealistically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow crane drop from a high-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.001042775809764862 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.87604284286499 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.001042775809764862, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.001042775809764862, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08897416293621063, + 0.11640136688947678, + 0.15857648849487305, + 0.1270385980606079, + 0.02737543359398842, + 0.047455351799726486, + 0.03171367943286896, + 0.02758464589715004, + 0.10008233785629272, + 0.2747979462146759 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.001042775809764862 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a distinctive PS1 graphical style with low-polygon geometry?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a low-polygon 3D model of the Yangtze River Dam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the dam model tilt and tumble violently as if struck by an earthquake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the water inside the dam represented as a single solid plane of cyan geometric mesh sloshing unrealistically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow crane drop from a high-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8261352181434631 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5761352181434631 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.8261352181434631, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.8261352181434631, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17732496559619904, + 0.08661513030529022, + 0.16342848539352417, + 0.06210622936487198, + 0.041849102824926376, + 0.06312724947929382, + 0.0514538511633873, + 0.046600814908742905, + 0.08947916328907013, + 0.2180149108171463 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.8261352181434631 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_5/index_tensor([3242, 3242])_group_5_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_5/index_tensor([3242, 3242])_group_5_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..28a081c6125fd6e571bc3197cced1219dd82243d --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_5/index_tensor([3242, 3242])_group_5_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "fluid 360-degree arc, captured from a slightly upward mid-shot perspective, captures an elf chef in the heart of a fantastical kitchen. The chef, with his pointed ears and a face radiating pure joy, wears a pristine white, tall, slightly ruffled traditional chef's hat, his short blond hair playfully jutting from the brim. He wears an apron woven from emerald green leaves and rhythmically bounces on a giant mushroom trampoline. The cap, a vibrant red speckled with cream, is incredibly springy, launching the elf chef high into the air each time he drops to his knees and springs upward. With each leap, balls of soft, springy dough and colorful berries—including crimson strawberries and plump blueberries—are lifted up, forming a dazzling, swirling trail around him, dancing through the air. Warm golden sunlight streams through the vast, flower-shaped windows, illuminating the space. It illuminates the luminous crystal pots and pans in the background, as well as tiny light particles floating in the air, casting soft yet crisp shadows on the floor and other surfaces. The entire scene is imbued with the vibrant, intricate details and warm light and shadows of a Pixar film. The vibrant colors, dominated by warm golds, emerald greens, and vibrant reds, create an atmosphere of carefree joy that is infectious.", + "seed": 5939, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_5/index_3242_seed_5939_dp_10_rank_20_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.014272464858368038, + "vlm_logprob": -0.014272464858368038, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.5, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.014272464858368038, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elf chef with pointed ears and short blond hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the chef wearing a tall white ruffled chef's hat and an apron woven from emerald green leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the chef bouncing on a giant mushroom trampoline with a vibrant red speckled cap?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are balls of soft dough and colorful berries (crimson strawberries and blueberries) forming a swirling trail around the chef?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene captured from a slightly upward mid-shot perspective with a fluid 360-degree arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026651980355381966 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6516520977020264 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026651980355381966, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026651980355381966, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09361173957586288, + 0.11956136673688889, + 0.08709359169006348, + 0.057165469974279404, + 0.04035419225692749, + 0.06857825070619583, + 0.11686014384031296, + 0.07559442520141602, + 0.11277536302804947, + 0.22840549051761627 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026651980355381966 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elf chef with pointed ears and short blond hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the chef wearing a tall white ruffled chef's hat and an apron woven from emerald green leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the chef bouncing on a giant mushroom trampoline with a vibrant red speckled cap?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are balls of soft dough and colorful berries (crimson strawberries and blueberries) forming a swirling trail around the chef?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene captured from a slightly upward mid-shot perspective with a fluid 360-degree arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003624300705268979 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628624439239502 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003624300705268979, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003624300705268979, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1462656557559967, + 0.1395406723022461, + 0.057761725038290024, + 0.0393485464155674, + 0.05186080560088158, + 0.05209234729409218, + 0.1521766036748886, + 0.04129673168063164, + 0.15076136589050293, + 0.16889555752277374 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003624300705268979 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elf chef with pointed ears and short blond hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the chef wearing a tall white ruffled chef's hat and an apron woven from emerald green leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the chef bouncing on a giant mushroom trampoline with a vibrant red speckled cap?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are balls of soft dough and colorful berries (crimson strawberries and blueberries) forming a swirling trail around the chef?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene captured from a slightly upward mid-shot perspective with a fluid 360-degree arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006736070849001408 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.0067362785339355 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006736070849001408, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006736070849001408, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13117176294326782, + 0.0957259014248848, + 0.2438136488199234, + 0.12934988737106323, + 0.04826696962118149, + 0.034621745347976685, + 0.10647609829902649, + 0.08384795486927032, + 0.08027517795562744, + 0.046450842171907425 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006736070849001408 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elf chef with pointed ears and short blond hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the chef wearing a tall white ruffled chef's hat and an apron woven from emerald green leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the chef bouncing on a giant mushroom trampoline with a vibrant red speckled cap?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are balls of soft dough and colorful berries (crimson strawberries and blueberries) forming a swirling trail around the chef?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene captured from a slightly upward mid-shot perspective with a fluid 360-degree arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011072147637605667 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511072158813477 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011072147637605667, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011072147637605667, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06379615515470505, + 0.07591771334409714, + 0.10465745627880096, + 0.20810335874557495, + 0.03819774091243744, + 0.0533762127161026, + 0.07933898270130157, + 0.08963945508003235, + 0.14736567437648773, + 0.1396072655916214 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011072147637605667 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elf chef with pointed ears and short blond hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the chef wearing a tall white ruffled chef's hat and an apron woven from emerald green leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the chef bouncing on a giant mushroom trampoline with a vibrant red speckled cap?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are balls of soft dough and colorful berries (crimson strawberries and blueberries) forming a swirling trail around the chef?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene captured from a slightly upward mid-shot perspective with a fluid 360-degree arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023277824744582176 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773277759552002 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023277824744582176, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023277824744582176, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0998762995004654, + 0.10669150203466415, + 0.08921817690134048, + 0.04996298626065254, + 0.18535663187503815, + 0.06735727190971375, + 0.2917323708534241, + 0.031173620373010635, + 0.03155166283249855, + 0.047079477459192276 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023277824744582176 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "fluid 360-degree arc, captured from a slightly upward mid-shot perspective, captures an elf chef in the heart of a fantastical kitchen. The chef, with his pointed ears and a face radiating pure joy, wears a pristine white, tall, slightly ruffled traditional chef's hat, his short blond hair playfully jutting from the brim. He wears an apron woven from emerald green leaves and rhythmically bounces on a giant mushroom trampoline. The cap, a vibrant red speckled with cream, is incredibly springy, launching the elf chef high into the air each time he drops to his knees and springs upward. With each leap, balls of soft, springy dough and colorful berries—including crimson strawberries and plump blueberries—are lifted up, forming a dazzling, swirling trail around him, dancing through the air. Warm golden sunlight streams through the vast, flower-shaped windows, illuminating the space. It illuminates the luminous crystal pots and pans in the background, as well as tiny light particles floating in the air, casting soft yet crisp shadows on the floor and other surfaces. The entire scene is imbued with the vibrant, intricate details and warm light and shadows of a Pixar film. The vibrant colors, dominated by warm golds, emerald greens, and vibrant reds, create an atmosphere of carefree joy that is infectious.", + "seed": 5940, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_5/index_3242_seed_5940_dp_10_rank_20_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.029183078836649657, + "vlm_logprob": -0.029183078836649657, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.875, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.029183078836649657, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elf chef with pointed ears and short blond hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the chef wearing a tall white ruffled chef's hat and an apron woven from emerald green leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the chef bouncing on a giant mushroom trampoline with a vibrant red speckled cap?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are balls of soft dough and colorful berries (crimson strawberries and blueberries) forming a swirling trail around the chef?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene captured from a slightly upward mid-shot perspective with a fluid 360-degree arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.055444445461034775 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9304444789886475 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.055444445461034775, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.055444445461034775, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1239076554775238, + 0.3527272641658783, + 0.13889378309249878, + 0.025005539879202843, + 0.06152694672346115, + 0.026516756042838097, + 0.08274234086275101, + 0.023796269670128822, + 0.08817256987094879, + 0.07671087980270386 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.055444445461034775 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elf chef with pointed ears and short blond hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the chef wearing a tall white ruffled chef's hat and an apron woven from emerald green leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the chef bouncing on a giant mushroom trampoline with a vibrant red speckled cap?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are balls of soft dough and colorful berries (crimson strawberries and blueberries) forming a swirling trail around the chef?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene captured from a slightly upward mid-shot perspective with a fluid 360-degree arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005270989146083593 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255270957946777 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005270989146083593, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005270989146083593, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1373743712902069, + 0.34905269742012024, + 0.15478426218032837, + 0.020867973566055298, + 0.0355750173330307, + 0.040262334048748016, + 0.050545867532491684, + 0.03986009955406189, + 0.1086200401186943, + 0.06305734813213348 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005270989146083593 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elf chef with pointed ears and short blond hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the chef wearing a tall white ruffled chef's hat and an apron woven from emerald green leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the chef bouncing on a giant mushroom trampoline with a vibrant red speckled cap?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are balls of soft dough and colorful berries (crimson strawberries and blueberries) forming a swirling trail around the chef?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene captured from a slightly upward mid-shot perspective with a fluid 360-degree arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014199178665876389 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264199256896973 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014199178665876389, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014199178665876389, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08404846489429474, + 0.292680561542511, + 0.21742913126945496, + 0.04716413840651512, + 0.036045562475919724, + 0.04214322939515114, + 0.03556077182292938, + 0.040321677923202515, + 0.11900095641613007, + 0.08560542017221451 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014199178665876389 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elf chef with pointed ears and short blond hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the chef wearing a tall white ruffled chef's hat and an apron woven from emerald green leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the chef bouncing on a giant mushroom trampoline with a vibrant red speckled cap?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are balls of soft dough and colorful berries (crimson strawberries and blueberries) forming a swirling trail around the chef?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene captured from a slightly upward mid-shot perspective with a fluid 360-degree arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016065552830696106 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.14106559753418 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016065552830696106, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016065552830696106, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21800868213176727, + 0.27247801423072815, + 0.12120893597602844, + 0.027933839708566666, + 0.03603341802954674, + 0.059241246432065964, + 0.07720240205526352, + 0.049424536526203156, + 0.07732253521680832, + 0.06114634871482849 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016065552830696106 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elf chef with pointed ears and short blond hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the chef wearing a tall white ruffled chef's hat and an apron woven from emerald green leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the chef bouncing on a giant mushroom trampoline with a vibrant red speckled cap?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are balls of soft dough and colorful berries (crimson strawberries and blueberries) forming a swirling trail around the chef?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene captured from a slightly upward mid-shot perspective with a fluid 360-degree arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05493522807955742 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299352169036865 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05493522807955742, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05493522807955742, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23118458688259125, + 0.1746951937675476, + 0.11605081707239151, + 0.06271473318338394, + 0.05950799211859703, + 0.06064826622605324, + 0.054273881018161774, + 0.05497436597943306, + 0.09020017087459564, + 0.09575002640485764 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05493522807955742 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "fluid 360-degree arc, captured from a slightly upward mid-shot perspective, captures an elf chef in the heart of a fantastical kitchen. The chef, with his pointed ears and a face radiating pure joy, wears a pristine white, tall, slightly ruffled traditional chef's hat, his short blond hair playfully jutting from the brim. He wears an apron woven from emerald green leaves and rhythmically bounces on a giant mushroom trampoline. The cap, a vibrant red speckled with cream, is incredibly springy, launching the elf chef high into the air each time he drops to his knees and springs upward. With each leap, balls of soft, springy dough and colorful berries—including crimson strawberries and plump blueberries—are lifted up, forming a dazzling, swirling trail around him, dancing through the air. Warm golden sunlight streams through the vast, flower-shaped windows, illuminating the space. It illuminates the luminous crystal pots and pans in the background, as well as tiny light particles floating in the air, casting soft yet crisp shadows on the floor and other surfaces. The entire scene is imbued with the vibrant, intricate details and warm light and shadows of a Pixar film. The vibrant colors, dominated by warm golds, emerald greens, and vibrant reds, create an atmosphere of carefree joy that is infectious.", + "seed": 5941, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_5/index_3242_seed_5941_dp_11_rank_22_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.009897435503080487, + "vlm_logprob": -0.009897435503080487, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.825, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.009897435503080487, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elf chef with pointed ears and short blond hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the chef wearing a tall white ruffled chef's hat and an apron woven from emerald green leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the chef bouncing on a giant mushroom trampoline with a vibrant red speckled cap?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are balls of soft dough and colorful berries (crimson strawberries and blueberries) forming a swirling trail around the chef?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene captured from a slightly upward mid-shot perspective with a fluid 360-degree arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011416582390666008 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511416435241699 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011416582390666008, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011416582390666008, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17168687283992767, + 0.06940603256225586, + 0.1066586896777153, + 0.06968643516302109, + 0.030247656628489494, + 0.044134486466646194, + 0.19861236214637756, + 0.1274835169315338, + 0.10408560931682587, + 0.07799839228391647 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011416582390666008 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elf chef with pointed ears and short blond hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the chef wearing a tall white ruffled chef's hat and an apron woven from emerald green leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the chef bouncing on a giant mushroom trampoline with a vibrant red speckled cap?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are balls of soft dough and colorful berries (crimson strawberries and blueberries) forming a swirling trail around the chef?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene captured from a slightly upward mid-shot perspective with a fluid 360-degree arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004104523919522762 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.5041046142578125 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004104523919522762, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004104523919522762, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2924501299858093, + 0.07766585797071457, + 0.05668430030345917, + 0.0776829719543457, + 0.05035601556301117, + 0.10542568564414978, + 0.07836707681417465, + 0.06610710918903351, + 0.0835694968700409, + 0.11169131845235825 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004104523919522762 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elf chef with pointed ears and short blond hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the chef wearing a tall white ruffled chef's hat and an apron woven from emerald green leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the chef bouncing on a giant mushroom trampoline with a vibrant red speckled cap?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are balls of soft dough and colorful berries (crimson strawberries and blueberries) forming a swirling trail around the chef?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene captured from a slightly upward mid-shot perspective with a fluid 360-degree arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036143234465271235 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.62861442565918 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036143234465271235, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036143234465271235, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22003427147865295, + 0.11070911586284637, + 0.3055233657360077, + 0.05029718950390816, + 0.03163037821650505, + 0.06132343038916588, + 0.03149415925145149, + 0.06897240877151489, + 0.07507572323083878, + 0.044939976185560226 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036143234465271235 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elf chef with pointed ears and short blond hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the chef wearing a tall white ruffled chef's hat and an apron woven from emerald green leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the chef bouncing on a giant mushroom trampoline with a vibrant red speckled cap?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are balls of soft dough and colorful berries (crimson strawberries and blueberries) forming a swirling trail around the chef?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene captured from a slightly upward mid-shot perspective with a fluid 360-degree arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02057553455233574 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895575523376465 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02057553455233574, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02057553455233574, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5670836567878723, + 0.06376050412654877, + 0.040272828191518784, + 0.04623519629240036, + 0.04842909425497055, + 0.04661504179239273, + 0.032226044684648514, + 0.08349040150642395, + 0.03209453821182251, + 0.03979269042611122 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02057553455233574 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elf chef with pointed ears and short blond hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the chef wearing a tall white ruffled chef's hat and an apron woven from emerald green leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the chef bouncing on a giant mushroom trampoline with a vibrant red speckled cap?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are balls of soft dough and colorful berries (crimson strawberries and blueberries) forming a swirling trail around the chef?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene captured from a slightly upward mid-shot perspective with a fluid 360-degree arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009776213206350803 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.6347761154174805 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009776213206350803, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009776213206350803, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.30814239382743835, + 0.07228872179985046, + 0.07995337247848511, + 0.16119703650474548, + 0.043299347162246704, + 0.017881978303194046, + 0.08968038111925125, + 0.14706456661224365, + 0.028397349640727043, + 0.05209488421678543 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009776213206350803 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "fluid 360-degree arc, captured from a slightly upward mid-shot perspective, captures an elf chef in the heart of a fantastical kitchen. The chef, with his pointed ears and a face radiating pure joy, wears a pristine white, tall, slightly ruffled traditional chef's hat, his short blond hair playfully jutting from the brim. He wears an apron woven from emerald green leaves and rhythmically bounces on a giant mushroom trampoline. The cap, a vibrant red speckled with cream, is incredibly springy, launching the elf chef high into the air each time he drops to his knees and springs upward. With each leap, balls of soft, springy dough and colorful berries—including crimson strawberries and plump blueberries—are lifted up, forming a dazzling, swirling trail around him, dancing through the air. Warm golden sunlight streams through the vast, flower-shaped windows, illuminating the space. It illuminates the luminous crystal pots and pans in the background, as well as tiny light particles floating in the air, casting soft yet crisp shadows on the floor and other surfaces. The entire scene is imbued with the vibrant, intricate details and warm light and shadows of a Pixar film. The vibrant colors, dominated by warm golds, emerald greens, and vibrant reds, create an atmosphere of carefree joy that is infectious.", + "seed": 5942, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_5/index_3242_seed_5942_dp_11_rank_22_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.01023719641380012, + "vlm_logprob": -0.01023719641380012, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 5.05, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.01023719641380012, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elf chef with pointed ears and short blond hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the chef wearing a tall white ruffled chef's hat and an apron woven from emerald green leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the chef bouncing on a giant mushroom trampoline with a vibrant red speckled cap?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are balls of soft dough and colorful berries (crimson strawberries and blueberries) forming a swirling trail around the chef?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene captured from a slightly upward mid-shot perspective with a fluid 360-degree arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020920798182487488 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895920753479004 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020920798182487488, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020920798182487488, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.052873071283102036, + 0.02879582718014717, + 0.08162744343280792, + 0.02590867131948471, + 0.02649618871510029, + 0.4567619264125824, + 0.09378957748413086, + 0.13663236796855927, + 0.024470578879117966, + 0.07264439761638641 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020920798182487488 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elf chef with pointed ears and short blond hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the chef wearing a tall white ruffled chef's hat and an apron woven from emerald green leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the chef bouncing on a giant mushroom trampoline with a vibrant red speckled cap?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are balls of soft dough and colorful berries (crimson strawberries and blueberries) forming a swirling trail around the chef?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene captured from a slightly upward mid-shot perspective with a fluid 360-degree arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0022052035201340914 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.1272053718566895 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0022052035201340914, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0022052035201340914, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09407796710729599, + 0.042254675179719925, + 0.18633253872394562, + 0.04175383225083351, + 0.03535899892449379, + 0.08224751055240631, + 0.05415435880422592, + 0.2259717881679535, + 0.04380998760461807, + 0.19403837621212006 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0022052035201340914 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elf chef with pointed ears and short blond hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the chef wearing a tall white ruffled chef's hat and an apron woven from emerald green leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the chef bouncing on a giant mushroom trampoline with a vibrant red speckled cap?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are balls of soft dough and colorful berries (crimson strawberries and blueberries) forming a swirling trail around the chef?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene captured from a slightly upward mid-shot perspective with a fluid 360-degree arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.001335205975919962 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.626335144042969 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.001335205975919962, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.001335205975919962, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10574504733085632, + 0.02763727679848671, + 0.08304951339960098, + 0.08774973452091217, + 0.040017370134592056, + 0.09371321648359299, + 0.2712548077106476, + 0.1579500138759613, + 0.04819454252719879, + 0.0846884697675705 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.001335205975919962 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elf chef with pointed ears and short blond hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the chef wearing a tall white ruffled chef's hat and an apron woven from emerald green leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the chef bouncing on a giant mushroom trampoline with a vibrant red speckled cap?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are balls of soft dough and colorful berries (crimson strawberries and blueberries) forming a swirling trail around the chef?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene captured from a slightly upward mid-shot perspective with a fluid 360-degree arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014191304333508015 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264191150665283 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014191304333508015, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014191304333508015, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08975303918123245, + 0.04548700153827667, + 0.2802768051624298, + 0.049508851021528244, + 0.0325533002614975, + 0.11040332168340683, + 0.07728772610425949, + 0.20270799100399017, + 0.02082349732518196, + 0.09119849652051926 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 7, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014191304333508015 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elf chef with pointed ears and short blond hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the chef wearing a tall white ruffled chef's hat and an apron woven from emerald green leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the chef bouncing on a giant mushroom trampoline with a vibrant red speckled cap?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are balls of soft dough and colorful berries (crimson strawberries and blueberries) forming a swirling trail around the chef?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene captured from a slightly upward mid-shot perspective with a fluid 360-degree arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012533470056951046 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387533664703369 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012533470056951046, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012533470056951046, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08074826747179031, + 0.06440995633602142, + 0.4355446994304657, + 0.05268929526209831, + 0.04151657596230507, + 0.10071124881505966, + 0.045890774577856064, + 0.07928669452667236, + 0.029872113838791847, + 0.06933038681745529 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012533470056951046 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_6/index_tensor([9835, 9835])_group_6_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_6/index_tensor([9835, 9835])_group_6_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..0ad9d9be74921a09c650687feeb8c5d7e45116b5 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_6/index_tensor([9835, 9835])_group_6_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "slow-motion medium close-up shot from a horizontal angle, the camera slowly zooming in, focuses on two egrets locked in a fierce struggle in the murky shallows of a swamp beneath brooding storm clouds. Their pristine white feathers are ruffled by the wind, their long, graceful necks twisting and tangling in a savage fashion as they fiercely peck at each other with dagger-sharp yellow beaks. Their powerful wings flap chaotically, hitting the water and sending up showers of water mixed with mud. With each violent twist and struggle, tufts of delicate white feathers are torn from their bodies, dancing and swirling in the strong wind like a sudden, tragic snowstorm against the backdrop of a deep gray sky. The scene is bathed in a cold, diffuse natural light, accentuating the stark contrast between the white feathers and the darkness, creating an atmosphere of raw, tense, and tragic beauty.", + "seed": 11071, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_6/index_9835_seed_11071_dp_12_rank_24_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.07500166334211826, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07500166334211826, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.85, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07500166334211826, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two white egrets visible in the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the egrets engaged in a struggle involving pecking and twisting necks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting the murky shallows of a swamp beneath storm clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in slow motion with a camera slowly zooming in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are tufts of white feathers torn from the birds and swirling in the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.021309703588485718 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8963096141815186 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.021309703588485718, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.021309703588485718, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15620768070220947, + 0.08906357735395432, + 0.04438095912337303, + 0.10955631732940674, + 0.10663717240095139, + 0.16631987690925598, + 0.169748455286026, + 0.012669251300394535, + 0.032552748918533325, + 0.11286395788192749 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.021309703588485718 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two white egrets visible in the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the egrets engaged in a struggle involving pecking and twisting necks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting the murky shallows of a swamp beneath storm clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in slow motion with a camera slowly zooming in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are tufts of white feathers torn from the birds and swirling in the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029814520850777626 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298144817352295 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029814520850777626, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029814520850777626, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13857501745224, + 0.07503078132867813, + 0.13980033993721008, + 0.14635828137397766, + 0.03139118850231171, + 0.12306665629148483, + 0.1599944531917572, + 0.03807798773050308, + 0.039386775344610214, + 0.10831855237483978 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029814520850777626 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two white egrets visible in the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the egrets engaged in a struggle involving pecking and twisting necks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting the murky shallows of a swamp beneath storm clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in slow motion with a camera slowly zooming in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are tufts of white feathers torn from the birds and swirling in the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0549544095993042 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299545288085938 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0549544095993042, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0549544095993042, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10139107704162598, + 0.09537673741579056, + 0.07697927206754684, + 0.15602655708789825, + 0.13088339567184448, + 0.14331091940402985, + 0.09048601984977722, + 0.027817320078611374, + 0.0558152012526989, + 0.12191350013017654 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0549544095993042 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two white egrets visible in the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the egrets engaged in a struggle involving pecking and twisting necks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting the murky shallows of a swamp beneath storm clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in slow motion with a camera slowly zooming in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are tufts of white feathers torn from the birds and swirling in the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.179883673787117 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8048837184906006 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.179883673787117, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.179883673787117, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15394365787506104, + 0.03952595591545105, + 0.06252462416887283, + 0.17939649522304535, + 0.04110991209745407, + 0.23163917660713196, + 0.03991638869047165, + 0.05326296016573906, + 0.09516700357198715, + 0.10351385176181793 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.179883673787117 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two white egrets visible in the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the egrets engaged in a struggle involving pecking and twisting necks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting the murky shallows of a swamp beneath storm clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in slow motion with a camera slowly zooming in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are tufts of white feathers torn from the birds and swirling in the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08904600888490677 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.464046001434326 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08904600888490677, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08904600888490677, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.109698586165905, + 0.03749818727374077, + 0.05844810977578163, + 0.10761591047048569, + 0.06371262669563293, + 0.17596577107906342, + 0.09888938814401627, + 0.06713185459375381, + 0.07648231834173203, + 0.20455728471279144 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08904600888490677 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow-motion medium close-up shot from a horizontal angle, the camera slowly zooming in, focuses on two egrets locked in a fierce struggle in the murky shallows of a swamp beneath brooding storm clouds. Their pristine white feathers are ruffled by the wind, their long, graceful necks twisting and tangling in a savage fashion as they fiercely peck at each other with dagger-sharp yellow beaks. Their powerful wings flap chaotically, hitting the water and sending up showers of water mixed with mud. With each violent twist and struggle, tufts of delicate white feathers are torn from their bodies, dancing and swirling in the strong wind like a sudden, tragic snowstorm against the backdrop of a deep gray sky. The scene is bathed in a cold, diffuse natural light, accentuating the stark contrast between the white feathers and the darkness, creating an atmosphere of raw, tense, and tragic beauty.", + "seed": 11072, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_6/index_9835_seed_11072_dp_12_rank_24_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.04243595562875271, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04243595562875271, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.25, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04243595562875271, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two white egrets visible in the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the egrets engaged in a struggle involving pecking and twisting necks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting the murky shallows of a swamp beneath storm clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in slow motion with a camera slowly zooming in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are tufts of white feathers torn from the birds and swirling in the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02700130268931389 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.65200138092041 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02700130268931389, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02700130268931389, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09155317395925522, + 0.01430719718337059, + 0.022952914237976074, + 0.05072782188653946, + 0.050371203571558, + 0.6158129572868347, + 0.047906506806612015, + 0.03586201369762421, + 0.01069326139986515, + 0.0598129965364933 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02700130268931389 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two white egrets visible in the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the egrets engaged in a struggle involving pecking and twisting necks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting the murky shallows of a swamp beneath storm clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in slow motion with a camera slowly zooming in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are tufts of white feathers torn from the birds and swirling in the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023305892944335938 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773305892944336 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023305892944335938, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023305892944335938, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.028508078306913376, + 0.028712857514619827, + 0.018587751314044, + 0.011241521686315536, + 0.018820468336343765, + 0.8269640207290649, + 0.02616056799888611, + 0.016899369657039642, + 0.005383445881307125, + 0.018721939995884895 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023305892944335938 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two white egrets visible in the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the egrets engaged in a struggle involving pecking and twisting necks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting the murky shallows of a swamp beneath storm clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in slow motion with a camera slowly zooming in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are tufts of white feathers torn from the birds and swirling in the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029799478128552437 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529799461364746 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029799478128552437, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029799478128552437, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.053751103579998016, + 0.01469358429312706, + 0.015948187559843063, + 0.0037234476767480373, + 0.013138475827872753, + 0.7673975229263306, + 0.11298445612192154, + 0.009805218316614628, + 0.0031503094360232353, + 0.0054076844826340675 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029799478128552437 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two white egrets visible in the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the egrets engaged in a struggle involving pecking and twisting necks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting the murky shallows of a swamp beneath storm clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in slow motion with a camera slowly zooming in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are tufts of white feathers torn from the birds and swirling in the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07002414762973785 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695024251937866 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07002414762973785, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07002414762973785, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04359228536486626, + 0.020431147888302803, + 0.03729918599128723, + 0.01708713173866272, + 0.03198012337088585, + 0.6251696348190308, + 0.15622057020664215, + 0.025616155937314034, + 0.031584568321704865, + 0.011019164696335793 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07002414762973785 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two white egrets visible in the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the egrets engaged in a struggle involving pecking and twisting necks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting the murky shallows of a swamp beneath storm clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in slow motion with a camera slowly zooming in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are tufts of white feathers torn from the birds and swirling in the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.062048956751823425 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.81204891204834 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.062048956751823425, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.062048956751823425, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12894903123378754, + 0.06609797477722168, + 0.07286225259304047, + 0.01834309659898281, + 0.030866654589772224, + 0.3424568176269531, + 0.24400489032268524, + 0.03633381426334381, + 0.010982762090861797, + 0.04910273849964142 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.062048956751823425 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow-motion medium close-up shot from a horizontal angle, the camera slowly zooming in, focuses on two egrets locked in a fierce struggle in the murky shallows of a swamp beneath brooding storm clouds. Their pristine white feathers are ruffled by the wind, their long, graceful necks twisting and tangling in a savage fashion as they fiercely peck at each other with dagger-sharp yellow beaks. Their powerful wings flap chaotically, hitting the water and sending up showers of water mixed with mud. With each violent twist and struggle, tufts of delicate white feathers are torn from their bodies, dancing and swirling in the strong wind like a sudden, tragic snowstorm against the backdrop of a deep gray sky. The scene is bathed in a cold, diffuse natural light, accentuating the stark contrast between the white feathers and the darkness, creating an atmosphere of raw, tense, and tragic beauty.", + "seed": 11073, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_6/index_9835_seed_11073_dp_13_rank_26_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.10370071455836297, + "vlm_logprob": -0.10370071455836297, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.525, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.10370071455836297, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two white egrets visible in the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the egrets engaged in a struggle involving pecking and twisting necks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting the murky shallows of a swamp beneath storm clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in slow motion with a camera slowly zooming in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are tufts of white feathers torn from the birds and swirling in the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05569298192858696 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9306929111480713 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05569298192858696, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05569298192858696, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23127533495426178, + 0.06667888909578323, + 0.06197967380285263, + 0.06761801242828369, + 0.1651393324136734, + 0.039281588047742844, + 0.1161116436123848, + 0.03630586341023445, + 0.15539810061454773, + 0.06021159142255783 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05569298192858696 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two white egrets visible in the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the egrets engaged in a struggle involving pecking and twisting necks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting the murky shallows of a swamp beneath storm clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in slow motion with a camera slowly zooming in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are tufts of white feathers torn from the birds and swirling in the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03811875730752945 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288118839263916 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03811875730752945, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03811875730752945, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14433208107948303, + 0.029736889526247978, + 0.08000488579273224, + 0.11794186383485794, + 0.1782488375902176, + 0.04293270409107208, + 0.13541360199451447, + 0.12576915323734283, + 0.08891858160495758, + 0.05670136585831642 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03811875730752945 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two white egrets visible in the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the egrets engaged in a struggle involving pecking and twisting necks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting the murky shallows of a swamp beneath storm clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in slow motion with a camera slowly zooming in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are tufts of white feathers torn from the birds and swirling in the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04305300861597061 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168052911758423 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04305300861597061, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04305300861597061, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1910892277956009, + 0.08414410799741745, + 0.06185919791460037, + 0.11687135696411133, + 0.04070990905165672, + 0.15029804408550262, + 0.23157450556755066, + 0.012110859155654907, + 0.08586157113313675, + 0.025481240823864937 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04305300861597061 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two white egrets visible in the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the egrets engaged in a struggle involving pecking and twisting necks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting the murky shallows of a swamp beneath storm clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in slow motion with a camera slowly zooming in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are tufts of white feathers torn from the birds and swirling in the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2813228964805603 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.406322956085205 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2813228964805603, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2813228964805603, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15818555653095245, + 0.05410291999578476, + 0.09426771849393845, + 0.09375458210706711, + 0.19204582273960114, + 0.09181225299835205, + 0.12876231968402863, + 0.04521738365292549, + 0.09175796061754227, + 0.05009349808096886 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2813228964805603 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two white egrets visible in the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the egrets engaged in a struggle involving pecking and twisting necks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting the murky shallows of a swamp beneath storm clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in slow motion with a camera slowly zooming in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are tufts of white feathers torn from the birds and swirling in the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10031592845916748 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.350316047668457 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10031592845916748, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10031592845916748, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14418087899684906, + 0.04031941667199135, + 0.07196152210235596, + 0.12650863826274872, + 0.21905842423439026, + 0.08359579741954803, + 0.13715746998786926, + 0.050954289734363556, + 0.10244283080101013, + 0.023820649832487106 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10031592845916748 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow-motion medium close-up shot from a horizontal angle, the camera slowly zooming in, focuses on two egrets locked in a fierce struggle in the murky shallows of a swamp beneath brooding storm clouds. Their pristine white feathers are ruffled by the wind, their long, graceful necks twisting and tangling in a savage fashion as they fiercely peck at each other with dagger-sharp yellow beaks. Their powerful wings flap chaotically, hitting the water and sending up showers of water mixed with mud. With each violent twist and struggle, tufts of delicate white feathers are torn from their bodies, dancing and swirling in the strong wind like a sudden, tragic snowstorm against the backdrop of a deep gray sky. The scene is bathed in a cold, diffuse natural light, accentuating the stark contrast between the white feathers and the darkness, creating an atmosphere of raw, tense, and tragic beauty.", + "seed": 11074, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_6/index_9835_seed_11074_dp_13_rank_26_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.13324899077415467, + "vlm_logprob": -0.13324899077415467, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.075, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.13324899077415467, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two white egrets visible in the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the egrets engaged in a struggle involving pecking and twisting necks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting the murky shallows of a swamp beneath storm clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in slow motion with a camera slowly zooming in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are tufts of white feathers torn from the birds and swirling in the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.044781774282455444 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1697816848754883 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.044781774282455444, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.044781774282455444, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.311246395111084, + 0.0762682557106018, + 0.03877543658018112, + 0.12103971838951111, + 0.11842577904462814, + 0.06765182316303253, + 0.04034584015607834, + 0.06531848758459091, + 0.05476323887705803, + 0.1061650738120079 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.044781774282455444 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two white egrets visible in the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the egrets engaged in a struggle involving pecking and twisting necks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting the murky shallows of a swamp beneath storm clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in slow motion with a camera slowly zooming in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are tufts of white feathers torn from the birds and swirling in the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12705393135547638 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.12705397605896 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12705393135547638, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12705393135547638, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2189864218235016, + 0.04222484305500984, + 0.06386890262365341, + 0.05829860642552376, + 0.251165509223938, + 0.052751798182725906, + 0.03867405280470848, + 0.056440163403749466, + 0.1692970097064972, + 0.048292625695466995 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12705393135547638 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two white egrets visible in the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the egrets engaged in a struggle involving pecking and twisting necks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting the murky shallows of a swamp beneath storm clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in slow motion with a camera slowly zooming in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are tufts of white feathers torn from the birds and swirling in the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20157355070114136 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7015736103057861 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20157355070114136, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20157355070114136, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.37515926361083984, + 0.04377897456288338, + 0.19847163558006287, + 0.06078470125794411, + 0.04600096866488457, + 0.07663051038980484, + 0.0533580407500267, + 0.041776761412620544, + 0.0663895308971405, + 0.03764965385198593 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20157355070114136 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two white egrets visible in the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the egrets engaged in a struggle involving pecking and twisting necks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting the murky shallows of a swamp beneath storm clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in slow motion with a camera slowly zooming in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are tufts of white feathers torn from the birds and swirling in the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11293628811836243 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.23793625831604 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11293628811836243, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11293628811836243, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09321732074022293, + 0.023003358393907547, + 0.07647822052240372, + 0.17011244595050812, + 0.11273236572742462, + 0.15077851712703705, + 0.10226049274206161, + 0.10942205041646957, + 0.10232020914554596, + 0.05967501550912857 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11293628811836243 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two white egrets visible in the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the egrets engaged in a struggle involving pecking and twisting necks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting the murky shallows of a swamp beneath storm clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in slow motion with a camera slowly zooming in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are tufts of white feathers torn from the birds and swirling in the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1798994094133377 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8048994541168213 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1798994094133377, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1798994094133377, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17089027166366577, + 0.040856849402189255, + 0.05585135519504547, + 0.04305485263466835, + 0.24350763857364655, + 0.10324905812740326, + 0.09912849217653275, + 0.06334736198186874, + 0.13437362015247345, + 0.04574042186141014 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1798994094133377 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_7/index_tensor([5616, 5616])_group_7_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_7/index_tensor([5616, 5616])_group_7_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..2883f7f6dc4467a174f43d8f9809bb9dda12837e --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_7/index_tensor([5616, 5616])_group_7_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "close-up shot, zooming in from a low angle, focuses on a fierce ancient warrior, fresh from a brutal battle. He hunches over in exhaustion, his hands straining to support his legs, clad in battle-worn metal kneepads. His massive frame trembles with heavy breathing. His long, black hair, soaked with sweat, clung to his dust- and blood-stained forehead and cheeks. His eyes are tightly closed, his brow furrowed. Each rapid breath emanates from his taut lips, a puff of cold white air that quickly dissipates in the chill morning air. His once-fine black iron armor is now covered in scratches and dents from the blows of swords and axes. The leather bindings connecting the armor plates are stained a dark red with blood. The tattered red cape flutters feebly in the breeze. The background is a battlefield strewn with corpses and filled with smoke. Broken flags and scattered weapons are blurred in the shallow depth of field, but only the image of the soldier struggling to regain his strength in the brief silence is clearly captured. The entire scene is shrouded in the cold, gray, diffuse light of dawn, which faintly reflects on the metal edges of armor and beads of sweat on skin, creating an atmosphere of extreme exhaustion, tragedy, and a resilient vitality.", + "seed": 15284, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_7/index_5616_seed_15284_dp_14_rank_28_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.03777662301436067, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03777662301436067, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.85, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03777662301436067, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focusing on an ancient warrior?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera zooming in from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior hunched over with hands supporting his legs in exhaustion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior wearing battle-worn black iron armor with blood-stained leather bindings and a tattered red cape?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a battlefield with corpses, smoke, and blurred broken flags/weapons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.039580415934324265 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2895803451538086 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.039580415934324265, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.039580415934324265, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10134364664554596, + 0.10504337400197983, + 0.0560419000685215, + 0.08464035391807556, + 0.10735395550727844, + 0.12199845910072327, + 0.12685637176036835, + 0.07760778069496155, + 0.17794807255268097, + 0.04116615653038025 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.039580415934324265 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focusing on an ancient warrior?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera zooming in from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior hunched over with hands supporting his legs in exhaustion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior wearing battle-worn black iron armor with blood-stained leather bindings and a tattered red cape?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a battlefield with corpses, smoke, and blurred broken flags/weapons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10037005692720413 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.350370168685913 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10037005692720413, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10037005692720413, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09964985400438309, + 0.09466759860515594, + 0.08880598098039627, + 0.17672646045684814, + 0.04674462229013443, + 0.09656818211078644, + 0.08356442302465439, + 0.04641743004322052, + 0.2345310002565384, + 0.03232448175549507 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10037005692720413 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focusing on an ancient warrior?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera zooming in from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior hunched over with hands supporting his legs in exhaustion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior wearing battle-worn black iron armor with blood-stained leather bindings and a tattered red cape?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a battlefield with corpses, smoke, and blurred broken flags/weapons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.038101088255643845 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881011962890625 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.038101088255643845, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.038101088255643845, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13512897491455078, + 0.17172309756278992, + 0.05460820719599724, + 0.1166110709309578, + 0.15755484998226166, + 0.07478820532560349, + 0.07782720774412155, + 0.04929421842098236, + 0.08544006198644638, + 0.07702408730983734 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.038101088255643845 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focusing on an ancient warrior?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera zooming in from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior hunched over with hands supporting his legs in exhaustion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior wearing battle-worn black iron armor with blood-stained leather bindings and a tattered red cape?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a battlefield with corpses, smoke, and blurred broken flags/weapons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006742820143699646 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.00674295425415 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006742820143699646, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006742820143699646, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14691366255283356, + 0.11649156361818314, + 0.0614548921585083, + 0.15889813005924225, + 0.15882046520709991, + 0.06279279291629791, + 0.056467097252607346, + 0.034417521208524704, + 0.0682261511683464, + 0.13551771640777588 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006742820143699646 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focusing on an ancient warrior?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera zooming in from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior hunched over with hands supporting his legs in exhaustion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior wearing battle-worn black iron armor with blood-stained leather bindings and a tattered red cape?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a battlefield with corpses, smoke, and blurred broken flags/weapons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004088733810931444 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504088878631592 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004088733810931444, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004088733810931444, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15812617540359497, + 0.07141971588134766, + 0.055093683302402496, + 0.08276516944169998, + 0.3613411486148834, + 0.05188526585698128, + 0.1321771889925003, + 0.020162466913461685, + 0.038007188588380814, + 0.029022011905908585 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004088733810931444 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up shot, zooming in from a low angle, focuses on a fierce ancient warrior, fresh from a brutal battle. He hunches over in exhaustion, his hands straining to support his legs, clad in battle-worn metal kneepads. His massive frame trembles with heavy breathing. His long, black hair, soaked with sweat, clung to his dust- and blood-stained forehead and cheeks. His eyes are tightly closed, his brow furrowed. Each rapid breath emanates from his taut lips, a puff of cold white air that quickly dissipates in the chill morning air. His once-fine black iron armor is now covered in scratches and dents from the blows of swords and axes. The leather bindings connecting the armor plates are stained a dark red with blood. The tattered red cape flutters feebly in the breeze. The background is a battlefield strewn with corpses and filled with smoke. Broken flags and scattered weapons are blurred in the shallow depth of field, but only the image of the soldier struggling to regain his strength in the brief silence is clearly captured. The entire scene is shrouded in the cold, gray, diffuse light of dawn, which faintly reflects on the metal edges of armor and beads of sweat on skin, creating an atmosphere of extreme exhaustion, tragedy, and a resilient vitality.", + "seed": 15285, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_7/index_5616_seed_15285_dp_14_rank_28_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.07452206928282976, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07452206928282976, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.85, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07452206928282976, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focusing on an ancient warrior?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera zooming in from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior hunched over with hands supporting his legs in exhaustion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior wearing battle-worn black iron armor with blood-stained leather bindings and a tattered red cape?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a battlefield with corpses, smoke, and blurred broken flags/weapons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01552237942814827 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.265522480010986 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01552237942814827, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01552237942814827, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10345885157585144, + 0.0687921792268753, + 0.21499161422252655, + 0.14238527417182922, + 0.08481348305940628, + 0.04205118864774704, + 0.10438300669193268, + 0.05007468909025192, + 0.05033797025680542, + 0.13871172070503235 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01552237942814827 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focusing on an ancient warrior?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera zooming in from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior hunched over with hands supporting his legs in exhaustion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior wearing battle-worn black iron armor with blood-stained leather bindings and a tattered red cape?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a battlefield with corpses, smoke, and blurred broken flags/weapons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.31349796056747437 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3134980201721191 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.31349796056747437, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.31349796056747437, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14914752542972565, + 0.06242765486240387, + 0.1001877710223198, + 0.06770581752061844, + 0.07609019428491592, + 0.07855444401502609, + 0.05886674299836159, + 0.05574078857898712, + 0.11654635518789291, + 0.2347327172756195 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.31349796056747437 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focusing on an ancient warrior?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera zooming in from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior hunched over with hands supporting his legs in exhaustion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior wearing battle-worn black iron armor with blood-stained leather bindings and a tattered red cape?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a battlefield with corpses, smoke, and blurred broken flags/weapons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03370363265275955 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408703565597534 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03370363265275955, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03370363265275955, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08153151720762253, + 0.15333659946918488, + 0.34079715609550476, + 0.07434619963169098, + 0.05344799533486366, + 0.06390926986932755, + 0.07044659554958344, + 0.03841809555888176, + 0.023142093792557716, + 0.10062436759471893 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03370363265275955 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focusing on an ancient warrior?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera zooming in from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior hunched over with hands supporting his legs in exhaustion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior wearing battle-worn black iron armor with blood-stained leather bindings and a tattered red cape?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a battlefield with corpses, smoke, and blurred broken flags/weapons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004640880040824413 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379641056060791 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004640880040824413, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004640880040824413, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07291651517152786, + 0.12914469838142395, + 0.15788421034812927, + 0.11003292351961136, + 0.1747937649488449, + 0.16338883340358734, + 0.07289733737707138, + 0.035716909915208817, + 0.021326271817088127, + 0.061898574233055115 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004640880040824413 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focusing on an ancient warrior?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera zooming in from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior hunched over with hands supporting his legs in exhaustion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior wearing battle-worn black iron armor with blood-stained leather bindings and a tattered red cape?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a battlefield with corpses, smoke, and blurred broken flags/weapons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005245493724942207 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255245685577393 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005245493724942207, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005245493724942207, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1597946137189865, + 0.14552029967308044, + 0.08071742206811905, + 0.06766244024038315, + 0.17414230108261108, + 0.10389622300863266, + 0.033097025007009506, + 0.09430307894945145, + 0.054278407245874405, + 0.08658821135759354 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005245493724942207 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up shot, zooming in from a low angle, focuses on a fierce ancient warrior, fresh from a brutal battle. He hunches over in exhaustion, his hands straining to support his legs, clad in battle-worn metal kneepads. His massive frame trembles with heavy breathing. His long, black hair, soaked with sweat, clung to his dust- and blood-stained forehead and cheeks. His eyes are tightly closed, his brow furrowed. Each rapid breath emanates from his taut lips, a puff of cold white air that quickly dissipates in the chill morning air. His once-fine black iron armor is now covered in scratches and dents from the blows of swords and axes. The leather bindings connecting the armor plates are stained a dark red with blood. The tattered red cape flutters feebly in the breeze. The background is a battlefield strewn with corpses and filled with smoke. Broken flags and scattered weapons are blurred in the shallow depth of field, but only the image of the soldier struggling to regain his strength in the brief silence is clearly captured. The entire scene is shrouded in the cold, gray, diffuse light of dawn, which faintly reflects on the metal edges of armor and beads of sweat on skin, creating an atmosphere of extreme exhaustion, tragedy, and a resilient vitality.", + "seed": 15286, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_7/index_5616_seed_15286_dp_15_rank_30_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.033067049086093904, + "vlm_logprob": -0.033067049086093904, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.374999976158142, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.033067049086093904, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focusing on an ancient warrior?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera zooming in from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior hunched over with hands supporting his legs in exhaustion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior wearing battle-worn black iron armor with blood-stained leather bindings and a tattered red cape?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a battlefield with corpses, smoke, and blurred broken flags/weapons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008444790728390217 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.008444786071777 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008444790728390217, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008444790728390217, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09404052793979645, + 0.11086802929639816, + 0.10105825960636139, + 0.022068340331315994, + 0.0667116791009903, + 0.2218083143234253, + 0.1735134720802307, + 0.0537593699991703, + 0.07398898154497147, + 0.08218301832675934 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008444790728390217 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focusing on an ancient warrior?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera zooming in from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior hunched over with hands supporting his legs in exhaustion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior wearing battle-worn black iron armor with blood-stained leather bindings and a tattered red cape?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a battlefield with corpses, smoke, and blurred broken flags/weapons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12708984315395355 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.127089738845825 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12708984315395355, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.9999998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12708984315395355, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04798298701643944, + 0.06099522486329079, + 0.11250338703393936, + 0.11102131754159927, + 0.05997064337134361, + 0.1088227704167366, + 0.2839276194572449, + 0.04878140613436699, + 0.0113226855173707, + 0.15467199683189392 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12708984315395355 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focusing on an ancient warrior?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera zooming in from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior hunched over with hands supporting his legs in exhaustion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior wearing battle-worn black iron armor with blood-stained leather bindings and a tattered red cape?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a battlefield with corpses, smoke, and blurred broken flags/weapons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02058207429945469 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955819606781006 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02058207429945469, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02058207429945469, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0974564403295517, + 0.19481955468654633, + 0.054098907858133316, + 0.09754714369773865, + 0.1466081142425537, + 0.09289022535085678, + 0.09890446811914444, + 0.017051398754119873, + 0.07022302597761154, + 0.1304006278514862 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02058207429945469 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focusing on an ancient warrior?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera zooming in from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior hunched over with hands supporting his legs in exhaustion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior wearing battle-worn black iron armor with blood-stained leather bindings and a tattered red cape?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a battlefield with corpses, smoke, and blurred broken flags/weapons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0024911104701459408 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002490997314453 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0024911104701459408, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0024911104701459408, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06920628994703293, + 0.12783217430114746, + 0.3266114890575409, + 0.08308287709951401, + 0.0600719079375267, + 0.06618843227624893, + 0.036099787801504135, + 0.01356841716915369, + 0.06632382422685623, + 0.15101487934589386 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0024911104701459408 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focusing on an ancient warrior?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera zooming in from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior hunched over with hands supporting his legs in exhaustion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior wearing battle-worn black iron armor with blood-stained leather bindings and a tattered red cape?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a battlefield with corpses, smoke, and blurred broken flags/weapons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006727426778525114 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.00672721862793 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006727426778525114, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006727426778525114, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1254645437002182, + 0.32346880435943604, + 0.3518274426460266, + 0.05736090615391731, + 0.012220252305269241, + 0.032298825681209564, + 0.041723061352968216, + 0.006540709175169468, + 0.027655232697725296, + 0.02144022472202778 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006727426778525114 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up shot, zooming in from a low angle, focuses on a fierce ancient warrior, fresh from a brutal battle. He hunches over in exhaustion, his hands straining to support his legs, clad in battle-worn metal kneepads. His massive frame trembles with heavy breathing. His long, black hair, soaked with sweat, clung to his dust- and blood-stained forehead and cheeks. His eyes are tightly closed, his brow furrowed. Each rapid breath emanates from his taut lips, a puff of cold white air that quickly dissipates in the chill morning air. His once-fine black iron armor is now covered in scratches and dents from the blows of swords and axes. The leather bindings connecting the armor plates are stained a dark red with blood. The tattered red cape flutters feebly in the breeze. The background is a battlefield strewn with corpses and filled with smoke. Broken flags and scattered weapons are blurred in the shallow depth of field, but only the image of the soldier struggling to regain his strength in the brief silence is clearly captured. The entire scene is shrouded in the cold, gray, diffuse light of dawn, which faintly reflects on the metal edges of armor and beads of sweat on skin, creating an atmosphere of extreme exhaustion, tragedy, and a resilient vitality.", + "seed": 15287, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_7/index_5616_seed_15287_dp_15_rank_30_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.09124334342777729, + "vlm_logprob": -0.09124334342777729, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.95, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.09124334342777729, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focusing on an ancient warrior?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera zooming in from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior hunched over with hands supporting his legs in exhaustion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior wearing battle-worn black iron armor with blood-stained leather bindings and a tattered red cape?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a battlefield with corpses, smoke, and blurred broken flags/weapons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020653657615184784 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.02065372467041 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020653657615184784, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020653657615184784, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14241038262844086, + 0.0561099648475647, + 0.10420072823762894, + 0.062217094004154205, + 0.10700719803571701, + 0.08460966497659683, + 0.07997888326644897, + 0.1310860514640808, + 0.06165511906147003, + 0.17072494328022003 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020653657615184784 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focusing on an ancient warrior?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera zooming in from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior hunched over with hands supporting his legs in exhaustion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior wearing battle-worn black iron armor with blood-stained leather bindings and a tattered red cape?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a battlefield with corpses, smoke, and blurred broken flags/weapons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.38711485266685486 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1371148824691772 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.38711485266685486, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.38711485266685486, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14192530512809753, + 0.07066498696804047, + 0.062201131135225296, + 0.12660428881645203, + 0.050406891852617264, + 0.08607933670282364, + 0.10732658207416534, + 0.08750475198030472, + 0.24245616793632507, + 0.024830609560012817 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.38711485266685486 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focusing on an ancient warrior?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera zooming in from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior hunched over with hands supporting his legs in exhaustion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior wearing battle-worn black iron armor with blood-stained leather bindings and a tattered red cape?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a battlefield with corpses, smoke, and blurred broken flags/weapons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04306042939424515 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168060541152954 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04306042939424515, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04306042939424515, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06847342103719711, + 0.07965755462646484, + 0.03994925692677498, + 0.06196434423327446, + 0.045206066220998764, + 0.13961900770664215, + 0.10030179470777512, + 0.08026561886072159, + 0.3152819275856018, + 0.06928092986345291 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04306042939424515 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focusing on an ancient warrior?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera zooming in from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior hunched over with hands supporting his legs in exhaustion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior wearing battle-worn black iron armor with blood-stained leather bindings and a tattered red cape?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a battlefield with corpses, smoke, and blurred broken flags/weapons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003195539116859436 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753195762634277 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003195539116859436, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003195539116859436, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1167212650179863, + 0.04148221015930176, + 0.0511697418987751, + 0.12702783942222595, + 0.07178021222352982, + 0.054381974041461945, + 0.05424637719988823, + 0.10995155572891235, + 0.07178369909524918, + 0.3014550805091858 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003195539116859436 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focusing on an ancient warrior?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera zooming in from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior hunched over with hands supporting his legs in exhaustion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior wearing battle-worn black iron armor with blood-stained leather bindings and a tattered red cape?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a battlefield with corpses, smoke, and blurred broken flags/weapons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0021922383457422256 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.12719202041626 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0021922383457422256, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0021922383457422256, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2671014964580536, + 0.07081158459186554, + 0.08206535875797272, + 0.04954217001795769, + 0.04333159700036049, + 0.1415921151638031, + 0.12983815371990204, + 0.07467344403266907, + 0.07035990059375763, + 0.07068418711423874 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0021922383457422256 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_8/index_tensor([9899, 9899])_group_8_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_8/index_tensor([9899, 9899])_group_8_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..8946133340703d5a76e20d015a8936dca51b586e --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_8/index_tensor([9899, 9899])_group_8_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "Shot in mesmerizing high-frame-rate slow motion, a macro close-up pans slowly and steadily to the right across a dense cluster of vibrant purple hyacinths. The entire scene is bathed in a hazy, synthetic mauve light, causing the waxy, bell-shaped florets to glow from within and causing the tiny droplets of nectar on their surfaces to shimmer like microscopic jewels. A swarm of bees engages in a frenzied, balletic performance, their furry yellow and black bodies depicted in exquisite detail. The incredibly fluid slow motion transforms their frantic dance into a cinematic spectacle: one bee hovers gracefully, its translucent wings gently blurring before delicately alighting on a petal; another buries its head deep into the blossom, its movements deliberate and focused; a third, its legs coated in golden pollen, methodically crawls from one floret to the next. The dark, blurred void of the background enhances the stylized aesthetic of 1980s Miami and makes the electric pinks and deep purples pop with a surreal intensity, creating a hypnotic and dreamlike atmosphere that feels both natural and artificially beautiful.", + "seed": 29918, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_8/index_9899_seed_29918_dp_16_rank_32_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.27693021297454834, + "vlm_logprob": -0.27693021297454834, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.525000011920929, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.27693021297454834, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up of a dense cluster of vibrant purple hyacinths?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in a hazy, synthetic mauve light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are bees depicted with furry yellow and black bodies in exquisite detail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show specific bee behaviors including one hovering, one burying its head in a blossom, and one crawling with golden pollen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dark, blurred void that enhances a stylized 1980s Miami aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01593216322362423 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.265932083129883 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01593216322362423, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01593216322362423, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25439542531967163, + 0.07425855845212936, + 0.131885826587677, + 0.10701481252908707, + 0.1341736912727356, + 0.07164475321769714, + 0.03795894607901573, + 0.08936757594347, + 0.04484804347157478, + 0.054452408105134964 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01593216322362423 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up of a dense cluster of vibrant purple hyacinths?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in a hazy, synthetic mauve light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are bees depicted with furry yellow and black bodies in exquisite detail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show specific bee behaviors including one hovering, one burying its head in a blossom, and one crawling with golden pollen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dark, blurred void that enhances a stylized 1980s Miami aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07005593925714493 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950559616088867 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07005593925714493, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07005593925714493, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09231290221214294, + 0.09307174384593964, + 0.13088272511959076, + 0.06786543130874634, + 0.22374382615089417, + 0.08383403718471527, + 0.06965860724449158, + 0.10618865489959717, + 0.09666186571121216, + 0.03578020632266998 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 2, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07005593925714493 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up of a dense cluster of vibrant purple hyacinths?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in a hazy, synthetic mauve light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are bees depicted with furry yellow and black bodies in exquisite detail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show specific bee behaviors including one hovering, one burying its head in a blossom, and one crawling with golden pollen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dark, blurred void that enhances a stylized 1980s Miami aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04866760969161987 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486676692962646 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04866760969161987, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04866760969161987, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06890842318534851, + 0.0913422554731369, + 0.1644648313522339, + 0.3046884536743164, + 0.12257367372512817, + 0.053665537387132645, + 0.0384540930390358, + 0.0972677543759346, + 0.033713024109601974, + 0.02492194063961506 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04866760969161987 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up of a dense cluster of vibrant purple hyacinths?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in a hazy, synthetic mauve light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are bees depicted with furry yellow and black bodies in exquisite detail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show specific bee behaviors including one hovering, one burying its head in a blossom, and one crawling with golden pollen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dark, blurred void that enhances a stylized 1980s Miami aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026368023827672005 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513681411743164 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026368023827672005, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026368023827672005, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14886973798274994, + 0.0616675466299057, + 0.16513316333293915, + 0.13536472618579865, + 0.2118598222732544, + 0.09691575914621353, + 0.03971878066658974, + 0.06517359614372253, + 0.04418792203068733, + 0.03110894002020359 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026368023827672005 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up of a dense cluster of vibrant purple hyacinths?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in a hazy, synthetic mauve light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are bees depicted with furry yellow and black bodies in exquisite detail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show specific bee behaviors including one hovering, one burying its head in a blossom, and one crawling with golden pollen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dark, blurred void that enhances a stylized 1980s Miami aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2236273288726807 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.34862738847732544 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.2236273288726807, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.8749999403953552, + "token_credit_reward": -1.2236273288726807, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2368536740541458, + 0.09797372668981552, + 0.141716867685318, + 0.07737593352794647, + 0.07421370595693588, + 0.09969419986009598, + 0.1674162894487381, + 0.048764199018478394, + 0.04200267791748047, + 0.013988730497658253 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.2236273288726807 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "Shot in mesmerizing high-frame-rate slow motion, a macro close-up pans slowly and steadily to the right across a dense cluster of vibrant purple hyacinths. The entire scene is bathed in a hazy, synthetic mauve light, causing the waxy, bell-shaped florets to glow from within and causing the tiny droplets of nectar on their surfaces to shimmer like microscopic jewels. A swarm of bees engages in a frenzied, balletic performance, their furry yellow and black bodies depicted in exquisite detail. The incredibly fluid slow motion transforms their frantic dance into a cinematic spectacle: one bee hovers gracefully, its translucent wings gently blurring before delicately alighting on a petal; another buries its head deep into the blossom, its movements deliberate and focused; a third, its legs coated in golden pollen, methodically crawls from one floret to the next. The dark, blurred void of the background enhances the stylized aesthetic of 1980s Miami and makes the electric pinks and deep purples pop with a surreal intensity, creating a hypnotic and dreamlike atmosphere that feels both natural and artificially beautiful.", + "seed": 29919, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_8/index_9899_seed_29919_dp_16_rank_32_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.23917156215757132, + "vlm_logprob": -0.23917156215757132, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.3, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.23917156215757132, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up of a dense cluster of vibrant purple hyacinths?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in a hazy, synthetic mauve light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are bees depicted with furry yellow and black bodies in exquisite detail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show specific bee behaviors including one hovering, one burying its head in a blossom, and one crawling with golden pollen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dark, blurred void that enhances a stylized 1980s Miami aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00792419072240591 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.0079240798950195 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00792419072240591, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00792419072240591, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.26272058486938477, + 0.18558374047279358, + 0.055361129343509674, + 0.04981283098459244, + 0.13189952075481415, + 0.03639610484242439, + 0.06256075948476791, + 0.02401762641966343, + 0.09395772218704224, + 0.0976899117231369 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00792419072240591 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up of a dense cluster of vibrant purple hyacinths?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in a hazy, synthetic mauve light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are bees depicted with furry yellow and black bodies in exquisite detail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show specific bee behaviors including one hovering, one burying its head in a blossom, and one crawling with golden pollen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dark, blurred void that enhances a stylized 1980s Miami aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016075992956757545 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.14107608795166 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016075992956757545, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016075992956757545, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.292977511882782, + 0.04447944089770317, + 0.05658702552318573, + 0.055053383111953735, + 0.11578468233346939, + 0.029171818867325783, + 0.044825147837400436, + 0.016213085502386093, + 0.09926481544971466, + 0.2456430196762085 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016075992956757545 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up of a dense cluster of vibrant purple hyacinths?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in a hazy, synthetic mauve light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are bees depicted with furry yellow and black bodies in exquisite detail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show specific bee behaviors including one hovering, one burying its head in a blossom, and one crawling with golden pollen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dark, blurred void that enhances a stylized 1980s Miami aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020581139251589775 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955812454223633 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020581139251589775, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020581139251589775, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20105378329753876, + 0.21071910858154297, + 0.07891281694173813, + 0.08266177028417587, + 0.05859367549419403, + 0.06690719723701477, + 0.05338078364729881, + 0.019454721361398697, + 0.07367218285799026, + 0.1546439677476883 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020581139251589775 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up of a dense cluster of vibrant purple hyacinths?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in a hazy, synthetic mauve light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are bees depicted with furry yellow and black bodies in exquisite detail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show specific bee behaviors including one hovering, one burying its head in a blossom, and one crawling with golden pollen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dark, blurred void that enhances a stylized 1980s Miami aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014200706034898758 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264200687408447 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014200706034898758, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014200706034898758, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22887225449085236, + 0.16497132182121277, + 0.04235105961561203, + 0.13668985664844513, + 0.06565795093774796, + 0.05012261122465134, + 0.04294313117861748, + 0.09775432199239731, + 0.08715732395648956, + 0.08348024636507034 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014200706034898758 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up of a dense cluster of vibrant purple hyacinths?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in a hazy, synthetic mauve light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are bees depicted with furry yellow and black bodies in exquisite detail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show specific bee behaviors including one hovering, one burying its head in a blossom, and one crawling with golden pollen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dark, blurred void that enhances a stylized 1980s Miami aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1370757818222046 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3870757520198822 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.1370757818222046, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -1.1370757818222046, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18784035742282867, + 0.05927728861570358, + 0.10944006592035294, + 0.06778550893068314, + 0.2859981060028076, + 0.05563697591423988, + 0.030813947319984436, + 0.03762402385473251, + 0.03883504867553711, + 0.1267486959695816 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.1370757818222046 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "Shot in mesmerizing high-frame-rate slow motion, a macro close-up pans slowly and steadily to the right across a dense cluster of vibrant purple hyacinths. The entire scene is bathed in a hazy, synthetic mauve light, causing the waxy, bell-shaped florets to glow from within and causing the tiny droplets of nectar on their surfaces to shimmer like microscopic jewels. A swarm of bees engages in a frenzied, balletic performance, their furry yellow and black bodies depicted in exquisite detail. The incredibly fluid slow motion transforms their frantic dance into a cinematic spectacle: one bee hovers gracefully, its translucent wings gently blurring before delicately alighting on a petal; another buries its head deep into the blossom, its movements deliberate and focused; a third, its legs coated in golden pollen, methodically crawls from one floret to the next. The dark, blurred void of the background enhances the stylized aesthetic of 1980s Miami and makes the electric pinks and deep purples pop with a surreal intensity, creating a hypnotic and dreamlike atmosphere that feels both natural and artificially beautiful.", + "seed": 29920, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_8/index_9899_seed_29920_dp_17_rank_34_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.3726247735321522, + "vlm_logprob": -0.3726247735321522, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.025, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.3726247735321522, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up of a dense cluster of vibrant purple hyacinths?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in a hazy, synthetic mauve light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are bees depicted with furry yellow and black bodies in exquisite detail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show specific bee behaviors including one hovering, one burying its head in a blossom, and one crawling with golden pollen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dark, blurred void that enhances a stylized 1980s Miami aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.025778142735362053 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.77577805519104 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.025778142735362053, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.025778142735362053, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12906110286712646, + 0.10729993134737015, + 0.21896182000637054, + 0.16260702908039093, + 0.052410971373319626, + 0.06572294235229492, + 0.07118478417396545, + 0.08359914273023605, + 0.04471511021256447, + 0.06443723291158676 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.025778142735362053 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up of a dense cluster of vibrant purple hyacinths?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in a hazy, synthetic mauve light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are bees depicted with furry yellow and black bodies in exquisite detail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show specific bee behaviors including one hovering, one burying its head in a blossom, and one crawling with golden pollen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dark, blurred void that enhances a stylized 1980s Miami aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08907097578048706 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.464071035385132 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08907097578048706, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08907097578048706, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24562394618988037, + 0.13433359563350677, + 0.17569886147975922, + 0.06921596080064774, + 0.04527425765991211, + 0.10593666136264801, + 0.06135701388120651, + 0.03776772692799568, + 0.029196659103035927, + 0.0955953374505043 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08907097578048706 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up of a dense cluster of vibrant purple hyacinths?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in a hazy, synthetic mauve light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are bees depicted with furry yellow and black bodies in exquisite detail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show specific bee behaviors including one hovering, one burying its head in a blossom, and one crawling with golden pollen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dark, blurred void that enhances a stylized 1980s Miami aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22557589411735535 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6005759239196777 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.22557589411735535, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.22557589411735535, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09456653147935867, + 0.060934558510780334, + 0.17020823061466217, + 0.23181535303592682, + 0.03260686621069908, + 0.049083810299634933, + 0.0389544777572155, + 0.08085045218467712, + 0.03017948567867279, + 0.21080029010772705 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.22557589411735535 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up of a dense cluster of vibrant purple hyacinths?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in a hazy, synthetic mauve light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are bees depicted with furry yellow and black bodies in exquisite detail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show specific bee behaviors including one hovering, one burying its head in a blossom, and one crawling with golden pollen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dark, blurred void that enhances a stylized 1980s Miami aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020600175485014915 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8956000804901123 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020600175485014915, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020600175485014915, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07726382464170456, + 0.041383784264326096, + 0.10175948590040207, + 0.1502494215965271, + 0.04504651203751564, + 0.027470506727695465, + 0.054246339946985245, + 0.07899153232574463, + 0.056410904973745346, + 0.3671777546405792 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020600175485014915 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up of a dense cluster of vibrant purple hyacinths?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in a hazy, synthetic mauve light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are bees depicted with furry yellow and black bodies in exquisite detail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show specific bee behaviors including one hovering, one burying its head in a blossom, and one crawling with golden pollen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dark, blurred void that enhances a stylized 1980s Miami aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5020986795425415 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2520986795425415 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.5020986795425415, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -1.5020986795425415, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1731976419687271, + 0.08899019658565521, + 0.0894157662987709, + 0.19134521484375, + 0.10363990068435669, + 0.12126511335372925, + 0.06280999630689621, + 0.05380139872431755, + 0.02711302973330021, + 0.08842168003320694 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.5020986795425415 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "Shot in mesmerizing high-frame-rate slow motion, a macro close-up pans slowly and steadily to the right across a dense cluster of vibrant purple hyacinths. The entire scene is bathed in a hazy, synthetic mauve light, causing the waxy, bell-shaped florets to glow from within and causing the tiny droplets of nectar on their surfaces to shimmer like microscopic jewels. A swarm of bees engages in a frenzied, balletic performance, their furry yellow and black bodies depicted in exquisite detail. The incredibly fluid slow motion transforms their frantic dance into a cinematic spectacle: one bee hovers gracefully, its translucent wings gently blurring before delicately alighting on a petal; another buries its head deep into the blossom, its movements deliberate and focused; a third, its legs coated in golden pollen, methodically crawls from one floret to the next. The dark, blurred void of the background enhances the stylized aesthetic of 1980s Miami and makes the electric pinks and deep purples pop with a surreal intensity, creating a hypnotic and dreamlike atmosphere that feels both natural and artificially beautiful.", + "seed": 29921, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_8/index_9899_seed_29921_dp_17_rank_34_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.053591414168477056, + "vlm_logprob": -0.053591414168477056, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.725, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.053591414168477056, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up of a dense cluster of vibrant purple hyacinths?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in a hazy, synthetic mauve light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are bees depicted with furry yellow and black bodies in exquisite detail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show specific bee behaviors including one hovering, one burying its head in a blossom, and one crawling with golden pollen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dark, blurred void that enhances a stylized 1980s Miami aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004543576389551163 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.629543781280518 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004543576389551163, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004543576389551163, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15668238699436188, + 0.040137190371751785, + 0.04895702376961708, + 0.07173386216163635, + 0.04980362951755524, + 0.16110801696777344, + 0.024728288874030113, + 0.19262336194515228, + 0.10220444947481155, + 0.15202182531356812 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004543576389551163 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up of a dense cluster of vibrant purple hyacinths?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in a hazy, synthetic mauve light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are bees depicted with furry yellow and black bodies in exquisite detail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show specific bee behaviors including one hovering, one burying its head in a blossom, and one crawling with golden pollen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dark, blurred void that enhances a stylized 1980s Miami aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016076110303401947 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.14107608795166 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016076110303401947, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016076110303401947, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.37512558698654175, + 0.04256118834018707, + 0.035018328577280045, + 0.02234564907848835, + 0.04094245657324791, + 0.06866580247879028, + 0.0346900150179863, + 0.19487017393112183, + 0.09642679989337921, + 0.08935396373271942 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016076110303401947 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up of a dense cluster of vibrant purple hyacinths?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in a hazy, synthetic mauve light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are bees depicted with furry yellow and black bodies in exquisite detail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show specific bee behaviors including one hovering, one burying its head in a blossom, and one crawling with golden pollen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dark, blurred void that enhances a stylized 1980s Miami aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05494098365306854 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929940938949585 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05494098365306854, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05494098365306854, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14866214990615845, + 0.050369180738925934, + 0.05194156616926193, + 0.12328886985778809, + 0.17141036689281464, + 0.06743884086608887, + 0.048791538923978806, + 0.18725520372390747, + 0.015259262174367905, + 0.13558299839496613 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05494098365306854 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up of a dense cluster of vibrant purple hyacinths?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in a hazy, synthetic mauve light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are bees depicted with furry yellow and black bodies in exquisite detail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show specific bee behaviors including one hovering, one burying its head in a blossom, and one crawling with golden pollen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dark, blurred void that enhances a stylized 1980s Miami aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012544183060526848 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.38754415512085 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012544183060526848, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012544183060526848, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14085473120212555, + 0.059758566319942474, + 0.048533421009778976, + 0.08330389857292175, + 0.09233343601226807, + 0.07152262330055237, + 0.07360440492630005, + 0.15216240286827087, + 0.14385905861854553, + 0.13406744599342346 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012544183060526848 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up of a dense cluster of vibrant purple hyacinths?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in a hazy, synthetic mauve light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are bees depicted with furry yellow and black bodies in exquisite detail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show specific bee behaviors including one hovering, one burying its head in a blossom, and one crawling with golden pollen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dark, blurred void that enhances a stylized 1980s Miami aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1798522174358368 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8048522472381592 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1798522174358368, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1798522174358368, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.26938289403915405, + 0.04253336414694786, + 0.035629041492938995, + 0.02803456038236618, + 0.03026948682963848, + 0.06853070855140686, + 0.017999785020947456, + 0.15061236917972565, + 0.05728847533464432, + 0.29971927404403687 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1798522174358368 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_9/index_tensor([6655, 6655])_group_9_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_9/index_tensor([6655, 6655])_group_9_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..654074415abd87f2ca032e0358ab00e3cff9a606 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_9/index_tensor([6655, 6655])_group_9_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "low-angle tracking shot follows a sleek, driverless car, the camera moving smoothly to the right in sync with the vehicle. The car glides forward with almost frictionless grace along a rain-soaked, futuristic city street. Its body is constructed of a smooth, obsidian-like composite material, its windows are completely opaque, dark glass that blends seamlessly into the car, while thin blue LED strips embedded in the sides and wheels outline its shape against the darkness. Towering skyscrapers flank the street, their glass facades gleaming with massive, ever-changing, dynamic holographic billboards. A thin, light-stained mist hangs in the air. The only source of light is the vibrant neon lights, transforming the car's sleek exterior into a flowing mirror, reflecting distorted, elongated reflections of the surrounding buildings and billboards in a palette of deep blue-violet and magenta. The car's movement trajectory is precise and stable, without any bumps or hesitation. The wheels turn silently on the slippery road, splashing only tiny, neon-lit water splashes. The whole scene is full of cyberpunk aesthetics, creating a surreal digital art atmosphere that is both highly developed and slightly alienated.", + "seed": 22474, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_9/index_6655_seed_22474_dp_18_rank_36_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.010225724708288909, + "vlm_logprob": -0.010225724708288909, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.7, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.010225724708288909, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, driverless car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the car's body made of a smooth, obsidian-like composite material with opaque dark glass windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are thin blue LED strips visible embedded in the sides and wheels of the car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a rain-soaked futuristic city street with towering skyscrapers displaying dynamic holographic billboards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle tracking shot moving smoothly to the right in sync with the vehicle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.010271662846207619 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.6352715492248535 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.010271662846207619, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.010271662846207619, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08831535279750824, + 0.06657672673463821, + 0.024722903966903687, + 0.06473549455404282, + 0.07176254689693451, + 0.024926714599132538, + 0.05613013729453087, + 0.19514477252960205, + 0.377702534198761, + 0.029982799664139748 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.010271662846207619 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, driverless car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the car's body made of a smooth, obsidian-like composite material with opaque dark glass windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are thin blue LED strips visible embedded in the sides and wheels of the car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a rain-soaked futuristic city street with towering skyscrapers displaying dynamic holographic billboards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle tracking shot moving smoothly to the right in sync with the vehicle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016080450266599655 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141080379486084 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016080450266599655, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016080450266599655, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.059753745794296265, + 0.1663694530725479, + 0.05318351462483406, + 0.08053631335496902, + 0.048796169459819794, + 0.029464514926075935, + 0.08396044373512268, + 0.15671713650226593, + 0.23160912096500397, + 0.08960963040590286 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016080450266599655 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, driverless car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the car's body made of a smooth, obsidian-like composite material with opaque dark glass windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are thin blue LED strips visible embedded in the sides and wheels of the car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a rain-soaked futuristic city street with towering skyscrapers displaying dynamic holographic billboards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle tracking shot moving smoothly to the right in sync with the vehicle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003615036141127348 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628614902496338 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003615036141127348, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003615036141127348, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04974493384361267, + 0.044363606721162796, + 0.026905369013547897, + 0.3588114380836487, + 0.050592124462127686, + 0.0904998928308487, + 0.036854568868875504, + 0.07745055109262466, + 0.10227102041244507, + 0.16250655055046082 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003615036141127348 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, driverless car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the car's body made of a smooth, obsidian-like composite material with opaque dark glass windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are thin blue LED strips visible embedded in the sides and wheels of the car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a rain-soaked futuristic city street with towering skyscrapers displaying dynamic holographic billboards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle tracking shot moving smoothly to the right in sync with the vehicle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012530997395515442 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.38753080368042 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012530997395515442, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012530997395515442, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05604499951004982, + 0.04509986191987991, + 0.08475092053413391, + 0.15728625655174255, + 0.08002296090126038, + 0.10296459496021271, + 0.11423559486865997, + 0.19694143533706665, + 0.07211586833000183, + 0.09053747355937958 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 3, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012530997395515442 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, driverless car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the car's body made of a smooth, obsidian-like composite material with opaque dark glass windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are thin blue LED strips visible embedded in the sides and wheels of the car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a rain-soaked futuristic city street with towering skyscrapers displaying dynamic holographic billboards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle tracking shot moving smoothly to the right in sync with the vehicle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008630476891994476 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758630275726318 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008630476891994476, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008630476891994476, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05630699545145035, + 0.09556394070386887, + 0.03917667269706726, + 0.11785541474819183, + 0.06907407939434052, + 0.08362450450658798, + 0.04032380133867264, + 0.038791995495557785, + 0.4114023745059967, + 0.04788024351000786 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008630476891994476 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle tracking shot follows a sleek, driverless car, the camera moving smoothly to the right in sync with the vehicle. The car glides forward with almost frictionless grace along a rain-soaked, futuristic city street. Its body is constructed of a smooth, obsidian-like composite material, its windows are completely opaque, dark glass that blends seamlessly into the car, while thin blue LED strips embedded in the sides and wheels outline its shape against the darkness. Towering skyscrapers flank the street, their glass facades gleaming with massive, ever-changing, dynamic holographic billboards. A thin, light-stained mist hangs in the air. The only source of light is the vibrant neon lights, transforming the car's sleek exterior into a flowing mirror, reflecting distorted, elongated reflections of the surrounding buildings and billboards in a palette of deep blue-violet and magenta. The car's movement trajectory is precise and stable, without any bumps or hesitation. The wheels turn silently on the slippery road, splashing only tiny, neon-lit water splashes. The whole scene is full of cyberpunk aesthetics, creating a surreal digital art atmosphere that is both highly developed and slightly alienated.", + "seed": 22475, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_9/index_6655_seed_22475_dp_18_rank_36_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.03121638474985957, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03121638474985957, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.05, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03121638474985957, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, driverless car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the car's body made of a smooth, obsidian-like composite material with opaque dark glass windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are thin blue LED strips visible embedded in the sides and wheels of the car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a rain-soaked futuristic city street with towering skyscrapers displaying dynamic holographic billboards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle tracking shot moving smoothly to the right in sync with the vehicle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10660326480865479 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3566031455993652 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10660326480865479, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10660326480865479, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13978515565395355, + 0.1095605418086052, + 0.034239258617162704, + 0.06238769367337227, + 0.08041281998157501, + 0.020758498460054398, + 0.05935840308666229, + 0.025580747053027153, + 0.01579400897026062, + 0.45212286710739136 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10660326480865479 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, driverless car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the car's body made of a smooth, obsidian-like composite material with opaque dark glass windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are thin blue LED strips visible embedded in the sides and wheels of the car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a rain-soaked futuristic city street with towering skyscrapers displaying dynamic holographic billboards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle tracking shot moving smoothly to the right in sync with the vehicle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020625164732336998 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895625114440918 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020625164732336998, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020625164732336998, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08597283065319061, + 0.05683116987347603, + 0.03845132887363434, + 0.06735482066869736, + 0.06022321432828903, + 0.026826977729797363, + 0.02564936690032482, + 0.04214544966816902, + 0.02650492638349533, + 0.5700398683547974 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020625164732336998 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, driverless car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the car's body made of a smooth, obsidian-like composite material with opaque dark glass windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are thin blue LED strips visible embedded in the sides and wheels of the car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a rain-soaked futuristic city street with towering skyscrapers displaying dynamic holographic billboards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle tracking shot moving smoothly to the right in sync with the vehicle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011075095273554325 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511075019836426 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011075095273554325, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011075095273554325, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12324253469705582, + 0.052562251687049866, + 0.03125334531068802, + 0.24515636265277863, + 0.02711792103946209, + 0.05323246121406555, + 0.034539103507995605, + 0.025329237803816795, + 0.029954997822642326, + 0.37761181592941284 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011075095273554325 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, driverless car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the car's body made of a smooth, obsidian-like composite material with opaque dark glass windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are thin blue LED strips visible embedded in the sides and wheels of the car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a rain-soaked futuristic city street with towering skyscrapers displaying dynamic holographic billboards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle tracking shot moving smoothly to the right in sync with the vehicle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005248814355581999 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.2552490234375 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005248814355581999, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005248814355581999, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.02477884478867054, + 0.011480797082185745, + 0.015348684042692184, + 0.019154157489538193, + 0.09862466156482697, + 0.028227834030985832, + 0.00680227717384696, + 0.009466513060033321, + 0.00735793262720108, + 0.7787583470344543 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005248814355581999 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, driverless car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the car's body made of a smooth, obsidian-like composite material with opaque dark glass windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are thin blue LED strips visible embedded in the sides and wheels of the car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a rain-soaked futuristic city street with towering skyscrapers displaying dynamic holographic billboards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle tracking shot moving smoothly to the right in sync with the vehicle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01252958457916975 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387529373168945 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01252958457916975, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01252958457916975, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18738894164562225, + 0.05138026922941208, + 0.04394981265068054, + 0.08557071536779404, + 0.1059570461511612, + 0.052952609956264496, + 0.06253766268491745, + 0.05937611311674118, + 0.06365463882684708, + 0.2872321903705597 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01252958457916975 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle tracking shot follows a sleek, driverless car, the camera moving smoothly to the right in sync with the vehicle. The car glides forward with almost frictionless grace along a rain-soaked, futuristic city street. Its body is constructed of a smooth, obsidian-like composite material, its windows are completely opaque, dark glass that blends seamlessly into the car, while thin blue LED strips embedded in the sides and wheels outline its shape against the darkness. Towering skyscrapers flank the street, their glass facades gleaming with massive, ever-changing, dynamic holographic billboards. A thin, light-stained mist hangs in the air. The only source of light is the vibrant neon lights, transforming the car's sleek exterior into a flowing mirror, reflecting distorted, elongated reflections of the surrounding buildings and billboards in a palette of deep blue-violet and magenta. The car's movement trajectory is precise and stable, without any bumps or hesitation. The wheels turn silently on the slippery road, splashing only tiny, neon-lit water splashes. The whole scene is full of cyberpunk aesthetics, creating a surreal digital art atmosphere that is both highly developed and slightly alienated.", + "seed": 22476, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_9/index_6655_seed_22476_dp_19_rank_38_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.007892649434506894, + "vlm_logprob": -0.007892649434506894, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.95, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.007892649434506894, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, driverless car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the car's body made of a smooth, obsidian-like composite material with opaque dark glass windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are thin blue LED strips visible embedded in the sides and wheels of the car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a rain-soaked futuristic city street with towering skyscrapers displaying dynamic holographic billboards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle tracking shot moving smoothly to the right in sync with the vehicle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007824012078344822 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.382823944091797 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007824012078344822, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007824012078344822, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08552998304367065, + 0.027475755661725998, + 0.4985615313053131, + 0.059048064053058624, + 0.026063235476613045, + 0.08371049165725708, + 0.059385545551776886, + 0.04931896552443504, + 0.021503208205103874, + 0.08940324187278748 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007824012078344822 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, driverless car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the car's body made of a smooth, obsidian-like composite material with opaque dark glass windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are thin blue LED strips visible embedded in the sides and wheels of the car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a rain-soaked futuristic city street with towering skyscrapers displaying dynamic holographic billboards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle tracking shot moving smoothly to the right in sync with the vehicle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0067525296472013 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.0067524909973145 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0067525296472013, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0067525296472013, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.030460814014077187, + 0.032980579882860184, + 0.49866336584091187, + 0.06678102165460587, + 0.021345088258385658, + 0.04835040494799614, + 0.15862543880939484, + 0.021150538697838783, + 0.018827512860298157, + 0.10281527042388916 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0067525296472013 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, driverless car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the car's body made of a smooth, obsidian-like composite material with opaque dark glass windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are thin blue LED strips visible embedded in the sides and wheels of the car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a rain-soaked futuristic city street with towering skyscrapers displaying dynamic holographic billboards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle tracking shot moving smoothly to the right in sync with the vehicle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008635204285383224 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.7586350440979 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008635204285383224, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008635204285383224, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10657117515802383, + 0.038093000650405884, + 0.1906118243932724, + 0.08789891749620438, + 0.05030008405447006, + 0.11877023428678513, + 0.20279154181480408, + 0.04152005910873413, + 0.08353984355926514, + 0.07990334182977676 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008635204285383224 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, driverless car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the car's body made of a smooth, obsidian-like composite material with opaque dark glass windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are thin blue LED strips visible embedded in the sides and wheels of the car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a rain-soaked futuristic city street with towering skyscrapers displaying dynamic holographic billboards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle tracking shot moving smoothly to the right in sync with the vehicle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007622915785759687 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882622718811035 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007622915785759687, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007622915785759687, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06961971521377563, + 0.07323475182056427, + 0.3387562334537506, + 0.08944786339998245, + 0.05486612021923065, + 0.06840267777442932, + 0.08646143227815628, + 0.024464916437864304, + 0.03182074800133705, + 0.16292566061019897 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007622915785759687 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, driverless car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the car's body made of a smooth, obsidian-like composite material with opaque dark glass windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are thin blue LED strips visible embedded in the sides and wheels of the car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a rain-soaked futuristic city street with towering skyscrapers displaying dynamic holographic billboards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle tracking shot moving smoothly to the right in sync with the vehicle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008628585375845432 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.7586283683776855 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008628585375845432, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008628585375845432, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.032145705074071884, + 0.018784254789352417, + 0.28620028495788574, + 0.024750756099820137, + 0.041916053742170334, + 0.09265519678592682, + 0.0860489085316658, + 0.06479544192552567, + 0.23507514595985413, + 0.11762827634811401 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008628585375845432 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle tracking shot follows a sleek, driverless car, the camera moving smoothly to the right in sync with the vehicle. The car glides forward with almost frictionless grace along a rain-soaked, futuristic city street. Its body is constructed of a smooth, obsidian-like composite material, its windows are completely opaque, dark glass that blends seamlessly into the car, while thin blue LED strips embedded in the sides and wheels outline its shape against the darkness. Towering skyscrapers flank the street, their glass facades gleaming with massive, ever-changing, dynamic holographic billboards. A thin, light-stained mist hangs in the air. The only source of light is the vibrant neon lights, transforming the car's sleek exterior into a flowing mirror, reflecting distorted, elongated reflections of the surrounding buildings and billboards in a palette of deep blue-violet and magenta. The car's movement trajectory is precise and stable, without any bumps or hesitation. The wheels turn silently on the slippery road, splashing only tiny, neon-lit water splashes. The whole scene is full of cyberpunk aesthetics, creating a surreal digital art atmosphere that is both highly developed and slightly alienated.", + "seed": 22477, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000216/group_9/index_6655_seed_22477_dp_19_rank_38_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.011105379555374384, + "vlm_logprob": -0.011105379555374384, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.675, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.011105379555374384, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, driverless car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the car's body made of a smooth, obsidian-like composite material with opaque dark glass windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are thin blue LED strips visible embedded in the sides and wheels of the car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a rain-soaked futuristic city street with towering skyscrapers displaying dynamic holographic billboards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle tracking shot moving smoothly to the right in sync with the vehicle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02208624593913555 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8970861434936523 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02208624593913555, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02208624593913555, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13041499257087708, + 0.2741466760635376, + 0.0298661757260561, + 0.10357953608036041, + 0.0855269581079483, + 0.02830025553703308, + 0.052763547748327255, + 0.15115560591220856, + 0.11262540519237518, + 0.03162079676985741 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02208624593913555 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, driverless car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the car's body made of a smooth, obsidian-like composite material with opaque dark glass windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are thin blue LED strips visible embedded in the sides and wheels of the car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a rain-soaked futuristic city street with towering skyscrapers displaying dynamic holographic billboards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle tracking shot moving smoothly to the right in sync with the vehicle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012561958283185959 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387561798095703 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012561958283185959, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012561958283185959, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.054094187915325165, + 0.40183836221694946, + 0.024250248447060585, + 0.22960855066776276, + 0.03281189873814583, + 0.033228591084480286, + 0.07037483155727386, + 0.09516973048448563, + 0.02079261839389801, + 0.03783101588487625 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 3, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012561958283185959 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, driverless car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the car's body made of a smooth, obsidian-like composite material with opaque dark glass windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are thin blue LED strips visible embedded in the sides and wheels of the car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a rain-soaked futuristic city street with towering skyscrapers displaying dynamic holographic billboards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle tracking shot moving smoothly to the right in sync with the vehicle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008636031299829483 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758635997772217 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008636031299829483, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008636031299829483, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12121220678091049, + 0.1473843902349472, + 0.08339724689722061, + 0.17575761675834656, + 0.03594589978456497, + 0.020831430330872536, + 0.04317012056708336, + 0.04880688339471817, + 0.14354607462882996, + 0.1799481362104416 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008636031299829483 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, driverless car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the car's body made of a smooth, obsidian-like composite material with opaque dark glass windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are thin blue LED strips visible embedded in the sides and wheels of the car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a rain-soaked futuristic city street with towering skyscrapers displaying dynamic holographic billboards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle tracking shot moving smoothly to the right in sync with the vehicle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00361218536272645 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628612041473389 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00361218536272645, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00361218536272645, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14802737534046173, + 0.31574830412864685, + 0.09387965500354767, + 0.0729675441980362, + 0.027519263327121735, + 0.02645408920943737, + 0.02854204550385475, + 0.06625550985336304, + 0.13410912454128265, + 0.08649713546037674 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00361218536272645 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, driverless car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the car's body made of a smooth, obsidian-like composite material with opaque dark glass windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are thin blue LED strips visible embedded in the sides and wheels of the car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a rain-soaked futuristic city street with towering skyscrapers displaying dynamic holographic billboards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle tracking shot moving smoothly to the right in sync with the vehicle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008630476891994476 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758630275726318 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008630476891994476, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008630476891994476, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.051207754760980606, + 0.11004019528627396, + 0.015131340362131596, + 0.05946113169193268, + 0.03511073440313339, + 0.04212978109717369, + 0.038301654160022736, + 0.19661477208137512, + 0.4110287129878998, + 0.04097388684749603 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008630476891994476 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_0/index_tensor([1564, 1564])_group_0_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_0/index_tensor([1564, 1564])_group_0_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..76f21994395b202fea3ed387c569fc26f88937e6 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_0/index_tensor([1564, 1564])_group_0_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "low-angle, handheld medium shot, imbued with a gentle vibration of energy, slowly approaches a jubilant mixed-gender athletic team celebrating on a vibrant green field. In the foreground, a female athlete, her brown hair tied in a high, messy ponytail, her face flushed, glistening with sweat, her expression radiating pure ecstasy. Beside her, a male teammate with short hair throws an arm around her shoulders and opens his mouth in a joyful, triumphant cry. They all wear royal blue and white jerseys made of breathable fabric, lightly stained with dirt from recent competitions. Around their necks hangs a heavy, gleaming gold medal, draped with a thick blue and white striped ribbon. With uncontrollable excitement, they collectively thrust their medals forward, clutching the ribbons and boisterously shaking them directly toward the camera, causing the polished gold discs to dance and glitter. The entire scene is bathed in the warm golden glow of the afternoon sun, casting long shadows and producing cinematic lens flares that sweep across the frame as the camera pans. Against the soft-focus background, the blurred buildings of the stadium stands and the falling confetti in the distance embellish the euphoria and deep emotional atmosphere of hard-earned victory and unbreakable team camaraderie.", + "seed": 28196, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_0/index_1564_seed_28196_dp_0_rank_0_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.10252953600138426, + "vlm_logprob": -0.10252953600138426, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.45, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.10252953600138426, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle handheld medium shot of a mixed-gender athletic team?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the athletes wearing royal blue and white jerseys with gold medals on thick blue and white striped ribbons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the athletes collectively thrust their medals forward and shake them directly toward the camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in warm golden afternoon sunlight with long shadows and cinematic lens flares?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly approach the team while panning?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0447082482278347 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.294708251953125 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0447082482278347, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0447082482278347, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14455461502075195, + 0.053127892315387726, + 0.052266765385866165, + 0.15861372649669647, + 0.09011000394821167, + 0.12500856816768646, + 0.07601691037416458, + 0.19399414956569672, + 0.072554811835289, + 0.03375255689024925 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0447082482278347 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle handheld medium shot of a mixed-gender athletic team?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the athletes wearing royal blue and white jerseys with gold medals on thick blue and white striped ribbons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the athletes collectively thrust their medals forward and shake them directly toward the camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in warm golden afternoon sunlight with long shadows and cinematic lens flares?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly approach the team while panning?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012553836219012737 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387553691864014 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012553836219012737, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012553836219012737, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18321365118026733, + 0.08959392458200455, + 0.08936277031898499, + 0.10193531960248947, + 0.06444937735795975, + 0.11502533406019211, + 0.07028639316558838, + 0.1251903474330902, + 0.08970637619495392, + 0.07123643904924393 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012553836219012737 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle handheld medium shot of a mixed-gender athletic team?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the athletes wearing royal blue and white jerseys with gold medals on thick blue and white striped ribbons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the athletes collectively thrust their medals forward and shake them directly toward the camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in warm golden afternoon sunlight with long shadows and cinematic lens flares?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly approach the team while panning?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020576467737555504 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955764770507812 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020576467737555504, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020576467737555504, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1426420360803604, + 0.11851858347654343, + 0.12748317420482635, + 0.0508454404771328, + 0.08872340619564056, + 0.045895326882600784, + 0.09412094950675964, + 0.17397400736808777, + 0.06763812154531479, + 0.09015897661447525 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020576467737555504 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle handheld medium shot of a mixed-gender athletic team?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the athletes wearing royal blue and white jerseys with gold medals on thick blue and white striped ribbons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the athletes collectively thrust their medals forward and shake them directly toward the camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in warm golden afternoon sunlight with long shadows and cinematic lens flares?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly approach the team while panning?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005947748199105263 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130947589874268 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005947748199105263, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005947748199105263, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.41065236926078796, + 0.16895820200443268, + 0.08839037269353867, + 0.058093778789043427, + 0.07062309980392456, + 0.03431190922856331, + 0.033499591052532196, + 0.03682234510779381, + 0.04514778032898903, + 0.05350058525800705 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005947748199105263 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle handheld medium shot of a mixed-gender athletic team?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the athletes wearing royal blue and white jerseys with gold medals on thick blue and white striped ribbons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the athletes collectively thrust their medals forward and shake them directly toward the camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in warm golden afternoon sunlight with long shadows and cinematic lens flares?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly approach the team while panning?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4288613796234131 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.053861379623413 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.4288613796234131, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.4288613796234131, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1484420895576477, + 0.09252596646547318, + 0.06456149369478226, + 0.06357579678297043, + 0.04572022333741188, + 0.05700327828526497, + 0.07337842881679535, + 0.3047034442424774, + 0.06193094328045845, + 0.08815832436084747 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.4288613796234131 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, handheld medium shot, imbued with a gentle vibration of energy, slowly approaches a jubilant mixed-gender athletic team celebrating on a vibrant green field. In the foreground, a female athlete, her brown hair tied in a high, messy ponytail, her face flushed, glistening with sweat, her expression radiating pure ecstasy. Beside her, a male teammate with short hair throws an arm around her shoulders and opens his mouth in a joyful, triumphant cry. They all wear royal blue and white jerseys made of breathable fabric, lightly stained with dirt from recent competitions. Around their necks hangs a heavy, gleaming gold medal, draped with a thick blue and white striped ribbon. With uncontrollable excitement, they collectively thrust their medals forward, clutching the ribbons and boisterously shaking them directly toward the camera, causing the polished gold discs to dance and glitter. The entire scene is bathed in the warm golden glow of the afternoon sun, casting long shadows and producing cinematic lens flares that sweep across the frame as the camera pans. Against the soft-focus background, the blurred buildings of the stadium stands and the falling confetti in the distance embellish the euphoria and deep emotional atmosphere of hard-earned victory and unbreakable team camaraderie.", + "seed": 28197, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_0/index_1564_seed_28197_dp_0_rank_0_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.15900339260697366, + "vlm_logprob": -0.15900339260697366, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.500000011920929, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.15900339260697366, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle handheld medium shot of a mixed-gender athletic team?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the athletes wearing royal blue and white jerseys with gold medals on thick blue and white striped ribbons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the athletes collectively thrust their medals forward and shake them directly toward the camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in warm golden afternoon sunlight with long shadows and cinematic lens flares?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly approach the team while panning?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3168763220310211 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3168762922286987 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3168763220310211, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3168763220310211, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14564794301986694, + 0.054541267454624176, + 0.16474232077598572, + 0.13780437409877777, + 0.0796227976679802, + 0.055940862745046616, + 0.1639402061700821, + 0.07155986875295639, + 0.06531328707933426, + 0.06088707223534584 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3168763220310211 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle handheld medium shot of a mixed-gender athletic team?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the athletes wearing royal blue and white jerseys with gold medals on thick blue and white striped ribbons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the athletes collectively thrust their medals forward and shake them directly toward the camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in warm golden afternoon sunlight with long shadows and cinematic lens flares?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly approach the team while panning?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016089366748929024 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.14108943939209 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016089366748929024, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016089366748929024, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09791868925094604, + 0.07291075587272644, + 0.17520521581172943, + 0.1216120570898056, + 0.054111137986183167, + 0.03577979654073715, + 0.12658122181892395, + 0.09469185769557953, + 0.1047549620270729, + 0.11643427610397339 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 6, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016089366748929024 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle handheld medium shot of a mixed-gender athletic team?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the athletes wearing royal blue and white jerseys with gold medals on thick blue and white striped ribbons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the athletes collectively thrust their medals forward and shake them directly toward the camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in warm golden afternoon sunlight with long shadows and cinematic lens flares?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly approach the team while panning?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02634584717452526 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651345729827881 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02634584717452526, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02634584717452526, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1600486785173416, + 0.051773421466350555, + 0.07354950904846191, + 0.13726826012134552, + 0.10267210751771927, + 0.09796366095542908, + 0.10615754872560501, + 0.04410500451922417, + 0.06738150119781494, + 0.15908034145832062 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02634584717452526 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle handheld medium shot of a mixed-gender athletic team?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the athletes wearing royal blue and white jerseys with gold medals on thick blue and white striped ribbons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the athletes collectively thrust their medals forward and shake them directly toward the camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in warm golden afternoon sunlight with long shadows and cinematic lens flares?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly approach the team while panning?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.048665110021829605 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486650466918945 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.048665110021829605, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.048665110021829605, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23633433878421783, + 0.05604817345738411, + 0.10564939677715302, + 0.13872301578521729, + 0.09249980747699738, + 0.1125209704041481, + 0.07212290912866592, + 0.0409417599439621, + 0.07190065085887909, + 0.07325894385576248 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.048665110021829605 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle handheld medium shot of a mixed-gender athletic team?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the athletes wearing royal blue and white jerseys with gold medals on thick blue and white striped ribbons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the athletes collectively thrust their medals forward and shake them directly toward the camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in warm golden afternoon sunlight with long shadows and cinematic lens flares?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly approach the team while panning?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.38704031705856323 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.137040376663208 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.38704031705856323, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.7500000596046448, + "token_credit_reward": -0.38704031705856323, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12112896144390106, + 0.0738363116979599, + 0.10009970515966415, + 0.11840560287237167, + 0.16198715567588806, + 0.07490644603967667, + 0.11182042956352234, + 0.05757207050919533, + 0.07440819591283798, + 0.10583508014678955 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.38704031705856323 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, handheld medium shot, imbued with a gentle vibration of energy, slowly approaches a jubilant mixed-gender athletic team celebrating on a vibrant green field. In the foreground, a female athlete, her brown hair tied in a high, messy ponytail, her face flushed, glistening with sweat, her expression radiating pure ecstasy. Beside her, a male teammate with short hair throws an arm around her shoulders and opens his mouth in a joyful, triumphant cry. They all wear royal blue and white jerseys made of breathable fabric, lightly stained with dirt from recent competitions. Around their necks hangs a heavy, gleaming gold medal, draped with a thick blue and white striped ribbon. With uncontrollable excitement, they collectively thrust their medals forward, clutching the ribbons and boisterously shaking them directly toward the camera, causing the polished gold discs to dance and glitter. The entire scene is bathed in the warm golden glow of the afternoon sun, casting long shadows and producing cinematic lens flares that sweep across the frame as the camera pans. Against the soft-focus background, the blurred buildings of the stadium stands and the falling confetti in the distance embellish the euphoria and deep emotional atmosphere of hard-earned victory and unbreakable team camaraderie.", + "seed": 28198, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_0/index_1564_seed_28198_dp_1_rank_2_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.09236805550754071, + "vlm_logprob": -0.09236805550754071, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.725, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.09236805550754071, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle handheld medium shot of a mixed-gender athletic team?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the athletes wearing royal blue and white jerseys with gold medals on thick blue and white striped ribbons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the athletes collectively thrust their medals forward and shake them directly toward the camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in warm golden afternoon sunlight with long shadows and cinematic lens flares?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly approach the team while panning?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12004534155130386 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2450454235076904 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12004534155130386, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12004534155130386, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10225535929203033, + 0.06842226535081863, + 0.18598605692386627, + 0.047591306269168854, + 0.05840231105685234, + 0.04052303358912468, + 0.04632408544421196, + 0.2001209408044815, + 0.15734614431858063, + 0.0930284932255745 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 2, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12004534155130386 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle handheld medium shot of a mixed-gender athletic team?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the athletes wearing royal blue and white jerseys with gold medals on thick blue and white striped ribbons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the athletes collectively thrust their medals forward and shake them directly toward the camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in warm golden afternoon sunlight with long shadows and cinematic lens flares?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly approach the team while panning?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016094176098704338 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141094207763672 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016094176098704338, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016094176098704338, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08083287626504898, + 0.11919786036014557, + 0.23632091283798218, + 0.061834707856178284, + 0.031185362488031387, + 0.03195321187376976, + 0.022596921771764755, + 0.11081553250551224, + 0.10841527581214905, + 0.1968473643064499 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016094176098704338 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle handheld medium shot of a mixed-gender athletic team?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the athletes wearing royal blue and white jerseys with gold medals on thick blue and white striped ribbons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the athletes collectively thrust their medals forward and shake them directly toward the camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in warm golden afternoon sunlight with long shadows and cinematic lens flares?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly approach the team while panning?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.062040552496910095 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120405673980713 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.062040552496910095, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.062040552496910095, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0861004889011383, + 0.1422148048877716, + 0.2225414365530014, + 0.06913929432630539, + 0.042303189635276794, + 0.043877605348825455, + 0.14268948137760162, + 0.06659955531358719, + 0.09178571403026581, + 0.09274836629629135 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.062040552496910095 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle handheld medium shot of a mixed-gender athletic team?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the athletes wearing royal blue and white jerseys with gold medals on thick blue and white striped ribbons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the athletes collectively thrust their medals forward and shake them directly toward the camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in warm golden afternoon sunlight with long shadows and cinematic lens flares?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly approach the team while panning?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.038109809160232544 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.28810977935791 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.038109809160232544, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.038109809160232544, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20456235110759735, + 0.14628829061985016, + 0.2972744107246399, + 0.0575081892311573, + 0.03858022764325142, + 0.13736426830291748, + 0.011760544031858444, + 0.019757486879825592, + 0.04967864230275154, + 0.03722564876079559 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.038109809160232544 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle handheld medium shot of a mixed-gender athletic team?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the athletes wearing royal blue and white jerseys with gold medals on thick blue and white striped ribbons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the athletes collectively thrust their medals forward and shake them directly toward the camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in warm golden afternoon sunlight with long shadows and cinematic lens flares?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly approach the team while panning?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22555039823055267 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6005504131317139 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.22555039823055267, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.22555039823055267, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1461511254310608, + 0.14420555531978607, + 0.1769275963306427, + 0.1347791701555252, + 0.1319805383682251, + 0.06445178389549255, + 0.024169759824872017, + 0.07188344746828079, + 0.06238323450088501, + 0.04306786134839058 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.22555039823055267 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, handheld medium shot, imbued with a gentle vibration of energy, slowly approaches a jubilant mixed-gender athletic team celebrating on a vibrant green field. In the foreground, a female athlete, her brown hair tied in a high, messy ponytail, her face flushed, glistening with sweat, her expression radiating pure ecstasy. Beside her, a male teammate with short hair throws an arm around her shoulders and opens his mouth in a joyful, triumphant cry. They all wear royal blue and white jerseys made of breathable fabric, lightly stained with dirt from recent competitions. Around their necks hangs a heavy, gleaming gold medal, draped with a thick blue and white striped ribbon. With uncontrollable excitement, they collectively thrust their medals forward, clutching the ribbons and boisterously shaking them directly toward the camera, causing the polished gold discs to dance and glitter. The entire scene is bathed in the warm golden glow of the afternoon sun, casting long shadows and producing cinematic lens flares that sweep across the frame as the camera pans. Against the soft-focus background, the blurred buildings of the stadium stands and the falling confetti in the distance embellish the euphoria and deep emotional atmosphere of hard-earned victory and unbreakable team camaraderie.", + "seed": 28199, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_0/index_1564_seed_28199_dp_1_rank_2_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.06013220828026533, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06013220828026533, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.475, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06013220828026533, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle handheld medium shot of a mixed-gender athletic team?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the athletes wearing royal blue and white jerseys with gold medals on thick blue and white striped ribbons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the athletes collectively thrust their medals forward and shake them directly toward the camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in warm golden afternoon sunlight with long shadows and cinematic lens flares?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly approach the team while panning?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05736155062913895 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.932361602783203 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05736155062913895, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05736155062913895, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2144974172115326, + 0.06894581764936447, + 0.15946240723133087, + 0.06345679610967636, + 0.07539819926023483, + 0.13985960185527802, + 0.04182972386479378, + 0.0996789038181305, + 0.06658932566642761, + 0.07028178870677948 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05736155062913895 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle handheld medium shot of a mixed-gender athletic team?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the athletes wearing royal blue and white jerseys with gold medals on thick blue and white striped ribbons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the athletes collectively thrust their medals forward and shake them directly toward the camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in warm golden afternoon sunlight with long shadows and cinematic lens flares?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly approach the team while panning?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012552070431411266 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387552261352539 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012552070431411266, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012552070431411266, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15934590995311737, + 0.06321367621421814, + 0.10360033810138702, + 0.04036886245012283, + 0.03698084130883217, + 0.298828125, + 0.12434703856706619, + 0.02710670977830887, + 0.08424416929483414, + 0.06196436658501625 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012552070431411266 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle handheld medium shot of a mixed-gender athletic team?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the athletes wearing royal blue and white jerseys with gold medals on thick blue and white striped ribbons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the athletes collectively thrust their medals forward and shake them directly toward the camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in warm golden afternoon sunlight with long shadows and cinematic lens flares?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly approach the team while panning?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02057483419775963 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955748081207275 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02057483419775963, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02057483419775963, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15682518482208252, + 0.04261938855051994, + 0.10632916539907455, + 0.0790540874004364, + 0.027787329629063606, + 0.03991593420505524, + 0.15522582828998566, + 0.22022202610969543, + 0.10294061154127121, + 0.06908053159713745 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02057483419775963 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle handheld medium shot of a mixed-gender athletic team?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the athletes wearing royal blue and white jerseys with gold medals on thick blue and white striped ribbons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the athletes collectively thrust their medals forward and shake them directly toward the camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in warm golden afternoon sunlight with long shadows and cinematic lens flares?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly approach the team while panning?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008637331426143646 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758637428283691 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008637331426143646, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008637331426143646, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.47857141494750977, + 0.18404024839401245, + 0.07984817028045654, + 0.04338446632027626, + 0.026018299162387848, + 0.039990682154893875, + 0.03609715402126312, + 0.06148596107959747, + 0.017373159527778625, + 0.03319040685892105 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008637331426143646 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle handheld medium shot of a mixed-gender athletic team?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the athletes wearing royal blue and white jerseys with gold medals on thick blue and white striped ribbons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the athletes collectively thrust their medals forward and shake them directly toward the camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in warm golden afternoon sunlight with long shadows and cinematic lens flares?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly approach the team while panning?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20153525471687317 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7015352249145508 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20153525471687317, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20153525471687317, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13687607645988464, + 0.09300661832094193, + 0.09528783708810806, + 0.06165773794054985, + 0.05520832911133766, + 0.18613409996032715, + 0.15843504667282104, + 0.09342404454946518, + 0.09137455374002457, + 0.0285956934094429 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20153525471687317 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_1/index_tensor([7084, 7084])_group_1_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_1/index_tensor([7084, 7084])_group_1_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..6c50869b39a19788b0b7b4a7e1306aa20a4fdc42 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_1/index_tensor([7084, 7084])_group_1_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "In a slowly rotating medium close-up shot, a weathered elderly man sits quietly. The entire frame is imbued with Steve McCurry's signature cinematography, characterized by intensely saturated colors and stark contrasts. His weathered face is etched with deep wrinkles, like a dry riverbed, his skin a bronzed hue carved by time and sunlight, and his sparse, silver-white hair is plastered to his scalp. He wears a faded, dark blue cotton gown intricately hand-embroidered patterns, the texture of the garment clearly visible in the lens. A ray of warm afternoon sunlight slants in through a small side window, precisely framing his profile and casting a soft, smeared light on the mottled ochre-colored earthen wall behind him. As the camera moves in an extremely slow arc around him, light shifts across his facial features, sometimes illuminating his sunken, slightly moist eyes, which gleam with warm gratitude at the memory of the past and a hint of unspoken nostalgic sadness; sometimes, half of his face is cast into soft shadow, highlighting his prominent cheekbones and his calloused hands, gently folded in front of him. His lips move slightly, as if silently and carefully recounting a forgotten story. Every subtle muscle twitch and change in his eyes is keenly captured by the camera, creating an atmosphere of profound intimacy, storytelling, and profound emotional resonance.", + "seed": 31146, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_1/index_7084_seed_31146_dp_2_rank_4_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.03223332148045301, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03223332148045301, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.925, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03223332148045301, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a weathered elderly man with deep wrinkles and silver-white hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a faded dark blue cotton gown with visible hand-embroidered patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background an ochre-colored earthen wall illuminated by a ray of warm afternoon sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a slow arc movement around the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the colors in the video intensely saturated with stark contrasts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.030224042013287544 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.530224084854126 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.030224042013287544, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.030224042013287544, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.6583912968635559, + 0.022855591028928757, + 0.027297241613268852, + 0.015777667984366417, + 0.023334845900535583, + 0.11439386755228043, + 0.024927936494350433, + 0.08107700943946838, + 0.0063546388410031796, + 0.02558993734419346 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.030224042013287544 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a weathered elderly man with deep wrinkles and silver-white hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a faded dark blue cotton gown with visible hand-embroidered patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background an ochre-colored earthen wall illuminated by a ray of warm afternoon sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a slow arc movement around the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the colors in the video intensely saturated with stark contrasts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07899527996778488 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5789952278137207 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07899527996778488, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07899527996778488, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5288676023483276, + 0.2699848413467407, + 0.05131418630480766, + 0.01591615378856659, + 0.021942419931292534, + 0.02333853207528591, + 0.01243579387664795, + 0.029674658551812172, + 0.011305377818644047, + 0.035220351070165634 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07899527996778488 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a weathered elderly man with deep wrinkles and silver-white hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a faded dark blue cotton gown with visible hand-embroidered patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background an ochre-colored earthen wall illuminated by a ray of warm afternoon sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a slow arc movement around the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the colors in the video intensely saturated with stark contrasts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002195212058722973 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127195358276367 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002195212058722973, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002195212058722973, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2198445349931717, + 0.09391866624355316, + 0.06106579676270485, + 0.11655990779399872, + 0.04894176125526428, + 0.03415472432971001, + 0.012868761084973812, + 0.033116575330495834, + 0.08753623068332672, + 0.29199302196502686 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002195212058722973 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a weathered elderly man with deep wrinkles and silver-white hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a faded dark blue cotton gown with visible hand-embroidered patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background an ochre-colored earthen wall illuminated by a ray of warm afternoon sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a slow arc movement around the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the colors in the video intensely saturated with stark contrasts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016062619164586067 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.1410627365112305 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016062619164586067, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016062619164586067, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.34272512793540955, + 0.4873010218143463, + 0.021726690232753754, + 0.021345015615224838, + 0.011088891886174679, + 0.00396171398460865, + 0.011241262778639793, + 0.01971472054719925, + 0.020078521221876144, + 0.06081700325012207 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016062619164586067 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a weathered elderly man with deep wrinkles and silver-white hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a faded dark blue cotton gown with visible hand-embroidered patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background an ochre-colored earthen wall illuminated by a ray of warm afternoon sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a slow arc movement around the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the colors in the video intensely saturated with stark contrasts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.033689454197883606 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408689498901367 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.033689454197883606, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.033689454197883606, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5731560587882996, + 0.20247165858745575, + 0.018258865922689438, + 0.09773343056440353, + 0.040081754326820374, + 0.017758773639798164, + 0.0075407144613564014, + 0.006983874831348658, + 0.015262702479958534, + 0.020752115175127983 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.033689454197883606 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a slowly rotating medium close-up shot, a weathered elderly man sits quietly. The entire frame is imbued with Steve McCurry's signature cinematography, characterized by intensely saturated colors and stark contrasts. His weathered face is etched with deep wrinkles, like a dry riverbed, his skin a bronzed hue carved by time and sunlight, and his sparse, silver-white hair is plastered to his scalp. He wears a faded, dark blue cotton gown intricately hand-embroidered patterns, the texture of the garment clearly visible in the lens. A ray of warm afternoon sunlight slants in through a small side window, precisely framing his profile and casting a soft, smeared light on the mottled ochre-colored earthen wall behind him. As the camera moves in an extremely slow arc around him, light shifts across his facial features, sometimes illuminating his sunken, slightly moist eyes, which gleam with warm gratitude at the memory of the past and a hint of unspoken nostalgic sadness; sometimes, half of his face is cast into soft shadow, highlighting his prominent cheekbones and his calloused hands, gently folded in front of him. His lips move slightly, as if silently and carefully recounting a forgotten story. Every subtle muscle twitch and change in his eyes is keenly captured by the camera, creating an atmosphere of profound intimacy, storytelling, and profound emotional resonance.", + "seed": 31147, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_1/index_7084_seed_31147_dp_2_rank_4_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.17094201911240817, + "vlm_logprob": -0.17094201911240817, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.125, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.17094201911240817, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a weathered elderly man with deep wrinkles and silver-white hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a faded dark blue cotton gown with visible hand-embroidered patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background an ochre-colored earthen wall illuminated by a ray of warm afternoon sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a slow arc movement around the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the colors in the video intensely saturated with stark contrasts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6335369348526001 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7585369348526001 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.6335369348526001, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.6335369348526001, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1578836739063263, + 0.05431731417775154, + 0.20568004250526428, + 0.037941135466098785, + 0.09259451180696487, + 0.03350627422332764, + 0.15706957876682281, + 0.12294154614210129, + 0.08183306455612183, + 0.05623290315270424 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.6335369348526001 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a weathered elderly man with deep wrinkles and silver-white hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a faded dark blue cotton gown with visible hand-embroidered patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background an ochre-colored earthen wall illuminated by a ray of warm afternoon sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a slow arc movement around the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the colors in the video intensely saturated with stark contrasts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1799256056547165 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.804925560951233 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1799256056547165, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1799256056547165, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08391610532999039, + 0.036747436970472336, + 0.11742407083511353, + 0.014089317992329597, + 0.054784197360277176, + 0.07042082399129868, + 0.2547280490398407, + 0.2558846175670624, + 0.037294115871191025, + 0.07471126317977905 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1799256056547165 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a weathered elderly man with deep wrinkles and silver-white hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a faded dark blue cotton gown with visible hand-embroidered patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background an ochre-colored earthen wall illuminated by a ray of warm afternoon sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a slow arc movement around the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the colors in the video intensely saturated with stark contrasts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0024868296459317207 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002486705780029 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0024868296459317207, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0024868296459317207, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2052931934595108, + 0.03529977798461914, + 0.025432344526052475, + 0.024841507896780968, + 0.08036419749259949, + 0.17735467851161957, + 0.2695096433162689, + 0.019008338451385498, + 0.046053700149059296, + 0.11684258282184601 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0024868296459317207 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a weathered elderly man with deep wrinkles and silver-white hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a faded dark blue cotton gown with visible hand-embroidered patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background an ochre-colored earthen wall illuminated by a ray of warm afternoon sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a slow arc movement around the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the colors in the video intensely saturated with stark contrasts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018182622268795967 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018182754516602 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018182622268795967, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018182622268795967, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07370699197053909, + 0.04751179739832878, + 0.037176426500082016, + 0.013511480763554573, + 0.057901255786418915, + 0.11190328001976013, + 0.5242858529090881, + 0.09361245483160019, + 0.008912435732781887, + 0.031478021293878555 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018182622268795967 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a weathered elderly man with deep wrinkles and silver-white hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a faded dark blue cotton gown with visible hand-embroidered patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background an ochre-colored earthen wall illuminated by a ray of warm afternoon sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a slow arc movement around the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the colors in the video intensely saturated with stark contrasts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02057810313999653 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895578145980835 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02057810313999653, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02057810313999653, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1380704641342163, + 0.03200539946556091, + 0.04916219785809517, + 0.02864976041018963, + 0.10833479464054108, + 0.1283377707004547, + 0.10481137782335281, + 0.07349257916212082, + 0.18821865320205688, + 0.14891695976257324 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02057810313999653 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a slowly rotating medium close-up shot, a weathered elderly man sits quietly. The entire frame is imbued with Steve McCurry's signature cinematography, characterized by intensely saturated colors and stark contrasts. His weathered face is etched with deep wrinkles, like a dry riverbed, his skin a bronzed hue carved by time and sunlight, and his sparse, silver-white hair is plastered to his scalp. He wears a faded, dark blue cotton gown intricately hand-embroidered patterns, the texture of the garment clearly visible in the lens. A ray of warm afternoon sunlight slants in through a small side window, precisely framing his profile and casting a soft, smeared light on the mottled ochre-colored earthen wall behind him. As the camera moves in an extremely slow arc around him, light shifts across his facial features, sometimes illuminating his sunken, slightly moist eyes, which gleam with warm gratitude at the memory of the past and a hint of unspoken nostalgic sadness; sometimes, half of his face is cast into soft shadow, highlighting his prominent cheekbones and his calloused hands, gently folded in front of him. His lips move slightly, as if silently and carefully recounting a forgotten story. Every subtle muscle twitch and change in his eyes is keenly captured by the camera, creating an atmosphere of profound intimacy, storytelling, and profound emotional resonance.", + "seed": 31148, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_1/index_7084_seed_31148_dp_3_rank_6_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.1402851386461407, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1402851386461407, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.9, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1402851386461407, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a weathered elderly man with deep wrinkles and silver-white hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a faded dark blue cotton gown with visible hand-embroidered patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background an ochre-colored earthen wall illuminated by a ray of warm afternoon sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a slow arc movement around the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the colors in the video intensely saturated with stark contrasts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.47524309158325195 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.975243091583252 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.47524309158325195, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.47524309158325195, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.40649843215942383, + 0.03441537544131279, + 0.035605475306510925, + 0.03900221362709999, + 0.04092875123023987, + 0.02651463821530342, + 0.24076353013515472, + 0.042492084205150604, + 0.02907235361635685, + 0.10470714420080185 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.47524309158325195 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a weathered elderly man with deep wrinkles and silver-white hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a faded dark blue cotton gown with visible hand-embroidered patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background an ochre-colored earthen wall illuminated by a ray of warm afternoon sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a slow arc movement around the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the colors in the video intensely saturated with stark contrasts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08906640112400055 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.464066505432129 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08906640112400055, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08906640112400055, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19921499490737915, + 0.05038570240139961, + 0.038823794573545456, + 0.03811101242899895, + 0.09125015884637833, + 0.06119513884186745, + 0.3741554617881775, + 0.08690444380044937, + 0.014010395854711533, + 0.04594888538122177 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08906640112400055 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a weathered elderly man with deep wrinkles and silver-white hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a faded dark blue cotton gown with visible hand-embroidered patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background an ochre-colored earthen wall illuminated by a ray of warm afternoon sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a slow arc movement around the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the colors in the video intensely saturated with stark contrasts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003612541826441884 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628612518310547 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003612541826441884, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003612541826441884, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14487384259700775, + 0.043458808213472366, + 0.10572925955057144, + 0.03033234365284443, + 0.019069870933890343, + 0.012530731968581676, + 0.5057929754257202, + 0.07578009366989136, + 0.018410643562674522, + 0.04402155429124832 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003612541826441884 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a weathered elderly man with deep wrinkles and silver-white hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a faded dark blue cotton gown with visible hand-embroidered patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background an ochre-colored earthen wall illuminated by a ray of warm afternoon sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a slow arc movement around the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the colors in the video intensely saturated with stark contrasts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020577168092131615 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955771923065186 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020577168092131615, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020577168092131615, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04915468022227287, + 0.03831935673952103, + 0.05003323033452034, + 0.1391567885875702, + 0.014912759885191917, + 0.01012017298489809, + 0.49331721663475037, + 0.13215428590774536, + 0.043574027717113495, + 0.02925749495625496 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 3, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020577168092131615 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a weathered elderly man with deep wrinkles and silver-white hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a faded dark blue cotton gown with visible hand-embroidered patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background an ochre-colored earthen wall illuminated by a ray of warm afternoon sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a slow arc movement around the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the colors in the video intensely saturated with stark contrasts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11292649060487747 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.237926483154297 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11292649060487747, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11292649060487747, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18531553447246552, + 0.02601187862455845, + 0.061534762382507324, + 0.058461856096982956, + 0.03745351359248161, + 0.023718899115920067, + 0.29165375232696533, + 0.179006427526474, + 0.03318362310528755, + 0.10365977138280869 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11292649060487747 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a slowly rotating medium close-up shot, a weathered elderly man sits quietly. The entire frame is imbued with Steve McCurry's signature cinematography, characterized by intensely saturated colors and stark contrasts. His weathered face is etched with deep wrinkles, like a dry riverbed, his skin a bronzed hue carved by time and sunlight, and his sparse, silver-white hair is plastered to his scalp. He wears a faded, dark blue cotton gown intricately hand-embroidered patterns, the texture of the garment clearly visible in the lens. A ray of warm afternoon sunlight slants in through a small side window, precisely framing his profile and casting a soft, smeared light on the mottled ochre-colored earthen wall behind him. As the camera moves in an extremely slow arc around him, light shifts across his facial features, sometimes illuminating his sunken, slightly moist eyes, which gleam with warm gratitude at the memory of the past and a hint of unspoken nostalgic sadness; sometimes, half of his face is cast into soft shadow, highlighting his prominent cheekbones and his calloused hands, gently folded in front of him. His lips move slightly, as if silently and carefully recounting a forgotten story. Every subtle muscle twitch and change in his eyes is keenly captured by the camera, creating an atmosphere of profound intimacy, storytelling, and profound emotional resonance.", + "seed": 31149, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_1/index_7084_seed_31149_dp_3_rank_6_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.07137934919446706, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07137934919446706, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.124999976158142, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07137934919446706, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a weathered elderly man with deep wrinkles and silver-white hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a faded dark blue cotton gown with visible hand-embroidered patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background an ochre-colored earthen wall illuminated by a ray of warm afternoon sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a slow arc movement around the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the colors in the video intensely saturated with stark contrasts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10119005292654037 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3511900901794434 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10119005292654037, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10119005292654037, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22180628776550293, + 0.038328226655721664, + 0.02689732424914837, + 0.059419143944978714, + 0.017581244930624962, + 0.02229573018848896, + 0.025706380605697632, + 0.4735463559627533, + 0.055371563881635666, + 0.05904773995280266 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10119005292654037 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a weathered elderly man with deep wrinkles and silver-white hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a faded dark blue cotton gown with visible hand-embroidered patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background an ochre-colored earthen wall illuminated by a ray of warm afternoon sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a slow arc movement around the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the colors in the video intensely saturated with stark contrasts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14284498989582062 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0178449153900146 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14284498989582062, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.8749998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14284498989582062, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23330500721931458, + 0.053984709084033966, + 0.05400244891643524, + 0.04280552640557289, + 0.05227593705058098, + 0.06666180491447449, + 0.16159190237522125, + 0.16482095420360565, + 0.12314857542514801, + 0.047403205186128616 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14284498989582062 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a weathered elderly man with deep wrinkles and silver-white hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a faded dark blue cotton gown with visible hand-embroidered patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background an ochre-colored earthen wall illuminated by a ray of warm afternoon sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a slow arc movement around the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the colors in the video intensely saturated with stark contrasts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004093126393854618 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504093170166016 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004093126393854618, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004093126393854618, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17337574064731598, + 0.08450714498758316, + 0.1233038604259491, + 0.13218653202056885, + 0.0995270162820816, + 0.040358081459999084, + 0.042561888694763184, + 0.12013138830661774, + 0.0829586386680603, + 0.10108968615531921 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004093126393854618 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a weathered elderly man with deep wrinkles and silver-white hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a faded dark blue cotton gown with visible hand-embroidered patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background an ochre-colored earthen wall illuminated by a ray of warm afternoon sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a slow arc movement around the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the colors in the video intensely saturated with stark contrasts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02979334630072117 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5297932624816895 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02979334630072117, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02979334630072117, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16052360832691193, + 0.0482642762362957, + 0.082163505256176, + 0.05707919970154762, + 0.07083257287740707, + 0.09261038899421692, + 0.08419819921255112, + 0.06536106765270233, + 0.0966423973441124, + 0.2423247992992401 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02979334630072117 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a weathered elderly man with deep wrinkles and silver-white hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a faded dark blue cotton gown with visible hand-embroidered patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background an ochre-colored earthen wall illuminated by a ray of warm afternoon sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a slow arc movement around the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the colors in the video intensely saturated with stark contrasts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07897523045539856 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.578975200653076 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07897523045539856, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07897523045539856, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1005268394947052, + 0.03603736683726311, + 0.07935550063848495, + 0.2029569000005722, + 0.10631111264228821, + 0.02779356762766838, + 0.028305450454354286, + 0.07702606916427612, + 0.06358645111322403, + 0.2781006991863251 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07897523045539856 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_10/index_tensor([9461, 9461])_group_10_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_10/index_tensor([9461, 9461])_group_10_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..30f833e1b2c5ac8a6621df41c4db492c9e6c5a68 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_10/index_tensor([9461, 9461])_group_10_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "In the desaturated, sun-baked style of classic Western films, low-angle close-ups focus intensely on the steely determination etched on the riders' weathered faces. Deeply shadowed by their dusty, wide-brimmed hats, their eyes narrow into slits in the harsh glare, their jaws clenched in determination. The camera remains still, preserving this powerful expression as their dark hands, clasped in worn leather gloves, clench and decisively pull back on the thick reins. This sudden, powerful movement causes their heavy camels, their backs piled with cloth-wrapped bundles, to turn sharply across the arid land. The animals' massive feet dig into the sand, kicking up a thick, swirling cloud of pale desert dust that briefly billows across the lower frame. Against a soft-focus background distorted by a shimmering heat haze, the rest of the long line of riders and beasts begins to slowly and deliberately follow the turn, their forms blurred against the vast, empty landscape, creating an atmosphere of intense and demanding leadership.", + "seed": 14480, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_10/index_9461_seed_14480_dp_20_rank_40_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.5836972154676914, + "vlm_logprob": -0.5836972154676914, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 0.95, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.5836972154676914, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the main subjects riders wearing dusty, wide-brimmed hats and leather gloves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the riders' faces show steely determination with narrowed eyes and clenched jaws?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the riders pull back on thick reins causing their camels to turn sharply?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the camels kick up a thick, swirling cloud of pale desert dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle close-up that remains still throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6333144307136536 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7583144307136536 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.6333144307136536, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.6333144307136536, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.39425864815711975, + 0.16060467064380646, + 0.04169154912233353, + 0.09234980493783951, + 0.08477488160133362, + 0.07075576484203339, + 0.017898982390761375, + 0.0188369732350111, + 0.04183771461248398, + 0.07699091732501984 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.6333144307136536 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the main subjects riders wearing dusty, wide-brimmed hats and leather gloves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the riders' faces show steely determination with narrowed eyes and clenched jaws?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the riders pull back on thick reins causing their camels to turn sharply?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the camels kick up a thick, swirling cloud of pale desert dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle close-up that remains still throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.38718941807746887 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1371893882751465 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.38718941807746887, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.38718941807746887, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12188243120908737, + 0.05950169265270233, + 0.2974754869937897, + 0.14865119755268097, + 0.0712301954627037, + 0.04110255092382431, + 0.023501155897974968, + 0.0441264733672142, + 0.073607437312603, + 0.11892138421535492 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.38718941807746887 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the main subjects riders wearing dusty, wide-brimmed hats and leather gloves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the riders' faces show steely determination with narrowed eyes and clenched jaws?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the riders pull back on thick reins causing their camels to turn sharply?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the camels kick up a thick, swirling cloud of pale desert dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle close-up that remains still throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.28134509921073914 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4063451290130615 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.28134509921073914, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.28134509921073914, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.33901283144950867, + 0.07648675888776779, + 0.1006535142660141, + 0.12141983211040497, + 0.052455492317676544, + 0.06778720021247864, + 0.032543737441301346, + 0.04431552439928055, + 0.045033928006887436, + 0.12029124051332474 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.28134509921073914 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the main subjects riders wearing dusty, wide-brimmed hats and leather gloves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the riders' faces show steely determination with narrowed eyes and clenched jaws?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the riders pull back on thick reins causing their camels to turn sharply?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the camels kick up a thick, swirling cloud of pale desert dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle close-up that remains still throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016098398715257645 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141098499298096 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016098398715257645, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016098398715257645, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11294392496347427, + 0.07599645107984543, + 0.05850306153297424, + 0.10241349786520004, + 0.04065394401550293, + 0.04716649278998375, + 0.019174156710505486, + 0.06536077708005905, + 0.10279016196727753, + 0.3749975264072418 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016098398715257645 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the main subjects riders wearing dusty, wide-brimmed hats and leather gloves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the riders' faces show steely determination with narrowed eyes and clenched jaws?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the riders pull back on thick reins causing their camels to turn sharply?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the camels kick up a thick, swirling cloud of pale desert dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle close-up that remains still throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.600538730621338 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2255387008190155 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.600538730621338, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -1.600538730621338, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2742954194545746, + 0.08324676752090454, + 0.08381341397762299, + 0.151426762342453, + 0.05812639370560646, + 0.1094401553273201, + 0.023984869942069054, + 0.04102039709687233, + 0.07207856327295303, + 0.10256725549697876 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.600538730621338 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In the desaturated, sun-baked style of classic Western films, low-angle close-ups focus intensely on the steely determination etched on the riders' weathered faces. Deeply shadowed by their dusty, wide-brimmed hats, their eyes narrow into slits in the harsh glare, their jaws clenched in determination. The camera remains still, preserving this powerful expression as their dark hands, clasped in worn leather gloves, clench and decisively pull back on the thick reins. This sudden, powerful movement causes their heavy camels, their backs piled with cloth-wrapped bundles, to turn sharply across the arid land. The animals' massive feet dig into the sand, kicking up a thick, swirling cloud of pale desert dust that briefly billows across the lower frame. Against a soft-focus background distorted by a shimmering heat haze, the rest of the long line of riders and beasts begins to slowly and deliberately follow the turn, their forms blurred against the vast, empty landscape, creating an atmosphere of intense and demanding leadership.", + "seed": 14481, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_10/index_9461_seed_14481_dp_20_rank_40_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.6952259639278054, + "vlm_logprob": -0.6952259639278054, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.95, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.6952259639278054, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the main subjects riders wearing dusty, wide-brimmed hats and leather gloves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the riders' faces show steely determination with narrowed eyes and clenched jaws?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the riders pull back on thick reins causing their camels to turn sharply?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the camels kick up a thick, swirling cloud of pale desert dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle close-up that remains still throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01500639133155346 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.2650065422058105 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01500639133155346, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01500639133155346, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16463728249073029, + 0.13410146534442902, + 0.1091172844171524, + 0.15243592858314514, + 0.12672513723373413, + 0.07516928017139435, + 0.05742068961262703, + 0.05610063672065735, + 0.08645380288362503, + 0.037838421761989594 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01500639133155346 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the main subjects riders wearing dusty, wide-brimmed hats and leather gloves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the riders' faces show steely determination with narrowed eyes and clenched jaws?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the riders pull back on thick reins causing their camels to turn sharply?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the camels kick up a thick, swirling cloud of pale desert dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle close-up that remains still throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0549858883023262 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929986000061035 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0549858883023262, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0549858883023262, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4478698670864105, + 0.10252563655376434, + 0.07850991934537888, + 0.2093861997127533, + 0.02770388312637806, + 0.030814195051789284, + 0.028481489047408104, + 0.01817428134381771, + 0.03976365178823471, + 0.016770878806710243 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0549858883023262 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the main subjects riders wearing dusty, wide-brimmed hats and leather gloves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the riders' faces show steely determination with narrowed eyes and clenched jaws?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the riders pull back on thick reins causing their camels to turn sharply?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the camels kick up a thick, swirling cloud of pale desert dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle close-up that remains still throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22555866837501526 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6005586385726929 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.22555866837501526, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.22555866837501526, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14823287725448608, + 0.15020376443862915, + 0.10152237862348557, + 0.12907695770263672, + 0.11436140537261963, + 0.06434411555528641, + 0.09199514240026474, + 0.085844486951828, + 0.0544167123734951, + 0.06000214070081711 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.22555866837501526 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the main subjects riders wearing dusty, wide-brimmed hats and leather gloves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the riders' faces show steely determination with narrowed eyes and clenched jaws?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the riders pull back on thick reins causing their camels to turn sharply?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the camels kick up a thick, swirling cloud of pale desert dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle close-up that remains still throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012542887590825558 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387542724609375 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012542887590825558, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012542887590825558, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17876864969730377, + 0.11711766570806503, + 0.033119235187768936, + 0.0479036383330822, + 0.0724402666091919, + 0.20032335817813873, + 0.17527087032794952, + 0.05844826623797417, + 0.05409630015492439, + 0.06251179426908493 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012542887590825558 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the main subjects riders wearing dusty, wide-brimmed hats and leather gloves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the riders' faces show steely determination with narrowed eyes and clenched jaws?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the riders pull back on thick reins causing their camels to turn sharply?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the camels kick up a thick, swirling cloud of pale desert dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle close-up that remains still throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680359840393066 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.043035995215177536 + ], + "logprob_reward": -3.1680359840393066, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -3.1680359840393066, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.35383832454681396, + 0.08432252705097198, + 0.04951387643814087, + 0.12117961794137955, + 0.07805227488279343, + 0.04655083641409874, + 0.07167857140302658, + 0.07178798317909241, + 0.07193387299776077, + 0.051142167299985886 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -3.1680359840393066 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In the desaturated, sun-baked style of classic Western films, low-angle close-ups focus intensely on the steely determination etched on the riders' weathered faces. Deeply shadowed by their dusty, wide-brimmed hats, their eyes narrow into slits in the harsh glare, their jaws clenched in determination. The camera remains still, preserving this powerful expression as their dark hands, clasped in worn leather gloves, clench and decisively pull back on the thick reins. This sudden, powerful movement causes their heavy camels, their backs piled with cloth-wrapped bundles, to turn sharply across the arid land. The animals' massive feet dig into the sand, kicking up a thick, swirling cloud of pale desert dust that briefly billows across the lower frame. Against a soft-focus background distorted by a shimmering heat haze, the rest of the long line of riders and beasts begins to slowly and deliberately follow the turn, their forms blurred against the vast, empty landscape, creating an atmosphere of intense and demanding leadership.", + "seed": 14482, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_10/index_9461_seed_14482_dp_21_rank_42_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.6624495958909392, + "vlm_logprob": -0.6624495958909392, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.25, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.6624495958909392, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the main subjects riders wearing dusty, wide-brimmed hats and leather gloves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the riders' faces show steely determination with narrowed eyes and clenched jaws?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the riders pull back on thick reins causing their camels to turn sharply?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the camels kick up a thick, swirling cloud of pale desert dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle close-up that remains still throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.09067763388156891 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4656777381896973 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.09067763388156891, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.09067763388156891, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16192999482154846, + 0.038958728313446045, + 0.10586398839950562, + 0.13720345497131348, + 0.08380275964736938, + 0.1260615587234497, + 0.027935167774558067, + 0.045405253767967224, + 0.08576984703540802, + 0.18706926703453064 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.09067763388156891 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the main subjects riders wearing dusty, wide-brimmed hats and leather gloves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the riders' faces show steely determination with narrowed eyes and clenched jaws?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the riders pull back on thick reins causing their camels to turn sharply?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the camels kick up a thick, swirling cloud of pale desert dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle close-up that remains still throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2814382314682007 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4064382314682007 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2814382314682007, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2814382314682007, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3235894739627838, + 0.03764013946056366, + 0.061040181666612625, + 0.05452769994735718, + 0.08169274777173996, + 0.04162072762846947, + 0.03531967103481293, + 0.045712169259786606, + 0.08485841006040573, + 0.2339988499879837 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2814382314682007 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the main subjects riders wearing dusty, wide-brimmed hats and leather gloves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the riders' faces show steely determination with narrowed eyes and clenched jaws?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the riders pull back on thick reins causing their camels to turn sharply?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the camels kick up a thick, swirling cloud of pale desert dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle close-up that remains still throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3486287295818329 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2236287593841553 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3486287295818329, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3486287295818329, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15178614854812622, + 0.05161181464791298, + 0.17001700401306152, + 0.04897100105881691, + 0.039612479507923126, + 0.063147634267807, + 0.046878617256879807, + 0.052842676639556885, + 0.05981259047985077, + 0.3153200149536133 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3486287295818329 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the main subjects riders wearing dusty, wide-brimmed hats and leather gloves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the riders' faces show steely determination with narrowed eyes and clenched jaws?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the riders pull back on thick reins causing their camels to turn sharply?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the camels kick up a thick, swirling cloud of pale desert dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle close-up that remains still throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012555602006614208 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.3875555992126465 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012555602006614208, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012555602006614208, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06145239248871803, + 0.028207138180732727, + 0.08406232297420502, + 0.0988924652338028, + 0.2010364830493927, + 0.2552160322666168, + 0.0198522862046957, + 0.029462380334734917, + 0.0562712661921978, + 0.16554728150367737 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012555602006614208 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the main subjects riders wearing dusty, wide-brimmed hats and leather gloves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the riders' faces show steely determination with narrowed eyes and clenched jaws?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the riders pull back on thick reins causing their camels to turn sharply?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the camels kick up a thick, swirling cloud of pale desert dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle close-up that remains still throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5789477825164795 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07894780486822128 + ], + "logprob_reward": -2.5789477825164795, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -2.5789477825164795, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10089114308357239, + 0.04156674072146416, + 0.13849414885044098, + 0.11316285282373428, + 0.11413991451263428, + 0.05618538334965706, + 0.027921443805098534, + 0.06860805302858353, + 0.05457567423582077, + 0.28445467352867126 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -2.5789477825164795 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In the desaturated, sun-baked style of classic Western films, low-angle close-ups focus intensely on the steely determination etched on the riders' weathered faces. Deeply shadowed by their dusty, wide-brimmed hats, their eyes narrow into slits in the harsh glare, their jaws clenched in determination. The camera remains still, preserving this powerful expression as their dark hands, clasped in worn leather gloves, clench and decisively pull back on the thick reins. This sudden, powerful movement causes their heavy camels, their backs piled with cloth-wrapped bundles, to turn sharply across the arid land. The animals' massive feet dig into the sand, kicking up a thick, swirling cloud of pale desert dust that briefly billows across the lower frame. Against a soft-focus background distorted by a shimmering heat haze, the rest of the long line of riders and beasts begins to slowly and deliberately follow the turn, their forms blurred against the vast, empty landscape, creating an atmosphere of intense and demanding leadership.", + "seed": 14483, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_10/index_9461_seed_14483_dp_21_rank_42_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.6888076527044177, + "vlm_logprob": -0.6888076527044177, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.85, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.6888076527044177, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the main subjects riders wearing dusty, wide-brimmed hats and leather gloves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the riders' faces show steely determination with narrowed eyes and clenched jaws?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the riders pull back on thick reins causing their camels to turn sharply?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the camels kick up a thick, swirling cloud of pale desert dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle close-up that remains still throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02480446547269821 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7748043537139893 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02480446547269821, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02480446547269821, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09673641622066498, + 0.09037192165851593, + 0.34959569573402405, + 0.12146539241075516, + 0.040034469217061996, + 0.08035023510456085, + 0.02906130999326706, + 0.06373082846403122, + 0.04586508125066757, + 0.0827886313199997 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02480446547269821 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the main subjects riders wearing dusty, wide-brimmed hats and leather gloves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the riders' faces show steely determination with narrowed eyes and clenched jaws?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the riders pull back on thick reins causing their camels to turn sharply?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the camels kick up a thick, swirling cloud of pale desert dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle close-up that remains still throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1130240187048912 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2380239963531494 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1130240187048912, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1130240187048912, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11264795064926147, + 0.08766939491033554, + 0.5066021680831909, + 0.05883351340889931, + 0.025777339935302734, + 0.04772984981536865, + 0.03662572428584099, + 0.04850434139370918, + 0.03573008254170418, + 0.03987964242696762 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1130240187048912 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the main subjects riders wearing dusty, wide-brimmed hats and leather gloves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the riders' faces show steely determination with narrowed eyes and clenched jaws?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the riders pull back on thick reins causing their camels to turn sharply?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the camels kick up a thick, swirling cloud of pale desert dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle close-up that remains still throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12707965075969696 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.127079725265503 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12707965075969696, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12707965075969696, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06792791187763214, + 0.04133221507072449, + 0.5406481623649597, + 0.03609941154718399, + 0.03464586287736893, + 0.029791489243507385, + 0.05585353448987007, + 0.03820190578699112, + 0.07781083136796951, + 0.07768864184617996 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12707965075969696 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the main subjects riders wearing dusty, wide-brimmed hats and leather gloves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the riders' faces show steely determination with narrowed eyes and clenched jaws?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the riders pull back on thick reins causing their camels to turn sharply?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the camels kick up a thick, swirling cloud of pale desert dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle close-up that remains still throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01108794566243887 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511087894439697 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01108794566243887, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01108794566243887, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05789104476571083, + 0.09622064232826233, + 0.23531706631183624, + 0.07766831666231155, + 0.06069391965866089, + 0.12044142931699753, + 0.09578351676464081, + 0.0735333263874054, + 0.09616921842098236, + 0.08628154546022415 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01108794566243887 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the main subjects riders wearing dusty, wide-brimmed hats and leather gloves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the riders' faces show steely determination with narrowed eyes and clenched jaws?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the riders pull back on thick reins causing their camels to turn sharply?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the camels kick up a thick, swirling cloud of pale desert dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle close-up that remains still throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680421829223633 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04304227605462074 + ], + "logprob_reward": -3.1680421829223633, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -3.1680421829223633, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0770566463470459, + 0.02272060699760914, + 0.46691107749938965, + 0.04872393235564232, + 0.07538438588380814, + 0.04657931625843048, + 0.06499002128839493, + 0.0626664087176323, + 0.04888993129134178, + 0.08607763797044754 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -3.1680421829223633 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_11/index_tensor([4990, 4990])_group_11_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_11/index_tensor([4990, 4990])_group_11_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..8187488a78bb7bdffd678c8b875c4e67781e5c51 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_11/index_tensor([4990, 4990])_group_11_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "From a dramatic low angle, the camera began to slowly pan forward while simultaneously reaching upward, revealing the breathtaking spectacle of a futuristic musical stage. Powerful, meticulously choreographed spotlights in cool white and electric blue swept across the dark, polished wooden floor, capturing the edges of towering, stylized Art Deco pillars—gleaming metal arches and geometric brass fins that evoked a lunar city. Center stage, a group of performers in shimmering silver sequined bodysuits sang with passionate, uplifting faces, their mouths moving perfectly harmonized verses about life in the lunar colony. Flanking them, a line of humanoid robotic dancers, their polished chrome bodies designed with sharp Art Deco lines, executed tap movements with inhuman precision, their metal feet pounding the stage in a single, sharp, segmented rhythm. A thick layer of stage fog clung to the floor, swirling around their legs and twisting into ethereal wisps that were eerily illuminated from within as they drifted past the robots' glowing blue LED eyes, creating a mesmerizing atmosphere of grandiose futuristic theatrical wonder.", + "seed": 16192, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_11/index_4990_seed_16192_dp_22_rank_44_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.26584979631006717, + "vlm_logprob": -0.26584979631006717, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.425, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.26584979631006717, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a low angle and panning forward while reaching upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the spotlights cool white and electric blue sweeping across a dark, polished wooden floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are there towering stylized Art Deco pillars with gleaming metal arches and geometric brass fins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a group of performers in shimmering silver sequined bodysuits singing center stage alongside humanoid robotic dancers with polished chrome bodies?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a thick layer of stage fog swirling around the legs of the performers and robots, illuminated from within?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10217073559761047 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.352170705795288 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10217073559761047, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10217073559761047, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16079223155975342, + 0.1558677852153778, + 0.028257017955183983, + 0.19306568801403046, + 0.09607670456171036, + 0.05426136031746864, + 0.033817142248153687, + 0.07357260584831238, + 0.1549038290977478, + 0.04938562586903572 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10217073559761047 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a low angle and panning forward while reaching upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the spotlights cool white and electric blue sweeping across a dark, polished wooden floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are there towering stylized Art Deco pillars with gleaming metal arches and geometric brass fins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a group of performers in shimmering silver sequined bodysuits singing center stage alongside humanoid robotic dancers with polished chrome bodies?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a thick layer of stage fog swirling around the legs of the performers and robots, illuminated from within?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1370267868041992 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3870267868041992 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.1370267868041992, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -1.1370267868041992, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19467918574810028, + 0.6014858484268188, + 0.014799060299992561, + 0.015862852334976196, + 0.04842640459537506, + 0.00980762392282486, + 0.016346437856554985, + 0.05417865142226219, + 0.033367838710546494, + 0.01104609202593565 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.1370267868041992 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a low angle and panning forward while reaching upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the spotlights cool white and electric blue sweeping across a dark, polished wooden floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are there towering stylized Art Deco pillars with gleaming metal arches and geometric brass fins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a group of performers in shimmering silver sequined bodysuits singing center stage alongside humanoid robotic dancers with polished chrome bodies?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a thick layer of stage fog swirling around the legs of the performers and robots, illuminated from within?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0381363146007061 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881362438201904 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0381363146007061, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0381363146007061, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16895359754562378, + 0.24510255455970764, + 0.05523780733346939, + 0.08573407679796219, + 0.13036708533763885, + 0.03835398703813553, + 0.029482610523700714, + 0.1082172691822052, + 0.07872378081083298, + 0.059827182441949844 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0381363146007061 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a low angle and panning forward while reaching upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the spotlights cool white and electric blue sweeping across a dark, polished wooden floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are there towering stylized Art Deco pillars with gleaming metal arches and geometric brass fins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a group of performers in shimmering silver sequined bodysuits singing center stage alongside humanoid robotic dancers with polished chrome bodies?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a thick layer of stage fog swirling around the legs of the performers and robots, illuminated from within?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03373498097062111 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4087350368499756 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03373498097062111, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03373498097062111, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20456016063690186, + 0.3987829387187958, + 0.02029787190258503, + 0.03617484122514725, + 0.048669084906578064, + 0.02479148469865322, + 0.07579797506332397, + 0.07087654620409012, + 0.0593043714761734, + 0.060744758695364 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03373498097062111 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a low angle and panning forward while reaching upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the spotlights cool white and electric blue sweeping across a dark, polished wooden floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are there towering stylized Art Deco pillars with gleaming metal arches and geometric brass fins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a group of performers in shimmering silver sequined bodysuits singing center stage alongside humanoid robotic dancers with polished chrome bodies?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a thick layer of stage fog swirling around the legs of the performers and robots, illuminated from within?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018180163577198982 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.0181803703308105 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018180163577198982, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018180163577198982, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09440671652555466, + 0.04726433753967285, + 0.05931321531534195, + 0.09764177352190018, + 0.17869500815868378, + 0.05410223826766014, + 0.11728042364120483, + 0.12771084904670715, + 0.08429767191410065, + 0.1392877995967865 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018180163577198982 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "From a dramatic low angle, the camera began to slowly pan forward while simultaneously reaching upward, revealing the breathtaking spectacle of a futuristic musical stage. Powerful, meticulously choreographed spotlights in cool white and electric blue swept across the dark, polished wooden floor, capturing the edges of towering, stylized Art Deco pillars—gleaming metal arches and geometric brass fins that evoked a lunar city. Center stage, a group of performers in shimmering silver sequined bodysuits sang with passionate, uplifting faces, their mouths moving perfectly harmonized verses about life in the lunar colony. Flanking them, a line of humanoid robotic dancers, their polished chrome bodies designed with sharp Art Deco lines, executed tap movements with inhuman precision, their metal feet pounding the stage in a single, sharp, segmented rhythm. A thick layer of stage fog clung to the floor, swirling around their legs and twisting into ethereal wisps that were eerily illuminated from within as they drifted past the robots' glowing blue LED eyes, creating a mesmerizing atmosphere of grandiose futuristic theatrical wonder.", + "seed": 16193, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_11/index_4990_seed_16193_dp_22_rank_44_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.07351315394043922, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07351315394043922, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.775, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07351315394043922, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a low angle and panning forward while reaching upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the spotlights cool white and electric blue sweeping across a dark, polished wooden floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are there towering stylized Art Deco pillars with gleaming metal arches and geometric brass fins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a group of performers in shimmering silver sequined bodysuits singing center stage alongside humanoid robotic dancers with polished chrome bodies?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a thick layer of stage fog swirling around the legs of the performers and robots, illuminated from within?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08208870142698288 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5820887088775635 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08208870142698288, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08208870142698288, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0705917701125145, + 0.025484684854745865, + 0.24506260454654694, + 0.22124703228473663, + 0.056420810520648956, + 0.14058838784694672, + 0.04995774105191231, + 0.05107252299785614, + 0.05016418173909187, + 0.08941024541854858 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08208870142698288 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a low angle and panning forward while reaching upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the spotlights cool white and electric blue sweeping across a dark, polished wooden floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are there towering stylized Art Deco pillars with gleaming metal arches and geometric brass fins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a group of performers in shimmering silver sequined bodysuits singing center stage alongside humanoid robotic dancers with polished chrome bodies?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a thick layer of stage fog swirling around the legs of the performers and robots, illuminated from within?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1428200900554657 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.017820119857788 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1428200900554657, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1428200900554657, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09567037969827652, + 0.04964837059378624, + 0.4139668345451355, + 0.12973298132419586, + 0.020743876695632935, + 0.12208831310272217, + 0.015360197052359581, + 0.027341051027178764, + 0.03867903724312782, + 0.0867689698934555 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1428200900554657 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a low angle and panning forward while reaching upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the spotlights cool white and electric blue sweeping across a dark, polished wooden floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are there towering stylized Art Deco pillars with gleaming metal arches and geometric brass fins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a group of performers in shimmering silver sequined bodysuits singing center stage alongside humanoid robotic dancers with polished chrome bodies?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a thick layer of stage fog swirling around the legs of the performers and robots, illuminated from within?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04307093471288681 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680710315704346 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04307093471288681, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04307093471288681, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07231425493955612, + 0.06257551163434982, + 0.05867396667599678, + 0.08071298897266388, + 0.04554570093750954, + 0.4100312888622284, + 0.041580211371183395, + 0.04835151508450508, + 0.07886960357427597, + 0.10134498029947281 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04307093471288681 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a low angle and panning forward while reaching upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the spotlights cool white and electric blue sweeping across a dark, polished wooden floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are there towering stylized Art Deco pillars with gleaming metal arches and geometric brass fins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a group of performers in shimmering silver sequined bodysuits singing center stage alongside humanoid robotic dancers with polished chrome bodies?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a thick layer of stage fog swirling around the legs of the performers and robots, illuminated from within?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0790177509188652 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5790176391601562 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0790177509188652, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0790177509188652, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07269584387540817, + 0.053261641412973404, + 0.03491387516260147, + 0.23047617077827454, + 0.053209420293569565, + 0.07573477923870087, + 0.04331611841917038, + 0.1250196099281311, + 0.16376107931137085, + 0.14761148393154144 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0790177509188652 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a low angle and panning forward while reaching upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the spotlights cool white and electric blue sweeping across a dark, polished wooden floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are there towering stylized Art Deco pillars with gleaming metal arches and geometric brass fins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a group of performers in shimmering silver sequined bodysuits singing center stage alongside humanoid robotic dancers with polished chrome bodies?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a thick layer of stage fog swirling around the legs of the performers and robots, illuminated from within?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02056829258799553 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895568370819092 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02056829258799553, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02056829258799553, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06680627912282944, + 0.19539383053779602, + 0.15875044465065002, + 0.11097180098295212, + 0.029553014785051346, + 0.1869082748889923, + 0.030450817197561264, + 0.04419189319014549, + 0.10386161506175995, + 0.07311198860406876 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 5, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02056829258799553 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "From a dramatic low angle, the camera began to slowly pan forward while simultaneously reaching upward, revealing the breathtaking spectacle of a futuristic musical stage. Powerful, meticulously choreographed spotlights in cool white and electric blue swept across the dark, polished wooden floor, capturing the edges of towering, stylized Art Deco pillars—gleaming metal arches and geometric brass fins that evoked a lunar city. Center stage, a group of performers in shimmering silver sequined bodysuits sang with passionate, uplifting faces, their mouths moving perfectly harmonized verses about life in the lunar colony. Flanking them, a line of humanoid robotic dancers, their polished chrome bodies designed with sharp Art Deco lines, executed tap movements with inhuman precision, their metal feet pounding the stage in a single, sharp, segmented rhythm. A thick layer of stage fog clung to the floor, swirling around their legs and twisting into ethereal wisps that were eerily illuminated from within as they drifted past the robots' glowing blue LED eyes, creating a mesmerizing atmosphere of grandiose futuristic theatrical wonder.", + "seed": 16194, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_11/index_4990_seed_16194_dp_23_rank_46_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.038354224525392056, + "vlm_logprob": -0.038354224525392056, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.55, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.038354224525392056, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a low angle and panning forward while reaching upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the spotlights cool white and electric blue sweeping across a dark, polished wooden floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are there towering stylized Art Deco pillars with gleaming metal arches and geometric brass fins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a group of performers in shimmering silver sequined bodysuits singing center stage alongside humanoid robotic dancers with polished chrome bodies?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a thick layer of stage fog swirling around the legs of the performers and robots, illuminated from within?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.056894417852163315 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.931894302368164 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.056894417852163315, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.056894417852163315, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24205026030540466, + 0.06531345844268799, + 0.0834755226969719, + 0.07156465947628021, + 0.11406803876161575, + 0.09749700129032135, + 0.13252966105937958, + 0.03857191279530525, + 0.09456925094127655, + 0.060360200703144073 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.056894417852163315 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a low angle and panning forward while reaching upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the spotlights cool white and electric blue sweeping across a dark, polished wooden floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are there towering stylized Art Deco pillars with gleaming metal arches and geometric brass fins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a group of performers in shimmering silver sequined bodysuits singing center stage alongside humanoid robotic dancers with polished chrome bodies?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a thick layer of stage fog swirling around the legs of the performers and robots, illuminated from within?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07901279628276825 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.579012870788574 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07901279628276825, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07901279628276825, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22937965393066406, + 0.06184445321559906, + 0.05934453383088112, + 0.054768674075603485, + 0.043162018060684204, + 0.03875851258635521, + 0.03651425987482071, + 0.3271978199481964, + 0.05669781193137169, + 0.09233224391937256 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07901279628276825 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a low angle and panning forward while reaching upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the spotlights cool white and electric blue sweeping across a dark, polished wooden floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are there towering stylized Art Deco pillars with gleaming metal arches and geometric brass fins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a group of performers in shimmering silver sequined bodysuits singing center stage alongside humanoid robotic dancers with polished chrome bodies?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a thick layer of stage fog swirling around the legs of the performers and robots, illuminated from within?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03371112421154976 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4087111949920654 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03371112421154976, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03371112421154976, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07941427826881409, + 0.26099562644958496, + 0.15358585119247437, + 0.08996300399303436, + 0.08703123778104782, + 0.0949506163597107, + 0.06330443173646927, + 0.054148945957422256, + 0.08032158017158508, + 0.03628437966108322 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03371112421154976 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a low angle and panning forward while reaching upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the spotlights cool white and electric blue sweeping across a dark, polished wooden floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are there towering stylized Art Deco pillars with gleaming metal arches and geometric brass fins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a group of performers in shimmering silver sequined bodysuits singing center stage alongside humanoid robotic dancers with polished chrome bodies?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a thick layer of stage fog swirling around the legs of the performers and robots, illuminated from within?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01108488067984581 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511085033416748 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01108488067984581, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01108488067984581, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0819445550441742, + 0.03381296992301941, + 0.0774940475821495, + 0.03689395263791084, + 0.05267591401934624, + 0.11259128898382187, + 0.11698692291975021, + 0.3179187476634979, + 0.07920359075069427, + 0.09047799557447433 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01108488067984581 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a low angle and panning forward while reaching upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the spotlights cool white and electric blue sweeping across a dark, polished wooden floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are there towering stylized Art Deco pillars with gleaming metal arches and geometric brass fins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a group of performers in shimmering silver sequined bodysuits singing center stage alongside humanoid robotic dancers with polished chrome bodies?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a thick layer of stage fog swirling around the legs of the performers and robots, illuminated from within?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011067903600633144 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511067867279053 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011067903600633144, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011067903600633144, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07233119010925293, + 0.024880893528461456, + 0.051855575293302536, + 0.03958725929260254, + 0.06493726372718811, + 0.05808190628886223, + 0.08671694993972778, + 0.4520406723022461, + 0.10730566084384918, + 0.04226268082857132 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011067903600633144 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "From a dramatic low angle, the camera began to slowly pan forward while simultaneously reaching upward, revealing the breathtaking spectacle of a futuristic musical stage. Powerful, meticulously choreographed spotlights in cool white and electric blue swept across the dark, polished wooden floor, capturing the edges of towering, stylized Art Deco pillars—gleaming metal arches and geometric brass fins that evoked a lunar city. Center stage, a group of performers in shimmering silver sequined bodysuits sang with passionate, uplifting faces, their mouths moving perfectly harmonized verses about life in the lunar colony. Flanking them, a line of humanoid robotic dancers, their polished chrome bodies designed with sharp Art Deco lines, executed tap movements with inhuman precision, their metal feet pounding the stage in a single, sharp, segmented rhythm. A thick layer of stage fog clung to the floor, swirling around their legs and twisting into ethereal wisps that were eerily illuminated from within as they drifted past the robots' glowing blue LED eyes, creating a mesmerizing atmosphere of grandiose futuristic theatrical wonder.", + "seed": 16195, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_11/index_4990_seed_16195_dp_23_rank_46_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.08748131040483713, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08748131040483713, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.1, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08748131040483713, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a low angle and panning forward while reaching upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the spotlights cool white and electric blue sweeping across a dark, polished wooden floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are there towering stylized Art Deco pillars with gleaming metal arches and geometric brass fins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a group of performers in shimmering silver sequined bodysuits singing center stage alongside humanoid robotic dancers with polished chrome bodies?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a thick layer of stage fog swirling around the legs of the performers and robots, illuminated from within?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.13007046282291412 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.130070447921753 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.13007046282291412, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.13007046282291412, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1487346887588501, + 0.046614475548267365, + 0.16615533828735352, + 0.040069133043289185, + 0.2015136480331421, + 0.11795815080404282, + 0.09175696969032288, + 0.09958062320947647, + 0.03656723350286484, + 0.051049746572971344 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.13007046282291412 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a low angle and panning forward while reaching upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the spotlights cool white and electric blue sweeping across a dark, polished wooden floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are there towering stylized Art Deco pillars with gleaming metal arches and geometric brass fins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a group of performers in shimmering silver sequined bodysuits singing center stage alongside humanoid robotic dancers with polished chrome bodies?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a thick layer of stage fog swirling around the legs of the performers and robots, illuminated from within?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2521122097969055 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5021121501922607 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2521122097969055, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2521122097969055, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.02771633304655552, + 0.018576057627797127, + 0.11253912001848221, + 0.09085133671760559, + 0.2864817976951599, + 0.2585248053073883, + 0.05449867621064186, + 0.02793474681675434, + 0.016286863014101982, + 0.10659026354551315 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2521122097969055 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a low angle and panning forward while reaching upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the spotlights cool white and electric blue sweeping across a dark, polished wooden floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are there towering stylized Art Deco pillars with gleaming metal arches and geometric brass fins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a group of performers in shimmering silver sequined bodysuits singing center stage alongside humanoid robotic dancers with polished chrome bodies?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a thick layer of stage fog swirling around the legs of the performers and robots, illuminated from within?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023299720138311386 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732996940612793 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023299720138311386, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023299720138311386, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14791761338710785, + 0.07651958614587784, + 0.21541881561279297, + 0.09574859589338303, + 0.02921207621693611, + 0.12919209897518158, + 0.1583707481622696, + 0.05011764541268349, + 0.03170856088399887, + 0.06579426676034927 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023299720138311386 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a low angle and panning forward while reaching upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the spotlights cool white and electric blue sweeping across a dark, polished wooden floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are there towering stylized Art Deco pillars with gleaming metal arches and geometric brass fins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a group of performers in shimmering silver sequined bodysuits singing center stage alongside humanoid robotic dancers with polished chrome bodies?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a thick layer of stage fog swirling around the legs of the performers and robots, illuminated from within?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008647731505334377 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758647918701172 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008647731505334377, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008647731505334377, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10661675035953522, + 0.03577008843421936, + 0.0917864441871643, + 0.08870143443346024, + 0.11339228600263596, + 0.2277139574289322, + 0.09561683982610703, + 0.045186564326286316, + 0.04024612531065941, + 0.15496952831745148 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008647731505334377 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a low angle and panning forward while reaching upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the spotlights cool white and electric blue sweeping across a dark, polished wooden floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are there towering stylized Art Deco pillars with gleaming metal arches and geometric brass fins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a group of performers in shimmering silver sequined bodysuits singing center stage alongside humanoid robotic dancers with polished chrome bodies?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a thick layer of stage fog swirling around the legs of the performers and robots, illuminated from within?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023276427760720253 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732763290405273 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023276427760720253, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023276427760720253, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06584350764751434, + 0.04557903856039047, + 0.16605983674526215, + 0.17323414981365204, + 0.15422290563583374, + 0.06857355684041977, + 0.06940539181232452, + 0.06761737912893295, + 0.07674070447683334, + 0.11272356659173965 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023276427760720253 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_12/index_tensor([7053, 7053])_group_12_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_12/index_tensor([7053, 7053])_group_12_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..755e49ace0f7573494f090416d9c985ced719bae --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_12/index_tensor([7053, 7053])_group_12_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "From a low, agile perspective, the camera accelerates along a long, straight driveway paved with dark, smooth asphalt. On either side, a row of ancient, towering oaks forms a dense canopy, their gnarled branches silhouetted against the deep twilight sky, painted in hues of purple and faded crimson. As the camera moves relentlessly forward, the trees blur into strips of darkness, creating a sense of urgent arrival. At the end of the driveway, a magnificent three-story stone mansion dominates. Its stately neoclassical facade is illuminated by a warm, golden glow, which pours from each large, mullioned window, casting long, alluring rays of light across the manicured lawn. As the camera accelerates, drawing closer to the ornate double doors at the entrance, architectural details become sharp and clear. But just as the viewer is about to be enveloped by the mansion's overwhelming presence, the entire image fades smoothly and completely to black, immersing the moment of arrival in a profound mystery.", + "seed": 7160, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_12/index_7053_seed_7160_dp_24_rank_48_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.0787037681788206, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0787037681788206, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.075, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0787037681788206, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perspective low and agile, moving along a long, straight driveway paved with dark, smooth asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are ancient, towering oaks visible on either side of the driveway forming a dense canopy with gnarled branches silhouetted against a twilight sky of purple and faded crimson?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera accelerate forward, causing the trees to blur into strips of darkness while approaching a three-story stone mansion with a neoclassical facade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the mansion illuminated by a warm, golden glow pouring from large, mullioned windows, casting light across a manicured lawn and revealing ornate double doors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the entire image fading smoothly and completely to black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12455824762582779 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.249558210372925 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12455824762582779, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12455824762582779, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3448192775249481, + 0.18501703441143036, + 0.07765786349773407, + 0.06837275624275208, + 0.035677313804626465, + 0.1045282855629921, + 0.09381847828626633, + 0.023926764726638794, + 0.03765061870217323, + 0.028531571850180626 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12455824762582779 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perspective low and agile, moving along a long, straight driveway paved with dark, smooth asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are ancient, towering oaks visible on either side of the driveway forming a dense canopy with gnarled branches silhouetted against a twilight sky of purple and faded crimson?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera accelerate forward, causing the trees to blur into strips of darkness while approaching a three-story stone mansion with a neoclassical facade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the mansion illuminated by a warm, golden glow pouring from large, mullioned windows, casting light across a manicured lawn and revealing ornate double doors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the entire image fading smoothly and completely to black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.038131725043058395 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881317138671875 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.038131725043058395, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.038131725043058395, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.29576557874679565, + 0.2510527968406677, + 0.0660802349448204, + 0.11058129370212555, + 0.053423866629600525, + 0.07204347848892212, + 0.0777890756726265, + 0.034914374351501465, + 0.01854931376874447, + 0.01979989744722843 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.038131725043058395 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perspective low and agile, moving along a long, straight driveway paved with dark, smooth asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are ancient, towering oaks visible on either side of the driveway forming a dense canopy with gnarled branches silhouetted against a twilight sky of purple and faded crimson?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera accelerate forward, causing the trees to blur into strips of darkness while approaching a three-story stone mansion with a neoclassical facade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the mansion illuminated by a warm, golden glow pouring from large, mullioned windows, casting light across a manicured lawn and revealing ornate double doors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the entire image fading smoothly and completely to black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01818285696208477 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018182754516602 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01818285696208477, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01818285696208477, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1492922157049179, + 0.14452576637268066, + 0.08281852304935455, + 0.08860836923122406, + 0.04142940416932106, + 0.09398438036441803, + 0.24355991184711456, + 0.03854752331972122, + 0.06316804140806198, + 0.05406588315963745 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01818285696208477 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perspective low and agile, moving along a long, straight driveway paved with dark, smooth asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are ancient, towering oaks visible on either side of the driveway forming a dense canopy with gnarled branches silhouetted against a twilight sky of purple and faded crimson?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera accelerate forward, causing the trees to blur into strips of darkness while approaching a three-story stone mansion with a neoclassical facade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the mansion illuminated by a warm, golden glow pouring from large, mullioned windows, casting light across a manicured lawn and revealing ornate double doors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the entire image fading smoothly and completely to black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011080164462327957 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511080265045166 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011080164462327957, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011080164462327957, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1393360197544098, + 0.07125085592269897, + 0.11708585172891617, + 0.09553783386945724, + 0.11848755180835724, + 0.10297691822052002, + 0.16260145604610443, + 0.08441226184368134, + 0.05958929657936096, + 0.04872194677591324 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011080164462327957 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perspective low and agile, moving along a long, straight driveway paved with dark, smooth asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are ancient, towering oaks visible on either side of the driveway forming a dense canopy with gnarled branches silhouetted against a twilight sky of purple and faded crimson?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera accelerate forward, causing the trees to blur into strips of darkness while approaching a three-story stone mansion with a neoclassical facade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the mansion illuminated by a warm, golden glow pouring from large, mullioned windows, casting light across a manicured lawn and revealing ornate double doors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the entire image fading smoothly and completely to black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20156584680080414 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7015658617019653 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20156584680080414, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20156584680080414, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11072447150945663, + 0.09172385185956955, + 0.09470925480127335, + 0.05235784128308296, + 0.07420532405376434, + 0.0790458619594574, + 0.06235748156905174, + 0.13549116253852844, + 0.15965956449508667, + 0.13972517848014832 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20156584680080414 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "From a low, agile perspective, the camera accelerates along a long, straight driveway paved with dark, smooth asphalt. On either side, a row of ancient, towering oaks forms a dense canopy, their gnarled branches silhouetted against the deep twilight sky, painted in hues of purple and faded crimson. As the camera moves relentlessly forward, the trees blur into strips of darkness, creating a sense of urgent arrival. At the end of the driveway, a magnificent three-story stone mansion dominates. Its stately neoclassical facade is illuminated by a warm, golden glow, which pours from each large, mullioned window, casting long, alluring rays of light across the manicured lawn. As the camera accelerates, drawing closer to the ornate double doors at the entrance, architectural details become sharp and clear. But just as the viewer is about to be enveloped by the mansion's overwhelming presence, the entire image fades smoothly and completely to black, immersing the moment of arrival in a profound mystery.", + "seed": 7161, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_12/index_7053_seed_7161_dp_24_rank_48_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.11047603599727154, + "vlm_logprob": -0.11047603599727154, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.025, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.11047603599727154, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perspective low and agile, moving along a long, straight driveway paved with dark, smooth asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are ancient, towering oaks visible on either side of the driveway forming a dense canopy with gnarled branches silhouetted against a twilight sky of purple and faded crimson?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera accelerate forward, causing the trees to blur into strips of darkness while approaching a three-story stone mansion with a neoclassical facade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the mansion illuminated by a warm, golden glow pouring from large, mullioned windows, casting light across a manicured lawn and revealing ornate double doors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the entire image fading smoothly and completely to black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07151585817337036 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8215157985687256 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07151585817337036, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07151585817337036, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24367915093898773, + 0.15256302058696747, + 0.1674998700618744, + 0.04727959260344505, + 0.07720311731100082, + 0.06553078442811966, + 0.055744290351867676, + 0.044578272849321365, + 0.044589344412088394, + 0.10133258998394012 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07151585817337036 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perspective low and agile, moving along a long, straight driveway paved with dark, smooth asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are ancient, towering oaks visible on either side of the driveway forming a dense canopy with gnarled branches silhouetted against a twilight sky of purple and faded crimson?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera accelerate forward, causing the trees to blur into strips of darkness while approaching a three-story stone mansion with a neoclassical facade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the mansion illuminated by a warm, golden glow pouring from large, mullioned windows, casting light across a manicured lawn and revealing ornate double doors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the entire image fading smoothly and completely to black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07006138563156128 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695061445236206 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07006138563156128, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07006138563156128, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1780005544424057, + 0.08615883439779282, + 0.21180234849452972, + 0.05700504407286644, + 0.05320574715733528, + 0.06006496027112007, + 0.10358453541994095, + 0.03707738220691681, + 0.043971020728349686, + 0.16912959516048431 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07006138563156128 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perspective low and agile, moving along a long, straight driveway paved with dark, smooth asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are ancient, towering oaks visible on either side of the driveway forming a dense canopy with gnarled branches silhouetted against a twilight sky of purple and faded crimson?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera accelerate forward, causing the trees to blur into strips of darkness while approaching a three-story stone mansion with a neoclassical facade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the mansion illuminated by a warm, golden glow pouring from large, mullioned windows, casting light across a manicured lawn and revealing ornate double doors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the entire image fading smoothly and completely to black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016062501817941666 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.1410627365112305 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016062501817941666, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016062501817941666, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18182259798049927, + 0.09819413721561432, + 0.08881247043609619, + 0.04881646856665611, + 0.04812246933579445, + 0.058409012854099274, + 0.12105292826890945, + 0.041080541908741, + 0.08291164040565491, + 0.23077766597270966 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016062501817941666 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perspective low and agile, moving along a long, straight driveway paved with dark, smooth asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are ancient, towering oaks visible on either side of the driveway forming a dense canopy with gnarled branches silhouetted against a twilight sky of purple and faded crimson?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera accelerate forward, causing the trees to blur into strips of darkness while approaching a three-story stone mansion with a neoclassical facade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the mansion illuminated by a warm, golden glow pouring from large, mullioned windows, casting light across a manicured lawn and revealing ornate double doors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the entire image fading smoothly and completely to black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007632853463292122 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882632732391357 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007632853463292122, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007632853463292122, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10257070511579514, + 0.12487967312335968, + 0.2248760312795639, + 0.04560523107647896, + 0.054873935878276825, + 0.04149942472577095, + 0.14962753653526306, + 0.06040855497121811, + 0.06674553453922272, + 0.12891337275505066 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007632853463292122 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perspective low and agile, moving along a long, straight driveway paved with dark, smooth asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are ancient, towering oaks visible on either side of the driveway forming a dense canopy with gnarled branches silhouetted against a twilight sky of purple and faded crimson?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera accelerate forward, causing the trees to blur into strips of darkness while approaching a three-story stone mansion with a neoclassical facade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the mansion illuminated by a warm, golden glow pouring from large, mullioned windows, casting light across a manicured lawn and revealing ornate double doors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the entire image fading smoothly and completely to black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.38710758090019226 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1371076107025146 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.38710758090019226, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.38710758090019226, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25148406624794006, + 0.25460097193717957, + 0.059381987899541855, + 0.04863623529672623, + 0.03410297632217407, + 0.05303677171468735, + 0.07680587470531464, + 0.06487611681222916, + 0.07113999128341675, + 0.08593504130840302 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.38710758090019226 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "From a low, agile perspective, the camera accelerates along a long, straight driveway paved with dark, smooth asphalt. On either side, a row of ancient, towering oaks forms a dense canopy, their gnarled branches silhouetted against the deep twilight sky, painted in hues of purple and faded crimson. As the camera moves relentlessly forward, the trees blur into strips of darkness, creating a sense of urgent arrival. At the end of the driveway, a magnificent three-story stone mansion dominates. Its stately neoclassical facade is illuminated by a warm, golden glow, which pours from each large, mullioned window, casting long, alluring rays of light across the manicured lawn. As the camera accelerates, drawing closer to the ornate double doors at the entrance, architectural details become sharp and clear. But just as the viewer is about to be enveloped by the mansion's overwhelming presence, the entire image fades smoothly and completely to black, immersing the moment of arrival in a profound mystery.", + "seed": 7162, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_12/index_7053_seed_7162_dp_25_rank_50_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.11953147435560822, + "vlm_logprob": -0.11953147435560822, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.5, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.11953147435560822, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perspective low and agile, moving along a long, straight driveway paved with dark, smooth asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are ancient, towering oaks visible on either side of the driveway forming a dense canopy with gnarled branches silhouetted against a twilight sky of purple and faded crimson?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera accelerate forward, causing the trees to blur into strips of darkness while approaching a three-story stone mansion with a neoclassical facade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the mansion illuminated by a warm, golden glow pouring from large, mullioned windows, casting light across a manicured lawn and revealing ornate double doors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the entire image fading smoothly and completely to black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04120674729347229 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4162068367004395 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04120674729347229, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04120674729347229, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22287456691265106, + 0.07590653747320175, + 0.036198366433382034, + 0.04512309655547142, + 0.0768229141831398, + 0.09351706504821777, + 0.09667608886957169, + 0.16933922469615936, + 0.0806802287697792, + 0.1028619185090065 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04120674729347229 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perspective low and agile, moving along a long, straight driveway paved with dark, smooth asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are ancient, towering oaks visible on either side of the driveway forming a dense canopy with gnarled branches silhouetted against a twilight sky of purple and faded crimson?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera accelerate forward, causing the trees to blur into strips of darkness while approaching a three-story stone mansion with a neoclassical facade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the mansion illuminated by a warm, golden glow pouring from large, mullioned windows, casting light across a manicured lawn and revealing ornate double doors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the entire image fading smoothly and completely to black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016089484095573425 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.14108943939209 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016089484095573425, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016089484095573425, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21386121213436127, + 0.06581972539424896, + 0.04729538410902023, + 0.04319864511489868, + 0.020227354019880295, + 0.01806531473994255, + 0.04565436393022537, + 0.16446851193904877, + 0.2204086184501648, + 0.1610008031129837 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016089484095573425 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perspective low and agile, moving along a long, straight driveway paved with dark, smooth asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are ancient, towering oaks visible on either side of the driveway forming a dense canopy with gnarled branches silhouetted against a twilight sky of purple and faded crimson?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera accelerate forward, causing the trees to blur into strips of darkness while approaching a three-story stone mansion with a neoclassical facade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the mansion illuminated by a warm, golden glow pouring from large, mullioned windows, casting light across a manicured lawn and revealing ornate double doors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the entire image fading smoothly and completely to black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011071793735027313 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511071681976318 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011071793735027313, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011071793735027313, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13060961663722992, + 0.04695911705493927, + 0.03363173082470894, + 0.06243889033794403, + 0.06164230778813362, + 0.10363249480724335, + 0.10046133399009705, + 0.24978165328502655, + 0.05828434228897095, + 0.15255847573280334 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011071793735027313 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perspective low and agile, moving along a long, straight driveway paved with dark, smooth asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are ancient, towering oaks visible on either side of the driveway forming a dense canopy with gnarled branches silhouetted against a twilight sky of purple and faded crimson?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera accelerate forward, causing the trees to blur into strips of darkness while approaching a three-story stone mansion with a neoclassical facade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the mansion illuminated by a warm, golden glow pouring from large, mullioned windows, casting light across a manicured lawn and revealing ornate double doors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the entire image fading smoothly and completely to black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005947392899543047 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130947589874268 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005947392899543047, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005947392899543047, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09284572303295135, + 0.04648208245635033, + 0.05619420111179352, + 0.0825786367058754, + 0.06449223309755325, + 0.04020044580101967, + 0.0913805142045021, + 0.20666098594665527, + 0.06500906497240067, + 0.2541561722755432 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005947392899543047 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perspective low and agile, moving along a long, straight driveway paved with dark, smooth asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are ancient, towering oaks visible on either side of the driveway forming a dense canopy with gnarled branches silhouetted against a twilight sky of purple and faded crimson?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera accelerate forward, causing the trees to blur into strips of darkness while approaching a three-story stone mansion with a neoclassical facade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the mansion illuminated by a warm, golden glow pouring from large, mullioned windows, casting light across a manicured lawn and revealing ornate double doors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the entire image fading smoothly and completely to black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.523341953754425 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.898341953754425 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.523341953754425, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.523341953754425, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11985578387975693, + 0.06478838622570038, + 0.07422307133674622, + 0.08509571105241776, + 0.09984032809734344, + 0.07130809128284454, + 0.14163543283939362, + 0.16425417363643646, + 0.08838943392038345, + 0.0906095951795578 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.523341953754425 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "From a low, agile perspective, the camera accelerates along a long, straight driveway paved with dark, smooth asphalt. On either side, a row of ancient, towering oaks forms a dense canopy, their gnarled branches silhouetted against the deep twilight sky, painted in hues of purple and faded crimson. As the camera moves relentlessly forward, the trees blur into strips of darkness, creating a sense of urgent arrival. At the end of the driveway, a magnificent three-story stone mansion dominates. Its stately neoclassical facade is illuminated by a warm, golden glow, which pours from each large, mullioned window, casting long, alluring rays of light across the manicured lawn. As the camera accelerates, drawing closer to the ornate double doors at the entrance, architectural details become sharp and clear. But just as the viewer is about to be enveloped by the mansion's overwhelming presence, the entire image fades smoothly and completely to black, immersing the moment of arrival in a profound mystery.", + "seed": 7163, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_12/index_7053_seed_7163_dp_25_rank_50_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.15288217831403017, + "vlm_logprob": -0.15288217831403017, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.975, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.15288217831403017, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perspective low and agile, moving along a long, straight driveway paved with dark, smooth asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are ancient, towering oaks visible on either side of the driveway forming a dense canopy with gnarled branches silhouetted against a twilight sky of purple and faded crimson?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera accelerate forward, causing the trees to blur into strips of darkness while approaching a three-story stone mansion with a neoclassical facade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the mansion illuminated by a warm, golden glow pouring from large, mullioned windows, casting light across a manicured lawn and revealing ornate double doors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the entire image fading smoothly and completely to black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12210674583911896 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2471067905426025 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12210674583911896, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12210674583911896, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3001306354999542, + 0.07555749267339706, + 0.06867948919534683, + 0.06249818950891495, + 0.06721324473619461, + 0.05772710219025612, + 0.08668844401836395, + 0.07326669991016388, + 0.11354311555624008, + 0.0946955531835556 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12210674583911896 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perspective low and agile, moving along a long, straight driveway paved with dark, smooth asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are ancient, towering oaks visible on either side of the driveway forming a dense canopy with gnarled branches silhouetted against a twilight sky of purple and faded crimson?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera accelerate forward, causing the trees to blur into strips of darkness while approaching a three-story stone mansion with a neoclassical facade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the mansion illuminated by a warm, golden glow pouring from large, mullioned windows, casting light across a manicured lawn and revealing ornate double doors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the entire image fading smoothly and completely to black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04870133101940155 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048701286315918 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04870133101940155, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04870133101940155, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4708661139011383, + 0.07756001502275467, + 0.0550382174551487, + 0.029990633949637413, + 0.05098230391740799, + 0.041685380041599274, + 0.0784914568066597, + 0.06206602230668068, + 0.06372620165348053, + 0.06959366798400879 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04870133101940155 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perspective low and agile, moving along a long, straight driveway paved with dark, smooth asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are ancient, towering oaks visible on either side of the driveway forming a dense canopy with gnarled branches silhouetted against a twilight sky of purple and faded crimson?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera accelerate forward, causing the trees to blur into strips of darkness while approaching a three-story stone mansion with a neoclassical facade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the mansion illuminated by a warm, golden glow pouring from large, mullioned windows, casting light across a manicured lawn and revealing ornate double doors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the entire image fading smoothly and completely to black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007627766579389572 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882627964019775 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007627766579389572, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007627766579389572, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2002830058336258, + 0.07433027029037476, + 0.0446915440261364, + 0.08621349930763245, + 0.07985809445381165, + 0.04122006148099899, + 0.06947382539510727, + 0.06840634346008301, + 0.15233683586120605, + 0.18318653106689453 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007627766579389572 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perspective low and agile, moving along a long, straight driveway paved with dark, smooth asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are ancient, towering oaks visible on either side of the driveway forming a dense canopy with gnarled branches silhouetted against a twilight sky of purple and faded crimson?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera accelerate forward, causing the trees to blur into strips of darkness while approaching a three-story stone mansion with a neoclassical facade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the mansion illuminated by a warm, golden glow pouring from large, mullioned windows, casting light across a manicured lawn and revealing ornate double doors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the entire image fading smoothly and completely to black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009786483831703663 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634786605834961 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009786483831703663, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009786483831703663, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19465096294879913, + 0.10748768597841263, + 0.10938682407140732, + 0.03067926876246929, + 0.0370764285326004, + 0.07421202212572098, + 0.07988227158784866, + 0.067422054708004, + 0.14304684102535248, + 0.15615566074848175 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009786483831703663 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perspective low and agile, moving along a long, straight driveway paved with dark, smooth asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are ancient, towering oaks visible on either side of the driveway forming a dense canopy with gnarled branches silhouetted against a twilight sky of purple and faded crimson?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera accelerate forward, causing the trees to blur into strips of darkness while approaching a three-story stone mansion with a neoclassical facade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the mansion illuminated by a warm, golden glow pouring from large, mullioned windows, casting light across a manicured lawn and revealing ornate double doors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the entire image fading smoothly and completely to black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5761885643005371 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8261885643005371 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5761885643005371, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5761885643005371, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14782626926898956, + 0.15359115600585938, + 0.060571592301130295, + 0.04935533553361893, + 0.0427757166326046, + 0.09064178913831711, + 0.04418205842375755, + 0.08895760029554367, + 0.10834278911352158, + 0.21375569701194763 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5761885643005371 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_13/index_tensor([6769, 6769])_group_13_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_13/index_tensor([6769, 6769])_group_13_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..9e2cf4d1dcb19fb1a0f1d5c4c1731fdefee0e55c --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_13/index_tensor([6769, 6769])_group_13_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "slow, horizontal, medium shot draws the viewer's attention to a programmer trapped in a late-night office. He's in his twenties, with short, dark hair slightly disheveled from long hours, and wears a loose-fitting, dark blue hooded sweatshirt. In the empty, silent office space, the only light comes from the laptop screen in front of him. Its cold, bluish-white light mercilessly illuminates his pained face, casting deep shadows around his furrowed brow and closed eyes. He clutches his head in agony, his hands tangled in his hair, his elbows resting on his cluttered desk, his body slumped slightly forward in exhaustion. An empty coffee mug and several crumpled sheets of scrap paper lie scattered on his desk. The laptop screen before him was densely packed with complex code. Syntax highlighting in various colors (green, white, orange) intertwined to form a daunting wall of text. A blinking cursor hovered over a critical line of error code, silently mocking his failure. The entire scene, dominated by cold blues and deep blacks, created a tense atmosphere of extreme concentration, isolation, and impending collapse.", + "seed": 13492, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_13/index_6769_seed_13492_dp_26_rank_52_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.04526160419918597, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04526160419918597, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.65, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04526160419918597, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot showing a programmer in a late-night office?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the programmer wearing a loose-fitting, dark blue hooded sweatshirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit primarily by the cold, bluish-white light of a laptop screen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the programmer clutching his head with hands tangled in his hair while slumped forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the laptop screen displaying dense code with syntax highlighting in green, white, and orange?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011983191594481468 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.636983394622803 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011983191594481468, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011983191594481468, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1543484479188919, + 0.1422635316848755, + 0.21244443953037262, + 0.08897808194160461, + 0.05910326912999153, + 0.04711487516760826, + 0.05259939283132553, + 0.06811210513114929, + 0.06900181621313095, + 0.10603400319814682 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011983191594481468 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot showing a programmer in a late-night office?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the programmer wearing a loose-fitting, dark blue hooded sweatshirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit primarily by the cold, bluish-white light of a laptop screen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the programmer clutching his head with hands tangled in his hair while slumped forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the laptop screen displaying dense code with syntax highlighting in green, white, and orange?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06208234280347824 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812082290649414 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06208234280347824, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06208234280347824, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21379408240318298, + 0.05420931056141853, + 0.050400976091623306, + 0.08701023459434509, + 0.07080794870853424, + 0.04037075862288475, + 0.02840386889874935, + 0.059911444783210754, + 0.09962260723114014, + 0.2954687476158142 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06208234280347824 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot showing a programmer in a late-night office?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the programmer wearing a loose-fitting, dark blue hooded sweatshirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit primarily by the cold, bluish-white light of a laptop screen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the programmer clutching his head with hands tangled in his hair while slumped forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the laptop screen displaying dense code with syntax highlighting in green, white, and orange?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0031986285466700792 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753198623657227 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0031986285466700792, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0031986285466700792, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18242007493972778, + 0.09756408631801605, + 0.15738171339035034, + 0.18055063486099243, + 0.05869858339428902, + 0.059743732213974, + 0.010549752973020077, + 0.03131008893251419, + 0.03460323065519333, + 0.1871780902147293 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0031986285466700792 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot showing a programmer in a late-night office?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the programmer wearing a loose-fitting, dark blue hooded sweatshirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit primarily by the cold, bluish-white light of a laptop screen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the programmer clutching his head with hands tangled in his hair while slumped forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the laptop screen displaying dense code with syntax highlighting in green, white, and orange?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07899803668260574 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.57899808883667 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07899803668260574, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07899803668260574, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1997978240251541, + 0.05085314065217972, + 0.043341804295778275, + 0.16709771752357483, + 0.062457069754600525, + 0.042759496718645096, + 0.03637782856822014, + 0.058038804680109024, + 0.1068975031375885, + 0.2323787659406662 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07899803668260574 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot showing a programmer in a late-night office?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the programmer wearing a loose-fitting, dark blue hooded sweatshirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit primarily by the cold, bluish-white light of a laptop screen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the programmer clutching his head with hands tangled in his hair while slumped forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the laptop screen displaying dense code with syntax highlighting in green, white, and orange?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0700458213686943 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950457096099854 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0700458213686943, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0700458213686943, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1978197991847992, + 0.06848053634166718, + 0.05624617263674736, + 0.08089600503444672, + 0.10115452110767365, + 0.041315339505672455, + 0.020600125193595886, + 0.04837716370820999, + 0.10799194127321243, + 0.27711838483810425 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0700458213686943 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow, horizontal, medium shot draws the viewer's attention to a programmer trapped in a late-night office. He's in his twenties, with short, dark hair slightly disheveled from long hours, and wears a loose-fitting, dark blue hooded sweatshirt. In the empty, silent office space, the only light comes from the laptop screen in front of him. Its cold, bluish-white light mercilessly illuminates his pained face, casting deep shadows around his furrowed brow and closed eyes. He clutches his head in agony, his hands tangled in his hair, his elbows resting on his cluttered desk, his body slumped slightly forward in exhaustion. An empty coffee mug and several crumpled sheets of scrap paper lie scattered on his desk. The laptop screen before him was densely packed with complex code. Syntax highlighting in various colors (green, white, orange) intertwined to form a daunting wall of text. A blinking cursor hovered over a critical line of error code, silently mocking his failure. The entire scene, dominated by cold blues and deep blacks, created a tense atmosphere of extreme concentration, isolation, and impending collapse.", + "seed": 13493, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_13/index_6769_seed_13493_dp_26_rank_52_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.03678891221061349, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03678891221061349, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.75, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03678891221061349, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot showing a programmer in a late-night office?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the programmer wearing a loose-fitting, dark blue hooded sweatshirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit primarily by the cold, bluish-white light of a laptop screen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the programmer clutching his head with hands tangled in his hair while slumped forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the laptop screen displaying dense code with syntax highlighting in green, white, and orange?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.021233031526207924 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.896233081817627 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.021233031526207924, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.021233031526207924, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12513647973537445, + 0.1782768964767456, + 0.04928765073418617, + 0.1064567044377327, + 0.03133993223309517, + 0.10772119462490082, + 0.1563328355550766, + 0.08161786943674088, + 0.057016536593437195, + 0.10681387037038803 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.021233031526207924 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot showing a programmer in a late-night office?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the programmer wearing a loose-fitting, dark blue hooded sweatshirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit primarily by the cold, bluish-white light of a laptop screen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the programmer clutching his head with hands tangled in his hair while slumped forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the laptop screen displaying dense code with syntax highlighting in green, white, and orange?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.043087948113679886 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168087959289551 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.043087948113679886, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.043087948113679886, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06372898817062378, + 0.16064399480819702, + 0.04945480823516846, + 0.04448389634490013, + 0.029179494827985764, + 0.08461065590381622, + 0.19413168728351593, + 0.19970256090164185, + 0.03254198282957077, + 0.1415218859910965 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.043087948113679886 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot showing a programmer in a late-night office?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the programmer wearing a loose-fitting, dark blue hooded sweatshirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit primarily by the cold, bluish-white light of a laptop screen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the programmer clutching his head with hands tangled in his hair while slumped forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the laptop screen displaying dense code with syntax highlighting in green, white, and orange?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0024952725507318974 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002495288848877 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0024952725507318974, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0024952725507318974, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16636130213737488, + 0.12808078527450562, + 0.06152833253145218, + 0.09888360649347305, + 0.10319848358631134, + 0.057503592222929, + 0.05930480360984802, + 0.07079379260540009, + 0.053217869251966476, + 0.20112743973731995 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0024952725507318974 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot showing a programmer in a late-night office?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the programmer wearing a loose-fitting, dark blue hooded sweatshirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit primarily by the cold, bluish-white light of a laptop screen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the programmer clutching his head with hands tangled in his hair while slumped forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the laptop screen displaying dense code with syntax highlighting in green, white, and orange?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07900255173444748 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.579002618789673 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07900255173444748, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07900255173444748, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0840897411108017, + 0.027820244431495667, + 0.04869818687438965, + 0.0801657885313034, + 0.04629538953304291, + 0.10646484792232513, + 0.08632979542016983, + 0.06689458340406418, + 0.05407058447599411, + 0.39917078614234924 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07900255173444748 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot showing a programmer in a late-night office?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the programmer wearing a loose-fitting, dark blue hooded sweatshirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit primarily by the cold, bluish-white light of a laptop screen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the programmer clutching his head with hands tangled in his hair while slumped forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the laptop screen displaying dense code with syntax highlighting in green, white, and orange?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03812575712800026 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.28812575340271 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03812575712800026, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03812575712800026, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11604433506727219, + 0.11920717358589172, + 0.13237673044204712, + 0.047003064304590225, + 0.05557377636432648, + 0.14122553169727325, + 0.08813025802373886, + 0.10783784836530685, + 0.051155850291252136, + 0.14144538342952728 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 5, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03812575712800026 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow, horizontal, medium shot draws the viewer's attention to a programmer trapped in a late-night office. He's in his twenties, with short, dark hair slightly disheveled from long hours, and wears a loose-fitting, dark blue hooded sweatshirt. In the empty, silent office space, the only light comes from the laptop screen in front of him. Its cold, bluish-white light mercilessly illuminates his pained face, casting deep shadows around his furrowed brow and closed eyes. He clutches his head in agony, his hands tangled in his hair, his elbows resting on his cluttered desk, his body slumped slightly forward in exhaustion. An empty coffee mug and several crumpled sheets of scrap paper lie scattered on his desk. The laptop screen before him was densely packed with complex code. Syntax highlighting in various colors (green, white, orange) intertwined to form a daunting wall of text. A blinking cursor hovered over a critical line of error code, silently mocking his failure. The entire scene, dominated by cold blues and deep blacks, created a tense atmosphere of extreme concentration, isolation, and impending collapse.", + "seed": 13494, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_13/index_6769_seed_13494_dp_27_rank_54_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.035092587349936366, + "vlm_logprob": -0.035092587349936366, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.0, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.035092587349936366, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot showing a programmer in a late-night office?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the programmer wearing a loose-fitting, dark blue hooded sweatshirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit primarily by the cold, bluish-white light of a laptop screen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the programmer clutching his head with hands tangled in his hair while slumped forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the laptop screen displaying dense code with syntax highlighting in green, white, and orange?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009141968563199043 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.88414192199707 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009141968563199043, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009141968563199043, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20460446178913116, + 0.05645202845335007, + 0.07908085733652115, + 0.06762204319238663, + 0.09312912076711655, + 0.13939346373081207, + 0.05812191590666771, + 0.061887532472610474, + 0.06452442705631256, + 0.1751841902732849 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009141968563199043 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot showing a programmer in a late-night office?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the programmer wearing a loose-fitting, dark blue hooded sweatshirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit primarily by the cold, bluish-white light of a laptop screen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the programmer clutching his head with hands tangled in his hair while slumped forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the laptop screen displaying dense code with syntax highlighting in green, white, and orange?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029814405366778374 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298144817352295 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029814405366778374, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029814405366778374, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0949188619852066, + 0.04849221557378769, + 0.1346287578344345, + 0.08402229845523834, + 0.1882399022579193, + 0.21355262398719788, + 0.03718246519565582, + 0.05568857491016388, + 0.03541409596800804, + 0.10786022245883942 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029814405366778374 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot showing a programmer in a late-night office?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the programmer wearing a loose-fitting, dark blue hooded sweatshirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit primarily by the cold, bluish-white light of a laptop screen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the programmer clutching his head with hands tangled in his hair while slumped forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the laptop screen displaying dense code with syntax highlighting in green, white, and orange?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0024925374891608953 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002492427825928 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0024925374891608953, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0024925374891608953, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18609343469142914, + 0.07012572139501572, + 0.09339866787195206, + 0.06644973903894424, + 0.1045970693230629, + 0.08738186955451965, + 0.18150784075260162, + 0.06135297194123268, + 0.07042460143566132, + 0.07866818457841873 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0024925374891608953 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot showing a programmer in a late-night office?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the programmer wearing a loose-fitting, dark blue hooded sweatshirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit primarily by the cold, bluish-white light of a laptop screen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the programmer clutching his head with hands tangled in his hair while slumped forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the laptop screen displaying dense code with syntax highlighting in green, white, and orange?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10031258314847946 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3503124713897705 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10031258314847946, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10031258314847946, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06509964168071747, + 0.04858086630702019, + 0.11787547171115875, + 0.09593640267848969, + 0.1538345217704773, + 0.14923575520515442, + 0.07669059187173843, + 0.06983522325754166, + 0.0427166149020195, + 0.1801948994398117 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10031258314847946 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot showing a programmer in a late-night office?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the programmer wearing a loose-fitting, dark blue hooded sweatshirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit primarily by the cold, bluish-white light of a laptop screen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the programmer clutching his head with hands tangled in his hair while slumped forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the laptop screen displaying dense code with syntax highlighting in green, white, and orange?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.033701442182064056 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4087014198303223 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.033701442182064056, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.033701442182064056, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19082166254520416, + 0.052071843296289444, + 0.07418765872716904, + 0.1378389298915863, + 0.1518346518278122, + 0.11473099887371063, + 0.059783000499010086, + 0.1346132755279541, + 0.02974640391767025, + 0.054371610283851624 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.033701442182064056 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow, horizontal, medium shot draws the viewer's attention to a programmer trapped in a late-night office. He's in his twenties, with short, dark hair slightly disheveled from long hours, and wears a loose-fitting, dark blue hooded sweatshirt. In the empty, silent office space, the only light comes from the laptop screen in front of him. Its cold, bluish-white light mercilessly illuminates his pained face, casting deep shadows around his furrowed brow and closed eyes. He clutches his head in agony, his hands tangled in his hair, his elbows resting on his cluttered desk, his body slumped slightly forward in exhaustion. An empty coffee mug and several crumpled sheets of scrap paper lie scattered on his desk. The laptop screen before him was densely packed with complex code. Syntax highlighting in various colors (green, white, orange) intertwined to form a daunting wall of text. A blinking cursor hovered over a critical line of error code, silently mocking his failure. The entire scene, dominated by cold blues and deep blacks, created a tense atmosphere of extreme concentration, isolation, and impending collapse.", + "seed": 13495, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_13/index_6769_seed_13495_dp_27_rank_54_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.026777894841507076, + "vlm_logprob": -0.026777894841507076, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.3, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.026777894841507076, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot showing a programmer in a late-night office?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the programmer wearing a loose-fitting, dark blue hooded sweatshirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit primarily by the cold, bluish-white light of a laptop screen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the programmer clutching his head with hands tangled in his hair while slumped forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the laptop screen displaying dense code with syntax highlighting in green, white, and orange?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009551186114549637 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.759551048278809 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009551186114549637, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009551186114549637, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18246212601661682, + 0.06741049140691757, + 0.0908837765455246, + 0.03503689169883728, + 0.07301190495491028, + 0.20303380489349365, + 0.08679188042879105, + 0.03519761562347412, + 0.03801066800951958, + 0.18816089630126953 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009551186114549637 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot showing a programmer in a late-night office?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the programmer wearing a loose-fitting, dark blue hooded sweatshirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit primarily by the cold, bluish-white light of a laptop screen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the programmer clutching his head with hands tangled in his hair while slumped forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the laptop screen displaying dense code with syntax highlighting in green, white, and orange?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018193040043115616 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018193244934082 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018193040043115616, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018193040043115616, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07917004823684692, + 0.0934346616268158, + 0.10194918513298035, + 0.04799984022974968, + 0.08935945481061935, + 0.08751985430717468, + 0.04666648432612419, + 0.2830128073692322, + 0.03943387418985367, + 0.1314537078142166 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018193040043115616 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot showing a programmer in a late-night office?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the programmer wearing a loose-fitting, dark blue hooded sweatshirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit primarily by the cold, bluish-white light of a laptop screen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the programmer clutching his head with hands tangled in his hair while slumped forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the laptop screen displaying dense code with syntax highlighting in green, white, and orange?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0010425376240164042 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.876042366027832 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0010425376240164042, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0010425376240164042, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1330486685037613, + 0.08089951425790787, + 0.10837559401988983, + 0.07891122996807098, + 0.12112712860107422, + 0.16246174275875092, + 0.11758481711149216, + 0.05704610049724579, + 0.040485333651304245, + 0.10005989670753479 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0010425376240164042 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot showing a programmer in a late-night office?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the programmer wearing a loose-fitting, dark blue hooded sweatshirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit primarily by the cold, bluish-white light of a laptop screen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the programmer clutching his head with hands tangled in his hair while slumped forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the laptop screen displaying dense code with syntax highlighting in green, white, and orange?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06204582005739212 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120458126068115 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06204582005739212, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06204582005739212, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06516750901937485, + 0.05010491982102394, + 0.07519881427288055, + 0.05744750052690506, + 0.15825413167476654, + 0.11335702240467072, + 0.0465983971953392, + 0.25163552165031433, + 0.043059054762125015, + 0.1391771286725998 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06204582005739212 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot showing a programmer in a late-night office?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the programmer wearing a loose-fitting, dark blue hooded sweatshirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit primarily by the cold, bluish-white light of a laptop screen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the programmer clutching his head with hands tangled in his hair while slumped forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the laptop screen displaying dense code with syntax highlighting in green, white, and orange?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04305689036846161 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680569648742676 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04305689036846161, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04305689036846161, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16154327988624573, + 0.07184964418411255, + 0.12139157950878143, + 0.07952919602394104, + 0.07213330268859863, + 0.2443867176771164, + 0.0633658617734909, + 0.060396600514650345, + 0.03527793660759926, + 0.0901259109377861 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04305689036846161 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_14/index_tensor([4825, 4825])_group_14_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_14/index_tensor([4825, 4825])_group_14_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..fe8a93e9f377e27aad61df40532f163fb09d3800 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_14/index_tensor([4825, 4825])_group_14_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up, static shot, level with the combatants, captures the raw power of a dramatic battle between two giant coconut crabs. Their powerful pincers lock in the exact center of the frame, the immense pressure causing their entire bodies to tremble in a silent, unyielding struggle for dominance. Surreal macroscopic detail reveals every nuance of their armored exoskeletons; the deep, iridescent purples and fiery oranges of their chitin plates are rendered with breathtaking clarity, showcasing the intricate network of ridges, pits, and fine bristles that give their bodies an almost alien texture. Spotted sunlight filtering through the unseen jungle canopy casts sharp, dramatic highlights and deep shadows across their forms, underscoring the sheer force as one crab's pincers slowly and powerfully rub against the other's. Their spiked eyes twitch with focused aggression, while their spiny legs dig deep into the dark, fertile soil and scattered leaf litter beneath the surface, poised for leverage in a tense, visceral, and perfectly focused confrontation.", + "seed": 23312, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_14/index_4825_seed_23312_dp_28_rank_56_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.18588539399206638, + "vlm_logprob": -0.18588539399206638, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.575, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.18588539399206638, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of two giant coconut crabs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the crabs' pincers locked in the exact center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the crabs display deep iridescent purple and fiery orange colors on their exoskeletons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static and level with the combatants?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is one crab's pincer slowly rubbing against the other's while their bodies tremble?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.051107585430145264 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.05110764503479 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.051107585430145264, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.051107585430145264, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09841189533472061, + 0.09744647145271301, + 0.04624508321285248, + 0.05564011260867119, + 0.2218025177717209, + 0.06239200383424759, + 0.1954093873500824, + 0.059589337557554245, + 0.0722237080335617, + 0.09083948284387589 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.051107585430145264 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of two giant coconut crabs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the crabs' pincers locked in the exact center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the crabs display deep iridescent purple and fiery orange colors on their exoskeletons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static and level with the combatants?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is one crab's pincer slowly rubbing against the other's while their bodies tremble?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7578513622283936 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6328513622283936 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.7578513622283936, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.7578513622283936, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1718711256980896, + 0.10567969083786011, + 0.06320511549711227, + 0.09280205518007278, + 0.12353292852640152, + 0.048762377351522446, + 0.1550855040550232, + 0.1276138424873352, + 0.055615004152059555, + 0.05583237111568451 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.7578513622283936 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of two giant coconut crabs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the crabs' pincers locked in the exact center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the crabs display deep iridescent purple and fiery orange colors on their exoskeletons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static and level with the combatants?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is one crab's pincer slowly rubbing against the other's while their bodies tremble?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020601576194167137 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895601511001587 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020601576194167137, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020601576194167137, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11176598072052002, + 0.16051724553108215, + 0.0314851850271225, + 0.10642228275537491, + 0.12617479264736176, + 0.1024184450507164, + 0.14068247377872467, + 0.07910805940628052, + 0.09710921347141266, + 0.04431635141372681 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020601576194167137 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of two giant coconut crabs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the crabs' pincers locked in the exact center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the crabs display deep iridescent purple and fiery orange colors on their exoskeletons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static and level with the combatants?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is one crab's pincer slowly rubbing against the other's while their bodies tremble?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07004949450492859 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695049524307251 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07004949450492859, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07004949450492859, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22245556116104126, + 0.12481284141540527, + 0.04461401328444481, + 0.04636413976550102, + 0.31848111748695374, + 0.09887000918388367, + 0.06414639204740524, + 0.024438509717583656, + 0.031093673780560493, + 0.024723807349801064 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07004949450492859 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of two giant coconut crabs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the crabs' pincers locked in the exact center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the crabs display deep iridescent purple and fiery orange colors on their exoskeletons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static and level with the combatants?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is one crab's pincer slowly rubbing against the other's while their bodies tremble?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029816951602697372 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298168659210205 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029816951602697372, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029816951602697372, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09903014451265335, + 0.08182398229837418, + 0.034917835146188736, + 0.04798018932342529, + 0.3184773325920105, + 0.16493932902812958, + 0.0758783146739006, + 0.02458888664841652, + 0.10832953453063965, + 0.04403438791632652 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029816951602697372 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up, static shot, level with the combatants, captures the raw power of a dramatic battle between two giant coconut crabs. Their powerful pincers lock in the exact center of the frame, the immense pressure causing their entire bodies to tremble in a silent, unyielding struggle for dominance. Surreal macroscopic detail reveals every nuance of their armored exoskeletons; the deep, iridescent purples and fiery oranges of their chitin plates are rendered with breathtaking clarity, showcasing the intricate network of ridges, pits, and fine bristles that give their bodies an almost alien texture. Spotted sunlight filtering through the unseen jungle canopy casts sharp, dramatic highlights and deep shadows across their forms, underscoring the sheer force as one crab's pincers slowly and powerfully rub against the other's. Their spiked eyes twitch with focused aggression, while their spiny legs dig deep into the dark, fertile soil and scattered leaf litter beneath the surface, poised for leverage in a tense, visceral, and perfectly focused confrontation.", + "seed": 23313, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_14/index_4825_seed_23313_dp_28_rank_56_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.18961259201169015, + "vlm_logprob": -0.18961259201169015, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.4, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.18961259201169015, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of two giant coconut crabs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the crabs' pincers locked in the exact center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the crabs display deep iridescent purple and fiery orange colors on their exoskeletons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static and level with the combatants?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is one crab's pincer slowly rubbing against the other's while their bodies tremble?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11859206110239029 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2435920238494873 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11859206110239029, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11859206110239029, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07854212075471878, + 0.07933132350444794, + 0.07317695766687393, + 0.06370651721954346, + 0.1414501816034317, + 0.058520372956991196, + 0.17380237579345703, + 0.09615948796272278, + 0.07793405652046204, + 0.15737669169902802 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11859206110239029 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of two giant coconut crabs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the crabs' pincers locked in the exact center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the crabs display deep iridescent purple and fiery orange colors on their exoskeletons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static and level with the combatants?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is one crab's pincer slowly rubbing against the other's while their bodies tremble?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6934210658073425 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6934210658073425 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.6934210658073425, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.6934210658073425, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04541383311152458, + 0.04123758524656296, + 0.03414801508188248, + 0.0600687675178051, + 0.0783894807100296, + 0.02522125653922558, + 0.6040490865707397, + 0.022417567670345306, + 0.03757758066058159, + 0.05147678032517433 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.6934210658073425 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of two giant coconut crabs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the crabs' pincers locked in the exact center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the crabs display deep iridescent purple and fiery orange colors on their exoskeletons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static and level with the combatants?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is one crab's pincer slowly rubbing against the other's while their bodies tremble?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02060706540942192 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8956069946289062 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02060706540942192, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02060706540942192, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06142304092645645, + 0.05989297106862068, + 0.03892217576503754, + 0.03552011400461197, + 0.126449316740036, + 0.01837882399559021, + 0.49414992332458496, + 0.040815651416778564, + 0.04044681042432785, + 0.08400124311447144 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02060706540942192 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of two giant coconut crabs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the crabs' pincers locked in the exact center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the crabs display deep iridescent purple and fiery orange colors on their exoskeletons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static and level with the combatants?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is one crab's pincer slowly rubbing against the other's while their bodies tremble?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08907381445169449 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.464073896408081 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08907381445169449, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08907381445169449, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06035944074392319, + 0.03243064507842064, + 0.022383294999599457, + 0.03582913801074028, + 0.13906598091125488, + 0.01340364571660757, + 0.6445106267929077, + 0.012181582860648632, + 0.01817978359758854, + 0.021655898541212082 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08907381445169449 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of two giant coconut crabs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the crabs' pincers locked in the exact center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the crabs display deep iridescent purple and fiery orange colors on their exoskeletons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static and level with the combatants?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is one crab's pincer slowly rubbing against the other's while their bodies tremble?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02636895328760147 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513688564300537 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02636895328760147, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02636895328760147, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06873505562543869, + 0.0247737355530262, + 0.04342099651694298, + 0.05276697501540184, + 0.08406469970941544, + 0.03205077350139618, + 0.5171841382980347, + 0.13092423975467682, + 0.015557785518467426, + 0.030521605163812637 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02636895328760147 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up, static shot, level with the combatants, captures the raw power of a dramatic battle between two giant coconut crabs. Their powerful pincers lock in the exact center of the frame, the immense pressure causing their entire bodies to tremble in a silent, unyielding struggle for dominance. Surreal macroscopic detail reveals every nuance of their armored exoskeletons; the deep, iridescent purples and fiery oranges of their chitin plates are rendered with breathtaking clarity, showcasing the intricate network of ridges, pits, and fine bristles that give their bodies an almost alien texture. Spotted sunlight filtering through the unseen jungle canopy casts sharp, dramatic highlights and deep shadows across their forms, underscoring the sheer force as one crab's pincers slowly and powerfully rub against the other's. Their spiked eyes twitch with focused aggression, while their spiny legs dig deep into the dark, fertile soil and scattered leaf litter beneath the surface, poised for leverage in a tense, visceral, and perfectly focused confrontation.", + "seed": 23314, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_14/index_4825_seed_23314_dp_29_rank_58_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.24702895246446133, + "vlm_logprob": -0.24702895246446133, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.1, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.24702895246446133, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of two giant coconut crabs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the crabs' pincers locked in the exact center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the crabs display deep iridescent purple and fiery orange colors on their exoskeletons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static and level with the combatants?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is one crab's pincer slowly rubbing against the other's while their bodies tremble?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16367506980895996 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.91367506980896 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16367506980895996, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16367506980895996, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11127707362174988, + 0.07540245354175568, + 0.05947377160191536, + 0.12293004989624023, + 0.1419840157032013, + 0.059112709015607834, + 0.1546846628189087, + 0.09855158627033234, + 0.10381314903497696, + 0.07277047634124756 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16367506980895996 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of two giant coconut crabs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the crabs' pincers locked in the exact center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the crabs display deep iridescent purple and fiery orange colors on their exoskeletons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static and level with the combatants?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is one crab's pincer slowly rubbing against the other's while their bodies tremble?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.89839768409729 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.52339768409729 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.89839768409729, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.89839768409729, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.085626520216465, + 0.059226930141448975, + 0.08341950178146362, + 0.037725597620010376, + 0.06508888304233551, + 0.07632073760032654, + 0.3198133409023285, + 0.10440562665462494, + 0.08519154787063599, + 0.08318133652210236 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.89839768409729 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of two giant coconut crabs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the crabs' pincers locked in the exact center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the crabs display deep iridescent purple and fiery orange colors on their exoskeletons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static and level with the combatants?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is one crab's pincer slowly rubbing against the other's while their bodies tremble?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02637499012053013 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513750553131104 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02637499012053013, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02637499012053013, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19628377258777618, + 0.18329936265945435, + 0.052884962409734726, + 0.07517216354608536, + 0.08533312380313873, + 0.038782160729169846, + 0.09415090084075928, + 0.11537692695856094, + 0.08242595195770264, + 0.07629067450761795 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02637499012053013 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of two giant coconut crabs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the crabs' pincers locked in the exact center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the crabs display deep iridescent purple and fiery orange colors on their exoskeletons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static and level with the combatants?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is one crab's pincer slowly rubbing against the other's while their bodies tremble?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11298047751188278 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.237980365753174 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11298047751188278, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11298047751188278, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05825633183121681, + 0.04767559841275215, + 0.027973506599664688, + 0.061973266303539276, + 0.05590759217739105, + 0.04524543508887291, + 0.40562716126441956, + 0.051307473331689835, + 0.1716317981481552, + 0.07440181821584702 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11298047751188278 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of two giant coconut crabs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the crabs' pincers locked in the exact center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the crabs display deep iridescent purple and fiery orange colors on their exoskeletons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static and level with the combatants?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is one crab's pincer slowly rubbing against the other's while their bodies tremble?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03371654078364372 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4087164402008057 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03371654078364372, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03371654078364372, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16278347373008728, + 0.07893259078264236, + 0.07225655019283295, + 0.04644925519824028, + 0.07824001461267471, + 0.06279375404119492, + 0.1743612289428711, + 0.09314759075641632, + 0.1627015769481659, + 0.06833387911319733 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03371654078364372 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up, static shot, level with the combatants, captures the raw power of a dramatic battle between two giant coconut crabs. Their powerful pincers lock in the exact center of the frame, the immense pressure causing their entire bodies to tremble in a silent, unyielding struggle for dominance. Surreal macroscopic detail reveals every nuance of their armored exoskeletons; the deep, iridescent purples and fiery oranges of their chitin plates are rendered with breathtaking clarity, showcasing the intricate network of ridges, pits, and fine bristles that give their bodies an almost alien texture. Spotted sunlight filtering through the unseen jungle canopy casts sharp, dramatic highlights and deep shadows across their forms, underscoring the sheer force as one crab's pincers slowly and powerfully rub against the other's. Their spiked eyes twitch with focused aggression, while their spiny legs dig deep into the dark, fertile soil and scattered leaf litter beneath the surface, poised for leverage in a tense, visceral, and perfectly focused confrontation.", + "seed": 23315, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_14/index_4825_seed_23315_dp_29_rank_58_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.18545766472816466, + "vlm_logprob": -0.18545766472816466, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.1, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.18545766472816466, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of two giant coconut crabs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the crabs' pincers locked in the exact center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the crabs display deep iridescent purple and fiery orange colors on their exoskeletons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static and level with the combatants?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is one crab's pincer slowly rubbing against the other's while their bodies tremble?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.013015788048505783 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.5130157470703125 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.013015788048505783, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.013015788048505783, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.26800185441970825, + 0.09299361705780029, + 0.022377081215381622, + 0.11389562487602234, + 0.07673069089651108, + 0.16890428960323334, + 0.03424619138240814, + 0.04419577866792679, + 0.09696443378925323, + 0.08169040828943253 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.013015788048505783 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of two giant coconut crabs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the crabs' pincers locked in the exact center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the crabs display deep iridescent purple and fiery orange colors on their exoskeletons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static and level with the combatants?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is one crab's pincer slowly rubbing against the other's while their bodies tremble?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8261919021606445 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5761919021606445 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.8261919021606445, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.8261919021606445, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3375420868396759, + 0.05649841949343681, + 0.03267405927181244, + 0.05582030862569809, + 0.11268998682498932, + 0.11244864761829376, + 0.07413343340158463, + 0.056611742824316025, + 0.053336482495069504, + 0.10824479907751083 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.8261919021606445 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of two giant coconut crabs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the crabs' pincers locked in the exact center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the crabs display deep iridescent purple and fiery orange colors on their exoskeletons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static and level with the combatants?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is one crab's pincer slowly rubbing against the other's while their bodies tremble?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00979321263730526 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634793281555176 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00979321263730526, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00979321263730526, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06237153708934784, + 0.06086689606308937, + 0.07197415828704834, + 0.0416276641190052, + 0.35763075947761536, + 0.23628336191177368, + 0.084344781935215, + 0.030057961121201515, + 0.01658870279788971, + 0.03825416415929794 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00979321263730526 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of two giant coconut crabs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the crabs' pincers locked in the exact center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the crabs display deep iridescent purple and fiery orange colors on their exoskeletons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static and level with the combatants?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is one crab's pincer slowly rubbing against the other's while their bodies tremble?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05498385801911354 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299838542938232 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05498385801911354, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05498385801911354, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3701004981994629, + 0.07288018614053726, + 0.03689907491207123, + 0.050855644047260284, + 0.07296440750360489, + 0.09363485872745514, + 0.09062313288450241, + 0.06806507706642151, + 0.061783574521541595, + 0.08219365030527115 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05498385801911354 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of two giant coconut crabs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the crabs' pincers locked in the exact center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the crabs display deep iridescent purple and fiery orange colors on their exoskeletons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static and level with the combatants?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is one crab's pincer slowly rubbing against the other's while their bodies tremble?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02330356277525425 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773303508758545 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02330356277525425, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02330356277525425, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09993280470371246, + 0.07017628848552704, + 0.03406762704253197, + 0.06415188312530518, + 0.06943538039922714, + 0.1897915005683899, + 0.16247940063476562, + 0.06586382538080215, + 0.18118982017040253, + 0.06291145831346512 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02330356277525425 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_15/index_tensor([1025, 1025])_group_15_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_15/index_tensor([1025, 1025])_group_15_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..ce7b2b1ab502cfde36b13dca5335b89165e52997 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_15/index_tensor([1025, 1025])_group_15_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "low-angle, wide-angle camera tracks backward, steadily keeping pace with a tall, Middle Eastern boy, about ten, as he walks determinedly through a sun-drenched spring forest. He has short, curly black hair and wears simple, black-rimmed rectangular glasses that frame his focused brown eyes and resolute jaw. He wears a practical navy windbreaker jacket, a gray T-shirt, durable khaki pants, and well-worn sneakers. Bright midday sunlight filters through the fresh green canopy of tall deciduous trees, creating a dynamic pattern of bright light and deep shadows on the mossy ground. Before him lies a clear stream, its water shimmering as it flows over smooth, gray stones. The atmosphere is tense, completely focused on the action about to unfold. When he reaches the stream's edge, he launches himself into the air with a powerful, graceful leap. The camera's movement dramatically slows to capture him at the peak of his leap, suspended in the air, as if floating for a moment. His body, stretched out, arms slightly outward for balance, is perfectly silhouetted against a bright blue sky, visible through gaps in the leaves, where sunlight catches the edges of his body, creating a halo effect that accentuates the pure, triumphant grace of his movement.", + "seed": 11692, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_15/index_1025_seed_11692_dp_30_rank_60_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.046400138456374404, + "vlm_logprob": -0.046400138456374404, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.85, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.046400138456374404, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a tall Middle Eastern boy with short curly black hair and rectangular glasses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the boy wearing a navy windbreaker jacket, gray T-shirt, khaki pants, and well-worn sneakers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a sun-drenched spring forest with a clear stream flowing over smooth gray stones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the boy launch himself into a powerful leap over the stream and suspend in the air at the peak?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle wide shot tracking backward, then slow down to capture the boy silhouetted against a bright blue sky with a halo effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16111551225185394 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9111155271530151 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16111551225185394, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16111551225185394, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2463844120502472, + 0.06279764324426651, + 0.06641953438520432, + 0.17936837673187256, + 0.07916555553674698, + 0.12477178871631622, + 0.048061762005090714, + 0.09990719705820084, + 0.038763176649808884, + 0.05436055362224579 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16111551225185394 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a tall Middle Eastern boy with short curly black hair and rectangular glasses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the boy wearing a navy windbreaker jacket, gray T-shirt, khaki pants, and well-worn sneakers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a sun-drenched spring forest with a clear stream flowing over smooth gray stones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the boy launch himself into a powerful leap over the stream and suspend in the air at the peak?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle wide shot tracking backward, then slow down to capture the boy silhouetted against a bright blue sky with a halo effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.033713199198246 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4087131023406982 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.033713199198246, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.033713199198246, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1957804262638092, + 0.0490386001765728, + 0.04931064695119858, + 0.11520058661699295, + 0.13700082898139954, + 0.10064450651407242, + 0.05036971718072891, + 0.11107854545116425, + 0.0857064500451088, + 0.10586971789598465 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.033713199198246 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a tall Middle Eastern boy with short curly black hair and rectangular glasses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the boy wearing a navy windbreaker jacket, gray T-shirt, khaki pants, and well-worn sneakers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a sun-drenched spring forest with a clear stream flowing over smooth gray stones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the boy launch himself into a powerful leap over the stream and suspend in the air at the peak?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle wide shot tracking backward, then slow down to capture the boy silhouetted against a bright blue sky with a halo effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006736426148563623 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.0067362785339355 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006736426148563623, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006736426148563623, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16143889725208282, + 0.0824870690703392, + 0.06162915751338005, + 0.15884533524513245, + 0.08967103809118271, + 0.14068174362182617, + 0.031065933406352997, + 0.11532112210988998, + 0.052749596536159515, + 0.1061101034283638 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006736426148563623 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a tall Middle Eastern boy with short curly black hair and rectangular glasses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the boy wearing a navy windbreaker jacket, gray T-shirt, khaki pants, and well-worn sneakers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a sun-drenched spring forest with a clear stream flowing over smooth gray stones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the boy launch himself into a powerful leap over the stream and suspend in the air at the peak?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle wide shot tracking backward, then slow down to capture the boy silhouetted against a bright blue sky with a halo effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004096094518899918 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504096031188965 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004096094518899918, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004096094518899918, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11185601353645325, + 0.03849590942263603, + 0.028747932985424995, + 0.13421250879764557, + 0.06441859900951385, + 0.06986920535564423, + 0.04522600769996643, + 0.1632830798625946, + 0.275871604681015, + 0.06801917403936386 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004096094518899918 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a tall Middle Eastern boy with short curly black hair and rectangular glasses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the boy wearing a navy windbreaker jacket, gray T-shirt, khaki pants, and well-worn sneakers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a sun-drenched spring forest with a clear stream flowing over smooth gray stones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the boy launch himself into a powerful leap over the stream and suspend in the air at the peak?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle wide shot tracking backward, then slow down to capture the boy silhouetted against a bright blue sky with a halo effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026339460164308548 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651339530944824 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026339460164308548, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026339460164308548, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11691641807556152, + 0.06204107403755188, + 0.04510726407170296, + 0.11555849760770798, + 0.11165592819452286, + 0.0984513908624649, + 0.08055717498064041, + 0.07724221795797348, + 0.17175394296646118, + 0.1207161545753479 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026339460164308548 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, wide-angle camera tracks backward, steadily keeping pace with a tall, Middle Eastern boy, about ten, as he walks determinedly through a sun-drenched spring forest. He has short, curly black hair and wears simple, black-rimmed rectangular glasses that frame his focused brown eyes and resolute jaw. He wears a practical navy windbreaker jacket, a gray T-shirt, durable khaki pants, and well-worn sneakers. Bright midday sunlight filters through the fresh green canopy of tall deciduous trees, creating a dynamic pattern of bright light and deep shadows on the mossy ground. Before him lies a clear stream, its water shimmering as it flows over smooth, gray stones. The atmosphere is tense, completely focused on the action about to unfold. When he reaches the stream's edge, he launches himself into the air with a powerful, graceful leap. The camera's movement dramatically slows to capture him at the peak of his leap, suspended in the air, as if floating for a moment. His body, stretched out, arms slightly outward for balance, is perfectly silhouetted against a bright blue sky, visible through gaps in the leaves, where sunlight catches the edges of his body, creating a halo effect that accentuates the pure, triumphant grace of his movement.", + "seed": 11693, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_15/index_1025_seed_11693_dp_30_rank_60_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.03762190919369459, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03762190919369459, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.0, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03762190919369459, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a tall Middle Eastern boy with short curly black hair and rectangular glasses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the boy wearing a navy windbreaker jacket, gray T-shirt, khaki pants, and well-worn sneakers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a sun-drenched spring forest with a clear stream flowing over smooth gray stones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the boy launch himself into a powerful leap over the stream and suspend in the air at the peak?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle wide shot tracking backward, then slow down to capture the boy silhouetted against a bright blue sky with a halo effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11350376158952713 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2385036945343018 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11350376158952713, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11350376158952713, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20226050913333893, + 0.0689840242266655, + 0.030962368473410606, + 0.03526553139090538, + 0.07409197092056274, + 0.017833566293120384, + 0.16605761647224426, + 0.04429763928055763, + 0.08461393415927887, + 0.2756328582763672 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11350376158952713 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a tall Middle Eastern boy with short curly black hair and rectangular glasses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the boy wearing a navy windbreaker jacket, gray T-shirt, khaki pants, and well-worn sneakers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a sun-drenched spring forest with a clear stream flowing over smooth gray stones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the boy launch himself into a powerful leap over the stream and suspend in the air at the peak?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle wide shot tracking backward, then slow down to capture the boy silhouetted against a bright blue sky with a halo effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02330542728304863 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7733054161071777 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02330542728304863, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02330542728304863, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22361458837985992, + 0.09433265030384064, + 0.025059957057237625, + 0.025275224819779396, + 0.09075868874788284, + 0.02337585762143135, + 0.12366881221532822, + 0.041541408747434616, + 0.05332208797335625, + 0.2990507185459137 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02330542728304863 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a tall Middle Eastern boy with short curly black hair and rectangular glasses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the boy wearing a navy windbreaker jacket, gray T-shirt, khaki pants, and well-worn sneakers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a sun-drenched spring forest with a clear stream flowing over smooth gray stones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the boy launch himself into a powerful leap over the stream and suspend in the air at the peak?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle wide shot tracking backward, then slow down to capture the boy silhouetted against a bright blue sky with a halo effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036153923720121384 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628615379333496 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036153923720121384, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036153923720121384, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10616475343704224, + 0.016727352514863014, + 0.01302712969481945, + 0.01285648439079523, + 0.008724580518901348, + 0.018545275554060936, + 0.025547759607434273, + 0.017031103372573853, + 0.06477266550064087, + 0.7166028618812561 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036153923720121384 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a tall Middle Eastern boy with short curly black hair and rectangular glasses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the boy wearing a navy windbreaker jacket, gray T-shirt, khaki pants, and well-worn sneakers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a sun-drenched spring forest with a clear stream flowing over smooth gray stones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the boy launch himself into a powerful leap over the stream and suspend in the air at the peak?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle wide shot tracking backward, then slow down to capture the boy silhouetted against a bright blue sky with a halo effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004637320525944233 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379637241363525 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004637320525944233, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004637320525944233, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10180746018886566, + 0.03492851182818413, + 0.035564642399549484, + 0.022611359134316444, + 0.03885878622531891, + 0.08977995812892914, + 0.11885105818510056, + 0.18956001102924347, + 0.10012196749448776, + 0.2679162621498108 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004637320525944233 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a tall Middle Eastern boy with short curly black hair and rectangular glasses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the boy wearing a navy windbreaker jacket, gray T-shirt, khaki pants, and well-worn sneakers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a sun-drenched spring forest with a clear stream flowing over smooth gray stones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the boy launch himself into a powerful leap over the stream and suspend in the air at the peak?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle wide shot tracking backward, then slow down to capture the boy silhouetted against a bright blue sky with a halo effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.043047644197940826 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680476665496826 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.043047644197940826, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.043047644197940826, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.143035426735878, + 0.04241345077753067, + 0.026590367779135704, + 0.033785779029130936, + 0.021986527368426323, + 0.02813776209950447, + 0.1251983642578125, + 0.1314680427312851, + 0.08790799975395203, + 0.3594762682914734 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.043047644197940826 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, wide-angle camera tracks backward, steadily keeping pace with a tall, Middle Eastern boy, about ten, as he walks determinedly through a sun-drenched spring forest. He has short, curly black hair and wears simple, black-rimmed rectangular glasses that frame his focused brown eyes and resolute jaw. He wears a practical navy windbreaker jacket, a gray T-shirt, durable khaki pants, and well-worn sneakers. Bright midday sunlight filters through the fresh green canopy of tall deciduous trees, creating a dynamic pattern of bright light and deep shadows on the mossy ground. Before him lies a clear stream, its water shimmering as it flows over smooth, gray stones. The atmosphere is tense, completely focused on the action about to unfold. When he reaches the stream's edge, he launches himself into the air with a powerful, graceful leap. The camera's movement dramatically slows to capture him at the peak of his leap, suspended in the air, as if floating for a moment. His body, stretched out, arms slightly outward for balance, is perfectly silhouetted against a bright blue sky, visible through gaps in the leaves, where sunlight catches the edges of his body, creating a halo effect that accentuates the pure, triumphant grace of his movement.", + "seed": 11694, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_15/index_1025_seed_11694_dp_31_rank_62_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.04958746302872896, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04958746302872896, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.8, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04958746302872896, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a tall Middle Eastern boy with short curly black hair and rectangular glasses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the boy wearing a navy windbreaker jacket, gray T-shirt, khaki pants, and well-worn sneakers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a sun-drenched spring forest with a clear stream flowing over smooth gray stones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the boy launch himself into a powerful leap over the stream and suspend in the air at the peak?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle wide shot tracking backward, then slow down to capture the boy silhouetted against a bright blue sky with a halo effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.18076908588409424 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8057690858840942 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.18076908588409424, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.18076908588409424, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3818867802619934, + 0.06196848675608635, + 0.14897757768630981, + 0.10326267778873444, + 0.0343007892370224, + 0.08422572165727615, + 0.0636117160320282, + 0.029413748532533646, + 0.051679614931344986, + 0.04067284241318703 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.18076908588409424 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a tall Middle Eastern boy with short curly black hair and rectangular glasses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the boy wearing a navy windbreaker jacket, gray T-shirt, khaki pants, and well-worn sneakers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a sun-drenched spring forest with a clear stream flowing over smooth gray stones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the boy launch himself into a powerful leap over the stream and suspend in the air at the peak?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle wide shot tracking backward, then slow down to capture the boy silhouetted against a bright blue sky with a halo effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020600175485014915 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8956000804901123 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020600175485014915, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020600175485014915, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17500294744968414, + 0.045550160109996796, + 0.1172831803560257, + 0.034843750298023224, + 0.03521156311035156, + 0.09767737239599228, + 0.03725239634513855, + 0.024059247225522995, + 0.09932895004749298, + 0.33379048109054565 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020600175485014915 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a tall Middle Eastern boy with short curly black hair and rectangular glasses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the boy wearing a navy windbreaker jacket, gray T-shirt, khaki pants, and well-worn sneakers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a sun-drenched spring forest with a clear stream flowing over smooth gray stones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the boy launch himself into a powerful leap over the stream and suspend in the air at the peak?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle wide shot tracking backward, then slow down to capture the boy silhouetted against a bright blue sky with a halo effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005250830203294754 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255250930786133 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005250830203294754, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005250830203294754, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19924235343933105, + 0.03995276242494583, + 0.4709836542606354, + 0.03406047821044922, + 0.06474445760250092, + 0.07574554532766342, + 0.027100704610347748, + 0.026518503203988075, + 0.03897164762020111, + 0.02267991192638874 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005250830203294754 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a tall Middle Eastern boy with short curly black hair and rectangular glasses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the boy wearing a navy windbreaker jacket, gray T-shirt, khaki pants, and well-worn sneakers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a sun-drenched spring forest with a clear stream flowing over smooth gray stones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the boy launch himself into a powerful leap over the stream and suspend in the air at the peak?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle wide shot tracking backward, then slow down to capture the boy silhouetted against a bright blue sky with a halo effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007627884857356548 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882627964019775 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007627884857356548, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007627884857356548, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13567543029785156, + 0.08336319774389267, + 0.1738085299730301, + 0.24632005393505096, + 0.0371163934469223, + 0.08310122787952423, + 0.04689347371459007, + 0.04373863339424133, + 0.07598518580198288, + 0.07399788498878479 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007627884857356548 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a tall Middle Eastern boy with short curly black hair and rectangular glasses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the boy wearing a navy windbreaker jacket, gray T-shirt, khaki pants, and well-worn sneakers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a sun-drenched spring forest with a clear stream flowing over smooth gray stones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the boy launch himself into a powerful leap over the stream and suspend in the air at the peak?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle wide shot tracking backward, then slow down to capture the boy silhouetted against a bright blue sky with a halo effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.033689338713884354 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408689260482788 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.033689338713884354, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.033689338713884354, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0860443115234375, + 0.058812905102968216, + 0.4165140986442566, + 0.11487815529108047, + 0.04927713796496391, + 0.037284765392541885, + 0.06988523155450821, + 0.03298288956284523, + 0.07396966964006424, + 0.060350801795721054 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.033689338713884354 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, wide-angle camera tracks backward, steadily keeping pace with a tall, Middle Eastern boy, about ten, as he walks determinedly through a sun-drenched spring forest. He has short, curly black hair and wears simple, black-rimmed rectangular glasses that frame his focused brown eyes and resolute jaw. He wears a practical navy windbreaker jacket, a gray T-shirt, durable khaki pants, and well-worn sneakers. Bright midday sunlight filters through the fresh green canopy of tall deciduous trees, creating a dynamic pattern of bright light and deep shadows on the mossy ground. Before him lies a clear stream, its water shimmering as it flows over smooth, gray stones. The atmosphere is tense, completely focused on the action about to unfold. When he reaches the stream's edge, he launches himself into the air with a powerful, graceful leap. The camera's movement dramatically slows to capture him at the peak of his leap, suspended in the air, as if floating for a moment. His body, stretched out, arms slightly outward for balance, is perfectly silhouetted against a bright blue sky, visible through gaps in the leaves, where sunlight catches the edges of his body, creating a halo effect that accentuates the pure, triumphant grace of his movement.", + "seed": 11695, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_15/index_1025_seed_11695_dp_31_rank_62_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.048555789049714804, + "vlm_logprob": -0.048555789049714804, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.925, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.048555789049714804, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a tall Middle Eastern boy with short curly black hair and rectangular glasses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the boy wearing a navy windbreaker jacket, gray T-shirt, khaki pants, and well-worn sneakers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a sun-drenched spring forest with a clear stream flowing over smooth gray stones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the boy launch himself into a powerful leap over the stream and suspend in the air at the peak?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle wide shot tracking backward, then slow down to capture the boy silhouetted against a bright blue sky with a halo effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1807340532541275 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8057340383529663 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1807340532541275, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1807340532541275, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1928243339061737, + 0.24001453816890717, + 0.07022394239902496, + 0.0483829639852047, + 0.038761887699365616, + 0.09053683280944824, + 0.039608441293239594, + 0.0447230190038681, + 0.10970021784305573, + 0.12522384524345398 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1807340532541275 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a tall Middle Eastern boy with short curly black hair and rectangular glasses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the boy wearing a navy windbreaker jacket, gray T-shirt, khaki pants, and well-worn sneakers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a sun-drenched spring forest with a clear stream flowing over smooth gray stones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the boy launch himself into a powerful leap over the stream and suspend in the air at the peak?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle wide shot tracking backward, then slow down to capture the boy silhouetted against a bright blue sky with a halo effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02636152133345604 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513614654541016 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02636152133345604, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02636152133345604, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.30987629294395447, + 0.07810819149017334, + 0.02678612433373928, + 0.03266207501292229, + 0.03706742450594902, + 0.11519031971693039, + 0.027120787650346756, + 0.03484998270869255, + 0.15910665690898895, + 0.17923207581043243 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02636152133345604 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a tall Middle Eastern boy with short curly black hair and rectangular glasses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the boy wearing a navy windbreaker jacket, gray T-shirt, khaki pants, and well-worn sneakers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a sun-drenched spring forest with a clear stream flowing over smooth gray stones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the boy launch himself into a powerful leap over the stream and suspend in the air at the peak?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle wide shot tracking backward, then slow down to capture the boy silhouetted against a bright blue sky with a halo effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0040955008007586 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504095554351807 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0040955008007586, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0040955008007586, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3188987672328949, + 0.11542315036058426, + 0.06334859132766724, + 0.03570491820573807, + 0.06223315745592117, + 0.09732522070407867, + 0.09074677526950836, + 0.09838610887527466, + 0.05418827757239342, + 0.06374502927064896 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0040955008007586 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a tall Middle Eastern boy with short curly black hair and rectangular glasses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the boy wearing a navy windbreaker jacket, gray T-shirt, khaki pants, and well-worn sneakers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a sun-drenched spring forest with a clear stream flowing over smooth gray stones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the boy launch himself into a powerful leap over the stream and suspend in the air at the peak?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle wide shot tracking backward, then slow down to capture the boy silhouetted against a bright blue sky with a halo effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005251660011708736 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255251884460449 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005251660011708736, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005251660011708736, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23346637189388275, + 0.04670514538884163, + 0.04027285426855087, + 0.06481432914733887, + 0.0511319562792778, + 0.12378356605768204, + 0.08247856795787811, + 0.03253892809152603, + 0.1307385116815567, + 0.1940697282552719 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005251660011708736 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a tall Middle Eastern boy with short curly black hair and rectangular glasses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the boy wearing a navy windbreaker jacket, gray T-shirt, khaki pants, and well-worn sneakers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a sun-drenched spring forest with a clear stream flowing over smooth gray stones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the boy launch himself into a powerful leap over the stream and suspend in the air at the peak?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle wide shot tracking backward, then slow down to capture the boy silhouetted against a bright blue sky with a halo effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02633620984852314 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651336193084717 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02633620984852314, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02633620984852314, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1685844361782074, + 0.15812481939792633, + 0.08008193224668503, + 0.06848735362291336, + 0.13779500126838684, + 0.06307653337717056, + 0.07322724163532257, + 0.05366106703877449, + 0.0876510962843895, + 0.10931050032377243 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02633620984852314 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_2/index_tensor([8134, 8134])_group_2_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_2/index_tensor([8134, 8134])_group_2_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..7966f960818639e75a6982f5d16d5236fed62979 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_2/index_tensor([8134, 8134])_group_2_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "medium shot, filmed from a slightly overhead angle and smoothly panning to the right, focuses on an elderly Asian tailor in a vintage-inspired tailor's studio. His graying hair is meticulously combed, and the corners of his eyes are lined with fine lines formed by age and concentration. He wears a simple off-white linen shirt, and a yellow tape measure hangs around his neck. A warm-toned work lamp hanging above his workbench serves as the primary source of light, illuminating his hand movements and the texture of the fabric while casting soft shadows on the rest of the room. One hand carefully holds down a dark blue wool fabric spread out on a massive wooden workbench, while the other firmly grips a heavy pair of shears with a gleaming metallic shears. As the camera steadily pans to the right, we see him steadily and deliberately moving the shears, the sharp blades gliding precisely along the pre-drawn white chalk line, neatly bisecting the cloth. The entire scene is filled with concentration, tranquility, and the exquisite spirit of craftsmanship.", + "seed": 9722, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_2/index_8134_seed_9722_dp_4_rank_8_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.03482798486948013, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03482798486948013, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.425, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03482798486948013, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly Asian tailor with graying hair and fine lines around his eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tailor wearing a simple off-white linen shirt with a yellow tape measure around his neck?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tailor using heavy metallic shears to cut a dark blue wool fabric along a white chalk line on a massive wooden workbench?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a warm-toned work lamp hanging above the workbench, casting soft shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera filmed from a slightly overhead angle and smoothly panning to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.038438402116298676 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288438320159912 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.038438402116298676, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.038438402116298676, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21967101097106934, + 0.09388509392738342, + 0.05671996250748634, + 0.029000824317336082, + 0.13601678609848022, + 0.04010120406746864, + 0.1198621317744255, + 0.052934687584638596, + 0.17202304303646088, + 0.07978525012731552 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.038438402116298676 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly Asian tailor with graying hair and fine lines around his eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tailor wearing a simple off-white linen shirt with a yellow tape measure around his neck?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tailor using heavy metallic shears to cut a dark blue wool fabric along a white chalk line on a massive wooden workbench?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a warm-toned work lamp hanging above the workbench, casting soft shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera filmed from a slightly overhead angle and smoothly panning to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014205290004611015 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264205455780029 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014205290004611015, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014205290004611015, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13799268007278442, + 0.07480915635824203, + 0.048499468713998795, + 0.02997869998216629, + 0.043277133256196976, + 0.034182652831077576, + 0.16139860451221466, + 0.11513886600732803, + 0.24399183690547943, + 0.11073089390993118 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014205290004611015 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly Asian tailor with graying hair and fine lines around his eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tailor wearing a simple off-white linen shirt with a yellow tape measure around his neck?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tailor using heavy metallic shears to cut a dark blue wool fabric along a white chalk line on a massive wooden workbench?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a warm-toned work lamp hanging above the workbench, casting soft shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera filmed from a slightly overhead angle and smoothly panning to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029807230457663536 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298073291778564 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029807230457663536, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029807230457663536, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13498012721538544, + 0.05435161292552948, + 0.038800694048404694, + 0.10125216841697693, + 0.22233116626739502, + 0.03492007032036781, + 0.14283420145511627, + 0.06088536977767944, + 0.15150997042655945, + 0.058134615421295166 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029807230457663536 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly Asian tailor with graying hair and fine lines around his eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tailor wearing a simple off-white linen shirt with a yellow tape measure around his neck?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tailor using heavy metallic shears to cut a dark blue wool fabric along a white chalk line on a massive wooden workbench?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a warm-toned work lamp hanging above the workbench, casting soft shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera filmed from a slightly overhead angle and smoothly panning to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.048645127564668655 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.04864501953125 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.048645127564668655, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.048645127564668655, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21613778173923492, + 0.04379810765385628, + 0.06134524196386337, + 0.046993378549814224, + 0.08429271727800369, + 0.048078753054142, + 0.19910657405853271, + 0.13180185854434967, + 0.10486800968647003, + 0.06357749551534653 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.048645127564668655 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly Asian tailor with graying hair and fine lines around his eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tailor wearing a simple off-white linen shirt with a yellow tape measure around his neck?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tailor using heavy metallic shears to cut a dark blue wool fabric along a white chalk line on a massive wooden workbench?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a warm-toned work lamp hanging above the workbench, casting soft shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera filmed from a slightly overhead angle and smoothly panning to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04304387420415878 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168043851852417 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04304387420415878, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04304387420415878, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15633325278759003, + 0.03539636358618736, + 0.05158228054642677, + 0.03642619401216507, + 0.49096113443374634, + 0.023352453485131264, + 0.03518438711762428, + 0.07474119961261749, + 0.06273986399173737, + 0.03328283503651619 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04304387420415878 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "medium shot, filmed from a slightly overhead angle and smoothly panning to the right, focuses on an elderly Asian tailor in a vintage-inspired tailor's studio. His graying hair is meticulously combed, and the corners of his eyes are lined with fine lines formed by age and concentration. He wears a simple off-white linen shirt, and a yellow tape measure hangs around his neck. A warm-toned work lamp hanging above his workbench serves as the primary source of light, illuminating his hand movements and the texture of the fabric while casting soft shadows on the rest of the room. One hand carefully holds down a dark blue wool fabric spread out on a massive wooden workbench, while the other firmly grips a heavy pair of shears with a gleaming metallic shears. As the camera steadily pans to the right, we see him steadily and deliberately moving the shears, the sharp blades gliding precisely along the pre-drawn white chalk line, neatly bisecting the cloth. The entire scene is filled with concentration, tranquility, and the exquisite spirit of craftsmanship.", + "seed": 9723, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_2/index_8134_seed_9723_dp_4_rank_8_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.04998820647597313, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04998820647597313, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.2, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04998820647597313, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly Asian tailor with graying hair and fine lines around his eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tailor wearing a simple off-white linen shirt with a yellow tape measure around his neck?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tailor using heavy metallic shears to cut a dark blue wool fabric along a white chalk line on a massive wooden workbench?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a warm-toned work lamp hanging above the workbench, casting soft shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera filmed from a slightly overhead angle and smoothly panning to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11340287327766418 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.238402843475342 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11340287327766418, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11340287327766418, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3902377784252167, + 0.031775955110788345, + 0.03039521351456642, + 0.0728544294834137, + 0.0448027104139328, + 0.12921999394893646, + 0.05131639167666435, + 0.12415286153554916, + 0.031215952709317207, + 0.09402873367071152 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11340287327766418 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly Asian tailor with graying hair and fine lines around his eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tailor wearing a simple off-white linen shirt with a yellow tape measure around his neck?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tailor using heavy metallic shears to cut a dark blue wool fabric along a white chalk line on a massive wooden workbench?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a warm-toned work lamp hanging above the workbench, casting soft shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera filmed from a slightly overhead angle and smoothly panning to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014210108667612076 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264210224151611 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014210108667612076, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014210108667612076, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23103517293930054, + 0.057666659355163574, + 0.04916105046868324, + 0.040641847997903824, + 0.0362447127699852, + 0.1134503111243248, + 0.0331462100148201, + 0.3032018840312958, + 0.04195792227983475, + 0.09349427372217178 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014210108667612076 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly Asian tailor with graying hair and fine lines around his eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tailor wearing a simple off-white linen shirt with a yellow tape measure around his neck?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tailor using heavy metallic shears to cut a dark blue wool fabric along a white chalk line on a massive wooden workbench?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a warm-toned work lamp hanging above the workbench, casting soft shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera filmed from a slightly overhead angle and smoothly panning to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03371216356754303 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408712148666382 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03371216356754303, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03371216356754303, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22573089599609375, + 0.04676483944058418, + 0.07466500997543335, + 0.08546017855405807, + 0.09485020488500595, + 0.08551096171140671, + 0.044794712215662, + 0.1444339156150818, + 0.030658842995762825, + 0.1671305149793625 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03371216356754303 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly Asian tailor with graying hair and fine lines around his eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tailor wearing a simple off-white linen shirt with a yellow tape measure around his neck?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tailor using heavy metallic shears to cut a dark blue wool fabric along a white chalk line on a massive wooden workbench?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a warm-toned work lamp hanging above the workbench, casting soft shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera filmed from a slightly overhead angle and smoothly panning to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03368968516588211 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4086897373199463 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03368968516588211, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03368968516588211, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.32213154435157776, + 0.05442255735397339, + 0.062325216829776764, + 0.037525471299886703, + 0.049895599484443665, + 0.1668521761894226, + 0.038172248750925064, + 0.1463598608970642, + 0.02975458838045597, + 0.09256067872047424 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03368968516588211 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly Asian tailor with graying hair and fine lines around his eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tailor wearing a simple off-white linen shirt with a yellow tape measure around his neck?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tailor using heavy metallic shears to cut a dark blue wool fabric along a white chalk line on a massive wooden workbench?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a warm-toned work lamp hanging above the workbench, casting soft shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera filmed from a slightly overhead angle and smoothly panning to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.054926201701164246 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299261569976807 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.054926201701164246, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.054926201701164246, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06090986728668213, + 0.04819194972515106, + 0.08406616002321243, + 0.05612228810787201, + 0.12193678319454193, + 0.10810515284538269, + 0.14686499536037445, + 0.11688461899757385, + 0.11385279148817062, + 0.14306536316871643 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.054926201701164246 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "medium shot, filmed from a slightly overhead angle and smoothly panning to the right, focuses on an elderly Asian tailor in a vintage-inspired tailor's studio. His graying hair is meticulously combed, and the corners of his eyes are lined with fine lines formed by age and concentration. He wears a simple off-white linen shirt, and a yellow tape measure hangs around his neck. A warm-toned work lamp hanging above his workbench serves as the primary source of light, illuminating his hand movements and the texture of the fabric while casting soft shadows on the rest of the room. One hand carefully holds down a dark blue wool fabric spread out on a massive wooden workbench, while the other firmly grips a heavy pair of shears with a gleaming metallic shears. As the camera steadily pans to the right, we see him steadily and deliberately moving the shears, the sharp blades gliding precisely along the pre-drawn white chalk line, neatly bisecting the cloth. The entire scene is filled with concentration, tranquility, and the exquisite spirit of craftsmanship.", + "seed": 9724, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_2/index_8134_seed_9724_dp_5_rank_10_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.23715873062610626, + "vlm_logprob": -0.23715873062610626, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.65, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.23715873062610626, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly Asian tailor with graying hair and fine lines around his eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tailor wearing a simple off-white linen shirt with a yellow tape measure around his neck?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tailor using heavy metallic shears to cut a dark blue wool fabric along a white chalk line on a massive wooden workbench?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a warm-toned work lamp hanging above the workbench, casting soft shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera filmed from a slightly overhead angle and smoothly panning to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6334921717643738 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7584921717643738 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.6334921717643738, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.6334921717643738, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16643297672271729, + 0.0674065500497818, + 0.13159482181072235, + 0.06621406972408295, + 0.04553869739174843, + 0.10456051677465439, + 0.08571822196245193, + 0.09350939095020294, + 0.04751051217317581, + 0.19151422381401062 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.6334921717643738 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly Asian tailor with graying hair and fine lines around his eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tailor wearing a simple off-white linen shirt with a yellow tape measure around his neck?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tailor using heavy metallic shears to cut a dark blue wool fabric along a white chalk line on a massive wooden workbench?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a warm-toned work lamp hanging above the workbench, casting soft shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera filmed from a slightly overhead angle and smoothly panning to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20163580775260925 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7016358375549316 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20163580775260925, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20163580775260925, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09182870388031006, + 0.024652212858200073, + 0.16057953238487244, + 0.05526210367679596, + 0.05558978393673897, + 0.12675197422504425, + 0.02397277019917965, + 0.07992012798786163, + 0.03529664874076843, + 0.3461461663246155 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20163580775260925 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly Asian tailor with graying hair and fine lines around his eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tailor wearing a simple off-white linen shirt with a yellow tape measure around his neck?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tailor using heavy metallic shears to cut a dark blue wool fabric along a white chalk line on a massive wooden workbench?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a warm-toned work lamp hanging above the workbench, casting soft shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera filmed from a slightly overhead angle and smoothly panning to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20163357257843018 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7016335725784302 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20163357257843018, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20163357257843018, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20912986993789673, + 0.07115790247917175, + 0.11964944750070572, + 0.09707023203372955, + 0.04346686601638794, + 0.18176433444023132, + 0.048106443136930466, + 0.1438375562429428, + 0.0392627976834774, + 0.04655452445149422 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20163357257843018 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly Asian tailor with graying hair and fine lines around his eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tailor wearing a simple off-white linen shirt with a yellow tape measure around his neck?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tailor using heavy metallic shears to cut a dark blue wool fabric along a white chalk line on a massive wooden workbench?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a warm-toned work lamp hanging above the workbench, casting soft shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera filmed from a slightly overhead angle and smoothly panning to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07902006804943085 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5790200233459473 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07902006804943085, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07902006804943085, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22574515640735626, + 0.04775918647646904, + 0.20724742114543915, + 0.11555114388465881, + 0.07150914520025253, + 0.032933760434389114, + 0.06587215512990952, + 0.14311091601848602, + 0.027471065521240234, + 0.06279999762773514 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07902006804943085 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly Asian tailor with graying hair and fine lines around his eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tailor wearing a simple off-white linen shirt with a yellow tape measure around his neck?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tailor using heavy metallic shears to cut a dark blue wool fabric along a white chalk line on a massive wooden workbench?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a warm-toned work lamp hanging above the workbench, casting soft shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera filmed from a slightly overhead angle and smoothly panning to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07001203298568726 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695012092590332 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07001203298568726, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07001203298568726, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.30866655707359314, + 0.059753865003585815, + 0.2494358867406845, + 0.0523054413497448, + 0.08816977590322495, + 0.09117229282855988, + 0.04305965080857277, + 0.026090681552886963, + 0.0372726246714592, + 0.044073186814785004 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07001203298568726 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "medium shot, filmed from a slightly overhead angle and smoothly panning to the right, focuses on an elderly Asian tailor in a vintage-inspired tailor's studio. His graying hair is meticulously combed, and the corners of his eyes are lined with fine lines formed by age and concentration. He wears a simple off-white linen shirt, and a yellow tape measure hangs around his neck. A warm-toned work lamp hanging above his workbench serves as the primary source of light, illuminating his hand movements and the texture of the fabric while casting soft shadows on the rest of the room. One hand carefully holds down a dark blue wool fabric spread out on a massive wooden workbench, while the other firmly grips a heavy pair of shears with a gleaming metallic shears. As the camera steadily pans to the right, we see him steadily and deliberately moving the shears, the sharp blades gliding precisely along the pre-drawn white chalk line, neatly bisecting the cloth. The entire scene is filled with concentration, tranquility, and the exquisite spirit of craftsmanship.", + "seed": 9725, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_2/index_8134_seed_9725_dp_5_rank_10_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.0310810430906713, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0310810430906713, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.775, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0310810430906713, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly Asian tailor with graying hair and fine lines around his eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tailor wearing a simple off-white linen shirt with a yellow tape measure around his neck?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tailor using heavy metallic shears to cut a dark blue wool fabric along a white chalk line on a massive wooden workbench?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a warm-toned work lamp hanging above the workbench, casting soft shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera filmed from a slightly overhead angle and smoothly panning to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014543830417096615 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.2645440101623535 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014543830417096615, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014543830417096615, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2465573251247406, + 0.07057160139083862, + 0.09432854503393173, + 0.07901797443628311, + 0.13415639102458954, + 0.11392203718423843, + 0.051419276744127274, + 0.04881681501865387, + 0.12351786345243454, + 0.037692245095968246 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014543830417096615 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly Asian tailor with graying hair and fine lines around his eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tailor wearing a simple off-white linen shirt with a yellow tape measure around his neck?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tailor using heavy metallic shears to cut a dark blue wool fabric along a white chalk line on a massive wooden workbench?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a warm-toned work lamp hanging above the workbench, casting soft shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera filmed from a slightly overhead angle and smoothly panning to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007639360148459673 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882639408111572 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007639360148459673, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007639360148459673, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20946405827999115, + 0.05229686573147774, + 0.10590888559818268, + 0.10726531594991684, + 0.06818962842226028, + 0.06287889927625656, + 0.044977158308029175, + 0.07647327333688736, + 0.18669754266738892, + 0.08584839850664139 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007639360148459673 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly Asian tailor with graying hair and fine lines around his eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tailor wearing a simple off-white linen shirt with a yellow tape measure around his neck?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tailor using heavy metallic shears to cut a dark blue wool fabric along a white chalk line on a massive wooden workbench?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a warm-toned work lamp hanging above the workbench, casting soft shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera filmed from a slightly overhead angle and smoothly panning to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.033703286200761795 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408703327178955 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.033703286200761795, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.033703286200761795, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.34720510244369507, + 0.07422962784767151, + 0.06947365403175354, + 0.1152379959821701, + 0.07824953645467758, + 0.07660618424415588, + 0.06941865384578705, + 0.040000054985284805, + 0.08538374304771423, + 0.04419545829296112 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.033703286200761795 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly Asian tailor with graying hair and fine lines around his eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tailor wearing a simple off-white linen shirt with a yellow tape measure around his neck?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tailor using heavy metallic shears to cut a dark blue wool fabric along a white chalk line on a massive wooden workbench?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a warm-toned work lamp hanging above the workbench, casting soft shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera filmed from a slightly overhead angle and smoothly panning to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020576000213623047 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895576000213623 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020576000213623047, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020576000213623047, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.36965975165367126, + 0.04955141991376877, + 0.08972126245498657, + 0.039136502891778946, + 0.09848134219646454, + 0.06925970315933228, + 0.0415499322116375, + 0.058752745389938354, + 0.07718721032142639, + 0.10670017451047897 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020576000213623047 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly Asian tailor with graying hair and fine lines around his eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tailor wearing a simple off-white linen shirt with a yellow tape measure around his neck?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tailor using heavy metallic shears to cut a dark blue wool fabric along a white chalk line on a massive wooden workbench?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a warm-toned work lamp hanging above the workbench, casting soft shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera filmed from a slightly overhead angle and smoothly panning to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07894273847341537 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5789427757263184 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07894273847341537, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07894273847341537, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.33306795358657837, + 0.059729643166065216, + 0.09223318099975586, + 0.08123157918453217, + 0.06667891889810562, + 0.11576005071401596, + 0.04460081830620766, + 0.06768661737442017, + 0.10394536703824997, + 0.035065848380327225 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07894273847341537 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_3/index_tensor([7250, 7250])_group_3_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_3/index_tensor([7250, 7250])_group_3_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..b38cbd4ece0ed57ee6fd866f659c82cdaf466df1 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_3/index_tensor([7250, 7250])_group_3_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "An extremely wide-angle shot, zooming in slowly and majestically, captures a silent ballet of cosmic destruction across the vast, star-studded expanse of deep sky. Two planets are on an inevitable collision course. One is a terrestrial world with a cracked, rust-colored crust and a deep, aquamarine ocean partially obscured by swirling white clouds; the other is a smaller, icy sphere, its pale blue surface a complex network of crystalline fractures. The camera remains fixed as they make contact. The impact is silent but visually deafening; the Earth-like planet's crust expands and shatters into continent-sized plates, which are violently thrust outward. Simultaneously, the icy planet's surface explodes into trillions of glittering fragments. From its ruptured core, brilliant, white-hot molten magma erupts in a furious, expanding fireball, casting a stark, dramatic light upon the unfolding chaos. Fiery tendrils of liquid rock and superheated gas blast outward, creating a breathtaking and terrifying debris field of rock and vaporized ice, all rendered in stunning, photorealistic 8K high resolution, creating an atmosphere of sublime and terrifying cosmic forces.", + "seed": 28614, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_3/index_7250_seed_28614_dp_6_rank_12_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.25078852362930776, + "vlm_logprob": -0.25078852362930776, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.85, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.25078852362930776, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extremely wide-angle view of a deep sky with stars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are two planets visible on a collision course, one terrestrial with rust-colored crust and aquamarine ocean, and one icy with pale blue crystalline fractures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera zoom in slowly while remaining fixed as the planets make contact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the terrestrial planet's crust expand and shatter into plates while the icy planet explodes into fragments upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a white-hot molten magma fireball erupt from the ruptured core of the terrestrial planet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.138150691986084 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3881506621837616 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.138150691986084, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -1.138150691986084, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25931400060653687, + 0.05322647467255592, + 0.09655282646417618, + 0.12186656892299652, + 0.03468536213040352, + 0.03690917789936066, + 0.04318975284695625, + 0.03602340444922447, + 0.3053392767906189, + 0.01289319060742855 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.138150691986084 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extremely wide-angle view of a deep sky with stars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are two planets visible on a collision course, one terrestrial with rust-colored crust and aquamarine ocean, and one icy with pale blue crystalline fractures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera zoom in slowly while remaining fixed as the planets make contact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the terrestrial planet's crust expand and shatter into plates while the icy planet explodes into fragments upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a white-hot molten magma fireball erupt from the ruptured core of the terrestrial planet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029862886294722557 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529862880706787 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029862886294722557, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029862886294722557, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1620209813117981, + 0.10450291633605957, + 0.4323463439941406, + 0.047361429780721664, + 0.043020978569984436, + 0.07300557941198349, + 0.024537745863199234, + 0.02073586918413639, + 0.06653577089309692, + 0.02593233436346054 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029862886294722557 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extremely wide-angle view of a deep sky with stars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are two planets visible on a collision course, one terrestrial with rust-colored crust and aquamarine ocean, and one icy with pale blue crystalline fractures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera zoom in slowly while remaining fixed as the planets make contact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the terrestrial planet's crust expand and shatter into plates while the icy planet explodes into fragments upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a white-hot molten magma fireball erupt from the ruptured core of the terrestrial planet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.054990630596876144 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929990530014038 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.054990630596876144, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.054990630596876144, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05784813314676285, + 0.03575040400028229, + 0.059248749166727066, + 0.06769836694002151, + 0.07823313027620316, + 0.10681974142789841, + 0.07212607562541962, + 0.21126827597618103, + 0.2915003001689911, + 0.019506821408867836 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.054990630596876144 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extremely wide-angle view of a deep sky with stars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are two planets visible on a collision course, one terrestrial with rust-colored crust and aquamarine ocean, and one icy with pale blue crystalline fractures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera zoom in slowly while remaining fixed as the planets make contact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the terrestrial planet's crust expand and shatter into plates while the icy planet explodes into fragments upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a white-hot molten magma fireball erupt from the ruptured core of the terrestrial planet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007641134783625603 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882641315460205 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007641134783625603, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007641134783625603, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16962018609046936, + 0.06766197830438614, + 0.2863352298736572, + 0.0542614720761776, + 0.1255062222480774, + 0.08490990102291107, + 0.05234362557530403, + 0.03428751230239868, + 0.04479392617940903, + 0.0802798718214035 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007641134783625603 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extremely wide-angle view of a deep sky with stars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are two planets visible on a collision course, one terrestrial with rust-colored crust and aquamarine ocean, and one icy with pale blue crystalline fractures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera zoom in slowly while remaining fixed as the planets make contact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the terrestrial planet's crust expand and shatter into plates while the icy planet explodes into fragments upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a white-hot molten magma fireball erupt from the ruptured core of the terrestrial planet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023297274485230446 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732973098754883 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023297274485230446, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023297274485230446, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09526921808719635, + 0.06616358458995819, + 0.25380387902259827, + 0.055888984352350235, + 0.20504343509674072, + 0.05945101007819176, + 0.04626941680908203, + 0.07446624338626862, + 0.0771046057343483, + 0.06653960049152374 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023297274485230446 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extremely wide-angle shot, zooming in slowly and majestically, captures a silent ballet of cosmic destruction across the vast, star-studded expanse of deep sky. Two planets are on an inevitable collision course. One is a terrestrial world with a cracked, rust-colored crust and a deep, aquamarine ocean partially obscured by swirling white clouds; the other is a smaller, icy sphere, its pale blue surface a complex network of crystalline fractures. The camera remains fixed as they make contact. The impact is silent but visually deafening; the Earth-like planet's crust expands and shatters into continent-sized plates, which are violently thrust outward. Simultaneously, the icy planet's surface explodes into trillions of glittering fragments. From its ruptured core, brilliant, white-hot molten magma erupts in a furious, expanding fireball, casting a stark, dramatic light upon the unfolding chaos. Fiery tendrils of liquid rock and superheated gas blast outward, creating a breathtaking and terrifying debris field of rock and vaporized ice, all rendered in stunning, photorealistic 8K high resolution, creating an atmosphere of sublime and terrifying cosmic forces.", + "seed": 28615, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_3/index_7250_seed_28615_dp_6_rank_12_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.12013889998197555, + "vlm_logprob": -0.12013889998197555, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.475, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.12013889998197555, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extremely wide-angle view of a deep sky with stars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are two planets visible on a collision course, one terrestrial with rust-colored crust and aquamarine ocean, and one icy with pale blue crystalline fractures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera zoom in slowly while remaining fixed as the planets make contact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the terrestrial planet's crust expand and shatter into plates while the icy planet explodes into fragments upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a white-hot molten magma fireball erupt from the ruptured core of the terrestrial planet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5251631140708923 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9001631140708923 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5251631140708923, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5251631140708923, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4853288531303406, + 0.05687093362212181, + 0.03392459824681282, + 0.12869465351104736, + 0.06220468878746033, + 0.07558917999267578, + 0.07950916141271591, + 0.03423674777150154, + 0.018963592126965523, + 0.024677537381649017 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5251631140708923 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extremely wide-angle view of a deep sky with stars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are two planets visible on a collision course, one terrestrial with rust-colored crust and aquamarine ocean, and one icy with pale blue crystalline fractures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera zoom in slowly while remaining fixed as the planets make contact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the terrestrial planet's crust expand and shatter into plates while the icy planet explodes into fragments upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a white-hot molten magma fireball erupt from the ruptured core of the terrestrial planet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011120719835162163 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511120796203613 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011120719835162163, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011120719835162163, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08330301195383072, + 0.052172575145959854, + 0.02527754195034504, + 0.6100245714187622, + 0.03305326774716377, + 0.0810205340385437, + 0.028230905532836914, + 0.04006922245025635, + 0.02513997256755829, + 0.021708372980356216 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011120719835162163 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extremely wide-angle view of a deep sky with stars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are two planets visible on a collision course, one terrestrial with rust-colored crust and aquamarine ocean, and one icy with pale blue crystalline fractures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera zoom in slowly while remaining fixed as the planets make contact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the terrestrial planet's crust expand and shatter into plates while the icy planet explodes into fragments upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a white-hot molten magma fireball erupt from the ruptured core of the terrestrial planet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.043079499155282974 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680796146392822 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.043079499155282974, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.043079499155282974, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4143122732639313, + 0.08579906076192856, + 0.047308001667261124, + 0.05481386184692383, + 0.09072955697774887, + 0.07227364927530289, + 0.03885011374950409, + 0.08602581173181534, + 0.0751502513885498, + 0.03473740071058273 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.043079499155282974 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extremely wide-angle view of a deep sky with stars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are two planets visible on a collision course, one terrestrial with rust-colored crust and aquamarine ocean, and one icy with pale blue crystalline fractures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera zoom in slowly while remaining fixed as the planets make contact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the terrestrial planet's crust expand and shatter into plates while the icy planet explodes into fragments upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a white-hot molten magma fireball erupt from the ruptured core of the terrestrial planet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005262095481157303 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.2552618980407715 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005262095481157303, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005262095481157303, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1399662345647812, + 0.3244347870349884, + 0.02682517096400261, + 0.07949364185333252, + 0.045820798724889755, + 0.06134021282196045, + 0.11966294050216675, + 0.058169636875391006, + 0.058397866785526276, + 0.08588879555463791 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005262095481157303 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extremely wide-angle view of a deep sky with stars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are two planets visible on a collision course, one terrestrial with rust-colored crust and aquamarine ocean, and one icy with pale blue crystalline fractures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera zoom in slowly while remaining fixed as the planets make contact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the terrestrial planet's crust expand and shatter into plates while the icy planet explodes into fragments upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a white-hot molten magma fireball erupt from the ruptured core of the terrestrial planet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016069071367383003 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141068935394287 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016069071367383003, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016069071367383003, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1786518543958664, + 0.20787544548511505, + 0.02270927093923092, + 0.10107605159282684, + 0.014127056114375591, + 0.15146470069885254, + 0.19519002735614777, + 0.036116279661655426, + 0.04558685049414635, + 0.04720248654484749 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016069071367383003 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extremely wide-angle shot, zooming in slowly and majestically, captures a silent ballet of cosmic destruction across the vast, star-studded expanse of deep sky. Two planets are on an inevitable collision course. One is a terrestrial world with a cracked, rust-colored crust and a deep, aquamarine ocean partially obscured by swirling white clouds; the other is a smaller, icy sphere, its pale blue surface a complex network of crystalline fractures. The camera remains fixed as they make contact. The impact is silent but visually deafening; the Earth-like planet's crust expands and shatters into continent-sized plates, which are violently thrust outward. Simultaneously, the icy planet's surface explodes into trillions of glittering fragments. From its ruptured core, brilliant, white-hot molten magma erupts in a furious, expanding fireball, casting a stark, dramatic light upon the unfolding chaos. Fiery tendrils of liquid rock and superheated gas blast outward, creating a breathtaking and terrifying debris field of rock and vaporized ice, all rendered in stunning, photorealistic 8K high resolution, creating an atmosphere of sublime and terrifying cosmic forces.", + "seed": 28616, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_3/index_7250_seed_28616_dp_7_rank_14_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.5194828258827329, + "vlm_logprob": -0.5194828258827329, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.6, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.5194828258827329, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extremely wide-angle view of a deep sky with stars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are two planets visible on a collision course, one terrestrial with rust-colored crust and aquamarine ocean, and one icy with pale blue crystalline fractures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera zoom in slowly while remaining fixed as the planets make contact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the terrestrial planet's crust expand and shatter into plates while the icy planet explodes into fragments upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a white-hot molten magma fireball erupt from the ruptured core of the terrestrial planet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4647057056427 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08970566838979721 + ], + "logprob_reward": -2.4647057056427, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -2.4647057056427, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2919243276119232, + 0.10154221206903458, + 0.021732036024332047, + 0.05192059651017189, + 0.022060390561819077, + 0.07304300367832184, + 0.056304674595594406, + 0.0834730938076973, + 0.10857200622558594, + 0.1894276887178421 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -2.4647057056427 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extremely wide-angle view of a deep sky with stars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are two planets visible on a collision course, one terrestrial with rust-colored crust and aquamarine ocean, and one icy with pale blue crystalline fractures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera zoom in slowly while remaining fixed as the planets make contact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the terrestrial planet's crust expand and shatter into plates while the icy planet explodes into fragments upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a white-hot molten magma fireball erupt from the ruptured core of the terrestrial planet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023411868140101433 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773411750793457 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023411868140101433, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023411868140101433, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10592896491289139, + 0.0761629119515419, + 0.02411891147494316, + 0.06912247091531754, + 0.03183264285326004, + 0.06295421719551086, + 0.04806489869952202, + 0.2113589495420456, + 0.1531359851360321, + 0.21731999516487122 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023411868140101433 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extremely wide-angle view of a deep sky with stars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are two planets visible on a collision course, one terrestrial with rust-colored crust and aquamarine ocean, and one icy with pale blue crystalline fractures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera zoom in slowly while remaining fixed as the planets make contact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the terrestrial planet's crust expand and shatter into plates while the icy planet explodes into fragments upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a white-hot molten magma fireball erupt from the ruptured core of the terrestrial planet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08910805732011795 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4641079902648926 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08910805732011795, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08910805732011795, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16330769658088684, + 0.05134294554591179, + 0.024537602439522743, + 0.04014336317777634, + 0.023489605635404587, + 0.12453658133745193, + 0.07711784541606903, + 0.15548257529735565, + 0.17571786046028137, + 0.16432392597198486 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08910805732011795 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extremely wide-angle view of a deep sky with stars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are two planets visible on a collision course, one terrestrial with rust-colored crust and aquamarine ocean, and one icy with pale blue crystalline fractures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera zoom in slowly while remaining fixed as the planets make contact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the terrestrial planet's crust expand and shatter into plates while the icy planet explodes into fragments upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a white-hot molten magma fireball erupt from the ruptured core of the terrestrial planet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007641607895493507 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882641792297363 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007641607895493507, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007641607895493507, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14924705028533936, + 0.04998094215989113, + 0.018600009381771088, + 0.021052831783890724, + 0.016657641157507896, + 0.07270350307226181, + 0.047931820154190063, + 0.11098624765872955, + 0.2950761914253235, + 0.21776379644870758 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007641607895493507 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extremely wide-angle view of a deep sky with stars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are two planets visible on a collision course, one terrestrial with rust-colored crust and aquamarine ocean, and one icy with pale blue crystalline fractures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera zoom in slowly while remaining fixed as the planets make contact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the terrestrial planet's crust expand and shatter into plates while the icy planet explodes into fragments upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a white-hot molten magma fireball erupt from the ruptured core of the terrestrial planet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012546890415251255 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387547016143799 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012546890415251255, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012546890415251255, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19006669521331787, + 0.06949309259653091, + 0.02284279838204384, + 0.032085396349430084, + 0.028402229771018028, + 0.05495710298418999, + 0.0654551088809967, + 0.14603881537914276, + 0.21663083136081696, + 0.1740279495716095 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012546890415251255 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extremely wide-angle shot, zooming in slowly and majestically, captures a silent ballet of cosmic destruction across the vast, star-studded expanse of deep sky. Two planets are on an inevitable collision course. One is a terrestrial world with a cracked, rust-colored crust and a deep, aquamarine ocean partially obscured by swirling white clouds; the other is a smaller, icy sphere, its pale blue surface a complex network of crystalline fractures. The camera remains fixed as they make contact. The impact is silent but visually deafening; the Earth-like planet's crust expands and shatters into continent-sized plates, which are violently thrust outward. Simultaneously, the icy planet's surface explodes into trillions of glittering fragments. From its ruptured core, brilliant, white-hot molten magma erupts in a furious, expanding fireball, casting a stark, dramatic light upon the unfolding chaos. Fiery tendrils of liquid rock and superheated gas blast outward, creating a breathtaking and terrifying debris field of rock and vaporized ice, all rendered in stunning, photorealistic 8K high resolution, creating an atmosphere of sublime and terrifying cosmic forces.", + "seed": 28617, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_3/index_7250_seed_28617_dp_7_rank_14_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.14308324567973613, + "vlm_logprob": -0.14308324567973613, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.825, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.14308324567973613, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extremely wide-angle view of a deep sky with stars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are two planets visible on a collision course, one terrestrial with rust-colored crust and aquamarine ocean, and one icy with pale blue crystalline fractures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera zoom in slowly while remaining fixed as the planets make contact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the terrestrial planet's crust expand and shatter into plates while the icy planet explodes into fragments upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a white-hot molten magma fireball erupt from the ruptured core of the terrestrial planet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5778993964195251 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8278993964195251 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5778993964195251, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5778993964195251, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.29294124245643616, + 0.13583071529865265, + 0.031546689569950104, + 0.06911357492208481, + 0.1271112561225891, + 0.06175662577152252, + 0.07173924893140793, + 0.05013218894600868, + 0.06756551563739777, + 0.09226299822330475 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5778993964195251 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extremely wide-angle view of a deep sky with stars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are two planets visible on a collision course, one terrestrial with rust-colored crust and aquamarine ocean, and one icy with pale blue crystalline fractures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera zoom in slowly while remaining fixed as the planets make contact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the terrestrial planet's crust expand and shatter into plates while the icy planet explodes into fragments upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a white-hot molten magma fireball erupt from the ruptured core of the terrestrial planet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0431424118578434 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168142318725586 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0431424118578434, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0431424118578434, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23725856840610504, + 0.10043177008628845, + 0.04369483143091202, + 0.29609745740890503, + 0.02748115360736847, + 0.01780529133975506, + 0.02412606216967106, + 0.06534917652606964, + 0.12245670706033707, + 0.06529895961284637 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0431424118578434 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extremely wide-angle view of a deep sky with stars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are two planets visible on a collision course, one terrestrial with rust-colored crust and aquamarine ocean, and one icy with pale blue crystalline fractures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera zoom in slowly while remaining fixed as the planets make contact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the terrestrial planet's crust expand and shatter into plates while the icy planet explodes into fragments upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a white-hot molten magma fireball erupt from the ruptured core of the terrestrial planet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05498882383108139 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299888610839844 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05498882383108139, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05498882383108139, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08067850768566132, + 0.05065552517771721, + 0.09159331023693085, + 0.11682900786399841, + 0.19969046115875244, + 0.03790086880326271, + 0.03405167534947395, + 0.10523612052202225, + 0.1715744435787201, + 0.11179002374410629 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 8, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05498882383108139 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extremely wide-angle view of a deep sky with stars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are two planets visible on a collision course, one terrestrial with rust-colored crust and aquamarine ocean, and one icy with pale blue crystalline fractures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera zoom in slowly while remaining fixed as the planets make contact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the terrestrial planet's crust expand and shatter into plates while the icy planet explodes into fragments upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a white-hot molten magma fireball erupt from the ruptured core of the terrestrial planet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016089951619505882 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141089916229248 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016089951619505882, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016089951619505882, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0665631964802742, + 0.04126865416765213, + 0.05898778513073921, + 0.06436822563409805, + 0.12274820357561111, + 0.1065131351351738, + 0.10362397134304047, + 0.06587144732475281, + 0.10192004591226578, + 0.26813530921936035 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016089951619505882 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extremely wide-angle view of a deep sky with stars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are two planets visible on a collision course, one terrestrial with rust-colored crust and aquamarine ocean, and one icy with pale blue crystalline fractures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera zoom in slowly while remaining fixed as the planets make contact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the terrestrial planet's crust expand and shatter into plates while the icy planet explodes into fragments upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a white-hot molten magma fireball erupt from the ruptured core of the terrestrial planet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02329564467072487 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732956409454346 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02329564467072487, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02329564467072487, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03301095962524414, + 0.013980516232550144, + 0.02421233430504799, + 0.02985566481947899, + 0.04256265610456467, + 0.047426577657461166, + 0.03104947693645954, + 0.07926250994205475, + 0.09306194633245468, + 0.605577290058136 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02329564467072487 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_4/index_tensor([4976, 4976])_group_4_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_4/index_tensor([4976, 4976])_group_4_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..5c6940c1cdf6bfdad0d7ed41f2e35900722732a5 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_4/index_tensor([4976, 4976])_group_4_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up, macro shot begins from a static, low-angle view, focusing on the underside of a weathered, black cast-iron handrail. A tiny, dried-out, pale-white paint, curling at the edges and showing fine cracks on its surface, clings precariously to the pitted, slightly rusted metal. The scene is illuminated by soft, diffuse ambient light from an overcast sky. Suddenly, a deep, low-frequency vibration travels through the handrail, causing the entire frame to subtly tremble. In cinematic slow motion, the last point of adhesion of the sheet shifts and delicately separates from the iron. The camera tilts steadily downward, maintaining focus as the sheet tumbles and drifts through the air, slowly rotating to reveal its fragile texture. Its descent ends, and it lands near-silently on a weathered wooden deck below, where it bounces once, almost imperceptibly, before coming to rest motionless on its side, a tiny speck of white against the prominent gray-brown grain of the sun-bleached wood, creating an atmosphere of quiet, focused, and contemplative thought.", + "seed": 31692, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_4/index_4976_seed_31692_dp_8_rank_16_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.014628128334879874, + "vlm_logprob": -0.014628128334879874, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.3, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.014628128334879874, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot an extreme close-up macro view of the underside of a weathered black cast-iron handrail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a tiny dried-out pale-white paint sheet visible on the handrail, showing fine cracks and curling at the edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the paint sheet separating from the handrail and tumbling through the air in cinematic slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt steadily downward as the paint sheet descends to reveal its texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the paint sheet land on a weathered wooden deck, bounce once, and come to rest motionless on its side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00846583116799593 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.883465766906738 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00846583116799593, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00846583116799593, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2154403030872345, + 0.07505859434604645, + 0.2415233701467514, + 0.15270604193210602, + 0.08767648786306381, + 0.031578510999679565, + 0.047218214720487595, + 0.0513194277882576, + 0.05904335528612137, + 0.038435641676187515 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00846583116799593 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot an extreme close-up macro view of the underside of a weathered black cast-iron handrail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a tiny dried-out pale-white paint sheet visible on the handrail, showing fine cracks and curling at the edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the paint sheet separating from the handrail and tumbling through the air in cinematic slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt steadily downward as the paint sheet descends to reveal its texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the paint sheet land on a weathered wooden deck, bounce once, and come to rest motionless on its side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011096316389739513 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511096477508545 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011096316389739513, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011096316389739513, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1522364467382431, + 0.04679657146334648, + 0.05791949853301048, + 0.5010658502578735, + 0.05118931829929352, + 0.013949265703558922, + 0.04737776145339012, + 0.03903695195913315, + 0.04158494248986244, + 0.0488433800637722 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011096316389739513 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot an extreme close-up macro view of the underside of a weathered black cast-iron handrail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a tiny dried-out pale-white paint sheet visible on the handrail, showing fine cracks and curling at the edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the paint sheet separating from the handrail and tumbling through the air in cinematic slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt steadily downward as the paint sheet descends to reveal its texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the paint sheet land on a weathered wooden deck, bounce once, and come to rest motionless on its side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014204232022166252 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264204025268555 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014204232022166252, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014204232022166252, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07183631509542465, + 0.016023414209485054, + 0.47173184156417847, + 0.16106124222278595, + 0.023144425824284554, + 0.03337661549448967, + 0.057898253202438354, + 0.057376928627491, + 0.03687913343310356, + 0.07067184895277023 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014204232022166252 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot an extreme close-up macro view of the underside of a weathered black cast-iron handrail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a tiny dried-out pale-white paint sheet visible on the handrail, showing fine cracks and curling at the edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the paint sheet separating from the handrail and tumbling through the air in cinematic slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt steadily downward as the paint sheet descends to reveal its texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the paint sheet land on a weathered wooden deck, bounce once, and come to rest motionless on its side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023305660113692284 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773305654525757 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023305660113692284, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023305660113692284, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07475895434617996, + 0.05179021134972572, + 0.07072309404611588, + 0.1903543323278427, + 0.0743873119354248, + 0.06481585651636124, + 0.06057114526629448, + 0.11312460899353027, + 0.0929068773984909, + 0.206567645072937 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 3, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023305660113692284 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot an extreme close-up macro view of the underside of a weathered black cast-iron handrail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a tiny dried-out pale-white paint sheet visible on the handrail, showing fine cracks and curling at the edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the paint sheet separating from the handrail and tumbling through the air in cinematic slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt steadily downward as the paint sheet descends to reveal its texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the paint sheet land on a weathered wooden deck, bounce once, and come to rest motionless on its side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016068601980805397 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141068458557129 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016068601980805397, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016068601980805397, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.020047171041369438, + 0.010909879580140114, + 0.06503228843212128, + 0.5071918368339539, + 0.03267720341682434, + 0.04790087789297104, + 0.03335471823811531, + 0.060669947415590286, + 0.03501718491315842, + 0.1871989518404007 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016068601980805397 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up, macro shot begins from a static, low-angle view, focusing on the underside of a weathered, black cast-iron handrail. A tiny, dried-out, pale-white paint, curling at the edges and showing fine cracks on its surface, clings precariously to the pitted, slightly rusted metal. The scene is illuminated by soft, diffuse ambient light from an overcast sky. Suddenly, a deep, low-frequency vibration travels through the handrail, causing the entire frame to subtly tremble. In cinematic slow motion, the last point of adhesion of the sheet shifts and delicately separates from the iron. The camera tilts steadily downward, maintaining focus as the sheet tumbles and drifts through the air, slowly rotating to reveal its fragile texture. Its descent ends, and it lands near-silently on a weathered wooden deck below, where it bounces once, almost imperceptibly, before coming to rest motionless on its side, a tiny speck of white against the prominent gray-brown grain of the sun-bleached wood, creating an atmosphere of quiet, focused, and contemplative thought.", + "seed": 31693, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_4/index_4976_seed_31693_dp_8_rank_16_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.029010096471756695, + "vlm_logprob": -0.029010096471756695, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.925, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.029010096471756695, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot an extreme close-up macro view of the underside of a weathered black cast-iron handrail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a tiny dried-out pale-white paint sheet visible on the handrail, showing fine cracks and curling at the edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the paint sheet separating from the handrail and tumbling through the air in cinematic slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt steadily downward as the paint sheet descends to reveal its texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the paint sheet land on a weathered wooden deck, bounce once, and come to rest motionless on its side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009363781660795212 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.884363651275635 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009363781660795212, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009363781660795212, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.41093146800994873, + 0.12280559539794922, + 0.06137758120894432, + 0.040942754596471786, + 0.025134555995464325, + 0.09485375881195068, + 0.05341210588812828, + 0.05786224827170372, + 0.05557463690638542, + 0.07710528373718262 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009363781660795212 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot an extreme close-up macro view of the underside of a weathered black cast-iron handrail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a tiny dried-out pale-white paint sheet visible on the handrail, showing fine cracks and curling at the edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the paint sheet separating from the handrail and tumbling through the air in cinematic slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt steadily downward as the paint sheet descends to reveal its texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the paint sheet land on a weathered wooden deck, bounce once, and come to rest motionless on its side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006756910588592291 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006756782531738 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006756910588592291, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006756910588592291, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.323183536529541, + 0.14603166282176971, + 0.03667665272951126, + 0.2477809339761734, + 0.042471516877412796, + 0.04971378296613693, + 0.035585321485996246, + 0.04069305583834648, + 0.03521697223186493, + 0.04264656454324722 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006756910588592291 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot an extreme close-up macro view of the underside of a weathered black cast-iron handrail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a tiny dried-out pale-white paint sheet visible on the handrail, showing fine cracks and curling at the edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the paint sheet separating from the handrail and tumbling through the air in cinematic slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt steadily downward as the paint sheet descends to reveal its texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the paint sheet land on a weathered wooden deck, bounce once, and come to rest motionless on its side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01819690316915512 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018197059631348 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01819690316915512, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01819690316915512, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.26167815923690796, + 0.16038936376571655, + 0.037504907697439194, + 0.11271858960390091, + 0.11916252970695496, + 0.11636879295110703, + 0.07365536689758301, + 0.01827837899327278, + 0.0750298798084259, + 0.025213995948433876 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01819690316915512 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot an extreme close-up macro view of the underside of a weathered black cast-iron handrail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a tiny dried-out pale-white paint sheet visible on the handrail, showing fine cracks and curling at the edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the paint sheet separating from the handrail and tumbling through the air in cinematic slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt steadily downward as the paint sheet descends to reveal its texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the paint sheet land on a weathered wooden deck, bounce once, and come to rest motionless on its side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06207640469074249 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120763301849365 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06207640469074249, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06207640469074249, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21017037332057953, + 0.08383499085903168, + 0.04120418056845665, + 0.09449873119592667, + 0.0323854498565197, + 0.12049101293087006, + 0.07470575720071793, + 0.10764899849891663, + 0.17523999512195587, + 0.05982057750225067 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06207640469074249 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot an extreme close-up macro view of the underside of a weathered black cast-iron handrail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a tiny dried-out pale-white paint sheet visible on the handrail, showing fine cracks and curling at the edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the paint sheet separating from the handrail and tumbling through the air in cinematic slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt steadily downward as the paint sheet descends to reveal its texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the paint sheet land on a weathered wooden deck, bounce once, and come to rest motionless on its side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04865648224949837 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048656463623047 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04865648224949837, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04865648224949837, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09458248317241669, + 0.04270515590906143, + 0.04062419384717941, + 0.05475468933582306, + 0.035423845052719116, + 0.10660529881715775, + 0.12036750465631485, + 0.15977521240711212, + 0.1679062396287918, + 0.17725534737110138 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04865648224949837 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up, macro shot begins from a static, low-angle view, focusing on the underside of a weathered, black cast-iron handrail. A tiny, dried-out, pale-white paint, curling at the edges and showing fine cracks on its surface, clings precariously to the pitted, slightly rusted metal. The scene is illuminated by soft, diffuse ambient light from an overcast sky. Suddenly, a deep, low-frequency vibration travels through the handrail, causing the entire frame to subtly tremble. In cinematic slow motion, the last point of adhesion of the sheet shifts and delicately separates from the iron. The camera tilts steadily downward, maintaining focus as the sheet tumbles and drifts through the air, slowly rotating to reveal its fragile texture. Its descent ends, and it lands near-silently on a weathered wooden deck below, where it bounces once, almost imperceptibly, before coming to rest motionless on its side, a tiny speck of white against the prominent gray-brown grain of the sun-bleached wood, creating an atmosphere of quiet, focused, and contemplative thought.", + "seed": 31694, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_4/index_4976_seed_31694_dp_9_rank_18_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.016458224039524794, + "vlm_logprob": -0.016458224039524794, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.575, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.016458224039524794, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot an extreme close-up macro view of the underside of a weathered black cast-iron handrail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a tiny dried-out pale-white paint sheet visible on the handrail, showing fine cracks and curling at the edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the paint sheet separating from the handrail and tumbling through the air in cinematic slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt steadily downward as the paint sheet descends to reveal its texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the paint sheet land on a weathered wooden deck, bounce once, and come to rest motionless on its side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006302481517195702 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.256302356719971 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006302481517195702, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006302481517195702, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20337556302547455, + 0.04383274167776108, + 0.27539393305778503, + 0.06299858540296555, + 0.176222026348114, + 0.04017208516597748, + 0.09960120171308517, + 0.03837740793824196, + 0.03621493652462959, + 0.02381153777241707 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006302481517195702 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot an extreme close-up macro view of the underside of a weathered black cast-iron handrail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a tiny dried-out pale-white paint sheet visible on the handrail, showing fine cracks and curling at the edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the paint sheet separating from the handrail and tumbling through the air in cinematic slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt steadily downward as the paint sheet descends to reveal its texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the paint sheet land on a weathered wooden deck, bounce once, and come to rest motionless on its side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00764006981626153 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.8826398849487305 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00764006981626153, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00764006981626153, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19600890576839447, + 0.020674049854278564, + 0.12131098657846451, + 0.12548106908798218, + 0.30246463418006897, + 0.03431513160467148, + 0.08706976473331451, + 0.06169050559401512, + 0.036298688501119614, + 0.014686252921819687 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00764006981626153 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot an extreme close-up macro view of the underside of a weathered black cast-iron handrail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a tiny dried-out pale-white paint sheet visible on the handrail, showing fine cracks and curling at the edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the paint sheet separating from the handrail and tumbling through the air in cinematic slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt steadily downward as the paint sheet descends to reveal its texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the paint sheet land on a weathered wooden deck, bounce once, and come to rest motionless on its side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036182431504130363 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628618240356445 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036182431504130363, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036182431504130363, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0859556496143341, + 0.04489348828792572, + 0.14507685601711273, + 0.17417137324810028, + 0.07737202942371368, + 0.10634564608335495, + 0.13376455008983612, + 0.156904399394989, + 0.06199052184820175, + 0.013525499030947685 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 7, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036182431504130363 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot an extreme close-up macro view of the underside of a weathered black cast-iron handrail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a tiny dried-out pale-white paint sheet visible on the handrail, showing fine cracks and curling at the edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the paint sheet separating from the handrail and tumbling through the air in cinematic slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt steadily downward as the paint sheet descends to reveal its texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the paint sheet land on a weathered wooden deck, bounce once, and come to rest motionless on its side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04866465553641319 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486645698547363 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04866465553641319, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04866465553641319, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05025199055671692, + 0.032799556851387024, + 0.345245897769928, + 0.07321707159280777, + 0.042605988681316376, + 0.05156736448407173, + 0.17346052825450897, + 0.12053753435611725, + 0.10085438191890717, + 0.009459705092012882 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04866465553641319 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot an extreme close-up macro view of the underside of a weathered black cast-iron handrail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a tiny dried-out pale-white paint sheet visible on the handrail, showing fine cracks and curling at the edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the paint sheet separating from the handrail and tumbling through the air in cinematic slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt steadily downward as the paint sheet descends to reveal its texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the paint sheet land on a weathered wooden deck, bounce once, and come to rest motionless on its side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016065670177340508 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.14106559753418 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016065670177340508, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016065670177340508, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0539047047495842, + 0.044387999922037125, + 0.1490769237279892, + 0.0429132916033268, + 0.03007015585899353, + 0.07786838710308075, + 0.31571143865585327, + 0.1050492525100708, + 0.08698870241641998, + 0.09402921050786972 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 2, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016065670177340508 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up, macro shot begins from a static, low-angle view, focusing on the underside of a weathered, black cast-iron handrail. A tiny, dried-out, pale-white paint, curling at the edges and showing fine cracks on its surface, clings precariously to the pitted, slightly rusted metal. The scene is illuminated by soft, diffuse ambient light from an overcast sky. Suddenly, a deep, low-frequency vibration travels through the handrail, causing the entire frame to subtly tremble. In cinematic slow motion, the last point of adhesion of the sheet shifts and delicately separates from the iron. The camera tilts steadily downward, maintaining focus as the sheet tumbles and drifts through the air, slowly rotating to reveal its fragile texture. Its descent ends, and it lands near-silently on a weathered wooden deck below, where it bounces once, almost imperceptibly, before coming to rest motionless on its side, a tiny speck of white against the prominent gray-brown grain of the sun-bleached wood, creating an atmosphere of quiet, focused, and contemplative thought.", + "seed": 31695, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_4/index_4976_seed_31695_dp_9_rank_18_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.009752311930060386, + "vlm_logprob": -0.009752311930060386, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.875, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.009752311930060386, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot an extreme close-up macro view of the underside of a weathered black cast-iron handrail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a tiny dried-out pale-white paint sheet visible on the handrail, showing fine cracks and curling at the edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the paint sheet separating from the handrail and tumbling through the air in cinematic slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt steadily downward as the paint sheet descends to reveal its texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the paint sheet land on a weathered wooden deck, bounce once, and come to rest motionless on its side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009155434556305408 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.8841552734375 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009155434556305408, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009155434556305408, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0790691077709198, + 0.06147635728120804, + 0.054544590413570404, + 0.06619132310152054, + 0.04148247465491295, + 0.02822842448949814, + 0.10458254814147949, + 0.2825683355331421, + 0.23749764263629913, + 0.044359225779771805 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009155434556305408 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot an extreme close-up macro view of the underside of a weathered black cast-iron handrail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a tiny dried-out pale-white paint sheet visible on the handrail, showing fine cracks and curling at the edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the paint sheet separating from the handrail and tumbling through the air in cinematic slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt steadily downward as the paint sheet descends to reveal its texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the paint sheet land on a weathered wooden deck, bounce once, and come to rest motionless on its side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036292895674705505 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628629207611084 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036292895674705505, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036292895674705505, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11061885207891464, + 0.05790189653635025, + 0.14301487803459167, + 0.03885491192340851, + 0.117788165807724, + 0.026006901636719704, + 0.07101116329431534, + 0.24856330454349518, + 0.1278136968612671, + 0.058426178991794586 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 2, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036292895674705505 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot an extreme close-up macro view of the underside of a weathered black cast-iron handrail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a tiny dried-out pale-white paint sheet visible on the handrail, showing fine cracks and curling at the edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the paint sheet separating from the handrail and tumbling through the air in cinematic slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt steadily downward as the paint sheet descends to reveal its texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the paint sheet land on a weathered wooden deck, bounce once, and come to rest motionless on its side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005952843930572271 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130952835083008 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005952843930572271, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005952843930572271, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.055798981338739395, + 0.03913095220923424, + 0.030766520649194717, + 0.08926214277744293, + 0.07643977552652359, + 0.021498464047908783, + 0.2644878625869751, + 0.23939840495586395, + 0.08471525460481644, + 0.09850170463323593 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005952843930572271 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot an extreme close-up macro view of the underside of a weathered black cast-iron handrail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a tiny dried-out pale-white paint sheet visible on the handrail, showing fine cracks and curling at the edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the paint sheet separating from the handrail and tumbling through the air in cinematic slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt steadily downward as the paint sheet descends to reveal its texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the paint sheet land on a weathered wooden deck, bounce once, and come to rest motionless on its side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006740925367921591 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006741046905518 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006740925367921591, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006740925367921591, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07119543850421906, + 0.022618338465690613, + 0.0563015416264534, + 0.10820773243904114, + 0.10602395981550217, + 0.04832664132118225, + 0.20548425614833832, + 0.18024015426635742, + 0.12228737771511078, + 0.07931450754404068 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006740925367921591 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot an extreme close-up macro view of the underside of a weathered black cast-iron handrail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a tiny dried-out pale-white paint sheet visible on the handrail, showing fine cracks and curling at the edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the paint sheet separating from the handrail and tumbling through the air in cinematic slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt steadily downward as the paint sheet descends to reveal its texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the paint sheet land on a weathered wooden deck, bounce once, and come to rest motionless on its side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023283066228032112 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773283004760742 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023283066228032112, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023283066228032112, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06959924101829529, + 0.045787911862134933, + 0.023210784420371056, + 0.02609320357441902, + 0.03024587593972683, + 0.02450663596391678, + 0.11888337880373001, + 0.2938272953033447, + 0.10628601908683777, + 0.26155978441238403 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023283066228032112 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_5/index_tensor([1133, 1133])_group_5_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_5/index_tensor([1133, 1133])_group_5_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..12a0b28f92547efe6df459ee1357d5825f205683 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_5/index_tensor([1133, 1133])_group_5_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "static, eye-level wide-angle shot captures a scene of profound tranquility. A solitary figure sits on a simple wooden box at the end of a long, weathered wooden pier, wearing a weathered dark green waterproof jacket and a gray wool beanie. The pier's planks, worn and gray, extend directly from the camera lens into the calm water. The man's posture is one of patient stillness, slightly hunched, his grip steady and deliberate on a long, thin fishing rod, its line disappearing into the glassy water below. The sky above is a masterpiece of dawn, a soft, diffuse glow illuminating pastel pinks, pale oranges, and cool blues that blend seamlessly at the horizon. This newly born light reflects perfectly on the mirror-like surface of the water, broken only by the faintest ripples lapping against the mossy pillars of the pier. The entire environment is immersed in a cool, quiet atmosphere, creating a profound sense of tranquil solitude and meditative waiting.", + "seed": 4816, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_5/index_1133_seed_4816_dp_10_rank_20_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.029568835347890853, + "vlm_logprob": -0.029568835347890853, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.3, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.029568835347890853, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a solitary figure sitting on a simple wooden box at the end of a long, weathered wooden pier visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing a weathered dark green waterproof jacket and a gray wool beanie?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the figure holding a long, thin fishing rod with the line disappearing into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the sky displaying a dawn glow with pastel pinks, pale oranges, and cool blues blending at the horizon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, eye-level wide-angle view where the pier planks extend directly from the camera lens into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0059755961410701275 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255975723266602 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0059755961410701275, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0059755961410701275, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3814474046230316, + 0.1592443287372589, + 0.03753543645143509, + 0.0517842061817646, + 0.02147062122821808, + 0.1350555568933487, + 0.004895327612757683, + 0.15182074904441833, + 0.047707606106996536, + 0.00903876218944788 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0059755961410701275 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a solitary figure sitting on a simple wooden box at the end of a long, weathered wooden pier visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing a weathered dark green waterproof jacket and a gray wool beanie?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the figure holding a long, thin fishing rod with the line disappearing into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the sky displaying a dawn glow with pastel pinks, pale oranges, and cool blues blending at the horizon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, eye-level wide-angle view where the pier planks extend directly from the camera lens into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023299487307667732 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732994556427 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023299487307667732, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023299487307667732, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2056848406791687, + 0.1278102546930313, + 0.008109780959784985, + 0.1334431916475296, + 0.03467075526714325, + 0.2444324642419815, + 0.0035554184578359127, + 0.1559240072965622, + 0.006586168427020311, + 0.07978316396474838 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023299487307667732 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a solitary figure sitting on a simple wooden box at the end of a long, weathered wooden pier visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing a weathered dark green waterproof jacket and a gray wool beanie?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the figure holding a long, thin fishing rod with the line disappearing into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the sky displaying a dawn glow with pastel pinks, pale oranges, and cool blues blending at the horizon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, eye-level wide-angle view where the pier planks extend directly from the camera lens into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016081036999821663 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141080856323242 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016081036999821663, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016081036999821663, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05577988922595978, + 0.3926538825035095, + 0.04982775077223778, + 0.1072477176785469, + 0.04046541079878807, + 0.1083563044667244, + 0.012035300955176353, + 0.06449343264102936, + 0.010089869610965252, + 0.15905043482780457 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016081036999821663 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a solitary figure sitting on a simple wooden box at the end of a long, weathered wooden pier visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing a weathered dark green waterproof jacket and a gray wool beanie?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the figure holding a long, thin fishing rod with the line disappearing into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the sky displaying a dawn glow with pastel pinks, pale oranges, and cool blues blending at the horizon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, eye-level wide-angle view where the pier planks extend directly from the camera lens into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0021962826140224934 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127196311950684 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0021962826140224934, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0021962826140224934, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.44203391671180725, + 0.0769086480140686, + 0.026221077889204025, + 0.10546967387199402, + 0.02884126454591751, + 0.0762285590171814, + 0.006719732191413641, + 0.08136442303657532, + 0.09215807914733887, + 0.06405459344387054 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0021962826140224934 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a solitary figure sitting on a simple wooden box at the end of a long, weathered wooden pier visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing a weathered dark green waterproof jacket and a gray wool beanie?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the figure holding a long, thin fishing rod with the line disappearing into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the sky displaying a dawn glow with pastel pinks, pale oranges, and cool blues blending at the horizon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, eye-level wide-angle view where the pier planks extend directly from the camera lens into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10029177367687225 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3502917289733887 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10029177367687225, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10029177367687225, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3657548427581787, + 0.14670772850513458, + 0.02721473015844822, + 0.01760444976389408, + 0.024718521162867546, + 0.20109783113002777, + 0.004548446740955114, + 0.1834699511528015, + 0.006026240065693855, + 0.022857269272208214 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10029177367687225 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, eye-level wide-angle shot captures a scene of profound tranquility. A solitary figure sits on a simple wooden box at the end of a long, weathered wooden pier, wearing a weathered dark green waterproof jacket and a gray wool beanie. The pier's planks, worn and gray, extend directly from the camera lens into the calm water. The man's posture is one of patient stillness, slightly hunched, his grip steady and deliberate on a long, thin fishing rod, its line disappearing into the glassy water below. The sky above is a masterpiece of dawn, a soft, diffuse glow illuminating pastel pinks, pale oranges, and cool blues that blend seamlessly at the horizon. This newly born light reflects perfectly on the mirror-like surface of the water, broken only by the faintest ripples lapping against the mossy pillars of the pier. The entire environment is immersed in a cool, quiet atmosphere, creating a profound sense of tranquil solitude and meditative waiting.", + "seed": 4817, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_5/index_1133_seed_4817_dp_10_rank_20_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.05128666646778583, + "vlm_logprob": -0.05128666646778583, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.625, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.05128666646778583, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a solitary figure sitting on a simple wooden box at the end of a long, weathered wooden pier visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing a weathered dark green waterproof jacket and a gray wool beanie?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the figure holding a long, thin fishing rod with the line disappearing into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the sky displaying a dawn glow with pastel pinks, pale oranges, and cool blues blending at the horizon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, eye-level wide-angle view where the pier planks extend directly from the camera lens into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012601747177541256 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.512601852416992 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012601747177541256, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012601747177541256, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1908390074968338, + 0.12983258068561554, + 0.08940078318119049, + 0.06798043102025986, + 0.14977650344371796, + 0.06066739559173584, + 0.09043006598949432, + 0.05089559778571129, + 0.1020573303103447, + 0.06812023371458054 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012601747177541256 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a solitary figure sitting on a simple wooden box at the end of a long, weathered wooden pier visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing a weathered dark green waterproof jacket and a gray wool beanie?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the figure holding a long, thin fishing rod with the line disappearing into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the sky displaying a dawn glow with pastel pinks, pale oranges, and cool blues blending at the horizon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, eye-level wide-angle view where the pier planks extend directly from the camera lens into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.038115546107292175 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881155014038086 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.038115546107292175, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.038115546107292175, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21681268513202667, + 0.13198165595531464, + 0.18874841928482056, + 0.1408994495868683, + 0.06699040532112122, + 0.028202960267663002, + 0.07852338254451752, + 0.05258575826883316, + 0.0520256944000721, + 0.0432295985519886 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.038115546107292175 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a solitary figure sitting on a simple wooden box at the end of a long, weathered wooden pier visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing a weathered dark green waterproof jacket and a gray wool beanie?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the figure holding a long, thin fishing rod with the line disappearing into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the sky displaying a dawn glow with pastel pinks, pale oranges, and cool blues blending at the horizon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, eye-level wide-angle view where the pier planks extend directly from the camera lens into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016083501279354095 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141083717346191 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016083501279354095, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016083501279354095, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24605800211429596, + 0.13276968896389008, + 0.2016911804676056, + 0.07086878269910812, + 0.050465017557144165, + 0.07038483768701553, + 0.07350727170705795, + 0.07643437385559082, + 0.029586978256702423, + 0.048233889043331146 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016083501279354095 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a solitary figure sitting on a simple wooden box at the end of a long, weathered wooden pier visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing a weathered dark green waterproof jacket and a gray wool beanie?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the figure holding a long, thin fishing rod with the line disappearing into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the sky displaying a dawn glow with pastel pinks, pale oranges, and cool blues blending at the horizon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, eye-level wide-angle view where the pier planks extend directly from the camera lens into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009778338484466076 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.6347784996032715 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009778338484466076, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009778338484466076, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4735531508922577, + 0.11790713667869568, + 0.05636812001466751, + 0.08561799675226212, + 0.03324710950255394, + 0.029229536652565002, + 0.055653054267168045, + 0.02409438043832779, + 0.09894679486751556, + 0.025382699444890022 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009778338484466076 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a solitary figure sitting on a simple wooden box at the end of a long, weathered wooden pier visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing a weathered dark green waterproof jacket and a gray wool beanie?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the figure holding a long, thin fishing rod with the line disappearing into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the sky displaying a dawn glow with pastel pinks, pale oranges, and cool blues blending at the horizon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, eye-level wide-angle view where the pier planks extend directly from the camera lens into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17985419929027557 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.804854154586792 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17985419929027557, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17985419929027557, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11665569990873337, + 0.1144973561167717, + 0.047663528472185135, + 0.11826705932617188, + 0.08058548718690872, + 0.025000479072332382, + 0.19363203644752502, + 0.03326304256916046, + 0.2394585907459259, + 0.03097669966518879 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17985419929027557 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, eye-level wide-angle shot captures a scene of profound tranquility. A solitary figure sits on a simple wooden box at the end of a long, weathered wooden pier, wearing a weathered dark green waterproof jacket and a gray wool beanie. The pier's planks, worn and gray, extend directly from the camera lens into the calm water. The man's posture is one of patient stillness, slightly hunched, his grip steady and deliberate on a long, thin fishing rod, its line disappearing into the glassy water below. The sky above is a masterpiece of dawn, a soft, diffuse glow illuminating pastel pinks, pale oranges, and cool blues that blend seamlessly at the horizon. This newly born light reflects perfectly on the mirror-like surface of the water, broken only by the faintest ripples lapping against the mossy pillars of the pier. The entire environment is immersed in a cool, quiet atmosphere, creating a profound sense of tranquil solitude and meditative waiting.", + "seed": 4818, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_5/index_1133_seed_4818_dp_11_rank_22_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.031712098559364674, + "vlm_logprob": -0.031712098559364674, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.975, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.031712098559364674, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a solitary figure sitting on a simple wooden box at the end of a long, weathered wooden pier visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing a weathered dark green waterproof jacket and a gray wool beanie?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the figure holding a long, thin fishing rod with the line disappearing into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the sky displaying a dawn glow with pastel pinks, pale oranges, and cool blues blending at the horizon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, eye-level wide-angle view where the pier planks extend directly from the camera lens into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009356813505291939 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.88435697555542 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009356813505291939, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009356813505291939, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20940808951854706, + 0.08757904917001724, + 0.08106075972318649, + 0.04354282468557358, + 0.1437472552061081, + 0.12381196767091751, + 0.08278006315231323, + 0.13575656712055206, + 0.0404818169772625, + 0.051831621676683426 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009356813505291939 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a solitary figure sitting on a simple wooden box at the end of a long, weathered wooden pier visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing a weathered dark green waterproof jacket and a gray wool beanie?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the figure holding a long, thin fishing rod with the line disappearing into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the sky displaying a dawn glow with pastel pinks, pale oranges, and cool blues blending at the horizon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, eye-level wide-angle view where the pier planks extend directly from the camera lens into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05499040335416794 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929990291595459 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05499040335416794, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05499040335416794, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1959008425474167, + 0.06439760327339172, + 0.061226736754179, + 0.05430588498711586, + 0.056779585778713226, + 0.09107262641191483, + 0.10361941158771515, + 0.13784566521644592, + 0.09843449294567108, + 0.1364172101020813 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05499040335416794 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a solitary figure sitting on a simple wooden box at the end of a long, weathered wooden pier visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing a weathered dark green waterproof jacket and a gray wool beanie?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the figure holding a long, thin fishing rod with the line disappearing into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the sky displaying a dawn glow with pastel pinks, pale oranges, and cool blues blending at the horizon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, eye-level wide-angle view where the pier planks extend directly from the camera lens into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020599940791726112 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895599842071533 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020599940791726112, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020599940791726112, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23214738070964813, + 0.17274469137191772, + 0.05985340103507042, + 0.03272207826375961, + 0.07812288403511047, + 0.034355759620666504, + 0.03813030943274498, + 0.20245498418807983, + 0.09505272656679153, + 0.054415784776210785 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020599940791726112 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a solitary figure sitting on a simple wooden box at the end of a long, weathered wooden pier visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing a weathered dark green waterproof jacket and a gray wool beanie?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the figure holding a long, thin fishing rod with the line disappearing into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the sky displaying a dawn glow with pastel pinks, pale oranges, and cool blues blending at the horizon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, eye-level wide-angle view where the pier planks extend directly from the camera lens into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036157488357275724 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628615856170654 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036157488357275724, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036157488357275724, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.35741546750068665, + 0.054786425083875656, + 0.04873235896229744, + 0.0849020779132843, + 0.17552611231803894, + 0.07657032459974289, + 0.0395905002951622, + 0.09336095303297043, + 0.02166137844324112, + 0.04745436832308769 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036157488357275724 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a solitary figure sitting on a simple wooden box at the end of a long, weathered wooden pier visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing a weathered dark green waterproof jacket and a gray wool beanie?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the figure holding a long, thin fishing rod with the line disappearing into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the sky displaying a dawn glow with pastel pinks, pale oranges, and cool blues blending at the horizon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, eye-level wide-angle view where the pier planks extend directly from the camera lens into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06999758630990982 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.694997549057007 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06999758630990982, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06999758630990982, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21882173418998718, + 0.07697857916355133, + 0.07113038003444672, + 0.0637611597776413, + 0.061755139380693436, + 0.09174007177352905, + 0.06717000156641006, + 0.17986293137073517, + 0.1157626062631607, + 0.05301736295223236 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06999758630990982 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, eye-level wide-angle shot captures a scene of profound tranquility. A solitary figure sits on a simple wooden box at the end of a long, weathered wooden pier, wearing a weathered dark green waterproof jacket and a gray wool beanie. The pier's planks, worn and gray, extend directly from the camera lens into the calm water. The man's posture is one of patient stillness, slightly hunched, his grip steady and deliberate on a long, thin fishing rod, its line disappearing into the glassy water below. The sky above is a masterpiece of dawn, a soft, diffuse glow illuminating pastel pinks, pale oranges, and cool blues that blend seamlessly at the horizon. This newly born light reflects perfectly on the mirror-like surface of the water, broken only by the faintest ripples lapping against the mossy pillars of the pier. The entire environment is immersed in a cool, quiet atmosphere, creating a profound sense of tranquil solitude and meditative waiting.", + "seed": 4819, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_5/index_1133_seed_4819_dp_11_rank_22_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.027240412030369043, + "vlm_logprob": -0.027240412030369043, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.225, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.027240412030369043, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a solitary figure sitting on a simple wooden box at the end of a long, weathered wooden pier visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing a weathered dark green waterproof jacket and a gray wool beanie?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the figure holding a long, thin fishing rod with the line disappearing into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the sky displaying a dawn glow with pastel pinks, pale oranges, and cool blues blending at the horizon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, eye-level wide-angle view where the pier planks extend directly from the camera lens into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006074419245123863 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.25607442855835 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006074419245123863, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006074419245123863, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2027592658996582, + 0.06453962624073029, + 0.01794702559709549, + 0.24036674201488495, + 0.15529637038707733, + 0.03802292421460152, + 0.07777411490678787, + 0.013123225420713425, + 0.11155107617378235, + 0.078619584441185 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006074419245123863 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a solitary figure sitting on a simple wooden box at the end of a long, weathered wooden pier visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing a weathered dark green waterproof jacket and a gray wool beanie?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the figure holding a long, thin fishing rod with the line disappearing into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the sky displaying a dawn glow with pastel pinks, pale oranges, and cool blues blending at the horizon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, eye-level wide-angle view where the pier planks extend directly from the camera lens into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0431005097925663 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168100595474243 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0431005097925663, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0431005097925663, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3063691556453705, + 0.07077866792678833, + 0.022371193394064903, + 0.21976886689662933, + 0.13071909546852112, + 0.051817767322063446, + 0.04898127540946007, + 0.009099620394408703, + 0.04552723094820976, + 0.09456716477870941 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0431005097925663 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a solitary figure sitting on a simple wooden box at the end of a long, weathered wooden pier visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing a weathered dark green waterproof jacket and a gray wool beanie?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the figure holding a long, thin fishing rod with the line disappearing into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the sky displaying a dawn glow with pastel pinks, pale oranges, and cool blues blending at the horizon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, eye-level wide-angle view where the pier planks extend directly from the camera lens into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014208698645234108 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264208793640137 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014208698645234108, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014208698645234108, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12048634141683578, + 0.2793499231338501, + 0.04440510645508766, + 0.08069740980863571, + 0.07512211054563522, + 0.07900569587945938, + 0.13518495857715607, + 0.026898199692368507, + 0.08599048852920532, + 0.0728597640991211 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014208698645234108 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a solitary figure sitting on a simple wooden box at the end of a long, weathered wooden pier visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing a weathered dark green waterproof jacket and a gray wool beanie?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the figure holding a long, thin fishing rod with the line disappearing into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the sky displaying a dawn glow with pastel pinks, pale oranges, and cool blues blending at the horizon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, eye-level wide-angle view where the pier planks extend directly from the camera lens into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002818067092448473 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.8778181076049805 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002818067092448473, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002818067092448473, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2618845999240875, + 0.10656412690877914, + 0.0979984849691391, + 0.11330690234899521, + 0.06864937394857407, + 0.08103924244642258, + 0.11563800275325775, + 0.01832004450261593, + 0.07795744389295578, + 0.05864182487130165 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002818067092448473 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a solitary figure sitting on a simple wooden box at the end of a long, weathered wooden pier visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing a weathered dark green waterproof jacket and a gray wool beanie?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the figure holding a long, thin fishing rod with the line disappearing into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the sky displaying a dawn glow with pastel pinks, pale oranges, and cool blues blending at the horizon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, eye-level wide-angle view where the pier planks extend directly from the camera lens into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07000036537647247 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695000410079956 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07000036537647247, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07000036537647247, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.45916178822517395, + 0.02933611534535885, + 0.09110505878925323, + 0.06510884314775467, + 0.12667933106422424, + 0.042212001979351044, + 0.07099666446447372, + 0.01915878988802433, + 0.038656316697597504, + 0.057585135102272034 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07000036537647247 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_6/index_tensor([3366, 3366])_group_6_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_6/index_tensor([3366, 3366])_group_6_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..ab10935eb54281c1991c538cced8f95520b959c4 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_6/index_tensor([3366, 3366])_group_6_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "static, eye-level medium close-up focuses on a luxurious leather wallet rhythmically swinging from a person's shoulder as they walk with a steady, deliberate gait. Crafted from rich, dark chocolate brown calfskin with a subtle grain, the wallet features a structured saddlebag silhouette and delicate cream stitching along the edges. It hangs from the shoulder of a person wearing a thick, soft ivory cashmere sweater, the delicate texture of the knit contrasting with the smooth leather. As the wallet swings back and forth in gentle, hypnotic arcs, its polished, rectangular gold buckle captures the soft, unfocused overhead lighting of the elegant room, creating a fleeting, star-like flash with each movement. The background, a light-focus blur of polished dark hardwood floors and tall, minimalist off-white walls, suggests a high-end boutique or art gallery. The scene is bathed in warm, gentle light, creating an atmosphere of quiet refinement, understated luxury, and serene movement.", + "seed": 28270, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_6/index_3366_seed_28270_dp_12_rank_24_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.17699094340205193, + "vlm_logprob": -0.17699094340205193, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.65, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.17699094340205193, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a dark chocolate brown leather wallet with cream stitching and a gold buckle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the wallet swinging rhythmically from a person's shoulder?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the person wearing a thick, soft ivory cashmere sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a light-focus blur of polished dark hardwood floors and tall off-white walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, eye-level medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04388245567679405 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168882369995117 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04388245567679405, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04388245567679405, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2617264688014984, + 0.10081517696380615, + 0.053126588463783264, + 0.06181066110730171, + 0.10112050175666809, + 0.20291434228420258, + 0.030793732032179832, + 0.038510482758283615, + 0.05047643184661865, + 0.09870554506778717 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04388245567679405 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a dark chocolate brown leather wallet with cream stitching and a gold buckle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the wallet swinging rhythmically from a person's shoulder?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the person wearing a thick, soft ivory cashmere sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a light-focus blur of polished dark hardwood floors and tall off-white walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, eye-level medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07004271447658539 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695042610168457 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07004271447658539, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07004271447658539, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10466064512729645, + 0.2691086232662201, + 0.03746909275650978, + 0.029200823977589607, + 0.10763539373874664, + 0.0434052012860775, + 0.06428214907646179, + 0.11898726969957352, + 0.1211702823638916, + 0.10408058762550354 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07004271447658539 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a dark chocolate brown leather wallet with cream stitching and a gold buckle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the wallet swinging rhythmically from a person's shoulder?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the person wearing a thick, soft ivory cashmere sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a light-focus blur of polished dark hardwood floors and tall off-white walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, eye-level medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07007316499948502 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695073127746582 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07007316499948502, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07007316499948502, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2544085383415222, + 0.11592450737953186, + 0.05211252346634865, + 0.055383604019880295, + 0.060090649873018265, + 0.2054208666086197, + 0.051691774278879166, + 0.0321650356054306, + 0.12286855280399323, + 0.04993393272161484 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07007316499948502 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a dark chocolate brown leather wallet with cream stitching and a gold buckle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the wallet swinging rhythmically from a person's shoulder?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the person wearing a thick, soft ivory cashmere sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a light-focus blur of polished dark hardwood floors and tall off-white walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, eye-level medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007628239691257477 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882628440856934 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007628239691257477, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007628239691257477, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1963956505060196, + 0.20917873084545135, + 0.03712961822748184, + 0.03914438188076019, + 0.08503810316324234, + 0.06232380121946335, + 0.03035281039774418, + 0.0358705148100853, + 0.043175045400857925, + 0.2613913416862488 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007628239691257477 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a dark chocolate brown leather wallet with cream stitching and a gold buckle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the wallet swinging rhythmically from a person's shoulder?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the person wearing a thick, soft ivory cashmere sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a light-focus blur of polished dark hardwood floors and tall off-white walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, eye-level medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6933281421661377 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6933281421661377 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.6933281421661377, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.6933281421661377, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1131717637181282, + 0.16974204778671265, + 0.0372588187456131, + 0.12237768620252609, + 0.14812421798706055, + 0.04092938080430031, + 0.07591922581195831, + 0.044697366654872894, + 0.08806069940328598, + 0.15971878170967102 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.6933281421661377 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, eye-level medium close-up focuses on a luxurious leather wallet rhythmically swinging from a person's shoulder as they walk with a steady, deliberate gait. Crafted from rich, dark chocolate brown calfskin with a subtle grain, the wallet features a structured saddlebag silhouette and delicate cream stitching along the edges. It hangs from the shoulder of a person wearing a thick, soft ivory cashmere sweater, the delicate texture of the knit contrasting with the smooth leather. As the wallet swings back and forth in gentle, hypnotic arcs, its polished, rectangular gold buckle captures the soft, unfocused overhead lighting of the elegant room, creating a fleeting, star-like flash with each movement. The background, a light-focus blur of polished dark hardwood floors and tall, minimalist off-white walls, suggests a high-end boutique or art gallery. The scene is bathed in warm, gentle light, creating an atmosphere of quiet refinement, understated luxury, and serene movement.", + "seed": 28271, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_6/index_3366_seed_28271_dp_12_rank_24_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.2356395686045289, + "vlm_logprob": -0.2356395686045289, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.725, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.2356395686045289, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a dark chocolate brown leather wallet with cream stitching and a gold buckle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the wallet swinging rhythmically from a person's shoulder?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the person wearing a thick, soft ivory cashmere sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a light-focus blur of polished dark hardwood floors and tall off-white walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, eye-level medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014920661225914955 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264920711517334 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014920661225914955, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014920661225914955, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25143444538116455, + 0.1427905112504959, + 0.05162228271365166, + 0.04820955544710159, + 0.08553729951381683, + 0.07455562055110931, + 0.024656519293785095, + 0.052748534828424454, + 0.2195698320865631, + 0.0488753616809845 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014920661225914955 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a dark chocolate brown leather wallet with cream stitching and a gold buckle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the wallet swinging rhythmically from a person's shoulder?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the person wearing a thick, soft ivory cashmere sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a light-focus blur of polished dark hardwood floors and tall off-white walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, eye-level medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11295364052057266 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2379536628723145 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11295364052057266, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11295364052057266, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11940407752990723, + 0.20815539360046387, + 0.034468404948711395, + 0.02548130415380001, + 0.048473283648490906, + 0.06382358074188232, + 0.031709324568510056, + 0.04839341714978218, + 0.37732377648353577, + 0.0427674874663353 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11295364052057266 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a dark chocolate brown leather wallet with cream stitching and a gold buckle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the wallet swinging rhythmically from a person's shoulder?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the person wearing a thick, soft ivory cashmere sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a light-focus blur of polished dark hardwood floors and tall off-white walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, eye-level medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07010528445243835 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6951053142547607 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07010528445243835, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07010528445243835, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10453096032142639, + 0.36038464307785034, + 0.01428828202188015, + 0.026731809601187706, + 0.15277332067489624, + 0.02008853852748871, + 0.019349519163370132, + 0.03308358043432236, + 0.24794751405715942, + 0.020821858197450638 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07010528445243835 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a dark chocolate brown leather wallet with cream stitching and a gold buckle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the wallet swinging rhythmically from a person's shoulder?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the person wearing a thick, soft ivory cashmere sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a light-focus blur of polished dark hardwood floors and tall off-white walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, eye-level medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005950118415057659 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130949974060059 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005950118415057659, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005950118415057659, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0467083640396595, + 0.5883744955062866, + 0.04308101907372475, + 0.010888693854212761, + 0.06830395758152008, + 0.02964591048657894, + 0.05550483614206314, + 0.05369160324335098, + 0.09234576672315598, + 0.011455382220447063 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005950118415057659 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a dark chocolate brown leather wallet with cream stitching and a gold buckle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the wallet swinging rhythmically from a person's shoulder?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the person wearing a thick, soft ivory cashmere sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a light-focus blur of polished dark hardwood floors and tall off-white walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, eye-level medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9742681384086609 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4742681384086609 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.9742681384086609, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.9742681384086609, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.046850163489580154, + 0.43177321553230286, + 0.0741846114397049, + 0.03664160519838333, + 0.07463550567626953, + 0.08863900601863861, + 0.02954011596739292, + 0.03452534228563309, + 0.15439555048942566, + 0.02881491370499134 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.9742681384086609 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, eye-level medium close-up focuses on a luxurious leather wallet rhythmically swinging from a person's shoulder as they walk with a steady, deliberate gait. Crafted from rich, dark chocolate brown calfskin with a subtle grain, the wallet features a structured saddlebag silhouette and delicate cream stitching along the edges. It hangs from the shoulder of a person wearing a thick, soft ivory cashmere sweater, the delicate texture of the knit contrasting with the smooth leather. As the wallet swings back and forth in gentle, hypnotic arcs, its polished, rectangular gold buckle captures the soft, unfocused overhead lighting of the elegant room, creating a fleeting, star-like flash with each movement. The background, a light-focus blur of polished dark hardwood floors and tall, minimalist off-white walls, suggests a high-end boutique or art gallery. The scene is bathed in warm, gentle light, creating an atmosphere of quiet refinement, understated luxury, and serene movement.", + "seed": 28272, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_6/index_3366_seed_28272_dp_13_rank_26_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.20783072374761105, + "vlm_logprob": -0.20783072374761105, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.475, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.20783072374761105, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a dark chocolate brown leather wallet with cream stitching and a gold buckle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the wallet swinging rhythmically from a person's shoulder?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the person wearing a thick, soft ivory cashmere sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a light-focus blur of polished dark hardwood floors and tall off-white walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, eye-level medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020817242562770844 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895817279815674 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020817242562770844, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020817242562770844, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11905922740697861, + 0.09380228072404861, + 0.016355032101273537, + 0.052620355039834976, + 0.06934745609760284, + 0.08088430017232895, + 0.04473481327295303, + 0.43593624234199524, + 0.04227029159665108, + 0.044989943504333496 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020817242562770844 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a dark chocolate brown leather wallet with cream stitching and a gold buckle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the wallet swinging rhythmically from a person's shoulder?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the person wearing a thick, soft ivory cashmere sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a light-focus blur of polished dark hardwood floors and tall off-white walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, eye-level medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16038089990615845 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9103808403015137 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16038089990615845, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16038089990615845, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12898686528205872, + 0.06279486417770386, + 0.059600405395030975, + 0.03807162865996361, + 0.05141614377498627, + 0.17805765569210052, + 0.0695793628692627, + 0.20946726202964783, + 0.11388512700796127, + 0.08814062178134918 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16038089990615845 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a dark chocolate brown leather wallet with cream stitching and a gold buckle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the wallet swinging rhythmically from a person's shoulder?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the person wearing a thick, soft ivory cashmere sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a light-focus blur of polished dark hardwood floors and tall off-white walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, eye-level medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08909856528043747 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4640984535217285 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08909856528043747, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08909856528043747, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1379527449607849, + 0.11604128777980804, + 0.07389476150274277, + 0.06063435971736908, + 0.04360190033912659, + 0.09955087304115295, + 0.03520633280277252, + 0.30519527196884155, + 0.06676781922578812, + 0.061154644936323166 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08909856528043747 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a dark chocolate brown leather wallet with cream stitching and a gold buckle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the wallet swinging rhythmically from a person's shoulder?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the person wearing a thick, soft ivory cashmere sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a light-focus blur of polished dark hardwood floors and tall off-white walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, eye-level medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011074034497141838 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511074066162109 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011074034497141838, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011074034497141838, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1115291565656662, + 0.2852746844291687, + 0.1444711685180664, + 0.04965993016958237, + 0.1912955343723297, + 0.027651062235236168, + 0.030676022171974182, + 0.07973270863294601, + 0.05710483342409134, + 0.022604918107390404 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011074034497141838 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a dark chocolate brown leather wallet with cream stitching and a gold buckle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the wallet swinging rhythmically from a person's shoulder?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the person wearing a thick, soft ivory cashmere sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a light-focus blur of polished dark hardwood floors and tall off-white walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, eye-level medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7577828764915466 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6327828764915466 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.7577828764915466, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.7577828764915466, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07809275388717651, + 0.07499360293149948, + 0.04207244887948036, + 0.048954032361507416, + 0.057037487626075745, + 0.1400386095046997, + 0.12616243958473206, + 0.10750694572925568, + 0.16416813433170319, + 0.16097356379032135 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.7577828764915466 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, eye-level medium close-up focuses on a luxurious leather wallet rhythmically swinging from a person's shoulder as they walk with a steady, deliberate gait. Crafted from rich, dark chocolate brown calfskin with a subtle grain, the wallet features a structured saddlebag silhouette and delicate cream stitching along the edges. It hangs from the shoulder of a person wearing a thick, soft ivory cashmere sweater, the delicate texture of the knit contrasting with the smooth leather. As the wallet swings back and forth in gentle, hypnotic arcs, its polished, rectangular gold buckle captures the soft, unfocused overhead lighting of the elegant room, creating a fleeting, star-like flash with each movement. The background, a light-focus blur of polished dark hardwood floors and tall, minimalist off-white walls, suggests a high-end boutique or art gallery. The scene is bathed in warm, gentle light, creating an atmosphere of quiet refinement, understated luxury, and serene movement.", + "seed": 28273, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_6/index_3366_seed_28273_dp_13_rank_26_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.2111041652970016, + "vlm_logprob": -0.2111041652970016, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.825, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.2111041652970016, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a dark chocolate brown leather wallet with cream stitching and a gold buckle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the wallet swinging rhythmically from a person's shoulder?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the person wearing a thick, soft ivory cashmere sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a light-focus blur of polished dark hardwood floors and tall off-white walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, eye-level medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016463035717606544 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141462802886963 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016463035717606544, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016463035717606544, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1011057049036026, + 0.2614922821521759, + 0.04163413867354393, + 0.06962177902460098, + 0.06186412274837494, + 0.08407667279243469, + 0.07785247266292572, + 0.10802559554576874, + 0.09125030040740967, + 0.10307690501213074 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016463035717606544 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a dark chocolate brown leather wallet with cream stitching and a gold buckle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the wallet swinging rhythmically from a person's shoulder?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the person wearing a thick, soft ivory cashmere sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a light-focus blur of polished dark hardwood floors and tall off-white walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, eye-level medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07900475710630417 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5790047645568848 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07900475710630417, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07900475710630417, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09312953054904938, + 0.13040393590927124, + 0.32823026180267334, + 0.22714026272296906, + 0.030290191993117332, + 0.02074514515697956, + 0.02366575412452221, + 0.030947081744670868, + 0.07681716978549957, + 0.03863067552447319 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07900475710630417 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a dark chocolate brown leather wallet with cream stitching and a gold buckle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the wallet swinging rhythmically from a person's shoulder?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the person wearing a thick, soft ivory cashmere sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a light-focus blur of polished dark hardwood floors and tall off-white walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, eye-level medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05501691997051239 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9300169944763184 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05501691997051239, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05501691997051239, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1082659438252449, + 0.30014610290527344, + 0.16547203063964844, + 0.09966851025819778, + 0.09844320267438889, + 0.03718358278274536, + 0.07554029673337936, + 0.031295061111450195, + 0.0334816537797451, + 0.050503648817539215 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05501691997051239 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a dark chocolate brown leather wallet with cream stitching and a gold buckle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the wallet swinging rhythmically from a person's shoulder?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the person wearing a thick, soft ivory cashmere sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a light-focus blur of polished dark hardwood floors and tall off-white walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, eye-level medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006737373303622007 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006737232208252 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006737373303622007, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006737373303622007, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2153474986553192, + 0.1282101273536682, + 0.22892825305461884, + 0.08696287870407104, + 0.08058925718069077, + 0.08492113649845123, + 0.02490927465260029, + 0.07064002752304077, + 0.05297036096453667, + 0.02652117982506752 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006737373303622007 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a dark chocolate brown leather wallet with cream stitching and a gold buckle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the wallet swinging rhythmically from a person's shoulder?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the person wearing a thick, soft ivory cashmere sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a light-focus blur of polished dark hardwood floors and tall off-white walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, eye-level medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8982987403869629 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5232987403869629 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.8982987403869629, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.8982987403869629, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0597832091152668, + 0.14198331534862518, + 0.15343526005744934, + 0.05734097212553024, + 0.08313583582639694, + 0.12108996510505676, + 0.041196390986442566, + 0.03115188702940941, + 0.18186607956886292, + 0.12901702523231506 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.8982987403869629 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_7/index_tensor([4149, 4149])_group_7_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_7/index_tensor([4149, 4149])_group_7_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..61b2c26f02324e3b03e81476a2daef7d80978049 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_7/index_tensor([4149, 4149])_group_7_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "delicate slow-motion close-up, shot from a slightly downward angle, focuses on a sun-drenched strawberry field. A pair of slender, pale hands with immaculately manicured nails carefully part a dense, emerald green clump of strawberry leaves. Warm, golden sunlight filters through the foliage, casting dappled shadows on her skin and the jagged edges of the leaves. Her fingertips finally rest on a heart-shaped, juicy, crimson strawberry, dangling from a slender stem. The fruit's plump, rounded surface, dotted with tiny yellow seeds, gleams with an alluring, honey-like sheen in the direct sunlight. Then, with a steady, light pull, the perfect fruit is plucked intact from the plant, resting safely between her fingers. The whole picture is filled with idyllic tranquility and the joy of harvest. The main colors are vivid green and passionate red, creating a natural, comfortable and vibrant warm atmosphere.", + "seed": 16936, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_7/index_4149_seed_16936_dp_14_rank_28_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.08641841132193803, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08641841132193803, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.325, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08641841132193803, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up filmed from a slightly downward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of slender, pale hands with immaculately manicured nails visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a heart-shaped, crimson strawberry with tiny yellow seeds visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the hands plucking the strawberry intact from the plant?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filled with warm, golden sunlight casting dappled shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.013893439434468746 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.7638936042785645 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.013893439434468746, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.013893439434468746, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1226171925663948, + 0.14772380888462067, + 0.03568172827363014, + 0.05775409936904907, + 0.09417305141687393, + 0.08619879931211472, + 0.02014150656759739, + 0.22817634046077728, + 0.021460633724927902, + 0.18607285618782043 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.013893439434468746 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up filmed from a slightly downward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of slender, pale hands with immaculately manicured nails visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a heart-shaped, crimson strawberry with tiny yellow seeds visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the hands plucking the strawberry intact from the plant?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filled with warm, golden sunlight casting dappled shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.252164363861084 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.502164363861084 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.252164363861084, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.252164363861084, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05888194590806961, + 0.1790591925382614, + 0.08122099936008453, + 0.15656746923923492, + 0.049206048250198364, + 0.019558126106858253, + 0.03926408290863037, + 0.29972130060195923, + 0.018976107239723206, + 0.09754472225904465 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.252164363861084 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up filmed from a slightly downward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of slender, pale hands with immaculately manicured nails visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a heart-shaped, crimson strawberry with tiny yellow seeds visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the hands plucking the strawberry intact from the plant?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filled with warm, golden sunlight casting dappled shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005262451246380806 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.25526237487793 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005262451246380806, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005262451246380806, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06144799664616585, + 0.1973225623369217, + 0.04492206498980522, + 0.13121530413627625, + 0.0742218866944313, + 0.09250662475824356, + 0.051089268177747726, + 0.2086791694164276, + 0.021753009408712387, + 0.116842120885849 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005262451246380806 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up filmed from a slightly downward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of slender, pale hands with immaculately manicured nails visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a heart-shaped, crimson strawberry with tiny yellow seeds visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the hands plucking the strawberry intact from the plant?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filled with warm, golden sunlight casting dappled shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12706275284290314 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1270627975463867 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12706275284290314, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12706275284290314, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07265090942382812, + 0.5122385025024414, + 0.04043955355882645, + 0.09327492862939835, + 0.029033677652478218, + 0.06348652392625809, + 0.011664255522191525, + 0.08806242793798447, + 0.03766602650284767, + 0.05148319900035858 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 3, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12706275284290314 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up filmed from a slightly downward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of slender, pale hands with immaculately manicured nails visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a heart-shaped, crimson strawberry with tiny yellow seeds visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the hands plucking the strawberry intact from the plant?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filled with warm, golden sunlight casting dappled shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.033709049224853516 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4087090492248535 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.033709049224853516, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.033709049224853516, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0886402353644371, + 0.24766592681407928, + 0.04484257474541664, + 0.043377749621868134, + 0.05504642054438591, + 0.10937806963920593, + 0.029429594054818153, + 0.17625872790813446, + 0.056360580027103424, + 0.14900007843971252 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.033709049224853516 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "delicate slow-motion close-up, shot from a slightly downward angle, focuses on a sun-drenched strawberry field. A pair of slender, pale hands with immaculately manicured nails carefully part a dense, emerald green clump of strawberry leaves. Warm, golden sunlight filters through the foliage, casting dappled shadows on her skin and the jagged edges of the leaves. Her fingertips finally rest on a heart-shaped, juicy, crimson strawberry, dangling from a slender stem. The fruit's plump, rounded surface, dotted with tiny yellow seeds, gleams with an alluring, honey-like sheen in the direct sunlight. Then, with a steady, light pull, the perfect fruit is plucked intact from the plant, resting safely between her fingers. The whole picture is filled with idyllic tranquility and the joy of harvest. The main colors are vivid green and passionate red, creating a natural, comfortable and vibrant warm atmosphere.", + "seed": 16937, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_7/index_4149_seed_16937_dp_14_rank_28_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.026712068170309067, + "vlm_logprob": -0.026712068170309067, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.175, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.026712068170309067, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up filmed from a slightly downward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of slender, pale hands with immaculately manicured nails visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a heart-shaped, crimson strawberry with tiny yellow seeds visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the hands plucking the strawberry intact from the plant?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filled with warm, golden sunlight casting dappled shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.010457363910973072 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.885457515716553 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.010457363910973072, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.010457363910973072, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21153588593006134, + 0.2957879900932312, + 0.11823668330907822, + 0.021825142204761505, + 0.030715132132172585, + 0.12325005978345871, + 0.06848708540201187, + 0.05471891164779663, + 0.03319448605179787, + 0.04224861040711403 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.010457363910973072 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up filmed from a slightly downward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of slender, pale hands with immaculately manicured nails visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a heart-shaped, crimson strawberry with tiny yellow seeds visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the hands plucking the strawberry intact from the plant?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filled with warm, golden sunlight casting dappled shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03372944891452789 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4087295532226562 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03372944891452789, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03372944891452789, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20884250104427338, + 0.40975865721702576, + 0.04500309377908707, + 0.03262506425380707, + 0.12286657840013504, + 0.08008982241153717, + 0.0117360670119524, + 0.03919155150651932, + 0.041023772209882736, + 0.008862865157425404 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03372944891452789 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up filmed from a slightly downward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of slender, pale hands with immaculately manicured nails visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a heart-shaped, crimson strawberry with tiny yellow seeds visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the hands plucking the strawberry intact from the plant?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filled with warm, golden sunlight casting dappled shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006742938421666622 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.00674295425415 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006742938421666622, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006742938421666622, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22771915793418884, + 0.19801118969917297, + 0.1077970638871193, + 0.0511106438934803, + 0.08716756850481033, + 0.09024803340435028, + 0.03480278328061104, + 0.07001065462827682, + 0.1221119612455368, + 0.011020848527550697 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006742938421666622 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up filmed from a slightly downward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of slender, pale hands with immaculately manicured nails visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a heart-shaped, crimson strawberry with tiny yellow seeds visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the hands plucking the strawberry intact from the plant?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filled with warm, golden sunlight casting dappled shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06204559653997421 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120455741882324 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06204559653997421, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06204559653997421, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.31988415122032166, + 0.0619080513715744, + 0.04782826825976372, + 0.15065985918045044, + 0.06158769503235817, + 0.04750604182481766, + 0.05936562269926071, + 0.1514284461736679, + 0.07250820845365524, + 0.027323681861162186 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06204559653997421 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up filmed from a slightly downward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of slender, pale hands with immaculately manicured nails visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a heart-shaped, crimson strawberry with tiny yellow seeds visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the hands plucking the strawberry intact from the plant?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filled with warm, golden sunlight casting dappled shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020584993064403534 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895585060119629 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020584993064403534, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020584993064403534, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.38309428095817566, + 0.14598645269870758, + 0.22508253157138824, + 0.08750016242265701, + 0.047939732670784, + 0.03167298063635826, + 0.014434813521802425, + 0.02178889326751232, + 0.013145535252988338, + 0.029354659840464592 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020584993064403534 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "delicate slow-motion close-up, shot from a slightly downward angle, focuses on a sun-drenched strawberry field. A pair of slender, pale hands with immaculately manicured nails carefully part a dense, emerald green clump of strawberry leaves. Warm, golden sunlight filters through the foliage, casting dappled shadows on her skin and the jagged edges of the leaves. Her fingertips finally rest on a heart-shaped, juicy, crimson strawberry, dangling from a slender stem. The fruit's plump, rounded surface, dotted with tiny yellow seeds, gleams with an alluring, honey-like sheen in the direct sunlight. Then, with a steady, light pull, the perfect fruit is plucked intact from the plant, resting safely between her fingers. The whole picture is filled with idyllic tranquility and the joy of harvest. The main colors are vivid green and passionate red, creating a natural, comfortable and vibrant warm atmosphere.", + "seed": 16938, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_7/index_4149_seed_16938_dp_15_rank_30_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.046897415770217776, + "vlm_logprob": -0.046897415770217776, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.574999952316284, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.046897415770217776, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up filmed from a slightly downward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of slender, pale hands with immaculately manicured nails visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a heart-shaped, crimson strawberry with tiny yellow seeds visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the hands plucking the strawberry intact from the plant?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filled with warm, golden sunlight casting dappled shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0228077732026577 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.022807598114014 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0228077732026577, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0228077732026577, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3515816628932953, + 0.07790417969226837, + 0.014694462530314922, + 0.07091668993234634, + 0.013941546902060509, + 0.042668767273426056, + 0.31926339864730835, + 0.022662529721856117, + 0.07108445465564728, + 0.015282289125025272 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0228077732026577 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up filmed from a slightly downward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of slender, pale hands with immaculately manicured nails visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a heart-shaped, crimson strawberry with tiny yellow seeds visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the hands plucking the strawberry intact from the plant?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filled with warm, golden sunlight casting dappled shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07005149126052856 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695051431655884 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07005149126052856, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07005149126052856, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.33006489276885986, + 0.13205872476100922, + 0.020627781748771667, + 0.0311710387468338, + 0.052397094666957855, + 0.06314599514007568, + 0.10659530013799667, + 0.040384188294410706, + 0.19706539809703827, + 0.02648960053920746 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07005149126052856 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up filmed from a slightly downward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of slender, pale hands with immaculately manicured nails visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a heart-shaped, crimson strawberry with tiny yellow seeds visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the hands plucking the strawberry intact from the plant?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filled with warm, golden sunlight casting dappled shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0032025498803704977 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753202438354492 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0032025498803704977, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0032025498803704977, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18115851283073425, + 0.19230766594409943, + 0.09253229945898056, + 0.07812655717134476, + 0.04693346098065376, + 0.13134250044822693, + 0.16865624487400055, + 0.038225527852773666, + 0.036942072212696075, + 0.033775124698877335 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0032025498803704977 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up filmed from a slightly downward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of slender, pale hands with immaculately manicured nails visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a heart-shaped, crimson strawberry with tiny yellow seeds visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the hands plucking the strawberry intact from the plant?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filled with warm, golden sunlight casting dappled shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03810911998152733 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288109064102173 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03810911998152733, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03810911998152733, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0830809623003006, + 0.23427172005176544, + 0.03152861446142197, + 0.06595033407211304, + 0.05116495117545128, + 0.04500565677881241, + 0.19679540395736694, + 0.024381494149565697, + 0.24902145564556122, + 0.01879933290183544 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03810911998152733 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up filmed from a slightly downward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of slender, pale hands with immaculately manicured nails visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a heart-shaped, crimson strawberry with tiny yellow seeds visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the hands plucking the strawberry intact from the plant?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filled with warm, golden sunlight casting dappled shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10031614452600479 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.350316047668457 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10031614452600479, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10031614452600479, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.198244109749794, + 0.11498210579156876, + 0.020416416227817535, + 0.18415245413780212, + 0.028593169525265694, + 0.06018078327178955, + 0.28952619433403015, + 0.03440847620368004, + 0.04567737504839897, + 0.023818952962756157 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10031614452600479 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "delicate slow-motion close-up, shot from a slightly downward angle, focuses on a sun-drenched strawberry field. A pair of slender, pale hands with immaculately manicured nails carefully part a dense, emerald green clump of strawberry leaves. Warm, golden sunlight filters through the foliage, casting dappled shadows on her skin and the jagged edges of the leaves. Her fingertips finally rest on a heart-shaped, juicy, crimson strawberry, dangling from a slender stem. The fruit's plump, rounded surface, dotted with tiny yellow seeds, gleams with an alluring, honey-like sheen in the direct sunlight. Then, with a steady, light pull, the perfect fruit is plucked intact from the plant, resting safely between her fingers. The whole picture is filled with idyllic tranquility and the joy of harvest. The main colors are vivid green and passionate red, creating a natural, comfortable and vibrant warm atmosphere.", + "seed": 16939, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_7/index_4149_seed_16939_dp_15_rank_30_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.14695485681295395, + "vlm_logprob": -0.14695485681295395, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.874999976158142, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.14695485681295395, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up filmed from a slightly downward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of slender, pale hands with immaculately manicured nails visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a heart-shaped, crimson strawberry with tiny yellow seeds visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the hands plucking the strawberry intact from the plant?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filled with warm, golden sunlight casting dappled shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.042690176516771317 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2926902770996094 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.042690176516771317, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.042690176516771317, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0805409699678421, + 0.04583758860826492, + 0.02953927591443062, + 0.013551448471844196, + 0.010058385320007801, + 0.019106177613139153, + 0.014451631344854832, + 0.7091951966285706, + 0.043478064239025116, + 0.0342412106692791 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.042690176516771317 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up filmed from a slightly downward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of slender, pale hands with immaculately manicured nails visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a heart-shaped, crimson strawberry with tiny yellow seeds visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the hands plucking the strawberry intact from the plant?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filled with warm, golden sunlight casting dappled shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5233953595161438 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8983953595161438 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5233953595161438, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5233953595161438, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.02044413611292839, + 0.06893043965101242, + 0.024329787120223045, + 0.012765436433255672, + 0.005227253772318363, + 0.009946762584149837, + 0.015906117856502533, + 0.7565546631813049, + 0.05546434223651886, + 0.030431047081947327 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5233953595161438 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up filmed from a slightly downward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of slender, pale hands with immaculately manicured nails visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a heart-shaped, crimson strawberry with tiny yellow seeds visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the hands plucking the strawberry intact from the plant?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filled with warm, golden sunlight casting dappled shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007647877559065819 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.88264799118042 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007647877559065819, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007647877559065819, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.01438892725855112, + 0.01373645942658186, + 0.03274188190698624, + 0.017859341576695442, + 0.022500239312648773, + 0.05633749067783356, + 0.02826729230582714, + 0.7079722285270691, + 0.09251166135072708, + 0.013684501871466637 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007647877559065819 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up filmed from a slightly downward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of slender, pale hands with immaculately manicured nails visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a heart-shaped, crimson strawberry with tiny yellow seeds visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the hands plucking the strawberry intact from the plant?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filled with warm, golden sunlight casting dappled shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14283858239650726 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.017838478088379 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14283858239650726, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.8749998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14283858239650726, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09003789722919464, + 0.029265902936458588, + 0.05352932587265968, + 0.018723787739872932, + 0.03559610992670059, + 0.050632044672966, + 0.018663961440324783, + 0.6153147220611572, + 0.05507776886224747, + 0.03315852954983711 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14283858239650726 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up filmed from a slightly downward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of slender, pale hands with immaculately manicured nails visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a heart-shaped, crimson strawberry with tiny yellow seeds visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the hands plucking the strawberry intact from the plant?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filled with warm, golden sunlight casting dappled shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018202288076281548 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018202304840088 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018202288076281548, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018202288076281548, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06931546330451965, + 0.015963047742843628, + 0.031692881137132645, + 0.013878265395760536, + 0.04127679020166397, + 0.026067322120070457, + 0.015799548476934433, + 0.7250702977180481, + 0.03837915137410164, + 0.022557197138667107 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018202288076281548 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_8/index_tensor([311, 311])_group_8_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_8/index_tensor([311, 311])_group_8_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..0d1f5a7c4c8824e99d031278c94d9238a1c7229b --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_8/index_tensor([311, 311])_group_8_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "The scene begins with a medium shot, then immediately begins a slow, deliberate pullback, all rendered in the subtle, fluid style of traditional Chinese ink painting. At its center is a Harrier jet, its form captured not with metallic precision but with bold, calligraphic strokes of deep black ink, defining its powerful outline against the hazy expanse. The jet hangs in a controlled hover, a moment of immense levitational force. Its powerful downward thrust is imagined not as fire, but as a chaotic yet elegant vortex of splashing ink and surging gray water, impacting the tranquil surface of the lake below. This disturbance sends forth perfectly concentric ripples, graceful circles of diluted ink slowly and rhythmically expanding across the vast, minimalist body of water, imbued with the distinctive fibrous texture of rice paper. As the camera continues to pull back to a final, breathtaking wide shot, the stark beauty of the entire scene is revealed: the distant mountains, rendered in increasingly lighter shades of gray, become layered, ethereal outlines, gradually fading into a soft, wet-on-wet mist that unifies water and sky. The entire composition adheres to a stark monochrome palette, creating a profound atmosphere of serene, contemplative beauty juxtaposed against the anachronistic presence of modern military equipment, a fusion of primal power and ancient art.", + "seed": 8662, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_8/index_311_seed_8662_dp_16_rank_32_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.07757521043531597, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07757521043531597, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.8, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07757521043531597, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a Harrier jet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the jet depicted in a controlled hover?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a traditional Chinese ink painting style with bold calligraphic strokes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a medium shot and pull back to a wide shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a lake with concentric ripples and distant mountains fading into mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.28383171558380127 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4088317155838013 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.28383171558380127, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.28383171558380127, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07504072040319443, + 0.040651675313711166, + 0.06865011155605316, + 0.2485986053943634, + 0.14323458075523376, + 0.08422265201807022, + 0.15846769511699677, + 0.050950922071933746, + 0.10286623984575272, + 0.02731684222817421 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.28383171558380127 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a Harrier jet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the jet depicted in a controlled hover?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a traditional Chinese ink painting style with bold calligraphic strokes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a medium shot and pull back to a wide shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a lake with concentric ripples and distant mountains fading into mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07903306186199188 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.579033136367798 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07903306186199188, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07903306186199188, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.047163210809230804, + 0.04659126326441765, + 0.03850792720913887, + 0.6696653962135315, + 0.09543070197105408, + 0.015895625576376915, + 0.024891790002584457, + 0.022039741277694702, + 0.025071589276194572, + 0.014742807485163212 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07903306186199188 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a Harrier jet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the jet depicted in a controlled hover?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a traditional Chinese ink painting style with bold calligraphic strokes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a medium shot and pull back to a wide shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a lake with concentric ripples and distant mountains fading into mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00320504535920918 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753204822540283 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00320504535920918, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00320504535920918, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06581362336874008, + 0.05126112699508667, + 0.0427946038544178, + 0.4335080683231354, + 0.15719211101531982, + 0.05165928602218628, + 0.061537619680166245, + 0.04926227405667305, + 0.036625009030103683, + 0.05034630745649338 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00320504535920918 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a Harrier jet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the jet depicted in a controlled hover?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a traditional Chinese ink painting style with bold calligraphic strokes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a medium shot and pull back to a wide shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a lake with concentric ripples and distant mountains fading into mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018189411610364914 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018189430236816 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018189411610364914, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018189411610364914, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03526148945093155, + 0.020792106166481972, + 0.01874905452132225, + 0.17228104174137115, + 0.13542653620243073, + 0.05455990135669708, + 0.17948852479457855, + 0.20531058311462402, + 0.17085012793540955, + 0.007280626334249973 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018189411610364914 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a Harrier jet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the jet depicted in a controlled hover?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a traditional Chinese ink painting style with bold calligraphic strokes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a medium shot and pull back to a wide shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a lake with concentric ripples and distant mountains fading into mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036168177612125874 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628616809844971 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036168177612125874, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036168177612125874, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07215573638677597, + 0.031639453023672104, + 0.045154038816690445, + 0.27744370698928833, + 0.10086365044116974, + 0.1576848030090332, + 0.08110262453556061, + 0.10449741035699844, + 0.04042476788163185, + 0.08903384208679199 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036168177612125874 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "The scene begins with a medium shot, then immediately begins a slow, deliberate pullback, all rendered in the subtle, fluid style of traditional Chinese ink painting. At its center is a Harrier jet, its form captured not with metallic precision but with bold, calligraphic strokes of deep black ink, defining its powerful outline against the hazy expanse. The jet hangs in a controlled hover, a moment of immense levitational force. Its powerful downward thrust is imagined not as fire, but as a chaotic yet elegant vortex of splashing ink and surging gray water, impacting the tranquil surface of the lake below. This disturbance sends forth perfectly concentric ripples, graceful circles of diluted ink slowly and rhythmically expanding across the vast, minimalist body of water, imbued with the distinctive fibrous texture of rice paper. As the camera continues to pull back to a final, breathtaking wide shot, the stark beauty of the entire scene is revealed: the distant mountains, rendered in increasingly lighter shades of gray, become layered, ethereal outlines, gradually fading into a soft, wet-on-wet mist that unifies water and sky. The entire composition adheres to a stark monochrome palette, creating a profound atmosphere of serene, contemplative beauty juxtaposed against the anachronistic presence of modern military equipment, a fusion of primal power and ancient art.", + "seed": 8663, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_8/index_311_seed_8663_dp_16_rank_32_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.06118825580924749, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06118825580924749, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.175, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06118825580924749, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a Harrier jet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the jet depicted in a controlled hover?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a traditional Chinese ink painting style with bold calligraphic strokes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a medium shot and pull back to a wide shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a lake with concentric ripples and distant mountains fading into mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16132400929927826 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9113240242004395 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16132400929927826, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16132400929927826, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15830416977405548, + 0.04709184169769287, + 0.032324906438589096, + 0.08947738260030746, + 0.07060259580612183, + 0.06066543981432915, + 0.07109134644269943, + 0.20806366205215454, + 0.1223193109035492, + 0.14005941152572632 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16132400929927826 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a Harrier jet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the jet depicted in a controlled hover?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a traditional Chinese ink painting style with bold calligraphic strokes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a medium shot and pull back to a wide shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a lake with concentric ripples and distant mountains fading into mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014209638349711895 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264209747314453 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014209638349711895, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014209638349711895, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07376811653375626, + 0.06652740389108658, + 0.044231776148080826, + 0.12433034181594849, + 0.2563839256763458, + 0.03955381363630295, + 0.06949588656425476, + 0.20514197647571564, + 0.03376465290784836, + 0.08680211007595062 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 7, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014209638349711895 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a Harrier jet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the jet depicted in a controlled hover?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a traditional Chinese ink painting style with bold calligraphic strokes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a medium shot and pull back to a wide shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a lake with concentric ripples and distant mountains fading into mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0022034193389117718 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127203464508057 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0022034193389117718, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0022034193389117718, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11611287295818329, + 0.05063839629292488, + 0.03007097914814949, + 0.05800880491733551, + 0.2946512997150421, + 0.03451414778828621, + 0.09363900125026703, + 0.09568121284246445, + 0.0841800719499588, + 0.14250320196151733 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0022034193389117718 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a Harrier jet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the jet depicted in a controlled hover?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a traditional Chinese ink painting style with bold calligraphic strokes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a medium shot and pull back to a wide shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a lake with concentric ripples and distant mountains fading into mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12702128291130066 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.127021312713623 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12702128291130066, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12702128291130066, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.045559145510196686, + 0.07266731560230255, + 0.039796132594347, + 0.13151273131370544, + 0.13424444198608398, + 0.0809306800365448, + 0.23527146875858307, + 0.1709965318441391, + 0.04359906539320946, + 0.045422520488500595 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12702128291130066 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a Harrier jet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the jet depicted in a controlled hover?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a traditional Chinese ink painting style with bold calligraphic strokes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a medium shot and pull back to a wide shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a lake with concentric ripples and distant mountains fading into mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0011829291470348835 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.751183032989502 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0011829291470348835, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0011829291470348835, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06859061866998672, + 0.06793554872274399, + 0.06380967795848846, + 0.029483094811439514, + 0.19564777612686157, + 0.07237318158149719, + 0.05638054013252258, + 0.2061208039522171, + 0.0586322546005249, + 0.18102653324604034 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0011829291470348835 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "The scene begins with a medium shot, then immediately begins a slow, deliberate pullback, all rendered in the subtle, fluid style of traditional Chinese ink painting. At its center is a Harrier jet, its form captured not with metallic precision but with bold, calligraphic strokes of deep black ink, defining its powerful outline against the hazy expanse. The jet hangs in a controlled hover, a moment of immense levitational force. Its powerful downward thrust is imagined not as fire, but as a chaotic yet elegant vortex of splashing ink and surging gray water, impacting the tranquil surface of the lake below. This disturbance sends forth perfectly concentric ripples, graceful circles of diluted ink slowly and rhythmically expanding across the vast, minimalist body of water, imbued with the distinctive fibrous texture of rice paper. As the camera continues to pull back to a final, breathtaking wide shot, the stark beauty of the entire scene is revealed: the distant mountains, rendered in increasingly lighter shades of gray, become layered, ethereal outlines, gradually fading into a soft, wet-on-wet mist that unifies water and sky. The entire composition adheres to a stark monochrome palette, creating a profound atmosphere of serene, contemplative beauty juxtaposed against the anachronistic presence of modern military equipment, a fusion of primal power and ancient art.", + "seed": 8664, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_8/index_311_seed_8664_dp_17_rank_34_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.06268395334482194, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06268395334482194, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.300000023841858, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06268395334482194, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a Harrier jet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the jet depicted in a controlled hover?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a traditional Chinese ink painting style with bold calligraphic strokes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a medium shot and pull back to a wide shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a lake with concentric ripples and distant mountains fading into mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11508239805698395 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2400825023651123 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11508239805698395, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11508239805698395, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1709669977426529, + 0.043975334614515305, + 0.2473074495792389, + 0.07881734520196915, + 0.09988263994455338, + 0.0767856016755104, + 0.08135060220956802, + 0.10180648416280746, + 0.054322801530361176, + 0.044784750789403915 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11508239805698395 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a Harrier jet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the jet depicted in a controlled hover?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a traditional Chinese ink painting style with bold calligraphic strokes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a medium shot and pull back to a wide shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a lake with concentric ripples and distant mountains fading into mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.033727146685123444 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4087271690368652 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.033727146685123444, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.033727146685123444, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09253528714179993, + 0.0986405685544014, + 0.11326571553945541, + 0.25769704580307007, + 0.09291619807481766, + 0.0555109977722168, + 0.13898666203022003, + 0.05227222293615341, + 0.05341539904475212, + 0.04475995525717735 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 6, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.033727146685123444 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a Harrier jet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the jet depicted in a controlled hover?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a traditional Chinese ink painting style with bold calligraphic strokes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a medium shot and pull back to a wide shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a lake with concentric ripples and distant mountains fading into mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014210343360900879 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264210224151611 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014210343360900879, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014210343360900879, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09509747475385666, + 0.046490833163261414, + 0.10566037148237228, + 0.14524464309215546, + 0.1404104083776474, + 0.0706966295838356, + 0.05649596452713013, + 0.048865702003240585, + 0.04088953882455826, + 0.2501484453678131 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014210343360900879 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a Harrier jet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the jet depicted in a controlled hover?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a traditional Chinese ink painting style with bold calligraphic strokes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a medium shot and pull back to a wide shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a lake with concentric ripples and distant mountains fading into mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1427706927061081 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.017770767211914 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1427706927061081, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.8750001192092896, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1427706927061081, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1306772232055664, + 0.038747865706682205, + 0.06091155484318733, + 0.1463375985622406, + 0.1976422667503357, + 0.30826255679130554, + 0.0487210676074028, + 0.036814238876104355, + 0.006879118271172047, + 0.02500651776790619 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1427706927061081 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a Harrier jet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the jet depicted in a controlled hover?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a traditional Chinese ink painting style with bold calligraphic strokes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a medium shot and pull back to a wide shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a lake with concentric ripples and distant mountains fading into mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007629185914993286 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.88262939453125 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007629185914993286, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007629185914993286, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07576629519462585, + 0.07678248733282089, + 0.21384888887405396, + 0.10810771584510803, + 0.06903991848230362, + 0.1641189455986023, + 0.10023048520088196, + 0.06182458624243736, + 0.0498102530837059, + 0.08047042787075043 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007629185914993286 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "The scene begins with a medium shot, then immediately begins a slow, deliberate pullback, all rendered in the subtle, fluid style of traditional Chinese ink painting. At its center is a Harrier jet, its form captured not with metallic precision but with bold, calligraphic strokes of deep black ink, defining its powerful outline against the hazy expanse. The jet hangs in a controlled hover, a moment of immense levitational force. Its powerful downward thrust is imagined not as fire, but as a chaotic yet elegant vortex of splashing ink and surging gray water, impacting the tranquil surface of the lake below. This disturbance sends forth perfectly concentric ripples, graceful circles of diluted ink slowly and rhythmically expanding across the vast, minimalist body of water, imbued with the distinctive fibrous texture of rice paper. As the camera continues to pull back to a final, breathtaking wide shot, the stark beauty of the entire scene is revealed: the distant mountains, rendered in increasingly lighter shades of gray, become layered, ethereal outlines, gradually fading into a soft, wet-on-wet mist that unifies water and sky. The entire composition adheres to a stark monochrome palette, creating a profound atmosphere of serene, contemplative beauty juxtaposed against the anachronistic presence of modern military equipment, a fusion of primal power and ancient art.", + "seed": 8665, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_8/index_311_seed_8665_dp_17_rank_34_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.11748258373700082, + "vlm_logprob": -0.11748258373700082, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.15, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.11748258373700082, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a Harrier jet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the jet depicted in a controlled hover?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a traditional Chinese ink painting style with bold calligraphic strokes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a medium shot and pull back to a wide shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a lake with concentric ripples and distant mountains fading into mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.28447484970092773 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4094748497009277 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.28447484970092773, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.28447484970092773, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07982680201530457, + 0.05589709058403969, + 0.1300893872976303, + 0.10292625427246094, + 0.12384584546089172, + 0.06859041005373001, + 0.2983081042766571, + 0.022253695875406265, + 0.032574962824583054, + 0.08568751811981201 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.28447484970092773 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a Harrier jet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the jet depicted in a controlled hover?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a traditional Chinese ink painting style with bold calligraphic strokes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a medium shot and pull back to a wide shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a lake with concentric ripples and distant mountains fading into mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018212120980024338 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.01821231842041 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018212120980024338, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018212120980024338, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08485181629657745, + 0.07109237462282181, + 0.29569271206855774, + 0.07842808961868286, + 0.08393743634223938, + 0.13017906248569489, + 0.056501198559999466, + 0.05766737461090088, + 0.110207200050354, + 0.03144276514649391 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 5, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018212120980024338 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a Harrier jet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the jet depicted in a controlled hover?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a traditional Chinese ink painting style with bold calligraphic strokes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a medium shot and pull back to a wide shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a lake with concentric ripples and distant mountains fading into mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.25210636854171753 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5021064281463623 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.25210636854171753, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.25210636854171753, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09569209814071655, + 0.058236245065927505, + 0.1293877363204956, + 0.10652486979961395, + 0.13502725958824158, + 0.15250825881958008, + 0.13560722768306732, + 0.04599631205201149, + 0.0912233367562294, + 0.049796584993600845 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.25210636854171753 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a Harrier jet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the jet depicted in a controlled hover?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a traditional Chinese ink painting style with bold calligraphic strokes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a medium shot and pull back to a wide shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a lake with concentric ripples and distant mountains fading into mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029799016192555428 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529798984527588 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029799016192555428, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029799016192555428, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15753687918186188, + 0.13576307892799377, + 0.05012441426515579, + 0.0649552196264267, + 0.04889747127890587, + 0.05511946976184845, + 0.16853372752666473, + 0.1334303766489029, + 0.04528864100575447, + 0.14035062491893768 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029799016192555428 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a Harrier jet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the jet depicted in a controlled hover?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a traditional Chinese ink painting style with bold calligraphic strokes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a medium shot and pull back to a wide shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a lake with concentric ripples and distant mountains fading into mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002820563269779086 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.8778204917907715 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002820563269779086, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002820563269779086, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1337927132844925, + 0.1471957117319107, + 0.17132510244846344, + 0.058827295899391174, + 0.07340626418590546, + 0.07517750561237335, + 0.13495314121246338, + 0.09493020921945572, + 0.07257399708032608, + 0.03781808912754059 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002820563269779086 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_9/index_tensor([886, 886])_group_9_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_9/index_tensor([886, 886])_group_9_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..f7e83d340c725102ab4a818d391cf9adb8c36e68 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_9/index_tensor([886, 886])_group_9_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "Richard Avedon-esque extreme close-up macro shot, shot in pure black and white, focuses squarely on the hand of Erlang's slender, resolute-faced father. This gaunt, wrinkled hand grips the joystick of an old wooden airplane with undeniable strength and composure. A hard, sidelight streams in from the side, sculpting every dry skin texture, bulging veins, and faint age spots. Deep shadows crisscross the skin's furrows, while sharp highlights etch the whitened knuckles from exertion and the polished, rounded tip of the joystick. The joystick itself is crafted from dark solid wood, its surface showing subtle scratches and patina of age, exuding a warm, solid patina. Although the old man's face is not visible in the camera, this static, tense gripping action, as well as the slight traces of labor embedded in the edges of the nails, have already conveyed a silent determination and a solemn sense of ritual for making final preparations for departure. The entire picture is full of the beauty of solidified time and the heavy emotion of the upcoming journey in the extreme details and strong contrast of light and shadow.", + "seed": 3128, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_9/index_886_seed_3128_dp_18_rank_36_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.16733040884137154, + "vlm_logprob": -0.16733040884137154, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.4, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.16733040884137154, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro focusing on a hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hand gripping a joystick made of dark solid wood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the image rendered in pure black and white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a hard sidelight creating deep shadows and sharp highlights on the skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the old man's face not visible in the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.058475423604249954 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9334754943847656 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.058475423604249954, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.058475423604249954, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3006100058555603, + 0.11342083662748337, + 0.07041627168655396, + 0.043296463787555695, + 0.06421415507793427, + 0.06768110394477844, + 0.16469204425811768, + 0.037757471203804016, + 0.031247500330209732, + 0.10666416585445404 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.058475423604249954 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro focusing on a hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hand gripping a joystick made of dark solid wood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the image rendered in pure black and white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a hard sidelight creating deep shadows and sharp highlights on the skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the old man's face not visible in the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5234143733978271 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8984143733978271 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5234143733978271, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5234143733978271, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25551503896713257, + 0.11712703108787537, + 0.11195684224367142, + 0.039079781621694565, + 0.05908050760626793, + 0.11465931683778763, + 0.08422483503818512, + 0.05428718402981758, + 0.026239704340696335, + 0.1378297507762909 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5234143733978271 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro focusing on a hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hand gripping a joystick made of dark solid wood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the image rendered in pure black and white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a hard sidelight creating deep shadows and sharp highlights on the skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the old man's face not visible in the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20159918069839478 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.70159912109375 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20159918069839478, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20159918069839478, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18116061389446259, + 0.0810251459479332, + 0.05174936726689339, + 0.04733630642294884, + 0.2645125389099121, + 0.1931786984205246, + 0.029225176200270653, + 0.08306466788053513, + 0.015014350414276123, + 0.05373314395546913 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20159918069839478 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro focusing on a hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hand gripping a joystick made of dark solid wood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the image rendered in pure black and white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a hard sidelight creating deep shadows and sharp highlights on the skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the old man's face not visible in the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02331695705652237 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7733168601989746 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02331695705652237, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02331695705652237, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15219268202781677, + 0.09549663960933685, + 0.09832309186458588, + 0.0303350817412138, + 0.159169003367424, + 0.25371813774108887, + 0.06711892783641815, + 0.04556760564446449, + 0.022493677213788033, + 0.07558519393205643 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02331695705652237 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro focusing on a hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hand gripping a joystick made of dark solid wood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the image rendered in pure black and white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a hard sidelight creating deep shadows and sharp highlights on the skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the old man's face not visible in the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029846109449863434 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.52984619140625 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029846109449863434, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029846109449863434, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.301794171333313, + 0.10342393815517426, + 0.049861274659633636, + 0.050670843571424484, + 0.02718234248459339, + 0.12546412646770477, + 0.09667407721281052, + 0.0731017217040062, + 0.051013439893722534, + 0.12081411480903625 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029846109449863434 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "Richard Avedon-esque extreme close-up macro shot, shot in pure black and white, focuses squarely on the hand of Erlang's slender, resolute-faced father. This gaunt, wrinkled hand grips the joystick of an old wooden airplane with undeniable strength and composure. A hard, sidelight streams in from the side, sculpting every dry skin texture, bulging veins, and faint age spots. Deep shadows crisscross the skin's furrows, while sharp highlights etch the whitened knuckles from exertion and the polished, rounded tip of the joystick. The joystick itself is crafted from dark solid wood, its surface showing subtle scratches and patina of age, exuding a warm, solid patina. Although the old man's face is not visible in the camera, this static, tense gripping action, as well as the slight traces of labor embedded in the edges of the nails, have already conveyed a silent determination and a solemn sense of ritual for making final preparations for departure. The entire picture is full of the beauty of solidified time and the heavy emotion of the upcoming journey in the extreme details and strong contrast of light and shadow.", + "seed": 3129, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_9/index_886_seed_3129_dp_18_rank_36_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.2787754182703793, + "vlm_logprob": -0.2787754182703793, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.525000011920929, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.2787754182703793, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro focusing on a hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hand gripping a joystick made of dark solid wood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the image rendered in pure black and white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a hard sidelight creating deep shadows and sharp highlights on the skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the old man's face not visible in the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03568664565682411 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.535686731338501 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03568664565682411, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03568664565682411, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19911368191242218, + 0.12128523737192154, + 0.08934348821640015, + 0.074513278901577, + 0.07461513578891754, + 0.05893908813595772, + 0.08930578082799911, + 0.16658438742160797, + 0.09517885744571686, + 0.031121058389544487 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03568664565682411 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro focusing on a hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hand gripping a joystick made of dark solid wood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the image rendered in pure black and white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a hard sidelight creating deep shadows and sharp highlights on the skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the old man's face not visible in the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.34875911474227905 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2237591743469238 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.34875911474227905, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.8750000596046448, + "token_credit_reward": -0.34875911474227905, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.26885083317756653, + 0.11047538369894028, + 0.036648575216531754, + 0.08917424082756042, + 0.20910988748073578, + 0.05905372276902199, + 0.012256946414709091, + 0.14852574467658997, + 0.03965624421834946, + 0.026248393580317497 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.34875911474227905 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro focusing on a hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hand gripping a joystick made of dark solid wood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the image rendered in pure black and white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a hard sidelight creating deep shadows and sharp highlights on the skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the old man's face not visible in the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9743148684501648 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4743148684501648 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.9743148684501648, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.9743148684501648, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22038166224956512, + 0.12409539520740509, + 0.20928043127059937, + 0.06197722256183624, + 0.14810051023960114, + 0.028692755848169327, + 0.042649876326322556, + 0.09116053581237793, + 0.03966758772730827, + 0.03399399667978287 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.9743148684501648 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro focusing on a hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hand gripping a joystick made of dark solid wood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the image rendered in pure black and white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a hard sidelight creating deep shadows and sharp highlights on the skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the old man's face not visible in the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029838239774107933 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298383235931396 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029838239774107933, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029838239774107933, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1825471669435501, + 0.07623542100191116, + 0.06376655399799347, + 0.0466126948595047, + 0.08904571086168289, + 0.087136410176754, + 0.1369486153125763, + 0.06447766721248627, + 0.05626911669969559, + 0.1969606727361679 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029838239774107933 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro focusing on a hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hand gripping a joystick made of dark solid wood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the image rendered in pure black and white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a hard sidelight creating deep shadows and sharp highlights on the skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the old man's face not visible in the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005278222728520632 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.25527811050415 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005278222728520632, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005278222728520632, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3019622266292572, + 0.10206703841686249, + 0.08549226820468903, + 0.07038190215826035, + 0.07433094829320908, + 0.050031501799821854, + 0.05378377437591553, + 0.1377515345811844, + 0.06701584160327911, + 0.05718296393752098 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005278222728520632 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "Richard Avedon-esque extreme close-up macro shot, shot in pure black and white, focuses squarely on the hand of Erlang's slender, resolute-faced father. This gaunt, wrinkled hand grips the joystick of an old wooden airplane with undeniable strength and composure. A hard, sidelight streams in from the side, sculpting every dry skin texture, bulging veins, and faint age spots. Deep shadows crisscross the skin's furrows, while sharp highlights etch the whitened knuckles from exertion and the polished, rounded tip of the joystick. The joystick itself is crafted from dark solid wood, its surface showing subtle scratches and patina of age, exuding a warm, solid patina. Although the old man's face is not visible in the camera, this static, tense gripping action, as well as the slight traces of labor embedded in the edges of the nails, have already conveyed a silent determination and a solemn sense of ritual for making final preparations for departure. The entire picture is full of the beauty of solidified time and the heavy emotion of the upcoming journey in the extreme details and strong contrast of light and shadow.", + "seed": 3130, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_9/index_886_seed_3130_dp_19_rank_38_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.2528307086788118, + "vlm_logprob": -0.2528307086788118, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.674999988079071, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.2528307086788118, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro focusing on a hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hand gripping a joystick made of dark solid wood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the image rendered in pure black and white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a hard sidelight creating deep shadows and sharp highlights on the skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the old man's face not visible in the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05447101965546608 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.054471015930176 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05447101965546608, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05447101965546608, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3218626081943512, + 0.04751329496502876, + 0.05147400125861168, + 0.06583825498819351, + 0.07987228035926819, + 0.05175832659006119, + 0.10462328046560287, + 0.07642266899347305, + 0.17394474148750305, + 0.02669047936797142 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05447101965546608 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro focusing on a hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hand gripping a joystick made of dark solid wood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the image rendered in pure black and white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a hard sidelight creating deep shadows and sharp highlights on the skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the old man's face not visible in the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12716080248355865 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1271607875823975 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12716080248355865, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12716080248355865, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12590926885604858, + 0.12278099358081818, + 0.2014223337173462, + 0.05862217769026756, + 0.0731503888964653, + 0.039854347705841064, + 0.057496972382068634, + 0.18681363761425018, + 0.07456348836421967, + 0.05938642472028732 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12716080248355865 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro focusing on a hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hand gripping a joystick made of dark solid wood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the image rendered in pure black and white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a hard sidelight creating deep shadows and sharp highlights on the skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the old man's face not visible in the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.0539166927337646 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4289166331291199 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.0539166927337646, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.6250000596046448, + "token_credit_reward": -1.0539166927337646, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21767590939998627, + 0.1052892655134201, + 0.1146782785654068, + 0.10828468203544617, + 0.029075516387820244, + 0.030360069125890732, + 0.042478036135435104, + 0.19241337478160858, + 0.10392967611551285, + 0.0558152012526989 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.0539166927337646 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro focusing on a hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hand gripping a joystick made of dark solid wood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the image rendered in pure black and white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a hard sidelight creating deep shadows and sharp highlights on the skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the old man's face not visible in the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02332312986254692 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7733230590820312 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02332312986254692, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02332312986254692, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1214984804391861, + 0.0625373125076294, + 0.18651477992534637, + 0.14849895238876343, + 0.03386123850941658, + 0.03465012460947037, + 0.036438509821891785, + 0.1584787517786026, + 0.16796906292438507, + 0.049552712589502335 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02332312986254692 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro focusing on a hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hand gripping a joystick made of dark solid wood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the image rendered in pure black and white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a hard sidelight creating deep shadows and sharp highlights on the skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the old man's face not visible in the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005281898658722639 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255281925201416 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005281898658722639, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005281898658722639, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16805249452590942, + 0.06886617839336395, + 0.08995909243822098, + 0.2809590697288513, + 0.1995011568069458, + 0.02561231516301632, + 0.03898626193404198, + 0.04641928896307945, + 0.04267321527004242, + 0.03897091746330261 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005281898658722639 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "Richard Avedon-esque extreme close-up macro shot, shot in pure black and white, focuses squarely on the hand of Erlang's slender, resolute-faced father. This gaunt, wrinkled hand grips the joystick of an old wooden airplane with undeniable strength and composure. A hard, sidelight streams in from the side, sculpting every dry skin texture, bulging veins, and faint age spots. Deep shadows crisscross the skin's furrows, while sharp highlights etch the whitened knuckles from exertion and the polished, rounded tip of the joystick. The joystick itself is crafted from dark solid wood, its surface showing subtle scratches and patina of age, exuding a warm, solid patina. Although the old man's face is not visible in the camera, this static, tense gripping action, as well as the slight traces of labor embedded in the edges of the nails, have already conveyed a silent determination and a solemn sense of ritual for making final preparations for departure. The entire picture is full of the beauty of solidified time and the heavy emotion of the upcoming journey in the extreme details and strong contrast of light and shadow.", + "seed": 3131, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000237/group_9/index_886_seed_3131_dp_19_rank_38_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.147623670543544, + "vlm_logprob": -0.147623670543544, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.375, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.147623670543544, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro focusing on a hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hand gripping a joystick made of dark solid wood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the image rendered in pure black and white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a hard sidelight creating deep shadows and sharp highlights on the skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the old man's face not visible in the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018819116055965424 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.268819332122803 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018819116055965424, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018819116055965424, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21843013167381287, + 0.06307141482830048, + 0.11158113181591034, + 0.0995500460267067, + 0.09581149369478226, + 0.07073348015546799, + 0.0889177918434143, + 0.2002600133419037, + 0.02139984630048275, + 0.030244609341025352 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018819116055965424 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro focusing on a hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hand gripping a joystick made of dark solid wood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the image rendered in pure black and white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a hard sidelight creating deep shadows and sharp highlights on the skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the old man's face not visible in the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.18000257015228271 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8050025701522827 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.18000257015228271, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.18000257015228271, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09599022567272186, + 0.13176922500133514, + 0.09456337988376617, + 0.03409002348780632, + 0.028637655079364777, + 0.01937144063413143, + 0.0374988317489624, + 0.5111136436462402, + 0.01578465662896633, + 0.031180894002318382 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.18000257015228271 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro focusing on a hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hand gripping a joystick made of dark solid wood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the image rendered in pure black and white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a hard sidelight creating deep shadows and sharp highlights on the skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the old man's face not visible in the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5233579277992249 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8983579277992249 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5233579277992249, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5233579277992249, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.37537121772766113, + 0.0951492115855217, + 0.11078277230262756, + 0.1884094923734665, + 0.028170345351099968, + 0.04106846824288368, + 0.022081203758716583, + 0.0958264172077179, + 0.026441015303134918, + 0.016699902713298798 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5233579277992249 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro focusing on a hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hand gripping a joystick made of dark solid wood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the image rendered in pure black and white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a hard sidelight creating deep shadows and sharp highlights on the skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the old man's face not visible in the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014216337352991104 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264216423034668 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014216337352991104, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014216337352991104, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2658765912055969, + 0.042243603616952896, + 0.13958831131458282, + 0.1334535926580429, + 0.05227392166852951, + 0.02637518011033535, + 0.03652094304561615, + 0.24886173009872437, + 0.029371174052357674, + 0.025434929877519608 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014216337352991104 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro focusing on a hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hand gripping a joystick made of dark solid wood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the image rendered in pure black and white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a hard sidelight creating deep shadows and sharp highlights on the skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the old man's face not visible in the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.001722401357255876 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.37672233581543 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.001722401357255876, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.001722401357255876, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12916819751262665, + 0.03658671677112579, + 0.1852377951145172, + 0.04609358310699463, + 0.09176161140203476, + 0.029334262013435364, + 0.022153427824378014, + 0.3906875550746918, + 0.03322240710258484, + 0.03575446084141731 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.001722401357255876 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_0/index_tensor([265, 265])_group_0_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_0/index_tensor([265, 265])_group_0_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..166b89e9b95284825c6f93e948a3b619ba8bc81a --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_0/index_tensor([265, 265])_group_0_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "close-up shot, shot from a slightly upward angle, rapidly tilts upward to match the subject's movement, capturing a mythical young hero. His raven black hair is neatly combed into two signature buns on either side of his head, held tightly in place by a red headband. His face is delicate and handsome, but now his brows are furrowed, his eyes wide, revealing extreme shock and alarm. As if startled or sensing intense danger, his body jolts violently, and he launches upward with explosive force. His feet rest firmly on a pair of blazing wheels. The golden hubs spin at high speed, emitting fiery sparks and pale blue flames, leaving a scorching trail in the air. A long, bright red ribbon dances wildly behind him, as if full of life, whipping and tumbling backwards at the sudden acceleration. Its surface, shimmering with the unique sheen of silk, traces countless sharp and graceful red arcs beneath the sacred celestial light. The background is a surging golden sea of clouds. The force of his sudden rise even creates a huge vortex in the clouds below. The whole picture is full of rich oriental mythology, dynamic tension and a tense atmosphere that is about to break out.", + "seed": 12442, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_0/index_265_seed_12442_dp_0_rank_0_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.05074260709807277, + "vlm_logprob": -0.05074260709807277, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.3, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.05074260709807277, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a mythical young hero with raven black hair styled in two buns held by a red headband?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hero's expression showing extreme shock and alarm with furrowed brows and wide eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the hero launching upward from a pair of blazing wheels with golden hubs that emit fiery sparks and pale blue flames?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a long, bright red silk ribbon whipping and tumbling behind the hero, creating red arcs against a background of a surging golden sea of clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start from a slightly upward angle and rapidly tilt upward to match the hero's explosive upward movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07033231854438782 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6953322887420654 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07033231854438782, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07033231854438782, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10143359005451202, + 0.07109419256448746, + 0.06932172924280167, + 0.0870630219578743, + 0.09510792791843414, + 0.2783272862434387, + 0.04229271784424782, + 0.13881467282772064, + 0.056435443460941315, + 0.060109421610832214 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07033231854438782 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a mythical young hero with raven black hair styled in two buns held by a red headband?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hero's expression showing extreme shock and alarm with furrowed brows and wide eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the hero launching upward from a pair of blazing wheels with golden hubs that emit fiery sparks and pale blue flames?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a long, bright red silk ribbon whipping and tumbling behind the hero, creating red arcs against a background of a surging golden sea of clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start from a slightly upward angle and rapidly tilt upward to match the hero's explosive upward movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08905625343322754 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4640562534332275 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08905625343322754, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08905625343322754, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12468639016151428, + 0.09672538936138153, + 0.07648225873708725, + 0.054954349994659424, + 0.060650359839200974, + 0.06080557033419609, + 0.27266448736190796, + 0.09089057147502899, + 0.06516550481319427, + 0.0969751626253128 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08905625343322754 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a mythical young hero with raven black hair styled in two buns held by a red headband?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hero's expression showing extreme shock and alarm with furrowed brows and wide eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the hero launching upward from a pair of blazing wheels with golden hubs that emit fiery sparks and pale blue flames?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a long, bright red silk ribbon whipping and tumbling behind the hero, creating red arcs against a background of a surging golden sea of clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start from a slightly upward angle and rapidly tilt upward to match the hero's explosive upward movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026352116838097572 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513521671295166 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026352116838097572, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026352116838097572, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08882688730955124, + 0.11140649020671844, + 0.07284769415855408, + 0.22801871597766876, + 0.0591701976954937, + 0.092457115650177, + 0.11148701608181, + 0.056792546063661575, + 0.0997115969657898, + 0.07928171753883362 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026352116838097572 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a mythical young hero with raven black hair styled in two buns held by a red headband?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hero's expression showing extreme shock and alarm with furrowed brows and wide eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the hero launching upward from a pair of blazing wheels with golden hubs that emit fiery sparks and pale blue flames?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a long, bright red silk ribbon whipping and tumbling behind the hero, creating red arcs against a background of a surging golden sea of clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start from a slightly upward angle and rapidly tilt upward to match the hero's explosive upward movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005946918856352568 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130947113037109 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005946918856352568, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005946918856352568, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11391162872314453, + 0.04769529029726982, + 0.10472607612609863, + 0.12354948371648788, + 0.10375872254371643, + 0.128617063164711, + 0.09533080458641052, + 0.053951945155858994, + 0.11084936559200287, + 0.11760964244604111 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005946918856352568 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a mythical young hero with raven black hair styled in two buns held by a red headband?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hero's expression showing extreme shock and alarm with furrowed brows and wide eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the hero launching upward from a pair of blazing wheels with golden hubs that emit fiery sparks and pale blue flames?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a long, bright red silk ribbon whipping and tumbling behind the hero, creating red arcs against a background of a surging golden sea of clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start from a slightly upward angle and rapidly tilt upward to match the hero's explosive upward movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06202542781829834 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812025547027588 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06202542781829834, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06202542781829834, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1129351556301117, + 0.05866825208067894, + 0.08416055887937546, + 0.2235439270734787, + 0.15669035911560059, + 0.11626025289297104, + 0.05877352133393288, + 0.06061633303761482, + 0.05949884653091431, + 0.06885285675525665 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06202542781829834 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up shot, shot from a slightly upward angle, rapidly tilts upward to match the subject's movement, capturing a mythical young hero. His raven black hair is neatly combed into two signature buns on either side of his head, held tightly in place by a red headband. His face is delicate and handsome, but now his brows are furrowed, his eyes wide, revealing extreme shock and alarm. As if startled or sensing intense danger, his body jolts violently, and he launches upward with explosive force. His feet rest firmly on a pair of blazing wheels. The golden hubs spin at high speed, emitting fiery sparks and pale blue flames, leaving a scorching trail in the air. A long, bright red ribbon dances wildly behind him, as if full of life, whipping and tumbling backwards at the sudden acceleration. Its surface, shimmering with the unique sheen of silk, traces countless sharp and graceful red arcs beneath the sacred celestial light. The background is a surging golden sea of clouds. The force of his sudden rise even creates a huge vortex in the clouds below. The whole picture is full of rich oriental mythology, dynamic tension and a tense atmosphere that is about to break out.", + "seed": 12443, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_0/index_265_seed_12443_dp_0_rank_0_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.07074805656448006, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07074805656448006, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.775, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07074805656448006, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a mythical young hero with raven black hair styled in two buns held by a red headband?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hero's expression showing extreme shock and alarm with furrowed brows and wide eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the hero launching upward from a pair of blazing wheels with golden hubs that emit fiery sparks and pale blue flames?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a long, bright red silk ribbon whipping and tumbling behind the hero, creating red arcs against a background of a surging golden sea of clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start from a slightly upward angle and rapidly tilt upward to match the hero's explosive upward movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.034062713384628296 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.409062623977661 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.034062713384628296, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.034062713384628296, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.32048630714416504, + 0.08283903449773788, + 0.0212189219892025, + 0.1363988071680069, + 0.09360964596271515, + 0.12342182546854019, + 0.14189234375953674, + 0.03209514543414116, + 0.018939845263957977, + 0.029098154976963997 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.034062713384628296 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a mythical young hero with raven black hair styled in two buns held by a red headband?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hero's expression showing extreme shock and alarm with furrowed brows and wide eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the hero launching upward from a pair of blazing wheels with golden hubs that emit fiery sparks and pale blue flames?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a long, bright red silk ribbon whipping and tumbling behind the hero, creating red arcs against a background of a surging golden sea of clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start from a slightly upward angle and rapidly tilt upward to match the hero's explosive upward movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2813626527786255 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4063626527786255 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2813626527786255, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2813626527786255, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4307859539985657, + 0.09416753053665161, + 0.040405359119176865, + 0.035724248737096786, + 0.061902064830064774, + 0.09784789383411407, + 0.1198694035410881, + 0.03441888466477394, + 0.03661026060581207, + 0.048268385231494904 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2813626527786255 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a mythical young hero with raven black hair styled in two buns held by a red headband?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hero's expression showing extreme shock and alarm with furrowed brows and wide eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the hero launching upward from a pair of blazing wheels with golden hubs that emit fiery sparks and pale blue flames?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a long, bright red silk ribbon whipping and tumbling behind the hero, creating red arcs against a background of a surging golden sea of clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start from a slightly upward angle and rapidly tilt upward to match the hero's explosive upward movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00978624727576971 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634786128997803 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00978624727576971, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00978624727576971, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15845303237438202, + 0.09862538427114487, + 0.13118062913417816, + 0.06508837640285492, + 0.05111703276634216, + 0.1080607920885086, + 0.12073029577732086, + 0.09358879923820496, + 0.11728677153587341, + 0.05586888641119003 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00978624727576971 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a mythical young hero with raven black hair styled in two buns held by a red headband?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hero's expression showing extreme shock and alarm with furrowed brows and wide eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the hero launching upward from a pair of blazing wheels with golden hubs that emit fiery sparks and pale blue flames?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a long, bright red silk ribbon whipping and tumbling behind the hero, creating red arcs against a background of a surging golden sea of clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start from a slightly upward angle and rapidly tilt upward to match the hero's explosive upward movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002196639310568571 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127196788787842 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002196639310568571, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002196639310568571, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4595140218734741, + 0.04952225089073181, + 0.04602593928575516, + 0.05863243713974953, + 0.18982981145381927, + 0.054090674966573715, + 0.037357959896326065, + 0.03322650119662285, + 0.041615985333919525, + 0.030184457078576088 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002196639310568571 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a mythical young hero with raven black hair styled in two buns held by a red headband?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hero's expression showing extreme shock and alarm with furrowed brows and wide eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the hero launching upward from a pair of blazing wheels with golden hubs that emit fiery sparks and pale blue flames?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a long, bright red silk ribbon whipping and tumbling behind the hero, creating red arcs against a background of a surging golden sea of clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start from a slightly upward angle and rapidly tilt upward to match the hero's explosive upward movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026332030072808266 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651332139968872 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026332030072808266, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026332030072808266, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13732139766216278, + 0.08342994749546051, + 0.04760117456316948, + 0.04404500499367714, + 0.17702661454677582, + 0.04486652463674545, + 0.10355803370475769, + 0.06445872038602829, + 0.22525106370449066, + 0.0724414810538292 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026332030072808266 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up shot, shot from a slightly upward angle, rapidly tilts upward to match the subject's movement, capturing a mythical young hero. His raven black hair is neatly combed into two signature buns on either side of his head, held tightly in place by a red headband. His face is delicate and handsome, but now his brows are furrowed, his eyes wide, revealing extreme shock and alarm. As if startled or sensing intense danger, his body jolts violently, and he launches upward with explosive force. His feet rest firmly on a pair of blazing wheels. The golden hubs spin at high speed, emitting fiery sparks and pale blue flames, leaving a scorching trail in the air. A long, bright red ribbon dances wildly behind him, as if full of life, whipping and tumbling backwards at the sudden acceleration. Its surface, shimmering with the unique sheen of silk, traces countless sharp and graceful red arcs beneath the sacred celestial light. The background is a surging golden sea of clouds. The force of his sudden rise even creates a huge vortex in the clouds below. The whole picture is full of rich oriental mythology, dynamic tension and a tense atmosphere that is about to break out.", + "seed": 12444, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_0/index_265_seed_12444_dp_1_rank_2_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.05043331643100828, + "vlm_logprob": -0.05043331643100828, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.925, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.05043331643100828, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a mythical young hero with raven black hair styled in two buns held by a red headband?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hero's expression showing extreme shock and alarm with furrowed brows and wide eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the hero launching upward from a pair of blazing wheels with golden hubs that emit fiery sparks and pale blue flames?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a long, bright red silk ribbon whipping and tumbling behind the hero, creating red arcs against a background of a surging golden sea of clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start from a slightly upward angle and rapidly tilt upward to match the hero's explosive upward movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020724769681692123 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8957247734069824 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020724769681692123, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020724769681692123, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14904223382472992, + 0.30445244908332825, + 0.07597441226243973, + 0.03441321849822998, + 0.08226912468671799, + 0.032859813421964645, + 0.20396080613136292, + 0.03026542440056801, + 0.03495193272829056, + 0.051810599863529205 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020724769681692123 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a mythical young hero with raven black hair styled in two buns held by a red headband?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hero's expression showing extreme shock and alarm with furrowed brows and wide eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the hero launching upward from a pair of blazing wheels with golden hubs that emit fiery sparks and pale blue flames?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a long, bright red silk ribbon whipping and tumbling behind the hero, creating red arcs against a background of a surging golden sea of clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start from a slightly upward angle and rapidly tilt upward to match the hero's explosive upward movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.179892435669899 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8048924207687378 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.179892435669899, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.179892435669899, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.104857437312603, + 0.36611407995224, + 0.03130277618765831, + 0.04335494339466095, + 0.06446851044893265, + 0.024388639256358147, + 0.08087752759456635, + 0.050459347665309906, + 0.1538476198911667, + 0.08032917231321335 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.179892435669899 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a mythical young hero with raven black hair styled in two buns held by a red headband?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hero's expression showing extreme shock and alarm with furrowed brows and wide eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the hero launching upward from a pair of blazing wheels with golden hubs that emit fiery sparks and pale blue flames?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a long, bright red silk ribbon whipping and tumbling behind the hero, creating red arcs against a background of a surging golden sea of clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start from a slightly upward angle and rapidly tilt upward to match the hero's explosive upward movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020588496699929237 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955883979797363 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020588496699929237, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020588496699929237, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06826838105916977, + 0.02326730452477932, + 0.05180039629340172, + 0.03178468719124794, + 0.325425922870636, + 0.030899198725819588, + 0.1635775864124298, + 0.1117420420050621, + 0.0581592358648777, + 0.13507527112960815 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020588496699929237 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a mythical young hero with raven black hair styled in two buns held by a red headband?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hero's expression showing extreme shock and alarm with furrowed brows and wide eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the hero launching upward from a pair of blazing wheels with golden hubs that emit fiery sparks and pale blue flames?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a long, bright red silk ribbon whipping and tumbling behind the hero, creating red arcs against a background of a surging golden sea of clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start from a slightly upward angle and rapidly tilt upward to match the hero's explosive upward movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.001178642618469894 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.751178741455078 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.001178642618469894, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.001178642618469894, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05655728653073311, + 0.07224302738904953, + 0.04215601459145546, + 0.05483775958418846, + 0.038987014442682266, + 0.038560207933187485, + 0.34969136118888855, + 0.10196603089570999, + 0.1669849455356598, + 0.07801634073257446 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.001178642618469894 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a mythical young hero with raven black hair styled in two buns held by a red headband?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hero's expression showing extreme shock and alarm with furrowed brows and wide eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the hero launching upward from a pair of blazing wheels with golden hubs that emit fiery sparks and pale blue flames?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a long, bright red silk ribbon whipping and tumbling behind the hero, creating red arcs against a background of a surging golden sea of clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start from a slightly upward angle and rapidly tilt upward to match the hero's explosive upward movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029782237485051155 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529782295227051 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029782237485051155, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029782237485051155, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05427461862564087, + 0.15531226992607117, + 0.060073353350162506, + 0.06029798090457916, + 0.08438103646039963, + 0.040768101811409, + 0.10327768325805664, + 0.182804137468338, + 0.04821329936385155, + 0.21059750020503998 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029782237485051155 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up shot, shot from a slightly upward angle, rapidly tilts upward to match the subject's movement, capturing a mythical young hero. His raven black hair is neatly combed into two signature buns on either side of his head, held tightly in place by a red headband. His face is delicate and handsome, but now his brows are furrowed, his eyes wide, revealing extreme shock and alarm. As if startled or sensing intense danger, his body jolts violently, and he launches upward with explosive force. His feet rest firmly on a pair of blazing wheels. The golden hubs spin at high speed, emitting fiery sparks and pale blue flames, leaving a scorching trail in the air. A long, bright red ribbon dances wildly behind him, as if full of life, whipping and tumbling backwards at the sudden acceleration. Its surface, shimmering with the unique sheen of silk, traces countless sharp and graceful red arcs beneath the sacred celestial light. The background is a surging golden sea of clouds. The force of his sudden rise even creates a huge vortex in the clouds below. The whole picture is full of rich oriental mythology, dynamic tension and a tense atmosphere that is about to break out.", + "seed": 12445, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_0/index_265_seed_12445_dp_1_rank_2_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.06626980160363019, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06626980160363019, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.9, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06626980160363019, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a mythical young hero with raven black hair styled in two buns held by a red headband?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hero's expression showing extreme shock and alarm with furrowed brows and wide eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the hero launching upward from a pair of blazing wheels with golden hubs that emit fiery sparks and pale blue flames?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a long, bright red silk ribbon whipping and tumbling behind the hero, creating red arcs against a background of a surging golden sea of clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start from a slightly upward angle and rapidly tilt upward to match the hero's explosive upward movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.043431807309389114 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1684317588806152 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.043431807309389114, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.043431807309389114, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2576804459095001, + 0.06692875921726227, + 0.07584807276725769, + 0.24817951023578644, + 0.06394857913255692, + 0.07725352048873901, + 0.0689174234867096, + 0.06651119887828827, + 0.020060626789927483, + 0.05467187613248825 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.043431807309389114 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a mythical young hero with raven black hair styled in two buns held by a red headband?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hero's expression showing extreme shock and alarm with furrowed brows and wide eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the hero launching upward from a pair of blazing wheels with golden hubs that emit fiery sparks and pale blue flames?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a long, bright red silk ribbon whipping and tumbling behind the hero, creating red arcs against a background of a surging golden sea of clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start from a slightly upward angle and rapidly tilt upward to match the hero's explosive upward movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2521187961101532 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5021188259124756 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2521187961101532, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2521187961101532, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2681991457939148, + 0.06742158532142639, + 0.047796253114938736, + 0.334905207157135, + 0.07448003441095352, + 0.055477481335401535, + 0.06922869384288788, + 0.028631150722503662, + 0.018684418871998787, + 0.035175956785678864 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2521187961101532 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a mythical young hero with raven black hair styled in two buns held by a red headband?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hero's expression showing extreme shock and alarm with furrowed brows and wide eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the hero launching upward from a pair of blazing wheels with golden hubs that emit fiery sparks and pale blue flames?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a long, bright red silk ribbon whipping and tumbling behind the hero, creating red arcs against a background of a surging golden sea of clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start from a slightly upward angle and rapidly tilt upward to match the hero's explosive upward movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0031960143242031336 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.7531962394714355 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0031960143242031336, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0031960143242031336, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3080678880214691, + 0.044169940054416656, + 0.11388824880123138, + 0.10444644093513489, + 0.11956822127103806, + 0.13094046711921692, + 0.07284489274024963, + 0.031131206080317497, + 0.01289964746683836, + 0.06204300373792648 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0031960143242031336 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a mythical young hero with raven black hair styled in two buns held by a red headband?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hero's expression showing extreme shock and alarm with furrowed brows and wide eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the hero launching upward from a pair of blazing wheels with golden hubs that emit fiery sparks and pale blue flames?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a long, bright red silk ribbon whipping and tumbling behind the hero, creating red arcs against a background of a surging golden sea of clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start from a slightly upward angle and rapidly tilt upward to match the hero's explosive upward movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0028181858360767365 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.8778181076049805 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0028181858360767365, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0028181858360767365, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.28295737504959106, + 0.08046959340572357, + 0.0627584382891655, + 0.18921737372875214, + 0.07953709363937378, + 0.06089276447892189, + 0.07758554071187973, + 0.05352698266506195, + 0.03232382982969284, + 0.08073104918003082 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0028181858360767365 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a mythical young hero with raven black hair styled in two buns held by a red headband?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hero's expression showing extreme shock and alarm with furrowed brows and wide eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the hero launching upward from a pair of blazing wheels with golden hubs that emit fiery sparks and pale blue flames?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a long, bright red silk ribbon whipping and tumbling behind the hero, creating red arcs against a background of a surging golden sea of clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start from a slightly upward angle and rapidly tilt upward to match the hero's explosive upward movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029784204438328743 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5297842025756836 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029784204438328743, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029784204438328743, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.27408143877983093, + 0.050513479858636856, + 0.05437137559056282, + 0.09233521670103073, + 0.056529246270656586, + 0.1338007003068924, + 0.18798969686031342, + 0.04927215352654457, + 0.04187626391649246, + 0.059230461716651917 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029784204438328743 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_1/index_tensor([8730, 8730])_group_1_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_1/index_tensor([8730, 8730])_group_1_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..58bc5d420f347b67942759064c6f1669a3506011 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_1/index_tensor([8730, 8730])_group_1_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "low-angle, dynamic tracking shot, clinging to the shimmering water, tracks a slender, ornate dragon boat alongside. The boat's hull is painted a vibrant Chinese red, its sides adorned with golden scales that gleam in the sunlight. A delicately carved, ferocious dragon head, its eyes wide open, fiercely cleaves the emerald waters. At the bow, a shirtless, muscular drummer rhythmically and forcefully strikes a massive cowhide drum. The heavy, powerful beats are like the heartbeat of the warship, providing the rhythm for the crew's progress. Behind him, dozens of crew members, clad in uniform white vests, swing their oars with astonishing unison, their muscular arms exerting their full strength with each stroke. Their teeth clenched, their faces etched with sweat, their faces focused and resolute. Steadily and decisively, they plunged their oars deep into the water, then pulled back sharply. This powerful, rhythmic, and repetitive movement propelled the dragon boat forward like an arrow, sending two tumbling white waves tumbling down either side. The brilliant sunlight bathed the entire scene in a warm golden glow. Splashing water created fleeting rainbows in the air, and the entire scene was filled with vibrant colors and a powerful sense of movement, creating an intense, competitive atmosphere brimming with primal vitality.", + "seed": 13445, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_1/index_8730_seed_13445_dp_2_rank_4_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.01449018674902618, + "vlm_logprob": -0.01449018674902618, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.5, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.01449018674902618, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle with a dynamic tracking movement alongside the boat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the dragon boat's hull painted vibrant Chinese red with golden scales on the sides?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a ferocious dragon head carved at the bow with wide-open eyes cleaving the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are shirtless muscular crew members wearing uniform white vests rowing in unison with clenched teeth and sweat on their faces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by brilliant sunlight creating a warm golden glow and fleeting rainbows in the splashing water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02912188693881035 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6541218757629395 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02912188693881035, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02912188693881035, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16523118317127228, + 0.06998404860496521, + 0.12010879069566727, + 0.15045598149299622, + 0.1005973070859909, + 0.11869008839130402, + 0.0494828037917614, + 0.06854754686355591, + 0.056764498353004456, + 0.10013773292303085 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02912188693881035 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle with a dynamic tracking movement alongside the boat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the dragon boat's hull painted vibrant Chinese red with golden scales on the sides?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a ferocious dragon head carved at the bow with wide-open eyes cleaving the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are shirtless muscular crew members wearing uniform white vests rowing in unison with clenched teeth and sweat on their faces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by brilliant sunlight creating a warm golden glow and fleeting rainbows in the splashing water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012546537443995476 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387546539306641 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012546537443995476, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012546537443995476, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06348980963230133, + 0.05472477525472641, + 0.07845407724380493, + 0.14014142751693726, + 0.07223009318113327, + 0.1870887279510498, + 0.14201362431049347, + 0.10060830414295197, + 0.07595011591911316, + 0.0852990671992302 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 6, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012546537443995476 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle with a dynamic tracking movement alongside the boat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the dragon boat's hull painted vibrant Chinese red with golden scales on the sides?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a ferocious dragon head carved at the bow with wide-open eyes cleaving the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are shirtless muscular crew members wearing uniform white vests rowing in unison with clenched teeth and sweat on their faces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by brilliant sunlight creating a warm golden glow and fleeting rainbows in the splashing water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009782115928828716 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634782314300537 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009782115928828716, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009782115928828716, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20241272449493408, + 0.06508029252290726, + 0.06988246738910675, + 0.07583113759756088, + 0.04825729876756668, + 0.12408673018217087, + 0.13716182112693787, + 0.08172720670700073, + 0.11238948255777359, + 0.08317088335752487 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009782115928828716 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle with a dynamic tracking movement alongside the boat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the dragon boat's hull painted vibrant Chinese red with golden scales on the sides?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a ferocious dragon head carved at the bow with wide-open eyes cleaving the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are shirtless muscular crew members wearing uniform white vests rowing in unison with clenched teeth and sweat on their faces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by brilliant sunlight creating a warm golden glow and fleeting rainbows in the splashing water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01818636804819107 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018186569213867 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01818636804819107, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01818636804819107, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1480051577091217, + 0.041992682963609695, + 0.048182886093854904, + 0.06615836918354034, + 0.047744642943143845, + 0.3315354585647583, + 0.07721442729234695, + 0.10401719808578491, + 0.0415356419980526, + 0.09361350536346436 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01818636804819107 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle with a dynamic tracking movement alongside the boat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the dragon boat's hull painted vibrant Chinese red with golden scales on the sides?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a ferocious dragon head carved at the bow with wide-open eyes cleaving the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are shirtless muscular crew members wearing uniform white vests rowing in unison with clenched teeth and sweat on their faces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by brilliant sunlight creating a warm golden glow and fleeting rainbows in the splashing water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0028140253853052855 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877813816070557 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0028140253853052855, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0028140253853052855, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25577446818351746, + 0.045915696769952774, + 0.06141747161746025, + 0.04267669469118118, + 0.04462984949350357, + 0.13511328399181366, + 0.03731882572174072, + 0.055537477135658264, + 0.1435752511024475, + 0.17804095149040222 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0028140253853052855 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, dynamic tracking shot, clinging to the shimmering water, tracks a slender, ornate dragon boat alongside. The boat's hull is painted a vibrant Chinese red, its sides adorned with golden scales that gleam in the sunlight. A delicately carved, ferocious dragon head, its eyes wide open, fiercely cleaves the emerald waters. At the bow, a shirtless, muscular drummer rhythmically and forcefully strikes a massive cowhide drum. The heavy, powerful beats are like the heartbeat of the warship, providing the rhythm for the crew's progress. Behind him, dozens of crew members, clad in uniform white vests, swing their oars with astonishing unison, their muscular arms exerting their full strength with each stroke. Their teeth clenched, their faces etched with sweat, their faces focused and resolute. Steadily and decisively, they plunged their oars deep into the water, then pulled back sharply. This powerful, rhythmic, and repetitive movement propelled the dragon boat forward like an arrow, sending two tumbling white waves tumbling down either side. The brilliant sunlight bathed the entire scene in a warm golden glow. Splashing water created fleeting rainbows in the air, and the entire scene was filled with vibrant colors and a powerful sense of movement, creating an intense, competitive atmosphere brimming with primal vitality.", + "seed": 13446, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_1/index_8730_seed_13446_dp_2_rank_4_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.0171997903380543, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0171997903380543, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.525, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0171997903380543, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle with a dynamic tracking movement alongside the boat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the dragon boat's hull painted vibrant Chinese red with golden scales on the sides?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a ferocious dragon head carved at the bow with wide-open eyes cleaving the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are shirtless muscular crew members wearing uniform white vests rowing in unison with clenched teeth and sweat on their faces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by brilliant sunlight creating a warm golden glow and fleeting rainbows in the splashing water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01535029523074627 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.390350341796875 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01535029523074627, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01535029523074627, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11420422792434692, + 0.17430934309959412, + 0.0851472020149231, + 0.11430198699235916, + 0.049788810312747955, + 0.06898897886276245, + 0.12842637300491333, + 0.02512093260884285, + 0.20257416367530823, + 0.03713789954781532 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01535029523074627 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle with a dynamic tracking movement alongside the boat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the dragon boat's hull painted vibrant Chinese red with golden scales on the sides?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a ferocious dragon head carved at the bow with wide-open eyes cleaving the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are shirtless muscular crew members wearing uniform white vests rowing in unison with clenched teeth and sweat on their faces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by brilliant sunlight creating a warm golden glow and fleeting rainbows in the splashing water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0430787019431591 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168078660964966 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0430787019431591, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0430787019431591, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17626148462295532, + 0.06512001901865005, + 0.2379635125398636, + 0.04674627259373665, + 0.0593348927795887, + 0.02506115473806858, + 0.1654260903596878, + 0.027961602434515953, + 0.15973518788814545, + 0.036389824002981186 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0430787019431591 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle with a dynamic tracking movement alongside the boat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the dragon boat's hull painted vibrant Chinese red with golden scales on the sides?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a ferocious dragon head carved at the bow with wide-open eyes cleaving the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are shirtless muscular crew members wearing uniform white vests rowing in unison with clenched teeth and sweat on their faces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by brilliant sunlight creating a warm golden glow and fleeting rainbows in the splashing water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009789552539587021 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.63478946685791 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009789552539587021, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009789552539587021, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25947195291519165, + 0.11306282132863998, + 0.09851863980293274, + 0.08415298908948898, + 0.056014999747276306, + 0.01694098301231861, + 0.16326090693473816, + 0.04317355901002884, + 0.1251177042722702, + 0.04028545692563057 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009789552539587021 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle with a dynamic tracking movement alongside the boat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the dragon boat's hull painted vibrant Chinese red with golden scales on the sides?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a ferocious dragon head carved at the bow with wide-open eyes cleaving the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are shirtless muscular crew members wearing uniform white vests rowing in unison with clenched teeth and sweat on their faces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by brilliant sunlight creating a warm golden glow and fleeting rainbows in the splashing water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016069306060671806 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141069412231445 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016069306060671806, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016069306060671806, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.29524779319763184, + 0.06422852724790573, + 0.13768289983272552, + 0.03863559290766716, + 0.0928262397646904, + 0.012806111946702003, + 0.06421136856079102, + 0.03391633555293083, + 0.2200544774532318, + 0.04039066657423973 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016069306060671806 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle with a dynamic tracking movement alongside the boat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the dragon boat's hull painted vibrant Chinese red with golden scales on the sides?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a ferocious dragon head carved at the bow with wide-open eyes cleaving the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are shirtless muscular crew members wearing uniform white vests rowing in unison with clenched teeth and sweat on their faces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by brilliant sunlight creating a warm golden glow and fleeting rainbows in the splashing water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.001711095916107297 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.376710891723633 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.001711095916107297, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.001711095916107297, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19613072276115417, + 0.06999441981315613, + 0.1306162029504776, + 0.06780461221933365, + 0.05707046389579773, + 0.06967645138502121, + 0.08940824121236801, + 0.03109120950102806, + 0.2296971082687378, + 0.05851055681705475 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.001711095916107297 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, dynamic tracking shot, clinging to the shimmering water, tracks a slender, ornate dragon boat alongside. The boat's hull is painted a vibrant Chinese red, its sides adorned with golden scales that gleam in the sunlight. A delicately carved, ferocious dragon head, its eyes wide open, fiercely cleaves the emerald waters. At the bow, a shirtless, muscular drummer rhythmically and forcefully strikes a massive cowhide drum. The heavy, powerful beats are like the heartbeat of the warship, providing the rhythm for the crew's progress. Behind him, dozens of crew members, clad in uniform white vests, swing their oars with astonishing unison, their muscular arms exerting their full strength with each stroke. Their teeth clenched, their faces etched with sweat, their faces focused and resolute. Steadily and decisively, they plunged their oars deep into the water, then pulled back sharply. This powerful, rhythmic, and repetitive movement propelled the dragon boat forward like an arrow, sending two tumbling white waves tumbling down either side. The brilliant sunlight bathed the entire scene in a warm golden glow. Splashing water created fleeting rainbows in the air, and the entire scene was filled with vibrant colors and a powerful sense of movement, creating an intense, competitive atmosphere brimming with primal vitality.", + "seed": 13447, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_1/index_8730_seed_13447_dp_3_rank_6_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.021281617041677237, + "vlm_logprob": -0.021281617041677237, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.2, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.021281617041677237, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle with a dynamic tracking movement alongside the boat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the dragon boat's hull painted vibrant Chinese red with golden scales on the sides?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a ferocious dragon head carved at the bow with wide-open eyes cleaving the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are shirtless muscular crew members wearing uniform white vests rowing in unison with clenched teeth and sweat on their faces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by brilliant sunlight creating a warm golden glow and fleeting rainbows in the splashing water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03888339549303055 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2888834476470947 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03888339549303055, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03888339549303055, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17180950939655304, + 0.05603773891925812, + 0.07604663819074631, + 0.061051324009895325, + 0.3972199559211731, + 0.09302502125501633, + 0.02805354632437229, + 0.051707759499549866, + 0.021300362423062325, + 0.04374813288450241 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03888339549303055 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle with a dynamic tracking movement alongside the boat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the dragon boat's hull painted vibrant Chinese red with golden scales on the sides?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a ferocious dragon head carved at the bow with wide-open eyes cleaving the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are shirtless muscular crew members wearing uniform white vests rowing in unison with clenched teeth and sweat on their faces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by brilliant sunlight creating a warm golden glow and fleeting rainbows in the splashing water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018192805349826813 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018192768096924 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018192805349826813, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018192805349826813, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18874293565750122, + 0.07505901157855988, + 0.04008980095386505, + 0.07911684364080429, + 0.09732919931411743, + 0.09581595659255981, + 0.22910115122795105, + 0.03881251811981201, + 0.05449410900473595, + 0.10143847018480301 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018192805349826813 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle with a dynamic tracking movement alongside the boat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the dragon boat's hull painted vibrant Chinese red with golden scales on the sides?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a ferocious dragon head carved at the bow with wide-open eyes cleaving the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are shirtless muscular crew members wearing uniform white vests rowing in unison with clenched teeth and sweat on their faces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by brilliant sunlight creating a warm golden glow and fleeting rainbows in the splashing water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007626346778124571 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882626533508301 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007626346778124571, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007626346778124571, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.37962421774864197, + 0.10204958915710449, + 0.07649873197078705, + 0.10393709689378738, + 0.08765391260385513, + 0.0802195817232132, + 0.06121155619621277, + 0.043530307710170746, + 0.024198872968554497, + 0.04107613116502762 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007626346778124571 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle with a dynamic tracking movement alongside the boat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the dragon boat's hull painted vibrant Chinese red with golden scales on the sides?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a ferocious dragon head carved at the bow with wide-open eyes cleaving the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are shirtless muscular crew members wearing uniform white vests rowing in unison with clenched teeth and sweat on their faces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by brilliant sunlight creating a warm golden glow and fleeting rainbows in the splashing water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03809477761387825 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2880947589874268 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03809477761387825, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03809477761387825, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21177802979946136, + 0.10083518922328949, + 0.056295789778232574, + 0.18894308805465698, + 0.10958877205848694, + 0.1577892154455185, + 0.06250281631946564, + 0.059386108070611954, + 0.013504951260983944, + 0.039376113563776016 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03809477761387825 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle with a dynamic tracking movement alongside the boat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the dragon boat's hull painted vibrant Chinese red with golden scales on the sides?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a ferocious dragon head carved at the bow with wide-open eyes cleaving the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are shirtless muscular crew members wearing uniform white vests rowing in unison with clenched teeth and sweat on their faces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by brilliant sunlight creating a warm golden glow and fleeting rainbows in the splashing water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003610759973526001 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628610610961914 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003610759973526001, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003610759973526001, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2872200012207031, + 0.06940454989671707, + 0.12679077684879303, + 0.057971421629190445, + 0.19459933042526245, + 0.06741291284561157, + 0.0472058430314064, + 0.05993105098605156, + 0.02377212792634964, + 0.0656919777393341 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003610759973526001 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, dynamic tracking shot, clinging to the shimmering water, tracks a slender, ornate dragon boat alongside. The boat's hull is painted a vibrant Chinese red, its sides adorned with golden scales that gleam in the sunlight. A delicately carved, ferocious dragon head, its eyes wide open, fiercely cleaves the emerald waters. At the bow, a shirtless, muscular drummer rhythmically and forcefully strikes a massive cowhide drum. The heavy, powerful beats are like the heartbeat of the warship, providing the rhythm for the crew's progress. Behind him, dozens of crew members, clad in uniform white vests, swing their oars with astonishing unison, their muscular arms exerting their full strength with each stroke. Their teeth clenched, their faces etched with sweat, their faces focused and resolute. Steadily and decisively, they plunged their oars deep into the water, then pulled back sharply. This powerful, rhythmic, and repetitive movement propelled the dragon boat forward like an arrow, sending two tumbling white waves tumbling down either side. The brilliant sunlight bathed the entire scene in a warm golden glow. Splashing water created fleeting rainbows in the air, and the entire scene was filled with vibrant colors and a powerful sense of movement, creating an intense, competitive atmosphere brimming with primal vitality.", + "seed": 13448, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_1/index_8730_seed_13448_dp_3_rank_6_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.01894089300185442, + "vlm_logprob": -0.01894089300185442, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.275, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.01894089300185442, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle with a dynamic tracking movement alongside the boat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the dragon boat's hull painted vibrant Chinese red with golden scales on the sides?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a ferocious dragon head carved at the bow with wide-open eyes cleaving the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are shirtless muscular crew members wearing uniform white vests rowing in unison with clenched teeth and sweat on their faces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by brilliant sunlight creating a warm golden glow and fleeting rainbows in the splashing water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02913890779018402 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6541388034820557 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02913890779018402, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02913890779018402, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06485620886087418, + 0.08736983686685562, + 0.032376114279031754, + 0.03071393258869648, + 0.6656292676925659, + 0.048647746443748474, + 0.018519898876547813, + 0.029961969703435898, + 0.013139968737959862, + 0.00878505501896143 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02913890779018402 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle with a dynamic tracking movement alongside the boat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the dragon boat's hull painted vibrant Chinese red with golden scales on the sides?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a ferocious dragon head carved at the bow with wide-open eyes cleaving the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are shirtless muscular crew members wearing uniform white vests rowing in unison with clenched teeth and sweat on their faces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by brilliant sunlight creating a warm golden glow and fleeting rainbows in the splashing water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03812025114893913 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881202697753906 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03812025114893913, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03812025114893913, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1865687072277069, + 0.15332037210464478, + 0.09147959202528, + 0.048872508108615875, + 0.34303852915763855, + 0.07565970718860626, + 0.022151576355099678, + 0.039523255079984665, + 0.022825079038739204, + 0.016560755670070648 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03812025114893913 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle with a dynamic tracking movement alongside the boat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the dragon boat's hull painted vibrant Chinese red with golden scales on the sides?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a ferocious dragon head carved at the bow with wide-open eyes cleaving the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are shirtless muscular crew members wearing uniform white vests rowing in unison with clenched teeth and sweat on their faces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by brilliant sunlight creating a warm golden glow and fleeting rainbows in the splashing water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004642185289412737 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379642009735107 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004642185289412737, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004642185289412737, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12435848265886307, + 0.5269269347190857, + 0.04523312300443649, + 0.03190566971898079, + 0.08573870360851288, + 0.10422946512699127, + 0.025847284123301506, + 0.020121559500694275, + 0.022274199873209, + 0.013364526443183422 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004642185289412737 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle with a dynamic tracking movement alongside the boat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the dragon boat's hull painted vibrant Chinese red with golden scales on the sides?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a ferocious dragon head carved at the bow with wide-open eyes cleaving the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are shirtless muscular crew members wearing uniform white vests rowing in unison with clenched teeth and sweat on their faces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by brilliant sunlight creating a warm golden glow and fleeting rainbows in the splashing water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016070010140538216 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.1410698890686035 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016070010140538216, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016070010140538216, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1496129333972931, + 0.08565272390842438, + 0.04779250547289848, + 0.042636461555957794, + 0.4100729525089264, + 0.07450460642576218, + 0.10283427685499191, + 0.04360869899392128, + 0.019121680408716202, + 0.024163246154785156 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016070010140538216 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle with a dynamic tracking movement alongside the boat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the dragon boat's hull painted vibrant Chinese red with golden scales on the sides?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a ferocious dragon head carved at the bow with wide-open eyes cleaving the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are shirtless muscular crew members wearing uniform white vests rowing in unison with clenched teeth and sweat on their faces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by brilliant sunlight creating a warm golden glow and fleeting rainbows in the splashing water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006733110640197992 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006732940673828 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006733110640197992, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006733110640197992, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12235701084136963, + 0.05250651016831398, + 0.03608817234635353, + 0.04167290776968002, + 0.5825114250183105, + 0.02450380101799965, + 0.04994240403175354, + 0.03237498924136162, + 0.040095120668411255, + 0.01794760674238205 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006733110640197992 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_10/index_tensor([8463, 8463])_group_10_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_10/index_tensor([8463, 8463])_group_10_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..6111d4c46d08b7152baa9417315ee1a679e2bc32 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_10/index_tensor([8463, 8463])_group_10_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "Rendered in a sharp, modern anime aesthetic, this high-angle shot smoothly tilts downward, maintaining a tight frame, as a man deliberately descends a seemingly endless series of ancient, shadowy stone stairs. The man has long, sleek black hair, meticulously braided into a high bun, with a few stray strands catching the sunlight. His face, defined by the clean, sharp lines characteristic of modern anime, is calm yet menacing; his narrow eyes focus downward, and a subtle, barely discernible curve curves across his lips. He wears a loose, dark charcoal monk's robe, the heavy fabric creating crisp, stylized folds that sway rhythmically with each calculated step. The only illumination comes from flickering flashlights from invisible wall sconces, casting his long, dancing shadow across the dilapidated, damp stone walls. As his feet land firmly on each step, they disturb clouds of ancient dust, which catch the warm orange glow and shimmer with brilliant, fleeting sparks. Below him, the air shimmers with a palpable, malevolent purple energy, and a corrosive mist seems to climb the steps to greet him, providing a sharp, energizing contrast to the oppressive gloom and immersing the scene in a tense, ominous atmosphere of silent procession into a terrifying place of power.", + "seed": 22325, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_10/index_8463_seed_22325_dp_20_rank_40_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.3483300684019923, + "vlm_logprob": -0.3483300684019923, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.65, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.3483300684019923, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a sharp, modern anime aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot high-angle and tilting downward smoothly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character a man with long, sleek black hair braided into a high bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a loose, dark charcoal monk's robe with stylized folds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a dilapidated, damp stone stairwell with flickering flashlight illumination?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6008801460266113 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2258801907300949 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.6008801460266113, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -1.6008801460266113, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20174765586853027, + 0.07246523350477219, + 0.036036811769008636, + 0.1495634913444519, + 0.09503906965255737, + 0.111334428191185, + 0.06847317516803741, + 0.13938464224338531, + 0.0785389319062233, + 0.04741660878062248 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.6008801460266113 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a sharp, modern anime aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot high-angle and tilting downward smoothly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character a man with long, sleek black hair braided into a high bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a loose, dark charcoal monk's robe with stylized folds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a dilapidated, damp stone stairwell with flickering flashlight illumination?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.062119875103235245 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812119960784912 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.062119875103235245, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.062119875103235245, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08520007878541946, + 0.05498354882001877, + 0.04846898466348648, + 0.08957093954086304, + 0.058818090707063675, + 0.0972311869263649, + 0.18890109658241272, + 0.08470804244279861, + 0.09836086630821228, + 0.19375725090503693 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.062119875103235245 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a sharp, modern anime aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot high-angle and tilting downward smoothly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character a man with long, sleek black hair braided into a high bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a loose, dark charcoal monk's robe with stylized folds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a dilapidated, damp stone stairwell with flickering flashlight illumination?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05495452135801315 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299545288085938 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05495452135801315, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05495452135801315, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14199993014335632, + 0.04589018225669861, + 0.038264792412519455, + 0.13343456387519836, + 0.11668828874826431, + 0.11837472766637802, + 0.0691814124584198, + 0.1198679655790329, + 0.11243001371622086, + 0.10386812686920166 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05495452135801315 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a sharp, modern anime aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot high-angle and tilting downward smoothly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character a man with long, sleek black hair braided into a high bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a loose, dark charcoal monk's robe with stylized folds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a dilapidated, damp stone stairwell with flickering flashlight illumination?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007629777304828167 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882629871368408 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007629777304828167, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007629777304828167, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10280656814575195, + 0.06583017110824585, + 0.03792953863739967, + 0.08100608736276627, + 0.06359288096427917, + 0.09223989397287369, + 0.07803470641374588, + 0.08059827238321304, + 0.15229350328445435, + 0.24566836655139923 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007629777304828167 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a sharp, modern anime aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot high-angle and tilting downward smoothly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character a man with long, sleek black hair braided into a high bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a loose, dark charcoal monk's robe with stylized folds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a dilapidated, damp stone stairwell with flickering flashlight illumination?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016066022217273712 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141066074371338 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016066022217273712, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016066022217273712, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1323358416557312, + 0.10128086805343628, + 0.044386427849531174, + 0.07773562520742416, + 0.06314639002084732, + 0.09909611195325851, + 0.16065244376659393, + 0.10948245972394943, + 0.08129369467496872, + 0.13059018552303314 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016066022217273712 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "Rendered in a sharp, modern anime aesthetic, this high-angle shot smoothly tilts downward, maintaining a tight frame, as a man deliberately descends a seemingly endless series of ancient, shadowy stone stairs. The man has long, sleek black hair, meticulously braided into a high bun, with a few stray strands catching the sunlight. His face, defined by the clean, sharp lines characteristic of modern anime, is calm yet menacing; his narrow eyes focus downward, and a subtle, barely discernible curve curves across his lips. He wears a loose, dark charcoal monk's robe, the heavy fabric creating crisp, stylized folds that sway rhythmically with each calculated step. The only illumination comes from flickering flashlights from invisible wall sconces, casting his long, dancing shadow across the dilapidated, damp stone walls. As his feet land firmly on each step, they disturb clouds of ancient dust, which catch the warm orange glow and shimmer with brilliant, fleeting sparks. Below him, the air shimmers with a palpable, malevolent purple energy, and a corrosive mist seems to climb the steps to greet him, providing a sharp, energizing contrast to the oppressive gloom and immersing the scene in a tense, ominous atmosphere of silent procession into a terrifying place of power.", + "seed": 22326, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_10/index_8463_seed_22326_dp_20_rank_40_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.6222300663590431, + "vlm_logprob": -0.6222300663590431, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.8249999761581421, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.6222300663590431, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a sharp, modern anime aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot high-angle and tilting downward smoothly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character a man with long, sleek black hair braided into a high bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a loose, dark charcoal monk's robe with stylized folds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a dilapidated, damp stone stairwell with flickering flashlight illumination?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812581777572632 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06258177757263184 + ], + "logprob_reward": -2.812581777572632, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -2.812581777572632, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08510604500770569, + 0.15783119201660156, + 0.028159577399492264, + 0.11569056659936905, + 0.0504264198243618, + 0.03730826824903488, + 0.10713009536266327, + 0.22804836928844452, + 0.061032719910144806, + 0.1292666792869568 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -2.812581777572632 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a sharp, modern anime aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot high-angle and tilting downward smoothly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character a man with long, sleek black hair braided into a high bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a loose, dark charcoal monk's robe with stylized folds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a dilapidated, damp stone stairwell with flickering flashlight illumination?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11324300616979599 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2382431030273438 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11324300616979599, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11324300616979599, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05451025813817978, + 0.10970314592123032, + 0.060998450964689255, + 0.10504318028688431, + 0.04372652247548103, + 0.04546312615275383, + 0.18420171737670898, + 0.28142064809799194, + 0.04768881946802139, + 0.06724409759044647 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11324300616979599 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a sharp, modern anime aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot high-angle and tilting downward smoothly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character a man with long, sleek black hair braided into a high bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a loose, dark charcoal monk's robe with stylized folds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a dilapidated, damp stone stairwell with flickering flashlight illumination?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1429358273744583 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0179357528686523 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1429358273744583, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.8749998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1429358273744583, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13702784478664398, + 0.06110619008541107, + 0.07412924617528915, + 0.06361888349056244, + 0.11876153200864792, + 0.04009661823511124, + 0.049998246133327484, + 0.19464342296123505, + 0.08102887123823166, + 0.1795891970396042 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1429358273744583 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a sharp, modern anime aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot high-angle and tilting downward smoothly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character a man with long, sleek black hair braided into a high bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a loose, dark charcoal monk's robe with stylized folds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a dilapidated, damp stone stairwell with flickering flashlight illumination?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012564901262521744 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.3875651359558105 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012564901262521744, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012564901262521744, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12034160643815994, + 0.1379966139793396, + 0.034639518707990646, + 0.07778551429510117, + 0.07557865232229233, + 0.031602777540683746, + 0.1153293177485466, + 0.20860955119132996, + 0.054499104619026184, + 0.14361733198165894 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012564901262521744 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a sharp, modern anime aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot high-angle and tilting downward smoothly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character a man with long, sleek black hair braided into a high bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a loose, dark charcoal monk's robe with stylized folds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a dilapidated, damp stone stairwell with flickering flashlight illumination?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029824819415807724 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529824733734131 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029824819415807724, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029824819415807724, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18280278146266937, + 0.16090823709964752, + 0.0644950345158577, + 0.04237983748316765, + 0.05642334371805191, + 0.05939801037311554, + 0.19788679480552673, + 0.06363379955291748, + 0.06002556532621384, + 0.11204663664102554 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029824819415807724 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "Rendered in a sharp, modern anime aesthetic, this high-angle shot smoothly tilts downward, maintaining a tight frame, as a man deliberately descends a seemingly endless series of ancient, shadowy stone stairs. The man has long, sleek black hair, meticulously braided into a high bun, with a few stray strands catching the sunlight. His face, defined by the clean, sharp lines characteristic of modern anime, is calm yet menacing; his narrow eyes focus downward, and a subtle, barely discernible curve curves across his lips. He wears a loose, dark charcoal monk's robe, the heavy fabric creating crisp, stylized folds that sway rhythmically with each calculated step. The only illumination comes from flickering flashlights from invisible wall sconces, casting his long, dancing shadow across the dilapidated, damp stone walls. As his feet land firmly on each step, they disturb clouds of ancient dust, which catch the warm orange glow and shimmer with brilliant, fleeting sparks. Below him, the air shimmers with a palpable, malevolent purple energy, and a corrosive mist seems to climb the steps to greet him, providing a sharp, energizing contrast to the oppressive gloom and immersing the scene in a tense, ominous atmosphere of silent procession into a terrifying place of power.", + "seed": 22327, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_10/index_8463_seed_22327_dp_21_rank_42_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.5171137697994709, + "vlm_logprob": -0.5171137697994709, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.825000023841858, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.5171137697994709, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a sharp, modern anime aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot high-angle and tilting downward smoothly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character a man with long, sleek black hair braided into a high bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a loose, dark charcoal monk's robe with stylized folds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a dilapidated, damp stone stairwell with flickering flashlight illumination?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2382819652557373 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1132819652557373 + ], + "logprob_reward": -2.2382819652557373, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -2.2382819652557373, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.083375483751297, + 0.10194971412420273, + 0.06015083193778992, + 0.058218929916620255, + 0.08283969759941101, + 0.06118132174015045, + 0.12382311373949051, + 0.1568826287984848, + 0.1372726410627365, + 0.13430561125278473 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -2.2382819652557373 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a sharp, modern anime aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot high-angle and tilting downward smoothly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character a man with long, sleek black hair braided into a high bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a loose, dark charcoal monk's robe with stylized folds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a dilapidated, damp stone stairwell with flickering flashlight illumination?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14299286901950836 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0179929733276367 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14299286901950836, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.8750001192092896, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14299286901950836, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12384763360023499, + 0.08800163120031357, + 0.07473314553499222, + 0.06625030934810638, + 0.10117758065462112, + 0.08884892612695694, + 0.08246485143899918, + 0.09955042600631714, + 0.12375286966562271, + 0.15137264132499695 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14299286901950836 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a sharp, modern anime aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot high-angle and tilting downward smoothly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character a man with long, sleek black hair braided into a high bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a loose, dark charcoal monk's robe with stylized folds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a dilapidated, damp stone stairwell with flickering flashlight illumination?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16040892899036407 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9104089736938477 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16040892899036407, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16040892899036407, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16717290878295898, + 0.08684685081243515, + 0.07833100110292435, + 0.04415491223335266, + 0.057932183146476746, + 0.08821945637464523, + 0.13450297713279724, + 0.10325194150209427, + 0.10833518207073212, + 0.13125254213809967 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16040892899036407 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a sharp, modern anime aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot high-angle and tilting downward smoothly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character a man with long, sleek black hair braided into a high bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a loose, dark charcoal monk's robe with stylized folds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a dilapidated, damp stone stairwell with flickering flashlight illumination?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020593401044607162 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955934047698975 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020593401044607162, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020593401044607162, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16210922598838806, + 0.08426870405673981, + 0.06725196540355682, + 0.04689328745007515, + 0.12235822528600693, + 0.10685301572084427, + 0.07801061123609543, + 0.10659682750701904, + 0.11154613643884659, + 0.11411207169294357 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020593401044607162 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a sharp, modern anime aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot high-angle and tilting downward smoothly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character a man with long, sleek black hair braided into a high bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a loose, dark charcoal monk's robe with stylized folds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a dilapidated, damp stone stairwell with flickering flashlight illumination?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023291684687137604 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.77329158782959 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023291684687137604, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023291684687137604, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09208080917596817, + 0.08217505365610123, + 0.07639177143573761, + 0.058624036610126495, + 0.032713551074266434, + 0.08163262903690338, + 0.03662245348095894, + 0.13302643597126007, + 0.14727789163589478, + 0.2594553530216217 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023291684687137604 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "Rendered in a sharp, modern anime aesthetic, this high-angle shot smoothly tilts downward, maintaining a tight frame, as a man deliberately descends a seemingly endless series of ancient, shadowy stone stairs. The man has long, sleek black hair, meticulously braided into a high bun, with a few stray strands catching the sunlight. His face, defined by the clean, sharp lines characteristic of modern anime, is calm yet menacing; his narrow eyes focus downward, and a subtle, barely discernible curve curves across his lips. He wears a loose, dark charcoal monk's robe, the heavy fabric creating crisp, stylized folds that sway rhythmically with each calculated step. The only illumination comes from flickering flashlights from invisible wall sconces, casting his long, dancing shadow across the dilapidated, damp stone walls. As his feet land firmly on each step, they disturb clouds of ancient dust, which catch the warm orange glow and shimmer with brilliant, fleeting sparks. Below him, the air shimmers with a palpable, malevolent purple energy, and a corrosive mist seems to climb the steps to greet him, providing a sharp, energizing contrast to the oppressive gloom and immersing the scene in a tense, ominous atmosphere of silent procession into a terrifying place of power.", + "seed": 22328, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_10/index_8463_seed_22328_dp_21_rank_42_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.22969602812081574, + "vlm_logprob": -0.22969602812081574, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.075, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.22969602812081574, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a sharp, modern anime aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot high-angle and tilting downward smoothly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character a man with long, sleek black hair braided into a high bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a loose, dark charcoal monk's robe with stylized folds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a dilapidated, damp stone stairwell with flickering flashlight illumination?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.0550540685653687 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.43005406856536865 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.0550540685653687, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.625, + "token_credit_reward": -1.0550540685653687, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08955194801092148, + 0.09382554143667221, + 0.024324504658579826, + 0.29159656167030334, + 0.06813755631446838, + 0.052497830241918564, + 0.0667898952960968, + 0.08252554386854172, + 0.16691240668296814, + 0.06383822858333588 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.0550540685653687 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a sharp, modern anime aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot high-angle and tilting downward smoothly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character a man with long, sleek black hair braided into a high bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a loose, dark charcoal monk's robe with stylized folds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a dilapidated, damp stone stairwell with flickering flashlight illumination?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026370925828814507 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513710021972656 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026370925828814507, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026370925828814507, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08704371005296707, + 0.03322763368487358, + 0.025461578741669655, + 0.10040180385112762, + 0.10843829810619354, + 0.08394613862037659, + 0.02612006664276123, + 0.07078427076339722, + 0.40884479880332947, + 0.055731698870658875 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026370925828814507 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a sharp, modern anime aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot high-angle and tilting downward smoothly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character a man with long, sleek black hair braided into a high bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a loose, dark charcoal monk's robe with stylized folds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a dilapidated, damp stone stairwell with flickering flashlight illumination?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04864467307925224 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048644781112671 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04864467307925224, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04864467307925224, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1473093032836914, + 0.13132865726947784, + 0.05346602573990822, + 0.08992142975330353, + 0.05593212693929672, + 0.10133947432041168, + 0.04708206281065941, + 0.08372607827186584, + 0.18933263421058655, + 0.10056225955486298 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04864467307925224 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a sharp, modern anime aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot high-angle and tilting downward smoothly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character a man with long, sleek black hair braided into a high bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a loose, dark charcoal monk's robe with stylized folds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a dilapidated, damp stone stairwell with flickering flashlight illumination?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008634377270936966 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758634567260742 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008634377270936966, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008634377270936966, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0989619642496109, + 0.1331150084733963, + 0.054980210959911346, + 0.18655051290988922, + 0.07141891121864319, + 0.08485617488622665, + 0.09421536326408386, + 0.06250161677598953, + 0.13087570667266846, + 0.08252457529306412 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008634377270936966 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a sharp, modern anime aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot high-angle and tilting downward smoothly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character a man with long, sleek black hair braided into a high bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a loose, dark charcoal monk's robe with stylized folds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a dilapidated, damp stone stairwell with flickering flashlight illumination?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009776095859706402 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.6347761154174805 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009776095859706402, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009776095859706402, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15172792971134186, + 0.046926889568567276, + 0.02774238958954811, + 0.14979389309883118, + 0.03642573580145836, + 0.14013315737247467, + 0.03516819328069687, + 0.07111585140228271, + 0.22728461027145386, + 0.11368133127689362 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009776095859706402 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_11/index_tensor([6009, 6009])_group_11_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_11/index_tensor([6009, 6009])_group_11_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..de5d6aa06c1ea93602c01e027cc7c0e6c085a0ed --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_11/index_tensor([6009, 6009])_group_11_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "static, perfectly composed wide-angle shot captures the dramatic video game title screen, rendered in a surreal, painterly digital art style. In the background, amid the crumbling, moss-encrusted ruins of a Gothic temple atop a storm-ravaged mountain, two stylized warriors freeze in a climactic duel. One warrior, a colossal figure clad in jagged obsidian plate armor inscribed with faintly glowing crimson runes, raises a massive two-handed clay with a crackle of red energy, caught mid-swing in a display of overwhelming force. Their opponent, a lithe, agile warrior clad in tight black leather and a flowing, tattered cloak, deftly parries the blow with twin curved daggers that glow brilliantly cyan, their bodies contorting into dynamic defensive poses. Intermittent flashes of lightning from a turbulent, deep purple sky illuminate the scene, creating a stark black-and-white contrast between their armor and the rain-slicked stone floor, casting deep shadows and sharp highlights. In the foreground, the main title text, occupying center of the screen, is rendered as massive, chiseled stone letters with deep, glowing golden cracks, slowly and majestically fading from view, transitioning from completely transparent to solid opaque as its inner glow intensifies, establishing the epic, high-stakes atmosphere of the upcoming adventure.", + "seed": 148, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_11/index_6009_seed_148_dp_22_rank_44_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.025766237173229456, + "vlm_logprob": -0.025766237173229456, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.325, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.025766237173229456, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in the crumbling, moss-encrusted ruins of a Gothic temple atop a storm-ravaged mountain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a colossal warrior in jagged obsidian plate armor with glowing crimson runes raising a massive two-handed clay with red energy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a lithe opponent in black leather and a tattered cloak parrying with twin curved daggers that glow brilliantly cyan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the main title text rendered as massive, chiseled stone letters with deep, glowing golden cracks in the center foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the title text slowly fading from transparent to solid opaque while its inner glow intensifies?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016451191157102585 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141451358795166 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016451191157102585, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016451191157102585, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1299423724412918, + 0.08568926900625229, + 0.11117953062057495, + 0.1413079798221588, + 0.17032337188720703, + 0.08916023373603821, + 0.08904741704463959, + 0.041164129972457886, + 0.06094207987189293, + 0.0812436193227768 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016451191157102585 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in the crumbling, moss-encrusted ruins of a Gothic temple atop a storm-ravaged mountain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a colossal warrior in jagged obsidian plate armor with glowing crimson runes raising a massive two-handed clay with red energy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a lithe opponent in black leather and a tattered cloak parrying with twin curved daggers that glow brilliantly cyan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the main title text rendered as massive, chiseled stone letters with deep, glowing golden cracks in the center foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the title text slowly fading from transparent to solid opaque while its inner glow intensifies?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014209168031811714 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264209270477295 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014209168031811714, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014209168031811714, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14663995802402496, + 0.17179441452026367, + 0.13796864449977875, + 0.10407671332359314, + 0.14963200688362122, + 0.048427630215883255, + 0.09886648505926132, + 0.04687869921326637, + 0.02976977825164795, + 0.06594569981098175 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014209168031811714 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in the crumbling, moss-encrusted ruins of a Gothic temple atop a storm-ravaged mountain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a colossal warrior in jagged obsidian plate armor with glowing crimson runes raising a massive two-handed clay with red energy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a lithe opponent in black leather and a tattered cloak parrying with twin curved daggers that glow brilliantly cyan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the main title text rendered as massive, chiseled stone letters with deep, glowing golden cracks in the center foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the title text slowly fading from transparent to solid opaque while its inner glow intensifies?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0031916177831590176 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.7531914710998535 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0031916177831590176, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0031916177831590176, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08950883150100708, + 0.07911313325166702, + 0.20440657436847687, + 0.15839312970638275, + 0.1080475002527237, + 0.06396754831075668, + 0.1453092098236084, + 0.04010031744837761, + 0.04031716287136078, + 0.07083655893802643 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0031916177831590176 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in the crumbling, moss-encrusted ruins of a Gothic temple atop a storm-ravaged mountain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a colossal warrior in jagged obsidian plate armor with glowing crimson runes raising a massive two-handed clay with red energy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a lithe opponent in black leather and a tattered cloak parrying with twin curved daggers that glow brilliantly cyan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the main title text rendered as massive, chiseled stone letters with deep, glowing golden cracks in the center foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the title text slowly fading from transparent to solid opaque while its inner glow intensifies?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005948578007519245 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130948543548584 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005948578007519245, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005948578007519245, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05998779833316803, + 0.06703323125839233, + 0.12093465030193329, + 0.052320461720228195, + 0.2451595813035965, + 0.09696785360574722, + 0.11894945800304413, + 0.041269417852163315, + 0.11351265013217926, + 0.08386494219303131 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 2, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005948578007519245 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in the crumbling, moss-encrusted ruins of a Gothic temple atop a storm-ravaged mountain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a colossal warrior in jagged obsidian plate armor with glowing crimson runes raising a massive two-handed clay with red energy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a lithe opponent in black leather and a tattered cloak parrying with twin curved daggers that glow brilliantly cyan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the main title text rendered as massive, chiseled stone letters with deep, glowing golden cracks in the center foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the title text slowly fading from transparent to solid opaque while its inner glow intensifies?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08903063088655472 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4640307426452637 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08903063088655472, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08903063088655472, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06856773048639297, + 0.02883610688149929, + 0.17382417619228363, + 0.06445065885782242, + 0.06097527593374252, + 0.09409965574741364, + 0.19168563187122345, + 0.10802782326936722, + 0.15883569419384003, + 0.05069722980260849 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 2, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08903063088655472 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, perfectly composed wide-angle shot captures the dramatic video game title screen, rendered in a surreal, painterly digital art style. In the background, amid the crumbling, moss-encrusted ruins of a Gothic temple atop a storm-ravaged mountain, two stylized warriors freeze in a climactic duel. One warrior, a colossal figure clad in jagged obsidian plate armor inscribed with faintly glowing crimson runes, raises a massive two-handed clay with a crackle of red energy, caught mid-swing in a display of overwhelming force. Their opponent, a lithe, agile warrior clad in tight black leather and a flowing, tattered cloak, deftly parries the blow with twin curved daggers that glow brilliantly cyan, their bodies contorting into dynamic defensive poses. Intermittent flashes of lightning from a turbulent, deep purple sky illuminate the scene, creating a stark black-and-white contrast between their armor and the rain-slicked stone floor, casting deep shadows and sharp highlights. In the foreground, the main title text, occupying center of the screen, is rendered as massive, chiseled stone letters with deep, glowing golden cracks, slowly and majestically fading from view, transitioning from completely transparent to solid opaque as its inner glow intensifies, establishing the epic, high-stakes atmosphere of the upcoming adventure.", + "seed": 149, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_11/index_6009_seed_149_dp_22_rank_44_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.07287743790075182, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07287743790075182, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.6, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07287743790075182, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in the crumbling, moss-encrusted ruins of a Gothic temple atop a storm-ravaged mountain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a colossal warrior in jagged obsidian plate armor with glowing crimson runes raising a massive two-handed clay with red energy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a lithe opponent in black leather and a tattered cloak parrying with twin curved daggers that glow brilliantly cyan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the main title text rendered as massive, chiseled stone letters with deep, glowing golden cracks in the center foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the title text slowly fading from transparent to solid opaque while its inner glow intensifies?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04384217783808708 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168842077255249 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04384217783808708, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04384217783808708, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1873207837343216, + 0.091370590031147, + 0.1245117038488388, + 0.08970123529434204, + 0.06348583847284317, + 0.02060147374868393, + 0.10835309326648712, + 0.09208809584379196, + 0.08916928619146347, + 0.1333979070186615 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04384217783808708 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in the crumbling, moss-encrusted ruins of a Gothic temple atop a storm-ravaged mountain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a colossal warrior in jagged obsidian plate armor with glowing crimson runes raising a massive two-handed clay with red energy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a lithe opponent in black leather and a tattered cloak parrying with twin curved daggers that glow brilliantly cyan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the main title text rendered as massive, chiseled stone letters with deep, glowing golden cracks in the center foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the title text slowly fading from transparent to solid opaque while its inner glow intensifies?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026356877759099007 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513569355010986 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026356877759099007, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026356877759099007, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.26091888546943665, + 0.0845491886138916, + 0.0814502164721489, + 0.06122653931379318, + 0.05848732963204384, + 0.07944519817829132, + 0.15081284940242767, + 0.06781579554080963, + 0.05370226502418518, + 0.10159167647361755 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026356877759099007 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in the crumbling, moss-encrusted ruins of a Gothic temple atop a storm-ravaged mountain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a colossal warrior in jagged obsidian plate armor with glowing crimson runes raising a massive two-handed clay with red energy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a lithe opponent in black leather and a tattered cloak parrying with twin curved daggers that glow brilliantly cyan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the main title text rendered as massive, chiseled stone letters with deep, glowing golden cracks in the center foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the title text slowly fading from transparent to solid opaque while its inner glow intensifies?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007622915785759687 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882622718811035 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007622915785759687, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007622915785759687, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2586171627044678, + 0.069859080016613, + 0.05709611251950264, + 0.06797653436660767, + 0.04146280884742737, + 0.039000254124403, + 0.18933002650737762, + 0.0619933046400547, + 0.08227483928203583, + 0.1323898285627365 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007622915785759687 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in the crumbling, moss-encrusted ruins of a Gothic temple atop a storm-ravaged mountain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a colossal warrior in jagged obsidian plate armor with glowing crimson runes raising a massive two-handed clay with red energy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a lithe opponent in black leather and a tattered cloak parrying with twin curved daggers that glow brilliantly cyan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the main title text rendered as massive, chiseled stone letters with deep, glowing golden cracks in the center foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the title text slowly fading from transparent to solid opaque while its inner glow intensifies?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005253676325082779 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255253791809082 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005253676325082779, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005253676325082779, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09168802201747894, + 0.0374305322766304, + 0.035206083208322525, + 0.04297367483377457, + 0.025204973295331, + 0.03799710422754288, + 0.17062760889530182, + 0.12769131362438202, + 0.07821229100227356, + 0.35296833515167236 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005253676325082779 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in the crumbling, moss-encrusted ruins of a Gothic temple atop a storm-ravaged mountain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a colossal warrior in jagged obsidian plate armor with glowing crimson runes raising a massive two-handed clay with red energy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a lithe opponent in black leather and a tattered cloak parrying with twin curved daggers that glow brilliantly cyan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the main title text rendered as massive, chiseled stone letters with deep, glowing golden cracks in the center foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the title text slowly fading from transparent to solid opaque while its inner glow intensifies?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2813115417957306 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4063115119934082 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2813115417957306, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2813115417957306, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.086126908659935, + 0.02797982469201088, + 0.05958811193704605, + 0.0635971799492836, + 0.03244578838348389, + 0.056218646466732025, + 0.43878376483917236, + 0.15220095217227936, + 0.05050796642899513, + 0.0325508788228035 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2813115417957306 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, perfectly composed wide-angle shot captures the dramatic video game title screen, rendered in a surreal, painterly digital art style. In the background, amid the crumbling, moss-encrusted ruins of a Gothic temple atop a storm-ravaged mountain, two stylized warriors freeze in a climactic duel. One warrior, a colossal figure clad in jagged obsidian plate armor inscribed with faintly glowing crimson runes, raises a massive two-handed clay with a crackle of red energy, caught mid-swing in a display of overwhelming force. Their opponent, a lithe, agile warrior clad in tight black leather and a flowing, tattered cloak, deftly parries the blow with twin curved daggers that glow brilliantly cyan, their bodies contorting into dynamic defensive poses. Intermittent flashes of lightning from a turbulent, deep purple sky illuminate the scene, creating a stark black-and-white contrast between their armor and the rain-slicked stone floor, casting deep shadows and sharp highlights. In the foreground, the main title text, occupying center of the screen, is rendered as massive, chiseled stone letters with deep, glowing golden cracks, slowly and majestically fading from view, transitioning from completely transparent to solid opaque as its inner glow intensifies, establishing the epic, high-stakes atmosphere of the upcoming adventure.", + "seed": 150, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_11/index_6009_seed_150_dp_23_rank_46_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.05800215471535921, + "vlm_logprob": -0.05800215471535921, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.8, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.05800215471535921, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in the crumbling, moss-encrusted ruins of a Gothic temple atop a storm-ravaged mountain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a colossal warrior in jagged obsidian plate armor with glowing crimson runes raising a massive two-handed clay with red energy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a lithe opponent in black leather and a tattered cloak parrying with twin curved daggers that glow brilliantly cyan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the main title text rendered as massive, chiseled stone letters with deep, glowing golden cracks in the center foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the title text slowly fading from transparent to solid opaque while its inner glow intensifies?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03426443785429001 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.409264326095581 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03426443785429001, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03426443785429001, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2573855519294739, + 0.08266734331846237, + 0.052719976752996445, + 0.13700374960899353, + 0.17150183022022247, + 0.03067958913743496, + 0.04509314149618149, + 0.04984363913536072, + 0.089054174721241, + 0.08405101299285889 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03426443785429001 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in the crumbling, moss-encrusted ruins of a Gothic temple atop a storm-ravaged mountain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a colossal warrior in jagged obsidian plate armor with glowing crimson runes raising a massive two-handed clay with red energy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a lithe opponent in black leather and a tattered cloak parrying with twin curved daggers that glow brilliantly cyan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the main title text rendered as massive, chiseled stone letters with deep, glowing golden cracks in the center foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the title text slowly fading from transparent to solid opaque while its inner glow intensifies?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018203692510724068 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.0182037353515625 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018203692510724068, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018203692510724068, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2883806526660919, + 0.12528061866760254, + 0.08072920888662338, + 0.19665922224521637, + 0.14055576920509338, + 0.03772956132888794, + 0.028385868296027184, + 0.01989978551864624, + 0.028892124071717262, + 0.05348718911409378 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018203692510724068 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in the crumbling, moss-encrusted ruins of a Gothic temple atop a storm-ravaged mountain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a colossal warrior in jagged obsidian plate armor with glowing crimson runes raising a massive two-handed clay with red energy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a lithe opponent in black leather and a tattered cloak parrying with twin curved daggers that glow brilliantly cyan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the main title text rendered as massive, chiseled stone letters with deep, glowing golden cracks in the center foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the title text slowly fading from transparent to solid opaque while its inner glow intensifies?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006734176073223352 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006734371185303 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006734176073223352, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006734176073223352, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2871304452419281, + 0.0544000044465065, + 0.0866921991109848, + 0.13727322220802307, + 0.170596644282341, + 0.02449822798371315, + 0.022316375747323036, + 0.01921769790351391, + 0.044040825217962265, + 0.15383434295654297 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006734176073223352 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in the crumbling, moss-encrusted ruins of a Gothic temple atop a storm-ravaged mountain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a colossal warrior in jagged obsidian plate armor with glowing crimson runes raising a massive two-handed clay with red energy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a lithe opponent in black leather and a tattered cloak parrying with twin curved daggers that glow brilliantly cyan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the main title text rendered as massive, chiseled stone letters with deep, glowing golden cracks in the center foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the title text slowly fading from transparent to solid opaque while its inner glow intensifies?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005254269111901522 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.25525426864624 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005254269111901522, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005254269111901522, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13249312341213226, + 0.07675699144601822, + 0.039887357503175735, + 0.11159766465425491, + 0.3651235103607178, + 0.061911195516586304, + 0.04836086556315422, + 0.028593366965651512, + 0.04707795009016991, + 0.08819801360368729 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005254269111901522 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in the crumbling, moss-encrusted ruins of a Gothic temple atop a storm-ravaged mountain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a colossal warrior in jagged obsidian plate armor with glowing crimson runes raising a massive two-handed clay with red energy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a lithe opponent in black leather and a tattered cloak parrying with twin curved daggers that glow brilliantly cyan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the main title text rendered as massive, chiseled stone letters with deep, glowing golden cracks in the center foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the title text slowly fading from transparent to solid opaque while its inner glow intensifies?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2255541980266571 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6005542278289795 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2255541980266571, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2255541980266571, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19579467177391052, + 0.048258621245622635, + 0.03850962966680527, + 0.14728137850761414, + 0.32608500123023987, + 0.023725459352135658, + 0.05185321718454361, + 0.014494921080768108, + 0.10240504890680313, + 0.05159207060933113 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2255541980266571 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, perfectly composed wide-angle shot captures the dramatic video game title screen, rendered in a surreal, painterly digital art style. In the background, amid the crumbling, moss-encrusted ruins of a Gothic temple atop a storm-ravaged mountain, two stylized warriors freeze in a climactic duel. One warrior, a colossal figure clad in jagged obsidian plate armor inscribed with faintly glowing crimson runes, raises a massive two-handed clay with a crackle of red energy, caught mid-swing in a display of overwhelming force. Their opponent, a lithe, agile warrior clad in tight black leather and a flowing, tattered cloak, deftly parries the blow with twin curved daggers that glow brilliantly cyan, their bodies contorting into dynamic defensive poses. Intermittent flashes of lightning from a turbulent, deep purple sky illuminate the scene, creating a stark black-and-white contrast between their armor and the rain-slicked stone floor, casting deep shadows and sharp highlights. In the foreground, the main title text, occupying center of the screen, is rendered as massive, chiseled stone letters with deep, glowing golden cracks, slowly and majestically fading from view, transitioning from completely transparent to solid opaque as its inner glow intensifies, establishing the epic, high-stakes atmosphere of the upcoming adventure.", + "seed": 151, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_11/index_6009_seed_151_dp_23_rank_46_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.06253034486435353, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06253034486435353, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.05, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06253034486435353, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in the crumbling, moss-encrusted ruins of a Gothic temple atop a storm-ravaged mountain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a colossal warrior in jagged obsidian plate armor with glowing crimson runes raising a massive two-handed clay with red energy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a lithe opponent in black leather and a tattered cloak parrying with twin curved daggers that glow brilliantly cyan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the main title text rendered as massive, chiseled stone letters with deep, glowing golden cracks in the center foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the title text slowly fading from transparent to solid opaque while its inner glow intensifies?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0438586100935936 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168858528137207 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0438586100935936, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0438586100935936, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1798659712076187, + 0.06044977903366089, + 0.02619086392223835, + 0.028614038601517677, + 0.047081805765628815, + 0.011124257929623127, + 0.014500077813863754, + 0.04717309772968292, + 0.0629018247127533, + 0.5220983028411865 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0438586100935936 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in the crumbling, moss-encrusted ruins of a Gothic temple atop a storm-ravaged mountain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a colossal warrior in jagged obsidian plate armor with glowing crimson runes raising a massive two-handed clay with red energy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a lithe opponent in black leather and a tattered cloak parrying with twin curved daggers that glow brilliantly cyan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the main title text rendered as massive, chiseled stone letters with deep, glowing golden cracks in the center foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the title text slowly fading from transparent to solid opaque while its inner glow intensifies?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008655649609863758 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758655548095703 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008655649609863758, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008655649609863758, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18360662460327148, + 0.03298287093639374, + 0.029833080247044563, + 0.025053953751921654, + 0.024387670680880547, + 0.011807323433458805, + 0.019645191729068756, + 0.051756422966718674, + 0.03622055426239967, + 0.5847063064575195 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008655649609863758 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in the crumbling, moss-encrusted ruins of a Gothic temple atop a storm-ravaged mountain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a colossal warrior in jagged obsidian plate armor with glowing crimson runes raising a massive two-handed clay with red energy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a lithe opponent in black leather and a tattered cloak parrying with twin curved daggers that glow brilliantly cyan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the main title text rendered as massive, chiseled stone letters with deep, glowing golden cracks in the center foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the title text slowly fading from transparent to solid opaque while its inner glow intensifies?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005247865337878466 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255248069763184 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005247865337878466, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005247865337878466, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4446606934070587, + 0.05086841806769371, + 0.021394893527030945, + 0.0315282866358757, + 0.049175091087818146, + 0.040602702647447586, + 0.032171983271837234, + 0.046682294458150864, + 0.04183908551931381, + 0.2410765290260315 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005247865337878466 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in the crumbling, moss-encrusted ruins of a Gothic temple atop a storm-ravaged mountain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a colossal warrior in jagged obsidian plate armor with glowing crimson runes raising a massive two-handed clay with red energy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a lithe opponent in black leather and a tattered cloak parrying with twin curved daggers that glow brilliantly cyan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the main title text rendered as massive, chiseled stone letters with deep, glowing golden cracks in the center foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the title text slowly fading from transparent to solid opaque while its inner glow intensifies?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002817115979269147 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877817153930664 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002817115979269147, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002817115979269147, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07354159653186798, + 0.020429786294698715, + 0.012615076266229153, + 0.016392922028899193, + 0.03299422934651375, + 0.012541084550321102, + 0.017396394163370132, + 0.0428624264895916, + 0.08184872567653656, + 0.6893778443336487 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002817115979269147 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in the crumbling, moss-encrusted ruins of a Gothic temple atop a storm-ravaged mountain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a colossal warrior in jagged obsidian plate armor with glowing crimson runes raising a massive two-handed clay with red energy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a lithe opponent in black leather and a tattered cloak parrying with twin curved daggers that glow brilliantly cyan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the main title text rendered as massive, chiseled stone letters with deep, glowing golden cracks in the center foreground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the title text slowly fading from transparent to solid opaque while its inner glow intensifies?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2520724833011627 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5020724534988403 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2520724833011627, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2520724833011627, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0711122378706932, + 0.08761885017156601, + 0.026690976694226265, + 0.09460487961769104, + 0.0963258221745491, + 0.026216836646199226, + 0.033729489892721176, + 0.16214852035045624, + 0.09166821837425232, + 0.3098842203617096 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2520724833011627 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_12/index_tensor([1011, 1011])_group_12_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_12/index_tensor([1011, 1011])_group_12_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..702c3d8977cf960d65b6109d86c1f1b946d354cf --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_12/index_tensor([1011, 1011])_group_12_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "high-angle drone shot slowly zooms out and tilts slightly downward, overlooking a lake as calm as a mirror, shrouded in morning mist. A soft, diffuse light penetrates the mist, casting a hazy glow over the deep emerald green surface, creating a cool, serene atmosphere. Several traditional, dark-wooden, varnished rowboats glide silently toward the center from different corners of the frame. Each boat is driven by a single boatman in a simple linen shirt. Their steady and deliberate strokes leave long, almost imperceptible V-shaped ripples on the smooth water. As the camera slowly retreats, the boats' paths gracefully intersect, their steady pace gradually approaching, eventually forming a loose, circular cluster in the center of the lake. The boats gently come to rest, and the boatmen sit back, their oars drawn. The scene evokes an almost meditative tranquility and harmony, as if time has stood still.", + "seed": 12178, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_12/index_1011_seed_12178_dp_24_rank_48_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.12491503106430173, + "vlm_logprob": -0.12491503106430173, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.675, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.12491503106430173, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a high-angle drone perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly zoom out and tilt slightly downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are several traditional dark-wooden varnished rowboats visible gliding on the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is each boat driven by a single boatman wearing a simple linen shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the boats form a loose circular cluster in the center of the lake before coming to rest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20030057430267334 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8253005743026733 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20030057430267334, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20030057430267334, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08208008855581284, + 0.03304572030901909, + 0.030424591153860092, + 0.030373457819223404, + 0.10439267009496689, + 0.14642520248889923, + 0.21288728713989258, + 0.15463285148143768, + 0.17922315001487732, + 0.02651500701904297 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20030057430267334 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a high-angle drone perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly zoom out and tilt slightly downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are several traditional dark-wooden varnished rowboats visible gliding on the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is each boat driven by a single boatman wearing a simple linen shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the boats form a loose circular cluster in the center of the lake before coming to rest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2016209065914154 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7016209363937378 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2016209065914154, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2016209065914154, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09936246275901794, + 0.0490536130964756, + 0.07336454838514328, + 0.15597178041934967, + 0.08933977037668228, + 0.09687689691781998, + 0.16640855371952057, + 0.0756869837641716, + 0.07570020854473114, + 0.11823520809412003 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2016209065914154 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a high-angle drone perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly zoom out and tilt slightly downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are several traditional dark-wooden varnished rowboats visible gliding on the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is each boat driven by a single boatman wearing a simple linen shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the boats form a loose circular cluster in the center of the lake before coming to rest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004647406283766031 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379647254943848 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004647406283766031, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004647406283766031, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.051684681326150894, + 0.08051048964262009, + 0.0374017134308815, + 0.12306934595108032, + 0.06580712646245956, + 0.10762989521026611, + 0.405669629573822, + 0.06953978538513184, + 0.034531574696302414, + 0.02415575087070465 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004647406283766031 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a high-angle drone perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly zoom out and tilt slightly downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are several traditional dark-wooden varnished rowboats visible gliding on the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is each boat driven by a single boatman wearing a simple linen shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the boats form a loose circular cluster in the center of the lake before coming to rest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03813046216964722 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288130521774292 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03813046216964722, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03813046216964722, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17293524742126465, + 0.08373086154460907, + 0.03467811271548271, + 0.2046852558851242, + 0.06850488483905792, + 0.07383278757333755, + 0.13462890684604645, + 0.12148340791463852, + 0.0322258397936821, + 0.07329471409320831 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03813046216964722 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a high-angle drone perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly zoom out and tilt slightly downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are several traditional dark-wooden varnished rowboats visible gliding on the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is each boat driven by a single boatman wearing a simple linen shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the boats form a loose circular cluster in the center of the lake before coming to rest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17987580597400665 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8048758506774902 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17987580597400665, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17987580597400665, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0722820982336998, + 0.09117080271244049, + 0.1084865853190422, + 0.30312126874923706, + 0.0790828987956047, + 0.03786343336105347, + 0.0626136064529419, + 0.07562288641929626, + 0.04186144098639488, + 0.1278950423002243 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17987580597400665 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "high-angle drone shot slowly zooms out and tilts slightly downward, overlooking a lake as calm as a mirror, shrouded in morning mist. A soft, diffuse light penetrates the mist, casting a hazy glow over the deep emerald green surface, creating a cool, serene atmosphere. Several traditional, dark-wooden, varnished rowboats glide silently toward the center from different corners of the frame. Each boat is driven by a single boatman in a simple linen shirt. Their steady and deliberate strokes leave long, almost imperceptible V-shaped ripples on the smooth water. As the camera slowly retreats, the boats' paths gracefully intersect, their steady pace gradually approaching, eventually forming a loose, circular cluster in the center of the lake. The boats gently come to rest, and the boatmen sit back, their oars drawn. The scene evokes an almost meditative tranquility and harmony, as if time has stood still.", + "seed": 12179, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_12/index_1011_seed_12179_dp_24_rank_48_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.08785659116692841, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08785659116692841, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.075, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08785659116692841, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a high-angle drone perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly zoom out and tilt slightly downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are several traditional dark-wooden varnished rowboats visible gliding on the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is each boat driven by a single boatman wearing a simple linen shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the boats form a loose circular cluster in the center of the lake before coming to rest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12971095740795135 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2547109127044678 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12971095740795135, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12971095740795135, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.077987901866436, + 0.6037545204162598, + 0.05297703668475151, + 0.04832322150468826, + 0.040019020438194275, + 0.039936237037181854, + 0.04336310550570488, + 0.02775086648762226, + 0.02848028764128685, + 0.03740774840116501 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12971095740795135 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a high-angle drone perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly zoom out and tilt slightly downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are several traditional dark-wooden varnished rowboats visible gliding on the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is each boat driven by a single boatman wearing a simple linen shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the boats form a loose circular cluster in the center of the lake before coming to rest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17992182075977325 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8049218654632568 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17992182075977325, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17992182075977325, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04389731585979462, + 0.11291073262691498, + 0.0328463539481163, + 0.046780917793512344, + 0.028455473482608795, + 0.5621657371520996, + 0.08149963617324829, + 0.031691957265138626, + 0.027863571420311928, + 0.03188828006386757 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17992182075977325 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a high-angle drone perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly zoom out and tilt slightly downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are several traditional dark-wooden varnished rowboats visible gliding on the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is each boat driven by a single boatman wearing a simple linen shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the boats form a loose circular cluster in the center of the lake before coming to rest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0024968183133751154 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002496719360352 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0024968183133751154, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0024968183133751154, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10869082808494568, + 0.3904072046279907, + 0.08637526631355286, + 0.11820021271705627, + 0.05697913095355034, + 0.05978163331747055, + 0.06786532700061798, + 0.02837148867547512, + 0.03471551463007927, + 0.04861339181661606 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0024968183133751154 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a high-angle drone perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly zoom out and tilt slightly downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are several traditional dark-wooden varnished rowboats visible gliding on the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is each boat driven by a single boatman wearing a simple linen shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the boats form a loose circular cluster in the center of the lake before coming to rest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03813505172729492 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288135051727295 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03813505172729492, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03813505172729492, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2015722393989563, + 0.08084172010421753, + 0.14194637537002563, + 0.13471515476703644, + 0.06809110939502716, + 0.06232263892889023, + 0.07383593171834946, + 0.06444970518350601, + 0.08880366384983063, + 0.08342139422893524 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03813505172729492 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a high-angle drone perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly zoom out and tilt slightly downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are several traditional dark-wooden varnished rowboats visible gliding on the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is each boat driven by a single boatman wearing a simple linen shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the boats form a loose circular cluster in the center of the lake before coming to rest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0890183076262474 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4640183448791504 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0890183076262474, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0890183076262474, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04017253965139389, + 0.06105417758226395, + 0.050680745393037796, + 0.12286806851625443, + 0.09708333760499954, + 0.4133034646511078, + 0.05102769657969475, + 0.059965480118989944, + 0.07523892819881439, + 0.028605611994862556 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0890183076262474 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "high-angle drone shot slowly zooms out and tilts slightly downward, overlooking a lake as calm as a mirror, shrouded in morning mist. A soft, diffuse light penetrates the mist, casting a hazy glow over the deep emerald green surface, creating a cool, serene atmosphere. Several traditional, dark-wooden, varnished rowboats glide silently toward the center from different corners of the frame. Each boat is driven by a single boatman in a simple linen shirt. Their steady and deliberate strokes leave long, almost imperceptible V-shaped ripples on the smooth water. As the camera slowly retreats, the boats' paths gracefully intersect, their steady pace gradually approaching, eventually forming a loose, circular cluster in the center of the lake. The boats gently come to rest, and the boatmen sit back, their oars drawn. The scene evokes an almost meditative tranquility and harmony, as if time has stood still.", + "seed": 12180, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_12/index_1011_seed_12180_dp_25_rank_50_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.10038531264290214, + "vlm_logprob": -0.10038531264290214, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.825, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.10038531264290214, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a high-angle drone perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly zoom out and tilt slightly downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are several traditional dark-wooden varnished rowboats visible gliding on the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is each boat driven by a single boatman wearing a simple linen shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the boats form a loose circular cluster in the center of the lake before coming to rest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22167275846004486 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.721672773361206 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.22167275846004486, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.22167275846004486, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18313123285770416, + 0.029390955343842506, + 0.11841887980699539, + 0.04708358272910118, + 0.043718449771404266, + 0.1336866319179535, + 0.3289332985877991, + 0.04114677384495735, + 0.03756185248494148, + 0.03692834451794624 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.22167275846004486 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a high-angle drone perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly zoom out and tilt slightly downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are several traditional dark-wooden varnished rowboats visible gliding on the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is each boat driven by a single boatman wearing a simple linen shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the boats form a loose circular cluster in the center of the lake before coming to rest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14287258684635162 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0178725719451904 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14287258684635162, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14287258684635162, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10349957644939423, + 0.0582677386701107, + 0.2376527488231659, + 0.07020305097103119, + 0.055929068475961685, + 0.07950255274772644, + 0.29675328731536865, + 0.048956092447042465, + 0.02592902071774006, + 0.023306867107748985 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14287258684635162 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a high-angle drone perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly zoom out and tilt slightly downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are several traditional dark-wooden varnished rowboats visible gliding on the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is each boat driven by a single boatman wearing a simple linen shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the boats form a loose circular cluster in the center of the lake before coming to rest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005264348816126585 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.2552642822265625 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005264348816126585, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005264348816126585, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10800696164369583, + 0.027711959555745125, + 0.04554137587547302, + 0.1974519044160843, + 0.04155556112527847, + 0.1328611969947815, + 0.35060518980026245, + 0.049694061279296875, + 0.018313460052013397, + 0.02825825847685337 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005264348816126585 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a high-angle drone perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly zoom out and tilt slightly downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are several traditional dark-wooden varnished rowboats visible gliding on the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is each boat driven by a single boatman wearing a simple linen shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the boats form a loose circular cluster in the center of the lake before coming to rest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04309365898370743 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168093681335449 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04309365898370743, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04309365898370743, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13268733024597168, + 0.04891607165336609, + 0.16762229800224304, + 0.1182192713022232, + 0.05784488841891289, + 0.16974397003650665, + 0.1540791094303131, + 0.0854141116142273, + 0.03547835722565651, + 0.02999466471374035 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 2, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04309365898370743 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a high-angle drone perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly zoom out and tilt slightly downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are several traditional dark-wooden varnished rowboats visible gliding on the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is each boat driven by a single boatman wearing a simple linen shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the boats form a loose circular cluster in the center of the lake before coming to rest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08902321010828018 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4640231132507324 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08902321010828018, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08902321010828018, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09951517730951309, + 0.025304988026618958, + 0.14003711938858032, + 0.055122487246990204, + 0.040879588574171066, + 0.07450198382139206, + 0.3145696222782135, + 0.14386552572250366, + 0.05389438569545746, + 0.05230912193655968 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08902321010828018 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "high-angle drone shot slowly zooms out and tilts slightly downward, overlooking a lake as calm as a mirror, shrouded in morning mist. A soft, diffuse light penetrates the mist, casting a hazy glow over the deep emerald green surface, creating a cool, serene atmosphere. Several traditional, dark-wooden, varnished rowboats glide silently toward the center from different corners of the frame. Each boat is driven by a single boatman in a simple linen shirt. Their steady and deliberate strokes leave long, almost imperceptible V-shaped ripples on the smooth water. As the camera slowly retreats, the boats' paths gracefully intersect, their steady pace gradually approaching, eventually forming a loose, circular cluster in the center of the lake. The boats gently come to rest, and the boatmen sit back, their oars drawn. The scene evokes an almost meditative tranquility and harmony, as if time has stood still.", + "seed": 12181, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_12/index_1011_seed_12181_dp_25_rank_50_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.07100748252123594, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07100748252123594, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.05, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07100748252123594, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a high-angle drone perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly zoom out and tilt slightly downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are several traditional dark-wooden varnished rowboats visible gliding on the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is each boat driven by a single boatman wearing a simple linen shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the boats form a loose circular cluster in the center of the lake before coming to rest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07930763065814972 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.7043075561523438 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07930763065814972, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07930763065814972, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10075318813323975, + 0.14230842888355255, + 0.040706995874643326, + 0.05222085863351822, + 0.09756152331829071, + 0.02718379721045494, + 0.08682488650083542, + 0.316091388463974, + 0.0724683627486229, + 0.06388057768344879 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07930763065814972 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a high-angle drone perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly zoom out and tilt slightly downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are several traditional dark-wooden varnished rowboats visible gliding on the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is each boat driven by a single boatman wearing a simple linen shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the boats form a loose circular cluster in the center of the lake before coming to rest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12708333134651184 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1270833015441895 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12708333134651184, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12708333134651184, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04193945601582527, + 0.1659902036190033, + 0.03310802951455116, + 0.048942312598228455, + 0.03265545889735222, + 0.02720274217426777, + 0.13001690804958344, + 0.3527970612049103, + 0.0938718244433403, + 0.07347598671913147 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12708333134651184 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a high-angle drone perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly zoom out and tilt slightly downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are several traditional dark-wooden varnished rowboats visible gliding on the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is each boat driven by a single boatman wearing a simple linen shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the boats form a loose circular cluster in the center of the lake before coming to rest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005258775316178799 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255258560180664 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005258775316178799, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005258775316178799, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07310818880796432, + 0.42471691966056824, + 0.05985727161169052, + 0.053147733211517334, + 0.03056042268872261, + 0.02948075532913208, + 0.032881300896406174, + 0.18312318623065948, + 0.04221317917108536, + 0.07091102004051208 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005258775316178799 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a high-angle drone perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly zoom out and tilt slightly downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are several traditional dark-wooden varnished rowboats visible gliding on the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is each boat driven by a single boatman wearing a simple linen shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the boats form a loose circular cluster in the center of the lake before coming to rest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04309331625699997 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168093204498291 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04309331625699997, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04309331625699997, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08428546786308289, + 0.34434714913368225, + 0.03169042989611626, + 0.04577811807394028, + 0.020462751388549805, + 0.030094128102064133, + 0.04426214471459389, + 0.30528026819229126, + 0.030092813074588776, + 0.06370674073696136 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04309331625699997 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a high-angle drone perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly zoom out and tilt slightly downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are several traditional dark-wooden varnished rowboats visible gliding on the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is each boat driven by a single boatman wearing a simple linen shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the boats form a loose circular cluster in the center of the lake before coming to rest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10029435902833939 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.350294351577759 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10029435902833939, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10029435902833939, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17513589560985565, + 0.4232581853866577, + 0.0386764295399189, + 0.036165423691272736, + 0.034120310097932816, + 0.018781553953886032, + 0.06259533017873764, + 0.06469685584306717, + 0.07801473885774612, + 0.06855528801679611 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10029435902833939 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_13/index_tensor([6878, 6878])_group_13_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_13/index_tensor([6878, 6878])_group_13_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..96911685e7469c7182dd22ac96be24e7487d89ed --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_13/index_tensor([6878, 6878])_group_13_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "In a slow-motion close-up, bathed in warm, vintage hues, an antique mahogany chest, its dark wood surface marred by minute scratches and a patina of age, is gently tilted. As the chest's opening descends, a pile of yellowed letters and dried flower petals begin to fall from it with a gentle, almost weightless grace. The camera tilts gently downward, following these fragments of memory. Some letters remain neatly folded in their cream-colored envelopes, while others, unfolded, flutter and turn gracefully in mid-air, briefly revealing elegant, faded cursive handwriting. Deep red and pale pink rose petals, dry and translucent, intertwine with the letters, drifting like a silent rain onto the polished dark wood floor below. A soft beam of afternoon sunlight slants in from outside the frame, piercing the swirling dust in the air and illuminating the delicate veins of the petals and the yellowed edges of the paper, casting long, soft shadows and creating a dreamlike atmosphere of deep tranquility and nostalgia.", + "seed": 12189, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_13/index_6878_seed_12189_dp_26_rank_52_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.01469940603710711, + "vlm_logprob": -0.01469940603710711, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.625, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.01469940603710711, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an antique mahogany chest with a dark wood surface showing scratches and patina?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do yellowed letters and dried flower petals fall from the chest's opening with a gentle, weightless motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are some of the falling letters in cream-colored envelopes while others are unfolded revealing faded cursive handwriting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include deep red and pale pink dry rose petals drifting onto a polished dark wood floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera tilting gently downward to follow the falling fragments while the scene is bathed in warm vintage hues with a soft beam of sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.043423015624284744 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1684229373931885 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.043423015624284744, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.043423015624284744, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.40851348638534546, + 0.18930383026599884, + 0.08004078269004822, + 0.07977834343910217, + 0.08449996262788773, + 0.04304788261651993, + 0.050333235412836075, + 0.031891267746686935, + 0.01915568672120571, + 0.013435585424304008 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.043423015624284744 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an antique mahogany chest with a dark wood surface showing scratches and patina?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do yellowed letters and dried flower petals fall from the chest's opening with a gentle, weightless motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are some of the falling letters in cream-colored envelopes while others are unfolded revealing faded cursive handwriting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include deep red and pale pink dry rose petals drifting onto a polished dark wood floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera tilting gently downward to follow the falling fragments while the scene is bathed in warm vintage hues with a soft beam of sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005269922316074371 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255270004272461 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005269922316074371, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005269922316074371, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.29399749636650085, + 0.10495880246162415, + 0.11161623150110245, + 0.1001797616481781, + 0.07792382687330246, + 0.045169439166784286, + 0.10170574486255646, + 0.08434174954891205, + 0.04653143137693405, + 0.03357553854584694 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005269922316074371 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an antique mahogany chest with a dark wood surface showing scratches and patina?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do yellowed letters and dried flower petals fall from the chest's opening with a gentle, weightless motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are some of the falling letters in cream-colored envelopes while others are unfolded revealing faded cursive handwriting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include deep red and pale pink dry rose petals drifting onto a polished dark wood floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera tilting gently downward to follow the falling fragments while the scene is bathed in warm vintage hues with a soft beam of sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012548773549497128 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387548923492432 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012548773549497128, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012548773549497128, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.34705373644828796, + 0.14994944632053375, + 0.12565875053405762, + 0.035204339772462845, + 0.11466608941555023, + 0.04468201473355293, + 0.12404029816389084, + 0.02557731606066227, + 0.014668218791484833, + 0.018499761819839478 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012548773549497128 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an antique mahogany chest with a dark wood surface showing scratches and patina?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do yellowed letters and dried flower petals fall from the chest's opening with a gentle, weightless motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are some of the falling letters in cream-colored envelopes while others are unfolded revealing faded cursive handwriting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include deep red and pale pink dry rose petals drifting onto a polished dark wood floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera tilting gently downward to follow the falling fragments while the scene is bathed in warm vintage hues with a soft beam of sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036143234465271235 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.62861442565918 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036143234465271235, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036143234465271235, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15833386778831482, + 0.10606500506401062, + 0.057766303420066833, + 0.0672934353351593, + 0.09894663095474243, + 0.1703086942434311, + 0.09477616101503372, + 0.13057780265808105, + 0.0662764385342598, + 0.04965566098690033 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036143234465271235 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an antique mahogany chest with a dark wood surface showing scratches and patina?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do yellowed letters and dried flower petals fall from the chest's opening with a gentle, weightless motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are some of the falling letters in cream-colored envelopes while others are unfolded revealing faded cursive handwriting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include deep red and pale pink dry rose petals drifting onto a polished dark wood floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera tilting gently downward to follow the falling fragments while the scene is bathed in warm vintage hues with a soft beam of sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008640995249152184 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758640766143799 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008640995249152184, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008640995249152184, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2037784308195114, + 0.11651555448770523, + 0.13780346512794495, + 0.12276992201805115, + 0.20055048167705536, + 0.055653657764196396, + 0.0557757206261158, + 0.05706251785159111, + 0.027748312801122665, + 0.022341961041092873 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008640995249152184 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a slow-motion close-up, bathed in warm, vintage hues, an antique mahogany chest, its dark wood surface marred by minute scratches and a patina of age, is gently tilted. As the chest's opening descends, a pile of yellowed letters and dried flower petals begin to fall from it with a gentle, almost weightless grace. The camera tilts gently downward, following these fragments of memory. Some letters remain neatly folded in their cream-colored envelopes, while others, unfolded, flutter and turn gracefully in mid-air, briefly revealing elegant, faded cursive handwriting. Deep red and pale pink rose petals, dry and translucent, intertwine with the letters, drifting like a silent rain onto the polished dark wood floor below. A soft beam of afternoon sunlight slants in from outside the frame, piercing the swirling dust in the air and illuminating the delicate veins of the petals and the yellowed edges of the paper, casting long, soft shadows and creating a dreamlike atmosphere of deep tranquility and nostalgia.", + "seed": 12190, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_13/index_6878_seed_12190_dp_26_rank_52_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.00877614519558847, + "vlm_logprob": -0.00877614519558847, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.9, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.00877614519558847, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an antique mahogany chest with a dark wood surface showing scratches and patina?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do yellowed letters and dried flower petals fall from the chest's opening with a gentle, weightless motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are some of the falling letters in cream-colored envelopes while others are unfolded revealing faded cursive handwriting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include deep red and pale pink dry rose petals drifting onto a polished dark wood floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera tilting gently downward to follow the falling fragments while the scene is bathed in warm vintage hues with a soft beam of sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012822323478758335 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387822151184082 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012822323478758335, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012822323478758335, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25991085171699524, + 0.14485099911689758, + 0.12296564877033234, + 0.02535763382911682, + 0.0489005446434021, + 0.09925622493028641, + 0.09486634284257889, + 0.11611024290323257, + 0.013196777552366257, + 0.07458476722240448 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012822323478758335 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an antique mahogany chest with a dark wood surface showing scratches and patina?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do yellowed letters and dried flower petals fall from the chest's opening with a gentle, weightless motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are some of the falling letters in cream-colored envelopes while others are unfolded revealing faded cursive handwriting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include deep red and pale pink dry rose petals drifting onto a polished dark wood floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera tilting gently downward to follow the falling fragments while the scene is bathed in warm vintage hues with a soft beam of sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007641371339559555 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882641315460205 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007641371339559555, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007641371339559555, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2542203962802887, + 0.08063434809446335, + 0.10597062110900879, + 0.14397646486759186, + 0.07924006879329681, + 0.11245712637901306, + 0.07724402099847794, + 0.020343918353319168, + 0.054814912378787994, + 0.07109809666872025 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007641371339559555 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an antique mahogany chest with a dark wood surface showing scratches and patina?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do yellowed letters and dried flower petals fall from the chest's opening with a gentle, weightless motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are some of the falling letters in cream-colored envelopes while others are unfolded revealing faded cursive handwriting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include deep red and pale pink dry rose petals drifting onto a polished dark wood floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera tilting gently downward to follow the falling fragments while the scene is bathed in warm vintage hues with a soft beam of sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006737728603184223 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.00673770904541 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006737728603184223, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006737728603184223, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1836233139038086, + 0.10915936529636383, + 0.14266812801361084, + 0.031057612970471382, + 0.09313321113586426, + 0.06875621527433395, + 0.044689491391181946, + 0.023061225190758705, + 0.1223626583814621, + 0.1814887672662735 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006737728603184223 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an antique mahogany chest with a dark wood surface showing scratches and patina?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do yellowed letters and dried flower petals fall from the chest's opening with a gentle, weightless motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are some of the falling letters in cream-colored envelopes while others are unfolded revealing faded cursive handwriting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include deep red and pale pink dry rose petals drifting onto a polished dark wood floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera tilting gently downward to follow the falling fragments while the scene is bathed in warm vintage hues with a soft beam of sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0024862352292984724 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002486228942871 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0024862352292984724, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0024862352292984724, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09489091485738754, + 0.10986007750034332, + 0.07692424952983856, + 0.022776423022150993, + 0.04913553595542908, + 0.13516809046268463, + 0.3246617615222931, + 0.023318491876125336, + 0.07406202703714371, + 0.08920247852802277 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0024862352292984724 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an antique mahogany chest with a dark wood surface showing scratches and patina?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do yellowed letters and dried flower petals fall from the chest's opening with a gentle, weightless motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are some of the falling letters in cream-colored envelopes while others are unfolded revealing faded cursive handwriting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include deep red and pale pink dry rose petals drifting onto a polished dark wood floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera tilting gently downward to follow the falling fragments while the scene is bathed in warm vintage hues with a soft beam of sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014193067327141762 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264193058013916 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014193067327141762, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014193067327141762, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.26975029706954956, + 0.06772604584693909, + 0.24528196454048157, + 0.08360978215932846, + 0.045586150139570236, + 0.03846918046474457, + 0.08717431873083115, + 0.05603710189461708, + 0.04666333645582199, + 0.05970179662108421 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014193067327141762 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a slow-motion close-up, bathed in warm, vintage hues, an antique mahogany chest, its dark wood surface marred by minute scratches and a patina of age, is gently tilted. As the chest's opening descends, a pile of yellowed letters and dried flower petals begin to fall from it with a gentle, almost weightless grace. The camera tilts gently downward, following these fragments of memory. Some letters remain neatly folded in their cream-colored envelopes, while others, unfolded, flutter and turn gracefully in mid-air, briefly revealing elegant, faded cursive handwriting. Deep red and pale pink rose petals, dry and translucent, intertwine with the letters, drifting like a silent rain onto the polished dark wood floor below. A soft beam of afternoon sunlight slants in from outside the frame, piercing the swirling dust in the air and illuminating the delicate veins of the petals and the yellowed edges of the paper, casting long, soft shadows and creating a dreamlike atmosphere of deep tranquility and nostalgia.", + "seed": 12191, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_13/index_6878_seed_12191_dp_27_rank_54_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.01776601322926581, + "vlm_logprob": -0.01776601322926581, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.725, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.01776601322926581, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an antique mahogany chest with a dark wood surface showing scratches and patina?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do yellowed letters and dried flower petals fall from the chest's opening with a gentle, weightless motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are some of the falling letters in cream-colored envelopes while others are unfolded revealing faded cursive handwriting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include deep red and pale pink dry rose petals drifting onto a polished dark wood floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera tilting gently downward to follow the falling fragments while the scene is bathed in warm vintage hues with a soft beam of sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.062356676906347275 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.81235671043396 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.062356676906347275, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.062356676906347275, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3799270689487457, + 0.05230712890625, + 0.17189417779445648, + 0.15796802937984467, + 0.06728225946426392, + 0.042563509196043015, + 0.05513032525777817, + 0.021768199279904366, + 0.02631109394133091, + 0.024848101660609245 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.062356676906347275 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an antique mahogany chest with a dark wood surface showing scratches and patina?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do yellowed letters and dried flower petals fall from the chest's opening with a gentle, weightless motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are some of the falling letters in cream-colored envelopes while others are unfolded revealing faded cursive handwriting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include deep red and pale pink dry rose petals drifting onto a polished dark wood floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera tilting gently downward to follow the falling fragments while the scene is bathed in warm vintage hues with a soft beam of sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0041077290661633015 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.50410795211792 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0041077290661633015, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0041077290661633015, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20029102265834808, + 0.10932893306016922, + 0.17698466777801514, + 0.03685373067855835, + 0.07329916954040527, + 0.04198718070983887, + 0.21620281040668488, + 0.04661855474114418, + 0.04676053673028946, + 0.05167339742183685 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0041077290661633015 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an antique mahogany chest with a dark wood surface showing scratches and patina?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do yellowed letters and dried flower petals fall from the chest's opening with a gentle, weightless motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are some of the falling letters in cream-colored envelopes while others are unfolded revealing faded cursive handwriting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include deep red and pale pink dry rose petals drifting onto a polished dark wood floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera tilting gently downward to follow the falling fragments while the scene is bathed in warm vintage hues with a soft beam of sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007633563131093979 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882633686065674 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007633563131093979, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007633563131093979, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1955806314945221, + 0.10060806572437286, + 0.1947564035654068, + 0.17675893008708954, + 0.0759364441037178, + 0.033240824937820435, + 0.08948734402656555, + 0.037235211580991745, + 0.061497513204813004, + 0.03489863499999046 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007633563131093979 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an antique mahogany chest with a dark wood surface showing scratches and patina?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do yellowed letters and dried flower petals fall from the chest's opening with a gentle, weightless motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are some of the falling letters in cream-colored envelopes while others are unfolded revealing faded cursive handwriting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include deep red and pale pink dry rose petals drifting onto a polished dark wood floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera tilting gently downward to follow the falling fragments while the scene is bathed in warm vintage hues with a soft beam of sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00219533103518188 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127195358276367 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00219533103518188, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00219533103518188, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2886546552181244, + 0.0740317851305008, + 0.1179719865322113, + 0.04970574751496315, + 0.03944465145468712, + 0.040433984249830246, + 0.21800068020820618, + 0.04144376143813133, + 0.063931405544281, + 0.06638134270906448 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00219533103518188 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an antique mahogany chest with a dark wood surface showing scratches and patina?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do yellowed letters and dried flower petals fall from the chest's opening with a gentle, weightless motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are some of the falling letters in cream-colored envelopes while others are unfolded revealing faded cursive handwriting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include deep red and pale pink dry rose petals drifting onto a polished dark wood floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera tilting gently downward to follow the falling fragments while the scene is bathed in warm vintage hues with a soft beam of sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01253676600754261 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387537002563477 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01253676600754261, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01253676600754261, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3099604845046997, + 0.08084350824356079, + 0.05253706872463226, + 0.07634218782186508, + 0.028495650738477707, + 0.06360741704702377, + 0.2800920009613037, + 0.036337900906801224, + 0.03263833746314049, + 0.039145439863204956 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01253676600754261 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a slow-motion close-up, bathed in warm, vintage hues, an antique mahogany chest, its dark wood surface marred by minute scratches and a patina of age, is gently tilted. As the chest's opening descends, a pile of yellowed letters and dried flower petals begin to fall from it with a gentle, almost weightless grace. The camera tilts gently downward, following these fragments of memory. Some letters remain neatly folded in their cream-colored envelopes, while others, unfolded, flutter and turn gracefully in mid-air, briefly revealing elegant, faded cursive handwriting. Deep red and pale pink rose petals, dry and translucent, intertwine with the letters, drifting like a silent rain onto the polished dark wood floor below. A soft beam of afternoon sunlight slants in from outside the frame, piercing the swirling dust in the air and illuminating the delicate veins of the petals and the yellowed edges of the paper, casting long, soft shadows and creating a dreamlike atmosphere of deep tranquility and nostalgia.", + "seed": 12192, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_13/index_6878_seed_12192_dp_27_rank_54_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.017320812121033667, + "vlm_logprob": -0.017320812121033667, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.7, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.017320812121033667, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an antique mahogany chest with a dark wood surface showing scratches and patina?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do yellowed letters and dried flower petals fall from the chest's opening with a gentle, weightless motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are some of the falling letters in cream-colored envelopes while others are unfolded revealing faded cursive handwriting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include deep red and pale pink dry rose petals drifting onto a polished dark wood floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera tilting gently downward to follow the falling fragments while the scene is bathed in warm vintage hues with a soft beam of sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06236182898283005 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812361717224121 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06236182898283005, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06236182898283005, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21964144706726074, + 0.08122341334819794, + 0.08298416435718536, + 0.1600634753704071, + 0.13456366956233978, + 0.06917034834623337, + 0.0860561802983284, + 0.04568111151456833, + 0.05123959481716156, + 0.0693766176700592 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06236182898283005 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an antique mahogany chest with a dark wood surface showing scratches and patina?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do yellowed letters and dried flower petals fall from the chest's opening with a gentle, weightless motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are some of the falling letters in cream-colored envelopes while others are unfolded revealing faded cursive handwriting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include deep red and pale pink dry rose petals drifting onto a polished dark wood floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera tilting gently downward to follow the falling fragments while the scene is bathed in warm vintage hues with a soft beam of sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004106779582798481 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.5041069984436035 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004106779582798481, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004106779582798481, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16346120834350586, + 0.07420768588781357, + 0.11632947623729706, + 0.1389104127883911, + 0.05330916866660118, + 0.03721103072166443, + 0.08851908147335052, + 0.07098814100027084, + 0.11067809164524078, + 0.14638574421405792 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004106779582798481 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an antique mahogany chest with a dark wood surface showing scratches and patina?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do yellowed letters and dried flower petals fall from the chest's opening with a gentle, weightless motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are some of the falling letters in cream-colored envelopes while others are unfolded revealing faded cursive handwriting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include deep red and pale pink dry rose petals drifting onto a polished dark wood floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera tilting gently downward to follow the falling fragments while the scene is bathed in warm vintage hues with a soft beam of sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009786129929125309 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634786128997803 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009786129929125309, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009786129929125309, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06850357353687286, + 0.037368930876255035, + 0.049765605479478836, + 0.09392686933279037, + 0.05737188830971718, + 0.07411506772041321, + 0.3737807869911194, + 0.045450981706380844, + 0.13891449570655823, + 0.060801807790994644 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009786129929125309 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an antique mahogany chest with a dark wood surface showing scratches and patina?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do yellowed letters and dried flower petals fall from the chest's opening with a gentle, weightless motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are some of the falling letters in cream-colored envelopes while others are unfolded revealing faded cursive handwriting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include deep red and pale pink dry rose petals drifting onto a polished dark wood floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera tilting gently downward to follow the falling fragments while the scene is bathed in warm vintage hues with a soft beam of sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036123041063547134 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628612518310547 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036123041063547134, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036123041063547134, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08348343521356583, + 0.05485382303595543, + 0.08788800239562988, + 0.08398864418268204, + 0.07352890819311142, + 0.056583572179079056, + 0.1839444786310196, + 0.04642023146152496, + 0.13618263602256775, + 0.19312629103660583 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036123041063547134 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an antique mahogany chest with a dark wood surface showing scratches and patina?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do yellowed letters and dried flower petals fall from the chest's opening with a gentle, weightless motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are some of the falling letters in cream-colored envelopes while others are unfolded revealing faded cursive handwriting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include deep red and pale pink dry rose petals drifting onto a polished dark wood floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera tilting gently downward to follow the falling fragments while the scene is bathed in warm vintage hues with a soft beam of sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0067370180040597916 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006737232208252 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0067370180040597916, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0067370180040597916, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07558510452508926, + 0.05189942196011543, + 0.06645695865154266, + 0.11969297379255295, + 0.15678271651268005, + 0.2534942924976349, + 0.14511354267597198, + 0.03191271796822548, + 0.044749967753887177, + 0.054312314838171005 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0067370180040597916 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_14/index_tensor([3883, 3883])_group_14_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_14/index_tensor([3883, 3883])_group_14_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..d3a027fedb5f308d75b7b8850e1e1b2caafe0128 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_14/index_tensor([3883, 3883])_group_14_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "rapid camera cut reveals a dynamic, low-angle tracking shot of a modern sedan with a sleek black metallic finish, which drives decisively and steadily into the entrance of a deep, arched tunnel. Inside, a focused man in his 40s sits at the wheel. His short, meticulously styled dark brown hair is lightly wrinkled on his forehead with concentration, his eyes fixed on the road ahead, his jaw set in a tense line. As the car plunges fully into the tunnel, rows of alternating magenta and cyberpunk blue neon tubes lining the walls instantly cast streams of light onto the car. These rays stretch and distort the car's impeccable paint, forming streaks of color that race backwards, interplaying with the fluid, slick colors reflected from the wet asphalt. The entire scene presents the unique hyperrealistic and realistic texture of Octane rendering. The mirror reflection of the car paint, the transparency of the glass, and the flowing light and shadow details on the driver's skin are all clearly visible, creating an immersive atmosphere full of speed, futuristic colors and high tension.", + "seed": 18675, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_14/index_3883_seed_18675_dp_28_rank_56_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.19150345511734485, + "vlm_logprob": -0.19150345511734485, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.15, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.19150345511734485, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a modern sedan with a sleek black metallic finish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle tracking shot that moves with the car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a man in his 40s with short dark brown hair visible sitting at the wheel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are rows of alternating magenta and cyberpunk blue neon tubes visible lining the tunnel walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene exhibit hyperrealistic textures with visible reflections on the car paint and driver's skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11351834237575531 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.238518238067627 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11351834237575531, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11351834237575531, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4184906780719757, + 0.061528414487838745, + 0.10499825328588486, + 0.06588554382324219, + 0.09988594800233841, + 0.08033787459135056, + 0.035197507590055466, + 0.039275143295526505, + 0.05454133823513985, + 0.039859309792518616 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11351834237575531 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a modern sedan with a sleek black metallic finish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle tracking shot that moves with the car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a man in his 40s with short dark brown hair visible sitting at the wheel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are rows of alternating magenta and cyberpunk blue neon tubes visible lining the tunnel walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene exhibit hyperrealistic textures with visible reflections on the car paint and driver's skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026363030076026917 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513631343841553 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026363030076026917, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026363030076026917, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2905634343624115, + 0.08079752326011658, + 0.1062091514468193, + 0.08716832846403122, + 0.1383843868970871, + 0.05838760361075401, + 0.12325923144817352, + 0.04245804250240326, + 0.03752179443836212, + 0.03525048866868019 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026363030076026917 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a modern sedan with a sleek black metallic finish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle tracking shot that moves with the car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a man in his 40s with short dark brown hair visible sitting at the wheel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are rows of alternating magenta and cyberpunk blue neon tubes visible lining the tunnel walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene exhibit hyperrealistic textures with visible reflections on the car paint and driver's skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.313494473695755 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3134944438934326 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.313494473695755, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.313494473695755, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5317325592041016, + 0.0887361690402031, + 0.06021769717335701, + 0.0737135261297226, + 0.08795768022537231, + 0.040777649730443954, + 0.02372201345860958, + 0.020662575960159302, + 0.03503294289112091, + 0.03744712844491005 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.313494473695755 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a modern sedan with a sleek black metallic finish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle tracking shot that moves with the car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a man in his 40s with short dark brown hair visible sitting at the wheel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are rows of alternating magenta and cyberpunk blue neon tubes visible lining the tunnel walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene exhibit hyperrealistic textures with visible reflections on the car paint and driver's skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02980075217783451 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298006534576416 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02980075217783451, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02980075217783451, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.27829882502555847, + 0.0438392236828804, + 0.09063554555177689, + 0.041835904121398926, + 0.1819513738155365, + 0.0338616706430912, + 0.1300821155309677, + 0.09711305052042007, + 0.058846037834882736, + 0.043536227196455 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02980075217783451 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a modern sedan with a sleek black metallic finish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle tracking shot that moves with the car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a man in his 40s with short dark brown hair visible sitting at the wheel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are rows of alternating magenta and cyberpunk blue neon tubes visible lining the tunnel walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene exhibit hyperrealistic textures with visible reflections on the car paint and driver's skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.47434067726135254 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9743406772613525 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.47434067726135254, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.47434067726135254, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22840136289596558, + 0.12329674512147903, + 0.046689461916685104, + 0.15501856803894043, + 0.23624542355537415, + 0.05641155689954758, + 0.05736590549349785, + 0.035470135509967804, + 0.025100216269493103, + 0.03600064665079117 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.47434067726135254 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "rapid camera cut reveals a dynamic, low-angle tracking shot of a modern sedan with a sleek black metallic finish, which drives decisively and steadily into the entrance of a deep, arched tunnel. Inside, a focused man in his 40s sits at the wheel. His short, meticulously styled dark brown hair is lightly wrinkled on his forehead with concentration, his eyes fixed on the road ahead, his jaw set in a tense line. As the car plunges fully into the tunnel, rows of alternating magenta and cyberpunk blue neon tubes lining the walls instantly cast streams of light onto the car. These rays stretch and distort the car's impeccable paint, forming streaks of color that race backwards, interplaying with the fluid, slick colors reflected from the wet asphalt. The entire scene presents the unique hyperrealistic and realistic texture of Octane rendering. The mirror reflection of the car paint, the transparency of the glass, and the flowing light and shadow details on the driver's skin are all clearly visible, creating an immersive atmosphere full of speed, futuristic colors and high tension.", + "seed": 18676, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_14/index_3883_seed_18676_dp_28_rank_56_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.05904354229569435, + "vlm_logprob": -0.05904354229569435, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.95, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.05904354229569435, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a modern sedan with a sleek black metallic finish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle tracking shot that moves with the car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a man in his 40s with short dark brown hair visible sitting at the wheel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are rows of alternating magenta and cyberpunk blue neon tubes visible lining the tunnel walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene exhibit hyperrealistic textures with visible reflections on the car paint and driver's skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06281981617212296 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812819719314575 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06281981617212296, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06281981617212296, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24928216636180878, + 0.07921572029590607, + 0.047188811004161835, + 0.19666610658168793, + 0.07771340757608414, + 0.1693086475133896, + 0.02908271551132202, + 0.04253024235367775, + 0.058463264256715775, + 0.050548914819955826 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06281981617212296 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a modern sedan with a sleek black metallic finish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle tracking shot that moves with the car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a man in his 40s with short dark brown hair visible sitting at the wheel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are rows of alternating magenta and cyberpunk blue neon tubes visible lining the tunnel walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene exhibit hyperrealistic textures with visible reflections on the car paint and driver's skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02981209009885788 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298120975494385 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02981209009885788, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02981209009885788, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19164852797985077, + 0.13319744169712067, + 0.07469138503074646, + 0.09415253251791, + 0.10558170825242996, + 0.06341905146837234, + 0.12137970328330994, + 0.07319750636816025, + 0.10059930384159088, + 0.042132847011089325 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02981209009885788 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a modern sedan with a sleek black metallic finish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle tracking shot that moves with the car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a man in his 40s with short dark brown hair visible sitting at the wheel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are rows of alternating magenta and cyberpunk blue neon tubes visible lining the tunnel walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene exhibit hyperrealistic textures with visible reflections on the car paint and driver's skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10032250732183456 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3503224849700928 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10032250732183456, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10032250732183456, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5341986417770386, + 0.06457634270191193, + 0.04123135283589363, + 0.06295382231473923, + 0.029687289148569107, + 0.028873655945062637, + 0.09756598621606827, + 0.03136199340224266, + 0.07153063267469406, + 0.03802035376429558 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10032250732183456 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a modern sedan with a sleek black metallic finish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle tracking shot that moves with the car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a man in his 40s with short dark brown hair visible sitting at the wheel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are rows of alternating magenta and cyberpunk blue neon tubes visible lining the tunnel walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene exhibit hyperrealistic textures with visible reflections on the car paint and driver's skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02327980473637581 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773279905319214 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02327980473637581, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02327980473637581, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1800028532743454, + 0.07675672322511673, + 0.060482207685709, + 0.1074606329202652, + 0.06807496398687363, + 0.10336591303348541, + 0.22260013222694397, + 0.08306402713060379, + 0.03735606372356415, + 0.06083647534251213 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02327980473637581 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a modern sedan with a sleek black metallic finish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle tracking shot that moves with the car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a man in his 40s with short dark brown hair visible sitting at the wheel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are rows of alternating magenta and cyberpunk blue neon tubes visible lining the tunnel walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene exhibit hyperrealistic textures with visible reflections on the car paint and driver's skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07898349314928055 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5789835453033447 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07898349314928055, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07898349314928055, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.45630374550819397, + 0.11212919652462006, + 0.0465947687625885, + 0.08542428910732269, + 0.07536893337965012, + 0.06586089730262756, + 0.048299290239810944, + 0.03277702257037163, + 0.03930498659610748, + 0.03793685883283615 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07898349314928055 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "rapid camera cut reveals a dynamic, low-angle tracking shot of a modern sedan with a sleek black metallic finish, which drives decisively and steadily into the entrance of a deep, arched tunnel. Inside, a focused man in his 40s sits at the wheel. His short, meticulously styled dark brown hair is lightly wrinkled on his forehead with concentration, his eyes fixed on the road ahead, his jaw set in a tense line. As the car plunges fully into the tunnel, rows of alternating magenta and cyberpunk blue neon tubes lining the walls instantly cast streams of light onto the car. These rays stretch and distort the car's impeccable paint, forming streaks of color that race backwards, interplaying with the fluid, slick colors reflected from the wet asphalt. The entire scene presents the unique hyperrealistic and realistic texture of Octane rendering. The mirror reflection of the car paint, the transparency of the glass, and the flowing light and shadow details on the driver's skin are all clearly visible, creating an immersive atmosphere full of speed, futuristic colors and high tension.", + "seed": 18677, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_14/index_3883_seed_18677_dp_29_rank_58_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.04868747293949127, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04868747293949127, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.1, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04868747293949127, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a modern sedan with a sleek black metallic finish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle tracking shot that moves with the car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a man in his 40s with short dark brown hair visible sitting at the wheel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are rows of alternating magenta and cyberpunk blue neon tubes visible lining the tunnel walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene exhibit hyperrealistic textures with visible reflections on the car paint and driver's skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.027258051559329033 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6522581577301025 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.027258051559329033, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.027258051559329033, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08841673284769058, + 0.052815377712249756, + 0.032601289451122284, + 0.0533396452665329, + 0.20723380148410797, + 0.0711485892534256, + 0.03742225095629692, + 0.07616988569498062, + 0.11218082904815674, + 0.26867154240608215 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.027258051559329033 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a modern sedan with a sleek black metallic finish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle tracking shot that moves with the car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a man in his 40s with short dark brown hair visible sitting at the wheel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are rows of alternating magenta and cyberpunk blue neon tubes visible lining the tunnel walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene exhibit hyperrealistic textures with visible reflections on the car paint and driver's skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029812784865498543 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529812812805176 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029812784865498543, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029812784865498543, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.263357013463974, + 0.0711287334561348, + 0.034111618995666504, + 0.07938382029533386, + 0.1118936762213707, + 0.08172981441020966, + 0.05040665343403816, + 0.12322675436735153, + 0.08390763401985168, + 0.10085424035787582 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029812784865498543 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a modern sedan with a sleek black metallic finish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle tracking shot that moves with the car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a man in his 40s with short dark brown hair visible sitting at the wheel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are rows of alternating magenta and cyberpunk blue neon tubes visible lining the tunnel walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene exhibit hyperrealistic textures with visible reflections on the car paint and driver's skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04866783693432808 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486679077148438 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04866783693432808, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04866783693432808, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22725097835063934, + 0.048966821283102036, + 0.05288420990109444, + 0.08175904303789139, + 0.11930827796459198, + 0.2299259603023529, + 0.08939110487699509, + 0.0534743070602417, + 0.04989591985940933, + 0.0471433661878109 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04866783693432808 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a modern sedan with a sleek black metallic finish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle tracking shot that moves with the car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a man in his 40s with short dark brown hair visible sitting at the wheel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are rows of alternating magenta and cyberpunk blue neon tubes visible lining the tunnel walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene exhibit hyperrealistic textures with visible reflections on the car paint and driver's skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04864603653550148 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486459732055664 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04864603653550148, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04864603653550148, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16803401708602905, + 0.15153063833713531, + 0.04559825733304024, + 0.05999964848160744, + 0.07295609265565872, + 0.09208029508590698, + 0.18318501114845276, + 0.051136668771505356, + 0.101622574031353, + 0.07385683059692383 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04864603653550148 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a modern sedan with a sleek black metallic finish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle tracking shot that moves with the car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a man in his 40s with short dark brown hair visible sitting at the wheel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are rows of alternating magenta and cyberpunk blue neon tubes visible lining the tunnel walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene exhibit hyperrealistic textures with visible reflections on the car paint and driver's skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08905265480279922 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.464052677154541 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08905265480279922, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08905265480279922, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12690864503383636, + 0.08087236434221268, + 0.05532246083021164, + 0.1292078197002411, + 0.20694640278816223, + 0.06819625943899155, + 0.06864869594573975, + 0.1020078957080841, + 0.05609828606247902, + 0.10579118132591248 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08905265480279922 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "rapid camera cut reveals a dynamic, low-angle tracking shot of a modern sedan with a sleek black metallic finish, which drives decisively and steadily into the entrance of a deep, arched tunnel. Inside, a focused man in his 40s sits at the wheel. His short, meticulously styled dark brown hair is lightly wrinkled on his forehead with concentration, his eyes fixed on the road ahead, his jaw set in a tense line. As the car plunges fully into the tunnel, rows of alternating magenta and cyberpunk blue neon tubes lining the walls instantly cast streams of light onto the car. These rays stretch and distort the car's impeccable paint, forming streaks of color that race backwards, interplaying with the fluid, slick colors reflected from the wet asphalt. The entire scene presents the unique hyperrealistic and realistic texture of Octane rendering. The mirror reflection of the car paint, the transparency of the glass, and the flowing light and shadow details on the driver's skin are all clearly visible, creating an immersive atmosphere full of speed, futuristic colors and high tension.", + "seed": 18678, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_14/index_3883_seed_18678_dp_29_rank_58_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.15070557491853834, + "vlm_logprob": -0.15070557491853834, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.6749999642372133, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.15070557491853834, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a modern sedan with a sleek black metallic finish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle tracking shot that moves with the car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a man in his 40s with short dark brown hair visible sitting at the wheel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are rows of alternating magenta and cyberpunk blue neon tubes visible lining the tunnel walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene exhibit hyperrealistic textures with visible reflections on the car paint and driver's skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2524045705795288 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5024045705795288 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2524045705795288, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2524045705795288, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06875303387641907, + 0.02188326232135296, + 0.03764228895306587, + 0.07134537398815155, + 0.0473320372402668, + 0.06085968762636185, + 0.4397766888141632, + 0.08126891404390335, + 0.030274949967861176, + 0.14086373150348663 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2524045705795288 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a modern sedan with a sleek black metallic finish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle tracking shot that moves with the car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a man in his 40s with short dark brown hair visible sitting at the wheel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are rows of alternating magenta and cyberpunk blue neon tubes visible lining the tunnel walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene exhibit hyperrealistic textures with visible reflections on the car paint and driver's skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018198659643530846 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018198490142822 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018198659643530846, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018198659643530846, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09031737595796585, + 0.08508607000112534, + 0.29850658774375916, + 0.114972785115242, + 0.04040154814720154, + 0.037986040115356445, + 0.14518007636070251, + 0.04698127135634422, + 0.04922036454081535, + 0.09134796261787415 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 6, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018198659643530846 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a modern sedan with a sleek black metallic finish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle tracking shot that moves with the car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a man in his 40s with short dark brown hair visible sitting at the wheel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are rows of alternating magenta and cyberpunk blue neon tubes visible lining the tunnel walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene exhibit hyperrealistic textures with visible reflections on the car paint and driver's skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0890643298625946 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.464064359664917 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0890643298625946, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0890643298625946, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03327568992972374, + 0.051354195922613144, + 0.3339107930660248, + 0.01819213479757309, + 0.024678049609065056, + 0.03258092328906059, + 0.2181733250617981, + 0.043343085795640945, + 0.10821346193552017, + 0.13627828657627106 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0890643298625946 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a modern sedan with a sleek black metallic finish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle tracking shot that moves with the car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a man in his 40s with short dark brown hair visible sitting at the wheel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are rows of alternating magenta and cyberpunk blue neon tubes visible lining the tunnel walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene exhibit hyperrealistic textures with visible reflections on the car paint and driver's skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006735597271472216 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006735801696777 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006735597271472216, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006735597271472216, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12465281039476395, + 0.09531987458467484, + 0.14466902613639832, + 0.19657278060913086, + 0.13282153010368347, + 0.046691425144672394, + 0.03537015616893768, + 0.04916032776236534, + 0.08585328608751297, + 0.08888876438140869 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006735597271472216 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a modern sedan with a sleek black metallic finish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle tracking shot that moves with the car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a man in his 40s with short dark brown hair visible sitting at the wheel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are rows of alternating magenta and cyberpunk blue neon tubes visible lining the tunnel walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene exhibit hyperrealistic textures with visible reflections on the car paint and driver's skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3871247172355652 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.13712477684021 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3871247172355652, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.7500000596046448, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3871247172355652, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15246076881885529, + 0.04736275598406792, + 0.13855043053627014, + 0.1656932234764099, + 0.07527818530797958, + 0.03971497714519501, + 0.10686937719583511, + 0.07407243549823761, + 0.05568096786737442, + 0.1443168967962265 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3871247172355652 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_15/index_tensor([6965, 6965])_group_15_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_15/index_tensor([6965, 6965])_group_15_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..9b007ce5bebd6b4b7dd2aac6cd112130f2caa1a1 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_15/index_tensor([6965, 6965])_group_15_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "From a high-angle, wide-angle shot, the camera begins a slow, sweeping arc across a vast circular room, rendered in the style of a hyper-detailed pencil drawing. Fine graphite lines and intricate cross-hatching define the vast, curved stone walls, creating a monochromatic world of varying shades of gray, from pale silver to deep charcoal. In the very center of the room's floor, illuminated by a harsh beam of light from an unseen source above, sits a massive, heavy stone disk. Its rough, weathered surface is covered in intricate occult symbols and \"War of the Two Cities\" geometry, as if deeply etched into the stone by an ancient, powerful force. With a low, grinding sound, the disk begins a steady and deliberate slide, retreating into a perfectly carved groove in the floor. As it moves, it reveals a vast black gap—the opening to a hidden spiral staircase, its stone steps worn smooth by time, descending into the impenetrable darkness below. The camera continues its sweeping, arcing motion, tilting downward to gaze into the void, emphasizing the staircase's profound depths and creating a solemn, awe-inspiring atmosphere of ancient mystery and discovery.", + "seed": 2818, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_15/index_6965_seed_2818_dp_30_rank_60_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.016172598768025636, + "vlm_logprob": -0.016172598768025636, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.425, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.016172598768025636, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in the style of a hyper-detailed pencil drawing with fine graphite lines and cross-hatching?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a vast circular room with curved stone walls featuring varying shades of gray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, heavy stone disk with intricate occult symbols and 'War of the Two Cities' geometry visible in the center of the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the stone disk slide steadily into a carved groove, revealing a black gap leading to a hidden spiral staircase descending into darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a high-angle wide shot and execute a slow, sweeping arc that tilts downward to gaze into the void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.027854250743985176 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6528542041778564 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.027854250743985176, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.027854250743985176, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17880238592624664, + 0.07101823389530182, + 0.060359083116054535, + 0.23283281922340393, + 0.06833247095346451, + 0.07950793951749802, + 0.07080207765102386, + 0.07915075123310089, + 0.07564708590507507, + 0.08354711532592773 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.027854250743985176 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in the style of a hyper-detailed pencil drawing with fine graphite lines and cross-hatching?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a vast circular room with curved stone walls featuring varying shades of gray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, heavy stone disk with intricate occult symbols and 'War of the Two Cities' geometry visible in the center of the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the stone disk slide steadily into a carved groove, revealing a black gap leading to a hidden spiral staircase descending into darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a high-angle wide shot and execute a slow, sweeping arc that tilts downward to gaze into the void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0032007675617933273 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753200531005859 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0032007675617933273, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0032007675617933273, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.126381978392601, + 0.053838785737752914, + 0.07887094467878342, + 0.2348058521747589, + 0.11187858134508133, + 0.10836172848939896, + 0.048256415873765945, + 0.0922057256102562, + 0.038409482687711716, + 0.1069905012845993 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0032007675617933273 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in the style of a hyper-detailed pencil drawing with fine graphite lines and cross-hatching?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a vast circular room with curved stone walls featuring varying shades of gray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, heavy stone disk with intricate occult symbols and 'War of the Two Cities' geometry visible in the center of the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the stone disk slide steadily into a carved groove, revealing a black gap leading to a hidden spiral staircase descending into darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a high-angle wide shot and execute a slow, sweeping arc that tilts downward to gaze into the void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023289471864700317 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773289442062378 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023289471864700317, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023289471864700317, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15596340596675873, + 0.16419623792171478, + 0.06719937920570374, + 0.20501099526882172, + 0.0832107812166214, + 0.07531674206256866, + 0.056622233241796494, + 0.09340447187423706, + 0.03771836683154106, + 0.06135739013552666 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023289471864700317 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in the style of a hyper-detailed pencil drawing with fine graphite lines and cross-hatching?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a vast circular room with curved stone walls featuring varying shades of gray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, heavy stone disk with intricate occult symbols and 'War of the Two Cities' geometry visible in the center of the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the stone disk slide steadily into a carved groove, revealing a black gap leading to a hidden spiral staircase descending into darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a high-angle wide shot and execute a slow, sweeping arc that tilts downward to gaze into the void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0059483409859240055 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130948543548584 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0059483409859240055, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0059483409859240055, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.052294544875621796, + 0.04158533364534378, + 0.05777798965573311, + 0.13213293254375458, + 0.07518656551837921, + 0.10593490302562714, + 0.0995824933052063, + 0.3285985291004181, + 0.04804285988211632, + 0.0588638074696064 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0059483409859240055 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in the style of a hyper-detailed pencil drawing with fine graphite lines and cross-hatching?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a vast circular room with curved stone walls featuring varying shades of gray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, heavy stone disk with intricate occult symbols and 'War of the Two Cities' geometry visible in the center of the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the stone disk slide steadily into a carved groove, revealing a black gap leading to a hidden spiral staircase descending into darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a high-angle wide shot and execute a slow, sweeping arc that tilts downward to gaze into the void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020570162683725357 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955702781677246 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020570162683725357, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020570162683725357, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1332559883594513, + 0.03971139341592789, + 0.053216468542814255, + 0.09768616408109665, + 0.046093061566352844, + 0.12019232660531998, + 0.11712770909070969, + 0.31605973839759827, + 0.058800142258405685, + 0.01785701885819435 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020570162683725357 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "From a high-angle, wide-angle shot, the camera begins a slow, sweeping arc across a vast circular room, rendered in the style of a hyper-detailed pencil drawing. Fine graphite lines and intricate cross-hatching define the vast, curved stone walls, creating a monochromatic world of varying shades of gray, from pale silver to deep charcoal. In the very center of the room's floor, illuminated by a harsh beam of light from an unseen source above, sits a massive, heavy stone disk. Its rough, weathered surface is covered in intricate occult symbols and \"War of the Two Cities\" geometry, as if deeply etched into the stone by an ancient, powerful force. With a low, grinding sound, the disk begins a steady and deliberate slide, retreating into a perfectly carved groove in the floor. As it moves, it reveals a vast black gap—the opening to a hidden spiral staircase, its stone steps worn smooth by time, descending into the impenetrable darkness below. The camera continues its sweeping, arcing motion, tilting downward to gaze into the void, emphasizing the staircase's profound depths and creating a solemn, awe-inspiring atmosphere of ancient mystery and discovery.", + "seed": 2819, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_15/index_6965_seed_2819_dp_30_rank_60_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.06879599820822477, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06879599820822477, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.4, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06879599820822477, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in the style of a hyper-detailed pencil drawing with fine graphite lines and cross-hatching?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a vast circular room with curved stone walls featuring varying shades of gray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, heavy stone disk with intricate occult symbols and 'War of the Two Cities' geometry visible in the center of the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the stone disk slide steadily into a carved groove, revealing a black gap leading to a hidden spiral staircase descending into darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a high-angle wide shot and execute a slow, sweeping arc that tilts downward to gaze into the void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.25322017073631287 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5032202005386353 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.25322017073631287, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.25322017073631287, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.42580363154411316, + 0.08492386341094971, + 0.024944176897406578, + 0.12463919073343277, + 0.04914916306734085, + 0.03219449147582054, + 0.033341601490974426, + 0.06735595315694809, + 0.06050220504403114, + 0.0971456840634346 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.25322017073631287 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in the style of a hyper-detailed pencil drawing with fine graphite lines and cross-hatching?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a vast circular room with curved stone walls featuring varying shades of gray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, heavy stone disk with intricate occult symbols and 'War of the Two Cities' geometry visible in the center of the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the stone disk slide steadily into a carved groove, revealing a black gap leading to a hidden spiral staircase descending into darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a high-angle wide shot and execute a slow, sweeping arc that tilts downward to gaze into the void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014220803044736385 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264220714569092 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014220803044736385, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014220803044736385, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.27446937561035156, + 0.11495088785886765, + 0.025829415768384933, + 0.07825643569231033, + 0.2036021202802658, + 0.09980214387178421, + 0.035855136811733246, + 0.019456710666418076, + 0.05128845199942589, + 0.09648934006690979 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014220803044736385 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in the style of a hyper-detailed pencil drawing with fine graphite lines and cross-hatching?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a vast circular room with curved stone walls featuring varying shades of gray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, heavy stone disk with intricate occult symbols and 'War of the Two Cities' geometry visible in the center of the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the stone disk slide steadily into a carved groove, revealing a black gap leading to a hidden spiral staircase descending into darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a high-angle wide shot and execute a slow, sweeping arc that tilts downward to gaze into the void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029805496335029602 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298054218292236 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029805496335029602, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029805496335029602, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.26614922285079956, + 0.04827089607715607, + 0.061170246452093124, + 0.18634745478630066, + 0.18116018176078796, + 0.0686170756816864, + 0.029452819377183914, + 0.03302275389432907, + 0.03799949213862419, + 0.08780988305807114 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029805496335029602 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in the style of a hyper-detailed pencil drawing with fine graphite lines and cross-hatching?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a vast circular room with curved stone walls featuring varying shades of gray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, heavy stone disk with intricate occult symbols and 'War of the Two Cities' geometry visible in the center of the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the stone disk slide steadily into a carved groove, revealing a black gap leading to a hidden spiral staircase descending into darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a high-angle wide shot and execute a slow, sweeping arc that tilts downward to gaze into the void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008642531931400299 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758642673492432 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008642531931400299, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008642531931400299, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22461381554603577, + 0.022793984040617943, + 0.026577206328511238, + 0.06907906383275986, + 0.4551587998867035, + 0.015580140054225922, + 0.02965637855231762, + 0.05062771961092949, + 0.06007181853055954, + 0.04584107920527458 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008642531931400299 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in the style of a hyper-detailed pencil drawing with fine graphite lines and cross-hatching?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a vast circular room with curved stone walls featuring varying shades of gray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, heavy stone disk with intricate occult symbols and 'War of the Two Cities' geometry visible in the center of the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the stone disk slide steadily into a carved groove, revealing a black gap leading to a hidden spiral staircase descending into darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a high-angle wide shot and execute a slow, sweeping arc that tilts downward to gaze into the void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.038090988993644714 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288090944290161 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.038090988993644714, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.038090988993644714, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4123937487602234, + 0.05495544895529747, + 0.03666721284389496, + 0.13512131571769714, + 0.1339569240808487, + 0.10413850843906403, + 0.031069595366716385, + 0.04515964165329933, + 0.028002146631479263, + 0.018535438925027847 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.038090988993644714 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "From a high-angle, wide-angle shot, the camera begins a slow, sweeping arc across a vast circular room, rendered in the style of a hyper-detailed pencil drawing. Fine graphite lines and intricate cross-hatching define the vast, curved stone walls, creating a monochromatic world of varying shades of gray, from pale silver to deep charcoal. In the very center of the room's floor, illuminated by a harsh beam of light from an unseen source above, sits a massive, heavy stone disk. Its rough, weathered surface is covered in intricate occult symbols and \"War of the Two Cities\" geometry, as if deeply etched into the stone by an ancient, powerful force. With a low, grinding sound, the disk begins a steady and deliberate slide, retreating into a perfectly carved groove in the floor. As it moves, it reveals a vast black gap—the opening to a hidden spiral staircase, its stone steps worn smooth by time, descending into the impenetrable darkness below. The camera continues its sweeping, arcing motion, tilting downward to gaze into the void, emphasizing the staircase's profound depths and creating a solemn, awe-inspiring atmosphere of ancient mystery and discovery.", + "seed": 2820, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_15/index_6965_seed_2820_dp_31_rank_62_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.11076684184372425, + "vlm_logprob": -0.11076684184372425, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.3, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.11076684184372425, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in the style of a hyper-detailed pencil drawing with fine graphite lines and cross-hatching?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a vast circular room with curved stone walls featuring varying shades of gray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, heavy stone disk with intricate occult symbols and 'War of the Two Cities' geometry visible in the center of the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the stone disk slide steadily into a carved groove, revealing a black gap leading to a hidden spiral staircase descending into darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a high-angle wide shot and execute a slow, sweeping arc that tilts downward to gaze into the void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.09047172963619232 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4654717445373535 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.09047172963619232, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.09047172963619232, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11912774294614792, + 0.07430621236562729, + 0.20710816979408264, + 0.036720629781484604, + 0.054671213030815125, + 0.10562275350093842, + 0.04806778207421303, + 0.07799837738275528, + 0.0821792259812355, + 0.19419793784618378 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.09047172963619232 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in the style of a hyper-detailed pencil drawing with fine graphite lines and cross-hatching?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a vast circular room with curved stone walls featuring varying shades of gray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, heavy stone disk with intricate occult symbols and 'War of the Two Cities' geometry visible in the center of the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the stone disk slide steadily into a carved groove, revealing a black gap leading to a hidden spiral staircase descending into darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a high-angle wide shot and execute a slow, sweeping arc that tilts downward to gaze into the void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008642885833978653 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758642673492432 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008642885833978653, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008642885833978653, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07462169975042343, + 0.06323572248220444, + 0.4014556109905243, + 0.05264690890908241, + 0.037876345217227936, + 0.03722217306494713, + 0.03172307461500168, + 0.15662020444869995, + 0.09744452685117722, + 0.04715374484658241 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008642885833978653 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in the style of a hyper-detailed pencil drawing with fine graphite lines and cross-hatching?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a vast circular room with curved stone walls featuring varying shades of gray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, heavy stone disk with intricate occult symbols and 'War of the Two Cities' geometry visible in the center of the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the stone disk slide steadily into a carved groove, revealing a black gap leading to a hidden spiral staircase descending into darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a high-angle wide shot and execute a slow, sweeping arc that tilts downward to gaze into the void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.428876131772995 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.0538761615753174 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.428876131772995, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.428876131772995, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19930997490882874, + 0.05427151173353195, + 0.12168549001216888, + 0.12852869927883148, + 0.07584413141012192, + 0.0709516853094101, + 0.053827621042728424, + 0.08518437296152115, + 0.09539104253053665, + 0.11500544846057892 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.428876131772995 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in the style of a hyper-detailed pencil drawing with fine graphite lines and cross-hatching?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a vast circular room with curved stone walls featuring varying shades of gray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, heavy stone disk with intricate occult symbols and 'War of the Two Cities' geometry visible in the center of the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the stone disk slide steadily into a carved groove, revealing a black gap leading to a hidden spiral staircase descending into darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a high-angle wide shot and execute a slow, sweeping arc that tilts downward to gaze into the void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00978483073413372 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634784698486328 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00978483073413372, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00978483073413372, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14275670051574707, + 0.09693589806556702, + 0.1980227530002594, + 0.06771057099103928, + 0.07658632844686508, + 0.17141811549663544, + 0.043360140174627304, + 0.10272970050573349, + 0.0372517928481102, + 0.06322798877954483 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00978483073413372 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in the style of a hyper-detailed pencil drawing with fine graphite lines and cross-hatching?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a vast circular room with curved stone walls featuring varying shades of gray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, heavy stone disk with intricate occult symbols and 'War of the Two Cities' geometry visible in the center of the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the stone disk slide steadily into a carved groove, revealing a black gap leading to a hidden spiral staircase descending into darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a high-angle wide shot and execute a slow, sweeping arc that tilts downward to gaze into the void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016058631241321564 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141058444976807 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016058631241321564, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016058631241321564, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15597644448280334, + 0.10211088508367538, + 0.12558434903621674, + 0.057953376322984695, + 0.12939126789569855, + 0.12445945292711258, + 0.056164227426052094, + 0.09814245998859406, + 0.1348949521780014, + 0.015322619117796421 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016058631241321564 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "From a high-angle, wide-angle shot, the camera begins a slow, sweeping arc across a vast circular room, rendered in the style of a hyper-detailed pencil drawing. Fine graphite lines and intricate cross-hatching define the vast, curved stone walls, creating a monochromatic world of varying shades of gray, from pale silver to deep charcoal. In the very center of the room's floor, illuminated by a harsh beam of light from an unseen source above, sits a massive, heavy stone disk. Its rough, weathered surface is covered in intricate occult symbols and \"War of the Two Cities\" geometry, as if deeply etched into the stone by an ancient, powerful force. With a low, grinding sound, the disk begins a steady and deliberate slide, retreating into a perfectly carved groove in the floor. As it moves, it reveals a vast black gap—the opening to a hidden spiral staircase, its stone steps worn smooth by time, descending into the impenetrable darkness below. The camera continues its sweeping, arcing motion, tilting downward to gaze into the void, emphasizing the staircase's profound depths and creating a solemn, awe-inspiring atmosphere of ancient mystery and discovery.", + "seed": 2821, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_15/index_6965_seed_2821_dp_31_rank_62_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.03890974102541804, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03890974102541804, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.125, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03890974102541804, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in the style of a hyper-detailed pencil drawing with fine graphite lines and cross-hatching?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a vast circular room with curved stone walls featuring varying shades of gray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, heavy stone disk with intricate occult symbols and 'War of the Two Cities' geometry visible in the center of the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the stone disk slide steadily into a carved groove, revealing a black gap leading to a hidden spiral staircase descending into darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a high-angle wide shot and execute a slow, sweeping arc that tilts downward to gaze into the void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1457245796918869 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0207245349884033 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1457245796918869, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1457245796918869, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2228633165359497, + 0.1909596025943756, + 0.11223078519105911, + 0.07000427693128586, + 0.0811258926987648, + 0.12445307523012161, + 0.062139324843883514, + 0.033113621175289154, + 0.050251130014657974, + 0.05285895988345146 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1457245796918869 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in the style of a hyper-detailed pencil drawing with fine graphite lines and cross-hatching?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a vast circular room with curved stone walls featuring varying shades of gray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, heavy stone disk with intricate occult symbols and 'War of the Two Cities' geometry visible in the center of the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the stone disk slide steadily into a carved groove, revealing a black gap leading to a hidden spiral staircase descending into darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a high-angle wide shot and execute a slow, sweeping arc that tilts downward to gaze into the void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0076469313353300095 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.8826470375061035 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0076469313353300095, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0076469313353300095, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1658049076795578, + 0.1855722963809967, + 0.09149669855833054, + 0.08184485137462616, + 0.07062302529811859, + 0.15168136358261108, + 0.04534277692437172, + 0.05755453184247017, + 0.07359493523836136, + 0.07648458331823349 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0076469313353300095 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in the style of a hyper-detailed pencil drawing with fine graphite lines and cross-hatching?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a vast circular room with curved stone walls featuring varying shades of gray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, heavy stone disk with intricate occult symbols and 'War of the Two Cities' geometry visible in the center of the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the stone disk slide steadily into a carved groove, revealing a black gap leading to a hidden spiral staircase descending into darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a high-angle wide shot and execute a slow, sweeping arc that tilts downward to gaze into the void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006747792940586805 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006747722625732 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006747792940586805, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006747792940586805, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09954603016376495, + 0.1985636055469513, + 0.2691539227962494, + 0.10515449941158295, + 0.06766396015882492, + 0.06284373998641968, + 0.07659569382667542, + 0.03201960399746895, + 0.05253696069121361, + 0.035921987146139145 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006747792940586805 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in the style of a hyper-detailed pencil drawing with fine graphite lines and cross-hatching?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a vast circular room with curved stone walls featuring varying shades of gray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, heavy stone disk with intricate occult symbols and 'War of the Two Cities' geometry visible in the center of the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the stone disk slide steadily into a carved groove, revealing a black gap leading to a hidden spiral staircase descending into darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a high-angle wide shot and execute a slow, sweeping arc that tilts downward to gaze into the void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004642304033041 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379642486572266 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004642304033041, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004642304033041, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10621774196624756, + 0.182962104678154, + 0.0848306193947792, + 0.07580462098121643, + 0.10084721446037292, + 0.16258518397808075, + 0.07558146119117737, + 0.05710874870419502, + 0.08896682411432266, + 0.06509549915790558 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004642304033041 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in the style of a hyper-detailed pencil drawing with fine graphite lines and cross-hatching?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a vast circular room with curved stone walls featuring varying shades of gray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, heavy stone disk with intricate occult symbols and 'War of the Two Cities' geometry visible in the center of the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the stone disk slide steadily into a carved groove, revealing a black gap leading to a hidden spiral staircase descending into darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a high-angle wide shot and execute a slow, sweeping arc that tilts downward to gaze into the void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0297870971262455 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529787063598633 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0297870971262455, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0297870971262455, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12151327729225159, + 0.12434800714254379, + 0.1533963829278946, + 0.08048203587532043, + 0.05315251275897026, + 0.17802707850933075, + 0.07063706964254379, + 0.047904856503009796, + 0.14233452081680298, + 0.028204314410686493 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 2, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0297870971262455 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_2/index_tensor([7646, 7646])_group_2_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_2/index_tensor([7646, 7646])_group_2_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..b5b33e0c3ee581106126835fbcd9dfb3aee13d18 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_2/index_tensor([7646, 7646])_group_2_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "low-angle, long shot, the camera slowly and steadily panning to the left, captures the epic scene of a massive armored train struggling to cross an icy, swiftly flowing river. Clad in a high-contrast black and white palette, the behemoth train's weathered, riveted steel hull reflects a cold sheen under the gloomy sky, its thick, angular armor pockmarked with the scratches and dents of battle. The icy water lashes against its massive metal, surging around its base, stirring up a cloud of white foam. Its massive wheels, half submerged in the water, slowly but powerfully churn the riverbed, each inch of progress seeming to defy the forces of nature. Thick black smoke billows from the train's chimney, then is blown away by the biting wind and merges beneath a thick, oppressive cloud. Despite the slight tremors caused by the impact of the water, its resolute and heavy outline appears unwavering against the desolate background, creating a solemn and oppressive atmosphere that demonstrates the unyielding industrial strength in desperate situations.", + "seed": 16126, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_2/index_7646_seed_16126_dp_4_rank_8_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.0376066155731678, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0376066155731678, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.8499999761581423, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0376066155731678, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle long shot of a massive armored train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera slowly and steadily panning to the left?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the train crossing an icy, swiftly flowing river with water lashing against its base?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a high-contrast black and white palette with thick black smoke billowing from the chimney?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the train's massive wheels half-submerged and churning the riverbed while creating white foam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.025168266147375107 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.9001681804656982 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.025168266147375107, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.025168266147375107, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1477506160736084, + 0.10819984972476959, + 0.1829763501882553, + 0.10170334577560425, + 0.09066512435674667, + 0.12164738029241562, + 0.03204662352800369, + 0.034212253987789154, + 0.044589802622795105, + 0.1362086981534958 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.025168266147375107 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle long shot of a massive armored train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera slowly and steadily panning to the left?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the train crossing an icy, swiftly flowing river with water lashing against its base?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a high-contrast black and white palette with thick black smoke billowing from the chimney?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the train's massive wheels half-submerged and churning the riverbed while creating white foam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12705929577350616 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1270592212677 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12705929577350616, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.9999998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12705929577350616, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13386103510856628, + 0.0794164389371872, + 0.17352108657360077, + 0.09504464268684387, + 0.1509627401828766, + 0.1898881196975708, + 0.030248651280999184, + 0.02855919674038887, + 0.06423453986644745, + 0.05426352471113205 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12705929577350616 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle long shot of a massive armored train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera slowly and steadily panning to the left?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the train crossing an icy, swiftly flowing river with water lashing against its base?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a high-contrast black and white palette with thick black smoke billowing from the chimney?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the train's massive wheels half-submerged and churning the riverbed while creating white foam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011088653467595577 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511088848114014 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011088653467595577, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011088653467595577, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17545369267463684, + 0.14117620885372162, + 0.21066251397132874, + 0.13250036537647247, + 0.11958985775709152, + 0.047662120312452316, + 0.017514731734991074, + 0.04982348531484604, + 0.05633414164185524, + 0.04928285628557205 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011088653467595577 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle long shot of a massive armored train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera slowly and steadily panning to the left?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the train crossing an icy, swiftly flowing river with water lashing against its base?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a high-contrast black and white palette with thick black smoke billowing from the chimney?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the train's massive wheels half-submerged and churning the riverbed while creating white foam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01607704907655716 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141077041625977 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01607704907655716, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01607704907655716, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15122893452644348, + 0.05789095163345337, + 0.12850618362426758, + 0.15358449518680573, + 0.1074967011809349, + 0.04988044127821922, + 0.016720933839678764, + 0.0176082830876112, + 0.2640189230442047, + 0.05306423828005791 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01607704907655716 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle long shot of a massive armored train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera slowly and steadily panning to the left?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the train crossing an icy, swiftly flowing river with water lashing against its base?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a high-contrast black and white palette with thick black smoke billowing from the chimney?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the train's massive wheels half-submerged and churning the riverbed while creating white foam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008639813400804996 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758639812469482 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008639813400804996, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008639813400804996, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1461847573518753, + 0.1840943694114685, + 0.16136647760868073, + 0.11182773858308792, + 0.053745564073324203, + 0.13883242011070251, + 0.01966835930943489, + 0.0598539337515831, + 0.02959425561130047, + 0.09483221918344498 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008639813400804996 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, long shot, the camera slowly and steadily panning to the left, captures the epic scene of a massive armored train struggling to cross an icy, swiftly flowing river. Clad in a high-contrast black and white palette, the behemoth train's weathered, riveted steel hull reflects a cold sheen under the gloomy sky, its thick, angular armor pockmarked with the scratches and dents of battle. The icy water lashes against its massive metal, surging around its base, stirring up a cloud of white foam. Its massive wheels, half submerged in the water, slowly but powerfully churn the riverbed, each inch of progress seeming to defy the forces of nature. Thick black smoke billows from the train's chimney, then is blown away by the biting wind and merges beneath a thick, oppressive cloud. Despite the slight tremors caused by the impact of the water, its resolute and heavy outline appears unwavering against the desolate background, creating a solemn and oppressive atmosphere that demonstrates the unyielding industrial strength in desperate situations.", + "seed": 16127, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_2/index_7646_seed_16127_dp_4_rank_8_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.06943104173988104, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06943104173988104, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.35, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06943104173988104, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle long shot of a massive armored train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera slowly and steadily panning to the left?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the train crossing an icy, swiftly flowing river with water lashing against its base?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a high-contrast black and white palette with thick black smoke billowing from the chimney?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the train's massive wheels half-submerged and churning the riverbed while creating white foam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014248774386942387 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.514248847961426 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014248774386942387, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014248774386942387, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1384030282497406, + 0.15482096374034882, + 0.020314741879701614, + 0.03795982897281647, + 0.05768902599811554, + 0.03364070504903793, + 0.09350761771202087, + 0.2174791842699051, + 0.06655077636241913, + 0.17963410913944244 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014248774386942387 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle long shot of a massive armored train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera slowly and steadily panning to the left?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the train crossing an icy, swiftly flowing river with water lashing against its base?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a high-contrast black and white palette with thick black smoke billowing from the chimney?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the train's massive wheels half-submerged and churning the riverbed while creating white foam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.31343698501586914 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3134369850158691 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.31343698501586914, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.31343698501586914, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15913869440555573, + 0.02568027563393116, + 0.06401058286428452, + 0.10155265033245087, + 0.07942935079336166, + 0.04950523376464844, + 0.02896861545741558, + 0.12337934225797653, + 0.1927994042634964, + 0.17553585767745972 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.31343698501586914 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle long shot of a massive armored train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera slowly and steadily panning to the left?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the train crossing an icy, swiftly flowing river with water lashing against its base?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a high-contrast black and white palette with thick black smoke billowing from the chimney?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the train's massive wheels half-submerged and churning the riverbed while creating white foam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008646194823086262 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758646011352539 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008646194823086262, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008646194823086262, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07658620923757553, + 0.19989775121212006, + 0.066152423620224, + 0.019710125401616096, + 0.10430930554866791, + 0.03287343308329582, + 0.02551943063735962, + 0.1678716242313385, + 0.17596033215522766, + 0.13111940026283264 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008646194823086262 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle long shot of a massive armored train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera slowly and steadily panning to the left?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the train crossing an icy, swiftly flowing river with water lashing against its base?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a high-contrast black and white palette with thick black smoke billowing from the chimney?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the train's massive wheels half-submerged and churning the riverbed while creating white foam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0010445620864629745 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.876044750213623 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0010445620864629745, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0010445620864629745, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06539277732372284, + 0.08303285390138626, + 0.08864261955022812, + 0.039955075830221176, + 0.05677056685090065, + 0.03476880118250847, + 0.04497575759887695, + 0.07763814181089401, + 0.13992498815059662, + 0.3688983619213104 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0010445620864629745 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle long shot of a massive armored train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera slowly and steadily panning to the left?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the train crossing an icy, swiftly flowing river with water lashing against its base?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a high-contrast black and white palette with thick black smoke billowing from the chimney?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the train's massive wheels half-submerged and churning the riverbed while creating white foam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00977869238704443 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.6347784996032715 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00977869238704443, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00977869238704443, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1594172567129135, + 0.17059239745140076, + 0.05988766625523567, + 0.03643389791250229, + 0.06240580230951309, + 0.020614000037312508, + 0.04935488477349281, + 0.15951316058635712, + 0.18026679754257202, + 0.10151416063308716 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00977869238704443 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, long shot, the camera slowly and steadily panning to the left, captures the epic scene of a massive armored train struggling to cross an icy, swiftly flowing river. Clad in a high-contrast black and white palette, the behemoth train's weathered, riveted steel hull reflects a cold sheen under the gloomy sky, its thick, angular armor pockmarked with the scratches and dents of battle. The icy water lashes against its massive metal, surging around its base, stirring up a cloud of white foam. Its massive wheels, half submerged in the water, slowly but powerfully churn the riverbed, each inch of progress seeming to defy the forces of nature. Thick black smoke billows from the train's chimney, then is blown away by the biting wind and merges beneath a thick, oppressive cloud. Despite the slight tremors caused by the impact of the water, its resolute and heavy outline appears unwavering against the desolate background, creating a solemn and oppressive atmosphere that demonstrates the unyielding industrial strength in desperate situations.", + "seed": 16128, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_2/index_7646_seed_16128_dp_5_rank_10_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.02740752974059433, + "vlm_logprob": -0.02740752974059433, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.925, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.02740752974059433, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle long shot of a massive armored train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera slowly and steadily panning to the left?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the train crossing an icy, swiftly flowing river with water lashing against its base?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a high-contrast black and white palette with thick black smoke billowing from the chimney?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the train's massive wheels half-submerged and churning the riverbed while creating white foam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.015331747010350227 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.390331745147705 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.015331747010350227, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.015331747010350227, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3223520517349243, + 0.11625824868679047, + 0.051971398293972015, + 0.08664669096469879, + 0.10479026287794113, + 0.035930488258600235, + 0.07835136353969574, + 0.05634104833006859, + 0.07270645350217819, + 0.07465193420648575 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.015331747010350227 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle long shot of a massive armored train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera slowly and steadily panning to the left?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the train crossing an icy, swiftly flowing river with water lashing against its base?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a high-contrast black and white palette with thick black smoke billowing from the chimney?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the train's massive wheels half-submerged and churning the riverbed while creating white foam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11292105913162231 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2379209995269775 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11292105913162231, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11292105913162231, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3119242787361145, + 0.05740654841065407, + 0.028242064639925957, + 0.08169182389974594, + 0.1256573349237442, + 0.07079046219587326, + 0.043836694210767746, + 0.09923568367958069, + 0.1387810856103897, + 0.042434003204107285 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11292105913162231 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle long shot of a massive armored train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera slowly and steadily panning to the left?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the train crossing an icy, swiftly flowing river with water lashing against its base?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a high-contrast black and white palette with thick black smoke billowing from the chimney?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the train's massive wheels half-submerged and churning the riverbed while creating white foam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0010442048078402877 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.876044273376465 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0010442048078402877, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0010442048078402877, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10291854292154312, + 0.16208136081695557, + 0.1065630167722702, + 0.046374909579753876, + 0.162458136677742, + 0.07186028361320496, + 0.1499985307455063, + 0.08470979332923889, + 0.04461382329463959, + 0.06842153519392014 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0010442048078402877 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle long shot of a massive armored train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera slowly and steadily panning to the left?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the train crossing an icy, swiftly flowing river with water lashing against its base?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a high-contrast black and white palette with thick black smoke billowing from the chimney?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the train's massive wheels half-submerged and churning the riverbed while creating white foam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0024917051196098328 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002491474151611 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0024917051196098328, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0024917051196098328, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.319685697555542, + 0.1519729346036911, + 0.02163795195519924, + 0.09609366208314896, + 0.06919316947460175, + 0.03439733013510704, + 0.04333451762795448, + 0.19620351493358612, + 0.029053466394543648, + 0.03842771798372269 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0024917051196098328 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle long shot of a massive armored train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera slowly and steadily panning to the left?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the train crossing an icy, swiftly flowing river with water lashing against its base?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a high-contrast black and white palette with thick black smoke billowing from the chimney?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the train's massive wheels half-submerged and churning the riverbed while creating white foam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005248932633548975 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.2552490234375 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005248932633548975, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005248932633548975, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1414216309785843, + 0.07210072875022888, + 0.082977294921875, + 0.08282041549682617, + 0.08621197938919067, + 0.0955040231347084, + 0.08449026942253113, + 0.14315159618854523, + 0.13969439268112183, + 0.07162771373987198 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005248932633548975 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, long shot, the camera slowly and steadily panning to the left, captures the epic scene of a massive armored train struggling to cross an icy, swiftly flowing river. Clad in a high-contrast black and white palette, the behemoth train's weathered, riveted steel hull reflects a cold sheen under the gloomy sky, its thick, angular armor pockmarked with the scratches and dents of battle. The icy water lashes against its massive metal, surging around its base, stirring up a cloud of white foam. Its massive wheels, half submerged in the water, slowly but powerfully churn the riverbed, each inch of progress seeming to defy the forces of nature. Thick black smoke billows from the train's chimney, then is blown away by the biting wind and merges beneath a thick, oppressive cloud. Despite the slight tremors caused by the impact of the water, its resolute and heavy outline appears unwavering against the desolate background, creating a solemn and oppressive atmosphere that demonstrates the unyielding industrial strength in desperate situations.", + "seed": 16129, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_2/index_7646_seed_16129_dp_5_rank_10_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.04278985494747758, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04278985494747758, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.35, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04278985494747758, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle long shot of a massive armored train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera slowly and steadily panning to the left?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the train crossing an icy, swiftly flowing river with water lashing against its base?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a high-contrast black and white palette with thick black smoke billowing from the chimney?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the train's massive wheels half-submerged and churning the riverbed while creating white foam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02786259725689888 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.777862548828125 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02786259725689888, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02786259725689888, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1616363525390625, + 0.04924236610531807, + 0.06557974964380264, + 0.09627438336610794, + 0.12249085307121277, + 0.17975251376628876, + 0.027998439967632294, + 0.17456386983394623, + 0.07770395278930664, + 0.04475751519203186 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02786259725689888 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle long shot of a massive armored train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera slowly and steadily panning to the left?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the train crossing an icy, swiftly flowing river with water lashing against its base?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a high-contrast black and white palette with thick black smoke billowing from the chimney?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the train's massive wheels half-submerged and churning the riverbed while creating white foam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16035886108875275 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9103589057922363 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16035886108875275, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16035886108875275, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16466909646987915, + 0.11748889833688736, + 0.16391056776046753, + 0.24704809486865997, + 0.06406468152999878, + 0.07576848566532135, + 0.02314726822078228, + 0.02843439392745495, + 0.06306491792201996, + 0.052403658628463745 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16035886108875275 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle long shot of a massive armored train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera slowly and steadily panning to the left?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the train crossing an icy, swiftly flowing river with water lashing against its base?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a high-contrast black and white palette with thick black smoke billowing from the chimney?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the train's massive wheels half-submerged and churning the riverbed while creating white foam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0010450384579598904 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.876045227050781 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0010450384579598904, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0010450384579598904, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2968737781047821, + 0.0876745879650116, + 0.051979850977659225, + 0.07542633265256882, + 0.04900963976979256, + 0.23723606765270233, + 0.024176280945539474, + 0.06242769584059715, + 0.08832033723592758, + 0.026875419542193413 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0010450384579598904 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle long shot of a massive armored train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera slowly and steadily panning to the left?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the train crossing an icy, swiftly flowing river with water lashing against its base?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a high-contrast black and white palette with thick black smoke billowing from the chimney?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the train's massive wheels half-submerged and churning the riverbed while creating white foam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020590482279658318 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955905437469482 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020590482279658318, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020590482279658318, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16303053498268127, + 0.14335501194000244, + 0.09146477282047272, + 0.1212773248553276, + 0.09042224287986755, + 0.11678696423768997, + 0.04064920172095299, + 0.09511787444353104, + 0.10415441542863846, + 0.03374163806438446 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020590482279658318 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle long shot of a massive armored train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera slowly and steadily panning to the left?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the train crossing an icy, swiftly flowing river with water lashing against its base?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a high-contrast black and white palette with thick black smoke billowing from the chimney?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the train's massive wheels half-submerged and churning the riverbed while creating white foam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004092295654118061 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504092216491699 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004092295654118061, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004092295654118061, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22544781863689423, + 0.10037615895271301, + 0.05910434201359749, + 0.07067213207483292, + 0.07400012761354446, + 0.12561272084712982, + 0.05693059787154198, + 0.14075647294521332, + 0.11138445883989334, + 0.03571523353457451 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004092295654118061 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_3/index_tensor([3017, 3017])_group_3_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_3/index_tensor([3017, 3017])_group_3_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..25d480580c01a9e2e8e01dfbcacfe49154a99a44 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_3/index_tensor([3017, 3017])_group_3_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "striking, high-contrast black-and-white close-up, shot from a slightly upward angle, captures a warrior clad in traditional Japanese samurai armor in slow motion. He wears a helmet adorned with a majestic kuwagata (front standing) and his face is concealed by a menacing menpo (cheek) mask, through which only a piercing, focused gaze can be seen. A strong, dramatic sidelight sculpts the taut muscles of his arms, giving each jet-black metal plate and tightly woven silk cord a distinct texture, reflecting sharp highlights. He is at the apex of a violent swordsmanship swing, his hands tightly gripping a gleaming katana. The blade slices through the air with lightning speed, leaving a blurred, deadly arc of silver light against the pure, profound darkness. As his body twists, the plates of his armor collide and rub against each other, and the dust stirred up by his feet floats and dances in the beam of light. The whole picture is full of primitive power and solidified dynamic beauty, creating a tense, focused and highly ritualistic battle atmosphere.", + "seed": 26073, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_3/index_3017_seed_26073_dp_6_rank_12_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.17050628912693355, + "vlm_logprob": -0.17050628912693355, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.9, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.17050628912693355, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video presented in black and white with high contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a warrior wearing traditional Japanese samurai armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior performing a violent swordsmanship swing with a katana?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a close-up from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a strong sidelight creating sharp highlights on the armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003853991162031889 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.878853797912598 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003853991162031889, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003853991162031889, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.045686274766922, + 0.018078427761793137, + 0.030503366142511368, + 0.01668686419725418, + 0.041520170867443085, + 0.027414632961153984, + 0.017021896317601204, + 0.6074144840240479, + 0.07888509333133698, + 0.11678881198167801 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003853991162031889 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video presented in black and white with high contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a warrior wearing traditional Japanese samurai armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior performing a violent swordsmanship swing with a katana?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a close-up from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a strong sidelight creating sharp highlights on the armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018193742260336876 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.01819372177124 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018193742260336876, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018193742260336876, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2904517948627472, + 0.09845297783613205, + 0.06714673340320587, + 0.027716225013136864, + 0.08755030483007431, + 0.047739118337631226, + 0.06950432062149048, + 0.17095163464546204, + 0.07315553724765778, + 0.06733132153749466 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018193742260336876 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video presented in black and white with high contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a warrior wearing traditional Japanese samurai armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior performing a violent swordsmanship swing with a katana?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a close-up from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a strong sidelight creating sharp highlights on the armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8261533975601196 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5761533975601196 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.8261533975601196, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.8261533975601196, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09376145899295807, + 0.05326031148433685, + 0.040083616971969604, + 0.031564243137836456, + 0.22771966457366943, + 0.14237578213214874, + 0.01992572471499443, + 0.21658171713352203, + 0.07432572543621063, + 0.10040172189474106 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 7, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.8261533975601196 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video presented in black and white with high contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a warrior wearing traditional Japanese samurai armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior performing a violent swordsmanship swing with a katana?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a close-up from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a strong sidelight creating sharp highlights on the armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004095738288015127 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504095554351807 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004095738288015127, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004095738288015127, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2104812115430832, + 0.05880628153681755, + 0.11652030795812607, + 0.04623251035809517, + 0.09130138158798218, + 0.08061085641384125, + 0.03074202500283718, + 0.22251012921333313, + 0.050999049097299576, + 0.09179624170064926 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004095738288015127 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video presented in black and white with high contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a warrior wearing traditional Japanese samurai armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior performing a violent swordsmanship swing with a katana?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a close-up from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a strong sidelight creating sharp highlights on the armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00023457636416424066 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -8.375234603881836 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00023457636416424066, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 8.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00023457636416424066, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2268497794866562, + 0.058516256511211395, + 0.02533181756734848, + 0.031240442767739296, + 0.17660360038280487, + 0.055374566465616226, + 0.028444023802876472, + 0.28430575132369995, + 0.07585898041725159, + 0.03747474402189255 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00023457636416424066 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "striking, high-contrast black-and-white close-up, shot from a slightly upward angle, captures a warrior clad in traditional Japanese samurai armor in slow motion. He wears a helmet adorned with a majestic kuwagata (front standing) and his face is concealed by a menacing menpo (cheek) mask, through which only a piercing, focused gaze can be seen. A strong, dramatic sidelight sculpts the taut muscles of his arms, giving each jet-black metal plate and tightly woven silk cord a distinct texture, reflecting sharp highlights. He is at the apex of a violent swordsmanship swing, his hands tightly gripping a gleaming katana. The blade slices through the air with lightning speed, leaving a blurred, deadly arc of silver light against the pure, profound darkness. As his body twists, the plates of his armor collide and rub against each other, and the dust stirred up by his feet floats and dances in the beam of light. The whole picture is full of primitive power and solidified dynamic beauty, creating a tense, focused and highly ritualistic battle atmosphere.", + "seed": 26074, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_3/index_3017_seed_26074_dp_6_rank_12_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.2514705214416608, + "vlm_logprob": -0.2514705214416608, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.55, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.2514705214416608, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video presented in black and white with high contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a warrior wearing traditional Japanese samurai armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior performing a violent swordsmanship swing with a katana?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a close-up from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a strong sidelight creating sharp highlights on the armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00400099391117692 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.129001140594482 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00400099391117692, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00400099391117692, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.257622629404068, + 0.06335124373435974, + 0.07947447896003723, + 0.15101702511310577, + 0.08468255400657654, + 0.06081583350896835, + 0.048649080097675323, + 0.11782301962375641, + 0.04437555372714996, + 0.0921885073184967 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00400099391117692 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video presented in black and white with high contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a warrior wearing traditional Japanese samurai armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior performing a violent swordsmanship swing with a katana?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a close-up from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a strong sidelight creating sharp highlights on the armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02330007031559944 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7733001708984375 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02330007031559944, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02330007031559944, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20665359497070312, + 0.1037745401263237, + 0.05283437296748161, + 0.06522320210933685, + 0.12397255003452301, + 0.15195757150650024, + 0.02656068280339241, + 0.10656522959470749, + 0.07382353395223618, + 0.08863473683595657 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02330007031559944 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video presented in black and white with high contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a warrior wearing traditional Japanese samurai armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior performing a violent swordsmanship swing with a katana?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a close-up from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a strong sidelight creating sharp highlights on the armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2236078977584839 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3486078679561615 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.2236078977584839, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -1.2236078977584839, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11410073190927505, + 0.07743793725967407, + 0.060831982642412186, + 0.21314840018749237, + 0.10492071509361267, + 0.09058940410614014, + 0.08668947219848633, + 0.042668867856264114, + 0.10344910621643066, + 0.10616341978311539 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.2236078977584839 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video presented in black and white with high contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a warrior wearing traditional Japanese samurai armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior performing a violent swordsmanship swing with a katana?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a close-up from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a strong sidelight creating sharp highlights on the armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005949525628238916 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.1309494972229 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005949525628238916, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005949525628238916, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15542931854724884, + 0.08638601750135422, + 0.08779598772525787, + 0.17934337258338928, + 0.1183307021856308, + 0.07384377717971802, + 0.0427384078502655, + 0.08188195526599884, + 0.05521616339683533, + 0.1190342903137207 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005949525628238916 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video presented in black and white with high contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a warrior wearing traditional Japanese samurai armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior performing a violent swordsmanship swing with a katana?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a close-up from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a strong sidelight creating sharp highlights on the armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0004941195948049426 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.625494003295898 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0004941195948049426, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0004941195948049426, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1879298985004425, + 0.05959524214267731, + 0.09484951198101044, + 0.1367521733045578, + 0.11012841016054153, + 0.07498239725828171, + 0.07652582228183746, + 0.03773701190948486, + 0.05554463341832161, + 0.16595491766929626 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0004941195948049426 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "striking, high-contrast black-and-white close-up, shot from a slightly upward angle, captures a warrior clad in traditional Japanese samurai armor in slow motion. He wears a helmet adorned with a majestic kuwagata (front standing) and his face is concealed by a menacing menpo (cheek) mask, through which only a piercing, focused gaze can be seen. A strong, dramatic sidelight sculpts the taut muscles of his arms, giving each jet-black metal plate and tightly woven silk cord a distinct texture, reflecting sharp highlights. He is at the apex of a violent swordsmanship swing, his hands tightly gripping a gleaming katana. The blade slices through the air with lightning speed, leaving a blurred, deadly arc of silver light against the pure, profound darkness. As his body twists, the plates of his armor collide and rub against each other, and the dust stirred up by his feet floats and dances in the beam of light. The whole picture is full of primitive power and solidified dynamic beauty, creating a tense, focused and highly ritualistic battle atmosphere.", + "seed": 26075, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_3/index_3017_seed_26075_dp_7_rank_14_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.22191034541465343, + "vlm_logprob": -0.22191034541465343, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.05, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.22191034541465343, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video presented in black and white with high contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a warrior wearing traditional Japanese samurai armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior performing a violent swordsmanship swing with a katana?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a close-up from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a strong sidelight creating sharp highlights on the armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011707055382430553 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.886706829071045 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011707055382430553, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011707055382430553, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.050791893154382706, + 0.014331053011119366, + 0.010332046076655388, + 0.720339298248291, + 0.013132399879395962, + 0.008684386499226093, + 0.028497418388724327, + 0.09078595787286758, + 0.014812442474067211, + 0.04829313978552818 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011707055382430553 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video presented in black and white with high contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a warrior wearing traditional Japanese samurai armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior performing a violent swordsmanship swing with a katana?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a close-up from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a strong sidelight creating sharp highlights on the armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03811657801270485 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288116693496704 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03811657801270485, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03811657801270485, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07919450849294662, + 0.046969447284936905, + 0.025520041584968567, + 0.7403491735458374, + 0.014455036260187626, + 0.009638977237045765, + 0.01225848589092493, + 0.024869613349437714, + 0.021137461066246033, + 0.025607217103242874 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03811657801270485 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video presented in black and white with high contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a warrior wearing traditional Japanese samurai armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior performing a violent swordsmanship swing with a katana?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a close-up from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a strong sidelight creating sharp highlights on the armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.0539112091064453 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4289112091064453 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.0539112091064453, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.625, + "token_credit_reward": -1.0539112091064453, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0431877039372921, + 0.04974176734685898, + 0.017688089981675148, + 0.6920803189277649, + 0.018557840958237648, + 0.025360753759741783, + 0.017352864146232605, + 0.05373964458703995, + 0.03290359303355217, + 0.04938738793134689 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.0539112091064453 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video presented in black and white with high contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a warrior wearing traditional Japanese samurai armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior performing a violent swordsmanship swing with a katana?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a close-up from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a strong sidelight creating sharp highlights on the armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005257115233689547 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.2552571296691895 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005257115233689547, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005257115233689547, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.019676825031638145, + 0.01682582125067711, + 0.008462158031761646, + 0.8941159844398499, + 0.012127747759222984, + 0.007284123916178942, + 0.007868423126637936, + 0.014533515088260174, + 0.0068934643641114235, + 0.012212003581225872 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005257115233689547 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video presented in black and white with high contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a warrior wearing traditional Japanese samurai armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior performing a violent swordsmanship swing with a katana?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a close-up from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a strong sidelight creating sharp highlights on the armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0005597693379968405 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.5005598068237305 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0005597693379968405, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0005597693379968405, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11166699230670929, + 0.11187688261270523, + 0.03405795991420746, + 0.19228266179561615, + 0.04422535002231598, + 0.028347855433821678, + 0.04931768774986267, + 0.3262206017971039, + 0.03088933788239956, + 0.07111462950706482 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0005597693379968405 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "striking, high-contrast black-and-white close-up, shot from a slightly upward angle, captures a warrior clad in traditional Japanese samurai armor in slow motion. He wears a helmet adorned with a majestic kuwagata (front standing) and his face is concealed by a menacing menpo (cheek) mask, through which only a piercing, focused gaze can be seen. A strong, dramatic sidelight sculpts the taut muscles of his arms, giving each jet-black metal plate and tightly woven silk cord a distinct texture, reflecting sharp highlights. He is at the apex of a violent swordsmanship swing, his hands tightly gripping a gleaming katana. The blade slices through the air with lightning speed, leaving a blurred, deadly arc of silver light against the pure, profound darkness. As his body twists, the plates of his armor collide and rub against each other, and the dust stirred up by his feet floats and dances in the beam of light. The whole picture is full of primitive power and solidified dynamic beauty, creating a tense, focused and highly ritualistic battle atmosphere.", + "seed": 26076, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_3/index_3017_seed_26076_dp_7_rank_14_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.041214900417253376, + "vlm_logprob": -0.041214900417253376, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 5.425, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.041214900417253376, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video presented in black and white with high contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a warrior wearing traditional Japanese samurai armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior performing a violent swordsmanship swing with a katana?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a close-up from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a strong sidelight creating sharp highlights on the armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0031143755186349154 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -8.128114700317383 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0031143755186349154, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 8.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0031143755186349154, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10673940926790237, + 0.0970979854464531, + 0.05889560282230377, + 0.02736598812043667, + 0.12335814535617828, + 0.04947645589709282, + 0.26371294260025024, + 0.20950910449028015, + 0.04043904319405556, + 0.023405328392982483 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0031143755186349154 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video presented in black and white with high contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a warrior wearing traditional Japanese samurai armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior performing a violent swordsmanship swing with a katana?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a close-up from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a strong sidelight creating sharp highlights on the armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016080215573310852 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141080379486084 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016080215573310852, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016080215573310852, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16226059198379517, + 0.06823315471410751, + 0.1822340041399002, + 0.08846509456634521, + 0.2937746047973633, + 0.040980588644742966, + 0.0855783224105835, + 0.028550582006573677, + 0.013039549812674522, + 0.036883510649204254 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016080215573310852 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video presented in black and white with high contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a warrior wearing traditional Japanese samurai armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior performing a violent swordsmanship swing with a katana?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a close-up from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a strong sidelight creating sharp highlights on the armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17987969517707825 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8048796653747559 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17987969517707825, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17987969517707825, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08806415647268295, + 0.03839968517422676, + 0.10180813819169998, + 0.038378942757844925, + 0.3142379820346832, + 0.11816678941249847, + 0.2451244294643402, + 0.014163783751428127, + 0.019676271826028824, + 0.021979795768857002 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17987969517707825 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video presented in black and white with high contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a warrior wearing traditional Japanese samurai armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior performing a violent swordsmanship swing with a katana?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a close-up from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a strong sidelight creating sharp highlights on the armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006734176073223352 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006734371185303 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006734176073223352, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006734176073223352, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07245149463415146, + 0.09241737425327301, + 0.1318489909172058, + 0.03727545589208603, + 0.21264833211898804, + 0.10664881020784378, + 0.16298918426036835, + 0.12944923341274261, + 0.01337225642055273, + 0.040898822247982025 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006734176073223352 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video presented in black and white with high contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a warrior wearing traditional Japanese samurai armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior performing a violent swordsmanship swing with a katana?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a close-up from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a strong sidelight creating sharp highlights on the armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00026603974401950836 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -8.250266075134277 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00026603974401950836, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 8.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00026603974401950836, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13557571172714233, + 0.07779832184314728, + 0.10107561945915222, + 0.08217505365610123, + 0.26872360706329346, + 0.06783293187618256, + 0.08845390379428864, + 0.11854024231433868, + 0.013351889327168465, + 0.046472687274217606 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00026603974401950836 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_4/index_tensor([1515, 1515])_group_4_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_4/index_tensor([1515, 1515])_group_4_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..a350b3f327761c8b8325259f5dc2c7d214973934 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_4/index_tensor([1515, 1515])_group_4_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "beautiful, PIXAR-style, full-body wide-angle shot tilts steadily to the right, tracking a young adventurer through the tranquil landscape of the humble executive garden. The character is a girl with expressive green eyes, dotted with freckles, and vibrant auburn hair tied in a loose ponytail that bounces with every step. She wears a sturdy teal tunic over a cream-colored long-sleeved shirt, a small leather backpack slung across her chest for exploration. With a light, curious gait, she strolls across an exquisitely arched moon bridge constructed of smooth, light-gray stone. Her eyes widen, her head turning in wonder as she takes in the meticulously crafted world around her: weeping willows, their leaves lush and swaying, and a tranquil mallow pond where oversized, friendly-looking mallows swim beneath perfectly formed lotus flowers. The entire scene is bathed in a soft, captivating sunlight, filtering through the leaves and casting dappled, shifting patterns of light and shadow across the path. Warm golden light, combined with a vibrant palette of lush greens, tranquil blues and earthy tones, creates an atmosphere of gentle beauty, peace and magical discovery.", + "seed": 26080, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_4/index_1515_seed_26080_dp_8_rank_16_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.03695457614958286, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03695457614958286, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.55, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03695457614958286, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main character a young girl with expressive green eyes, freckles, and vibrant auburn hair in a loose ponytail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the girl wearing a sturdy teal tunic over a cream-colored long-sleeved shirt with a small leather backpack?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the girl strolling across an arched moon bridge made of smooth, light-gray stone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include weeping willows with lush swaying leaves and a pond with oversized mallows swimming beneath lotus flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt steadily to the right while tracking the girl's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011525829322636127 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511525630950928 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011525829322636127, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011525829322636127, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08380177617073059, + 0.03125214949250221, + 0.061331607401371, + 0.07313047349452972, + 0.20236968994140625, + 0.12636853754520416, + 0.0655369982123375, + 0.06291723996400833, + 0.204869344830513, + 0.08842214941978455 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011525829322636127 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main character a young girl with expressive green eyes, freckles, and vibrant auburn hair in a loose ponytail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the girl wearing a sturdy teal tunic over a cream-colored long-sleeved shirt with a small leather backpack?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the girl strolling across an arched moon bridge made of smooth, light-gray stone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include weeping willows with lush swaying leaves and a pond with oversized mallows swimming beneath lotus flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt steadily to the right while tracking the girl's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011086766608059406 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511086940765381 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011086766608059406, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011086766608059406, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05442747101187706, + 0.02466394007205963, + 0.06416890770196915, + 0.06950025260448456, + 0.08778851479291916, + 0.17881016433238983, + 0.08372534066438675, + 0.09300629049539566, + 0.2532835006713867, + 0.09062564373016357 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011086766608059406 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main character a young girl with expressive green eyes, freckles, and vibrant auburn hair in a loose ponytail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the girl wearing a sturdy teal tunic over a cream-colored long-sleeved shirt with a small leather backpack?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the girl strolling across an arched moon bridge made of smooth, light-gray stone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include weeping willows with lush swaying leaves and a pond with oversized mallows swimming beneath lotus flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt steadily to the right while tracking the girl's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03809351474046707 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2880935668945312 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03809351474046707, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03809351474046707, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.045071542263031006, + 0.030588621273636818, + 0.22543102502822876, + 0.1459134817123413, + 0.06807819753885269, + 0.14721134305000305, + 0.0690552368760109, + 0.04735138267278671, + 0.2021958976984024, + 0.019103292375802994 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03809351474046707 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main character a young girl with expressive green eyes, freckles, and vibrant auburn hair in a loose ponytail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the girl wearing a sturdy teal tunic over a cream-colored long-sleeved shirt with a small leather backpack?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the girl strolling across an arched moon bridge made of smooth, light-gray stone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include weeping willows with lush swaying leaves and a pond with oversized mallows swimming beneath lotus flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt steadily to the right while tracking the girl's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06205142289400101 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.81205153465271 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06205142289400101, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06205142289400101, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14326366782188416, + 0.15074476599693298, + 0.04741331934928894, + 0.05014174059033394, + 0.11803465336561203, + 0.12681566178798676, + 0.053823813796043396, + 0.0850730687379837, + 0.1891859918832779, + 0.0355033203959465 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06205142289400101 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main character a young girl with expressive green eyes, freckles, and vibrant auburn hair in a loose ponytail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the girl wearing a sturdy teal tunic over a cream-colored long-sleeved shirt with a small leather backpack?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the girl strolling across an arched moon bridge made of smooth, light-gray stone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include weeping willows with lush swaying leaves and a pond with oversized mallows swimming beneath lotus flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt steadily to the right while tracking the girl's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0620153471827507 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120152950286865 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0620153471827507, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0620153471827507, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.026669641956686974, + 0.0325617715716362, + 0.06094774976372719, + 0.07269629836082458, + 0.08898505568504333, + 0.22111736238002777, + 0.08436105400323868, + 0.053561847656965256, + 0.35267943143844604, + 0.006419749930500984 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0620153471827507 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "beautiful, PIXAR-style, full-body wide-angle shot tilts steadily to the right, tracking a young adventurer through the tranquil landscape of the humble executive garden. The character is a girl with expressive green eyes, dotted with freckles, and vibrant auburn hair tied in a loose ponytail that bounces with every step. She wears a sturdy teal tunic over a cream-colored long-sleeved shirt, a small leather backpack slung across her chest for exploration. With a light, curious gait, she strolls across an exquisitely arched moon bridge constructed of smooth, light-gray stone. Her eyes widen, her head turning in wonder as she takes in the meticulously crafted world around her: weeping willows, their leaves lush and swaying, and a tranquil mallow pond where oversized, friendly-looking mallows swim beneath perfectly formed lotus flowers. The entire scene is bathed in a soft, captivating sunlight, filtering through the leaves and casting dappled, shifting patterns of light and shadow across the path. Warm golden light, combined with a vibrant palette of lush greens, tranquil blues and earthy tones, creates an atmosphere of gentle beauty, peace and magical discovery.", + "seed": 26081, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_4/index_1515_seed_26081_dp_8_rank_16_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.02455963809043169, + "vlm_logprob": -0.02455963809043169, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.0, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.02455963809043169, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main character a young girl with expressive green eyes, freckles, and vibrant auburn hair in a loose ponytail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the girl wearing a sturdy teal tunic over a cream-colored long-sleeved shirt with a small leather backpack?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the girl strolling across an arched moon bridge made of smooth, light-gray stone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include weeping willows with lush swaying leaves and a pond with oversized mallows swimming beneath lotus flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt steadily to the right while tracking the girl's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006190174724906683 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.131190299987793 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006190174724906683, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006190174724906683, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18573680520057678, + 0.0462796613574028, + 0.023857370018959045, + 0.045293424278497696, + 0.08825646340847015, + 0.0453033484518528, + 0.37514421343803406, + 0.08342843502759933, + 0.06528614461421967, + 0.04141412302851677 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006190174724906683 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main character a young girl with expressive green eyes, freckles, and vibrant auburn hair in a loose ponytail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the girl wearing a sturdy teal tunic over a cream-colored long-sleeved shirt with a small leather backpack?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the girl strolling across an arched moon bridge made of smooth, light-gray stone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include weeping willows with lush swaying leaves and a pond with oversized mallows swimming beneath lotus flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt steadily to the right while tracking the girl's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006740096490830183 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006740093231201 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006740096490830183, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006740096490830183, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22244897484779358, + 0.06675612926483154, + 0.056150179356336594, + 0.05399947986006737, + 0.06918621063232422, + 0.04889647662639618, + 0.020730504766106606, + 0.08148038387298584, + 0.06974440813064575, + 0.31060725450515747 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006740096490830183 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main character a young girl with expressive green eyes, freckles, and vibrant auburn hair in a loose ponytail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the girl wearing a sturdy teal tunic over a cream-colored long-sleeved shirt with a small leather backpack?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the girl strolling across an arched moon bridge made of smooth, light-gray stone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include weeping willows with lush swaying leaves and a pond with oversized mallows swimming beneath lotus flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt steadily to the right while tracking the girl's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03809225186705589 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2880921363830566 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03809225186705589, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03809225186705589, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.35322892665863037, + 0.11911401897668839, + 0.06215274706482887, + 0.1124890074133873, + 0.0754278227686882, + 0.016695549711585045, + 0.10286775976419449, + 0.07191643863916397, + 0.058603085577487946, + 0.027504608035087585 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03809225186705589 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main character a young girl with expressive green eyes, freckles, and vibrant auburn hair in a loose ponytail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the girl wearing a sturdy teal tunic over a cream-colored long-sleeved shirt with a small leather backpack?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the girl strolling across an arched moon bridge made of smooth, light-gray stone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include weeping willows with lush swaying leaves and a pond with oversized mallows swimming beneath lotus flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt steadily to the right while tracking the girl's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.033698562532663345 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408698558807373 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.033698562532663345, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.033698562532663345, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11328698694705963, + 0.03210679069161415, + 0.027747230604290962, + 0.05118357390165329, + 0.047830745577812195, + 0.03257042169570923, + 0.0313386507332325, + 0.050140380859375, + 0.12696677446365356, + 0.48682844638824463 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.033698562532663345 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main character a young girl with expressive green eyes, freckles, and vibrant auburn hair in a loose ponytail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the girl wearing a sturdy teal tunic over a cream-colored long-sleeved shirt with a small leather backpack?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the girl strolling across an arched moon bridge made of smooth, light-gray stone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include weeping willows with lush swaying leaves and a pond with oversized mallows swimming beneath lotus flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt steadily to the right while tracking the girl's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03807710483670235 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2880771160125732 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03807710483670235, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03807710483670235, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04422662779688835, + 0.049193136394023895, + 0.05520898848772049, + 0.04920822009444237, + 0.053287260234355927, + 0.05047709867358208, + 0.1510235071182251, + 0.3732142150402069, + 0.05347384139895439, + 0.1206870749592781 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03807710483670235 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "beautiful, PIXAR-style, full-body wide-angle shot tilts steadily to the right, tracking a young adventurer through the tranquil landscape of the humble executive garden. The character is a girl with expressive green eyes, dotted with freckles, and vibrant auburn hair tied in a loose ponytail that bounces with every step. She wears a sturdy teal tunic over a cream-colored long-sleeved shirt, a small leather backpack slung across her chest for exploration. With a light, curious gait, she strolls across an exquisitely arched moon bridge constructed of smooth, light-gray stone. Her eyes widen, her head turning in wonder as she takes in the meticulously crafted world around her: weeping willows, their leaves lush and swaying, and a tranquil mallow pond where oversized, friendly-looking mallows swim beneath perfectly formed lotus flowers. The entire scene is bathed in a soft, captivating sunlight, filtering through the leaves and casting dappled, shifting patterns of light and shadow across the path. Warm golden light, combined with a vibrant palette of lush greens, tranquil blues and earthy tones, creates an atmosphere of gentle beauty, peace and magical discovery.", + "seed": 26082, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_4/index_1515_seed_26082_dp_9_rank_18_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.06379315983504057, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06379315983504057, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.025, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06379315983504057, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main character a young girl with expressive green eyes, freckles, and vibrant auburn hair in a loose ponytail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the girl wearing a sturdy teal tunic over a cream-colored long-sleeved shirt with a small leather backpack?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the girl strolling across an arched moon bridge made of smooth, light-gray stone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include weeping willows with lush swaying leaves and a pond with oversized mallows swimming beneath lotus flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt steadily to the right while tracking the girl's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.033912573009729385 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4089126586914062 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.033912573009729385, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.033912573009729385, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2244356870651245, + 0.10849965363740921, + 0.043219275772571564, + 0.04156501963734627, + 0.07027430087327957, + 0.1565895825624466, + 0.18686078488826752, + 0.05384552478790283, + 0.07621629536151886, + 0.03849387541413307 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.033912573009729385 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main character a young girl with expressive green eyes, freckles, and vibrant auburn hair in a loose ponytail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the girl wearing a sturdy teal tunic over a cream-colored long-sleeved shirt with a small leather backpack?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the girl strolling across an arched moon bridge made of smooth, light-gray stone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include weeping willows with lush swaying leaves and a pond with oversized mallows swimming beneath lotus flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt steadily to the right while tracking the girl's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009793094359338284 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634793281555176 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009793094359338284, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009793094359338284, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14453692734241486, + 0.0914171040058136, + 0.06368288397789001, + 0.04191918298602104, + 0.22585450112819672, + 0.13763785362243652, + 0.08474560081958771, + 0.051167264580726624, + 0.05968053266406059, + 0.09935817122459412 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009793094359338284 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main character a young girl with expressive green eyes, freckles, and vibrant auburn hair in a loose ponytail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the girl wearing a sturdy teal tunic over a cream-colored long-sleeved shirt with a small leather backpack?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the girl strolling across an arched moon bridge made of smooth, light-gray stone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include weeping willows with lush swaying leaves and a pond with oversized mallows swimming beneath lotus flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt steadily to the right while tracking the girl's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11292936652898788 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.237929344177246 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11292936652898788, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11292936652898788, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07689795643091202, + 0.09787330776453018, + 0.05276254564523697, + 0.11232264339923859, + 0.12300662696361542, + 0.20652920007705688, + 0.059914134442806244, + 0.05537506192922592, + 0.11400806903839111, + 0.10131043940782547 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11292936652898788 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main character a young girl with expressive green eyes, freckles, and vibrant auburn hair in a loose ponytail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the girl wearing a sturdy teal tunic over a cream-colored long-sleeved shirt with a small leather backpack?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the girl strolling across an arched moon bridge made of smooth, light-gray stone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include weeping willows with lush swaying leaves and a pond with oversized mallows swimming beneath lotus flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt steadily to the right while tracking the girl's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06205635145306587 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812056303024292 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06205635145306587, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06205635145306587, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1312629133462906, + 0.20770719647407532, + 0.05728248134255409, + 0.04198639839887619, + 0.2786232531070709, + 0.053469859063625336, + 0.043833669275045395, + 0.024624425917863846, + 0.06274640560150146, + 0.09846336394548416 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06205635145306587 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main character a young girl with expressive green eyes, freckles, and vibrant auburn hair in a loose ponytail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the girl wearing a sturdy teal tunic over a cream-colored long-sleeved shirt with a small leather backpack?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the girl strolling across an arched moon bridge made of smooth, light-gray stone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include weeping willows with lush swaying leaves and a pond with oversized mallows swimming beneath lotus flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt steadily to the right while tracking the girl's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10027441382408142 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3502743244171143 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10027441382408142, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10027441382408142, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.42160937190055847, + 0.09805417060852051, + 0.11489716172218323, + 0.0564846433699131, + 0.03996429592370987, + 0.056248631328344345, + 0.04490951821208, + 0.034815266728401184, + 0.06601162254810333, + 0.06700533628463745 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10027441382408142 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "beautiful, PIXAR-style, full-body wide-angle shot tilts steadily to the right, tracking a young adventurer through the tranquil landscape of the humble executive garden. The character is a girl with expressive green eyes, dotted with freckles, and vibrant auburn hair tied in a loose ponytail that bounces with every step. She wears a sturdy teal tunic over a cream-colored long-sleeved shirt, a small leather backpack slung across her chest for exploration. With a light, curious gait, she strolls across an exquisitely arched moon bridge constructed of smooth, light-gray stone. Her eyes widen, her head turning in wonder as she takes in the meticulously crafted world around her: weeping willows, their leaves lush and swaying, and a tranquil mallow pond where oversized, friendly-looking mallows swim beneath perfectly formed lotus flowers. The entire scene is bathed in a soft, captivating sunlight, filtering through the leaves and casting dappled, shifting patterns of light and shadow across the path. Warm golden light, combined with a vibrant palette of lush greens, tranquil blues and earthy tones, creates an atmosphere of gentle beauty, peace and magical discovery.", + "seed": 26083, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_4/index_1515_seed_26083_dp_9_rank_18_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.03259954694658518, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03259954694658518, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.675, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03259954694658518, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main character a young girl with expressive green eyes, freckles, and vibrant auburn hair in a loose ponytail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the girl wearing a sturdy teal tunic over a cream-colored long-sleeved shirt with a small leather backpack?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the girl strolling across an arched moon bridge made of smooth, light-gray stone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include weeping willows with lush swaying leaves and a pond with oversized mallows swimming beneath lotus flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt steadily to the right while tracking the girl's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016380712389945984 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141380786895752 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016380712389945984, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016380712389945984, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14915154874324799, + 0.04332076758146286, + 0.029619023203849792, + 0.04298800230026245, + 0.03650258854031563, + 0.09719144552946091, + 0.05241356045007706, + 0.13545270264148712, + 0.06971430033445358, + 0.3436461091041565 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016380712389945984 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main character a young girl with expressive green eyes, freckles, and vibrant auburn hair in a loose ponytail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the girl wearing a sturdy teal tunic over a cream-colored long-sleeved shirt with a small leather backpack?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the girl strolling across an arched moon bridge made of smooth, light-gray stone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include weeping willows with lush swaying leaves and a pond with oversized mallows swimming beneath lotus flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt steadily to the right while tracking the girl's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009790615178644657 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634790420532227 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009790615178644657, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009790615178644657, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14820842444896698, + 0.0331653356552124, + 0.040000345557928085, + 0.04113149270415306, + 0.1941576898097992, + 0.06703028827905655, + 0.05473386496305466, + 0.07430420070886612, + 0.0636058896780014, + 0.28366243839263916 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009790615178644657 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main character a young girl with expressive green eyes, freckles, and vibrant auburn hair in a loose ponytail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the girl wearing a sturdy teal tunic over a cream-colored long-sleeved shirt with a small leather backpack?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the girl strolling across an arched moon bridge made of smooth, light-gray stone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include weeping willows with lush swaying leaves and a pond with oversized mallows swimming beneath lotus flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt steadily to the right while tracking the girl's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04864523932337761 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048645257949829 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04864523932337761, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04864523932337761, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18176184594631195, + 0.059232890605926514, + 0.05843483656644821, + 0.14710918068885803, + 0.13486477732658386, + 0.09972406178712845, + 0.05798397585749626, + 0.06644138693809509, + 0.06287378817796707, + 0.13157328963279724 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04864523932337761 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main character a young girl with expressive green eyes, freckles, and vibrant auburn hair in a loose ponytail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the girl wearing a sturdy teal tunic over a cream-colored long-sleeved shirt with a small leather backpack?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the girl strolling across an arched moon bridge made of smooth, light-gray stone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include weeping willows with lush swaying leaves and a pond with oversized mallows swimming beneath lotus flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt steadily to the right while tracking the girl's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01818835735321045 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.0181884765625 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01818835735321045, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01818835735321045, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09787357598543167, + 0.03595002368092537, + 0.05055316165089607, + 0.058765217661857605, + 0.057805344462394714, + 0.0610257089138031, + 0.08497186005115509, + 0.03474479913711548, + 0.07290229946374893, + 0.44540801644325256 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01818835735321045 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main character a young girl with expressive green eyes, freckles, and vibrant auburn hair in a loose ponytail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the girl wearing a sturdy teal tunic over a cream-colored long-sleeved shirt with a small leather backpack?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the girl strolling across an arched moon bridge made of smooth, light-gray stone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include weeping willows with lush swaying leaves and a pond with oversized mallows swimming beneath lotus flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt steadily to the right while tracking the girl's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06999281048774719 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.694992780685425 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06999281048774719, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06999281048774719, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1377495974302292, + 0.06385599821805954, + 0.06502579152584076, + 0.12942558526992798, + 0.2087077647447586, + 0.14857271313667297, + 0.05476151779294014, + 0.07197750359773636, + 0.08060147613286972, + 0.039322081953287125 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06999281048774719 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_5/index_tensor([7910, 7910])_group_5_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_5/index_tensor([7910, 7910])_group_5_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..ceb4fd417f4d18fee3a72e95c25726608c5aec4a --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_5/index_tensor([7910, 7910])_group_5_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "low-angle tracking shot follows a massive heavy tank, its massive hull clad in a dull, weathered military green. Its hull is covered in scratches, burn marks, and patches of rust that have peeled off, revealing the dark metal beneath. With an unstoppable, ponderous rhythm, the tank slowly patrols a completely abandoned city thoroughfare. Its metal tracks, coated in thick mud and concrete debris, relentlessly roll over piles of rubble and twisted rebar, each crushing movement producing a dull, cracking sound and sending up small plumes of dust. In the background, the shattered skeletons of buildings, black windows staring out like empty eye sockets, are cast in a gloomy gray sky. The air is thick with dust and the faint scent of cigarette smoke. As the tank slowly moved forward, its angular turret turned to one side vigilantly and steadily amidst a low hydraulic hum, and its long gun barrel swept across the deserted streets and dilapidated building facades in an orderly manner, creating an oppressive atmosphere of post-apocalyptic silence and high tension.", + "seed": 31147, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_5/index_7910_seed_31147_dp_10_rank_20_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.060797685757279396, + "vlm_logprob": -0.060797685757279396, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.3, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.060797685757279396, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle following a massive heavy tank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tank's hull clad in dull, weathered military green with visible scratches, burn marks, and peeling rust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tank moving slowly through a completely abandoned city thoroughfare with metal tracks coated in thick mud and concrete debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tank's angular turret turn to one side while its long gun barrel sweeps across deserted streets and dilapidated building facades?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of shattered building skeletons with black windows against a gloomy gray sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018255196511745453 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.143255233764648 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018255196511745453, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018255196511745453, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15508446097373962, + 0.1457817256450653, + 0.21520653367042542, + 0.08613558113574982, + 0.07965423911809921, + 0.021885981783270836, + 0.03107455000281334, + 0.0610651895403862, + 0.15826329588890076, + 0.045848410576581955 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018255196511745453 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle following a massive heavy tank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tank's hull clad in dull, weathered military green with visible scratches, burn marks, and peeling rust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tank moving slowly through a completely abandoned city thoroughfare with metal tracks coated in thick mud and concrete debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tank's angular turret turn to one side while its long gun barrel sweeps across deserted streets and dilapidated building facades?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of shattered building skeletons with black windows against a gloomy gray sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07003993541002274 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695039987564087 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07003993541002274, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07003993541002274, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21218828856945038, + 0.09119297564029694, + 0.09382179379463196, + 0.06322693824768066, + 0.03231406956911087, + 0.014875811524689198, + 0.019487833604216576, + 0.0409044586122036, + 0.339803546667099, + 0.09218428283929825 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07003993541002274 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle following a massive heavy tank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tank's hull clad in dull, weathered military green with visible scratches, burn marks, and peeling rust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tank moving slowly through a completely abandoned city thoroughfare with metal tracks coated in thick mud and concrete debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tank's angular turret turn to one side while its long gun barrel sweeps across deserted streets and dilapidated building facades?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of shattered building skeletons with black windows against a gloomy gray sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17987412214279175 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8048741817474365 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17987412214279175, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17987412214279175, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1581595540046692, + 0.11332668364048004, + 0.07045811414718628, + 0.44224950671195984, + 0.022322947159409523, + 0.03932446613907814, + 0.03498776629567146, + 0.04554617404937744, + 0.03581070154905319, + 0.03781411424279213 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17987412214279175 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle following a massive heavy tank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tank's hull clad in dull, weathered military green with visible scratches, burn marks, and peeling rust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tank moving slowly through a completely abandoned city thoroughfare with metal tracks coated in thick mud and concrete debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tank's angular turret turn to one side while its long gun barrel sweeps across deserted streets and dilapidated building facades?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of shattered building skeletons with black windows against a gloomy gray sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023289354518055916 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773289442062378 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023289354518055916, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023289354518055916, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18106302618980408, + 0.08235573023557663, + 0.06258539110422134, + 0.25830841064453125, + 0.065361388027668, + 0.04227156564593315, + 0.05831804871559143, + 0.04046623408794403, + 0.17950884997844696, + 0.02976125106215477 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023289354518055916 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle following a massive heavy tank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tank's hull clad in dull, weathered military green with visible scratches, burn marks, and peeling rust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tank moving slowly through a completely abandoned city thoroughfare with metal tracks coated in thick mud and concrete debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tank's angular turret turn to one side while its long gun barrel sweeps across deserted streets and dilapidated building facades?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of shattered building skeletons with black windows against a gloomy gray sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012529820203781128 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.3875298500061035 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012529820203781128, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012529820203781128, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2389451116323471, + 0.1697104275226593, + 0.10277479887008667, + 0.11527649313211441, + 0.029586492106318474, + 0.02683218941092491, + 0.029990240931510925, + 0.07817690074443817, + 0.15723875164985657, + 0.0514686293900013 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012529820203781128 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle tracking shot follows a massive heavy tank, its massive hull clad in a dull, weathered military green. Its hull is covered in scratches, burn marks, and patches of rust that have peeled off, revealing the dark metal beneath. With an unstoppable, ponderous rhythm, the tank slowly patrols a completely abandoned city thoroughfare. Its metal tracks, coated in thick mud and concrete debris, relentlessly roll over piles of rubble and twisted rebar, each crushing movement producing a dull, cracking sound and sending up small plumes of dust. In the background, the shattered skeletons of buildings, black windows staring out like empty eye sockets, are cast in a gloomy gray sky. The air is thick with dust and the faint scent of cigarette smoke. As the tank slowly moved forward, its angular turret turned to one side vigilantly and steadily amidst a low hydraulic hum, and its long gun barrel swept across the deserted streets and dilapidated building facades in an orderly manner, creating an oppressive atmosphere of post-apocalyptic silence and high tension.", + "seed": 31148, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_5/index_7910_seed_31148_dp_10_rank_20_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.11746860314160586, + "vlm_logprob": -0.11746860314160586, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.1, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.11746860314160586, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle following a massive heavy tank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tank's hull clad in dull, weathered military green with visible scratches, burn marks, and peeling rust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tank moving slowly through a completely abandoned city thoroughfare with metal tracks coated in thick mud and concrete debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tank's angular turret turn to one side while its long gun barrel sweeps across deserted streets and dilapidated building facades?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of shattered building skeletons with black windows against a gloomy gray sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04473138973116875 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.169731378555298 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04473138973116875, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04473138973116875, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2759220004081726, + 0.12266291677951813, + 0.05229698494076729, + 0.047109514474868774, + 0.1220630556344986, + 0.03892761468887329, + 0.09024520218372345, + 0.0964624285697937, + 0.07494958490133286, + 0.07936075329780579 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04473138973116875 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle following a massive heavy tank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tank's hull clad in dull, weathered military green with visible scratches, burn marks, and peeling rust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tank moving slowly through a completely abandoned city thoroughfare with metal tracks coated in thick mud and concrete debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tank's angular turret turn to one side while its long gun barrel sweeps across deserted streets and dilapidated building facades?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of shattered building skeletons with black windows against a gloomy gray sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.043073903769254684 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168073892593384 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.043073903769254684, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.043073903769254684, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.43597865104675293, + 0.07305663824081421, + 0.08001860976219177, + 0.03092155233025551, + 0.07312799990177155, + 0.027893198654055595, + 0.05306510627269745, + 0.09851142019033432, + 0.07024569064378738, + 0.057181164622306824 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.043073903769254684 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle following a massive heavy tank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tank's hull clad in dull, weathered military green with visible scratches, burn marks, and peeling rust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tank moving slowly through a completely abandoned city thoroughfare with metal tracks coated in thick mud and concrete debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tank's angular turret turn to one side while its long gun barrel sweeps across deserted streets and dilapidated building facades?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of shattered building skeletons with black windows against a gloomy gray sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.47427064180374146 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9742706418037415 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.47427064180374146, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.47427064180374146, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4017634391784668, + 0.08348284661769867, + 0.06282597035169601, + 0.08758248388767242, + 0.08722271770238876, + 0.05172652751207352, + 0.050887685269117355, + 0.05511978641152382, + 0.069025419652462, + 0.050363168120384216 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.47427064180374146 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle following a massive heavy tank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tank's hull clad in dull, weathered military green with visible scratches, burn marks, and peeling rust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tank moving slowly through a completely abandoned city thoroughfare with metal tracks coated in thick mud and concrete debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tank's angular turret turn to one side while its long gun barrel sweeps across deserted streets and dilapidated building facades?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of shattered building skeletons with black windows against a gloomy gray sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014199530705809593 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264199733734131 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014199530705809593, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014199530705809593, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10587894916534424, + 0.09827539324760437, + 0.083903469145298, + 0.16160476207733154, + 0.145032599568367, + 0.07004803419113159, + 0.057996176183223724, + 0.10767287015914917, + 0.0785711333155632, + 0.09101659804582596 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014199530705809593 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle following a massive heavy tank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tank's hull clad in dull, weathered military green with visible scratches, burn marks, and peeling rust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tank moving slowly through a completely abandoned city thoroughfare with metal tracks coated in thick mud and concrete debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tank's angular turret turn to one side while its long gun barrel sweeps across deserted streets and dilapidated building facades?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of shattered building skeletons with black windows against a gloomy gray sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01106754969805479 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.5110673904418945 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01106754969805479, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01106754969805479, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.35718557238578796, + 0.08226996660232544, + 0.04277820140123367, + 0.029475411400198936, + 0.11352632194757462, + 0.032750554382801056, + 0.06186734139919281, + 0.0634344294667244, + 0.1482728123664856, + 0.06843937188386917 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01106754969805479 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle tracking shot follows a massive heavy tank, its massive hull clad in a dull, weathered military green. Its hull is covered in scratches, burn marks, and patches of rust that have peeled off, revealing the dark metal beneath. With an unstoppable, ponderous rhythm, the tank slowly patrols a completely abandoned city thoroughfare. Its metal tracks, coated in thick mud and concrete debris, relentlessly roll over piles of rubble and twisted rebar, each crushing movement producing a dull, cracking sound and sending up small plumes of dust. In the background, the shattered skeletons of buildings, black windows staring out like empty eye sockets, are cast in a gloomy gray sky. The air is thick with dust and the faint scent of cigarette smoke. As the tank slowly moved forward, its angular turret turned to one side vigilantly and steadily amidst a low hydraulic hum, and its long gun barrel swept across the deserted streets and dilapidated building facades in an orderly manner, creating an oppressive atmosphere of post-apocalyptic silence and high tension.", + "seed": 31149, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_5/index_7910_seed_31149_dp_11_rank_22_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.3190778367221355, + "vlm_logprob": -0.3190778367221355, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.9, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.3190778367221355, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle following a massive heavy tank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tank's hull clad in dull, weathered military green with visible scratches, burn marks, and peeling rust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tank moving slowly through a completely abandoned city thoroughfare with metal tracks coated in thick mud and concrete debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tank's angular turret turn to one side while its long gun barrel sweeps across deserted streets and dilapidated building facades?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of shattered building skeletons with black windows against a gloomy gray sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.18123143911361694 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8062314987182617 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.18123143911361694, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.18123143911361694, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16817477345466614, + 0.08874708414077759, + 0.06574012339115143, + 0.04137931391596794, + 0.16293543577194214, + 0.17729337513446808, + 0.10284900665283203, + 0.059293195605278015, + 0.04062433913350105, + 0.09296344965696335 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.18123143911361694 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle following a massive heavy tank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tank's hull clad in dull, weathered military green with visible scratches, burn marks, and peeling rust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tank moving slowly through a completely abandoned city thoroughfare with metal tracks coated in thick mud and concrete debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tank's angular turret turn to one side while its long gun barrel sweeps across deserted streets and dilapidated building facades?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of shattered building skeletons with black windows against a gloomy gray sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.47435474395751953 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9743547439575195 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.47435474395751953, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.47435474395751953, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.043399374932050705, + 0.019890278577804565, + 0.112938791513443, + 0.025908896699547768, + 0.011966082267463207, + 0.5794868469238281, + 0.024146519601345062, + 0.04008251056075096, + 0.03226393088698387, + 0.10991676151752472 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 2, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.47435474395751953 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle following a massive heavy tank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tank's hull clad in dull, weathered military green with visible scratches, burn marks, and peeling rust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tank moving slowly through a completely abandoned city thoroughfare with metal tracks coated in thick mud and concrete debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tank's angular turret turn to one side while its long gun barrel sweeps across deserted streets and dilapidated building facades?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of shattered building skeletons with black windows against a gloomy gray sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8983117938041687 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5233117938041687 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.8983117938041687, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.8983117938041687, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1584840714931488, + 0.037351883947849274, + 0.08212882280349731, + 0.05338975414633751, + 0.060089681297540665, + 0.3236965835094452, + 0.059667009860277176, + 0.037659093737602234, + 0.018443450331687927, + 0.1690896898508072 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.8983117938041687 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle following a massive heavy tank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tank's hull clad in dull, weathered military green with visible scratches, burn marks, and peeling rust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tank moving slowly through a completely abandoned city thoroughfare with metal tracks coated in thick mud and concrete debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tank's angular turret turn to one side while its long gun barrel sweeps across deserted streets and dilapidated building facades?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of shattered building skeletons with black windows against a gloomy gray sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018207907676696777 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018208026885986 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018207907676696777, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018207907676696777, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17327651381492615, + 0.06386487185955048, + 0.16340568661689758, + 0.044761721044778824, + 0.031967829912900925, + 0.23677964508533478, + 0.060575876384973526, + 0.03125261887907982, + 0.033687204122543335, + 0.16042806208133698 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018207907676696777 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle following a massive heavy tank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tank's hull clad in dull, weathered military green with visible scratches, burn marks, and peeling rust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tank moving slowly through a completely abandoned city thoroughfare with metal tracks coated in thick mud and concrete debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tank's angular turret turn to one side while its long gun barrel sweeps across deserted streets and dilapidated building facades?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of shattered building skeletons with black windows against a gloomy gray sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023283299058675766 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732832431793213 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023283299058675766, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023283299058675766, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08533754199743271, + 0.10402888059616089, + 0.17182935774326324, + 0.022198650985956192, + 0.016452467069029808, + 0.28355103731155396, + 0.03876272961497307, + 0.03808390721678734, + 0.06360731273889542, + 0.1761481761932373 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023283299058675766 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle tracking shot follows a massive heavy tank, its massive hull clad in a dull, weathered military green. Its hull is covered in scratches, burn marks, and patches of rust that have peeled off, revealing the dark metal beneath. With an unstoppable, ponderous rhythm, the tank slowly patrols a completely abandoned city thoroughfare. Its metal tracks, coated in thick mud and concrete debris, relentlessly roll over piles of rubble and twisted rebar, each crushing movement producing a dull, cracking sound and sending up small plumes of dust. In the background, the shattered skeletons of buildings, black windows staring out like empty eye sockets, are cast in a gloomy gray sky. The air is thick with dust and the faint scent of cigarette smoke. As the tank slowly moved forward, its angular turret turned to one side vigilantly and steadily amidst a low hydraulic hum, and its long gun barrel swept across the deserted streets and dilapidated building facades in an orderly manner, creating an oppressive atmosphere of post-apocalyptic silence and high tension.", + "seed": 31150, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_5/index_7910_seed_31150_dp_11_rank_22_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.19399670585989953, + "vlm_logprob": -0.19399670585989953, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.625, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.19399670585989953, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle following a massive heavy tank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tank's hull clad in dull, weathered military green with visible scratches, burn marks, and peeling rust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tank moving slowly through a completely abandoned city thoroughfare with metal tracks coated in thick mud and concrete debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tank's angular turret turn to one side while its long gun barrel sweeps across deserted streets and dilapidated building facades?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of shattered building skeletons with black windows against a gloomy gray sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.041644562035799026 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.29164457321167 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.041644562035799026, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.041644562035799026, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11606945097446442, + 0.06577835977077484, + 0.051333650946617126, + 0.04415876045823097, + 0.20567725598812103, + 0.11507708579301834, + 0.10145233571529388, + 0.07984541356563568, + 0.11268985271453857, + 0.10791780799627304 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.041644562035799026 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle following a massive heavy tank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tank's hull clad in dull, weathered military green with visible scratches, burn marks, and peeling rust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tank moving slowly through a completely abandoned city thoroughfare with metal tracks coated in thick mud and concrete debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tank's angular turret turn to one side while its long gun barrel sweeps across deserted streets and dilapidated building facades?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of shattered building skeletons with black windows against a gloomy gray sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.42897579073905945 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.0539758205413818 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.42897579073905945, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.42897579073905945, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07488466799259186, + 0.13507255911827087, + 0.14530017971992493, + 0.029079820960760117, + 0.08086895942687988, + 0.13901035487651825, + 0.12883757054805756, + 0.06143111363053322, + 0.159083753824234, + 0.046431053429841995 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.42897579073905945 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle following a massive heavy tank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tank's hull clad in dull, weathered military green with visible scratches, burn marks, and peeling rust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tank moving slowly through a completely abandoned city thoroughfare with metal tracks coated in thick mud and concrete debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tank's angular turret turn to one side while its long gun barrel sweeps across deserted streets and dilapidated building facades?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of shattered building skeletons with black windows against a gloomy gray sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.47428399324417114 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9742839932441711 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.47428399324417114, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.47428399324417114, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15826067328453064, + 0.10101490467786789, + 0.0998939797282219, + 0.04797812178730965, + 0.17068731784820557, + 0.06950534135103226, + 0.07021991163492203, + 0.050155844539403915, + 0.10116609185934067, + 0.1311178058385849 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.47428399324417114 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle following a massive heavy tank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tank's hull clad in dull, weathered military green with visible scratches, burn marks, and peeling rust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tank moving slowly through a completely abandoned city thoroughfare with metal tracks coated in thick mud and concrete debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tank's angular turret turn to one side while its long gun barrel sweeps across deserted streets and dilapidated building facades?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of shattered building skeletons with black windows against a gloomy gray sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012546537443995476 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387546539306641 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012546537443995476, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012546537443995476, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13604623079299927, + 0.10742072761058807, + 0.09236376732587814, + 0.07909723371267319, + 0.09892207384109497, + 0.1241878867149353, + 0.10522174090147018, + 0.11035548150539398, + 0.09558077901601791, + 0.05080407112836838 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012546537443995476 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle following a massive heavy tank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tank's hull clad in dull, weathered military green with visible scratches, burn marks, and peeling rust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tank moving slowly through a completely abandoned city thoroughfare with metal tracks coated in thick mud and concrete debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tank's angular turret turn to one side while its long gun barrel sweeps across deserted streets and dilapidated building facades?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of shattered building skeletons with black windows against a gloomy gray sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012532645836472511 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387532711029053 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012532645836472511, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012532645836472511, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23754586279392242, + 0.21182876825332642, + 0.08137836307287216, + 0.05839940533041954, + 0.08080044388771057, + 0.11812596768140793, + 0.05747418850660324, + 0.05931864678859711, + 0.04263124614953995, + 0.052497126162052155 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012532645836472511 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_6/index_tensor([8835, 8835])_group_6_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_6/index_tensor([8835, 8835])_group_6_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..6522563736605628e8dfeeb568cb8b46cc062eb5 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_6/index_tensor([8835, 8835])_group_6_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "tense close-up shot from a slightly upward angle, the camera held still, locking the viewer's gaze firmly on a fighter pilot. He wears a matte, dark gray, high-tech flight helmet, its integrated oxygen mask clinging to the lower half of his face, revealing only a steely gaze and a slightly furrowed brow, his jawline taut with intense concentration. He wears an olive green, anti-G flight suit, the thick collar detail clearly visible. The transparent visor faintly reflects the countless flashing green instrument indicators and red warning symbols within the cockpit. Surrounded by a compact cockpit filled with complex electronic equipment and multi-function displays, his body barely moving under the immense acceleration. Through the curved cockpit glass in front of him, a thick, rolling sea of white clouds streaks backward at breakneck speed. Dazzling sunlight occasionally penetrates through gaps in the clouds, casting rapidly shifting, interlaced patches of light and dark on his helmet and face. The entire scene is filled with extreme concentration under high pressure and a sense of silence before the storm, creating a tense, professional and powerful atmosphere.", + "seed": 33526, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_6/index_8835_seed_33526_dp_12_rank_24_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.21314761154353618, + "vlm_logprob": -0.21314761154353618, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.075, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.21314761154353618, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a tense close-up of a fighter pilot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pilot wearing a matte dark gray high-tech flight helmet with an integrated oxygen mask?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the pilot wearing an olive green anti-G flight suit with a visible thick collar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the view through the cockpit glass show white clouds streaking backward with shifting patches of sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008977407589554787 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.88397741317749 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008977407589554787, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008977407589554787, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22524361312389374, + 0.08943776786327362, + 0.053069524466991425, + 0.055404771119356155, + 0.1143072098493576, + 0.13364961743354797, + 0.054522495716810226, + 0.14451521635055542, + 0.08333230763673782, + 0.046517543494701385 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008977407589554787 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a tense close-up of a fighter pilot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pilot wearing a matte dark gray high-tech flight helmet with an integrated oxygen mask?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the pilot wearing an olive green anti-G flight suit with a visible thick collar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the view through the cockpit glass show white clouds streaking backward with shifting patches of sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9743185639381409 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.47431856393814087 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.9743185639381409, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.9743185639381409, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1501377373933792, + 0.1262815296649933, + 0.0435178317129612, + 0.08816351741552353, + 0.06175176426768303, + 0.07250982522964478, + 0.11463113874197006, + 0.12772487103939056, + 0.06772848963737488, + 0.14755326509475708 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.9743185639381409 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a tense close-up of a fighter pilot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pilot wearing a matte dark gray high-tech flight helmet with an integrated oxygen mask?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the pilot wearing an olive green anti-G flight suit with a visible thick collar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the view through the cockpit glass show white clouds streaking backward with shifting patches of sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.043067965656518936 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680679321289062 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.043067965656518936, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.043067965656518936, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16605380177497864, + 0.13810467720031738, + 0.09286905080080032, + 0.04034681245684624, + 0.0759572982788086, + 0.12961462140083313, + 0.048449959605932236, + 0.10668078064918518, + 0.11288069188594818, + 0.08904232829809189 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.043067965656518936 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a tense close-up of a fighter pilot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pilot wearing a matte dark gray high-tech flight helmet with an integrated oxygen mask?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the pilot wearing an olive green anti-G flight suit with a visible thick collar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the view through the cockpit glass show white clouds streaking backward with shifting patches of sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02330903708934784 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7733089923858643 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02330903708934784, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02330903708934784, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14710894227027893, + 0.14435173571109772, + 0.07336855679750443, + 0.07301823794841766, + 0.17343734204769135, + 0.1437242329120636, + 0.08023277670145035, + 0.06374428421258926, + 0.05614813417196274, + 0.04486575722694397 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02330903708934784 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a tense close-up of a fighter pilot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pilot wearing a matte dark gray high-tech flight helmet with an integrated oxygen mask?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the pilot wearing an olive green anti-G flight suit with a visible thick collar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the view through the cockpit glass show white clouds streaking backward with shifting patches of sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0160650834441185 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.1410651206970215 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0160650834441185, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0160650834441185, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1436954289674759, + 0.18612106144428253, + 0.08620243519544601, + 0.18008418381214142, + 0.02860132046043873, + 0.025105495005846024, + 0.03325945511460304, + 0.06730976700782776, + 0.05204349383711815, + 0.19757740199565887 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0160650834441185 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "tense close-up shot from a slightly upward angle, the camera held still, locking the viewer's gaze firmly on a fighter pilot. He wears a matte, dark gray, high-tech flight helmet, its integrated oxygen mask clinging to the lower half of his face, revealing only a steely gaze and a slightly furrowed brow, his jawline taut with intense concentration. He wears an olive green, anti-G flight suit, the thick collar detail clearly visible. The transparent visor faintly reflects the countless flashing green instrument indicators and red warning symbols within the cockpit. Surrounded by a compact cockpit filled with complex electronic equipment and multi-function displays, his body barely moving under the immense acceleration. Through the curved cockpit glass in front of him, a thick, rolling sea of white clouds streaks backward at breakneck speed. Dazzling sunlight occasionally penetrates through gaps in the clouds, casting rapidly shifting, interlaced patches of light and dark on his helmet and face. The entire scene is filled with extreme concentration under high pressure and a sense of silence before the storm, creating a tense, professional and powerful atmosphere.", + "seed": 33527, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_6/index_8835_seed_33527_dp_12_rank_24_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.3174499979708344, + "vlm_logprob": -0.3174499979708344, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.2, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.3174499979708344, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a tense close-up of a fighter pilot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pilot wearing a matte dark gray high-tech flight helmet with an integrated oxygen mask?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the pilot wearing an olive green anti-G flight suit with a visible thick collar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the view through the cockpit glass show white clouds streaking backward with shifting patches of sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0033109153155237436 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.003310680389404 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0033109153155237436, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0033109153155237436, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15514786541461945, + 0.15396107733249664, + 0.09794847667217255, + 0.1040092185139656, + 0.047898706048727036, + 0.048953622579574585, + 0.02880311943590641, + 0.17732827365398407, + 0.10875576734542847, + 0.07719387114048004 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0033109153155237436 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a tense close-up of a fighter pilot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pilot wearing a matte dark gray high-tech flight helmet with an integrated oxygen mask?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the pilot wearing an olive green anti-G flight suit with a visible thick collar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the view through the cockpit glass show white clouds streaking backward with shifting patches of sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5021052360534668 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2521052658557892 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.5021052360534668, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -1.5021052360534668, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08792957663536072, + 0.05993490666151047, + 0.08835158497095108, + 0.059816911816596985, + 0.10078322142362595, + 0.04985413700342178, + 0.04900104179978371, + 0.1994192749261856, + 0.047043487429618835, + 0.25786590576171875 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.5021052360534668 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a tense close-up of a fighter pilot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pilot wearing a matte dark gray high-tech flight helmet with an integrated oxygen mask?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the pilot wearing an olive green anti-G flight suit with a visible thick collar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the view through the cockpit glass show white clouds streaking backward with shifting patches of sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04868566244840622 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486855506896973 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04868566244840622, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04868566244840622, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1406456083059311, + 0.10369296371936798, + 0.11419360339641571, + 0.08280893415212631, + 0.08790609240531921, + 0.11686532944440842, + 0.10438623279333115, + 0.10645174235105515, + 0.02977246604859829, + 0.11327706277370453 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04868566244840622 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a tense close-up of a fighter pilot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pilot wearing a matte dark gray high-tech flight helmet with an integrated oxygen mask?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the pilot wearing an olive green anti-G flight suit with a visible thick collar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the view through the cockpit glass show white clouds streaking backward with shifting patches of sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02060834877192974 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895608425140381 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02060834877192974, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02060834877192974, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12034893035888672, + 0.24928288161754608, + 0.056011151522397995, + 0.07994893193244934, + 0.0592048354446888, + 0.044453199952840805, + 0.09872453659772873, + 0.11725245416164398, + 0.052389778196811676, + 0.122383251786232 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02060834877192974 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a tense close-up of a fighter pilot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pilot wearing a matte dark gray high-tech flight helmet with an integrated oxygen mask?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the pilot wearing an olive green anti-G flight suit with a visible thick collar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the view through the cockpit glass show white clouds streaking backward with shifting patches of sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012539827264845371 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387539863586426 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012539827264845371, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012539827264845371, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07247453927993774, + 0.04649459570646286, + 0.04404881224036217, + 0.05052882060408592, + 0.09280826151371002, + 0.030809063464403152, + 0.016804013401269913, + 0.21815675497055054, + 0.042480260133743286, + 0.3853948414325714 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012539827264845371 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "tense close-up shot from a slightly upward angle, the camera held still, locking the viewer's gaze firmly on a fighter pilot. He wears a matte, dark gray, high-tech flight helmet, its integrated oxygen mask clinging to the lower half of his face, revealing only a steely gaze and a slightly furrowed brow, his jawline taut with intense concentration. He wears an olive green, anti-G flight suit, the thick collar detail clearly visible. The transparent visor faintly reflects the countless flashing green instrument indicators and red warning symbols within the cockpit. Surrounded by a compact cockpit filled with complex electronic equipment and multi-function displays, his body barely moving under the immense acceleration. Through the curved cockpit glass in front of him, a thick, rolling sea of white clouds streaks backward at breakneck speed. Dazzling sunlight occasionally penetrates through gaps in the clouds, casting rapidly shifting, interlaced patches of light and dark on his helmet and face. The entire scene is filled with extreme concentration under high pressure and a sense of silence before the storm, creating a tense, professional and powerful atmosphere.", + "seed": 33528, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_6/index_8835_seed_33528_dp_13_rank_26_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.27426383942365645, + "vlm_logprob": -0.27426383942365645, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.875, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.27426383942365645, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a tense close-up of a fighter pilot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pilot wearing a matte dark gray high-tech flight helmet with an integrated oxygen mask?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the pilot wearing an olive green anti-G flight suit with a visible thick collar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the view through the cockpit glass show white clouds streaking backward with shifting patches of sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.314058393239975 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3140584230422974 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.314058393239975, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.314058393239975, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11814253777265549, + 0.32490092515945435, + 0.05653475597500801, + 0.22720329463481903, + 0.018557360395789146, + 0.029607266187667847, + 0.04098660126328468, + 0.08308953046798706, + 0.06709994375705719, + 0.03387787938117981 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.314058393239975 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a tense close-up of a fighter pilot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pilot wearing a matte dark gray high-tech flight helmet with an integrated oxygen mask?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the pilot wearing an olive green anti-G flight suit with a visible thick collar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the view through the cockpit glass show white clouds streaking backward with shifting patches of sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6933881044387817 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6933881044387817 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.6933881044387817, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.6933881044387817, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2936171889305115, + 0.21451207995414734, + 0.08444936573505402, + 0.04736655578017235, + 0.05294940248131752, + 0.02534746564924717, + 0.09437546879053116, + 0.04800361022353172, + 0.056674517691135406, + 0.0827043429017067 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.6933881044387817 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a tense close-up of a fighter pilot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pilot wearing a matte dark gray high-tech flight helmet with an integrated oxygen mask?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the pilot wearing an olive green anti-G flight suit with a visible thick collar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the view through the cockpit glass show white clouds streaking backward with shifting patches of sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.31346607208251953 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3134660720825195 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.31346607208251953, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.31346607208251953, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19231750071048737, + 0.2700612545013428, + 0.2086452692747116, + 0.04763665050268173, + 0.0315098911523819, + 0.026663506403565407, + 0.0626751184463501, + 0.09163489937782288, + 0.04760922119021416, + 0.021246720105409622 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.31346607208251953 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a tense close-up of a fighter pilot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pilot wearing a matte dark gray high-tech flight helmet with an integrated oxygen mask?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the pilot wearing an olive green anti-G flight suit with a visible thick collar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the view through the cockpit glass show white clouds streaking backward with shifting patches of sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02982817403972149 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298280715942383 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02982817403972149, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02982817403972149, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16222891211509705, + 0.2942351996898651, + 0.13282054662704468, + 0.13256004452705383, + 0.045499034225940704, + 0.03174128010869026, + 0.0579562708735466, + 0.05823051556944847, + 0.05459441617131233, + 0.030133718624711037 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02982817403972149 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a tense close-up of a fighter pilot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pilot wearing a matte dark gray high-tech flight helmet with an integrated oxygen mask?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the pilot wearing an olive green anti-G flight suit with a visible thick collar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the view through the cockpit glass show white clouds streaking backward with shifting patches of sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020578453317284584 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895578384399414 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020578453317284584, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020578453317284584, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15292468667030334, + 0.3388301134109497, + 0.06651008874177933, + 0.1597840040922165, + 0.050675179809331894, + 0.0841113030910492, + 0.03628749027848244, + 0.05581016466021538, + 0.03154698759317398, + 0.02351999469101429 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020578453317284584 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "tense close-up shot from a slightly upward angle, the camera held still, locking the viewer's gaze firmly on a fighter pilot. He wears a matte, dark gray, high-tech flight helmet, its integrated oxygen mask clinging to the lower half of his face, revealing only a steely gaze and a slightly furrowed brow, his jawline taut with intense concentration. He wears an olive green, anti-G flight suit, the thick collar detail clearly visible. The transparent visor faintly reflects the countless flashing green instrument indicators and red warning symbols within the cockpit. Surrounded by a compact cockpit filled with complex electronic equipment and multi-function displays, his body barely moving under the immense acceleration. Through the curved cockpit glass in front of him, a thick, rolling sea of white clouds streaks backward at breakneck speed. Dazzling sunlight occasionally penetrates through gaps in the clouds, casting rapidly shifting, interlaced patches of light and dark on his helmet and face. The entire scene is filled with extreme concentration under high pressure and a sense of silence before the storm, creating a tense, professional and powerful atmosphere.", + "seed": 33529, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_6/index_8835_seed_33529_dp_13_rank_26_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.27341241464018823, + "vlm_logprob": -0.27341241464018823, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.7, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.27341241464018823, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a tense close-up of a fighter pilot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pilot wearing a matte dark gray high-tech flight helmet with an integrated oxygen mask?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the pilot wearing an olive green anti-G flight suit with a visible thick collar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the view through the cockpit glass show white clouds streaking backward with shifting patches of sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009840430691838264 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.884840488433838 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009840430691838264, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009840430691838264, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23430028557777405, + 0.19293928146362305, + 0.054778486490249634, + 0.056332025676965714, + 0.06120594963431358, + 0.04789049178361893, + 0.1057523563504219, + 0.04717712849378586, + 0.1718604862689972, + 0.02776351571083069 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009840430691838264 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a tense close-up of a fighter pilot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pilot wearing a matte dark gray high-tech flight helmet with an integrated oxygen mask?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the pilot wearing an olive green anti-G flight suit with a visible thick collar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the view through the cockpit glass show white clouds streaking backward with shifting patches of sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2236610651016235 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.34866103529930115 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.2236610651016235, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -1.2236610651016235, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.043350912630558014, + 0.15794150531291962, + 0.08736377209424973, + 0.01949077844619751, + 0.4420943260192871, + 0.030125999823212624, + 0.02654700167477131, + 0.01658548042178154, + 0.1283801645040512, + 0.04812011495232582 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.2236610651016235 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a tense close-up of a fighter pilot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pilot wearing a matte dark gray high-tech flight helmet with an integrated oxygen mask?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the pilot wearing an olive green anti-G flight suit with a visible thick collar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the view through the cockpit glass show white clouds streaking backward with shifting patches of sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07003948837518692 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950395107269287 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07003948837518692, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07003948837518692, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0884740948677063, + 0.13791218400001526, + 0.2377348393201828, + 0.03738695755600929, + 0.1640288382768631, + 0.15371733903884888, + 0.06610865145921707, + 0.04367651790380478, + 0.04469158127903938, + 0.02626895159482956 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07003948837518692 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a tense close-up of a fighter pilot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pilot wearing a matte dark gray high-tech flight helmet with an integrated oxygen mask?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the pilot wearing an olive green anti-G flight suit with a visible thick collar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the view through the cockpit glass show white clouds streaking backward with shifting patches of sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.033722419291734695 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408722400665283 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.033722419291734695, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.033722419291734695, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11920665949583054, + 0.20555134117603302, + 0.08570801466703415, + 0.0391845628619194, + 0.08975834399461746, + 0.06841098517179489, + 0.02456488087773323, + 0.022271426394581795, + 0.27116793394088745, + 0.0741758868098259 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.033722419291734695 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a tense close-up of a fighter pilot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pilot wearing a matte dark gray high-tech flight helmet with an integrated oxygen mask?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the pilot wearing an olive green anti-G flight suit with a visible thick collar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the view through the cockpit glass show white clouds streaking backward with shifting patches of sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02979866974055767 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529798746109009 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02979866974055767, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02979866974055767, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05918034166097641, + 0.8016173243522644, + 0.014021439477801323, + 0.009286826476454735, + 0.03645799309015274, + 0.020812835544347763, + 0.010543371550738811, + 0.016123091802001, + 0.019602257758378983, + 0.012354523874819279 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02979866974055767 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_7/index_tensor([9781, 9781])_group_7_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_7/index_tensor([9781, 9781])_group_7_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..1b72c7114980fa82778cdbff21e92ad2967007c5 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_7/index_tensor([9781, 9781])_group_7_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "In an extreme close-up, the camera tilts downward at an extremely slow speed, tracking the entirety of a single movement. The image begins with a cheek as smooth and delicate as porcelain, illuminated by a cool spotlight from above and sideways, revealing the skin's texture. A crystalline, perfectly shaped spherical teardrop, like a tiny diamond, clings to the skin. It pauses for a moment, its interior reflecting the blurred light and shadows surrounding it, before slowly and deliberately sliding down, leaving a trail of faint, moist shimmer across the cheek. When it reaches the jawline, it detaches from the skin, tracing an elegant yet weighty arc in the air. Throughout, the teardrop maintains its integrity against the dark background, shimmering with a solitary light. The camera continues to follow, and finally, this teardrop carrying silent emotions hits heavily on the dark gray, polished concrete floor below, and instantly explodes into a circle of extremely delicate crown-shaped water splashes. Countless tiny droplets splash in all directions, and then quickly merge into the reflection of the ground. The whole scene presents a solemn, sad and extremely focused atmosphere under the minimalist light and shadow.", + "seed": 21766, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_7/index_9781_seed_21766_dp_14_rank_28_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.12781919818371534, + "vlm_logprob": -0.12781919818371534, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.675, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.12781919818371534, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focusing on a human cheek with porcelain-like skin texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a crystalline, perfectly shaped spherical teardrop visible clinging to the cheek at the start?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the teardrop slide down the cheek, detach at the jawline, and hit the dark gray polished concrete floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the teardrop explode into a circle of crown-shaped water splashes upon hitting the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt downward at an extremely slow speed to track the entire movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.049312345683574677 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0493123531341553 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.049312345683574677, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.049312345683574677, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18102866411209106, + 0.23657599091529846, + 0.10896554589271545, + 0.06728093326091766, + 0.037777818739414215, + 0.04819261282682419, + 0.11346861720085144, + 0.09998297691345215, + 0.05274968221783638, + 0.05397715047001839 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.049312345683574677 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focusing on a human cheek with porcelain-like skin texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a crystalline, perfectly shaped spherical teardrop visible clinging to the cheek at the start?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the teardrop slide down the cheek, detach at the jawline, and hit the dark gray polished concrete floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the teardrop explode into a circle of crown-shaped water splashes upon hitting the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt downward at an extremely slow speed to track the entire movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4289078712463379 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.053907871246338 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.4289078712463379, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.4289078712463379, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16708457469940186, + 0.33502551913261414, + 0.07315021008253098, + 0.04292677342891693, + 0.02675410732626915, + 0.030716417357325554, + 0.0861542820930481, + 0.08236723393201828, + 0.023861436173319817, + 0.1319594532251358 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.4289078712463379 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focusing on a human cheek with porcelain-like skin texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a crystalline, perfectly shaped spherical teardrop visible clinging to the cheek at the start?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the teardrop slide down the cheek, detach at the jawline, and hit the dark gray polished concrete floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the teardrop explode into a circle of crown-shaped water splashes upon hitting the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt downward at an extremely slow speed to track the entire movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009795336984097958 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634795188903809 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009795336984097958, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009795336984097958, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1241406798362732, + 0.09183962643146515, + 0.06318214535713196, + 0.10221102088689804, + 0.03457443416118622, + 0.057255059480667114, + 0.2094351053237915, + 0.178396537899971, + 0.05387715622782707, + 0.08508823812007904 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009795336984097958 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focusing on a human cheek with porcelain-like skin texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a crystalline, perfectly shaped spherical teardrop visible clinging to the cheek at the start?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the teardrop slide down the cheek, detach at the jawline, and hit the dark gray polished concrete floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the teardrop explode into a circle of crown-shaped water splashes upon hitting the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt downward at an extremely slow speed to track the entire movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06203988194465637 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812039852142334 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06203988194465637, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06203988194465637, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09530530869960785, + 0.0703081414103508, + 0.03144121542572975, + 0.03998984023928642, + 0.06246085464954376, + 0.033292483538389206, + 0.2403862178325653, + 0.22192516922950745, + 0.07984137535095215, + 0.12504936754703522 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06203988194465637 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focusing on a human cheek with porcelain-like skin texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a crystalline, perfectly shaped spherical teardrop visible clinging to the cheek at the start?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the teardrop slide down the cheek, detach at the jawline, and hit the dark gray polished concrete floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the teardrop explode into a circle of crown-shaped water splashes upon hitting the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt downward at an extremely slow speed to track the entire movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08904055505990982 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.464040517807007 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08904055505990982, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08904055505990982, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06807903945446014, + 0.12496985495090485, + 0.05713159218430519, + 0.027035020291805267, + 0.11105073243379593, + 0.04411127045750618, + 0.14097960293293, + 0.28462982177734375, + 0.07372841984033585, + 0.06828465312719345 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08904055505990982 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In an extreme close-up, the camera tilts downward at an extremely slow speed, tracking the entirety of a single movement. The image begins with a cheek as smooth and delicate as porcelain, illuminated by a cool spotlight from above and sideways, revealing the skin's texture. A crystalline, perfectly shaped spherical teardrop, like a tiny diamond, clings to the skin. It pauses for a moment, its interior reflecting the blurred light and shadows surrounding it, before slowly and deliberately sliding down, leaving a trail of faint, moist shimmer across the cheek. When it reaches the jawline, it detaches from the skin, tracing an elegant yet weighty arc in the air. Throughout, the teardrop maintains its integrity against the dark background, shimmering with a solitary light. The camera continues to follow, and finally, this teardrop carrying silent emotions hits heavily on the dark gray, polished concrete floor below, and instantly explodes into a circle of extremely delicate crown-shaped water splashes. Countless tiny droplets splash in all directions, and then quickly merge into the reflection of the ground. The whole scene presents a solemn, sad and extremely focused atmosphere under the minimalist light and shadow.", + "seed": 21767, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_7/index_9781_seed_21767_dp_14_rank_28_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.12945743463933468, + "vlm_logprob": -0.12945743463933468, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.675, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.12945743463933468, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focusing on a human cheek with porcelain-like skin texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a crystalline, perfectly shaped spherical teardrop visible clinging to the cheek at the start?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the teardrop slide down the cheek, detach at the jawline, and hit the dark gray polished concrete floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the teardrop explode into a circle of crown-shaped water splashes upon hitting the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt downward at an extremely slow speed to track the entire movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02856641449034214 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.653566360473633 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02856641449034214, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02856641449034214, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4000760316848755, + 0.1382371038198471, + 0.0695519968867302, + 0.10219869762659073, + 0.0802193358540535, + 0.03179280087351799, + 0.05407125875353813, + 0.03144354000687599, + 0.024515576660633087, + 0.06789359450340271 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02856641449034214 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focusing on a human cheek with porcelain-like skin texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a crystalline, perfectly shaped spherical teardrop visible clinging to the cheek at the start?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the teardrop slide down the cheek, detach at the jawline, and hit the dark gray polished concrete floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the teardrop explode into a circle of crown-shaped water splashes upon hitting the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt downward at an extremely slow speed to track the entire movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.38710442185401917 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1371043920516968 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.38710442185401917, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.38710442185401917, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14588648080825806, + 0.07333347946405411, + 0.039468225091695786, + 0.057606860995292664, + 0.0556829497218132, + 0.03157518804073334, + 0.49926069378852844, + 0.03225138410925865, + 0.022569697350263596, + 0.04236503317952156 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.38710442185401917 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focusing on a human cheek with porcelain-like skin texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a crystalline, perfectly shaped spherical teardrop visible clinging to the cheek at the start?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the teardrop slide down the cheek, detach at the jawline, and hit the dark gray polished concrete floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the teardrop explode into a circle of crown-shaped water splashes upon hitting the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt downward at an extremely slow speed to track the entire movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009800177067518234 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634799957275391 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009800177067518234, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009800177067518234, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0753677487373352, + 0.1181836649775505, + 0.055725108832120895, + 0.020132647827267647, + 0.23607508838176727, + 0.04691200703382492, + 0.15437892079353333, + 0.14043262600898743, + 0.05641936883330345, + 0.09637283533811569 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009800177067518234 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focusing on a human cheek with porcelain-like skin texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a crystalline, perfectly shaped spherical teardrop visible clinging to the cheek at the start?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the teardrop slide down the cheek, detach at the jawline, and hit the dark gray polished concrete floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the teardrop explode into a circle of crown-shaped water splashes upon hitting the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt downward at an extremely slow speed to track the entire movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07899979501962662 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5789997577667236 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07899979501962662, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07899979501962662, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10097301006317139, + 0.09127839654684067, + 0.033529799431562424, + 0.06022365763783455, + 0.06503862142562866, + 0.08027084916830063, + 0.28736260533332825, + 0.10600103437900543, + 0.06565450131893158, + 0.10966747999191284 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07899979501962662 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focusing on a human cheek with porcelain-like skin texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a crystalline, perfectly shaped spherical teardrop visible clinging to the cheek at the start?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the teardrop slide down the cheek, detach at the jawline, and hit the dark gray polished concrete floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the teardrop explode into a circle of crown-shaped water splashes upon hitting the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt downward at an extremely slow speed to track the entire movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14281636476516724 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0178163051605225 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14281636476516724, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14281636476516724, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19156357645988464, + 0.26726680994033813, + 0.053008072078228, + 0.06665750592947006, + 0.06963060796260834, + 0.04602959752082825, + 0.08758361637592316, + 0.06059178709983826, + 0.09084431082010269, + 0.06682412326335907 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14281636476516724 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In an extreme close-up, the camera tilts downward at an extremely slow speed, tracking the entirety of a single movement. The image begins with a cheek as smooth and delicate as porcelain, illuminated by a cool spotlight from above and sideways, revealing the skin's texture. A crystalline, perfectly shaped spherical teardrop, like a tiny diamond, clings to the skin. It pauses for a moment, its interior reflecting the blurred light and shadows surrounding it, before slowly and deliberately sliding down, leaving a trail of faint, moist shimmer across the cheek. When it reaches the jawline, it detaches from the skin, tracing an elegant yet weighty arc in the air. Throughout, the teardrop maintains its integrity against the dark background, shimmering with a solitary light. The camera continues to follow, and finally, this teardrop carrying silent emotions hits heavily on the dark gray, polished concrete floor below, and instantly explodes into a circle of extremely delicate crown-shaped water splashes. Countless tiny droplets splash in all directions, and then quickly merge into the reflection of the ground. The whole scene presents a solemn, sad and extremely focused atmosphere under the minimalist light and shadow.", + "seed": 21768, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_7/index_9781_seed_21768_dp_15_rank_30_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.06066977088339627, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06066977088339627, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.4, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06066977088339627, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focusing on a human cheek with porcelain-like skin texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a crystalline, perfectly shaped spherical teardrop visible clinging to the cheek at the start?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the teardrop slide down the cheek, detach at the jawline, and hit the dark gray polished concrete floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the teardrop explode into a circle of crown-shaped water splashes upon hitting the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt downward at an extremely slow speed to track the entire movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.027092037722468376 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6520919799804688 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.027092037722468376, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.027092037722468376, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.26797378063201904, + 0.047939423471689224, + 0.08636265248060226, + 0.08720900863409042, + 0.13106533885002136, + 0.06707973778247833, + 0.1384108066558838, + 0.046364959329366684, + 0.0570327527821064, + 0.070561483502388 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.027092037722468376 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focusing on a human cheek with porcelain-like skin texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a crystalline, perfectly shaped spherical teardrop visible clinging to the cheek at the start?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the teardrop slide down the cheek, detach at the jawline, and hit the dark gray polished concrete floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the teardrop explode into a circle of crown-shaped water splashes upon hitting the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt downward at an extremely slow speed to track the entire movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16037581861019135 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9103758335113525 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16037581861019135, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16037581861019135, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20731155574321747, + 0.08720359951257706, + 0.04889153316617012, + 0.044879864901304245, + 0.06402912735939026, + 0.1071256697177887, + 0.1542603224515915, + 0.09713488817214966, + 0.06073920428752899, + 0.12842430174350739 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16037581861019135 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focusing on a human cheek with porcelain-like skin texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a crystalline, perfectly shaped spherical teardrop visible clinging to the cheek at the start?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the teardrop slide down the cheek, detach at the jawline, and hit the dark gray polished concrete floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the teardrop explode into a circle of crown-shaped water splashes upon hitting the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt downward at an extremely slow speed to track the entire movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00320064858533442 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753200531005859 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00320064858533442, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00320064858533442, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.33397236466407776, + 0.03199904412031174, + 0.05473603308200836, + 0.038628458976745605, + 0.0993153527379036, + 0.04827451705932617, + 0.047883130609989166, + 0.08881749212741852, + 0.07933467626571655, + 0.17703887820243835 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00320064858533442 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focusing on a human cheek with porcelain-like skin texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a crystalline, perfectly shaped spherical teardrop visible clinging to the cheek at the start?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the teardrop slide down the cheek, detach at the jawline, and hit the dark gray polished concrete floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the teardrop explode into a circle of crown-shaped water splashes upon hitting the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt downward at an extremely slow speed to track the entire movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03369740769267082 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4086973667144775 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03369740769267082, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03369740769267082, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13608939945697784, + 0.02586979605257511, + 0.028601747006177902, + 0.021765433251857758, + 0.07831461727619171, + 0.11583192646503448, + 0.1767011135816574, + 0.11383862048387527, + 0.20731952786445618, + 0.09566789120435715 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03369740769267082 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focusing on a human cheek with porcelain-like skin texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a crystalline, perfectly shaped spherical teardrop visible clinging to the cheek at the start?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the teardrop slide down the cheek, detach at the jawline, and hit the dark gray polished concrete floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the teardrop explode into a circle of crown-shaped water splashes upon hitting the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt downward at an extremely slow speed to track the entire movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07898294180631638 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5789828300476074 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07898294180631638, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07898294180631638, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08854285627603531, + 0.08256636559963226, + 0.09546446800231934, + 0.059083450585603714, + 0.14882515370845795, + 0.09795602411031723, + 0.1800547093153, + 0.052233390510082245, + 0.08287561684846878, + 0.11239797621965408 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07898294180631638 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In an extreme close-up, the camera tilts downward at an extremely slow speed, tracking the entirety of a single movement. The image begins with a cheek as smooth and delicate as porcelain, illuminated by a cool spotlight from above and sideways, revealing the skin's texture. A crystalline, perfectly shaped spherical teardrop, like a tiny diamond, clings to the skin. It pauses for a moment, its interior reflecting the blurred light and shadows surrounding it, before slowly and deliberately sliding down, leaving a trail of faint, moist shimmer across the cheek. When it reaches the jawline, it detaches from the skin, tracing an elegant yet weighty arc in the air. Throughout, the teardrop maintains its integrity against the dark background, shimmering with a solitary light. The camera continues to follow, and finally, this teardrop carrying silent emotions hits heavily on the dark gray, polished concrete floor below, and instantly explodes into a circle of extremely delicate crown-shaped water splashes. Countless tiny droplets splash in all directions, and then quickly merge into the reflection of the ground. The whole scene presents a solemn, sad and extremely focused atmosphere under the minimalist light and shadow.", + "seed": 21769, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_7/index_9781_seed_21769_dp_15_rank_30_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.04655181895941496, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04655181895941496, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.525, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04655181895941496, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focusing on a human cheek with porcelain-like skin texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a crystalline, perfectly shaped spherical teardrop visible clinging to the cheek at the start?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the teardrop slide down the cheek, detach at the jawline, and hit the dark gray polished concrete floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the teardrop explode into a circle of crown-shaped water splashes upon hitting the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt downward at an extremely slow speed to track the entire movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.027287285774946213 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.652287244796753 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.027287285774946213, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.027287285774946213, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1251976639032364, + 0.10395943373441696, + 0.08566144108772278, + 0.08017724752426147, + 0.039985284209251404, + 0.09026768803596497, + 0.13893112540245056, + 0.054422810673713684, + 0.052853185683488846, + 0.22854414582252502 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.027287285774946213 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focusing on a human cheek with porcelain-like skin texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a crystalline, perfectly shaped spherical teardrop visible clinging to the cheek at the start?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the teardrop slide down the cheek, detach at the jawline, and hit the dark gray polished concrete floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the teardrop explode into a circle of crown-shaped water splashes upon hitting the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt downward at an extremely slow speed to track the entire movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.062085479497909546 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120853900909424 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.062085479497909546, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.062085479497909546, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.083139568567276, + 0.1527865082025528, + 0.059587135910987854, + 0.06595533341169357, + 0.04168654978275299, + 0.14649933576583862, + 0.1320364624261856, + 0.08143705874681473, + 0.07809025049209595, + 0.1587817519903183 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.062085479497909546 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focusing on a human cheek with porcelain-like skin texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a crystalline, perfectly shaped spherical teardrop visible clinging to the cheek at the start?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the teardrop slide down the cheek, detach at the jawline, and hit the dark gray polished concrete floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the teardrop explode into a circle of crown-shaped water splashes upon hitting the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt downward at an extremely slow speed to track the entire movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004101318307220936 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504101276397705 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004101318307220936, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004101318307220936, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.024854246526956558, + 0.06703955680131912, + 0.08601171523332596, + 0.03344978764653206, + 0.0916576161980629, + 0.10905012488365173, + 0.16978201270103455, + 0.055457279086112976, + 0.17863965034484863, + 0.18405801057815552 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004101318307220936 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focusing on a human cheek with porcelain-like skin texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a crystalline, perfectly shaped spherical teardrop visible clinging to the cheek at the start?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the teardrop slide down the cheek, detach at the jawline, and hit the dark gray polished concrete floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the teardrop explode into a circle of crown-shaped water splashes upon hitting the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt downward at an extremely slow speed to track the entire movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02634584717452526 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651345729827881 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02634584717452526, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02634584717452526, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07238001376390457, + 0.09201738983392715, + 0.03895311802625656, + 0.050559960305690765, + 0.06942687928676605, + 0.049086201936006546, + 0.0771854817867279, + 0.09900914132595062, + 0.13565795123577118, + 0.3157239258289337 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02634584717452526 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focusing on a human cheek with porcelain-like skin texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a crystalline, perfectly shaped spherical teardrop visible clinging to the cheek at the start?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the teardrop slide down the cheek, detach at the jawline, and hit the dark gray polished concrete floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the teardrop explode into a circle of crown-shaped water splashes upon hitting the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt downward at an extremely slow speed to track the entire movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11293916404247284 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2379391193389893 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11293916404247284, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11293916404247284, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.046456921845674515, + 0.029240094125270844, + 0.07396433502435684, + 0.05724691227078438, + 0.111323282122612, + 0.05174332112073898, + 0.0942162275314331, + 0.13805972039699554, + 0.16302742063999176, + 0.23472175002098083 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11293916404247284 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_8/index_tensor([5200, 5200])_group_8_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_8/index_tensor([5200, 5200])_group_8_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..40eba762e64d0d4372d76c237f44aa3e9ddd0cc4 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_8/index_tensor([5200, 5200])_group_8_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "slowly zooming shot, viewed from a slightly upward angle, initially focuses on a giant octopus tentacle, as thick as an ancient tree trunk. Its skin, a mix of dark purple and deep reddish-brown, is covered in a thin layer of bioluminescent mucus. In the abyss, devoid of natural light, this mucus casts a cold, ever-shifting blue-green glow, illuminating the tentacle's dense cluster of suction cups of varying sizes. The interior of these cups appears pale, almost translucent. As the camera pulls out, we see the tentacle, with slow yet irresistible force, entangling itself around an ancient Greek-style stone statue of a warrior. The statue's surface, pitted by age and the pressure of the deep sea, is now covered in a thick layer of green algae and white, tube-like worms. Carefully and steadily, the octopus's tentacle winds upward, starting from the statue's base, following the warrior's carved leg muscles, and finally wrapping around his arm, which clenched his spear. Its powerful suction cups cling tightly to the mottled stone surface. The entire scene is immersed in deep, almost inky black sea water. Countless tiny, luminous plankton float slowly like stardust, and the outlines of more dilapidated buildings can be vaguely seen in the distance, creating an atmosphere of tranquility, mystery, and a hint of ancient sadness and awe.", + "seed": 31435, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_8/index_5200_seed_31435_dp_16_rank_32_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.21532534584403037, + "vlm_logprob": -0.21532534584403037, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.0249999523162843, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.21532534584403037, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a giant octopus tentacle as thick as an ancient tree trunk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tentacle's skin dark purple and deep reddish-brown with bioluminescent mucus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tentacle entangle an ancient Greek-style stone statue of a warrior covered in green algae and white tube-like worms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a close-up on the tentacle and slowly zoom out to reveal the statue and surrounding environment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in deep, inky black sea water with tiny luminous plankton floating like stardust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8990589380264282 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5240589380264282 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.8990589380264282, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.8990589380264282, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14740166068077087, + 0.18082286417484283, + 0.09519399702548981, + 0.06802147626876831, + 0.06905217468738556, + 0.13154548406600952, + 0.18132872879505157, + 0.03999309986829758, + 0.04472694918513298, + 0.04191359877586365 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.8990589380264282 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a giant octopus tentacle as thick as an ancient tree trunk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tentacle's skin dark purple and deep reddish-brown with bioluminescent mucus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tentacle entangle an ancient Greek-style stone statue of a warrior covered in green algae and white tube-like worms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a close-up on the tentacle and slowly zoom out to reveal the statue and surrounding environment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in deep, inky black sea water with tiny luminous plankton floating like stardust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14284540712833405 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.017845392227173 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14284540712833405, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14284540712833405, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19191022217273712, + 0.15416409075260162, + 0.12909163534641266, + 0.057972997426986694, + 0.06339975446462631, + 0.06441830843687057, + 0.15754391252994537, + 0.04676453024148941, + 0.11024676263332367, + 0.024487728253006935 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14284540712833405 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a giant octopus tentacle as thick as an ancient tree trunk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tentacle's skin dark purple and deep reddish-brown with bioluminescent mucus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tentacle entangle an ancient Greek-style stone statue of a warrior covered in green algae and white tube-like worms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a close-up on the tentacle and slowly zoom out to reveal the statue and surrounding environment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in deep, inky black sea water with tiny luminous plankton floating like stardust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006747911684215069 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006747722625732 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006747911684215069, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006747911684215069, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18275736272335052, + 0.11314539611339569, + 0.08788853883743286, + 0.04909493401646614, + 0.09866470843553543, + 0.07943470776081085, + 0.19673684239387512, + 0.054295994341373444, + 0.0693703293800354, + 0.06861118227243423 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006747911684215069 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a giant octopus tentacle as thick as an ancient tree trunk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tentacle's skin dark purple and deep reddish-brown with bioluminescent mucus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tentacle entangle an ancient Greek-style stone statue of a warrior covered in green algae and white tube-like worms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a close-up on the tentacle and slowly zoom out to reveal the statue and surrounding environment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in deep, inky black sea water with tiny luminous plankton floating like stardust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018190113827586174 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018189907073975 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018190113827586174, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018190113827586174, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.30701181292533875, + 0.3231816291809082, + 0.031786173582077026, + 0.04692972078919411, + 0.03785325586795807, + 0.029869722202420235, + 0.060342300683259964, + 0.11203847080469131, + 0.023536676540970802, + 0.027450207620859146 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018190113827586174 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a giant octopus tentacle as thick as an ancient tree trunk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tentacle's skin dark purple and deep reddish-brown with bioluminescent mucus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tentacle entangle an ancient Greek-style stone statue of a warrior covered in green algae and white tube-like worms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a close-up on the tentacle and slowly zoom out to reveal the statue and surrounding environment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in deep, inky black sea water with tiny luminous plankton floating like stardust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00978435855358839 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.63478422164917 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00978435855358839, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00978435855358839, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1969529688358307, + 0.28800833225250244, + 0.08642345666885376, + 0.033776894211769104, + 0.028584280982613564, + 0.06774826347827911, + 0.13079160451889038, + 0.053154706954956055, + 0.04060003161430359, + 0.07395941019058228 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00978435855358839 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slowly zooming shot, viewed from a slightly upward angle, initially focuses on a giant octopus tentacle, as thick as an ancient tree trunk. Its skin, a mix of dark purple and deep reddish-brown, is covered in a thin layer of bioluminescent mucus. In the abyss, devoid of natural light, this mucus casts a cold, ever-shifting blue-green glow, illuminating the tentacle's dense cluster of suction cups of varying sizes. The interior of these cups appears pale, almost translucent. As the camera pulls out, we see the tentacle, with slow yet irresistible force, entangling itself around an ancient Greek-style stone statue of a warrior. The statue's surface, pitted by age and the pressure of the deep sea, is now covered in a thick layer of green algae and white, tube-like worms. Carefully and steadily, the octopus's tentacle winds upward, starting from the statue's base, following the warrior's carved leg muscles, and finally wrapping around his arm, which clenched his spear. Its powerful suction cups cling tightly to the mottled stone surface. The entire scene is immersed in deep, almost inky black sea water. Countless tiny, luminous plankton float slowly like stardust, and the outlines of more dilapidated buildings can be vaguely seen in the distance, creating an atmosphere of tranquility, mystery, and a hint of ancient sadness and awe.", + "seed": 31436, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_8/index_5200_seed_31436_dp_16_rank_32_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.08947478849440813, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08947478849440813, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.6, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08947478849440813, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a giant octopus tentacle as thick as an ancient tree trunk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tentacle's skin dark purple and deep reddish-brown with bioluminescent mucus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tentacle entangle an ancient Greek-style stone statue of a warrior covered in green algae and white tube-like worms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a close-up on the tentacle and slowly zoom out to reveal the statue and surrounding environment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in deep, inky black sea water with tiny luminous plankton floating like stardust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3890751898288727 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1390751600265503 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3890751898288727, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3890751898288727, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19986648857593536, + 0.09523171186447144, + 0.1958354115486145, + 0.1910674124956131, + 0.07221049815416336, + 0.05911022797226906, + 0.04602948948740959, + 0.06070644408464432, + 0.04006623104214668, + 0.03987608477473259 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3890751898288727 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a giant octopus tentacle as thick as an ancient tree trunk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tentacle's skin dark purple and deep reddish-brown with bioluminescent mucus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tentacle entangle an ancient Greek-style stone statue of a warrior covered in green algae and white tube-like worms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a close-up on the tentacle and slowly zoom out to reveal the statue and surrounding environment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in deep, inky black sea water with tiny luminous plankton floating like stardust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026363030076026917 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513631343841553 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026363030076026917, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026363030076026917, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16071929037570953, + 0.16590498387813568, + 0.35868218541145325, + 0.0670814961194992, + 0.0731063261628151, + 0.03339112550020218, + 0.03765609487891197, + 0.0321061834692955, + 0.036199964582920074, + 0.035152312368154526 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026363030076026917 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a giant octopus tentacle as thick as an ancient tree trunk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tentacle's skin dark purple and deep reddish-brown with bioluminescent mucus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tentacle entangle an ancient Greek-style stone statue of a warrior covered in green algae and white tube-like worms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a close-up on the tentacle and slowly zoom out to reveal the statue and surrounding environment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in deep, inky black sea water with tiny luminous plankton floating like stardust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011079221963882446 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.51107931137085 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011079221963882446, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011079221963882446, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07929166406393051, + 0.04695257171988487, + 0.30622997879981995, + 0.2058383971452713, + 0.0690368115901947, + 0.04990365728735924, + 0.047403741627931595, + 0.07134057581424713, + 0.05637563765048981, + 0.06762699037790298 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011079221963882446 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a giant octopus tentacle as thick as an ancient tree trunk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tentacle's skin dark purple and deep reddish-brown with bioluminescent mucus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tentacle entangle an ancient Greek-style stone statue of a warrior covered in green algae and white tube-like worms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a close-up on the tentacle and slowly zoom out to reveal the statue and surrounding environment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in deep, inky black sea water with tiny luminous plankton floating like stardust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01107639167457819 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.5110764503479 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01107639167457819, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01107639167457819, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19724705815315247, + 0.11159008741378784, + 0.07676540315151215, + 0.16989529132843018, + 0.18248338997364044, + 0.08339939266443253, + 0.043970610946416855, + 0.0336897112429142, + 0.04090779647231102, + 0.060051240026950836 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01107639167457819 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a giant octopus tentacle as thick as an ancient tree trunk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tentacle's skin dark purple and deep reddish-brown with bioluminescent mucus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tentacle entangle an ancient Greek-style stone statue of a warrior covered in green algae and white tube-like worms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a close-up on the tentacle and slowly zoom out to reveal the statue and surrounding environment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in deep, inky black sea water with tiny luminous plankton floating like stardust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00978010892868042 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634779930114746 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00978010892868042, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00978010892868042, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07378126680850983, + 0.04358159750699997, + 0.22119538486003876, + 0.24478299915790558, + 0.05068489909172058, + 0.18918387591838837, + 0.06484728306531906, + 0.061461787670850754, + 0.03611420840024948, + 0.014366714283823967 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00978010892868042 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slowly zooming shot, viewed from a slightly upward angle, initially focuses on a giant octopus tentacle, as thick as an ancient tree trunk. Its skin, a mix of dark purple and deep reddish-brown, is covered in a thin layer of bioluminescent mucus. In the abyss, devoid of natural light, this mucus casts a cold, ever-shifting blue-green glow, illuminating the tentacle's dense cluster of suction cups of varying sizes. The interior of these cups appears pale, almost translucent. As the camera pulls out, we see the tentacle, with slow yet irresistible force, entangling itself around an ancient Greek-style stone statue of a warrior. The statue's surface, pitted by age and the pressure of the deep sea, is now covered in a thick layer of green algae and white, tube-like worms. Carefully and steadily, the octopus's tentacle winds upward, starting from the statue's base, following the warrior's carved leg muscles, and finally wrapping around his arm, which clenched his spear. Its powerful suction cups cling tightly to the mottled stone surface. The entire scene is immersed in deep, almost inky black sea water. Countless tiny, luminous plankton float slowly like stardust, and the outlines of more dilapidated buildings can be vaguely seen in the distance, creating an atmosphere of tranquility, mystery, and a hint of ancient sadness and awe.", + "seed": 31437, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_8/index_5200_seed_31437_dp_17_rank_34_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.03088102536275983, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03088102536275983, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.025, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03088102536275983, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a giant octopus tentacle as thick as an ancient tree trunk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tentacle's skin dark purple and deep reddish-brown with bioluminescent mucus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tentacle entangle an ancient Greek-style stone statue of a warrior covered in green algae and white tube-like worms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a close-up on the tentacle and slowly zoom out to reveal the statue and surrounding environment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in deep, inky black sea water with tiny luminous plankton floating like stardust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08086737245321274 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.580867290496826 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08086737245321274, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08086737245321274, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3066260516643524, + 0.17402714490890503, + 0.0956493392586708, + 0.104998379945755, + 0.056899070739746094, + 0.0315549336373806, + 0.020305562764406204, + 0.04888005182147026, + 0.0656936764717102, + 0.09536577761173248 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08086737245321274 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a giant octopus tentacle as thick as an ancient tree trunk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tentacle's skin dark purple and deep reddish-brown with bioluminescent mucus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tentacle entangle an ancient Greek-style stone statue of a warrior covered in green algae and white tube-like worms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a close-up on the tentacle and slowly zoom out to reveal the statue and surrounding environment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in deep, inky black sea water with tiny luminous plankton floating like stardust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02059059962630272 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955905437469482 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02059059962630272, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02059059962630272, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17181681096553802, + 0.3966018855571747, + 0.11600683629512787, + 0.045003365725278854, + 0.05659255012869835, + 0.05617682635784149, + 0.01616298407316208, + 0.06532527506351471, + 0.017471833154559135, + 0.05884156376123428 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02059059962630272 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a giant octopus tentacle as thick as an ancient tree trunk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tentacle's skin dark purple and deep reddish-brown with bioluminescent mucus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tentacle entangle an ancient Greek-style stone statue of a warrior covered in green algae and white tube-like worms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a close-up on the tentacle and slowly zoom out to reveal the statue and surrounding environment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in deep, inky black sea water with tiny luminous plankton floating like stardust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0046426597982645035 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379642486572266 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0046426597982645035, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0046426597982645035, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08753485977649689, + 0.18981815874576569, + 0.13061898946762085, + 0.08843229711055756, + 0.0934332013130188, + 0.09058473259210587, + 0.06687924265861511, + 0.16871988773345947, + 0.026766309514641762, + 0.05721237510442734 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 7, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0046426597982645035 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a giant octopus tentacle as thick as an ancient tree trunk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tentacle's skin dark purple and deep reddish-brown with bioluminescent mucus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tentacle entangle an ancient Greek-style stone statue of a warrior covered in green algae and white tube-like worms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a close-up on the tentacle and slowly zoom out to reveal the statue and surrounding environment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in deep, inky black sea water with tiny luminous plankton floating like stardust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0430544950067997 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680545806884766 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0430544950067997, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0430544950067997, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20290322601795197, + 0.13804303109645844, + 0.05169909447431564, + 0.18308167159557343, + 0.10027608275413513, + 0.08269289880990982, + 0.0239347442984581, + 0.07451330870389938, + 0.030063938349485397, + 0.1127919927239418 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0430544950067997 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a giant octopus tentacle as thick as an ancient tree trunk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tentacle's skin dark purple and deep reddish-brown with bioluminescent mucus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tentacle entangle an ancient Greek-style stone statue of a warrior covered in green algae and white tube-like worms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a close-up on the tentacle and slowly zoom out to reveal the statue and surrounding environment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in deep, inky black sea water with tiny luminous plankton floating like stardust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005249999929219484 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255249977111816 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005249999929219484, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005249999929219484, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2781313359737396, + 0.12567022442817688, + 0.06090592220425606, + 0.05723319947719574, + 0.09551078081130981, + 0.08528319746255875, + 0.06038355082273483, + 0.09744280576705933, + 0.01666092313826084, + 0.12277806550264359 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005249999929219484 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slowly zooming shot, viewed from a slightly upward angle, initially focuses on a giant octopus tentacle, as thick as an ancient tree trunk. Its skin, a mix of dark purple and deep reddish-brown, is covered in a thin layer of bioluminescent mucus. In the abyss, devoid of natural light, this mucus casts a cold, ever-shifting blue-green glow, illuminating the tentacle's dense cluster of suction cups of varying sizes. The interior of these cups appears pale, almost translucent. As the camera pulls out, we see the tentacle, with slow yet irresistible force, entangling itself around an ancient Greek-style stone statue of a warrior. The statue's surface, pitted by age and the pressure of the deep sea, is now covered in a thick layer of green algae and white, tube-like worms. Carefully and steadily, the octopus's tentacle winds upward, starting from the statue's base, following the warrior's carved leg muscles, and finally wrapping around his arm, which clenched his spear. Its powerful suction cups cling tightly to the mottled stone surface. The entire scene is immersed in deep, almost inky black sea water. Countless tiny, luminous plankton float slowly like stardust, and the outlines of more dilapidated buildings can be vaguely seen in the distance, creating an atmosphere of tranquility, mystery, and a hint of ancient sadness and awe.", + "seed": 31438, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_8/index_5200_seed_31438_dp_17_rank_34_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.05012046778574586, + "vlm_logprob": -0.05012046778574586, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.675, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.05012046778574586, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a giant octopus tentacle as thick as an ancient tree trunk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tentacle's skin dark purple and deep reddish-brown with bioluminescent mucus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tentacle entangle an ancient Greek-style stone statue of a warrior covered in green algae and white tube-like worms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a close-up on the tentacle and slowly zoom out to reveal the statue and surrounding environment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in deep, inky black sea water with tiny luminous plankton floating like stardust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14402765035629272 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0190277099609375 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14402765035629272, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14402765035629272, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.34651482105255127, + 0.09179607033729553, + 0.05230901762843132, + 0.04815574735403061, + 0.07782870531082153, + 0.07340361177921295, + 0.06239777430891991, + 0.06086134538054466, + 0.09480948001146317, + 0.09192346781492233 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14402765035629272 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a giant octopus tentacle as thick as an ancient tree trunk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tentacle's skin dark purple and deep reddish-brown with bioluminescent mucus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tentacle entangle an ancient Greek-style stone statue of a warrior covered in green algae and white tube-like worms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a close-up on the tentacle and slowly zoom out to reveal the statue and surrounding environment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in deep, inky black sea water with tiny luminous plankton floating like stardust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023296110332012177 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732961177825928 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023296110332012177, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023296110332012177, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2785642743110657, + 0.09478530287742615, + 0.15514451265335083, + 0.15754882991313934, + 0.05985715240240097, + 0.07789881527423859, + 0.04359627142548561, + 0.049391768872737885, + 0.04030245542526245, + 0.04291069507598877 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023296110332012177 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a giant octopus tentacle as thick as an ancient tree trunk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tentacle's skin dark purple and deep reddish-brown with bioluminescent mucus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tentacle entangle an ancient Greek-style stone statue of a warrior covered in green algae and white tube-like worms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a close-up on the tentacle and slowly zoom out to reveal the statue and surrounding environment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in deep, inky black sea water with tiny luminous plankton floating like stardust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004640643019229174 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379640579223633 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004640643019229174, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004640643019229174, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15464597940444946, + 0.10379186272621155, + 0.09587916731834412, + 0.10105337202548981, + 0.05815907195210457, + 0.1429441273212433, + 0.10767459124326706, + 0.0618070513010025, + 0.10057473927736282, + 0.07347001880407333 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004640643019229174 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a giant octopus tentacle as thick as an ancient tree trunk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tentacle's skin dark purple and deep reddish-brown with bioluminescent mucus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tentacle entangle an ancient Greek-style stone statue of a warrior covered in green algae and white tube-like worms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a close-up on the tentacle and slowly zoom out to reveal the statue and surrounding environment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in deep, inky black sea water with tiny luminous plankton floating like stardust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07000403106212616 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950039863586426 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07000403106212616, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07000403106212616, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2127007097005844, + 0.16619810461997986, + 0.11469654738903046, + 0.0455121286213398, + 0.09283614903688431, + 0.08615656942129135, + 0.061174117028713226, + 0.12460944056510925, + 0.03491394594311714, + 0.0612022839486599 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07000403106212616 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a giant octopus tentacle as thick as an ancient tree trunk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tentacle's skin dark purple and deep reddish-brown with bioluminescent mucus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tentacle entangle an ancient Greek-style stone statue of a warrior covered in green algae and white tube-like worms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a close-up on the tentacle and slowly zoom out to reveal the statue and surrounding environment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in deep, inky black sea water with tiny luminous plankton floating like stardust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008633904159069061 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758634090423584 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008633904159069061, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008633904159069061, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3116641640663147, + 0.09641099721193314, + 0.09708503633737564, + 0.06472817063331604, + 0.08037544041872025, + 0.07303575426340103, + 0.12024524062871933, + 0.03309224918484688, + 0.046037472784519196, + 0.0773254781961441 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008633904159069061 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_9/index_tensor([4324, 4324])_group_9_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_9/index_tensor([4324, 4324])_group_9_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..5d51702aef14ed0b0efbd0fd656bb6d4a8eb2033 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_9/index_tensor([4324, 4324])_group_9_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "medium shot, framed from the side and panning slowly to the right, captures a pair of dancers in an ornate room, capturing them in a moment of profound intimacy and artistry. The male dancer, wearing a loose, off-white linen shirt with sleeves casually rolled to the elbows and paired with dark, slim-fitting trousers, has slightly curled dark brown hair and gazes intently and tenderly at his partner. The female dancer, clad in an emerald silk gown that flows gracefully across the floor with their gentle steps, wears her auburn hair loosely tied in a low bun, with strands cascading down her neck. A serene, captivated smile lingers on her face. Their bodies are pressed tightly together, their movements fluid and synchronized, as if the only sounds in the world are their breathing and heartbeats. Beside them, a large vintage Chesterfield sofa sits quietly, its crimson velvet fabric shimmering in the light, its delicate buttons and pulls and dark, carved wood armrests revealing the texture of time. The entire scene is bathed in a dramatic, soft light, as if streaming in through a tall window. The light precisely outlines the dancers' bodies and the folds of their clothing, casting long, soft shadows on the floor. This striking contrast of light and dark, the rich, slightly faded color palette, and the depth of the characters' emotions all combine to create the rich storytelling and painterly quality that are hallmarks of Annie Leibovitz's photography, imbuing the image with a tranquility, intimacy, and timeless romance.", + "seed": 3471, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_9/index_4324_seed_3471_dp_18_rank_36_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.1310750207863748, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1310750207863748, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.5, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1310750207863748, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are two dancers visible, with the male wearing an off-white linen shirt and dark trousers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the female dancer wearing an emerald silk gown with her hair in a low bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a large vintage Chesterfield sofa with crimson velvet fabric visible beside the dancers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.046615537256002426 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1716156005859375 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.046615537256002426, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.046615537256002426, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25559669733047485, + 0.10774889588356018, + 0.03819875046610832, + 0.046116311103105545, + 0.07454531639814377, + 0.03483076021075249, + 0.1577616035938263, + 0.02909277379512787, + 0.08772648125886917, + 0.16838234663009644 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.046615537256002426 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are two dancers visible, with the male wearing an off-white linen shirt and dark trousers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the female dancer wearing an emerald silk gown with her hair in a low bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a large vintage Chesterfield sofa with crimson velvet fabric visible beside the dancers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5761716365814209 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8261716365814209 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5761716365814209, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5761716365814209, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12938247621059418, + 0.12133657932281494, + 0.07977434247732162, + 0.08063073456287384, + 0.2345411330461502, + 0.1362813413143158, + 0.07454957067966461, + 0.037345901131629944, + 0.0383213646709919, + 0.06783656030893326 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5761716365814209 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are two dancers visible, with the male wearing an off-white linen shirt and dark trousers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the female dancer wearing an emerald silk gown with her hair in a low bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a large vintage Chesterfield sofa with crimson velvet fabric visible beside the dancers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0052625699900090694 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.25526237487793 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0052625699900090694, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0052625699900090694, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2743223309516907, + 0.10375484824180603, + 0.08615628629922867, + 0.07368113100528717, + 0.15108534693717957, + 0.04783935472369194, + 0.027548590674996376, + 0.12582619488239288, + 0.029458334669470787, + 0.08032754808664322 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0052625699900090694 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are two dancers visible, with the male wearing an off-white linen shirt and dark trousers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the female dancer wearing an emerald silk gown with her hair in a low bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a large vintage Chesterfield sofa with crimson velvet fabric visible beside the dancers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020591065287590027 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955910205841064 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020591065287590027, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020591065287590027, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1451236754655838, + 0.1539597511291504, + 0.04734243080019951, + 0.0512416698038578, + 0.2930119037628174, + 0.08037858456373215, + 0.04434828832745552, + 0.0957709401845932, + 0.02374984882771969, + 0.06507290154695511 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020591065287590027 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are two dancers visible, with the male wearing an off-white linen shirt and dark trousers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the female dancer wearing an emerald silk gown with her hair in a low bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a large vintage Chesterfield sofa with crimson velvet fabric visible beside the dancers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006734294816851616 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006734371185303 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006734294816851616, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006734294816851616, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1963745802640915, + 0.13734716176986694, + 0.0765574723482132, + 0.13570567965507507, + 0.15771058201789856, + 0.08335162699222565, + 0.08538208901882172, + 0.02330455742776394, + 0.035994984209537506, + 0.0682712271809578 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006734294816851616 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "medium shot, framed from the side and panning slowly to the right, captures a pair of dancers in an ornate room, capturing them in a moment of profound intimacy and artistry. The male dancer, wearing a loose, off-white linen shirt with sleeves casually rolled to the elbows and paired with dark, slim-fitting trousers, has slightly curled dark brown hair and gazes intently and tenderly at his partner. The female dancer, clad in an emerald silk gown that flows gracefully across the floor with their gentle steps, wears her auburn hair loosely tied in a low bun, with strands cascading down her neck. A serene, captivated smile lingers on her face. Their bodies are pressed tightly together, their movements fluid and synchronized, as if the only sounds in the world are their breathing and heartbeats. Beside them, a large vintage Chesterfield sofa sits quietly, its crimson velvet fabric shimmering in the light, its delicate buttons and pulls and dark, carved wood armrests revealing the texture of time. The entire scene is bathed in a dramatic, soft light, as if streaming in through a tall window. The light precisely outlines the dancers' bodies and the folds of their clothing, casting long, soft shadows on the floor. This striking contrast of light and dark, the rich, slightly faded color palette, and the depth of the characters' emotions all combine to create the rich storytelling and painterly quality that are hallmarks of Annie Leibovitz's photography, imbuing the image with a tranquility, intimacy, and timeless romance.", + "seed": 3472, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_9/index_4324_seed_3472_dp_18_rank_36_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.1019452412147075, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1019452412147075, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.674999952316284, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1019452412147075, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are two dancers visible, with the male wearing an off-white linen shirt and dark trousers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the female dancer wearing an emerald silk gown with her hair in a low bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a large vintage Chesterfield sofa with crimson velvet fabric visible beside the dancers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.052179109305143356 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0521790981292725 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.052179109305143356, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.052179109305143356, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15007026493549347, + 0.08766749501228333, + 0.05897700414061546, + 0.05773761868476868, + 0.07748797535896301, + 0.1311907321214676, + 0.0523986853659153, + 0.04830627515912056, + 0.24257932603359222, + 0.09358465671539307 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.052179109305143356 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are two dancers visible, with the male wearing an off-white linen shirt and dark trousers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the female dancer wearing an emerald silk gown with her hair in a low bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a large vintage Chesterfield sofa with crimson velvet fabric visible beside the dancers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.428909569978714 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.0539095401763916 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.428909569978714, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.428909569978714, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.055818330496549606, + 0.042837176471948624, + 0.07222133129835129, + 0.05983031168580055, + 0.17153768241405487, + 0.03979441151022911, + 0.04598330333828926, + 0.041054971516132355, + 0.40126094222068787, + 0.06966147571802139 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.428909569978714 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are two dancers visible, with the male wearing an off-white linen shirt and dark trousers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the female dancer wearing an emerald silk gown with her hair in a low bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a large vintage Chesterfield sofa with crimson velvet fabric visible beside the dancers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0028255560901015997 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877825736999512 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0028255560901015997, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0028255560901015997, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08493572473526001, + 0.07084932178258896, + 0.13744129240512848, + 0.08301616460084915, + 0.10947661846876144, + 0.05956873670220375, + 0.043208856135606766, + 0.07558532059192657, + 0.18279202282428741, + 0.15312589704990387 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0028255560901015997 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are two dancers visible, with the male wearing an off-white linen shirt and dark trousers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the female dancer wearing an emerald silk gown with her hair in a low bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a large vintage Chesterfield sofa with crimson velvet fabric visible beside the dancers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018189646303653717 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018189430236816 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018189646303653717, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018189646303653717, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.058963946998119354, + 0.058383338153362274, + 0.06799273937940598, + 0.06463688611984253, + 0.1873951107263565, + 0.08293626457452774, + 0.028545022010803223, + 0.09390990436077118, + 0.13674376904964447, + 0.22049300372600555 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018189646303653717 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are two dancers visible, with the male wearing an off-white linen shirt and dark trousers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the female dancer wearing an emerald silk gown with her hair in a low bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a large vintage Chesterfield sofa with crimson velvet fabric visible beside the dancers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007622324395924807 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882622241973877 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007622324395924807, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007622324395924807, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12752120196819305, + 0.05860346555709839, + 0.07872394472360611, + 0.1930992305278778, + 0.09916635602712631, + 0.08932184427976608, + 0.06734420359134674, + 0.08454886823892593, + 0.11953040212392807, + 0.08214042335748672 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007622324395924807 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "medium shot, framed from the side and panning slowly to the right, captures a pair of dancers in an ornate room, capturing them in a moment of profound intimacy and artistry. The male dancer, wearing a loose, off-white linen shirt with sleeves casually rolled to the elbows and paired with dark, slim-fitting trousers, has slightly curled dark brown hair and gazes intently and tenderly at his partner. The female dancer, clad in an emerald silk gown that flows gracefully across the floor with their gentle steps, wears her auburn hair loosely tied in a low bun, with strands cascading down her neck. A serene, captivated smile lingers on her face. Their bodies are pressed tightly together, their movements fluid and synchronized, as if the only sounds in the world are their breathing and heartbeats. Beside them, a large vintage Chesterfield sofa sits quietly, its crimson velvet fabric shimmering in the light, its delicate buttons and pulls and dark, carved wood armrests revealing the texture of time. The entire scene is bathed in a dramatic, soft light, as if streaming in through a tall window. The light precisely outlines the dancers' bodies and the folds of their clothing, casting long, soft shadows on the floor. This striking contrast of light and dark, the rich, slightly faded color palette, and the depth of the characters' emotions all combine to create the rich storytelling and painterly quality that are hallmarks of Annie Leibovitz's photography, imbuing the image with a tranquility, intimacy, and timeless romance.", + "seed": 3473, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_9/index_4324_seed_3473_dp_19_rank_38_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.05340918516740203, + "vlm_logprob": -0.05340918516740203, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.25, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.05340918516740203, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are two dancers visible, with the male wearing an off-white linen shirt and dark trousers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the female dancer wearing an emerald silk gown with her hair in a low bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a large vintage Chesterfield sofa with crimson velvet fabric visible beside the dancers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018819818273186684 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.268819808959961 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018819818273186684, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018819818273186684, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25680363178253174, + 0.06622850894927979, + 0.12312853336334229, + 0.02799513377249241, + 0.09935916215181351, + 0.07243925333023071, + 0.11321543902158737, + 0.11753177642822266, + 0.051159195601940155, + 0.07213937491178513 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018819818273186684 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are two dancers visible, with the male wearing an off-white linen shirt and dark trousers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the female dancer wearing an emerald silk gown with her hair in a low bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a large vintage Chesterfield sofa with crimson velvet fabric visible beside the dancers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22557665407657623 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.600576639175415 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.22557665407657623, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.22557665407657623, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06982658803462982, + 0.07723352313041687, + 0.0351611003279686, + 0.04743470996618271, + 0.1159435510635376, + 0.13143718242645264, + 0.24132224917411804, + 0.05125083401799202, + 0.03681062161922455, + 0.19357961416244507 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.22557665407657623 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are two dancers visible, with the male wearing an off-white linen shirt and dark trousers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the female dancer wearing an emerald silk gown with her hair in a low bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a large vintage Chesterfield sofa with crimson velvet fabric visible beside the dancers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0017220443114638329 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.3767218589782715 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0017220443114638329, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0017220443114638329, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18344317376613617, + 0.04682723432779312, + 0.16092614829540253, + 0.04407898336648941, + 0.028708921745419502, + 0.1172025129199028, + 0.15377232432365417, + 0.050719793885946274, + 0.15385782718658447, + 0.06046311557292938 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0017220443114638329 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are two dancers visible, with the male wearing an off-white linen shirt and dark trousers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the female dancer wearing an emerald silk gown with her hair in a low bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a large vintage Chesterfield sofa with crimson velvet fabric visible beside the dancers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0067406888119876385 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006740570068359 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0067406888119876385, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0067406888119876385, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09481503814458847, + 0.0752001628279686, + 0.07289044559001923, + 0.02499793842434883, + 0.06609497219324112, + 0.10081672668457031, + 0.17285190522670746, + 0.038373272866010666, + 0.19182811677455902, + 0.1621313989162445 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0067406888119876385 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are two dancers visible, with the male wearing an off-white linen shirt and dark trousers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the female dancer wearing an emerald silk gown with her hair in a low bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a large vintage Chesterfield sofa with crimson velvet fabric visible beside the dancers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014186720363795757 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264186859130859 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014186720363795757, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014186720363795757, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09649746865034103, + 0.15413251519203186, + 0.2896275222301483, + 0.07061352580785751, + 0.12447992712259293, + 0.04999842494726181, + 0.06544103473424911, + 0.03513296693563461, + 0.04126307740807533, + 0.07281352579593658 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014186720363795757 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "medium shot, framed from the side and panning slowly to the right, captures a pair of dancers in an ornate room, capturing them in a moment of profound intimacy and artistry. The male dancer, wearing a loose, off-white linen shirt with sleeves casually rolled to the elbows and paired with dark, slim-fitting trousers, has slightly curled dark brown hair and gazes intently and tenderly at his partner. The female dancer, clad in an emerald silk gown that flows gracefully across the floor with their gentle steps, wears her auburn hair loosely tied in a low bun, with strands cascading down her neck. A serene, captivated smile lingers on her face. Their bodies are pressed tightly together, their movements fluid and synchronized, as if the only sounds in the world are their breathing and heartbeats. Beside them, a large vintage Chesterfield sofa sits quietly, its crimson velvet fabric shimmering in the light, its delicate buttons and pulls and dark, carved wood armrests revealing the texture of time. The entire scene is bathed in a dramatic, soft light, as if streaming in through a tall window. The light precisely outlines the dancers' bodies and the folds of their clothing, casting long, soft shadows on the floor. This striking contrast of light and dark, the rich, slightly faded color palette, and the depth of the characters' emotions all combine to create the rich storytelling and painterly quality that are hallmarks of Annie Leibovitz's photography, imbuing the image with a tranquility, intimacy, and timeless romance.", + "seed": 3474, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000240/group_9/index_4324_seed_3474_dp_19_rank_38_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.16996575025841593, + "vlm_logprob": -0.16996575025841593, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.225, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.16996575025841593, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are two dancers visible, with the male wearing an off-white linen shirt and dark trousers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the female dancer wearing an emerald silk gown with her hair in a low bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a large vintage Chesterfield sofa with crimson velvet fabric visible beside the dancers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03153834864497185 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.656538248062134 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03153834864497185, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03153834864497185, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15834873914718628, + 0.04033183306455612, + 0.06802210211753845, + 0.06361483037471771, + 0.07050047069787979, + 0.03557160496711731, + 0.055563896894454956, + 0.17481261491775513, + 0.16121722757816315, + 0.17201663553714752 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03153834864497185 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are two dancers visible, with the male wearing an off-white linen shirt and dark trousers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the female dancer wearing an emerald silk gown with her hair in a low bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a large vintage Chesterfield sofa with crimson velvet fabric visible beside the dancers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7577964067459106 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6327964067459106 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.7577964067459106, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.7577964067459106, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10506371408700943, + 0.047050394117832184, + 0.07578699290752411, + 0.07864870876073837, + 0.05236106365919113, + 0.059884052723646164, + 0.05358448997139931, + 0.18442367017269135, + 0.09406357258558273, + 0.24913331866264343 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.7577964067459106 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are two dancers visible, with the male wearing an off-white linen shirt and dark trousers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the female dancer wearing an emerald silk gown with her hair in a low bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a large vintage Chesterfield sofa with crimson velvet fabric visible beside the dancers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007641016039997339 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882640838623047 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007641016039997339, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007641016039997339, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1975427120923996, + 0.06295524537563324, + 0.05868815258145332, + 0.10153865069150925, + 0.04337596148252487, + 0.03126346319913864, + 0.06588446348905563, + 0.15693242847919464, + 0.10026723146438599, + 0.1815517395734787 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007641016039997339 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are two dancers visible, with the male wearing an off-white linen shirt and dark trousers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the female dancer wearing an emerald silk gown with her hair in a low bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a large vintage Chesterfield sofa with crimson velvet fabric visible beside the dancers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0430765300989151 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168076515197754 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0430765300989151, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0430765300989151, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11618907749652863, + 0.056693799793720245, + 0.0812603309750557, + 0.09887798875570297, + 0.03663985803723335, + 0.054492659866809845, + 0.0602901466190815, + 0.1324213147163391, + 0.15254440903663635, + 0.2105904072523117 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0430765300989151 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are two dancers visible, with the male wearing an off-white linen shirt and dark trousers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the female dancer wearing an emerald silk gown with her hair in a low bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a large vintage Chesterfield sofa with crimson velvet fabric visible beside the dancers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009776449762284756 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634776592254639 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009776449762284756, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009776449762284756, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14839522540569305, + 0.0572868287563324, + 0.07812502980232239, + 0.11073312163352966, + 0.21172693371772766, + 0.022447561845183372, + 0.04756060242652893, + 0.1513904631137848, + 0.09529519826173782, + 0.07703899592161179 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009776449762284756 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_0/index_tensor([5544, 5544])_group_0_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_0/index_tensor([5544, 5544])_group_0_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..83c918048eb6895cf16e2388181758d4ac15af69 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_0/index_tensor([5544, 5544])_group_0_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "medium close-up shot from a level angle focuses on a classical beauty, standing three-quarters sideways. Her cascading black hair is loosely tied into an elegant chignon, a few playful strands gently cascading across her jade-like face, framing its soft contours. She wears a sumptuous lake-blue silk robe, the fabric shimmering softly in the afterglow of the setting sun filtering through the carved wooden windows. The collar and cuffs are intricately embroidered with orchids in delicate silver thread. She is situated in an antique study, the mahogany bookshelves and desk in the background appearing hazy and profound in the soft light. Her shoulders slumped slightly, her long eyelashes trembling slightly. Then, her graceful red lips parted, and she let out a long, almost silent breath. This sigh caused her already slumped shoulders to slump even further as the breath was released, as if draining away the last bit of strength. The entire scene was enveloped in a warm and slightly melancholic golden aura, creating a tranquil, melancholic, and poetic classical atmosphere.", + "seed": 23712, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_0/index_5544_seed_23712_dp_0_rank_0_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.10751216784119606, + "vlm_logprob": -0.10751216784119606, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.299999976158142, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.10751216784119606, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up from a level angle focusing on a classical beauty standing three-quarters sideways?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the character have cascading black hair loosely tied into a chignon with strands framing her face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a lake-blue silk robe with silver thread embroidery of orchids on the collar and cuffs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the character's action include slumped shoulders, trembling eyelashes, and parting red lips to release a long breath?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the setting an antique study with hazy mahogany bookshelves and a desk, bathed in a warm golden afterglow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03585480526089668 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4108548164367676 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03585480526089668, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03585480526089668, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1986950933933258, + 0.21824797987937927, + 0.04038425534963608, + 0.04014229774475098, + 0.039790064096450806, + 0.10714275389909744, + 0.17361144721508026, + 0.0920785441994667, + 0.05117986351251602, + 0.038727741688489914 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03585480526089668 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up from a level angle focusing on a classical beauty standing three-quarters sideways?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the character have cascading black hair loosely tied into a chignon with strands framing her face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a lake-blue silk robe with silver thread embroidery of orchids on the collar and cuffs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the character's action include slumped shoulders, trembling eyelashes, and parting red lips to release a long breath?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the setting an antique study with hazy mahogany bookshelves and a desk, bathed in a warm golden afterglow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0890476405620575 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.46404767036438 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0890476405620575, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0890476405620575, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2236507683992386, + 0.20700007677078247, + 0.1077273041009903, + 0.05649859085679054, + 0.018558597192168236, + 0.043263886123895645, + 0.11783743649721146, + 0.13349199295043945, + 0.04175393283367157, + 0.0502174012362957 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0890476405620575 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up from a level angle focusing on a classical beauty standing three-quarters sideways?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the character have cascading black hair loosely tied into a chignon with strands framing her face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a lake-blue silk robe with silver thread embroidery of orchids on the collar and cuffs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the character's action include slumped shoulders, trembling eyelashes, and parting red lips to release a long breath?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the setting an antique study with hazy mahogany bookshelves and a desk, bathed in a warm golden afterglow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12704972922801971 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.127049684524536 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12704972922801971, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12704972922801971, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1791788786649704, + 0.193357914686203, + 0.10791841894388199, + 0.018888244405388832, + 0.030500255525112152, + 0.05027680844068527, + 0.09491363167762756, + 0.1886315643787384, + 0.06029558181762695, + 0.07603868842124939 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12704972922801971 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up from a level angle focusing on a classical beauty standing three-quarters sideways?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the character have cascading black hair loosely tied into a chignon with strands framing her face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a lake-blue silk robe with silver thread embroidery of orchids on the collar and cuffs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the character's action include slumped shoulders, trembling eyelashes, and parting red lips to release a long breath?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the setting an antique study with hazy mahogany bookshelves and a desk, bathed in a warm golden afterglow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14281441271305084 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0178143978118896 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14281441271305084, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14281441271305084, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2923857271671295, + 0.15557187795639038, + 0.12055563926696777, + 0.07877422869205475, + 0.03830989450216293, + 0.0860280692577362, + 0.05241582915186882, + 0.06280517578125, + 0.0638517290353775, + 0.049301840364933014 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14281441271305084 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up from a level angle focusing on a classical beauty standing three-quarters sideways?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the character have cascading black hair loosely tied into a chignon with strands framing her face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a lake-blue silk robe with silver thread embroidery of orchids on the collar and cuffs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the character's action include slumped shoulders, trembling eyelashes, and parting red lips to release a long breath?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the setting an antique study with hazy mahogany bookshelves and a desk, bathed in a warm golden afterglow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14279425144195557 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.017794132232666 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14279425144195557, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.8749998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14279425144195557, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11403924971818924, + 0.1066724881529808, + 0.045206982642412186, + 0.02509284019470215, + 0.040574926882982254, + 0.05413788557052612, + 0.23954223096370697, + 0.2098178118467331, + 0.10589363425970078, + 0.05902191251516342 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14279425144195557 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "medium close-up shot from a level angle focuses on a classical beauty, standing three-quarters sideways. Her cascading black hair is loosely tied into an elegant chignon, a few playful strands gently cascading across her jade-like face, framing its soft contours. She wears a sumptuous lake-blue silk robe, the fabric shimmering softly in the afterglow of the setting sun filtering through the carved wooden windows. The collar and cuffs are intricately embroidered with orchids in delicate silver thread. She is situated in an antique study, the mahogany bookshelves and desk in the background appearing hazy and profound in the soft light. Her shoulders slumped slightly, her long eyelashes trembling slightly. Then, her graceful red lips parted, and she let out a long, almost silent breath. This sigh caused her already slumped shoulders to slump even further as the breath was released, as if draining away the last bit of strength. The entire scene was enveloped in a warm and slightly melancholic golden aura, creating a tranquil, melancholic, and poetic classical atmosphere.", + "seed": 23713, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_0/index_5544_seed_23713_dp_0_rank_0_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.053098491951823236, + "vlm_logprob": -0.053098491951823236, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.35, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.053098491951823236, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up from a level angle focusing on a classical beauty standing three-quarters sideways?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the character have cascading black hair loosely tied into a chignon with strands framing her face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a lake-blue silk robe with silver thread embroidery of orchids on the collar and cuffs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the character's action include slumped shoulders, trembling eyelashes, and parting red lips to release a long breath?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the setting an antique study with hazy mahogany bookshelves and a desk, bathed in a warm golden afterglow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014055782929062843 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.3890557289123535 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014055782929062843, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014055782929062843, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3366161286830902, + 0.04612887278199196, + 0.07148467749357224, + 0.13339272141456604, + 0.11536400020122528, + 0.0724511444568634, + 0.07324806600809097, + 0.05714622139930725, + 0.033166639506816864, + 0.06100151315331459 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014055782929062843 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up from a level angle focusing on a classical beauty standing three-quarters sideways?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the character have cascading black hair loosely tied into a chignon with strands framing her face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a lake-blue silk robe with silver thread embroidery of orchids on the collar and cuffs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the character's action include slumped shoulders, trembling eyelashes, and parting red lips to release a long breath?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the setting an antique study with hazy mahogany bookshelves and a desk, bathed in a warm golden afterglow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029813595116138458 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529813528060913 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029813595116138458, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029813595116138458, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3470690846443176, + 0.06649208813905716, + 0.0810379609465599, + 0.23544910550117493, + 0.06122976914048195, + 0.05484405532479286, + 0.04571608453989029, + 0.040486469864845276, + 0.02059341035783291, + 0.047082021832466125 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029813595116138458 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up from a level angle focusing on a classical beauty standing three-quarters sideways?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the character have cascading black hair loosely tied into a chignon with strands framing her face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a lake-blue silk robe with silver thread embroidery of orchids on the collar and cuffs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the character's action include slumped shoulders, trembling eyelashes, and parting red lips to release a long breath?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the setting an antique study with hazy mahogany bookshelves and a desk, bathed in a warm golden afterglow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.043075501918792725 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680755615234375 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.043075501918792725, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.043075501918792725, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2741415798664093, + 0.10923711955547333, + 0.1538592129945755, + 0.1802719086408615, + 0.06650887429714203, + 0.09270822256803513, + 0.019579095765948296, + 0.02761741913855076, + 0.022980736568570137, + 0.05309581011533737 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.043075501918792725 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up from a level angle focusing on a classical beauty standing three-quarters sideways?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the character have cascading black hair loosely tied into a chignon with strands framing her face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a lake-blue silk robe with silver thread embroidery of orchids on the collar and cuffs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the character's action include slumped shoulders, trembling eyelashes, and parting red lips to release a long breath?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the setting an antique study with hazy mahogany bookshelves and a desk, bathed in a warm golden afterglow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16036343574523926 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9103634357452393 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16036343574523926, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16036343574523926, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2561585009098053, + 0.061263106763362885, + 0.1174895390868187, + 0.20197553932666779, + 0.0801103487610817, + 0.05198470875620842, + 0.05130007490515709, + 0.037228990346193314, + 0.04705040901899338, + 0.09543869644403458 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16036343574523926 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up from a level angle focusing on a classical beauty standing three-quarters sideways?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the character have cascading black hair loosely tied into a chignon with strands framing her face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a lake-blue silk robe with silver thread embroidery of orchids on the collar and cuffs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the character's action include slumped shoulders, trembling eyelashes, and parting red lips to release a long breath?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the setting an antique study with hazy mahogany bookshelves and a desk, bathed in a warm golden afterglow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01818414404988289 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018184185028076 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01818414404988289, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01818414404988289, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21915942430496216, + 0.06436226516962051, + 0.22991204261779785, + 0.0615714006125927, + 0.08971261233091354, + 0.07231929898262024, + 0.06441157311201096, + 0.030194811522960663, + 0.050064779818058014, + 0.11829176545143127 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01818414404988289 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "medium close-up shot from a level angle focuses on a classical beauty, standing three-quarters sideways. Her cascading black hair is loosely tied into an elegant chignon, a few playful strands gently cascading across her jade-like face, framing its soft contours. She wears a sumptuous lake-blue silk robe, the fabric shimmering softly in the afterglow of the setting sun filtering through the carved wooden windows. The collar and cuffs are intricately embroidered with orchids in delicate silver thread. She is situated in an antique study, the mahogany bookshelves and desk in the background appearing hazy and profound in the soft light. Her shoulders slumped slightly, her long eyelashes trembling slightly. Then, her graceful red lips parted, and she let out a long, almost silent breath. This sigh caused her already slumped shoulders to slump even further as the breath was released, as if draining away the last bit of strength. The entire scene was enveloped in a warm and slightly melancholic golden aura, creating a tranquil, melancholic, and poetic classical atmosphere.", + "seed": 23714, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_0/index_5544_seed_23714_dp_1_rank_2_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.08015067838132381, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08015067838132381, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.8, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08015067838132381, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up from a level angle focusing on a classical beauty standing three-quarters sideways?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the character have cascading black hair loosely tied into a chignon with strands framing her face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a lake-blue silk robe with silver thread embroidery of orchids on the collar and cuffs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the character's action include slumped shoulders, trembling eyelashes, and parting red lips to release a long breath?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the setting an antique study with hazy mahogany bookshelves and a desk, bathed in a warm golden afterglow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02714633382856846 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.652146339416504 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02714633382856846, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02714633382856846, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16934092342853546, + 0.03156782686710358, + 0.02757287211716175, + 0.025967776775360107, + 0.3462013006210327, + 0.0989348292350769, + 0.09174520522356033, + 0.10484111309051514, + 0.06364912539720535, + 0.040179044008255005 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02714633382856846 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up from a level angle focusing on a classical beauty standing three-quarters sideways?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the character have cascading black hair loosely tied into a chignon with strands framing her face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a lake-blue silk robe with silver thread embroidery of orchids on the collar and cuffs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the character's action include slumped shoulders, trembling eyelashes, and parting red lips to release a long breath?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the setting an antique study with hazy mahogany bookshelves and a desk, bathed in a warm golden afterglow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.054968513548374176 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299685955047607 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.054968513548374176, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.054968513548374176, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12155919522047043, + 0.03694896027445793, + 0.019177841022610664, + 0.024673957377672195, + 0.5010840892791748, + 0.0635511502623558, + 0.06457310914993286, + 0.05342072620987892, + 0.07312547415494919, + 0.041885510087013245 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.054968513548374176 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up from a level angle focusing on a classical beauty standing three-quarters sideways?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the character have cascading black hair loosely tied into a chignon with strands framing her face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a lake-blue silk robe with silver thread embroidery of orchids on the collar and cuffs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the character's action include slumped shoulders, trembling eyelashes, and parting red lips to release a long breath?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the setting an antique study with hazy mahogany bookshelves and a desk, bathed in a warm golden afterglow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05495993793010712 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929960012435913 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05495993793010712, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05495993793010712, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08934888243675232, + 0.0335007980465889, + 0.012920447625219822, + 0.015114150010049343, + 0.5662707686424255, + 0.03748752549290657, + 0.08748747408390045, + 0.06956411153078079, + 0.05274895578622818, + 0.035556916147470474 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05495993793010712 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up from a level angle focusing on a classical beauty standing three-quarters sideways?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the character have cascading black hair loosely tied into a chignon with strands framing her face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a lake-blue silk robe with silver thread embroidery of orchids on the collar and cuffs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the character's action include slumped shoulders, trembling eyelashes, and parting red lips to release a long breath?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the setting an antique study with hazy mahogany bookshelves and a desk, bathed in a warm golden afterglow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2255791276693344 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6005791425704956 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2255791276693344, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2255791276693344, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04912591353058815, + 0.017865702509880066, + 0.011515564285218716, + 0.026822097599506378, + 0.692353367805481, + 0.02635032683610916, + 0.02340860478579998, + 0.01418111938983202, + 0.10233259946107864, + 0.036044731736183167 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2255791276693344 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up from a level angle focusing on a classical beauty standing three-quarters sideways?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the character have cascading black hair loosely tied into a chignon with strands framing her face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a lake-blue silk robe with silver thread embroidery of orchids on the collar and cuffs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the character's action include slumped shoulders, trembling eyelashes, and parting red lips to release a long breath?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the setting an antique study with hazy mahogany bookshelves and a desk, bathed in a warm golden afterglow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03809947893023491 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288099527359009 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03809947893023491, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03809947893023491, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08821450918912888, + 0.027535811066627502, + 0.03604156896471977, + 0.06386401504278183, + 0.36062198877334595, + 0.09826310724020004, + 0.05093184858560562, + 0.16627851128578186, + 0.040147002786397934, + 0.06810164451599121 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 7, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03809947893023491 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "medium close-up shot from a level angle focuses on a classical beauty, standing three-quarters sideways. Her cascading black hair is loosely tied into an elegant chignon, a few playful strands gently cascading across her jade-like face, framing its soft contours. She wears a sumptuous lake-blue silk robe, the fabric shimmering softly in the afterglow of the setting sun filtering through the carved wooden windows. The collar and cuffs are intricately embroidered with orchids in delicate silver thread. She is situated in an antique study, the mahogany bookshelves and desk in the background appearing hazy and profound in the soft light. Her shoulders slumped slightly, her long eyelashes trembling slightly. Then, her graceful red lips parted, and she let out a long, almost silent breath. This sigh caused her already slumped shoulders to slump even further as the breath was released, as if draining away the last bit of strength. The entire scene was enveloped in a warm and slightly melancholic golden aura, creating a tranquil, melancholic, and poetic classical atmosphere.", + "seed": 23715, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_0/index_5544_seed_23715_dp_1_rank_2_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.07363583892583847, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07363583892583847, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.2, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07363583892583847, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up from a level angle focusing on a classical beauty standing three-quarters sideways?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the character have cascading black hair loosely tied into a chignon with strands framing her face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a lake-blue silk robe with silver thread embroidery of orchids on the collar and cuffs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the character's action include slumped shoulders, trembling eyelashes, and parting red lips to release a long breath?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the setting an antique study with hazy mahogany bookshelves and a desk, bathed in a warm golden afterglow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.013873806223273277 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.38887357711792 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.013873806223273277, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.013873806223273277, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20919491350650787, + 0.10246725380420685, + 0.04626540467143059, + 0.15217414498329163, + 0.15317295491695404, + 0.028252961114048958, + 0.06146249547600746, + 0.028538886457681656, + 0.07025998085737228, + 0.1482110321521759 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.013873806223273277 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up from a level angle focusing on a classical beauty standing three-quarters sideways?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the character have cascading black hair loosely tied into a chignon with strands framing her face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a lake-blue silk robe with silver thread embroidery of orchids on the collar and cuffs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the character's action include slumped shoulders, trembling eyelashes, and parting red lips to release a long breath?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the setting an antique study with hazy mahogany bookshelves and a desk, bathed in a warm golden afterglow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04308018460869789 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680800914764404 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04308018460869789, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04308018460869789, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2188829630613327, + 0.06539007276296616, + 0.050294313579797745, + 0.07773514837026596, + 0.16219459474086761, + 0.04085538908839226, + 0.07017424702644348, + 0.04006076976656914, + 0.09830374270677567, + 0.1761087328195572 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04308018460869789 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up from a level angle focusing on a classical beauty standing three-quarters sideways?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the character have cascading black hair loosely tied into a chignon with strands framing her face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a lake-blue silk robe with silver thread embroidery of orchids on the collar and cuffs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the character's action include slumped shoulders, trembling eyelashes, and parting red lips to release a long breath?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the setting an antique study with hazy mahogany bookshelves and a desk, bathed in a warm golden afterglow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.043066367506980896 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680662631988525 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.043066367506980896, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.043066367506980896, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19410055875778198, + 0.08683840930461884, + 0.10686926543712616, + 0.08710915595293045, + 0.11310454457998276, + 0.10073812305927277, + 0.04628381133079529, + 0.060569364577531815, + 0.09908858686685562, + 0.10529822111129761 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.043066367506980896 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up from a level angle focusing on a classical beauty standing three-quarters sideways?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the character have cascading black hair loosely tied into a chignon with strands framing her face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a lake-blue silk robe with silver thread embroidery of orchids on the collar and cuffs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the character's action include slumped shoulders, trembling eyelashes, and parting red lips to release a long breath?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the setting an antique study with hazy mahogany bookshelves and a desk, bathed in a warm golden afterglow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2520986795425415 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5020986795425415 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2520986795425415, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2520986795425415, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07976052910089493, + 0.0690898671746254, + 0.04467877000570297, + 0.04336755350232124, + 0.19167469441890717, + 0.020446132868528366, + 0.13272348046302795, + 0.05138986185193062, + 0.2044348120689392, + 0.16243435442447662 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2520986795425415 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up from a level angle focusing on a classical beauty standing three-quarters sideways?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the character have cascading black hair loosely tied into a chignon with strands framing her face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a lake-blue silk robe with silver thread embroidery of orchids on the collar and cuffs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the character's action include slumped shoulders, trembling eyelashes, and parting red lips to release a long breath?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the setting an antique study with hazy mahogany bookshelves and a desk, bathed in a warm golden afterglow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016060156747698784 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.1410603523254395 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016060156747698784, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016060156747698784, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2375544309616089, + 0.0605437308549881, + 0.11570719629526138, + 0.15628372132778168, + 0.16256165504455566, + 0.041510652750730515, + 0.041402388364076614, + 0.028936324641108513, + 0.043966203927993774, + 0.1115337610244751 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016060156747698784 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_1/index_tensor([5498, 5498])_group_1_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_1/index_tensor([5498, 5498])_group_1_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..55cb5c91b0432ae74146fb146f26334f3621b030 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_1/index_tensor([5498, 5498])_group_1_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "static, eye-level, medium shot captures the back of a sleek, modern utility van, its glossy charcoal-gray paint gleaming in the warm, golden glow of the late afternoon sun on a suburban driveway. The power liftgate slides open with silent, automatic smoothness, but instead of groceries, a torrent of colorful, glossy, bouncing balls erupts from the cargo hold in a playful, mischievous cascade. The entire scene unfolds in mesmerizing slow motion, as vibrant orbs—a brilliant blend of red, blue, yellow, and green—tumble out, spilling and bouncing across the clean concrete with exaggerated, graceful elasticity. The camera then smoothly tilts downward, isolating and focusing on a vibrant red ball as it rhythmically and deliberately bounces toward the lens, growing larger with each impact until it fills the frame, its polished surface reflecting the world around it. The entire whimsical scene then fades gently to black.", + "seed": 11687, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_1/index_5498_seed_11687_dp_2_rank_4_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.16798229033593087, + "vlm_logprob": -0.16798229033593087, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.8, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.16798229033593087, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, modern utility van with glossy charcoal-gray paint?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the power liftgate slide open automatically, releasing a torrent of colorful, glossy, bouncing balls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a suburban driveway with the van illuminated by the warm, golden glow of late afternoon sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly tilt downward to focus on a vibrant red ball bouncing toward the lens until it fills the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the entire scene unfold in mesmerizing slow motion before fading gently to black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.42917731404304504 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.0541772842407227 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.42917731404304504, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.42917731404304504, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06576463580131531, + 0.02413516864180565, + 0.029813725501298904, + 0.07804117351770401, + 0.15305358171463013, + 0.05335386097431183, + 0.07595982402563095, + 0.0654110461473465, + 0.13696438074111938, + 0.31750252842903137 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.42917731404304504 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, modern utility van with glossy charcoal-gray paint?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the power liftgate slide open automatically, releasing a torrent of colorful, glossy, bouncing balls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a suburban driveway with the van illuminated by the warm, golden glow of late afternoon sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly tilt downward to focus on a vibrant red ball bouncing toward the lens until it fills the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the entire scene unfold in mesmerizing slow motion before fading gently to black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023304030299186707 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773303985595703 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023304030299186707, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023304030299186707, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07074511051177979, + 0.03273274004459381, + 0.08458899706602097, + 0.12425649166107178, + 0.05354949086904526, + 0.07195022702217102, + 0.06992829591035843, + 0.11035413295030594, + 0.07006333023309708, + 0.31183114647865295 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 3, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023304030299186707 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, modern utility van with glossy charcoal-gray paint?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the power liftgate slide open automatically, releasing a torrent of colorful, glossy, bouncing balls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a suburban driveway with the van illuminated by the warm, golden glow of late afternoon sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly tilt downward to focus on a vibrant red ball bouncing toward the lens until it fills the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the entire scene unfold in mesmerizing slow motion before fading gently to black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16037246584892273 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9103724956512451 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16037246584892273, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16037246584892273, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12279542535543442, + 0.1505431830883026, + 0.09442019462585449, + 0.051939934492111206, + 0.05732255429029465, + 0.06975043565034866, + 0.04965577647089958, + 0.07898354530334473, + 0.09201241284608841, + 0.23257647454738617 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16037246584892273 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, modern utility van with glossy charcoal-gray paint?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the power liftgate slide open automatically, releasing a torrent of colorful, glossy, bouncing balls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a suburban driveway with the van illuminated by the warm, golden glow of late afternoon sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly tilt downward to focus on a vibrant red ball bouncing toward the lens until it fills the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the entire scene unfold in mesmerizing slow motion before fading gently to black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.001510670525021851 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.5015106201171875 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.001510670525021851, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.001510670525021851, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09208210557699203, + 0.04748391732573509, + 0.050950005650520325, + 0.08096341043710709, + 0.05359621345996857, + 0.05280837416648865, + 0.12343395501375198, + 0.09154019504785538, + 0.2518317401409149, + 0.15531010925769806 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.001510670525021851 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, modern utility van with glossy charcoal-gray paint?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the power liftgate slide open automatically, releasing a torrent of colorful, glossy, bouncing balls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a suburban driveway with the van illuminated by the warm, golden glow of late afternoon sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly tilt downward to focus on a vibrant red ball bouncing toward the lens until it fills the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the entire scene unfold in mesmerizing slow motion before fading gently to black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2255469709634781 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.600546956062317 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2255469709634781, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2255469709634781, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.043186236172914505, + 0.028894411399960518, + 0.0546925812959671, + 0.05920157954096794, + 0.1058921068906784, + 0.05129672959446907, + 0.07509364932775497, + 0.059013642370700836, + 0.19360102713108063, + 0.3291279971599579 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2255469709634781 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, eye-level, medium shot captures the back of a sleek, modern utility van, its glossy charcoal-gray paint gleaming in the warm, golden glow of the late afternoon sun on a suburban driveway. The power liftgate slides open with silent, automatic smoothness, but instead of groceries, a torrent of colorful, glossy, bouncing balls erupts from the cargo hold in a playful, mischievous cascade. The entire scene unfolds in mesmerizing slow motion, as vibrant orbs—a brilliant blend of red, blue, yellow, and green—tumble out, spilling and bouncing across the clean concrete with exaggerated, graceful elasticity. The camera then smoothly tilts downward, isolating and focusing on a vibrant red ball as it rhythmically and deliberately bounces toward the lens, growing larger with each impact until it fills the frame, its polished surface reflecting the world around it. The entire whimsical scene then fades gently to black.", + "seed": 11688, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_1/index_5498_seed_11688_dp_2_rank_4_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.159968054597266, + "vlm_logprob": -0.159968054597266, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.125, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.159968054597266, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, modern utility van with glossy charcoal-gray paint?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the power liftgate slide open automatically, releasing a torrent of colorful, glossy, bouncing balls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a suburban driveway with the van illuminated by the warm, golden glow of late afternoon sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly tilt downward to focus on a vibrant red ball bouncing toward the lens until it fills the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the entire scene unfold in mesmerizing slow motion before fading gently to black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20176686346530914 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.701766848564148 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20176686346530914, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20176686346530914, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08544731140136719, + 0.02870587445795536, + 0.03651006519794464, + 0.03448846936225891, + 0.031168632209300995, + 0.04091082513332367, + 0.016528097912669182, + 0.031027795746922493, + 0.041909754276275635, + 0.6533032059669495 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20176686346530914 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, modern utility van with glossy charcoal-gray paint?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the power liftgate slide open automatically, releasing a torrent of colorful, glossy, bouncing balls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a suburban driveway with the van illuminated by the warm, golden glow of late afternoon sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly tilt downward to focus on a vibrant red ball bouncing toward the lens until it fills the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the entire scene unfold in mesmerizing slow motion before fading gently to black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009793920442461967 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634793758392334 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009793920442461967, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009793920442461967, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13958168029785156, + 0.08188549429178238, + 0.050755251199007034, + 0.1345590502023697, + 0.12179967761039734, + 0.11771335452795029, + 0.07856688648462296, + 0.07543875277042389, + 0.07060284912586212, + 0.12909705936908722 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009793920442461967 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, modern utility van with glossy charcoal-gray paint?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the power liftgate slide open automatically, releasing a torrent of colorful, glossy, bouncing balls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a suburban driveway with the van illuminated by the warm, golden glow of late afternoon sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly tilt downward to focus on a vibrant red ball bouncing toward the lens until it fills the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the entire scene unfold in mesmerizing slow motion before fading gently to black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4743134379386902 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9743134379386902 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.4743134379386902, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.4743134379386902, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05368021875619888, + 0.09890250116586685, + 0.0334305502474308, + 0.04494361951947212, + 0.05366665497422218, + 0.06954041123390198, + 0.015054719522595406, + 0.03012588992714882, + 0.0288364477455616, + 0.571819007396698 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.4743134379386902 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, modern utility van with glossy charcoal-gray paint?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the power liftgate slide open automatically, releasing a torrent of colorful, glossy, bouncing balls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a suburban driveway with the van illuminated by the warm, golden glow of late afternoon sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly tilt downward to focus on a vibrant red ball bouncing toward the lens until it fills the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the entire scene unfold in mesmerizing slow motion before fading gently to black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.001039560534991324 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.876039505004883 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.001039560534991324, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.001039560534991324, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03856183588504791, + 0.025338441133499146, + 0.020968524739146233, + 0.05282377451658249, + 0.035511285066604614, + 0.05221884697675705, + 0.019735274836421013, + 0.01891048438847065, + 0.026048898696899414, + 0.7098826766014099 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.001039560534991324 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, modern utility van with glossy charcoal-gray paint?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the power liftgate slide open automatically, releasing a torrent of colorful, glossy, bouncing balls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a suburban driveway with the van illuminated by the warm, golden glow of late afternoon sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly tilt downward to focus on a vibrant red ball bouncing toward the lens until it fills the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the entire scene unfold in mesmerizing slow motion before fading gently to black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11292649060487747 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.237926483154297 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11292649060487747, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11292649060487747, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03179625794291496, + 0.01904672011733055, + 0.015585377812385559, + 0.05183464661240578, + 0.0323568619787693, + 0.05633728206157684, + 0.027727343142032623, + 0.02195565775036812, + 0.04396926984190941, + 0.6993905901908875 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11292649060487747 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, eye-level, medium shot captures the back of a sleek, modern utility van, its glossy charcoal-gray paint gleaming in the warm, golden glow of the late afternoon sun on a suburban driveway. The power liftgate slides open with silent, automatic smoothness, but instead of groceries, a torrent of colorful, glossy, bouncing balls erupts from the cargo hold in a playful, mischievous cascade. The entire scene unfolds in mesmerizing slow motion, as vibrant orbs—a brilliant blend of red, blue, yellow, and green—tumble out, spilling and bouncing across the clean concrete with exaggerated, graceful elasticity. The camera then smoothly tilts downward, isolating and focusing on a vibrant red ball as it rhythmically and deliberately bounces toward the lens, growing larger with each impact until it fills the frame, its polished surface reflecting the world around it. The entire whimsical scene then fades gently to black.", + "seed": 11689, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_1/index_5498_seed_11689_dp_3_rank_6_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.12428995419759303, + "vlm_logprob": -0.12428995419759303, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.125, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.12428995419759303, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, modern utility van with glossy charcoal-gray paint?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the power liftgate slide open automatically, releasing a torrent of colorful, glossy, bouncing balls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a suburban driveway with the van illuminated by the warm, golden glow of late afternoon sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly tilt downward to focus on a vibrant red ball bouncing toward the lens until it fills the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the entire scene unfold in mesmerizing slow motion before fading gently to black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2525242269039154 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5025242567062378 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2525242269039154, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2525242269039154, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11922110617160797, + 0.10722354799509048, + 0.07965300232172012, + 0.13276983797550201, + 0.21034766733646393, + 0.11007364094257355, + 0.039737969636917114, + 0.07644236087799072, + 0.05550197884440422, + 0.06902888417243958 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2525242269039154 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, modern utility van with glossy charcoal-gray paint?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the power liftgate slide open automatically, releasing a torrent of colorful, glossy, bouncing balls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a suburban driveway with the van illuminated by the warm, golden glow of late afternoon sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly tilt downward to focus on a vibrant red ball bouncing toward the lens until it fills the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the entire scene unfold in mesmerizing slow motion before fading gently to black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01608314923942089 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141083240509033 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01608314923942089, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01608314923942089, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06120412424206734, + 0.07675038278102875, + 0.03659917041659355, + 0.07767144590616226, + 0.19983221590518951, + 0.17136216163635254, + 0.0596887469291687, + 0.1224382296204567, + 0.050164736807346344, + 0.14428885281085968 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01608314923942089 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, modern utility van with glossy charcoal-gray paint?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the power liftgate slide open automatically, releasing a torrent of colorful, glossy, bouncing balls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a suburban driveway with the van illuminated by the warm, golden glow of late afternoon sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly tilt downward to focus on a vibrant red ball bouncing toward the lens until it fills the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the entire scene unfold in mesmerizing slow motion before fading gently to black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0700308233499527 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695030927658081 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0700308233499527, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0700308233499527, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09667329490184784, + 0.0549299381673336, + 0.22704625129699707, + 0.2121240645647049, + 0.15858867764472961, + 0.07024464756250381, + 0.01665693335235119, + 0.06088490039110184, + 0.058774352073669434, + 0.04407693073153496 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0700308233499527 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, modern utility van with glossy charcoal-gray paint?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the power liftgate slide open automatically, releasing a torrent of colorful, glossy, bouncing balls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a suburban driveway with the van illuminated by the warm, golden glow of late afternoon sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly tilt downward to focus on a vibrant red ball bouncing toward the lens until it fills the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the entire scene unfold in mesmerizing slow motion before fading gently to black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0015116228023543954 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.501511573791504 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0015116228023543954, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0015116228023543954, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05565785616636276, + 0.04172646254301071, + 0.16454549133777618, + 0.06917756050825119, + 0.10692788660526276, + 0.18096838891506195, + 0.035536814481019974, + 0.08988165110349655, + 0.1259576380252838, + 0.12962017953395844 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 2, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0015116228023543954 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, modern utility van with glossy charcoal-gray paint?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the power liftgate slide open automatically, releasing a torrent of colorful, glossy, bouncing balls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a suburban driveway with the van illuminated by the warm, golden glow of late afternoon sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly tilt downward to focus on a vibrant red ball bouncing toward the lens until it fills the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the entire scene unfold in mesmerizing slow motion before fading gently to black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2812999486923218 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4062999486923218 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2812999486923218, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2812999486923218, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06371163576841354, + 0.056606315076351166, + 0.07424759119749069, + 0.08358541131019592, + 0.14952589571475983, + 0.11302907019853592, + 0.04946810379624367, + 0.10659204423427582, + 0.14624764025211334, + 0.1569862961769104 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2812999486923218 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, eye-level, medium shot captures the back of a sleek, modern utility van, its glossy charcoal-gray paint gleaming in the warm, golden glow of the late afternoon sun on a suburban driveway. The power liftgate slides open with silent, automatic smoothness, but instead of groceries, a torrent of colorful, glossy, bouncing balls erupts from the cargo hold in a playful, mischievous cascade. The entire scene unfolds in mesmerizing slow motion, as vibrant orbs—a brilliant blend of red, blue, yellow, and green—tumble out, spilling and bouncing across the clean concrete with exaggerated, graceful elasticity. The camera then smoothly tilts downward, isolating and focusing on a vibrant red ball as it rhythmically and deliberately bounces toward the lens, growing larger with each impact until it fills the frame, its polished surface reflecting the world around it. The entire whimsical scene then fades gently to black.", + "seed": 11690, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_1/index_5498_seed_11690_dp_3_rank_6_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.07356240423396229, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07356240423396229, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.525, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07356240423396229, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, modern utility van with glossy charcoal-gray paint?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the power liftgate slide open automatically, releasing a torrent of colorful, glossy, bouncing balls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a suburban driveway with the van illuminated by the warm, golden glow of late afternoon sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly tilt downward to focus on a vibrant red ball bouncing toward the lens until it fills the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the entire scene unfold in mesmerizing slow motion before fading gently to black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07017774879932404 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6951777935028076 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07017774879932404, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07017774879932404, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1679360568523407, + 0.5297430753707886, + 0.06803340464830399, + 0.044606417417526245, + 0.02029305137693882, + 0.05529659613966942, + 0.014543015509843826, + 0.02405804768204689, + 0.011224758811295033, + 0.06426546722650528 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07017774879932404 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, modern utility van with glossy charcoal-gray paint?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the power liftgate slide open automatically, releasing a torrent of colorful, glossy, bouncing balls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a suburban driveway with the van illuminated by the warm, golden glow of late afternoon sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly tilt downward to focus on a vibrant red ball bouncing toward the lens until it fills the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the entire scene unfold in mesmerizing slow motion before fading gently to black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016076931729912758 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141077041625977 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016076931729912758, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016076931729912758, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09442982077598572, + 0.0957348495721817, + 0.09821848571300507, + 0.3014008700847626, + 0.030184511095285416, + 0.1396908164024353, + 0.050083015114068985, + 0.07397900521755219, + 0.015529735013842583, + 0.10074886679649353 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016076931729912758 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, modern utility van with glossy charcoal-gray paint?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the power liftgate slide open automatically, releasing a torrent of colorful, glossy, bouncing balls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a suburban driveway with the van illuminated by the warm, golden glow of late afternoon sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly tilt downward to focus on a vibrant red ball bouncing toward the lens until it fills the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the entire scene unfold in mesmerizing slow motion before fading gently to black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07898745685815811 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5789873600006104 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07898745685815811, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07898745685815811, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05207854136824608, + 0.49414491653442383, + 0.08677109330892563, + 0.06863433122634888, + 0.026382409036159515, + 0.04679694399237633, + 0.014737210236489773, + 0.08620303869247437, + 0.02332339435815811, + 0.10092808306217194 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07898745685815811 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, modern utility van with glossy charcoal-gray paint?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the power liftgate slide open automatically, releasing a torrent of colorful, glossy, bouncing balls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a suburban driveway with the van illuminated by the warm, golden glow of late afternoon sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly tilt downward to focus on a vibrant red ball bouncing toward the lens until it fills the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the entire scene unfold in mesmerizing slow motion before fading gently to black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0010387268848717213 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.876038551330566 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0010387268848717213, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0010387268848717213, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08984559029340744, + 0.2591501772403717, + 0.028118601068854332, + 0.05670852214097977, + 0.034790799021720886, + 0.2466905415058136, + 0.021992851048707962, + 0.060572609305381775, + 0.0197620689868927, + 0.182368203997612 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0010387268848717213 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, modern utility van with glossy charcoal-gray paint?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the power liftgate slide open automatically, releasing a torrent of colorful, glossy, bouncing balls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a suburban driveway with the van illuminated by the warm, golden glow of late afternoon sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly tilt downward to focus on a vibrant red ball bouncing toward the lens until it fills the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the entire scene unfold in mesmerizing slow motion before fading gently to black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20153115689754486 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.701531171798706 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20153115689754486, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20153115689754486, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1019442155957222, + 0.05430058389902115, + 0.031721316277980804, + 0.18328207731246948, + 0.0361013226211071, + 0.06267870962619781, + 0.06357093900442123, + 0.07684718817472458, + 0.03820646554231644, + 0.3513472080230713 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20153115689754486 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_10/index_tensor([7071, 7071])_group_10_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_10/index_tensor([7071, 7071])_group_10_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..27080fde6aaea9913f1e6372809dd333b885d641 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_10/index_tensor([7071, 7071])_group_10_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "An extreme wide shot, captured from the perspective of a quiet, slowly drifting drone, reveals a vast, city-like spaceship in high orbit, slowly rotating around a vibrant planet. The vessel is a massive, multi-ringed structure constructed of gunmetal-gray alloy and polished composite materials, its immense scale accentuated by the planetary backdrop. Soaring spires, reminiscent of futuristic skyscrapers, pierce the void, interconnected by delicate, luminous bridges, while vast, transparent domes cover what appear to be parks and residential areas. The ship's surface is an intricate tapestry of complex paneling, deep structural canyons, and countless streams of warm golden light from windows and avenues, creating the impression of a metropolis alive in the vacuum of space. The entire station rotates majestically and deliberately on its central axis, a slow, graceful cosmic rotation. Below, the Earth-like planet occupies a large portion of the frame, its surface a breathtaking swirl of deep blue oceans, green and brown continents, and brilliant white clouds. A distant star casts a harsh, bright light on the side of the ship, creating sharp, crisp shadows that crawl across its metal hull as the ship turns, while reflected light from the planet bathes the underside of the ship in a soft, ethereal blue glow. The combination of silent, steady camera drifts and the imperceptible rotation of the ship against the static backdrop of the distant star creates a profound atmosphere of awe, scale, and tranquility, a profound sense of technological grandeur.", + "seed": 20309, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_10/index_7071_seed_20309_dp_20_rank_40_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.39854586087167265, + "vlm_logprob": -0.39854586087167265, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.35, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.39854586087167265, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot an extreme wide shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perspective that of a quiet, slowly drifting drone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive, multi-ringed spaceship constructed of gunmetal-gray alloy and polished composite materials?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the spaceship feature soaring spires, luminous bridges, and transparent domes covering parks or residential areas?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the spaceship slowly rotating around a vibrant Earth-like planet that occupies a large portion of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8148113489151 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1898113191127777 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.8148113489151, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -1.8148113489151, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5719927549362183, + 0.07031512260437012, + 0.10642543435096741, + 0.01722790114581585, + 0.0159026887267828, + 0.019156189635396004, + 0.012621546164155006, + 0.01899826154112816, + 0.032802991569042206, + 0.13455714285373688 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.8148113489151 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot an extreme wide shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perspective that of a quiet, slowly drifting drone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive, multi-ringed spaceship constructed of gunmetal-gray alloy and polished composite materials?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the spaceship feature soaring spires, luminous bridges, and transparent domes covering parks or residential areas?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the spaceship slowly rotating around a vibrant Earth-like planet that occupies a large portion of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10037825256586075 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3503782749176025 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10037825256586075, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10037825256586075, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.31010687351226807, + 0.06834353506565094, + 0.12421759217977524, + 0.05062476918101311, + 0.031239960342645645, + 0.10471346974372864, + 0.05708874762058258, + 0.02682960033416748, + 0.09708796441555023, + 0.12974746525287628 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10037825256586075 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot an extreme wide shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perspective that of a quiet, slowly drifting drone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive, multi-ringed spaceship constructed of gunmetal-gray alloy and polished composite materials?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the spaceship feature soaring spires, luminous bridges, and transparent domes covering parks or residential areas?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the spaceship slowly rotating around a vibrant Earth-like planet that occupies a large portion of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016095347702503204 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141095161437988 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016095347702503204, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016095347702503204, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.8150365948677063, + 0.04133588820695877, + 0.022385932505130768, + 0.03157877177000046, + 0.015617121942341328, + 0.022750932723283768, + 0.008653859607875347, + 0.013049391098320484, + 0.014792708680033684, + 0.014798811636865139 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016095347702503204 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot an extreme wide shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perspective that of a quiet, slowly drifting drone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive, multi-ringed spaceship constructed of gunmetal-gray alloy and polished composite materials?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the spaceship feature soaring spires, luminous bridges, and transparent domes covering parks or residential areas?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the spaceship slowly rotating around a vibrant Earth-like planet that occupies a large portion of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03814079239964485 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881407737731934 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03814079239964485, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03814079239964485, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5469970703125, + 0.0998016744852066, + 0.07736871391534805, + 0.06454874575138092, + 0.046034373342990875, + 0.04377065598964691, + 0.022531921043992043, + 0.021216100081801414, + 0.055862825363874435, + 0.02186800353229046 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03814079239964485 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot an extreme wide shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perspective that of a quiet, slowly drifting drone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive, multi-ringed spaceship constructed of gunmetal-gray alloy and polished composite materials?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the spaceship feature soaring spires, luminous bridges, and transparent domes covering parks or residential areas?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the spaceship slowly rotating around a vibrant Earth-like planet that occupies a large portion of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02330356277525425 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773303508758545 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02330356277525425, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02330356277525425, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.6234035491943359, + 0.027005283161997795, + 0.0188307985663414, + 0.030963702127337456, + 0.04926237091422081, + 0.02582101710140705, + 0.09416848421096802, + 0.032203372567892075, + 0.038448628038167953, + 0.05989280343055725 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02330356277525425 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extreme wide shot, captured from the perspective of a quiet, slowly drifting drone, reveals a vast, city-like spaceship in high orbit, slowly rotating around a vibrant planet. The vessel is a massive, multi-ringed structure constructed of gunmetal-gray alloy and polished composite materials, its immense scale accentuated by the planetary backdrop. Soaring spires, reminiscent of futuristic skyscrapers, pierce the void, interconnected by delicate, luminous bridges, while vast, transparent domes cover what appear to be parks and residential areas. The ship's surface is an intricate tapestry of complex paneling, deep structural canyons, and countless streams of warm golden light from windows and avenues, creating the impression of a metropolis alive in the vacuum of space. The entire station rotates majestically and deliberately on its central axis, a slow, graceful cosmic rotation. Below, the Earth-like planet occupies a large portion of the frame, its surface a breathtaking swirl of deep blue oceans, green and brown continents, and brilliant white clouds. A distant star casts a harsh, bright light on the side of the ship, creating sharp, crisp shadows that crawl across its metal hull as the ship turns, while reflected light from the planet bathes the underside of the ship in a soft, ethereal blue glow. The combination of silent, steady camera drifts and the imperceptible rotation of the ship against the static backdrop of the distant star creates a profound atmosphere of awe, scale, and tranquility, a profound sense of technological grandeur.", + "seed": 20310, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_10/index_7071_seed_20310_dp_20_rank_40_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.2876432027667761, + "vlm_logprob": -0.2876432027667761, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.0, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.2876432027667761, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot an extreme wide shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perspective that of a quiet, slowly drifting drone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive, multi-ringed spaceship constructed of gunmetal-gray alloy and polished composite materials?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the spaceship feature soaring spires, luminous bridges, and transparent domes covering parks or residential areas?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the spaceship slowly rotating around a vibrant Earth-like planet that occupies a large portion of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.984339714050293 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4843396842479706 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.984339714050293, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.984339714050293, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15311555564403534, + 0.10302367806434631, + 0.18077175319194794, + 0.19741187989711761, + 0.03418026491999626, + 0.09902135282754898, + 0.04664284735918045, + 0.08086785674095154, + 0.07789350301027298, + 0.027071289718151093 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.984339714050293 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot an extreme wide shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perspective that of a quiet, slowly drifting drone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive, multi-ringed spaceship constructed of gunmetal-gray alloy and polished composite materials?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the spaceship feature soaring spires, luminous bridges, and transparent domes covering parks or residential areas?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the spaceship slowly rotating around a vibrant Earth-like planet that occupies a large portion of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.31344500184059143 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.313444972038269 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.31344500184059143, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.31344500184059143, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0784463882446289, + 0.051666442304849625, + 0.0515655055642128, + 0.09452003240585327, + 0.07545340806245804, + 0.1763579547405243, + 0.10079975426197052, + 0.20617260038852692, + 0.11981287598609924, + 0.04520503804087639 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 5, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.31344500184059143 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot an extreme wide shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perspective that of a quiet, slowly drifting drone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive, multi-ringed spaceship constructed of gunmetal-gray alloy and polished composite materials?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the spaceship feature soaring spires, luminous bridges, and transparent domes covering parks or residential areas?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the spaceship slowly rotating around a vibrant Earth-like planet that occupies a large portion of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023302631452679634 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7733025550842285 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023302631452679634, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023302631452679634, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12658588588237762, + 0.15800577402114868, + 0.16871774196624756, + 0.037831924855709076, + 0.02980143576860428, + 0.155406653881073, + 0.032797932624816895, + 0.05244237184524536, + 0.19228233397006989, + 0.046127934008836746 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023302631452679634 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot an extreme wide shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perspective that of a quiet, slowly drifting drone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive, multi-ringed spaceship constructed of gunmetal-gray alloy and polished composite materials?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the spaceship feature soaring spires, luminous bridges, and transparent domes covering parks or residential areas?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the spaceship slowly rotating around a vibrant Earth-like planet that occupies a large portion of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07902700453996658 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.579026937484741 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07902700453996658, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07902700453996658, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2091425508260727, + 0.13111138343811035, + 0.149226114153862, + 0.06310701370239258, + 0.03180084004998207, + 0.17179031670093536, + 0.031493719667196274, + 0.07503075897693634, + 0.09817180037498474, + 0.039125509560108185 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07902700453996658 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot an extreme wide shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perspective that of a quiet, slowly drifting drone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive, multi-ringed spaceship constructed of gunmetal-gray alloy and polished composite materials?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the spaceship feature soaring spires, luminous bridges, and transparent domes covering parks or residential areas?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the spaceship slowly rotating around a vibrant Earth-like planet that occupies a large portion of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03810166195034981 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881016731262207 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03810166195034981, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03810166195034981, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.060341976583004, + 0.05267847701907158, + 0.06645743548870087, + 0.029054084792733192, + 0.0995296984910965, + 0.5755190253257751, + 0.01174461841583252, + 0.05538792908191681, + 0.026809902861714363, + 0.02247679978609085 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03810166195034981 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extreme wide shot, captured from the perspective of a quiet, slowly drifting drone, reveals a vast, city-like spaceship in high orbit, slowly rotating around a vibrant planet. The vessel is a massive, multi-ringed structure constructed of gunmetal-gray alloy and polished composite materials, its immense scale accentuated by the planetary backdrop. Soaring spires, reminiscent of futuristic skyscrapers, pierce the void, interconnected by delicate, luminous bridges, while vast, transparent domes cover what appear to be parks and residential areas. The ship's surface is an intricate tapestry of complex paneling, deep structural canyons, and countless streams of warm golden light from windows and avenues, creating the impression of a metropolis alive in the vacuum of space. The entire station rotates majestically and deliberately on its central axis, a slow, graceful cosmic rotation. Below, the Earth-like planet occupies a large portion of the frame, its surface a breathtaking swirl of deep blue oceans, green and brown continents, and brilliant white clouds. A distant star casts a harsh, bright light on the side of the ship, creating sharp, crisp shadows that crawl across its metal hull as the ship turns, while reflected light from the planet bathes the underside of the ship in a soft, ethereal blue glow. The combination of silent, steady camera drifts and the imperceptible rotation of the ship against the static backdrop of the distant star creates a profound atmosphere of awe, scale, and tranquility, a profound sense of technological grandeur.", + "seed": 20311, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_10/index_7071_seed_20311_dp_21_rank_42_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.2765548836439848, + "vlm_logprob": -0.2765548836439848, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.725, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.2765548836439848, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot an extreme wide shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perspective that of a quiet, slowly drifting drone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive, multi-ringed spaceship constructed of gunmetal-gray alloy and polished composite materials?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the spaceship feature soaring spires, luminous bridges, and transparent domes covering parks or residential areas?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the spaceship slowly rotating around a vibrant Earth-like planet that occupies a large portion of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2512133121490479 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.37621328234672546 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.2512133121490479, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -1.2512133121490479, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14638866484165192, + 0.04366518184542656, + 0.06176569312810898, + 0.12025821954011917, + 0.2514069378376007, + 0.053405147045850754, + 0.14724873006343842, + 0.035014595836400986, + 0.02855537459254265, + 0.11229145526885986 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.2512133121490479 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot an extreme wide shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perspective that of a quiet, slowly drifting drone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive, multi-ringed spaceship constructed of gunmetal-gray alloy and polished composite materials?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the spaceship feature soaring spires, luminous bridges, and transparent domes covering parks or residential areas?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the spaceship slowly rotating around a vibrant Earth-like planet that occupies a large portion of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07006271928548813 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950626373291016 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07006271928548813, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07006271928548813, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09147385507822037, + 0.05462133511900902, + 0.06847662478685379, + 0.06864198297262192, + 0.30960121750831604, + 0.06299854815006256, + 0.11248238384723663, + 0.09075836092233658, + 0.02350430376827717, + 0.11744138598442078 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07006271928548813 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot an extreme wide shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perspective that of a quiet, slowly drifting drone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive, multi-ringed spaceship constructed of gunmetal-gray alloy and polished composite materials?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the spaceship feature soaring spires, luminous bridges, and transparent domes covering parks or residential areas?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the spaceship slowly rotating around a vibrant Earth-like planet that occupies a large portion of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011092543601989746 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511092662811279 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011092543601989746, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011092543601989746, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.103424571454525, + 0.04112048074603081, + 0.12817929685115814, + 0.1157059445977211, + 0.27373582124710083, + 0.02414756268262863, + 0.07329960912466049, + 0.02474517747759819, + 0.02604684978723526, + 0.18959465622901917 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011092543601989746 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot an extreme wide shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perspective that of a quiet, slowly drifting drone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive, multi-ringed spaceship constructed of gunmetal-gray alloy and polished composite materials?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the spaceship feature soaring spires, luminous bridges, and transparent domes covering parks or residential areas?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the spaceship slowly rotating around a vibrant Earth-like planet that occupies a large portion of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02982458658516407 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298244953155518 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02982458658516407, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02982458658516407, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1052175983786583, + 0.06121332198381424, + 0.1428838074207306, + 0.0953950434923172, + 0.19111672043800354, + 0.026070449501276016, + 0.11290183663368225, + 0.0285023283213377, + 0.04993801563978195, + 0.18676087260246277 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02982458658516407 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot an extreme wide shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perspective that of a quiet, slowly drifting drone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive, multi-ringed spaceship constructed of gunmetal-gray alloy and polished composite materials?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the spaceship feature soaring spires, luminous bridges, and transparent domes covering parks or residential areas?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the spaceship slowly rotating around a vibrant Earth-like planet that occupies a large portion of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020581256598234177 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955812454223633 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020581256598234177, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020581256598234177, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2061658501625061, + 0.046162232756614685, + 0.047141075134277344, + 0.16038300096988678, + 0.25160953402519226, + 0.030023014172911644, + 0.045316096395254135, + 0.010558263398706913, + 0.04797280952334404, + 0.15466813743114471 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020581256598234177 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extreme wide shot, captured from the perspective of a quiet, slowly drifting drone, reveals a vast, city-like spaceship in high orbit, slowly rotating around a vibrant planet. The vessel is a massive, multi-ringed structure constructed of gunmetal-gray alloy and polished composite materials, its immense scale accentuated by the planetary backdrop. Soaring spires, reminiscent of futuristic skyscrapers, pierce the void, interconnected by delicate, luminous bridges, while vast, transparent domes cover what appear to be parks and residential areas. The ship's surface is an intricate tapestry of complex paneling, deep structural canyons, and countless streams of warm golden light from windows and avenues, creating the impression of a metropolis alive in the vacuum of space. The entire station rotates majestically and deliberately on its central axis, a slow, graceful cosmic rotation. Below, the Earth-like planet occupies a large portion of the frame, its surface a breathtaking swirl of deep blue oceans, green and brown continents, and brilliant white clouds. A distant star casts a harsh, bright light on the side of the ship, creating sharp, crisp shadows that crawl across its metal hull as the ship turns, while reflected light from the planet bathes the underside of the ship in a soft, ethereal blue glow. The combination of silent, steady camera drifts and the imperceptible rotation of the ship against the static backdrop of the distant star creates a profound atmosphere of awe, scale, and tranquility, a profound sense of technological grandeur.", + "seed": 20312, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_10/index_7071_seed_20312_dp_21_rank_42_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.042013129126280545, + "vlm_logprob": -0.042013129126280545, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.55, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.042013129126280545, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot an extreme wide shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perspective that of a quiet, slowly drifting drone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive, multi-ringed spaceship constructed of gunmetal-gray alloy and polished composite materials?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the spaceship feature soaring spires, luminous bridges, and transparent domes covering parks or residential areas?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the spaceship slowly rotating around a vibrant Earth-like planet that occupies a large portion of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06571012735366821 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9407100677490234 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06571012735366821, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06571012735366821, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23568512499332428, + 0.2938959002494812, + 0.07004202157258987, + 0.022362204268574715, + 0.10452982783317566, + 0.04660137742757797, + 0.0163937546312809, + 0.03165832534432411, + 0.08857893943786621, + 0.090252585709095 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06571012735366821 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot an extreme wide shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perspective that of a quiet, slowly drifting drone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive, multi-ringed spaceship constructed of gunmetal-gray alloy and polished composite materials?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the spaceship feature soaring spires, luminous bridges, and transparent domes covering parks or residential areas?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the spaceship slowly rotating around a vibrant Earth-like planet that occupies a large portion of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07004749029874802 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695047378540039 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07004749029874802, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07004749029874802, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11480838060379028, + 0.14202801883220673, + 0.08648104220628738, + 0.05325283482670784, + 0.12945954501628876, + 0.05190364643931389, + 0.014016088098287582, + 0.08696264773607254, + 0.09561710804700851, + 0.22547072172164917 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07004749029874802 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot an extreme wide shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perspective that of a quiet, slowly drifting drone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive, multi-ringed spaceship constructed of gunmetal-gray alloy and polished composite materials?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the spaceship feature soaring spires, luminous bridges, and transparent domes covering parks or residential areas?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the spaceship slowly rotating around a vibrant Earth-like planet that occupies a large portion of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012557603418827057 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387557506561279 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012557603418827057, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012557603418827057, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17742526531219482, + 0.1598314344882965, + 0.06534043699502945, + 0.07133016735315323, + 0.07110078632831573, + 0.07377387583255768, + 0.03784530982375145, + 0.14153864979743958, + 0.16088317334651947, + 0.04093089699745178 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012557603418827057 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot an extreme wide shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perspective that of a quiet, slowly drifting drone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive, multi-ringed spaceship constructed of gunmetal-gray alloy and polished composite materials?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the spaceship feature soaring spires, luminous bridges, and transparent domes covering parks or residential areas?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the spaceship slowly rotating around a vibrant Earth-like planet that occupies a large portion of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0550089068710804 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.930008888244629 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0550089068710804, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0550089068710804, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1329290121793747, + 0.23089845478534698, + 0.0414634570479393, + 0.0917736068367958, + 0.08214405924081802, + 0.048466309905052185, + 0.034676842391490936, + 0.12455788254737854, + 0.15958772599697113, + 0.053502634167671204 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0550089068710804 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot an extreme wide shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perspective that of a quiet, slowly drifting drone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive, multi-ringed spaceship constructed of gunmetal-gray alloy and polished composite materials?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the spaceship feature soaring spires, luminous bridges, and transparent domes covering parks or residential areas?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the spaceship slowly rotating around a vibrant Earth-like planet that occupies a large portion of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006741517689079046 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006741523742676 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006741517689079046, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006741517689079046, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1702268421649933, + 0.22215351462364197, + 0.061273276805877686, + 0.0716099813580513, + 0.10910223424434662, + 0.08671863377094269, + 0.022706877440214157, + 0.07310979068279266, + 0.11775214970111847, + 0.06534671783447266 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006741517689079046 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_11/index_tensor([4751, 4751])_group_11_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_11/index_tensor([4751, 4751])_group_11_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..85464a7cf223e91a634590db8a5f8d4a2f7bea04 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_11/index_tensor([4751, 4751])_group_11_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "close-up shot, captured from a slightly overhead angle, captures a borosilicate glass beaker with clear white graduations resting on a dark gray metal lab table. The beaker is filled with a liquid emitting an eerie, bright fluorescent green. The liquid itself seems to be a source of light, illuminating the dimly lit laboratory and casting dynamic green specks of light on the cold surface. A transparent glass stirring rod, partially submerged in the liquid, rapidly accelerates from a gentle, steady rotation. As the speed increases, a rapidly and forceful micro-vortex is whipped up in the center of the liquid, deepening and becoming increasingly distinct. The center of the vortex sinks, and the liquid at the edges is spun up by centrifugal force, forming a steady, deep spiral funnel. Light penetrates the spinning glass rod and the vortex, creating a vibrant, dynamic effect. The entire scene is imbued with the focused, tense, and unpredictable energy of a scientific experiment.", + "seed": 28408, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_11/index_4751_seed_28408_dp_22_rank_44_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.048115938110277055, + "vlm_logprob": -0.048115938110277055, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.274999976158142, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.048115938110277055, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up captured from a slightly overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a borosilicate glass beaker with clear white graduations visible on a dark gray metal lab table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the beaker contain a liquid emitting a bright fluorescent green light that illuminates the surroundings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a transparent glass stirring rod rapidly accelerating from a steady rotation to form a deep spiral vortex in the liquid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show dynamic green specks of light on the surface and light penetrating the spinning glass rod and vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009562993422150612 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.634562969207764 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009562993422150612, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009562993422150612, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2508373558521271, + 0.11165621876716614, + 0.07720247656106949, + 0.0457015335559845, + 0.054573483765125275, + 0.04420458897948265, + 0.11020206660032272, + 0.07576915621757507, + 0.14434978365898132, + 0.08550337702035904 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009562993422150612 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up captured from a slightly overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a borosilicate glass beaker with clear white graduations visible on a dark gray metal lab table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the beaker contain a liquid emitting a bright fluorescent green light that illuminates the surroundings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a transparent glass stirring rod rapidly accelerating from a steady rotation to form a deep spiral vortex in the liquid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show dynamic green specks of light on the surface and light penetrating the spinning glass rod and vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14289553463459015 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.017895460128784 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14289553463459015, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.8749998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14289553463459015, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13667453825473785, + 0.11963365972042084, + 0.09814630448818207, + 0.032854463905096054, + 0.10929295420646667, + 0.07732918113470078, + 0.12463618814945221, + 0.14274221658706665, + 0.11337953060865402, + 0.04531104490160942 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14289553463459015 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up captured from a slightly overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a borosilicate glass beaker with clear white graduations visible on a dark gray metal lab table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the beaker contain a liquid emitting a bright fluorescent green light that illuminates the surroundings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a transparent glass stirring rod rapidly accelerating from a steady rotation to form a deep spiral vortex in the liquid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show dynamic green specks of light on the surface and light penetrating the spinning glass rod and vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0015182883944362402 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.501518249511719 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0015182883944362402, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0015182883944362402, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17992225289344788, + 0.18593758344650269, + 0.055014993995428085, + 0.05735645443201065, + 0.08056701719760895, + 0.03697850927710533, + 0.12772949039936066, + 0.06297911703586578, + 0.12394552677869797, + 0.08956904709339142 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0015182883944362402 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up captured from a slightly overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a borosilicate glass beaker with clear white graduations visible on a dark gray metal lab table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the beaker contain a liquid emitting a bright fluorescent green light that illuminates the surroundings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a transparent glass stirring rod rapidly accelerating from a steady rotation to form a deep spiral vortex in the liquid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show dynamic green specks of light on the surface and light penetrating the spinning glass rod and vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.078973688185215 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5789737701416016 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.078973688185215, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.078973688185215, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17767497897148132, + 0.12514467537403107, + 0.10344438254833221, + 0.05930747836828232, + 0.08236247301101685, + 0.043182373046875, + 0.07602521777153015, + 0.1459624320268631, + 0.14582659304141998, + 0.041069407016038895 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.078973688185215 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up captured from a slightly overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a borosilicate glass beaker with clear white graduations visible on a dark gray metal lab table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the beaker contain a liquid emitting a bright fluorescent green light that illuminates the surroundings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a transparent glass stirring rod rapidly accelerating from a steady rotation to form a deep spiral vortex in the liquid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show dynamic green specks of light on the surface and light penetrating the spinning glass rod and vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007629185914993286 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.88262939453125 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007629185914993286, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007629185914993286, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2711077928543091, + 0.14816904067993164, + 0.05323954299092293, + 0.04163409397006035, + 0.10139718651771545, + 0.05673603713512421, + 0.10115660727024078, + 0.07721222937107086, + 0.054525986313819885, + 0.094821497797966 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007629185914993286 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up shot, captured from a slightly overhead angle, captures a borosilicate glass beaker with clear white graduations resting on a dark gray metal lab table. The beaker is filled with a liquid emitting an eerie, bright fluorescent green. The liquid itself seems to be a source of light, illuminating the dimly lit laboratory and casting dynamic green specks of light on the cold surface. A transparent glass stirring rod, partially submerged in the liquid, rapidly accelerates from a gentle, steady rotation. As the speed increases, a rapidly and forceful micro-vortex is whipped up in the center of the liquid, deepening and becoming increasingly distinct. The center of the vortex sinks, and the liquid at the edges is spun up by centrifugal force, forming a steady, deep spiral funnel. Light penetrates the spinning glass rod and the vortex, creating a vibrant, dynamic effect. The entire scene is imbued with the focused, tense, and unpredictable energy of a scientific experiment.", + "seed": 28409, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_11/index_4751_seed_28409_dp_22_rank_44_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.029003902990370988, + "vlm_logprob": -0.029003902990370988, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.3, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.029003902990370988, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up captured from a slightly overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a borosilicate glass beaker with clear white graduations visible on a dark gray metal lab table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the beaker contain a liquid emitting a bright fluorescent green light that illuminates the surroundings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a transparent glass stirring rod rapidly accelerating from a steady rotation to form a deep spiral vortex in the liquid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show dynamic green specks of light on the surface and light penetrating the spinning glass rod and vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01701061986386776 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.517010688781738 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01701061986386776, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01701061986386776, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5931294560432434, + 0.07240341603755951, + 0.07030699402093887, + 0.029741406440734863, + 0.023169754073023796, + 0.03901316225528717, + 0.044556114822626114, + 0.026326118037104607, + 0.03575032576918602, + 0.0656033307313919 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01701061986386776 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up captured from a slightly overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a borosilicate glass beaker with clear white graduations visible on a dark gray metal lab table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the beaker contain a liquid emitting a bright fluorescent green light that illuminates the surroundings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a transparent glass stirring rod rapidly accelerating from a steady rotation to form a deep spiral vortex in the liquid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show dynamic green specks of light on the surface and light penetrating the spinning glass rod and vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026382768526673317 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513826847076416 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026382768526673317, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026382768526673317, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5682557225227356, + 0.03426095470786095, + 0.0722622498869896, + 0.018884720280766487, + 0.04021020978689194, + 0.03121134638786316, + 0.04351922497153282, + 0.10255254060029984, + 0.05295449495315552, + 0.035888586193323135 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026382768526673317 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up captured from a slightly overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a borosilicate glass beaker with clear white graduations visible on a dark gray metal lab table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the beaker contain a liquid emitting a bright fluorescent green light that illuminates the surroundings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a transparent glass stirring rod rapidly accelerating from a steady rotation to form a deep spiral vortex in the liquid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show dynamic green specks of light on the surface and light penetrating the spinning glass rod and vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.001517812255769968 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.5015177726745605 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.001517812255769968, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.001517812255769968, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.7123510837554932, + 0.09724079072475433, + 0.07241404056549072, + 0.015324198640882969, + 0.00828616227954626, + 0.019316913560032845, + 0.014557885006070137, + 0.013483435846865177, + 0.033242885023355484, + 0.0137826818972826 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.001517812255769968 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up captured from a slightly overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a borosilicate glass beaker with clear white graduations visible on a dark gray metal lab table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the beaker contain a liquid emitting a bright fluorescent green light that illuminates the surroundings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a transparent glass stirring rod rapidly accelerating from a steady rotation to form a deep spiral vortex in the liquid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show dynamic green specks of light on the surface and light penetrating the spinning glass rod and vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08903215825557709 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4640321731567383 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08903215825557709, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08903215825557709, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.7368972897529602, + 0.02120494283735752, + 0.051541171967983246, + 0.035321224480867386, + 0.019520828500390053, + 0.039631932973861694, + 0.03308550640940666, + 0.019610973075032234, + 0.017420778051018715, + 0.025765283033251762 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08903215825557709 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up captured from a slightly overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a borosilicate glass beaker with clear white graduations visible on a dark gray metal lab table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the beaker contain a liquid emitting a bright fluorescent green light that illuminates the surroundings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a transparent glass stirring rod rapidly accelerating from a steady rotation to form a deep spiral vortex in the liquid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show dynamic green specks of light on the surface and light penetrating the spinning glass rod and vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011076156049966812 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511075973510742 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011076156049966812, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011076156049966812, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2231024205684662, + 0.07778408378362656, + 0.075992651283741, + 0.08654890954494476, + 0.09438710659742355, + 0.06070338562130928, + 0.17138671875, + 0.02614331990480423, + 0.07335371524095535, + 0.11059775203466415 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011076156049966812 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up shot, captured from a slightly overhead angle, captures a borosilicate glass beaker with clear white graduations resting on a dark gray metal lab table. The beaker is filled with a liquid emitting an eerie, bright fluorescent green. The liquid itself seems to be a source of light, illuminating the dimly lit laboratory and casting dynamic green specks of light on the cold surface. A transparent glass stirring rod, partially submerged in the liquid, rapidly accelerates from a gentle, steady rotation. As the speed increases, a rapidly and forceful micro-vortex is whipped up in the center of the liquid, deepening and becoming increasingly distinct. The center of the vortex sinks, and the liquid at the edges is spun up by centrifugal force, forming a steady, deep spiral funnel. Light penetrates the spinning glass rod and the vortex, creating a vibrant, dynamic effect. The entire scene is imbued with the focused, tense, and unpredictable energy of a scientific experiment.", + "seed": 28410, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_11/index_4751_seed_28410_dp_23_rank_46_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.04794980043079704, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04794980043079704, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.65, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04794980043079704, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up captured from a slightly overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a borosilicate glass beaker with clear white graduations visible on a dark gray metal lab table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the beaker contain a liquid emitting a bright fluorescent green light that illuminates the surroundings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a transparent glass stirring rod rapidly accelerating from a steady rotation to form a deep spiral vortex in the liquid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show dynamic green specks of light on the surface and light penetrating the spinning glass rod and vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008963466621935368 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.633963584899902 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008963466621935368, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008963466621935368, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0974365696310997, + 0.054152172058820724, + 0.12245700508356094, + 0.24414794147014618, + 0.033238764852285385, + 0.03909657150506973, + 0.04064682871103287, + 0.04827838018536568, + 0.048216212540864944, + 0.27232950925827026 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008963466621935368 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up captured from a slightly overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a borosilicate glass beaker with clear white graduations visible on a dark gray metal lab table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the beaker contain a liquid emitting a bright fluorescent green light that illuminates the surroundings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a transparent glass stirring rod rapidly accelerating from a steady rotation to form a deep spiral vortex in the liquid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show dynamic green specks of light on the surface and light penetrating the spinning glass rod and vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17994999885559082 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8049499988555908 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17994999885559082, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17994999885559082, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08850835263729095, + 0.15946124494075775, + 0.14444977045059204, + 0.06825549155473709, + 0.07670944184064865, + 0.06941483914852142, + 0.1848032921552658, + 0.03368515148758888, + 0.03116070106625557, + 0.14355167746543884 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17994999885559082 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up captured from a slightly overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a borosilicate glass beaker with clear white graduations visible on a dark gray metal lab table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the beaker contain a liquid emitting a bright fluorescent green light that illuminates the surroundings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a transparent glass stirring rod rapidly accelerating from a steady rotation to form a deep spiral vortex in the liquid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show dynamic green specks of light on the surface and light penetrating the spinning glass rod and vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0010451575508341193 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.876045227050781 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0010451575508341193, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0010451575508341193, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.219854936003685, + 0.10586099326610565, + 0.09254768490791321, + 0.15327486395835876, + 0.07643505185842514, + 0.035189464688301086, + 0.14592653512954712, + 0.04087591543793678, + 0.061938878148794174, + 0.06809571385383606 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0010451575508341193 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up captured from a slightly overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a borosilicate glass beaker with clear white graduations visible on a dark gray metal lab table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the beaker contain a liquid emitting a bright fluorescent green light that illuminates the surroundings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a transparent glass stirring rod rapidly accelerating from a steady rotation to form a deep spiral vortex in the liquid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show dynamic green specks of light on the surface and light penetrating the spinning glass rod and vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.043053124099969864 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168053150177002 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.043053124099969864, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.043053124099969864, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08844036608934402, + 0.059088531881570816, + 0.055090975016355515, + 0.34649088978767395, + 0.03543560951948166, + 0.06797660142183304, + 0.0392134003341198, + 0.07875129580497742, + 0.0885380357503891, + 0.1409742534160614 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.043053124099969864 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up captured from a slightly overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a borosilicate glass beaker with clear white graduations visible on a dark gray metal lab table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the beaker contain a liquid emitting a bright fluorescent green light that illuminates the surroundings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a transparent glass stirring rod rapidly accelerating from a steady rotation to form a deep spiral vortex in the liquid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show dynamic green specks of light on the surface and light penetrating the spinning glass rod and vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006737255025655031 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006737232208252 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006737255025655031, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006737255025655031, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13872545957565308, + 0.13836419582366943, + 0.0975402370095253, + 0.15927809476852417, + 0.04879777133464813, + 0.10207020491361618, + 0.05226799100637436, + 0.04917841777205467, + 0.0680769756436348, + 0.14570069313049316 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006737255025655031 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up shot, captured from a slightly overhead angle, captures a borosilicate glass beaker with clear white graduations resting on a dark gray metal lab table. The beaker is filled with a liquid emitting an eerie, bright fluorescent green. The liquid itself seems to be a source of light, illuminating the dimly lit laboratory and casting dynamic green specks of light on the cold surface. A transparent glass stirring rod, partially submerged in the liquid, rapidly accelerates from a gentle, steady rotation. As the speed increases, a rapidly and forceful micro-vortex is whipped up in the center of the liquid, deepening and becoming increasingly distinct. The center of the vortex sinks, and the liquid at the edges is spun up by centrifugal force, forming a steady, deep spiral funnel. Light penetrates the spinning glass rod and the vortex, creating a vibrant, dynamic effect. The entire scene is imbued with the focused, tense, and unpredictable energy of a scientific experiment.", + "seed": 28411, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_11/index_4751_seed_28411_dp_23_rank_46_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.027351181395351885, + "vlm_logprob": -0.027351181395351885, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.1, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.027351181395351885, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up captured from a slightly overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a borosilicate glass beaker with clear white graduations visible on a dark gray metal lab table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the beaker contain a liquid emitting a bright fluorescent green light that illuminates the surroundings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a transparent glass stirring rod rapidly accelerating from a steady rotation to form a deep spiral vortex in the liquid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show dynamic green specks of light on the surface and light penetrating the spinning glass rod and vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026787081733345985 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.026787281036377 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026787081733345985, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026787081733345985, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05753539875149727, + 0.11025228351354599, + 0.05913041904568672, + 0.06233580410480499, + 0.048486970365047455, + 0.021261489018797874, + 0.02861299365758896, + 0.06345801055431366, + 0.435259073972702, + 0.11366749554872513 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026787081733345985 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up captured from a slightly overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a borosilicate glass beaker with clear white graduations visible on a dark gray metal lab table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the beaker contain a liquid emitting a bright fluorescent green light that illuminates the surroundings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a transparent glass stirring rod rapidly accelerating from a steady rotation to form a deep spiral vortex in the liquid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show dynamic green specks of light on the surface and light penetrating the spinning glass rod and vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0487031489610672 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048703193664551 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0487031489610672, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0487031489610672, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06928068399429321, + 0.0932653620839119, + 0.03375215828418732, + 0.07865764945745468, + 0.08130573481321335, + 0.029892774298787117, + 0.0474666953086853, + 0.08025556802749634, + 0.21993328630924225, + 0.2661900818347931 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0487031489610672 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up captured from a slightly overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a borosilicate glass beaker with clear white graduations visible on a dark gray metal lab table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the beaker contain a liquid emitting a bright fluorescent green light that illuminates the surroundings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a transparent glass stirring rod rapidly accelerating from a steady rotation to form a deep spiral vortex in the liquid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show dynamic green specks of light on the surface and light penetrating the spinning glass rod and vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0028257938101887703 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877825736999512 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0028257938101887703, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0028257938101887703, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15808039903640747, + 0.14746685326099396, + 0.0457146130502224, + 0.03681871294975281, + 0.0462627187371254, + 0.025003960356116295, + 0.05234565958380699, + 0.03808526694774628, + 0.4039541184902191, + 0.04626777023077011 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0028257938101887703 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up captured from a slightly overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a borosilicate glass beaker with clear white graduations visible on a dark gray metal lab table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the beaker contain a liquid emitting a bright fluorescent green light that illuminates the surroundings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a transparent glass stirring rod rapidly accelerating from a steady rotation to form a deep spiral vortex in the liquid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show dynamic green specks of light on the surface and light penetrating the spinning glass rod and vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.048653870820999146 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486538410186768 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.048653870820999146, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.048653870820999146, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10624467581510544, + 0.1425522416830063, + 0.10318552702665329, + 0.023473864421248436, + 0.030235573649406433, + 0.02344251610338688, + 0.0405912883579731, + 0.042344655841588974, + 0.4234007000923157, + 0.06452891230583191 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.048653870820999146 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up captured from a slightly overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a borosilicate glass beaker with clear white graduations visible on a dark gray metal lab table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the beaker contain a liquid emitting a bright fluorescent green light that illuminates the surroundings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a transparent glass stirring rod rapidly accelerating from a steady rotation to form a deep spiral vortex in the liquid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show dynamic green specks of light on the surface and light penetrating the spinning glass rod and vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009786011651158333 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634786128997803 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009786011651158333, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009786011651158333, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07716201990842819, + 0.11797414720058441, + 0.12199875712394714, + 0.042349036782979965, + 0.030346833169460297, + 0.02312469482421875, + 0.04097554460167885, + 0.05174538493156433, + 0.43367621302604675, + 0.0606473945081234 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009786011651158333 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_12/index_tensor([915, 915])_group_12_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_12/index_tensor([915, 915])_group_12_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..c3e867efd5e826de6c8600b79ea79028d5b6f09a --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_12/index_tensor([915, 915])_group_12_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "static, eye-level medium shot, imbued with subtle film grain for a cinematic quality, captures a realistic portrait of a royal woman. She stands poised on a smooth, mossy stone ledge, before a thundering waterfall that plunges into a dark pool below, sending a perpetual cloud of fine mist high into the air. A focused beam of afternoon light pierces the clouds, illuminating her. Her raven hair, elegantly curled, her fair skin, speckled with shimmering droplets of mist, contrasts starkly with her deep emerald velvet gown, appearing heavy and damp. Her features are somber and pensive, her dark eyes peering through the lens. Her right hand loosely grips a large, ornate fan made of dark carved wood and faded silk, its weight a testament to her weary elegance. Focused light catches water particles in the air, creating a shimmering halo around her, accentuating the profound melancholy in her expression and creating a powerful, atmospheric scene of quiet dignity set against the raw power of nature.", + "seed": 26645, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_12/index_915_seed_26645_dp_24_rank_48_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.09850639309734106, + "vlm_logprob": -0.09850639309734106, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.325000011920929, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.09850639309734106, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static, eye-level medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a realistic portrait of a royal woman with raven hair and fair skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a deep emerald velvet gown that appears heavy and damp?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a thundering waterfall plunging into a dark pool with a cloud of fine mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the woman holding a large, ornate fan made of dark carved wood and faded silk in her right hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03876115754246712 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6637611389160156 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03876115754246712, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03876115754246712, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13937179744243622, + 0.050598468631505966, + 0.061190854758024216, + 0.04066576436161995, + 0.09197105467319489, + 0.1420985758304596, + 0.2624630033969879, + 0.08888958394527435, + 0.08793415874242783, + 0.03481675311923027 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03876115754246712 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static, eye-level medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a realistic portrait of a royal woman with raven hair and fair skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a deep emerald velvet gown that appears heavy and damp?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a thundering waterfall plunging into a dark pool with a cloud of fine mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the woman holding a large, ornate fan made of dark carved wood and faded silk in her right hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03813023492693901 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288130283355713 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03813023492693901, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03813023492693901, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1961522400379181, + 0.04303742200136185, + 0.17561540007591248, + 0.07011716812849045, + 0.04889584332704544, + 0.11157499253749847, + 0.23126821219921112, + 0.061907391995191574, + 0.02191341295838356, + 0.03951790928840637 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03813023492693901 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static, eye-level medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a realistic portrait of a royal woman with raven hair and fair skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a deep emerald velvet gown that appears heavy and damp?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a thundering waterfall plunging into a dark pool with a cloud of fine mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the woman holding a large, ornate fan made of dark carved wood and faded silk in her right hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02329447865486145 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773294448852539 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02329447865486145, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02329447865486145, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10108588635921478, + 0.05811048671603203, + 0.24861982464790344, + 0.03087652660906315, + 0.04620141163468361, + 0.05917949974536896, + 0.21227845549583435, + 0.19623292982578278, + 0.02446158044040203, + 0.022953426465392113 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02329447865486145 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static, eye-level medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a realistic portrait of a royal woman with raven hair and fair skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a deep emerald velvet gown that appears heavy and damp?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a thundering waterfall plunging into a dark pool with a cloud of fine mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the woman holding a large, ornate fan made of dark carved wood and faded silk in her right hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005252371542155743 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255252361297607 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005252371542155743, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005252371542155743, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20453138649463654, + 0.08209924399852753, + 0.42312759160995483, + 0.02585144340991974, + 0.007349337451159954, + 0.023939305916428566, + 0.02028290554881096, + 0.18929608166217804, + 0.014983683824539185, + 0.008539114147424698 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005252371542155743 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static, eye-level medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a realistic portrait of a royal woman with raven hair and fair skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a deep emerald velvet gown that appears heavy and damp?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a thundering waterfall plunging into a dark pool with a cloud of fine mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the woman holding a large, ornate fan made of dark carved wood and faded silk in her right hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.387093722820282 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1370937824249268 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.387093722820282, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.7500000596046448, + "token_credit_reward": -0.387093722820282, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13997924327850342, + 0.03632264956831932, + 0.18609683215618134, + 0.16003172099590302, + 0.16514456272125244, + 0.12759284675121307, + 0.03638206422328949, + 0.09050866216421127, + 0.020440692082047462, + 0.03750075772404671 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.387093722820282 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, eye-level medium shot, imbued with subtle film grain for a cinematic quality, captures a realistic portrait of a royal woman. She stands poised on a smooth, mossy stone ledge, before a thundering waterfall that plunges into a dark pool below, sending a perpetual cloud of fine mist high into the air. A focused beam of afternoon light pierces the clouds, illuminating her. Her raven hair, elegantly curled, her fair skin, speckled with shimmering droplets of mist, contrasts starkly with her deep emerald velvet gown, appearing heavy and damp. Her features are somber and pensive, her dark eyes peering through the lens. Her right hand loosely grips a large, ornate fan made of dark carved wood and faded silk, its weight a testament to her weary elegance. Focused light catches water particles in the air, creating a shimmering halo around her, accentuating the profound melancholy in her expression and creating a powerful, atmospheric scene of quiet dignity set against the raw power of nature.", + "seed": 26646, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_12/index_915_seed_26646_dp_24_rank_48_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.05802471553906798, + "vlm_logprob": -0.05802471553906798, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.275, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.05802471553906798, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static, eye-level medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a realistic portrait of a royal woman with raven hair and fair skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a deep emerald velvet gown that appears heavy and damp?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a thundering waterfall plunging into a dark pool with a cloud of fine mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the woman holding a large, ornate fan made of dark carved wood and faded silk in her right hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07498854398727417 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.949988603591919 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07498854398727417, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07498854398727417, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0923423320055008, + 0.05412829667329788, + 0.021147074177861214, + 0.030609076842665672, + 0.033699240535497665, + 0.07265951484441757, + 0.10345657914876938, + 0.14353546500205994, + 0.09855982661247253, + 0.34986257553100586 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07498854398727417 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static, eye-level medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a realistic portrait of a royal woman with raven hair and fair skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a deep emerald velvet gown that appears heavy and damp?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a thundering waterfall plunging into a dark pool with a cloud of fine mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the woman holding a large, ornate fan made of dark carved wood and faded silk in her right hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0549841970205307 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299840927124023 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0549841970205307, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0549841970205307, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.33949121832847595, + 0.1474768966436386, + 0.06413809955120087, + 0.042856328189373016, + 0.05786652863025665, + 0.0491660013794899, + 0.037727195769548416, + 0.0917264074087143, + 0.0681975856423378, + 0.1013537272810936 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0549841970205307 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static, eye-level medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a realistic portrait of a royal woman with raven hair and fair skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a deep emerald velvet gown that appears heavy and damp?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a thundering waterfall plunging into a dark pool with a cloud of fine mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the woman holding a large, ornate fan made of dark carved wood and faded silk in her right hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026355251669883728 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651355266571045 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026355251669883728, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026355251669883728, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20084340870380402, + 0.1066899225115776, + 0.03878597915172577, + 0.03507629409432411, + 0.04796281084418297, + 0.028626997023820877, + 0.04853952303528786, + 0.029098931699991226, + 0.030926870182156563, + 0.43344923853874207 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026355251669883728 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static, eye-level medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a realistic portrait of a royal woman with raven hair and fair skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a deep emerald velvet gown that appears heavy and damp?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a thundering waterfall plunging into a dark pool with a cloud of fine mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the woman holding a large, ornate fan made of dark carved wood and faded silk in her right hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006739031057804823 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006739139556885 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006739031057804823, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006739031057804823, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11579423397779465, + 0.17672227323055267, + 0.03478782996535301, + 0.0130265261977911, + 0.08888620883226395, + 0.010305901989340782, + 0.013963491655886173, + 0.02842780575156212, + 0.025923730805516243, + 0.4921620190143585 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006739031057804823 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static, eye-level medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a realistic portrait of a royal woman with raven hair and fair skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a deep emerald velvet gown that appears heavy and damp?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a thundering waterfall plunging into a dark pool with a cloud of fine mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the woman holding a large, ornate fan made of dark carved wood and faded silk in her right hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1270565539598465 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.12705659866333 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1270565539598465, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1270565539598465, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15694628655910492, + 0.1039520725607872, + 0.04843342676758766, + 0.03728285804390907, + 0.04386656731367111, + 0.06500010937452316, + 0.025388477370142937, + 0.03502190113067627, + 0.028408842161297798, + 0.4556994140148163 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1270565539598465 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, eye-level medium shot, imbued with subtle film grain for a cinematic quality, captures a realistic portrait of a royal woman. She stands poised on a smooth, mossy stone ledge, before a thundering waterfall that plunges into a dark pool below, sending a perpetual cloud of fine mist high into the air. A focused beam of afternoon light pierces the clouds, illuminating her. Her raven hair, elegantly curled, her fair skin, speckled with shimmering droplets of mist, contrasts starkly with her deep emerald velvet gown, appearing heavy and damp. Her features are somber and pensive, her dark eyes peering through the lens. Her right hand loosely grips a large, ornate fan made of dark carved wood and faded silk, its weight a testament to her weary elegance. Focused light catches water particles in the air, creating a shimmering halo around her, accentuating the profound melancholy in her expression and creating a powerful, atmospheric scene of quiet dignity set against the raw power of nature.", + "seed": 26647, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_12/index_915_seed_26647_dp_25_rank_50_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.06648782156407833, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06648782156407833, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.175000023841858, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06648782156407833, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static, eye-level medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a realistic portrait of a royal woman with raven hair and fair skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a deep emerald velvet gown that appears heavy and damp?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a thundering waterfall plunging into a dark pool with a cloud of fine mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the woman holding a large, ornate fan made of dark carved wood and faded silk in her right hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10748475790023804 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.607484817504883 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10748475790023804, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10748475790023804, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21260233223438263, + 0.16605879366397858, + 0.028918517753481865, + 0.04678545892238617, + 0.020021680742502213, + 0.025728831067681313, + 0.09751056134700775, + 0.13916534185409546, + 0.21918265521526337, + 0.044025812298059464 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10748475790023804 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static, eye-level medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a realistic portrait of a royal woman with raven hair and fair skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a deep emerald velvet gown that appears heavy and damp?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a thundering waterfall plunging into a dark pool with a cloud of fine mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the woman holding a large, ornate fan made of dark carved wood and faded silk in her right hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05499221011996269 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929992198944092 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05499221011996269, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05499221011996269, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2306160032749176, + 0.1185496374964714, + 0.08366306126117706, + 0.07723193615674973, + 0.03123512864112854, + 0.027625305578112602, + 0.0470820851624012, + 0.20994363725185394, + 0.05975852161645889, + 0.11429469287395477 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05499221011996269 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static, eye-level medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a realistic portrait of a royal woman with raven hair and fair skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a deep emerald velvet gown that appears heavy and damp?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a thundering waterfall plunging into a dark pool with a cloud of fine mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the woman holding a large, ornate fan made of dark carved wood and faded silk in her right hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01607704907655716 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141077041625977 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01607704907655716, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01607704907655716, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13060827553272247, + 0.3594468832015991, + 0.0932716429233551, + 0.06452085077762604, + 0.024489568546414375, + 0.015806328505277634, + 0.04528546705842018, + 0.15982110798358917, + 0.04986422136425972, + 0.056885719299316406 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01607704907655716 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static, eye-level medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a realistic portrait of a royal woman with raven hair and fair skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a deep emerald velvet gown that appears heavy and damp?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a thundering waterfall plunging into a dark pool with a cloud of fine mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the woman holding a large, ornate fan made of dark carved wood and faded silk in her right hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011076981201767921 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511076927185059 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011076981201767921, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011076981201767921, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2887459099292755, + 0.12264811247587204, + 0.2186960130929947, + 0.08927804231643677, + 0.02362673543393612, + 0.05350252985954285, + 0.059780120849609375, + 0.019770456477999687, + 0.07802064716815948, + 0.04593146592378616 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011076981201767921 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static, eye-level medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a realistic portrait of a royal woman with raven hair and fair skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a deep emerald velvet gown that appears heavy and damp?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a thundering waterfall plunging into a dark pool with a cloud of fine mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the woman holding a large, ornate fan made of dark carved wood and faded silk in her right hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14280810952186584 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.017808198928833 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14280810952186584, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.8750001192092896, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14280810952186584, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19909101724624634, + 0.15116675198078156, + 0.0357695035636425, + 0.06723156571388245, + 0.10951368510723114, + 0.024375196546316147, + 0.043531276285648346, + 0.28493431210517883, + 0.0241097379475832, + 0.06027694419026375 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14280810952186584 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, eye-level medium shot, imbued with subtle film grain for a cinematic quality, captures a realistic portrait of a royal woman. She stands poised on a smooth, mossy stone ledge, before a thundering waterfall that plunges into a dark pool below, sending a perpetual cloud of fine mist high into the air. A focused beam of afternoon light pierces the clouds, illuminating her. Her raven hair, elegantly curled, her fair skin, speckled with shimmering droplets of mist, contrasts starkly with her deep emerald velvet gown, appearing heavy and damp. Her features are somber and pensive, her dark eyes peering through the lens. Her right hand loosely grips a large, ornate fan made of dark carved wood and faded silk, its weight a testament to her weary elegance. Focused light catches water particles in the air, creating a shimmering halo around her, accentuating the profound melancholy in her expression and creating a powerful, atmospheric scene of quiet dignity set against the raw power of nature.", + "seed": 26648, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_12/index_915_seed_26648_dp_25_rank_50_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.07895183116197586, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07895183116197586, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.075, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07895183116197586, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static, eye-level medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a realistic portrait of a royal woman with raven hair and fair skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a deep emerald velvet gown that appears heavy and damp?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a thundering waterfall plunging into a dark pool with a cloud of fine mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the woman holding a large, ornate fan made of dark carved wood and faded silk in her right hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12509413063526154 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.375094175338745 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12509413063526154, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12509413063526154, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16815894842147827, + 0.07569626718759537, + 0.07850728929042816, + 0.19263340532779694, + 0.03741060569882393, + 0.04301087185740471, + 0.053409550338983536, + 0.07659980654716492, + 0.19881372153759003, + 0.07575959712266922 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12509413063526154 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static, eye-level medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a realistic portrait of a royal woman with raven hair and fair skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a deep emerald velvet gown that appears heavy and damp?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a thundering waterfall plunging into a dark pool with a cloud of fine mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the woman holding a large, ornate fan made of dark carved wood and faded silk in her right hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03373163938522339 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408731698989868 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03373163938522339, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03373163938522339, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16846589744091034, + 0.09868193417787552, + 0.25962015986442566, + 0.048527881503105164, + 0.05554190278053284, + 0.02722294069826603, + 0.08535737544298172, + 0.08403477817773819, + 0.07052595913410187, + 0.10202125459909439 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03373163938522339 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static, eye-level medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a realistic portrait of a royal woman with raven hair and fair skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a deep emerald velvet gown that appears heavy and damp?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a thundering waterfall plunging into a dark pool with a cloud of fine mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the woman holding a large, ornate fan made of dark carved wood and faded silk in her right hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011080989614129066 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511081218719482 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011080989614129066, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011080989614129066, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11473263800144196, + 0.13122346997261047, + 0.10522681474685669, + 0.0704910084605217, + 0.11079815775156021, + 0.08011123538017273, + 0.06942519545555115, + 0.08919719606637955, + 0.14289610087871552, + 0.08589818328619003 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011080989614129066 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static, eye-level medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a realistic portrait of a royal woman with raven hair and fair skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a deep emerald velvet gown that appears heavy and damp?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a thundering waterfall plunging into a dark pool with a cloud of fine mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the woman holding a large, ornate fan made of dark carved wood and faded silk in her right hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023288888856768608 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732889652252197 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023288888856768608, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023288888856768608, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22550378739833832, + 0.27959132194519043, + 0.04056984931230545, + 0.08287641406059265, + 0.07147793471813202, + 0.06895309686660767, + 0.07109148055315018, + 0.11773207783699036, + 0.022591087967157364, + 0.019612940028309822 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023288888856768608 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static, eye-level medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a realistic portrait of a royal woman with raven hair and fair skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a deep emerald velvet gown that appears heavy and damp?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a thundering waterfall plunging into a dark pool with a cloud of fine mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the woman holding a large, ornate fan made of dark carved wood and faded silk in her right hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2015635073184967 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7015634775161743 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2015635073184967, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2015635073184967, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17322301864624023, + 0.13302983343601227, + 0.27442193031311035, + 0.07822263985872269, + 0.053587768226861954, + 0.046888407319784164, + 0.02919687144458294, + 0.06403165310621262, + 0.05260070040822029, + 0.09479716420173645 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2015635073184967 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_13/index_tensor([4351, 4351])_group_13_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_13/index_tensor([4351, 4351])_group_13_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..c48bc131588c3d6a3958167fa29a1f26cd6c4587 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_13/index_tensor([4351, 4351])_group_13_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "medium close-up shot from a slightly high angle depicts the scene, the camera exhibiting a subtle handheld tremor that lends it a raw, intimate feel. In the center of the frame, a clean-shaven man awakens from a deep slumber on a simple footrest. He wears a loose, saffron-colored robe made of a rough, simple fabric. The austere room is cast in cool, deep shadows, a stark contrast to a brilliant ray of golden morning sunlight filtering through a tall, narrow window. This beam, imbued with dancing dust, falls directly upon his face, highlighting the weathered lines around his eyes and the texture of his skin. Stimulated by the light, his eyelids begin to twitch subtly, then open in a slow, hesitant motion. His pupils, initially unfocused, gradually constrict as they adjust to the brightness, his expression like a calm canvas returning to consciousness. The atmosphere is one of profound tranquility and concentration, the gentle awakening juxtaposed with the camera's slight instability creating a powerful and intimate visual narrative.", + "seed": 30483, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_13/index_4351_seed_30483_dp_26_rank_52_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.08291351199150085, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08291351199150085, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.05, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08291351199150085, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up of a clean-shaven man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a loose, saffron-colored robe made of rough fabric?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by cool deep shadows with a single beam of golden sunlight filtering through a tall narrow window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man's face show weathered lines and skin texture highlighted by the sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit a subtle handheld tremor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20565573871135712 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7056556940078735 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20565573871135712, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20565573871135712, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2283988893032074, + 0.09335790574550629, + 0.09415864944458008, + 0.04158482700586319, + 0.07636985182762146, + 0.07264314591884613, + 0.1100388690829277, + 0.07914316654205322, + 0.14924421906471252, + 0.055060405284166336 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20565573871135712 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up of a clean-shaven man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a loose, saffron-colored robe made of rough fabric?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by cool deep shadows with a single beam of golden sunlight filtering through a tall narrow window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man's face show weathered lines and skin texture highlighted by the sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit a subtle handheld tremor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03813666105270386 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881367206573486 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03813666105270386, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03813666105270386, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22056621313095093, + 0.10449621081352234, + 0.1036461666226387, + 0.030363889411091805, + 0.06504251807928085, + 0.04484202340245247, + 0.08342964202165604, + 0.13271665573120117, + 0.16769783198833466, + 0.0471988245844841 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03813666105270386 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up of a clean-shaven man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a loose, saffron-colored robe made of rough fabric?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by cool deep shadows with a single beam of golden sunlight filtering through a tall narrow window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man's face show weathered lines and skin texture highlighted by the sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit a subtle handheld tremor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018200766295194626 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018200874328613 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018200766295194626, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018200766295194626, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.34699729084968567, + 0.1472892165184021, + 0.09066259115934372, + 0.03871320188045502, + 0.022212572395801544, + 0.07383518666028976, + 0.07639500498771667, + 0.06065711751580238, + 0.09809225797653198, + 0.04514552652835846 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018200766295194626 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up of a clean-shaven man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a loose, saffron-colored robe made of rough fabric?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by cool deep shadows with a single beam of golden sunlight filtering through a tall narrow window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man's face show weathered lines and skin texture highlighted by the sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit a subtle handheld tremor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009791914373636246 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634791851043701 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009791914373636246, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009791914373636246, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14214849472045898, + 0.06870514899492264, + 0.08687534183263779, + 0.10316561907529831, + 0.03605325147509575, + 0.07293444871902466, + 0.06734396517276764, + 0.1072934940457344, + 0.231639564037323, + 0.08384065330028534 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009791914373636246 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up of a clean-shaven man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a loose, saffron-colored robe made of rough fabric?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by cool deep shadows with a single beam of golden sunlight filtering through a tall narrow window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man's face show weathered lines and skin texture highlighted by the sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit a subtle handheld tremor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14278247952461243 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.01778244972229 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14278247952461243, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14278247952461243, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20368848741054535, + 0.08321844786405563, + 0.04726786911487579, + 0.038288556039333344, + 0.03522545099258423, + 0.05571622774004936, + 0.1623837649822235, + 0.11320174485445023, + 0.16517367959022522, + 0.09583573788404465 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14278247952461243 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "medium close-up shot from a slightly high angle depicts the scene, the camera exhibiting a subtle handheld tremor that lends it a raw, intimate feel. In the center of the frame, a clean-shaven man awakens from a deep slumber on a simple footrest. He wears a loose, saffron-colored robe made of a rough, simple fabric. The austere room is cast in cool, deep shadows, a stark contrast to a brilliant ray of golden morning sunlight filtering through a tall, narrow window. This beam, imbued with dancing dust, falls directly upon his face, highlighting the weathered lines around his eyes and the texture of his skin. Stimulated by the light, his eyelids begin to twitch subtly, then open in a slow, hesitant motion. His pupils, initially unfocused, gradually constrict as they adjust to the brightness, his expression like a calm canvas returning to consciousness. The atmosphere is one of profound tranquility and concentration, the gentle awakening juxtaposed with the camera's slight instability creating a powerful and intimate visual narrative.", + "seed": 30484, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_13/index_4351_seed_30484_dp_26_rank_52_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.06217322964221239, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06217322964221239, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.35, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06217322964221239, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up of a clean-shaven man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a loose, saffron-colored robe made of rough fabric?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by cool deep shadows with a single beam of golden sunlight filtering through a tall narrow window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man's face show weathered lines and skin texture highlighted by the sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit a subtle handheld tremor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07998794317245483 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5799880027770996 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07998794317245483, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07998794317245483, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0706656277179718, + 0.05294027552008629, + 0.07246554642915726, + 0.0880962684750557, + 0.1699814647436142, + 0.08335518091917038, + 0.13525140285491943, + 0.12499088793992996, + 0.1491127908229828, + 0.053140588104724884 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07998794317245483 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up of a clean-shaven man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a loose, saffron-colored robe made of rough fabric?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by cool deep shadows with a single beam of golden sunlight filtering through a tall narrow window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man's face show weathered lines and skin texture highlighted by the sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit a subtle handheld tremor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029832802712917328 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298328399658203 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029832802712917328, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029832802712917328, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11057251691818237, + 0.049363188445568085, + 0.051047880202531815, + 0.08461851626634598, + 0.10189223289489746, + 0.055263910442590714, + 0.11445705592632294, + 0.2596614956855774, + 0.1255245804786682, + 0.04759861156344414 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029832802712917328 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up of a clean-shaven man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a loose, saffron-colored robe made of rough fabric?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by cool deep shadows with a single beam of golden sunlight filtering through a tall narrow window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man's face show weathered lines and skin texture highlighted by the sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit a subtle handheld tremor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008643831126391888 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758643627166748 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008643831126391888, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008643831126391888, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2379923164844513, + 0.17335793375968933, + 0.12836183607578278, + 0.18197813630104065, + 0.06941211968660355, + 0.04729275405406952, + 0.031178876757621765, + 0.04681339114904404, + 0.06153985485434532, + 0.02207273617386818 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008643831126391888 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up of a clean-shaven man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a loose, saffron-colored robe made of rough fabric?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by cool deep shadows with a single beam of golden sunlight filtering through a tall narrow window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man's face show weathered lines and skin texture highlighted by the sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit a subtle handheld tremor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012544183060526848 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.38754415512085 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012544183060526848, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012544183060526848, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10492230206727982, + 0.06094501167535782, + 0.09522884339094162, + 0.13155581057071686, + 0.14500808715820312, + 0.16216027736663818, + 0.06559165567159653, + 0.1070966050028801, + 0.07881097495555878, + 0.04868039861321449 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012544183060526848 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up of a clean-shaven man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a loose, saffron-colored robe made of rough fabric?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by cool deep shadows with a single beam of golden sunlight filtering through a tall narrow window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man's face show weathered lines and skin texture highlighted by the sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit a subtle handheld tremor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17985738813877106 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8048573732376099 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17985738813877106, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17985738813877106, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22226490080356598, + 0.0784984678030014, + 0.06458232551813126, + 0.1551056206226349, + 0.14982439577579498, + 0.10328809171915054, + 0.055388618260622025, + 0.06690426170825958, + 0.05413961783051491, + 0.050003696233034134 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17985738813877106 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "medium close-up shot from a slightly high angle depicts the scene, the camera exhibiting a subtle handheld tremor that lends it a raw, intimate feel. In the center of the frame, a clean-shaven man awakens from a deep slumber on a simple footrest. He wears a loose, saffron-colored robe made of a rough, simple fabric. The austere room is cast in cool, deep shadows, a stark contrast to a brilliant ray of golden morning sunlight filtering through a tall, narrow window. This beam, imbued with dancing dust, falls directly upon his face, highlighting the weathered lines around his eyes and the texture of his skin. Stimulated by the light, his eyelids begin to twitch subtly, then open in a slow, hesitant motion. His pupils, initially unfocused, gradually constrict as they adjust to the brightness, his expression like a calm canvas returning to consciousness. The atmosphere is one of profound tranquility and concentration, the gentle awakening juxtaposed with the camera's slight instability creating a powerful and intimate visual narrative.", + "seed": 30485, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_13/index_4351_seed_30485_dp_27_rank_54_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.09617600655183196, + "vlm_logprob": -0.09617600655183196, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.325000011920929, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.09617600655183196, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up of a clean-shaven man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a loose, saffron-colored robe made of rough fabric?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by cool deep shadows with a single beam of golden sunlight filtering through a tall narrow window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man's face show weathered lines and skin texture highlighted by the sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit a subtle handheld tremor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.35150235891342163 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2265024185180664 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.35150235891342163, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.8750000596046448, + "token_credit_reward": -0.35150235891342163, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10992942005395889, + 0.05065476521849632, + 0.04583575949072838, + 0.036763470619916916, + 0.043909791857004166, + 0.06395468860864639, + 0.05855395644903183, + 0.05484571307897568, + 0.29381263256073, + 0.24173973500728607 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.35150235891342163 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up of a clean-shaven man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a loose, saffron-colored robe made of rough fabric?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by cool deep shadows with a single beam of golden sunlight filtering through a tall narrow window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man's face show weathered lines and skin texture highlighted by the sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit a subtle handheld tremor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01110091432929039 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511100769042969 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01110091432929039, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01110091432929039, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0679640918970108, + 0.07063177973031998, + 0.06731124967336655, + 0.08132763206958771, + 0.0785994678735733, + 0.061940453946590424, + 0.10057678073644638, + 0.07067181915044785, + 0.2879839837551117, + 0.11299275606870651 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01110091432929039 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up of a clean-shaven man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a loose, saffron-colored robe made of rough fabric?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by cool deep shadows with a single beam of golden sunlight filtering through a tall narrow window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man's face show weathered lines and skin texture highlighted by the sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit a subtle handheld tremor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005954384338110685 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130954265594482 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005954384338110685, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005954384338110685, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11679500341415405, + 0.07070471346378326, + 0.036383096128702164, + 0.044289715588092804, + 0.04686708003282547, + 0.07514765858650208, + 0.09171555191278458, + 0.1237512156367302, + 0.17150866985321045, + 0.22283722460269928 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005954384338110685 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up of a clean-shaven man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a loose, saffron-colored robe made of rough fabric?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by cool deep shadows with a single beam of golden sunlight filtering through a tall narrow window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man's face show weathered lines and skin texture highlighted by the sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit a subtle handheld tremor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023308105766773224 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773308038711548 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023308105766773224, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023308105766773224, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20804595947265625, + 0.06316341459751129, + 0.02497495338320732, + 0.030903039500117302, + 0.056917861104011536, + 0.07069799304008484, + 0.10831369459629059, + 0.03187417984008789, + 0.24849848449230194, + 0.15661047399044037 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023308105766773224 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up of a clean-shaven man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a loose, saffron-colored robe made of rough fabric?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by cool deep shadows with a single beam of golden sunlight filtering through a tall narrow window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man's face show weathered lines and skin texture highlighted by the sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit a subtle handheld tremor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08901426941156387 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4640142917633057 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08901426941156387, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08901426941156387, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22890593111515045, + 0.03878752142190933, + 0.047570765018463135, + 0.07675617933273315, + 0.04937640205025673, + 0.10407331585884094, + 0.12489347159862518, + 0.04556348919868469, + 0.1770186722278595, + 0.10705431550741196 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08901426941156387 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "medium close-up shot from a slightly high angle depicts the scene, the camera exhibiting a subtle handheld tremor that lends it a raw, intimate feel. In the center of the frame, a clean-shaven man awakens from a deep slumber on a simple footrest. He wears a loose, saffron-colored robe made of a rough, simple fabric. The austere room is cast in cool, deep shadows, a stark contrast to a brilliant ray of golden morning sunlight filtering through a tall, narrow window. This beam, imbued with dancing dust, falls directly upon his face, highlighting the weathered lines around his eyes and the texture of his skin. Stimulated by the light, his eyelids begin to twitch subtly, then open in a slow, hesitant motion. His pupils, initially unfocused, gradually constrict as they adjust to the brightness, his expression like a calm canvas returning to consciousness. The atmosphere is one of profound tranquility and concentration, the gentle awakening juxtaposed with the camera's slight instability creating a powerful and intimate visual narrative.", + "seed": 30486, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_13/index_4351_seed_30486_dp_27_rank_54_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.13606461137533188, + "vlm_logprob": -0.13606461137533188, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.1, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.13606461137533188, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up of a clean-shaven man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a loose, saffron-colored robe made of rough fabric?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by cool deep shadows with a single beam of golden sunlight filtering through a tall narrow window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man's face show weathered lines and skin texture highlighted by the sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit a subtle handheld tremor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.47925716638565063 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9792571663856506 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.47925716638565063, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.47925716638565063, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1626022309064865, + 0.11535391211509705, + 0.08846239745616913, + 0.08048251271247864, + 0.11285924166440964, + 0.14682622253894806, + 0.10861953347921371, + 0.08129557967185974, + 0.05775919929146767, + 0.04573917016386986 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.47925716638565063 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up of a clean-shaven man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a loose, saffron-colored robe made of rough fabric?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by cool deep shadows with a single beam of golden sunlight filtering through a tall narrow window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man's face show weathered lines and skin texture highlighted by the sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit a subtle handheld tremor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.043101079761981964 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1681010723114014 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.043101079761981964, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.043101079761981964, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4240771234035492, + 0.08876901119947433, + 0.07893460243940353, + 0.04553573206067085, + 0.05084206908941269, + 0.13008235394954681, + 0.049318406730890274, + 0.06628277152776718, + 0.03839782252907753, + 0.027760099619627 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.043101079761981964 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up of a clean-shaven man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a loose, saffron-colored robe made of rough fabric?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by cool deep shadows with a single beam of golden sunlight filtering through a tall narrow window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man's face show weathered lines and skin texture highlighted by the sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit a subtle handheld tremor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004098112694919109 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504097938537598 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004098112694919109, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004098112694919109, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.26473501324653625, + 0.12205154448747635, + 0.13636688888072968, + 0.14398349821567535, + 0.08214037120342255, + 0.04396190866827965, + 0.07470368593931198, + 0.06421947479248047, + 0.02667359821498394, + 0.041164036840200424 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004098112694919109 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up of a clean-shaven man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a loose, saffron-colored robe made of rough fabric?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by cool deep shadows with a single beam of golden sunlight filtering through a tall narrow window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man's face show weathered lines and skin texture highlighted by the sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit a subtle handheld tremor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011085470207035542 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511085510253906 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011085470207035542, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011085470207035542, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2825133204460144, + 0.22745376825332642, + 0.07479718327522278, + 0.05371266230940819, + 0.10037829726934433, + 0.04290146380662918, + 0.08395346254110336, + 0.06215557083487511, + 0.028577428311109543, + 0.043556876480579376 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011085470207035542 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up of a clean-shaven man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a loose, saffron-colored robe made of rough fabric?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by cool deep shadows with a single beam of golden sunlight filtering through a tall narrow window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man's face show weathered lines and skin texture highlighted by the sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit a subtle handheld tremor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14278122782707214 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0177812576293945 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14278122782707214, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14278122782707214, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.33101680874824524, + 0.15298815071582794, + 0.05324126034975052, + 0.10458968579769135, + 0.11024375259876251, + 0.08446165919303894, + 0.035020098090171814, + 0.030830340459942818, + 0.028697863221168518, + 0.06891041249036789 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14278122782707214 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_14/index_tensor([6323, 6323])_group_14_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_14/index_tensor([6323, 6323])_group_14_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..cc84f929ca655327c3c95b84a89a9c9ddbe63056 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_14/index_tensor([6323, 6323])_group_14_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "In a documentary-style, a medium shot with a slight handheld shakiness captures a determined young man standing at the edge of a weathered, ancient city wall, his toes practically dangling. He wears a slightly oversized military green training uniform, the fabric trembling slightly in the cold wind. A professional black safety harness tightly binds him, connecting to a thick bungee cord fixed behind him. The overcast sky casts an even, cool, diffuse light, highlighting the mottled moss and weathered marks on the wall's masonry, and also sharpening the boy's resolute facial features. Without hesitation, he leaned his body forward, slightly opened his arms to maintain his initial balance, and then decisively pushed off the edge of the wall. His body fell vertically towards the mist-shrouded deep valley below like an arrow. The camera tilted downward quickly, following his falling figure closely, capturing the moment when his uniform was blown close to his body by the strong wind. The whole picture was full of extreme concentration, courage and an unswerving sense of ritual, presenting an unpretentious, heart-pounding documentary aesthetic.", + "seed": 23810, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_14/index_6323_seed_23810_dp_28_rank_56_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.056993645057082175, + "vlm_logprob": -0.056993645057082175, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.4, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.056993645057082175, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young man wearing a military green training uniform?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man standing at the edge of a weathered, ancient city wall with his toes dangling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a black safety harness connected to a thick bungee cord fixed behind him?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man push off the wall and fall vertically towards a mist-shrouded valley?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt downward quickly to follow the falling figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2563418447971344 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.506341814994812 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2563418447971344, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2563418447971344, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2553572952747345, + 0.10353899002075195, + 0.10131407529115677, + 0.04305225983262062, + 0.07376079261302948, + 0.06914454698562622, + 0.0600731186568737, + 0.05713445320725441, + 0.082248255610466, + 0.15437620878219604 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2563418447971344 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young man wearing a military green training uniform?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man standing at the edge of a weathered, ancient city wall with his toes dangling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a black safety harness connected to a thick bungee cord fixed behind him?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man push off the wall and fall vertically towards a mist-shrouded valley?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt downward quickly to follow the falling figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014221743680536747 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264221668243408 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014221743680536747, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014221743680536747, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06203233823180199, + 0.07461413741111755, + 0.0742880254983902, + 0.05425639450550079, + 0.08416765928268433, + 0.11311449110507965, + 0.1278304159641266, + 0.06715696305036545, + 0.13939234614372253, + 0.20314723253250122 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014221743680536747 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young man wearing a military green training uniform?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man standing at the edge of a weathered, ancient city wall with his toes dangling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a black safety harness connected to a thick bungee cord fixed behind him?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man push off the wall and fall vertically towards a mist-shrouded valley?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt downward quickly to follow the falling figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006746490485966206 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006746292114258 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006746490485966206, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006746490485966206, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10118146985769272, + 0.08834822475910187, + 0.044102929532527924, + 0.04972633346915245, + 0.10437926650047302, + 0.2145940214395523, + 0.11583530157804489, + 0.029283074662089348, + 0.1671951860189438, + 0.08535417169332504 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006746490485966206 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young man wearing a military green training uniform?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man standing at the edge of a weathered, ancient city wall with his toes dangling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a black safety harness connected to a thick bungee cord fixed behind him?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man push off the wall and fall vertically towards a mist-shrouded valley?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt downward quickly to follow the falling figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0017141900025308132 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.37671422958374 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0017141900025308132, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0017141900025308132, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15546931326389313, + 0.08134733885526657, + 0.0528743602335453, + 0.048725567758083344, + 0.07786882668733597, + 0.12456895411014557, + 0.12315893918275833, + 0.06583638489246368, + 0.1918770968914032, + 0.07827326655387878 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0017141900025308132 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young man wearing a military green training uniform?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man standing at the edge of a weathered, ancient city wall with his toes dangling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a black safety harness connected to a thick bungee cord fixed behind him?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man push off the wall and fall vertically towards a mist-shrouded valley?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt downward quickly to follow the falling figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005943956319242716 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130943775177002 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005943956319242716, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005943956319242716, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07706883549690247, + 0.095179982483387, + 0.07728446274995804, + 0.07235432416200638, + 0.07874873280525208, + 0.09560228139162064, + 0.08040322363376617, + 0.1555568277835846, + 0.1603231579065323, + 0.10747817903757095 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005943956319242716 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a documentary-style, a medium shot with a slight handheld shakiness captures a determined young man standing at the edge of a weathered, ancient city wall, his toes practically dangling. He wears a slightly oversized military green training uniform, the fabric trembling slightly in the cold wind. A professional black safety harness tightly binds him, connecting to a thick bungee cord fixed behind him. The overcast sky casts an even, cool, diffuse light, highlighting the mottled moss and weathered marks on the wall's masonry, and also sharpening the boy's resolute facial features. Without hesitation, he leaned his body forward, slightly opened his arms to maintain his initial balance, and then decisively pushed off the edge of the wall. His body fell vertically towards the mist-shrouded deep valley below like an arrow. The camera tilted downward quickly, following his falling figure closely, capturing the moment when his uniform was blown close to his body by the strong wind. The whole picture was full of extreme concentration, courage and an unswerving sense of ritual, presenting an unpretentious, heart-pounding documentary aesthetic.", + "seed": 23811, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_14/index_6323_seed_23811_dp_28_rank_56_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.10446542957797647, + "vlm_logprob": -0.10446542957797647, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.875, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.10446542957797647, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young man wearing a military green training uniform?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man standing at the edge of a weathered, ancient city wall with his toes dangling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a black safety harness connected to a thick bungee cord fixed behind him?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man push off the wall and fall vertically towards a mist-shrouded valley?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt downward quickly to follow the falling figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4786328971385956 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.978632926940918 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.4786328971385956, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.4786328971385956, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05712142214179039, + 0.032250095158815384, + 0.04718188941478729, + 0.050754498690366745, + 0.036940060555934906, + 0.039884719997644424, + 0.06933306902647018, + 0.04181104525923729, + 0.5364905595779419, + 0.08823262155056 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.4786328971385956 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young man wearing a military green training uniform?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man standing at the edge of a weathered, ancient city wall with his toes dangling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a black safety harness connected to a thick bungee cord fixed behind him?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man push off the wall and fall vertically towards a mist-shrouded valley?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt downward quickly to follow the falling figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01257891021668911 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387578964233398 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01257891021668911, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01257891021668911, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09215715527534485, + 0.05661061778664589, + 0.09067977964878082, + 0.04986114427447319, + 0.05926857143640518, + 0.11402935534715652, + 0.25528445839881897, + 0.06194636970758438, + 0.12276989221572876, + 0.09739261865615845 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01257891021668911 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young man wearing a military green training uniform?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man standing at the edge of a weathered, ancient city wall with his toes dangling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a black safety harness connected to a thick bungee cord fixed behind him?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man push off the wall and fall vertically towards a mist-shrouded valley?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt downward quickly to follow the falling figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016091477125883102 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141091346740723 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016091477125883102, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016091477125883102, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08202415704727173, + 0.05065353587269783, + 0.03746432438492775, + 0.06380212306976318, + 0.03830306604504585, + 0.043086856603622437, + 0.0751698836684227, + 0.055042482912540436, + 0.4809762239456177, + 0.0734773725271225 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016091477125883102 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young man wearing a military green training uniform?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man standing at the edge of a weathered, ancient city wall with his toes dangling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a black safety harness connected to a thick bungee cord fixed behind him?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man push off the wall and fall vertically towards a mist-shrouded valley?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt downward quickly to follow the falling figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0024900403805077076 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002490043640137 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0024900403805077076, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0024900403805077076, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07920467108488083, + 0.055790722370147705, + 0.04476218298077583, + 0.04028281942009926, + 0.02922067977488041, + 0.0856240764260292, + 0.05422435328364372, + 0.04374535381793976, + 0.422261506319046, + 0.1448836773633957 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0024900403805077076 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young man wearing a military green training uniform?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man standing at the edge of a weathered, ancient city wall with his toes dangling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a black safety harness connected to a thick bungee cord fixed behind him?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man push off the wall and fall vertically towards a mist-shrouded valley?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt downward quickly to follow the falling figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012533823028206825 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387533664703369 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012533823028206825, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012533823028206825, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.030672090128064156, + 0.020793145522475243, + 0.051369309425354004, + 0.027916697785258293, + 0.030326420441269875, + 0.05238700658082962, + 0.10185830295085907, + 0.05681776627898216, + 0.32336023449897766, + 0.3044990301132202 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012533823028206825 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a documentary-style, a medium shot with a slight handheld shakiness captures a determined young man standing at the edge of a weathered, ancient city wall, his toes practically dangling. He wears a slightly oversized military green training uniform, the fabric trembling slightly in the cold wind. A professional black safety harness tightly binds him, connecting to a thick bungee cord fixed behind him. The overcast sky casts an even, cool, diffuse light, highlighting the mottled moss and weathered marks on the wall's masonry, and also sharpening the boy's resolute facial features. Without hesitation, he leaned his body forward, slightly opened his arms to maintain his initial balance, and then decisively pushed off the edge of the wall. His body fell vertically towards the mist-shrouded deep valley below like an arrow. The camera tilted downward quickly, following his falling figure closely, capturing the moment when his uniform was blown close to his body by the strong wind. The whole picture was full of extreme concentration, courage and an unswerving sense of ritual, presenting an unpretentious, heart-pounding documentary aesthetic.", + "seed": 23812, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_14/index_6323_seed_23812_dp_29_rank_58_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.07700119423680007, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07700119423680007, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.575, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07700119423680007, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young man wearing a military green training uniform?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man standing at the edge of a weathered, ancient city wall with his toes dangling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a black safety harness connected to a thick bungee cord fixed behind him?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man push off the wall and fall vertically towards a mist-shrouded valley?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt downward quickly to follow the falling figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2871883511543274 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4121882915496826 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2871883511543274, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2871883511543274, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.32997050881385803, + 0.054777514189481735, + 0.03511710464954376, + 0.04136890545487404, + 0.03027726709842682, + 0.08573117107152939, + 0.040989138185977936, + 0.11798365414142609, + 0.08424986153841019, + 0.17953482270240784 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2871883511543274 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young man wearing a military green training uniform?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man standing at the edge of a weathered, ancient city wall with his toes dangling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a black safety harness connected to a thick bungee cord fixed behind him?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man push off the wall and fall vertically towards a mist-shrouded valley?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt downward quickly to follow the falling figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.055007439106702805 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9300074577331543 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.055007439106702805, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.055007439106702805, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14303407073020935, + 0.05634452775120735, + 0.047375816851854324, + 0.04923637956380844, + 0.019998295232653618, + 0.14288552105426788, + 0.24931515753269196, + 0.08601631969213486, + 0.10393563657999039, + 0.10185832530260086 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.055007439106702805 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young man wearing a military green training uniform?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man standing at the edge of a weathered, ancient city wall with his toes dangling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a black safety harness connected to a thick bungee cord fixed behind him?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man push off the wall and fall vertically towards a mist-shrouded valley?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt downward quickly to follow the falling figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029834305867552757 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529834270477295 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029834305867552757, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029834305867552757, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18442195653915405, + 0.045566048473119736, + 0.0635211393237114, + 0.062247585505247116, + 0.028321905061602592, + 0.05906885862350464, + 0.13327641785144806, + 0.09740074723958969, + 0.08308516442775726, + 0.24309015274047852 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029834305867552757 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young man wearing a military green training uniform?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man standing at the edge of a weathered, ancient city wall with his toes dangling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a black safety harness connected to a thick bungee cord fixed behind him?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man push off the wall and fall vertically towards a mist-shrouded valley?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt downward quickly to follow the falling figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003194113029167056 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753194332122803 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003194113029167056, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003194113029167056, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0975649505853653, + 0.051778025925159454, + 0.05093710869550705, + 0.08254355192184448, + 0.05455734580755234, + 0.03181206434965134, + 0.059038907289505005, + 0.17292805016040802, + 0.14149217307567596, + 0.2573477625846863 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003194113029167056 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young man wearing a military green training uniform?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man standing at the edge of a weathered, ancient city wall with his toes dangling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a black safety harness connected to a thick bungee cord fixed behind him?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man push off the wall and fall vertically towards a mist-shrouded valley?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt downward quickly to follow the falling figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009781762026250362 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634781837463379 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009781762026250362, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009781762026250362, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.039392728358507156, + 0.019098056480288506, + 0.01372740138322115, + 0.019866835325956345, + 0.01117386482656002, + 0.020755097270011902, + 0.09894628077745438, + 0.08708973973989487, + 0.32398200035095215, + 0.3659680485725403 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009781762026250362 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a documentary-style, a medium shot with a slight handheld shakiness captures a determined young man standing at the edge of a weathered, ancient city wall, his toes practically dangling. He wears a slightly oversized military green training uniform, the fabric trembling slightly in the cold wind. A professional black safety harness tightly binds him, connecting to a thick bungee cord fixed behind him. The overcast sky casts an even, cool, diffuse light, highlighting the mottled moss and weathered marks on the wall's masonry, and also sharpening the boy's resolute facial features. Without hesitation, he leaned his body forward, slightly opened his arms to maintain his initial balance, and then decisively pushed off the edge of the wall. His body fell vertically towards the mist-shrouded deep valley below like an arrow. The camera tilted downward quickly, following his falling figure closely, capturing the moment when his uniform was blown close to his body by the strong wind. The whole picture was full of extreme concentration, courage and an unswerving sense of ritual, presenting an unpretentious, heart-pounding documentary aesthetic.", + "seed": 23813, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_14/index_6323_seed_23813_dp_29_rank_58_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.1901591108646244, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1901591108646244, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.8, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1901591108646244, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young man wearing a military green training uniform?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man standing at the edge of a weathered, ancient city wall with his toes dangling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a black safety harness connected to a thick bungee cord fixed behind him?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man push off the wall and fall vertically towards a mist-shrouded valley?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt downward quickly to follow the falling figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8998494744300842 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5248494744300842 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.8998494744300842, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.8998494744300842, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05848231539130211, + 0.02785336598753929, + 0.030051028355956078, + 0.2800094187259674, + 0.04134804382920265, + 0.04556390643119812, + 0.08929292857646942, + 0.1477443128824234, + 0.13869218528270721, + 0.14096248149871826 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.8998494744300842 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young man wearing a military green training uniform?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man standing at the edge of a weathered, ancient city wall with his toes dangling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a black safety harness connected to a thick bungee cord fixed behind him?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man push off the wall and fall vertically towards a mist-shrouded valley?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt downward quickly to follow the falling figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007647759281098843 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.88264799118042 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007647759281098843, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007647759281098843, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10138404369354248, + 0.14891886711120605, + 0.04798131436109543, + 0.055261895060539246, + 0.03628505766391754, + 0.07981599122285843, + 0.16242830455303192, + 0.14091093838214874, + 0.10093475878238678, + 0.12607888877391815 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007647759281098843 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young man wearing a military green training uniform?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man standing at the edge of a weathered, ancient city wall with his toes dangling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a black safety harness connected to a thick bungee cord fixed behind him?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man push off the wall and fall vertically towards a mist-shrouded valley?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt downward quickly to follow the falling figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03373359888792038 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408733606338501 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03373359888792038, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03373359888792038, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11203336715698242, + 0.0658499151468277, + 0.034544315189123154, + 0.12264876067638397, + 0.07497811317443848, + 0.04282278195023537, + 0.08064670860767365, + 0.12013288587331772, + 0.21550126373767853, + 0.13084183633327484 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03373359888792038 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young man wearing a military green training uniform?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man standing at the edge of a weathered, ancient city wall with his toes dangling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a black safety harness connected to a thick bungee cord fixed behind him?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man push off the wall and fall vertically towards a mist-shrouded valley?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt downward quickly to follow the falling figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0019392033573240042 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.251939296722412 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0019392033573240042, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0019392033573240042, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11086617410182953, + 0.04426481947302818, + 0.021358583122491837, + 0.26550590991973877, + 0.02170567773282528, + 0.03365258872509003, + 0.08078527450561523, + 0.16708166897296906, + 0.1602701097726822, + 0.09450912475585938 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0019392033573240042 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young man wearing a military green training uniform?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man standing at the edge of a weathered, ancient city wall with his toes dangling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a black safety harness connected to a thick bungee cord fixed behind him?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man push off the wall and fall vertically towards a mist-shrouded valley?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt downward quickly to follow the falling figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00762551836669445 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882625579833984 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00762551836669445, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00762551836669445, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.058537837117910385, + 0.027733400464057922, + 0.027315696701407433, + 0.040917836129665375, + 0.04661327973008156, + 0.05247878655791283, + 0.11380178481340408, + 0.16098202764987946, + 0.36910581588745117, + 0.1025136262178421 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00762551836669445 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_15/index_tensor([4608, 4608])_group_15_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_15/index_tensor([4608, 4608])_group_15_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..8fc4b8d5aa269f322439a0876bc991544a35861c --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_15/index_tensor([4608, 4608])_group_15_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "Captured from a first-person perspective, the extreme macro shot, shot in a breathtaking macro photography style, begins with the camera slowly and deliberately tilting downwards towards a shattered, circular black makeup application. A single, bright, focused spotlight, shining from an overhead angle, illuminates the scene, creating sharp, dramatic highlights and deep, velvety shadows. The pressed, shimmering highlighter within the compact—a pale champagne gold with iridescent pink and lavender shades—shatters into a chaotic mosaic of large chunks and fine dust. As the compact is tilted further, a mesmerizing slow-motion avalanche of iridescent powder begins to splash onto the dark, matte, subtly textured slate surface below. Each individual micro-glitter particle, crystal-clear, tumbles and bounces in a cascading light show; some particles catch the focused light and shimmer with an intense, jewel-like glow, while others reveal a subtle pearlescent sheen as they settle. The incredibly shallow depth of field blurs the background into pure black, creating a luxurious and hypnotic atmosphere focused entirely on the beautiful, destructive dance of light and texture.", + "seed": 1714, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_15/index_4608_seed_1714_dp_30_rank_60_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.020140216592699288, + "vlm_logprob": -0.020140216592699288, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.25, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.020140216592699288, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective with an extreme macro view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and deliberately tilt downwards towards a shattered circular black makeup compact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the compact a pale champagne gold color with iridescent pink and lavender shades that shatters into large chunks and fine dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the powder splash onto a dark matte subtly textured slate surface in slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred into pure black due to an incredibly shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.022285155951976776 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.397284984588623 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.022285155951976776, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.022285155951976776, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2132093459367752, + 0.09543047100305557, + 0.05926071107387543, + 0.15222814679145813, + 0.06856629997491837, + 0.0488513745367527, + 0.10728824883699417, + 0.07536374032497406, + 0.05884776636958122, + 0.12095385789871216 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.022285155951976776 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective with an extreme macro view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and deliberately tilt downwards towards a shattered circular black makeup compact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the compact a pale champagne gold color with iridescent pink and lavender shades that shatters into large chunks and fine dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the powder splash onto a dark matte subtly textured slate surface in slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred into pure black due to an incredibly shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02638915553689003 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513891220092773 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02638915553689003, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02638915553689003, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24648723006248474, + 0.10574501752853394, + 0.12568780779838562, + 0.07753214985132217, + 0.11539158225059509, + 0.038753803819417953, + 0.05573543161153793, + 0.03467075526714325, + 0.13963177800178528, + 0.06036445125937462 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02638915553689003 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective with an extreme macro view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and deliberately tilt downwards towards a shattered circular black makeup compact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the compact a pale champagne gold color with iridescent pink and lavender shades that shatters into large chunks and fine dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the powder splash onto a dark matte subtly textured slate surface in slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred into pure black due to an incredibly shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00865045003592968 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758650302886963 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00865045003592968, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00865045003592968, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11904902011156082, + 0.13817285001277924, + 0.09411216527223587, + 0.2038406878709793, + 0.11931415647268295, + 0.07414411753416061, + 0.05822064355015755, + 0.09531640261411667, + 0.055762287229299545, + 0.042067695409059525 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00865045003592968 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective with an extreme macro view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and deliberately tilt downwards towards a shattered circular black makeup compact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the compact a pale champagne gold color with iridescent pink and lavender shades that shatters into large chunks and fine dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the powder splash onto a dark matte subtly textured slate surface in slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred into pure black due to an incredibly shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03811956197023392 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881195545196533 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03811956197023392, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03811956197023392, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08020907640457153, + 0.19740590453147888, + 0.02523096278309822, + 0.1032986044883728, + 0.46880635619163513, + 0.03970837593078613, + 0.029596760869026184, + 0.035801734775304794, + 0.007949605584144592, + 0.011992603540420532 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03811956197023392 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective with an extreme macro view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and deliberately tilt downwards towards a shattered circular black makeup compact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the compact a pale champagne gold color with iridescent pink and lavender shades that shatters into large chunks and fine dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the powder splash onto a dark matte subtly textured slate surface in slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred into pure black due to an incredibly shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0052567594684660435 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255256652832031 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0052567594684660435, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0052567594684660435, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2756037712097168, + 0.1469114124774933, + 0.05630818381905556, + 0.13789892196655273, + 0.11157205700874329, + 0.010361057706177235, + 0.08092548698186874, + 0.09769487380981445, + 0.026517760008573532, + 0.05620645731687546 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0052567594684660435 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "Captured from a first-person perspective, the extreme macro shot, shot in a breathtaking macro photography style, begins with the camera slowly and deliberately tilting downwards towards a shattered, circular black makeup application. A single, bright, focused spotlight, shining from an overhead angle, illuminates the scene, creating sharp, dramatic highlights and deep, velvety shadows. The pressed, shimmering highlighter within the compact—a pale champagne gold with iridescent pink and lavender shades—shatters into a chaotic mosaic of large chunks and fine dust. As the compact is tilted further, a mesmerizing slow-motion avalanche of iridescent powder begins to splash onto the dark, matte, subtly textured slate surface below. Each individual micro-glitter particle, crystal-clear, tumbles and bounces in a cascading light show; some particles catch the focused light and shimmer with an intense, jewel-like glow, while others reveal a subtle pearlescent sheen as they settle. The incredibly shallow depth of field blurs the background into pure black, creating a luxurious and hypnotic atmosphere focused entirely on the beautiful, destructive dance of light and texture.", + "seed": 1715, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_15/index_4608_seed_1715_dp_30_rank_60_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.026062522456049918, + "vlm_logprob": -0.026062522456049918, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.2, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.026062522456049918, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective with an extreme macro view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and deliberately tilt downwards towards a shattered circular black makeup compact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the compact a pale champagne gold color with iridescent pink and lavender shades that shatters into large chunks and fine dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the powder splash onto a dark matte subtly textured slate surface in slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred into pure black due to an incredibly shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08541427552700043 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.710414171218872 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08541427552700043, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08541427552700043, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1003551334142685, + 0.3225390613079071, + 0.09863543510437012, + 0.08465603739023209, + 0.04046483710408211, + 0.03215974569320679, + 0.04536304622888565, + 0.16900980472564697, + 0.03175324574112892, + 0.07506368309259415 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08541427552700043 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective with an extreme macro view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and deliberately tilt downwards towards a shattered circular black makeup compact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the compact a pale champagne gold color with iridescent pink and lavender shades that shatters into large chunks and fine dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the powder splash onto a dark matte subtly textured slate surface in slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred into pure black due to an incredibly shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01612197607755661 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141121864318848 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01612197607755661, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01612197607755661, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08055693656206131, + 0.25328338146209717, + 0.09186885505914688, + 0.10735467076301575, + 0.07225117087364197, + 0.04055188596248627, + 0.10403958708047867, + 0.13380925357341766, + 0.0344867967069149, + 0.08179739117622375 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 7, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01612197607755661 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective with an extreme macro view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and deliberately tilt downwards towards a shattered circular black makeup compact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the compact a pale champagne gold color with iridescent pink and lavender shades that shatters into large chunks and fine dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the powder splash onto a dark matte subtly textured slate surface in slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred into pure black due to an incredibly shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01607939414680004 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141079425811768 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01607939414680004, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01607939414680004, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19201704859733582, + 0.2833274304866791, + 0.0326436348259449, + 0.03815353661775589, + 0.04150265455245972, + 0.059433478862047195, + 0.03912653774023056, + 0.06751301884651184, + 0.024932095780968666, + 0.22135059535503387 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01607939414680004 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective with an extreme macro view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and deliberately tilt downwards towards a shattered circular black makeup compact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the compact a pale champagne gold color with iridescent pink and lavender shades that shatters into large chunks and fine dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the powder splash onto a dark matte subtly textured slate surface in slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred into pure black due to an incredibly shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00674400432035327 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006743907928467 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00674400432035327, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00674400432035327, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10084763169288635, + 0.09366191178560257, + 0.10159040987491608, + 0.14961563050746918, + 0.035558052361011505, + 0.045297130942344666, + 0.05156826972961426, + 0.030744876712560654, + 0.03744099661707878, + 0.35367509722709656 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00674400432035327 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective with an extreme macro view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and deliberately tilt downwards towards a shattered circular black makeup compact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the compact a pale champagne gold color with iridescent pink and lavender shades that shatters into large chunks and fine dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the powder splash onto a dark matte subtly textured slate surface in slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred into pure black due to an incredibly shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0059529622085392475 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130952835083008 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0059529622085392475, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0059529622085392475, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1861877292394638, + 0.1339041143655777, + 0.07566700130701065, + 0.12188275158405304, + 0.1256672441959381, + 0.05723307281732559, + 0.03384675458073616, + 0.03330835700035095, + 0.05100305378437042, + 0.18129993975162506 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0059529622085392475 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "Captured from a first-person perspective, the extreme macro shot, shot in a breathtaking macro photography style, begins with the camera slowly and deliberately tilting downwards towards a shattered, circular black makeup application. A single, bright, focused spotlight, shining from an overhead angle, illuminates the scene, creating sharp, dramatic highlights and deep, velvety shadows. The pressed, shimmering highlighter within the compact—a pale champagne gold with iridescent pink and lavender shades—shatters into a chaotic mosaic of large chunks and fine dust. As the compact is tilted further, a mesmerizing slow-motion avalanche of iridescent powder begins to splash onto the dark, matte, subtly textured slate surface below. Each individual micro-glitter particle, crystal-clear, tumbles and bounces in a cascading light show; some particles catch the focused light and shimmer with an intense, jewel-like glow, while others reveal a subtle pearlescent sheen as they settle. The incredibly shallow depth of field blurs the background into pure black, creating a luxurious and hypnotic atmosphere focused entirely on the beautiful, destructive dance of light and texture.", + "seed": 1716, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_15/index_4608_seed_1716_dp_31_rank_62_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.01834937846288085, + "vlm_logprob": -0.01834937846288085, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.5, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.01834937846288085, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective with an extreme macro view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and deliberately tilt downwards towards a shattered circular black makeup compact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the compact a pale champagne gold color with iridescent pink and lavender shades that shatters into large chunks and fine dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the powder splash onto a dark matte subtly textured slate surface in slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred into pure black due to an incredibly shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04766051098704338 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4226605892181396 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04766051098704338, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04766051098704338, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22264261543750763, + 0.33322280645370483, + 0.09620500355958939, + 0.0882006511092186, + 0.051918838173151016, + 0.045628808438777924, + 0.03163417428731918, + 0.03210436552762985, + 0.0482841320335865, + 0.05015857145190239 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04766051098704338 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective with an extreme macro view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and deliberately tilt downwards towards a shattered circular black makeup compact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the compact a pale champagne gold color with iridescent pink and lavender shades that shatters into large chunks and fine dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the powder splash onto a dark matte subtly textured slate surface in slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred into pure black due to an incredibly shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026393450796604156 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651393413543701 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026393450796604156, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026393450796604156, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.29506349563598633, + 0.12234147638082504, + 0.13246871531009674, + 0.1266864389181137, + 0.14524438977241516, + 0.049946367740631104, + 0.021253522485494614, + 0.04074714705348015, + 0.031265988945961, + 0.03498243913054466 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026393450796604156 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective with an extreme macro view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and deliberately tilt downwards towards a shattered circular black makeup compact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the compact a pale champagne gold color with iridescent pink and lavender shades that shatters into large chunks and fine dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the powder splash onto a dark matte subtly textured slate surface in slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred into pure black due to an incredibly shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005956517532467842 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130956649780273 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005956517532467842, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005956517532467842, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17514680325984955, + 0.2472243756055832, + 0.10669483244419098, + 0.11807462573051453, + 0.06553592532873154, + 0.071670763194561, + 0.051629941910505295, + 0.057064589112997055, + 0.06851829588413239, + 0.03843993321061134 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005956517532467842 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective with an extreme macro view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and deliberately tilt downwards towards a shattered circular black makeup compact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the compact a pale champagne gold color with iridescent pink and lavender shades that shatters into large chunks and fine dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the powder splash onto a dark matte subtly textured slate surface in slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred into pure black due to an incredibly shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007636994123458862 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882637023925781 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007636994123458862, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007636994123458862, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24694103002548218, + 0.08654434978961945, + 0.04540242254734039, + 0.09925800561904907, + 0.04789896309375763, + 0.0937894806265831, + 0.10511934012174606, + 0.16296732425689697, + 0.06060206517577171, + 0.051477041095495224 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007636994123458862 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective with an extreme macro view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and deliberately tilt downwards towards a shattered circular black makeup compact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the compact a pale champagne gold color with iridescent pink and lavender shades that shatters into large chunks and fine dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the powder splash onto a dark matte subtly textured slate surface in slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred into pure black due to an incredibly shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0040994188748300076 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504099369049072 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0040994188748300076, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0040994188748300076, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.30783411860466003, + 0.12876807153224945, + 0.0653725415468216, + 0.24991734325885773, + 0.018029984086751938, + 0.023109758272767067, + 0.04316817224025726, + 0.04760463163256645, + 0.06002465635538101, + 0.056170765310525894 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0040994188748300076 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "Captured from a first-person perspective, the extreme macro shot, shot in a breathtaking macro photography style, begins with the camera slowly and deliberately tilting downwards towards a shattered, circular black makeup application. A single, bright, focused spotlight, shining from an overhead angle, illuminates the scene, creating sharp, dramatic highlights and deep, velvety shadows. The pressed, shimmering highlighter within the compact—a pale champagne gold with iridescent pink and lavender shades—shatters into a chaotic mosaic of large chunks and fine dust. As the compact is tilted further, a mesmerizing slow-motion avalanche of iridescent powder begins to splash onto the dark, matte, subtly textured slate surface below. Each individual micro-glitter particle, crystal-clear, tumbles and bounces in a cascading light show; some particles catch the focused light and shimmer with an intense, jewel-like glow, while others reveal a subtle pearlescent sheen as they settle. The incredibly shallow depth of field blurs the background into pure black, creating a luxurious and hypnotic atmosphere focused entirely on the beautiful, destructive dance of light and texture.", + "seed": 1717, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_15/index_4608_seed_1717_dp_31_rank_62_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.017175860796123744, + "vlm_logprob": -0.017175860796123744, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.675, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.017175860796123744, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective with an extreme macro view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and deliberately tilt downwards towards a shattered circular black makeup compact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the compact a pale champagne gold color with iridescent pink and lavender shades that shatters into large chunks and fine dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the powder splash onto a dark matte subtly textured slate surface in slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred into pure black due to an incredibly shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04364648461341858 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.9186465740203857 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04364648461341858, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04364648461341858, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.43720412254333496, + 0.04917597025632858, + 0.026466812938451767, + 0.04973728582262993, + 0.05429158732295036, + 0.04147043824195862, + 0.10609090328216553, + 0.08867154270410538, + 0.08587466180324554, + 0.06101668253540993 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04364648461341858 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective with an extreme macro view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and deliberately tilt downwards towards a shattered circular black makeup compact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the compact a pale champagne gold color with iridescent pink and lavender shades that shatters into large chunks and fine dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the powder splash onto a dark matte subtly textured slate surface in slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred into pure black due to an incredibly shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02639484405517578 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651394844055176 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02639484405517578, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02639484405517578, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22356931865215302, + 0.04125556722283363, + 0.15462718904018402, + 0.07846612483263016, + 0.09906043112277985, + 0.14224174618721008, + 0.029124721884727478, + 0.12068738043308258, + 0.036078259348869324, + 0.07488925009965897 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02639484405517578 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective with an extreme macro view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and deliberately tilt downwards towards a shattered circular black makeup compact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the compact a pale champagne gold color with iridescent pink and lavender shades that shatters into large chunks and fine dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the powder splash onto a dark matte subtly textured slate surface in slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred into pure black due to an incredibly shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004105473402887583 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504105567932129 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004105473402887583, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004105473402887583, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.40179508924484253, + 0.06844360381364822, + 0.03340612351894379, + 0.17707668244838715, + 0.04427839070558548, + 0.08814170956611633, + 0.034494806081056595, + 0.03796679899096489, + 0.042868297547101974, + 0.07152848690748215 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004105473402887583 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective with an extreme macro view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and deliberately tilt downwards towards a shattered circular black makeup compact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the compact a pale champagne gold color with iridescent pink and lavender shades that shatters into large chunks and fine dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the powder splash onto a dark matte subtly textured slate surface in slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred into pure black due to an incredibly shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007635101210325956 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882635116577148 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007635101210325956, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007635101210325956, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15477070212364197, + 0.17968964576721191, + 0.08186201751232147, + 0.16819682717323303, + 0.03616325557231903, + 0.15783174335956573, + 0.03359893709421158, + 0.09795078635215759, + 0.048340585082769394, + 0.04159544035792351 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007635101210325956 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective with an extreme macro view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and deliberately tilt downwards towards a shattered circular black makeup compact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the compact a pale champagne gold color with iridescent pink and lavender shades that shatters into large chunks and fine dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the powder splash onto a dark matte subtly textured slate surface in slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred into pure black due to an incredibly shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004097400698810816 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.5040974617004395 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004097400698810816, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004097400698810816, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.6545800566673279, + 0.0355842225253582, + 0.07190598547458649, + 0.07261662930250168, + 0.015615357086062431, + 0.023916756734251976, + 0.03400598093867302, + 0.05742880329489708, + 0.011549619026482105, + 0.022796520963311195 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004097400698810816 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_2/index_tensor([9603, 9603])_group_2_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_2/index_tensor([9603, 9603])_group_2_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..75898cc1362f8eacde11fb3e040fc76433087ac6 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_2/index_tensor([9603, 9603])_group_2_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "static, eye-level close-up, framed in a documentary style, captures a quiet moment in a modern office. A crisp, standard white sheet of paper lies flat against the dark, polished wood grain of a minimalist desk. The scene is illuminated primarily by cool, soft natural light from a large, out-of-focus window, creating subtle reflections on the desk's smooth surface. The action begins with an invisible draft of air causing the corner of the paper to subtly tremble. Then, the entire sheet is gently lifted and peeled from the desk in a slow, silent arc. It hovers for a moment, suspended just above the surface, before beginning to glide sideways, gliding smoothly and steadily across the polished wood. As the paper reaches the edge of the desk, it loses the support of the current and begins to drift downward. Its descent is an elegant, oscillating dance as it gently twists and turns, catching the ambient light before disappearing to the floor through the bottom of the frame, creating an atmosphere of serene and contemplative focused observation.", + "seed": 32187, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_2/index_9603_seed_32187_dp_4_rank_8_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.2926016906276345, + "vlm_logprob": -0.2926016906276345, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.925, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.2926016906276345, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static, eye-level close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a crisp, standard white sheet of paper visible lying flat on a dark, polished wood grain desk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature cool, soft natural light from a large, out-of-focus window creating reflections on the desk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the paper lift, hover, glide sideways across the desk, and then drift downward out of the bottom of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera completely static throughout the entire sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.29846373200416565 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4234637022018433 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.29846373200416565, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.29846373200416565, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07247911393642426, + 0.07520979642868042, + 0.09362415224313736, + 0.1343322992324829, + 0.03621245548129082, + 0.03148446977138519, + 0.058564383536577225, + 0.05825647711753845, + 0.41051965951919556, + 0.029317142441868782 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.29846373200416565 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static, eye-level close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a crisp, standard white sheet of paper visible lying flat on a dark, polished wood grain desk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature cool, soft natural light from a large, out-of-focus window creating reflections on the desk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the paper lift, hover, glide sideways across the desk, and then drift downward out of the bottom of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera completely static throughout the entire sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011112585663795471 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511112689971924 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011112585663795471, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011112585663795471, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1032274067401886, + 0.06930547207593918, + 0.13221821188926697, + 0.01673581823706627, + 0.04808448255062103, + 0.03412911295890808, + 0.3417138457298279, + 0.02000558376312256, + 0.21195998787879944, + 0.02262006513774395 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011112585663795471 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static, eye-level close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a crisp, standard white sheet of paper visible lying flat on a dark, polished wood grain desk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature cool, soft natural light from a large, out-of-focus window creating reflections on the desk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the paper lift, hover, glide sideways across the desk, and then drift downward out of the bottom of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera completely static throughout the entire sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0052617397159338 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.2552618980407715 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0052617397159338, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0052617397159338, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1034521833062172, + 0.015480829402804375, + 0.10363161563873291, + 0.029141904786229134, + 0.028015239164233208, + 0.06613068282604218, + 0.04582984745502472, + 0.02764500305056572, + 0.48763105273246765, + 0.09304162114858627 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0052617397159338 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static, eye-level close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a crisp, standard white sheet of paper visible lying flat on a dark, polished wood grain desk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature cool, soft natural light from a large, out-of-focus window creating reflections on the desk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the paper lift, hover, glide sideways across the desk, and then drift downward out of the bottom of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera completely static throughout the entire sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011077924631536007 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511077880859375 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011077924631536007, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011077924631536007, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10155133157968521, + 0.060635119676589966, + 0.02869650349020958, + 0.017353078350424767, + 0.029393555596470833, + 0.04280776157975197, + 0.1339649260044098, + 0.0458625927567482, + 0.4996947646141052, + 0.040040452033281326 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011077924631536007 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static, eye-level close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a crisp, standard white sheet of paper visible lying flat on a dark, polished wood grain desk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature cool, soft natural light from a large, out-of-focus window creating reflections on the desk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the paper lift, hover, glide sideways across the desk, and then drift downward out of the bottom of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera completely static throughout the entire sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1370924711227417 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3870925009250641 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.1370924711227417, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -1.1370924711227417, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1172712966799736, + 0.03493275120854378, + 0.026435667648911476, + 0.019432269036769867, + 0.03384602442383766, + 0.02786359004676342, + 0.03817316144704819, + 0.04826138913631439, + 0.5976092219352722, + 0.05617466941475868 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.1370924711227417 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, eye-level close-up, framed in a documentary style, captures a quiet moment in a modern office. A crisp, standard white sheet of paper lies flat against the dark, polished wood grain of a minimalist desk. The scene is illuminated primarily by cool, soft natural light from a large, out-of-focus window, creating subtle reflections on the desk's smooth surface. The action begins with an invisible draft of air causing the corner of the paper to subtly tremble. Then, the entire sheet is gently lifted and peeled from the desk in a slow, silent arc. It hovers for a moment, suspended just above the surface, before beginning to glide sideways, gliding smoothly and steadily across the polished wood. As the paper reaches the edge of the desk, it loses the support of the current and begins to drift downward. Its descent is an elegant, oscillating dance as it gently twists and turns, catching the ambient light before disappearing to the floor through the bottom of the frame, creating an atmosphere of serene and contemplative focused observation.", + "seed": 32188, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_2/index_9603_seed_32188_dp_4_rank_8_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.2082304739393294, + "vlm_logprob": -0.2082304739393294, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.825, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.2082304739393294, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static, eye-level close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a crisp, standard white sheet of paper visible lying flat on a dark, polished wood grain desk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature cool, soft natural light from a large, out-of-focus window creating reflections on the desk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the paper lift, hover, glide sideways across the desk, and then drift downward out of the bottom of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera completely static throughout the entire sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.30050894618034363 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.425508975982666 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.30050894618034363, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.30050894618034363, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0702936127781868, + 0.046226900070905685, + 0.05064529553055763, + 0.024432053789496422, + 0.01912805438041687, + 0.04746533930301666, + 0.5737494230270386, + 0.11752278357744217, + 0.031200014054775238, + 0.019336558878421783 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.30050894618034363 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static, eye-level close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a crisp, standard white sheet of paper visible lying flat on a dark, polished wood grain desk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature cool, soft natural light from a large, out-of-focus window creating reflections on the desk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the paper lift, hover, glide sideways across the desk, and then drift downward out of the bottom of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera completely static throughout the entire sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029837315902113914 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298373699188232 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029837315902113914, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029837315902113914, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08981205523014069, + 0.09608860313892365, + 0.05030026659369469, + 0.03242306783795357, + 0.056223511695861816, + 0.013402207754552364, + 0.45024603605270386, + 0.16784922778606415, + 0.02836761809885502, + 0.015287443995475769 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029837315902113914 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static, eye-level close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a crisp, standard white sheet of paper visible lying flat on a dark, polished wood grain desk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature cool, soft natural light from a large, out-of-focus window creating reflections on the desk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the paper lift, hover, glide sideways across the desk, and then drift downward out of the bottom of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera completely static throughout the entire sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007639478426426649 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882639408111572 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007639478426426649, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007639478426426649, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05689340829849243, + 0.023010751232504845, + 0.029668454080820084, + 0.02555181086063385, + 0.04374122619628906, + 0.19555243849754333, + 0.38107314705848694, + 0.21304737031459808, + 0.01619683764874935, + 0.015264545567333698 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007639478426426649 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static, eye-level close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a crisp, standard white sheet of paper visible lying flat on a dark, polished wood grain desk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature cool, soft natural light from a large, out-of-focus window creating reflections on the desk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the paper lift, hover, glide sideways across the desk, and then drift downward out of the bottom of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera completely static throughout the entire sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009783650748431683 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634783744812012 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009783650748431683, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009783650748431683, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0248524509370327, + 0.013338686898350716, + 0.03792271390557289, + 0.0184943825006485, + 0.020620636641979218, + 0.11478795111179352, + 0.5243094563484192, + 0.2095206081867218, + 0.021738659590482712, + 0.014414469711482525 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009783650748431683 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static, eye-level close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a crisp, standard white sheet of paper visible lying flat on a dark, polished wood grain desk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature cool, soft natural light from a large, out-of-focus window creating reflections on the desk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the paper lift, hover, glide sideways across the desk, and then drift downward out of the bottom of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera completely static throughout the entire sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.693382978439331 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.693382978439331 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.693382978439331, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.693382978439331, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.01002817414700985, + 0.01485191099345684, + 0.01124577410519123, + 0.012670832686126232, + 0.007917020469903946, + 0.013690185733139515, + 0.8471545577049255, + 0.0200874712318182, + 0.034301452338695526, + 0.02805272489786148 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.693382978439331 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, eye-level close-up, framed in a documentary style, captures a quiet moment in a modern office. A crisp, standard white sheet of paper lies flat against the dark, polished wood grain of a minimalist desk. The scene is illuminated primarily by cool, soft natural light from a large, out-of-focus window, creating subtle reflections on the desk's smooth surface. The action begins with an invisible draft of air causing the corner of the paper to subtly tremble. Then, the entire sheet is gently lifted and peeled from the desk in a slow, silent arc. It hovers for a moment, suspended just above the surface, before beginning to glide sideways, gliding smoothly and steadily across the polished wood. As the paper reaches the edge of the desk, it loses the support of the current and begins to drift downward. Its descent is an elegant, oscillating dance as it gently twists and turns, catching the ambient light before disappearing to the floor through the bottom of the frame, creating an atmosphere of serene and contemplative focused observation.", + "seed": 32189, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_2/index_9603_seed_32189_dp_5_rank_10_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.30762361818924544, + "vlm_logprob": -0.30762361818924544, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.625, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.30762361818924544, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static, eye-level close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a crisp, standard white sheet of paper visible lying flat on a dark, polished wood grain desk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature cool, soft natural light from a large, out-of-focus window creating reflections on the desk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the paper lift, hover, glide sideways across the desk, and then drift downward out of the bottom of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera completely static throughout the entire sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9117401838302612 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5367401838302612 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.9117401838302612, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.9117401838302612, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20594538748264313, + 0.1528891921043396, + 0.09966332465410233, + 0.06498189270496368, + 0.04244906082749367, + 0.050996895879507065, + 0.10689433664083481, + 0.15778687596321106, + 0.05662667378783226, + 0.061766367405653 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.9117401838302612 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static, eye-level close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a crisp, standard white sheet of paper visible lying flat on a dark, polished wood grain desk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature cool, soft natural light from a large, out-of-focus window creating reflections on the desk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the paper lift, hover, glide sideways across the desk, and then drift downward out of the bottom of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera completely static throughout the entire sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026389852166175842 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513898372650146 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026389852166175842, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026389852166175842, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10181185603141785, + 0.2681310772895813, + 0.10004489868879318, + 0.09524054825305939, + 0.05855469033122063, + 0.03781655803322792, + 0.059771161526441574, + 0.15670357644557953, + 0.03768131509423256, + 0.08424428850412369 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026389852166175842 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static, eye-level close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a crisp, standard white sheet of paper visible lying flat on a dark, polished wood grain desk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature cool, soft natural light from a large, out-of-focus window creating reflections on the desk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the paper lift, hover, glide sideways across the desk, and then drift downward out of the bottom of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera completely static throughout the entire sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0031994604505598545 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753199577331543 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0031994604505598545, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0031994604505598545, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06545039266347885, + 0.3251398503780365, + 0.10554106533527374, + 0.04480936750769615, + 0.0194083359092474, + 0.068150594830513, + 0.10601584613323212, + 0.13343212008476257, + 0.02409721165895462, + 0.1079551950097084 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0031994604505598545 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static, eye-level close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a crisp, standard white sheet of paper visible lying flat on a dark, polished wood grain desk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature cool, soft natural light from a large, out-of-focus window creating reflections on the desk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the paper lift, hover, glide sideways across the desk, and then drift downward out of the bottom of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera completely static throughout the entire sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02058989740908146 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895589828491211 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02058989740908146, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02058989740908146, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09994596242904663, + 0.12637348473072052, + 0.07353196293115616, + 0.12331945449113846, + 0.05972735583782196, + 0.0462515726685524, + 0.07054191082715988, + 0.2433893233537674, + 0.051334913820028305, + 0.10558407008647919 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02058989740908146 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static, eye-level close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a crisp, standard white sheet of paper visible lying flat on a dark, polished wood grain desk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature cool, soft natural light from a large, out-of-focus window creating reflections on the desk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the paper lift, hover, glide sideways across the desk, and then drift downward out of the bottom of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera completely static throughout the entire sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5761986970901489 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8261986970901489 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5761986970901489, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5761986970901489, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0971706435084343, + 0.21774612367153168, + 0.054192326962947845, + 0.05900303274393082, + 0.04779764637351036, + 0.037709638476371765, + 0.14937031269073486, + 0.11584922671318054, + 0.07076165825128555, + 0.15039946138858795 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5761986970901489 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, eye-level close-up, framed in a documentary style, captures a quiet moment in a modern office. A crisp, standard white sheet of paper lies flat against the dark, polished wood grain of a minimalist desk. The scene is illuminated primarily by cool, soft natural light from a large, out-of-focus window, creating subtle reflections on the desk's smooth surface. The action begins with an invisible draft of air causing the corner of the paper to subtly tremble. Then, the entire sheet is gently lifted and peeled from the desk in a slow, silent arc. It hovers for a moment, suspended just above the surface, before beginning to glide sideways, gliding smoothly and steadily across the polished wood. As the paper reaches the edge of the desk, it loses the support of the current and begins to drift downward. Its descent is an elegant, oscillating dance as it gently twists and turns, catching the ambient light before disappearing to the floor through the bottom of the frame, creating an atmosphere of serene and contemplative focused observation.", + "seed": 32190, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_2/index_9603_seed_32190_dp_5_rank_10_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.21056457511149346, + "vlm_logprob": -0.21056457511149346, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.0249999523162843, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.21056457511149346, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static, eye-level close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a crisp, standard white sheet of paper visible lying flat on a dark, polished wood grain desk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature cool, soft natural light from a large, out-of-focus window creating reflections on the desk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the paper lift, hover, glide sideways across the desk, and then drift downward out of the bottom of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera completely static throughout the entire sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2512904107570648 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6262904405593872 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2512904107570648, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2512904107570648, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.38101500272750854, + 0.09430469572544098, + 0.0452665314078331, + 0.09414509683847427, + 0.12012247741222382, + 0.07968717068433762, + 0.05702383816242218, + 0.029785433784127235, + 0.063123419880867, + 0.035526394844055176 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2512904107570648 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static, eye-level close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a crisp, standard white sheet of paper visible lying flat on a dark, polished wood grain desk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature cool, soft natural light from a large, out-of-focus window creating reflections on the desk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the paper lift, hover, glide sideways across the desk, and then drift downward out of the bottom of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera completely static throughout the entire sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01821727119386196 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018217086791992 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01821727119386196, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01821727119386196, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.28279000520706177, + 0.2561309039592743, + 0.07877897471189499, + 0.07499625533819199, + 0.05707079544663429, + 0.05560753867030144, + 0.040488120168447495, + 0.0773218497633934, + 0.05104170739650726, + 0.025773881003260612 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01821727119386196 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static, eye-level close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a crisp, standard white sheet of paper visible lying flat on a dark, polished wood grain desk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature cool, soft natural light from a large, out-of-focus window creating reflections on the desk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the paper lift, hover, glide sideways across the desk, and then drift downward out of the bottom of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera completely static throughout the entire sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0022046088706701994 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127204418182373 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0022046088706701994, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0022046088706701994, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5853102803230286, + 0.10416275262832642, + 0.03446832671761513, + 0.01932668685913086, + 0.0844782367348671, + 0.023110099136829376, + 0.053470488637685776, + 0.04725319892168045, + 0.02764991670846939, + 0.020770100876688957 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0022046088706701994 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static, eye-level close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a crisp, standard white sheet of paper visible lying flat on a dark, polished wood grain desk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature cool, soft natural light from a large, out-of-focus window creating reflections on the desk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the paper lift, hover, glide sideways across the desk, and then drift downward out of the bottom of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera completely static throughout the entire sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02329075336456299 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732906341552734 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02329075336456299, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02329075336456299, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3876773416996002, + 0.08889330178499222, + 0.061294764280319214, + 0.10022959113121033, + 0.19696243107318878, + 0.04746995121240616, + 0.018600238487124443, + 0.023350892588496208, + 0.030687276273965836, + 0.04483424499630928 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02329075336456299 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static, eye-level close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a crisp, standard white sheet of paper visible lying flat on a dark, polished wood grain desk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature cool, soft natural light from a large, out-of-focus window creating reflections on the desk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the paper lift, hover, glide sideways across the desk, and then drift downward out of the bottom of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera completely static throughout the entire sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7578198313713074 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6328198313713074 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.7578198313713074, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.7578198313713074, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2910919785499573, + 0.14746615290641785, + 0.11141059547662735, + 0.09657540172338486, + 0.06388214230537415, + 0.05496925115585327, + 0.06695187836885452, + 0.04278070479631424, + 0.10495228320360184, + 0.019919641315937042 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.7578198313713074 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_3/index_tensor([1995, 1995])_group_3_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_3/index_tensor([1995, 1995])_group_3_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..b08694a87107134708d71bc3bf8320af9f436e0b --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_3/index_tensor([1995, 1995])_group_3_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "dramatic overhead close-up, then a slow pull-back, focuses on a towering, classically styled bookcase constructed of dark cherrywood. It sits in a dimly lit study, a warm beam from an old-fashioned desk lamp illuminating the dust particles hanging in the air. Each shelf visibly buckles under the immense weight of countless heavy hardcovers and faded paperbacks, showing signs of straining under the weight. Suddenly, with a sharp, ominous ripping sound, a tiny crack appears in the grain of one of the shelf's main vertical supports. The jagged crack then snakes upward with alarming speed, swiftly and violently. The light reveals the brutal tearing of wood fibers, sending tiny splinters scattering outward. As the crack widens, the massive structure groans and shakes violently, sending the books within trembling with it, foreshadowing an impending, catastrophic collapse. The entire scene is imbued with an atmosphere of intense tension and irreversible destruction.", + "seed": 18869, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_3/index_1995_seed_18869_dp_6_rank_12_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.176059677824378, + "vlm_logprob": -0.176059677824378, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.125, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.176059677824378, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle an overhead close-up that slowly pulls back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a towering bookcase made of dark cherrywood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a dimly lit study with a warm beam from an old-fashioned desk lamp illuminating dust particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the shelves visibly buckle and strain under the weight of heavy hardcovers and paperbacks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a jagged crack appear in a vertical support and snake upward rapidly, causing the structure to shake violently?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08965030312538147 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5896503925323486 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08965030312538147, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08965030312538147, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2009899914264679, + 0.06723238527774811, + 0.054220858961343765, + 0.18664489686489105, + 0.20303604006767273, + 0.06503058969974518, + 0.10866518318653107, + 0.05186447128653526, + 0.03695156052708626, + 0.025364043191075325 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08965030312538147 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle an overhead close-up that slowly pulls back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a towering bookcase made of dark cherrywood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a dimly lit study with a warm beam from an old-fashioned desk lamp illuminating dust particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the shelves visibly buckle and strain under the weight of heavy hardcovers and paperbacks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a jagged crack appear in a vertical support and snake upward rapidly, causing the structure to shake violently?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.25211769342422485 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.50211763381958 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.25211769342422485, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.25211769342422485, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08426109701395035, + 0.06094755232334137, + 0.04609955847263336, + 0.3292847275733948, + 0.05454820394515991, + 0.07454092800617218, + 0.09472570568323135, + 0.10536453872919083, + 0.1209319680929184, + 0.0292956605553627 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.25211769342422485 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle an overhead close-up that slowly pulls back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a towering bookcase made of dark cherrywood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a dimly lit study with a warm beam from an old-fashioned desk lamp illuminating dust particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the shelves visibly buckle and strain under the weight of heavy hardcovers and paperbacks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a jagged crack appear in a vertical support and snake upward rapidly, causing the structure to shake violently?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020598655566573143 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955986499786377 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020598655566573143, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020598655566573143, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21923406422138214, + 0.1114022508263588, + 0.08350928872823715, + 0.09706248342990875, + 0.12548066675662994, + 0.035261120647192, + 0.14369772374629974, + 0.05255923420190811, + 0.07395593076944351, + 0.057837244123220444 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020598655566573143 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle an overhead close-up that slowly pulls back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a towering bookcase made of dark cherrywood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a dimly lit study with a warm beam from an old-fashioned desk lamp illuminating dust particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the shelves visibly buckle and strain under the weight of heavy hardcovers and paperbacks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a jagged crack appear in a vertical support and snake upward rapidly, causing the structure to shake violently?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4288911819458008 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.0538911819458008 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.4288911819458008, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.4288911819458008, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09167784452438354, + 0.031556691974401474, + 0.05283382162451744, + 0.3057538568973541, + 0.06263303011655807, + 0.08036679774522781, + 0.1120385080575943, + 0.1408112794160843, + 0.05007682368159294, + 0.07225146144628525 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.4288911819458008 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle an overhead close-up that slowly pulls back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a towering bookcase made of dark cherrywood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a dimly lit study with a warm beam from an old-fashioned desk lamp illuminating dust particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the shelves visibly buckle and strain under the weight of heavy hardcovers and paperbacks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a jagged crack appear in a vertical support and snake upward rapidly, causing the structure to shake violently?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08904055505990982 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.464040517807007 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08904055505990982, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08904055505990982, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15709218382835388, + 0.06983742117881775, + 0.06583685427904129, + 0.1418517827987671, + 0.11615545302629471, + 0.09045030921697617, + 0.09161005169153214, + 0.10499252378940582, + 0.042137134820222855, + 0.12003621459007263 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08904055505990982 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dramatic overhead close-up, then a slow pull-back, focuses on a towering, classically styled bookcase constructed of dark cherrywood. It sits in a dimly lit study, a warm beam from an old-fashioned desk lamp illuminating the dust particles hanging in the air. Each shelf visibly buckles under the immense weight of countless heavy hardcovers and faded paperbacks, showing signs of straining under the weight. Suddenly, with a sharp, ominous ripping sound, a tiny crack appears in the grain of one of the shelf's main vertical supports. The jagged crack then snakes upward with alarming speed, swiftly and violently. The light reveals the brutal tearing of wood fibers, sending tiny splinters scattering outward. As the crack widens, the massive structure groans and shakes violently, sending the books within trembling with it, foreshadowing an impending, catastrophic collapse. The entire scene is imbued with an atmosphere of intense tension and irreversible destruction.", + "seed": 18870, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_3/index_1995_seed_18870_dp_6_rank_12_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.12926959227770568, + "vlm_logprob": -0.12926959227770568, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.55, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.12926959227770568, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle an overhead close-up that slowly pulls back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a towering bookcase made of dark cherrywood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a dimly lit study with a warm beam from an old-fashioned desk lamp illuminating dust particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the shelves visibly buckle and strain under the weight of heavy hardcovers and paperbacks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a jagged crack appear in a vertical support and snake upward rapidly, causing the structure to shake violently?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08069198578596115 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.7056920528411865 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08069198578596115, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08069198578596115, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2560766637325287, + 0.08675965666770935, + 0.026234660297632217, + 0.051085248589515686, + 0.09488539397716522, + 0.29079851508140564, + 0.16660143435001373, + 0.015025925822556019, + 0.006998549681156874, + 0.005534050520509481 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08069198578596115 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle an overhead close-up that slowly pulls back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a towering bookcase made of dark cherrywood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a dimly lit study with a warm beam from an old-fashioned desk lamp illuminating dust particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the shelves visibly buckle and strain under the weight of heavy hardcovers and paperbacks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a jagged crack appear in a vertical support and snake upward rapidly, causing the structure to shake violently?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20158728957176208 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7015873193740845 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20158728957176208, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20158728957176208, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5394134521484375, + 0.06350874900817871, + 0.03455260023474693, + 0.030683383345603943, + 0.047557659447193146, + 0.08952504396438599, + 0.04514379799365997, + 0.02207990363240242, + 0.06278597563505173, + 0.06474944949150085 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20158728957176208 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle an overhead close-up that slowly pulls back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a towering bookcase made of dark cherrywood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a dimly lit study with a warm beam from an old-fashioned desk lamp illuminating dust particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the shelves visibly buckle and strain under the weight of heavy hardcovers and paperbacks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a jagged crack appear in a vertical support and snake upward rapidly, causing the structure to shake violently?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012552070431411266 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387552261352539 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012552070431411266, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012552070431411266, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.7392218112945557, + 0.015412378124892712, + 0.023687103763222694, + 0.015524976886808872, + 0.03653820976614952, + 0.0380248986184597, + 0.037222445011138916, + 0.0104907788336277, + 0.011448187753558159, + 0.0724291205406189 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012552070431411266 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle an overhead close-up that slowly pulls back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a towering bookcase made of dark cherrywood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a dimly lit study with a warm beam from an old-fashioned desk lamp illuminating dust particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the shelves visibly buckle and strain under the weight of heavy hardcovers and paperbacks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a jagged crack appear in a vertical support and snake upward rapidly, causing the structure to shake violently?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.31342172622680664 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3134217262268066 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.31342172622680664, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.31342172622680664, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5571057796478271, + 0.07009577751159668, + 0.02612517960369587, + 0.038799773901700974, + 0.07876935601234436, + 0.053673047572374344, + 0.05216476693749428, + 0.0415523499250412, + 0.022421998903155327, + 0.059291936457157135 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.31342172622680664 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle an overhead close-up that slowly pulls back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a towering bookcase made of dark cherrywood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a dimly lit study with a warm beam from an old-fashioned desk lamp illuminating dust particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the shelves visibly buckle and strain under the weight of heavy hardcovers and paperbacks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a jagged crack appear in a vertical support and snake upward rapidly, causing the structure to shake violently?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.038094889372587204 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288094997406006 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.038094889372587204, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.038094889372587204, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3624657690525055, + 0.07115167379379272, + 0.02333502098917961, + 0.031518083065748215, + 0.11310411989688873, + 0.10951242595911026, + 0.10297410935163498, + 0.07565519213676453, + 0.02233034186065197, + 0.08795326948165894 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.038094889372587204 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dramatic overhead close-up, then a slow pull-back, focuses on a towering, classically styled bookcase constructed of dark cherrywood. It sits in a dimly lit study, a warm beam from an old-fashioned desk lamp illuminating the dust particles hanging in the air. Each shelf visibly buckles under the immense weight of countless heavy hardcovers and faded paperbacks, showing signs of straining under the weight. Suddenly, with a sharp, ominous ripping sound, a tiny crack appears in the grain of one of the shelf's main vertical supports. The jagged crack then snakes upward with alarming speed, swiftly and violently. The light reveals the brutal tearing of wood fibers, sending tiny splinters scattering outward. As the crack widens, the massive structure groans and shakes violently, sending the books within trembling with it, foreshadowing an impending, catastrophic collapse. The entire scene is imbued with an atmosphere of intense tension and irreversible destruction.", + "seed": 18871, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_3/index_1995_seed_18871_dp_7_rank_14_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.2489088274538517, + "vlm_logprob": -0.2489088274538517, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.575, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.2489088274538517, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle an overhead close-up that slowly pulls back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a towering bookcase made of dark cherrywood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a dimly lit study with a warm beam from an old-fashioned desk lamp illuminating dust particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the shelves visibly buckle and strain under the weight of heavy hardcovers and paperbacks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a jagged crack appear in a vertical support and snake upward rapidly, causing the structure to shake violently?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5291435122489929 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9041435122489929 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5291435122489929, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5291435122489929, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06952566653490067, + 0.04063019901514053, + 0.05760924145579338, + 0.057193949818611145, + 0.3867129683494568, + 0.027421725913882256, + 0.1573534607887268, + 0.03484455123543739, + 0.03589990735054016, + 0.1328083723783493 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5291435122489929 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle an overhead close-up that slowly pulls back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a towering bookcase made of dark cherrywood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a dimly lit study with a warm beam from an old-fashioned desk lamp illuminating dust particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the shelves visibly buckle and strain under the weight of heavy hardcovers and paperbacks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a jagged crack appear in a vertical support and snake upward rapidly, causing the structure to shake violently?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22564077377319336 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6006407737731934 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.22564077377319336, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.22564077377319336, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06201251596212387, + 0.04290648549795151, + 0.056086938828229904, + 0.05041893199086189, + 0.10025763511657715, + 0.03361528739333153, + 0.4576612412929535, + 0.03317134827375412, + 0.07055316120386124, + 0.09331648051738739 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.22564077377319336 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle an overhead close-up that slowly pulls back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a towering bookcase made of dark cherrywood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a dimly lit study with a warm beam from an old-fashioned desk lamp illuminating dust particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the shelves visibly buckle and strain under the weight of heavy hardcovers and paperbacks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a jagged crack appear in a vertical support and snake upward rapidly, causing the structure to shake violently?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.062107887119054794 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812107801437378 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.062107887119054794, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.062107887119054794, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17558793723583221, + 0.053812798112630844, + 0.20990008115768433, + 0.14542199671268463, + 0.03465234488248825, + 0.0665651485323906, + 0.12618348002433777, + 0.03499183431267738, + 0.04247543588280678, + 0.11040890961885452 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.062107887119054794 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle an overhead close-up that slowly pulls back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a towering bookcase made of dark cherrywood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a dimly lit study with a warm beam from an old-fashioned desk lamp illuminating dust particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the shelves visibly buckle and strain under the weight of heavy hardcovers and paperbacks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a jagged crack appear in a vertical support and snake upward rapidly, causing the structure to shake violently?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.34865084290504456 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2236508131027222 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.34865084290504456, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.34865084290504456, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08246088773012161, + 0.061040014028549194, + 0.08758839219808578, + 0.08045179396867752, + 0.06119779497385025, + 0.03885815665125847, + 0.08031109720468521, + 0.058414146304130554, + 0.16539931297302246, + 0.28427842259407043 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.34865084290504456 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle an overhead close-up that slowly pulls back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a towering bookcase made of dark cherrywood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a dimly lit study with a warm beam from an old-fashioned desk lamp illuminating dust particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the shelves visibly buckle and strain under the weight of heavy hardcovers and paperbacks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a jagged crack appear in a vertical support and snake upward rapidly, causing the structure to shake violently?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07900112122297287 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5790011882781982 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07900112122297287, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07900112122297287, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.044701505452394485, + 0.049070004373788834, + 0.07619062066078186, + 0.03341712802648544, + 0.050675999373197556, + 0.021094297990202904, + 0.1834574043750763, + 0.13924714922904968, + 0.0948818102478981, + 0.3072640895843506 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07900112122297287 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dramatic overhead close-up, then a slow pull-back, focuses on a towering, classically styled bookcase constructed of dark cherrywood. It sits in a dimly lit study, a warm beam from an old-fashioned desk lamp illuminating the dust particles hanging in the air. Each shelf visibly buckles under the immense weight of countless heavy hardcovers and faded paperbacks, showing signs of straining under the weight. Suddenly, with a sharp, ominous ripping sound, a tiny crack appears in the grain of one of the shelf's main vertical supports. The jagged crack then snakes upward with alarming speed, swiftly and violently. The light reveals the brutal tearing of wood fibers, sending tiny splinters scattering outward. As the crack widens, the massive structure groans and shakes violently, sending the books within trembling with it, foreshadowing an impending, catastrophic collapse. The entire scene is imbued with an atmosphere of intense tension and irreversible destruction.", + "seed": 18872, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_3/index_1995_seed_18872_dp_7_rank_14_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.22798253297805787, + "vlm_logprob": -0.22798253297805787, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.6749999880790711, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.22798253297805787, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle an overhead close-up that slowly pulls back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a towering bookcase made of dark cherrywood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a dimly lit study with a warm beam from an old-fashioned desk lamp illuminating dust particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the shelves visibly buckle and strain under the weight of heavy hardcovers and paperbacks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a jagged crack appear in a vertical support and snake upward rapidly, causing the structure to shake violently?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3972359299659729 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1472358703613281 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3972359299659729, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.7499999403953552, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3972359299659729, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23114056885242462, + 0.05024270713329315, + 0.07073372602462769, + 0.11309724301099777, + 0.08058502525091171, + 0.0586753748357296, + 0.04517369344830513, + 0.03530699387192726, + 0.20391114056110382, + 0.11113352328538895 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3972359299659729 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle an overhead close-up that slowly pulls back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a towering bookcase made of dark cherrywood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a dimly lit study with a warm beam from an old-fashioned desk lamp illuminating dust particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the shelves visibly buckle and strain under the weight of heavy hardcovers and paperbacks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a jagged crack appear in a vertical support and snake upward rapidly, causing the structure to shake violently?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10035140812397003 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.350351333618164 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10035140812397003, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10035140812397003, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4378754198551178, + 0.03063003160059452, + 0.03315306454896927, + 0.04963326081633568, + 0.10248226672410965, + 0.11537258327007294, + 0.012932355515658855, + 0.043364640325307846, + 0.054748278111219406, + 0.11980811506509781 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10035140812397003 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle an overhead close-up that slowly pulls back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a towering bookcase made of dark cherrywood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a dimly lit study with a warm beam from an old-fashioned desk lamp illuminating dust particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the shelves visibly buckle and strain under the weight of heavy hardcovers and paperbacks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a jagged crack appear in a vertical support and snake upward rapidly, causing the structure to shake violently?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08907992392778397 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4640798568725586 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08907992392778397, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08907992392778397, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3612727224826813, + 0.01807350106537342, + 0.04319541156291962, + 0.039278075098991394, + 0.30708691477775574, + 0.09385182708501816, + 0.03341483697295189, + 0.05268580839037895, + 0.01568695716559887, + 0.03545404598116875 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08907992392778397 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle an overhead close-up that slowly pulls back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a towering bookcase made of dark cherrywood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a dimly lit study with a warm beam from an old-fashioned desk lamp illuminating dust particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the shelves visibly buckle and strain under the weight of heavy hardcovers and paperbacks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a jagged crack appear in a vertical support and snake upward rapidly, causing the structure to shake violently?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.47426366806030273 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9742636680603027 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.47426366806030273, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.47426366806030273, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.532724916934967, + 0.026558568701148033, + 0.029953988268971443, + 0.03772204369306564, + 0.12488322705030441, + 0.06173130124807358, + 0.022466562688350677, + 0.06379155814647675, + 0.049556635320186615, + 0.050611257553100586 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.47426366806030273 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle an overhead close-up that slowly pulls back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a towering bookcase made of dark cherrywood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a dimly lit study with a warm beam from an old-fashioned desk lamp illuminating dust particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the shelves visibly buckle and strain under the weight of heavy hardcovers and paperbacks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a jagged crack appear in a vertical support and snake upward rapidly, causing the structure to shake violently?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07898173481225967 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.578981637954712 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07898173481225967, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07898173481225967, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.6266335248947144, + 0.023269059136509895, + 0.012161741964519024, + 0.03378341346979141, + 0.0610542893409729, + 0.034477755427360535, + 0.01808709278702736, + 0.06982342898845673, + 0.057808488607406616, + 0.06290123611688614 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07898173481225967 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_4/index_tensor([9218, 9218])_group_4_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_4/index_tensor([9218, 9218])_group_4_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..d4ba0f2c11fdff6897494d04b635f848f3137aac --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_4/index_tensor([9218, 9218])_group_4_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "In a tightly composed, static close-up shot, golden-yellow raw beer surges violently within a glass that nearly fills the frame. The scene is rendered with the surreal quality of a Pixar film. Within the translucent honey-colored liquid, countless tiny, vibrant bubbles, like shimmering golden dust, surge rapidly and densely from the bottom, brimming with vivid energy. As the liquid churns vigorously, a creamy, dense, and delicate white foam explodes from the surface, its crown rapidly expanding and its surface constantly shifting, gracefully forming a soft, billowing cloud-like structure. Each bubble's bursting and reforming is clearly visible in exquisite detail. Warm, soft lighting penetrates the liquid from behind, casting a captivating halo and precisely outlining the rich, three-dimensional texture of the foam, with soft highlights reflecting off the moist surface. Against the backdrop of warm colors, the entire picture is not only full of refreshing dynamics and visual impact, but also shows a pleasant, animation-specific artistic beauty and vitality. The atmosphere is lively and full of fantasy.", + "seed": 8792, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_4/index_9218_seed_8792_dp_8_rank_16_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.06925861649215222, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06925861649215222, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.1, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06925861649215222, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static close-up of a glass filled with golden-yellow raw beer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do countless tiny, vibrant bubbles surge rapidly and densely from the bottom of the glass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a creamy, dense white foam explode from the surface and form a soft, billowing cloud-like structure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there warm, soft backlighting that casts a halo and outlines the three-dimensional texture of the foam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style rendered with the surreal quality of a Pixar film?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.025502419099211693 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7755024433135986 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.025502419099211693, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.025502419099211693, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24421915411949158, + 0.19962793588638306, + 0.06826149672269821, + 0.03997206687927246, + 0.2663336396217346, + 0.04843628779053688, + 0.025959311053156853, + 0.02468578703701496, + 0.03603162616491318, + 0.04647272080183029 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.025502419099211693 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static close-up of a glass filled with golden-yellow raw beer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do countless tiny, vibrant bubbles surge rapidly and densely from the bottom of the glass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a creamy, dense white foam explode from the surface and form a soft, billowing cloud-like structure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there warm, soft backlighting that casts a halo and outlines the three-dimensional texture of the foam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style rendered with the surreal quality of a Pixar film?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.18000377714633942 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8050037622451782 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.18000377714633942, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.18000377714633942, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.30011871457099915, + 0.13138547539710999, + 0.07197433710098267, + 0.05549829825758934, + 0.1568693071603775, + 0.039191339164972305, + 0.03130999207496643, + 0.04280714690685272, + 0.06323104351758957, + 0.10761439055204391 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.18000377714633942 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static close-up of a glass filled with golden-yellow raw beer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do countless tiny, vibrant bubbles surge rapidly and densely from the bottom of the glass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a creamy, dense white foam explode from the surface and form a soft, billowing cloud-like structure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there warm, soft backlighting that casts a halo and outlines the three-dimensional texture of the foam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style rendered with the surreal quality of a Pixar film?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.062084585428237915 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812084674835205 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.062084585428237915, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.062084585428237915, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2811691164970398, + 0.20922216773033142, + 0.10662125051021576, + 0.03438366577029228, + 0.0664002001285553, + 0.05461930111050606, + 0.09523512423038483, + 0.034648314118385315, + 0.051494989544153214, + 0.06620579957962036 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.062084585428237915 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static close-up of a glass filled with golden-yellow raw beer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do countless tiny, vibrant bubbles surge rapidly and densely from the bottom of the glass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a creamy, dense white foam explode from the surface and form a soft, billowing cloud-like structure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there warm, soft backlighting that casts a halo and outlines the three-dimensional texture of the foam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style rendered with the surreal quality of a Pixar film?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00864158570766449 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758641719818115 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00864158570766449, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00864158570766449, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1631718873977661, + 0.21845917403697968, + 0.05338744446635246, + 0.03811533749103546, + 0.036616113036870956, + 0.05405525863170624, + 0.04913010448217392, + 0.07206812500953674, + 0.04860082268714905, + 0.2663957178592682 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00864158570766449 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static close-up of a glass filled with golden-yellow raw beer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do countless tiny, vibrant bubbles surge rapidly and densely from the bottom of the glass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a creamy, dense white foam explode from the surface and form a soft, billowing cloud-like structure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there warm, soft backlighting that casts a halo and outlines the three-dimensional texture of the foam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style rendered with the surreal quality of a Pixar film?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07006071507930756 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950607299804688 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07006071507930756, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07006071507930756, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4574618935585022, + 0.16660237312316895, + 0.04129834473133087, + 0.025975322350859642, + 0.05206447094678879, + 0.05638434365391731, + 0.060712676495313644, + 0.022036168724298477, + 0.04578714072704315, + 0.07167726010084152 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07006071507930756 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a tightly composed, static close-up shot, golden-yellow raw beer surges violently within a glass that nearly fills the frame. The scene is rendered with the surreal quality of a Pixar film. Within the translucent honey-colored liquid, countless tiny, vibrant bubbles, like shimmering golden dust, surge rapidly and densely from the bottom, brimming with vivid energy. As the liquid churns vigorously, a creamy, dense, and delicate white foam explodes from the surface, its crown rapidly expanding and its surface constantly shifting, gracefully forming a soft, billowing cloud-like structure. Each bubble's bursting and reforming is clearly visible in exquisite detail. Warm, soft lighting penetrates the liquid from behind, casting a captivating halo and precisely outlining the rich, three-dimensional texture of the foam, with soft highlights reflecting off the moist surface. Against the backdrop of warm colors, the entire picture is not only full of refreshing dynamics and visual impact, but also shows a pleasant, animation-specific artistic beauty and vitality. The atmosphere is lively and full of fantasy.", + "seed": 8793, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_4/index_9218_seed_8793_dp_8_rank_16_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.033457071986049414, + "vlm_logprob": -0.033457071986049414, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.65, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.033457071986049414, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static close-up of a glass filled with golden-yellow raw beer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do countless tiny, vibrant bubbles surge rapidly and densely from the bottom of the glass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a creamy, dense white foam explode from the surface and form a soft, billowing cloud-like structure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there warm, soft backlighting that casts a halo and outlines the three-dimensional texture of the foam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style rendered with the surreal quality of a Pixar film?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02340138889849186 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8984014987945557 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02340138889849186, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02340138889849186, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08612112700939178, + 0.06001047417521477, + 0.5632193088531494, + 0.06689108163118362, + 0.0639328882098198, + 0.03946426138281822, + 0.04166390374302864, + 0.02104116603732109, + 0.030338382348418236, + 0.027317428961396217 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02340138889849186 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static close-up of a glass filled with golden-yellow raw beer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do countless tiny, vibrant bubbles surge rapidly and densely from the bottom of the glass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a creamy, dense white foam explode from the surface and form a soft, billowing cloud-like structure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there warm, soft backlighting that casts a halo and outlines the three-dimensional texture of the foam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style rendered with the surreal quality of a Pixar film?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06210654228925705 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8121066093444824 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06210654228925705, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06210654228925705, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07896512746810913, + 0.19218234717845917, + 0.14600470662117004, + 0.14137056469917297, + 0.03779671713709831, + 0.11433922499418259, + 0.0315692313015461, + 0.07501941919326782, + 0.10261857509613037, + 0.08013409376144409 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06210654228925705 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static close-up of a glass filled with golden-yellow raw beer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do countless tiny, vibrant bubbles surge rapidly and densely from the bottom of the glass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a creamy, dense white foam explode from the surface and form a soft, billowing cloud-like structure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there warm, soft backlighting that casts a halo and outlines the three-dimensional texture of the foam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style rendered with the surreal quality of a Pixar film?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026365818455815315 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513657569885254 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026365818455815315, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026365818455815315, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09324679523706436, + 0.40058356523513794, + 0.169851616024971, + 0.056789714843034744, + 0.03767448663711548, + 0.1427450180053711, + 0.018554354086518288, + 0.02602272294461727, + 0.03582851216197014, + 0.01870318315923214 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026365818455815315 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static close-up of a glass filled with golden-yellow raw beer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do countless tiny, vibrant bubbles surge rapidly and densely from the bottom of the glass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a creamy, dense white foam explode from the surface and form a soft, billowing cloud-like structure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there warm, soft backlighting that casts a halo and outlines the three-dimensional texture of the foam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style rendered with the surreal quality of a Pixar film?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0067384387366473675 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006738662719727 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0067384387366473675, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0067384387366473675, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10595883429050446, + 0.0948576033115387, + 0.2882705330848694, + 0.03209304437041283, + 0.04094623774290085, + 0.30080512166023254, + 0.04641139134764671, + 0.040604475885629654, + 0.03277704864740372, + 0.017275666818022728 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0067384387366473675 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static close-up of a glass filled with golden-yellow raw beer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do countless tiny, vibrant bubbles surge rapidly and densely from the bottom of the glass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a creamy, dense white foam explode from the surface and form a soft, billowing cloud-like structure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there warm, soft backlighting that casts a halo and outlines the three-dimensional texture of the foam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style rendered with the surreal quality of a Pixar film?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04867317155003548 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048673152923584 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04867317155003548, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04867317155003548, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14656484127044678, + 0.08230224251747131, + 0.3380434215068817, + 0.02681860327720642, + 0.02388770692050457, + 0.2832459807395935, + 0.03585779666900635, + 0.03187289834022522, + 0.021976327523589134, + 0.009430243633687496 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04867317155003548 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a tightly composed, static close-up shot, golden-yellow raw beer surges violently within a glass that nearly fills the frame. The scene is rendered with the surreal quality of a Pixar film. Within the translucent honey-colored liquid, countless tiny, vibrant bubbles, like shimmering golden dust, surge rapidly and densely from the bottom, brimming with vivid energy. As the liquid churns vigorously, a creamy, dense, and delicate white foam explodes from the surface, its crown rapidly expanding and its surface constantly shifting, gracefully forming a soft, billowing cloud-like structure. Each bubble's bursting and reforming is clearly visible in exquisite detail. Warm, soft lighting penetrates the liquid from behind, casting a captivating halo and precisely outlining the rich, three-dimensional texture of the foam, with soft highlights reflecting off the moist surface. Against the backdrop of warm colors, the entire picture is not only full of refreshing dynamics and visual impact, but also shows a pleasant, animation-specific artistic beauty and vitality. The atmosphere is lively and full of fantasy.", + "seed": 8794, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_4/index_9218_seed_8794_dp_9_rank_18_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.026600210252217947, + "vlm_logprob": -0.026600210252217947, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.3, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.026600210252217947, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static close-up of a glass filled with golden-yellow raw beer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do countless tiny, vibrant bubbles surge rapidly and densely from the bottom of the glass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a creamy, dense white foam explode from the surface and form a soft, billowing cloud-like structure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there warm, soft backlighting that casts a halo and outlines the three-dimensional texture of the foam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style rendered with the surreal quality of a Pixar film?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02253565937280655 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.897535562515259 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02253565937280655, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02253565937280655, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14288952946662903, + 0.1199556365609169, + 0.23182322084903717, + 0.04869091510772705, + 0.06645148247480392, + 0.026067038998007774, + 0.0786115974187851, + 0.21058893203735352, + 0.04795743525028229, + 0.026964237913489342 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02253565937280655 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static close-up of a glass filled with golden-yellow raw beer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do countless tiny, vibrant bubbles surge rapidly and densely from the bottom of the glass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a creamy, dense white foam explode from the surface and form a soft, billowing cloud-like structure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there warm, soft backlighting that casts a halo and outlines the three-dimensional texture of the foam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style rendered with the surreal quality of a Pixar film?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05501364544034004 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.930013656616211 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05501364544034004, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05501364544034004, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07675769925117493, + 0.18908879160881042, + 0.09618546813726425, + 0.07930547744035721, + 0.09591663628816605, + 0.028361739590764046, + 0.06322194635868073, + 0.2698761820793152, + 0.06532727181911469, + 0.03595874831080437 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05501364544034004 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static close-up of a glass filled with golden-yellow raw beer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do countless tiny, vibrant bubbles surge rapidly and densely from the bottom of the glass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a creamy, dense white foam explode from the surface and form a soft, billowing cloud-like structure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there warm, soft backlighting that casts a halo and outlines the three-dimensional texture of the foam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style rendered with the surreal quality of a Pixar film?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0015200738562271 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.501520156860352 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0015200738562271, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0015200738562271, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11900686472654343, + 0.18156172335147858, + 0.26098835468292236, + 0.09976671636104584, + 0.05292725935578346, + 0.03727269545197487, + 0.05131257697939873, + 0.1076645776629448, + 0.04486074671149254, + 0.04463846981525421 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0015200738562271 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static close-up of a glass filled with golden-yellow raw beer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do countless tiny, vibrant bubbles surge rapidly and densely from the bottom of the glass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a creamy, dense white foam explode from the surface and form a soft, billowing cloud-like structure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there warm, soft backlighting that casts a halo and outlines the three-dimensional texture of the foam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style rendered with the surreal quality of a Pixar film?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005254980642348528 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255254745483398 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005254980642348528, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005254980642348528, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06018202379345894, + 0.13273809850215912, + 0.17606864869594574, + 0.08197572827339172, + 0.01713854819536209, + 0.0314057432115078, + 0.08388160169124603, + 0.32818448543548584, + 0.01934262365102768, + 0.06908244639635086 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005254980642348528 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static close-up of a glass filled with golden-yellow raw beer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do countless tiny, vibrant bubbles surge rapidly and densely from the bottom of the glass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a creamy, dense white foam explode from the surface and form a soft, billowing cloud-like structure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there warm, soft backlighting that casts a halo and outlines the three-dimensional texture of the foam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style rendered with the surreal quality of a Pixar film?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04867669194936752 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486767292022705 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04867669194936752, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04867669194936752, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12469260394573212, + 0.10643906146287918, + 0.44566261768341064, + 0.12454670667648315, + 0.0659685730934143, + 0.02651960588991642, + 0.01765506900846958, + 0.04803252965211868, + 0.021802812814712524, + 0.018680397421121597 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04867669194936752 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a tightly composed, static close-up shot, golden-yellow raw beer surges violently within a glass that nearly fills the frame. The scene is rendered with the surreal quality of a Pixar film. Within the translucent honey-colored liquid, countless tiny, vibrant bubbles, like shimmering golden dust, surge rapidly and densely from the bottom, brimming with vivid energy. As the liquid churns vigorously, a creamy, dense, and delicate white foam explodes from the surface, its crown rapidly expanding and its surface constantly shifting, gracefully forming a soft, billowing cloud-like structure. Each bubble's bursting and reforming is clearly visible in exquisite detail. Warm, soft lighting penetrates the liquid from behind, casting a captivating halo and precisely outlining the rich, three-dimensional texture of the foam, with soft highlights reflecting off the moist surface. Against the backdrop of warm colors, the entire picture is not only full of refreshing dynamics and visual impact, but also shows a pleasant, animation-specific artistic beauty and vitality. The atmosphere is lively and full of fantasy.", + "seed": 8795, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_4/index_9218_seed_8795_dp_9_rank_18_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.04245242271572351, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04245242271572351, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.55, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04245242271572351, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static close-up of a glass filled with golden-yellow raw beer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do countless tiny, vibrant bubbles surge rapidly and densely from the bottom of the glass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a creamy, dense white foam explode from the surface and form a soft, billowing cloud-like structure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there warm, soft backlighting that casts a halo and outlines the three-dimensional texture of the foam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style rendered with the surreal quality of a Pixar film?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02830258384346962 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6533026695251465 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02830258384346962, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02830258384346962, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.026752060279250145, + 0.032797671854496, + 0.13642510771751404, + 0.039384257048368454, + 0.037887655198574066, + 0.11216381937265396, + 0.06925452500581741, + 0.47057825326919556, + 0.017586473375558853, + 0.05717016011476517 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02830258384346962 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static close-up of a glass filled with golden-yellow raw beer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do countless tiny, vibrant bubbles surge rapidly and densely from the bottom of the glass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a creamy, dense white foam explode from the surface and form a soft, billowing cloud-like structure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there warm, soft backlighting that casts a halo and outlines the three-dimensional texture of the foam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style rendered with the surreal quality of a Pixar film?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1003938838839531 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.350393772125244 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1003938838839531, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1003938838839531, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.046442996710538864, + 0.026762258261442184, + 0.06108365207910538, + 0.09583640843629837, + 0.057049524039030075, + 0.043671123683452606, + 0.05974522605538368, + 0.5622937083244324, + 0.022416941821575165, + 0.024698158726096153 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1003938838839531 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static close-up of a glass filled with golden-yellow raw beer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do countless tiny, vibrant bubbles surge rapidly and densely from the bottom of the glass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a creamy, dense white foam explode from the surface and form a soft, billowing cloud-like structure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there warm, soft backlighting that casts a halo and outlines the three-dimensional texture of the foam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style rendered with the surreal quality of a Pixar film?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023311249911785126 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773311138153076 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023311249911785126, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023311249911785126, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.041003525257110596, + 0.02458108775317669, + 0.2867138385772705, + 0.06339073181152344, + 0.010040730237960815, + 0.029189012944698334, + 0.06544952839612961, + 0.42630496621131897, + 0.010026338510215282, + 0.04330030828714371 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 2, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023311249911785126 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static close-up of a glass filled with golden-yellow raw beer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do countless tiny, vibrant bubbles surge rapidly and densely from the bottom of the glass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a creamy, dense white foam explode from the surface and form a soft, billowing cloud-like structure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there warm, soft backlighting that casts a halo and outlines the three-dimensional texture of the foam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style rendered with the surreal quality of a Pixar film?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005256996490061283 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.2552571296691895 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005256996490061283, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005256996490061283, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.053668685257434845, + 0.03502224013209343, + 0.2799777090549469, + 0.05781902000308037, + 0.04014315828680992, + 0.10930877923965454, + 0.08012507110834122, + 0.2133358120918274, + 0.023288056254386902, + 0.10731146484613419 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 7, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005256996490061283 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static close-up of a glass filled with golden-yellow raw beer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do countless tiny, vibrant bubbles surge rapidly and densely from the bottom of the glass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a creamy, dense white foam explode from the surface and form a soft, billowing cloud-like structure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there warm, soft backlighting that casts a halo and outlines the three-dimensional texture of the foam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style rendered with the surreal quality of a Pixar film?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05499739944934845 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929997444152832 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05499739944934845, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05499739944934845, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07058598846197128, + 0.025210564956068993, + 0.347262978553772, + 0.04492127522826195, + 0.023132987320423126, + 0.04929875582456589, + 0.05904150754213333, + 0.05955880880355835, + 0.05062387138605118, + 0.27036330103874207 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05499739944934845 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_5/index_tensor([7561, 7561])_group_5_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_5/index_tensor([7561, 7561])_group_5_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..e08998df6853455122bb2a2531bce73adfb413b1 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_5/index_tensor([7561, 7561])_group_5_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "dramatic low-angle shot tracks a sleek, metallic charcoal-gray sports car as it explosively takes off from a standstill on a rain-slicked city street at night. The camera, kept close to the ground, highlights the car's aggressive, low-profile silhouette and its wide, performance-oriented tires. The asphalt, a black mirror, gleams against the ambient glow of the streetlights and the vibrant electronic hues of the neon signs in the distance, reflecting the scene with liquid clarity. In a sudden, violent movement, the car's rear tires bite into the wet pavement, instantly sending up a torrent of atomized spray, illuminated by the fiery red glow of the vehicle's full-width LED taillights. The camera pans smoothly as the car accelerates at breakneck speed, its pristine, high-gloss bodywork streaking across the urban backdrop, transforming it into a dynamic blur of light and color, creating an exhilarating, high-energy atmosphere of raw power and speed.", + "seed": 15343, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_5/index_7561_seed_15343_dp_10_rank_20_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.016387243336066604, + "vlm_logprob": -0.016387243336066604, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.399999952316284, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.016387243336066604, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, metallic charcoal-gray sports car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the car start from a standstill and accelerate explosively on a rain-slicked city street at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the car's rear tires shown biting into the wet pavement and sending up a torrent of atomized spray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by the car's fiery red full-width LED taillights reflecting on the wet asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle shot close to the ground and pan smoothly as the car accelerates?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02037792094051838 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.020378112792969 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02037792094051838, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02037792094051838, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.27893587946891785, + 0.08591380715370178, + 0.04376569017767906, + 0.028256718069314957, + 0.047487616539001465, + 0.052294738590717316, + 0.0371018722653389, + 0.08918770402669907, + 0.1344599574804306, + 0.20259611308574677 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02037792094051838 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, metallic charcoal-gray sports car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the car start from a standstill and accelerate explosively on a rain-slicked city street at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the car's rear tires shown biting into the wet pavement and sending up a torrent of atomized spray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by the car's fiery red full-width LED taillights reflecting on the wet asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle shot close to the ground and pan smoothly as the car accelerates?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011089949868619442 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.51108980178833 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011089949868619442, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011089949868619442, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1308359056711197, + 0.1282159835100174, + 0.0435497984290123, + 0.05257323384284973, + 0.07540540397167206, + 0.05610933527350426, + 0.054165635257959366, + 0.20973140001296997, + 0.07470285892486572, + 0.1747104525566101 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011089949868619442 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, metallic charcoal-gray sports car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the car start from a standstill and accelerate explosively on a rain-slicked city street at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the car's rear tires shown biting into the wet pavement and sending up a torrent of atomized spray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by the car's fiery red full-width LED taillights reflecting on the wet asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle shot close to the ground and pan smoothly as the car accelerates?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00249182409606874 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.0024919509887695 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00249182409606874, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00249182409606874, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1545337438583374, + 0.1557164490222931, + 0.03791336715221405, + 0.02347414195537567, + 0.06418795883655548, + 0.037826597690582275, + 0.04238409921526909, + 0.21258027851581573, + 0.06696867942810059, + 0.20441466569900513 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00249182409606874 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, metallic charcoal-gray sports car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the car start from a standstill and accelerate explosively on a rain-slicked city street at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the car's rear tires shown biting into the wet pavement and sending up a torrent of atomized spray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by the car's fiery red full-width LED taillights reflecting on the wet asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle shot close to the ground and pan smoothly as the car accelerates?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01819058135151863 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018190383911133 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01819058135151863, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01819058135151863, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10727780312299728, + 0.056523289531469345, + 0.12939384579658508, + 0.028595054522156715, + 0.057068876922130585, + 0.10363718867301941, + 0.04468714818358421, + 0.0816897302865982, + 0.08758263289928436, + 0.30354446172714233 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01819058135151863 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, metallic charcoal-gray sports car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the car start from a standstill and accelerate explosively on a rain-slicked city street at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the car's rear tires shown biting into the wet pavement and sending up a torrent of atomized spray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by the car's fiery red full-width LED taillights reflecting on the wet asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle shot close to the ground and pan smoothly as the car accelerates?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029785940423607826 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5297858715057373 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029785940423607826, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029785940423607826, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06401441246271133, + 0.10220285505056381, + 0.0570002906024456, + 0.03712032735347748, + 0.03107387013733387, + 0.03650897368788719, + 0.015131278894841671, + 0.15026572346687317, + 0.07134328782558441, + 0.43533894419670105 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029785940423607826 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dramatic low-angle shot tracks a sleek, metallic charcoal-gray sports car as it explosively takes off from a standstill on a rain-slicked city street at night. The camera, kept close to the ground, highlights the car's aggressive, low-profile silhouette and its wide, performance-oriented tires. The asphalt, a black mirror, gleams against the ambient glow of the streetlights and the vibrant electronic hues of the neon signs in the distance, reflecting the scene with liquid clarity. In a sudden, violent movement, the car's rear tires bite into the wet pavement, instantly sending up a torrent of atomized spray, illuminated by the fiery red glow of the vehicle's full-width LED taillights. The camera pans smoothly as the car accelerates at breakneck speed, its pristine, high-gloss bodywork streaking across the urban backdrop, transforming it into a dynamic blur of light and color, creating an exhilarating, high-energy atmosphere of raw power and speed.", + "seed": 15344, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_5/index_7561_seed_15344_dp_10_rank_20_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.13412731913849713, + "vlm_logprob": -0.13412731913849713, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.7, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.13412731913849713, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, metallic charcoal-gray sports car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the car start from a standstill and accelerate explosively on a rain-slicked city street at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the car's rear tires shown biting into the wet pavement and sending up a torrent of atomized spray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by the car's fiery red full-width LED taillights reflecting on the wet asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle shot close to the ground and pan smoothly as the car accelerates?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4295961558818817 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.054596185684204 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.4295961558818817, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.4295961558818817, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09068189561367035, + 0.06836282461881638, + 0.14238204061985016, + 0.12915456295013428, + 0.11624031513929367, + 0.03908143937587738, + 0.19043388962745667, + 0.07548347115516663, + 0.028924500569701195, + 0.11925507336854935 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.4295961558818817 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, metallic charcoal-gray sports car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the car start from a standstill and accelerate explosively on a rain-slicked city street at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the car's rear tires shown biting into the wet pavement and sending up a torrent of atomized spray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by the car's fiery red full-width LED taillights reflecting on the wet asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle shot close to the ground and pan smoothly as the car accelerates?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07905090600252151 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5790510177612305 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07905090600252151, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07905090600252151, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2753044366836548, + 0.08661975711584091, + 0.07838127017021179, + 0.052935950458049774, + 0.14823392033576965, + 0.05719764903187752, + 0.02562204748392105, + 0.04099613428115845, + 0.05599408224225044, + 0.1787148118019104 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07905090600252151 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, metallic charcoal-gray sports car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the car start from a standstill and accelerate explosively on a rain-slicked city street at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the car's rear tires shown biting into the wet pavement and sending up a torrent of atomized spray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by the car's fiery red full-width LED taillights reflecting on the wet asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle shot close to the ground and pan smoothly as the car accelerates?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11297557502985 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.237975597381592 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11297557502985, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11297557502985, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16796401143074036, + 0.06889568269252777, + 0.08610735833644867, + 0.1993214339017868, + 0.15325337648391724, + 0.06253857910633087, + 0.04865463450551033, + 0.0810655802488327, + 0.050032779574394226, + 0.0821666270494461 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11297557502985 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, metallic charcoal-gray sports car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the car start from a standstill and accelerate explosively on a rain-slicked city street at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the car's rear tires shown biting into the wet pavement and sending up a torrent of atomized spray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by the car's fiery red full-width LED taillights reflecting on the wet asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle shot close to the ground and pan smoothly as the car accelerates?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005955924745649099 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130955696105957 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005955924745649099, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005955924745649099, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11674617975950241, + 0.05122319236397743, + 0.04797990247607231, + 0.08000402897596359, + 0.059477243572473526, + 0.06982181966304779, + 0.15939565002918243, + 0.2774900794029236, + 0.04549095034599304, + 0.09237098693847656 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005955924745649099 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, metallic charcoal-gray sports car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the car start from a standstill and accelerate explosively on a rain-slicked city street at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the car's rear tires shown biting into the wet pavement and sending up a torrent of atomized spray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by the car's fiery red full-width LED taillights reflecting on the wet asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle shot close to the ground and pan smoothly as the car accelerates?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04305803403258324 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168057918548584 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04305803403258324, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04305803403258324, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2222704142332077, + 0.0749940350651741, + 0.05382612720131874, + 0.07526309788227081, + 0.12283705174922943, + 0.08913740515708923, + 0.043993301689624786, + 0.1318652629852295, + 0.016519973054528236, + 0.1692933589220047 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04305803403258324 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dramatic low-angle shot tracks a sleek, metallic charcoal-gray sports car as it explosively takes off from a standstill on a rain-slicked city street at night. The camera, kept close to the ground, highlights the car's aggressive, low-profile silhouette and its wide, performance-oriented tires. The asphalt, a black mirror, gleams against the ambient glow of the streetlights and the vibrant electronic hues of the neon signs in the distance, reflecting the scene with liquid clarity. In a sudden, violent movement, the car's rear tires bite into the wet pavement, instantly sending up a torrent of atomized spray, illuminated by the fiery red glow of the vehicle's full-width LED taillights. The camera pans smoothly as the car accelerates at breakneck speed, its pristine, high-gloss bodywork streaking across the urban backdrop, transforming it into a dynamic blur of light and color, creating an exhilarating, high-energy atmosphere of raw power and speed.", + "seed": 15345, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_5/index_7561_seed_15345_dp_11_rank_22_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.01665598712861538, + "vlm_logprob": -0.01665598712861538, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.475, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.01665598712861538, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, metallic charcoal-gray sports car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the car start from a standstill and accelerate explosively on a rain-slicked city street at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the car's rear tires shown biting into the wet pavement and sending up a torrent of atomized spray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by the car's fiery red full-width LED taillights reflecting on the wet asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle shot close to the ground and pan smoothly as the car accelerates?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03901754319667816 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.28901743888855 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03901754319667816, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03901754319667816, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25310394167900085, + 0.050379183143377304, + 0.05999263748526573, + 0.021064886823296547, + 0.06619027256965637, + 0.0480848029255867, + 0.0430527925491333, + 0.032206833362579346, + 0.05883457139134407, + 0.3670900762081146 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03901754319667816 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, metallic charcoal-gray sports car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the car start from a standstill and accelerate explosively on a rain-slicked city street at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the car's rear tires shown biting into the wet pavement and sending up a torrent of atomized spray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by the car's fiery red full-width LED taillights reflecting on the wet asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle shot close to the ground and pan smoothly as the car accelerates?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008650803938508034 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758650779724121 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008650803938508034, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008650803938508034, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11307287961244583, + 0.08166110515594482, + 0.07167641073465347, + 0.12317949533462524, + 0.03961584344506264, + 0.2837100327014923, + 0.05202769860625267, + 0.03578396886587143, + 0.08097780495882034, + 0.11829471588134766 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008650803938508034 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, metallic charcoal-gray sports car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the car start from a standstill and accelerate explosively on a rain-slicked city street at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the car's rear tires shown biting into the wet pavement and sending up a torrent of atomized spray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by the car's fiery red full-width LED taillights reflecting on the wet asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle shot close to the ground and pan smoothly as the car accelerates?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00464016804471612 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379640102386475 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00464016804471612, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00464016804471612, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09340560436248779, + 0.07276802510023117, + 0.09137154370546341, + 0.12994924187660217, + 0.05806364119052887, + 0.18934978544712067, + 0.04880613833665848, + 0.1258523166179657, + 0.0685150995850563, + 0.12191855162382126 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 3, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00464016804471612 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, metallic charcoal-gray sports car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the car start from a standstill and accelerate explosively on a rain-slicked city street at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the car's rear tires shown biting into the wet pavement and sending up a torrent of atomized spray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by the car's fiery red full-width LED taillights reflecting on the wet asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle shot close to the ground and pan smoothly as the car accelerates?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0046363710425794125 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379636287689209 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0046363710425794125, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0046363710425794125, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08439657837152481, + 0.06206892803311348, + 0.03221352770924568, + 0.05218915268778801, + 0.046751465648412704, + 0.39009907841682434, + 0.026555556803941727, + 0.09054992347955704, + 0.05306509882211685, + 0.16211067140102386 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0046363710425794125 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, metallic charcoal-gray sports car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the car start from a standstill and accelerate explosively on a rain-slicked city street at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the car's rear tires shown biting into the wet pavement and sending up a torrent of atomized spray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by the car's fiery red full-width LED taillights reflecting on the wet asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle shot close to the ground and pan smoothly as the car accelerates?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02633504942059517 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513350009918213 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02633504942059517, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02633504942059517, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15694129467010498, + 0.09820234775543213, + 0.0406746007502079, + 0.07927487045526505, + 0.16096951067447662, + 0.0693858191370964, + 0.07071547210216522, + 0.10311219096183777, + 0.15172073245048523, + 0.0690031573176384 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02633504942059517 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dramatic low-angle shot tracks a sleek, metallic charcoal-gray sports car as it explosively takes off from a standstill on a rain-slicked city street at night. The camera, kept close to the ground, highlights the car's aggressive, low-profile silhouette and its wide, performance-oriented tires. The asphalt, a black mirror, gleams against the ambient glow of the streetlights and the vibrant electronic hues of the neon signs in the distance, reflecting the scene with liquid clarity. In a sudden, violent movement, the car's rear tires bite into the wet pavement, instantly sending up a torrent of atomized spray, illuminated by the fiery red glow of the vehicle's full-width LED taillights. The camera pans smoothly as the car accelerates at breakneck speed, its pristine, high-gloss bodywork streaking across the urban backdrop, transforming it into a dynamic blur of light and color, creating an exhilarating, high-energy atmosphere of raw power and speed.", + "seed": 15346, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_5/index_7561_seed_15346_dp_11_rank_22_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.022049028798937796, + "vlm_logprob": -0.022049028798937796, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.925, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.022049028798937796, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, metallic charcoal-gray sports car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the car start from a standstill and accelerate explosively on a rain-slicked city street at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the car's rear tires shown biting into the wet pavement and sending up a torrent of atomized spray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by the car's fiery red full-width LED taillights reflecting on the wet asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle shot close to the ground and pan smoothly as the car accelerates?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03929219767451286 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.289292097091675 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03929219767451286, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03929219767451286, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2561488747596741, + 0.07710806280374527, + 0.05190417170524597, + 0.10707936435937881, + 0.16965559124946594, + 0.02398800291121006, + 0.018610693514347076, + 0.041687946766614914, + 0.22114449739456177, + 0.03267277777194977 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03929219767451286 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, metallic charcoal-gray sports car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the car start from a standstill and accelerate explosively on a rain-slicked city street at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the car's rear tires shown biting into the wet pavement and sending up a torrent of atomized spray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by the car's fiery red full-width LED taillights reflecting on the wet asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle shot close to the ground and pan smoothly as the car accelerates?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020607998594641685 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8956079483032227 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020607998594641685, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020607998594641685, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09793303906917572, + 0.11133520305156708, + 0.14935389161109924, + 0.09393656253814697, + 0.19686183333396912, + 0.050752002745866776, + 0.022719139233231544, + 0.043188855051994324, + 0.13687629997730255, + 0.09704313427209854 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 2, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020607998594641685 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, metallic charcoal-gray sports car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the car start from a standstill and accelerate explosively on a rain-slicked city street at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the car's rear tires shown biting into the wet pavement and sending up a torrent of atomized spray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by the car's fiery red full-width LED taillights reflecting on the wet asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle shot close to the ground and pan smoothly as the car accelerates?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0142059950158 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.2642059326171875 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0142059950158, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0142059950158, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.253797709941864, + 0.0712190791964531, + 0.04115654155611992, + 0.04792677238583565, + 0.10178748518228531, + 0.03525785729289055, + 0.010965690016746521, + 0.06370958685874939, + 0.28930047154426575, + 0.08487886935472488 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0142059950158 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, metallic charcoal-gray sports car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the car start from a standstill and accelerate explosively on a rain-slicked city street at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the car's rear tires shown biting into the wet pavement and sending up a torrent of atomized spray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by the car's fiery red full-width LED taillights reflecting on the wet asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle shot close to the ground and pan smoothly as the car accelerates?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02635931596159935 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513593196868896 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02635931596159935, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02635931596159935, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05360202491283417, + 0.08659908175468445, + 0.09346464276313782, + 0.03739631548523903, + 0.10798341035842896, + 0.02982603758573532, + 0.024760520085692406, + 0.021630901843309402, + 0.4778725206851959, + 0.06686454266309738 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02635931596159935 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, metallic charcoal-gray sports car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the car start from a standstill and accelerate explosively on a rain-slicked city street at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the car's rear tires shown biting into the wet pavement and sending up a torrent of atomized spray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by the car's fiery red full-width LED taillights reflecting on the wet asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle shot close to the ground and pan smoothly as the car accelerates?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00977963674813509 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634779453277588 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00977963674813509, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00977963674813509, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5780193209648132, + 0.05476866289973259, + 0.03487645834684372, + 0.04915281757712364, + 0.07942184060811996, + 0.033568479120731354, + 0.012846711091697216, + 0.02645167149603367, + 0.0987890437245369, + 0.03210499882698059 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00977963674813509 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_6/index_tensor([1082, 1082])_group_6_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_6/index_tensor([1082, 1082])_group_6_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..db9b18c127f0c56ee22476e62eac64cc056e34b1 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_6/index_tensor([1082, 1082])_group_6_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up shot, looking upward from a very low angle, captured in extreme slow motion using high-speed photography, captures a disturbing moment of predation. Amidst the deep, inky blue waters, a massive, cubical jellyfish, its translucent, almost crystalline umbrella-like body emitting a ghostly bioluminescence, becomes the sole source of light in the darkness. Its countless slender yet deadly, thread-like tentacles, densely covered with visible stinging cells, resemble a tightening, shimmering web of death, carefully yet relentlessly entangling a small, silver-scaled fish. As time slows to a crawl, the fish's body undergoes its final, violent twists, each feeble throb of its tail fin stirring up tiny, visible eddies in the surrounding water. Its silently gaping mouth and wide-open eyes are filled with primal terror. The cold bioluminescence illuminates the broken, fleeting flashes on the fish scales and the tiny particles suspended in the water, plunging the background into pure darkness. The entire process vividly displays the prey's final struggle and the irresistible grace of the predator. The picture is full of cruel and beautiful primitive power, deeply revealing the cruelty and majesty of the laws of nature.", + "seed": 4867, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_6/index_1082_seed_4867_dp_12_rank_24_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.021329180058091878, + "vlm_logprob": -0.021329180058091878, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.55, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.021329180058091878, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up looking upward from a very low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in deep, inky blue water with a background of pure darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, cubical jellyfish with a translucent, crystalline umbrella-like body visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a small, silver-scaled fish being entangled by the jellyfish's thread-like tentacles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in extreme slow motion showing the fish's violent twists and visible eddies in the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06448458880186081 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8144845962524414 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06448458880186081, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06448458880186081, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17521211504936218, + 0.15052489936351776, + 0.04239742085337639, + 0.08412057906389236, + 0.09096690267324448, + 0.0533045195043087, + 0.06831298023462296, + 0.06224161013960838, + 0.24883058667182922, + 0.024088308215141296 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06448458880186081 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up looking upward from a very low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in deep, inky blue water with a background of pure darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, cubical jellyfish with a translucent, crystalline umbrella-like body visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a small, silver-scaled fish being entangled by the jellyfish's thread-like tentacles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in extreme slow motion showing the fish's violent twists and visible eddies in the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0046483553014695644 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379648208618164 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0046483553014695644, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0046483553014695644, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0851311981678009, + 0.1481097936630249, + 0.11521686613559723, + 0.06368952244520187, + 0.3566764295101166, + 0.029894527047872543, + 0.028903597965836525, + 0.06600428372621536, + 0.05656612664461136, + 0.04980763792991638 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0046483553014695644 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up looking upward from a very low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in deep, inky blue water with a background of pure darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, cubical jellyfish with a translucent, crystalline umbrella-like body visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a small, silver-scaled fish being entangled by the jellyfish's thread-like tentacles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in extreme slow motion showing the fish's violent twists and visible eddies in the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004097163211554289 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504096984863281 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004097163211554289, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004097163211554289, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1664465069770813, + 0.09699725359678268, + 0.048633839935064316, + 0.05363349989056587, + 0.2581399381160736, + 0.044819265604019165, + 0.029639871791005135, + 0.09285904467105865, + 0.07651082426309586, + 0.13232000172138214 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004097163211554289 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up looking upward from a very low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in deep, inky blue water with a background of pure darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, cubical jellyfish with a translucent, crystalline umbrella-like body visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a small, silver-scaled fish being entangled by the jellyfish's thread-like tentacles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in extreme slow motion showing the fish's violent twists and visible eddies in the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003615273628383875 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628615379333496 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003615273628383875, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003615273628383875, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10460280627012253, + 0.0532396174967289, + 0.032756906002759933, + 0.020920300856232643, + 0.25090354681015015, + 0.03561019524931908, + 0.02793094515800476, + 0.2647029757499695, + 0.03869051858782768, + 0.17064222693443298 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003615273628383875 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up looking upward from a very low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in deep, inky blue water with a background of pure darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, cubical jellyfish with a translucent, crystalline umbrella-like body visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a small, silver-scaled fish being entangled by the jellyfish's thread-like tentacles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in extreme slow motion showing the fish's violent twists and visible eddies in the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029800519347190857 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298004150390625 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029800519347190857, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029800519347190857, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10547637939453125, + 0.13726559281349182, + 0.061372604221105576, + 0.11856584995985031, + 0.14606325328350067, + 0.0554046668112278, + 0.03998111933469772, + 0.12669332325458527, + 0.10331931710243225, + 0.10585790872573853 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029800519347190857 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up shot, looking upward from a very low angle, captured in extreme slow motion using high-speed photography, captures a disturbing moment of predation. Amidst the deep, inky blue waters, a massive, cubical jellyfish, its translucent, almost crystalline umbrella-like body emitting a ghostly bioluminescence, becomes the sole source of light in the darkness. Its countless slender yet deadly, thread-like tentacles, densely covered with visible stinging cells, resemble a tightening, shimmering web of death, carefully yet relentlessly entangling a small, silver-scaled fish. As time slows to a crawl, the fish's body undergoes its final, violent twists, each feeble throb of its tail fin stirring up tiny, visible eddies in the surrounding water. Its silently gaping mouth and wide-open eyes are filled with primal terror. The cold bioluminescence illuminates the broken, fleeting flashes on the fish scales and the tiny particles suspended in the water, plunging the background into pure darkness. The entire process vividly displays the prey's final struggle and the irresistible grace of the predator. The picture is full of cruel and beautiful primitive power, deeply revealing the cruelty and majesty of the laws of nature.", + "seed": 4868, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_6/index_1082_seed_4868_dp_12_rank_24_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.06783374045044184, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06783374045044184, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.375, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06783374045044184, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up looking upward from a very low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in deep, inky blue water with a background of pure darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, cubical jellyfish with a translucent, crystalline umbrella-like body visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a small, silver-scaled fish being entangled by the jellyfish's thread-like tentacles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in extreme slow motion showing the fish's violent twists and visible eddies in the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2325582057237625 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.607558250427246 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2325582057237625, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2325582057237625, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11654125154018402, + 0.08221206814050674, + 0.06397495418787003, + 0.11039586365222931, + 0.05926959961652756, + 0.1452198326587677, + 0.08405616134405136, + 0.0996367335319519, + 0.1429891586303711, + 0.09570439904928207 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2325582057237625 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up looking upward from a very low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in deep, inky blue water with a background of pure darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, cubical jellyfish with a translucent, crystalline umbrella-like body visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a small, silver-scaled fish being entangled by the jellyfish's thread-like tentacles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in extreme slow motion showing the fish's violent twists and visible eddies in the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005267194472253323 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255267143249512 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005267194472253323, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005267194472253323, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1707257628440857, + 0.12055384367704391, + 0.05888513848185539, + 0.1676296591758728, + 0.05421099439263344, + 0.08435200899839401, + 0.10533512383699417, + 0.054313842207193375, + 0.07045174390077591, + 0.11354188621044159 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005267194472253323 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up looking upward from a very low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in deep, inky blue water with a background of pure darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, cubical jellyfish with a translucent, crystalline umbrella-like body visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a small, silver-scaled fish being entangled by the jellyfish's thread-like tentacles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in extreme slow motion showing the fish's violent twists and visible eddies in the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026346080005168915 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.65134596824646 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026346080005168915, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026346080005168915, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3296201825141907, + 0.13687974214553833, + 0.046921536326408386, + 0.13823378086090088, + 0.0858626440167427, + 0.06132819131016731, + 0.057314030826091766, + 0.03737533465027809, + 0.07282490283250809, + 0.03363965079188347 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026346080005168915 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up looking upward from a very low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in deep, inky blue water with a background of pure darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, cubical jellyfish with a translucent, crystalline umbrella-like body visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a small, silver-scaled fish being entangled by the jellyfish's thread-like tentacles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in extreme slow motion showing the fish's violent twists and visible eddies in the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026345962658524513 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.65134596824646 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026345962658524513, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026345962658524513, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17007511854171753, + 0.09528907388448715, + 0.04298023879528046, + 0.08025825023651123, + 0.12426413595676422, + 0.14766497910022736, + 0.15929333865642548, + 0.048280179500579834, + 0.07485060393810272, + 0.057044047862291336 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026345962658524513 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up looking upward from a very low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in deep, inky blue water with a background of pure darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, cubical jellyfish with a translucent, crystalline umbrella-like body visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a small, silver-scaled fish being entangled by the jellyfish's thread-like tentacles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in extreme slow motion showing the fish's violent twists and visible eddies in the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.048651259392499924 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486512184143066 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.048651259392499924, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.048651259392499924, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08769425749778748, + 0.10394280403852463, + 0.04162939265370369, + 0.08745594322681427, + 0.26888948678970337, + 0.1798974871635437, + 0.07118811458349228, + 0.04621238633990288, + 0.03168853744864464, + 0.08140156418085098 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.048651259392499924 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up shot, looking upward from a very low angle, captured in extreme slow motion using high-speed photography, captures a disturbing moment of predation. Amidst the deep, inky blue waters, a massive, cubical jellyfish, its translucent, almost crystalline umbrella-like body emitting a ghostly bioluminescence, becomes the sole source of light in the darkness. Its countless slender yet deadly, thread-like tentacles, densely covered with visible stinging cells, resemble a tightening, shimmering web of death, carefully yet relentlessly entangling a small, silver-scaled fish. As time slows to a crawl, the fish's body undergoes its final, violent twists, each feeble throb of its tail fin stirring up tiny, visible eddies in the surrounding water. Its silently gaping mouth and wide-open eyes are filled with primal terror. The cold bioluminescence illuminates the broken, fleeting flashes on the fish scales and the tiny particles suspended in the water, plunging the background into pure darkness. The entire process vividly displays the prey's final struggle and the irresistible grace of the predator. The picture is full of cruel and beautiful primitive power, deeply revealing the cruelty and majesty of the laws of nature.", + "seed": 4869, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_6/index_1082_seed_4869_dp_13_rank_26_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.03378333505243063, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03378333505243063, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.425, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03378333505243063, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up looking upward from a very low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in deep, inky blue water with a background of pure darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, cubical jellyfish with a translucent, crystalline umbrella-like body visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a small, silver-scaled fish being entangled by the jellyfish's thread-like tentacles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in extreme slow motion showing the fish's violent twists and visible eddies in the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.134297177195549 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1342971324920654 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.134297177195549, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.134297177195549, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15138141810894012, + 0.13343928754329681, + 0.060805562883615494, + 0.04041749984025955, + 0.17581886053085327, + 0.05111822485923767, + 0.05378344655036926, + 0.12511734664440155, + 0.1290663480758667, + 0.07905208319425583 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.134297177195549 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up looking upward from a very low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in deep, inky blue water with a background of pure darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, cubical jellyfish with a translucent, crystalline umbrella-like body visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a small, silver-scaled fish being entangled by the jellyfish's thread-like tentacles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in extreme slow motion showing the fish's violent twists and visible eddies in the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0028330450877547264 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877832889556885 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0028330450877547264, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0028330450877547264, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.150487020611763, + 0.09765035659074783, + 0.08311142772436142, + 0.06917822360992432, + 0.17911456525325775, + 0.030472593382000923, + 0.0654551312327385, + 0.09161515533924103, + 0.08559521287679672, + 0.1473202407360077 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0028330450877547264 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up looking upward from a very low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in deep, inky blue water with a background of pure darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, cubical jellyfish with a translucent, crystalline umbrella-like body visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a small, silver-scaled fish being entangled by the jellyfish's thread-like tentacles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in extreme slow motion showing the fish's violent twists and visible eddies in the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005255336407572031 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255255222320557 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005255336407572031, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005255336407572031, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1073341816663742, + 0.04548113793134689, + 0.10845865309238434, + 0.13531361520290375, + 0.10264116525650024, + 0.055713385343551636, + 0.1155116856098175, + 0.09734581410884857, + 0.07662449032068253, + 0.15557585656642914 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 3, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005255336407572031 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up looking upward from a very low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in deep, inky blue water with a background of pure darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, cubical jellyfish with a translucent, crystalline umbrella-like body visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a small, silver-scaled fish being entangled by the jellyfish's thread-like tentacles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in extreme slow motion showing the fish's violent twists and visible eddies in the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005948459263890982 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130948543548584 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005948459263890982, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005948459263890982, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13439050316810608, + 0.06728671491146088, + 0.04406963661313057, + 0.04935143142938614, + 0.0876268818974495, + 0.057656846940517426, + 0.02587498165667057, + 0.07422050088644028, + 0.21376702189445496, + 0.24575552344322205 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005948459263890982 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up looking upward from a very low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in deep, inky blue water with a background of pure darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, cubical jellyfish with a translucent, crystalline umbrella-like body visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a small, silver-scaled fish being entangled by the jellyfish's thread-like tentacles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in extreme slow motion showing the fish's violent twists and visible eddies in the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0205826573073864 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895582675933838 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0205826573073864, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0205826573073864, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12422245740890503, + 0.07067707180976868, + 0.04499921575188637, + 0.05414881557226181, + 0.1488548368215561, + 0.0473785437643528, + 0.06734516471624374, + 0.19201786816120148, + 0.13197925686836243, + 0.11837676912546158 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 4, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0205826573073864 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up shot, looking upward from a very low angle, captured in extreme slow motion using high-speed photography, captures a disturbing moment of predation. Amidst the deep, inky blue waters, a massive, cubical jellyfish, its translucent, almost crystalline umbrella-like body emitting a ghostly bioluminescence, becomes the sole source of light in the darkness. Its countless slender yet deadly, thread-like tentacles, densely covered with visible stinging cells, resemble a tightening, shimmering web of death, carefully yet relentlessly entangling a small, silver-scaled fish. As time slows to a crawl, the fish's body undergoes its final, violent twists, each feeble throb of its tail fin stirring up tiny, visible eddies in the surrounding water. Its silently gaping mouth and wide-open eyes are filled with primal terror. The cold bioluminescence illuminates the broken, fleeting flashes on the fish scales and the tiny particles suspended in the water, plunging the background into pure darkness. The entire process vividly displays the prey's final struggle and the irresistible grace of the predator. The picture is full of cruel and beautiful primitive power, deeply revealing the cruelty and majesty of the laws of nature.", + "seed": 4870, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_6/index_1082_seed_4870_dp_13_rank_26_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.04469364741817117, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04469364741817117, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.9, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04469364741817117, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up looking upward from a very low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in deep, inky blue water with a background of pure darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, cubical jellyfish with a translucent, crystalline umbrella-like body visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a small, silver-scaled fish being entangled by the jellyfish's thread-like tentacles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in extreme slow motion showing the fish's violent twists and visible eddies in the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.13890428841114044 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.138904333114624 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.13890428841114044, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.13890428841114044, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.35039207339286804, + 0.06752704828977585, + 0.13380947709083557, + 0.08522810786962509, + 0.07277927547693253, + 0.10752056539058685, + 0.040419090539216995, + 0.07112034410238266, + 0.02795378305017948, + 0.043250277638435364 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.13890428841114044 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up looking upward from a very low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in deep, inky blue water with a background of pure darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, cubical jellyfish with a translucent, crystalline umbrella-like body visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a small, silver-scaled fish being entangled by the jellyfish's thread-like tentacles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in extreme slow motion showing the fish's violent twists and visible eddies in the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009810447692871094 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634810447692871 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009810447692871094, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009810447692871094, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05282291769981384, + 0.07484590262174606, + 0.03607505187392235, + 0.03904249519109726, + 0.2687622010707855, + 0.3124118149280548, + 0.0771545022726059, + 0.04759940505027771, + 0.0160501841455698, + 0.0752355232834816 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009810447692871094 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up looking upward from a very low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in deep, inky blue water with a background of pure darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, cubical jellyfish with a translucent, crystalline umbrella-like body visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a small, silver-scaled fish being entangled by the jellyfish's thread-like tentacles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in extreme slow motion showing the fish's violent twists and visible eddies in the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005958413239568472 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130958557128906 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005958413239568472, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005958413239568472, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.400957852602005, + 0.06767191737890244, + 0.08554542064666748, + 0.0304123368114233, + 0.05332089960575104, + 0.0837332233786583, + 0.16389384865760803, + 0.06508911401033401, + 0.025465652346611023, + 0.02390972338616848 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005958413239568472 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up looking upward from a very low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in deep, inky blue water with a background of pure darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, cubical jellyfish with a translucent, crystalline umbrella-like body visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a small, silver-scaled fish being entangled by the jellyfish's thread-like tentacles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in extreme slow motion showing the fish's violent twists and visible eddies in the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006741872988641262 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006742000579834 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006741872988641262, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006741872988641262, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17785991728305817, + 0.066309854388237, + 0.06322774291038513, + 0.02477429434657097, + 0.4225945472717285, + 0.015380164608359337, + 0.029706193134188652, + 0.017571860924363136, + 0.07338933646678925, + 0.10918606072664261 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006741872988641262 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up looking upward from a very low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in deep, inky blue water with a background of pure darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, cubical jellyfish with a translucent, crystalline umbrella-like body visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a small, silver-scaled fish being entangled by the jellyfish's thread-like tentacles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video captured in extreme slow motion showing the fish's violent twists and visible eddies in the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06205321475863457 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120532035827637 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06205321475863457, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06205321475863457, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21328741312026978, + 0.13795346021652222, + 0.03227376192808151, + 0.056642331182956696, + 0.21393342316150665, + 0.04039173200726509, + 0.03534847870469093, + 0.04277238994836807, + 0.09577370434999466, + 0.1316232681274414 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06205321475863457 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_7/index_tensor([1113, 1113])_group_7_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_7/index_tensor([1113, 1113])_group_7_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..28682d135e8d353446e060501cee2ec77ed1136c --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_7/index_tensor([1113, 1113])_group_7_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "In vibrant anime style, a high-angle tracking shot swoops down, keeping pace with a wise strategist, plummeting through a stormy sky. His long silver hair whips violently against his sharp, angular, cell-shadowed face, a look of fierce determination, his jaw set, his piercing eyes narrowed against the raging wind. He clads in a voluminous robe of deep indigo silk, embellished with intricate golden cloud patterns; the fabric snaps and billows around him, defying the relentless force of the wind in chaotic, stylized arcs. One hand, white-knuckled, holds his signature fan, crafted from dark, majestic eagle feathers, firmly in place. The entire scene is dramatically lit from above by a swirling vortex of bruised purple and charcoal gray storm clouds, casting stark, shifting shadows across his features, while intermittent bursts of jagged lightning briefly illuminate the frame. As he falls at a controlled pace, the landscape far below is rendered as an impressionistic, motion-blurred tapestry of deep greens and earthy browns, with faint speed lines emphasizing the dizzying descent, creating an atmosphere of tense and epic critical, high-stakes action.", + "seed": 17969, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_7/index_1113_seed_17969_dp_14_rank_28_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.062266360688954595, + "vlm_logprob": -0.062266360688954595, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.625, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.062266360688954595, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the character depicted as a wise strategist with long silver hair and a sharp, angular face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a voluminous deep indigo silk robe with intricate golden cloud patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character holding a fan made of dark eagle feathers in one hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a stormy sky with swirling purple and gray clouds and jagged lightning?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a high-angle tracking shot that swoops down while keeping pace with the falling character?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22660227119922638 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.60160231590271 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.22660227119922638, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.22660227119922638, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4857812523841858, + 0.02238914743065834, + 0.052143070846796036, + 0.06822763383388519, + 0.06914978474378586, + 0.09419571608304977, + 0.04317258670926094, + 0.053164832293987274, + 0.0399385467171669, + 0.0718374252319336 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.22660227119922638 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the character depicted as a wise strategist with long silver hair and a sharp, angular face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a voluminous deep indigo silk robe with intricate golden cloud patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character holding a fan made of dark eagle feathers in one hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a stormy sky with swirling purple and gray clouds and jagged lightning?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a high-angle tracking shot that swoops down while keeping pace with the falling character?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011080636642873287 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511080741882324 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011080636642873287, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011080636642873287, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19197754561901093, + 0.026710357517004013, + 0.033811669796705246, + 0.027715835720300674, + 0.05135899409651756, + 0.04568633809685707, + 0.1043163612484932, + 0.4413881003856659, + 0.042121756821870804, + 0.03491298481822014 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011080636642873287 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the character depicted as a wise strategist with long silver hair and a sharp, angular face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a voluminous deep indigo silk robe with intricate golden cloud patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character holding a fan made of dark eagle feathers in one hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a stormy sky with swirling purple and gray clouds and jagged lightning?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a high-angle tracking shot that swoops down while keeping pace with the falling character?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05495181307196617 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299519062042236 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05495181307196617, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05495181307196617, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24313659965991974, + 0.05261395871639252, + 0.07716650515794754, + 0.07549741864204407, + 0.06111187860369682, + 0.06903394311666489, + 0.07462017983198166, + 0.16644614934921265, + 0.11977846175432205, + 0.06059489771723747 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05495181307196617 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the character depicted as a wise strategist with long silver hair and a sharp, angular face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a voluminous deep indigo silk robe with intricate golden cloud patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character holding a fan made of dark eagle feathers in one hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a stormy sky with swirling purple and gray clouds and jagged lightning?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a high-angle tracking shot that swoops down while keeping pace with the falling character?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007627174723893404 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882627010345459 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007627174723893404, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007627174723893404, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.47489485144615173, + 0.06128634512424469, + 0.036850228905677795, + 0.03272248059511185, + 0.04246778413653374, + 0.06509019434452057, + 0.12113553285598755, + 0.05193213373422623, + 0.05837687477469444, + 0.05524362623691559 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007627174723893404 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the character depicted as a wise strategist with long silver hair and a sharp, angular face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a voluminous deep indigo silk robe with intricate golden cloud patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character holding a fan made of dark eagle feathers in one hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a stormy sky with swirling purple and gray clouds and jagged lightning?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a high-angle tracking shot that swoops down while keeping pace with the falling character?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011069907806813717 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.5110697746276855 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011069907806813717, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011069907806813717, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2292843759059906, + 0.06914075464010239, + 0.08590526878833771, + 0.07613340020179749, + 0.09588347375392914, + 0.11385421454906464, + 0.17078302800655365, + 0.07956886291503906, + 0.04698551446199417, + 0.03246115893125534 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011069907806813717 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In vibrant anime style, a high-angle tracking shot swoops down, keeping pace with a wise strategist, plummeting through a stormy sky. His long silver hair whips violently against his sharp, angular, cell-shadowed face, a look of fierce determination, his jaw set, his piercing eyes narrowed against the raging wind. He clads in a voluminous robe of deep indigo silk, embellished with intricate golden cloud patterns; the fabric snaps and billows around him, defying the relentless force of the wind in chaotic, stylized arcs. One hand, white-knuckled, holds his signature fan, crafted from dark, majestic eagle feathers, firmly in place. The entire scene is dramatically lit from above by a swirling vortex of bruised purple and charcoal gray storm clouds, casting stark, shifting shadows across his features, while intermittent bursts of jagged lightning briefly illuminate the frame. As he falls at a controlled pace, the landscape far below is rendered as an impressionistic, motion-blurred tapestry of deep greens and earthy browns, with faint speed lines emphasizing the dizzying descent, creating an atmosphere of tense and epic critical, high-stakes action.", + "seed": 17970, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_7/index_1113_seed_17970_dp_14_rank_28_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.02375091230496764, + "vlm_logprob": -0.02375091230496764, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.025, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.02375091230496764, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the character depicted as a wise strategist with long silver hair and a sharp, angular face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a voluminous deep indigo silk robe with intricate golden cloud patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character holding a fan made of dark eagle feathers in one hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a stormy sky with swirling purple and gray clouds and jagged lightning?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a high-angle tracking shot that swoops down while keeping pace with the falling character?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04379311576485634 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168793201446533 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04379311576485634, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04379311576485634, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07340949028730392, + 0.025586867704987526, + 0.052734825760126114, + 0.05068676546216011, + 0.059589795768260956, + 0.0275462344288826, + 0.07060112059116364, + 0.10508403182029724, + 0.46920374035835266, + 0.0655570700764656 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04379311576485634 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the character depicted as a wise strategist with long silver hair and a sharp, angular face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a voluminous deep indigo silk robe with intricate golden cloud patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character holding a fan made of dark eagle feathers in one hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a stormy sky with swirling purple and gray clouds and jagged lightning?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a high-angle tracking shot that swoops down while keeping pace with the falling character?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007633917964994907 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882633686065674 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007633917964994907, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007633917964994907, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.044927917420864105, + 0.04464627429842949, + 0.04906255006790161, + 0.03525467962026596, + 0.04678277298808098, + 0.04380336403846741, + 0.06886164098978043, + 0.03632558509707451, + 0.5610767006874084, + 0.06925855576992035 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007633917964994907 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the character depicted as a wise strategist with long silver hair and a sharp, angular face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a voluminous deep indigo silk robe with intricate golden cloud patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character holding a fan made of dark eagle feathers in one hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a stormy sky with swirling purple and gray clouds and jagged lightning?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a high-angle tracking shot that swoops down while keeping pace with the falling character?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03810384124517441 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881038188934326 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03810384124517441, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03810384124517441, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04843134433031082, + 0.05252349004149437, + 0.05766012892127037, + 0.055651962757110596, + 0.03563597798347473, + 0.03232782334089279, + 0.023283815011382103, + 0.05315818265080452, + 0.5914887189865112, + 0.04983852803707123 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03810384124517441 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the character depicted as a wise strategist with long silver hair and a sharp, angular face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a voluminous deep indigo silk robe with intricate golden cloud patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character holding a fan made of dark eagle feathers in one hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a stormy sky with swirling purple and gray clouds and jagged lightning?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a high-angle tracking shot that swoops down while keeping pace with the falling character?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005946444813162088 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130946636199951 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005946444813162088, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005946444813162088, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.061991337686777115, + 0.05188954994082451, + 0.04587031900882721, + 0.03958791121840477, + 0.161739319562912, + 0.037685003131628036, + 0.0201822929084301, + 0.037325676530599594, + 0.5206765532493591, + 0.023052003234624863 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005946444813162088 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the character depicted as a wise strategist with long silver hair and a sharp, angular face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a voluminous deep indigo silk robe with intricate golden cloud patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character holding a fan made of dark eagle feathers in one hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a stormy sky with swirling purple and gray clouds and jagged lightning?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a high-angle tracking shot that swoops down while keeping pace with the falling character?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023277241736650467 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732772827148438 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023277241736650467, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023277241736650467, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05028047040104866, + 0.06395481526851654, + 0.10368473082780838, + 0.05162804573774338, + 0.04381034895777702, + 0.052464842796325684, + 0.0868728905916214, + 0.011424907483160496, + 0.5085504651069641, + 0.02732844464480877 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 2, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023277241736650467 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In vibrant anime style, a high-angle tracking shot swoops down, keeping pace with a wise strategist, plummeting through a stormy sky. His long silver hair whips violently against his sharp, angular, cell-shadowed face, a look of fierce determination, his jaw set, his piercing eyes narrowed against the raging wind. He clads in a voluminous robe of deep indigo silk, embellished with intricate golden cloud patterns; the fabric snaps and billows around him, defying the relentless force of the wind in chaotic, stylized arcs. One hand, white-knuckled, holds his signature fan, crafted from dark, majestic eagle feathers, firmly in place. The entire scene is dramatically lit from above by a swirling vortex of bruised purple and charcoal gray storm clouds, casting stark, shifting shadows across his features, while intermittent bursts of jagged lightning briefly illuminate the frame. As he falls at a controlled pace, the landscape far below is rendered as an impressionistic, motion-blurred tapestry of deep greens and earthy browns, with faint speed lines emphasizing the dizzying descent, creating an atmosphere of tense and epic critical, high-stakes action.", + "seed": 17971, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_7/index_1113_seed_17971_dp_15_rank_30_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.08900748509913683, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08900748509913683, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.1, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08900748509913683, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the character depicted as a wise strategist with long silver hair and a sharp, angular face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a voluminous deep indigo silk robe with intricate golden cloud patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character holding a fan made of dark eagle feathers in one hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a stormy sky with swirling purple and gray clouds and jagged lightning?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a high-angle tracking shot that swoops down while keeping pace with the falling character?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3143073320388794 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3143073320388794 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3143073320388794, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3143073320388794, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1435079127550125, + 0.022981902584433556, + 0.2915683090686798, + 0.03408694639801979, + 0.352146178483963, + 0.0451645702123642, + 0.025917809456586838, + 0.03225737810134888, + 0.011977443471550941, + 0.04039151594042778 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3143073320388794 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the character depicted as a wise strategist with long silver hair and a sharp, angular face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a voluminous deep indigo silk robe with intricate golden cloud patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character holding a fan made of dark eagle feathers in one hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a stormy sky with swirling purple and gray clouds and jagged lightning?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a high-angle tracking shot that swoops down while keeping pace with the falling character?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011084762401878834 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.51108455657959 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011084762401878834, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011084762401878834, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10970565676689148, + 0.06493684649467468, + 0.19676415622234344, + 0.028159599751234055, + 0.3344404399394989, + 0.036197479814291, + 0.031795796006917953, + 0.04134688153862953, + 0.011121267452836037, + 0.14553184807300568 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 2, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011084762401878834 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the character depicted as a wise strategist with long silver hair and a sharp, angular face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a voluminous deep indigo silk robe with intricate golden cloud patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character holding a fan made of dark eagle feathers in one hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a stormy sky with swirling purple and gray clouds and jagged lightning?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a high-angle tracking shot that swoops down while keeping pace with the falling character?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07002526521682739 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950252056121826 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07002526521682739, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07002526521682739, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14312149584293365, + 0.06163717061281204, + 0.3840821385383606, + 0.037583570927381516, + 0.1652330607175827, + 0.02652428112924099, + 0.05220985785126686, + 0.02481359802186489, + 0.0262259840965271, + 0.07856880128383636 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07002526521682739 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the character depicted as a wise strategist with long silver hair and a sharp, angular face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a voluminous deep indigo silk robe with intricate golden cloud patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character holding a fan made of dark eagle feathers in one hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a stormy sky with swirling purple and gray clouds and jagged lightning?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a high-angle tracking shot that swoops down while keeping pace with the falling character?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02634398825466633 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651344060897827 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02634398825466633, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02634398825466633, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0637512132525444, + 0.05417788401246071, + 0.3522668480873108, + 0.024700243026018143, + 0.19272731244564056, + 0.08538445085287094, + 0.07947586476802826, + 0.08885489404201508, + 0.016196170821785927, + 0.042465124279260635 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 4, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02634398825466633 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the character depicted as a wise strategist with long silver hair and a sharp, angular face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a voluminous deep indigo silk robe with intricate golden cloud patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character holding a fan made of dark eagle feathers in one hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a stormy sky with swirling purple and gray clouds and jagged lightning?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a high-angle tracking shot that swoops down while keeping pace with the falling character?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023276077583432198 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732760906219482 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023276077583432198, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023276077583432198, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1321132630109787, + 0.06732182949781418, + 0.08008629828691483, + 0.04675093665719032, + 0.26517215371131897, + 0.1334068924188614, + 0.11655885726213455, + 0.02162584289908409, + 0.033049944788217545, + 0.10391395539045334 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023276077583432198 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In vibrant anime style, a high-angle tracking shot swoops down, keeping pace with a wise strategist, plummeting through a stormy sky. His long silver hair whips violently against his sharp, angular, cell-shadowed face, a look of fierce determination, his jaw set, his piercing eyes narrowed against the raging wind. He clads in a voluminous robe of deep indigo silk, embellished with intricate golden cloud patterns; the fabric snaps and billows around him, defying the relentless force of the wind in chaotic, stylized arcs. One hand, white-knuckled, holds his signature fan, crafted from dark, majestic eagle feathers, firmly in place. The entire scene is dramatically lit from above by a swirling vortex of bruised purple and charcoal gray storm clouds, casting stark, shifting shadows across his features, while intermittent bursts of jagged lightning briefly illuminate the frame. As he falls at a controlled pace, the landscape far below is rendered as an impressionistic, motion-blurred tapestry of deep greens and earthy browns, with faint speed lines emphasizing the dizzying descent, creating an atmosphere of tense and epic critical, high-stakes action.", + "seed": 17972, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_7/index_1113_seed_17972_dp_15_rank_30_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.0418810598552227, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0418810598552227, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.4, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0418810598552227, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the character depicted as a wise strategist with long silver hair and a sharp, angular face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a voluminous deep indigo silk robe with intricate golden cloud patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character holding a fan made of dark eagle feathers in one hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a stormy sky with swirling purple and gray clouds and jagged lightning?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a high-angle tracking shot that swoops down while keeping pace with the falling character?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10108307003974915 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3510830402374268 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10108307003974915, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10108307003974915, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12216143310070038, + 0.032543253153562546, + 0.03774084150791168, + 0.12857738137245178, + 0.13908544182777405, + 0.042054448276758194, + 0.04021553695201874, + 0.27041730284690857, + 0.04348599165678024, + 0.1437184363603592 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10108307003974915 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the character depicted as a wise strategist with long silver hair and a sharp, angular face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a voluminous deep indigo silk robe with intricate golden cloud patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character holding a fan made of dark eagle feathers in one hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a stormy sky with swirling purple and gray clouds and jagged lightning?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a high-angle tracking shot that swoops down while keeping pace with the falling character?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02329331450164318 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732932567596436 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02329331450164318, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02329331450164318, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25839757919311523, + 0.036771856248378754, + 0.0881332978606224, + 0.06958504021167755, + 0.09770356863737106, + 0.043153245002031326, + 0.04076319560408592, + 0.04540049284696579, + 0.17852728068828583, + 0.14156444370746613 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02329331450164318 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the character depicted as a wise strategist with long silver hair and a sharp, angular face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a voluminous deep indigo silk robe with intricate golden cloud patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character holding a fan made of dark eagle feathers in one hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a stormy sky with swirling purple and gray clouds and jagged lightning?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a high-angle tracking shot that swoops down while keeping pace with the falling character?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04866249859333038 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486624240875244 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04866249859333038, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04866249859333038, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11975310742855072, + 0.05595073103904724, + 0.06830886751413345, + 0.13029032945632935, + 0.1306471973657608, + 0.058773674070835114, + 0.1260499358177185, + 0.03973238542675972, + 0.09578390419483185, + 0.17470991611480713 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04866249859333038 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the character depicted as a wise strategist with long silver hair and a sharp, angular face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a voluminous deep indigo silk robe with intricate golden cloud patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character holding a fan made of dark eagle feathers in one hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a stormy sky with swirling purple and gray clouds and jagged lightning?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a high-angle tracking shot that swoops down while keeping pace with the falling character?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018185080960392952 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018185138702393 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018185080960392952, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018185080960392952, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4499439001083374, + 0.052964575588703156, + 0.20185460150241852, + 0.07354860007762909, + 0.038113366812467575, + 0.05857860669493675, + 0.011035311967134476, + 0.02021576464176178, + 0.056416962295770645, + 0.03732836991548538 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018185080960392952 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the character depicted as a wise strategist with long silver hair and a sharp, angular face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a voluminous deep indigo silk robe with intricate golden cloud patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character holding a fan made of dark eagle feathers in one hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a stormy sky with swirling purple and gray clouds and jagged lightning?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a high-angle tracking shot that swoops down while keeping pace with the falling character?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01818133518099785 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018181324005127 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01818133518099785, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01818133518099785, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17114338278770447, + 0.052954237908124924, + 0.04449601098895073, + 0.0901355966925621, + 0.1221398264169693, + 0.08996517211198807, + 0.13793379068374634, + 0.2269885540008545, + 0.035726387053728104, + 0.028517059981822968 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01818133518099785 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_8/index_tensor([6063, 6063])_group_8_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_8/index_tensor([6063, 6063])_group_8_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..78c25e7e36865cbe1863d8f8ab4920a645295619 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_8/index_tensor([6063, 6063])_group_8_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "close-up, low-angle tracking shot, close to the ground, moves slowly alongside a massive hydralisk. In the warm, soft orange glow of an off-screen bedroom bedside lamp, the alien creature's deep purple and tan chitinous shell reflects a soft sheen, coated in a thin, shimmering mucus. Steadily and powerfully, it crawls across a thick, off-white shag carpet, the soft down flattened and soaked beneath its weight, leaving a trail of damp, shimmering liquid. The high-frame-rate slow-motion shot captures every hypnotic, undulating contraction and relaxation of its serpentine lower body, every inch of muscle undulation and skin stretching visible, imbued with an eerie, biomechanical beauty. In the background, the wooden bed legs and the edges of the draped sheets appear blurred in the shallow depth of field. The entire scene, under the warm lighting, eerily blends the terrifying creature with the peaceful bedroom environment, creating a focused, fascinating and unsettling surreal atmosphere.", + "seed": 30572, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_8/index_6063_seed_30572_dp_16_rank_32_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.358265125984326, + "vlm_logprob": -0.358265125984326, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.8, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.358265125984326, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive hydralisk with deep purple and tan chitinous shell?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the creature crawling on a thick, off-white shag carpet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the creature's shell coated in a thin, shimmering mucus that reflects a soft sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a warm, soft orange glow resembling an off-screen bedside lamp?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up, low-angle tracking shot moving slowly alongside the creature?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.601603627204895 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22660359740257263 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.601603627204895, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -1.601603627204895, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0763576477766037, + 0.04496346414089203, + 0.04753611609339714, + 0.1437108963727951, + 0.13733214139938354, + 0.07248245924711227, + 0.1663803607225418, + 0.12048285454511642, + 0.13012126088142395, + 0.06063282862305641 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.601603627204895 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive hydralisk with deep purple and tan chitinous shell?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the creature crawling on a thick, off-white shag carpet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the creature's shell coated in a thin, shimmering mucus that reflects a soft sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a warm, soft orange glow resembling an off-screen bedside lamp?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up, low-angle tracking shot moving slowly alongside the creature?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07900310307741165 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.579003095626831 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07900310307741165, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07900310307741165, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14973482489585876, + 0.12263033539056778, + 0.05441093444824219, + 0.2766435742378235, + 0.06442209333181381, + 0.04631233215332031, + 0.06933838874101639, + 0.13379546999931335, + 0.03506716340780258, + 0.047644905745983124 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07900310307741165 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive hydralisk with deep purple and tan chitinous shell?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the creature crawling on a thick, off-white shag carpet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the creature's shell coated in a thin, shimmering mucus that reflects a soft sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a warm, soft orange glow resembling an off-screen bedside lamp?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up, low-angle tracking shot moving slowly alongside the creature?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10036671906709671 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3503668308258057 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10036671906709671, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10036671906709671, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05881809443235397, + 0.055233824998140335, + 0.059789128601551056, + 0.12778423726558685, + 0.1293489933013916, + 0.11222365498542786, + 0.06891881674528122, + 0.10379187017679214, + 0.1424901932477951, + 0.14160114526748657 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10036671906709671 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive hydralisk with deep purple and tan chitinous shell?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the creature crawling on a thick, off-white shag carpet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the creature's shell coated in a thin, shimmering mucus that reflects a soft sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a warm, soft orange glow resembling an off-screen bedside lamp?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up, low-angle tracking shot moving slowly alongside the creature?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036176491994410753 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628617763519287 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036176491994410753, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036176491994410753, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14389558136463165, + 0.1414986401796341, + 0.05875558778643608, + 0.1069459468126297, + 0.046085163950920105, + 0.09483636170625687, + 0.06876424700021744, + 0.14614485204219818, + 0.13407687842845917, + 0.05899673327803612 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036176491994410753 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive hydralisk with deep purple and tan chitinous shell?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the creature crawling on a thick, off-white shag carpet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the creature's shell coated in a thin, shimmering mucus that reflects a soft sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a warm, soft orange glow resembling an off-screen bedside lamp?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up, low-angle tracking shot moving slowly alongside the creature?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006734531372785568 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006734371185303 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006734531372785568, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006734531372785568, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05557414889335632, + 0.05441908538341522, + 0.048451028764247894, + 0.12248948961496353, + 0.39078956842422485, + 0.02946319989860058, + 0.045390404760837555, + 0.10403496772050858, + 0.08056456595659256, + 0.06882353127002716 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006734531372785568 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up, low-angle tracking shot, close to the ground, moves slowly alongside a massive hydralisk. In the warm, soft orange glow of an off-screen bedroom bedside lamp, the alien creature's deep purple and tan chitinous shell reflects a soft sheen, coated in a thin, shimmering mucus. Steadily and powerfully, it crawls across a thick, off-white shag carpet, the soft down flattened and soaked beneath its weight, leaving a trail of damp, shimmering liquid. The high-frame-rate slow-motion shot captures every hypnotic, undulating contraction and relaxation of its serpentine lower body, every inch of muscle undulation and skin stretching visible, imbued with an eerie, biomechanical beauty. In the background, the wooden bed legs and the edges of the draped sheets appear blurred in the shallow depth of field. The entire scene, under the warm lighting, eerily blends the terrifying creature with the peaceful bedroom environment, creating a focused, fascinating and unsettling surreal atmosphere.", + "seed": 30573, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_8/index_6063_seed_30573_dp_16_rank_32_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.46521822111681105, + "vlm_logprob": -0.46521822111681105, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.4, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.46521822111681105, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive hydralisk with deep purple and tan chitinous shell?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the creature crawling on a thick, off-white shag carpet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the creature's shell coated in a thin, shimmering mucus that reflects a soft sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a warm, soft orange glow resembling an off-screen bedside lamp?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up, low-angle tracking shot moving slowly alongside the creature?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1277015209198 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12770149111747742 + ], + "logprob_reward": -2.1277015209198, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -2.1277015209198, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08721103519201279, + 0.032422829419374466, + 0.07803245633840561, + 0.06905129551887512, + 0.11828078329563141, + 0.26210111379623413, + 0.06552061438560486, + 0.13813014328479767, + 0.03347138687968254, + 0.11577834188938141 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 7, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -2.1277015209198 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive hydralisk with deep purple and tan chitinous shell?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the creature crawling on a thick, off-white shag carpet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the creature's shell coated in a thin, shimmering mucus that reflects a soft sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a warm, soft orange glow resembling an off-screen bedside lamp?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up, low-angle tracking shot moving slowly alongside the creature?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.089093878865242 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4640939235687256 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.089093878865242, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.089093878865242, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09311877191066742, + 0.029281264171004295, + 0.10918117314577103, + 0.06890861690044403, + 0.11866594851016998, + 0.15415146946907043, + 0.09925559163093567, + 0.08781049400568008, + 0.02288682945072651, + 0.21673990786075592 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.089093878865242 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive hydralisk with deep purple and tan chitinous shell?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the creature crawling on a thick, off-white shag carpet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the creature's shell coated in a thin, shimmering mucus that reflects a soft sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a warm, soft orange glow resembling an off-screen bedside lamp?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up, low-angle tracking shot moving slowly alongside the creature?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0891168862581253 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4641168117523193 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0891168862581253, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0891168862581253, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09012074768543243, + 0.032922495156526566, + 0.06405379623174667, + 0.05797014757990837, + 0.08602136373519897, + 0.19135652482509613, + 0.15622858703136444, + 0.05651542544364929, + 0.04170961305499077, + 0.22310125827789307 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0891168862581253 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive hydralisk with deep purple and tan chitinous shell?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the creature crawling on a thick, off-white shag carpet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the creature's shell coated in a thin, shimmering mucus that reflects a soft sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a warm, soft orange glow resembling an off-screen bedside lamp?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up, low-angle tracking shot moving slowly alongside the creature?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00763652054592967 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882636547088623 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00763652054592967, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00763652054592967, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1025891900062561, + 0.0271974578499794, + 0.049903176724910736, + 0.10811606049537659, + 0.0655590295791626, + 0.27945032715797424, + 0.1085134744644165, + 0.099928118288517, + 0.07145053893327713, + 0.08729267120361328 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 6, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00763652054592967 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive hydralisk with deep purple and tan chitinous shell?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the creature crawling on a thick, off-white shag carpet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the creature's shell coated in a thin, shimmering mucus that reflects a soft sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a warm, soft orange glow resembling an off-screen bedside lamp?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up, low-angle tracking shot moving slowly alongside the creature?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0125422989949584 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387542247772217 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0125422989949584, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0125422989949584, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05140673369169235, + 0.018418507650494576, + 0.09259316325187683, + 0.11193494498729706, + 0.07188121974468231, + 0.26057231426239014, + 0.15781643986701965, + 0.07770854979753494, + 0.05867288261651993, + 0.09899524599313736 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 6, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0125422989949584 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up, low-angle tracking shot, close to the ground, moves slowly alongside a massive hydralisk. In the warm, soft orange glow of an off-screen bedroom bedside lamp, the alien creature's deep purple and tan chitinous shell reflects a soft sheen, coated in a thin, shimmering mucus. Steadily and powerfully, it crawls across a thick, off-white shag carpet, the soft down flattened and soaked beneath its weight, leaving a trail of damp, shimmering liquid. The high-frame-rate slow-motion shot captures every hypnotic, undulating contraction and relaxation of its serpentine lower body, every inch of muscle undulation and skin stretching visible, imbued with an eerie, biomechanical beauty. In the background, the wooden bed legs and the edges of the draped sheets appear blurred in the shallow depth of field. The entire scene, under the warm lighting, eerily blends the terrifying creature with the peaceful bedroom environment, creating a focused, fascinating and unsettling surreal atmosphere.", + "seed": 30574, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_8/index_6063_seed_30574_dp_17_rank_34_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.3187677897978574, + "vlm_logprob": -0.3187677897978574, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.875, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.3187677897978574, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive hydralisk with deep purple and tan chitinous shell?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the creature crawling on a thick, off-white shag carpet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the creature's shell coated in a thin, shimmering mucus that reflects a soft sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a warm, soft orange glow resembling an off-screen bedside lamp?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up, low-angle tracking shot moving slowly alongside the creature?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.407324194908142 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2823241949081421 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.407324194908142, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -1.407324194908142, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.060021668672561646, + 0.01537418644875288, + 0.022626057267189026, + 0.043730784207582474, + 0.052351657301187515, + 0.040109697729349136, + 0.02299610711634159, + 0.13544681668281555, + 0.5126163959503174, + 0.0947265774011612 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.407324194908142 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive hydralisk with deep purple and tan chitinous shell?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the creature crawling on a thick, off-white shag carpet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the creature's shell coated in a thin, shimmering mucus that reflects a soft sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a warm, soft orange glow resembling an off-screen bedside lamp?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up, low-angle tracking shot moving slowly alongside the creature?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06205993518233299 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120598793029785 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06205993518233299, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06205993518233299, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04024925455451012, + 0.021495938301086426, + 0.03284323960542679, + 0.06135953962802887, + 0.06712062656879425, + 0.04756191745400429, + 0.038095712661743164, + 0.043676599860191345, + 0.5394194722175598, + 0.10817769914865494 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06205993518233299 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive hydralisk with deep purple and tan chitinous shell?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the creature crawling on a thick, off-white shag carpet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the creature's shell coated in a thin, shimmering mucus that reflects a soft sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a warm, soft orange glow resembling an off-screen bedside lamp?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up, low-angle tracking shot moving slowly alongside the creature?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11299644410610199 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2379963397979736 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11299644410610199, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11299644410610199, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.036965977400541306, + 0.017722686752676964, + 0.013314721174538136, + 0.07396117597818375, + 0.031507302075624466, + 0.05784058943390846, + 0.048757318407297134, + 0.07002002000808716, + 0.47904103994369507, + 0.17086920142173767 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11299644410610199 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive hydralisk with deep purple and tan chitinous shell?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the creature crawling on a thick, off-white shag carpet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the creature's shell coated in a thin, shimmering mucus that reflects a soft sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a warm, soft orange glow resembling an off-screen bedside lamp?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up, low-angle tracking shot moving slowly alongside the creature?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0028217521030455828 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877821922302246 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0028217521030455828, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0028217521030455828, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05589858442544937, + 0.030010133981704712, + 0.01441441010683775, + 0.04162371903657913, + 0.02982475981116295, + 0.038801174610853195, + 0.04444366693496704, + 0.10363215208053589, + 0.5394775867462158, + 0.10187385231256485 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0028217521030455828 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive hydralisk with deep purple and tan chitinous shell?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the creature crawling on a thick, off-white shag carpet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the creature's shell coated in a thin, shimmering mucus that reflects a soft sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a warm, soft orange glow resembling an off-screen bedside lamp?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up, low-angle tracking shot moving slowly alongside the creature?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008636622689664364 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758636474609375 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008636622689664364, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008636622689664364, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.038208313286304474, + 0.020571229979395866, + 0.018726110458374023, + 0.095890112221241, + 0.06985042989253998, + 0.028225604444742203, + 0.07554865628480911, + 0.08722702413797379, + 0.4214951992034912, + 0.14425727725028992 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008636622689664364 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up, low-angle tracking shot, close to the ground, moves slowly alongside a massive hydralisk. In the warm, soft orange glow of an off-screen bedroom bedside lamp, the alien creature's deep purple and tan chitinous shell reflects a soft sheen, coated in a thin, shimmering mucus. Steadily and powerfully, it crawls across a thick, off-white shag carpet, the soft down flattened and soaked beneath its weight, leaving a trail of damp, shimmering liquid. The high-frame-rate slow-motion shot captures every hypnotic, undulating contraction and relaxation of its serpentine lower body, every inch of muscle undulation and skin stretching visible, imbued with an eerie, biomechanical beauty. In the background, the wooden bed legs and the edges of the draped sheets appear blurred in the shallow depth of field. The entire scene, under the warm lighting, eerily blends the terrifying creature with the peaceful bedroom environment, creating a focused, fascinating and unsettling surreal atmosphere.", + "seed": 30575, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_8/index_6063_seed_30575_dp_17_rank_34_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.32923985468223693, + "vlm_logprob": -0.32923985468223693, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.575, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.32923985468223693, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive hydralisk with deep purple and tan chitinous shell?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the creature crawling on a thick, off-white shag carpet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the creature's shell coated in a thin, shimmering mucus that reflects a soft sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a warm, soft orange glow resembling an off-screen bedside lamp?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up, low-angle tracking shot moving slowly alongside the creature?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4072692394256592 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2822691798210144 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.4072692394256592, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -1.4072692394256592, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13451237976551056, + 0.17247365415096283, + 0.07368031144142151, + 0.08487281948328018, + 0.032848116010427475, + 0.1417473554611206, + 0.13801120221614838, + 0.056503113359212875, + 0.0917617455124855, + 0.07358939945697784 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.4072692394256592 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive hydralisk with deep purple and tan chitinous shell?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the creature crawling on a thick, off-white shag carpet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the creature's shell coated in a thin, shimmering mucus that reflects a soft sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a warm, soft orange glow resembling an off-screen bedside lamp?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up, low-angle tracking shot moving slowly alongside the creature?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1428525447845459 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.017852544784546 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1428525447845459, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1428525447845459, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07585160434246063, + 0.09322909265756607, + 0.03322982043027878, + 0.4487522542476654, + 0.035254620015621185, + 0.15228424966335297, + 0.06082286685705185, + 0.033887989819049835, + 0.04538964480161667, + 0.02129785344004631 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1428525447845459 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive hydralisk with deep purple and tan chitinous shell?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the creature crawling on a thick, off-white shag carpet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the creature's shell coated in a thin, shimmering mucus that reflects a soft sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a warm, soft orange glow resembling an off-screen bedside lamp?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up, low-angle tracking shot moving slowly alongside the creature?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07904352992773056 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5790436267852783 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07904352992773056, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07904352992773056, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06718055158853531, + 0.0220965389162302, + 0.03233068063855171, + 0.4320564568042755, + 0.037892382591962814, + 0.10595797747373581, + 0.10058543086051941, + 0.09683836996555328, + 0.06336987763643265, + 0.04169170930981636 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07904352992773056 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive hydralisk with deep purple and tan chitinous shell?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the creature crawling on a thick, off-white shag carpet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the creature's shell coated in a thin, shimmering mucus that reflects a soft sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a warm, soft orange glow resembling an off-screen bedside lamp?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up, low-angle tracking shot moving slowly alongside the creature?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005954266060143709 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130954265594482 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005954266060143709, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005954266060143709, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10917063802480698, + 0.10154925286769867, + 0.0673149898648262, + 0.2738662660121918, + 0.027085158973932266, + 0.1062440574169159, + 0.08422984182834625, + 0.14067168533802032, + 0.04224049299955368, + 0.047627683728933334 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005954266060143709 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive hydralisk with deep purple and tan chitinous shell?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the creature crawling on a thick, off-white shag carpet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the creature's shell coated in a thin, shimmering mucus that reflects a soft sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a warm, soft orange glow resembling an off-screen bedside lamp?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up, low-angle tracking shot moving slowly alongside the creature?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011079693213105202 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511079788208008 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011079693213105202, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011079693213105202, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0532575361430645, + 0.13385701179504395, + 0.05145556852221489, + 0.3020689785480499, + 0.03178655356168747, + 0.07619184255599976, + 0.21200652420520782, + 0.0811963900923729, + 0.03794223815202713, + 0.020237337797880173 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011079693213105202 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_9/index_tensor([4718, 4718])_group_9_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_9/index_tensor([4718, 4718])_group_9_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..8ef0d9b4f8c2eb5de56145ffbf206bf61c848129 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_9/index_tensor([4718, 4718])_group_9_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "low-angle, medium shot slowly pans right, tracking a mysterious elderly man as he moves with a steady, deliberate gait across the polished obsidian platforms of a futuristic, thorn-filled station. His face is wrinkled and weathered, his enigmatic, deep eyes reflecting the chaotic light around him. His long, dark coat, made of thick, worn synthetic fabric with a high collar, shimmers as he approaches a sleek, silently circling maglev train. As he cautiously steps from the platform into the train, his gaze unwavering, a massive holographic advertisement flickers and pulsates around him, casting a dramatic, shifting cyan and purplish-red glow and deep, shifting shadows across his gaunt features. The seamless metal door immediately begins to slide closed with a soft hiss, and at the last instant, the shifting light pattern is cut off, leaving his figure sharply silhouetted against the glow of the train's interior before the door seals completely. As the maglev train accelerates quickly and silently into the dark tunnel, the camera maintains its position, bathing the now-empty platform in the cold, impersonal light of the holographic advertisements, creating a profound and lingering atmosphere of mystery and loneliness.", + "seed": 26825, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_9/index_4718_seed_26825_dp_18_rank_36_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.08650601003319025, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08650601003319025, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.0, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08650601003319025, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly man with a wrinkled, weathered face and deep eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a long, dark coat made of thick, worn synthetic fabric with a high collar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene take place on polished obsidian platforms within a futuristic, thorn-filled station?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a massive holographic advertisement flicker and pulsate with cyan and purplish-red light, casting shifting shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle medium shot that slowly pans right to track the man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2821640074253082 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4071639776229858 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2821640074253082, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2821640074253082, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2010575234889984, + 0.021783960983157158, + 0.05132452771067619, + 0.11723989993333817, + 0.0766369104385376, + 0.022283321246504784, + 0.039685700088739395, + 0.029720623046159744, + 0.3989675045013428, + 0.04130008444190025 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2821640074253082 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly man with a wrinkled, weathered face and deep eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a long, dark coat made of thick, worn synthetic fabric with a high collar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene take place on polished obsidian platforms within a futuristic, thorn-filled station?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a massive holographic advertisement flicker and pulsate with cyan and purplish-red light, casting shifting shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle medium shot that slowly pans right to track the man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05497900769114494 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929979085922241 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05497900769114494, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05497900769114494, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11048998683691025, + 0.016752419993281364, + 0.05722789838910103, + 0.03474670276045799, + 0.026178432628512383, + 0.01821199804544449, + 0.05843197926878929, + 0.02518520876765251, + 0.6178680658340454, + 0.03490723669528961 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05497900769114494 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly man with a wrinkled, weathered face and deep eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a long, dark coat made of thick, worn synthetic fabric with a high collar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene take place on polished obsidian platforms within a futuristic, thorn-filled station?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a massive holographic advertisement flicker and pulsate with cyan and purplish-red light, casting shifting shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle medium shot that slowly pans right to track the man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.038103725761175156 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881038188934326 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.038103725761175156, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.038103725761175156, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06210705637931824, + 0.032558783888816833, + 0.02084171213209629, + 0.08124849200248718, + 0.023222897201776505, + 0.021315177902579308, + 0.04680218547582626, + 0.024564169347286224, + 0.660662829875946, + 0.026676654815673828 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.038103725761175156 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly man with a wrinkled, weathered face and deep eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a long, dark coat made of thick, worn synthetic fabric with a high collar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene take place on polished obsidian platforms within a futuristic, thorn-filled station?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a massive holographic advertisement flicker and pulsate with cyan and purplish-red light, casting shifting shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle medium shot that slowly pans right to track the man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008644540794193745 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.7586445808410645 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008644540794193745, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008644540794193745, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09003022313117981, + 0.055611129850149155, + 0.02947176992893219, + 0.0598311610519886, + 0.04843546450138092, + 0.06456407159566879, + 0.06273505091667175, + 0.039135631173849106, + 0.5125423669815063, + 0.03764311969280243 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008644540794193745 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly man with a wrinkled, weathered face and deep eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a long, dark coat made of thick, worn synthetic fabric with a high collar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene take place on polished obsidian platforms within a futuristic, thorn-filled station?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a massive holographic advertisement flicker and pulsate with cyan and purplish-red light, casting shifting shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle medium shot that slowly pans right to track the man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04863876849412918 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486388206481934 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04863876849412918, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04863876849412918, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0824761614203453, + 0.03156222403049469, + 0.09050184488296509, + 0.11705444008111954, + 0.0623711496591568, + 0.07654524594545364, + 0.053941234946250916, + 0.06418156623840332, + 0.38000211119651794, + 0.041364047676324844 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04863876849412918 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, medium shot slowly pans right, tracking a mysterious elderly man as he moves with a steady, deliberate gait across the polished obsidian platforms of a futuristic, thorn-filled station. His face is wrinkled and weathered, his enigmatic, deep eyes reflecting the chaotic light around him. His long, dark coat, made of thick, worn synthetic fabric with a high collar, shimmers as he approaches a sleek, silently circling maglev train. As he cautiously steps from the platform into the train, his gaze unwavering, a massive holographic advertisement flickers and pulsates around him, casting a dramatic, shifting cyan and purplish-red glow and deep, shifting shadows across his gaunt features. The seamless metal door immediately begins to slide closed with a soft hiss, and at the last instant, the shifting light pattern is cut off, leaving his figure sharply silhouetted against the glow of the train's interior before the door seals completely. As the maglev train accelerates quickly and silently into the dark tunnel, the camera maintains its position, bathing the now-empty platform in the cold, impersonal light of the holographic advertisements, creating a profound and lingering atmosphere of mystery and loneliness.", + "seed": 26826, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_9/index_4718_seed_26826_dp_18_rank_36_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.033931149542331694, + "vlm_logprob": -0.033931149542331694, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.65, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.033931149542331694, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly man with a wrinkled, weathered face and deep eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a long, dark coat made of thick, worn synthetic fabric with a high collar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene take place on polished obsidian platforms within a futuristic, thorn-filled station?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a massive holographic advertisement flicker and pulsate with cyan and purplish-red light, casting shifting shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle medium shot that slowly pans right to track the man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.043721459805965424 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1687214374542236 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.043721459805965424, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.043721459805965424, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.02643565647304058, + 0.02036600187420845, + 0.014920191839337349, + 0.4241695702075958, + 0.03568825498223305, + 0.3980293571949005, + 0.021792801097035408, + 0.023712417110800743, + 0.00911529827862978, + 0.02577051892876625 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.043721459805965424 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly man with a wrinkled, weathered face and deep eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a long, dark coat made of thick, worn synthetic fabric with a high collar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene take place on polished obsidian platforms within a futuristic, thorn-filled station?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a massive holographic advertisement flicker and pulsate with cyan and purplish-red light, casting shifting shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle medium shot that slowly pans right to track the man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02330111712217331 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773301124572754 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02330111712217331, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02330111712217331, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06268413364887238, + 0.036136988550424576, + 0.0910305380821228, + 0.2652125060558319, + 0.07158280909061432, + 0.2866615056991577, + 0.04115968942642212, + 0.031730372458696365, + 0.022844478487968445, + 0.09095703065395355 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02330111712217331 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly man with a wrinkled, weathered face and deep eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a long, dark coat made of thick, worn synthetic fabric with a high collar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene take place on polished obsidian platforms within a futuristic, thorn-filled station?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a massive holographic advertisement flicker and pulsate with cyan and purplish-red light, casting shifting shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle medium shot that slowly pans right to track the man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04305985942482948 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168059825897217 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04305985942482948, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04305985942482948, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.171006977558136, + 0.0650687962770462, + 0.055943235754966736, + 0.19146014750003815, + 0.1311398446559906, + 0.18325109779834747, + 0.058412253856658936, + 0.034956663846969604, + 0.04401002824306488, + 0.06475090980529785 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04305985942482948 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly man with a wrinkled, weathered face and deep eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a long, dark coat made of thick, worn synthetic fabric with a high collar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene take place on polished obsidian platforms within a futuristic, thorn-filled station?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a massive holographic advertisement flicker and pulsate with cyan and purplish-red light, casting shifting shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle medium shot that slowly pans right to track the man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004639100283384323 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379639148712158 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004639100283384323, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004639100283384323, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12978121638298035, + 0.06113439425826073, + 0.032554373145103455, + 0.14974232017993927, + 0.100508913397789, + 0.2711063325405121, + 0.15906618535518646, + 0.03578993305563927, + 0.020402679219841957, + 0.03991366922855377 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 6, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004639100283384323 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly man with a wrinkled, weathered face and deep eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a long, dark coat made of thick, worn synthetic fabric with a high collar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene take place on polished obsidian platforms within a futuristic, thorn-filled station?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a massive holographic advertisement flicker and pulsate with cyan and purplish-red light, casting shifting shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle medium shot that slowly pans right to track the man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05493421107530594 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.92993426322937 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05493421107530594, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05493421107530594, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08924971520900726, + 0.05569698289036751, + 0.03607824072241783, + 0.18449954688549042, + 0.14603126049041748, + 0.1964828372001648, + 0.13140426576137543, + 0.0696241483092308, + 0.026981957256793976, + 0.0639510303735733 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05493421107530594 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, medium shot slowly pans right, tracking a mysterious elderly man as he moves with a steady, deliberate gait across the polished obsidian platforms of a futuristic, thorn-filled station. His face is wrinkled and weathered, his enigmatic, deep eyes reflecting the chaotic light around him. His long, dark coat, made of thick, worn synthetic fabric with a high collar, shimmers as he approaches a sleek, silently circling maglev train. As he cautiously steps from the platform into the train, his gaze unwavering, a massive holographic advertisement flickers and pulsates around him, casting a dramatic, shifting cyan and purplish-red glow and deep, shifting shadows across his gaunt features. The seamless metal door immediately begins to slide closed with a soft hiss, and at the last instant, the shifting light pattern is cut off, leaving his figure sharply silhouetted against the glow of the train's interior before the door seals completely. As the maglev train accelerates quickly and silently into the dark tunnel, the camera maintains its position, bathing the now-empty platform in the cold, impersonal light of the holographic advertisements, creating a profound and lingering atmosphere of mystery and loneliness.", + "seed": 26827, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_9/index_4718_seed_26827_dp_19_rank_38_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.0315426180139184, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0315426180139184, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.525, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0315426180139184, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly man with a wrinkled, weathered face and deep eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a long, dark coat made of thick, worn synthetic fabric with a high collar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene take place on polished obsidian platforms within a futuristic, thorn-filled station?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a massive holographic advertisement flicker and pulsate with cyan and purplish-red light, casting shifting shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle medium shot that slowly pans right to track the man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04357652738690376 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.16857647895813 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04357652738690376, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04357652738690376, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13512344658374786, + 0.24899126589298248, + 0.051827285438776016, + 0.11190054565668106, + 0.033056143671274185, + 0.06013686954975128, + 0.16522517800331116, + 0.036639504134655, + 0.06071634590625763, + 0.09638338536024094 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04357652738690376 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly man with a wrinkled, weathered face and deep eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a long, dark coat made of thick, worn synthetic fabric with a high collar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene take place on polished obsidian platforms within a futuristic, thorn-filled station?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a massive holographic advertisement flicker and pulsate with cyan and purplish-red light, casting shifting shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle medium shot that slowly pans right to track the man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029816603288054466 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298166275024414 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029816603288054466, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029816603288054466, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12634214758872986, + 0.1582639366388321, + 0.10141005367040634, + 0.07017440348863602, + 0.0516793318092823, + 0.051156941801309586, + 0.20056237280368805, + 0.04249080270528793, + 0.03404224291443825, + 0.1638777256011963 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029816603288054466 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly man with a wrinkled, weathered face and deep eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a long, dark coat made of thick, worn synthetic fabric with a high collar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene take place on polished obsidian platforms within a futuristic, thorn-filled station?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a massive holographic advertisement flicker and pulsate with cyan and purplish-red light, casting shifting shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle medium shot that slowly pans right to track the man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.033696141093969345 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408696174621582 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.033696141093969345, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.033696141093969345, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09603141993284225, + 0.11780983209609985, + 0.04151018708944321, + 0.04295351356267929, + 0.033203087747097015, + 0.07914519309997559, + 0.21467731893062592, + 0.04956480860710144, + 0.06975089758634567, + 0.25535374879837036 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.033696141093969345 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly man with a wrinkled, weathered face and deep eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a long, dark coat made of thick, worn synthetic fabric with a high collar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene take place on polished obsidian platforms within a futuristic, thorn-filled station?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a massive holographic advertisement flicker and pulsate with cyan and purplish-red light, casting shifting shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle medium shot that slowly pans right to track the man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012539944611489773 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387539863586426 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012539944611489773, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012539944611489773, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12247341871261597, + 0.06663893908262253, + 0.05045185983181, + 0.1135145053267479, + 0.06081792339682579, + 0.29103806614875793, + 0.1386156529188156, + 0.031271353363990784, + 0.07817582786083221, + 0.0470024049282074 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012539944611489773 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly man with a wrinkled, weathered face and deep eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a long, dark coat made of thick, worn synthetic fabric with a high collar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene take place on polished obsidian platforms within a futuristic, thorn-filled station?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a massive holographic advertisement flicker and pulsate with cyan and purplish-red light, casting shifting shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle medium shot that slowly pans right to track the man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03808387368917465 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288083791732788 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03808387368917465, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03808387368917465, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06000308692455292, + 0.10383106023073196, + 0.05556298419833183, + 0.10468786954879761, + 0.0934593677520752, + 0.046411287039518356, + 0.18931740522384644, + 0.04528180882334709, + 0.10330081731081009, + 0.19814424216747284 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03808387368917465 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, medium shot slowly pans right, tracking a mysterious elderly man as he moves with a steady, deliberate gait across the polished obsidian platforms of a futuristic, thorn-filled station. His face is wrinkled and weathered, his enigmatic, deep eyes reflecting the chaotic light around him. His long, dark coat, made of thick, worn synthetic fabric with a high collar, shimmers as he approaches a sleek, silently circling maglev train. As he cautiously steps from the platform into the train, his gaze unwavering, a massive holographic advertisement flickers and pulsates around him, casting a dramatic, shifting cyan and purplish-red glow and deep, shifting shadows across his gaunt features. The seamless metal door immediately begins to slide closed with a soft hiss, and at the last instant, the shifting light pattern is cut off, leaving his figure sharply silhouetted against the glow of the train's interior before the door seals completely. As the maglev train accelerates quickly and silently into the dark tunnel, the camera maintains its position, bathing the now-empty platform in the cold, impersonal light of the holographic advertisements, creating a profound and lingering atmosphere of mystery and loneliness.", + "seed": 26828, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000261/group_9/index_4718_seed_26828_dp_19_rank_38_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.04159431774169207, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04159431774169207, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.575, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04159431774169207, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly man with a wrinkled, weathered face and deep eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a long, dark coat made of thick, worn synthetic fabric with a high collar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene take place on polished obsidian platforms within a futuristic, thorn-filled station?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a massive holographic advertisement flicker and pulsate with cyan and purplish-red light, casting shifting shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle medium shot that slowly pans right to track the man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10078176110982895 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3507816791534424 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10078176110982895, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10078176110982895, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11219639331102371, + 0.30210116505622864, + 0.15717360377311707, + 0.045642416924238205, + 0.06767662614583969, + 0.05264788120985031, + 0.09210716933012009, + 0.0457119420170784, + 0.04215450584888458, + 0.08258827775716782 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10078176110982895 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly man with a wrinkled, weathered face and deep eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a long, dark coat made of thick, worn synthetic fabric with a high collar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene take place on polished obsidian platforms within a futuristic, thorn-filled station?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a massive holographic advertisement flicker and pulsate with cyan and purplish-red light, casting shifting shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle medium shot that slowly pans right to track the man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02635025978088379 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651350259780884 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02635025978088379, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02635025978088379, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11039800196886063, + 0.14515209197998047, + 0.25622522830963135, + 0.04409250617027283, + 0.044187869876623154, + 0.05914762616157532, + 0.12505905330181122, + 0.0757749006152153, + 0.04054497554898262, + 0.0994178056716919 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02635025978088379 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly man with a wrinkled, weathered face and deep eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a long, dark coat made of thick, worn synthetic fabric with a high collar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene take place on polished obsidian platforms within a futuristic, thorn-filled station?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a massive holographic advertisement flicker and pulsate with cyan and purplish-red light, casting shifting shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle medium shot that slowly pans right to track the man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03370063751935959 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408700704574585 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03370063751935959, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03370063751935959, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07650282233953476, + 0.07964268326759338, + 0.2766507863998413, + 0.07501568645238876, + 0.08676943182945251, + 0.024276673793792725, + 0.16329681873321533, + 0.07605507969856262, + 0.04143664985895157, + 0.10035329312086105 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03370063751935959 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly man with a wrinkled, weathered face and deep eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a long, dark coat made of thick, worn synthetic fabric with a high collar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene take place on polished obsidian platforms within a futuristic, thorn-filled station?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a massive holographic advertisement flicker and pulsate with cyan and purplish-red light, casting shifting shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle medium shot that slowly pans right to track the man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004095857031643391 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504096031188965 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004095857031643391, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004095857031643391, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1043558418750763, + 0.07574425637722015, + 0.05457989126443863, + 0.06454794853925705, + 0.12344137579202652, + 0.08709155023097992, + 0.2151229828596115, + 0.11721698939800262, + 0.05540575832128525, + 0.10249331593513489 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 4, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004095857031643391 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly man with a wrinkled, weathered face and deep eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a long, dark coat made of thick, worn synthetic fabric with a high collar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene take place on polished obsidian platforms within a futuristic, thorn-filled station?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a massive holographic advertisement flicker and pulsate with cyan and purplish-red light, casting shifting shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle medium shot that slowly pans right to track the man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.043043073266744614 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680431365966797 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.043043073266744614, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.043043073266744614, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1505146324634552, + 0.11441565304994583, + 0.19258250296115875, + 0.06583313643932343, + 0.1392117738723755, + 0.05774230509996414, + 0.1278422772884369, + 0.048050686717033386, + 0.035383615642786026, + 0.06842342764139175 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.043043073266744614 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000272/group_1/index_tensor([1048, 1048])_group_1_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000272/group_1/index_tensor([1048, 1048])_group_1_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..14088f332b48f4c8df7cb64ff0d5d00798402468 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000272/group_1/index_tensor([1048, 1048])_group_1_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "dramatic, high-angle, sweeping drone captures a futuristic, multi-track, long-range, electric snowmobile as it silently glides in a straight line across the endless, untouched Arctic landscape. Rendered in ultra-realistic 3D, the vehicle features a sleek, aerodynamic body constructed from a light-absorbing matte black composite material, with a large, full-color panoramic cockpit at the front. It moves on four independently articulated track pods, which churn the pristine powder below, carving four perfectly parallel paths through the snow. The camera slowly pulls back and ascends, revealing the immense scale of the polar expanse—a vast, rolling ocean of white beneath a pale blue sky. The low-hanging sun, barely out of frame, bathes the scene in a cold, crisp light, casting long, soft blue shadows and creating subtle, mirrored highlights on the sharp edges of the vehicle. The entire scene is imbued with a profound sense of serene isolation and desolate beauty, emphasizing the vehicle's solitary journey through the vast, silent wilderness.", + "seed": 28903, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000272/group_1/index_1048_seed_28903_dp_2_rank_4_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.13363583646714688, + "vlm_logprob": -0.13363583646714688, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.825, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.13363583646714688, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a futuristic electric snowmobile with four independently articulated track pods?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the snowmobile's body constructed from a light-absorbing matte black composite material?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the snowmobile feature a large, full-color panoramic cockpit at the front?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment an endless, untouched Arctic landscape with a vast, rolling ocean of white snow under a pale blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pull back and ascend while the snowmobile moves in a straight line?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.39161229133605957 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1416122913360596 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.39161229133605957, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.39161229133605957, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23405662178993225, + 0.10393591970205307, + 0.2100832313299179, + 0.09446017444133759, + 0.036883193999528885, + 0.025047142058610916, + 0.08620332926511765, + 0.03640568256378174, + 0.08482854068279266, + 0.08809612691402435 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.39161229133605957 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a futuristic electric snowmobile with four independently articulated track pods?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the snowmobile's body constructed from a light-absorbing matte black composite material?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the snowmobile feature a large, full-color panoramic cockpit at the front?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment an endless, untouched Arctic landscape with a vast, rolling ocean of white snow under a pale blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pull back and ascend while the snowmobile moves in a straight line?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.054972801357507706 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299728870391846 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.054972801357507706, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.054972801357507706, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21762390434741974, + 0.178275004029274, + 0.24493011832237244, + 0.060132093727588654, + 0.056537605822086334, + 0.02586124837398529, + 0.03870026767253876, + 0.029428502544760704, + 0.13070249557495117, + 0.01780874654650688 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.054972801357507706 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a futuristic electric snowmobile with four independently articulated track pods?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the snowmobile's body constructed from a light-absorbing matte black composite material?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the snowmobile feature a large, full-color panoramic cockpit at the front?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment an endless, untouched Arctic landscape with a vast, rolling ocean of white snow under a pale blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pull back and ascend while the snowmobile moves in a straight line?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17988239228725433 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8048824071884155 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17988239228725433, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17988239228725433, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.33010685443878174, + 0.18024685978889465, + 0.2572459876537323, + 0.030459731817245483, + 0.04830960929393768, + 0.015322737395763397, + 0.06066277623176575, + 0.02195689268410206, + 0.022218968719244003, + 0.03346957266330719 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17988239228725433 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a futuristic electric snowmobile with four independently articulated track pods?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the snowmobile's body constructed from a light-absorbing matte black composite material?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the snowmobile feature a large, full-color panoramic cockpit at the front?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment an endless, untouched Arctic landscape with a vast, rolling ocean of white snow under a pale blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pull back and ascend while the snowmobile moves in a straight line?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003616461530327797 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.6286163330078125 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003616461530327797, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003616461530327797, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19880451261997223, + 0.08300083875656128, + 0.2965107858181, + 0.05501275509595871, + 0.04978387430310249, + 0.024774253368377686, + 0.07765883207321167, + 0.09001310914754868, + 0.08474563807249069, + 0.03969546779990196 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003616461530327797 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a futuristic electric snowmobile with four independently articulated track pods?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the snowmobile's body constructed from a light-absorbing matte black composite material?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the snowmobile feature a large, full-color panoramic cockpit at the front?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment an endless, untouched Arctic landscape with a vast, rolling ocean of white snow under a pale blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pull back and ascend while the snowmobile moves in a straight line?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03809523582458496 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288095235824585 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03809523582458496, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03809523582458496, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1443176120519638, + 0.1086697205901146, + 0.12374120205640793, + 0.06577897071838379, + 0.10957382619380951, + 0.11595664173364639, + 0.056812264025211334, + 0.06378569453954697, + 0.13553716242313385, + 0.07582691311836243 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03809523582458496 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dramatic, high-angle, sweeping drone captures a futuristic, multi-track, long-range, electric snowmobile as it silently glides in a straight line across the endless, untouched Arctic landscape. Rendered in ultra-realistic 3D, the vehicle features a sleek, aerodynamic body constructed from a light-absorbing matte black composite material, with a large, full-color panoramic cockpit at the front. It moves on four independently articulated track pods, which churn the pristine powder below, carving four perfectly parallel paths through the snow. The camera slowly pulls back and ascends, revealing the immense scale of the polar expanse—a vast, rolling ocean of white beneath a pale blue sky. The low-hanging sun, barely out of frame, bathes the scene in a cold, crisp light, casting long, soft blue shadows and creating subtle, mirrored highlights on the sharp edges of the vehicle. The entire scene is imbued with a profound sense of serene isolation and desolate beauty, emphasizing the vehicle's solitary journey through the vast, silent wilderness.", + "seed": 28904, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000272/group_1/index_1048_seed_28904_dp_2_rank_4_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.23759987717494369, + "vlm_logprob": -0.23759987717494369, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.35, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.23759987717494369, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a futuristic electric snowmobile with four independently articulated track pods?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the snowmobile's body constructed from a light-absorbing matte black composite material?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the snowmobile feature a large, full-color panoramic cockpit at the front?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment an endless, untouched Arctic landscape with a vast, rolling ocean of white snow under a pale blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pull back and ascend while the snowmobile moves in a straight line?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8336541652679443 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5836541652679443 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.8336541652679443, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.8336541652679443, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08902887254953384, + 0.06991145014762878, + 0.057202767580747604, + 0.039402496069669724, + 0.10822600871324539, + 0.11604832112789154, + 0.08904965221881866, + 0.2919429838657379, + 0.043814513832330704, + 0.09537287801504135 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.8336541652679443 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a futuristic electric snowmobile with four independently articulated track pods?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the snowmobile's body constructed from a light-absorbing matte black composite material?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the snowmobile feature a large, full-color panoramic cockpit at the front?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment an endless, untouched Arctic landscape with a vast, rolling ocean of white snow under a pale blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pull back and ascend while the snowmobile moves in a straight line?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10033135116100311 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3503313064575195 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10033135116100311, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10033135116100311, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.116023488342762, + 0.058928925544023514, + 0.13212774693965912, + 0.06490553170442581, + 0.10664180666208267, + 0.05212407931685448, + 0.039037641137838364, + 0.08673160523176193, + 0.25937268137931824, + 0.08410651981830597 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10033135116100311 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a futuristic electric snowmobile with four independently articulated track pods?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the snowmobile's body constructed from a light-absorbing matte black composite material?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the snowmobile feature a large, full-color panoramic cockpit at the front?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment an endless, untouched Arctic landscape with a vast, rolling ocean of white snow under a pale blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pull back and ascend while the snowmobile moves in a straight line?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1798977255821228 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8048977851867676 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1798977255821228, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1798977255821228, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13402022421360016, + 0.13351482152938843, + 0.042028628289699554, + 0.036683231592178345, + 0.06511817872524261, + 0.277973473072052, + 0.02258375845849514, + 0.12913627922534943, + 0.06631212681531906, + 0.09262927621603012 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1798977255821228 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a futuristic electric snowmobile with four independently articulated track pods?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the snowmobile's body constructed from a light-absorbing matte black composite material?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the snowmobile feature a large, full-color panoramic cockpit at the front?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment an endless, untouched Arctic landscape with a vast, rolling ocean of white snow under a pale blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pull back and ascend while the snowmobile moves in a straight line?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004097993951290846 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504097938537598 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004097993951290846, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004097993951290846, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1982654631137848, + 0.08373340219259262, + 0.12640511989593506, + 0.09762681275606155, + 0.16217143833637238, + 0.1315029114484787, + 0.04009728133678436, + 0.04090260714292526, + 0.07768767327070236, + 0.041607316583395004 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004097993951290846 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a futuristic electric snowmobile with four independently articulated track pods?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the snowmobile's body constructed from a light-absorbing matte black composite material?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the snowmobile feature a large, full-color panoramic cockpit at the front?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment an endless, untouched Arctic landscape with a vast, rolling ocean of white snow under a pale blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pull back and ascend while the snowmobile moves in a straight line?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07001814991235733 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950180530548096 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07001814991235733, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07001814991235733, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09229417145252228, + 0.1265074908733368, + 0.1992499679327011, + 0.054658353328704834, + 0.050379835069179535, + 0.07492570579051971, + 0.03184785693883896, + 0.11117736250162125, + 0.18106870353221893, + 0.077890545129776 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07001814991235733 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dramatic, high-angle, sweeping drone captures a futuristic, multi-track, long-range, electric snowmobile as it silently glides in a straight line across the endless, untouched Arctic landscape. Rendered in ultra-realistic 3D, the vehicle features a sleek, aerodynamic body constructed from a light-absorbing matte black composite material, with a large, full-color panoramic cockpit at the front. It moves on four independently articulated track pods, which churn the pristine powder below, carving four perfectly parallel paths through the snow. The camera slowly pulls back and ascends, revealing the immense scale of the polar expanse—a vast, rolling ocean of white beneath a pale blue sky. The low-hanging sun, barely out of frame, bathes the scene in a cold, crisp light, casting long, soft blue shadows and creating subtle, mirrored highlights on the sharp edges of the vehicle. The entire scene is imbued with a profound sense of serene isolation and desolate beauty, emphasizing the vehicle's solitary journey through the vast, silent wilderness.", + "seed": 28905, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000272/group_1/index_1048_seed_28905_dp_3_rank_6_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.1599603159353137, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1599603159353137, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.675, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1599603159353137, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a futuristic electric snowmobile with four independently articulated track pods?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the snowmobile's body constructed from a light-absorbing matte black composite material?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the snowmobile feature a large, full-color panoramic cockpit at the front?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment an endless, untouched Arctic landscape with a vast, rolling ocean of white snow under a pale blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pull back and ascend while the snowmobile moves in a straight line?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5311703681945801 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9061703681945801 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5311703681945801, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5311703681945801, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14657843112945557, + 0.030297718942165375, + 0.05724025517702103, + 0.052600037306547165, + 0.14578646421432495, + 0.27052971720695496, + 0.14793844521045685, + 0.038867294788360596, + 0.06763133406639099, + 0.04253034666180611 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5311703681945801 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a futuristic electric snowmobile with four independently articulated track pods?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the snowmobile's body constructed from a light-absorbing matte black composite material?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the snowmobile feature a large, full-color panoramic cockpit at the front?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment an endless, untouched Arctic landscape with a vast, rolling ocean of white snow under a pale blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pull back and ascend while the snowmobile moves in a straight line?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0549808144569397 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929980754852295 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0549808144569397, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0549808144569397, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12335988879203796, + 0.03743909299373627, + 0.06615851819515228, + 0.05058828368782997, + 0.034613125026226044, + 0.11005745083093643, + 0.21693728864192963, + 0.161794513463974, + 0.15173327922821045, + 0.04731852561235428 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0549808144569397 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a futuristic electric snowmobile with four independently articulated track pods?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the snowmobile's body constructed from a light-absorbing matte black composite material?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the snowmobile feature a large, full-color panoramic cockpit at the front?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment an endless, untouched Arctic landscape with a vast, rolling ocean of white snow under a pale blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pull back and ascend while the snowmobile moves in a straight line?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1603594720363617 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.910359501838684 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1603594720363617, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1603594720363617, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2464785873889923, + 0.055394914001226425, + 0.057127635926008224, + 0.029854873195290565, + 0.11363127827644348, + 0.1430068463087082, + 0.115165114402771, + 0.1241210326552391, + 0.06796026974916458, + 0.04725947976112366 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1603594720363617 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a futuristic electric snowmobile with four independently articulated track pods?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the snowmobile's body constructed from a light-absorbing matte black composite material?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the snowmobile feature a large, full-color panoramic cockpit at the front?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment an endless, untouched Arctic landscape with a vast, rolling ocean of white snow under a pale blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pull back and ascend while the snowmobile moves in a straight line?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00464171078056097 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379641532897949 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00464171078056097, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00464171078056097, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21919234097003937, + 0.030878081917762756, + 0.03894583508372307, + 0.06728009134531021, + 0.07231894880533218, + 0.12844257056713104, + 0.19740161299705505, + 0.05890001356601715, + 0.06290410459041595, + 0.12373640388250351 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00464171078056097 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a futuristic electric snowmobile with four independently articulated track pods?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the snowmobile's body constructed from a light-absorbing matte black composite material?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the snowmobile feature a large, full-color panoramic cockpit at the front?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment an endless, untouched Arctic landscape with a vast, rolling ocean of white snow under a pale blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pull back and ascend while the snowmobile moves in a straight line?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04864921420812607 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048649311065674 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04864921420812607, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04864921420812607, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1514299511909485, + 0.03327452763915062, + 0.04856117442250252, + 0.04831935837864876, + 0.08903870731592178, + 0.08220140635967255, + 0.23327653110027313, + 0.14534920454025269, + 0.06725753843784332, + 0.10129161179065704 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04864921420812607 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dramatic, high-angle, sweeping drone captures a futuristic, multi-track, long-range, electric snowmobile as it silently glides in a straight line across the endless, untouched Arctic landscape. Rendered in ultra-realistic 3D, the vehicle features a sleek, aerodynamic body constructed from a light-absorbing matte black composite material, with a large, full-color panoramic cockpit at the front. It moves on four independently articulated track pods, which churn the pristine powder below, carving four perfectly parallel paths through the snow. The camera slowly pulls back and ascends, revealing the immense scale of the polar expanse—a vast, rolling ocean of white beneath a pale blue sky. The low-hanging sun, barely out of frame, bathes the scene in a cold, crisp light, casting long, soft blue shadows and creating subtle, mirrored highlights on the sharp edges of the vehicle. The entire scene is imbued with a profound sense of serene isolation and desolate beauty, emphasizing the vehicle's solitary journey through the vast, silent wilderness.", + "seed": 28906, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000272/group_1/index_1048_seed_28906_dp_3_rank_6_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.14356013289652764, + "vlm_logprob": -0.14356013289652764, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.8, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.14356013289652764, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a futuristic electric snowmobile with four independently articulated track pods?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the snowmobile's body constructed from a light-absorbing matte black composite material?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the snowmobile feature a large, full-color panoramic cockpit at the front?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment an endless, untouched Arctic landscape with a vast, rolling ocean of white snow under a pale blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pull back and ascend while the snowmobile moves in a straight line?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4846454858779907 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9846454858779907 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.4846454858779907, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.4846454858779907, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10584097355604172, + 0.16655594110488892, + 0.032788850367069244, + 0.09474338591098785, + 0.1713259518146515, + 0.04185293987393379, + 0.04776166006922722, + 0.3149116337299347, + 0.011250942014157772, + 0.012967733666300774 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.4846454858779907 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a futuristic electric snowmobile with four independently articulated track pods?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the snowmobile's body constructed from a light-absorbing matte black composite material?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the snowmobile feature a large, full-color panoramic cockpit at the front?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment an endless, untouched Arctic landscape with a vast, rolling ocean of white snow under a pale blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pull back and ascend while the snowmobile moves in a straight line?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05498611554503441 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929986000061035 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05498611554503441, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05498611554503441, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18934643268585205, + 0.12348037213087082, + 0.10470452904701233, + 0.05427691712975502, + 0.12645693123340607, + 0.06967715173959732, + 0.18887779116630554, + 0.048174142837524414, + 0.05652926117181778, + 0.03847644850611687 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05498611554503441 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a futuristic electric snowmobile with four independently articulated track pods?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the snowmobile's body constructed from a light-absorbing matte black composite material?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the snowmobile feature a large, full-color panoramic cockpit at the front?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment an endless, untouched Arctic landscape with a vast, rolling ocean of white snow under a pale blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pull back and ascend while the snowmobile moves in a straight line?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11293373256921768 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.23793363571167 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11293373256921768, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11293373256921768, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11574166268110275, + 0.2533971667289734, + 0.07560893148183823, + 0.03857087716460228, + 0.10380464047193527, + 0.03101266734302044, + 0.21078167855739594, + 0.07902910560369492, + 0.05783941596746445, + 0.03421387821435928 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11293373256921768 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a futuristic electric snowmobile with four independently articulated track pods?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the snowmobile's body constructed from a light-absorbing matte black composite material?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the snowmobile feature a large, full-color panoramic cockpit at the front?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment an endless, untouched Arctic landscape with a vast, rolling ocean of white snow under a pale blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pull back and ascend while the snowmobile moves in a straight line?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00319589558057487 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753195762634277 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00319589558057487, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00319589558057487, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2014014571905136, + 0.27968695759773254, + 0.08252247422933578, + 0.06137165054678917, + 0.03489243984222412, + 0.04442104697227478, + 0.12422413378953934, + 0.1311696618795395, + 0.024968044832348824, + 0.015342171303927898 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00319589558057487 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a futuristic electric snowmobile with four independently articulated track pods?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the snowmobile's body constructed from a light-absorbing matte black composite material?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the snowmobile feature a large, full-color panoramic cockpit at the front?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment an endless, untouched Arctic landscape with a vast, rolling ocean of white snow under a pale blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pull back and ascend while the snowmobile moves in a straight line?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06203943490982056 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812039375305176 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06203943490982056, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06203943490982056, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07957170158624649, + 0.2076396644115448, + 0.06453285366296768, + 0.03890874609351158, + 0.30289486050605774, + 0.06676950305700302, + 0.13885360956192017, + 0.04686756804585457, + 0.03626781702041626, + 0.017693689092993736 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06203943490982056 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000272/group_10/index_tensor([3233, 3233])_group_10_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000272/group_10/index_tensor([3233, 3233])_group_10_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..4efa96c87898832c2591aa8fa1b549a312b31964 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000272/group_10/index_tensor([3233, 3233])_group_10_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "In the style of a stylish cyberpunk anime, static, eye-level wide-angle shots frame the scene in perfectly symmetrical composition, focusing on a translucent ghost train as it begins to depart from a desolate, rain-slicked platform. The spectral locomotive, perfectly fixed in the center of its frame, is a marvel of ethereal energy; its translucent chassis shimmers and pulsates, its interior lit in electric blue and vibrant fuchsia, revealing faint, glowing circuit patterns within its futuristic form. The platform is a dark, damp expanse of concrete, reflecting the train's otherworldly glow in countless puddles formed by the persistent drizzle. As the train glides silently forward, steadily and inexorably away from the tangible world, its ghostly form begins to dissolve into the dark, holographic void looming at the end of the track. The rear of the train dematerializes first, fragmenting into a cascade of glowing pixels and data streams that merge seamlessly with the inky black, which itself is filled with flickering, shimmering holographic advertisements and cascading strings of cyan digital code, creating a profound atmosphere of futuristic loneliness and mysterious transition.", + "seed": 2767, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000272/group_10/index_3233_seed_2767_dp_20_rank_40_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.2508271185681224, + "vlm_logprob": -0.2508271185681224, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.125, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.2508271185681224, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a stylish cyberpunk anime aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene framed with a static, eye-level wide-angle shot in a perfectly symmetrical composition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a translucent ghost train with an electric blue and vibrant fuchsia interior?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a dark, rain-slicked concrete platform with puddles reflecting the train's glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the train glide forward while its rear dematerializes into glowing pixels and data streams merging with a dark, holographic void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0023731421679258347 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.877373218536377 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0023731421679258347, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0023731421679258347, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14130036532878876, + 0.04156351462006569, + 0.04275217279791832, + 0.18499915301799774, + 0.048282891511917114, + 0.12874001264572144, + 0.12853650748729706, + 0.06341727077960968, + 0.04767213389277458, + 0.17273594439029694 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0023731421679258347 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a stylish cyberpunk anime aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene framed with a static, eye-level wide-angle shot in a perfectly symmetrical composition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a translucent ghost train with an electric blue and vibrant fuchsia interior?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a dark, rain-slicked concrete platform with puddles reflecting the train's glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the train glide forward while its rear dematerializes into glowing pixels and data streams merging with a dark, holographic void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2235530614852905 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.34855303168296814 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.2235530614852905, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -1.2235530614852905, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2100086361169815, + 0.12408967316150665, + 0.09611891955137253, + 0.0698460191488266, + 0.05730622634291649, + 0.061925798654556274, + 0.03440958261489868, + 0.15577703714370728, + 0.09748218953609467, + 0.09303582459688187 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.2235530614852905 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a stylish cyberpunk anime aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene framed with a static, eye-level wide-angle shot in a perfectly symmetrical composition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a translucent ghost train with an electric blue and vibrant fuchsia interior?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a dark, rain-slicked concrete platform with puddles reflecting the train's glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the train glide forward while its rear dematerializes into glowing pixels and data streams merging with a dark, holographic void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0040955008007586 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504095554351807 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0040955008007586, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0040955008007586, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2448420375585556, + 0.1272267997264862, + 0.08778806775808334, + 0.1328393816947937, + 0.04907337203621864, + 0.08371193706989288, + 0.031470172107219696, + 0.07590875029563904, + 0.0752912163734436, + 0.0918482095003128 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0040955008007586 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a stylish cyberpunk anime aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene framed with a static, eye-level wide-angle shot in a perfectly symmetrical composition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a translucent ghost train with an electric blue and vibrant fuchsia interior?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a dark, rain-slicked concrete platform with puddles reflecting the train's glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the train glide forward while its rear dematerializes into glowing pixels and data streams merging with a dark, holographic void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005940163973718882 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130939960479736 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005940163973718882, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005940163973718882, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20921590924263, + 0.1660996526479721, + 0.06618445366621017, + 0.17159412801265717, + 0.05131932720541954, + 0.03800736367702484, + 0.14682713150978088, + 0.044953037053346634, + 0.039633993059396744, + 0.06616497039794922 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005940163973718882 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a stylish cyberpunk anime aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene framed with a static, eye-level wide-angle shot in a perfectly symmetrical composition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a translucent ghost train with an electric blue and vibrant fuchsia interior?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a dark, rain-slicked concrete platform with puddles reflecting the train's glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the train glide forward while its rear dematerializes into glowing pixels and data streams merging with a dark, holographic void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01817372441291809 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018173694610596 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01817372441291809, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01817372441291809, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14213158190250397, + 0.05385411158204079, + 0.0675617977976799, + 0.14048032462596893, + 0.045376069843769073, + 0.029818035662174225, + 0.11173640936613083, + 0.12331970781087875, + 0.06832072138786316, + 0.21740120649337769 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01817372441291809 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In the style of a stylish cyberpunk anime, static, eye-level wide-angle shots frame the scene in perfectly symmetrical composition, focusing on a translucent ghost train as it begins to depart from a desolate, rain-slicked platform. The spectral locomotive, perfectly fixed in the center of its frame, is a marvel of ethereal energy; its translucent chassis shimmers and pulsates, its interior lit in electric blue and vibrant fuchsia, revealing faint, glowing circuit patterns within its futuristic form. The platform is a dark, damp expanse of concrete, reflecting the train's otherworldly glow in countless puddles formed by the persistent drizzle. As the train glides silently forward, steadily and inexorably away from the tangible world, its ghostly form begins to dissolve into the dark, holographic void looming at the end of the track. The rear of the train dematerializes first, fragmenting into a cascade of glowing pixels and data streams that merge seamlessly with the inky black, which itself is filled with flickering, shimmering holographic advertisements and cascading strings of cyan digital code, creating a profound atmosphere of futuristic loneliness and mysterious transition.", + "seed": 2768, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000272/group_10/index_3233_seed_2768_dp_20_rank_40_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.3688689746893942, + "vlm_logprob": -0.3688689746893942, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.675, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.3688689746893942, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a stylish cyberpunk anime aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene framed with a static, eye-level wide-angle shot in a perfectly symmetrical composition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a translucent ghost train with an electric blue and vibrant fuchsia interior?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a dark, rain-slicked concrete platform with puddles reflecting the train's glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the train glide forward while its rear dematerializes into glowing pixels and data streams merging with a dark, holographic void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0026290398091077805 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.377628803253174 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0026290398091077805, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0026290398091077805, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08876129239797592, + 0.23701691627502441, + 0.015929073095321655, + 0.05511730909347534, + 0.022412335500121117, + 0.06636466085910797, + 0.0625004693865776, + 0.08114221692085266, + 0.16044412553310394, + 0.21031160652637482 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0026290398091077805 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a stylish cyberpunk anime aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene framed with a static, eye-level wide-angle shot in a perfectly symmetrical composition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a translucent ghost train with an electric blue and vibrant fuchsia interior?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a dark, rain-slicked concrete platform with puddles reflecting the train's glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the train glide forward while its rear dematerializes into glowing pixels and data streams merging with a dark, holographic void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.804821252822876 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17982123792171478 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.804821252822876, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -1.804821252822876, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0868329331278801, + 0.47220128774642944, + 0.028971364721655846, + 0.03313076123595238, + 0.045897215604782104, + 0.11428657174110413, + 0.040030404925346375, + 0.02420244738459587, + 0.044528067111968994, + 0.10991888493299484 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.804821252822876 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a stylish cyberpunk anime aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene framed with a static, eye-level wide-angle shot in a perfectly symmetrical composition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a translucent ghost train with an electric blue and vibrant fuchsia interior?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a dark, rain-slicked concrete platform with puddles reflecting the train's glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the train glide forward while its rear dematerializes into glowing pixels and data streams merging with a dark, holographic void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005255692172795534 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255255699157715 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005255692172795534, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005255692172795534, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08152355998754501, + 0.4573955237865448, + 0.019381767138838768, + 0.036686837673187256, + 0.03654610738158226, + 0.07284869253635406, + 0.03520655632019043, + 0.033690884709358215, + 0.04320021718740463, + 0.18351982533931732 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005255692172795534 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a stylish cyberpunk anime aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene framed with a static, eye-level wide-angle shot in a perfectly symmetrical composition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a translucent ghost train with an electric blue and vibrant fuchsia interior?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a dark, rain-slicked concrete platform with puddles reflecting the train's glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the train glide forward while its rear dematerializes into glowing pixels and data streams merging with a dark, holographic void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011068493127822876 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511068344116211 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011068493127822876, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011068493127822876, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.28071463108062744, + 0.2853209972381592, + 0.02244015969336033, + 0.027746159583330154, + 0.07481273263692856, + 0.08844802528619766, + 0.03070722706615925, + 0.0344076044857502, + 0.03302682191133499, + 0.12237567454576492 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011068493127822876 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a stylish cyberpunk anime aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene framed with a static, eye-level wide-angle shot in a perfectly symmetrical composition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a translucent ghost train with an electric blue and vibrant fuchsia interior?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a dark, rain-slicked concrete platform with puddles reflecting the train's glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the train glide forward while its rear dematerializes into glowing pixels and data streams merging with a dark, holographic void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02057039551436901 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955702781677246 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02057039551436901, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02057039551436901, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10688810795545578, + 0.30924034118652344, + 0.06025921553373337, + 0.03181030601263046, + 0.03593681752681732, + 0.053760357201099396, + 0.04069134220480919, + 0.0392611064016819, + 0.06219983100891113, + 0.259952574968338 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02057039551436901 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In the style of a stylish cyberpunk anime, static, eye-level wide-angle shots frame the scene in perfectly symmetrical composition, focusing on a translucent ghost train as it begins to depart from a desolate, rain-slicked platform. The spectral locomotive, perfectly fixed in the center of its frame, is a marvel of ethereal energy; its translucent chassis shimmers and pulsates, its interior lit in electric blue and vibrant fuchsia, revealing faint, glowing circuit patterns within its futuristic form. The platform is a dark, damp expanse of concrete, reflecting the train's otherworldly glow in countless puddles formed by the persistent drizzle. As the train glides silently forward, steadily and inexorably away from the tangible world, its ghostly form begins to dissolve into the dark, holographic void looming at the end of the track. The rear of the train dematerializes first, fragmenting into a cascade of glowing pixels and data streams that merge seamlessly with the inky black, which itself is filled with flickering, shimmering holographic advertisements and cascading strings of cyan digital code, creating a profound atmosphere of futuristic loneliness and mysterious transition.", + "seed": 2769, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000272/group_10/index_3233_seed_2769_dp_21_rank_42_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.12115369490347802, + "vlm_logprob": -0.12115369490347802, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.35, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.12115369490347802, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a stylish cyberpunk anime aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene framed with a static, eye-level wide-angle shot in a perfectly symmetrical composition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a translucent ghost train with an electric blue and vibrant fuchsia interior?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a dark, rain-slicked concrete platform with puddles reflecting the train's glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the train glide forward while its rear dematerializes into glowing pixels and data streams merging with a dark, holographic void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0030452092178165913 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.378045082092285 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0030452092178165913, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0030452092178165913, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2555176019668579, + 0.18078505992889404, + 0.03343864902853966, + 0.0714087262749672, + 0.11894311010837555, + 0.06932531297206879, + 0.09779942035675049, + 0.03357706591486931, + 0.07288636267185211, + 0.06631861627101898 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0030452092178165913 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a stylish cyberpunk anime aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene framed with a static, eye-level wide-angle shot in a perfectly symmetrical composition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a translucent ghost train with an electric blue and vibrant fuchsia interior?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a dark, rain-slicked concrete platform with puddles reflecting the train's glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the train glide forward while its rear dematerializes into glowing pixels and data streams merging with a dark, holographic void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.576101541519165 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.826101541519165 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.576101541519165, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.576101541519165, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1593511551618576, + 0.27280089259147644, + 0.055271778255701065, + 0.07092584669589996, + 0.07734663039445877, + 0.07841026782989502, + 0.08601303398609161, + 0.032787781208753586, + 0.10052161663770676, + 0.06657097488641739 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.576101541519165 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a stylish cyberpunk anime aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene framed with a static, eye-level wide-angle shot in a perfectly symmetrical composition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a translucent ghost train with an electric blue and vibrant fuchsia interior?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a dark, rain-slicked concrete platform with puddles reflecting the train's glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the train glide forward while its rear dematerializes into glowing pixels and data streams merging with a dark, holographic void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0019384894985705614 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.251938343048096 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0019384894985705614, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0019384894985705614, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1847178041934967, + 0.1739126443862915, + 0.05837273970246315, + 0.06312670558691025, + 0.07895398885011673, + 0.17838703095912933, + 0.08983705192804337, + 0.04524502903223038, + 0.05976324528455734, + 0.06768383085727692 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0019384894985705614 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a stylish cyberpunk anime aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene framed with a static, eye-level wide-angle shot in a perfectly symmetrical composition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a translucent ghost train with an electric blue and vibrant fuchsia interior?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a dark, rain-slicked concrete platform with puddles reflecting the train's glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the train glide forward while its rear dematerializes into glowing pixels and data streams merging with a dark, holographic void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00862929504364729 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758629322052002 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00862929504364729, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00862929504364729, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16570088267326355, + 0.11134635657072067, + 0.05877986550331116, + 0.039630644023418427, + 0.11528190225362778, + 0.09637855738401413, + 0.04785264655947685, + 0.060831110924482346, + 0.049326542764902115, + 0.25487157702445984 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00862929504364729 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a stylish cyberpunk anime aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene framed with a static, eye-level wide-angle shot in a perfectly symmetrical composition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a translucent ghost train with an electric blue and vibrant fuchsia interior?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a dark, rain-slicked concrete platform with puddles reflecting the train's glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the train glide forward while its rear dematerializes into glowing pixels and data streams merging with a dark, holographic void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01605393923819065 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141054153442383 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01605393923819065, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01605393923819065, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1504768580198288, + 0.0851326659321785, + 0.029635760933160782, + 0.052255723625421524, + 0.09851590543985367, + 0.11676961928606033, + 0.08893679082393646, + 0.061297036707401276, + 0.21382950246334076, + 0.1031501516699791 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01605393923819065 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In the style of a stylish cyberpunk anime, static, eye-level wide-angle shots frame the scene in perfectly symmetrical composition, focusing on a translucent ghost train as it begins to depart from a desolate, rain-slicked platform. The spectral locomotive, perfectly fixed in the center of its frame, is a marvel of ethereal energy; its translucent chassis shimmers and pulsates, its interior lit in electric blue and vibrant fuchsia, revealing faint, glowing circuit patterns within its futuristic form. The platform is a dark, damp expanse of concrete, reflecting the train's otherworldly glow in countless puddles formed by the persistent drizzle. As the train glides silently forward, steadily and inexorably away from the tangible world, its ghostly form begins to dissolve into the dark, holographic void looming at the end of the track. The rear of the train dematerializes first, fragmenting into a cascade of glowing pixels and data streams that merge seamlessly with the inky black, which itself is filled with flickering, shimmering holographic advertisements and cascading strings of cyan digital code, creating a profound atmosphere of futuristic loneliness and mysterious transition.", + "seed": 2770, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000272/group_10/index_3233_seed_2770_dp_21_rank_42_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.3321397613734007, + "vlm_logprob": -0.3321397613734007, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.25, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.3321397613734007, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a stylish cyberpunk anime aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene framed with a static, eye-level wide-angle shot in a perfectly symmetrical composition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a translucent ghost train with an electric blue and vibrant fuchsia interior?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a dark, rain-slicked concrete platform with puddles reflecting the train's glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the train glide forward while its rear dematerializes into glowing pixels and data streams merging with a dark, holographic void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01501226332038641 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.390012264251709 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01501226332038641, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01501226332038641, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12224794924259186, + 0.14011172950267792, + 0.025121357291936874, + 0.029679303988814354, + 0.16252462565898895, + 0.03958136960864067, + 0.27827727794647217, + 0.09952724725008011, + 0.036842234432697296, + 0.06608687341213226 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01501226332038641 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a stylish cyberpunk anime aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene framed with a static, eye-level wide-angle shot in a perfectly symmetrical composition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a translucent ghost train with an electric blue and vibrant fuchsia interior?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a dark, rain-slicked concrete platform with puddles reflecting the train's glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the train glide forward while its rear dematerializes into glowing pixels and data streams merging with a dark, holographic void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6005139350891113 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22551396489143372 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.6005139350891113, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -1.6005139350891113, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13239893317222595, + 0.03476909548044205, + 0.0334748737514019, + 0.03850475326180458, + 0.4173952341079712, + 0.059133730828762054, + 0.05672205239534378, + 0.09242459386587143, + 0.08162517100572586, + 0.053551554679870605 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.6005139350891113 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a stylish cyberpunk anime aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene framed with a static, eye-level wide-angle shot in a perfectly symmetrical composition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a translucent ghost train with an electric blue and vibrant fuchsia interior?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a dark, rain-slicked concrete platform with puddles reflecting the train's glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the train glide forward while its rear dematerializes into glowing pixels and data streams merging with a dark, holographic void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006742938421666622 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.00674295425415 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006742938421666622, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006742938421666622, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09540944546461105, + 0.07859940081834793, + 0.06058170646429062, + 0.06659705191850662, + 0.18419264256954193, + 0.06884421408176422, + 0.21744774281978607, + 0.05808401480317116, + 0.06953242421150208, + 0.1007114052772522 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006742938421666622 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a stylish cyberpunk anime aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene framed with a static, eye-level wide-angle shot in a perfectly symmetrical composition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a translucent ghost train with an electric blue and vibrant fuchsia interior?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a dark, rain-slicked concrete platform with puddles reflecting the train's glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the train glide forward while its rear dematerializes into glowing pixels and data streams merging with a dark, holographic void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029796238988637924 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5297961235046387 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029796238988637924, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029796238988637924, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08751393109560013, + 0.2096032351255417, + 0.07336600124835968, + 0.08771641552448273, + 0.30324214696884155, + 0.04319168999791145, + 0.025149060413241386, + 0.12017122656106949, + 0.019999023526906967, + 0.03004726581275463 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029796238988637924 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a stylish cyberpunk anime aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene framed with a static, eye-level wide-angle shot in a perfectly symmetrical composition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a translucent ghost train with an electric blue and vibrant fuchsia interior?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a dark, rain-slicked concrete platform with puddles reflecting the train's glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the train glide forward while its rear dematerializes into glowing pixels and data streams merging with a dark, holographic void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008633431047201157 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758633613586426 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008633431047201157, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008633431047201157, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18613040447235107, + 0.06224333867430687, + 0.041482169181108475, + 0.04856656864285469, + 0.09348345547914505, + 0.05324151739478111, + 0.07260481268167496, + 0.07047517597675323, + 0.15400995314121246, + 0.21776260435581207 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008633431047201157 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000272/group_11/index_tensor([9648, 9648])_group_11_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000272/group_11/index_tensor([9648, 9648])_group_11_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..d7a6fa9bff6e411f2663d592ba4d8a30d909c4e9 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000272/group_11/index_tensor([9648, 9648])_group_11_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "high-speed, 360-degree orbital shot, executed in extreme slow motion, revolves around the precise impact point, where a magical arrow radiating an intense, pulsating cyan glow strikes its target. The arrow itself has a shaft made of dark, polished wood and a gray goose-feather feather plume, but its crystalline tip is a wellspring of luminous, ethereal energy, leaving a faint, shimmering trail in the air. The target is an ancient, weathered oak surface, its dark, knotty grain marked by deep cracks and a damp sheen, suggesting a massive doorway to a forgotten place. At the moment the glowing arrow makes contact, the wood violently erupts in a time-frozen explosion; a chaotic cloud of sharp, jagged splinters and fine wood dust blasts outward in all directions. The camera's rapid rotation captures this ballet of destruction from every conceivable angle, each individual fragment capturing the arrow's otherworldly glow, creating a tense and dramatic atmosphere of immense, concentrated power and sudden, violent release against a backdrop of deep, uncertain shadows.", + "seed": 20712, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000272/group_11/index_9648_seed_20712_dp_22_rank_44_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.24138252194970847, + "vlm_logprob": -0.24138252194970847, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.675, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.24138252194970847, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a 360-degree orbital shot revolving around the impact point?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video executed in extreme slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the arrow's shaft made of dark, polished wood with a gray goose-feather plume and a crystalline tip radiating cyan glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the target an ancient, weathered oak surface with dark knotty grain, deep cracks, and a damp sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the moment of impact show a time-frozen explosion of sharp, jagged splinters and fine wood dust blasting outward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9049900770187378 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5299900770187378 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.9049900770187378, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.9049900770187378, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1740550547838211, + 0.11447291076183319, + 0.05589272454380989, + 0.06956112384796143, + 0.08750512450933456, + 0.10929311811923981, + 0.05414215475320816, + 0.14889578521251678, + 0.10482130199670792, + 0.08136069029569626 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.9049900770187378 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a 360-degree orbital shot revolving around the impact point?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video executed in extreme slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the arrow's shaft made of dark, polished wood with a gray goose-feather plume and a crystalline tip radiating cyan glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the target an ancient, weathered oak surface with dark knotty grain, deep cracks, and a damp sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the moment of impact show a time-frozen explosion of sharp, jagged splinters and fine wood dust blasting outward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.25208377838134766 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5020837783813477 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.25208377838134766, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.25208377838134766, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5699276924133301, + 0.09160368889570236, + 0.03148210421204567, + 0.030727485194802284, + 0.025107551366090775, + 0.031394872814416885, + 0.025705445557832718, + 0.030866000801324844, + 0.1259273886680603, + 0.03725774213671684 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.25208377838134766 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a 360-degree orbital shot revolving around the impact point?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video executed in extreme slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the arrow's shaft made of dark, polished wood with a gray goose-feather plume and a crystalline tip radiating cyan glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the target an ancient, weathered oak surface with dark knotty grain, deep cracks, and a damp sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the moment of impact show a time-frozen explosion of sharp, jagged splinters and fine wood dust blasting outward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02060951665043831 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8956096172332764 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02060951665043831, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02060951665043831, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.6613724827766418, + 0.057301346212625504, + 0.02047036588191986, + 0.012589176185429096, + 0.018969671800732613, + 0.023932402953505516, + 0.021311892196536064, + 0.01665658690035343, + 0.07648260146379471, + 0.09091336280107498 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02060951665043831 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a 360-degree orbital shot revolving around the impact point?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video executed in extreme slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the arrow's shaft made of dark, polished wood with a gray goose-feather plume and a crystalline tip radiating cyan glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the target an ancient, weathered oak surface with dark knotty grain, deep cracks, and a damp sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the moment of impact show a time-frozen explosion of sharp, jagged splinters and fine wood dust blasting outward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02058989740908146 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895589828491211 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02058989740908146, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02058989740908146, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2990775406360626, + 0.03574110195040703, + 0.030282752588391304, + 0.016848783940076828, + 0.03131891414523125, + 0.042490601539611816, + 0.05515327304601669, + 0.02221718057990074, + 0.1529286801815033, + 0.3139411509037018 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02058989740908146 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a 360-degree orbital shot revolving around the impact point?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video executed in extreme slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the arrow's shaft made of dark, polished wood with a gray goose-feather plume and a crystalline tip radiating cyan glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the target an ancient, weathered oak surface with dark knotty grain, deep cracks, and a damp sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the moment of impact show a time-frozen explosion of sharp, jagged splinters and fine wood dust blasting outward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008639340288937092 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758639335632324 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008639340288937092, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008639340288937092, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4705224931240082, + 0.09168180823326111, + 0.03183850646018982, + 0.03644736111164093, + 0.04380253702402115, + 0.018457798287272453, + 0.043108630925416946, + 0.11190038174390793, + 0.04201846197247505, + 0.11022204905748367 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008639340288937092 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "high-speed, 360-degree orbital shot, executed in extreme slow motion, revolves around the precise impact point, where a magical arrow radiating an intense, pulsating cyan glow strikes its target. The arrow itself has a shaft made of dark, polished wood and a gray goose-feather feather plume, but its crystalline tip is a wellspring of luminous, ethereal energy, leaving a faint, shimmering trail in the air. The target is an ancient, weathered oak surface, its dark, knotty grain marked by deep cracks and a damp sheen, suggesting a massive doorway to a forgotten place. At the moment the glowing arrow makes contact, the wood violently erupts in a time-frozen explosion; a chaotic cloud of sharp, jagged splinters and fine wood dust blasts outward in all directions. The camera's rapid rotation captures this ballet of destruction from every conceivable angle, each individual fragment capturing the arrow's otherworldly glow, creating a tense and dramatic atmosphere of immense, concentrated power and sudden, violent release against a backdrop of deep, uncertain shadows.", + "seed": 20713, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000272/group_11/index_9648_seed_20713_dp_22_rank_44_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.1048693235963583, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1048693235963583, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.525, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1048693235963583, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a 360-degree orbital shot revolving around the impact point?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video executed in extreme slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the arrow's shaft made of dark, polished wood with a gray goose-feather plume and a crystalline tip radiating cyan glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the target an ancient, weathered oak surface with dark knotty grain, deep cracks, and a damp sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the moment of impact show a time-frozen explosion of sharp, jagged splinters and fine wood dust blasting outward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.21440520882606506 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7144051790237427 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.21440520882606506, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.21440520882606506, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12628750503063202, + 0.04717594012618065, + 0.03958119451999664, + 0.15338489413261414, + 0.035675741732120514, + 0.05511775240302086, + 0.262451708316803, + 0.13263024389743805, + 0.11143646389245987, + 0.03625855594873428 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 3, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.21440520882606506 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a 360-degree orbital shot revolving around the impact point?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video executed in extreme slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the arrow's shaft made of dark, polished wood with a gray goose-feather plume and a crystalline tip radiating cyan glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the target an ancient, weathered oak surface with dark knotty grain, deep cracks, and a damp sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the moment of impact show a time-frozen explosion of sharp, jagged splinters and fine wood dust blasting outward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06206553801894188 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812065601348877 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06206553801894188, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06206553801894188, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14142127335071564, + 0.06729637086391449, + 0.07241437584161758, + 0.03889939934015274, + 0.04143897444009781, + 0.045532505959272385, + 0.458024263381958, + 0.06643735617399216, + 0.03575469180941582, + 0.03278079256415367 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06206553801894188 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a 360-degree orbital shot revolving around the impact point?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video executed in extreme slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the arrow's shaft made of dark, polished wood with a gray goose-feather plume and a crystalline tip radiating cyan glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the target an ancient, weathered oak surface with dark knotty grain, deep cracks, and a damp sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the moment of impact show a time-frozen explosion of sharp, jagged splinters and fine wood dust blasting outward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03813367709517479 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881336212158203 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03813367709517479, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03813367709517479, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1277090460062027, + 0.0305029209703207, + 0.07199261337518692, + 0.06651632487773895, + 0.09276793897151947, + 0.05043107271194458, + 0.44277921319007874, + 0.031176915392279625, + 0.04561973735690117, + 0.040504228323698044 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03813367709517479 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a 360-degree orbital shot revolving around the impact point?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video executed in extreme slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the arrow's shaft made of dark, polished wood with a gray goose-feather plume and a crystalline tip radiating cyan glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the target an ancient, weathered oak surface with dark knotty grain, deep cracks, and a damp sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the moment of impact show a time-frozen explosion of sharp, jagged splinters and fine wood dust blasting outward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17994283139705658 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8049428462982178 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17994283139705658, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17994283139705658, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1023196205496788, + 0.05621602013707161, + 0.08411639928817749, + 0.053487833589315414, + 0.04944285377860069, + 0.1249614953994751, + 0.2108108550310135, + 0.08735405653715134, + 0.1023816168308258, + 0.12890924513339996 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17994283139705658 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a 360-degree orbital shot revolving around the impact point?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video executed in extreme slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the arrow's shaft made of dark, polished wood with a gray goose-feather plume and a crystalline tip radiating cyan glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the target an ancient, weathered oak surface with dark knotty grain, deep cracks, and a damp sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the moment of impact show a time-frozen explosion of sharp, jagged splinters and fine wood dust blasting outward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029799362644553185 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529799461364746 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029799362644553185, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029799362644553185, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12417343258857727, + 0.06394320726394653, + 0.037768132984638214, + 0.07746171206235886, + 0.06834948062896729, + 0.037561457604169846, + 0.3173362612724304, + 0.0453229583799839, + 0.10782773047685623, + 0.12025564163923264 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029799362644553185 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "high-speed, 360-degree orbital shot, executed in extreme slow motion, revolves around the precise impact point, where a magical arrow radiating an intense, pulsating cyan glow strikes its target. The arrow itself has a shaft made of dark, polished wood and a gray goose-feather feather plume, but its crystalline tip is a wellspring of luminous, ethereal energy, leaving a faint, shimmering trail in the air. The target is an ancient, weathered oak surface, its dark, knotty grain marked by deep cracks and a damp sheen, suggesting a massive doorway to a forgotten place. At the moment the glowing arrow makes contact, the wood violently erupts in a time-frozen explosion; a chaotic cloud of sharp, jagged splinters and fine wood dust blasts outward in all directions. The camera's rapid rotation captures this ballet of destruction from every conceivable angle, each individual fragment capturing the arrow's otherworldly glow, creating a tense and dramatic atmosphere of immense, concentrated power and sudden, violent release against a backdrop of deep, uncertain shadows.", + "seed": 20714, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000272/group_11/index_9648_seed_20714_dp_23_rank_46_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.28053282760083675, + "vlm_logprob": -0.28053282760083675, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.499999988079071, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.28053282760083675, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a 360-degree orbital shot revolving around the impact point?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video executed in extreme slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the arrow's shaft made of dark, polished wood with a gray goose-feather plume and a crystalline tip radiating cyan glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the target an ancient, weathered oak surface with dark knotty grain, deep cracks, and a damp sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the moment of impact show a time-frozen explosion of sharp, jagged splinters and fine wood dust blasting outward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.0628721714019775 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.43787211179733276 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.0628721714019775, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.6250000596046448, + "token_credit_reward": -1.0628721714019775, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21612702310085297, + 0.2600187063217163, + 0.07800368964672089, + 0.08930978178977966, + 0.04155459254980087, + 0.037711791694164276, + 0.10896695405244827, + 0.07192104309797287, + 0.04618376865983009, + 0.05020258575677872 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.0628721714019775 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a 360-degree orbital shot revolving around the impact point?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video executed in extreme slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the arrow's shaft made of dark, polished wood with a gray goose-feather plume and a crystalline tip radiating cyan glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the target an ancient, weathered oak surface with dark knotty grain, deep cracks, and a damp sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the moment of impact show a time-frozen explosion of sharp, jagged splinters and fine wood dust blasting outward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2813347578048706 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4063347578048706 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2813347578048706, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2813347578048706, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3235538601875305, + 0.12559236586093903, + 0.07865175604820251, + 0.048007234930992126, + 0.06580198556184769, + 0.03800487890839577, + 0.14151111245155334, + 0.0893414318561554, + 0.028859267011284828, + 0.060676153749227524 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2813347578048706 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a 360-degree orbital shot revolving around the impact point?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video executed in extreme slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the arrow's shaft made of dark, polished wood with a gray goose-feather plume and a crystalline tip radiating cyan glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the target an ancient, weathered oak surface with dark knotty grain, deep cracks, and a damp sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the moment of impact show a time-frozen explosion of sharp, jagged splinters and fine wood dust blasting outward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029841480776667595 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529841423034668 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029841480776667595, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029841480776667595, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.32615309953689575, + 0.1397695094347, + 0.043867435306310654, + 0.15109474956989288, + 0.07449517399072647, + 0.02357863448560238, + 0.08645778149366379, + 0.03776092082262039, + 0.03646416962146759, + 0.08035853505134583 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029841480776667595 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a 360-degree orbital shot revolving around the impact point?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video executed in extreme slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the arrow's shaft made of dark, polished wood with a gray goose-feather plume and a crystalline tip radiating cyan glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the target an ancient, weathered oak surface with dark knotty grain, deep cracks, and a damp sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the moment of impact show a time-frozen explosion of sharp, jagged splinters and fine wood dust blasting outward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012547126039862633 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387547016143799 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012547126039862633, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012547126039862633, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11382051557302475, + 0.11990556865930557, + 0.034659214317798615, + 0.06574493646621704, + 0.0678848996758461, + 0.04282219335436821, + 0.4390678107738495, + 0.036900412291288376, + 0.03665199503302574, + 0.042542412877082825 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012547126039862633 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a 360-degree orbital shot revolving around the impact point?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video executed in extreme slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the arrow's shaft made of dark, polished wood with a gray goose-feather plume and a crystalline tip radiating cyan glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the target an ancient, weathered oak surface with dark knotty grain, deep cracks, and a damp sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the moment of impact show a time-frozen explosion of sharp, jagged splinters and fine wood dust blasting outward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016068601980805397 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141068458557129 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016068601980805397, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016068601980805397, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.26221829652786255, + 0.16787183284759521, + 0.144292414188385, + 0.09548071026802063, + 0.06889093667268753, + 0.02114221267402172, + 0.10058596730232239, + 0.03574651852250099, + 0.060274235904216766, + 0.04349690303206444 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016068601980805397 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "high-speed, 360-degree orbital shot, executed in extreme slow motion, revolves around the precise impact point, where a magical arrow radiating an intense, pulsating cyan glow strikes its target. The arrow itself has a shaft made of dark, polished wood and a gray goose-feather feather plume, but its crystalline tip is a wellspring of luminous, ethereal energy, leaving a faint, shimmering trail in the air. The target is an ancient, weathered oak surface, its dark, knotty grain marked by deep cracks and a damp sheen, suggesting a massive doorway to a forgotten place. At the moment the glowing arrow makes contact, the wood violently erupts in a time-frozen explosion; a chaotic cloud of sharp, jagged splinters and fine wood dust blasts outward in all directions. The camera's rapid rotation captures this ballet of destruction from every conceivable angle, each individual fragment capturing the arrow's otherworldly glow, creating a tense and dramatic atmosphere of immense, concentrated power and sudden, violent release against a backdrop of deep, uncertain shadows.", + "seed": 20715, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000272/group_11/index_9648_seed_20715_dp_23_rank_46_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.254128010943532, + "vlm_logprob": -0.254128010943532, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.999999988079071, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.254128010943532, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a 360-degree orbital shot revolving around the impact point?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video executed in extreme slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the arrow's shaft made of dark, polished wood with a gray goose-feather plume and a crystalline tip radiating cyan glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the target an ancient, weathered oak surface with dark knotty grain, deep cracks, and a damp sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the moment of impact show a time-frozen explosion of sharp, jagged splinters and fine wood dust blasting outward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7037667632102966 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7037667632102966 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.7037667632102966, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.7037667632102966, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08058982342481613, + 0.08500128239393234, + 0.29267287254333496, + 0.14074699580669403, + 0.12002682685852051, + 0.054321810603141785, + 0.05561064928770065, + 0.09443692862987518, + 0.050274625420570374, + 0.026318129152059555 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.7037667632102966 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a 360-degree orbital shot revolving around the impact point?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video executed in extreme slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the arrow's shaft made of dark, polished wood with a gray goose-feather plume and a crystalline tip radiating cyan glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the target an ancient, weathered oak surface with dark knotty grain, deep cracks, and a damp sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the moment of impact show a time-frozen explosion of sharp, jagged splinters and fine wood dust blasting outward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.38705188035964966 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1370518207550049 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.38705188035964966, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.7499999403953552, + "token_credit_reward": -0.38705188035964966, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06981667876243591, + 0.19877071678638458, + 0.1712544560432434, + 0.05749354138970375, + 0.04330506920814514, + 0.041773468255996704, + 0.10706456750631332, + 0.12459538877010345, + 0.15341170132160187, + 0.03251441568136215 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.38705188035964966 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a 360-degree orbital shot revolving around the impact point?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video executed in extreme slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the arrow's shaft made of dark, polished wood with a gray goose-feather plume and a crystalline tip radiating cyan glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the target an ancient, weathered oak surface with dark knotty grain, deep cracks, and a damp sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the moment of impact show a time-frozen explosion of sharp, jagged splinters and fine wood dust blasting outward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02638404630124569 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651384115219116 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02638404630124569, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02638404630124569, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0723649263381958, + 0.15649881958961487, + 0.18914109468460083, + 0.18201078474521637, + 0.04281754419207573, + 0.07447338849306107, + 0.08581047505140305, + 0.0989546999335289, + 0.0730476826429367, + 0.02488056570291519 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02638404630124569 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a 360-degree orbital shot revolving around the impact point?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video executed in extreme slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the arrow's shaft made of dark, polished wood with a gray goose-feather plume and a crystalline tip radiating cyan glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the target an ancient, weathered oak surface with dark knotty grain, deep cracks, and a damp sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the moment of impact show a time-frozen explosion of sharp, jagged splinters and fine wood dust blasting outward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12708501517772675 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.127084970474243 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12708501517772675, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12708501517772675, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10388340055942535, + 0.09983092546463013, + 0.2022695094347, + 0.23994296789169312, + 0.032167695462703705, + 0.10481292009353638, + 0.15695138275623322, + 0.028345422819256783, + 0.012038213200867176, + 0.0197575856000185 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12708501517772675 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a 360-degree orbital shot revolving around the impact point?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video executed in extreme slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the arrow's shaft made of dark, polished wood with a gray goose-feather plume and a crystalline tip radiating cyan glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the target an ancient, weathered oak surface with dark knotty grain, deep cracks, and a damp sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the moment of impact show a time-frozen explosion of sharp, jagged splinters and fine wood dust blasting outward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026352349668741226 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513524055480957 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026352349668741226, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026352349668741226, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05989052355289459, + 0.18275536596775055, + 0.3522956669330597, + 0.04118199646472931, + 0.0324631966650486, + 0.10161139070987701, + 0.04986641928553581, + 0.040453165769577026, + 0.0865311548113823, + 0.05295119062066078 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026352349668741226 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000272/group_13/index_tensor([4118, 4118])_group_13_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000272/group_13/index_tensor([4118, 4118])_group_13_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..7bce49a351c12cff6ea3f7c3b18fd30e5bc69cdc --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000272/group_13/index_tensor([4118, 4118])_group_13_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "stunning close-up shot from a sideways angle, using high-speed photography, captures in breathtaking slow motion the plump, ruby-red tomato plummeting downward. Its skin is smooth and glossy, with a tiny, bright green stem still tucked in at the tip. Under the bright, even studio lighting, the tomato appears remarkably fresh and juicy. As the tomato's base touches the crystal-clear, perfectly still water of a transparent glass container below, a silent visual impact erupts: a perfect crown of countless shimmering droplets gracefully scatters in all directions, each droplet distinctly reflecting light. As the tomato slowly sinks into the water, it trails a trail of tiny, shimmering silver bubbles in its wake. Simultaneously, delicate concentric ripples steadily and deliberately spread outward from the point of impact, disturbing the tranquility. The image, framed by a pristine background and vibrant, fresh tones, captures this fleeting moment, creating a pure, dynamic, and Zen-like visual aesthetic.", + "seed": 4340, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000272/group_13/index_4118_seed_4340_dp_26_rank_52_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.006397824222221971, + "vlm_logprob": -0.006397824222221971, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 5.175, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.006397824222221971, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a plump, ruby-red tomato with a smooth, glossy skin and a tiny bright green stem?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot as a close-up from a sideways angle using high-speed photography in slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tomato plummet downward into a transparent glass container filled with crystal-clear, perfectly still water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Upon impact, does a crown of shimmering droplets scatter in all directions while the tomato sinks leaving a trail of silver bubbles and concentric ripples?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by bright, even studio lighting against a pristine background with vibrant, fresh tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009035768918693066 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.759035587310791 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009035768918693066, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009035768918693066, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21658459305763245, + 0.06833537667989731, + 0.04940151050686836, + 0.058464620262384415, + 0.04800692945718765, + 0.17172707617282867, + 0.12333740293979645, + 0.11983606964349747, + 0.09483903646469116, + 0.04946737736463547 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009035768918693066 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a plump, ruby-red tomato with a smooth, glossy skin and a tiny bright green stem?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot as a close-up from a sideways angle using high-speed photography in slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tomato plummet downward into a transparent glass container filled with crystal-clear, perfectly still water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Upon impact, does a crown of shimmering droplets scatter in all directions while the tomato sinks leaving a trail of silver bubbles and concentric ripples?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by bright, even studio lighting against a pristine background with vibrant, fresh tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011083347722887993 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511083126068115 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011083347722887993, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011083347722887993, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18863406777381897, + 0.05581009387969971, + 0.01873917505145073, + 0.027312971651554108, + 0.016750935465097427, + 0.03670695051550865, + 0.1413244903087616, + 0.1435214877128601, + 0.274375855922699, + 0.09682394564151764 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011083347722887993 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a plump, ruby-red tomato with a smooth, glossy skin and a tiny bright green stem?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot as a close-up from a sideways angle using high-speed photography in slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tomato plummet downward into a transparent glass container filled with crystal-clear, perfectly still water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Upon impact, does a crown of shimmering droplets scatter in all directions while the tomato sinks leaving a trail of silver bubbles and concentric ripples?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by bright, even studio lighting against a pristine background with vibrant, fresh tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003616936504840851 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628616809844971 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003616936504840851, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003616936504840851, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20581552386283875, + 0.02082626149058342, + 0.01809663325548172, + 0.025379573926329613, + 0.019348159432411194, + 0.02799108251929283, + 0.21144556999206543, + 0.09155482798814774, + 0.27964556217193604, + 0.0998968705534935 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003616936504840851 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a plump, ruby-red tomato with a smooth, glossy skin and a tiny bright green stem?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot as a close-up from a sideways angle using high-speed photography in slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tomato plummet downward into a transparent glass container filled with crystal-clear, perfectly still water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Upon impact, does a crown of shimmering droplets scatter in all directions while the tomato sinks leaving a trail of silver bubbles and concentric ripples?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by bright, even studio lighting against a pristine background with vibrant, fresh tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036147984210401773 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628614902496338 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036147984210401773, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036147984210401773, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1328909546136856, + 0.03698015585541725, + 0.02996017038822174, + 0.02766469679772854, + 0.020556915551424026, + 0.03827294334769249, + 0.2308032214641571, + 0.09214771538972855, + 0.3056826889514923, + 0.08504056185483932 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036147984210401773 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a plump, ruby-red tomato with a smooth, glossy skin and a tiny bright green stem?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot as a close-up from a sideways angle using high-speed photography in slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tomato plummet downward into a transparent glass container filled with crystal-clear, perfectly still water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Upon impact, does a crown of shimmering droplets scatter in all directions while the tomato sinks leaving a trail of silver bubbles and concentric ripples?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by bright, even studio lighting against a pristine background with vibrant, fresh tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004638269543647766 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379638195037842 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004638269543647766, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004638269543647766, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1085413247346878, + 0.043064557015895844, + 0.023107778280973434, + 0.024617822840809822, + 0.021460622549057007, + 0.026351071894168854, + 0.10965302586555481, + 0.10301946848630905, + 0.2907295227050781, + 0.2494547814130783 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004638269543647766 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "stunning close-up shot from a sideways angle, using high-speed photography, captures in breathtaking slow motion the plump, ruby-red tomato plummeting downward. Its skin is smooth and glossy, with a tiny, bright green stem still tucked in at the tip. Under the bright, even studio lighting, the tomato appears remarkably fresh and juicy. As the tomato's base touches the crystal-clear, perfectly still water of a transparent glass container below, a silent visual impact erupts: a perfect crown of countless shimmering droplets gracefully scatters in all directions, each droplet distinctly reflecting light. As the tomato slowly sinks into the water, it trails a trail of tiny, shimmering silver bubbles in its wake. Simultaneously, delicate concentric ripples steadily and deliberately spread outward from the point of impact, disturbing the tranquility. The image, framed by a pristine background and vibrant, fresh tones, captures this fleeting moment, creating a pure, dynamic, and Zen-like visual aesthetic.", + "seed": 4341, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000272/group_13/index_4118_seed_4341_dp_26_rank_52_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.006074235076084733, + "vlm_logprob": -0.006074235076084733, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 5.4, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.006074235076084733, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a plump, ruby-red tomato with a smooth, glossy skin and a tiny bright green stem?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot as a close-up from a sideways angle using high-speed photography in slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tomato plummet downward into a transparent glass container filled with crystal-clear, perfectly still water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Upon impact, does a crown of shimmering droplets scatter in all directions while the tomato sinks leaving a trail of silver bubbles and concentric ripples?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by bright, even studio lighting against a pristine background with vibrant, fresh tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005701114423573017 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255701065063477 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005701114423573017, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005701114423573017, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11837668716907501, + 0.06511633843183517, + 0.2643173336982727, + 0.0673530250787735, + 0.12912704050540924, + 0.08842071890830994, + 0.04545700550079346, + 0.06895476579666138, + 0.06328313797712326, + 0.08959401398897171 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005701114423573017 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a plump, ruby-red tomato with a smooth, glossy skin and a tiny bright green stem?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot as a close-up from a sideways angle using high-speed photography in slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tomato plummet downward into a transparent glass container filled with crystal-clear, perfectly still water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Upon impact, does a crown of shimmering droplets scatter in all directions while the tomato sinks leaving a trail of silver bubbles and concentric ripples?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by bright, even studio lighting against a pristine background with vibrant, fresh tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016081271693110466 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.1410813331604 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016081271693110466, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016081271693110466, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11021336168050766, + 0.13495604693889618, + 0.20775192975997925, + 0.08260251581668854, + 0.10610562562942505, + 0.2035352736711502, + 0.028054600581526756, + 0.04163173958659172, + 0.03617328405380249, + 0.04897566884756088 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016081271693110466 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a plump, ruby-red tomato with a smooth, glossy skin and a tiny bright green stem?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot as a close-up from a sideways angle using high-speed photography in slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tomato plummet downward into a transparent glass container filled with crystal-clear, perfectly still water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Upon impact, does a crown of shimmering droplets scatter in all directions while the tomato sinks leaving a trail of silver bubbles and concentric ripples?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by bright, even studio lighting against a pristine background with vibrant, fresh tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0031947072129696608 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753194808959961 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0031947072129696608, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0031947072129696608, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11051904410123825, + 0.12809035181999207, + 0.2851417660713196, + 0.0915190801024437, + 0.06803227216005325, + 0.10833133012056351, + 0.06832031905651093, + 0.02316720224916935, + 0.028482170775532722, + 0.08839640766382217 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0031947072129696608 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a plump, ruby-red tomato with a smooth, glossy skin and a tiny bright green stem?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot as a close-up from a sideways angle using high-speed photography in slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tomato plummet downward into a transparent glass container filled with crystal-clear, perfectly still water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Upon impact, does a crown of shimmering droplets scatter in all directions while the tomato sinks leaving a trail of silver bubbles and concentric ripples?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by bright, even studio lighting against a pristine background with vibrant, fresh tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0021990183740854263 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127199172973633 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0021990183740854263, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0021990183740854263, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13558202981948853, + 0.04154006391763687, + 0.16849477589130402, + 0.09349576383829117, + 0.05601363629102707, + 0.0667530968785286, + 0.06021440029144287, + 0.09397628158330917, + 0.09592689573764801, + 0.1880030632019043 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0021990183740854263 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a plump, ruby-red tomato with a smooth, glossy skin and a tiny bright green stem?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot as a close-up from a sideways angle using high-speed photography in slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tomato plummet downward into a transparent glass container filled with crystal-clear, perfectly still water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Upon impact, does a crown of shimmering droplets scatter in all directions while the tomato sinks leaving a trail of silver bubbles and concentric ripples?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by bright, even studio lighting against a pristine background with vibrant, fresh tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003195063676685095 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753195285797119 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003195063676685095, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003195063676685095, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09374945610761642, + 0.11225088685750961, + 0.11281561851501465, + 0.07657936215400696, + 0.16862933337688446, + 0.09397865831851959, + 0.035587992519140244, + 0.07050671428442001, + 0.0544099286198616, + 0.18149201571941376 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003195063676685095 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "stunning close-up shot from a sideways angle, using high-speed photography, captures in breathtaking slow motion the plump, ruby-red tomato plummeting downward. Its skin is smooth and glossy, with a tiny, bright green stem still tucked in at the tip. Under the bright, even studio lighting, the tomato appears remarkably fresh and juicy. As the tomato's base touches the crystal-clear, perfectly still water of a transparent glass container below, a silent visual impact erupts: a perfect crown of countless shimmering droplets gracefully scatters in all directions, each droplet distinctly reflecting light. As the tomato slowly sinks into the water, it trails a trail of tiny, shimmering silver bubbles in its wake. Simultaneously, delicate concentric ripples steadily and deliberately spread outward from the point of impact, disturbing the tranquility. The image, framed by a pristine background and vibrant, fresh tones, captures this fleeting moment, creating a pure, dynamic, and Zen-like visual aesthetic.", + "seed": 4342, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000272/group_13/index_4118_seed_4342_dp_27_rank_54_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.00450224787928164, + "vlm_logprob": -0.00450224787928164, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 5.675, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.00450224787928164, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a plump, ruby-red tomato with a smooth, glossy skin and a tiny bright green stem?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot as a close-up from a sideways angle using high-speed photography in slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tomato plummet downward into a transparent glass container filled with crystal-clear, perfectly still water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Upon impact, does a crown of shimmering droplets scatter in all directions while the tomato sinks leaving a trail of silver bubbles and concentric ripples?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by bright, even studio lighting against a pristine background with vibrant, fresh tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006300467532128096 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.131300449371338 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006300467532128096, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006300467532128096, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3293590545654297, + 0.08447206020355225, + 0.08165854960680008, + 0.07997361570596695, + 0.05914317071437836, + 0.07162194699048996, + 0.05721940100193024, + 0.03528163582086563, + 0.11743133515119553, + 0.08383926749229431 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006300467532128096 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a plump, ruby-red tomato with a smooth, glossy skin and a tiny bright green stem?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot as a close-up from a sideways angle using high-speed photography in slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tomato plummet downward into a transparent glass container filled with crystal-clear, perfectly still water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Upon impact, does a crown of shimmering droplets scatter in all directions while the tomato sinks leaving a trail of silver bubbles and concentric ripples?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by bright, even studio lighting against a pristine background with vibrant, fresh tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009792031720280647 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634791851043701 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009792031720280647, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009792031720280647, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20986886322498322, + 0.09251748770475388, + 0.045867759734392166, + 0.0436362661421299, + 0.08685096353292465, + 0.06166093051433563, + 0.06850937008857727, + 0.040207043290138245, + 0.2198547124862671, + 0.13102658092975616 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009792031720280647 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a plump, ruby-red tomato with a smooth, glossy skin and a tiny bright green stem?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot as a close-up from a sideways angle using high-speed photography in slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tomato plummet downward into a transparent glass container filled with crystal-clear, perfectly still water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Upon impact, does a crown of shimmering droplets scatter in all directions while the tomato sinks leaving a trail of silver bubbles and concentric ripples?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by bright, even studio lighting against a pristine background with vibrant, fresh tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0015138844028115273 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.501513957977295 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0015138844028115273, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0015138844028115273, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11798583716154099, + 0.08168116211891174, + 0.04087407514452934, + 0.16488760709762573, + 0.114530049264431, + 0.061845067888498306, + 0.05773606896400452, + 0.07776306569576263, + 0.12925314903259277, + 0.1534438580274582 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0015138844028115273 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a plump, ruby-red tomato with a smooth, glossy skin and a tiny bright green stem?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot as a close-up from a sideways angle using high-speed photography in slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tomato plummet downward into a transparent glass container filled with crystal-clear, perfectly still water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Upon impact, does a crown of shimmering droplets scatter in all directions while the tomato sinks leaving a trail of silver bubbles and concentric ripples?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by bright, even studio lighting against a pristine background with vibrant, fresh tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0017132379580289125 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.376713275909424 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0017132379580289125, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0017132379580289125, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2272491306066513, + 0.09156143665313721, + 0.08640040457248688, + 0.06592630594968796, + 0.0606909915804863, + 0.0762941762804985, + 0.043279942125082016, + 0.0640532523393631, + 0.16899582743644714, + 0.1155485138297081 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0017132379580289125 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a plump, ruby-red tomato with a smooth, glossy skin and a tiny bright green stem?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot as a close-up from a sideways angle using high-speed photography in slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tomato plummet downward into a transparent glass container filled with crystal-clear, perfectly still water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Upon impact, does a crown of shimmering droplets scatter in all directions while the tomato sinks leaving a trail of silver bubbles and concentric ripples?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by bright, even studio lighting against a pristine background with vibrant, fresh tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0031916177831590176 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.7531914710998535 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0031916177831590176, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0031916177831590176, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18216992914676666, + 0.055966366082429886, + 0.05012372508645058, + 0.09268953651189804, + 0.0824340432882309, + 0.17453719675540924, + 0.10336699336767197, + 0.05626549571752548, + 0.1203613206744194, + 0.08208538591861725 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0031916177831590176 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "stunning close-up shot from a sideways angle, using high-speed photography, captures in breathtaking slow motion the plump, ruby-red tomato plummeting downward. Its skin is smooth and glossy, with a tiny, bright green stem still tucked in at the tip. Under the bright, even studio lighting, the tomato appears remarkably fresh and juicy. As the tomato's base touches the crystal-clear, perfectly still water of a transparent glass container below, a silent visual impact erupts: a perfect crown of countless shimmering droplets gracefully scatters in all directions, each droplet distinctly reflecting light. As the tomato slowly sinks into the water, it trails a trail of tiny, shimmering silver bubbles in its wake. Simultaneously, delicate concentric ripples steadily and deliberately spread outward from the point of impact, disturbing the tranquility. The image, framed by a pristine background and vibrant, fresh tones, captures this fleeting moment, creating a pure, dynamic, and Zen-like visual aesthetic.", + "seed": 4343, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000272/group_13/index_4118_seed_4343_dp_27_rank_54_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.007007691916078329, + "vlm_logprob": -0.007007691916078329, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 5.2, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.007007691916078329, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a plump, ruby-red tomato with a smooth, glossy skin and a tiny bright green stem?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot as a close-up from a sideways angle using high-speed photography in slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tomato plummet downward into a transparent glass container filled with crystal-clear, perfectly still water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Upon impact, does a crown of shimmering droplets scatter in all directions while the tomato sinks leaving a trail of silver bubbles and concentric ripples?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by bright, even studio lighting against a pristine background with vibrant, fresh tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.010181513614952564 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.635181427001953 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.010181513614952564, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.010181513614952564, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07898833602666855, + 0.04839439317584038, + 0.1493711769580841, + 0.053348004817962646, + 0.047594986855983734, + 0.10832031816244125, + 0.02769491821527481, + 0.04232547804713249, + 0.19223661720752716, + 0.25172579288482666 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.010181513614952564 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a plump, ruby-red tomato with a smooth, glossy skin and a tiny bright green stem?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot as a close-up from a sideways angle using high-speed photography in slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tomato plummet downward into a transparent glass container filled with crystal-clear, perfectly still water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Upon impact, does a crown of shimmering droplets scatter in all directions while the tomato sinks leaving a trail of silver bubbles and concentric ripples?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by bright, even studio lighting against a pristine background with vibrant, fresh tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012546772137284279 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387546539306641 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012546772137284279, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012546772137284279, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17953792214393616, + 0.05085380747914314, + 0.24808861315250397, + 0.045240286737680435, + 0.05014089494943619, + 0.02514009363949299, + 0.04888627305626869, + 0.14835472404956818, + 0.07561657577753067, + 0.12814079225063324 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012546772137284279 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a plump, ruby-red tomato with a smooth, glossy skin and a tiny bright green stem?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot as a close-up from a sideways angle using high-speed photography in slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tomato plummet downward into a transparent glass container filled with crystal-clear, perfectly still water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Upon impact, does a crown of shimmering droplets scatter in all directions while the tomato sinks leaving a trail of silver bubbles and concentric ripples?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by bright, even studio lighting against a pristine background with vibrant, fresh tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0076261102221906185 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882626056671143 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0076261102221906185, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0076261102221906185, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13294470310211182, + 0.07618451118469238, + 0.1374368518590927, + 0.13207510113716125, + 0.08056067675352097, + 0.14931316673755646, + 0.06837081909179688, + 0.026339896023273468, + 0.1468791961669922, + 0.049895092844963074 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0076261102221906185 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a plump, ruby-red tomato with a smooth, glossy skin and a tiny bright green stem?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot as a close-up from a sideways angle using high-speed photography in slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tomato plummet downward into a transparent glass container filled with crystal-clear, perfectly still water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Upon impact, does a crown of shimmering droplets scatter in all directions while the tomato sinks leaving a trail of silver bubbles and concentric ripples?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by bright, even studio lighting against a pristine background with vibrant, fresh tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002196639310568571 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127196788787842 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002196639310568571, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002196639310568571, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08929374814033508, + 0.043396007269620895, + 0.17948609590530396, + 0.07600310444831848, + 0.06928699463605881, + 0.14271698892116547, + 0.03778636083006859, + 0.052893925458192825, + 0.26875001192092896, + 0.040386784821748734 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002196639310568571 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a plump, ruby-red tomato with a smooth, glossy skin and a tiny bright green stem?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot as a close-up from a sideways angle using high-speed photography in slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tomato plummet downward into a transparent glass container filled with crystal-clear, perfectly still water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Upon impact, does a crown of shimmering droplets scatter in all directions while the tomato sinks leaving a trail of silver bubbles and concentric ripples?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by bright, even studio lighting against a pristine background with vibrant, fresh tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0024874242953956127 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002487659454346 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0024874242953956127, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0024874242953956127, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1108560711145401, + 0.16596771776676178, + 0.13524675369262695, + 0.03483186289668083, + 0.028415096923708916, + 0.13601253926753998, + 0.023226484656333923, + 0.09912362694740295, + 0.15756775438785553, + 0.1087520569562912 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0024874242953956127 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000272/group_14/index_tensor([6988, 6988])_group_14_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000272/group_14/index_tensor([6988, 6988])_group_14_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..81b218d5898579cfbb90b82578ee2371131f375e --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000272/group_14/index_tensor([6988, 6988])_group_14_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "In a graceful, fluid 360-degree pan, the camera begins from a slightly upward angle, slowly circling a single long-bud fir tree standing tall amidst soft grass. As the camera pans, time magically shifts, beginning with spring, with tender green buds sprouting from its branches. The needles take on the fresh, translucent texture of a watercolor painting, and its signature blue-purple cones take shape like tiny gemstones, shimmering in the soft morning light. Then, as the camera smoothly sweeps through a 90-degree pan, the scene seamlessly transitions to midsummer. The sky is the signature, hand-painted blue of Hayao Miyazaki's films, and the sun, blazing brightly, casts a deep, vibrant dark green on the fir needles. The ripe blue-purple cones, plump and prominent on the branches, clump with a faint, almost tangible sheen. The camera continues to rotate, the autumn atmosphere deepening, the surrounding background tinged with warm ochre and gold. The setting afternoon sun casts long, soft shadows on the ground, and the light penetrates the treetops, gilding the entire tree with a warm golden halo. Finally, as the camera completes its final arc, winter snow quietly arrives, blanketing the entire world in a thick, soft layer of white snow. Snowflakes gently accumulate on every branch of the fir tree, forming a stark and serene contrast with the dark trunks and blue-purple cones half-hidden in the snow. The air is cool, and the picture presents an ultimate quiet beauty. The entire transformation is imbued with the delicate hand-painted texture and warm sense of life that are unique to Ghibli animations, as if time itself is gently flowing around this tree.", + "seed": 3221, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000272/group_14/index_6988_seed_3221_dp_28_rank_56_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.04712378941476345, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04712378941476345, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.4, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04712378941476345, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a single long-bud fir tree standing in soft grass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a 360-degree pan starting from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the tree transitioning through spring, midsummer, autumn, and winter seasons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style characterized by a hand-painted texture similar to Ghibli animations?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the winter scene show the tree blanketed in a thick layer of white snow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.010515756905078888 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.6355156898498535 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.010515756905078888, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.010515756905078888, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.30959323048591614, + 0.09617870301008224, + 0.08921454846858978, + 0.07064124941825867, + 0.049459148198366165, + 0.04894033819437027, + 0.2071077674627304, + 0.07578609138727188, + 0.024372631683945656, + 0.028706256300210953 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.010515756905078888 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a single long-bud fir tree standing in soft grass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a 360-degree pan starting from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the tree transitioning through spring, midsummer, autumn, and winter seasons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style characterized by a hand-painted texture similar to Ghibli animations?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the winter scene show the tree blanketed in a thick layer of white snow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08907130360603333 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.464071273803711 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08907130360603333, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08907130360603333, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16497178375720978, + 0.2487141340970993, + 0.1622239500284195, + 0.08907894790172577, + 0.040195100009441376, + 0.06883369386196136, + 0.06892359256744385, + 0.03959934785962105, + 0.053253285586833954, + 0.06420616060495377 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08907130360603333 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a single long-bud fir tree standing in soft grass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a 360-degree pan starting from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the tree transitioning through spring, midsummer, autumn, and winter seasons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style characterized by a hand-painted texture similar to Ghibli animations?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the winter scene show the tree blanketed in a thick layer of white snow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07001770287752151 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950178146362305 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07001770287752151, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07001770287752151, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10253458470106125, + 0.13811713457107544, + 0.13147027790546417, + 0.14138175547122955, + 0.09974294155836105, + 0.11567820608615875, + 0.08973265439271927, + 0.042129456996917725, + 0.07102503627538681, + 0.06818791478872299 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07001770287752151 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a single long-bud fir tree standing in soft grass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a 360-degree pan starting from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the tree transitioning through spring, midsummer, autumn, and winter seasons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style characterized by a hand-painted texture similar to Ghibli animations?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the winter scene show the tree blanketed in a thick layer of white snow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011075684800744057 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511075496673584 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011075684800744057, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011075684800744057, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24781274795532227, + 0.10113562643527985, + 0.12558788061141968, + 0.1575579047203064, + 0.08809998631477356, + 0.05949891731142998, + 0.0435948520898819, + 0.05701405182480812, + 0.05461247265338898, + 0.0650855302810669 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011075684800744057 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a single long-bud fir tree standing in soft grass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a 360-degree pan starting from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the tree transitioning through spring, midsummer, autumn, and winter seasons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style characterized by a hand-painted texture similar to Ghibli animations?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the winter scene show the tree blanketed in a thick layer of white snow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05493849888443947 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929938554763794 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05493849888443947, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05493849888443947, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06146188825368881, + 0.08743325620889664, + 0.10664087533950806, + 0.16562943160533905, + 0.17691658437252045, + 0.1148279681801796, + 0.09367260336875916, + 0.060508206486701965, + 0.05287883058190346, + 0.08003036677837372 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05493849888443947 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a graceful, fluid 360-degree pan, the camera begins from a slightly upward angle, slowly circling a single long-bud fir tree standing tall amidst soft grass. As the camera pans, time magically shifts, beginning with spring, with tender green buds sprouting from its branches. The needles take on the fresh, translucent texture of a watercolor painting, and its signature blue-purple cones take shape like tiny gemstones, shimmering in the soft morning light. Then, as the camera smoothly sweeps through a 90-degree pan, the scene seamlessly transitions to midsummer. The sky is the signature, hand-painted blue of Hayao Miyazaki's films, and the sun, blazing brightly, casts a deep, vibrant dark green on the fir needles. The ripe blue-purple cones, plump and prominent on the branches, clump with a faint, almost tangible sheen. The camera continues to rotate, the autumn atmosphere deepening, the surrounding background tinged with warm ochre and gold. The setting afternoon sun casts long, soft shadows on the ground, and the light penetrates the treetops, gilding the entire tree with a warm golden halo. Finally, as the camera completes its final arc, winter snow quietly arrives, blanketing the entire world in a thick, soft layer of white snow. Snowflakes gently accumulate on every branch of the fir tree, forming a stark and serene contrast with the dark trunks and blue-purple cones half-hidden in the snow. The air is cool, and the picture presents an ultimate quiet beauty. The entire transformation is imbued with the delicate hand-painted texture and warm sense of life that are unique to Ghibli animations, as if time itself is gently flowing around this tree.", + "seed": 3222, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000272/group_14/index_6988_seed_3222_dp_28_rank_56_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.07485315892845393, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07485315892845393, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.925, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07485315892845393, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a single long-bud fir tree standing in soft grass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a 360-degree pan starting from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the tree transitioning through spring, midsummer, autumn, and winter seasons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style characterized by a hand-painted texture similar to Ghibli animations?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the winter scene show the tree blanketed in a thick layer of white snow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.024358049035072327 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.774358034133911 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.024358049035072327, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.024358049035072327, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2451547086238861, + 0.0703575536608696, + 0.05263881757855415, + 0.22992996871471405, + 0.042701687663793564, + 0.056971319019794464, + 0.03736844286322594, + 0.023971203714609146, + 0.17249825596809387, + 0.06840799748897552 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.024358049035072327 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a single long-bud fir tree standing in soft grass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a 360-degree pan starting from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the tree transitioning through spring, midsummer, autumn, and winter seasons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style characterized by a hand-painted texture similar to Ghibli animations?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the winter scene show the tree blanketed in a thick layer of white snow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11298569291830063 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.237985610961914 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11298569291830063, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11298569291830063, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14227019250392914, + 0.03086681105196476, + 0.030126595869660378, + 0.02769044041633606, + 0.13069719076156616, + 0.21027319133281708, + 0.09397176653146744, + 0.05715576559305191, + 0.23924879729747772, + 0.037699293345212936 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11298569291830063 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a single long-bud fir tree standing in soft grass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a 360-degree pan starting from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the tree transitioning through spring, midsummer, autumn, and winter seasons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style characterized by a hand-painted texture similar to Ghibli animations?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the winter scene show the tree blanketed in a thick layer of white snow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11293287575244904 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2379329204559326 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11293287575244904, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11293287575244904, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10616032034158707, + 0.016639092937111855, + 0.01828256994485855, + 0.019957557320594788, + 0.09295311570167542, + 0.05117349326610565, + 0.03369329497218132, + 0.030329663306474686, + 0.5344825983047485, + 0.09632827341556549 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11293287575244904 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a single long-bud fir tree standing in soft grass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a 360-degree pan starting from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the tree transitioning through spring, midsummer, autumn, and winter seasons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style characterized by a hand-painted texture similar to Ghibli animations?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the winter scene show the tree blanketed in a thick layer of white snow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011076745577156544 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511076927185059 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011076745577156544, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011076745577156544, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1857251226902008, + 0.058028094470500946, + 0.020118912681937218, + 0.02063172310590744, + 0.14737732708454132, + 0.15141268074512482, + 0.06807829439640045, + 0.026990119367837906, + 0.2734759747982025, + 0.04816173389554024 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011076745577156544 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a single long-bud fir tree standing in soft grass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a 360-degree pan starting from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the tree transitioning through spring, midsummer, autumn, and winter seasons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style characterized by a hand-painted texture similar to Ghibli animations?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the winter scene show the tree blanketed in a thick layer of white snow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11291243135929108 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.23791241645813 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11291243135929108, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11291243135929108, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1515817642211914, + 0.013142289593815804, + 0.022694816812872887, + 0.01915055513381958, + 0.07167556881904602, + 0.049512673169374466, + 0.05589040368795395, + 0.05085454508662224, + 0.46684402227401733, + 0.0986533984541893 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11291243135929108 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a graceful, fluid 360-degree pan, the camera begins from a slightly upward angle, slowly circling a single long-bud fir tree standing tall amidst soft grass. As the camera pans, time magically shifts, beginning with spring, with tender green buds sprouting from its branches. The needles take on the fresh, translucent texture of a watercolor painting, and its signature blue-purple cones take shape like tiny gemstones, shimmering in the soft morning light. Then, as the camera smoothly sweeps through a 90-degree pan, the scene seamlessly transitions to midsummer. The sky is the signature, hand-painted blue of Hayao Miyazaki's films, and the sun, blazing brightly, casts a deep, vibrant dark green on the fir needles. The ripe blue-purple cones, plump and prominent on the branches, clump with a faint, almost tangible sheen. The camera continues to rotate, the autumn atmosphere deepening, the surrounding background tinged with warm ochre and gold. The setting afternoon sun casts long, soft shadows on the ground, and the light penetrates the treetops, gilding the entire tree with a warm golden halo. Finally, as the camera completes its final arc, winter snow quietly arrives, blanketing the entire world in a thick, soft layer of white snow. Snowflakes gently accumulate on every branch of the fir tree, forming a stark and serene contrast with the dark trunks and blue-purple cones half-hidden in the snow. The air is cool, and the picture presents an ultimate quiet beauty. The entire transformation is imbued with the delicate hand-painted texture and warm sense of life that are unique to Ghibli animations, as if time itself is gently flowing around this tree.", + "seed": 3223, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000272/group_14/index_6988_seed_3223_dp_29_rank_58_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.03250885000452399, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03250885000452399, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.025, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03250885000452399, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a single long-bud fir tree standing in soft grass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a 360-degree pan starting from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the tree transitioning through spring, midsummer, autumn, and winter seasons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style characterized by a hand-painted texture similar to Ghibli animations?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the winter scene show the tree blanketed in a thick layer of white snow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01326591894030571 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.388266086578369 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01326591894030571, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01326591894030571, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12189844995737076, + 0.7005984783172607, + 0.017012344673275948, + 0.014009539037942886, + 0.011703284457325935, + 0.03537767380475998, + 0.024546653032302856, + 0.031113548204302788, + 0.024201322346925735, + 0.01953868381679058 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01326591894030571 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a single long-bud fir tree standing in soft grass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a 360-degree pan starting from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the tree transitioning through spring, midsummer, autumn, and winter seasons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style characterized by a hand-painted texture similar to Ghibli animations?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the winter scene show the tree blanketed in a thick layer of white snow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11296407878398895 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.237964153289795 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11296407878398895, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11296407878398895, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12806527316570282, + 0.32640933990478516, + 0.04044247791171074, + 0.032448165118694305, + 0.05541062727570534, + 0.07434484362602234, + 0.06479046493768692, + 0.08773276954889297, + 0.0953368991613388, + 0.09501910209655762 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11296407878398895 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a single long-bud fir tree standing in soft grass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a 360-degree pan starting from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the tree transitioning through spring, midsummer, autumn, and winter seasons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style characterized by a hand-painted texture similar to Ghibli animations?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the winter scene show the tree blanketed in a thick layer of white snow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02058732882142067 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.89558744430542 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02058732882142067, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02058732882142067, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0784575492143631, + 0.49405357241630554, + 0.02515457570552826, + 0.02691471204161644, + 0.016577785834670067, + 0.04656866565346718, + 0.07873515039682388, + 0.022441180422902107, + 0.08148223906755447, + 0.12961457669734955 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02058732882142067 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a single long-bud fir tree standing in soft grass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a 360-degree pan starting from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the tree transitioning through spring, midsummer, autumn, and winter seasons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style characterized by a hand-painted texture similar to Ghibli animations?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the winter scene show the tree blanketed in a thick layer of white snow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005950473714619875 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130950450897217 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005950473714619875, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005950473714619875, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07025550305843353, + 0.602241039276123, + 0.02240476943552494, + 0.019859153777360916, + 0.008996092714369297, + 0.030664261430501938, + 0.04857185110449791, + 0.03132029250264168, + 0.10305988788604736, + 0.06262712925672531 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005950473714619875 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a single long-bud fir tree standing in soft grass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a 360-degree pan starting from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the tree transitioning through spring, midsummer, autumn, and winter seasons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style characterized by a hand-painted texture similar to Ghibli animations?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the winter scene show the tree blanketed in a thick layer of white snow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009776449762284756 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634776592254639 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009776449762284756, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009776449762284756, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11565319448709488, + 0.4046938121318817, + 0.03220248594880104, + 0.021917674690485, + 0.016020068898797035, + 0.03790518268942833, + 0.10310379415750504, + 0.08775870501995087, + 0.05556153878569603, + 0.125183567404747 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009776449762284756 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a graceful, fluid 360-degree pan, the camera begins from a slightly upward angle, slowly circling a single long-bud fir tree standing tall amidst soft grass. As the camera pans, time magically shifts, beginning with spring, with tender green buds sprouting from its branches. The needles take on the fresh, translucent texture of a watercolor painting, and its signature blue-purple cones take shape like tiny gemstones, shimmering in the soft morning light. Then, as the camera smoothly sweeps through a 90-degree pan, the scene seamlessly transitions to midsummer. The sky is the signature, hand-painted blue of Hayao Miyazaki's films, and the sun, blazing brightly, casts a deep, vibrant dark green on the fir needles. The ripe blue-purple cones, plump and prominent on the branches, clump with a faint, almost tangible sheen. The camera continues to rotate, the autumn atmosphere deepening, the surrounding background tinged with warm ochre and gold. The setting afternoon sun casts long, soft shadows on the ground, and the light penetrates the treetops, gilding the entire tree with a warm golden halo. Finally, as the camera completes its final arc, winter snow quietly arrives, blanketing the entire world in a thick, soft layer of white snow. Snowflakes gently accumulate on every branch of the fir tree, forming a stark and serene contrast with the dark trunks and blue-purple cones half-hidden in the snow. The air is cool, and the picture presents an ultimate quiet beauty. The entire transformation is imbued with the delicate hand-painted texture and warm sense of life that are unique to Ghibli animations, as if time itself is gently flowing around this tree.", + "seed": 3224, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000272/group_14/index_6988_seed_3224_dp_29_rank_58_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.02550748414359987, + "vlm_logprob": -0.02550748414359987, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.225, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.02550748414359987, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a single long-bud fir tree standing in soft grass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a 360-degree pan starting from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the tree transitioning through spring, midsummer, autumn, and winter seasons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style characterized by a hand-painted texture similar to Ghibli animations?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the winter scene show the tree blanketed in a thick layer of white snow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.030848296359181404 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.530848264694214 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.030848296359181404, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.030848296359181404, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13828423619270325, + 0.04887516424059868, + 0.08215803653001785, + 0.04827244579792023, + 0.22225520014762878, + 0.0595172755420208, + 0.058472685515880585, + 0.2846897840499878, + 0.02967667765915394, + 0.02779845893383026 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.030848296359181404 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a single long-bud fir tree standing in soft grass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a 360-degree pan starting from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the tree transitioning through spring, midsummer, autumn, and winter seasons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style characterized by a hand-painted texture similar to Ghibli animations?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the winter scene show the tree blanketed in a thick layer of white snow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07005327194929123 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950533390045166 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07005327194929123, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07005327194929123, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07426996529102325, + 0.23177573084831238, + 0.05313844606280327, + 0.028805341571569443, + 0.17645706236362457, + 0.0519084669649601, + 0.08403618633747101, + 0.21232005953788757, + 0.04626704752445221, + 0.041021671146154404 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 7, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07005327194929123 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a single long-bud fir tree standing in soft grass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a 360-degree pan starting from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the tree transitioning through spring, midsummer, autumn, and winter seasons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style characterized by a hand-painted texture similar to Ghibli animations?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the winter scene show the tree blanketed in a thick layer of white snow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018192103132605553 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018192291259766 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018192103132605553, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018192103132605553, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07775618135929108, + 0.05699635669589043, + 0.026217948645353317, + 0.05796961486339569, + 0.1338370442390442, + 0.07141901552677155, + 0.08015021681785583, + 0.10448594391345978, + 0.10426250100135803, + 0.2869051694869995 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018192103132605553 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a single long-bud fir tree standing in soft grass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a 360-degree pan starting from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the tree transitioning through spring, midsummer, autumn, and winter seasons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style characterized by a hand-painted texture similar to Ghibli animations?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the winter scene show the tree blanketed in a thick layer of white snow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005253438837826252 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255253314971924 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005253438837826252, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005253438837826252, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1142517700791359, + 0.07252141833305359, + 0.10020239651203156, + 0.10340964794158936, + 0.11956877261400223, + 0.10467985272407532, + 0.06312108039855957, + 0.18075965344905853, + 0.0923207700252533, + 0.04916466772556305 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005253438837826252 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a single long-bud fir tree standing in soft grass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a 360-degree pan starting from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the tree transitioning through spring, midsummer, autumn, and winter seasons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style characterized by a hand-painted texture similar to Ghibli animations?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the winter scene show the tree blanketed in a thick layer of white snow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003190310439094901 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753190517425537 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003190310439094901, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003190310439094901, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0304114893078804, + 0.038945116102695465, + 0.04437834396958351, + 0.036703746765851974, + 0.17171315848827362, + 0.03199241682887077, + 0.046550214290618896, + 0.24734419584274292, + 0.04110896587371826, + 0.3108523190021515 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003190310439094901 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000272/group_2/index_tensor([7436, 7436])_group_2_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000272/group_2/index_tensor([7436, 7436])_group_2_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..8a2f55616d9ad64e18b0e905bbb677345635bc76 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000272/group_2/index_tensor([7436, 7436])_group_2_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "long, low-angle drone tracking shot follows a camel caravan at full speed across the vast desert. As the sun dips below the horizon, its last rays paint the rolling golden dunes a brilliant orange-red, casting the caravan's elongated, dramatic silhouettes across the sand. Five or six sturdy, dark brown Bactrian camels, laden with heavy saddlebags adorned with colorful tassels and brass bells, gallop at a powerful, rhythmic pace. Riders, clad in traditional robes and turbans, lean over their humps, their robes rustling in the wind, their faces, chiseled by the wind, etched with determination and focus. With each shove and lift of the camels' hooves, they powerfully throw back vast clouds of fine yellow sand, creating trails of golden mist that shimmer in the low sunlight. This mist lingers behind the caravan, blurring the distant horizon. The entire picture is wrapped in warm tones, creating an epic atmosphere that is both desolate and magnificent and full of indomitable vitality, as if it is an eternal journey to the unknown.", + "seed": 27519, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000272/group_2/index_7436_seed_27519_dp_4_rank_8_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.1385477640433237, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1385477640433237, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.775, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1385477640433237, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a tracking shot following a camel caravan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are there five or six dark brown Bactrian camels laden with saddlebags visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the camels galloping at a powerful, rhythmic pace while throwing clouds of yellow sand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a vast desert with rolling golden dunes painted orange-red by the setting sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.33177122473716736 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4567712545394897 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.33177122473716736, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.33177122473716736, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15256355702877045, + 0.061905231326818466, + 0.037905674427747726, + 0.31856587529182434, + 0.04356398805975914, + 0.0608162097632885, + 0.07805735617876053, + 0.08995533734560013, + 0.028856640681624413, + 0.12781019508838654 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.33177122473716736 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a tracking shot following a camel caravan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are there five or six dark brown Bactrian camels laden with saddlebags visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the camels galloping at a powerful, rhythmic pace while throwing clouds of yellow sand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a vast desert with rolling golden dunes painted orange-red by the setting sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10035604238510132 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.350356101989746 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10035604238510132, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10035604238510132, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15494196116924286, + 0.09323756396770477, + 0.061545051634311676, + 0.2047143131494522, + 0.04082697257399559, + 0.10113541781902313, + 0.06058042123913765, + 0.20607732236385345, + 0.022835368290543556, + 0.05410559102892876 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10035604238510132 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a tracking shot following a camel caravan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are there five or six dark brown Bactrian camels laden with saddlebags visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the camels galloping at a powerful, rhythmic pace while throwing clouds of yellow sand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a vast desert with rolling golden dunes painted orange-red by the setting sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17992769181728363 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8049277067184448 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17992769181728363, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17992769181728363, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19514039158821106, + 0.08532249182462692, + 0.03544112294912338, + 0.10426724702119827, + 0.09912548214197159, + 0.0810132846236229, + 0.13514883816242218, + 0.14561329782009125, + 0.027676543220877647, + 0.09125131368637085 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17992769181728363 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a tracking shot following a camel caravan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are there five or six dark brown Bactrian camels laden with saddlebags visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the camels galloping at a powerful, rhythmic pace while throwing clouds of yellow sand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a vast desert with rolling golden dunes painted orange-red by the setting sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07897336035966873 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5789732933044434 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07897336035966873, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07897336035966873, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04872821643948555, + 0.03699938952922821, + 0.027575215324759483, + 0.23991720378398895, + 0.0424465574324131, + 0.03873194009065628, + 0.14054103195667267, + 0.34806880354881287, + 0.039083171635866165, + 0.037908487021923065 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 3, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07897336035966873 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a tracking shot following a camel caravan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are there five or six dark brown Bactrian camels laden with saddlebags visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the camels galloping at a powerful, rhythmic pace while throwing clouds of yellow sand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a vast desert with rolling golden dunes painted orange-red by the setting sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0017105009173974395 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.376710414886475 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0017105009173974395, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0017105009173974395, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06848234683275223, + 0.04406443610787392, + 0.019362716004252434, + 0.7100331783294678, + 0.015570650808513165, + 0.037031885236501694, + 0.022262176498770714, + 0.014870801009237766, + 0.016481656581163406, + 0.05184014514088631 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0017105009173974395 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "long, low-angle drone tracking shot follows a camel caravan at full speed across the vast desert. As the sun dips below the horizon, its last rays paint the rolling golden dunes a brilliant orange-red, casting the caravan's elongated, dramatic silhouettes across the sand. Five or six sturdy, dark brown Bactrian camels, laden with heavy saddlebags adorned with colorful tassels and brass bells, gallop at a powerful, rhythmic pace. Riders, clad in traditional robes and turbans, lean over their humps, their robes rustling in the wind, their faces, chiseled by the wind, etched with determination and focus. With each shove and lift of the camels' hooves, they powerfully throw back vast clouds of fine yellow sand, creating trails of golden mist that shimmer in the low sunlight. This mist lingers behind the caravan, blurring the distant horizon. The entire picture is wrapped in warm tones, creating an epic atmosphere that is both desolate and magnificent and full of indomitable vitality, as if it is an eternal journey to the unknown.", + "seed": 27520, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000272/group_2/index_7436_seed_27520_dp_4_rank_8_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.22409177157096566, + "vlm_logprob": -0.22409177157096566, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.325, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.22409177157096566, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a tracking shot following a camel caravan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are there five or six dark brown Bactrian camels laden with saddlebags visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the camels galloping at a powerful, rhythmic pace while throwing clouds of yellow sand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a vast desert with rolling golden dunes painted orange-red by the setting sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3462305963039398 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4712306261062622 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3462305963039398, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3462305963039398, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.30422380566596985, + 0.05392906442284584, + 0.07339862734079361, + 0.0767938643693924, + 0.06740421801805496, + 0.07454799115657806, + 0.09982497245073318, + 0.10882402211427689, + 0.09061378985643387, + 0.05043965205550194 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3462305963039398 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a tracking shot following a camel caravan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are there five or six dark brown Bactrian camels laden with saddlebags visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the camels galloping at a powerful, rhythmic pace while throwing clouds of yellow sand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a vast desert with rolling golden dunes painted orange-red by the setting sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.34872329235076904 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.223723292350769 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.34872329235076904, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.34872329235076904, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15814146399497986, + 0.1567295491695404, + 0.08968846499919891, + 0.07713934034109116, + 0.09969749301671982, + 0.12491169571876526, + 0.1918962597846985, + 0.028943711891770363, + 0.05238320678472519, + 0.020468819886446 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.34872329235076904 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a tracking shot following a camel caravan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are there five or six dark brown Bactrian camels laden with saddlebags visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the camels galloping at a powerful, rhythmic pace while throwing clouds of yellow sand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a vast desert with rolling golden dunes painted orange-red by the setting sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14285440742969513 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0178544521331787 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14285440742969513, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14285440742969513, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21524779498577118, + 0.20330794155597687, + 0.06627137213945389, + 0.08221286535263062, + 0.05872579291462898, + 0.11635176092386246, + 0.07470814138650894, + 0.0818210318684578, + 0.06707803905010223, + 0.034275270998477936 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14285440742969513 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a tracking shot following a camel caravan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are there five or six dark brown Bactrian camels laden with saddlebags visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the camels galloping at a powerful, rhythmic pace while throwing clouds of yellow sand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a vast desert with rolling golden dunes painted orange-red by the setting sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.281314879655838 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4063148498535156 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.281314879655838, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.281314879655838, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19494515657424927, + 0.12992240488529205, + 0.03757479786872864, + 0.0566924586892128, + 0.06352110952138901, + 0.04765717685222626, + 0.0954647958278656, + 0.20543363690376282, + 0.14753685891628265, + 0.02125166915357113 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.281314879655838 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a tracking shot following a camel caravan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are there five or six dark brown Bactrian camels laden with saddlebags visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the camels galloping at a powerful, rhythmic pace while throwing clouds of yellow sand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a vast desert with rolling golden dunes painted orange-red by the setting sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.001335682114586234 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.626335620880127 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.001335682114586234, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.001335682114586234, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2963213324546814, + 0.06737995147705078, + 0.064335897564888, + 0.05638081952929497, + 0.04504624754190445, + 0.10089941322803497, + 0.044619958847761154, + 0.10704787075519562, + 0.14707978069782257, + 0.07088875770568848 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.001335682114586234 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "long, low-angle drone tracking shot follows a camel caravan at full speed across the vast desert. As the sun dips below the horizon, its last rays paint the rolling golden dunes a brilliant orange-red, casting the caravan's elongated, dramatic silhouettes across the sand. Five or six sturdy, dark brown Bactrian camels, laden with heavy saddlebags adorned with colorful tassels and brass bells, gallop at a powerful, rhythmic pace. Riders, clad in traditional robes and turbans, lean over their humps, their robes rustling in the wind, their faces, chiseled by the wind, etched with determination and focus. With each shove and lift of the camels' hooves, they powerfully throw back vast clouds of fine yellow sand, creating trails of golden mist that shimmer in the low sunlight. This mist lingers behind the caravan, blurring the distant horizon. The entire picture is wrapped in warm tones, creating an epic atmosphere that is both desolate and magnificent and full of indomitable vitality, as if it is an eternal journey to the unknown.", + "seed": 27521, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000272/group_2/index_7436_seed_27521_dp_5_rank_10_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.1295858249417506, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1295858249417506, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.0, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1295858249417506, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a tracking shot following a camel caravan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are there five or six dark brown Bactrian camels laden with saddlebags visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the camels galloping at a powerful, rhythmic pace while throwing clouds of yellow sand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a vast desert with rolling golden dunes painted orange-red by the setting sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2228851616382599 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8478851318359375 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2228851616382599, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2228851616382599, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09527195245027542, + 0.04859255254268646, + 0.07492823898792267, + 0.04101023077964783, + 0.026165250688791275, + 0.07392703741788864, + 0.060534048825502396, + 0.0813097208738327, + 0.17476998269557953, + 0.3234909772872925 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2228851616382599 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a tracking shot following a camel caravan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are there five or six dark brown Bactrian camels laden with saddlebags visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the camels galloping at a powerful, rhythmic pace while throwing clouds of yellow sand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a vast desert with rolling golden dunes painted orange-red by the setting sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22564277052879333 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6006428003311157 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.22564277052879333, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.22564277052879333, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04261724650859833, + 0.039545703679323196, + 0.06011791154742241, + 0.07655999064445496, + 0.22447939217090607, + 0.11066456884145737, + 0.13010063767433167, + 0.06655248254537582, + 0.07679915428161621, + 0.17256291210651398 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.22564277052879333 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a tracking shot following a camel caravan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are there five or six dark brown Bactrian camels laden with saddlebags visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the camels galloping at a powerful, rhythmic pace while throwing clouds of yellow sand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a vast desert with rolling golden dunes painted orange-red by the setting sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16038790345191956 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9103878736495972 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16038790345191956, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16038790345191956, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14961418509483337, + 0.0476548932492733, + 0.09674776345491409, + 0.03934988006949425, + 0.16474494338035583, + 0.058976683765649796, + 0.09658968448638916, + 0.15109726786613464, + 0.11188770830631256, + 0.08333700895309448 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16038790345191956 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a tracking shot following a camel caravan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are there five or six dark brown Bactrian camels laden with saddlebags visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the camels galloping at a powerful, rhythmic pace while throwing clouds of yellow sand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a vast desert with rolling golden dunes painted orange-red by the setting sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03809603676199913 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2880959510803223 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03809603676199913, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03809603676199913, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07414907217025757, + 0.022801455110311508, + 0.12460318952798843, + 0.030301302671432495, + 0.10903027653694153, + 0.09426067769527435, + 0.3568997085094452, + 0.08580698072910309, + 0.06802503764629364, + 0.03412230312824249 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03809603676199913 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a tracking shot following a camel caravan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are there five or six dark brown Bactrian camels laden with saddlebags visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the camels galloping at a powerful, rhythmic pace while throwing clouds of yellow sand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a vast desert with rolling golden dunes painted orange-red by the setting sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0009172523277811706 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.000917434692383 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0009172523277811706, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0009172523277811706, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09721270948648453, + 0.03393610194325447, + 0.08804192394018173, + 0.04177253320813179, + 0.21110351383686066, + 0.06107288971543312, + 0.08158781379461288, + 0.054889190942049026, + 0.11089024692773819, + 0.21949312090873718 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0009172523277811706 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "long, low-angle drone tracking shot follows a camel caravan at full speed across the vast desert. As the sun dips below the horizon, its last rays paint the rolling golden dunes a brilliant orange-red, casting the caravan's elongated, dramatic silhouettes across the sand. Five or six sturdy, dark brown Bactrian camels, laden with heavy saddlebags adorned with colorful tassels and brass bells, gallop at a powerful, rhythmic pace. Riders, clad in traditional robes and turbans, lean over their humps, their robes rustling in the wind, their faces, chiseled by the wind, etched with determination and focus. With each shove and lift of the camels' hooves, they powerfully throw back vast clouds of fine yellow sand, creating trails of golden mist that shimmer in the low sunlight. This mist lingers behind the caravan, blurring the distant horizon. The entire picture is wrapped in warm tones, creating an epic atmosphere that is both desolate and magnificent and full of indomitable vitality, as if it is an eternal journey to the unknown.", + "seed": 27522, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000272/group_2/index_7436_seed_27522_dp_5_rank_10_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.19614070625975727, + "vlm_logprob": -0.19614070625975727, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.4, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.19614070625975727, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a tracking shot following a camel caravan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are there five or six dark brown Bactrian camels laden with saddlebags visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the camels galloping at a powerful, rhythmic pace while throwing clouds of yellow sand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a vast desert with rolling golden dunes painted orange-red by the setting sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.35820287466049194 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6082029342651367 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.35820287466049194, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.35820287466049194, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08765794336795807, + 0.08188772946596146, + 0.030575089156627655, + 0.0337032824754715, + 0.426132470369339, + 0.09630060195922852, + 0.056725725531578064, + 0.08747165650129318, + 0.05849204212427139, + 0.04105348885059357 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.35820287466049194 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a tracking shot following a camel caravan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are there five or six dark brown Bactrian camels laden with saddlebags visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the camels galloping at a powerful, rhythmic pace while throwing clouds of yellow sand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a vast desert with rolling golden dunes painted orange-red by the setting sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22564001381397247 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.600640058517456 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.22564001381397247, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.22564001381397247, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03016994148492813, + 0.12467999011278152, + 0.018958915024995804, + 0.14743387699127197, + 0.2931079566478729, + 0.07995111495256424, + 0.020416542887687683, + 0.0285324826836586, + 0.21989066898822784, + 0.03685840964317322 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 8, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.22564001381397247 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a tracking shot following a camel caravan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are there five or six dark brown Bactrian camels laden with saddlebags visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the camels galloping at a powerful, rhythmic pace while throwing clouds of yellow sand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a vast desert with rolling golden dunes painted orange-red by the setting sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14286018908023834 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.017860174179077 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14286018908023834, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14286018908023834, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0981900691986084, + 0.05502920597791672, + 0.01738281361758709, + 0.06786240637302399, + 0.05342232808470726, + 0.051607050001621246, + 0.04316034913063049, + 0.030443968251347542, + 0.5339410901069641, + 0.048960741609334946 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14286018908023834 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a tracking shot following a camel caravan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are there five or six dark brown Bactrian camels laden with saddlebags visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the camels galloping at a powerful, rhythmic pace while throwing clouds of yellow sand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a vast desert with rolling golden dunes painted orange-red by the setting sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2520625591278076 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5020625591278076 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2520625591278076, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2520625591278076, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06975165009498596, + 0.028102494776248932, + 0.06618339568376541, + 0.18046815693378448, + 0.11256517469882965, + 0.1977943331003189, + 0.03972761705517769, + 0.06722117960453033, + 0.17580430209636688, + 0.06238171085715294 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 3, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2520625591278076 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a tracking shot following a camel caravan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are there five or six dark brown Bactrian camels laden with saddlebags visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the camels galloping at a powerful, rhythmic pace while throwing clouds of yellow sand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a vast desert with rolling golden dunes painted orange-red by the setting sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0019378946162760258 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.2519378662109375 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0019378946162760258, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0019378946162760258, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04757785052061081, + 0.06781753897666931, + 0.015735013410449028, + 0.027094146236777306, + 0.08407702296972275, + 0.024776486679911613, + 0.04111528396606445, + 0.08713546395301819, + 0.5861238241195679, + 0.01854737102985382 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0019378946162760258 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000272/group_4/index_tensor([4126, 4126])_group_4_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000272/group_4/index_tensor([4126, 4126])_group_4_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..44b80941e5e606b3878170c14136de5f936d7b5f --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000272/group_4/index_tensor([4126, 4126])_group_4_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "steady, horizontal medium shot plunges the viewer deep into a dark, rocky cavern, where three desert warriors huddle closely together. They wear still suits patchworked from gray and sand-colored fabric, their surfaces covered in scuffs, eroded by sand, and crudely patched. Complex pipes and recycling equipment cling to their bodies, reflecting a faint metallic sheen in the dim light. The only light comes from a portable luminous globe on the ground between them. Its faint, warm yellow light shines upward, casting deep, dynamic shadows on their weathered faces, making every wrinkle carved by the sun and wind-blown sand appear jagged and distinct. Most striking are their eyes, devoid of any white, completely shrouded in a deep, star-like blue, amplified by the warm glow. They lean forward slightly, whispering in hushed tones, their lips barely moving, their voices as low as the rustling of windblown sand. One of them would occasionally glance quickly towards the darkness of the cave entrance, his eyes sharp as an eagle, while the other would respond to his companion's words with an almost imperceptible nod. Their gestures were extremely small and precise, and every subtle movement was full of high vigilance and unspoken tacit understanding. The whole scene was filled with a tense, secretive and solemn atmosphere.", + "seed": 6630, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000272/group_4/index_4126_seed_6630_dp_8_rank_16_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.13064857721328735, + "vlm_logprob": -0.13064857721328735, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.6, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.13064857721328735, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a steady, horizontal medium shot inside a dark, rocky cavern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are three desert warriors visible huddled closely together wearing patchwork suits of gray and sand-colored fabric with scuffs and pipes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single portable luminous globe on the ground casting warm yellow light and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the warriors have eyes completely shrouded in a deep, star-like blue without any white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the warriors shown leaning forward slightly with small, precise gestures while whispering in hushed tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02915511652827263 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6541550159454346 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02915511652827263, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02915511652827263, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23699362576007843, + 0.1329214721918106, + 0.2160303294658661, + 0.08374958485364914, + 0.04387090727686882, + 0.017804814502596855, + 0.05160044506192207, + 0.06535357236862183, + 0.04227043315768242, + 0.10940482467412949 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02915511652827263 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a steady, horizontal medium shot inside a dark, rocky cavern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are three desert warriors visible huddled closely together wearing patchwork suits of gray and sand-colored fabric with scuffs and pipes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single portable luminous globe on the ground casting warm yellow light and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the warriors have eyes completely shrouded in a deep, star-like blue without any white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the warriors shown leaning forward slightly with small, precise gestures while whispering in hushed tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04310096427798271 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1681010723114014 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04310096427798271, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04310096427798271, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14663490653038025, + 0.04648099094629288, + 0.12713763117790222, + 0.048696864396333694, + 0.020898254588246346, + 0.039919786155223846, + 0.027972038835287094, + 0.03565337136387825, + 0.241632878780365, + 0.26497331261634827 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04310096427798271 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a steady, horizontal medium shot inside a dark, rocky cavern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are three desert warriors visible huddled closely together wearing patchwork suits of gray and sand-colored fabric with scuffs and pipes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single portable luminous globe on the ground casting warm yellow light and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the warriors have eyes completely shrouded in a deep, star-like blue without any white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the warriors shown leaning forward slightly with small, precise gestures while whispering in hushed tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01819608360528946 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018196105957031 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01819608360528946, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01819608360528946, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09672949463129044, + 0.2635127007961273, + 0.06298314034938812, + 0.03680672496557236, + 0.016557348892092705, + 0.017860496416687965, + 0.019881824031472206, + 0.04990147054195404, + 0.02646636962890625, + 0.4093003273010254 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01819608360528946 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a steady, horizontal medium shot inside a dark, rocky cavern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are three desert warriors visible huddled closely together wearing patchwork suits of gray and sand-colored fabric with scuffs and pipes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single portable luminous globe on the ground casting warm yellow light and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the warriors have eyes completely shrouded in a deep, star-like blue without any white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the warriors shown leaning forward slightly with small, precise gestures while whispering in hushed tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.28136327862739563 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4063632488250732 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.28136327862739563, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.28136327862739563, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13596592843532562, + 0.07253733277320862, + 0.09621317684650421, + 0.04956549406051636, + 0.02131970226764679, + 0.025678280740976334, + 0.02142465114593506, + 0.024284930899739265, + 0.021845322102308273, + 0.5311651825904846 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.28136327862739563 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a steady, horizontal medium shot inside a dark, rocky cavern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are three desert warriors visible huddled closely together wearing patchwork suits of gray and sand-colored fabric with scuffs and pipes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single portable luminous globe on the ground casting warm yellow light and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the warriors have eyes completely shrouded in a deep, star-like blue without any white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the warriors shown leaning forward slightly with small, precise gestures while whispering in hushed tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.28142744302749634 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4064273834228516 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.28142744302749634, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.28142744302749634, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11821593344211578, + 0.11149269342422485, + 0.1819460242986679, + 0.24229486286640167, + 0.1075744554400444, + 0.017049524933099747, + 0.019798941910266876, + 0.020298145711421967, + 0.06220855936408043, + 0.11912088841199875 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.28142744302749634 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "steady, horizontal medium shot plunges the viewer deep into a dark, rocky cavern, where three desert warriors huddle closely together. They wear still suits patchworked from gray and sand-colored fabric, their surfaces covered in scuffs, eroded by sand, and crudely patched. Complex pipes and recycling equipment cling to their bodies, reflecting a faint metallic sheen in the dim light. The only light comes from a portable luminous globe on the ground between them. Its faint, warm yellow light shines upward, casting deep, dynamic shadows on their weathered faces, making every wrinkle carved by the sun and wind-blown sand appear jagged and distinct. Most striking are their eyes, devoid of any white, completely shrouded in a deep, star-like blue, amplified by the warm glow. They lean forward slightly, whispering in hushed tones, their lips barely moving, their voices as low as the rustling of windblown sand. One of them would occasionally glance quickly towards the darkness of the cave entrance, his eyes sharp as an eagle, while the other would respond to his companion's words with an almost imperceptible nod. Their gestures were extremely small and precise, and every subtle movement was full of high vigilance and unspoken tacit understanding. The whole scene was filled with a tense, secretive and solemn atmosphere.", + "seed": 6631, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000272/group_4/index_4126_seed_6631_dp_8_rank_16_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.12657082155346872, + "vlm_logprob": -0.12657082155346872, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.725, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.12657082155346872, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a steady, horizontal medium shot inside a dark, rocky cavern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are three desert warriors visible huddled closely together wearing patchwork suits of gray and sand-colored fabric with scuffs and pipes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single portable luminous globe on the ground casting warm yellow light and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the warriors have eyes completely shrouded in a deep, star-like blue without any white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the warriors shown leaning forward slightly with small, precise gestures while whispering in hushed tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.021766813471913338 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8967669010162354 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.021766813471913338, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.021766813471913338, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18378503620624542, + 0.1131761446595192, + 0.03665350005030632, + 0.10521047562360764, + 0.053907472640275955, + 0.15229611098766327, + 0.10546192526817322, + 0.04643867537379265, + 0.14990052580833435, + 0.053170181810855865 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.021766813471913338 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a steady, horizontal medium shot inside a dark, rocky cavern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are three desert warriors visible huddled closely together wearing patchwork suits of gray and sand-colored fabric with scuffs and pipes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single portable luminous globe on the ground casting warm yellow light and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the warriors have eyes completely shrouded in a deep, star-like blue without any white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the warriors shown leaning forward slightly with small, precise gestures while whispering in hushed tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06207584589719772 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120758533477783 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06207584589719772, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06207584589719772, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.082577183842659, + 0.04554987698793411, + 0.047193411737680435, + 0.07233939319849014, + 0.10768216103315353, + 0.10834217816591263, + 0.09388595819473267, + 0.1980956643819809, + 0.1420315057039261, + 0.10230272263288498 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06207584589719772 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a steady, horizontal medium shot inside a dark, rocky cavern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are three desert warriors visible huddled closely together wearing patchwork suits of gray and sand-colored fabric with scuffs and pipes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single portable luminous globe on the ground casting warm yellow light and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the warriors have eyes completely shrouded in a deep, star-like blue without any white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the warriors shown leaning forward slightly with small, precise gestures while whispering in hushed tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00978671945631504 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634786605834961 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00978671945631504, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00978671945631504, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19801585376262665, + 0.2682667076587677, + 0.07727799564599991, + 0.14879265427589417, + 0.041392549872398376, + 0.11005442589521408, + 0.04251634702086449, + 0.023864079266786575, + 0.029892709106206894, + 0.05992661789059639 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00978671945631504 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a steady, horizontal medium shot inside a dark, rocky cavern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are three desert warriors visible huddled closely together wearing patchwork suits of gray and sand-colored fabric with scuffs and pipes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single portable luminous globe on the ground casting warm yellow light and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the warriors have eyes completely shrouded in a deep, star-like blue without any white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the warriors shown leaning forward slightly with small, precise gestures while whispering in hushed tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2256583720445633 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6006584167480469 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2256583720445633, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2256583720445633, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09157097339630127, + 0.0786614790558815, + 0.0369085855782032, + 0.06430613994598389, + 0.048648178577423096, + 0.0520004965364933, + 0.04438847303390503, + 0.109529510140419, + 0.03921009600162506, + 0.4347760081291199 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2256583720445633 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a steady, horizontal medium shot inside a dark, rocky cavern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are three desert warriors visible huddled closely together wearing patchwork suits of gray and sand-colored fabric with scuffs and pipes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single portable luminous globe on the ground casting warm yellow light and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the warriors have eyes completely shrouded in a deep, star-like blue without any white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the warriors shown leaning forward slightly with small, precise gestures while whispering in hushed tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3135663568973541 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3135663270950317 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3135663568973541, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3135663568973541, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12487737089395523, + 0.07184485346078873, + 0.04134311527013779, + 0.05984488129615784, + 0.026974130421876907, + 0.09506020694971085, + 0.1075478121638298, + 0.138248011469841, + 0.2147650271654129, + 0.11949461698532104 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3135663568973541 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "steady, horizontal medium shot plunges the viewer deep into a dark, rocky cavern, where three desert warriors huddle closely together. They wear still suits patchworked from gray and sand-colored fabric, their surfaces covered in scuffs, eroded by sand, and crudely patched. Complex pipes and recycling equipment cling to their bodies, reflecting a faint metallic sheen in the dim light. The only light comes from a portable luminous globe on the ground between them. Its faint, warm yellow light shines upward, casting deep, dynamic shadows on their weathered faces, making every wrinkle carved by the sun and wind-blown sand appear jagged and distinct. Most striking are their eyes, devoid of any white, completely shrouded in a deep, star-like blue, amplified by the warm glow. They lean forward slightly, whispering in hushed tones, their lips barely moving, their voices as low as the rustling of windblown sand. One of them would occasionally glance quickly towards the darkness of the cave entrance, his eyes sharp as an eagle, while the other would respond to his companion's words with an almost imperceptible nod. Their gestures were extremely small and precise, and every subtle movement was full of high vigilance and unspoken tacit understanding. The whole scene was filled with a tense, secretive and solemn atmosphere.", + "seed": 6632, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000272/group_4/index_4126_seed_6632_dp_9_rank_18_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.12824647454544902, + "vlm_logprob": -0.12824647454544902, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.849999988079071, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.12824647454544902, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a steady, horizontal medium shot inside a dark, rocky cavern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are three desert warriors visible huddled closely together wearing patchwork suits of gray and sand-colored fabric with scuffs and pipes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single portable luminous globe on the ground casting warm yellow light and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the warriors have eyes completely shrouded in a deep, star-like blue without any white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the warriors shown leaning forward slightly with small, precise gestures while whispering in hushed tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02339836023747921 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8983983993530273 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02339836023747921, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02339836023747921, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09908239543437958, + 0.26188960671424866, + 0.022518014535307884, + 0.027732551097869873, + 0.02605753019452095, + 0.02460896410048008, + 0.45553267002105713, + 0.053193505853414536, + 0.009648622013628483, + 0.01973617449402809 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02339836023747921 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a steady, horizontal medium shot inside a dark, rocky cavern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are three desert warriors visible huddled closely together wearing patchwork suits of gray and sand-colored fabric with scuffs and pipes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single portable luminous globe on the ground casting warm yellow light and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the warriors have eyes completely shrouded in a deep, star-like blue without any white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the warriors shown leaning forward slightly with small, precise gestures while whispering in hushed tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04309023171663284 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168090343475342 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04309023171663284, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04309023171663284, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.060769543051719666, + 0.5419904589653015, + 0.04994945228099823, + 0.03567530959844589, + 0.04374365881085396, + 0.03259701281785965, + 0.07114849984645844, + 0.09174656122922897, + 0.05915210768580437, + 0.013227359391748905 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04309023171663284 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a steady, horizontal medium shot inside a dark, rocky cavern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are three desert warriors visible huddled closely together wearing patchwork suits of gray and sand-colored fabric with scuffs and pipes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single portable luminous globe on the ground casting warm yellow light and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the warriors have eyes completely shrouded in a deep, star-like blue without any white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the warriors shown leaning forward slightly with small, precise gestures while whispering in hushed tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007634628098458052 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.88263463973999 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007634628098458052, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007634628098458052, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04086742177605629, + 0.3451381325721741, + 0.012438442558050156, + 0.019289525225758553, + 0.0936112105846405, + 0.0341927632689476, + 0.38206520676612854, + 0.04425886273384094, + 0.021229213103652, + 0.006909118965268135 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007634628098458052 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a steady, horizontal medium shot inside a dark, rocky cavern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are three desert warriors visible huddled closely together wearing patchwork suits of gray and sand-colored fabric with scuffs and pipes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single portable luminous globe on the ground casting warm yellow light and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the warriors have eyes completely shrouded in a deep, star-like blue without any white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the warriors shown leaning forward slightly with small, precise gestures while whispering in hushed tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.38713008165359497 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1371300220489502 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.38713008165359497, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.7499999403953552, + "token_credit_reward": -0.38713008165359497, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10226333886384964, + 0.2797345817089081, + 0.04868987575173378, + 0.032567448914051056, + 0.1201733946800232, + 0.08256176114082336, + 0.217194601893425, + 0.04678346589207649, + 0.0488334558904171, + 0.02119804173707962 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.38713008165359497 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a steady, horizontal medium shot inside a dark, rocky cavern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are three desert warriors visible huddled closely together wearing patchwork suits of gray and sand-colored fabric with scuffs and pipes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single portable luminous globe on the ground casting warm yellow light and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the warriors have eyes completely shrouded in a deep, star-like blue without any white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the warriors shown leaning forward slightly with small, precise gestures while whispering in hushed tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17997907102108002 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8049790859222412 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17997907102108002, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17997907102108002, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04210923984646797, + 0.5357274413108826, + 0.02272886224091053, + 0.014808855950832367, + 0.021213946864008904, + 0.03938018158078194, + 0.0511074960231781, + 0.12495285272598267, + 0.12943926453590393, + 0.018531857058405876 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17997907102108002 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "steady, horizontal medium shot plunges the viewer deep into a dark, rocky cavern, where three desert warriors huddle closely together. They wear still suits patchworked from gray and sand-colored fabric, their surfaces covered in scuffs, eroded by sand, and crudely patched. Complex pipes and recycling equipment cling to their bodies, reflecting a faint metallic sheen in the dim light. The only light comes from a portable luminous globe on the ground between them. Its faint, warm yellow light shines upward, casting deep, dynamic shadows on their weathered faces, making every wrinkle carved by the sun and wind-blown sand appear jagged and distinct. Most striking are their eyes, devoid of any white, completely shrouded in a deep, star-like blue, amplified by the warm glow. They lean forward slightly, whispering in hushed tones, their lips barely moving, their voices as low as the rustling of windblown sand. One of them would occasionally glance quickly towards the darkness of the cave entrance, his eyes sharp as an eagle, while the other would respond to his companion's words with an almost imperceptible nod. Their gestures were extremely small and precise, and every subtle movement was full of high vigilance and unspoken tacit understanding. The whole scene was filled with a tense, secretive and solemn atmosphere.", + "seed": 6633, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000272/group_4/index_4126_seed_6633_dp_9_rank_18_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.12399650793522596, + "vlm_logprob": -0.12399650793522596, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.725, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.12399650793522596, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a steady, horizontal medium shot inside a dark, rocky cavern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are three desert warriors visible huddled closely together wearing patchwork suits of gray and sand-colored fabric with scuffs and pipes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single portable luminous globe on the ground casting warm yellow light and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the warriors have eyes completely shrouded in a deep, star-like blue without any white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the warriors shown leaning forward slightly with small, precise gestures while whispering in hushed tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03959359601140022 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2895936965942383 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03959359601140022, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03959359601140022, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11062530428171158, + 0.06947740167379379, + 0.08206330984830856, + 0.017748713493347168, + 0.08168980479240417, + 0.33697816729545593, + 0.09736576676368713, + 0.022723695263266563, + 0.07431977242231369, + 0.10700807720422745 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03959359601140022 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a steady, horizontal medium shot inside a dark, rocky cavern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are three desert warriors visible huddled closely together wearing patchwork suits of gray and sand-colored fabric with scuffs and pipes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single portable luminous globe on the ground casting warm yellow light and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the warriors have eyes completely shrouded in a deep, star-like blue without any white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the warriors shown leaning forward slightly with small, precise gestures while whispering in hushed tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03813757747411728 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288137674331665 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03813757747411728, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03813757747411728, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09044928848743439, + 0.07515702396631241, + 0.03464881703257561, + 0.09203039854764938, + 0.07709173858165741, + 0.4038470387458801, + 0.06057080626487732, + 0.06880638748407364, + 0.040943749248981476, + 0.05645471066236496 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03813757747411728 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a steady, horizontal medium shot inside a dark, rocky cavern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are three desert warriors visible huddled closely together wearing patchwork suits of gray and sand-colored fabric with scuffs and pipes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single portable luminous globe on the ground casting warm yellow light and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the warriors have eyes completely shrouded in a deep, star-like blue without any white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the warriors shown leaning forward slightly with small, precise gestures while whispering in hushed tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008644777350127697 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.7586445808410645 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008644777350127697, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008644777350127697, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04781375080347061, + 0.047739140689373016, + 0.01365971565246582, + 0.031441982835531235, + 0.19458864629268646, + 0.012279205955564976, + 0.56395024061203, + 0.021147122606635094, + 0.02366742119193077, + 0.04371272400021553 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008644777350127697 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a steady, horizontal medium shot inside a dark, rocky cavern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are three desert warriors visible huddled closely together wearing patchwork suits of gray and sand-colored fabric with scuffs and pipes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single portable luminous globe on the ground casting warm yellow light and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the warriors have eyes completely shrouded in a deep, star-like blue without any white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the warriors shown leaning forward slightly with small, precise gestures while whispering in hushed tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2521528899669647 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.502152919769287 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2521528899669647, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2521528899669647, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08022619038820267, + 0.050533365458250046, + 0.0407583974301815, + 0.10824044048786163, + 0.042759280651807785, + 0.030597450211644173, + 0.13642993569374084, + 0.1900012195110321, + 0.19886156916618347, + 0.12159208953380585 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2521528899669647 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a steady, horizontal medium shot inside a dark, rocky cavern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are three desert warriors visible huddled closely together wearing patchwork suits of gray and sand-colored fabric with scuffs and pipes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single portable luminous globe on the ground casting warm yellow light and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the warriors have eyes completely shrouded in a deep, star-like blue without any white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the warriors shown leaning forward slightly with small, precise gestures while whispering in hushed tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2814536988735199 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4064537286758423 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2814536988735199, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2814536988735199, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09791627526283264, + 0.03930659964680672, + 0.03923531249165535, + 0.07752125710248947, + 0.14912769198417664, + 0.20090417563915253, + 0.14839518070220947, + 0.03598335012793541, + 0.052536480128765106, + 0.15907372534275055 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2814536988735199 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000272/group_5/index_tensor([4693, 4693])_group_5_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000272/group_5/index_tensor([4693, 4693])_group_5_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..621ba85da3e0a689512ed561e5967718a2243139 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000272/group_5/index_tensor([4693, 4693])_group_5_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "low-angle, wide-angle shot from the edge of the platform, the camera held still, facing the deep, dark maw of the tunnel. Suddenly, two incredibly bright, piercing LED headlights pierce the pitch blackness, casting long, cool, slightly haloed beams of light. A modern, silver-gray subway train, accompanied by a rapidly escalating roar, bursts forth from the darkness at high speed. The sleek metal body reflects a cold, flowing light from the rows of fluorescent lights on the platform. A distinctive yellow stripe on the side transforms into a streak of light as it moves at high speed, casting a massive, swiftly moving shadow across the polished concrete floor. With a sharp screeching sound of brakes, the train slows, its massive form gliding steadily and deliberately into the brightly lit platform area, finally coming to a smooth and precise stop alongside the yellow safety line. The warm light from the train windows contrasts sharply with the cool tones of the platform, imbuing the scene with the dynamic power of the city's pulse and the tranquility of the moment that is about to begin.", + "seed": 22344, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000272/group_5/index_4693_seed_22344_dp_10_rank_20_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.3377933666110039, + "vlm_logprob": -0.3377933666110039, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.775, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.3377933666110039, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.6, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low-angle, wide-angle perspective at the edge of a platform?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still while facing the dark tunnel entrance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a modern silver-gray subway train with a distinctive yellow stripe burst from the tunnel at high speed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the train slow down with screeching brakes and stop precisely alongside a yellow safety line?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by cool fluorescent platform lights and warm light from the train windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008727265521883965 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.508727073669434 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008727265521883965, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008727265521883965, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15604239702224731, + 0.11893697828054428, + 0.0729769915342331, + 0.03715428709983826, + 0.08342702686786652, + 0.26849156618118286, + 0.10970853269100189, + 0.027486581355333328, + 0.04247302934527397, + 0.08330259472131729 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008727265521883965 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low-angle, wide-angle perspective at the edge of a platform?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still while facing the dark tunnel entrance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a modern silver-gray subway train with a distinctive yellow stripe burst from the tunnel at high speed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the train slow down with screeching brakes and stop precisely alongside a yellow safety line?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by cool fluorescent platform lights and warm light from the train windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.898368239402771 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.523368239402771 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.898368239402771, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.898368239402771, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12218057364225388, + 0.154231995344162, + 0.14308372139930725, + 0.05493283271789551, + 0.1703881174325943, + 0.20471471548080444, + 0.060793034732341766, + 0.03263062611222267, + 0.03957425057888031, + 0.017470072954893112 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.898368239402771 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low-angle, wide-angle perspective at the edge of a platform?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still while facing the dark tunnel entrance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a modern silver-gray subway train with a distinctive yellow stripe burst from the tunnel at high speed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the train slow down with screeching brakes and stop precisely alongside a yellow safety line?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by cool fluorescent platform lights and warm light from the train windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014216220006346703 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264216423034668 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014216220006346703, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014216220006346703, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03668469563126564, + 0.07648970186710358, + 0.08688906580209732, + 0.028369810432195663, + 0.0523298941552639, + 0.5564786195755005, + 0.045284487307071686, + 0.04041396453976631, + 0.04206418991088867, + 0.03499554470181465 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014216220006346703 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low-angle, wide-angle perspective at the edge of a platform?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still while facing the dark tunnel entrance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a modern silver-gray subway train with a distinctive yellow stripe burst from the tunnel at high speed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the train slow down with screeching brakes and stop precisely alongside a yellow safety line?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by cool fluorescent platform lights and warm light from the train windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7578480839729309 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6328480839729309 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.7578480839729309, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.7578480839729309, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06087623909115791, + 0.10288179665803909, + 0.07770854234695435, + 0.04761485010385513, + 0.04739682376384735, + 0.4722640812397003, + 0.022444674745202065, + 0.09890002012252808, + 0.031589001417160034, + 0.03832397982478142 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.7578480839729309 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low-angle, wide-angle perspective at the edge of a platform?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still while facing the dark tunnel entrance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a modern silver-gray subway train with a distinctive yellow stripe burst from the tunnel at high speed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the train slow down with screeching brakes and stop precisely alongside a yellow safety line?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by cool fluorescent platform lights and warm light from the train windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009807024151086807 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634807109832764 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009807024151086807, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009807024151086807, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05974319949746132, + 0.041944436728954315, + 0.07609758526086807, + 0.03817598149180412, + 0.08331021666526794, + 0.5948362946510315, + 0.031764354556798935, + 0.016266385093331337, + 0.027856357395648956, + 0.03000520169734955 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009807024151086807 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, wide-angle shot from the edge of the platform, the camera held still, facing the deep, dark maw of the tunnel. Suddenly, two incredibly bright, piercing LED headlights pierce the pitch blackness, casting long, cool, slightly haloed beams of light. A modern, silver-gray subway train, accompanied by a rapidly escalating roar, bursts forth from the darkness at high speed. The sleek metal body reflects a cold, flowing light from the rows of fluorescent lights on the platform. A distinctive yellow stripe on the side transforms into a streak of light as it moves at high speed, casting a massive, swiftly moving shadow across the polished concrete floor. With a sharp screeching sound of brakes, the train slows, its massive form gliding steadily and deliberately into the brightly lit platform area, finally coming to a smooth and precise stop alongside the yellow safety line. The warm light from the train windows contrasts sharply with the cool tones of the platform, imbuing the scene with the dynamic power of the city's pulse and the tranquility of the moment that is about to begin.", + "seed": 22345, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000272/group_5/index_4693_seed_22345_dp_10_rank_20_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.2685074765235186, + "vlm_logprob": -0.2685074765235186, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.9, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.2685074765235186, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low-angle, wide-angle perspective at the edge of a platform?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still while facing the dark tunnel entrance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a modern silver-gray subway train with a distinctive yellow stripe burst from the tunnel at high speed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the train slow down with screeching brakes and stop precisely alongside a yellow safety line?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by cool fluorescent platform lights and warm light from the train windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.010582166723906994 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.135581970214844 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.010582166723906994, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.010582166723906994, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09604714065790176, + 0.06396740674972534, + 0.10715188086032867, + 0.13047640025615692, + 0.08135299384593964, + 0.15480798482894897, + 0.14803685247898102, + 0.04755190759897232, + 0.05013894662261009, + 0.12046846002340317 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 6, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.010582166723906994 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low-angle, wide-angle perspective at the edge of a platform?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still while facing the dark tunnel entrance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a modern silver-gray subway train with a distinctive yellow stripe burst from the tunnel at high speed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the train slow down with screeching brakes and stop precisely alongside a yellow safety line?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by cool fluorescent platform lights and warm light from the train windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.0539414882659912 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4289414882659912 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.0539414882659912, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.625, + "token_credit_reward": -1.0539414882659912, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08962925523519516, + 0.08513323217630386, + 0.06375394016504288, + 0.2815677523612976, + 0.09953363239765167, + 0.055476173758506775, + 0.06496916711330414, + 0.0476972833275795, + 0.03868255764245987, + 0.17355696856975555 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.0539414882659912 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low-angle, wide-angle perspective at the edge of a platform?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still while facing the dark tunnel entrance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a modern silver-gray subway train with a distinctive yellow stripe burst from the tunnel at high speed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the train slow down with screeching brakes and stop precisely alongside a yellow safety line?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by cool fluorescent platform lights and warm light from the train windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0160837359726429 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141083717346191 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0160837359726429, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0160837359726429, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09135086834430695, + 0.16987016797065735, + 0.057253241539001465, + 0.16846254467964172, + 0.09124955534934998, + 0.05264832451939583, + 0.10130229592323303, + 0.06516210734844208, + 0.06050524488091469, + 0.1421956717967987 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0160837359726429 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low-angle, wide-angle perspective at the edge of a platform?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still while facing the dark tunnel entrance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a modern silver-gray subway train with a distinctive yellow stripe burst from the tunnel at high speed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the train slow down with screeching brakes and stop precisely alongside a yellow safety line?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by cool fluorescent platform lights and warm light from the train windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.25213193893432617 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5021319389343262 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.25213193893432617, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.25213193893432617, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12051742523908615, + 0.08617051690816879, + 0.0911140888929367, + 0.18250226974487305, + 0.06525169312953949, + 0.055439259856939316, + 0.06283058971166611, + 0.017727091908454895, + 0.07221460342407227, + 0.2462325096130371 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.25213193893432617 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low-angle, wide-angle perspective at the edge of a platform?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still while facing the dark tunnel entrance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a modern silver-gray subway train with a distinctive yellow stripe burst from the tunnel at high speed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the train slow down with screeching brakes and stop precisely alongside a yellow safety line?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by cool fluorescent platform lights and warm light from the train windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009798052720725536 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634798049926758 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009798052720725536, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009798052720725536, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19012904167175293, + 0.06596530973911285, + 0.08753788471221924, + 0.11099977046251297, + 0.13851423561573029, + 0.047634921967983246, + 0.04524252936244011, + 0.0502728708088398, + 0.20141811668872833, + 0.06228538230061531 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009798052720725536 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, wide-angle shot from the edge of the platform, the camera held still, facing the deep, dark maw of the tunnel. Suddenly, two incredibly bright, piercing LED headlights pierce the pitch blackness, casting long, cool, slightly haloed beams of light. A modern, silver-gray subway train, accompanied by a rapidly escalating roar, bursts forth from the darkness at high speed. The sleek metal body reflects a cold, flowing light from the rows of fluorescent lights on the platform. A distinctive yellow stripe on the side transforms into a streak of light as it moves at high speed, casting a massive, swiftly moving shadow across the polished concrete floor. With a sharp screeching sound of brakes, the train slows, its massive form gliding steadily and deliberately into the brightly lit platform area, finally coming to a smooth and precise stop alongside the yellow safety line. The warm light from the train windows contrasts sharply with the cool tones of the platform, imbuing the scene with the dynamic power of the city's pulse and the tranquility of the moment that is about to begin.", + "seed": 22346, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000272/group_5/index_4693_seed_22346_dp_11_rank_22_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.43348466558381915, + "vlm_logprob": -0.43348466558381915, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.624999988079071, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.43348466558381915, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low-angle, wide-angle perspective at the edge of a platform?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still while facing the dark tunnel entrance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a modern silver-gray subway train with a distinctive yellow stripe burst from the tunnel at high speed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the train slow down with screeching brakes and stop precisely alongside a yellow safety line?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by cool fluorescent platform lights and warm light from the train windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009557443670928478 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.134557247161865 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009557443670928478, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009557443670928478, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3462170362472534, + 0.0580778531730175, + 0.10648781806230545, + 0.04927081987261772, + 0.07550057023763657, + 0.09076355397701263, + 0.11886519938707352, + 0.030321195721626282, + 0.05773564428091049, + 0.06676028668880463 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009557443670928478 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low-angle, wide-angle perspective at the edge of a platform?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still while facing the dark tunnel entrance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a modern silver-gray subway train with a distinctive yellow stripe burst from the tunnel at high speed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the train slow down with screeching brakes and stop precisely alongside a yellow safety line?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by cool fluorescent platform lights and warm light from the train windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4289119839668274 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.0539119243621826 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.4289119839668274, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.6249999403953552, + "token_credit_reward": -0.4289119839668274, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1679745316505432, + 0.15769736468791962, + 0.1667623668909073, + 0.0831950381398201, + 0.05366387218236923, + 0.023958364501595497, + 0.07323315739631653, + 0.0706251785159111, + 0.17159853875637054, + 0.031291596591472626 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.4289119839668274 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low-angle, wide-angle perspective at the edge of a platform?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still while facing the dark tunnel entrance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a modern silver-gray subway train with a distinctive yellow stripe burst from the tunnel at high speed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the train slow down with screeching brakes and stop precisely alongside a yellow safety line?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by cool fluorescent platform lights and warm light from the train windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0067449514754116535 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006744861602783 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0067449514754116535, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0067449514754116535, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1819181889295578, + 0.058826085180044174, + 0.07622818648815155, + 0.08457110077142715, + 0.0912306159734726, + 0.19641777873039246, + 0.0329693928360939, + 0.03670599311590195, + 0.14564990997314453, + 0.09548275172710419 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0067449514754116535 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low-angle, wide-angle perspective at the edge of a platform?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still while facing the dark tunnel entrance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a modern silver-gray subway train with a distinctive yellow stripe burst from the tunnel at high speed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the train slow down with screeching brakes and stop precisely alongside a yellow safety line?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by cool fluorescent platform lights and warm light from the train windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.701568603515625 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2015685737133026 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.701568603515625, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -1.701568603515625, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.294528603553772, + 0.1178913563489914, + 0.09725914150476456, + 0.05019068717956543, + 0.03519390523433685, + 0.08015124499797821, + 0.04420426860451698, + 0.03710222616791725, + 0.17276450991630554, + 0.07071403414011002 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.701568603515625 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low-angle, wide-angle perspective at the edge of a platform?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still while facing the dark tunnel entrance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a modern silver-gray subway train with a distinctive yellow stripe burst from the tunnel at high speed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the train slow down with screeching brakes and stop precisely alongside a yellow safety line?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by cool fluorescent platform lights and warm light from the train windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02064034529030323 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8956403732299805 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02064034529030323, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02064034529030323, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2119286060333252, + 0.14399057626724243, + 0.1186111643910408, + 0.050084587186574936, + 0.07468343526124954, + 0.12953099608421326, + 0.06384169310331345, + 0.027019713073968887, + 0.11847400665283203, + 0.0618351511657238 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02064034529030323 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, wide-angle shot from the edge of the platform, the camera held still, facing the deep, dark maw of the tunnel. Suddenly, two incredibly bright, piercing LED headlights pierce the pitch blackness, casting long, cool, slightly haloed beams of light. A modern, silver-gray subway train, accompanied by a rapidly escalating roar, bursts forth from the darkness at high speed. The sleek metal body reflects a cold, flowing light from the rows of fluorescent lights on the platform. A distinctive yellow stripe on the side transforms into a streak of light as it moves at high speed, casting a massive, swiftly moving shadow across the polished concrete floor. With a sharp screeching sound of brakes, the train slows, its massive form gliding steadily and deliberately into the brightly lit platform area, finally coming to a smooth and precise stop alongside the yellow safety line. The warm light from the train windows contrasts sharply with the cool tones of the platform, imbuing the scene with the dynamic power of the city's pulse and the tranquility of the moment that is about to begin.", + "seed": 22347, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000272/group_5/index_4693_seed_22347_dp_11_rank_22_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.31245614122599363, + "vlm_logprob": -0.31245614122599363, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.875, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.31245614122599363, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low-angle, wide-angle perspective at the edge of a platform?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still while facing the dark tunnel entrance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a modern silver-gray subway train with a distinctive yellow stripe burst from the tunnel at high speed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the train slow down with screeching brakes and stop precisely alongside a yellow safety line?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by cool fluorescent platform lights and warm light from the train windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008249021135270596 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.633248805999756 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008249021135270596, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008249021135270596, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17778821289539337, + 0.05129672586917877, + 0.05608775094151497, + 0.06585648655891418, + 0.1287478655576706, + 0.2640814781188965, + 0.038304924964904785, + 0.021365752443671227, + 0.14228618144989014, + 0.054184697568416595 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008249021135270596 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low-angle, wide-angle perspective at the edge of a platform?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still while facing the dark tunnel entrance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a modern silver-gray subway train with a distinctive yellow stripe burst from the tunnel at high speed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the train slow down with screeching brakes and stop precisely alongside a yellow safety line?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by cool fluorescent platform lights and warm light from the train windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6328290104866028 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7578290104866028 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.6328290104866028, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.6328290104866028, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0747443214058876, + 0.02042488567531109, + 0.0253605954349041, + 0.041595183312892914, + 0.23077185451984406, + 0.16085505485534668, + 0.01992107182741165, + 0.014660853892564774, + 0.29567086696624756, + 0.11599528044462204 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.6328290104866028 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low-angle, wide-angle perspective at the edge of a platform?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still while facing the dark tunnel entrance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a modern silver-gray subway train with a distinctive yellow stripe burst from the tunnel at high speed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the train slow down with screeching brakes and stop precisely alongside a yellow safety line?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by cool fluorescent platform lights and warm light from the train windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01420564204454422 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264205455780029 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01420564204454422, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01420564204454422, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15082046389579773, + 0.02367747761309147, + 0.0705127939581871, + 0.04497174918651581, + 0.06415168195962906, + 0.2662671208381653, + 0.0252317376434803, + 0.012182814069092274, + 0.19970831274986267, + 0.14247584342956543 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01420564204454422 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low-angle, wide-angle perspective at the edge of a platform?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still while facing the dark tunnel entrance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a modern silver-gray subway train with a distinctive yellow stripe burst from the tunnel at high speed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the train slow down with screeching brakes and stop precisely alongside a yellow safety line?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by cool fluorescent platform lights and warm light from the train windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8983442187309265 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5233442187309265 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.8983442187309265, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.8983442187309265, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08167615532875061, + 0.030002402141690254, + 0.05245266482234001, + 0.03700922057032585, + 0.13624124228954315, + 0.1263868808746338, + 0.05571206286549568, + 0.020439090207219124, + 0.34055057168006897, + 0.11952967196702957 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.8983442187309265 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low-angle, wide-angle perspective at the edge of a platform?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still while facing the dark tunnel entrance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a modern silver-gray subway train with a distinctive yellow stripe burst from the tunnel at high speed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the train slow down with screeching brakes and stop precisely alongside a yellow safety line?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by cool fluorescent platform lights and warm light from the train windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008652813732624054 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758652687072754 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008652813732624054, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008652813732624054, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15742656588554382, + 0.05212818458676338, + 0.06381189078092575, + 0.04652536287903786, + 0.13803499937057495, + 0.15241828560829163, + 0.03353218734264374, + 0.02519250102341175, + 0.253341406583786, + 0.07758868485689163 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008652813732624054 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000272/group_6/index_tensor([9780, 9780])_group_6_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000272/group_6/index_tensor([9780, 9780])_group_6_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..ad8c8cbce5d0dcba9cf2b38479485408f5b9fdd1 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000272/group_6/index_tensor([9780, 9780])_group_6_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "static, high-angle, top-down shot provides a direct, bird's-eye view, peering directly down into the heart of the dense rainforest canopy. The frame centers on an intricately woven bird's nest, a vibrantly colored marvel composed of iridescent beetle carapaces, vibrant purple orchid petals, and shimmering green moss. Inside, three tiny chicks huddle closely together, covered in soft, pale yellow down. They tilt their heads upward in a unified, expectant gesture, their tiny black beaks open in silent anticipation. The nest is firmly nestled in the fork of a massive, lichen-covered branch, surrounded by broad, waxy leaves that emanate moisture. Beneath this intimate scene, the colossal forms of the ancient rainforest giants create an intricate mosaic of deep green foliage, their true scale hinted at only by the tiny gaps between the leaves above. Filtered, ethereal sunlight penetrates the dense canopy, making individual leaves shimmer and casting a soft, dappled light over the nest, creating an atmosphere of tranquility, sacredness, and a deeply immersive new life hidden in the wilderness.", + "seed": 19719, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000272/group_6/index_9780_seed_19719_dp_12_rank_24_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.40051366584375503, + "vlm_logprob": -0.40051366584375503, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.025, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.40051366584375503, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, high-angle, top-down view looking directly down?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an intricately woven bird's nest made of iridescent beetle carapaces, purple orchid petals, and green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are three tiny chicks with pale yellow down huddled inside the nest with their heads tilted upward and beaks open?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the nest nestled in the fork of a massive, lichen-covered branch surrounded by broad, waxy leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by filtered, ethereal sunlight creating a soft, dappled light effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9118276834487915 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1618276834487915 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.9118276834487915, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -1.9118276834487915, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.34842103719711304, + 0.052190884947776794, + 0.060458920896053314, + 0.04581109434366226, + 0.23644985258579254, + 0.03414503112435341, + 0.042891744524240494, + 0.054234232753515244, + 0.04841998592019081, + 0.07697725296020508 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.9118276834487915 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, high-angle, top-down view looking directly down?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an intricately woven bird's nest made of iridescent beetle carapaces, purple orchid petals, and green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are three tiny chicks with pale yellow down huddled inside the nest with their heads tilted upward and beaks open?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the nest nestled in the fork of a massive, lichen-covered branch surrounded by broad, waxy leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by filtered, ethereal sunlight creating a soft, dappled light effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.062166254967451096 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812166213989258 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.062166254967451096, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.062166254967451096, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4178767204284668, + 0.03471918776631355, + 0.05229467898607254, + 0.033144596964120865, + 0.25700700283050537, + 0.03524203598499298, + 0.029029516503214836, + 0.04152372479438782, + 0.03822635859251022, + 0.060936108231544495 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.062166254967451096 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, high-angle, top-down view looking directly down?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an intricately woven bird's nest made of iridescent beetle carapaces, purple orchid petals, and green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are three tiny chicks with pale yellow down huddled inside the nest with their heads tilted upward and beaks open?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the nest nestled in the fork of a massive, lichen-covered branch surrounded by broad, waxy leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by filtered, ethereal sunlight creating a soft, dappled light effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006746253930032253 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006746292114258 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006746253930032253, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006746253930032253, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2588837444782257, + 0.04880715534090996, + 0.07274186611175537, + 0.07355447858572006, + 0.26839810609817505, + 0.03605275973677635, + 0.04088231921195984, + 0.07741785049438477, + 0.05729593336582184, + 0.06596580147743225 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006746253930032253 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, high-angle, top-down view looking directly down?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an intricately woven bird's nest made of iridescent beetle carapaces, purple orchid petals, and green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are three tiny chicks with pale yellow down huddled inside the nest with their heads tilted upward and beaks open?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the nest nestled in the fork of a massive, lichen-covered branch surrounded by broad, waxy leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by filtered, ethereal sunlight creating a soft, dappled light effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007630369160324335 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882630348205566 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007630369160324335, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007630369160324335, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2210494428873062, + 0.05556177720427513, + 0.11525565385818481, + 0.08713319897651672, + 0.216120183467865, + 0.06439525634050369, + 0.06290094554424286, + 0.039819151163101196, + 0.04583531618118286, + 0.09192909300327301 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007630369160324335 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, high-angle, top-down view looking directly down?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an intricately woven bird's nest made of iridescent beetle carapaces, purple orchid petals, and green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are three tiny chicks with pale yellow down huddled inside the nest with their heads tilted upward and beaks open?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the nest nestled in the fork of a massive, lichen-covered branch surrounded by broad, waxy leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by filtered, ethereal sunlight creating a soft, dappled light effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014197767712175846 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264197826385498 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014197767712175846, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014197767712175846, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2063823938369751, + 0.07014922052621841, + 0.0772768035531044, + 0.08039708435535431, + 0.27149996161460876, + 0.05744418874382973, + 0.04821453616023064, + 0.05504975840449333, + 0.05240272730588913, + 0.08118337392807007 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014197767712175846 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, high-angle, top-down shot provides a direct, bird's-eye view, peering directly down into the heart of the dense rainforest canopy. The frame centers on an intricately woven bird's nest, a vibrantly colored marvel composed of iridescent beetle carapaces, vibrant purple orchid petals, and shimmering green moss. Inside, three tiny chicks huddle closely together, covered in soft, pale yellow down. They tilt their heads upward in a unified, expectant gesture, their tiny black beaks open in silent anticipation. The nest is firmly nestled in the fork of a massive, lichen-covered branch, surrounded by broad, waxy leaves that emanate moisture. Beneath this intimate scene, the colossal forms of the ancient rainforest giants create an intricate mosaic of deep green foliage, their true scale hinted at only by the tiny gaps between the leaves above. Filtered, ethereal sunlight penetrates the dense canopy, making individual leaves shimmer and casting a soft, dappled light over the nest, creating an atmosphere of tranquility, sacredness, and a deeply immersive new life hidden in the wilderness.", + "seed": 19720, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000272/group_6/index_9780_seed_19720_dp_12_rank_24_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.20029324647039176, + "vlm_logprob": -0.20029324647039176, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.375, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.20029324647039176, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, high-angle, top-down view looking directly down?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an intricately woven bird's nest made of iridescent beetle carapaces, purple orchid petals, and green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are three tiny chicks with pale yellow down huddled inside the nest with their heads tilted upward and beaks open?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the nest nestled in the fork of a massive, lichen-covered branch surrounded by broad, waxy leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by filtered, ethereal sunlight creating a soft, dappled light effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9003185629844666 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5253185629844666 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.9003185629844666, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.9003185629844666, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11967733502388, + 0.045240599662065506, + 0.09297938644886017, + 0.13083413243293762, + 0.10213132947683334, + 0.0805758535861969, + 0.10439326614141464, + 0.10631905496120453, + 0.15674935281276703, + 0.06109964847564697 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.9003185629844666 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, high-angle, top-down view looking directly down?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an intricately woven bird's nest made of iridescent beetle carapaces, purple orchid petals, and green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are three tiny chicks with pale yellow down huddled inside the nest with their heads tilted upward and beaks open?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the nest nestled in the fork of a massive, lichen-covered branch surrounded by broad, waxy leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by filtered, ethereal sunlight creating a soft, dappled light effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07903570681810379 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.579035758972168 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07903570681810379, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07903570681810379, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14952148497104645, + 0.11645469814538956, + 0.0951068326830864, + 0.0843886137008667, + 0.04464733600616455, + 0.07943498343229294, + 0.06628759205341339, + 0.16719718277454376, + 0.13416533172130585, + 0.06279588490724564 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07903570681810379 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, high-angle, top-down view looking directly down?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an intricately woven bird's nest made of iridescent beetle carapaces, purple orchid petals, and green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are three tiny chicks with pale yellow down huddled inside the nest with their heads tilted upward and beaks open?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the nest nestled in the fork of a massive, lichen-covered branch surrounded by broad, waxy leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by filtered, ethereal sunlight creating a soft, dappled light effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006744833197444677 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006744861602783 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006744833197444677, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006744833197444677, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09376855194568634, + 0.0709494948387146, + 0.06842978298664093, + 0.07280665636062622, + 0.08559166640043259, + 0.051417455077171326, + 0.08542774617671967, + 0.17040465772151947, + 0.2607477009296417, + 0.04045626521110535 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006744833197444677 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, high-angle, top-down view looking directly down?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an intricately woven bird's nest made of iridescent beetle carapaces, purple orchid petals, and green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are three tiny chicks with pale yellow down huddled inside the nest with their heads tilted upward and beaks open?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the nest nestled in the fork of a massive, lichen-covered branch surrounded by broad, waxy leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by filtered, ethereal sunlight creating a soft, dappled light effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008635676465928555 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758635520935059 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008635676465928555, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008635676465928555, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07460210472345352, + 0.05881306901574135, + 0.053761307150125504, + 0.05763360857963562, + 0.060418128967285156, + 0.06570490449666977, + 0.04895748198032379, + 0.1363871991634369, + 0.41066527366638184, + 0.0330568291246891 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008635676465928555 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, high-angle, top-down view looking directly down?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an intricately woven bird's nest made of iridescent beetle carapaces, purple orchid petals, and green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are three tiny chicks with pale yellow down huddled inside the nest with their heads tilted upward and beaks open?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the nest nestled in the fork of a massive, lichen-covered branch surrounded by broad, waxy leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by filtered, ethereal sunlight creating a soft, dappled light effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006731452886015177 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.0067315101623535 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006731452886015177, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006731452886015177, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13484245538711548, + 0.05199457332491875, + 0.2303021401166916, + 0.0930224061012268, + 0.051864705979824066, + 0.026698075234889984, + 0.04692495986819267, + 0.23734232783317566, + 0.08691392093896866, + 0.040094468742609024 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006731452886015177 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, high-angle, top-down shot provides a direct, bird's-eye view, peering directly down into the heart of the dense rainforest canopy. The frame centers on an intricately woven bird's nest, a vibrantly colored marvel composed of iridescent beetle carapaces, vibrant purple orchid petals, and shimmering green moss. Inside, three tiny chicks huddle closely together, covered in soft, pale yellow down. They tilt their heads upward in a unified, expectant gesture, their tiny black beaks open in silent anticipation. The nest is firmly nestled in the fork of a massive, lichen-covered branch, surrounded by broad, waxy leaves that emanate moisture. Beneath this intimate scene, the colossal forms of the ancient rainforest giants create an intricate mosaic of deep green foliage, their true scale hinted at only by the tiny gaps between the leaves above. Filtered, ethereal sunlight penetrates the dense canopy, making individual leaves shimmer and casting a soft, dappled light over the nest, creating an atmosphere of tranquility, sacredness, and a deeply immersive new life hidden in the wilderness.", + "seed": 19721, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000272/group_6/index_9780_seed_19721_dp_13_rank_26_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.22027946636080742, + "vlm_logprob": -0.22027946636080742, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.3, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.22027946636080742, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, high-angle, top-down view looking directly down?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an intricately woven bird's nest made of iridescent beetle carapaces, purple orchid petals, and green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are three tiny chicks with pale yellow down huddled inside the nest with their heads tilted upward and beaks open?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the nest nestled in the fork of a massive, lichen-covered branch surrounded by broad, waxy leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by filtered, ethereal sunlight creating a soft, dappled light effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9767622947692871 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4767622649669647 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.9767622947692871, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.9767622947692871, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1941373497247696, + 0.24595637619495392, + 0.17135073244571686, + 0.07056834548711777, + 0.06943178921937943, + 0.03986580669879913, + 0.08203407377004623, + 0.040751706808805466, + 0.028406348079442978, + 0.05749746412038803 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.9767622947692871 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, high-angle, top-down view looking directly down?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an intricately woven bird's nest made of iridescent beetle carapaces, purple orchid petals, and green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are three tiny chicks with pale yellow down huddled inside the nest with their heads tilted upward and beaks open?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the nest nestled in the fork of a massive, lichen-covered branch surrounded by broad, waxy leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by filtered, ethereal sunlight creating a soft, dappled light effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10035819560289383 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.350358247756958 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10035819560289383, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10035819560289383, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14298194646835327, + 0.14020474255084991, + 0.2229941040277481, + 0.12597554922103882, + 0.0288647823035717, + 0.04697585850954056, + 0.08010288327932358, + 0.028499620035290718, + 0.1277036964893341, + 0.055696770548820496 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10035819560289383 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, high-angle, top-down view looking directly down?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an intricately woven bird's nest made of iridescent beetle carapaces, purple orchid petals, and green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are three tiny chicks with pale yellow down huddled inside the nest with their heads tilted upward and beaks open?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the nest nestled in the fork of a massive, lichen-covered branch surrounded by broad, waxy leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by filtered, ethereal sunlight creating a soft, dappled light effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012557249516248703 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387557029724121 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012557249516248703, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012557249516248703, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1689198911190033, + 0.08308014273643494, + 0.25853070616722107, + 0.12777547538280487, + 0.02847016602754593, + 0.04057157784700394, + 0.06100272759795189, + 0.05901758000254631, + 0.10015053302049637, + 0.07248113304376602 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012557249516248703 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, high-angle, top-down view looking directly down?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an intricately woven bird's nest made of iridescent beetle carapaces, purple orchid petals, and green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are three tiny chicks with pale yellow down huddled inside the nest with their heads tilted upward and beaks open?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the nest nestled in the fork of a massive, lichen-covered branch surrounded by broad, waxy leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by filtered, ethereal sunlight creating a soft, dappled light effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0040932451374828815 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504093170166016 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0040932451374828815, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0040932451374828815, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12213447690010071, + 0.13862955570220947, + 0.1982671618461609, + 0.10151119530200958, + 0.056774839758872986, + 0.0662979856133461, + 0.09645868092775345, + 0.05839100107550621, + 0.10132579505443573, + 0.06020932272076607 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0040932451374828815 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, high-angle, top-down view looking directly down?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an intricately woven bird's nest made of iridescent beetle carapaces, purple orchid petals, and green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are three tiny chicks with pale yellow down huddled inside the nest with their heads tilted upward and beaks open?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the nest nestled in the fork of a massive, lichen-covered branch surrounded by broad, waxy leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by filtered, ethereal sunlight creating a soft, dappled light effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007626346778124571 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882626533508301 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007626346778124571, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007626346778124571, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16971896588802338, + 0.19234493374824524, + 0.07881862670183182, + 0.03838268294930458, + 0.053950726985931396, + 0.045047275722026825, + 0.15386416018009186, + 0.15317422151565552, + 0.05551039054989815, + 0.05918802320957184 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007626346778124571 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, high-angle, top-down shot provides a direct, bird's-eye view, peering directly down into the heart of the dense rainforest canopy. The frame centers on an intricately woven bird's nest, a vibrantly colored marvel composed of iridescent beetle carapaces, vibrant purple orchid petals, and shimmering green moss. Inside, three tiny chicks huddle closely together, covered in soft, pale yellow down. They tilt their heads upward in a unified, expectant gesture, their tiny black beaks open in silent anticipation. The nest is firmly nestled in the fork of a massive, lichen-covered branch, surrounded by broad, waxy leaves that emanate moisture. Beneath this intimate scene, the colossal forms of the ancient rainforest giants create an intricate mosaic of deep green foliage, their true scale hinted at only by the tiny gaps between the leaves above. Filtered, ethereal sunlight penetrates the dense canopy, making individual leaves shimmer and casting a soft, dappled light over the nest, creating an atmosphere of tranquility, sacredness, and a deeply immersive new life hidden in the wilderness.", + "seed": 19722, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000272/group_6/index_9780_seed_19722_dp_13_rank_26_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.20872234217822552, + "vlm_logprob": -0.20872234217822552, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.325, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.20872234217822552, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, high-angle, top-down view looking directly down?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an intricately woven bird's nest made of iridescent beetle carapaces, purple orchid petals, and green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are three tiny chicks with pale yellow down huddled inside the nest with their heads tilted upward and beaks open?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the nest nestled in the fork of a massive, lichen-covered branch surrounded by broad, waxy leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by filtered, ethereal sunlight creating a soft, dappled light effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9759582877159119 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.47595828771591187 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.9759582877159119, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.9759582877159119, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21545366942882538, + 0.16185075044631958, + 0.07612761855125427, + 0.10348439961671829, + 0.09338074922561646, + 0.08175643533468246, + 0.021186698228120804, + 0.05126604437828064, + 0.08273746818304062, + 0.1127561628818512 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.9759582877159119 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, high-angle, top-down view looking directly down?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an intricately woven bird's nest made of iridescent beetle carapaces, purple orchid petals, and green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are three tiny chicks with pale yellow down huddled inside the nest with their heads tilted upward and beaks open?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the nest nestled in the fork of a massive, lichen-covered branch surrounded by broad, waxy leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by filtered, ethereal sunlight creating a soft, dappled light effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03815203532576561 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288151979446411 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03815203532576561, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03815203532576561, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13440574705600739, + 0.21968868374824524, + 0.06308775395154953, + 0.06083265691995621, + 0.09589317440986633, + 0.0335003025829792, + 0.03306801617145538, + 0.09121520817279816, + 0.12684370577335358, + 0.1414647400379181 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03815203532576561 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, high-angle, top-down view looking directly down?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an intricately woven bird's nest made of iridescent beetle carapaces, purple orchid petals, and green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are three tiny chicks with pale yellow down huddled inside the nest with their heads tilted upward and beaks open?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the nest nestled in the fork of a massive, lichen-covered branch surrounded by broad, waxy leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by filtered, ethereal sunlight creating a soft, dappled light effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009789789095520973 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634789943695068 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009789789095520973, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009789789095520973, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19301801919937134, + 0.09003133326768875, + 0.05137797072529793, + 0.06828046590089798, + 0.20501597225666046, + 0.08413051813840866, + 0.020689044147729874, + 0.08310866355895996, + 0.09668450057506561, + 0.10766351968050003 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009789789095520973 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, high-angle, top-down view looking directly down?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an intricately woven bird's nest made of iridescent beetle carapaces, purple orchid petals, and green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are three tiny chicks with pale yellow down huddled inside the nest with their heads tilted upward and beaks open?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the nest nestled in the fork of a massive, lichen-covered branch surrounded by broad, waxy leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by filtered, ethereal sunlight creating a soft, dappled light effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008636267855763435 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758636474609375 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008636267855763435, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008636267855763435, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18519195914268494, + 0.11411990970373154, + 0.08191699534654617, + 0.12481663376092911, + 0.11882536113262177, + 0.05102137103676796, + 0.04415381699800491, + 0.11175122857093811, + 0.0758201852440834, + 0.0923825353384018 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008636267855763435 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, high-angle, top-down view looking directly down?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an intricately woven bird's nest made of iridescent beetle carapaces, purple orchid petals, and green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are three tiny chicks with pale yellow down huddled inside the nest with their heads tilted upward and beaks open?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the nest nestled in the fork of a massive, lichen-covered branch surrounded by broad, waxy leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by filtered, ethereal sunlight creating a soft, dappled light effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011075330898165703 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511075496673584 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011075330898165703, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011075330898165703, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25700995326042175, + 0.18867653608322144, + 0.1283721625804901, + 0.10799616575241089, + 0.047019656747579575, + 0.0370541512966156, + 0.03194370120763779, + 0.04840922728180885, + 0.05390150845050812, + 0.09961681813001633 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011075330898165703 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000272/group_8/index_tensor([9365, 9365])_group_8_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000272/group_8/index_tensor([9365, 9365])_group_8_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..164b76ec4f3c080f280b8c5c0d5b1cbf9ea4b4c3 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000272/group_8/index_tensor([9365, 9365])_group_8_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "In a Ghibli-inspired aesthetic, a low-angle medium close-up tilts steadily upward, tracking the graceful, slow-motion ascent of the celestial woman. Her eyes are closed, a serene, blissful expression on her face, a gentle smile on her lips. A divine, ethereal light pours from beyond the frame, capturing the intricate, shimmering gold thread embroidery of constellations on her ancient, flowing, deep blue silk robe. Her pearly hair floats weightlessly around her head like a halo. A long, colorful ribbon trails around her waist, composed of soft pinks, gentle lavenders, and pale yellows, dancing and undulating languidly in the air. The atmosphere is filled with tiny, luminous dust particles that drift and shimmer like fireflies against the backdrop of a soft-focus, painterly sky. Dusk clouds are rendered in beautiful, blended lines of rose, orange, and violet, creating a scene of profoundly magical and tranquility.", + "seed": 19753, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000272/group_8/index_9365_seed_19753_dp_16_rank_32_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.04631766173988581, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04631766173988581, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.0, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04631766173988581, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a low-angle medium close-up that tilts steadily upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central character a woman wearing an ancient, flowing deep blue silk robe with gold thread embroidery of constellations?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman's expression serene with closed eyes and a gentle smile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a long ribbon composed of soft pinks, gentle lavenders, and pale yellows trailing from her waist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a soft-focus sky with dusk clouds in rose, orange, and violet hues?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1641395092010498 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9141395092010498 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1641395092010498, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1641395092010498, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1458323448896408, + 0.10792611539363861, + 0.10773065686225891, + 0.14550074934959412, + 0.04741876572370529, + 0.05533218756318092, + 0.03624335303902626, + 0.05405586212873459, + 0.07245394587516785, + 0.22750598192214966 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1641395092010498 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a low-angle medium close-up that tilts steadily upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central character a woman wearing an ancient, flowing deep blue silk robe with gold thread embroidery of constellations?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman's expression serene with closed eyes and a gentle smile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a long ribbon composed of soft pinks, gentle lavenders, and pale yellows trailing from her waist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a soft-focus sky with dusk clouds in rose, orange, and violet hues?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009795219637453556 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634795188903809 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009795219637453556, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009795219637453556, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2309100329875946, + 0.10002816468477249, + 0.11570647358894348, + 0.09885723888874054, + 0.10775665938854218, + 0.09074226766824722, + 0.03284216672182083, + 0.047624193131923676, + 0.048716429620981216, + 0.12681640684604645 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009795219637453556 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a low-angle medium close-up that tilts steadily upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central character a woman wearing an ancient, flowing deep blue silk robe with gold thread embroidery of constellations?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman's expression serene with closed eyes and a gentle smile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a long ribbon composed of soft pinks, gentle lavenders, and pale yellows trailing from her waist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a soft-focus sky with dusk clouds in rose, orange, and violet hues?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02980225533246994 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298023223876953 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02980225533246994, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02980225533246994, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09639818221330643, + 0.26215633749961853, + 0.05967514216899872, + 0.12506282329559326, + 0.052071839570999146, + 0.041946180164813995, + 0.08433905243873596, + 0.05650806799530983, + 0.0509730689227581, + 0.17086924612522125 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02980225533246994 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a low-angle medium close-up that tilts steadily upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central character a woman wearing an ancient, flowing deep blue silk robe with gold thread embroidery of constellations?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman's expression serene with closed eyes and a gentle smile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a long ribbon composed of soft pinks, gentle lavenders, and pale yellows trailing from her waist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a soft-focus sky with dusk clouds in rose, orange, and violet hues?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026339344680309296 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651339292526245 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026339344680309296, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026339344680309296, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19117678701877594, + 0.17516659200191498, + 0.08434446901082993, + 0.16938497126102448, + 0.06247888505458832, + 0.07589905709028244, + 0.06115857884287834, + 0.06970956176519394, + 0.04473439231514931, + 0.06594674289226532 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026339344680309296 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a low-angle medium close-up that tilts steadily upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central character a woman wearing an ancient, flowing deep blue silk robe with gold thread embroidery of constellations?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman's expression serene with closed eyes and a gentle smile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a long ribbon composed of soft pinks, gentle lavenders, and pale yellows trailing from her waist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a soft-focus sky with dusk clouds in rose, orange, and violet hues?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0015119798481464386 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.501512050628662 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0015119798481464386, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0015119798481464386, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2950507402420044, + 0.07123754173517227, + 0.08565781265497208, + 0.052872829139232635, + 0.11778948456048965, + 0.0472545325756073, + 0.17578916251659393, + 0.027838105335831642, + 0.036467794328927994, + 0.09004194289445877 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0015119798481464386 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a Ghibli-inspired aesthetic, a low-angle medium close-up tilts steadily upward, tracking the graceful, slow-motion ascent of the celestial woman. Her eyes are closed, a serene, blissful expression on her face, a gentle smile on her lips. A divine, ethereal light pours from beyond the frame, capturing the intricate, shimmering gold thread embroidery of constellations on her ancient, flowing, deep blue silk robe. Her pearly hair floats weightlessly around her head like a halo. A long, colorful ribbon trails around her waist, composed of soft pinks, gentle lavenders, and pale yellows, dancing and undulating languidly in the air. The atmosphere is filled with tiny, luminous dust particles that drift and shimmer like fireflies against the backdrop of a soft-focus, painterly sky. Dusk clouds are rendered in beautiful, blended lines of rose, orange, and violet, creating a scene of profoundly magical and tranquility.", + "seed": 19754, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000272/group_8/index_9365_seed_19754_dp_16_rank_32_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.059554833779111506, + "vlm_logprob": -0.059554833779111506, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.675, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.059554833779111506, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a low-angle medium close-up that tilts steadily upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central character a woman wearing an ancient, flowing deep blue silk robe with gold thread embroidery of constellations?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman's expression serene with closed eyes and a gentle smile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a long ribbon composed of soft pinks, gentle lavenders, and pale yellows trailing from her waist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a soft-focus sky with dusk clouds in rose, orange, and violet hues?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2061961591243744 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7061961889266968 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2061961591243744, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2061961591243744, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2689738869667053, + 0.1060151755809784, + 0.0644315853714943, + 0.08093806356191635, + 0.08070674538612366, + 0.04811938852071762, + 0.07621143758296967, + 0.05277271196246147, + 0.08184538781642914, + 0.1399856060743332 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2061961591243744 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a low-angle medium close-up that tilts steadily upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central character a woman wearing an ancient, flowing deep blue silk robe with gold thread embroidery of constellations?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman's expression serene with closed eyes and a gentle smile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a long ribbon composed of soft pinks, gentle lavenders, and pale yellows trailing from her waist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a soft-focus sky with dusk clouds in rose, orange, and violet hues?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03371550515294075 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4087154865264893 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03371550515294075, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03371550515294075, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.49972885847091675, + 0.0856425017118454, + 0.09008356183767319, + 0.022300709038972855, + 0.03720415383577347, + 0.03300546854734421, + 0.020854299888014793, + 0.09014607220888138, + 0.04897497594356537, + 0.07205939292907715 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03371550515294075 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a low-angle medium close-up that tilts steadily upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central character a woman wearing an ancient, flowing deep blue silk robe with gold thread embroidery of constellations?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman's expression serene with closed eyes and a gentle smile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a long ribbon composed of soft pinks, gentle lavenders, and pale yellows trailing from her waist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a soft-focus sky with dusk clouds in rose, orange, and violet hues?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0263564120978117 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513564586639404 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0263564120978117, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0263564120978117, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.34667137265205383, + 0.1180315688252449, + 0.08834101259708405, + 0.04812797158956528, + 0.07487989962100983, + 0.050950437784194946, + 0.06645455956459045, + 0.06271091848611832, + 0.0722733736038208, + 0.07155893743038177 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0263564120978117 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a low-angle medium close-up that tilts steadily upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central character a woman wearing an ancient, flowing deep blue silk robe with gold thread embroidery of constellations?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman's expression serene with closed eyes and a gentle smile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a long ribbon composed of soft pinks, gentle lavenders, and pale yellows trailing from her waist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a soft-focus sky with dusk clouds in rose, orange, and violet hues?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02979392558336258 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5297939777374268 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02979392558336258, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02979392558336258, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2904384434223175, + 0.07991497963666916, + 0.09596098214387894, + 0.04581594467163086, + 0.052831072360277176, + 0.07343726605176926, + 0.050610922276973724, + 0.13626429438591003, + 0.052036385983228683, + 0.12268965691328049 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02979392558336258 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a low-angle medium close-up that tilts steadily upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central character a woman wearing an ancient, flowing deep blue silk robe with gold thread embroidery of constellations?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman's expression serene with closed eyes and a gentle smile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a long ribbon composed of soft pinks, gentle lavenders, and pale yellows trailing from her waist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a soft-focus sky with dusk clouds in rose, orange, and violet hues?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0017121669370681047 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.376712322235107 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0017121669370681047, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0017121669370681047, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2861182391643524, + 0.0913955494761467, + 0.02836460992693901, + 0.11665208637714386, + 0.09324575215578079, + 0.038684915751218796, + 0.06567487120628357, + 0.05744388699531555, + 0.07169543206691742, + 0.1507246345281601 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0017121669370681047 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a Ghibli-inspired aesthetic, a low-angle medium close-up tilts steadily upward, tracking the graceful, slow-motion ascent of the celestial woman. Her eyes are closed, a serene, blissful expression on her face, a gentle smile on her lips. A divine, ethereal light pours from beyond the frame, capturing the intricate, shimmering gold thread embroidery of constellations on her ancient, flowing, deep blue silk robe. Her pearly hair floats weightlessly around her head like a halo. A long, colorful ribbon trails around her waist, composed of soft pinks, gentle lavenders, and pale yellows, dancing and undulating languidly in the air. The atmosphere is filled with tiny, luminous dust particles that drift and shimmer like fireflies against the backdrop of a soft-focus, painterly sky. Dusk clouds are rendered in beautiful, blended lines of rose, orange, and violet, creating a scene of profoundly magical and tranquility.", + "seed": 19755, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000272/group_8/index_9365_seed_19755_dp_17_rank_34_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.026913064159452917, + "vlm_logprob": -0.026913064159452917, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.1, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.026913064159452917, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a low-angle medium close-up that tilts steadily upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central character a woman wearing an ancient, flowing deep blue silk robe with gold thread embroidery of constellations?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman's expression serene with closed eyes and a gentle smile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a long ribbon composed of soft pinks, gentle lavenders, and pale yellows trailing from her waist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a soft-focus sky with dusk clouds in rose, orange, and violet hues?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.055253151804208755 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.055253267288208 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.055253151804208755, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.055253151804208755, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11990181356668472, + 0.1001308336853981, + 0.049341171979904175, + 0.050858691334724426, + 0.07768791168928146, + 0.05896073952317238, + 0.35849687457084656, + 0.037087876349687576, + 0.051567867398262024, + 0.09596624970436096 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.055253151804208755 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a low-angle medium close-up that tilts steadily upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central character a woman wearing an ancient, flowing deep blue silk robe with gold thread embroidery of constellations?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman's expression serene with closed eyes and a gentle smile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a long ribbon composed of soft pinks, gentle lavenders, and pale yellows trailing from her waist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a soft-focus sky with dusk clouds in rose, orange, and violet hues?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01820240542292595 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018202304840088 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01820240542292595, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01820240542292595, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.227899968624115, + 0.12633365392684937, + 0.032908614724874496, + 0.18213917315006256, + 0.04735807701945305, + 0.057760339230298996, + 0.16310718655586243, + 0.05837707594037056, + 0.041460491716861725, + 0.0626555010676384 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01820240542292595 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a low-angle medium close-up that tilts steadily upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central character a woman wearing an ancient, flowing deep blue silk robe with gold thread embroidery of constellations?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman's expression serene with closed eyes and a gentle smile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a long ribbon composed of soft pinks, gentle lavenders, and pale yellows trailing from her waist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a soft-focus sky with dusk clouds in rose, orange, and violet hues?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029801908880472183 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529801845550537 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029801908880472183, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029801908880472183, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2039961814880371, + 0.05209372192621231, + 0.05381090193986893, + 0.07672987133264542, + 0.10565626621246338, + 0.05811309441924095, + 0.270668625831604, + 0.050316013395786285, + 0.045491378754377365, + 0.08312395215034485 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029801908880472183 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a low-angle medium close-up that tilts steadily upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central character a woman wearing an ancient, flowing deep blue silk robe with gold thread embroidery of constellations?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman's expression serene with closed eyes and a gentle smile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a long ribbon composed of soft pinks, gentle lavenders, and pale yellows trailing from her waist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a soft-focus sky with dusk clouds in rose, orange, and violet hues?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02979646995663643 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5297963619232178 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02979646995663643, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02979646995663643, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1944378763437271, + 0.11534562706947327, + 0.08521881699562073, + 0.12114885449409485, + 0.07045922428369522, + 0.12528268992900848, + 0.10453582555055618, + 0.05386935919523239, + 0.049355294555425644, + 0.0803464874625206 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02979646995663643 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a low-angle medium close-up that tilts steadily upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central character a woman wearing an ancient, flowing deep blue silk robe with gold thread embroidery of constellations?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman's expression serene with closed eyes and a gentle smile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a long ribbon composed of soft pinks, gentle lavenders, and pale yellows trailing from her waist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a soft-focus sky with dusk clouds in rose, orange, and violet hues?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0015113847330212593 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.501511573791504 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0015113847330212593, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0015113847330212593, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.27059662342071533, + 0.08534941077232361, + 0.1627373993396759, + 0.038627542555332184, + 0.03882904350757599, + 0.059695784002542496, + 0.14005160331726074, + 0.035589128732681274, + 0.04685711860656738, + 0.1216663345694542 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0015113847330212593 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a Ghibli-inspired aesthetic, a low-angle medium close-up tilts steadily upward, tracking the graceful, slow-motion ascent of the celestial woman. Her eyes are closed, a serene, blissful expression on her face, a gentle smile on her lips. A divine, ethereal light pours from beyond the frame, capturing the intricate, shimmering gold thread embroidery of constellations on her ancient, flowing, deep blue silk robe. Her pearly hair floats weightlessly around her head like a halo. A long, colorful ribbon trails around her waist, composed of soft pinks, gentle lavenders, and pale yellows, dancing and undulating languidly in the air. The atmosphere is filled with tiny, luminous dust particles that drift and shimmer like fireflies against the backdrop of a soft-focus, painterly sky. Dusk clouds are rendered in beautiful, blended lines of rose, orange, and violet, creating a scene of profoundly magical and tranquility.", + "seed": 19756, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000272/group_8/index_9365_seed_19756_dp_17_rank_34_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.05401748933363706, + "vlm_logprob": -0.05401748933363706, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.6, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.05401748933363706, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a low-angle medium close-up that tilts steadily upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central character a woman wearing an ancient, flowing deep blue silk robe with gold thread embroidery of constellations?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman's expression serene with closed eyes and a gentle smile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a long ribbon composed of soft pinks, gentle lavenders, and pale yellows trailing from her waist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a soft-focus sky with dusk clouds in rose, orange, and violet hues?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1470469981431961 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0220470428466797 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1470469981431961, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1470469981431961, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11863955855369568, + 0.1338379979133606, + 0.15323258936405182, + 0.15284156799316406, + 0.09351181983947754, + 0.050184231251478195, + 0.06596305966377258, + 0.033098455518484116, + 0.1498245894908905, + 0.04886626452207565 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1470469981431961 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a low-angle medium close-up that tilts steadily upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central character a woman wearing an ancient, flowing deep blue silk robe with gold thread embroidery of constellations?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman's expression serene with closed eyes and a gentle smile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a long ribbon composed of soft pinks, gentle lavenders, and pale yellows trailing from her waist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a soft-focus sky with dusk clouds in rose, orange, and violet hues?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04307059198617935 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680705547332764 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04307059198617935, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04307059198617935, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19628416001796722, + 0.20539455115795135, + 0.1899729073047638, + 0.08708668500185013, + 0.07553384453058243, + 0.02239968627691269, + 0.04422329366207123, + 0.05497974529862404, + 0.0662732645869255, + 0.05785192549228668 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04307059198617935 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a low-angle medium close-up that tilts steadily upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central character a woman wearing an ancient, flowing deep blue silk robe with gold thread embroidery of constellations?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman's expression serene with closed eyes and a gentle smile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a long ribbon composed of soft pinks, gentle lavenders, and pale yellows trailing from her waist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a soft-focus sky with dusk clouds in rose, orange, and violet hues?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04866397753357887 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048664093017578 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04866397753357887, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04866397753357887, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14317074418067932, + 0.1819530427455902, + 0.1328846514225006, + 0.08156108856201172, + 0.06591883301734924, + 0.04573722556233406, + 0.04115264490246773, + 0.11432789266109467, + 0.149367094039917, + 0.04392676427960396 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04866397753357887 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a low-angle medium close-up that tilts steadily upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central character a woman wearing an ancient, flowing deep blue silk robe with gold thread embroidery of constellations?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman's expression serene with closed eyes and a gentle smile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a long ribbon composed of soft pinks, gentle lavenders, and pale yellows trailing from her waist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a soft-focus sky with dusk clouds in rose, orange, and violet hues?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029794851318001747 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529794931411743 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029794851318001747, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029794851318001747, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18025268614292145, + 0.1465221792459488, + 0.13058216869831085, + 0.11031601577997208, + 0.056771036237478256, + 0.0540788471698761, + 0.12718336284160614, + 0.05998452752828598, + 0.052546799182891846, + 0.0817624032497406 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029794851318001747 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a low-angle medium close-up that tilts steadily upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central character a woman wearing an ancient, flowing deep blue silk robe with gold thread embroidery of constellations?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman's expression serene with closed eyes and a gentle smile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a long ribbon composed of soft pinks, gentle lavenders, and pale yellows trailing from her waist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a soft-focus sky with dusk clouds in rose, orange, and violet hues?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.001511027687229216 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.501511096954346 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.001511027687229216, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.001511027687229216, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13717173039913177, + 0.06597819924354553, + 0.09287988394498825, + 0.09698382765054703, + 0.045448027551174164, + 0.06603066623210907, + 0.31606268882751465, + 0.04790865257382393, + 0.02751149795949459, + 0.10402482748031616 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.001511027687229216 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_0/index_tensor([5864, 5864])_group_0_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_0/index_tensor([5864, 5864])_group_0_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..78a54f5ced3a45e215f266606d6f9454c0d99a2e --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_0/index_tensor([5864, 5864])_group_0_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "striking aerial drone shot begins from high above, swooping vertically at breathtaking speed, focusing on a deep green river below, its turbulent currents shrouded in white foam. As the camera rapidly descends, shifting to a low-angle tracking shot close to the water's surface, a narrow, vibrantly colored centipede boat suddenly bursts into the frame. Painted a vibrant red and gold, its prow is adorned with a ferocious, lifelike dragon head, cutting through the surging waves. On board, twenty muscular, tanned rowers, wearing matching red sleeveless vests, lean forward in unison, their faces focused, their teeth clenched, their bodies pulsating in unison to the thunderous beat of a drummer at the bow. Filmed in a high-speed style, each stroke is meticulously deconstructed: the wooden blade slices neatly into the water, then, driven by the rowers' back muscles, is pulled back with a powerful pull. The resulting spray explodes into countless crystalline droplets in the bright sunlight, suspended in the air in graceful slow-motion, each droplet reflecting light. The sound of the boat cutting through the turbulent current intertwines with the deafening beat of drums and the heavy breathing of the rowers, while the dense tropical rainforest rapidly recedes on both sides. The entire scene is filled with a sense of primal power, a tense competitive rhythm, and a surge of adrenaline, creating an ultimate sense of athletic competition.", + "seed": 32733, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_0/index_5864_seed_32733_dp_0_rank_0_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.12672757562249898, + "vlm_logprob": -0.12672757562249898, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.5, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.12672757562249898, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an aerial drone shot that swoops vertically at high speed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a narrow boat painted red and gold with a dragon head on the prow visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are twenty muscular rowers wearing matching red sleeveless vests visible on the boat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filmed in a high-speed style where the oar strokes are deconstructed into slow-motion with crystalline water droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background show a deep green river surrounded by a dense tropical rainforest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16131538152694702 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9113154411315918 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16131538152694702, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16131538152694702, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05553843080997467, + 0.16664570569992065, + 0.2998502850532532, + 0.18021118640899658, + 0.07274343818426132, + 0.043131787329912186, + 0.01764834113419056, + 0.025623340159654617, + 0.055588822811841965, + 0.08301865309476852 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16131538152694702 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an aerial drone shot that swoops vertically at high speed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a narrow boat painted red and gold with a dragon head on the prow visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are twenty muscular rowers wearing matching red sleeveless vests visible on the boat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filmed in a high-speed style where the oar strokes are deconstructed into slow-motion with crystalline water droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background show a deep green river surrounded by a dense tropical rainforest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009807142429053783 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634807109832764 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009807142429053783, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009807142429053783, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.059157516807317734, + 0.11792667955160141, + 0.07536403834819794, + 0.12487772852182388, + 0.08374043554067612, + 0.03591351583600044, + 0.12053221464157104, + 0.13257499039173126, + 0.16521790623664856, + 0.08469496667385101 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009807142429053783 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an aerial drone shot that swoops vertically at high speed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a narrow boat painted red and gold with a dragon head on the prow visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are twenty muscular rowers wearing matching red sleeveless vests visible on the boat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filmed in a high-speed style where the oar strokes are deconstructed into slow-motion with crystalline water droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background show a deep green river surrounded by a dense tropical rainforest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07007472217082977 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950747966766357 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07007472217082977, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07007472217082977, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05425402149558067, + 0.06557116657495499, + 0.1133200079202652, + 0.11829033493995667, + 0.042886048555374146, + 0.047724027186632156, + 0.04824652150273323, + 0.11798568814992905, + 0.23842711746692657, + 0.15329505503177643 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07007472217082977 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an aerial drone shot that swoops vertically at high speed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a narrow boat painted red and gold with a dragon head on the prow visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are twenty muscular rowers wearing matching red sleeveless vests visible on the boat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filmed in a high-speed style where the oar strokes are deconstructed into slow-motion with crystalline water droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background show a deep green river surrounded by a dense tropical rainforest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07901786267757416 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5790178775787354 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07901786267757416, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07901786267757416, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0436750091612339, + 0.160064697265625, + 0.23409950733184814, + 0.10603315383195877, + 0.09121014177799225, + 0.06800425052642822, + 0.035518694669008255, + 0.03386799618601799, + 0.05349118635058403, + 0.17403544485569 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07901786267757416 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an aerial drone shot that swoops vertically at high speed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a narrow boat painted red and gold with a dragon head on the prow visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are twenty muscular rowers wearing matching red sleeveless vests visible on the boat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filmed in a high-speed style where the oar strokes are deconstructed into slow-motion with crystalline water droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background show a deep green river surrounded by a dense tropical rainforest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3134227693080902 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3134227991104126 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3134227693080902, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3134227693080902, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12449494749307632, + 0.07955531030893326, + 0.4971141219139099, + 0.09517128020524979, + 0.02360556833446026, + 0.039364710450172424, + 0.01435630489140749, + 0.021872559562325478, + 0.06642436236143112, + 0.038040801882743835 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3134227693080902 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "striking aerial drone shot begins from high above, swooping vertically at breathtaking speed, focusing on a deep green river below, its turbulent currents shrouded in white foam. As the camera rapidly descends, shifting to a low-angle tracking shot close to the water's surface, a narrow, vibrantly colored centipede boat suddenly bursts into the frame. Painted a vibrant red and gold, its prow is adorned with a ferocious, lifelike dragon head, cutting through the surging waves. On board, twenty muscular, tanned rowers, wearing matching red sleeveless vests, lean forward in unison, their faces focused, their teeth clenched, their bodies pulsating in unison to the thunderous beat of a drummer at the bow. Filmed in a high-speed style, each stroke is meticulously deconstructed: the wooden blade slices neatly into the water, then, driven by the rowers' back muscles, is pulled back with a powerful pull. The resulting spray explodes into countless crystalline droplets in the bright sunlight, suspended in the air in graceful slow-motion, each droplet reflecting light. The sound of the boat cutting through the turbulent current intertwines with the deafening beat of drums and the heavy breathing of the rowers, while the dense tropical rainforest rapidly recedes on both sides. The entire scene is filled with a sense of primal power, a tense competitive rhythm, and a surge of adrenaline, creating an ultimate sense of athletic competition.", + "seed": 32734, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_0/index_5864_seed_32734_dp_0_rank_0_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.17084806859493257, + "vlm_logprob": -0.17084806859493257, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.55, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.17084806859493257, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an aerial drone shot that swoops vertically at high speed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a narrow boat painted red and gold with a dragon head on the prow visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are twenty muscular rowers wearing matching red sleeveless vests visible on the boat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filmed in a high-speed style where the oar strokes are deconstructed into slow-motion with crystalline water droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background show a deep green river surrounded by a dense tropical rainforest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1611863374710083 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9111863374710083 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1611863374710083, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1611863374710083, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09329552948474884, + 0.169935941696167, + 0.12907062470912933, + 0.04390181601047516, + 0.030289774760603905, + 0.22799678146839142, + 0.13408522307872772, + 0.12861929833889008, + 0.024547001346945763, + 0.018258020281791687 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1611863374710083 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an aerial drone shot that swoops vertically at high speed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a narrow boat painted red and gold with a dragon head on the prow visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are twenty muscular rowers wearing matching red sleeveless vests visible on the boat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filmed in a high-speed style where the oar strokes are deconstructed into slow-motion with crystalline water droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background show a deep green river surrounded by a dense tropical rainforest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008663449436426163 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758663654327393 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008663449436426163, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008663449436426163, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.056259769946336746, + 0.19656632840633392, + 0.08485981076955795, + 0.07881535589694977, + 0.06527069956064224, + 0.11644589900970459, + 0.14494317770004272, + 0.0413692444562912, + 0.06450685113668442, + 0.15096281468868256 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008663449436426163 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an aerial drone shot that swoops vertically at high speed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a narrow boat painted red and gold with a dragon head on the prow visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are twenty muscular rowers wearing matching red sleeveless vests visible on the boat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filmed in a high-speed style where the oar strokes are deconstructed into slow-motion with crystalline water droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background show a deep green river surrounded by a dense tropical rainforest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14288923144340515 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0178892612457275 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14288923144340515, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14288923144340515, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0919380709528923, + 0.09662304073572159, + 0.055778518319129944, + 0.05593811720609665, + 0.0535697266459465, + 0.0926954597234726, + 0.053471315652132034, + 0.04084515944123268, + 0.35152408480644226, + 0.10761646181344986 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14288923144340515 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an aerial drone shot that swoops vertically at high speed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a narrow boat painted red and gold with a dragon head on the prow visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are twenty muscular rowers wearing matching red sleeveless vests visible on the boat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filmed in a high-speed style where the oar strokes are deconstructed into slow-motion with crystalline water droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background show a deep green river surrounded by a dense tropical rainforest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01820240542292595 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018202304840088 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01820240542292595, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01820240542292595, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06441599130630493, + 0.06537892669439316, + 0.06920351833105087, + 0.18296493589878082, + 0.08034750819206238, + 0.24597293138504028, + 0.08416710793972015, + 0.04787802696228027, + 0.04798787832260132, + 0.11168326437473297 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01820240542292595 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an aerial drone shot that swoops vertically at high speed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a narrow boat painted red and gold with a dragon head on the prow visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are twenty muscular rowers wearing matching red sleeveless vests visible on the boat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filmed in a high-speed style where the oar strokes are deconstructed into slow-motion with crystalline water droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background show a deep green river surrounded by a dense tropical rainforest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5232989192008972 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8982989192008972 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5232989192008972, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5232989192008972, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4856016933917999, + 0.05164726451039314, + 0.06215415522456169, + 0.04155019298195839, + 0.024374496191740036, + 0.09322895109653473, + 0.04700232297182083, + 0.028564080595970154, + 0.06013526767492294, + 0.10574153065681458 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5232989192008972 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "striking aerial drone shot begins from high above, swooping vertically at breathtaking speed, focusing on a deep green river below, its turbulent currents shrouded in white foam. As the camera rapidly descends, shifting to a low-angle tracking shot close to the water's surface, a narrow, vibrantly colored centipede boat suddenly bursts into the frame. Painted a vibrant red and gold, its prow is adorned with a ferocious, lifelike dragon head, cutting through the surging waves. On board, twenty muscular, tanned rowers, wearing matching red sleeveless vests, lean forward in unison, their faces focused, their teeth clenched, their bodies pulsating in unison to the thunderous beat of a drummer at the bow. Filmed in a high-speed style, each stroke is meticulously deconstructed: the wooden blade slices neatly into the water, then, driven by the rowers' back muscles, is pulled back with a powerful pull. The resulting spray explodes into countless crystalline droplets in the bright sunlight, suspended in the air in graceful slow-motion, each droplet reflecting light. The sound of the boat cutting through the turbulent current intertwines with the deafening beat of drums and the heavy breathing of the rowers, while the dense tropical rainforest rapidly recedes on both sides. The entire scene is filled with a sense of primal power, a tense competitive rhythm, and a surge of adrenaline, creating an ultimate sense of athletic competition.", + "seed": 32735, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_0/index_5864_seed_32735_dp_1_rank_2_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.16246700063347816, + "vlm_logprob": -0.16246700063347816, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.6999999940395356, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.16246700063347816, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an aerial drone shot that swoops vertically at high speed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a narrow boat painted red and gold with a dragon head on the prow visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are twenty muscular rowers wearing matching red sleeveless vests visible on the boat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filmed in a high-speed style where the oar strokes are deconstructed into slow-motion with crystalline water droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background show a deep green river surrounded by a dense tropical rainforest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.25359296798706055 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5035929679870605 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.25359296798706055, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.25359296798706055, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19397468864917755, + 0.356795996427536, + 0.05368984863162041, + 0.059212855994701385, + 0.04786297678947449, + 0.08054880797863007, + 0.0254064928740263, + 0.06829247623682022, + 0.06343109160661697, + 0.05078475549817085 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.25359296798706055 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an aerial drone shot that swoops vertically at high speed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a narrow boat painted red and gold with a dragon head on the prow visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are twenty muscular rowers wearing matching red sleeveless vests visible on the boat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filmed in a high-speed style where the oar strokes are deconstructed into slow-motion with crystalline water droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background show a deep green river surrounded by a dense tropical rainforest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0125612523406744 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387561321258545 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0125612523406744, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0125612523406744, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0428139790892601, + 0.03275900334119797, + 0.07772340625524521, + 0.056141097098588943, + 0.0233010146766901, + 0.11187554895877838, + 0.030411377549171448, + 0.3606792390346527, + 0.23463697731494904, + 0.029658369719982147 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0125612523406744 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an aerial drone shot that swoops vertically at high speed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a narrow boat painted red and gold with a dragon head on the prow visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are twenty muscular rowers wearing matching red sleeveless vests visible on the boat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filmed in a high-speed style where the oar strokes are deconstructed into slow-motion with crystalline water droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background show a deep green river surrounded by a dense tropical rainforest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06209466606378555 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120946884155273 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06209466606378555, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06209466606378555, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0652577131986618, + 0.04971572756767273, + 0.08359149098396301, + 0.07389350235462189, + 0.02420050837099552, + 0.37286674976348877, + 0.03402368351817131, + 0.07061101496219635, + 0.1345914751291275, + 0.09124815464019775 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06209466606378555 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an aerial drone shot that swoops vertically at high speed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a narrow boat painted red and gold with a dragon head on the prow visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are twenty muscular rowers wearing matching red sleeveless vests visible on the boat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filmed in a high-speed style where the oar strokes are deconstructed into slow-motion with crystalline water droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background show a deep green river surrounded by a dense tropical rainforest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00979321263730526 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634793281555176 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00979321263730526, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00979321263730526, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06827646493911743, + 0.23775292932987213, + 0.10841591656208038, + 0.053474877029657364, + 0.02271641045808792, + 0.057870734483003616, + 0.03076297789812088, + 0.1163659319281578, + 0.18542122840881348, + 0.11894254386425018 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00979321263730526 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an aerial drone shot that swoops vertically at high speed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a narrow boat painted red and gold with a dragon head on the prow visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are twenty muscular rowers wearing matching red sleeveless vests visible on the boat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filmed in a high-speed style where the oar strokes are deconstructed into slow-motion with crystalline water droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background show a deep green river surrounded by a dense tropical rainforest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.47429290413856506 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9742928743362427 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.47429290413856506, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.4999999701976776, + "token_credit_reward": -0.47429290413856506, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04023478925228119, + 0.1654483526945114, + 0.23783466219902039, + 0.06778217107057571, + 0.023894399404525757, + 0.024759484454989433, + 0.019477076828479767, + 0.051494114100933075, + 0.20149075984954834, + 0.1675841510295868 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.47429290413856506 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "striking aerial drone shot begins from high above, swooping vertically at breathtaking speed, focusing on a deep green river below, its turbulent currents shrouded in white foam. As the camera rapidly descends, shifting to a low-angle tracking shot close to the water's surface, a narrow, vibrantly colored centipede boat suddenly bursts into the frame. Painted a vibrant red and gold, its prow is adorned with a ferocious, lifelike dragon head, cutting through the surging waves. On board, twenty muscular, tanned rowers, wearing matching red sleeveless vests, lean forward in unison, their faces focused, their teeth clenched, their bodies pulsating in unison to the thunderous beat of a drummer at the bow. Filmed in a high-speed style, each stroke is meticulously deconstructed: the wooden blade slices neatly into the water, then, driven by the rowers' back muscles, is pulled back with a powerful pull. The resulting spray explodes into countless crystalline droplets in the bright sunlight, suspended in the air in graceful slow-motion, each droplet reflecting light. The sound of the boat cutting through the turbulent current intertwines with the deafening beat of drums and the heavy breathing of the rowers, while the dense tropical rainforest rapidly recedes on both sides. The entire scene is filled with a sense of primal power, a tense competitive rhythm, and a surge of adrenaline, creating an ultimate sense of athletic competition.", + "seed": 32736, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_0/index_5864_seed_32736_dp_1_rank_2_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.10064977016299963, + "vlm_logprob": -0.10064977016299963, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.775, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.10064977016299963, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an aerial drone shot that swoops vertically at high speed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a narrow boat painted red and gold with a dragon head on the prow visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are twenty muscular rowers wearing matching red sleeveless vests visible on the boat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filmed in a high-speed style where the oar strokes are deconstructed into slow-motion with crystalline water droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background show a deep green river surrounded by a dense tropical rainforest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22690880298614502 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.601908802986145 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.22690880298614502, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.22690880298614502, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17837633192539215, + 0.10553429275751114, + 0.12510254979133606, + 0.2246389538049698, + 0.020733565092086792, + 0.02471490576863289, + 0.22388680279254913, + 0.07395478338003159, + 0.015984954312443733, + 0.007072848733514547 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.22690880298614502 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an aerial drone shot that swoops vertically at high speed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a narrow boat painted red and gold with a dragon head on the prow visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are twenty muscular rowers wearing matching red sleeveless vests visible on the boat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filmed in a high-speed style where the oar strokes are deconstructed into slow-motion with crystalline water droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background show a deep green river surrounded by a dense tropical rainforest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009806315414607525 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634806156158447 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009806315414607525, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009806315414607525, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25031188130378723, + 0.13063091039657593, + 0.05800487846136093, + 0.06241772323846817, + 0.07329443097114563, + 0.053188733756542206, + 0.08880985528230667, + 0.1287309229373932, + 0.08387237042188644, + 0.0707382783293724 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009806315414607525 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an aerial drone shot that swoops vertically at high speed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a narrow boat painted red and gold with a dragon head on the prow visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are twenty muscular rowers wearing matching red sleeveless vests visible on the boat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filmed in a high-speed style where the oar strokes are deconstructed into slow-motion with crystalline water droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background show a deep green river surrounded by a dense tropical rainforest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14291329681873322 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.017913341522217 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14291329681873322, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14291329681873322, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10389764606952667, + 0.06015167757868767, + 0.03527425229549408, + 0.1717822551727295, + 0.04657462611794472, + 0.09793844074010849, + 0.25794628262519836, + 0.04302950203418732, + 0.04239026457071304, + 0.14101503789424896 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14291329681873322 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an aerial drone shot that swoops vertically at high speed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a narrow boat painted red and gold with a dragon head on the prow visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are twenty muscular rowers wearing matching red sleeveless vests visible on the boat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filmed in a high-speed style where the oar strokes are deconstructed into slow-motion with crystalline water droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background show a deep green river surrounded by a dense tropical rainforest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02330903708934784 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7733089923858643 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02330903708934784, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02330903708934784, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1769930124282837, + 0.12622450292110443, + 0.12345512956380844, + 0.33899828791618347, + 0.0626714900135994, + 0.02529074251651764, + 0.042648740112781525, + 0.016543962061405182, + 0.02516600862145424, + 0.06200817599892616 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02330903708934784 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an aerial drone shot that swoops vertically at high speed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a narrow boat painted red and gold with a dragon head on the prow visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are twenty muscular rowers wearing matching red sleeveless vests visible on the boat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filmed in a high-speed style where the oar strokes are deconstructed into slow-motion with crystalline water droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background show a deep green river surrounded by a dense tropical rainforest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10031139850616455 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.350311279296875 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10031139850616455, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10031139850616455, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4327174425125122, + 0.1140507385134697, + 0.03459851071238518, + 0.11459054797887802, + 0.03201781213283539, + 0.1568569839000702, + 0.030753346160054207, + 0.026903895661234856, + 0.026682429015636444, + 0.030828330665826797 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10031139850616455 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_1/index_tensor([3921, 3921])_group_1_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_1/index_tensor([3921, 3921])_group_1_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..e429116bd9693159c4bc91cb374b78060dfe4eee --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_1/index_tensor([3921, 3921])_group_1_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "medium-long shot, beginning at eye level and moving steadily and smoothly upward, reveals a mythical phoenix floating with almost imperceptible ease above a boundless sea of clouds, thick as cotton wool. Dawn's golden sunlight slants across the horizon, tinting the cloudtops a warm orange-red. Beneath it, the clouds swirl and unfurl, forming vast white swirls and mountain ranges. As the camera pans, the first thing that catches the eye is the phoenix's dazzling, multi-meter-long tail, composed of countless delicate feathers that seem woven from a solidified rainbow. As the phoenix gently sways, its feathers gleam with the luster of emerald, sapphire, and amethyst. The colors flow and shift across the feathers, emitting a soft, dreamy halo. The camera continues to move upward, passing over its elegant form, draped in fiery red-gold feathers. The edges of each feather appear to be outlined in liquid gold. Its massive wings are gracefully outstretched, light filtering through its translucent wingtips, radiating a divine glow. Finally, the camera freezes on a close-up of its noble and majestic head, crowned with an exquisite golden crest and a beak as smooth and sharp as obsidian. Its molten amber eyes gaze calmly into the distance, gleaming with wisdom and antiquity. The entire scene is filled with a sense of tranquility, solemnity, and epic grandeur.", + "seed": 30302, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_1/index_3921_seed_30302_dp_2_rank_4_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.09659378714859486, + "vlm_logprob": -0.09659378714859486, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.7, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.09659378714859486, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a mythical phoenix floating above a sea of clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the scene begin at eye level and move steadily upward while the camera pans?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the phoenix's tail multi-meter long, composed of countless delicate feathers with a solidified rainbow appearance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with a close-up of the phoenix's head featuring a golden crest and obsidian-colored beak?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the phoenix's molten amber eyes visible gazing calmly into the distance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02391364611685276 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773913621902466 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02391364611685276, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02391364611685276, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08741176128387451, + 0.04600624740123749, + 0.05593249574303627, + 0.1318175494670868, + 0.036845967173576355, + 0.06682602316141129, + 0.02411612495779991, + 0.48281413316726685, + 0.03119485080242157, + 0.03703480213880539 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02391364611685276 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a mythical phoenix floating above a sea of clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the scene begin at eye level and move steadily upward while the camera pans?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the phoenix's tail multi-meter long, composed of countless delicate feathers with a solidified rainbow appearance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with a close-up of the phoenix's head featuring a golden crest and obsidian-colored beak?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the phoenix's molten amber eyes visible gazing calmly into the distance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2813510596752167 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.406351089477539 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2813510596752167, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2813510596752167, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1637369692325592, + 0.08853544294834137, + 0.028486177325248718, + 0.03177163377404213, + 0.03361234441399574, + 0.15862661600112915, + 0.04038690775632858, + 0.3393263816833496, + 0.07629778236150742, + 0.039219699800014496 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2813510596752167 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a mythical phoenix floating above a sea of clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the scene begin at eye level and move steadily upward while the camera pans?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the phoenix's tail multi-meter long, composed of countless delicate feathers with a solidified rainbow appearance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with a close-up of the phoenix's head featuring a golden crest and obsidian-colored beak?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the phoenix's molten amber eyes visible gazing calmly into the distance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05497821792960167 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929978132247925 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05497821792960167, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05497821792960167, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.038866233080625534, + 0.022772662341594696, + 0.01493091881275177, + 0.04210541769862175, + 0.04779591038823128, + 0.03852040693163872, + 0.025789447128772736, + 0.7284855246543884, + 0.017682183533906937, + 0.023051250725984573 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05497821792960167 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a mythical phoenix floating above a sea of clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the scene begin at eye level and move steadily upward while the camera pans?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the phoenix's tail multi-meter long, composed of countless delicate feathers with a solidified rainbow appearance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with a close-up of the phoenix's head featuring a golden crest and obsidian-colored beak?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the phoenix's molten amber eyes visible gazing calmly into the distance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.033694181591272354 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408694267272949 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.033694181591272354, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.033694181591272354, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.053006697446107864, + 0.052434805780649185, + 0.033544521778821945, + 0.04635028913617134, + 0.04859360679984093, + 0.09394384175539017, + 0.023096896708011627, + 0.43242114782333374, + 0.15832124650478363, + 0.058286961168050766 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.033694181591272354 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a mythical phoenix floating above a sea of clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the scene begin at eye level and move steadily upward while the camera pans?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the phoenix's tail multi-meter long, composed of countless delicate feathers with a solidified rainbow appearance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with a close-up of the phoenix's head featuring a golden crest and obsidian-colored beak?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the phoenix's molten amber eyes visible gazing calmly into the distance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08903183043003082 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.464031934738159 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08903183043003082, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08903183043003082, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13214462995529175, + 0.05591624230146408, + 0.023818887770175934, + 0.027434250339865685, + 0.02852010168135166, + 0.06008758768439293, + 0.025084521621465683, + 0.4653518497943878, + 0.08784039318561554, + 0.09380154311656952 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08903183043003082 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "medium-long shot, beginning at eye level and moving steadily and smoothly upward, reveals a mythical phoenix floating with almost imperceptible ease above a boundless sea of clouds, thick as cotton wool. Dawn's golden sunlight slants across the horizon, tinting the cloudtops a warm orange-red. Beneath it, the clouds swirl and unfurl, forming vast white swirls and mountain ranges. As the camera pans, the first thing that catches the eye is the phoenix's dazzling, multi-meter-long tail, composed of countless delicate feathers that seem woven from a solidified rainbow. As the phoenix gently sways, its feathers gleam with the luster of emerald, sapphire, and amethyst. The colors flow and shift across the feathers, emitting a soft, dreamy halo. The camera continues to move upward, passing over its elegant form, draped in fiery red-gold feathers. The edges of each feather appear to be outlined in liquid gold. Its massive wings are gracefully outstretched, light filtering through its translucent wingtips, radiating a divine glow. Finally, the camera freezes on a close-up of its noble and majestic head, crowned with an exquisite golden crest and a beak as smooth and sharp as obsidian. Its molten amber eyes gaze calmly into the distance, gleaming with wisdom and antiquity. The entire scene is filled with a sense of tranquility, solemnity, and epic grandeur.", + "seed": 30303, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_1/index_3921_seed_30303_dp_2_rank_4_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.0990355221554637, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0990355221554637, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.025, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0990355221554637, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a mythical phoenix floating above a sea of clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the scene begin at eye level and move steadily upward while the camera pans?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the phoenix's tail multi-meter long, composed of countless delicate feathers with a solidified rainbow appearance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with a close-up of the phoenix's head featuring a golden crest and obsidian-colored beak?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the phoenix's molten amber eyes visible gazing calmly into the distance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01371119823306799 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.388710975646973 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01371119823306799, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01371119823306799, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4724228084087372, + 0.03397897630929947, + 0.10362470895051956, + 0.06250413507223129, + 0.15806278586387634, + 0.021515250205993652, + 0.02130432426929474, + 0.036312926560640335, + 0.03120298683643341, + 0.059071097522974014 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01371119823306799 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a mythical phoenix floating above a sea of clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the scene begin at eye level and move steadily upward while the camera pans?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the phoenix's tail multi-meter long, composed of countless delicate feathers with a solidified rainbow appearance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with a close-up of the phoenix's head featuring a golden crest and obsidian-colored beak?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the phoenix's molten amber eyes visible gazing calmly into the distance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3486192226409912 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2236192226409912 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3486192226409912, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3486192226409912, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2563043236732483, + 0.05769450217485428, + 0.053554367274045944, + 0.0763760507106781, + 0.2188263237476349, + 0.05344090983271599, + 0.06966860592365265, + 0.0865974947810173, + 0.07329169660806656, + 0.05424569174647331 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3486192226409912 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a mythical phoenix floating above a sea of clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the scene begin at eye level and move steadily upward while the camera pans?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the phoenix's tail multi-meter long, composed of countless delicate feathers with a solidified rainbow appearance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with a close-up of the phoenix's head featuring a golden crest and obsidian-colored beak?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the phoenix's molten amber eyes visible gazing calmly into the distance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04866284132003784 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486629009246826 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04866284132003784, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04866284132003784, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06902536749839783, + 0.041796475648880005, + 0.06156700849533081, + 0.1673477441072464, + 0.21314702928066254, + 0.057652898132801056, + 0.11604908108711243, + 0.050919309258461, + 0.03920558840036392, + 0.1832895129919052 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04866284132003784 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a mythical phoenix floating above a sea of clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the scene begin at eye level and move steadily upward while the camera pans?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the phoenix's tail multi-meter long, composed of countless delicate feathers with a solidified rainbow appearance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with a close-up of the phoenix's head featuring a golden crest and obsidian-colored beak?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the phoenix's molten amber eyes visible gazing calmly into the distance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014187425374984741 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264187335968018 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014187425374984741, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014187425374984741, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21171587705612183, + 0.032419443130493164, + 0.049819465726614, + 0.025213757529854774, + 0.15315189957618713, + 0.05912567302584648, + 0.03339754790067673, + 0.02039515972137451, + 0.1195526048541069, + 0.29520857334136963 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014187425374984741 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a mythical phoenix floating above a sea of clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the scene begin at eye level and move steadily upward while the camera pans?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the phoenix's tail multi-meter long, composed of countless delicate feathers with a solidified rainbow appearance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with a close-up of the phoenix's head featuring a golden crest and obsidian-colored beak?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the phoenix's molten amber eyes visible gazing calmly into the distance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0699969232082367 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6949968338012695 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0699969232082367, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0699969232082367, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25945690274238586, + 0.023872163146734238, + 0.020134063437581062, + 0.0437224805355072, + 0.202211394906044, + 0.032273974269628525, + 0.04807891324162483, + 0.02072254754602909, + 0.16919545829296112, + 0.18033210933208466 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0699969232082367 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "medium-long shot, beginning at eye level and moving steadily and smoothly upward, reveals a mythical phoenix floating with almost imperceptible ease above a boundless sea of clouds, thick as cotton wool. Dawn's golden sunlight slants across the horizon, tinting the cloudtops a warm orange-red. Beneath it, the clouds swirl and unfurl, forming vast white swirls and mountain ranges. As the camera pans, the first thing that catches the eye is the phoenix's dazzling, multi-meter-long tail, composed of countless delicate feathers that seem woven from a solidified rainbow. As the phoenix gently sways, its feathers gleam with the luster of emerald, sapphire, and amethyst. The colors flow and shift across the feathers, emitting a soft, dreamy halo. The camera continues to move upward, passing over its elegant form, draped in fiery red-gold feathers. The edges of each feather appear to be outlined in liquid gold. Its massive wings are gracefully outstretched, light filtering through its translucent wingtips, radiating a divine glow. Finally, the camera freezes on a close-up of its noble and majestic head, crowned with an exquisite golden crest and a beak as smooth and sharp as obsidian. Its molten amber eyes gaze calmly into the distance, gleaming with wisdom and antiquity. The entire scene is filled with a sense of tranquility, solemnity, and epic grandeur.", + "seed": 30304, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_1/index_3921_seed_30304_dp_3_rank_6_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.1349535934627056, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1349535934627056, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.349999988079071, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1349535934627056, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a mythical phoenix floating above a sea of clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the scene begin at eye level and move steadily upward while the camera pans?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the phoenix's tail multi-meter long, composed of countless delicate feathers with a solidified rainbow appearance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with a close-up of the phoenix's head featuring a golden crest and obsidian-colored beak?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the phoenix's molten amber eyes visible gazing calmly into the distance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.034240130335092545 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.409240245819092 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.034240130335092545, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.034240130335092545, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.29798200726509094, + 0.07837048918008804, + 0.16032804548740387, + 0.16843360662460327, + 0.058126311749219894, + 0.049699436873197556, + 0.08135539293289185, + 0.042441193014383316, + 0.023259997367858887, + 0.040003519505262375 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.034240130335092545 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a mythical phoenix floating above a sea of clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the scene begin at eye level and move steadily upward while the camera pans?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the phoenix's tail multi-meter long, composed of countless delicate feathers with a solidified rainbow appearance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with a close-up of the phoenix's head featuring a golden crest and obsidian-colored beak?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the phoenix's molten amber eyes visible gazing calmly into the distance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.38705188035964966 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1370518207550049 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.38705188035964966, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.7499999403953552, + "token_credit_reward": -0.38705188035964966, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1848539412021637, + 0.08159992098808289, + 0.15473572909832, + 0.09770641475915909, + 0.05912415683269501, + 0.08810076862573624, + 0.16052263975143433, + 0.06215212866663933, + 0.05195765942335129, + 0.059246573597192764 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.38705188035964966 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a mythical phoenix floating above a sea of clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the scene begin at eye level and move steadily upward while the camera pans?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the phoenix's tail multi-meter long, composed of countless delicate feathers with a solidified rainbow appearance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with a close-up of the phoenix's head featuring a golden crest and obsidian-colored beak?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the phoenix's molten amber eyes visible gazing calmly into the distance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.048666927963495255 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486669540405273 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.048666927963495255, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.048666927963495255, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13388194143772125, + 0.05773284286260605, + 0.0777459666132927, + 0.08894505351781845, + 0.05424896627664566, + 0.125299334526062, + 0.1535651534795761, + 0.0735170841217041, + 0.13454927504062653, + 0.10051441192626953 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.048666927963495255 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a mythical phoenix floating above a sea of clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the scene begin at eye level and move steadily upward while the camera pans?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the phoenix's tail multi-meter long, composed of countless delicate feathers with a solidified rainbow appearance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with a close-up of the phoenix's head featuring a golden crest and obsidian-colored beak?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the phoenix's molten amber eyes visible gazing calmly into the distance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14277295768260956 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.017772912979126 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14277295768260956, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14277295768260956, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19342079758644104, + 0.05083387345075607, + 0.11681745201349258, + 0.10750313103199005, + 0.07522033900022507, + 0.03974030911922455, + 0.08226615190505981, + 0.04521702229976654, + 0.03842352703213692, + 0.25055745244026184 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14277295768260956 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a mythical phoenix floating above a sea of clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the scene begin at eye level and move steadily upward while the camera pans?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the phoenix's tail multi-meter long, composed of countless delicate feathers with a solidified rainbow appearance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with a close-up of the phoenix's head featuring a golden crest and obsidian-colored beak?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the phoenix's molten amber eyes visible gazing calmly into the distance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.062036070972681046 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120360374450684 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.062036070972681046, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.062036070972681046, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13700422644615173, + 0.04818454012274742, + 0.10681343823671341, + 0.18155816197395325, + 0.06373876333236694, + 0.10410074889659882, + 0.1739356815814972, + 0.031085453927516937, + 0.04910712689161301, + 0.1044718325138092 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.062036070972681046 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "medium-long shot, beginning at eye level and moving steadily and smoothly upward, reveals a mythical phoenix floating with almost imperceptible ease above a boundless sea of clouds, thick as cotton wool. Dawn's golden sunlight slants across the horizon, tinting the cloudtops a warm orange-red. Beneath it, the clouds swirl and unfurl, forming vast white swirls and mountain ranges. As the camera pans, the first thing that catches the eye is the phoenix's dazzling, multi-meter-long tail, composed of countless delicate feathers that seem woven from a solidified rainbow. As the phoenix gently sways, its feathers gleam with the luster of emerald, sapphire, and amethyst. The colors flow and shift across the feathers, emitting a soft, dreamy halo. The camera continues to move upward, passing over its elegant form, draped in fiery red-gold feathers. The edges of each feather appear to be outlined in liquid gold. Its massive wings are gracefully outstretched, light filtering through its translucent wingtips, radiating a divine glow. Finally, the camera freezes on a close-up of its noble and majestic head, crowned with an exquisite golden crest and a beak as smooth and sharp as obsidian. Its molten amber eyes gaze calmly into the distance, gleaming with wisdom and antiquity. The entire scene is filled with a sense of tranquility, solemnity, and epic grandeur.", + "seed": 30305, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_1/index_3921_seed_30305_dp_3_rank_6_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.1664385139942169, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1664385139942169, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.949999988079071, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1664385139942169, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a mythical phoenix floating above a sea of clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the scene begin at eye level and move steadily upward while the camera pans?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the phoenix's tail multi-meter long, composed of countless delicate feathers with a solidified rainbow appearance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with a close-up of the phoenix's head featuring a golden crest and obsidian-colored beak?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the phoenix's molten amber eyes visible gazing calmly into the distance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03881791979074478 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288817882537842 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03881791979074478, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03881791979074478, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16594931483268738, + 0.08390797674655914, + 0.16516581177711487, + 0.11287739127874374, + 0.06272739917039871, + 0.16944339871406555, + 0.08662344515323639, + 0.08526422828435898, + 0.039160337299108505, + 0.028880739584565163 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03881791979074478 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a mythical phoenix floating above a sea of clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the scene begin at eye level and move steadily upward while the camera pans?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the phoenix's tail multi-meter long, composed of countless delicate feathers with a solidified rainbow appearance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with a close-up of the phoenix's head featuring a golden crest and obsidian-colored beak?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the phoenix's molten amber eyes visible gazing calmly into the distance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.348654568195343 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2236545085906982 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.348654568195343, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.8749999403953552, + "token_credit_reward": -0.348654568195343, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22612738609313965, + 0.10780338197946548, + 0.05189201235771179, + 0.07072988152503967, + 0.06201798841357231, + 0.07366418093442917, + 0.1210455372929573, + 0.1713528037071228, + 0.07895080745220184, + 0.03641599044203758 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.348654568195343 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a mythical phoenix floating above a sea of clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the scene begin at eye level and move steadily upward while the camera pans?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the phoenix's tail multi-meter long, composed of countless delicate feathers with a solidified rainbow appearance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with a close-up of the phoenix's head featuring a golden crest and obsidian-colored beak?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the phoenix's molten amber eyes visible gazing calmly into the distance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2015904039144516 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7015904188156128 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2015904039144516, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2015904039144516, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17358215153217316, + 0.10141463577747345, + 0.0867374986410141, + 0.11898952722549438, + 0.10728468000888824, + 0.1195264384150505, + 0.11040342599153519, + 0.06453472375869751, + 0.08687210083007812, + 0.030654828995466232 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2015904039144516 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a mythical phoenix floating above a sea of clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the scene begin at eye level and move steadily upward while the camera pans?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the phoenix's tail multi-meter long, composed of countless delicate feathers with a solidified rainbow appearance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with a close-up of the phoenix's head featuring a golden crest and obsidian-colored beak?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the phoenix's molten amber eyes visible gazing calmly into the distance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1427948772907257 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0177948474884033 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1427948772907257, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1427948772907257, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04888707771897316, + 0.10098443925380707, + 0.06355889141559601, + 0.09809891134500504, + 0.08147291094064713, + 0.04838431254029274, + 0.12923279404640198, + 0.10473291575908661, + 0.1806211769580841, + 0.14402656257152557 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1427948772907257 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a mythical phoenix floating above a sea of clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the scene begin at eye level and move steadily upward while the camera pans?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the phoenix's tail multi-meter long, composed of countless delicate feathers with a solidified rainbow appearance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with a close-up of the phoenix's head featuring a golden crest and obsidian-colored beak?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the phoenix's molten amber eyes visible gazing calmly into the distance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10033480077981949 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.350334882736206 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10033480077981949, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10033480077981949, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09470830857753754, + 0.09113484621047974, + 0.0657469630241394, + 0.08430533111095428, + 0.05700307711958885, + 0.12067454308271408, + 0.13986550271511078, + 0.17082832753658295, + 0.1036907508969307, + 0.07204239815473557 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10033480077981949 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_10/index_tensor([9051, 9051])_group_10_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_10/index_tensor([9051, 9051])_group_10_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..06f15c9e4bcc4739abb696fc8fc64e91a3e15cb1 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_10/index_tensor([9051, 9051])_group_10_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "slow panning shot to the right first sweeps across a pile of official documents haphazardly stacked on a heavy mahogany table. The yellowed parchment is coated with a thin layer of gray dust. In the soft light slanting in from the high windows, the aged ink marks are faintly visible, and fine dust particles hang in the air. With steady and deliberate movement, the camera finally focuses on a ginger longhair cat, peacefully hibernating. It is clad in a magnificent, custom-made ministerial attire of deep blue velvet, with intricate gold embroidery adorning the collar and cuffs, and a delicate white lace ruffle at the neck. Curled up on a luxurious crimson velvet cushion, the cat is curled into a compact, perfect ball of fur, its furry tail tip twitching only occasionally, its chest rising and falling rhythmically with its deep, steady breathing. The entire scene is bathed in a warm and soft halo, creating a tranquil, solemn and slightly magical atmosphere. The overall picture presents a distinct retro film texture and delicate grain, like a breathing classical oil painting forgotten by time.", + "seed": 9908, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_10/index_9051_seed_9908_dp_20_rank_40_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.11717015504837036, + "vlm_logprob": -0.11717015504837036, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.3, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.11717015504837036, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a slow pan to the right across a pile of official documents on a heavy mahogany table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the parchment yellowed, coated with gray dust, and displaying faint aged ink marks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a ginger longhair cat visible wearing deep blue velvet attire with gold embroidery and a white lace ruffle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the cat curled into a ball on a crimson velvet cushion with only its tail tip twitching and chest rising and falling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a retro film texture with delicate grain resembling a classical oil painting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11475116014480591 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.239751100540161 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11475116014480591, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11475116014480591, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04603356495499611, + 0.028770320117473602, + 0.03287499025464058, + 0.36869367957115173, + 0.07021286338567734, + 0.06968743354082108, + 0.09907007962465286, + 0.138912171125412, + 0.12362004816532135, + 0.02212480641901493 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11475116014480591 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a slow pan to the right across a pile of official documents on a heavy mahogany table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the parchment yellowed, coated with gray dust, and displaying faint aged ink marks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a ginger longhair cat visible wearing deep blue velvet attire with gold embroidery and a white lace ruffle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the cat curled into a ball on a crimson velvet cushion with only its tail tip twitching and chest rising and falling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a retro film texture with delicate grain resembling a classical oil painting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07903867959976196 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.579038619995117 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07903867959976196, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07903867959976196, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2586090564727783, + 0.031447701156139374, + 0.03422200679779053, + 0.21772895753383636, + 0.24849453568458557, + 0.026793094351887703, + 0.061207085847854614, + 0.043901342898607254, + 0.030844515189528465, + 0.046751681715250015 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07903867959976196 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a slow pan to the right across a pile of official documents on a heavy mahogany table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the parchment yellowed, coated with gray dust, and displaying faint aged ink marks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a ginger longhair cat visible wearing deep blue velvet attire with gold embroidery and a white lace ruffle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the cat curled into a ball on a crimson velvet cushion with only its tail tip twitching and chest rising and falling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a retro film texture with delicate grain resembling a classical oil painting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0486576184630394 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486576557159424 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0486576184630394, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0486576184630394, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13652200996875763, + 0.06325078010559082, + 0.03656772896647453, + 0.17590360343456268, + 0.2026359587907791, + 0.0994616448879242, + 0.07378906011581421, + 0.11963789165019989, + 0.05508464574813843, + 0.03714673966169357 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0486576184630394 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a slow pan to the right across a pile of official documents on a heavy mahogany table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the parchment yellowed, coated with gray dust, and displaying faint aged ink marks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a ginger longhair cat visible wearing deep blue velvet attire with gold embroidery and a white lace ruffle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the cat curled into a ball on a crimson velvet cushion with only its tail tip twitching and chest rising and falling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a retro film texture with delicate grain resembling a classical oil painting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2813430428504944 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4063429832458496 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2813430428504944, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2813430428504944, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10464084148406982, + 0.03413747251033783, + 0.04770674556493759, + 0.056341324001550674, + 0.14885635673999786, + 0.09714862704277039, + 0.08718516677618027, + 0.23134545981884003, + 0.11801435053348541, + 0.07462361454963684 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 4, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2813430428504944 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a slow pan to the right across a pile of official documents on a heavy mahogany table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the parchment yellowed, coated with gray dust, and displaying faint aged ink marks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a ginger longhair cat visible wearing deep blue velvet attire with gold embroidery and a white lace ruffle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the cat curled into a ball on a crimson velvet cushion with only its tail tip twitching and chest rising and falling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a retro film texture with delicate grain resembling a classical oil painting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06206027418375015 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120603561401367 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06206027418375015, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06206027418375015, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2728434205055237, + 0.04085671156644821, + 0.04582389071583748, + 0.0908413976430893, + 0.07693993300199509, + 0.13775412738323212, + 0.11681246757507324, + 0.12200474739074707, + 0.03811364620923996, + 0.058009613305330276 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06206027418375015 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow panning shot to the right first sweeps across a pile of official documents haphazardly stacked on a heavy mahogany table. The yellowed parchment is coated with a thin layer of gray dust. In the soft light slanting in from the high windows, the aged ink marks are faintly visible, and fine dust particles hang in the air. With steady and deliberate movement, the camera finally focuses on a ginger longhair cat, peacefully hibernating. It is clad in a magnificent, custom-made ministerial attire of deep blue velvet, with intricate gold embroidery adorning the collar and cuffs, and a delicate white lace ruffle at the neck. Curled up on a luxurious crimson velvet cushion, the cat is curled into a compact, perfect ball of fur, its furry tail tip twitching only occasionally, its chest rising and falling rhythmically with its deep, steady breathing. The entire scene is bathed in a warm and soft halo, creating a tranquil, solemn and slightly magical atmosphere. The overall picture presents a distinct retro film texture and delicate grain, like a breathing classical oil painting forgotten by time.", + "seed": 9909, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_10/index_9051_seed_9909_dp_20_rank_40_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.07786226123571396, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07786226123571396, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.574999976158142, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07786226123571396, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a slow pan to the right across a pile of official documents on a heavy mahogany table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the parchment yellowed, coated with gray dust, and displaying faint aged ink marks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a ginger longhair cat visible wearing deep blue velvet attire with gold embroidery and a white lace ruffle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the cat curled into a ball on a crimson velvet cushion with only its tail tip twitching and chest rising and falling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a retro film texture with delicate grain resembling a classical oil painting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06319567561149597 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8131957054138184 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06319567561149597, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06319567561149597, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05053982883691788, + 0.0684572234749794, + 0.020645003765821457, + 0.020074082538485527, + 0.045855943113565445, + 0.03018117882311344, + 0.018080122768878937, + 0.050862327218055725, + 0.0685754045844078, + 0.626728892326355 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06319567561149597 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a slow pan to the right across a pile of official documents on a heavy mahogany table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the parchment yellowed, coated with gray dust, and displaying faint aged ink marks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a ginger longhair cat visible wearing deep blue velvet attire with gold embroidery and a white lace ruffle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the cat curled into a ball on a crimson velvet cushion with only its tail tip twitching and chest rising and falling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a retro film texture with delicate grain resembling a classical oil painting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08910554647445679 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4641056060791016 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08910554647445679, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08910554647445679, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.026833252981305122, + 0.04493274539709091, + 0.014371802099049091, + 0.011451357044279575, + 0.02246888540685177, + 0.03516817092895508, + 0.014092698693275452, + 0.05180865526199341, + 0.03718005120754242, + 0.7416924238204956 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08910554647445679 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a slow pan to the right across a pile of official documents on a heavy mahogany table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the parchment yellowed, coated with gray dust, and displaying faint aged ink marks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a ginger longhair cat visible wearing deep blue velvet attire with gold embroidery and a white lace ruffle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the cat curled into a ball on a crimson velvet cushion with only its tail tip twitching and chest rising and falling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a retro film texture with delicate grain resembling a classical oil painting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05497336387634277 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299733638763428 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05497336387634277, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05497336387634277, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.02379387803375721, + 0.011866224929690361, + 0.007678158115595579, + 0.01102691050618887, + 0.037055861204862595, + 0.023887941613793373, + 0.06545331329107285, + 0.14176207780838013, + 0.05750928074121475, + 0.6199663877487183 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05497336387634277 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a slow pan to the right across a pile of official documents on a heavy mahogany table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the parchment yellowed, coated with gray dust, and displaying faint aged ink marks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a ginger longhair cat visible wearing deep blue velvet attire with gold embroidery and a white lace ruffle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the cat curled into a ball on a crimson velvet cushion with only its tail tip twitching and chest rising and falling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a retro film texture with delicate grain resembling a classical oil painting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12706978619098663 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1270697116851807 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12706978619098663, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.9999998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12706978619098663, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.029947388917207718, + 0.017304467037320137, + 0.015539025887846947, + 0.014613386243581772, + 0.27716338634490967, + 0.046310801059007645, + 0.05055798590183258, + 0.10437970608472824, + 0.2865089774131775, + 0.1576748639345169 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12706978619098663 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a slow pan to the right across a pile of official documents on a heavy mahogany table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the parchment yellowed, coated with gray dust, and displaying faint aged ink marks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a ginger longhair cat visible wearing deep blue velvet attire with gold embroidery and a white lace ruffle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the cat curled into a ball on a crimson velvet cushion with only its tail tip twitching and chest rising and falling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a retro film texture with delicate grain resembling a classical oil painting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05496693402528763 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929966926574707 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05496693402528763, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05496693402528763, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04232412576675415, + 0.037567831575870514, + 0.047699615359306335, + 0.05151217803359032, + 0.08542963117361069, + 0.04711052402853966, + 0.030024126172065735, + 0.06344442069530487, + 0.14730162918567657, + 0.44758591055870056 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05496693402528763 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow panning shot to the right first sweeps across a pile of official documents haphazardly stacked on a heavy mahogany table. The yellowed parchment is coated with a thin layer of gray dust. In the soft light slanting in from the high windows, the aged ink marks are faintly visible, and fine dust particles hang in the air. With steady and deliberate movement, the camera finally focuses on a ginger longhair cat, peacefully hibernating. It is clad in a magnificent, custom-made ministerial attire of deep blue velvet, with intricate gold embroidery adorning the collar and cuffs, and a delicate white lace ruffle at the neck. Curled up on a luxurious crimson velvet cushion, the cat is curled into a compact, perfect ball of fur, its furry tail tip twitching only occasionally, its chest rising and falling rhythmically with its deep, steady breathing. The entire scene is bathed in a warm and soft halo, creating a tranquil, solemn and slightly magical atmosphere. The overall picture presents a distinct retro film texture and delicate grain, like a breathing classical oil painting forgotten by time.", + "seed": 9910, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_10/index_9051_seed_9910_dp_21_rank_42_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.11275447830557823, + "vlm_logprob": -0.11275447830557823, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.200000023841858, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.11275447830557823, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a slow pan to the right across a pile of official documents on a heavy mahogany table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the parchment yellowed, coated with gray dust, and displaying faint aged ink marks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a ginger longhair cat visible wearing deep blue velvet attire with gold embroidery and a white lace ruffle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the cat curled into a ball on a crimson velvet cushion with only its tail tip twitching and chest rising and falling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a retro film texture with delicate grain resembling a classical oil painting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16174036264419556 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9117403030395508 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16174036264419556, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16174036264419556, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.30931514501571655, + 0.09954483062028885, + 0.12465736269950867, + 0.10773997008800507, + 0.11360703408718109, + 0.09836999326944351, + 0.04511205852031708, + 0.043363869190216064, + 0.025002146139740944, + 0.03328754007816315 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16174036264419556 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a slow pan to the right across a pile of official documents on a heavy mahogany table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the parchment yellowed, coated with gray dust, and displaying faint aged ink marks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a ginger longhair cat visible wearing deep blue velvet attire with gold embroidery and a white lace ruffle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the cat curled into a ball on a crimson velvet cushion with only its tail tip twitching and chest rising and falling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a retro film texture with delicate grain resembling a classical oil painting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12712301313877106 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1271231174468994 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12712301313877106, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12712301313877106, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24153167009353638, + 0.12698905169963837, + 0.1430228054523468, + 0.0810399204492569, + 0.07312661409378052, + 0.08076408505439758, + 0.05129561573266983, + 0.09844119846820831, + 0.02645367942750454, + 0.07733532786369324 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12712301313877106 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a slow pan to the right across a pile of official documents on a heavy mahogany table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the parchment yellowed, coated with gray dust, and displaying faint aged ink marks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a ginger longhair cat visible wearing deep blue velvet attire with gold embroidery and a white lace ruffle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the cat curled into a ball on a crimson velvet cushion with only its tail tip twitching and chest rising and falling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a retro film texture with delicate grain resembling a classical oil painting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07003071159124374 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695030689239502 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07003071159124374, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07003071159124374, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10842134803533554, + 0.06616514921188354, + 0.08965252339839935, + 0.06307472288608551, + 0.19406574964523315, + 0.22648648917675018, + 0.1071542426943779, + 0.03866611421108246, + 0.049238696694374084, + 0.05707494914531708 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07003071159124374 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a slow pan to the right across a pile of official documents on a heavy mahogany table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the parchment yellowed, coated with gray dust, and displaying faint aged ink marks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a ginger longhair cat visible wearing deep blue velvet attire with gold embroidery and a white lace ruffle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the cat curled into a ball on a crimson velvet cushion with only its tail tip twitching and chest rising and falling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a retro film texture with delicate grain resembling a classical oil painting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14282195270061493 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.017822027206421 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14282195270061493, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.8750001192092896, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14282195270061493, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0702858492732048, + 0.08236020803451538, + 0.0927160382270813, + 0.15701352059841156, + 0.1484820693731308, + 0.20699262619018555, + 0.04192734882235527, + 0.07472637295722961, + 0.06459739059209824, + 0.06089862063527107 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14282195270061493 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a slow pan to the right across a pile of official documents on a heavy mahogany table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the parchment yellowed, coated with gray dust, and displaying faint aged ink marks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a ginger longhair cat visible wearing deep blue velvet attire with gold embroidery and a white lace ruffle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the cat curled into a ball on a crimson velvet cushion with only its tail tip twitching and chest rising and falling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a retro film texture with delicate grain resembling a classical oil painting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06205635145306587 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812056303024292 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06205635145306587, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06205635145306587, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.26653552055358887, + 0.10046739131212234, + 0.1440194994211197, + 0.05327488109469414, + 0.11680105328559875, + 0.0746709555387497, + 0.056703172624111176, + 0.08423249423503876, + 0.0454489029943943, + 0.05784612521529198 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06205635145306587 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow panning shot to the right first sweeps across a pile of official documents haphazardly stacked on a heavy mahogany table. The yellowed parchment is coated with a thin layer of gray dust. In the soft light slanting in from the high windows, the aged ink marks are faintly visible, and fine dust particles hang in the air. With steady and deliberate movement, the camera finally focuses on a ginger longhair cat, peacefully hibernating. It is clad in a magnificent, custom-made ministerial attire of deep blue velvet, with intricate gold embroidery adorning the collar and cuffs, and a delicate white lace ruffle at the neck. Curled up on a luxurious crimson velvet cushion, the cat is curled into a compact, perfect ball of fur, its furry tail tip twitching only occasionally, its chest rising and falling rhythmically with its deep, steady breathing. The entire scene is bathed in a warm and soft halo, creating a tranquil, solemn and slightly magical atmosphere. The overall picture presents a distinct retro film texture and delicate grain, like a breathing classical oil painting forgotten by time.", + "seed": 9911, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_10/index_9051_seed_9911_dp_21_rank_42_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.09405420646071434, + "vlm_logprob": -0.09405420646071434, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.775, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.09405420646071434, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a slow pan to the right across a pile of official documents on a heavy mahogany table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the parchment yellowed, coated with gray dust, and displaying faint aged ink marks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a ginger longhair cat visible wearing deep blue velvet attire with gold embroidery and a white lace ruffle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the cat curled into a ball on a crimson velvet cushion with only its tail tip twitching and chest rising and falling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a retro film texture with delicate grain resembling a classical oil painting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.25310245156288147 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.503102421760559 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.25310245156288147, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.25310245156288147, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06006428226828575, + 0.0671040266752243, + 0.5607469081878662, + 0.02823556214570999, + 0.11631837487220764, + 0.10037452727556229, + 0.018734203651547432, + 0.01379355601966381, + 0.010490343905985355, + 0.024138223379850388 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.25310245156288147 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a slow pan to the right across a pile of official documents on a heavy mahogany table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the parchment yellowed, coated with gray dust, and displaying faint aged ink marks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a ginger longhair cat visible wearing deep blue velvet attire with gold embroidery and a white lace ruffle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the cat curled into a ball on a crimson velvet cushion with only its tail tip twitching and chest rising and falling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a retro film texture with delicate grain resembling a classical oil painting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12715628743171692 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1271562576293945 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12715628743171692, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12715628743171692, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07257134467363358, + 0.057524193078279495, + 0.6454454064369202, + 0.030725596472620964, + 0.04299827665090561, + 0.0538337416946888, + 0.014564791694283485, + 0.022138351574540138, + 0.016391759738326073, + 0.043806519359350204 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12715628743171692 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a slow pan to the right across a pile of official documents on a heavy mahogany table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the parchment yellowed, coated with gray dust, and displaying faint aged ink marks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a ginger longhair cat visible wearing deep blue velvet attire with gold embroidery and a white lace ruffle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the cat curled into a ball on a crimson velvet cushion with only its tail tip twitching and chest rising and falling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a retro film texture with delicate grain resembling a classical oil painting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04306808114051819 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680681705474854 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04306808114051819, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04306808114051819, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.055670399218797684, + 0.10360433906316757, + 0.30777671933174133, + 0.016821686178445816, + 0.15717142820358276, + 0.11261173337697983, + 0.07777822762727737, + 0.09607338160276413, + 0.0445556566119194, + 0.027936376631259918 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04306808114051819 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a slow pan to the right across a pile of official documents on a heavy mahogany table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the parchment yellowed, coated with gray dust, and displaying faint aged ink marks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a ginger longhair cat visible wearing deep blue velvet attire with gold embroidery and a white lace ruffle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the cat curled into a ball on a crimson velvet cushion with only its tail tip twitching and chest rising and falling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a retro film texture with delicate grain resembling a classical oil painting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020588379353284836 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955883979797363 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020588379353284836, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020588379353284836, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05134335532784462, + 0.11836383491754532, + 0.26087307929992676, + 0.050285037606954575, + 0.08156150579452515, + 0.10220953822135925, + 0.06122630834579468, + 0.05184502154588699, + 0.18335366249084473, + 0.03893868252635002 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020588379353284836 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a slow pan to the right across a pile of official documents on a heavy mahogany table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the parchment yellowed, coated with gray dust, and displaying faint aged ink marks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a ginger longhair cat visible wearing deep blue velvet attire with gold embroidery and a white lace ruffle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the cat curled into a ball on a crimson velvet cushion with only its tail tip twitching and chest rising and falling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a retro film texture with delicate grain resembling a classical oil painting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026355832815170288 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651355743408203 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026355832815170288, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026355832815170288, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1533280909061432, + 0.06032364070415497, + 0.17926310002803802, + 0.14994733035564423, + 0.16724054515361786, + 0.08289100229740143, + 0.07136762142181396, + 0.023198014125227928, + 0.050628114491701126, + 0.06181250512599945 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026355832815170288 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_11/index_tensor([2072, 2072])_group_11_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_11/index_tensor([2072, 2072])_group_11_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..b901c3e7cdde74e10f29671d6e19357fa88deeea --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_11/index_tensor([2072, 2072])_group_11_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "An unsteady, slightly trembling overhead shot slowly pulls back to reveal the entire, baffling spectacle, beginning with a heavy, dark wooden table, upon which rests an open hardcover copy of A Brief History of Time. From between the yellowed pages, countless shimmering cosmic dust and luminous, translucent mathematical equations rise in elegant spirals, forming a dazzling galaxy of knowledge connecting the book to the ceiling. Meanwhile, the surrounding, cathedral-like library undergoes an Inception-like geometric folding. Towering mahogany shelves bend and twist in ways that defy the laws of physics, forming impossible angles and surreal arches. The floor curls upward, the ceiling folds downward, the entire spatial structure resembling a complex dream undergoing self-reconfiguration. The cool bluish-violet light emanating from the equations and dust intertwines with the warm yellow light of the library's original lamps, emanating from their classic green shades, casting a shifting, grotesque, and dynamic shadows across the warped wooden surfaces. While capturing this surreal and magnificent scene, the camera's slight shaking exacerbates the instability of the picture, creating an awe-inspiring visual shock that is both chaotic and extremely orderly, perfectly capturing the moment when knowledge breaks through physical constraints.", + "seed": 9794, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_11/index_2072_seed_9794_dp_22_rank_44_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.11024288441985845, + "vlm_logprob": -0.11024288441985845, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.075, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.11024288441985845, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is an open hardcover copy of 'A Brief History of Time' visible on a heavy dark wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do shimmering cosmic dust and luminous mathematical equations rise from the book's pages in elegant spirals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the library's mahogany shelves bend and twist into impossible angles and surreal arches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature cool bluish-violet light from the equations mixing with warm yellow light from lamps with classic green shades?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot unsteady and slightly trembling while slowly pulling back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06236104294657707 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812361001968384 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06236104294657707, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06236104294657707, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.6708918213844299, + 0.09584934264421463, + 0.02443937584757805, + 0.02661997079849243, + 0.05879516154527664, + 0.01643482781946659, + 0.027458487078547478, + 0.023364219814538956, + 0.029489099979400635, + 0.026657650247216225 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06236104294657707 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is an open hardcover copy of 'A Brief History of Time' visible on a heavy dark wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do shimmering cosmic dust and luminous mathematical equations rise from the book's pages in elegant spirals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the library's mahogany shelves bend and twist into impossible angles and surreal arches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature cool bluish-violet light from the equations mixing with warm yellow light from lamps with classic green shades?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot unsteady and slightly trembling while slowly pulling back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005259842611849308 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255259990692139 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005259842611849308, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005259842611849308, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5272496938705444, + 0.05015156418085098, + 0.03345238044857979, + 0.02650882489979267, + 0.07035572826862335, + 0.02324814721941948, + 0.07909535616636276, + 0.10323656350374222, + 0.039662208408117294, + 0.047039590775966644 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005259842611849308 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is an open hardcover copy of 'A Brief History of Time' visible on a heavy dark wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do shimmering cosmic dust and luminous mathematical equations rise from the book's pages in elegant spirals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the library's mahogany shelves bend and twist into impossible angles and surreal arches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature cool bluish-violet light from the equations mixing with warm yellow light from lamps with classic green shades?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot unsteady and slightly trembling while slowly pulling back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16038566827774048 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9103856086730957 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16038566827774048, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16038566827774048, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22461676597595215, + 0.04568514600396156, + 0.028355155140161514, + 0.043746814131736755, + 0.10325074940919876, + 0.06146542727947235, + 0.180462047457695, + 0.05857539176940918, + 0.1723613291978836, + 0.0814811959862709 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16038566827774048 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is an open hardcover copy of 'A Brief History of Time' visible on a heavy dark wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do shimmering cosmic dust and luminous mathematical equations rise from the book's pages in elegant spirals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the library's mahogany shelves bend and twist into impossible angles and surreal arches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature cool bluish-violet light from the equations mixing with warm yellow light from lamps with classic green shades?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot unsteady and slightly trembling while slowly pulling back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009781880304217339 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634781837463379 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009781880304217339, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009781880304217339, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.511612057685852, + 0.04033803194761276, + 0.03272409737110138, + 0.058075159788131714, + 0.08922954648733139, + 0.05819930508732796, + 0.07436756044626236, + 0.04136475548148155, + 0.05969648435711861, + 0.034393008798360825 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009781880304217339 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is an open hardcover copy of 'A Brief History of Time' visible on a heavy dark wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do shimmering cosmic dust and luminous mathematical equations rise from the book's pages in elegant spirals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the library's mahogany shelves bend and twist into impossible angles and surreal arches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature cool bluish-violet light from the equations mixing with warm yellow light from lamps with classic green shades?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot unsteady and slightly trembling while slowly pulling back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3134259879589081 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3134260177612305 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3134259879589081, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3134259879589081, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4281882643699646, + 0.05741375684738159, + 0.05698571726679802, + 0.020951958373188972, + 0.12794160842895508, + 0.07503689080476761, + 0.0997072160243988, + 0.04453049972653389, + 0.05445951968431473, + 0.034784480929374695 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3134259879589081 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An unsteady, slightly trembling overhead shot slowly pulls back to reveal the entire, baffling spectacle, beginning with a heavy, dark wooden table, upon which rests an open hardcover copy of A Brief History of Time. From between the yellowed pages, countless shimmering cosmic dust and luminous, translucent mathematical equations rise in elegant spirals, forming a dazzling galaxy of knowledge connecting the book to the ceiling. Meanwhile, the surrounding, cathedral-like library undergoes an Inception-like geometric folding. Towering mahogany shelves bend and twist in ways that defy the laws of physics, forming impossible angles and surreal arches. The floor curls upward, the ceiling folds downward, the entire spatial structure resembling a complex dream undergoing self-reconfiguration. The cool bluish-violet light emanating from the equations and dust intertwines with the warm yellow light of the library's original lamps, emanating from their classic green shades, casting a shifting, grotesque, and dynamic shadows across the warped wooden surfaces. While capturing this surreal and magnificent scene, the camera's slight shaking exacerbates the instability of the picture, creating an awe-inspiring visual shock that is both chaotic and extremely orderly, perfectly capturing the moment when knowledge breaks through physical constraints.", + "seed": 9795, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_11/index_2072_seed_9795_dp_22_rank_44_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.06678019911050796, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06678019911050796, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.3, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06678019911050796, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is an open hardcover copy of 'A Brief History of Time' visible on a heavy dark wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do shimmering cosmic dust and luminous mathematical equations rise from the book's pages in elegant spirals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the library's mahogany shelves bend and twist into impossible angles and surreal arches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature cool bluish-violet light from the equations mixing with warm yellow light from lamps with classic green shades?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot unsteady and slightly trembling while slowly pulling back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03414589539170265 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4091458320617676 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03414589539170265, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03414589539170265, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2682983875274658, + 0.03912045434117317, + 0.12387797981500626, + 0.10348052531480789, + 0.1377057582139969, + 0.14335118234157562, + 0.04703424125909805, + 0.0415889248251915, + 0.043915554881095886, + 0.05162699893116951 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03414589539170265 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is an open hardcover copy of 'A Brief History of Time' visible on a heavy dark wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do shimmering cosmic dust and luminous mathematical equations rise from the book's pages in elegant spirals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the library's mahogany shelves bend and twist into impossible angles and surreal arches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature cool bluish-violet light from the equations mixing with warm yellow light from lamps with classic green shades?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot unsteady and slightly trembling while slowly pulling back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009786837734282017 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634786605834961 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009786837734282017, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009786837734282017, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1691276729106903, + 0.07532227784395218, + 0.14865370094776154, + 0.037743039429187775, + 0.0896856039762497, + 0.24483579397201538, + 0.07216700911521912, + 0.047435276210308075, + 0.057431355118751526, + 0.05759827420115471 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009786837734282017 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is an open hardcover copy of 'A Brief History of Time' visible on a heavy dark wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do shimmering cosmic dust and luminous mathematical equations rise from the book's pages in elegant spirals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the library's mahogany shelves bend and twist into impossible angles and surreal arches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature cool bluish-violet light from the equations mixing with warm yellow light from lamps with classic green shades?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot unsteady and slightly trembling while slowly pulling back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10032585263252258 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3503258228302 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10032585263252258, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10032585263252258, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11731401830911636, + 0.04116428643465042, + 0.05581744387745857, + 0.06385862827301025, + 0.1510523408651352, + 0.250880628824234, + 0.14863909780979156, + 0.0932280495762825, + 0.04486304149031639, + 0.033182431012392044 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10032585263252258 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is an open hardcover copy of 'A Brief History of Time' visible on a heavy dark wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do shimmering cosmic dust and luminous mathematical equations rise from the book's pages in elegant spirals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the library's mahogany shelves bend and twist into impossible angles and surreal arches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature cool bluish-violet light from the equations mixing with warm yellow light from lamps with classic green shades?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot unsteady and slightly trembling while slowly pulling back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009779046289622784 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.63477897644043 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009779046289622784, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009779046289622784, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14849525690078735, + 0.07898882776498795, + 0.1561005562543869, + 0.1388307809829712, + 0.07853049784898758, + 0.17925213277339935, + 0.09809830784797668, + 0.03247573971748352, + 0.03945712745189667, + 0.04977082461118698 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009779046289622784 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is an open hardcover copy of 'A Brief History of Time' visible on a heavy dark wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do shimmering cosmic dust and luminous mathematical equations rise from the book's pages in elegant spirals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the library's mahogany shelves bend and twist into impossible angles and surreal arches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature cool bluish-violet light from the equations mixing with warm yellow light from lamps with classic green shades?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot unsteady and slightly trembling while slowly pulling back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1798633635044098 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8048633337020874 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1798633635044098, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1798633635044098, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06050770357251167, + 0.06302312016487122, + 0.0903039202094078, + 0.14789064228534698, + 0.14847664535045624, + 0.31481629610061646, + 0.11983349174261093, + 0.027998989447951317, + 0.01860719732940197, + 0.008541987277567387 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1798633635044098 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An unsteady, slightly trembling overhead shot slowly pulls back to reveal the entire, baffling spectacle, beginning with a heavy, dark wooden table, upon which rests an open hardcover copy of A Brief History of Time. From between the yellowed pages, countless shimmering cosmic dust and luminous, translucent mathematical equations rise in elegant spirals, forming a dazzling galaxy of knowledge connecting the book to the ceiling. Meanwhile, the surrounding, cathedral-like library undergoes an Inception-like geometric folding. Towering mahogany shelves bend and twist in ways that defy the laws of physics, forming impossible angles and surreal arches. The floor curls upward, the ceiling folds downward, the entire spatial structure resembling a complex dream undergoing self-reconfiguration. The cool bluish-violet light emanating from the equations and dust intertwines with the warm yellow light of the library's original lamps, emanating from their classic green shades, casting a shifting, grotesque, and dynamic shadows across the warped wooden surfaces. While capturing this surreal and magnificent scene, the camera's slight shaking exacerbates the instability of the picture, creating an awe-inspiring visual shock that is both chaotic and extremely orderly, perfectly capturing the moment when knowledge breaks through physical constraints.", + "seed": 9796, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_11/index_2072_seed_9796_dp_23_rank_46_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.11046460466459393, + "vlm_logprob": -0.11046460466459393, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.4, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.11046460466459393, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is an open hardcover copy of 'A Brief History of Time' visible on a heavy dark wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do shimmering cosmic dust and luminous mathematical equations rise from the book's pages in elegant spirals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the library's mahogany shelves bend and twist into impossible angles and surreal arches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature cool bluish-violet light from the equations mixing with warm yellow light from lamps with classic green shades?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot unsteady and slightly trembling while slowly pulling back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023798992857336998 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773798942565918 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023798992857336998, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023798992857336998, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18169692158699036, + 0.025194110348820686, + 0.09268985688686371, + 0.054595667868852615, + 0.5048742890357971, + 0.0285906121134758, + 0.04442451521754265, + 0.028105231001973152, + 0.027775254100561142, + 0.012053493410348892 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023798992857336998 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is an open hardcover copy of 'A Brief History of Time' visible on a heavy dark wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do shimmering cosmic dust and luminous mathematical equations rise from the book's pages in elegant spirals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the library's mahogany shelves bend and twist into impossible angles and surreal arches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature cool bluish-violet light from the equations mixing with warm yellow light from lamps with classic green shades?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot unsteady and slightly trembling while slowly pulling back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004642185289412737 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379642009735107 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004642185289412737, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004642185289412737, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22553956508636475, + 0.03364492952823639, + 0.05442977324128151, + 0.044981859624385834, + 0.37410297989845276, + 0.07116852700710297, + 0.0577947199344635, + 0.05517111346125603, + 0.0557192787528038, + 0.027447214350104332 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004642185289412737 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is an open hardcover copy of 'A Brief History of Time' visible on a heavy dark wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do shimmering cosmic dust and luminous mathematical equations rise from the book's pages in elegant spirals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the library's mahogany shelves bend and twist into impossible angles and surreal arches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature cool bluish-violet light from the equations mixing with warm yellow light from lamps with classic green shades?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot unsteady and slightly trembling while slowly pulling back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023289937525987625 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773289918899536 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023289937525987625, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023289937525987625, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08129426091909409, + 0.028939226642251015, + 0.05824610963463783, + 0.05615830048918724, + 0.48146146535873413, + 0.12853451073169708, + 0.07612749189138412, + 0.028319276869297028, + 0.04737941548228264, + 0.013539818115532398 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023289937525987625 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is an open hardcover copy of 'A Brief History of Time' visible on a heavy dark wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do shimmering cosmic dust and luminous mathematical equations rise from the book's pages in elegant spirals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the library's mahogany shelves bend and twist into impossible angles and surreal arches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature cool bluish-violet light from the equations mixing with warm yellow light from lamps with classic green shades?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot unsteady and slightly trembling while slowly pulling back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026342246681451797 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513421535491943 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026342246681451797, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026342246681451797, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3601105511188507, + 0.03920631483197212, + 0.04710584506392479, + 0.06081896647810936, + 0.27195706963539124, + 0.06600560992956161, + 0.07535496354103088, + 0.022180797532200813, + 0.04347634315490723, + 0.013783560134470463 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026342246681451797 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is an open hardcover copy of 'A Brief History of Time' visible on a heavy dark wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do shimmering cosmic dust and luminous mathematical equations rise from the book's pages in elegant spirals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the library's mahogany shelves bend and twist into impossible angles and surreal arches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature cool bluish-violet light from the equations mixing with warm yellow light from lamps with classic green shades?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot unsteady and slightly trembling while slowly pulling back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4742496609687805 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9742496609687805 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.4742496609687805, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.4742496609687805, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3278198838233948, + 0.047056373208761215, + 0.03048071637749672, + 0.056942813098430634, + 0.17374369502067566, + 0.13648979365825653, + 0.0848098024725914, + 0.07414497435092926, + 0.04975048452615738, + 0.018761446699500084 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.4742496609687805 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An unsteady, slightly trembling overhead shot slowly pulls back to reveal the entire, baffling spectacle, beginning with a heavy, dark wooden table, upon which rests an open hardcover copy of A Brief History of Time. From between the yellowed pages, countless shimmering cosmic dust and luminous, translucent mathematical equations rise in elegant spirals, forming a dazzling galaxy of knowledge connecting the book to the ceiling. Meanwhile, the surrounding, cathedral-like library undergoes an Inception-like geometric folding. Towering mahogany shelves bend and twist in ways that defy the laws of physics, forming impossible angles and surreal arches. The floor curls upward, the ceiling folds downward, the entire spatial structure resembling a complex dream undergoing self-reconfiguration. The cool bluish-violet light emanating from the equations and dust intertwines with the warm yellow light of the library's original lamps, emanating from their classic green shades, casting a shifting, grotesque, and dynamic shadows across the warped wooden surfaces. While capturing this surreal and magnificent scene, the camera's slight shaking exacerbates the instability of the picture, creating an awe-inspiring visual shock that is both chaotic and extremely orderly, perfectly capturing the moment when knowledge breaks through physical constraints.", + "seed": 9797, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_11/index_2072_seed_9797_dp_23_rank_46_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.08453166019171476, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08453166019171476, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.1, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08453166019171476, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is an open hardcover copy of 'A Brief History of Time' visible on a heavy dark wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do shimmering cosmic dust and luminous mathematical equations rise from the book's pages in elegant spirals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the library's mahogany shelves bend and twist into impossible angles and surreal arches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature cool bluish-violet light from the equations mixing with warm yellow light from lamps with classic green shades?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot unsteady and slightly trembling while slowly pulling back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03844551742076874 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288445472717285 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03844551742076874, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03844551742076874, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3494373559951782, + 0.05808817967772484, + 0.05315138027071953, + 0.11474266648292542, + 0.06052910536527634, + 0.13272112607955933, + 0.045590173453092575, + 0.06428691744804382, + 0.05079122260212898, + 0.07066191732883453 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03844551742076874 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is an open hardcover copy of 'A Brief History of Time' visible on a heavy dark wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do shimmering cosmic dust and luminous mathematical equations rise from the book's pages in elegant spirals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the library's mahogany shelves bend and twist into impossible angles and surreal arches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature cool bluish-violet light from the equations mixing with warm yellow light from lamps with classic green shades?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot unsteady and slightly trembling while slowly pulling back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00978896301239729 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634788990020752 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00978896301239729, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00978896301239729, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09264417737722397, + 0.03982377424836159, + 0.037856586277484894, + 0.10820028185844421, + 0.05839626118540764, + 0.09311366826295853, + 0.06597231328487396, + 0.1428418755531311, + 0.10629420727491379, + 0.2548568546772003 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00978896301239729 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is an open hardcover copy of 'A Brief History of Time' visible on a heavy dark wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do shimmering cosmic dust and luminous mathematical equations rise from the book's pages in elegant spirals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the library's mahogany shelves bend and twist into impossible angles and surreal arches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature cool bluish-violet light from the equations mixing with warm yellow light from lamps with classic green shades?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot unsteady and slightly trembling while slowly pulling back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.201551616191864 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7015516757965088 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.201551616191864, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.201551616191864, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09679937362670898, + 0.10014092177152634, + 0.11027558892965317, + 0.31820106506347656, + 0.0576159693300724, + 0.10519010573625565, + 0.03813283517956734, + 0.06269703805446625, + 0.05223161354660988, + 0.05871547758579254 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.201551616191864 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is an open hardcover copy of 'A Brief History of Time' visible on a heavy dark wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do shimmering cosmic dust and luminous mathematical equations rise from the book's pages in elegant spirals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the library's mahogany shelves bend and twist into impossible angles and surreal arches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature cool bluish-violet light from the equations mixing with warm yellow light from lamps with classic green shades?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot unsteady and slightly trembling while slowly pulling back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012535471469163895 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387535572052002 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012535471469163895, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012535471469163895, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14073611795902252, + 0.11850680410861969, + 0.09088889509439468, + 0.14181697368621826, + 0.033024273812770844, + 0.16918669641017914, + 0.0390608049929142, + 0.07663314044475555, + 0.07123883813619614, + 0.11890746653079987 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012535471469163895 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is an open hardcover copy of 'A Brief History of Time' visible on a heavy dark wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do shimmering cosmic dust and luminous mathematical equations rise from the book's pages in elegant spirals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the library's mahogany shelves bend and twist into impossible angles and surreal arches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature cool bluish-violet light from the equations mixing with warm yellow light from lamps with classic green shades?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot unsteady and slightly trembling while slowly pulling back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16033673286437988 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9103367328643799 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16033673286437988, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16033673286437988, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1623048484325409, + 0.0771460011601448, + 0.14102362096309662, + 0.10705285519361496, + 0.08536544442176819, + 0.1442631185054779, + 0.07075286656618118, + 0.12076834589242935, + 0.05045431852340698, + 0.04086856544017792 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16033673286437988 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_12/index_tensor([3666, 3666])_group_12_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_12/index_tensor([3666, 3666])_group_12_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..0b19715f0c2c29553c5ddde52e2f46a779bb33f9 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_12/index_tensor([3666, 3666])_group_12_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "From a high-angle wide shot, the camera slowly descends and circles a starkly contrasting scene, revealing a small group of people tightly packed together in the absolute center of a vast, immaculate sports field. Deep green, perfectly manicured grass stretches into the darkness surrounding the empty, cavernous stadium. Towering light masts, unseen beyond the frame, pour down intense, cool-white illumination, carving the figures out of the night and creating a powerful black-and-white contrast. Bright overhead lighting falls on their heads and shoulders, casting their faces in deep, expressive shadows. Their bodies cast long, sharp, twisting shadows that stretch like black fingers across the grass. The figures, dressed in tracksuits, are huddled together, shoulders pressed together, some with their arms draped over their neighbors, heads bowed together in a tight circle. Though largely still, the huddled figures are imbued with subtle movement, chests rising and falling with heavy, controlled breathing. The steam of their collective breath rises and mixes with the cold night air, catching the brilliant light. The atmosphere was charged with tension and focused solidarity; it was a private, high-stakes moment, isolated under the dramatic glare of the stadium lights, creating a powerful image of unity and impending action.", + "seed": 23407, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_12/index_3666_seed_23407_dp_24_rank_48_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.03542779497802258, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03542779497802258, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.7, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03542779497802258, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a high-angle wide shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly descend and circle the central group of people?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the figures dressed in tracksuits and huddled tightly together in the center of a vast sports field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by intense cool-white stadium lights creating a stark black-and-white contrast with deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are visible details such as rising steam from breath and long, sharp shadows cast on the grass present?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0972132459282875 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4722132682800293 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0972132459282875, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0972132459282875, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.26541435718536377, + 0.05243859812617302, + 0.04888704791665077, + 0.036014262586832047, + 0.07125920057296753, + 0.11118157207965851, + 0.14678481221199036, + 0.053884122520685196, + 0.18962351977825165, + 0.024512456730008125 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0972132459282875 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a high-angle wide shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly descend and circle the central group of people?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the figures dressed in tracksuits and huddled tightly together in the center of a vast sports field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by intense cool-white stadium lights creating a stark black-and-white contrast with deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are visible details such as rising steam from breath and long, sharp shadows cast on the grass present?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03812748193740845 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881274223327637 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03812748193740845, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03812748193740845, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08774399012327194, + 0.04186723008751869, + 0.035395748913288116, + 0.04718984290957451, + 0.027596453204751015, + 0.01913330890238285, + 0.11364679038524628, + 0.047171272337436676, + 0.5481829047203064, + 0.03207245096564293 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03812748193740845 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a high-angle wide shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly descend and circle the central group of people?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the figures dressed in tracksuits and huddled tightly together in the center of a vast sports field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by intense cool-white stadium lights creating a stark black-and-white contrast with deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are visible details such as rising steam from breath and long, sharp shadows cast on the grass present?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012539944611489773 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387539863586426 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012539944611489773, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012539944611489773, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18156753480434418, + 0.08975226432085037, + 0.033665888011455536, + 0.04032253473997116, + 0.018481668084859848, + 0.042979754507541656, + 0.33794617652893066, + 0.06853324919939041, + 0.1576574295759201, + 0.029093442484736443 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012539944611489773 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a high-angle wide shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly descend and circle the central group of people?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the figures dressed in tracksuits and huddled tightly together in the center of a vast sports field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by intense cool-white stadium lights creating a stark black-and-white contrast with deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are visible details such as rising steam from breath and long, sharp shadows cast on the grass present?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011075212620198727 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511075019836426 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011075212620198727, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011075212620198727, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.28563013672828674, + 0.12017497420310974, + 0.20014964044094086, + 0.03940242901444435, + 0.046725086867809296, + 0.061584651470184326, + 0.11039252579212189, + 0.0800250992178917, + 0.034335218369960785, + 0.02158024162054062 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011075212620198727 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a high-angle wide shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly descend and circle the central group of people?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the figures dressed in tracksuits and huddled tightly together in the center of a vast sports field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by intense cool-white stadium lights creating a stark black-and-white contrast with deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are visible details such as rising steam from breath and long, sharp shadows cast on the grass present?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018183089792728424 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.01818323135376 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018183089792728424, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018183089792728424, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17330551147460938, + 0.07295943796634674, + 0.03411351516842842, + 0.06790681183338165, + 0.06550578773021698, + 0.04971656948328018, + 0.16515009105205536, + 0.1336209923028946, + 0.20253588259220123, + 0.035185396671295166 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018183089792728424 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "From a high-angle wide shot, the camera slowly descends and circles a starkly contrasting scene, revealing a small group of people tightly packed together in the absolute center of a vast, immaculate sports field. Deep green, perfectly manicured grass stretches into the darkness surrounding the empty, cavernous stadium. Towering light masts, unseen beyond the frame, pour down intense, cool-white illumination, carving the figures out of the night and creating a powerful black-and-white contrast. Bright overhead lighting falls on their heads and shoulders, casting their faces in deep, expressive shadows. Their bodies cast long, sharp, twisting shadows that stretch like black fingers across the grass. The figures, dressed in tracksuits, are huddled together, shoulders pressed together, some with their arms draped over their neighbors, heads bowed together in a tight circle. Though largely still, the huddled figures are imbued with subtle movement, chests rising and falling with heavy, controlled breathing. The steam of their collective breath rises and mixes with the cold night air, catching the brilliant light. The atmosphere was charged with tension and focused solidarity; it was a private, high-stakes moment, isolated under the dramatic glare of the stadium lights, creating a powerful image of unity and impending action.", + "seed": 23408, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_12/index_3666_seed_23408_dp_24_rank_48_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.04402283225208521, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04402283225208521, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.875, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04402283225208521, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a high-angle wide shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly descend and circle the central group of people?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the figures dressed in tracksuits and huddled tightly together in the center of a vast sports field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by intense cool-white stadium lights creating a stark black-and-white contrast with deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are visible details such as rising steam from breath and long, sharp shadows cast on the grass present?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14900043606758118 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.024000406265259 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14900043606758118, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14900043606758118, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17840465903282166, + 0.10261587798595428, + 0.041606515645980835, + 0.07038139551877975, + 0.2917768061161041, + 0.1744246929883957, + 0.047350358217954636, + 0.04298432171344757, + 0.0222660880535841, + 0.028189288452267647 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14900043606758118 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a high-angle wide shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly descend and circle the central group of people?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the figures dressed in tracksuits and huddled tightly together in the center of a vast sports field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by intense cool-white stadium lights creating a stark black-and-white contrast with deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are visible details such as rising steam from breath and long, sharp shadows cast on the grass present?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.043070364743471146 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680703163146973 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.043070364743471146, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.043070364743471146, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2810126841068268, + 0.05565328896045685, + 0.059845566749572754, + 0.083023302257061, + 0.07192052155733109, + 0.053786519914865494, + 0.079171322286129, + 0.213418647646904, + 0.02959609217941761, + 0.0725720152258873 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.043070364743471146 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a high-angle wide shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly descend and circle the central group of people?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the figures dressed in tracksuits and huddled tightly together in the center of a vast sports field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by intense cool-white stadium lights creating a stark black-and-white contrast with deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are visible details such as rising steam from breath and long, sharp shadows cast on the grass present?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016062501817941666 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.1410627365112305 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016062501817941666, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016062501817941666, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.31227031350135803, + 0.08304420858621597, + 0.1247740238904953, + 0.15314088761806488, + 0.05098599195480347, + 0.0835631862282753, + 0.04741273447871208, + 0.08592768758535385, + 0.033429697155952454, + 0.02545125223696232 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016062501817941666 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a high-angle wide shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly descend and circle the central group of people?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the figures dressed in tracksuits and huddled tightly together in the center of a vast sports field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by intense cool-white stadium lights creating a stark black-and-white contrast with deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are visible details such as rising steam from breath and long, sharp shadows cast on the grass present?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005248458590358496 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255248546600342 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005248458590358496, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005248458590358496, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24382449686527252, + 0.07276485860347748, + 0.06562498211860657, + 0.12940911948680878, + 0.08168414980173111, + 0.13001027703285217, + 0.07965206354856491, + 0.1071767807006836, + 0.04893224686384201, + 0.040920987725257874 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005248458590358496 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a high-angle wide shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly descend and circle the central group of people?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the figures dressed in tracksuits and huddled tightly together in the center of a vast sports field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by intense cool-white stadium lights creating a stark black-and-white contrast with deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are visible details such as rising steam from breath and long, sharp shadows cast on the grass present?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006732400041073561 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.00673246383667 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006732400041073561, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006732400041073561, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2816997468471527, + 0.12567731738090515, + 0.13017407059669495, + 0.09772635251283646, + 0.0611051470041275, + 0.05370895192027092, + 0.047445543110370636, + 0.0751514732837677, + 0.04383096471428871, + 0.08348049223423004 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006732400041073561 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "From a high-angle wide shot, the camera slowly descends and circles a starkly contrasting scene, revealing a small group of people tightly packed together in the absolute center of a vast, immaculate sports field. Deep green, perfectly manicured grass stretches into the darkness surrounding the empty, cavernous stadium. Towering light masts, unseen beyond the frame, pour down intense, cool-white illumination, carving the figures out of the night and creating a powerful black-and-white contrast. Bright overhead lighting falls on their heads and shoulders, casting their faces in deep, expressive shadows. Their bodies cast long, sharp, twisting shadows that stretch like black fingers across the grass. The figures, dressed in tracksuits, are huddled together, shoulders pressed together, some with their arms draped over their neighbors, heads bowed together in a tight circle. Though largely still, the huddled figures are imbued with subtle movement, chests rising and falling with heavy, controlled breathing. The steam of their collective breath rises and mixes with the cold night air, catching the brilliant light. The atmosphere was charged with tension and focused solidarity; it was a private, high-stakes moment, isolated under the dramatic glare of the stadium lights, creating a powerful image of unity and impending action.", + "seed": 23409, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_12/index_3666_seed_23409_dp_25_rank_50_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.018324622977524997, + "vlm_logprob": -0.018324622977524997, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.275, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.018324622977524997, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a high-angle wide shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly descend and circle the central group of people?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the figures dressed in tracksuits and huddled tightly together in the center of a vast sports field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by intense cool-white stadium lights creating a stark black-and-white contrast with deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are visible details such as rising steam from breath and long, sharp shadows cast on the grass present?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03434944897890091 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5343494415283203 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03434944897890091, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03434944897890091, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11501961946487427, + 0.05993650481104851, + 0.0275120846927166, + 0.33365365862846375, + 0.2371315360069275, + 0.09468410909175873, + 0.0408247672021389, + 0.025161108002066612, + 0.02934662438929081, + 0.03673004359006882 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03434944897890091 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a high-angle wide shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly descend and circle the central group of people?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the figures dressed in tracksuits and huddled tightly together in the center of a vast sports field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by intense cool-white stadium lights creating a stark black-and-white contrast with deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are visible details such as rising steam from breath and long, sharp shadows cast on the grass present?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029811397194862366 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529811382293701 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029811397194862366, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029811397194862366, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06402707099914551, + 0.08890771865844727, + 0.035548366606235504, + 0.39510172605514526, + 0.08225050568580627, + 0.18824847042560577, + 0.0795525461435318, + 0.03027474880218506, + 0.013656693510711193, + 0.022432096302509308 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029811397194862366 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a high-angle wide shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly descend and circle the central group of people?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the figures dressed in tracksuits and huddled tightly together in the center of a vast sports field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by intense cool-white stadium lights creating a stark black-and-white contrast with deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are visible details such as rising steam from breath and long, sharp shadows cast on the grass present?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014193654991686344 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264193534851074 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014193654991686344, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014193654991686344, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04029862582683563, + 0.15022329986095428, + 0.057498373091220856, + 0.2551133930683136, + 0.15563592314720154, + 0.16004839539527893, + 0.0798792615532875, + 0.054136328399181366, + 0.0324070081114769, + 0.014759374782443047 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014193654991686344 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a high-angle wide shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly descend and circle the central group of people?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the figures dressed in tracksuits and huddled tightly together in the center of a vast sports field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by intense cool-white stadium lights creating a stark black-and-white contrast with deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are visible details such as rising steam from breath and long, sharp shadows cast on the grass present?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004634591285139322 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379634380340576 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004634591285139322, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004634591285139322, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08117835968732834, + 0.036174286156892776, + 0.028641557320952415, + 0.3223884403705597, + 0.13563187420368195, + 0.2631513476371765, + 0.06135252118110657, + 0.03219277039170265, + 0.02334357425570488, + 0.01594522036612034 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004634591285139322 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a high-angle wide shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly descend and circle the central group of people?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the figures dressed in tracksuits and huddled tightly together in the center of a vast sports field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by intense cool-white stadium lights creating a stark black-and-white contrast with deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are visible details such as rising steam from breath and long, sharp shadows cast on the grass present?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008634022437036037 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758634090423584 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008634022437036037, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008634022437036037, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12094081193208694, + 0.11153772473335266, + 0.056530870497226715, + 0.2161877304315567, + 0.12780164182186127, + 0.09913616627454758, + 0.09134479612112045, + 0.05412828549742699, + 0.0619654655456543, + 0.06042647734284401 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008634022437036037 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "From a high-angle wide shot, the camera slowly descends and circles a starkly contrasting scene, revealing a small group of people tightly packed together in the absolute center of a vast, immaculate sports field. Deep green, perfectly manicured grass stretches into the darkness surrounding the empty, cavernous stadium. Towering light masts, unseen beyond the frame, pour down intense, cool-white illumination, carving the figures out of the night and creating a powerful black-and-white contrast. Bright overhead lighting falls on their heads and shoulders, casting their faces in deep, expressive shadows. Their bodies cast long, sharp, twisting shadows that stretch like black fingers across the grass. The figures, dressed in tracksuits, are huddled together, shoulders pressed together, some with their arms draped over their neighbors, heads bowed together in a tight circle. Though largely still, the huddled figures are imbued with subtle movement, chests rising and falling with heavy, controlled breathing. The steam of their collective breath rises and mixes with the cold night air, catching the brilliant light. The atmosphere was charged with tension and focused solidarity; it was a private, high-stakes moment, isolated under the dramatic glare of the stadium lights, creating a powerful image of unity and impending action.", + "seed": 23410, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_12/index_3666_seed_23410_dp_25_rank_50_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.03837241446599364, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03837241446599364, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.8, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03837241446599364, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a high-angle wide shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly descend and circle the central group of people?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the figures dressed in tracksuits and huddled tightly together in the center of a vast sports field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by intense cool-white stadium lights creating a stark black-and-white contrast with deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are visible details such as rising steam from breath and long, sharp shadows cast on the grass present?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11530476063489914 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.365304708480835 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11530476063489914, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11530476063489914, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1995108276605606, + 0.042827241122722626, + 0.1482590287923813, + 0.08086974918842316, + 0.22207880020141602, + 0.056867845356464386, + 0.041367314755916595, + 0.032324522733688354, + 0.05020958557724953, + 0.12568499147891998 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11530476063489914 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a high-angle wide shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly descend and circle the central group of people?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the figures dressed in tracksuits and huddled tightly together in the center of a vast sports field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by intense cool-white stadium lights creating a stark black-and-white contrast with deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are visible details such as rising steam from breath and long, sharp shadows cast on the grass present?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04308658093214035 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168086528778076 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04308658093214035, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04308658093214035, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11061199754476547, + 0.05779678001999855, + 0.07503508776426315, + 0.059309687465429306, + 0.03879833593964577, + 0.03762315958738327, + 0.12468524277210236, + 0.08543820679187775, + 0.03407231718301773, + 0.37662917375564575 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04308658093214035 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a high-angle wide shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly descend and circle the central group of people?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the figures dressed in tracksuits and huddled tightly together in the center of a vast sports field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by intense cool-white stadium lights creating a stark black-and-white contrast with deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are visible details such as rising steam from breath and long, sharp shadows cast on the grass present?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009781643748283386 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634781837463379 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009781643748283386, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009781643748283386, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12253858894109726, + 0.05948738753795624, + 0.19353176653385162, + 0.04650186747312546, + 0.08205637335777283, + 0.052041906863451004, + 0.08613943308591843, + 0.09642525762319565, + 0.20259621739387512, + 0.05868126079440117 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009781643748283386 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a high-angle wide shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly descend and circle the central group of people?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the figures dressed in tracksuits and huddled tightly together in the center of a vast sports field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by intense cool-white stadium lights creating a stark black-and-white contrast with deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are visible details such as rising steam from breath and long, sharp shadows cast on the grass present?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0076268198899924755 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882627010345459 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0076268198899924755, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0076268198899924755, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11283834278583527, + 0.12943673133850098, + 0.07573395222425461, + 0.020418504253029823, + 0.01959623023867607, + 0.01116189081221819, + 0.060359664261341095, + 0.02766086719930172, + 0.05690338835120201, + 0.4858904778957367 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0076268198899924755 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a high-angle wide shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly descend and circle the central group of people?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the figures dressed in tracksuits and huddled tightly together in the center of a vast sports field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by intense cool-white stadium lights creating a stark black-and-white contrast with deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are visible details such as rising steam from breath and long, sharp shadows cast on the grass present?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016062267124652863 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141062259674072 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016062267124652863, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016062267124652863, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22647951543331146, + 0.14274854958057404, + 0.10951633006334305, + 0.021128768101334572, + 0.034477949142456055, + 0.037547770887613297, + 0.0453023836016655, + 0.0747324600815773, + 0.07799032330513, + 0.23007607460021973 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016062267124652863 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_13/index_tensor([7398, 7398])_group_13_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_13/index_tensor([7398, 7398])_group_13_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..3db93b07dbd09f10b1b99cdd8e2386fc24318d51 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_13/index_tensor([7398, 7398])_group_13_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "low-angle, upward shot begins beneath the ice. As the subject breaks the surface, the camera quickly tilts upward and zooms out slightly to capture the full view. Across the vast expanse of the Arctic ice, tinged with a soft golden glow by the low, polar sunlight, the thick, solid ice trembles violently and arches upward. Then, with a dull, resounding roar, a massive humpback whale crashes through the ice with unstoppable force, its massive head leading the way. Its deep blue, almost black skin is streaked with white scratches from time and mottled with barnacles. The signature white folds of its belly are clearly visible among the broken ice. As its massive body continues to rise, it throws tons of ice and a cloud of glittering ice debris into the air, which glints like diamonds in the sunlight. Water cascades down its smooth skin like a waterfall, forming a spectacular mist together with the splashing ice. It draws a majestic arc in the air, and its huge eyes flash with an ancient and wise light. The whole scene, with the interweaving of cold blue and white tones and warm golden light, is full of primitive, majestic power and breathtaking awe.", + "seed": 33481, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_13/index_7398_seed_33481_dp_26_rank_52_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.035088067618198694, + "vlm_logprob": -0.035088067618198694, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.624999976158142, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.035088067618198694, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a massive humpback whale visible breaking through the ice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the whale's skin deep blue or black with white scratches and barnacles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a vast expanse of Arctic ice with a soft golden glow from low sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle upward shot beneath the ice and then tilt upward while zooming out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a cloud of glittering ice debris and cascading water visible as the whale rises?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016458461061120033 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141458511352539 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016458461061120033, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016458461061120033, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22428429126739502, + 0.11814357340335846, + 0.12805286049842834, + 0.05961330607533455, + 0.06056920811533928, + 0.05586887523531914, + 0.056266747415065765, + 0.2101781815290451, + 0.04291580617427826, + 0.044107165187597275 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016458461061120033 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a massive humpback whale visible breaking through the ice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the whale's skin deep blue or black with white scratches and barnacles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a vast expanse of Arctic ice with a soft golden glow from low sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle upward shot beneath the ice and then tilt upward while zooming out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a cloud of glittering ice debris and cascading water visible as the whale rises?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012558897957205772 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387558937072754 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012558897957205772, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012558897957205772, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12961910665035248, + 0.09690123051404953, + 0.06333807855844498, + 0.041764821857213974, + 0.0724823921918869, + 0.04496848210692406, + 0.04401082172989845, + 0.16996687650680542, + 0.11411399394273758, + 0.22283418476581573 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012558897957205772 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a massive humpback whale visible breaking through the ice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the whale's skin deep blue or black with white scratches and barnacles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a vast expanse of Arctic ice with a soft golden glow from low sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle upward shot beneath the ice and then tilt upward while zooming out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a cloud of glittering ice debris and cascading water visible as the whale rises?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0024861162528395653 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002486228942871 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0024861162528395653, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0024861162528395653, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.40486517548561096, + 0.10177138447761536, + 0.12212679535150528, + 0.04360027238726616, + 0.08984857052564621, + 0.051559265702962875, + 0.04547789692878723, + 0.05202046036720276, + 0.039370421320199966, + 0.04935969039797783 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0024861162528395653 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a massive humpback whale visible breaking through the ice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the whale's skin deep blue or black with white scratches and barnacles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a vast expanse of Arctic ice with a soft golden glow from low sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle upward shot beneath the ice and then tilt upward while zooming out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a cloud of glittering ice debris and cascading water visible as the whale rises?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14275798201560974 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0177578926086426 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14275798201560974, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.8749998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14275798201560974, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10444235801696777, + 0.09554403275251389, + 0.07198984920978546, + 0.06468824297189713, + 0.1178709864616394, + 0.05789262056350708, + 0.0673757940530777, + 0.20062148571014404, + 0.1377953290939331, + 0.08177931606769562 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14275798201560974 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a massive humpback whale visible breaking through the ice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the whale's skin deep blue or black with white scratches and barnacles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a vast expanse of Arctic ice with a soft golden glow from low sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle upward shot beneath the ice and then tilt upward while zooming out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a cloud of glittering ice debris and cascading water visible as the whale rises?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0011788808042183518 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.751178741455078 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0011788808042183518, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0011788808042183518, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23965692520141602, + 0.16479308903217316, + 0.07713297009468079, + 0.12135039269924164, + 0.050637468695640564, + 0.08087348937988281, + 0.1004222184419632, + 0.06841976195573807, + 0.056497883051633835, + 0.04021575301885605 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0011788808042183518 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, upward shot begins beneath the ice. As the subject breaks the surface, the camera quickly tilts upward and zooms out slightly to capture the full view. Across the vast expanse of the Arctic ice, tinged with a soft golden glow by the low, polar sunlight, the thick, solid ice trembles violently and arches upward. Then, with a dull, resounding roar, a massive humpback whale crashes through the ice with unstoppable force, its massive head leading the way. Its deep blue, almost black skin is streaked with white scratches from time and mottled with barnacles. The signature white folds of its belly are clearly visible among the broken ice. As its massive body continues to rise, it throws tons of ice and a cloud of glittering ice debris into the air, which glints like diamonds in the sunlight. Water cascades down its smooth skin like a waterfall, forming a spectacular mist together with the splashing ice. It draws a majestic arc in the air, and its huge eyes flash with an ancient and wise light. The whole scene, with the interweaving of cold blue and white tones and warm golden light, is full of primitive, majestic power and breathtaking awe.", + "seed": 33482, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_13/index_7398_seed_33482_dp_26_rank_52_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.033150349371135236, + "vlm_logprob": -0.033150349371135236, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.175, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.033150349371135236, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a massive humpback whale visible breaking through the ice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the whale's skin deep blue or black with white scratches and barnacles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a vast expanse of Arctic ice with a soft golden glow from low sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle upward shot beneath the ice and then tilt upward while zooming out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a cloud of glittering ice debris and cascading water visible as the whale rises?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00801951065659523 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.88301944732666 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00801951065659523, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00801951065659523, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07807466387748718, + 0.2899283766746521, + 0.08692070841789246, + 0.030459845438599586, + 0.08023550361394882, + 0.08063603192567825, + 0.08305016905069351, + 0.14479906857013702, + 0.0503263995051384, + 0.07556920498609543 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 7, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00801951065659523 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a massive humpback whale visible breaking through the ice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the whale's skin deep blue or black with white scratches and barnacles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a vast expanse of Arctic ice with a soft golden glow from low sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle upward shot beneath the ice and then tilt upward while zooming out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a cloud of glittering ice debris and cascading water visible as the whale rises?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07900982350111008 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.579009771347046 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07900982350111008, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07900982350111008, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08355341851711273, + 0.10662461072206497, + 0.031647879630327225, + 0.024290164932608604, + 0.043600596487522125, + 0.16367340087890625, + 0.12856806814670563, + 0.21121346950531006, + 0.028844552114605904, + 0.17798380553722382 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07900982350111008 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a massive humpback whale visible breaking through the ice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the whale's skin deep blue or black with white scratches and barnacles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a vast expanse of Arctic ice with a soft golden glow from low sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle upward shot beneath the ice and then tilt upward while zooming out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a cloud of glittering ice debris and cascading water visible as the whale rises?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004090870730578899 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504090785980225 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004090870730578899, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004090870730578899, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17184194922447205, + 0.22074517607688904, + 0.1046001985669136, + 0.10855213552713394, + 0.05609481781721115, + 0.10481389611959457, + 0.08029083907604218, + 0.05740992724895477, + 0.058359675109386444, + 0.037291400134563446 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004090870730578899 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a massive humpback whale visible breaking through the ice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the whale's skin deep blue or black with white scratches and barnacles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a vast expanse of Arctic ice with a soft golden glow from low sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle upward shot beneath the ice and then tilt upward while zooming out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a cloud of glittering ice debris and cascading water visible as the whale rises?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06999647617340088 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6949963569641113 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06999647617340088, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06999647617340088, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17614224553108215, + 0.31716978549957275, + 0.08450090140104294, + 0.03671078011393547, + 0.07567121088504791, + 0.08177407085895538, + 0.02406519092619419, + 0.0657942146062851, + 0.05185385048389435, + 0.08631774038076401 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06999647617340088 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a massive humpback whale visible breaking through the ice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the whale's skin deep blue or black with white scratches and barnacles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a vast expanse of Arctic ice with a soft golden glow from low sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle upward shot beneath the ice and then tilt upward while zooming out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a cloud of glittering ice debris and cascading water visible as the whale rises?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004635065793991089 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379634857177734 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004635065793991089, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004635065793991089, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16030220687389374, + 0.17832982540130615, + 0.08024625480175018, + 0.08314130455255508, + 0.12596654891967773, + 0.09650436788797379, + 0.054741546511650085, + 0.14310935139656067, + 0.02873782441020012, + 0.04892074689269066 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004635065793991089 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, upward shot begins beneath the ice. As the subject breaks the surface, the camera quickly tilts upward and zooms out slightly to capture the full view. Across the vast expanse of the Arctic ice, tinged with a soft golden glow by the low, polar sunlight, the thick, solid ice trembles violently and arches upward. Then, with a dull, resounding roar, a massive humpback whale crashes through the ice with unstoppable force, its massive head leading the way. Its deep blue, almost black skin is streaked with white scratches from time and mottled with barnacles. The signature white folds of its belly are clearly visible among the broken ice. As its massive body continues to rise, it throws tons of ice and a cloud of glittering ice debris into the air, which glints like diamonds in the sunlight. Water cascades down its smooth skin like a waterfall, forming a spectacular mist together with the splashing ice. It draws a majestic arc in the air, and its huge eyes flash with an ancient and wise light. The whole scene, with the interweaving of cold blue and white tones and warm golden light, is full of primitive, majestic power and breathtaking awe.", + "seed": 33483, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_13/index_7398_seed_33483_dp_27_rank_54_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.014052298362366855, + "vlm_logprob": -0.014052298362366855, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.875, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.014052298362366855, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a massive humpback whale visible breaking through the ice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the whale's skin deep blue or black with white scratches and barnacles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a vast expanse of Arctic ice with a soft golden glow from low sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle upward shot beneath the ice and then tilt upward while zooming out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a cloud of glittering ice debris and cascading water visible as the whale rises?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.010131007060408592 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.635130882263184 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.010131007060408592, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.010131007060408592, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18344831466674805, + 0.04612813517451286, + 0.0879117026925087, + 0.07496538758277893, + 0.05525144189596176, + 0.10039950162172318, + 0.2640945315361023, + 0.03893603757023811, + 0.055820006877183914, + 0.0930449515581131 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.010131007060408592 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a massive humpback whale visible breaking through the ice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the whale's skin deep blue or black with white scratches and barnacles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a vast expanse of Arctic ice with a soft golden glow from low sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle upward shot beneath the ice and then tilt upward while zooming out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a cloud of glittering ice debris and cascading water visible as the whale rises?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012558897957205772 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387558937072754 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012558897957205772, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012558897957205772, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14769674837589264, + 0.049890872091054916, + 0.0458570197224617, + 0.03323813155293465, + 0.05097932368516922, + 0.04815005511045456, + 0.457949161529541, + 0.058203622698783875, + 0.05060087516903877, + 0.057434212416410446 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012558897957205772 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a massive humpback whale visible breaking through the ice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the whale's skin deep blue or black with white scratches and barnacles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a vast expanse of Arctic ice with a soft golden glow from low sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle upward shot beneath the ice and then tilt upward while zooming out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a cloud of glittering ice debris and cascading water visible as the whale rises?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002815451705828309 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877815246582031 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002815451705828309, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002815451705828309, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1829604059457779, + 0.042730662971735, + 0.024344809353351593, + 0.03727608546614647, + 0.03472433239221573, + 0.04462270438671112, + 0.5526599884033203, + 0.022313371300697327, + 0.01704026572406292, + 0.041327450424432755 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002815451705828309 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a massive humpback whale visible breaking through the ice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the whale's skin deep blue or black with white scratches and barnacles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a vast expanse of Arctic ice with a soft golden glow from low sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle upward shot beneath the ice and then tilt upward while zooming out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a cloud of glittering ice debris and cascading water visible as the whale rises?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04304444417357445 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168044328689575 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04304444417357445, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04304444417357445, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07282575219869614, + 0.05639656260609627, + 0.03367249667644501, + 0.0221467986702919, + 0.08690022677183151, + 0.09914816915988922, + 0.5669082999229431, + 0.018560662865638733, + 0.02011607028543949, + 0.023324882611632347 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04304444417357445 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a massive humpback whale visible breaking through the ice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the whale's skin deep blue or black with white scratches and barnacles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a vast expanse of Arctic ice with a soft golden glow from low sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle upward shot beneath the ice and then tilt upward while zooming out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a cloud of glittering ice debris and cascading water visible as the whale rises?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0017116909148171544 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.376711845397949 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0017116909148171544, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0017116909148171544, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1213926300406456, + 0.06837090849876404, + 0.04716632887721062, + 0.06358475238084793, + 0.061192043125629425, + 0.2781892418861389, + 0.23615305125713348, + 0.021799806505441666, + 0.028398944064974785, + 0.07375233620405197 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0017116909148171544 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, upward shot begins beneath the ice. As the subject breaks the surface, the camera quickly tilts upward and zooms out slightly to capture the full view. Across the vast expanse of the Arctic ice, tinged with a soft golden glow by the low, polar sunlight, the thick, solid ice trembles violently and arches upward. Then, with a dull, resounding roar, a massive humpback whale crashes through the ice with unstoppable force, its massive head leading the way. Its deep blue, almost black skin is streaked with white scratches from time and mottled with barnacles. The signature white folds of its belly are clearly visible among the broken ice. As its massive body continues to rise, it throws tons of ice and a cloud of glittering ice debris into the air, which glints like diamonds in the sunlight. Water cascades down its smooth skin like a waterfall, forming a spectacular mist together with the splashing ice. It draws a majestic arc in the air, and its huge eyes flash with an ancient and wise light. The whole scene, with the interweaving of cold blue and white tones and warm golden light, is full of primitive, majestic power and breathtaking awe.", + "seed": 33484, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_13/index_7398_seed_33484_dp_27_rank_54_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.027566371904686093, + "vlm_logprob": -0.027566371904686093, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.425, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.027566371904686093, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a massive humpback whale visible breaking through the ice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the whale's skin deep blue or black with white scratches and barnacles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a vast expanse of Arctic ice with a soft golden glow from low sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle upward shot beneath the ice and then tilt upward while zooming out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a cloud of glittering ice debris and cascading water visible as the whale rises?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.010048163123428822 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.6350483894348145 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.010048163123428822, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.010048163123428822, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1380721777677536, + 0.1882460117340088, + 0.1415407508611679, + 0.06180310621857643, + 0.1907389760017395, + 0.04512479156255722, + 0.057956255972385406, + 0.0322587750852108, + 0.09929235279560089, + 0.044966839253902435 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.010048163123428822 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a massive humpback whale visible breaking through the ice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the whale's skin deep blue or black with white scratches and barnacles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a vast expanse of Arctic ice with a soft golden glow from low sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle upward shot beneath the ice and then tilt upward while zooming out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a cloud of glittering ice debris and cascading water visible as the whale rises?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02059655450284481 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895596504211426 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02059655450284481, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02059655450284481, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10918533802032471, + 0.16772817075252533, + 0.09098812937736511, + 0.06332365423440933, + 0.17712973058223724, + 0.02921268902719021, + 0.10103410482406616, + 0.09046191722154617, + 0.07326347380876541, + 0.0976727306842804 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02059655450284481 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a massive humpback whale visible breaking through the ice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the whale's skin deep blue or black with white scratches and barnacles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a vast expanse of Arctic ice with a soft golden glow from low sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle upward shot beneath the ice and then tilt upward while zooming out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a cloud of glittering ice debris and cascading water visible as the whale rises?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004091345705091953 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504091262817383 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004091345705091953, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004091345705091953, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4710482358932495, + 0.2630622982978821, + 0.04364633187651634, + 0.03240388631820679, + 0.07616423070430756, + 0.019362367689609528, + 0.02615930885076523, + 0.013555137440562248, + 0.03356153517961502, + 0.021036608144640923 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004091345705091953 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a massive humpback whale visible breaking through the ice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the whale's skin deep blue or black with white scratches and barnacles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a vast expanse of Arctic ice with a soft golden glow from low sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle upward shot beneath the ice and then tilt upward while zooming out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a cloud of glittering ice debris and cascading water visible as the whale rises?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10028034448623657 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.350280284881592 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10028034448623657, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10028034448623657, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.26034969091415405, + 0.08496206998825073, + 0.059321917593479156, + 0.07726152241230011, + 0.1474040150642395, + 0.12966784834861755, + 0.03444945439696312, + 0.05480034276843071, + 0.12856580317020416, + 0.023217355832457542 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10028034448623657 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a massive humpback whale visible breaking through the ice?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the whale's skin deep blue or black with white scratches and barnacles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a vast expanse of Arctic ice with a soft golden glow from low sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle upward shot beneath the ice and then tilt upward while zooming out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a cloud of glittering ice debris and cascading water visible as the whale rises?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002815451705828309 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877815246582031 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002815451705828309, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002815451705828309, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14433835446834564, + 0.12359382212162018, + 0.054321158677339554, + 0.05241267755627632, + 0.38003769516944885, + 0.03373074159026146, + 0.0853671059012413, + 0.01836307905614376, + 0.05024750158190727, + 0.05758783966302872 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002815451705828309 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_14/index_tensor([3758, 3758])_group_14_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_14/index_tensor([3758, 3758])_group_14_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..f93b3a8c39691af7fa8060b56cd5cacc495e8721 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_14/index_tensor([3758, 3758])_group_14_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "powerful, upward shot follows the bow of a massive, wedge-shaped Star Destroyer, slowly pulling out to reveal its awe-inspiring scale. The vessel's colossal silhouette nearly fills the entire frame. In a high-contrast, monochrome style, a harsh, hard light shines from one side, carving sharp angles and a cold, metallic sheen into its weathered hull. Countless complex geometric panels, deep grooves, and protruding superstructures intertwine in a stark interplay of light and shadow, creating a stark contrast between light and dark. With unstoppable force, the Star Destroyer calmly and relentlessly charges through a dense meteorite belt. Smaller meteorites instantly crumble into silent dust upon contact with the forward energy shield, while larger, cratered rocks violently shatter as they scrape against the ship's armor, the flying debris leaving fleeting, brilliant white trails against the absolute blackness of the cosmic abyss. The entire scene is free of any color, only pure black, white and gray, which perfectly emphasizes the overwhelming power of this war machine and the coldness and vastness of the universe, creating a breathtaking, epic sense of grandeur and deterrence.", + "seed": 26718, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_14/index_3758_seed_26718_dp_28_rank_56_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.218864032253623, + "vlm_logprob": -0.218864032253623, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.225000023841858, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.218864032253623, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive, wedge-shaped Star Destroyer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned for an upward shot that pulls out to reveal the ship's scale?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the Star Destroyer shown charging through a dense meteorite belt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do smaller meteorites crumble into dust while larger rocks shatter upon contact with the ship?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene rendered in a high-contrast monochrome style using only black, white, and gray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.39067912101745605 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.140679121017456 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.39067912101745605, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.39067912101745605, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3942437469959259, + 0.06823378801345825, + 0.030612235888838768, + 0.055805936455726624, + 0.17431640625, + 0.08263746649026871, + 0.09863791614770889, + 0.016757406294345856, + 0.049545854330062866, + 0.029209258034825325 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.39067912101745605 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive, wedge-shaped Star Destroyer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned for an upward shot that pulls out to reveal the ship's scale?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the Star Destroyer shown charging through a dense meteorite belt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do smaller meteorites crumble into dust while larger rocks shatter upon contact with the ship?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene rendered in a high-contrast monochrome style using only black, white, and gray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1428772360086441 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0178773403167725 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1428772360086441, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.8750001192092896, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1428772360086441, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.37015411257743835, + 0.07231151312589645, + 0.055665433406829834, + 0.07427148520946503, + 0.11915798485279083, + 0.09307612478733063, + 0.0981552004814148, + 0.03902522847056389, + 0.0424722321331501, + 0.03571069985628128 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1428772360086441 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive, wedge-shaped Star Destroyer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned for an upward shot that pulls out to reveal the ship's scale?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the Star Destroyer shown charging through a dense meteorite belt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do smaller meteorites crumble into dust while larger rocks shatter upon contact with the ship?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene rendered in a high-contrast monochrome style using only black, white, and gray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5232903361320496 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8982903361320496 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5232903361320496, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5232903361320496, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.32015344500541687, + 0.11139120906591415, + 0.09154605120420456, + 0.08772072196006775, + 0.1669447422027588, + 0.02926379069685936, + 0.047580406069755554, + 0.05796930938959122, + 0.05686630308628082, + 0.03056403435766697 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5232903361320496 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive, wedge-shaped Star Destroyer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned for an upward shot that pulls out to reveal the ship's scale?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the Star Destroyer shown charging through a dense meteorite belt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do smaller meteorites crumble into dust while larger rocks shatter upon contact with the ship?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene rendered in a high-contrast monochrome style using only black, white, and gray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026387644931674004 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513876914978027 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026387644931674004, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026387644931674004, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21043117344379425, + 0.10965085029602051, + 0.11723271757364273, + 0.0681920275092125, + 0.2930695712566376, + 0.045324645936489105, + 0.04812246933579445, + 0.026081429794430733, + 0.026813343167304993, + 0.05508176609873772 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026387644931674004 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive, wedge-shaped Star Destroyer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned for an upward shot that pulls out to reveal the ship's scale?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the Star Destroyer shown charging through a dense meteorite belt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do smaller meteorites crumble into dust while larger rocks shatter upon contact with the ship?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene rendered in a high-contrast monochrome style using only black, white, and gray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01108582317829132 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.5110859870910645 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01108582317829132, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01108582317829132, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5289493799209595, + 0.06977736949920654, + 0.02066158503293991, + 0.01650811731815338, + 0.11194119602441788, + 0.058458201587200165, + 0.04369591549038887, + 0.03169270604848862, + 0.03173740580677986, + 0.08657808601856232 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01108582317829132 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "powerful, upward shot follows the bow of a massive, wedge-shaped Star Destroyer, slowly pulling out to reveal its awe-inspiring scale. The vessel's colossal silhouette nearly fills the entire frame. In a high-contrast, monochrome style, a harsh, hard light shines from one side, carving sharp angles and a cold, metallic sheen into its weathered hull. Countless complex geometric panels, deep grooves, and protruding superstructures intertwine in a stark interplay of light and shadow, creating a stark contrast between light and dark. With unstoppable force, the Star Destroyer calmly and relentlessly charges through a dense meteorite belt. Smaller meteorites instantly crumble into silent dust upon contact with the forward energy shield, while larger, cratered rocks violently shatter as they scrape against the ship's armor, the flying debris leaving fleeting, brilliant white trails against the absolute blackness of the cosmic abyss. The entire scene is free of any color, only pure black, white and gray, which perfectly emphasizes the overwhelming power of this war machine and the coldness and vastness of the universe, creating a breathtaking, epic sense of grandeur and deterrence.", + "seed": 26719, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_14/index_3758_seed_26719_dp_28_rank_56_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.14938668422400952, + "vlm_logprob": -0.14938668422400952, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.425, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.14938668422400952, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive, wedge-shaped Star Destroyer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned for an upward shot that pulls out to reveal the ship's scale?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the Star Destroyer shown charging through a dense meteorite belt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do smaller meteorites crumble into dust while larger rocks shatter upon contact with the ship?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene rendered in a high-contrast monochrome style using only black, white, and gray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.25418955087661743 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5041894912719727 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.25418955087661743, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.25418955087661743, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2374328225851059, + 0.06883136928081512, + 0.3427509069442749, + 0.02932196669280529, + 0.04075465351343155, + 0.07655646651983261, + 0.03052687831223011, + 0.043260809034109116, + 0.04430248588323593, + 0.08626160025596619 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.25418955087661743 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive, wedge-shaped Star Destroyer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned for an upward shot that pulls out to reveal the ship's scale?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the Star Destroyer shown charging through a dense meteorite belt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do smaller meteorites crumble into dust while larger rocks shatter upon contact with the ship?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene rendered in a high-contrast monochrome style using only black, white, and gray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.033741552382707596 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4087414741516113 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.033741552382707596, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.033741552382707596, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25073638558387756, + 0.08739077299833298, + 0.2634684145450592, + 0.08528188616037369, + 0.027863606810569763, + 0.07093995809555054, + 0.03904841095209122, + 0.04903315752744675, + 0.06465137749910355, + 0.06158604845404625 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.033741552382707596 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive, wedge-shaped Star Destroyer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned for an upward shot that pulls out to reveal the ship's scale?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the Star Destroyer shown charging through a dense meteorite belt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do smaller meteorites crumble into dust while larger rocks shatter upon contact with the ship?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene rendered in a high-contrast monochrome style using only black, white, and gray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3870234787464142 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1370234489440918 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3870234787464142, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3870234787464142, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.35154488682746887, + 0.06255459785461426, + 0.1431073397397995, + 0.06665067374706268, + 0.04104343801736832, + 0.04327521100640297, + 0.07302640378475189, + 0.05432143434882164, + 0.09735075384378433, + 0.06712525337934494 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3870234787464142 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive, wedge-shaped Star Destroyer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned for an upward shot that pulls out to reveal the ship's scale?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the Star Destroyer shown charging through a dense meteorite belt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do smaller meteorites crumble into dust while larger rocks shatter upon contact with the ship?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene rendered in a high-contrast monochrome style using only black, white, and gray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023314977064728737 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773314952850342 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023314977064728737, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023314977064728737, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14297975599765778, + 0.03340423107147217, + 0.29235777258872986, + 0.08991597592830658, + 0.06496084481477737, + 0.059970103204250336, + 0.08998608589172363, + 0.04204009100794792, + 0.1211753860116005, + 0.06320968270301819 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023314977064728737 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive, wedge-shaped Star Destroyer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned for an upward shot that pulls out to reveal the ship's scale?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the Star Destroyer shown charging through a dense meteorite belt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do smaller meteorites crumble into dust while larger rocks shatter upon contact with the ship?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene rendered in a high-contrast monochrome style using only black, white, and gray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04866386204957962 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048663854598999 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04866386204957962, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04866386204957962, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14932921528816223, + 0.07394159585237503, + 0.19888895750045776, + 0.1938757449388504, + 0.08687262237071991, + 0.041959598660469055, + 0.0688997209072113, + 0.0828409418463707, + 0.05125854164361954, + 0.05213303491473198 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04866386204957962 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "powerful, upward shot follows the bow of a massive, wedge-shaped Star Destroyer, slowly pulling out to reveal its awe-inspiring scale. The vessel's colossal silhouette nearly fills the entire frame. In a high-contrast, monochrome style, a harsh, hard light shines from one side, carving sharp angles and a cold, metallic sheen into its weathered hull. Countless complex geometric panels, deep grooves, and protruding superstructures intertwine in a stark interplay of light and shadow, creating a stark contrast between light and dark. With unstoppable force, the Star Destroyer calmly and relentlessly charges through a dense meteorite belt. Smaller meteorites instantly crumble into silent dust upon contact with the forward energy shield, while larger, cratered rocks violently shatter as they scrape against the ship's armor, the flying debris leaving fleeting, brilliant white trails against the absolute blackness of the cosmic abyss. The entire scene is free of any color, only pure black, white and gray, which perfectly emphasizes the overwhelming power of this war machine and the coldness and vastness of the universe, creating a breathtaking, epic sense of grandeur and deterrence.", + "seed": 26720, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_14/index_3758_seed_26720_dp_29_rank_58_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.10077687110751868, + "vlm_logprob": -0.10077687110751868, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.875, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.10077687110751868, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive, wedge-shaped Star Destroyer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned for an upward shot that pulls out to reveal the ship's scale?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the Star Destroyer shown charging through a dense meteorite belt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do smaller meteorites crumble into dust while larger rocks shatter upon contact with the ship?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene rendered in a high-contrast monochrome style using only black, white, and gray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16191284358501434 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9119127988815308 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16191284358501434, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16191284358501434, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.27940478920936584, + 0.10782662779092789, + 0.0978040099143982, + 0.11831244826316833, + 0.025252189487218857, + 0.019682586193084717, + 0.12834787368774414, + 0.025904428213834763, + 0.11848039925098419, + 0.0789845809340477 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16191284358501434 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive, wedge-shaped Star Destroyer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned for an upward shot that pulls out to reveal the ship's scale?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the Star Destroyer shown charging through a dense meteorite belt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do smaller meteorites crumble into dust while larger rocks shatter upon contact with the ship?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene rendered in a high-contrast monochrome style using only black, white, and gray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08909355103969574 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4640934467315674 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08909355103969574, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08909355103969574, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3127385973930359, + 0.13781538605690002, + 0.08167792111635208, + 0.13467930257320404, + 0.04988134652376175, + 0.04219841584563255, + 0.10375151038169861, + 0.02661086991429329, + 0.03353634104132652, + 0.07711025327444077 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08909355103969574 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive, wedge-shaped Star Destroyer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned for an upward shot that pulls out to reveal the ship's scale?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the Star Destroyer shown charging through a dense meteorite belt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do smaller meteorites crumble into dust while larger rocks shatter upon contact with the ship?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene rendered in a high-contrast monochrome style using only black, white, and gray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22553983330726624 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6005398035049438 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.22553983330726624, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.22553983330726624, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17821358144283295, + 0.11607414484024048, + 0.1878187656402588, + 0.18816439807415009, + 0.08790134638547897, + 0.06134409084916115, + 0.0604078583419323, + 0.03989313170313835, + 0.022503245621919632, + 0.05767948552966118 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.22553983330726624 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive, wedge-shaped Star Destroyer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned for an upward shot that pulls out to reveal the ship's scale?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the Star Destroyer shown charging through a dense meteorite belt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do smaller meteorites crumble into dust while larger rocks shatter upon contact with the ship?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene rendered in a high-contrast monochrome style using only black, white, and gray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02060099132359028 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8956010341644287 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02060099132359028, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02060099132359028, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15884792804718018, + 0.06559376418590546, + 0.09628987312316895, + 0.16652151942253113, + 0.10895754396915436, + 0.18880994617938995, + 0.03400304540991783, + 0.04206406697630882, + 0.03870576247572899, + 0.10020650923252106 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02060099132359028 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive, wedge-shaped Star Destroyer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned for an upward shot that pulls out to reveal the ship's scale?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the Star Destroyer shown charging through a dense meteorite belt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do smaller meteorites crumble into dust while larger rocks shatter upon contact with the ship?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene rendered in a high-contrast monochrome style using only black, white, and gray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006737136282026768 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006737232208252 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006737136282026768, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006737136282026768, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1200774535536766, + 0.5193436145782471, + 0.0665176585316658, + 0.05846920236945152, + 0.02301938086748123, + 0.025616774335503578, + 0.032615918666124344, + 0.03332597389817238, + 0.0325763002038002, + 0.08843780308961868 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006737136282026768 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "powerful, upward shot follows the bow of a massive, wedge-shaped Star Destroyer, slowly pulling out to reveal its awe-inspiring scale. The vessel's colossal silhouette nearly fills the entire frame. In a high-contrast, monochrome style, a harsh, hard light shines from one side, carving sharp angles and a cold, metallic sheen into its weathered hull. Countless complex geometric panels, deep grooves, and protruding superstructures intertwine in a stark interplay of light and shadow, creating a stark contrast between light and dark. With unstoppable force, the Star Destroyer calmly and relentlessly charges through a dense meteorite belt. Smaller meteorites instantly crumble into silent dust upon contact with the forward energy shield, while larger, cratered rocks violently shatter as they scrape against the ship's armor, the flying debris leaving fleeting, brilliant white trails against the absolute blackness of the cosmic abyss. The entire scene is free of any color, only pure black, white and gray, which perfectly emphasizes the overwhelming power of this war machine and the coldness and vastness of the universe, creating a breathtaking, epic sense of grandeur and deterrence.", + "seed": 26721, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_14/index_3758_seed_26721_dp_29_rank_58_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.10362296663224697, + "vlm_logprob": -0.10362296663224697, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.0249999880790712, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.10362296663224697, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive, wedge-shaped Star Destroyer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned for an upward shot that pulls out to reveal the ship's scale?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the Star Destroyer shown charging through a dense meteorite belt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do smaller meteorites crumble into dust while larger rocks shatter upon contact with the ship?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene rendered in a high-contrast monochrome style using only black, white, and gray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11451922357082367 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2395191192626953 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11451922357082367, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11451922357082367, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20429015159606934, + 0.07973740994930267, + 0.13228069245815277, + 0.07685533165931702, + 0.03088618442416191, + 0.07835015654563904, + 0.03134019672870636, + 0.1711091548204422, + 0.07908046990633011, + 0.11607025563716888 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11451922357082367 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive, wedge-shaped Star Destroyer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned for an upward shot that pulls out to reveal the ship's scale?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the Star Destroyer shown charging through a dense meteorite belt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do smaller meteorites crumble into dust while larger rocks shatter upon contact with the ship?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene rendered in a high-contrast monochrome style using only black, white, and gray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02637290023267269 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513729095458984 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02637290023267269, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02637290023267269, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1659880429506302, + 0.10590966045856476, + 0.13435973227024078, + 0.08750887960195541, + 0.08019556105136871, + 0.1049375981092453, + 0.04600078985095024, + 0.059788815677165985, + 0.09436006098985672, + 0.12095098197460175 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02637290023267269 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive, wedge-shaped Star Destroyer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned for an upward shot that pulls out to reveal the ship's scale?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the Star Destroyer shown charging through a dense meteorite belt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do smaller meteorites crumble into dust while larger rocks shatter upon contact with the ship?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene rendered in a high-contrast monochrome style using only black, white, and gray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.34859591722488403 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2235958576202393 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.34859591722488403, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.8749999403953552, + "token_credit_reward": -0.34859591722488403, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11069244891405106, + 0.2643457353115082, + 0.11905024945735931, + 0.0762878805398941, + 0.09223644435405731, + 0.07341203093528748, + 0.057163089513778687, + 0.06894997507333755, + 0.06447717547416687, + 0.07338494062423706 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.34859591722488403 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive, wedge-shaped Star Destroyer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned for an upward shot that pulls out to reveal the ship's scale?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the Star Destroyer shown charging through a dense meteorite belt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do smaller meteorites crumble into dust while larger rocks shatter upon contact with the ship?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene rendered in a high-contrast monochrome style using only black, white, and gray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01255783811211586 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.3875579833984375 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01255783811211586, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01255783811211586, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11839265376329422, + 0.3946771025657654, + 0.2048051804304123, + 0.024813704192638397, + 0.05139193683862686, + 0.03447522222995758, + 0.018956894055008888, + 0.0507061667740345, + 0.05840817838907242, + 0.04337305203080177 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01255783811211586 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive, wedge-shaped Star Destroyer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned for an upward shot that pulls out to reveal the ship's scale?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the Star Destroyer shown charging through a dense meteorite belt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do smaller meteorites crumble into dust while larger rocks shatter upon contact with the ship?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene rendered in a high-contrast monochrome style using only black, white, and gray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0160689540207386 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141068935394287 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0160689540207386, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0160689540207386, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13433313369750977, + 0.1855669766664505, + 0.039152611047029495, + 0.04574335739016533, + 0.10663454979658127, + 0.0482737235724926, + 0.05769370123744011, + 0.06665991991758347, + 0.057136163115501404, + 0.2588058412075043 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0160689540207386 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_15/index_tensor([9785, 9785])_group_15_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_15/index_tensor([9785, 9785])_group_15_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..b0a50dd7c6ffb8c1d1d3227dde6efaf69438c41f --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_15/index_tensor([9785, 9785])_group_15_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "An extremely slow zoom shot, seamlessly transitioning from close-up to extreme close-up, focuses entirely on the right eye of an elderly woman. Her eyes are a deep amber, their irises crisscrossed with intricate, delicate textures that seem to bear witness to the passage of time. Fine lines of crow's feet are visible at the corners of her eyes, and her skin, slightly dry but brimming with life, is shrouded in a film of shimmering tears. With a slow, heavy blink, this film of tears sways slightly, reflecting the soft afternoon light filtering through the window on the right side of the frame, creating a tiny, bright spot in her pupil. A single, almost-fallen teardrop dangles from her sparse lower lashes, trembling slightly under the weight of gravity, brimming with tension. Warm sidelight casts a soft shadow on her cheek, creating a striking contrast between light and dark. The background is completely blurred, a halo of warm tones, suggesting a tranquil interior. The whole picture has warm tones, a tranquil and sad atmosphere, and is full of a sense of silent storytelling, as if thousands of words are condensed in this tear-filled gaze.", + "seed": 20188, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_15/index_9785_seed_20188_dp_30_rank_60_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.14477299060672522, + "vlm_logprob": -0.14477299060672522, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.525, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.14477299060672522, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot an extremely slow zoom transitioning from close-up to extreme close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject focused entirely on the right eye of an elderly woman?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the woman's eyes deep amber with intricate, delicate textures in the irises?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a single teardrop dangling from her sparse lower lashes, trembling slightly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background completely blurred with warm tones, while warm sidelight casts a soft shadow on her cheek?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4331616461277008 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.0581616163253784 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.4331616461277008, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.4331616461277008, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12171079218387604, + 0.1800851821899414, + 0.1094270572066307, + 0.25231316685676575, + 0.04526254162192345, + 0.04748474434018135, + 0.03726420924067497, + 0.07239824533462524, + 0.03769742697477341, + 0.09635668247938156 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.4331616461277008 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot an extremely slow zoom transitioning from close-up to extreme close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject focused entirely on the right eye of an elderly woman?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the woman's eyes deep amber with intricate, delicate textures in the irises?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a single teardrop dangling from her sparse lower lashes, trembling slightly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background completely blurred with warm tones, while warm sidelight casts a soft shadow on her cheek?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07006516307592392 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950652599334717 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07006516307592392, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07006516307592392, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06676899641752243, + 0.43640199303627014, + 0.03826482594013214, + 0.2004529982805252, + 0.06668469309806824, + 0.028213191777467728, + 0.029368706047534943, + 0.052585162222385406, + 0.01904626004397869, + 0.0622132234275341 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07006516307592392 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot an extremely slow zoom transitioning from close-up to extreme close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject focused entirely on the right eye of an elderly woman?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the woman's eyes deep amber with intricate, delicate textures in the irises?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a single teardrop dangling from her sparse lower lashes, trembling slightly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background completely blurred with warm tones, while warm sidelight casts a soft shadow on her cheek?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1429639309644699 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0179638862609863 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1429639309644699, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1429639309644699, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11840545386075974, + 0.335152804851532, + 0.024948906153440475, + 0.18872684240341187, + 0.0630231648683548, + 0.14688175916671753, + 0.026357334107160568, + 0.03576945513486862, + 0.027838686481118202, + 0.03289559483528137 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1429639309644699 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot an extremely slow zoom transitioning from close-up to extreme close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject focused entirely on the right eye of an elderly woman?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the woman's eyes deep amber with intricate, delicate textures in the irises?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a single teardrop dangling from her sparse lower lashes, trembling slightly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background completely blurred with warm tones, while warm sidelight casts a soft shadow on her cheek?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07004538178443909 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950454711914062 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07004538178443909, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07004538178443909, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05832286924123764, + 0.1567746251821518, + 0.02859806828200817, + 0.07393258810043335, + 0.06139221787452698, + 0.04847664013504982, + 0.044697683304548264, + 0.2169618010520935, + 0.06182575970888138, + 0.24901770055294037 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07004538178443909 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot an extremely slow zoom transitioning from close-up to extreme close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject focused entirely on the right eye of an elderly woman?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the woman's eyes deep amber with intricate, delicate textures in the irises?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a single teardrop dangling from her sparse lower lashes, trembling slightly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background completely blurred with warm tones, while warm sidelight casts a soft shadow on her cheek?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007628831081092358 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882628917694092 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007628831081092358, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007628831081092358, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2103593349456787, + 0.21117769181728363, + 0.02970561385154724, + 0.10707949846982956, + 0.08955661207437515, + 0.06287897378206253, + 0.07679455727338791, + 0.07223526388406754, + 0.04347466677427292, + 0.0967378169298172 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007628831081092358 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extremely slow zoom shot, seamlessly transitioning from close-up to extreme close-up, focuses entirely on the right eye of an elderly woman. Her eyes are a deep amber, their irises crisscrossed with intricate, delicate textures that seem to bear witness to the passage of time. Fine lines of crow's feet are visible at the corners of her eyes, and her skin, slightly dry but brimming with life, is shrouded in a film of shimmering tears. With a slow, heavy blink, this film of tears sways slightly, reflecting the soft afternoon light filtering through the window on the right side of the frame, creating a tiny, bright spot in her pupil. A single, almost-fallen teardrop dangles from her sparse lower lashes, trembling slightly under the weight of gravity, brimming with tension. Warm sidelight casts a soft shadow on her cheek, creating a striking contrast between light and dark. The background is completely blurred, a halo of warm tones, suggesting a tranquil interior. The whole picture has warm tones, a tranquil and sad atmosphere, and is full of a sense of silent storytelling, as if thousands of words are condensed in this tear-filled gaze.", + "seed": 20189, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_15/index_9785_seed_20189_dp_30_rank_60_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.18163034319877625, + "vlm_logprob": -0.18163034319877625, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.224999988079071, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.18163034319877625, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot an extremely slow zoom transitioning from close-up to extreme close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject focused entirely on the right eye of an elderly woman?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the woman's eyes deep amber with intricate, delicate textures in the irises?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a single teardrop dangling from her sparse lower lashes, trembling slightly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background completely blurred with warm tones, while warm sidelight casts a soft shadow on her cheek?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3516605496406555 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2266604900360107 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3516605496406555, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.8749999403953552, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3516605496406555, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08231052756309509, + 0.12680736184120178, + 0.06283701956272125, + 0.15743489563465118, + 0.11218506097793579, + 0.06851600855588913, + 0.14347407221794128, + 0.09524651616811752, + 0.0596281997859478, + 0.09156033396720886 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3516605496406555 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot an extremely slow zoom transitioning from close-up to extreme close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject focused entirely on the right eye of an elderly woman?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the woman's eyes deep amber with intricate, delicate textures in the irises?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a single teardrop dangling from her sparse lower lashes, trembling slightly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background completely blurred with warm tones, while warm sidelight casts a soft shadow on her cheek?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08908329904079437 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.464083194732666 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08908329904079437, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08908329904079437, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20815637707710266, + 0.06479621678590775, + 0.15902113914489746, + 0.0737338587641716, + 0.06574112176895142, + 0.08939231187105179, + 0.06910371780395508, + 0.05543650686740875, + 0.07263816893100739, + 0.14198054373264313 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08908329904079437 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot an extremely slow zoom transitioning from close-up to extreme close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject focused entirely on the right eye of an elderly woman?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the woman's eyes deep amber with intricate, delicate textures in the irises?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a single teardrop dangling from her sparse lower lashes, trembling slightly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background completely blurred with warm tones, while warm sidelight casts a soft shadow on her cheek?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.18006668984889984 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.805066704750061 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.18006668984889984, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.18006668984889984, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13109254837036133, + 0.1185898557305336, + 0.11527546495199203, + 0.1091136783361435, + 0.07243598997592926, + 0.08494492620229721, + 0.07154527306556702, + 0.0919579491019249, + 0.10283162444829941, + 0.10221268236637115 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.18006668984889984 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot an extremely slow zoom transitioning from close-up to extreme close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject focused entirely on the right eye of an elderly woman?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the woman's eyes deep amber with intricate, delicate textures in the irises?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a single teardrop dangling from her sparse lower lashes, trembling slightly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background completely blurred with warm tones, while warm sidelight casts a soft shadow on her cheek?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2813918888568878 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4063918590545654 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2813918888568878, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2813918888568878, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1457497924566269, + 0.15317775309085846, + 0.0513695627450943, + 0.13283011317253113, + 0.04076872020959854, + 0.08562497049570084, + 0.044231269508600235, + 0.18373951315879822, + 0.04655790701508522, + 0.1159503236413002 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2813918888568878 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot an extremely slow zoom transitioning from close-up to extreme close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject focused entirely on the right eye of an elderly woman?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the woman's eyes deep amber with intricate, delicate textures in the irises?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a single teardrop dangling from her sparse lower lashes, trembling slightly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background completely blurred with warm tones, while warm sidelight casts a soft shadow on her cheek?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005949288606643677 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.1309494972229 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005949288606643677, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005949288606643677, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13242533802986145, + 0.19372521340847015, + 0.03715825825929642, + 0.07932940125465393, + 0.054752856492996216, + 0.07047243416309357, + 0.1486734300851822, + 0.18492670357227325, + 0.019623946398496628, + 0.07891237735748291 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005949288606643677 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extremely slow zoom shot, seamlessly transitioning from close-up to extreme close-up, focuses entirely on the right eye of an elderly woman. Her eyes are a deep amber, their irises crisscrossed with intricate, delicate textures that seem to bear witness to the passage of time. Fine lines of crow's feet are visible at the corners of her eyes, and her skin, slightly dry but brimming with life, is shrouded in a film of shimmering tears. With a slow, heavy blink, this film of tears sways slightly, reflecting the soft afternoon light filtering through the window on the right side of the frame, creating a tiny, bright spot in her pupil. A single, almost-fallen teardrop dangles from her sparse lower lashes, trembling slightly under the weight of gravity, brimming with tension. Warm sidelight casts a soft shadow on her cheek, creating a striking contrast between light and dark. The background is completely blurred, a halo of warm tones, suggesting a tranquil interior. The whole picture has warm tones, a tranquil and sad atmosphere, and is full of a sense of silent storytelling, as if thousands of words are condensed in this tear-filled gaze.", + "seed": 20190, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_15/index_9785_seed_20190_dp_31_rank_62_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.17831125715747476, + "vlm_logprob": -0.17831125715747476, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.525, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.17831125715747476, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot an extremely slow zoom transitioning from close-up to extreme close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject focused entirely on the right eye of an elderly woman?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the woman's eyes deep amber with intricate, delicate textures in the irises?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a single teardrop dangling from her sparse lower lashes, trembling slightly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background completely blurred with warm tones, while warm sidelight casts a soft shadow on her cheek?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5823871493339539 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8323871493339539 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5823871493339539, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5823871493339539, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16550204157829285, + 0.14360232651233673, + 0.07240002602338791, + 0.11570663005113602, + 0.16143806278705597, + 0.05126282572746277, + 0.05802537873387337, + 0.0880887508392334, + 0.09815343469381332, + 0.045820530503988266 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5823871493339539 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot an extremely slow zoom transitioning from close-up to extreme close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject focused entirely on the right eye of an elderly woman?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the woman's eyes deep amber with intricate, delicate textures in the irises?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a single teardrop dangling from her sparse lower lashes, trembling slightly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background completely blurred with warm tones, while warm sidelight casts a soft shadow on her cheek?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.043099597096443176 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680996417999268 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.043099597096443176, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.043099597096443176, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4283246695995331, + 0.12205038219690323, + 0.12035416066646576, + 0.06995311379432678, + 0.03621123731136322, + 0.03936798870563507, + 0.035586219280958176, + 0.05151665583252907, + 0.059566691517829895, + 0.03706887736916542 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.043099597096443176 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot an extremely slow zoom transitioning from close-up to extreme close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject focused entirely on the right eye of an elderly woman?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the woman's eyes deep amber with intricate, delicate textures in the irises?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a single teardrop dangling from her sparse lower lashes, trembling slightly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background completely blurred with warm tones, while warm sidelight casts a soft shadow on her cheek?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10040035843849182 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.350400447845459 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10040035843849182, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10040035843849182, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.32061052322387695, + 0.15536370873451233, + 0.0698522999882698, + 0.0529765821993351, + 0.021612053737044334, + 0.027695145457983017, + 0.0688113197684288, + 0.0748465433716774, + 0.15817143023014069, + 0.050060395151376724 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10040035843849182 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot an extremely slow zoom transitioning from close-up to extreme close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject focused entirely on the right eye of an elderly woman?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the woman's eyes deep amber with intricate, delicate textures in the irises?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a single teardrop dangling from her sparse lower lashes, trembling slightly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background completely blurred with warm tones, while warm sidelight casts a soft shadow on her cheek?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16041633486747742 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9104163646697998 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16041633486747742, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16041633486747742, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2512940466403961, + 0.10854712128639221, + 0.10753455758094788, + 0.05715307965874672, + 0.07174379378557205, + 0.06310730427503586, + 0.05984470620751381, + 0.11651553213596344, + 0.09485669434070587, + 0.06940312683582306 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16041633486747742 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot an extremely slow zoom transitioning from close-up to extreme close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject focused entirely on the right eye of an elderly woman?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the woman's eyes deep amber with intricate, delicate textures in the irises?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a single teardrop dangling from her sparse lower lashes, trembling slightly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background completely blurred with warm tones, while warm sidelight casts a soft shadow on her cheek?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005252846051007509 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255252838134766 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005252846051007509, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005252846051007509, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18790987133979797, + 0.05310886725783348, + 0.12209686636924744, + 0.11942557990550995, + 0.049405377358198166, + 0.10148646682500839, + 0.1956842690706253, + 0.08655906468629837, + 0.013120856136083603, + 0.07120281457901001 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005252846051007509 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extremely slow zoom shot, seamlessly transitioning from close-up to extreme close-up, focuses entirely on the right eye of an elderly woman. Her eyes are a deep amber, their irises crisscrossed with intricate, delicate textures that seem to bear witness to the passage of time. Fine lines of crow's feet are visible at the corners of her eyes, and her skin, slightly dry but brimming with life, is shrouded in a film of shimmering tears. With a slow, heavy blink, this film of tears sways slightly, reflecting the soft afternoon light filtering through the window on the right side of the frame, creating a tiny, bright spot in her pupil. A single, almost-fallen teardrop dangles from her sparse lower lashes, trembling slightly under the weight of gravity, brimming with tension. Warm sidelight casts a soft shadow on her cheek, creating a striking contrast between light and dark. The background is completely blurred, a halo of warm tones, suggesting a tranquil interior. The whole picture has warm tones, a tranquil and sad atmosphere, and is full of a sense of silent storytelling, as if thousands of words are condensed in this tear-filled gaze.", + "seed": 20191, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_15/index_9785_seed_20191_dp_31_rank_62_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.28711268533952533, + "vlm_logprob": -0.28711268533952533, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.075, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.28711268533952533, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot an extremely slow zoom transitioning from close-up to extreme close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject focused entirely on the right eye of an elderly woman?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the woman's eyes deep amber with intricate, delicate textures in the irises?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a single teardrop dangling from her sparse lower lashes, trembling slightly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background completely blurred with warm tones, while warm sidelight casts a soft shadow on her cheek?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.828757107257843 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.578757107257843 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.828757107257843, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.828757107257843, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1317424476146698, + 0.0506754145026207, + 0.12402857840061188, + 0.03761470317840576, + 0.06816268712282181, + 0.022671326994895935, + 0.04114547371864319, + 0.08335521072149277, + 0.042947907000780106, + 0.39765626192092896 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.828757107257843 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot an extremely slow zoom transitioning from close-up to extreme close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject focused entirely on the right eye of an elderly woman?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the woman's eyes deep amber with intricate, delicate textures in the irises?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a single teardrop dangling from her sparse lower lashes, trembling slightly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background completely blurred with warm tones, while warm sidelight casts a soft shadow on her cheek?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1428700089454651 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0178699493408203 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1428700089454651, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1428700089454651, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09590348601341248, + 0.059184107929468155, + 0.20996516942977905, + 0.04055875912308693, + 0.08142758160829544, + 0.07009407877922058, + 0.07841910421848297, + 0.06092064827680588, + 0.09049376845359802, + 0.2130332887172699 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1428700089454651 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot an extremely slow zoom transitioning from close-up to extreme close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject focused entirely on the right eye of an elderly woman?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the woman's eyes deep amber with intricate, delicate textures in the irises?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a single teardrop dangling from her sparse lower lashes, trembling slightly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background completely blurred with warm tones, while warm sidelight casts a soft shadow on her cheek?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.18006370961666107 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8050637245178223 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.18006370961666107, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.18006370961666107, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0744662880897522, + 0.050172027200460434, + 0.14801785349845886, + 0.0825265645980835, + 0.0534217469394207, + 0.07046563178300858, + 0.08227533102035522, + 0.11832170933485031, + 0.05864716321229935, + 0.26168569922447205 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 2, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.18006370961666107 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot an extremely slow zoom transitioning from close-up to extreme close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject focused entirely on the right eye of an elderly woman?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the woman's eyes deep amber with intricate, delicate textures in the irises?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a single teardrop dangling from her sparse lower lashes, trembling slightly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background completely blurred with warm tones, while warm sidelight casts a soft shadow on her cheek?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2813824415206909 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.406382441520691 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2813824415206909, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2813824415206909, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15148800611495972, + 0.1013442873954773, + 0.14428699016571045, + 0.05067053437232971, + 0.05034831911325455, + 0.06295037269592285, + 0.07766703516244888, + 0.1406594216823578, + 0.07833287864923477, + 0.14225216209888458 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2813824415206909 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot an extremely slow zoom transitioning from close-up to extreme close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject focused entirely on the right eye of an elderly woman?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the woman's eyes deep amber with intricate, delicate textures in the irises?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a single teardrop dangling from her sparse lower lashes, trembling slightly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background completely blurred with warm tones, while warm sidelight casts a soft shadow on her cheek?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0024901593569666147 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002490043640137 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0024901593569666147, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0024901593569666147, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12851448357105255, + 0.10530698299407959, + 0.0636017695069313, + 0.10766319185495377, + 0.0742577314376831, + 0.06632517278194427, + 0.06966595351696014, + 0.15805964171886444, + 0.04380926489830017, + 0.18279586732387543 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0024901593569666147 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_2/index_tensor([910, 910])_group_2_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_2/index_tensor([910, 910])_group_2_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..daefa68728d6a9c1a5495bba437a7a895617b87c --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_2/index_tensor([910, 910])_group_2_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "series of eye-level static shots captures a scene rendered entirely in the style of a dynamic black-and-white ink calligraphic painting. A lone, abstract figure, composed of explosive and gestural black ink strokes, desperately sprints through a desolate, minimalist hall. The environment is defined by severe, angular ink lines that form jagged queue barriers and empty, skeletal officer cubicles, all set against a distinctly textured cream-colored paper background that reveals its fibrous grain. Each consecutive frame in the sequence presents a frozen moment of frantic movement, the figure's body leaning forward, limbs caught in a series of wet, splattered ink and dry brush streaks in their stride, conveying immense speed. The aesthetic is one of extreme high contrast, with deep, saturated black ink bleeding and splattering with primal energy, creating a powerful visual narrative within the cold, abstract space, depicting urgent despair and solitary struggle.", + "seed": 10742, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_2/index_910_seed_10742_dp_4_rank_8_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.24028112096711993, + "vlm_logprob": -0.24028112096711993, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.575, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.24028112096711993, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style that of a black-and-white ink calligraphic painting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a textured cream-colored paper revealing fibrous grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a minimalist hall with severe, angular ink lines forming jagged queue barriers and empty officer cubicles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an abstract figure composed of explosive and gestural black ink strokes sprinting forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the shots presented as eye-level static frames showing frozen moments of movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008239680901169777 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.00823974609375 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008239680901169777, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008239680901169777, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25384119153022766, + 0.10753538459539413, + 0.056485846638679504, + 0.03739418089389801, + 0.03641285374760628, + 0.22997376322746277, + 0.11986470967531204, + 0.03243967890739441, + 0.0481015145778656, + 0.0779508575797081 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008239680901169777 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style that of a black-and-white ink calligraphic painting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a textured cream-colored paper revealing fibrous grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a minimalist hall with severe, angular ink lines forming jagged queue barriers and empty officer cubicles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an abstract figure composed of explosive and gestural black ink strokes sprinting forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the shots presented as eye-level static frames showing frozen moments of movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03810957819223404 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288109540939331 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03810957819223404, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03810957819223404, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15217635035514832, + 0.0697227194905281, + 0.09558511525392532, + 0.03005560301244259, + 0.10444813221693039, + 0.09179185330867767, + 0.15514534711837769, + 0.09872366487979889, + 0.05733676254749298, + 0.14501440525054932 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03810957819223404 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style that of a black-and-white ink calligraphic painting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a textured cream-colored paper revealing fibrous grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a minimalist hall with severe, angular ink lines forming jagged queue barriers and empty officer cubicles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an abstract figure composed of explosive and gestural black ink strokes sprinting forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the shots presented as eye-level static frames showing frozen moments of movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016079746186733246 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141079902648926 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016079746186733246, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016079746186733246, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14590731263160706, + 0.11725199222564697, + 0.0803791955113411, + 0.0791187733411789, + 0.04502761736512184, + 0.09387239068746567, + 0.10038527101278305, + 0.023632140830159187, + 0.057138506323099136, + 0.25728678703308105 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016079746186733246 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style that of a black-and-white ink calligraphic painting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a textured cream-colored paper revealing fibrous grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a minimalist hall with severe, angular ink lines forming jagged queue barriers and empty officer cubicles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an abstract figure composed of explosive and gestural black ink strokes sprinting forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the shots presented as eye-level static frames showing frozen moments of movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0019393223337829113 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.251939296722412 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0019393223337829113, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0019393223337829113, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2142866849899292, + 0.08424396812915802, + 0.08573084324598312, + 0.0441850908100605, + 0.07603093236684799, + 0.10476212948560715, + 0.11604158580303192, + 0.034017838537693024, + 0.06356552243232727, + 0.17713533341884613 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0019393223337829113 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style that of a black-and-white ink calligraphic painting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a textured cream-colored paper revealing fibrous grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a minimalist hall with severe, angular ink lines forming jagged queue barriers and empty officer cubicles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an abstract figure composed of explosive and gestural black ink strokes sprinting forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the shots presented as eye-level static frames showing frozen moments of movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1370372772216797 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3870373070240021 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.1370372772216797, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -1.1370372772216797, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2067115753889084, + 0.1926475316286087, + 0.13936953246593475, + 0.09511096030473709, + 0.0647757276892662, + 0.03342527151107788, + 0.055743783712387085, + 0.022768158465623856, + 0.04366828873753548, + 0.14577919244766235 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.1370372772216797 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "series of eye-level static shots captures a scene rendered entirely in the style of a dynamic black-and-white ink calligraphic painting. A lone, abstract figure, composed of explosive and gestural black ink strokes, desperately sprints through a desolate, minimalist hall. The environment is defined by severe, angular ink lines that form jagged queue barriers and empty, skeletal officer cubicles, all set against a distinctly textured cream-colored paper background that reveals its fibrous grain. Each consecutive frame in the sequence presents a frozen moment of frantic movement, the figure's body leaning forward, limbs caught in a series of wet, splattered ink and dry brush streaks in their stride, conveying immense speed. The aesthetic is one of extreme high contrast, with deep, saturated black ink bleeding and splattering with primal energy, creating a powerful visual narrative within the cold, abstract space, depicting urgent despair and solitary struggle.", + "seed": 10743, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_2/index_910_seed_10743_dp_4_rank_8_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.13942650528624653, + "vlm_logprob": -0.13942650528624653, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.4, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.13942650528624653, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style that of a black-and-white ink calligraphic painting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a textured cream-colored paper revealing fibrous grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a minimalist hall with severe, angular ink lines forming jagged queue barriers and empty officer cubicles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an abstract figure composed of explosive and gestural black ink strokes sprinting forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the shots presented as eye-level static frames showing frozen moments of movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03146511688828468 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5314650535583496 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03146511688828468, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03146511688828468, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5001511573791504, + 0.04883965104818344, + 0.04103359580039978, + 0.03983883932232857, + 0.04626473784446716, + 0.0660635456442833, + 0.14624527096748352, + 0.014806396327912807, + 0.017133252695202827, + 0.07962353527545929 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03146511688828468 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style that of a black-and-white ink calligraphic painting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a textured cream-colored paper revealing fibrous grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a minimalist hall with severe, angular ink lines forming jagged queue barriers and empty officer cubicles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an abstract figure composed of explosive and gestural black ink strokes sprinting forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the shots presented as eye-level static frames showing frozen moments of movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01819046586751938 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018190383911133 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01819046586751938, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01819046586751938, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5559117794036865, + 0.07447053492069244, + 0.07185583561658859, + 0.028528187423944473, + 0.026851147413253784, + 0.026468899101018906, + 0.14836089313030243, + 0.016125505790114403, + 0.02075188234448433, + 0.03067529946565628 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01819046586751938 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style that of a black-and-white ink calligraphic painting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a textured cream-colored paper revealing fibrous grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a minimalist hall with severe, angular ink lines forming jagged queue barriers and empty officer cubicles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an abstract figure composed of explosive and gestural black ink strokes sprinting forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the shots presented as eye-level static frames showing frozen moments of movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07003137469291687 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950314044952393 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07003137469291687, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07003137469291687, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2953583598136902, + 0.05072205141186714, + 0.21297615766525269, + 0.15978893637657166, + 0.09060028940439224, + 0.03200635313987732, + 0.0428464338183403, + 0.036000579595565796, + 0.06273109465837479, + 0.016969844698905945 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07003137469291687 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style that of a black-and-white ink calligraphic painting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a textured cream-colored paper revealing fibrous grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a minimalist hall with severe, angular ink lines forming jagged queue barriers and empty officer cubicles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an abstract figure composed of explosive and gestural black ink strokes sprinting forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the shots presented as eye-level static frames showing frozen moments of movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.001335205975919962 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.626335144042969 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.001335205975919962, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.001335205975919962, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.28173473477363586, + 0.059785809367895126, + 0.08118266612291336, + 0.09536608308553696, + 0.08850464224815369, + 0.04915986955165863, + 0.271291583776474, + 0.01801333762705326, + 0.02936657704412937, + 0.02559468150138855 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.001335205975919962 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style that of a black-and-white ink calligraphic painting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a textured cream-colored paper revealing fibrous grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a minimalist hall with severe, angular ink lines forming jagged queue barriers and empty officer cubicles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an abstract figure composed of explosive and gestural black ink strokes sprinting forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the shots presented as eye-level static frames showing frozen moments of movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5761103630065918 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8261103630065918 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5761103630065918, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5761103630065918, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14140936732292175, + 0.048452798277139664, + 0.15577931702136993, + 0.05864153429865837, + 0.03544336557388306, + 0.0489821620285511, + 0.41167932748794556, + 0.021449506282806396, + 0.035562921315431595, + 0.04259973764419556 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5761103630065918 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "series of eye-level static shots captures a scene rendered entirely in the style of a dynamic black-and-white ink calligraphic painting. A lone, abstract figure, composed of explosive and gestural black ink strokes, desperately sprints through a desolate, minimalist hall. The environment is defined by severe, angular ink lines that form jagged queue barriers and empty, skeletal officer cubicles, all set against a distinctly textured cream-colored paper background that reveals its fibrous grain. Each consecutive frame in the sequence presents a frozen moment of frantic movement, the figure's body leaning forward, limbs caught in a series of wet, splattered ink and dry brush streaks in their stride, conveying immense speed. The aesthetic is one of extreme high contrast, with deep, saturated black ink bleeding and splattering with primal energy, creating a powerful visual narrative within the cold, abstract space, depicting urgent despair and solitary struggle.", + "seed": 10744, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_2/index_910_seed_10744_dp_5_rank_10_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.09532349600922316, + "vlm_logprob": -0.09532349600922316, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.224999988079071, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.09532349600922316, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style that of a black-and-white ink calligraphic painting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a textured cream-colored paper revealing fibrous grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a minimalist hall with severe, angular ink lines forming jagged queue barriers and empty officer cubicles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an abstract figure composed of explosive and gestural black ink strokes sprinting forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the shots presented as eye-level static frames showing frozen moments of movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036434237845242023 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.37864351272583 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036434237845242023, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036434237845242023, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1576661765575409, + 0.08457311987876892, + 0.08122789114713669, + 0.07570856809616089, + 0.0798240453004837, + 0.09480435401201248, + 0.0756308063864708, + 0.14222180843353271, + 0.06203972175717354, + 0.1463034749031067 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036434237845242023 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style that of a black-and-white ink calligraphic painting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a textured cream-colored paper revealing fibrous grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a minimalist hall with severe, angular ink lines forming jagged queue barriers and empty officer cubicles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an abstract figure composed of explosive and gestural black ink strokes sprinting forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the shots presented as eye-level static frames showing frozen moments of movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01606660895049572 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141066551208496 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01606660895049572, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01606660895049572, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.36681100726127625, + 0.061914995312690735, + 0.08741342276334763, + 0.05451872572302818, + 0.07951455563306808, + 0.06534400582313538, + 0.054636914283037186, + 0.06239683926105499, + 0.046849798411130905, + 0.12059973180294037 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01606660895049572 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style that of a black-and-white ink calligraphic painting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a textured cream-colored paper revealing fibrous grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a minimalist hall with severe, angular ink lines forming jagged queue barriers and empty officer cubicles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an abstract figure composed of explosive and gestural black ink strokes sprinting forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the shots presented as eye-level static frames showing frozen moments of movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026353510096669197 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651353597640991 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026353510096669197, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026353510096669197, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2083447277545929, + 0.08789384365081787, + 0.2191849946975708, + 0.07125581800937653, + 0.08422762900590897, + 0.04988541826605797, + 0.0530252568423748, + 0.0716351717710495, + 0.06445934623479843, + 0.09008780866861343 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026353510096669197 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style that of a black-and-white ink calligraphic painting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a textured cream-colored paper revealing fibrous grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a minimalist hall with severe, angular ink lines forming jagged queue barriers and empty officer cubicles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an abstract figure composed of explosive and gestural black ink strokes sprinting forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the shots presented as eye-level static frames showing frozen moments of movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0017118098912760615 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.376711845397949 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0017118098912760615, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0017118098912760615, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1842557042837143, + 0.09008650481700897, + 0.07723498344421387, + 0.08716323226690292, + 0.24278989434242249, + 0.03548656404018402, + 0.0552130825817585, + 0.09921839833259583, + 0.047409478574991226, + 0.0811421200633049 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0017118098912760615 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style that of a black-and-white ink calligraphic painting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a textured cream-colored paper revealing fibrous grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a minimalist hall with severe, angular ink lines forming jagged queue barriers and empty officer cubicles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an abstract figure composed of explosive and gestural black ink strokes sprinting forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the shots presented as eye-level static frames showing frozen moments of movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.42884212732315063 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.0538420677185059 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.42884212732315063, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.6249999403953552, + "token_credit_reward": -0.42884212732315063, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18175622820854187, + 0.07640349119901657, + 0.10928933322429657, + 0.08688906580209732, + 0.16595003008842468, + 0.1140688806772232, + 0.05941380560398102, + 0.07663029432296753, + 0.06863260269165039, + 0.06096624955534935 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.42884212732315063 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "series of eye-level static shots captures a scene rendered entirely in the style of a dynamic black-and-white ink calligraphic painting. A lone, abstract figure, composed of explosive and gestural black ink strokes, desperately sprints through a desolate, minimalist hall. The environment is defined by severe, angular ink lines that form jagged queue barriers and empty, skeletal officer cubicles, all set against a distinctly textured cream-colored paper background that reveals its fibrous grain. Each consecutive frame in the sequence presents a frozen moment of frantic movement, the figure's body leaning forward, limbs caught in a series of wet, splattered ink and dry brush streaks in their stride, conveying immense speed. The aesthetic is one of extreme high contrast, with deep, saturated black ink bleeding and splattering with primal energy, creating a powerful visual narrative within the cold, abstract space, depicting urgent despair and solitary struggle.", + "seed": 10745, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_2/index_910_seed_10745_dp_5_rank_10_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.10046162335202098, + "vlm_logprob": -0.10046162335202098, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.85, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.10046162335202098, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style that of a black-and-white ink calligraphic painting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a textured cream-colored paper revealing fibrous grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a minimalist hall with severe, angular ink lines forming jagged queue barriers and empty officer cubicles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an abstract figure composed of explosive and gestural black ink strokes sprinting forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the shots presented as eye-level static frames showing frozen moments of movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0049674902111291885 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.00496768951416 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0049674902111291885, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0049674902111291885, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0896051675081253, + 0.2398781031370163, + 0.056774646043777466, + 0.0735175684094429, + 0.03138608857989311, + 0.019115325063467026, + 0.05093885585665703, + 0.3638511300086975, + 0.028965767472982407, + 0.045967403799295425 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0049674902111291885 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style that of a black-and-white ink calligraphic painting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a textured cream-colored paper revealing fibrous grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a minimalist hall with severe, angular ink lines forming jagged queue barriers and empty officer cubicles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an abstract figure composed of explosive and gestural black ink strokes sprinting forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the shots presented as eye-level static frames showing frozen moments of movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029805263504385948 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298051834106445 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029805263504385948, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029805263504385948, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.059772323817014694, + 0.5498937964439392, + 0.10154469311237335, + 0.08276403695344925, + 0.023317420855164528, + 0.04742198809981346, + 0.022965071722865105, + 0.022713985294103622, + 0.048804786056280136, + 0.04080197215080261 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029805263504385948 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style that of a black-and-white ink calligraphic painting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a textured cream-colored paper revealing fibrous grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a minimalist hall with severe, angular ink lines forming jagged queue barriers and empty officer cubicles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an abstract figure composed of explosive and gestural black ink strokes sprinting forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the shots presented as eye-level static frames showing frozen moments of movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07899990677833557 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5789999961853027 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07899990677833557, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07899990677833557, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04856902360916138, + 0.22761765122413635, + 0.03562246635556221, + 0.03677085414528847, + 0.03450598567724228, + 0.03553301468491554, + 0.03987342491745949, + 0.4224405288696289, + 0.05724006146192551, + 0.061826955527067184 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07899990677833557 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style that of a black-and-white ink calligraphic painting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a textured cream-colored paper revealing fibrous grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a minimalist hall with severe, angular ink lines forming jagged queue barriers and empty officer cubicles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an abstract figure composed of explosive and gestural black ink strokes sprinting forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the shots presented as eye-level static frames showing frozen moments of movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0015135272406041622 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.501513481140137 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0015135272406041622, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0015135272406041622, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05080404877662659, + 0.1812952607870102, + 0.07649428397417068, + 0.027209483087062836, + 0.01640773005783558, + 0.016530534252524376, + 0.0397111140191555, + 0.4865383207798004, + 0.03052038699388504, + 0.07448884844779968 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0015135272406041622 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style that of a black-and-white ink calligraphic painting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a textured cream-colored paper revealing fibrous grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a minimalist hall with severe, angular ink lines forming jagged queue barriers and empty officer cubicles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an abstract figure composed of explosive and gestural black ink strokes sprinting forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the shots presented as eye-level static frames showing frozen moments of movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.38702192902565 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1370218992233276 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.38702192902565, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.38702192902565, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05529891327023506, + 0.0613866001367569, + 0.04414505511522293, + 0.03375286981463432, + 0.028667904436588287, + 0.031189918518066406, + 0.029070764780044556, + 0.6418525576591492, + 0.03300892934203148, + 0.0416264608502388 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.38702192902565 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_3/index_tensor([643, 643])_group_3_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_3/index_tensor([643, 643])_group_3_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..b93e1ac32a6ffa2a796f6588599b31e896fa050c --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_3/index_tensor([643, 643])_group_3_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "stunning close-up, captured at eye level, the camera remains stationary, focused on the tip of a brush saturated with thick ink. The brush tip is crafted from fine wolf hair, each delicate bristle saturated with the inextricably rich ink. Softly illuminated by a sidelight from a window, it gleams with a moist, glossy sheen, gathering into a perfectly pointed cone. The background is a slightly out-of-focus, finely textured white rice paper, creating a minimal depth of field. At the very tip of the brush tip, a perfectly spherical drop of ink, carefully condensing and slowly expanding under the pull of gravity, its smooth black surface like a miniature convex mirror, clearly reflecting a bright, luminous spot. As the weight of the ink bead reaches its critical point, it silently separates from the brush tip in a stable and calm manner, maintaining a perfect spherical shape in the air and falling towards the white rice paper below. The entire picture forms a strong visual contrast with pure black and pure white, full of extreme tranquility, concentration and Zen, freezing a fleeting moment into eternal art.", + "seed": 30463, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_3/index_643_seed_30463_dp_6_rank_12_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.09030286949127912, + "vlm_logprob": -0.09030286949127912, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.925, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.09030286949127912, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focused on the tip of a brush made of fine wolf hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the brush tip saturated with thick black ink forming a moist, glossy sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a perfectly spherical drop of ink visible at the tip, slowly expanding and then separating to fall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a slightly out-of-focus, finely textured white rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera stationary at eye level with soft sidelight illumination?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20742203295230865 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7074220180511475 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20742203295230865, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20742203295230865, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3064320981502533, + 0.05462437495589256, + 0.07075536996126175, + 0.11086311936378479, + 0.03378507122397423, + 0.128024622797966, + 0.05644747242331505, + 0.07553116232156754, + 0.04325464740395546, + 0.12028207629919052 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20742203295230865 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focused on the tip of a brush made of fine wolf hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the brush tip saturated with thick black ink forming a moist, glossy sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a perfectly spherical drop of ink visible at the tip, slowly expanding and then separating to fall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a slightly out-of-focus, finely textured white rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera stationary at eye level with soft sidelight illumination?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026391824707388878 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513917446136475 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026391824707388878, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026391824707388878, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3594266176223755, + 0.18004529178142548, + 0.12957899272441864, + 0.05573682859539986, + 0.03612752631306648, + 0.067662812769413, + 0.03281005471944809, + 0.022506020963191986, + 0.06708386540412903, + 0.04902198165655136 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026391824707388878 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focused on the tip of a brush made of fine wolf hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the brush tip saturated with thick black ink forming a moist, glossy sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a perfectly spherical drop of ink visible at the tip, slowly expanding and then separating to fall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a slightly out-of-focus, finely textured white rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera stationary at eye level with soft sidelight illumination?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16040131449699402 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9104013442993164 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16040131449699402, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16040131449699402, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2857923209667206, + 0.10137840360403061, + 0.14500769972801208, + 0.03410336747765541, + 0.02899274230003357, + 0.041068486869335175, + 0.06227514520287514, + 0.16530418395996094, + 0.06949319690465927, + 0.06658446043729782 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16040131449699402 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focused on the tip of a brush made of fine wolf hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the brush tip saturated with thick black ink forming a moist, glossy sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a perfectly spherical drop of ink visible at the tip, slowly expanding and then separating to fall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a slightly out-of-focus, finely textured white rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera stationary at eye level with soft sidelight illumination?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008643713779747486 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758643627166748 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008643713779747486, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008643713779747486, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1976916342973709, + 0.06096912547945976, + 0.027944572269916534, + 0.02031114138662815, + 0.05374825745820999, + 0.0683288425207138, + 0.1322975605726242, + 0.037972673773765564, + 0.051457956433296204, + 0.34927821159362793 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008643713779747486 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focused on the tip of a brush made of fine wolf hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the brush tip saturated with thick black ink forming a moist, glossy sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a perfectly spherical drop of ink visible at the tip, slowly expanding and then separating to fall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a slightly out-of-focus, finely textured white rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera stationary at eye level with soft sidelight illumination?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04865546151995659 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486555099487305 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04865546151995659, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04865546151995659, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2999938130378723, + 0.08936803042888641, + 0.09994936734437943, + 0.0706726685166359, + 0.027710868045687675, + 0.0950881689786911, + 0.050616368651390076, + 0.08637089282274246, + 0.046133071184158325, + 0.13409672677516937 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04865546151995659 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "stunning close-up, captured at eye level, the camera remains stationary, focused on the tip of a brush saturated with thick ink. The brush tip is crafted from fine wolf hair, each delicate bristle saturated with the inextricably rich ink. Softly illuminated by a sidelight from a window, it gleams with a moist, glossy sheen, gathering into a perfectly pointed cone. The background is a slightly out-of-focus, finely textured white rice paper, creating a minimal depth of field. At the very tip of the brush tip, a perfectly spherical drop of ink, carefully condensing and slowly expanding under the pull of gravity, its smooth black surface like a miniature convex mirror, clearly reflecting a bright, luminous spot. As the weight of the ink bead reaches its critical point, it silently separates from the brush tip in a stable and calm manner, maintaining a perfect spherical shape in the air and falling towards the white rice paper below. The entire picture forms a strong visual contrast with pure black and pure white, full of extreme tranquility, concentration and Zen, freezing a fleeting moment into eternal art.", + "seed": 30464, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_3/index_643_seed_30464_dp_6_rank_12_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.034043447114527225, + "vlm_logprob": -0.034043447114527225, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.599999952316284, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.034043447114527225, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focused on the tip of a brush made of fine wolf hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the brush tip saturated with thick black ink forming a moist, glossy sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a perfectly spherical drop of ink visible at the tip, slowly expanding and then separating to fall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a slightly out-of-focus, finely textured white rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera stationary at eye level with soft sidelight illumination?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06715822964906693 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8171582221984863 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06715822964906693, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06715822964906693, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13754744827747345, + 0.06383753567934036, + 0.04888399317860603, + 0.07712891697883606, + 0.06269187480211258, + 0.0794687569141388, + 0.09721162170171738, + 0.07345851510763168, + 0.14999477565288544, + 0.2097766399383545 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06715822964906693 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focused on the tip of a brush made of fine wolf hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the brush tip saturated with thick black ink forming a moist, glossy sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a perfectly spherical drop of ink visible at the tip, slowly expanding and then separating to fall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a slightly out-of-focus, finely textured white rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera stationary at eye level with soft sidelight illumination?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018214929848909378 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018214702606201 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018214929848909378, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018214929848909378, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16184669733047485, + 0.10282224416732788, + 0.04526025801897049, + 0.07233790308237076, + 0.07495925575494766, + 0.08117752522230148, + 0.10235612839460373, + 0.08033917844295502, + 0.10807875543832779, + 0.17082206904888153 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018214929848909378 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focused on the tip of a brush made of fine wolf hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the brush tip saturated with thick black ink forming a moist, glossy sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a perfectly spherical drop of ink visible at the tip, slowly expanding and then separating to fall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a slightly out-of-focus, finely textured white rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera stationary at eye level with soft sidelight illumination?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03810911998152733 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288109064102173 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03810911998152733, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03810911998152733, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3639994263648987, + 0.09361933916807175, + 0.05121520161628723, + 0.07439853996038437, + 0.0767817422747612, + 0.055099911987781525, + 0.09244298934936523, + 0.06605353206396103, + 0.08057951927185059, + 0.04580971971154213 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03810911998152733 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focused on the tip of a brush made of fine wolf hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the brush tip saturated with thick black ink forming a moist, glossy sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a perfectly spherical drop of ink visible at the tip, slowly expanding and then separating to fall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a slightly out-of-focus, finely textured white rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera stationary at eye level with soft sidelight illumination?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008640640415251255 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758640766143799 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008640640415251255, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008640640415251255, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1314062774181366, + 0.1067846342921257, + 0.06620534509420395, + 0.04253105819225311, + 0.22195962071418762, + 0.11035153269767761, + 0.07940107583999634, + 0.03893326595425606, + 0.12423646450042725, + 0.07819076627492905 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008640640415251255 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focused on the tip of a brush made of fine wolf hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the brush tip saturated with thick black ink forming a moist, glossy sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a perfectly spherical drop of ink visible at the tip, slowly expanding and then separating to fall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a slightly out-of-focus, finely textured white rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera stationary at eye level with soft sidelight illumination?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03809431567788124 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2880942821502686 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03809431567788124, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03809431567788124, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14241091907024384, + 0.07271071523427963, + 0.026714207604527473, + 0.05668789520859718, + 0.15978264808654785, + 0.08158539235591888, + 0.08904122561216354, + 0.05466649308800697, + 0.16933198273181915, + 0.14706850051879883 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03809431567788124 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "stunning close-up, captured at eye level, the camera remains stationary, focused on the tip of a brush saturated with thick ink. The brush tip is crafted from fine wolf hair, each delicate bristle saturated with the inextricably rich ink. Softly illuminated by a sidelight from a window, it gleams with a moist, glossy sheen, gathering into a perfectly pointed cone. The background is a slightly out-of-focus, finely textured white rice paper, creating a minimal depth of field. At the very tip of the brush tip, a perfectly spherical drop of ink, carefully condensing and slowly expanding under the pull of gravity, its smooth black surface like a miniature convex mirror, clearly reflecting a bright, luminous spot. As the weight of the ink bead reaches its critical point, it silently separates from the brush tip in a stable and calm manner, maintaining a perfect spherical shape in the air and falling towards the white rice paper below. The entire picture forms a strong visual contrast with pure black and pure white, full of extreme tranquility, concentration and Zen, freezing a fleeting moment into eternal art.", + "seed": 30465, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_3/index_643_seed_30465_dp_7_rank_14_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.03771799807436764, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03771799807436764, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.75, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03771799807436764, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focused on the tip of a brush made of fine wolf hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the brush tip saturated with thick black ink forming a moist, glossy sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a perfectly spherical drop of ink visible at the tip, slowly expanding and then separating to fall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a slightly out-of-focus, finely textured white rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera stationary at eye level with soft sidelight illumination?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0973273515701294 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.47232723236084 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0973273515701294, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0973273515701294, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2325926572084427, + 0.15337853133678436, + 0.10498444736003876, + 0.12681496143341064, + 0.09326323866844177, + 0.0366104319691658, + 0.05284155160188675, + 0.046061694622039795, + 0.05034476891160011, + 0.103107750415802 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0973273515701294 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focused on the tip of a brush made of fine wolf hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the brush tip saturated with thick black ink forming a moist, glossy sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a perfectly spherical drop of ink visible at the tip, slowly expanding and then separating to fall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a slightly out-of-focus, finely textured white rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera stationary at eye level with soft sidelight illumination?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036440177354961634 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628643989562988 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036440177354961634, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036440177354961634, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11079231649637222, + 0.0765807032585144, + 0.1936310976743698, + 0.060519102960824966, + 0.20657671988010406, + 0.024783015251159668, + 0.03780972212553024, + 0.048636071383953094, + 0.05308275297284126, + 0.18758849799633026 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 2, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036440177354961634 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focused on the tip of a brush made of fine wolf hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the brush tip saturated with thick black ink forming a moist, glossy sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a perfectly spherical drop of ink visible at the tip, slowly expanding and then separating to fall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a slightly out-of-focus, finely textured white rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera stationary at eye level with soft sidelight illumination?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018200181424617767 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018200397491455 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018200181424617767, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018200181424617767, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07319188863039017, + 0.054858043789863586, + 0.18819259107112885, + 0.05109608173370361, + 0.17571987211704254, + 0.0683903768658638, + 0.05848661810159683, + 0.15410181879997253, + 0.07211292535066605, + 0.10384982824325562 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 4, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018200181424617767 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focused on the tip of a brush made of fine wolf hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the brush tip saturated with thick black ink forming a moist, glossy sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a perfectly spherical drop of ink visible at the tip, slowly expanding and then separating to fall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a slightly out-of-focus, finely textured white rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera stationary at eye level with soft sidelight illumination?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026356296613812447 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513562202453613 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026356296613812447, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026356296613812447, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07461543381214142, + 0.023176390677690506, + 0.08299978077411652, + 0.06394728273153305, + 0.660595178604126, + 0.014354865998029709, + 0.023220110684633255, + 0.015335865318775177, + 0.015083824284374714, + 0.026671264320611954 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026356296613812447 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focused on the tip of a brush made of fine wolf hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the brush tip saturated with thick black ink forming a moist, glossy sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a perfectly spherical drop of ink visible at the tip, slowly expanding and then separating to fall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a slightly out-of-focus, finely textured white rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera stationary at eye level with soft sidelight illumination?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04306214302778244 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168062210083008 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04306214302778244, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04306214302778244, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1205844059586525, + 0.0671071782708168, + 0.06779055297374725, + 0.06659781187772751, + 0.3262060582637787, + 0.05312800407409668, + 0.07260874658823013, + 0.05546708405017853, + 0.0976925939321518, + 0.0728176012635231 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04306214302778244 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "stunning close-up, captured at eye level, the camera remains stationary, focused on the tip of a brush saturated with thick ink. The brush tip is crafted from fine wolf hair, each delicate bristle saturated with the inextricably rich ink. Softly illuminated by a sidelight from a window, it gleams with a moist, glossy sheen, gathering into a perfectly pointed cone. The background is a slightly out-of-focus, finely textured white rice paper, creating a minimal depth of field. At the very tip of the brush tip, a perfectly spherical drop of ink, carefully condensing and slowly expanding under the pull of gravity, its smooth black surface like a miniature convex mirror, clearly reflecting a bright, luminous spot. As the weight of the ink bead reaches its critical point, it silently separates from the brush tip in a stable and calm manner, maintaining a perfect spherical shape in the air and falling towards the white rice paper below. The entire picture forms a strong visual contrast with pure black and pure white, full of extreme tranquility, concentration and Zen, freezing a fleeting moment into eternal art.", + "seed": 30466, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_3/index_643_seed_30466_dp_7_rank_14_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.17694856822490693, + "vlm_logprob": -0.17694856822490693, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.35, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.17694856822490693, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focused on the tip of a brush made of fine wolf hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the brush tip saturated with thick black ink forming a moist, glossy sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a perfectly spherical drop of ink visible at the tip, slowly expanding and then separating to fall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a slightly out-of-focus, finely textured white rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera stationary at eye level with soft sidelight illumination?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.23402222990989685 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6090222597122192 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.23402222990989685, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.23402222990989685, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18626821041107178, + 0.22141076624393463, + 0.054123640060424805, + 0.05880894884467125, + 0.04782068356871605, + 0.2366536557674408, + 0.05318060144782066, + 0.04238676279783249, + 0.04062649980187416, + 0.058720242232084274 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.23402222990989685 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focused on the tip of a brush made of fine wolf hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the brush tip saturated with thick black ink forming a moist, glossy sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a perfectly spherical drop of ink visible at the tip, slowly expanding and then separating to fall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a slightly out-of-focus, finely textured white rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera stationary at eye level with soft sidelight illumination?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.043117180466651917 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1681172847747803 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.043117180466651917, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.043117180466651917, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.30533599853515625, + 0.07985200732946396, + 0.04638448730111122, + 0.047433577477931976, + 0.02805311046540737, + 0.04543282091617584, + 0.03604375943541527, + 0.045517876744270325, + 0.02789357863366604, + 0.3380528390407562 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.043117180466651917 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focused on the tip of a brush made of fine wolf hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the brush tip saturated with thick black ink forming a moist, glossy sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a perfectly spherical drop of ink visible at the tip, slowly expanding and then separating to fall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a slightly out-of-focus, finely textured white rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera stationary at eye level with soft sidelight illumination?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5233802795410156 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8983802795410156 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5233802795410156, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5233802795410156, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17995624244213104, + 0.039846647530794144, + 0.03956538066267967, + 0.035510994493961334, + 0.02295071817934513, + 0.034268349409103394, + 0.027927393093705177, + 0.05236842855811119, + 0.028559444472193718, + 0.5390464067459106 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5233802795410156 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focused on the tip of a brush made of fine wolf hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the brush tip saturated with thick black ink forming a moist, glossy sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a perfectly spherical drop of ink visible at the tip, slowly expanding and then separating to fall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a slightly out-of-focus, finely textured white rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera stationary at eye level with soft sidelight illumination?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01420411467552185 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264204025268555 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01420411467552185, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01420411467552185, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22063350677490234, + 0.1231679767370224, + 0.06632918119430542, + 0.06432964652776718, + 0.07307150959968567, + 0.2264881581068039, + 0.10747495293617249, + 0.03374091535806656, + 0.01401594653725624, + 0.0707482323050499 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01420411467552185 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up focused on the tip of a brush made of fine wolf hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the brush tip saturated with thick black ink forming a moist, glossy sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a perfectly spherical drop of ink visible at the tip, slowly expanding and then separating to fall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a slightly out-of-focus, finely textured white rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera stationary at eye level with soft sidelight illumination?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07001903653144836 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695019006729126 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07001903653144836, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07001903653144836, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08489033579826355, + 0.030670585110783577, + 0.03287714719772339, + 0.03933663293719292, + 0.03692466765642166, + 0.12930452823638916, + 0.052424363791942596, + 0.1888131946325302, + 0.07323132455348969, + 0.3315272331237793 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07001903653144836 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_4/index_tensor([7723, 7723])_group_4_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_4/index_tensor([7723, 7723])_group_4_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..43becc2f022fe94b63597e59dc2391e9a553b561 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_4/index_tensor([7723, 7723])_group_4_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "striking low-angle close-up tracking shot locks onto the wheels of a heavily modified rally car. Sporting a vibrant blue and white paint scheme, its white, multi-spoke alloy wheels mounted with thick, block-patterned all-terrain tires spin at breakneck speed, their sidewalls speckled with mud. As the car, in a precisely controlled drift, glides through a tight bend on a rough, gravelly dirt track, the camera pans rapidly, always in sync with the wheels. The tires tear fiercely at the soft ground, sending a massive cloud of thick brown dust and fine stones flying backwards in a spectacular wall of dust. In the glaring afternoon sun, the rising dust thickens into a golden mist, contrasting sharply with the deep shadows cast below. The entire scene is imbued with a sense of raw power, speed, and adrenaline-fueled tension, perfectly showcasing the car's exceptional handling at the limit.", + "seed": 11399, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_4/index_7723_seed_11399_dp_8_rank_16_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.02014707252383232, + "vlm_logprob": -0.02014707252383232, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.35, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.02014707252383232, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle close-up focused on the wheels of a rally car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the car have a blue and white paint scheme with white multi-spoke alloy wheels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the tires thick, block-patterned, all-terrain tires speckled with mud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the car drifting on a rough, gravelly dirt track while kicking up a massive cloud of brown dust and stones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan rapidly in sync with the wheels under glaring afternoon sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005549856927245855 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.630549907684326 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005549856927245855, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005549856927245855, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08524910360574722, + 0.3114013969898224, + 0.23887935280799866, + 0.06540537625551224, + 0.033692169934511185, + 0.04132841154932976, + 0.11990640312433243, + 0.0475805327296257, + 0.03245064988732338, + 0.024106565862894058 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005549856927245855 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle close-up focused on the wheels of a rally car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the car have a blue and white paint scheme with white multi-spoke alloy wheels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the tires thick, block-patterned, all-terrain tires speckled with mud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the car drifting on a rough, gravelly dirt track while kicking up a massive cloud of brown dust and stones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan rapidly in sync with the wheels under glaring afternoon sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018200766295194626 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018200874328613 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018200766295194626, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018200766295194626, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15160520374774933, + 0.31047290563583374, + 0.1433413326740265, + 0.07099780440330505, + 0.05779801681637764, + 0.08990371972322464, + 0.045603763312101364, + 0.029378652572631836, + 0.040487319231033325, + 0.06041126698255539 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018200766295194626 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle close-up focused on the wheels of a rally car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the car have a blue and white paint scheme with white multi-spoke alloy wheels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the tires thick, block-patterned, all-terrain tires speckled with mud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the car drifting on a rough, gravelly dirt track while kicking up a massive cloud of brown dust and stones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan rapidly in sync with the wheels under glaring afternoon sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05496140569448471 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299614429473877 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05496140569448471, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05496140569448471, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18548254668712616, + 0.30472174286842346, + 0.11552803218364716, + 0.07179276645183563, + 0.044666390866041183, + 0.12181704491376877, + 0.06261912733316422, + 0.024798071011900902, + 0.04313454031944275, + 0.025439737364649773 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05496140569448471 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle close-up focused on the wheels of a rally car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the car have a blue and white paint scheme with white multi-spoke alloy wheels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the tires thick, block-patterned, all-terrain tires speckled with mud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the car drifting on a rough, gravelly dirt track while kicking up a massive cloud of brown dust and stones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan rapidly in sync with the wheels under glaring afternoon sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016069423407316208 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141069412231445 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016069423407316208, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016069423407316208, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11767054349184036, + 0.07629456371068954, + 0.07369351387023926, + 0.11467090994119644, + 0.04785386845469475, + 0.3945525586605072, + 0.07109786570072174, + 0.02411932684481144, + 0.043141886591911316, + 0.036904968321323395 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016069423407316208 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle close-up focused on the wheels of a rally car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the car have a blue and white paint scheme with white multi-spoke alloy wheels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the tires thick, block-patterned, all-terrain tires speckled with mud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the car drifting on a rough, gravelly dirt track while kicking up a massive cloud of brown dust and stones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan rapidly in sync with the wheels under glaring afternoon sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005953910294920206 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130953788757324 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005953910294920206, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005953910294920206, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07537009567022324, + 0.14367160201072693, + 0.0760737806558609, + 0.11859013140201569, + 0.06890050321817398, + 0.24087366461753845, + 0.06992345303297043, + 0.10830165445804596, + 0.051540348678827286, + 0.04675479233264923 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005953910294920206 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "striking low-angle close-up tracking shot locks onto the wheels of a heavily modified rally car. Sporting a vibrant blue and white paint scheme, its white, multi-spoke alloy wheels mounted with thick, block-patterned all-terrain tires spin at breakneck speed, their sidewalls speckled with mud. As the car, in a precisely controlled drift, glides through a tight bend on a rough, gravelly dirt track, the camera pans rapidly, always in sync with the wheels. The tires tear fiercely at the soft ground, sending a massive cloud of thick brown dust and fine stones flying backwards in a spectacular wall of dust. In the glaring afternoon sun, the rising dust thickens into a golden mist, contrasting sharply with the deep shadows cast below. The entire scene is imbued with a sense of raw power, speed, and adrenaline-fueled tension, perfectly showcasing the car's exceptional handling at the limit.", + "seed": 11400, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_4/index_7723_seed_11400_dp_8_rank_16_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.008257976081222296, + "vlm_logprob": -0.008257976081222296, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 5.025, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.008257976081222296, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle close-up focused on the wheels of a rally car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the car have a blue and white paint scheme with white multi-spoke alloy wheels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the tires thick, block-patterned, all-terrain tires speckled with mud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the car drifting on a rough, gravelly dirt track while kicking up a massive cloud of brown dust and stones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan rapidly in sync with the wheels under glaring afternoon sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00322073046118021 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.378220558166504 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00322073046118021, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00322073046118021, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06694386899471283, + 0.05410591885447502, + 0.1862042397260666, + 0.042260464280843735, + 0.17518126964569092, + 0.1523493379354477, + 0.1527908891439438, + 0.040026187896728516, + 0.05676579475402832, + 0.0733720064163208 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00322073046118021 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle close-up focused on the wheels of a rally car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the car have a blue and white paint scheme with white multi-spoke alloy wheels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the tires thick, block-patterned, all-terrain tires speckled with mud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the car drifting on a rough, gravelly dirt track while kicking up a massive cloud of brown dust and stones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan rapidly in sync with the wheels under glaring afternoon sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009794510900974274 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.63479471206665 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009794510900974274, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009794510900974274, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12523788213729858, + 0.0801023542881012, + 0.20385652780532837, + 0.05165174603462219, + 0.24398398399353027, + 0.08896538615226746, + 0.07393819838762283, + 0.03885149583220482, + 0.04680347815155983, + 0.04660898819565773 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009794510900974274 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle close-up focused on the wheels of a rally car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the car have a blue and white paint scheme with white multi-spoke alloy wheels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the tires thick, block-patterned, all-terrain tires speckled with mud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the car drifting on a rough, gravelly dirt track while kicking up a massive cloud of brown dust and stones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan rapidly in sync with the wheels under glaring afternoon sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012540886178612709 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387540817260742 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012540886178612709, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012540886178612709, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1402958780527115, + 0.06935198605060577, + 0.16693484783172607, + 0.18821898102760315, + 0.13604982197284698, + 0.05944173410534859, + 0.11465219408273697, + 0.045054469257593155, + 0.032797496765851974, + 0.04720256105065346 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012540886178612709 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle close-up focused on the wheels of a rally car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the car have a blue and white paint scheme with white multi-spoke alloy wheels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the tires thick, block-patterned, all-terrain tires speckled with mud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the car drifting on a rough, gravelly dirt track while kicking up a massive cloud of brown dust and stones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan rapidly in sync with the wheels under glaring afternoon sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005946089047938585 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130946159362793 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005946089047938585, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005946089047938585, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09038951247930527, + 0.1916332244873047, + 0.1038523018360138, + 0.05856703966856003, + 0.11460129171609879, + 0.11620652675628662, + 0.14621181786060333, + 0.06574118882417679, + 0.04009280353784561, + 0.07270430773496628 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005946089047938585 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle close-up focused on the wheels of a rally car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the car have a blue and white paint scheme with white multi-spoke alloy wheels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the tires thick, block-patterned, all-terrain tires speckled with mud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the car drifting on a rough, gravelly dirt track while kicking up a massive cloud of brown dust and stones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan rapidly in sync with the wheels under glaring afternoon sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0097876638174057 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634787559509277 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0097876638174057, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0097876638174057, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04618625342845917, + 0.03565448150038719, + 0.1333126574754715, + 0.024948714300990105, + 0.04558931663632393, + 0.07825625687837601, + 0.5092402100563049, + 0.04410881549119949, + 0.04434160143136978, + 0.03836170956492424 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0097876638174057 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "striking low-angle close-up tracking shot locks onto the wheels of a heavily modified rally car. Sporting a vibrant blue and white paint scheme, its white, multi-spoke alloy wheels mounted with thick, block-patterned all-terrain tires spin at breakneck speed, their sidewalls speckled with mud. As the car, in a precisely controlled drift, glides through a tight bend on a rough, gravelly dirt track, the camera pans rapidly, always in sync with the wheels. The tires tear fiercely at the soft ground, sending a massive cloud of thick brown dust and fine stones flying backwards in a spectacular wall of dust. In the glaring afternoon sun, the rising dust thickens into a golden mist, contrasting sharply with the deep shadows cast below. The entire scene is imbued with a sense of raw power, speed, and adrenaline-fueled tension, perfectly showcasing the car's exceptional handling at the limit.", + "seed": 11401, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_4/index_7723_seed_11401_dp_9_rank_18_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.011520659644156694, + "vlm_logprob": -0.011520659644156694, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.675, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.011520659644156694, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle close-up focused on the wheels of a rally car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the car have a blue and white paint scheme with white multi-spoke alloy wheels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the tires thick, block-patterned, all-terrain tires speckled with mud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the car drifting on a rough, gravelly dirt track while kicking up a massive cloud of brown dust and stones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan rapidly in sync with the wheels under glaring afternoon sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005552109330892563 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.630552291870117 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005552109330892563, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005552109330892563, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5931706428527832, + 0.04500722512602806, + 0.035165440291166306, + 0.023545274510979652, + 0.013580228202044964, + 0.12164532393217087, + 0.047851841896772385, + 0.017918387427926064, + 0.05820775777101517, + 0.04390794411301613 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005552109330892563 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle close-up focused on the wheels of a rally car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the car have a blue and white paint scheme with white multi-spoke alloy wheels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the tires thick, block-patterned, all-terrain tires speckled with mud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the car drifting on a rough, gravelly dirt track while kicking up a massive cloud of brown dust and stones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan rapidly in sync with the wheels under glaring afternoon sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016091125085949898 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141091346740723 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016091125085949898, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016091125085949898, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3883289694786072, + 0.11237029731273651, + 0.115226611495018, + 0.0832272544503212, + 0.05964973196387291, + 0.05743929743766785, + 0.07691528648138046, + 0.01972047984600067, + 0.024657072499394417, + 0.062464985996484756 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016091125085949898 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle close-up focused on the wheels of a rally car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the car have a blue and white paint scheme with white multi-spoke alloy wheels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the tires thick, block-patterned, all-terrain tires speckled with mud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the car drifting on a rough, gravelly dirt track while kicking up a massive cloud of brown dust and stones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan rapidly in sync with the wheels under glaring afternoon sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020583707839250565 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955836296081543 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020583707839250565, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020583707839250565, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11188554018735886, + 0.018529171124100685, + 0.03619372472167015, + 0.06969651579856873, + 0.07156983017921448, + 0.10975264757871628, + 0.3246898055076599, + 0.03550121933221817, + 0.15839852392673492, + 0.06378303468227386 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020583707839250565 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle close-up focused on the wheels of a rally car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the car have a blue and white paint scheme with white multi-spoke alloy wheels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the tires thick, block-patterned, all-terrain tires speckled with mud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the car drifting on a rough, gravelly dirt track while kicking up a massive cloud of brown dust and stones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan rapidly in sync with the wheels under glaring afternoon sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006735952105373144 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006735801696777 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006735952105373144, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006735952105373144, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2483312338590622, + 0.011017466895282269, + 0.014336246997117996, + 0.02628682740032673, + 0.062383316457271576, + 0.09819106012582779, + 0.24833615124225616, + 0.04668522998690605, + 0.19964975118637085, + 0.04478272423148155 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006735952105373144 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle close-up focused on the wheels of a rally car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the car have a blue and white paint scheme with white multi-spoke alloy wheels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the tires thick, block-patterned, all-terrain tires speckled with mud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the car drifting on a rough, gravelly dirt track while kicking up a massive cloud of brown dust and stones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan rapidly in sync with the wheels under glaring afternoon sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008640403859317303 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758640289306641 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008640403859317303, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008640403859317303, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.38704583048820496, + 0.014042602851986885, + 0.048058122396469116, + 0.018199622631072998, + 0.035836976021528244, + 0.1380787491798401, + 0.1263657510280609, + 0.044262148439884186, + 0.1466425657272339, + 0.04146769270300865 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008640403859317303 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "striking low-angle close-up tracking shot locks onto the wheels of a heavily modified rally car. Sporting a vibrant blue and white paint scheme, its white, multi-spoke alloy wheels mounted with thick, block-patterned all-terrain tires spin at breakneck speed, their sidewalls speckled with mud. As the car, in a precisely controlled drift, glides through a tight bend on a rough, gravelly dirt track, the camera pans rapidly, always in sync with the wheels. The tires tear fiercely at the soft ground, sending a massive cloud of thick brown dust and fine stones flying backwards in a spectacular wall of dust. In the glaring afternoon sun, the rising dust thickens into a golden mist, contrasting sharply with the deep shadows cast below. The entire scene is imbued with a sense of raw power, speed, and adrenaline-fueled tension, perfectly showcasing the car's exceptional handling at the limit.", + "seed": 11402, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_4/index_7723_seed_11402_dp_9_rank_18_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.027000311855226757, + "vlm_logprob": -0.027000311855226757, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.925, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.027000311855226757, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle close-up focused on the wheels of a rally car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the car have a blue and white paint scheme with white multi-spoke alloy wheels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the tires thick, block-patterned, all-terrain tires speckled with mud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the car drifting on a rough, gravelly dirt track while kicking up a massive cloud of brown dust and stones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan rapidly in sync with the wheels under glaring afternoon sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011115179397165775 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.761115074157715 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011115179397165775, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011115179397165775, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07049151510000229, + 0.030319560319185257, + 0.059866663068532944, + 0.06030447408556938, + 0.16610921919345856, + 0.12387201189994812, + 0.24744156002998352, + 0.17870843410491943, + 0.030315808951854706, + 0.03257065266370773 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011115179397165775 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle close-up focused on the wheels of a rally car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the car have a blue and white paint scheme with white multi-spoke alloy wheels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the tires thick, block-patterned, all-terrain tires speckled with mud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the car drifting on a rough, gravelly dirt track while kicking up a massive cloud of brown dust and stones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan rapidly in sync with the wheels under glaring afternoon sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018216218799352646 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018216133117676 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018216218799352646, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018216218799352646, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.337845116853714, + 0.05367446690797806, + 0.09070369601249695, + 0.02147725410759449, + 0.08190493285655975, + 0.12912113964557648, + 0.03176148608326912, + 0.169594869017601, + 0.04507393389940262, + 0.03884313255548477 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018216218799352646 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle close-up focused on the wheels of a rally car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the car have a blue and white paint scheme with white multi-spoke alloy wheels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the tires thick, block-patterned, all-terrain tires speckled with mud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the car drifting on a rough, gravelly dirt track while kicking up a massive cloud of brown dust and stones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan rapidly in sync with the wheels under glaring afternoon sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0549660325050354 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299659729003906 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0549660325050354, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0549660325050354, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09734497964382172, + 0.029509684070944786, + 0.10467489808797836, + 0.04659999907016754, + 0.05475234612822533, + 0.1406119018793106, + 0.3898109495639801, + 0.05549393966794014, + 0.021538488566875458, + 0.05966281145811081 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0549660325050354 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle close-up focused on the wheels of a rally car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the car have a blue and white paint scheme with white multi-spoke alloy wheels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the tires thick, block-patterned, all-terrain tires speckled with mud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the car drifting on a rough, gravelly dirt track while kicking up a massive cloud of brown dust and stones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan rapidly in sync with the wheels under glaring afternoon sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04306808114051819 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680681705474854 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04306808114051819, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04306808114051819, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07637041807174683, + 0.01429175864905119, + 0.0657535195350647, + 0.01746995374560356, + 0.06248500198125839, + 0.1903967261314392, + 0.3939319849014282, + 0.09865927696228027, + 0.007689063437283039, + 0.07295224815607071 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04306808114051819 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle close-up focused on the wheels of a rally car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the car have a blue and white paint scheme with white multi-spoke alloy wheels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the tires thick, block-patterned, all-terrain tires speckled with mud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the car drifting on a rough, gravelly dirt track while kicking up a massive cloud of brown dust and stones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan rapidly in sync with the wheels under glaring afternoon sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007636047434061766 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882636070251465 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007636047434061766, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007636047434061766, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1054525226354599, + 0.04056328907608986, + 0.1672573685646057, + 0.05853066220879555, + 0.03673636168241501, + 0.10767630487680435, + 0.1850953847169876, + 0.18291567265987396, + 0.02700694277882576, + 0.0887654721736908 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007636047434061766 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_5/index_tensor([4761, 4761])_group_5_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_5/index_tensor([4761, 4761])_group_5_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..e671c69ec9d285740cbff149d39c4177b6efe4e3 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_5/index_tensor([4761, 4761])_group_5_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "low-angle shot, the camera tilting upward as the action unfolds, initially focusing on a pitch-black crow perched atop a weathered, dark wooden utility pole, its sharp talons clutching a tangled bundle of black cables below. Under the even, diffuse light of a gloomy sky, its glossy feathers reflect a faint shimmer of deep blue and purple iridescence, and its alert, inky black eyes scan the surroundings warily. The vast, oppressive background of a uniformly gray sky, devoid of a single cloud pattern, creates a sense of bleak loneliness. Suddenly, as if startled by an invisible roar, the crow's body shrank, then explosively spread its vast wings, decisively leaving the power lines with a single, powerful kick. With a ferocious and rapid flapping of wings, each feather traces a distinct path through the air. The camera smoothly follows its flight path upwards, capturing its vertical climb with a powerful posture, and eventually transforms from a clearly detailed creature into a pure black silhouette that shrinks continuously on the boundless gray canvas, until it completely merges into the sky, leaving only empty power lines trembling slightly in the silence.", + "seed": 18906, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_5/index_4761_seed_18906_dp_10_rank_20_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.06076483437791467, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06076483437791467, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.95, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06076483437791467, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot initially a low-angle view of a pitch-black crow perched on a weathered wooden utility pole?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the crow have glossy feathers reflecting deep blue and purple iridescence under a gloomy sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the crow suddenly shrink its body and explosively spread its wings to take flight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward and follow the crow's flight path until it transforms into a shrinking black silhouette against a gray sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the crow merging into the sky while empty power lines tremble slightly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.021772295236587524 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8967723846435547 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.021772295236587524, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.021772295236587524, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.28592777252197266, + 0.22210511565208435, + 0.04630236327648163, + 0.13953910768032074, + 0.07195809483528137, + 0.042740266770124435, + 0.052938565611839294, + 0.031442414969205856, + 0.0650557279586792, + 0.04199054837226868 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.021772295236587524 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot initially a low-angle view of a pitch-black crow perched on a weathered wooden utility pole?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the crow have glossy feathers reflecting deep blue and purple iridescence under a gloomy sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the crow suddenly shrink its body and explosively spread its wings to take flight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward and follow the crow's flight path until it transforms into a shrinking black silhouette against a gray sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the crow merging into the sky while empty power lines tremble slightly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2521854043006897 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.502185344696045 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2521854043006897, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2521854043006897, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.42650264501571655, + 0.21367383003234863, + 0.047294504940509796, + 0.05996380001306534, + 0.09910505264997482, + 0.018062913790345192, + 0.05944231525063515, + 0.022560372948646545, + 0.017939258366823196, + 0.03545532748103142 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2521854043006897 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot initially a low-angle view of a pitch-black crow perched on a weathered wooden utility pole?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the crow have glossy feathers reflecting deep blue and purple iridescence under a gloomy sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the crow suddenly shrink its body and explosively spread its wings to take flight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward and follow the crow's flight path until it transforms into a shrinking black silhouette against a gray sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the crow merging into the sky while empty power lines tremble slightly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004643609281629324 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379643440246582 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004643609281629324, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004643609281629324, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1816907674074173, + 0.11536358296871185, + 0.054675620049238205, + 0.1263832151889801, + 0.053608234971761703, + 0.12051045149564743, + 0.11814168840646744, + 0.07493322342634201, + 0.1001710593700409, + 0.0545220747590065 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004643609281629324 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot initially a low-angle view of a pitch-black crow perched on a weathered wooden utility pole?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the crow have glossy feathers reflecting deep blue and purple iridescence under a gloomy sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the crow suddenly shrink its body and explosively spread its wings to take flight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward and follow the crow's flight path until it transforms into a shrinking black silhouette against a gray sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the crow merging into the sky while empty power lines tremble slightly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004642541520297527 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379642486572266 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004642541520297527, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004642541520297527, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18376588821411133, + 0.13044898211956024, + 0.060230374336242676, + 0.07139222323894501, + 0.0671132430434227, + 0.0831318274140358, + 0.08447936177253723, + 0.09309157729148865, + 0.08152560144662857, + 0.14482088387012482 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004642541520297527 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot initially a low-angle view of a pitch-black crow perched on a weathered wooden utility pole?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the crow have glossy feathers reflecting deep blue and purple iridescence under a gloomy sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the crow suddenly shrink its body and explosively spread its wings to take flight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward and follow the crow's flight path until it transforms into a shrinking black silhouette against a gray sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the crow merging into the sky while empty power lines tremble slightly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020580321550369263 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895580291748047 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020580321550369263, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020580321550369263, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.39190423488616943, + 0.036380618810653687, + 0.03122660517692566, + 0.041072435677051544, + 0.15361085534095764, + 0.045169636607170105, + 0.035394102334976196, + 0.09256275743246078, + 0.08703693747520447, + 0.08564181625843048 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020580321550369263 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle shot, the camera tilting upward as the action unfolds, initially focusing on a pitch-black crow perched atop a weathered, dark wooden utility pole, its sharp talons clutching a tangled bundle of black cables below. Under the even, diffuse light of a gloomy sky, its glossy feathers reflect a faint shimmer of deep blue and purple iridescence, and its alert, inky black eyes scan the surroundings warily. The vast, oppressive background of a uniformly gray sky, devoid of a single cloud pattern, creates a sense of bleak loneliness. Suddenly, as if startled by an invisible roar, the crow's body shrank, then explosively spread its vast wings, decisively leaving the power lines with a single, powerful kick. With a ferocious and rapid flapping of wings, each feather traces a distinct path through the air. The camera smoothly follows its flight path upwards, capturing its vertical climb with a powerful posture, and eventually transforms from a clearly detailed creature into a pure black silhouette that shrinks continuously on the boundless gray canvas, until it completely merges into the sky, leaving only empty power lines trembling slightly in the silence.", + "seed": 18907, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_5/index_4761_seed_18907_dp_10_rank_20_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.12158832913264632, + "vlm_logprob": -0.12158832913264632, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.575, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.12158832913264632, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot initially a low-angle view of a pitch-black crow perched on a weathered wooden utility pole?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the crow have glossy feathers reflecting deep blue and purple iridescence under a gloomy sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the crow suddenly shrink its body and explosively spread its wings to take flight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward and follow the crow's flight path until it transforms into a shrinking black silhouette against a gray sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the crow merging into the sky while empty power lines tremble slightly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05643404647707939 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.931434154510498 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05643404647707939, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05643404647707939, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4170103669166565, + 0.10900010913610458, + 0.0473155751824379, + 0.07052075862884521, + 0.08722808212041855, + 0.04982968419790268, + 0.0507034957408905, + 0.09256495535373688, + 0.0344388447701931, + 0.041388098150491714 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05643404647707939 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot initially a low-angle view of a pitch-black crow perched on a weathered wooden utility pole?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the crow have glossy feathers reflecting deep blue and purple iridescence under a gloomy sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the crow suddenly shrink its body and explosively spread its wings to take flight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward and follow the crow's flight path until it transforms into a shrinking black silhouette against a gray sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the crow merging into the sky while empty power lines tremble slightly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5234206318855286 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8984206318855286 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5234206318855286, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5234206318855286, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2691740095615387, + 0.09358615428209305, + 0.06601633876562119, + 0.11615576595067978, + 0.10298360139131546, + 0.09528452903032303, + 0.12925423681735992, + 0.03521297127008438, + 0.03336150944232941, + 0.058970857411623 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5234206318855286 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot initially a low-angle view of a pitch-black crow perched on a weathered wooden utility pole?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the crow have glossy feathers reflecting deep blue and purple iridescence under a gloomy sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the crow suddenly shrink its body and explosively spread its wings to take flight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward and follow the crow's flight path until it transforms into a shrinking black silhouette against a gray sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the crow merging into the sky while empty power lines tremble slightly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004644202534109354 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379644393920898 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004644202534109354, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004644202534109354, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24306167662143707, + 0.05974477156996727, + 0.07521095871925354, + 0.18112000823020935, + 0.13781997561454773, + 0.11605092138051987, + 0.041188329458236694, + 0.04606930911540985, + 0.07036090642213821, + 0.029373161494731903 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004644202534109354 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot initially a low-angle view of a pitch-black crow perched on a weathered wooden utility pole?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the crow have glossy feathers reflecting deep blue and purple iridescence under a gloomy sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the crow suddenly shrink its body and explosively spread its wings to take flight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward and follow the crow's flight path until it transforms into a shrinking black silhouette against a gray sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the crow merging into the sky while empty power lines tremble slightly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005255929194390774 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255255699157715 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005255929194390774, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005255929194390774, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08462667465209961, + 0.11904033273458481, + 0.09850429743528366, + 0.07444585859775543, + 0.07131584733724594, + 0.2767464220523834, + 0.12642702460289001, + 0.041272398084402084, + 0.04468141496181488, + 0.06293978542089462 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005255929194390774 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot initially a low-angle view of a pitch-black crow perched on a weathered wooden utility pole?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the crow have glossy feathers reflecting deep blue and purple iridescence under a gloomy sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the crow suddenly shrink its body and explosively spread its wings to take flight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward and follow the crow's flight path until it transforms into a shrinking black silhouette against a gray sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the crow merging into the sky while empty power lines tremble slightly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018186835572123528 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018187046051025 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018186835572123528, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018186835572123528, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.46349361538887024, + 0.10977928340435028, + 0.08865280449390411, + 0.04414289444684982, + 0.048397719860076904, + 0.0490131713449955, + 0.057339590042829514, + 0.047099772840738297, + 0.03152471035718918, + 0.06055646017193794 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018186835572123528 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle shot, the camera tilting upward as the action unfolds, initially focusing on a pitch-black crow perched atop a weathered, dark wooden utility pole, its sharp talons clutching a tangled bundle of black cables below. Under the even, diffuse light of a gloomy sky, its glossy feathers reflect a faint shimmer of deep blue and purple iridescence, and its alert, inky black eyes scan the surroundings warily. The vast, oppressive background of a uniformly gray sky, devoid of a single cloud pattern, creates a sense of bleak loneliness. Suddenly, as if startled by an invisible roar, the crow's body shrank, then explosively spread its vast wings, decisively leaving the power lines with a single, powerful kick. With a ferocious and rapid flapping of wings, each feather traces a distinct path through the air. The camera smoothly follows its flight path upwards, capturing its vertical climb with a powerful posture, and eventually transforms from a clearly detailed creature into a pure black silhouette that shrinks continuously on the boundless gray canvas, until it completely merges into the sky, leaving only empty power lines trembling slightly in the silence.", + "seed": 18908, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_5/index_4761_seed_18908_dp_11_rank_22_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.059218208538368344, + "vlm_logprob": -0.059218208538368344, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.1, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.059218208538368344, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot initially a low-angle view of a pitch-black crow perched on a weathered wooden utility pole?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the crow have glossy feathers reflecting deep blue and purple iridescence under a gloomy sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the crow suddenly shrink its body and explosively spread its wings to take flight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward and follow the crow's flight path until it transforms into a shrinking black silhouette against a gray sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the crow merging into the sky while empty power lines tremble slightly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018015561625361443 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.143015384674072 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018015561625361443, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018015561625361443, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1181177869439125, + 0.05316360667347908, + 0.07856307923793793, + 0.07122816145420074, + 0.10729334503412247, + 0.1374429315328598, + 0.22887922823429108, + 0.10760483145713806, + 0.04743689298629761, + 0.05027009919285774 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018015561625361443 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot initially a low-angle view of a pitch-black crow perched on a weathered wooden utility pole?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the crow have glossy feathers reflecting deep blue and purple iridescence under a gloomy sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the crow suddenly shrink its body and explosively spread its wings to take flight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward and follow the crow's flight path until it transforms into a shrinking black silhouette against a gray sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the crow merging into the sky while empty power lines tremble slightly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.25217095017433167 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5021709203720093 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.25217095017433167, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.25217095017433167, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18622958660125732, + 0.024134140461683273, + 0.09185776114463806, + 0.07596522569656372, + 0.3317070007324219, + 0.05758906528353691, + 0.1158018559217453, + 0.030072102323174477, + 0.03410559147596359, + 0.05253765359520912 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.25217095017433167 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot initially a low-angle view of a pitch-black crow perched on a weathered wooden utility pole?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the crow have glossy feathers reflecting deep blue and purple iridescence under a gloomy sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the crow suddenly shrink its body and explosively spread its wings to take flight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward and follow the crow's flight path until it transforms into a shrinking black silhouette against a gray sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the crow merging into the sky while empty power lines tremble slightly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004101199563592672 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504101276397705 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004101199563592672, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004101199563592672, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1019928827881813, + 0.04290202632546425, + 0.07542216777801514, + 0.11855227500200272, + 0.09325890988111496, + 0.10067284107208252, + 0.07265933603048325, + 0.19797775149345398, + 0.08471336215734482, + 0.11184845119714737 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004101199563592672 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot initially a low-angle view of a pitch-black crow perched on a weathered wooden utility pole?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the crow have glossy feathers reflecting deep blue and purple iridescence under a gloomy sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the crow suddenly shrink its body and explosively spread its wings to take flight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward and follow the crow's flight path until it transforms into a shrinking black silhouette against a gray sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the crow merging into the sky while empty power lines tremble slightly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036188371013849974 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.6286187171936035 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036188371013849974, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036188371013849974, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05302075296640396, + 0.035731345415115356, + 0.02844778448343277, + 0.11561266332864761, + 0.07838279753923416, + 0.09952258318662643, + 0.2884076237678528, + 0.08673722296953201, + 0.14720958471298218, + 0.06692766398191452 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036188371013849974 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot initially a low-angle view of a pitch-black crow perched on a weathered wooden utility pole?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the crow have glossy feathers reflecting deep blue and purple iridescence under a gloomy sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the crow suddenly shrink its body and explosively spread its wings to take flight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward and follow the crow's flight path until it transforms into a shrinking black silhouette against a gray sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the crow merging into the sky while empty power lines tremble slightly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018184494227170944 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018184661865234 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018184494227170944, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018184494227170944, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09692548215389252, + 0.05122886598110199, + 0.03853018954396248, + 0.04256010055541992, + 0.08679305762052536, + 0.07410359382629395, + 0.08693607896566391, + 0.23333990573883057, + 0.09330687671899796, + 0.19627587497234344 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018184494227170944 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle shot, the camera tilting upward as the action unfolds, initially focusing on a pitch-black crow perched atop a weathered, dark wooden utility pole, its sharp talons clutching a tangled bundle of black cables below. Under the even, diffuse light of a gloomy sky, its glossy feathers reflect a faint shimmer of deep blue and purple iridescence, and its alert, inky black eyes scan the surroundings warily. The vast, oppressive background of a uniformly gray sky, devoid of a single cloud pattern, creates a sense of bleak loneliness. Suddenly, as if startled by an invisible roar, the crow's body shrank, then explosively spread its vast wings, decisively leaving the power lines with a single, powerful kick. With a ferocious and rapid flapping of wings, each feather traces a distinct path through the air. The camera smoothly follows its flight path upwards, capturing its vertical climb with a powerful posture, and eventually transforms from a clearly detailed creature into a pure black silhouette that shrinks continuously on the boundless gray canvas, until it completely merges into the sky, leaving only empty power lines trembling slightly in the silence.", + "seed": 18909, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_5/index_4761_seed_18909_dp_11_rank_22_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.0832105290144682, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0832105290144682, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.8, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0832105290144682, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot initially a low-angle view of a pitch-black crow perched on a weathered wooden utility pole?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the crow have glossy feathers reflecting deep blue and purple iridescence under a gloomy sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the crow suddenly shrink its body and explosively spread its wings to take flight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward and follow the crow's flight path until it transforms into a shrinking black silhouette against a gray sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the crow merging into the sky while empty power lines tremble slightly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.044759318232536316 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1697592735290527 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.044759318232536316, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.044759318232536316, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15299251675605774, + 0.10732397437095642, + 0.0925014540553093, + 0.06684593856334686, + 0.17083130776882172, + 0.040886010974645615, + 0.17696905136108398, + 0.08018317073583603, + 0.058603569865226746, + 0.05286296457052231 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.044759318232536316 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot initially a low-angle view of a pitch-black crow perched on a weathered wooden utility pole?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the crow have glossy feathers reflecting deep blue and purple iridescence under a gloomy sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the crow suddenly shrink its body and explosively spread its wings to take flight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward and follow the crow's flight path until it transforms into a shrinking black silhouette against a gray sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the crow merging into the sky while empty power lines tremble slightly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3487033545970917 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.223703384399414 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3487033545970917, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3487033545970917, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11170946061611176, + 0.09873773157596588, + 0.059337422251701355, + 0.060846827924251556, + 0.05213728919625282, + 0.09296415001153946, + 0.17210543155670166, + 0.1349000781774521, + 0.11645618826150894, + 0.1008053719997406 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3487033545970917 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot initially a low-angle view of a pitch-black crow perched on a weathered wooden utility pole?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the crow have glossy feathers reflecting deep blue and purple iridescence under a gloomy sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the crow suddenly shrink its body and explosively spread its wings to take flight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward and follow the crow's flight path until it transforms into a shrinking black silhouette against a gray sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the crow merging into the sky while empty power lines tremble slightly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005953436251729727 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130953311920166 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005953436251729727, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005953436251729727, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18983712792396545, + 0.12587465345859528, + 0.12126506119966507, + 0.11158528923988342, + 0.06790920346975327, + 0.05714842677116394, + 0.1076950803399086, + 0.06800592690706253, + 0.06848538666963577, + 0.08219382911920547 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005953436251729727 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot initially a low-angle view of a pitch-black crow perched on a weathered wooden utility pole?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the crow have glossy feathers reflecting deep blue and purple iridescence under a gloomy sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the crow suddenly shrink its body and explosively spread its wings to take flight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward and follow the crow's flight path until it transforms into a shrinking black silhouette against a gray sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the crow merging into the sky while empty power lines tremble slightly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004099181387573481 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504099369049072 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004099181387573481, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004099181387573481, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1561630666255951, + 0.0759376585483551, + 0.12358468770980835, + 0.06896353513002396, + 0.10484873503446579, + 0.07846180349588394, + 0.08011805266141891, + 0.07644796371459961, + 0.0962541475892067, + 0.13922026753425598 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004099181387573481 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot initially a low-angle view of a pitch-black crow perched on a weathered wooden utility pole?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the crow have glossy feathers reflecting deep blue and purple iridescence under a gloomy sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the crow suddenly shrink its body and explosively spread its wings to take flight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward and follow the crow's flight path until it transforms into a shrinking black silhouette against a gray sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the crow merging into the sky while empty power lines tremble slightly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012537354603409767 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387537479400635 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012537354603409767, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012537354603409767, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.33818647265434265, + 0.10892746597528458, + 0.08072622120380402, + 0.058274395763874054, + 0.11474587768316269, + 0.05477910488843918, + 0.0882963240146637, + 0.04392097890377045, + 0.0569421760737896, + 0.0552009642124176 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012537354603409767 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_6/index_tensor([3230, 3230])_group_6_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_6/index_tensor([3230, 3230])_group_6_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..36ca6dd5a8af48a606e18d1527bfd5f91d38df1f --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_6/index_tensor([3230, 3230])_group_6_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "An immersive first-person perspective, tilted slightly downward, evokes the impression of being seated before a rustic, dark-wood desk. At the center of the frame, a pair of weathered, calloused hands delicately interact with an ancient bamboo scroll. Their skin is dry, their knuckles prominent, and each deep line of their palms bears witness to the passage of time. The left hand firmly presses the scroll. The bamboo has a deep amber hue from age, its surface smooth and mellow from constant caressing. The dark brown silk cords binding the strips are slightly frayed at the edges. With the rough yet remarkably steady fingertips of the right hand, the bamboo scroll is gently and deliberately pushed to the right. As each section of the bamboo slide lies flat on the dark tabletop, a gentle, dry click echoes, revealing rows of ancient seal characters meticulously carved with a knife. The powerful strokes of these characters are deeply embedded in the texture of the bamboo. Under the warm and soft light that shines in from the side of the painting, like candlelight, a subtle contrast of light and shadow is created within the grooves of the characters, making each simple and solemn character full of three-dimensionality and a sense of historical weight. The entire scene is filled with warm colors, and the atmosphere is tranquil and focused, full of a reverence for knowledge and history.", + "seed": 20722, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_6/index_3230_seed_20722_dp_12_rank_24_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.06534682647325099, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06534682647325099, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.75, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06534682647325099, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a first-person perspective tilted slightly downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of weathered, calloused hands with prominent knuckles visible interacting with the scroll?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an ancient bamboo scroll with a deep amber hue and dark brown silk cords visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the right hand push the bamboo scroll to the right, revealing rows of ancient seal characters carved into the bamboo?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm, soft side lighting resembling candlelight that creates strong light and shadow contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07433314621448517 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0743331909179688 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07433314621448517, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07433314621448517, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10550842434167862, + 0.03409050405025482, + 0.04167616367340088, + 0.4342479407787323, + 0.08178364485502243, + 0.11824528872966766, + 0.052734795957803726, + 0.03696093708276749, + 0.048834435641765594, + 0.04591793939471245 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07433314621448517 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a first-person perspective tilted slightly downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of weathered, calloused hands with prominent knuckles visible interacting with the scroll?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an ancient bamboo scroll with a deep amber hue and dark brown silk cords visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the right hand push the bamboo scroll to the right, revealing rows of ancient seal characters carved into the bamboo?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm, soft side lighting resembling candlelight that creates strong light and shadow contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20163103938102722 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7016310691833496 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20163103938102722, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20163103938102722, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09016092121601105, + 0.03322303667664528, + 0.047902144491672516, + 0.5232890844345093, + 0.04053449630737305, + 0.07588393241167068, + 0.10845479369163513, + 0.018053678795695305, + 0.034516531974077225, + 0.027981381863355637 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20163103938102722 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a first-person perspective tilted slightly downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of weathered, calloused hands with prominent knuckles visible interacting with the scroll?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an ancient bamboo scroll with a deep amber hue and dark brown silk cords visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the right hand push the bamboo scroll to the right, revealing rows of ancient seal characters carved into the bamboo?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm, soft side lighting resembling candlelight that creates strong light and shadow contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036208562087267637 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628620624542236 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036208562087267637, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036208562087267637, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15046115219593048, + 0.04038963466882706, + 0.09266510605812073, + 0.2788560390472412, + 0.07100404053926468, + 0.12519071996212006, + 0.09622644633054733, + 0.030314382165670395, + 0.06475930660963058, + 0.05013319477438927 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036208562087267637 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a first-person perspective tilted slightly downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of weathered, calloused hands with prominent knuckles visible interacting with the scroll?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an ancient bamboo scroll with a deep amber hue and dark brown silk cords visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the right hand push the bamboo scroll to the right, revealing rows of ancient seal characters carved into the bamboo?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm, soft side lighting resembling candlelight that creates strong light and shadow contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.043056320399045944 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680562496185303 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.043056320399045944, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.043056320399045944, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09183786809444427, + 0.057961609214544296, + 0.04738524556159973, + 0.4588577449321747, + 0.03957488387823105, + 0.09559416025876999, + 0.03067963942885399, + 0.037179939448833466, + 0.08847299218177795, + 0.052455976605415344 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.043056320399045944 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a first-person perspective tilted slightly downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of weathered, calloused hands with prominent knuckles visible interacting with the scroll?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an ancient bamboo scroll with a deep amber hue and dark brown silk cords visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the right hand push the bamboo scroll to the right, revealing rows of ancient seal characters carved into the bamboo?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm, soft side lighting resembling candlelight that creates strong light and shadow contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004092770162969828 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504092693328857 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004092770162969828, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004092770162969828, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08331728726625443, + 0.034686557948589325, + 0.052767351269721985, + 0.2918204367160797, + 0.11696401238441467, + 0.11343467235565186, + 0.15163907408714294, + 0.061265554279088974, + 0.04959975928068161, + 0.04450530186295509 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004092770162969828 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An immersive first-person perspective, tilted slightly downward, evokes the impression of being seated before a rustic, dark-wood desk. At the center of the frame, a pair of weathered, calloused hands delicately interact with an ancient bamboo scroll. Their skin is dry, their knuckles prominent, and each deep line of their palms bears witness to the passage of time. The left hand firmly presses the scroll. The bamboo has a deep amber hue from age, its surface smooth and mellow from constant caressing. The dark brown silk cords binding the strips are slightly frayed at the edges. With the rough yet remarkably steady fingertips of the right hand, the bamboo scroll is gently and deliberately pushed to the right. As each section of the bamboo slide lies flat on the dark tabletop, a gentle, dry click echoes, revealing rows of ancient seal characters meticulously carved with a knife. The powerful strokes of these characters are deeply embedded in the texture of the bamboo. Under the warm and soft light that shines in from the side of the painting, like candlelight, a subtle contrast of light and shadow is created within the grooves of the characters, making each simple and solemn character full of three-dimensionality and a sense of historical weight. The entire scene is filled with warm colors, and the atmosphere is tranquil and focused, full of a reverence for knowledge and history.", + "seed": 20723, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_6/index_3230_seed_20723_dp_12_rank_24_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.07865420361049473, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07865420361049473, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.674999976158142, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07865420361049473, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a first-person perspective tilted slightly downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of weathered, calloused hands with prominent knuckles visible interacting with the scroll?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an ancient bamboo scroll with a deep amber hue and dark brown silk cords visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the right hand push the bamboo scroll to the right, revealing rows of ancient seal characters carved into the bamboo?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm, soft side lighting resembling candlelight that creates strong light and shadow contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03232857584953308 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.0323286056518555 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03232857584953308, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03232857584953308, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2419120967388153, + 0.10918574780225754, + 0.05469240993261337, + 0.052118655294179916, + 0.04863988608121872, + 0.10003051161766052, + 0.27842122316360474, + 0.034521304070949554, + 0.037232425063848495, + 0.043245747685432434 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03232857584953308 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a first-person perspective tilted slightly downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of weathered, calloused hands with prominent knuckles visible interacting with the scroll?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an ancient bamboo scroll with a deep amber hue and dark brown silk cords visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the right hand push the bamboo scroll to the right, revealing rows of ancient seal characters carved into the bamboo?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm, soft side lighting resembling candlelight that creates strong light and shadow contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22563877701759338 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.600638747215271 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.22563877701759338, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.22563877701759338, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16484473645687103, + 0.23624290525913239, + 0.038195058703422546, + 0.035214971750974655, + 0.060012854635715485, + 0.11861312389373779, + 0.24366825819015503, + 0.024467943236231804, + 0.028884397819638252, + 0.04985577240586281 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.22563877701759338 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a first-person perspective tilted slightly downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of weathered, calloused hands with prominent knuckles visible interacting with the scroll?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an ancient bamboo scroll with a deep amber hue and dark brown silk cords visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the right hand push the bamboo scroll to the right, revealing rows of ancient seal characters carved into the bamboo?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm, soft side lighting resembling candlelight that creates strong light and shadow contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004642185289412737 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379642009735107 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004642185289412737, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004642185289412737, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07723404467105865, + 0.14196547865867615, + 0.03918778523802757, + 0.03234125301241875, + 0.13216456770896912, + 0.08138537406921387, + 0.379472941160202, + 0.04361484572291374, + 0.036119308322668076, + 0.036514390259981155 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004642185289412737 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a first-person perspective tilted slightly downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of weathered, calloused hands with prominent knuckles visible interacting with the scroll?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an ancient bamboo scroll with a deep amber hue and dark brown silk cords visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the right hand push the bamboo scroll to the right, revealing rows of ancient seal characters carved into the bamboo?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm, soft side lighting resembling candlelight that creates strong light and shadow contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1270485818386078 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1270484924316406 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1270485818386078, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.9999998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1270485818386078, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0977168157696724, + 0.17418955266475677, + 0.0843711644411087, + 0.057845499366521835, + 0.10270817577838898, + 0.14640535414218903, + 0.16758421063423157, + 0.025546154007315636, + 0.05617570877075195, + 0.08745738118886948 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1270485818386078 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a first-person perspective tilted slightly downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of weathered, calloused hands with prominent knuckles visible interacting with the scroll?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an ancient bamboo scroll with a deep amber hue and dark brown silk cords visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the right hand push the bamboo scroll to the right, revealing rows of ancient seal characters carved into the bamboo?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm, soft side lighting resembling candlelight that creates strong light and shadow contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036128980573266745 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628612995147705 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036128980573266745, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036128980573266745, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09070475399494171, + 0.3346732556819916, + 0.0340755321085453, + 0.040040627121925354, + 0.06497320532798767, + 0.03458964079618454, + 0.27611467242240906, + 0.04685572162270546, + 0.01981046423316002, + 0.05816210061311722 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036128980573266745 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An immersive first-person perspective, tilted slightly downward, evokes the impression of being seated before a rustic, dark-wood desk. At the center of the frame, a pair of weathered, calloused hands delicately interact with an ancient bamboo scroll. Their skin is dry, their knuckles prominent, and each deep line of their palms bears witness to the passage of time. The left hand firmly presses the scroll. The bamboo has a deep amber hue from age, its surface smooth and mellow from constant caressing. The dark brown silk cords binding the strips are slightly frayed at the edges. With the rough yet remarkably steady fingertips of the right hand, the bamboo scroll is gently and deliberately pushed to the right. As each section of the bamboo slide lies flat on the dark tabletop, a gentle, dry click echoes, revealing rows of ancient seal characters meticulously carved with a knife. The powerful strokes of these characters are deeply embedded in the texture of the bamboo. Under the warm and soft light that shines in from the side of the painting, like candlelight, a subtle contrast of light and shadow is created within the grooves of the characters, making each simple and solemn character full of three-dimensionality and a sense of historical weight. The entire scene is filled with warm colors, and the atmosphere is tranquil and focused, full of a reverence for knowledge and history.", + "seed": 20724, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_6/index_3230_seed_20724_dp_13_rank_26_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.04200937519781291, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04200937519781291, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.15, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04200937519781291, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a first-person perspective tilted slightly downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of weathered, calloused hands with prominent knuckles visible interacting with the scroll?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an ancient bamboo scroll with a deep amber hue and dark brown silk cords visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the right hand push the bamboo scroll to the right, revealing rows of ancient seal characters carved into the bamboo?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm, soft side lighting resembling candlelight that creates strong light and shadow contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.034132763743400574 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.034132957458496 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.034132763743400574, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.034132763743400574, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21717633306980133, + 0.16678877174854279, + 0.1217426061630249, + 0.06341218948364258, + 0.10622545331716537, + 0.06137003377079964, + 0.042327266186475754, + 0.030744215473532677, + 0.10644432157278061, + 0.08376885205507278 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.034132763743400574 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a first-person perspective tilted slightly downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of weathered, calloused hands with prominent knuckles visible interacting with the scroll?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an ancient bamboo scroll with a deep amber hue and dark brown silk cords visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the right hand push the bamboo scroll to the right, revealing rows of ancient seal characters carved into the bamboo?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm, soft side lighting resembling candlelight that creates strong light and shadow contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10034482926130295 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3503448963165283 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10034482926130295, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10034482926130295, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18264971673488617, + 0.21274179220199585, + 0.1173432320356369, + 0.1253034472465515, + 0.08957250416278839, + 0.034553349018096924, + 0.026702463626861572, + 0.05289062112569809, + 0.09680739790201187, + 0.061435479670763016 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10034482926130295 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a first-person perspective tilted slightly downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of weathered, calloused hands with prominent knuckles visible interacting with the scroll?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an ancient bamboo scroll with a deep amber hue and dark brown silk cords visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the right hand push the bamboo scroll to the right, revealing rows of ancient seal characters carved into the bamboo?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm, soft side lighting resembling candlelight that creates strong light and shadow contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036170552484691143 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628617286682129 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036170552484691143, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036170552484691143, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16953738033771515, + 0.1765517145395279, + 0.12132260203361511, + 0.19689439237117767, + 0.0505579449236393, + 0.049843352288007736, + 0.02489415928721428, + 0.030430708080530167, + 0.07192055135965347, + 0.10804718732833862 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036170552484691143 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a first-person perspective tilted slightly downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of weathered, calloused hands with prominent knuckles visible interacting with the scroll?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an ancient bamboo scroll with a deep amber hue and dark brown silk cords visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the right hand push the bamboo scroll to the right, revealing rows of ancient seal characters carved into the bamboo?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm, soft side lighting resembling candlelight that creates strong light and shadow contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07001326233148575 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950132846832275 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07001326233148575, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07001326233148575, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12966956198215485, + 0.1547662615776062, + 0.06572168320417404, + 0.06780504435300827, + 0.05004862695932388, + 0.0887717679142952, + 0.042724236845970154, + 0.10913754999637604, + 0.1028200089931488, + 0.18853527307510376 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07001326233148575 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a first-person perspective tilted slightly downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of weathered, calloused hands with prominent knuckles visible interacting with the scroll?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an ancient bamboo scroll with a deep amber hue and dark brown silk cords visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the right hand push the bamboo scroll to the right, revealing rows of ancient seal characters carved into the bamboo?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm, soft side lighting resembling candlelight that creates strong light and shadow contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00193896540440619 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.251938819885254 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00193896540440619, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00193896540440619, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06238105520606041, + 0.13416506350040436, + 0.1428636610507965, + 0.24116793274879456, + 0.10877227038145065, + 0.08615633845329285, + 0.06945773959159851, + 0.02591622993350029, + 0.043743688613176346, + 0.08537600934505463 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00193896540440619 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An immersive first-person perspective, tilted slightly downward, evokes the impression of being seated before a rustic, dark-wood desk. At the center of the frame, a pair of weathered, calloused hands delicately interact with an ancient bamboo scroll. Their skin is dry, their knuckles prominent, and each deep line of their palms bears witness to the passage of time. The left hand firmly presses the scroll. The bamboo has a deep amber hue from age, its surface smooth and mellow from constant caressing. The dark brown silk cords binding the strips are slightly frayed at the edges. With the rough yet remarkably steady fingertips of the right hand, the bamboo scroll is gently and deliberately pushed to the right. As each section of the bamboo slide lies flat on the dark tabletop, a gentle, dry click echoes, revealing rows of ancient seal characters meticulously carved with a knife. The powerful strokes of these characters are deeply embedded in the texture of the bamboo. Under the warm and soft light that shines in from the side of the painting, like candlelight, a subtle contrast of light and shadow is created within the grooves of the characters, making each simple and solemn character full of three-dimensionality and a sense of historical weight. The entire scene is filled with warm colors, and the atmosphere is tranquil and focused, full of a reverence for knowledge and history.", + "seed": 20725, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_6/index_3230_seed_20725_dp_13_rank_26_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.01936009875498712, + "vlm_logprob": -0.01936009875498712, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.75, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.01936009875498712, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a first-person perspective tilted slightly downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of weathered, calloused hands with prominent knuckles visible interacting with the scroll?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an ancient bamboo scroll with a deep amber hue and dark brown silk cords visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the right hand push the bamboo scroll to the right, revealing rows of ancient seal characters carved into the bamboo?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm, soft side lighting resembling candlelight that creates strong light and shadow contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02676050364971161 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.776760578155518 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02676050364971161, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02676050364971161, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14330703020095825, + 0.11008644104003906, + 0.07521510124206543, + 0.10506860166788101, + 0.05176796391606331, + 0.04792853072285652, + 0.23957224190235138, + 0.05324672535061836, + 0.058428045362234116, + 0.11537932604551315 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02676050364971161 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a first-person perspective tilted slightly downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of weathered, calloused hands with prominent knuckles visible interacting with the scroll?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an ancient bamboo scroll with a deep amber hue and dark brown silk cords visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the right hand push the bamboo scroll to the right, revealing rows of ancient seal characters carved into the bamboo?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm, soft side lighting resembling candlelight that creates strong light and shadow contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016088545322418213 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141088485717773 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016088545322418213, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016088545322418213, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08021926134824753, + 0.1529880315065384, + 0.03711550310254097, + 0.04852025955915451, + 0.0925498902797699, + 0.0266810804605484, + 0.4024564325809479, + 0.04803936555981636, + 0.029461033642292023, + 0.08196909725666046 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016088545322418213 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a first-person perspective tilted slightly downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of weathered, calloused hands with prominent knuckles visible interacting with the scroll?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an ancient bamboo scroll with a deep amber hue and dark brown silk cords visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the right hand push the bamboo scroll to the right, revealing rows of ancient seal characters carved into the bamboo?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm, soft side lighting resembling candlelight that creates strong light and shadow contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002490278100594878 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002490043640137 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002490278100594878, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002490278100594878, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06316971033811569, + 0.0826617181301117, + 0.09434497356414795, + 0.10019543021917343, + 0.03977276384830475, + 0.02630377560853958, + 0.3511572778224945, + 0.05385879427194595, + 0.06579625606536865, + 0.12273932248353958 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002490278100594878 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a first-person perspective tilted slightly downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of weathered, calloused hands with prominent knuckles visible interacting with the scroll?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an ancient bamboo scroll with a deep amber hue and dark brown silk cords visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the right hand push the bamboo scroll to the right, revealing rows of ancient seal characters carved into the bamboo?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm, soft side lighting resembling candlelight that creates strong light and shadow contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04864523932337761 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048645257949829 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04864523932337761, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04864523932337761, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11811748892068863, + 0.04840466380119324, + 0.06664980947971344, + 0.03476492315530777, + 0.07297277450561523, + 0.028853055089712143, + 0.3197154402732849, + 0.031706955283880234, + 0.15626801550388336, + 0.12254688888788223 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04864523932337761 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a first-person perspective tilted slightly downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of weathered, calloused hands with prominent knuckles visible interacting with the scroll?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an ancient bamboo scroll with a deep amber hue and dark brown silk cords visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the right hand push the bamboo scroll to the right, revealing rows of ancient seal characters carved into the bamboo?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm, soft side lighting resembling candlelight that creates strong light and shadow contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002815927378833294 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.8778157234191895 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002815927378833294, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002815927378833294, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10012135654687881, + 0.09467745572328568, + 0.08539476245641708, + 0.141525998711586, + 0.11471987515687943, + 0.037940479815006256, + 0.1969909369945526, + 0.08561527729034424, + 0.05540591850876808, + 0.08760789781808853 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002815927378833294 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_7/index_tensor([1597, 1597])_group_7_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_7/index_tensor([1597, 1597])_group_7_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..e0cc7d186e7f589d3bd32be2d9cc2825b7a5b1a7 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_7/index_tensor([1597, 1597])_group_7_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "slow-motion close-up, the camera starting at eye level and tilting downward, captures a plump red apple, perched precariously on the edge of a classic wooden desk. Bright, warm sunlight pours in through a large classroom window, illuminating the desk's warm oak grain and the subtle scratches of time, stirring up dust clouds in a golden shaft of light. The apple boasts a vibrant red skin, its smooth, waxy surface reflecting a single, dazzling highlight, topped by a short, dry, brown stem. With a barely perceptible jolt, it begins a slow, inexorable roll, its curves shimmering in the light, before gracefully clearing the desk's sharp, right-angled edge and beginning its brief, silent descent to the floor below. The warm tones of the image create a tranquil, nostalgic atmosphere. Rows of desks are faintly visible in the soft-focus background, creating a momentary aesthetic, as if frozen in time.", + "seed": 20890, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_7/index_1597_seed_20890_dp_14_rank_28_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.05140681061893702, + "vlm_logprob": -0.05140681061893702, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.3, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.05140681061893702, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a slow-motion close-up of a plump red apple?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the apple perched on the edge of a classic wooden desk with visible oak grain and scratches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does bright warm sunlight stream through a large classroom window, illuminating dust clouds in a golden shaft?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the apple roll slowly off the sharp right-angled edge of the desk and begin a descent to the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera starting at eye level and tilting downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023067114874720573 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.898066997528076 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023067114874720573, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023067114874720573, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21695594489574432, + 0.04519602656364441, + 0.057854581624269485, + 0.11787763983011246, + 0.026258863508701324, + 0.18340060114860535, + 0.04491938278079033, + 0.08450981229543686, + 0.10461892187595367, + 0.11840815097093582 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023067114874720573 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a slow-motion close-up of a plump red apple?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the apple perched on the edge of a classic wooden desk with visible oak grain and scratches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does bright warm sunlight stream through a large classroom window, illuminating dust clouds in a golden shaft?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the apple roll slowly off the sharp right-angled edge of the desk and begin a descent to the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera starting at eye level and tilting downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12710432708263397 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1271042823791504 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12710432708263397, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12710432708263397, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06820381432771683, + 0.06403043121099472, + 0.10112980008125305, + 0.17093579471111298, + 0.09987498819828033, + 0.15248970687389374, + 0.04704543948173523, + 0.1211676374077797, + 0.06954662501811981, + 0.10557571053504944 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12710432708263397 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a slow-motion close-up of a plump red apple?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the apple perched on the edge of a classic wooden desk with visible oak grain and scratches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does bright warm sunlight stream through a large classroom window, illuminating dust clouds in a golden shaft?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the apple roll slowly off the sharp right-angled edge of the desk and begin a descent to the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera starting at eye level and tilting downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03374696895480156 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4087469577789307 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03374696895480156, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03374696895480156, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07227866351604462, + 0.10051035135984421, + 0.17178820073604584, + 0.06467341631650925, + 0.06683747470378876, + 0.05877649411559105, + 0.16542334854602814, + 0.13874386250972748, + 0.09232145547866821, + 0.06864673644304276 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03374696895480156 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a slow-motion close-up of a plump red apple?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the apple perched on the edge of a classic wooden desk with visible oak grain and scratches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does bright warm sunlight stream through a large classroom window, illuminating dust clouds in a golden shaft?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the apple roll slowly off the sharp right-angled edge of the desk and begin a descent to the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera starting at eye level and tilting downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0110772168263793 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511077404022217 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0110772168263793, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0110772168263793, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07316383719444275, + 0.04292360320687294, + 0.04315399006009102, + 0.05544969439506531, + 0.026654789224267006, + 0.14126789569854736, + 0.16489830613136292, + 0.17422841489315033, + 0.23373836278915405, + 0.044521067291498184 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0110772168263793 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a slow-motion close-up of a plump red apple?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the apple perched on the edge of a classic wooden desk with visible oak grain and scratches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does bright warm sunlight stream through a large classroom window, illuminating dust clouds in a golden shaft?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the apple roll slowly off the sharp right-angled edge of the desk and begin a descent to the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera starting at eye level and tilting downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06203842535614967 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120384216308594 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06203842535614967, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06203842535614967, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08248802274465561, + 0.03268454223871231, + 0.01950516365468502, + 0.04293743148446083, + 0.03734750300645828, + 0.046337977051734924, + 0.14892438054084778, + 0.24373124539852142, + 0.2999337613582611, + 0.04610997810959816 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06203842535614967 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow-motion close-up, the camera starting at eye level and tilting downward, captures a plump red apple, perched precariously on the edge of a classic wooden desk. Bright, warm sunlight pours in through a large classroom window, illuminating the desk's warm oak grain and the subtle scratches of time, stirring up dust clouds in a golden shaft of light. The apple boasts a vibrant red skin, its smooth, waxy surface reflecting a single, dazzling highlight, topped by a short, dry, brown stem. With a barely perceptible jolt, it begins a slow, inexorable roll, its curves shimmering in the light, before gracefully clearing the desk's sharp, right-angled edge and beginning its brief, silent descent to the floor below. The warm tones of the image create a tranquil, nostalgic atmosphere. Rows of desks are faintly visible in the soft-focus background, creating a momentary aesthetic, as if frozen in time.", + "seed": 20891, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_7/index_1597_seed_20891_dp_14_rank_28_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.05869721695780754, + "vlm_logprob": -0.05869721695780754, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.274999976158142, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.05869721695780754, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a slow-motion close-up of a plump red apple?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the apple perched on the edge of a classic wooden desk with visible oak grain and scratches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does bright warm sunlight stream through a large classroom window, illuminating dust clouds in a golden shaft?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the apple roll slowly off the sharp right-angled edge of the desk and begin a descent to the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera starting at eye level and tilting downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01590811088681221 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.265908241271973 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01590811088681221, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01590811088681221, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.047601643949747086, + 0.02694418467581272, + 0.08419761806726456, + 0.0320575051009655, + 0.03012978471815586, + 0.05863839015364647, + 0.0663628801703453, + 0.3533041775226593, + 0.2673853635787964, + 0.0333784818649292 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01590811088681221 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a slow-motion close-up of a plump red apple?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the apple perched on the edge of a classic wooden desk with visible oak grain and scratches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does bright warm sunlight stream through a large classroom window, illuminating dust clouds in a golden shaft?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the apple roll slowly off the sharp right-angled edge of the desk and begin a descent to the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera starting at eye level and tilting downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11302157491445541 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2380216121673584 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11302157491445541, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11302157491445541, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09030365943908691, + 0.04529537260532379, + 0.07040935754776001, + 0.05431078374385834, + 0.040048133581876755, + 0.03089711256325245, + 0.043355103582143784, + 0.2141730785369873, + 0.36235401034355164, + 0.048853375017642975 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11302157491445541 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a slow-motion close-up of a plump red apple?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the apple perched on the edge of a classic wooden desk with visible oak grain and scratches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does bright warm sunlight stream through a large classroom window, illuminating dust clouds in a golden shaft?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the apple roll slowly off the sharp right-angled edge of the desk and begin a descent to the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera starting at eye level and tilting downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023322314023971558 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773322343826294 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023322314023971558, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023322314023971558, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10787765681743622, + 0.06378959864377975, + 0.11781556159257889, + 0.04933646321296692, + 0.02120642177760601, + 0.05279204994440079, + 0.05972985923290253, + 0.38589707016944885, + 0.08814921230077744, + 0.05340614914894104 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023322314023971558 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a slow-motion close-up of a plump red apple?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the apple perched on the edge of a classic wooden desk with visible oak grain and scratches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does bright warm sunlight stream through a large classroom window, illuminating dust clouds in a golden shaft?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the apple roll slowly off the sharp right-angled edge of the desk and begin a descent to the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera starting at eye level and tilting downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014197885990142822 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264197826385498 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014197885990142822, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014197885990142822, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04376855865120888, + 0.031109854578971863, + 0.08149106055498123, + 0.0187308918684721, + 0.03185366839170456, + 0.08180733025074005, + 0.23154433071613312, + 0.33691293001174927, + 0.10474862903356552, + 0.03803268447518349 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014197885990142822 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a slow-motion close-up of a plump red apple?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the apple perched on the edge of a classic wooden desk with visible oak grain and scratches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does bright warm sunlight stream through a large classroom window, illuminating dust clouds in a golden shaft?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the apple roll slowly off the sharp right-angled edge of the desk and begin a descent to the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera starting at eye level and tilting downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1270361989736557 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1270360946655273 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1270361989736557, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.9999998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1270361989736557, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0673762857913971, + 0.0166233628988266, + 0.01538860984146595, + 0.02973177656531334, + 0.014244228601455688, + 0.02087363414466381, + 0.08006315678358078, + 0.6794299483299255, + 0.04208608716726303, + 0.03418290242552757 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1270361989736557 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow-motion close-up, the camera starting at eye level and tilting downward, captures a plump red apple, perched precariously on the edge of a classic wooden desk. Bright, warm sunlight pours in through a large classroom window, illuminating the desk's warm oak grain and the subtle scratches of time, stirring up dust clouds in a golden shaft of light. The apple boasts a vibrant red skin, its smooth, waxy surface reflecting a single, dazzling highlight, topped by a short, dry, brown stem. With a barely perceptible jolt, it begins a slow, inexorable roll, its curves shimmering in the light, before gracefully clearing the desk's sharp, right-angled edge and beginning its brief, silent descent to the floor below. The warm tones of the image create a tranquil, nostalgic atmosphere. Rows of desks are faintly visible in the soft-focus background, creating a momentary aesthetic, as if frozen in time.", + "seed": 20892, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_7/index_1597_seed_20892_dp_15_rank_30_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.05419799592345953, + "vlm_logprob": -0.05419799592345953, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.274999976158142, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.05419799592345953, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a slow-motion close-up of a plump red apple?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the apple perched on the edge of a classic wooden desk with visible oak grain and scratches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does bright warm sunlight stream through a large classroom window, illuminating dust clouds in a golden shaft?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the apple roll slowly off the sharp right-angled edge of the desk and begin a descent to the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera starting at eye level and tilting downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014260291121900082 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.389260292053223 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014260291121900082, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014260291121900082, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.016529854387044907, + 0.009738890454173088, + 0.020726516842842102, + 0.01646127551794052, + 0.006228276062756777, + 0.011017237789928913, + 0.8224966526031494, + 0.025105882436037064, + 0.031863320618867874, + 0.03983210399746895 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014260291121900082 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a slow-motion close-up of a plump red apple?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the apple perched on the edge of a classic wooden desk with visible oak grain and scratches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does bright warm sunlight stream through a large classroom window, illuminating dust clouds in a golden shaft?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the apple roll slowly off the sharp right-angled edge of the desk and begin a descent to the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera starting at eye level and tilting downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05501071363687515 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9300107955932617 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05501071363687515, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05501071363687515, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.034974921494722366, + 0.027149202302098274, + 0.034569062292575836, + 0.03293347731232643, + 0.0336177833378315, + 0.012370724231004715, + 0.5624434351921082, + 0.031007684767246246, + 0.12109140306711197, + 0.10984233766794205 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05501071363687515 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a slow-motion close-up of a plump red apple?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the apple perched on the edge of a classic wooden desk with visible oak grain and scratches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does bright warm sunlight stream through a large classroom window, illuminating dust clouds in a golden shaft?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the apple roll slowly off the sharp right-angled edge of the desk and begin a descent to the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera starting at eye level and tilting downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.062127940356731415 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8121278285980225 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.062127940356731415, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.062127940356731415, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.011167335323989391, + 0.014649293385446072, + 0.048205964267253876, + 0.005567186512053013, + 0.004243363626301289, + 0.008633541874587536, + 0.6243588328361511, + 0.02997928485274315, + 0.03859123960137367, + 0.2146039456129074 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.062127940356731415 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a slow-motion close-up of a plump red apple?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the apple perched on the edge of a classic wooden desk with visible oak grain and scratches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does bright warm sunlight stream through a large classroom window, illuminating dust clouds in a golden shaft?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the apple roll slowly off the sharp right-angled edge of the desk and begin a descent to the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera starting at eye level and tilting downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012540768831968307 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387540817260742 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012540768831968307, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012540768831968307, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.011941961944103241, + 0.007636878173798323, + 0.011873675510287285, + 0.006986151449382305, + 0.006981353275477886, + 0.02408374473452568, + 0.672635555267334, + 0.05378906801342964, + 0.16146793961524963, + 0.042603664100170135 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012540768831968307 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a slow-motion close-up of a plump red apple?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the apple perched on the edge of a classic wooden desk with visible oak grain and scratches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does bright warm sunlight stream through a large classroom window, illuminating dust clouds in a golden shaft?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the apple roll slowly off the sharp right-angled edge of the desk and begin a descent to the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera starting at eye level and tilting downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1270502656698227 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1270501613616943 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1270502656698227, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.9999998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1270502656698227, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.010531419888138771, + 0.008087747730314732, + 0.008105962537229061, + 0.007677493616938591, + 0.004992167465388775, + 0.012423457577824593, + 0.739501953125, + 0.0242147333920002, + 0.13843680918216705, + 0.04602815583348274 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1270502656698227 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow-motion close-up, the camera starting at eye level and tilting downward, captures a plump red apple, perched precariously on the edge of a classic wooden desk. Bright, warm sunlight pours in through a large classroom window, illuminating the desk's warm oak grain and the subtle scratches of time, stirring up dust clouds in a golden shaft of light. The apple boasts a vibrant red skin, its smooth, waxy surface reflecting a single, dazzling highlight, topped by a short, dry, brown stem. With a barely perceptible jolt, it begins a slow, inexorable roll, its curves shimmering in the light, before gracefully clearing the desk's sharp, right-angled edge and beginning its brief, silent descent to the floor below. The warm tones of the image create a tranquil, nostalgic atmosphere. Rows of desks are faintly visible in the soft-focus background, creating a momentary aesthetic, as if frozen in time.", + "seed": 20893, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_7/index_1597_seed_20893_dp_15_rank_30_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.025968425162136554, + "vlm_logprob": -0.025968425162136554, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.775, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.025968425162136554, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a slow-motion close-up of a plump red apple?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the apple perched on the edge of a classic wooden desk with visible oak grain and scratches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does bright warm sunlight stream through a large classroom window, illuminating dust clouds in a golden shaft?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the apple roll slowly off the sharp right-angled edge of the desk and begin a descent to the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera starting at eye level and tilting downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.019519738852977753 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.019519805908203 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.019519738852977753, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.019519738852977753, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13401605188846588, + 0.08938268572092056, + 0.06772766262292862, + 0.0666346475481987, + 0.0857725590467453, + 0.07153727859258652, + 0.12273009121417999, + 0.18023237586021423, + 0.08159860223531723, + 0.10036805272102356 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.019519738852977753 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a slow-motion close-up of a plump red apple?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the apple perched on the edge of a classic wooden desk with visible oak grain and scratches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does bright warm sunlight stream through a large classroom window, illuminating dust clouds in a golden shaft?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the apple roll slowly off the sharp right-angled edge of the desk and begin a descent to the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera starting at eye level and tilting downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029839398339390755 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529839515686035 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029839398339390755, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029839398339390755, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12508608400821686, + 0.12443012744188309, + 0.09429369866847992, + 0.05852062627673149, + 0.06313589215278625, + 0.14663098752498627, + 0.08927185833454132, + 0.1416752189397812, + 0.04765787348151207, + 0.10929770767688751 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029839398339390755 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a slow-motion close-up of a plump red apple?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the apple perched on the edge of a classic wooden desk with visible oak grain and scratches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does bright warm sunlight stream through a large classroom window, illuminating dust clouds in a golden shaft?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the apple roll slowly off the sharp right-angled edge of the desk and begin a descent to the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera starting at eye level and tilting downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0381493978202343 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288149356842041 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0381493978202343, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0381493978202343, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12134736031293869, + 0.3305692970752716, + 0.23062294721603394, + 0.046597208827733994, + 0.01805267296731472, + 0.04610319435596466, + 0.05761648342013359, + 0.05251153185963631, + 0.03812140226364136, + 0.05845785140991211 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0381493978202343 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a slow-motion close-up of a plump red apple?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the apple perched on the edge of a classic wooden desk with visible oak grain and scratches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does bright warm sunlight stream through a large classroom window, illuminating dust clouds in a golden shaft?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the apple roll slowly off the sharp right-angled edge of the desk and begin a descent to the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera starting at eye level and tilting downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008637449704110622 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758637428283691 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008637449704110622, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008637449704110622, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08875364065170288, + 0.04469708725810051, + 0.12754647433757782, + 0.05190826207399368, + 0.04140651226043701, + 0.08027946203947067, + 0.11503351479768753, + 0.10391831398010254, + 0.23279984295368195, + 0.11365686357021332 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 2, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008637449704110622 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a slow-motion close-up of a plump red apple?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the apple perched on the edge of a classic wooden desk with visible oak grain and scratches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does bright warm sunlight stream through a large classroom window, illuminating dust clouds in a golden shaft?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the apple roll slowly off the sharp right-angled edge of the desk and begin a descent to the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera starting at eye level and tilting downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.033696141093969345 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408696174621582 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.033696141093969345, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.033696141093969345, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05153025686740875, + 0.04508346691727638, + 0.06445822864770889, + 0.019477413967251778, + 0.0917649194598198, + 0.05861487239599228, + 0.11630995571613312, + 0.1559189260005951, + 0.18955197930335999, + 0.20728997886180878 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.033696141093969345 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_8/index_tensor([5039, 5039])_group_8_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_8/index_tensor([5039, 5039])_group_8_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..e8e0a62c01421ce1deea453eb02d5fded55501ab --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_8/index_tensor([5039, 5039])_group_8_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "wide-angle drone shot, panning slowly to the left, captures a bottomless chasm between two steep, rock-crusted gray peaks. A taut steel cable, like a thin silver thread, stretches across the void, gleaming faintly in the harsh light of the sky. Atop this cable, a muscular acrobat in a tight black tracksuit, rides a minimalist, ultra-lightweight climbing bike. Its frame is made of matte carbon fiber, devoid of any frills or gears. His face is a look of intense concentration, his brow furrowed, his lips pursed. His body constantly makes subtle, almost imperceptible adjustments, his arms slightly outstretched for balance. He pedals carefully, steadily, and deliberately, the bike's thin tires pressing precisely against the narrow cable. Every inch of progress is filled with a breathtaking tension. The entire picture adopts a high-contrast, low-saturation black and white color scheme, which infinitely magnifies the rough texture of the mountains and the pale emptiness of the sky. The thin clouds floating below further highlight the dizzying height, creating an extreme, lonely and powerful tranquil atmosphere.", + "seed": 2614, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_8/index_5039_seed_2614_dp_16_rank_32_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.11494955690577627, + "vlm_logprob": -0.11494955690577627, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.3, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.11494955690577627, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a wide-angle view panning slowly to the left?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a bottomless chasm between two steep, rock-crusted gray peaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a muscular acrobat wearing a tight black tracksuit riding a minimalist climbing bike on a taut steel cable?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a high-contrast, low-saturation black and white color scheme?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the acrobat's face showing intense concentration with a furrowed brow and pursed lips?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2932801842689514 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4182801246643066 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2932801842689514, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2932801842689514, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15717920660972595, + 0.07442043721675873, + 0.04235915094614029, + 0.02513577602803707, + 0.05261470377445221, + 0.036178238689899445, + 0.053990308195352554, + 0.4204349219799042, + 0.04581586644053459, + 0.09187144786119461 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2932801842689514 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a wide-angle view panning slowly to the left?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a bottomless chasm between two steep, rock-crusted gray peaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a muscular acrobat wearing a tight black tracksuit riding a minimalist climbing bike on a taut steel cable?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a high-contrast, low-saturation black and white color scheme?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the acrobat's face showing intense concentration with a furrowed brow and pursed lips?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014237492345273495 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264237403869629 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014237492345273495, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014237492345273495, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1882523000240326, + 0.05554705485701561, + 0.033686961978673935, + 0.03476514667272568, + 0.14664989709854126, + 0.025763776153326035, + 0.02870640531182289, + 0.11937632411718369, + 0.12120197713375092, + 0.246050164103508 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014237492345273495 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a wide-angle view panning slowly to the left?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a bottomless chasm between two steep, rock-crusted gray peaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a muscular acrobat wearing a tight black tracksuit riding a minimalist climbing bike on a taut steel cable?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a high-contrast, low-saturation black and white color scheme?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the acrobat's face showing intense concentration with a furrowed brow and pursed lips?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009792031720280647 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634791851043701 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009792031720280647, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009792031720280647, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12455450743436813, + 0.034803856164216995, + 0.03713052347302437, + 0.051308006048202515, + 0.09788663685321808, + 0.05202452465891838, + 0.0341634638607502, + 0.21125569939613342, + 0.1121845543384552, + 0.2446882575750351 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009792031720280647 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a wide-angle view panning slowly to the left?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a bottomless chasm between two steep, rock-crusted gray peaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a muscular acrobat wearing a tight black tracksuit riding a minimalist climbing bike on a taut steel cable?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a high-contrast, low-saturation black and white color scheme?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the acrobat's face showing intense concentration with a furrowed brow and pursed lips?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005257589276880026 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255257606506348 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005257589276880026, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005257589276880026, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16887134313583374, + 0.02924545854330063, + 0.01302745658904314, + 0.03049960546195507, + 0.032254256308078766, + 0.016395438462495804, + 0.029645955190062523, + 0.4743368923664093, + 0.029924018308520317, + 0.1757996380329132 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005257589276880026 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a wide-angle view panning slowly to the left?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a bottomless chasm between two steep, rock-crusted gray peaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a muscular acrobat wearing a tight black tracksuit riding a minimalist climbing bike on a taut steel cable?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a high-contrast, low-saturation black and white color scheme?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the acrobat's face showing intense concentration with a furrowed brow and pursed lips?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2521804869174957 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5021804571151733 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2521804869174957, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2521804869174957, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0536813847720623, + 0.02897409349679947, + 0.030416326597332954, + 0.041612714529037476, + 0.08765552192926407, + 0.0593474917113781, + 0.07944049686193466, + 0.4922041893005371, + 0.05612438917160034, + 0.07054334133863449 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2521804869174957 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "wide-angle drone shot, panning slowly to the left, captures a bottomless chasm between two steep, rock-crusted gray peaks. A taut steel cable, like a thin silver thread, stretches across the void, gleaming faintly in the harsh light of the sky. Atop this cable, a muscular acrobat in a tight black tracksuit, rides a minimalist, ultra-lightweight climbing bike. Its frame is made of matte carbon fiber, devoid of any frills or gears. His face is a look of intense concentration, his brow furrowed, his lips pursed. His body constantly makes subtle, almost imperceptible adjustments, his arms slightly outstretched for balance. He pedals carefully, steadily, and deliberately, the bike's thin tires pressing precisely against the narrow cable. Every inch of progress is filled with a breathtaking tension. The entire picture adopts a high-contrast, low-saturation black and white color scheme, which infinitely magnifies the rough texture of the mountains and the pale emptiness of the sky. The thin clouds floating below further highlight the dizzying height, creating an extreme, lonely and powerful tranquil atmosphere.", + "seed": 2615, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_8/index_5039_seed_2615_dp_16_rank_32_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.13864351119846105, + "vlm_logprob": -0.13864351119846105, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.025000011920929, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.13864351119846105, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a wide-angle view panning slowly to the left?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a bottomless chasm between two steep, rock-crusted gray peaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a muscular acrobat wearing a tight black tracksuit riding a minimalist climbing bike on a taut steel cable?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a high-contrast, low-saturation black and white color scheme?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the acrobat's face showing intense concentration with a furrowed brow and pursed lips?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.262505441904068 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5125054121017456 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.262505441904068, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.262505441904068, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12691175937652588, + 0.0947023257613182, + 0.08919867873191833, + 0.06709858030080795, + 0.12137982994318008, + 0.15348683297634125, + 0.16019418835639954, + 0.08522215485572815, + 0.06385698169469833, + 0.03794867545366287 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.262505441904068 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a wide-angle view panning slowly to the left?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a bottomless chasm between two steep, rock-crusted gray peaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a muscular acrobat wearing a tight black tracksuit riding a minimalist climbing bike on a taut steel cable?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a high-contrast, low-saturation black and white color scheme?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the acrobat's face showing intense concentration with a furrowed brow and pursed lips?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023333260789513588 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7733333110809326 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023333260789513588, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023333260789513588, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15491077303886414, + 0.17461027204990387, + 0.09527613967657089, + 0.08153561502695084, + 0.10256310552358627, + 0.03836556151509285, + 0.06416117399930954, + 0.09231103956699371, + 0.09415469318628311, + 0.10211162269115448 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023333260789513588 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a wide-angle view panning slowly to the left?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a bottomless chasm between two steep, rock-crusted gray peaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a muscular acrobat wearing a tight black tracksuit riding a minimalist climbing bike on a taut steel cable?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a high-contrast, low-saturation black and white color scheme?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the acrobat's face showing intense concentration with a furrowed brow and pursed lips?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014208698645234108 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264208793640137 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014208698645234108, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014208698645234108, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18227747082710266, + 0.06743714958429337, + 0.08522673696279526, + 0.0814322680234909, + 0.11381274461746216, + 0.08981231600046158, + 0.05279490351676941, + 0.16153748333454132, + 0.10068816691637039, + 0.06498082727193832 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014208698645234108 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a wide-angle view panning slowly to the left?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a bottomless chasm between two steep, rock-crusted gray peaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a muscular acrobat wearing a tight black tracksuit riding a minimalist climbing bike on a taut steel cable?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a high-contrast, low-saturation black and white color scheme?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the acrobat's face showing intense concentration with a furrowed brow and pursed lips?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005958176217973232 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130958080291748 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005958176217973232, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005958176217973232, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14865601062774658, + 0.04478191211819649, + 0.08489317446947098, + 0.07117775827646255, + 0.32292288541793823, + 0.05972994118928909, + 0.07519696652889252, + 0.09097964316606522, + 0.034466326236724854, + 0.0671953484416008 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005958176217973232 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a wide-angle view panning slowly to the left?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a bottomless chasm between two steep, rock-crusted gray peaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a muscular acrobat wearing a tight black tracksuit riding a minimalist climbing bike on a taut steel cable?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a high-contrast, low-saturation black and white color scheme?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the acrobat's face showing intense concentration with a furrowed brow and pursed lips?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.38721197843551636 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1372120380401611 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.38721197843551636, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.7500000596046448, + "token_credit_reward": -0.38721197843551636, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2359752357006073, + 0.045967306941747665, + 0.04148354381322861, + 0.043007999658584595, + 0.1444358378648758, + 0.04106089472770691, + 0.03117336332798004, + 0.05867273360490799, + 0.23638927936553955, + 0.12183378636837006 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.38721197843551636 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "wide-angle drone shot, panning slowly to the left, captures a bottomless chasm between two steep, rock-crusted gray peaks. A taut steel cable, like a thin silver thread, stretches across the void, gleaming faintly in the harsh light of the sky. Atop this cable, a muscular acrobat in a tight black tracksuit, rides a minimalist, ultra-lightweight climbing bike. Its frame is made of matte carbon fiber, devoid of any frills or gears. His face is a look of intense concentration, his brow furrowed, his lips pursed. His body constantly makes subtle, almost imperceptible adjustments, his arms slightly outstretched for balance. He pedals carefully, steadily, and deliberately, the bike's thin tires pressing precisely against the narrow cable. Every inch of progress is filled with a breathtaking tension. The entire picture adopts a high-contrast, low-saturation black and white color scheme, which infinitely magnifies the rough texture of the mountains and the pale emptiness of the sky. The thin clouds floating below further highlight the dizzying height, creating an extreme, lonely and powerful tranquil atmosphere.", + "seed": 2616, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_8/index_5039_seed_2616_dp_17_rank_34_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.13359491038136184, + "vlm_logprob": -0.13359491038136184, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.075, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.13359491038136184, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a wide-angle view panning slowly to the left?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a bottomless chasm between two steep, rock-crusted gray peaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a muscular acrobat wearing a tight black tracksuit riding a minimalist climbing bike on a taut steel cable?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a high-contrast, low-saturation black and white color scheme?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the acrobat's face showing intense concentration with a furrowed brow and pursed lips?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.21735279262065887 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7173527479171753 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.21735279262065887, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.21735279262065887, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.025193259119987488, + 0.017776714637875557, + 0.07515904307365417, + 0.06815642863512039, + 0.6069339513778687, + 0.09953544288873672, + 0.08068615198135376, + 0.013741163536906242, + 0.0077939508482813835, + 0.005023866891860962 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.21735279262065887 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a wide-angle view panning slowly to the left?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a bottomless chasm between two steep, rock-crusted gray peaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a muscular acrobat wearing a tight black tracksuit riding a minimalist climbing bike on a taut steel cable?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a high-contrast, low-saturation black and white color scheme?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the acrobat's face showing intense concentration with a furrowed brow and pursed lips?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04869474843144417 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486948490142822 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04869474843144417, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04869474843144417, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07577910274267197, + 0.05489664897322655, + 0.08447040617465973, + 0.20928995311260223, + 0.35004276037216187, + 0.144731804728508, + 0.030936159193515778, + 0.018847860395908356, + 0.008274382911622524, + 0.022730879485607147 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04869474843144417 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a wide-angle view panning slowly to the left?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a bottomless chasm between two steep, rock-crusted gray peaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a muscular acrobat wearing a tight black tracksuit riding a minimalist climbing bike on a taut steel cable?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a high-contrast, low-saturation black and white color scheme?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the acrobat's face showing intense concentration with a furrowed brow and pursed lips?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011087356135249138 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511087417602539 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011087356135249138, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011087356135249138, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.028056202456355095, + 0.03658709675073624, + 0.03257813677191734, + 0.04818354547023773, + 0.23633727431297302, + 0.5011019110679626, + 0.06160084158182144, + 0.01273269858211279, + 0.016458215191960335, + 0.026364117860794067 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011087356135249138 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a wide-angle view panning slowly to the left?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a bottomless chasm between two steep, rock-crusted gray peaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a muscular acrobat wearing a tight black tracksuit riding a minimalist climbing bike on a taut steel cable?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a high-contrast, low-saturation black and white color scheme?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the acrobat's face showing intense concentration with a furrowed brow and pursed lips?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036221628542989492 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628622055053711 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036221628542989492, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036221628542989492, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.02336503192782402, + 0.013980048708617687, + 0.017997119575738907, + 0.027979282662272453, + 0.7466498017311096, + 0.13152165710926056, + 0.02335367165505886, + 0.004956947639584541, + 0.0030906214378774166, + 0.007105755619704723 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036221628542989492 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a wide-angle view panning slowly to the left?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a bottomless chasm between two steep, rock-crusted gray peaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a muscular acrobat wearing a tight black tracksuit riding a minimalist climbing bike on a taut steel cable?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a high-contrast, low-saturation black and white color scheme?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the acrobat's face showing intense concentration with a furrowed brow and pursed lips?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3872174918651581 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1372175216674805 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3872174918651581, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3872174918651581, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05676879733800888, + 0.030876556411385536, + 0.04982490837574005, + 0.06569920480251312, + 0.09728970378637314, + 0.13545148074626923, + 0.3535833954811096, + 0.03144005313515663, + 0.03937751054763794, + 0.1396884322166443 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3872174918651581 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "wide-angle drone shot, panning slowly to the left, captures a bottomless chasm between two steep, rock-crusted gray peaks. A taut steel cable, like a thin silver thread, stretches across the void, gleaming faintly in the harsh light of the sky. Atop this cable, a muscular acrobat in a tight black tracksuit, rides a minimalist, ultra-lightweight climbing bike. Its frame is made of matte carbon fiber, devoid of any frills or gears. His face is a look of intense concentration, his brow furrowed, his lips pursed. His body constantly makes subtle, almost imperceptible adjustments, his arms slightly outstretched for balance. He pedals carefully, steadily, and deliberately, the bike's thin tires pressing precisely against the narrow cable. Every inch of progress is filled with a breathtaking tension. The entire picture adopts a high-contrast, low-saturation black and white color scheme, which infinitely magnifies the rough texture of the mountains and the pale emptiness of the sky. The thin clouds floating below further highlight the dizzying height, creating an extreme, lonely and powerful tranquil atmosphere.", + "seed": 2617, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_8/index_5039_seed_2617_dp_17_rank_34_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.07778037544339896, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07778037544339896, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.425, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07778037544339896, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a wide-angle view panning slowly to the left?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a bottomless chasm between two steep, rock-crusted gray peaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a muscular acrobat wearing a tight black tracksuit riding a minimalist climbing bike on a taut steel cable?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a high-contrast, low-saturation black and white color scheme?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the acrobat's face showing intense concentration with a furrowed brow and pursed lips?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12328635156154633 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.248286247253418 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12328635156154633, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12328635156154633, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2776373624801636, + 0.10043720155954361, + 0.07058315724134445, + 0.11170657724142075, + 0.06496483832597733, + 0.0831177830696106, + 0.07389632612466812, + 0.05305042490363121, + 0.1305587738752365, + 0.03404760733246803 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12328635156154633 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a wide-angle view panning slowly to the left?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a bottomless chasm between two steep, rock-crusted gray peaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a muscular acrobat wearing a tight black tracksuit riding a minimalist climbing bike on a taut steel cable?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a high-contrast, low-saturation black and white color scheme?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the acrobat's face showing intense concentration with a furrowed brow and pursed lips?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023323478177189827 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7733235359191895 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023323478177189827, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023323478177189827, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22981150448322296, + 0.09916450083255768, + 0.058201588690280914, + 0.05230154097080231, + 0.20097392797470093, + 0.05387140437960625, + 0.07679673284292221, + 0.03938493877649307, + 0.09681890904903412, + 0.09267496317625046 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023323478177189827 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a wide-angle view panning slowly to the left?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a bottomless chasm between two steep, rock-crusted gray peaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a muscular acrobat wearing a tight black tracksuit riding a minimalist climbing bike on a taut steel cable?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a high-contrast, low-saturation black and white color scheme?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the acrobat's face showing intense concentration with a furrowed brow and pursed lips?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012550539337098598 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387550354003906 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012550539337098598, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012550539337098598, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20634892582893372, + 0.049893755465745926, + 0.044310517609119415, + 0.06552482396364212, + 0.05301745980978012, + 0.10491582751274109, + 0.05788286775350571, + 0.05333978310227394, + 0.256020188331604, + 0.10874583572149277 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012550539337098598 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a wide-angle view panning slowly to the left?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a bottomless chasm between two steep, rock-crusted gray peaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a muscular acrobat wearing a tight black tracksuit riding a minimalist climbing bike on a taut steel cable?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a high-contrast, low-saturation black and white color scheme?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the acrobat's face showing intense concentration with a furrowed brow and pursed lips?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004098350182175636 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504098415374756 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004098350182175636, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004098350182175636, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2707599401473999, + 0.16108503937721252, + 0.035619985312223434, + 0.09123432636260986, + 0.07361439615488052, + 0.07336634397506714, + 0.044865481555461884, + 0.04019642248749733, + 0.1138947531580925, + 0.09536328911781311 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004098350182175636 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a wide-angle view panning slowly to the left?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a bottomless chasm between two steep, rock-crusted gray peaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a muscular acrobat wearing a tight black tracksuit riding a minimalist climbing bike on a taut steel cable?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a high-contrast, low-saturation black and white color scheme?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the acrobat's face showing intense concentration with a furrowed brow and pursed lips?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22564315795898438 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6006431579589844 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.22564315795898438, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.22564315795898438, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21456195414066315, + 0.09611169248819351, + 0.055883388966321945, + 0.036438487470149994, + 0.046855419874191284, + 0.053938720375299454, + 0.06390272825956345, + 0.03175139054656029, + 0.18193566799163818, + 0.21862058341503143 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.22564315795898438 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_9/index_tensor([8240, 8240])_group_9_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_9/index_tensor([8240, 8240])_group_9_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..6f3d417f427eddf11aa01c6f63d9fbe5d37b0b1f --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_9/index_tensor([8240, 8240])_group_9_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "sweeping aerial shot, captured from a slightly upward angle, smoothly follows a massive cyan dragon as it soars through a boundless, turbulent sea of clouds. Thick cumulonimbus clouds intertwine with wispy cirrus clouds, swirling violently under the dragon's turbulence, creating vast vortices and turbulent currents. Rays of golden rays penetrate the gaps between the clouds, casting magnificent pillars of light. The dragon's slender, sinuous body emanates a deep, vibrant cyan. Each scale, like meticulously crafted jade, gleams with an ever-changing iridescence in the sunlight, its edges tinged with a faint golden halo. Powerful muscular lines are faintly visible beneath the scales. Atop its majestic head, a pair of eyes blazing with golden flames offer insight. Its long whiskers and white mane, stretching from its crown to its back, flow backwards at high speed. With grace and power, it sometimes calmly slants into the depths of dense cloud, leaving only a faint outline, and sometimes suddenly bursts through the sky, scattering vast clouds into ethereal mist. Its smooth and continuous movements resemble a dance in the sky. The contrast between the cool cyan and the warm gold creates an epic atmosphere of grandeur, sacredness, and ancient mystery.", + "seed": 26474, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_9/index_8240_seed_26474_dp_18_rank_36_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.04740924178622663, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04740924178622663, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.975, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04740924178622663, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive dragon with a deep, vibrant cyan body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a boundless, turbulent sea of clouds containing thick cumulonimbus and wispy cirrus clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are rays of golden light penetrating the clouds to create pillars of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the dragon have golden flames in its eyes, a white mane, and scales that gleam with iridescence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot sweeping from a slightly upward angle following the dragon's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.18002349138259888 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.805023431777954 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.18002349138259888, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.18002349138259888, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1997186690568924, + 0.08645596355199814, + 0.24244701862335205, + 0.08969715982675552, + 0.030195804312825203, + 0.022118529304862022, + 0.04359062388539314, + 0.04272074997425079, + 0.05795777961611748, + 0.18509769439697266 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.18002349138259888 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive dragon with a deep, vibrant cyan body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a boundless, turbulent sea of clouds containing thick cumulonimbus and wispy cirrus clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are rays of golden light penetrating the clouds to create pillars of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the dragon have golden flames in its eyes, a white mane, and scales that gleam with iridescence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot sweeping from a slightly upward angle following the dragon's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036159863229840994 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628615856170654 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036159863229840994, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036159863229840994, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17838144302368164, + 0.04968065768480301, + 0.23465606570243835, + 0.156324103474617, + 0.05337236449122429, + 0.030082250013947487, + 0.04965078830718994, + 0.08068764954805374, + 0.034182578325271606, + 0.13298210501670837 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036159863229840994 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive dragon with a deep, vibrant cyan body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a boundless, turbulent sea of clouds containing thick cumulonimbus and wispy cirrus clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are rays of golden light penetrating the clouds to create pillars of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the dragon have golden flames in its eyes, a white mane, and scales that gleam with iridescence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot sweeping from a slightly upward angle following the dragon's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.033704325556755066 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4087042808532715 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.033704325556755066, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.033704325556755066, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2343573421239853, + 0.15211117267608643, + 0.1827000230550766, + 0.07210281491279602, + 0.07925231009721756, + 0.041349947452545166, + 0.09740468859672546, + 0.056950896978378296, + 0.01855539157986641, + 0.06521535664796829 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.033704325556755066 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive dragon with a deep, vibrant cyan body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a boundless, turbulent sea of clouds containing thick cumulonimbus and wispy cirrus clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are rays of golden light penetrating the clouds to create pillars of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the dragon have golden flames in its eyes, a white mane, and scales that gleam with iridescence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot sweeping from a slightly upward angle following the dragon's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008637567982077599 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758637428283691 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008637567982077599, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008637567982077599, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12239162623882294, + 0.048613905906677246, + 0.18230172991752625, + 0.054654836654663086, + 0.0415060818195343, + 0.03215767815709114, + 0.05216096341609955, + 0.08719098567962646, + 0.06984388828277588, + 0.30917832255363464 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008637567982077599 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive dragon with a deep, vibrant cyan body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a boundless, turbulent sea of clouds containing thick cumulonimbus and wispy cirrus clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are rays of golden light penetrating the clouds to create pillars of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the dragon have golden flames in its eyes, a white mane, and scales that gleam with iridescence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot sweeping from a slightly upward angle following the dragon's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01106483768671751 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.5110650062561035 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01106483768671751, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01106483768671751, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.129744291305542, + 0.11157061904668808, + 0.23322248458862305, + 0.08974157273769379, + 0.044369541108608246, + 0.046904563903808594, + 0.06916201114654541, + 0.12674665451049805, + 0.09374915063381195, + 0.054789070039987564 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01106483768671751 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "sweeping aerial shot, captured from a slightly upward angle, smoothly follows a massive cyan dragon as it soars through a boundless, turbulent sea of clouds. Thick cumulonimbus clouds intertwine with wispy cirrus clouds, swirling violently under the dragon's turbulence, creating vast vortices and turbulent currents. Rays of golden rays penetrate the gaps between the clouds, casting magnificent pillars of light. The dragon's slender, sinuous body emanates a deep, vibrant cyan. Each scale, like meticulously crafted jade, gleams with an ever-changing iridescence in the sunlight, its edges tinged with a faint golden halo. Powerful muscular lines are faintly visible beneath the scales. Atop its majestic head, a pair of eyes blazing with golden flames offer insight. Its long whiskers and white mane, stretching from its crown to its back, flow backwards at high speed. With grace and power, it sometimes calmly slants into the depths of dense cloud, leaving only a faint outline, and sometimes suddenly bursts through the sky, scattering vast clouds into ethereal mist. Its smooth and continuous movements resemble a dance in the sky. The contrast between the cool cyan and the warm gold creates an epic atmosphere of grandeur, sacredness, and ancient mystery.", + "seed": 26475, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_9/index_8240_seed_26475_dp_18_rank_36_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.013564319955185056, + "vlm_logprob": -0.013564319955185056, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.675, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.013564319955185056, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive dragon with a deep, vibrant cyan body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a boundless, turbulent sea of clouds containing thick cumulonimbus and wispy cirrus clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are rays of golden light penetrating the clouds to create pillars of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the dragon have golden flames in its eyes, a white mane, and scales that gleam with iridescence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot sweeping from a slightly upward angle following the dragon's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03822053596377373 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2882206439971924 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03822053596377373, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03822053596377373, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.7885612845420837, + 0.018338216468691826, + 0.014052802696824074, + 0.011027024127542973, + 0.009633246809244156, + 0.006205122917890549, + 0.00796167366206646, + 0.011356326751410961, + 0.009971744380891323, + 0.1228925809264183 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03822053596377373 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive dragon with a deep, vibrant cyan body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a boundless, turbulent sea of clouds containing thick cumulonimbus and wispy cirrus clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are rays of golden light penetrating the clouds to create pillars of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the dragon have golden flames in its eyes, a white mane, and scales that gleam with iridescence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot sweeping from a slightly upward angle following the dragon's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003190072951838374 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753190040588379 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003190072951838374, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003190072951838374, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.28888383507728577, + 0.14576630294322968, + 0.10904969274997711, + 0.05864410847425461, + 0.1444655805826187, + 0.03411011025309563, + 0.06545377522706985, + 0.055309005081653595, + 0.04904019087553024, + 0.04927743598818779 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003190072951838374 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive dragon with a deep, vibrant cyan body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a boundless, turbulent sea of clouds containing thick cumulonimbus and wispy cirrus clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are rays of golden light penetrating the clouds to create pillars of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the dragon have golden flames in its eyes, a white mane, and scales that gleam with iridescence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot sweeping from a slightly upward angle following the dragon's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005249644163995981 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255249500274658 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005249644163995981, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005249644163995981, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.153119757771492, + 0.09354980289936066, + 0.03660743683576584, + 0.05547057464718819, + 0.09597934782505035, + 0.14075155556201935, + 0.292876273393631, + 0.04536046087741852, + 0.03258918225765228, + 0.05369565263390541 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005249644163995981 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive dragon with a deep, vibrant cyan body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a boundless, turbulent sea of clouds containing thick cumulonimbus and wispy cirrus clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are rays of golden light penetrating the clouds to create pillars of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the dragon have golden flames in its eyes, a white mane, and scales that gleam with iridescence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot sweeping from a slightly upward angle following the dragon's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01253335177898407 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387533187866211 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01253335177898407, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01253335177898407, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.7412554621696472, + 0.051651012152433395, + 0.011655721813440323, + 0.022150063887238503, + 0.03313297778367996, + 0.008074433542788029, + 0.03850103169679642, + 0.025326281785964966, + 0.03098881244659424, + 0.037264179438352585 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01253335177898407 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive dragon with a deep, vibrant cyan body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a boundless, turbulent sea of clouds containing thick cumulonimbus and wispy cirrus clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are rays of golden light penetrating the clouds to create pillars of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the dragon have golden flames in its eyes, a white mane, and scales that gleam with iridescence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot sweeping from a slightly upward angle following the dragon's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008627994917333126 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758627891540527 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008627994917333126, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008627994917333126, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.713814377784729, + 0.06618029624223709, + 0.01737857051193714, + 0.024976802989840508, + 0.061056461185216904, + 0.015194578096270561, + 0.04793654382228851, + 0.022456668317317963, + 0.017386317253112793, + 0.013619408011436462 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008627994917333126 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "sweeping aerial shot, captured from a slightly upward angle, smoothly follows a massive cyan dragon as it soars through a boundless, turbulent sea of clouds. Thick cumulonimbus clouds intertwine with wispy cirrus clouds, swirling violently under the dragon's turbulence, creating vast vortices and turbulent currents. Rays of golden rays penetrate the gaps between the clouds, casting magnificent pillars of light. The dragon's slender, sinuous body emanates a deep, vibrant cyan. Each scale, like meticulously crafted jade, gleams with an ever-changing iridescence in the sunlight, its edges tinged with a faint golden halo. Powerful muscular lines are faintly visible beneath the scales. Atop its majestic head, a pair of eyes blazing with golden flames offer insight. Its long whiskers and white mane, stretching from its crown to its back, flow backwards at high speed. With grace and power, it sometimes calmly slants into the depths of dense cloud, leaving only a faint outline, and sometimes suddenly bursts through the sky, scattering vast clouds into ethereal mist. Its smooth and continuous movements resemble a dance in the sky. The contrast between the cool cyan and the warm gold creates an epic atmosphere of grandeur, sacredness, and ancient mystery.", + "seed": 26476, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_9/index_8240_seed_26476_dp_19_rank_38_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.03510675714351237, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03510675714351237, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.1, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03510675714351237, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive dragon with a deep, vibrant cyan body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a boundless, turbulent sea of clouds containing thick cumulonimbus and wispy cirrus clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are rays of golden light penetrating the clouds to create pillars of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the dragon have golden flames in its eyes, a white mane, and scales that gleam with iridescence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot sweeping from a slightly upward angle following the dragon's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11308576911687851 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2380857467651367 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11308576911687851, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11308576911687851, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.02930627018213272, + 0.02148319222033024, + 0.036771997809410095, + 0.04963969439268112, + 0.6730838418006897, + 0.02491634525358677, + 0.060695406049489975, + 0.02901456132531166, + 0.04996268078684807, + 0.025126032531261444 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11308576911687851 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive dragon with a deep, vibrant cyan body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a boundless, turbulent sea of clouds containing thick cumulonimbus and wispy cirrus clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are rays of golden light penetrating the clouds to create pillars of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the dragon have golden flames in its eyes, a white mane, and scales that gleam with iridescence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot sweeping from a slightly upward angle following the dragon's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0021984234917908907 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127198219299316 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0021984234917908907, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0021984234917908907, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.02325473167002201, + 0.059081509709358215, + 0.03667515888810158, + 0.12774893641471863, + 0.5323088765144348, + 0.04251882806420326, + 0.028111452236771584, + 0.03866520896553993, + 0.08339142054319382, + 0.028243878856301308 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0021984234917908907 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive dragon with a deep, vibrant cyan body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a boundless, turbulent sea of clouds containing thick cumulonimbus and wispy cirrus clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are rays of golden light penetrating the clouds to create pillars of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the dragon have golden flames in its eyes, a white mane, and scales that gleam with iridescence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot sweeping from a slightly upward angle following the dragon's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03810659423470497 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288106679916382 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03810659423470497, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03810659423470497, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05198410525918007, + 0.15562158823013306, + 0.042328670620918274, + 0.14676007628440857, + 0.4355485141277313, + 0.03249988704919815, + 0.026677019894123077, + 0.032825540751218796, + 0.05090691149234772, + 0.024847762659192085 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03810659423470497 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive dragon with a deep, vibrant cyan body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a boundless, turbulent sea of clouds containing thick cumulonimbus and wispy cirrus clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are rays of golden light penetrating the clouds to create pillars of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the dragon have golden flames in its eyes, a white mane, and scales that gleam with iridescence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot sweeping from a slightly upward angle following the dragon's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011077099479734898 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511076927185059 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011077099479734898, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011077099479734898, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0246288925409317, + 0.04462519288063049, + 0.04121775925159454, + 0.017500152811408043, + 0.6434848308563232, + 0.03603093698620796, + 0.037357304245233536, + 0.0792677253484726, + 0.02992200292646885, + 0.04596525430679321 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011077099479734898 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive dragon with a deep, vibrant cyan body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a boundless, turbulent sea of clouds containing thick cumulonimbus and wispy cirrus clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are rays of golden light penetrating the clouds to create pillars of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the dragon have golden flames in its eyes, a white mane, and scales that gleam with iridescence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot sweeping from a slightly upward angle following the dragon's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011065899394452572 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.51106595993042 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011065899394452572, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011065899394452572, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.027253976091742516, + 0.0280640609562397, + 0.06068159267306328, + 0.2004922330379486, + 0.5273810029029846, + 0.017415907233953476, + 0.03144918382167816, + 0.023721948266029358, + 0.062069810926914215, + 0.021470217034220695 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011065899394452572 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "sweeping aerial shot, captured from a slightly upward angle, smoothly follows a massive cyan dragon as it soars through a boundless, turbulent sea of clouds. Thick cumulonimbus clouds intertwine with wispy cirrus clouds, swirling violently under the dragon's turbulence, creating vast vortices and turbulent currents. Rays of golden rays penetrate the gaps between the clouds, casting magnificent pillars of light. The dragon's slender, sinuous body emanates a deep, vibrant cyan. Each scale, like meticulously crafted jade, gleams with an ever-changing iridescence in the sunlight, its edges tinged with a faint golden halo. Powerful muscular lines are faintly visible beneath the scales. Atop its majestic head, a pair of eyes blazing with golden flames offer insight. Its long whiskers and white mane, stretching from its crown to its back, flow backwards at high speed. With grace and power, it sometimes calmly slants into the depths of dense cloud, leaving only a faint outline, and sometimes suddenly bursts through the sky, scattering vast clouds into ethereal mist. Its smooth and continuous movements resemble a dance in the sky. The contrast between the cool cyan and the warm gold creates an epic atmosphere of grandeur, sacredness, and ancient mystery.", + "seed": 26477, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000285/group_9/index_8240_seed_26477_dp_19_rank_38_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.08352015907876194, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08352015907876194, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.650000011920929, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08352015907876194, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive dragon with a deep, vibrant cyan body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a boundless, turbulent sea of clouds containing thick cumulonimbus and wispy cirrus clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are rays of golden light penetrating the clouds to create pillars of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the dragon have golden flames in its eyes, a white mane, and scales that gleam with iridescence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot sweeping from a slightly upward angle following the dragon's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.34878653287887573 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2237865924835205 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.34878653287887573, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.8750000596046448, + "token_credit_reward": -0.34878653287887573, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07598237693309784, + 0.02011621929705143, + 0.03339238464832306, + 0.029002603143453598, + 0.04737361520528793, + 0.04298430681228638, + 0.5221925377845764, + 0.031487204134464264, + 0.04205029830336571, + 0.15541841089725494 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.34878653287887573 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive dragon with a deep, vibrant cyan body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a boundless, turbulent sea of clouds containing thick cumulonimbus and wispy cirrus clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are rays of golden light penetrating the clouds to create pillars of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the dragon have golden flames in its eyes, a white mane, and scales that gleam with iridescence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot sweeping from a slightly upward angle following the dragon's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0031932813581079245 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753193378448486 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0031932813581079245, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0031932813581079245, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22283051908016205, + 0.06059504672884941, + 0.05851651355624199, + 0.08018984645605087, + 0.06090136617422104, + 0.05938353016972542, + 0.140614852309227, + 0.01981772482395172, + 0.06415855139493942, + 0.232992023229599 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0031932813581079245 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive dragon with a deep, vibrant cyan body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a boundless, turbulent sea of clouds containing thick cumulonimbus and wispy cirrus clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are rays of golden light penetrating the clouds to create pillars of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the dragon have golden flames in its eyes, a white mane, and scales that gleam with iridescence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot sweeping from a slightly upward angle following the dragon's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029800867661833763 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298008918762207 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029800867661833763, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029800867661833763, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1861002892255783, + 0.03938863426446915, + 0.061605460941791534, + 0.18325696885585785, + 0.04653002321720123, + 0.03223836049437523, + 0.30937460064888, + 0.019625850021839142, + 0.03299938887357712, + 0.08888048678636551 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029800867661833763 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive dragon with a deep, vibrant cyan body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a boundless, turbulent sea of clouds containing thick cumulonimbus and wispy cirrus clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are rays of golden light penetrating the clouds to create pillars of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the dragon have golden flames in its eyes, a white mane, and scales that gleam with iridescence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot sweeping from a slightly upward angle following the dragon's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02328970469534397 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773289680480957 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02328970469534397, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02328970469534397, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1006166860461235, + 0.03482604771852493, + 0.043060000985860825, + 0.04684141278266907, + 0.056446950882673264, + 0.04886113852262497, + 0.4153025448322296, + 0.023705946281552315, + 0.03926512598991394, + 0.1910742223262787 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02328970469534397 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive dragon with a deep, vibrant cyan body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a boundless, turbulent sea of clouds containing thick cumulonimbus and wispy cirrus clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are rays of golden light penetrating the clouds to create pillars of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the dragon have golden flames in its eyes, a white mane, and scales that gleam with iridescence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot sweeping from a slightly upward angle following the dragon's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012530408799648285 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387530326843262 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012530408799648285, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012530408799648285, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12827706336975098, + 0.036554768681526184, + 0.07536184787750244, + 0.04412390664219856, + 0.07335169613361359, + 0.035930100828409195, + 0.4482574462890625, + 0.02602662518620491, + 0.03102688677608967, + 0.10108964890241623 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012530408799648285 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/A beige lion changes from big to small.-0.mp4 b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/A beige lion changes from big to small.-0.mp4 new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..45c85d5324105ed3f5d42eda98317151c3e74ae7 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/A beige lion changes from big to small.-0.mp4 @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:3bf50fdcbf4b0304414c315d202e018d92aa04f0413113762cf986b78df88bca +size 1258743 diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/A beige tiger changes from small to big.-1.mp4 b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/A beige tiger changes from small to big.-1.mp4 new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..caaf8029a3f90e8219c00be272320595e130dc55 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/A beige tiger changes from small to big.-1.mp4 @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:ec05950f6feb68e895aac1c1a2a2fd38ffd617833f7cc412ec2c7c6f3308d472 +size 844599 diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/A beige tiger is in front of a tree, then the tiger moves to the left of the tree.-0.mp4 b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/A beige tiger is in front of a tree, then the tiger moves to the left of the tree.-0.mp4 new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..5428793771e4305425e033d502ee2589f8a89939 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/A beige tiger is in front of a tree, then the tiger moves to the left of the tree.-0.mp4 @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:5b438cafdc7504e810117e0f8c3ef4317d8222bc082e6410966dc2b86b99b18f +size 693080 diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/A black drone and a blue drone are floating in the air.-2.mp4 b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/A black drone and a blue drone are floating in the air.-2.mp4 new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..c893236ce7795468f1d1d1eb607d0e704eb6b864 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/A black drone and a blue drone are floating in the air.-2.mp4 @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:6e9f6cb7c622721867d7d8e3d2c5b70a175ce317ab8eff1417752205c2987a6e +size 878690 diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/A car speeds along a winding mountain road, with trees rapidly passing by.-1.mp4 b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/A car speeds along a winding mountain road, with trees rapidly passing by.-1.mp4 new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..75294248a2189dac0d33a1b31201cec72e579fdf --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/A car speeds along a winding mountain road, with trees rapidly passing by.-1.mp4 @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:a1776c48507dfe07b3aacb4a650282ab7ec7e9052a88e5776fda85fc604849b8 +size 1007913 diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/A drone is floating in the air.-2.mp4 b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/A drone is floating in the air.-2.mp4 new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..61e9ff5765f54016936aedbb4d7b76b187b3d5d2 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/A drone is floating in the air.-2.mp4 @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:38705de7c2962ea7d42ff043da7e1c040dd3e915e4f7f14ed70a81445f17d6b4 +size 767449 diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/A droplet of water is falling.-2.mp4 b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/A droplet of water is falling.-2.mp4 new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..d4ff11a0abdcc95e5ddcb0399cf1c0932ffa9b93 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/A droplet of water is falling.-2.mp4 @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:c9bb60f3609118d908168154af2ccae9aa0e0b9573bf90641f0e899740a8b9bb +size 945478 diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/A giraffe is walking.-1.mp4 b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/A giraffe is walking.-1.mp4 new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..d55c345d1c14f984f258d16cdfc6969ae7909625 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/A giraffe is walking.-1.mp4 @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:bc6b0d64528a6d4b541fe86358eafd302e6e0595551404e5c093ceeb77f0745a +size 775190 diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/A man and a woman is doing yoga.-1.mp4 b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/A man and a woman is doing yoga.-1.mp4 new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..2bdbc00f24c3e4676d72abfd4ef7dedd5b1a2bf7 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/A man and a woman is doing yoga.-1.mp4 @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:e4550b73b119b78c0cf64907c1e3075a1d0c7267e3036a47824d9bd945dfb160 +size 443806 diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/A orange fox is running.-0.mp4 b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/A orange fox is running.-0.mp4 new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..0a718886f821c458c4d92739a4033a3305266e12 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/A orange fox is running.-0.mp4 @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:d1436afa0ad21f544b8975a6ce29b1b53c145388dc8b5ff5fd32d6f54c83ee89 +size 1214282 diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/A panda changes from big to small.-2.mp4 b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/A panda changes from big to small.-2.mp4 new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..cf05f1901b0dff208504f3905b35c21902e39387 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/A panda changes from big to small.-2.mp4 @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:f15e2ed024123b5665d5390432b56c41fef43b748ea930648259e414cccde522 +size 870453 diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/A red ball and a blue ball bouncing down stairs-0.mp4 b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/A red ball and a blue ball bouncing down stairs-0.mp4 new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..e81358e17987334584bd07988a081e8c3ac913ed --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/A red ball and a blue ball bouncing down stairs-0.mp4 @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:e0bcfa4422bf3c5b7816f4ad03c1e0b804fb2c972a5fa6f2644e665660cbbc7d +size 693371 diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/A red ball and a blue ball bouncing down stairs-1.mp4 b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/A red ball and a blue ball bouncing down stairs-1.mp4 new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..2f8d9fdad7cd79beeee2b851503a0cb340e6f5ef --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/A red ball and a blue ball bouncing down stairs-1.mp4 @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:eb2336b29fadb2fa7cead21eb36f63961d77b6bdd8439bed383a515b2ace85bb +size 759927 diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/A red ball and a blue ball fall from a height, hits the ground, and bounces back up.-2.mp4 b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/A red ball and a blue ball fall from a height, hits the ground, and bounces back up.-2.mp4 new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..01f312b68976384f6217f32dd47bf320f107ea78 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/A red ball and a blue ball fall from a height, hits the ground, and bounces back up.-2.mp4 @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:34c1d888b62bf0234fe3b5d1445aec169cffb80507b1676e8dbcb80ac5f240da +size 1478099 diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/A red ball bouncing down stairs-2.mp4 b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/A red ball bouncing down stairs-2.mp4 new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..c1ab1e2936597ef70140f5c6b4462e1923ccbd29 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/A red ball bouncing down stairs-2.mp4 @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:05d2871dead52a5def3ef597ccb8fd61a52aae1dc9a41c75a0a78f8e70a85905 +size 892204 diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/A red ball falls from a height, hits the ground, and bounces back up.-1.mp4 b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/A red ball falls from a height, hits the ground, and bounces back up.-1.mp4 new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..b983cade45fd77c49764fd97e4e095e9fe747f66 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/A red ball falls from a height, hits the ground, and bounces back up.-1.mp4 @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:c8f9bca3033c7be5c510eff34c15a6d65aad06a6e0e0f13975b228dc5247df98 +size 1406276 diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/A red car is moving along the road.-2.mp4 b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/A red car is moving along the road.-2.mp4 new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..9ff91220b383387603937b0b3a905ffb6a7586f5 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/A red car is moving along the road.-2.mp4 @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:c202581e4a0fd1e2e89c2fa845ab5d6d3c40fc863ddfb96affcd25a6942cd238 +size 1082393 diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/A red top and a blue top are spinning.-0.mp4 b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/A red top and a blue top are spinning.-0.mp4 new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..50fee726904a840286cb48f8a422e5c4328b0465 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/A red top and a blue top are spinning.-0.mp4 @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:6a858916ca64c2c98a6151ddf6a9ade20cc4fb170c79a78bdda1f2cd0f2f33c9 +size 758129 diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/A red top and a blue top are spinning.-1.mp4 b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/A red top and a blue top are spinning.-1.mp4 new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..13f37ee2b19f11b15fe548b52d26f3e59b7b1246 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/A red top and a blue top are spinning.-1.mp4 @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:4c98cc663eeef0851e06632cd0da267173416e899566fd6fa35d0fa0d54cfa7c +size 974238 diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/A top is spinning.-0.mp4 b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/A top is spinning.-0.mp4 new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..74496197b934ee89df7ae507985c726feae14962 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/A top is spinning.-0.mp4 @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:d4a2a5ffebe5f1c21ffbe385c81b3cdf748aa9dcfea0a548ac81a208729b9393 +size 1204807 diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/A top is spinning.-1.mp4 b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/A top is spinning.-1.mp4 new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..00ae4741517a7c2579ac22fab79ffcbfb58d4336 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/A top is spinning.-1.mp4 @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:5c5e2e6a41ded6c58a38923b9e23c0536fddaf9f0b957b337767dc2fd10dbd54 +size 356010 diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/A white sheep is in front of a tree, then the sheep moves to the left of the tree.-2.mp4 b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/A white sheep is in front of a tree, then the sheep moves to the left of the tree.-2.mp4 new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..cb3e9ef55ecc9f6b5124f1dbd7337fb18e834f50 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/A white sheep is in front of a tree, then the sheep moves to the left of the tree.-2.mp4 @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:a916ddb947ace171583652939eec43ee11aad56487b16613732730de2cce44c4 +size 638788 diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/A white sheep is walking.-2.mp4 b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/A white sheep is walking.-2.mp4 new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..f8e854ce74b4fd0a894d0143c7e9b5fc18b5640e --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/A white sheep is walking.-2.mp4 @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:aabdcf7938ee2eb4800e99183880fc445277ee287bebfa161d95101a48bca851 +size 930537 diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/An orange cat and a white cat are fighting.-2.mp4 b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/An orange cat and a white cat are fighting.-2.mp4 new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..a561ceb1502a8679f18ef44a441351a01b23a8fd --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/An orange cat and a white cat are fighting.-2.mp4 @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:f9e279e032df1ae0616c9b1ba4575d2c408b540c1b9d824dc90dab5557a2726f +size 846319 diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/An orange cat and a white cat are running.-2.mp4 b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/An orange cat and a white cat are running.-2.mp4 new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..31bab111afe99844276adf2785d8928c7c89942f --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/An orange cat and a white cat are running.-2.mp4 @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:ead5183d833752a6d02a4c69e553418de010daf55052c95522e9d213bba33d0d +size 1108770 diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/An orange cat changes from big to small.-2.mp4 b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/An orange cat changes from big to small.-2.mp4 new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..c393b225bcd964c1d3a2038d6c507cf07bd0eded --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/An orange cat changes from big to small.-2.mp4 @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:63e0f2b06df88a3839a418c2d2ae8ed1c18dfb250b3755c6e0fcdf2b9e844185 +size 860243 diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/An orange cat is in front of a tree, then the cat moves to the left of the tree.-2.mp4 b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/An orange cat is in front of a tree, then the cat moves to the left of the tree.-2.mp4 new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..d33e75e4b2c14ef9a772a5e25bb43d9f1cdc7118 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/An orange cat is in front of a tree, then the cat moves to the left of the tree.-2.mp4 @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:ee83e6b09943753f5ab538d59094a6bd836bff74205cfd8b5ea9512832ef80cb +size 980450 diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/An orange cat is on the left of an apple, then the cat moves to the right of the apple.-2.mp4 b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/An orange cat is on the left of an apple, then the cat moves to the right of the apple.-2.mp4 new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..0b381e13ce7ff704a6702c825336a5163f18a45a --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/An orange cat is on the left of an apple, then the cat moves to the right of the apple.-2.mp4 @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:e262643bce16188fd28bb0384772831573584e577aef7b2611b6b7ece8e75cff +size 698148 diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/An orange dog changes from big to small.-1.mp4 b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/An orange dog changes from big to small.-1.mp4 new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..2fb20b08a9372bb9bb5b9c4f8887da55ef84ea0b --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/An orange dog changes from big to small.-1.mp4 @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:1d611278958a8b6d33ae5f57bb4f8956b2020ce7bbb61dec90f4df972ea40355 +size 728659 diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/An orange dog is running.-0.mp4 b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/An orange dog is running.-0.mp4 new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..87b875ef3396d99f9fd08e1a973b928ed0fe1697 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/An orange dog is running.-0.mp4 @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:5687b6e3b7c4fcbb02327077fd510460a294d467bc9792d62ff90609a7224890 +size 1165915 diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/An orange dog is running.-1.mp4 b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/An orange dog is running.-1.mp4 new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..6f8421868c223ebeeaa9a8f84a27bce3fb78fb4c --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/An orange dog is running.-1.mp4 @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:fd7d44efe8b0e972ca2c27fbe12485e3c2e9bcb2c3132e5b2f8fe60574858b70 +size 1367481 diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/Two black drones are floating in the air.-2.mp4 b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/Two black drones are floating in the air.-2.mp4 new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..7477588418c6688c7375650623c9309fec818101 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/Two black drones are floating in the air.-2.mp4 @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:521a06b69bd13236986a62128a16aa26106f909d00fa2ace8d8e465f756f33e4 +size 627799 diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/Two blue birds flies through the sky, coming close to each other and forming a complex formation.-2.mp4 b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/Two blue birds flies through the sky, coming close to each other and forming a complex formation.-2.mp4 new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..474d402ed604a74cbbf26f7301a26b211affd999 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/Two blue birds flies through the sky, coming close to each other and forming a complex formation.-2.mp4 @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:c25a6f98a42c6b5708ea1bb3a5878e2dace350b3b6868270a1633314af8678e9 +size 872694 diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/Two brown bears are running.-2.mp4 b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/Two brown bears are running.-2.mp4 new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..d378d7b702a8438bc3af76d6a527c82a2a092dd1 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/Two brown bears are running.-2.mp4 @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:d161465eabbde0bd772ab88001a37b8e5dab5eb407dff33c070ff044eba52c37 +size 1197334 diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/Two footballs spin rapidly on the floor.-2.mp4 b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/Two footballs spin rapidly on the floor.-2.mp4 new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..cb21c7c102bcfd58e5208be7d51554c264ae3926 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/Two footballs spin rapidly on the floor.-2.mp4 @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:a6997e9cf6e58230a8c8222a8de3a3b0645e297e0a91f7dba21d7ee079589481 +size 1067709 diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/Two giraffes are walking.-0.mp4 b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/Two giraffes are walking.-0.mp4 new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..478618225ab71e774aaf184101d8e525deaf0e63 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/Two giraffes are walking.-0.mp4 @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:3277e8b8f3448257d01a0dcdb9793e06712e7f143496bb68106eee32fa51964f +size 734346 diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/Two orange dogs are running.-2.mp4 b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/Two orange dogs are running.-2.mp4 new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..ea68d663a0b5db0b88cc3936033b35ed41bfa649 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/Two orange dogs are running.-2.mp4 @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:645ecc7d2c6685c190459d0963052eab1d38924a7927edbf93cf4d6e11c484aa +size 1214532 diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/Two people are doing yoga.-2.mp4 b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/Two people are doing yoga.-2.mp4 new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..e3eacf732c06d8c46143c30469cf0a3fc460ee4f --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/Two people are doing yoga.-2.mp4 @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:d55ae13dcd6258dfd00faf93a1a32b0e640f4fba5e4c3becfe0b90820342d142 +size 627770 diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/Two red balloons are floating in the air.-0.mp4 b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/Two red balloons are floating in the air.-0.mp4 new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..d6603c811779e8e7ea310d9ef28fe2b91c5bbb48 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/Two red balloons are floating in the air.-0.mp4 @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:d5e39cb8185604000483deb40cb448cd0c396729f64d13bce7558cadd3d3e923 +size 661610 diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/Two red tops are spinning.-2.mp4 b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/Two red tops are spinning.-2.mp4 new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..8e52b9c2f8d5feca81f4e45ff9353193c5dac795 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/Two red tops are spinning.-2.mp4 @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:6b43e7eea0fb27df19164f62c7dfa4648915334c1ab852bc39377d2e1b9c8c79 +size 741915 diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/Two sandy kangaroos are fighting.-0.mp4 b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/Two sandy kangaroos are fighting.-0.mp4 new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..505402a5b2407ff5f61eaeec3db75cb43b8698bd --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/Two sandy kangaroos are fighting.-0.mp4 @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:eb3b29ecbdb7f5cf17d32b8b0869c00c3334b3ef0b9777cbd687ea0aaa44f9ed +size 743861 diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/Two sandy kangaroos are fighting.-1.mp4 b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/Two sandy kangaroos are fighting.-1.mp4 new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..bb7877aa6d5011a558c1c03b2f17b65a812127d1 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/Two sandy kangaroos are fighting.-1.mp4 @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:88fba68a743163f21d447bdfe97155c78a96292638733c898fbbc30a37d02b39 +size 777463 diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/Two sandy kangaroos are jumping.-2.mp4 b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/Two sandy kangaroos are jumping.-2.mp4 new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..99d3cc0ffc210c02dc1f99bc175a7d3430ff7b3d --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/Two sandy kangaroos are jumping.-2.mp4 @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:338501b91440b9bb1c8db41021c69e5370b523bf8908cb861371a991d7714afd +size 862475 diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/Two white sheep are walking.-1.mp4 b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/Two white sheep are walking.-1.mp4 new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..b3b10d762a4d69c244e97fd4e25b51d0cacfde9d --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Instance_Preservation/Two white sheep are walking.-1.mp4 @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:109fa4521c0dc8d61ffcc23de899fa224e5e172eb6373bc62f421e69a45a45ef +size 1206094